Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2025
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
15 findings- The Town adopted the Clearwater Specific Plan in January 2009 for a resort development on Old Mammoth Road Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- Old Mammoth Place, approved in March 2010 under the plan, allowed up to 340 residential units and up to 488 lodging rooms Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- In August 2016 the owner obtained CSP amendments that added 10 feet of building height and removed the on-site workforce housing requirement Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- The approved Amended Phase One project began construction in April 2022 and was substantially completed in April 2025, with some landscaping bonded Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- DZA 24-001 adds condominium hotel uses to the Amended Phase One plan; the Council voted 4-0 to introduce the ordinance on March 19, 2025 Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- An amended Phase One CSP for an Old Mammoth Road hotel site proposes 10 single-story resort cabins and 20 Villa units Downtown and Main Street
- The Town Council denied the appeals and approved the Limelight Hotel project after hearings in June and July 2022 Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- The approved project is a six-story, 185,754-square-foot condominium hotel with 151 hotel rooms and 15 for-sale condominium units Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- The project includes a geothermal well system; the water district's consultant raised concerns about a nearby production well Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- The site had earlier Mammoth Hillside entitlements that were to be rescinded when the Limelight approvals took effect Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- In February 2021 the Town Council was asked for feedback on a development agreement for a Limelight 151-room hotel and 23 residences Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- Resolution No. 22-53 attaches construction measures, including an October 15 soil-stabilization deadline each year Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- DZA 24-001 requests an amendment to allow a condominium hotel component with 20 hotel units Planning and Zoning
- A 2025 agenda packet says a state-mandated extension under AB 1561 moved the Mammoth Hillside entitlement expiration to July 12, 2022 Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
- A November 2020 Concept Review application proposed a first phase of 151 hotel rooms and 23 managed residences Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
Transcript
102 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:21 All right, I have 9 a.m. I would like to call to order the February 12th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we please have roll. Commissioner Eckert. Here. Commissioner Fleming. Here. Commissioner Grand. Here. Vice Chair Verruck. Here. Chair Vanderhurst. Here. Thank you, Jamie. If everyone would please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. And Kim, would you mind leading us? Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
2:53 Thank you, Kim. I would now like to open up public comment. I will ask if anybody has public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda, if you could hold off until that agenda item has been opened. So with that, I'll open up public comment. I don't believe snowstorms are on the agenda, so.
3:25 Nolan asked that I just give you an update on some of our activities leading into tomorrow's snowstorm. Pretty usual for us, kind of our normal operations with a couple tweaks. So we will be closing the scenic loop probably around one o'clock. We'll be sweeping, asking everyone to leave, and then locking the gates because we don't clear that during the storm. Probably have that back open, I suspect, sometime around Saturday, late as Sunday morning. We're going to close the dog park.
3:53 So we will be burning that in. The snow is going to be, well, if it comes in as projected. We saw what happened last week, so we'll see. But if it does come in as predicted, it'll be too much for us to open up the gates and keep that facility open. So we'll be burning it in and keeping the public out. Also closed Whitmore because the snow level will be low enough to where the track and all the facilities down there will be covered. So we'll be closing the gate at the parking lot and closing Whitmore until that snow melts out.
4:20 And we also made a number of tweaks to Davison, and we continue to fight Google Maps and everybody else with a GPS that is sending everyone up Davison this season. We don't know what changed, but obviously everybody's GPS is sending them to Davison to get to Canyon Lodge.
4:36 So we're going to maintain the berm at the top of the hill. We've added a CMS board at the bottom, notifying people that there's no access to Canyon Lodge. And we may also place a staff member at the bottom this Saturday, depending on what the road looks like, how icy it is, to basically stop them before they even get close to the top. Because, you know, I think we've had 20 vehicles in a pileup three weeks ago and 12 last weekend. Wow. Yeah.
5:04 Trying to get down Davidson or trying to get up Davidson? Column A and column B. Wow. Yeah. So the locals know how to navigate the road, but we get people who are just not prepared to get up that steep slope and then just go sliding back down. Other than that, crew's in good shape. We're going on shift tomorrow at noon. We only have one piece of equipment down, so everything's ready to go. We've got plenty of backups. We've got tons of snow storage, so we don't anticipate any major issues in our typical activities.
