TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2022

Town Council Special meeting

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

3 findings

Transcript

330 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:50 Sarah, we're just commenting on it. It's about time you brought Miles to a meeting again. Yeah, you know, his dad's been on paternity leave, so he's been watching him, but they just got home from Bishop, and I was like, why don't you take a minute? I'll hang out with him for a second. So they went skiing yesterday at June. So he's already been skiing, ice skating. He's been to Saline Valley.

4:22 More adventures in five months than most grown-ups, I think. So he's doing great. Getting him ready to be an Eastern Sierra resident. Okay. I think we see a lot of people here. I'll counsel. Jeremy, you see most of your board present? Let me take it quick. Looks like we have five of eight. Should we go ahead and get started then? Okay.

5:01 Let's do. All right. Welcome, everybody, to the Wednesday, January 26, 2002 meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. As we know, this is going to be a joint meeting, but we're going to go ahead and move forward with opening it as we normally do. So we will ask Sarah to do roll call, please.

5:23 Oh, I'm sorry, Sarah. Sorry. No, Sarah, I don't want you to do it. Please, don't do that. I was like, oh, no. Sarah's like, what? Am I supposed to do something? Oh, my gosh. Okay. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? She raised her hand. Yeah, I saw your hand raised. Here. Sorry, I muted. Councilmember Salzer? Here. Councilmember Stapp? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Present. Mayor Salcido? Present.

5:56 Okay. Let's do Pledge of Allegiance. Let's see. Dan, would you lead us today, please? Yeah, please stand and join me in Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag. Thank you very much. Are there any public comments that we have? Anybody would like to say or anybody waiting to say anything in public comments? No, there are not.

6:35 Okay. Those would be for those comments that had nothing to do with items on the agenda for tonight. Alrighty. We're going to go ahead then and move into our policy matters. Before we do, though, I just wanted to thank the board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism for being here with us to conduct a joint meeting on our goals and funding for the fiscal year of 2022-23 coming up.

7:00 It's not often we all meet together, but Jeremy, did you want to have an opportunity to introduce your board or ask them to at least say hi to everybody here? Absolutely. Thank you for having us, Madam Mayor. Pleasure to be here working with the town council on these topics for the MLT board. You know, I think as we kind of get into the meeting, we'll give everybody a chance from our board to

7:31 Ask questions, make comments. We'll kind of, you know, I spoke to Linda a little bit before the meeting, and we'd like to do that in an organized fashion. We want to stay focused on topic. You know, we are talking about fiscal year 22-23, so July 1-22 to June 23, and that is the focus of our discussion here today on both deliverables and budget.

7:59 So as we get into the meeting, we can kind of go in an organized fashion through both town council and board to make sure everybody gets their opportunity to say something and or ask questions. But thank you for having us, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Linda, if I may, if we could ask Jeremy to go ahead and have the board

8:27 It is a joint meeting, so they're here as a body. We ought to recognize them from a roll call that we know we have a majority of the board here joined together in this joint meeting. So just from a protocol standpoint, if we could... I can take the roll. Jamie can just do a roll call for the board. That would be helpful. Then we're... Yeah, let's do that. Yeah, Jamie, why don't you go ahead and do it if you have that available. Okay. Chair Goico. Thank you. Present. Vice Chair Foster. Here. Treasurer Morris.

8:58 Here. Board Member Clark. Here. Board Member Mendel is not here, I guess. Board Member Crabb is not here. Board Member Radcliffe. Here. And of course, Board Member Salzer is already here. Okay. So officially under policy matters on item 4.1 is the Town Council joint meeting with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to discuss planning goals and funding fiscal year 22.

9:32 To 23, Marketing Plan. So I'm going to ask that Rob, I know Rob, you've been working closely with MLT, so hopefully you'll walk us through the opening up of this. Absolutely, Madam Mayor, thank you. So I want to kind of start off by, you know, we have what I want to call a model sort of agreement with MLT in regards to

10:01 The structure for that particular agreement. And one of the key points in there is an annual discussion on the deliverables, which are basically what's to be produced for the dollars being contributed to the contract. And in this particular case, one of the things that we kind of stumbled into last year was that while the deliverables, which are very specific sort of strategies that have been developed by MLT on what they're going to deliver for the year, they didn't.

10:30 Have sort of the opportunity for Town Council to weigh in in advance of the development of those with some overarching sort of either focus or some focus points at least to be addressed. So this approach this year is designed to kind of get that voice to Town Council, let them sort of present to you what they think needs to be the areas you guys work on. Now, we try to make it appropriately high.

10:58 Because it is really just concepts to address the expertise that that resides within MLT and the processes for delivering this are really what should come to bear on these focus points in the development of the deliverables. So I guess the expectation would be that.

11:15 When we meet later in this year, prior to the budget finalization, when we talk about the deliverables, that each one of these focus points would be addressed in some way in those deliverables. So that's the key point. And I think that's where more of the detail will be. But again, that's coming from MLT at that point. So to get to this point, we met, meaning the town council met on January 19th, and they reviewed a set of

11:42 of focus points that staff, through listening to council discussions, had brought forward as options of what we need to work on. And all of the council members gave us feedback in that process. And what we've done is basically captured that input. We've added some additional sort of overarching areas to discuss. Then we just fine-tuned the other focus points. We didn't really make...

12:09 Modifications to the four main focus points, but that's, you know, going to be really the meat and potatoes of what we're talking about here. So I'll kind of go through, you know, we did add some overarching goals. And when I say that, it would be that anything that we're doing, you know, should be striving to achieve this sustainable destination, thinking of our natural resources as being limited.

12:37 We really want to think about how do we preserve them, not only for now and mitigate the impacts, but really to provide the growth of those resources and for generations to come that we would foster them and they would be available to us. But also achieving a sustainable economic growth that really helps us to provide public investments and address the other things that are needed.

13:05 Outside of marketing. So those two are the overarching, the staff report, hopefully you guys had a chance to review the staff report and the details that are in there may provide a little bit more, but the hopes here today is that we'll just walk through them and I'm going to walk through all four bullet points, you know, and their sort of ancillary components. And then I'm going to stop at the end of that. And I hope from that, you know, you guys can come forward and say, ask clarifying questions.

13:32 Or have general dialogue about what you're hearing. So the first and foremost on the focus items is education, you know, and kind of putting there both visitor and resident, because I think that's a need we have, you know, for our community and really sort of mitigating the community environmental impacts from visitation. You know, we talk about this a lot, that natural resource, that limited resource, you know, how do we...

14:00 prevent too much of an impact on that, and that goes through educating folks that are here. I think there's also a component of educating our current residents, maybe a little bit on, you know, what we're doing in this regard, how we're trying to minimize the impact to that, and just a general conversation around acknowledging the impacts, but also the need to have visitors. I mean, we frankly exist here because of our resort status and our visitation.

14:29 So that's really important. So continuing to promote reasonable travel and stewardship. And some of this stuff is really on the work plans from prior year MLT projects. And they were things that are important to continue. And that's why they're listed here as well. Under the education one, point C is really awareness and the diversity of experiences.

14:53 Spread people out into a multitude of areas that we have because we do have pockets of sort of amenity around here, natural and man-made and really sort of getting people to understand what those are and educating folks on their existence. I mean, a lot of times people come up here and do the sport that they're planning on doing, but they may be introduced to another area or something that would provide them.

15:17 With, you know, even more enjoyment, more draw to our community. That includes some of the major initiatives we have, like Walk, Bike, Ride, and really, you know, enhancing on the host program. I'm not saying, like, talking about funding the host program. I'm talking about, you know, maybe some talking points for the host program. How do they sell? How do they work through those processes? How do they sort of sell that? I mean, if they're the ambassadors that are on scene, how do they...

15:43 Navigate what to provide. What are the talking points? How do they spread those out? So it's really kind of leaning in on that particular area and providing sort of the expertise on how to manage the visitors and what they're doing here. The second focus point is re-energizing the destination visitation. Some feedback we heard from council, we want to kind of broaden.

16:09 Sort of the draw, if you will. So we talk about the things that we have within Mammoth Lakes, but we have resources within Mammoth County that can draw visitors to Mammoth Lakes that provide amenities that are outside of our boundaries. And so, you know, kind of pushing the envelope a little bit on that regional promotion and getting those broader appeal and audience attraction, because I think there will be things that may exist within the county that draw folks to us and stay within the town of Mammoth Lakes, if you will.

16:37 But we really want, you know, lifting of the economic for the entire region would be a strong result of that. We talk about targeting the shoulder seasons. You know, we talk about a limited resource that we have. You know, we can only cram so many people in at a time. And I think, you know, in the heights of our visitation, we've got those really well covered. It's really how do we kind of focus in on the target for the shoulder seasons and when we may be down a little bit on

17:07 On visitation and up on capacity, how do we sort of balance that out a little bit? Extended stays at three nights or more. John is always talking about the midweek stays and how we've got opportunity there to spread out and get more visitation during that time period because the resources are available to us.

17:32 Focusing on that, that's a really important growth opportunity for us and seeing that as important to put a lot of marketing into. Maintaining an appropriate level of brand marketing for Southern California, really promoting that charter air service to MMH.

17:50 That's sort of our core market. I know we've got designs around looking broader and really bringing folks from elsewhere, but don't lose sight of the fact that when you think about the resort for ski resorts and such from Southern California, Mammoth is the one. And so let's keep that on point and keep that sort of process working well. But then expanding the marketing outside of the region.

18:16 You know, these strong air connections now through Bishop and the Commercial Air Service down there, connecting through Denver and just the Denver connects to the entire world. So, you know, how do we get, we get those folks coming from long distances who will have those longer stays, who will have, you know, probably more discretionary funds to spend on their stays and just really working on those, those expansion, expanded commercial flights. How do we get those other regions?

18:44 The third bullet point or third focus point, local community, you know, marketing focus, this is getting to be a little bit more on the intrinsic side than just outwardly directions, but reflecting the community values in our intended community, in our intended visitor experience, we have a culture in this town and we want to sort of represent that so that

19:11 You know, maybe locals feel a lot like when someone comes here, maybe they get to be a local for a while and they get to understand what that means and what it would take, you know, not what it would take to live here, but what it would be like to live here year-round. And that's the experience folks want to get. But I think having those fingerprints of our community on that experience, but in the marketing effort as well. And so I think that would be important. You know, the Buy Local campaigns.

19:39 You know, MLT themselves, you know, I think try to buy local with efforts they do, but it's very, you know, minimalistic as far as what can be supporting MLT's actual activities. But this is really more around promoting those local businesses and the visitor services that they provide and working to, you know, make them a part of what we're marketing for. And I hope that...

20:04 It sort of resonates with the business community that they're getting what they need out of MLT to support what they need to do for the visitors that are coming in. Strengthen and promote local business relationships in coordinating and maybe focusing on visitor experience. The visitor experience is something I worry about a lot. I think we've got opportunity there where

20:34 We can provide either a good experience or a bad experience. And I think if we focus in on the ways to provide the best experience for them, then we get that repeat customer and folks coming back. But it's also going to be less impactful on the local community as well. And if we're bolstering services that support the visitation, it would provide maybe more services available for locals and feel less impacted by our peak seasons if we focus in a little bit on that.

21:05 Assisting to define, you know, the where and the what of local infrastructure enhancements that, you know, really needed to have the best impact on our visitor experience. So, you know, not asking to fund, you know, the bathrooms in the Lake Space Center or any of that type of stuff. It's really just more, where do we need to, where does the town need to invest?

21:31 In amenities that will support visitation. Where are the pinch points? Where are the problem areas? You know, what are we hearing from feedback? And we'll kind of get to that excess measurements here in a bit, but it's really, what are we, what are you guys seeing? What do you think would be the biggest bang for the buck on helping the cost and, you know, providing that feedback to us? The, you know, engaging in peer network, you know, resort.

21:57 Thank you so much.

22:21 And utilizing the feedback they get through that process and directing traffic on what we do here in our local area. And then promoting local events, you know, enhance and expand events and development of maybe event venues that are out there. And that would be working in conjunction with the town, obviously, on event venues. But that's our bread and butter. A lot of the time for the summer is just having those things that draw folks here. And so that's a critical component.

22:51 Finally, fourth bullet point is around developing successful measures. And I say alongside of traditional marketing measures, typically when we receive an update from MLT on the success of a campaign or something along the lines to that, it's really those marketing measurements, the click-through rates, the viewing time on the page and all that type of stuff that means a lot in your world as far as marketing.

