TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 14:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

3 findings

Transcript

427 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:06 You were just missing Commissioner Eckhart at this point, but I would assume he's going to be here in person shortly. Okay. And I understand we have some members of the public joining you in Suite Z today. We do. We have about 11 people here from the public. Well, welcome all the people from the public. Welcome back to Suite Z. Okay, well, let's go ahead and get this meeting going. We've got a pretty robust agenda today, so I'm sure we'll find use for that extra minute.

0:40 So I would like to call to order the July 14th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we have a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Eckert is absent. Commissioner Kennedy. Here. Vice Chair Burroughs. Present. Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you. Commissioner Kennedy, would you care to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Sure.

1:13 Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of Alaska and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. I would like to open the meeting now to public comment, but a couple of caveats I'd like to throw out there. First of all, if you're here to deliver public comment on an item that's on the agenda.

1:41 I would ask you to hold off until that agenda item is being discussed. And Jamie, because of the length of this meeting and all the agenda items we have, I'm gonna ask you to limit public comment per person to three minutes. Yep, I'll do that. Thank you. So does anybody have any public comment right now on any matter that is not relevant to the agenda? Jenna, please. Thank you very much.

2:13 So Jenna Carter, Town of Mammoth Lakes Code Compliance Officer here. Just to give a quick update from the Code Compliance Division, we have 74 open cases right now, and we opened 21 new cases in the last 30 days, and we've closed 21 cases in the last 30 days, so swap out there. The new trend for the last 30 days has been issuing stop work notices on unpermitted construction jobs. It's just the season to build, and everyone's been pulling permits.

2:42 Otherwise, so that's it for me. If anyone has any questions, I'm happy to answer. Thank you. Anyone on the commission have questions for Jenna? Please, Commissioner Chang. Are businesses allowed to post those bore signs still outside of their business? Yeah. Technically not right now. We are working on updating our sign code to potentially allow them.

3:12 So I haven't been as heavy-handed on them as probably in years past, but we are looking to allow them in the near future once the sign code's updated. Thank you. Any other questions for Jenna from the Commission? No? Thank you, Jenna. Appreciate the hard work. Thank you. Have a great meeting, everyone. Jamie, do we have anyone present in Suite Z that would like to submit public comment at this time? No, we do not. We have anybody electronically that has their hand raised.

3:46 No, we do not. Thank you, Jamie. And I will close public comment and we'll move on to our first presentation. It's a presentation on Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. And I believe our presenter is Councilman Wentworth. Yes, good afternoon, Chair Vanderhurst, a member of the commission of the public.

4:05 I'm here today in my capacity as a volunteer member of the Board of Directors of the Mammoth Lakes Drills and Public Access Foundation, MLTPA. So with that qualification, I can go ahead and share my screen and go ahead and provide a presentation that I hope you'll find of interest. Thank you. I'm assuming everybody can see this okay. Great. Good news. So many thanks again to all of you for the opportunity to share this presentation with you.

4:40 A presentation that's been making the rounds in the region of the eastern Sierra. And we're going to start off with a land acknowledgement, which is something that we've been doing, which is important for the work that we do. Public lands in the United States hold the creation stories, burial grounds, and ceremonies of indigenous people who were killed or forcibly removed from their ancestral homes during territorial acquisition. Many tribes comprised of different bands live in the eastern Sierra region, caring for their native lands as they coexist with the ongoing impacts of colonization.

5:09 Past or present tribes and bands associated with the region that this effort is aware of include, but are not limited to, to the Miwok, the Monolake Kazetika, the Monomanash, the Numu Payut, the Newe Shoshone, the Timbi Sha, the Utuutu Guatu Payut, and the Washo. Two Numu terms describe the region and provide the important context to ideas offered in this presentation. The first is Paimadu Toyabi, Western Mountains, and the other more widely known place name is Payanadu.

5:38 The place where water flows. This acknowledgement is an invitation to all organizations, residents, and visitors to recognize the way this history has been shaped, the way this history has shaped the present as all parties work together in anticipation of a better future. So thank you for your attention to that. And we'll start off with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. This is a partnership that was formed with support from the Washington Office of the U.S. Forest Service.

6:06 As well as the various jurisdictions you see listed below, it's everybody from Alpine County, Mono County, Inyo County, the Town, Caltrans, BLM, Bureau of Land Management, National Park Service, and the U.S. Forest Service. The partnership has been supported for the last couple of years from a nice grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy in Proposition 68, and this is known as the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative.

6:32 The grant was awarded in March of 2019. It's about a $620,000 grant funded for Prop 68, as I mentioned, to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. And it was awarded to the town of Mammoth Lakes on behalf of regional partners. And you may ask, well, why was it done that way? Well, that was because there was no regional authority that could accept such a grant. As you all know, the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments is now a joint powers authority.

6:58 Going forward in the future, these types of grants would most likely go to the ESCOG. The town was generous enough to step up and be willing to submit the grant application on behalf of this effort. Work got underway two summers ago, in July of 2019. And this gives you a sense of the geography of where this grant is working. Again, Alpine County down to the southern tip of Inyo County. It includes five National Park Service units, two National Forests.

7:28 Bureau of Land Management, LADDP Lands, basically everything that's within this, within our Eastern Sierra Region, which is a pretty unique effort, given the geography of these types of efforts that typically happen within the state.

7:41 There's a number of contractors that are working on this effort. A group called HIBAR Consulting, a guy named Michael Ward is doing a lot of lead facilitating for the recreation stakeholders track and projects and funding. PlaceWorks and ICF, we'll talk about them in a second, were key for the climate adaptation and resilience assessment. SMG Consulting is a group led by a guy named Carl Roboto that some of you may know out of South Lake Tahoe. Worked in the Visitor Connection Group, which I think some of you were part of.

8:07 And MLTPA, the nonprofit foundation that I serve on the board of as a volunteer, we provide a lot of project management, and we're also helping the town out with grant reporting and staff support for all the tracts of the grant. So as I mentioned, there are four tracts of this grant, and I'll give you some detail on what's happened with all four of these different things.

8:28 And here's their current status at this point, where the grant is scheduled to wind up the end of this year, the end of 2021. The recreation stakeholders completed, climate adaptation resilience is completed, the visitor audience is completed, the final step we're working on is the projects and funding, we'll talk about that in a second. Like all things that started in 2019, this was pre-COVID, and the original goal was to do these, there's a lot of analog meetings, a lot of in-person workshops.

8:56 Obviously COVID changed everything. And actually we found we were very successful in moving over to a digital space. It actually proved to be very beneficial to the grant because the public engagement I think was more robust than it might have been otherwise. And we were able to use a lot of technology, technological tools to achieve a lot of the goals and deliverables for the grant. So it's an interesting lesson for all of us, the way that COVID worked in ways that maybe we hadn't anticipated.

9:21 So the Recreation Stakeholders Grant, this was an effort, sorry, Recreation Stakeholders Track, was outreach to the public. We received about 183 different ideas for projects. Each of the members, organizations of the SSRP provided project ideas as well. And these were just ideas. These are project ideas of how we could

9:42 to improve sustainability for recreation and tourism here in the region. There was a scoring effort which has nothing to do with ranking the projects or which projects might get funded or what might move forward, but just to get a sense of what kinds of ideas are coming in and they were scored again by the public based on the perceived value of these projects for stewardship, access and equity and benefits for gateway communities. So this was just an internal scoring effort. The public took a look at these projects to figure out

10:11 How they might be valued going forward. Some of the project ideas included things like dispersed camping. And I think you're all aware of the very important effort that Monmouth County and a whole variety of partners here in the region have taken on to get a really robust dispersed camping program in place for the summer. Camp Like a Pro, you can now get an app that was put together by volunteer efforts on the app store and through Google Android. But these are the types of things that are of real importance to a wide variety of

10:40 Stakeholders and members of our communities throughout the region. So this is in place. There's a webpage. If you need more information on this, I can certainly share it. You can see the final deliverables, the final project descriptions, and all the rest of that. There's also very important funding opportunities that are associated with those projects that are available on that page. The Climate Adaptation and Resilience Assessment, which is a very interesting effort. And again, it looked at the same geography that we talked about at the beginning, all three counties.

11:09 Five national parks, two national forests. What was unique about this effort is a team of economists from a group called ICF did an ecosystem services analysis in terms of what is the annual value of the ecosystem services that come out of our region. And the average is about $100 billion a year. $100 billion a year in ecosystem services come out of the eastern Sierra. It's primarily in water.

11:36 is primarily in carbon sequestration. The outdoor recreation economy is about $2 billion. Those other two are in the $40 to $50 billion range. But this is something important to advise the state of California and our federal partners that monetized, evaluated ecosystem services come out of our region, which is a lot when you think it's mostly rocks and sagebrush, but hey, we produce a lot of good things come out of here.

12:02 And the vulnerability assessment was led by a group called PlaceWorks, which has a very, very well-recognized firm in the state of California. They most recently were the lead consultants on California's adaptation planning guide for climate change. So they did great work with this effort. This effort is completed. You can read there's an executive summary of the full report is there, all the backup data and the rationale for

12:28 Those dollar amounts that were, I just represented on behalf of the ecosystem services, that's all available. So that track is completed. Finally, the visitor audience track of the completed tracks. This was a group of about, I think some of you are probably part of this, of members of DMOs, NGOs, anybody in the region who has sort of a direct frontline

12:53 Engagement with the visitor audience. And they worked together over a process of about nine months, identified a variety of themes that are organized around the values of sustainable recreation and stewardship for our region. This is not about compelling more people to come up here. It's about putting together a program so that people get here, they have an opportunity to be educated, be fluent in...

13:17 The ideas of stewardship, of sustainability, of how to care for this region as we all try to, try to make better stewards out of our visitors, not that they aren't good stewards to begin with, but really to invest in that. They also identified protocols and sort of standards for how images should be used to represent the values that they've articulated for the region. And all this is folded into a package that's informed by guiding principles. Everything from

13:44 be reliable, implementable, forward-looking, and don't compete with existing efforts, don't compete with existing messaging, but to complement it and to encourage it to really engage with our visitor audience.

13:56 Again, this is a nice shot of the group that started off pre-COVID. Very wide range of representation from stakeholders and groups from across the region. But this group, as with the rest of them, translated into a virtual and digital space, and that worked out pretty well. So again, this visitor connection package, the results of their work, is available online. If anybody wants to read it, take a look at it. That one is done. And the final tract that we're all working on right now is the projects and funding tract. And this is where we take

14:24 All of these different project ideas, we bring them together and we're looking to identify funding opportunities to fund some of these projects to get some things done on the ground in the immediate future. So you can see how the various components add up together to create one of these eight SRTI projects. It starts with all these ideas, everything from the recreation stakeholder ideas to the ideas that came out of the climate track and came out of the visitor connection track. It goes through a variety of filters.

14:54 What's going to be feasible? Where is there money that can be found readily to move these things forward? And this becomes this collection of projects for which the grant will pay to help write applications for eight different project submittals. Again, ideas coming from these different pots. The filters take things from desirability to feasibility. And how do we look at funding for the highest probability for success?

15:19 And each of these eight project ideas would need to be submitted by one of the members of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. So we're in the process now of bringing all this together, prioritizing funding. We're looking where is there money to move some of these projects forward and to draft project summaries that will actually become the project descriptions for the grant proposals and then working with identified members of the ESSRP who are interested in submitting these grant applications.

15:47 What the ESSRP, the partnership has done is they've drafted a prospectus for investment that looks out over 10 years. It looks out over the short, medium, long term. What do we need in this region? What type of investments are the partners looking for? And we're aligning the projects that we're identifying to fit into that prospectus. So there's a long-term view and then we're looking for short-term opportunities. Again, taking all the different project ideas, rolling them up through these various filters and then identifying eight

16:17 So far, we're on time and on budget. About $70,000 worth so far in volunteer hours. Cash donations, I think, is up to about $7,500. So for the town who has a contract with the SNC, this is good news. They can demonstrate leverage and donations. This presentation has been given. You can see the various bodies. You've seen this already.

16:43 And I think we'll be hitting up some other folks in the coming weeks and months. Just an opportunity to keep everybody in the loop of what's happening with this effort. A couple of tangential things I think would be very of real interest to the PEDC. The first thing, as I mentioned, the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments is now a joint powers authority. And their grant application was made a couple months ago.

17:06 On behalf of the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program, which is a program that the ESCOG has initiated, and a grant from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife was awarded to establish this Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator. And what this is, is this is, it's about $3.4 million to establish a NEPA ID team that can start doing the environmental processing necessary to process.

17:33 The NEPA Environmental Work for Fire and Fuels Reduction. This NEPA ID team would be hopefully locally hired, so it's creating jobs and skills within our region. It can deal with fire and fuels, but can also deal with sustainable recreation projects. So that's a pretty big deal, 3.4 million grant award to the ESCOG. When the ESCOG is at JPA, it had only been in place for a couple months. That's a pretty interesting development. And this is a map. The first project that that grants could be focused on is the Mammoth Donut Project.

18:03 Which I know you're all aware of. And you can see this is, you know, it's a 50,000 acre fuels reduction project all around the town of Mammoth Lakes. Something that's critically needed to harden our community against the threat of wildfire. And you can see up here, this is along the two or three corridor going up to Main Lodge. You can see all the fuels up here right around the Main Lodge project is being proposed. They're going to need mitigation. They're going to need treatment. So it's great to have had that grant in hand to start really moving forward to addressing those fuels challenges.

18:30 The other projects moving forward is a business plan to leverage outside resources to rebuild campgrounds in the region. This is one of 10 grants that were nationally awarded from the Innovative Finance for National Forest Program. That business plan will be produced probably in September. It's the second round of funding that's already been applied for. And this is to look at how do we rebuild and reinvest on all the campgrounds on the Indian National Forest in the region. But hopefully this business model is something that could spill over to the campgrounds in Inyo County.

18:59 Other regional partners. And so this project is moving forward. What's been really great about participating in a national grant like this is understanding the mechanics of how regions work and how rural regions like ours with typically very little capacity, how do we leverage all of our different resources to actually generate capital to attract investment into our region to do the kinds of things that need to be done on the ground. And this is a very interesting

19:28 Graphic that was presented at the ESCOG a little while back about the role of local government, how it ties in with partnerships, how it ties in with the ESCOG, with their joint powers authority and their ability to access funding either from the federal government, private sector or state funding. So this has been a very interesting project that's been going on as well as supporting this effort. A couple other things on the state front, the state of California has reconfigured their wildfire management and resilience task force.

19:55 And I know you're all tracking what's happening to the state budget. I think there's about $2 billion assigned to this effort. A lot of very interesting people are on this task force. One of them, of course, is Stacey Corliss, Supervisor Corliss from Mono County, who is the head of RCRC. She serves on that board in that capacity, as well as Wade Crowfoot, who was in town a little while ago, who was the head of the Natural Resources Agency of the state of California. That's a pretty exciting moving forward. That is being made possible.

20:21 By a shared stewardship agreement that was signed between the state of California and the U.S. Forest Service. Believe it or not, the state of California and the U.S. Forest Service have never had such an agreement in place before. It identifies the types of projects that are of mutual interest, both the state and the federal government to move forward. It's pretty fire and natural resources focused, but sustainable recreation is called out in this agreement as well. That's a really nice, compelling, overarching policy documents informing all this.

20:47 Which is important because the state of California is moving very aggressively seeking out nature-based solutions for climate change and for biodiversity. The governor launched one of these, an effort in California, a very ambitious effort back in the fall. There have been a variety of public workshops and meetings, which I'm sure some of you have attended. You can see the dates when those meetings were happening over the spring. The Sierra Nevada's meeting was on April 28th. They gathered a lot of data and they're going to take that back into the...

21:16 The allocation probably of funding, what they're going to be doing with the state. There's another meeting coming up on the state's climate change program that's coming up on July 27th. They are, what I've seen from the state is they're taking all this data and they're literally transposing it and turning it into action items and things that they want to do because they're so interested in nature-based solutions. Well, all of us out here in these rural areas, we are in the nature business. So it's a very important and interesting development.

21:45 Wanting to really come out. It kind of vaguely rings a bell. I might have told those stuff. Hey, Chief Davis, can you mute yourself, please? Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Michael. Thank you, Chief. As I mentioned, the state is in the middle of updating their climate adaptation strategies, which they do every couple of years.

22:06 And they're looking to nest existing efforts so that climate change and adaptation strategy that the SRTI has produced as a great candidate to be nested into the state's progress that they're making going forward around climate change mitigation and adaptation. They've got a series of priorities that they've established. A couple, two that are of interest to all of us are, well, helping nature to adapt to climate change and accelerate nature-based solutions.