5:33 Just be business as usual. With that, happy to answer any questions. Any questions for Hayes in regards to the big storm coming in tomorrow or winter operations? Sounds like you got it dialed in, Hayes. We hope so. Do you foresee, and just quick question, do you foresee this strategy with Davidson being something that you guys will enable every winter? Yeah, we've been talking about this.
5:59 A lot of what we're doing is not sustainable. The amount of effort we've put into signage, managing those signs, you know, and berms and so forth, they're really a reaction to what we're seeing in the moment. We've talked about what the future would look like to try to get the GPSs and so forth to change how they direct people up Davis into Canyon Lodge, and we struggle just with any road closure in town.
6:27 Getting the maps to actually reflect the closures and so forth. We've talked about putting a gate at the top, a permanent gate and closing it for the winter and then we can notify the mapping that the street does not go through and hopefully that would fix it. Not saying we're going to do that, we're just talking out loud trying to find something that is sustainable because the level of effort we've had to put into keeping people off that street has been pretty significant.
6:55 If we do make significant changes, we'll probably notify the public. We'll go throughout typical channels and be talking to Town Council about that. Well, if there's no questions for Hayes, I'll just say huge thanks from the community, Hayes, for being on it as usual. Your crew does an amazing job considering what's going on out there and, you know, some of the erratic behavior, not just from visitors but locals as well. So huge thanks and please pass that on to your team. Appreciate that. Be safe and put your chains on. Thank you. Thank you, Hayes.
7:26 Any other public comment this morning? Nolan, did you say Andy was going to join us in this portion of public comment or when we open up the agenda item? Okay. Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Okay, then I will close public comment. And let's go to item 4.1. And just so everyone in the audience knows, item 4.2 has been continued to the March 12th.
8:05 meeting. So if anyone is here in regards to Snow Creek 8, 7 and 8, that will be next month. So I just don't want you to be here if you think that that is something we're going to address today. So 4.1, consideration of District Zoning Amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004, and tentative tract map 24-003.
8:33 for a subsequent amendment to the amended Phase I Clearwater Specific Plan located at 164 Old Mammoth Road. And I believe, Nolan, did you want to start the presentation or Kim? Sure, Kim will be providing the presentation and Andy Morris, the town attorney, is on now. I believe Andy's going to provide just a brief statement to open up the hearing item. Okay.
9:02 So Andy, if you're there, take it away. Do we have him, Jamie? You might be muted, muted, Andy, if you can hear me. Okay, let's try this again. So we have a little procedural wrinkle to this, which is unusual for what the PEDC does. State law says that because you are amending a specific plan, the recommendation of approval, if there's going to be one, has to come from a majority of the total membership of the commission.
9:48 You need three yes votes to recommend approval. A 2-2 vote does nothing. That's neither approval nor a denial. If the commission wants to recommend denial, that does not take three votes. You can recommend denial on a 2-1 if you're so inclined. We're just in this anomalous position where yes requires a different number of votes than a no. I should also point out that we have four commissioners available today.
10:16 Commissioner Fleming is not available because she has a conflict of which she's recused herself. And Commissioner Baruch does not have a conflict and she is available to participate. There were some circumstances we need to look into to confirm she does not have a conflict, but she's clear. So you've got four commissioners able to vote. A 2-2 would be the worst possible outcome from my perspective because it doesn't move this forward. 3-1 would move it forward to the council with a recommendation for approval.
10:44 If you can't quite get there, even a 2-1 recommendation of denial or 3-1 recommendation of denial would at least move it along. So that's where we stand. If we have any questions about that as we go along, I'll be here throughout the meeting. Thank you, Andy. And thank you for touching on the topic of Commissioner Fleming's conflict of interest. With that, I'll ask Commissioner Fleming to leave the dais and go into the penalty box. And we'll get you when the...
