TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

637 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:40 Linda, you have such a stern look on your face. You're muted. What's new? Story of our lives, right? Indeed, indeed. Any big excitement this afternoon? Yeah, a fair amount of cases. Not surprising. I guess, yeah. Hey, Stu. Hey, Stu. Are we live, by the way? Yeah, well, yeah, probably. Yes, you are.

3:42 Dan, I'm assuming Kirk is with you in Sweet Z? Yes, he is. I'm here. Thank you all. In that instance, I apologize for being a moment or too late. I will call this meeting of the Town Council for August 4th to order. Roll call, please. Council Member Wray is absent. Council Member Staff? Here. Council Member Wentworth?

4:21 Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Here. Mayor Salzer. Present. Thank you, Jamie. Pledge of Allegiance. We're going to spring this one on Dan tonight. Dan, you want to lead us in the pledge? Please join me in the pledge to our fight. I pledge allegiance. For which it stands, it is liberty and justice for all. Okay, we almost got that right.

5:03 Public comments. Now is the time for any member of the public wishing to comment on anything other than what is on the agenda. Jamie, do we have any public comments? Yes, we do. We have a gentleman in Sweet Z. Good evening. My name is Mark Davis. I've lived in Mammoth for almost 40 years, and I don't believe we've ever faced times like we're facing right now. Rhetorical question for this town council. Are we a community or are we a commodity?

5:38 As a commodity, real estate agents are really happy about the way things are right now. Development is proposing some real boom and bust development. We've tried this before. It fails. Resort and tourism economy, it is our basis. But is it more important than the community? Apparently so.

6:02 And corporations and corporation dollars will be well represented at this council and in your decisions. But how about the people? That's who I'm here to speak for, the community. And this community is hurting, maybe even dying. People, voters are facing huge challenges. Your decisions can make this better or much worse. Housing is not being treated.

6:33 As an appropriate priority, it should be number one, no less, no way should anything be more important because this community is dying without it. Small businesses cannot hire help. Help cannot find housing. And housing rates are skyrocketing far beyond what people are paid. This community is hurting and maybe even dying. We need livability. People didn't come here just to work.

7:03 Can you believe it? But I think that this council has potentially forgotten that, that people come here because it's a wonderful place to live. Livability isn't three jobs. A place to raise children. If we're too much of a commodity, we're our families. Growth is not the answer. We've tried outgrowing this before. Boom and bust has existed in Mammoth since 1877. And boom and bust has always busted.

7:36 And we're heading down that road again right now. Your leadership is the only thing that stands between us and catastrophe. And it's time to consider really desperate measures. I ask that this town council examine a slow or no growth policy. Stop trying to grow out of your problems. You're growing the problems faster than you're growing the solutions. This is our community. I know you care.

8:05 But I must ask that you also act. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Any further public comments? Yes. Stacey Corliss, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Good afternoon, counsel. Stacey Corliss, I'm speaking as an individual today, not representing the Mono County Board of Supervisors in any way. And I hope you'll indulge me. I may not be able to comment on later items. So I just, I want to commend this counsel and town staff.

8:38 On the historic investment in housing that you have made and that you are discussing today, this is the right direction and we need to keep going. I want to add to those comments some things I said to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board today.

8:56 You know, there's been a lot of controversy, I'm sure we've all seen about an ad campaign that was launched late last week, and they made a quick course correction that I just want to say I really appreciate it. And I appreciate all their work to support mitigating the impacts, the negative impacts of tourism and recreation that we've experienced over the last couple of years.

9:20 Now they have this campaign, Hug What You Love, and it really is in the right spirit, inviting our visitors to be part of our community, to engage with us in stewardship of our public lands. And all I want to say to council today, too, is I hope you, and I ask this of the MLT board, too, and I'll ask it of my own board of supervisors, is that you embrace this spirit of stewardship, of kindness and collaboration.

9:47 As we tackle these intractable problems like our current housing crisis that's impacting the town, the county, and so many other mountain communities across the country and resort communities across the country. I was disappointed in the discussion a couple weeks ago with the MLT board by comments that were made by MLT and some council members and in negotiations with other town-affiliated NGOs.

10:17 It seems like we're not, you know, sometimes in these negotiations that we're not on the same team. So I just urge the council to take this spirit of collaboration in which we all have to compromise and probably give up something and work together. We're all part of this community. We all need to be part of solutions. We need to create a shared vision and find common goals. Let's focus on where we want to go and who we want to be as a community.

10:45 Instead of protecting our individual or organizational interests. We really are in this together, and I hope that that's what we remember when we face these difficult issues that we're facing that you just heard about from Mark. Please count on me to support you and be a partner in all of this, and I'm sure the county as well. Thank you. Thank you, Stacey. Any further public comments? Ashley Toops, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

11:19 Hi, everybody. Thank you so much. I will make this completely as brief as possible. As I know, some of what I have to say is redundant and everyone knows about the situation. I was the one that started a Facebook post about the most recent MLT, Visit Mammoth advertisement that I think brought it to a lot of people's attention. Well,

11:47 I appreciate, and I know the community appreciates that the backpedaling has begun on that and that the website changed. I have been hearing a lot and agree that we're interested in what happens next as far as looking at the massive budget for advertising that MLT receives. I know some of that money has been voted on and has been allocated specifically for that purpose.

12:17 But maybe not all of it. The community wants some of the money, whatever money we can take to make a real difference beyond repeatedly asking visitors to be better. Some of the people that come up here and look at our beautiful home and think it's okay to throw trash on the ground because there isn't anywhere to put it aren't going to stop doing that because we ask them to.

12:43 We need money for housing, for employees, for our businesses, surely. And nobody, I think, is arguing against that. But we also need personnel to help patrol the dispersed campers' areas that we've been told repeatedly we don't have money to hire those people. Yet we have fires that are out of control and tons of trash in those areas. We need more bear-proof trash cans for recreational areas.

13:12 More bathrooms at trailheads and other high traffic recreation areas. Because I'm pretty sure most people would rather use a restroom than poop in the woods. Sorry to be so frank. But that's a serious problem we have. And part of it's because there are no bathrooms or very few bathrooms. And also just more simple things like doggy bag stations with larger trash cans in more areas.

13:41 I feel like maybe we can start with the easy one, the Measure A money. Maybe we can discuss what funds from TBID can be taken from marketing and distributed to infrastructure that will actually benefit the business community and the greater Mammoth Lakes and Eastern Sierra community as a whole. The money that was spent on that campaign that's been quickly taken down has already been wasted, but I think we still want more answers.

14:11 I'm afraid if we don't push for the accountability and change, we're going to see more terrible unchecked spending in our future. We would like transparency about where that money is going, as it is in very large sum of money, and we would like some help with what we've been asking for, for at least the last year to make our town safe and more appealing to the hundreds of thousands of visitors who come here already. Thank you.

14:42 Thank you, Ashley. Any further public comments? No, there are not. Thank you then, Jamie. Moving on, Dan, do we need to add anything or remove anything from the agenda? Just agenda amendment. The introduction of our HR manager, Lynette Dean, is being pulled off. She got called out of town on a family emergency. Thank you, Dan. Moving on then to reports from commission and or departments. Let me see a hand.

15:17 Stu. Thank you, Mayor, members of Council, our community. Just a quick update from Parks and Recreation. I just want to acknowledge and recognize and thank the hundreds of people that came and celebrated Park and Recreation Month with us. That was this past July. We celebrated with free swim days at the Whitmore Pool. We celebrated with free skate nights at the rec zone. And due to that overwhelming demand, we're going to schedule some more of those.

15:49 So we might even kind of get a disco night going as well. So again, just want to acknowledge and recognize everybody for supporting recreation and the value it provides our community. Camps are going exceedingly well. We've only got a couple of weeks to go. They'll wrap up on August 17th. So providing that update and summary to the commission in a later meeting. And we announced last night at the commission meeting that we have extended the pool.

16:17 Closing date, another week till September 10th. I know we have a lot of interested and eager swimmers down there, so we'll extend our lap swim season by another week. And just quickly, Recreation Commission met yesterday, received a comprehensive presentation on the five-year CIP that was made to Council by Hayes a couple of months ago, so the Commission was very appreciative of the time that Hayes took to walk them through that plan.

16:47 Also received an update on the CRC. We're scheduling that site tour with everybody. So everyone's looking forward to that on August 11th. They finalized their annual work plan calendar and their schedules. So they'll meet on the first Tuesday of every month, which is what they've been meeting for for the last, I don't know, probably decade or so. They didn't change the meeting time. So the commission will still meet on the first Tuesday of every month at 1.30.

17:14 And for the foreseeable future, they have selected or elected to conduct those meetings via Zoom. And just finally, we wrapped up that meeting yesterday with our kind of first discussion of many on our deferred maintenance program of work. As you know, council allocated an additional $300,000, so we have about $340,000 that we want to program and spend perhaps later this fiscal year.

17:44 The majority of that will be spent in the next fiscal year, 2022, 2023. So we started that great discussion and looking forward to further finalizing that program of work. And I believe that is all I had, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Thank you, Stu. And for a personal note, I think at this point, we can stop calling it the Deferred Maintenance Program and just call it our maintenance program, funded in the way we're currently funding it. It has been working very well.

18:13 And hopefully we can continue down that path. Any questions for Stu? Seeing none. Any other reports from commission and or departments? Bill, I do have my hand raised. I'm at the podium. Grady? Okay, Grady. And Hayes does as well. We'll start with Grady and go to Hayes. And you can hear me with this bike like that? Yeah, I hear you. Super. Two things I wanted to talk about. We had our initial air service group meeting. We reinstituted that after about a year off.

18:46 Just this last week, that group was made up of a representative of Mammoth Resorts, MLT, the FBO at the airport, and town staff. And we'll be talking about two things. First of all, air service this winter. Advanced air is scheduled to begin in December. I don't have the routes or schedule at all yet. That's really up to MLT to announce once they're set.

19:05 I know they do include serious discussions about Hawthorne and Palomar down in San Diego County. The second focus of that group will be how do we get to 10,000 employments. If we don't do it next year, certainly in 2023, that's our goal. So that's the two items of the discussion. The other update is we had our most recent FAA Inyo County Bishop Airport meeting. They are getting very close to completing what they need to do to be able to start flights in December with United Airlines.

19:33 There are two outstanding on-site issues. They're having an ARF vehicle, their firefighting vehicle, delivered in mid-August, and then it'll launch right into training for that. And their sprung structure, it's about a 3,000-foot structure, which will act as a portion of their terminal building. I'm not sure if it's been delivered yet, but I know they're advertising for somebody to install that, and that's looking very good as well. What that'll do, that'll allow FAA to issue their Part 139 certificate and complete all their environmental documentation.

20:02 The last thing we had was Mark McLarty in our Bishop meeting. He really wanted to point out two things. One is he hopes the one that we have in August is the last one. He has about 20 FAA staff through it every single meeting for the last year and a half, almost two years, and that's a great amount of resources. But on top of that, he really wanted to mention that in his entire career, and he's been with FAA for 30-plus years, due to retire sometime in the next one or three, depending on who you ask,

20:32 He just wanted to state that he has never seen a region come together to work together with two airports to work on one Bishop Airport and also on a future regional plan. And he wanted to thank the group and make sure that he's telling his other colleagues that he's actually never seen that in his career. And that was a proud moment for him. So that's all I had if you have any questions. Thank you. Any questions for Grady? Seeing none. A's, you're up. All right, Mr. Mayor, I had a question for Grady there.

21:05 Oh, go ahead, John. I didn't see your hand. Sorry. Yeah, no worries. Grady, just as I think you're aware, a discussion about air services coming up in the ESCOG meeting on August 13th, and I know that Elaine's been reaching out to John Urdi, but I'm hoping that's on your radar just in case you or someone from the town could be present to maybe answer any questions that might be coming as part of that discussion. Yeah, I do have that on my calendar, and I'll look for an invite so I can participate as necessary.

21:34 We'll be ready to support and add additional information to whatever MLT has. That'd be great. Thank you very much. Okay. Seeing no other hands. Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So earlier this year, town staff completed a mobility hub study under a Caltrans grant. And as we've discussed previously, this study generated a number of questions, more questions than it actually answered.

22:03 And so since then, staff has consulted with Fear and Peers to try to answer a number of those questions. Fear and Peers is going to complete the Mammoth Lakes Mobility Hub Study Program using some previously collected data and new stakeholder input to determine whether the mobility hubs proposed in the administrative draft are still appropriate. And as part of this process, we are identifying quick build mobility hub strategies that could enhance the use of the existing park and ride lot.

22:30 And determine whether any mobility hub strategies above and beyond what has been proposed already have the potential to enhance the CRC at Mammoth Creek Park. We're going to be posting a new survey that will help us better understand traveler behavior and interest.

22:48 And try to identify strategies that will reduce driving, increase walking, and manage parking, among many other things. So I ask for you to look for this new survey. It's going to be posted here shortly. We have links and QR codes that are going to go up on all of the Town of Mammoth Lakes media. And we hope that you can find the time to take this very important survey. Additionally, we'll have Fear and Peers and Town staff at Belusa Belusa talking to the captive audience there trying to solicit input on this very important study. Thank you.

23:18 Thank you, Hayes. Any questions for Hayes? Yeah, Hayes, was that the, I got an email from Sandra over the weekend. Is that the survey you're referring to? Yeah, it was very well done. I thought it was very well put together. So thanks for that. And hope everybody engages and takes that. It's really important. Thank you. Thank you. Any further reports? Yes, Mr. Mayor, this is Dan looking at a quick update on, hopefully relatively quick.

23:51 On COVID update, a lot of different activity this last week, so we haven't been setting this as a regular agenda item since we dropped our emergency declaration at the town level. It still is in full force and effect at the county level and state level. But we did want to give you a quick update. Brian Wheeler's on the call. We'll have him jump into some of this when getting some of the case rates and some of the discussion here. But a quick update on case rates, some CDC recommendations, some state recommendations.

24:21 Also, a Mono County mask mandate going out for all persons who are in an indoor setting and a public setting. Then a little bit on vaccinations and testing as we continue to work against the COVID-19 disease and the various variants that have come forward, most recently the Delta One that we're battling with at this point in time. Our case rates are definitely moving up in our community.

24:53 Seeing a substantial increase. We had additional ones come in today, and I'll have Brian speak to that. But we've had, in the last month, 38 different cases come into the system here. And this is for the Mono County residents and the rates there. We've actually seen over a couple of dozen or more cases of visitors that have reported to the hospital feeling sick and being tested positive as well.

25:20 Those cases get reported to the county of origin here in the state or out. So we are definitely seeing that bump up and increase. If you look at our case for 100,000, we're at 15.3 cases as of the 24th of July. That may be bumping up a little bit. And a positivity rate about 6.34% in our county. And if you look back a ways back into toward the end of June, we had a zero rate.

25:50 Those types of elements. So we have definitely seen some heavy activity through July and into August through that. I'll have, I think Brian's on. I'm going to invite him to speak a little bit of this in terms of stuff we're seeing, Mono County breakthrough cases. He can explain part of that. We've seen 16 of those, et cetera. So Brian, if you want to speak to this particular slide, I'd appreciate it as we're looking at the impacts here. Sure.

26:18 So, yeah, as Dan mentioned, we have seen 16 breakthrough cases. These individuals were symptomatic. And if you have been following the information related to the Delta variant, you are probably aware that if you're vaccinated and contract the Delta variant, you have the same amount of virus in your nose and throat as an unvaccinated person and can transmit

26:47 To just as many individuals. And with the Delta variant, the RO, or the rate of infection, the number of people that you could potentially infect is five to nine. So for every individual that tests positive, you're going to potentially see five to nine more cases. It's very transmissible.

27:12 It's one of the most transmissible viruses known to man. It's up there with measles and mumps. It's worse than chickenpox. These individuals, some were symptomatic, some were, some had symptoms. However, none have been hospitalized, no one with severe illness. And, you know, that is certainly good at this point. However,

27:37 You know, the more cases we are going to see, eventually we will see increased hospitalizations and serious illness. We had eight cases come in today alone so far. The day is not over. We had four cases come in yesterday, including two people under the age of 10. There is great concern with the Delta variant that children are going to be more susceptible.

28:05 And they are, those who are under 12, as you know, are not eligible for vaccination at this point in time and really have no protection against the virus. We, you know, we continue to do contact tracing and investigation. We have noticed that we are seeing a little bit less cooperation and some people just aren't taking our calls, hanging up or not really giving us any

28:36 And, you know, this is vital for us to, as one of the tools to help stop the spread of the virus. Also, I just want to put on everyone's radar the Lambda variant, which may, and I say may, be able to bypass the vaccine altogether. The data on that is still out. That variant was first seen in Peru in 2020.

29:05 And based on what they've seen, it was bypassing the vaccine that was made in China, which, to be honest, has had a lot of different numbers as far as how effective it is and does not seem to be the best option as far as vaccine. We don't have enough information in the United States. It's only about 5% of cases so far in California.

29:33 That's probably even maybe a little more than that, but the Delta variant is about 93% of the cases sequenced in the country. So Delta is the most prevalent strain currently, and it is obviously the one that's causing most problems, as we can see.

29:59 Not sure what's on the next slide, Dan. Yeah, I was just going to go kind of last statement here. We need to control the spread and to do those things. We've been looking at recommendations coming out of the CDC as well as the state. The recent changes out of the CDC really looked at a recommendation for the use of a mask or face coverings, even for fully vaccinated people to actually do this in an indoor setting.

30:25 Especially if they're substantial and high transmission. We'll speak to some detail on that in a moment. Additional information coming out, looking at the transmission and how impactful it is. And so it's the stuff that Brian was just touching on. The rate of spread is high. Also, if you are, even if you're fully vaccinated and have a known exposure, looking to...

30:50 Get people tested at that point, three to five days or so after that exposure, continue to wear a mask accordingly until they get a negative test result. And so as they are making that recommendation for universal indoor masking, also for the school systems, I think that it will be affecting California as well for teachers and staff and students, et cetera, regardless of vaccination status. And so that's creating some consternation there. But as mentioned,

31:19 Given the ability for the Delta variant to spread, the look at masking is very important. The couple of areas they looked at in terms of the standards in the CDC was that substantial transmission and high transmission. If you look at our numbers there, we are sitting in that high transmission category. Very sorry to see that in our community. It's definitely there. And then just wasn't...

31:47 But a few weeks back, we were in that moderate transmission level. And so based on where we're at and the recommendations coming forward, we have issued, say we in a broad sense there from the EOC in Mono County. And Brian, I'll just speak to some of the details on it. But effective this Friday, August 6th, there will be a mask mandate within Mono County for anybody in a public setting. There are some exceptions for that.

32:16 But for the vast majority of us, it will require us to wear a mask inside. And then the idea being, can we get to a point of three consecutive weeks at that six per 100,000, get back into that modern transmission level within that CDC guideline. So we do have a target in there. We're pushing people to really take a hard look at that. And Brian,

32:43 He's still there, but I can have him speak to a little bit of the details of our, of the mask order, the discussions with that. Dr. Johnson is the current acting health official, so, or health officer, so, is issued underneath his signature there as we get into that element. And, Ryan, if you're still there, if you want to speak to some of the elements of this, then. Absolutely, but before I jump into elements, I did want to cover one other thing. Even though,

33:12 We are seeing breakthrough cases, you know, people that are fully vaccinated getting COVID. The important thing to really remember and focus on is that 99.99% of them don't get hospitalized, don't get severe illness, and I think it's 99.999 do not succumb to the virus. So, you know, still a good, a great virus.

33:41 You know, breakthrough cases or post-vaccination infections, as they're really known, breakthrough cases is kind of the buzzword. They're expected with all vaccines. So this is not anything out of the ordinary, but just something we have to track as it seems that each variant is getting stronger as it mutates. So in regards to the order that we put out on Tuesday,

34:11 And to be clear, we had it go into effect on Friday so that we could communicate with, you know, the business communities, with town council, with the board of supervisors and with the community like we will do tomorrow just to give information, give time for everyone to prepare. We didn't want it to be, you know, happen so fast that no one had a chance to react or didn't see it coming.

34:37 So to be clear, this is just a masking mandate. There are no other restrictions. There's no capacity restrictions. There's no cancellations of events. This is the simplest and most effective step we could take at this point to not only protect our workforce, as we have had a couple of businesses impacted very recently.

35:03 By cases and have had to close or modify their schedules or temporarily close. And those are the types of things we're trying to avoid. And, you know, for the sake of our businesses who have had a rough COVID past how many weeks, I'm not quite sure at this point. And then the other concern is protecting the school students who are under the age of ability to vaccinate as we try to open the schools up.

35:31 I think we all think it's very important for kids to be in school. And, you know, the group that is under this age of 12 is at high risk. And again, there are some studies showing that the Delta variant is potentially more harmful to this age group than variants in the past. So that's why we're asking people to wear a mask for the sake of our workers, our community, and our children.

36:02 Basically, the gist of the order is that when you are in indoor settings, such as grocery stores, restaurants, restaurants until you start to eat, of course, and other, you know, shops and businesses, offices, office settings, the Civic Center here, that a mask is required. And that's really the biggest part of it. You know, outdoor events.

36:32 We recommend you wear a mask if it's a large outdoor event, such as this weekend, we have Balooza, Balooza, and public health will be there conducting, testing, vaccination, providing information and masks, but there's no requirement. So when you're outdoors, you know, if you're working alone, you don't have to wear a mask. When you're in those confined spaces where...

36:57 The virus can easily float around if people aren't wearing masks. And with Delta, there is far more virus than in the other variants that is produced. You know, that is basically the ask, is that you wear a mask. It's plain and simple. And then as with the... Of course, we do have, right, the exemptions, those who are very young to the young to wear a mask, flow too. Certain medical conditions.

37:29 You know, and what we see listed here have the exemption of not wearing a mask. But in general, the general public at this point should be wearing a mask. The statewide order on masking really focused on different areas, public transit, and then the school systems, health care systems. And so there's a few areas within the state that they've issued guidance on requiring that regardless of vaccination status.

37:59 Impacts our local jail, for example, and obviously the hospital who has been wearing masks since day one almost, so they continue to require that. Then the other different areas there is noted that the state's put out, but they haven't done a statewide mandate on indoor use of masks. A number of different counties and cities across the state have imposed similar orders as the one here in Monoke as well. Just kind of a mix of stuff as we go forward between what

38:30 CDC, the state, and what we're seeing here locally coming into that. And with the mask, it's great. I think the key element for protection on the virus really is to get vaccinated. Here in Mono County, we're still doing pretty well in terms of the total number of doses we have and put out there. These may have gone up a little bit, but the last number is approximately 75% of those eligible in Mono County have gotten the first dose. 68% are fully vaccinated.

38:58 And so I think that's an important element in the push on that. There's a number of vaccination clinics that are out there. It's free. There's walk-up. You can RSVP, if you will, for the different types of vaccination that are available. Won't go through all the different areas, but throughout the county, we have them in the town here, a number of other locations. And also, as Brian mentioned, we'll actually be doing some at Balooza Palooza.

39:29 That being available there, a lot of different walk-in clinics you can go to. So one of the key issues on this is really pushing hard for the vaccination status for a couple of things. One, just that protection, stopping the disease. And the other side, as you're hearing the breakthrough cases, if you've been vaccinated, you're still catching the disease. The impact is minimal. I mean, in terms of if you're not really sick as bad, you know, you're not seeing much hospitalization from that.

40:00 On the other hand, if you're not and you catch it a lot more in terms of just severeness of the illness again that happens with that. Then the other side is to continue the testing side of it, encouraging people to go back again. We've seen a substantial increase in the number of people being tested as the virus has expanded out. I'll just say yesterday they had a pop-up testing clinic right outside of Vons. Personally stopped by, Bob, get tested.

40:29 24 hours later, you get the result back and negative. So that was good. But it's out there. It's free, encouraging people to continue to do that. It does two things. It helps us with the overall surveillance of going on in our community, especially with the Delta virus and vaccinated people as there's a lot of asymptomatic. And so you don't know it unless you're tested, but you actually could be sharing the virus with friends and family and coworkers.

40:58 And then also, again, just looking at that positivity rate is one of the measurements, what is going on in our community to really get to know that. And we do have free testing at different locations, again, throughout the community, throughout Mono County, different places there to get people in and have that review done. As Brian mentioned, we are trying to get this information out to our community. We will have a bilingual community conversation scheduled for tomorrow, August 5th.

41:28 I think you covered it pretty well. Questions? John?

42:02 Dan, Brian, are we, what's the status of the EOC at this point and do you guys anticipate having to maybe start to regroup and regather with that team? Yeah, we've increased our meetings already. I think we've met like four times in the past couple weeks, Dan, something like that. Yes. So we are keeping a close eye on things and meeting more frequently to the extent we're going to have to ramp up.

42:30 It's yet to be seen. You know, the question is, will this be a large wave like last summer or a potentially smaller wave because of the amount of people we have vaccinated? We will continue to monitor and make those decisions based on, you know, the current, what's going on currently. And Dan, I'm assuming that the question for you may be for Andy, that all of our

42:56 Emergency orders, decrees, all that stuff are still in place in effect, or are we going to have to be revisiting things? All at the local level, all of the local orders have been lifted. The state ones are still in place as far as an emergency step and different elements there that the governor has issued, i.e. our ability to have this meeting in this format. That continues through at least the end of September. The town has actually lifted our emergency declaration if things...

