Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
4 findings- A FY2025-26 first-quarter update listed $1.087 million available in Fund 205 Fund 205 - Solid Waste
- Measure R Fund 216 was projected to reach $4,325,000 by June 30, 2025; staff sought $350,000 of it for Mammoth Creek Park Parks and Recreation
- Gas Tax fund balance was listed at about $2.4 million in three reports from 2022 to 2024, then $294,945 in November 2025 Snow Operations and Wildfire
- Measure R Trails fund (Fund 215) available balance was $888,061 at the close of FY24-25, up from $526,758 at the close of FY22-23 Trails
Transcript
365 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:15 Wow. It's loud on the folding tables. All right. Good evening, all. And welcome to this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, December 6th. Great to see you all here. And we're going to get started. So I'm going to ask my good friend, well, Jamie, if you could call the roll. Sure. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth.
3:46 Present. And do we need a call for MLT or is that we'll do that later? Okay, good. Thank you all. Mr. Mayor Pro Tem, would you mind leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. All right. So now I'll move on to public comments. Anything you want to share with the town council for things that are not on this evening's agenda? Yes, please come forward. You need to come up and talk to the microphone so the folks at home can see it. Thank you.
4:35 Hi, greetings everyone. My name is Sarah Walsh and I want to take this opportunity to introduce myself. I am actually on the ballot to run for Monon County District Supervisor for District 3. Mammoth Lakes is a part of that district. So instead of coming here, just enjoy your food and beverage. I also like to understand your politics. And I am happy. You will be the first. I am excited to be here as well as just also formed the Eastern Sierra Brewers Alliance.
5:05 As well as in politics, I'm the owner and founder of June Lake Brewing. And I enjoy attending all the different breweries that are here as well. So I hope to learn a lot from you guys. And I just want to take this opportunity to let you guys know I'm running. And the election is March 5th. Ballots get mailed in February. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much for coming down. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? I don't see anybody else in the room. Jamie, anybody out in the universe? Okay.
5:36 So we'll move on then to, Dan, any additions to this evening's agenda? No, Mr. Mayor, no additions. Okay. Moving on then to reports from commissions and or departments. Anybody want to step up? I'll do the one. Yeah, we had our recent short-term rental advisory committee meeting, a good discussion over the elements of the certified property program, and then we established three subcommittees to do work, one of them looking at the certified property program.
6:08 One looking at our zoning designations and some structure in that with some options. And the other one that we affectionately call the carrots and sticks, looking at short-term rentals and how do we enhance the potential of a community housing through those processes. And so most of the committees, I think, at least met once. And so we look forward to that reporting out the next meeting, which is December 12th. And that'll start at 4 o'clock versus 5 o'clock. Or is it an hour earlier at 4 for people who have a...
6:38 Thank you. Okay, good. I know it's on top of everybody's mind, so good to get regular updates for that. Anybody else from staff? Anybody updates? Councilmembers, any observations, questions? No? Dan, part of our last meeting, we had that very interesting
7:07 Presentation from Mammoth Resorts on the main lodge redevelopment. And I would assume the staff took a bunch of notes and hopefully we'll get some feedback. Yeah, what wound up on that is after that meeting, Jen Merlo, who's our contract planner for that, was taking notes. She'll put a draft of those notes together, what she captured, ship it back out to staff for review and make sure we're all in agreement. Then that's something we can share out and just let you know, hey, this is what we captured out of the discussion moving forward. I think that'll be good. I think there's a lot of good suggestions from council about
7:36 Getting a framework in place, sort of getting things organized. It's going to be a real big opportunity for collaboration, cooperation between all of us, and I think we want to make sure that the process is something that's going to lend itself to that. All right, so then we'll move on then to the December 2023 Public Works Engineering CIP update. Hayes is good. Anybody got a question for Hayes? I think we're good. Merry Christmas. Okay.
8:05 We'll move on from that, so we'll move on now to our workshop. And Pat, you're the president, chair, I believe, or no? I am the chair. Good, congratulations. Thank you. You got all your folks here? We do not. You're moving a lot faster than we anticipated you were moving, which is a first. If you want to jump to the next item, we could do that. If you want to wait, you have other board members coming in. We do. John, if you want to give your recognition of the Mayor's Spirit of Mammoth Award. Okay, we can do that.
8:36 I have some notes. Oh, you're getting those. We started this award a few years back for each year as a mayor to note and take a look at nominating somebody, or in a couple of cases, it's been an organization or something of that nature. But the idea was to recognize somebody who we believe really emphasizes what the spirit of Mammoth looks like, feels like.
9:06 How they embody that in the work and the efforts and the thing they're doing and how they make a difference in the community. So it's a chance to kind of annually kind of a unique way to recognize a member of the community who has really made a contribution. It may be something that a lot of people aren't as aware of as well as what may be very aware of, but it's a chance to make that type of a recognition and call that to the community's attention. Thank you.
9:35 Thank you, Dan, for that introduction. And, of course, I prepared a speech. So, Janet Hatfield, the Mayor of Mammoth Lakes, as his or her parting action, designates an individual or an organization to be recognized as abiding the spirit of Mammoth Lakes and to be formally recognized with the Mayor's Spirit of Mammoth Lakes Award. While a definition of the spirit of Mammoth Lakes is elusive,
10:08 And should probably remain that way. I can't think of a more deserving or more appropriate embodiment of the spirit of Mammoth Lakes than Janet Hatfield. I first met Janet Hatfield in this room in some kind of weird virtual environment with some colleague she pulled up from the Indian National Forest. And the advice to the council and to the community was that we need to save ourselves from the threat of catastrophic wildfire.
10:39 Okay? Tall order. But as we've come to learn, in the universe that is Janet Hatfield, there is simply no such thing. We've worked together, Janet and I worked together, drafting the Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program for the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, the first program of the new Regional Joint Powers Authority to be approved by all four regional partners. Janet promptly went out and secured a multi-million dollar grant to get work going here in Mammoth Lakes. Like that.
11:12 Millions of dollars. She has brought together partners from all over the region, all over the state, and all over the country in pursuit of a vision. And although we are proud to serve as the incubator and the first project, the first component of this mighty vision, Janet and the Whitebark's vision is much larger than our humble community. This is truly a regional vision and at a landscape scale. Whitebark's mission is to take action, no problem there,
11:42 Cultivate partnerships and empower communities to create and sustain resilient landscapes for future generations. Even this morning as I was researching, going to the website, pop-up windows, get your comments in by December 18th. It just never stops. So by honoring Janet, we honor everything and everybody that comes in her great wake. This includes the Whitebark Institute, its team and board of directors, U.S. Forest Service, the Eastern Sierra Council governments,
12:12 And all the other partners' capacity and funding as entrained. And while a ready definition for the spirit of Mammoth Lakes may be elusive, we know that it is bold if it is nothing else. And bold fits Janet Hatfield and the Whitebark Institute to a T. So congratulations. The plaque will be printed. Do we have it? Oh, we got it up there. Okay, so now you got to bring your crew, bring your people up here. Bring them.
13:06 We'll note also that we do have a plaque in the back of the room that will have your name on it from that. And if you want to introduce your team briefly so we know who they all are, go to the microphone. So yeah, I don't want to take a lot of time. You guys have heard me babble at length for a number of years now.
14:07 But honor and a privilege to do this work in such a beautiful place. It's also at times a real burden because it feels like you're racing against the clock. So this award is really meant for the whole team of folks and all the partners that came to the table under all of the odds that were stacked up against us. And I'm very grateful to you all. But today is with me our new executive director, Laura Beardsley, who I'm eternally grateful to.
14:36 For stepping in sort of midstream. Our new board member, Amanda Serini, who has just joined us to build out our board. And last but certainly not least, my better half, Brian, who bared the brunt of a pretty stressful year. Thank you, Janet. Thank you, White Barker. Okay, so now we're going to move on. We're going to do some council shuffling. Is that right? Oh, well, we got our... Oh, is there... You guys all here? You ready to go? We can go, yeah. Yeah, okay, good.
15:12 So we are now going to have a workshop, a joint meeting with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, an annual recap. And Jamie, do you need to call roll for this? Go ahead, I guess. Chair Foster? Here. Vice Chair Clark? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here. Secretary Mendel? Board Member Souser is here. Board Member Magner is absent. Board Member Carell? Here. Board Member Quezada Costa?
15:44 He's not here. Board Member Wallace is not here. Do they have a quorum? Do they ask that question? It's a workshop. Okay. Oh, just, just, you know. They do. Okay, good. Did she call you? Did she call John? Yeah. She does. Okay. Okay. Great. You want to just hop right into it? Please, hop right in. Thank you. I've been waiting to see John hop. All right. Appreciate the time tonight. Thank you for coming out here and listening to us for a recap for the 2020.
16:18 Thank you.
16:50 Now we know that it's about controlled growth and about education. So really working on the stewardship side of the education, our Real and Real campaign, which you'll hear a little bit about, is 100% geared towards stewardship. It's not about just bringing people here. We are still focused on the visitation opportunities, the midweek winters, the shoulder seasons, and really that destination business coming in. So we want to definitely make sure that we highlight that. And today what we're going to go through, I'll give you a quick financial overview.
17:21 And then we'll talk a little bit about air service from last year. Departmental updates, like I mentioned, each person will be presenting. We've got Lara Kaler and Sarah Winters will be Zooming in as well. And then I'll be doing a TBID annual report, which will be at the tail end here. A couple things before we really get into it. We sent out a postcard probably a week and a half ago about community sentiment. You know, we are looking to get feedback from the community.
17:50 We've had about 240 surveys come back in. About 90% have been primary residents. About 30% of those have been business owners as well. Unfortunately, we only have one response in Spanish. So we definitely need to figure out how, and I know this has always been a challenge, but how to get more feedback from the Hispanic community. The good news is out of the 240 surveys that have come in, we've had 100 people raise their hand to be part of future focus groups.
18:14 So we're working with a company called Future Partners. So in January, we're going to start doing some local focus groups to continue this process. I think a lot of you are familiar with the JLL program that Visit California is doing from strategic planning for the state of California in the different regions. If you want more information on that, tomorrow morning we have our community coffee at 8.30. Bethany DeRose, who gave a presentation to our board this afternoon, will be doing a presentation for the community tomorrow.
18:43 That's a much bigger program. The High Sierra region is everything from Inyo County up to Alpine County down into Yosemite and Tahoe. So it's a much bigger region, but we want to make sure that Mammoth Lakes has its own understanding of what our challenges are and what the opportunities moving forward are. So if you got this and you haven't clicked on the QR code on the back, please do. We'll also be sending out, as we're doing this annual recap today,
19:10 We are going to be sending out, it's actually bigger than this, but we're going to be sending out an annual report that will be in your mailboxes likely by the end of next week. And so this will have quite a bit more information. And then on the back, it also has the same QR code. So we're hoping we can get a bit more participation in the survey as well. So with that being said, let me roll right into this. So on the financial overview side, you know, last year from a TOT standpoint was a record by far.
19:40 It was even well ahead of the 21-22 season, which we thought was going to be a really hard one to beat. But this just gives you an idea of where we've been since 2013-14 fiscal. Back in 2013-14, we were just shy of $10 million. Last year, we were just shy of $30 million. And so with a couple of hiccups there for COVID, we have been constantly growing the revenue side. And I think that the opportunity there is...
20:06 The controlled growth, the revenues are coming in. We need to utilize those dollars. You've heard me say it before to solve the challenges that come with visitation, whether it's parking or trash or restaurants or those different pieces. So we continue to look at that, but the revenues on the TOD side just wanted to show how the growth has happened over the last decade. This past year, this past year for the TBID, the gray line is the budget. I don't expect you to be able to read the numbers on there, but gray line is the budget. The blue line is actual.
20:37 Last year, we budgeted fairly, what I thought was fairly aggressively, and you can see that across each of the categories of lodging, restaurant, retail, and ski area that we exceeded budget across the board. This, I think, is really the true tale of this. This shows you the revenues by segment for the overall revenues for that segment. So again, lodging last year was somewhere in the vicinity of $220 million that came in.
21:06 Of that came the T-Bid, and of that came the TOT. But the big thing is that our businesses raised that money. And on the blue is the retail, the teal is the restaurants, and then the green is the ski area. And so you can look at, again, where we were growing, then COVID hit. We still did fairly well. And then the last two years, we have been growing pretty exponentially. One thing I'd note, too, is that back in 1617,
21:33 That was the last year that we included season passes from the Mountain. After that, when the Icon Pass came into being, we no longer had those in there. That was all voluntary from the Mountain. So from 2013, when we put the TBID into place until we renewed it in 2018, season passes were included. Once it became corporate, they were no longer included, which we appreciate the support and not something that we took a hit on. Can I ask you what those numbers?
22:02 That's the snowfall. So the snowfall, and I put the snowfall on here because I think it's important to note that we're not a one-trick pony. We're not just based on whether we have a great season for skiing or not a great season. We've been able to pick up the shoulder seasons in the summer. And so you can see even back 21, 22, we only had 260 inches of snow, which in our measurements is pretty low, but we're still able to have a pretty substantial growth in all categories.
22:33 I'm talking about our expenses. So our Measure A expenses, and this is Measure A plus other income. So it's not necessarily just the amount of funds that the council has assigned to us. In this fiscal year, it was $2 million. But we did have other revenues that came in. So this kind of shows the breakdown. At this point, this was the first year that we had split wages and payroll and benefits into both TBID and TOT. So it was 50-50.
23:03 This fiscal year that we're in now, we've actually moved that to being 75% TBID, 25% measure A. So it'll actually bring those numbers down. But what's important here is on the measure A expenses, if you look at the marketing, sales, communications, and special events, they make up 76% of the dollars spent on the programs. So that's education programs, that's visitation programs, all of those pieces. Then we look at the TBID expenses, and it's even stronger. So again, this was when we had...
23:32 A much smaller portion of the wages and benefits coming out of TBID, it was 50%, this year it's 75%, but because the revenues are so much stronger, it's a much lower total. But on the TBID side, you can see that 93% of the revenues that come in for the TBID are spent directly on the programs. They're not spent on overhead, they're not even really spent on the wages and payroll. And then when we combine them, again, the marketing, sales, communications, and special events becomes 88% of the budget.
24:01 And then the general administrative, which is the wages, the benefits and the overhead is 12%. In this industry, the average or the typical average is between 30% and 35% on overhead. And so for the fact that we're managing this size of a budget with a pretty substantially lower G&A is I think important to note. Rolling quickly into the air service report. You know, last winter was very strong in both.
