TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2024

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

188 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:59 One of the things that I'm really starting to have issues with is the local business community not having the time to get up and stand up for themselves and speak for themselves. That's not the business world in Mammoth that I was raised with. But they can just say...

1:44 I answer every email I get unless it's about golf. Then I might not have time. I haven't heard anybody in the last 15 minutes. Yeah. She has a meeting that's running over. We have one more minute. Who wants to do a pledge today? I'll do it. Okay, John.

2:51 I will now call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, September 18th at 4 o'clock, straight up. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubser? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. Pledge of Allegiance. John, would you lead us in the pledge? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag.

3:21 And I thank you all. Public comments. Now is the time for any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that does not otherwise appear on tonight's agenda.

3:45 Good afternoon, Mayor, Councilmembers and Town Staff. I'm Brianna Goyko with the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I wanted to speak before you and just highlight a few things that have been going on with our organization. The Business Excellence Awards we've been working on for a few weeks now. We just finalized our list of finalists. So we have eight different categories, three finalists per category. So excited to honor and celebrate a lot of top-performing businesses and people in our community. So that'll be open to our chamber members.

4:14 Thank you so much.

4:31 Later tonight. And then we are, I think I've mentioned a few times our career compass program. So we'll be doing a career expo at the school. We're taking over one of the days at the school during their homecoming week. Hopefully people will be semi-focused. But we're excited to host this with the school and we'll be bringing in.

4:52 People, business, businesses and people from the business community to speak to students throughout the day. We will be doing some mock interviews. We're figuring out exactly what that looks like, but trying to practice interviewing skills with our young people there. And so we're really looking forward to this day. Right now we're looking for professionals.

5:15 Town staff, people in our community to speak to the students, and then also still looking for volunteers to help with those mock interviews with the students. So this is going to be taking place on October 22nd. And let me see if there were any other details. If anyone listening is interested, anyone here, please reach out to us, mammothlakeschamber.org. And with that, I think that's my report. Thank you. Thank you very much.

5:45 Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers and staff. My name is Josh Taylor. I'm with the Western States Regional Council of Carpenters, and I represent thousands of contractors throughout California. And I'm here tonight, myself personally, I've got about 20 years of experience in the construction and development industry. So I'm here tonight to speak about the labor concerns that I have for the Mammoth Main Lodge project. I know it's not on your agenda tonight.

6:09 But I wanted to talk about developers and their common practices. It's very common for developers, their marketing tactics to suggest that projects will bring some benefit to the community. And surely this project will add some benefit to the community. And I expect that you'll hear some things about the improved tourism from the developer, the increased hospitality and residential access.

6:29 And I expect that you'll hear that this project would improve the economic stability of the local economy. All of those things sound great. The concern that I have here is for the community is such that although these benefits that I just mentioned may in fact come to fruition through the project approval, with the generational wealth that this is going to create for Altera and the private investors, what isn't the community being offered as a byproduct to the extreme profitability your board has the potential to allow through approval?

6:54 Let's take a look at Mammoth Lakes, its residents, workers, and community members, many who wear multiple hats, do largely in part to the cost of living and limited full-time job opportunities. I see something missing from the equation here that the town has a real opportunity to capture. This town is growing, and in turn, there are a lot of construction jobs being performed by contractors and workers. One major problem is that many of the workers are coming from afar and outside the community. So how beneficial would it be to hold the developer accountable to creating well-paying jobs, not only in the permanent jobs once the facilities are complete,

7:23 But also in the multi-years and phases of construction to get it to completion. So what I'm proposing here is that your board hold the developer accountable to a higher standard than basic approval process. And in turn, how your board shapes the approval expectations can offer tremendous benefit to residents, constituents, and the like. The key to this is that my organization works with town, cities, and community leadership to maximize the benefits to community via accountability held to the developer who will gain generational wealth from their endeavors.

7:51 The best part of this is it's super easy and it's not a burden to the town and it won't require much from your board and team.

7:57 I'd like to work with you to help shape holding the developer to a higher standard, and I'd like to speak with you all in more detail at your availability. My question to you is would you like to know more about how we can help maximize the benefits? So what I'd like to do is leave some business cards with the clerk and let you know that I'd be reaching out to continue this discussion. I look forward to you being able to maximize these community benefits through this project application. Thank you. Any further public comments? Seeing none. Oh, I have a...

8:32 Okay. Okay. So, Rob and maybe Andy, but I think this is mostly for Rob. Last week in the paper, someone published a full-page ad that gave a strong implication that the TOT measure that's being put on the ballot would be used for the Civic Center project.

8:58 So I guess they weren't paying attention to the many, many discussions we had here in Council about that project and also that we had a $29 million bond sale in the spring specifically for these kinds of capital projects, which are different funds. So I was just hoping you could clarify that because I wouldn't want our community to have the wrong understanding of this funding mechanism.

9:27 Yeah, so with our project for the Civic Center, we did go out and receive a bond, pursued that process to receive a bond. What was critical for us to do is to ensure that the bond repayment, you know, is when you get a bond, you have to repay it over a certain number of years, interest and so forth.

9:52 That that debt service payment would not increase our annual operating expense in any way, shape, or form. So my predecessor, Dan Holler, really outlined a way of taking our existing debt, looking at how the timing of that debt comes offline, holding those money still in our general fund debt service account, and allowing for the full payment.

10:19 We have those monies been holding aside.

10:48 Bond judgment payments that we did a few years ago in 2017. We restructured that debt and have paid that down considerably. But we had a delta between the $2 million we were paying on that and the $1.86 that we pay annually. We're keeping those monies in that same fund. And then finally we had the police building. So the police facility as part of this transaction has been paid off.

11:13 The $315,000 annual debt service is available to be reallocated. So when you add all that stuff together, the cost of this bond has been structured in such a way to not impact us whatsoever. And so when you do go out and bond something, you are, you know, leveraging your ability to get something achieved. In that debt service was certainly funding for the Civic Center, but we also had money set aside for the purchase of the foundation property, that $4.5 million, which will produce the MAC.

11:43 Which is also producing, you know, the sixth classroom child care, the dog park, the other things that we're putting on that. So a lot of benefit from that activity. Thank you. Mr. Mayor Sauser, there are no additions to the agenda. Thank you very much. Moving on to presentations. 5.1, approve the proclamation declaring September 17 to 23 as constitution. I will read this proclamation.

12:22 Proclamation of Town Council, Town Manager, Lake State of California declared September 17, 2023 constitutionally whereas September 17, 2024 marks the 237th anniversary of the drafting of the Constitution of the United States of America by the Constitutional Convention and whereas it is fitting and appropriate to a court official recognition to this magnificent document and its memorable anniversary and

12:53 Whereas Public Law 915 guarantees the issuing of a proclamation each year by the President of the United States of America designating September 17 through 23 as Constitution Week.