43:25 Turned relief sideways. We could come back and issue another one if we needed to. At this point, we're operating underneath the counties and the EOC is active. As Brian mentioned, we've had several smaller group meetings the last few weeks. We have another regular scheduled broader group meeting tomorrow. Those will continue as necessary and as frequently as we need to be able to respond accordingly to that and feel free.

43:51 I don't really have anything to add to that. Everything that's being said is right. We could get back to our state emergency. That's what happens when you go to suite Z, Andy. Any other questions? I'll ask mine. Brian, the 16 breakthroughs, over what period of time is that? And how many regular infections have we seen in that same time? So those have been over the last two months and about 38 cases total.

44:27 I'm approximating. I don't have that exact figure, but those are the approximate figures in timeline. Yeah, it just seems that what we're seeing nationally for the breakthrough percentage, we are way over that, and that is concerning to me. I don't know what the cause could be. Phil, we're really not. If you look at the total number of vaccines delivered, and, you know, we're talking about 8,154 individuals who are fully vaccinated.

44:58 16 breakthrough cases statistically is pretty low. I think nationally they're saying, although it, you know, the numbers kind of change daily. The last I heard was somewhere between one and four percent of vaccinated people could experience breakthrough cases. But again, we will have to see as this evolves. Okay, thank you. Further questions? Kirk, you're there. I can't.

45:32 See you if you have questions. Now's the time. No questions. Thank you. In that case, thank you all. We will move on. Any other reports from commissions and or departments? Thank you, Brian. Thank you all. Have a good night. Mr. Mayor, I've got a couple of questions for the town manager, if you have a second. Yes, go ahead, John. So, Dan, I just want to...

45:57 Perhaps state a couple of obvious points, but to follow up in the last council meeting, some of the actions that were taken that perhaps didn't get reported in the local press and local media. I know some of these things on the agenda this evening, but perhaps we could just reiterate some of the actions taking place in the last meeting. First off, can you just share with the council, with the public, the amount of money that the council appropriated for housing? I know you were going to go back and do some true up on that number. What does that number look like at this point?

46:24 Yeah, that will be an item here coming up on the agenda formally, but we committed new dollars at $5.7 million, and then we had $300,000 previously that will go into our housing fund to help support the 238 Sierra Manor project with MLH. So we will be seeing $6 million committed to housing. There's some other smaller amounts going into our maintaining our revolving loan fund and some additional dollars going into that housing fund that have not been.

46:53 Okay, good. And the second question has to do with a lot of concern with folks about the relationship of Measure A

47:21 T-Bid, how do we as a community market ourselves? And it's technical. There's some technical things in there. And I think we've talked about having a workshop coming up in the relatively near future for council to have a discussion about what Measure A is, how that works, what the T-Bid is, how that works, how the various authorities that the town council has over those various pots of monies, maybe give a quick update. And when we anticipate, we're going to have that workshop and that conversation.

47:48 Yeah, we definitely took that to heart as we met with each of our NGOs talking about coming back and reviewing agreements, contracts, funding, explaining how some of the funding works and the commitments of it. That will be at meetings scheduled by the Town Council later in the agenda. At the end of the agenda, we've actually asked Council to take a look at some times and dates coming forward to actually move those types of meetings forward for those types of discussions across our various

48:18 I think it'd be very helpful. I've had a number of constituents ask me about, you know, who's responsible for this. I think this unfortunate ad that was up last week really amplified a lot of that. And I think it's, I don't think anybody should make any foregone conclusion that the council, at least I speak for myself, it's an automatic, it's not a gimme that the TBID is going to get renewed. I think we've got a lot of work to do here.

48:43 To figure out exactly how that's going to work. And finally, Dan, I know that staffs are working on, I think, from the direction from the last meeting to come up with a simple and easy to understand allocation that the town will hopefully be making on an annual basis out of TOT funds for housing. I know that's in the works. Maybe give an idea of when we might expect to see a nice, clear, simple, easy to understand.

49:09 Allocation that the town with its partners will be making the housing on an annual basis. Yes, a couple of things for that. One is in the capital improvement program that the council saw here a while back, we are allocating dollars into housing as part of that program. It's a nice place to put it. Ultimately, it's a capital program or it's an investment in future housing as capital asset in our community.

49:35 We put $1.4 million in the current year, and that's been allocated as part of the action that you'll be taking, a recommendation. We have an additional $1.1 million next year committed in there. Our goal on that, that'll probably get adjusted a little bit, but the idea behind that would be the equivalent of a 1% TOT based on our budgets going forward that we would be allocating through that capital improvement program, committing those dollars.

50:02 And then being able to move them into particular programs, depending on the priority of the council, working with our partners as we go forward. But I think if we can enhance that level of general fund dollar commitment, both coming from the town, our town-held reserves related to tourism, our town-held reserves related to housing, to have a minimum of a 1% TOT committed through that process. Plus, if we have additional resources, obviously we can do that too.

50:32 A systematic commitment of that through our capital improvement program is very effective. It works. It allows the council to have discretion and authority over how that money is invested into housing, but also highlights through probably several different opportunities the amount of dollars that the town is investing in this particular area.

50:53 That's great. Looking forward to that. I know all of us who follow the Community Housing Action Plan, there's a recommendation in there for the council to put a revenue proposal in front of the voters. I know Lynda and I, we were talking about that back prior to COVID, and it would be a great first step if the council and the town can work together to say, before we take something to the voters, we're going to get to 1% TOT allocation of housing before we even have to get to that question. I think that would be great.

51:20 Great progress. So, Dan, thanks for those updates. I just want to, anything we can do to make this clear to the public, especially in light of the kinds of public comments we got this evening is helpful. So, thank you very much. Yeah, John, I didn't want to get into the conversation now, but since you brought it up, important to note that the $6 million that Dan is talking about is allocations for this year. That's only a one-year allocation. And I think the misunderstanding is in how we run our budget and how we end up with the millions of dollars, like our $6 million this year.

51:50 That we have spent year over year over year for the last several years. But I caution us to be careful about just throwing money at the wall and not having an actual program to fund. I think we, and Dan, I think as these things come forward, we invested in a whole number of things that are part of a program. And that's, again, part of the challenge, I think, to you, town manager and staff, to make this easily understood to the public, how much money we're appropriating, where it's going.

52:20 And we're not going to get lost in a lot of Excel sheets and a lot of budget minutiae. It's really critically important for us as elected officials to be able to go to the public and say, this is how much is going into it. This is where it's going. And anything along those lines would be really helpful. So thank you. Yep. Thanks, John. Anything else from commissions and or departments? I almost forgot where I was. I think Linda's got her hand up. Yeah, I've got my hand up here. Go ahead.

52:49 Okay, thanks. Yeah, I wanted to point out to the community and also to each other once more that our community update that's begun to come out on a weekly basis, usually from Stu, is a really great kind of look at what council has done just in the last week. And because it's a weekly...

53:09 Newsletter, if you will. It should be going out far and wide. If you know people that you are aware of who are not receiving this, those spoke to several of the items, John, that you brought up right here, and that is a good opportunity for us. And the question for staff is, is that being placed in our media at all? I mean, I know it's online media. What about print media within the county? Well, we ship it out to our notify me list and on social media.

53:38 We're not paying for placement in the print component at this level, but it does go out to a large distribution of people. I think that includes the press as well. Yeah, I would be curious to know if there are other council people that, you know, council members who wonder if that would not be worth the expense. Do we believe that there are certain people in our community who don't follow social media and would indeed see it in a print media? Is there any, you know,

54:08 Comment on that. The more education we can do, the better. I don't know what format it would move into to pay it to move forward, but always interested in looking. Any comments from any other council members? Okay. Could we maybe hear and talk about that at one of our next meetings to see what kind of cost that would be, and if staff feels that that's justified, I think it might be a...

54:40 Something to talk about. Yeah, I don't know if we'll have it ready for the exact next meeting, Linda, but definitely something we're looking at of how do we get it out there and do we look at some actually paid elements and what does that begin to look like hopefully to get attention from the community as a way of communicating additional information out. It is in our current work program looking at those elements. Okay, good, because I think it's a great piece that's going out and I think it's well worth a read and I know why.

55:06 Forward it wildly. And I think everybody else does too. I see it on Facebook. I see it on Instagram. But I think I see it on Instagram. Anyway, it's definitely worth it. And kudos to staff and to Stu who's putting that together. Thank you, Linda. Moving on then to item 6.1, recognition of retiring finance manager, Cindy Myrold. Rob, you're leading us on this. Yes, I am. Mayor Sauser and council members.

55:41 My pleasure to present to you tonight a little bit of a celebration for Cindy Myrold's 22 years of service to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Cindy started work for the town July 1999, and her last day was just a few days ago, July 2021. So a long and good career and challenging career and wonderful moments.

56:06 She started in July of 1999 as an accounting assistant in charge of accounts payable, sort of worked up her way through that through promotions and other processes. She started as a revenue collection person and in 2003 became the supervisor of that revenue department. 2005 she was promoted to accounting manager taking on the annual audit processes which are quite extensive for the town.

56:33 Very, very much appreciated all the work there that she has done. But that dedication, that effort, that energy sort of won those opportunities for her. The things that kind of went on after that, Cindy took on a number of key roles within the finance department in really critical times. As you know, we have litigation time, the aftermath of litigation, and the challenges that fell within the finance area. So Cindy's sort of the area.

57:03 Keeping all of that together and navigating through that entire process. I had some staff talk to me the other day, and they'd been here for a very long time, and they said, you know, sort of an end of an era without Cindy there, because she had been there for the entire time that they had been employed at the town. So, I know when I started, I arrived in 2016, you know, she was in the position of a finance manager, and, you know, really extremely helpful for me.

57:32 25 years prior to that, we're all in private finance and accounting and really sort of understanding the public side of things and how they work. And, you know, she tried. I'm a little bit hard-headed sometimes, but she tried really to get me to understand, but at the same time also listened, you know, to what I was trying to do and was open to going in new directions and really working on that. I came to rely obviously extensively on her experience and that willingness to listen.

58:00 Cindy really understands the role of a town employee and the fact that we may be called upon to perform duties that are outside of our normal roles and responsibilities. It could be shoveling out drains and a flood. In this last experience with Cindy, she was the finance section chief for our USC operations. And so that understanding, that willingness to kind of put the community first is such a tremendous asset.

58:30 And it's something Cindy totally understands. One of Cindy's strongest suits, I think, is developing lifelong friendships with people that she has worked with. She always really often champions for their success and really tries to help mentor them and really understand how she can contribute to the success they have or maybe even provide them with an opportunity that is helpful. And that's just really amazing. And people see that.

59:00 Her big heart, genuine caring for others. And that's sort of what sort of gets people to migrate towards her in that friendship that she has. The size of her heart and dedication is evident in the last few months. She continued to serve the needs of the town and help us keep afloat as she processed through the loss of her beloved husband, Larry. I'm both in awe and humbly grateful for her efforts there. Cindy is already missed.

59:33 We talked on the phone the other day, and she said, you know, I don't miss the work so much, but I definitely miss the people, and that's true. So, Cindy, I want to thank you for the years of dedicated service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I hope the next chapter of your life does bring you. You're welcome to say some words, and we have a plaque, and we have some flowers. I want to say thank you to everybody and Town Council and the community for these last few months have been really, really hard, and the community really stepped up.

1:00:11 Came forward, helping me through this process. So thank you. While everyone's hugging Cindy, I just want to say that during the litigation of bankruptcy days, that was a hard, that was hard times for all of us here at the town for a couple years. And I, I honestly don't think we would have gotten through it without you. That you, yeah, you were indispensable. We could not have done that without you.

1:02:01 Okay. Council, would you like to add anything? Just a beautiful moment and wish we could have been there to share our love. Thanks and respect for Cindy all the great work she's done. Really great to see the team be able to do this kind of stuff in person. Only wish we could be there. A beautiful moment. Thank you for sharing.

1:02:58 Yes, indeed. I think John said it well. Cindy, we wish you the very, very best going forward and thank you for all the years of all of your hard work and really caring about the town and everyone who lives and works here. So you will be greatly missed. Most of what I know of town finance I learned sitting in her office. So she is missed. Sorry. A Kirk. We go back a long way. She's held my hand more than once.

1:03:33 Thank you for everything you've done. Okay. Unless someone has other things they'd like to say, anyone else on the Zoom, I will move forward to staff presentation, code compliance officer update. Rick. Thank you, Mayor, Council. Thank you for having me. So I'm going to ask to give a little update of what I've been working on for the last few months. So I'm going to start off with some of the main stuff that we've been doing.

1:04:15 We're working mainly on quality of life calls. Jenna also does this, as does Kari. Basically, we go through town and we're looking at all the super nice free items that people are trying to get rid of, which usually stays there for over the weekend. On Mondays, we're forced to call Mammoth Disposal. First, we can start with the property owner to give them an opportunity to clear it out. Excuse me. And then we end up having a Mammoth Disposal. Rick, if you want to share your...

1:04:45 Slideshow, if you have it there, that'd be great. It's not up on the screen? It's not on our screen. Let me try one more time here. Is that working? Yes. All right, there we go. So basically, that's what we're looking at here. So these are just items, this is just from the last couple weeks, things we find usually on Monday mornings, usually at the end of the month, at the beginning of the month as people are moving out. Wildlife calls we've had so far this year. In 2021, we've had 35 bear calls.

1:05:28 We've had two deer killed by a mountain lion. Been in contact with the biologist for, the local biologist for Fish and Wildlife who's conducting the mountain lion study in our area. We had a video posted on our Critters and Co-Compliance page a few weeks back that was provided to us by someone out of Snow Creek. I showed that to the biologist and he actually showed me a map of where the mountain lion's been traveling. So he's been way up

1:05:58 Up by Duck Lake, it comes down right through the middle of town and walks through a straight north, starting right at Snow Creek and all the way up Minaret and then to June Lake and back. It seems to be, it's actually a female, seems to be her pattern. So we've had two deer killed. I confirmed it with a biologist that it was, those were mountain lion kills based on how they looked. We've had one coyote call. We have one suspected bat bite.

1:06:29 And an actual jaguar call, which I'm highly suspect of. So I'm not sure, I'm pretty sure they're not in North America. So some photographs of some of the wildlife calls we've had in the last few weeks. So this is a mother and one of her cubs. The other cub was up in the tree. This was taken between mono and lupine. There's another female, a larger female. This one's actually pretty young.

1:07:00 Maybe just a couple years old. There's a larger female that's been on Burner Street that's generated quite a few calls. And she also has two cubs. This is a photograph taken at the Ventura Grand Hotel. This is the cooler that was in the back of someone's car. There was nothing in it. So there was no scent that attracted the bear to this car. But when the bear walks by, they're familiar with what a cooler is.

1:07:30 And it's going to take its chance to see what's in there. This is a photograph of a vehicle where the bear got stuck in the car. They're really good at getting in. They cannot get out usually, so they destroy the car in an attempt to get out. I'm assuming this car was total. Again, no food in this car, as they claimed, but you never know. This is kind of a gross one. Sorry about that. This is one of the mountain lion kills. This deer was actually pulled out of Mammoth Creek. And based on the map that I saw from Fish and Wildlife,

1:08:01 This was killed by that female. There's another one that was off of, I can't remember the name of the street off the top of my head, a tamarack, excuse me, where it was the same cat it looked like, as you can see where the cat stalls and kind of tries to dispose of it. What we're concerned about is that if you look at the picture, it's almost like a surgical incision that the mountain lions do, but usually at this point they'll eat the,

1:08:29 The viscera of the animal. In this case, the animal we were assuming was animal spooked and the deer fell into the water and didn't get a chance to eat it. The other one had the same type of thing where the deer was actually buried. This is a coyote that's been frequenting the Vons parking lot. I've been getting calls that some people are throwing food at it, which I would like to see stopped. I have to catch someone doing that so I can cite them for that. Domestic animal calls.

1:09:00 Or domestic animals as a whole. With the help of Crystal Stewart, we started an online registration program, licensing program for domestic animals. I believe this is the same system that Mono County is using, as well as Inyo County, and with it, we'll be able to cross-reference what dogs are registered within the counties and within the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Over the last couple of months,

1:09:31 We've had a total of eight animal bites for June and July. One of them was a cat that took place in the house, and the rest were kind of weird ones. None of them are sightable offenses. We've had seven other dog bites. One was an owner bitten by their dog at home. One was a dog on a leash at Tied Up that bit the waiter. One literally jumped out of a car as the car was moving and bit someone. One ran through a screen and attacked a dog.

1:10:02 So the screen door was shut, the dog just plowed right through it. This was one of the people that were bitten. It was a dog walker with three large dogs, and she was literally dragged by the dogs as it tried to bite someone. Actually, one of them succeeded in biting someone. One literally opened to the storm door with the lever handle. And one dog was off leash at McLeod, which her...

1:10:32 We've issued three quarantine letters. So dogs that do bite a human being and draw blood, the animal has to be quarantined. It's a 10-day quarantine. Two of those dogs were local dogs and one we did on behalf of Santa Cruz County. The people who reside in Santa Cruz and they found out they were coming to Mammoth to visit. So the people on this one from Santa Cruz, they're very cooperative. They kept the dog within the...

1:11:02 The building where they were staying while they were here. Early in June, just before the camping season got in the full swing, I met with the camp host. It's usually a meeting that I have with U.S. Forest Service and Department of Fish and Wildlife, and we give them information on what to do about wildlife, what to do about anything that comes through their camp. This time, however, it was just me. Forest Service was busy with a fire down in Lone Pine.

1:11:34 And our local warden is out on medical leave. For the summer, I changed my work hours. Someone was talking about illegal fires out in the Shady Rest area and out in the Scenic Loop. I actually changed my hours so I can address that on Friday and Saturday nights. And so far, it's been pretty successful. Last year at this time, I had multiple fires, illegal campfires in the Lakes Basin area.

1:12:04 Lakes Basin has not been as busy as it was last year. The people out on the scenic loop, they all are kind of self-policing. There's quite a few people who live there for the summer, and when campers come up and try to start a fire, I've actually been told by the people who try to start fires that the regulars come up and go, hey, you cannot do that. So that's good to hear.

1:12:28 And I've been working with the Forest Service, keeping people out of the Shady Rest area, or just that forest area just north of Shady Rest. During that meeting, I also created this little pamphlet for them. We usually get a bunch of stuff from the Department of Fish and Wildlife, but there's a lot of information. I decided that to streamline it, this is pretty much all they need on what to do about feeding bears and how to secure your food. I also gave them a list of the...

1:12:57 I've been concentrating my patrols there in the Lakes Basin mostly for parking. Last summer parking was...

1:13:28 Completely out of control up in the lakes basin. It's been substantially better this year. Last year I was averaging about 22 citations per day, mostly for blocking traffic. This year I'm averaging about five per day in the lakes basin, which is a lot better than it was last year. Again, looking for illegal fires. The illegal campers that we had last summer in the lakes basin have not materialized like they did last year. A lot of the campgrounds do have room.

1:13:57 I know last year, especially in June, all of our campgrounds were closed, so that kind of added to the problem. Again, with illegal camping, I've been patrolling up just north of Shady Rest and just making sure that the people who are camping right next to the park and within that two-mile limit of sawmill cutoff know that they cannot camp there, so we're working with the Forest Service there as well. Mark Scott is our local

1:14:27 Law enforcement officer at the Forest Service. He and I have planned on conducting night patrols together, but so far the need is not material, unfortunately. In addition to Forest Service patrols, just on my throne there as bragging rights for last weekend. I happened to be in the parking lot. Some guy comes running out and went, man, we just called 911. That was fast. So I just happened to be there. I'll take credit for it. The lady was dehydrated on the Heart Lake Trail. So I went and checked on her.

1:14:58 Gave an assessment to dispatch and they confirmed what trail they're on. Luckily, I was there because they had told dispatch they were on the Duck Pass trail. So it was a completely different trail. She was all right. She was able, we carried her out on a Stokes basket and she was okay as far as anyone we love. This is kind of a weird one. This just materialized last week. It's a roadkill initiative with a Department of Fish and Wildlife.

1:15:28 The last few years, anytime we have an animal that's wounded or that's found dead on the highway, we usually just dispose of it in the woods. I contacted the local biologist and we came to the conclusion that there's a freezer available at the, a walk-in freezer at the hatchery. So instead of just throwing the animals out, we've been saving the deer so that they can use them for studies. They use them to bait bear traps and to bait mountain lion traps.

1:15:57 So at least the deer are not being wasted. So that's kind of a weird sentiment, but I've always hated just throwing these things away. I like to see them being used, at least for something useful. Other activities, we're still maintaining, or helping maintain the Town of Mammoth Lakes Critters and Co-Complains page. We do updates on it. We post videos, talk about new initiatives and things that are coming up on various days. So that's one of the things I've been working on.

1:16:30 Other activities, we participated in the town cleanup, and I believe that was in May or late May, early June. We had the health fair with the CHP, where we had 10 car seats given out and installed, and four that were inspected during the course of the health fair. That's pretty much all I've been working on. Does anybody have any questions for me? Any questions for Rick? Let's start with John. Thank you very much.

1:17:05 Great presentation, the great work you're doing. Just checking to see if you're aware of the Camp Like a Pro program that Monroe County's been running for dispersed camping. If you're not, there's a lot of great collateral literature. There's a website. There's a bunch of resources. I can probably look to Kim Anaclario from Mammoth Lakes Recreation to get you connected with that. It might be really helpful for you when you're talking to people. I know it's got a lot of presence in the stores and shops, but it sounds like you're...

1:17:32 You're keeping the appropriate hours for the tasks that you're doing and going to the places. So, Dan, maybe we could get Kim Anteclaria connected with Richard for that. One quick question about Mountain Lion. That range was from Duck Lake down, coming down, like the Duck Pass drainage into cold water. Did I hear that right? Well, it starts off in Duck Lake. That's the initial point on the map that I saw.

1:18:00 It's kind of weird. Usually they kind of walk in a big circle and they don't really deviate from their path. This one seems to be walking in straight lines. So it's not coming down through the cold water area. It looks like it's kind of circumventing and coming down almost west of the bluffs and then dropping down to Snow Creek from there. So I'm not sure how she's navigating those rocks, but I guess they're called mountain lions for a reason.

1:18:28 All right, well, good. Let's get you connected with Kim in that moment. Yeah, I was not aware of that program. I'd like to see some of that literature. Yeah, great. I think it's been very successful. Could be really helpful for what you're doing after. Thank you. Thank you. Linda. Hi, Rick. Good work. I mean, a really wide range of things you're doing and so useful. So, no, I'm just very happy to see you.

1:18:53 Doing everything you're doing. I would like to see that Jaguar when it wanders through town. I'd be interested in myself in seeing that. Yeah, be sure and let us know about that. So, no questions, but thank you. All right, thank you. Thank you, Linda Kirk. I have no question. Thank you for all your work. Thank you. Rick, are the bears, are we only dealing with them when we get calls or are you noticing when they're getting too close and hazing them so they stay afraid of humans?

1:19:24 Well, I had one last. It's kind of a mix of both. Usually, I'll drive around and look for them. When I worked for Fish and Wildlife, they had a saying, it was actually a classification of a bear called No Harm, No Foul. So they're not really doing anything that's out of the ordinary. I really don't do much with them. But we did have one last week that started off over at the Sunflower Condos and made his way over to behind.

1:19:53 Jimmy's Taverna. He was going through a bag of trash that I thought they had left out, but what it turned out was the guy who was throwing the trash out ran into the bear and dropped it and took off. So I got up to the bear, I bumped him with a bumper, hit my air horn, and from there I kind of chased him all the way to the high school. Once at the high school, it was safe for me to use a non-lethal deterrent.

1:20:21 Wildlife beanbag projectiles are shot out of a 12-gauge shotgun. But I don't like doing, I wouldn't do that in the middle of town, so I made sure I had a clear shot and haze them all the way out and chase them through the trails. And he got to the point where as soon as he heard the sound of the shotgun racking, he would run. And that's what I want from them. I want them to hear the word bear and be afraid of that word. That's the first thing everybody yells.

1:20:49 I usually yell bear just before I shoot a beanbag at him. Thank you. Thank you. Any public comments or questions? No, there are not. In that case, thank you very much. All right. Thank you for having me. Moving on to a housing financing overview. Grady, I understand you're going to kick us off on this one. Okay. Grady, it doesn't show you're muted, but I cannot hear you. Nothing yet. We'll give Grady a minute to log back in.

1:22:05 Any luck there? Now I hear you. I just went out and came back and that was it. So thank you very much, Mr. Mayor. So tonight we have two agenda items. The first, which will include all four town council members, is overall financing presentation. The second is more specific to the parcel. We'll have a very brief break between those two. I'm going to give a brief presentation to each item, then turn it over to Pacific. First on the financing presentation.

1:22:34 As the town moves forward with the housing program, all the staff really wanted to ensure the town council had every little piece of information and be able to take advantage of all the available resources. Pacific was very aware of this and volunteered several weeks ago to provide today's presentation to get you up to date on affordable housing statewide, nationwide, every little bit you could. I want to remind you that there was also an affordable housing 101 presentation.

1:23:01 That we did for the public during the planning of parcel. It was in August of 2019. I think it's still on the website. And if not, we'll certainly make it available if anybody wants to go back. It's much more basic. But again, it was really good information. So with that, I'm just going to turn it over to Caleb Brew from Pacific. And Caleb, please share your screen, whoever needs to. And staff, of course, is available to answer questions when we're done. So thank you. Thanks, Grady.

