Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
519 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:24 You guys good? Jamie, are you good? Are there a lot of people online? 13. Okay. Okay. Just to get a sense for, yeah. Dan, are you good? One more minute. Okay. I do it all by myself. And so we're always like, all by myself. I do it. I do it.
4:57 I'm just waiting for Dan. He needed a second. Mr. Haller, his second to last meeting.
5:26 He's not making eye contact yet, so I can't go because that'd be rude. Okay. All right, everyone. We're going to go ahead and get started. I am calling.
5:54 Oh, I could have, but I'm afraid I'll break it, and that would be bad. I'll call to order this meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Council for Wednesday, February 7th, and it's 4.04 p.m. I would like to turn this over to Town Manager Dan Holler, who will talk about the first point. If you want to do a quick roll call. Okay. So, Jamie, if you could, please call the roll. Thank you.
6:24 Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Here. Mayor Salzer is absent. Yes, and I wanted to speak. We have an item on the agenda that would consideration request for remote participation by Mayor Salzer. Speaking with him earlier, he is still in Reno. His wife's in the hospital in pretty serious condition. Given that, he has indicated that he will not be able to participate given the issues going on.
6:54 Thank you so much, and yes, we're sending Mayor Sauser and his wife our very best thoughts. So now we would like to have the Pledge of Allegiance, and we're asking Cynthia Fleming to lead us, and thanks for her service to our community.
7:26 All right. So we will begin this evening with public comments. This is for items not otherwise on the agenda this evening. And I just want to make a note that this evening's agenda does say that the speaking time will be five minutes.
7:58 And when we get to some later agenda items, if there are a large number of speakers, we may reduce that time to three minutes. We'll just get a read of how many people want to speak at that time, and then we'll make the call at that time. Thanks a lot. Are there any public comments in the room? If not, Jamie, are there any public comments online? Okay. Every time I say no, something goes on. Someone comes.
8:33 Bobby, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, this is Bobby Tanner. Can you hear me? Yes. Yes. Yes, I would like to speak about the Reds Meadow Road, if that, with your permission. Go ahead. I recently learned that the District Ranger, Mr. Fred Wong, addressed you guys with some information about the Reds Road. You had a subsequent discussion with Mr. Wong.
9:10 I have numerous questions into the Forest Service that have gone unanswered. We are currently in, we're quite in a state of limbo. We have had absolutely no stakeholder meetings. As I said, we have numerous questions into the Forest Service. One thing that I noticed in
9:37 A couple things in Mr. Wong's presentation. He said that he was hoping there'd be some accommodations for a partial operation of my business this summer. I would like to know what that means and how do you run a resort? How do you open a resort like that? Only partially. So I'd like to know if you guys have any access to the Forest Service. Mr. Wong.
10:05 Previously, in the last letter to me on June 16th, told me that in the future, I should contact his recreation officer if I would like a response from him. And his recreation officer has also not responded to me. Also, that I noticed in his presentation, he talked about that this is for the 20 disclosure, as far as this coming summer, 2024, and the limited
10:35 The information I received from the Forest Service, they said, they told me in writing this is for 24 and 25 and there's unknown how much the closures will be in 26. I asked if these weekend open, the road being open on weekends is a for sure deal and the response was no, there is no guarantees that these weekend openings will actually happen.
11:05 And so I'm having a great difficulty obtaining any information on this. We are currently losing customers. We were told that the press releases we've seen said that there will be wellness permits available on weekends this summer. We've tried to obtain wellness permits and we have been denied, told there are no wellness permits available. Consequently, we've lost customers. They were able to go to Rush Creek and get their wellness permits.
11:34 So, and then also the information put out that we see publicly from the Forest Service that because of the snowpack that the project is behind schedule. That is a wholly inaccurate statement and I'm hoping I could somehow have the opportunity to have a stakeholder meeting to address these issues because this is your Town of Mammoth project. You're the sponsor of this project. That's why I'm pleading to you to try to
12:02 Okay, thank you. Next, then, Mr. Holler, are there any additions to the agenda?
12:35 No, member of Bubser, we have no additional items to add to the agenda. Okay, great. So next, we have a council presentation. Is that correct? It's not department heads. This will be the you to... Okay, so Dan has a presentation to make, and here is Nolan. Yes, thank you. Actually, this is a dual presentation this evening, so this is kind of exciting. I don't think I've done this before.
13:05 We are recognizing Nolan for two significant achievements. So I'm not sure which one's greater, but the first one is he has recently been appointed as the Community Economic Development Director, overseeing that department, planning, building, code enforcement, working with the PEDC, other related duties as assigned, which includes snow removal, those types of things.
13:30 We had a competitive process. Nolan rose to the top through that process, background, knowledge, et cetera. Being able to step into that position, he's been acting for several months now. So that has really allowed him to step into some areas and I think get a better feel for some of the duties that he'll now be taking on formally.
13:50 The other side that kind of leads into that is this is also his 10-year anniversary week. So we're celebrating him being with the town of Mammoth Lakes for 10 years. Prior to that, I think it was a year and a half in Inyo County. Then he decided to come to a more snowy place. I was going to say better, but, you know, it's all relative. But anyway, being able to come up here, his wife and young, she's how old now, your daughter? Four. Four, so keeps him busy.
14:18 Those elements there. But I think through the planning department, Nolan's expertise there, just growing up in some of the more significant, larger planning elements and those types of things, working through a lot of the key issues in there, dealing with some of the building side and other stuff. And probably most notably in the last few years, he really has been the lead force and some of the architect behind our Housing Now initiative. And as that continues to be a high priority of this department, having that knowledge and background will be
14:47 Very valuable to the department, to the community, and to the town as an organization. Challenge will be finding somebody at his caliber behind him to fill in behind that position. So congratulations to Nolan both on the appointment in terms of the director as well as achieving 10 years with the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I believe you have the 10-year certificate. We'll get a photo with the council on him, but then you guys can make comments as you like. Before I do that, Nolan, you want to?
15:16 You got 30 seconds. I'm just very excited for the opportunities ahead. It's been a great 10 years so far of working with the town. I look forward to the future and being the leader for the department going forward. So thank you. First the shaking of the hand. You're going to be busy. Because of the two elements, we'll get a photo as well with the 10 years.
15:53 Just congratulations, Nolan. We really appreciate you stepping up. Look forward to working with you.
16:39 Nolan, did you used to work at Z Ranch? Yeah, what a great, what a success story, huh? You too can go from waiting tables to be in public service. Thanks, Nolan. Nolan, you know, the Housing Now program is a real source of great pride for our community, and so we're just excited to see what you'll do next, so congratulations. Congratulations, Nolan. I think...
17:08 The council, I think, really is invested in maintaining the continuity of the great programs we've put in place. So looking forward to all the great work we're going to be doing in the next coming years. So congratulations. And next, we're on item six. So that is reports from commissions and or departments as needed. So here we go. Go ahead. Good evening, council. Jason Heilman, Sergeant Mammoth Lakes Police Department.
17:41 We're going to kind of switch gears from all the snow and transition back into bicycles and bicycle safety. Please announce that the town of Mammoth Lakes through the police department was awarded a $40,000 grant from the California Office of Traffic Safety to support e-bike, bicycle and pedestrian safety. This grant's kind of unique because it was geared heavily toward e-bike safety.
18:09 Which we've all been talking about at the end of summer. And with our new ordinance, this is going to allow the police department in conjunction with the town to do more community outreach to promote safety. I'm very passionate about this grant because not only does the police department value safety, but I'm an avid bicyclist. When I'm not patrolling in a police car, you'll see me riding my bike around. I ride an e-bike to work in the summer. My daughter rides an e-bike around town.
18:39 So e-bike safety is something that I take very serious. So what does this grant look like and what's the program going to look like? It's a lot of community outreach. It's very education heavy, not enforcement. A lot of pop-up events, a lot of community bike rides, bicycle rodeos. It's going to allow us to purchase and outfit helmets to those in need.
19:04 And one specific thing about this grant is we were able to get some e-bike specific helmets, better quality, a little better looking, that we can hand out to the youth in need that don't have them. And if they look good, they'll wear them. So pop-up tents around town to promote safety. And it's also going to allow us to purchase, the department, to purchase a bicycle for community outreach, a proper police bike that's outfitted with
19:34 All the equipment so we can be out there making these contacts, take away the barrier of a police car, get out there, engage with the public, and really just gain compliance and help educate so we can all work together to create a safer environment for bikes and for e-bikes. So it'll be pedestrians, bicycles, and e-bikes, but you're going to see a lot more outreach from the police department on that end, working with Parks and Rec, working with the town.
20:03 And our local stakeholders to do more events. And the grant will run through September 2024 and hopefully beyond that. But with that, I can take any questions. Anyone has any? Any questions? I have a quick question. Yes. Are there any jurisdictional constraints on where you can be taking this program and taking your bikes and that kind of thing? Because obviously all the MUPS are all under permit from the Forest Service.
20:28 There's a Towns to Trails planning effort that's going on that's kind of a big interest in e-bikes as well, and I'm just wondering what your geography is going to look like. So the grant is obviously from the Office of Traffic Safety, which deals more with the roadways and the highways, but we all know that our multi-use paths, they all intersect with roadways, they all intersect with highways, so as long as there's a nexus to the highways, we'll be out there. And so the goal is really to just grow this program and kind of try and build the...
20:57 I don't know, the frontrunner for bicycle safety and e-bike safety, because they're not going away. More kids are on them, more adults are on them, and they're only getting faster, they're only getting more prevalent on the road, so it's kind of a, it's new to us, so we're going to see where we can take it, and I'm excited, and Chief Casabian's excited, and yeah, hopefully the town's excited. Good, thank you. And there'll be a press release for us coming by the end of the week. Great. Congratulations on the grant.
21:26 Sorely needed. We'll be very happy this summer to see you all out there keeping people safe. So thank you. Yeah, perfect timing. And we're going to start with the schools while it's still snowing. So by the time the streets are open for biking, the kids will already have it in their heads that, hey, that the message is out there. So we'll be starting even before the snow melts. Great. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Hi there.
21:57 Hello. Fred Wong, Mammoth District Ranger. I just had some announcements. Let's see here. Five things I wanted to briefly announce here, if I can find my notes again. Okay, let's talk about Reds Meadow Road, because it seems to be interesting to folks. So we are trying to work with Vista, our concessions, as well as the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
22:24 To try to consider all options of trying to keep to have campgrounds, specifically the Reds Meadow campground open during the weekends during the road construction. And so the two largest hurdles for Vista is finding enough work for these people to do during the weekdays when they're not working down there. And we are working with the town of Mammoth Lakes to try to find alternative jobs for them to do during the weekdays.
22:53 But also finding hookups for the camp hosts during the weekdays to have up here in Mammoth Lakes to live in while they are doing that alternative job during the weekdays. So we're working with the Town of Mammoth Lakes to figure out solutions for that. Also, I do want to mention, we did have, Forest Service did have a meeting with the Town of Mammoth Lakes staff regarding the snow pit that is
23:20 About east of our District Ranger office. And so due to the high levels of hydrocarbons that we found this year after, well, last year, I should say, we have to take a pause on entertaining a snow pit in the future until we are able to remediate the high levels of hydrocarbons in there. And the reason being, we don't really know what the cause of the high level of hydrocarbons are.
23:49 However, we know that if we were adding more snow on top of that, it would cause the hydrocarbons to seep into the very porous pumice soils in the groundwater. So we need to remediate that before we add any additional snow loading in that area. So I don't really anticipate us to be able to remediate that for a number of years. So I think the town staff is
24:17 Aware of the situation, and so I believe they're trying to find alternative locations for the snow pit. Also, Sherwin Tanks I wanted to talk about. As you know, this last season, we have a lot of logs out there. We just, and they're primarily from the Reds Meadow Road and from the road construction area and also from our hazard tree operations down at Reds Meadow Road. And so we're finding ways of trying to get rid of it.
24:46 Today, the day expired for us trying to sell that logs over there, and it's a great deal. It's for a $270 starting bid for all that wood. However, we did not get any bids, unfortunately, so we're going to try to figure out alternative ways of trying to get rid of it because I know it's unsightly over there, but also I know we are, the Town of Mammoth Lakes in partnership with the Forest Service is planning to implement some
25:16 Vault toilets and a parking lot in there. And so we're trying to figure out how to coordinate doing that. I want to also talk about grooming, snow grooming. I know that's a big interest to this town. So we are in the process of training up a couple of our staff. We are starting to get staffed up to operate the state-owned snow groomer. However, we have issues with, I guess it's broken again.
25:46 So we're trying to fix it. However, I think we're going to try to attempt to groom as much as we can with the available equipment that we have probably this weekend because essentially we were waiting for enough snow to groom and so I think we have enough snow now. So it's just a matter of finding the equipment. And then finally, I do want to mention that we are exploring the possibility of offering Christmas tree tags next year on the Inyo National Forest.
26:16 We're really on the beginning stages. And so ultimately we will know probably end to end of the year and we'll before the next Christmas comes. And we're probably going to be seeking comments from the public. And so we need, if the town is interested in this, we really encourage positive comments regarding these Christmas tree tags. So those are all my announcements. Any questions? Question?
26:46 And I'm sorry if I get the word wrong. Have you, has the Forest Service tested other locations for the hydrocarbons besides the snow pit? We are trying to do that, but for the main purpose of finding out the cause. You know, there could be a variety of causes. We don't know for sure. So we're going to go to different areas to test potential correlations, confounding principles, but...
27:10 Yeah, we are planning to do it. So the plan is to develop some sort of sampling plan for that area to find the extent of the pollution in there because we just did a cursory sampling of it and so it wasn't really a systematic sampling design. Okay, and then may I ask, because I don't know what hydrocarbons are. Yes, they can be, they fall into four different categories, diesel, gasoline.
27:40 I forget a couple of others. And so I can't remember exactly which particular hydrocarbon this was detected, but it was really high levels and it was actually pretty alarming from a pollution standard. Okay, thank you. And then I would like to say I would love to see Christmas tree cutting permits on the Ineo. My family, we always get them every year, but we usually have to go up to the Toyabe forest. So that would be wonderful to have that option here.
28:10 Thanks. Any other questions? I'm just kind of confused about the snow pit situation. Is there a possibility that those hydrocarbons could be coming from past Forest Service use? Well, certainly it could be coming from past uses, but generally for the Forest Service, the only thing that we've used over there was as a helipad. So, yeah, I think there could be potential other permitted
28:43 Events that happen during that area. It's just concerning because we've got the situation with the cabins out on Old Mammoth Road. I haven't heard anything about that in years. And with this situation here, it puts the community kind of a difficult situation here. And I know that you've been talking with staff about this, but we really need to figure out a way forward with this thing.
29:07 I know there are other communities that have snow pits. We can do some research on what the permitting's been like for those snow pits in other communities. I just can't, I'm just having a hard time squaring the fact that we stand out with the representation from yourself that this could go on for years and this could cause all kinds of problems. So I'm hoping we can figure out a way to move this thing forward. Well, I certainly encourage the town to find other options. Now, normally snow pits aren't.
29:33 A normal thing on Forest Service land. I know there's one in Alaska, and they do have a lot of mitigation measures of catchment basins and that sort of stuff, but it's a rare case that I think that's the only one I know of, and typically snow pits are on private land, so we really strongly encourage the town to look for options on private land, and I know the town has done that, and I know this place is surrounded by Forest Service land. There's really limited options.
30:00 Yeah, because that means 75% within our municipal boundaries is federal land. So we're kind of a unique situation. So I hope we can get this figured out without causing all kinds of undue hardship. So I have two questions. So the first is, is there something special about the aquifer in that area that makes the concern for leaching into the groundwater greater than if the snow pit were in another part of town where it would also?
30:28 Yeah, our, you know, our hydrologist is the expert on this, but essentially that area technically does not drain into Murphy Gulch because it infiltrates into the soil even before it gets to Murphy Gulch. And so whatever, I don't know exactly which aquifer that it drains into, but
30:53 And I don't know exactly how water is managed here on runoff around here, so I can't really answer that. All I know is it gets into the groundwater even before it reaches the surface water of the Murphy Gulch drainage. Okay, thank you. And then I guess that's it. Thank you so much. Any other questions? All right, thank you. Great, thank you. Thank you. Any other departments have... So then I'll just ask council, were there any questions on the...
31:25 Capital Project update that's generally usually in our packet. No, I appreciate the fact that the numbers, the budget numbers associated with it, so that's good to know. And the help as we go into the budget process. Absolutely. Okay. Terrific. Then moving along, next we have item 7.1, public presentation, and this is the 2023 Mammoth Disposal Annual Report. And I think, Pam, you're going to, oh, there you are. Thank you.
31:55 Yeah, I can just introduce the item briefly. Good evening, Council. Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager. One of the components of our franchise agreement with Mammoth Disposal includes an annual report from Mammoth Disposal each year to the Council. A number of items are called out that should be included in that report. Those were listed in your packet, so I won't go through those.
32:18 For various reasons, we haven't done this annual report previously, I think just with COVID and then with the transfer station not being fully operational until last year as its full year of operation. So primarily this report is focused on last year, but it does include some statistics and data from the two previous years as well.
32:38 With that, I'll turn it over to Kendra Knight and Michelle Irwin from Mammoth Disposal. They'll cover some of the highlights of the presentation. And then, of course, if you have questions, we can do kind of a Q&A at the end. Thank you.
32:51 Thank you. Good afternoon, Councilmembers. Thank you. We'll make this really brief. I'm Kendra. This is Michelle. Thanks for having us. So like Pam just said, yes, we are proudly serving the town of Mammoth Lakes in Mono County. I've been with Mammoth Disposal for three years. This is a three-year review, interestingly. If we want to go to the next one, thank you. Sorry, Pam.
33:17 And here's our team. We got to go and take, I took a bunch of photos of our team. As you can see right here, there's our office staff right there, Corey, Deborah, myself in Maui, Rob, and we have Peter with his grandchild, and Michelle, and Mike, and that's all us up there at Warming Hut having lunch. And then we have our awesome drivers. Mine's Marco right there. If you can see all our drivers right here, you can get to know your driver. We can go to our next one.
33:44 And then our recycling and transfer station staff. We just hired a couple more that we're going to add to this as well. Really exciting. And this is some numbers. 2023 tonnage, monthly reports right here, which I can't really see that well. So can you see that, Michelle? I apologize. But as you can see in your packet, you'll see this information in there. I apologize. My contacts aren't working so great today. So if you have questions regarding this.
34:14 Please let us know after the end of this presentation. You can go to the next slide. Thank you. Again, Michelle, can you read those numbers? We were just talking about I need to go to the eye doctor. Thank you, Dan. Fantastic. Do you mind going back to that last slide? Thank you so much. I made it green and it highlighted right there. 2023, as you can see, 2021, for instance, right here. Waste tonnage.
34:46 That's a lot of tons. 11,000, almost 12,000 tons. Okay, so since Pumice Valley is now our C&D kind of landfill, construction, demolition, debris, that kind of thing, as well as our Christmas trees. We recycled all our Christmas trees over there. Since we don't have Benton Crossing landfill now, this is what we're using for that kind of thing. And then we also hauled to Fallon, Nevada. In 2021, I want you guys to see this because it's pretty cool. We recycled 270,
35:16 Mattresses. So that's interesting. In 2022 was only 43. In 2023 was 242. 77 total commercial cardboard bins were in service last year. You can see all these numbers down here. I won't go into all of this right here, but we can go to the next slide, too. Thank you.