24:33 Bishop and at Mammoth Yosemite. Denver was up 2,700 round trips. So that's roughly 1,350 individuals, roughly. So that was pretty strong. San Francisco up as well. Across the board, we were strong. Hawthorne, we saw a huge jump, 129%, because we eliminated Los Angeles. We had commercial service out of Los Angeles prior. We anticipated that we would pick up in Hawthorne, and we did.
25:03 And I think this winter going into it, Burbank did not perform as well as we had hoped. We actually, when we flew with JSX years ago, we got Burbank up to about 80% load factor. So we kind of assumed that Burbank would pick up where JSX left off. And I think having Hawthorne and Burbank as options may have just spread it out. And so when we're looking at it this year with Burbank out of the picture, Hawthorne right now is already up 63% compared to where we were last year.
25:31 So just like we expected it to go up last year when we got rid of the LAX service, we expected the Burbank service, and it looks like that's actually coming to fruition. Carlsbad's up about 7% so far for this year. It's only 70 round trips. San Francisco is pretty much flat to last year.
25:50 Denver, unfortunately, right now is quite a bit behind. It's about 900 passengers or 900 round trips behind, which is about 20%. So overall, going into this winter, we're about 12% off of where we were, but we're about 500 people. And I think a lot of that has to do with the fact that there's not a ton of snow, and I think we need to get that out there. Also notable for last year was with the ridiculous winter that we had, we were very, very fortunate at the fact that we got most of our planes in.
26:21 And most of the challenges that we had, even with advanced airlines, you know, we had, if you can see this, we had a completion rate to Mammoth Yosemite Airport of 76%. But because they can divert to Bishop, because they're on schedule, they can actually divert down to Bishop. That went up to 91%. So it's almost a guarantee that you're going to get in here at this point.
26:46 And so that was sizable. And when we look back at 16, 17, which was another big year, even the completion rate for this year was much better than that. The problem more so than anything last year was actually having the highway closed. We'd get people in, but then we couldn't get them up the hill. With Bishop, it was also a very impressive, almost 96% completion rate. The biggest problem with the cancellations for Bishop wasn't Bishop Airport. I think we had two or three days that were affected by weather down there.
27:16 The rest of it was based on issues coming out of Denver. We had issues with planes getting stuck in Aspen, so they couldn't get to San Francisco to connect for our flight. And we also had normal issues in San Francisco with fog, et cetera. But, you know, 96% completion rate, that's really what we've been aiming for is that 96, 98%. This puts us on par with most of the ski towns in the West. So when you look at Vail, they're probably more like a 98%. If you look at Telluride, they're probably more like 96, 97. So it really worked out well.
27:46 So that's what I had on this side. I am going to turn it over to Laura, who's on Zoom. You probably won't be able to see her. Hello? Can you hear me at least? We can hear you. Hi, Laura. Awesome. How's everyone doing? Good evening. Sorry I'm joining you on Zoom. I have a sick child, so I didn't want to spread my germs around to everyone.
28:13 But yeah, so for our communications recap for 22-23, really our most important communication work came in the middle of the historic winter. I remember the meeting we had internally in January where we knew everyone in town was exhausted and the snow kept coming and the visitors kept coming when they could get here. And it was just a really critical time for the community.
28:43 And so we created this be patient, be considerate, be kind messaging. And I really think that was the pinnacle of our work on the communication side last year. We put this messaging out everywhere. We put it out in newsletters, on social media. And basically, we were just trying to educate the visitor on what to expect when they showed up in town and kind of ask them to have a little sympathy, empathy.
29:11 For our community who was shoveling daily and then showing up for work to serve them in our restaurants and retail stores. This messaging went on throughout the spring when we started having propane issues and homes blowing up and all sorts of chaos. We worked with a lot of our partners, the town, the mountain, Mono County. We really came to the table.
29:39 In partnerships, that was the only way we could make all this work to make sure everybody was on the same page and putting the same thing out there. The feedback we received from visitors and locals alike was very, very positive. Next slide, please. It was about 17 newsletter communications sent from January to April. This was a combination of, like I said, our visitor newsletters as well as our local community newsletters.
30:10 The average open rate on these newsletters was 50%. Industry standard is about 25% open rate for our newsletter. So people were interested, people were reading. And again, these were community newsletters. So our community was reading. And we got a lot of thanks. I think that the best part of my winter was a community business owner telling me that our messaging felt like a warm hug, that they felt like we were paying attention.
30:40 And I do believe over the years, you know, the little side note I have at the bottom, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we have a track record of stepping up for the community. And last winter was no different. Obviously, you know, to go back to COVID times, we put messaging out there then for people not to come. And then we did the community food bank. Our partnerships with the community just continue to grow stronger and stronger through efforts like these.
31:09 We have the lists and the newsletters and the social media audience to really be able to direct this messaging when needed. And I think we have shown up for that. So that's really the biggest piece of the communication side from 22-23. Next slide, please. And then on the domestic PR side, we did have an excellent...
31:37 Full year of media placements. We had 279 placements. That includes articles that were syndicated, which means they ran in one publication and then many, many other publications, you know, picked up the same article. And we had a total of 13.5 billion impressions on all of that media coverage. And this was from July 1, 2022 through June 30, 2023. So this includes...
32:04 You know, obviously winter articles, but also fall coverage, and then spring and into summer coverage as well. So that's it from the communication side. Thank you. One thing I forgot to note was if you do have questions, feel free to ask them after each presentation so that we don't move. I'm going to turn it over to Michael. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International Sales, Marketing, and PR. So just a quick recap of things on the international side. Whoa, going too fast.
32:38 So obviously if you guys were out there hiking or fishing or paddle boarding at all this summer or this fall, you probably saw a lot of folks that are visiting from other countries. You heard a lot of accents. We are definitely seeing the re-emergence and the rebound of international visitation. It's very exciting to see. Obviously we were pretty flat there during the pandemic. And so to get that key visitor element back into Mammoth Lakes, they generally come during our times of need.
33:06 They come in the autumn, they come in the spring, they come midweek winter. So it's a key, key visitation segment that we want to really, really reestablish. So kind of some strategy that we put in place to reestablish our international was obviously to renew our contracts with our seven agencies that represent Mammoth Lakes around the world. You can see in the 18 international markets, it's a pretty darn big footprint. So we're getting our message out there to a lot of different folks.
33:33 And then on the international side, the strategy is normally to get media placements to drive curiosity, to aspire people to see Mammoth Lakes. Like I know LA, I know San Francisco, I know Yosemite. This place, Mammoth Lakes, looks incredible. Winter or summer, I'm going to look into booking a trip there or include it on my California itinerary. So that's kind of the way we strategize the visitation for the international. Continue to train the travel trade.
34:03 And then to work with all of our partners, whether it's Visit California, whether it's Altera, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Moto County, Inyo County, really, really continue that strong partnership we've got with all of our regional, state, and national partners. So on the trade side, we were very busy training a lot of folks out there. We did 363 B2B training sessions. That's basically explaining the people who are selling trips, where we are.
34:32 How to get here. What makes us so unique? What are the things you can do in Mammoth Lakes? Why make Mammoth your base to explore Yosemite? Why see Mono Lake? Why see Bodie? What the heck is Bodie? What is that place? I've heard about it. Crazy pictures. And you can see we trained a heck of a lot of travel agents, a little over 3,200. That wasn't all necessarily just me in person. That's also our seven international agencies out there training people in the travel trade industry in their perspective markets.
35:01 Very, very active. And then on the international PR side, we had a little over 300 international media placements that racked up a value of almost $2 million in media coverage, which is a very, very strong number. And then you can see the overall impressions were a little north of almost two and a quarter million. So quite a few impressions. And that was quick.
35:29 That was the international. Do you guys have any questions specifically on international? Thank you. Hi, I'm Emily Bryant. I am the local marketing manager here. I'm going to go over special events. This might not be the most exciting special events presentation you guys have heard. I'm not going to be as boisterous as Dakota used to be. So last year we did actually have a 31% increase in the amount of funding that we gave out to
36:06 events for the 22-23 season. As you all know, we had a brand new Tier 1 event come here in October, which is very exciting, the OCR World Championships. That's a five-year deal, so we will be seeing them again. We're very excited about that partnership. Additionally, you know, we did really employ the campground hosts this year, not only to promote our special events, but actually also to promote the Camp Like a Pro program.
36:33 Because a lot of times they're full and so that's a great way for them to get them into the right spots. So Dakota and I did a lot of work and in touch with the campground hosts over the last summer. Very exciting to sort of connect with them again this year. As you may know, they turn over a lot and a lot of them are new to our area and they don't know what's going on. They don't know how to get into Red's Meadow. They don't know these things. So that's a very exciting program and connection there.
37:00 And then, of course, everybody's aware we did have to move and delay some of our events due to the summer winter that we had. And, you know, that did actually result in us having three Tier 1 events on the same weekend, Yoga Fest, Mammoth Tough, and the Outbound Music Festival. And I think if you were here during that weekend, it was a really great active weekend for the middle of September.
37:26 And then finally, the Prism Cam. You've heard about this. It's now online. It has a great look at Main Street. It is a static video, but then it does give a 24-hour time lapse. If we could just get some snow, it would be a great way to tell what the road conditions are like here. Now, moving on to local marketing. As you all know, we continue to support the Yifty gift card program with the idea this year that...
37:56 We would actually pursue a different program with Bandwango, which was the Apre Ski Trail. Actually, as it turned out, the Bandwango Apre Ski Trail was not as successful as we would like, and so we have stepped away from that. It does look like the Yifty gift card continues to be a super success as people continue to buy, and I will just say there's still about $10,000 out there.
38:19 of gift cards available to spend in our community. So if you are a business and you are not on the Yifty gift card program, hit me up and let's get you signed up. United and Advanced Air Promotions, all of you have gotten those local discount code in your PO box, and then additionally the promotion of the 10-pack. We've also really focused this year on special offers because what we saw
38:43 In terms of industry research was that travelers are really looking for those special deals and offers. They want to take advantage of those opportunities to get a discount. Sometimes it's just a little bit of a lower rate if they're coming here midweek. And then also, we did have to go out and create a new occupancy reporting system. In the past, Mono County has been gracious enough to host that reporting system for us, but unfortunately...
39:10 At the beginning of last year, they let us know that they would no longer be able to support that server for us. So we went out and we found, sorry, a new system. And it's really great. And I think, you know, we've seen a lot of good results. It also provides for the lodging community a little bit more access to the research on ADR and rev pars across the country and compare with other mountain towns. Now you'll see a note on here about open rate.
39:37 I think it is really important to note because we do talk a lot about our communications with our community members. The occupancy report has about 389 people on the list and it has an open rate of almost 70%. So what we put in that email is very important and people are looking at it. Finally, the digital kiosk. This is a program with the California Welcome Centers. We have installed a digital kiosk in our lobby and this allows them to access
40:07 You know, visitor information 24 hours a day. We rearranged the doors so this kiosk is fully available to visitors at all hours of the day. And then my lovely trout sticker on there. I'm really excited about our trout sticker. You're going to see more of that probably next year, but I think that was a really popular sticker that we got out there this year. Any questions?
40:49 Hi, my name is Samantha Lindberg. I am the Digital Marketing Manager for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and I'm going to do a brief recap on our digital marketing efforts, starting with our website. Oh my gosh. So you may or may not know, but we launched our new website at the beginning of November, and we initially started that RFP process with a company named Tempest at the beginning of February. Typically...
41:23 Given the complexity of how much content we had within our website and we had transferring over, typically that would take a lot longer, but we ended up launching within eight months. Our website the last fiscal year saw 1.2 million users with an average engagement rate of 47%. The industry average engagement rate for other DMOs within our industry is about 45 to 50%, so we're pretty in line here.
41:50 And then diving in a little bit deeper here, our average time on site for our website is 49 seconds, and we had over 273,000 pass-throughs to other local businesses and resources through our website. Moving on to our social media efforts. So our goal with social media is to share aspirational content, information on events, local businesses, along with providing educational and stewardship information.
42:18 Within this last past year, our social media accounts, Instagram and Facebook specifically, had nearly 70 million impressions, an average engagement rate of 4%, which is exceptionally high given that the average engagement rate for our industry is anywhere from less than 1% to up to 3%. Link clicks from our social media was over 190,000, and these links include any direct links from our website or external sources. In addition to
42:49 What Laura said earlier, a big part of last year was also our safety messaging with the be patient, be kind, and be considerate. With that, we shared 62 posts with specific messaging, and these posts yielded nearly 2 million impressions within five months. And within those five months, we also saw about 242 engagements from those safety messaging questions. Thank you.
43:26 Okay, Sarah's going to do the marketing recap and I'm going to drive forward. Hi, everyone. I'm so sorry I couldn't be there in person, similar to Lara, also dealing with a sick little toddler. So thank you for having me. I've met some of you in the room, but I am the new director of marketing for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And so I'm really excited to report on some incredible work that was done by the team and my predecessor.
43:52 Kicking it off with noting that the launch of the Real and Real campaign and focusing on that stewardship message was the highest priority as we headed into the paid media efforts for fiscal year 22-23. I'm not going to read everything off the slide. You guys have this information, but I'm going to pull out some specific highlights that I think are really important to note. So when we're looking at delivering this brand new brand campaign, really educating the visitor on how to keep Mammoth Lakes tourism.
44:21 You know, around for generations to come and pushing that stewardship education message. We got that message in those videos and those in that educational content in front of 149 million people. In addition, we drove over 20 million views to some of that new real unreal content, as well as almost 700,000 click throughs over to our website.
44:48 So as I take you through the seasons, I think it's really important because we structure our paid media by four content types. So we do fall, winter, spring and summer, as well as airline service. So when we're looking at fall performance, it's important to note that these markets, what that we're marketing to is kind of like real-time content that's showing up thanks to our in-house photographer, Sam, and as well as our content team, Laura and Lauren.
45:15 Really looking at how we can educate people on what's happening in real time to drive those midweek bookings with the nature enthusiasts that potentially have no kids, high income, and can come during maybe a last minute decision to come. So looking at the California and Nevada base and kind of driving that seasonal message of coming up and participating in leaf peeping and all of the outdoor recreation that pertains to fall.
45:43 Things to note here is that this is actually our lowest amount of spend in terms of where we're putting our paid advertising, but we're seeing such a big return. I know that we saw, you know, 74,000 people driving to the website. We saw an increased time on site, and then we saw almost 1.7 million video views of the Real Unreal campaign during this time. To dive into winter, the unique winter that...
46:12 Didn't end. When I get to summer and spring, we'll see that we actually didn't really have summer messaging. But this is really where we put the bulk of our dollars and really try to push that midweek visitation in our airline service and really support those efforts there. It's important to note that this is when we also drive to our fire markets.
