Town Council Special meeting
at 16:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
351 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:01 Thank you, Jamie. Yeah, you saved me from myself. You good? Dan? You good? Okay.
2:39 Good afternoon, everyone. I would like to welcome you to the special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Thursday, February 15, 2024. And to begin, before we do the roll call, I would like to ask that we consider the request for remote participation by Mayor Sauser pursuant to government code section 54953.
3:08 Since Mayor Sauser needs to be out of town to care for his wife, we are asking that he participate via Zoom. So Jamie, do I need a motion or anything or just call? Yeah, a motion and a second. Okay, could I have a motion? I'll make a motion that we allow Bill to participate remotely. I'll second. Great, so we have a motion from Councilmember Rice, second from Councilmember Ray. Jamie, can you please call the roll? Councilmember Ray? Here. Yes.
3:38 Yes. Oh, sorry. Yes. That'll be next. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem-Bubser? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Great. Thank you. And now, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Ray? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem-Bubser? Here. Mayor Salzer? Present. Great. And I have asked if Terry would please lead us in the pledge, so if you could all stand.
4:14 To allegiance and to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. So now we are at the part of the agenda where we are requesting public comments for matters that are not otherwise on the agenda this evening.
4:50 For matters that aren't on the agenda, please approach the podium. And if no one in the room has comments, Jamie, is there anyone online? Okay. So then we will move on to agenda item four, which is policy matters. And we will have a council discussion and direction regarding recommendations from the BAE Urban Economics Short-Term Rental Study. And Rob will take us through this matter.
5:20 Thank you. Yes, as part of the last Town Council meeting, it was brought up that there was a wish to kind of go a deeper dive into the BAE report, and particularly the recommendations that were made as part of that report. Staff has done some work on that. We've brought Aaron Nussain here tonight, who's the author of the report, to start us off, and he's going to go through a little bit, and then we're going to go through the 24 items.
5:50 Probably seven policy items that are from those that we'll kind of break down, but we wanted to talk to sort of the disposition of the rest of them as well, because I think there's some elements to that. But I'll go ahead and kick it off with Aaron and let him go through his, I think he's got a presentation as well. Thank you. Great. Thank you, Rob.
6:09 So again, my name is Aaron Nussain. I'm a principal with BAE Urban Economics. I was a primary author of the short-term rental study for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We've previously presented most of the content that's contained in the study to the SDR Advisory Committee. Right now, I'm just going to briefly review the contents of the report in terms of the table of contents, essentially, and summarize really the key market understanding.
6:39 And then if there are specific questions that council members have about any of the individual data points, I'm happy to dig into those questions as needed. So recognizing the relatively small size of the community and the relative shortage of robust data sources available to run complex statistical analyses, the short-term rental study that I prepared
7:17 relies heavily on a review of the contemporary academic and professional literature on the relationship between short-term rentals and local housing markets with a specific focus on impacts to housing availability and pricing. We also then looked at impacts to the tourist accommodations industry and sort of how short-term rentals interface with dedicated hotel and motel properties.
7:45 We looked at more than 50 studies. The bulk of those were peer-reviewed academic articles. We also had a fair number of professional reports covering a variety of jurisdictions. For the most part, the literature review is very consistent in terms of the conclusion that relationships do exist between the prevalence of short-term rentals in a market.
8:10 And the availability and pricing of long-term housing within that same market. The specific coefficients of impact vary significantly between those studies based on a whole variety of factors ranging from research methodologies to the nature of that community, the size of that community, and the prevalence of STRs within that specific market. The third-party professional reports generally
8:38 Coincide with the conclusions identified in the academic literature. There's at least one case where for San Luis Obispo County, they did a county-wide analysis and determined that STRs aren't driving the market in that case. However, in that instance, STRs make up only about 6% of the total housing stock compared to 35% in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
9:05 And the general conclusion is that the level of concentration has an impact on whether or not STRs are really influencing the way housing is being used in a given context. In addition to literature review, we looked at market data for the town of Mammoth Lakes in Mono County.
9:26 We recognize that the tourism industry is a main driving force for the local economy, both within the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County more broadly, and that short-term rentals make up a significant portion of your tourist accommodations inventory, somewhere between 60 and 80 percent, depending on how you actually count those units.
9:51 The housing market in the town of Mammoth Lakes is also highly constrained in terms of your ability to build and the new inventory. And second homes and second home demand is a significant driving factor for the housing market and pricing in particular within the town of Mammoth Lakes market. And we've generally come to the conclusion that short-term renting really helps to facilitate second home demand.
10:19 By providing an additional income stream that supports second home ownership and long-term purchase and hold decisions for those households. In addition to the market analysis, we looked at regulatory approaches that are being taken in a handful of other peer communities, mostly throughout the Mountain West.
10:39 Looking at different approaches to short-term rental regulation that can vary quite widely from a rather hands-off approach to more significant market interventions like the establishment of caps and wait lists or in the case of City of Southlake, Tahoe a moratorium on short-term renting in certain districts similar to what you have under Measure Z in Town of Mammoth Lakes.
11:00 And then we put forward 24 recommendations for the town to consider. These aren't necessarily hard recommendations. In my opening remarks to the STR Advisory Committee, I explained that there is no one standard approach to short-term rental regulation. It really depends on the local context within a given community, as well as the objectives that that community is trying to achieve through...
11:29 So I look forward to kind of further explaining the basis for some of the recommendations as needed as well as you know explaining how they might function within that context from an economic perspective. Just one last quick slide before I hand it back to Rob and Dan to go over kind of where they stand on the recommendations. I just wanted to briefly summarize
11:56 Kind of my understanding of how STRs function as part of the housing market from the research I've done in Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, as well as a variety of other jurisdictions in California. And one of the contexts that I see quite commonly, particularly in mountain communities, is a highly constrained land supply. You have complex land ownership issues. You have complex topography that limit your ability to develop.
12:23 And so the ability to just build out of the problem, out of the shortage of workforce and affordable housing is quite challenging. That generally puts jurisdictions in the position of needing to better utilize the existing housing stock. That's challenging given that that housing stock is in diverse ownership and is in a variety of kind of alternative uses.
12:46 Construction costs are a significant barrier, as well as the spending power of many workforce households. It's largely a service-based economy with many workforce households relying on service-based wages, which makes covering construction costs quite challenging. The other thing is this is a phenomenal place. You have demand on the housing market in the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's originating from all over the state and the nation.
13:14 So that second home demand is usually coming from households with quite a bit greater resources than your typical workforce household in terms of income as well as assets. So over time, those second home buyers are often able to out-compete local workforce households, and it's a cumulative consumption of your constrained and finite housing stock over time, which is a significant challenge.
13:41 And it is really that second home demand that is the primary market distortion that you're up against. Short-term renting really functions to simply facilitate second home ownership. Again, by providing an income stream. In some cases, property owners can fully offset their costs. In many cases, it's only partially offsetting their costs, but it brings the holding costs down to a level that is affordable and something that they can achieve.
14:07 Short-term renting can also expand the pool of potential second home buyers and owners by again providing additional income and purchasing power that that household might not have access to otherwise. Lastly, I want to comment on investment activity. So one of the recommendations is to consider a waiting period on short-term rental permits after the purchase of a property that's really intended to try and influence the investment market and in particular influence 1031 exchanges.
14:37 And essentially what that does is limit the ability to accrue income and essentially represent the property as a commercial investment during an initial period during which time that transaction is being finalized. And really, again, that's intended to sort of discourage the conversion of the housing stock into an investment vehicle and a commodification of housing.
15:05 And lastly, I again want to emphasize that STRs do represent a very significant portion of your tourist accommodations inventory. You're a remote community. You rely on those tourist accommodations to bring in tourist dollars. And so any approach to a short-term rental regulation really needs to be balanced against the potential impacts to economic development and economic sustainability.
15:28 That said, I also view a lack of sustainable workforce housing as a long-term economic sustainability issue. We're already hearing stories about businesses being unable to operate in the way they would like to because they can't find workers to keep the doors open. And so over time, that can become more and more severe of an issue, again, as that second home market eats into your housing, your finite housing inventory.
15:54 So with that, I'm open for questions on the kind of main content of the report unless you guys would like to transition and talk specifically about recommendations. So does anybody have, on council first, does anyone have questions on the report? Well, I guess I just have one question that popped in my mind is how many 1031 exchanges occur here annually? Do we know?
16:21 That's a great question, and it wasn't data that I was able to collect as part of this research, but it's a very, very good question. Okay, thanks. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I just have a sort of a procedural question. How do we, how do we, how do you see us going through this? So my. This evening, like what, how would you like to. So what I thought we would do was ask questions about the main report. And then do we need to take public comment? So we'll.
16:52 Ask questions about the main report of the council, then take public comment, then go to the recommendations part of the report, ask questions, take comment, and then any discussion. Okay. If I may, we want to walk through like each recommendation. A lot of them we've already gone through and said it really applies, doesn't apply, it's being implemented. So we have a few that we want to get consensus direction on.
17:14 Thank you very much for the report. It was very interesting and a lot of interesting
17:43 Sort of observations in it. One of the things I took away from it is that at the end of the day, between the academic literature and the various markets you look at, Mammoth Lakes doesn't, you know, it's an idiosyncratic market, as they all are. And so the question, and I don't mean to put you on the spot with this at all, but the historic development of this community around
18:11 Condominium Complexes, the desire to drive tourism visitation through condo complexes with pre-internet infrastructure is a significant part of the history of this community and the legacy of how we got to where we are. And I didn't...
18:29 I didn't get a sense that that was really analyzed. In other words, the historic development of this, the infrastructure build of this community was not something that you basically said, look, I don't have data on this. There's a lot of sort of mid-high-level review of literature, but the actual world drilled down into the historic development and construction of our infrastructure wasn't really analyzed. I wonder if you could talk about that a little bit.
18:54 Yeah, that's correct. So the scope of work for this particular research was really focused in on determining whether or not a relationship is likely to exist between short-term rentals and conditions in the housing market. I definitely understand that this community was built out as a tourist destination. In particular, many of the multifamily properties, the condominium buildings, were built with the intention of them being
19:23 Second home, seasonal tourist accommodations in some form or another. That is ultimately, whether or not the town wants to discourage the continued use of those properties in that manner, I think is really more of a land use decision than something really pertaining to whether or not it...
19:45 You know, STRs affect housing markets. So at the end of the day, these are obviously local decisions. These are decisions that people in these communities need to make based on their own experience, their own understanding of what their infrastructure is like. I know we get accused of, not accused, but our attorneys from Truckee. And oh, there's a Truckee influence. So one of the things we learn is that
20:11 How housing is built and been developed into Truckee is in many ways exactly the opposite of what we have here. Largely. So these idiosyncrasies are really important to consider as we make our policy decisions over the sun. Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, there's also questions of, you know, if a large portion of that existing inventory was instantly converted over into full-time occupancy, that has impacts to sewer flow and a lot of other, you know, infrastructure-related issues, which you may or may not be
20:41 Built to accommodate. And that is really a separate question that we did not address as part of this study, but it's a very real one. Okay, good. Thank you. That's it. Anyone? Mayor Salazar, I see you have your hand up. Go ahead. I do. Thanks. One of my concerns here is we're looking at trying to convert some of these condos to long-term rentals or purchases. Have we looked at the affordability? Have we looked at whether or not with the cost of building
21:10 We would just be creating a market for other wealthy people to buy them before they came down to the affordability for locals. Have we looked at any of that? We are so different from other areas. I don't see us being able to affect the market to the point where it gets affordable for locals, even missing middles or even two times AMI. So that's a great question. We did look at that to some extent.
21:36 Existing condo pricing would be affordable to at least a portion of the workforce, obviously not all. There's oftentimes questions, particularly in the more recent housing market that we've seen where there have been multiple offers on most properties, a lot of all cash offers.
21:55 And things of that nature, local workforce households, even if they can afford that price point, simply get out competed because their offer isn't quite as attractive as something coming in from outside the area that's all cash. That's a reality that we've seen in a lot of jurisdictions and something we've heard had been occurring in Town of Mammoth Lakes as well. And then there's also the question of, you know, how many properties would rather than being
22:22 Put on the market for sale would be converted to long-term rental. That's a question. We don't know that number per se. The only real data point that we have is really from the City of South Lake Tahoe. Following implementation of Measure T, the city has documented about 10 to 15% of the units that were previously in short-term rental use have rolled over into some form of full-time occupancy, either
22:51 For sale or for rent. There aren't a lot of other data points. It's a rather difficult metric to track, and most other jurisdictions haven't been doing a particularly good job of that. In Tahoe, were those primarily single-family residences, houses or condos, one? Two, when we looked at the affordability and people being able to buy them locally out of the workforce, did we take into consideration the HOA fees as huge as they are in Mammoth?
