Town Council
at 15:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
618 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
6:03 Yes. So before tonight's meeting start, I just wanted to say thank you all for coming, but my birthday is not for two weeks. But that being said, I understand that Mr. Erdi's birthday is today. So if everybody would like to join me saying happy birthday, John. Happy birthday, John. Excellent. Thank you very much. Yes, sir. Mayor Pro Tem Sauser. So we're going to get started. I'm going to call this meeting to order. And thank you all for coming. Great to see everybody here.
6:36 And we're going to get started with a quick update. We just came from a ribbon-cutting ceremony over on a freshly paved, rebuilt section of Laurel Mountain Road, which, as I think we all know, leads to, helps us get to the parcel, a unique housing program that we're doing here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. That was a wonderful event. And, Jamie, if we could please call the roll. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray?
7:04 Here. Councilmember Rice. Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salzer. Present. Mayor Wentworth. Here. Thank you all. I've asked Ted Carlton to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening. Good afternoon. Thank you, Ted. Okay, so we're going to get started, as we do with public comments, and these are public comments for items that are not otherwise on the agenda. Mr. Carlton. Twofer. The reason I'm here is...
7:50 Sierra Classic Theater wishes to do a play this winter called The Minutes, which is ironically set in a town council setting. This room would be the perfect venue for this because obviously there's going to be no more theater. It's going to be under construction. So SCT has been told that there's some issues regarding using this room, that it would be unfair for one group to use it versus another, et cetera, et cetera.
8:22 I'm giving you a great chance to be able to say yes to something tonight here. And I think you should work with Mr. Holler and the town attorney and maybe make that happen for us next March. Thank you. Thank you very much. We will take that under advisement. Sounds like an interesting question. And Dan and Andy, let's talk about that one. That sounds interesting. Thank you, Ted. Okay, any other public comments, again, for things that are not on the agenda for this evening? Okay, anybody out in the...
8:53 Virtual Universe. Nope. Okay. Thank you. So move on now to the agenda. Dan, any additions to the agenda this evening? No additions, Mr. Mayor. Okay. Thank you. And we'll move on then to item 6.1, Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project Update, Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Area. I believe Kim Cook is with us and Jen is with us somewhere, maybe. There she is. Hi, Jen.
9:23 Hi, good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. Dan, did you want to do any introduction or should I just go for it? Go ahead, Jen, you can walk into this. It's a regular monthly updater, so just give a heads up of where we're at in the project. Thanks, Dan. Yeah, this is just a brief monthly update hitting on the major items that are happening relative to this project. We...
9:52 Have identified a few items in highlight for your agenda. That includes just update on the environmental field work that's underway. Will be done by the end of this month. That we continue to work on the outreach plan for this project. And that Senate Bill 606, that's...
10:17 The bill that allows for all or a portion of State Route 203 to be relinquished to the town, it in no way commits the town to taking any action or accepting any portion of that road. And that bill did pass the legislature. It has been signed by the governor and will take effect on January 1st. Now, that only opens the door for this process. Then there is a
10:46 Lengthy process with Caltrans to go through analysis and consider implications and what that might mean and whether relinquishment is even desirable. So we are now in communication with Caltrans to start that first step of preparing a report that analyzes the relinquishment. And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions you have, but just want to keep it brief for you tonight. Thank you.
11:15 Thank you, Jen. Kim, anything to add? No, I don't have anything to add. Okay. Councilmembers, any questions? Jen, I guess maybe just two questions. We're anxiously looking forward to a more robust report out on this very significant project. I know you guys are working hard on that. Do you have any idea when that might be? And then, Dan, I've got a question for you about when the PEDC meeting might be getting scheduled, so go ahead.
11:48 Thanks, Mayor. Our high-level schedule has a draft EIR, EIS out for release in late April. But in order for us to be able to prepare that, we need to have a draft of this specific plan, which has not yet been prepared. So there will be some time.
12:09 For us to be working on that effort collaboratively with the applicant before the material is ready for full analysis and preparation of that report. But as a rough schedule where we are targeting spring, late spring of next year for the draft environmental analysis to be available. Okay, we've got a nice full room with a very interested, attentive audience and we're all very interested in hearing what that project is going to look like. So very much looking forward to seeing that coming forward.
12:36 Dan, any thoughts on this planning commission meeting we're trying to schedule? We're a joint one to give an update on that. And right now, probably looking toward the end of November, it'll probably end up needing to be a special meeting given dates, otherwise it'll be moved into December. We'd like to have it sooner than later if we can. We'll get some dates out for schedules. We'll need to follow up with PEDC members. A couple have, or one at least, have a conflict, and so we're working around trying to get a majority of the PEDC to be at the meeting as well. Okay, good.
13:03 Okay, any public comment on this item? Not seeing any real good. Okay, Jen, thank you very much. Kim, thank you very much. We'll move on now to item 6.2, Town Council Subpart C Public Comment. And Mr. Reef.
13:21 Hello, everyone. Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. I don't have much to say regarding this letter. We put this together to reflect your comments related to the subpart C process in the last meeting. I do believe this covers all of the Council's talking points as it relates to subpart C, with the due date for that being the 20th, which I hope to then submit tomorrow.
13:48 So other than that, I don't have much to say related to this letter. Of course, if you all do, please let me know. Just a quick clarification. So I believe that the town manager circulated an update to the letter that was in the packet. Is that correct? Yes. Okay, so have you all seen this? Listen out. All we did was update the language related to the sharp and the trails and stuff to actually reflect the language that's actually in the adopted trail system master plan. Okay, the sharp, which is in adopted. Bolts are more or less the same.
14:17 Okay, but there are, well, there were some differences, and I think it's important that they, I think what's in the letter now ties here specifically to the adopted plans of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, which the Sharp is a component of the Trail System Master Plan, that's an adopted plan, so. Mr. Mayor, I would just say that I preferred the first letter, but as a letter for the purposes of this process, I am fine with the second letter. Okay.
14:46 Is there any action required on this, or is this just an update? Okay. This is just providing information based on the last meeting, so no formal actions needed this evening to submit this onto the board service. Okay. Any public comment? This virtually? No. Chris, I'm sorry, you had a thought. So, I know that last week we, you know, essentially agreed to what's in the letter. I've gotten some pretty significant pushback from a few community members.
15:16 They're really concerned that we haven't represented the community-based alternatives that have been worked on historically. This isn't ideal, but my proposal would be that we...
15:39 Significantly reduce the comments that we put in because we know that we have a community meeting coming up at the end of the month where I think there's going to be a lot of voices that want to be heard and I'm just concerned that we are not representing the broadest community interests with this letter. Thank you. Anybody else? One thing just to add is in the attachments that Dan circulated, there is a summary.
16:09 Okay, good.
16:37 It's their EIR, I would think they could look it up, but I know it's a big document, so we'll incorporate that if we proceed forward. Yeah, good. That would just be helpful for that part of that, because that is a, that's an area where we do not have an adopted plan, so it would be helpful to have what we have. Okay, and that Mammoth Trails meeting is coming up lost on the 26th, correct? Correct. And that's an opportunity for anybody in the community, if you've got ideas.
17:04 It's a specific recommendation with the Trail System Master Plan to convene the community, to convene the public, to be able to hash out some of these issues. So that will be coming up. My concern is that we, this, there's three, just for the public, there's three opportunities to comment on this over snow vehicle situation. And so the first one is October 20th. That goes to the Forest Service. Then they go away and work for a year. So this will create momentum. So I just.
17:33 Want to be on the record to say that I think, you know, I mean, do you want me to get into the kinds of feedback or are we just going to present this to the Forest Service as if it's a united community? No, no, no. I think we're at the very beginning of this. I think it's a good high-level representation of the town's policy, the current existing policy. Any member of the public can participate. It is a Forest Service process. It's not a town process. So I think it's a good, it's a fine place to get started. There will be.
18:02 Many other proposed alternatives come out. This was there, and it is done a little differently. Normally there's three or four that come out at the same time. That did not happen here. So our letter basically, and the letter that I will write personally, just establishes our ability to be members of this process.
18:22 So then my last thing is, because I've been to all the meetings, I've really paid attention to this. It's disappointing how few members of the public have shown up for this. So I just want to let you know that October 20th is the deadline. It is not hard. You go on the Forest Service website and put in your comments. But if you have, you know, preferences or wishes for what you want to see in terms of over-snow vehicle use in the...
18:47 Areas surrounding the town specifically, you need to make your voice heard now because it just gets harder as the process goes on. So I'm just letting everybody know. Good. Great. Thank you. Okay. Anything else? You guys okay? All right. So we'll move on now to the next item. This is a public presentation. Lawson, thank you very much. Thank you. Yeah. You're welcome. Thank you. All right. Item 7.1, Annual Report from Robert Yoki, President of the Southern Monro Historical Society. Mr. Yoki.
19:20 Mr. Mayor and council members, I promised I was going to do this in two minutes because I know you've got a big agenda today. It's my pleasure to report to you on the successful conclusion of the yearly operations at the Mammoth Museum, the Hayden Cabin, which is run by the Southern Mono Historical Society. The museum was open to the public seven days a week beginning Memorial Day weekend through September 15th. Our excellent staff not only maintained the facility and its grounds, as well as provided docent tours to over 1,000 visitors this season.
19:52 The Board of Directors of the Museum wish to thank the Town Council with special thanks to Dan Holler and Stu Brown for working to raise the yearly funding for museum operations to $50,000 per year. This funding will now allow the museum to operate at a sustainable level for the near future. However, in order to allow for future growth, we would ask that this amount be adjusted yearly to, at minimum, match increases in the yearly cost of living.
20:20 A major drain on the museum's yearly budget is caused by the needed maintenance in the ground, most notably the cost of a public toilet facility, as well as garbage and recycling costs that are incurred by the museum as a result of the grounds themselves being recognized and heavily used as part of the park system. The museum grounds provide a park-like setting for picnics and other outdoor recreational activities to tourists and residents alike.
20:53 We have asked Stu Brown to consider providing the garbage, recycling, and toilet facilities from within the budget of the Town Parks Department beginning next year, May of 2024. Mr. Brown has agreed in principle to the idea, and we asked the Town Council to consider an increase to the Parks Department budget that might allow for that department to take over these necessary public services, allowing the museum then to best utilize its yearly funding.
21:21 In addition to our daily operations, the museum sponsored several public events, including the annual Mammoth Book Fair, a music and moonshine concert, as well as hosting the Mammoth Yoga Festival, which included two nights of concerts that were open to the public as well, all held under the shade of our 30 by 40 museum canopy known as the Temple of Folly. Our museum membership drives were included in these events, as well as our year-end
21:50 Giving Tuesday Drive. As a result, new members have been added, as well as the renewals to our existing membership. Increasing the number of families' museum memberships will be one of the main goals for this coming year. It was our good fortune to hire as our museum manager a highly qualified and experienced manager named Frankie Devine. Ms. Devine will continue working for the museum on a limited basis during our off-season.
22:17 As well as working this winter for the Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association at the Mammoth Lakes Welcome Center. Please stop in and meet her. She has expressed her love of the Hayden Cabin and her role as its manager and plans to return to the museum again in the spring as her full-time role as museum manager. In conclusion, the state of the Mammoth Museum is not only stable, but it is a fine position to continue its growth into the future. Thank you again for your continued support of this important institution.
22:49 The second report I'd like to give quickly is Major U funds as well as Mammoth Lake Tourism fund our history trolley program that the museum administers. This letter is from our Shakespearean, Mike Dostro, Shakespearean actor, so if it sounds a little Shakespearean, then that'll explain why. Greetings, esteemed members of the Mammoth Town Council. First and foremost, we at Southern Mono Historical Society, the Mammoth Museum at the Hayden Cabin, would like to thank you for your continued support.
23:19 of our museum and the Mammoth Trolley History Program. This year, your program funding has resulted in 420 hours of history telling. Our goal with your continued support is to continue to provide the good people of our community and its visitors with quality interpretive programming highlighting the rich and fascinating history of the Eastern Sierra region and this area in particular. Our diverse troop of costume history storytellers seeks to engage, entertain, and edify the receptive
23:49 We would like to extend our appreciation to them for allowing us to stage our interpretive programming in their mobile venue.
24:19 And look forward to our continued alliance next season and the years to come. This year and in the future, this vital programming hinges on the continued support from you, the members of the Mammoth Town Council, as well as Measure U funding, for which we extend our greatest appreciation, and to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you for taking your valuable time to listen to this synopsis of this year's History Teller Program and your continued funding of this important effort to engage, entertain, and edify the visitors and the residents.
24:50 of the town of Mammoth Lakes. With warmest regards, yours truly, Michael Dostro, Administrator. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any questions for Robert? No? Good. Thank you very much, Robert. Mr. Mayor? Sir? I believe we have a couple other reports from commissions and or departments as well. Okay, good. Please. Are there additional reports from departments and or commissions? Mr. Erdy?