1:23:29 Thanks, council members for having us here. Everybody hear me okay? Yep, you're good. Outstanding. And I assume you all can see the screen, but today we're going to talk about a few subjects, kind of state and national level housing and really with an emphasis on financing probably more than anything. Some local opportunities and challenges and then we've taken the time to kind of go through every product type.

1:23:56 And unit type to kind of determine a rough local gap, financing gap that we would look to the town to organize around and support. And then finally, some financing strategies. So, Michelle, and you're controlling the slides, I understand? Yes. Okay, so go ahead and you can just move through them. So, this just really sets the table for you guys. I think, you know, some of this probably might be intuitive to you, but...

1:24:24 You know, the need is just more than ever. And production levels are really down. And that's just kind of a perfect storm for causing the situation that we're in. This is really, especially on the coastal markets, but really at a national level. You all know about homelessness and certainly the coastal cities are experiencing that. But I think the big thing that we're seeing is the political support for housing being greater than it's ever been before.

1:24:53 Puts us into perspective of housing becoming a national issue. And then, you know, in my 20-plus year career, I've never seen as much money devoted to affordable housing as I do now, especially in California. And then, you know, I think you know about some of the land use reforms. Certainly, Sandra and your planning staff know. But they're doing a lot of things at the local planning level that are trying to encourage housing production and make it easier. So next slide, Shellen.

1:25:23 You know, that sort of sets up. There you go. There you go. So with the way things have been in California, the affordable housing finance system has really been organized around rental housing at less than 80 percent AMI. So it's that area where all the resources are targeted. And there's the stats for Mono County to give you an idea of kind of who that takes care of on an income level.

1:25:53 But that's really the system that's in place now, and it's leveraged off the Federal Housing Tax Credit. That's a resource that every state gets access to kind of on a per capita basis. And so all of the gap financing sources, the HCD funding sources, most local jurisdictions back when redevelopment was around were organized around the Federal Housing Tax Credit.

1:26:18 And mainly because it was just a free federal resource that could be used to finance affordable housing. And as a result, the most affordable housing that got built was rental housing. And that really has resulted in a system today with such high demand, it's oversubscribed about three to one. So for every three projects that come into the system that want to get tax credits, only about one gets it currently in California.

1:26:46 So the system is constrained by that credit or the lack of supply of that credit and it really sets up a need for a competition to pick projects. So what that means is, is as you look at those competitions, and next slide, Shelyn, if you can't hear what I'm saying, like you can just, when I get to the end, you can move it on. But that competition really for the tax credit is kind of has two paths.

1:27:17 And one path is the 9% credit. It's got a bigger credit. It's generally for smaller projects. But the way they give those credits out or award those credits or pick the winners is based heavily on the amount of subsidy you bring to the table beyond the credit itself. So on average, it's about $100,000 a unit in subsidy is needed to win tax credits in that program.

1:27:43 This isn't like the rule or anything, but it's just sort of what happens on average. You can get lucky. Sometimes you can have more committed to a project and still not get funded. But, you know, on average, about $100,000 per unit is needed. And then the second path is what we're currently doing with the parcel, and that's the 4% tax credit path. And that generally is for larger projects. And right now the system kind of works based on two criteria. One are called high resource areas.

1:28:13 And what that means is those are areas that are around the state that have generally pretty good schools, pretty decent incomes. What it's meant to do is basically reward putting children into these areas because the outcomes that the children can realize are better statistically because the schools are better or whatever.

1:28:37 And right now a big chunk of Mammoth is in a high resource area. That's probably a testament to, you know, the quality of life that you all as a community have produced there. But nevertheless, the parcel, entire parcel is in a high resource area. So that's a good thing. The second thing that's not so good that the system awards based upon is lowest cost. And that's where Mammoth doesn't do well at all.

1:29:02 Because the cost of building Mammoth are probably some of the highest in the state, certainly the highest in any rural area, and even higher than a lot of urban areas. And as a result, the parcel and its projects don't fare very well in the system. You meet the one criteria, and that's good, but when it comes to the second criteria, it becomes a problem. So neither path favors Mammoth particularly well, but there's some encouraging changes coming, and I'll go through those now.

1:29:31 At the federal level, there's a bill currently being working its way through Congress called the Affordable Housing Credit Improvement Act. And what they're going to do in that bill if it makes it through, and I think you guys have been hearing sort of about the infrastructure package and been hearing about a reconciliation bill. This credit improvement act is not in the infrastructure package, but it will be in a reconciliation.

1:29:56 And the federal tax credit, I think, as you guys might know, has broad bipartisan support. So even though the Reconciliation Act will be a Democrat-driven program, it's likely to include this Credit Improvement Act. In fact, there's promises already in place that will allow that to happen.

1:30:23 So that's that. And then there's also a real great opportunity for more tax credits to be available for ELI units or units targeted at 30% AMI, extremely low income. And so those are a couple of things. There's also increases in home and gap financing, so National Housing Trust Fund. And then there's an interesting program that Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon is sponsoring called the Middle Income Tax Credit. And that's got to be meant to service rental units at 100% AMI.

1:30:54 Currently, the federal tax credit services incomes an average of 60% AMI, but it does allow it to go up to 80, but this new middle income tax credit would go up to 100% AMI. So that's the federal stage, lots of encouraging news, and I think it really is set policy-wise by the fact that housing is such a dominant issue right now from a national perspective.

1:31:19 In California, I think you guys know, lots going on, but one of the things that is happening that is a direct benefit to the parcel right now is there's $1.75 billion in the budget that has been set aside for projects that have HCD financing but have yet to get their tax credits. You guys will remember that we have an infill infrastructure grant award for $20 million.

1:31:47 That's HCD financing. We also have the No Place Like Home, $500,000 that really the county helped provide. That's HCD financing. So the parcels financing path, this first phase, is really secure because it has priority status in that $1.75 billion in resources. So we're kind of looking at everything from the perspective of this project is financed.

1:32:14 This is an over-the-counter program for projects that have that HCD funding, and we will likely be using that for the parcel for the first phase anyway. For the future, I'll just say that HCD is looking at programs that will increase limits for non-tax credit projects. Remember, the system is constrained by tax credits, and so they're trying to figure out how to create their programs in a way that will help have projects happen outside of tax credit financing.

1:32:43 And then the good news for Mammoth 2 and the parcel specifically is the ATD's programs are going to continue to favor high resource areas, which Mammoth has a large chunk of. So that's kind of the good news. And I'll just pause there because I'm going to switch over to Sheldon and have her lead a little bit of this presentation here. But do you guys have any questions that you want to ask at this point about financing before we move on? Any questions, guys? Just speak up. I've got a couple of questions, Caleb, while I've got you here.

1:33:14 You may have heard the town manager's representation about our ability to produce, say, 1% of TOT, general fund dollars to put towards housing.

1:33:29 And I'm wondering if you could speak and advise the council, the public as to the value of that type of money, which has no restrictions on it. It doesn't have AMI restrictions on it. It's not a federal program. It's not a state program. How valuable is the color of that money to the kinds of projects that we're trying to do? Well, I'd say it's extremely valuable because the flexibility gives you freedom to do the income targeting and the product type that's most concentrated on what you say you need.

1:33:59 Right. So for that reason, I mean, all of these monies I just mentioned in the talk here all come with rules and strings and sometimes prevailing wages and other restrictions that really drive the use of that money and what you can use it for. And so, you know, John, you bet. I mean, it's very good. It also the other thing I would just add the value of that money is it also its flexibility will allow you a better opportunity to get other types of money into your town.

1:34:29 Because of the flexibility of your money. I mean, a lot of times local money comes with its own restrictions that you now have to marry up with the state or local or federal programs. And by having a flexible source of money, it becomes highly valuable leverage to acquire other money. So those are the two main values I see. So I just want to point that out. Dan, perhaps you could do a little quick backup envelope.

1:34:50 estimate how much if we were to produce 1% of TOT on an annual basis, what kind of a dollar figure that we're looking at. And also to point out that if we were to put a revenue or a tax measure on the ballot.

1:35:04 It would be constrained. There would be language constraints in there that would constrain what we could do with those dollars. And I just think for the council to really understand how valuable those dollars are for leverage, for match, for discretion, to be able to do the kinds of things that are idiosyncratic to our community. Dan, I'll give you a second to do that penciling there. The other thing is, Caleb, as you pointed out, Mammoth Lakes is a very idiosyncratic.

1:35:33 Thank you so much.

1:36:03 Maddening collision of policy objectives, things along the lines of things like local control. I know, I'm sure you're aware, I think as a council member, every day I'm getting emails from elected officials from around the state who are irate about what the local control constraints could mean to a community of Mammoth Lakes. How can we effectively advocate for ourselves and our interests and our community interests at the state level? Be interested in any insights you might have on that.

1:36:33 Yeah, no, that's great. So we'll talk about the local control issue because you're really delving into the land use area, right, is the main one you're talking about there. And, you know, the communities, the cities, the counties as a whole in California have collectively done a poor job of producing housing, right? I'm saying the group of the, you know, 500 plus of the counties and cities have done a bad job.

1:36:59 They've kind of done this one-size-fits-all approach, like you all shall change everything, and they're not really paying attention very much to the producers of housing that are actually fulfilling their housing elements and getting units built. So you guys are getting caught up in a maze of bad actors that are not producing anything and, in fact, are fighting the production of housing. So one of the things I would advocate for is just simply, like, tailor the mandate.

1:37:29 To those that are not producing the housing. If you're going to put on the requirement to build housing and, you know, give up local control, only make that apply to those that aren't building housing, for starters. And that sort of kind of fits with SB35, which is the, you know, an existing bill that allows, you know, developers to bypass local control pretty much entirely, bypass CEQA as well. And it's for those jurisdictions that really haven't produced the housing.

1:37:58 And so measures like that I think would be important. But then as far as the just advocacy in general and sort of the clash of policies, the governor's office has a team of housing people that we are close to. And, you know, I can make introductions to anybody in his office that that deals in the housing department as well as HCD.

1:38:21 Gustavo Velasquez is very willing to sit down with elected leaders from communities and or city managers, whatever, and just talk about stuff and talk about their policies. And I do think, John, that I do believe that there is a willing group ready to listen and hear about the differences, especially that Mammoth Lakes has versus some of the other communities.

1:38:45 But it's just about getting an audience in front of them. And, you know, if you guys would like help doing that, I can certainly make moves to produce that. No, I think we'd be very, very interested in that. And I think, Mr. Mayor and whoever's going to be the mayor of their next go-around, working with the county, we need to get into that because we're getting, we're doing, we're going above and beyond. And we're making real commitments, real investments into housing.

1:39:08 And we're just running into all kinds of crosswinds and problems coming out of the state policy that I guess would do small. There's a whole other conversation. Before I let you go, Caleb, just another thing that we can talk about this offline.

1:39:22 I serve on a state climate change group through OPR. And we've got agendized something called the Citizen Advisory Committee for the Department of Housing and Community Development's Community Development Block Grant Mitigation. And an opportunity for the group that I serve on, this is the OPR, the ICARP TAC group, to become that body.

1:39:43 Perhaps we can just check it offline if you have any idea of what that means, what the implications for that might be, whether or not it might have a conflict, but that would be very helpful. And Dan, finally, what's that number? What's a 1% TOT of general fund? What's that number look like on an annual basis? I'm assuming you're not talking about 1%, but one point of TOT. I'm sorry, one point. Yeah, Dan, how much? What is it? 7.7% of TOT, not 1%, just so the audience at home understands.

1:40:13 Thanks for that clarification. Yeah, what we look at is out of that 13% tax rate, if you take 1% of that tax rate, it would generate on the low end 1.1 million up to 1.5 million based on budget and actual. So let's say 1.1 on the low end, 1.5 on the top.

1:40:32 Excellent. And we can always do better than that, but I think it's really important for council, we're all hearing this, hopefully the communities, and Caleb, thanks very much for helping us to characterize the value of those dollars. That's great money, and I think we should really be looking at doing that as a minimum. So thank you all for this. And just real quick, if I could add to that, John, thanks for having us this evening.

1:40:56 Yes, all these funds build off of that affordable housing tax credit at the federal level, but yes, your money is flexible, but we also need it in order to leverage and receive awards for that tax credit. So it's not as if that local money is just free to be used for other upper incomes that are not covered by the tax credit because there...

1:41:19 We're showing that, yes, we can get this 9% or 4% tax credit to fund these projects, but those are also coupled with, often with two, three, four additional sources of funds in order to be able to make a project work at the costs that Mammoth is experiencing. And these are costs that we're seeing right now as we're working through the parcels. So these are real costs that we're seeing. And as we get into the presentation, we'll get into real detailed numbers about where you might consider targeting those monies. Yeah, and I think you heard some of the public comment at the beginning of the meeting.

1:41:49 Our community is existentially threatened. And we do not want to turn into a community of a bunch of COVID refugees from high-value Southern California areas and an imprisoned workforce and have no middle class, nothing in between those disparities. So I think it's a real determination of all of ours to make sure we don't get backed into those types of corners. So looking forward to how we can really take best advantage of that type of money to move these things forward.

1:42:21 One other thing, John, that is not yet out there yet, but the federal government part of the COVID Relief Act basically cares. There's $155 million that is coming to California for rural areas, for housing. And that's something that I think, you know, Mammoth traditionally hasn't competed well in a while for those kinds of monies, but with so much, the odds are that we can have a good chance.

1:42:50 To get some of that money for the parcel or other projects in town. So just know that that's something we're eyeing. And when HTD comes out with the rules for that money, we'll definitely be with your team there in the town to have you ready to go. We're going to sharpen up our grant writing skills. Yeah. Any other questions for Caleb in the first part before we move to the second? No, no further questions, but thank you. That was very illuminating. Thank you. Thank you, Caleb. I guess you're up.

1:43:24 Hi, good evening. Thanks for having us again. So I just wanted to kind of continue on with where we were with Caleb's presentation, but just the real quick high-level challenges and opportunities. I mean, you all understand and Caleb touched on the high costs that the community faces because of where you are, right, and the climate that you're in. But one of the other things that he didn't touch on, but I think that's really important to just understand overall, is that

1:43:54 When we compete for these state funds at all different levels, we're generally, rural communities are competing against each other. So the community of Mammoth, with all of its high cost, are competing against, you know, Hanford's and Lemoore's and places in the Central Valley that have much lower costs and perhaps not too different of incomes.

1:44:15 So that just sets the stage as to why it is so competitive and so difficult. So those are the challenges, but you also want to be positive and talk about the opportunities. And I won't spend a lot of time on this, but at the end of the day, all of the financing sources that Caleb talked about, I mean, some of the rules are still a little bit to be determined, but they all require leveraging of land and money. So when you have...

1:44:40 Sort of leveraged land, such as the parcel or other publicly owned land, you have a benefit and you're more competitive. When you have density, not only are you saving costs by having density in and of itself, but also because some of the financing requires it. Entitlements are the same way. They're preference and you get additional points and you get additional competitiveness. Leveraging other funds, leveraging overall community support, which I think

1:45:06 The town of Mammoth has done a really phenomenal job of gaining and leveraging the experience of developers and local advocacy groups. And so those are things that, you know, makes the parcel sort of work, but it also would make future developments work when you have, you know, very low cost or no cost land, very high density, previously entitled, other HCD funds or other funds altogether, community support and then experienced development construction team.

1:45:37 So really quick, I don't know how many of you are familiar with this image. It may have been in your needs assessment. Okay, great. So the idea is really...

1:45:49 Just, you know, to create achievable housing, you need to provide for all types of incomes. You have your lowest income on the far left and the orange. Your middle income, which your needs assessment called missing middle, so I'll try to use the same words, goes from, you know, above tax credit up to 80 percent. And then in your needs assessment, it goes up to, you know, 150 to 200 percent. But, you know, that can be debated. And then this red area.

1:46:15 Okay, so I just wanna go through each

1:46:44 Sort of the cost and the gap needed for each of these types of units. It's a high level. It's the best estimate. But I mean, we are on the ground getting bids as we speak. So it's a pretty good estimate. But a lot of unit mix, prevailing wages, a lot of assumptions go into it.

1:47:06 So those rentals at 80% AMI, i.e. the parcel, family of three earning, you know, $57,000 and below, those units cost about $560,000. We can leverage about $528,000 or we can obtain about $528,000 of public sources, right, between state, home, tax credit, private equity.

1:47:31 What we would need, generally speaking, is about $30,000 and change of local gap financing, local gap money. That can come in deferred fees. Land is not included in these numbers at all. We're assuming contributed land in all of these scenarios. But that can come in deferred fees. It can come in TOT monies. It can come in some kind of foundation money or no place like home monies that the county provided.

1:48:00 So $32,000 a gap for a typical tax credit deal. When you move up and you see the circle to those missing middle 80% and above units that are still rentals, this is where the gap gets the highest, right? So the price of the unit is slightly less than the price of a tax credit unit because of a lot of the oversight and the...

1:48:24 The different rules around all the soft funds create some costs. But so you still have a $500,000, a $495,000 unit in Mammoth. But it only leverages based on the rents that those folks can achieve. It only leverages about $240,000 of other sources on a per unit basis. So that local gap number is tremendous, right? At $250,000 a unit. So that's where, to Andrea's point earlier, when you're talking about, you know, the TOT monies, they're incredibly valuable.

1:48:53 But, you know, a million of TOT monies could, you know, on the low end that Dan mentioned could get you four of these units roughly versus, you know, a million divided by 30,000, quite a bit more tax credit units, just to put it in perspective.

1:49:09 And to be clear, these numbers come really looking at the community as a whole, not parcel specific, not looking at the infrastructure, IIG, other things. This is really looking at the community as a whole, what you could possibly achieve and looking at real-time numbers just to sort of give you guys an example as to what we're seeing. And it also makes some assumptions about a certain amount of units.

1:49:30 And I think that's a really good point. I think that's a really good point. I think that's a really good point.

1:50:00 Really unrestricted Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County funds that are not tied to, you know, a CDBG grant or a home grant or, you know, I think in possibly maybe there's areas where there's local transportation funds, you know, how can you work with all the money that you see coming before you and ask the question, can any of this be used for housing?

1:50:22 Can any of it be used for a bus stop for housing? Can any of it be used for parking for housing? And really asking those questions as you see all the money coming forward in a variety of forms, you know, our recommendation is you would look at all of those and say, what can be used? And be able to try to make those calls as much as you can to make the most of those TOT dollars through every decision that you're making.

1:50:49 So thanks. And then just moving on real quickly, and then I'll do a slide that just compares them so you see them side by side. But this is that same income group, but it's for a home ownership opportunity. And this, you know, it really is a public policy decision as to what level of income you want to use public money or, you know, or create policies to incentivize what level of income of ownership.

1:51:15 So do you want to focus on, we split it in two, do you want to focus on 80 to 120 percent? These splits are arbitrary, we just did it for the purpose of an example, or do you want to go higher and focus on affordable homeownership for families making up to 200 percent AMI, right? It's a policy decision.

1:51:35 The one thing about the 80 to 120 area is that is where your existing homebuyers assistance programs can plug in where the 120 to 200 percent might be Town of Mammoth Lakes homebuyers assistance, not funds at Mammoth Lakes Housing where the town is getting to assist homebuyers.

1:51:54 And so the short story here is these are kind of a townhome product, a condominium product. It's still not a single family home on its own land, if you will, because that is still more expensive than what we're seeing. But so we've got a housing price for both. Obviously, the cost of the housing is the same, just over $600,000, $615,000. Assuming a family is at 120% AMI, so we backed in what their mortgage could be based on having good credit, reasonable mortgage rates, you know, a lot of assumptions.

1:52:24 They, there's a local gap of about $170,000 per $600,000, $615,000 unit, right? So that is what that homeownership money would have to provide to get somebody into a unit at this income. At the higher income, you know, that gap goes down tremendously because they have more buying power. That family has more buying power, right? So still same price home at $615,000.

1:52:51 But based on their buying power, they would only need a gap of about $20,000 per unit. There's a, you know, with homeownership, there's a whole nother can of worms that you open up. I would say, and you guys are very well aware, but making sure that you have an entity or group that can really manage deeds and long-term affordability.

1:53:13 So quick side-by-side comparison, no new information on this slide. You guys have it. It just shows you, you know, sort of the parcel idea, this kind of affordable rental tax credit development has a contribution of $30,000 plus. A market rate rental is the tough one at about $250,000 per unit for sale at sort of a moderate income, you know, right in here of the bridge is about $170,000 and then for sale on sort of the higher income.

1:53:43 So I hope that is helpful. And I think this is sort of the last slide of the first session, if you will. I'll turn it back over to Caleb just to talk through, but I want to introduce the slide a little bit because the quote at the top is from the 2017, very end of 2017 needs assessment.

1:54:06 And the image, the table that you see at the bottom is talking about actually what Councilmember Wentworth mentioned, I think, earlier on in the discussion or public comment discussion. But there is this idea of what...

1:54:20 What in your action plan can you do to create and continue a housing strategy? And so those were the three things that fell into the financing that were in your action plan that fell into the financing side of things. So go ahead, Caleb, if there's anything else you wanted to add to this slide. You could just back up one slide to the chart. And, you know, I think that as you guys are looking at, you know, where you want to target your housing production, this is sort of the financial thing to organize around.

1:54:49 And this is really why, if you see that market rate rental category, this is why you don't see market rate rentals built in your community. Because the rents are not that high to justify the enormous costs to build. And so equity just can't get a return on it. And so when you look at what gets built there, well, condos get built there, for sale product gets built there. It's really not going to be that market rate rental unit.

1:55:17 So that's just something to notice. It's a pretty, I mean, you know, it's kind of crazy actually to think that, you know, you'd spend $250,000 to subsidize a market rate rental. Now, keep in mind, we estimated the market rent. I think this doesn't have to be a market rate rental. It could be a 120% AMI rental, a 150% AMI rental. You know, you could put deed restrictions on it and make it into what you wanted it to be.

1:55:44 And, you know, we made some assumptions on rent, but just to kind of ground for you guys where the rents are set at to do this market rate rental analysis, we set the rent at 100% AMI. So that just means that someone earning 100% AMI, if they were paying 30% of their income for housing, this would be, you know, an affordable rate for them. But just to give you a peg, you know, a one bedroom might be $1,500 a unit.

1:56:12 A two-bedroom might be about $1,775 and a three-bedroom about $2,000. Now that might be a little low maybe in certain cases, but just for good quality product, that's a good rent. And obviously if those rents can be pushed higher, then that subsidy will come down with it. Not substantially, I don't think, but if that turned into $200,000 because the rents could be higher, that might be an achievable outcome. But this kind of just sets you up to sort of evaluate

1:56:41 You know, policy decisions and, you know, where you're going to allocate your resources. And obviously, if we move out of the 150% for sale area and we have buyers at those levels, you know, that subsidy theoretically could be zero on some of those units beyond just the land and the infrastructure that we already have kind of contributed or secured. So I'll stop there with questions.

1:57:05 If I could just wrap up and we'll get to questions is when Caleb says, mentions like having those rents at 100% AMI, that's really about also about community health, right? So that's not just we should set it at 100% AMI, but let's assume Mammoth had the ability to grow and wasn't land constrained and people were building market rate apartments. You know, a healthy community has a supply that's available to your area median income. It might not be the nicest unit, but there should be a range there. And I think that, you know,

1:57:35 Planners and housing analysts alike would say that, you know, that's really a healthy community if you have some of those market rate units not restricted that can meet that target income group. And then your staff report actually does have the 2017 needs assessment numbers tied to these types of units. So it's not on our slide presentation, but it is in your staff report and those come straight from the 2017 needs assessment.

1:58:04 Just I would add to put it into perspective that 100% AMI family is a family of three making about $71,000 a year. That's where that falls. And Mayor Salzer, this will be the end of this presentation before we move to parcel specific items. So now's your shot. Thank you very much. So I will go to the council with questions or answers, if you will, starting again with John.

1:58:39 Mr. Mayor, thank you very much. And I don't want to be hogging the mic, but I'll put in my two bits here. So, Dan, on the town side of things, I believe that the Community Development Department is our lead staff capacity for this, for these efforts. Is that correct? Yeah, they're definitely the ones charged on the housing side between Sandra and her team.

1:59:05 So Sandra and Nolan. And I can't see, is anybody from Mammoth Lakes Housing on this call? I can't, I don't know who's here, who's not here. We'll get that, I guess, in a second. Okay, so Andy and Shallon, you tagged exactly the question that I was scribbling down, which is the council's need to start doing some prioritization as rubber hits the road.

1:59:39 For the social benefits of the investment we're making in housing to benefit this community. And Dan, this is, I mean, this is a triage discussion. And I am very specifically looking to you and our staff to bring those specific questions to the council as we prioritize where we're going to be investing.

2:00:05 This goes exactly along the lines that Caleb and Sheldon and Andy have lined out for you this evening. Does that make sense and is that clear? Yes, and we are looking at a number of those types of areas and different needs in the community, be it the ownership or rental, based on what we're seeing out there in terms of some of the research as well as the studies that have been done. This goes exactly to what Mr. Davis was saying in public comment.