13:05 Therefore, be it resolved by the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lake, State of California, that September 17 to 23, 2024, is recognized as Constitution Week in the Town of Mammoth Lakes and urges all citizens to study the Constitution and reflect on the privilege of being an American with all the rights and responsibilities which that privilege involves. I would now entertain any deliberation or emotion.

13:35 Mr. Mayor, I would so move that the town council approve and adopt the resolution as you so eloquently read. Thank you. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Approved for zero. And I understand we have Carrie with us to receive this.

14:05 6.1 Introduce new airport maintenance coordinator.

15:17 Graham, I'm not going to try to pronounce it. Sabine, you're going to do the introductions here. Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Council, fellow staff members. I'm Sabine Spring, the Airport Operations Manager. And I'm here tonight to introduce our new Airport Maintenance Coordinator, Graham Aitkenhead. This is Graham. He is, he's,

15:47 Come to us from the Santa Barbara area. He is currently facing Finding Housing, which is a rite of passage that we're really grateful that he's willing to endure to be part of the airport team. He has a background in pretty much everything that we do, including attending a high school next to an airport. And what did you call it? The Point Loma Pause, where the teacher would pause.

16:16 In her lecture as the airplane flew over and then keep on going. We're very happy to have him as part of our crew and looking forward to seeing how he grows with us at the airport. And I would also like to mention that today is the one-year anniversary of Brandon Rohr's coming on our crew.

16:42 He's in the back there and we're really happy that he's growing and expanding and contributing to the airport with us. Thank you. Graham Aitkenhead for wanting to know how to pronounce it. Thank you guys for the opportunity and look forward to learning all the stuff about the airport in many years to come. Thank you very much. Welcome aboard.

17:31 Okay, moving on to staff presentation 7.1, Housing Now program update. Nolan. Okay, so this is the Housing Now update for the September 18, 2024 meeting. This update, we will just be focusing on three current projects of the Housing Now program. That's the Lease to Locals program, the 60 Joaquin small site development.

18:18 And then kind of daylighting what we're working on with parcel phase three, the ownership phase. So in the lease to locals program, on the left is just a snapshot of the ongoing activity that placemates has as far as their interaction with potential property owners. The one area to kind of highlight new leads continue to drop down, that's because

18:44 New leads only stay in that category until they've reached out to people and then they fall into one of the other categories of really particular interest is those who are interested and future interests represent about 15 property owners who are evaluating the program and whether they how they want to proceed.

19:05 Then of the searching for tenants, there's currently two property owners who have properties registered that are then searching for a tenant to match with their properties. One area to note is on the application review. You can see in the yellow versus blue.

19:24 Here on the screen, it went down and that's because there was a successful lease that occurred in the last week so that one property has now been leased up through the program and that the check request has been submitted to finance to provide that initial payment to that property owner.

19:43 So that is a win that we do have a property there. The other property that's in application review, they're just waiting on some, the final lease agreement to be provided by that property owner and then move that one forward to the approval stage. One other I did want to highlight is on the not qualified category. Within the not qualified, the reasons that have come up are either the properties outside the

20:11 Urban Growth Boundary of the Town. The price exceeds the rent cap. It's an unpermitted property type, meaning it's a triplex or a fourplex or something larger, or it's an existing long-term rental. The existing long-term rental one is of interest since that was a...

20:27 A big kind of discussion point when we're discussing the guidelines for the program. And of note here, if we had allowed existing long-term rentals to participate in the program, then that would have been 12 properties that are already renting to locals that would have received a subsidy. So it wouldn't be unlocking new housing. It would just be kind of...

20:49 Maintaining the status quo for those already that are already renting long-term, which really isn't the goal of the program since the goal is to create new long-term rentals in the community. Jumping over to the 60 Joaquin project, some pretty exciting progress has happened in the last moment. Can I ask you a question on the lease to locals? Yes. How many...

21:10 I guess, what's our goal? You know, we have about $300,000. If that's divided by $18,000, potentially, what are we aiming for? The budget that they kind of laid out for us initially, because not every property would get the $18,000, because that would mean that every property had four qualified tenants and that they do a year lease. With their breakdown, they kind of provided during the presentations and discussions with council, the goal was approximately 41 properties.

21:41 With that $325,000 that was available for the subsidies. Thank you. When does the current agreement expire? It would be in July of 25. So jumping to the 60 Joaquin Small Site Development Project. On the screen here we have a photo from kind of the beginning of September, so September 6th. So about, you know, two weeks ago, which all you see is the foundations. Jumping forward to September 11th.

22:16 We have the initial modules coming in. So what's shown here is the ground floor of one of the four units, the garage coming in. And then jumping to the next day, September 12th, you have all the modules in place and the structures looking more or less like they're going to look once the siding and finishes go on. So it's really, I think, highlighting the speed with which modules can...

22:45 be placed on site and go from just a foundation to essentially the vertical construction in a matter of what is that about a week really from foundation to this and then they're currently working out there on site working on the exterior finishes as well as the interior connections and the other the other items that have to be completed on site so that works ongoing they are still targeting a completion date of probably early

23:14 Early to spring of 2025 is kind of our goal with where we'll see this project being completed. Nolan, could you talk a little bit about the intent of the project, meaning these are for sale units and how the amount of subsidy roughly, the AMI roughly, and then what will happen with the funds that are received from the proceeds of the sale?

23:38 Sure. So these will be for sale units, meaning we'll sell them with a deed restriction in place, ensuring that the units remain as affordable units for the target household, really, for a minimum 55-year term. However, that term renews at every sale.

23:56 In theory, our goal is to have them in perpetuity. The target AMI, or area median income for these units, is the 150% mark, so really targeting that missing middle, since it is all town funds going into the project. The goal will be a for sale price of approximately $500,000 with these units, which equates to about $175,000 subsidy.

24:18 Then so that roughly two million dollars from the sale of the four units would get reinvested back into the Housing Now program to then be used for future projects. I just wanted to highlight that because as you know with our Housing Now initiatives and the multifaceted approach the small site development is something that we see opportunity in and the town has been acquiring land for this very purpose and so there's some scalability to what we're doing with this. We may engage some of this on parcel phase three.

24:49 We also have other lands we've acquired within town that we can take this same approach and deliver it on that. And that just providing for, you know, currently it's all general fund dollars associated with this. So it has that freedom to go to that middle income status. So really a broad breadth approach. I just wanted to highlight that for people that may not be familiar with our program. Robert Nolan, how I'm assuming condo-like there will be a homeowner association even though there's only four units.