11:13 when the agenda item has been concluded. So any questions for Andy on that clarification on the vote procedure and the possible outcomes before we go to staff? All right, Nolan. Thank you, Andy. With that, I'll have Kim Cook give a presentation or overview on the project. Thank you.
11:35 And for our commissioners who were here for the last public hearing, I apologize if any of this is redundant. I am going to go through the same slides that I presented at our last hearing for Commissioner Grand and for the public that may not have attended the last hearing. So the application before you is the outbound hotel villas project. This entitlement application includes three different application types, a district zoning amendment, use permit, and tentative tract map. Is it not?
12:23 This project site encompasses approximately six acres and is located within the Clearwater Specific Plan zoning district. The Clearwater Specific Plan establishes land use guidelines and development standards for the properties included within the CSP zoning district. The CSP document includes in its vision and goals section a statement that the Clearwater Specific Plan
12:48 Envisions a pedestrian-oriented, mixed-use corridor along Old Mammoth Road, and the plan provides for a blend of retail, condominium hotel, and conference uses, in addition to plaza area that provides a venue for a variety of community activities and events. So for background on this site, the Clearwater specific plan was adopted by Town Council in January 2009.
13:18 This was along with a development for a new pedestrian-oriented mixed-use resort destination located in the North Old Mammoth Road District of town. Adoption of the CSP included approval of the Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. And following that, in March of 2010, the PEDC approved a vesting tentative tract map.
13:47 Use permit and design review for a mixed-use project called Old Mammoth Place. This was a large-scale project which included up to 340 residential units as well as up to 488 lodging rooms, eight on-site workforce housing units, multiple outdoor public events plazas, approximately 20,000 square feet of commercial and retail space, 17,000 square feet of restaurant space,
14:17 As well as conference space and spa and wellness center. The parking for that project was entirely within an underground parking garage. And as part of the old Mammoth Place project, the town approved a district zoning amendment in April of 2010 to clarify how building height was to be measured and how when a building sits on top of a parking garage.
14:42 And then subsequently another district zoning amendment was approved in 2010 to provide clarification on how their fees would be charged for the entitled project. And over the following approximately six years the property owner was not able to obtain financing to construct the project.
15:05 So in August of 2016, in order to improve the viability and marketability of the project, the owner obtained approval for amendments to the CSP through a district zoning amendment in order to allow a 10-foot increase in building height, an increase in net residential square footage, and elimination of an on-site workforce housing requirement.
15:31 At that time, a CEQA addendum was prepared and that addendum concluded that the proposed project modifications were consistent with what was analyzed as part of the CSP final EIR. And more recent background, approximately five years later in 2021, after the property changed ownership,
15:55 A district zoning amendment was approved to amend the CSP to establish interim development standards for phase one of this Clearwater specific plan development. The interim development standards accommodate a less intensive expansion and upgrade of the existing hotel, restaurant, and public spaces than was originally envisioned by the Old Mammoth Place entitlements and the CSP.
16:26 The Planning and Economic Development Commission later approved the major design review in February of 2022, and this was for the phase one project consisting of interior and exterior improvements to the existing 149-unit hotel and rafters restaurant.
16:49 As well as construction of 30 new resort cabin units, including five fourplex structures, which are referred to as villas. An expanded event space was included and added pedestrian amenities along Old Mammoth Road. The project also includes seven on-site affordable housing units located within an existing spa building that was converted to that use.
17:15 Construction of the approved project began in April of 2022. It is nearing completion. There are several final requirements and conditions of approval that have yet to be satisfied and are required to be satisfied before a final certificate of occupancy can be issued. So the most recent background information for this property
17:43 Includes in 2023, temporary certificate of occupancy was issued for the project subject to a compliance agreement with the building division. And in 2024, construction of the phase one CSP project, like I said, is nearing completion before a final certificate of occupancy can be issued. So the current proposed project
18:11 Proposes to convert 20 existing hotel accommodation units that are located within the five fourplex structure referred to as villas into condominium hotel units that could be sold individually. The required applications to accomplish the proposed project include the district zoning amendment. This is necessary to amend the phase one clear water specific plan to modify the permitted uses.