46:33 The Denver area in the Northeast with some of the dollar spend. This is also when we tend to find some of those more unique opportunities such as Dog Trekker, Travel Zoo, Hulu, some of Matador, some of the bigger content types that we can't necessarily do in all seasons. So this is where you'll see the largest amount of spend, almost $2 million. And we saw about almost 100 million impressions. So eyes on this.
46:59 Brand awareness piece all the way down the booking funnel. We also saw almost 400,000 websites or users driven to the website. And I think it's important to note that there's a big chunk of airline referrals here. So driving to that airline booking website to actually make those bookings and get those conversions. Due to the snowfall, the crazy snowfall, we actually paused.
47:26 This winter marketing in March because it was no longer safe for the community, for people to travel and we hit pause on making sure that we were kind of adjusting to the community needs at that point. So spring and summer, the spring and summer that really never was. So I think our spring and summer actually ran like that.
47:49 Update and Visuals and Creative actually ran for four weeks. Prior to that was an extended winter campaign. So really driving that spring skiing and summer skiing message to the California and Nevada markets and looking at where we could get those skiers and get that education out there on who should come in and visit.
48:09 This is interesting because although it performed really well, there was a time where there was quite a bit of like ski snow ad fatigue. And so actually when we got into the trained creative of summer, it actually increased a lot of these percentage to goal because we had such a long run of that winter messaging. So again, this was about 550.
48:30 A thousand dollars, so a little bit more than fall, but a lot less than winter. And time on site was almost 50 seconds. And then you can see where we had almost 5 million video views. I think people started to get really into some of that winter messaging and then diving into some of that real and real summer content. Here are some creative examples just to get your eyes on them. I know they're in your packet, but this kind of takes you through all the different types of paid advertising that we worked through. So whether that was our partnership with United Airlines and that.
49:03 All the advertorial slash ads that we get in there are out of home examples, as well as some of our day-to-day social media marketing messages through Meta. So this is kind of takes you through examples of all of the marketing creative that we did last year. And then some last notes, research. Research is a big part of what we do. It's an even bigger part of this fiscal year. So I think it's really exciting to hear some of the things that are coming down the pipeline. I did want to talk about...
49:33 Samari Insights. So Samari is an ad effectiveness survey. And we saw because we launched a new campaign that this information was really important to understand and digest. So for every dollar we spent on marketing, we saw a $358 return. So that drove almost $571 million in tourism revenue just from the ad tracking from that brand awareness piece. Mammoth Visitors, when they were tracking this, they saw that
50:01 Actually, one of our strongest audiences is Snow. And although it's such a small audience, it became the strongest in recognizing our brand, their desire to travel to Mammoth, and how much they related to the real-on-real messaging, that stewardship messaging. What it also showed us, which is really valuable for our new website, is that other than friends and family, the DMO website is the number one source of information for people that see our branding. So I think it's really important to note that
50:31 That with our new website, they're going to have access to even more information. And due to the Real and Real campaign, that 50%, there was a 50% recall on our brand awareness, which is really high in the industry. So it was really interesting to read through some of that ad effectiveness studies. In addition, with our agency of record, the shipyard, we do seasonal air service studies that have carried over until this year. And then with tourism economics, we're able to really look at our...
51:00 Monthly dashboard that pulls in data from all of our data resources, whether that's credit card data, whether that's geolocation data, and all different types of data. So we're able to make real-time decisions with the dollars that we're spending on behalf of the community. Great. Thank you, Sarah. I appreciate it. The other thing on the research side, and we'll be talking about at our board meeting next month, is the visitor profile. So typically we do a visitor profile every two years, figure out who people are, where they're coming from, what they're coming for, how much they're spending.
51:32 Where they're staying, how they're getting here, all those different pieces. And so we're expecting to see a copy of that next week. We'll be presenting at our board meeting on January 3rd. So happy to present that to town council as well. If you want it on your agenda, we can bring that in as well. But that's always good information to see how we've changed the dynamic over the years. So 2016, 2018, nothing because of COVID. And then we're coming back into it now.
51:56 The last thing we have here is just the TBID annual report. This is something that we do every year just to give you an idea of where we've been and what we're doing. I had given you the budget breakdowns and the expense breakdowns, but on the annual report here, as you obviously know, we renewed the TBID for September 2023 through August of 2028.
52:15 We did have a great support from the community, again, 62.4% of the voting businesses voted to approve renewal. We've been in place for 10 years. This is starting our 11th year at this point, and we appreciate the support. There are no changes to the district boundary. It's still just the town of Mammoth Lakes, and the town of Mammoth Lakes incorporates the airport as well, so it's just within the town boundaries. And the assessments on lodging, retail, and restaurant are the same as they've been since 2013. We have not changed those.
52:44 We did work with the mountain to increase the percentage on ski tickets and lessons up to 2.5 and also incorporate golf in. So golf will be on greens fees and lessons, not on season passes just as it is in the wintertime. So anticipate that that's probably a $300,000 to $400,000 to $500,000 impact every year just from that additional half point increase. Last year, the lodging exceeded budget by $333,000, so just about 18%. Retail was up about 4.5%.
53:15 Restaurants were strong, up 14%. The ski area's up 9%. So again, I budgeted last year fairly aggressively. I budgeted this year even more aggressively. We're ahead of last year through October in the budget. We're ahead of last year. We're behind budget by a minor amount, $28,000. I think we're ahead of last year by $56,000. So obviously November and December are not looking like they're going to be super strong, but we can always recover that.
53:44 We're not talking about major numbers. Overall, the TBID exceeded budget by 11.5%, and our reserve sit at $4.2 million in that fund. That fund is really what we use when we write checks in the next couple of weeks here at United Airlines for this winter's service. Typically, that's going to be about a couple million dollars worth of checks, so we need that reserve there for those purposes as well as operating uncertainties. So are there any questions of myself, the team? Any thoughts?
54:14 Councilmembers, questions? No questions, John. One comment. Sure. I think the presentation shows us just how mobile, if you will, the MLT can be, how they can segue, stop advertising for people to come here in March and start worrying about that, and that makes them a great community asset. So I just wanted to point that out. They've always been great about being nimble. Well, I'll just...
54:53 Maybe add to that. I think it's going to be really interesting to see what happens as we go into what my normal year. And I think that we've been through the town, the council, and Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we've been through all kinds of stuff over the last 12 months. Socially, politically, partnership-wise, natural environment-wise. And I think it's really nice to be able to start looking at
55:21 Okay, we've got some terra firma, some stable ground underneath us. And I think it's going to be very exciting, very interesting to see what happens as we go forward. I have a lot of thoughts and a lot of ideas, but I'm not going to start yapping right now. But I want to thank you on behalf of the Council of Town. Thank you for your time, for your effort, for the expertise of your team, all the great work your team does. And I think just really echoing Bill's sentiment. I think it's great to see the responsiveness on the local side.
55:51 And I think when you guys are putting out the information about be kind, be considerate, don't be, you know, just be a human being. And looking at some of the things that come to the town in terms of things like parking tickets, all the nonsense that was going on up at Canyon Lodge last year, and how important this partnership is to emphasize what the message is and what we as a jurisdiction need to do to be able to back that up and all be on the same page with these things as we go forward. So just personally, I'm very much looking forward to the next year.
56:20 And to work with you guys as we go forward. I appreciate that, John. And I think the other piece that's really key is what's happening with JLL, with the Visit California Strategic Planning. I think that's a great thing moving forward and what we're doing on a localized level to make sure that Mammoth Lakes has their own strategic planning to move forward. And I'm going to say just one thing because I've been sitting in those JLL meetings. It's how important it is for all of us to understand that what's going on up in Tahoe, what's going on up in that place up there.
56:50 And how different we are from that. And how we're going to have to start, this is a real opportunity to start differentiating a little bit. They're really in triage mode. I mean, all the issues we have about over-tourism and things like that, if we think for a second that we've got it bad, they're on the verge of the whole thing imploding and getting quite serious. We empathize with them. We can do what we can to help them out. But I think in our geography, in our region, and in Mammoth Lakes,
57:18 We have an opportunity to be differentiating on a lot of different fronts. It's just one thing I think we'll need to look forward to. And I'd encourage everybody, if you haven't read the Tahoe Stewardship Plan that just came out recently, it's 165 pages of information. We are different, but we're the same. You know, all the things that they want to say are challenges are maybe amplified up there a little bit because of their day traffic, but we're all dealing with parking and trash and visitors being disrespectful.
57:43 It's 17 jurisdictions up there came up with this tourism master plan, and I think it's something that we need to strive for down here as well so that we can avoid getting so far down the road that we're mopping up instead of being proactive. And I think we have a real opportunity. We're ahead of that curve, and that's a real thing to be looking forward to. Okay, any MLT board members, anything you want to ask at council? Okay, any public comment out there, Jamie? Okay. Chris, are you about to turn your mic on?
58:17 You good? Okay. The website looks really great. Oh, thank you. It was a lot of work from our team. Sam and Emily really did the book with that work. And Jezebel, who's not here, but yeah, lots of work. Thank you. Yeah, I just want to say thank you to everybody. I know how hard you all work. And the numbers speak for themselves. I know that it was a really challenging time as we went through the renewal of the TBID, but I think...
58:46 We all worked together and came up with a solution. And I think, again, the numbers absolutely speak for themselves. You guys have evened out our quiet seasons, gotten people here when we need them. And so just thank you. And we'll look forward to seeing what happens next year. Okay. Well, I think we're good. Thank you all very much. Pat, thank you. Thank you for the opportunity. Appreciate it. Thank you very much.
59:16 And so we are going to, we're going to move our seats now. Okay, so we'll take a quick break. We're going to shuffle the deck chairs around. Thank you.
59:45 Okay, I gotta come out. I gotta come out. And we have a Puerto Rican dish that we call it a sweet plantain and meat pie. It's like a lasagna. No cheese, no gluten, but it's sweet plantain. Are you open these days? Wednesdays through Sundays. Okay.
59:59 I've been locked in my house for all kinds of things. Are you really? Yeah. Good luck. I'll come out. I'll come out. Make a reservation. Do it online? This week is... I'm sure it's going to be slow like this week, but normally, yeah, call. Yeah. Not the day of, because sometimes I don't get to. No, I'll be out.
1:00:53 Thank you.
1:01:34 Thank you.
1:02:04 All set. Okay. We are now moving on to 7.2. 7.2. The recognition of the outgoing mayor. I'm recognizing it. Good. Thank you very much. We're done with that. We'll move on to the next item. So, I am going to take this over, John. Okay. Thank you, Bill. So, this is our recognition of our outgoing mayor. I will tell you that...
1:04:56 John and I have worked at Crosspoint and sometimes together for a lot of years, starting with the gate issue and the forming of MLTPA, which John did and all of that. He has always worked for the community, for the locals and the visitors to create a sustainable environment for them and us. And has worked to create regional alliances to bring us all together, which is an important...
1:05:26 And I have a plaque for you, but I would ask if anyone else would like to say anything.
1:05:54 I just want to thank Mayor Wentworth for making my first year as a member of Town Council so much easier because it's quite a learning curve. So thank you for that. You're very generous with your time.
1:06:26 And your advice. I also just want to acknowledge that nobody works harder on behalf of this town than our mayor. You know, I don't think people realize, but every month he has the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership Call, which literally has 100 people on it. And there's an extensive presentation that goes with it. That's above and beyond everything that.
1:06:55 That John has done for the town. So I just think when you see him in Vons or in the back country or wherever, make sure that you thank and acknowledge him for all that he does for our whole community. With that, if we would all go in front, I'm sure Stu has his camera there to take a picture. Okay, well, thank you all. It's been a pleasure and it will continue to be a pleasure. This is a very interesting thing to do.
1:08:18 If you like this sort of thing. So with that, we're now, is this Jamie's? Is this the Jamie show? Ms. Gray? Sure. Appointment of mayor and mayor pro tem. Do I hear a motion to appoint a new mayor? I would move that we, I will nominate our mayor pro tem, Mr. Sauser, to be the next mayor of the town mayor. Do we have a second? I'll second. Okay.
1:08:53 We have a motion and a second. I guess Jamie, call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser? Am I allowed to vote for myself? Of course. Sure. Better vote for yourself. Yes. Don't. Yeah, Bill. Yes? Okay. Mayor Whitworth? Yes. Thank you. Congratulations. And I think, Bill, before we make this truly official, we have to start. But that will come after the next time. Do you want to rearrange the deck chairs on the deck chair? Yes, I do.
1:09:28 Okay. Yeah, on the Titanic. I had to say it. Well, that's showing confidence in me being elected mayor. So, next up would be the Vice Mayor Pro Tem. My mind is gone. I moved to appoint Chris Bubser for Mayor Pro Tem. I'll third that. We have a motion, a public comment. Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Wray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes.
1:10:17 Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. Thank you very much. No, I'm good. I'm good. Whatever you guys like. Okay, that moves us on the consent agenda. Nine-one. Me too. I need to do any appointments to commissions, committees, and boards. Yes. I have to flip to a different page for that. Next up is appointments to commissions, committees, and boards. So I have some recommendations here.
1:11:10 That I will start with, if that's fine with the rest of the council. Land use, there are several areas there, but all of them the same, the people who are currently appointed. Intergovernmental, status quo, same as we have currently. Transportation, the one change I am recommending there is the LTC, and that would be to have Amanda step into John's place.
1:11:40 With the town manager as the alternate. Local issues would be John taking my place on the Mammoth Lake Tourism Board, if that is fine with all of you. All others would remain the same. And I believe we could just make one motion to cover all of that, if somebody would like to make it as presented. I move to approve the changes to boards and commissions as presented. I'll second.
1:12:11 I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Any public comment? With that, I'll call for it. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. 5-0. Okay, forgive me while my mind takes a short vacation here. Moving on to consent agenda. Item 9.1.
1:12:42 Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of November 15. Thank you. 9.2, accept check registers 11-8-23, 11-16-23, 11-21-23, 11-29-23. And that is all. Does anyone want to pull anything from consent? Can I have a motion? I move to approve the consent agenda as presented. Second. I have a motion and a second.
1:13:18 Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Moving on to Item 10.1, consider approval of a request from Mammoth Housing for an additional $700,000. Dan? Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. We discussed this item in detail at your last meeting. This is funding for Eastern Sierra Community Housing for the Access Apartment Project.
1:13:49 Pretty good consensus from the council that you want us to come back with a funding recommendation to move this project forward. We were able to do a follow-up meeting with some representatives from Eastern Sierra Community Housing staff, some elected officials in town and county, and I think we walked through and got a much better understanding of the finances that are available within the current budgets, including the towns, etc.
1:14:14 And we are recommending an allocation of additional $700,000 to the project. The project is moving from an 11 to a 13-unit project, which provides additional funding. Also looking at options to increase some of the units to 120% AMI, which adds additional cash flow into the project in the long term with those levels. We are continuing to leverage a variety of funding sources from Grants, Town, County.