25:19 That's correct. So they're a PUD, meaning they'll own the land and then the kind of vertical structure above it. But there will be an HOA with CC&Rs for the complex. Have we done any research into what we believe those fees may well be? So right now the draft budget we got, I want to say, is around $6.50 a month for snow removal, insurance, trash, water.

25:45 And then the exterior maintenance on those. We have a meeting set up with the developer to really review the budget in detail to see if there's other areas that can be addressed or adjusted. And that, I said earlier, the $500,000 affordable price, that did include that HOA budget as built into that to make sure it's affordable to that 150% AMI group. Thank you. Any other questions on that one?

26:12 Just an observation. Chris, back to your question about that anonymous advertisement in the newspaper. This is exactly the type of project that something like Measure L would benefit. Not state money, general fund, not restricted. We can set the AMI level where we want. Part of the whole complement of the Housing Now program, that's fair to say, I'm assuming. Absolutely. Okay. Thank you.

26:39 All right, so moving on to the parcel phase three. So at this stage, we've received kind of two concept plans that we've provided feedback to the developer on. In this case, the developer is a group, the opinion group. They're working with Pacific on just this specific phase of the development. The main thing is Pacific West has experience in.

27:05 Tax credit housing and large-scale rental housing without necessarily expertise in ownership housing. So that's where they've brought in the opinion group to assist them with this phase. So the initial concepts that they've proposed, the two different concepts have either 42 dwelling units or 41 dwelling units that they've proposed with the main difference being up in this

27:32 Northeast corner of the site here as to what that kind of layout looks like, whether it be what they proposed was a sixplex facing into kind of a cul-de-sac design or a fiveplex that directly faces the road here. These will be considered what's called row houses, so they're essentially single-family homes, but then do have a connection to give them the appearance of a sixplex.

28:01 So similar to 60 Joaquin, they will be a PUD style of ownership, meaning the owner will own the land plus the structure above. There's kind of ongoing conversations as far as the ownership and how the funding will come in place for the road and other kind of circulation elements of it, whether it becomes a public road, which then would allow some IIG funding to go into it, whereas if it's part of the development, then it would be a private road.

28:30 Controlled by the HOA or common areas. So there's ongoing discussions related to that and ongoing discussions. What's not shown on these kind of conceptual site plans is there are the inclusion of MUPS or multi-use pass along this road. So it would come there's enough right-of-way here along the east side of this section as well as along this connection. So then it'll connect over to Chaparral.

28:56 on the side as well as Tavern on the north side just to provide additional connectivity through the site. The one area where staff continues to kind of focus our efforts and what that development might look like is really in that northeast corner. So on the screen here is just a concept that Amy Callanan put together which takes the 60 Joaquin building footprints and puts them on the site just to see how they would fit within the site.

29:25 The goal of providing a buffer with the development scale between the adjacent single-family residential as you step to the more denser central area of the parcel, which was really one of the kind of visions and key focus areas of the master plan was to have that kind of stepped as far as the density goes. So this just is another kind of iteration of what could fit there. This is a cul-de-sac design with...

29:53 With eight units around that cul-de-sac and these would in this case be the same size as the 60 Joaquin project. So that's kind of about where we're at with the parcel as far as next steps and the development of it. This would again require the town.

30:12 Commit to a subsidy really on the front end is to bring the price down to what would be affordable for the future households. Initially the developer was coming in asking for a subsidy in the three to three hundred fifty thousand dollar range per unit which we said was way too high since we can build units at a hundred fifty thousand dollar subsidy range so we really said go back and come back with a product that fits that model.

30:37 Which is what they've done here. They've indicated to us we haven't seen the pro forma or the detailed floor plans yet, but they've indicated that what they're proposing fits within that kind of subsidy range. And so we then gave them the go ahead to kind of do the next step on the schematic design step so we can really get something that's more of a final site plan to start bringing forward and reviewing.

31:01 Just want to add some components to that. When we talk about this particular ownership phase, when you look at the other six phases of the parcel, they're all heavily subsidized by either state or federal funding, state funding for the units that are developed, and that's why those AMI rates are so restricted, and we talked about that at the last update. These would be funded from general fund, very similar to the 60 Joaquin project.

31:30 So as Nolan indicated, and I'm really proud of the staff for actually working through this with the developer, is the initial request was almost $16 million of general fund money just for this particular project, these 42 units. And so that's just something we could not do at all. And going back, working through that, not only the subsidy level.

31:53 But the overall design of the project and the design and look at the buildings, that was a lot of heavy lifting by staff to get to that point. And frankly, listening by the developer, right? They understood what we were trying to achieve and they came back, at least in this phase, with a good project. So we're still working through that. We wanted to bring it forward to council so you guys could see the progress that's being made on this. There'll be subsequent...

32:17 Discussions to bring this forward, but I think, Nolan, this is something that could, as long as the funding is provided, could start very, very quickly. Correct. The developer has indicated that they could be ready as soon as next spring to start grading and site work on it. And it's really, I think, up to us and the developer to work through that final schedule and make sure the entitlements and that.

32:42 The town is happy with the design going forward and that we are comfortable with what they want to build. And that includes the Housing Now update. If there's any questions from council or the public on the item. My only question on the last piece where we were looking at the Joaquin style and the cul-de-sac, since we know what our subsidy was on that project, I'm assuming it would be similar on this for that style.

33:18 That would be the hope, yes. Any other questions? I don't have any questions, but I just really want to take a moment and thank the team. You know, I talk to a lot of colleagues all over the state who are really frustrated trying to build housing for their community or find housing or make it possible.

33:45 You know, I know that the team's been working on this for a long time, long before I was sitting up here. But it's coming to fruition. You know, the first phase of the parcel will be fully occupied very soon. Now we, Council Member Ray, I just want to share this because you walked in right after Nolan said it, or shortly after, the first placemate contract is signed and people are moving in and the second one is happening.

34:14 You know, we know that our funding could provide for up to 40 households, 40, 41 households to be housed. It's working. And I want to thank Brianna and the chamber for bringing that program to us. You know, when communities come together and put their focus on something and fund it, then people get housed.

34:38 You know, the other thing is the 60 Joaquin Project, which I haven't gotten to see in person, but I saw the photos of. It's happening. And so I just want to take a minute. I wish we had champagne because I really wanted that first placemate. I've been asking poor Rob every day. I'm like, do we have one yet? Do we have one yet? Because once you show people what's possible, then...

35:00 The other thing I wanted to mention was we can't talk about this enough as staff and counsel because a friend of mine

35:11 Who has a little kid said, I saw pictures of the new playground at the parcel. Is that, can anyone go there? I'm like, yes, we built it for our community. So please, it's an amazing facility, but so is the new playground at the CRC. So yes, it's been a long time coming. Yes, we've, you know, been through a lot to get here, but I just want to make sure everyone understands that.

