TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

655 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Hi, Linda. Hi, everybody. So it's at the end of September that we have to start meeting here? Yeah, it's September 30th. It goes all the way to the end of September, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

1:50 Are we going to be able to get Bill? Is he down on the lake? No, he's home. Oh, he's home? Okay. I think so. He was in the office yesterday. Oh, okay. Thank you. Yeah. I thought about two or three times. And forgot. Again. Again. Again. No, actually, it's on tonight. There is something to speak to. Well, I walked horseshoe again. It's lower and lower. Is it still there? It's sad.

2:48 Yeah, really sad. So Bill's having a barbecue Friday. Saturday. Saturday. That's right, Matt. I wrote it down. Yeah. Come on. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. How are we all today? Wow, it's going to be a tough meeting. I can't even get a response to that. Okay. I'm a minute or two late here because I had a little trouble connecting today. So with that, I will call this meeting to order.

4:30 And Hayes, I see you're with us. Will you lead us in the pledge, please? Can I do the roll call first, Mayor Sauser? Oh, yes, do the roll call. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Sapp? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Here. Mayor Sauser? Here. Present. Thank you for keeping me on track, Jamie. Now, if it's ready, we'll do the pledge.

5:04 Please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you all, sir. Moving on to public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on any item that is otherwise not on the agenda. Jamie, do we have public comments?

5:38 Yes, we have a member of the public in suite D. Okay, three minutes you said? Is that what you said? Or is it five? Okay, okay, all right. Good evening, my name is America Hernandez, and will I, do I need to move here? I can't see them. Okay, just stop, we just. Okay, so I don't get to see them. Okay, all right. So, my name is America Hernandez.

6:22 I'm part of the community here. I've been here for 24 years, and my family goes back to not sure how long back. But anyways, the reason for me being here is to say farewell to Mammoth. It's been great living in Mammoth Lakes. And thank you for the opportunity of living here. I got to

6:53 Finished my university in Mexico City, and I came back from Mexico City here and lived here, had wonderful experience working here. I started working for Mammoth Hospital. I had the great opportunity of working with Gary Myers and his staff. We did great things in the 90s.

7:23 And I will never forget Jack Copeland for the opportunity that he provided me with collaboration of bringing the Mexican consulate to provide services to the Hispanic community. I thank you. I miss you very much. And I totally understand why

7:53 You broke relationship with me because you had to. I know deep inside you didn't want to. I remember our closed door conversation and you had to choose between us or the mountain and I understand. Okay. Thank you so much to Bonnie Swartz, to all those great ladies that I work with at the cast off.

8:23 That are no longer with us. I just thank you for everything. Thank you for this nature that made me be able to handle this area. And the last minute what I would like to talk to is my concern about Mammoth Housing. We do not have to travel far away.

8:56 To see the crisis of Mammoth Housing for the workforce and the poor and anything like that, you can find it here in Mono County and Mammoth Lakes. I don't know exactly what will happen in the future, but basically what I pray for all the time and hope for is housing.

9:25 For the working, a community that we do not need to live under employee housing, but that we have the opportunity of owning within our community. We don't want to rent forever or have to leave this community because we can no longer afford living in our home.

9:57 So I just hope that there's prosperity for the town, nature, and those that are second or third homeowners or fourth homeowners that they can, you know, that all of you guys can find a balance to have, you know, everything here. So thank you. Thank you.

10:35 America, thank you very much. Jamie, any further public comments? No. Thank you. With that, you all should have received correspondence from First Five Mono County regarding child care. I just want to note and make sure that everybody got that. Moving on from that, Dan, do we have any additions or changes to the agenda? Nobody do not, Mr. Mayor. Thank you very much. We will now go to reports from commissions and or departments as needed.

11:16 I think Joel had his hand up, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I said Joel. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers. I'd just like to share a few slides for a few minutes, if I may. So I just wanted to update everyone on what's been going on around the July 4th holiday and the weekends before and after. We've had a pretty strong presence on the ground this season compared to really any in the past. We've got a robust...

11:49 And so this season, you know, we're all out there. And not only that, but we've...

12:17 We've created new programs. There's Trashy Thursdays, which MLT and Mammoth Mountain Resort put together, and we're helping with that each Thursday. And if you've been out and about, you've probably seen some of these folks. Really exciting July 4th weekend, July 3rd, in fact, we had approximately 550 interactions, which is a record for us. You know, we're really getting out there and talking to people.

12:47 Have a strong presence. It's a very well-received program. People are delighted to see us out there. You know, one out of a hundred isn't if we're asking them to not do a certain activity on a certain trail, but lots of interacting with folks. And then people are very interested in wayfinding. Where can they access trailheads or where do the trails go and what types of outdoor recreation options are available?

13:17 That's the breakdown for that. And then this is always very encouraging to see. The number of observations of dogs on leach, the percentage keeps getting better over time. That's very good to see. We're also seeing under observed user groups, e-bikers are certainly bumping up in numbers. We have a lot more vendors renting e-bikes to visitors and residents. And we're just seeing that

13:47 I know everybody I know in the last year got a new bike. So we're just seeing a huge bump in numbers in bikes in general and especially e-bikes. And then in this photo you can see that we could use some bike racks almost at every trailhead. This was brought up in the walk, bike, ride action plan process. And we've...

14:15 Express the need to the district, the forest, and we hope to see some of that type of infrastructure take shape soon. There's certainly a need. What's encouraging about this is that there's not as many cars, obviously. People are able to ride uphill pretty easily to access the lakes basin, and then they can park a bike instead of parking a car, which is pretty interesting. And then also,

14:42 We're continuing to see a lot of litter out and about, and I don't know why the Welcome Center was so trashed, but we keep cleaning it up, trying to keep it clean. I think a lot of stuff blows in from maybe overflowing dumpsters is a hunch. I don't think there's that many litter bugs among us. This photo shows a lot of the activity. We've got an Adopt-A-Trail team in the center bottom.

15:07 That program is doing very well. We've installed much of the needed signage for that program. A lot of people getting out hiking. All the bike trailers are full when they come up to Horseshoe Lake. A lot of interest around the cycling. You know, we're just seeing bikes everywhere again. Trail Days program every Wednesday. We want to encourage people to sign up at mammothtrails.org, right on the homepage.

15:37 Click on a link to sign up for this. You can volunteer with us each Wednesday to do trail construction, maintenance, design, or you can volunteer with a host on the weekends or holidays. This is going very well. We've got so far over $10,000 of equivalent labor value. We've had two large youth groups help us out along with 25 individuals signing up for Wednesdays and several people in particular that are

16:06 Regular, really just every week. Very encouraging to see. The Adopt-a-Trail program that I mentioned before, on the left here you can see one of the new signs. Thank you, Angie, if you're watching. I'm glad you're having fun with this. We are too. A lot of people are excited to get out and, you know, put on the best and help us out. And then this program, we're seeing so far a lot of success.

16:34 Over $10,000 has been donated toward the Mammoth Lakes Trail System specifically through this program and 89 volunteer hours so far with almost $2,500 in labor value. And this is just getting kicked off. This slide shows the raw trail counter data in a chart here. Compared to previous years, we are seeing an uptick at some of the more popular

17:04 Trails like Duck Pass, the Mamie Bridge is seeing a lot of visitors along with the Twin Lakes Bridge area. On average, however, we're not that much higher than last season. We just have more facilities that are open, obviously. I think people are able to spread out. The private sector is open, like restaurants and things like that. But we're still seeing a very sustained

17:33 And that's all I had to share for now. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Thank you, Joel. Any questions for Joel? Seeing none, I will move on to any other reports from commissions. And Sandra, I saw her hand first. Stuart, you're gonna have to be next. Of course, ladies first. Thank you so much.

18:02 Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Director. Just a brief update, the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last week. They had a pretty big agenda. They received a presentation on the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. They also conducted a kind of listening session for the old Mammoth Road Transit discussion. That item will be coming forward to Town Council, I believe, in the next month.

18:27 And a summary of their comments will be included as a part of your packet. They also approved a use permit for cannabis use in the industrial zone. And they approved the use permit design review package for the Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station. And then finally, they found that the capital improvement program is consistent with our general plan. And that item will be coming before you shortly as well.

18:57 Because of the number of items and the comments we received on the old Mammoth Road item, they did continue a couple of their items to the next planning commission meeting, which is on August 11th. And that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra. Any questions? Linda. Hi, Sandra. I do have a question. In the town of Mammoth Lakes, the town boundaries, we're limited to three dispensaries. Is that correct?

19:25 No, the retail, so this is, this, this cannabis is not a dispensary, it's not a retail use, this is a just cultivation, but there are limits to the number of retail uses we can have, but it's really geographic limits rather than number of uses, so if that makes sense. So I guess my question is, could we have another dispensary within the town?

19:51 I think there is one spot where they could adjust the locations of the two existing dispensaries. Yeah, so there is, I think, one little spot where we could have another one, but we haven't had any proposals for that. And I think it's that Center Street, on Center Street back there, that area there where you could have another one because of the overlaps of the schools and the other retail businesses. Can you do cultivation in town?

20:20 No, cultivation, I believe cultivation is just in the industrial zone. Okay. Okay. And then, oh, and then the town of the city of Bishop has approved their first retail cannabis dispensary, correct? I believe so. Yeah, I think I heard that. Okay. Thank you very much, Sandra. Thank you. John. Hi, Sandra. Hi, John. How are you? I'm all right. How are you?

20:50 I'm doing great. Thanks for asking. I've got a request and a dam for some documents related to the turnaround, the bus turnaround on Old Mammoth Road. I'm looking forward to following up with that. I think we all understand that it's a ministerial action. It's not something that council, you know, the decision is not something that's necessarily coming to council in that sense. But do you have any idea as to when?

21:15 When recommendations from staff will be coming forward, I think the council wants to make sure we have a chance to engage with the public as that starts coming forward. I believe it's August 7th. Hayes, do you have the final date? It's the 18th is what's currently proposed. The 18th, sorry about that, the 18th. Okay, well, it'll be helpful, Dan, those things we talked about against those documents. We hope to get those in advance. So thank you very much. Thank you, John. Any other questions for Sandra?

21:47 Okay, Stuart, that makes you up. Thank you, Mayor. Members of Council, community, it would be remiss upon myself if I didn't talk a little bit about Parks and Rec during Park and Recreation Month. It is July, Park and Recreation Month. We adopted our proclamation just a couple of weeks ago. Time flies. But we are wrapping up the month, and I would like to encourage our community to join us.

22:17 For free Friday night skate at the Mammoth Rec Zone this Friday from 6 to 8 p.m. And then we've been running free swim day every Sunday afternoon at the pool, which has been great. Weather's always been a little bit temperamental, but that's okay. Good to see the rain. But again, we do want to encourage everybody to come out and enjoy a beautiful swimming day slash afternoon at the Whitmore pool this Sunday from 12 to 6.

22:43 Just a couple of other updates. Just while Joel was talking about Adopter Trail, we've been working through our Adopter Hole program at the Shady Rest Disc Golf Park. And I'm pleased to announce that we have 15 hole sponsors. So we've only got three spots left, which is great. And all those donations, actually all those sponsorships, contribute towards the course enhancements. So we'll be able to install additional tee pads for the recreation.

23:12 And then also additional tee signs. So just a wonderful support from the community. So I wanted to take this opportunity to thank each and every business organization, governmental organization that supported disc golf. It's certainly a growing amenity. So we're very thrilled about that. And also a big announcement, the Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Club will be hosting the first annual PDGA sanctioned disc golf tournament.

23:42 At the course on August 14th. It's called the Shady Rest Open. And I'll expect to see a lot of people. So great to see. And then just finally, the Recreation Commission meets on August 3rd. A couple of items I'll be talking about will be the CRC update. Again, just a lot of action over there as well. And then also Hayes will be updating the commission on the CIP plan that was presented to council.

24:11 And then also we'll be talking about the deferred maintenance program of work. As you know, we received an allocation, thank you, $300,000 back in May. So we have around $340,000 over the next 12 to 18 months of the program. So staff will kind of present that program of work to the commission on August 3rd. So that is all I have, Mr. Sauser. Thank you, Stu. Any questions for Stu?

24:42 Seeing no hands raised, I will call for any other reports from commissions or departments as needed. Mayor Raimondo. Mayor Sauser, I have an update from Finance World. We received our American Recovery Act funding, part of the funding that was established back in March of 2021. We were not a direct recipient city, so we received our funding as an allocation from the state of California, and that was received in July.

25:12 As a reminder, that's roughly, we received $964,000, which is roughly 50% of our total receipt, but we receive the rest of that 12 months from now, so next July. And through the process of our application submitting documents, the funding is a revenue replacement, so revenue lost as associated with COVID. So that will be coming forward before council as part of our

25:41 We have a fund balance discussion in October. We bring the final results of this current fiscal year there, and we will include those monies as discussion for options on what they can fund. So that's exciting news. Even more exciting news, our new HR manager started on Monday, and so the town is no longer suffering from Rob's HR management tactics, but we have a professional in-house.

26:10 I'm very excited about that. We'll bring her before Council on the 4th of August. Also, Cindy Myrold is retiring as of July 30th, and so we will have recognition for her years of service and her retirement on the 4th. And finally, I'd like to just acknowledge this last weekend, we had a celebration of life that was put on by the fire department for Cindy's husband, Larry Myrold.

26:37 And it was a very moving and very beautiful ceremony that they put on. I thought it went off very well. Town leadership, including Mayor Sauser, who helped cooking facilities and duties, and that went off pretty well as well. But it was just great to see the outpouring and the community come together to celebrate this wonderful part of our town. So just wanted to update the folks on that. Thank you. Thank you, Rob. Any questions for Rob on that?

27:08 Seeing none. Any other reports? A couple things. So the Attorney General of the State of California just announced that a tentative settlement has been reached in the opioid class action litigation. A bunch of cities, hundreds and hundreds of cities and counties across the country, including 79 in California, sued a bunch of the big pharma companies over their opioid production and distribution practices and the tentative settlements, because there are several of them.

27:39 Call for about $2.3 billion to come to California. There are no details yet on how much the town would get. We were not one of the plaintiffs, but we're in line to get some money anyway. It'll be paid out over time. Some cities are going to take the money directly. It has to be used for kind of opioid-related things. Other cities are likely to forward their payments to their counties if the counties are in a better position to do that kind of work with the funds. So we don't really have any details yet.

28:07 Again, no dollars, no timetable, but at some point there will be additional information and we will come back to you with some thoughts about that. In addition to that, just following up on our ongoing Suddenlink conversations, the three county councils and I sent another letter to the DUC and Suddenlink with kind of some specific requests of Suddenlink following up on our previous letter.

28:32 We've heard kind of informally that the previous letter did get some attention at the PUC, and so we look forward to further productive discussions. Thank you, Andy. Any questions? Seeing no hands. Any further reports? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I'll have one too, but we have Frank Freefold via phone. He wanted to do a quick fire update for council members. He's calling in from the north part of the county. That would be great. Frank, go.

29:07 Good afternoon, Mayor Sauser, members of the council. Yes, calling in graciously from Antelope Valley Fire Protection District, allowing me to steal some Wi-Fi. I can tell you just from looking out the window, the Tamarack fire up a few days ago is looking, I would describe it as angry, strong wind blowing on that and a good ice cap on top, so I know they have their hands full there. The lightning that we've had in the region,

29:40 With that last monsoon flow, while it did have a fair amount of moisture with it, we did pick up several starts. To the best of my knowledge, all of those have been picked up. We had one above the Knolls off the Scenic Loop and another, the Pumice Fire, kind of on the backside of the mountain above Red's Meadow. I've been speaking with my four service partners. They had a heli-tech crew on that yesterday and making good headway.

30:09 So, so far we're looking good with the dry and windy weather today. It wouldn't be a surprise to see some holdover fires pop up the next day or two. Sherwin's, Doe Ridge area by the airport all took a lot of activity as well as the Inyo craters area. Other than that, we're looking pretty good and kind of keeping our fingers crossed and I'll answer any specific questions if I can. Thank you. Thank you, Chief. Any questions? John.

30:41 Frank, just want to thank you for showing up. I know that we're right now, we're in sort of a sweet spot for the moment, fire and smoke wise, but I think there's a lot of concern in the community. We do have some very important projects coming forward, the Mammoth Donut among them, and I think really making sure we keep a high level of visibility for fire with the council and the public. It's really helpful to have you here. I'm sure Dan will be calling on you from time to time, but we want to make sure we're counting our lucky stars, but we're not getting...

31:11 Not relaxing. So thanks for showing up today. Appreciate it. Absolutely. And I would share, this probably sounds like a broken record, but solidly for the last 10 years of my career, starting in 79, seeing some new things every year. Just recently, some property that I owned on the National Forest that I sold when I came to Mammoth, burned the Beckworth Complex. And I can tell you when you have a...

31:41 Piece of property that you understand intimately. As a fire person, you run the scenarios through your head. How would this respond? And I got some photos from the owner, and I can tell you that the results were orders of magnitude beyond my worst imagination. The heavy fuels are record dry. We're seeing long-range spotting, frequent area ignitions from spotting, which there's really no way to control that.

32:12 So it's, this is really uncharted territory for all of us. And the speed and the percent consumption is really unseen. So yeah, I'm really excited about the Mammoth Donut and some other work that we're doing. But boy, we want to be just super careful. And please help me with that first five feet and your decks. Thank you.

32:38 One other quick thing. Any report from Markleyville? We've all got friends up there. I haven't been bothering them because of what they're dealing with. Is there anything you can say about the town? It looks like the fire just kind of went around it and by it, but how are they doing up there? Do you know? I have not had direct contact with people on the ground there. The direction of the fire, the speed, and the way the column is behaving, I think the primary concerns are really going to be more to the northeast of there.

33:10 Don't want to speak too much on it because I haven't been on the ground there, but I know we had some people in a meeting here with me earlier and needed to get back to Reno and they were hoping to get past the incident before 395 was closed. So there's an awful lot going on there. Okay, thank you. Any other questions for Frank? Seeing no hands. Chief, thanks very much. We do appreciate it. Mr. Mayor, again, I want to echo what Rob said. Really appreciate.

33:44 The participation and just support for Cindy by total staff and the leadership team there and from our fire district to you. We were able to just participate in service because you and your team were there cooking and getting that part of the ceremony ready for us. And we just really appreciate your participation allowing us to participate and say goodbye to a good one.

34:13 We're going to have a hole in us for a while. Yes, we will. Thank you. The credit goes to Rob for pulling us all together. He did a great job. Thanks to all of you. Yep. Okay. That being said, any further reports? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I need to give you kind of a quick COVID update, if I may. We haven't been doing these regularly as part of the agenda.

34:43 Given some just recent stuff, I did want to give the council a quick update of the things we're looking at and what's going on. A little bit in the county to give you an idea of some of the elements that we're staying on top of. We are seeing an increase in terms of cases. We had a long period of time. It was relatively flat. Since the 1st of July, we've seen kind of a steady uptick. I believe we had a couple more positive cases even today. Still overall, relatively a low case rate, but it is concerning to see the current movement.

35:12 And throughout the community, we've had actually some, what I would say, even very young elements as well as throughout the community impacted by COVID currently. And so it's something that we're continuing to watch. There's a number of different indicators that the state has put out through CDC, et cetera, looking at the potential for guide and mask and indoor settings and stuff. It was interesting, the state kind of put this together. This is not a tiered system, but...

35:41 Kind of looks like one, but they were very clear to state that it is not. But really, they're starting to look at things in other different categories where you would look at asking for indoor masking for everybody, not just a non-vaccinated. We're not there at this point in terms of our case rates and where we're at in there. So you start to look at the recommendations that's come out. That's currently at the county level, we've done that, that we've requested.

36:10 I'll talk about that more in a minute. But the reminder on that is really to continue to push the idea of being vaccinated out there to get people into that. I believe recently this says 25 vaccinations since 06. I think that's jumped up by at least 50 if I've got my numbers correct. We still are getting people coming in and being vaccinated, getting that first dose in and then notified out those couple of weeks to get that second dose.

36:40 That is still available for sign-up. People can do that. And so if there's questions on that, they can get ahold of Mono County Health and get set up for that or go on to the MyTurn website to get signed up for vaccination processes. So we're still pushing that element out there to get the rest of our population. We are looking at over 8,000 fully vaccinated people coming through Mono County. That includes residents and...

37:08 Some second homeowners and visitors in the area that have gone through the system here in Mono County. Based on that, we're looking at currently in the town and stuff, it's still, if you are vaccinated, we are not requiring a mask in public spaces in the indoor element. The Mono County Public Health Department did put out a recommendation for masking indoors as well as in...

37:33 Required settings like medical settings and stuff. That came out just this week. And again, the push for that was based on the uptick in cases that have impacted our community and throughout the state. We're also seeing that being driven somewhat by the Delta variant as it makes its way through. We're seeing that as being more dominant or the dominant strain at this point.

38:01 And as noted in here, these were some slides that were presented to the Board of Supervisors yesterday. There is this very concern of the pandemic of the unvaccinated at the adult level and all that activity. The vast majority of cases are definitely in that population. There's also a concern at that younger age level, to note on here, being the concerns at the pediatric search. We've seen a little bit of that here in Mono County as well, some very young.

38:28 So we're still watching all that and looking. We're not making any particular actions at this point.

38:46 At the town level or public health or in the current recommendation to beef up mask wearing if you're going to be in a public space, especially with other numerous people in there who are not vaccinated, those types of elements, unknown areas, that is encouraged at this point, but not mandated. One of the elements there is continuing our testing work. It's still available. It's still free as people need that.

39:15 The follow-up we're doing, for example, this last couple of days, we've had some cases pop up in some of the firefighters that have been in the community, resulting in some significant testing going on site and getting that done. I think it was over 50. And then also just we did have a larger group of people coming in to the system here and the testing operation here in Mammoth.

39:39 I think it was about 100-plus that came through that testing. A lot of that is due to the contact tracing and the fact that we've had these cases pop up within the community the last few days, last week or so, actually, if things have started to move forward again. So we're looking at continuing that program. It's still out there. There's some modifications, potentially, in the state contracts and stuff. But right now, that pre-COVID testing is still...

40:04 Widely available within the community. Again, encouraging people, if you do have symptoms or you're concerned, you can still get tested. Please do so. And again, on top of that, with the vaccination program as well. So there's a lot of the walk-in clinics you can go to here for vaccines. As I mentioned earlier, we're asking people to do that. You'll see the dates here, 7-23 this week at Bridgeport.

40:33 A couple of dates in August, the 6th and the 27th, we'll have walk-in clinics here at the Mammoth High School. So again, encouraging people to get in, be vaccinated, take that step forward in this concerning growth in the pandemic side that we're seeing. So I wanted to give you just that quick update where we're at on that. There are some concerns. We're working with some of the positive cases of getting people into a hotel, getting them set up. We're back into that mode a little bit.

41:02 Working as we can through that. And so, again, something that we're watching, part of this is saying, hey, we're still on top of this. We actually did a short kind of emergency EOC meeting last night to kind of get an update on where we're at, what we're looking at. And then the ongoing process, we'll be meeting again next week with that group, obviously. Well, I mean, obviously you all, but to me, our regular meeting process with the EOC and the operational center. So that is still set up. We need to ramp things back up. We can.

41:32 Right now is still watching and really trying to walk through where we're at in current state of affairs here. Brian Wheeler, public health officer for the county, just, you know, he's going to, just classic, he's going to be out for a week or so on vacation, so he asked Linda to step in and he assumed this would be a pretty easy step in, things were pretty calm and first thing that happens is.

42:01 A bunch of positive tests come in. So I'll ask Kirk if she wants to speak on behalf in that area or in that hat a little bit in that kind of acting or backup position at all, Lynda. So if you'd like to make any additional comments, that'd be great. Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Dan. That was a really good summary of kind of what's looking at us right now. And also to remind people that in addition to the vaccines we taught, the vaccine walk-in clinics you discussed, anytime there's our pharmacies,

42:30 And also the hospital is now including vaccine availability in if you have another visit or you're also can make an appointment to come in and have it there if you would prefer. So there's good availability of vaccine. We have plenty of vaccine to give. I think we gave, like you said, 50 earlier in the week, which I think reflects a concern of the unfortunate death that we had a couple of weeks ago, as well as a lot of positive cases and people hearing.