23:21 to add on to the monthly payments to create the affordability. Great questions. In the city of South Lake Tahoe is predominantly single-family homes, but there were some condominiums, I believe, involved in that inventory.
23:34 In terms of the assessment of affordability, we did consider HOA fees as part of that. However, it can be a little bit difficult considering that HOAs vary from property to property and can vary quite widely depending on special assessments and the age of the property, how well it's been maintained, things of those nature. Thank you. Can I ask one quick follow-up question? Of course. At the end of the day, we could get with staff and do this research, but if you look at
24:08 AMI levels here. And you took whatever sample of a condo complex, which is not to single out condos, but that's the stock we've got, to bring a condo with an average of an HOA fee into like 150 AMI level from current market valuations, that analysis was not done. We did look at the affordability of condominium sales. Let me see if I can actually pull up the specific numbers if you'd like. Give me just a moment.
24:39 But we did look at that. We looked at a variety of condominium sales, and we compared that to affordable purchase prices, and included a discussion related to HOA fees, and discussed the general range that we were seeing. So when you say affordable, you're talking about in the context of AMI law. Correct. Correct. And I mean, just anecdotally, I think the sense is that in order to bring
25:05 Those, that pricing down to get into the AMI levels we're trying to attract, it's a, it would be a significant, you're talking about a significant set of reductions to try to get even in that neighborhood, right? Well, we were looking specifically at current resale values of condominium units as being affordable in the sort of moderate to a portion of the above moderate range. You can take your time, we'll get back to that later, but I just wanted to.
25:34 That analysis would be of interest. Yeah, that analysis is in the report. I'm narrowing in on it now. So I think we were looking at something around like 180 to 200 percent of AMI as being potentially affordable, if I recall correctly, for condominium purchase at what's a little bit higher than a current interest rate. When I did the analysis, interest rates were a little bit higher.
26:12 But that analysis is included in the report. Okay, but maybe just expand upon that a little bit. So you're saying you were looking at $180 to $200 AMI. How does that align? Is that where current condo valuations are at? Correct. That's based more or less on a comparison to the median sale price for condominium units in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, and the numbers are in the report? Correct. What page is it? It's around... Is your page 32? Yeah. Yeah, that's table five.
26:41 Is the affordable purchase prices and then the discussion prior to that, I believe starting on page 29. Okay, yeah, I've got that flagged. Okay, thank you. Absolutely. Okay, everyone good? I'm going to ask mine. Okay, great. So just two questions to start that are to clarify a question a constituent asked that I want to make sure we get answered. So I think it's on page, let's see.
27:15 Okay, so the first was on page 23. And that's the question about, this person asked me, they said a third of all STRs are controlled by a handful of people, a small number of people, and that's the chart. And is that, do we have clarity, and this may be a question for staff more than Erin.
27:46 Do we have clarity? Because I think a lot of that is property management companies. But do we know about the number of individuals that own a large number of STRs? Yes. We've done some analysis before. We do have an idea of how many out there that have a multitude of them. They're not a great deal of that. That would be the ownership of each of the properties and also managing them as sort of a property manager. It's somewhere less than 10.
28:17 Sure. That's why I clarified. And then the next question was
28:47 Aaron, could you just comment on the fact that there were 500 new short-term rentals and 300 fewer long-term rentals over the last decade? That's on page 25. Just comment on that finding and how that might compare to other places. Right. So that's generally based on a comparison of census data. There's a lot of factors involved there.
29:17 In general, it's reflective of an increase in particular seasonal occupancy of housing within the town of Mammoth Lakes where more units are sitting vacant for a portion of the year that are occupied incrementally. That's predominantly what I think is explaining the change. Thank you. And then one of the things that you pointed out at the beginning this evening, but that
29:48 And I can't find the place in the report where it stated that there's not great correlation. There's a member of the public who keeps commenting on a piece of the report that there's not great correlation between short-term rentals and the availability of housing. And yet, then you also state that
30:20 The concentration of the short-term rentals has an impact. So, for example, in Town of Mammoth Lakes, I believe that it was in RMF II, 50% of the units hold short-term rental certificates. Is that the right number? Okay, good. Some of this I'm doing from memory, sorry. And so if that's the case, wouldn't that be a higher proportion than almost anywhere else? And wouldn't that have an impact? And is there any way for your firm to do an analysis?
30:50 You know, I realize that it will be based on empiric evidence, but you could do economic analysis of that specific question. So there's a few questions there. I'll start with the first one, which is, if I recall the comment you're referring to, I believe they're sort of misstating the findings from the report in a couple of different ways. So first and foremost, the review of the academic and professional literature,
31:19 Almost unanimously found that there are relationships between the presence of short-term rentals in a market and housing availability and pricing. The exact degree to which STRs are affecting the market can vary based on a variety of things, concentration being one of them. That individual also has, I believe, commented relating to my comments around
31:46 Second home ownership being the primary market distortion with short-term renting being one of the factors that facilitates second home ownership. And so I just wanted that to be sort of clear that short-term renting and short-term rental regulation is in some ways working at the margins of the issue. It's not taking on second home ownership directly.
32:11 That said, I'm not familiar with any tools that are really available to local jurisdictions to directly impact the ability of somebody to purchase a second home. And so you're relegated to these inherently marginal tools and levers to try and influence the second home market to the extent possible. And that may be things like short-term rental regulation, limitations on where fractional ownership units can be located.
32:40 Things of that nature. I'll also acknowledge that if you were in a situation where you could simply rapidly build a large number of units or could purchase a large number of units and de-restrict them for workforce and affordable housing in such volumes that it addresses the need, you wouldn't have to worry about short-term rental regulation as a marginal tool to influence the market. It'd be addressing things more directly.
33:07 However, you're largely constrained in terms of your land availability, your ability to build units rapidly. And so it puts you in a position where there's a rationale to try and utilize your existing housing stock more efficiently. And that may involve trying to influence a second home market through things like short-term rental regulation. Your final point speaking to...
33:35 The impact of short-term rental specifically in the RMF2 zone. I would venture from my professional opinion that a 50% concentration of short-term rental registered short-term rentals as a proportion of the total housing inventory in a specific area is going to have a significant influence on pricing and demand for those units in the market.
34:01 Because there's a clear demonstrated ability to market those units to the tourist industry, occupy those units, and it may in many cases be a defining characteristics of those unit when an individual is going to or considering purchasing one of those units. The exact impact on pricing may vary and is much more difficult to pin down through statistical analysis. Okay.
34:33 So now we will take public comment, but it's specific to the report, correct? And it's not questioning, it's just comment. So can I get clarity? Because I want to make sure we do this correctly. Chris, and I think, you know, maybe what John was asking earlier, I want, from a staff perspective, we've gone through the 24 recommendations, and we've got comments to talk about each of them.
35:03 Some of them are being done already. Some of them are complete already. Some of them are under review. Some of them are not applicable. And some of them are policy items. So I think while general comments about just like you guys did asking questions of the report or just generally making comments about the report is fine. But I would think that as we go through these.
35:28 And I do plan to go through each one of them, just at least maybe to explain why they were labeled as such, and you guys can make a different determination. But when we get to a policy item, I think tonight is really about getting consensus for staff. We're not going to make any decisions, I think, from a perspective as that. I do need, though, clarity on where we have, if we have the majority of people consenting to have staff pursue this.
35:56 Then that will be our direction, right, to go and work on that. And so I think at that point we might have to pause and get some public comment on that. It might be a little bit of a mix-up. Dan, you can weigh in if you think differently. But I think that's going to be the approach that's most efficient to get through it. That's fine. I figured Andy would have something to say. So you have to take public comment on any aspect of this item.
36:26 Tell the public that they're limited only to questions or limited only to comments. And you have to take all the public comment before the council really starts deliberating. So the council could simply ask questions and then take public comment. But if you're going to start really thinking this through or starting to deliberate and make decisions, the public comment has to have been completed prior to that. So. Because at the point of order, I may be wrong here, but are we taking
36:56 My understanding is this is sort of a workshop format. Correct. So the question that Annie brought about making decisions and taking votes, where does this, what type of agenda item is this? Yeah, we weren't expecting votes. Yeah, it's not really asking to vote instead, but we are looking for clear direction so that would be deliberation to some degree and say, okay, do you want us to continue to work on an item or not? We'll need to pull that out, otherwise we'll have a lot of information.
37:22 Have to bring everything back. Okay, understood. So Andy, does that meet the threshold of the public comment advice you were giving? Well, to the extent that the council is going to provide direction, you will, as Dan said, you will be deliberating in order to do that. So we do need to take public comment. And again, the public comment can be about anything having to do with the BAA report, because that is how this has been agendized. Andy, would it be okay if we
37:51 Let's say we got to one of the policy items, or I guess in any one of those items, Pro Tem, Mayor Pro Tem could ask for public comment after each item is presented? Yes, you can segment the discussion if the council can remember to not start deliberating on a different piece as to which the public has not yet been allowed to provide comment. That you can do. I think you were just reminding the public that their questions may not be answered.
38:22 You know, they can ask questions, but it's not that, you know, John's not going to be able to address them all directly. Correct. So it was two parts. But I was also just making sure that we also followed the procedure correctly. So what will happen is if we let the staff talk about the recommendations one by one, and then we ask questions as a council, then we stop, no deliberation, the public's allowed to comment.
38:50 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
39:21 So public comment number three on the agenda was public comment for matters not on the agenda. And then we're on number four, policy matters. So if you had something not on the agenda, you unfortunately. OK. We're on policy matter 4.1. OK?
39:53 Thanks. Okay. So the first recommendation is an update to the definition of short-term rental. We labeled this one as under review. And that's because this really draws attention to different types of short-term rentals that really we don't have a proliferation of them in the town. So it's not something that we see as a high priority. It's something we can review.
40:21 Through update. But we are basically not recommending any discussion on this further. We were just in review on that. Okay. Any questions or any public comment? Just a question. So if I guess if staff were determined that you did want to make a change to the definition, does that require an update to the municipal code?
40:46 It would, yes. So we are rewriting Sections 3 and 5 that do address that. That will be before Council actually on the 6th of March now, not the 21st as we talked about. That will not impact the timing in which we discussed, you know, how the implementation of them, if you will, the April 22nd date. But yes, those would require an update of the definition section at the beginning of Code Section 3.
41:14 And it just talks about what it is. Okay. So with the Certified Property Program, which I think we all have a consensus to move forward on, do you believe that the definition that we have is sufficiently consistent with the Certified Property Program so you can implement it? Yes. That's correct. Yeah. Okay. All right. Okay. Any other questions on recommendation number one, update the definition of an STR? Mayor Souser, any questions on that? He's on mute. You're on mute.
41:50 Okay, no questions on it. When I'm looking at other documents, it won't let me do my normal unmute. Okay, sorry. So then we, are we going through every recommendation because there are, I can't hear you. No, there's 24 recommendations. We can group a couple of these together with the ones we'll have, and then you can take comments on two or three of them. There'll be a couple where we're going to want more discussion, so we'll pause on those to make sure there's adequate time for public comment.
42:17 Yeah, I think, I mean, the complexity of this, we are trying to go through it in such a way that people can follow along. I could jump to the six or seven policy items, but it's really jumping around, and I just don't know if people would be able to follow along. So that was my thought, as we go through each and every one of them. I didn't know it was going to be this cumbersome as far as questions and public comment, because some of them are, we're doing it. So hopefully there's not a lot of public comment around that.
42:44 But we do have to allow for it. So now that we've had that one and the council has asked their questions, I need to take public comment. Is there any public comment on recommendation number one, which was to update the definition of a short-term rental? Okay, go ahead. Travis, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Okay. So
43:25 Rob, go ahead. But I think it would make sense to group as many as you can where there's no action or else we're going to be here all night. Thanks. I would agree. Okay. Second item is the maintenance of records allowing more analysis. This is being accomplished through certified properties updates. We will be collecting data on a monthly basis on every unit, talking about the availability of it.
43:49 The nights rented, the rates, the total gross receipts by unit. So we will have a lot of statistical data on that. This is basically taken care of as part of certified properties. The other element, if you want me to jump through the certified properties components, number five was updating TOT property search tools. As I've presented last time,
44:17 That is currently live on our town's website where we show all registered. Hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on. Yeah, that's. I think we really need to stick with one item at a time. I think we can do this efficiently. Questions from council. I think, look, the public has asked for this. Council members have asked us for a review of this document. Let's just do it methodically because if we start jumping around, it's. I thought he was going to go through an order. Yeah, so we're. All right, I'm not following along. Okay, I can go one at a time. Let's just go one at a time. Item number two. Okay.