35:36 Every person sitting along the wall, every staff member, everybody who had the courage to buy the land almost 10 years ago now in the parcel really deserves our gratitude. And I just wanted to say that. Thanks. Thank you. Any public comment on this issue? Jamie, anything online? Okay. I have a couple of questions, Amanda. Do you have any else? Okay.

36:07 I'm sorry, thank you. A couple of just some high-level questions. You mentioned the MUP, Nolan. There is a MUP kind of circulation plan for the whole project, right? That's correct. So there's already obviously the existing sidewalks and MUPs that have been put in on all the main roads, so Chaparral, Inyo, and Tavern Road.

36:29 So this would be a connection that would connect to those to provide additional connectivity. And then within each kind of subsequent phase, there's ongoing MUPS that provide additional connectivity. Okay. I think also to the point about the success of this, is it, I think, I don't know if you're all hearing this, I'm hearing this kind of repeated refrain, well, it's great, but I can't, I can't, I don't qualify to live in the parcel.

36:53 And I think it's going to be really important to be emphasizing the Housing Now program and all the various components of it so the public doesn't start saying, well, yeah, you built this beautiful thing, but no one can live in it. I'm just hearing that, and that's something to be thinking about. Another point of decision is having to do with the parking. We made some decisions about, well, this is going to be parking that at some point could turn into housing.

37:22 And I just wonder at what point staff anticipates we have to start making those kinds of decisions. Maybe not anytime soon, but we don't want to ignore that because in the walk, bike, ride plan, there's these very ambitious ideas about putting the remote parking, you know, structures or just a place to park things so that we can get more housing. Do we need to, is that soon or is that down the road? So we heard you.

37:46 I think it was last meeting when you brought that fact up. And so as we have these Housing Now initiative updates every town council meeting, I think that's planned for the next meeting to talk about the show you on a schematic where that parking lot is laid out, how it fits in with the existing mobility of the site.

38:08 And it's how centrally located it is. So there was some continuing conversations on that in a similar update process. Yeah, it's just those are decisions. We're going to have to make some choices about that. And finally, just your point, Chris, also about, I mean, MLT is telling the world what we're doing here. And no one else is doing stuff like this. So, Chris, your words are, you know, well-founded and well-deserved. But this is, we should all be aware of kind of the unique work we're doing with housing in the mountain community that

38:38 People can't afford to live in anymore, so it's a good thing. So thank you. It is. And as for the question of whether people can qualify to move in there or not, a lot of these people are moving out of other places, which will make them available for the people who don't qualify. So it's a well-rounded, well-thought-out program, the Housing Now in its totality. I could not be more proud of it.

39:02 And I do just want to say one thing, Council Member Wentworth, you know, you said that people are saying no one can live there, and I just want to correct everyone and remind them that it will be fully

39:12 For sure. And we'll be having, yeah, so I'll leave it at that, but I did,

39:41 There was one other thing you said that I wanted to make sure we clarified. Well, if it comes to me, I'll say it at the end. Thank you. Okay, very good. Moving on now to reports from commissions and or departments. We have no writtens. Do we have orals? Good afternoon, Council. I'm Sierra Waugh with Mammoth Yosemite Airport, and I just have a few updates for you guys tonight.

40:15 The first is that we will be hosting a co-hosting a chamber of commerce business after hours at the airport. We'll be co-hosting it with Hawk Creek Aviation and that'll be on October 29th. So that will be in the terminal located at the airport. We hope some of you may be able to participate and other members of the public as well. So additional information will be.

40:43 Provided soon and you can find that also on the Chamber of Commerce website shortly.

40:49 The second update that I have is that our tri-annual full-scale emergency exercise is going to be next Saturday on September 28th. So I know Sabine's talked a bit about what that event is, and I just wanted to remind everyone that'll be occurring, and we're going to have some electronic messaging along the highway to try to keep people kind of moving and not stopping because it may be alarming to see all of the emergency vehicle.

41:16 Ashley Pierce, Ashley Pierce, She is the airport administrative analyst. So she's working with us right now for about a month, three days a week.

41:45 She has been in the Mammoth Area for about 13, 14 years. She has history at our airport. She's worked with Alaska Airlines. She's worked with Hawk Creek Aviation with Advanced Airline Operations and is currently working as the United.

42:02 Compliance Coordinator down in Bishop a couple days a week. So she knows airlines, she knows our airport, and we're very happy to have her. And she'll be assisting. So far, we've kind of been focusing on customer service and providing kind of better customer service to our users and information to tenants, as well as administrative kind of cleanup and compliance. So we're really happy to have her on board.

42:30 Hi, I'm Ashley, I just want to say thank you and I'm looking forward to the job. Any questions on any of those three? Nope, nope, we're good. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Hi, Ashley. Good evening, Council, Mayor Pro Tem, our Mayor, community, staff, Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation, PIO, just a few updates for the benefit of the community and Council this evening. Our big event this weekend, Mammoth Trail Fest.

43:08 So that begins on Friday. We have a few people running in the event here today, so good luck. That's sold out over 1,500 people, so a lot of runners. We've had bikers, now we're going to have the runners. So a few changes in town, so Canyon Boulevard will be closed between Hillside and Lake Mary Road. That's from Saturday 6 a.m. to 8.30, so that's the shorter closure on Saturday. Sunday from 6 a.m. to 11 a.m., so a little bit longer closure.

43:38 That's the larger race, that's the 26K, that's the live Eurovision event, so we're all fingers crossed for some blue sky. So big event, just a lot of coordination's been happening with a lot of our town staff, police, engineering team and so forth, and Tim, we have transit organised and so forth with Esther and the Mammoth and Mammoth Mountain, so pretty exciting event. So look forward to being there, watching that, watching the runners, running myself, thankfully.

44:07 September 24th, that's next Tuesday, that's the annual bike rodeo. So we do this each year in partnership with our police department as well. That's a minimum day, so it's 12.30 to 4 o'clock at Shady Rest Park. So we're back to bikes, we do the runners, we're back to bikes. So that's just kids on bikes all over the park. So a really fun event, a lot of education, information, a lot of fun to be had by all.

44:31 The other event coming up is October 3rd. Yesterday, another monumental day, we turned back on the chiller, so we're getting going, we're starting to cool the slab, we've got to clean it first. We have the crew from LA Kings coming up on Tuesday, Wednesday next week to help us make ice, paint lines, put logos in. Kings have a new logo, so we've got to put that on the ice as well, all over the building. So pretty excited about that.

44:58 The other event, October 3rd, which is at Thursday, is the first Winter Expo. So again, another really what we think value-driven community event. So if you want to come and learn all about what's happening this winter, not only from what the town is doing, but also what the community is doing and all our partners, please come by. It's from 5 to 8 p.m. Thursday, October 3rd. And that's going to be at LA Kings Ice over here at the CRC.

