Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
7 findings- The Town Council denied the appeals and approved the Limelight Hotel project after hearings in June and July 2022 Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- The approved project is a six-story, 185,754-square-foot condominium hotel with 151 hotel rooms and 15 for-sale condominium units Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- A 2026 agenda packet says the Limelight Hotel was completed in 2025 and is the first new hotel development in approximately 20 years Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- The Town Council approved a one-year extension of the Limelight tentative tract map, to July 6, 2025 Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- Resolution No. 22-53 attaches construction measures, including an October 15 soil-stabilization deadline each year Limelight Hotel Mammoth (North Village)
- Community Recreation Center closeout lists $9,630,000 from Measure R and $3,090,000 from Measure U toward a $16,959,862.68 total Measure R and Measure U
- Limelight Hotel: Council denied the appeal and approved the project; a CEQA addendum sets October 15 stabilization Planning and Zoning
Transcript
389 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:19 Yeah, this is just, we're going to call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer is absent. Mayor Salzer? Present. Thank you. At this point, we are going to move into a closed session in the back closed session room. Is that right? Mr. Mayor, can you announce the nature of the closed session room? You've got to read the two items, Bill. Oh, that's right.
2:51 1.1, Conference with Legal Counsel Anticipated Litigation, Initiation of Litigation Pursuant to Paragraph 4 of Subdivision D of Section 5495.9, One Case. 1.2, Conference with Legal Counsel Existing Litigation, Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 5495.9, Name of Case, Natasha Mitchell v. City of Mammoth Lakes.
3:23 Why is everybody outside? You're here so long. You're here just in time to go to the closed session room. I made it. Sorry. We're tired. Congrats. I was like, is she even going to make it today? Thanks. I made it. I was like, this is the one thing I have to do today. Congratulations. Thanks.
4:39 Michael puts out every morning. See? It's a ritual. My husband. There you go. For my wife. That's sweet. I will now bring us back to order coming out of the closed session. Next thing up is Pledge of Allegiance and I will lead us if you'll all stand and join us. Oh, yeah. Nothing to announce from closed session. This is exercise. Sit. Stand.
37:50 Public comments. Now is the time. Any member of the public wishing to speak on something that is not otherwise on the agenda? Hi. Thank you for having us. I'm Kendra Knight. I'm the new executive director for Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I wanted to introduce you all to Cassidy Moyer, who is now taking over for me as sustainability coordinator for Mammoth Disposal. So meet Cassidy. She's available for any information.
38:17 And so forth. And we'll be doing a presentation with you all in just a couple of months here. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you.
38:25 Yeah, hi everyone. My name's Cassidy. I was actually born and raised here in the Eastern Sierra, so it feels good to be back home. I left for four years and got my education up at Portland State University where I studied community and sustainable urban development. So I'm super excited to be in this position and help make our community a lot more green and a lot better. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any further public comments?
38:56 Seeing none, we will move on to item number six, additions or changes to the agenda. Rob? Mayor Sauser, we would like to make an adjustment to the agenda and swap the position of 12.4, bring that up in front of 12.2. It flows better with the presentation that staff intends to provide tonight. Thank you very much. So we will do that. Moving on to introductions.
39:30 Introduce new revenue specialist Maria Lupita Lopez, Rob. Yes, I'm here tonight to introduce Lupita, who worked for us for a little bit as a temporary employee in our enforcement, DOT enforcement realm, and then came to work with us as a revenue specialist. And Lupita, her background story a little bit, she grew up in Mexico.
40:09 Moved to the United States when she was 20 years old. Did not speak English when she came to the United States. And essentially the purpose for coming here, get an education at the university. Came by herself, no family, no support. So worked through all that process alone. Very difficult road, I think is what you said. But really kept her focus on the goals and found success in that entire process.
40:38 About five years ago, moved to Mammoth Lakes and really wanted to find a job in public service, right? An opportunity to sort of represent the Spanish-speaking community. We obviously have a very large portion of our community is Spanish-speaking and Lupita has really elevated the game for the town in that role. In fact, we have a lot of people that are
41:07 They're bilingual, right? We like to have the ability to communicate with all. But that doesn't really compare to someone who is deeply, you know, just immersed in it and can really share things very comfortably. And we've noticed it, not only have I noticed it in the staff, but as you'll hear a little bit about the Spirit of Mammoth Award, Lupita was nominated for that based upon elevating the game at the front counter.
41:35 Thank you very much. Thank you for the opportunity of being part of this organization. I am very happy to be here and represent the Spanish-speaking community, be a resource for them.
42:05 Saying that, I also want to address that in Spanish. Muchas gracias por la oportunidad de pertenecer a esta organización. Igualmente, estoy muy emocionada de ser un recurso y ser y darle representación a la comunidad hispanohablante en este pueblo. Muchas gracias. Thank you.
42:34 Thank you very much. Okay, next, introduce payroll HR specialist Ryan Meditre. Amanda. Good evening, Mayor and Town Council members. I am Amanda Pelham, the human resources manager for the town. It's my pleasure to introduce Ryan Meditre this evening. So Lupita is taking over for Ryan. He was previously our revenue specialist and he has been promoted into the payroll and human resources specialist position with us.
43:03 He was working as a revenue specialist for about a year prior to that, facilities management at June Mountain and with the United States Air Force before that for several years. We're excited to have him join our HR team and round that out. As you were aware, we recently added HR analyst Allison Floyd and we think Ryan's just the perfect addition to continue to enhance our internal support for our town employees so that they can continue to provide exceptional service to the community of Mammoth Lakes.
43:33 So, welcome, Ryan. Hi, yeah, I am very pleased and very proud to get to continue to serve this community and serve this organization in this new role. Thank you all very much. Congratulations. Next, we are introducing new Parks and Public Works hybrid employee, Isidro Vargas. Stu. Yes, thank you, council. Council members, mayor.
44:20 Members of our community, it's my pleasure to introduce Isidro this evening. He is our full-time hybrid position. As you know, we have three hybrid positions. We're always challenged to find really good people to work with Warren and Pat on both Parks Maintenance and the roads crew. Isidro was born and raised in Mammoth Lakes, right? Played a bunch of soccer. Yeah.
44:44 He was good. So I was fortunate to spend a bunch of time with Isidro, played a lot with All-Stars, Mammoth High School, I think I did a lot of refereeing games with you. Yeah, so you sometimes listen. It was good. Isidro worked for Parks Maintenance in the summer of 2023, so not that long ago, and most recently was the Employee of the Month at ESTA, right? Yeah, pretty cool, right? Isidro has some snow removal experience, so he's going to get a pretty good crash course here.
45:13 Hopefully in the not too distant future. And it has a commercial driver's license, so all ready to go. So here's our full-time hybrid. So he'll work for seven months with Parks Maintenance, kind of with Warren and Marco, and then he'll jump over with Pat and the roads crew. So we're really excited to see Isidro join our team. It might be a little while before we actually get to drive around in some snow, right? But he'll be ready. So with that, my pleasure and honor to introduce Isidro to the Town Council and community of Mammoth Lakes this evening.
45:43 Do you want to just say any words? Are we good? Man, a few words. Introduce yourself. Thank you. And more introductions. Introduce and swear in new police sergeant Daniel Hansen. Mr. Casabian. Good evening, counsel. Dan Casabian, chief of police. Familiar face here. Not very new. Been around for about 15 years with the police department. When he started, I was his original FTO.
46:21 We talked a little bit about the introduction portion of it here. I can go through his bio and talk about everything that he's done, but I'm going to let him do that, talk to Council a little bit and kind of go through what he's done in his career. We're very fortunate and proud to have Daniel on board as a sergeant. He's gone through the ranks with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. So with that, I'll let him come up and talk to you a little bit and let you know what his career looks like. Good evening, Council. Thank you. This is a really proud moment for me and my family.
46:51 As the Chief mentioned, I've been here, February is going to mark my 17th year with the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And I've seen the Town make a lot of changes and go into a new direction. And I'm very proud to be in this role and be able to continue my career doing something different. So I started my career with the Town of Mammoth Lakes back in 2008. And Chief Schindley and Lieutenant Short at the time gave me a great opportunity to send me to the Academy. And I came back.
47:20 Hard charging, ready to go. And I've spent the last 16 plus years doing a lot of different stuff. So one of my first special assignments that I was involved in was a canine officer. I was a canine officer for about three and a half, four years. Immediately after that, I stepped into the SRO role where I was able to work with the community and work with the schools. I did that for about four years. I'm a part of the sexual assault response team. I've been a part of that for many years.
47:50 Part of our POA board member for many years, helping guide the direction of our association to where it is today. And last year I was promoted to corporal and it was that first big step as a supervisor. And today I stand here as a sergeant and I'm extremely proud and I can't thank you guys enough. I thank the chief and a good majority of my family's here tonight.
48:13 I thank all of them for the support over the years, my wife, and especially all the people in uniform back there that have helped build me up as the officer and supervisor that I am today. There's a lot of faces in here, and they were all part of me being where I am today. So thank you all that's here, and thank you, Chief.
48:49 Thank you.
49:20 Okay, moving on. Item number eight, report from commissions and or departments as needed. We're going to start off with the oral reports. Rob, or you want another?
50:25 I'll start her off. Yeah. So a couple of things that I want to update tonight in this area is the town is bringing back our Spirit of Mammoth Award. We had this award. It's a quarterly award given to full-time employees that demonstrate high standards of quality of work as well as going above and beyond what would normally be the normal course of their duty and performance of their job.
50:54 Nominations can be made by anybody within the town. Any employee can nominate another employee, and they have to do so in writing. They submit a write-up as to why they believe this person has gone above and beyond. That goes to the department heads. We review that and take the nominations, go through them, and decide on who we want to win for the quarter. There's only one person that can win. But as an organization, we celebrate all the nominations.
51:23 You know, for the winner, you get a certificate of appreciation signed by the mayor, very illustrious. You get a $100 cash reward as well as emails recognition within our employee annual recognition luncheon as well as other town publications. The winner for this quarter...
51:51 And we're not going to announce all of them. We're going to bring them to council if they want to come to council, or we're going to talk about this for everybody in that. But since this is the introduction of the program, the winner of this award for the quarter is Mr. Rick Bellis, which I think might be in the audience. A little bit about why Rick was nominated. So Rick is a code compliance officer. Rick was nominated for his efforts during the proceedings of our bear incident we had in late August.
52:27 And into early September. Rick happened to be on vacation when that occurred, and then he returned to put together some documentation. If you remember, that was going right into a holiday weekend, and so we really wanted to get things out into the community. Rick came back, put some stuff together, and a plan to get it out into camp hosts and things like that in the basin. We knew we were going to be busy that weekend. Then went back to vacation, and then he came back for our
52:57 Town Council meeting on the 4th and presented alongside of us with what town efforts and focus was. During that meeting, we also heard from a number of community members, camp hosts, praising Rick for his efforts, recognizing the fact that he was up there working in that capacity, working to educate folks.
53:21 And working with the Bears. And so they made reference to seeing him out there. And so, you know, Rick's passion for professionalism presented for the town very, very well. So we think that certainly earned the award for the Spirit of Mammoth. So I will present. Did Rick run up there? He left.
54:06 I wanted to provide just a quick other nominees, Kevin Bossenbecker, permit technician for the building department, Riley Grisenbeck, the facilities and asset manager, Ron Haskins, our building inspector, Lupita Lopez, which you met earlier, revenue specialist, Frederico Martinez, public works maintenance worker, Angie Place.
54:27 Claystead, our Assistant Clerk, Bailey Thompson, Permit Technician and Plans Examiner, and Pat Vargas, our Public Works Maintenance Manager. So for something we rolled out at the 1st of September and had people...
54:39 Provide nominations. It was really wonderful to see how many people stepped up, and these are really great nominations. I shared them all with you in our Town Manager update last week, but it's a great program, and we really want to recognize people who are really representing well for the town and going above and beyond. My other update, so the airport just completed a tri-annual exercise, and since it's a full three-year exercise, it's a full-scale exercise that is
55:08 It's in conjunction with a 2024 statewide medical and health exercise. So this didn't just include airport personnel. This included all of our, like 53 different agencies and departments. We had three hospitals involved in this. Four helicopters and about 153 individuals. Our team at the airport had done a lot of, I'm going to share my screen here really quick. Run through a few of the photos.
55:46 The team at the airport had put this together just to make sure that everyone was included all through the region, Mono County, Inyo County. The hospitals also ramped up their staff so that they could respond to this as if it were a mass casualty incident. The key focus on this one
56:10 It was a mass casualty incident. There was chemical decontamination and pediatric surge scenario. There were 40 people involved in a plane crash. The plane ran into some deer on the runway. But they basically triaged everyone out there on the tarmac, flew them out of there from one section of the airport to another, and they...
56:34 They also transported them to the hospital. The hospital had staff spooled up, and they were treating it as such. So really incredible scenarios played out. They actually were able to burn. So there was a fire that they took the ARF out and had to extinguish. But it was incredibly successful and really couldn't be more proud of the team at the airport for the work that they do, but also just something like this for the community.
57:00 We got a lot of good feedback from people saying that, you know, how incredible this opportunity was. And when you think about it, this is something for the community, right? We're sharpening the skills of all of our medic teams, all of our fire teams, so they could respond to incidents that may occur in our area. And obviously that happens from time to time. So I'm extremely proud of the team on that. So that is the end of my updates. Thank you, Rob. Any other verbal?
57:30 Presentations from any commission or department. Seeing none, there's also 8.1 October 24 Public Works Engineering CIP Report, 8.2 Office of Outdoor Recreation Update. Those are written only unless you have questions. I have a good question. Okay. Do we have an opening date on the dog park? Yeah, so that one, our staff is doing the final work on that space. And so...
58:02 I thought we had a plan to have it open pretty quickly, but we're still working through that process. Okay. We'll move on then to Item 9, 9.1, Elections Update, presented by Queenie Barnard, Mono County Clerk, Recorder and Registrar. Good afternoon. Thank you for having me. I'm Queenie Barnard, Mono County Clerk, Recorder, Registrar, and I'm here to provide an election update for you all. So I'm going to go ahead and share my screen.
58:49 So, as mentioned, we'll be providing an election update today, and we'll go over voter registration and general election voting. So, some key dates coming up. So, next week, actually, ballots are going to be mailed to every registered voter, and on October 8th, ballot drop boxes are going to be open throughout the state of California, and then election day, November 5th, polls will be open 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., and then on November 22nd, we plan to certify the election results.
59:19 So these are the polling place locations and drop box locations throughout Mono County. There has been a change here in Mammoth for polling place. So it was previously at the high school. So it's now been moved to our county civic center. All other polling locations are still at the local community centers. And the ballot drop box locations, they're located in front of each of the community centers and in front of the county civic center.
59:44 And ballots can also be dropped off at our office in Bridgeport Monday through Friday 8 to 5 and election day 7 to 8. So just some statistics of voter turnout for the last couple elections. General elections typically have a higher voter turnout than primaries and presidential general elections have the highest voter turnout so we can expect a pretty high turnout for this upcoming election.
1:00:08 So registering to vote, the easiest way to register to vote is online, registertovote.ca.gov. You can register or re-register to vote, and 16 and 17 year olds can also pre-register to vote. You can also contact our office to request to have a voter registration card mailed to you. And if you need to register after October 21st and you still want to vote in this November 5th election, you can do so in person at a poll place or up in Bridgeport at our county elections office.
