Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2024
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
212 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:36 Good morning, everyone. It is 9 a.m. and I would like to start today's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Today is Wednesday, December 11th and it is 9 a.m. This is our normal start time. So with that, I will have us all stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. May I do the roll call first? Sure. Roll call, please. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Fleming and Commissioner Grand are absent. Vice Chair Verruck? Here. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you, Jamie.
3:06 We'd like everyone to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. And Kim, would you mind leading us, please, today? Sure. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Always forget that part, Jamie.
3:31 And with that, I'd like to open up public comment. I will ask if anybody has public comment they'd like to submit to this commission in regards to a matter on today's agenda that you wait until that agenda item has been opened for discussion. So with that, do we have any other public comment that would like to be submitted today? I do have an update from Stu Brown, the Parks and Recreation Director. He had another meeting.
3:57 He couldn't be here, but he wanted me to give an update on the town's tree lighting celebration that happened this past Friday. So that event was held at the Community Recreation Center or the LA Kings at Mammoth Ice Rink. The town began planning for this event to have it at that venue in 2018 when the playground was completed. I remember waiting until the CRC was completed as well to move it over there.
4:27 So they lit up the 50-foot Jeffrey Pine that's in the center of the playground with over 4,500 LED lights. Approximately 300 people attended the event, with 230 of those enjoying the complimentary skating at the rink. In addition to the ice rink, there were eight local vendors in the first-ever holiday market in the south lobby selling their holiday goods.
4:52 The fire pit and complimentary s'mores were a huge hit, along with the hot chocolate donated by Mammoth Lakes Tourism and distributed by the Mammoth Lakes Cheerleaders. And then lastly, Santa stopped by with Woolly and had a great photo booth for all the kids. My daughter definitely enjoyed the photo having Santa and Woolly there. So it was a really well-attended event.
5:17 Huge portion of the community was out in attendance, kind of saw everyone out there. And then the next event is Skate with Santa on Thursday, December 19th from 5 to 7 p.m. And is that complimentary Skate with Santa? I will get back to you on that. No worries. Thank you. I don't think Stu could have said it better himself, Nolan. Maybe a little longer. Any other public comment that would like to be submitted before this commission this morning?
5:48 Do we have anybody on Zoom, Jamie? Okay. Then I will close the public comment and we will go to our public hearing item. The first item is 4.1, which is the consideration of District Zoning Amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004, and tentative tract map 24-003.
6:14 for a subsequent amendment to the amended Phase 1 Clearwater Specific Plan located at 164 Old Mammoth Road to modify the permitted uses for. And then I won't read the rest. And I believe this morning our staff contact or our staff person is Kim. Thank you. Sorry, Kim. So just for the two gentlemen in the audience, kind of the way we'll proceed with this matter is Kim will give us our staff report.
6:48 And then the Commission will have the opportunity to ask staff for questions. We would also love to have any sort of a presentation or statement by the applicant, which I'm assuming you guys are representing or maybe somebody on Zoom. And then we will reopen it up for questions. And then we'll bring it up to Commission for conversation, thoughts, opinions, and then we'll make a decision. Thank you. Sorry, Kim, didn't mean to interrupt you. No worries at all.
7:27 And there will be public comment in there, too. Sorry, guys. Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. The application before you today is for the outbound Hotel Villas Project. This entitlement application includes three different application types, district zoning amendment, a use permit, and a tentative tract map. The project site encompasses approximately six acres and is located in the Clearwater-specific plan zoning district.
8:04 The Clearwater Specific Plan establishes land use guidelines and development standards for the area covered by the CSP. The CSP document in its vision and goals section 1.1 includes a statement that the Clearwater Specific Plan envisions a pedestrian-oriented mixed-use corridor along Old Mammoth Road.
8:25 The plan provides for a blend of retail, condominium hotel, and conference uses in addition to plaza areas that provide a venue for a variety of community activities and events. The current project application is subject to the amended phase one CSP standards, which is the subject of this application.
8:49 For a bit of the background for the site, the Clearwater Specific Plan was originally adopted by Town Council in January of 2009. This was for the development of a pedestrian-oriented mixed-use resort destination located in the North Old Mammoth Road District of the town. Adoption of the CSP included approval of the final Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report.
9:20 Then in March of 2010, the PEDC approved a vesting tentative tract map, a use permit, and a design review for a mixed-use project called the Old Mammoth Place. The Old Mammoth Place entitlements approved a large-scale redevelopment project which included up to 340 residential units with up to 488 lodging rooms, eight on-site workforce housing units,
9:47 Multiple outdoor public events plazas, as well as approximately 20,000 square feet of commercial retail space, approximately 17,000 square feet of restaurant space, 9,500 square feet of conference space, and a 4,500 square foot spa and wellness center, as well as an ice rink pool and an underground parking garage covering the entire site.
10:16 As part of the Old Mammoth Place project, the town approved two district zoning amendments. Those included clarification of how building height was to be measured when the building sits on top of a parking garage and clarification on how fees would be charged for the entitled project. And then over a period of approximately six years following the Old Mammoth Place project approval,
10:44 The property owner was unable to obtain financing to construct the project. So in August 2016, as an effort to improve the viability and marketability of the project, the owner obtained approval for amendments to the specific plan and the old Mammoth Place entitlements, which included a 10-foot increase in the building height, an increase in net residential square footage.
11:11 and elimination of an on-site workforce housing requirement. At that time, a CEQA addendum to the CSP EIR was prepared and concluded that the proposed modifications were consistent with what was analyzed as part of the CSP final EIR. The images included here at the top right, that was the original Old Mammoth Place project elevation approved. And then the bottom image is
11:40 the slightly larger scale approved project in 2016. So approximately five years later in 2021 after the project changed ownership a district zoning amendment application DZA 21-001 was approved to amend the CSP to establish interim development standards for phase one of the CSP development.
12:09 The interim development standards accommodated a less intensive expansion and upgrade of the existing hotel, as well as the restaurant and public spaces. This was a reduced scale and not as intense as was originally envisioned by the CSP and the Old Mammoth Place entitlements. The Planning and Economic Development Commission later approved a major design review application.
12:39 in February 2022 for a project consisting of interior and exterior improvements to the existing 149-unit hotel and Raptors restaurant, as well as the construction of 30 new resort cabins, which include including five four-plex villa structures and an expanded event space and added pedestrian-oriented amenities.
13:08 The project also included seven on-site affordable housing units located within an existing spa building. And construction of the approved project began in April of 2022. It's currently nearing completion. So between 2023 and 2024, a temporary certificate of occupancy was issued for the project. And this was subject to a compliance agreement with the building division.
13:39 Construction of the phase one project is almost complete. However, there are several final site improvements and conditions of approval that must be completed or satisfied before a final certificate of occupancy can be issued. So on to the current proposal. The project proposes to convert 20 existing hotel accommodation units that are located within the five fourplex structures referred to as villas.
14:13 into condominium hotel units that may be sold individually. The required applications to accomplish the proposed project include a district zoning amendment to amend the amended phase one clear water specific plan to modify the permitted uses by adding condominium hotel uses subject to a use permit and subdivision map approval.
14:38 The proposed DZA language includes a definition for condominium hotel uses, adds development and operating standards applicable to condominium hotel units uses, and removes language that previously excluded condominium hotel uses from the amended phase one CSP. Additional minor text revisions are included to provide greater clarity to the reader.
15:04 A use permit is also included to establish the proposed condominium hotel use, which aligns with the original CSP land use permitting requirements, and this allows the town to require conditions of approval for the use, such as minimum operating standards. A tentative tract map is included to subdivide the 20 units for condominium hotel purposes. The proposed lot configuration would create a separate condominium owner's association lot.