35:45 Here's our equipment and vehicles purchased all carb compliant for our state. In 2021, you can see that we purchased $783,616 worth of vehicles and equipment. You can look at your presentation to see what that was. A number of different bins, vehicles, etc.
36:05 And then we have our total for 2022 was almost $1.8 million worth of equipment. And then last year was over $2 million worth of equipment. So as you can see with three years, it's $4.5 million worth of vehicles and equipment. That includes cardboard bins, a bunch of different recycling types of equipment, such as this new sort line that I want you guys to see when you have a chance. You go to the next slide. Thank you.
36:32 Did you have comments about that one, though? No. Okay. Great. Okay. These are our mandates. As you guys know, as Councilmember Bubser was telling you guys, we have a lot of recycling mandates coming up. I'm not going to get into these right now. Let me know if you have questions. I'm happy to come back and give a presentation regarding every mandate, as well as the next slide. Thank you. More mandates.
36:53 Affecting the town of Mammoth Lakes. We can go to the next one, too. That might even be more mandates. SB 1383, you guys know about that organics mandate. We're exempt until 2026. We will reapply for that exemption. That's an elevation waiver as well as rural exemption. With that, though, we just applied for and are receiving $75,000 worth of grant funding over two years for the schools, education outreach, tower gardens. The next slide will show you, I think. That's more mandate outreach.
37:23 Those are postcards. I'm happy to give you guys all of that information as well. There we go. Some fun little kid photos. I love getting to work with all the children in the schools. It's my favorite part of my job. As you can see, we have all these tower gardens. We have eight going right now. It's really cool. Some of the kids get these vegetables bigger than their heads.
37:42 They're stating they love lettuce now. They love to eat. Right? Pam's daughter loves lettuce now. I mean, this is like real vegetables. So it's really exciting. This is really cool. Kids get to see this program firsthand and then tell their parents. And then we get to know about it, too. Next slide, please. Ooh, more photos. Hold on.
38:06 Transfer Station. That took a little while for us to build that, but it's up and running now, $6.6 million later. Really great facility. You guys have all seen that and had a tour. I'd love to give you a tour of our buyback center as well. We have that sort line going, as you can see photos of that. It's awesome. It's so fun. I mean, really, being up there. You know, it's really cool to see kind of the system, see the flow of materials and what comes through, too. What else on that slide do I want to tell you? Sounds good. Yeah, let's go to the next one.
38:37 And there's our team having fun as well as our Mammoth Disposal magnet with our QR code to download that recycling guide that's right there on the right. And we look forward to 2024. The next slide. Thank you, Pam.
38:50 So, this year, we have a lot of changes, as I mentioned, but we also have a lot of great things happening, like a household hazardous waste grant coming, $46,000, paint reuse areas, cardboard bins coming, $275,000 grant being written in June that I know we'll receive over two years for CalRecycle, as well as, I just heard this, that new CRV program, SB 1013, I have dreams about this.
39:17 This bill, we just was announced CalRecycle, new grant funding for this, is due in April. Really exciting, so we can get some new equipment. So it'll be really cool. Just really, lots of great things happening at the Transfer Station Recycling Center. Thank you, guys. Thank you. Any questions? I have a question. Go ahead. So, ambitious, good, great to see all this stuff coming online. We had a discussion about fees a little while ago, and there was some
39:48 Comment made about a variety of different programs to really start to encourage people starting to bring their stuff down to the get it integrated in these great systems you're putting together. I don't see any of that for the 2024 program here. Can you maybe come back to us or if I'm missing them, but we can maybe get an update on those things. Yes, I'd love to provide that and provide you with more in depth of what we're doing for programs for this. The district ranger was just here, but he kind of skedaddled out of here. Is there communication between you guys and the Forest Service?
40:18 Such that if things are not ending up where they're supposed to be ending up, is there some reporting going on back and forth so we can, I mean, I know we've got people on the ground looking for these kinds of things, but mattresses, couches, junk that, hey, it's too expensive, it's too difficult to take down to the transfer station. Are you in contact with the public lands folks about?
40:38 about those kinds of challenges? Michelle Irwin, Mammoth Disposal. Yes, any calls that come in from the public, from the town, from the Forest Service, if there's any litter like that, we send our team out to go and pick it up and bring it in and properly dispose of it. Can you do that on federal public land? I mean, if we get a report that there's like a bunch of couches that got dumped off of the road, Old Mammoth Road, and they need to be picked up, is that something you guys...
41:03 You can respond to those calls? Yes. We haven't had any calls like that as yet, but if something like that was to come up, we would definitely work with whatever enforcement agency or town forest service and make sure we can help take care of that. Okay. That's good to know. I think in the past we had where the shooting range used to be. We worked with that group there to clean that up and it helped give them discount bins and such to clean up all the old appliances and stuff that were shot up. So we've worked with them in the past. Okay. We look forward to following up with you on those kinds of challenges. Thank you.
41:31 If I could, too, I did want to just add about programs for the upcoming year. It is on here a little bit on this slide, but as part of the Household Hazardous Waste Grant and the other SB 1383 grant, we will be working with Mammoth Disposal to provide community household hazardous waste days, drop-off days.
41:52 As well as green waste collection days. So that would be in addition to our annual town cleanup day. These would be more focused on specific types of items. At least one of each of those per year, possibly two of each of those per year, depending on how much funding we have and how much effort it takes to get these things organized as we see how they work. And do you have a name or brand for these things?
42:20 What are you going to call them? Free e-waste days? Yes. Free e-waste days. Free green waste days. That kind of thing. We'll come up with a really cool name, though. We have already kind of started our branding, too. If I could just flip back to this slide with our outreach for the various mandates. We plan to kind of continue this branding through any other outreach that we do for other types of initiatives like these cleanup days. Okay.
42:43 We don't have a clever name per se yet at this time, but we would probably brand it in conjunction with our annual cleanup day and in conjunction with the branding that we've already done. Okay, so whether it's a state mandate or a town program, it's going to look and feel like that when it goes out. Is that our styrofoam band? Is that the town? Okay, good. So it all kind of gets commingled. We beat the state. Yeah. And we have these in the back of the room on postcards if you want to take one home with you. Okay, great.
43:09 And I've worn my bag, and they're both in English and Spanish. And to touch on what Pam said, we welcome names. If you'd like to, yeah, let me know. I'd love to work with you guys on naming these events, actually. Okay. It'd be really cool. Good. And I'd love to come back and tell you about all the money we're going to make for us in the future, too. Thank you so much. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Next, item number eight is the consent agenda.
43:37 I'll read the consent agenda first. So 8.1 is to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of January 17, 2024. 8.2, approve the minutes of the special meeting of January 31, 2024. 8.3, authorize the contract for airport pavement maintenance management plan update to Brandly Engineering Inc. 8.4, approve the resolution adopting the town of Mammoth Lake's paid sick leave policy. 8.5,
44:05 Approve the resolution adopting the Town of Mammoth Lake Snow Patrol Policy 8.6. Accept check register 1824, accept check register 12424, and accept register 13124. So are there any items that council members or the public want to pull from the agenda? Seeing none and none from the public.
44:33 Then we will go ahead and I will request a motion to approve the consent agenda. I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. And a second? I'll second. Okay. A motion from Councilmember Rice and a second from Councilmember Ray. And so, Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. All right.
45:04 Moving on to policy matters. We are on to agenda item 9.1, which is the approval of the employment agreement with Rob Patterson for the position of town manager. And I think that our town attorney, Andrew Morris, will be presenting or starting this item. Yes, thank you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem.
45:33 So the Brown Act says that you cannot discuss executive compensation, that is town manager compensation in closed session. So at the last meeting, the council did discuss the appointment of Mr. Patterson in closed session, except for compensation. You didn't talk about compensation at all. And since you can't approve compensation in closed session, you can't approve his employment agreement in closed session. But I will just let the public know that...
45:57 The discussion of everything except compensation has already occurred, and tonight the council can consider all of that again, but you're discussing compensation for the first time. All right. So with that, just to let the rest of council know that the mayor and I worked with Mr. Patterson on the proposed agreement, and I am now going to read the salary as agreed to. So it's a weekly salary of...
46:26 So are there any questions from the council? If you would maybe just briefly characterize your discussions with Mr. Patterson that you and the mayor had, I'm assuming it was cordial and productive.
46:57 Absolutely. I've been in many salary negotiations in my career, and I was very impressed with how Rob really came in very thoughtfully and it was a very, very cordial and really one of the easier negotiations because I think as our finance director with our conservative budgeting that we do,
47:25 Rob knows all too well how important it is that we stick to things that are considered reasonable. So just to point out, there was one thing in the contract where there was an opportunity for an increase this July, and we discussed the fact that the optics would be best if we had that
47:52 Thank you. Any other questions?
48:22 So then are there any questions from the public? Am I, is that the right order? Yeah. I'm happy for help, certainly. If I can make one comment early on, again in discussions with Mayor Sauser, as you mentioned, the two of you worked with Rob, he did want me to express his appreciation for the same conversation that happened and that
48:47 He was in full support of the agreement that was reached in that negotiation process, so he wanted to make sure you were aware of that. Yeah, you can ask for any public comment, council comment, and Mr. Patterson. So first, any comments from the public? Anyone online? And then any other comments from, oh, any comments from Mr. Patterson? No, thank you. I think it was a very simple negotiation.
49:19 The salary that we based that on was a 10% increase over current. And as you noted, we had per contract some range adjustments that were already basically approved by resolution. But again, just taking a 10% increase now. And then the opportunities for more that comes later with performance of the job. So I really look forward to that. Is this my part where I get to talk about how grateful I am for being in this position or just this?
49:49 Contract. You have the mic. You can say whatever you want. You know, I wanted to thank council for a thoughtful process, right? That was a long process that was gone through. There was a lot of steps to that. And I appreciated the questions that were asked, the aspects that were brought forward to try to just figure out really where passions were for the community and capabilities. So that was a good process, and I really appreciate that.
50:18 Secondly, I'm grateful for this opportunity. What a tremendous organization the Town of Mammoth Lakes has. Dan has built a very strong core of people in the workforce, and they're excellent at the work that they do, and I'm really pleased to be a part of that organization and to lead them into the future. Dan had gratefully given us a 12-month notice for his departure, which I'm grateful for.
50:48 What that did is set a finish line out there that we had to get a whole lot done in a short amount of time. So staff, and I think that was directed by Dan more than anybody else, but we've been running hard for that. You saw some of my comments in the paper. It was surrounding the fact that we've been trying to get a very great deal of items completed before his departure, and now we've got some transition work to do. So I think my efforts...
51:17 are going to be to focus on transitioning the organization to new leadership. We haven't had that in 10 years. That's a very, very long time. And I think our styles are slightly different, although Dan and I work very closely together for just about every single day.
51:34 And so it will be very similar but slightly different. And I want to make sure that the organization has very strong legs. You know, we get through that transition process, we understand what we need to do, and we implement some changes that I'm looking to implement as far as how we approach outwardly to the community and those types of things at all levels. But just grateful for the opportunity. Dan's set us up for success. I hope I don't screw it up.
52:04 And I'll do my best not to. And I really appreciate all of the staff for the Town of Mammoth Lakes that will support us through this transition. And I appreciate Council for giving me the opportunity. So thank you. Absolutely. So any other comments, any discussion from Council? Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'm prepared to make a motion if that would be OK. Please do. I would move that the Town Council approve the employment agreement with Rob Patterson for the position of Town Manager effective March 1st.
52:35 2024. I'll second. Great. So we have a motion from Councilmember Wentworth, a second from Councilmember Rice. Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser? Yes. All right. Wow, we are cooking along. So let's see. Next, we have been requested to move
53:03 Item 9.5, which is to review and provide comments on the town civic center design up to the next agenda item because we have the architects online and would like to let them head home for the evening and they're also on the clock. So with that, I think it's our new Director of Community and Economic Development and Nolan Bobroff and Hayes. So
53:33 Take it away. I'm just going to provide a quick introduction on the item and then we do have Brandon Gulati and Brian Nichols from HMC Architects who will provide a further overview on the design of the project. I'm just going to share my screen for one quick slide here.
54:01 All right, so this item is intended to give the town council and the public an opportunity to comment on the design for the town civic center project prior to the planning and economic development commission's consideration of the design at an upcoming commission meeting. The history of the site and the project is quite long. The town and other partners acquired this site, known as the McFlex parcel, approximately 20 years ago through a land exchange with the Forest Service.
54:29 For the purpose of constructing a civic plaza on the site that consolidates a wide variety of public and civic uses to a single location within the community. To date, the site has been developed with the Superior Court of California, the Mono County Administrative Offices, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, the Mammoth Community Church, and is the site for the future expansion of the Mammoth Hospital.
54:52 The location for the town's building within the site is the vacant parcel circled in red on the screen directly west of the Mono County Administrative Building and adjacent to Sierra Park Road. Staff have been actively working with the design team from HMC Architects to move the project through the town's design review process in anticipation of beginning construction on the project this summer.
55:18 And with the target move-in date of fall of 2026. As noted before, this item is just to provide the council and public an opportunity to comment on that. And with that, I will hand it off to the architect team to provide a short presentation on the design for the project. Cool. Thank you. And pleasure as always to be here again presenting to council. There's not two Brandon Galatis. I copy-pasted a link to Brian, so that's why he's shown up to me as well.
55:48 So we're going to run through and try and keep it brief for you, but would love to hear your feedback on the design. Can you all see that? Yes. Yes. Yes. Excellent. All right. As Brandon said, I'm Brian Nichols. We just happened to Zoom has doubled us up. So, you know, as you just saw, the site is here right next to the Mono County building, next to the courthouse.
56:19 And we're going to go through this pretty quickly just because we know you guys have a long meeting. But if you have any questions, please chime in. We can answer questions if we go. We can answer them at the end, however is best for you all. But we just wanted to share some of the sort of the original thinking to the project. You know, we like to start with goals and vision and guiding principles really before we
56:43 Start to draw anything. And some of the things we had talked about at the very beginning was really creating a space where the public engages with their local government. You know, basically a space that is kind of welcoming. It's an invitation. It doesn't sort of scare people away. It's a place where the people can come. And, you know, they're meeting people across the desk. You know, it's a place for engagement and collaboration. You know, very flexible.
57:12 Easy wayfinding. We've heard some things about other places that are similar, but you walk in and you don't know where to go. We wanted to avoid that. Really creating a space that could be flexible enough to be used for community events, because knowing that, say, the council chamber, for instance, is not used on a constant basis and really trying to find ways to take advantage of that.
57:36 Really trying to create a way to sort of, you know, have sidewalks and things that connect to the other buildings on that kind of little campus. And to really, you know, let the building acknowledge what's special about Mammoth and about the area. And, you know, we talked a lot about this idea of village and the trees and the mining history and the sort of the recreation. And really, it's just an amazing place. And we wanted the building to kind of celebrate that. The building itself is really simple.
58:05 Essentially three parts. There's the city offices where the staff work, there's the sort of the place where the public comes to interact, the lobby space, and then there's the council chamber, and obviously the lobby has restrooms and other support spaces. We've located the building as per the site right there along Sierra Park Road. The staff parking would be to the north, and the visitor parking would be to the south, and the model counted building is essentially on the east side.
58:33 So what we wanted to do was, you know, we really have those distinct parts of public area and city staff area, but we really wanted sort of architecturally them to seem like those things are interlocked because we didn't want it to feel like two buildings next to each other. So when you see the elevations and the renderings, you'll kind of see that we're kind of joining those two pieces. And as you see, the council chamber to us is this very special moment where
59:03 People come and it's really where you see your government happening, you know, like we do tonight. And so we located it along Sierra Park Road and we rotated it. So architecturally it's this visible element that you can kind of see in the building. And then lastly, the roof is built in a way, you know, we talked with the city a lot about the office building having the office part being, you know, a flat roof with no parapets so the snow would blow off. But then over the lobby we really didn't want to, like on the
59:33 I know there have been some issues on the Monaco County building where the snow sort of drops onto the parking lot. We wanted to get the snow away from the main entry. So essentially the roof is lifted up, sort of to open up the entry to the south into the staff parking lot. And then all the snow and the drainage would go off to the left where there really aren't any sort of people coming in and out of the building.
1:00:00 And then, you know, we also talked about, you know, wanting kind of more of a civic presence. So we've sort of brought in this idea of these tree-like columns to sort of celebrate kind of this village and the trees idea. But also, you know, if you think of kind of classic civic buildings, lots of times there's columns on the exterior and we felt like it gave it a little bit of a civic presence. You guys know the site, obviously, but, you know, in case you're interested, these are the buildings that are sort of our immediate neighbors on the project. And this is the site.
1:00:30 As you can see, the gray block here is the new Civic Center building. The lighter gray are the sort of our neighboring buildings. And you can see the 33 parking spaces up here. That's the staff parking. We are actually working on ways to sort of maybe try to get a little bit more parking in there.
1:00:49 And then Tavern Road is where the Mono County and sort of visitor parking for the new Civic Center would be with a little bit of an entry plaza off the lobby because we had talked about becoming more of a public space and having other uses, you know, so maybe there's some outdoor space you can use during the summertime. So this, and I'll hand it off to Brandon for this part.
1:01:13 So this is looking a little bit in more detail with those plans and diagrams we were just looking at. You can see town offices are really that right side of the building. We're doing it two-story for a few reasons. One, it's the most efficient way to lay out the building on the site, and it's also going to be cost effective given the construction type and usage of the space.
1:01:31 And again, there's that public interface that is really connecting this with the council, which we've talked about being a flexible use space that can be utilized for other events throughout the week. At the back, you can see support for both the town offices and also the lobby and council. And again, what really came up in so many conversations was this idea that you want warm, friendly faces.
1:01:54 Really, once you enter the space, you want to feel like you're talking to somebody at the town that, you know, you can trust and interact with. So right when you walk in the doors, you're being greeted by that. You can see that actually in the star there. So there's this interaction between the town offices on the right and that public interface that happens. And this space really becomes a space that you can utilize so people come, your staff can come out into this public interface and start to work with individuals as well.
1:02:20 Going to the second floor again, it was a really efficient way to stack the building and two stories. It's also going to reduce some of our operational costs with heating as well as reducing our losses to the environment from a heating standpoint and reducing the total amount of square footage that we have for our envelope. So it made a lot of sense from a cost standpoint to organize it this way. We have private offices or the darker blue and then we have an open office in the middle. And again, our support really.
1:02:49 Landed along that northern spine of the building and we have all of our circulation in the back. These are some elevations of the project. We'll get to the materials in a moment. You can dive a little bit deeper if you have questions about what type of materials. But, you know, we're using a lot of earthy colors, referencing stone, wood. We're also looking at using materials that are going to be durable. I mean, this is going to be a civic building. It's going to be something that you want to be easily maintainable and very durable over its lifetime.
1:03:20 Because this is, you know, an investment that you're making into the town. So on the south facade, sorry, Brian, on the south facade, our main entry, we'll have some rendering so you get a little bit. I don't know why it's taking a second to. Sorry. Maybe go to the next one. Yeah.