22:31 As well as leveraging resources for climate action through partnerships and collaboration, which is what the partnership is about. It's what that SRTI is all about, which is pretty interesting. And this is kind of, this is an interesting slide that's from their slide deck. It's kind of a trick question. Mr. Chairman, I would ask if there are any volunteers who'd be able to identify what lake this is. Anybody on the commission want to identify which lake that is? Commissioner Kennedy, please. Looks like Tenaya to me. Yes, juice and cookies for,

23:02 Commissioner Kenney, that's exactly right. When this slide was presented in front of about 150 people from the state, none of them had any idea where this was. The point being, it's nice to be acknowledging the beautiful places where federal stuff takes place, but these partnerships have to be real. They have to mean something and they have to be actionable. So yeah, juice and cookies that Jessica will talk a little later offline. Thank you very much for that. The Great American Outdoors Act.

23:27 We're now transitioning to how much money is available to be invested in these projects. Unprecedented amounts of funds coming through the Great American Outdoors Act and the reauthorization of the Land, Water, and Conservation Fund. The State of California budget, a generational investment in the State of California, which has been approved, but as you all know, in Sacramento, there's still hassling and haggling to figure out exactly where all the money's going to go, but it's been approved. The largest budget, I think, in the history of the State of California.

23:57 Then, of course, President Joe Biden. There's some key announcements made just last evening. First is the American Rescue Plan, which has passed. A lot of funding coming from the federal government to invest in a lot of kind of programs we're talking about. The National Association of Counties did an analysis of the American Rescue Plan, and they determined that about $65 billion was going to local communities out of the American Rescue Plan, including about $1.5 billion.

24:23 Over two years to public land counties. Well, Marno County is a public land county, as is Inyo County. My understanding that Inyo County's got about $3 million out of this. I think Marno County's got about $2 million out of this. Money is flowing. Who would have thought we'd be talking about this a year ago, but a lot of money is flowing. The American Jobs Plan, I know that most of you are following what's happening with this, appears to be...

24:46 There's a deal on a bipartisan infrastructure plan, and the Democrats announced, at least the Budget Committee announced last night, that they have a deal on a $3.5 trillion investment into soft infrastructure. Money is flowing. Now the caution with all this, of course, is we as Americans, we're not really good at infrastructure these days. New York City tried to build an extension to a subway line. It turned out to be the most expensive extension to a subway line ever built by a factor of three or four, which is not encouraging.

25:16 And of course, we all know what's been happening with the bullet train project here in California. So we've got some work to do to be able to implement and do public infrastructure efficiently, but the funding is certainly there and that's arriving. And finally, just things that are of interest to us, Secretary Vilsack just announced the new Chief of the U.S. Forest Service. I won't make you all guess who that was, but it turns out it was a gentleman named Randy Moore. And Randy Moore has been the head of Region 5 in California for many years.

25:45 I've worked closely with him. Many of us have worked closely with him over these many years. He is now the chief of the U.S. Forest Service, which I think is interesting for us in our region. Perhaps there may be some opportunities there for us going forward. It's important to point out that the policy objectives of the federal government and the current administration and the state of California are aligned. We are on the same page from the state and the federal perspective, which should bode well for opportunities for us in our public lands investments here in the Eastern Sierra. And I'll just close with this observation.

26:15 As some of you know, I enjoy skiing in the backcountry from time to time. There's a little place out of Bridgeport called Twin Lakes, which I always love to go to because there was never anybody up there. I never saw any people up there. Well, I headed up there this spring and heading out of the parking lot, got up nice and early, got there at 7 o'clock in the morning. And oh my goodness, golly, golly gee me, there were eight Sprinter vans and 35 cars at the end of the road. Never seen something like that before. That's pretty interesting.

26:45 Got up in, this is the Matterhorn Peak, actually back up in the Sawtooth back there. Must have been 45, 50 people up there. I did my best to do some casual interviews. Hey, where are you from? Well, I'm from the parking lot. No, no, where do you live? Oh, well, I live in Reno. I live in Gardnerville. I live in South Lake Tahoe. I live in Atlanta. Atlanta, yeah, well, I can work remotely now, so I'm living in South Lake Tahoe so I can come down and ski in the backcountry in places like this.

27:12 This is the most beautiful place I have ever seen. I'm going to do everything I possibly can do to continue to work remotely so I can come and recreate in places like this. So as we all know, it's just this ongoing year over year increase in interest in our region and how can we blame them because it is the most beautiful place on earth.

27:33 So with that, Mr. Chairman, that concludes my presentation. Happy to entertain any questions if there are any. And again, I thank you all very much for your time and just having a look at this, making sure we're all on the same page in the region as these efforts go forward. Yeah, Councilman Wentworth, we appreciate you bringing this before us. And I will just personally say, I really appreciate your passion and your energy that you bring to this project. So with that, I'll open it up to my fellow commissioners. Does anybody have any questions for John at this time? Commissioner Chang, please.

28:09 Council Member Wentworth, thank you for the presentation. Of the $600,000, the grant that you have received, how much of that actually goes to actual projects or is that simply just for studies and consultants to come up with various analysis and approach as to how to move forward? At the end of the day, this entire effort will identify eight projects

28:39 that will need to be matched with partners from the region to submit grant applications to get things done on the ground. So at the end of the day, I would say it's eight, but these projects are going to be projects of region-wide significance. So for example, if the town has a project that the town really wants to get done, but it's really kind of town-centric, well, the town can pursue that, the funding opportunities that we've identified.

29:03 The town can certainly go off and do what it wants to do. But these eight projects are really about building regional capacity and are projects that are unique and that they would be of regional interest and regional impact. Of the eight project you were talking about, are you referring to just, are these actual, like a tangible project that we can physically see? Or is this something that is the group of folks from various groups, they will

29:34 Go and conduct more studies or more additional research. No, these would be tangible outputs. These will be tangible things. For example, that visitor connection package I mentioned, this is the framework for an entire program for the region to establish a regional voice on behalf of sustainable recreation and stewardship. And the idea is to find funding to stand that up.

30:02 with a lead agency, most likely ESCOG, to then establish a regional voice that can engage with an audience of, we don't even know how many people come up here every year, but somewhere between five and seven million people, to establish that and implement and launch that program. One of the presentations you have, a slideshow that you have, it says, help nature adapt to climate change and accelerate nature-based solutions. You know, perhaps,

30:32 You know, since English is not my mother tongue, I find that statement a little confusing, that nature, that humans are going to help nature to adapt climate change. Can you explain a little bit about that, given that, you know. Yeah, so that is a slide from the state of California. That was a slide produced by the Governor's Office of Planning and Research, which is leading the state's

31:01 Adaptation, mitigation plan for climate change. So I can't help you out with that. I found that language a little awkward myself. I think there's been a subsequent refinement for that, so that language is no longer there as one of their priorities. But the key thing that the state has done is the state is identifying now that nature within the boundaries of the state, frankly, throughout the planet, has a key and critical role to help the human beings mitigate their excesses with regards to climate change.

31:31 And this is specifically with regard to carbon sequestration, I would think, which is a big priority in agriculture, but it's also revaluing the value of natural aspects like forests, wetlands, you know, vast desert areas and things like that in the Eastern Sierra, because they have a critical role to play as a nature-based solution in mitigating and helping us to deal with the effects of climate change. So I think nature-based solutions

31:59 That's what the state means by that. And the state, because they need to have nature-based solutions to help with the solutions to climate change, that is motivating them to come out and take a renewed interest in rural California. Because frankly, the nature-based solutions they're looking at are predominantly in rural California. And what's interesting to us, Commissioner Chang, is that the state, I believe there's $11 billion in that budget that's going to these nature-based solutions. It's going to be investments into rural areas like ours.

32:29 It's not clear exactly how the money is going to be spent or how it's going to be allocated, but I think it represents opportunities for us and for our region. Is there a timeline on those eight projects that you were referring to? They should be publicly identified, I would hope, in the next, probably by the end of August. But a key part of that is aligning those project ideas up with the funding. And frankly, when we wrote the grant, we started this whole entire process, you know,

32:58 We thought, okay, well, maybe there'll be some money out there. Hopefully get lucky and there'll be some money to fund some of these things. We're now dealing with a deluge of funding. There's a guy named Derek Kirk. Do you guys all know what GoBiz is? Does that ring a bell? This is the state's Office of Small Business Investment and Business Investment throughout the state. We now have a regional representative. He's a guy named Derek Kirk. And he's going to be in town in a couple of weeks.

33:24 Mr. Chairman, our staff, if we want to think about some introductions, he wants to meet folks from our communities, but he's going to be our guide for this project, for all of us, taking us on a guided tour into the state budget so we can figure out where is the money, what money is going to be applicable and available to us and our community, how can we then apply for it and bring that money, bring those resources to the benefit of our constituents. So it's, you know, it's a challenge to have all

33:53 All these financial opportunities and it's on the scale of trillions of dollars at this point. So we're doing our best to wind our way through all that. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Any other questions for Councilman Wentworth from the commission? I've just got a couple of really quick question, but John, I would very much like to be part of that conversation when the gentleman from the state gets here. I would appreciate that invite. Sure. John, my question is specific to the Mammoth Donut. I've seen that slide a few times now in this presentation.

34:25 And I've always kind of scratched my head and wondered if the Valentine Reserve is going to be part of that thinning process. Yes, and I would assume that it is. My understanding is that there's already a fuels treatment effort happening on the Valentine Reserve that's already underway. That's already happening. I know that the area around where Mammoth Resorts has that

34:53 That campground that they rent from LA County Parks, that's been an area of real concern. That's another place that's being looked at. I'm not the expert on the donut project. There's a woman named Janet Hatfield. And I know that Sandra knows her and is aware of that effort. I believe that Kim Cook from Sandra's staff is going to the regular meetings. But I would encourage you guys at some point in the near future to get an update on that project. Because not only is the environmental work now funded,

35:22 There's a $5 million directed grant from CAL FIRE to start actually doing some of the treatments on the ground. And I know that the town managers is involved with some biomass utilization discussions for all the, you know, the wood product that's going to come out of that. This project's going to happen. And I think the Planning Commission, with the help of your staff, can understand where your jurisdiction is. But this is, you know, our community is about to get a haircut.

35:46 And we know how sensitive we are to getting haircuts. I've been cutting my own hair for the last year. And it's not a pretty process. It's not fun. It's not encouraging. Sometimes the results are disastrous. We all know how important it is to get a good haircut. Well, we're about to all get a very, very big, very significant haircut. The aesthetics are going to matter. The impacts to our recreation assets are going to matter. And obviously, it's going to be very important for our public safety because we're going to really mitigate and cut down the risk of

36:14 Wildfire consuming our community. So I would encourage you, Chair Vanderhurst, working with Sandra to maybe get a presentation from Jana on the, get an update on what's happening with that project because a lot of money is now flowing to it. Perfect. I would encourage that as well. Last question, Councilman Wentworth, and I apologize if it's a curve ball and you can't answer it. Do you have any idea of the Mammoth Donut Project, if they will address the burn piles that were left up in the lakes basin from last summer's cut?

36:42 That's an excellent question. I know it's been a topic of conversation, but I do not have a good answer for you. I would encourage you to check in with Sandra, check in with Kim Cook, and check in with Janet Hatfield. Let's see where we're at on that one. Thank you. Jamie, is there anybody from the public that wants to ask any questions to John? I know we've got a big agenda, but I want to open it up. This is a very important presentation. Tracy Walker, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

37:18 Hi, thank you. I'm here to make comments on the end of Woodman Public Transportation. And that's our next, Tracy, that's our next agenda item. Right now we're still on the SRTI presentation from Councilwoman Wentworth. So if you wouldn't mind muting yourself and then we'll give you a chance to give public comment on the next one. Great, I think all of us who are waiting to speak would agree that our time is equal valuable to yours and we are now 40 minutes into this meeting.

37:48 Thank you, Tracy. Would you please mute yourself? There are no other public comments. No public comment, Jamie? No. Okay. Thank you, Councilman Wentworth. Thank you all. Good luck. We'll talk soon. We'll now move on to our next agenda item, which is the old Mammoth Road transit presentation. And I believe Hayes or Amy is our staff contact today.

38:17 I'll kick it off, Michael, and Hayes is going to add some input, and we also have Phil Moores, Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Transit with us as well to contribute to the presentation. Take it away, Amy. All right, thank you. I will share my screen here. And while you're loading your screen, I just want to kind of frame the Commission's role in this presentation. We are not making any decisions as a body today. We are here to collect public comment.

38:54 on the presentation. There we go, I found it. Okay. Are you seeing my presentation? Yeah. Old Mammoth Road Transit. Okay, thank you. And Michael, you beat me to it. First slide here is exactly that, to just frame our conversation and explain for everybody the purpose and expectations for this part of the meeting. What we have for you here today is a presentation by the staff.

39:27 with an opportunity to follow for comments and questions from commission and the public. We're not asking the planning commission to make any decisions here today, but rather we want to collect comment and input, which staff will continue to address with the intention of presenting and passing along the information to town council. That is tentatively set for August 18th.

39:54 to be determined and we'll confirm as soon as we possibly can. Does that cover everything from your end, Michael? Perfect, thank you. Okay. So a little bit of background here for the presentation. For those who may not be aware, the town and ESTA or Eastern Sierra Transit Authority are a partnership to provide free public transit throughout the town of Mammoth Lakes.

40:23 Coming up in the near future, there are some changes that will affect transit along Old Mammoth Road due to some current development projects, in particular, the construction of the Community Recreation Center at Mammoth Creek Park and also the ongoing development of the Snow Creek 7 Creek House development. Just a brief overview of existing bus service along the Old Mammoth area. The red line or trolley service currently extends

40:56 Out to the Snow Creek Athletic Club and Club Drive. The buses stage here, which means they make up their headway, or which is another way to refer to the spacing or the distance between consecutive buses. And the drivers also get out of their buses to take their breaks at Snow Creek. And then the Purple Line, as well as the other regional ESTA buses, stage and take their driver breaks at the Vons Shopping Center.

41:29 Following the development of the Community Recreation Center and the Snow Creek, Snow Creek 7 Creek House development, the turnaround that's currently located on Club Drive is going to be removed. And that's because development is going to occur on that location. It's private property owned by Snow Creek. In conjunction with the construction of the CRC,

41:57 The red line and trolley, the purple line and the regional buses will all move their staging locations to the CRC. So this is regardless of the removal of the club drive turnaround. All of that staging is intended to now occur at the CRC and it will not occur at Vons or a club drive. However, the town and Eston need to identify a new turnaround location for the red line and the trolley.

42:26 in order to maintain transit service, any kind of transit service to the Old Mammoth neighborhood beyond Minaret. Otherwise, the option would be to just continue to loop around Minaret and Chateau and not provide any transit service out to the Old Mammoth neighborhood. I'm going to pass over to Hayes here to give you a little bit of history on transit to the Old Mammoth neighborhood.

42:49 Thanks, Amy. So there's a bit of history related to providing transit service to the old Mammoth neighborhood. Dates back to 2010 with the initiation of the grain line, also known as the old Mammoth lift. This service went all the way out to the bluffs. In 2011, this route was changed. Some modifications were made to have it reach Eagle Lodge and a portion of Minaret Road. At that point, the turnaround was changed to lower Red Fur.

43:19 And service continued in that format for about five years until 2016. In spring of 2017, a limited line was created in response to resident concerns of discontinuing the old gray line. And that was focused on midweek service for employees in the downtown areas and schools. That was discontinued in summer of 2017.

43:44 However, fall of 2017, a couple of round trips were created to meet the demand for schools and some service was added using dial ride. In spring of 2019, that was discontinued due to staffing and budget concerns. And since then, services like Amy showed on her first slide with the existing transit route has ceased at Club Drive. Go ahead, Amy. All right.

44:15 And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Phil. Phil Moores. He is the Executive Director of ESTA. Thank you. Hello, everyone. Yeah, we need a spot to turn around as our current turnaround spot is being overbuilt. And we need to be able to provide some service, you know, to the upper area there in Old Mammoth without extending our headways too far and cutting into driver brakes or requiring

44:48 Additional routes that would be very expensive and difficult to staff. In the winter, as you know, the roads can be kind of treacherous for larger vehicles. We can get up in the past Woodman most of the time, but there are a lot of times during the winter where we can't get up there because it's just too steep.

45:12 We need to have sufficient radius for turning the 40-foot buses that we have on the routes up there, and we need to make sure that we're operating in areas where there's not conflict between personal vehicles. I was in the Aspen Village checking out that potential for turning around through that private community, and a car had stopped.