44:46 Item number two, does anyone on council have question on item number two, which was maintaining records to allow ongoing analysis? No questions. Okay. Any public comment on item number two, maintaining records to allow ongoing analysis? Jamie, anyone online? Seeing none, Rob, go on to number three. Sorry, just to be clear. So if there is no, there's no.
45:14 Ask for consensus. So we're assuming if there's no public comment, no questions from council, the staff presentation stands when we move forward, right? Correct. Okay, good. Thank you. Item number three is a policy item, and this is updating code language on vested interests. So it specifically had stated in the recommendations, and this would be a part of our municipal code edits that we would bring forth on the 6th of March.
45:43 And it talks about how vacation home rental permits shall not be, and this, I'm kind of reading some mocked up language that has already been included before, but it's about vacation home rentals permits shall not be construed as providing property rights or vested interests in entitlements in continued operation of a vacation rental home. Vacation rental permits are revocable licenses which require, which expire annually, and vacation
46:12 Home rental permits shall not run with the land. So that was language that was recommended. It has been vested. It talks specifically about how the permit process is not a right, but is a permit provided by the town to the operator, whether it be a certified property owner or whether it be a business tax certificate holder who is an operator to rent that.
46:38 We can add those components to our municipal code update, but I would like to have consensus from council on that. So if there are any questions, I'm happy to answer that. Any questions on number three, which is the vested interest? This was, may I clarify, this was part of the certified property program recommendation from the committee, correct? No, this was actually a part of the BAE report for activity that...
47:05 Has been, I'm going to say, challenging in other jurisdictions. And this particular language clarifies that, the components about how it expires and how it's not a right, but it's something that's administered by the town. And I think in this particular case, that had been, had gone through some legal challenges and were upheld. So we felt comfortable that it would sustain.
47:29 That was, that's an element that could be a part of ours, but it's not currently a part of it. I see, but it is consistent with our intention. It's just improved language. Thank you. Great. Any questions from council? Quick question. Will the full, where will the full language of this be available to the public? Would that be next week?
47:48 So the full language on that would come forth on the 6th of March with the rest of the certified properties components. Good. Okay. So folks have a chance to see the full language. Yep. And has Andy Emerson will take a look at this and he can offer any legal insight? He's going to review everything that we put together on that process for sure. Okay. Good. Thank you. Yep.
48:08 Any public comments on this item number three, recommendation number three, update the code language on vested interests? Seeing none in the room, Jamie? Oh, okay. I realize that I don't have the language in front of me right now, so I guess I would really like to have it clarified when you're talking about that, you know, there's not a right that this moves forward, and I understand that, that expires annually.
48:44 But are there any type of clarification as to why this might not move forward annually if you're doing your business and acting in an honorable way? So anyways, it concerns me that it could say that it can expire annually, but you've been doing everything in your power to do things properly, but you can have that right taken away. Thank you. Jamie, anyone online? Okay.
49:19 I realized I had a comment. My name is Ted Carlton. I had a comment about a statement you made earlier, and I realized, well, which of the 24 points of order would this fall under? I'm not sure I want to wait, so I want to get at it, which was you mentioned in the study you said that we'd lost 300 long-term rentals and gained 500 STRs over the decade. I think it was 2010 to 2020.
49:50 Between like 2005 and 2009, this community built a whole bunch of affordable housing and then managed to mismanage a lot of the deed restrictions which were lost. How many of those, do we have any numbers on the number of deed restrictions that were lost and how many of those were converted to SDRs? It would be kind of interesting, are those 300 and 500 numbers, do they correlate with the town's mismanagement of that program?
50:26 I don't think, so the, when you have a deed restriction program, one of the things that you have is first right of refusal to purchase that property to retain that deed restriction. If you don't have funds to purchase the property, you lose that right. So it's not necessarily a mismanagement, it might be a lack of funds. With regard to the time, during that period of time, with regard to the data information, I think, Nolan, you might have some on that, but I'd.
50:55 I don't know if you've got it off right now. I don't have the exact numbers that we lost, but my recollection of the deed restrictions that we lost in that time were primarily in the San Joaquin Villas, Meridian Court, Aspen Village, and the Gray Eagle Complexes on Mountain Boulevard. And at least for Meridian Court, Aspen Village, and San Joaquin Villas, none of those units then became short-term rentals because there's other prohibitions in place.
51:27 In those complexes that prevent them from being short-term rentals. Within the Gray Eagle complex, the units that were deed restricted are the use permit on that complex still prohibits them from being short-term rental. So even though they're not deed restricted, they're not short-term rental units. All right. Continuing along, we are now. I'm sorry. Please state your name. I'm Rob Knott, constituent and long-term realtor.
52:06 We have lost a few properties that were deed restricted for resale. And I still don't quite, I'll save that comment for later. But in reference to affordable housing and deed restricted properties, I know we have the sort, well, now you're calling it the parcel, and now we're looking at maybe doing some rentals for the first 80 units that are coming up due. But in terms of sales,
52:37 It's my understanding that the fourth phase is when purchase of those units over this order will be available, which could be three, four, for all we know, five years down the road. And our biggest concern right now for the moratorium is workforce housing. I think it's terrific that we're offering properties for lease for workforce housing coming up, and I guess it's for city units.
53:07 When it comes to terms of purchasing, for low-income housing and workforce housing, you know, three, four years may not be too long down the road to wait, but maybe we could do a combination at this point, because right now I still don't see the purpose of this moratorium that we have in its place. And it was my understanding, talking to some council members, that this could possibly be resolved in February.
53:39 And I don't see it happening. And lastly, no matter how we bring down the resale market, unless these properties that are brought down are deed restricted, the buying public is going to gobble them up. Because over the course of the last three, four years, especially since the start of the moratorium, we've seen a good number of the buying public wanting to get out of Southern California, LA Orange, and San Diego counties.
54:12 As well as San Francisco and throughout the nation, they're buying these properties. And if we see a drop in property values for listings that are not deed restricted to the local public only, they're never going to buy. Because in the last few years, we have seen multiple offer situations, properties selling over listed price, if not at full price. As of most recently,
54:44 We're looking at very little, if anything, under listed price, but properties selling at listed price in conventional matters. But with what we're looking at today... Excuse me, I'm so sorry, but we're trying to stick to the agenda, so this is about items on the agenda. And lastly, I think it was Miranda brought up 1031 exchanges. Well, we don't have a lot of 1031 exchanges here in Mammoth.
55:14 But it's not uncommon at all. But what I don't quite understand is what impact a 1031 exchange transaction would have on workforce housing. Thank you very much. Thank you. All right. So item number four, please. So staff was looking for some consensus from council on item number three. Oh, right. Sorry about that. As to whether they include that language or not in the municipal code.
55:48 Anyone? Do you want to vote or do you want us to do a consensus? Just consensus, so are you? I think that's a good idea. I would follow that recommendation. You okay with that? Yeah, just I think the comments about the language being fully available. Yep. That would be important because it is, it sounds a little bit provocative, so it'd be good to get that, make sure that language is available. Yes, and the earlier the better. And then Mayor Salzer? I would agree that. I would agree we move this forward, making no decisions on it until we see the actual language. Of course. Thank you.
56:18 Okay. Now item number four. Thank you. Yes, item number four labeled as in review. Item number four is requiring STR platforms to submit data. We realized this would be wonderful if this would actually work. And talking...
56:37 A little bit more with Aaron about that recommendation. Some very large municipalities have been able to get the platforms to provide data to them. We have not been successful in that. So this would be writing aspects into our municipal code that says they're required to do that. We didn't put it into the current work program because it's, I'm going to just be frank, it's a bit pie in the sky for us.
57:06 And so I didn't want to spend our time and energy on that at the moment with all the other things we had in flight. So I think we have it under review. I do have conversations ongoing with Airbnb about some data that they can provide to us, but it's not the level of data that we are even discussing of collecting with our normal certified properties component.
57:28 And when you think about a single unit possibly being advertised on multiple platforms, capturing that data gets a little bit complex, right? So if we're asking for the information by unit from the operator or owner, then that's a little bit better, right? We go through enforcement cases. We're spending a lot of time getting this data, but it's through the operator itself. So we said that's in review. We're not interested in pursuing it tonight. Since that's the case, do we even need to have discussion?
57:57 I'm going to move on. Just if there's questions and just if there's public comment, then we'll go to the next. All right. Questions on number five? Four. Four. Thank you. Yeah, I think I appreciate to some degree the position we are. It's been repeated. We were stated earlier that an SDR market, we're one of the largest in the state of California per capita. And I think for all of us to understand that there are exigent forces at work. Your microphone. Sorry.
58:27 That there are exigent forces at work in all this, such as big technology, large, you know, public, capitally profit-motivated data manipulation services, which are these platforms. Maybe we can't do anything about it, but I don't want us just to toss in the towel and give up the fight. So I'm not going to push for it tonight, but I think we all need to be aware that there are things beyond our control that are driving all this. And I don't...
58:54 Suggest we should just go meekly into the night, but I appreciate the position you're in. So thank you. All right. Are there any public comments in the room or online on item number four, requiring STR platforms to submit data? Okay. Moving on to number five, updating the TOT property search tool. Yes. So this is a part of our certified properties program implemented. It's currently live.
59:24 We have a website which would provide all the details associated with a particular unit, and that's allowing any general public who may be nearby to use a map function to find that, because they'll know exactly where they are. They can find that particular unit and get information off of that. With the certified properties, it's a part of that because some of the aspects that we are implementing with that program would then be added to the data available on the platform, but that is a part of our process.
59:54 All right. Any questions? I see any questions from you, Bill? No, I think he's good. So any public comment in the room or online? Okay. And no, you don't need? I don't need anything. Item number six, I will need, this is a policy item. Okay. This is prohibiting short-term rental renting of properties recently subject to eviction.
1:00:25 So as the recommendation was produced to reduce the incentive for property owners to evict existing tenants in order to convert the property to a short-term rental, consider prohibiting units that have recently been subject to an eviction from being registered as a short-term rental for a specific period.
1:00:44 The town may also consider prohibiting short-term renting properties that are recently used for long-term rentals, though identifying such properties may be challenging at times. This particular one was narrowed down to that that had been a subject of an eviction, and we'd like your input or we'd like direction on whether we should pursue that, because that's going to be a lot. It's going to be fairly complex. It's not something that we're going to be able to write into the code, I think, so quickly, because there are
1:01:14 Aspects that we have to analyze as far as what the eviction reasons were. It's not necessarily someone doing well and then getting evicted so that something could be made to short-term. It may be some other reason. So we have to draw those distinctions in what we write. But what I would be looking for is consensus on whether or not we pursue this. Questions from? Would that prohibition
1:01:42 Follow the sale of a property? If I were to evict my tenant today and then sell my property next month, would that follow the sale of it or no? So the sale, the certified property registration does not go with the sale. So it's a reapplication, if you will, for that. And if you put something in place that says if you evicted someone in order to do that, then that would apply, correct? So that would follow, okay.
1:02:12 Rob, my question here is how much extra staff time do you see this taking? Staff time is, after all, money. I like the idea of not being able to evict short-term rent. I would agree with that. However, it depends on, you know, resources. Yeah, I think some of this, you know, if you talk about some of the detailed analysis, it certainly will take time.
1:02:37 We are, as a part of the certified properties, adding some staff on to do some administration and enforcement activities. But yes, this will take a degree of time. I would say probably a few months for analysis and implementation based on everything else we're doing, right? As the certified properties is updated, we are currently building the platform by which to collect the data. We have to onboard all the units. So we are deep into a lot of heavy lifting in the revenue collection team.
1:03:07 All right. John, did you have a question? Did Andy do have any thoughts on this, on the legal realities of doing something like this? Well, in general, the town is not required to allow anyone a short-term rent. So since the town can completely ban short-term rentals if it were so inclined, and nobody's talking about that, it means the town can restrict short-term rentals.
1:03:30 I think we would want to be very careful in our definition of what would be an eviction. So this is something that, as Rob said, requires further study and further and a great deal of care, rather, in how it's set up. But the concept, I think, is perfectly fine. My question is, do we have a sense of if this is actually a problem in our community? I have heard of circumstances by which this has occurred. I don't know that it's a broad problem, but it has existed in the last couple of years.
1:04:03 All right. And then are there any public comments in the room? Seeing none. Any online? Okay. So then I guess the question is for council just to give some guidance on it. So I guess really what's the policy question? Do you want us to say whether we're pursuing this in the short term? Yeah. Do you want us to pursue this and bring it back to you as far as a work program that could
1:04:37 Provide restrictions on when my staff would be able to issue a certified property certificate for a particular unit. And so this would be additional data. It wouldn't necessarily go into effect, obviously, with what we're doing right now on certified properties, but it would be a work plan to bring back to you probably mid-summer. Okay. So the question is, would we entertain this not as part of the certified properties program that we're
1:05:06 Implementing in the short-term, but something that staff can look into and come back to us with later. I would like to see this. I think that... Your mic's not on again. I'm sorry. I'll just leave it on. You're killing Amanda. Just leave your mic on. I'll just leave it on. I would very much like to see this come forward. I think I don't see this short-term rental problem.