25:25 Good evening, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to give you a quick update from the OCR event that we had a couple weeks ago. I really appreciate the support from the town and community. I appreciate Mr. Mayor coming up for the event on Saturday and Rob from the town coming up on Friday and meeting with the folks up there as well and getting a tour of the event and the opportunities leading to the next four years that were contracted with them. For this year's event, we actually had 55 countries that were represented. I think we had the normal suspects of Australia and New Zealand.
25:54 Italy, Ireland, UK, Germany, all those. But we also had places like Argentina, Chile, Congo, Ecuador, El Salvador, all the Scandinavian countries, Jamaica, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Latvia, Lithuania. It was a great opportunity for us to showcase for the world. The finals that were up there on Saturday and Sunday, it was amazing to see the amount of folks that were in from Mexico all flying their flags, the folks that were in from Chile flying their flags.
26:23 We had 37 competitors from Puerto Rico that came to the event. So pretty amazing and a lot of opportunity to grow this. So this year we had just shy of 1,200 unique individuals competing. We had about 2,200 registrations. So some people would run a 3K and then go on to run a 15K or even the 100 meter, which is kind of the ninja type course. And so with that also came about 1,000 spectators with those folks. So the anticipation is we can continue to grow this as we move forward.
26:51 We are working with them tentatively the dates for next year, October 4th through 6th. So it's not the three-day weekend, which I think is actually good for us to populate another weekend that may not have as many people here. But the opportunity is to continue to grow this. I just wanted to give you that update. Thank you very much. Any questions? The event was really great. I would just want to extend to the event organizers our appreciation for taking the risk to invest in a long-term
27:21 You know, five-year opportunity. They maybe have taken a little bit of a hit on this first year, but they did a great job. It was a great organization. Looking forward to seeing them again next year. Yeah, very professional organization. Absolutely. Thank you, John. Okay, other department heads? Departments, departments. Anybody? No? Dan? Everybody's good. Okay. Thank you. We'll move on to the item 8.1.
27:49 This is the parcel affordable housing construction update and lease up information presented by Buckingham Property Management. And I believe we have Shallon is with us or Amy or Amy right here. I'm sorry, you guys go ahead. We'll have Amy provide a brief update on the construction update status and then we also have Shallon Rodriguez and Jenny Reed to present on the lease up part after the construction update. Okay, great. Thank you. So please.
28:21 Thanks. Amy Callanan, Engineering Manager. And I've been heavily involved in the parcel project since we started working on it in 2019. So just got a couple slides and photos updated from the last time I was here before you. This is an aerial photo that was taken this morning or around noon today. And you can see building A, the large building, and building B. The most exciting thing is that building B is getting some paint on it. Just a quick,
28:52 Recap of the parcel project. 25 acres to be constructed in multiple phases. Master plan was set for a maximum of 580 units to contain both rental and ownership unit. What you see under construction right now is this phase one, building A and building B and all of the roads.
29:20 Building A, or this phase known as the Sawyer, contains 66 units in building A, 15 units in building B, a pretty even mix of studio, one bedroom, two bedroom, and three bedroom units, all to be rented under 80% of the average median income. Also contains a community space and a daycare.
29:43 Public amenities include a public park and new public infrastructure, including roads, sidewalks, multi-use paths, bus stops, and utilities. I know a lot of you have heard this before, but for the benefit of those who haven't, I just wanted to go through a brief summary. So current progress on the exterior. Building B is siding is complete, and it's getting a coat of paint. Siding on Building A is in progress. And most recently...
30:11 The community space at the front of Building A, the curtain wall installation is in progress. I'll show you some pictures in a minute. Interiors, I don't have any updated interior photos today, but the drywall and the interior painting is nearly complete. And other utility installation is continuing in progress. So aerial photo, just looking straight down at the project. North is actually to the right of the photo, but we're looking at Buildings A, B.
30:40 And you can now clearly see the concrete curb and gutter that has been installed for the new road connections. This is going to be a new Inyo Street connection to Center Street here. And this is the extension of Tavern Road into the parcel. And over here in this, it's a little hard to see, but eventually Chaparral Road will actually tee into the Tavern Road extension as well.
31:09 So a couple of shots. This is from that Chaparral Road and Tavern Road intersection where you can see that some of the backer boards for the siding on Building A is being installed. And we're looking across the park to the daycare area at the front of the building. And you can sort of make out that the curtain walls and the glass doors have been installed since the last time you saw photos.
31:34 This is the corner of Building A that's closest to the intersection of Tavern Road and the new Inyo Street. And so this is the community space. The doors of this community space will open up to the public park and where there will be a public picnic pavilion so that there's some interaction between the community space in the buildings and the public space outside. This is looking up Inyo Street a bit towards Center Street.
32:05 You can see Building B getting its paint in the background. Just turning and looking back south on Inyo Street towards one of the main entrants of Building A in the community space. Just some closer pictures of Building B as we head down Inyo Street towards Center Street. So all these pictures are from this morning. The contractor that's doing the site work is planning to start paving asphalt in towards the site next week.
32:51 So within a week or two, we should have asphalt on the roads as well. So this drone shot was, again, from about 12 o'clock this afternoon. You can still see snow on Mammoth Mountain. And just a quick look ahead towards phase two, which was approved by Planning Commission and Council. It will hold up to 148 units.
33:26 Likely to be built in two separate phases in and of itself. And it's looking like tree removal for this phase may progress this fall. Any questions? Any questions from council? Yeah? I guess just if we have, you know, a finishing date. I'm going to leave that to the developer. Okay, thanks. Chris, Bill, anything?
33:57 Thank you. It's so inspiring for all of us in this room as a community to be seeing these kinds of images. And it's quite profound to be seeing this. I think this community is building more units of community housing than any other jurisdiction that we can find, certainly a resort destination, even in the state of California. And that's being made possible by local, by us. We're doing this together. Yes.
34:23 Exactly right. And that's, applause is for Amy, Hayes, the entire team that's been working on this in Pacific. You guys have done just amazing work, so thank you. Yeah. Nolan, do you have something to add, or? No. Next up, we do have Jenny Reed and Shellen on the call. Jenny was gonna have a brief presentation on just the lease-up process that they're pursuing for the parcel for the Sawyer phase. Okay, great. Thank you. Jenny.
34:51 Hello, good afternoon. Pleasure to meet you. Shellen, nice to see you again. Whoever wants to go first, please go first. And please introduce yourselves. We've got a nice crowd of folks here in the room this afternoon. So if it's okay, I'll just do a quick introduction. You know, Shellen Rodriguez, for those of you who don't know me, with SMR Development representing the Pacific companies.
35:16 You know, great presentation by staff. Thank you so much for your continued support of the project, as well as leadership and just the community in general. I mean, having a construction project so close to the center of town is sometimes tricky and does sometimes have some, you know, there's just some pain points. So we know that. It's part of the deal with construction, and we just appreciate the support that we've gotten from staff and leadership.
35:46 Jenny Reed is here as a representative of Buckingham Property Management. Jenny is in charge of hiring folks to manage the Sawyer and then will be in charge of hiring folks and managing, property managing the future phases of the parcel. So we just thought it was really important and I appreciate the town inviting us.
36:09 To kind of give an update, not only on construction completion, which really drives the marketing and lease up process, but also just, you know, what exactly Jenny and her team are sort of doing behind the scenes. So she's got a presentation that I think she can share and has an opportunity for questions and answers at the end. So I'll just turn it over to you, Jenny. Thank you. Anyone confirm that you can?
36:38 Yeah, we can see that just fine. Thank you, Jenny. You may need to speak up just a little bit, Jenny. It's kind of hard to hear you. Thank you. Okay. Is this better? That's a little better. Thank you. My volume's at max, so I'll try to talk loud. So I am based in our corporate office in Clovis. I'm typically up in the area right now almost monthly. Normally it would be quarterly, but there's a lot going on up there right now.
37:04 So I just wanted to cover a few things that I know from talking with members of the community have kind of been sort of some ongoing questions and then I'm happy to, you know, answer random questions at the end. So I sort of, so just a quick overview of the topics that I kind of have broken out here is an update on the current wait list, a breakdown of the units and kind of what that looks like, getting current information to the public, which I know is a concern.
37:39 Our processing for application timeline and the guidelines and some information on declined applicants, which has been coming up, a little bit of information on move-in and what happens when we do get certificate of occupancy, some of the concerns we expect to come up, and like I mentioned, questions. So at this point, we do have a wait list. It's managed here at our corporate office. As of today, there's 466 people on the interest list.
38:08 I did want to clarify that every interested person that contacts is added to the interest list. We don't pre-qualify. We don't drill down on their sources or their amount of income at the point that they're put on the interest list. And there are people that started on the interest list in the very end of 2021. So their circumstances could have changed. So once we do start processing, we would look at kind of their current situation.
38:33 This is really typical for lease-ups. This is kind of, you know, how we manage when there are delays related to construction, making sure that we are as fair as possible as far as processing people for the units. So getting current information to the public. So we, I know there was one for the parcel, which was, you know, the broad overreaching name at PacWest.
38:57 Approval, we created a Sawyer Facebook page. It will be managed by Buckingham. We're committed to doing at least weekly updates with information as far as updates, what's going on with construction, where we're at with possible changes for timelines, some basic information just about Buckingham and the apartment complex in general, you know, and we can technically.
39:20 Add information when we start processing. So we can obviously list a list of names, but we can let them know that we are actively processing. This is what's going on so that there's more transparency for the public as far as where things are at and kind of getting information handed down quicker and more equally across the board so that everyone feels like they're connected. One of the things we've also discussed is there's a
39:46 Thank you so much.
40:16 And again, we can then reiterate kind of where we're at with the waitlist and update updates. And then the last would be updating information on the town's website, which I know Shaleen sent an email about as well. And kind of linking the Facebook page to that, making sure that some of the information is updated, which I know is already in process. And then the PDF once we get.
40:38 Final approval from PAC West could be added to there as well so that, again, it's the same consistent information across all of the platforms and hopefully will help to provide people with more direct access to information to kind of ease some of the concerns that people are having. As far as a breakdown of the units, so...
41:01 The site, we have it kind of broken out between the sites for the No Place Like Home funds, which is the eight guaranteed units, and then there are five units with preference, which would leave between 67 and 72 affordable units, depending on how many units are taken by No Place Like Home. And then that leaves one employee unit, and that is kind of what encompasses the whole site. We're working with the county staff to...
41:29 Figure out a game plan as far as, you know, the manager they're training, their experience that aligns with the requirements of the no place like home funds. And so those things are kind of happening simultaneously behind the scenes. Processing application timeline. So we pretty much work backwards from the CO date. So to us, the guiding time is the CO date, which right now is tentatively March. I have heard whispers of April.
41:56 And so normally we work backwards from that date and that date is really critical to us. So typically 90 to 120 days prior to that, we would hire a local community manager that will supervise the lease up. So right now we're looking to bring that person on board in December. It's important to us to find somebody that's local to the community, that knows the area, that knows the positives and the challenges in that area.
42:25 60 to 90 days prior to the CO date is when we would begin contacting people off the interest list, processing applications, which is tentatively slated for the end of December or the beginning of January. That's a very active time. And depending on the volume of applicants, depending on what's going on, sometimes we have other managers or supervisors come to the area to assist with processing. But that's a very intensive time period because we...
42:52 Have a limited date window of getting applications, you know, approved and making sure that all of the information that we have is current. And so I just want to be transparent that when the CO dates get extended, then it kind of pushes that timeline further out. So that's sort of where we're orienting right now. Once we do start processing paperwork, then we try to educate the residents as much as possible during that process.
43:19 If we think there's a chance there could be delays, we'll tell residents that we're going to continue to collect their pay stubs until they physically move into the property and to drop them off by the office to try to make it as easy on the applicants as possible because it has potential to be difficult on them if we're trying to reprocess paperwork if we get outside of those gate pages. So as far as the processing guidelines go,
43:47 One of the things that we really want is we want it to just be fair, consistent, and transparent across the board. I know there's been some anxiety, some frustration, some rumor mills about what's going on, who's going to qualify, who's going to get units. And so for us as a property management company, that's really the key is fair, consistent, transparent. So everybody will have to go through the same process. Everybody has to meet the...
44:11 And we do that and keep that in mind. And that's, you know, how we avoid fair housing claims. That's how we, you know, maintain our reputation. So as we go down, every person has a credit check. I do want to make a small caveat that sometimes there are some subtle differences in the criteria on those households that qualify under the no place like home funds. And so sometimes there's just some differences there.
44:40 But on the regular affordable units, they would have to do a credit check. They have to have a minimum score of 540. We say they can't have balances due to a utility. If they provide proof that they pay any balances to a utility and that was the only issue on their credit, then a supervisor has the ability to override it. No evictions or unlawful detainers and then collections or huge balances obviously impact their credit score and cause problems with them qualifying. Everyone does a criminal check.