43:00 I did notice yesterday a little bit of uptick in mask wearing at Vons and Rite Aid. I don't know if that's because people are coming from LA where the masks are required. And I saw many locals also remasking. So hopefully we can get this stopped in its tracks and not have any issues here toward the end of our summer. But a little more activity in the last week than there had been for several weeks.

43:30 Yeah, as we said, don't put away your masks quite yet. So, thank you, Dan. Thank you, yeah. Kirk brought his in. But part of that is just a reminder, we still need to be diligent in how we're doing this, diligent in making sure we're practicing other things, again, good hand hygiene and those types of elements and other pieces of that. So, glad to answer any questions we can on that. It's something that we are watching carefully.

43:56 We'll continue to provide updates as appropriate in this, but there definitely is that heightened awareness here these last week, 10 days, as we've seen those upticks in cases and kind of a mix. The other element, I think it was, we've seen about 10 cases in the last few weeks in people who are vaccinated. So the vaccination doesn't mean you will not catch COVID, but it does.

44:20 Generally mean you're going to have a much less of a time with it in terms of how sick you get and obviously threat of death and that is greatly diminished in vaccinated people who catch COVID. Again, underlying health conditions always a concern as well, what happens with that. But a good reminder for us to stay vigilant in our processes and encourage people to take the vaccination and be careful in how they interact otherwise. Glad to address any other questions there.

44:52 Any questions for Dan or Linda? John? Just to reiterate in case everybody doesn't know this, there's plenty of vaccine available at multiple opportunities here in Mammoth Lakes, correct? Absolutely. And it's all free, it's all available, there's plenty of vaccine to go around, so yeah, please get vaccinated. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Any other questions?

45:19 If there's no questions, the last thing, Mayor, that I wanted to note, we were notified yesterday, and then there's some news reports out today that Clint Wilter, our counterpart in Ennio County, he was the county CAO down there, been their public works director, moved up into the manager position there, the chief administrative officer for the county, great partner in working with us in a number of different areas, the SCOG being one.

45:46 Transit, the airport, a number of different areas. On the 20th, just here the other day, he did pass away. Some dude came to cancer. And a great loss for the community down there, a great loss for Inyo County, and obviously an impact on his family. I really do want to express it was good to work with him. I thought he was very talented, great background coming into this area, in this region, and he had a love for it.

46:14 He will be missed from a professional level and working that way. And obviously I know the Inyo County family very much will miss his leadership and the work that he put into Inyo County the last few years that he was here several years down in that area and the different positions he held. So very sad to hear that. It was very sudden from that perspective. But our hearts and prayers about his family and to the Inyo County that will be missing him and that impact that that'll leave.

46:44 As they recover from that, how do we, again, continue to partner and be good stewards with each other as we look to the future of the Eastern Sierra, an area truly that Clint did care about and very much enjoyed being in this area and being a part of this broader community as well as the community there in Nino County. So I just want to note that it's been out a little bit of stuff, but a great loss for our region. Thank you. Linda. I did speak with Leslie Chapman, and she will be named the interim.

47:15 CAO. We're acting. Thank you. Okay. Anything further from departments? Seeing none, I will move on to item six, staff presentations. 6.1 quarterly DOT enforcement update for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2021. Rob. Thank you, Mayor, Sauser, and council members. Share my screen real quick. Can you see the PowerPoint at this point? Yep.

47:53 Okay, perfect. So this is our fourth quarter, fourth quarter recap on the efforts we have for TOT enforcement. This particular quarter, and this would be from April through June, we did open 30 cases in that quarter. And in that process, we had hired on our part-time enforcement person and sort of building the processes and how we review.

48:28 So it's been very productive in sort of leveling the minefield with folks out there, certainly during the times that we were closed. But what we're focusing on now is sort of long-term things that we hadn't had resources to look at before. And that would be going through point by point within host compliance and looking for folks that are out there trying to work and identify the properties. And so a lot of effort has been put into that.

48:57 This is a different focus and way of looking at the enforcement cases than what we've done in the past. So in the past, we've always relied on reporting that comes directly from host compliance on daily activity that we see. We're catching folks that are just now sort of launching into the foray, if you will, and maybe not have everything that they need to be doing this legally. But this particular approach is looking really back across things that have occurred prior to host even being available as a...

49:27 As a tool for us. So the activity is sort of tapping into another area and it's been fairly good. I think we're getting these folks on the right side of what they need to be doing and getting them remitting. A lot of times it's educational, sometimes it's not, but we do find that it's a very effective approach and we'll continue that process. We're also working through our audit backlog.

49:55 So we've been working through that. In audits, the results of those come about, a lot of times there are difficulty in calculating the actual tax, so we correct those, that level of understanding, we correct the timing at which they're reporting the revenues and those types of things. So there's a lot of educational opportunities, and to a lesser degree, there's people who are just generally and accurately reporting the data, but everybody gets their

50:24 It's caught up. They get their due penalties and interest if there's, you know, depending upon how it goes. And that's been effective as well. We have a major project we do annually, the business tax certificate renewal process that starts in December and ends in basically July. It really shouldn't be that long, but it is quite arduous. We ended up with 87 businesses, which we had no response from. And we are kind of looking for ways, and you'll see the theme throughout this presentation,

50:54 We're looking for ways to improve our efficiencies and our processes here. So that's really one that's a little bit too arduous for the workload that we have. And so we're looking at ways of improving that process. We also had, you know, through all this enforcement activity and the audits, a number of citation appeals. Those are the appeal mechanism that is before town council, where we reviewed the citations that were issued in the case. And those have been very successful.

51:24 A number of them, and while most of them have been upheld, there's been some good dialogue around the situation and the circumstances that really help folks understand what's going on, but it's a process by which our municipal code allows people to have appeals, and it kind of keeps some of the work off of your desks as well. So far, we don't have anybody that wants to continue past that process and want to bring it before you, but that will surely be coming in our near future. Put together the quarterly report.

51:55 Just to show you the effort. It is quite large. I think that most of our enforcement activity has really happened in the last half of the year. To have collections, total collections over 400,000, that's quite large. And so the efforts are there. I think it's been very effective in sort of educating people.

52:20 The time period when we had the citations for health orders, those were particularly difficult because they're very substantial penalties and fines. And I think people who did sort of fall into that area where they made some poor decisions or were unaware, that was really, really challenging. So I know the team, we're all looking forward to getting beyond that process. And I think for the most part with our backlog of enforcement, we're there. It will still come about for

52:49 Thank you so much for joining us.

53:21 On the enforcement side, we're going to continue that review, the red and blues within host compliance. That's what I just talked about with identifying properties that are unidentifiable. And so we've got a number of tactics that we use to do that. And it's a lot of just boots on the ground type stuff to really find out what some of these are. And our part-time worker, Kim, is really quite good at that. So she's been doing a very good job. We'll also continue to review the

53:50 Thank you so much.

54:18 Sort of adjusting the part-time hours, we do have limits on what we can utilize a part-time worker for, so there will be some reduction in hours work or days of the week work for that part-time, but I think it won't really impact the overall production because the systems have been developed and been functioning quite well. We're also working with legal to step beyond the lean process and provide some additional tools. In some cases, we have some egregious cases where people

54:46 Are aware, and they just, the draw of, financial draw of doing business, whether it's legal or illegal is too great. And so they, we end up with a lien process at the end. So we place a lien on their property for notice determination. We just need a little bit better next level above that. And those things could include certainly, you know, administrative subpoenas coming directly from your dais.

55:16 And also maybe a decision to, in the most egregious cases, we can sue the operator for the activity and seek some higher level of legal injunction into the activity, but we're still working through that process. And we're constantly working on ways of improving our efficiencies, and one of those is post-enforcement monitoring. Everybody we do an enforcement case on, we have to continually monitor them for...

55:43 Being still compliant or not operating if they're zoning. And that just is arduous. It's a daily process. It takes a lot of time. So we're looking for ways of improving that. We are also looking as a team focus on just looking at our procedures, things that we do on a monthly basis, on a weekly basis, on an annual basis. How do we improve that so that it takes us less time? There's better communication perhaps with our operators.

56:12 And we just really improve our efficiencies and that way spend less time trying to just work through the processes but actually getting the best bang for the buck for what we're actually doing. And that includes a little bit of team dynamics and other things that we've got in play. We also, we have missing returns and missing returns require us to actually close accounts if someone doesn't provide a tax return. And we've had some recent cases where

56:42 And people have intended to continue to do business, but for some reason fell off with providing returns. And so the closure of that in subsequent enforcement case and back open, really too cumbersome for us to process. So as part of our next municipal code update, we'll be looking to make enhancements to that. Because we really do need people to turn in returns every single month. And we do need to be very vigilant about having high expectations that we'll complete that or they will face penalties.

57:11 The work that we're doing today works really well when someone just leaves town, but when someone decides not to do something, it's just more complex. I'd like to take a look again at the ambassador program that we did during COVID-19 and see how we can evolve that project. I think it was very effective to get the team out in front of the businesses and the community in a positive way. And I'd like to sort of look at either next phase of that or a different look and feel in this post-COVID.

57:41 The other thing we're working on is communication enhancements. Our municipal code really dictates the way we communicate with our businesses, and if there are someone in violation or other areas, we have to go through a mailing process that requires first-class mail as well as certified mail. And we really want to start to reach out with emails and really be able to have that as our forefront. We utilize Constant Contact as an emailing system.

58:11 Which provides us really good information about when someone has actually viewed an email, whether they opened it, all the statistical data that goes along with that. So it's helpful in enforcement cases when someone says they may or may not receive some correspondence, we can actually hone in on exactly whether they did or not. And people seem to be doing a much better job of keeping us up to date on their email systems than they are with our mailing address. And when you move, you typically take your email with you, which is not like your mailing.

58:41 I'm very excited about that. We've got a couple special projects I want to talk about. This is really related to the last third quarter presentation from Council and the feedback that I received from you all with regard to data collection and our municipal code sort of updates. So I'll kind of dive into that just a little bit here next. For special projects on data collection.

59:08 We did alter our business tax certificate application to try to capture some statistical data on what the property, the life cycle and history of that property was. If they're applying for a short-term rental business license, we know their intent, where they want to go into the future, but we really don't know whether that was a conversion from a long-term or it was a purchased prior short-term rental by a new owner and they want to open the business. So we're trying to get a little bit of information and that

59:37 Collection began in June of 21, so it's just two months into it. It really will take some time to produce that. So we're also working on, in addition to that, we're working on a new certification process for properties within town to be a legal rental facility. Right now we issue TOT certificates to an operator for a unit, but we really want to get to certifying a specific unit one time to be rentable within our community.

1:00:07 And that would give us a bit more information as far as better control of who is the contacts, who is the 24-hour contact, who's the responsible parties and so forth. But within that, we were working on a questionnaire to try to gather a little bit of history about those properties that are there. So we'll collect that on the longer-term items. Like long-term rentals, we were also trying to capture that.

1:00:34 And so we just don't have a clear picture of what that looks like within the town. So we think though the majority at least of

1:01:04 The rentals in town we can capture through the rental agencies, but there'll be some one-offs that we'll have to figure out a solution to try to consider. And we're continuing to research what things are being done by peer communities or peer resort communities primarily. What have they solved within our same similar nightly rental challenges and how are they approaching some of those?

1:01:30 And so we can, rather than reinvent the wheel, we can kind of glean from them what works and what doesn't work. Not everything that is done out there will work within the Town of Mammoth Lakes, but I think it's good to bring forward, at least to you all, a list of here's what's going on and what we can actually take advantage of and get some input from you on what you really want to do. So that's the first special project. The next one is Municipal Code Updates. We ourselves, and since I've been here for five years now,

1:02:00 We have not done a complete revamp of section three and five of our municipal code, which is what covers businesses and short-term rentals. There's a lot of work to be done. We as staff have identified things that need to be corrected through our efforts and actions and things that would help us to hone in on really efficient enforcement and better understanding, frankly, for the operators that are in the community. But we'd also like to request town council involvement.

1:02:30 In a meeting or two with my staff, I'd like to have folks come in and just give us their input on, here's some quality of life challenges that we see, here's some things you guys want you to focus on when you bring forward these municipal code updates, just so we can get your side of the story and how you feel or what you're being told by constituents needs to be addressed in this overall approach. So that's something I think Dan is working to put that together.

1:03:00 And my team, we meet weekly. We would love to have you guys come into those meetings. I talk a little bit about the new certification process. And that will streamline this considerably because there'll be only one certificate for the properties that are out there. I think it would be a good time to sort of get rid of the grandfathered-in process about inspections that are going on. That's, in my opinion, a little more requirement that...

1:03:29 Every unit that's in town and operating needs to be inspected and needs to have everything safety-wise and other others documented there. That's been the case since I've been here for all new established businesses, but it is something that some of the older units and older businesses haven't had to do. And then I talked a little bit more about the peer resort, really looking at the TOT revenue folks.

1:03:58 We do like, we look to have this goal completed by November of 2021. I think as large as it is, that we probably would have it done that period of time if we get a significant amount of effort. And I think the timing works right. We're rolling into a new business year for 22 and we're in a bit of a better place. I'd like to acknowledge too, you know, we get calls. I got a call from, you know,

1:04:25 I'm a member of the community today with very good ideas about how to address housing shortage maybe through our rental application process and our certification process. So I appreciate the input we get and they provide us with things to bring forward as options for council to review. And so I, again, proud of what the team has done in this last quarter and what they continue to do. We have a lot of work ahead of us, but it seems as though

1:04:55 If we continue on for another couple of quarters with the work that was completed in these last two, we will be in a very good place as far as illegal activities sort of minimizing and more robust legal rental activity there as well as possibly some better definitions of what we have within our community. That's the end of the presentation if there's any questions. Thank you, Rob. Questions? Linda.

1:05:26 I don't have any specific questions. I like some of the ideas that you brought up, especially around how to get into areas we haven't done before. So I think that they're strong ideas. I would like to hear more about the ideas that the public brings forward. And I think bringing those to council and letting us add that to the mix would be good. I think you have a good team, Rob. I like the continuing sort of expanding the role of host compliance as a program.

1:05:57 Getting into the areas that weren't right available at first. So no, all in all, very pleased and appreciate the report as always, Rob. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. John? Hi, Rob. You're familiar with the CHAP, right? The Community Housing Action Plan? Your colleague, Sandra, I think at this point, she owns that document. I think there's been talk in the housing circles, we need to update that. I don't know when that's gonna happen.

1:06:28 But I think the work that you're doing with the data is really, really important. And I just encourage you to check with Sandra, make sure that the data we're collecting is going to be relevant and it can help to inform that CHAP update. I'm really concerned that there's a specific...

1:06:43 The thing that was called out in the CHAP to do that, it was supposed to be a GIS database to locate where the short-term, where the long-term units are. Somehow that thing fell through the crack. It sounds like you're kind of picking that thing up, but that's critically important, especially for the council to start making decisions about if we're going to be making zoning decisions, use decisions, all the rest of it. Really, really important. Looking forward to having that discussion with you and your team about the quality of life ordinance. Maybe give us a little bit of a heads up so we can...

1:07:12 Do our homework. But that's going to be very interesting. And so is that the thing you anticipate is coming back in November of this year is the update to the quality of life ordinance? Well, it's going to be an update to section three and five, which is components of that. It's not the overall quality of life ordinance update. All right. Well, Dan, that's something we talked about that a little bit. Another thing that we've been talking about is this part of, you know, the council's top priority, which is housing.

1:07:42 is reviewing and looking at policy codes and all the rest of it associated with short-term rentals. And Dan, I think you mentioned maybe that's maybe in the like the fourth, sort of like in the after Thanksgiving timeframe, something like that, but that's gonna be really important. I think, Rob, I would encourage as you're doing this peer research with other communities, there's a lot to be learned, hopefully, or not learned from our...

1:08:07 Our fellow mountain communities and resort destinations dealing with this issue because I'm interested in getting very aggressive on that front and I'm not really interested in hedge funds coming in, buying up properties in Mammoth Lakes and using that for whatever purposes they do those kinds of things for. We need to be really focused on housing for our community.

1:08:30 So these are all great efforts. Thank you. But a lot to follow up here. And again, getting aligned with the chat, with the chat on the future needs of that, because this data, it's really, really important data. And it's great to see someone stepping into the breach there, but it definitely falls through the cracks there for a year or so. Those are my thoughts, Mr. Mayor. Thank you for the time. Thank you, John. Sarah? Yeah, John, thanks for mentioning that regarding the hedge funds. That's a huge.

1:08:57 Huge concern of mine. I do just have one question, Rob, and maybe this is a little premature, but, you know, you mentioned peer community processes to reduce conversion of long-term to short-term rental. Do you know offhand if any of these peer communities have a hard cap on number of short-term rentals? Yeah, I do. Palm Springs only allows one rental per owner.

1:09:26 And that's been something that, you know, we've kind of been monitoring the results that they've been able to achieve. I know, you know, South Lake Tahoe is trying to actually really limit or eliminate that over the next couple of years. So they've sort of have a phasing out approach. So there's a lot of sort of, I don't say aggressive, because those aren't, South Lake Tahoe is definitely aggressive, but some of the other ones, the limitations are not quite, you know.

1:09:56 They're not quite that aggressive, but they're there, and they're something that we probably will like to employ some aspect of in our future. When you mention South Lake Tahoe, do you mean that they're kind of eliminating the amount of permits sort of by attrition? I think that's the goal, but I think there's a drop dead date, and Andy, you may know this, on when they will not allow short-term rentals, if I'm not mistaken.

1:10:27 Their approach is a little bit interesting. So there was some community frustration about the number of STRs and that led to a ballot measure that requires them to phase them out. And I think Rob's right, there's a drop dead date, but we can check on that. And so then the city ended up having to defend that ballot measure in court because the local realtors then sued the city.

1:10:51 Over the validity of the ballot measure that the city hadn't put on the ballot. They had nothing to do with. So the city was kind of stuck between the rock and the hard place of kind of having to defend this thing. But as far as I know, the measure has been upheld and that's what they're doing. So their approach is very aggressive. And I can also just give you another data point that Truckee, which I know a little bit about, has never had any caps of any kind, but there's starting to be some community pressure.

1:11:21 Thank you so much. Thank you, Sarah Kirk.

1:11:39 When I look at the quality of life ordinance sections, maybe we need to go back and review that again because with the housing issue and the transit down to Bishop and the housing down in Bishop, I mean, it's becoming, you know, I think it's impacting our quality of life, especially our workers. That's my comment. Thank you, Kirk. As for me,

1:12:09 I am hoping that sometime in the next few months we actually hold a council workshop on this and waste some of your time with extra meetings on workshops on a couple of other very important pieces that I think we work better through in the workshop versus a meeting set up. So look forward to that. I know, Rob, that you are looking at our peer resorts and how they're handling the STR and the VRBOs and Airbnbs and all of that that are popping up like

1:12:40 Wild Grass. But also I would encourage you to look at some of the larger cities. I know some of them have sued those groups and Andrew has brought us some of those results before to see what we can and can't do. Sorry, Andrew, didn't mean to confuse you. Andy, okay, I got it. As to what we can and can't do and I would encourage us to look at some of that as well. And in the future, I think we have to take an approach.

1:13:08 of looking at all of our available options, including zoning options, or flat out limiting the number of STRs, but I think that's an argument for a different date. Well done, Rob, on your presentation. Thank you. And on that note, I'm having a conference call tomorrow with city attorneys from about eight other cities, some near Napa, some down in the Coachella Valley and South Lake Tahoe.

1:13:37 And elsewhere, Newport Beach and a few others to talk about sort of that venture capital issue that some of you were raising. And also I think that'll probably turn into a kind of informal group looking at how to regulate STRs and ensure the availability of housing and resort communities. So we are continuing to be out there looking at other approaches and trading ideas and sharing with our colleagues in other cities and we'll be out there continuing to do that.

1:14:06 Thank you, Andy. I'm anxious to hear a feedback on that. Linda. Andy, when you, or I'm sorry, Rob, when you gave us some data, a couple meetings ago, I believe, when you had looked at the ownerships of STRs as you could, we did not indicate any sort of motion movement into the venture capital piece of that, to this date, at least. No, we didn't see that.

1:14:34 Going on too much here. There were just a couple of individuals that had bought a multiple set of houses, but not that newer trend that is being analyzed. We haven't really seen any of that. It's a little harder to detect, too, though, from this process. And so that's something I'm really interested in hearing, what Andy finds out tomorrow and the next few days about identification of that. Right, because by the time we would hear about that, it might have already been completed, and then there we would be.

1:15:04 Yeah, you may have, bring in some community partners around that too, hard to be alert for and aware of that, of that going on, if that were to happen also. And then just a question, Andy, for you, in regards to the hotels versus sort of short-term rentals, in those communities that are especially getting, you know, interested in the limitation of short-term rental, are they, on the other hand, not opposing or not being necessarily opposing development of hotels and other,

1:15:34 Sort of lodging entities. Yeah, I mean, that's been my experience and that's my understanding is that the consensus seems to be that hotels certainly have a place. Hotels are an important thing to have in any kind of resort community, place where people want to come. And if you plan for a facility to be a hotel, if your zoning kind of contemplates that hotels will be in one area and if all the land uses around it are compatible with the hotels,

1:16:03 And that's perfectly good. I think that the frustration that some people, some cities have had is just to have these kind of quasi-hotels going in residential neighborhoods with all the impacts that they create that people weren't expecting. I mean, in Truckee, for example, there's one house in a residential neighborhood that's advertised as an Airbnb that sleeps 32 people. So that's really a hotel in all but name, and the neighbors aren't too happy about it. And there are other things like that. So anyway, I haven't seen any cities that are trying to regulate

1:16:32 Hotels as such. They just don't want there to be a free-for-all in residential neighborhoods of houses that are kind of being used as hotels. Right. Okay. John. Yeah, just to, perhaps I was being a little hyperbolic when talking about hedge funds, but that is a thing and it is happening nationwide. But I think in small communities like this, you may see entrepreneurs who are simply aggregating.

1:17:00 You know, four, five, ten, fifteen different properties running it as a business, which I guess is okay. A lot of the arguments we heard at the beginning of this whole effort were, well, it will help local residents afford their mortgages and do that kind of thing, but it's turning into a speculative business, which is something we need to be aware of. And Rob, I think, you know, you and your team are doing great work within a known space, but the thing we know about this is that it is a constantly

1:17:29 It's a viral space. It's constantly evolving. It's constantly changing. And we have to constantly be as vigilant as that virus is in terms of its ability to poach housing stock for our community. So again, I look forward to having that conversation with you about the standards and that kind of stuff. And Andy, I think it would be really helpful for us if you think it's possible for all of these resort, these mountain towns resort communities to maybe

1:17:57 Figure out a way to get to a standardized set of expectations so people don't go to a community. It's a different thing every place they go. Maybe that's not possible, but that might make it easier to enforce. It might be easier to deal with. People might say, well, I didn't know, and I'm confused. It's just a thought if that's a possibility. We can kick that idea around and see if there's any interest in it. But the circumstances of each community, even each resort community, are all kind of unique.

1:18:28 Different political pressures, different facts on the ground, but it's an idea that's worth exploring. Yeah, because it would be in all of our interests if it's a common kind of playbook and people can't be playing one, playing us off against somebody else and it's like, look, these are the rules. We're part of a consortium that's doing things with a common set of expectations. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. And of course, in the long run, if it is sort of equal across the board.

1:18:55 If a lawsuit gets filed, it would be across the board as well and give us ammunition as we probably wouldn't be the first suit. So let Truckee go first and then Andy can give us their experience and tell us how to do it. Do we have any public comments on this, please? No, we do not. Thank you very much. With that, Rob, thank you for your presentation. Thank you. I will now move on to the consent agenda. I will try to read them quickly.

1:19:25 7-1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of July 7. 7-2, award local road and muck rehabilitation STIP project to Qualcomm Contractors, Inc. 7-3, accept the closeout report for projects associated with airport improvement program grant 3-06-0146-041-2020. That's too many dashes.

1:19:51 7-4, approve the resolution authorizing closure of a portion of Minaret Road from Main to Meridian and authorize a parking fee program in the vicinity for the 25th Annual Mammoth Festival of Beers in Beluzakalooza. 7-5, accept payment report number 22-01, 21-55, and 22-02. Anyone want to pull anything from consent? Hearing nothing, I would entertain a motion to approve.

1:20:21 I'll make a motion that we approve the consent agenda, item 7.1 through 7.5. I'll second the motion. I have a motion from Linda, a second from Kirk. Any further deliberations? Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Sauser? Yes. Passes 5-0. Thank you all.