45:41 and blocked the road to do some packing or do something. They weren't in the car, but whenever you get into residences or parking lots and so forth, you've got a potential for interference with the route and it just causes problems with timing and also space for safe maneuvering. We want to...

46:09 You know, keep the buses on the big road, on Old Mammoth Road as much as possible instead of going down some of the smaller neighborhood streets. I know we go a little bit on Woodman with the Woodman turnaround concept, but it's not nearly as much as some of the other ideas that I've seen as far as driving down some of the neighborhood roads. Yeah, and so, you know, going further, adding a new route and...

46:36 You're going further up into Mammoth like some people have wanted, Old Mammoth. There just isn't a lot of demand up there that would justify a whole new route and hiring a new driver and I think getting close as we are proposing to get, that is probably the best course of action for serving the Old Mammoth area. Was there a next slide you wanted me to cover? There is.

47:04 There you go. Yes, thank you. So this talks a little bit, there was a question at the last meeting we had about frequency and the number of buses that would be there and the times that they would be there. This, of course, is, I believe, one of the best discussions, one of the most productive discussions we can have is to talk about the number of buses that go up to the Woodman turnaround, what time they do it.

47:31 Right now you can see the schedule here is different from the summer and the winter and by time of day. If you see a 30-minute schedule, you can tell that's two buses an hour and a 20-minute schedule is three buses an hour. And you can see those time periods where they are currently going on those routes. So that'll give you an answer and an idea of the frequency. So yeah, that answers the question I got in the last meeting.

48:04 Thank you, Phil. So over the course of the last several months or last several years, in fact, there have been other proposed turnaround or endpoint locations for transit service. And I'm just going to go through them here briefly before coming back to what we're going to call our preferred option. Starting at the top of the hill, the top of Old Mammoth Road at the Bluffs.

48:31 This location, as Phil mentioned, adds quite a bit of additional headway or spacing and timing between the buses. It's about an additional mile and a half each way beyond the current club drive location and therefore doesn't lend itself to being an extension of the red line. Rather, a separate route with dedicated drivers would be required to serve the bluffs.

48:56 In addition, he'll also reference the logistical difficulties of this location, specifically in the winter due to the snow and the ice, steep grades of the road. And the land ownership at the intersections of Fur and Laverne and Old Mammoth Road, it's U.S. Forest Service, which comes along with a whole host of further complications. Moving down the hill to Red Fur. As Hayes mentioned in his history of

49:28 Transit to Old Mammoth. There had at one point been service that looped, either looped through Red Fur or turned around at Lower Red Fur. This is still a bit far and adds too much headway to lend itself to an extension of the Red Line and again a separate route with additional drivers and therefore additional expense would be required at this location.

49:48 That location comes along with similar logistical difficulties due to winter snow and ice, as well as site distance problems, particularly at the upper end of Redford. Redford being a residential road, transit on the road itself would not be consistent with the town transit plan, which includes a goal to avoid traveling on rural streets, and it would therefore be a significant impact to those residents directly on Redford.

50:22 I'm going to come back to Woodman, moving down the hill to just talk about Waterford. At one of our meetings in the past few months, a few residents suggested turning around at the cul-de-sac at the end of Waterford. So we took a look at this at a staff level. The town right-of-way at this location is not wide enough to accommodate turning around the turning radius for the red line of the trolley. Again, traveling on this residential road is not.

50:52 consistent with the transit plan goals of avoiding rural streets, which would also create a significant impact to the residents directly on Waterford. Some other members of the public have proposed turning around within the Mammoth Community Water District property that hosts the water tanks. Staff and ESTA have

51:19 looked at this from a logistical standpoint and the turning radius around the water tanks is just simply not large enough to accommodate the buses. The land ownership here, while it is public agency, Mammoth Community Water District, we have not had conversations with the water district about this location and this location would impact residents on Waterford as well as in the Aspen Village Apartments. Bill also referenced some

51:52 comments from the public about the potential to turn around within the Aspen Village parking lot. Again, this is private land ownership, residential area. Turning around or making arrangements to turn around on private land is not a desirable situation for the town. It would be very difficult to maintain the kind of security that the town would need to continually operate.

52:21 Reliable transit without some of the difficulties that Phil mentioned with residents blocking traffic within the parking lot. And we know that this parking lot has historical snow management difficulties. In addition, turning around here would have significant impact to residents on Waterford Avenue, near Waterford Avenue, and specifically within the Aspen Village Apartments.

52:52 Another public suggestion was to turn around within the St. Joseph's Church parking lot. And at first, this was a new idea that had been presented to staff a couple of weeks ago or about a month ago. And we've considered it. However, it presents itself with the similar difficulties to the Aspen Village parking lot situation. It being private land ownership, it being difficult to...

53:20 It also makes use of the rural street inconsistent with the town transit goals.

53:45 And it pushes the end of the line further from a known concentration of riders at the Aspen Villa departments. One location that had been proposed and discussed previously is on Snow Creek 7 property just east of the fire station. This would be a private land ownership arrangement as well and with the same

54:14 or similar challenges we've already previously discussed. In addition, the engineering logistics of this location are a bit difficult. In order to provide the turning radius necessary, there's a lot of earthwork would need to be done, and engineering has some significant safety concerns at this location. With the multi-use path being located on the north side of Old Mammoth Road, a turnaround here would have to cross that path.

54:42 two times, and those crossings would create two new access points for an entrance and an exit onto Old Mammoth Road, and that's in addition to the fire station entrance and Club Drive itself. And again, this turnaround potential turnaround location just moves it further from a known concentration of riders at Aspen Village. So jumping back to Woodman, which Phil has referred to in the past, we are

55:13 Staff is presenting this as our proposed turnaround preferred option. ESSA considers turning around the red line in the trolley to be an acceptable additional headway just over a half mile in each direction from the existing club drive turnaround. And therefore, a separate route and separate drivers would not be required here. The public agency land ownership

55:44 Mammoth Community Water District owns the lot on the corner, and under a partnership agreement, the town has secured an easement for the use of this land. This location keeps the transit almost entirely on the Collector Street, consistent with the transit plan. Impact to the residential Woodman Street would be minimal, only about a couple hundred feet on the north end of Woodman. And staff.

56:13 has proposing several mitigation methods to address the foreseen impacts. Extending transit to this location maintains service to the known concentration of riders that I've referenced at the Aspen Village Apartments, and thus creating future unmet needs, unmet transportation needs, and it extends service even further into the old mammoth neighborhood to a fairly central location.

56:42 And engineering staff also considers this to be a safe design, engineering staff as well as ESTA. It provides adequate turning radius to accommodate a full-size 40-foot bus when necessary, and it uses an existing road intersection, and other safety concerns can be mitigated. I just want to bring up quickly, an alternative to all these suggested locations would be a no-service alternative to the Old Mammoth neighborhood.

57:14 I think I mentioned when we were looking at the transit map earlier in the presentation that the buses could simply loop around Old Mammoth Road after the CRC, Old Mammoth Road onto Minaret and then Chateau. However, this would not provide any service to the Old Mammoth neighborhood. It would be even further, quite a significant distance further from concentration of known riders in the Aspen Village Apartments and it could create

57:44 Additional unmet transit needs. So here we see a site plan of a concept conceptual site plan of our preferred turnaround location at Woodman Street. A bus would travel on Old Mammoth Road from east to west and turn into the Woodman site and stopping here at a transit shelter location before exiting at the already existing Woodman location.

58:14 So we have a paved turnaround. As I mentioned, it can accommodate a full-size bus, 40-foot bus when necessary. And the site plan would include widening this portion of Woodman Road to accommodate a bus picking up passengers while still allowing two-way traffic on Woodman Street. And widening this section of Woodman Road at the intersection would also help to mitigate site distance issues.

58:43 We're proposing to add some boulders and landscaping at the south end of this parcel to mitigate noise and headlights adjacent to the residents nearby. There could potentially be two parking spaces intended for pickup and drop-off of passengers. And we're showing a small transit shelter. This would be identical to the shelter at the Westin, so not nearly as big as the shelters currently along Main Street.

59:14 And the one on Old Mammoth Road, but smaller. And then we typically include trash and recycling receptacles, a bike rack, and ADA compliant ramp for access down to the road, and then a ceiling light for safety inside the shelter. We've conducted several methods of public outreach regarding the transit service on Old Mammoth Road and regarding the potential Woodman Street turnaround.

59:48 We launched an online survey via the Engagement with Lakes platform on May 14th, and that survey is currently open. I'll come back to a little bit more details about the survey in just a moment. We sent a few email blasts out, and I see a typo here. It's not 138 addresses. It's 1,382 addresses that the town has in a database of public, basically public service announcement type.

1:00:20 An email database. Those emails went out on May 14th, June 8th, and June 28th. Facebook posts accompanied those, the first email blast on May 17th and May 20th. On the Engaged Mammoth Lakes page,

1:00:36 There is also included a list of frequently asked questions. A lot of those items we've already discussed here during the presentation or they will be coming up on future slides, but I encourage you to go onto the Engage Mammoth Lakes website to read some of those FAQs. There are also signs posted at the Woodman Street site and within many of the transit shelters and the buses currently in service. We held an on-site open house on May 20th.

1:01:07 We had approximately 40 residents in attendance, many of whom, most of whom actually were residents of the nearby Woodman Street and Mill Street neighborhoods. We also held a following open house at the Aspen Village Apartments Community Center with about 15 or so attendees, many of whom were at the previous open house on May 20th from

1:01:37 the Woodman and Mill Street neighborhood. And then today, our Planning Commission meeting, and we are proposing to follow up with a presentation to Town Council tentatively scheduled for August 18th. And we have received some individual comments and questions via email and phone calls. So going into the online survey a little bit, again, I mentioned we launched this in our engagement with Lakes platform, which

1:02:07 which we started using a couple of years ago during the plan the parcel process. The survey opened on May 14th and it's currently open. We're planning to close that prior to the town council meeting so we can include a full survey of results in the town council staff report. It included 14 questions regarding service on the old Mammoth Road, potential turnaround locations and potential amenities. We've received 87 responses to date.

1:02:36 We'll go through a quick summary of the results. I'm not going to go through all the questions right now, as we're intending to include a full report in the town council staff report. Are you a resident of the old Mammoth neighborhood? 59 of the respondents, so that's 68% said yes. How often do you use public transit? You can see the majority use transit seldom, less than one time per week.

1:03:06 Do you think transit service should be extended further along Old Mammoth Road, further than the existing Club Drive, Snow Creek, Athletic Club Stop? 66.7% say yes. And where would your preferred location along Old Mammoth Road be for a new turnaround? 46% here say this is Woodman Street. Other options are Tamarack, Lower Red Fur, Upper Red Fur, and this blue chunk on the side is Fur and Laverne.

1:03:39 Just a quick comment. The way we perceive that based on some comments that a lot of the people who would like to see transit to Fur and Laverne have a desire to access recreation locations up in that area, such as the Mammoth Rock Trailhead during the summer, as well as the end of the road closure during the winter.

1:04:04 Mill City Site and things like that. We've previously discussed some of the logistical difficulties of extending the red line specifically up to that location. What changes would be most likely to increase your use of public transit? The most popular answer here is a more consistent transit schedule throughout the year followed a bit by more frequent stops near your residence. What amenities would you like to see at a transit stop? With the most popular answer being a transit shelter.

1:04:37 Followed by trash and recycling receptacles. And how often should buses stop in the Old Mammoth neighborhood? This one is pretty evenly distributed, every 15, 20, 30 minutes, hourly, or never. Several of the others believe also, some of the others said even more frequently, every 5 or 10 minutes. Several of them said, just reiterated never. We will provide...

1:05:09 A full report as part of the Town Council Staff Report. And other survey questions asked if the survey takers visited the Old Mammoth neighborhood. And they asked if transit service were to be extended further out Old Mammoth Road, how often would you use it? What changes would be most likely to increase your use of public transit? What is or would be your primary use of public transit? For example, recreation, work, errands, etc.

1:05:42 What times of day are you or would you be most likely to use public transit? A discussion about the two parking spaces which are currently included in the proposed Woodman Street bus turnaround plan. How long do you think they should be permitted for? Would you use the Owl late night trolley if it provided service to the Old Mammoth neighborhood? Where should bus stops be located along Old Mammoth Road between Minaret Road and Woodman Street? And then any other comments or concerns?

1:06:13 And as I mentioned, we're going to come to, I'm going to present some comments and concerns here next, but a full report will be included as part of the town council staff report. We've categorized the public comments and concerns that we've received thus far into these categories, safety, noise, light, environmental concerns, snow management, low past ridership and funding or cost. So starting with safety,

1:06:47 The primary comments we received were related to the uphill sight distance at Woodman Street due to the curve and snow banks, downhill speed of oncoming traffic, and reports of many close call accidents. Staff believes we address many of these concerns by the widening of the road will improve the sight distance.

1:07:13 We can include a driver speed feedback sign uphill of the Woodman Street intersection location. The site design accommodates additional snow storage from the site as well as some snow storage from the intersection area. The town and ESTA staff are confident with this level of safety. And in the past three years, there have only been three reported traffic collisions between Ranch Road and Red Fur.

1:07:40 Two of which occurred at Redford and one at Club Drive, however, no actual collisions at Woodman Street. With respect to noise, there's been concern about potential idling of buses at the Woodman Street location, about the chains on the buses and about the frequency of the buses. Buses are not intended to idle at the Woodman Street location. As we previously mentioned, the staging for those buses to accommodate bus headway and driver breaks is going to take place at the CRC.

1:08:12 So the Woodman would function only as a typical bus stop, with the bus stopping only long enough to pick up and drop off passengers before it moves on to back down the street. In addition, the bus fleet will begin transitioning to a quiet electric technology in the near future. Planning for this is beginning this fiscal year. Phil would be able to answer some more specific questions about this at the end of the presentation.

1:08:44 Providing service to Old Mammoth at Woodman Street can be adjusted based on demand. With respect to light, comments were centered around headlight glare as well as a light within the bus shelter. Boulders and landscaping are proposed to mitigate direct glare from the headlights during the turning around of the bus. And the light in the bus shelter itself is a single downward ceiling light controlled by a photo cell.

1:09:14 And other mitigations could be included as well. Environmental concerns focused on this being a deer or wildlife corridor, CEQA, tree removal and water or the nearby perceived wetlands. This would present minimal impact to wildlife compared to existing traffic already on Old Mammoth Road and Whitman Street.

1:09:43 And in the last three years, there's only been one vehicle versus deer incident between Ranch Road and Redford, and this actually occurred at Ranch Road. Regarding CEQA, the project is statutorily exempt, with it being a ministerial project, meaning there's no discretionary decision required to allow the project to actually be constructed. The only permit required would be a building permit for the transit shelter, and that is a ministerial process.

1:10:13 Five trees are proposed to be removed in order to accommodate the turnaround. Most of these are on the edge of Woodman Street where Woodman Street would need to be widened. The Aspen Grove at the downhill side of the lot will be preserved. And historic downstream drainage patterns which run into the sort of wetland area downhill will also be preserved.

1:10:45 Regarding snow management, snow management, there's concern about the snow banks at the corner of Woodman Street and Old Mammoth creating a blind corner and some concerns about the plowing of Woodman Street. As previously discussed, the widening of the road at the section of Woodman Street would help to reduce the impact of the snow banks and the site design accommodates the snow storage from the site as well as the widened portion of Woodman at the intersection. And with respect to low past ridership,

1:11:17 There's concern that the previous routes were canceled because of low ridership and no one wants or needs transit. The turnaround, again, is intended to serve as an extension of the redline trolley. It's not a separate route. No transferring would be required to access redline locations and an additional driver would not be required. And town staff and ESSA believe that past ridership numbers may not necessarily reflect

1:11:48 potential ridership of an extended red line due to the differences in the proposed schedule and routes. And as previously presented in the preliminary survey results, the majority of the feedback that we have received thus far is in favor of the route extension. And lastly, with respect to funding and cost, the town and ESTA have many available options that could potentially fund construction of the turnaround, and these include the transit reserves fund,

1:12:20 The town's road rehab fund, grant funding, and private funding. And in addition, this site comes with no acquisition cost because of an easement trade with the Mammoth Community Water District. That concludes the majority of my presentation with just a brief touch on our next steps.

1:12:46 We will continue to take public comments here at this meeting and following up until the town council meeting, which is tentatively scheduled for August 18th. And we will work to address those public comments as best as we can. Thank you, Amy. At this time, I'd like to open up to any questions from my fellow commissioners or staff on the presentation. Hello, Michael. Greg, please, Commissioner Eckert. You know, one thing that...