15:34 This is shown as lot one on your right. I tried to highlight it because it's a little small. And for the remainder is the resort owner lot. And there would be required easements which are noted on this tentative map. These easements would be for shared access, parking, snow storage, trash enclosure facilities.
16:03 As well as utilities and other shared facilities. Any final, the final easement language and configuration would need to be completed through a reciprocal easement agreement. A draft has been submitted to the town and is under review but would be finalized and would require town staff approval prior to final map approval. So since this project involves a new use,
16:37 A new use rather than a proposed new development. The analysis of the project is really focused around the project's consistency with the Clearwater specific plan as well as the general plan land use designation. On your right you see a diagram of the Clearwater specific plan land use designations. There are three land use designations identified within the CSP.
17:05 And the proposed project is located within Land Use Area 2, which is shown in light pink. And this area is designated for a condominium hotel and is described within the CSP as an area for a building or a combination of buildings that function as a hotel with privately held condominium hotel units or traditional hotel units.
17:37 The proposed subsequent amendment to the amended Phase I Clearwater Specific Plan does uphold the overall intent and goals of the original CSP and the amended Phase I CSP in that condominium hotel uses are permitted within the CSP and therefore the conversion of the villas to condominium hotel units
18:00 does comply with the original intent of allowed uses in the CSP as well as the arrangement of land uses on the site. For consistency with the general plan land use designation, the site is located within the Clearwater specific plan. The intent of the CSP as described within the general plan.
18:29 is to provide for a pedestrian-oriented, mixed-use district for residents and visitors within the North Old Mammoth Road area. Permitted uses include hotel, condominium hotel, workforce housing, street front retail along Old Mammoth Road, and a large public plaza intended for use as an event venue. On a couple of the upper bullet points, I did just include a little bit of background.
19:04 That the current amended Phase 1 CSP specifically excludes condominium hotel uses from the Phase 1 project. From what I have pieced together from the application for the 2021 DZA, that application included a concept for the hotel expansion that would be a tiny home design.
19:31 which are really more of a temporary type of structure that could potentially be moved. And so it does appear that the original language that was included in the amended Phase 1 CSP was voluntary by the applicant and reflected the tiny home concept.
19:55 So it does not appear that staff required that condominium hotel uses be excluded from the amended phase one CSP project. So now with the constructed project, the five fourplex villa structures were actually stick built. They are more permanent in nature.
20:25 And we believe that that is why the applicant is coming forward with this proposal that isn't reflective of the original concept for the project. So the required findings for approval of this project, we have four primary areas that require findings for approval. The first is the findings for the district zoning amendment.
20:59 We have separate findings for the use permit application and the tentative tract map and we are also required to make findings that the project is consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act. In your resolution, staff was able to make affirmative findings for all of these required areas and to go over the agency and public comments,
21:36 The application was routed to the Mammoth Community Water District, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and internal town departments for review. Conditions of approval that have been included in the PEDC resolution require compliance with all of the applicable local agency requirements. As an example, staff received one condition from the
22:06 Mammoth Community Water District, and this is included as condition of approval number 43 in the resolution, and that will require that each of the units be privately sub-metered, and that would be consistent with the state Senate Bill 7. Staff did receive one email indicating that a public comment would be sent directly to the PEDC members.
22:35 I had not received that public comment until it was forwarded to me this morning, so I apologize, I have not had a chance to review it thoroughly, but that can be made part of the record, and has the commission received that email? I believe all three of us, and I imagine the two who are not here have as well. Okay, great.
23:01 So with that, that concludes my presentation. Staff does find that the proposed outbound villas project meets the applicable requirements and recommends the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and recommending to town council approval of district zoning amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004.
23:29 and tentative tract map 24-003 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Thank you, Kim. With that, I'll throw it back on the commission if anybody has any questions for staff at this time or if you'd like to hold your questions or thoughts until we have the whole presentation. Great. Okay. Then I'd like to invite the applicant to make a statement or a presentation. Maybe just let us know
24:00 Who you are and who you're representing, please. Certainly. First of all, good morning, everybody. Appreciate you guys having us here this morning. It's looking forward to discussion later today. By introduction, my name is Daniel O'Berry. I oversee hospitality asset management for Warton, who is the lead partner behind the ownership of what is now outbound Mammoth. Additionally, I have a few of my colleagues who are joining us here virtually, first of which is Matt Maring, and he'll be kind of giving a little
24:25 context and some color as far as the project and the events that have transpired to date and ultimately lead us to why we're speaking with you all this morning. Additionally, we have Mark Carney, who's our land use council, who some of you may know or have worked with in the past, who will kind of give a additional expound upon some of the history that came out, went over in their initial remarks here. And then finally, we have Christopher Payne, who is our condo and residential council on the project. So with that, I will flip it over to Mark to get things started.
24:58 Good morning, Chair Ganderhurst and Commissioner. Commissioners, my name is Mark Carney. I'm the applicant's land use attorney, as Daniel said. I've been practicing land use law in Mammoth since 1988. I actually represented the prior owner of the site in connection with the town's adoption of the Clearwater Specific Plan and the Old Mammoth Place project that Kim described. And so my clients asked me to provide some additional background information.
25:29 to give some context to today's application. But before I do, I want to thank the town staff, in particular, Kim Cook and Amy Callanan for the really good work that they've provided us, the really good service they've provided us from the start. You'll learn that this was originally conceived of in 2020, and
25:58 Kim and Amy and the rest of the staff have been working hand-in-hand with us for these four years to get to the point where we are today. I also want to compliment them on the quality of their work product. The staff report that we received on this matter is extremely clear and thorough and we appreciate that as well as the thorough and clear presentation that Kim made.
26:27 By way of background, as many of you may know, the Sierra Nevada Lodge opened the old Mammoth Road in 1967, and it operated largely unchanged for more than 40 years. In 2008, a new owner by the name of Jim Demetriotis set out to develop a mixed-use resort on the site consistent with the vision and goals of the general plan. And it's an important site, as you know, because on the south is a townhome project.
26:56 On the east is a town home project, so there's a lot of expectations in terms of this project helping to create vitality in the old Mammoth Road corridor. And so the original specific plan that I helped get approved back in 2009 was really a very ambitious project. It was basically the six acres is the size of the West Village and there was a hope.
27:26 that we could get that same level of animation and lodging, which was envisioned in the General Plan and the Old Mammoth Road District Plan on this site. And so Mr. Demetriatus and his team set forth to get the Clearwater Specific Plan approved and then ultimately, as Kim mentioned, the Old Mammoth Place project. That project included 340
27:56 Tonda Hotel units, which included 488 lodging rooms, eight on-site workforce housing units, three outdoor public events venues, 20,000 square feet of retail space, 17,000 square feet of restaurant space, 9,500 square feet of conference space, a 4,500 square foot spa and wellness center, an ice rink, pools and hot tubs.
28:26 So obviously an ambitious effort to try to, in one fell swoop, address all of the needs that the town's guiding documents described. And so the town approved the project. It was consistent with the general plan and consistent with the old Mammoth District study. Unfortunately,
28:56 That was 2009, was about a year into the Great Recession. And as a consequence, during the following seven-year period, there was no financing available for the site. It was actually too ambitious of an idea for that time period. And it wasn't able to be financed. And I know that the prior owner tried hard, every which way, to get the financing for the project.
29:23 But it didn't happen in the first seven years. So what happened in 2016 is he went back to the town to try to make it more economically viable and sought some amendments to the specific plan in Old Mammoth Place to increase the building height, to expand the residential square footage, and increase the underground parking capacity to 610 spaces.