23:17 I want to step back from that a little bit and kind of go to the measuring the impacts. So almost, you know, on a higher level of what is happening based upon either our visitation or activities that are going on. And so for that, we kind of, we talked about surveys, maybe surveys are an outdated process, but we really do need, you know, a sort of a measurement that gets to the core impact of visitation.

23:46 And gets that feedback loop. I'm hoping that what we generate over time is that we have a really good data gathering point here. And we know it informs the decisions of what council wants to focus on in the future. It informs the approach that MLT will take in executing those in the future.

24:03 We talk about guest surveys, you know, really visitor satisfaction surveys that helped to identify those pain points. You know, where is the troubling areas within our experience? You know, we may not see it because we live here all the time and an outside eye may pick that up. You know, business surveys, you know, what are they seeing? You know, are they able to increase their revenues? Are they doing well from the activity that we have? Is there something we could do differently to support that opportunity? And then finally, resident surveys.

24:33 You know, really focusing in on what we're trying to do to mitigate the impacts of that, you know, improve the quality of life indicators and those types of things. And I think that's, you know, while some of these things may seem like they reside outside of the influence of MLT, I think they would go a long way not only to, you know, sort of interject MLT into those areas a little bit tighter and maybe do some relationship building there, but I think it would really, you know, serve to inform.

25:02 How we're doing, you know, how we're doing with our resort, how we're doing with inviting visitors and what can we do better. So I'll kind of pause there. That's the four bullet points with some underlying bits and pieces to kind of drive for understanding. But happy to field questions to either myself or council. Thank you, Rob, for helping us walk through those again. They are a little bit different than what we discussed last week.

25:31 And so I wanted to take an opportunity to let Council comment on these and add air, discuss anything in their minds. So if I may, I'd like to start with you, Bill, because you do represent the Council on Mount Flakes Tourism. And so I'd like to kind of see your take on this before everybody else. You know, I thought they were all well thought out when we viewed them last week.

26:02 I think that what we're seeing today, the only changes are ones that staff has heard from council. So I'm comfortable with them moving forward. The one thing I would like to add to it is as we tighten up this contract, which is what we're attempting to do here, that we don't lose sight of the need to be absolutely flexible. You know, we don't know if there's going to be COVID. We don't know if there's going to be a major drought. We don't know if we're going to have snow for the rest of this year.

26:29 So in terms of going out and changing the message that MLT is sending, which we have been very successful with in the past, I think we need to keep that in mind, that flexibility. I don't know how you would add it to the contract, but that I think is hugely important. Otherwise, I'm happy with the bullet points here. Okay, Bill. Thank you. I appreciate that. Let's see. John, do you want to take any comments on this? Yes, thank you very much.

27:00 Brief and succinct because I really want to hear from the MLT board and really do have a conversation here. On the overarching goals, I appreciate that they're included. I think we need a little wordsmithing here. I'm not sure what achieve a sustainable destination with natural resources means. I think we could do a little better with that. So let's do some work on these things. The sentiment is right. It's the right thing, but I think we've got to do some work on that. And to be clear,

27:28 Rob, you mentioned the deliverables would be in the agreements or something else is going to come back to us. It's going to be more granular, more tiering from these things, correct? That's correct. So we usually review the deliverables, which are the strategies that are developed by MLT around early May, late April, early May. Right. And so we've done that in prior years as well. We intended to. And this is just informing them on how to.

27:58 Where to focus and what strategies we want to, not not as strategies, but what we want them to address. Okay, so then I think just from the definitional side, I think it's, I think we need to be very clear what we talk about when we say regional. And I think we're not, in my mind, we're not just talking about Mono County. I think that

28:21 The Eastern Sierra Council of Governments includes both Inyo and Mono Counties. We have important and critical partnerships with City of Bishop and Inyo County as well. We just completed a very significant regional effort that also included Alpine County. So I think we need to be very explicit about that. We don't want to be confusing any of our regional partners about that. On 3D.

28:45 assist to define where what local infrastructure. I'm wondering if we could add the word programming into that as well, because there's obviously infrastructure things, but the town's got investments, a lot of programming, and a lot of that programming stuff is going to be very important, that soft tissue stuff going forward with that.

29:04 On the peer network engagement, we talked about the Colorado Association of Ski Towns. Dan and I have talked a little bit about that. It's a very minimal investment to have access to that network. But I want to make sure that that does not get siloed off just into MOT's world. I think the council needs to know about that. And I don't know if that's something that we can deal with that later, but the council needs to know what's happening in those peer communities. And that may be on the council side of things and not just...

29:32 on the MLT side of things. And just a quick note on surveys. Obviously, I'm sure the MLT board is aware that doing surveys on federal land is an existential proposition. So we want to make sure that the surveys that you got, whatever surveys you're doing, are capturing the experience that people are having on federal lands because that's what they're here to do. But just a cautionary note on that one. And thank you. All right. Thank you, John.

30:04 Kirk. Kirk is there. There's Kirk. Okay. Yeah. Hi, Kirk. Hi, Linda. You know, we talk about quality of life, but we also need to focus on quality of visitation, and I think this does, and trying to find that balance between the locals and, you know, making, obviously, a living, and then the quality of visitation. So I think this addresses it pretty well.

30:34 That's my comment. All right. Thanks. Thanks, Kirk. And Sarah? I don't have much to comment, but I did want to hop on John's suggestion that we get informed about the peer network conversations. I would really love to see, like, maybe a report on, you know, where we are in...

31:00 As compared to those peer networks, because I do think that is something that doesn't come to counsel a ton. So no other questions besides that. All right, great. My comments are, you know, that I think this is, you know, very far along. Comments that both Bill, John, everybody have made, I would agree with. I think it just, you know, puts it a little together. But remember, the next opportunity we have to see this will be when we get closer to the contract. And so having it ready to go.

31:29 Well ahead of time, as we haven't always been very successful at, I think is absolutely perfect. Plus that the MLT would realize that these are well thought out and now it's going to be our opportunity to get the feedback from the board members of MLT. I mean, as a partnership, this would be more ideal of a early on discussion and agreement on the overarching goals. And while the focus items.

31:58 Are examples of, I don't think anyone on town council wants to be the body that is, you know, granularly telling MLT how to run their business. And so I think this hits a bit of a medium point in that. So I'm happy to proceed with this. And Jeremy, on that note, can you then maybe walk some of your members through comments and maybe examples and thoughts about these different focus items?

32:27 Yeah, you know, I'd like to start, you know, with our Executive Director, John Urdi, kind of just talking to some of the points that you brought up. And John, you know, I went back and listened to what Town Council discussed last week.

32:45 And, you know, it's being brought up again here, kind of the peer community, this Colorado Association of Ski Towns. I know we've been extremely involved, have a great partnership with Cal Travel, you know, and I want you to, I think some of the things that we do with Cal Travel are kind of lend to what the town council is asking about.

33:11 And so I definitely want you to focus on that if you can for a moment. And then if there's anything else that, you know, town councilors brought up just now that you want to speak to, and then we'll kind of go through the board real quickly. Yeah, absolutely. So the Cal Travel Association is really the advocacy wing for tourism in the state of California. I've sat on that board now for about 10 years. And so Visit California is the promotional wing for the state of California and Cal Travel focuses on the legal challenges.

33:41 That face businesses in the tourism industry in California. So we are very well versed with that among other destinations within the state. You know, it's not always comparable when places like San Francisco and San Diego and Los Angeles are spending lots of time, lots of effort, lots of money on homelessness in a different way. Obviously, people living on the street and not just not being able to find housing. So that's been very helpful. I think the other side with the peer.

34:09 The peer comparisons, you know, we do keep an eye on what's going on out there. And I think as far as I've got a lot of different contacts everywhere from Jackson Hole to Aspen to Vail and looking at how they're dealing with different situations, looking at how they're dealing with workforce challenges, looking at how they're dealing with fires, looking at how they're communicating messaging on transportation challenges. So I think the Colorado Association of Ski Towns is a great start.

34:36 I think working with our friends at Ski California are helpful for the Ski Town challenges that we all face. And so I do think that we can continue to expand on those and probably set up our own peer networks as well. And I do tend to forward articles.

34:54 Different pieces that I find out there either to Dan and Rob or to some of the council members as well as our board when they are something that really kind of rings true with what we're dealing with here. So we can start to see how is the town of Vail dealing with parking challenges or how are they dealing with restaurant closures or how are they dealing with housing. So we will continue to expand on that opportunity too.

35:17 Learn from other places. And frankly, we're working closely with Sandra and Nolan at the town to help really promote the efforts that are going on here in town for the housing challenges to let the world know what we're doing and hopefully others can learn from us as well. So in general, I thank you, Rob. I think Rob and I do spend a fair amount of time together and working through these four bullet points.

35:44 You know, there are, as Rob mentioned, these are a lot of things that we have been focused on for a few years, whether it's been that education. You know, in the summertime, we are not just inviting people here to have fun hiking, biking, golfing, et cetera. We're really asking them to come up here and be stewards for the community and for the environment. We'll continue to focus on that. I think some of the new things where we're focusing more on the resident surveys, I think that should be something that's in conjunction with the town itself.

36:12 I think we really need to do that jointly to really get that feedback. And I think we need to couch it so that we don't just get the, I guess, the angry comments that we expect to get back because as also was mentioned, we are a tourism town. And I think that the idea that we should just eliminate tourism is not really a sound.

36:30 Business plan for us here. So I think we've got an opportunity to continue on those pieces. The air service into Mammoth Yosemite Airport is critically important for us. I think that the opportunities there are going to be very widespread as we move forward. We've got a great partner in Advanced Airlines. We also have other airline partners that we've talked to in the past that we could bring back in. And we all know that the folks that are flying in here tend to have a little bit more on the resources, maybe spend a little more time here.

36:59 There were folks coming in on the Monday flight from Carlsbad that were here Monday through Thursday, which is exactly what we're hoping for. Get those folks into the restaurants, get those folks out onto the hill when we're not piling on the...

37:14 The people when we don't need them necessarily. So looking at all the opportunities and looking at how we can spread that out, the diversity of the experience, doing things like our trail challenge programs in the summertime, the host program has been something that we jumped on supporting immediately when that came out because we do feel that that education piece is key. And so I do think that all the pieces that we have down here are critical to the success of the community. And I do think the one bullet point that really

37:41 What resonates with me is reflecting community values in our intended visitor experience. You know, we really want to make sure that people are coming here to enjoy what we enjoy as residents. They're coming here to enjoy it as visitors, but we want them to realize that they need to be able to treat it as our residents do. You know, it's not just come here, have fun, destroy the place and leave. And so that's where our energy has been over the last couple of summers. Last year, we spent three quarters of a million dollars in quote unquote marketing and advertising.

38:11 Really to educate people on how to respect the community and environment. And that was the Mammoth Lakes Love Song, the Hug What You Love Campaign, and all those different pieces that really were trying to educate people on how to live with our locals and make sure that they don't trash the place. So I'm very comfortable with where we're headed with these pieces. John Wentworth, to your point, we have...

38:37 Our process really starts here in March with our board of directors with building our strategies and goals, which really comes from this conversation. So from these four bullet points, we sit down with our board, we figure out the strategies and goals moving forward. Once those are set, we come back in April with the deliverables to our board at that first Wednesday of April. We will get on the calendar for your second meeting of April. Once those are approved by our board, we'll present goals, strategies, and deliverables. Then we come back in...

39:05 In May to our board with the first draft of budgets and plans with the idea that we get those finalized in June and start the fiscal year on July 1. So that is the planning calendar that we have set in the past. I would like to see us get into, you know, we're in January with our first quarterly meeting. I think April, July, and October makes sense to have these quarterly check-ins. I think they've been incredibly valuable.

39:31 You know, even just the meeting you had last week and being able to address some of these things prior to this meeting, I think has made this a much smoother process. So I appreciate that. Awesome. Thank you, John, for all of that. Hopefully that answers at least a little bit on the peer communities, gives you a little clarification on some of the things that we're already involved in, but we can most certainly add to that.

39:58 I wanted to just give my board members a chance to comment. I'm going to start with my executive committee. So I'll start with my vice chair, Mr. Pat Foster. Do you want to make any comments, Pat, on these focus points, focus items that we've discussed? Yeah, you know what, I'll keep it brief. One, I want to thank you all for being here. I think this is a very important step in the process.