45:23 So we will have that new 50% discounted pass, which would be great. We have a new adult play pass we're rolling out as well, so look for that. And just a lot of information about our camps and programs and leagues this winter. And finally, commission now meets every second month, right, so six times a year. So we'll meet again on October 1st, and that's going to be Tuesday at 2.30. A couple of items there. We'll go through the LA Kings Ice Operating Plan.

45:53 We'll do the presentation for our spring-summer programs, how we did, what happened, who came, who didn't come, those type of things, how successful a lot of those camps were, some survey information, a lot of those feedback notes from our customers as well. We also have our fee schedule discussion that we talked about as well, so the Commission's going to start that discussion, getting ready in preparation for the Council workshop on the 20th of November, so we might have another.

46:21 Stab at that as well in November if they choose to have a special meeting. And then we have our first workshop coming up with Mammoth Lakes Recreation as well. So we'll be kind of establishing the agenda for that. So that's all I had, Mr. Mayor. Any questions you may have? Questions for Stu. I do have a question. Yes. Okay, so the ice is opening on the 3rd of October. Is it opening earlier to hockey kids or no? I've heard rumors. Yes. So as soon as it's ready, which we think will be that Monday. Okay.

46:51 Thank you. So we're trying to get L.A. King, sorry, the Bishop High School hockey team up as well as our local youth teams on the ice practicing by Monday, but that's going to be, you know, yeah, depending on how much ice we get laid down on those type of things. Okay, thank you. Fingers crossed, yeah, super exciting. Thank you, Stu. You're very welcome, thank you. Any other departments wishing to speak? Seeing none, we will move on to consent. I will read the items. 9-1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 4.

47:27 9-2, adopt the resolution authorizing the temporary closure of Canyon Boulevard for the Rebelle Raleigh Technical Vehicle Inspection on October 9. 9-3, authorize the contract for the design of airport taxi lane rehabilitation to Wood Rogers. 9-4, authorize Chaparral Road Extension subcontractor addition. 9-5, cancel the regularly scheduled town council meeting of October 16.

47:52 9-6, accept the project closeout report for the Main Street Landscaping Project, 9-7, accept check registers, 9-5-24 and 9-12-24. Does anyone want to pull anything from consent? Yeah, Mr. Mayor, I would like to have item 9.2 brought out. We have the founder of the Rebel Rally available on Zoom.

48:22 to provide just a bit of an update about what that program is and what it will mean for the community benefits. So if we can entertain that, I'd like to call that out so she can have some time to speak. We will pull 9.2. Before we get to that, I would entertain a motion then for the rest. I move that we approve the consent agenda, excluding item 9.2. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none. Jamie.

48:53 Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. 5-0 passes. Thank you. 9.2, Rob, we'll start with you and you can do the introductions. Yes, so we had some interest in providing the community with an opportunity to understand more about this program that will be essentially starting in the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

49:23 So we asked the founder, Emily Miller, to attend this evening. She so graciously accepted that. And so I'd like to turn it over to her to talk a little bit about this particular event and what it brings to our community.

49:39 Yes, thank you so much. Thank you, Mayor, Council, and staff. My name is Emily Miller. I am the founder and the rally director. The Rebel Rally is technically the longest competitive off-road rally in the United States today, and it just so happens to be for women. It is not a race for speed. These are not race cars. It is a competition for endurance and precision.

50:00 And precision driving. It is for stock manufacturing vehicles and not for race cars. It's 11-day event. And it starts in Mammoth for pre-tech, tech and welcome events. And then there are eight days of stages across California and Nevada. It covers every type of terrain, altitude and temperature, especially starting in Mammoth.

50:22 The unique thing about the Rebel is that there are no cell phones, no GPS, and no personal support crews, and no outside assistance. So it relies...

50:31 On traditional navigation. They can't even use their cell phones at night. They're locked up and sealed. It is a very, very challenging event, and it is very life-changing for those who participate. We are in our ninth year, and this is our second year in Mammoth. We also build three remote base camps across the desert in Nevada, and we finish right along the Mexico border. And it's...

50:57 Takes place in remote confidential locations and were permitted through a number of land management agencies through Department of Interior.

51:07 We started last year in Mammoth, and this is our ninth year of the rally. We have started also on the Hoover Dam. We have started six years in Lake Tahoe, and we came last year to Mammoth. A lot of us spend time in Mammoth. We're all fanatical skiers and mountain bikers and love Mammoth. It holds a special place for us, and you have incredible terrain here. And so we came last year to test it, and we had such a warm experience and such a...

51:36 It's a great level of service that we really want to come back. Our lodging location for Tech is the Village at Mammoth, and we work with the Village at Mammoth staff, and we also work with the resort. We are sold out. We have 67 teams, 134 competitors.

51:54 Also, our friends, families, and sponsors of the teams. I have 127 staff. About 60 staff will be on-site for tech inspection. And then also attending are a number of our partners. We have very strong partners, including some of our biggest are Toyota.

52:11 Ford, Yeti, Pirelli, and Jeep. For example, Toyota field seven teams of employees. They field 14 engineers for the specific purpose of developing leadership and teamwork skills through the rally's challenges.

52:26 We are partnered with Tread Lightly. We have all solar base camps. And we've worked unique to us in automotive as we've pioneered with our partner Renewable Innovations to rapid power electric vehicles with green hydrogen. For example, Rivian debuted their R1S truck when they launched it through the Rebell and have put in engineers and employees for four years as we've really developed the program for electric vehicles.

52:56 As an organization, we are a for-profit business, but we have a wing called Rebel Impact, and it is outlined extensively on our website at rebelrally.com. And so we're focused on supporting women's businesses and education efforts, credible nonprofits, and sustainability and responsible use. And we do that through financial giving and volunteerism. We work extensively with the land management agencies and companies on a number of special projects from Girls in STEM. This year we're doing some big projects.

53:25 We do projects with the wildlife refuges and education around that. And we give awards from $1,000 up to $10,000 to various nonprofits throughout the year. And we do that all throughout the year, not just once. We usually give at a minimum $30,000 plus in awards to special scholarships, et cetera.

53:48 Currently, we are looking at how we can support the community. It's been really fun to be in Mammoth and learn more about kind of what's going on in town and what the needs are. You know, I come from a small ski community, so I, you know, I understand some of the unique challenges that, you know, resort towns can have. And so our goal is to benefit the youth who need support of access to sports and recreation.

54:15 I have met with Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, just had initial talks to understand more of their needs. Just learning about the Parks and Rec scholarship programs, we plan to give to that. And then also, our teams don't get monetary prizes, but we give to teams nonprofits.