18:40 by adding condominium hotel uses that would be subject to a use permit and subdivision map approval. The proposed DZA language includes a definition for condominium hotel units. It adds additional development and operating standards that would be applicable to condominium hotel uses and adds
19:04 Sorry, removes language that previously excluded condominium hotel units from the amended Phase I Clearwater Specific Plan. Additional minor text revisions were included in the proposed amendment to provide clarity for the reader. A use permit is also required. It's required in order to approve a condominium hotel use within the
19:30 original Clearwater Specific Plan, so we included this for this proposed amendment, and this allows the town to require conditions of approval for the proposed use, such as minimum operating standards and occupancy requirements. A tentative tract map is included to subdivide the 20 units for condominium hotel purposes, and the proposed lot configuration creates a separate condominium owners association within lot one,
20:01 Shown in this figure. And this creates a owner, sorry, a lot one for the proposed condominium hotel component, plus the remainder lot, which is the resort owner lot. And this would include required easements that are noted for shared access, parking, snow storage, trash enclosures, utilities, and other shared facilities.
20:32 Final easement language and configuration of these easements would be completed through a reciprocal easement agreement, which is subject to review and approval by town staff prior to the final map approval. Since the proposed project involves a change in use rather than a new development, the analysis of the project is focused on the consistency with the Clearwater Specific Plan as well as the general plan land use designation.
21:04 There are three land use designations identified within the Clearwater Specific Plan, which are depicted at the right. The proposed outbound villas subdivision for condominium hotel purposes is located within land use area two, as shown here in pink. This area is designated for condominium hotel units and is described within the Clearwater Specific Plan as a building or combination of buildings.
21:32 that function as a hotel with privately held condominium hotel units or traditional hotel units. And consistency with the Clearwater Specific Plan includes that the proposed subsequent amendment to the amended Phase 1 Clearwater Specific Plan uphold the overall intent and goals of the original CSP and the amended Phase 1 CSP.
21:57 Condominium hotel uses are permitted within the Clearwater Specific Plan and therefore conversion of the villa structures to condominium hotel units will comply with the permitted uses in the CSP as well as the conceptual land use diagram for that.
22:15 And this slide is really just showing a side-by-side comparison of the site development as it sits today, along with the land use map designated by the Clearwater Specific Plan. So required findings for approval for the proposed district zoning amendment include findings that the amendment is consistent with, sorry,
22:48 The findings for approval require that the commission make findings that the district zoning amendment is consistent with the municipal code and can the findings be made for approval of a use permit pursuant to the municipal code and if the findings can be made for approval of a tentative tract map pursuant to the state subdivision map act.
23:14 And finally, if the proposed project is consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act. Through the review of this project, the application was routed to the Mammoth Community Water District, the Fire Protection District, and internal town departments. The conditions of approval that are included with the draft PEDC resolution require compliance with all of the applicable local agency requirements.
23:46 Staff did receive one email indicating that a public comment would be sent prior to the last public hearing, and that comment was distributed to the commission for review. Staff did have a chance to meet with the commenter after that hearing. We met in December and provided clarification on some of the issues that were raised, such as whether there was a DA.
24:17 applicable to the property, which is not the case. There was not a DA adopted for the site, as well as parking requirements and setback requirements. I know that that commenter was appreciative of meeting with staff about those items. We did receive a second public comment a couple days ago on Monday, and some of the issues raised in that public comment letter included access to the site,
24:46 which the commentator preferred access to be limited to Laurel Mountain because of traffic concerns. The CEQA document that was prepared found that the traffic impacts from the larger project proposed for the site would not result in a negative impact to the surrounding community. So staff does not feel that the proposed access is going to
25:15 contribute to any additional traffic for the Sierra Nevada Road access location. I think that's pretty much it for the public comments at this point. And with that, staff was able to make affirmative findings for approval of the application. And we would recommend that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached resolution.
25:43 Making the required CEQA and municipal findings and recommending to town council approval of district zoning amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004 and tentative tract map 24-003 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications by the commission. Thank you, Kim. I am going to ask the applicant or the representatives of the applicant to make a statement at the podium.