29:52 But despite those efforts, financing remained unattainable throughout the next five years. Therefore, the owner's only choice at that time was to pivot his focus to refreshing the existing hotel rooms and to renovating the existing residences and public spaces at the lodge. As a consequence, the vision and goals for this site, as we're outlining the general plan of the Old Mammoth's
30:20 District study remained unfulfilled and Old Mammoth Road continued to struggle to meet the needs and expectations of locals and visitors alike. Enter Waterton in 2021. They purchased this site and set out to expand and renovate and rebrand the Seattle Lodge in a manner that could be financed. It essentially realized that
30:50 We could wait another 15 years and Old Mammoth Place could still be unfinanceable. And so instead Waterton applied for a less dense and lower scale expansion and renovation of the site while leaving open the possibility that sometime in the future if it were to become financially feasible then Old Mammoth Place could still be developed.
31:18 as it was originally envisioned and approved. So during this interim phase, Waterton obtained design review approval and a conditional use permit for the renovations and made some substantial investments, significant investments to expand and upgrade the hotel, the restaurant, the public spaces, and really to try to create a dynamic outdoor food and restaurant venue along Old Mammoth Road. Specifically,
31:48 Waterton updated and enhanced all of the hotels, entryways, lobbies, public spaces and accommodations. They added the 20 villa units that we're discussing today and 10 cabin units on the hotel inventory in order to enhance the site as a place for families to vacation. All of the new units that were built will accommodate families. And so what they've set out to do is round out the resort offering.
32:16 In addition to the traditional hotel rooms, all of which were upgraded and updated, they wanted to add more family units, which is what they did. They also created a new restaurant called Bar Sierra with an expanded outdoor seating deck, created a food and beverage garden, an events venue along Old Mammoth Road, which is served by Bar Sierra and food trucks. They upgraded and increased the capacity of the event and meeting space of the site.
32:46 They created a new wine bar in the hotel lobby, installed a new pool and hot tub, created multiple landscaped amenity areas, provided workforce housing on site again for a minimum of five employees, and constructed a new sidewalk along Laurel Mountain Road for the full length of the site, which supports the town's Safe Routes to Schools initiative. And what Waterden did was the first
33:16 Redevelopment, first major expansion and renovation of a hospitality project in Mammoth in decades. It transformed the site into a contemporary full-service resort and made significant strides towards achieving the general plan's goals for the Old Mammoth Road District, including increased hotel occupancies and a revitalized streetscape, while still keeping open the possibility that
33:46 If somehow, someday, the big idea were to prove to be financeable, either this owner or a future owner could pursue that goal. As Kim mentioned, the focus of today's discussion is the building units. Those were stick-built, ground-up.
34:13 And originally, through the entitlement process, Kim is right, there was no requirement that there be a change from the original approval in the Clearwater-specific plan, which allowed 340 condo hotel units. But the villas were originally intended to just operate as hotel rooms.
34:43 Entitlement and Redevelopment Process, Waterton received some unsolicited requests to whether or not those units could be converted into townhomes, condos for ownership while still maintaining the primary goal, which would be that they are lodging units. And so that's what brings us here today is Waterton's request.
35:12 to convert the villas into condominium ownership. I will now turn the matter over to Matthew Mearing, and Matthew is the Executive Vice President for Hospitality at Waterton, to pick up where I left off. Thanks, Mark. Thanks, Chairman Vanderhurst and the Commission. Appreciate the time today.
35:38 Mark gave some really great context, so I just wanted to really kind of add on to what he said and give you the ownership perspective of this whole condo hotel concept we're here today to talk about. But first of all, I'd like to thank Nolan, Amy, Kim, Gina, Andy, and the rest of the staff for all the hard work. I echo very much what Mark said. I realize there's a lot going on in the town, and so I appreciate everyone working well. There's no proactive.
36:06 collaborative banner. Also apologize, I can't be there in person. I'm currently pulled up in an airport while I was waiting to jump on a flight and I'd rather be out there enjoying the early season snow that was dumped over Thanksgiving. So apologize, I'm not there in person. But I know I've addressed some of you when we first took over the project, took this project at the Planning Commission in 2021. Yeah, there's also some new faces, so I thought at the risk of sounding a little repetitive.
36:34 For some of the familiar faces, give you a little more background on the project. When Waterton acquired this property three years ago, I presented a vision of the Commission for a concept called Outbound Hotels. Specifically, we had an idea to go about creating fun, cool, lifestyle hotels and iconic outdoor leisure destinations. I think beach towns, ski towns, national park towns.
37:01 Really with the goal to create a product that appealed to younger travelers, families, anyone else really who desired to stay at a property with a little bit of soul and a real sense of place. So, you know, Outbound is really a product that appeals to travelers who don't have the means or desire to splurge on a $1,500 night hotel room, but still want a hotel experience with some personality and character, with more personality and character than staying at a hotel.
37:29 You know, a branded kind of limited service budget hotel. So that's the niche that outbound occupies. You know, at the time when we spoke, we only had one other property in the outbound portfolio. It was in Jackson Hole. It was under renovation at the time. So it wasn't exactly a lengthy track record of success I could point to at the time. It was, I think it was a little bit of a leap of faith for kind of everyone in the planning commission and within town council.
37:57 But that being said, as we sit here today, we now have five outbound properties. We have a property at the South Gate Yosemite in Oakhurst, California that's under construction. That's a ground-up project. We just opened a project in Stowe, Vermont. We obviously have a property in Jackson Hole. And we are, as of next week, we'll have our fifth outbound property in Sedona, Arizona. So I think, yeah.
38:26 Mammoth is in good company with some of the other markets that the product is in. But needless to say, from 2021, when I first got one in front of the commission until today, the concept has clearly resonated. And we think, at Waterton, that this Mammoth property is a really great representation of the brand. So when we went to put together our business plan for the property,
38:54 Yeah, we wanted, we worked with the Planning Commission, and I think we came up with a great plan that, you know, complied with the general plan, fit the character of the neighborhood, you know, achieved a lot of the goals that the town had, you know, for this, yeah, for this site. Yeah, at the same time, we wanted to make sure that we maintained, as Mark alluded to, the option to undertake a larger development at some point. So that's why we made it clear about our specific plan.
39:20 Instead of abandoning it, leave that optionally open either for us or for a subsequent owner down the line. So after we closed on the property in 2021, end of 2021, we proceeded to invest $65 million in the property, both to acquire it and really transform it, reposition it, reimagine it. Mark touched on some of this, but specifically we redid the whole site,
39:50 Landscaping, et cetera, with a real emphasis on activating Old Mammoth Road. We built a staircase to connect pedestrian traffic to Old Mammoth Road. We, you know, we worked on, we redid the pedestrian walkway and Laurel Mountain Road. We partnered with some local entrepreneurs so they could park their food truck on site to enhance the other resort's food offerings. We renovated the former rafter space. We built out the wine bar.
40:17 The lobby, which has become a great community hangout, created the vacant spa to workforce housing, built out a new pool and hot tub, and we added the 30 additional rooms, which Kim touched upon. So for those of you who remember this property and we acquired it, I think it was a bit of an eyesore, to say the least. It had been neglected for years.
40:46 Yeah, the majority of the site was a sea of asphalt, there's a dilapidated mini golf course on the site, sad little pool that was way past its useful life, and you have some buildings that were needed some love. Initially, the interiors were pretty tired, outdated, so what we did with our investment was really transform the property. Yeah, we essentially took what was a rundown, blighted select service hotel and transformed it into a family-friendly resort.
41:14 Yeah, I'm sensitive to the fact over the years, I know that, you know, the town of Mammoth has had a somewhat spotty history with fly-by-night developers coming in and out of town. They promised grand plans only to, you know, eventually disappear, and that's not what we did. We made a commitment back in 2021 to invest in the community. Yeah, we stepped up the plate and definitely held our end to the bargain, and I can truly say that this was a kind of proverbial win-win for people.