1:00:37 And you can register to vote and vote if you are a U.S. citizen and a resident of California, if you want to vote here in California, 18 years old or older on election day, not currently serving a state or federal prison term for the conviction of a felony, and not currently found mentally incompetent to vote by a court.
1:00:56 And a lot of folks don't realize, but persons with a prior felony conviction can register to vote if they are in a local detention facility for any of these reasons here, if they're on parole, probation, mandatory supervision, post-release community supervision, on federal supervised release, or a person with a juvenile wardship adjudication.
1:01:20 We encourage everybody to check your voter status, voterstatus.sos.ca.gov, and you can check if you're registered to vote, where you're registered to vote, your political party preference, and all of these other pieces that you can check out.
1:01:35 So now jumping to the actual ballot. So the contests and measures that you can expect to see on your ballot. President and Vice President of the United States, United States Senator, full and partial term, United States Representative, 3rd Congressional District, and State Assembly Member, 8th District. There are quite a few state propositions. I won't go through all of them, but I provided links if you want to find out more about them.
1:02:00 And then we have our local contest. So these will vary depending on your residence. So as you're aware, there is the Town of Mammoth Lakes Councilmember that is still going to election. Even though there's two seats and two candidates, there is still a write-in candidate period, which is right now, and it is open until October 22nd. So for folks who are interested in being a write-in candidate,
1:02:23 For town council, they would reach out to the town clerk. And for any of these other races, you would reach out to the local county election official. So in addition to town council member, there's also the Mono County Office of Education Board, Trustee Area 3. There's one seat and two candidates. There's Bishop Unified School District.
1:02:43 Board, which is a shared district with Inyo County, so voters who live in Swalmeadows and Paradise will see that on their ballots. There's two seats and four candidates. And then the Southern Mono Healthcare District Board Member, there's three seats and four candidates. And there's a couple local measures on the ballot, which once again will vary depending on your residence. So there's Measure J, which is the Mammoth Unified School District School Safety and Improvement Measure. This is a bond measure, so it will require 55% of the vote.
1:03:13 Then we have Measure K, which is raising the transient occupancy tax rate in unincorporated Mono County. This is a general tax measure, so this will require the majority of the voters to pass. And then as you're aware, there's Measure L, which is raising the transient occupancy tax rate in the town of Mammoth Lakes. This is also a general tax measure, so this will also require the majority of voters to pass.
1:03:36 And then we have Measure M, which is the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District Special Tax for Emergency Response and Fire Protection Services. This is a special tax measure, so this will require two-thirds of the vote to pass. And lastly, we have Measure R, which is Bishop Unified School District Bond Measure. So once again, this is a shared district with Inyo County, so the measure letter is also shared with them. And this is a bond measure, so this will require 55% of the vote.
1:04:02 And that wraps up what you can expect to see on your ballot depending on where you live in Mono County. So now I'm just going to go over vote by mail ballot return options. So there's a couple different ways you can return your vote by mail ballot. You can return it by mail using that yellow postage prepaid return envelope. You can return it in person in Bridgeport at our county elections office. You can drop it off in any of those six...
1:04:25 Ballot drop boxes located throughout the county, but you can also drop it off in any drop box in the state of California. It does come back to us in Mono County. And you could drop it off at any polling place or vote center within the state of California. We do encourage you to vote early. Ballots must be postmarked by election day and received by our office no later than seven days after election day. If you do choose to vote by mail and wait until election day, please go into the post office and watch them postmark your ballot.
1:04:54 We cannot process your ballot after it's received within the seven days after election day if it hasn't been postmarked on or before election day. So we've had instances of folks just dropping their ballot off in the box on election day and assuming that it will get postmarked, but the post office doesn't actually postmark it until the 6th. And so we can't count it, unfortunately. So if you're going to wait until the very last minute...
1:05:18 Make sure you go into the post office and watch the post market. Otherwise, drop it off in a drop box because those will be open until 8 p.m. Okay. Ballots. How often are ballots picked up from drop boxes?
1:05:30 Ballots are retrieved from six secure drop boxes located through Mono County and teams of two. And then on election day, poll workers will collect ballots from drop boxes at 8 p.m. and lock the slot door. So this is the current schedule of when we will be retrieving ballots from the drop boxes. And the frequency is just based on how far out from the election we are.
1:05:52 So some vote-by-mail ballot reminders. Before you return your vote-by-mail ballot, make sure it's in that yellow return envelope provided with your ballot and make sure you sign it and print your residential address. A signature is required in order for your ballot to be counted. If the signature is missing or the signature doesn't match, your ballot will be challenged and we do notify folks within 24 hours if there's an email on file and we will mail you.
1:06:22 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:06:38 And then any voter can request a remote accessible vote-by-mail ballot. This is a RAVBM ballot that is emailed to the voter to download, print, fill out by pen, and mail back to the county elections office to be counted like a regular ballot. So what happens when a vote-by-mail ballot is received? So we went over the different ways that you can turn in a ballot. So once we've received them, whether it's from the post office, Dropbox, the Bridgeport front counter, or from a poll place on election day,
1:07:08 Once we've received them, it goes to the ballot check-in and signature verification stage. So this is just an example of a ballot being checked in. And so by default, assuming that there has not been a ballot return for this voter yet, you'll see that green tack there, and it defaults to a good return status. Then we were going to check the voter's signature. So we also have the ability to view a voter's signature history.
1:07:35 For voters who have re-registered to vote, so this is just an example of mine. Back in 2012, there's a different version of my signature. So for a lot of people who register to vote online, it gives them the option to pull their signature from the DMV.
1:07:50 As you can see, my signature here, it was signed on one of those digital pads at the DMV. So if you're ever wondering what your signature is on file with our voter registration, if you've registered online, it's most likely what's on your driver's license. So assuming that the signature is verified and checked in, the next stage is going to be sorting the ballot and storing them until they're processed on election day.
1:08:17 So when they're processed on election day, we have this equipment here as our central count ballot scanner and tabulator. So the ballots are scanned in by voting precinct. And once they're scanned in, ballots that meet certain conditions, so write-in candidate, overvote, those are automatically sent to adjudication application for digital ballot review, which means two staff members are visually looking at each of these ballots that are there for adjudication. So write-in candidates.
1:08:46 Whether they're a qualified writing candidate or not, we still have to view each of those and either confirm that this is a qualified writing candidate and this is a valid vote or it's just some random person's name and that won't count. So voting in person at a poll place.
1:09:05 This is pretty straightforward. You confirm your polling location. The only change is, as I mentioned, in Mammoth. It's going to be at the county civic center instead of the high school. And your polling location is printed on the back of your county voter information guide, which has been mailed out to voters. So if you haven't already received it, you should be receiving it any day now.
1:09:28 And then you go and vote at your polling location between 7 a.m. and 8 p.m. on election day. And this is the equipment you will encounter at a poll place if you vote in person. There's the electronic poll pad, and this is what is used to check you in when you first walk into a poll place. And so a poll worker will ask for your name and your address to look you up. And this replaced those physical paper rosters that you used to sign back in the day. And then we have the large equipment here on the right that you will feed the ballot through.
1:09:58 So what happens to a ballot cast at a polling place? So after polls have closed at 8 on election day, county IT and election staff will shut down the voting machines and the ballots and those compact flesh memory cards are collected from each voting machine and those transport teams of two will transport the ballots and memory cards from each polling location to the election office in Bridgeport.
1:10:21 So, results and tally reporting. So, initial results will be available after 8 p.m. on election day and posted on the election results page.
1:10:29 These semi-official results will include early vote-by-mail ballots received, and then results will be updated as polling place ballots are delivered to our office throughout the evening. So our furthest poll place is out in Chalfant. So depending on the weather, if you all remember the November 2022 election, the roads were closed, but we anticipate having all precinct ballots back in Bridgeport by around 11 or midnight.
1:10:56 As I mentioned, results are going to be updated as we receive poll place ballots. Once all the precincts are 100% reporting, then all poll places have returned to our office with their ballots. However, this does not mean that all ballots have been counted because vote-by-mail ballots can still be received and processed.
1:11:16 And just a little slide about election observers. So elections are a public process and there are certain aspects of election activities that are open to the public to observe.
1:11:27 We have some testing happening next week, so that equipment that I just went over that we use to tabulate vote-by-mail ballots and the equipment that you see at a poll place, those get all pulled out. We have test ballots and expected results of those test ballots. We run the test ballots through all the machines, run the results, and compare our results with expected results, and they should match, right? And then, of course, you can observe the returned vote-by-mail ballot processing, so the signature
1:11:57 Check-in verification process. Polling place locations, folks can observe on election day at any of the polling locations. Election night ballot receipt and counting, if folks want to come up to Bridgeport at midnight, they can observe that too. And official canvas, so up until when we certify the election on the 22nd. And more information about being an election observer is provided in that link at the bottom of the page. And California Secretary of State does have a rumor control page, and that's designed to
1:12:27 In response to some of the most widespread rumors about elections. So this link here, I encourage you to check it out. And I included some screenshots of what those look like. So rumor, if I leave something blank on my ballot, my ballot will not be counted. That's not true. You can vote for as many or as few contests as you choose. There are people who just vote for one contest because that's the only one they care about.
1:12:48 Rumor that Californians with felony background are prohibited from voting in the state's election. As we went over earlier, that's not true. Voting rights are restored after a jail sentence is served. We do have a frequently asked questions page. So I linked it here because I know you can't read that. But hopefully it addresses pretty much all the frequently asked questions that have come up about elections and this election in particular.
1:13:10 And then I like to share misinformation and disinformation resources, some links there to those resources as well as some reliable fact checking sites.
1:13:20 And I encourage you to keep up to date on elections. You can visit our elections page for more information. As mentioned, we have that Frequently Asked Questions page. We have our candidates, measures, where to vote, ways to vote. Election results will be posted there. Also recommend subscribing to our election updates. We'll be pushing out the results to all our subscribers as we get results updated.
1:13:45 And that wraps up my presentation. I have a little slide just with our contact information if anybody has any questions, but I'll go ahead and stop sharing, and thank you for having me. Questions? I have a quick question. For Measure L, if you live in Crowley, will that be on your ballot, or is it only for residents of Mammoth Lakes? Only for residents of Mammoth. Thank you. But I will note that Measure K, even though it is a transient occupancy tax that only affects unincorporated Mono County,
1:14:14 All Mono County voters will see that on their ballot. How's everything going? Good? Ready? Okay, good. We're counting on you. Thank you. I have one question. So someone in my family has had a major medical issue and their signature is no longer anywhere near what it was.
1:14:39 So if you're checking signatures, is that vote going to be discounted? Does she need to re-register? How do we deal with that? Because we plan on just mailing in our ballots. Yeah. So as long as it does look quite similar, and we do keep that in mind when folks get older, the signatures come in and they do get very squiggly and it is harder to compare them. But for the most part, we do keep that in mind. We're not super...
1:15:05 Like strict, like it has to match. We still are trying to give voters the benefit of the doubt. Their signature is not going to be exact every single time. However, if it does still not pass our
1:15:17 Two-person check. The first person who is checking in the ballot will flag it if they think that the signature is a mismatch, and then a second set of ayes will look at it and confirm whether or not they do agree. So if it does end up being challenged, we'll send them the letter to cure their ballot, and they can just provide that signature, and we'll update their voter registration with that new signature. Thank you. Any questions from those in attendance?
1:15:48 Seeing none, Queenie, thank you very much. Moving on then to staff presentations, 10.1 Housing Now program update, Nolan. So this item is a co-update with Hayes and myself providing updates on two different aspects of our...
1:16:28 Ongoing housing programs. The first topic will be on the multimodal circulation elements that have been incorporated into the parcel or planned for the parcel. Then the second part of it will be an update on the housing production status of where we're currently at with ARENA and from the 2017 housing needs assessment and where we're projected to go with some of the housing projects we have in the pipeline.
1:16:54 So with that, I'll turn it over to Hayes to talk about the multimodal elements within the parcel. Thanks, Nolan. And we thought it would be good to update everybody on what we're doing to build a neighborhood. You know, we talk a lot about the housing and putting people in housing, but I think it's good to reflect upon what we've done with this parcel in building an integrated multimodal neighborhood. And I believe that the parcel is the most integrated.
1:17:21 We built upon the principles we created within the mobility element, within walk, bike, ride, and complete streets. And all of the new roads that we've constructed have sidewalks, they have transit stops, transit shelters, and have been integrated into the existing neighborhood.
1:17:46 For instance, to the north, they started construction just the other day on Center Street, connecting the existing sidewalks on the extension of Inyo Street to the $10 million-plus infrastructure that we built on the Main Street Promenade. That work will be completed later this season. To the east, we connected Tavern Road to Laurel Mountain. We did a project in advance of the parcel.
1:18:13 Where we connected two complete, two Safe Routes to School projects on Sierra Nevada Road and Tavern Road, north to south, connecting streets that go east-west that connect to the schools and hospitals and so forth. That was by design so that we would have these connections for the future residents of the parcel. And to the south, we connected to Chaparral, and we do have plans longer term to connect those sidewalks on Sierra Nevada.
1:18:42 We have street lights that are forthcoming. The infrastructure has been put in, but the street lights haven't been constructed yet, so that's to come. And in the future, we're looking to put in a parking lot, the two blue boxes. A couple of years ago, when we were starting the infrastructure, Dan Holler presented a proposal to spend about $50,000 using town staff to build a temporary parking lot.
1:19:11 Which was originally sited near Phase 3, which would be the southeast intersection of the Tavern and Inyo connection, kind of in the middle of the intersection. Our plan was to use some grindings to kind of provide a temporary parking lot. But that's now...
1:19:37 Looking like it's going to be part of phase three. So we're now looking at a lot kind of central to the overall parcel, creating some additional parking. We're also looking at building a multi-use connection to Manzanita. Many years ago, we secured an easement through a parcel there, and we are looking at building a multi-use path and a bridge to connect the Sierra Valley sites neighborhood to the parcel and all the infrastructure we've built there.
1:20:06 And then you'll see it soon. Phase three is in development, the home ownership phase. And we're planning on providing a multi-use path through those ownership units, which will kind of follow where Nolan's cursor is to the south and to the west connecting the infrastructure we've already built. So we've come a long way in just a few years on the parcel. And like I said, this is a great multimodal community.
1:20:33 Providing multi-use paths, sidewalks, lighting, and transit to this new community. Great. So jumping into where we're at as far as housing production goes, there are currently two metrics that the town uses to monitor housing production, mainly focused on affordable housing production.
1:20:56 One is the state assigned regional housing needs allocation, or RHNA, and the other is the 2017 housing needs assessment, which used a whole different metric for how many units were needed. The state assigned one, so the RHNA, sets the target for how many units of the various income levels the town needs to plan for and issue permits for.
1:21:18 It's intended to identify the number of units at various income levels to satisfy the housing demand in 2027 based on projected population and the number of units. The current arenas for the period of 2019 through 2027 and for what's called the sixth cycle of the state housing element, which is what we're currently in, the town needed to plan for 155 units spread across the various income levels.