54:37 Monetary Awards, and they are listed on our website. For example, one team has already given to Mono County to the animal shelter pretty extensively when they learned about the needs of the local area because their selected nonprofit are...

54:56 Our animals. So we are really honored to be back in Mammoth and we're excited to potentially be able to move our tech inspection from a parking lot kind of pushed to the side where we were able to operate last year and to really involve more of the community this year in our activities. It is midweek. We come in midweek off season and we are out before a busy weekend.

55:23 So happy to answer any questions and really appreciate your time and consideration. Questions? Thank you, Rob. Thanks for pulling this. This is a great update. We look forward to meeting you and saying hi this weekend. And we love Nevada. And thank you for the contributions you may be making to some of our local nonprofits. And I look forward to saying hello and welcome. Thanks for coming back. All right. I hope everybody can join us. Thank you.

55:55 With that, I would entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve Item 9.2 to adopt the resolution authorizing the temporary closure of Canyon Boulevard for the Rebel Rally Technical Vehicle Inspection on October 9, 2024. I second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? I defer the deliberations and any vote.

56:26 Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes 5-1. Thank you. Thank you. Moving on to policy matters. 10.1, update and discussion on the timeline for the Snow Creek Development Agreement amendment. And this is on the timeline. This is not when we will be discussing the merits of or going into deep detail on the DA. Thank you.

56:56 Yeah, so this item is really just to discuss where we're at with the Snow Creek Development Agreement ongoing negotiations and the next steps as we envision them for moving this forward and to get some additional outside analysis and review of what's being proposed. So currently we're at this kind of, we'll call it a workshop, but it's really not a workshop to discuss what's in the DA. It's just to discuss how we're going to move it forward.

57:25 What we propose is then going into the next, what we'd say, month, four weeks to six weeks is to engage with an outside consultant who specializes in development agreements with the focus being that they would be reviewing each of the deal points proposed, confirm that the points are clear and have enough detail to get the results that we hope.

57:51 And really then identify any gaps or loopholes that could be failure points in the future DA. What we've seen with the existing DA is there's a lot of confusion as to what was promised or agreed upon back in 2010. And now that we're actually at the stage of implementing the project, it creates a lot of uncertainty with what they're required to do and what the town is in place to receive from the development.

58:17 This consultant, that's really the goal of it. We're not asking the consultant to negotiate new elements to the deal. We really just kind of solidify what is being proposed. After that, once we would get that peer review back or consultant analysis back to the town, we'd obviously review what came back from the consultant and make any necessary adjustments to that.

58:45 And then going forward, obviously the dates are tentative, depending how long that analysis and review takes, but potentially in November we would be looking to have a joint town council and planning and economic development commission meeting. That was a request of the PEDC at the last meeting was to have a joint meeting with the town council just to have that opportunity to have that dialogue with what's being proposed in the development agreement.

59:11 So we would look to have that joint meeting. We'd also, at that meeting, be reviewing the results of that consultant analysis, the existing financial analysis that was already prepared, and then the proposed amendments that are being considered pending the kind of outcome of that joint meeting and where we're at in the process. The next steps would be either additional workshops and ongoing items or moving forward to then the public hearings with the commission and town council.

59:44 Questions? I have a few. So when will we as a council be able to actually see where we are at with all this, what the actual proposals are in all of that, and when would we be commenting on what we wanted to see out of that outside of tonight? We obviously don't want to get into that tonight. Is that at the joint meeting? Will there be a workshop outside of that for us to participate?

1:00:17 How do you see that going forward? Because I'm still unclear on exactly what it is he's asking, and I want to be able to weigh in on that outside of staff's position prior to moving too far forward. Absolutely. So definitely at the joint workshop that, you know, ideally having both groups forward together to have that discussion on what's being proposed in the exact language.

1:00:45 As well as then if there need be additional, any additional workshops. We don't envision having something at the one October meeting because that's really when the outside consultant's going to be working on that peer review. We don't anticipate having anything back from them at the October 2nd or 4th? Second meeting. So I think, just to build a follow-up on what you were saying, I think that it's important that we have some idea of exactly what the applicant is asking for.

1:01:27 And from the consultant what the consequences or benefits are from that aspect. Exactly. Versus what they were with the original. Exactly. And then when we get into discussion with the Planning and Economic Development Commission that there are things on the table so that if there are concerns in the PEDC based on the document, we can respond to those. We may have our own concerns. I know no action is being taken at that point, but I would hope a pretty thorough vetting of what's being proposed. And I think...

1:01:55 We all look very much forward to hearing from the PEDC because they're trying to navigate all this. I mean, this is a pretty extraordinary thing. A 20-year, a lot can happen in 20 years. And milestones and deliverables and actual things. So looking forward to this. And thanks to staff for reaching out and bringing some, hopefully some eyes and some fresh eyes looking at all this to see what we're going to be looking at for this thing. Very good. Any other questions? Public comments or questions on this item? I have just one. Yeah, go.

1:02:26 So, you know, I know there's the typical, we have the joint meeting, and that's an open meeting where the public could come and listen and weigh in, but then for the PEDC, for the planning meeting, you know, people may or may not show up. I guess what I'm really trying to get at is the community is going to care a lot about this project, but sometimes they don't engage until

1:02:57 You know, we're pretty far down the path. So what advice do you have for everyone involved to just make sure that the community is really paying attention through this process? Because once it's done, it's done. And it feels like a lot of times they ask questions after it's done. Sure. So really the joint workshop is a perfect opportunity for that since it's not, you know, not so far along that it's at the public hearing when we're asking for consideration or at the...

1:03:24 PEDC, we're asking for a recommendation to the Town Council, but ultimately what goes forward to the Town Council has to, if it's a recommendation for approval from the PEDC, what goes forward to the Town Council has to largely match what was being considered by the PEDC. So at that stage, it's not too late to make changes or delay it or continue it, but ideally the time to really get that good feedback from the community and from the Council and from the PEDC is at the workshops.

1:03:55 Great. So, yeah, I guess, you know, it's just something that we just want to make sure we let people know about as much as we can. Yeah, I just wanted to add something to what Nolan said. When we came up with this concept or this plan, it was really to make sure that we provide enough opportunity, right? So we can't make people come to have the conversations, but we can certainly make sure that we're going at such a pace where people can keep up.

1:04:22 People can attend the meetings, and we can have as many as necessary in order to make sure we work through the issues that we have. I think, you know, the deadline is for expiration of the current DA is somewhere in July 25, and so we've got some time to get this done right, right? So that's kind of the process that we're taking. We've listened to some of the input from the community members. We want to make sure that we provide enough opportunity, we provide enough facts and conversation.