1:05:27 Thank you. All right. Are you clear? Are you good with that one? Yeah.
1:05:58 Okay, number seven, establish a waiting period for new home purchases. I'm assuming if there was objection, objection, they would come out. I got nods. That's why I went to Mayor Sauser. Everyone else nodded yes. Perfect. Thank you. Item seven, establish a waiting period for new home purchases to receive a certified property certificate. So this...
1:06:25 You know, as an option, so I'll read, you know, what the recommendation established a waiting period for at least one year following the purchase of a residential property before that property is eligible to apply for an SDR permit, in our case to be registered as a certified property, and to be added to a potential wait list. This creates an uncertainty regarding the ability to generate revenue through the short-term renting. It may reduce the price premium that investors are willing to pay. So the question I have as a policy item for you all.
1:06:54 Is do you want to impose a waiting period before a new purchase can obtain a short-term rental certificate or make a certified property? All right. So first of all, any questions? Yeah. So in the certified property program, when you say a waiting period, who's waiting? So in this particular instance, as I stated earlier, when you sell a property,
1:07:26 The certification does not go with the property. The new owner would have to reapply for that with the town. And under our current certified properties program, as it's outlined in our practices, they could apply for it the day they bought it, right, the day it closes. And we have a certain process to go through to issue that, but it would be issued right away. This question then is, do we want to prevent that from happening for a period of time? It said in here, you know, for a
1:07:55 At least a year, I'd say probably up to a year, or some other period of time, less than that, if you wish. But that would restrict them from receiving the ability to rent in that period of time. And at this point, staff is not anticipating this is tied to any kind of a cap on the number of certificates available, correct? That's correct. This assumes there is no cap, but there would just be a waiting period. That's a separate question later on, yes. Okay.
1:08:23 Any other questions? Any questions from? Oh, wait, we're doing with council first. Okay. Mayor Sauser, you have a question on this matter or this item? No questions, just comment. Okay. So, Jamie, since these are very specific and we have so many of them, can we do three minutes for public comment? Okay, great. So, if you have public comment, please come to the podium and state your name. I'm just wondering, what is the purpose of
1:09:00 A 12-month lag time in order to start short-term rentals for new purchases of condominiums. If there is not for getting certificates. So the basis for the recommendation is to insert some uncertainty into that purchase decision.
1:09:28 For second home buyers, it could be for condos, it could be for single family properties, but essentially it means for some period of time, the buyer can't rely on that income to help them defray purchase and hold costs, which may influence some prospective buyers in terms of their purchase decisions.
1:10:11 It's kind of moved along, and it's a little bit of a concern, because we're kind of almost assuming that we're going to do this and move forward. So, you know, if you're looking at a 12-month waiting period, if you wanted to do a waiting period at all, I don't see that a 12-month waiting period would be good. It should be much shorter. And I think you need to be very careful, because it's been mentioned earlier. There's a lot of folks out there with cash that would like to come up here.
1:10:38 And do something like this. 12 waiting period is not going to be an issue with them. They can outbid any of the people that are trying to buy this locally. You could just do exactly the opposite of what you want to do now and also reduce our 70% income that you guys have to use to function on. Thank you. Anyone else in the room with a comment on number seven about waiting periods? Then online. We'll go to online.
1:11:10 Galaxy Note 9, unmute yourself and give your comments. If you have your hand up online, please state your question. All right. So now the staff is requesting our input on whether we want to pursue establishing waiting period of at least one year. Mayor Salzer, I see your finger up. Is that you wanting to speak? It certainly is, and I thank you, Chris.
1:12:08 So a waiting period to me only does what Terry was alluding to. It's going to give second home buyers who don't need to rent an opportunity to buy that. It will not bring the price down enough for locals to buy. So we not only lose a potential long-term rental, we also lose the short-term rental which creates our income. So I am not interested in this. So I have
1:12:40 A question for this. How does this get, is this through the municipal code, is this how this gets put into place? Yes, so this would be a part of the municipal code and then enforced by my team. Okay, so if we wanted to come back and revisit something like this in a year or two, would a moratorium be necessary to put something like this in place? No. Okay, and would it require a municipal code update to do that? It would, yes. Okay.
1:13:09 So I don't support this either at this time. I'm thinking we'll talk to some of these other policy issues that come later as part of a comprehensive package of, is this my microphone? No. It's the person that had a public comment that didn't talk. Galaxy Note 9. Watch Jamie do this. Yeah. Okay. See? That's where the power lies. Yep. Right there. I'm looking at these elements.
1:13:37 With somewhat of a maybe a strategic kind of perspective. And so I think at this time, I'm not supportive of something like this yet. I'm looking at the package, the recommendations coming out of the advisory committee, the things that are going to happen with the parcel, how the market might move around, the opportunity to put a revenue measure on the ballot for next year. I'm kind of looking to see, let's put those things in place and see what happens. And we can talk about it more. But I want to just give you an insight into kind of how I'm thinking about this. At this point, at this time, I'm not supporting this.
1:14:07 Something like this. You know, this is something that I have expressed curiosity about since we began these discussions. And can I ask a question of Aaron? I don't know how much follow-up you've done in the communities that you've done studies in or in communities that have implemented these. I know that you mentioned at our previous meeting that this was something that
1:14:32 You had seen be potentially effective. You know, in regards to the concerns about people who don't need the short-term rental income snapping up properties, can you speak to that at all? Is that something you've seen? We don't necessarily have good data on that for comparison jurisdictions. From talking to staff, I've been hearing that
1:14:55 There's a perception that wait periods are reasonably effective. That's mostly coming from jurisdictions that also have caps that have resulted in wait lists. So in some cases you have say a one year waiting period, then the person applies, then they have to get on a six to 12 to 24 month wait list to actually get a permit under the cap system, which interjects a really significant
1:15:18 Amount of uncertainty into the buying process about whether or not they can generate income. That said, it doesn't preclude them from long-term renting the unit in the interim. That's always an option that could generate income.
1:15:33 It influences the ability to buy a unit under a 1031 exchange and use the STR income to rationalize the exchange. Again, they could do it as a long-term rental and still facilitate the exchange if it's rented for at least the minimum period during the initial two-year period. So it wouldn't preclude a 1031 exchange if they rented it long-term? Correct. That's very interesting. I had a follow-up, but it disappeared.
1:16:04 Maybe we can go to Amanda and come back to you. I understand what you're saying, Bill, where you feel like it would make Mammoth Lakes, you know, more palatable to ultra wealthy people that can just buy it up and afford to not rent it for a year. I also, I guess I feel like, well, it's kind of an interesting thing and it would stop people who are strictly buying investment properties. So maybe that is enough to
1:16:35 You know, help us a little bit. I don't know. Yeah, and just, if I could, just to follow a little bit on that. Another question is I've been, we've all been weighing these and working through these questions. If you, if the goal for this community is to put people into units, put people into housing units, I guess the question is, and you've talked eloquently this evening about these are marginal tools. These are tools around the edges. It doesn't sound like
1:17:06 The nexus is obvious of putting in place a restriction like this that somehow, how do you get from that to getting somebody into a unit? And I think in my mind, I'm thinking about kind of a package of restriction on when you can get a certificate and maybe there's caps and maybe all those kind of more punitive tools. But even with those things, the question I still have is, well, if you do all that stuff, how does that get someone into a unit? And maybe you could...
1:17:33 Talk that a little bit. Yeah, that's a great question. And it's inherently deeply complicated, right? You've got a lot of various factors involved and a lot of things that aren't under the local government's control. You're hoping to influence markets. You can't dictate what markets do. And so I think that's a good concern. In the case of a full moratorium on short-term renting, we saw 10 to 15% conversion.
1:18:01 It's not clear exactly what these sort of less intrusive interventions, the extent to which they're effective in terms of actually getting people into units.
1:18:11 It's also why some of the- When you say full moratorium, I mean, you're talking about a market that has an indefinite moratorium? Well, so that's mainly leaning on the South Lake Tahoe example. Right. Where, yeah, they don't allow short-term rental in most residential neighborhoods. They've seen 10 to 15 percent of units previously enrolled as short-term rentals converting to long-term occupancy. That's the first time I've ever heard that.
1:18:36 Well, and this goes to, like, South Lake Tahoe. It's a very idiosyncratic. I understand. I get it. But it's sort of the extreme example. I'm aware. But it's just, I never heard that specific. Okay. So, you know, it is a question, the extent to which these various tools will have beneficial outcomes. It's also why some of the later recommendations towards the end of this list are specifically speaking to complementary programs.
1:19:02 So I can see short-term rental regulation being effective, particularly in the near term, as a way to create space in the market for some of these other tools to be more effective. Things like deed restriction purchase programs, down payment assistance, you know, rental assistance, things of that nature. Right. And the only other thing that's in the back of my mind is the social cost.
1:19:28 The community cost and the need for a community to be coherent as they take on challenges like this and that at what point do you pull the trigger that's going to really, okay, set every, you know, really start getting into that really tough stuff. At what point is the right point to do that? And that's something that I consider. So a couple of questions and then if you think of your, or did you think of your shit? It was more of a comment, you know, I just, the pause, I've been,
1:19:57 You know, we've gotten so many emails from people who say, I just, I just want to, you know, I want to be a part of this community. I want to have my piece of paradise and shop at your stores and a pause, to me, would still allow people to have that. It would just require them to maybe wait for a minute and maybe rent to a local for a year so they could get their 1031 exchange and then they could short-term rent.
1:20:26 Aaron, have you seen any community do a waiting period without caps at the same time? Not to my recollection. Okay, and then can you talk about communities you're aware of that have done the one-year waiting period? There are a number of them that have the one-year waiting period. The one that I'm most familiar with offhand is Town of Truckee. It's relatively new. They also have one of the more aggressive caps that has resulted in a wait list.
1:20:58 Again, what I'm hearing from staff is that it's been relatively effective. I don't have specific numbers on, you know, the volume of transactions or whatnot. We haven't done that follow-up yet. Okay. Can you refresh our memory of what the Truckee cap is? In terms of numbers or percent of the housing stock, I don't have that offhand. Okay. I can get that for you. All right. I can tell you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I can tell you that the cap is something like
1:21:28 1,300 units, which Truckee set at the number of STR certificates that it had outstanding before it adopted the cap. It is a lower percentage of the housing stock than in Mammoth Lakes, but like Erin, I don't recall the exact number. Okay. But it was kind of, it became capped around where it was. It wasn't like something out in the future. Okay. And that's very common. Most of the caps that I've seen go in.
1:21:54 More or less around the current number of permitted SDRs. And so it limits further penetration into the housing market, but isn't necessarily revoking permits. And we can talk about that more when we get to the cap item. Okay. So staff needs some consensus around the waiting period for new home purchases. We do. And I've been
1:22:23 Keeping score, I think I've got two no's and two yes's if I were to get a consensus on that so far. To me, I think it's kind of hard to give guidance when you wouldn't do it without a cap. I don't see, no one's ever done that before and I don't really see, the only thing that would do is impact 1031 exchanges. You could do it without a cap, at least theoretically.
1:22:53 But yeah, impacting those investment decisions may or may not be a policy priority for the town council. To me, I don't want to be the first community to do a waiting period and not, it just feels... We haven't gotten to the camps yet. Yeah, that's why... Could you not vote until we... Can we come back to this?
1:23:21 Yeah, and that's, I mean, for me, that's fine, because as I've said, I'm looking at these as, you know, comprehensive things, and if we need to have these conversations, that makes a lot of sense. I'll put a big box around this one. Okay. All right. Number eight, updating fractional and timeshare codes. Yeah, so this one is really not applicable to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, great. So move on. Move on. All right. Number nine, increase enforcement penalties.
1:23:50 We have that as complete. Our town already imposes the maximum fines that are allowable under the state law. Okay. We're ahead of the game. So, number 10. Question on number 9? Go for it. Okay. But you just opened up. Now we're going to have to go through the whole thing. That's why we're here. Okay. That's what we do.