1:14:42 Eastern Sierra Community Housing Resources going into the project and others. So with that, we believe the project is at this point fully funded. I would say in some cases a bit super funded. So we do have some contingency and capabilities if there should be some challenges. The one other element that we committed to in working with Eastern Sierra Community Housing would be to provide
1:15:08 Our funding up front, and we'll also make a similar request to Mono County, this provides the cash flow for the project. Originally, there was concern about having to borrow money to cash flow to make sure there was no problem in getting the project paid for as it goes, mainly because of state grant reimbursements sometimes do not go quickly. So the two commitments there would be, one is that funding up front, and secondly, if there is a challenge in cash flow,
1:15:36 Come and ask us. We'll address it. We'll fund it. So we'll figure out how to get the cash flow so they're not, you know, running into those types of problems. We know what that looks like in some other projects at times. So I think it's a great partnership that's coming together now to fund this project fully at a level that hopefully it's more than funded or reimburse Eastern Sierra Community Housing for some upfront cost as well through the process there. A little tough getting here, frankly, but...
1:16:04 The recommendations there for that additional $700,000 in funding, which would be in addition to the $1.5 million the town has already committed. I can answer questions. Patricia from Eastern Sierra Community Housing is here, and I think Nolan's in the room, and he can speak to details as well if there's any particular questions from the town council. Questions from council. Okay. Public comments. Anyone from the public wish to speak on this item? Mayor Sauser and council members.
1:16:53 Patricia Robertson, I'm the Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Community Housing, and I have with me here today are Kevin Sherada, our Project Manager, who is hired on as temporary staff capacity through our organization to help push this project through the permitting and construction phase. Since the last time we reviewed this project, I worked really closely with Nolan, town staff in the building department.
1:17:22 To fine-tune the fees and our consultants and to present this budget to you today, which I think is really our good faith efforts really tight. We also were able to find some additional funding sources through the CDBG grant, which had some administration funds that we can move into the construction sources. I think that's a great compromise. That was a great idea.
1:17:51 That Nolan had. But the budget that you see before you today represents a reduction of about $600,000 in the overall project budget and an additional $300,000 in revenue source from the CDBG grant but also in additional fundraising. We fine-tuned our fundraising numbers. We actually got some more checks in the mail today so it's not completely accurate but that effort is still ongoing.
1:18:25 I think that it's been a great team effort, but the tightening up of the budget really does reduce our buffer for unknowns. Snow removal, for example, change orders. We can't predict the future, and so we do have a contingency. I think the budget is accurate. It's quite tight. I think that this shows our good faith effort to compromise and work together and also for our organization to take on.
1:18:57 Some additional risk. I also wanted to just make clear to everybody that during the last six years, in addition to securing the funding, completing grant applications, moving through the design and the bidding phase of this project, we carried the asset at a net loss for six years. Those carrying costs are not part of this development budget, but we've spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on insurance, interest.
1:19:29 Snow removal again, but all of those costs that aren't associated with the actual project itself, but that's part of the risk that we've taken on in carrying this asset during that pre-development period. I also wanted to give credit to our board of directors because they made two decisions which really made this process possible. We were able to sell two rental properties in order to seed the pre-development fund that paid for all the upfront costs that we've had.
1:19:59 As part of the development budget. So the NEPA analysis, paying some of the architecture fees up front, all of that was funded through sources that our board identified that we could use to forego some of our rental properties to invest in this project. They have also invested a percentage of our net proceeds at the end of the fiscal year towards keeping that account full so that we can continue to
1:20:30 Can I ask one question? Yes.
1:21:08 Patricia, you mentioned NEPA, and you mentioned that I think the last time you were in front of us. I'm not, I don't understand, help us understand what NEPA, the NEPA component of this project. So this project went through an environmental analysis including CEQA, which is the California Environmental Quality Act, but also the federal environmental quality requirements because of the funding sources. Okay, it's not where it is, it's just the funding sources required that that. Required the study.
1:21:35 It's a negative declaration, so there's nothing wrong with it. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any further public comment? Yes. Good evening, folks. My name is Michael. You might remember me from the recent past. And I just wanted to come tonight and present myself as a face of an individual participant who would benefit from these various programs, accessible housing, affordable housing.
1:22:21 I know sometimes when you're doing all these major number crunching, you can forget about the human spirit, the reason you're even motivated to collaborate and fund such projects. And I like to say I'm one of those reasons. As you know, I'm here for an unusual reason of obtaining health care. Unfortunately, that's going to be postponed again until we can find housing for me. And I'm faithful and very hopeful that in the near future, that opportunity will open up based on the...
1:22:50 Thank you. Anyone else in the room?
1:23:31 Hey, I just want to say I really support the Access Apartments and Sandy wanted me to mention that I did a fundraiser with my partner Grace a couple years back in that building exactly and we got at least 30 people from the community turn out and over 10 plus businesses donate to the fundraiser and we like did raffles, we had our friends come out from June Lake and Mono City and
1:24:01 They all supported it, and they're really excited for this project. And so, yeah, I think you should just go give them $900,000. We need this, you know, like, and just everything that's going on, you know, this is ready to go. What better way to contribute to the community than building, what is it now, like, 13 units or something? So that'd be a great way to say it. No one's going to say, oh, well, how much was there 13 units? How much did they cost? No one's going to say that.
1:24:31 But you are able to say we helped 13 families stay in Mammoth. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else? Good evening. Hi, Jennifer Kreitz, Mono County Board of Supervisors and Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board member as well. And the...
1:25:01 Continuum care. So I'm involved in housing and homelessness and I know what a challenge it is to find solutions. And I think this is one of many pieces to the puzzle. And as you know, the supervisors, the Mono County has supported this project.
1:25:24 In the town recently was $600,000. We've supported the Sawyer with $2.3 million for 13 units. They are dedicated to supportive housing through our behavioral health program. We've supported the Innsbruck Home Key Project along with you as well.
1:25:45 With 550,000. So I just implore you to continue your partnership with Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Mono County and everybody in the region. So thank you. Thank you. Good evening, counsel. Tom Hodges, board member of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. I just wanted to express my gratitude to John and Amanda in particular who worked with us to kind of figure this out and Dan and Nolan also just kind of.
1:26:18 Grounded through the details. And as you say, John, it's, you know, development's a business. And I think we kind of whittled down to the, you know, the nuts and bolts and the dollars and cents and figured this thing out. And I appreciate you guys' effort to work with us to figure, to get down to the final numbers and look forward to having your support on this as you consider voting for it. And I just also wanted to acknowledge, we did bring Kevin along with us so that you know, John, that there is actually a body behind the name that Kevin's done a lot of work for us.
1:26:47 An excellent project manager working on the Innsbruck Lodge for us right now and has been very, very engaged on access apartments up to this point. So we know we're going to hit the ground running on this and going to jump right into amending our plans and working on the update to the building permit and then engaging our contractor and hit the ground running come springtime. Looking forward to really knocking this thing out and delivering this project to the community. So thank you.
1:27:17 Thank you. Anyone else? And I apologize for the glasses. I've been having severe allergy attacks. But I'm here to, again, once again, talk in support of Mammoth Lakes Housing and access apartments. And I know that all of you know the background, but just to refresh, what's been happening in the last six years with construction costs?
1:27:55 Many grant applications. I think we're over, well over six million with grants, probably nearing seven. During that period, of course, construction costs have gone up each year. And of course, with the grant, some of the grants, it's taken two years to get that grant approved. In the meantime, the construction costs have gone up. So they have to go back and try to get extensions and additional grants.
1:28:26 And I mean several of them have taken over two years. But as a community, we should be so fortunate because those grants are in our name, the town of Mammoth Lakes, and in Mammoth Lakes Housing, which is now Eastern Sierra Community Housing. So accepting all of that, and then I read the staff report, and it's a 700,000 ask.
1:28:55 And we're left with such a small amount. Where is that going to come from? You know, Patricia's paired that budget down to the nitty gritty. And it seems like less than $120,000 is such a small amount to close that gap. Can't we do that? I listened to John's report tonight on the TV.
1:29:22 And it's always great. Our TOT keeps going up. That's a lot more money to spend. And we do wonderfully aggressive. His budgeting is aggressive. Ours is conservative. So I think I'm asking you to give that extra less than $120,000 along with the $700. And let's close the gap so that we can get on with the
1:29:49 Architectural Design, Updates, and all the little permitting requirements, but the most important of all is to sign that pre-construction contract so the contractor knows we're in, not wait another year for, you know, for everything to go up and up. So I'm just asking, I'm just begging you, as a town, you know, we should be able to show our support for a project that's in the heart of Mammoth.
1:30:17 That nobody that's going to live there is going to commute out. They're going to work or walk to work. So thank you very much. Thank you for listening. Anyone else in the room? Do we have anyone online? With that, I will bring it back for deliberation or motion. If I may address the budget gap that was noted, there actually is not a financial gap. I mean, right now, Eastern Sierra Community Housing is...
1:30:53 Going through building plans and stuff, but there's actually adequate funding to sign the construction contract as of now. Part of the funding that we're putting back into the program includes reimbursement of dollars back into the land purchase. There's, try to remember, Patricia, about $400,000 left on that note, so there's about $800,000 in cash that would roll back into Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
1:31:19 And part of the existing A&E cost and soft cost. There's still some of that to incur, but a portion of that would be reimbursed back as well. So the actual construction cost of just a hair under $7 million, which knowing remodel projects, the contingency, the majority of that will probably be utilized, just given the reality of projects. But between all the different funding sources, there is adequate funding to sign the contract to move forward with construction.
1:31:49 And as Patricia noted, being able to close the last little bit of gap out of that excess that would flow into Eastern Sierra Community Housing actually fully funds the project. And we've made the commitment to cover any cash flow needs that are necessary to make sure the project can move forward smoothly. Thank you. So, Tom, thank you for your comments. And I think the council really wants to support this project. I anticipate that we will.
1:32:18 But I think as we go forward with development projects, specifically with Eastern Sierra Community Housing, I think we can do a better job, all of us can do a better job of baking the partnership and baking who's doing what right from the beginning of the project. And I think it would avoid some of the confusion that happened in trying to chase numbers down and figure out what lives where.
1:32:44 I certainly support this project. I want to see this moving forward. I think to Sandy's point, I mean, this is a long historical relationship between Eastern Sierra Committee of Housing and the town. But I think, and I didn't catch your name. I'm sorry, your project manager. Kevin, I just, what's your last name? Okay, there's a Kevin Esch who's on LinkedIn, who's somebody different. But I think as we, as projects ripen and we start getting into, okay,
1:33:09 Here are the dollars and cents. Here's the roles and responsibilities. Here's the ask. Here are the contingencies. Here's all the rest of it. I think I look forward to doing a better job with those kinds of things so that when the project does come forward, it's clear everybody kind of knows where everything lies and we don't have to, to Sandy's point, wait a couple weeks to kind of sit down and hash out all the numbers and that kind of stuff. But just an observation. But I fully support the project. I'm ready to make a motion. Well, my feeling is they've come down quite a bit.
1:33:39 You know, the gap was 1.4. I feel like a few weeks ago our recommendation was to give them $900,000, and now they've come in asking for less than that recommendation. You know, I'd be comfortable giving them the $819,000 to fund it. I want to get this project going, so. On my part, I will say that I'm very comfortable with the $700,000. I've talked to Dan a lot about this. This should finish the project if the contingency can't cover it.
1:34:12 The contract has already been let. We can come back and do a measure to finish that. I have been a little uncomfortable with how the whole thing has come forward and been brought up and what the actual costs were versus what was going to end up going where at the end. So I, for one, am very comfortable with the $700 and if it becomes absolutely necessary to have it brought back to us, which doesn't take that long. This gives the money to move the project forward and actually build it. So I'm very comfortable. Chris?
1:34:46 Yes. I think that part of the challenge we have as a council is that when we prepare for a meeting and there's 700,000 in our staff report, and I did ask folks if that was going to be enough, I was told that that was going to be enough. So the tricky part is that when, you know, I totally appreciate members of the community coming and talking about other needs as you see them and board members, but
1:35:17 We don't, for us to shift 119,000 right here real time is a very uncomfortable thing because we try so hard to make sure that we're always very conscientious about coming here to make, to take votes, knowing where the money's coming from. So I really think it's important to mention that because I hear, you know, impassioned pleas, but I also think process matters. And so I really.
1:35:46 I think I had to mention that. Yeah, with that in mind, I'll make a motion at the $700,000. And again, it just goes back to what I was saying earlier. It's like, it's not a good idea. It's just not helpful to put council in a position of, oh, there's actually, we need something else. Let's see if we can work together, bring the thing forward so we're voting on the merits of it. So I'll make a motion, Mr. Mayor, to move the project forward, approve the allocation of additional $700,000 in funding to be committed to the excess part.
1:36:16 Department's Project. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Sarah, did you wish to comment on this? I was getting ready to move. Any further deliberation? With that, Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Yay. Good. Let's go. Thank you all. Let's go. Okay, moving on to 10.2, which is to request Caltrans
1:36:48 To do a relinquishment report assessment for State Route 203. Dan, we're going straight to you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is a follow-up to the discussion we had at the last meeting regarding the Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge project, but broader than that in looking at legislation that allowed for the relinquishment all over a portion of 203 that runs through Mammoth Lakes. To move this forward, Caltrans requires a request to do a relinquishment assessment report.
1:37:18 Based on the discussion at the last meeting, the letter does ask them to do a full analysis on 203 through our community, and also to identify what we call logical segments, and we'll work with them on how we want to look at this process. This takes it basically from the edge of town or 395 for, there's an element in there that's in the county, but all the way up to Minaret Summit.
1:37:41 It allows us to look at the status and conditions of the whole road and what that would look like. And again, be able to break it out, like what comes through town, what's maybe the village, what's up 203, what's at the mountain, et cetera. So it allows that report to go forward upon request. It still does not obligate the town to accept any of the roadway. It's not a matter of us doing this and say, oh, by the way, now you've committed to something. The answer there is, no, we have not.
1:38:09 We get a full report, though, of the status of the roadway, which I think provides some valuable information in terms of the condition and status of the State Route 203 through our community all the way up to Minaret Summit and ultimately tying into the Reds Meadow Road, which ultimately will be Town's responsibility for that road going into Reds Meadow through a whole different process of funding.
1:38:31 So there's a draft letter here requesting Caltrans to move forward with that report. A lot of work to do within that process to get that report done. It will take some time, no doubt, to be able to come back and look at that and have some work with the Caltrans in different portions of the roadway. If there's any questions, we can address that. We believe this captures the discussion to move this item forward to have the road looked at its entirety, again, with no obligation to accept it. And at the main lodge side, they are still at...