1:13:25 It seems like it would be a pretty simple thing to do, and if I lived across the street, I'd like to see you do. If you're going to have a light at night in that thing, and it just happens to have the wrong angle of the dangle, and it's coming in my bedroom window, it would kind of get under my skin. While it's going to be on a photo cell, could it also be on some sort of a motion detector so there was nobody there, it wasn't on, and that after the buses stop running at night, it doesn't stay on all night?

1:13:59 Hayes or Amy? Thanks, Greg. Staff actually had exactly this conversation before the presentation and I alluded to that a bit just by saying that additional mitigation measures could be possible and so yes, this is something that we discussed and we can look into how we could manage that. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions from the commission for staff at this time? I cannot see Commissioner Burroughs so I don't know if...

1:14:33 There she is. I think everyone's good. I would really like just to hear the public comment. Okay. Then let's open it up to public comment right now. Jamie, do you want to do the electronic or the in-person first? Or do you want to alternate each one? We'll do in-person first here in Suite Z. Please. I invite the public to come and try and maximize your three minutes. Please. Yes, into the microphone. Hello.

1:15:02 My name is John Guatelli. I'm a resident of the Woodman neighborhood, and I hope you all got my email. Maybe you can nod if you did and had a chance to read it. I emailed each of the commissioners, and I want to thank you for reading it if you did and letting me tell it to you right now. The central issue in our neighborhood is, you know, we feel that this bus turnaround is going to spoil, maybe even ruin is a strong enough word, our neighborhood.

1:15:30 And I wouldn't wish it on any old Mammoth neighborhood, and not just my own. And I think the central conundrum of all of this is a conflation of goals with a solution that doesn't fit. Namely, you have two problems. You have ridership and you have a turnaround. And almost everything that Amy sent to support Woodman was predicated on extending the red line with a large bus. The problem is...

1:15:58 taken care of if you don't use those large buses. Look, ridership. We heard it's low. We heard some qualifications. Look at the 2019 report by Mr. Moores. When he talked about ridership west of Club Drive, and he said, oh, what happens if the school buses restart? He said ridership would be decimated. That's his word, decimated.

1:16:23 So we don't need that. What you need, of course, is to give service to Aspen Village. And that's necessary. But you don't need to do it the way you're planning to do it. Let's talk about turnarounds. Amy did a fine job explaining alternatives. And I'm glad that you had a chance to hear all that. But again, her analysis was predicated on extending the red line. Just have the red line turn at Minaret. Putting a new line.

1:16:52 Like the old Gray Line, that size bus is commensurate with running a bus into a rural residential neighborhood. That size bus is commensurate with the need, the ridership need. It was empty for all the years I watched it, but maybe if it fills up at Aspen Village, it won't be. Don't run it to Red Fur, run it all the way up to La Verne and Fur, because you just heard from Amy.

1:17:17 There's a desire to have transportation to that site as a recreational site. That's in the town goals, right? That's in the sharp document, the Sherwin Area Recreational Plan. Do something good. Do something creative. Do something positive. Don't just do the easy thing, the cheap thing, the expedient thing. That ruins a beautiful neighborhood. The reason I bought my home and other people bought their home.

1:17:44 All right. I think that covers it. Thank you for listening to those thoughts. Thank you. We appreciate it. I'll be sure. I was kind of wondering if all this is stemming from the fact that you're going to lose the Snow Creek turnaround. And the Aspen Village, the Aspen Village people are minutes away. It seems like it would be in the best interest to at least talk to Ralph Lockhart.

1:18:15 or Chuck Landy and work something out. It seems to make just way too much common sense to have a turnaround at the athletic club. Thank you. Is there another member of the public at Sweet Z? If you would not, if you would mind, please identifying yourself when you first come up to the podium. Certainly. My name is Tim Hurl. I'm a resident of Aspen Village, and I am the president of the Homeowners Association at Aspen Village. Now, you may be surprised to hear there's a homeowners association at Aspen Village because...

1:18:50 I've heard no mention of the fact that three of the buildings in Aspen Village are condominiums, and I've had no contact regarding this process. The only reason I'm here is because I happened to see an article in the sheet last week, and so I thought I'd need to come here and speak for Aspen Village. Now, my concern is not so much where the turnaround is or the size buses.

1:19:18 But my concern is that there is consistent service to the Aspen Village area for all the reasons you know of, the lack of parking there, the lack of parking at the locations where we work at, like it's usually the ski lodges, often the ski lodges. And so what I would like to advocate for is consistent service. What I would like to see no less frequently than every 20 minutes. And I would like to see that.

1:19:46 Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I need notes because I'm not as good at public speaking as some of my...

1:20:20 My name is Caroline Sanderson. I've lived in Mammoth for 30 years. I've lived on Woodman Street for 23 years. Today you're going to hear a lot of different concerns from a lot of people from our neighborhood about the bus turnaround being proposed on the corner of Woodman and Old Mammoth Road. And unfortunately, based on that presentation, it sounds to me like town staff plans to push this through with or without community support.

1:20:48 Unfortunately, I think largely without community support, particularly in Old Mammoth. So my plea to you guys is if this turnaround is presented to the town council as the only viable turnaround in Old Mammoth, even though Hayes initially said that there was that viable location at Snow Creek just east of Station 2.

1:21:11 Then I respectfully request that it be built with zero infrastructure. So no parking places, no bus shelter, no bike racks, whatever is the minimum thing that you need to complete ADA requirements and pave the turnaround.

1:21:29 The infrastructure proposed is completely excessive with respect to the need. I understand that even constructing a paved turnaround will still result in tree removal and the destruction of animal habitat, but it's the minimum ask that I can ask for. The data, as John presented and some other people presented in previous Esther reports, has shown us again and again that there is little or no ridership past Snow Creek, the ski trails, and Aspen Village.

1:21:58 So again, I would say please use any excess funding that there is to build those structures and infrastructure at either the westbound Aspen Village stop or the eastbound Ranch Road stop because we know that dedicated ridership exists out there. Don't build infrastructure on Woodman Street. If the Woodman turnaround proves to have enough passengers at a later date, then maybe consider building the infrastructure then.

1:22:30 I also urge the town engineering staff to remember that in that June meeting at Aspen Village and today, they've assured us that this, that an engineering study has been completed and that this is a safe location to turn around 40-foot buses. It isn't.

1:22:47 Regardless of whether or not there have been accidents in the past, it's not a safe location. I personally believe that accidents and injuries are likely to occur in both the winter and summer months, and I believe that the decision to do this is putting the public, the drivers, and people driving up and down Old Mammoth Road in danger. With that said, on a lighter note, I just want to conclude by saying I don't want Public Works to construe that as hearing.

1:23:14 that what we want is a traffic light on Old Mammoth Road because that'll make things safer. What the residents on Woodman Street want is for the town to continue to work with ESTA and the community on the safest and most appropriate solution for public transit in Old Mammoth. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Caroline.

1:23:40 Hello, Mitchell Duco. Our family will have the greatest impact because we're at 19 women. In the initial meeting when we went out to the site, Hayes or Haislip Hayes said that this falls under a ministerial protocol, which is not accurate.

1:23:58 Because my understanding of ministerial is painting of buildings, street signs, et cetera, et cetera. This does fall under a CEQA protocol or even a environmental impact report protocol. And the reason being is because

1:24:17 There's parking, there's safety issues with the blind intersection. Just pulling out today, we almost got in an accident, a biker almost got ran over when we were pulling out today. I don't know if the city attorney has walked this site in the winter, and the liability about this site, I think, can't be understated. Then the turnout, the widening of Woodman is not going to help in regards to the winter months.

1:24:45 in that the snow bank is so high you can't even see, so you really have to creep out. It takes about 10 seconds before you can even go when you decide to go. And I think there's the, there are unusual circumstances that don't fall under the ministerial guidelines, and that is the environmental issues, light, noise, buses over a

1:25:09 Town pumping station for water, pollution, safety, ground vibration with a 40-foot bus. And I also want to address the wildlife, the wildlife walk behind our house, and that is literally 10 feet from where the station is. They walk through there every night across Old Mammoth. Instead of having a three-point intersection where Old Mammoth, Mill Street, and Woodman connect, now we're going to have two

1:25:39 Thank you. Thank you.

1:25:58 The report and the study that originally went out, the email study, was very skewed. I think those statistics on the study are very skewed because there was no line if we were against the study. Basically, you had to answer what times would be best to go through the area.

1:26:17 So you had to answer it and you couldn't even finish the study. And then recently we got an email saying that they'll reset the study. So I'm wondering if the study is based on the reset or is it based on the original people who wrote in? So I think that the figures in that study are very skewed and biased.

1:26:35 And I don't think we should be pacifying Snow Creek to build three extra condos on their site at the expense of a less dense populated area in the Woodman area. And that's my take on this whole thing. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Mark Duco. This is my brother and we're in the same property adjacent. I just wanted to say a little bit about personal aspects of this. One thing that wasn't mentioned is Old Mammoth is a historic area.

1:27:10 I consider our property, which, by the way, my father built that land or bought that land in approximately 1955 and built that cabin there by hand. Anytime I'm around the city, somebody says, oh, I know that cabin. It's a historic ski cabin. It's so historic. It's so historic, actually, that my father, believe it or not, was sitting with Dave McCoy on the deck before it was the entire ski resort was built. And he used to ski with him. He used to hike to the top of the mountain and ski.

1:27:40 Dave McCoy offered to my father if he wanted to start a ski resort. Well, unfortunately, my father declined. Howdy if not, I probably wouldn't be sitting here having this conversation with you right now. But some of the things I'd like to reinforce that my brother said is, I don't know how many people have actually been to the site and looked at the actual property lines and where our cabin is. This stop is less than 10 feet from our bathroom, our bedroom, and our living room windows. There is nothing that will not have a significant impact.

1:28:10 An electric bus, a gas bus, it doesn't matter what the fuel is. There will be people waiting there. Just so you know that this land, when it was stewarded by the water department, which is another point of contention, they didn't take care of the land. We have, on more than four occasions, had broken windows in our living room from snow removal. This is just the trickle from the snow removal. This snow removal that's going to happen now is five times, ten times the snow removal.

1:28:36 Thank you so much.

1:29:05 As part of this process, nobody was really directly notified about this. So there's a lot of input that that one is really receiving at this time. But I challenge anybody to invite them out to come take a visit here and see what this really means, because this does not belong on what truly is a residential piece of property that has been converted into a commercial use sort of property, even though it's not zoned as such, because the water department was going to use it and do minimal impact.

1:29:31 Well, it wasn't minimal impact. And this is just another opportunity where the city is coming and now piggybacking on something else. And it's just going to be a bad situation, not only for the community and the people that live there, but for people up the street who have come and knocked on my door today saying they won't have any part of this, but they couldn't attend this meeting today. And I can tell you, a biker almost hit my car by three inches when we were on the way to this meeting today. And if you think that widening that street even by 30 feet is going to make a difference, it's not.

1:30:00 This is one of the most egregious, ridiculous projects I've ever seen in this town. Thank you very much. Thank you. Hi. My name is Christy Caldwell, and I live out in the old Mammoth area. And I have two questions. This obviously is going to happen one way or the other. What is the timing on this situation? Does anybody have an answer for that? Are we two years out? Are we five years out? Are we a year out? Is there anybody that can answer that?

1:30:40 Okay. And then the second question I have is, will there, I mean, the Snow Creek turnaround is going to go away. I understand that. It's private property. Will there be a bus stop there somewhere close by? Will that remain? Those are my two questions. Thank you very much. Thank you.

1:31:03 Chair Vanderhurst, at the pleasure of the commission, we can take the public comments and the questions and respond to those all at the end of the public comment period, or we can answer them kind of person by person, whatever is the pleasure of the commission. Let's answer them person by person, please, Sandra. Great. Hayes or Amy, do you want to respond to the question about timing for replacing the transit stop and then whether or not there would be another bus stop at Snow Creek?

1:31:34 I'll go ahead and field that. So as far as timing is concerned, we don't have an answer. This is going to go before town council and they'll make the decision as to whether or not this project is going to move forward and that will dictate the timing. We'll have a better answer once the town council weighs in on whether or not this is going to proceed. As far as a bus stop at Snow Creek, that's to be determined.

1:32:00 There's a couple options as Amy went through in our presentation that would provide an opportunity to maintain a stop out there, but all is predicated on having a line that runs out to old Mammoth. If we go with the no service option, obviously there would be no stop there. Thank you, Hayes. Amy, do we have any more in-person public comment? Yes, we do.

1:32:32 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:33:03 that we do need that the ridership because of Aspen Village bus service in that area is needed for a number of reasons for the people there. So location, of course, turnaround as it was publicized today is the issue. And as Amy's presentation was today, with each location, there are adverse consequences. There's no...

1:33:32 Perfect solution to where the turnaround should be. I do know from personal experience that a turnaround up in the bluffs, just in my opinion, should not be a consideration strictly because of the roadway coming down the bluffs. And as you come down that roadway, it's in the shadows in the winter, substantially steep, typically icy.

1:33:58 And when you get down to the bottom of that grade is the right-hand terminal on Old Mammoth Road and just a very, very dangerous situation, particularly if it's a bus vehicle on that. I thought that the lady that spoke earlier, her comments on if it did go to the Woodman site, that substantial screening on the, I believe it's the south edge of that property would be necessary.

1:34:28 And, of course, lighting as well. A question that I had of staff, and I don't expect it answered today, but I would like an analysis done. It seems like that south, excuse me, the east, the lower entrance to Red Fur, that there may or may not be an opportunity there if there was some widening of the road, some signage.

1:34:55 It's really, really extreme, but if that developed into a three-way stop to keep the speed of traffic down, that might be a consideration and allow a turnaround at that site. Thank you. Thank you. Does anybody ask one question? I can make a comment already. Prepare to ask a question. Sure. Thanks for letting me ask one question. I forgot. I don't know if Phil Moores is still here. Is he here? He is here.

1:35:34 Phil, in your 2019 analysis, you didn't favor Woodman in part because I think according to the schedule of the red line, you thought that only maybe one in three buses could get there because of, I guess, headway. That would actually decrease service to Aspen Village, for example, but that wasn't in your schedule now. How has that problem been resolved?

1:36:04 of the additional time required to go up to, that was a Red Fur question, I believe, because at that time, when I first got here, there was a strong demand for ESTA to go up to Red Fur and make that left and come down Red Fur and help with the school children there. We had a dialer ride.

1:36:32 Small dollar ride bus that was doing that in the morning and the afternoons for the school kids, but they wanted us to do more and to go up there and that every minute counts on this route. It's really stretched to the limit. There's not a lot of time to add. There's no time really to add. This is the minimal thing that I could justifiably ask the bus operators to do and take out of their break time. The frequency of going

1:37:01 To Woodman, I think is an important question. There was a gentleman, the homeowner president there at Aspen Village, said he wanted 20-minute service. It's three times an hour. And how late would that be necessary? How early would that be necessary? Those are important questions I think that we need to discuss in more detail. I'm not sure if that answers your question. Well, thank you. But I'd urge everyone, the commissioners, to look.

1:37:31 at the report, I'm quite certain you were speaking about Woodman as a turnaround and that you could justify maybe one in three buses going to Woodman because of layover concerns. I apologize if I'm mistaken, but I'm pretty sure that's right. So have you thought about that again or is this or you're just remembering I'm wrong.

1:37:53 I don't remember that detail of that report. It's been a few years, but we have recently discussed. I read it. It's on there. I'm sure. Go look. Please look. I believe you. And we most recently talked with bus operators, Hayes and Amy and I met with the ESSA staff in Mammoth and talked about this extension, talked about the new community center turnaround.

1:38:21 And the way that could happen. And we're confident that it could be done to Woodman. So yeah, I don't see a problem with that. Like I said, I don't remember my report in 2019 about that. And you might be right. Thank you, Phil. If I may, Phil and Michael, an important factor that wasn't incorporated into that report is the change to the red line.

1:38:50 going to the CRC and taking those headway breaks at the CRC, which actually shaves off, you know, a few precious seconds from the red line, from the red line headway, and it makes that turnaround or the extension out to Woodman a bit more favorable. Thank you, Amy. Tracy, do we have any other members of the public in Sweet Z? No. I know we have a lot of people waiting online. My name is Sue Mierhoff and I live up on Wilma.

1:39:22 Bill Street. My question is, approximately how many people do you feel are going to be riding this bus, you know, throughout the day or whatever? Do you have any estimate? I don't have the exact numbers for, and of course we can't really tell, you know, what the future will bring, but the town of Mammoth Lakes system carries 900,000 passengers a year. It's a very healthy system.