1:24:17 There's been some confusion in the community about fees, at the relationship between what it is you charge for a license, and people have said, well, why don't you just charge what you can with the licenses? And I think this relates back to state law. Could you maybe clarify that? Yeah, and this particular one is about penalties, which is a little different than the question you're asking, but I'll address the question you're asking. With regard to fees, you are required by the state of California to only charge
1:24:46 What it costs you as an organization to perform those functions to provide that service with which you are charging a fee for. And so you can't charge whatever you want. You have to charge something that makes sense with a financial calculation or a time study that says how much time a staff member spent on it, or in this case we did for certified properties, is the structure and size of our staff, how much that costs the organization, and then
1:25:15 Figuring out a way to charge that per unit out into the future. So that's how you can charge fees. Okay, but these are not fees. These are the actual penalties. These are actually the penalties. And how much discretion does the town do we have in terms of assessing penalties? So the state of California sets a maximum penalty that you can charge, and they're usually progressive. So first offense, I think it's $1,500 is your first
1:25:43 Your first starting point, and then from there it goes to 3,000, and from there it goes to 5,000. And that is in our town's municipal code, and that is what my enforcement team charges. And each day, if you will, is a next penalty if you are in the middle of some illegal activities. So are these levels, are we at the max? We are at the max. We're at the max. So we're going ahead with max. Okay. That's what Rob just said. Yeah, that's why I moved off. Yeah. Okay.
1:26:12 Is there any public comment on item number nine? Anyone online? Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I wanted to make a comment on the waiting period for new homes, but I wasn't called on. There is an article regarding South Lake Tahoe that there was a piece written in the Tahoe Daily Tribune.
1:26:44 By the President of Locals for Affordable Housing. She said his housing prices have doubled in the last decade, a staggering 44% of all housing in South Lake Tahoe. Over 700, I'm sorry, over 7,000 homes now sent empty most of the year. And I just, you know, kind of like what John mentioned, it might end up really being a decline in top taxes that the town collects because
1:27:14 If people are able to buy a home and not have to rent or not want to rent and then only come up for a few weeks at a time, it's an unintended consequence. So I just really want to caution that. Okay. So no other comments on item number nine and no policy decision needed. So we'll go on to item number 10. Okay.
1:27:49 Rob, your microphone's not on. Thank you. Just say again what you just said. Yes, item number 10, we believe is not applicable. While we do have ski leases, we do have those 90-day lease elements. We, through our enforcement team, work through that and require to physically see each one of those leases.
1:28:12 And look for just what is described here as a breakage in the lease, you know, where it ends up being less than 30 days where someone was in the home. That is a way of, I'm going to say, circumventing a ban. This would be for the non-zoned areas, RMF1s, if you will. That primarily happens there. They advertise still for, you know, longer term.
1:28:37 But it's these ski lease processes. So we have a whole process by which we review that through enforcement. So we didn't need anything else on that we felt. Okay. So if they break the lease and then they're out of compliance with our code, then what happens? That's when our enforcement team, we open a whole case on that. We go through every detail that they have.
1:29:04 They will have enforcement charges, penalties, interest, everything, the whole nine yards. Thank you. Okay. So is everyone good? That's already, are you good? Yes, I am. Thank you. Okay. Everyone? Mayor Salazar, good? Just give me a thumbs up. Okay, great. So then number 11. Yes, item 11 is a policy question. And this was regarding to caps, the number of short-term rental permitted.
1:29:33 To have in the town. So I think that's kind of self-explanatory. I don't know if you want any more detail. You can read what was written in the recommendation. But it's basically saying, do we want to cap either where we are now or slightly below or slightly above? Okay, questions. So again, with this item, how does a town implement something like this? Is this an update to the municipal code?
1:30:06 Yes, this would be an update to the municipal code and, you know, require, I think, probably additions to our tracking processes because you're basically counting every item and if it's even within zones, that activity as well. So it's going to be, you know, a fair amount of adjustment to our tracking processes to keep track of this. So it's municipal code and then there's a, the staff is going to need a bunch more
1:30:35 Resources and tools to be able to enforce it, monitor, do all that kind of stuff, right? Yeah, we would have to build processes around that, and it would be electronic, likely, so it's not staff, but it's just a little bit of time, honestly. Okay. And so if I could turn to you, if, let's say these are pretty draconian, severe measures, if all of the tools that a municipality has at its disposal, if we did everything,
1:31:03 Caps, time limits, you know, try to crush the market, try to really do to the market something to make it affordable. Again, how does that translate into housing? Especially given the fact that we have forces that are outside of the immediate market that are dictating what the market actually is. What do you have to do to get people into units?
1:31:26 Right. So again, that's a fundamental question. And unfortunately, we don't have really good numbers on exactly what that relationship is. Again, it varies from community to community. There's a lot of factors that influence those outcomes. Really, what we're talking about in terms of all of these provisions, the intent is to influence those purchase and hold decisions of second home buyers and owners.
1:31:55 Can be sort of a middle ground option between kind of openly allowing STRs, you know, with essentially freely and, you know, a full moratorium. So you can say we rely on short-term rentals for tourist accommodations that we rely on to support our local economy. We don't want to put the brakes on too hard.
1:32:22 On our local economic activity, so we want to maintain some level of short-term rental activity, but we want to make sure and try to reduce the influence of short-term renting and those related income streams as a price pressure within the housing market. And so you can set a cap with the intention of influencing future purchase transactions and limit the extent to which those buyers can rely on that income.
1:32:48 To bid up the price and expand the pool of potential buyers. But the visibility that we would have into what that would look like and the consequences is pretty, at this point, is pretty murky. Exactly what the outcome is going to be is uncertain. Exactly. And it takes a leap of faith to some extent to do something innovative. I always recommend whenever bringing these types of recommendations forward that
1:33:18 You do something and then monitor actively for some period of time to see how it's working, how it's influencing the market and be willing to make adjustments down the road as needed. And there's a certain sort of faith and commitment to that kind of a process that needs to be undertaken. Okay. Thank you. Questions?
1:33:46 I have to take a little umbrage with the term draconian because to me draconian would be severe, like putting a cap way below what it is. Okay, wait, we're not discussing it. Okay. So ask your question just so I can't. Question is, have you seen many communities put a cap that is somewhat above where their current amount of short-term rentals are?
1:34:06 Specifically, Placer County. I helped them with their, well, I did a similar study. They implemented their own regulatory updates. They elected to set the cap above the existing level by some margin. They wanted to allow, you know, some room for growth within the SDR market and in terms of their tourist accommodation inventory. To date, they have not actually hit that cap. I'm in conversations with
1:34:32 County staff to do some analysis to kind of better understand why that additional inventory hasn't been absorbed yet. So again, it's that process of establish a new requirement and then assess and see what the market response is. And has Placer County seen any increase in the housing stock for long-term rentals?
1:34:55 What would the effect of that? Do you see any measurable effect of that cap that's above where they currently are? Generally speaking, from what I'm hearing from staff, they're not seeing significant changes in the market, which would generally make sense if people can readily go and get a permit. There's no real uncertainty in the purchase transaction. They can more or less be confident that they'll be able to get the permit and generate that income. And do they have a waiting period?
1:35:25 I don't believe so. Okay. Thank you. When they enacted their cap, did they see property values drastically decline? In Placer County, they did not. In Town of Truckee, I don't believe it was a precipitous change. There has been some downward pressure on the market more recently. Nothing like what you're seeing in Palm Springs. I think that's a very unique situation. The Palm Springs market was fairly depressed for quite a long period.
1:35:56 During the pandemic, they saw a dramatic increase in demand for investment properties in the area, new short-term rental permits. There was a dramatic spike in housing prices. And now we're seeing the reverse of that. So it's really more of a near-term bubble versus this long-term incremental.
1:36:13 And do you know, with Palm Springs, didn't they put the, like, 20% cap, or do you know what their numbers were before and after? I'm not super, I'm not intimately familiar with Palm Springs. I know it mainly due to the recent media articles. Okay, thanks. Have you seen caps in, are you familiar with our Measure Z?
1:36:39 Have you seen caps in communities that have a similar structure such as we do with Measure Z because we don't have, you know, broad-based availability for short-term rentals across all zones? I'm not familiar with an immediate... Don't put your mic on. There's a lot of different paramutations. Sorry, yeah, I'm not familiar with any jurisdictions that are, you know, immediately comparable to what you're seeing in Town of Mammoth Lakes. There's a lot of different paramutations of cap structures.
1:37:10 For example, City of Santa Cruz has caps but only in certain zones where they've been seeing the most short-term rental pressure. And then other zones are less restricted, so it's sort of the inverse of what you might see in Town of Mammoth Lakes. There's a lot of different options. You can really structure it in whatever way you see fit based on conditions on the ground. Mayor Souser, you have questions about the caps specifically, item number 11? No questions. Okay.
1:37:53 I don't really have any questions. So now it would be time to take public comment. So anybody in the room have a comment? So please come to the... No, we really do have to follow the process. So please come forward. Oh, sorry, the mic. It's pretty tough to ask questions the way you guys are putting this.
1:38:37 I'm going to get kind of through here as we're moving forward. But just if I'm looking at kind of Mammoth compared to everything else, most other areas that are putting caps on or other restrictions or anything like that are far different. The makeup is far different than Mammoth is. We already have Measure Z, so you already restricted short-term rentals in residential areas because it was stated that
1:39:07 They are not really set up for a short-term rental. It becomes more of an issue with noise and traffic and trash and all of that, whereas your condos, that's what they were built for, and so that is where short-term rentals make more sense, and so that's where Measure Z, you know, was put in place. I don't know, you know, kind of where I see all this going, maybe we should throw it all out the window and open it all up.
1:39:35 But if you're going to put a cap on anything, then it needs to be town-wide. It should not be in a specific area, and I don't feel there should be caps on anything. Thank you. Chris, can I just say something? That tonight, it's kind of a, talking about it, this is not the public's final chance to comment on it. Like, this would come back to us, and you would know people's opinions when it came back, and you'd be able to address certain things later, too.
1:40:04 But thanks for commenting tonight. Right. Thank you. So any public comment online? Diane, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I guess I would like to say, I feel like this is, you know how the Weather Channel, they'll say we're going to get three feet and we get six inches and they don't come back the same day and go, oh, it didn't work or it didn't happen. So I kind of think what I would like as a public citizen is when you implement
1:40:39 All the items you decide to implement because I really don't think you really consider what the public thinks. You have a path and you're going to go on the path and you're going to hope it works. So I understand that you hope what you want works. But if it doesn't work, how about we have a moratorium on your votes, what you implemented, that it ends on a certain day because it didn't work based on science and data.
1:41:07 That's my comment. All right, Jamie, any other comments online? Veronica, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, my name is Veronica. I hold my master's from the UCLA Graduate School of Public Affairs, which includes a comprehensive program in study and urban planning. So we have come together with a goal to increase housing affordability to locals, right? So the question is, how can we achieve this goal?
1:41:39 And from an urban planning perspective, on the topic of caps and a waiting period, which do go hand in hand, many on prior committees have raised issues of decreases in property values, resale values. But there is evidence, as reported in this study, that caps and a waiting period can indeed impact or decrease resale value because
1:42:08 We don't have investors competing to purchase these homes. So in the interest of making homes more affordable for locals who are looking to purchase, both caps and the waiting period are indeed effective ways at increasing affordabilities for locals because we don't have that competition bidding wars with investors who are looking to purchase to make their home an Airbnb.
1:42:36 Of course, with this being said, a grandfathered approach to not revoke current short-term licenses would be an effective way to balance this all, keep everything level, and not further impact the affordability for locals who are trying to purchase. That is all. Thank you. Thank you.
1:43:07 Podium and state your name. Thank you. I think it's been brought to everyone's attention on more than one occasion that our buyers are not investors. When you're getting a $10,000 snow removal assessment at any given year, this is not an investment for our buyers. Thank you. All right. So now we need to give some guidance to staff.
1:43:46 on this policy. So I'll just hop in. And I think we've all been waiting to sort of have these discussions amongst ourselves. And I think part of this discussion is the fact that we've all recognized, the town has certainly recognized that the residential housing market in Mammoth is a failed market. This was a recognition that happened many years ago.
1:44:18 And so you look at the tactics that the town and the community has taken to address a failed market. So we've had opportunities. We bought 25 acres in the middle of town. We are working with a variety of, you know, affordable housing developers to take advantage of that property thing. We've developed a Housing Now program. We're buying units. We're deed restricting units. We're investing all that. We've put $30 million into a failed housing market on behalf of the residents.
1:44:48 That's the path that we're on. And so when I marry that with the historic infrastructure of how this place was built and what the infrastructure is that we have to work with to try to address this problem and combine that with the recommendations coming out of the advisory committee about bringing more revenue, putting a proposition in front of the voters to bring in revenue to keep us on that path.
1:45:15 At least for the short-term right now, I'm not saying to take these kinds of things off the table, but I think that doubling down on the investment and the strategic approach we've taken at this point makes the most sense to me in this moment, especially given the fact that, and let's imagine a scenario where we put a ballot measure on the ballot and the public rejects it. It doesn't happen.