26:13 But if anyone has any questions of staff that they want to ask now, please feel free. We definitely will come back to Q&A between the staff and the applicant, so you will have another opportunity. But if anyone has a question to Kim or Nolan on the staff report right now, feel free to ask it. Good. Then I will ask the representatives of the applicant if they'd like to make a statement.
26:48 Thanks, Chairman Vanderhurst and Planning Commission. Thanks, Nolan. And your team have been great to work with throughout this process. I don't necessarily want to get up here and, you know, rehash the last, you know, meeting, but I'm happy to give you any background, Commissioner Grand, to get you up to speed on the project, if that'd be helpful.
27:15 I definitely read the papers in the details prior to the previous meeting, so I'm very familiar with that, and I visited the site, so I personally don't have any questions. Okay. Any questions for the applicant from any of the other commissioners at this time? No? And I might ask you just to hang tight after I close public comment. Happy to. Jamie, do we have any public comment, either in suite Z?
27:45 or via Zoom at this time. If you do have public comment, please approach the podium. And nothing via Zoom. Can you state your name for the record? Sorry. Sorry, Matt Merring. So with that, I'll close public comment, and I'll bring it back up to the commission. Any questions for either Matt, who represents the applicant, or town staff on their presentation? I just have a couple of really quick clarifying questions, Kim.
28:21 So, this project will still meet its snow storage requirements, even with whatever we decide today, is that correct? That's correct. And how about the parking? I know we talked at length last month about there being a trigger that enacted a valet service, and there was some confusion as to whether the villa's occupants, their cars, would be subject to that valet system.
28:52 So what was your question, whether the parking would be impacted by the... The people who were staying at the villas, if... I can't remember what the occupancy threshold trigger point was. I think it was 70%. Am I corrected with that? Let me pull it up. I did have a... And I promise not to go ad nauseum like I did last time on this one. But I just... A clarifying statement as to the villa occupants would be subject...
29:23 to the valet system once it's been triggered. I think that is what I'm looking for. Yes or no. So that is correct. The parking management plan in place for the site would apply to the condominium units. The valet requirement is implemented at 83% hotel occupancy. And the requirement is that there would be three valet attendance for parking and retrieval.
29:52 Service is said to be complimentary for hotel and restaurant guests, and so the applicant can speak to what their intent is for the condominium units, but staff's requirement would be that the parking applicable to all of the condominium units, because they are located in the same parking lot, would also be a part of this parking management plan. That is correct, yeah, that's the intent. Okay, it'll be part of the plan.
30:22 Thank you for the clarification, both of you. With that, I'll go back up to the commission. Last chance, any questions or any opinions, any statements you'd like to make before we close this and go to a vote or possible motion? Anybody? Nope. Thank you, Matt. Appreciate it. Thank you. With that. Stay up here. You can grab a seat. Okay. Thank you. With that, I'll ask if anybody would like to put forth a motion at this point.
30:57 Kim, can you put it back up on the big screen, please? I can just read it. And I think we have it here. Yeah, I just didn't, I was just looking for it. Oh, this is just the agenda. Adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and recommending to the Town Council approval of District Zoning Amendment 24-001, use permit 24-004, and tentative tract map 24-003 as recommended by staff.
31:52 And you can say so moved. Thank you, Jamie. Does anyone want to make the first motion on that? I'll make a motion to accept. Do I have a second? Okay, any other comments, opinions before we go to vote? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Eckert? No. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 3-1. Thank you. Thank you for taking the time in person. Appreciate it. Good luck with your travels.
32:24 Andy, thank you for taking the time. Now we'll go to business matters. If someone could please let Commissioner Fleming know she can return to the dais. She went in the penalty box, but she went in the back way. Yeah. Okay. She's sitting in the bathroom. She might, yeah.
33:56 Nolan, do you want me to open this up and Gina can pop in when she gets here or would you rather have us wait? Okay. Good call. With that, we'll pause item 5.1 and we'll go to item 6, the consent agenda, which is 6.1, 6.2, 6.3. Would anybody like to pull one of these items off the consent agenda or would somebody like to make a motion to approve all three items on the consent agenda?