1:39:00 Evaluating the alternatives related to that project and the location of the road, but that would be part of that evaluation as it looks at the existing roadway and what the cost would be in those types of elements. So of maintenance and construction, if they have to rebuild the whole road, there's a lot of factors that go into that. With that, any questions for that? John? The report itself, is it a written narrative document? A, B, does it include GIS engineering?
1:39:31 Any kind of survey type work that has any legal standing? I don't know all the standards for that. I know it brings back elements for looking at the total cost of reconstruction. My guess is we would want information on the rights away and easements.
1:39:48 The underlying easement through a lot of that area, which is port service, and then what the Caltrans has in their right-of-way maps and stuff. But I'll let Andy respond to some of that. Yeah, so Caltrans apparently has not done very much of this because it's relatively rare that they abandon any part of a state highway. And since the town has no obligation to take any part of it, if we think that the information we get back is inadequate, we can certainly say we'd like to get more information. Okay, because it has come up in the LTC and Caltrans has advised that they're starting a major reconstruction project of the entire road.
1:40:18 And I think it might make sense to talk to Caltrans to say, Andy, to your point, if they haven't done this thing before, maybe the report can consist of whatever engineering work they're going to do as part of their road reconstruction. That might make sense to wait because then we've got good contemporary engineering and survey work. I would sort of add that in as part of a motion to say we'd like to coordinate those efforts so that we don't...
1:40:44 Caltrans doesn't go flailing around trying to do something they've never done before, but actually get stuff that's going to be part of their reconstruction project. And we've actually had that preliminary discussion with Ryan Dermody, the program here, in terms of looking at that, what they were planning to look at. I think it's a 30-plus million dollar project. Yeah, and it's eight years. I think it's an eight-year project. Out their ways. And so all of that data they put together on that would be something that they would plan to incorporate.
1:41:09 Because if they were to, one of the comments was, yeah, if we have that plan, we know that's going to be a cost, plus whatever cost increases are between now and then, that would actually be a check they would have to write to the town if we were taking an obligation to rebuild that road. So we want a good number, good information, what does that look like? Not that we would do that, but that has been discussed early on, that we would get all of that data. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, John. Amanda? Chris? Sorry that I haven't asked this before, but it...
1:41:45 It did just occur to me. So Caltrans is doing this study and they're providing us the information. But when we think about this project of redoing all of 203, how confident are we that, you know, Caltrans is going to be completely forthcoming in everything that could be involved in this? Like, is there some kind of balance to them issuing this report?
1:42:13 Okay, thank you.
1:42:44 Actually, I see a benefit that Caltrans has already started and done most of the plan, which is supposed to start in six years, because they will have already gathered the maintenance details and what they normally do and the pavement report. I am comfortable with the letter. I originally thought that we should include in it, but I believe that there will be enough communication between the state and us to get by.
1:43:14 But I don't know that the people doing this for the state are going to understand the logical segments. So I would like to see something in the letter about, you know, we can't get it cleared to 395. We can only get it, as I understand, to Meridian. So from Meridian all the way up to Minaret Summit, from Minaret Road to Minaret Summit, from the cinder shed, basically, to Minaret Summit, and from the mountain to Minaret Summit so that we can understand truly what the maintenance costs, because that's really the...
1:43:44 I believe Caltrans will come up with the money to rebuild it. But the kicker is how much every year does that cost? We can deal with that if we decide to do something. But I think those logical, to me anyway, segments are important to have sussed out in whatever they come up with. Yeah, we want to really take a look at those segments because it might be a lot more narrow. Like we want to look through the middle of town. We want to look through from Minaret up to Mammoth. We want to look. There might be some.
1:44:14 Smaller segments in there where you're looking at construction, you're looking at road width, you're looking at what could go in the road, if it's ours versus theirs, you're looking at that maintenance component. We'll ask them to look at 395 up, although they're not obligated. The legislation talks just in the town boundary. So we can call something out in there, but I don't want to, then they go, no, this is what you said, so we're not going to look at some other modifications to that. But we can definitely bring back that information and say, here's how we're
1:44:43 Bifurcating the road out to have it looked at. That might be better. If we're missing something, you can ask for more information. Right, as long as we're having those communications. I mean, the idea, Dan, you got it all in one letter, on one piece. Easy for me to read and digest. I like it. But I think also this is coming out of a discussion with Mammoth Resorts about the disposition of the road up at Main Lodge. So having numbers around maintenance costs and things like that, that needs to help inform whatever decision, whatever we're going to figure out to do up there.
1:45:14 That's the critical data that we're going to need to have. Yeah, we want that maintenance by segment, but also total reconstruction, annual maintenance cost, estimated cost, everything due to pavement treatments, et cetera. There's a whole process. This is not going to be a short report. It's going to take time. I would expect it to take a good six months plus, frankly, maybe not to the end of the year before they actually have a full report done. That'll be moving quickly.
1:45:41 I'm prepared to make a motion if you want to add a public comment. Any public comment on this? Thank you. Tom Hodges here, Vice President of Plain Development at Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and part of the applicant team for the redevelopment project. I just want to be clear that from the perspective of Mammoth, we were really, you know, when we started, got the legislation forwarded, SB 606 and so forth.
1:46:13 You know, the intent of that was to address the relinquishment from where the redevelopment started to the west. And so I guess I just want to just formally state for the record that, you know, although I understand you guys have the option to look at the remainder of the Highway 203 down to the Meridian intersection, you know, specifically for us, that's not part of our project. So we, you know, would...
1:46:40 I guess my only concern to the time frame for the relinquishing report to be your assessment to be prepared for you guys, I just have a little bit of concern whether the extent of that would impact the overall schedule for the rest of the project in terms of publishing the draft, CEQA NEPA documents, environmental impact report, environmental impact statement. So I don't know whether that's something you guys can look into.
1:47:07 Maybe there's a way to bifurcate those two parts of it. So if there's a concern with overall timing, I mean, you know, we're anticipating the draft environmental documents to be published in about a year from now, roughly something like that. So, you know, if this report's prepared and available by early summer, it probably shouldn't be a problem. If it goes much beyond that, it might have an impact on the overall timing of releasing the public draft environmental impact.
1:47:36 You already are at EIS, Joint Document. So I would just request that you guys maybe look into that. And this is a lengthy, lengthy process already. And I hate to add another chunk of time to it unnecessarily. I don't know. Just want to throw that out there for you guys. But again, from our perspective, for the project, the original intent was to evaluate the relinquishment from where we would affect the right-of-way with the redevelopment of Main Lodge.
1:48:06 Would you be just to the east of existing main lodge area? Thanks. If I could, one of the things that we talked a lot about in the workshop was getting a framework in place for decision-making. And I think it would be really helpful, Dan, when you get the notes back from Jen or whatever, this framework, so we can go into this process, get the report rolling, let's see where we're at as the thing comes forward, and then we'll figure out what to do with it at that point. Yeah, I understand. I mean, they probably got to get...
1:48:37 Into a little bit to understand exactly what it's going to take. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Frankly, we need to understand what the state would be willing to do. They may not want us to only take that section. Any other public comments in the room? Do we have any online, Jamie? So I would move to approve the letter as drafted to Caltrans requesting a relinquishment assessment report to be for all or a portion of State Route 2 and 3. I'll second. I have a motion and a second.
1:49:18 Deliberation. Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Moving on now, Item 10.3, e-bike, Ordinance and Municipal Code Update, Lawson. Lawson Rafe, Office of Outdoor Recreation.
1:49:43 I think this is a long time coming. We have discussed a lot of the e-bike issues and just travel issues in general with folks either on the multi-use pathways, sidewalks that often double as multi-use pathways, and the need to address some of these issues. Before you, you will see the proposal for the addition to the municipal code to cover
1:50:09 These different types of uses to create regulation around some of these uses that will allow, hopefully, MLPD to primarily educate people in a better manner and have some teeth behind that education to maybe do some more enforcement if necessary.
1:50:29 I will say we did get the majority of this from Andy and the Municipal Code up in Truckee. I think they've done a good job up there of working in this e-bike space. Now, just a few things here briefly because I don't want to reread what you already have in your packet.
1:50:48 But this addresses all classes of e-bikes as these alternative modes of transportation. And being that the maximum wattage for those is 750, it does rule out those e-motorbikes, brand names, Saurons, things of that nature. I could be pronouncing it wrong.
1:51:07 So that is covered in this code. It addresses those e-dirt bikes, a 15-mile-per-hour speed limit, reckless driving, as well as endangering wildlife, other animals, alcoholic beverages or drugs, collisions, things of that nature. We did want to expand this, not only the MUPs, but the sidewalks as well, because the MUP is the sidewalk, particularly on the town.
1:51:36 Other than that, again, I don't want to reread too much of what I've already given you. Does anyone have any questions? Yeah, I just want to say that even though I did give Lawson and the PD the truck ordinance to take a look at, this is not just a cut and paste job. Lawson and the PD did take a really careful look at it and made some changes to it. So this is not just, well, whatever they did, we'll do too. This is independent thought from both Lawson and the people who are going to have to enforce this.
1:52:01 And in particular on the e-motorbike issue, Truckee did not have that really addressed in their municipal code and something we'd wanted to address based on feedback along with some other items. Any questions? In Truckee, appreciate what you said. Are any of the mops up there under special use permit to the federal government? No, the town only has one real trail that this applies to and it's not on Forest Service land. So there's no special use permit at all.
1:52:37 Okay. I don't intend to open up any kind of a black hole, but when you're dealing with infrastructure under permit to the federal government, there are ADA considerations, and I'm hoping that you and the PD and the Ford, you sort of coordinated on that, because questioning someone about what they're doing with a non-human-powered thing on a federally licensed thing can get very tricky. So I'm assuming you guys have kind of looked at that a little bit. Yeah.
1:53:06 We've been in coordination with the forest on this. I've spoken to the recreation officer at the Forest Service. They did not express concerns related to that. But I can, of course, re-engage them if necessary. But they did not directly express any concerns to me. That's fine. It's just a note. Once upon a time, I looked into some of these issues that get kind of complicated. The other thing is, because this sector is so rapidly changing and so rapidly evolving, are you confident, Lawson, this is something that can scale?
1:53:34 Not necessarily scale up, maybe scale sideways, but it's going to allow you in the PD sufficient decision space to deal with a lot of things that maybe we haven't even anticipated yet. I believe that it does, to the best of our ability at this time. I did work with Chief Kasabian on this as well, got his input, and he felt it did provide not only enough tea for the current situation, but hopefully for things we might find in the future. Now, of course, there are
1:54:03 Maybe unanticipated things that this may not cover, but we do feel this is the best stab at it thus far. This is a good place to get started. We'll see what happens. Thank you. Sarah? No questions. Thank you. Chris? My only question is how confident we are that we have a good plan for enforcement because it's, you know, I would be curious to hear, I should have probably asked this before, but
1:54:35 In your conversations with the police department, I just worry about asking them to enforce this code. And have we thought of creative ways to sort of get this out to the public without turning it into an enforcement challenge for them? Yes. I think this provides the framework to deal with some of the most egregious
1:54:59 Cases that we may face out there on the multi-use pathway. I don't think the goal of this is to be out there ticketing every single person and creating a scene in that regard. But in my conversations with the PD as well, they are aware of this. I think there are opportunities in the future to have more of a presence.
1:55:22 As it relates to the MUPS, whether that is, you know, a particular individual who may be able to patrol that in the future. But I think this really just creates that baseline framework to primarily educate people. And I think that's the goal. And then once we have this framework in place, we can build other proper, appropriate use items out on the landscape, signage, things of that nature. And then they can reference back to something.
1:55:51 That is actually part of the code. And for what it's worth, what Lawson is describing is exactly how Truckee PD has gone about it. It's not intended to be heavy enforcement. It's really intended to be a basis for having conversations out on the trail and educating trail users about here are the things you can and can't do, should and shouldn't be doing out on the trail. Really more framework for conversation than a framework for lots and lots of tickets. Thank you. A couple of things, Lawson.
1:56:23 It seems to me in reading this, and I like the way it's written up, but a lot of these would just as well be enforced on human power to not just motorize. The 15 mile an hour speed limit, the out of control, we see all of those happening not just with e-bikes. We love to call them out because so many more people can now ride bikes. But can that be done in this or does this, Andy shaking his head yes, so I'm comfortable with that.
1:56:53 So one of the last sections of the ordinance prohibits reckless operation of any alternative transportation device on trails, and that includes bikes. That includes things that are purely human-powered and things that are electrically powered. It's intended to give the PD and maybe Lawson staff the ability to have conversations and maybe sight if necessary for anyone who's being dangerous, even if they're just on a bicycle. Could that apply also to the speed limit? Yeah, it has a speed limit in here.
1:57:23 Because it's a human problem, not a bike problem. So we need to solve it as a human problem, not a bike problem. Okay, my next one, because sometimes my mind wanders when I'm reading this stuff. So my note is maybe different power specs other than 750 watts based on a rider's weight. So I can keep up with my buddies on the trail. Sorry, guys, I just can't. Other than that, do we have any other questions?
1:57:53 Sorry. Do you have a wattage recommendation? Yes. You do? How many watts was that scooter? We'll talk. We'll talk. Anyway, inside joke, folks. Yeah. Do we have any public comment on this item? Do we have any comment online on this item?
1:58:14 In that case, I would accept a... Yeah, what we're looking for is comment tonight. There's no formal action. If there's no adjustments, we'll work this up into an introduction for an ordinance at your next meeting and then move it through the process accordingly. But we didn't want to presume that we had it dialed in yet. So we appreciate those comments and that'll help us inform the staff write-up and some additional information when it comes back. That being said, looking at my agenda, we have one council member who needs to have a hard stop at 630.
1:58:46 Correct? That was hopeful, but it's not. Okay. I just have to drive tonight. So I'm asking you if you would like to see us move the financial audit up above 10-4 and 10-5 so that if you have to leave early, we get through the one that I consider probably the most crucial. You know what? Actually, the weather has held off, so I'm okay, but I really appreciate that. Good enough.
1:59:16 In that case, we will move to item 10.4, the ESCCRP Wildfire Fuels Reduction Project. Dan. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Again, this here is part of the whole Mona County Fuels Reduction Program that Whitebark is working on and others, a whole partnership here making this work. What was requested here was to provide a formal comment from the town on environmental...
1:59:42 assessment process, the EA work that's going on, so we have a draft letter that addresses support for the project. It also touches on some key elements in there. One is the type of work that's done we would trust does not impact our recreational amenities. Secondly, that we've had questions raised on whether or not the work can continue in inventory roadless areas. That doesn't mean they don't have roads, but different discussion.