1:03:42 Okay, that loads. You'll see the south on a better view when we go to the renderings. This is looking from Sierra Park Road on the east elevation down there and then on the north elevation you're seeing really what staff looks at when they come into their parking. So again, there's a flat roof that's happening at the...
1:04:00 The town offices, that is really happening to help scour the snow from the top of the roof. As we looked at the site, we spent a lot of time together with the town understanding really where some of the pain points are going to be for snow removal, ice buildup, public entries, safety, and largely we came up with a flat roof to capture as much as we can up here and then let the snow blow off over time. And then we do have a sloped roof that is going to take a lot of the snow and dump it into the landscape area in our snow storage area.
1:04:31 And as we move to the renderings, this is that view.
1:04:33 The elevation, unfortunately, didn't load. This is our southern view as you come along tavern and you park. We're trying to maintain a lot of the existing trees you see in this forecourt space. So there'll be some trees, there'll be likely some boulders that we find when we start doing excavation that can come out into this space. And again, it becomes a space that is inviting. It starts integrating the outdoor natural environment into, you know, really your experience of the building as you approach it. And as Brian had mentioned, we have these columns on the exterior that are evoking that sun.
1:05:02 And this is the view from...
1:05:32 Staff entered largely. And again, this is looking at various materials that I think we have a material board here that we can get to in a minute. This is a view of the lobby on entry. And so what you're actually seeing is if you entered and turned left or the view from the town offices because they will have windows out. So again, we're looking at using warm materials, durable materials, making it a warm, inviting space for the public to engage and interact.
1:06:03 And that's council that you're seeing in that volume that's kind of a gray volume. And this is the council chamber. And this is a view of what you're seeing actually in the background is the break room for the town offices, but in general is showing you the overall layout of the offices. We have some private offices that are enclosed with storefronts to allow a lot of daylight in. And then we have some open offices that are kind of in the foreground in this photo. And a lot of the way the building was laid out was putting the private offices actually at the back.
1:06:36 Daylight deep into the space. Anybody in the open office is getting an equivalent amount of views in daylight as anybody in the private offices would. So this is the pallet for the exterior. So we wanted to keep it simple. We wanted, as Brendan said, durable, long-lasting, and economical was one of the sort of high on the list. So it's really a combination of mostly fiber cement cladding, which is essentially
1:07:06 Panels that are made of essentially, they're like concrete cement panels. And then the council chamber has essentially kind of a large format. We wanted, you know, again, and I, you know, you might have wanted to clad that in stone, but, you know, that was kind of kind of too far, but we found essentially a tile product, and it's essentially kind of big tiles that kind of approximates the look of kind of a stone finish.
1:07:35 The lobby, the ceiling in the lobby is actually kind of a wood-like finish, but it's just for durability and longevity. There's essentially a metal product that has kind of a faux wood look to it, so that the idea is that on the inside it has small perforations in it, so it can be acoustical, so that it can sort of help tamp down the sound in the lobby. The roof is just kind of your standard standing seam roof.
1:08:03 Glass is just kind of a gray-tinted glass with, you know, kind of solar control qualities. Kind of a dark bronze mullions, which are kind of almost reed-like black, but they have just a little hint of warmth to them. And then for the sort of the office part, that part that you saw on the renderings that kind of had the vertical kind of reddish-orange, that's kind of the Corten standing scene panels. Now, a lot of these materials sort of...
1:08:31 Kind of echo some of the finishes that are on the police station. So we're trying to sort of create some consistency there too, in addition to kind of the idea of longevity and durability and economic. And then on the inside, it's kind of the same idea is, you know, terrazzo on the floors because it's long lasting. You know, we talked about going with just polished concrete, but we felt ultimately, I think.
1:08:59 discussions with the city that that was kind of too far, kind of too raw of a space. But the council chamber on the inside and the outside is basically the same material. There's some kind of accent carpets and then a couple places with sort of wood accents like within the council chamber and things like that. You don't need to go through each and every material. And the office space is kind of meant to just be kind of bright and airy.
1:09:29 We're actually currently looking at right now kind of exposed ceilings so we can get more height and more get the daylight kind of further into that open office area. And that was the last slide we have. So we'd love to hear any questions or comments or thoughts. Thank you. Any questions from the council? I have a couple.
1:09:59 Okay. Thank you very much. Very interesting. Has this been through the design review process yet? Yes. We had an advisory design panel meeting last week, and then we're going to have a follow-up meeting at the end of the month. We're working on scheduling. Okay. Do these visualizations reflect the input that came from that design review process? Yes. The interior was a lot of the comments that came from the ADP on warming up the lobby area, and those were reflected in these renderings. Okay.
1:10:29 First impression, it feels a little, this thing feels a little alien. I think one of the things we pride ourselves on Mammoth Lakes is being an authentic community, and I think there's probably some more work to do to figure out how to get this to reflect, to see the community reflected in it. It doesn't feel like it's connected to this.
1:10:50 Community. That's just a first impression. And I would like to, I know that there are creative ways to do that. I think there's, I would better encourage the team to do a bit more work on this to make it, make it feel like who we are. We're not, we're not, this is not a pretentious place. This is an authentic.
1:11:07 Real community with real people. And I think there's things that we can do to maybe reflect that a little bit better. On the council chamber, I think we all recognize that the reality of public spaces these days, especially where the public is engaged, is that technology has to be like a primary consideration. It's nice to have a nice lit oval over the council room. That's kind of cute. But I think just really investing to make sure it's going to be a functional space for all the types of...
1:11:35 I think we're going to anticipate it's going to be really from one council member sort of a priority. To Snow Hayes, I'm going to assume that you're taking the lead on that. Okay, so I'll leave it there. I'm hoping that there has been a debrief of the Mono County building, the lessons learned. There's a lot of...
1:11:57 There's a lot of sort of difficult, unfortunate things that happen at building. There are spaces in that building that still are not usable, and I'm really hoping that that debrief is done quite thoroughly, and we're not going to be running into those kinds of problems again. The grading, the site, I would anticipate there's going to be a fair amount of grading for the site, because right now there's sort of a hill that goes down from there. Is that? Yes, we have some grading.
1:12:24 Thank you so much.
1:12:54 A lot of our money. One thing just to point out, we are a town, and it's a little confusing to see city on the drawings. There's the city of Bishop or the town of Mammoth Lakes. That'd be helpful to get that updated. On the parking, so there was a representation of public parking is to the south, but then in later images here, it looks like we're all going to be sharing the Mono County parking lot. Is there discreet parking for this building, or is it going to be blended?
1:13:23 So we have our own staff parking and the Mono County parking is actually public right-of-way. Okay. So that is shared parking and we're going through a process right now to create more parking shared with the county for our vehicles and creating more parking for the public who will interact with us and creating those spaces so it's easy to access. So at the end of the day, it's...
1:13:43 All that parking is going to be shared between the public going into various buildings. Yeah, it's all public. And even the parking spaces going around the police station, into the court, those are all, they're all public. Okay, so is there a wayfinding program for this? Yeah. So as part of that campus, I think there's one of the notes there about wayfinding, having the campus field, the sidewalks and integration of all the buildings. So when you show up at the town offices, if you get sent to the courts, there's a clear path of travel to get there.
1:14:11 That would be really helpful because there is something about this structure that's reminiscent of the Monroe County building and I think if people don't clearly know where they're going it could get pretty confusing. Did I see a fireplace in the lobby? We might want to think about that a little bit. I mean, everybody in the community has got to go through for a fireplace and EPA compliant stoves and all the rest of it. Would it be a gas fireplace or would it be actually burning wood? No, it's not.
1:14:41 Gas. Gas. Gas. I would just say that I think we can come up with something better. It's a topic of ongoing discussion. Yeah, I think that's maybe something to think about. And finally, just in terms of the exterior, this goes back to that sort of authenticity thing about what does this building feel like in terms of this community?
1:15:04 We've recently just done the CRC, which has got a very different look. We've gone through discussions about the logo and the brand of the town. I'm assuming that's going to be around for a while. I think maybe we could find a way to kind of, if you take that blue, if you take that logo, that look and feel, maybe with some of the exterior materials to blend it a little bit better. But all in all, very impressive. For all of us who've been in the current town offices in the morning with the animals and the fumes, I think it's...
1:15:32 Something we're very much looking forward to, but I think we can do probably a little bit better job to make it give it a real mammoth feel to it. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, so my questions are more logistical. So I'm sure there have been discussions. What are the discussions about plans for future staff growth? I know that we keep our staff very trim, but it's just a question.
1:15:58 Yeah, we actually designed some spaces into the building so we can expand. Nothing significant, but there's some extra offices and there's some spaces reserved in the second floor for expansion. And then just in terms of like the sort of trend towards flexible spaces and not having so many fixed offices, were there discussions around that? Yeah, you're speaking my language. So that has been something I've been discussing with staff since day one is that
1:16:27 We will change over time. So even the fixed offices on the outside, we are working with a company on a modular system. So we can change those as our needs change. And then the interior offices are modular in nature. We actually sent a delegation of staff to look at some options. So pretty much all the furniture and office solutions will ultimately be modular. Oh, that's great. Next, it looked to me like in the chambers, the council chambers, it was fixed seats.
1:16:56 Like sort of theater-style seating, so I misread that. Okay, thank you. And then just a couple more. The grant for the Resiliency Center I know is still out there. Is there any update on that just in the context of? No, we don't have any updates. Okay. I will say that we have taken that Emergency Operations Center through complete design and that if we were fortunate enough to receive that grant, we would be able to integrate that into what you've seen today.
1:17:26 Very, very seamlessly. And my last question. Are there grants available for making buildings more energy efficient, and have we optimized them? We track all kinds of grants, and any opportunity to make this building more efficient, we would take advantage of. I have not personally seen anything in our grants meeting with our consultant of late, but it is something we're definitely interested in, because it would save the community money on our long-term utility bills.
1:17:56 I just have to say it. I heard this amazing story on NPR about passive heating. It's much more prevalent in Europe, but it's something that we should keep our eye on. Those are all my questions. So then any questions from the public? Any questions online, Jamie? Okay. Dave, please unmute yourself and give your comment. Yes, it's just a question. What's the budget for this building? What's the cost of building this?
1:18:32 We're working through that process on that right now. We're in the $24 million range. We're looking at some debt issuance in that, so there's some other costs related to that. But you're running about $1,000 a foot, given what we're looking at all in, a little bit of that. So it's expensive in that perspective. We're working through the financing side.
1:18:57 As we look at the other elements that we're spending dollars on already that related to a lot of elements, our goal is to have a very limited impact on our general fund. Part of that will be we have a couple of years where we're still in this building, so the transition of the lease payment, stuff like that will take time, so we'll have a dual payment, if you will, for a couple of years. But it's actually, it's coming together. I would just like to remind staff and the council of the optics of
1:19:24 Dropping, you know, $25 million on this after having spent $25 to $30 million on a skate rank while preparing to throw STR owners under the bus and saddle us with, you know, entirely with the cost of workforce housing. So I just think the council ought to be wary of those optics. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else, Jamie? No. All right. Is there...
1:19:54 I guess if there's no other comments or questions. Yeah, there's no formal action we need. We're just looking for comments. We'll take the ones we've received there and take a look and see how we integrate and come back. A little bit changes there, most likely a little bit. But overall, sounds like it's moving in the right direction. Lynn, in terms of a, I mean, we've been going forward with this.
1:20:16 When do we anticipate some kind of a decision or decision point about when we're actually giving an authorization to proceed? So what will the next step at your next formal meeting actually will have the financial plan in place. So that'll be an action item in terms of setting and not to exceed amount in a debt issuance. So that'll be a step forward there. And then once we get the next round of the design done, at that point we'd be looking at
1:20:45 We can bring it in for formal to go into the construction drawings. And so then that would be moving forward. The financing plan would look at bringing that information in now, setting a maximum. We would actually not issue the debt until we actually have a contract so we know how much we need and be able to incise the bonds at the same time that we'd go out for an award of a bid. They're within a few weeks of each other, but in that time frame.
1:21:15 A process that would bring that forward in June, July to be able to move forward to construction at that point, awarding the bid. Back it up for a couple of weeks from now, we will be coming back. If we do some tweaking in the design, boom, we're ready to go and move forward. Unless there's any, you know, concerns at that point, we'd have one more bite at the apple to slow down. Okay, and Rob Patterson knows about all this, right? He's been in all the meetings and, yeah, he's really excited about it.
1:21:43 Okay, I'll take that. We'll take that under advisement. Yeah. Yes, please come to the microphone. I'm sorry, you didn't ask for a call. Oh, she did? I didn't hear that, so I'm sorry about that. Terry Stelick, you know, I just, grown up here, been in snow country for a long time, but everything that keeps getting designed and built is flat roofs. Why do we keep building flat roofs? I mean, that's, we're not just a little bit of snow country. So anyways.
1:22:20 If properly designed, a flat roof does function better. We found, in looking at the examples from the Mono County building as we were directed, that roof shed was an issue. And with public access on multiple sides of this building, having the snow shed into public spaces was a concern.
1:22:39 But like I said, if properly designed, you can hold the load, you can hold the weight, and the snow will scour. Yes, if you get into a situation like last year, you do have to get up there and remove snow, and we are prepared, and we've designed for that. But in most circumstances, in most winters, it will function on its own, and will actually create a safer environment for the public who are, you know, moving around the building. And just one final thing. I think going forward, as we bring this agenda item...
1:23:07 So next we are on to agenda item 9.2.
1:23:33 And this is to consider the certified properties proposal from the short-term rental advisory committee. And I think Rob Patterson will lead this item. Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem. So as you know, we've been working through certified properties, I'm sorry, with the SDR advisory committee for a number of months on several aspects, if you will, of our short-term rental program.
1:24:07 This one is probably one of the most straightforward elements of that because it's the administration components. And I'll say that the majority of the items being considered here in the Certified Properties Program are born out of years of our enforcement activities, understanding where some shortfalls are with our current process of administration, which would be
1:24:32 Business tax certificates coupled with TOT certificates or transient occupancy tax certificates. And so that kind of came to fruition during the moratorium as the TOT certificates, if you will, belong to the business owner versus the property owner. Well, certified properties flips that and allows for the actual property owner to have the certificate for
1:25:01 For utilization as a short-term rental. And then they can contract with someone else who's an operator or they can operate it themselves if they have their own BTC. As I said, the Certified Properties Program is really the administrative functions that we wanted to update associated with this. The work that we did in the subcommittee was to engage with some of our operators that elected to be on that subcommittee.
1:25:29 And work with us and talk about some of the challenges and how we should address them. So we got good input from lodging community. I certainly had members of my team on the discussion through that process. So I'll just kind of briefly go through some of the elements that were included in the discussion and in how we would implement these processes. So first and foremost, safety.
1:25:51 You know, we have a goal really to enhance the security of guests as well as quality of life for the community and improve the visitor experience. That was the charge that we kind of focused on. One of the biggest elements was required inspections. When we first implemented the inspection process back, I think, in 2015, we did not, we grandfathered in a number of buildings.
1:26:16 Thank you.
1:26:44 We wanted to require that every unit be inspected every four years. The four-year time frame came from the volume that it would take to inspect those. We think that's about the maximum we can get with our current inspectors. And these inspectors are not town employees. They are contracts. They're business owners within the town that perform these functions for us. But doing about 25% of the outstanding or STRs per year, that's around 900 properties.
1:27:14 In addition to having those properties inspected, we wanted to increase some of the areas that we look at, right? That's where we talk about the quality of life, the quality of experience. So areas that were more challenging, we focused additional elements of our inspection on that. And so that's an enhancement of that process. The other thing we have a lot of trouble with is emergency contacts.
1:27:42 So emergency contacts have in the past been simply a name on file where someone has to come in and say, yes, I will be the emergency contact for this business. You're required to be able to respond within 60 minutes, 24 hours a day, seven days a week to any issues that may occur on the property. We found that a lot of people who are operating from a distance, you know, didn't really have a well thought through plan for this and would just find someone to sign up for it.
1:28:11 So we're requiring that that 24-hour contact either be the property owner or operator within the town who's present within the town, a property management company, or a company engaged in the service business of providing 24-hour contacts. So we have those in town and folks can sign up with them. It's not signing up with the property management company. It's simply contracting with someone to be that 24-hour contact.
1:28:41 That would need to be shared with the town. We would do a process by which we validate that as accurate because we certainly would have to know who they are and move forward. Other element was interactive maps. So we have GIS-based maps on our website now that show the location of all of our legal properties that are certified in town. This information would include
1:29:05 How to contact that if there is a problem. So the 25-hour contact would certainly be present. But also the manager's name and telephone number. And then some pertinent information about occupancy limits and number of parking spaces. These are, again, things that we've had issues with in the past. But we want the ability to someone who's next to a unit that has something going on to be able to go to a website, call it up, and see if it's legal. And then from there, there'll be maps. Not maps, but...
1:29:31 Contact information where they can contact our enforcement department if there seems to be something amiss. I'm happy to follow up on that. Cleaning services, so each unit has a cleaning service that's registered with the town, so we need that information. We've had a lot of instances in the past where the cleaning hasn't been maybe up to certain standards or is just performed by anybody in town.
1:29:57 By having that information on file with the town, we can contact the cleaning services if there are any regulatory changes, if there are any health order issues or challenges that we have in the future, or any requirements necessary to protect the public in the event of any further outbreaks, like similar to what we have with COVID and the changes we made there. The other thing we want to do in conjunction with this review of our administration is to
1:30:24 Revisit all increases in occupancy requests. I'll say the town had a very open policy to that process before, and if someone requested it, we would just look at if there are any egregious challenges to providing additional increase in occupancy, and if there were not, we would grant them. We're going to flip that a little bit and try to tighten that up to say that
1:30:49 Everyone fits the standard mold unless there are mitigating circumstances that that particular unit has. So it's not just a simple desire for more people. It is that this unit is larger than most, has more bedrooms than most, those types of things that could provide a reason to increase the occupancy. So we will be reviewing that process as part of this. We also, talking to our operators, they had a desire to
1:31:19 Provide more educational materials, you know, code of conduct, that type of stuff that could be provided to every person that comes up to rent a unit so they kind of get a general sense of what our expectations are of them as they visit our community and just really how they should conduct themselves in those processes. That's, you know, semi-effective but I think people, there's some degree of people that want to know the rules so they can follow them and I think it'll be helpful for that.
1:31:50 I'm going to say tougher areas is with regard to penalties. We have a goal with all of our disciplinary action is to encourage operators to remain within regulations, right? That's the purpose. It's not to inflict pain and suffering on folks, but really to get compliance, to get adherence to the rules, to get people that are going to follow through. We kind of broke down our issues into two. We have the sort of operational or minor variances where
1:32:20 We can have either code compliance or other issues that may be brought up, condition of the property, things that need to be addressed. And so the town would make the operator owner, certified properties owner aware of the issues and request that they make those adjustments, correct those corrective actions. And no sort of penalties, no fines, nothing would be incorporated in that at that time. And penalties don't come into play.
1:32:50 Unless the operator does not respond, right? That's where it starts to become a problem. And so we give them 30 days to respond. If they don't respond in 30 days, then we can provide incentive through the form of some fines to be responsive. And those fines can continue. After a 45-day notice, we would have their license suspended until the problems are resolved. So it's definitely an escalation of response.