34:53 I'll make a motion to approve these. Consent agenda, all three items. Do I have a second? I'll second that. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Consent agenda approved 5-zip. Thank you for that suggestion, Jamie. Now we'll go backwards to business matter 5.1, which is the consideration of time extension request 24-003.
35:23 for a three-year time extension of the Terra Blanca Project Entitlement, which is located at 3789 Main Street, and I believe our staff contact is Gina. Thanks, Michael. One second. I'll be presenting the time extension request for Terra Blanca Project at 3789 Main Street.
36:17 In August 2024, staff reached out to the applicant and property owner to inform them that the two-year deadline for their entitlements, 43789, were about to expire in November of 2024. The applicant submitted a formal time extension request on November 7, 2024, requesting a three-year time extension for the project. The subject property is at 9.6.
36:42 0.96 acre parcel located at 3789 Main Street. The site was previously developed with a mixed use structure and surface parking lot known as Los Sierras. The current zoning designation is mixed lodging residential, which zoning code describes as an area intended to allow one or more of a variety of lodging residential and non-residential uses to encourage a mix of uses and emphasize transient occupancy.
37:10 The proposed 12-unit multifamily residential townhome development features four three-story triplex structures ranging in size from 10,571 square feet to 10,765 square feet. The project was approved on November 8, 2022 by the Planning Commission and since then the applicant has been working towards securing funding, restructuring the project management team and finding a contractor. However, construction has not started at this time.
37:42 So this is the site plan just to jog everyone's memory. The driveway comes right off of Main Street. And then here's some elevations to show the general aesthetic and architecture of the units. So the project meets the following findings pursuant to chapter 17.64.060, time limits and extensions. The applicant
38:18 has made a good faith effort to exercise the permit and comply with the conditions of approval in a timely manner. They've submitted a letter along with the time extension application which describes circumstances that have led to the delayed project execution. First, the applicant indicates that the project architect and a key development partner have left the project team which required significant adjustments to the project management and design approach.
38:48 The applicant further explains that their team is facing challenges in sourcing materials and is working to adjust the construction plans and material selection to increase the financial viability of the development. The applicant also states that finding a contractor willing to take on the development is increasingly difficult and suggests that the additional time may be necessary to ensure the project can be completed to a high standard of quality and safety.
39:16 The permit is still in compliance with the general plan, this chapter, and any applicable specific plans. The original conditions of approval have not been modified. No new conditions have been imposed. The plans remain the same. So everything else should not be affected. The original review authority will make
39:43 We'll make project-specific findings to support the decision. And then CEQA, since the project meets all the criteria pursuant to CEQA guidelines, section 15303, and no changes to the approved project have occurred, this time extension request is not subject to any additional environmental review. And so the recommended action to adopt the planning and economic...
40:12 Commission Resolution 205001, making the required CEQA municipal findings, approve the time extension request 24-003 for a three-year time extension. And that's it. Thank you, Gina. Do we have anybody in Suite Z or via Zoom who's representing the applicant? No? Yes, this is Chris Ford, and I believe Peter Dybich is also on as well. Yeah, Peter is here.
40:45 Yes, I'm here as well. Peter, would you like to make a statement? Well, not more than we're in the process of finding. We found a new contractor that we're talking to right now. We have a new architect on the team. We're currently looking for a project manager, I would say. And we'll see some movements here. We anticipate to see some movements here in the next couple of months. But it's been a challenging journey here with losing our...
41:13 Oh, I'm losing my partner, actually. Got it. Peter, would you mind staying on the line, just in case any commissioners have a question they'd like to throw your way? I'm on the line, yep. Thank you. I'll bring it back to the commission. Well, actually, I'll open up public comment. Do we have any public comment, Jamie, via Zoom or anybody in suite Z? Mr. Hodges, are you just here for the ride?