1:45:41 We're getting into a situation with the parcel and things like that because we have a micro-wage inflation thing going on in town and people can no longer qualify for those kinds of things. That's getting us into more extreme circumstances. In that kind of a situation, I'm going to be more inclined to look at these types of measures and say, okay, look, we have to do things that are going to put at risk whatever social comity, I encourage you all to look up that word, social comity, social coherence,
1:46:11 That we have as a community of locals and an extended community. The woman made the point that people who live their mammoth dream by being able to afford to supplement the income to be able to make this stuff work. So I'm looking at that conflagration of circumstances and opportunities and realities to say, for the time being, I'm not comfortable going down this road. I want to see what happens with a ballot measure. I want to see the degree to which there is buy-in and recognition that
1:46:40 Doing the TOT measure, which I think is what we have some sort of consensus over. Looking at the, you know, leveraging our economy, leveraging the resources out of this. Again, part of recognizing it's a failed market is we're never going to solve this problem. The best we can do is mitigate. Mitigate, mitigate, mitigate over time. There's never going to be any solution.
1:47:02 to the housing challenges in Mammoth Lakes or any of these communities because the forces, so many forces outside of this are conspiring against us. So that's kind of where I'm at at this point. And I think you've made some really astute comments about the fact that there is a balance in communities, the degree to which this kind of alternative tourist accommodation is a fundamental component of your financing program. And in Mammoth Lakes,
1:47:29 I think we're more extreme than any other community I can think of. We're 70 or 80 percent of the operating capital for the town that we can use to invest in housing mitigation solutions comes from this thing that was built. And I think let's give this a shot. Let's see what happens in the election. Let's upload these revenue measures. And when looking at these things in totality, that's kind of where I'm at at this point. So thank you. Who wants to go next? I'll take a stab if you're willing.
1:48:01 Please proceed. I agree with John on some of his comments there. We have this housing program underway. We haven't let it get to maturity to see what an impact it's going to have before trying to chop over the things. If we look at Measure Z, which doesn't allow anyone to rent out nightly single-family homes, and we ask ourselves, how many new rentals did that create for locals?
1:48:30 The answer is almost zero. There's just a larger percentage of houses that sit empty. If one of our goals is an environmental goal to cap tourism, then a cap on the number of STRs is appropriate. But if that's what we're doing, we need to say that and be honest about it. If we're using it to create housing, I do not believe it will work. Using Tahoe's example of 10 to 15 percent,
1:49:00 Doesn't work for me because most of those in Mammoth were already illegal to rent because of Measure Z. So it's not, it's apples and oranges and it doesn't work. And Placer County, I mean, I've done a lot of traveling in Placer County, a lot of good wineries. Certainly it is not related to what we have here in Mammoth or how Mammoth was built. Thank you. You know, I've been thinking about this a lot and someone very smart said,
1:49:33 You know, the definition of a deal is when nobody's happy, right? I think I've said this before at a council meeting. So, you know, I personally, I don't love the rental subsidy program. However, I am willing to look at placemates, do a trial period. I don't love the...
1:49:52 Tax going to the ballot and potentially competing with the fire department's bond. I'm concerned about both measures suffering, as Alish astutely said the other week. So, you know, those are two things that I'm not super impassioned about and have some reservations about, but I would be willing to consider them if we also would be willing to consider perhaps a cap above where we are now.
1:50:21 I wonder how harmful this would really be. And it would allow us the mechanism to reduce the numbers if we found that the vote measure didn't pass, the ballot measure didn't pass, or if the placemates failed. How can we compromise? And so I'm looking at how can we compromise? Can we establish a cap that is above where we're at now?
1:50:48 Potentially a waiting period. And then we also, trial placemates, we also put the ballot, or put the tax measure on the ballot. I have a procedural question. If there is consensus to move forward on exploration of a cap and or a waiting period, is this come down to a council vote? And is this a 3-2 vote? Or what's the outcome here? That's correct. I mean, when we're looking tonight for consensus, you know, I'm...
1:51:17 I'm looking for three people to say that they want to move this forward. And then it would come back to Council as a policy item. It would have to be, you know, prior to, it would be in conjunction with the implementation of certified properties and the lifting of the moratorium, if you will. It would occur simultaneously with all of that. But it would be back to Council with the specific language to review and to vote on.
1:51:47 That would be the process. Can I ask a procedural on top of that? So you said it would come back with the certified properties in the moratorium, but it would be a separate matter. It would be a separate matter, yeah, and it would take us, you know, some time to structure that together. But yes, it would be a separate item from certified properties. But would it necessarily slow down the
1:52:14 March 6th, because I think we all agree that we want to move towards that. Well, it really depends, right? When you're talking about a cap, then other questions, I will have other questions, if you will, about where, and then there's other performance elements. When you start to add caps, then you need to consider an expectation of a certificate holder having to perform a certain amount of rentals so they can't just get it.
1:52:43 Thank you.
1:53:13 Thank you. And Amanda, I didn't mean to, because I was just asking that procedural, so go ahead. I would be in favor of a cap, including the most amount of town that we could legally include, and at a rate of today's rates, or I'd be open to slightly higher. I wouldn't want to decrease our numbers. Okay. I guess I'm next. Everyone's spoken, right? Mayor Souther spoke? Okay. All right.
1:53:51 I think that there's just a lot of different moving parts in this process right now. But I think what I would be most comfortable with going forward is I sort of am thinking about what you said, John, but I think I'd go even a step farther. We, you know, the short-term rental committee
1:54:25 We did a lot of work. A lot of people put their time and energy into it. We can talk about some of the limitations of that, some of the information that we have now that we didn't have at the time. But I guess I'll just say this. I am most in favor of us going forward as a community with the ballot measure to increase TOT so that
1:54:54 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:55:21 You know, we talk about the fact, can we build our way out of this problem? And the answer is, maybe, maybe not. But until we really work hard for potential public-private partnerships or whatever it is to get more market-rate housing into this community, we're just going to continue to struggle. And so to that end, I'd like to see...
1:55:46 John said he wants to see what happens. I am telling the town of Mammoth Lakes, if we don't pass that ballot measure and the fire measure in November, then we will be back here and I will be looking at caps. And I mean, I think for me personally, that's
1:56:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:56:38 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:57:09 And so to me that we had to go back to waiting period. And to me, I think, do we do need further clarification? Is everyone good? I want to make sure that I'm not just talking for myself. So are we good? So Chris, you had wanted to talk about that particular item yourself. I think I have where everyone else sits. And you'd made some comments. You want to finish those comments on the waiting period? Are you?
1:57:37 I think it's tied to, I don't see a waiting period having any benefit without caps. It just seems, you know, disconnected. You may want to open that hole back up for a little public comment, too, just so we'll make sure we're covered on those items. Sure thing. Okay, so. We're trying to track it, so. Yeah, absolutely. We can do public comment to begin item 11 at the appropriate time. Okay. We took comment for number 11. Seven. Okay.
1:58:09 So going back, thank you, to number seven, this was about, but I thought we took public comment then too because that was just a deliberation. Okay. Okay, thank you. Okay, good. Now, we are on to number 12. I do apologize for how arduous this is, but it is a challenge to get through and
1:58:38 All right. I think orchestrate all that and you're all doing very well. Item number 13 is to consider. Oh, 12. I'm sorry. Item 12 is a policy item and this is creating a mechanism to reduce the allowed permits when needed. And so it was marked as a policy because it's sort of tied to 11 indicating that if you had a cap.
1:59:06 What structure would you use to reduce that? But I will leave it as a policy item as you guys can address that. Okay. So any questions from council? I think really on that one, Chris, we can take comment and ask that. We had it on there because if they are a limit permit, how do you move them up or down becomes a real part of that process.
1:59:34 But just to keep everything consistent, I will see if anyone in the room or online wants to comment on 12. It wouldn't happen unless 11 happened, so. I have a comment, but not a question. Oh, okay. So after public comment. Yeah, so no public comment in the room. Any public comment online? Okay, go ahead. So I think supporting, I think, what Councilmember Bubser has said, I would like to see
2:00:05 This thing, anything that tiers to a cap or waiting period or all the rest of it, I would like staff to look at all of these things as part of a comprehensive package. I understand it's not a be a significant priority, but I think I would like to see, give you the time to look at this thing as a comprehensive package to bring that back. We'd like to see a consensus on that versus one request. Oh, fair enough. Any discussion?
2:00:36 Can you be specific, John, a comprehensive package to bring what back? To bring the recommendation from staff for CAPS, a recommendation from staff about a waiting period, and a recommendation from staff.
2:00:52 We're on item number 12 for that one as well. Because again, it's like, I mean, I appreciate this, the public's patience with us kind of working through this one item at a time. In my mind, this is a comprehensive set of policies. So that, you know, November, whenever we see what the outcomes of elections and see how these things kind of work, if this comes back, it's a staff recommendation that they put time into this, given Mammoth Lakes, given what's happening.
2:01:19 This is going to be a suite of recommendations to consider. So to clarify, you'd like staff to bring this back as a comprehensive package after the outcome of the November election? Well, to start working on it now. I think that, I mean, to start working on it now so that, like, this is not...
2:01:39 We're not going to sit around and wait to see what happens in November. Let's have this in our back pocket. Let's start looking at what some of these things might look like. So if I may, John, because I am a little bit confused. We've gone through these and said, do we want staff to be working to bring this back to you now? Councilmember, Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser, mentioned her comments on the fact that should those ballot measures fail, she would expect.
2:02:07 this to come back to council as an item and that would at that point you know the count staff be ready to kind of talk about it um what I'm hearing from you is though is is a little bit different it's going okay I'm saying I'm picking up on someone said something about this summer I believe there's a there's a I may have misheard that but I heard I thought you heard saying something about bringing something back in the summer and if that's if I heard that incorrectly then I'll take it back so you're making a recommendation that we that we bring back
2:02:36 A discussion to council on caps and a waiting period and a mechanism by which to adjust those caps. Yeah, later. But again. If I may, Chris, may I speak? Go ahead. Of course. We're entering a time period where our staff is going to be somewhat overwhelmed. As a council, we can ask them to bring anything back at any time.
2:03:07 So I would just assume wait on telling staff I want this to come back until we as a council see the results of some of these things. And then if we want it to come back, we can then ask them to prepare a comprehensive report on this. But at this point, staff can be pretty overwhelmed for the next few months. So I would prefer to take a wait and see on the council's perspective and then we can ask to bring it back if we'd be met. So let me, if I could just maybe clarify what I'm thinking. If you, if, if
2:03:36 What could be done is to take the expert of your, you know, consultees, whatever you want to call it. Council may not want to do this, but to look at your experience in Mammoth Lakes and to drill down into the specifics of who we are as a community and look at these items that we're not pursuing in the short term.
2:03:57 But to say, should you want to go forward, this is what a package of these things would look like. So we don't have to assemble the whole thing in November, December, but we start putting the pieces together. That would be my recommendation. Okay. Let me be clear. What I'm asking for is that staff begins the work because I would want to have this package of a waiting period, caps, and a mechanism,
2:04:27 to modify permits ready because if these ballot initiatives fail on the November ballot, then at the next council meeting, I want these things back. So I don't want. I understood that very clearly. Thank you. Very, very clearly. I did.
2:04:52 I did get a little bit confused about John's comments because it would... My only thing is to add this number 12, which I believe is related, that that should be included in Councilmember... Then we're saying the same thing. We're saying the same thing. I'm just saying add that into this. Okay. That's clear. Thank you. Okay. Are we good? Okay. Great. So we're on number 13. Could we take a five-minute break? Yep. Because if I don't stand up, I'm...
2:09:49 Let's reconvene, please. Chris, if I may, I need to say something as we get started here. I will. Thank you, Bill. Stay off mute. We're on number 13, lucky 13. That doesn't apply to us. John Wentworth, please report to the dais. I was going to bang this thing, but I'm good. Mayor Sauser would like to make a comment, so please go ahead.
2:10:41 Okay, I am in a borrowed conference room in the hospital. You all know where I'm at and what my circumstances are. I am going to lose the ability to use this room in another half hour, half hour plus. Frankly, I didn't see the meeting going this long. So at that point, I'm going to have to back out. I apologize for any inconvenience. Not to worry. And thank you for being here, first of all. We're so grateful.
2:11:09 And then the other thing is I think the rest might go quickly. We'll hope for. But could I point a privilege for the mayor? Should I ask if there's any specific items he has a strong point of view on? I think we've been through the hardest ones. If it gets to the point where you need to leave, Bill, and you want to make sure you comment on one of the upcoming items, just let us know, okay?