45:09 We use a company that does our criminal checks for us. They typically are checking criminal backgrounds based on addresses over the last seven years. Criminal is not something that we have issues handled by the community manager. Those are handled by a supervisor just because of the legal issues in California and what and what cannot affect rental criteria. If there was someone to have an issue with their criminal background, that would be handled by a supervisor.
45:37 Housing history. So verifying two years of favorable housing history to confirm they paid the rent on time, they were a resident in good standing. Typically we ask how many people were living in the unit and as part of this project confirming that for the last 12 months they've lived in Mammoth. And so that will be something that's verified as part of verifying their housing history. And so then they would move into processing.
46:03 For the most part, we will pick a decent-sized chunk of people off of the interest list, and we will contact them in order to begin processing them. We don't contact the entire interest list, because that would be literally opening the floodgate for hundreds and hundreds of people. So with a project this size, we would probably contact the first 100 people that are on the wait list, and we would work through the application processing with those 100 people. And they would either...
46:32 You know, let us know they're no longer interested or they've moved out of the area. They would be interested in scheduling appointments and setting up to see if they qualify. And we would work through the process. Once we got through that initial 100 people, if we had filled the whole property, then we would notify everybody that's left on the wait list that at this point we had filled the complex and that they would remain on the wait list for future vacancies. If we did not fill the complex, then we would just continue contacting in order until we were able to actually fill.
47:01 The complex. There's been a lot of questions about income. So 80% is the highest AMI. There are other lower AMIs. And so the verification for income for everybody is the same. So if you have employment income, you are getting three months of current back-to-back pay stubs are what is provided, and we'll send a verification to the employer. If you have other sources of income, Social Security, Cash Aid.
47:27 Disability, any of those, we're going to accept an award letter from whatever agency that is with what your current benefit amount is. Everyone has to provide third-party documentation. It's not that someone can, they can't show us what the deposits are into their bank account, things like that. The rules are the same as far as what they need to provide. And not that I'm going to go through them in depth, but just for transparency purposes.
47:54 The same for income calculations, especially on employment income are done for every household. So the way we calculate income is the same for everyone. And so we would go through, calculate the four different ways based on their verification from their employer, which we call a VOE, or their pay stubs and ensure that they are not over the income limits for the property. If they have non-employment income.
48:23 Again, collecting whatever the award letters are for that, and there's a process if they have the same monthly amount or if they do not have the same monthly amount, doing a three-month average. Once all that's collected, then they do a final on-site review, which is making sure that they've passed all of the criteria. So it's basically the community manager going through, making sure that they pass the credit, they pass the criminal, they have the housing history, including the 12 months in Mammoth, that their income is within the restrictions for
48:54 The particular unit they're being processed for, and then they will send it to our corporate compliance, which is a department within our corporate office. The managers upload the files to our third-party file server, and it's reviewed by our compliance department. So the final decision actually doesn't belong with the community manager. It is with a third person that is removed from the property just to ensure that all of our T's are crossed, I's are dotted, all of our calculations are correct.
49:23 So that we're 100% certain that we're moving qualified households into every unit. And so one of the things that often comes up as issues that might come up for some of you as complaints are the reasons that applicants are declined. So they will be declined if they don't meet the credit requirements. They can be declined for criminal, for unfavorable housing history.
49:46 For not being able to verify housing history. So if we have a hard time reaching a prior landlord, we will ask the applicant to help connect us with the correct person. But if we cannot verify it, then we will decline them. If they're over the income limits, if they cannot verify income sources. So if they don't provide pay stubs, if they can't provide award letters that show the benefits they're receiving, that's reasons for decline.
50:13 And tenant failure to respond in general. So we give them usually seven days to respond with paperwork after it's requested. If they don't communicate and don't provide in seven days, then they can be declined for failure to respond. Obviously, with such a lengthy list of people eager to get in, we want to make sure that we're not waiting and waiting for weeks if there's literally no communication from an applicant.
50:39 Applicants are informed verbally from the community manager and then they are also sent an actual written letter that explains the reason that they were declined. Move-in and certificate of occupancy. So for the last couple of weeks prior to the site being handed off to Buckingham, we're usually physically on site quite a bit. We walk all of the units, we walk the physical property, we're getting things set up like trash service or...
51:07 Stuff in communal spaces, things like that, the office. And so usually by that point, we're pretty confident as far as when we're actually going to get keys and so we can begin scheduling movements. I know that this has been a concern also as far as the logistics of this. And so I just wanted to kind of stress that the logistics will be handled sort of on a basis of kind of assessing the state of the property and when it actually comes online.
51:37 You get 50 feet of snow again, that might impact how we want to do things logistically. We do things like only move certain people into each section so that everybody that's moving in is going to a different part of the building. There's some different access things with these buildings that we would want to make sure that we're being aware of, but we have to be responsible in how we're scheduling the move-in so that we don't have a nightmare on property as far as everybody trying to get into the same space at the same time.
52:05 And so that would be conveyed to the people that are moving in as early as we know when we will get keys so that we can sort of space that out. It's very typical that we will do these signings early in the morning, that we will do them at night, that we will do them on the weekend. And that's very common to kind of spread out the move-in so that it makes it a smoother transition for everybody into their new project.
52:31 And then the people who were on the interest list that did not end up getting qualified for a unit, that were never actually contacted to qualify for a unit, that becomes the wait list for the property after the site is 100%. And everybody remains on there in order and they would be contacted in order based on the unit that they would potentially qualify for. And then the line of communication with that is that typically...
52:58 Every six to nine months, a letter goes out that confirms that they're still on the wait list, it updates their contact information, confirms they want to stay on the wait list, and then potentially, you know, with additional phases coming online, we would utilize that wait list as well for that. Expected concerns, because I know there have been a lot of concerns already, and, you know, because I'm a pretty straightforward person.
53:22 I do expect for there to be applicants that are anxious and upset if they are not contacted as part of the initial batches to be processed. A lot of times applicants want to give information about their personal circumstances and try to justify that they should get priority over someone else. But this project is just being processed based on the order that people went onto the interest list. So I expect for some people to try to...
53:50 Advocate for themselves in their specific situation. Applicants who are declined and they believe that someone in similar circumstances was approved. This is a tough one. We could have two people who both work at bonds and one gets declined and one gets approved. And the one that gets declined gets really upset because they know their coworker was approved. But maybe the person who was declined makes $25 an hour and the person who was approved only makes $20 an hour.
54:19 We're not allowed to disclose that kind of information. And so sometimes people get frustrated because we're very limited. All we can tell people is why they didn't qualify. We can't tell them why someone else did qualify over them. And a lot of times that causes frustration. And then affordable applicant concerns about no place like home households. We have multiple projects that are combo properties. And sometimes as residents move in.
54:47 And the last thing I have is...
55:16 Community Perception, who was approved in decline, have done a couple of meetings and presentations. And I know there's been a lot of concern that the city was going or the town was going to just put town workers here was one of the concerns. One was that people from the mountain were going to take all of this housing. And, you know, we're here to just say at Buckingham that we are going to process an order of the wait list.
55:40 And that's the order we go in. But if someone who happens to work for the town or happens to work at Mammoth Mountain were to apply and be next on the wait list and qualify, we would approve them. And so I'm just being transparent that I could see that that could also cause some backlash if people were to find out about that in the community, because then they want to think that what they were originally concerned about is happening. But again, for us, it's purely...
56:07 Were they in order on the wait list? And did they actually qualify for a unit? And that's kind of all I had. Jenny, thank you very much. I think that's exactly what the council is looking for. So thank you. I think I'll turn first any council questions on Jenny's presentation. And Shallon, do you want to hop in first or should we wait to do Jenny first and then go to you? I'm just happy to answer questions as needed. Okay, so Shallon, you and Jenny can tag team on that.
56:40 Okay, why don't we, Jenny, why don't you stop sharing your screen so we can see both of you well here in Suite Z, the Carleton Memorial Theater Complex. So, questions, any questions from Council? Amanda, you want to start? I do have some questions. Okay. I'm sorry, I'm unfamiliar with the No Place Like Home program. Can you briefly explain what that is?
57:07 Sure, I can pick that one, Jenny, if that works, and then you can chime in if I see anything incorrect. But that's, and I knew that was going to come up because we haven't talked about it recently. It's essentially two sources of funds that came into the project totaling at about $2.3 million from Mono County.
57:32 I say two sources, but really it acts and feels like one source. So Mono County actually was one of the largest soft fund providers of the first phase of Mammoth. And so what those funds do, they're state- awarded funds through the county to projects that help house people that are suffering addiction and or homelessness or some other type of certain criteria. And those folks go through
58:02 Process are processed through Mono County Health and Human Services, who we've been working really closely with, both in the pre-development entitlement stages, as well as keeping them up to speed on construction. And now it's kind of Buckingham has been working closely with them just to make sure that everyone's aligned. So those are those units. There's eight no place like home units that we're calling them and then that are reserved for them. And that's per.
58:29 The financing requirement that was put in place at closing, so years ago at this point, and then there's an additional five units that are prioritized for them. So, it could, like Jenny mentioned, it could be up to 13 units, but it probably will be somewhere, you know, minimum of eight, but probably somewhere between eight and 13, and it might, over time, it'll flex a little bit if that's helpful. Thank you.
58:58 And then I guess I had a couple other questions. How will you initially contact everyone on the list? Are you calling everyone or emailing or sending out letters? So for, it's my understanding that there's some concern from this group that we should have some initial immediate contact now. And so we've talked about sending a letter now to everybody that's currently on the wait list, which gives them just an update on.
59:23 The process, the taming, the link to the Facebook. But when we contact people to actually process them to come in, those are phone conversations. Typically, we try to set people up for success with as few appointments as possible. So it's more of a conversation of can you confirm your income sources and guiding them on what documentation they need to bring to the appointment with them. And that's, you know, on a case by case that's very customized to the individual.
59:49 Okay, thank you. Another concern that I had was the two years of housing history. How would you deal with folks that have been living in their cars or maybe, you know, sleeping on someone's couch? So those, again, are handled more on a case-by-case basis. So, you know, we're looking to make sure that the people that we're renting to from a rental standpoint are...
1:00:16 Going to pay the rent, going to maintain their unit. And so that's really the goal. That's part of the no place like home funds. Typically, those units have separate requirements for things like housing history because they qualify under things like that. So we would have to kind of look at each individual circumstance differently because I know that housing is a premium in this area. And so we're trying to set the complex up for success with renting to, you know,
1:00:46 The best possible people to make sure that they take care of the units. Okay, so if someone has been living in their car, they could maybe go through the There's No Place Like Home program if they're already on the wait list? I think we'd have to talk to the county. I don't want to overstep on their behalf and see. But I think, you know, we have people that will provide documentation, just like I talked about with overriding for.
1:01:18 The credit, if someone were to show that they have paid off the utility bill, if someone provided, you know, we would ask for it in writing, but provided documentation as far as, you know, this is what happened, I ended up homeless, this is my history, and they still met the income requirements, then we can still technically override that criteria. Okay, thank you. And then my other comments are, I guess just I was surprised by the credit check that they have to have a certain credit score.
1:01:47 Is there any wiggle room with that too or is that you? 540 is pretty low. Okay, I'm not super familiar. So that one technically we're pretty firm on the 540. We do have workarounds for the utility bills and if that's what's contributing to their credit. But again, it links back for us from a property management standpoint.
1:02:16 It links back to the likeliness of them to pay their rent and uphold the commitment they make with the lease. And so that's really where we kind of get into an issue. Thank you. And then the community manager that you'll be hiring, I guess I just had a little bit of a concern. It's extremely difficult to find employees here.
1:02:42 Because of the housing crisis. So I don't know if that's, you know, if we should start looking for that to fill that position or if you should start looking to fill that position sooner or, you know, that's just my concern is that you're going to have a hard time filling that position. Yes, we have several other sites in the area. So we know that staffing is a challenge. We did just recently hire a community manager that I think is a pretty good fit. But we are working with
1:03:10 I'd have to look up the name, but we are working with an agency that's helped us with temps in the past that's basically doing some recruiting for us on the side to see what she can find as far as the applicants, but there are some specific things we're looking for. You know, as part of our agreement for management with the No Place Like Home Fund, we're specifically looking for a manager that's bilingual.
1:03:32 We're specifically looking for someone that's going to take some specific training and have some certain types of experiences. So I'm on the same page with you. So we are doing some of the groundwork behind the scenes right now. We're just not looking to actually officially hire that person and put them in place until closer just because the lease up funds will have to pay that person's salary in full until the site is fully operational and we have rent to offset those expenses.
1:04:00 Okay, thanks. And then I have one last question. Will people be told what number they are on your wait list or interest list? They are not supposed to be told, no. And that is just because we run into many more problems logistically when we start giving out numbers on the interest list and people...