41:42 For both parties, you know, we got the opportunity to expand our portfolio to an iconic California resort town. Yeah, and obviously the town benefited from new jobs that were created, increased top revenue. I think everyone benefited from just cleaning up that corner of, you know, one of the most important intersections of the town of Mammoth, really cleaning that corner up and activating it.
42:06 So needless to say, given the size of our investment in the property and the fact this property is really one of the flagships for the outbound brand, this is a really, really important asset for Waterton, our investor group. I want to touch on top for a minute on the TOT, just to highlight, basically we reopened in January of last year.
42:33 Resort with the new keys, the additional 30 keys. And, you know, the first year coming out of a renovation is typically slow. It takes three or four years to ramp a property up and stabilize it as, you know, you introduce, reintroduce yourself to the market. But in the first year alone, you know, basically 2024, we've increased room for revenue by a million and a half dollars versus, you know, 2019, which is the...
43:02 Yeah, prior, obviously the prior ownership groups hold period. So I'd also mention we, you know, once stabilized, we project that this property will kick off an additional $8 million incremental rooms revenue over those 2019 numbers. So really significant increase.
43:27 You know, and revenue to the town, which, and to our ownership group, which benefits everyone, obviously. So that, I guess, really begs the question, why are we here today, you know, asking for the ability to sell 20 of our units as condo hotels? I think Mark touched on this a little bit, but, you know, stepping back since 2021, you know, there have been certainly have been challenges developing this project that no one could have predicted, you know, two specifically, one,
43:56 Yeah, the winter of 22, 23, which dumped 800 inches of snow on the mountain. While great for the skiing was really devastating to the development, you know, set our construction timelines back many months. And anyone who knows construction knows that construction delays equal real dollars. It also delayed the reopening of the project by several months, which is, you know, a little more heightened.
44:24 In a resort market like Mammoth, if you miss an opening by a few months because it's such a seasonal market and depending on when you reopen, it can have a really material effect on your P&L. So especially in a market like Mammoth where you have six or seven months to really make hay and generate revenue. So number one was the snowstorms in the middle of our
44:51 Yeah, renovation, which set us back. The other was inflation. Yeah, it started to rear its head two years ago now at this point, which obviously led to much higher interest rates, which I'm sure everyone in the room feels in some capacity, one way or another. But, you know, higher interest rates really, really crippled the real estate business, as you all know. So when we recently refinanced the property,
45:19 We had to take on much pricier debt than we anticipated back in 2021 due to the Federal Reserve hiking rates. So the interest rates and the delays related to the winter had a pretty material effect on our reopening of the property. But anyone who's in business to survive, you have to pivot and adapt. So while we were sitting around lamenting our situation last winter,
45:48 With the delays and cost overruns, the 20 units we're looking to sell today came out in line. And, you know, original thought, as Mark mentioned, was these units would be larger, they're more residential feel, they have kitchens, they're almost 800 square feet, they're really, they're more condo kind of apartment type product. We thought it would be a great option for families.
46:13 And we really felt it would be a unique product type in Mammoth that could compete directly with the short-term rental market. As the villas started to come online, people started randomly driving up and asking our team, when were we listing the units, when were we selling them? And after this happened five or six times, I kind of took it as a sign that the universe was trying to tell us something. Since we didn't...
46:41 Contemplate this execution from the get-go, and since this would be our first type of condo hotel execution in a resort market, Dan and I did a ton of research, talked to a lot of people in town, and what we came away with was there was a huge demand for this type of product at our price point in Mammoth, given the current inventory of what's out there.
47:06 Like our hotel, these condo units would be positioned to be filling a unique niche for new housing product. It's going to be priced beneath the limelines of the luxury product that's recently come online at market, but it's still a fresh new product with hotel-style amenities that's accessible to a lot more people than...
47:27 Some of the recent luxury product has come online. At the same time, these hotel units haven't resonated with the transient hotel guests like we thought they would. What we found is the short-term rental customers, they generally want a little more space than what these units offer.
47:51 Really, our customers are gravitating towards the 10 standalone cabins, which are half the size of the villa units, and they've been gravitating towards the traditional hotel keys. So these specific units, they run about 27% occupancy, which is well, well, well below the other room types of the property. So I guess in short, stepping back, this condo hotel execution allows us to re-level the playing field,
48:20 Pay down some more expensive debt. It's a very similar execution to the majority of our competitors in hotel properties in town, which have this type of product. It's very common in other resort towns, as you probably all know. But, you know, this gives, and it still gives us the opportunity to capture transient revenue for us in our ownership group, and that equals TOT dollars for the town. So, you know, to put this into perspective, these 20 units are only about 10% of our inventory.
48:50 You know, we estimate the reduced transient rooms revenue once, you know, if we're successful selling these as condos, will equal about $400,000 a year annually, which is like less than 5% of the incremental rooms revenue that we'll be generating through the, you know, the repositioning of the property stabilization. So it's kind of a rounding error.
49:16 And then I think the other thing to know, which Mark touched on, is there's no really, we're not changing the end use of the property. As you mentioned, the Clearwater Specific Plan allowed for almost 400 condo hotel units as designed. So it isn't really departing from the spirit of the original Clearwater Specific Plan. So with that, I think I'll pass it back to you, Chairman Vanderhurst, who can open it up for questions and happy to, happy to answer any questions.
49:46 Appreciate the presentation, gentlemen, and the historical perspective. It always is beneficial, even to those of us who have heard it before. It's good to know where we've been and possibly where we're going. So with that, I'll throw it back to the Commission if we have any questions before I open up to public comment, or would you guys prefer to wait until you hear from the public? Public.
50:09 Please. All right. Then I might ask you guys to stay on the Zoom, if you wouldn't mind. And do we have any public comment in person? Paige, you're the only one. No? Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? None. Okay. Then I will close public comment. Surprised by that, but I will close public comment. And we'll bring it back up to the commission. Any questions for staff or the applicant or any of the gentlemen on the Zoom call at this time?
50:39 Commissioner Verruck, I'll throw it to you first. Sure. I do have a question. I guess it would probably go toward to staff. I mean, it's obvious, you know, with limelight coming online and the way that that project is being built where it is a combination of pure hotel and residential units. So obviously that's something that if
51:00 You know, back in the day, if it was presented this way, it would more or less have been, I mean, obviously you can't predict, but it would have been approved or it wouldn't have been necessarily an issue. Is that safe to say? I think that's fair. Like I was saying during the presentation, I haven't found anything in the project file when the district zoning amendment from 2021 was approved.
51:28 where staff or commission required the language prohibiting condominium component or condominium hotel component within the phase one. So it does appear to have been voluntary language that was proposed by the applicant team that was accepted by the town based on their concept. And then, so what happens to those units if they're sold and the
51:57 Do you want me to take that? Go ahead, Dan.
52:25 Now, as far as the way that we've structured the application and kind of our intent going forward, right, is to guard against the ability for the new ownership of the bill is to prevent that possibility, right? And so while it's not in our intention at this current point in time, just given where things stand, we do not want to take that off the table and prevent that from ultimately being a possibility for the town and the community should circumstances and economics change.
52:51 Would you mind just expanding upon that a bit? Is that something that's going to be incorporated in the CC&Rs? How do you maintain that maneuverability and flexibility going forward? Yep, I will actually defer that to Christopher Payne on our side here. Sorry, Dawn, I didn't mind. No, that's fine. Good morning, everybody. Chris Payne. I'm a partner with Ballard-Spar. Thank you for the question, Chair Vanderhurst and Commissioners.