1:21:46 The state designates this. You're required to identify the areas where the units could go, but the state doesn't necessarily require you to build the units. However, as shown here, the town has made significant progress in actually building the units within the RHNA. So we're excited to highlight here that we have satisfied the RHNA categories for the extremely low. That's less than 30% AMI, very low.
1:22:16 Which is less than 50% AMI, the low income, and then the above moderate, which is everything above 120%, so that's everything market rate. So we're doing really well for our arena numbers. The one area where we're lacking is in the moderate income category. That's the 81% to 120% AMI. That's the category we've talked extensively about, because that's the category where
1:22:40 State and federal funds don't provide assistance in that category, and so it's really then up to local jurisdictions to step in to figure out how to not only plan for it, but really, you know, we know there's a need for that target of housing here in the community, so how to actually build housing in that. We were successful in...
1:23:00 Getting the Access Apartments Project with the CDBG funding to allow for a portion of those units, about 49% of the units or six units to be restricted at the 120% income level. But we do know that we need some additional units there. So jumping forward to look at the other metric, which is the housing needs assessment.
1:23:23 So this was from the 2017 Housing Needs Assessment, which that report identified a need for 595 units through 2022, which was then broken down into four categories. Those categories were affordable housing rental units, affordable housing ownership units, market rate rental units, and market rate ownership units. The circle graph on the right then shows the numbers that correspond to each of those categories. The town's primary focus is on the affordable units, both on rent
1:23:52 So while the town did not achieve the affordable numbers by 2022, the town has made significant progress over the past three years. That progress is shown in the green on the chart. So in the affordable housing rental category, we've produced
1:24:23 We have 186 units of the 231 that they projected we needed. Where on the ownership side, we've produced 16. These are either under construction or have been completed 16 of the 175 needed. However, when you look to the projected, which is shown in red, you see we do start to close that gap. So on the rental side, we've surpassed what that needs assessment said we needed. And then on the ownership side, we get
1:24:52 Close to the 175, we're at 148 projected. The projected is based on known projects, and that projection is through 2030. And so those known projects include parcel phases 2B, parcel phase, then phases 3 and 4, the bridge program at a rate of 5 units per year.
1:25:12 The Small Site Development Opportunities, that's the two other vacant sites we have. And then it also includes the Snow Creek 8D Restricted Units, since those are a known project that are currently in the pipeline. So as shown, we will get pretty close to it on the ownership side as far as what that need was in 2017.
1:25:32 However, due to the age of the housing needs assessment at this point, it's approximately seven years old. The town has been working with Mono County, Inyo County, and the city of Bishop to work on defining the scope of work for an update to that study.
1:25:46 Each jurisdiction's needs are slightly different, but there's enough common ground that a regional study would be helpful, and it also would provide the detailed data for each jurisdiction that is needed. Some of the goals for the town on that update is to, one, update the actual numbers for the...
1:26:06 For what the housing needs are, and also to better inform on which areas we should focus on in the future, such as rental versus ownership, then which income groups we know we need to target as well, whether it's below 80%, whether it's 120 to 150 or even higher. Thus far from 2017 to now, we know there's a need across all income categories and for all types, so we've really been putting all of our efforts into
1:26:33 All aspects of housing to get it built, but going into the future, we can hopefully be a little more focused on where we're putting our efforts. With that, that concludes the update. If there's any questions on either the multimodal elements or the housing production numbers. Questions? Well, I have a question, but it's kind of unrelated. Basically, I've seen Townsend, Colorado pushing the slogan, no money for housing.
1:27:04 And what that essentially boils down to is the like 10% inclusionary housing, getting rid of the in-lieu fees and making companies build the housing. Is that something that we should look into here or discuss or what are your thoughts on those programs? Sure, I can touch on it and then...
1:27:27 I looked to Andy as well to provide a little bit additional input on that. So we used to have a 10% inclusionary requirement pre-2015. And that was for any project that was larger than 10 units had to provide 10% of the units as affordable. That was in place, I have to go back and confirm the exact date of when it was in place and when it, when it,
1:27:53 I know it expired in 2015. During that period, we actually got no units built. There was a handful of projects entitled and none of them ultimately moved forward really due to the cost and the issues with that. In 2015, we did an updated nexus study and updated housing mitigation ordinance, which results in kind of where our current housing mitigation ordinance is based off of, which said
1:28:18 All types of mitigation, whether it's payment of in-lieu fee, on-site units, off-site, provision of land, ultimately equates back to what the in-lieu fee would be, meaning if the in-lieu fee is $10,000 per unit and you're building 10 units, it's a value of $100,000, then you can't really build a unit for $100,000, but that's essentially what the value of that housing mitigation would be.
1:28:42 If the direction is to look into inclusionary in the future, it's something we can definitely bring back and provide additional information on, but the current housing ordinance just requires it to relate back to that nexus study. Thank you. Can I ask, you said it expired in 2015. When did it start? It did not expire. It was updated in 2015. But when was it enacted? I can get that number. Okay. Thank you.
1:29:09 The status quo was a policy choice by the council. It's not the only choice available to the town. It's just what the council at the time decided to do. But if you wanted to have no in lieu fee and actually have it be housing, I think broadly that would work. There might need to be some exceptions for projects with fewer than 10 units if you're going to have a 10% collusionary requirement. But cities all over the state have different degrees to which they will accept in lieu fees rather than building housing. Thank you.
1:29:41 Other questions? Yeah, we have a couple. So thank you for the update. This is just some random thoughts and ideas. First thing is that I know, Rob, I think you've been working with the District Ranger on the possibility of doing some housing over their administrative site. And I think we've all heard that the Farm Bill that had the language in there to make that possible, the House passed a continuing resolution. For some reason, that provision was carved, specifically carved out of the Farm Bill.
1:30:12 So that's a setback and a disappointment. It could come back in, but I know that's something you've been working with Fred Wong, and that's something we can hopefully resuscitate at some point. But it's in terms of talking with our representatives as he wins the election, but that could be something obviously to follow up on. Another thing is that in the 2017 needs assessment also included the Community Housing Action Plan.
1:30:36 And there was a recommendation in there for a TOT increase, which I know we've talked about Measure L, but I think my sense is that is one and the same thing, that that recommendation for a 2% increase, it coincides with what we voted to put on the ballot. So I just wanted to see if that nexus, if I'm correct in that. Yes, I can definitely flip to that. I do recall there was that recommendation. We had an effort back in 2020 that was looking at implementing that and then COVID happened and it
1:31:08 Ultimately kind of went to the wayside to be revisited now. Okay, so I just, it's a, Rob, you got to talk. Yeah, I was just going to add a little bit to that. So the recommendation to obviously do the ballot measure came from the STR Advisory Committee. Right. And that was a lot of information provided to that committee did come from that chat from that period of time. So I think, you know, while there's not going to be a direct connection, it's definitely.
1:31:37 Been in the process for quite some time and flowed through that process to where it is today. Yeah, it's been identified as a need going all the way back to 2017. The other thing is, Rob, you mentioned about a video that Betsy, I see you're in the room, you may have some information on that MLT was producing about the housing that's being built here in Mammoth Lakes. I think it was being produced for World Tourism Day. Is that video complete? Is it done? Is it available?
1:32:09 I know the portions that I start in is done. Okay, we'll get to that in a second. We'll get to that in a second. Hi, yes, Betsy Truax, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Yes, so Mammoth Lakes Tourism is part of a coalition of destination organizations.
1:32:26 focused on stewardship efforts called Destination Think, and as part of World Tourism Day on September 27th, many of these destinations were invited to share information, videos, so we did put together a video. It's very amateur. I was the iPhone videographer, but I'm happy to share that out because Destination Think actually tapped Mammoth Lakes as an example of a destination that is really doing great work on
1:32:55 On housing and workforce housing and affordable housing. Yeah, if you could share that link to something, that'd be great to have that. It's kind of interesting to have a DMO, marketing organization, you know, highlighting successes being made in housing as a destination. It'd be a great thing to be able to share. Yeah, so I know Rob has the link, so I don't know if you want to share it out or I can. Okay, great. I guess my final sort of observation is
1:33:19 Hearing about phase three, you know, things are changing with the Forest Service. I think, Rob, at some point would be great, I think, for council, maybe when the new council gets seated to maybe regroup on that a little bit and make sure that subsequent phases were all on the same page. We think this is what we need to do or not need to do. You know, go back and look at those parking issues again. Some of the things have been part of the ongoing conversations with this. And because this is an ongoing iterative process to make sure we're investing in the kind of housing, the kind of product that we think we need.
1:33:48 Whenever you think that's an appropriate time to do that, I think it'd be great to have those conversations. Obviously, we don't want to get out of sync with everybody, but that'd be a good conversation to have. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Robert, I would add on to that that sometime early in the new year, before we get too deep into our strategic planning process, maybe we have an item on going over what our housing fees and mitigations and all of that is so that
1:34:17 New and old council members will be up to speed with where we are and we can decide if there's a need to look at that as you suggested and alter those prices and things. You have to just add one thing. There's been some misinformation, if I could put it generously, about in the local media. I think it's really important for everybody to understand decisions get made by, you know, decades ago that we are obligated by law.
1:34:41 We don't have any choice to make any decisions around that. But I think to your point, to identify the decision space that actually is available to us and the kinds of things, Amanda, you're talking about, do we need to make changes to the in lieu programs and things like that to be dealing with current projects, things that we actually have some authority over, what's happened in the past, what's happened in the past, and we're bound by a lot of that stuff. So I think that's a great suggestion to take a look at that. Because that will inform part of our strategic plan on certain. Yeah. Public comment on this item.
1:35:12 No one's jumping up. Anything in the... Very good. And I would just add to Amanda's question that the 10% requirement was put in place in 2009. Okay, moving on then to 10.2, 2024 Spring and Summer Park and Recreation Department Program and Facility Presentations. Stu. Let's see. Are we starting the five-minute clock for the... Oh, no, never mind. Okay. The wood is brief, Bill.
1:35:55 Mr. Mayor, let me do the proverbial here. I do want to clearly respect everybody's time, so it's a pretty lengthy presentation, so I really just want to kind of hit the highlights. We presented to the Commission last night in great detail, and the entire team were able to contribute to the slide deck, so I will do my very best to pass on a lot of that good information to you, but it is the biannual.
1:36:24 It was getting so large and unwieldy that we kind of split it in two presentations. So this is kind of just the past spring summer and then we'll be back doing kind of the fall winter. So we'll kind of just roll through. If I miss a slide and you want to talk about a slide, just, you know, let me know and I can kind of go back. I think we're all familiar with the purpose of Parks and Rec and being an essential component of our community. Keywords, high quality, diverse.
1:36:53 All improved, all leading to an improved quality of life. Our vision statement, our mission statement, a couple of keywords there, multi-purpose, year round, indoor, outdoor, accessible to all residents and visitors. So this deck kind of covers programming, scholarship update, customer feedback from our customer satisfaction surveys, always very enlightening, kind of a little bit of a look-see through and what's happening in our parks and facilities.
1:37:21 Our vents, the pool and the rec zone. So this slide just kind of covers, you might want to see this in a larger screen, but I'll just keep it rolling for right now if that's okay. So this kind of gives you a snapshot of spring and summer. So again, this is kind of the spring programming plus the summer camps. So this kind of gives you a little bit of a look to see that we were just shy of a thousand youth program enrollments, which is kind of a big milestone for us.
1:37:48 632 program enrollments. And you can see that's kind of how we break up the age categories. We would like to kind of next fee schedule look at introducing kind of the, we have the active adult senior. I'd like to really think about introducing the active senior category. I think that might be quite meaningful and helpful for a lot of our active seniors. So we have about 20 camp products.
1:38:18 And you can see they're provided by in-house staff and the team were kind of the, as Doug said, probably the best team of camp councillors he's had since he's been with us in four years. So that's great. We also have third party providers and we provide all those lesson products as well. So you can see it's nine weeks of summer camps with about 25 different lesson products, camps and so forth throughout the six month season.
1:38:45 The key aspect you want to look at this slide is to, you know, if it's the sum of all parts, trying to make all the sum of the parts as equal as possible, if that makes sense, right? We don't want to kind of create a larger piece of pie. We want to kind of, you know, split the pies up into equal sizes just to make sure and ensuring that we're really kind of delivering a diverse array of opportunities, right, for our recreation providers.
1:39:09 You can see here we've done a pretty good job. You can see the larger ones there, certainly kind of Camp Mammoth, which was that new product at the CIC, skateboard camp, big biking camp, climbing camp and so forth. So you can kind of see our larger camp. So that's really the snapshot of that one. No surprise here, I think, with everybody, right? The largest participation is certainly our third to fifth grade.
1:39:31 And you can kind of see here the high school, those products are kind of the junior kind of CIT councillor products, right? So we're really, that's really kind of the workforce development end of the spectrum here by grade and the kind of the explorers are kind of introducing them to camp. So you can kind of see here that the green and the blue give you kind of a perspective of the total amount of registrations and the unique registrations.
1:39:56 Meaning that the difference of those two numbers would be the number of people that participated in multiple camps or programs, if that makes sense. And this kind of gives you, Doug was very impressed with this slide, a lot of information, hopefully it kind of makes sense. You can see, you know, 641 just summer camp registrations, total unique 435, so you can kind of see the difference with the delta. Serving 120 families, which is pretty cool. 281 kids on the wait list.
1:40:24 And we did something a little bit differently this year. We kind of, on June 1st, we kind of had a cutoff there, which I think you're all familiar with if you're a parent, that you couldn't kind of make any changes past that point. So it was really helpful for us throughout the season to have the family members and the parents commit to their camps, and then we can kind of work through the wait list a little bit more actively, right? So I think we're able to kind of get that on and a little bit better, you know, each year the team does that. No camp, that could be kind of a...
1:40:54 Not a smiley face, little symbol there. That basically means that those people did not register at the pre-registration period. You know what I mean? So every person that wanted to get into a camp got into a camp at pre-registration. So if you're one of those unlucky 108 people, that just means that you tried to register for a camp kind of while they were ongoing or in their season, right? So anyway, that explains that. And you can kind of see here a little bit the local, non-local,
1:41:24 You know, 302, 133, so about 70, sorry, 30% of our camps are comprised of visitors or non-residents. So I know that was a question that you were interested to know. Really cool slide, this one, you saw it in your slide deck as well. So 295 people got the camp of their choice, 102 got two camps, all the way down to a person that got seven camps. So we're trying to figure out how that person...
1:41:51 Got into seven camps. That was pretty cool. I don't know how they did that, but they just played the game, I think is kind of what they were trying to do. And if you really want to kind of get your child into seven camps, it can be done. After school programs, this kind of area has really exploded in the past, as you know. Most of our kind of counselors are just here for the summer season, so we're able to kind of extend their employment opportunities. You can see here gymnastics is obviously, you know, continues to grow. You know, we're even hosting
1:42:22 Those clinics at the CRC, really popular, little wreckers, used to be little sluggers, just a little bit more diverse, basketball and bike squads, so really good diverse programming. Tony Collisata Scholarship Fund, that amount is probably more than what we did in the entire year last year, 13,000, so again, this is just six months of scholarships. So again, if we're on pace to get through winter and then spring.
1:42:48 You can see we're probably going to easily get to the 20,000 plus 150 scholarship level, which is fantastic. So really excited about that. This is our little customer satisfaction survey. It goes to all the campers and their parents. 10% response rate, 64 of 640 gives you 10%. So pretty good response rate. We're pretty satisfied with that. We kind of switched it up this year to kind of state it. Did this product camp experience meet?