2:00:37 We have some limited ability to be able to do that effectively, but I want to make sure we're all clear what that is. The second thing is I'm really wondering where that GIS tool is. The GIS tool that was called out in the Community Housing Action Plan, which is going to be an absolutely critical tool for the council to help make policy decisions along these lines. So I'm underlining that. I think Rob talked about that at the last meeting.

2:01:01 That is a critical tool that we're going to need to make these types of decisions. So I just want to reemphasize that. And Sandra, Nolan, I know that's been on everybody's radar for a while, but we need that, and we need it sooner rather than later. Another item is, it's not a rhetorical question, Dan, but who is going to be managing these units? As the town starts investing in these properties, I know we've had discussions with MLH around their contract, and that's going to be

2:01:30 You know, that's not an idle thing to come back and have that conversation. If they're not willing to do it, who is going to do it? But that's, please put that on our list as we start investing in these units. I know that they're handling the deed restrictions, but that is going to be very important. And finally, Shallon and Andy, as you're laying out kind of a town-wide program, Dan, I think as we, as the town council,

2:01:55 Allocates general fund monies and do what we can to invest in these opportunities to make sure that the housing program, and Sandra Nolan, as we get surpluses of TOT, as things happen that we've got money to invest, that we can very efficiently invest in housing opportunities. Mr. Mayor, you mentioned earlier about the program, right? Having that program in place such that when we get surpluses of TOT and we've got money to invest,

2:02:24 That it's very clear to the council and to the community that we can make efficient investments in housing around the AMI levels with the policy types of discussions we're making so that we will not, we will have a middle, our community housing program is going to speak to the needs of the middle and we're not just dealing with the uber wealthy and we're not just dealing with people at the lowest ends of the AMI levels that federal and state funding is hopefully going to support. So I hope you guys all wrote all that down.

2:02:54 I wrote it down. I got it right here. Nobody can read it, but I wrote it down. So thank you very much, Cale, Shillen, and this is exactly the kinds of things we need to be talking about. This is the rubber hitting the road, and we need to be effective as we respond to these challenges. So thank you. Thank you, John. Linda? Thank you. A couple questions. I mean, I think John's got some great questions, and that's all really illuminating.

2:03:25 Questions for me are like, when we would identify a need, for example, we have a mall that is not well rented on the bottom for retail and up above there's a bunch of empty space and there was some discussion about maybe we could get this owner to somehow click in and go for some tax credits and do some housing up there. So there is a lot of ideas that don't have

2:03:51 Any solution presented, say, in, you know, a chart like you're just presenting, would that be correct? Yeah, I mean, I think there's all kinds of other ways to work it. I mean, there's adaptive reuse, which is the example you just said, and that's actually considered new construction under the financing programs. But really, when you look at any other ideas, it comes down to

2:04:17 What are you dealing with? Are you dealing with an increase in sources to finance the building or are you resulting in a decrease in costs, right? Those are kind of the impetus to where you focus your efforts. And so sometimes you can get into adaptive reuse situations that are so expensive to retrofit, even though you're getting the land in the building, it's like, no thanks. You know, you'd rather have a blank sheet to work with.

2:04:43 Yes, there are alternatives. I often find them to be difficult to implement and execute because they're not common. But yes, there are alternatives for sure. And so that brings me to the point of when we identify gaps like that in what's available through state and federal kind of funding.

2:04:59 What is a reasonable path to advocate for and how does that come about? I mean, that's a longer play, that's a longer solution, no doubt, but it's just, I find it really frustrating that if someone were to, you know, take down an old building that has sort of outlived its use, it's in a great primary, you know, it's in a great location, it would be great to help them. Okay, how about if you rebuild your store here and then up above it, two or three floors of, you know, housing, which could be, you know,

2:05:29 At any one of the AMIs that we talk about that are the most logical to help fund, is there any help for anything like that? I mean, we're working to fit in the box we're presented with. I get that. But what about a box that, you know, how do we go about advocating and helping to push to create a box where there's more things that could fit into it, like the idea I just said? I find that really frustrating. You know, this is, we're talking about what's available now, but how do we?

2:05:58 Get to the things that could be, should be, would be great to be available. If I could just speak to that real quick, I mean, unfortunately, you know,

2:06:07 Redevelopment took a lot of those opportunities away, and that's really where you can look to, you know, if you were to introduce a new tax measure, if you were to find a way to commit more local monies that could create that incentive, right? And then be able to use certain flexibilities like, you know, CDBG can be used to purchase land for 80% and below. And that's where you will, you know, it really requires, you know, bringing everyone together and looking at some of your local.

2:06:36 contractor and development community that live and work on a smaller scale in Mammoth and say, look, if we need to do some reuse, and obviously it has economic benefit to the community, doing some redevelopment, reinventing neighborhoods and areas within Mammoth that can really revitalize the community. And unfortunately, it takes a lot of groundwork, right? It gets everyone in the room saying, okay, who's going to stand up and say, I care about this community and I'm willing to...

2:07:03 Bring my building to the table. Who else is in to help me figure out what to do with it to help create housing and revitalize the community? And that's really where your local leverage will come into play. Because when you have those real local dollars and people see like, okay, I'm not being asked to do this for free. I'm maybe going to do it for a little bit less profit than I would if I were doing X, Y, or Z. But you have those people in your community. I mean, Mammoth is full of people who care and who business leaders who are experiencing staff shortages. And, you know, I think now is your

2:07:32 Critical mass place where you say, okay, if we go for this money, who's going to be at the table to help us spend it in the best way to revitalize the community, provide housing and do it in a way that everyone comes out a little bit ahead, including people who are getting the housing and being able to invest those dollars, because those are complicated pieces. And, you know, there really isn't the state money to be able to do that since we don't have redevelopment anymore.

2:07:59 I think you're exactly right that those creative solutions have to be brought to the table. Where is it that you can, you know, remake certain buildings that have outlived their use? And there should be, you know, a grand inventory of like, okay, well, there's an opportunity over there. I mean, we all know the park and ride exists. Can we build something over the park and ride? I mean, all of those things need to be sort of listed and thought about and bring the partners to the table to figure out how to, you know, make those bigger solutions.

2:08:27 So it's sort of a parallel track, if you will. So we have the track that's sort of, okay, this is what's available today right now with past credits. And so we're running on that track, but then maybe somehow we need to generate the energy to have a track on this side that looks at those things that would work. Nothing's available now. How do we work to A, make it available and B, move people along that? So I feel like I don't want to ignore that other thing because we're over here trying to, you know, like I said, like before, you know, fit it all into the box that's available.

2:08:56 You know, how do we build up a new box? So thanks for at least helping me understand that a little bit. Thanks. And Linda, I would just add that it really starts with your zoning and general plan, too. So, you know, does the commercial areas, the retail areas, does it allow residential above ground floor commercial, right? And if it doesn't, then that's where it starts to start, you know, maybe work on what's going on with ADUs, accessory dwelling units, you know, how is that?

2:09:25 What's your zoning allow in that area? And, you know, so those kind of policy decisions definitely are set to the table for what's possible. And then we can talk about financing later, right? But the land use really matters. Yeah, thanks, Hubba. I'd like to keep that open, keep looking at that because...

2:09:42 I think that that's the long game. I mean, what we're doing here is the long game, but that's even a longer game. And like you said, the land use, you know, question first, trying to get that cleaned up so that people could look and go, oh, there's a little, you know, a little opportunity here. So thanks for speaking to that. Thank you, Linda. Kirk? Thank you, Bill. My question or my comment is, when is a project going to actually be turnkey?

2:10:14 You know, it's all this discussion and everything else. We do have some land and everything. When is it, you know, however the funding mechanism comes together, when do we actually get product? Thank you. Yeah, we need to be careful with that, I think, because if the question is, I am assuming what you're asking is the parcel, that needs to be in the parcel discussion so that I'm being recused and not a piece of it.

2:10:46 I'm not, I'm not, I'm not targeting, I mentioned the parcel, but there's other, you know, other opportunities out there. What I'm asking for is, okay, this has been a discussion and I appreciate it and I recognize many of the tools and everything else, but, you know, what are the priorities and when are we going to actually get product, turnkey product out there?

2:11:10 You know, we talk about a housing crisis. Okay. And we talk about these general tools that, you know, are available out there. And, you know, when are we going to actually identify a project and get it done? Thank you.

2:11:31 Caleb, do you want to take that or speak a little bit? I can speak certainly to just the timeline that a typical project would take from the time that sort of it's identified to the time that it's complete. You know, I would say when you're working with these sources of funds that we talked about here, which are the sources that help the folks, you know, in the orange, you are held to...

2:11:58 The timeline that those sources of funds have in regards to their application periods and when they're awarded. So generally, after a site is identified, say it's zoned correctly and it doesn't need to go through much entitlement besides design review or something, you know, it takes maybe three, if it does need to go through a zone change, usually it's six to nine months, if not longer. If it doesn't, then maybe you could get through design review and three to

2:12:27 And then you have to line that up so that you are what we call entitled and you've gotten CEQA and all that stuff complete in order to apply for the financing. And then financing takes anywhere from six months to two years to get when it comes to these state funds. And then usually if you're more than 40 units, it's a year of construction.

2:12:55 In a traditional climate, and we all know, you know, Mammoth, a year of construction can very easily be two. So the answer to your question is, I would say a very typical tax credit project could easily take, you know, three years from the time it's identified.

2:13:14 To the time the doors are open. And I don't know if I can speak to the parcel, but it's happening incredibly fast from an overall timeline is just as an inform. It's, you know, approved and rezoned and remastered planned in January, February of 20 and then, excuse me, of 21 and then applied for funding and then will be in the ground.

2:13:39 Starting, you know, perhaps starting some of the tree removal this fall, and we can talk more about it in detail later, but doors opened in 2023, so that's a two-year window, which is very, very fast, and I can give you examples of other projects that we've worked in in Placer County, California, or other places that, you know, have been much, much longer. Shannon, if I could just interrupt real quick that, I mean, Kirk, you...

2:14:06 You and I know, and it might not be everyone's favorite project, but Meridian Court was record-breaking fast from the land purchased in 2003 to sale of units in 2005. And that was 100% local financed. And just to give the public an idea as to just how long it takes, that required...

2:14:23 No permission of anything other than a quick trip to the Planning Commission and the Council commitment of dollars, which happened very fast. And I think from the day you purchase a piece of land, you can expect in Mammoth that no one will move into that unit for at least two years. Thank you, Andrea. I ask the question because I get a lot of questions from the business community who is having a difficult time hiring employees and keeping employees.

2:14:52 A lot of them having to commute to Bishop and even further down. So to let the business community know we're pushing on this, we're going after the grants, we're looking at the funding and everything else, but it's still before the turnkey we're looking at maybe two to three years. Is that correct? I'll give you this, Kurt. I predict you can reliably tell the business community,

2:15:23 That there's going to be units available starting in 2023, and you could expect a steady supply of units to be delivered every year thereafter for three or four years. That's what we're committed to in our efforts globally in the town, without mentioning specific projects. I mean, we see that space of possibilities being real, and that's what I would, you know.

2:15:49 I'd be happy to talk to any businesses about that strategy and what we're committed to and what we think we can achieve. Thank you. Thank you very much. Now, that's one question. And the other question is the financial gap to meet a 2023 timeline. So, you know, if we can get something other than a...

2:16:08 Thank you. Grady, I see a hand up.

2:16:41 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. You know, I've lived and breathed this more than anybody in the last three and a half years, and actually almost four years by the time we started talking about making an offer on the parcel. So I want to make two comments. One is on the, I'll call it the program. You know, last council meeting, council took some great aggressive actions to put more money towards housing. You're going to affirm some of those tonight. The parcel's certainly moving along.

2:17:08 But what you've heard tonight also, and that's one of the reasons we really wanted Pacific here was I think you have a lot more resources, a lot more information now where the town manager, community development can turn this into a true housing program. Right now we have some great plans. We're doing all positive things. I think they're all in the right direction. But I think the questions that I just heard especially have said this is great, but what's our program? What's our real policy on this? And I think

2:17:34 You've given us enough guidance and we have enough information now to move forward with that. The other thing I wanted to mention very quickly, a lot of communities don't have, is that we have, frankly, a united community now. Through Plan the Parcel, yes, we had some detractors. We had some people saying we want to keep all the trees. But by and large, we had overwhelming community support, which is not always the case. And we have that now for affordable housing. And we have that willingness to town council. And I'm not going to...

2:18:02 to beat on any other communities up north around Lake Tahoe, but three years ago when we started planning the parcel and even acquiring the land, we actually got some criticism from some of the community who said, well, gee, they have this 11-acre project up in Tahoe that they're ready to go and they'll be under construction next year. Yeah, it's three years later and we are now very much ahead of them and that's really because of the support.

2:18:28 The community and the town council to take their necessary actions. I don't do that just to, you know, just to blow smoke. I'm serious about that and that willingness will make us more successful than most in the future. So thank you for allowing me to do that little commentary. Thank you. Thank you, Grady. John, your hands up as well. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just to follow up on a couple of things that Linda said. For Caleb, Shailen, and Andrea, we refer to kind of that reconversion,

2:19:00 Thank you, Caleb, that you guys are kind of talking about. The term of art, I think that we least use within the town is utilization, and we focus this specifically at all the condo product that we have. We all know how difficult that is, but just as a term of art, I think that would be useful for kind of using the same vernacular. Grady, I really want to echo and reinforce that idea about a town of Mammoth Lakes housing program. Dan, you and I have talked a lot about that. Shalen, great to hear that sort of.

2:19:27 Timeline of new construction. But we've got a lot of opportunities that we can make investments in, buying small lots, thinking about putting up a fourplex here or duplex there. Dan, all of those things need to be in that program. This is idiosyncratic and specific to Mammoth Lakes. And finally, I think that the conversation about marshalling the true political will of the community to move this stuff forward. Many members of the community put on a housing summit.

2:19:55 In Mammoth Lakes, volunteers put together. We raised a lot of money. We made that happen. And Dan, frankly, at this point, I'm looking for who is going to be the lead to convene the construction industry, to convene the business industry, to start figuring out how we are going to be raising these barns together. Is that our town staff? Is that Mammoth Lakes Housing? That is a very specific need. And frankly, it's an opportunity to translate.

2:20:22 Thank you so much.

2:20:42 Well over $10,000 to that community for that housing summit. I think it's really time for us to start turning to our staff and turning to MLH to convene that group, bring those folks together. What do we actually have in our toolkit, local builders, local business interests to work along the lines that Linda's talking about to start putting a real dent into this stuff? I look forward to hearing who's going to own that and who's going to be in charge of that program. So thank you. Thank you, John.

2:21:11 Grady, your hand is still up, but I'm assuming you're done. I don't know how to turn it off from my side. With that, pretty much all the questions have been asked, so I'm not going to go into that. Do we have any public comments on this section? Yes, we do. Okay. That is all the public comment. Thank you. That being said, Linda, you're going to lead the next section because I have to back out.

2:22:52 I'm assuming at this point you'd probably like a little break? Yes, I think that's a very good idea. Why don't we reconvene at 6.30? And at that point in time I will be recused because I live too close to the parcel to comment on it so everybody knows my face won't be appearing at that time. I thank you all. Okay, see you in a few. We are in recess till 6.30. Thank you. Correct. Hey, Shellen, we can see your screen. I don't know if you want to stop.

2:25:28 Screen sharing for a sec and come back. Thanks, Sandra. I was multitasking. You're welcome. I'm just checking to make sure my mic didn't turn off again. I'm okay. Thank you very much. Who knows? I'm still trying to find the unmute button. Dan, do you have Kirk there? I'm here.

2:31:59 Okay, good. So we're all here, all three of us. All right, before we commence on this next agenda item, I just wanted to take a minute to give a shout out to Council Member Ray, who's not able to join us tonight and that she hopefully is safely resting at home and doing the hard work that she's trying to do right now. So anyway, all right, let's proceed to the agenda item 8.3, which is the parcel update.

2:32:27 And let's see, Grady, are you going to kick this off for us? Yes, and my introduction will be even more brief than before. I want to quote, or actually just paraphrase, an LA Times article that I've read about land battles and resorts towns. There are battles that go on all the time about growth versus no growth. There was a comment in this article specifically about Mammoth, about the only feasible way for the town to satisfy the state housing requirements.

2:32:58 is the development of the parcel. There was even references to land transfers with Bob Tanner and US Forest Service. And a quote in this article was that new hotels will greatly increase the number of service workers and other employees in town who will be unable to find affordable housing. Councilmember Stapp was on the town council. The article was dated August 4th, today, 1996.

2:33:22 Just as a perspective, exactly, and I'm happy to forward the article. There are some other very interesting comments in it, but it just gives you a vision, and again, what I ended with last time is the same as today. We're here because of this town council and your willingness to be aggressive, make this happen finally after all these years. So 1996 article, I'll pass it on to Dan and he can distribute it, but it's the same comments, exactly the same, even to the hotel.

2:33:51 And service workers. So that's all I have, Pro Tem, Mayor Salcido, and I'll just turn to Pacific and let them do their presentation. So thank you. Thank you, Grady. That's really interesting. I can't wait to read that in retrospect. So thanks. All right, Shellen. Sure. Thank you. So we were asked to, we've been giving parcel updates, you know, in it.

2:34:14 In conjunction with staff, written updates at every council meeting. But we wanted to take some time and dive in a little bit.

2:34:23 So we're going to talk tonight about where we are in regards to our plans and our financing, go over schedule, which I think we'll touch on a lot of things that were mentioned in the last agenda item, but I think we'll dive in a little bit and then really talk about our next phase, phase two, and what that's going to look like and the timing associated with it, how it is going to affect the infill infrastructure grant funds that we've been successful in obtaining.

2:34:52 And then a holistic look at future phases. And so as before warned, the last few slides do have a lot of numbers in them. It's a, you know, it's a big chart, but I think we'll be able to get through it and hopefully not bore anyone to death, but hopefully be, you know, just really open the eyes to what this is going to take. So moving on, you've seen this chart a million times. We're at the financing stage. We're trying to begin site work.

2:35:22 Later this year with trees, I'll get into it, but I just wanted to let you guys, you know, to just reiterate that we're moving forward and we're moving forward arguably very quickly compared to some other developments. But so this is a more in-depth look at our timeline. We, you know, we need to get through some work with CAL FIRE before we can...

2:35:48 Actually take trees down, but we're thinking that we'll be able to do that later this summer, maybe September, October be complete. So trees, I'm not sure if they're actually marked, the signage is up, but September, October trees will be down. The likelihood of us being able to start grading or moving forward with grading this fall, it just doesn't make a lot of sense with mobilizing. So we'll do that as soon as we can in the spring.

2:36:15 For phase one, both phase one that you see in the green in the image, which is the apartments, as well as phase one of the public right-of-way improvements, which you see in the blue, the funny shape, and that includes extension south from center, tavern road across east-west of the site, and the public park here in the middle. So that grading can start, you know, as soon as we're able with weather.

2:36:44 And then we'll move forward with Foundation's podium. And in the meantime, we'll be building the modules. This is modular construction. Those will be built in the manufacturing plant here in Idaho. And then come October of 2022, we'll be able to set the modules on site and start marrying them, start doing the landscaping and the interiors being completed six months, roughly later in May of 2023 that we've discussed. So that's our panel.

2:37:14 Go ahead, Linda. I'm sorry, Sheldon, before you proceed, what is a BMP? Best Management Practices, basically putting... Best Management Practices. Putting downstream water, you know, ways to keep the water clean, ways to, you know, make sure that the fencing is up, all of those things, best management. Okay, okay. I'm sure I was supposed to know that, but I have no clue what that is. No reason you should. It's a good point, and I should have... It actually doesn't really even need to be included there.

2:37:44 So for the public's benefit,

2:37:48 You know, this is an unusual project. I mean, it is going incredibly fast. And I think for many of the people in Mammoth who may not be in the planning department, who might not be a public employee, you know, you learn about maybe a hotel project when it comes to planning commission or is being noticed, right? You're like something, there's a big development that's coming out and you get the public notice and it becomes before the planning commission first. And oftentimes when that happens, all of the pre-work, all of the

2:38:17 Civil engineering and architecture has started, and the public doesn't know that that's happened. So by the time a regular development comes before a planning commission, there may have been work happening for two, three, five years prior to coming to planning commission. Because of the public nature of this project and the town owning the land as long as it has and going through the public process that you did, for us, when we were selected as developer,

2:38:42 You know, we don't have a signed agreement, and we have been moving so quickly, and it's just hit the ground running, submitted the IIG grant within record time, and then really working with town staff who has been working so hard to push this project forward. And, you know, when was the last time we've, you know...

2:39:02 The Town of Mammoth Lakes has built a public right away. And these are major street corridors that have sidewalks, multi-use paths, sewer, drainage, water, stormwater. I mean, this is a big undertaking and we have moved incredibly fast. And I really want to make sure that everyone understands the hard work of this team, town staff included, consultants really pushing to be able to get this ready to go. And we plan to build on our current work and we're just going to keep on planning that infrastructure.

2:39:32 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:40:05 After we get the trees cleared, we are, or while we're getting the trees cleared, we're moving forward. We've kicked off our team, our consultant team, to move forward on the phase two right-of-way, which is the extension down to Chaparral. We'll see it in the next slide. But we'll get that designed and permitted. That's, you know, a three to...

2:40:22 Five-month process. This fall, winter, it'll move faster because we've done the hard work in phase one with those rights of ways, figuring out the best mitigation, stormwater, figuring out the size of the mops, the materials, et cetera. But we're going to do that this fall. That's happening. And we'll be able to then get in the ground on the grading of phase two of the right of way.

2:40:45 And perhaps even the residential at the same time that we're getting in the ground of phase one, right? So we're kind of sliding in phase two behind phase one so that we'll just continually be improving.

2:40:57 The site, improving the site. So this is the image of phase two of the right of way, which again, it connects the site down to Chaparral. So this is great because you really will have a full connection through the parcel for, you know, bikes, cars and pedestrians along with the park. So then, and the other thing that this includes, phase two will include all of the offsite improvements, which includes the broadband extension.

2:41:27 Way down over to the high school sidewalks, along Tavern, over to Laurel Mountain, Center Street to Main sidewalks. So there's a substantial amount of what we would call off-site improvements that are incorporated into phase one and phase two. So, Sheldon, if you go back to that. So we're going to hook in the broadband to the fast at high school, you said.

2:41:55 Yeah, it's at, okay, okay, we're bringing it over. We're doing the joint trenches for them. It's at Sierra Park is what we generally call it. Yeah, great. Does that make sense? I mean, it's far. Yeah, yeah. It's far. We don't have to. No, I think that's great. I'm just kidding. It is great. It's going to be a huge improvement for the parcel. It is quite an endeavor, joint trenching, you know, the mile and a half or whatever it is. Yeah, okay. Okay, so any other questions on this?

2:42:30 Madam Mayor, I'm just, I'm, I'm tallying up some questions as we go, so I'm going to kind of wait to the end at some point. Okay, thanks, John. So, Caleb, do you want to take this, just talking through kind of what we're thinking with phase two? I can. So, I think for starters, what you kind of hear right-of-way phase one, right-of-way phase two, it's kind of important to remember there's kind of two phases going on. There's the right-of-way phasing, and then there's the development phasing. So,

2:43:01 Keeping track of that's a little bit cumbersome, but what you see there on the screen now, what we were thinking, and this is kind of where I think we'd really appreciate some feedback from Council as to the policy direction you want us to head, but what we were thinking for what we'll call the development phase two is we wanted to try to get into tackling some homeownership units.

2:43:27 And that's what you see on the screen there, that number two in that shaded area, that orange shaded area, that was kind of what we were looking at going after maybe next from a planning perspective, going through the process with town staff and the public on the planning of that. And kind of moving forward there and looking at maybe tackling that, you know, 120% AMI and greater range, okay, with that section there that's moving around.

2:43:56 So that's kind of the approach that we're thinking. The reason why that's kind of a good approach perhaps is that it's not, you know, maybe if we did half at $120,000, half at $150,000, it's not a large local town investment at this point. We'll get to a slide later on that kind of shows you phase by phase what we think the town could provide in financing. But because this is a home ownership model,

2:44:24 For this phase, it doesn't require the depth and breadth of public subsidy necessarily as the rental projects do. So one of the reasons we thought we wanted to go that way was for that reason. The other is that without a big financing process with the state, it allows us to actually get into the ground without having to go through that six-month window of financing that we've been in for the parcel phase one with the rental apartment. So that was the idea.

2:44:53 And then on this same slide, you know, you can kind of see what we're thinking about, Shelley, if you want to flip sides now, if we look at maybe what would be a phase three or a phase four, kind of this area, you know, and this is really interchangeable, I think, but the goal, we'll get to the kind of the programming of each of these phases and when they would happen, but you can kind of imagine every year we're breaking ground on a phase, okay?

2:45:21 So this year we'll break ground on phase one with tree removal, et cetera. Next year we'll break ground on phase two. 2023 we break ground on phase three. And we kind of just keep going. You know, every year start a new phase would be the goal. Go through the planning process, get it approved, move it forward. But, you know, these phases are interchangeable. I would say that if I had to, you know, make an ask of what we would do if we did phase two there, the homeownership units.

2:45:48 That we'd either do Phase 3 or Phase 4 as the next one. So the 3 and 4 are probably really interchangeable from our point of view. We'll have all the infrastructure we need for either one to go. And, you know, so I think that's kind of what we're headed to. There's been some kind of conversations around the adjacent commercial properties, around the Phase 3 area there.