1:33:18 And again, this is born out of challenges that my team has faced with enforcement in the past and not having enough teeth in the program. So this is really, I think, a soft approach that encourages compliance. And then if you refuse to comply, it has definitely rapid expansion. The other thing in penalties was major violations of conduct. And so in that particular area, this is more the egregious elements that I'm hoping everybody
1:33:46 Really tries to avoid, especially with this process. I will say in these elements, there is an immediate suspension of the ability to rent for three months. So that's fairly significant. That's a couple of key things. It's obviously not a broad brush approach. There are some items that, again, critical to the proper function of the program.
1:34:14 Critical to sometimes life safety and just really addresses some of our repeat offenders, if you will. First and foremost is on the audit side and this is important because we have a lot of our, we do a lot of audits through the process I'm about to cover here in a minute about updated fees and certified properties. We will expand that process.
1:34:34 And we really end up with two different directions that audits typically take. They are educational. Someone did not understand the rules and regulations, and they weren't following them or they weren't remitting properly. And then there are the people that just don't report all their revenue. And so those are the ones that we would come down on the hardest because those are the ones that are cheating the system. Our enforcement efforts, I always say, are more about
1:35:02 Leveling the playing field for the people that will follow the rules than it is about hammering down on those that are not. But in this particular case, if you're caught underreporting your revenues, we will put you in park for three months. And that's an important aspect, I think, for everyone to understand that it's really a zero-tolerance policy on that because it's important. Remodeling construction without a required building permit.
1:35:27 Thank you.
1:35:57 And then the three strikes rule, so operator just continues to have minor violations, they just continue to be a problem operator, which unfortunately we have a few of those, then we would basically address that as an issue for the property owner to kind of be put in part for a bit. Now this isn't one that's, it's going to be fairly egregious. All of these are determined to be egregious acts that would sort of bring about
1:36:27 This level of adjustment. But they are there at our disposal should that become necessary. And, you know, we talked about there's really this ongoing concern. There can be an initial suspension earned for the first occurrence, but that can actually escalate. It can go further. And so we'd ride it in such a way that, you know, you can earn pauses in your ability to rent for a longer period of time if you so warrant it.
1:36:56 And then finally in the section of fees. So our fees are fairly low currently for administering the program. And it's because we've addressed it in the time it takes for staff to perform the function of issuing a certificate to the property. That is how it was determined. Fees by the town are determined to be what it takes for us to perform those.
1:37:23 Services, and in this case it was calculated on the amount of time it takes to issue a permit. It does not include any of the activity as far as monitoring, enforcement, collection, all of the other fundamental aspects associated with managing short-term rentals. And so in this process we sort of re-evaluated those expenses and those costs.
1:37:47 And I won't read through them in detail, but they're laid out in the staff report is exactly what we intended to do. We also are incrementing staff here. We wanted to add one full-time staff, and this would be dedicated to audits. And then we have an existing part-time staff for enforcement. We wanted to add a secondary staff for enforcement that's part-time as well. And that's because when someone's not there while we're open every day, we get questions that come in we want to have sort of an overlap of.
1:38:17 of staff with the ability to address questions that may come up and responses from people that we've reached out to. So all in on that, the total cost of administration is about $900,000. And we would need, based upon the 3,600 units that exist there today, roughly an annual fee of $250.
1:38:41 So that is what the fee schedule when we implement this will be coming to council as and associated with that. So to add all these elements, that requires a major rewrite of the municipal code, sections three and five, to basically strip out all the TOT references and TOT certificate references and incorporate certified property language as well as specific elements that we've talked about.
1:39:11 Here tonight. And so we are targeting to bring the first reading of those municipal code edits to town council on February 21st. In the staff report, I falsely believed I needed 15 days between the first and second reading. And Andy corrected my understanding. So we are actually going to bring the second reading forward on March the 6th, first council meeting that we can after that.
1:39:38 And then after the second reading, there will be a 30-day required waiting period for implementation. Once that is implemented, those new rules and regulations will be in place for all operators, both those currently operating and the folks that are hoping to be operating soon. So we also wanted to kind of point to the fact that this rules and regulations aspect of our certified properties work
1:40:08 Is also what will allow us to terminate the moratorium if the council chooses to do so. And then we would look to run those two. It requires the same level of, I think, ordinance update. So it's the same. We would run that in conjunction with our municipal code updates. So the timing of the moratorium lifting.
1:40:32 It could be as soon as early April when the 30-day period of time expires past our March 6 second reading. So I will pause there and see if there are any questions about this process. Thank you, Rob. Any questions from Council? I have a couple questions. How many employees are on the revenue team? So right now we have a revenue accountant who's sort of the lead. We have two revenue specialists and an enforcement.
1:41:02 Part-time employee. So we would go to three revenue specialists, two part-time enforcement activity, enforcement and one revenue accountant. A portion of my time is included in that as well as I help with all audits, not audits, but any challenging issues. Okay, and then the total cost of the salary for all of those employees with benefits is $400,000 approximately?
1:41:30 That's correct. And again, that's using just a small portion of mine and then not all of the revenue specialists that I currently have because they some aspect of the work and again, this is based on focusing work on STR. Some of them are working on opening other businesses, service businesses and that stuff in town. So I carved one of them out and then we added the rest of that, but that's correct. Okay. Thank you. And then I had a question about owners who clean their own
1:41:59 STR units. Would they just be able to list themselves as the cleaners? They could, yeah. I think in each of these cases we referenced that the owner who was engaged in either 24-hour contact or the cleaning aspects could continue to do so. Okay. Thank you. So, Rob, in layperson's language, should the council vote to proceed with this item, the expiration date of the moratorium
1:42:31 You mentioned early April, and the staff reports this is April 22nd. Can we get some clarity on that, please? Yes. That references my previous thought that I needed 15 days between the first and second reading, which meant that the second reading would not occur until, I think it would be March, is it 21st or 20th? March 20th.
1:42:52 And so if that second reading occurred on March 20th, 30 days after that would land on April 20th, which is a Saturday, so we went to April 22nd, which is the Monday. But after this was created, we realized we could do it a little bit quicker, and so we elected to do so. So what would that date be? April 8th, rather. April 8th, that's the day after my birthday. Okay, we'll take it.
1:43:19 You just told your birthday to everyone. Now we're going to torment you. Well, I like cookies and cakes, and I have a list. John, I will also reference, these are all best-case scenarios. If there are any challenges, and challenges can result in the municipal code changes not being ready, there being some edits that go from first reading to second reading, if you have any of those of significance, you have to conduct a first reading again, which we could delay that.
1:43:49 I think all in all, hitting that 22nd would be sort of the far end, which just gives us one meeting of gap of support. Well, I think what matters to the public is that we are now, if we move forward with this, we're starting to create an environment of certainty. And so people, investors, people buying, selling, we're starting to get a schedule in place people can make some decisions about, which I think will be helpful to everybody concerned.
1:44:19 That's my only question. I'm interested in the public comment. Yes. I would say greater certainty. Certainty sounds really, I wouldn't use that word, certainty. Greater certainty. Greater certainty. Some more transparency. I don't know. Certainty sounds definite. All right. So with that, could I have a show of hands?
1:44:40 Thank you so much. Thank you.
1:45:11 So please come forward. Mr. Morris. Good evening. John Morris. I was the chair of the short-term rental advisory committee, and I was also on the subcommittee that worked with Rob and his crew on the certified properties program. I won't need five minutes. I'll make it quick. Great program. Really tightens things up.
1:45:33 I'm really hoping this can get approved tonight. As Rob alluded to, most of the things he said, this is going to provide better communication between the owner and the town, creates more accountability on the owner's side, which is good, provides for more standardization and a higher bar of safety throughout the STR community, which is also good. Two things I think are most important is it, A, is going to hopefully provide a better experience for all of our visitors.
1:46:02 Which is something we all want in business. We want them coming back. We want them to have a good time and enjoy themselves. And equally important for me is I think that also this is going to help create a little bit more cohesiveness between locals and visitors. I'm hoping that what this program does is it sort of eliminates some of the nuisances that short-term rentals can create for locals and some of the inconveniences for residents, loud parties.
1:46:27 Trash and things like that. So let's hope that by getting this program together, having the fine structure be a little more robust and everything tightened up a little bit, that that works because we all want to live in harmony together and we need to make a living too. So anyway, I would ask that you all consider approving this process, this certified properties program tonight so we can get moving and hopefully get the moratorium lifted sooner than later. Thanks for your time. Thank you.
1:46:57 If there's no one else in the room, then we will go to comments online. Dave, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes, I'm also in agreement with everything just said. I just have a question about the timing. You guys were able to enact the moratorium immediately. Why is it that you're not able to lift the moratorium immediately? Why there need to be two readings plus 30 days since that process did not occur in implementing the moratorium?
1:47:29 Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other comments? Hang on. Can we get a response from the town attorney on that? Is that possible? Well, certainly. I'd be happy to address that. The shorter answer is that that's how the law works. So the moratorium statute says you can do it immediately, right away. But to terminate a moratorium, you don't do it immediately right away. It takes adoption of an ordinance using the regular process, which means it has to come to the council twice, plus 30 days. That's just how the law works. Thank you.
1:48:00 Is there, are there any other comments online? Oh, okay. I thought there were more than one. Sorry. Thank you for that clarification. Appreciate it. Of course. Absolutely. So next, it is time for the council to have a discussion. Does anyone have any thoughts or any? Well, I certainly want to hear from Amanda and Chris because you guys were representatives on that. But just going, I'll just start by, I attended all the meetings and I think they were enormously productive. I obviously want to thank all the members of the committee.
1:48:30 For the work that they did to make this go as smoothly and as quickly as it did in a very tricky environment. A couple observations. I think that one of the things that it was so interesting to hear was I think sort of a consensus of the committee to we're not going to get into the caps business. We're not going to go.
1:48:50 With the most draconian methods that I think most people were afraid of. But instead there was kind of a consensus around let's try some other approaches, more creative things first. And I think that that's what's reflected in the recommendations coming from this. And I think that that is a really important thing. And I think what John Morris just said about we have to cohabitate. We have to, we have a limited housing stock.
1:49:14 We don't have room to expand. And I think to take an initial approach like this makes a lot of sense. I think that the Certified Property Program goes a long way to do that. I hear from constituents who are living in long-term rental condominium complexes, and they have no recourse when the nuisances get out of hand and people can't work and they can't get to their jobs, they can't do the things that they're doing.
1:49:42 So I think this is a very good step forward, but I very much look forward to hearing from you guys about your thoughts on this. Me first? Okay. Well, I guess I feel that this 9.2 is also tied to 9.3, so I wasn't quite sure when to bring up my feelings about it. But you saying, like, oh, the committee didn't go with the draconian measures of implementing caps, I really feel that we were unable to...
1:50:11 Have the meat of the discussion about that because the committee was intimidated and threatened. And honestly, I feel like we're rushing through this process. And my parents always taught me you rush through something and you usually have to do it twice. So my feelings are the BAE finalized report
1:50:39 Came out after the STR committee put together their recommendations. I don't feel that these recommendations were discussed in depth or in detail at all. And I would be in support of having our town staff look over these recommendations and bring it to us. We are public officials and, you know, people can threaten me, people can intimidate me, but...
1:51:07 I ran for office for a reason, and I'm going to stand up for all the people who are not able to come to Suite Z on Wednesday nights at 4 p.m. And so I just, I feel very differently than you, John, and I know that volunteers on the STR committee did their best, but I personally feel that we were not able to have an open, honest conversation because of threats and intimidation. So I would
1:51:35 Ask that we put it on our town staff and on the council to make those hard choices that, you know, was maybe a very big ask of certain community members. Those are my feelings. Anybody else or I should go. I will talk about agenda item 9.2 only at this point. And so for the certified properties program,
1:52:05 I do feel that this is long overdue and it does address many of the challenges that community members have shared about living in our town. I think that it could have gone farther. I'm glad that we are collecting at least the amount of funds that will cover our nut as a community.
1:52:37 At least the $400,000 of like hard costs. I do think that there are additional costs and burdens on the town staff from short-term rentals that could have been included as well. But that said, I feel like this program is long overdue and I feel good about this agenda item. And so I would recommend that we
1:53:05 You know, move forward with asking staff to come back to us with the ordinance. So that's where I am. I don't know if I went too far by going, you know, and saying what I think we should do because. No, I think, I mean, that's, I'm in concurrence with that. I think with this item, I think it's, this is baseline and this is a place to start. And so I'm supportive of moving forward with this and then we'll get to the other items in the next item.
1:53:32 You know, and I do think it's worth mentioning that the town is very serious about collecting its TOT, and I hope, I think that Rob Patterson made that very clear, and I think you've, you know, the community has seen that when we get these cases in front of us where it is really egregious, you know, actually defrauding the town, that we mean business. You know, this is a very important
1:54:00 Source of revenue for our town. And now I think our staff will have all the means necessary in order to accomplish that goal. So that feels important. So this doesn't require a formal motion, or does it, Dan? I mean, sort of my impression is that if we could just have consensus. If you have a motion, though, just based on the dialogue, that would be helpful. Okay. Clear direction to staff. There's an outline of one in the.
1:54:30 Staff report in terms of proceeding forward to implement and to bring back an ordinance implementing the Certified Property Program. Having clear direction would be good. Okay. Thank you. Yeah, I'm prepared to make a motion. I know, Sarah, do you have anything you want to add to this? Okay, so I would move that the Town Council advance the recommendation of the SDR Advisory Committee to establish a Certified Properties Program to address safety, penalties, and fees as outlined.
1:55:01 Direct staff to make municipal code edits to support these administrative changes and bring these back to the council as soon as is practical. Okay. Do we have a second? I think I can second that because you didn't mention the moratorium. Yeah. All right. So a motion from Councilmember Wentworth. But just to clarify, if we move forward with this, it sets in motion the repeal of the moratorium. And I just want to make sure that you understand it, that that's...
1:55:33 That's what we're doing. I mean, I would say if tonight, if we were voting on lifting the moratorium tonight, my vote would be no. So that being said, I'm in support of the certified properties and moving forward with that. But if we were bringing a vote tonight to lift the moratorium, my vote would be no. So the motion on the floor doesn't commit the council to rescinding the moratorium. It just tells us to bring...
1:56:00 These items back to the Council at the next meeting. And I anticipated that there would be, there would have to be separate agenda items and separate consideration for the rescission of the moratorium and the adoption of the Certified Properties Ordinance. So you could certainly say yes to one and say no to the other at that point. Thank you, Andy. Okay, well, I'm going to look for some clarity on that because it's my, the way this was presented and the way you presented that we were doing the
1:56:28 The updates to the municipal code that these things will be going in parallel. So I'd like some- So what was proposed and what was in the staff report was if we can, moving forward, the code amendments for the certified property. That has to follow a certain timeline. We talked early on in some of the committee work going, once we have that in there, it can really tighten up a lot of the enforcement levels. The opportunity would be to consider that.
1:56:53 Lifting of the moratorium under that same timeframe. They are separate ordinances. You have a separate ordinance to lift the moratorium. You have a separate ordinance to implement the certified property program. So if they come together, then they would be on the same timeline. So our concern was if we did the certified property program and it took longer or the moratorium was lifted earlier.
1:57:20 You would have two sets of regulations for a period of time that would create confusion. Okay, but the point is that we do not, I mean, clarify this, we do not have an agenda item this evening that specifically addresses the lifting of the moratorium. That is correct. It's not on, because we need to get direction on this if we're going to bring it forward. The recommendation would be to bring them in parallel so we don't end up with two different.
1:57:44 So when does staff anticipate bringing back an agenda item that we can vote on that has to do with the moratorium? The same time that we bring back the certified property ordinance as proposed so they would both be coming back. And so you would be dealing with certified properties, first reading, walk through that, do you want to do it, vote yay or nay. You would have a separate agenda item, separate ordinance saying this is the action to take to lift the moratorium.
1:58:13 And that's February, so that's February 21st. Or the, yeah, that's the date if it's all ready to go, that would be the date it would hit your calendar. Okay, so, right, so that's. The moratorium is not before this evening. So the question of the moratorium is going to come back to us later. Okay, cool. All right, just want to make sure we're all clear about that. So we did have a motion and a second. I see, I see. Bringing back the Certified Properties Program Ordinance. Yes.
1:58:41 So I see no need to amend my motion. Correct. Okay. And no need to amend the second, so. Correct. So, Jamie, could we please have roll call? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser? Yes. All right. We are now moving on to item 9.3, and this is to receive information and provide direction on the short-term
1:59:10 Rental Advisory Committee recommendations. And I believe Mr. Holler will be taking this item forward. And could we take a five-minute break? Yes, absolutely. If you need a break, we'll definitely do that. Thanks. All right. Mr. Holler, take it away. Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser. The next item, again, is dealing with the set of recommendations that came from the advisory committee.
2:04:55 We're looking at short-term rentals. There's four areas we're going to touch on. We'll be looking for direction as we walk through these various options that were discussed as ways of more focus in this case on dealing with housing and some short-term rental support in areas where we may see transition from short-term to long-term housing for local residents.
2:05:17 When we talk about long-term housing, keep in mind often that might be like a six months, nine months. It's not necessarily always meaning multiple years, but we have that discussion as well. The four areas that we touched on, and I'll walk through these and come back and you can address them individually. One is a funding source for housing programs that is more dedicated in that area. That would be a ballot measure. That would be a tax measure. There was a couple options we looked at. I'll touch on those.
2:05:47 We talked about a couple different rental subsidy programs, three different levels of one, two are very similar. We'll walk through those. On that one, I will note, one of them is placemates or leasing to locals. There was a presentation made to the chamber. That presentation is in your packet. It does provide background and information how something of that nature could be implemented. There's a housing downtown down payment purchase program.
2:06:15 This was one focused more on that long-term issue. How do we get people into housing? Actually, it's an ownership base, so hopefully there's a longer-term securing of secure housing for our employees and workforce here in the community. The other element, attachments in your department, the last one is dealing with a zoning designation. We've looked at some possible changes to the RMF-2 zoning.
2:06:43 We'll touch on that. I think there's been some challenges in just explaining the purpose and why for that and what it means and doesn't mean. There's a map attached that walks through that as well. And then also we did include, it was referenced, the BAE economic study that was presented. The full one of those did go to the last meeting of the committee. It was delayed getting the last one out.
2:07:10 On December 12th, they spent a fair, a good amount of time actually discussing the draft report, and there's a lot of discussion that went through that. I think that helped firm up some of the recommendations that were in the final report that we did not spend a lot of time on at the last advisory committee meeting. The author, main author of the report, Aaron Nassane, is on the call this evening if you have questions there, but also down the road if you want to look more detail at that. He's more than willing to participate in the future.
2:07:38 So I think one of the key elements when we got into this, we dealt with the certified property program. That was a good discussion at the committee level and strong support for having stronger regulatory frameworks in place and we're moving forward accordingly. The other element was, as we talked a lot about the idea of how do you invest in short-term current housing to get long-term housing out of it, I think there's a clear recognition that one of the main issues was funding.