1:43:16 Exceed or did not meet your expectations. And you can kind of see the different colors there, right? So dark is exceeds. The middle kind of blue color meets expectations. And the green one there is did not. So you can kind of see here, I think, pretty familiar, which we, I think, all understand. You can see that registration process was just different, right? So, you know, we're obviously learning a lot about that. Availability of information.
1:43:44 Overall satisfaction, just a couple of concerns there from a few parents and pretty high quality of instruction as well. So overall, and you can see the biggest exceed met expectations with staff. So really good to see that, right? I think that's what we all want to see from our camp councillors. Adult programs, again, this is Mark Bell's World, summer camps and those other programs at Doug Gephardt.
1:44:12 So the adult program supervisor managed all these products and programs, which is fantastic. This just shows you kind of the split again. Softball tournaments are kind of a third-party program, right? That's when those providers come up and do the softball tournaments over the two weeks at Shady Rest. Men's and co-ed softball is our league. And you can kind of see here the split between pickleball, which is growing, kind of outpaced the Whitmore 50 Challenge, volleyball tournament and so forth. And I would see pickleball probably...
1:44:42 Meeting up with men's and co-ed softball here in the not too distant future. Spring and summer facility rentals, you can kind of see here the community center is still a really well used and utilized and certainly appreciated facility from our community, right? So you can see that is comprised of the majority of our rentals followed by- Stuart, sorry to interrupt real quick, that's a community center by the village, not the community recreation center. Yes, that's correct. Thank you. Yep. Okay.
1:45:11 Yeah, the CRC we don't rent, right? We just use it for our facilities and our programming. So Community Centre at the Village, Shady Rest Park, Whitmore Fields, Dog Agility, right? So that space that we programmed with the new fencing on Field 3, that is kind of that Dog Agility space. So you can kind of see that does generate quite a bit of revenue because that's very new. Pickleball Tournament.
1:45:35 The left number there you can see again in six months, you know, we're already at 16,000. The total last year was 17 and a half. So again, just seeing a lot of use in our facility. So really excited to see that. Community egg hunts. It was just a shame with our spring egg hunt that we did it in the blizzard, but that's how it goes. Yeah, it's life in the eastern Sierra. But thank you everybody that came out. Here's our town manager presenting Carol with the most number of laps.
1:46:04 As part of the Whitmore 50, I think Betsy took that photo, right? Another beautiful morning of the Whitmore pool before the sun came up. That was kind of later in the season. I think Carol got to, what, 88 miles? Yeah. Didn't quite get to 100. Didn't quite get to 100, so, you know. And she was swimming, you know, if not every day, twice a day, so just great to see the commitment from our lap swimmers.
1:46:27 A bunch of facility improvements here, right? So Riley and the Public Works Department went through the majority of our facilities and amenities just painting those. So you can kind of see here, we're just trying to keep our facility at the pool up to date. Visitation, really busy summer. I mean, that's great to see, right? Again, hard to kind of pinpoint where those numbers were. I think it's a compilation of a lot of those things. That does include kind of those free swim Sundays.
1:46:54 During Parks and Recreation Months, I know it's really popular for families, but again, we really like to see that progression of use. Average visitor per day, you can kind of see that continues to increase. Pretty sad, the 2020 number. Just want to kind of just move on from that period of time. Pool continues to do well in revenue, just over 35,000. So you can kind of see here the split is kind of really the swim lessons, the large majority admissions.
1:47:24 And swim team rental. So that's kind of the big three. Mark did say that actually we do see a lot of redemption for our hot showers. So it's really a popular venue and amenity for a lot of our campers and Pacific Crest hikers coming down to the pool and getting their hot showers. So it's good amenity. Swim lessons, just the takeaway here, you know, 108 was a little bit less than 121. So the team is trying to figure out how to kind of increase that capacity for next year.
1:47:54 And private lessons. The big change there was just working with the Husky Club. They have a program ELOP. Yep, I'll leave it at that. It's a good acronym that somebody knows, but I've forgotten since yesterday. But that's a program that we work with the school and we're serving those kids really to introduce them to water and water safety. So wonderful program. Takeaway from this slide, you can see really the demand is in tiny tots and level one.
1:48:23 And not so much in level four, right? So that's just showing you what was enrolled, what's available on the wait list. So clearly tiny tots in level one is an area we want to kind of work on and provide more opportunities for our parents to get their kids in their lessons. We do this keep stop start. If you had a look at this, there's some really good recommendations and thoughts, you know, very, very mindful feedback from our staff. So I won't need to go through all of those, but it does help us kind of plan.
1:48:51 To enhance our facility and operations each year. So I really appreciate their feedback. Stop selling cookies. I thought that was an interesting one. Not too sure where that came from. And then on the other side there, start with the vending machine. So summer play membership. This was a new program, as we know, that we introduced, that was able, if you bought this product, you're able to swim at the Whitmore Pool and play at the Mammoth Rec Zone. You can see we sold 51, just over 5,500.
1:49:20 Again, you know, split fairly evenly between the students, seniors and adults. Redemption at the pool, 623, mainly from our lap swimmers, right? So 531 adults, 21 families, three students, 58 senior. So 676 total, majority were redeemed at the pool, which is not surprising because we replaced essentially the season pass at the pool with this summer plan membership.
1:49:50 Just flipping over to the Mammoth Rec Zone, season highlights, great new facility, what a wonderful amenity for the community, really proud of that. We introduced that Summer Plain membership, lots of new programs and a real learning curve, I think, for the team, right, to understand what it takes to operate a 40,000 square foot building, beautiful sport court. I think everybody appreciated all the different kind of opportunities and games and activities they could do on that sport surface.
1:50:15 So again, here's just a slide on visitation. Just over 3,000 people came by. You can see, again, not surprising, I think I commented on this before, just a lot of our students, you know, getting into that facility, which is great. I mean, that's really what you want to see. Revenue mix, again, you can see a majority of our students, adults, youth admissions, just under $10,000. Again, you can see the first year, we just really wanted to kind of make that available to the community and see what people wanted to do and play.
1:50:46 How they want to play. You can see just a very open schedule. That's essentially from noon to 10 p.m. Now, just a caveat here as well. During summer camps, we did not open during the day, right? So for the public, it was really a Parks and Rec summer camp dedicated facility, right? So we really didn't want to mix public with our kids, right? It's their facility. So once the kids completed their camps for the day, then we opened up the facility.
1:51:15 Later in the evening, so that was really for adults and those programming, so gives you a snapshot there. Fun stuff, I think the adults had a good time as well, everything from basketball, volleyball, pickleball, cricket, and even soccer. There we go. Youth program, started a basketball, kind of an instructional basketball, back to school, and Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey have kind of got in there lately to do some triads and dry land before the ice was laid down.
1:51:42 Summer play memberships. This is the redemption. So not nearly as many clearly as the pool, new product, new year, 53 total redeemed. So certainly an area of opportunity for us, particularly as we've realized again with those students, you know, everyone that paid, you know, $3 every time to come into that facility, really got to get them to buy that part. So it just makes so much sense, right? So we'll keep working on that for next year. And we hosted a wonderful town's 40th anniversary.
1:52:11 Even though it looks blue sky, we all know it was not quite blue. It's a bit wet, a bit cold, a bit cloudy, but I think we all had a great time. And again, that's just another value of that facility. And we also hosted, if you did get there, the county's Kitapalooza. That was in June. So that is it. Hopefully that was not too fast, enough information. And hopefully it was helpful for you. So thank you for the opportunity. Questions?
1:52:42 For Stu? Or comments? Well, I guess I just appreciate that at Kittapalooza they were giving away puppies, so I appreciate that we were not giving away puppies at our kids' events this summer. Thank you for the update. I know someone about a puppy. Maybe we can do hot chocolate and some drinks. Puppies. Anything done? No. Any public comment? Online public? Very good. Thank you.
1:53:14 Thank you. Thanks for the detail. I appreciate it. Thank you. Yeah. Hopefully it's helpful. Moving forward to 10.3, review of municipal code 15.24.100, lofts, mezzanine requirements, California building code specific to short-term rentals. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. I'm going to kick this off and hand it over.
1:53:40 to our building official, Tom Perry, to talk about more of the detail aspects. So we brought this forward. There has been a significant amount of confusion in the community, and that's coming forward to us, to council. And so we wanted to walk through some of the details and some of the timing with which changes were made. And nothing has been made recently as far as changes to
1:54:09 The question here is with the Towns Municipal Code.
1:54:36 The one that you read off, it's attached to the agenda item. Hopefully you were able to read that. It was only a couple of pages as municipal codes go. But it definitely spells out the differences and it's solely focused on lofts. And again, this comes from, Tom will update this, information back in 2017 where there was a lot of concern about lofts in the area. And we needed to sort of solve for what was out there.
1:55:06 This kind of came about with regard to inspections. There are inspections that are town-focused come in the form of seeking an opportunity for a short-term rental business. So if you have a short-term rental business, you have to get your property inspected back when we did the certified properties a few months ago.
1:55:30 We did make edits to that process. You know, we went from the TOT certificates to certified properties. In that sort of space, one of the key areas we did was there were no more grandfathering in of rentals that may have been already in action back in prior to, I think it was 2015 when we implemented that. Some were not inspected.
1:55:58 Many others are inspected. I mean, there's many inspections that go on every year. But the town has, you know, a set of parameters we're looking for with an inspection, and that's related to town municipal code. The inspection forms themselves, and we'll get to some of the mitigating efforts that we're going to talk about here at the end of this presentation, but they're sort of vague in the sense of
1:56:22 Making sure that it matches the Towns Municipal Code, right? We've all seen the red book on the corner there. The Towns Municipal Code book is quite large. But in specifics, the building area here, that one checkbox, we're going to make some adjustments to the checkoff list and get a little bit more detailed, really to make sure that no mistakes are made for wherever that may be in that process. So I'll turn it over to Tom, and then I want to kind of
1:56:51 Close up at the end. We did have a good meeting today with the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors. Really appreciate their time. We spent probably a little more than an hour on the phone really addressing questions and concerns and challenges, but also what we came away from is some requests that they would like for us to do, and I think we're certainly
1:57:14 Prepare to do that and want to do that in a very timely manner so that we improve the level of communication and I think minimize any sort of confusion that may be out there. And so I appreciate that partnership and we'll look forward to working more closely on that in the future. But I'll turn it over to Tom and then proceed after that. Okay, thanks, Bob.
1:57:38 Good evening, Town Council. I just wanted to start off with a brief history of the lofts and the codes that we have on our books for the local code. If you may recall, some of you were here, I think, back then. 2015, we had the Quality of Life ordinance that was passed, and that basically kind of set the stage for the issuance of business tax certificates for transient rentals for...
1:58:01 Dwelling units, condos, and a lot of condos with lofts. Prior to that, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department and us knew about the safety issues that we had with lofts, and there's a lot of them out there. But it wasn't a factor until we started formally issuing business tax certificates to allow transient overnight rentals in these units. So when I took the job in April of 2016,
1:58:28 It had actually gotten, the whole loft situation had gotten a lot of people in an uproar. My predecessor, the building official before me and the fire code official before me recognized these safety hazards that we have in lofts and they basically had an outright prohibition on the rental of any loft units at all, total prohibition. So that set the stage for a lot of people to be quite upset over the whole thing.
1:58:55 We do have a lot of safety issues with these lofts. We're aware of stairs, but also head clearance, lack of escape rescue, inadequate floor area, ventilation, natural light, those kind of things are prevalent in these lofts. They're pretty widespread in town, so it's a pretty big issue. So my charge when I took the job in 2016 was to establish minimum standards at the local level.
1:59:23 To basically set the baseline of what constitutes a safe loft and legal loft versus an unsafe illegal loft in the unbuilt or excuse me in the unaltered environment in the as-is condition of these lofts. But at the same time the charge was also to find a solution or come up with a means or a method to still somehow allow the rentals to proceed. So it was a it's kind of a daunting task because we didn't want to do a total prohibition on all rentals.
1:59:52 We're all units with lofts, but we didn't want to just turn a blind eye to these glaring safety issues that we knew existed for many years. So through that, I got to work basically reaching out to a lot of people back then, a lot of stakeholders, realtors, architects, builders, property managers, and I definitely really had a lot of meetings with those folks to discuss this issue.
2:00:17 What happened ultimately was that I went through 50 years of code data going all the way back to 1964 through all the decades to now. And basically when I went through the code data and all these code provisions that go back, I basically tried to select the ones that were the least restrictive provisions because there are conflicting provisions in current code versus old code. And so what provisions should I use? What standards should I use?
2:00:43 I just basically selected the ones that were a little less restrictive than others to try to make it as forgiving as I can, but still kind of maintain a baseline that has code basis to establish safety for these units with lofts. A good example of that are stairs, and that seems to be the hot topic now are the width of stairs, and that seems to have come up pretty intensely in recent times.
2:01:08 For current code, you know, from the 1980s to now, 36 inches has been the standard for stairs. But through the 1960s and 1970s, 30 inches in stair width was allowed. So I selected that width because it was allowed for many years through the 60s and 70s to basically access small areas at an occupant load of less than 10.
2:01:31 And every loft that we have in town is basically going to have that occupant load of less than 10. They're very small. So I thought it fitting to use that criteria for the 30-inch standard for the width of stairs. I point out to you that even in today's code, through the entire last 50 years of code, 30-inch wide stairs are the most forgiving standard that's ever been out for stairs. They've been 36. They still are. Commercial is 44.
2:01:59 The residential code since 2011 allows a reduction down to 31 and a half inches in width for stairs for one and two family dwellings, but we haven't had anything in the code in the last 50 years that goes all the way down to 30. So I just wanted to also share some quick data and some quick stats with stairs because they are dangerous. There's a history with these things as it relates to accidents. I point out that according to Reuters,
2:02:29 Between 1990 and 2012, nearly 25 million people were treated in emergency departments for stair-related injuries. That averaged out to be about 38 injuries per 10,000 people in the U.S. each year. And then according to the Tenge law firm, more than 1 million injuries are caused by stairway falls each year in the U.S. Stairway accidents are the second leading cause of injury, with motor vehicles being first. And then stairway accidents result in 12,000 facilities each year, and that date is as recent as last.
2:02:58 Year 2023 from a law firm. Then another law firm by the name of Galfanberger basically established or has determined that there's five top leading areas where these accidents occur, one of which is rented apartments or houses, and that's in addition to construction sites, factories, retail stores, and amusement parks. So I thought I'd just share that data. Stairs can be and are dangerous by themselves.
2:03:28 And they're also to be used as a means of egress. So when you factor in the safety factor with stairs and how they relate to get people out of the building in the event of a fire or an emergency, as well as getting firefighters in to make rescues, it's a pretty critical component. Now with that in our code, we had to basically establish some means or method to still allow rentals to proceed even though a lot of these lofts have issues, not just stairs but had clearance issues and that kind of thing.