40:26 I watched the council meeting last week. Rob, I think you and your staff did a terrific job in outlining these bullet points. I think it's a great framework for us. I think it focuses on all the important things that we need to focus on, which is one, tourism, but two, responsible tourism, and educating our visitors, protecting our resources, and doing what's best for our businesses. So I think this is a great first step. I really have no...

40:54 No issues with any of the bullet points. Like I said, Rob, I think you did a great job. I think that this looks really good. Our board does serve the council. And so hearing this, going through this list, going through this process, I really appreciate it. And I'm looking forward to next steps. Awesome. Thank you, Pat. Mr. Morris, would you like to say any comments? Yeah, good evening. Again, yeah, I think I did what Pat said. I really appreciate the time.

41:23 I definitely agree. We need these meetings. Hopefully we can get them done quarterly on a regular basis. It really helps for us to get a mutual understanding of what issues you guys are facing, what the town is facing, and for you to understand the things that MLT is doing and some of the issues that we're facing. So it really kind of clears up any issues that might be between the two groups that are misunderstood. Just a couple comments. I know we will get into the budgeting or the revenue side of things in a minute.

41:52 Kind of want to just, and I appreciate, I think, what was said last week, but sort of this mantra that John and I have been, John, what Erty and I have been talking about is that is using tourism revenue to help address the issues that arise from tourism. And that really is sort of where I think a lot of our focus is on the board. And where I'm going with that is, you know, as long as the tourism department is being...

42:18 It's being successful and revenues are increasing that will in turn drive. Yes, it drives issues. No question about it. We're all seeing there are issues, community and environmental issues that are going on right now. There's absolutely no question about that. And those are derived from the fact that we have a lot of people here and not a lot of people to service them, unfortunately. But anyway, that's that's where we I hope we can keep that that focus because the revenues definitely can can help.

42:47 Generate revenues to help some of the problems we've had. Just a couple of the comments. Let's see. When we're talking about the education piece, you know, and I'm not sure if it was John or Jeremy that said it, but I hate to say this, but we really do need to educate our locals, too, about not trashing the place because...

43:07 They're somewhat guilty as well. So if we're going to do that education piece, it needs to start with the locals. The locals need to be walking the walk and talking the talk and making sure that they're picking up their trash and their dog poop and all those other things that we want our guests to do when they come here. And we all know we have our friends that are not always so good at that. So definitely want to make sure we have that piece to the locals too, that it's a joint.

43:35 Education of preserving this beautiful place that we live in and making sure that we're not adversely affecting it. Just two more quick comments. One is regarding the, there was talk about promoting the areas outside of Mammoth.

43:51 I understand where you guys are going with that. And I think John Erty can talk to this a little better than me. We want to be a little careful with that, how much we drive people out of town. The T-bid part of it is, and I know it's a separate discussion really, but the T-bid is, that's got to be really careful because.

44:09 The T-Bit is paid by people that are businesses in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and if we're sending people outside of Mammoth, then that's a tricky thing. As far as Measure A dollars and that sort of thing, certainly we do want people to be aware of the great surroundings we have, and we want to try to mitigate. We always talk about the Lakes Basin, so let's use that as the example. We don't want the Lakes Basin to get just pounded with people all the time. We'd like to spread people out.

44:34 I'm sure that a lot of people, restaurants would like people to stay in town for lunch and not go out of town for the whole day. So there's, you know what I mean? There's a balance there. So I think we just have to be a little careful with sending people out of Mammoth too much. The final thing is in regards to, Rob, you brought this up in regards to numbers. And again, Mr. Urdi can probably speak to this better than myself.

44:56 But, you know, a lot of times the numbers are how we gauge our success in a lot of the campaigns that we do. The, you know, the success of a specific marketing campaign and so forth. And I understand where you guys are coming from that you get bombarded with numbers and it starts to get blurry over a while. And I totally get that. But that's how MLT measures the individual successes of campaigns, broader successes as far as.

45:21 The surveys, the visitor satisfaction, absolutely 100%. We need to make sure that our guests are having a good time while they're here. And if they're not, what are we doing not doing? What things can we do to improve their experience? That is absolutely 100% critical. So appreciate the work that everybody has done on this. It's a fantastic start. Probably not too many tweaks needed by the MLT side and appreciate all your guys' time. Thank you very much.

45:49 Wonderful. Thank you, Mr. Morris. Mr. Clark, would you like to provide any comments and feel free to mention anything from the Mammoth Mountain perspective as well? Thanks, Jeremy. And indeed, I have to start off, I know everybody's been saying it, but I too want to relay my gratitude for all the work that's gotten into this. I think the approach this year is fantastic.

46:15 Looking at the calendar and trying to get some feedback so that we're all working together as a team as we go forward trying to figure out our strategies for the coming years is just perfect. So I really appreciate that. It does allow us to take a look at many things.

46:32 And, you know, as we look at a region and we look at our communities, we know we have opportunities here in our communities. We know we have to focus on housing. We know we have to focus on the recreational experience for our guests and for our residents. We know we have to focus on transit and everything that comes along with those things. So as we, Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, look at this,

46:57 Our role can be in all these different four points that you talked about, and it's definitely within the area of raising enough money to address these concerns, right? So it's already been said, but it's important for us to understand that the funding to address our opportunities comes from tourism. And as we look at the last time that

47:23 The tourism board sat down and came up with some business objectives. You know, one of them was achieve $20 million in annual TOT and do that by FY22-23, with five months of that being $1 million and five months being that $2 million. That specific goal was related to trying to find a more consistent business community and really trying to make sure that we're continuing.

47:51 To look at the economic growth that we need to look at. It was mentioned already that sustainable destination environment and how important that is and certainly some wordsmithing. The sustainable economic growth is also just as important. So it's great to see that this process is going through and looking at that. All the other items that everybody's mentioned, I won't go into, but I just wanted to add that in terms of.

48:20 And overall process. I think we're really figuring it out and moving forward together. So appreciate that very much. Wonderful. Thank you so much, Eric. Deb Ratcliffe, would you like to add any comments?

48:36 No, I just reiterate what my fellow board members have mentioned. Rob, great job. I think it was very succinctly done, very purposeful, very focused. And as we all know, if we try to do everything, we won't accomplish anything. And so I think if we're focused on these areas, I think we'll be successful. And, you know, John already made a point about, you know, people come here to enjoy, you know, what we love, but they also have high expectations.

49:05 And I see it and experience it every single day because I'm a business owner here and I hear, you know, people on transit, I hear things and it'll be really interesting to understand how we can effectively and reasonably meet those expectations, but also within, you know, with the residents and the businesses here. And so the number four, which is about the measurement and understanding.

49:30 The feedback from the visitors, the businesses, and the residents, and how we can consolidate those so that effectively we can meet everybody's expectations. And so this is my first meeting here with the Joint Council, so I appreciate that. And I appreciate you allowing me to be part of the organization and just really looking forward to how we can bring all this together. Wonderful. Thank you so much, Deb.

49:56 Mr. Sauser, I know you spoke on behalf of the town councilor. Is there anything on the MLT side of things you would like to make mention of? Wait, let me switch hats. I actually have a couple of comments just based on what everybody has said so far. Wonderful. Go right ahead, sir. On the outside of Mammoth Promotions and the problem with potential TBD and everything else there, the fact is...

50:26 We cannot survive on what is just in Mammoth. We are not just skiing in the Lakes Basin. We have motorcycle riders. We have snowmobile riders. We have cross-country runners. We have high-altitude runners. We have birders. And the majority of these things take place outside of Mammoth. And I think a direct correlation could be made to the success of all the businesses paying into TBID and promoting those activities. I think they are critical to spreading our people out. Yes, we have to be careful.

50:56 It is critical that we spread people out. So our advertising needs to go to some of those places and some of those other things. Eric, thank you for mentioning the fact that sustainability isn't just environmental sustainability, but economic sustainability. That is an important piece of NEPA and CEQA and everything else that is often forgotten. So I want to thank you for bringing that forward. The word sustainability has been used.

51:25 to try and close an awful lot of trails that I ride on. And I appreciate that someone else sees that we have to be economically viable first and foremost. Other than that, I'm good to go. Thanks. Wonderful. Thank you, Mr. Salzer. You know, I'll conclude it here and then I'll hand it back to you, Madam Mayor. The focus items are fantastic.

51:54 They make a lot of sense to me. Well thought out. Well done. Rob Patterson, thank you again for your time and effort putting that together. You know, I represent the Chamber of Commerce as well, and I just wanted to speak to that briefly. You know, we have to be, as the MLT organization, acutely aware of what is happening in our community.

52:22 And I just wanted to let you know that we are, you know, we have a very strong partnership with the Chamber of Commerce, providing an excellent guest experience, providing excellent customer service, making sure that the messaging, you know, the marketing, the resources that we're putting out there

52:48 You know, jive with what our small business community is doing. And so I just wanted to speak to that briefly, that it is very important for our organization, even though we may not necessarily be the organization that provides the solution to whatever the issue may be.

53:09 It is very important that we are aware of what's going on and that we are taking that into account when we are putting together our strategy and tactics. And I know John Urdi and his staff take that into account. And so I wanted to communicate that and really kind of drive that home. But that's my kind of one comment on this is that we are well aware of, and we will continue to be through surveys.

53:39 And different ways of getting that information. And as things change, you know, but I think we are very plugged into what the local community, especially the business community is experiencing, whether it's housing issues, staffing issues, you know, you know, you know, kind of a high volume of visitation and business, you know, we are aware of those things and we are.

54:06 You know, taking that into account when we are putting together our marketing strategies for the community, because we understand that we represent in large part the voice of this community, you know, kind of our messaging is a lot of times what people are seeing first before they decide to book their trip here or come to Mammoth to visit. So I just wanted to kind of speak to that. And with that, Madam Mayor, I will.

54:34 You know, bring it back to you. Okay, thank you. I'd like to know, I'm sorry, I'm just trying to find my mute, make sure it's on. Yeah, thank you to all the members here for speaking up and talking about that. And for my part, I just wanted to comment that this is something that we want to hear more regularly. You know, John and I talked about it, even that, you know, monthly.

55:04 So I would definitely like to see that again.

55:33 And keep us well informed about what everyone's doing. And so we're back then to, I think, based on the comments made here, I'd like to circle back to council. And if you have any comments, just raise your hand and I'll call on you to fill out this conversation before we move on. Anybody would like to say anything? Nope, I don't see any. Oh, John, yes. I'm muted, John. John, muted.

56:06 Sorry, I raised my virtual hand. I'll make sure I raised my analog hand going forward. So I've got a couple of thoughts here and I hope everybody can just indulge me for a couple of things. These may be some things to get some conversations started. And I think that it's a key theme here is I think that it's nice to hear that we're all sort of in agreement and the document looks nice and that's good. We've done some good work, but I think we're really just getting started with all this. And I think...

56:35 All of us recognize that we're moving into another level of sophistication with how we manage this destination. And I think we need to be looking at it from a systems perspective. And that's maybe a little bit dry, but I'll come back to that in a second. So the first thing on that overarching goal statement, I did not, please don't peg me as being someone who's just calling out the environmental side or the natural resources side of things. I'll just, you know.

57:04 calling out the clunky grammar. So I think it would be helpful when that statement is redrafted that it's not two statements. We're not setting up a binary statement about business versus natural resources. It's one statement. It's a holistic statement. And I think that's an interesting challenge. It sounds like a lot of fun, but I think Rob, that's something you and staff can figure out a way to draft something like that. A couple other points. John Ernie, when you mentioned about the peer

57:33 Look at the peer resorts and the cast and those kinds of groups. And a lot of the things you rattled off are obviously of real interest, but those are of real policy interest to the council. And a lot of those things are things that the council has the authority to act on and needs to be acting on. So, Sarah, just to, you know, echo what you said, that

57:55 Peer engagement needs to be at the council level as well. And it's something that we need to be engaged with. It's an obvious point at this point, but a lot of these ski towns now are all sharing a similar ski pass, whether it's the Epic Pass or the Icon Pass. We have a lot of conversations to have with our communities. There are also Icon Pass communities.

58:20 So that we can work constructively with Altera management and Altera leadership in Denver to say, look, we're seeing a common set of problems and concerns there across all the communities. And these are policy issues I want to make just to follow up on what Sarah said to really emphasize that. On this issue of the regional, I'm just going to throw in something that's a nuance and make sure we're clear about that.

58:50 MLT and the town need to be participating in the regional conversation around visitation. This is not about should visitors go here or there. The air service that's coming into Bishop is something that we cannot underestimate for a single second. You know, the Whitefish, Montana airport out in the middle of nowhere, growing, expanding, going crazy, 50,000 employments. We are going to be in that business.