2:46:14 And so do we, you know, do we try to incorporate, work with, figure out other strategies there? That's kind of why, you know, that might lead us to going toward more of the red area, the phase four area, turning that into phase three. But what we'd like to do is kind of start with phase two there and then kind of move accordingly. And so direction on that would be helpful to us as you think about, you know, what would be next kind of. And then maybe Shelly, if you want to. These, so the.

2:46:42 The income targeting, whether it's rental or home ownership, is really based on the IIG grant that we submitted and trying to maximize the 450 units that we committed and what that looks like. And the next few slides will show that. So just to know that these are not willy-nilly ideas and thoughts about what's home ownership or rental or anything like that. It's really about income targeting based on what the commitments we made to the state. Yeah, so...

2:47:11 So as you look at the possible phasing plan, you know, it's maybe five phases we end up with there with the last one probably being that five, you know, being the last thing we would do. And part of that is because there's maybe some opportunities to work with adjacent landowners and possibly gain access to that section of the property by other means other than crossing mill ditch. And if we

2:47:40 You know, there's another policy question that kind of comes up, maybe from a planning perspective. You know, maybe that'd be nicer if that state is one kind of constant open space area there that didn't have a, you know, a vehicular or pedestrian access through it. Maybe, you know, maybe that's something worth preserving, let's say. Also probably would save some infrastructure money if we didn't have to build the infrastructure to cross there.

2:48:05 Can we access from other parcels, Office Center? You don't know yet. We're kind of investigating some new opportunities there. So that's kind of where that is. And if we want to flip the next slide, this is just a refresher of the slide you've already seen. Nothing new there. Before we go on.

2:48:27 Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'm looking at Caleb, there's about three or four different policy questions that you brought up there. Looking in the agenda packet, it's not agendized. I mean, it's important stuff, but Madam Mayor Pro Tem and Mr. Hall are wondering how do you want to proceed on this? I don't know if we can really get into this tonight. It's good to have a preview of what it's going to be, but I think this is...

2:48:52 Pretty important stuff. So, John, the question is that, you know, we're sort of asking maybe even Andy, you know, how far we can delve into this under it being a staff presentation of parcel update as opposed to a policy discussion? Yeah, that's sort of an Andy question for sure. But also, glad you're bringing these things up. I don't think we can get into them tonight. And I'd like to...

2:49:17 I have some questions around that when we get to the end to frame up that conversation so we can have good staff work and we can make the appropriate decisions at the appropriate time. Okay, so let's ask our town council. I think I can do this without having a horrible echo now. This discussion item covers the entire parcel so you can discuss anything about the parcel but it's not really set up for the council to make a bunch of decisions or really much in the way of any decisions. It's really...

2:49:43 Just receiving information, anything parcel related is fair game. Just, I don't think you should be kind of giving a lot of specific direction. But endless amounts of questions. Absolutely. Okay, thank you. Linda, my concern is that, okay, it seems that we're given a presentation, it looks like that parcel number two is all 120% of AMI.

2:50:13 I'm not following the discussion correctly. So, you know, I'm kind of confused as to the purpose of this. You know, if we accept this as a presentation, are we endorsing 120% of AMI on Parcel 2? I'm not sure. Council Member Stapp, I wouldn't think so. I think that this is...

2:50:39 Some ideas being thrown out with as many questions as we want to ask. We're not making any decisions. We're not really giving any direction. We're simply receiving information and asking questions about it. Does that make sense, Council Member Wentworth? Yeah, it's all time for me. I'm making notes of my questions that we can. Okay, good. All right, so why don't we continue with the presentation. No questions. We'll come back to those when it's a point at which.

2:51:10 We have a moment to do that. Okay. Gotcha. And again, you know, we're just trying to, you know, give you ideas that we're thinking about. You know, you guys will provide us the appropriate direction and when you're ready to do that. And then obviously, you know, the time you need to take, I mean, we're just kind of bringing forth the, you know, a possible program here for you. So that's really how to think about. You've got to have something to think about and talk about. So that's what this is. Okay. Let's go. Okay. So, Shelley, if you want to go to the next slide.

2:51:40 This just depicts kind of what a possible program, that's why it says possible on the slide, program could look like for the remaining areas of the parcel, all the areas of the parcel. And so every one of those kind of just depicts the phase, what could be built in that phase. And, you know, that's the first thing, kind of when it would start, when it would be complete, the number of units, what kind of units would be built.

2:52:10 The income targeting. And as you can see there, to Kirk's question, you know, we had thought about 120 to 150% AMI for that second phase there. The town of Mammoth Lakes funding needed and why we took the time to really go through this exercise and kind of create this mock development or possible development plan was to sort of help the town begin to consider what kind of money would be needed, by when would it be needed.

2:52:38 And just to start framing the conversation, right? And obviously this varies by what the choices are, but this is at least something to work with. The town of Mammoth, yeah. You know, this is, you sort of said, you know, mock development. I mean, as I mentioned before, we made some commitments both as a team, the development team, which is Pacific Companies and the Town of Mammoth Lakes in our IIG application. It does have some flexibility.

2:53:08 But in that IIG application, we did have some rentals for upper incomes. We had a few for sale units for upper incomes. And at the bottom line there, you'll see IIG earned. So by producing certain income level of income units, we get IIG money. So you'll see by producing those 120 to 150% AMI units there where it says phase two, we don't.

2:53:31 The town doesn't get very much money of the IIG money to be able to do that. So the IIG money really comes into the town as we build those lower income units. So this table here represents the commitments made in the IIG application. So yes, there's some flexibility, but this is what we said that we would do. And we really...

2:53:56 This came from Kirk every time we were before the council, whether it was the master plan or the, you know, the land commitment or things like that was, what's it going to cost? What's it going to cost? What's it going to cost? And this is our projected build-out cost of local funds needed is a huge number of, you know, 16-5. And, you know, it's moving as fast as we possibly can. You know, we're looking at that needing that 16-5 by May of 2024.

2:54:25 Which is around the corner. And that, you know, that's, and those are, you know, real dollars that we need to work towards to be able to bring the full execution of the parcel to fruition. Andrew, real quick, that's a, that's an all-in number. That's not a per unit number, right? That's like a, somehow we need 16.5 million in the bank at some point. Okay, thank you. Yeah, that's, that's set up, John, to be, you know,

2:54:52 What you see there is a combination of things happening. We have to deliver a certain unit count and certain income targeting and product type to earn the IIG. And so at the bottom there, we're going to get to that, but it's basically based on the income targeting of phase one of 30 to 80% AMI and based on the number of units, studio through three bedroom,

2:55:22 That earns us that much money of the IIG that we have of 20 million. We earn the money based on production. Now, keep in mind, we can draw it down. We don't have to produce anything to draw it down. We can draw it down, build infrastructure. But at the end of the day, to earn it and keep it without having to pay it back, we've got to deliver housing roughly along these lines. And as you can see, the 30% to 80% AMI delivers a lot more earning of IIG.

2:55:52 Then does the homeownership unit, as an example, because they're not as valuable to the state from the state's point of view. Therefore, you don't earn as much. But this money can be earned by deeper targeting. It can be earned by bigger units. It can be earned by more units that are higher income targeted. It's kind of like a puzzle that you have to kind of manage. And this is just really a proposal to sort of work with for the short term. And, you know, the other thing I'll just say,

2:56:20 Is that when it comes to actual funding from the town, you'll notice at the bottom there, Town of Commitment needed Town of Mammoth Lake's funding date. We have the ability to play with the actual funding. We can bridge your money is kind of the short answer. Whereas if we have a funding commitment, we can work with that. We can get other financing aligned. We can bridge it with other private sources.

2:56:44 And then kind of stretch that out so that your payment doesn't have to come in. So that's kind of what we sketched out here. This actually took, even though it looks like kind of a simple slide, it actually took quite a bit of work to prepare. You know, financial models run for each of these phases and estimating the need of funding, etc. But you get the idea. And when you kind of establish policy direction, finally, we'll be able to drill down on that even further.

2:57:12 That's a sketch of what the development of the parcel would look like, the amount of money that the town could look at contributing. The only thing I'll say in addition to this is that, you know, we are obviously always looking for state resources, federal resources, and we will continue to do that just like we have already, just like the infrastructure money, the $20 million that we got together. And we're going to continue to do our best to help.

2:57:41 You know, stretch the town's money as far as possible, you know, if you will. So you can see on that first phase, like if you had to just look at what we did accomplish, thanks to Mono County, I give great credit to them, we were obviously only able to ask for about $3,600 a unit from the town in addition to the land and the infrastructure we got together. You know, future phases, we're not making that assumption. We're not making the assumption that the county's got money like they did this time.

2:58:08 So just those kinds of things, you know, we're going to do our best to try to minimize that financial outlay because that's our job to do that. But at the same time, you know, you get a picture there of what it's going to take. So I'll pause there. The rest of the presentation is really just specifics on the IIG, which we can cover if you want real quick. Mayor, what do you say? Do you want to cover the last few slides real quick and then go to questions?

2:58:37 Why don't we take a few questions now in a little bit of a smaller bite? Why don't we do that? Councilmember Wentworth, why don't you go ahead? Yeah, thank you all. I've got a good idea. So quick questions going back to the beginning. The modular production out of Idaho, any challenges there? Or do you guys feel confident you can deliver based any production delays? Anything happening? What? No, we feel very confident.

2:59:07 And actually, I think you all know we have a factory that builds these. We actually are not scheduled to use our factory for the first phase. We're using Nashua Builders for the first phase, another Idaho modular builder that we just did a project for us. And so, you know, I see good capacity, John, in the factories. I don't see it as an issue. We're doing well. We're building now actively. Three modules a day come out of our factory, and Nashua, I think, spits out two a day. Okay, good.

2:59:35 We don't have to worry about production from that. At least we have to worry about that. Okay, Cal Fire. I don't know, Supervisor Corliss is not on this call any longer, but what's going on with Cal Fire and that tree harvesting thing, that cannot not be addressed. And Dan, we need to write a letter with...

3:00:00 Mono County, with Mono County, and just Caleb, Andrea, and Shellen, you may not be aware, Supervisor Corliss serves on something called the Forest Resilience Task Force, and her capacity is head of the RCRC. Also on that task force, a guy named Wade Crowfoot, who's the head of the Natural Resources Agency of the State of California, and Stacey had offered in the past, when I talked with her anecdotally about this problem, to get the...

3:00:27 The challenge we're having to build housing, running into a bureaucratic blockade from CAL FIRE to get that resolved. Dan and Madam Mayor and Kirk, I would ask that we send a letter, very specifically targeted, laying out what we're dealing with that's keeping us from getting housing built based on that CAL FIRE issue. If anybody needs any more information, what's going on? You guys are all clear what I'm talking about, right? Yes. Okay, let's not, that has to be, we need to do something.

3:00:56 That has to happen. Micromobility, again, Caleb, for you and your team, the town is, you may have heard earlier, Hayes talked about work that's happening around micromobility. This goes back to the conversation we had about parking a long time ago. I really want to make sure that the work that we're doing with these phases is tied in to the opportunities that's coming out of that micromobility and that planning effort.

3:01:22 These things should be happening. You guys should all be talking with each other because the conversation around parking versus whatever policy things our staff is coming up with for micro mobility solutions. I hope you guys are talking with each other about this. I don't know if you are, if you're not, but I'm certainly looking to make sure that you are talking about it because we want to park humans and not automobiles. A general question about state and federal funding. I work.

3:01:49 In the recreation space, doing a bunch of work over there. We are keenly aware of all this federal money that's potentially coming and all the state money that's coming, but we don't really quite know when. And I'm wondering if there's going to be some money for broadband in all of that, but also as a general question of timing and sequencing, do we want to be thinking about maybe not rushing too much?

3:02:16 So that we can wait and see how all that funding gets baked. I would hate to see us move forward with some solutions we could talk about in a second. If, gee, if we'd waited four months or five months or six months, I mean, that reconciliation legislation, that should be done by September, hopefully. But to get all that money from the federal stuff through the pipelines into the place we can actually get our hands on it, I think that's something tactically we need to be thinking about. It's not a rhetorical.

3:02:46 Question, but it's an observation. Same thing with the state. There's a guy named Derek Kirk, who's, who, do you guys know what GoBiz is? Andrea? I've heard of it, I don't know, yeah. Okay, Shalen, do you know what GoBiz is? So GoBiz is the state of California's small business and business.

3:03:04 Investment arm. It lives in the governor's office. It's an executive-level department. Our region finally has a dedicated representative. He's going to be over in the Eastern Sierra next week, August 11th and 12th. I know, Linda, you'll be meeting him with, I think, as part of an ESCO conversation. I'll be meeting with him and Dan as part of a Monroe County Town of Mammoth Lakes-focused discussion. He is our guide for where all the money is in the state budget.

3:03:28 It still has not gone through the trailer bill process. We don't know where it's been allocated and where it's going to end up. So I'm thinking that, Dan, hopefully as we meet with Derek next week, we can be feeding good information back to these guys so we can make good tactical decisions that we don't jump and do something where if we'd waited three or four months, oh my goodness, the floodgates have opened, there's going to be a whole bunch more money. Just something to think about on that.

3:03:53 The ownership phase two, we'll come back to that to some degree, but again, to Dan and the staff, that GIS tool, we need that. If we're going to be asked to make policy decisions about home ownership and things like that, we don't know what the net of these things are going to be. So just, again, another plea to get that tool in place. I'll save these other questions to the end because I think they're going to apply to everything, but I've got four or five more. Is that all good? You guys got all that?

3:04:25 Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Councilmember, staff, would you like to ask some questions? No, I just have one comment. You know, this is the first I've seen of this presentation, so I'm going to have to sit down and look at this and compare it with our wait list. And so, again, this is all new information to me. This is the first I've seen it. So thank you. And thank you for all the work that's been put into this, too.

3:04:54 Thank you. Of course. The question I would like to just double back on is, can you explain to me again the rationale for moving from very low income to the higher income for phase two with lesser units being built in phase two? Yeah, sure. I mean, you know, again, it all kind of stems from what we...

3:05:22 collectively committed to producing under the Infill Infrastructure Grant, okay? Now, to state that again, there's two things we're managing. Obviously, it's the master plan and the planning document that that is, and then it's the Infill Infrastructure Grant Award. The Infill Infrastructure Grant Award is flexible, meaning we don't have to do any home ownership units if we decide not to, okay?

3:05:52 It's a formula that we earn money based upon the targeting, the unit type, and the size of the unit, right? So that's the program. When it comes to the master plan, and Shelyn, maybe that's where you want to kick in, then that becomes sort of the policy document about what's developed on the site. And so, you know, the reason that we said, you know, first of all, that area right next.

3:06:18 And that density is because that's a lower density area of the site. That's meant to be two-story development. Not real dense, so not very efficient as apartments, for one. So that, you know, you can see in there that that area, too, is the lower density buildings. Those are meant to be two-story buildings, no greater than. And that's why we thought it was a good home ownership area, because it would blend with the existing neighborhood there to the east.

3:06:44 And kind of help be a transition into the rest of the higher density areas of the site. But that was the rationale for it. It was also something that we thought could be developed, you know, in providing a mix, right, a broad range, because the first phase would be sort of this 30 to 80% AMI. And then, you know, like, let's start delivering some workforce housing at the upper end, right? So we kind of thought that maybe delivering that product to market, see how it fits.

3:07:12 See how it works. And we don't have the financing contingency with other resources from the state. So that was the rationale behind that. And those don't necessarily have to be homeownership. I mean, we were, you know, we listened to the council meeting a couple weeks ago where there was this, you know, rapid move, like, how do we go fast? How do we go faster? And, you know, if there was a, you know, a local commitment of dollars towards some of these units, whether they be market or, you know,

3:07:42 Upper income rental or upper income for sale, which in our slide show the upper income for sales cost less per unit of local dollars than the upper income for rent. But, you know, really, like, how can we look at some of those units in that those G buildings there and really deliver them in many ways in conjunction with the first phase of development? You know, we could do those very fast with the commitment of local dollars. Again,

3:08:10 Just thinking, really working in response to need and overhearing council and staff discussions, both our private conversations with staff that we have in our bi-weekly meetings and hearing the urgency that we hear at council meetings and just trying to respond to that need. So that was really what that was. Because if we look at, you know, our, and of course,

3:08:31 While we do that, we'll be looking at entitling those other projects so that they can get in line for financing. So that really was part of that motivation. And as Caleb said, we'll get into some of these slides later that show the IIG expenditures, but it doesn't have to be for sale. It doesn't have to be...

3:08:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:09:07 What kind of impact and financial impact does that actually look like for the parcel as you look towards making these financial decisions? So not our request. For sure, our bread and butter as an organization and as a company is focusing on these low-income housing tax credit projects. It's what we do best.

3:09:24 Yes, we can still do this market rate rental and for sale product based on your desired need, but that's really, it's fine with us, whatever direction we go, it was really in response to how do we get units on the ground for you as quickly as possible based on the programming that you all went through in the plan, the parcel phase. So that's really where that came from. Okay, could you go to the last slide you showed us again, please? The chart? That chart.

3:09:55 So when we look at Town of Mammoth Lakes funding needed, it kind of goes across there with a total of, yeah, I'm sorry, I've got to get the people out of the way here. Okay, so you're talking about $60 million over the five phases projected roughly? Yes. Okay, and then the phasing of when that money is due is down below the Town of Mammoth Lakes commitment.

3:10:24 So February 22, February. So the funding for both phase two and three, you say, would be about the same time. So that's about eight million, I guess, in there. Yeah, so that's a commitment. And then below it would be the funding date. Okay. So it all comes right, kind of do all there pretty quick. Okay. All right. Yeah, that's just, I wanted to take a look at that as well. And if I may, just to clarify.

3:10:52 The commitment is needed to be competitive in those low-income housing tax credits. Yes, understood. Yeah, understood. Yep, and then the funding date is when it actually needs to come to fruition. Yeah, it actually comes due. It would be 22, 24. Okay. All right. I think I have no further questions right now. If you wanted to maybe proceed to the next. Sure. Yeah, that's great. So this just finishes up. This is just an IIG refresher.

3:11:19 So you guys know exactly how that's going. Again, $20 million award. It's meant to cover two critical things, public infrastructure and then podium parking. That's what it can cover. No surface parking allowed. Only podium parking is covered with that money. And I've already talked about what it takes to earn the money, not have to pay it back. We get to draw it down immediately to build things, but we have to earn it to keep it.

3:11:46 And then that's just a refresher on, you know, what we promised in the IIG, 450 units. Again, flexible to move all that around as long as we deliver the unit numbers and, you know, types that are needed to get the full award. The one thing I just do want to point out is under our DDA currently we're limited to 450 units, so the flexibility to move within the IIG becomes somewhat constrained. If we had more units,

3:12:15 Then you can change the income targeting, let's say, to serve a little bit higher incomes and not have to worry about necessarily earning all the IIG. Okay, so that's just that point. So, Shelley, if you want to move on, this is just a quick refresher of money spent or, you know, fixing to be spent. First phase there, roughly $4 million in the colored area.

3:12:37 And then the podium parking for the first buildings under phase one construction would be 3.6. So we'd have roughly 13 to go after we do phase one. And phase one is on track to start. I mean, we are in good shape and we can expect that. Phase two, Shelyn, if you want to go on one more. Phases kind of two and three, you know, the infrastructure there would be the extension of Chaparral.

3:13:06 We do some off-sites that are, you know, connectivity off-sites, the broadband extension, that kind of stuff. And then the last little bit of right-of-way would also be done there. So that's kind of the idea is get things handled, get everything figured out. We'd roughly, after the end of the day, end up with about eight and a half million that we could use for podium parking on the other phases. So that's just kind of how to think about that. And I think it's a relevant discussion when we talk about crossing mill.

3:13:36 Ditch and doing those improvements that, you know, we, by not spending that money on that, let's say, that does open up more money for parking. And, you know, I know that's one of the big policy concerns is, you know, is there going to be enough parking on this site? You know, covered parking is obviously better than surface parking from snow removal reasons and others. Also helpful for density. So just...

3:14:04 Those are some policy considerations there to begin to think about. And that's really it. I mean, with that eight and a half, that would kind of be the additional money available for parking, podium parking. And again, you know, the numbers flex a little bit based on actual bids, etc. But this just gives you a good sketch of where we are at this point. We are looking to build all of this infrastructure next summer.

3:14:29 Spring and Summer and Fall getting it all done. And so all these roads and everything would be in place by the end of really next year. So that's the program. And we're still waiting for our official contract from the state. But I have others that are still not here either. So I'm not worried. But that's where we are at this point. So that kind of completes the IAG refresher.

3:14:55 And I think that does it for us for presentation purposes and we can do whatever questions and conversations you guys want to have. Sheldon or Andrea, do you have anything you want to add to anything? Well, just to real clear on the parking, you know, you're...

3:15:11 You're such an optimist, Caleb, and it's wonderful. But just so you know, podium parking, we're looking at about $60,000 of space. So with $8.5 million to do podium parking for all of the other units outside of the first 81 that we're building, it only gets us about another 120 or so podium parking spaces for the remaining

3:15:39 300 plus units to get to the 450. So, you know, with podium parking being a priority, you know, if there really is a policy direction from council to staff to really minimize surface parking, you know, that $16.5 million number for build-out goes up substantially to get those.

3:16:04 You know, podium spaces. You know, we're looking at tuck under spaces for the townhomes and some other things. But, you know, we've heard that surface parking is not desirable. The preferred plan said that. But, you know, we're trying to make the best investment of the town's dollars and the IAG money. And this is where I said in the general presentation that to the extent that there might be local transportation funds, other opportunities to capitalize on infrastructure or housing that can help.

3:16:32 Bolster that $8.5 million once the right-of-way is complete. That helps with moving surface parking to podium parking, as well as density. You know, the bigger building, like the one that we're doing, shown there is A1. You know, that's a much more efficient way to deliver a podium parking than a smaller building. So we're really looking at all those things and trying to make the best use of town, state, and federal dollars. But man, that $20 million went real fast.

3:17:01 It always does. Okay, thank you. If anybody else would like to say anything before we get to questions at all? Okay, let's start on questions again. Councilmember, maybe before you dive into that, would you have some public comment? Okay, thank you very much. Go ahead. It's not obvious to me what you mean by podium parking. Structured parking is basically underneath the, you know, it's structured underneath the building, so you tuck under.

3:17:45 Some of us completely, and some can be alone, but it's tucked under the building. And my apologies. Okay, any other public comment? No? Okay, here, oh, go ahead. Sorry, Tom Hodges blinked back and forth a couple times. It looks like he does have a comment. Okay, please unmute yourself, Tom, and give your comments. Thanks, sorry, my, normally a hand turns yellow, but it was just changing the color. It wasn't changing the color, so I was a little confused, but my apologies. Thanks for taking my question, or just as a comment, really.

3:18:24 I wanted to make the Town Council aware that the 2017 Housing Needs Assessment document that informed the Community Housing Action Plan, there was actually numbers in there about the units that were needed at that time. And for sale, for purchase housing units in that report identified up to 55 units for the income range of 120 to 150% AMI.

3:18:54 So I just, I wanted to endorse and support the notion of doing the for sale product in phase two. I think it's a great idea. One, it's a low, it's a low match. Two, it can get done in short order. And, you know, there was demand based on our housing needs assessment in 2017. Anecdotally from our employees, we're hearing a lot of people asking for that type of product to be, that they're looking for, for purchase opportunities.

3:19:22 And, you know, hopefully we, the Mountain, can further inform that need and demand. We're just in the process of completing a housing needs assessment of our employee base and should have really good metrics and data from our employees of what they're looking for. We've asked all those questions about, are you looking for rental? Are you looking for purchase? You know, what's your price range? You know, also attached to their income levels so that we can, you know, have real data that...

3:19:50 Can help inform these decisions. But, you know, it's clear to me that there's demand for that product, you know, in 2017, much less now, it's only greater. So, I think it's a slam dunk to go forward with that, with the four purchase for sale units in phase two. And that's my comments. Thank you. Okay, thank you very much. Is that it? No more, Jamie? There's one more public comment. Hi, Ted Carlton. Mr. Hodges and Andrea bring up

3:20:23 An interesting point. So Andrea said in her comment that more local dollars could get more units built in conjunction to phase one, I guess in phase two. And Hodges is talking about for purchase units and that demand. What's the cost per unit to do that versus throwing $3 million at Joaquin Street? Are we going to do a comparison to decide what's the better deal and what's the bigger bang for the buck? Thank you.

3:20:57 Okay, thank you. Those are all the public comments. Okay, thanks. All right, more questions? Councilmember Whiteworth? Yeah, thank you. All right, let's do the easy ones first. One of the slides, the text said funding low due to Mono County. I think I know what that means. It means that the funding need is low because of the grant money that came in from Mono County for...

3:21:31 Forgive me, what was the term that's used for that particular type of housing? The no place like home funding and the MHSA funding, which are two sources, the county's contributing, I think their total is like 2.3 million total between the two sources, but yes, that's coming from them. Just to make sure that we're clearing the semantics of that, but that was a positive, not that the county's not contributing money.