1:20:54 Now I'm trying to find my next page. Okay. Mr. Mayor, if I may, we did have a public comment come in late just due to the starting time of the agenda. If you wish to allow that to happen, that's up to you. But Brandon Brocia was hoping to address the council in a public comment, thinking the meeting started later in the day than what it does. Thank you. Dan, I even texted you back that I would remember to put him in. Oftentimes I fail. Yes, Brandon, if you want to...

1:21:25 If you're in suite Z, step up to the podium. Is this on? All right. Oh, yeah. Thank you. And I'm sorry for my tardiness. I did not realize that this was a four and I thought it was 430. Thanks, Town Council. I will be brief here. I just wanted to have public comments quickly to discuss something that came up almost two years ago and then we had a worldwide disaster happen. I'm going to...

1:21:58 I would like to bring back into talking points banning the bottle for the town of Mammoth Lakes. I would like to once more introduce the movement of banning single-use plastic water bottles in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I know the last year and a half has been a pause on this effort. The time to re-engage is now. Why the sense of urgency? I brought it up back then. It is...

1:22:27 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:22:53 I would like the town of Mammoth Lakes to take a proactive approach and not wait, move now to create our own structure on this because if we wait, we will have to follow. I think we can lead. I would like to see the town of Mammoth leads. As a community, as community leaders, we should be an example of what a town does to lead change that affect the environment and the environmental impacts.

1:23:21 Let's do this before the state measure that effectively handcuffs us into lobbied results that will be a fraction of what real change is. As leaders of this community, we should be taking every opportunity to protect and serve and pass on great policies to our future generations. This ban would be a catalyst to other green measures that we, again, as the town of Mammoth Lakes can be.

1:23:50 I would like to get this on the agenda for the next town council meeting. That's the only reason why I brought it up is just to plant the seed for you guys for this next couple weeks here.

1:24:19 I have the full agenda. We have already had this conversation. We were really close before COVID hit. I have a lot of Girl Scouts that would want to come in and talk to you guys about this as well. Please consider it. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Brandon. Moving. Yeah, John. What is the procedure, Mr. Mayor, if we'd like to agendize this? I've got a couple of questions for the town attorney on this as well. It would be to just pass it along to Dan and or myself.

1:24:53 That you would like this to be on the agenda. I would like this to be on the agenda. Andy, I've got a couple of questions for you about local ordinances and state superseding stuff like we've done with, had to deal with the plastic bags and those other unfortunate incidents and stuff, but we can talk offline, I guess. Just give me a call. Happy to talk through that. Okay, great. Thank you. Yeah, I'd like to second that. I would very much like to see this on the agenda as soon as possible. Thank you. Sarah?

1:25:25 Let's stick on agenda. Okay, moving forward then. I will go to public hearings. 8.1, public hearing to discuss expenditures and accomplishments of the town's 2017 Community Block Grant. I will open this public hearing and I will go to Sandra. Thank you, Mayor Salzer, Council. I'm gonna turn it over to Nolan Barra, our housing planner,

1:25:57 Brief presentation summarizing the expenditures and accomplishments for our CDBG grant. Go ahead, Nolan, thanks. Great, thank you. So this is the closeout of the 2017 CDBG grant. That's grant number 17, CDBG-12096. Just a quick timeline of the grant. On November 2017, the Town Council authorized submittal of the application for home buyer assistance and single unit residential rehabilitation.

1:26:26 In July 2018, the town was notified that we were awarded $700,000 for the grant. We executed the standard agreement in October 2018. And just kind of indicative of how the state operates, almost a year and a half later, in April 2019, we were actually authorized to begin incurring costs under that grant. And then the CDBG grants come with a two-year expenditure deadline.

1:26:55 Slightly longer than two years, and so that's July 31st, 2021, so next week. However, since we didn't have any loans that were pending or awaiting funding and no rehabilitation grants or loans, we went ahead and proceeded with the closeout hearing today. Just some grant highlights. We expended $450,655 of the awarded funds.

1:27:24 Also, we used $91,180 of program income for grant-related activities. Program income is money that's received by the town that's in previous loans or previous CDBG-funded activities are repaid. The town's able to retain that money and reinvest it on it. Reinvested for eligible CDBG activities. Of that, we spent $486,500 on the Home Buyer Assistance Program.

1:27:54 That provided three home loans to households in the community. Two of those units were for condominium units and one was for single family residents. We did not provide any funding for single unit residential rehabilitation. Some of the challenges that we faced on that were just lack of qualified or eligible households because it is restricted to households earning 80% of the area median income or below.

1:28:23 Lack of interest, lack of contractors when people did show interest who would take on those jobs. Then one instance on a mobile home unit, the owner was trying to get their evidence that they own the unit from HCD, the state agency, and they ran their roadblocks there trying to get evidence that they actually own their mobile unit. Also then we spent approximately $37,000 on administration.

1:28:51 So that reimburses the town for Mammoth Lakes housing costs related to administration of the grant and then town costs for staff time to monitor MLH, file reports and other related costs. Just a quick graph here. This is just kind of showing most recent CDBG grants and the two most recent home grants. It's another federal grant program.

1:29:18 Just showing the bottom line is the average loan amount provided, and the upper line is the average home price that was purchased with those loan amounts. As kind of everyone would expect, the current home prices are much higher than previous grants. This second item here is the 2014 CDBG grant. There's also just some data on whether the units were deed restricted previously, meaning that it was

1:29:45 You know, restricted to a certain income level or whether they want purchase the market rate unit, but they started to qualify at that income level. And then just next steps, we'll submit the closeout reports to the state. That closes out our current grants. Then we're awaiting notification on the 2020 and 2021 CDBG grants. We applied in September 2020 for $3 million for the 238 Sierra Manor Road project. We're still in the queue.

1:30:17 The state is dealing with a big backlog of over-the-counter projects. So we're still awaiting any word on that. And then we submitted last month for the 2021 grant for $500,000 for homebuyer assistance. So potentially in the next nine to 18 months, we'll hear word from the state on that grant and be able to provide new homebuyer loans. That I'll open up to the council or the public for questions.

1:30:47 I also believe Patricia Richardson, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing is on the call as well. Thank you, Nolan. I will go to the council for questions or comments. Linda? Hi, Nolan. Thank you for this. When you talked about there not being any qualified homeowners for the availability of the single unit residential rehab grants or loans, I mean, do you think that was that, I mean, what do you think the...

1:31:23 What kind of the roadblocks were for that? I think some of it is, so that program provided either grants, if you're qualified with the eligibility for the, there was $10,000 grants available, meaning that they'd be forgiven, but the eligibility was very restrictive on that one. And then there was the other side, which would be low interest or zero interest preferred loans.

1:31:56 Those, or yeah, deferred loans. And those, I think just homeowners are reluctant to take on any additional kind of burden on loans. They might have to repay in the future. And then the other part of that, landlords could actually get a loan as well through that program, but those required repayments starting immediately. So again, I think it's just landlords hesitant to take on additional kind of burden that they're going to have to repay.

1:32:23 I mean, when I look at the qualifications for this, it was so narrow. I mean, ages, ADA, or really, you know, 50% AMI. And how many people at 50% AMI, you know, own a property that they could, you know, rehab with 10,000? I mean, it just didn't appear to be very user-friendly. And what year was that put out? So that grant, again, it's the same grant.

1:32:51 Basically begin able to take or taking applications beginning April 2019. Okay, just a thought on that. So no more questions for you, but thanks for the report. Thank you, Linda. John? No questions. I'm interested in Patricia's comments, but no comments. Sarah? Yeah, I'm also interested in Patricia's comments. I'm wondering if this is an appropriate venue to discuss the CBD.

1:33:24 CDBG grant that we've decided not to apply for. I think we can touch on that as well after we hear Patricia's comments. Thank you. Burke? No questions. I have no questions. Patricia, go ahead. Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I apologize. I think I said Patricia Richardson instead of Patricia Robertson. Oh, that's okay, Nolan.

1:33:58 Thank you, everybody. This is Patricia Robertson, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I just wanted to give a few additional statistics to add to Nolan's very thorough report. Like he mentioned, we were able to fund three households, purchase their primary residence in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and that included eight individuals, including three children. These households have members working in law enforcement.

1:34:26 As a professional athlete in education, in tourism and in retail. I wanted to kind of just touch on the importance of utilizing diverse funding sources for our home buyer assistance program. And so I wanted to note that between 2018 and 2021, we made 15 home buyer loans and three of which were funded with CDBG funds.

1:34:58 represents 20% of all the funding for this program. And so it just goes to show that this is a popular program in our community. It helps our local households be able to gain the benefits from homeownership and become invested in the long term in our community. And so we're always grateful to partner with the town on different funding sources for this program.

1:35:26 And then I wanted to also just touch on Nolan's slide, which showed the number of deed restricted units that actually were utilized through this program in partnership with the Homebuyer Assistance Program. And you'll notice over time on that slide that

1:35:45 More households really need more subsidy as home prices grow. And so a lot of our households utilize both deed restricted ownership, which has a below market rate purchase price, along with down payment assistance because their income is low and so that they can't qualify for a primary mortgage to cover the full cost, even of a deed restricted unit. Hopefully that makes sense.

1:36:14 You can't see me, so it's a little weird. But lastly, I wanted to mention another barrier to the rehabilitation program, which I believe we did speak to some landlords about this program, and there was some interest among landlords for a low interest rate loan to rehabilitate their apartment units. However, many of them

1:36:42 And so I think there was some trepidation around that as well.

1:37:10 But I think that's all I have. I'm happy to answer any other questions. Patricia, thank you very much. Any specific questions for Patricia? Patricia, out of the 15 in the last four years that we've given, are those all in the town or some of those county? That number would be inclusive of the town of Mammoth Lakes. We do operate this program in Mono County in partnership with...

1:37:40 Mono County, but that's not included in this report today. Thank you very much. JB, do we have any public comment on this item? No, we do not. Okay. So with that, I will close the public hearing and move on to the next as there is no specific action here unless I'm missing it. Would that be correct, Nolan? Correct. I mean, I guess that's...

1:38:15 Council's direction or Dan's whether we wanted to touch on briefly the CDBG application that we did not submit for 2021. I just, I don't know where an appropriate time to discuss this is because I know we had the letter and I emailed Molly Day-Baye a couple weeks ago now and I have not heard back from her. I mean, I just, I'm wondering when we're gonna have discussion about this. Dan, do you have an answer for us?

1:38:45 Noah, if you want to touch on that, you can. I can speak to that. The idea of the child care, actually, not on the item here, but we do have an item to come back in a broader scope and talk about the child care element and what we're looking at from what would actually be an honest or more aggressive feasibility study versus a project that came back into us that was very focused on doing a shovel-ready project versus a feasibility study.

1:39:11 On child care and the need and stuff. And there's a lot of moving parts to that that we believe valid things to be addressed as we begin to look at child care, whether it's ages, whether it's how large of a facility. We do have one planned in the parcel. What role does that play? But the information that we were moving forward with as a feasibility study came back with the information from First Five, looking at really any study that looked at what you do.

1:39:43 We need to control a site. We need to get the building design, building plans, and a shovel-ready project for construction, which actually the grand amount, one, would not have funded that level of work, and secondly, it really wasn't a feasibility of looking at childcare. It was a feasibility looking at a particular building or site that was undefined. So it kind of got a little what are we actually asking for question.

1:40:08 We are continuing to look at child care. We do want to come back in with a more detail level discussion with the council as we look forward and some of the other work that's going on in the community, both Mammoth Lakes and I think even the county's looking at some stuff beyond countywide issues in terms of child care issues and children in general. Thanks. I just know we got a couple of letters on this and I just don't want this to, I want the public to know that it's on the radar.

1:40:38 Absolutely, yes. It's definitely not something that's being ignored. Thank you. Yeah, that will take a broader discussion than what we're able to have here for the way this is agendized. Yes, I understand. Thank you. Thank you. Did you want to add anything to that? No, I think Dan touched on all the kind of points and issues that we had with submitting that application and that it made more sense to delay it potentially to the next CDBG rounding so that we have a more comprehensive and robust

1:41:10 Scope of work for that grant. Right. Thank you. Moving on, I will remind you all the next five items are already all open public hearings. They are continued from our meeting of July 7th. So I will not be opening them individually, but we will be closing each as we go through. 8.2 is conduct a public hearing and adopt a resolution confirming the assessment and...

1:41:38 Ordering the levy for assessment for District 93-1 Juniper Ridge. Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And since we have five similar public hearings, perhaps a little housekeeping, for each we'll be adopting a resolution confirming ordering a levy of assessment for the particular assessment district.

1:42:00 This is based on an engineer's report, which was presented and approved by the council at its June 2nd meeting, which indicated the financials and the assessment at that time. The council adopted on the June 2nd meeting a resolution initiating today's proceedings and actually last meeting's proceedings, which are continuing today.

1:42:19 Declaring that intention to levy and assess these various assessment districts. The resolution of intention also called for this public hearing in order to allow for testimony of any interested person. We need to take each one of these separately. And like you said, we need to close the public hearing and adopt the resolution. But I'll kind of follow a similar process and hopefully get into a little bit of a rhythm here. For each, I'll go through the recommendation, provide a little bit of information about what the assessment.

1:42:49 I will say in advance of that for out of the five assessment districts, only two, Juniper Ridge and the Bluffs will be receiving the maximum assessment. That's because we're pretty low on reserves and they have a lot of work that needs to be done.

1:43:08 For the other three, NBS, our consultants did a really good job of trying to minimize the assessment, trying to find ways to try to provide some relief to those residents in light of the pandemic and so forth. So with that, I'll begin with Juniper Ridge. Staff is recommending that Town Council conduct a public hearing and after receiving the staff report, public testimony and deliberation, adopt the resolution confirming and ordering the levy of assessment.

1:43:37 Levy for the assessment district 93-1 Juniper Ridge for the fiscal year 21-22. Juniper Ridge, this assessment district provides the landscaping, the flowers, you know, the green spaces, provides street lighting, decorative wall in the area, provides snow stakes and snow removal. What it does not provide is pavement treatments, curb and gutter repair and things of that nature.

1:44:07 The assessment for this year is $1,200 per lot. This is the same as previous years. Like I said, that they have a lot of needs for reserves and a lot of work that needs to be done. I will add that we're going through a process to reassess the assessment district. When it was created back in 1993, there was no cost escalator at that time. So what we're assessing right now is really not enough to maintain and manage the infrastructure there.

1:44:35 With that, that concludes my presentation. Happy to field any questions that you may have. Thank you, Hayes. Before I go to questions, do we have any other members of the public wishing to speak on this item? No, we do not. Thank you very much. Then I would go for questions from Council to Hayes. Raise your hands if you want to speak. I'm not going to go through the whole list. Seeing none, I will close the public hearing and bring the item before you to make a...

1:45:07 To adopt a resolution confirming the levy of assessments for 93-1 Juniper Ridge. And that would then require a second, Mr. Mayor? Okay, then I will second that. So I have a motion from me, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Jamie? Council Member Ray? I don't think Council Member Ray is there, maybe? Let's go on. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes.

1:45:45 Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Back to Councilmember Rae? Yes. Okay. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes 5-0. Thank you very much. Moving on to Item 8.3. Conduct a public hearing and adopt a resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Special Maintenance District Assessment District 93 for the Bluffs. Hayes.

1:46:12 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So, like you stated, staff is recommending that the Town Council conduct the public hearing and after receiving the staff report, public testimony and deliberation, adopt the attached resolution ordering the levying and collection of assessments within the Bluffs Assessment District, number 93-4, Zone 1 for the 21-22 fiscal year. The Bluffs Maintenance Assessment District provides paving, asphalt treatments,

1:46:41 Snow stakes, snow removal operations, street lights and drainage improvements for that area. Last year, the assessment was zero. They had enough in their reserves to cover their operations, but upon further examination of the assessment district's needs, the levy was placed at $2,100, and that is to make sure we have appropriate reserves for snow removal operations and the future asphalt treatments that are necessary to keep the road in good state of repair.

1:47:11 That concludes my presentation. Happy to field any questions you may have. Thank you. Do we have any public comments on this, Jamie? No, we do not. Any questions for Hayes? I would entertain a motion. So moved. Thank you, John. I will second. I have a motion from John, a second from Bill. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes.

1:47:50 For Tim Salcido. Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. Passes 5-0. I will tell you I've messed that up. I needed to end the public hearing before our deliberations, but it will still work fine. Thank you. Moving on to 8.4, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Special Maintenance District, Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District. On this one, Linda, I need to ask you to turn off your camera and recuse.

1:48:20 I shall do that. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So staff recommends that the Town Council conduct the public hearing and after receiving the staff report, public testimony and deliberation adopt the attached resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District Number 2002-1 for fiscal year 21-22. This is a benefit assessment district that provides landscaping, irrigation,

1:48:51 The proposed assessment is $17.56 per linear foot, which is down from $30.81 last year. We're happy to provide some relief there. I will add that staff has worked with a landscape architect to develop a comprehensive landscape and streetscape plan.

1:49:19 This was kind of put on hold because of COVID, but staff is looking to bring this forward in 22 as a beautification project for the Old Mammoth Road Assessment District. That is the conclusion of my report. Happy to answer any questions you may have. Thank you, Hayes. Do we have any public comment or input on this, Jamie? No, we do not. Any questions for Hayes on this? I will ask then for a motion. So moved. I'll second. I have a motion from John, a second from Sarah.

1:49:53 Any further deliberations? Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes 4-0 with Lynda recusing. Lynda, you may now come back. 8.5, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Special Maintenance District North Village Benefit Assessment District.

1:50:26 2002-2, Zone 1, Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Staff is recommending that the Town Council conduct the public hearing and after receiving the staff report, public testimony and deliberation, adopt the attached resolution ordering levy and collection of assessments within special maintenance district, North Village Benefit Assessment District Number 2002-2, Zone 1.

1:50:50 For fiscal year 21-22. This benefit assessment district provides snow removal operations, sidewalk sweeping, landscaping, street lights, banners, curb gutter repair, sidewalk repair in the area around the village. The assessment for this year is a total of $50,300 and is split by formula between the one bedroom to three bedroom units, which range from $70 to $117.

1:51:20 Thank you. Thank you. Do we have any

1:51:48 Public comments on this, Jamie? No, we do not. I will then close the public hearing and call for a motion. I will move to approve as presented. Second. I have a motion from myself, a second from Mr. Wentworth. Any further deliberations? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Sorry. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer?

1:52:26 Passes 5-0, thank you all. 8.6, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Special Maintenance District, Benefit Assessment District Number 2014-1, Mammoth View, Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1:52:47 You may be surprised to hear that staff is recommending that Town Council conduct a public hearing and after receiving the staff report public testimony and deliberation adopt the attached resolution ordering the levy and collection of assessments within the Mammoth View Benefit Assessment District number 2014-1 for fiscal year 2021. Viewpoint Road was taken over by the Town a number of years ago to facilitate some future development in that area.

1:53:14 And assessment district was formed to take care of the road and some of the areas right around there. Mainly street pavement, snow removal operation, street lights, some directional signage and future way finding and monument signage that may occur with a future project. The assessment for this year is $11.48 per unit. Last year it was zero and the year before that it was $107 and it should be mentioned that the maximum assessment

1:53:43 Could be $109. So like I said, the consultants did a good job minimizing the impact to those residents. That concludes my presentation. Happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Hayes. Do we have any public comments on this item, Jamie? No, we do not. Thank you very much. I will then call on council for a motion. So moved. A second. Thank you.

1:54:15 John, I have a motion from John, a second from Sarah. Any further deliberation? And I close the public hearing. Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Approves 5-0. And any of the public hearings I forgot to close are hereby closed.

1:54:49 Moving on to policy matters. 9.1, approve execution of agreements with Caltrans to confirm various roles and responsibilities along State Route 203, Main Street. Hayes, you're up again. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And can you please confirm that you are seeing my green screen? Yes, we are. Thank you, sir. So the recommendation for today is to authorize the town manager and mayor to execute the following agreements with Caltrans.

1:55:26 A delegated maintenance agreement, an agreement for sharing cost of state highway electrical facilities, project-specific maintenance agreement, and a work for others agreement, and also to authorize the town manager to execute amendments to these agreements as needed to incorporate new infrastructure and accommodate additional responsibilities that may benefit the town.

1:55:51 So a little bit of background, no secret, SR203 is under state jurisdiction and managed by the Bishop Caltrans District 9 office. And the town has constructed a significant amount of infrastructure along Main Street since incorporation. And the town continues to maintain and manage that infrastructure under a variety of permits and agreements.

1:56:17 And that infrastructure includes the landscaping, sidewalks, mops, banners, street signs, CMS boards, crosswalk and bike lane striping, drainage infrastructure, bus shelters, wayfinding. There is a healthy amount of improvements out there that are under the management of the town. The town also does some regular service and maintenance. We provide street sweeping and we do storm removal operations.

1:56:43 We have about 40 years, almost 40 years worth of permits and agreements, MOUs, and they have become somewhat difficult to track and update. There are very well-known conflicts within those agreements and some very unclear responsibilities. So a few years ago, town staff and Caltrans Encroachment Permits Division started working together to pretty much wipe the slate clean.

1:57:09 And start with a whole bunch of new documents working within the Caltrans framework. And what we came up with was four agreements that really will cover everything but a couple of minor things that will need to be done on annual encroachment permit. Excuse me, annual encroachment permit. There's a work for others agreement, delegated maintenance agreement, specific maintenance agreement, and some cost sharing agreements. And I'll walk through each one of these.

1:57:38 First, a Work for Others Agreement. What this is, is an agreement that allows the town to reimburse the state of California for work it does on our traffic signals. There's been a number of incidents where the town has had to call on Caltrans to help us out with our traffic signals. We own three of them at Old Mammoth Road and Meridian, Meridian Minaret and Canyon Lake Mary.

1:58:03 And we have had a lot of trouble finding a reliable contractor and specifically a contractor that is able to provide services in an emergency. Most of the contractors down in Los Angeles, we have an emergency, something breaks. We're told it'll be a week before we can get up here. And I'm sure we've all seen our flashing signals when something goes down.

1:58:25 Caltrans has their own electrical staff and their own team that can maintain signals. So we're working on an agreement that will allow, under emergency circumstances, the state of California to come in and do work on our facilities. And this will be a huge benefit to the town and our residents and visitors, as we'll have somebody available locally to keep our equipment in a good state of repair. We put together a delegated maintenance agreement.

1:58:54 This agreement will provide a mechanism for the state to reimburse the town for doing work on the highway, specifically street sweeping debris removal and snow removal operations on our sidewalks. This will be replacing a couple of existing delegated maintenance agreements from 1986 and 2005. Obviously, a lot of infrastructure has been conducted in the last 15 to 40 years, so it's time to renew this agreement.

1:59:22 We provide these services now. We're not looking to add any additional work. And this agreement does not obligate the town to do work. It just simply provides a mechanism to be reimbursed when we do do work. It's proposed to provide $12,000 to the town for street sweeping debris removal and $40,000 to the town for snow removal operations. The extent is only from Thompson's Way.

1:59:51 Up to Forest Trail by the Village. We're not taking on any responsibility outside of the extent it's really in the core of town. Moving on to the project-specific maintenance agreement. This agreement is really to confirm the town's responsibilities related to the maintenance of facilities the town has constructed on Caltrans property. It replaces a myriad of agreements, encroachment permits.

2:00:22 And it really covers everything we've built in almost the last 40 years from the sidewalks, pathways, mobs, under crossings, the bus shelters, landscaping, wayfinding, storm drain systems, retaining walls, street lighting, pedestrian beacons, you name it. It's all going to be brought under one agreement that we can maintain in one place rather than having this battery of documents that are kind of unwieldy.

2:00:48 We're not proposing any new responsibilities on their agreement. This is just what has been built. And like the recommendation states, we would like to provide the town manager the ability to amend this agreement as necessary as the town onboard new infrastructure. Next is an agreement for sharing of costs of state highway electrical facilities. This one's kind of interesting. A couple...

2:01:18 A lot of our infrastructure was in place before some of these state requirements were imposed, but at current times, the state of California and municipal governments share the cost of providing signals along the state highway. So this agreement would provide just that. We're looking at putting together a program where we do quarterly billings for traffic signals and the lighting, the maintenance, the labor.