59:19 And if you look at some peer destinations like what's happening in Jackson Hole, where there's enormous civil resistance to what's happening with tourism, that the over-tourism things we were talking about before the pandemic, that has just gotten worse. And if you look at what the state of Hawaii is doing, the kind of proactive measures they're making about a 21st century sustainable tourism statewide program, we need to be

59:47 Knowing that stuff and working as a region to make sure that we are ahead of that. We are being proactive. We have enormous opportunities, but it's going to require enormous engagement. Just wanted to point that out. Another point that I think is the most significant thing is we go back to the systems analogy. This is great for looking at MLT, looking at the specifics of what you're going to be doing. But the town side of the ledger,

1:00:17 is not complete. We haven't even talked about that yet. And if you look at, we could maybe kind of get started with this, if you look at, you know, 3D assist to define where and what local infrastructure programming enhancements are needed, it's going to be very hard for me as a council member to support this contract when it comes back if it's not clearly articulated what are the town's responsibilities in this system and in this

1:00:44 In this system, in this management of being a sustainable destination, I'm going to need to see, okay, if MLT is doing all this, what are the town's roles and responsibilities so we go into this knowing who's doing what. It's going to be critical to avoid the miscommunications and the frustrations in the past. Both sides of the ledger have to be populated. So I turn to Dan and Rob a little bit on that. I mean, I don't know how we want to do that, but...

1:01:11 That's got to be really clear. It's got to be really clear so we can say to the constituents, to the community, MLT is doing this. This is what they do. This is our responsibility. This is the town's responsibility. So we can really mitigate the frustrations and the conflict and some of that kind of stuff. So we really embrace MLT as a partner. MLT embraces the town as a partner. And we're doing this together as a systemic thing. Finally, I just want to point out

1:01:43 Well, as part of that, we're generating an enormous amount of TOT. That's a great thing. From my perspective, there are two things that are sort of principal priorities for the town to do with that funding. The first is to invest in the programs and infrastructure that we need to be doing with MLT to make this a successful, sustainable destination.

1:02:08 We have to hold up our end of the bargain. It needs to be clear what our roles and responsibilities are, and we have to be doing that. And the second thing is to take advantage of this unbelievable sort of micro economy to invest in housing. The council's already made those commitments, and I think that if we optimize ourselves as a sustainable destination, we're going to be able to put a dent in the community's housing needs that no other...

1:02:36 Peer community like anyone in the West could do something like that. And we need to articulate that very clearly to the public. This is what we're doing with the funding that's coming in with these dollars. I know we're on the way to doing that, but we all need to be on the same page with that. And finally, I would just emphasize, as we optimize this system, this sustainable destination, that what's really at the heart of all this, from my perspective, is caring, taking care, taking care of this

1:03:05 We as a community need to take care of ourselves

1:03:29 of our community, of our environment, of this whole thing. And I think if we go into this with that kind of an attitude, that's going to get us to the point of being successful, which we are, but we can optimize that success. And that goes back to that point about sustainability. I'm not using that term in a pejorative sense. It is just a common sense use of that word. Can we do all this in a way that it's going to be around?

1:03:53 For 100 years, for future generations, for everything. That's got to be all of our goal. If we all take care of ourselves, our place, our businesses, the people that work for us, the people that work for us, I think we're going to have a good chance of getting there. So sorry for the soapbox, but I've been stewing on this a little bit. So thank you very much for indulging those thoughts. The place to do it. Thank you, John, for that. Any other council members with any comments or closing thoughts on this topic?

1:04:20 I did just want to make what my boss calls a sprinkle, which is, yeah, just something to think of for our future discussions. I know we're probably not going to hammer it out tonight, but one thing I'd really be interested in seeing, and I'm sorry I didn't mention this at first, was, you know, which point is it? It's a three, it's the infrastructure point, so 3D.

1:04:49 I feel like MLT could really potentially take ownership of some of the marketing and beautification on our streets in town. I know that our town historically takes care of that stuff, the snowflakes.

1:05:13 And the banners. And I just wanted to, like, throw out the idea that that might be something that MLT could really shine at while taking some of the burden off of our town staff. So just throwing that out there. That's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Mayor Salcido, we do have a member of the public with a comment. Very good. Thank you, Jamie. Ask him to go ahead, please. Ron Cohen, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:05:45 Hey, everyone. Ron Cohen, President of Manhattan, June Mountains. Thanks for the discussion. I just wanted to add a couple of points. Like everyone else, appreciate the work going in ahead of this and trying to narrow down the focus of where MLT is looking over the next year. For me, it really comes down to priorities. And when I think generally about priorities in the town,

1:06:14 I think of maintaining vibrant visitation, keeping our air service program going and making sure that we grow it and get the advantage of the amazing work that's been done to get reliable regional air service going. But there's a bunch of other stuff, housing for our workforce, child care for our workforce.

1:06:44 Recreation experience for everyone, not just for visitors, but those of us who live here and moved here for that reason. Tourism impacts, what Councilmember Wentworth described as over tourism. Tourism impacts, we all know they're there. And transit, modern, efficient transit in our region. Those are all a bunch of really important priorities in my mindset for

1:07:12 For the town. And so when I think about all those priorities and I look at the focus items, I start to immediately think about who does what. And MLT is an incredibly successful and a highly skilled organization.

1:07:34 Fantastic. A marketing pro. We're so lucky to have him leading marketing for MLT in our community. I've got a great marketing team here at the ski area. And I know that if I asked Joanie to lead her team to go out and maintain the lifts, they would do the best they could. But I wouldn't ask them to do that because they're not the right people to do that. And so I think about what we're operating and what we're marketing.

1:08:03 And so when I look at the focus items, what I really see in there and what I don't see in there is really the key things that I think MLT ought to be focused on. MLT ought to be focused on vibrant visitation and maintaining the air service program over everything else. That's their core mission. That's what they're really, really good at. And so, and we need it. We need it consistently.

1:08:32 It doesn't matter how successful the ICON pass program is. We've got to keep visitation coming. That's our economy. And so to me to not have that as the number one overriding thing that MLT is focused on, it's not correctly aligned from my perspective. I'm sure some people disagree, but I would just give that comment.

1:08:59 Some other comment, you know, things like education. We can spend a half a million dollar a summer telling people not to litter, or we can spend a half a million dollar a summer installing trash cans and emptying them when they get full. And we have to decide where we're going to put our money. And I think that infrastructure point is key. And that leads me to my last point, which is...

1:09:27 I think very similar to the one that Councilmember Wentworth just made. This contract with MLT, it really does look like we're trying to get everything. We want to throw everything in the kitchen sink with the limited amount of money that we're providing to MLT. What are all the other things that we're going to do with the money that's generated by TOT?

1:09:57 I think it takes town council to really prioritize those things. Where are we going to spend that money? If we can say, hey, as a town, we're going to spend our general fund money on these priorities, things like housing and childcare and transit, and the things that aren't mainly in MLT's bailiwick, that could really help MLT narrow down in the contract what they really ought to be focused on. If we don't do that, they're going to try to...

1:10:25 Grab everything because like a good organization, they're hearing all the pressures in the community. And when they hear and feel the pressures, they want to respond to that. But we've got to do the work of narrowing that down for them and not looking to MLT to achieve all those wins for us. So, you know, I think we're in a totally different world than we were three, four, five years ago. There's some major changes.

1:10:54 to talk about and how our funding comes in and where we ought to be focusing. And I look forward to having that conversation with council and with the community. I really think that will help us when we get to the next step with MLT in defining exactly what that contract should be. Thanks for the opportunity to talk. Okay, thank you, Ron. Jamie, was there any other public comment? No, there was not. Okay. You know, to Ron's point,

1:11:25 A few months ago and last year, the Town Council worked on those strategic priorities. They're pretty simple. It's not long. It's all contained on one piece of paper. And I think that if we lined that up and compared it with the sort of MLT direction, I think we would find areas in there where we're identifying that exactly what Ron brought up and knowing that we were doing those priorities.

1:11:52 And how Mammoth Lakes Tourism fits into that so there's not redundancy or confusion about who's doing what. I think that's a sound idea. That being said, is there anybody either on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board or on Town Council who would like to have another comment before we move on here? Madam Mayor, this is John. Just one final comment.

1:12:20 Follow up on what John Wentworth said. And that is regarding caring, helping each other and that whole sentiment. That is something that is super critical and it's hard. You know, we've been trying this with the Lodging Association for many, many years. We've had some success. We've had a lot of people join in on a regular basis. We've talked about a lot of important things.

1:12:40 I guess the thing I want to say is we've got to continue to try. We cannot be siloed in our businesses, in our segments and stuff. We've got to come together. I'm not trying to do kumbaya here, but seriously, we definitely need people to understand and feel appreciated. I'll just say it hurts me personally when I go into Vons and I see people I've lived here for 35 years now. And when I see people that I've known all that time who are angry with me.

1:13:09 For being part of MLT because they feel like I'm part of the problem. And that's tough. And I've tried to have conversations and sometimes they just don't want to talk about it anymore because they're just overworked and underpaid and frustrated and yada, yada. And we've got to get away from that to the extent that we possibly can. Can't please everybody, but we have to continue these conversations and bring people in so that, you know, all the people that, as many people that work and live here can enjoy it and make a living at the same time.

1:13:36 But we've got to continue these conversations in a broader community basis. So thanks for your comments, John, on that. I appreciate that. Thank you. Yeah, thank you, John. I think just not to beat this up, but there is a real sense of fatigue right now. You know, we're two years in. A few months ago, we thought we were getting a handle on this. And then it, you know, went sideways again. Schools closed again. Cases were up. So.

1:14:05 I think recognizing that as a source of constant stress and disappointment is one of the first things we can do. And then based on that, I don't know if that's a campaign chamber puts out or the town or how we want to talk about that, but it's that whole, you know, well-being of our community. You know, what are we doing? What actively can we do? How do we spread that? So maybe we need to...

1:14:33 Yeah, maybe look at that and have an item soon where we can talk about that a little bit and see what options we might have. So, but thank you for identifying that because I think that's really important. So, on that place right there, then what I'm hearing is a consensus on the part of both Town Council and the Board of Memphis Tourism that we are in

1:15:04 Agreement on the, certainly on the focus items and perhaps a little work to be done now, overarching goals, but allowing us to go forward with these on the part of MLT and on the part of Mammoth Lake or Town Council. Is there anybody that would not, would want to take issue or not agree in spirit with that? Madam Mayor, if I could just ask sort of a sequencing issue here. Is staff going to update?

1:15:34 Based on the comments that were delivered this evening, and then MLT will work based on those updated comments, and will those comments be circulated? Yes, that's my understanding, but we need to check in with Rob here and see if that's doable. Yeah, it's absolutely doable. You know, I think, and I think the process by which tonight you're sharing those thoughts with MLT, I mean, this isn't, this is an opportunity for council to share.

1:16:03 Where they want to focus on. And I think you've all done that very well. I think MLT's heard that. I know they're taking notes on that. The strategies that they employ to achieve those are coming forward. I don't know that wordsmithing down to a fine point on that is absolutely critical. I think they've heard what they want to focus on. I mean, we can certainly do whatever you'd like. I can freshen this up and we can pass it around. But at the end of the day, you guys have shared your focus points and that they've been heard.

1:16:32 Yeah, I just think, I think, Rob, it's important with the time and effort that went into this and the direction that's come from council. I think council would, and I think MLT board would very much like to see how the ideas and things are expressed get actually translated into a written document. And I think we need to really be documenting all these things because this is a foundation for the next step. It's a foundation for the next step. There may be points that we need to clarify.

1:16:59 And I would just request it. I mean, just a simple document that is the, you know, the overarching goals and the focus items, that that just, that's a sync list be updated based on what staff has heard this evening to make sure they're all kind of on the same page. Just to avoid confusion, to avoid misunderstandings. And there's going to be a lot of what we've got to do going forward. Yeah, absolutely. We can do that. Great. And then we'll be looking at the contract. When's the first time we actually see kind of a draft of the contract for 22-23, Ron?

1:17:28 Well, so we already, I mean, essentially we have a contract through the end of 23, so June 30th of 23. The only thing that we talk about on an annual basis is the deliverables and the compensation. So we will take a look at the deliverables. I think, as John already said, second meeting of April. And our next discussion topic for this evening will be funding. So hopefully those two elements are...