3:22:01 Yeah. The second thing is, Andrea, I just want to, if we could use a different term of art other than upper income when we're talking about within this universe that we're talking about, right? I think we all know, we all get that. We're dealing with a, you know, we're one of those places that wealthy human beings are looking to buy properties to mitigate the effects of the

3:22:29 I think when you're saying upper income,

3:22:59 Billionaires. So let's just all practice that going forward. That'll be useful. What does ROW stand for? Right of way. Right of way. Right of way. Okay, good. Thank you. So those are inferred for the public certification. It's publicly owned streets. So there's a big difference. I mean, in Mammoth, you'll find a lot of private streets and a lot of, you know, driveways with other condo developments and things like that. But these are publicly owned roads. So it's a pretty big

3:23:27 Deal. You know, get the roads built, they get committed to the town, they become the town's responsibility, which is why there's so much care in going into the engineering of these roads and the infrastructure to support a development of this size. Yep. And, Caleb, thanks for pointing out again that we, as a small community that's being very aggressive in trying to meet our housing needs, we still can't get a signed agreement out of the state for the IIG contract. Is that fair to say?

3:23:57 That's correct. I don't know if there's any county people listening on this, but the advocacy to the state for the work that we're doing, I'm more than willing to go to Sacramento. I'm vaccinated, and this is aggravating to me. Okay, so now this is kind of a multi-hydra kind of a thing. The first thing is, I appreciate the numbers, those all-in, those 20 million, whatever that number is that's needed to make all this stuff happen.

3:24:27 Makes sense. One concern I have is that the way this is set up is the council has the right, and Andy, you can weigh in and this is needed, to approve each phase as we go forward, right? And that's...

3:24:44 There's reasons for that. There's also reasons to be able to look at the totality of this effort to say, look, we can look at numbers that are going to make this whole thing work. And I just want to point this out that, you know, there's, you know, so far so good. But if we were to move forward with a funding opportunity to make this all work with one developer, well, what happens if everybody, people start getting hit by buses?

3:25:10 Then what are we going to do? Just bringing that up. I want to make sure we don't skip over that. The question to you, Dan, is, Dan, does the town have the authority to issue a bond that could cover $20 million that we could do in a reasonable timeframe that could cover some of the needs that we're talking about here? Could you speak to that a little bit? The whole question there becomes is having a dedicated revenue source that you could bond against versus a general tax bond, which would be...

3:25:41 Okay, but we could, I mean, we're going back to that CHAP question, which we talked about earlier. We've got TOT, if the councils, we can make a commitment of 1%, one point of TOT, but this is something that we could put on the ballot, theoretically, to float a bond to cover this $20 million that we're talking about. I mean, you could get a bond issue through that process, but you'd have to have that dedicated revenue go with it versus just our general fund. You can do a general obligation bond, I guess, at that point through a voter initiative.

3:26:10 That they'd have to approve, which would come out of the general fund, there'd be no dedicated revenue to it. So that's something to maybe, we could talk about that more. Yeah, I think. But 2022 is coming up. I think it's, the bigger question will be, is what's the actual need at the end of this point? Okay, but just that's, in terms of, you know, that's a direction from the CHAP, to find a funding source, this is a specific thing that we're talking about, something to think about. I would like,

3:26:40 Dan, in terms of the coordination of the micromobility and these parking questions are going to keep coming up, who is the lead on that? Is that a Hayes and Sandra thing? Is that Grady still playing this role? Who's going to be coordinating those opportunities, especially with money like LTC funding or money coming out of broadband? Who's running point on that and who's going to be accountable for identifying those opportunities?

3:27:07 Ultimately, it's kind of a team approach. The last round in discussions with LTC is there's no substantial funding currently available until, I think, 2026. So that's out of ways for any type of real funding into the parcel from LTC based on the last round of discussions. Some of that could shift a little bit, but likely not a lot of funding there. The whole element of the mobility, be it micro, be it parking, et cetera, is kind of that whole.

3:27:33 Scope of the mobility study that's being done, which is coming out of LTC under Public Works, driving that issue, looking at that, and how does it link in and tie to, so it's not being done independently of this project, this project has to tie into that larger program of work on mobility in general. Okay, so the sequencing of these efforts, are they aligning? Yeah, they ultimately will, yes, because they have to, in terms for all of it to work together, it'll have to line up that way.

3:28:01 And we will be looking at parking issues within the parcel and other places and where do you leave and how do you get on something else and those types of challenges. Okay. You know, leave. I am, I am, I tend to be, I'm very much looking forward to the analysis about those private units in that phase too, Caleb, as you've presented. I know we're not going to make a decision tonight, but that's intriguing. I'd like to see what the cost thing looks like, I think.

3:28:31 In terms of the work that we may be doing on some other projects and that other town program that we're funding where we get the best value for the money, the taxpayers' money, I think it's going to be interesting to look at that. And I am interested in this, the question came up about what's in the DDA and the constraint that's in there with the number of units. I know that's been an issue that these three council members have debated and looked at.

3:28:57 But I would like to take another look at that. And I think if it's going to give us some flexibility with the funding, I'm not predisposing a decision, but I would like to look at if we went, if we gave you guys some more headroom in terms of the unit count, if that's going to help with the financing, but also take a look at the density concerns and making sure that I'd like to look at that again. If that's going to be an opportunity for financing, I'd like to see what that looks like.

3:29:26 And that's what I've got here for one last thought that I appreciate Mr. Hodges saying that the Mountain is doing their own kind of independent needs assessment. I hope that the town is going to be doing something similar. I'd hate to think that, well, gee, you know, Mammoth Resorts was able to come up with the resources to do a assessment for their own employees, their own staff. And yet the town that our assessment is five, six, seven years out of date. And I'd hate to have competing interests.

3:29:56 Coming to the table at the same time. And again, that goes back to, we talked about doing an update to the needs assessment, an update to the community housing action plan, Dan, something to be thinking about as all these things start to converge. If we don't have the information, we don't have the information, but it would be great to get a sense of what the needs are like, especially given, you know, we're dealing going into COVID phase two. And I think that the situation that we talked about, Andrea, with the housing situation in destination communities like ours,

3:30:25 That's probably going to get aggravated. That's only going to get worse. And it's a whole new ballgame. And we need some analysis for that. So my thoughts. Thank you for your patience. Sorry to ramble on like that, but thank you very much. Okay, thank you. Councilmember Stapp? Thank you very much. All this information, I mean, it's just being presented to me now. I haven't had a chance to sit down with staff or Mammoth Lake Housing staff.

3:30:57 So, you know, I don't have any comments on it. At this time, I just need to sit down and I appreciate the presentation. I think it's a good first step. And now I need to try to dig into the details to see, make sure I can understand it as well as explain it to the community. So thank you.

3:31:21 Okay, thank you. Thank you guys for this presentation. It was really useful, a lot to think about. I particularly like this last chart here that we're looking at right now. But I will ask staff, what would you see then as next steps in this process? So we've received a presentation tonight. What are the next motions on this? Well, if I could.

3:31:47 I've already sent a long list of questions and directions we need to take to the town manager, and he said that, yeah, we're going to get together between Sandra, myself, Rob, Hayes, himself, the full parcel team, and really take a look at that, take a look at this exhibit, and come back to you with a recommendation. If that's our job, is to analyze all this stuff and get back to you, and I think I've framed most of the questions.

3:32:11 I haven't heard much new tonight in terms of the questions, and that was framed in an email I sent to the town manager over the last couple of weeks, a couple of them, in fact, and I think he's on board with that, and we have a good way to head forward, but our next step is to analyze all that as a full team and then get something back to you. The timing for that, you know, I can't answer that. We have a lot of other things going on in August, but we'll talk to Dan tomorrow unless we can volunteer something today, but it's a focused effort, multiple meetings, and then get back to you with recommendations. Is that a fair statement, Dan?

3:32:42 Yeah, we're working through that. We'll start that process. I mean, this is looking at all the various housing programs, not just the parcel. And I think, you know, that's a broader discussion definitely we're having at the staff level as well as we'll have to have with the parcel team. How much of this do we just throw into one project versus any other type of diversity within the community? And I think that's a valid question to have and to look at this. There's some options here, definitely.

3:33:07 But you could also take every nickel and just put it in this project alone and do nothing else, which I wouldn't recommend, frankly. But that is an option to look at. If that's where council wants to go, we can definitely do those types of elements. But I think right now, like Kirk said, too, we're really just getting all of this from a staff level tonight as well. I mean, we got the PowerPoint out today. We have a little staff report prior. So we haven't digested this at all at this point. Okay, so it'll take some time. I'm sorry, Grady, go ahead.

3:33:36 Thank you. I just wanted to add one thing, and it's something that we deal with, frankly, almost on a daily basis on the parcel. When we're preparing these two reports, and when we work together as a team on this, we're going to have to also bring the town attorney in because these are larger policy issues, but they very much affect what happened on the parcel. We only need to be very careful about when we can and cannot involve the full council.

3:34:02 It's a question we deal with all the time because certainly, you know, affordable housing is a policy issue, but the parcel is the elephant in the room. We're going to deal with all of it together. So everybody willing to be involved and we'll make sure we tread lightly and do it correctly. Well, from a policy level, I could probably at least speak for this council member and that is that I would not want any decision delay on the part of staff or town council to cause a delay in the implementation of the parcel plan.

3:34:32 So just, you know, if we can keep up to speed and move along at the speed that we need to in order to facilitate the development of these units, that would be important. Okay. Any other comments to end this item then? Everybody has what they need. Thank you very much to Caleb and Shellen and Andrea for being here and helping us.

3:35:00 Get our hands around us for your good ideas, your hard work, so not at all unnoticed or unappreciated, so thank you guys very, very much. Staff, thank you for all you're doing, staff, to work on this. I know it's a full-time, along with many other full-time things you're doing, so good job, everybody. So, okay, let's end this. Thank you, everyone, and we'll wait and have Mayor Sauser rejoin us and continue. Is he coming back? There he is.

3:35:37 Oh, yeah. He's pushing the buttons. There he is. Okay, there you go, sir. There we are. Thank you all for that piece of work. Moving on to consent agenda. 9.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of July 21. 9.2, accept payment approval reports number 21-56, 22-04, 22-05.

3:36:09 And 21-57. And that is our entire consent tonight. Anybody want to pull anything? Accept a motion then? Mr. Mayor, I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, Jamie, please. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser?

3:36:41 Yes. Passes 4-0. I've had a request from a couple of people to move their items up. I understand we have someone from Bird Scooters with us who would like to go so he doesn't have to stay up all night. And I believe that there is someone from Mammoth Rocks on as well. So I will ask you what your pleasure is. Do you want to take those out of order?

3:37:11 Or just go in order. It's fine with me to take them out of order. I agree. John? I'm here for the duration, so it's a pleasure, Mr. Mayor. Then let's skip down to 10.4 to start with. Agreement with Bird Scooters. And Hayes, you're up.

3:37:39 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, and thank you, Council, for taking this order, and Michael, I appreciate your patience. I've heard John mention micromobility a couple times in tonight's Council meeting, and it's honestly a really exciting opportunity. Over the last few years, Town Staff has spoken with a few different micromobility providers, whether that be bike share or scooter share.

3:38:01 And the vendors we've spoken to in the past have not really had a viable plan to manage operations through our challenging seasons here at the town. So when we were approached by Byrd, you know, we asked them a number of really difficult questions about how they would overcome these challenges. And Byrd proposed a plan that appears to address the known and really well-publicized issues regarding micromobility.

3:38:27 So we ran the general concept by the planning commission and received direction to advance that to town council for further evaluation. However, before we did that, we felt it was prudent to have a conversation with our partners at the United States Forest Service. And we wanted to be sure before we talked to council that e-scooters would be permitted or not be permitted on the U.S. Forest Service mops. We felt this would be critical to operations and decision making.

3:38:54 And it's entirely possible we were the first people to ask this question at the Forest Service, so it took some time to get an answer. We ultimately did receive a decision from the District Ranger that e-scooters would be treated the same as e-bikes on Forest Service property. And huge thanks to Matt Perullo for shepherding that decision. I don't think we would have gotten an answer if we didn't have him involved. So this evening, we're asking you to receive a presentation from Bird and ask them any questions.

3:39:23 And then we are seeking authorization for the town manager to execute an agreement with BERT. At this time, we are contemplating a permit to operate for the remainder of the year as kind of a pilot program to test the waters. And we'll take any lessons learned from those operations to craft a permit process for micromobility providers and possibly some new ordinances to support that process. This is something Public Works and the town attorney are already working on.

3:39:52 So, Michael, if you're with me, at this time I'd like to introduce Michael and invite him to share this evening's presentation. Thank you very much, Hayes. Good evening, Mayor Sauser, members of Council. Thank you very much for having me here this evening and for your consideration in taking the agenda out of order here. I do have a short presentation, as Hayes indicated. Is everyone able to see my screen? Thank you.

3:40:23 As mentioned, I am with the Revenue and Partnerships team at Bird Scooters. We are a shared electric mobility company. We actually have since expanded to multiple modalities in terms of the vehicles that we do offer. Our system is very similar to some of the bike share systems that you might be familiar with. The objective is to allow people to travel those sub-five-mile trips that I believe the geography of Mammoth Lake predominantly consists of.

3:40:49 In order to reduce congestion on some of the roads, improve air quality, and generally improve the quality of life within a community. The way that our systems work is individuals will download a mobile application on their phone, see one of these scooters or one of the e-bikes within the community, or via the map functionality on the app, create an account where they will view a safety tutorial that teaches them about safe riding behavior as well as proper parking etiquette.

3:41:16 Scan the scooter to unlock it, take it where they need to go, usually somewhere around 10 to 15 minutes away before hitting a button to end their ride. Somebody else will then come along and do the exact same thing. So there are multiple short trips per day per scooter. Our pricing structure is typically $1 to unlock the scooter, followed by a certain number of cents per minute, depending on certain town or city conditions.

3:41:46 The vehicle that I believe would be most readily available for the town of Mammoth Lakes would be our Bird Zero. This is a custom-designed scooter that has been specifically built for the purposes of a rideshare application. As you can see, it is equipped with a bell, a front headlamp visible up to 500 feet at night. Running lights and brake lights sit with similar visibility. I'd also like to draw your attention to the bottom right hand of the screen where you will see a decal that indicates

3:42:15 Most of the key safe driving behavior that we want to have available to everybody as well as the 24-7 customer service number and email address that any riders or non-riders can use to get hold of us to request service such as moving a scooter or reporting an issue. The way that our approach typically works is to ensure that we do have the approval of a city.

3:42:37 Before coming to a town in this instance, before coming to a new community to implement one of these systems, part of that involves the conversations that we've had with the Planning and Economic Development Committee, Hayes, Matt, and everyone else at the city that we've had the privilege of working with thus far. I do want to be clear, we are not seeking any subsidy or any investment from the city itself. BIRD will be covering all of the upfront costs to implement one of these systems. There is no cost to the city at all.

3:43:07 We do also provide a city relationship manager. This is an individual bird employee that all city staff will be able to reach out to so that we can create dynamic technological solutions to resolve any concerns that might arise at a later date. This means that there is always somebody that city staff can turn to to ensure that we are providing the best level of service possible. With respect to the day-to-day operations, as Hayes alluded to, we have built a unique model within our industry.

3:43:36 What we do is we actually partner with a local member of the community to provide a small business for an entrepreneur that has no upfront costs, no fixed costs, no termination penalty to ensure that if this is something that simply does not fit with their lifestyle at a later date, there is no penalty to them exiting. What this means is that we can immediately provide a primary economic benefit, in this case to two individuals that we have already had agreements signed with within Mammoth Lakes that are locals within the community.

3:44:06 And can respond to all the day-to-day necessities from an operational perspective. This includes deploying the scooters, rebalancing, which is just a fancy word for moving scooters around from places where people have ended their ride, and keeping them recharged as they are all electric vehicles. In terms of the benefits of the community.

3:44:26 56% of our trips do end in front of a small business. There has been considerable research, including a study by Emory University earlier this year, which has shown that scooters accessible by alternative transportation see significantly increased spending, or sorry, businesses accessible by alternative transportation see significantly increased spending within them. With respect to our fleet manager program, the average take-home for these business owners is a little over $70,000 a year.

3:44:56 Approximately 2.5 million visitors coming during the summer season. I do believe that there is the potential for that to be substantially more. And finally, as a key point of that Emory University study, over a six-month period, directly as a result of e-scooters, roughly $921 per e-scooter in additional spending was done in local small businesses, particularly in the food and beverage industry. So this can be a very good way to help stimulate the local economy.

3:45:22 Particularly at a time when I think everyone has struggled as a result of some of the restrictions related to COVID. For Mammoth Lake specifically, I believe within the staff report, Council has seen the proposed operational zone. This zone is a digital...

3:45:44 Boundary that we can create that will prevent scooters from operating outside of that. I'll go into a little bit more detail in a minute, but I did want to indicate that any scooter that happens to cross one of the thresholds that you are seeing here will no longer be operational until it returns to the operating zone. Ideally, we would love to do a launch sometime this month to capitalize on the remainder of the summer and fall season prior to any change in the weather.

3:46:09 As mentioned, we have already sourced two local individuals who will be helping as fleet managers. With respect to the number of vehicles, which I know is typically a concern for most communities, I think a modest fleet size of somewhere from 50 to 75 units would be appropriate to start out with. Not all of these would be active at any given time. So certainly, even if there were 75 vehicles present within Mammoth Lakes, perhaps only about 70% would be out on the street on any given day.

3:46:41 To the point I was making earlier, our company was the first to offer shared electric scooters. We are now present in over 300 cities globally. What that means is that our geofencing and geospeed technology is incredibly robust. Geofencing refers to the digital boundaries that I was alluding to earlier, or rather describing earlier, that are controlled via a GPS unit that is on board every single one of our scooters or e-bikes.

3:47:06 If a scooter crosses over one of the boundaries that we have delineated as the operational zone, it'll slow down to about 1.5 miles per hour, start beeping and flashing, and the user will get a notification on their phone indicating that they must return to the operational zone. Our technology also allows us to create areas where we reduce the speed of the scooters. We typically have them at 15 miles per hour, which is roughly what your average amateur bicyclist travels at. If there is a particular area where reduced speed would be necessary,

3:47:34 We can certainly implement that with the collaboration of city staff as well. Bird is also the only company to offer a feature that we call helmet selfies. It's one of the ways that we encourage helmet use. If a rider takes a photograph at the end of their ride wearing a helmet, they will receive a credit to their next ride. We have an ongoing free helmet campaign going throughout the entire continental United States. An individual can apply right through our website or right through the mobile application.

3:48:00 And receive a helmet for a $9.95 shipping and handling cost sent directly to their doorstep. With respect to parking management, you notice that there were some pins on the previous map. I can go back to that if you'd like. Maybe not. Essentially, what we can do is create specific areas where we incentivize riders to go, encourage them. Here we go. I encourage them to park so that scooters are always positioned in the most appropriate location possible.

3:48:33 Finally, for our constant development in terms of responding to what we hear our users request, we designed warm-up mode. What this is, is on certain make models of our scooters, a reduction in the maximum speed for a new rider down to six miles per hour until they gain a little bit more confidence and a little bit more familiarity with the system, at which point the scooters will gradually increase in terms of the maximum speed that is offered as well as the level of acceleration.

3:49:02 to the ultimate cap, 15 miles per hour. Quick Start is for the regular commuter, as about 66%, so two-thirds of our trips, are taken for utility purposes. Quick Start allows individuals who are regular users of scooters to skip that flow where they have to scan and simply walk up to a scooter and take it where they need to go. When they leave, we'll automatically walk and end their ride for them. I believe council will likely have a few questions for me, so rather than...

3:49:30 Get too into the weeds here. I'd love to make sure that I address the unique considerations for Mammoth and provide any answers that you might be looking for. Thank you, Michael. I'll go to Council for questions. John? Thank you very much. I'm a big fan of scooters. I've used them.

3:49:53 Extensively. A couple of quick questions. Does Bird currently have a corporate parent? Are you aligned with Lyft or Uber or any of those companies? Or are you your own company with your own app? We are our own company with our own app. Okay. Second question is, we have, as you may be aware, very...

3:50:13 Excellent question. So rather than putting real estate on the scooters, as there's a little bit of a limited amount there,

3:50:40 Within our mobile application, we have unique to each community that we work in a section around local rules, local regulations, as well as local know-how. We can include links within that section or even a splash page that directs individuals to a trail map or something along those lines so that they have all the information readily available to them.

3:50:58 Well, I would just, as we get to a motion on this, I would want to make sure that the town manager makes sure that we link up our trails program, a lot of the collateral, a lot of the, and now, are there any e-bikes involved in this yet, or is this just scooters? For the time being, we would be focusing exclusively on the scooters. However, we do have e-bikes available in some North American markets and are expanding our presence in that regard, so certainly it's something we could offer at a later date.

3:51:25 Okay, and finally, you guys make money through data, is that correct? Is that a fair way to put this or no? No, we do not sell any of our data. We do not make any money off of our data. It is solely off of the ride revenue that is generated. Okay, good. Thank you very much. Good to know. Thank you. Thank you, Councilman. Thank you, John. Okay, good evening, Michael. Thank you for being here. A couple of questions. They might be kind of a...

3:51:52 Rookie questions, but I'll ask anyway. When someone can't ride on the sidewalk, where do they ride? Typically, an individual should treat one of these scooters like they would a bicycle. So keep it to the right side of a lane, use bike lanes where appropriate, trails where there is no prohibition on motorized vehicles, if available. So you can ride them anywhere you can ride a bicycle? Essentially. So there is state law governing their use, which 99% of which boils down to treat it like a bicycle.

3:52:23 Okay. Okay. And you've checked with the town staff and that would be fine on our streets? Yes. Okay. So if I took it for a ride and I was, you know, say 15 minutes on it and got somewhere and left it and came out again and, you know, got back on it, how much would that cost roughly? Excellent question. For a 15 minute ride,

3:52:50 Given the geography of Mammoth Lakes, I would assume you're probably looking at about $4 to $5 realistically. Okay. Or to pause your ride and go in to have lunch for a couple of hours and then return, you'd be charged a lower fee during that time, but would be charged a small fee for the reservation since it would be preventing another user from accessing the scooter. Okay, so that was my other question. If I went to lunch and I took my scooter and I left it out there and I went in and ate and I came out and had been picked up by somebody else and rode off.

3:53:18 So you can, you said just geo-reserve it and it'll still be waiting for me when I get out? Exactly, you can pause your ride. Further to that, part of the responsibility of our fleet manager will be rebalancing the scooters, meaning moving them to areas where people are likely to use them again. We have a very sophisticated machine learning algorithm that can actually predict where scooters should be positioned.

3:53:39 It's very unlikely that you would find yourself in a scenario where... Then I have to call Uber and then it's like, oh, wait, we don't have Uber every day in Mammoth. So that would be, we'd be stuck. And can you ride them all the way up to Main Lodge? I apologize. I don't know Main Lodge off the top of my head. Would you be able to...

3:54:00 More detail as to where that's located within. I think that stays, or Hayes is waving his pencil here, I think. Yes, so initially the, what has been proposed is really the core of town. We've proposed restricting access to anything outside of the village going up to Main Lodge, and we've restricted access to the lakes basins just past. Okay, good. Probably a good idea. Just known conflicts and just wanting to kind of test the waters within the core of town. Yeah.

3:54:27 But you could ride it up to, you could ride up to Canyon, Canyon Lodge? Okay. And you could ride it up the multi-use pathway, how far towards the basin? We're proposing right around Canyon Boulevard, so you could access. Okay, so let's stop there. Staff, we've kind of gone back and forth. We've had some folks interested in taking it further up to get to the residences.

3:54:52 Just past there. Yeah. But we want to make sure that we're not creating additional conflicts on the lake space and path initially. Okay. And when you're riding on the multi-use pathways and you have electric bikes and you have scooters, it's just like having another bicycle and just everybody watches out for everybody. Okay. All right. Thank you. I think that's all my questions. Thank you, Michael. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I've written

3:55:22 The scooter's in San Francisco. That's all I have to say. San Francisco is certainly a very different environment than I think what we might expect within Mammoth Lake. Certainly a significantly reduced fleet size will probably help create a more positive experience within the town. So I guess the follow-up question is, are we going to have winter tires riding the scooter during the wintertime? See, I was thinking chains, but no, I'm joking.

3:55:53 The scooter fleet would be seasonal for the time being. What that means is that when the weather became a little bit inappropriate for somebody to be riding, it would be brought to a central location on property before being returned come springtime. No further questions. Thank you. Thank you for the presentation. Thank you. So my questions, Michael, I'm looking at your map here. You show 30-plus areas in town where you would have stations for these.

3:56:28 Are these occurring on private property or on public domain? The majority of the deployments would occur in the public right-of-way, meaning in the boulevard strip or at the edge of the sidewalk where there's sufficient clearance not to impede any pedestrian traffic. I apologize for not including a photograph of these scooters when deployed, but essentially they're very beautifully lined up.

3:56:53 To be clear, with respect to the 30 stations there, those are example deployment areas. There may be some variability in terms of where the ultimate deployments occur and certainly push to ensure we have additional feedback from our fleet managers. And I'm assuming if you have to deploy them like in the village where it's primarily private, you would get a contract with them for that permission? It would depend on the entity that we...

3:57:23 I would think there's a certain implied liability there if it's going off of them. I'm assuming for all the spots in the public domain that you would get permission from town for each of those prior to stationing them so that we can ensure that they are not blocking or impeding.