1:04:52 We do this analysis and we get to a vote when the time is right. Okay, thank you. Do we have a date selected in November or it's not decided? Like would those be council meeting nights or? Yeah, we didn't want to go too specific on the exact dates. You know, there's two meetings in November, I think the 6th and the 18th, if I'm correct, or 20th.

1:05:22 We didn't want to nail it down to any one particular time period. Okay, thanks. Anything further from up here? Jamie, anything online? Anyone in the public? There we go. Moving on then. Item 10.2, Yosemite National Park Visitor Access Management Draft Plan and Environmental Assessment Public Comment. With this we have Rob and then Lawson. We do.

1:05:58 So I'll kind of kick it off here a little bit and we can go in as much detail as you want to hear or as quickly as you want to go through this, but a great process and I do want to thank Lawson for assisting in doing a deep dive analysis. This is a fairly sizable document, roughly 225 pages to go through and determine what

1:06:22 You know, the different proposals are that are out there. And if you don't mind, Lawson, I'll just do a little bit of an introduction on this. So Yosemite National Park has been working through plans to address the impacts on the natural environment from visitation. So the purpose of this visitor access management plan is to reduce overcrowding, protect resources, and reduce traffic congestion, expanding the tools that are available for

1:06:47 Controlling vehicle volume and providing equitable visitor experience. So they really want to make sure that, similar to what we do here in the town of Mammoth Lakes, where we're trying to manage visitation with either improved processes, they're trying to take that same approach. It's really needed to make sure that that natural resource has a long-term approach. They're able to manage that. And really also, though, this is public land, so provide that

1:07:17 The planning process has been in a number of phases for a couple of years now. This is the third phase. The first two were really civic engagement where we were collecting data. They've also been collecting data through the recent closure periods after post-COVID where they had restrictions on

1:07:45 Access to the parks during the peak times of the year. And so they've been pulling that data down and providing some of these analysis and opportunities. So we'll kind of talk a little bit about, there's detail in the staff report, I think, on all the different alternatives. There's a baseline alternative A, which is what it was prior to COVID.

1:08:10 There's B and C, which have some degree of restrictions for access. Lawson has gone through and provided bullet points in the staff report to talk in detail about those. And then there's Alternative D, which allows for sort of selected restrictions within Yosemite National Park and really more access to that. So I think, Lawson, I'll turn it over to you and see if there's any points you want to make on that. And we'll get on to some of our proposed comments.

1:08:39 Yes, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Thank you for that background, Rob. Much appreciated. Before we jump into the EA and the four proposed options that Yosemite is proposing, I want to give you a little bit more background on some of this stuff. First of all, why are they going through this process? I think we've all seen that overcrowding is occurring in many of these parks, and I think you have seen...

1:09:07 Parks respond in kind, whether that's Glacier National Park, Zion National Park, who all instituted new policies to address what you will see over and over again, the desired condition. So taking a step back here again real quickly, what is this? We want to go through and have the public lands and the national parks identify their visitor capacity.

1:09:32 What is visitor capacity? Max level of visitor use that will achieve and maintain the desired condition. What is the desired condition? And that is a balance between visitor use and experience and environmental protection. So that's really what they're looking at.

1:09:53 The National Park Service along with many other agencies including the BLM, Forest Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Army Corps of Engineers are all participants in what's called the Interagency Visitor Use Management Council. They provided some guiding documents in 2016 and 2017 on how to effectively go through this process.

1:10:17 How do we get to this desired condition? What do we think about to get to this desired condition? And then they came out with a final visitor capacity guidebook in 2019. And the main reason I bring this up is this is on the forefront of the minds of the many of the public lands. And there has been a formal process at the federal level to look at this stuff and examine this stuff, but leave it vague enough.

1:10:47 For the parks to kind of do their own analysis to determine what is best for them. But with all of that in mind and with trying to reach this desired condition, the balance between visitor use and experience and environmental protection, the park has come up with the four alternatives that Rob mentioned. I believe you should have a copy of a park service produced little flyer.

1:11:13 That really distills everything, I think, quite well. So I won't harp on that too much. But piggybacking again here on our staff report, you will see a lot of the positives and negatives that we discussed with these various items. What we are concerned about, what might work well, and what are some concerns that they may not have anticipated to try and determine what would be the best option for you all.

1:11:42 to decide for the town of Mammoth Lakes. With that in mind, Rob and myself recommend option D based on this. We feel that in order to reach this desired condition of environmental protection as well as visitor use and experience that taking a one-size-fits-all approach of options B and C that in effect

1:12:07 eliminate the spontaneity and close out the ability for people to experience their public land without some form of reservation. It also, I think, takes a bit of a one-size-fits-all approach with those two options to say that every area of Yosemite National Park is experiencing the same stress as Yosemite Valley. As such, and reading through how the parks...

1:12:34 Define creating these experiences. The town manager and myself felt that that would be a good place to start. I think we can all understand that Yosemite Valley is tough, extremely busy, extremely crowded, and we really do believe that there are experience as well as environmental issues that occur as a result of that in the valley. But rather than taking this one-size-fits-all approach,

1:13:01 of kind of options B and C and doing nothing, which we don't feel is good as well of option A, we feel that D is an excellent move forward. This would be our recommendation from staff, but of course we wanted to engage you all, determine if there was one of these that you favored as it related to a public comment, which I would then draft and submit by September 30th.

1:13:28 But also, if anybody throughout this has any questions on what they're proposing, the four options, anything I've spoken about, please let me know. Otherwise, I would love to hear from each of you if you have an opinion on the matter. I just would like to add a couple of things. When we talk about some of the specific comments that would be provided, they really wanted it to focus in on analysis of each of these particular four proposals.

1:13:57 And talk about, you know, what some of the maybe unintended consequences would be of these proposals. So as we went through the comment component, a couple of them that I wanted to highlight because folks, you know, our locals will recognize this. But one of the things that they mentioned with the restricted access is opening before five o'clock in the morning.

1:14:24 The vehicle traffic on the roads went up tenfold. So if you think about people entering the park, as many as 500 cars entering the park before 5 a.m. One of the unintended consequences was impacts with wildlife, right? That's when their nocturnal animals are most active, they're out and about. And so now we've flooded the streets with people.

1:14:49 And so I kind of backed that up a little bit and thought about Mono County, right? You have to travel some distance to get to the park entrance and you end up with impacting our deer and bear and other wildlife on the roads of Mono County. So that is a direct environmental impact to us. We also have public safety issues. Many of you have been up Highway 120 westbound. That's not the easiest road.