1:17:57 With this focus point well in its way, but the deliverables will be in late April. Okay. All right. Fine. All right. Yes, I'd like to make just one quick comment, if I could, please. I don't know that I want to see staff spend too much time rewriting, based on the comments today, what's already been done. I trust Mr. Erty and Mr. Patterson to get together and figure this out and bring it back to us with those comments.

1:18:24 being brought forward in the potential contract and contract language. I'd rather see that come back earlier than rehash something we've already done. Thank you. So what you're saying is that within the goals and focus items that the next time, you know, making sure that those are dusted off, making sure they reflect the conversations we had today, but not necessarily spend a huge amount of time in actually putting another agenda item together to bring forward. Is that what I'm hearing?

1:18:52 Yeah, I think the next agenda item to come forward should be some kind of a draft of what the deliverables are going to look like in the next contract for us to hash over rather than hashing this piece over again. Yeah, and just to be on my interest in hashing this over, I just want to see a record of what was heard. I mean, this could be done, I would think, in an hour at the most. So that's, you know, direction to staff. And are there other council members that would concur with that? Or are people, you know, kind of okay with just leaving it until it comes to us?

1:19:22 As a scope of work for the next contract. I also do not want to put a lot of work and effort into this. I think it will be reflected in that. So we can work with directing staff. I don't want to just give direction. I'm okay with what's proposed. I think if we put together a document and we clarify exactly the points we made tonight,

1:19:50 It will help us build on what we do for the future. I think it will also give council maybe a checklist of things that they could review to make sure they're addressed within the deliverables. I don't think it's too much. The point is, as MOT goes into their process, I would hope that they have the notes from today updated so that we don't wait until it comes back to the contract and the notes roll off.

1:20:19 It's a procedural thing. So, Rob, we'll leave you and John, I think, so John already to sort of, you know, parse that out, make sure it is where we want it, and then we can share that and make sure we're where we want to be. Sounds good? Okay, let's do that. Sounds very good. All right. So, let's move on then to the part of this, the staff report and the next discussion, which is the funding recommendation. So, Rob, again, if you could... Yeah, and I want to...

1:20:47 Absolutely. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I do want to make a couple of comments on some of the statements that I've heard so far just to kind of bring focus in what we're trying to achieve here tonight. I am very encouraged by the amount of passion that's out there and what I'm hearing with people that want to engage in the challenges that we have. And I think that that's going to bring...

1:21:12 Some very robust and good discussions in future meetings where we talk in general concepts about these processes. But tonight, you know, it's just how do we direct focus on where things are going with that. And I hope it wasn't going to be too broad, but we were asking for too much. It was just sort of narrowed down to, you know, here's what we think needs to be addressed. With regard to funding, you know, switching gears to that, you know,

1:21:38 Most contracts are funded in a way where, you know, here's the things we're asking you to accomplish, here's the things we're asking you to focus on, and you should, you know, for those efforts, here's the compensation. And with MLT, it's been a little bit different, and I think some of the comments I heard just a minute ago about, you know, what are the expectations of MLT, they may have been shaped by that and by the funding process that we've utilized.

1:22:06 And I do anticipate that shift, and I was hoping this process would sort of highlight that, but a shift in expectations to more marketing type stuff and less just general tourism things that may exist in our current contract. And what I'm getting at here is when we do the budget, and yes, we budget the town of Mammoth Lakes extremely conservatively, and it does produce a fair amount of

1:22:34 Excess revenue on a typical year. This year is going to be, you know, another one of those years and provides us with funding to do a lot of projects and do a lot of things and meet the needs of the community and where the pain points are for the community. So that's definitely there. But when we do the budget, we've always, you know, MLT has allocated a percentage of the TOT and it goes all to

1:23:00 What we're proposing here is to sort of change that philosophy and say,

1:23:30 Okay, we want to discuss, you know, certainly the areas of achievement, what we want MLT to focus on for the year, and then try to establish a dollar amount for that. And I think, you know, that would be an annual discussion. It is a part of the sort of contract process to be discussed on an annual basis. But it should be a little bit less, I think, than the total that was allocated to tourism from Measure A allocations.

1:23:58 And that would free up those dollars to be utilized for things that the town should be doing in support of tourism. A couple of examples, you know, we've had MLT pay for fish stocking in the past. We've had MLT pay, you know, contribute to the host program and those types of things where those are sort of operational aspects and things that the town itself should be taking on. And so, you know, with this process, not only are we shifting focus to say, MLT, you provide that marketing arm.

1:24:27 And we are going to pay you dollars to perform that. And then on the other side, we'll still maybe have some dollars in the budget to do some of these other things. So what I proposed was a $2 million funding for the fiscal year 22-23. And that is a little bit of a haircut from last year. It was 2.335 last year. I think there was some direction to see a little bit of

1:24:57 of economy put into that number, a little bit of a reduction. That's what I heard as discussions from council. And so that was kind of the recommendation that we went forward. This will not affect the allocation to tourism, housing, transit, all the things that we currently do from our TOT allocations. Those would continue to remain. So the reserves would also continue to remain in those particular areas.

1:25:25 I think I heard earlier Bill mentioned he likes for MLT to be dynamic and be able to pivot and address circumstances that come to light that weren't a part of our budgeted expectations. And with the tourism reserve and all sorts of things, that allows for MLT to come forward and request additional funding. I mean, if there's something that's totally different than we anticipated for the year, they can come to council and say,

1:25:51 We think we need to do this campaign. This wasn't a part of our normal process, but we've got to address this particular emergency issue, and there's the funding for it, and it goes there. So by saying this dollar amount doesn't lock it in, that's all the dollars that would ever be available. Certainly T-Bit is still there and in play, but this reserve would also be brought to bear on additional marketing if necessary. You know, we've proved in the past that even though we have those reserves bucket set up,

1:26:20 We can utilize them for the needs of the community. Just this last August, we allocated 1.9 million from Tourism Reserve in support of our housing program because we had a very large ask of the housing program and we needed to break open all the piggy banks and town council has that direction and they certainly execute on it. So we would continue to do that in the future. I think, you know, supporting the community impacts and the needs.

1:26:43 Through the additional dollars, that's worked well for us and should move forward. So there's not a whole lot more to present on this one tonight. It's just that, you know, I have staff, you know, putting out there a $2 million allocation for that fiscal year. I think it will help MLT to understand where they need to be at this stage of the game. It's like, we're just starting the budgeting process. It's like, okay, that's what we're going to receive for funding from the town to achieve these focus items.

1:27:09 We know what we need to do, and I trust John already can make that number work, but would like to hear from council, I think, on that, and then MLT and Madam Mayor. Okay, thank you. Before we go on, though, I just wanted to make a couple of clarifying points in my own head, because I'm also trying to understand how this impacts everything. That the 2.35 that is currently

1:27:39 being allocated to tourism will not change. What is going to change is that rather than receiving that as an automatic basis to MLT, that that will then go in the pot of tourism, out of which we will take the $2 million to pay Mammoth Lakes Tourism, leaving the remainder of that money, which was, again, we go back to the Measure A allocations and the work that's been done on that over time.

1:28:07 That that would then leave that money for either the town council to determine other needs around tourism, which was, you know, at one point in the last year was primarily housing or other projects that we might want to do, which could include things like the work we were doing in the lake space and in conjunction with the Forest Service, some of the other initiatives that we put forward. So that I wanted to make that clear that that was still not a cut to tourism.

1:28:36 But it's adjusting the payment that goes directly to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And also, you know, reminding, you know, our audience, if you will, that, you know, that is not the total amount of money that Mammoth Lakes Tourism has, that they also are able to gain the the T bid, which then rounds out a budget in a way that still leaves them.

1:28:57 Amount of money to do the job. But this would be the piece of the money we give them, the expectations and the hopes and the jointly agreed upon things that would be accomplished with that money. So I wanted to just kind of hit that quickly. All right, let's go back. Can I make another comment based upon some of that? Just further clarifying. So the allocation to tourism, that 2.35 points you were addressing, it covered

1:29:24 That $300,000 to the Chamber of Commerce, as well as funding to MLT. And whatever was left over was funded to MLT. In this particular case, the $2 million would be to MLT, and then the town would take $300,000 and do that to the Chamber. So those are separate items. And also for the host program. The host program also. Yeah, and so the host program is something, you know, that's where by the budgeting process, then there should be dollars.

1:29:53 Above and beyond, let's say it's 2.3 million that we would be putting into both MLT and the chamber, there would be dollars available above and beyond that that could go for the host program and that would be a part of the budget plan and then the reserve discussions as we talked about that our council direction would come over and above as the year progresses on but actually during the budgeting process we'd be able to take

1:30:16 You know, things like fish stocking that we've asked MLT to shoulder in on before for the host program and probably fund them out of our dollars, the town's portion of that. Right. Okay. Thank you, Rob. Okay. I am going to, once again, call on Councilmember Sauser as our MLT representative to have the floor first here to ask any questions or make any comments. I don't have a lot of questions or comments.

1:30:44 Going to a fixed rate, as long as it's negotiated, you know, on an annual basis with them is fine. The item I was going to look at was 2.3, but if we're going to take the chamber obligation away, it's the same thing, so I wouldn't push on that so hard. The problem I have with moving some of these things out of MLT's bailiwick in terms of paying for it, if we have a bad TOT year,

1:31:10 And don't think we won't again. I know we're riding a high right now, but highs don't ever last in Mammoth. And we take on the fish stocking and we take on the host program and everything else that's not coming out of their budget. Then when we have that bad TOT year, we're going to pull those back and those programs are then going to suffer. It could happen either way, but TOT is a little more, tourism is a little more flexible in that they haven't taken that money and used it for other, you know, road plowing.

1:31:40 Or whatever you will. But the concept of moving it forward, I have no real issue with. If we're taking the 3.3 out of their budget from last year and moving it to our budget with a commitment from council that the things it funded would continue, then I could probably support this. Okay. So I'm hearing you say that we continue to be very mindful of our budget as we've...

1:32:09 We have been and that we continue to be watchful, which then we go to Rob Patterson. Does that sound reasonable, Rob? Well, and that we make some of the things that we are going to take out of there. Right. Fish stocking is hugely important. I mean, my personal opinion is we need to increase that program, not decrease it. We're losing fishermen that have been coming here generationally because they come to Mammoth and don't catch fish because of the

1:32:38 The way Fish and Game or Fish and Wildlife now is handling the fish program that they have, the hatcheries. So as long as we are going to make those things prioritized so they will receive funding, then I have no real issue. But we also then have to work very closely with MLT, closer than we have, so that we know what the effect of the stocking program is and whether it should go up or down.

1:33:07 They've got that finger on that pulse. I don't want us to have to put our finger on it as well. Okay. All right. Thank you, Bill, for your comments. Okay, Sarah, I'm going to go to you here. Thanks, Linda. Again, I will just reiterate what I said last week, which is I believe that MLT should be able to live off of TBID revenues. However, I do think that this is acceptable and that's all I have. Okay. Thank you. John? I'm going to...

1:33:39 Introduce a term that I believe is family-friendly. The term is bass-ackwards. And I just want to go back to following up what we were talking about before, talking about assigning roles and responsibilities. Bill, I hear what you're saying, but I think just to build on the very productive conversation we've been having so far, the town...

1:34:00 with MLT needs to define those roles and responsibilities. And whatever programs a town is going to take on should be based on what we've been talking about. And the four, and again, Rob, that's what I'm really looking forward to seeing, those overarching goals and the focus item, just written it out, we get, he gives us a North Star to work from. And we can really, you know, define from that, start getting into the program levels and who's the roles and responsibilities level. Let's look at that

1:34:30 From that perspective, right? So it's clear to everybody, if fish stocking, is that something the town's going to take on? Great. We all know that's on the town side of the leisure. And let's not sort of perpetuate this ambiguity of, well, MLT could come back and maybe they could do this, maybe they could do that. Let's figure this stuff out. Let's figure out who's going to be doing what. And then we can budget and do the things we need to do from there. Let's take advantage of this moment, I guess is what I'm saying. Let's just.

1:34:57 Make it clear who's going to be doing what, and then budget accordingly and put the priorities first, as Mr. Cohen was saying earlier. Okay, thank you, John. It's not a dirty word. It's a family-friendly. Okay, thank you for that. And Kirk. Thank you, Madam Mayor. It's kind of a concern. I just don't want us to drop any of our programs. I mean, defining...