3:57:54 Our other modes of transportation. With respect to the specific locations, again, this system is deployed dynamically, so the pins that you are seeing are not the exact areas where you might indeed find scooters. The hope is that through the agreement, we have certain provisions in terms of where we would or would not be allowed to deploy, and we provide all the education necessary to our fleet managers to adhere to those, meaning they don't include...

3:58:22 Deploy in areas where it would potentially impede traffic. At the end of pedestrian traffic, bicycle traffic, or automobile traffic. What I mean by that is typically we advocate for deployment with what's known as the boulevard strip, the area between the curb and the sidewalk where you might find, for example, a row of light poles, a bench, a row of planter, something along those lines that otherwise might not be used by pedestrians.

3:58:52 Yeah. So I'm assuming in the contract, and Hayes, that's probably for you, that we would be giving permission for each spot, that they would not be allowed to just take them. And I don't mean to sound negative here, just in talking with other towns who have done bikes and scooters and things in the past, not necessarily with your company, the issues that they have had and where these things end up and the problems they create with pedestrian and other. And I just want to assure.

3:59:21 Myself and the other council members that we have thought about that and that you have to get permission and we can't just put them out there where you would be appropriate. Yeah, I can feel that. So what we've discussed is a couple of different things. One, BERT has ability to require these things to be returned to certain locations. So they can't just be dropped off willy-nilly wherever a user wants. So we can specify that.

3:59:47 I wouldn't want to immediately impede on the usage because I can't predict what the public's going to want to use these things for. So what I would be suggesting is providing some very specific parameters on where they can deploy these things and where they can be safely left. And like Michael said, you know, certain areas where there's enough width in the sidewalk or an area of right-of-way that is off the, you know, outside of the, where the public corridor would be.

4:00:17 Outside of pedestrians where they'd be. So we would set that framework. And if we found conflicts, we can, Michael can speak to this more, but they can deploy changes to the system in real time. So if the town says, hey, this just isn't working for us in this location, we can contact our representative and they can void that area out so the scooters can no longer be returned to these locations if we were to find a problem.

4:00:45 Exactly. It takes about 15 to 20 minutes to implement any new geofencing parameters so we can absolutely block out any areas that are creating any areas of concern. Thank you. That's about all I have for the moment. One more. In any of the areas do you do this where you're working off of public land? Do you ever get charged a franchise fee? In some areas, yes, absolutely. It's certainly something that we're more than happy to discuss with the city to figure out what would be most appropriate.

4:01:18 For context, we are present in over 300 cities globally at this point in time, so certainly there will be some variability with respect to both the size of the city and the franchise fee that might be involved. Thank you. Any public comments? Yes, go ahead. Hi, my name is Eric Wallsterman. Just happened to be here for the next agenda. I haven't heard this. A couple of comments. Bill, I think your comments were spot on and excellent. I've been in several cities with these scooters.

4:01:50 And I can tell you with 100% accuracy and certainty, these will end up everywhere. I literally just got back from Austin on Sunday and unbeknownst to me about this conversation was commenting to the friends I was visiting as to what it looked like a junkyard with scooters everywhere. I've seen this in Sacramento. I've seen this in San Diego. And I'll also say this, you know, with e-bikes and everything else, that's great. Most people don't want to ride a bike.

4:02:18 Most people don't know how to ride a scooter, and it'll be downright dangerous coming down hills. I'm all for recreation. As an MLR commissioner, I'm surprised we never saw this thing. I'm all for having fun, but if we're going to go forward with this, be very aware these will end up everywhere. I don't care what their algorithm says, unless there's boots on the ground moving these, or you have to put them in a secure location where they are locked until the next person gets them. You're going to find...

4:02:48 This looks like a junkyard all over town. Thanks. Thank you. Any further public comments? No, there are not. Thank you. I will bring this then back to council for their motion or further comments. Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion if it's appropriate, unless there's more deliberation needed. John, go ahead and make it. We can deliberate after if necessary. Thank you. I would move that the town council authorize the town manager to enter in an agreement

4:03:21 with bird scooters, any permits as may be necessary and to further integrate the opportunities to integrate Mammoth Lakes Trail System, electronic messaging and information in with the scooter program as Mr. Cavato indicated are possible. I'll second that. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Seeing none.

4:03:57 I had a couple comments. So as we move forward to this, I know the town manager, and we'll have this contract, you know, checked over by county council, or town council, I'm sure, and there'll be an add-on if it doesn't work out, and et cetera, et cetera, correct? Okay. Let me tackle that. I'm in the process of drafting it now. I've talked to my counterparts in a couple other cities, and we have learned from their experiences, and so I'm taking the best features of a couple different agreements.

4:04:29 Stitching them together to make something that works for Mammoth. And I've talked to Sandra and Hayes about exactly what we do and don't want. So I'm drafting it. There will be an out clause. The initial thought is to have the permit term just be for this year, going through October 15th, and then we can kind of reassess over the winter. But it will have ways for us to make sure that scooters are not just abandoned, ways to ensure that Bird will come and retrieve scooters that are in places they shouldn't be.

4:04:58 And as much protection as we can think of to add in for the town. Yeah, right. That's so any liability we would have for someone ending up in a pond or something. So, okay. Thanks. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you, Michael.

4:05:34 Moving on to the next, we're going to go to 10.5, request by Mammoth Rocks event producers for a reimbursable grant. Dan, we're going to start with you on this one. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I thought of before you, it's similar to what we've done in the past with Belusa Belusa, you know, different size and scope of an event. The request came from the Mammoth Rocks LLC group for a $15,000 reimbursable grant as they look at some upfront costs.

4:06:05 Securing talent and other elements for the event coming up August 26th to 28th. Ultimately, it's kind of a three-part event with a motorcycle rally, music and food. There, it's not the first year. The event's been going on for a while, so it is established. It's a village-based event at this point, so there's no ticketed event portion for the motorcycle ride. The recommendation, if it does go forward,

4:06:36 Eric Wasserman is here and can speak to some of the detail on that as well.

4:07:06 The event, it's not unique in these areas to look at some of this just in terms of some of the unknowns going forward. Often the upfront cost becomes a challenge and then of course the question is always subject to weather and other elements from that perspective. Depending on that, whether or not they'll often, I'll say with Beluza, Beluza experience has been they've repaid the grant on a couple of, I think three different occasions now. Even when they've actually lost money on the event, they've still fully paid back to town.

4:07:34 In terms of how they manage their own finances and that structure has worked well in supporting that event. There is information in the packet regarding the event and kind of walk through the details of that. Again, Mr. Osterman is here and can provide additional details on the event and their plans and the structure of it as may be appropriate for council questions before considering the proposal as provided in the attached resolution.

4:08:05 Thank you. And we have someone there to speak to this, right? Yes. I'm here for any questions. Okay, thank you. With that, I'll bring it to council for questions and or comments. John? I don't have any questions. I've spoken to the proponents and Dan and I've discussed this. I think we need to be cautious about establishing any expectations in the community. But I think in this...

4:08:42 In this instance, I think this makes sense and I'm prepared to support it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Just a couple of questions. I've also spoken to, as you said, the proponents of this and to staff and just a couple of questions I just have not thought to ask. Is there a written agreement in place around this grant? Yes, what we end up doing on that, we have the resolution that actually is adopted by council, then we have a letter agreement.

4:09:15 That follows that like we do for all of our events. Okay. So that we have... And is there any guarantee on this for repayment? It's tied to the success of the event. So it's not an absolute guarantee. You know, the event doesn't go off or there's something that happens. At that point, we do the analysis and it can be a partial or no reimbursement based on the success of the event. Okay. Okay. And as John referred to, I think this is...

4:09:43 Maybe a larger discussion we have at council level, maybe at a later date, because I think it does set up an expectation in town that, you know, perhaps every event, but I also agree that this is, you know, a larger event, a bigger event, draws a larger crowd, probably has a bigger revenue stream to it. And so, you know, I support this, but I think we need to look at it in the larger context, maybe at a later date. That's all I have. Thanks. Thank you. I have no comments.

4:10:16 Thank you. My take on it was, and I've talked with Eric about this, and I don't want to set up a precedent so that everybody with an event, you know, at the Village comes to us asking for a reimbursable grant. However, these are extreme times. The group didn't get a chance to make much last year, so I understand the need. I just want to...

4:10:44 You know, proceed very cautiously, and Linda, I agree, we need a policy. But I am a huge supporter of all our events. We have seen last year the chaos in the Lakes Basin versus what we're experiencing this year to a large part because of the events and other attractions in town disperse the guests, if you will. So that's my take on it. Do we have any public comments on this? No, we do not.

4:11:14 We did receive an email from Matthew Lehman in support of it. Thank you very much, Jamie. With that, I would entertain a motion. So I'll make a motion that council approve a resolution allocating $15,000 in general fund support to Mammoth Rocks LLC to provide support funding for the 2021 Mammoth Rocks event to be held in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Second.

4:11:43 I have a motion from Linda, a second from John. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Sorry, Councilmember who? Wentworth? I'm sorry, yes. Couldn't hear you there, Jamie. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you all. Thank you all, and I'm glad that was a lot faster in the housing portion of the meeting. Yes, it was. Housing is a little bit more important than you, Eric. Sorry.

4:12:18 I would definitely agree with that. Sure, it was very educational, Eric. Okay, moving on then. Item 10.1, approval of funding allocations and policy direction for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Housing Program. Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. We have a cover sheet and a resolution in the packet. I won't walk through all the details there. This really is the implementation piece from the last discussion we had on housing and programs and then focus on the town efforts.

4:12:51 It does provide authorization in terms of adjusting our budget and moving dollars from some of the various reserves and undesignated areas into our housing fund, its town housing programs, the allocation of moving $5.7 million of previously uncommitted money. We would also move $300,000 for the MLH project out of, again,

4:13:18 General Fund Reserve side, so it's all sitting in the same area allocated to the particular housing programs there. This includes unrestricted fund balance from the general fund, includes the general fund housing revenue sitting in reserves, the same thing with tourism reserves, and then also some of our unrestricted housing-related dollars, program income dollars and some other.

4:13:46 Smaller pieces of grant dollars or loan payments that have come in are unrestricted. Part of that policy direction was to move those into this housing program. In some cases, they're sitting in different locations within the budget to consolidate that into one place, provides a better tracking and accounting of those funds. The other piece from some policy elements in there was maintaining our deed-restricted buyback account at the $600,000 level.

4:14:15 We, in the past, have utilized our in-loo fees to make sure that that's retained. And some of the programs there, we actually do lose dollars on the buyback. We don't fully recover money. It's different reasons for that. And so, but we want to be able to retain and maintain that fund without having to come back each time and say, hey, we spent an extra $5,000 or $10,000 or $20,000 on a rehab project or shortfall in terms of the resale of a...

4:14:41 Project or deed restriction in that case. So the resolution outlines those elements. Again, the various projects and stuff were discussed in detail at the last council meeting and added additional elements potentially to that this evening discussing some other project work. So with that, I can answer additional questions. I believe it fairly represents and captures the direction provided at the last council meeting regarding funding for a town housing program.

4:15:13 Thank you, Dan. Questions or comments, starting with Linda. Oh, mix it up, huh? Okay, the only question I have is that we do the final reconciliation in October of all of our funds and whatever. There could possibly be some more money we put away and we'll just take care of that at the time. Correct. Okay, thank you. John? Dan, thanks for pulling this together. I think we still have some work to do to make this

4:15:45 Simple, easy for the public to understand, and certainly for the elected officials to be able to efficiently advise the community and the public of what we're doing to invest in housing. I would anticipate that people will be looking at, well, gee, Vail did this, or, you know, Steamboat's doing that, or Telluride's doing that. You know, in the context of that discussion, I think...

4:16:10 It's going to be great to be able to really turn this into a program. Linda mentioned earlier things about social media, being able to get, making sure the town's got the appropriate graphics capacity to be able to get our message out and the current channels that are being used for community discussion and to really do a little bit of a branding effort with this. This is the town's community housing program and I think the council members are going to be eager to look at the

4:16:36 The TOT revenue that we generate through tourism and through the unbelievable recreational opportunities in this community to help fund this program going forward. So thanks for pulling this together. We will have ongoing work to do to make sure that it's simple, easy to understand, and that we're funding it and we're getting units to Kirk's ongoing concern. We're getting units on the ground and we're housing people. So thanks a lot for pulling this together. We appreciate it. Thank you, John. Kirk? I strongly support it.

4:17:08 Thank you very much. I support this. I thank the town for pulling this together. And John, I agree with you. We need to tell people what's going on, but sometimes they just don't pay attention. I'm not worried about those people. Yeah. We have any public comments on this item? No, we do not. Thank you very much. That being said, I would entertain a motion.

4:17:39 Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the resolution of the council policy authorizing the allocation of funds to support the Town of Mammoth Lakes housing program. I hope you can hear that okay. I have to speak off mic a little bit. If that was audible, that's my motion. Thank you. That was good. Thank you, John. I'll second that. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberation? Hearing none, Jamie. Councilmember Stapp.

4:18:09 Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. Passes 4-0. Moving on to Item 10.2, Housing Impact Mitigation Fee Schedule Discussion. Sandra. Thank you, Mayor Sauser, Councilmembers. I get a new smiling face on my computer. Thank you. There you go. The item before you tonight is an opportunity for the Town Council to review

4:18:40 Our current housing fees and provide direction on potential changes to our fee schedule. For this staff report, I didn't include information on the fee schedule prior to 2015, which the fees were much different then, but I'm happy to do that in the future if the council would like to see that information. But for the purposes of this discussion, in 2015, the town council completed a housing fee nexus study.

4:19:06 And that fee schedule and that study resulted in a comprehensive update to our housing mitigation program and fee schedule. As part of that 2015 update, the council adopted fees that were below the maximum fee amounts for all of the uses. The next study did include fees for maximum fees for residential, lodging, retail, restaurant, office, industrial and service fees.

4:19:34 And then in 2019, the Town Council considered an update to the fee schedule and adopted a modest increase to the housing fees, which is permitted within the Nexus Study. So the Nexus Study just really caps out the fees and the Council, when they originally approved them in 2015, kind of hit them at a lower level in 2019, a modest increase. And so at this point, the 2019 housing fees, they're shown on page three of your staff report and those are the current fees that we're collecting.

4:20:03 So we have provided information and recommendation on potential fee increases as a part of this staff report. And for purposes of your discussion, I recommend that you discuss the fees kind of in two separate groups, with the first group being those commercial fees that are collected on a square foot basis. And then the second group being the residential and lodging fees that are collected on either a per unit or per room basis.

4:20:28 So we have provided some suggestions for the commercial fees. We looked at the annual CPI increase for 2019 and 2020, and that's about 7% for those two years. So we've included that in your staff report just to look at possibly a modest increase to the commercial type fees. And that's what we did previously as well. So in the 2019 update, we provided a CPI information for, I think it was three years at that point.

4:20:58 So this would be basically the two years that we haven't included in the fee update. And then for the residential and lodging fees, we provided four options for the council to consider. So the first one is just to keep the fees as they are. The second option is to do a CPI increase similar to the commercial fees. The third option would be to set the fees just at the midpoint of the 2015 Nexus study. And then the final option is to set the fees at the maximum allowed by the Nexus study.

4:21:25 So in talking about fees, just a reminder, we are starting a diff and housing fee update right now. So we are kicking off the project soon, talking to consultants and trying to kind of get that started. So we anticipate that a comprehensive update to the diff and housing fees will return to you sometime mid next year. So, and just to close out, if you do receive direction from the council tonight to increase the fees.

4:21:53 We will bring it back for a public hearing, which is required to update the fees. And then it's about, I think, 60 days after that when the fees would come into, would be enacted. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. Thank you. Before we go to questions, the studies you're looking at doing, it basically will replace our current Nexus study, correct? The Diff in Housing study, yes, will replace our current...

4:22:22 Yes. And when do we anticipate that is done? We're hoping by the end of the fiscal year, so June of next year. Thank you, Sandra. I just wanted council members to have that before we started this. Sure. So, Kirk, let's really shake it up and start with you this time. I don't know if I'm going to shake it up or not, but yes, I support the increase in fees, yes. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Linda?

4:22:58 Yes, I'm kind of a fan over many years of watching this play out in different venues is the moderate, consistent adjustment to sort of a CPI, if you will. So I would support a 7% increase, which is, and the reason I do is that if you wait a number of years,

4:23:23 And then you do a Nexus study and you find that you've fallen far behind. It's really difficult for people trying to develop these things to accommodate that. So I'm sort of in favor of a moderate, consistent raise in fees to reflect the reality of the time. So I would support a 7% increase. Thank you, Linda. John.

4:23:54 So where do these fees go? They go into our in-lieu housing fee program. So they're really basically kind of that chunk of funding. So we use it for different housing sources. And I believe in the last staff report, we had kind of a summary of all that. I can pull that up and give you a detail of where all the fees go. No, if you could speak a little bit, Sandra, all the conversations this evening around the community housing program and all this kind of work.

4:24:24 Will these fees be available for things like the thing we just approved? Is it basically unrestricted general fund dollars that we can then use to apply to housing opportunities going forward? They need to be used for the purpose of the fees that are being collected, which is mitigation of housing. And so we use them for those purposes. Fees have been used in the past, like I mentioned, to support our deed restriction buyback program.

4:24:51 Retain that flexibility in making affordable housing. We've used these fees in the purchase of the parcel. It's been used for, I think, matching some grant dollars at one point in time. So there's been a variety of uses, but it has to go to housing mitigation alone. So it's not totally unrestricted. So it does have a focus that we have to follow for the fees and the purpose that we're collecting them for. For both of these buckets, Sandra, that you mentioned,

4:25:18 Both of these buckets, the money goes into the in-lieu fees as Dan is describing, correct? Correct, yes. Okay. When you say you're calculating a CPI date range in this, what is the date range that you looked at for these calculations? It's for the calendar year of 2019 and 2020. Okay. So this spike in inflation that's been happening the last three or four months, they are not included in this 7%. Is that correct? Right.

4:25:47 You know, they do calculate the CPI increases on a monthly basis, but in the past, we've always done an annual CPI increase for the previous year. So we've never actually kind of done this six month. I can take a look and see what the six month numbers are. But, you know, I mean, I think that information would be fed into that housing study as we look to the future for the fees as well. Well, yeah, I'm just concerned about that because

4:26:13 Looking backwards, the numbers like February, March and April, I think February, March are relatively flat. And then March, April, May, June, I mean, all this, I mean, again, it's COVID inflation, but it's real. And I think also it's a reality that for those who are doing development at this point, Mammoth Real Estate is just looking more valuable by the hour.

4:26:43 Based on what's happened with COVID, and again, the examples we talked about earlier. Linda, I'm kind of with you with the 7% modest increase, but I think that this is a much more complex and sophisticated problem, and Sandra, I think when these, will it be a staff presentation on those diff updates, what the date range is being looked at?

4:27:08 Because we're in a very unique, we've never been in a situation like this before when we're looking at diff. We will come before council with the contract for the consultant and at that time we can provide kind of an update on here's where we are now, here's what this contract will cover, here's the things that we'll look at and you know here's the date range for when we'll kind of get to a resolution on the project.

4:27:36 Okay, and when that diff proposal comes back to us, you're saying sort of, what, June or July of next year? And when do you think these, if that comes back, does the council vote on it, when would they be implemented? It's just 60, you know, it's the public hearing, just like with these 60 days after that. The last time we updated the nexus studies, we did take a couple council meetings to get through kind of a discussion. We had a healthy discussion with the development community.

4:28:04 And, you know, the housing community. So we actually took them as two separate items the last time. They were about a year apart, so the death and the housing. So we did have a lot of discussions. I think this is a really good process this time because we're going to put all the fees together so we can really kind of look at all of the fees in line. And we've already had, you know, some meetings with our consultant that we're looking to hire.

4:28:28 And they really thought that it's a really good opportunity to kind of allow the council and the community to really line up all these fees. And they really get a good idea of kind of the total totality of the fees that are included for developers. Yeah, I'm going to be very interested in that scope of work, especially to the degree to which single family residential, again, there's not, but if we have a lot of an influx, a lot of very wealthy people buying,

4:28:59 Second properties, things like that, taking things out of our community housing market, those opportunities. We need to make sure we're mitigating the costs of supporting that type of stuff. Yeah, in the Nexus study, I mean, really what they're looking at is the mitigation of the impacts that the development is creating. So if you're building a new single family home, you're going to pay for the impact that you're creating as a part of that project.

4:29:28 So it can't really take into account the gap that we have currently for housing or for any other kind of infrastructure. It's really only forward-looking. Good. And that's appropriate. Yeah. So I'm willing to give the development community a little bit of a break and go with Linda on the modest increase at this point. But I do that only given the opportunity, Sandra, with this thing you're going to be bringing back to us, the forward-looking diff and moving into a world with a

4:29:58 Chronic virus problem. That's where I'm at. Thank you. Thank you, John. Yeah, I am okay with the modest 7% across the board. Sandra, sorry we didn't take this private residence versus commercial, but you laid it out as 7% across the board, so I think it works just fine. And that's fine with me. Do we have any public comment on this item? No, we do not.

4:30:28 Okay, thank you there very much. With that being said, I would entertain a motion for our 7%. Sorry, but the motion really is to direct us to look at that, to bring it back. This is not a final decision. Right, got it. So you have consensus as we get in? Do you don't need a motion? Yeah, the consensus direction is fine. I don't know if you need a formalized motion for that. You can just give us a consensus. That's what you want to see brought back. And as we come back...

4:31:02 With the public hearing process, then you'd have formal action and discussion at that point. Mayor Sauser, may I make one more small comment? Yes, of course. Okay. Sandra, in your staff report, you referred to the CPI was averaged over the last three years. So if you take into account those three years, which preceded the start of COVID, then the NEXUS study will capture both the period of

4:31:34 COVID and the inflationary period going on now and anything else that happens in the next year, correct? Right. So that's just a typo. So it's actually two years. It's 2019 and 2020. So I apologize for that. But yeah, the next study really is, you know, will take into account the impacts that will be created kind of in the future. And it's a good question about how much of our current environment is.

4:31:59 Considered as a part of this next study, and so we'll pose that question to the consultant. I think it seems like we've got a really good consultant on board, and I think they'll have some good ideas about that and be able to speak to that. Okay, thank you. I have no comments, thank you. I think we have consensus for you to move forward without a vote on this. Good enough? Yes, thank you so much. One last thought, Sandra. I'm assuming this consultant has experience working in resort and destination communities, right?

4:32:29 Yes, broad range of experience doing gift analysis all over the state. So, yes. But, David, Destination Resort Basics. Yes, yes. These communities like ours. Yes. David, Tassie, and Associates. They've actually done work in Mammoth Lakes. They're familiar with the communities. Yeah, all over the state. They've done a lot of this type of work. Yeah. Okay, moving on to 10.3, Town Priorities for International Forest Program of Work. Dan, you're leading us off on this again.

4:33:01 Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. But I wanted to bring in, we had a request from Gordon Martin, the Mammoth District Ranger who recently retired. But the request that comes in on this is each year the Inyo National Forest starts to put together their overall program of work for the whole forest. Knowing that we had a number of projects that had the potential to require a fair amount of NEPA support and other resources from the forest.

4:33:27 They ask us to submit kind of a prioritized work program for their consideration and for them to take to their leadership team, which I believe is in process or it's moved forward. The list before you in the packet is the information we've submitted, it's the things that we've been working on. And again, it primarily focused on the NEPA work for the highest priority items and there's write-ups of those within the packet for you. That's really looking at our...

4:33:54 Sherwin Area Trail Program there. We're also trying to get sign-off on the engineering side for the trailhead. There is the Mammoth Creek Park East. We're looking at a dog park in there. We've had a lot more demand and issues for that between on-leash, off-leash, other elements, exercising animals. And then also we're trying to get them out of Shady Reds Park where they currently hang out on our ball fields, which they leave little surprises for our ball players or our soccer players.

4:34:23 Fair amount of complaint from that and a lot of cleanup after winter. And then also looking at the term on our snow pit where we actually have snow storage. The issue there is extension looking. The current permit expires in December. But the idea is to get a longer term permit under our belt so we have time to work. And then really start to dive into what does the land tenure look like there long term, whether we own it or get to a different type of room.

4:34:50 Processed where the cost of that facility isn't in the hundreds of thousands of dollars each year as it impacts our snow removal budget and cost for snow storage. The other one is looking at acquisition of forest land around the airport. This has been an ongoing discussion. We've actually had support from the FAA to actually fund the acquisition of the Forest Service property adjacent around the airport. There's a map in there proposed.

4:35:18 This really allows us, one, to secure site area for runway protection zones and those elements, but also the actual expansion of the airport, kind of out of it being the commercial air service component, but we know we have demands, fire season, more than we'd like to see, frankly, for helicopter service, like a HILA attack for fire, which should be a good attack base for this portion of the Sierras. Looking at some other expansion areas and those types of elements.

4:35:48 Charter Service, moving that forward. Looking at some other hangar space, larger hangar space, we've actually had some requests for that, working with the FBO. I think there's some great opportunities for the airport, but we are land constrained that we actually have control over. So that would be the push on that one. And then the last one, really our shady rest in your craters, often referred to as SHRIC, our planning program there, that Joel is up.

4:36:18 Leading up that team on that, we have a state grant. We are requesting a one-year extension on the state expenditure of money to complete the planning work that we're doing, but ultimately that'll need to go back into the Forest Service and have a very substantial environmental impact review in terms of any modifications and changes to the trail system, really linking that area ultimately even to the June Lake and touching both sides of 395.