1:04:24 It just causes a tremendous amount of drama. So from a policy standpoint, Buckingham has a policy that we don't provide the position on the wait list because it just makes it easier for people trying to buy other people's positions on the wait list and offering money or asking to trade. And when they know the physical number, it just seems to increase those issues exponentially.
1:04:52 And so from a policy standpoint, we do not give the number. I just want to add just another way to address that question because, you know, Jenny and I have gone back and forth a lot on whether or not how to handle this, right? As a human, if you're on the wait list and you've been on there since, you know, for 24 months and you just want to know, should I be thinking about renewing my lease or should I not be, right? I mean, these are real lives at hand.
1:05:22 What I think Jenny and I came to, because, I mean, she's been doing this in the weeds a lot longer than I have, that what they do in many other, and what they do in many other developments is using their Facebook page that we hope, again, will be linked to all the different sources that people are now using. We just want there to be one, you know, one place to get information. As batches go out, like as
1:05:49 Buckingham is contacting, say, the first 50 people or the first 80 people, as Jenny mentioned. There could be an update on the Facebook page saying the first batch of 100 applicants have been contacted. If you've been contacted, please respond quickly or you will lose your opportunity. And if you have not been contacted, it's because you have not been identified to be in that first batch or whatever the proper words are. But I think it's a good way for people to sort of know
1:06:18 Oh, yeah, I didn't get the email or I didn't get the phone call. Double check my voicemails kind of thing to know. I didn't miss anything. It just hasn't happened yet. And wait till the next time I see an update. So it's not a perfect system, but I do have to really trust the professionals, you know, in the room on this particular issue. Thank you. Thanks for the update. And those are all my questions. Thanks. Thank you, Amanda. Anybody else have questions? Questions? Yes, Chris, go ahead. Thanks.
1:06:49 A couple of things. That just, I totally hear your answer, and yet it's so unsatisfying. That would just be so anxiety-provoking. Is there any way you could divide it into quadrants and you're not telling people numbers, but you're saying? Because if somebody's in the bottom quartile, it's going to be years. And I just feel like it's so much more humane. So that would be my appeal, to just think about a way to give people some kind of signal. I could be, to be honest, I could be on board with that. I think it's, it's.
1:07:19 Vague enough to avoid some of the problems I'm talking about, but would at least give them some general idea, because I do think that it's very likely that we won't even get halfway through the list, being transparent with all of you. So I think if we can break it up into, you know, you're in the first 25% or, you know, you said break it up into four quarters and say this is, it's growing every day. So, and, you know, we can.
1:07:47 We can have Monique tell people at this point that you're in the fifth group of 100 for processing or something along those lines. I think you would be willing to do something like that if you feel like that would really help. Thank you. I think it would. People have been waiting a long time. There's so much uncertainty around housing here that it's extra anxiety-inducing.
1:08:15 Only other question, because Amanda had such good questions. Has every person that signed up on this list been informed when they signed up about the income requirements? Because I'm afraid that there's people on the list who don't know that they're not close to qualifying. And I think that would be a real disappointment for people.
1:08:38 So people are told that it's an affordable complex, but we don't really drill down on that when they come on the list because unfortunately if somebody applied and went on the list at the end of 2021 and they were making $100,000 at that point and they've since lost their job and they're now making $40,000, we wouldn't want to discourage people that are interested in looking for housing based on, you know, circumstances that no longer apply. So everyone is basically encouraged at this point, but the...
1:09:06 Information that we're looking at sending out that we would mail out in the PDF will clarify the affordable requirements and will obviously draw light to that. So when we send that out to provide information, you know, hopefully if there is somebody on there that knows that there will over the limit because people can be under the limit as well.
1:09:27 Just so we say that, you know, you should make two and a half times the rent. So if you don't make two and a half times whatever the lowest rent is on property, you won't qualify either. And so it lets people know that they need to sort of be in this slot limit. And so we can make sure that that's very clear in what we send out now to everybody on the wait list. That'd be great. Thank you. Yeah, you know, I'm going to try to be careful here because I'm conflicted. I can't give certain information or ask certain questions. So throw something at me.
1:09:58 If I go far afoul here, my concern is if I heard correctly and maybe not, I don't always, I'm getting old, but we're looking at interviewing people and starting to put people in there in March or April, which is completely different from what we've been told prior is going to be our occupancy dates. It was going to be this fall and then it was going to be December and then when we took a tour, it was December for 15 units or something and April for the next.
1:10:27 Then the next thing I got from Pacific was it was going to be December and the rest of them in January. Now I'm hearing March or maybe April. I'm sitting here with my face hanging out telling my constituents things. And then the egg is on my face because somehow we can't get this straight. I realize it was a big winter, but we knew the effects of that winter literally months ago. Commissioner, I'm happy to take that one.
1:10:57 Hear your frustration. I mean, I think the short answer is not a very good one, but construction is hard. It's really hard in Mammoth. We've had full crews working on Sundays. A lot of concerns with how our financing would or would not allow us to open one building.
1:11:27 At a different time than a second building. We really wanted to explore that. And sometimes I think when there's so much attention on site and contractors, to be honest, a contractor's construction management deadline, it changes every week. Every week their estimated construction schedule changes because
1:11:52 One plumbing part wasn't in, and so everything else on their construction, not project manager sheet, I call it a spreadsheet, but it's not, gets revised. And so, you know, one of the things that is wonderful about working in Mammoth and also really hard is that there's so much interest and there's so much communication that, you know, you'll go out to site and the contractor is like, just had my meeting, the current, the current,
1:12:18 Schedule shows, you know, December 1st for building A or building B probably in this case and December 25th or whatever for building B. And that is true at that moment in time. But, you know, that contractor doesn't know that our finance investors don't allow us to open one building without another. They were considering it, but they couldn't because of then this fire.
1:12:46 Thank you so much.
1:13:13 You know, we need to do better. And I think the communication that Jenny's talking about will be really tight between her, I and Pacific West Builders. But at this point in time, it's March, late March, you know, easily can move by a week or two in any direction, could easily move by a month if you get a big dump. So I don't know if that's a lot of words to say, mea culpa, right?
1:13:42 Yeah, again, I've dealt with a lot of construction projects in Mammoth over the years, and I realize there are issues, but perhaps even better communication back to those of us who keep, yay, we're going to be there this fall, winter, spring. If we have snow in Mammoth, I'm so surprised it's not going to be until next spring. Just, please. Sure, and, you know, just to reiterate, and in the...
1:14:14 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
1:14:41 Do whatever I can to make sure there's one message coming. Okay. And, you know, blame it on construction. Don't take it on yourself for late delivery. We understand the reality of this. I don't have any comments or questions. I think it was an excellent presentation. Jenny and Sheldon, thanks for being here. My only question is, I'm assuming this is being recorded, correct? The meeting?
1:15:07 Well, this presentation as part of the meeting was being recorded? Correct. So it would be great if we could edit this presentation out and find a way to post this on the town's website or something because I think this is a really good definitive overview of the process. So if there's a way technically to do that, I think that would be a great thing to do. And then we can point them, give all of us a place to point constituents to, this is what's happening, this is what's going to go on. So that shouldn't be too hard to do. Maybe we figure out how to do that. I have an email as well. Oh, okay, please. Yeah, go ahead.
1:15:37 That's right. So public comments. There will be some public comments in this video. Jess Landry says, would I have to leave the parcel if my income went above a certain limit during my lease? And what are the pet policies? And will there be parking available? Okay. Jenny, who wants to take that? Three questions. I can take them.
1:15:59 So we recertify annually to confirm that their income is still within the limits for the property. So if their income does increase to the point that they no longer qualify for any unit, then yes, they can be asked to leave. If they were moved into a lower percentage unit and their rent increased and they would qualify for a higher percentage unit, we have the ability to change the...
1:16:24 Mapping for the property and they would start to pay the rent on the higher unit and we would look for another unit that we would basically swap with on the lower percentage. Parking, yes, I think that we will have to be very clear with the parking on the property and how that works with individual units and how many spaces. I do not know off the top of my head how many spaces are on the property.
1:16:50 But I am making a note to myself right now that we will post that on Facebook as soon as I look it up and get a breakdown of how the parking will work. So if that person wants to find the Facebook, I will make sure that that is updated there once I look at the schematics and see how many parking spaces we actually have available. And yeah, specific communities allows their properties to be pet friendly. They do require a security deposit. We require a...
1:17:17 Pet lease addendum that would have to be signed and we would need all documentation on the animal prior to it coming on property. So we would need proof of current vaccination and other information about the animal before it was on property. Thank you. Anything else, Jamie, from emailing those? Any public comments or questions from the folks here? Yes, please. Good evening, Council Buckingham. Representatives, my name is Colin Campbell.
1:17:50 I've been a Mammoth resident for eight years now. I've been following the parcel since Mammoth acquired the land and been kind of invested in it. I reached out pretty early in the process and I was told that I was eighth on the waiting list. I know tonight they weren't supposed to tell me, but, and you know, coming here and hearing that they're sending updates every nine months, well, like, I haven't heard.
1:18:21 The last time the website's been updated was February of this year.
1:18:51 Commissioner said, still says move-in dates fall 2023. So just knowing that that's, you know, the avenue to go through and that I had to call Buckingham to hear that, oh yeah, it's actually in January, you know, like move-in dates, but show up tonight, yeah, it's actually April, spring. It's just hard watching the brakes getting pumped on this for years now, you know.
1:19:21 Yeah, I'd just like to at least see a little bit more update and getting more information to the public because I was told I was eighth. Updates every six to nine months and I just searched my email, Buckingham, haven't heard anything, voicemails, nothing, calls, nothing. And I've been in Mammoth this long, I've worked for the town, I've worked for the mountain, it's a great community here, you know, I'd love to be here long-term, raise a family.
1:19:52 It's hard not to get jaded. It's kind of tough. So I don't know what kind of answer I'm going to get from any of this, but thanks for hearing me. Oh, thank you very much. And that's exactly the kind of information we need to hear. We've heard the same kinds of things from other people. That's, I think, why the council requested we get this presentation from Buckingham. We asked for this a little while ago. So there's obviously some communication and some channel work that we have to do.
1:20:18 I think we're going to be looking to staff to probably give an update at this point at every council meeting around the questions and things you're talking about. We're going to work very, very diligently to get this communication, get these wires uncrossed and get this stuff figured out because I've been hearing the same thing for a bunch of other people as well. Yeah, I'd like to emphasize, you know, like the avenue, like nobody uses Facebook. Like Facebook is, I mean, Cambridge Analytica, everyone knows it's the worst platform on the Internet.
1:20:49 When you go to look up information about this, what do you do? You Google the parcel. You don't go on Facebook and like, oh, because what are you going on Facebook for? See some people freaking about vaccines and stuff. You don't know. Yeah, sorry. I'm just a little jaded. We got it. Hang in there. We're going to get there. Thank you very much. Thank you. Am I allowed to work?
1:21:15 Just hang on a second. Why don't you take a note of these things? We're just hearing public comment now, so we'll go through the public comment. We'll give you a chance to follow up. Yes, please. Good afternoon, or is it evening? My name is Sonia Bush, and I have a request for Buckingham. As we're screening these people or bringing them in, could one of the questions be, where are you coming from or where are you residing now? Because I'm looking for the data to show us what will be vacant. Will they be leaving a place where they're living with 10 people? Will they be leaving a place that might be?
1:21:46 Open to other workforce housing. So I'm looking for some of that information to help us with our workforce housing. Great. Good point. Thank you. Anybody else? Make a public comment get a round of applause. Anybody else? I received another email. Oh, you did? Please. Go ahead, Jamie. Sandy Hogan asks, Spanish written instructions? Spanish speakers to answer questions by phone? Manager requirements? Spanish speaker?
1:22:21 Roll of MLH. Why aren't the updates sent to MLH as well as the town? Are the updates in Spanish? Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you, Sandy. Anything else? No. So, Sheldon and Jenny, you got those couple comments or questions. Why don't you guys go ahead?
1:22:38 Yeah, let me take a quick stab at it. And let me first is the issue with Facebook not being the proper platform to provide updates. The second is the town website being outdated. I think those were from the first speaker. The third is more of a data request of just regarding getting the data for where folks are coming from so that.
1:23:03 The community can better understand the workforce housing needs. And then I think the last email was very focused on the ability to be bilingual and whether or not applications and paperwork websites will be in Spanish. So first, I'll handle the Spanish speaking one first, and Jenny can correct me. But as she mentioned, she is going to be hiring a community manager there.
1:23:33 And being bilingual is a very important quality, very important skill set that they are looking for. And that was both because of the demographic that we're serving and because of the requirements associated with the county's No Place Like Home funds. We are committed to hiring the best person for the job and knowing how difficult it is to find people
1:24:02 To work in Mammoth, you know, we may not be able to get the person that is an A-plus in every single area. Buckingham has a Spanish translator available, I think, 24-7. I could be wrong about that. Jenny can confirm. And then our websites can be, at least the town website, I believe, can be done in Spanish. You can just click the button to date. At least that's what the town websites, I think, have.