1:39:52 And the bulk of those, of course, are in the center of town and to the lodges. And as with any transit agency, the busiest parts are not out on the ends where they turn around typically unless there's a real ridership generator there. And we know that the old Mammoth area is not super densely populated. Aspen Village is our most densely populated neighborhood.

1:40:18 I can probably get, for the town council meeting coming up, I'll ask, I'll figure out what the Snow Creek numbers are at that stop, how many people are boarding and alighting at that stop, and I'll put that together as best I can for the next meeting that we have. Because it seems like primarily we're dealing with Aspen Village, and I realize that that is, you know, that's an issue. I mean, we need to provide.

1:40:46 Transportation for people to get into town to their jobs and whatnot. But if there's not that big of a rider capacity in any one session, why do we need such this giant bus that's going all the way out to Woodman Street? If a smaller bus, a dial-a-ride-sized bus, could go into Aspen Village and turn around on somewhat of a regular basis, wouldn't that be an option to consider? I mean, rather than put

1:41:15 Make this giant bus go 15 miles. Ma'am, he's trying to answer your question. Ma'am, he's trying to answer your question. I'm sorry, I didn't speak up good enough. It's not practical to change buses mid-route. You're right that a smaller bus. Also, to have a giant bus going out 15 plus times a day to Whitman Street, that's not practical. Ma'am, I'm going to ask you to let him answer your question, please.

1:41:44 Yeah, so we have the large buses that are filled to capacity in the core, in the center of the route, and we can't put a smaller vehicle on that, and it's not practical to change vehicles mid-route based on demand. It's just not efficient or practical to do that. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Steve Irwin, and coincidentally, I work for ESTA.

1:42:25 And I have for some time. I also live in the neighborhood. I live on Mill Street. Sue is my neighbor. And I think that we can all agree that we need transportation out to Aspen Village. There is a good, solid ridership from Aspen Village, but very little beyond that.

1:42:54 In the past, it's been in the low single digits per day when we ran the gray line out there. And I just think it's not needed. I think the alternatives that I can think of would be to come up with some way of negotiating with Snow Creek or with the athletic club out there.

1:43:23 Or something like that, because that really is a very convenient location. Right next, another thing that hasn't been mentioned is that there's a considerable significant ridership from Snow Creek 4 in the wintertime. There's a lot of rental units out there. There's a lot of skiers that walk to the bus stop from Snow Creek 4 and take the bus and go skiing.

1:43:52 Aside from Aspen Village. So my suggestions, Dan made the suggestion earlier, that we figure out some way to negotiate with Snow Creek or Snow Creek Athletic Club using parts of both of those properties in order to keep the stop where it is, because that really is the most convenient place, I think.

1:44:20 There's one other alternative we could consider, and that would be if we're going to use the CRC as a transit hub, we could run a small, we call them cutaways, a small bus from the CRC up to some point in Old Mammoth to pick up people and transfer them at the CRC, and that would not be

1:44:47 That's less than optimal, but it wouldn't be too bad, I don't think. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Tracy Walker, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. I'd like to thank any council members who are present and also the Planning Commission. I'd like to...

1:45:18 Thank the whoever it was, Commissioner Michael Banquist for allowing questions during this time period. I'd like to thank the Duco brothers who are directly impacted by living less than 10 feet from where the asphalt will be for going to considerable time and expense to show up for these meetings. I just got off the phone with Jean Marie. She owns a large parcel across the street from Old Mammoth. She

1:45:47 was not, has only been informed by myself and unfortunately I lost her number and she is going to try and speak. She is adamantly against this project as most of us that live in Old Mammoth. So my name is Tracy Walker. I live on Woodman Street. I've lived in Old Mammoth since 1995. I have owned property out on Woodman Street since 1999. One of the reasons that I purchased

1:46:15 in that area is due to the green space. We are in an area that increasingly has more value because it has less people, less density, and it is rural residential. You guys several times spoke about how it's part of the transit plan to not have large buses on rural residential streets and also about the impact of adding additional

1:46:44 Thank you so much.

1:47:14 on our street by Edison last year and the year previous, which affected birds. And there just seems to not be a sense of respect for the community in Old Mammoth. It is not a safe location. I have pulled out on multiple occasions and we have a serious issue with cyclists, especially the electric bikes.

1:47:40 People who live up above on the bluffs coming down with increasing speed. And I disagree strongly with the statement that there's a half mile visibility in either direction. I don't believe that that's true. I have seen numerous close calls in animals that may or may not have been reported as injured hit in our neighborhood, including our neighbor's cat who was recently

1:48:09 Run over by a speeding vehicle. I would welcome a slow down sign on the downhill side. So I would really like to know why isn't the Water District property adjacent to Aspen Village being considered as an option? The presentation that was given today, I just challenge that it's a much larger, more convenient location.

1:48:37 It's a bigger space. It's right next to Aspen Village, where you guys have created, maybe not you guys, but a trash disaster for our neighborhood with high-density housing. Old Mammoth did not want that. And we have things now due to Aspen Village, including this proposed bus turnaround and infrastructure and taking down of trees and disrespect to wildlife.

1:49:06 and our goal of having a rural residential area from Aspen Village. There is trash that never ever was in the neighborhood because of the density that was brought in. Please keep the density to these areas where we don't have all of this wildlife keeps on getting pushed out, pushed out, pushed out. Why this meeting is stated

1:49:34 to be about locations and yet you're not offering really any other options. Please wrap up your comments. Thank you. I would like to say also that the staff that has attended the previous two meetings has not been very friendly with us or really provided answers. Now Amy did a great job today of you know countering all of these different

1:50:03 I also believe that there's an exemption to fall under in order to run these buses on a rural residential road and I ask that that be inquiried too. Thank you, Tracy. I would like to also say that the majority of people you guys are claiming are in favor, where are these people? Today was the very first time that we have seen anybody from Aspen Village.

1:50:35 The June 30th meeting was actually held at Aspen Village and not one person showed up in favor or even to speak to from that entire community. The only people who were present at that meeting were people that are opposed to this Woodman location. The May 20th meeting, we had one person in favor, three people who were kind of questionable.

1:51:05 And about 30 of us, possibly more, who are not pleased with the location. The study that you guys have created is really skewed. And so it's difficult to look at those numbers and really take them seriously. And I took that study. And it's also, again, difficult to look at the presentation that says that there is a half mile visibility. I challenge that. I've lived on that street.

1:51:35 Since 1999, and I'm telling you, there are safety issues at play. I thank you for your time, and I thank my neighbors for coming out to support each other in this. Tracy. Stacey Corliss, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, good afternoon, everyone. This is Stacey Corliss. I am the Mono County District 5 supervisor representing this area. I live on Sherwin Street.

1:52:07 And many thanks to commissioners for hearing all this comment today. And let me just say, I think I made this comment about five years ago when we started wrestling with difficult transit issues for this area. Let this be a lesson to us as public servants of how to maybe do things differently next time and engage people in these issues earlier and more often and in different ways. I sent some written comments for the commission. I won't.

1:52:37 Repeat all of them, but I get my main message is I'm urging the town to reconsider the preferred location for the bus turnaround at Woodman. It's unfair to pit quality of life and safety issues against the very real need for public transit in the old Mammoth area. Please, I support the comments that suggested looking for solutions in the club drive area, working with the developer.

1:53:06 to at least have a temporary solution in that area or somewhere nearby. But it is difficult, I have to say as a resident, to really take seriously the statements that safety issues are addressed and that all the quality of life issues can be mitigated. A lot of this could have been avoided if

1:53:30 The public had been engaged in this issue much earlier. The first I heard about it was at a town council meeting back in February. I reached out to town council members and the town manager, had a great meeting with Hazlip Hayes, and I appreciate town staff's work on this. I know you're busy, but again, it does feel like all the presentations are kind of backing into Woodman as the only option.

1:53:55 Out of many imperfect options, but I urge the town to go back to the drawing board on this and consider other solutions. Thank you all for your time. Thank you, Stacey. Amy, do we have any additional public comment? Finally, Chair Vanderhurst, I received an email from Katie Drake. It says, I would like to express my support for the proposed Woodman Street bus turnaround.

1:54:25 I believe frequent and reliable transport to the Old Mammoth neighborhood is an important and valuable addition to the red line route. We currently live close to the red and purple lines and use those buses frequently. They add immensely to our quality of life. When considering moving to the Old Mammoth area, a huge drawback for our family was the lack of public transit options. And that is all the public comment. Thank you, Jamie. All right, at this time, I think I'll close this presentation. I'd like to thank everyone who...

1:54:56 submitted their public comment, whether on Zoom or in person, your passion is definitely being felt, no question about it. And I would advise you to maybe bring that same passion and energy to the next town council meeting. So thank you for your participation. I'm gonna move into our public hearings. We'll go to 5.1, which is to consider the approval of a use permit request to allow commercial cannabis.

1:55:26 Cultivation, Manufacturing and Distribution Facility at 312 Commerce Drive, Units A and B in the Industrial Zone. And I think Mike, is Michael our staff contact on this? Yep. One second while I share my screen. Can everybody see that all right? Yeah. Thank you, Michael. Thank you. All right. So the applicant, Peter Sheldon, is requesting

1:56:01 Use permit 21-002 to allow commercial cannabis cultivation, manufacturing and distribution facility at 312 Commerce Drive, Units A and B. Use permit for various commercial cannabis activities was previously issued for the subject site in 2016 and amended in 2018. However, the use permit expired on March 13, 2021 due to inactivity and the cannabis business operation never commenced. Peter is the same applicant as the previous use permit.

1:56:31 But the proposed cannabis activities differ, and the current use permit proposal should be considered on its own merits. 312 Commerce Drive is located in the Industrial Zoning District. The site was developed in 1999 with an approximately 5,750 square foot structure that is divided into three leasable spaces. The proposed cannabis business will occupy two of the spaces, with the remaining space occupied by a vehicle service business.

1:57:04 The proposed project consists of cultivation, manufacturing and distribution uses operating under the elevation green business. The proposed cultivation operation will consist of four rooms. Plants will be moved from room to room as they transition through various stages of growth. Once plants reach the final stage of growth, they'll be moved to the mature canopy room, which can accommodate a total of 126 mature plants.

1:57:30 Plants will then be harvested, waved, and home to dry in the drying and harvest storage room. Once dried, the plants will be processed, waved, and recorded in the track and trace system. The product will then be packaged for wholesale to a manufacturer, packaged for temporary use in Elevation Greens manufacturing operations, or packaged into a final retail form. The proposed manufacturing operation will produce cannabis goods such as edibles, vape cartridges, pre-rolls,

1:57:56 and mechanical extracts and the manufacturing methods will not include any forms of volatile extraction. The proposed distribution operation will consist of transporting cannabis and cannabis products to and from other licensed establishments and is required to adhere to all regulations set forth by the Bureau of Cannabis Control, town Mammoth Lakes and all applicable state and local laws. A proposed site plan for the operation can be seen here.

1:58:28 The cultivation operation is located in the center of the site plan, which is the ground floor of Unit A. Additionally, on the second floor of Unit A, located on the left side of this site plan, drying, harvesting, and non-manufactured cannabis processing will take place. Manufacturing and distribution activities will occur in Unit B, which can be accessed from Unit A through an internal door. The proposed operations and site plan have been reviewed by the Mammoth Fire District, Police Department,

1:58:57 and Mammoth Community Water District and all have given their approval for the project. Staff has determined that the findings for the use permit can be met and recommends the adoption of the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approved use permit 21-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. This concludes my presentation. The applicant, Peter Shelvin.

1:59:29 and his consultant Margie DeRose are both on the Zoom call if they're needed to answer any questions. So my fellow commissioners, before we start with the questioning of staff, I would like to invite the applicant if he'd like to make a statement on his proposal at this time. It's not required, but if you'd like to, this would be the appropriate time. I'm not seeing anybody's box light up here. So I'm gonna assume you're

2:00:07 going to reframe. So I'll open it up to my fellow commissioners if they would like to ask any questions of staff or the applicant. Commissioner Chang, please. Michael, did you say that this is the same applicant that had the approval back in 2016, which expired in 2018 or 2000, something like that? That's correct. Yeah, it actually expired in March of this year. So March of 2021.

2:00:43 And so this is an extent, this is a new approval, new submission, it's not an extension. That's correct. Completely separate from the previous application that was approved. And like I said earlier, you know, reviewed on its own merits and with no real need to look at what was previously approved for the site. Okay. So I have questions for the applicant in that

2:01:14 I'm trying to. We've got your audio. Okay. Sorry about my video. I'm off here. Commissioner Chang, please. Okay. So the question for the applicant is, one of the question is, I understand that this is a new submission. However, we did quite a bit of time back then to evaluate this particular case or a similar case, a prior submission. What?

2:01:50 I just need to understand why then that materialized. It took several years and now you're coming back for a similar application, similar type of a production facility. So I'm a little confused as to if it didn't work, why is it working? Why do you think it's going to work now? Well, what we were doing previously was food manufacturing and we ran into

2:02:22 We had purchased a great deal of packaging, about $30,000, and the state changed their templates for what was required on those packaging, which kind of burned that money. We then waited again, and there was several changes to templates. And then as time went on, sort of a demand for that product changed.

2:02:50 Thank you, sir.

2:03:20 You know, we always want our local businesses here to succeed. And, you know, we would like to see a business like yours to succeed as well. So, with that said, do you think the current legislations and policies here in California, do you think that's going to somehow have a create additional headwind for you? Yes.

2:03:48 The state is changing its policy dramatically and making it far easier for small businesses to survive. And actually just yesterday or the day before, they just combined all the three departments of the Department of Cannabis Control, Cultivation into one department. Gavin Newsom just got that pushed through. So things are more streamlined, less burdensome.

2:04:18 There was, I mean, when this, when we initially applied and adult use became legal, there were thousands of applications and a lot of those have not made it, but this is a good time now and having a small or a very small grow to, you know, like a small winemaker. There's customers that want quality. They're getting very frustrated with the sort of

2:04:48 Volume production out there for good medicine. So I think we'll do well. So you kind of describe your business as more like a craft grower? Oh, completely. Got it. Okay. Yeah. No, the square footage of each facility is 1,300 square feet. So the area, the flower area is about, you know, 350 square feet. So it's, and when you see the number of whatever it was, 100 and something plants, those are small plants. Those aren't big.

2:05:20 There isn't that room in the facility. Thank you. Thank you. Any further questions for either staff or the applicant from our fellow commissioners? Michael, I've got a couple of really quick questions for you. You said this project has gained the approval from the Mammoth Lakes Fire District, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, and the Mammoth Lakes Water District. Is that correct? Correct. Could you briefly explain why we,

2:05:59 Why the applicant had to get the approval from the water district? Well, any type of use permit would, you know, go to the water district for review, regardless of the type. But this one was a little bit different than any ones that we have approved in the past, just because we have not, under our current regulations, permitted any cannabis cultivation. So it's important for the district to look at both water use.

2:06:28 and water discharge to make sure that there weren't going to be any impacts that would be felt throughout the system. And I know they went back and forth with the applicant a couple of times, but they were able to work with the applicant to make sure their operating plans met the requirements of the district. Got it.

2:06:55 And this applicant is not intending to have any sort of a storefront down there, correct? This is 100% manufacturing or cultivation? Yes, that's correct. There'll be no exterior indication that there is even a cannabis business inside of the building. And there will be no retail as well. Got it. And this application is not subject to our zoning radius ordinances we have in place for the retail?

2:07:25 operations in town, correct? That's correct. Whereas the retail operations have to be certain distances from each other, that's not the case with the manufacturing, distribution and cultivation. And how many other manufacturing, cannabis manufacturing operations are currently operating in the industrial park? Currently one other manufacturing operation. So this would be our second? Correct.

2:07:55 Got it. Okay. And then my last question is for Peter, the applicant. Peter, if you get green-lighted today and once your operation is up and running, how many employees are you envisioning having working for you? Within the first year, four. If we plan to, if this all goes the way it's supposed to go, to add an additional loft in the B unit, and then we'd probably bring in three more employees. Got it. Okay.

2:08:25 You're creating a workforce. Yeah, and it's year-round, irregardless of economy and weather and everything else. Got it, thank you. So if I don't have any further questions from my fellow commissioners, I'd like to open this up to public comment. Jamie, do we have any public comment, either in person or via Zoom? No, we do not. Okay, then I'll bring it back to the commission. Does anybody want to deliberate on this, have a conversation?

2:08:57 State their views? Well, I always root for the little guys. Yay! If it's a craft business, you know, we want them to succeed. And hopefully, you know, they're not going to get bogged down with all the legislations and politics of California. So, and hopefully that they can, you know, really flourish in moving forward. You know, the...