2:00:08 The element there was trying to get full support for this project to move through the EA process to make sure that those things are highlighted as areas that are not impacted through the environmental process that it will go through and that we can see this project continue to go forward. The environmental assessment is critical for us to begin moving into funding and implementation of a lot of the work. Some of it's already happened on non-federal land and a little bit federal land areas where the environmental work was already completed.
2:00:36 So the letter does that. I will note that one additional request that's come up that I would recommend as a separate motion is some reference to some of the state documents that have been prepared related to wildfire and processes for sustainable recreation, working together a lot of areas. And having those documents maybe as a reference in supporting the EA could be very beneficial. Member Wentworth at the time, Mayor Wentworth, we had that discussion.
2:01:03 I'll let you speak to that. I think if we did that, if we could take it kind of in two motion steps, it would be beneficial so we could speak to the one. But the first one was get a letter of support in through the EA process that we actually want to see this move forward and hopefully without being diminished in its scope and scale. Thank you, Dan. Comment or questions? No questions. I got lost on the state.
2:01:34 Requirements part. I thought we were just... We'll come back to those documents and stuff. This is an environmental assessment. Right, okay. Yeah. So right now, the motion would be there's an action request to support the letter as drafted. Yes. There's a second piece we want to talk about briefly. I just wanted to introduce that. Okay, let's do the first part. Do the first one first with the letter, and then we can go to the second piece. In the report, the only thing that I made a note on here was...
2:02:02 That we're preparing the landscape for the reintroduction of beneficial fire. And I would love to see added to that and other means of creating a healthy and sustainable forest. Because fire is only while it has become the knee-jerk reaction. We have to have fire. We have to have fire. Before we can have fire, the forest has to be treated in ways to make it safe for us to have those fires. So I would just...
2:02:27 Yeah, we don't specifically speak to that in the letter. I know. I just wanted to point that out. You know the project does a lot of those things, but that is a good thing to remind her that it's not just putting fire in the landscape. Yeah, it's not just beneficial fire. There's so many things on the forest that have been let go, like thinning projects and all of those things that have created this issue. I would love to see us deal with all of that. With that, nothing else here. Any public comment on this? Good afternoon, Alex Tamire, Fire Chief, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District.
2:03:03 Also father of two girls at the hockey rink, so I'll make it really quick. Honestly, hopefully a no-brainer. This is something I'm going to be bringing to my board for support as well. The letter looks fantastic, so appreciate town support on this. Obviously, fire doesn't see any boundaries. We had a...
2:03:22 We'll talk over at Mammoth Creek Parcel, which is a town parcel. We had the exact same conversation. The IRA work is important to make sure that that stays in this project, especially when you look at areas in the shore winds and the lakes basin. So your support in that is important. Thank you. And congratulations to Jen and her team. Thank you. Any other public comment? Do we have anything online? Thank you. I will bring it back to council then. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the...
2:03:55 Council approve the submission of public comments as presented with any additions or subtractions as suggested. We didn't hear anything formally regarding the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, the ESCCRP. I'll second, but I want to clarify that it's presenting the letter as written. Yeah, that's my understanding. I'm just making sure because I heard different things. Okay, I'll second. I have a first and a second. Jamie?
2:04:29 Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. And then we did want to, the other element that we've done a lot of work on, some regional documents and looking at fire management and elements with different programs and projects identified. And this project actually supports a lot of the goals and efforts of those documents that have pulled together. They are a state.
2:05:00 I'd like to just dive into those as a separate motion. Yeah. Because the town has worked very closely with Whitebark for the integration of sustainable outdoor recreation practices and infrastructure with the project. This goes all the way back to the beginning. And this came out of when we first met, Jen, and I believe in this very chamber. And measure R.
2:05:25 Efforts have been used to provide data and to work closely with the White Bark Team to do that. There is now a state document, California's Joint Strategy for Sustainable Outdoor Recreation and Wildfire Resilience, that if the town could submit this as a reference document to help inform not just practices with this project, but I know this is a county-wide, potentially region-wide project, to have this included as a reference document for best practices going forward for that integration.
2:05:54 Sustainable Recreation, Wildfire Resilience. That would be my proposal. And I would make a motion to do that. So you're asking for a letter of support? You're asking for introduction of this document? To add, for the town to submit, Dan, you want to? What we would do is submit a separate comment that would incorporate a request that the document referenced would be a reference document, informing document.
2:06:26 And the analysis of the EA and the approval of the project accordingly. So kind of a short statement with it, but it provides information that we think is critical to our region, not just to the town, of how that sustainable recreation and fire resiliency blends together, especially in the Eastern Sierra when you look at our tourism-based economy. I agree that they do run together. I would be more comfortable had I already read the report I have. So I don't know.
2:06:59 How it calls out recreation. That's fine. We can wait. But I share it out. Yeah, we've read it. Lawson's looked at it. So I mean, if you're telling me I'm comfortable with it, then I can be comfortable with it. I trust you and Lawson. So I don't know how it spells out recreation or what forms of recreation or any of those other things. Can I say trust me? Am I allowed to ask a clarified question? I don't know if I'm allowed to ask the folks from Whitebark.
2:07:29 Am I allowed to in this situation? Yeah, they're supporting the project, if you want. Okay. Maybe to the mayor, though, so you can- Folks from Whitebark, could you, could someone come? And I would just like to hear your thoughts as well about whether you think it's a good idea to reference the state, California state report. Sure. So as John mentioned, Janet Hatfield, Whitebark Institute. I don't know where to look. There it is. Right here. Just look right here.
2:07:55 So I think what Councilmember Wentworth is referring to is the work he's done with the State Wildfire Task Force that with the Region 5 MOU with the state to, you know, increase pace and scale with this million acre target is how do we not leave recreation as sort of an afterthought given the importance of it in the state of California. And so this document helps provide some of those critical, that critical framework so that those of us that aren't from.
2:08:25 That world sort of can see it through the lens of the recreation, recreating public and those that work in that realm. So I think it would be a reference document. I think we recognize this summer working on Mammoth Creek. There are impacts to recreation when this work happens. It's very intensive. It's often dangerous to the public. So I don't want to give the misconceived notion that there won't be interruptions because, of course, you can't have public walking through a dangerous area.
2:08:55 I see a lot of value in an opportunity for Mammoth Lakes to lead in that sector, given the importance of recreation on the Inyo National Forest and surrounding landscapes. Thank you. That's exactly right. And I think also having just as a reference argument, there may be funding opportunities. There may be when Janet and the White Park team are writing grants for multi-million dollar projects in the states looking for multiple sectors. And we had a meeting with the
2:09:23 Head of the Wildfire Task Force just yesterday on this very topic and saying the projects are going to score higher to the degree to which they're saying it's not just this sector, it's this and this and this and this, multiple benefits. And just to have this thing as a reference document, I think it may be helpful as we all go forward looking to trying to find money for these projects.
2:09:44 Yeah, and I have no problem with that, John, as long as you're giving me assurances that it calls out recreation in general and isn't specific to any type of recreation so we don't see side-by-sides. No, no, no. When this was developed, there was a lot of public outreach. A lot of friends in the Motorized Committee were very involved in this, and this is writ large. In that case, I have no problem with it. Trust me. We have a motion from John. Does somebody want to second that motion? Yes. So the motion would be...
2:10:17 For the town to submit as a separate comment the California's Joint Strategy for Sustainable Outdoor Recreation and Wildfire Resilience as a reference document to help inform the environmental assessment. John, it looks like the gentleman on the front page just took somebody off of his bike with it. This is a gentle woman. Yeah. I have a motion. I'll second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation?
2:10:54 Jamie. Councilmember Rae. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer. Yes. Mayor Souser. Yes. Thank you all very much. Okay. Moving on then to 10.5, Council Strategic Priorities and Key Objectives Update. Number 24, Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. The staff report outlines a little bit of background over the last several years we've pulled together.
2:11:27 I think the proposal this evening is a little broader in some of the statements that we've had historically with.
2:11:55 And I want to touch on that and some of the priority statements and the staff report.
2:12:23 Calls out some of the background, how we got here. It looks at the various objectives, lists them out correctly. The one attachment, repeated one from last year or so. But that was the very first one about the investment in community-focused projects. But that is correct in the written staff report. So high-level overview initially in looking at a short-term vision. And this gets built over time with the council in trying to pick out key themes that you all reference or speak to.
2:12:52 Some specific areas and some broader in their scope. But that key statement talks about investing in our community quality of life through economic, environmental and financial sustainability. That really has come out of that quality of life statement that has surrounded a lot of our work. It's often a very broad general statement and a lot of communities utilize it. We have the best quality of life ever. Describe that to most of the communities in the U.S. that do these types of.
2:13:22 But as we've done that, it's really been, I think, related to the types of investments that we have made, whether it's in our recreational side, whether more recently focused on housing, whether it's in improving infrastructure, whether it is some of the more aggressive things we've taken, look at child care, looking at arts and culture. There's a lot of elements that have come into play. But I think our community focused and also hopefully broad community, whether you're, I like to say, zero to 100.
2:13:51 You know, for activity, for recreational, for lifelong learning, those types of elements. And we say this actually get achieved then through economic environment and financial stability, sustainability. The economic side obviously is investments back in businesses. It's how we survive through a tourism visitor-based community. It's the elements that we look at, whether it's a supportive business or whether it's how we put projects.
2:14:20 In the ground around us, hopefully they're done sustainably, they're done with respect for the community and carrying their weight through town, whether this is a new small business opening, supporting via the chamber and other things, or whether it's a new hotel project. The environmental side, again, the broad statements, and you heard a lot of that in the MLT presentation earlier. How do we change and deal with issues of messaging? What happens when we see the shifts in this last winter and those types of things that happen?
2:14:50 The other side is the more nuanced environmental elements, be that the work we're doing right now on a plastic bottle ban or doing the work with our sustainability partners with Mammoth Disposal, with community gardens and different elements and looking at implementation of state law requirements on that side. So I think there's a number of other things as we look at the environmental piece we're doing with our mobility hubs. We're looking at the electrification of places. How do we support those types of initiatives that are...
2:15:19 Coming to us to the state and in our own development processes. And then the last statement, the financial sustainability, all this builds together. So without that financial capacity, we would not be doing the things we're doing. The council has been very clear in allowing how we work our budgets, how we build resources, how we allocate those out, how we become effective and efficient and how we operate our various services and programs.
2:15:46 And then looking at those strategic investments. Where do we put those dollars? And often trying to manage that growth in expenditures that doesn't result in just a growth in government, but actually an enhancement of services and programs back to the quality of life and it runs through those key areas there. And we believe we do that by investing in our community-focused projects. And I won't read each of the statements there. You can look at those. The key one on that probably is that number one about our
2:16:16 Housing Now Initiative. In the past, we've identified very specific projects. I think you're very familiar with the project work, and it's ongoing and moving through those various things, and hopefully we come up with some other additional creative ideas of how we continue to see housing move forward. We talk about enhanced sustainability and diversity of local businesses in the tourism economy. Looks like part of that is restated with the housing initiative. Sorry.
2:16:46 Facility here, really, how do we go into our, in fact, there's a double statement in there, but we start to look at work on our federal lands, how do we enhance our experiences the year-round, the visitation, the thing we just talked about, about fire resiliency, if we can't be successful in that area, we're really going to have challenges in how we handle our recreational economy here.
2:17:11 And then we look at just locally and then investing in our businesses. We talk about the beautification of Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. We talk about how we're investing in signage or snow management and other elements there to benefit our visitors and our local businesses. And that goes into culture and events and those types of things. Our environmental resiliency goes to these same areas and how we deal with.
2:17:36 The forest, how we deal with the number of different elements we're working on right now. I, again, won't read through each of the items. If you look at the staff report on pages 107 and 108, they're more clearly stated through that process. And then engaging with planning and the work that we're doing. You look at subpart C on the forest. You look at the other work we're doing. The coordination that we have in a number of those areas really set the tone for our future sustainability.
2:18:04 Our resiliency that we can move through in a community that way. And then we talk about implementation of just enhanced required municipal services. We have to keep the train running as the things required to do. We have a lot of state mandates. We have a lot of community expectations. We have a normal operational element of our budget to implement those services and programs. And a lot of things that are very straightforward, there's a list of them in the staff report, whether it's issuing permits, doing accounting.
2:18:33 You know, statutory requirements to do a lot of things. I think a couple areas there to touch on would be, again, hopefully the completion of the Civic Center vision with the new town offices being proposed. That has been on the books for numerous years. In terms of a kind of cornerstone of the community and having the courts and the county and the town and police and the hospital and those services grouped together there. And then we look at a lot of just the state mandates.
2:19:03 Touch on those as we go through things, whether it's in solid waste, recycling, those types of areas. Housing development, we have seen substantial legislative actions come forward, and likely this next season we'll see several more. Some of them get frustrating because they don't seem to worry about winter weather, as one example. It can be very frustrating, but how do we work through those things for implementation on things that are going to be mandated to do as core services in that?
2:19:32 I'll pause there. Really looking for comment and direction this evening. If we're hitting the mark, if we're touching on the things that you see as having priority for staff work to help us develop our own programming and some of the future budget allocations in particular areas. And if you kind of work off of the page 107-108 of your packet, probably the best in terms of the draft language there to see that proposal and those changes.
2:20:00 And again, a lot of this was designed to try to capture things that have been discussed over the last few months or several months, frankly, in different areas that we could look at. So if we're missing something, if you want some, you know, wordsmithing, or if you're sitting on this and you want to shoot a note to say, hey, this doesn't make sense, or that ideally here tonight was to have this discussion, bring this back at your next meeting to finalize the document to provide some direction looking into the next year. I'll pause there.
2:20:30 Thank you, Dan. Bringing it back to Council. Questions and or comments. Who would like to start? I have some ideas. Do you want to just dive into this? Yeah, let's just go. Okay. I don't have any issue with any of the individual components of this. I think that this is something that Council just started a while ago doing these priorities. I think it's benefited us a lot. I think it's a really important thing to do. However, first point is on the housing piece.
2:20:58 I think that, Andy, I've mentioned this before, I think we need to start talking seriously about council compensation. The housing crisis, it's affecting everybody. It's affecting our leadership. Someone like me of independent means, I can afford to do this. But I've heard your stories, the travails of people trying to work and live in this community. And I think we need to be intelligent about what it takes to serve in a leadership capacity in the council, even the planning commission.
2:21:27 Given what's happening with housing, given with everything else, we are providing leadership and direction to a staff that's incredibly competent and professional, is capable of doing amazing things, but if we don't have a leadership up here that can show up and provide the work, then I'd be interested in an analysis of what we can do about something like that. So for decades, the law in California has been that you can only increase council pay by 5% a year, and you can't make it.