2:03:59 So when a unit has discovered or has issues with it that are safety features that are in violation of code even when the unit was built originally, and by the way, a lot of these condo lofts, I can tell you, have things that didn't even comply with code at the time they were built, whether it was original construction or shortly after, a lot of these didn't comply with code at the time of original construction. We had to come up with some type of
2:04:29 Method, if you will, to still somehow allow rentals for these units despite these issues. So we came up with a method or a condition where if we do have a loft that has a problem or some kind of safety issue and it's infeasible if not impossible to fix, which a lot of these are, we have a setup where people, those two occupants that could be in the loft can be relocated to sleep in another area of the unit, such as another bedroom.
2:04:56 Or a fold-out couch with a bed or something like that. And then requires a simple placard to be placed up in the loft with the removal of the beds to not facilitate, so it doesn't facilitate sleeping. We call it the net neutral revenue solution. And it has been used quite a bit over the last seven years since this has been in code. It's not perfect, but it has been used quite a bit.
2:05:22 Honestly, I've not had any complaints in seven years on it. People appear to be thankful to be able to rent their unit despite it not being perfect, having the two people sleep up there. So it's worked out pretty well. But it seems like there's been a little bit of criticism on that in recent times. I also would like to point out that our code has alternative methods and means built into it. So if people can't meet the letter of our code, say back to stairs, stair width, if they have a stair width.
2:05:50 That's less than 30 inches. They can do a repair in that scenario and bring those stairs to the 30 inch width that was the code of yesteryear instead of today's code of 36 inches. That's supported by the Health and Safety Code for the reuse of existing methods and materials of construction. And we do have that rolled into our code and it's been there along with everything else that we have in the code. And like Rob mentioned, we haven't changed the code at all in seven years. Not one single.
2:06:19 And this has been on our website and it has been out there for quite some time. So some actions, Rob had kind of touched on that. Some of the actions that I have on my radar screen right now and something that's become very evident to me is that we need more training. I think we need to have more training and we also need to have, potentially if this works out for folks, individual training where I actually accompany one of these inspectors out.
2:06:45 On one of the scheduled TOT inspections where we can really drill down on this stuff. I think that's needed and that's become evident to me in the last two weeks. A few other actions here. We have a loft inspection checklist that apparently has a link that doesn't work. We need to fix that. There's also a link that we used to have in Municode in the section. It's not there now. So I've placed an inquiry with Municode to have that added back in. So there's a quickly accessible link to
2:07:14 A flow chart that I have developed that ties this information together and makes it fairly more easily understandable for those laypersons out there. And then finally, we're going to develop a checklist, a separate checklist that Rob had mentioned, because even though the code in our local code, the section is fairly brief, it is code, it's building code, it's mundane, it's not exciting, it's tough for people to read. I'll, you know, I'll get, I'll say that.
2:07:45 I think developing a very, very simple abbreviated checklist that inspectors can use and other people can use too, I think, would be very helpful. So those are a few examples of the actions that I'm planning on taking to try to help folks with this in general. So with that, that's basically an overview of the code aspect of this, and I'll turn it back over to the council.
2:08:11 I've got some more things I would like to add just real quick and hopefully remember your thoughts for Tom's questions. But I wanted to kind of point out too in the code here and I think it's also in the state building requirements that there is a differentiation between short-term rental and residence and long-term. And it's based on familiarity with the unit, someone who lives in that full-time.
2:08:38 As opposed to someone who would be coming up and utilizing it for a night or a couple of nights. So that was sort of recognized in that process and there's a differentiation in there. So that kind of puts it firmly in the STR realm, right? And we talk about, you know, the town issues a business tax certificate to an operator and then in the new process here we certify the property as legal for nightly rentals.
2:09:07 Having something that does not comply with our own code, does not comply with any building codes of any time, is where it becomes problematic to certify a property. So with our inspectors that we had out there, we had five inspectors, we're down to three inspectors now, and basically based on this process, I'll say that out loud, we are, this mitigation effort is designed
2:09:37 As Tom said, to kind of make the value of the nightly rental consistent with that slight being utilized, right, that loft being utilized. The calculation for occupancy is based upon the number of bedrooms, and you get basically two occupants per bedroom and then plus two for general other areas. And I think it has a maximum of 10 with the state.
2:10:06 State code, is that correct? Unless there's some extenuating circumstances for the facility. But when we talk about this net neutral revenue, it means that that same calculation, and again,
2:10:21 When someone comes to me and they say, you know, we have a three-bedroom, you know, we can calculate exactly what that would be as far as the number of occupants that are allowed. And when you think about a value for short-term rentals, aside from any other thing as far as location and all those things, it's usually occupancy that really drives that the most. And so with regard to this process, it makes the occupancy the same whether you could sleep in it or not.
2:10:48 And so that's the maybe a little bit deeper explanation on that net neutral revenue component. And frankly, that wasn't required when you think about the work that Tom was doing. He was going through and sort of firming up how to, you know, legitimize these spaces and determine what good sets of ground rules based upon building codes were.
2:11:15 But then also recognizing the fact that we need to find a way to not eliminate those rentals that are out there. So Tom talked about a couple of things that in his realm that we're doing. We're also working with the Board of Realtors. Similar to disclosure documents, we're going to create a one-page sort of summary explanation of the situation.
2:11:41 And the mitigating efforts, what would need to happen and how that can be accomplished and work through. We're going to provide a draft of that and work with the realtors to make sure that the tone, the messaging, everything kind of works for their environment. We look to have that done fairly quickly because they've also invited us to the membership meeting, I think it's the 24th of October. We'll be able to present to the
2:12:11 The realtor is in town. We would like to have all that stuff finalized by that period of time. And again, I just want to appreciate the outreach and the communication because talking about it, working through what may be supportive of both sides in the level of understanding and how we minimize the impact on either buyers, sellers, operators of short-term rentals, that was very much appreciated.
2:12:41 I'll kick it back to council for any questions. Questions, John? I don't have any questions. I know that there's been a lot of confusion and concern about all this. This is an information item for us, so I guess we don't need any action at this point, but hopefully this gets to the various levels of inspectors, people inspecting for real estate purchase, people inspecting for nightly rental compliance.
2:13:08 So, well, thanks a lot for the update. The only question I had is when you did that 50-year look back, that was in the state code, is that right? Correct, yes. Yeah, it wasn't our code because we don't exist for 50 years. So you're looking at the state body of code? Correct, yes. Going back to 1964. Okay, good. Yeah, thank you. That's it. 64 being the year our first condo was built. Okay. Amanda? Thank you for explaining everything. I don't have any.
2:13:39 Questions at this time. Thanks. Do we have any idea how many of those old units have been holding STR permits to this point that would now be disallowed? I mean, I know they would have been disallowed through the years, except they fell through the cracks because we didn't have the ability to do the inspections and everything else. Sort of getting down to the core, how many more angry people can I expect calls from? I don't have that number, Mr. Sauser. I think that
2:14:12 And we're treating this as we go through the inspection process, right? I talked about how we've got some that have come up recently through these TOT or the certified property inspections and that every certified property requires to be inspected every four years. So we'll work through that process of inspection.
2:14:38 When you say disallowed, the only thing disallowed is sleeping in that. It's not disallowed for short-term rental businesses. And there's mitigating efforts for that. Thank you. Public comment from the public. So there's, do I have to do anything here? No. So there's a lot to say about all this. I know you guys have been CC'd on emails. The problem, I think, because what it looks like now currently is that
2:15:17 This, like, compliance stuff with the lofts is going to affect all these units like Sierra Park Villas, Sherwin Villas, Crystal Villas East, Crystal Villas West, Sierra Manors, all of those complexes that were built pretty much like when Mammoth was blowing up and nothing was really regulated. So right now what's happening is you're getting
2:15:46 Some, like, exact same floor plans, exact same blueprint, some of these are passing TOT inspections and some of them aren't. So now it comes down to, okay, like, whose fault is this? Like, why three years ago did somebody's unit, you know, pass the TOT inspection and now it's selling and now it's not passing? So now it's getting sort of finger pointed, I think, to the inspectors being responsible for, like,
2:16:15 Being the people to be in charge of like this massive, you know, issue that's happening. I don't know what the situation is, how it works with town, like why the town, why the inspectors can't work for the town, because then I think that that would probably be more like accurate regulation and it would go back to the town, because now they're just able to kind of be like, well, wasn't our problem, it was the inspector's problem, you know.
2:16:44 I could go on and on about that. But the other thing that I don't understand is like the safety issue aspect. Safety issues are just safety issues. So if it's a safety issue for a nightly rental.
2:16:59 Little kids sleeping in the loft. It's also a safety issue for a local family that's living in the loft, and it's probably even more important for the local family living there, who's there all the time, probably has multiple kids living in the lofts, because we all know that, like, we don't have enough space in Mammoth. So whether, I just don't think it matters. Like, it's either going to be regulated, I think, for every, you know, sort of.
2:17:27 Aspect of rental or not. Like it just doesn't make sense to do STR versus monthly and one's okay, one's not. The other thing is that the, I don't know what I just had written this note, but it was something that Tom had said about the stairs where I don't think it only has to do, it has to do with, from my understanding with fire department stuff, it has to do with getting a stretcher up there. So.
2:17:57 That also affects a local family that, you know, happens to have somebody have a heart attack in the loft and they need to get a stretcher up there. Doesn't matter. Oh, that was what it doesn't matter if they're familiar with the unit or not. And then I also wonder in like 2016 when 2015 when this new code compliance like quality of life ordinance came about if I guess you were a new official then if you knew of
2:18:27 All of these units in town that weren't built to code. Because I feel like that would affect how things were regulated. Like, hey, if we know thousands of floor plans are not, were never built to code, then how would that affect things? I think that that's kind of it. Thank you. Thank you. Any further public comment? This is an informational item. We will move on. I asked you, there was nothing, right? Yeah.
2:19:06 Yes. Rob, can I ask, what's the difference between a long-term rental and a short-term rental? Like, why do we enforce this rule on short-term rentals and not long-term rentals? So the code, and I tried to address this earlier in my comments, and Tom probably has a better explanation as far as the building code references for transient occupancy versus residential. And that's, I think, it's clearly distinct.
2:19:38 In our code references that if a loft for residential purposes is considered a bedroom and then differentiates that for short-term rental on that basis. So, Tom, I don't know if there's sections on that where the short-term rental versus long-term is designated? Basically, there is a distinction in the code between
2:20:03 You know, transient and non-transient renters. It has been kind of a cornerstone for a very long time that what we're touching on about familiarity and that kind of thing. So we have since 2011, we have, you know, of course, we get more codes over time, right? Just what we need, right? So, but we have the CBC, the California Building Code and the California Residential Code. What gave rise to the Residential Code was a recognition by the Code Council that there's just generally a lesser hazard across the board for
2:20:33 I'd also add that the environment back in 2016 when I took this job was that the game changer again was the quality of life ordinance. So since we're now
2:21:01 Have a formal connection. The town to these units where we're formally issuing a BTC, it changed it from where we knew about these problems, but it was only going to be relegated to family and private owners and their guests. Now we're actually allowing formally people to stay there on a transient basis. So that was the environment back in 2016 was that we had to do something about it. We could no longer just let it go.
2:21:29 And the standards you find in the code, by the way, are minimum standards. Anything less than that is illegal. That's always been the structure of the codes, and that definitely is the structure of our local code, too. So if somebody meets or exceeds these standards, that's fine. But these are like a minimum baseline standard that establishes fire life safety in these lofts.
2:21:50 Okay. I guess my question was more like do we inspect long-term rentals? We do not. So we have a very lenient long-term rental. In fact, you don't have to even have a business license if you have just one long-term rental. So we don't even have visibility to those. So we don't have authority to go into long-term rentals and say you have your stairs are too narrow? No, we don't. Okay.
2:22:13 And I think, just if I could, I think, I mean, that's the crux of this, is that the town is issuing business licenses. And so when the town is issuing a business license, I'll turn it over to Andy, there's levels of liability that come into this. Isn't that, I mean, that's the crux of all this, right? Well, and we have a way of getting in there. We can require people to let us in as a condition of getting a license. Absent that, the only way to inspect someone's home...
2:22:37 Whether it's a long-term rental or owner-occupied is with an inspection warrant, which is issued by a court. And that's not something we can really do at scale. Okay. Thank you. When this issue does come up, and Tom, correct me if I'm wrong, is with a residential, is they seek to do a remodel. Then there's certain expectations that they bring the conditions up to modern standards. And that's why it was very important, and Tom said earlier about a repair.
2:23:07 And that distinction is very important, right? He considers mitigating a problem of two narrowest stairs would be a repair, and that would allow for that code at any one time, which is the 30-inch minimum, versus a remodel, which would require the 36 inches. But the point of saying all this is that if someone who owns a residence comes in,
2:23:34 With one of these units and wants to do a full remodel, then they could bump into the building standards in that challenge. But I think that's probably the extent from a residential aspect that we would encounter that. These are really not codes that Mammoth has written. These are state mandated codes, correct? It's a compilation of state codes over time, yes. Right. It's important that people point the finger at us.
2:24:04 All we're doing is enforcing what should have been enforced back in 64. Well, and I will say that the area where we have made our own standards is that Tom is really, really trying to find ways of making stuff okay. So he's using the discretion that he has as a building official within the building code to try to find solutions is what's happening. But the underlying standards, right, they're state standards. Right. I just want people out there to understand that.
2:24:32 Not something we did to try and hurt somebody. That's the way it's always been. That's why I didn't want to just kind of invent numbers out of thin air because that becomes very undefendable at the end of the day. So I thought it was very important to have code basis for what we have in our local code because that was state code going all the way back to 1964 to present day. Thank you, guys. Moving on to consent. 11.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 18, 2024.
2:25:01 11.2, adopt the resolution approving an amended conflict of interest code. 11.3, authorize the use of 515-2024 third budget adjustment allocation of $35,000 to complete the child care project. 11.4, accept check register 917-24, check register 920-24, and 925-24. Anyone want to pull anything from consent?
2:25:30 I would accept a motion. Go ahead. I move that we approve the consent agenda. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Whiteworth? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Moving on now, I believe what we will do at this point is take a short break to allow us to get up and stretch legs and stuff a bit. So it is currently...
2:26:05 625. At 635, we will bang the gavel. Does that work for everybody? Thank you. Can I ask you a question? So, one minute? Can you show up? Want to partake in any... Thanks. Nope. Not yet. Okay, if we can get everybody to return to their seats, please. Excuse me, sorry. For those of you paying attention from home, we are going to change the next section. We're going to start...
2:36:29 Dealing with 12.1, then 12.3, then 12.4, then 12.2. Yes, I went to Levining. I cannot count. That being said, we are going to 12.1, time extension request, Limelight Hotel Project Dentative Track Map, TTM 22-002 Entitlement. Kim. Thank you, Mayor and Councilmembers.
2:36:58 The application before you is a time extension request. This was submitted by the Limelight Hotel project proponent. A one-year extension is requested to be added to the life of the tentative track map component of the project entitlement. The tentative track map approved a reconfiguration of the six parcels that combined make up the project site. The reconfiguration was
2:37:27 To make these parcels into two lots and a subdivided lot one into 15 resort condominium units within the limelight hotel footprint. So the tentative tract map on just generally tentative tract maps automatically expire 24 months after the approval date unless an extension of time is requested and granted by the original approval authority.
2:37:52 The track map entitlement for this project would have expired on July 6th of this year. However, we did receive a time extension request prior to that expiration date. And at that time, the expiration date is suspended until action is taken on this application. So if approved, the requested time extension would extend the life of the track map to July 6th, 2025.