1:15:18 And especially for people who may be unfamiliar with it in the middle of the night. I can say unfortunately in search and rescue I've had to recover people off of the side of that mountain in their vehicles and it's just not a safe place to be in the middle of the night. So those were the two main areas of concern. I really also wanted to implore them to increase the use of technology both in

1:15:45 The way vehicles are accessing that. If you've all seen the current process where you may have, I think the longest wait time is 90 minutes from the gate. So you've got some percentage of the vehicles still gasoline powered that are idling there for hours waiting and the impacts of that process on the natural environment. But increase the technology.

1:16:09 of getting people into the park, increase the ability for managing people within the park and the real-time management of that. I think as we all are constantly looking for here in the town of Mammoth Lakes is how do we utilize technology to help us understand what's happening, right? Get the data out of where people are going around within the facility. So I'm imploring them to do that work as well.

1:16:32 As Lawson mentioned, this is due by the end of September. This was the only opportunity to engage this with you all. And we would really love to hear from you if there is something, an alternate point or something else you would like us to highlight.

1:16:49 And I do want to mention one other thing as it relates to the comments Rob made about Highway 120. Also think about the ancillary impacts of the National Treasure and people wanting to visit before 5 a.m. They will then maybe go disperse camp on the immediately adjacent Inyo National Forest so they can be close to the gate, all the impacts that that can possibly have from human waste to fire to then enter that gate at 4.59 and then maybe go sleep a little bit in the park or go and start recreating to gain access.

1:17:20 John? Yeah. I've looked at this, and I think D for us, I think it makes a lot of sense. Really good observations that you guys are looking at the ancillaries of unintended consequences. The other one is that I've noticed for all of us how it starts affecting the behavior of locals, because locals get in there and start gaming the reservation system, and that starts, all of our behavior over here starts getting a little loco. And that's,

1:17:49 And I've heard complaints from the park service that, you know, well, the locals on the east side are like hogging the permits or they're taking over too many permits. It starts distorting everything. So I think D is by far the best thing from the east side's perspective, I think. And excellent observations. I would just add in this human behavior thing, how it starts to affect our culture over here, which may have unintended consequences to the park and their desire to manage the audience.

1:18:17 We're going to distort that, and we will distort it. But really good comments, so thank you. Amanda? I liked alternative D. Although I don't know, do you think that the Forest Service will put the infrastructure in there to check people before they go only into the valley? I think it would be nice for everyone on the east side to be able to go in a little bit to Yosemite and not have to fight for permits.

1:18:45 I mean, my family, we don't go because I don't plan far enough in advance to get permits. So I would be happy with alternative D. Chris? Oh, Sarah just turned her mic on. Sarah, go ahead. Yeah, I agree. I think, you know, when the reservation system sort of came into effect, I was really conflicted about it as someone who worked in Yosemite for eight years and in the Valley for much of that time and how crazy it can get there.

1:19:18 But, and I thought, well, this is, you know, this, for the sake of the wildlife and the sake of the park, like, the reservation system is a good thing, but I did really struggle with the inherent, like, gatekeeping-ness of the reservation system because not everybody does have access to, you know, to.

1:19:38 I appreciate all the effort as well.

1:20:07 D makes sense to me because it's really what we should be commenting on. I mean, it's the closest thing to our community. We understand best what the challenges are, and I really appreciated the in-depth explanation of unintended consequences of B and C. And yeah, we all wish that there didn't have to be reservation systems in parks, but on the western entrance, I understand why it came to that. Thank you.

1:20:40 My knee jerk to this when I first saw the proposals was D. I still am having a hard time understanding why the Park Service chose C, except closing is easier than being open. Did I see that out loud? But we often see that with our federal partners. I also believe that D will provide...

1:21:03 If we have to have a system, the fewest unintended consequences are impact, if you will, to the partner communities that provide the access. The people who are irritated because they showed up and couldn't get in. As I say with a lot of these things, a lot of it is planning. If you had brochures showing people all the other magnificent spots outside of the valley, you could disperse them better. And it's a matter of dispersing.

1:21:31 Not just numbers coming in. So if we have to have one of these, I believe D is by far the best. Although my tongue-in-cheek added on to that is anybody who qualifies for and has purchased a senior pass to the parks should get in all the time unqualified.

1:21:49 If I could just add one thing, Bill, to your point about disbursement. There is policy when Mr. Zinke was the Secretary of the Interior that got adopted by the Park Service that really encouraged national parks to be dispersing their audience and to be providing multiple points of access into national parks. And that might be something I'm still trying to dig up that policy stuff for you guys. But that could be another thing to add. I don't think they've changed that. I think that's still in effect.

1:22:17 Which is provide as many different ways into a park as you possibly can and try to disperse your audience. We would love to see this more disbursement. We've got plenty of public land over here that people can enjoy. In some ways it's kind of nicer than what you see in a parking lot in the valley. There are a lot of things still in place that are not being implemented all over. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That being said, do we have any public comments on this? Nothing. We don't have any decision-making to do here, so do you have what you need from us?

1:22:50 We do. Thank you very much. Yes, and thank you both. Yeah, and thanks for the time spent on this. Moving on then to Councilmember Reports. Who wants to start off this party? I have nothing to report. There you go. We'll piggyback on that. Chris? To the third. Okay. You did go to the Chamber of Power Lunch yesterday. Yeah, but I figured you guys would talk about it. Yeah. John? I had my mic off.

1:23:22 All right. I'll really quickly thank you to the chamber for holding a power lunch. It was an opportunity for the two town council candidates for two spots to introduce themselves since there won't formally be an election. There will be it on the ballot. And then they gave the opportunity for the four local ballot measures for folks who are

1:23:51 Engaged with that to explain what the measures are. And so thank you to the chamber and everyone who helped organize that. That is all. John. Thank you. I attended the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting on September 5th. The whole agenda was closed session items. It's the nature of business that happens down there. On September 6th, I attended the Nevada County Sustainability Summit up in Truckee.

1:24:19 Very interesting day. Kind of the highlight of that is the convergence of the California Jobs First in the state, coming along with wildfire and sustainable outdoor recreations. A lot of things are kind of coming together for that. I went to the Yosemite Visitor Access Open House.

1:24:35 Got to meet some folks that I've only seen in Zoom meetings in person, which was nice. Shake a couple of hands and say hello. And then I attended with Chris and Bill Uyer, the Chamber candidate forum. Really nice forum, really well put together. Thanks to the Chamber for doing that. And a lot of interesting information was shared. That's it. I attended that as well. And I worked on a wildlife video with the Chamber and all those involved, or MLT, is putting that on, actually.

1:25:06 And I'm anxious to see the final product. Hopefully we will be showing that at the next council meeting. And that is all. I'm looking forward to the return of the 70 degree temperature this weekend. With that, we are officially adjourned. I tried to make it not a record at 523. Oh, that's pretty close. Yes.