2:01:47 Any overhead assessments and so forth. It's gonna require a little bit of work with SCE with the billing and metering. We kind of started looking into this deeper and we may actually be paying for some of this infrastructure right now. There's a couple of meters in place that will probably have to be redone to make sure that the billing of this infrastructure is appropriate and meets the intent of this agreement, but that'll come.

2:02:16 What we're proposing is a split. We're on the intersection of, say, 203 and Lake Mary, where it's a four-way intersection. Half those legs are Caltrans, half the legs are towns, so it would be a 50-50 split. On Old Mammoth Road, where it intersects with 203, two-thirds are on the state highway system, one-third's on the town, so we'd be responsible for one-third of those costs.

2:02:45 This is just a map showing those two intersections. So all but the work for other agreements have been approved by Caltrans Legal and are pretty much ready for signature so we can advance these forward if approved. I put up the recommendation again and I just want to say thanks to our partners at Caltrans. This was a very, very heavy lift and took

2:03:15 A couple of years to put together and many years of research to figure out the battery of this document and the extent of the work that we've done together. Really like to thank, you know, Stephen Winsenried for his work on this. This wouldn't have come together without his effort in shepherding this through the Caltrans bureaucracy. With that, that ends my presentation and I'm happy to field any questions you may have. Thank you, Hayes. Going to council for questions or comments, Linda.

2:03:47 No question. Sounds reasonable. Sounds like a great idea to get this cleaned up. Sounds like it was a big job, Nolan. I mean, Hayes, so, yeah. Good on you. Thanks. John? Hayes, I'm not going to get into the very heavy lifting of the agreements. I mean, that's your expertise, Caltrans's expertise. Great work. If you're happy with it, they're happy with it. Let's go forward. I do want to ask a question about the intersection.

2:04:17 At Minaret 203 in Lake Mary Road. Right across Mammoth Brewing, you'd call that out, 50-50 split on that. I was talking with Dan, I've been spending a fair amount of time at that intersection over the last couple weeks as I try to rehabilitate from COVID, you know, 1.0. And the pedestrian timing in that intersection is really bad. It's arbitrary.

2:04:46 It makes no sense. This morning, or yesterday afternoon, you had a green signal to water for literally three seconds, and then it went to something else. So it's excellent work that you're figuring out a way to get maintenance up there to be able to deal with that. But as you and I, as we all know, that intersection with the proposals you brought to the LTC for Mupp work.

2:05:07 I know it's about planning at this point, but that's going to be a critical recreation infrastructure there. Are you confident? I know this is better than what we have right now, which is nothing, but as that becomes increasingly dense with recreation and pedestrian traffic and all the rest of it, I'm assuming you're thinking this is going to be a good solution for dealing with that. Those types of future challenges, they're going to be coming at that intersection for sure. Yeah, absolutely, John.

2:05:34 It was only brought to my attention today that there was a timing issue on that signal, and I showed in the presentation that's actually a Caltrans signal, it's not a town signal. Honestly, we don't know these things until someone brings them to our attention, so we'll forward this over to the Caltrans Maintenance Division, make sure that they're aware of these issues and have their team make the corrections to the signal timing. As far as the agreement, I believe it provides the appropriate flexibility for us to

2:06:04 Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Thank you.

2:06:26 Yeah, that's going to be a really, we know what that intersection is going to become. So, well, yeah, good on you for pursuing that, getting in the trenches, getting this done. It's better than we are now. And we'll see how this works in the future. It's good to know we've got someone who can fix a fuse, fix a timer, do something. We don't have to wait for three weeks to get a fix. So thank you very much for that. Thank you, John. Moving on to Sarah. But before I do, I want to say, Sarah, I'm jealous. It appears you have sun in your cubicle.

2:06:55 I do. It's just like for half an hour, but I can try and move the curtain. Oh, you're good. I have a north-facing window that's beautiful, but I never get any sun. Yeah, yeah. We love it, you know, 11 months out of the year. So, any questions on this item? I don't. I don't. Thank you so much. Thanks for all your hard work, Hayes. Kirk.

2:07:23 No questions. Thank you, Hayes, for all your hard work. Thank you. My only comment is anytime we can improve our agreements with state or federal agencies to make them more streamlined, attaboy. So I am thankful for the work and hopefully this will make things flow a little easier. Any public comment on this item? No, there is not. Thank you. With that, I would move forward to a motion.

2:07:54 Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Council approve the item as presented by the Public Works Director. I'll second that. Thank you. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Council Member Wray? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wentworth?

2:08:22 Yes, and I look forward to following up with that information on the intersection of Hayes. Yes, absolutely. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes 5-0. Thank you very much. Moving on then to the next item. Authorize the memory of understanding by and between the Town Forest Service and Mammoth Main Lodge. What are we calling it? The R.

2:08:54 Anyway, MMLR, for the purpose of establishing requirements and procedures for the preparation of a joint EIR-EIS document for the proposed Mammoth-Main Lodge-based Pacific Plan project. Sandra. Thank you, Mayor Salazar, Councilmembers. As you summarize, this item is a memorandum of understanding for the environmental process for the main lodge redevelopment project.

2:09:22 The purpose of this MOU is to establish procedures for how the town, the floor of service, and the applicant will work together on this environmental process. The MOU establishes the roles and responsibilities for each party as well as an overall framework for communications and joint review of those environmental documents.

2:09:45 Just to note about the process for this project, we did receive a concept review application, which the council considered on June 16th, alongside the Planning and Economic Development Commission. The Appleton is currently working to put together a full entitlement package for the project. We expect that full submittal to be in about two months. They're trying to kind of take the comments that they received in June and put together their package for submittal for a town review.

2:10:15 When you get down to the heart of the MOU, the real intent of this MOU is that the town forest service and the applicant, we're gonna stay in sync through this process. We're gonna ensure that we're dealing with project refinements as a group as they occur. And we have been coordinating closely with the forest service and the applicant on this MOU process. And we did hear from the forest service that they're not ready to sign the MOU right away. They do have to process.

2:10:42 We've processed this document through their grants and agreements team, but they have provided preliminary comments on it, and we don't anticipate significant comments to come out of their grants and agreements review. With that being said, staff would recommend that the town council authorize staff to execute the MLU, subject to final approval by the town attorney. With that, I'm available for any questions. We also have Chandler VanScock, who's been helping shepherd this process as well.

2:11:09 And I'll just point out that the basic format of the MOU is the one that the Forest Service indicated that they strongly prefer. We had given them a slightly different format in the beginning, and they said that would be difficult for them to get through their bureaucracies. They said, can we start with this? And we said, sure. And then we made a number of changes intended to clarify that the town retains discretion over CEQA things and over other kind of town-related things, kind of trying to clearly delineate.

2:11:37 Where the Forest Service can make decisions and where we get to make decisions without the Forest Service telling us what to do. So that is the intent. I've reviewed it. Our outside Sequa-Nepa Council has reviewed it and we think this is a good document. Thank you, Andy. Comments or questions from Council? Linda? No, thank you, Andy. If you have reviewed it and you're in favor, I have no further questions. Thank you. John.

2:12:11 Just to clarify for the council and for the public, the reality of moving forward with a very complex project that involves both a federal agency, maybe multiple federal agencies and the town, is that the environmental work only proceeds as expeditionally as all the partners involved in the project are ready to proceed. Is that fair to say?

2:12:38 That's the intent. I mean, we are looking to move through this process, you know, concurrently as much as we can. You know, I think that the key with that, with being in sync on these things is that if items come up or if changes occur, we're kind of all dealing with these changes as they're coming up. And that's really kind of, that's really the purpose of the MOU is we are going to work together. We understand this is a complex project and we're going to work to bring this forward as a team.

2:13:07 Okay, so with that in mind, so Sandra, you made some representations about the applicant wanting to be submitting something to the town within two months. And my understanding is that Forest Service is saying they're looking for some critical and specific federal documents that they're not even close to being ready.

2:13:30 The Forest Service is advising perhaps anecdotally that scoping may not start for this project until January. So I think it's extremely important that when staff is making representations to the council on progress that's happening on this effort, that your representations are not just to the town's interests, but they're to the interests of the entire project. Otherwise, we get into situations perhaps setting some unrealistic expectations.

2:14:00 Saying, well, the applicant's going to submit something to us in two months. And then the public saying, well, what's going on with this? The applicant perhaps wanting to call town council members and saying, you know, why aren't she moving forward on things? When we all know and we need to know that this thing only moves forward when the parties to this MOU are in agreement and are in sync that it should move forward. Is that, am I making sense here?

2:14:28 Yeah, I understand your comment. And I think kind of circling back to what Andy said is that there are, while we all want to move in sync, move together, move forward, there are items that are really only to town's discretion and items that are only to Forest Service discretion. And so I think we understand that and we'll work through that. And certainly we're not going to try to impose our requirements outside of our authority. And I'm assuming that Forest Service feels the same way about our authority.

2:14:54 But it is definitely, as you mentioned, a very complex project. There's a lot of moving parts. There's a lot of agencies. And I think the MOU really just helps to clarify how we're going to handle the environmental process and how we're going to move this piece of it forward. Okay, so then when there's any action related to this effort that you're asking the council to do, I would hope and expect that the council members are going to say, okay, well, this is maybe town specific. What is happening with the larger effort?

2:15:24 Where is the Forest Service on this? And our expectation is that you will speak to where the Forest Service is at, what communications you're getting for them, so that we don't inadvertently get siloed into just our little lane, because we know we have to be looking at this thing as a totality. Is that fair to reasonable expectation? Yes, absolutely. This project is a big, one big project with a lot of moving parts, but certainly we're going to be representing what's happening on Forest Service land because it directly affects.

2:15:53 What happens on town land. So it is, there is definitely a relationship and our intent is to bring this forward as kind of a whole piece with a lot of different parts, but really explaining to the council and the public where all of the pieces are falling and how we're all moving forward. Is it reasonable for us to be able to say, to request forest service documents or forest service process pieces? I'm assuming through you guys, because we're not going to be calling up the forest service and asking for this stuff, but.

2:16:22 If the four, like scoping notices, communications, you know, the NEPA process, we can turn to you guys to be the reliable source of information for the town, the community, for everything that's happening on the federal side. Is that fair to say? Yes. Okay. More to come. Those are my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you, John. Sarah. I have no questions. Thank you. Kirk. No questions. Thank you. Thank you.

2:16:52 I hope we're all ready for this. This is a huge project. This is going to require changing our own general plan because it was for service land and now it's private land and it currently it isn't in our own zoning. So there are a lot of things that need to move forward even outside of the environmental process which is pretty much what we're talking about here that is going to be heavy lifting for our town staff and for the consultants coming in on this. So I am looking forward from hearing back on regular.

2:17:20 basis on all aspects of this. I thank you. Do we have any public comments on this? Yes. Tom Cage, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay, great. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. With this large project, does it give the town the ability to negotiate?

2:17:52 property tax distribution differently than what it currently exists in the county with what the town gets from the county and obviously at some point you're gonna involve a fire district who will be providing services, water district who may or may not be providing services and as you said it's going to require a general plan amendment so I just am curious if

2:18:21 Oh, and LAFCO. I think this will have to go through LAFCO. So that's another agency that we'll have to deal with. And I don't know if any of that needs to be written into this MOU agreement. Andy might have some comments on that. But my most curious thing is it's going to be, like you say, a big project. I don't know the total dollar amount, but if we have a chance to negotiate a different tax split.

2:18:49 With the county, that could be a very good thing for the town. Thank you very much. Let me address those questions. This MOU is specific to the CEQA and NEPA process. This is not anything else. This is just us talking to the Forest Service and the applicant about how we're going to handle the environmental review. All those other things are not really intended to be part of this particular agreement. We can talk about those other things, of course. I mean, we can always...

2:19:18 Go to the county and talk to them about changing the tax distribution. Of course, they have no obligation to say yes. We can talk to them anytime. LAFCO issues, if those come up, then we'll deal with them in some other document or some other process. But this one is just CQA NEPA. Linda, was that your hand raised? Okay, thank you. So is it fair to say, Andy, that the only way probably to get the county to participate like that would be something like an EIFD?

2:19:54 And that was not part of this. We have not had, there are no finance-related discussions that are part of this MOU because it's limited environmental stuff. Discussions about those things are maybe for another time and we can talk about what those options might be another time. Yeah, and from my perspective, Dan, we need to start talking about that sooner rather than later because I see some great opportunity here if the mountain hasn't brought it up already.

2:20:26 Any other public comments, Jamie? Yes, Tom Hodges, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi guys, Tom here. Yeah, yeah, just while I was just gonna reinforce what Andy said and what Sandra said and yeah, I mean, this MAU pertains to the NEPA and the CEQA process and which is its own, you know, path in its own right. And then, you know, the development proposal will layer in on that as Sandra alluded to.

2:21:02 We'll start getting to these more complicated discussions as things move along here in the coming months. But yeah, really, you know, our role in this MOU is really we're just a quiet participant because it's really the town and the Forest Services process that we fully are respecting and obviously following and complying with the regulations as they're defined in CEQA and NEPA. So really appreciate, you know, all the hard work by Sandra and Chandler today.

2:21:31 Certainly a huge project. But I do want to point out to you guys that we did do a similar process back in 2007, 2006, 2007 with the Eagle Lodge. It was a joint document then and we did get through it. And I think just the key is, as Sandra pointed out, is just to keep everybody in sync on the process steps as much as they're very similar processes, but there's uniqueness to the noticing and so forth and just collaboration on those time frames.

2:22:00 Which, you know, I don't think there's going to be really any issues with that. And just so you know, John, you made a comment about some of the requirements of the Forest Service. We are very aggressively moving forward with them reviewing our updated master development plan was one of the hurdles they asked for to do in advance of the public noticing. We're into that. They've been submitted a draft. They're in review. We're expecting to get that reviewed and accepted by them in the coming month. So, you know,

2:22:30 It's possible we could have a public noticing going out late September, something of that nature I think is possible, but we'll see how it plays out. Again, it's not our process. It's definitely the towns and the forest services to shepherd through, and we're obviously just following their lead in participating. Yeah, John. Yeah, Tom, thanks for that.

2:22:54 Sandra, I'm pretty sure that you received some communication from Leslie Yen of the Forest Service around expectations for when scoping would get underway and things like that. And Tom, not trying to undermine anything, but again, I think having good, incredible information for the public, for the council is really important. So Sandra and Dan, do you want to weigh in on that communication that you received from Leslie Yen so that we can start maybe thinking realistically and setting some expectations that can make sense to folks?

2:23:22 Sure. I mean, I think Leslie sent us an email today just indicating that she had some concerns about the timeline for the project. She did put together a kind of high-level schedule. She did clarify that that schedule was based on some previous projects they worked on and isn't exactly the schedule for the project. But I think that the Forest Service has made it clear to the applicant that

2:23:50 They really want to get through the master development process before they're moving into the environmental. So unless they did indicate she expects that the MDP should be approved within the next four to six weeks. So I would anticipate that they can update their schedule deadlines and we can kind of talk about the next biggest step in this environmental process, which is the scoping. That's kind of the next opportunity for the public to provide comments and to really help the town and the Forest Service.

2:24:19 Determine what the scope of the environmental analysis will be. So Dan, I don't know if you have anything to add on that. I do see Gordon's on the call. I don't know if Gordon has additional comments as well. Yeah, just that my understanding is that scope, again, just set public expectations may not be till the first of next year. So that's, I think we just, we just want to be realistic with the public to say, if you want to start engaging with this process, it looks like probably the first part of 2022, but that's what I'm hearing.

2:24:55 Okay. Any other questions or comments on this or any other public comments? Gordon Martin, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yeah, just a little bit of clarification. This, what you're voting on here is the MOU. And the MOU, when you boil it down, is just a way to pay for the environmental review by the contractor that we have.

2:25:29 And it's a bit separate from the master development plan. We did receive the master development plan last Friday, and we are in the process of reviewing it. We do expect that to be complete somewhere around the end of August, optimistically. And once we get the master development plan,

2:25:59 We don't approve them. They get accepted. We would be at that point open to accepting a project proposal from Mammoth Mountain. And once we have that proposal, we can start moving forward with the environmental process there when we know.

2:26:26 What it is that they're actually proposing. The master development plan is a list of ideas, dreams, whatever, that may or may not come to fruition, but it's a document that spans many years, five to ten years, and individual projects out of that master development plan will come forward kind of piece by piece.

2:26:56 The real work starts when, after we've accepted the master development plan, we get that first project proposal that's tied into that plan. Thank you, Gordon. Any questions for Gordon? Seeing none, do we have any further public comments? No, we do not. Thank you very much. With that, I would entertain a motion. Your hand almost went up. Yeah, I freaked myself out.

2:27:36 Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council authorize a memorandum of understanding by and between the Town, U.S. Forest Service and Mammoth Mountain Land Redevelopment. Forgive me if I don't get the acronym right. Subject to the Town Attorney's approval and finalization of the MOU for the purpose of establishing requirements and procedures for the preparation of a joint EIR-EIS document for MMLR's proposed Mammoth Main Lodge Base specific plan project.

2:28:05 As described in the MOU included as attachment A. I'll second the motion. I have a motion from John, a second from Kirk. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, I will ask for the question, Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes 5-0. At this point, we have been at this.

2:28:37 For almost two and a half hours, so I will call a break until 6.30. Thank you all.

2:30:41 All right.

2:31:40 On a recess. Yeah. On housing. We do. Can you get on a new ride? Um, so I just wanted to get a new bike outfitted. Everything I wanted to get for it, so I'll get it out. More cool enough. Yeah, yeah. What do you have here? GS-1250. What did you have? Do you enjoy it? Love it. Yeah, it's quite a .

2:32:41 The first trip out, I almost dumped it, because I've never ridden two of them on dirt. It's just weird. It's super weird. And we've been out somewhere, and the rain came pretty hard, and I really saw it. So, just a little bit of a red cap on that. I think it started going, and I got it stopped. And she didn't say anything on the back, but I was like, that must be terrifying. I didn't have any issues. Those tires were already difficult. And then you got it.

2:33:13 Somebody that you can't control. And you can't really do a robot. Right? Second behind it, right? She's leaning the wrong way and it's like, oh, oh, oh. That's hard to correct. That was good.

2:34:07 Okay, I saw Linda and John both pop up for a minute. So I'm assuming they are present. Dan is back. Kirk is there.

2:35:28 So I will now move on to item number 9.3, Town Housing Work Program Review and Council Direction on Current Housing Initiatives and Funding. Daniel. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll kick this off, then we'll be a little bit of a shared presentation with Sandra Moberly and Nolan Bobroff. But the item before you really is to give you a good overview of the town.

2:35:57 We've done efforts to date a number of different areas and where we see us going and related to providing housing to our community. One of the strategic priorities of town council is to make, you know, enhance the availability of affordable housing for the community. And so we begin to do that. We have a number of initiatives that have been in the works, and we really do want to get them in front of the town council at this point to take a look at. It requires...

2:36:25 Some direction, commitment of funds, et cetera, to be able to move this forward. We had been looking at this coming forward this past year, a lot more detail at that point in time as well and looking at different elements and obviously got sidetracked with a little COVID-19 pandemic and so working through that. But even through there, we have accomplished quite a bit, we believe, in terms of housing work and what we're doing. We'll spend some time on some of the...

2:36:55 Program from an administrative standpoint and then actually some specific areas for council consideration to move some housing projects forward. So we've looked at that. We've had a lot of different dollars committed through housing over the last several years looking at two different kind of reserve funds that we work with in the town, one being the Measure A reference dollars, TOT dollars committed to housing.

2:37:22 Once back 17-18 with the shifting back to actually adding more dollars into that allocation following the changes that were made after the MLLA settlement efforts and putting dollars back into the housing side from there. That's been tracked and spent accordingly. Part of that has been what's actually funded Nolan's work on the housing side as well.

2:37:50 Plus, then we also set aside money as a separate fund. You see this in the budget process, but we usually don't spend a lot of time highlighting it, but it's Fund 245, and we do have dollars that go into there. We also track some of our grant programs and work out of that fund as well, and so when we reference those in here, just an FYI for that, the general fund reserve, if we talk to that, from housing designated, that's coming out of that TOT.

2:38:19 Housing Community Development Fund, and we set that up, and we do have general fund dollars that go into there, different areas that we end up working with in that particular fund. So I wanted to kind of highlight those things. Then as we walk through this, we do want to take a look at a number of different factors that we've been working on, giving you an overview, kind of the housing program in big picture, then down to specific projects.

2:38:45 We have a lot of discussion. We talk about the CHAP. We talk about our housing element. We talk about other activities there, state requirements. We kind of want to walk through those and then understand that structure that our overall, you know, from a town perspective, the housing element is that foundational document. It's actually the CEQA done, et cetera. It really is the legal structure. The Community Housing Action Plan was accepted by the town council. It's actually not an adopted type plan. It hasn't gone through.

2:39:14 Are there other evaluations in there? And then, of course, the state overlays out and says, here's your allocation of housing you need to plan for. And the state numbers are just that. It's a planning tool, not a thou shalt build tool. They lay out and say, here's, you know, you have to identify you have enough land for these types of uses. We do take that seriously as we work through it and try to meet those requirements and those types of elements.

2:39:40 Also, as we walk through some of this, we will talk about a lot of the dollars that the town has committed to housing, well over and above what would be from the Measure A type allocation of the TOT allocation for housing. As we get in some of the projects, we'll speak to those specifically. This is a broad element in discussion over housing in general. Just note on the front end, we have very little discussion other than just

2:40:07 A little bit of basic information regarding the parcel. We've done that on purpose so that Mayor Sauser and Member Ray can participate through this whole discussion. So the extent that we want to deal with the parcel, that'll be coming up actually in a separate meeting coming up August 4th for more detail there at that point. So we want to keep this really focused on that broader issue. And then some goals and stuff on housing that are outside of the work on the parcel, which is a significant...

2:40:36 Thank you so much.

2:41:00 No one understand. If you want to pop some of the slides up, you want to walk through some of that broader background, then we'll get into the policy discussion. And sorry, what other thing? If you went through the staff report, you've seen a number of highlights where we talk about a council policy item or discussion area. We wanted to highlight those in the staff report.

2:41:20 To make you think, kind of think through those as you looked at the staff report. We want to come back at the end and actually walk through each of those discussion areas and get council a concurrence direction and then moving forward in those areas or modify it currently. So with that, I'm going to turn it back to Sandra and then to Nolan to kind of hit on some of these highlights and big picture items that we've been working through with our housing program.

2:41:46 Thanks, Dan. Super helpful introduction. So Nolan put together this PowerPoint presentation just to hit on some of the background and work program items. So I'll hand it over to Nolan and he and I will kind of tag team the presentation a little bit here. Go ahead, Nolan. Great. So yeah, the first piece of the report is really on some of the background data, just on some of the previous year's data on...

2:42:11 On units built, in lieu fees collected, that's the housing, affordable housing fees. And then work towards meeting our regional housing needs allocation, that's the RHNA. So this first slide is just showing the in lieu housing fee fund balance over the last five years. Now it's grown or in some cases shrunk. A few areas to highlight just on the debit side. So we did move $500.

2:42:40 And we also, the Revolving Loan Fund has always been funded using the in-lieu housing fee balance. However, prior to 2018, the funds just came out of the in-lieu balance. It wasn't kept or tracked separately.

2:43:05 It's that fund 245 that Dan talks to. So that's where the money is now retained for the revolving loan fund. So we, prior to 2019, maintained a $300,000 balance for the revolving loan funds. That's that $186,000 transfer in 2018. It was that money combined with some other reimbursements that were paid back to the town, one of them being the town previously had an employee down payment assistance program.

2:43:34 So that was repaid and a few other expenditures were combined to get that initial $300,000. And then in 2019, that revolving loan was increased to $600,000. So again, we moved $180,000 over to that account, along with a few other loans that were repaid in order to maintain that minimum $600,000 balance there. So that remaining $226,000 that you see there,

2:44:02 226, 798. That was current as of last week. I believe it has grown a little bit more with a few permits that have been issued in the last week, but that's kind of unrestricted funds that are out there available to be redirected towards future housing projects. Moving forward, kind of segue into building permits. So this one's just showing permits that have been submitted, issued,

2:44:31 We did only for housing over the last four years. We broke it out this way because this aligns with how it's shown in the annual planning report that's submitted to the state. It also kind of tracks progress when you look at it, at least the back end data, you know, parcel by parcel as the progress is from coming in all the way to being completed. And then prior to even submitted, there's also an entitlement phase for a lot of the projects.