53:19 Yes, there is a provision in the CCNRs that reserves all future development rights outside the boundaries of lot one and reserves with the owner of the so-called remainder lot. Yes, that lot one has its own property rights and so the redevelopment of that boundary of lot one would require the consent of those owners, but we have
53:48 Drawn that line, so to speak, on the TTM specifically to those villas. The entire remainder of the site is unencumbered by the CC&Rs, so that would be treated as if it's the same as today. And the REA, the Reciprocal Easement,
54:17 agreement that was referenced during the staff discussion also has that same flexibility so that as the remainder parcel has, let's say, relocated curb cuts or has relocated utilities, that REA is easier to adapt over time than a traditional, you know, set of owner's association documents.
54:45 Thank you. Apologies for hijacking your question. Oh, no problem. My other question would be with regard to ownership and those that wanted to possibly do nightly rentals and or maybe not do rentals at all, just use it for personal use. It seems, is it possible that the CC&Rs would require those 20 units that if they did want to do a nightly rental, they'd have to do it through?
55:13 Outbound only because it just seems private rentals are so challenging in other areas and because the building, it just, I mean, I think it creates a lot of confusion for guests, but at the same time, I understand, you know, if it's my property, I want to be able to sort of do what I want to do with it within reason, but is that something that Outbound would consider where if they did choose to?
55:37 Thank you so much. Thank you.
56:07 We can force them to be a part of basically take the hotel manager as the manager of those units. Think cams, utilities maintenance, not utilities, sorry, maintenance, kind of the common area of just maintaining all that, right? That is, they would have to engage us as the manager to do that. Now, from the rental management side of things, while we can't tell them that, hey, you must list it through us on our website, what have you, what we can do is
56:34 is provide the path of lease resistance to do that. So if they were to choose to rent outside of us, they would still have to go through, you know, check when we'd be at the front desk, they'd have to provide the reservation, the details on the reservation themselves and kind of go through a bunch of logistical hoops or logistical hoops in order to kind of provide that because we as the manager would still need to know how that works. Now, they could also not list it in general, however, but when you look at the price point and the overall kind of what these units are going to be.
57:01 These will not be full-term units. We're capping owner stays at consecutive days, 30 consecutive days, after which the owner has to check out for the next day, right? So it's not going to be a permanent residence at all. And then two, with that kind of where these things are at, it'll be more so, we view this as more the buyer of the pool will be someone that buys it and uses it kind of at their leisure. However, it will also value the income stream from the RMA itself.
57:31 Thank you. If I could add to that point, and Mark, assuming that your hand raised is to kick me under the table, is, and again, I'll also start with, on this time, to thank staff and Andy Morris and others because this is a technical legal area.
57:57 But staff dove headfirst into it, and I think we came up with a solution that everyone gets what they want. And that solution is the CC&Rs do require that owners have a limit on their stays. So even the owner stays will be short-term occupancy. And the CC&Rs, as well as the town conditions, require that when an owner is not occupying the unit, it must be made available for rental.
58:26 And then as Daniel and others have stated, there's a separate concern that the applicant shares with the town, which is the quality of maintenance. The standard of maintenance needs to be consistent across the entire resort. And so that's what Daniel was saying is regardless of who is renting it, the hotel will control the standards of operation, the standards of property management, the
58:54 The exteriors and interiors will be maintained by the same hotel operator. It's very important for security. It's very important for maintaining who we know is on the site and also for providing all of the community experience around all the exterior amenities, etc. So this is the primary use is for transit occupancy. That is a clear
59:19 A requirement under your review, under the use, the request for the use change, is that the change in ownership to condominium ownership will not change the use as a primary occupancy, a transient occupancy product, and that is satisfied in both the CC&Rs and in the town's conditions. Thank you, Chris. I'm glad I deferred because I would not have been able to communicate it as clearly as you did.
59:46 I just wanted to say that implicit in Commissioner Brooke's question is the assumption that the units could be lived in by the owners full time. And that is a reasonable assumption based upon the practice of Mammoth and condo hotels throughout. The good news for the town with respect to that is that, as Chris said, that can't happen.
1:00:15 Nobody can, the owner can't live in these units without interruption. In fact, to my knowledge, it's the first kind of hotel project, it would be the first kind of hotel project in town that includes owner occupancy restrictions, as Chris has laid out. And so Waterton has agreed to that, even though it's
1:00:45 The first of its kind in town, because it's in the mutual best interest of the town and Waterton for that to happen. And so there's no, there would be no concern that someone would actually just live in these units full time. It can't happen. Thank you. Mark, can I just ask you a quick question on that last statement you just made? Yes. Let me ask town staff a quick question beforehand. What RMF zone is this property in?
1:01:17 This property is zoned Clearwater specific plan. Okay. So there are no town oversight in terms of 30 day max or minimum or permanent residency. There's no town oversight, no town regulation in effect. For? In other words, I just want to see, I want to, I guess I'll get to the question. The question is, if somebody did purchase a unit and decided they wanted to live there full time,
1:01:47 Could they supersede the arrangement and the agreement they signed with Waterton to force the situation so they could live there full-time? In other words, could they sue? I'm going to defer to Andy Morris, who's been really focused with Chris Payne, if I may, Chair, because I think Andy would be a perfect person to respond to your question.
1:02:15 Let's start with the premise that anyone can sue anyone at any time for anything. It doesn't mean that they'll win. The CC&Rs that Chris's team have put together are intended to be as airtight as they can be. And it is very difficult to challenge successfully the validity of CC&Rs if they're properly prepared by people who know what they're doing. And Chris's team clearly do know what they're doing. So although there are no zoning-based restrictions on the duration of those owner stays,
1:02:44 The CC&Rs will be valid, binding, enforceable. I don't think that the owners would be able to successfully challenge the length of stay provisions in the CC&Rs, and we anticipate that, although there could be some enforcement challenges because it's hard to monitor how long people are staying, we would like to think that ultimately people will not be staying past 30 days, and if they are, I think it will be in a surreptitious way rather than by challenging the CC&Rs and trying to
1:03:14 Secure for themselves a legal above-board right to stay for more than 30. You know, if I may supplement that, and correct me if I'm wrong, Andy, but I believe that the proposed resolution, which includes, you know, the amended DZA, actually does, from its own perspective, limit occupancy to 30 days. And so there's more than just the CCNRs ensuring that there will be transient occupancy in these units. I'd forgotten about that. Thank you for that correction, Mark.
1:03:45 Thank you, gentlemen. Appreciate the answer, and I apologize for the vague question. Commissioner Eckert, do you have any questions for either staff or the applicant? I have a couple questions. Not so much as how this is going to get used, but my recollection was that we were at a stage in this project, and it was going to go in the future into something along the lines of a more ambitious project, shall we say, and that
1:04:16 These units were meant to be actually temporary and that they would be here for a duration of time until the economy, the developers, finances, everything else, the stars aligned and the project would move forward. To me, if there's 20 units that are converted into condominiums in the middle of this, that's game over. You're not going to build the original
1:04:47 was a underground parking garage for the entire lot. You're going to have a pedestal with 20 units on top of it right in the center. I just don't see how this isn't about canceling the future of this project as much as it is how those 20 units are going to get used. So I'd like to see that elaborated on a little bit. If I may, the building units are in the south section of the property.
1:05:14 And so there could be a project which would be proposed in the future which would redevelop the essentially the northern two-thirds of the site with a project which is similar to the old Mammoth Place project which was approved back in 2010. And that project could be accommodated entirely with an underground parking garage, maybe not 488.
1:05:45 So, you know, we have a lot of cars, maybe not 601 cars, but certainly a significant number of underground parking spaces to accommodate the redevelopment of the northern two-thirds of the property. Now, as Chris Payne said, theoretically, it could include the villas as well, but in order for that to happen, you'd have to get the consent of the owners to include.