41:40 I'll close public comment and I'll throw it back up on the commission. Any questions for either Gina or Nolan on the staff side or Peter who is the applicant for this time extension request? I got one for staff. This is worded as three years but just the way the state law and everything works, am I correct that this is actually a four-year extension? The three that we're approving is subject to an automatic extension beyond that and if so for how long?
42:11 So the only automatic extension that would apply would be if they file and get their final map recorded, then they would be providing an additional year for the other entitlements on the project, so the design review component, but they're not provided just an automatic extension. In the past, there were a number of state automatic extensions, but those aren't applicable at the moment. Any other questions for staff or the applicant? Are we talking three-year extension from?
42:43 to complete the project or is it three-year extension to just start the project? So the three-year extension would be to have their final map submitted and deemed complete by the town and then ultimately record it or approved and recorded and then like I said then they are provided an additional year to pull their building permits to then commence the project upon that final map so the three years is really just for that.
43:10 The final map expiration, because they need that before they can pull building permits. Any follow-up questions? No? Commissioner Baruch? I just have a really quick question for the applicant, and feel free to say, I don't know, or I don't have an answer for that. In a perfect world, you get answers to all of the hurdles that you laid out in your letter requesting this extension. In a perfect world, what would be,
43:49 Your pace of progress in this development. Like, are you looking to break ground in 2025? Are you looking to, what would be the ideal scenario for you? I think the likelihood of breaking ground 2025, it's very slim, right? So I'm assuming as the snow melts 2020, what is it, 2026 would be the objective here. Okay.
44:20 So is there a reason you would not be able to break the break the ground in 2025? Sorry, I'm at the airport. We have to get all the plans in order. We have to get the team in order. And I just don't think that starting the project as the snow starts falling in the fall, it's a good approach. Any further questions for either staff or the applicant? No? With that, I'll throw it back up to the commission if anybody would like to make a motion.
45:05 Adopt the resolution making the required municipal code findings and approving time extension request 24-003 for a three-year extension of the Terra Blanca development entitlement TER22-003 and DR22-002 with conditions as recommended by staff. All the above, but I'd also like to add a condition that this is for one year or not. Is that something we can amend, Nolan, to your knowledge? Yes, it is.
45:43 Okay. Okay. Does anyone want to make a second on the proposed motion with the amendment or would somebody like to make a fresh motion? Either one, I'm listening. I second the commissioner. Okay. So we have a motion that's been seconded with the amendment adjusting the extension from three years to one year. Can I say something here, Ms. Bitter? Please. I think we're just making it extremely difficult for us because we're going to
46:21 We might sit here a year from now and ask me for another extension. At least give us two years. That's what I would suggest. I would prefer three, of course, but just putting in an additional stress on the project. And it comes to, you know, we could have started this project. We would have gone with a contractor that has been offering us. You know, we have had developers interested in the project. I just haven't felt good.
46:49 Thank you, Peter.
47:20 With that, we do have a motion that's been seconded with an amendment. I'm going to put it forward for a vote. And if it doesn't pass, then we can talk about another motion. May I make, to be clear, the applicant could have asked for a six-year extension. Is that correct? That is correct. The Subdivision Map Act and the Municipal Code allows for up to a six-year extension request. Okay.
47:50 I would like to make a motion to go back to the original recommended motion. We already have a motion and a second, so we have to vote on it. We have to vote on it. Okay. After that, if it fails, then you can make another motion. Got it. Okay. Is that clear to everyone? Clear to everyone? Mm-hmm. Okay. With that, Jamie, please put it to a vote. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Fleming? No. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? No. Chair Vanderhurst? No.
48:20 Motion fails. Motion fails 3-2. So now I'll put it back to the commission. Would somebody like to put forth an alternative motion? I would like to make a motion, the recommended motion to adopt the resolution. Do I need to read the whole thing as written? Or do you want me to read it? So this is the motion that is in the staff report that you read out about five minutes ago, correct, Jamie? Yes. Okay. Does everyone understand the motion?
48:51 that Commissioner Verruck has put forth? Yes. Can I get a second on that motion, please? Second. We have a second. Any further conversation, opinion, questions from the commission? No? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Eckert? No. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? No. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Motion passes 3-2. Thank you. Thank you, Gina.