2:09:27 The one, you know, looks like you're gonna have a four to seven employees or maybe more. So, of course, you know, we don't know housing. That's the housing is always an issue for a lot of employers here in town. And that's a decent size employment you have. So, you know, I think this, to me, it's, you know, I'm in favor of it. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Burroughs. I do have one comment.

2:10:00 I just want to say that I've made it very clear in all our meetings that I'm not looking to have a pot store on every corner and I don't think that that sends a good message to our kids and our community. However, I know that there's only one other business in the commerce area that is making soaps and whatnot. And so...

2:10:29 I feel pretty good about this, that we're not overburdening that area, and it's not overly concentrated with marijuana type dispensaries, cultivation, whatnot, so I'm in support of this one. Thank you, Commissioner Burrows. Michael, would you just, oh, sorry, Commissioner Eckert. Yeah, as long as we got four or seven people working here that weren't before.

2:10:58 And more importantly to me, it's four or seven people that are working here who are not selling skis, who are not tourism related. Maybe we don't want to become the pot king of the Eastern Sierra, but at least these are local people who are going to work here 12 months out of the year, have one job 40 hours a week. I'm a big yes. Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. Michael, could you just really briefly, I know this meeting is going very long, but would you really briefly maybe bring the commission up to speed on

2:11:28 If we did have a slew of subsequent applicants that wanted to open up this type of business, how we could limit the amount of operation down there? Sure. So, you know, the way the use permit process works, you're essentially reviewing the applications for, you know,

2:11:57 Performance with the zoning district and also impacts the surrounding properties. And if it would, if we were ever to reach a point where, you know, the excess or number of cannabis related businesses in the area were, you know, disrupting the character, not allowing other businesses to operate properly, and were causing, you know, issues that were felt down in the industrial zone or else throughout other parts of town.

2:12:27 That's definitely something that you could bring up through the application process and as a way to limit. Because there's no, in the code, there's no real limit to the number, especially for cultivation, manufacturing and distribution. But that's definitely something that you could bring up through the process. Thank you, Michael. So if unless Commissioner Kennedy has a thought that she'd like to share, I will definitely entertain a motion.

2:12:59 I will make a motion, but Michael, can you put the slide back up? Sure. You see it? Maybe? I do not see your screen anymore. You see it? No, we don't have your screen. I can pull it up. Strange. On my end, maybe. I'm not sure what. If anyone else hasn't pulled it, feel free to use it. It just came up, Michael. Okay.

2:13:32 Perfect. So I will move to adopt the PEDC resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving use permit 21-002 with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second that. Jamie, may we have a vote please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Commissioner Eckert? You're on mute. Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes.

2:14:11 Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Congratulations, Peter. We honestly hope your operation is successful and you have a workforce on the higher end of seven or eight. And like Commissioner Eckert said, anything we can do to help diversify the economy here is a welcome thing. So good luck. Thank you very much. All right, we're gonna move to...

2:14:42 Public hearing item 5.2, consider approval of the use permit design review and variance requests to allow the expansion of the Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station at 59 Commerce Drive and at 264 Commerce Drive. And I believe Kim is our staff contact on this one. Yes, thank you, Michael. I'm going to share my screen. Can everybody see that? We got it. Okay.

2:15:30 Peter, I think you have to mute yourself. Hello. Okay. Sorry, Kim. Hey, Peter, would you mind muting yourself or dropping off the Zoom, please? Thank you. It's all yours, Kim. Thank you. So if everybody can see my screen, I'll get going. This is the public hearing and consideration of the proposed Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station Expansion Project.

2:16:02 We have two use permit applications, a major design review and a variance application for consideration as a part of this project. A little background as to how we got here. The Mammoth Disposal Company currently operates an existing small volume transfer station and buyback recycling center at 59 Commerce Drive. The facility serves the town and other areas of Mono County under an approved franchise agreement.

2:16:30 Under the facility's current solid waste permit, solid waste facilities permit, the transfer station is limited to accepting a maximum of 15 tons of waste per day. In September of 2020, Town Council approved a new franchise agreement between the town and Mammoth Disposal Company. Some of the town's primary objectives in negotiating the franchise agreement included addressing changes in service and disposal operations.

2:16:59 In anticipation of the Benton Crossing landfill closure, which is expected to occur around January 1st, 2023. Other needs were to provide for additional capacity, including the construction of a new transfer station building and to provide for improved recycling services. The approved franchise agreement requires Mammoth disposal to construct a new transfer station building.

2:17:27 Located at the site of the existing transfer station by December 1st, 2022. Once Benton Crossing Landfill is closed, Mammoth Disposal Route Trucks and other users will no longer be able to haul loads directly to the landfill. It is anticipated that those loads will be dumped at the transfer station in Mammoth and consolidated into long haul trucks prior to being transported to a different landfill. The town received an application for the

2:17:57 Transfer Station Expansion Project on August 26, 2020, and on November 18, 2020, Town Council authorized a professional services agreement with Michael Baker International for the preparation of an initial study, mitigated negative declaration to evaluate the potential impacts associated with the proposed development and operation of the transfer station.

2:18:23 The transfer station expansion project comprises two separate properties. A use permit is required to permit the proposed large volume transfer station use at 59 Commerce Drive. This use falls under the town's major utility land use category. A separate use permit is required to permit the proposed large collection recycling facility at the 264 Commerce Drive site at this site.

2:18:56 The major design review and variance applications are applicable to the proposed construction at the 59 Commerce Drive site. The project proposes to expand the existing transfer station facilities at the 59 Commerce Drive site, relocate the existing buyback recycling center currently located at 59 Commerce Drive to the 264 Commerce Drive site.

2:19:24 and to relocate the fleet maintenance operations currently occupying the building at 264 Commerce Drive to the 59 Commerce Drive site. The site design for 59 Commerce Drive is intended to improve on-site operations, increase efficiencies and increase the amount of solid waste and recyclable materials that can be processed.

2:19:53 When individual patrons and route trucks from Mammoth Lakes and the surrounding community dispose of waste at the transfer station, the waste would be sorted, compacted, and consolidated inside the transfer station building and loaded into haul trucks, which the facility is not currently capable of handling. Those haul trucks would then transport the waste to a different landfill facility within 48 hours of receiving the waste.

2:20:20 Proposed site improvements include construction of a new 9,600 square foot enclosed transfer station building, a new 1,856 square foot office building. Part of the project includes demolition of the existing 1,200 square foot office building, the relocation of the fleet maintenance operations to the existing 3,050 square foot building.

2:20:47 Construction of a new 2,250 square foot metal canopy structure, which will be used to shelter new truck scales and a 200 square foot scale house, and construction of a 10 foot tall masonry wall and access gates. Due to the physical site constraints, internal truck circulation and access requirements,

2:21:14 The applicants are requesting the option to provide a snow management plan through the use permit process instead of providing all required snow storage on site. The project proposes temporary snow storage areas, mainly in the corners and on the south side of the property. The transfer station facility is anticipated to receive an average of 78 tons of waste per day with a peak throughput of 301.

2:21:44 Tons per day. The transfer station building, office building, metal canopy, scale booth, and other site improvements are designed to integrate with the surrounding environment and adjacent industrial uses to the greatest extent possible given the industrial nature of the use. The proposed building heights are below the maximum 35 foot height limit. The exterior building colors selected for the new structures are based on the Mammoth Lakes Design Guidelines Color Handbook Recommendations.

2:22:18 and incorporates the desired color palette for the town. The proposed colors are the specified commercial coating colors available for the metal building components. No trees will be removed from the site as a part of the project because there are no trees currently on the site. A landscape plan for the project does include the planting of six new Jeffrey pine trees along the Commerce Drive frontage and incorporates boulders and native shrubs.

2:22:48 The requested variance for the 10-foot-tall masonry wall and access gates, it would be a 2-foot height increase from 8 feet to 10 feet. And the request is based on improved screening for the outdoor storage and work areas of the site, as well as to deter bears and unauthorized access to the site. So moving on to the 264 Commerce Drive site.

2:23:20 There is an existing 6,800 square foot metal building on the site currently used for Mammoth Disposal's fleet maintenance operations. This building would be repurposed for operation of the buyback recycling center. The site proposes three primary operational areas, which includes a buyback center for CRV containers, a non-buyback recycling center,

2:23:50 A household hazardous waste collection area, and the non-public areas within the building include commercial unloading and curbside recyclable sorting area, commercial cardboard and recycling and bailing area, and a bailing loading and transport area. To convert the site to a large collection recycling facility, the project proposes to move

2:24:20 Portable bins and equipment from the current operation at 59 Commerce Drive. No major physical improvements to the building or paved areas are proposed. However, new drainage and utility improvements are required as well as construction of a six foot tall perimeter masonry wall for screening purposes. The applicant is requesting the option here to provide a snow management plan as well based on the need for year round circulation for route trucks.

2:24:51 The building at the site is more than twice the size of the current recycling facility at 59 Commerce Drive, which is intended to accommodate the increase in volume of recyclable material, which is anticipated to receive approximately 11 tons per day with a peak of 36 tons per day. The project is consistent with the general plan land use map. The entire project area is

2:25:23 designated as industrial. And the general plan, the industrial land use designation allows a limited variety of light manufacturing and service uses that can be contained within wholly enclosed structures. The project would be consistent with this requirement because the entire project site is located in the town's industrial district and the proposed operations would primarily be conducted within wholly enclosed structures. And both sites are also screened from public.

2:25:53 The project is also consistent with specific goals and policies of the general plan, which I've listed here on the slide. The project also meets the development standards applicable to new development in the industrial zoning district, including standards for building height, setbacks, parking, landscaping, exterior lighting, and screening. Due to the physical site constraints at both sites and the year-round internal truck circulation needs,

2:26:26 The applicant's request to provide a snow management plan for snow removal through this use permit application process would satisfy snow storage requirements of the zoning code. Additionally, approval of the requested variance for the increase in wool height at the 59 Commerce Drive site would satisfy the development standard for fence and wool heights. An initial study mitigated negative

2:26:58 negative declaration was prepared to evaluate the potential environmental effects of the project. During preparation of the draft ISMND, a request for tribal consultation was received from the Mono Lake Kutsadika Tribe. Staff and the consultant team held a consultation meeting with the tribe's chairperson, Charlotte Ling, in order to provide project information and answer questions from the tribe.

2:27:23 After that meeting, we did not receive any additional comments or requests for information from Charlotte Lane. Prior to the public review and comment period for the draft ISNM&D, the applicant team provided two presentations as public outreach regarding the project. A public presentation was organized by the applicant and was held via Zoom on March 23rd.

2:27:49 A presentation was also given to the trails HOA board on March 31st. The draft initial study mitigated negative declaration was circulated for public review from May 10th, 2021 to June 8th, 2021. The town received three comment letters in total, which included comments from Cal Recycle, Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District and Mono County Environmental Health.

2:28:18 Responses to the comments received on the draft IS M&D were prepared and included in the final M&D and based on the analysis provided in the initial study mitigated negative declaration, it was found that there would not be a significant effect on the environment as a result of the project with mitigation measures incorporated. The mitigation measures have been included as conditions of approval and they include a workers environmental awareness program.

2:28:51 Archeological and Native American monitoring and preparation of a traffic management plan for approval by the Public Works Department prior to issuance of a grading permit. With that, staff is recommending that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the PEDC resolutions, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings to adopt the mitigated negative declaration.

2:29:24 And approve use permit number 20-001 and 20-004, sign review 20-002 and variance 20, that was 20-001 with conditions as recommended. That concludes my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Kim. On the PEDC. Is the applicant on the call? There is somebody representing. We have.

2:29:54 Glenn Long and Dave Brown here to represent Mammoth Disposal. We also have Kristen Bogue and Alan Ashimini with Michael Baker International if there are any questions about the environmental analysis. Great, thank you, Kim. So before I'm gonna turn it over to the commission's questions for staff or the applicant, I'd like to give the applicant, first of all, thank you for your patience to wait this long into this agenda, but if you'd like to take a...

2:30:23 A moment or two to address the commission. Now would be the appropriate time. Okay. Actually, Dave, I'll start and I'll hand it off to you. My name is Glenn Long. I'm the district general manager for Mammoth Disposal. Dave Brown, who's with me here today, is our lead engineer on the project and has been involved in it from the beginning. And so I think that certainly the project overall is a...

2:30:53 Great response to the inevitable closure of the Ben Crossing landfill. It sounds like a long ways off, the first of 2023, but obviously, in fact, it's the end of next year. And so we have a tight window to get this done. And I think everyone's worked together to make sure it's the right project and that we get it right. So with that, Dave, go ahead. Good afternoon. Whoa. Sorry, I've got some feedback. Hold on.

2:31:25 I think that took care of it. So I'm going to share my screen here in a minute. Let me pull this up. That should work. So good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, commissioners, town staff, members of the public. As Glenn said, I'm Dave Brown. I've been working on this since the beginning. If you guys can see my screen okay. We got you. So there's just, in town staff, I really appreciate what Kim pulled together there in the presentation. I think that hits on.

2:31:54 Pretty much the overview for the whole project, but there's a couple items I want to bring up, and part of it's because of comments that happen through the public process and talking about the public outreach. Some folks didn't quite understand what was actually happening, so I was going to put a visual with it. As Kim said, there's really two sites that are involved. One has the existing fleet maintenance operations, and that'll basically be where the new recycling goes to, and the existing site right off 59 Commerce is where the existing transfer station and

2:32:23 Recycling is and what that'll end up being is a new transfer station within the fleet maintenance center right next to it. As you can see on this exhibit, the nearest neighbors are the trail subdivision here to the southwest. They pretty much aligned the entire business park. That was one of the big reasons to have a public outreach meeting with them. This project, there were initial discussions about doing a transfer station back in 2013 and even before that, at that time, for those that were around, it actually involved.

2:32:53 Some additional property and was going to move some other facilities closer to the trails. All that went away back in 2013 as well. So this one only deals with the property where the existing transfer station is. The actual public outreach with the trails went really well. I want to say there were probably now less than six or eight people that showed up or attended for that virtual meeting. And it was about the same turnout that we ended up seeing the other public outreach meeting. There were basically about five folks that showed up.

2:33:22 Between the two meetings, no one really had any comments about the overall design or any design changes. The one item people did ask a lot about was circulation. So I wanted to explain just two parts of this exhibit just so that folks know what these arrows actually represent because it was a great question and it's not really described in the text anywhere. So what you're seeing on here, these blue arrows basically represent what a

2:33:48 A normal person, what their travel route would be. So somebody coming in to just drop off their trash, what they would see during a normal day is they would basically pull straight in, go under a new covered canopy, meet with, you know, see the attendant shed, and then could pull straight over and drop off right at the transfer building. There's a set, you know, we have, you know, several spaces over in this area and then they would basically pull out that same direction to exit the facility.

2:34:16 The green arrows is what you would see for the route trucks. So these are the ones that pick up trash that currently go to Benton and now would come here to drop off. They would pull straight through, go over the actual scale, and then they have just a single pull through and pull out through the building that's separate from the public just to keep people apart. The last color you see is this orange color. And this is basically the on-the-road haul trucks that would be taking the basically as

2:34:44 The way a tipping station works is, or a transfer station works, is all the trash goes on to a tipping floor, gets loaded by material handlers and loaders into, you know, great big, you know, tractor-trailer-type rigs, and then those will get hauled off to a landfill facility. So that's what this orange line is, is really just giving an idea of what the actual, you know, tractor-trailers that you would end up seeing for the haul trucks. And that was the majority of what folks were really asking about during the public outreach meeting. We did have a summertime

2:35:14 Route so that folks, if they're just dropping off their bag of trash, they can basically, you know, just check in with the attendant and we're going to have these two public drop boxes here on the south side. When it's not used for snow cover, that's what this blue pattern is, is really for snow storage. So outside of winter months, there would be two bins right here that they could immediately just drop their bag in there and immediately pull out and not have to wait in line or in queue to do something at the transfer building.

2:35:42 So this is really set up to try and, you know, expedite and get people in and out as quick as they can, make it a little more efficient, as Kim was saying in the report. The other item that kind of got the CC to, sorry, the other item up at 264 Commerce that I had from some of the public outreach is what's actually really changing? What can we expect to change up there? The building is unchanged.

2:36:08 All the storm drains out in front of it are unchanged. The main part that's changing is this blue, there's some minor earthwork that's going to happen to basically bring the current infiltration system up to current standards. So we're working with, you know, Town Public Works on this to go ahead and expand this infiltrator. Other than that, it's really just the only other improvement going in is a wall, basically from the building out to this property line.