1:24:32 So hopefully that answers that question. And then in regard to the data, I think that is a question that Buckingham is going to be gathering is not only where their address is, but if they've lived in Mammoth for the 12 months prior, the intent has always been, as we understood it from the town to provide local community housing. And so that is where that's coming from. I think primarily, in other words, you don't want a bunch of folks coming from.
1:25:00 L.A. who just want to go move to the mountains and then get on the list early and then folks who are working and playing and living and raising their families in Mammoth don't get a chance to move in. So that's the thinking behind that. And we're certainly happy to share data that we can. It won't be individual, specific to individuals, obviously, for security and privacy reasons. But I think that Buckingham will happily share that.
1:25:26 I think a lot of the misunderstandings around this have been because there is so much communication on the town's website that's not controlled by Pacific or Buckingham. And that's just because, you know, there's been a lot going on and everyone's got a lot on their on their plates. And so I agree the town's website does need to be revised and I would.
1:25:49 I would urge it to, I would urge every, all of the information to go to one place. And I believe that one place should be the Buckingham site because they're closest to all of the issues around pets and incomes and Spanish speaking abilities. So that is really the request that we have of our partners at this point. And Facebook, I mean, I think the gentleman who spoke raises a good point. Not everybody uses Facebook.
1:26:18 I think that's something that Jenny and I need to discuss. Certainly, she's got a lot of experience, and Buckingham has done this many, many times, and that has been their go-to platform. We are open to looking at that differently and seeing what else we can do. Great. Thank you. Jenny, do you have some thoughts? I think I got everything. Okay. I just wanted to clarify that when I said the updates every six to nine months, that was in reference to once the site is full.
1:26:44 And maintaining the wait list moving forward. So at this point, as we build an interest list, they're just giving updates to the COD as we have them, and they have a basic list of information. But that wasn't in reference to right now. That was after the site is 100% occupied. It's a good point. And a typical project, just one more thing. I know you have a full agenda, but in a typical development that we work with Buckingham on, the wait, the interest list would not have started until around now.
1:27:14 About six months prior. And I think it was a really strong desire of the town of Mammoth Lakes to, you know, get this going so that we could answer people's questions and create a place for them to go. And I think it's done that 476 people fold, but it does have its challenges when it's open so early. There is no method to update folks on that interest list. Okay.
1:27:42 Well, great. We're a community that deals with challenges just about every day, just like everybody else does. So we're looking forward to getting some of these wires untangled, getting this stuff moving forward. Amy, I know you and Nolan will work actively with Pacific and everybody else to get these kinds of things figured out. So any final thoughts, questions? Yes, please. Just for the project manager, so it's an amazing-looking facility. It's a beautiful job. I'm just wondering.
1:28:11 Do we have an update on sort of an all-in cost of what a two-bedroom unit would have cost to construct in that facility? To answer your question, I don't have a most recent update, more than we expected, more than we budgeted for. We had over a million dollars of snow load movement this winter. I mean, I know everyone's felt that pain, so it's not news. But, you know, a million bucks, we certainly...
1:28:45 We certainly budgeted for some of that, but if you spread that out over 81 units, that's a, you know, that's a substantial increase in costs. Luckily, we closed this when interest rates were still at a really reasonable, or I shouldn't say reasonable, but prior to the interest rate jump. So, you know, we're pretty fortunate on that front. Okay, I'm sure that kind of information will be forthcoming as we go forward. Okay, so if there's nothing else, we're going to move on.
1:29:13 And just for the interest of everybody here in the room, we're going to do something called the Consent Agenda. We'll do that first. The one additional policy matter. And after that, we'll take a break. And then we'll come back and get into probably the highlighted event of the evening. So I'm going to go ahead and do the Consent Agenda. These items are item 9.1, to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of October 4, 2023. Item 9.2, approve the reading and adopt the ordinance amending the Municipal Code Chapter 10.12, Parking.
1:29:43 And item 9.3 is accept check register from the 4th of October, the amount of $1,358,850.78. Anybody like to pull anything? Good? Okay? Anybody in the audience want to pull any of these exciting items? I'm not seeing any interest. Jamie, go ahead and move to approve as presented. Okay? I'll second. We'll have a second. Excuse me, folks. If you have conversations, please take them out in the hall. We're still trying to run a meeting here, so thank you.
1:30:14 We have a motion. We have a second. Thank you very much. Jamie, the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Consent agenda is agreed to as presented. Thank you very much. Okay, we're moving on now to policy matter 10.1, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, ESTA, proposed modifications to fixed route transit in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:30:40 And folks, again, if you want to talk, that's fine, but please go out in the hall and close the door if you could. We had a lot of folks who are interested in this item as well. So I believe Hayes, you're up. I am. And Phil. Good evening, Phil. Welcome. Thank you. Haislip Hayes, Public Works Director, joined with Phil Morris, Executive Director of ESTA. Phil, your public hearing notice in the paperwork wonders. Thank you. Oh, Lord. So we're here today just to talk about our proposed changes to fixed route transit.
1:31:09 We're not looking for a motion, but a roaring thumbs up would be appreciated. Most of our changes are to the Purple Line. You'll note that most of our lines in the wintertime are run by the ski area, so we're really only talking about the town-owned lines. We're proposing to split the Purple Line, and I'll get into some of these details, to better access Vons, Old Mammoth, the parcel, and the CRC.
1:31:34 And we're looking to implement these changes this winter. And we'll be back in the spring to talk about similar changes to summer routes because we're looking to address access to the Welcome Center, Trails End Park, maybe Mill City and some other recreation destinations. Case, real quick, CRC stands for? Community Recreation Center. Great, thank you. I didn't know I was going to have such a big audience. Community Recreation Center, thank you. So here's the map for transit service last winter. Here's this winter. Any questions?
1:32:03 No, I know you can't see that, and there's a lot of detail in this. So I'm going to kind of fixate some of the things that we're trying to change here. So in 22, 23, and for many years, we've run the Purple Line into the parking lot of Vons. And for a number of reasons, that's a problem. It's private property. And, Phil, you can talk at length to this. But it's something we've been looking to address and change. So, Phil, if you want to kind of let them know the issues with it. At length? No, I think they're here for some tale, so maybe.
1:32:33 Very good. Yeah, because I can talk about transit all day long. But yeah, from a public entity perspective, operating on private property has its own challenges, especially when you're in a parking lot with a large vehicle. You can't avoid little mishaps and problems. And it's just safer and easier and faster to stay on the main streets with a transit route. Thanks, Phil. And for that reason, our change is in splitting the line.
1:33:00 Allows us to keep track transit on Old Mammoth Road, Meridian and Sierra Park. And we've got a couple of stops that we're looking to bolster. We do have in our CIP replacing the transit stop by Carl's Jr. with a new transit mansion. And we're looking to do that in the next couple of years. We're looking to address the parcel. We've talked a lot about the parcel in 22-23. It didn't exist. So we're looking to provide a route. We're looking to pave the next couple of weeks. We'll be ready to go with transit.
1:33:30 And provide service to those residents once they start to move in. And we do have pedestrian connectivity. We have transit shelters all being completed as part of that infrastructure project. The Community Recreation Center, you know, this facility has been in construction for a few years now. But we will open the doors in November, which will allow us to change how that route works and access that facility.
1:34:01 So the Community Recreation Center, the LA Kings Ice at Mammoth Lakes, we're looking to loop transit around Old Mammoth Road and Chateau. Phil will tell you that that is actually one of the most popular areas. The bus is often full before it even leaves this part of town and heads up to the mountain. So by looping this both inbound and outbound, it allows us to provide better service and better access to the recreation center. It also will align with the other routes for
1:34:31 As a connection point and actually function as that mobility hub that we all envisioned. Phil calls the purple line the spaghetti line. And you can see on the left what we were dealing with in 22-23. It wasn't really functioning that great. And Phil, you can speak to your philosophy on how routes go in and out and why we made these alignments a little bit more streamlined and not so circular. Well, primarily it's for
1:35:00 Resident, or visitors, and people that want to use the system for the first time, I can tell you, even when I got this job, I struggled to understand what the Purple Line was doing. And it was supposed to be my job to know. So, yeah, it's a little convoluted, and if you're a local, you don't have too many problems with it, but if you're new or you're trying to use the system from outside, it's almost impossible. That's why I called it a bowl of spaghetti, because it's just, where is this noodle going?
1:35:26 So the new alignment will be more direct, better coverage, and allow for better driver breaks. Right now the service, we have to go out and relieve them because there's not enough time for a break on the line. So this is addressing a lot of problems. Better coverage, better driver treatment, and clearer presentation of your transit routes.
1:35:50 And so you can see, you know, the spaghetti on the left and on the right, we have the two lines. It's a little bit more obvious in this drawing. You've got the purple line and the teal line. And so we have duplicity in Old Mammoth, the corridor, accessing the hospital, the schools, the grocery stores, bonds and grocery outlets. So we think that functions much better. Also, duplicity in the park and ride lot, which is somewhat underutilized. We're looking to bolster that as another mobility hub and working with some of our partners. We've reached out to, like, YARTS and such.
1:36:20 To utilize this and having more routes in that corridor will allow for better access to town from people coming from the outside as well as our trippers from Reno and Lancaster. One change we're kind of debating is Sierra Valley sites. Right now we have kind of a loop that goes through. Problem with that is you only get access about every hour with a half hour headway.
1:36:48 And, you know, to Phil's point of having one route going in and out, you'll get access every 30 minutes. So we're looking to move the route to Mono Street and have it just go up and down that corridor and consolidate those stops onto one road. It also will reduce headway and allow us to access more of town. Moving on to the more contentious part of our proposal. So last year,
1:37:16 We called an audible and were able to run transit through the fire station. They graciously gave us permission to loop through the fire station, but we are not allowed to stop there or pick up riders there. So we had one stop near Ranch Road where all of Old Mammoth had to access. And throughout the winter, we had a number of conversations and were asked to review and look at providing service to Old Mammoth again.
1:37:41 We exhausted our options for a turnaround. We looked at all the private property and so forth in the neighborhood. And for, you know, Phil, as he mentioned, it's not ideal to work on private property and ask for easements and lock up their property in perpetuity. So we started evaluating street options, again, because we can use all of our rights away. And so we looked at Redford again. Again, we have issues with the grade of the road and the problems with...
1:38:11 Icing up. And we looked at even bringing the route down Woodman and looping Cliff Circle, which we figured would probably not be well received. We did some noise studies. We looked at site distance. These are some of the issues the neighborhood brought up. So we had an engineer, an independent engineer look at those. But at the end of the day, we don't really have a lot of options. And through some other opportunities, a developer is moving forward with constructing.
1:38:37 The turnaround. Doesn't mean we have to use it, but it's going to be there to meet their condition of approval and available for our use if we so desire. Also to address some of the community concerns, we've looked at reducing the size of the bus. The cutaways would run the teal route. Reducing the headways instead of 20 minutes, 30 minute routes. And then looking at our operating hours only to mitigate the noise and the light clear and so forth.
1:39:05 We also changed the layout plan. We initially had a very large, robust transit stop on Woodman proposed with transit shelter, lighting, parking. We've eliminated all of those amenities, so it has a significantly smaller footprint. It's more in alignment with the driveway that was kind of existing. We're just pulling that out with new asphalt to the roadway just to complete a loop. We're not widening Woodwind. We're not putting up any additional signage on any of those things.
1:39:34 So that allows us to run a route and provide a number of stops and better serve old Mammoth. I know I've ran through this pretty quick. I'm trying to be respectful of all the people in the room and what they're interested in. But I'm happy to field any questions you may have on our proposed route changes and take any public comments. Okay, thank you very much. I know there are people here this evening who are interested in this question. We have a number of interesting policy questions this evening.
1:40:01 Councilmembers, any questions of a technical nature for staff at this point? Just one thing that I noticed. Can you put the, Jamie, could you put the, or no. Oh, hey, sorry. Back up. So I know that the letter that went out informing the public talked about the fact that we were going to be using cutaways, but it doesn't discuss that the town trolley will be used at night. And I think it's important.
1:40:32 I mean, I'm only asking technical questions now, but that seems to me like something that probably should have been really called out to the public. I think that's important. I appreciate that. And like I said, I ran through this pretty quick. In this image for the 23-24 transit routes, it shows the bus size for the individual routes. And you'll see that the night in trolley, or excuse me, the night.
1:41:00 Late night and evening trolley is in fact a trolley, as opposed to the orange line or red line, which are the larger blue bird buses, which was originally last year something we were considering taking out there to deal with the number of passengers that ride the red line. Okay, any questions? Yes. So a couple of clarifications of terms. So a cutaway, I guess you can see it on this graphic, it's kind of hard to see, but originally we were talking about a great big bus.