49:21 Thank you, Peter, for making the chance or making the time to call in from the airport. Safe travels. Thank you. So we have already done the consent agenda, so now we'll move on to Commissioner Reports, and I'll start on my far left. Commissioner Grand, do you have a report you'd like to put forth? I do not, thank you so much, Michael. Commissioner Verruck? No, I don't have any reports. Okay. Commissioner Fleming? No reports. Okay. Commissioner Eckert?
49:54 Well, normally I'm the first one to want to get out of here. But that's basically my time has come here. I've been out of town a lot and going back and forth. And I just wanted to put forward that I will be resigning from the commission, put it 30, 90 days, whatever it takes for the town council to go through their procedures and search and whatever. First of all, I'd like to thank the staff.
50:23 You guys put up with a lot of crap that you don't deserve. And a lot of people don't understand that. There's so many rules and regulations that make absolutely no sense that override all of this that you've got a really tough job and you do a really good job of it. I'd also like to thank my fellow commissioners and also the commissioners that have been on here going back to Roy Sari. It'd be nice if we had more people step up.
50:53 There's a whole lot of people out there in their 30s and 50s that should really get involved at some point in this government, and this one isn't that tough, you know, it's a meeting a month, a couple of hearings, but somebody's got to do it, and it should be you, whoever you are. So, anyway, that's my spiel, and like I said, 30, 90 days, whatever it takes.
51:22 I would just like to publicly thank Commissioner Eckert for his time and everything, his intimate knowledge of Mammoth Lakes that you've brought to every meeting. I have found just working with you the last few years that you bring insight that isn't necessarily being talked about from the business community to this commission and to our decisions and our conversations. So huge thanks for
51:50 All the time you took and put into this, and I wish you nothing but the best. Thank you. And with that, I'll go ahead and bypass my commission report and pass it off to Nolan here for director's report. Great. I want to echo Chair Van Hur's comments. Commissioner Eckert, we appreciate your time that you've served here. I just looked it up. You've been on the commission for about seven and a half years, so it's greatly appreciated with your service to...
52:22 The town here. And then on other director update items. The only one I really wanted to highlight is shortly after the December commission meeting, we got word for the parcel that the first phase is 100% full as of mid-December. So it took approximately about three months to fully lease up that project from when they received occupancy to when they were completely full for the 81 units. So definitely a big milestone was.
52:52 achieved there in December. Fantastic. That's it. That concludes your director's report. And we got one other that just came through. I was waiting for an update on Mammoth Creek Inn. That they have been still working on the project throughout the winter. Previous to winter, they did complete their driveway and parking areas, but they have not been striped or inspected, so that will hold up occupancy until the snow is cleared. And then
53:25 They've largely completed the majority of their inspections, so they are slowly moving towards completion of that project. It has been a long time coming, and they do continue to at least meet the required milestones from the building division for inspections to keep the project alive and moving towards completion, which is really our desire for that project. Quick.
53:54 Aesthetic question on the Mammoth Creek Inn Extension Project. The back of those buildings, which face the cast-off kind of back door, the windows into the stairwells seem to be open to the elements. Is that on purpose? I'm going to have to go back and look at the design. It's been a number of years. That project, I think, was one of my first projects. Actually, I worked on, like, 2014. So I can follow up with you on that item.
54:24 Okay. Yeah, it will be nice when there's a day when this is no longer talked about because it's been completed in a satisfactory manner. But until that time, Nolan, would you please automatically include updates on this project for your director's report? I think it's very important that this builder knows that this commission has eyes on that project. Definitely. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate it.
54:51 All right, with that, I will adjourn today's meeting until our next regularly planned meeting, which will be on March 12th, 2025, here in Suite Z at 9 a.m. And as of now, the only agenda item for that meeting that we know of is Snow Creek 7 and 8, correct? The development agreement for Snow Creek 7 and 8. The DEA, right. Okay, well, thank you, everyone, for coming. Appreciate it. Thank you. Have a good day. Good luck tomorrow.