2:08:08 We see that in our own Housing Now program. The town has committed a substantial amount of funding over the last five, six years now, well over $30 million going into housing projects and programs. We see that of having close to 220 units kind of on the books and several under construction. So we've made a significant commitment, but having a dedicated funding source going forward that it would...
2:08:34 Add a lot of strength to the programs recommended and to the current programs the town is currently implementing. The two areas that we really spoke to regarding the funding source was two different ballot measure potentials. One would be an increase in TOT revenue, and the recommendation was not to exceed 2%, so you could go one, one and a half, two, or half, whatever.
2:09:03 Choice you'd want to make for a ballot question to go forward on that. And I will note the other driver for a local funded program is because we can target different income levels. Almost all of the state and federal money target 80%. Area median income households are lower. There's a few programs you can get to a 120, but it's a few and far between. The towns program, if it's town revenues,
2:09:32 You can define that program, set a different income level, set, you know, we look at workforce, we tend to talk regional, Mono Inyo County. We do have a lot of people transferring those areas and stuff. And so making sure that we're building these programs in a way that can hit a group of our employees in the community, our workforce, and others, it just, it's...
2:09:56 They don't qualify for a lot of the subsidized housing, but incomes aren't a level for market rate housing. So balancing that off with local revenues is one of the tools to get to drive those types of decisions and those types of programs. The two items that were discussed, again, an increase in the transient occupancy tax, you'll hear, say, TOT, or a gross receipts tax that was targeted more just to the short-term rental,
2:10:25 You take a look at the gross receipts. You'd walk and see how you define those. The differentials, a little bit on those. The TOT, it's a pass-through. To the owner, it's set. You collect it. It's calculated on total revenues generated, which that includes like cleaning fees and other things of that nature. There's no deduct from that.
2:10:48 A gross receipts tax, you had to define what's in that gross receipts. If that's just rental income, you could have those types of discussions and look at that. Again, the recommendation, if you look at gross receipts, not to exceed 1.5% was the recommendation from the committee. Regardless of the choice there, there's other discussions and points that would need to happen. If you have a preference for one or the other, we can bring it back. Are you looking at a general?
2:11:17 The other thing is just the timing of the development of a ballot measure.
2:11:48 Oh, man, I just dropped. 88 days prior to the election, so you're back. I think the latest is August 9th that you could have to get it to the county, so ideally it'd be back before you June, July to work through those processes. And August, you know, that drop-dead date to be able to actually have a ballot measure. Andy can assist with some of that process and some of the writing and some of the elements that have to happen in the process. There's different options you can pursue in how you take a ballot measure forward.
2:12:16 The item before you tonight is more about do you want one, and if you do, do you have a preference between a TOT or a gross receipts-based tax measure, and then we can get into more detail on general, special, et cetera, as we walk through that process. But the key element for the rest of the program was really having a funding source. And so when we talk about rental subsidy programs, there was three generally talked about.
2:12:45 One is that leasing to locals, the placemates program that presented to the chamber. I think the benefit to that, there's some experience locally or regionally with that. Truckee has that program implemented. I think South Lake Tahoe area has a similar program in place. It has a, I'll say, relatively higher just admin cost component to it, whether it be shorter or less if we get it in-house or rent with the chamber or other organization. The nice part about it is kind of,
2:13:14 Baked and ready to go. So if you want to do a pilot program on a short-term basis for let's subsidize to get people into a rental program, that one is set up, ready to go. So it'd be a fairly easy implementation process. And if you want to do a pilot program in the PowerPoint, they had a one-year cost of about $400,000. We could actually take that out of the Housing Now program this year and be able to fund something of that nature.
2:13:43 And then you can see, does it work? Is it a program you like, don't like? How does it work with the community? A very similar one was talked about at the committee level, looking at setting base rents and providing subsidies for that, encouraging people to go in. The details of that would take more time to flesh out. I think it's very similar to the other one. So bottom line on either of those, you're looking at how do we subsidize existing housing owners.
2:14:11 Be it a short-term rental or not, depending on how you want to structure it. How do we subsidize them to say, yes, I will rent out my unit, I will rent out my room, I will be engaged in this, or a subsidy of X, and the program would walk through that. So if there's an interest in doing one of those, we can definitely idea with being back one and have that discussion. A third component, took off of the program in Vail called Vail Indeed, where
2:14:39 They actually buy a deed restriction on a unit and it's there for the life of the property, if you will. The idea here was a shorter one. Let's say you wanted to provide a subsidy for somebody who's willing to commit a short-term rental for five years or seven years or 10 years into a rental pool and provide a subsidy to encourage that to happen. They're giving up potential revenue generated out of the short-term market, but you're offsetting that in a long-term component to create.
2:15:08 Not necessarily secure housing for the long term, but definitely a good period of time where someone may be able to get established in the community and move into other types of housing. So the question on that one would be, is there a preference to move forward with a pilot project with one of these? The other option, of course, could be let's wait and see if we get new funding, do it at that point, but you could move forward on a smaller scale on a pilot program.
2:15:36 Underneath a rental program. The third, and I'll come back to each of these for direction from the council, but a housing down payment purchase program. This here was really focused on how do we target that missing middle folks, households in the community who really have a desire to have ownership.
2:15:56 In their housing. They're looking for longer-term, secure, stable housing. They're not at the whim of a landlord, so to speak, process. The idea here, again, was looking at how do you subsidize the cost of that housing down. There's a couple different programs out there that work. We've provided some sample information of how they can work. It's a subsidized rate down.
2:16:20 And depending on the program, you turn around, when the house is sold, there's dollars that come back to the program, so it can recycle, if you will, the dollars going through the future. There is a phase of the parcel that has looked at a similar process. They've actually had some discussions on that, that this program could support, and it's targeting up to 200% of area immediate income households.
2:16:45 This would take more work in terms of getting the program and the guidelines and making sure we're lining up with lenders and the requirements they have when they go into these types of programs and the funding side. So it's similar to our bridge program. The difference in the bridge program we do is we buy a unit, we actually just reduce the cost, put somebody into that, and then it has a deed restriction at that income level going forward. That would be an option not to have necessarily.
2:17:14 A lower income level or whether it's tied to the 200% or not would be one of the program discussions. How much of that down payment assistance comes back or shared appreciation or shared loss, if you will, on some units as that moves forward. So again, if we want to do that program, given the work of putting it together and the funding source, the recommendation may be to wait until we get additional funding in.
2:17:40 We had looked at maybe a pilot one there, but you'd probably do one or two loans is all. So again, we could do something that way, but looking at that, having a stronger funding source may make more sense in terms of moving that forward. If it's a priority, we continue to work through and get the guidelines done and how the program would work and make sure that that's well articulated and put out and then be able to move forward. The last one, and it was dealing with
2:18:09 Residential multifamily to zoning districts. The existing district is quite wide. The recommendation was to look at a bifurcation of that district. And this was brought forward initially when we first put the moratorium in and we began this discussion. There was a significant amount of public comment related to particular areas in the community saying,
2:18:31 This just doesn't make sense here. We run a lot of our properties almost like a hotel almost or something of that nature. It's set up for that truly transient activity. It's not set up well for living, if you will, and there's a lot of the debate and discussion. A lot of that was the portal area around Canyon up toward Eagle and those areas. So we did look at that, and it probably makes some sense to take a look at that.
2:18:56 Does it make sense to break up our RMF2 zoning? The other piece to that is looking at it from if you're looking at rental subsidies and you're looking at down payment assistance, it's not that you could necessarily preclude, but you may want to focus that in particular areas. Do we build neighborhoods? Do we look at areas, frankly, are more affordable by age or by locations, et cetera, that you look at in terms of working with those types of subsidy programs?
2:19:26 Thank you so much.
2:19:56 It kind of followed Nolan's plate who just got a new job and he's trying to find somebody behind him to implement these types of items. So just the workload element of that one would be a little bit challenging if we're moving all of these together at once just in terms of time and effort that could be done there. The other thing, again, we did not spend a lot of time at the last committee meeting.
2:20:19 On the BAE report, looking at some of the options that were laid out in there. Some are similar to some of these types of programs that were there. So I'd like to, Mayor Pro Tem, come back and really ask the council in terms of general comments, and then we'd like to get direction on the front end, just your general thoughts and comments and things, but come back in and say, from a ballot tax measure, do you have a preference?
2:20:50 One, do you want to do one? Secondly, if you do, of the two presented, do you have a preference? Or if you want to come up with a third, that'd be your prerogative. Take comment on that. The committee has spent time on those. Give us some direction and then walk through each of those instead of trying to craft it all at once. So I wanted to write a broad overview. And then walk through each one. What's your preference to move these forward or not?
2:21:16 This is now recommendations coming to the council to work through. So I would say a general comment on it and then begin walking one at a time and then taking public comment accordingly as we go through each item. I'd be glad to answer any general questions from the council as well. Sounds good. So does anybody on the council have any general questions? I have a question about rental subsidies. Is there anywhere in the BAE report where they suggest
2:21:48 Rental subsidies in this list of 30 or 22, 24 suggestions. There is item 22 says establish additional dedicated local funding sources for housing programs. But I don't, unless I'm missing, which is entirely possible. Just wondering if anyone found that. Let me, if Aaron is on the Zoom there, Aaron can speak to that.
2:22:19 I know there's programs discussed in general, but Aaron, the question was, was there specific discussions on a rental subsidy program? Hi there. There weren't recommendations as part of this report specific to a rental subsidy program. I've evaluated similar programs in other communities. They can be of value in terms of helping to open up existing housing resources for full-time occupancy. In general, I view these types of rental housing subsidy programs really as
2:22:50 Thank you so much.
2:23:21 Any other general questions before we start to go through item by item? I just did have a question for Aaron. You know, when you gave your presentation on the 12th, there weren't a lot of recommendations at the time. There are, as Sarah just said, you know, upwards of 24. There are 24. Could you do two things?
2:23:52 Tell us whether any of the findings that came after the presentation on the 12th that were unique to our community that caused you to think about the recommendations differently. So were there any findings about our community that made us different? And then secondly, of the recommendations, are there any that you would strongly recommend that we consider in the future? I mean, obviously we're
2:24:22 We're on a path now, but this was a lot of good work, and I just want to make sure we aren't missing anything. Well, I appreciate that. I'll start with your first question, which is, was there anything that I observed as part of the analysis that really made Mammoth Lakes unique? And I think there are a variety of items. You know, the one observation that I think really rises to the stop is recognizing that you're a
2:24:51 Destination Economy. You rely on the tourism industry to support much of your community from an economic and fiscal standpoint. It's important that you maintain the infrastructure that you need to continue that type of economic activity. And one of the key pieces of that infrastructure is your tourist accommodations inventory. And when looking at the distribution of that inventory between hotel motel units and short-term rentals,
2:25:21 It shows a strong reliance on short-term rental to provide tourism accommodations and overnight accommodations. And so that puts the town of Mammoth Lakes in a position where if you wanted to try and restrict short-term rentals aggressively in order to encourage the creation of long-term housing, you would be limiting your tourist accommodations inventory in a way that could have significant economic impacts.
2:25:50 The recommendations were tailored in a way that tried to strike a balance there and really call that to the forefront. The recommendations that are provided are intended to identify options that the town council may want to consider as part of a balanced strategy. I think I opened my comments to the advisory committee by describing that
2:26:18 There is no one way to go about SDR regulation. There's no way to go about housing policy. And so I recommend that the town council look through the recommendations, identify options that you think are a good fit for the strategy that you'd like to pursue for the priorities that you're identifying, recognizing that the recommendations are also based on what other communities are doing and approaches that appear to be successful in other areas.
2:26:47 Okay. Thank you. So I guess... Could I ask, could you follow up on Chris's second question, which was, is there anything you would strongly recommend? Right. You know, some of the recommendations that I do strongly recommend that town is starting to implement with a certified properties program, which are some of the basic sort of process improvements that can give you...
2:27:26 As a starter, much better information on the scope of the short-term rental sector, how often those properties are being used, and give you some better tools there to monitor the industry at large. We have seen caps be fairly effective in other communities in terms of providing a little bit of certainty to the hotel industry that demand will be there for their units moving forward.
2:27:56 And to, you know, insert some doubt in the second home market that prospective second home buyers can generate income off of the property that they're looking at. We've also seen the one-year wait period as being effective to reduce pressure on the housing market resulting from 1031 exchange transactions, which are essentially
2:28:28 Purchases of residential real estate that is a commercial exchange of property. And in order to do that, you have to be able to demonstrate that you can generate commercial revenue off the property. And so it functions to create a disconnect between sort of the commodification of the housing stock and some of those investment actors. Thank you. Okay, thanks. Thank you so much for being here.
2:29:00 Just one question of that. I mean, these... I'm sorry. The kinds of things you're talking about, Aaron, they don't have to take place within the context of a moratorium, correct? Not necessarily, no. Okay. Thank you. All right. So now we are going to go through item by item. And the first item is about finding a revenue source.
2:29:30 to fund housing programs. So I think first it would make sense to have the council have the opportunity to ask any clarifying questions of staff about this specific item, which is just, you know, would we consider a tax measure to be able to fund some of the expansion of our Housing Now program?
2:29:54 And our current Housing Now program. And if so, you know, so do you have any questions, I guess, really, I just leave it at that, other questions. I don't have any questions of staff, but I would like to hear from Chris and Amanda about how you would represent, you know, your sense of the conclusions that came out of the committee, the advisor committee. Was there consensus? Was there disagreement? What did you take out of those discussions? Where did the committee kind of land on these things?
2:30:21 And on the first item? Yes, just on the revenue measure. Okay. I feel that we heard a lot of public comment throughout the process that we have to find the revenue somewhere. One of the challenges, if we were to go with a TOT tax, so that would be on all properties, which many people felt was more fair.
2:30:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:31:22 The committee didn't really weigh in on that.
2:31:51 When we talk about whether we could consider something like a 1.5% tax on gross receipts of short-term rentals, that felt to be less popular, I don't mean popular, I mean less appetizing to the committee. Amanda, I would love to know if you think that's what you heard. Kind of, I guess. I don't know. I guess I feel like the pros and cons were the opposite, where it's like, well, if we're just adding that onto STR owners,
2:32:23 You know, STR owners make up, I think it was like 80, is it 70 or 80% of the TOT is paid by STR owners. So, 79? Okay. So that, you know, that's not placed fairly on all payers of TOT, but that, you know, it is more hidden from customers in that STRs would probably
2:32:49 And then the opposite of, you know.
2:33:17 It's not fair because hotels wouldn't be paying it, but it's not visible. And then one other point that I think it was Chairman Morris said was that on $1,000, a 2% increase in TOT is $20. Do I have that right, Mr. Morris? I don't want to misrepresent you. So it's just, you know, to keep things in perspective.
2:33:43 Those were some of the main points that, and thank you for the clarification because those are good clarifications, Amanda. That's very helpful. Thank you both. Thank you. Any? Oh, go ahead. Can I make the comment that this is inherently hypothetical because we don't know if the voters are going to pass either of these? And I just think this is not a burden in the hand and I have concerns about that. That being said, Sarah, I mean, I feel like so far.
2:34:13 The recommendations from the STR committee are to change the $25 annual fee to $250 and make the owners comply with some new regulations on safety and 24-hour contacts and things like that. So I'm not convinced that that's going to tip the scales. I'm not convinced that that's enough.
2:34:40 And so that's where my feelings of we've rushed through this and I think it's like a Band-Aid on a gushing wound. So that's where I kind of feel like these recommendations should be looked at in further detail. Okay, well, Madam Mayor Pro Tem, how do you want to do public comment? So I was about to go to that because I think we're really just talking about this.
2:35:05 So unless there are any other questions because we were tipping into deliberation. So are we good too? So could I just have a show of hands of how many people in the room plan to make public comment on this item? So far I just see two, three, four. And then how about online? Two, three. So I think just because there are four of these and there will probably be comments on each, I'd ask everybody.
2:35:33 We'll start with the people in the room. Please come up. We'll ask Jamie to set the timer for three minutes. Let's make sure that we stay focused on the item at hand and we don't go into the other areas so we can stay very focused. And then also, if somebody has made a point that you agree with, if you could mention that you agree with them.
2:35:59 And then just make your points that are distinct. That would be super helpful with making sure we're able to get through these and everyone has a chance to speak. Thanks. So please come to the podium. Good evening again. John Morris from the STR committee. I would strongly encourage an increase in TOT. Obviously, you have the discretion of how much that might be.
2:36:31 A 1% increase in TOT would generate approximately $1.5 million to $2.2. A 2% increase would be somewhere between $3.4 and $4.5 million annually. The reason I feel strongly about that, I don't, again, I don't feel that it's right to put this all on the backs of the short-term rental owners. I can tell you from the standpoint of being concerned about what our tax rate is.
2:37:01 When we instituted the T bid, however many years ago, that was a 1% increase at Snow Creek, I have never had a single person contest the T bid cost, not one. So with the guests that we have coming here, and I'm not saying we're trying to gouge anybody, but a 1% or 2% increase on their bill is not very much, and it generates
2:37:24 Something that we desperately need in this town, which is housing. This is what this whole thing is about. It's all about housing and how we fund it. So unless there is another funding mechanism that, and also I think that that will pass with 50%. I'm not a fan of going 67% because
2:37:44 Those are always hard to pass. But I trust the council that they would use the money correctly for housing. And so anyway, I would be in favor of the 2% increase from 13 to 15% with all of those funds going to all housing initiatives. Hopefully the new plans that we have, programs we have in place, and if there are additional funds, those can go into other housing initiatives too. So thank you. Before you go, John, did you say you support a 2% increase in the TOT? What I pushed for on the...
2:38:13 The committee was a 2% increase. So that would give approximately between $3.4 and $4.5 million in additional revenue to the town annually, depending on what our revenues were. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Terry Stelick. I'll agree with John. So I think that we need to go with the 2% TOT.
2:38:44 You know, to say that we're going to go the other way and hide an increase in our rates, you know, one way or the other. If it goes up to 2%, we aren't increasing our rates if we can't, you know. So it kind of goes both ways, but at least the 2% goes across the board and raises more money for what we're trying to do as housing. So to me, I have a concern about just going with a general tax as opposed to a special tax because there has been. There was a fee that was
2:39:14 For housing a long time ago. And that fee was reduced at one point in time quite a while ago because we didn't have a housing issue at that time. So that would be my only concern is if we're just going with a general tax as opposed to a special tax. And so because I truly feel that this is not going to go away. It's going to be an ongoing issue and you need the ongoing funds to be able to deal with it. I have quite a few more comments, but I'll hold them for another time.
2:39:43 Thank you. Hello. Elise Moeckler, local business owner, also a member of the STR committee. Just a quick comment. I actually think this would go forward if the funds are earmarked and you go for the two-thirds vote. I think that the voters are going to want to know that this money is specifically going to go to housing and not just into the general fund. Thank you. Anyone else? David Eichmann, part-time resident. You obviously need a funding source, so you have to choose.
2:40:21 It seems more equitable to increase the TOT. And I would rely on the tourism people as to one or two percent. But that's what I would recommend. Thank you. All right. Oh, here we go. Hello. Good evening. Alex Tamire, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. Just something for consideration. The fire district will be going for a ballot measure in November as well. Traditionally, we have conflicting measures.