2:44:58 One kind of important area here is the 2019. That was a code change year. So we had a large number of permits submitted right at the end of December of 2019. So that's why you see this really big jump here of 46 and 19 and even the eight for ADUs. So in subsequent years, we will be seeing those permits be issued and then completed as those people pull the permits.

2:45:28 You also notice that over the years, it has been kind of an increase. We have seen on ADUs being not just interest, but actually permits being pulled and being built. And so that's, again, kind of throughout, you start seeing those numbers climb when you look at it in this format. So touching on the regional housing needs allocation, that's the RENA. That is the state required item. California requires all jurisdictions to adequately plan.

2:45:58 to meet the housing needs of everyone in the community and to demonstrate compliance with that requirement, the state has come up with a methodology for determining how many housing units are needed in each community. So that's the, again, the abbreviation is just the RHNA. RHNA is broken into separate income categories and identifies the number of units that are needed to satisfy minimum housing demand in 2027.

2:46:26 Based on projected population and the number of existing housing units. The arena is set for a specific time period that coincides with the housing element cycles. We're currently operating within the sixth cycle of the housing element that spans from 2019 to 2027. Mammoth Lakes is included within the Mono County region for the allocation. The arena for all of Mono County is 240 units. That number is then broken.

2:46:54 Further broken out based on where the population's located and where that future demand will be. So based on that, it's determined that 64.6 of the RHNA is allocated to Mammoth Lakes and 35.4% is allocated to unincorporated Mono County. So this top row here just shows the RHNA numbers for Mammoth Lakes. And then the subsequent rows show how many permits.

2:47:22 And then, as shown here, there were, sorry, my Zoom screen's in the way, 102 units received permits all in 2019, 2020. All those were for above moderate units, above moderate income units, meaning there's no income restriction. However, when we get to 2021, it's anticipated that

2:47:50 91 units will be permitted that fall either in extremely low, very low, or low income categories. So that includes the 80 affordable units from the parcel. The one additional unit that's the manager's unit will fall in the above moderate category because it's not deed restricted. Then the 11 one bedroom low income units, that's the 238 Sierra Manor Road project.

2:48:16 So that permit was submitted in 2020, and we anticipate it being issued this year. So we obviously can't count these units on the official progress report given to the state. I included it here just to show that there is some anticipated success on the arena for this coming year. And then obviously shown here, this is the moderate where we definitely need to get some more units permitted.

2:48:44 In this area, however, as the next slide show, I think it kind of highlights difficulties with moderate income category. So I brought this graphic from my counterpart up in Truckee, and I believe she borrowed it from Mountain Housing Council of Tahoe, Truckee. I find it really informative to show just how units, the kind of spectrum of units from affordable low income to moderate to above middle income, and how those units are built.

2:49:15 So the 102 above moderate units in 2019-2020 fall on this spectrum over here, the upper middle income, meaning there's no state and federal funds needed. Usually there's no subsidy needed to build those units. It's just market rate. Whereas the 91 affordable units fall on the opposite end of the spectrum. I mean, they're typically built using state or federal grant dollars. So that's where you see housing types such as rental units, which is what we're seeing.

2:49:42 For the parcel on 238 Sierra Manor Road. And then in the middle here is the moderate to middle income, which is a tricky category because state and federal funds aren't eligible to fund units in this category because the income levels are too high. But the cost to develop units in this range exceed what the homeowner can support. So there's still a subsidy needed. So that's really where local funding's needed to close that funding gap.

2:50:12 Which is some of related to the discussion tonight to direct some funding towards that kind of income category. No, I'm sorry to interrupt, but is it fair to say that that what you've just illustrated is the missing middle that everybody talks so much about? That is exactly the missing middle. Good. Thank you. Thanks. It's a great graphic. Thanks for sharing that.

2:50:34 So this next chart is just showing what kind of preservation of deed restricted units. These aren't new units built over the last four years. These are existing deed restricted units where either through use of the town or Mono County revolving loan fund or stewardship by Mammoth Lakes Housing to match up an eligible homeowner with a unit that's being sold. Then also the bottom row are units that were purchased by the town in 2019.

2:51:04 These two units were previously deed restricted units. I believe 200% AMI. The deed restrictions were lost during the 2008 downturn because there wasn't available funding then to purchase and preserve those units. However, should the town choose in the future to sell those units or use them in another capacity, we could place a new deed restriction on those units prior to selling them.

2:51:32 So just here, yeah, over the last four years, three units have been preserved with the revolving loan fund, and seven units have been kind of a direct homeowner to homeowner sale through that stewardship by MLH. So moving on to just kind of the town housing work programs and the items that I've been either working on over the last year, year and a half, and then working on planning on the future.

2:52:03 So partial development, building permit for phase one is expected to be issued in this year, if not this summer, that will be moving forward. Grant administration, that's really just working through the CDBG, HOME, BEGIN and other grants with state agencies and then working with our sub-recipients to make sure those funds are going out and all the reporting and compliance requirements are being met.

2:52:31 Also looking at the ADU incentive program. So with the adoption of all the updated ADU standards and the opinion that ADUs can provide a fairly easy solution to increase the number of units in the community. We're looking at how to incentivize development of those. So that will be a work program item coming back. But some of the items likely to be included in that incentive program is

2:53:00 Financial incentives for actually restricting the ADU as a due restricted rental unit. Pre-approved plans for ADUs. We're currently working with Mono County. They're also working to have pre-approved plans using some of their grant funding, and those plans will be available to the town for town use as well. Whether it is improved fee waivers or fee reductions on the building permit side. And then one last area is

2:53:28 The development standard incentives beyond what the state's already allowed for. So this can be done either outright for ADUs or through an adjustment process that provides certain reductions for just the ADU portion. Then item four is the housing element, the housing action plan implementation. We'll be bringing back a much detailed discussion on this in September 2021, so I won't.

2:53:56 Get too deep into it here. The next one is that portable housing portfolio. When I took on the position of housing coordinator, we knew we had many units out there that had received down payment assistance, but there was no real comprehensive database of where those units were, how much money was loaned, when the money's repaid, if there's interest. So that I've put together, I'd say it's probably 90% complete of a comprehensive portfolio.

2:54:25 For all the town, the units of the town's a party too. Then going forward, we'll be working to ensure compliance and ongoing compliance of all those town monitored units. Next item is the annual housing reporting to the state. State on either grant funded projects and then just on housing development requires a number of different reports that they, to keep us on our toes, like to change annually what they're asking for.

2:54:54 So part of it is trying to identify how we can track that data to streamline that reporting, and then also how can we track that data to inform future policy decisions, which I think touches on John's comment earlier to Rob about the GIS database. So that's still on the radar to put all the data in there. Part of it's just...

2:55:20 What data we want to track, identifying that, and then going out and saying, okay, what are the different metrics used to track that data or at least flag that data so we can record it accurately. One issue on the one we talked about earlier was just mainly on the long-term rental side, identifying where those are. That's something that will definitely need to be focused on and talked about how to do that. The next item is ongoing coordination with Mayor of Fixed Housing.

2:55:48 So as through their contract and just as a partner in the community, making sure that our work isn't, we're not doing duplicative work that one can do versus the other. The next one is just an ongoing work program item is zoning code amendments related to housing. Currently, we don't have any zoning code amendments in the queue. The ones we've recently completed include the town density bonus program update, ADU regulations update.

2:56:18 The housing mitigation credit valuation. The next kind of work program item related to that, that won't be a zoning code amendment necessarily, but will be the housing update piece. Then the last two are really just high level ones of inquiries from potential developers who are either wanting to use the density bonus to get more units or on the other side, someone who's wanting to come in and actually just build affordable housing.

2:56:47 Helping them with the entitlement process to get through it so they can actually get built. Item 10 is staying up to date on all the housing bills and what's changing, what's coming down the pipeline as far as from the state. Moving into the housing funding sources. So the column on the left is either town general fund dollars or quasi unrestricted funds, meaning they

2:57:17 It came to us through either grant or some other program, but we can essentially once we've completed the grant requirements and been repaid by the state, we can choose or Town Council can direct to keep that money in the housing fund rather than repaying the general fund. So Senate Bill 2 is kind of one of those quasi unrestricted fund amounts. It's $160,000 provided by Senate Bill 2. That's a $75 recording fee that

2:57:46 It gets paid for all real estate documents. So we applied for that money for the conceptual land use planning for the parcel. The state has since repaid that money. So we've completed all of our grant requirements. So that's one of those where we can choose to keep it in the housing reserve rather than moving into the general fund. Next one's the LEAP grant. That's $65,000.

2:58:11 Again, we applied for that funding to fund the master planning work for the parcel. We've been awarded that grant dollars, but we haven't been repaid by the state. We're still waiting for our standard agreement from them. The in-lieu housing payments, that's the one I touched on earlier. That's about $230,000 of unrestricted or undedicated money.

2:58:35 Yeah, Nolan, let me interrupt you real quick on that. Those first couple of items there for the council, we'll come back to that as a policy question, but as we receive dollars back from the various housing elements where we've put up general fund money on the front end to do work, as mentioned there on the parcel in this case, or other types of planning projects that we'll end up doing in the future, the direction at this point has been as we get that reimbursement back is not to really pay it back into the general fund at this portion at this point in time, but to actually put that and retain it.

2:59:04 In that housing reserve, that fund 245. And so those funds continue to get recycled back into the housing program versus shifted back over for other priorities or other elements within the general fund. And that's been kind of an ongoing policy direction at my level to staff as those dollars have come back in. And that'll be down the road a little bit later this evening. We'll be looking for confirming that policy direction by the council to continue to do that. And then also, as Noah mentioned, the revolving loan fund.

2:59:33 Our goal is there is to maintain that $600,000 level and to do that out of our housing in lieu revenues as they come in. As noted on the slide, we're about $35,000 short in that fund, give or take. And so we want to be able to make sure that we retain that level. That fund has been very critical in not losing deed restricted units. So those types of elements where we get those dollars back and we keep them up.

2:59:58 Yeah, Mark, for those purposes, anything that would have gone back to the general fund being directed back into the housing fund? I understand. So yeah, he just touched on the revolving loan fund piece there. The town funds, as noted, were about $35,000 short due to a subsidy that was required for the last RLF purchase unit in order to reduce the deed restriction down from 200% to 120% that required about $35,000.

3:00:28 The next one, the HELP loan repayments. This was a grant program that was in place in 2005 and 2007. There's home buyer assistance that provided 30-year deferred payment loans. However, the grant did require repayment to the state after a period of 10 years. So at that 10-year mark, the state notified us of how many of those outstanding loans had been repaid, meaning that we got the money and we had remitted it to the state.

3:00:56 And then the town, using a combination of in lieu, fee funds, and general fund dollars, paid the remaining balance to the state there by satisfying all of our state requirements for that grant. However, at that time, there's still a number of outstanding loans out there. Since that time, four additional loans have been repaid to the town with a valuation of about $235,000.

3:01:24 Some of that was prior to the parcel purchase, so 131,000 of that went to the purchase of the parcel, and then the remaining 105,000 that has since been repaid remains available for other future housing program purposes. Again, that's one of those policy questions Dan had mentioned were at the council's discretion that can remain available in the housing reserves or be repaid back to the general fund. It's also important.

3:01:51 Important to note that there is at least five additional outstanding loans out there to help loans with a valuation of approximately $272,000. However, it's unknown when those loans would be repaid. The deadline for repayment is not until 2036 and 2038. So that would be the latest that it would be repaid. But if a homeowner either sells or refinances or choose to repay it sooner, they can do so.

3:02:19 Then the last piece is the Creative Housing Fund. This is the originally $2 million that Town Council had set aside in fiscal year 1920. We had used $600,000 to purchase the two units on Meridian Court. And then this is what's remaining there in that fund. On the other side, we have the federal and state restricted funds. I didn't put dollar amounts in here because it's...

3:02:43 Constantly evolving with depending which grants are active, which grants and which grants have been closed out. And also these dollars are very restricted in that we have to call all the federal and state guidelines. They can only be used for the approved activities that were included in those grant applications. And any area if we find that we're not in compliance, then we potentially would have to repay those funds back to the state or back to the federal government.

3:03:13 So on the CDBG, we currently have the Homebuyer Assistance and Rehab Grant. We had the closeout hearing earlier tonight. We have CARES Act funds that are being used for mortgage and utility assistance. And then we've applied for the $3 million for 238 Sierra Manor Road and the $500,000 for homebuyer assistance. On the home grant side, we have...

3:03:37 Our current 2016 grant, that's also being, expenditure deadline is July 31st as well, so that one's being closed out currently. And then the state has indicated to us that the NOFA, the 2021 home NOFA will be out, it's supposed to be every month, so we expect to be there in August or September.

3:04:00 But also that it's going to be a two-year NOFA, meaning to combine the 2020 and 2021 fund allocations into one NOFA. So it's going to be higher amounts that we are eligible to apply for. So at this point, we've been told we'll be eligible to apply for a million dollars, but we'll see once that NOFA comes out if that's the case. On the housing fund commitment side, this is your dollars that have been committed to housing projects.

3:04:28 So we've committed $1,000,000 to Tavern Road improvements related to the parcel. We've committed $101,000 to moderate income loan program. This would provide two first-time homebuyer loans to homebuyers at the 120% AMI. So that's that missing middle area of that chart. That's the area to meet. Then committed $300,000 to Mammoth Lakes Housing 238 Sierra Manor Road project.

3:04:59 So now I'm going to pass it on to Sandra to talk about this slide. Thanks, Nolan. Yeah, Dan and you, Nolan kind of hit on some of these items, but just recapping our general plan housing elements versus the community housing action plan. You know, the general plan housing element, it's our legal framework for our housing program, and it is reviewed by the California Department of Housing and Community Development, HCD.

3:05:28 And they do assign, as Noah mentioned previously, a review period, this implementation period for this sixth cycle is 2019 to 2027. So we will be looking to update the housing element probably starting 2026 for the intent of having it completed in 2027. That's a little bit different than the Community Housing Action Plan, which is really, you know, we talked about it previously when it was adopted.

3:05:56 The Community Housing Action Plan gave us the ability to look at a housing program that wasn't really tied to this legal framework that's assigned to us by the state. This was a little bit more creative. A lot of the discussion in the chat was about, you know, it's not a hard and fast document. It's intended to be, you know, fluid and change as conditions change. And as we all mentioned, we'll be bringing that back. We'll be bringing that back to town council on September 1st.

3:06:25 for review discussion and kind of just to check in on where we are with that program. So Nolan, I think you can go to the next slide at this point. Yeah, so the last slide is really just the council discussion and direction policy questions that are in the staff report. I'm not sure if council and or Dan prefer to keep the slide up or if we wanna bring it back so everyone can see who's talking and open up the discussion.

3:06:55 Thank you, Nolan. I'll kind of lead this off. I think you can drop the slide down if you look at the tail end of the staff report there. It's in there versus trying to read the slide and listen to people talk on that. So the...

3:07:09 As we dive into this, we look at a lot of the direction related to the use of money and the funding of that. Just before we touch on that, I was going to note the staff report, we walked through the whole Measure A question in terms of, we referenced that. It's a couple of different ballot questions that we referred to as, I think it started in 1996 A and then a...

3:07:28 2002A and then 2006 Measure T, I think it was at that point. So a reference Measure A, it goes back to ballot questions where the TOT was increased. All of those ballot measures were general taxes. None of them had any absolute expenditure requirements in there. So we referred to that, though, through the process that went into approving those things was through the political commitments.

3:07:55 The council members at the time made those commitments is helping to get those ballot measures passed and how they would be allocated accordingly. And that was done through that process. And then there's kind of an outline of those changes and items attached to the staff report. I will walk through all of those. The other major change came with the bankruptcy filing by the town and the airport litigation and the final settlement on that.

3:08:22 Which cost the town about $2.1 million annually, $2 million in a debt payment, and then over a million dollars in the annual operating revenue for the airport that was lost through that process and or that negotiated settlement of that lawsuit. So those things were there. That resulted in a substantial change to how Major A dollars were allocated.

3:08:45 The housing piece of that really took the brunt of that change, although all the various areas that were committed to lost revenues. And then in 1718, there was an effort to go back and restore some of the housing funds and modify a lot of the work done in the balancing through the lawsuit settlement process. And I mentioned that on purpose, a little bit on that, just to understand there's been a lot of moving parts there.

3:09:10 But the other side to that was in the settlement process and coming back and the long-term planning the town did financially. The planning at the time was focused on getting through that and a lot of heavy lifting and work done there. But actually there was no planning in there to actually reinstate or go back to any of the previous commitments for housing transit or tourism in those areas. So that's been kind of a...

3:09:38 Moving elements a little bit, we came back in 17-18, did that work, making a shift again, shifting some money back into the TOT side for housing, making some modifications in transit and tourism at that time as well. More details on that as a council may wish there through that. And so really we came back and looked at the...

3:10:03 Program before you tonight and looking at some of the housing issues. I want to walk through some of the core recommendations and really talk about some upcoming projects that we've identified in funding for those projects. So at this point, one of our key elements would be as we look at that direction from those funds as no one's walked through the SB2 fund, the LEAP funds, HELP funds, there's a category of those dollars that have come back.

3:10:30 To the town to reimburse us from various things. The direction has been to move those funds into a housing reserve and that fund 245 so we can utilize it for those things.

3:10:43 First is repaying the general funding, putting those dollars back into a general fund account. I would think that makes a lot of sense as those dollars have been utilized on the housing side and continue to utilize it that way as long as we're able to from a financial standpoint, that recommendation. We've been following that and doing that. That would be kind of the first policy discussion in the direction as we are repaid dollars that we expand, especially in that planning work and those types of elements that can be reimbursed.

3:11:13 That those reimbursements really go back into that fund as we look to the future. I'm going to pause after each one of these items just if there are any council questions related to them. We'll get into some more detail. Kind of goes, I think, from some easy policy direction to the more difficult ones. But as we have those types of funds, I guess the question that council would be, is there any concerns with the way we've been managing those and directing them back into the housing programs? Thank you, Dan.

3:11:41 And I'm assuming you're just looking for some sort of consensus from Council here. Yeah, in that direction, that would be fine, yes. Right, so if you want to tell him during your comments. So let's start with Linda. Dan, as we move through these seven items, as we speak about each of them, will you just remind us of the amount of money in each of them, roughly, we're speaking about? Yeah, the first one, that SB2 in the LEAP funds, I think it's about $120,000, a little over that, in terms of dollars.

3:12:10 That have been committed there. We're waiting on another $65,000 coming in. May have that off just a little bit in there. We got $200 and some. We got $160 out of SB2, $65,000, I think, from the LEAP that's coming. And the HELP grant, I think there's $105 that's remaining there. So those dollars would be back into that fund. Okay, thank you.

3:12:36 Excuse me, Mayor Sauser, did you want to do each one of these individually and give direction or do them as a whole or? My request as we walk through them, we just get direction as we go and then if there's any particular motion at the end that we may want, we can come back to that. Yeah, did you give your comments if you just tell them whether you're in favor of putting the money back into that fund or not? Yeah, so I would be in favor of continuing to fund them. Thank you, Linda. John?

3:13:04 Yes, I'm in favor. It sounds to me, Dan, for some quick math, it's about $300,000 that would go into Fund 245. I'm going to make sort of a general request that we're done with all this, that we brand this fund or give it a name to the public. This is a lot of bureaucratic gobbledygook. No aspersions being cast. So that it's clear.

3:13:32 I know you'll come back to us at the next meeting with kind of what the dollar amount you think you can do, but if this is whatever you guys want to call it, the town's housing program, the town's housing investment, so that we as council members can have clear and easily understandable conversations with constituents. So yeah, I certainly support not repaying the general fund, taking this approximately $300,000 and putting it into for this evening's conversation into 245s. Thank you.

3:14:01 And just a reminder, the funds have been placed there, so they've been in that fund, so the direction to leave them there, I guess, versus moving them to the general fund. Right. Thank you. Just making sure we're clear on the conversation. Sure. Thank you. Sarah. Yes, I'm also in favor of keeping those in 245. Kirk. Yes, I'm in favor of keeping those funds in the 245. I'm also in favor of

3:14:35 Thank you.

3:15:07 Went through that a while back. You know, we reduced the total fees that were really being charged to like a hotel multifamily type of products. Single family was extremely low. That went up. The other one dropped down fairly dramatically. But we've done one small increase of those here a couple of years ago. We anticipate coming back to you on August 4th looking at the current nexus study, the current housing fee study that has been done.

3:15:34 And there is some room within that study. These fees could be increased. We'd bring that back for consideration. I don't recall the number, the amount that can be done there, but we'd want to bring that back for discussion. And then if the council wants to move forward with that, we would come back to the process on a public hearing to increase that fee accordingly. So it'd be a couple of different bites at the apple, if you will, to review those fees. Then on top of that, we are updating the overall development impact fee program, which would include a

3:16:03 Housing Nexus Fee Study that will not be completed likely until the end of the fiscal year. So it will be a two-step process for that. The other policy question we have there, we utilize those funds. I guess that goes to number three here. We use those funds to maintain our in-lieu fee to maintain our revolving loan fund. We've been trying to maintain that now at $600,000. That went up from $300,000 a few years ago.

3:16:31 And to do that, it's about $35,000 short. Ultimately, that would take an action to move those dollars from that in-lieu fee program into that revolving loan fund. And that is a policy direction going forward. To the extent that that fund gets dropped down for a variety of reasons, that we would automatically continue to backfill that so we maintain that amount of money to secure and preserve need-restricted units. So there's two policy items there related to the in-lieu fee.

3:17:01 The first one being, does Council wish to see a proposal to increase the fee? And then the second one being to use some of the current revenue there to maintain that $600,000 level of funding for the evolving loan fund. Thank you, Dan. Let's reverse the order here and start with Kirk this time. I'm not following the direction. Are we talking about Council policy discussion direction on number two?

3:17:38 We need to have a discussion on in lieu housing fees as well as development impact fees. Those have been substantially changed over the last years. So I think we need more information on both of those as to...

3:17:55 You know, the full impact of the developer impact fees and what are we charging now as well as what the fire district and the water district are charging. So some sort of comps to help bring that forward. So yes, yeah, I'm very much in favor of bringing this, bringing both of those items forward. Thank you, Kirk. Number three.

3:18:22 Yes. Staff is recommending that the in lieu housing fee be used to maintain the 600,000 level in the RLF. Yes. Number four, yes. Number five, yes. Number six. The town manager is slowing me down. Appreciate some enthusiasm. Okay. Then moving up to Sarah. Yeah.

3:18:54 I agree with Kirk. This is a really big priority for me personally is revisiting these impact fees. Is there discussion of making those in lieu housing fees based on square footage as opposed to units, individual unit? There's some elements where some of that has been done in the past a little bit, but the square footage does apply to the non...

3:19:23 Like retail and commercial and things of that nature, there's a square footage calculation. In order for the nexus to work when you talk about a house, something that's being built on a unit standpoint, it gets much more complicated of how you do that for an impact. The square footage and the other commercial type buildings or retail are easier to calculate or more to the norm. To go to a square footage on a home or something, we do go down to a certain level in waive fees on small like ADUs or...

3:19:51 I forget, like, they're a fraction of the cost, for example, for other reasons there in terms of how they're impacted. But you want to be able to have a solid nexus on that or you can be challenged on the fee and that can get to be a very difficult process and you want to be careful that you don't get so creative that you lose the fee completely. So, from a legal challenge, agencies have gone through those. So, it is.

3:20:20 So yes on two and three for me. If we're going to do two and three is kind of a block right now. Thank you. Thank you. Sarah, John? Yes on two and three for me. I would like to understand, Dan, as part of what you're bringing back, what is the max we could go to within the current scale within the diff? Just we have some idea where we're starting from. Go ahead.

3:20:51 I can hit on that really quickly. The maximum for residential would be $8,200 per unit. And right now we're at 6,000. And then the max for lodging would be $9,300 per room. And right now we're at 4,000. So that's just within the existing Nexus study. We wouldn't have to do a new Nexus study. It has to go through a process. But then, you know, as Dan mentioned, we'll be bringing back kind of a comprehensive look at our diff fees and our housing fees in the next year or so.