2:21:54 I think the last increase was two years ago, so the council could at some point.
2:22:24 Adopt an ordinance to get your pay up, you know, two years worth, which would take effect when the new council is seated in late November or December of 2024. You can go to the voters and ask the voters to set it at whatever level you like. Okay, I mean, this is a question, and I don't, there's no answer here, but I think we need to start thinking about, I mean, if people are working two and three jobs or whatever, how can, you can work one job and you can be in an elected position, you can be in the planning commission and you can work.
2:22:54 But I don't know. But that's an observation. I think we need to think about that. The second thing is that climate change is not mentioned anywhere in here. And I appreciate that climate change is a global concern. But I think we need to start, we need to, you know, this is the hottest year ever recorded. This situation is not getting any better. And with our reliance on natural resources and all the rest of it, we need to figure out how to start integrating that into this.
2:23:20 I would point out also that the climate change policy in the state of California is very, it's almost the same as the national climate change policy coming out of Washington. They just published their fifth climate assessment. We're working on our fifth climate assessment. We have federal partners. I think that's something that we need to look at. If I may on that one, I have the wrong place there, but we put it kind of under the state mandates.
2:23:44 Which incorporated solid waste, electrification, housing development, and climate change. We're seeing elements come out from the state that are going to be imposed to relate back to that. It doesn't mean we can't do more than core mandates of the town and our core services need to start thinking through those elements. I understand. I understand. But I think we need to start thinking a much more
2:24:09 We have a different approach to all this, especially because we're a lot of people come to our community. They've never seen the things that, I mean, the amazing work that White Bark is doing, the interpretive opportunities for that. When you ask people, well, if you live in a city, well, I don't see climate change. I mean, hell, turn the air conditioning up a little bit. It's not a visceral thing. What's happening in the Arctic? What's happening around here? We are on the front lines. We are in a unique position to be interpreters of that stuff. So it's a global observation.
2:24:38 Final thing is, without causing staff's brains to blow up, we need to start looking at our general plan. And I appreciate that all the elements, we're current with all the various elements, but I was around in 2007, I participated in the process. The changes that we're seeing in this community, we're pushing it. We're getting to that point where we really need to start thinking about who we are, where we're going, what is this place going to look like? So those are just three kind of high-level observations.
2:25:07 I guess I just had a question of the completion of the Civic Center. We plan on doing that with grants. The Civic Center element, the completion of that Civic Center vision would be the construction of the town offices. We'd be funding the one grant we had out for that. We did not receive. We have another one in the works. We don't forget that or not.
2:25:36 This would be a town-funded town office project. Civic Center Vision Incorporated, we're the last group to the party, if you will. It had the courts that came in. We built the police station in that location. The county offices went into that location. The hospital was there and has done some increases and have future expansion plans. And then the town offices there. The idea was that becomes a civic center and the concept of that centralization of all.
2:26:07 Thank you. Thank you.
2:26:43 Over a decade ago. I don't have any other questions at this time. Just a heads up, the new document you gave us has the same. It still has a problem. Yeah. If you go to the written document, the written report, it has all the correct pieces under the correct heading. I just wanted to alert my colleague up here so we didn't. So I agree with what John said about climate. I think it needs to be.
2:27:23 I would like to...
2:27:45 Think about making sure we incorporate a solid goal for what we're doing with the next phase of the parcel, so housing. And then also, in the past, we were so focused on the parcel that we didn't focus as much on the folks who don't qualify for the parcel. And I want to make sure we're very clear that that is a serious priority for this town. Those are the things that I think are the highest priority at this point for me. Thank you.
2:28:16 Thank you. For me, this is sort of an interim thing. We started working on this kick by winter and a whole lot of other things, and we just kept kicking the ball down the road. So to me, this is a temporary thing. Keeping it sort of vague allows staff to bring us things that tie to this, which is really what this is for, for staff, for, you know, that 5 or 10 percent that we have left after the thing going forward. I'm very comfortable with how it's...
2:28:51 Written up in the document, not comfortable with that, calling out anything else at this point. This is going to be an incredibly busy year, regardless of what's set here, because of things we have to do. We're going to go through a town manager change. We're just bringing on a new police chief. We have to bring on a new PEDC. There are so many things. Our basket is already so full. Even if we set it as a priority here, I don't know that that's going to move.
2:29:24 I'm sure we can find the room for it in what you've written, which makes me comfortable with it.
2:29:59 Chris was saying, which I think in the, which goes back to the moratorium, which is currently in effect. We've got a committee working on this. There are going to be ideas and suggestions coming out of that that may inform the Housing Now program. That doesn't need necessarily be in this, but I hear what you're saying. The town owns, how many acres do we own over there, Dan? 25. 25. It's sold off, so 20 plus. But there's opportunities in there that may come out of the recommendations of the Advisory Council and Council.
2:30:31 The bridge program has been focused in that area. There's definitely
2:31:00 Those elements. And so what I didn't want to do is get it so pigeonholed. We come back and go, well, that's not what we said, which we usually don't run that foul that way either. But I hear that. And there will be some additional work that goes with this usually that talks about the types of programs that are being considered and worked on. But they're just, again, we can work smith this down and add a couple of things in there. The goal would be to keep it at one page. So we can.
2:31:29 Look at it and know what we're doing. But there's a couple of wordsmithing things we could do to add a couple of things if that's a consensus. For sure. I do want to get those couple of things in only because the public has been paying a lot more attention to what we do these days. And as a result, they might go to the website and look at it. And I know that when I think about what we should be doing as a town, I actually consult this document regularly just to keep.
2:31:59 Myself, honest. So I think, you know, those couple of tweaks would probably go a long way to communication because people have questions, they can actually just go look on the website. And so this will come back to us? Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Okay, because I need a laminated version to carry around with me. Well, I don't want to laminate it until we get it final. Okay. Yeah, on the 20th, we'll come back with it. I see a couple places we can add in some of that.
2:32:31 Element on a couple of specifics there. That's kind of consensus there. I'm looking for a head nod. Are we all good up here? Yes. Thank you all. Do we have any public comment on this? I'm automatic now, I guess, huh? Okay. Hi, Tom Hodges again, Vice President of Planning and Development at Mammoth Mountain. So, Bill, not to throw more stuff in the bucket, but I did want to suggest you might consider adding language in there, particularly with the mobility hubs.
2:33:06 Maybe just pointing out district parking or public parking, centralized public parking. I mean, it's an issue we've discussed in the past as a community. At one point, we even had a task group thrown together to kind of study where's the potential site for sort of aggregated public parking in our commercial corridor areas, downtown in particular. And we kind of lost momentum on that.
2:33:32 If you recall, that was really part and parcel to downtown revitalization. And I just really feel like as a community, we've lost momentum entirely on commercial revitalization of our commercial corridors. You know, we do Main Street beautification, old Mammoth Road beautification, do everything we can in the public right-of-way, but when there's dilapidated one-story old commercial buildings that are the core of our community, it still can look good to our outside visitors.
2:34:03 In comparison to our peer resorts. So there's a lot of work to do there. I know maybe we'll find new motivation, new momentum when Dan moves on and we have a new town manager and a new community development director. Maybe it's an opportunity to really kind of engage on that again. But I think it's worthwhile to at least maybe put that detail in here just because we did spend a lot of time on that in the past. And I worked on, in 2014, I worked on the committee that worked on the updates of the
2:34:33 Commercial Zoning Code Update. And there was a lot of good work done with that group and a lot of good information in the Commercial Zoning Code that we really have never taken advantage of. Nobody's taken advantage of. And, you know, it's one of the things that I always like to bring up is that, you know, it was a big move when that was done. And we went through a general plan amendment. We went through a CEQA document approval. And there was a lot of heavy lifting done then. And it's just all sat idle. And in particular,
2:35:01 Was the sort of change in the definition of density in our commercial corridor. We went from this real bizarre kind of unit thing that nobody could understand and make any sense of to a floor air ratio definition of density in commercial zones. So far floor air ratio. And we were pretty generous in what was assigned to those parcels and sort of increasing what's allowable. But what tanks the whole thing is the parking.
2:35:30 Right. There's no ability to provide the parking as defined by our parking code on those small commercial parcels that, you know, with underground parking and so forth. So none of that redevelopment is happening through the private, you know, end of the business, you know, private entities and owners of those parcels. And, you know, one way we can maybe incentivize that is to create sort of centralized district parking. And that might be a way we could say, hey.
2:35:59 If you do this redevelopment, you can offset so much your parking through the public parking locations and so forth to incentivize people to redevelop their properties, which also, by the way, is one of the few remaining areas where we have available density airspace, if you will, to provide locals housing. And, you know, that's, again, it's a pretty ambitious program, but I still think that there's a way that we could, through
2:36:29 You know, funding sources for housing set up potentially a program where, again, we could create incentives for people if they redevelop their commercial properties from a single story 0.25 FAR existing development into a 1.5 FAR that has, you know, a couple flats, two or three flats of locals housing above redeveloped commercial frontage. I mean, what a win that could be. I mean, there's a lot of, you know, we say, how are we going to solve this problem? We got to look at...
2:36:58 What we have available as assets in our community, there's a lot of unused, untapped density there, which makes everything else work. If you, you know, you do increase density in our commercial zones, it'll make transit work better, it'll make feet first work better, all these things will work better. So I just wanted to bring that back to your guys' attention because it is stuff we've worked on in the past and I would like to see, you know, maybe, I know there's a lot on the plate there, but it's one of those things, you know, we just don't want to miss the opportunities.
2:37:26 And also to, you know, the EIFD discussions. That was like originally the EIFD discussion was all about how we could fund for public parking. That was what started the whole discussion back in, I can't remember how long ago that was, 2012 or 14 or whatever those days were. So again, as we talk about EIFDs in this document, you know, you have to be very specific about where you would use those funds. And I think that's certainly one of those areas where it would be worthwhile.
2:37:53 To that end, we need to have a definitive plan of what that is and what the costs are, right? And, you know, there's been work done in the past and we made some progress, but we kind of ran out of steam. So just wanted to bring that back up. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Mr. Mayor, if I could. Dan, I would like to see included in here references to walk, bike, ride and the downtown revitalization plan just in a such-as context. I think, Tom, that...
2:38:21 Those things are covered in those plans. I think it's for the new town to make sure it's referenced in there. The second thing is I think that this goes back to what we're doing with the moratorium, not prejudging what's going to come out of that, but I think that there's going to be some potentially some very interesting ideas that can help inform downtown revitalization. So I would encourage us all to stay tuned and see what comes out of those recommendations with Council Axon because that may really reinform a lot what may happen with all that. So thank you for bringing those things up.
2:38:51 So I'd like to thank you, Tom. I was really hammering on Main Street beautification for a long time and I pretty much have just given up. So I appreciate you mentioning that because it was a passion project of mine for a while until it withered and died. Just in our defense, COVID, winter of 2023, thank you. So what I would ask everyone to do here then, this is going to be coming back. Dan has a lot of information.
2:39:22 But this has worked best, and we started this process a long time ago. This has worked best as a one-page sheet with four bullets under four main topics. So for all the things we want to add, I would love to see recommendations come back into how we alter this or eliminate some of this to bring in, because this is basically a one-year sort of wish list, to bring some of those things forward, because I'm not seeing it.
2:39:52 I don't think parking comes up to the level of being a priority because we have so many other things that we have, not that we don't need to deal with it. Well, I think what I'm recommending is those ideas are covered in those two plans. So if Dan can find a way to put those things in there as referenced in the downtown revitalization plan or as talked about in the walk, bike, ride plan, all those mobility, that's all in those things. So at least it covers it without getting to.
2:40:23 Anything else from the audience? Anything online? Anything from the dais? Then we will move on to item, yeah, you have what you need, Dan, right? Yes, thank you. Move on to item 10.6, presentation of pre-audit financials results by fiscal year 22-23, fund balance projects and continuing commitments. Rob. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. Let me pull up.
2:40:59 Presentation here real quick and I will make it quick for you, Chris. Okay. So we prepare this fund balance review. This is actually a review of how we've finalized fiscal year 22-23. So we'll be closed in June 30th. And this is called pre-audit because these numbers are basically put together for the numbers we present to our auditors. There are...
2:41:47 And I'll start with the first here.
2:42:15 Highly recommend for folks that really want to follow along in detail that they review the staff report that was written for this. In this particular case, I've significantly pared down the presentation to just talk about recommendations that we're making and not necessarily go through every single fund that's presented in the staff report. But there's a great amount of detail in those reports, and it definitely will keep you informed as far as the purpose and need for each of those funds, what they represent, and how they're funded.
2:42:44 As well as some reconciliations of some of our Measure A allocation reserves as well. So starting off with our financial record, when you talk about the general fund, fund balance, there are a number of components that live within that fund balance. Our projected fund balance at the close of 630 is about $14.9 million, and that is comprised of several components. We have in there our...
2:43:12 Vehicle Loan, that $851,207, that started, I think, back in 2013-14 timeframe, 12 perhaps, with a loan from our Vehicle Replacement Fund, and we've been steadily repaying that debt, accelerating that actually in the last couple of years, and now we have a total balance due of $851,000.
2:43:36 Majority of that's covered in 23-24's general budget allocations, and you'll see a request in my presentation later on to fully pay off that debt with tonight's funding. We have our reserves, which is the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, the Operating Reserve, and the Debt Reserve. Those all reside in this general fund balance. And those, as we talk about during our budgetary process,
2:44:02 The Reserve for Economic, each one of them are tied to a specific funding mechanism. The Reserve for Economic Uncertainty is a percentage of 20% of our budgeted general fund revenue for the year. The operating reserve is 5%. And then the debt reserve represents 50% of what debt is serviced by the general fund on an annual basis. So if we do have a change in debt service that's funded by the general fund.
2:44:30 That number would have to be adjusted as well. So as part of my budgeting annually, we make those edits and adjustments, but they're represented in these balances. And then finally, we have the housing, transit, and tourism reserve balances. In the staff report, there was sort of a reconciliation of showing how those revenues are generated, where they come from, what expenditures were recorded, and then what anticipated carryovers are present.
2:45:00 For the year, so there's pretty good information in there, but this represents the balance of each of those funds. When you pair all that down, you end up with an unrestricted fund balance of about $3.8 million, slightly above that. Any questions on that? The next component we do is we really look at carryover. So carryover represents projects or other allocations of funds that were done in this year or previous years.
2:45:31 When the funds were not expended. So they were earmarked for some particular item. For whatever reason, all the invoices didn't show up or it was a project that rolled across multiple years, but they were sitting in the general fund. That's where we need to carry them over. So what I mean carry them over is we will not only reserve these revenues for the year. That's what fund balance is, revenues over expenditures.