2:11:38 You got it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Number 13, consider fewer restrictions on hosted STRs. Yeah, so that we had listed as not applicable. The town has very few hosted STRs and setting a policy structure for those units is not recommended. So we had that as non-applicable. Okay. Is that all right with everyone? Anyone have a...
2:12:04 Anything? Okay, good. So, number 14, consider a cap on nights rented in non-hosted STRs. So, this is a policy question, and again, it's kind of going to limiting the amount of rental nights that a particular STR can conduct, and that's, we...
2:12:33 I had that not applicable earlier, but I think based upon the conversation, maybe it's a policy discussion, but I'm just going to open it up that way. Does everybody understand what that means? Yeah, so basically the ones that have certificates would have a cap on the number of nights they can run. That's correct. Okay, so any questions from council? Bill, question? You could just do thumbs up for yes, thumbs down for no.
2:13:03 No, I have no real questions on this one. Thank you. Okay. Is there any public comment in the room on item number 14, considering a cap on nights in non-hosted STRs? Seeing no one in the room. Anyone online? Mike, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yeah, thank you for that. Hey, I'm curious about the number of nights. If I wanted to, you know, rent...
2:13:34 Okay, so Rob will go ahead and answer. Yeah, no, that's not a short-term rental if it's 31 nights or more. Okay, great. So then deliberation, does anyone have? I mean, John? I don't.
2:14:07 See why we would do this, because once they have a certificate, then we want them to rent. Okay, so the policy would be not to pursue. Okay, so number 15. Go ahead. 15 is considered further geographic targeting on STR regulations. I have this listed as not applicable, and I'll explain why.
2:14:34 You know, the concept presented here, and just like any of these concepts, which can come back to Council, would likely be a part of a redevelopment or downtown district review. So this would be something that would come before Council, I think, with a larger program focus on
2:14:57 Redeveloping a particular district and then the same conversation could be had around those, but I don't see it as it relates to the STR program that we're discussing tonight. So I listed it as not applicable. Very good. Anyone have any questions about that? Just a quick...
2:15:19 A technical question. How would something like this come forward? This is a zoning? Well, it could be zoning or it could be even a micro section of a zone. So, for example, if we have, you know, a downtown district, we have Old Mammoth Road District. If the council and Nolan were working through some special processes in those districts to either incentivize people to
2:15:42 Build out or change processes in that area. This could be a discussion. So it's not necessarily zoning. It's more even micro-targeted than that. It would be focusing in these particular areas. So not now seems to make sense to me. Okay. Since we said not applicable, do we need to take? Okay. Bless you. So is there any public comment in the room on item number 15? And how about online? Okay.
2:16:14 16 was considering STR density limits, and we had this non-applicable as well. I think this is very difficult to implement. Basically, it's a proximity process, so we just have it as not applicable. It would be too hard to implement in our city, our town. Because you can't throw a stone and not hit an STR. So, no questions.
2:16:37 Other questions or clarifications? You're okay with it being not applicable? And I still need to ask any comments on item number 16 in the room or online? Okay. Number 17. Item 17 is a policy item. Item 17 was to update analysis of workforce housing need. So the most recent housing needs analysis was conducted in 2017 and provided information used in the development of the Community Housing Action Plan, the CHAP.
2:17:10 The Town's Housing Element Update. A new housing needs study, it will be appropriate following the construction of at least the first phase of the parcel and time to support the next required housing element update. So we kind of felt it was appropriate once we had implemented some of the planned housing that's being built and just see how that impacts us townwide. But I would like input from Council on that.
2:17:40 Okay, so first questions. So are you, sorry, point of clarification, are you proposing a time frame? I would propose that we would not engage in this analysis until after we have at least phase one of the parcel occupied and the impacts of how that would hit other regions of town as people are moving out of either where they are and going into that.
2:18:09 And then again, since the age of the last analysis, I think it's really appropriate to do that, but we want to do it at the right time. Great. So questions? Go ahead. Okay. Is this, would this effort be tied to the needs of the housing element of the general plan? So this is required to go through CEQA and all that kind of process?
2:18:32 The needs assessment would not be tied to CEQA, but the housing element adoption would require CEQA. Okay, so I'm trying to break this out a little bit because I think there's something interesting in the report which had to do with the fact that if you have a robust STR market, you're incentivizing employment and you're incentivizing housing needs for all the people who are supporting the STR.
2:18:56 This seems to be really important, but I don't think we need to do something that's not constrained by what the folks at OPR are telling us about what needs to be in a housing element. So I'm wondering if you could talk to that a little bit so that we could do this in a way that's going to give us more community-specific data that's going to address some of the things that were brought up in the analysis, if you could speak to that. Definitely. I think in this there could be...
2:19:24 A focus study that would address some of the needs and areas of lack of data that we currently have identified in the VAE report and also some additional areas that we've identified, such as, you know, as we're looking at implementing additional housing programs are, are we targeting the right AMI groups, are we targeting the right type of units, size, rental versus owner, all of that. So I think there could be, you know, it wouldn't quite.
2:19:50 Meet the criteria of a housing needs assessment, because that's a very specific type of report, but it would be a more tailored report to address that, that we could put together. Yeah, we need data that's specific to our needs. So I think we obviously have to do this. The timing is, I hear your recommendation on the timing, but we want to make sure we do something that's not going to be constrained by state mandates, that's going to give us data that we need to make policy decisions. Does that make sense? Yes. Okay. Okay.
2:20:18 We're still on questions. Understood. So that was just to make sure we can do that. Sure. I appreciate that. Questions on this? Bill, any questions on number 17? No questions. Comments on item number 17, updating our analysis of workforce housing needs in the room? Online? Okay. So who wants to go first, just giving guidance to staff?
2:20:52 I'll go first. I think that we should wait until the parcel is filled and, you know, reevaluate where we are with housing. I'm sure we're still behind and in need. So I think it would be good to get another study. Same. Okay, Bill? Yeah, I have no problem with doing that study after we see what the parcel delivers and the other, you know, the Joaquin Street units, the access apartments, that there are so many things happening over the next year.
2:21:24 I would like to see the results of those before we do a study so we don't have to pay for two. Okay. I would concur, except that I would say that once phase one of the parcel is occupied, I think that's the right time to do this. I don't want to wait for other projects that are under construction. We know how that goes. But I would also say that the housing element is a very specific thing that is mandated, and I would like to see us do some kind of workshop or
2:21:56 Thank you. Number 18. Strongly oppose legislation similar to SB 584.
2:22:26 Yes. Done. Complete. What's that? Yes. That's complete. We will continue. It comes up again. I think that thing's dead. Thank goodness. Okay. Number 19. Encourage development of other accommodation types. Yes, please. So go ahead. Do you need policy direction? I had it as not applicable. I mean, we have other zoned property types in development. One of the projects being limelight. Sure.
2:22:55 You know, others proceeding perhaps in the entitlement process, but I think that the diversification of that is really based upon, you know, what wants to be built in the market. Yeah, and this was specific to tourist accommodations, so, you know, I've already talked about other kinds of housing that I think we should be thinking about, but if this is NA, is everyone okay with that? I'm okay with it, yeah. Bill, are you okay with this? Okay.
2:23:26 Number 20, lobby for tenants' rights reform. Chris, real quick. Yes. Andy's going to be speaking in my ear a little bit about not taking public comment on the not applicable items. I think 13 was in question whether that was done, and I don't think we took public comment on 18. Okay. So what is your recommendation?
2:23:55 I think in this particular one, so I'll go back to 13, you know, considering fewer restrictions on, you know, hosted short-term rentals, I said they're not applicable because we have very few in town, and I don't think we took public comment on that. Okay. Yeah, the council needs to take public comment even if you decide that it's not something that we're interested in pursuing. That's still a form of deliberation. So before you decide that it's not relevant or that you're not going to talk about it, you need to ask if there's public comment. Okay, fair enough. I apologize to everyone.
2:24:26 Anyone in the room want to give public comment on number 13, and I will read what it is for clarification. Consider fewer restrictions on hosted STRs. And no one online? Okay. And then... On number 18 was strongly opposed legislation similar to SB 584, which is for folks that don't know, would tax short-term or transient occupancy tax at the state level at a 15% rate?
2:24:57 And so that would mean our total tax rates, you know, would be 28% for TOT. Bless you. And then the state of California promises to do great things with the money. But that is not passed. So anyone in the room want to comment on number 18, which was opposing SB 584? And anyone online? Okay. So number 19.
2:25:26 Does anyone, this was encouraging development of other accommodation types, but it was specific to tourist accommodations. Anyone want to give comment on number 19? Anyone online? Yes. Okay, go ahead. Sarah, please unmute yourself and give your comments. We cannot hear you, Sarah. I don't see her over in the normal. Has she been promoted? Yeah, there's a hand. I see the hand. I don't see her over here, though.
2:26:23 Thank you. I needed the option to be able to unmute myself. I just wanted to reiterate. We can't hear you. Can you hear me now? Yes. All right. Sorry about that. I wanted to, in light of this item, I've suggested countless times that I encourage Town Council to agendize the, to review developer impact fees, the schedule of fees and the
2:27:05 Thank you so much.
2:27:35 Typically, when you do engage the private sector, the homes will actually get built. Thank you. All right, so thank you. Number 20, lobby for tenants' rights reform. Is this, go ahead. Yeah, so, you know, staff has this in review. Essentially, what the recommendation is right now at the state of California, the tenant rights are a little bit higher than the property owner rights.
2:28:09 And, you know, we have legislative action on occasion. We have lobbyists on retainer. This is not a specific town initiative that we are pursuing at this time. And it's fairly large and complex, if you will. I think recommending to lean into that. I have it listed as in review. I would not recommend to lean into that at this point in time. Okay. Any questions from?
2:28:38 The Council. All right. Any public comment on this item? Item number 20, tenants' rights reform. Anyone online? Okay. Number 20. Just real quick, I want to make, I appreciate the complexity of it, but this is something that's important, so I think when we come back to a legislative review, I think we should be looking, we should maybe look at it at that time. What I would suggest is
2:29:09 If there are actually pieces of legislation coming forward for us to respond to, definitely we can do those types of elements, but not like proposing a piece of legislation. Understood. So it'd be more of watching what's out there, then we can take positions accordingly. Okay. Yeah, let's keep our eyes on this. Number 21, expand and diversify the housing supply. Did we get public comment on the last one? Pardon me? Did we get public comment on 20? I did, and then John asked a question after. Okay.
2:29:39 Okay, thanks. So this is expanding diversity of housing supply, and I have this listed as in process. You know, we have the Housing Now initiative and several recommendations from the SDR committee that, you know, council, I believe, has reviewed and is making recommendations on for
2:30:07 Different components to be added to the Housing Now Initiative. I think we're kind of doing that. So I listed it as in process, but happy to address any questions on that. Any questions from Council on this one? No questions. Bill? Okay, I see you nodding no. The one thing I would say is that I would love to see an addition to the Housing Now program that's very specific to expanding.
2:30:36 The market rate rental for folks who make 80% to 200% of AMI. I would love to see that initiative. And if I may on that, there is a third phase of the parcel that is focused on that. It's more for sale, but it could be tied to a rental, depending on who acquires the property. There are some proposals coming forward with those. Just bluntly, they're very expensive. Excuse me.
2:31:05 All right. Several, well, anyway, very expensive. Okay, and I think that's great that we are looking into it, and let's make sure the public's aware of that so that just everybody has the same information as we try to move forward. Thank you. Any comments from the public on item number, what was that, 21? Anyone online? Okay, number...
2:31:35 22, establish... Oh, okay, go ahead. Sarah, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi again. I think that this would fit in this section, I believe. I would like to just hear an update from council as to where they are with receiving a placemate presentation or at least watching the chamber presentation that was recorded and would like to hear...
2:32:08 Thank you. All right. Thank you. So number 22.
2:32:42 Establish additional dedicated local funding sources for housing programs. Yes, so I have this listed as a policy item. As you remember, at the same meeting, last meeting, we were reviewing a TR committee, advisory committee recommendations. There was a couple of different
2:33:03 I would like to hear what a recommendation would be for that funding source.
2:33:32 Okay, thank you. So questions from counsel on this? I guess, Rob, what did you hear? Did you hear? What were the two options that you heard at the last meeting? So the two options that were presented by the STR committee, one of them was a 2% increase transient occupancy tax, and the second one was a fee, a tax on certified properties. I think it was actually 1.5% of...
2:34:00 Collected TOT on, I'm sorry, gross receipts on the STRs only. So it wouldn't be the full amount of TOT, but it would be just Schedule Fs, which are short-term rentals. And at that time, I heard a desire to not go that direction, but more go towards a 2% TOT increase, but it wasn't, the full council did not weigh in on it.