3:21:20 Yeah, what I would like to do is to work within the parameters that we have adopted right now so we don't have to wait six months or a year to do all that stuff. We need to do it anyway. Kirk, I certainly understand we need to look at all that stuff. But working with them, what we've got, let's take a look at that and let's interest in staff's recommendation. But let's go higher on that for sure with what's already available. Yeah, because we have these big developments coming up and I don't want to dilly-dally.

3:21:49 And have people trying to get these through while the fees are still low. Does that make sense? Correct. Yeah, so the first bump up would come back to you for a final direction on the fourth. We'll have the numbers there. Then we have to do a public hearing process. So we want to be able to do that and have that done correctly to put those fees in place. That would happen within the next 30 to 60 days as there's a process we have to follow.

3:22:19 Thank you, Sarah, Linda. So let me clarify for a minute. So the immediate uptick to the fees could be based on our current existing nexus study. And then in the interim between, so what part of 21-22 do you think we could have a new completed nexus study by? It'll be toward the end of the year, end of the fiscal year. So we're looking at almost a year for that. So I mean, as soon as we can put together a new well,

3:22:53 Thought out, you know, defendable nexus study. I'm really anxious to get to that. But we're right, we don't wanna not push this as far as we can and have people try to get in under the wire on that. So I think we should, you know, push that, push immediately and then get the nexus study in and then be willing to switch it again because those are important landmarks for us to get done. So yes, I'm in favor of both two and three at this present time. Thank you, Linda.

3:23:25 So I am in favor of bringing this back to us for discussion. We always, you know, are open for discussion. And on the other two, yeah, sure, sounds good. And before I go further on that, do we have any public input on the first two pieces? This is Mayor John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just have some clarity questions that I wanted to ask.

3:24:02 Back in 2017-18 when we had the recalibration of the Measure A budgets from Mammoth Lakes Tourism for quote-unquote housing, where are those funds accounted for? On the housing funding slide, you know, the creative housing fund I thought might be where that might live, but I don't see that. Going from the 2.5 points...

3:24:23 of TOT to 2.35 points of TOT has been roughly $200,000 a year. So that's about $800,000 that should be in a housing fund somewhere, whether it's this fund 245. And then back in 2018-19, the MLT board made the recommendation that the Tourism Reserve moving forward for at least four years would be recommended to go to housing.

3:24:46 This year alone, that's over $900,000. Last year, which was a very impacted COVID year, was $450,000. And 2018-19 was a $1.3 million amount. So it's about $2.65 million. And then my last question is, I saw that it sounded like Nolan mentioned that the Creative Housing Fund was $2 million. And I think in the board packet, it looked like it was from overages from this year, where we exceeded TOT by $5 million.

3:25:15 So I guess if it's $2 million from this year, we've exceeded TOT the last, well, with the exception of last year, we've only exceeded it by $2.5 million. We've been exceeding it by about $5 million a year. And I guess the question is, are there other places where previous years' overages are stored, or is it on that $245 fund? That's one question. So, Dan, you want to take that on, or you want me to attempt it?

3:25:48 I can address some of that as pretty straightforward. I mean, the overage of TOT in general, it's kind of a very broad generalization as every year and actually each quarter we bring things forward in terms of our overall budget, whether it be TOT or property tax or savings and operations, those funds are allocated out by council. That has gone to a variety of housing elements. We looked at the purchase of the parcel. That was as...

3:26:17 About $7.5 million of general fund money that went into that. $1 million committed to future capital in there on Tavern Road Works, so that's sitting in a capital fund. $300,000 that we set aside is still set aside for housing for 238-30 Manor Road, for example.

3:26:37 And so there's a lot of dollars in there. Part of that, some of those funds that came for the purchase have been repaid. Some of that came out of our road fund, for example, with general fund dollars. And it also pretty much zeroed out or close to zeroing out some of our town reserves. And some of that has been repaid out of those additional dollars over time. We have to walk back through all the detail on that. There's been other capital investments made, obviously, as priorities and reimbursement in our parks and those types of things.

3:27:05 Savings and or additional revenues come into the town. The creative housing component of that, we set aside $2 million. We spent about $670,000 on the two units that we purchased. There's about 1.3 left in there. That was then utilized for COVID. Those dollars went into the COVID response elements and that was utilized for direct response cost as well as some of those dollars utilized for our...

3:27:33 Housing Rental Assistance Program and other dollars utilized for the business assistance program. A portion of the TOT excess out of tourism was also used in that business assistance program. We'd have to walk through the detail of the dollars looped around in those areas.

3:27:53 I believe the current balance in the TOT reserves is about $1.8 million. Those are still sitting in that reserve as we do. We have not asked Council to commit those to a particular housing project. That's one of the discussions this evening. So those are still identified there. There has been some expenditure out of those over time.

3:28:14 Some years back, I won't go into detail there, not huge dollar amounts, but things have been committed out of those, which we're tracking accordingly. It's that 1.8 or so is the current net number estimated coming out of the end of this year.

3:28:28 The other side of that has been within the MLH side and some housing. We've had additional funding out of there. We've had additional staff funding to come into all those different things. There are detailed lists. We can give that. We've presented them to the council in the past in terms of where savings of dollars have gone over time the last several years.

3:28:50 The current balance, for example, in the housing fund itself that we have would be $800,000, the tourism, I mentioned about $1.8. The creative housing fund, if you will, or that innovative housing fund is sitting about $1.7 million and another $400,000 on top of that of restricted revenue based on some of the grant stuff. So there is a fair amount of dollars in each of those. $200,000 was recently committed to

3:29:19 Thank you. Thank you.

3:29:37 Down payment program for missing middle. We've done some other things of that nature as well as you walk through the housing element. But not every single dollar that's been saved in the general fund that's been gone to housing. There are dollars in there that have gone to capital investment. There has been dollars going to the town reserves. There's dollars going for other commitments the town has that we look at that. And those dollars that are in there is a combination of all our revenues and our expenditures and balanced out accordingly.

3:30:05 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

3:30:33 If you look at some of the other elements, there's a lot of other pieces of where dollars have been allocated over time and what's dropped to different areas that is in there that we could walk through as well. If you wish to have us spend the time and pull all that detail together, that's very doable. Thank you, Dan. I'm going to answer this a little myself. Rob brings us quarterly reports on how we're doing, and we finish the year in a quarter after the next year begins.

3:31:02 Each time there are excess funds to a certain point, the council allocates them to what the needs are, that is housing, that is maintenance, that is a whole lot of things. And that would be the time to bring forward any questions on how we're spending it, not three years after the fact. So anybody that wants to keep up on how we do our budgeting and where the money goes is welcome to any of that information at the time we deal with it.

3:31:29 I would not look forward to seeing staff spending a whole lot of time pulling out specifics that were given to us back when these decisions were made. Thank you. That's my speech for the night. Sorry. Any more public on those first two items? Mr. Mayor, if I may, I think the question that I had was not to bring up previous years here, but to ask for when the...

3:31:57 Budget was recalibrated in 2017-18. It was spelled out to us that those dollars were going to housing, and I just want to make sure that those are in a housing fund somewhere. So that's what I'm asking for, so that I can understand that the commitment from MLT back to the town, which has been fairly substantial over the last four years, is in fact going into that fund. If the council doesn't decide to use the tourism reserve funds,

3:32:24 That have been set aside for the last three years at 2.6 million to go towards housing, then maybe housing is not that big of a problem. I think that would be very irresponsible. If our board has said we have this pot of money and we want to see it 100% go towards housing and it's not being utilized, I think that's irresponsible. Yeah, thank you, John. However, they are not tourism dollars. They are town dollars that we then fund tourism with. I don't want to get into that argument here and now.

3:32:55 Thank you. Moving on then. Dan, or Sandra, whoever's bringing up the next. Yeah, the other item four we have listed there is very similar to the first one, just on the HELP funds going back into the general, versus any repayment of those HELP loans would go back into a housing fund versus back into the general fund. That's a pretty basic one, similar to the first items that we could address there. Then we'll have some other items of allocation of dollars for programs.

3:33:31 Okay, Linda. Pretty straightforward again. Yeah, I would agree completely. Thank you. John? Yes. Sarah? Yes. Kirk? Yes, but going back to the public comment, I think we need to get some sort of summary of how these dollars have been allocated. Well, we did just recently get a history of the different

3:34:06 Advisory votes that had been passed. So, you know, yes, but in the same respect, I want to address the public comment, and I think we need a summary of the overages for the last couple of years. Thank you. Kirk, you're right. I agree. It would be good to be able to see a flow chart because we're better able to defend ourselves if we can see that.

3:34:36 I can assure anyone listening that since I have been on council, I have been aware of every bit of TOT overreach and where it went. I have seen multiple documents spelling that out in detail. I think the solution to that is to have the, you know, pull one of those out and just put it out there because it is very clear.

3:35:04 Very well thought through. No question where every cent of that excess TOT has been. We've been schooling it many times and it's very easy to access. So if that's the question, that's the easy part. Thank you, Linda. And yes, I agree with moving this housing fund. Dan, thank you. The next item, Mr. Mayor, I think it was everybody, really deals with as we move into items five, six, and seven, we're looking at and we can...

3:35:37 At the end of this, I was assuming coming back with public comment and broader issues and other elements as well. But the first one there is that we recently acquired, or will be closing on it this week, a parcel of 60 Joaquin, that parcel about a quarter acre. We've looked at that as the option, as that came forward, looking to do, I'll say, a four to six unit affordable housing project. We'll look at trying to maximize that into the six units.

3:36:03 A real rough kind of order of magnitude cost of that is probably, you know, $3 million. It's very rough. That may be a little high, a little low, depending on what we ultimately build in terms of scope and size and obviously construction cost. And so if that's a priority, as the council expressed in terms of authority to go buy that property, those dollars are coming out of that housing fund, the 245 fund. And then...

3:36:29 Really getting to work on the planning and the design work and then figuring out, you know, the bidding process and stuff of that nature to actually build it. This would be a, you know, public works project so it'd have a little bit of process that way, some additional costs just prevailing wages and those types of elements for projects of this type of work.

3:36:48 So that would be a request on that is beginning to identify $3 million really to be able to move that forward. And again, as we get into the project, that may move up or down a little. It would come back accordingly. But that would be the first target amount. That's looking at about $500,000 a unit from, you know, all the design work, planning work, any type of utility work, and then into the construction of the facility.

3:37:15 The goal there would be in all of these areas for housing. Hopefully we're able to be able to move these forward relatively quickly, meaning within the next, say, 12 to 24 months that we would start to have something coming out of the ground in these areas in addition to the parcel working moving forward. So that would be the first one. If you want me to hit, I could hit these three project areas and you can talk to them as a group if you wish. Dan, let's do them individually like we had originally talked.

3:37:47 We'll get through them pretty quick unless I get long-winded for some reason, which could happen. So the $3 million towards our new acquisition, Lynda. Absolutely. I mean, this is why the Creative Housing Fund was developed last year when we put that money aside to buy those two condo units. That's what it was for. This money will move us into actually design and construction.

3:38:16 Of that piece of property we just bought. I think that brings us five or six units. That was how staff was directed by council. So yes. Thank you, Linda. John? Yes. Sarah? Yes. Was that a yes? You're sitting close enough to Dan, you can kick him. I want to tell you how excited I am by this project. The millions upon millions of dollars we have spent in housing over the last 10 years, and it is way up there.

3:38:52 If we allocate these funds now, the potential is by the end of next summer, we could have six new units, our first actual units of housing on the ground. And that just excites me no end. Rather than planning and the other things we've been involved in, this, boy, this is where I'm coming from. So obviously, yes. Thank you.

3:39:20 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. The next item really deals with ongoing work and efforts with private sector development. We've had two or three different individuals approach the town on how can we work with them in enhancing the amount of affordable housing in the community. I'll note the amount above in this one, ultimately the council policy in terms of how we target that for income limits, whether that missing middle was talked about earlier.

3:39:46 In working with some of the private sector side of that, there's been a lot of interest in how do they help in that area, truly seeing housing as a need in our community. One particular project that came for about six units.

3:40:00 Again, with the question being to build those and put them out on a market rate, they're going to be a $500,000 and up type of a market. The question there was looking at the buying of a deed restriction once those projects come forward to have that option so we can come in and help buy down the value of the unit with somebody in terms of putting a deed restriction on it so if somebody could afford a...

3:40:26 Say a $300,000 loan, you come back in and you put a $200,000 deed restriction purchase or whatever that would require to close the gap, then that deed restriction would be perpetual. So it's not something that's just a period of time, pay the loan back and then we lose it. The idea is how do we set these up? And this would be an ownership standpoint where you can actually retain that deed restricted unit into the future.

3:40:50 Ideally forever, so to speak, but for the long haul of saying these now starts to address that missing middle program. And to have some of the private sector folks come in and really look at this and say, how do we partner with the town effectively to bring these types of options forward actually has been a real positive thing to see. And I know a couple cases, if they really can't do that and partner with the town, they really don't have an interest in doing the market rate, although they could.

3:41:19 But they don't see that as a high need within the community, so it's not something that some individuals are excited to go do because they're not trying to do it just from a pure, you know, market-driven development. They're really looking at it going, we believe the town needs this type of development. It needs this type of affordable housing. And how can we participate together ultimately in a program that we help fund?

3:41:44 And then if we do go down that road and it doesn't work, they have the option to sell them at market rate, and so the risk is relatively low on the private sector side. But the idea here would be if you look at about a six-unit or so project, more and a half million committed to that for up to like $250,000 or so per unit if that's what it takes to buy down to get the deed restrictions in place.

3:42:09 Obviously, this will take some work in terms of the actual cost of the units and what would be that market component. One of the elements of these is we have a program in either center or no one can speak this more detail. If people get a double density on that by restricting their units, additional units to the workforce, but not AMI restricted. Our goal would be to go in and buy that down to an AMI.

3:42:35 Basically that area median income restriction on all six units, not just on the additional units that would go into a project. And if I've got the zoning incorrect there, Nolan or Sandra? No, I think that summarizes it exactly what we're looking at. There's obviously challenges and legal hoops we have to jump through to get there, but I think we can get there, hopefully. Thank you.

3:43:02 So the idea here would be to set aside that pot of money to really begin to work with the private sector side and say how do we bring these units again online and relatively quickly. In some cases they own land and they're really waiting more for how can we work together versus just doing it as a true private sector developer. Thank you. Dan, if I might comment, I mean, what are we looking at as far as AMI on these? I mean, is that an open-ended? Yeah, 120 and under.

3:43:34 Maybe that missing middle. 20 and under? Yeah. So it starts with that hitting that missing middle component. Okay. Kirk, any others? Go ahead and make it. Bill, we couldn't hear you. You were talking off mic there. Well, darn that mic. I'll have to teach him better. Kirk, you started comments. You may as well go ahead with any other comments on this item and whether you approve of it or not. I approve moving forward. And as long as it's brought back to council. Thank you. Kirk, Sarah? Yes, I approve.

3:44:19 John? We're on number six now, is that correct? That is correct. Yes, I approve. Yes, I support. Linda? Yes, absolutely. As for me, I approve as well with the restriction as Kirk placed it, that each project that this may or may not refer to will come back to council so we can determine the cost effectiveness thereof.

3:44:48 Versus potentially buying more land with the same amount and building more and all of those things just so that we can, you know, ferret them out. But partnering with the public to build the things we need when they are more expensive than public can build on their own, I think it's a great idea. So thank you. And Mr. Mayor, just a little clarification on that. If the town's doing it, these projects are prevailing wage projects. And I think if there's a way to work with the private sector to get units,

3:45:19 To your point that they don't have to be built or developed at prevailing wage, again, there's legal stuff to figure out, but there's something to be mindful of. No, it's kind of an open question as to whether buying a deed restriction in connection with new construction would be deemed a subsidy to the project. I've had this discussion with Nolan's counterpart in Truckee, and I think that if that's something that is going to be pursued, we would probably need to request an opinion from the state.

3:45:47 The labor people at DIR as to whether that would trigger it or not. It's pretty clear that buying restriction that is on an existing structure, no problem. There's no constructions. There's no prevailing wage angle. But if somebody really is constructing something new and we're handing them money, even if we're buying something for the money, we need to understand how DIR would view that. And those things, Andy, they can take up to six months to get those opinions, correct?

3:46:16 They try to be a little faster than that, but it can take a bit. So if that's something that we should look at, then we would need to request that from them. And probably sooner rather than later, just so we know what the answer is before you're too far down the road. Yeah, so as part of whatever approval is for that item, let's proceed that right away. Yeah, since this item is being approved, Andy, I would assume that that is an important thing for you to take on. Yeah.

3:46:46 Ultimately, we have to look at what does the agreement look like with the private sector side and how much we're committing or letting them sell it on the open market. Definitely look into those. The last item here really deals with the partnership we have with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Council is aware of the work that they're doing at 238 Sierra Manor Road for 11 units. We talked about that a bit earlier in the report.

3:47:15 The town has committed $300,000 to that project to assist already. The request here would be for an additional $1.2 million, which would bring the total contribution to $1.5 million. You have a write-up in the packet that walks through the background information on that related to the project that has been prepared by Patricia Robertson at MLH and looked at that, how do we move that forward. This is kind of a critical...

3:47:43 Item for supporting this at this point. I believe they have a meeting on Friday with the state to talk about outstanding grants. And as they begin to show the ability to close the potential gap on the construction estimate, it definitely helps them with the state discussion on moving their grant applications to the next phase in terms of that approval process that we hope would be coming forward from the HCD for the...

3:48:11 Rehabilitation, basically, of the existing property there and moving it into that element. So the request here would be the additional $1.2 million bringing the total talent commitment to $1.5 million in partnership with MLH. Thank you, Dan. Linda. Let me try to get this question out where it makes any sense. So if MLH were successful in getting the other grant that they are pursuing, we give them the other $1.2 million.

3:48:44 Will that fill the gap completely? And if it overfills the gap that the first people paid back for that is back into the town, either Fund 245 or Creative Housing Fund, whatever it is, does that make any sense? Yeah, I think what we've looked at, I think as we get these dollars, there's still a gap there. They've identified a number of ways to close it. It's getting close again until we get approval from the state and they get the next step on their re-

3:49:12 Thank you so much.

3:49:34 Those types of issues? By a tree or two to plan. I mean, I'm just saying that I want that to be recognized that if there is... Yeah, there's a number of different funding sources going into this, so, but it's, and this here would truly be 11, you know, affordable, very affordable, low and very low, I believe, apartments. But yes, I'm in favor of this. Thank you, Linda. John.

3:50:07 Yeah, I support this. And Dan, just to be clear, this funding is intended to fill that financing gap that's going to make the project viable. Correct. It gets it a lot closer to being completely filled. I feel depending on your cost estimate, there is a little bit of a gap still. But we don't know what that really looks like as yet. All right. If the gap gets either bigger or smaller, to Linda's point, you'll come back to us and let us tell us what's happening.

3:50:37 Correct. We want to get it done and we don't want to just make another commitment. Oh, the gap got bigger and all that kind of stuff. So, yeah, I support it. I think Mr. Mayor Patricia's got her hand up. I don't know if you want to call on her yet or if you want to wait until we get through this. Yeah, I have no problem with that. Patricia? Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. A little. Thank you. I just raised my hand so that I could answer.

3:51:07 Councilmember Salcido's question about does this completely fill the gap? And we are, with this contribution, we'll be about 75% of the way there. We're currently working on compiling 18 separate funding sources, which is an average of 550,000 per funding source. And so this project really represents, you know, the cobbling together of resources from the entire community. And so,

3:51:37 I'm still working on that outstanding 25%. I have sources identified and conversations are underway, but it's a work in progress. And Patricia, you guys are also looking at doing some redos to bring costs down on the project, as I understand, correct? Yes, can you still hear me? Yeah. Yes, absolutely. Yeah, we're working with our architects to try to bring the costs down about 5% to 10%, which will help fill the gap as well. Thank you.

3:52:15 Sarah. Mayor Sauser, in addition, I received an email from Emily Bryant that says, hello, counsel. I am a regular watcher of Rob's budget presentations quarterly, and I would not agree that where the excess money is spent has been clear during those presentations, as stated by Mayor Sauser. I would appreciate the counsel agendizing a specific item to go through this in more detail. I think it would be great.

3:52:40 It would greatly help the public to have a more digestible breakdown of these funds. I appreciate the town manager summarizing the best he can, but I am now more confused. Were funds saved for housing used on COVID expenditures? Thanks. Thank you. Sarah? Yes, I'm in support of this. Kirk? Yes. I am in support of this as well and look forward to, you know, future...

3:53:17 Thank you very much.

3:53:51 I'll say a mix of housing from rental affordable to moderate missing middle, if you will, ownership type housing components. So a fair amount in that. We can walk through the dollars in there that is in our housing community development fund, the regular housing fund as well. We do note in the staff report we touched on the...

3:54:12 Major A allocations and stuff of that nature. If there's additional questions not related to the next item on the agenda, which is MLT, but related to the housing funding structure and where we have that, we can take those at this point. As I mentioned earlier, roughly, these numbers will get refined as we come forward.

3:54:32 There's about what I would call our Housing Community Development Fund, Fund 245, about $1.7 million of uncommitted money, $200,000 of that will be going out to pay for the Joaquin property, for that 6D Joaquin. There's about $800,000 in the TOT-based housing fund, and there is about $1.8 million.

3:55:00 I think it's 1.8 million. There may be a reserve component that pushes that down a little bit, about 1.8 million. And the tourism fund at this point, there is, as mentioned earlier, in the housing in Luffy, I'm not recommending actually that be utilized at this point. There would be about $200,000 that would be available in that fund. And then...

3:55:23 There's about $400,000 of restricted housing funding that potentially could go to this depending on the restrictions on the funds. Some elements there may not allow it to be utilized in some of these areas. That would be an analysis we'd have to do. And there is approximately about 1.2, 1.3 million uncommitted general fund dollars currently out there that we believe anyway as we wrap up the year end.

3:55:49 That could potentially move into these funds as well. So we'll walk through those. I'd like to bring that back in detail so it's fully understood. Along with that, we can walk back through the allocation of past budget-ending dollars in terms of where those have gone. It's not just the TOT or those types of dollars. It's the compilation of all our savings and our budget and the excess or shortfall in revenues.

3:56:18 To clarify, as I mentioned, we had set aside $2 million for housing. We spent just under $700,000. We had $1.3 million that we kept in the housing fund. That money, that was general fund dollars. That did go to COVID response. That was fully refunded in the last budget update by putting $1.4 million into that housing reserve. So that refunded the dollars we utilized for the COVID response component.

3:56:47 There was a piece, I believe, of the Tourism Reserve, a piece of that. I can't remember if it was, I think, I want to say in the $200,000 range. It might have been more than that. It went into the business recovery dollars that we put out, the grants to the businesses. Part of that did come out of the Tourism Reserve dollars back into those businesses that went out there, as well as we did other dollars out of town funds and stuff for housing support in terms of our rental support program.

3:57:18 Some housing dollars, but also out of that 1.3 million that was committed to the overall COVID response element. So those dollars are responding to the community in those areas. With that, we can address other particular questions as we can from the public or the council related to our housing program. There's a lot of work effort going into this. And to be able to say, yes, we have dollars committed that we can begin to find to really move forward some additional units in town and kind of a mix of

3:57:49 Income limits and ownership and rental I think is a huge step forward to enhance the overall community housing here. John. So a couple things. So we've gone through these seven items. This agenda item this evening came out of a discussion around the MLH contract in which council gave pretty specific direction to staff to do what we've just seen this evening. Thank you very much for that. And we look forward

3:58:21 You know, to the next meeting, you'll come back with actuals and what this is actually going to look like, but we're talking about a five million, give or take investment into housing for some short-term needs, and that's great. Thank you very much for doing that. There's a couple pieces of unfinished business. The first is to clarify, and this spills maybe a little bit into our next item, but to clarify the contract with MLH around the needs and to ensure that

3:58:50 The Community Development Director, Sandra, Nolan, Dan, whoever you want to sign to it, that it's staff can get in front of the council and say, this is what's in the contract. These are the deliverables. And these are specific things that people are working on. We need to get over that. We can't sit here in a meeting and say, well, I don't know what someone does. That's not excusable. And so that's an item that we have to work on next meeting whenever you guys want to bring that back. But that clarity, that level of clarity.

3:59:19 It's got to be in there. Final thing I would add is my conversations with constituents. The general ask was, okay, yeah, put more money into housing. What is the plan? What is the program? This goes back to the idea that this has gotten three or four or five different names this evening. I think for us, for council members to communicate effectively with the public, there needs to be a name for the, call it the town's housing program, whatever you want to call it.