1:06:12 their units into a new redevelopment. We don't think that's likely, and so just being candid, we believe that if Waterton or Succession Interest wants to pursue the so-called big idea, which was evidenced by Old Mammoth Place, they still could do it. It just would not include this one lot within which the villas are situated.
1:06:41 But everything else could be very similar to what it was originally envisioned. And that's why Waterton took pains to keep the specific plan in place, specifically to allow for the option of redeveloping the northern two-thirds of the site at some time in the future. Keep in mind, the original building is 1967, as you know, Commissioner Eckert.
1:07:09 At some point in the future, it's probably likely that it will be raised, that the town will require underground parking, the town will require compliance with the Clearwater specific plan, and we will have a somewhat smaller version of Old Mammoth Place. I just see this as a stake in the heart, you know.
1:07:43 We're going to go through and do these 20 condos. They're going to get half a million apiece, $10 million-ish. But that $10 million is going to completely negate the future of this project. And the use will be the same. I agree with that. There's no real problem there about who gets what out of the condo or the hotel room. But it's just, to me, if we're going to take this as...
1:08:12 20 units, I think we're really diluting ourselves as to what we're actually doing. Well, we would still have the, this owner or future owner would still have the opportunity to build 320 more condo hotel units on the site pursuant to the Clearwater-specific plant. Nothing's changed at all in that respect. It's just a financial decision as to whether or not it makes financial sense to do so, and thus far it has not made financial sense to do so. But that's not to say it won't be
1:08:46 Feasible in the future. Yeah, you still have a lot of land to work with, even carving these 20 units out. It's, you know, almost five acres. So you have substantial land to create density and, you know, increase the key count and do something more grand down the road. So we don't want to put a stake in the heart of it, quite frankly, because having that optionality in the land increases the value of our real estate.
1:09:12 Which is why Mark alluded to, we took great pains to keep the existing entitlements in place. That's my smart. Okay. I just have a couple of really quick questions, and this is probably a little bit more for staff. Kim, would you just mind expanding upon, in the map that you presented to us, figure one, the proposed subdivision configuration, the remainder part that is
1:09:46 Kind of right behind the main building. You mentioned that was the garbage collection area going to be relocated there and snow storage relocated there. And did I hear something about parking being relocated there? No. So what I had mentioned is that the easements for the shared facilities would be identified for those elements of the site. So required.
1:10:15 Trash Enclosure, which is located at the southwest corner of the site. It currently exists, but a reciprocal easement agreement would be required to include access and use of that trash enclosure by the condominium owners, as well as so required parking for each of those units.
1:10:40 would have to be established through that reciprocal easement agreement for a minimum of 21 parking spaces so that in the event a future redevelopment does occur and they need to change the configuration of the parking lot to provide underground parking that there will always be a minimum of 21 parking spaces dedicated to this lot one that would be created for the condominium owners.
1:11:10 So this is really just showing the configuration of the lot one, you know, kind of the minimum limits of that project so that it preserves the rest of the area for potential redevelopment that could occur in the future. And the placement of this lot is actually not terrible because it's not located right on the front.
1:11:39 Frontage of Old Mammoth Road, where we really wanted to kind of focus the pedestrian activity and potential new retail development. And it is, you know, set back a little bit and was intended to be set back a little bit by the original CSP, which identified that area as condominium hotel uses. So hopefully that answers your question. It does, but it leads to another question.
1:12:09 I'll apologize for throwing this curveball at staff. If I remember correctly, when we approved the master plan for the old Mammoth Place, which is the rendition after Clearwater, there was an issue with the required parking, and we granted them a smaller, a less amount of parking than the town guidelines under the stipulation that there was a valet.
1:12:39 System that was going to be put in place. Can you maybe touch on how that affects the valet system or are these villas, are these villas subject to that valet requirement or not? Maybe just if you could expand upon that a bit. So the reduced parking requirement was a part of the amended phase one CSP DZA and there was a valet component to that.
1:13:10 parking agreement. And we did not really touch that existing agreement. And the number of parking spaces required for condominium hotel uses versus hotel uses does not really change. So in effect, that parking management agreement, I believe that's what it was titled,
1:13:38 Isn't affected by this proposed project, only in the sense that a minimum of 21 units must always be available for the condominium hotel use. And those 21 units live within the reduced parking requirements that we agreed upon with the applicant, with the developer? They would already be subject to that agreement, yeah.
1:14:04 But not subject to the valet parking requirements. Am I hearing that correctly? In other words, if somebody does rent it out, let's say somebody rents it out on a nightly basis through Waterton, through the front desk, and it happens to be a very full weekend for the property, are they subject to the valet or not? That's a good question. It wasn't conditioned that they would be required to valet park.
1:14:37 So that would be a question. If the CC&Rs address any of the shared parking or valet operations of the hotel? I'll say in practice, as far as the management of the property, it would be required. If the general hotel guests and their renting through us are required by the valet provisions, then these guests who would be staying in the villas would also be required by that.
1:15:05 From a management perspective, makes it much easier on the team there. Okay. Is that actually written out someplace? Is that listed as a condition for approval? I don't believe it's a condition of approval per Kim's part, but I will defer to Chris as far as being written out in the governing documents. Thank you. So the conditions around the 21 spaces that have been mentioned by Kim are in the REA.
1:15:37 And they effectively are drafted as a protection to the owners, not as a mandate for a certain type of parking. So two scenarios. Well, let me start with the first scenario. Parking right now is outside of lot one. So under the REA, reciprocal easement, the hotel manager controls all parking.
1:16:06 and can comply with the valet requirements on, let's just say, 99% of the time. What the REA does, however, is to protect the rights of an owner, not a guest, but an owner that wants to come and use that villa for their stay to a certain designated area that's close to the villas to say,
1:16:36 That if they want to park there close to their unit, they can park there. You know, that again, that doesn't, I guess that does impair the valet management component in an extreme situation where somebody can say, I don't want to use valet, I just want to go park, I'm right near my unit, but that would be the only instance. In any other scenario, the
1:17:05 Hotel is operating the parking per the parking plan. Well, Chris, I have a question about that because my understanding was that Waterton was objecting to designating specific parking spaces for these units. He didn't want to have 21 spaces nearby the villas that would be designated for the villas. This is sounding a little bit different than that. And also, I guess a query is...
1:17:31 If somebody were renting not through the front desk, but renting through some other platform or on their own, it seems to me that they would also not be required to take advantage of the valet parking, that they could step into the shoes of the owners and essentially park in designated spaces if there are going to be designated spaces for the villas. But I guess for members of the commission, if you can help us understand where you would like this to end up being, we can maybe craft conditions that reflect
1:18:00 your vision for this or address your concerns. Well, and before we turn it over, if I could at least clarify, yes, we initially objected to that designation, but staff convinced us that it was an important feature. And so the current documents are on the staff report include within the TTM.
1:18:30 That designated area. And the current REA does add that protection that I just described. So at least what I spoke of is consistent with what the current application in front of the mission is today. So if there's a change of direction, we'll roll with it. Andy, any thoughts on that? I'd love to hear your professional opinion.
1:19:02 Well, I think that the staff perspective has been wanting to ensure that villa owners and guests could park in spaces that were reasonably close to the villas rather than perhaps being required to park further away. I don't think that we've really thought about the valet issue. So I think probably both the Waterington team and the staff are thinking about the valet issue for the first time now.