4:36:44 Then we have a number of other elements we put in there, ongoing work programs. We have ongoing, every year, our operating plans and a number of things that get submitted. And then also, just starting to get the thought process for those major planning projects that are coming forward. We've just started the discussion with Leslie Yen, the supervisor here in the INYO, on looking at the administrative site there as you come into town where the Forest Service facilities are.

4:37:15 For a potential housing project. We are looking at fuels management. You look at the donut project, quote unquote, the massive fuels reduction program that's going on in the community as well as other ones they've already approved. And then, of course, we have the NEPA sequel work that will be going forward related to the main lodge. All of those are very significant projects coming forward.

4:37:38 That will end up requiring a lot of resources. We don't have them well defined in terms of what that need or timeline looks like yet, but those are all in the process. So those are all been highlighted as work program areas. But the top five are ones that really impact our current work program. Joel Rathje has joined us. He can speak to some of the details if you have questions, especially in that first grouping of projects. If there's questions on some of the details there, he'd be able to respond to some of those issues more.

4:38:07 Expertly than I can at this point. I'll be glad to take any questions. We're really looking for confirmation from the council. We put this forward to the four services. They needed it timely. If there's some modification to it or change in terms of a priority dropping off or if you don't want to pursue something, then we can let them definitely be made aware of that so there would not be an impact. The four service was aware of the meeting. I know Leslie was out actually enjoying the backcountry.

4:38:36 And they're in between Ranger for the Mammoth District. So the Ranger coming in and on a DTL will be here August 16th. Board just left on July 30th. So we're in an interim gap there. Thank you, Dan. I will go to council for comments or questions. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Dan, I just...

4:39:09 I want to comment what a real inspiring kind of sigh of relief it is to see all of the efforts I know that you've been working on and that Joel Rathees has been working on, that MLR has been working on, that Janet Hatfield, that all kinds of people working on sort of documented in one place at one time. And I know for some of my fellow council members and fellow staff members of the town, the whole federal landscape could be a

4:39:39 Seemingly, it's a mystery and it's kind of a dark hole and who knows what goes on out there. But I think we all share a keen understanding the degree to which the destiny of this community is linked to that federal public landscape. And I'm not making light of the fact that I support the priorities as documented here. I think you've done an excellent job rolling this up. I would just hope that I know the council's approved that the chief recreation officer position.

4:40:08 But we're calling it for the moment to make sure we get that recruited. Just for everybody who's listening, paying attention, Dan made a very cogent observation, which is in this moment, there is no District Ranger in the Mammoth Lakes District. There is no acting District Ranger on the Mammoth Lakes District. Right now, if there's a problem, we are supposed to be getting in touch with Jody Nickerson Powell from the White Mountain District Ranger District.

4:40:37 And we're entering in the busiest two weeks of our season, potentially. It's okay. We can deal with this. We as a town and community know how to handle this kind of stuff. This is the reality of dealing with a federal agency whose ultimate leadership is the president of the United States. They report that direction. So I'll leave it there. But Dan, really, thank you very much for pulling this together. It's for all of us that work in that space. It's great to see this document in front of the council, this forum.

4:41:05 And Joel, thank you for showing up for all the great work that you're doing. So I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda. Yes. Okay. Yes, this was certainly useful to me to see kind of on one page all the things that we talk about and we plan for and respond to. But to see this sort of compiled like this was very useful to me. I spent some time going through ones that...

4:41:39 I didn't know as much about and talk to staff about this, so I don't think I have any further questions right now, so thank you very much. Thank you, Linda. Kirk? I support the priorities. I think they all need to be numbered one. Thank you. I'm not going to go there. Okay. For me, Dan, I appreciate that we have put all of this together and forwarded it to the Forest Service.

4:42:13 Because as we know, they are going to pick and choose whatever they like, regardless of what our wishes or desires are, or even what our needs are. So at least this way, we have given them a whole suite of options to look at on our behalf, and I do appreciate that. It is my belief that all we need is consensus on this, because it's just moving it this forward. And I will give you that right after we have public comment. There are no public comments.

4:42:43 Thank you, John. Just one last thought. The audience also for this is, I know there's a potentially a large development project happening out in the Sherwin's area, Snow Creek No. 8, which may or may not be coming forward in a timely manner. The number one, I know I'm not saying, Bill, it's the number one priority, but the Sherwin's area trail work requests for final sign-up on trailhead plans.

4:43:11 That's an effort that's been in the works for over a decade. I would advise that that project brings significant value to that project should that project move forward. And I would really encourage the proponents of that effort to reach out to the town manager. Let's see how we can work together to realize the full potential of that effort. It stems from the Sherman Area Recreation Plan, the Sherman's Working Group, a lot of great work that went out there that's going to bring real value to that project. So I'll leave it at that. Thank you.

4:43:40 Thank you, John. A couple of months ago, we actually reached out and had a great conversation with the project owner, manager, Chuck Landy, regarding that and talked about the need for the connectivity and the issues that are in plan. Very receptive and very good discussion. Good. Good to hear. Thank you. I think that's still in the works and planned accordingly. Mr. Mayor, up to you. On time and stuff, I don't know if Joel or Stu were involved in some of these projects. Yeah, we are just looking for the consensus to move the project list forward.

4:44:16 Joe, do you want to make any comments here? I think, John, you mentioned over a decade, I think most folks are pretty familiar with the Sherwin's area trails proposals and the different iterations that have been brought forward. What I hope you can see in the attachment is the thoughtful nature of that project proposal in that there's a lot of restoration work.

4:44:42 And rebuilding of existing infrastructure that's not supposed to exist out there. And just to see that it really is an effort to do smart trail design and make a really good effort to spread people out on well-designed and well-maintained system infrastructure. And then the shady rest in your craters planning effort is at a different point.

4:45:09 In its process, it's on the very front edge of planning. We're trying to go through a very thoughtful planning process. Tonight, I just met with the June Lake group and that went well. But right now, we're very much at the front edge of public outreach. And so, you know, north of town between Mammoth and June.

4:45:33 The general concept is to connect these amazing ski towns together with a thoughtful system of trails. If anybody has any questions, I'm happy to answer them. I will point out that Winter Recreationists already have a connection from Mammoth to June Lake, but we are moving on. Any questions for Joel? Great work. Thank you, Joel. With that, Dan, I think you have, was there any public on this? No, there was not. Thank you.

4:46:08 Stu's waving at you. I don't know if you know. I see Stu. Go ahead, Stu. Thanks, Mayor. It's okay. I know you were getting back to me. I just do want to thank, you know, everybody for support on this. A lot of advocacy, you know, clearly throughout the community for a dog park. You know, it's certainly a formal dog park. I mean, Shady Rest Park has been that de facto park for quite some time. And, you know, Joel's been part of that. And we've all been kind of working to find a solution. So we're very pleased that the Forest Service is willing to consider.

4:46:37 Police area at Mammoth Creek Park East. I want to thank Matt and Joel for all their help on that. I want to thank Recreation Commission. Is it a strategic work plan item? So we're checking those off the list as we go. And certainly our community group called Positivity Mammoth have been a very strong advocate and will continue to be advocates for this project if it gets to move forward. So just want to make those public comments and thank you for the support. Thank you very much, Stu.

4:47:08 So that gives us what we need there. I will move us on then to 10.6, government letter to be sent to the California Citizens Redistricting Commission. Daniel. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. The proposal before you is something that the SCOG has been working on coming from a regional perspective. What is our alignment or what's that affinity group, if you will, from an agency standpoint that Mono County...

4:47:36 Mammoth Lakes, Bishop, Inyo County. How do we fit in from a representative standpoint at the state and federal level? I think right now the district that we're in, if you will, really bifurcates the type of communities we are. If you're looking at the high desert down in the San Bernardino or you're going way over the crest down into the valley area for portions of this. I think the letter that says proposed comes back and says

4:48:04 As far as an advocate side would be, hey, we believe we have a stronger affinity group with other like communities within the Sierra Mountain Range. And that's really this Eastern Sierra type of a group. And so it kind of lays that out. It's a request we can put into the citizen group. They take a look at all the information they get in terms of making recommendations. I know Lynda and John both serve on the ESCOG, so they have been part of this discussion as well.

4:48:34 So the recommendation would be, unless there's a significant amendment to the letter, it would go as is. And the council also has the right, if you wish, to submit your own letter as well, that would be the same or different. But the idea there would be having a joint presentation coming from this sub-region of the larger district, if you will, or the region, that we're requesting a very similar...

4:48:59 I call it an affinity group almost. This is the type of other communities and environments that we associate with and from a representation standpoint believe that we can be better represented in this same environment versus some of the other spread out that could happen or be in place with other communities that we have less in common just from a geographic alignment as well as the rural nature of our community.

4:49:31 Yeah, looking for direction on this that would go back then to ESCOG for a final letter going out as a group. And if there's any other action the council wishes or direction to provide. So if I'm hearing you right, there's really, it can be one action item, but the question is support ESCOG's letter and do we want our own letter to boot? Yeah, if you want to do a separate one on behalf of the town, you could do that as well as supporting us. Yep. With that, I will go to Linda. Thank you. I mean, I'm,

4:50:05 You know, I'm happy with the letter that's coming from ESCOG. The question of do we want to send a letter individually from the town? Is the county sending one? Do we know? I think, aren't they? They're not. I haven't heard. If we did one, yeah, the recommendation would be we basically utilize the ESCOG letter, but we're having our own signature. Whether that carries more weight coming as a region and it has the individual...

4:50:36 Well, I mean, if we sent a letter from the town, I doubt if that would have a negative impact and possibly somebody might notice. I don't know. I don't have a strong opinion either way about it. That's it for me. Thank you, Linda. John? I have a strong opinion about supporting this letter.

4:51:10 I'm tired. I think we're all tired of not being represented in the State Assembly, in the State Senate, and frankly, in our congressional district. And it's a problem. It is a real problem. So I strongly support the letter as drafted by the ESCOG folks. And whatever we can do to reinforce it, I would support that as well. Thank you, John. Kirk? I would support two letters. Thank you, Kirk.

4:51:39 I would support two letters as well. I hate to put the extra on Dan to write the second letter, but having been involved in these kind of things for decades at this point, I think each different group or agency that can send a letter just strengthens the argument. Do we have any public comment on this item? Nope. Elaine, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good evening, Mayor and Council. I'm Elaine Cavall. I represent the...

4:52:14 I just wanted to thank you for consideration of this item and thank your staff for putting it together. I think that Mr. Holler did an excellent job covering the items therein and I appreciate your support. I'm happy to take any questions that you have. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine. Does anybody have any questions for Elaine? I have a question for Elaine. Elaine, what's your thought on sending the two letters? One from Yascog and one from the town.

4:52:46 I think that if the council substantially agrees with the recommendations included in the ESCOG letter, the additional support would probably carry weight. Okay, that's what I think too. Thank you, Elaine. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine. Any further public comment? No. Thank you, Jamie. With that, Mayor, if we have one other question that was raised on the counties that are listed, it's on the last page of the letter.

4:53:17 I was going to ask Elaine if she knew if the ESCOT had talked about reaching up, even the Plumas County going above Truckee, if you will, Nevada, into that other rural area, or did that get too broad in its scope? But Plumas County, I think, would be another one that would have, don't want to get into a lot of amendments back and forth because all the agencies have to sign off on this, but that would be another area that seems like, you know, Plumas and Sutter area would have another affinity with what Eastern Sierra looks like. But I don't know if that was discussed or not at the ESCOT level.

4:53:50 It was not discussed. The counties that are listed were those that were recommended by the subcommittee of the ESCOG. Certainly, I could take that recommendation back to the ESCOG, and if they wish to include it, we can include it in our correspondence. Yeah, Elaine, I just don't want to have to go back and forth with all the agencies, but it could be something we could put in our letters, say, consideration in addition to. We could make that come from as it would be contradictory to what ESCOG is doing, but I don't want to slow the process down either.

4:54:22 Thank you. I appreciate that. Elaine, did your subcommittee look at population in those counties to see how many more people we would have to add to actually make a district? Because that bottom line in our redistricting, that's the important piece. You have to have a certain percentage of population within the district. We did not look at the population, and obviously that will be a challenge since all of the counties and communities included in the letter are pretty rural.

4:54:51 But the commission specifically requests definition of communities of interest. And so I think that's what we're leaning on to try and make this recommendation. Thank you. Dan, do you want a motion on this? Are you good with consensus? Actually, if we're going to write our own letter, we should probably have a motion. Yeah, I would do a motion. And I think ESCOG is looking for formal action from all of the bodies in support. Right. So in that case, I would move to support the ESCOG letter.

4:55:25 And to write a letter of our own covering the same topic. I'll second that. So there is a motion from me, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Hearing none, I will ask for the item, Jamie. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes 4-0.

4:55:53 And I think this is a good enough idea that I'm going to take this to Council on Truckee next week, and I will try to get the Eastern County Supervisors from Nevada and Placer Counties on board as well to see if they want to take it to their boards. I think that's a great idea. At some point, somebody somewhere has to look at population and see how we can actually draw out lines that will fit into the necessary priorities, if you will.

4:56:22 Andy, if there's any traction momentum up there, please let us know, and it's going to take some lifting maybe if we can get behind this thing, but this is, we're sick and tired of the same things that you guys are sick and tired of, so. I think we all have more in common with each other than we do with people in the flatlands. Thank you. We have been called snow farmers, but that doesn't mean that we are actual farmers. Is that a bad thing? Yeah.

4:56:52 Okay. Call for the... Did we vote on this yet? Call for the... Yes, you did. We did. And I'm getting confused. Michael is on his camera, and all of a sudden, I don't know what I'm doing. We were five hours in. You're entitled to... Yeah. Accept the... The next item is accept the 2020 Community Indicators Report. I'll start, Mayor Souser. Yeah, I'll start. Thank you, Mayor Souser, Councilmembers.

4:57:26 The Community Indicators Report is one of the annual reports that are prepared by my department. And this report shows the key indicators in the community and how they've changed over the past year. This report's required by the Town General Plan. And on page three of the report, you see kind of a snapshot of how things have gone over the past year. And the trends on that snapshot look mostly neutral and negative.

4:57:54 In the areas of air, waste, transit, and affordable housing. While I think the snapshot looks somewhat bleak, it's important to keep in mind that these trends are based on a five-year timeline. And with one bad year, like 2020, can really kind of skew the data. So I will turn it over to Michael, who's going to give you a little bit more detail on a couple of those categories. Michael? Oh, we can't hear you, Michael. He's not muted. There's no... Yeah, you're not muted on Zoom.

4:58:32 Michael, you may need to log out and log back in. Zoom doesn't like us tonight, I guess. I don't know. Or Suddenlink doesn't like us. That might be it. Well, I think we don't like them. Is that right? Yeah. The feeling's mutual. Oh, okay. That's good to know. Okay. Still, I can't hear you. Is your microphone or your computer turned off, maybe? Or it's like your Zoom is going to a different spot? Yeah.

4:59:22 So I'm happy to answer any questions. I can hit on, go with a couple of the indicators. Michael, sometimes I actually have to call in on my phone. I have a separate. Well, instead of using too much time, I think we can all see the paper. Michael, sorry I'm cutting you off here. But for the sake of time, from my standpoint, I'm looking at the things that are bad.

4:59:53 And I think I can tie them all either to the fire last year or to COVID. I don't see any trends here that alarm me if you take those things into consideration. So I would go to other council members starting with John for comments or questions. Mr. Mayor, I can concur with your observations and your analysis. Thank you. Thank you. Linda?

5:00:24 This is one of my favorite reports, actually, because I think it really gives a good snapshot, and I've also used it in the past for grant writing and things like that. So I have two comments. One is that, absolutely, these are very closely tied to everything that happened last year. COVID, fire, you know, I think we even had less recycling, less trash, because we weren't...

5:00:47 Yeah, we weren't doing things to generate as much. I mean, so I think that's all pretty easy. The other thing I have, Sandra, for you is that how is this distributed? Is this distributed throughout the county partners? Because if people didn't know that this existed, I think it's really useful for agencies like that. I typically put it out on our website, and I think that's a good point. I can ship it to Stu, and he's sending out Stu's news on Friday. Or not Stu's news on town.

5:01:17 Town News. So we can ship it out with that too. I think the more, you know, the more eyes on this document we can get, the better. And I appreciate the kudos. Michael did a great job putting this together and it's a lot of work. A lot of work to put together. It is. And like I said, I mean, you know, I've used it.

5:01:36 And, you know, they use it at the hospital. They use it in Health and Human Services every time they write a grant or something. This comes up and people try to find it and no one ever knows where it is and end up having to, you know. So, yeah, I mean, I think that these are really good pieces of the pie here. So thanks for the work on this and bringing it to our attention. I'm glad that this year it got off consent agenda and actually into the regular agenda. So thank you. Can you guys hear me now? Yes. Yeah, there you go.

5:02:05 Really, really sorry about that. Of course, I'm sitting around waiting for my time and then my microphone doesn't work. You know, I mean, you guys kind of touched on some of the highlights, but one thing I want to mention is that staff's looking to make improvements to the future community indicators reports to make it a more useful document that can be used as intended and to inform how about decision making. And, you know, council member input would be greatly appreciated in that process. So just something to have on your radar.

5:02:33 That we may be reaching out in the coming months to try to make improvements and try to make the document something that works for you and helps the town as a whole. If you need any help with that, I'd be happy to assist with that if you were interested. Thanks. Moving on to Kirk, questions or comments? I think it's an excellent report. Thank you. Pretty much I've given mine, so we'll go to public.

5:03:10 We do not have any public comments. Thank you. So we are just accepting this, Dan, that should not, or Andy, that should not require a motion, or does it? Yeah, we'd like to have a motion to accept the report, so it's formally on record that we've submitted it. It's part of our general plan requirements, so having that formal action helps document that. Okay, so moved. And I'll second with a big shout out to Michael and his efforts and his skills with audio technology. Thank you.

5:03:45 I have a motion from Linda, a second from John, any other deliberation? Hearing none, Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. 4-0, thank you all. Moving on to 10.8, update on biomass project, organic waste diversion, and related solid waste programs and projects.

5:04:18 Yes, Mr. Mayor, in light of the time, I'll keep this very short, and if we need to bring something back in more detail, we can do that. Been working to try to get this before you, just given the number of projects that are going on around us, state law changes, there's a lot of different elements that are moving targets at this point. Had a good meeting with the county today and talking about some joint efforts related to this work. We have been working through a number of things on just going on on the federal landscape.

5:04:47 Fairly, I shouldn't say, very significantly large projects in the works. The donut project, if you will, that 55,000 acres of fuels treatment. There's a big grant to do fuels work within the community. There are some fuels work projects already approved with NEP in the Forest Service. All of that will generate a lot of material. Recently, a lot of questions coming up on the drying out.

5:05:14 Piles in the lake space and real concern about those catching fire. So as we look to the future, how do we take that material and not just let it sit and burn in the forest, but actually move it out is a significant issue we're trying to look at. And the whole issue of that fires and the climate feedback loop, it was a great chart coming out of some of the research out there just in terms of how this impacts on a bigger picture.

5:05:39 Looking at kind of the regional biomass system, one of the challenges of moving material out of the forest has always been how to make it work economically. We're starting to look at those elements and moving in a direction, I think, that begins to do that, some subsidy level through other feedstock levels and those types of facilities. We've given some updates in the past on this.

5:06:02 Again, I think it's something that deserves more time and stuff. But again, this evening, just a heads up for that. We are working on a number of areas. But the amount of material potentially coming out in the next, frankly, I would say the probably next 20 years of coming off of the forest is going to be substantial. And having something in place that we can begin to utilize added value, other product, a way of dealing with that.

5:06:29 The amount of material will be a key issue for us looking to the future. And then the nice part about biomass is once you're done for that 20 years, you just start over again. It's green, renewable energy. And managing the carbon sequestration of our forests are getting to be a bigger and bigger issue. The bootleg fire and other fires within the state have raised the question of the carbon credits that people have purchased for these forests. Now what happens if they burn?

5:06:57 It's millions and millions of dollars of carbon credits that start to get into the question of what happens when that stuff goes up in smoke, literally. So there's a number of issues out there. At this point, the idea was to try to give you an overview of a lot of the work and the programs. We don't need specific action this evening. If you want to make comments tonight, that'd be great. But as we get a little further down the road, we'd be coming back again with additional updates and information.

5:07:24 But there is a lot of action going on in this space in and around our community. So we want to try to get an update to you. So sorry for the time, but I think it deserves a full discussion. And tonight, probably not tonight to do that. So thank you. Glad to answer any questions. We'll make it a short discussion. John. Dan, thank you. And for all of us, Dan is exactly right.

5:07:55 State of California's pursuit of nature-based solutions, biodiversity, the 30 by 30 efforts. This comes specifically to our region and who we are. As you know, I serve on a Climate Change Advisory Council, the Governor's Office of Planning and Research. So much stuff to share with you guys. We won't do it tonight. I know we don't have a chat function in this meeting, but there's a photograph from the San Francisco Chronicle from NOAA showing the fires burning in Northern California.

5:08:25 Full color, full relief. If anybody has any doubt what's happening with the climate, and we're right in the middle of this. So, Dan, thanks for this. I'll take you up on that offer. Let's maybe put something together for our colleagues here about what's coming in front of us. It's big. The other piece is there are millions and millions and millions of dollars behind it. Stacey Corliss is one of the participants in that Forest Resilience Task Force. There's a lot going on, so I'll leave it there, but a lot for us to be thinking about.

5:08:54 Thank you, John. Linda? I agree. I'd like to have the energy and the time to dive into this deeper. That's a lot to understand here, and it's not my native language, but I'd appreciate a more full presentation, so can we maybe push that a little bit and pick this up again? Thank you, Kirk. I agree with Linda. Thank you, Kirk. Now, let me get out my 16-page report that I want to read to you. The fact is,

5:09:27 This needs to happen. We now have a Forest Service that instead of reintroducing fire is actually burning piles after they dry and then burning them in the snow. If we just burnt that wood in our fireplaces, we would cut the carbon going into the atmosphere in half. So if we truly want to do something about carbon and carbon sequestration, to do something so that when the forest produces duff and excess wood as the trees die,

5:09:57 We can burn them and make electricity and cut the amount of carbon that we're putting out into the air. This is huge. And this needs to be done forest-wide. The forests need to be thin. The dead trees need to come out. So hopefully what we're doing with this donut project will teach us some and we can go out there and actually save our forests, if you will. So that's my soapbox for tonight. Thank you all. Do we have any public comment on this one?

5:10:27 No, we do not. Thank you. Moving on to discussing council workshop. No, no, discuss a council workshop schedule. I may suggest the same thing on this item, Bill. We really, Mr. Mayor, we really do want to look at looking at some schedules out there and starting to meet with our partner agencies, NGOs, looking at some topical areas where we believe we're going to need to take in a workshop format, take it out of the regular council meeting night.

5:10:58 I've got a little bit of input from a few of you in terms of dates and stuff that may work as we start to look at these. We can spend some time on this evening or we can bring this back at your next meeting to have a workshop on setting workshops. But I think just giving, again, the lateness of the night, the timing, and trying to get these dates and stuff squared away. Bring your calendars if you can and help us kind of work through this. And then really looking at a priority of who do you want to, as far as meeting with.

5:11:27 And then it's going to be a little bit of herding cats to get all the other agencies on board, too. But I wanted to start here as we've had a lot of discussion about meeting with our NGOs and other partners, you know, the county with our commissions, et cetera, then topical subject matter areas, which may or may not include another agency in those same discussions. So a lot of material. Again, glad to do whatever council wishes, but it looks like some of us are fading quickly.

5:11:55 Yeah, from my standpoint, I'd like to deal with this in a different council meeting, but I do want to reiterate what you said. This isn't about just workshops with our NGO partners, because they may or may not be necessary, but there are some items that I think we could better serve by having a workshop on them and then putting the item on our next agenda to cut down the meeting time and to give us a better chance to respond. Comments from other council members?

5:12:22 No, I would totally agree, Bill. I think that this is, I mean, even today at MLT, they were really, you know, wanting to do at least quarterly workshops because they, you know, feel that there's, you know, miscommunication, a little bit of information needs to be shared, a lot to talk about with us. So, you know, just that alone, we need to allocate some time, I think, for those things. But not tonight.

5:12:49 I agree completely. And again, we're migrating into a little bit more of a, hey, let's get together and talk kind of a culture to, hi, we have a contract. Here are the deliverables. Here's the scope. Let's work it out. Let's get things done and make sure everybody knows who's doing what. And we can all be accountable in the end to each other, which is what matters. Thank you, John. Any other comments? Kirk's already holding his head in his hand, so I think that's comment enough.

5:13:21 Thank you for the comment. Any public comment on this? No, there is not. Thank you. With that, I will move on to Councilmember Reports, and I will start mine off with no report. John? I'd like a mulligan, please, Mr. Mayor. Yes, you may have one. Thank you, sir. Linda? No report. Kirk? No report. Thank you all very much.

5:13:55 Moving on then, we are going to move into closed session. We will close out of this meeting and adjourn this meeting. Well, not adjourn, but we will move into closed session. So Dan sent us all a link. We need to back out of here. Dan, do you need time? Yeah, just a couple minutes, but if I can also just note that the topic of the closed session is discussion with representatives regarding...