2:36:34 And that's the only improvements. Everything else is already paved. The building's going to be unchanged. It actually makes it a very, very fairly simple process for when the transition happens to move that recycling center over here and get it operational for folks with the least amount of downtime. So kind of looking ahead, we pulled together a overall schedule back. This was actually from a year ago, surprisingly, as I look at it and I can see that this was looking at what it would take to go through the use process.

2:37:03 Use permit process, building permits, and eventually really focus on this lower part down here, which is construction. Ironically, we had this meeting set for here right around July. We had the Town Planning Commission meeting around the 19th. So our powers of prediction happened to work out, knock on wood, on that. But the way that construction is going to work on this is basically the main...

2:37:27 Part of the grading and main building frame are going to happen this fall, basically here probably starting somewhere right around September 1st or slightly before or after. There's going to be a big push to get that building frame up, get it shielded in so that then the interiors can be worked on over the winter months. And then sometime as soon as we get some favorable weather in 2022, the contractor will finish up working on that scale canopy. Keep in mind that

2:37:56 The existing transfer station operation is going to keep going on this site during all of the construction. So the way we're accommodating that is basically having a line drawn right down the middle where everything on this west half is being built really in 2021, which is today just bin storage. And then that allows the transfer station to keep operating the way it is today. And then at some point in 22, there'll be a temporary relocation of that attendant shed that's out there right down probably over to this area.

2:38:26 Just south of the transfer station, just with some outdoor bins for a few months while this canopy gets erected. That's the overall kind of how everything's moving forward. As far as the staff report and recommendations, we, you know, we've reviewed those. We request approval of the use permit, the design review and the variance with, you know, the way staff has it recommended and are happy to answer any questions that folks might have. I can leave this screen up or I can stop sharing.

2:38:56 Thank you. If you wouldn't mind, stop sharing, just so I can get a good bird's eye view of the Zoom square. So at this time, I'd like to open it up to any questions from the commission to either staff or the applicant. Commissioner Burroughs, please. Kim, can you let us know what the HOA trails stated? And I just wanted to clarify that all waste is gonna be removed within 48 hours. Is that correct?

2:39:30 Yes, so the 48 hours is a regulatory requirement for their solid waste facilities permit. The comments that we received from Cal Recycle and from Motto County Environmental Health both corrected the document to state it's not 72 hours, it's actually 48 hours. So that was corrected and the applicants will have to comply with that.

2:39:55 As far as the trails HOA public outreach meeting, I was on that meeting and I recall some comments regarding the last project that was proposed and then there were questions regarding increases in traffic and potential increases in noise. At that point in the project, we had not released the draft mitigated negative declaration for public review and comment.

2:40:24 So once that was released, we emailed two of the primary people commenting at that meeting, E.L. Smurgeon, and I can't quite remember the other gentleman's name. But so that was put out there, and since that time, we have not received any comments. And then we have considered the bike path there, the multi-use path, and we were putting mitigation there too.

2:40:53 for traffic flow and to protect our pedestrians, correct? That's right. So as a special public works condition of approval for the project, I think it was like condition number 61, there is a pedestrian activated rapid flashing beacon that is going to be required to be installed at the MAP connector trail that crosses Commerce Drive. Thank you, that's all I had.

2:41:24 Thank you. Anybody else on the commission have questions for staff or the applicant? Please, Commissioner Chang. The 10-foot wall, do we have any 10-foot wall in this town other than what's being proposed? Commissioner Chang, this is, thank you. I believe we have some retaining walls on

2:41:49 Main Street that are probably taller than that. Freestanding walls, not that I can think of off the top of my head, but I do believe we do have some retaining walls kind of between the properties along the north side of Main Street that probably exceed 10 feet. This is not retaining wall though, right? Correct. This is just freestanding walls. And it's going to be mason block, you said? That's right. It would need to be a masonry solid block wall.

2:42:20 I think Dave has proposed, it's a, Dave, can you describe the wall material? Sure, so the, it's a masonry wall right now. We were in between doing a CMU type block wall or doing a precast tilt-up wall that fits into, you know, channels with columns. Either way, it's still a masonry wall, which is what the zoning ordinance required for this type of use. Kim, you talked about,

2:42:55 You described the amount of volume that is coming in to the transfer station and also to the other location, the other building. Can you translate that? Well, maybe the applicant can help me understand this. Can you translate that in terms of number of trucks that's going to come in and out of that street? And what is that circulation pattern? Are you coming down Main Street? Are you coming down?

2:43:25 Meridian, to get to Commerce Drive, and how many trucks are we talking about here per day? Yeah, so we did have an analysis in the appendices for the mitigated negative declaration. There was a traffic analysis done which did break down the number of trips and included truck trips. Dave, can you speak to that at all? Dave or Kristen?

2:44:02 So just to, this is Kristen Boga, I'm with Michael Baker International and I assist the town with the CEQWID document. Just to clarify, we're asking what the ADT was that was considered for the traffic impact analysis for the LOS. I'm sorry, that's a lot of acronym, I don't understand. That's not, so. Are we asking how many average daily trips we're gonna have for the purposes of considering delay on the roads?

2:44:32 No, I'm asking how many trucks are actually going in and out of Commerce Drive from these two facilities on a daily basis based on the volume that was quoted earlier. I can look that up for you right now. Kristen, I've got that spreadsheet already ready if you want me to show that. Sure, that'd be great. I'll just do that real quick. So this is the spreadsheet straight out of the...

2:45:09 Transportation analysis that was done for this. So, and you're right, most of this, Commissioner, is coming off of Meridian and up to Highway 203. The route trucks, so the guys that pick up the, you know, containers throughout the day, the main difference they're going to see is instead of going from the town out to Benton, they're going from the town straight to this site. But otherwise, any of, any volume that, beyond those that would have gone to Benton is now coming down to a 300 Meridian. So what you're seeing here is, go ahead, sorry.

2:45:39 So is it correct to say that you have a fixed amount of trucks that are going through town to pick up trash, right? And then everybody, all these trucks are going out to Benton currently. And so now we're simply just, that's going to stop in 2003 and that's all going to go into the transfer station. That's correct. And parking wise, are all these trucks going to park here?

2:46:10 Or are they going to be routed somewhere else? So to answer those two questions, so on this table, what you're going to see in this top third is existing volumes. The second tiering is project-generated volumes. So you'll just see this nine trucks or nine trips. So this is basically the increase that this project is having. Because it's overwhelmingly, the amount of trips that really come into this facility is mostly vehicles that are actually dropping off very small loads.

2:46:41 The second part of your question, and I apologize, I got focused on the first part, what was the second part? No, no, no, it's okay. I was just wondering, you know, with the traffic pattern and the volume, the traffic volume of the trucks, are they then, when they're done picking up, are they staying here? Oh, absolutely. Yes. So the parking that was shown on the site plan, I'll pull that over just so you can see it.

2:47:15 On this layout, all these parking spaces over here on the right, these are where the trucks park. There's not a whole lot of trucks. This is a very, you know, small amount of trucks. But the whole trucks basically just park over here at night, and then in the morning, they're out doing routes during the day, which is the same way they're set up on the other side up the street. They're just parked in the morning or overnight and then out during the day. So there wouldn't be any, the whole trucks aren't going to be, you know, parked somewhere outside of this facility. This is literally where their fleet maintenance is going to happen.

2:47:44 Where their haul trucks will be. And then the only new truck coming in is really just the on-the-road haul trucks that are taking this up to a whole different landfill. Okay. If you can lead this up here real quick. Sure. One of the reasons I asked about the parking is that I see here the legend here says parking area for snow storage calculation. That's the gray area. So that covers quite a bit of the spacing here.

2:48:15 And if you look at the snow storage area, it's the light blue area that you have. And I understand you guys are, you will provide a snow management process or report on this. Does this mean you still have sufficient amount of parking in the wintertime, you know, for these, for the fleet of trucks that you have?

2:48:48 So, yes. So, right now, there's only one parking space that's actually shown in a snow storage area. That would be the space 11. The rest of all the snow storage shown is outside of what would be a parking area. So, it's not, yeah, we wouldn't be pushing snow right into a, we're not trying to double count, you know, snow storage within a parking space. Got it. Okay. That's all I have. Thank you, sir. Yes. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Any other commissioners who have any questions?

2:49:18 Jessica, if you're good, Commissioner Kennedy's good, Commissioner Burroughs, already had a chance, Commissioner Eckert, I'm gonna assume not if I don't see your mute turn off. Jamie, do we have any public comment on this, either in person or via Zoom? No, we do not. We do not. So I just have a really quick question for Dave, and Dave, if you feel comfortable answering it, then feel free, if you don't, then don't.

2:49:50 Have you identified the new landfill location? Yes. So there's, right now the plan is that, and just to clarify, you mean to where the waste is going to end up ultimately being hauled to? Correct, sir. Yeah, right now the, you know, basically the Waste Connections, which is the parent company for Mammoth Disposal, they're in contracts with, I believe it's Russell Paths up out of near Fallon. Glenn, you might, you know, clarify that, but that's where it would be going.

2:50:19 Yeah, we met with Public Works and I believe their accounting department from the city of Fallon about two months ago and we talked with them probably about a year and a half ago as well. So that's the closest location that we could go to and they are very interested in getting the flow to come to them. So yeah, had very positive meetings and we expect that to continue down that road.

2:50:49 Got it. And Glenn, that long-haul truck that would be taking the waste up to Fallon, will that truck live on the Mammoth site when it's not in transit? Yeah, we park it inside. Got it, okay. I think, you know, what we're estimating right now, currently in Fallon, they're only open five days a week to local residents, but they're going to open it up on the weekends for us.

2:51:18 And so we'll be probably hauling six days a week at minimum. And so that 48-hour issue is really not going to be an issue. So it's, I mean, I think we've got it pretty well thought out. And we've already been in conversations with a local company that we use right now to haul our recycling material to Southern California. We're talking to them about increasing their business and doing the hauls from here to Fallon.

2:51:48 Got it. Has any thought been given to if the highways are closed in the winter because of the weather and you guys cannot get it out in the 40 hours? Basically, we haven't come up with an actual price yet. We have pricing for the direct route, the closest route, but we've already been in conversations about what happens when, you know, we have

2:52:13 You know, eight feet of snow in a night and got to go a different direction. So we will have pricing with them already set up if that, you know, if that happens, which I'm sure it's so. So you do have a plan B in place. We do. Thank you. And Kim, my question for you is, is this application meeting all the town's requirements in terms of parking for the public? Yes, it is. The recycling facility site requires 11 spaces.

2:52:44 They have proposed 14 spaces, including parking spaces in queue for unloading. And the transfer station site requires 23 spaces, and they're providing 27 spaces, including vehicles in queue, which is just the way that their operation works. People aren't parking there long-term, they're driving through and dropping off material. Got it. Thank you, Kim.

2:53:10 Am I right in assuming that the snow management plan involves some hauling of snow offsite? Is that kind of what I'm hearing? That's correct. So as part of the snow management plan, they have to identify the temporary storage areas, the snow removal schedule and the snow removal company that they, I believe they have to identify the snow removal company that they will be contracting with.

2:53:40 The agreement does get recorded for the property. Got it. And so they're meeting all the town's requirements in terms of that plan? Yes. Thank you. Yeah, I don't have any other questions. I'll throw it back to the other commissioners if you have any comments or questions, or if you want to deliberate on this, or if not, I'll happily entertain a motion.

2:54:11 Hey, Chair, the only comment I have is that retaining, is that freestanding walls of 10 feet. That seems extremely high, but at the same time, I understand that, you know, why they want to do what they want to do. But it's, I guess, it's unfair for me to say, let me rephrase that, it's unfair for me to say that it's extremely high, even though I know the typical standard here in your state, you don't really see 10 foot walls.

2:54:41 in any industrial facilities. So I'm just curious because, you know, you have a, you know, when you drive on Commerce Drive, you go up, you know, there's a slight gray and then so you're going to see that wall on the left-hand side even taller. So, and I'm assuming there's going to be vegetation around the area to kind of break up the facade.

2:55:12 So anyway, I mean, that's just more of a comment, you know, feedback than anything else. Got it. Dave, would you like to address that or are you good? Yeah, I think to, and just to clarify, the wall is not going to be on the commerce frontage, so that's going to be unchanged. The area where the wall is going to be located is basically in the back half of this property. So there's already an existing, basically the wall that's already at the south end of this property is already a 10 foot high, you know,

2:55:41 You know, two foot by two foot type stacked block wall. So it'd be the same height. So as far as visibility from the trails looking down, they're about 60 feet higher than this site. They're not going to see, you know, the extra two foot height. The guys that will see it is on the west side next to the alley. It'll be an extra two feet taller next to those industrial folks. Part of the reason that for the whole, well, I won't go into the reason on the 10 foot, I think you guys already understand that with just security and bear control is the whole reason to need that extra two feet.

2:56:10 You know, bears can certainly climb over eight feet pretty easy, but at 10 feet, they really struggle. Thank you. Any other questions? No? Would anybody care to put forth a motion? Can Kim put up the motion, the approval? I'm trying. Sorry, I didn't know if I had, I'm going in and out of service, so I'm trying. So, is it up? It is up. We need the last page. Oh, it's the airport.

2:56:56 Oh, how about now? Nope, airport. No, you need to stop sharing and reshare again, I think. Or you could read the recommendation and then a commissioner can say, so moved. Oh, there it is. Perfect. Okay.

2:57:16 I make a motion to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolutions making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings to adopt the mitigated negative declaration and approve use permits 20-001 and 20-004, design review 20-002 and variance 19-001 with conditions as recommended. Jen, really quick, that was a typo. It should be variance 20-001.

2:57:46 20, sorry, variance, 20-001, as, with conditions as recommended. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. We have a second from Commissioner Eckert. Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Congratulations, gentlemen.

2:58:16 Hey, Glenn, one last question I wanted to shoot at you and I kind of forgot. Do you anticipate increasing your employee force with this expansion? Yeah, actually, we have already started in some ways developing some of our younger folks and in anticipation of some of the jobs that we'll need to fill downstream, so absolutely. I think the total headcount to run it is going to be, I think, five and we're partway there already. Thank you. Yep.

2:58:44 Thank you. Congratulations, gentlemen. Thank you very much, everybody. All right, I'm going to bounce this over to Sandra right now as we move into business matters. I think we are getting up against the clock and Sandra has a couple of ideas. Thanks, Chair Vanderhurst. So we do have two items that need to be considered today. That's item 6.1 and 6.2. However, staff recommends that we could continue item 6.3, 4, 5 and item 7.1 to your August meeting.

2:59:14 I'm very comfortable with that. Okay. Is the commission good with it? Thumbs up? Great. Thank you. Okay, let's jump into business matters 6.1, consideration of the five-year capital improvement and resolution of general plan consistency. Thanks, Chair Vanderhurst. And I have a presentation prepared that takes a look at the near-term projects and speaks to the resolution of consistency. But I am prepared to call an audible given that we are up against the clock.

2:59:44 and really focus this conversation on the work that needs to be done today and commit to the commission that I will return at the next planning commission meeting and take an even deeper dive into the projects, which is really the exciting stuff that's going on. So pulse of the commission and you're interested in doing it. Okay. If you're good with that. All right. I'm going to call this speed planning. All right. So the recommendation before you,

3:00:13 is that the PEDC receive a quick presentation on the five-year CIP and confirm by resolution that the CIP is consistent with the general plan. The staff report identified two key issues before you. One, is the CIP as presented to town council consistent with the general plan? And are the proposed projects consistent with CEQA? The reason that this needs to happen is that government code section 65401 requires

3:00:43 That the Planning and Economic Development Commission review all capital projects that will be planned, initiated, or constructed during the ensuing fiscal year for conformity with the general plan as required by state planning and zoning law. In the staff report, I provided a table which included all of the proposed projects for the five-year CIP. I included a column that correlates each one of those projects with a general plan policy.

3:01:12 In general, a lot of these speak to economic facilities that support commercial air service, community design, ensuring safe, attractive public places, sidewalks, trails, streets and such. Land use, obviously affordable housing is a hot item. Increasing housing supply is a general plan policy. A lot of plans speak, excuse me, a lot of policies speak to mobility and there's a lot of CIP projects that emphasize feet first.

3:01:41 Enhancing Transit and also a number of projects that speak to parks, open space and recreation, which are all really tied to goals in the general plan. As far as CEQA is concerned, staff has determined that the CIP is consistent, excuse me, CIP consistency with the general plan is not a project pursuant to CEQA guidelines section 15378.