2:34:25 And if I can add to that, the recommendation was up to 2%, and I don't think if you want to wait to come back on a percentage number, whether it's one, one and a half, two, or whatever, unless there's a consensus to go with a particular number, that helps us in drafting and bringing stuff forward again versus having to have that discussion. So it was bouncing around a little bit that way, so I think it leaned toward TOT, but there wasn't a strong consensus on the level of TOT.
2:34:51 I'll go first. That would help. Are we discussing? No, this is questions. Okay, this is questions. But if you have a question. No, no question. Question? Question? No. Mayor Sauser, do you have a question about the? No questions. Okay, so then public comment. Anyone in the room have public comment on item 22? Anyone online? Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
2:35:25 Hi, I just want to thank Dan for reminding us that the council, when it was discussed, that it was up to 2%, not at 2%. And then also, I just personally want to thank Mayor Sauser for being online tonight. And I appreciate the sacrifice that you're making right now. And just know that our prayers are with you and your wife. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay. Thank you very much. All right. So.
2:35:59 Who wants to go first on the deliberation for this? I guess I know it's a higher threshold to get, but I would like to go after the tax that specifically designates this increase to only be spent on housing and doing a 2%. 2% special tax versus general. Yes. All right. Yes, we can come back. So I agree with you on the 2%.
2:36:32 Based on my experience doing these things, I think that there are two considerations here. The first is that I think that the public is aware of what this is about. So I don't think we're going to run into that question about, well, if it's not a special tax, what are you going to do with it? And I think that the challenge and the problems we have are so overwhelming that I'm not too worried about the money being spent in a way other than for housing.
2:37:01 The other concern is that the Housing Now program is all about being nimble and being able to respond to opportunities, and it's going to be very difficult to write language on a two-thirds measure that's going to allow for all the different types of opportunities that could come up. So I don't think we need to do it as a two-thirds vote in order to ensure it's going to do what it needs to do.
2:37:29 Unintended consequence could be if we do it as a two-thirds measure that staff or the town could start saying, well, you've got your two-thirds thing, so then we're going to take all the other TOT money, just spend that on other things, and we're not going to be able to have a really strong pool. So I agree with you. My thoughts would be on the technical side of it. I think we can go with a lower threshold, and I think it's going to still satisfy the needs and interest that we would have for it. So those are my thoughts. Okay.
2:37:59 So, Mayor Sauser, what are your thoughts on item number 22? Well, it appears that the majority of council at home there already are set for the 2%, so I won't bother arguing for less than that. Well, not everyone has weighed in, so tell me what you're thinking. Or tell us, not me, us. So the problem that I have with 2%, and I don't know the answer,
2:38:33 And what does it do to us competitively with our peer resorts and peer markets? Do we collect 2% and does it cost us enough business that we actually end up collecting less taxes overall and then, you know, shooting ourselves in the foot? And again, I haven't had time to analyze this. I don't know what others are charging or what the effect is of that.
2:38:54 We do have that information, so could staff, could you just, I think it's important for Bill to know that. Yeah, so generally, I mean, there are some municipalities that are charging higher, so right now we're at 13% TOT and 1% TBID for any transient rentals. We have as high as 17% in the state of California, and so this would put us at 15%, so we would not be the highest, but
2:39:23 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:40:00 Not your ballgame. Okay. Do you want me to go or do you want to go? I'm fine with whatever the consensus of the council is. I don't really have a strong opinion on it, to be honest. Okay. I am in favor of 2%.
2:40:22 The reason being that I just stayed in a hotel in the Sacramento area and there were three lines of taxes. Like, it's everybody has. Like, I don't consider the T-bid when I'm thinking about this. So if we get to 15%, we're not the highest and this is how we get our revenue. So I'm okay with that. In terms of 50 or 66%, you know, we are spending general fund dollars every year.
2:40:51 I just think it's 50% threshold on this special tax would be a safer bet given all of the
2:41:21 You know, down, I don't know, just downstream, things that will have to happen if it doesn't pass. How's that? So, we're basically at a 2% special tax. How about it as a general tax? It would be 2% general tax. Sorry is what I meant. I'm using the wrong words. A 2% general tax. Are you okay with that?
2:41:53 Bill, are you okay with a 2% general tax? You're muted, Bill. You're muted, yeah. Didn't touch the right screen. Another problem that I have with going down this is we're taxing people that don't get to vote on their own behalf. But yeah, if that's consensus, then that's where we go. And then I almost shudder to bring this up, but I think we should. We didn't talk about sun setting, and that was something that's under consideration. Do you, I mean, I think you'd probably rather have.
2:42:31 Guidance on that now, wouldn't you? Well, I think knowing what to start to pursue, right? This is a long road to develop one of these and to talk about how that process goes through. I think there will be more opportunity to discuss that. Having 2% in general is helpful for now, but it will come back. And, you know, John, you know the details of how these things come to fruition. And there's going to be a lot of discussion around that and the opportunity for sunset can be discussed at that point. Very good.
2:43:00 Yeah, I'd just say let's not have too much discussion on it because it's February. And so I think this should be prioritized in terms of whatever decisions we need to get this process to get this thing on the ballot. We need to get on this. All right. Number 23, aggressively expand inventory of deed-restricted housing. Thank you. So, yes, I have this listed as in process. This is one of our most successful aspects of our Housing Now initiative where we have called the Bridge Program, purchasing houses and selling them at market, selling them at
2:43:34 Subsidized rates. That's very effective. So that's in process. Any questions? This is in process, so we don't need to give policy recommendation, but any questions? Any public comment on this item? Number 23, expanding the inventory of deed-restricted housing, which is something we're doing in the housing now. Anyone online? Okay. Number 24. Pursuing economic development initiatives. So we
2:44:06 We had that as not applicable, so this is not really a direct policy action in the town. However, we've been several market forces that have increased wages, because this is talking about wage that supports the ability to purchase housing. We have a lot of market forces in town affecting wage, and it's primarily a supply and demand, especially when you talk about specialized operators.
2:44:35 And so that's already at work. We're sort of moving up fairly quickly. The town's also been, you know, aggressive, at least in our pay schedules. And everybody's responding to California's requirements for minimum wage. So I have that listed as not applicable at this time. I think it is important, though, for us to just mention that part two says to engage with large landowners and employers to provide additional developable land, which
2:45:00 Thank you. Thank you.
2:45:29 I do want to just ask if anybody from Council has any questions or comments on that and then take public comment because I feel like it comes up and here's the chance for us to address it and get feedback.
2:45:55 No questions. I have a question. Have we looked into, I think it was in Colorado, they had the, like, no money for housing initiatives where I believe that they get rid of the option of paying a fee and it's, you have to build housing. Have we looked at that? We have not here, mainly because then when we do that, our biggest challenge is land. So you can say you must build housing. The question will be where.
2:46:24 And so, again, different discussions on this already with some of the larger projects. We've had a couple folks come to us, hey, we'd love to build some units. There's no land for us to build on that's readily available. I mean, they're looking for something more than a quarter acre type stuff. So if you do those types of conditions, we can do those. Be like similar, inclusionary. Chances are it won't necessarily generate any housing. It will stop development, but not necessarily to generate housing because it's
2:46:54 Where do you actually put it? We just had a conversation the other day with somebody looking, and then they're asking, well, do you care if we build in Bishop? Do you care if we build somewhere else? Bishop doesn't have a lot of land either. In fact, they complained to us on that same issue. We can't get LA to free up land. We go, we can't get the Forest Service free up land. So I think you want to be cautious how you hit those and say, will it actually result in housing, I guess is the bottom line question. Because we know some struggles already with that.
2:47:22 And or it moves the price of land up quickly too. So if we're forcing people to go do that just from a market force standpoint. There's some elements of that that can be in there. The development impact fees and housing fees are currently under review. You should see them another 60 or 90 days at the latest in terms of an update on fees. Those all tie to certain nexus studies and demand created. And also if there's existing problems, you can't use free...
2:47:49 Future fees to address existing conditions. There are some limits on what you can do with those fees and how you work those through. But, yeah, I've heard that before, I guess, now that you're defining it, but that would be a challenge just for us. We could do that. The question would be, where do you build? And is it for every development? Like, if you want to do a three-unit development, instead of paying fees, you've got to build a half a unit or a full unit. There's a whole issue that gets into those types of issues.
2:48:18 Thank you. They get creative. Anyone else have any questions? No questions. Okay. Then I want to make sure we take public comment on number 24. Anyone in the room? This was just talking about increasing local wage levels, but the second half of it was about engaging with landowners and employers to make sure they provide housing for workers. So anyone want to comment on item 24?
2:48:49 Anyone online? Dan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, thanks for everybody for staying late and going through all these items. I appreciate the town council's efforts on resolving the housing shortage. So I just want to say overall, Mammoth is a tourist destination and short-term rentals increase tourism revenue by making tourism more affordable and available in Mammoth.
2:49:15 Short-term rentals and tourism benefits local businesses, government revenue, and real estate development. Short-term rentals should be encouraged and not discouraged, in my opinion, from a public policy perspective. The goal here is to solve a housing affordability problem for local residents. In my view, reducing short-term rentals is not the most cost-effective way to solve the housing shortage for the local population. Limiting short-term rentals harms everyone in the community, with the exception of hotel developers.
2:49:44 It has a relatively low effect on solving the housing shortage for the local population. I heard like a 10-15% conversion rate. So I think that's the more expensive way to go. I think the short-term rental committee had many great recommendations, particularly the idea of making long-term renting more economically attractive for both local residents and landlords through subsidizing long-term renting rates and funding.
2:50:10 Through this transit occupancy tax. I also believe that the development of higher density housing on lower cost land deed restrictions for primary occupancy further away from the resort areas will help solve the housing shortage for local residents by increasing ownership. So thank you very much. And that's my perspective on all this. Okay. Gary, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
2:50:41 And, well, go ahead. Hi, yeah, I have been involved in listening to the committee's debates over this. One of the things that seems to pop up quite often, and Brian brought it up this evening, or sorry, not Brian, Bill brought it up this evening. Nobody who is being affected by this actually has the opportunity to vote, or very few people, let's put it this way, a high percentage of the people who are being affected by these taxes, by these changes, do not have the ability to vote.
2:51:14 And it seems like the council and the committees, nobody on those councils or committees are actually short-term rental owners who are directly affected. There might be business owners who have some indirect effect, but directly affected people have not been included in the committees, have not been included in the council's discussion. Gary, I'm sorry to interrupt, but we're on this specific item number 24, which is
2:51:44 About continuing to engage with landowners and employers to make resources available. Okay, thank you. I was unaware of that. I didn't have an opportunity to discuss earlier. Okay. But my comments should still be held in there, which is nobody's getting the opportunity to discuss who's being affected. Okay, thank you. Yeah. All right.
2:52:15 So basically, does anybody, because it seemed to me, now that we've taken public comment, is there anyone else, Jamie? Okay, good. So did anyone on council have any comments about item 24? Because I think it's not about the wages, but about, you know, just making sure that we are pursuing opportunities to get housing resources when there is.
2:52:46 You know, the opportunity to do so. Did you? It looked like you had something to say. I just have an observation about this. Throughout this entire process, we've heard a lot of people, a lot of members of the public and others saying, why don't you make big real estate development projects, you know, do their bit? And I think as council and staff, I think, is aware, we're updating the fees. That's coming back to us. I think we're keenly aware that our housing mitigation rules and policies are insufficient at this point. But I also want to point out that
2:53:15 We're dealing with a lot of legacy issues. There was the leadership in the community many years ago was convinced that somehow we would turn this entire town into something that looked like Vail or some other place. These are old discussions. And so there's a lot of entitlements that aren't good, that are legally binding, that are in the stream.
2:53:39 These things are going to come up, and we're not going to be able to do anything about it. We'll try to point those things out. Legal counsel will advise us of that, so just let everybody know that we're dealing with a 20-year legacy of these kinds of things. We're going to do everything we can with the legal opportunities we can to do something about it, but there's some unpleasant, I'm not going to say strange fruit, but there's some funny things in the pipeline. I'm not saying strange fruit. All right.
2:54:09 So I think we will now be adjourning into closed session. Do I have to read that, right? And I put my agenda away. So give me a second. My agenda. Here we are. All right. So the council will adjourn into closed session to discuss
2:54:41 Item 5.1, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8, the Town Council, oh, this is just, oh yeah, the Council will hold a conference with its representatives in regards to property negotiations pertaining to a property at 100 College Parkway. And the negotiators are Daniel Holler and Rob Patterson.
2:55:03 The parties are Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Foundation, Representatives Betsy Truax, Luan Mendel, and Gary Myers. And we'll adjourn now into closed session. Thank you, everyone. Can we take a quick break? Of course, we can take a five-minute break.