2:38:18 The extension would provide adequate time for the project proponent to complete eight outstanding engineering division conditions of approval, which are required to be satisfied prior to approval of the final map. So just as an example, the conditions of approval that are outstanding include a subdivision guarantee.
2:38:42 This is required at least 30 days prior to the Planning and Economic Development Commission approving a final map. Another requirement is survey monumentation. And limelight is to confirm installation of the monuments or provide a bond of $15,680. The town staff also needs to approve revised CC&Rs that the applicant has provided.
2:39:10 Proof of payment of the Mono County taxes is required prior to taking action on the final map approval. A transit shelter easement and a snow storage easement. The town received comments from the applicant on both of those easements. And so there's some back and forth between the town and the project proponent on those items. And then the final item is a slope easement vacation.
2:39:39 And engineering staff needs to schedule this for town council approval for vacation of that, for a vacation resolution. So once all of those items are completed, the final map approval can move forward. But until that time, the final map application is not complete. And so with these outstanding items, unfortunately,
2:40:06 The final map was not considered timely filed, and the applicant team was under the impression that they had exercised the entitlement for the project by commencing construction and submitting a final map application, but due to the outstanding conditions, technically the final map can, or the tracked map can expire.
2:40:31 Since there has been steady progress on the project construction and ongoing efforts to complete the final map approval process, staff has been able to make affirmative findings for approval of the time extension request and therefore staff recommends the town council approve the resolution making the required municipal code findings for approval for tenant...
2:40:56 Time extension request number 24-002 with the conditions that are recommended in the resolution. And that does it for me, unless you have any questions. The proponents of the project are based in Colorado, is that correct? That's correct. If they filed any comment, I mean, is there anything that we need to know from them? I'm assuming they're not here, so they're happy with this. Is that fair to say? Right. Unfortunately, Andy Reid, who works with Aspen Hospitality, he wasn't able to make this Zoom call.
2:41:35 But they did submit a letter as part of their time extension request application, which indicated that they really are making a good faith effort to timely file their final map and proceed with construction. Okay, so there's nothing we need to know from them as part of whatever we're going to do tonight. Okay, thank you. Further comment from the Dias? Public comment on this issue? Jamie? Okay.
2:42:06 Moving forward, then I would accept a motion or? I move that we approve the resolution making the required municipal code findings and approving time extension request 24-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. A second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes.
2:42:40 Passes for, oh, thank you all. Moving on to item 12.3, Snow Creek Development Agreement discussion. Nolan. Great, thank you. So this discussion item's ongoing discussion related to the proposed Snow Creek Development Agreement amendment. The focus on this was really to highlight what would be allowed or occur.
2:43:26 For the Snow Creek 8 development with the amended DA in place and then without a development agreement in place. So the staff report in the table in the agenda packet walks through all the distinctions between all the various aspects of the project with regards to the development agreement and the project. So I'll provide us a quick summary of those distinctions. So the first one is what? Before we start real quick.
2:43:54 So the distinction, is there a draft development agreement that's been proposed? Yeah, so the, I mean, the drafts are the terms that have been the ongoing discussion, the actual language. It's in draft form. We can bring that forward if we think it's appropriate at a meeting level. If not, it would come for it. No, that's fine. I just wanted, so we're, the comparison is being made for proposed draft language. It's on the table at this point. Correct. So really the,
2:44:23 The focus, I guess we can start with that one. The focus of the proposed amendments from the developers asking for an additional 20 years on the life of the DA, so to extend it to 2045, and a removal of the language where they lose a day for each day construction of the 18-hole golf course and hotel have not started. In exchange for that, the town's proposing
2:44:45 To require the continued operation of the existing nine-hole golf course for the life of the DA with some parameters for the operation built into that. The permanent protection of the roughly 61 acres of the existing golf course that would permanently protect it for open space and recreation uses. And then including an option for additional summer and winter recreational amenities on that expansion area. So those are the proposed amendments that have
2:45:13 And discussed with the developer in the town and at least at the staff level and the developer are in agreement as far as those amendments. Okay. Thank you. So just to walk through this, the amount of development or the scope of the development allowed does not change with or without the DA. That development proposal is outlined in the master plan. The DA simply
2:45:42 Memorializes that that is what was proposed and then vests that within the development agreement. So outside of change to the master plan, the scope of the development would not allow, would not change. So it allows for up to 790 residential units, up to 400 hotel rooms, which are counted as a half unit in the master plan based on their size. Allows for commercial uses and then recreation, the expansion of the 18-hole golf course.
2:46:12 One distinction, the next one is on the housing mitigation. So with the DA, it locks in place that the developer is responsible to provide 47 units of on-site deed-restricted housing. These would be ownership units. Payment of approximately $2.6 million in lieu fees. Then use of their existing FTE credits, which the developer owns from a...
2:46:37 previous development transaction that provided land for the Aspen Village affordable housing apartments. Based on those fees and then based on the approximate subsidy that would require to
2:46:54 Purchase 47 units if the town was going out and purchasing units to then deed restrict them. The value of that housing mitigation package ranges from $9.8 million to $12.2 million. If the DA were not in place, the project would simply be subject to the current housing mitigation in effect at the time of building permits submittal. We can't predict where that will go in the future, but based on the current fiscal year fee schedule, the project would be required to pay.
2:47:22 The community benefits, community benefits is the bulk of what a DA provides. These are benefits that are above and beyond what zoning could provide for. I'm not going to walk through these in detail. The ones shown in red are the ones that would go away if the DA were to not be in place. That's the $10 million additional financial contribution.
2:47:52 The parkland in excess of what would otherwise be required. The programming of public spaces and the land for the propane tank storage. The last two, it's not necessarily saying that if they built a project, those wouldn't happen. There's just no mechanism to require those elements. All the others shown in blue will generally occur with or without the DA. And really, they become, if it makes financial sense to...
2:48:19 To produce those, such as the golf course, whereas some of the others have already been completed, such as the egress easement and the preservation of the Mammoth Creek open space corridor. Next one is the vested rights. So this is really what a developer seeks in a DA is that guarantee of their assurances to build the project and then the vesting of what regulations they're going to be subject to should they build the project so when they go to get financing.
2:48:49 The bank has that understanding of what they're financing and what they're pursuing. So in this case, it vests the building permit fees and the development impact fees based on the fiscal year 2009-10 rates. The building fees do increase annually based on the California Construction Cost Index. With those increases from 2009 to current, they're saving about $1,200 per triplex based on what current fees would be.
2:49:17 The development impact fees in 2009-2010, they were substantially higher. It was about $50,600 for a triplex. However, the DA does allow them to pay a lower rate if the diffs were to be decreased, which they were. They're about half that rate currently at $23,000 per triplex. The DA also vests all current and future entitlements. So this includes any existing tentative maps and use permits for the project.
2:49:46 And then any future entitlements they get, it vests those for the life of the DA. Without the DA, those entitlements are valid for two years with an option for up to a six-year extension. And generally, once construction is commenced or a final map is recorded, those entitlements are then considered to be exercised. And lastly, it vests the governing documents. This includes all the three iterations of the master plan, the general plan and zoning code that were in effect in 2009. The DA were to go away.
2:50:16 The project would still be subject to the 2007 master plan. However, that could be potentially amended. It requires a whole different process to amend it that is lengthy and isn't a guarantee for anyone. And then it would be subject to a current general plan and zoning code for anywhere the master plan is silent.
2:50:36 Lastly, looking at recreation and open space amenities. So if the DA, at least with the proposed amendments in place, it would guarantee the operation of the existing golf course. It would also allow for the provision of interim trails on the 94-acre golf course expansion area.
2:50:54 They would permanently protect that open or the existing golf course for open space and recreation uses. Without the DA, there's no mechanism to require the operation of the golf course or those trails or to permanently protect that area. The last one, it is important to point out, the master plan designates the existing golf course areas recreation. However, that is something that a future developer could ask to be changed. There's no guarantee that the town would
2:51:24 Consider that change, but it's something they could ask for. If it's permanently protected, then there's no option to change it. So just a quick summary of what happens if the SDA expires, the town loses those benefits, the project would be subject to current building and diff fees, the housing mitigation would be based on the current housing ordinance, the developer could still build the project outline in the master plan, then future entitlements would be subject to the timelines in the zoning code.
2:51:55 And lastly, the there's no requirement to operate the current golf course. With that, that completes the kind of summary. I'm available to answer questions as well as the developer, Chuck Landy. Questions? I don't have a question, but I have a comment. Thank you for your presentation. I wanted to say that I'm happy to see a developer building housing instead of paying in lieu fees. John? I'm going to, I'll defer to you if you go first, Bill. I've got it.
2:52:32 I need some more detailed information. I was a little confused while we were doing that. I have several things in here, and I'm probably going to jump all over the place on you. If this isn't done, then the fees he's required aren't necessarily today's fees for housing mitigation. It would be whatever is in place when he submits his building permits. Is that correct? Correct. And so the number in the report is just the current fiscal year.
2:53:00 Because that's all we know for sure. We don't know where future fees will go. So what's missing for me here, programming of public spaces, Great Lawn, Outfitters Cabin, et cetera, I would want to see that spelled out. Who's going to program it? Who's going to run it? Whose expenses are they? So I don't want someone to be able to come to me and say, we did this so lousy that none of the things that we put in there are enforceable.
2:53:28 So I want to make sure that the operation of the golf course is enforceable and in a playable condition. We've had someone say before that USGA can provide us with those. We could contact them and find out if they have it. If not, Mr. Landy himself is a golf course developer. Perhaps he could provide us with what the verbiage needs to be for a well-maintained golf course.
2:53:57 Time of operation. Obviously, we can't say it's got to go from Memorial Day to Thanksgiving because we never know what our snow conditions are, but something in there to talk about snow conditions and the fact that it needs to be operated. The land that the current course sits on, I have it written here somewhere, to be protected.
2:54:25 And not built perhaps some kind of environmental easement or whatever that takes. But also I would like to see the land that the back nine was going to go on protected as well. So if a hotel developer wants to come in and finish those nine into an 18 at some time in the future, as long as we leave that course viable in the permit, that land is available for that. What public good from that land would be in terms of it's been suggested we're going to have paths.
2:54:55 Cross-Country skiing, there's potentiality for a lot of things there. Again, I would like to see it spelled out in such a way that we know those are going to happen. Who's going to program it? Who's going to pay for it? Who's going to maintain it? So that we have some certainty and not just vague suggestions that maybe we will do this. Right now, I think that is the bulk of my scattered comments. More to come.
2:55:28 The operation of the golf course, and I don't know if we can do this. We talked to Andy about this a little earlier today. Everything right now is tied to the DA. I would like to see that if we get it in the DA that it's going to run for the life of the DA, that that golf course will stay in perpetuity, not just for the 20-year life of the DA. As an old guy, I can tell you that 20 years really isn't all that long. And right now, those are the specifics I'm looking for.
2:55:59 My preference, of course, and I talked to Chuck today, Mr. Landy, excuse me, I should be more formal, just not who I am. My preference, of course, would be to build a beautiful golf course out there. I think that there's great public benefit in that, and that's what the public was originally told they could get, but we know that he could build this project and close the whole thing down without a DA. So I would like us to move this forward, but I would like specificity in here that is not in the current DA.
2:56:28 And not in any of the proposed language that I have seen. So that I know going forward that recreational assets will be maintained, whether that is going to be the town's responsibility or Mr. Landy's responsibility or the homeowners associations of seven and eight, that all needs to be, you know, clearly laid out in the product we produce here. Okay, so I got a couple questions, some process questions.
2:56:56 We're not taking any action. This is about to get some general comment back from Council. My understanding is a draft development agreement would go to the Planning Commission, correct? Correct. Okay. But that document doesn't exist yet. Okay. So I have some similar concerns to yours, Bill. I've got some more technical weedy type concerns about has inflation been factored into these things and the timing of the DA versus...
2:57:26 If we change codes, if we do some things aren't, how does all that work? And I don't want to bog us all down with that this evening. But I appreciate the needs and the interest of the developer of moving this forward, and let's get some clarity in all this. I would just like to get some time with staff to go over this. And then I would like to understand, do we, does the council...
2:57:46 Do we approve something to go to the Planning Commission? Or does staff just write it up based on what you've heard from council and other people, and you put a draft document in front of the Planning Commission, and that's how it starts? How does that work? So we can go, you know, either way, we can have a workshop that's reviewing the draft document with council, with commission, if that's appropriate to review the exact language, or similar to other zoning code ordinance or ordinances, it would go to.
2:58:15 The official language would go to Planning Commission at a public hearing for a recommendation and then would come to council for adoption. Okay, so I'm just wondering, like, Bill's comments about certainty and specificity, are you hearing that? Are you going to put that into the draft document? Yes. Will the draft document come to council before it goes to the Planning Commission or is that not appropriate? It's not generally how it works. Okay. Because it's going to come to you after it comes to the Planning Commission. So I think we would want to make sure that the
2:58:45 The Council is on board conceptually with the main deal points, but I don't know that you need to see the full draft document. But we have heard very clearly the desire to have no loose ends and not have any ambiguity. And I think everyone, I think even Mr. Landy would agree that the current DA has some areas that are ambiguous and those could be tightened up. That's certainly what we hope to do as part of the amendment is to remove the ambiguity and make everything much clearer. Okay, so if it's appropriate, if it's okay,
2:59:15 I would like to request some time with staff to go into some very, you know, detaily kind of, you know, weedy types of discussions so I can really understand what's in here. And then I may, I don't want to be providing comments outside of a public setting. I could write them up. I don't know what the right way to do that is, but I don't want to be, you know, providing comments outside of everybody else hearing them. But I need to spend some time getting into the weeds on this thing. So one of the things that I would recommend for all of us here on council, because this is a very,
2:59:45 Large public process. This is a huge project. This is in line with the rebuild of the main lodge, 1,000 units. While it does not come to council, it goes to planning commission. I get notice of all planning commission meetings. I can go and look at their packet and I can review this without it coming directly to me. So that is my recommendation. That is certainly what I would plan on doing so that I can make comment before it comes to us for a vote.
3:00:14 Okay. But is it okay for me to sit down with staff and ask some really minutiae, weedy type questions? I don't see why it would not be. Councilmember, you can talk to them on anything they're willing to talk to you about. If they're willing to talk. Sometimes they're not willing to talk to you about this. It's a problem. I would like to just add a little bit to the comment on the specificity of things. One of the things, if you go back and look at some analysis that's been completed on the development agreement,
3:00:44 Early on, I'd say probably April timeframe, at Council's direction, staff conducted a financial review and analysis. I think it was Kaiser Marston, firm that performed that analysis. In more recent times, there have been requests for a more detailed review of that language. So it talks specifically about tying up the language very tightly to make sure that it is done well.
3:01:14 And so that's the process that we're going to start in October and November. I think we've found BBK. No? Okay. So we've got a firm identified to do that work. And I think it's important to note that it's specifically to make sure those things are tied up tightly and clearly. So that work is going on.
3:01:43 And if you look at the outline that we laid out, it was referenced in there, and so giving them a little bit of time to get that completed, and that's why we're not going before PEDC until probably December time frame, if I remember correctly. But just wanted to acknowledge that that's heard loud and clear by both council and, frankly, community concern, and we're embracing that to make sure that it's accurate. Okay, how do I book some time with you people?