3:59:48 We potentially have allocated $5 million to the town's housing program, establish a naming convention. We need to stick with it. That helps to, we'll go a long way with accountability. And I think that's gonna be very important. The money stuff, I don't, I'm not, you know, we need to get that cleaned out. There needs to be accountability to the public. The only thing that I'm really interested in is the reserve accounts. The council member Fernie and I worked on setting that up many years ago.

4:00:15 It was very clear there are these Measure A reserve accounts for the three political commitment areas. We all understand that the town gets a big share of TOT that's not in those reserve accounts, and those are the town, it's the money that the town uses to go in the general fund, but accounting on those reserve accounts would be helpful. And those are my thoughts. But thank you very much to staff for bringing this together. For Sandra, Dan, Nolan, you, and Rob, this is exactly what we asked for, and thank you very much. John, any further questions or comments? Raise your hand, please.

4:00:45 Would you speak? Seeing none, any further public comments or questions? Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you, Jamie. I just wanted to thank staff and town council for talking about housing so in-depth this evening and for making a substantial contribution to our ongoing project.

4:01:12 It really enables us to leverage the local funds three times over with state, federal and additional local grants throughout from partners in the region to create this housing project. And so it's evident that we need to work together and I'm excited to see all of these projects moving forward. So thank you. Thank you, Patricia. Any further? There are no more public comments. Thank you. With that,

4:01:47 I will move forward with item 9.4, agreement between Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll kick this off and then open it up for discussion. The agreement, I'll say the, what I'll call a boilerplate agreement component or the front end of the agreement. You've seen before, it walks through the requirements. It comes off of town attorney's.

4:02:18 As with each of these agreements, really where the rubber starts to come to meet the road, if you will, is working through annual deliverables and then working through compensation. Most of these agreements that we have in place, not all, but have kind of a multi-year component to it. Every year the deliverable section is reviewed in light of the scope that's identified as well, broader scope usually, and then that deliverable component.

4:02:47 And then also looking at the funding structure, and that can be reviewed annually by the council. For MLT in particular, we've had a couple different follow-up elements to this in the past presentations there at the MLT, as well as we had a joint workshop in April. The workshop, a lot of discussion related to housing and the elements on that and what could be done or not be done.

4:03:13 Very little discussion, I hate to say at that point in time, but not a lot of discussion on the hard deliverables and on the funding structure, but definitely highlighted a need for looking at funding related to housing components. The other side to that is as we went into...

4:03:30 And based on that, MLT did go back. They worked through a budget. They spent time on that, developed that, and brought that forward. The MLT includes the Tourism and Business Improvement District funding in their budget, which is kind of outside the purview of the town council other than when you adopt or are in the process of approving the actual program that controls TBID.

4:03:56 But as we looked at that, I did have request from council members in terms of adopting the town budget. If we were to adopt that budget, does that automatically put in place funding for our NGOs, MLT being one of those at the time, MLH, MLR as well? And the answer to that has been no, because we have no contractual obligations that are completed at that point. Since then, we have completed three different agreements, one with...

4:04:24 MLR, one with MLH, and one actually with the Chamber of Commerce. MLT is the last one coming forward at this point. There has been some questions again on that of being able to look at that and have that discussion before us this evening, both in terms of, say, that scope deliverables, but really then the funding source, funding structure for the tourism agreement. Understand the frustration. That'll be coming out.

4:04:49 Meeting this evening just in terms of timing and process to some degree on that and the dollars there. As mentioned earlier, different accounting or different process for allocation of revenues in these areas definitely have been modified over time.

4:05:04 And the item here before you tonight continues some of that discussion. The staff report walks through part of that process, part of, again, a little bit of the history on the allocation of Measure A dollars. That was approved from a voter initiative, again, not.

4:05:19 Binding type elements there, but definitely advisory in terms of the use of that, which includes town's facilities and other recreational amenities, as well as marketing and housing, so things are there. I think the other significant shift, which has been a really positive element for the town in terms of our whole tourism structure, has been the implementation of the Tourism Business Improvement District, which started in September of 2013. I think it's...

4:05:45 I could be wrong on this one, John. I think it's still the most creative one in the state in terms of how it actually applies to all tourism businesses. The vast majority of T-bids, if not all of them, tend to be focused just on the hotel tax, that transit occupancy tax level. What the town was able to do here in partnership with businesses, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and the hotel, the lodging industry, it was quite...

4:06:13 Creative, if you will, and very powerful in terms of that. Roughly, numbers are rough here in terms of some of the timing, but TBIT has generated since then. Over $42 million has gone back into marketing or projected to go into marketing, including 21-22 fiscal year. And that has definitely made a difference. I think we see that in...

4:06:35 Revenue generation from TOT activity for the number of people coming in the community from a visitor base and also being able to, I think, strengthen the average daily rate that we get out of lodging properties in particular, but also then that feeds into the other tourism-based businesses. TOT dollars have continued to go through, and as I mentioned earlier, and as I mentioned, John mentioned as well early in his comments, that

4:07:03 The allocation process has been shifting since, I'm going to say since 12-13, 13-14 with the litigation settlement and then again in 17-18 with a shift there as well in terms of the different allocations between the town and the transit, housing, and tourism for those elements. And there's some information in the report there. I'd say those are those numbers. You go back and there's a couple little pieces here and there that would move around in terms of some allocations.

4:07:33 I've been done over that time as well, but to show an order of magnitude over that time frame of what we've done for our tourism side of the house, and I think we've benefited from that in terms of seeing our growth in TOT. And really this last year with a COVID year, I'll say from the staff side, we're very surprised at the strength that we're able to come back on in a year that there was ideally no travel allowed for a number of months, although I think several people kind of ignored that element.

4:08:01 So being able to move through that and be able to end the year what looks like will be about a $16 million a year. So that was huge for that. The element there, so it comes through that, and then ultimately we laid out some options for council for discussion, consideration. Obviously, one of those would be you could sit back and just, you know, kind of let the current allocation stuff go as projected, 2.334,500 for,

4:08:31 I think that's the number going into MLT is I think what they base their budget on. The other option obviously would be looking at a modification of that. Kind of an alternative that was proposed or looked at would be looking at setting hard funding for a two-year period, which either could be a reduced amount of those two years or one year at the current and one year reduced. That would take the timing issue out that has created a certain level of consternation, fully understanding those types of elements.

4:09:00 But I think the item here really is as the council does have authority over those TOT revenues and how they wish to utilize them for tourism or other purposes is definitely within your purview as a legislative body overseeing the tax allocations and the tax revenues there and could definitely make those adjustments. It's not unique, frankly, to have some of these agreements come forward. We've done that both with MLR, MLH, and even the chamber agreement, modifying them.

4:09:28 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

4:09:55 In the report or otherwise there that we can speak to as would help your deliberation. Thank you, Dan. As another potentially lengthy item, I'm gonna ask for council questions and then go to public and come back for council comments. So question time, Linda. Questions in regards to this item. I don't think I have any questions at this time. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. John? So Dan,

4:10:28 The agreement that's in the packet, that is the agreement that is the proposed budget, the proposed agreement that the MLT board, that's the proposal from MLT for the contract with the town, correct? Yeah, their proposal would be what I would call Exhibit C in the compensation, which calls out that $2,334,500.

4:10:54 The other option there is if the compensation was to be modified, there's an option, if you will, in there that could be considered by council. But otherwise, the agreement and the deliverables are those which came out of the discussion with MLT. But this has been known to the town and known to the council for how many months? This came out after that June time frame is after that joint meeting that we had the elements in here from the deliverables and those elements.

4:11:25 And then the calculation tied to the town's budget was at that point. So I mentioned there were questions raised that as we adopted our budget that there was, I'll say, honest questions coming up. But if our budget adoption locks this in, then we should not approve the town's budget, frankly, at that point in time. I understand. And it's been known and looked at, but there has been concerns raised. But the document, the budgeting effort that MOT did, the public...

4:11:54 I'll save this for my comments, but this has been a known thing to the town of the council for a long time. And we've had a representative from the council on the MLT board engage with this for the last, you know, Linda, how long you've been our rep on there for at least a year, right? So this has all been known. And the final question I have is, so the question for us this evening is to approve this proposal or not.

4:12:24 Or is that clear to me what the specific question is in front of us this evening? So the question before tonight is to approve the agreement as presented, if you will, that would maintain the existing calculation for compensation in place, or the council may request a modification to the compensation structure, and you actually...

4:12:47 If you're going to reduce compensation, you could make a modification to deliverable, so it would be all open for discussion at this point. So you have a simple yes, approve as is, or approve with the amended compensation structure, which doing so, that would need to go back to the MLT board for their approval then as well, as it is a modification to the agreement from what their board has approved. Okay, thank you. Sarah? So if it...

4:13:20 Okay, so I will first say, and I was kind of going to save this for my comments, but I will say that I was the one who was not in favor of approving the town budget with the Measure A allocations as they were. And, you know, I discussed with Dan whether or not I would vote no on the town budget. And, you know, I was informed that we could discuss that funding with...

4:13:45 in regards to MLT's contract. So I'll just throw that out there that I was that person. And I have more comments that I'll say later, but my question is, if we were to vote for, we would provide annual compensation in the amount of 2 million, and it goes back to MLT's board.

4:14:12 Do they have the opportunity to reject it, or what do you think the downstream effects of that would be? Yes. I mean, as it goes back that way, ultimately, it's a two-party agreement, so they would need to approve it in terms for us to make any payments to them. I think the one point of discussion there could be in terms of if they would request a modification to the deliverable section. If something got reduced in funding, do they reduce something in their deliverable side? But it would need to go back to them for...

4:14:40 Thank you. That's my only question. Thank you, Kirk.

4:15:12 I'm not understanding the process. I mean, there's some historical commitments. And in this, what we're proving here, you know, locks it in at a lower level than the political commitments. Is that correct? Yeah, the political commitment originally, if you remember, was the two and a half points and TOT points. I got modified to a 2.35 at the airport litigation. Correct. So that's currently there.

4:15:40 The proposed compensation originally was based off of that number, the 2.35 to head to town budget. On the projected budget? On the adopted budget, but what about the excess TOT at the end of the year? That stays with the town in a tourism-based reserve, which can be utilized for that or other purposes. So it stays on the reserve, and how does Mammoth Lake Tourism access that money? They could come and make a request for that, which we have done in the past.

4:16:10 Or as currently, the direction at MLT at this point has been the support of utilizing those excess funds to address housing elements. Ultimately, the town council can utilize those funds as you desire. It was an advisory vote. I recognize that. So the item before you would be whether to retain that existing allocation of the 2.35 percentage points, if you will, of TOT, or to

4:16:38 Utilize a different number for their compensation. Wait, hang on a second. We're not talking about changing Measure A allocations, correct? Yeah, what would still happen, those allocations are staying tracked accordingly, but if you change the allocation to MLT, let's say it's a $2 million allocation, and that's their budget next year, we will still track 2.35 percentage points of TOT dollars.

4:17:07 Okay, but I just want to make clear that the allocation of Measure A dollars is not to any given organization. Correct. It is an allocation to purposes. And I...

4:17:32 I don't see anything in this agenda item that we're discussing Measure A allocations. We're talking about a contract with MLT this evening, correct? Correct. What I'm saying is the calculation for MLT is based off of our budgeted TOT revenue and a 2.35 points of equivalent TOT revenue going to MLT less to payment to the Chamber of Commerce.

4:18:01 So it is Measure A dollars, if you will, going to, out of the tourism bucket, going to MLT for this agreement. The amount of those tourism dollars you wish to grant to MLT is what's under discussion. Okay, but we're not having a Measure A allocation discussion this evening? No. Okay, thank you. Okay, my questions. One.

4:18:34 Have we passed a budget? The Town of Mammoth Lakes has adopted an annual budget, yes. And in that annual budget, have we allocated 2.35 of our estimated DOT to tourism and MLT? To tourism, yes. Ultimately, this contract will say how much of that goes to MLT? Right. That's our political commitment. The original political commitment...

4:19:05 To MLT, which was viewed differently than it is today, was for 2.5 points plus all business tax certificates. Correct? Correct. Yeah, thank you. Then we took money from all of the political commitments in terms of hard dollar amounts or a percentage of what they were getting to help pay for the lawsuit, which pretty much gutted housing in the process. Correct.

4:19:39 Right. So then, John and Colin and the council at the time, in order to move the funds around and make it more equitable, we stopped deducting the hard dollar amount and changed percentages so that we could put more funding back into housing and ultimately take more funding out of MLT by not only taking the percentage down from 2.5 to 2.35,

4:20:09 But also only allocating MLT the amount in our estimated TOT revenue, which we on purpose estimate low. So that's how we got here. Those are my questions. I have a whole lot more comments, obviously, going later. At this point, I would open it up for public comments. And you have all received various emails and letters, I am sure, and phone calls.

4:20:41 So I want to acknowledge those, but we won't rehash those, only the new comments. The airport litigation really messed things up. And then, you know, obviously... Good evening, Mayor Sauser, neighbor Sauser, and council members, John Morris, treasurer of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. My focus tonight is on the contract between MLT and Town of Mammoth Lakes and our process.

4:21:12 Not quite sure why we're saying we don't have a contract. I have in my hands a contract, which is a four-year contract, which began fiscal year 2019, so July of 2019. It runs through June of 23. It is a contract. It is signed by people in this room. I feel it is a contract. It is a contract. It is a contract. It is a contract. A couple things I'd like to read in here quickly. Under the fees and payment section 3.3,

4:21:38 One, compensation. Town will provide the contractor, which is MLT, compensation under the terms and conditions that's provided for in Exhibit C. Exhibit C will be updated each fiscal year to reflect the current year compensation for MLT based on the town's adopted base budget for TOT revenues. That's our funding source right there. Exhibit A in the contract. This is the existing contract. Talks about...

4:22:07 That has been done. That was done according to our calendar. Exhibit C in our existing contract reads, this exhibit

4:22:37 It says compensation. This exhibit will be updated annually based on the town budget, approved transient occupancy tax revenue and any adjustment to allocation of reserve rates approved by town council. The town council of Mammoth Lakes will approve updated exhibit C by May 1st of each year. Today is July 21st. So the last...

4:23:02 One thing I will note is in this contract, my signature page, it is signed for the Town of Mammoth Lakes by Dan Holler, attested to by Jamie Gray, approved to as form by Andy Morris. For MLT, it is signed by John Urdi and myself, John Morris. That, in my terms, is a contract.

4:23:21 A couple things I'd just like to say about that. The MLT board absolutely agrees that more funding should go towards workforce housing. We've been working towards that. And we think that well more than the proposed $334,000 reduction to MLT's current fiscal year budget should go to housing. As business owners and managers, we live with staffing struggles every day. And in many cases...

4:23:45 Myself included at Snow Creek. We've had to adjust our business models to meet smaller staffing levels. We understand housing. We get it. We have had exactly one meeting with council over the past several years, and that meeting devolved into a discussion, from a discussion, on MLT's deliverables, which was what it was supposed to be about, into a housing conversation. As we discussed at that meeting this past spring, we need to meet with the council on a regular basis, perhaps quarterly.

4:24:12 to review current MLT programs, deliverables, successes, and the town's needs, and to further demonstrate how MLT leverages our community's funds to grow TOT and provide additional funds back to the town for programs like workforce housing. Any proposed change to MLT's budget, which are...

4:24:30 Absolutely, our community's funds should be discussed in an open forum and well in advance of any new fiscal year. We have a shared working calendar exactly for that purpose. We look forward to working with the council in the coming months and continuing to leverage our community's marketing dollars to both improve quality visitation during the slower seasons and winter midweeks and to educate our visitors on how to recreate responsibly.

4:24:56 Thank you, John. Next up. Good evening, everybody. Jeremy Goyko, MLT Board Chair and Board of Director for the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Appreciate all the discussion tonight. You know, our budget at MLT has

4:25:37 You know, we've had this tourism reserve, we've had the recalibration, we've lost the business tax license, you know, so, and then in our mind, that money was supposed to be going to housing. So I think there's a lot of confusion tonight, you know, and ultimately Mammoth Lakes Tourism wants to be a partner.

4:26:02 With the town of Mammoth Lakes to figure out our workforce housing crisis that we're going through right now. So we support these efforts in your last, you know, part of the agenda. You guys had a lot of great discussion putting some money towards some housing efforts. I appreciate the mayor's enthusiasm for that. I share that enthusiasm. You know, we want to help support these efforts and we want to work with you.

4:26:32 After we've completed our budgeting process and want to take money and you just want to put it towards housing, you know, that's very nebulous. It's very vague. Okay, what exactly is going to happen with that money? There doesn't seem to be quite a plan in place that we can follow that's clear. You know, we want to work with you on, you know, figuring that process out. You know, so what I ask.

4:27:00 Is that you allow us to walk through that process this next year. You know, let's stick to the contract. Let's stick to the process that's happened and work together to figure out solutions to our housing problem that we're having right now. On top of that, you know, I represent the small business community as a board of director for the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Our small business community has had a lot of challenges, housing probably being one of the biggest, but also

4:27:29 COVID, drought, fire, you know, it was a light snow year. We're dealing with a lot of issues. Money that goes to Mammoth Lakes Tourism ultimately is money that is invested into the small business community. It brings revenue not just to the town, but also to our small businesses. So when, you know, when you come to us saying you want another reduction in our budget,

4:27:56 That to us is you're taking away investment into the small business community. And right now our small business community needs all the help it can get. So, you know, I hope we can, I appreciate the discussions that's happening tonight. I think a lot of this is due to confusion between, you know, where

4:28:20 Mammoth Lakes Tourism is under the impression that millions of dollars that have been diverted from our budget are going to housing. So when you're asking for more money to go to housing and it's not clear what exactly is going to happen with $334,000, which is a lot of money. That's a lot of money. I had a couple people say that's not a lot of money. It's a lot of money, okay?

4:28:43 We want clarity on that. We want to be part of the process and part of that discussion to figure out what's the best way to allocate those dollars. So, you know, we had a meeting, I believe it was end of April, April 28th, if I'm not mistaken.

4:29:00 A lot of the discussion was around housing. It was a little haphazard. You know, I think what I'd like to see moving forward is if MLT board, MLT staff and town council can meet on a quarterly basis to, you know, and create an agenda for that meeting so that we can have a productive quarterly meeting discussing workforce housing and how we can

4:29:24 You know, combine our efforts, work together. I would also like to see the chamber involved in some of that stuff because the chamber membership is extremely affected by the workforce housing crisis that we're going through right now. So I will be reaching out to schedule and set up some quarterly meetings as the new chair for the MLT board. And I look forward to working with you during this process, you know, and hope that that

4:29:51 You know, we can kind of get past tonight and some of the confusion that I think we're all going through with this. All right. Thank you so much. Thank you, Jeremy. Do we have any more public comments? Jamie. Yes, we do. Good evening, council and staff.

4:30:17 I'm Terry Stellick with Seasons for Economy and Rentals. And, you know, a lot's been said. And there's a lot going on here. And I know how horrible this housing crisis is. I live it every day with my staff. And I hear it from others in town. But I'm just going to say political commitment, transparency, which I can't tell you how many times I've heard about transparency tonight even, just about how we're doing things, how the public needs to be involved, and how they need to know how these

4:30:46 Decisions are being made. And process. And I don't think any of those are being reached in how you guys are working through this tonight. And so I don't know, is that a step back? Because there is a contract with MLT. So if you don't feel MLT is moving forward in the way that you want them to with the monies that you've given them, then that's...

4:31:11 Why you have a contract with them. That's when you have that discussion. And so now you're kind of midterm coming in and saying this. I haven't heard tonight, I've heard a lot of talk about where monies have gone for this excess fund that is coming from TOT that's been taken, you know, from the MLT contract. I can't tell you that I could tell you where it is. I think that I've heard this.

4:31:38 Thank you, Jerry. Hello, Mayor, and hello, Council. I'm Robert Richards.

4:32:21 I've been sitting here and listening to this, and, you know, I gotta say, there's a whole lot of layers to everything that's been talked about tonight that I'm out of my element on, but there are some basics here that I just really can't understand. We have a huge, huge employee housing situation here and workforce housing situation, and we talk about, it was referenced before, we talk about, there's two projects, one in Manzanita or

4:32:50 So I'm confused about when we're talking about $350,000 coming out of MLT and I'll disagree with Jeremy in that case.

4:33:20 That's nothing. What are we doing about the really big problem and where's that money coming from and how? We've been talking about housing for a long time, but we're in serious problems here. We have Little Nell getting ready to break ground up on a new piece of property across from the village next to the Western for a five-star hotel. How are they going to staff it? And where are those people going to live? And I just think everything that we're talking about is...

4:33:47 It is a minutiae compared to the big problem. When I hear about $5 million going towards housing and a good portion of that is for 12 units, I think we've got a long way to go before we can get this town running properly in terms of the functionality of the mountain and all the small businesses here and all the big businesses here. And I just want to throw that out to the council for some thought and consideration.

4:34:15 Yeah, thank you, Robert. If I may, real quick, that included the 11 units we're talking about with MLH as well. And then we didn't get into the discussion this evening because of conflicts on the council, but we do have the parcel, which over time, but that would be a total of about 450 units plus 80 to start with, but that's going to be a whole other element. Yeah, correct. So, thank you. Yes, thank you, Rob Patterson, Finance Director for the town. Really good comments and dialogue tonight.

4:34:47 I did want to fill in some of the blanks on where maybe housing has come from, and there's questions that have been raised tonight about where the plot of money is, if you will. So before we made the reallocation back in 17, 18, the counts contribution to housing was the MLH contract of $330,000 roughly, and then there was a home

4:35:14 So it was 550 per year that was just flat dollar amounts paid towards housing. Then after the recalibration, I looked at the four years, that was 17-18 through the current fiscal year. Our average TOT has been 17.4 million. So the 17.4 million means that an average payment to housing was

4:35:42 About $1.14 million. So that's up between a little over $600,000, $650,000 a year increase to housing on an annual basis. So across those four years, that average allocation is about $4.5 million to housing, and it's $2.5 million higher than it would have been. So when you talk about, you know, where were those funds and how were they allocated, that goes into

4:36:10 A housing reserve, similar to the tourism reserve, it can be utilized by council action. Every year I do produce, as part of that fund balance presentation in October, I do produce a report that shows all the TOT revenue, the allocation based on the percentages, and then the expenditure line item details for that.

4:36:32 I'd be happy to kind of provide those over the last few years, but we've been doing that since we put that process together, and I'd be happy to share that. But I think it was important to address the questions about where those funds had come up, just to continue that dialogue, and again, very good dialogue tonight. And one thing, John, Fund 245's traditional name is Housing Programs. It's been that for five years. Great. Let's stick with just good, consistent naming conventions, too.

4:37:01 Cut down on the noise and the confusion. Thank you, Rob. Further public comments? No, that's all the public comments. Okay, thank you. I will take it back to council for comments. Linda. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. There have been, just so that we don't think there's not a lot more comments, we all received a lot of comments, both pro and con in regards to this commentary. So we may have had, I think, three or four people.

4:37:41 In suite Z, but there was multiple, multiple letters that I didn't want to have people think that we weren't paying a lot of attention to. So thank you everyone for your input for sure. I just want to start out by saying that I am the MLT representative from the council and I've really enjoyed watching the process of MLT, watching the discussion about the work that they do.

4:38:04 You know, kind of seeing them close up and really admiring what we do in our tourism department. So let there be no question that I have any desire to strip away the funding for MLT or to see us stop advertising our town because the work they're doing now is way more than trying to get people here. It has a lot to do with how we manage our tourism, how we educate our tourists, how we improve the experience for tourists. So I'm very much a fan.

4:38:33 And very supportive of the work that MLT does. I'm also a fan of contracts. And, you know, they are the fundee. The town of Mammoth Lakes is a funder. They are the fundee. We have a contract that spells out the terms of a contract, all the contract language. And then we have our exhibits, one of which is the compensation, which is reviewed yearly.

4:38:59 So we are at that point now. So any amendment we made now would be amendment, not to the contract, but rather to the exhibit C, which is a piece that prescribes the compensation. This discussion kind of came up in pieces. And when I try to track it back a little bit and understand why we got where we are here was that don't forget as early as May, we were still...