2:45:58 But we will carry them forward and carry forward a budget into the subsequent fiscal year. So 23-24 will now increment the budget by the amounts that we need to carry over so that those monies are available when either the invoice comes in or the project gets completed. And again, a little bit of a detail is provided in the staff report for those amounts. I list them here to show you they deduct from the available fund balance because they're going to be reserved for those fundings.
2:46:26 And that brings our available fund balance down to $3.6 million. Then we go into staff recommendations. Again, there's a lot of detail between those two in the staff report, but staff recommendations is where we utilize the strategic priorities, as we just talked about, come up with some suggestions on where to allocate those funds that support those processes and things that may be in-flight, things that we are working on as staff with regard to either
2:46:58 General work programs or, you know, funding programs for our Housing Now programs and so forth. I've got these sort of ranked in dollar value, if you will. And first one be future capital, a million dollars set aside for bond reserve. And this, you know, we anticipate for the Civic Center, an estimated bond need of about a reserve of about 1.8 to 2 million. So we need to take over time, we need to build up.
2:47:27 That amount, when you talk about a bond reserve, it actually is not funds that we hold on to. We actually pay them to a company that holds them in reserve for our debt payments. And again, that only comes into fruition if we do incur debt on this, as we will likely have to. So we need a bond reserve amount done in place by mid-calendar 2024.
2:47:52 So we're starting that process tonight by recommending an allocation of a million. The second one is Housing Now programs and more specifically the bridge program within the Housing Now programs, setting aside $950,000 for that. The town is currently in negotiations to obtain some additional units for this program. And while we do have some fund balance associated with that particular program,
2:48:22 We wanted to augment that to support those planned purchases. So that's the $950,000 is. Earlier this evening, you approved the allocation of the $700,000 for access apartments for Eastern Sierra Community Housing. And this is essentially the contingency in developer fees as noted. And we won't talk any further about that, but $700,000 was anticipated and baked into this presentation.
2:48:51 Back to Housing Now programs, $350,000 for small site development. So we have a small program in place. And this is similar to the work done on 60 Joaquin, where we are purchasing land, acquiring land, and then building on that. So this would be sort of the start of that process for the acquisition, I believe. On that, any questions on those recommendations?
2:49:21 I'll bring them back in a final chart if there's general discussions at that point. Note Chris's comment earlier. Both of these programs, when we look at that small site development, that bridge program, those are targeted at that missing middle group. Those are definitely part of that mix that really heightens that particular. Continuing on with staff recommendations, we have a couple of pages of these. Vehicle replacement loan, as I stated earlier, we have that total balance of $851,000.
2:49:52 Money is designated for that in 23-24 budget as it is, but the remaining unpaid balance is $161,000, so recommending that we pay that off. That will fully fund our vehicle replacement program as it's designed, and we go through that in great detail during the final budget presentation for the fiscal year. The ESCCRP Mono County Fuels Reduction Project, town staff is recommending a commitment of $150,000.
2:50:22 Airport equipment. We have a need for some particular mowing equipment.
2:50:52 That we do not have in our possession. We don't have in our vehicle replacement funding. So these are additions to the fleet. And staff is recommending we sort of commingle these funds with some additional to actually obtain that piece of equipment. It's a tractor and a 15-foot mowing deck that will be needed to really clear the runway areas and taxiway areas and those surroundings as we have. This is right now about a six-week project.
2:51:20 For us to get this accomplished with our six-foot-wide push-along mower, not a push mower, but in front of a tool cat. So this is a significant reduction in time and efficiency, and this is a 20-year lifespan piece of equipment. So good investment. Rob, I have a question for you real quick. Yep. When we do that, so that will be added equipment, not replaced equipment. So then an amount every year goes into the vehicle replacement fund to replace this when it's done.
2:51:49 For every $100,000 we spend, do you have any approximation of how much that adds to the amount we need to put into the vehicle replacement fund? It really depends upon the life cycle of the vehicle. You know, we have police cars that have a five-year lifespan, so we look at the original purchase cost, we increment that cost annually by 3% to say that this value of the increased cost of the asset, and then we divide that by the number of years of life expected.
2:52:18 This particular one, you know, this $140,000, we're going to divide that over 20 years. So it's, you know, pretty significantly reduces the cost impact. Our snowblowers and loaders are all 20-year pieces of equipment. Most of our other vehicles are 10 years. But it varies, Bill, depending upon the size, cost of the item, and the lifespan. Sorry, I didn't mean to take you off task. You're good. No, no, all good. Parks equipment, I have $80,000.
2:52:54 Listed in there, we had, you know, several items that, I'll say, several pieces of equipment, and I listed them all in the staff report, that were recommended for replacement. They were beyond their life cycle in the 20-plus year range. Many of them, they're off-highway vehicle pieces of equipment, so sort of not quite on the radar as much as some of the overrode items.
2:53:21 That we're utilizing. So we let those go a little bit further beyond. But the $80,000, not only services maybe a small gap in our vehicle replacement funding, but also there's a couple of additions to the fleet that we had recommended in there. I believe a trailer and a blower head for one of our tracklaces. That's more appropriate for our sidewalks. We acquired a used trackless a few years ago with a much larger head that we were using in specific areas.
2:53:48 And so this would narrow that down and utilize that in our general rotation, I believe, of snow removal on sidewalks. But that $80,000, it covers, you know, the cost of the replacement as well as tax and everything else associated with that. But recommended for that. Airport operations, you know, we look at the revenue versus the operational expense. And this last couple of years we have – oh, I'm sorry. Thank you.
2:54:18 Last couple of years, we've been utilizing some of the funding that has been provided by the FAA for general operations that was obtained during COVID response. We've sort of metered that out across the years, but we do have a fairly significant amount of support. Both the general fund and in the cases of these grant funds support the operations of the airport. And so we have at the end of the year, we had a little bit of a shortfall and wanted to.
2:54:46 To tidy that up, if we have any shortfalls in there, it can reduce the amount of fund balance that we carry in the airport, and all that fund balance is reserved for capital projects, and so just didn't want to have an impact on that, so small reduction. The town recruitment, we've had a number of recruitment opportunities this year, and they're still ongoing. I list them out here, manager, police chief, CED director, and some police sergeants, so more than anticipated, not
2:55:13 More than anticipated. Actually, we had some that we're not aware of when we began our budgeting process or finished our budgeting process for the year. So a little bit of a shortfall in that area. We wanted to add $30,000 for that. Finally, there's a green business program funds. We're recommending about $15,000. And this is to support High Sierra Energy Foundation on their green businesses. And it's based on some defined metrics. But I believe they had some funding.
2:55:42 And we're looking to lean in and support with that. All told, these recommendations are slightly more than we had available. But again, with the conservative nature of how we go through this process, I'm not concerned about that deficit of just about $15,000. So we're recommending the allocation of all of the available funds that we've identified for during this review. Are there any questions? Rob?
2:56:15 FEMA reimbursement, any update on that and how we're doing with that or Dan's kind of shaking his, okay. Sorry I brought that up. We'll hear about that later. Okay. No, it's fine. We're going through the process. I think we're on our sixth or seventh FEMA representative that's working with us on our submissions. We have met all the deadlines for that. We definitely set aside funding to support.
2:56:42 What we need to accomplish that's been identified. We've funded the projects that we need to do for an emergency process. We funded the activities for the winter. So from a funding standpoint, we're in good shape. We will do everything we can to get that reimbursement. Recently did receive notification that FEMA is going to recognize these snow-related expenses. For folks that may have not heard this before, snow is not generally something FEMA reimburses for.
2:57:10 It usually has to be a very narrowly defined impact due to how significant snow impacts the nation on an annual basis. It would bankrupt FEMA to address those. But in this particular case, they have allowed for snow expenses, which will help us not only in the removal aspect, but certainly some of the damages that will occur. Okay, and the report that we're investing in, when is that going to be finished? Oh, the after-action review?
2:57:37 Yeah, we just began that process. I would not anticipate that until, what did you think, Dan? I thought mid-spring. Yeah, it'll be out until June, July probably. By the time they get everything pulled together and the level of detail and review they're doing, it's quite comprehensive and will take time. Okay, I just think there's a federal election coming up, and I think that could be a very important advocacy tool for us, depending on who's running. And I think if all of us are getting a little...
2:58:06 Request to participate in committees and things like that. I encourage us all to follow up. I think that's because FEMA is a federal thing, and I think climate change and all the rest of it, that's something to be advocating for. Okay, the weather and the budget, and I think, Pat, in the MLT budget, Rob, we talked about this before, and I think MLT is very astute to be saying, the way I answered the question, what the numbers were, who answered that question? You asked that question.
2:58:35 What are those little numbers up there at the top? Inches of snow. And I think that to coordinate with MLT, if you could put, if you continue to put those snow inches up there, but also maybe an asterisk, days of fire, you know, smoke closures, those kinds of impacts to be coordinating. So council is saying, okay, we're seeing that from the TOT side and we're seeing this from the budget side. I think that's an important partnership opportunity to be looking at as we go forward. So just wanted to bring that up.
2:59:05 How are we doing, well, the inflection point, Rob, that you've talked about before, that's five or seven years out, I think we need to start bringing that into our budgeting process. The town, since the, wherever we went, whatever you want to call that thing a couple years ago, great budgeting process, great work from staff, keeping us on track with this, we have something looming out there, and we need to start, you know, identifying when that might happen, so that when we talk to the public and the constituents,
2:59:32 We're going to hit a point here, four, three, four, five, seven, whatever those years out, it's going to happen. We need, we're a tourism-based recreation economy. We need to be all in on what's happening because we're going to face some real challenges when we get to that. So I would encourage us as our budget process going forward, let's, you know, it's here. We think it may be here. Finally, how are we doing at that new CRC thing, how the bookings over there?
2:59:58 Looks great to me. Okay, I'm hearing that it's doing pretty well. We're still working through all the things with the contractor. Andy can speak to some of the battles there, but we won't have a final reconciliation on that for a while yet. I'm just talking on the attendance number. I'm assuming people. Great. I mean, we've hit, like, I think the second weekend we were open, the first weekend, and we had a, it was a $5,000 a day Saturday. That's a, and that would have been, like, one of our highest, like, record Saturdays at the outdoor rink.
3:00:27 Okay. This was kind of a normal day. Just bringing it something to... It's actually doing very well from a usage standpoint. Those receipts, if we are over budget, over projection, where does that go? If the receipts to the building and that is general fund dollars, it stays there in the general fund, but it is offsetting the cost of that facility. At some point, interesting to understand, if we're doing well over there, what are we putting that back into? It rolls back in.
3:00:54 General funding. It goes back in ultimately that park side and stuff of that nature, but it would be no different than if our property tax goes up or TOT goes up. Yeah, okay. End up in the general fund side. Okay, thank you for that. I'm okay with the recommendations as presented. Ladies? You're okay? Amanda? Yeah, I'm okay about it. I guess I just, for the Civic Center, I just am hoping that we get a grant for that or you don't have to pay for all of that. So.
3:01:30 You know, saving a million dollars for that right now seems like a lot, and hopefully we can get a grant. Chris? I am fine with the recommendations. I think I'll leave it there. I'm fine with the recommendations. I am as well. I am fine moving this forward. And that million dollars actually isn't for the cost of building. That is just so that if we go out and bond to build it.
3:02:06 It covers half of what one year's payment would be? Yeah, if I may on that, depending on how you finance the debt, there's one element of that. If you do it, it requires a bond reserve. So you have to set aside the equivalent of a full payment with the trustee who's paying the bonds. If you don't have it in cash, it actually gets built into your borrowing. So if we put cash over there and it does earn interest, it goes back into that as well.
3:02:33 If you don't, then you have to borrow an extra million or $2 million that goes in and funds that reserve. So by putting money up front on it, it reduces our bond costs, both from an issuance standpoint as well as carrying interest on that debt over time versus having cash and making some interest, there's a little gap between those two usually. So that's what that's for. It actually reduces the amount of money you have to borrow.
3:03:03 That is not, ultimately, it can both be committed to the very last payment. So that's 20, 25, 30 years out, but it can be used for your last final payment. Anything else from here? Any public comment on this item? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. We need a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that the council approve the recommendations from staff on the pre-audit actual financial presentation.
3:03:41 And adopt a resolution amending the fiscal year 23-24 budget as recommended on attachment A. One minor caveat is the money that's going to ES, to Whitebark, ESS to reach that effort. Representations were made by Mono County, that there would be a matching component to that, and I would encourage all of us to follow up on that. The council is allocating those dollars with an expectation that we will have a fruitful conversation with our friends at Mono County to further invest in this project. So that would be my...
3:04:10 Motion and caveat. Thank you. Can I get a second? I'll second. Thank you. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes. Okay, moving on. We are now going to go, oh no, we're not done yet. We still have councilmember reports. Councilmember reports. Amanda?
3:04:43 Sorry, trying to think about what I've been doing since I've seen you. It seemed like, was it just last week? I am meeting on a subcommittee for the STR Advisory Committee, and we've had two meetings about zoning, so nothing really to report out of that yet, but that's what I've been up to. I attended the more term advisory council meeting on the 30th. I'm going to go to every single one of those meetings. I'm really anxious to hear what's going on in those little working groups.
3:05:15 I anticipate some good things coming out of that. A number of items I shared with the ESSRP having to do with regional recreation things, the Visit California effort that John Urdi mentioned, which is really important. It's not just tourism, it's housing, it's everything's in there. And I'll save it because I want to say goodnight to my friends before we have to go. So I'll save the rest of it. Okay. I am hanging out a lot with Amanda on our subcommittee.
3:05:46 And really grateful that it does seem like we have a good work plan. We have three subcommittees addressing three different issues, which I think will allow us to expedite the process, which we're all very committed to. So this is my plea to members of the public that we meet again next Tuesday the 12th. And if you want to see how the progress is going, you should really watch.
3:06:16 On your favorite Zoom or other streaming platform. But, you know, this is a really important process and we'd love to hear. We'd love to have people participating. Thank you. On Monday with John and Lawson, I attended online the JLL Sierra Nevada region. Very interesting, but that was my month. Attended MLT.
3:06:52 This afternoon, you guys saw their presentation, so I don't need to cover all of that. One of the things that was announced there was that this weekend, Chairs 10 and 4 would be open. They are busy making snow, we're going on with that, and that's about all I have. That being said, we will now adjourn into closed session. Yeah, it'll be quick, yeah. Two items, 12.1, Conference with Legal Counsel, Existing Litigation.
3:07:28 Main Street Taxpayers Association v. Town of Mammoth Lakes. Item 12.2, Conference Legal Counsel Existing Litigation. Again, name of case, Main Street Taxpayers Association v. Town of Mammoth Lakes. We will now adjourn into the closed session.