2:40:48 They both tend to suffer. We're actually working with the school district. They're moving up in March. I understand these are both very important issues, but just wanted to put that out there. Thank you for your time. Thank you. I think seeing no one else, should we go to online? Rose, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Very good. Thank you.
2:41:11 My name is Rose Perez-Jessen. I'm an STR owner in Villa de los Pinos, which is in the proposed low-priority targeted RMF-2 subzone. I serve as president of VDLP, and I'm a lawyer who graduated from UCLA School of Law.
2:41:25 I bought my VDLP unit on an STR basis via a 1031 exchange in 1999, the year after the town dropped its consideration of using eminent domain to take over our units then for workforce housing. Excuse me, Rose, I'm so sorry to interrupt, but we're talking specifically about... I'm getting there. I've attended each of the advisory committee meetings, and the problem is, you know...
2:41:51 They were mandated with focusing on the STRs in Mammoth. They did not look at other funding sources. The public was specifically told that the committee's hearings, that the committee did not have the authority to consider other funding mechanisms, such as an increase in property taxes, sales taxes, vacant second home taxes, or other taxes to fund its proposed housing programs. As such, the town council should disregard the committee's recommendations to move
2:42:20 Thank you. Thank you.
2:42:34 Sales, property, lodging, real estate transfer, excise taxes can be dedicated sources for community housing efforts. Recommending is a call to action to study a local tax measure to determine correct mechanisms, property versus sales versus tot, to place on ballot with legal analysis necessary. The STR committee did not conduct any such sort of study, and therefore its recommendation on the ballot tax measure is unsupported.
2:43:02 And instead of accepting the committee's recommendation, the town council should commission a study on whether the correct mechanism to fund the proposed housing programs is an increase in property taxes, sales taxes, or other taxes in lieu of further taxes on tot or STR receipts for presentation to voters. STR owners bring substantial revenue to the town in terms of taxes and tourist dollars. STRs did not create the housing problem, nor should they be burdened financially.
2:43:31 Thank you.
2:43:51 Mammoth is not such a market. According to the VA report, the majority of the housing market in Mammoth is for seasonal and occasional use second homes. And studies essentially conclude that the conversion of long-term housing to STR use does not represent a significant market driver in such second home markets. In fact, it was found that STRs are not the primary driver of housing availability and pricing issues in these communities with large numbers of second homes.
2:44:20 Thank you so much. Thank you very much. Yes, thank you. Jamie, do we have other? Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, good evening. Thank you for taking the time to take public comment on each item.
2:44:47 I would like to say that I think we have to remind ourselves that our policies drive our outcome and that we have watched the town really grow the TOT over the years. Sorry about that. And every year the TOT comes in above budget by millions of dollars. So it was one person that would vote on this.
2:45:13 I would see a challenge in approving more TOT for housing when there is excess revenue every year in TOT over your budget that you approve and adopt every year for many years, probably since 2011 or since the threatened bankruptcy. Furthermore, I don't think we want to push more TOT onto the hotels. I think it would behoove us to push more
2:45:43 of more people into hotels and not into short-term rentals. Such a lion's share of our housing stock and our visitor accommodations already. So let's start moving people towards the limelight and towards the new developments for the hotels and start opening up our housing stock for our locals, which has been diminished over the years.
2:46:13 And if that means creating a fund or a fee for short-term rentals, increasing that, then I think that's the right route to go. But again, I feel like I've watched the town have a lot of excess funds over the years in TOT, and they've been able to dedicate that to housing. So I'm not sure I see a need for additional TOT at this time. Thanks. Thank you. Who's next?
2:46:41 Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, good evening. This is Jan Henry. I'm a STR owner who uses her property about 100 days out of the year and also does a seasonal lease for three months each winter. I don't know, well, I'm sure you're aware of it, but there is a measure on the ballot for March with an increase to property taxes to benefit the Mammoth Unified School District, which I support.
2:47:12 And as a second homeowner who visits the town and supports the town, I would support that tax increase to our property taxes. And I feel like that's a fair tax and it's something that would be helpful to the schools, but it also is to help with staff housing for the school district. And I just feel like, I feel like, and I've said it before, I'm going to say it again.
2:47:40 That targeting the STR owners, and I know Amanda Rice doesn't agree, but targeting the STR owners is not the right thing to do. It needs to be a community-wide property tax, and that's, I'm sure it would get passed on the measure if you put it forward, but a small increase on our property taxes would make a huge financial gain for the town for their housing program. Thank you. Thank you.
2:48:09 And that's all the comments on point one. So now it's time for the council to discuss and deliberate. And before we do, could I ask staff to clarify? Is it appropriate to ask staff to clarify about how our funding mechanisms work and about how little property tax?
2:48:31 comes to the Town of Mammoth Lakes? Yeah, the state, yeah, I can do that. The statement on the property tax, like for the school district and ultimately I think the fire district, it's actually a parcel tax. It's a tax on your, each parcel, so it's not actually a property tax from a mill levy or a rate of that. Property tax rates are set by state law. You can do a ballot measure for certain ones as an override. They're very difficult, and Andy could probably speak to more detail on those.
2:48:59 So the actual property tax, we get a very small share of it. I forget the percentage, but the majority of it goes to the county, frankly, and then schools, special districts, et cetera. So a very minor increase in the property tax. If it was actually a property tax rate, it'd have to be a fairly substantial rate to generate the same level of revenues that we're talking about from either of the proposals here.
2:49:24 The other proposals there is a parcel tax, which is different than a property tax because it's per parcel and there's a calculation which each parcel pays which is different commercial or residential depending how they structure it. It's interesting to say that part of it more work. The other side of that mentioned a sales tax. We've done one of those for Measure R, for example, that was passed for recreational purpose. A half cent brings in.
2:49:52 Probably just under $2 million in sales tax revenue, which could be an option. There's ultimately a cap on the maximum amount of sales tax you can levy in a local community, if I remember state law correctly. So there are some other elements that way, but the primary ones looking at here were things that the council could implement from a voter initiative standpoint. The others would take a lot more work in process to put a parcel tax in.
2:50:18 Or you could look at a sales tax side as another option. I think that came up briefly at the committee and was not one they wanted to pursue. But if you want to speak to that, Andy, feel free. So they are different. Thank you. All right. So does anyone have thoughts? May I ask one other question? May I ask one other question? Rob, for business tax licenses, the businesses in town pay a percentage of their gross sales, right?
2:50:50 There's like a baseline rate, and I just paid mine, so I know there's a baseline rate, and then you have to put in your gross sales, and then. You have gross receipts, yes. Uh-huh. Okay. Do STR owners have to do that at this point? Operators do, yes. Operators do, but like a single, if I own one STR, I don't pay. So if you own one STR, and you are the operator of that, so you have a BTC for it, then you would also be required to pay that similar gross receipts. Mm-hmm. Yes.
2:51:19 But if I am contracted through a management company, then they would pay that? That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Thoughts, anyone, about? Yeah, I'll maybe just jump in. I think I'm pleased to hear the consensus from the committee and other folks in the committee that the 2% TOT seems to be a reasonable thing to do. That makes sense to me.
2:51:45 I have had some experience with tax measures in town. It's a very delicate balance when you talk about two-thirds versus a general. One thing I will say is that we have had TOT funds that we've allocated on a year-over-year basis, but the council's aware, maybe some folks weren't aware, that we're heading towards an inflection point with...
2:52:09 The cost of running an organization like this, that within the foreseeable future, we're going to hit a point where there's, that is not something we can count on. So I think the housing thing is not going to go away. That's going to be around for a long time. So I think it's prudent to start putting in a revenue source that's going to help us out with these things. And it was in the Community Housing Action Plan. It was a recommendation.
2:52:30 Appropriate time to consider it and try to bring this thing forward. I think on the one hand for general, I think it would be, it's a lower threshold, it's a lower bar. I think that there is sufficient awareness within the community that housing is a need. And I think that that need's not going to go anywhere. And I think it would be pretty insane if it were to pass, the council would put it to somewhere else. I don't know where else it would go. That's the most pressing need that we've got.
2:52:58 And I think that the other sort of tricky part about doing it as a restricted measure is to write the language in such a way that the town can use it to fund, you know, what programs, what purposes, and you start getting all tangled up in the language of that. I think one of the reasons we've been successful with the TOT we've been able to invest is its general fund. We can be opportunistic with it and we can, council can put it to where it's most needed.
2:53:27 So that my sense at this point is TOT general, but we're not making that decision tonight, but that's what I would offer. Okay. And at 2%. Yeah, so there's the type that we're thinking about. So TOT or gross receipts, the percent, the whether it's for general fund or
2:53:52 Specifically for housing, and that has a different threshold on the ballot. And then finally, one thing we haven't talked about yet, but whether there would be a sunset, because that was something that did come up in the committee. So with those things on the table, do either of you have any thoughts about any of this? Or I can go if you'd rather.
2:54:21 The element on that, a lot of those items, if you have a choice to say we'd like to look at a TOT increase up to 2%, there's some leanings for one of those. This will come back to you and actually give you more time than to dialogue and say, do we want a sunset? Are we good with 2%? Do we want a general or special? Tonight we're trying to, do you want a revenue source?
2:54:43 Here's some choices. If you call out the one and you give some direction, that's helpful. But the idea would be to bring that back and you can have a detailed discussion over the intricacies of that particular tax base. I think if there's a threshold to say, yes, we agree we need revenue, these are viable options. I'm willing to look at this one. If there's other caveats you want to look at, call those out. I think the level of detail you're driving down would be helpful, but you will get another bite at this apple.
2:55:12 Thank you. Can I ask a procedural question? Are we going to be voting on one, two, three, four tonight? I would like to get direction on each of those so we know what to bring back. And we would do that in the form of a vote. Tonight would be helpful. If you want to mix the order up, that's your prerogative. Are you saying we're ranking or we're going number one? Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Voting on number one going, do you want more revenue? Do you want to see a TOT come back?
2:55:42 Yes or no. If you do, yes, great, we'll bring that back. Rental subsidy program, do you want one? If you don't, we don't put one in. If you do, do you want to do a pilot program now or do you want to wait until there's additional revenue or do you want to look at just a small one to start with or there's a couple options in there? So we're looking for those directions so we know what to bring back and begin the work program because this will take time. I'm just going to get out in front of this and say I'm not willing to vote on
2:56:11 One or two without having town staff go back and look at caps and a waiting period. Okay. Yeah, this is an interesting question because we don't have the moratorium is not on the agenda for this evening. Correct. And I have a little bit of a question for Andy. If we're deliberating these other things but there's this thing hanging out in the room, I mean, look, we can, Madam Mayor, we can go through each of these items but understand that
2:56:44 I think it's really important that staff, you get some direction out of this, but we're not, I'm not, I'm waiting to hear this debate. I mean, we're hearing some representation of two of my fellow council members on this. I think that's going to be the most important question because I think it's going to be a tough thing to bring these recommendations back to the community if the council's going to say we want to extend this moratorium for another year. I mean, that's...
2:57:09 That's a big question. So I think, I mean, Madam, we can go through these as an advisory basis and look at these things, but I think we need, staff needs to, we go back to this next meeting, we need to agendize this in a sequential order that's going to make sense. Because right now we're looking at things that I think the committee has recommended. As one Councilmember, I've looked, I think they're reasonable. I think they make sense. I think that we're in a cultural moment here. I think we need to be mindful of that.
2:57:39 Let's go ahead with these things, but I think we need to make sure that this question about the moratorium gets front and center, because otherwise we're going to be wasting everybody's time. Fair enough. Is there consensus even to say that we want staff to pursue looking at a funding mechanism for
2:57:59 Additional? Because these programs, if the subsidy program or the down payment program is going to end up in housing now, we will need a funding mechanism. Is that something that you're comfortable? Because we don't have to make a motion and vote, but staff does need direction in order to be able to come back to us next time with more information. I mean, I'd say I believe that we need a funding source for housing. I mean, we put TOT money into housing, but
2:58:32 It's really expensive to build. I mean, Dan said tonight that the town, the Civic Center, you know, $1,000 a square foot. You know, I don't believe it's that much on our housing now. But, you know, it's expensive to build here. It's expensive to buy here. You know, yeah, we have, we've gotten a lot of unexpected revenue from TOT over the years, and housing is still an issue. So I think having a housing...
2:59:00 A fund for housing would be great. I know that we do put money into housing. It's measure A, right? I'm gonna get that right. Yeah, so we do put money into housing, but it's just never enough. Yeah, I don't know. To me, it feels like it's never enough. It's still a problem. You know, the next phase of the parcel is so expensive. I don't know.
2:59:26 And again, that's only helping people who make 80% of AMI and below. So yeah. I mean. I think that we need funding for housing. And I would like to see staff's recommendations for how to secure that funding. And then I would also like to see staff's recommendations discussing the BAE recommendations, the 24 points. But I just want to be very clear. We had a bunch of citizens from the community who met. You guys are part of that committee. We should not be.
2:59:56 If you want to overrule the recommendations, you want to be clear about that, I think you need to come out and say that. Because I think I'm looking at a citizens group that's making these recommendations, and I'm listening to what the community is saying. So I think if members of the council want to say, we don't like that, we want to have the staff make recommendations, that's fine. But that's something I think we need to be careful about. I would say, John, like this recommendation, register rentals of 90 days or less. That's one of...
3:00:24 The recommendations from BAE, we did not discuss that in the committee at all. There are 24 options on here and we did not discuss 24 of them. Hold on, you're interrupting. We talked to Aaron and he prioritized saying certified property program, caps are effective, one year wait period for STR certificates. We did not talk about one year wait period for STR certificates and the discussion on caps was
3:00:53 Shortened and I don't know. I mean, that was the same night that people's addresses were shared and that somebody from the public was implying that people were on the STR committee for personal gain. And I don't think that everyone on the STR committee felt comfortable saying how they really felt. So that's why I bring up, hey.
3:01:20 Maybe that was a huge ask. Maybe we're rushing through this and maybe we need to ask for some more thoughtful... Well, I'd like to hear from our representatives. Do you believe that this advisory committee was an illegitimate process? I mean, what I'm hearing from you, at least, is that you don't, because of, you know, the difficulties of the process, that somehow the recommendations from the committee are not legitimate and that the council should not take these things seriously. I'm just wondering what your thoughts are. Well, I would say that...
3:01:49 Receiving these recommendations after we have put forward our recommendations, to me that doesn't make sense. I don't understand, you know, the only reason to me why we did that is because we're rushing.
3:02:02 We're trying to meet this deadline and the way that we're going, we're going to hit it a month early to rush through it. So I don't understand. This would not have been my choice is to receive this the day before we talk about it and then not go over the recommendations. So that's why I'm recommending that we have a talk about it here because I feel that I don't feel that it was an honest conversation. Okay, so what I would recommend, Madam Mayor Pro Tem, is that we table this discussion.
3:02:31 We wait to have a full council back here and we address this issue because this moratorium thing, there's obviously serious concerns of at least one, maybe two council members on this issue. I think we need to table this discussion. I think...
3:02:46 I don't feel comfortable sharing my thoughts when there's an agenda looming above this that could undermine everything, and I think we should wait, we should table all this, and we should wait until we have a full council back here, and we should figure out where we're going.
3:03:01 I feel like there's a sort of Damocles hanging over my thoughts, my recommendations, and I think we need to have a good council discussion on the status of the moratorium, where we're at with this process. If you think it's illegitimate, you are one of our representatives on the committee, let's air all this out and figure out where we go. I would respectfully disagree because I feel we can still have beneficial conversations.
3:03:28 about the subsidy program, about the housing down payment program, and how we're going to address item number four, where does zoning even come into this? I don't think that that is all held up by the...
3:03:45 Contemplation of a moratorium or no moratorium. We're just going to slow ourselves down. A lot of people did really good work on these items. The moratorium discussion was on the last matter, and we were able to give some, well, it's tied to the last. I understand that there's a more meta
3:04:06 Situation happening where ultimately we are going to have to have this conversation, but I think a lot of hard work was done and people came out and I think it would be beneficial for us to hear on the other matters. Yeah, and that's, so I would just ask my fellow council members, please sincerely engage with these items. I mean, let's talk about these things on their merits.
3:04:31 And if you feel like, Sarah, as you said, you don't want to weigh in on these things because you have concerns about the caps and things like that, let's make sure we get it so it's all out in front of us and it's all clearly stated and so that we know where we're at, where we stand. Mayor Pro Tem, if I may, I understand the request there. I'm going to say they're not mutually exclusive. I mean, we could come back and say all of these need to come back to you even from the direction tonight so you're not making a final decision.
3:04:58 If some of the concern that I'm hearing is we would also like to have an analysis on the other recommendations that came out of the economic report. We would set that up as a separate agenda item in the future, walk through those items, and that could inform, yeah, hey, we really do want a subsidy program or no, we want to soft launch into that or not launch into that. But I think if we had direction to come back with one, we can lay some stuff out knowing that
3:05:27 There's also a concern over the other elements that were presented in the BAE report. And we can walk through those. Aaron's glad to come into a meeting, Zoomer here, and assist in walking through those. So you can, there, what I think, if I'm hearing wrong, let me know. But what I'm hearing there somewhat is go, I don't want to jump into this stuff. It's solved when we have other issues potentially to address. I heard at least a majority, I think, say,
3:05:55 We need a revenue source for housing. Great. We could bring that back. But the concern would be I don't want to do a final vote on that until I've had a chance to look through these other recommendations. I'm kind of hearing that as well. So they don't have to be mutually included, but if you stack them, if you will, you bring them back in that sequence, it allows you to have the discussion that I'm hearing being asked for, looking at those things. But it also gives staff enough direction so we can begin to work on these other items as they come back.
3:06:24 If you want to do a TOT tax, for example, it's not going to be on your next meeting. It's just not going to be ready that fast. But the BAA report, it's a consultant. We can set that up. Next meeting might be tough. It's already long. But be able to come back in and say, or you may want to do a workshop on that. Let's do a workshop on that with the council. Walk through those things. Let's have that discussion. But knowing what we need to go work on on the staff side would be helpful that way.
3:06:49 But those other discussions may then change some of the focus on how that could go. And that is a council decision, ultimately, to look at those other items. I'm kind of trying to read the dealings here a little bit, but I don't think they're absolutely mutually exclusive, but it sounds like I'm not going to give you a final vote until I have a chance to digest this other information. But if staff can start working on this, it's going to take a few weeks to really...
3:07:18 Work through these items to come back. So we could have that discussion prior to a final vote on a tax measure or something of that nature. Does that make sense? I hear you. I think Council Member Ray has something to say, so I want to make sure we get that. I just feel that it's very important to give credence to this report that we commissioned by a professional, by someone who does not have a personal stake.
3:07:47 In this, I want to thank the members of this committee who worked very hard and gave up a ton of their personal time to bring these recommendations forward to us. I was not able to give that much time and so I am so grateful to the members of this committee who were able to do that. That being said, the members of this committee are members of this community. There were some issues happening that...
3:08:20 I could understand that members of the committee might have felt very uncomfortable perhaps bringing forward suggestions that were unpopular based on what occurred, and I think it would behoove us to digest the contents of these recommendations from an outside consultant who we paid, who is a professional, who is not running into people at THONS.