1:35:24 The roles and everything, but, you know, I just don't, I do have a concern that some of the things that Mammoth Lake Tourism had done in the past is going to be shifted out of their purview and, you know, such as if, you know, fish stocking or whatever it happens to be, and I just don't want to see any of those things somehow missed, you know, or omitted in the tire, in the

1:35:52 In the budget process. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Kirk. All right. Jeremy, I'd like to have the chance for the board members of MLT to weigh in on this if they'd like. Any comments, that'd be great. Any questions they might have, this would be the time for that. So I'll leave that to your capable hands. Absolutely. You know, as I did before, I'd like to start with some comments from our Executive Director, John Urdi.

1:36:20 John, do you mind kind of commenting on, you know, the $2 million proposed budget? You know, are you comfortable working with that? And then also just speak a little bit to, you know, if funding for programs like the Fish Stocking Chamber Host Program, you know, were kind of moved over to Town of Mammoth Lakes General Fund, you know, how do you see that working? Is that problematic at all? Can you talk to that a little bit? And then we'll get...

1:36:49 Yeah, to start off, I think that Councilmember Wentworth has a really good point. Without the definition of the rules and responsibilities, it's hard to say whether $2 million is the right number. Mayor Salcido has always asked the question of how much is enough. And I think one of the things that we've been talking about, at least in the last year, is something like scheduled charter service and the goal of getting to 10,000 employments. And if we want to get to 10,000 employments in a year, it's going to be a pretty big investment. And is $2 million enough? Maybe.

1:37:20 It may not be. And I think that when we talk about the 2.35 that we had last year and we talk about the chamber, the commitment, the 2.35 points on 14.5 million last year was actually around 2.65 million minus the 300,000 went to the chamber. So looking at next year, if the town budgets 16 million, the 2.35 points is about 2.9 million.

1:37:45 So if we cap out at $2 million, there's $900,000 available for the town to fund the chamber, fund fish stocking, fund host program, fund whatever else there. I think the big question mark to me is we did have the town as a partner when it came to the scheduled charter service for this winter and this coming summer. And that was a commitment so that we could start the road to the $10,000 employments.

1:38:11 I think part of the discussion without coming up with the arbitrary number of $2 million or $2.3 million or $1.75 million is what are the roles and responsibilities and what's it going to take to get there? And what, you know, to go back to the conversation about the T-bid, Prop 26 is pretty specific that we have to benefit the people that pay into the T-bid with the use of those dollars. And we've always promoted Bodie and Mono Lake.

1:38:36 Convict and all those other places with the idea that the bed base and the restaurant base and everything else is still Mammoth Lake. So, you know, there are certain things, though, that we have been very cautious about using TBID dollars for that may be misconstrued as misuse of funds because they're maybe not.

1:38:54 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

1:39:18 That may not pass the Prop 26 smell test. So I think that roles and responsibilities and kind of what's expected from Mammoth Lakes Tourism is a big one because, you know, we're signed on for summer air service this year with advanced airlines flying mid-June to mid-September. I think we have a decent cap number with them as far as the maximum that we could pay.

1:39:38 I think we'll have a little bit of funding left over from the winter that was committed by the town, and I think that the rest of it is fairly doable. Are we going to hit 10,000 employments this year? No, we're probably going to hit 4,000 employments this year. To get to 10,000, we double all these numbers. Now, all of a sudden, you're talking about an $800,000 cap and beyond. We want nothing more than to see Mammoth Yosemite Airport as productive and vibrant as Bishop Airport.

1:40:04 But it takes money to do those things. So I do think that, thank you, John, for mentioning that, but that is a very clear definition to say when we talk about how much is enough, it depends on what you want us to do. All right, sounds good. Thank you, Mr. Erty. I'll go through the board in the same order we did last time. Mr. Foster, Vice Chair, would you like to make any comments on the proposed funding for Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the 22-23 year?

1:40:36 Just a quick comment. I am not opposed to the idea of a flat rate or a cap or something for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. That's not for me at all. But just like John Wentworth pointed out and John already following up there, deciding on what that number is, I think we need to decide who's doing what before we can really figure out where we land on that number. All right. Sounds good. Thank you, Mr. Foster. Mr. Morris, any comments?

1:41:07 Sure. Just a couple real quick. Going back just to Ron Cohen's comments, you know, it's really highest and best use of staff and organization. That's really what it is. You know, the town has equipment. The town has obviously more manpower in general than MLT does. So it's just deciding on, you know, who's best at what. That's really important.

1:41:28 And as far as funding goes, yeah, I mean, I'll be honest, I'm never a fan of cutting any amount of NLTs funding. Economics is pretty simple. It's a law of diminishing returns. If you're spending money and it's making more money, you keep spending the money to keep making more money. I realize that town has lots of things that they have to do. I just want to be a little bit careful if the revenue stream is still strong and is still doing really well and is bringing in.

1:41:55 Thank you, Mr. Morris. Mr. Clark.

1:42:26 Your comments. Thanks, Jeremy. Thanks, everyone. I'm going to reiterate the roles and responsibility. I mean, that's clear where, you know, the best way to determine the funding is what is the organization doing and what are their responsibilities. So I think everybody's kind of saying the same thing along those lines.

1:42:50 I will also reiterate what Mr. Morris just said. Marketing dollars does produce revenue for the town. So keep that in mind. And then when looking at a fixed dollar amount, that certainly makes sense. And if that aligns to the roles and responsibilities, I think that makes complete sense. The reserves, those, because of the budgeting strategy throughout the town, those reserves do get

1:43:19 A lot of money deposited into them, and they've been able to do a lot for us, not just the most recently the housing, but we've also done the signage throughout the town, and we've done other programs like that. So when there is tourism type areas that need to be funded, those reserves are going to have some funding in them, and we could utilize them with the proposed way that Rob has stated. Have a fixed amount, but still have a percentage.

1:43:47 Applied to tourism so that you get that and you can apply that to where the needs are that we're all talking about identifying. But when it comes down to, you know, the roles and responsibility again, I mean, fish stocking or the host programs, those are all needed, but I don't think that's within the Mammoth Lakes tourism realm. That is more of a town realm in this case.

1:44:16 That side of the ledger. That way we won't be disputing what's going on. And I think we need to limit areas of dispute and debate. So for me, I think it's simpler to have clear rules and responsibilities. Thanks. All right. Thanks so much, Mr. Clark. Deb Radcliffe, your comments. I'm just supporting my team members here. I'm all good. Thank you.

1:44:45 All right. Wonderful. Mr. Sauser, any other comments from what you've heard? No, I'm good. Thanks. All right. Wonderful. You know, I am not opposed to a $2 million kind of set budget for Mammoth Lakes tourism. You know, last year, we were kind of operating, you know, during our budget process, which starts now, January, February.

1:45:21 So as long as we are aware of what our budget is so that we can build the budget around that,

1:45:51 You know, I'm comfortable with that moving forward. You know, would want to have a little bit more discussion with my executive director, Mr. Erty, about, you know, is 10,000 employments, you know, something, you know, Rob Patterson, Madam Mayor, is that something, you know, I haven't heard anybody else bring that up, but, you know, John is clearly

1:46:20 You know, has heard that in some conversations with town counselors or town staff, that that is a, you know, a desire that we want to hit that. So, you know, again, I'm comfortable with the two million moving forward, but to reiterate what our board is saying and what my executive director is saying, we need to be very clear what falls in what bucket.

1:46:47 You know, and what are we responsible for? And we will build the budget according to that and move forward with those goals and objectives. That's all for me, Madam Mayor. Back to you. Okay, thank you very much for doing that. I was just thinking that the people that we have working together, like Rob has been delegated to be the representative between council and MLT.

1:47:16 And obviously, John Urdi, you're the person for MLT. I believe that for all of this, both making sure that the priorities are really clear, who's doing what is crystal clear, that Rob and Mr. Urdi and Mr. Patterson can be working on this and be reporting back to us also. I don't think all of us need to be involved all the time with that, but that's why we have.

1:47:41 Those two that are sort of working on that. So I might direct a question to Rob Patterson and to John Urdi if that seems a way forward that will meet these requests that we're being asked to really identify. Yeah, I think it absolutely does. And I think the only other point that I wanted to make when we talk about roles and responsibilities and we talk about...

1:48:06 objectives is, you know, Linda, you and I have had this conversation about what the objectives are. I mean, this year we will, if we hit budget for the remainder of the TOT year, the last six months of the year, we'll hit $20 million. We will far exceed that and we will be probably $25 million north. So I guess the part of the conversation is when it comes down to what the expectations are on MLT.

1:48:32 If next year's budget goes from $14.5 million to $16 million, is that our objective is $16 million? Or is it to continue to try and crest that $20 million to give you that $5, $6, $7, $8, $9, $10 million over budget to be able to put towards housing or restrooms or trash or parking or whatever other program? So I think that's another piece where we're making sure that we know what the objective is. Is it to hit that budget?

1:48:58 Is it to continue to bring in the additional money over that budget? That helps us to figure out how we're going to continue to do things because if we are targeting a $16 million TOT budget, then yeah, maybe we don't need as much funding to get to that. If we're happy with that $4, $5, $6, $10 million overage every year that we can utilize other places, then that needs to be understood. But I do think that Rob definitely...

1:49:24 Get together and work on that priorities. In fact, we've had a number of conversations that really focus on that to begin with. So I don't think it will be a stretch. Okay, good. Rob, comments on that? Yeah, thank you for that. And no, I agree. There's some additional work we can do, especially the moving parts that I've interjected to this with assignments that have previously been MLTs and something that the town staff is coming forward on. Certainly our...

1:49:49 The sort of roles and responsibilities do come out a little bit in the budget process, and that will be a part of the discussion as we talk through that, especially if we have some of the excess dollars we've talked about. I mean, I don't disagree with anything I've heard as far as the expectations of this year. It's going to be a high number. I would say that under no expectation that we target to strictly what we budget. We do that for a particular reason, and it's constraining the size of our organization.

1:50:19 It is basically getting it to what it needs to do to support the core services at that appropriate level. And I don't want to budget $20 million, grow to that size of an organization, maybe providing slightly more core services for the community, but not noticeably for that kind of money. And at the end of the day, on a downturn, have to lay off staff and others to get there. I think we...

1:50:47 We as leaders of the town manage to that number. We manage our workforce to deliver on that. And that's why we do that. But certainly there is work to be done in defining these roles. And folks want to hear more of that. And John and I work well together on that process and happy to do so. But no, we want to get in. As far as the 10,000 employments, I mean, I want...

1:51:09 That's very important to me. Obviously, I am the executive director for the airport. I want to see that come back to us. 10,000 employments means a million dollars a year in capital funding for projects. If we don't hit that number, it drops to 150,000 a year. So you can see the impact it would have on our programs and our capital and availability. But I do believe also that, you know, and so right now, to give you an example, the employments are...

1:51:37 Somewhere we have maybe 4,000 employments for the year planned or 4,000 opportunities. And so we would have to grow that significantly in order to even get near 10,000. So there's a lot of work and it's a multi-year work to get there. I think we work on that and we have those reserve dollars available for incremental push. I mean, if it's getting additional markets and other things like that.

1:52:02 More work to be done. I'm happy to do it. I think it's successful for our organizations collectively in the community. Okay. And then, Rob, you can report back to council. And, you know, John, you're welcome to come in and chat, too, as time goes on. Okay. I noticed that Mr. Wentworth has his hand up. Yeah, I think I just want to let's get back to ground a little bit here. And I appreciate the discussions about money, but that's an old saw that

1:52:30 You know, with the TOT numbers and MOT in the town. Okay, let's get back to sort of basics here. Rob and John, when you're having that conversation, let's really focus on what is the best organization to perform the task. And let's make sure we're informed by who has what authorities. So for example, the town has authoritative relationships with the forest, with all the federal agencies. So all the infrastructure, all those things that are happening as part of making sure that we're doing our

1:53:00 The town is doing its side of the ledger with infrastructure and programming, those kinds of things. The town is going to be hiring and staffing up an office of outdoor recreation. Let's really focus on, let's not worry about the money yet. Let's worry about which is the best organization to perform the tasks that's going to get us.

1:53:22 to long-term sustainability for what we're doing. So I just want to throw that out there and make sure that let's get that done first, and then the money, that will help figure out where the money's going to have to fall because if this ends up on the town side, then MOT doesn't have to do it. If there's something MOT's got to do, okay, that's on MOT's side. A final point has to do with wildfire and has to do with a project like the Mammoth Donut Project.