3:02:09 And therefore is not subject to CEQA Environmental Quality Act. With that, that concludes my presentation. I'm happy to field any questions you may have at this time. Any questions for Hayes from the commission? No, but that was an amazing brief. Well, I have a chair, a question for chair though, and staff is given the time constraint that we have here today.

3:02:42 Are we, are you, Ms. Hayes, are you still asking us to vote on this? Yeah, the real, the work to be done today is finding the CIP consistent with the general plan. So the staff report speaks to that requirement and provides a table that correlates all the projects with general plan policy. So staff feels very strongly that what has been presented to town council and what is before you today is consistent with the general plan.

3:03:12 And like I said, the real exciting stuff is talking about the projects and I'll commit to coming back at the next meeting with a deeper dive into that so you have an idea of what's on the table the next coming years. But we feel comfortable, at least I feel comfortable with staff saying that the work in front of you, this resolution can be done quickly. Mr. Chang, are you comfortable with that answer? I mean, I guess, you know, if

3:03:49 If the commissioners are comfortable with it, and given that, you know, especially Hayes have, you know, expertise on all this stuff, certainly, I just want to make sure that we're not caught as the commissioners that we're rushing through something without going through this in detail. It's just a matter of, I don't know, liabilities?

3:04:24 I'm thinking more on a liability perspective than anything else. And so I just want to make sure that we don't have public say, hey, you didn't spend enough time on this during a discussion. But that's my only concern. That's the only concern I have. So just from staff perspective, Commissioner Chang, if the commission is comfortable that they understand the CIP,

3:04:57 and are comfortable that the item is consistent with the general plan as we've outlined in the staff report, I think you can move forward tonight. If you don't feel like the presentation you've received and the staff report provide you with that comfort level, then, you know, we can, Hais can provide, you know, provide additional information now to give you that comfort level. So it's really

3:05:19 kind of where the commission is. We certainly can speak more to it now. We're just sensitive of everyone's time and we're trying to, you know, kind of wrap the meeting up if we can. But we're happy to expand on it if there's questions or concerns. Yeah, and to elaborate on that, I'm not trying to rush this. I walk into this with a feeling that there's an understanding of the staff report and the information that's been provided by staff in advance of the meeting. And I'm happy to walk back through that.

3:05:48 And if we're uncomfortable with the timeframe, we can always, you know, continue this. It does push my timeline with town council for adoption, but it is what it is. I mean, it's your level of comfort. I feel like the information was provided in our packet along with all of our projects. And I feel like everything has aligned appropriately with what our goals are in the town.

3:06:13 And I think that we had more than enough information in our packet and we had opportunity to ask questions to staff. So thank you. Commissioner Kennedy, what are your thoughts on this? I agree with Commissioner Burroughs. I am particularly excited to hear more on these and to talk more on it next time. So I appreciate that, Hayes, for you to give us more of an update then. But I agree, I feel like what I needed to feel good about things was in the packet. And just to confirm, this is...

3:06:43 An annual thing, is that correct? Yeah, I didn't go through the kind of the revised CIP process that we discussed with council, but the Reader's Digest version is the goal is to get this in front of council more often, to have a conversation about it regularly, not only just once a year stick on the shelf, but at third quarter budget reviews, fourth quarter budget reviews, to continuously remind council of, you know, kind of the priorities and put something in front of them to help them make budget decisions.

3:07:12 Only once a year does the Planning Commission have to confirm the consistency with the general plan. So this will be an annual occurrence moving forward. Yeah, in that case, I feel good about it going forward with it today. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Eckert, do you have any thoughts on this? Unless this is something that is going to push our boss behind another month, I'm fine with, we had 360 pages to look at today and I'm pretty sure we're all good with what was in it.

3:07:48 So Hayes, it sounds like we're comfortable moving forward with this today. What do you need from us? What's our action item? Is it a motion? Is it a resolution? Adopt the resolution that was in the packet. Got it. So I will happily entertain a motion if somebody wants to put one forth. I need it posted on the screen. Hayes, do you want to just read the motion and then the commission? I was pulling it up. Bear with me. And we're going to hold you to...

3:08:36 Coming back with that sexy presentation, Hayes. That's the fun part. I'm excited about that. There's a few in that table that caught my eye. We got a lot cooking right now. Sorry, I'm getting sidetracked talking about all this exciting stuff and not pulling up the resolution. So it's a resolution of the Planning and Economic Development Commission of the Town of Mammoth Lakes finding the fiscal year 21-22

3:09:14 Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan in conformance with the Town of Mammoth Lakes General Plan pursuant to Section 65401 of the Government Code. I move we vote on the resolution. Oh, go ahead, Greg. I'll move we vote on the resolution. That Hayes just been unseated. I'll second. Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes.

3:09:49 Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. And we look forward to seeing you next month, Hayes. Thank you all. Appreciate your time. We'll see you next month. Okay, we're gonna move on to business matter 6.2, opportunity for the public to provide verbal or written comments on the draft environmental impact report for the Mammoth Yosemite Airport Terminal Area Development Project. And I believe our staff contact is Grady Dutton. Thank you for your patience, Grady.

3:10:21 No, actually, thank you, Michael. I'm going to turn it right to Kimberly for the introduction and the business part of it, and then I'm available to answer questions and provide context with the time being what it is. So, Kim, all yours. I'm here. Thank you. Thank you, Grady. I'm going to share my screen. Everybody see that? Yeah. Okay, perfect. So, this item is being presented to provide a summary of the project and EIR process.

3:10:54 And to provide an opportunity for the public to give verbal or written comments on the draft EIR document during the 45-day public review and comment period, which ends July 28th. So a little background, Town Council adopted the 2018 through 19 and 2023 through 2024 Airport Capital Improvement Program on December 19th, 2018.

3:11:23 Adoption of an ACIP does not compel the town to complete or fund any of the listed projects, but it does make the identified projects eligible for FAA Airport Improvement Program funding. Large projects are eligible for additional discretionary AIP funding, which is determined through negotiations with the FAA. Appropriate environmental review must be completed for all projects identified.

3:11:53 Prior to construction, all proposed airport actions that are subject to FAA approval also require environmental impact analysis to be prepared pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act, which is NEPA. The project is also subject to the California Environmental Quality Act, which is why an environmental assessment pursuant to NEPA and an environmental impact report pursuant to CEQA have been prepared for this same project.

3:12:23 On June 26, 2019, Town Council authorized consulting agreements with Wallace Environmental Consulting and Meaden Hunt, Inc. for the preparation of the CEQA and NEPA review for projects included in the ACIP. The June 26 staff report to Town Council stated that completion of the environmental analysis would not necessarily lead to the terminal or apron projects moving on to the design or construction phase.

3:12:49 And it was stated that in order to comply with federal and California environmental disclosure requirements, it would be prudent to conduct a comprehensive evaluation that includes all of the potential projects at the same time. It is noted in this staff report that the environmental review process for this project did begin prior to well-publicized efforts by Inyo County.

3:13:14 to take the necessary steps to improve Bishop Airport and obtain FAA approval to initiate commercial air service. In light of the fact that Bishop Airport expects to meet their requirements and to begin commercial service in December 2021, it was determined that it would be prudent to complete a comprehensive environmental evaluation so that the town is in a position to respond to future changes in airport service and air service needs in the region.

3:13:44 that are analyzed in the EIR document are not anticipated to begin for several years, if at all, to meet possible future demand, and all projects addressed in the ACIP are reviewed on an annual basis with the town and the FAA to ensure that the airport sponsor, who is the town, is taking necessary steps to respond to changing air service needs.

3:14:14 Okay, so the project site is identified as a 22-acre area of the Mammoth Yosemite Airport. The town owns 196 acres of the airport land and approximately 8.7 acres of undeveloped land within the 22-acre project area would be occupied by the proposed improvements. The scope of the environmental analysis for both MEPA and CEQA evaluates the implementation of the Terminal Area Development Plan

3:14:46 at the Mammoth Yosemite Airport. The project includes construction of a new passenger terminal, aircraft parking apron, related infrastructure, maintenance building, which includes aircraft rescue and firefighting vehicle, commercial apron, and associated infrastructure, which includes wastewater disposal and vehicle parking lots.

3:15:12 The proposed terminal area improvements are intended to allow the airport to function more efficiently and effectively to meet existing and projected demand. So a notice of preparation for the environmental impact report and a notice of intent to prepare an environmental assessment were published in the sheet on October 19th, 2019. The notices were circulated to invite comments from interested agencies and the public.

3:15:44 As to the environmental concerns that should be considered in the EIR. The notices also provided information regarding a public scoping meeting, which was scheduled for October 24th, 2019. The scoping process is intended to solicit comments from governmental agencies and the public. We did not receive any comments from the public, but we did receive comments from Caltrans District 9.

3:16:13 The Department of Toxic Substances Control, Department of Fish and Wildlife, and Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board. Some of the environmental concerns that were raised in those responses included impacts on designated Seedneck Highway 395, traffic impacts and relation to planned road improvements, biological resources, including animal movement patterns.

3:16:41 Existing or potential future environmental contamination and release of asbestos or lead-based paint during any required demolition and impacts on surface and groundwater quality. The draft EIR analyzes potential impacts in the following areas, which include aesthetics and visual resources, air quality, biological resources, cultural resources, and tribal cultural resources, geology, soils and mineral resources, greenhouse gas emissions,

3:17:13 Hazards and hazardous materials, hydrology and water quality, land use, population and housing, noise, public services and recreation, transportation, utilities and energy, as well as cumulative impacts, alternatives and significant and unavoidable environmental impacts, irreversible environmental commitments and growth inducing impacts.

3:17:44 The analysis provided in the draft EIR determined that no significant effect on the environment would occur if the following mitigation measures are implemented. So I've summarized the implementation measures. There is a requirement that two floristic field surveys occur and be conducted during blooming periods for potentially occurring special status plant species. There's a requirement for a pre-construction survey on the project site between April and June.

3:18:13 to determine if the presence of western white-tailed jackrabbit exists, and if so, the town would need to work with CDFW to determine how to conserve the species. The third requirement is to provide all construction personnel with a tailgate training by qualified archaeologist in the identification of archaeological resources and protocol if such resources are encountered.

3:18:42 And the last mitigation measure establishes protocol if evidence of human burial or scattered human remains are encountered during construction at the site. So next steps, we are having a separate public workshop and public hearing for the environmental assessment document. That meeting will be held via Zoom on Monday, July 19th and begins at 4 p.m. We anticipate it will end around 5.30 p.m.

3:19:12 The FAA is the approval authority for the EA. And later on, we would expect to bring the EIR to Town Council to take action on the project and consider certification of the final EIR at a future meeting. So with that, we would recommend that PEDC, the Planning and Economic Development Commission receive verbal or written comments.

3:19:40 on the draft environmental impact report prior to the close of the 45-day public comment period, which ends at 5 p.m. on July 28th. That concludes my presentation. I know Grady is available to provide context on what the town plans to move forward with. Thank you, Kim. At this time, does anyone on the commission have a question for either Grady or Kim? Question for Grady, please.

3:20:10 Please. Grady, what was that term that you used last time when you did a presentation with the airport that had to do with the receiving the grant, a million dollar? Employments. We are looking for, we're looking forward to 10,000 employments. Employments, that's it, okay. Which gives us a $1 million entitlement funding. Entitlement funding. Does this particular report, this study, have any correlation with?

3:20:39 That particular employment entitlement. No, it does not. Only, I mean, the only very slim nexus, if you will, is if we have these facilities, we're more likely to be able to attract the air service required to get to 10,000 employments. But we can get to 10,000 now with our current facilities. So that is not a direct correlation. Thank you. Anybody else? Commissioner Burroughs, I see you've got your unmuted. Did you have a question?

3:21:11 No, I just switched devices. All right. Commissioner Kennedy or Commissioner Eckert, do you have questions for either Kim or Grady on this business matter? Nothing for me. Thank you. I've got one for Grady and it's really not for today, but down the line. So this is something that we planned before we knew we were going to be subbing everything out to Bishop. If we get grants to build this terminal building at some point in the future.

3:21:45 Does the FAA provide grants for O&M on it or just to build it without any planned air service? I wouldn't want to see us have a big, beautiful terminal building down there with no commercial air service subsidizing it. Right. And specific to that, and I'll keep it as short as I can because with CEQA, we're very careful not to provide new information to the public that they didn't have and had a chance to look at and see in the document.

3:22:15 But we, you know, as Kim said in the staff report, we started this process before Bishop was, frankly, we weren't sure it was going to happen or not. So it was included terminal and stuff. FAA will not provide us the 20 to $30 million required for terminal unless we are sure and can prove to them that we have commercial service coming here and active. So that's not going to happen. We're not, you know, we wouldn't even request the money, of course, until we...

3:22:42 Unless we had some sort of commercial service at some point in the future. In addition to that, they wouldn't provide operation maintenance money regardless. So that would be on us. We'd be very cautious about building a building that we can't maintain. That's what I wanted to hear. Grady, I've got a question for you. Of all the projects that are kind of outlined in this report, the EIR, is the town funding any build out there currently in this next,

3:23:15 Budget? Let me, I'll get to the answer as best I can. We, we're actually doing right now a pavement rehabilitation process, a project on the East General Aviation Ramp. It's underway. That is all FAA funding. We're looking at our next larger project at the airport would be the maintenance facility that is included in this project. We have about a million dollars in entitlements coming to us in the future.

3:23:45 We are going to apply, and we've already had a pre-meeting with FAA about applying for discretionary funds, other funds that FAA has available on a nationwide basis for that project. They're very aware of it in San Francisco and in the regional office in Los Angeles, and we're very hopeful that they'll give that strong consideration. So we're not spending any of our own money right now, but we're very focused on 10,000 employments, entitlement money to allow us to have a real capital improvement program.

3:24:13 Moving forward without having to fund that with the general fund. Got it. And bear with me here, Don Grady. Is this a fair way to summarize this in layman's terms that EIR is basically you guys are just, you want to get your paperwork lined up to keep your options open down the road. Is that kind of fair? That is absolutely fair when it comes to the terminal project part of the old report.

3:24:43 The art facility, we really want to move forward. The apron, we want to move forward a few of the other things. You know, this might be an appropriate time to mention it because the public, if they listened to the last airport presentation, they heard about helicopter pads, things like that, if you'll recall. That's not part of this. That is something we just thought of. It's not an issue with CEQA because it's not even conceptual at this point. It's just a what-f for a few years down the road. If we move forward with that at all, it would definitely have to come back for further environmental review.

3:25:12 In appropriate fashion. In terms of ACIP consistency with the general plan, thank you, you just did that. That's your previous item. And if I could, the only thing I wanted to add to this is that something I showed to town council last meeting, and it's unrelated to this, but it's absolutely appropriate time to show that the airport is doing well. We've been working with local transportation commission in Mono County to improve airport road.

3:25:41 It's been on the list for LTC for a number of years and Mammoth County has been very good about keeping it on that list and making that happen and I'm going to zap myself out of this so you can see that's Airport Road. That's at the airport entrance looking back to the west and they've completed it, they did a great job and we thanked him at the last town council meeting so I just want to let you know that stuff's still happening.

3:26:08 We're still spending money. We have support of Mono County and LTC as well, and that means the state of California. Thank you. Thank you, Grady. Jamie, did we have any public comment on this, either in person or via Zoom? No, we do not. Okay. Then I'm gonna bring it back to my fellow commissioners for any further conversation or deliberation. Nothing on my end. So what was the action item on this again, Grady, that we were to receive public comment? I think I saw that.

3:26:41 Either verbal or written. That's right. So the recommended action is to receive verbal or written comments on the draft EIR document. So the public comment period ends on July 28th. So we are able to receive public comment until 5 p.m. on July 28th. So anybody in the public who's listening, there's still time to provide comment. Kim, does that need to be a motion made by this body? No.

3:27:14 Are all the commissioners comfortable? You can thumbs up if you want, if your screen's dark, I'm comfortable with it, so. Perfect. I think it considered it a pass. Is that the proper process for that, Kim? We've opened it and there was no comment and. That's great. That's what we needed. Okay. Thank you. Thanks guys, appreciate it.

3:27:41 So I think we're going to table 6-3, 6-4, 6-5 and 7-1. I'd also like to table the commissioner reports unless somebody has something they want to get out there to the public or to this body, which if not, will leave us our director report. We can table that, Chair Vanderhurst. We'll table that. Okay, then I'm going to adjourn today's meeting.

3:28:07 into our next regularly scheduled meeting on August 11th, 2021. Huge thanks to all of you for your patience. This was a biggie. Huge thanks to Commissioner Burroughs for via commuting the longest distance today of anyone. And you guys have a great...