3:08:53 Okay. Any other comments? Shall we proceed just to give feedback? You know, many committee members came tonight, so at least we can hear what those thoughts were. And then knowing that none of these are all advisory at this point. None of these are moving forward because staff will have to go deeper into them. And then at the end, I guess we'll have a conversation about
3:09:22 Proceeding and Next Steps. But let's talk about the rental subsidy program. That's where we are, right? I'm sorry. I want to make sure I'm... Okay. So, Dan, do you want to describe the three options? Yeah, I can touch on those briefly again real quick. Yeah. The rental subsidy program, the first two are very similar. The first one was the placemates, so the leasing, the locals. The outside agency does that. They do all the upfront work, the marketing.
3:09:51 They have a program in place. They do that outreach. They've been effective in a half a dozen or a dozen different communities around the country, a couple locally being Truckee, and I believe it was Southlake or El Dorado area where they've done some work in. That's kind of a turnkey program. You'd have to fund it. There would be a process. It would be quick, but not next week type of a thing. The other one was more of a thought process, very similar. Let's create a program and subsidize rental work.
3:10:19 That could be more of a town-driven and we have to put the program together. The third one was a longer-term look, looking for longer-term subsidies. That would take more work in terms of the program itself if there's a desire to do that. So I guess there is one, again, back to is there a general desire to look at a subsidy program, especially on an interim basis, just to see, I think it was Aaron's comment too, on a short-term basis, we can see if it has an impact. Then where do you want to go from there?
3:10:47 Again, I'll say the timing on any of these is going to be a few council meetings out to get there, and we could agendize the BAA report and have a different discussion on that prior to final action, just given the timing and sequencing, if that's a desire.
3:11:01 From the Council. So can I ask a question real quick? You mentioned, Dan, that if we were to, say, want to go with the placemates program, that that's kind of shovel-ready, if you were, that that's something that we could proceed with. Yeah, that would be easier to get going. We still have to go through a contract. We have to meet with them. Understood. But that's what we're not building a new program. Correct. It's turnkey. We could move with it. Correct. So I'm inclined to say that let's move ahead with that.
3:11:27 But I just want to know, does that something that we need to wait for this review, the BEA report, or? I don't want to speak for Councilmember Sauser, but I recall him in the past saying that he was not in favor of rental subsidy programs. And I am also inclined to not be in favor of rental subsidy programs. I could potentially, you know, with a limited time frame, with a pre-built program, I'm not ruling it out.
3:11:58 But I also think that I know another member of council has expressed concerns about this. Okay, but just to be clear that the funding, we would not, let's assume we don't have a funding resource. So this would be a short-term thing, sort of a proof of concept kind of thing to see if it works, see how it might function in the market. That's all we could do at this point. That would be correct. What I would suggest if we want to go that is having them come in and do a presentation, the company.
3:12:27 To you as a council, you could ask direct questions, you could ask for their examples, you can look at that, what would that look like, and then you have a contractual obligation to work, so it would take a while to put that in place, identifying the funding, it would be limited, shorter term, and again, as that process goes forward, if there's consensus, you want to have more dialogue on the BA report, and that can happen in that intervening time, but we'd be moving forward, at least in this.
3:12:55 To see what this looks like and see how it does actually impact putting people in housing. It would be short interim, no commitment to ongoing with the company is what I'm hearing. And I would just add that many members of the short-term rental committee and I attended the lease to locals placement program at the chamber.
3:13:23 It was really impressive. I did actually do a little bit of checking around, and it has been successful in other places. And remember that it's not just a rental subsidy program. This is a way for us, because one of our goals was to try to migrate short-term rentals to long-term rentals by making it more appealing and giving people some confidence. And so that's why I would recommend that we...
3:13:51 I received this presentation as a council because I felt there were some communities that have already had success with it. And the other thing is it's a lot more cost effective than it seems at first because some of the numbers they quoted were for multiple years. So I do think it's worth having a look at that. And it wouldn't require us hiring additional staff and it wouldn't require us to commit to this forever. It's a year at a time.
3:14:23 I do think it's important since we have the public here. Can I say my thoughts on it? Absolutely, I'm sorry. I didn't see that you had. Go ahead. That's okay. I have mixed feelings about it. I feel like, yes, it gets some people into housing immediately. We've heard from some members of the public saying this is needed and we should do this. On the other hand, it's money that's just given away to
3:14:53 STR owners, possibly, or other homeowners. And then part of me feels like, well, shouldn't businesses be paying a living wage? So isn't there some, you know, economics where it's got to balance a bit? So I have mixed feelings on the leasing to locals, but I'm not sure exactly which way I would go, but I would like more information from the staff. Very good. And then I heard a lot of comments just on rental subsidy programs in general. So I think
3:15:23 That there's just, I think the answer is there's a lot to still unpack in the potential, you know, rental subsidies to migrate short-term rentals to long-term rentals. With that, I would like to take public comment. So is there anybody in the room who would like to give public comment? Please just come to the podium. And thank you.
3:15:49 So I also sat through the placemate presentation, and I love this program. The moratorium was put in place because this is an emergency situation. This is a shovel-ready program that's ready to go. The administration falls on placemate. It doesn't fall on the town. And at the very least, I would request that you sit through the presentation by them and then make the decision. Thank you. Anyone else in the room want to make a comment? How about online? All right.
3:16:18 Thank you very much. That was number two. Are we going to... So where are we with, where do we leave this with number two? What's the direction to staff for number two? So if I'm hearing, I'll call it a consensus. You can vote accordingly if you wish, that you would like to see the presentation at the council level from the lease to locals, where I've got more information on it at that point.
3:16:43 You could make a decision if we want to go with that, then it would take time to implement the program again. You're going to have a contractual relationship, et cetera, whatever that process would take. And he's gone through it one other time, so. So I would like to add to that. I would like to see a presentation from these folks based on a scope of work that we can afford. So it's not just a high-level general presentation. It's, okay, we would be willing to do this for this period of time.
3:17:10 So that once council hears that, we could take a vote and say whether or not we want to proceed with that program. Is that, I see some nodding heads. So that's, it's not just, hey, this is what we do. No, no, no, we would have a budget that we're working within to tell them do this and here's kind of what we're at. So that we could take action on that after the presentation is made, that would be part of the agenda item, then we can take an action on what we want to do with it after that.
3:17:33 Because much of that is driven by the incentives that you are offering. And so that's something that I would assume staff would look at because that would be general fund dollars and it would be trade-offs from the Housing Now program. So absolutely, I think staff would direct them to come to us with something that we could. Yeah, it's a presentation as part of an action item. That's what I would suggest. Okay. Next we are.
3:18:03 Talking about the housing down payment purchase program, I do think it's valuable to just air what this program is. So I would just turn to Dan and if you could just describe it, I think. Yeah, again, I think kind of the staff report walks through that, but getting our current workforce into housing as an owner.
3:18:27 It's difficult because of the pricing of housing in our community, be it a condo or be it a single family resident, be it other housing types here. A lot of our missing middle component, making up to that 200% of AMI, what we're seeing in some of our programs, even with a good wage, they really can't afford to purchase housing in Mammoth. So the program here would be, here is a down payment assistance program. We can get you into a unit. There's some factors on that.
3:18:55 There's dollars that go into it, and the program here would be set up, so let's say five years down the road, ten years down the road, you're going to sell that unit. Either all or a portion of our assistance would come back to the town, plus you would share in the appreciated value of the unit if it went up. If it doesn't appreciate in value, have the different programs, then we also share in the loss, and or we get paid first after the bank.
3:19:21 And then the owner takes the risk on losing dollars. So we'd have to work through that program, but generally it'll go both directions. Some programs will take a little bit of a haircut on how much comes back to them. That incentivizes people to get in there and invest and try to grow the value of the unit. So we'd have a lot more program development on that. This is a relatively, it's a higher dollar program. I would assume it's going to be in the $250,000 to $400,000 a unit, depending on pricing.
3:19:49 We want people to have to put part of their own money in. There's some rules and regulations on that as well. If the program you like, we can take a look at that and maybe a little slower process because I think having a steady income stream would provide the revenues to try to do this type of a program. The one benefit to it is ultimately a majority of the dollars put in ultimately go back into the program or can go back into the program as units are bought and sold over time.
3:20:16 So it's a longer-term investment in securing housing. Thank you. And I think one of the main things to point out is that this does require a revenue stream, so this would be not even something we could contemplate until after we found that revenue stream and got it passed. That said, do you have any questions for staff about this program specifically? I want to make sure I don't miss any questions. Do you have any questions? No. Okay. So then,
3:20:47 Anyone in the room, would you like to make public comment on the housing down payment program specifically? Okay. So, thoughts? Okay, go ahead. I'm supportive of this program. I think we should look into it. I mean, it feels like the Housing Now program a bit, but, you know, I'm supportive of this. And when you say the Housing Now, you mean the bridge component? The bridge component, yes. That's okay. Yeah, I want to make sure. Who wants to go next?
3:21:21 I love the idea that we would be not only making homeownership accessible to the missing middle, but, you know, building the community and encouraging people to stay here. So I'm supportive of it. Okay. Yeah, I think, I mean, it's academic, because without a revenue stream, this doesn't happen. So I think I'm supportive, but no revenue stream, no program. Understood. Okay.
3:21:53 What we do on this one on that is staff would have it as a work program. It wouldn't be quite as high as a priority, maybe some of the others, but begin looking at the program guidelines and details so it would come as revenue becomes available. So we'd have it ready to go versus waiting until after the fact, if you will, if that makes sense. It kind of does, but again, this revenue question, I mean, if there's not going to be any direction or support from the council for a revenue measure,
3:22:21 Maybe say maybe keep your powder dry for a little bit. If it does come in, the nice part would be, hey, here's a program that revenue's going to help fund. So you could actually point to something concrete that it would support. Again, having that discussion, I agree, that discussion on the front end of the staff. It would take some time again to build the program, and we've had offers from some of the committee members to help, as well as samples from other agencies, too, and other programs that are similar in nature that we would borrow from. Thank you.
3:22:54 So then number four is the review to whether or not we should continue the review of possible zoning changes to the RMF to zoning designation. And so you talked about this a little bit earlier. So but if you could just reiterate the point of why this would even be necessary, I think that would just be a good level set to begin the conversation. Yes. Again, I think it really was driven early on when we let.
3:23:23 Put the moratorium in place. There was a lot of concerns over particular properties in different areas of town that really felt we are designed to support the tourism economy. We are very much destination resort. This is where people rent and go. And it's in the portal areas. It was driven up above the village, if you will, going up to the gondola and up to canyon. It was in the eagle.
3:23:50 Roger, there's some debates where the lines would go and stuff and some different elements that way. But as we took a look at that and said if you wanted to bifurcate some of that out where those areas are more tourism intensive, at least appearing, there's some debate back and forth to that. They all ultimately do that. But you begin to look at those and say if you took more of the downtown area in a broader stretch.
3:24:15 We could take a look at that and say, if you bifurcate that zoning out, is there areas where you would take a lot of these incentive programs and it would be more a sense of focus, not a, you don't want to have to just say limit, we'd only do it there, you could, but it'd be a focused area, again, limited resources. I think the other element this would help drive is we have a lot of different planning documents related to our downtown, we have different places, different
3:24:42 Work that's been done. It would be nice to take those and say what is the consensus of those and does that, do a lot of that other planning work fit with the overlay or the change that we're talking about? Does it make sense to have some focuses across the community on the type of development and the ability to look at different, a little bit differently? On the front end, frankly, nothing would have any changes if you did that because the whole process will take time.
3:25:09 The zoning process would be staff, it would be community, it would be the planning commission, then it would be back to council for final action. So this one, we call it a lower priority, a lower priority staff work program, something to look at. Taking it on now, it would just be a little bit overwhelming. But I think it's something worth having that consideration, especially as we look at some of the other overlay planning work that we've done in districts, in the downtown and other places. How does this fit together with some of that type of work?
3:25:39 So I think it's a valid work program, but it's not something that would be undertaken. My guess, probably we'd be good to get to it within the year. It should take longer than that, frankly. Thank you. Does anyone on council have any questions about this item, number four, about zoning? I don't have any questions, but I have some ideas for deliberation, for sure. Okay. We want to get to the public before we... Yeah, yeah, yeah, of course. No questions. Comments, please.
3:26:08 Okay. Any members of the public who would like to comment on this item? My name's Christina and I'm an owner at Bigwood. I appreciate the hard work that the committee has been doing the past few months. My concern comes with the proposed new zoning map. During the committee meeting I asked what criteria the subcommittee used for the map zone proposal and I do not feel like this question has been answered that actually reflects the map proposed. Looking at the map I am extremely confused how there is a strip west of the minaret.
3:26:41 Called out as RMF2, which is as walkable to Eagle Lodge, the Village, and Golf Course as the condominiums down Lakeview Boulevard is to Canyon and Meridian is to Eagle Lodge. Bigwood itself is 0.6 miles to Eagle and are closer to summer and winter hubs than many of the other complexes in those zones. The complexes in this area have live-in managers, parking, comparable HOAs are walkable to the Village, Eagle, as much as many of the proposed RMF-T condominiums.
3:27:10 All of the aspects that have been attributed to the RMFT zone applied to the complexes in my area. The only reason to change zones is to govern these areas different in the future. It would not make sense to do just this for incentives for long-term renters, which should be given to a larger area, not a smaller one. So if these areas are going to be split in the future, I would request the committee to explain to the council and the audience how they got the boundaries of the new proposed map.
3:27:39 Please do not continue down this road of rezoning without there being an understanding of why the proposed boundaries are where they are and confirm the criteria that they use is reflected in the new zone map. Thank you. Terry Stelick, I'd like to start out and say, you know, I said this at the committee. I don't know why you're, if you're looking to rezone something to simply say that this area is available for your
3:28:17 I have no idea why you would do that. You have a housing issue. You have an entire town that's in four and a half square miles. If somebody wants to, you know, rent long term in an area that is RMF 2 and in more what you're determining as a resort area, why would you eliminate that? That just seems silly to me. You're putting money towards that. I've heard
3:28:46 The gentleman with BAE, he refers to residential real estate. This town was not built with any condos that are residential real estate. This town was built with condos on the idea that they were short-term rentals. There's not enough parking. There's no storage. They are not built for residential use. There's not a person in this town that if they're in a condo that they don't have to have an extra storage unit.
3:29:13 And potentially have parking elsewhere. So consider that when you guys are working on all of this. Houses were residential, but as real estate has gone, houses and condos are out of reach of residential use at this point in time. So, and I also want you to remember that over 70% of your income is coming from your industry, which is tourism. And the industry drives your community.
3:29:43 If you don't have your industry, you can't have anything else for your community. That's a fine line that you have to walk. And so I want you guys to remember that as you're moving forward. And the gentleman from BAE also said that. Mammoth is unique where we have far more necessity of our TOT and our...
3:30:07 Our visitors than any other community because every other community has more property tax that comes into their community. So, you know, as we're moving forward and you guys are making these decisions.
3:30:21 You know, I hear that you've spent over $30 million on affordable housing. Well, where did that $30 million come from? It came from tourism dollars. And so because the tourism dollars were strong enough, you guys had that money to be able to do something else. If you cut your tourism dollars, you're cutting off the nose to spite the face. Thank you. Anyone else in the room? Jamie, anyone online? Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
3:30:55 Hello again. This is Jan. I live in Tyrolean Village, and I fully agree with what Christina Avery shared earlier regarding the location of some of these properties. I'm, you know, a street across on Lake Mary Road from other areas that are considered resort where my home is closer.
3:31:21 to Eagle Lodge than they are to Canyon, and that makes no sense. I'm right on a trolley line for visitors to be able to do things. But also, like the past speaker just said, we don't have a garage, we don't have storage, we have limited parking, we do have an on-site property manager who manages all four of the villages, and it seems like some of the decision for the
3:31:50 The redlining that is on that map just doesn't make sense. And I think it's a bad idea to move forward with the zoning change. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else online? Rose, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Rose again. Even though the proposed zoning split is stated to be low priority,
3:32:15 It still clouds our titles and impacts the values of our properties in the targeted orange zone as it continues to linger as something that the town is contemplating for discriminatory redlining unfair housing options. Please remove it from further consideration as it unnecessarily divides our community, clouds our titles.
3:32:38 It imposes unnecessary conditions on those otherwise qualifying for benefits under either of the proposed housing programs. Owners of properties, regardless of their location, who need or want to sell or rent their homes, whether they're single-family residences, condos, or otherwise.
3:32:56 Should have the ability to sell or rent to anyone, including the additional pool of lower income workers who would qualify for the proposed housing programs. Moreover, those workers should be able to choose where they want to live anywhere in Mammoth rather than in a limited area that the town perceives as preferential for them for whatever reason. To create a targeted red line area, we'll lower property values in that area.
3:33:21 Although that may serve the town's goal to acquire workforce housing at lower prices, that would essentially constitute a discriminatory taking without just compensation on top of taxation without representation as the vast majority of STR owners are second homeowners who are not registered to vote in Mammoth Lakes. We'd be back to 1998 all over again. In addition to taxing considerations, the town council should require developers to provide housing in lieu of cash.
3:33:51 And not permit them to buy themselves out of the burden of building housing for their employees and thereby making it the burden of STR or other owners. So thank you for your consideration. Thank you. Anyone else online? Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, thank you again. I just want to be clear that redlining is not, this is not redlining. Redlining is denial of credit or insurance. It's historically been used.
3:34:22 to segregate minority groups. I find it offensive that we would use redlining to represent wealthy people trying to keep their STRs. And the point of zoning is, or the point of the moratorium was to look at housing.
3:34:46 And housing for locals. I would love to see the council and the planning commission look at expanding the RMF1 zone. That's the zone for our locals because that allows no short-term rental. Why aren't we looking at expanding that zone? That's what I would like to see and encourage you to consider and ask staff to consider. Thank you. Thank you. Kim, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
3:35:16 Hi, thanks for listening today. I think, you know, I support everything that's been said about essentially don't feed the hand that, what is it, don't cut the hand that feeds you? I don't remember exactly. But basically, you know, you've got a big zone of tourist income coming in to help you fund all these programs, to help you provide housing. Why would you split out half of those people and not allow them to contribute or to rent long-term or to have down payment assistance?
3:35:46 But also my point is a little different in that you should really, if you are going to split zoning, you should be looking at these complexes individually. You know, some of these were built in the early 70s before the town was incorporated. They were built for vacation homeowners. And if you look at their floor plans, they're not really suitable for long-term housing. They're not homes that people are jumping up to go into. And they should remain, you know, able to STR. And if you talk now about splitting the zoning.
3:36:13 I think we all see that there's some writing on the wall where you're looking forward towards license caps or other issues for these STR owners, which will deplete their property values and aren't going to provide the great housing solutions you're looking for. Thanks for listening. Thank you. Okay, that's all the comments. So, anyone on council? I don't think there's any.
3:36:39 Pending decision, but I do think it's beneficial to have a conversation so that staff has the benefit of understanding where we are. Does anyone want to raise their hand? I could start. I am sensitive to the idea of choosing winners and losers, which is why when we instituted the moratorium, I suggested that it apply to everyone and not just the selected zones. So I
3:37:09 I am listening to the public comment on this, and I do have a good amount of hesitation about making a decision that would single out certain areas. And I think the point of why we chose them makes sense. That is a reason why I favor a cap at or near where we're at.