1:53:48 50,000 acre fuels reduction project that's going to be a significant area of concern for the community. Who's going to do the messaging and the outreach to talk to the community about what it means to start treating 50,000 acres of forest around this community that could fundamentally change the character of this place? I just throw that out as an example.

1:54:10 Rob, is that on the town side? Is that on the MOT side? Just things like that to think about. But let's bring it back to the authorities and what's the best organization to do the task? Thank you, Madam Mayor. Okay. So what I'm hearing, at least from council, is a general consensus that we can move forward with an agreement on the $2 million going into the contract yearly update through finance and deliverables.

1:54:39 So if that is the case, is that binding enough for everyone to feel comfortable with going forward? Rob, I would look to you. Is that get you what you need to do to move forward with this contract? Are you ready to sign in April or May? Yes. Yes, it does. I'm good with that. Okay. Okay. Very good. I thought there was...

1:55:06 An idea of the roles and responsibilities before the dollars. I think we're putting the cart before the horse here. And I know that the council had that prior to some of the other conversation that Mr. Wentworth started, but I think that that is definitely cart before the horse if you're signing off on 2 million and it ends up being 2.5 being the necessary number. I would say that, Rob, go ahead. I just, you know, the roles and responsibilities, MLT does the marketing.

1:55:35 I think there's fine tuning that we need to do to that. I was hoping that those focus points were defining some of the expectations and that the dollar amount would be suitable for that level of expectation. There's work to be done on this 100%. I don't want to prolong this where we're going back and maybe in late June having a discussion about what dollar amounts are out there. I think we want to come to what it is and execute. And if council is not comfortable doing that,

1:56:05 And then, you know, we'll push it down the road and try to work on how we define who's going to do what. But it's not meaningfully different. I mean, we know what the town does. We know what MLT does. These are fine-tuned discussions that we will have that maybe bring clarity for the people that are making the decisions today, but it's not going to be noticeably different if those comments make sense. Because I think that our goal for tonight as town council was to set an amount.

1:56:35 Madam Mayor, are you talking about a consensus?

1:57:03 On a budget number? We are talking about, in general, the general direction I'm hearing is that we will go with a $2 million for MLT funding for next year to plan to that. Yeah, I'm okay with that. Again, John and Rob go off and have their discussion. $2 million to target. Well, again, who is doing what?

1:57:32 Right? And the town, the council needs to understand that there may be a bunch of things that are going to come back into our budget that may be coming back on our side of the ledger. And so we'll have to look at that when we get to that. But that's, if you want to start with $2 million, set that as a starting place to start and go forward, understanding that it's not set yet. It's just we're trying to get the budget to that number. It appears to me that what the council is suggesting is that if MLT believes that the scope of work needs to be amended,

1:58:02 To reflect a $2 million contribution from the town, then MLT should explain what they think they can or cannot do and should propose an amended scope of work. So it's the number that is relatively fixed. It's the scope that maybe bears discussion. But that seems to be the starting point for further discussions between John and Rob. Yes, thank you, Andy. That's good clarification. I appreciate that. Okay.

1:58:27 I'm going to take that as a point to move forward unless anybody thinks we should do something further on this. Seeing none. All right, we're going to move on. Thank you, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Mayor Salcido, we have another comment from the public. Okay, thank you, Jamie, for bringing that up. Ron Cohen, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hey, sorry to drag things on. I'll be quick. I just wanted to weigh in again and just say priorities first.

1:59:00 Roles and responsibilities next. And then really thinking about that point about Measure A. The unrestricted aspect of Measure A is critical for MLT's plan. That scope of work amendment should be able to be prioritized and detailed to the point where it's clear what...

1:59:27 What's going to be, what's needed to be unrestricted? That's one piece. The other piece is what else does the town want to fund through Measure A? And so I totally get structural containment of the, trying to keep the organization from growing by keeping the budget amount down. But as a retired bad lawyer,

1:59:56 I still remember one maxim, which is the expression of one is the exclusion of the other. And so when we talk about things like, hey, we set the budget down so that there was 1.5 million extra of allocation under the political commitment for marketing. And instead, we took it for housing. At that point, we took $2 million.

2:00:25 We're roughly about for marketing and we took 1.5 and put it for housing. The political commitment is for marketing, tourism, housing and transit. So when we take money from marketing and we put it into housing, our very own political commitment says that we're breaking our political commitment. And I don't necessarily have a problem with that, but I think we need to think about.

2:00:54 And so to me, pegging $2 million is a nice round number. And I know.

2:01:24 That MLT can come in and show us how they'll get great value out of spending $2 million. If we tell them it's 2.5, they'll show us great value in 2.5. If we tell them less, they'll show us great value in less. We need to know how much unrestricted measure A is needed and for what. And if it's more than 2 million, so be it. If it's less, so be it. What are we doing with TBID? And what are we doing with town?

2:01:52 And then what are those other priorities? And, you know, maybe we start to rethink as we go forward. Look, if we're going to 25 million in TOT, 30 million in TOT down the road as we continue to grow, trying to hold to these points that were derived before the TBIT existed long ago.

2:02:16 We just stretch that fiction more and more. And it's something we're trying to resolve for in how we're talking about stuff instead of solving for what are the town's priorities. So appreciate the time to comment again. Thank you. Thank you, Ryan. Okay, if there's nothing else on this topic, I think we're going to say again thank you to Mammoth X Tourism and move on to the next agenda item. So we are two hours in. Why don't we take a 10-minute break?

2:02:45 See you back here at 610. Thank you, everybody. Thanks again. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Thank you all. Thanks for coming. Okay. Let's see. One, two, three. Okay. I think we have Town Council back. Yes, we have Town Council back. So let's go back at it here. The next policy matter is...

2:13:13 4.2, which is Resolution Approving an Application for the Fiscal Year 21 ARPA Travel, Tourism and Outdoor Recreation Funding Opportunity. So is that going to be? Probably me. Oh, there you are, Sandra. I'm just looking for you. Hi there. Hi. Thank you so much, Mayor Salcio, Council members. Yes, this item is a request for the Town Council to approve a resolution authorizing the staff to apply for EDA grant funding.

2:13:43 The grant funding would be to provide additional parking in the North Village area. This is a part of a $240 million competitive grant program established by the Economic Development Administration, really to help communities who were hit by the tourist communities that were hit by COVID. And it's to help support the recovery of the industry, economic resilience of the community for the future.

2:14:12 So the EDA allows for a broad range of projects to be funded through this source. And they do have a technical assistance program where members of the EDA will talk to staff about different projects that we're looking at. And so staff took advantage of this technical assistance program and met a number of times with the EDA, talked through a variety of different projects that were identified in our destination resort community economic development strategy.

2:14:40 And with the help of the EDA Technical Assistance Rep focused in on providing additional parking in the North Village. Our rep advised us that that seemed like the project that was the most competitive for funding through this program. So that's why that item is included in your resolution as a recommendation.

2:15:01 And so we will put together the grant application. We've already been working on it and we'll get that submitted by the first rolling deadline, which is January 31st. So with that, staff would recommend that the town council direct us to apply for grant funding for additional parking in the North Village. And just as a note, the EDA grant does require up to a 20% match.

2:15:24 For funding, and we have prepared a budget for this project. It's around $950,000, so our match would be up to $200,000 for the project. So once we, you know, get the grant, we can talk about where that funding would come from, but this would just allow us to apply for the grant, and then the counselor can decide whether or not to accept the grant once we know whether or not we've been awarded it. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Yeah, I just had a couple quick ones, and then we can go on.

2:15:53 Where is it at? The parking? Yes. It's right below the current town parking lot that's below the Westin, so it would be basically another kind of piece of that parking lot at the Westin. And how many spots? The town's parking lot below the Westin. And how many spots? I think it's like 22 spots. Okay. Okay, thank you. All right. On that, questions from council?

2:16:21 Raise your hand if you have questions or comments on this. John? Thank you, Madam Mayor. So big props to Sandra and to Dan and whoever else was involved in this effort. We've had significant challenges with the EDA and a regional representative being able to get anything, any type of project that would fit the criteria that our particular regional contact was providing. So,

2:16:53 Well done. Congratulations. Let's hope we can make this happen. I'm supportive. I don't have any specific questions. And I'm sure we'll be able to find the match should the EDA come up with something. But great work to Sandra and Dan for figuring out a way to get some money out of that. Yeah. Very formidable federal agency. Thank you. Absolutely. Kirk? No questions, Madam Mayor. Okay, Sarah? No questions. That's exciting. And Bill?

2:17:25 I'm good. Okay. Well, on that note, I believe we are to do a, let me check this here. I think it's just a resolution here. So can we have a motion to act on this resolution? Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the resolution as presented.

2:17:50 Authorizing the joint application, authorizing the town manager to sign the local match commitment letter, committing up to $1 million in funding towards the project. Nope, wait. Staff recommends that the town council adopt a resolution authorizing town staff to submit an application for the fiscal year 21 ARPA travel, tourism, and outdoor recreation funding opportunity. Thank you. Sorry, apologies. Okay, wait a second.

2:18:21 Second. And is there any comment, public comment on this, Jamie? No, there is not. Okay, thank you. All right, call for the vote, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes, thank you. Motion passes 5-0.

2:18:44 All right. Then the next item is 4.3. Discuss a potential joint project home key grant application with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And Nolan, I think you're here. There you are. I know. Yes, I am. Great. Thank you. So I'm going to introduce this item and then hand it over to Patricia Robertson to give a short presentation and really talk through the details on the project.

2:19:11 One thing to point out or to ask the council as out of courtesy to the property owner, we're not going to disclose the current name or address when we're talking about it due to just ongoing negotiations with Mammoth Lakes Housing on that. The proposed application is a joint application to convert an existing use into 15...

2:19:40 We're between 15 to 17 studio, one-bedroom apartment units, proposed grant. It's a state program that's aimed at preventing and responding to homelessness. So with that, I will pass it on to Patricia to really talk through the details. All right. Good evening, Patricia. Hi. Good evening, Madam Mayor and fellow council members.

2:20:08 I'm Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I'm here this evening to talk about an imminent and exciting opportunity to expand housing options for our workforce. Not so long ago, Mammoth Lakes Housing was presented with an opportunity to acquire an existing hotel property in the town, which lined up with this grant opportunity, which

2:20:38 is specifically for acquiring existing uses. And so sort of all of the stars have aligned and we're here this evening to ask for the town's partnership in this project. As Nolan mentioned, out of respect for the current business, the owners ask that we don't speak of the business name at this time. I'm going to share my screen and talk through a little bit more in detail about the scope of this project.

2:21:23 So this evening we're discussing a potential Project Home Key state grant application, which is a joint application between Mammoth Lakes Housing, a nonprofit housing development organization, and the town of Mammoth Lakes. Mono County has approved a funding allocation to this project pending the town's participation, but they will not be a partner to the actual grant application.

2:21:57 As Nolan mentioned, the state has allocated funding for this program, which was developed during the COVID-19 public health crisis response in order to rapidly increase housing supply in the state through acquisition of existing structures and converting them into housing. The current opportunity that was presented to Mammoth Lakes Housing is

2:22:29 A small hotel in the town of Mammoth Lakes. The total project cost is approximately $6 million. That includes the acquisition of the site, the rehabilitation, all the pre-development costs, permit fees, etc. I've walked the site a couple of different times with an architect and a physical inspector, and we think that we can convert the

2:22:59 The current rooms that are currently available into 15 studio apartments and one manager's unit. These will be affordable to households earning below 80% of the area median income. And I provided that here for you to see what that looks like for one person and a two-person household. I think one thing that is extremely exciting about this opportunity is that

2:23:27 Before Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town reached out to the state to talk about this project, the standard for this program was that 100% of the units in projects needed to be below 30% of the area median income. And through advocacy efforts of both Mammoth Lakes Housing and town staff, we were able to

2:23:54 To demonstrate that we have a large population of working homeless in our community, living in their cars or in overcrowded homes that have one or two jobs per person and so have income above 30% AMI. And so the state has agreed to accept our application and we could potentially be the first Project Home Key grant recipient in the state serving above 30% of the area median income.

2:24:26 Here's just a short punch list of what the rehabilitation for the site would look like. We are proposing to do a fire suppression retrofit. The property doesn't have fire sprinklers at the moment, and so that would be an important improvement for the site and obviously an amenity that we would want our residents to have. We will provide accessibility.

2:24:54 And then I think we're looking to provide a community.