1:19:28 If the Commission has a different thought about whether there should be designated spaces for the villas, or some thoughts about how you'd like Valley Parking to work vis-a-vis occupants of the villas, I mean, I think now's the time to talk through it. I have a comment. Please, Kim. So I did pull up the parking management plan that was approved for the amended Phase 1 project, and what it states is that the
1:19:56 Property owner will implement valet parking at 85% occupancy of the 179 room hotel. So that would be 152 occupied rooms. So the existing valet plan does include the villa units. So I guess the question would be, do we need to add a condition of approval basically saying that these units
1:20:24 Will still be included as part of the parking management plan for Valley services. I think there's a couple options. We could probably add a condition of approval or potentially amend the parking management plan. Okay. So that's, I think, a question for the commission is, how do you think this would best work? Do you think it makes sense to have the villas have parking designated that's close by where people can just go and park, which would
1:20:55 Make it, I guess, somewhat incumbent upon the operator to try, to some extent, to keep other people out of the spaces, or would you rather see it that everybody, whether they're staying at the resort or in the villas, has to participate in valet parking? Once they hit that 85% occupancy threshold is the question. Yeah. And with that, I'll throw it back up to the commission here. I'd love to hear both of your thoughts on this. And I apologize for going down the rabbit hole, but I think this is important.
1:21:25 I guess my question is, Kim, when you're saying, and everybody, that there's 21 designated spots, I mean, just in looking at the map, there's significantly more than 21 spots in Lot 1 or that are adjacent to Lot 1 that are on Sierra Nevada Road. So I don't know when you're saying, are you talking specifically about marking those spots so that they're designated for Unit 1, they're designated for Unit 2, or is it just
1:21:55 It's just an overall, that area is for the villas, this one parking section before the villas. And then, you know, the other thing is in the summertime, the parking, or in the wintertime, I should say, the parking increases so that you have that lot on Old Mammoth Road, right? Or is that, are there parking spaces there where the turf was during the summer, where there were events? Are there still some parking spaces along?
1:22:23 There are, right? In the wintertime, primarily, I'm assuming. Over by Bar Sierra? Yes. Okay. All right. Well, I don't know that I have that much of a... I understand, you know, if you're 85% occupied, then there's concern with healthier parking and where they're parking, but also the people that are staying in villas, you know, they have kitchens, so my assumption would be that they're going to have a little bit more luggage and groceries and, you know, they're having them...
1:22:53 be allowed to park, you know, specified in this area, I think would be important for those, for those people staying in the, in the villas. So I'm not really sure how you, maybe mark them as reserved or something along those lines? Possibly, I don't know. Yeah. Like just villa parking, not necessarily per unit, but just villa parking. Sure. And before you go, Dan, I just would like to hear from Commissioner Eckert. Do you have any thoughts on the parking or the valet? Parking, valet, it seems to me, this is all,
1:23:23 Only when it's 85% occupancy or more, right? Okay, so it's only kicking in when it's a cluster. So you don't really want to have three different systems go because it's already Christmas week or whatever and why would you want to have three different sets of rules? I think it should all be under the original plan was for these units to be in that number of spaces and inside of that trigger. Just leave it alone. I'll say from an operations perspective, the
1:23:53 Team, Peter and the team at the property will have an understanding of how many of the villas are occupied on each of the nights and that since they're the ones administrating the parking valet, they'll be able to kind of guard around that as far as which cars are parked where and kind of providing that area of proximity to the villas for those residents and those guests, or those owners and those guests, sorry. So to agree with Greg there, I think it's from an operational standpoint easier to have it all fall underneath the current parking agreement.
1:24:23 Okay, and then I guess, and I apologize because I'm asking you on the fly here, how would you regulate that? Like, would you actually have staff out there telling people they couldn't park in the 21 or is the 21 subject to the valet and whoever the valet parks the car, the valet parks the car? That would be the lot where the valet parks the car and they have an understanding as far as which cars go where, if you will, right? So you would have an understanding.
1:24:49 X car is attributed to a bill, then that car should be parked over there. If it's not, then you park it elsewhere. Okay. Has there been a point where you've had to do the valet parking yet? Not yet. Okay. Any other thoughts from everybody in the Zoom world up there on this matter? I'll just reinforce the way we structured the documents. Again, the lot one is the boundary of the...
1:25:22 Villa buildings. So the parking, even the designated parking, is all exterior to lot one and is owned and controlled by the hotel owner. So it is clearly subject to the parking plan. In terms of operations, and I know this is part of Andy's question about how do you manage guest stays, even guest stays that are coming from an out of sight.
1:25:51 Rental Manager. This falls back into this required property management agreement that we were talking about maintains control of operations of the site, standard of, you know, standards for maintenance, same staff doing all the work. That includes managing the parking, right? Because again, parking is on the hotel site. So even a rental guest that comes from the outside, they're going to have to go through
1:26:19 The hotel front desk, they're going to have to get a parking designation. And so all of those valet rules can stay in place without change the way it's currently working. Again, I really think we're just at this last point of are we adding, which again, we're aligned with we want the owners to be happy and to not feel like the hotel is putting their parking in a bad spot. Do we want to have a provision which is currently in,
1:26:49 The REA to say that that owner that doesn't want to use valet can park closer to their villa. But for the rest of the operation, it's going to be maintained the same way it's currently operated. And I suppose we could also add that trap door to say even the owner's right to park near their villa is subject to
1:27:23 The required use of valet when there's 85% occupancy. We can add that to the REA as well, too. Andy, would you be comfortable with that amendment? It's not really a legal issue so much as a policy issue. So whatever the commission would like to do here, I think we can make work legally. I'm confident the Waterton team can draft it, and I'm confident that it will be legal. So it's really, what's your pleasure, commissioners? Thank you, Andy. Don, did you have a...
1:27:55 Something else that you wanted to share? I had one other question, but it's not regarding parking, so I don't know if we want to stay on. Okay, please. Okay, so, you know, in the one letter that we did receive from the public, they talked about SB7, which is the plumbing code for meter, so each unit has to be metered. Is this going to be an issue to put a water meter on every unit? No, we've already requested and received multiple quotes, and we're prepared to move forward with that. Great.
1:28:26 And that item is also a condition of approval requiring compliance with SP7. Okay. That's what I thought, but I thought I should, since Tom isn't here, I'd address it. Kim, does this affect the snow storage plan, snow management plan in any way, shape, or form?
1:28:44 We are requiring that snow storage and snow management be addressed within the REA easement document, and I'll defer to Amy if there were any revisions from the original snow management plan to the current easement sort of proposed configuration. Right, so there aren't any changes proposed to the snow management plan, which is the document that
1:29:09 describe locations for temporary snow storage to then later be hauled away and trucked away by the owner when the conditions dictate and that document also allows the town to to enforce the snow removal on the property but in this
1:29:26 For this proposed project, since all of the parking and the driveway and access is proposed to be on the remainder lot, which is the hotel lot, the reciprocal easement agreement is proposing that the resort management team continues to be responsible for all of the snow management and snow storage, which I agree is the logical
1:29:49 Way to move forward. So this really shouldn't affect snow storage at all, but it does simply address that snow removal and snow management is an operation that the resort performs, I guess, on behalf of the ownership property. Okay, thank you. I'll just ask you really quick, Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? You already closed public comment. Okay, I just want, because we've kind of gone down them.
1:30:20 A little bit of a rabbit hole here on a few topics. Well, gentlemen, thank you. Any other thoughts or opinions you'd like to put out from the Waterton team? There's nothing for me. Again, thank you all for your time and kind of the thorough conversation we've had today. Thank you, gentlemen. Appreciate it. With that, I'll throw it back to the commission. Any other thoughts, opinions? Any desire to make a motion? I still have the issue of
1:30:50 This whole meeting is just to change ownership on 20 units. The whole project would work just fine the way it is. All the rentals, all the parking, all the snow storage, it doesn't change because there's 20 deeds. What changes is these folks are going to be able to pull out a significant amount of their initial investment, cash it out, but then it's going to have this forever problem to try and develop it going forward. And it's not going to be insurmountable.