4:39:24 Under lots of guidelines and restrictions for COVID, so I won't use that as an excuse, but when we budgeted our TOT at 14.5, the first thing that I thought about is, well, then that's an automatic increase to MLT. So started talking about that, the budget came forward, it was really important that we get that budget going, set us forward, but knowing that we still had to approve the MLT contract, so not an excuse, but what I know is that...

4:39:51 As being on both sides of that funding equation as a funder and as a fundee, contract changes are a reality of life. They come monthly, they come weekly, they come quarterly, they come yearly, and it is often on both the funder who may lose funding and then to put it out to the fundee of, oh, we're going to have to change this. That is not a small deal. A great deal of...

4:40:15 Time, effort is put into crafting a budget. So MLT was very fairly working off of the 14.5, I get that, which then led to out of 2.35, the 2.334 funding that was in their budget. So looking at it from a funder's standpoint is that, okay, our priorities have changed.

4:40:40 Our priorities a year ago, a year before, were really starting to turn. But this year when we did our strategic planning, the very, very loudest priority was, without a doubt, housing. Housing, housing, housing. We hear it from the chamber loud and clear. We hear it from employees loud and clear. We hear it from every corner of our community that housing is pivotal. Without housing, we cannot continue to do what we do. Could not be more clear.

4:41:06 So looking then back at the MLT question, if someone could tell me fairly and without question, you know, based on a great deal of data and data crunching, what the right number for tourism is, it would be thrilling. Because right now, the budgeted amount for the total number of dollars for tourism next year is $7.127 million. Okay? That's a lot of money.

4:41:35 It's been a lot of money for a long time. Is that the number we need? Anyway, I digress a little bit from that. So in trying to sort of control the funding to the fundee and to understand how we can move in the future, I moved into the thought of, okay, maybe we need to cut this down to a, you know, 2 million, take back that 334, which will absolutely go into one of our housing funds.

4:42:06 I've thought about, okay, we use it to fund that $200,000 that we paid for that piece of property. The other $134,000 is used for the planning, the building design, starting to move forward into that. If that is a concrete thing to do with that, then that can be the concrete thing to do for that.

4:42:24 So if MLT is already, I understand, $800,000 ahead on their TBID collections this year. It was budgeted at $5.1 million this year for TBID. It is already closing in on $6 million. I would not appear that the $334,000 is much of a pain to them. And I get it. It's not about the amount of money. It's about what people are talking about is the change of contract. Was this the right time to do it? Was this the right way to do it?

4:42:54 Arguably, it is what it is. It's a change to the funding. It's a change to compensation based on a priority and a strategic priority that is very, very clear to me. So I think that's sort of who I am. And another reason that I don't, well, I respect the comments that people have made about this being a really not good thing to do to MLT to change the terms of the contract at this late stage.

4:43:23 I understood that one of the reasons that the town helped to seat these NGOs was that an NGO had the ability to be more nimble than a government entity. Now, a government entity changing a budget, that is a really, really difficult thing. MLT is not a government entity. It is an NGO. Is it able to, you know, backfill this if they need to?

4:43:47 I would think they do. They have $1.4 million in a Measure A reserve, and they have $2 million in a T-bid reserve. I would think that the problem of a 3-3-4 downturn in a budget amendment would not be a difficult thing to support monetarily, but I think we already knew that going into that that wasn't the point. So I will support us adjusting.

4:44:14 The amended or amending the amount paid this year to MLT. I will leave it to the rest of our council to discuss their thoughts and comments on this, but I think that summarizes my kind of personal thoughts about this question, understanding that we have no greater priority than understanding and getting our handle around housing. Now MLT is right.

4:44:43 Let me back up just a little bit. They told us last year that every penny that went into the tourism reserve, they would want to go to housing. Well, that's good because we were going to do that anyway. It's very important that that money go into housing. So, yes, they have. And over the years, as I studied the history of MLT, yeah, there have been budget adjustments and budget things. But in spite of that,

4:45:13 You know, I mean, they've gotten, you know, over the years, their budget has not really gone down. The lowest they've gotten, I believe, was way back in 14-15, which was, I think, 6 million between TBID and business licenses and TOT. Last year, even in the middle of a pandemic, the 19-20 still came out at 6.5 million. Last year was 6.20-21 was almost 7 million.

4:45:42 So I think we're okay money-wise. I think they've done a great job. I think MLT is a great organization. I have nothing but a positive thing to say about that. But in this case, I feel that at this point in the process, asking them to take a little bit less off the top and beginning to put more of that into housing and then going forward, that we begin to also look carefully at that, what we're giving them based on what

4:46:11 So that's all my comments. I think that's all I have right now. Thanks. Mr. McFarney, I just want to clarify one comment, Linda, I think that you made on the TBID budget. For the year ending 2021, they were running $800,000 above budget for TBID. Still one more month to go. Not in the current year, obviously, starting.

4:46:33 July 1st. No, absolutely not. Thank you, Dan. Still, that's an estimated number. Oh, it's fiscal year 2021, so by the time we get the June in, they're going to be welcome to $6 million in TBID last year. Well, July 1, before that. Yeah, and you're running over that. No, no, you're running over that. Yeah, $6 million would be a combination of everything. Not just TBID. Yeah, so the clarity there.

4:47:03 So just wanna make sure that it's clear that the TBD was running over budget, but it's, the budget was 3.8 and it's projected at four, whatever, yeah, so. It was projected, 2021 was projected a 5.1 TBD. That's what I have in my records here. And the grand total was budgeted to be 6.9 and we're already 800,000 over that without the rest of June. Yes, that includes TOT. A 1.7 last year.

4:47:43 Thank you, everybody. Okay. Moving on to John. There is no doubt that housing, community housing, is the biggest challenge that is facing our community. There's no disagreement, I don't think, from anybody about that. So the question is not whether or not housing. The question is how. How are we going to create and set appropriate

4:48:15 You know, expectations for the community of what can actually be done to deal with, which is fundamentally an existential problem, given our land base. And it's incumbent upon the council to figure out, to work with its partners, the how. There are so many issues involved in this discussion that need to be fully vetted, reviewed, and discussed by the council to set intelligent policy.

4:48:46 Going forward. In my mind, we have failed not only MLT, we failed MLH and we failed MLR. Because, Lynda, to your point, these are people that we contract with to provide services. And all three of these NGOs have ended up at the very last minute with a council that is uninformed, doesn't, says things like, well, I don't know what you do.

4:49:16 And making decisions that can only be deemed to be arbitrary and almost petulant about, well, let's take a little bit out of here. And that's just not good policy. That's not us rising to the challenges and providing the type of leadership and direction that's necessary to really take this on. So just one example of this. TBID and Measure A in marketing are

4:49:44 Apples and oranges. They are not the same thing. We, as a council, have no control or influence however deep it gets spent. All the constituents that come to us and say there are too many people here. You're telling them, you know, you're not, you know, telling them how to recreate responsibly. You're not providing the type of information they need to have a good experience in this community. We have leverage.

4:50:11 To inform that through the commitment we make through Measure A to marketing. I would be more than happy to take all the Measure A money that's going to marketing and put it into housing. But have we considered the fact that if we do that, then the only thing that's communicating to the world about our destination is the T-bid over which the Town Council, the People's Representative, have no influence.

4:50:36 That is not, that is something that we have to consider and we have to think about. And we have to have serious, profound and thorough conversations about how we're going to navigate all that. The TIPA is up for renewal in two years. We haven't even talked about that. In terms of this agreement, I am going to propose that we approve it as is. We can come back to it anytime we want.

4:51:00 Once we've exhausted and gone through a thorough policy review and provided direction to this community as to where we're going and how we're going to deal with this housing crisis using every lever at our disposal. Several years ago, a gentleman named Scott McGuire was the head of the board. He was in Jeremy's position with MLT. They put together a very specific process for when...

4:51:23 The budget will be proposed when the town council would review and meet it and so that we could provide direction to everybody well in advance of whatever date this is, July, whatever, to making decisions about our budget. We didn't stick to that. We didn't hold up our end of the bargain. We had our one discussion with the MLT board where we should have had an agenda very specifically. These are the specific deliverables. We need to talk about the specific deliverables. We didn't do that.

4:51:52 So I just feel that we have to do, it's another thing we have to do is the review of how we engage with these folks that we're contracting with so that we can really work together as a larger community team to deliver on the things that we have to do. There's a lot of work we have to do in that space to get it right. This is not the way to do it. This is not the way to get to where we need to get to. So from my point this evening, to prove it as is,

4:52:22 Let's start having those discussions that we need to have so we can have a full and thorough review of policy direction commitments we want to make and then let the chips fall where they may. But in this case, we're putting the chips first. And we've not had the kind of discussions that are coherent and exhaustive about where we're going with this thing. So I need to support this thing as presented. The MLH contract, we said, okay, we'll do it for a year. We have to come back to all these things and we have to be coherent.

4:52:51 Thorough, transparent, and frankly professional in how we deal with these folks because they're doing the best that they can. So that's where I'm at. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Sarah. Thank you, John. Thank you, Linda. I just want to address the two main talking points from MLT here. The first is that they don't have an issue with the money being moved. They have an issue with the process.

4:53:18 I'm just spitballing here, but I have a feeling that if we wait until next year or we wait until 2023, it's not going to be an issue with the process. It's going to be an issue with something else. Nobody wants their funding to be reduced. I get it. But MLT is not being blindsided by this. At the joint meeting that we had with MLT on the 28th of April, it was made extremely clear that the council was asking

4:53:45 How much money do you need to do what you do? And MLT refused to answer that question. And now they're sending out messaging that I find really disingenuous. Laura Kaler's email today said, if this discussion had been held four or five months ago, this would most likely be a non-issue. But after working months on its budget, we only have the town to try to change the terms at the 11th hour. MLT deserves better.

4:54:13 We brought this discussion to the table before MLT's budget was approved. MLT's leadership decided to ignore the concerns and move forward with its budget. I did express to the town manager prior to the town's budget approval that I was not comfortable with approving the allocation as it stood and Dan...

4:54:39 Assured me that we could have that discussion when we talked about this contract. I did not want to throw a grenade into the town's budget approval process. This is my first time doing this. I did express my concerns and I know that that was made clear to MLT. Laura's letter from today stated that the money in question is not MLT's money but the business community's marketing dollars.

4:55:07 I worked as a contract blogger for MLT for two years. And in that time, I made repeated visits to the three-story luxury condo that MLT owns to interview elite athletes who stay in Mammoth on the business community's marketing dollars. It was paid extremely well for the stories that I wrote. I had my ski pass purchased for two years in a row with the business community's marketing dollars.

4:55:36 Now, while I applaud MLT for hiring local, it's pretty obvious to me that they're not hurting for funding. To the MLT staff and board, I just, I need to reiterate that you are not being victimized here. The second point is that there is some question as to whether this money will go towards housing. It was in all caps in the letter from today, possibly go towards housing. I don't think I need to spend a lot of time on this.

4:56:06 I think we've seen from the housing work plan that there are plenty of places to put this funding, but I can say right now, put it towards the creative housing fund, put it towards 238 Sierra Manor Road. There's your transparency. It's very easy to follow that money. So I don't think this is an issue. I sat and listened to the lodging association and the restaurant association members.

4:56:30 Both complain at both of their meetings on Monday how they can't find staffing and it's just all they ever wish for. But these same members are just dismayed that we would think to take any money away from marketing to put towards housing and I'm just really not sure what the disconnect is there. To my fellow council members, I would just ask you, where do you want to stand? What do you want?

4:56:59 Your legacy to be. Kirk, when you and I used to sit in the Sheetz office and talk about the need for housing five years ago, you told me that we could be the change makers. You were the one that sparked my interest in running for town council. And we sit here with an opportunity to move a very small, relatively small amount of money from an organization that has a great deal of it.

4:57:28 But this move will be a statement that this council is taking action on behalf of the backbone of this community, which is the workforce. And those people do not have a million dollar mouthpiece like MLT does. I will be so proud to say that I voted to put their interests first. This is what I was elected to do. So I believe that this is the right thing for our community at this time. And I know that in voting for $2 million.

4:57:56 I will be voting my conscience. Thank you. Sarah Kirk. Thank you, Bill. I campaign for all the different political commitments for housing, for marketing, for the general fund. And I continue to support those different initiatives. So if you look at Mammoth Lake Tourism, they should be getting 2.5 points of the TOT plus the business license.

4:58:31 And obviously that's changed through the litigation and everything else. But I think it's important that the town maintain its political commitments because if we have to go out to ask for any other kind of revenues in support of housing, in support of just general, just taking care of our roads and everything else, I mean,

4:58:58 It's not just housing. It's also, you know, government services. If we're only spending a half a million dollars on road when we should be spending a million dollars on road, then sooner or later that's going to catch up to us and that's going to hurt the whole community. I support the political commitments. I continue to support Mammoth Lake tourism, Mammoth Lake housing, and the commitments that have been made over the years. That's my position.

4:59:28 Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. For me, I do not support taking the extra $300 and some thousand from them. We did pass a budget. We did make a commitment to them. And I will tell you, it goes far beyond just the deliverables. When we went into COVID, we asked them to actually advertise for people not to come here, and they did that. They did not have to. That was working with us. They are now putting out a message about responsible tourism.

4:59:58 They don't have to do that. It's not in their deliverables, but they're doing it because they're working for the business community and for our community as a whole. We still have holes in tourism. Midweek, winter, and all but about 45 days of summer, we have needs. Tourism is our industry. It is our business. How much money is appropriate? Well, I'll tell you, the only experts I know to tell us that, and maybe, Sarah, they have not told us yet,

5:00:27 But they told us they don't want their budget reduced. The only experts we have are from Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Mammoth Lakes Business Community. None of us here, I mean, I certainly used to, but I'm sort of ancient now, have the expertise that they have. We have spent money because of the way we've run our budget and because of our conservative approach, which has taken money out of MLT's hands by the millions.

5:00:55 We have been able to fund housing. We just told the town manager we want to find $5.7 million for a couple of little projects. That doesn't include the parcel. That doesn't include future projects. That doesn't include the money that hopefully we'll have in surplus at the end of this fiscal year. So we're pouring money into housing, and I am excited about it because for the first time ever with the tens of millions we've spent, we may actually get some housing on the ground.

5:01:22 So I would be opposed to changing their contract at this point. I think that if a housing project came up that was cost-worthy, we could even probably go to their board and ask them to give us some of their reserves, and it would probably happen. We need to think as partners, because that's what we are. All the revenue coming in is general fund money. It isn't tourism money. It isn't housing money.

5:01:52 It isn't transportation money. It is all general fund money. And these are the commitments we've made in the past and tried to live up to for the betterment of our community and have been very successful in doing so. Several places, including the state of Colorado in the past, have decided to cut their marketing because people are going to come anyway. And they all found out that that just doesn't work. If you don't maintain your image, if you don't maintain your marketing, you will lose.

5:02:21 So if that is our goal, then we should definitely cut tourism. With the advent of the TBID, they have even been more successful. And now they are segueing into midweek and into off-season things. So I am comfortable with moving forward with the commitment we have already made to this contract. Any final comments from Council? John.

5:02:51 Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion when you're ready to entertain such a motion. Make it up, John. I would move that the Town Council approve the contract, including attachment C as presented, and further that the Town Manager will agendize a, whether it's a workshop or a discussion around marketing and funding of marketing in Mammoth Lakes, including discussion of a future authorization of the T-Bid.

5:03:24 I will second that motion. Any further deliberation? John, does your motion include or incorporate the political commitments of the past? Yes. The current one, the 2.35. Yes, the current allocations of Measure A funds, yes. Thank you. Chair Stouser, if I may? Yes.

5:03:56 It'd be possible to amend this to say something in regards to the funding for fiscal year 22-23, capping that down to the 2 million mark, begin a sort of process of setting, using a standard other than the set 2.35 and then beginning work on understanding what that would mean between now and then.

5:04:23 Linda, if in my motion where I requested the agendizing of discussion around marketing funds between measuring the T-bit, that would be a great opportunity to have that discussion. And as the town attorney pointed out, we can amend this agreement anytime we want to. But I think we need to get a very clear and looking out.

5:04:47 I'm certainly open to entertaining those types of things, but I don't feel confident doing anything until we as a council have had a really good thorough discussion about, you know, the measure A money that goes into marketing, the political commitments that Kirk is talking about, and really having a thorough discussion about understanding exactly what a T-bit is and the autonomy

5:05:17 That a T-Bid has. And it really makes sure we all understand that the most significant voting block in the T-Bid is Mammoth Resorts. And do we really want to get into a situation where we're going to our constituents and saying, hey, marketing, that's all handed by the T-Bid. Well, the T-Bid's doing crazy stuff. Well, we don't have any influence over that. We do not have a seat at that table. And until this council's had that discussion and we've exhausted that stuff, that's the time to have it.

5:05:46 It turns out we want to start capping Measure A money and doing things with MLT's contract, fine. But I don't, I'm not comfortable doing anything until we have that discussion. And I would echo that. I would be uncomfortable saying in two years we're going to cut you to two million without having the discussion of how this affects us long-term and ongoing. And frankly, if we want to change how that money is spent, then we change in their deliverables and with our talking to them how they spend the money. But I'm comfortable with the...

5:06:17 The motion in my second. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, we've already gone to the public. Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? No. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? No. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Mayor Sauser, may I make another comment? I'm sorry, I interrupted you. Motion passes free to Linda, go ahead. Thank you. I would like to request that our staff

5:06:51 Kind of look at an analysis and help us understand what the direct link between how much money we spend on marketing and the results are linked. I have no idea what the number for marketing is. Is it 1 million, 5 million, 7 million? What is the right number? I've read reports, I've read studies that have tried and at least taken a swing at trying to quantify what

5:07:21 Amount of money it needs to get one person to come to your town. We are, you know, we are completely in the dark here. We are just going along and saying we just want to, you know, spend money on tourism. Let's spend, it's 2.35 because that's what we used to do and that seems like a good number. We have no idea. So I would be really happy if the town...

5:07:44 Staff could begin to pull together a group like that. I think there's some people even now on the MLT board who have a great interest in doing this. And I would like to dive into that to begin to inform us what the money we're spending on is getting us as more direct correlation. Mr. Mayor, Linda, it's a good question and it's a question that should be explored. I would just add from my own experience that in marketing, there is no definitive answer to those questions.

5:08:13 The digital world provides things. You can measure clicks. You can measure impressions. You can do that kind of stuff. Before the advent of this type of technology, there was never an answer to that. So I'm more than happy to entertain that. I'm not supportive of going down the black hole because there is no certainty to those types of questions. Marketing is not an exact science. It never has been.

5:08:38 I don't know that I completely agree with that, John, because from my research and my discussions, I feel somewhat differently. So I would like to at least work on that, because I'm just really uncomfortable with just sort of an arbitrary number that seems like a good one. You know, this year, let's just base it on some projected TOT, and it's okay, that's what it is. And I'm not comfortable with that. I'm not necessarily continuing to be comfortable with tying the...

5:09:05 Let's bring that back as part of the agendized.

5:09:29 Discussion that was just approved in the last item. Actually, my question is more to the town manager and whether or not he would feel comfortable directing his staff to do this. We can take a look at that. Yeah, marketing's tough, but I think there's some folks we can definitely talk to and get a better feel for where we're at. So we can bring that back in that discussion. All right, thank you. Okay, then, moving on. 9.5. Yes, indeed, folks. It's been a long one.

5:10:02 Transition to in-person meetings, protocols for town council meetings. If I could lead this off, I may be able to keep it to a little shorter discussion with a little bit of a modified recommendation that's what's sitting in the staff report. The two issues in this one really was looking at some protocols discussed last time and masking and verification of vaccinations and stuff for people coming into suite Z.

5:10:32 I think some real consternation to be able to do that and what that means to just have a greater level of conflict potentially with our public and how we handle them. But I think given where we're at in the pandemic at the beginning of the meeting, we gave you an overview, some challenges, the things that we're seeing just in terms of things bumping up. We do see some people who are vaccinated either sick and or positive COVID without symptoms. It could be spreading that.

5:11:00 So the request here would be, as much as I don't like pushing this off, I think for the reality's sake, I think you're probably going to be looking into September at least before you go to a formalized bringing everybody back in together. As it is now, I think with the open meeting where people can come in if they so desire, or if another council member wanted to come in, they could. I know there's some conflicts coming up in August and September, frankly, with council members.

5:11:29 We'd be glad to discuss it at the level you like, but the recommendation really would be, if you wish to consider a full council level in person, that it's least pushed out into the September timeframe. And I say that in part because we just don't know where this pandemic is going this summer and even into the fall. We know at this point we can continue this process through the end of September. Whether that gets extended again at the state level, we don't know.

5:11:56 But I think we feel much more cautious, not pushing for an in-person, you know, everybody feeling obligated to be here at this point in time. Just given where we're at with the data that's coming in over the last few weeks and stuff, I think there's a greater comfort level of if you wish to come in, come in. But I would not want to put that pressure on this group at this point to be everybody together in a meeting in this room with other public members. Given the concerns expressed prior,

5:12:26 Thank you, Dan. That being said, I don't know that we need any kind of a motion or anything.

5:12:55 If you want to come into Suite Z, you can come into Suite Z. If you do not, you are more than welcome to continue to meet through Zoom. It was my intention to potentially even be in the room tonight, but with the changes from the CDC and the Mono County advisories and everything else, I am sort of rethinking that. So you may see me in Suite Z, just so I can practice running a Zoom meeting.

5:13:24 from my laptop at the dais rather than in my house. But other than that, I am more than comfortable from my standpoint, bringing this back before us in terms of in-person meeting sometime in September. Let's move on up, Kirk. Unless there's any other, yeah, oh, sorry. I thought, okay, if there's other comments, Bill, great, thanks. I'm just gonna go through Council, Kirk. Yeah, I'm supportive of,

5:13:56 Meeting again in September. Yep. In the council chamber. Yep. Sarah? Yeah, I'm fine with kicking this down the road. I am not stoked about hanging out in the room with people breathing right now. What about with people that aren't breathing? Well, then that's another issue altogether. If I can't get a laugh out of you once a meeting, I haven't done it. John?

5:14:29 Yeah, that would be called dinner. Yeah. I just play it. Let's just play it as it goes. I'm certainly happy here. I don't want to, I think, you know, let's just play it as it comes. And Linda. He has three computers. The last couple of days, I may never leave home again. So I don't know. It's like, it's not, it's not, not great. So yeah, I think September is a good time to take another look at it. Okay, Dan, you got everything we need to move forward.

5:15:03 Thank you. I am done with that item. Moving on to Councilmember Reports. John? Yeah, John? Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers, I really don't have a report. There's nothing of, things have been busy, but nothing that's, I think, especially germane and of interest to the Council this evening. Holy Moses, call the press. It happens. Linda? Hold on. I'm laughing first.

5:15:39 I don't know. I got home on the 12th and there was a lot of stuff going on and lots of commentary and people wanting to talk about stuff. And then now there's COVID and we're talking about that again. So that's all I have. Thank you very much. Sarah? Yeah, I attended the Mammoth Lake Lodging Association and Restaurant Association. I just listened in. I didn't really participate.

5:16:10 Kind of try to just hear it in the background if I can. I also attended the decennial redistricting.

5:16:17 Public Testimony Meeting. And a few other members of our community were there, Chris Bubser, Sandy Hogan, Stacey Corliss. And we gave public comment to the commission for Zone G to advocate for an assembly district, which would include Mono, Inyo, Mariposa, Tuolumne, Calaveras, Alpine, and parts of the Tahoe Basin and Truckee in an assembly district. So that was pretty cool to have a part in. So that's what I have for this week.

5:16:47 And thank you for participating in that, Sarah. That is an important piece. Clerk. Just an update on the Mammoth Lake Housing wait list. We're still at 88. We don't seem to be able to fill or find units for them. And we continue, Mammoth Lake Housing continues to work on the 238 project. And when that is completed in 2023, I believe we'll have 11 more units.

5:17:16 So that's all I have to report. Thank you. And while I have gone to several meetings and met with several other people, nothing of consequence, so I'm going to make no report. Rob, you came back on. Does any other staff members wish to speak on anything? No. Good. With that, I am going to move us into closed session. Dan, can you move us into a room or do you have a separate link for this?

5:17:46 Yeah, we just sent out to your email an invite for the Zoom meeting for this. If we could take a five-minute break before that and take a look at your email, then you'll have the Zoom link for that. If you don't have it, I'll stay on this one for a moment and let me know and then we can make sure that you have the link or I'll send it again. Thank you.