3:02:13 John, you know how to book time with me. Okay, so I'll book some time. But I want to sit down. I want to really get into the weeds and a lot of the stuff. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Anyone else? Any public comment on this item? Nothing. I'm astounded. Okay, with that, this is an information only. We will move on to the next, unless you wanted to say something. Thank you very much. Yep. Moving on now to item.
3:02:46 12.4 Community Recreation Center closeout and settlement agreement with Hamill Construction regarding project completion. Good evening. Give me a second here to share my screen. Good evening, Council. Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works, joined with my client, Stu Brown. Stu and I have been working together for a very long time, and I call Stu my client because his programming has been informing the design of this project for nine years.
3:03:35 And so all that hard work you heard about this afternoon has been informing the design of this project for many years. Typically we do our closeout reports written with a bunch of backgrounds, some photos, and kind of walking through the financials, but this is kind of a big deal. This is closing out nine years worth of work, hopefully, with your approval. Nine years for some of you, 20-something for the rest.
3:04:03 Nine years for just this piece. I'll leave it at that. And so I felt it was a good idea to kind of walk you through some of this history and kind of maybe take a little bit of a trip down memory lane. We started on this in October 21st of 2015 where we received direction from town council to move forward with preliminary designs and some environmental analysis. Next year we contract with HMC.
3:04:33 The following year, in 2017, we certified the EIR. By March of 2018, we went out for our first bid, and then there was a spike in steel tariffs. Our bids came in crazy high, and we rejected those bids in 2018 and went back to the drawing board. In 2018, the Town Council approved a phased approach.
3:04:54 And then in 2019, after a lot of discussion, we agreed to move forward with a totally different design, a sprung structure. And that kind of set us on our current path. We redesigned the entire building. We went out to bid in March of 2020. And that project was still too expensive. We went through a value engineering process after rejecting the bids in June. And then in August of 2020, we went out for our third bid and got a decent number.
3:05:23 And awarded that contract in February of 2021. And it was a very long road to get there. We spent months, and this isn't even close to the final design, I just pulled some images from my very large files. We spent months just looking at where the building was going to go, where the park was going to go, where the parking lot was going to go. We spent a lot of time looking at massing.
3:05:50 How big the project was going to be compared to its neighbors, how the different orientations would impact visibility and so forth, spent months looking at this. We started out with an open-air roof. Sounds like an absolutely horrible idea at this point, but at that time, it was completely open to the elements. It looked really nice, though, I have to admit. This is the project we ultimately bid the first go-around, and bids came in at just under $21 million.
3:06:22 For just the structure. And like I said, I was completely open to the elements. This was the entrance. And we moved on to the sprung structure, like I mentioned, and we included a lot of elements. It had a mezzanine, it had community spaces, a number of great public amenities that were built in that project that ultimately we had to value engineer out. What we ended up with in phase one was just over 40,000 square feet of enclosed space, nearly an acre of enclosed space.
3:06:54 An Olympic ice rink, our mechanical enclosure and systems, four locker rooms with showers, public restrooms, storage facilities, an exterior patio area, and then our mobility hub, parking lot, transit shelter, EV charging, which has served us well. What we eliminated from that second bid, the first iteration of the sprung structure, was the mezzanine viewing, which you can see here in that photo, concession spaces, office spaces.
3:07:23 The elevated bleachers, the exterior signage, the community room, and the mobility hub, which we ultimately added back in. And over the years, through conversations with rec commission, planning commission, town council, a number of these elements have been requested to be put back in. And town council has put money into these elements, which we'll talk about a little bit in this presentation and more in the next presentation. We provide an opportunity to provide additional investment in this project.
3:07:52 So the construction side of things, after we got a good bid, the contractor got to work in April of 2021. By fall of 2021, they have completed the earthwork and the slab for the sprung structure. We delivered the sprung in early spring and they started installing that. And by fall, they were working on the interior work. Had a bit of a rough winter. And by January 2023, they were up on...
3:08:21 Their contract days. Through the next summer, they worked on the interior of the project, and by that fall, we were feeling confident that the project was going to be substantially complete for us to open, and we did not waste any time making ice, and got to work while they were still pouring concrete on the exterior of the building. On November 25th of 2023, we had our opening day, Ice Friday, as Stu coined it.
3:08:49 And then we issued a notice of completion accepting all of the punch list items this last January. And since then, the contractor has been working on some of the punch list items. So, funding. Now, I am looking at this project from when we started. So all of my numbers date back to 2015. I can break them down on various phases, components, the construction contract.
3:09:18 I did break down some of the larger components to share with you what those cost, but I wanted to paint a picture of the totality of this project from day one. So if someone asks you how much has it cost us to date to get to where we are, you'll have that number here in just a second. But we invested quite a bit of money into this project. We had some diff components. There were some private donations for the scoreboard. We had private investment from Tesla to help us with the electrical system.
3:09:48 Melrose, Measure U, and the largest was Measure R at $9.6 million. Some of the major costs, obviously the construction contract at just under $11 million, and I'm including the settlement, which I'll talk about in just a moment. We purchased the Sprung structure directly from Sprung and delivered that as owner furnish to the contractor. That cost us just under $3 million. We also provided the chiller system because we had a very specific product that we wanted.
3:10:20 That would perform in our environment, so we purchased that directly and furnished it to the contractor. That was $171,000. We spent $216,000 in engineering, so that's our materials testing, surveying, and so forth. We spent $189,000 on environmental work through Michael Baker to get us through that process. We spent $1.7 million on our architects.
3:10:48 And mind you, that's three different designs and multiple iterations within each design. We typically will estimate 15% for architectural costs. And we actually didn't come in too much higher, all things considered. They did a lot of revisions for us over the years. We spent $113,000 on legal fees. We spent $43,000 on a nesting bird survey.
3:11:17 Monitoring a nesting bird, and then archaeological monitoring. Obviously, this is a sensitive area for historic man and the tribes, and so we had an archaeological monitor anytime we were digging, looking to make sure that we didn't find something of value or historic value. We bought our dasher boards and provided those to the contractor. That was $158,000.
3:11:43 And then our sound system and scoreboard, another $40,000. Any questions so far? We have 40,000 square feet under roof. You want to tell us what the size of the original buildings were because they were considerably smaller? The original, sorry, for the first phase or the first iteration of the plan? The first iteration that came in at $22 or $23 million in the bid.
3:12:26 I think it was, I'd actually have to go look at that. It was a larger building, the first iteration, because we had community spaces that were off to the side. The second bit was the same footprint, but it had raised mezzanine and community spaces that were on a second floor within the same envelope. But if you're interested in what that original size was, I'd have to go pull that plan set and get you that number.
3:12:53 But I believe it was larger. And just one other clarification. If you go back to the financing, where the money came from, the two Measure Arm, Measure U are restricted special fund things. They can't be used for things other than recreation, trails, parks, mobility, and arts and culture. And that is $12 million of the $16 million. So this is public investment in this project. And those are funds that could not have gone anywhere else.
3:13:23 Just in case anybody is listening. Yeah. I would also add to that, John, that the mellow roofs and the donations and the diff funds were also restricted as well. So only 20% of the financing for this project from the general fund was, I would say, discretionary. Perfect. Thank you. So where does that take us? So like I said, the total that we have set aside for this project today was $16,959,862 since 2015.
3:13:55 Our cost since 2015 is $16 million, $123,714. However, we are holding almost $1.8 million in our contract right now, and that's due to a number of reasons. State requires us to withhold those funds when we receive stock payments. We have discussed a settlement with this contractor for the reduced scope of work.
3:14:21 That would be an $800,000 reduction in their contract. So we would be paying out an additional $900 plus $1,000, which would take our closeout budget to $17,115,240. Based on what we've set aside so far, that would leave a gap of $155,000.
3:14:47 We have some remaining work. Like I said, we're looking at a settlement and reduced scope from that contractor. We believe there's about $150,000 in work that we feel needs to be completed to make the project whole. We have bid that work in phase two, what we call the tenant improvements, which we'll talk about in the next items. So we have solid numbers for that work. We believe it's appropriate to include it in this first phase because it was part of this first phase.
3:15:15 If you were inclined to add those dollars, the gap would be $305,000. So if you were asked how much have we invested since 2015 in the first phase of this project, it's $17,265,240. We do need to do a little bit of work tonight. As we discussed, there is a settlement on the table with the contractor to reduce that scope. It's a large impact to the contract, so we'd be asking the town council.
3:15:48 to authorize the town manager to execute that settlement agreement and construction change order with Hamlet Construction. And if you're inclined to put the capital reserves towards the remaining work and the funding gap, we would ask that you authorize the town manager to do so. And we can circle back to this recommendation. This is now time for the Stu show. And I'll drive Stu. Okay, sounds great.
3:16:17 Matter of a correction, so this was Ice Friday, November 24th, so my mistake, sorry, I didn't want to correct you during, but yeah, we missed it by day. You gave me, you actually emailed that to me. I did, so, but we want to make sure it was the right day. Again, you know, whenever we complete any project, you know, that we've done here in the town, we always want to celebrate it, and this one's certainly no different, right? So this was a monumental day, Herculean effort by so many people.
3:16:42 Very emotional, you know, certainly for me and a lot of people, you know, were involved in this project. So it does take us back, but, you know, what a day and what a 10-year period of time it was in that project. So the presentation is just a really quick summary. I'll try and be brief.
3:16:59 As much as I can. So let's just roll through. But, you know, we started out on this project with the Parks and Recreation Commission and with staff concurrently, you know, with the planning for this project. So 2.15, Parks and Recreation Commission got together and really talked about the goals and the vision, right? So we started that process and it wasn't only just for the Community Recreation Centre at the time. It was really for Mammoth Creek Park, right? We really wanted to create that recreation destination. So when we were looking at...
3:17:26 The CIC, we wanted to know how it was going to engage, interact and assimilate with the green space that was really important, right? With the playground that we just put in in 2017, right? We reorientated that national demonstration inclusive playground to accommodate the construction of the CIC, right? And now we're kind of seeing the fruits of all that work and that labour coming forward now with that beautiful park that we have and then next year we'll hopefully wrap up a lot of that other work.
3:17:52 You know, we've really been kind of seeing this, and I think it has been certainly the last, what, 11 months since we've operated, you know, just seen just shy of 30, 35,000 people in 11 months have been through that building, which is just staggering, you know, really impressive. And then we officially open to the public tomorrow. So super excited to see that. And that will be our first, you know, full season of operations, which kind of gets us to seven months.
3:18:19 Again, you know, it's really what I kind of term that kind of game changer for our community. If I may, real quick, for those following along at home, you may not have noticed that we transitioned from 12.2 to 12.4 with the stew talking. Is that correct? No. This is all. Oh, we're the same. Okay. We're the same. We're on 12.4. We're good. We just, we're kind of summarizing the project as we kind of wrap it up.
3:18:49 Before we move into... So we're still... Closing out, but moving on. So, I mean, these are just some slides. I don't know if you had a chance to see these, but again, like we do with our commission, and we just really want to make sure that we're being transparent and open. So, I mean, again, really impressive operating days, you know, almost double, and then we'll obviously increase that again this year. Next slide shows the visits. I mean, this was, you know, a 300% increase.
3:19:18 Which I think we've all talked about. So just shy of, you know, 30,000 people went through that building in five months, which was just staggering. Just some, you know, winter programs by the numbers, you know, adult hockey grew to 109. Women's hockey program, you know, Sydney and Gee started that, you know, program with no women, right? And now we're up to, you know, 95 and growing. We have a whole scheduled ice time dedicated just for women's learn to play in hockey and leagues and tournaments and so forth.
3:19:45 Youth hockey, that continues to grow each and every year. Skating lessons, you know, 126, you know, 76 the year before, and then curling. You know, we really wanted to make sure this was a multi-use ice sheet, so it's not just for hockey, not just for lessons, ice skates, you know, it does everything that we want it to do. So if you've been in there, you saw that we had the curling houses last year, and we have even brighter versions this year. So again, curling is a big part of that programming. Just jumping through the next slide.
3:20:15 You know, just a quick snapshot at summer. I think I showed you this before. So that was kind of our summer visitation. Next slide shows kind of the suite of adult programs. And then the next slide shows the youth, which we kind of talked about in the previous presentation. And the next slide kind of gets to that 40th anniversary and just shows, you know, the opportunities that we can accommodate in that building for special events.
3:20:39 As we get to the next slide, we'll kind of talk a little bit about this winter. So this was kind of a snapshot of our operating plan. We presented this to the commission yesterday. So this just kind of shows you what's really to come this winter. So as we get into this, I didn't want to come up during our presentation because I wanted to keep it brief, but tomorrow is a really big day. I really hope everybody can come along, check out the opening day of celebrations with our new and first ever Winter Expo.
3:21:08 You know, it's always been a summer expo, everyone's like, you know, so much stuff going on in summer, but now with this facility, with our community recreation centre, it really changes the game, right, for recreation in our community. So we have a ton of stuff to do and a ton of stuff to offer, not just from kind of parks and recreation, but all the recreation providers in our community. So the winter expo is really going to feature that. Public can come along and skate for free, have some wonderful lucky door prizes. I think some people have just said they're just going to...
3:21:35 Walk in and walk out for the three hours, so many raffle tickets they can get, so we'll see how we do. But anyway, so our Winter Expo really kicks off our Winter of Celebrations. Then you get on to the next slide. Again, this was a really big initiative that we rolled out, and thanks to the Council for approving our 50% off pass, right? So this is our Winterscape membership that kind of goes on sale tomorrow through the month of October. And these are all the other special promotions that we have.
3:22:03 Not really changed from the years past. The third one down, that community night, we really wanted to kind of showcase, you know, a night for the community. Last year we did some stuff on Thursday. This year it's Wednesday. We think that's going to fit into everybody's kind of schedule before the weekend. I can't go still. What's that? I won't be able to attend. It's the first Wednesday night of each month. I know. Come anytime.
3:22:30 But, let me just say, so the first night is the free skate night, and then the second week you can come and learn to curl, then you can actually come and learn to play hockey, and then you can come and learn to X, you know, so each of those Wednesdays we have a different community focus, is that what I mean? So once you've probably done one, which is a non-council night, you can come back another time and, you know, learn to curl, learn all about ice sport. So that's kind of the theme with community night.
3:22:58 And we're just kind of working a little bit with Betsy and community engagement and see if we can kind of generate some interest on that night, partner with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. They'll kind of help us offer some free hot chocolate, some two-for-ones, some giveaways, some lucky door prizes, those type of things to really see if we can get the community out for free on those nights. And you can kind of see that winter play pass, right? So we listened to a lot of our participants from last year.
3:23:23 And they're really interested in kind of this winter play pass that kind of gives them the opportunity for a very heavily discounted product just to kind of join, drop in, pick up, stick time, instructional, curling, whatever it might be. Just give me a 10 play pass that I can use for, you know, as many things as I can over the winter. So super excited about that. Next one. Again, just our smorgasbord of community events. Like to highlight that we'll have the first haunted rink event.