2:25:23 Room that would provide some personal storage lockers for potentially ski equipment or camping equipment. And that space would also have a common area laundry room and then potentially some additional common space for service providers to meet with their clients. Another exciting aspect of this opportunity is that the state is really committed to turning funds around very quickly.

2:25:57 Which we all know isn't normally the case. Project Home Key is committed to making award announcements within 45 days of the application and then requiring that the project be complete within 12 months. And so with this opportunity, we could potentially have 15 additional housing units for our workforce by next fall.

2:26:27 Or this fall, the fall that's coming up. I will note, and I can mention this again in a further slide, that the grant deadline is actually May 2nd. However, the state released a priority deadline of January 31st. And so if you apply by January 31st, which is Monday, you can receive a one-for-one match for any local funding commitment.

2:26:57 So the funding commitment from Mono County and the potential funding commitment from the Town of Mammoth Lakes equals an additional $1 for every dollar from the state for this project. This is a breakdown of the budget. Mammoth Lakes Housing has entered into a letter of intent with the owner for the purchase of the site. And so we're working currently

2:27:30 At the moment on a purchase agreement, a legally binding purchase agreement that would allow us to perform some due diligence. That would also allow a financing contingency, obviously, until we know if we're awarded the grant funds. And so the rehab work, we're looking at approximately $1.6 million. We did get some cost estimates from a construction management company.

2:27:59 And as I mentioned, I walked the site with the architect. And so the total development cost is approximately 6 million. Here is the funding breakdown for this project. So starting at the bottom of the bar graph, you'll see the project home key funds. The base award amount is per unit. And so our project qualifies for 2.7 million. The county has potentially committed to 550,000.

2:28:33 Pending the town's commitment. The town, we're asking the town for at a minimum $750,000 towards this project. I would ask for a commitment not to exceed $1 million. But that can equal a one-for-one-dollar match from the state of an additional $1.3 million. There are some small bonus points for applying early.

2:29:00 And then I'm actively pursuing other funding opportunities through social services, our regional continuum of care, which is the entity that receives homelessness funding through IMACA. And so those are ongoing conversations that could potentially support this project. They are not committed at this time, and they likely would not be committed by the application due date, which is Monday.

2:29:29 But those conversations are ongoing. And so the budget that I showed you, we rounded all those numbers up to be round numbers. And so there isn't actually a gap per se, but depending on if we're able to secure additional funding sources, then other commitments like the town or the county then could potentially be reduced.

2:29:53 You'll see the leverage of local dollars is about one local dollar for every $3 from the state that we're able to secure. I just wanted to demonstrate the per unit investment. On the low side, if the town commits $750,000, that's $50,000 per unit. Up to a million is $66,000 per unit. The county is potentially committing $36,000 per unit.

2:30:25 And then the total community investment on the high end is about $100,000 per unit. The state investment for this project is approximately $4 million or $250,000 per unit. I like showing, you know, images of our community and those folks that are struggling with housing to demonstrate that these are the folks that could potentially live in this project. It will be approximately 15 studio units and could accommodate.

2:30:58 I'm singles, couples, single parents, our workforce up to 80% of the area median income. And so this is a great opportunity that's just coming together very quickly. That's the end of my presentation, but I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have. Okay. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry, Nolan, back to you. No, so that, like I said, Patricia, I really, I think, summarized all the details and

2:31:32 We are available for any questions that the council or public has. Okay, very good. All right, let's start with some questions here. Kirk, how about you? Let's talk about, do you have any questions for Patricia or on the project? I have no questions for Patricia. I think it's a real opportunity for the town. Okay, thank you. Sarah? Yeah, no questions. I think this is amazing. Ready to go.

2:32:03 Okay, Bill? Yeah, I have a few, if I could. Please. If we get the grant and we build it, who is going to manage it? Who's the initial manager through occupancy and then who's the long-term manager? So who do the rent dollars go to? Mammoth Lakes Housing will be the owner of the project as the nonprofit developer and we will receive the rents and pay the bills of the project.

2:32:36 In an initial estimate of the operating budget, I think the project is expected to net maybe $5,000 annually after expenses because the rents are restricted to low income. It's not an income generating profitable business necessarily, and it's not that many units, so that's also part of it.

2:33:01 And then we will contract with Buckingham Property Management Company, who is our local property management company, who is experienced in operating affordable housing projects in our region. And there will be one unit on-site available for an on-site manager employed by Buckingham Property Management Company. Thanks for that. Upkeep and maintenance, with the low rents like this and with what the management company is going to want out of it, can we be assured?

2:33:32 That the rents will be enough for the upkeep and maintenance or will this be an ongoing expense for Mammoth Lakes housing or potentially through funding of that the town of Mammoth Lakes? That's a really great question. Part of the operating budget does include a line item for reserve set aside and at this moment I'm setting aside I think 17% of gross rents annually towards the maintenance long-term maintenance reserve.

2:34:00 And I think that equates to approximately $15,000 annually. Is it similar to what Emaca does at Glass Mountain? Because I think they're a little short on their maintenance dollars. I don't know exactly how much they set aside for reserve. I know they do have some reserves. You know, I know that the project has had some problems in the past.

2:34:28 But I'm not exactly sure of the budgeting or how they do their asset management for that project. Okay, thank you. Can this be restricted or will the loan, will the grant allow us to do that to people who actually work in the area? Or is it because it's for homeless issues, is this just something that goes to the homeless population whether they are part of our workforce or not? Because our real need is.

2:34:59 For those working homeless, if you will. So can that restriction be put on these? So we can't add a requirement that they be employed in the area. We can't, due to fair housing laws, we can't require that they be employed because they might receive their income from Social Security benefits or other sources.

2:35:27 So we can't require that they have a job, per se. They have to be able to pay the rent. But the main requirement of this project will be that they are experiencing homelessness, which, you know, reading social media over the last four months, I don't think we'll have a problem filling the units with those who are unable to find insecure housing. And then the income limit, the maximum income limit of 80% of the area median. Thank you.

2:35:58 Have we had an appraisal done on the property? I realize that they don't want the property name known or anything, but have we had done at least a sidewalk appraisal done to know that this is a correct price for the property? Yes, so part of the application is a requirement that we submit an appraisal, and that should be coming to me in the next day or so. Okay, and one last thing, not meaning to be completely negative, but sometimes it works out that way. The Sierra Manor Project looked like it was...

2:36:28 A really great deal in the beginning, and it's costing certainly more than Mammoth Lakes Housing or I ever expected it to cost for the amount of units there, and hopefully we will get that thing in. Do we see any of those same issues with this, or is this going to be smooth sailing and we're actually going to get occupancy without going back to the well over and over again? Well, I think, you know, with the funding sources that I identified in the budget slide,

2:36:57 I think that we'll be ready to go. You know, the state wants these projects done within 12 months. I think, you know, we're aiming for a little bit less than that. I don't think, you know, because it's a state, a priority of the state and it's a priority of Mammoth Lake's housing and it's a priority of the town, I think that we'll be able to get it done in that timeline. You know, I was a little surprised when the cost estimate came back. It was higher than I had anticipated for this project as well.

2:37:26 But it seems like the state's willing to pitch in enough money to make it feasible. And so it seems like it's going to work out. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. John?

2:37:41 Madam Mayor, I'm going to defer to Sarah. It sounds like you might have a follow-up comment. Oh, thank you so much. I apologize. It blends into the background. No worries. I got excited. And Bill reminded me that I did have two questions. The first is, Patricia, have you identified a contractor to do the remodel?

2:38:04 We will have a bid process, and so there'll be a process for contractors to apply if they're interested in working on this project. Okay, great. And my second question is, do you know how many parking spaces are going to be available per unit? Oh, I believe that there's approximately 22 parking spaces on the site right now. I think we would aim for, you know, we'll have to widen some of those to be ADA compliant.

2:38:34 So I would aim for one parking space per studio apartment and then perhaps two for the on-site manager. Thank you so much. Okay, back to you, John. Great, thank you. Good questions. Big, multiple shout-outs to Patricia and you and Mono County. I know Supervisor Kreitz is listening in this evening for everybody who works so hard to pull this together. This is great. I have...

2:39:04 I have questions and concerns along Bill's lines and along Sarah's lines. And I guess my question is, at what point, if the town makes the commitment, we go ahead and we get the grant, at what point do we actually start obligating funds to actually start doing things? Because at that point, before we do that, I would really like to know, contractor, contingency, who's doing this, who's doing what?

2:39:33 Have we allowed for the cost of construction in Mammoth Lakes? Is there asbestos in the building? All those kinds of crazy things. I'm more than happy to go forward now with the understanding in my discussion with the town manager. We will get a second bite at this to see the details of who's going to do the work and all that kind of stuff. Am I correct in that assumption? Certainly. I don't think it's an issue to bring it back. If we get the award, the town will probably have to accept the award. We'll probably have more information by then.

2:40:04 You know, we'll have a firmer timeline. We might have a firmer scope of work, maybe slightly reduced, maybe slightly expanded. But yeah, we can certainly come back and give council as much information as we have. And at this point, it looks like we're trying to commit all the local funding towards the rehabilitation for the project. So that's the source of the funds that we're using for that piece of the project.

2:40:29 Okay, so, but you mentioned that the town would have to accept the grants. I'm assuming, Dan, like in and around that decision point, we would want to get an update at that point. So, okay, I'm good. Thank you very much. Okay, thank you, everyone. And thank you, Patricia. I have a couple of questions. I think you answered most of it. On the timeline, you know, it says fall of 22, but yet the construction is 12 months. And so are you, does that feel pretty sure fall of 22 that?

2:40:57 You know, at least some would be occupiable by then? I think so. You know, the requirement is that we finish within 12 months of award. If we are awarded the funds in March, that gives us until March 2023. But I feel like it's a good goal to shoot for the fall when everyone's looking for housing. And I see why that might be unreasonable at this point. Okay. Will there be pets allowed?

2:41:28 You know, I don't have any community rules for the project at this point. We're not allowed to deny support animals. So certainly that those would be allowed. Okay. And now you said that you've gone out to the county departments, social services, behavioral health, probably to see if they have funds available.

2:41:51 Which one of those are you think able to come forward? I didn't know if there's any money left in the money from behavioral health around their programs, but what does it look like from them? So I've been working most actively with the social services department. They seem to have an ability to draw funds that are specific to housing and homelessness, funds that haven't been accessed before.

2:42:20 And so I'm working really closely with Kathy Peterson to identify those funds and figure out if permanent housing is an eligible use. And so behavioral health hasn't been as forthcoming in those conversations. I can certainly try again. And our other sources, IMACA, who administers the continuum of care, and they have a lot of different pots of funding. And we're trying to identify which of those can be used for permanent housing.

2:42:50 Okay. And then I don't know if we have still any access to any foundations down in the Inyo area. There was a couple at one point and if there was any gap filling available from them just in case. No, I'm not aware of anything, but that's a good point. I can look into that. Okay. That sounds good. No, this is great. I mean, this is really exciting. That's like 15 units, bang, you know, done. And that's huge.

2:43:19 So, you know, great, great idea. Keep that out for everybody. And, you know, I just also hope it doesn't accelerate. And like when Bill mentioned the asbestos, I was like, ooh, that's not what you want to hear. But it's an older, you know, if it's an older building, that's always a possibility. But yeah, I think we should go forward and get this going. So, great.

2:43:40 Really, thanks for bringing this to us for sure. Nolan, thanks all the work on that. It was a really good staff report. And on that note, Jamie, any public comment on this issue? No, there is not. Okay, great. All right, any other comments before we go to a vote on this at all? I see none. Okay, call for a motion approval. Madam Mayor, I'll try again, if that's okay. Yeah, you almost got it. Yeah, it was close.

2:44:14 Just lost in space. I would move that the Town Council adopt a resolution authorizing the joint application and authorize the Town Manager to sign the local match commitment letter committing up to $1 million in funding towards the project or in an amount otherwise agreed upon by the Town Council. Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember Wentworth. Move second. Second. Thank you.

2:44:43 Second by Councilmember Rae. Jamie, can we have a vote, please? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Staab? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Great. Thank you, everybody. That's a happy thing to kind of end on here because that is the end of our agenda for tonight.

2:45:08 So thank you, everyone. Thank you, Patricia, for your presentation. Thank you, everyone, for being here and listening. And we will meet again next Wednesday night. That will be, what's the date on that? February 2nd. Wednesday, February 2nd. So we'll see everybody then. Take good care and we will have a good weekend. Bye, everyone. Thank you all.