1:41:31 The cutaway is a much smaller vehicle, correct? Correct. Okay. Well, let me just clarify real quick. Yeah, they come in different sizes. The cutaway is a truck chassis with a transit shell. That's a cutaway. And they can run anywhere from, you know, 20 feet to 38 feet. So they do make them in different sizes. The size that we're proposing? At the smaller size. It's smaller to mid.
1:41:58 Okay. Depending on demand, I mean, but mostly smaller to mid. Okay. And, Hayes, your point about the amenities, all the other things that were discussed before, the idea of your proposal now is to make this as minimally impactful as possible. Is that fair to say? That's fair to say. Okay. And, again, a question just administratively. The authority by which this is coming towards council, where council is not actually – this is not an action item on our agenda. Can you explain a little bit the nature of why this is coming forward? I believe it has to do with –
1:42:28 Actually changing the routes. It's not so much about wooden, it's about changing routes. Is that fair to say? That is fair to say. Because part of ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, is funded with federal dollars, there are some rules along with that. And part of that goes is if you're changing a certain percentage of a route or a system, then it requires a public hearing. And so that's why this was necessary for my organization. And yeah.
1:42:58 Okay, so we're really talking about the system. And this component of a system serves the whole community and all that. Okay, good. So thank you. Any other questions up here? Okay, is there public comment on this item? Yes, please come forward. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm John Guatelli, and my wife and I were fortunate enough to own a home in the Woodman neighborhood now for 10 years this month. And it's a beautiful neighborhood, not the least of which the people that live there.
1:43:33 Our wonderful neighbors, and they've been very welcoming to us. Unfortunately, a lot of them couldn't be here today because of the short notice about this whole issue. But I want to share with you that, and we do appreciate these changes that would reduce the mitigation that Mr. Hayes described, and thank you for a very nice summary, but we still remain very strongly opposed to this project for a number of reasons, some of which are environmental degradation of our quality of life.
1:44:02 In the neighborhood. And the fact that we don't need the ridership in the neighborhood. The ridership that needs to be served, and we acknowledge this, is at the Aspen Village and at the Snow Creek condominium area. I'd like to get to safety in a second, but first I want to say that we don't agree that no alternatives exist. As you may know, and I don't think you did mention, Mr. Hayes, the Snow Creek 7 agreement has built into it that the developer, Chad Marr, will provide a bus turnaround.
1:44:32 And in that agreement is a very complete, bona fide engineering plan that shows making a turnaround that would be adjacent to the fire station, fire station number two. We can talk about what a great site that is or what a great site it isn't, but at some point the town accepted that as fulfillment of an obligation. And one has to wonder why it was never used over more than a decade and why it was good enough to fulfill an obligation but it can't be used now.
1:45:01 The other thing I want to point out, and I just talked to Mr. Holler about this this morning. Thank you, sir, for a very nice, helpful conversation. That, in fact, there's a pretty good deal offered, it seems to me, to use the Snow Creek Athletic Club parking lot. Apparently, they want the town to pave it, which, given Chadmar's obligation, I think they'd be the ones to pay for that. And so then you're left with...
1:45:26 You know, needing to do snow removal, which you kind of need to do anyway. So I would ask, why don't you accept that deal? And finally, I want to mention that forward, looking a little bit forward, you know, Woodman neighborhood's not really a destination. It's just a place to turn a bus around. If you look forward to development, perhaps, of the Mill City area as a staging area, you know, someday you may be wanting to put public transportation.
1:45:54 Up there. And then, you know, work you do at Woodman's going to be kind of an orphan turnaround. So that seems like a waste. I want to come to safety. Mr. Holler was kind enough to share with us on Monday a report that Mr. Hayes just referenced by LSA on safety. And a striking thing is they suggest that for safety and line of sight, and this wouldn't matter what size bus you have, I don't think, that snow...
1:46:20 Berms, they call it, I guess snow banks is another word, would need to be removed 175 feet on either side east and west of the turnaround. That's 350 feet of getting rid of snow banks on Old Mammoth Road. This seems kind of impossible. And, you know, Bill and I talked about that yesterday. So I would urge a council to consider that, you know, even if you don't have to vote on this,
1:46:49 You're going to be giving tacit approval here in this public forum to this project. And it seems very doubtful that the conditions for safety are going to be met that are outlined in a document that's in the public record. And it's from a company that you commissioned. So that seems something to think about. Lastly, I just want to say that we're so disappointed in the events of the last few days. And to put them in context, at this meeting a year ago, September,
1:47:17 Mr. Hayes, you looked at this council and you said, please give us guidance. I believe you used the word guidance. And Mr. Wentworth, you said at some point, I believe, and you guys can correct me if I'm wrong, but my memory serves, that you said, you know, we know what the people don't want. What do they want? That's never been addressed. I wrote to Bill over the summer. What's going to happen? No answer. And last week, we get a document from Mr. Holler.
1:47:46 And, you know, to his credit, it's a very conciliatory document. But it also is conflicted. It says we want to hear from you and we anticipate more concerns. But on the other hand, it says basically it's a done deal. The project has been approved. Council's not going to vote on it. And the contractors have been contracted. And then yesterday, on top of that, the construction started. And here we are talking about it today.
1:48:16 So we feel pretty disrespected and railroaded. And, you know, we don't, as you know, if you checked your inbox, and I gave hard copies here to the town clerk. Sorry, I'll be done in two seconds. We asked attorneys to send you a letter and say, you know, we're not going for this. And please take a look at it. It not only has the concerns that I just reviewed, but talks about the fact that we don't believe.
1:48:43 Any proper environmental considerations have been made. And, you know, I can speak for myself. I hate to get involved in this kind of thing at a legal level. It's just so against my nature. But I feel like we need to defend our neighborhood. Okay. Thank you. John, thank you very much. And just to be clear, because I know we'll have a lot of public comment this evening, in the agenda it's published five minutes for public comment. Good. Say what you want to say.
1:49:14 It's going to be helpful to everybody. We don't need to repeat things. If someone has said something well, that's fine. Let's maybe make this additive as we go forward. But please, go ahead. It's fine. That's what's published in the agenda. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Billy State. I'm a homeowner in the Woodman neighborhood for 10 years. Part of that, I worked for the Mountain for Seven producing events. I've been in the ski snowboard industry for 30 years. Part of that, my father's a ski instructor here, brought me here as a child. So I happen to use.
1:49:44 The shuttle. And I use it frequently. And most importantly, who I see in the morning when I go to get on that shuttle, and I have to hike in or ride my bike, and I have snowboard boots so I can make it, is the backbone of our entire town, which is the hospitality service worker. So there is, I don't know, every maid, every, like, chef, everybody's trying to get on the bus to go to work.
1:50:16 So it's incredibly selfish to not consider those people and put them at the forefront of this bus stop. And it means everyone. And it's easy to see. Because it's easy to see. That said, and secondly, as an avid skier, it's impossible to find a parking spot. So it's completely counterintuitive for this neighborhood to reject this bus stop when they could walk out their door and get to the ski resort with
1:50:46 Thirdly, the last time that there was a neighborhood agenda, there were several parents extremely bummed that this neighborhood was rejecting their ability for their children to get to school. Again, incredibly selfish. And then, you know, the thing is also is if this was ever a year to be an example of the neighbors floundering in the snow, not being able to exit.
1:51:15 The street being closed. And how nice it would have been to have a bus stop. This neighborhood is aging, and they're going to need that bus stop sooner than they think. That's my two cents. Thank you. Yes, thank you very much. Okay, anybody else? Hi, good evening. Just a quick question. I noticed that the loop that went to the RV park is taken out, and I wonder what the rationale for that was. Thank you. Hayes? Bill?
1:51:47 Looking to address that in the summertime, but not in the wintertime. Okay. Thank you. Anybody else? Mr. Carlton. One question on the purple line. If we're not going to have people in the parcel until April, why are we running a bus in there? Thank you. That's the same thing. To hold, please, hang on one second. We have a plan to run the route down Main Street and make a right on Old Mammoth up until the point that the residents move into the parcel.
1:52:20 Thank you. Yes, please. I'm sorry. Community is what happens when people care about each other. Last summer, I was out and spoke with the person doing the safety survey. Personally, his words to me were, it's not going to happen. They need 40 more feet for safety minimum. It's my understanding that a lot of trees are going to be taken out if this project goes through. The neighborhood really does not.
1:52:51 Want this. Why? If you pull the map back up, the 23-24 Winter Transit map, you'll notice that this is an awkward intersection. Mill Street comes down. There's a significant curve on Old Mammoth, which is known to anyone who spends any time in the neighborhood to be a dangerous spot to cross.
1:53:19 People gain speed. It's quite a steep slope coming down. I don't see where this safety concern is being addressed. Last year, when we were talking about this, we had, and somebody may have the exact number, but it was over 200. I think it was close to 300 signatures, not only people in Old Mammoth, but people who understand the safety concerns that we had with this location.
1:53:50 And to revisit yesterday, I'm out walking my dogs, and there's grating going on. They were pulling up asphalt. And so I went into the town offices, and I asked if there had been a permit pulled for this. And I was given about four different answers before this very official document was given to me, supposedly the permit for them to be working yesterday.
1:54:20 I have to support what has been said about the neighborhood feeling very disrespected in this whole process. It's been non-transparent. The letters that were sent out, some of them were received yesterday or the day before. One of our neighbors mentioned that they were on vacation until the end of the month and their mail was being held.
1:54:50 We feel excluded from this great concern. Number one, safety. I mean, certainly, and I do have the question of, you know, where does the liability go when the accident happens? Because it's not going to be if, it's when. Anyone who's driven down or ridden a bike down that area knows, right? Also, I've been in the neighborhood long enough to remember the pre-existing service that we had.
1:55:17 Where my child, who was a young school-age elementary school at that time, came home on numerous occasions crying that she was cold because she had been waiting for the bus for over an hour. So this limited service and at that time wasn't running on time, it really isn't going to encourage people to utilize the service if you're standing out.
1:55:45 In freezing temperatures, and especially for kids. Snow removal. I'm not sure if any of you all, I know one of you is an old mammoth, but are out there. Last season at the 1800 block on Old Mammoth Road, which is a little closer to town than Tamarack, that point was one and a quarter lane for over a six-month period. And if buses had been running at that time,
1:56:18 Certainly this increases the danger, especially for a pedestrian, of being hit. I'm really discouraged of the snow removal that we had last season. There were days when we had no snow removal from town on our street. At one point it was 36 hours. So running buses with the berms, which were so high they were knocking off.
1:56:48 The street signs, which many of them have been missing, again, over six months. We did not have a street sign on Woodman for over six months, and they have misspelled the, or it's inconsistent. The snow removal is real serious, and it's a real concern. We would appreciate transparency and safety, and is there a permit for them to?
1:57:15 Be removing asphalt and grading. And I was told by the operator yesterday that the trees were coming down today. So another question is, how many trees? And are those trees also on the upper south side of Old Mammoth? Thank you. Great questions there, and I'm sure Hayes. The town will take note of those questions, and we'll follow up with communications about trees and snow removal and things like that. Yes, sir? Let's echo the sentiments of John and Tracy.
1:57:47 I have the most to lose. Our family's been there since 1959. We're adjacent to the property. I feel through the whole process we have been disrespected. We've been kept in the dark. We officially never got a letter from the very beginning, and we're adjacent, not even from the very beginning. We were accused of falsifying the 300 signatures we had, and I'm not going to say who on the city council had said that because I don't believe in calling people out personally like that. That was extremely disrespectful. That was number one.
1:58:17 The letter that was received from Dan Holler had gross errors in it, but the city of Mammoth already took over from the Water District via grant deed on July 2nd, the property. So you basically said that we're going to move forward with this without even council approval. You guys negotiated with ESSA behind closed doors and the Water District to have that, to get that. That's like, there's a lot of bravado there.
1:58:44 And that's another form of disrespect. And we all know that's dangerous. I've been coming here since 1970 when I was born. I might have been conceived in that cabin. My parents are, my dad's dead, but my mom does not know. So that's an interesting thing. But I think someone has a large ego who designed this project. And I think that we need to put that ego aside and really listen to the people.
1:59:13 Who live in the area? Because this area is where my childhood happened. It all happened there. And the Dan Holler letter was like seven days before. And then I finally got it six days before. It's like, what are we supposed to drop everything if we live out of town and come up here? And then the authorization, who authorized this? Was it the city council? I mean, is this leadership? The leadership of the council is being run by an engineer?
1:59:41 And the city manager, don't you guys want to know the liability of this? Doesn't Chadmar want to know the liability of this? There is so much liability here. Like Tracy said, I mean, I've all been craned by my bike there. I used to hitchhike from that point to the mountain. You know, is there really this much need in that area for a bus? I understand Aspen Village is truly important because there are a lot of workers on the mountain, but north of that, it's mostly locals, you know.
2:00:09 Hey, it'd be great to take the bus. I might even take the bus. I hitchhiked when I was a kid, you know, if there was that much snow. And that's the honest truth. I was in the back of a Subaru brat with, you know, with safety belts. There were bucket seats in the back of a brat. I would get picked up all the time and go to the Mammoth. I used to turn the lights on at the main lodge.