1:31:18 But it certainly isn't going to make it any easier. And I just am not entirely comfortable with having this island in the middle of this project. And if I may say one on that note, to the point on cashing out, this is not a cash out for profit for us. There is no distributions that are being derived from this. This is purely to level set the cost overruns that were, to help offset the cost overruns that were done during the project.
1:31:50 Change in circumstances as far as the macroeconomic capital market environments. Thank you. And if I may add, you know, Waterton had the option, the town gave Waterton the option to either amend the interim plan or to vacate the Clearwater-specific plan. That was an option that the town provided Waterton among its options going forward.
1:32:19 And Waterton specifically decided not to accept the option of vacating a specific plan because it does not want to drive a stake into the heart of that big idea. The reality is it's simply not financeable now. If and when it becomes financeable, then the owner will take another look at it. And it's going to have to be redeveloped at some point in the future, the northern part of it.
1:32:50 And when it does, the town is going to require underground parking. So the big idea is still alive. And it's in the town's interest and the owner's interest to keep it alive until the day that it makes sense to pursue that idea. So I just want to make it clear that there's no desire whatsoever.
1:33:21 to prevent that or to make it less or make it more difficult to go forward with the vision of Old Mammoth Place. It just can't happen right now. We've been through 15 years of Great Recession and a lot of smart people have tried to crack that code and haven't been able to. And fortunately what Waterton did is say, you know what, in the meantime, let's improve the community, let's improve Old Mammoth Place.
1:33:51 And then sometime in the future, if it makes sense, then we'll do it again. Thank you. Any other thoughts, opinions? No? Anybody care to make a motion? Okay. I would like to make a motion to adopt the resolution.
1:34:15 Making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and recommendation to the Town Council approval of District Zoning Amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004, and tentative tract map 24-003 with conditions as recommended by staff. Would you like to add an amendment or a modification to that in regards to the valet parking and the 85%?
1:34:44 Threshold? Is that appropriate? Well, I thought that was part of, I thought that was already part of the, okay, well then to, so what is that parking thing called again? It is a parking management plan. Oh, the parking, and to include the parking, the existing parking management plan with a 85% threshold of occupancy. So just for,
1:35:12 Full clarity, does that mean that the villa units, all 20 of them are subject to the parking management plan when the 85% occupancy trigger happens? Yes, that's my understanding is that the intent is that when the 85% occupancy is triggered, it is going to include the units that are within the villas and that the valet services would need to apply to the villas parking.
1:35:43 And you're comfortable with that modification in your motion? Yes, I am comfortable. Okay. With that, do I have a second? Second. Any further conversation? I have a clarifying question before you vote. I think that the REA and the CC&Rs are not yet final. I think that there's still some fine-tuning to do between Waterton team and the staff. So is the motion to accept all this, kind of prove it conceptually?
1:36:13 subject to getting the documents finalized to the mutual satisfaction of the applicant of the town? Yes. Yes. Yes. Is that... Thank you. Okay. And no further conversation. Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Eckert? No. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes 2-1. Congratulations, gentlemen. And we look forward to seeing the final agreement that it will be hammered out between...
1:36:45 Town staff and the applicant. So thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you all. With that, we will go to the consent agenda, which are two matter of minutes from the October 9th meeting and the October 13th meeting. If there are no edits that are suggested, I would entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda. Motion to approve. Second. I second. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Eckert.
1:37:15 Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Ksenna agenda passes 3Z. Thank you. Commissioner reports. Commissioner Eckert, do you have something you'd like to report out? I do not. Commissioner Verruck? The design committee has not met recently. Got it. Okay. I'll just throw out there that this Saturday is Night of Lights, so if you have a chance to enjoy it, I do believe that the standing area out on the snow is free to the public.
1:37:45 The Village Gondola will be running and that's free to the public. If you haven't been or you haven't taken your kids, no matter how old they are, bundle them up. It is a fantastic way to kick off what will hopefully be an amazing ski season. Mammoth Mountain does a truly amazing job with that event, with that festival. I believe it's one of the best community events.
1:38:10 that we have, so if anybody has a chance to get out there, please enjoy, and again, it is free to the public, as long as you're outside of Canyon Lodge, I believe, so please enjoy. With that, I'll ask Nolan to give us his director's report. Great, thank you. As a follow-up to the earlier item on the Skate with Santa event, I did get an update, so it is not free, however,
1:38:36 Local students, so in Inyo Ramono students in grades K through 12, it's $5 for the Skate with Santa, adults are $9, and that includes skate and helmet rentals, and any ice rink pass holders, that is included within that pass, so there's no cost for anyone with a 2024-25 skate pass. Thank you, Nolan.
1:39:04 And then some other updates, a brief update on the Town Civic Center project. So work did continue up until this week. They were able to pour the foundation at the end of last week with this brief clearing in the weather. They also placed all utilities. So that does set the contractor up to restart the project here in the spring and go vertical with the building.
1:39:32 Also, this summer, they completed the sidewalk and angled parking along Sierra Park Road. Amy, correct me if I'm wrong, those areas are not open yet, but they are, the infrastructure and concrete is all poured there. That's correct. The contractor did pull the fence down yesterday, and so pending a little bit of additional snow removal and cleanup of those spaces, we will be opening those for the winter.
1:40:01 So then once they go vertical, the target completion date is still fall of 2026 for that project. A few projects updates on the housing front. Parcel phase one as of this week, 76 of the 80 affordable units are occupied. The property management Buckingham is working on the final four tenants or units to certify their documents. They're hoping to complete those this week.
1:40:31 And then they would be moving in some point in the future, so that would then fully occupy that project. 60 Joaquin, that's the town's four-unit affordable housing project, is nearing completion. Prior to the snowfall, they were able to complete all the paving and curb and gutters on the site, and they're currently working on the interior of the units to finish those up. They are anticipated to be ready in early 2025 for sale.
1:41:00 The Eastern Sierra Community Housing Innsbruck Lodge Project. Six of the 16 units were completed in May of 2024 and have been occupied since. The remaining 10 units are waiting for electrical switch gear. They're expecting that equipment to arrive in January 2025. All the construction on those units are done. Everything is completed. It's just waiting for that equipment to arrive to install it, which will then...
1:41:28 Clear those units to be issued a certificate of occupancy. So they're anticipating that project to be completed here in early 2025. The access apartments project that's across the street here at 238 Sierra Manor Road. Construction is ongoing. They were able to
1:41:46 Complete all the exterior framing, they have the roof on, it's sheeted and they're continuing to work on that here into the winter. They're expecting that to be completed in fall of 2025. On the non-housing front side, a brief update on the Mammoth Creek Inn project. So I did check with the building inspector. The structures themselves are largely completed with most of the sign-offs done on those.
1:42:14 They were looking, or clearing the site and doing cleanup earlier last week, and if they had a window, they were looking to pave it, but if it, if weather does come in, that'll be pushed to the spring. They will need all the paving and striping and ADA features done before they can be issued a certificate of occupancy, but it is moving in the right direction here to complete that project. Glacially. Very slowly.
1:42:44 Got it. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate that. Any questions for Nolan in regards to his director's report or anything he may not have touched upon that you'd like to hear? Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate it. Thank you, staff. With that, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which will be January 8th here in Suite Z at 9 a.m. 2025. Crazy. That happened. 2025. Thank you, everyone, for attending today. Appreciate it. And with that, we'll...
1:43:14 Shut her down. Have a great Christmas. Have a great New Year, guys. Appreciate it. Appreciate you.