3:37:38 Because that doesn't choose winners and losers. It's unilateral. It's also a reason why I am in support of a waiting period because that would apply across the board. Thank you. Okay. You know, I looked at the agenda for this evening as, you know, holistically with how to bring all these parts together so they add up to something that would make sense going forward. Obviously, we're going to have some, we'll have some different discussions on that.
3:38:11 Looking at the zoning piece, I think that what Terry Stellick and others have said is it's just common sense. And I very much appreciated the BAE gentleman and what he's thought and what I heard this evening is he gets the nuance of this community. He understands that the infrastructure that was built in this town was built fundamentally around nightly rentals. That's the infrastructure that we've got.
3:38:38 And it's a blessing because it drives the TOT that makes it possible. We had to put $30 million into housing. It's a critical engine. It's a critical engine. What we have to do is find the balance. We have to find the balance between the idiosyncrasies of our infrastructure and how we're built and how we can start to address these housing issues. And it's a nuanced thing. And it's idiosyncratic and specific to Mammoth Lakes.
3:39:04 So with this housing thing, I think that there is a way to find that kind of a balance because there's some other contributing factors. Dan mentioned all the planning stuff that we have in downtown. A lot of that stuff is completely out of date. It's not, you know, there's no retail anymore. All these assumptions that went into those plans, they need to be reviewed. I don't see it as being a horribly odious process.
3:39:32 But I think that we need to look at all of that stuff for downtown. We need to look at all that stuff. And I think it's also important, again, to find that balance of where the revenue-generating things are happening in nightly rentals and say, look, that is the way that's going to be. I think that the Certified Property Program is so important because there are people in the community who live in those areas, and they need to make sure they have redress.
3:40:00 I've got complaints from people all the time. I get them last night, this last weekend, partying, blah, blah, blah, all that quality of life stuff. I called the cops. Nobody showed up. We have to share the built environment that we've got, and we have to find a way to do that. And I think that this is going to be a progressive thing. I'm not supportive of doing any kind of shock value program that doesn't accommodate.
3:40:30 The culture of this community and who we are and how all this infrastructure works. This has got to be kind of a gradual process. And I strongly support going to the planning commission saying, look, you need to take a look at this, at the potential for zoning without any predetermined outcome. But to look at this, to look at all the plans for downtown, the ones that don't make any sense anymore, take those off the shelf. And let's look at the downtown area as a place for investment and growth.
3:40:59 And to do something with that area. Not to punish people who have nightly rental certificates and all the rest of it. What are we going to do with this downtown area? So I strongly support this. And I think it's something, if we do want to get into caps, if we do want to get into the SDR business, let's do the analysis. If it takes a year or so, fine. It takes a year, it takes some time to do it. Let's take the time to do that and figure out what the potential is of this downtown area. Because this is the last real estate we have in town to actually
3:41:28 Do anything with, and I think one of the next things we're looking at, the main lodge redevelopment project, what are we going to do that's compelling, that's going to keep people from just driving right up the road and just going right up there? It's an opportunity, so I would encourage us to pursue this. Those are my thoughts. Well, I didn't say anything yet, but you and I were on the committee. We were on this committee, the zoning committee, and I feel like from the start, my feelings have been, this is really hard.
3:42:01 I don't know. I don't know if this needs to be done. I don't, you know, should Tyrolean Village and Bigwood, should that be included? Should it not? I feel like it's subjective. I'm not an expert in this. So, you know, I think like the Planning and Economic Development Committee, you know, maybe they have more insight, but I definitely, you know, I feel like we've heard
3:42:27 Owners on both sides where, you know, they're like, well, we don't want to be, if there's a new resort zone, we don't want that. We want the carrots that you would offer to the RMF2. And then everyone in the RMF2 is upset that, well, we want to be considered resort zone. You know, I understand the arguments of we're a resort town. The whole town is four square miles. You know, why do we need to do this? So I feel like the whole zoning thing, it's been hard.
3:42:58 It was hard being on the committee, and I don't feel like I can make a final decision on if that should be separately zoned or not. Again, my suggestion is not for us to predetermine it, but we do have a planning commission. Right. And they're the planning and economic development commission to be looking at this holistically with that eye towards downtown. And let's see what they would have to say about it. Yeah. I agree.
3:43:30 That was a hard committee. And I think that that committee came about because there was a massive outcry and there was a lot of misinformation and there were people who weren't impacted by any of this, writing letters and calling. And so I think that it's really important for us as a community to take a pause, to try to understand what's been discussed.
3:43:59 Ultimately to realize that if you listen to everything you heard tonight, everyone can make an argument for don't do this here, don't do it to my property, and yet we do need to find a place for folks to live. And so I think it's really important for us to look at our town holistically. There's some major changes that will be coming. I think it's important to remind folks that
3:44:33 We haven't had a newly approved project to look and I'm going off topic here but I think it's worth saying because I heard a lot of public comments. I won't address every one but there was a lot of talk about development agreements and why haven't you extracted this from the new
3:44:52 So I just think it's really important.
3:45:22 Thank you. Thank you.
3:45:47 I think anything that would impact zoning.
3:46:18 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:46:44 Any final thoughts on this item, number four? So where are we at on this item? That in my, I could make a proposal for staff. I think that it is that this conversation began out of perceived need to address a vocal part of the population and instead of just
3:47:12 I would say that this would be start over.
3:47:42 After we do that, really, I understand taking the holistic look at that, and I think we're hearing that from folks working through the Planning Department, the Planning Economic Development Commission. As I mentioned earlier, this will be a slow process. This is not going to get started quickly. I do think we'll take all the comments together there. I mean, there's a fairness question. How do we do that? How does it fit with current plans? What needs to be done? What doesn't need to be done?
3:48:07 Is it an element in the whole STR housing development? We would still be going through that. And yeah, it's like that. I'm not an expert in this stuff yet. So I'll say yet. Being able, but taking it back through that process. But again, it would not be something that, I'll be honest with, I know the workload, it will take time to get to. It will not be quick in terms of this. Even the planning work and going back through a lot of the other things on the shelves, there's elements that are good, bad.
3:48:35 We have to be pulled out and thought through and how we take that forward. I tend to lean toward that approach. Let's take a holistic look. What do we have out there? What works well? What doesn't? Are there some tweaks and changes? And what does that lead us to without a preconceived outcome? Is that we can? Is everyone comfortable with that? Yeah. I mean, I have no expectation it happens quickly, but this is the kind of analysis that I think we need to have to be able to make decisions about things.
3:49:03 Absolutely. And all the downtown stuff, most of those plans, I don't, again, a lot, any plan that's dependent upon retail to make it successful, okay, just say, look, that's, there is no more retail, let's get real about this stuff, and start getting a vision for what that would look like. And I think, to be clear, that subcommittee did not go deep into downtown at all, and so that's why I feel,
3:49:33 It probably needs a fresh start. Yeah. Okay. Staff, do you feel as if you have enough information from this matter, or is there anything you would like us to clarify? I'm just looking at the other staff who's putting a thumbs up, so. Okay. Thank you, everyone. And thanks for everyone, particularly the short-term rental committee who participated. It was tough. We started a conversation. This is...
3:50:05 Going to be ongoing probably forever. So we do appreciate very much the service of those who helped us get this going. All right. So moving along, thank you for your patience. Those of you who are here to talk about the MOU. Just one last point. I think that staff, I hope you heard that.
3:50:38 Some real work needs to be done in terms of what comes back to council and in what order. Because this was not, this was not, I don't think this represented what other, what council members wanted to see tonight, what they wanted to be see debated. And I think we've ended up, as a member of the audience said, we're in the mud. And I think we need to get out of it. And I would just hope that you, please bring us back a sequenced agenda that makes sense so we can, if.
3:51:05 Something's not going to happen. We're not going to waste our time to waste the public's time doing the things that don't add up to anything. Again, the goal on this one was these were the recommendations out of the committee. Sure. Understood. So we wanted to walk through those. Understood. All right. So thank you for your patience, those who are here for item.
3:51:24 9.4 to approve the MOU between Blue Forest Finance Incorporated, World Resources Institute, and the Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resilience Project. And this is the Wildfire Resilience Action Financial Team, or RAFT, subject to the final legal partner agency review. So who is bringing this forward? That would be Dan. Thank you. The item before you has come out of a group meeting.
3:51:54 Before it was the financial advisory team or FAT. So we changed the name from FAT to something else. But the idea here was a number of partners have gotten together talking about how do we proceed with really ultimately figuring out funding options for the massive amount of fuel reduction work planned in and around Mammoth and in Mammoth County and ultimately beyond that.
3:52:19 The different groups and stuff we've worked with, there's a number of different elements and some of this is coming up and say we want to have at least a working structure as we bring a number of different agencies together. The MOU is a non-binding MOU and some of that federal agency partners and stuff who probably can't quite get there if they wanted to even I don't think in terms of the requirements there. But part of that is because we have such a large group of people working through this we wanted to have a structure though that
3:52:49 And so ideally the
3:53:16 A number of agencies will be taking this forward. It puts us all in the room together with a common vision, if you will, a common purpose without being a binding action item. So the idea there is Blue Forest and World Resources Institute, the group there, is looking at some very creative financing elements out there, but they need people in the room to be able to get behind that and understand it, to be able to move that forward.
3:53:42 Element to this is going through a number of agencies, so there may be some tweaks to the MOU. If they're not substantive, we'd like to have authority just to go ahead and move those forward if we need to amend it. If is there anything that is substantive or of a legal nature, then obviously we'd have to review that and have it come back to the council for another approval. The concern with the number of agencies involved is there are a lot of amendments and stuff. We'll be at this process for several months.
3:54:10 And as we put it together, I know Andy took a look at it when the question was, this is kind of a non-binding type MOU, so it's not obligating the town to do things, but the partners at the table have a discussion, if I can paraphrase that correctly. Janet Hatfield from the Whitebark Institute's here can speak to it as well. She's on that, and it's been a...
3:54:33 Supporter behind it and pushing it. Yeah, shoving it forward. So I'm not sure who else it's gone to yet. We're probably one of the more earlier adopters getting this. The group meeting and we're looking on this has been beneficial. I think looking at where we can go and how do we end up getting serious about reducing the wildfire.
3:54:53 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:55:23 Any questions for Janitor? Anyone else? No, not for me. Any comments? Thanks for staying late. Sorry we didn't put you there. Yeah, sorry. All right. They are. You're popular. All right. I'm just glad we are moving this forward because I think it's a very, very essential
3:55:59 Project for our community, and I'm glad we're able to participate. So with that, would anyone I could enter? Oh, public comment. I was catching myself. Is there any public comment from anyone in the room or online? They all left? It's not you, Janet. So with that, I could entertain a motion.
3:56:24 I would move that the Council approve the NYU between Blue Forest Finance, Inc., World Resources Institute, Eastern Sierra Climate Committee Resilience Project, Wildfire Resilience Action Team, The Raft. Action Financial Team. Action Financial Team. Thank you. Subject to final legal partner agency review. Thank you. I'll second. Great. So we have a motion from Councilmember Wentworth and a second from Councilmember Rice. Could you please call the roll?
3:56:52 Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Good news. We like good news at the end of a long meeting. Thanks, Janet. Sorry. Thank you. You're very patient. And Chief Temeier, too. Okay, so moving along. Agenda Item 9.6.
3:57:21 This is a council update and direction on proposed legislation and related items. Mr. Holler. Yes, and I'll try to keep this relatively short. A lot of information in the packet. We did provide a copy of the town's legislative policy and direction that was adopted back in April of 23. We utilized that a lot of times in analyzing legislation. The one thing I did want to highlight in this process, a lot of this stuff happens very, very quickly.
3:57:50 At times, we'd like to get before council and go, hey, how do you feel about a bill? Let's spend the time to discuss it. And by the time we go through that process, it becomes moved. It's either already killed and or passed. It moves through the legislative process very quickly. Others kind of hang out, and you've got to keep an eye on them. We do utilize a number of resources for this. Some of that's obviously the Cal Cities, looking at some stuff from the city basis. We look at utilizing...
3:58:18 Kyra Ross with Emanuel Jones as a consultant working in the legislature, effective tool. It's great they represent just local agencies or governmental agencies, public agencies that are up for Turkey, and there's a lot of cross-pollination that happens through that process. Andy can speak to that as well. And then we do get resources from a variety of other sources, RCRC, the county level, especially in the federal legislation, that's a good benefit.
3:58:46 Other agencies and, I'll say, interest groups within the community and the region actually send us stuff now and again. Hey, are you aware of something going on in the legislature? You know, for example, we've taken a position on SB 584. That was the bill targeting an increase of TOT by 15% statewide and going into housing. The bill is not dead. It has not yet had enough votes to get out of committee. It is still sitting there. We're still watching that. Hopefully it just...
3:59:15 It goes away, frankly. A lot of opposition to that element. Definitely in the legislative process this year, we believe that the budget discussion is going to be dominating a lot of decisions. You can read the news and they have a $38 to $58 billion deficit going up, not going up.
3:59:35 Different debate as how revenues are coming into the state. So we know that's going to dominate a lot of the discussion and how it impacts legislation and what can go forward on those types of things. I want to touch on, I did put a highlight in some of the federal stuff in here, so just FYI, but I want to touch on some of the state bills real quick as potential ones that we want to take a look at and taking some action on. We just recently, Rob and I attended the Cal Cities.
4:00:05 Mountain Desert Division of the League. A lot of discussion on different legislative topics there as well. And by the way, we'll be hosting July 19th that division meeting here in Mammoth. So put that on your calendars if you remember. But one of them is AB 1772. This is dealing with retail theft, and it's a strengthening of that bill in terms of a lot of the elements of stores. We've some business owners on the...
4:00:32 League Division basically have made the comment that this and some other factors, they've gotten out of business. It's just not worth the fight in terms of the amount of losses they were taken. There's an AB 1725. It doesn't impact us probably today really directly, but this is on a reporting of all police judgments that you go out. Anything over $50,000, you have to take those judgments, have them posted on your website with good information. They're already public.
4:01:02 We have access to that, but a lot of agencies are going, here's one more duplication of putting information out into the community. The EFID element, we've talked in the past quite a bit about that. There's an amendment proposed, whether it impact us directly yet, we're not sure, but it would allow if you have an EFID that incorporates high or very high fire hazardous areas.
4:01:30 You could actually use that type of funding to buy heavy equipment to help with fuel reduction work, for example. So there's very, very nuanced bills as well, very, very broad ones that come through that. There's several bills related to housing, HCD bills. Again, a lot of those.
4:01:48 Are focused on, I'll say, reducing local control over housing development and putting additional standards on what you must do and can do. There's a few that also have some benefit side, some funding and some restructuring. As we go through those, we tend to be cautious on the local control ones where we lose that control, which gives the developers a lot more, and it's not just always affordable with others as that housing can move forward. There is a
4:02:16 Bill focused on the wildfire community hardening program, actually looking at making it easier to fund and do some hardening of communities, which would be a positive element if we could play that into our wildfire protection plan that we've already adopted into our general plan a while back on some benefits that program. That was SB 946. There's SB 947. Talks about state highways. If there's a joint project that comes in and there's support from the state,
4:02:48 And the project has a cost overrun. The bill would obligate the state actually to cover that cost overrun versus the local agencies who commit dollars and not have to pay more out unexpectedly. There's another one dealing with a wildlife continuity element in your connectivity element in your general plan. That would be an update in the future.
4:03:16 Anywhere where you would have to go through and do an update, anywhere where you have wildlife going through your community, define those areas where they come through, and then, again, limiting development impact in that element, which we saw this in some of our trails in the past and some of the impact that type of work has on some of the elements when they're living in the middle of a forest, what happens in those types of areas. So that's a feel for some of those bills out there doing those things.
4:03:43 A couple of those, as mentioned, some of them make a lot of sense probably for us to support. Those that really take away our local control or add additional burdens. Not so exciting to support those or actually step in and oppose some of those. Again, what you have in here also, the bill list, it's a weekly list we get from Emanuel Jones. We share that out around staff and look at those. Are there elements that we should be making comments on? The other case on some of these, I'll reach out to the lobbyists go.
4:04:12 Does this bill look like it's going to move forward or not? No, it doesn't look like it has the votes, and so then do we put a lot of extra time in to put an opposition or a support letter in, or do we wait until it, see if it's actually viable or not going forward? The time element is one of the key issues on this, just in terms of how quickly things come up. They need a comment immediately. If it's something that isn't clear, if we don't comment, if we want to come to council, again, I'll mention often it's...
4:04:41 It becomes a moot point because it's already moved through the process and or died in some cases, which is all right, unless it's one we're supporting, then we have those same challenges. So I'll pause there. I think there's some of these bills make a lot of sense for us to send in a letter of support, you know, in terms of the wildfire support, in terms of even the hardening support, in terms of things of that nature that can help us in the environment we live in. Others.
4:05:09 The opposition side in terms of those elements that really make life more difficult for local agencies. Several of these are called out as a mandate on local government, therefore the state would have to pay for that element. Chances are several of those may die in the Appropriations Committee because of the budget problems with the state and or they'll get very creative in how it doesn't require local
4:05:36 We see this all the time in the solid waste. Because you have the ability to levy a fee to cover those costs, that mandate is not a state program they have to fund because you can cover the costs through raising rates, which, again, passing the buck, so to speak, in my mind on some of those things. Let me pause there. If there's questions, just one, on just the process we use, that we do a lot of work based on the legislative policy.
4:06:05 Either myself, working with the mayor, we can sign stuff, we put that together. If we have time and there's questions, bring that to council. If it seems to be controversial a lot of times, that just doesn't go anywhere at that point at the town level, just because of time and the legislative process. They're expecting 2,200 plus bills to be introduced in this next go around. So trying to stay on top of a handful of those becomes challenging and reading through those is...
4:06:34 Quite a process. So let me pause here. Thank you. If there's particular questions, I can walk through some of these if you want to, if you just allow us to work with them for action or if you want to specifically look at a bill and take a formal direction, we can do that as well. Does anyone have questions? It's getting late. I did note that when there's a letter in opposition or support, you will copy the council once it's sent. Yes. Okay, great.
4:07:06 Just because there may be an opportunity for us to say, hey, I know that person, would you like us to? Absolutely. Okay. Generally what you're doing is that letter, it goes to the bill sponsor, it goes to our lobbyist, it goes to our representatives, and it'll go to the league, cities, Cal cities. Okay. So there's a process of pushing all that out as well. I had one that I had a question about, but I can't find it anymore, so I will.
4:07:32 Follow-up separately because it looks like we're losing people. So I would say thank you for... Yeah, and if the process is working for you all, we'll continue to work through that as we look at the copy you accordingly. I am glad that we are engaging in this and I'm glad we, you know, hired Emanuel Jones because we should have our voice heard. We have a point of view and we have needs and so we should be. So I think it's great.
4:08:03 All right. With that, we are on to the last agenda item, which is Councilmember Reports. So who would like to go first? Okay. I'll go first. Mammoth Lakes Housing Meeting was canceled on Monday due to the snowstorm, so I have nothing to report at this time. Okay. Nothing. Nothing. I think we've talked quite enough for one day. So we are adjourned. Do I have to say till when?
4:08:33 February 21. Until that super fun meeting on February 21st. See y'all there. Thank you. Thank you.