3:23:52 In the CRC, so we're really excited about that. The Little Kings program kicks off next week. We're bringing back community tree lighting ceremony. The big Christmas tree there gets lit up mid-October, so we're excited about that. So we'll do that December 6th. And you can see the other events that we've hosted previously as well. So that kind of gets us to kind of sponsorship. Chuck was here, Mr. Landy. You can see his proud...
3:24:19 Proud sponsor of the Community Recreation Center, which we're really excited. And these are the new In Ice logos. So when you're at the ice rink, you can kind of see these in the ice. They're really cool. So we have Snow Creek Resort, Mammoth Disposal, LADWP and Measure R right there front and center. And then you're just starting to see the new LA Kings logo. This is a big rebranding effort that they've just gone through as well. So we've got that new In Ice logo. And around the boards, I know everybody's been there, just a tremendous response.
3:24:47 From the entire community, all our business partners buying their dashboard and showcasing their wonderful business to the community. So this slide is kind of the last slide, so thank you. So what we're kind of put up here are kind of planned programming and facility enhancements. You know, some are subject to kind of council action. Some have been completed. Some are underway. But you can see here we've got kind of the on-ice events on the left. So with, again, the extended season, we're able to offer more programming for the community.
3:25:18 So you can kind of see here we've got fall, lesson, hockey, you know, rates, women's learn to play, fall, winter and spring, you know, skating lesson programs. We're looking at bringing a regional figure skating competition to the area, which we're really excited about, broom ball, and then our community night every Wednesday. And then off ice, a couple of items that we've already completed. We installed 10,000 square feet of rubber flooring.
3:25:43 So that's around the majority of all this programming area. Now the important thing about that flooring is it just makes it more usable and functional, right, for all our programs we want to do. So we've got a lot of interest for indoor pickleball, right? I know pickleball is kind of crazy. So we're actually going to be able to stripe an indoor pickleball court in the south lobby. So a lot of those folks that want to play during the winter come on down and pay just the rec zone fee, whatever that is, top of my head. You can come and drop in and play some pickleball.
3:26:13 Half Court Basketball. We're also talking with Wave Raider to help us kind of set up this kind of pop-up skate park inside the South Lobby during kind of the Christmas holidays. We've got kind of new arcade, hockey and foosball, table soccer in there as well, and we've got some enhanced vending machines. So a lot of fun stuff that's, you know, coming along. But probably the biggest item there that you're looking at, which is that third bullet, are the elevated seating, right? So when we design this...
3:26:39 Building, we designed it for all the programming, but, you know, then we kind of understand, well, where are all those people actually going to sit and watch a lot of that programming, right? So they want to watch the hockey, they want to watch all the curling. We had the California Curling Championships last year, but you really couldn't see it because you really couldn't, you know, look down from an elevated position. So, you know, part of the phase two that we're talking about is that elevated seating. So we're excited to kind of see that put together.
3:27:05 And then in the next presentation, we'll kind of talk about the staff offices and a few of those items as well. So again, programming has really informed the design of this building, and these are all really critical, important items that we really want to kind of add to that project to make it more functional, usable, and to benefit the community. So that is it, I believe, on my presentation. So thank you for being patient and tolerant of our presentation. Thank you, Stu. And I wanted to bring this full circle.
3:27:35 So we started talking about the intent of the design and how the programming was influencing the design. Stu's presentation shows how his department is capitalizing on this facility and just demonstrating how valuable all those decisions, all those changes were to this project over time. With that, this concludes my presentation. We've got a little bit of work to do, but I'm happy to field any questions you may have. Questions for the crew? Amanda?
3:28:06 I'm excited to get on the ice tomorrow. I don't have any questions. Thank you. That was very thorough. John. So we're on 12.4, correct? Correct. So the question I have is about the facade and the seating. Is that in 12.4 or is that in a different item? That would be in 12.2, which comes after 12.4. Of course it does. Thank you. I don't have any questions. Thank you very much. Do we have any public comment? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion.
3:28:41 So, Andy, I don't know how we weave that in. Is it a motion or is it consensus to authorize the town manager on the budget and settlement? I think a motion would be in order so we have a record of it. Thank you. So I'm ready to make it. Yeah, there is a recommended motion here, so. Yeah. And I can put up the amended motion. Please. If you give me one second. So, Mr. Mayor, Mr. Bill.
3:29:27 Yes. Thank you. I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to execute a settlement agreement with Hamill Construction and further authorize the Town Manager to use capital reserves to close out current phases of the CRC, otherwise known as a Community Recreation Center. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie.
3:29:53 Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes. 4-0, thank you all. Thank you. Moving on now in numerical, well, okay, not exactly in numerical. We will go to 12.2, Ward Construction Contract for Community Recreation Center Improvements.
3:30:16 Before we go down this road, I will tell you all that the person who came in with the low bid is a close friend and neighbor. But in consultation with our town attorney, there is no conflict there because there's nothing monetarily going on. I haven't decided if I will abstain from the vote yet or not. This facility is so darn important to me. I want to get it done. You are not required to abstain because there's no formal legal conflict.
3:30:45 Thank you for disclosing your relationship. Thank you. With that, we will go to the Stu and Hayes show. So we will close one chapter and open another chapter of the CRC. Hopefully this one doesn't take nine years. So the recommendation has been amended. So in the staff report,
3:31:11 I may mention the fact that we had open bids or were planning to open bids after the staff reports were due and that we would present the information at the time at council because we don't have a second meeting this month and we wouldn't be able to award until November and we would lose a month of construction potentially. So I appreciate you letting us do this a little bit.
3:31:37 So I'm going to read through the recommendation just so we're all clear on the changes. Approve the plans and specifications. Authorize the town manager to award the contract to the lowest responsive bidder, Layman Construction, for $968,098. Authorize the public works director to execute the construction contract and accept the project when complete.
3:32:05 Waive any irregularities in the bid total. Authorize the Public Works Director to review and approve minor revisions to complete the project to an additional 10% of the award amount. Authorize use of $800,000 in capital reserves to fully fund the project. And authorize a contract to purchase and install bleachers worth Great Western for $50,217. So the phase two scope.
3:32:32 In the last presentation, we talked about how in phase one, we pulled out a number of elements to value engineer it and to bring it within budget. We'd like to add some of these elements back at the direction of the rec commission and town council in previous meetings, including some decking and access improvements for the elevated viewing, the exterior facade, which I have an image of, John, mechanical roofing,
3:33:00 We value engineer the roofing just to be a metal deck and it leaks and it creates a giant ice rink inside our mechanical structure which is a problem. Some electrical HVAC sprinkler connections to the offices and some work that I'm going to talk through that has already been accomplished adding flooring, the purchases of offices and furniture which you approved in a different meeting.
3:33:26 Adding concession counters, some exterior lighting improvements, adding a contingency, and the purchase of bleachers, netting, and ADA lift, exterior lighting, and sound denting. So there's a lot of components in this, and like I mentioned in the last presentation, while we'll consider that funding part of phase one, we'll be doing the work to complete some of the incomplete contract items within the scope of this construction contract, and it's included in the overall scope here.
3:33:58 Those dollars, when you break them down, the construction contract at $968,000. The flooring, which has already been installed, was $184,657. The dirt offices, this is a modular solution. Dirt is the name of the product. Can you please translate that acronym? I cannot. Is that actually a name? It's the name. That's also my personal email address, but we'll talk about that later.
3:34:25 Coincidences. I'm telling you. I didn't know you were in the office furniture business, but great to hear. So this is a modular solution, and this is the same product we are looking at for the town hall. This was recommended by our architects, and for the town hall, it saves us a fair bit of money on those interior spaces. We looked at it as an opportunity to test the product.
3:34:50 And see how we like it and implement it here. And it looks like this is going to be a really great solution. You guys have previously approved this. And it's in production now with an installation date in November, along with the furniture that complements those offices. Concession counters, which are being built locally. Parking lot lighting. We have previously purchased the lights. They're solar lights consistent with all of our path lighting.
3:35:18 But we do need a contractor to install the pads, if you will, and the structural elements. Providing a contingency to the construction contract, a little bit more than 10%, about just between 11 and 12. And then approving the purchase of bleachers. And these will be installed on top of the metal decking netting to protect those sitting in those bleachers from pucks.
3:35:45 An ADA lift, so the architects design structure with a lift in mind to make it easier on the contractor. We're going to purchase that and furnish it. Exterior lighting, so we've received some complaints about some of the lighting on the back of the building not being well downshielded. We're buying new lights and we're going to replace those so we can be a little bit more respectful to our neighbors. And in the same vein, we're looking at chiller sound mitigation.
3:36:13 Last year, we did not have gates installed around our mechanical enclosure, and that sound got out to our neighbors. We installed the gates, but it still feels loud to us. We are within the decibel limits for our property, but we feel we could be better neighbors by providing additional sound mitigation. There is a high-pitched whine to that chiller, and we're going to work to mitigate that, and so we're asking to put $30,000 into that sound mitigation. So what does this all look like?
3:36:45 John, this is the sign as designed and bid and approved through the building department. And so this is what it will look like at the end. We're working with the Kings on a new sign. So right now it's on the side of the building. We're going to bring that front and center and build that into our structure. And it's designed in such a way that we can change that out and do different signage in the summertime. Yep, the rec zone signage. And it'll be complementary to some additional signage, which will be part of a signage and wayfinding program. But that is for you.
3:37:14 This is Hayes' Arts and Crafts. We didn't pay to have renderings done of the interior spaces. We've been through that so many times, but I wanted to kind of show what we're talking about for these bleachers. So the area up top in blue is the upper deck of the CMU locker rooms in its entirety. The red area is the northerly side of that area, which we will be separating with a wall.
3:37:43 And putting all of our mechanical systems behind it. It'd be, you know, you won't be able to get into those systems. It kind of protects the people from the equipment. We have five sets of bleachers, and I believe the total is 243 plus 5 ADA. And the plan said it was 224, but working with the bleacher manufacturer, we're able to squeeze a few more seats out of it.
3:38:11 The green area on the right-hand side is where the elevator goes, and then the images below are just the side view of it, so you can see the image to the left, you know, how the seating is to the rink side, and the red is where the mechanical stuff will go, and then looking at it from the other angle, you can see the elevator, the lift, and then the mechanical structure, and then where the seating would go. Image of the flooring, I suspect everybody's been in there and seen all this flooring.
3:38:40 It made a huge difference to the facility for sound, accessibility, and then for all the programming that students got planned. It's great to have a nice flooring. Safe. We talked about the offices. These were previously approved by town council. This contract will provide for the fire sprinkler systems, the HVAC systems, the tie-in of the electrical systems, ceilings. So the upper image is the office.
3:39:10 As you come into the building on the right-hand side, and then on the left-hand side, we'll have counters. And Stu, I don't know if you want to mention kind of your thoughts on how those will be used. Yeah, so really the goal here is to create, you know, the home of Parks and Recreation, right? So we don't really need or really want people coming up to rent the community center or the village or to purchase a camp or program here in the town offices per se. We really want them to be...
3:39:37 At the CIC, right? That's our home for Parks and Rec. So that's what this space on the left is going to be. So you'll have these ADA low and a little bit of higher counter, a little TV on the right that displays all the products that we're selling. And then in that space there are our three supervisors plus a workspace. And then our recreation manager is that back office as well. So we really think that's a really good functional, practical use of space. And it'll actually have a little corridor about eight foot wide, I think.
3:40:05 Into the South Lobby. So the purpose there is to control access in and out of the South Lobby. And that's to really enhance and facilitate programming. So if we're having a birthday party in that space, we can actually control access in and out. So it does become that person's rentable space. So again, pickleball will be in there, the skate park, you know, whatever we want to do in that 2000 square foot South Lobby, we're really controlling access and know who's in and who's not in that space. So we're really excited about this, about this function.
3:40:36 And then on the westerly side of the building, another modular space to support not only storage, birthday parties, but we learned that we didn't have enough space for co-ed hockey and co-ed sports. We needed additional locker rooms. So this will also be a flex space for that. So just additional programming areas and to meet an existing need. Are these things, they have heating in them? I mean, they're...
3:41:04 Gets kind of chilly in there. Yes. We're going to let Stu's team have some heat. Yes. And some air conditioning. We buy some pretty good puffy jackets, but I think heat goes a lot. Yeah. And so they'll be tied in. In the construction plan set, there's a tie-in to the HVAC system. Where there's not, there's capacity for electric heaters, wall heaters. They're like plate heaters that have been.
3:41:34 Kind of already designed to work with this facility. So we're going to keep Stu's people comfortable. Yeah, thanks for bringing that up because we only heat that building to 45 degrees. No, it's chilly in there. Yeah, it's a nice rink. Yeah. It's well insulated. A really big refrigerator. So, yes, to make our staff more comfortable and certainly more productive. Heat goes a long way. So funding. So previously we had set aside a total of $1,050,000.
3:42:06 So that was done in three chunks of $350,000. That was back when Dan was the town manager. And he was setting the money aside with your approval for these future improvements. But we were not putting it aside to a budget. Like, we had not gone through an exercise to figure out how much this was going to cost. And so we've gone through that exercise. We now know what it's going to cost to get through all these improvements.
3:42:34 And so the decision in front of you is whether or not you want to allocate the funds to get to this place. The money we have spent so far on the flooring and the office improvements is fully covered. So we're asking for money above and beyond what has been previously allocated. To the tune, the exact number is 796-413. I rounded it up to $800,000 in the recommendation. Any questions on what we've discussed so far?
3:43:09 No, I just want to say that, Stu, I went by the CRC and I saw the nice plaque at the entrance that demonstrates the public investment that went into that. I'm assuming that that stays there. It does. It's year-round. Okay. Rob and I have talked a little bit about that, so that's a good touch. Appreciate that. No questions, though. Okay. A public comment. In that case, I will go back for a deliberation and a motion. Mr. Mayor,
3:43:41 I would move that the Town Council authorize $800,000 to implement a series of staff recommendations as detailed this evening. Oh, I'm sorry. Hang on a second.
3:44:10 Layman Construction for $968,098. Authorize the Public Works Director to execute the construction contract and accept the project upon completion. Waive any irregularities in the bid total. Authorize the Public Works Director to review and approve minor revisions to complete the project, up to an additional 10% of the award amount. Authorize use of $800,000 in capital reserves to fully fund the project. Authorize the contract to purchase and install bleachers with Great Western for $50,217.
3:44:39 Did I get that right? You did. There's the motion. I have a motion. I'll second. I have a second. Any further deliberations? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes 4-0, and I thank you all. Thank you. Thank you, and we hope to see you tomorrow at the Expo. This is a long time coming.
3:45:04 So it's free skating tomorrow. Absolutely. Five to eight, three hours. So anybody's out there who's listening, it's free skating tomorrow. Free, free, free. That's it. First community event. Although we won't cover medical bills. We'll cover yours. Okay. Thank you all. Moving on now to council member reports. I will go first, Bill. I have nothing to report. Nor aye.
3:45:33 John. My only item is the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments had a strategic planning session last week that went really, really well. And the ESCOG is really standing up and doing things that are real value to us and to our regional partners. There will be more to come on that. Chris is part of that. But it was a pretty exciting event. Thank you. That's it. And I have no report. Thank you all. We will now adjourn this meeting. And I brought it in just when I said I would.
3:46:05 7.45? I said 7.30 to 8 o'clock, so. Okay, there you go. We are done. Where'd he go? Stew! Stew, how little of ice skates do you have?