2:00:28 For years. I've raced NASTAR since I was six years old. And this is just so upsetting to us. I'm like, I'm so emotional about it. It was really even hard to come today. You know, none of us were ever contacted. And then it gets punted from the city council back. I'm assuming it got punted back to the engineers, the Haislip and the city manager. It got punted back to them. They shouldn't have to deal with this. It should not go through. It really shouldn't. It's dangerous. The safety stuff, even...
2:00:57 Per a phone call, he said, Sauser said that the 175 easement for the snow is dangerous. I'm paraphrasing, but he even admitted it. It's like, you want that liability? I wouldn't from a safety standpoint. I mean, does that go back to Chadmar? Is Chadmar liable for this? Is the city liable for this? You know, is it going to be approved by you guys? What is going to happen? What's the process? Is it ministerial?
2:01:26 I don't know. Is it ministerial? It is ministerial. And why is it ministerial? You can explain it? Yes, please. Go ahead. Yeah, why don't you finish your comment, Daniel? It's ministerial, and that's the other part. And then why wasn't the original turnaround, which was negotiated with Snow Creek at that place? Why wasn't that? Well, was it because the new 13 more units got built, and then it got punted up the street to us?
2:01:58 We're, you know, I'd like to live in a million-dollar condo and not have a turnaround near me, but, like, there is no respect to the old guard here. You know, there really isn't. It's just like, are we a town of corporate influence from developers? You know, it's crazy. Let's get back to some old-school values where you actually listen to people and not, you know, say, hey, it's going through, it's authorized.
2:02:26 I mean, if I was the city council, I'd be mad if it was punted back. You know, I mean, I'd be pissed. Dan shouldn't have to deal with this. It's just not right, and we're against it. And we're going to do everything in our power legally to move forward with this. And like, and I understand, you know, why can't you repave the racket club for $200,000? And it's not going to be that much, let's be honest. I mean, ice rink number, are these ice rink numbers where it was supposed to be $400,000, then it was a million?
2:02:55 Et cetera, et cetera. It just goes on and on. Understood. Thank you very much. Thanks for coming. I appreciate it. So, ma'am, real quick, before you get up, Hayes, you want to speak to the ministerial? Okay, we can do that. Fine. So, there will be a response from the town about this ministerial action that's going to be coming up. So, please, ma'am. Well, hi there. I'm Ann Gimble. I live at 64 Mill Street. And usually I would have prepared comments, but I really didn't have a chance because I just got your letter two days ago.
2:03:29 I worked as a department head running government mental health and alcohol drug programs for the better part of 30 years. So I have some understanding of how government is supposed to work. If there's an environmental impact statement, I don't think any of us have seen it. And when we visited this about a year ago,
2:03:56 We did have a lot of signatures, and my understanding was if this came back up again as a topic that we would be consulted beforehand, not after the fact where there's a done deal. I passed your crane on my way driving down here. It doesn't exactly engender faith that you care what your constituents think. And in terms of safety,
2:04:29 I can't tell you how many times. I've come down Mill Street. I've stopped at the stop sign on Woodland. I've looked over my shoulder, and I haven't seen anything. So I pull out, and suddenly there's a car that's right on my bumper. There is a curve in Old Mammoth Road that impedes visibility, and that is going to be a big, fat problem for your buses, for traffic coming down Mill Street, for traffic on Woodland. I'm done.
2:04:58 Thank you. Okay, anybody else? Anything? Excuse me? Okay, please. Yeah. So, Hais, I think we got the ministerial question and maybe the environmental one. Charlotte, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, thank you. Can you hear me okay? Yes, we can hear just fine. Thank you. Okay, thank you. My name is Charlotte Kaufman, and I'm here today to voice my support for the bus turnaround on Woodman. Some of my neighbors are saying they want you to listen.
2:05:36 To the neighbors, so please listen to me because I support the turnaround. I live on Mill Street in Old Mammoth and I actually live there. I'm not a second homeowner like so many people in Old Mammoth are. The turnaround will be just a few houses down from me at the bottom of our street. We have two daughters in the Mammoth school system. Both are in sports. Because of their school and sports schedules, it would have been very convenient for them to take the bus to school and home last year.
2:06:03 However, once the old Mammoth bus stop was moved to Ranch Road, we found the stop to be too dangerous and too far for them to use. We experienced the biggest winter on record and pedestrians are forced to cross the street and walk alongside huge snow berms and snowy icing conditions to get to that stop. We were lucky because we have the job flexibility and economic means to keep transporting our kids via car, but not everyone has those means.
2:06:29 While this bus turnaround would be a huge improvement to quality of life for our own family, it will also be a boon for our less advantaged neighbors who don't have cars or who rely on public transportation. The letter that was sent out on this subject mentioned using the smaller bus with a reduced schedule. Please do not do limited service. Please do regular service. I would urge the council to consider a regular-sized bus.
2:06:56 Or at least a regular-sized bus during the morning and afternoon school rush so students can easily get to and from school. You may have heard from some of my neighbors who purport to care about both the environment and social justice, but that support seems to have stopped when it comes to a bus turnaround in their own backyard. I would urge those opposed to think about others in their community and how beneficial this turnaround will be for us all. Thanks to the council for listening on this and thanks to ESTA and the Public Works Department.
2:07:24 for looking into this issue and providing a solution for all families. Thank you. Thank you very much, Charlotte. Okay, next. Eric Kaufman, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Jennifer Kreitz, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, good evening. Thank you for your opportunity to speak. I just, I have a question to address. I was looking at the teal line.
2:08:05 And it looks like it goes up to the intersection of Lake Mary and Minaret, but does it go around the village or like where does it turn around wondering if it drops people at the village? And then I just want to say I appreciate people's comments thinking about the working class folks that live full-time in Old Mammoth and, you know, just the greater good. Thank you. That's all. Thank you. Jennifer, Supervisor Crates will record your question and respond to that at the end.
2:08:35 Anybody else? Anna Maria, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, thank you. Good evening, Mayor Wentworth and the Town Council, and thank you for hearing public comments. We had thought the Woodman turnaround was off the table after the nearly unanimous public outcry that included over 300 signatures collected in opposition of the proposal.
2:08:59 Old Mammoth residents rightly questioned the so-called Woodman solution due to excessive noise and light pollution, disruption of our historic residential neighborhood, environmental impact, and traffic safety issues. In addition, there's very little demand for extending the bus line into Old Mammoth. Not only is the extension trivial in distance at a little over half a mile, but the defunct gray line was canceled due to lack of ridership.
2:09:27 When I wrote the Town Council a year ago, April, about my concerns, then Mayor Linda Salcido wrote back, quote, thank you for your thoughtful letter. Town staff have been directed to continue to search for a site that would be agreeable to everyone. The process is slowly moving along and hopefully there will be more talk about.
2:09:46 More to talk about soon. She continued, I appreciate your reaching out. The more counsel hears from the community, the better we can represent the best interests of our residents. So I asked, what happened? We never heard from anyone since then, either on the counsel or town staff until Mr. Holler's letter dated October 10th, which presented the turnaround at Woodman as a done deal.
2:10:10 Just today, as John mentioned, we've also learned that there was a potential agreement with Snow Creek that was recently turned down because of snow removal and a maintenance clause. So there are other options that can help service Aspen Village and schoolchildren. Making Woodman Safe, based on the safety survey, which was shared with us on Monday,
2:10:33 As John mentioned, requires 175 feet of snowbank clearance in both directions from Woodman, an impossible task in the best of years. The lack of transparency in this entire process has been truly mind-boggling. Among other issues, we still don't know why the original Chadmar Snow Creek site east of the fire station was never pursued. Obviously, it is feasible in terms of engineering because that is the plan approved by the Town Council when Snow Creek 7 Agreement was made.
2:11:03 Why did the Town Council persist in pursuing Woodman over the original Chadmar plan, given the massive community opposition to Woodman? Was it a sham agreement that was never intended to be implemented? We are left to speculate, since there has been no open dialogue or discussion. Numerous people have articulated that we would like to be part of the solution and work with the Council for a solution that, as Mayor Salcido said in her email, would be agreeable to everyone.
2:11:33 Yet the current town staff has pursued a course of action behind closed doors that thumbs their collective noses at the concerns of over 300 residents of Mammoth Lakes. Mayor Wentworth and town council members, I urge you to stop the current plan of action and work with us to find a solution that would be agreeable to everyone and represent the best interests of all the residents of Mammoth Lake. In conclusion, I hope today is not about...
2:12:00 Taking one on the chin in listening while we voice our concerns, but rather taking our concerns to heart, hearing our voices, and moving forward to find a solution together. Thank you. Mark Dutko, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Okay, can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you. Quick story, I'll make it fast. I live, we own the property adjacent to the stop and...
2:12:32 Since the 1950s, my family's been an integral part of the Old Mammoth community. We have a deep-rooted history here, and it's a history shared by many in our neighborhood. Old Mammoth is more than just a place. It's a legacy, a way of life, and a haven for all of us who call it home. My father, an avid skier, used to conquer Mammoth Mountain on snowshoes for his daily run. It was here he met a fellow adventurer named Dave McCoy, a name many of you may recognize.
2:12:56 One day, my father and Dave were at our cabin sharing drinks and stories. Dave leaned over and whispered, this is the best margarita north of Mexico, a testament to the quality of Old Mammoth and the friendships that form here. Old Mammoth is a unique and historic place, a place that my family, my grandmother, my father, my brothers, nieces, nephews, and hundreds of our friends have called home for the better part of their lives. We've organized community events that maintain a safe, quiet, rural setting where good choices and mutual respect were our guiding principles.
2:13:26 Yes, things have changed over the years, but our core values and needs remain the same. We are the ones who live here, who breathe life into this community, yet we now find ourselves in the midst of discussions about a town project that seems far removed from our necessities and the community's needs. This project appears to cater to the wishes of a select few and for reasons that we must scrutinize. Since the Water Department leveled the trees and plowed the snow from the site next to our cabin, we witnessed broken windows.
2:13:53 Noise, trash, barren lot, promises of replanting trees remain unfulfilled, and water department drain the water from the land, killing the aspens and other vegetation for great distances. Dan Holler tells us that our needs have been addressed, but that couldn't be farther from the truth. Our needs have been disregarded and shaped by the town's objectives and agenda. Our cabin is a mere five feet from the bus turnaround, and not once have we been contacted about it. How does it make sense for snowplows to work in the dead of night?
2:14:21 With buses empty and senseless, imagine someone removes your home from a quiet residential area and tells you there will be a bus turnaround on that property. Not on the street, not somewhere that makes sense, but on your property right there, a place that you expected to be a residence. This is a solution that no one requested or desired. Would you vote for such a project at your residence?
2:14:44 The town, unfortunately, has deceived us. They've obstructed information, offered last-minute notices, and limited public participation. When we gathered 300 signatures on a petition, one town leader implied we were coercing residents or astroturfing. Is this the behavior of a public servant? Shouldn't a small town be in tune with the residents than a bustling city or more? Mammoth Lakes is our home, but it increasingly feels like Hoboken, New Jersey. Many residents are delusioned.
2:15:11 And rightly so. The town is aware of this, and yet it persists in neglecting and evading the reality that we are the residents and we deserve better. No one here is against public transit when it's logical and serves the community. What we are against is being forced into an impractical, illogical, and financially irresponsible solution. Moreover, safety concerns loom large, potentially leading to future litigation, accidents of all types.
2:15:36 Old Mammoth residents are deeply concerned about these factors, far more than the minority who are pushing for this senseless solution driven by questionable motives. The town even declined a viable alternative and including town leaders that kept us in the dark, including land ownership. These questions and others will no longer be left unanswered as the past cannot be our guide. The town council must engage in a genuine dialogue with the community rather than offering rushed five minute slots.
2:16:04 Thank you very much. Stacey Corliss, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good evening, Mayor Wentworth and Councilmembers.
2:16:38 I'm not here to speak for or against any transit options tonight, but I just want to express as a former county supervisor who's been involved in this transit issue for about seven years, my profound disappointment in the way this item was handled tonight. To not provide any type of a staff report or maps or any information to the public on pretty big transit changes is really honestly shameful from a public engagement perspective.
2:17:07 I feel like we all could do a lot better. So I urge you to fix that. There's a cure for that. Publish maps, hold another discussion session, and give some more information. For instance, my question, you know, I saw the letter that was sent from Town Manager Holler, which I appreciate the communication to interested parties about this discussion tonight.
2:17:35 It mentioned using shorter cutaway buses, but it didn't mention something that was displayed on the map tonight and in subsequent email communication that the night trolley will run. So does that mean Estes going to run trolleys till 2 a.m. into this neighborhood? Well, I know that the night trolley ends earlier on certain parts of the route. You know, what does that really look like? And, you know, what's the plan there? And then really what happens next?
2:18:05 Um, town staff will, or SDA staff will provide, um, you know, kind of a clear path forward. Is there, will there be any other discussion or, or is this it? Um, you know, I'd appreciate some kind of update from the town. And I also hope, uh, you know, I've said this before in transit meetings that, that are, that our town could consider transit solutions that are far less divisive and, um,
2:18:33 Perhaps more efficient, such as microtransit. But in the short term, help us through what happens next. And please, let's have better communication, put some things in writing, give people something to respond to. Thank you. Jesse, please unmute yourself and give your comments. All right. Can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you just fine. Great. I actually had a very similar comment. My mom lives on Cliff Circle. I remember riding my bike to high school from Evergreen.
2:19:08 Would have liked to hop on a bus, but seems like this topic has got a lot of opinions and was not noticed adequately or conveyed adequately to people who are going to be impacted by it. So I really hope there can be some type of continuance of this hearing, whatever it is, whatever decision is or isn't going to be made, but give the
2:19:34 People an opportunity to meet with ESTA and look at the documents and provide input and maybe provide some input to be implemented. It kind of seems like a sham hearing if there's tractors out there right, you know, days ago and we're talking about it now. So again, hoping that you guys can continue this.
2:20:00 And in the meantime, schedule a workshop with the ESTA to present the topics to people who have interest in it and give them a chance to understand and provide comment. And if the city attorney is there, if they can comment on what qualifies for legal requirements for noticing and to see if this did so, the ESTA representative cited that this does need to go to hearing. But again, I believe there's requirements.
2:20:28 for qualifications for hearings, and this doesn't seem to abide by it. The location just does seem kind of silly, seems very dangerous, and I'm pretty scared that someone's going to get hurt flying down on a bike too fast or something, so that'll be really a bummer if that happens, but my primary request is that this is continued and that the residents have a chance to meet with
2:20:56 I just want to be completely clear. I've known a lot of the speakers tonight that gave comments.
2:21:32 Public comment for quite a long time and all of us are extremely in favor of access to public transportation. We know how important it is, especially in a resort community where you don't want the streets to be gridlocked with vehicles and drivers who may not necessarily know how to drive under those conditions. What I'd like to go back to is the data.
2:21:58 That ESTA has provided to us over the years currently and in 2017 when they attempted to run the bus up to Red Fur Road, which is that the need exists in the area around Aspen Village, the ski trails and the apartment buildings on the south side of Old Mammoth Road that are across from Aspen Village. That's where the majority of workforce housing is. And I did hear tonight about about school children and I do see that.
2:22:27 But the majority of the need is located in one spot. So our request, or at least my request, going back to the beginning here in 2017, is let's put the turnaround where the need is. And again, the answers that we've gotten back from town staff, you know, about viability and not wanting to put turnarounds on private property, we've done it before.
2:22:55 I just think that until there's a demand in Old Mammoth, and we've continually shown that there's not. I remember John Helm couldn't even put
2:23:25 A piece of data on the slide because literally zero people rode the bus west of Aspen Village. So I reached out to John Eastman yesterday because I was at my wit's end and I've stopped crying. But I talked to John for a long time and I talked to him about, you know, why people choose to live in Old Mammoth.
2:23:47 We all have chosen to live in Old Mammoth for the same reasons. We're not looking to be near services or streetlights or gondolas flying over our heads or buses going up and down the streets and people with skis and snowboards in our front yards. We've chosen that lifestyle because it appeals to us for the tranquility, for...
2:24:08 Just the general quietness. You feel like you're in the woods, which isn't how you feel anymore in Mammoth. And it's wonderful to go into town and attend the events and see the fireworks. But I thank God every time I'm driving back to my own house to get out of that. With that said, like a couple of other people I'm interested, Town Manager Holler's letter mentioned smaller buses and reduced routes. But again, I know that the night trolley runs.
2:24:37 Until 2 a.m. And I don't think it's appropriate to run buses from 6 a.m. to 2 a.m. in a residential neighborhood in Old Mammoth like Woodman. It's a complete waste. Those buses will be empty. And I just don't think it's a good use of anyone's time or anyone's money. Thank you. Thank you very much. I appreciate hearing these comments. We're maybe getting a little bit repetitive. We've heard a lot of the same things. We're hearing them. We appreciate that. So I think for the future comments, if...
2:25:10 If you have something new to add, welcome. We want to hear if it's been said, perhaps say it's been stated eloquently, and thank you. Anybody else? Just an email. Okay. Wesley Pratch says, I lived at Mammoth for 10 years and rode the bus for eight of those years. I never used the bus when I lived on Mill Street because it was inaccessible and dangerous to walk all the way to Snow Creek. I support the bus turnaround.
2:25:35 It will make the area safer as the town will have to do better snow removal for a better line of sight and will be an environmental win for the area with shared public transportation. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so Hayes, Esther, we have some questions here. And again, the council, we're in a little bit of a difficult position because obviously we're not being asked to take any action this evening. This is coming from Esther, it's coming from the town. So you've heard the questions and perhaps you can provide some responses. Yeah, a lot of ground to cover here, John.
2:26:03 But you started off exactly where I wanted to start. This is the beginning of a process. You know, that's why there is no action tonight. We were looking for a roaring thumbs up as to what we're doing and, hey, proceed. But there was no action, right? And the notices went out to notify everybody that we were starting this process and having these conversations. You could make a decision tonight if you were so inclined, but you don't have to. And you could give us, tell us to come back later. So all of that's on the table.
2:26:32 The accusations that we haven't been talking to them, well, Dan's letter was, let them know we're having this conversation. There's also, this may be difficult to articulate, so I'll do my best and please ask any questions. It was no secret that Snow Creek 7 was looking for an opportunity to build a turnaround, and I'm not going to debate the engineering of some of the previous proposals, and none of that had previously been approved through town council.
2:27:02 But they came forward, got all the permission from the Water District, and applied for a grading permit to do this work. It does not mean we have to use it, but they have permission to construct to meet their condition of approval. The town attorney was involved in putting together those agreements to ensure that they met their condition, because they are looking to close out their project and need to build a turnaround to meet that condition. So that's how that came forward, and that is a ministerial action. The permit comes forward. It's no different than your neighbor paving their driveway.
2:27:32 We go through that process. We look at that. If they met all the conditions, they get their permit. There was a question about the teal line and the village. It does loop the village, so it follows the same pattern as the purple line and the red line and so forth. What else would you like me to address? The status of the environmental document. Oh, that was a categorical exemption. Under CEQA. Under CEQA. Okay. What's next? You tell me.
2:28:04 Can I ask you? Hang on, ma'am, please. Thank you. Okay, so I'm going to turn to council members for questions and any thoughts you guys have on this, and then we'll come to that question of what's next. We'll come to that after that. So, Bill, you had a phone here. First quick question. We've heard tonight several times a mention of a safety study that said we would have to remove snow berms 170 feet in the east and west. However, if I read that correctly, if we used any other newly built
2:28:34 Station along Old Mammoth Road where there are going to be big berms. The suggestion would always be to remove those berms 170 feet in both directions. It is not unique to this location. Your thought? I would agree with that. That is systemic within town. When we have large snow berms, it's no different than Canyon Boulevard or the Noles. We have heard several times tonight. First, I have spent more time on this than almost any other thing I've had to deal with on council.
2:29:02 We've heard over and over that we simply are not looking at other alternatives. Have we looked at other alternatives? We have looked at every alternative presented and every alternative we could come up with. And I have done that with you on many occasions. So there are things there that simply aren't correct. I'm assuming you're going to be allowing us some comments later. Yeah. So those are my questions so people understand what is being asked at this site would have to occur from those people on any other site as well.
2:29:36 Okay, any other questions for staff? Okay, so let's move on to comments. Why don't you go ahead. Okay. Yep. I dropped my son off at ski trails every morning last winter, every weekday morning, and I watched people every morning walk to and wait at that dangerous stop, and I am so ashamed that we allowed that to happen to the most disadvantaged people in this town who so rarely have a voice.
2:30:11 And who certainly can't fly in from Aspen to attend a public meeting. And anyone with a shred of human decency should be ashamed as well. As for the options proposed by the opponents of this turnaround, I cannot speak to their viability, but I trust our public works director and I trust that he chose the right solution. The thinking that this is a personal attack upon you as a resident of Old Mammoth.
2:30:36 Due to someone's large ego who wants to push this project through is, I just, I can't think of any other term but narcissism. The language around this turnaround is so hyperbolic. I am in shock. What an outrage. I am so emotional about this. Children and hospitals are being bombed in this world right now. We all need to get a grip. We all need to think about how fortunate we are that these are the issues we are outraged about.
2:31:03 And thank our lucky stars that this is an issue that is worthy of tears. Please, please, let the council members speak. Thank you. We should thank our lucky stars that this is an issue that is worthy of tears. I'm done discussing this. Thank you. Amanda? Nothing? Chris? I live in Old Mammoth. I'm not going to dox myself, but I live close enough to this that...
2:31:38 I've thought about it a lot. I'm on the board of Vesta. I totally respect Phil and the work he does. We are so blessed with a public transit system that's free. It makes it easier for our visitors. It makes it a little bit easier for our workers. But I do have to say that one of my comments is we need to build a...
2:32:00 Safe shelter at stop two at Ranch Road as soon as humanly possible. And so I would like to make sure that gets on the record. Look, nothing's easy in this town. We live here because we love it. But the truth of the matter is that we're a community and we have to stick together. And I think it's.
2:32:21 It's imperative that we find a place to make it possible for the folks who live, particularly in Aspen Village, but other folks in Old Mammoth, they have a place to get on the bus. It's also not fair that people in Old Mammoth don't have access to our free public transit. So I think before we get so emotional about this, we need to take a step back. We need to look at the options.
2:32:50 Thank you so much.
2:33:18 Bigger things to address as a community. And let's get to those. I mean, that's all I had to say. Thank you. So this is something that I've been dealing with for a long time. Every time somebody has come up with a potential solution, I have gone out. If I couldn't make a determination on my own, I have taken Hayes, I have taken Phil, I have taken John Eastman, or he has taken me to show me potential places.
2:33:51 The Woodman Turnaround, in my opinion, and my opinion is based on a lot of things, 65 years in Mammoth, 40 years doing snow removal. I've been in the construction business. I know a bit about safety. The Woodman Turnaround is the only and the safest place to turn a bus around in Old Mammoth. Do I wish there was another solution? I do. Have we all looked for other solutions? Yes, we have. To be told we haven't because we disagree with you is hurtful for me.
2:34:21 To say I don't listen to you because I disagree with you is hurtful to me. There are reasons and knowledge and a lot of effort that go into this. I wish there was a better solution. I do not see a better solution. I believe the people not only in Aspen Village and in ski trails, but also in that entire south front that somebody else spoke about that is rentals and apartments and workforce.
2:34:50 I feel almost attacked. So that's all I will say.
2:35:22 Thank you. Thank you. So I'm going to close this out by trying to get a little bit boring. I concur with what we've heard up here. I've been visited the sites. There's nothing else. And for the folks in Old Mammoth, I really appreciate your concerns. I hear them. I understand them. This is not really about Old Mammoth.
2:35:50 It's about the whole rest of the community because as Phil laid out these lines, these are lines and buses that are going all the way through the community and they've got to have a place to turn around. There's no other place to do it. So I do want to say that the public component of this, because it is a ministerial action, it doesn't fall under the normal process that the council would take or the committee would take.
2:36:19 So I'm keenly aware of the frustration. I hear it. I understand it completely. It's not enviable for anybody. But I think the consensus from the council here is to ask the question, if this moves forward, what is next? John, there was one other question asked about whether this was noticeably legal to be a public hearing. Sure. And I would love to get Andy's opinion on that. Thank you. Public hearing was conducted under the requirements of the transit rules that apply to ESTA, not anything that applies to the town.
2:36:54 So as I sit here, I don't actually know what the notice requirements were because it's not our hearing exactly. Okay. Bill? Yes, thank you. Yeah, public hearings, like I had mentioned before, are required when a certain percentage of a route is affected. And this definitely tripped that trigger. We have our own charter and rules as a public transit organization. And we just chose this venue because, look, it's the best one. I mean, I could have had it at the pizza joint and nobody shows up.
2:37:24 This was perfect. And so I came to take my lumps and listen to the ideas. I can tell you that it's not always like this. These public hearings often bring good solutions from the public. We often get good ideas and we make changes and we listen. But we've been doing this for years and I think we've heard it all. I don't think there's anything new that I've heard tonight. So, yeah, it's the best solution for us and we had to have a hearing. Okay, thank you.
2:37:53 I mean, you say we had to, ESTA had to have you. Sierra Transit, yeah, needed to have this, and this was the best venue for it. Okay, good. So, what is next at this point? Honestly, that's up to you guys. If you're comfortable giving us direction to move forward, we'll start to implement these routes. We've got some tweaks we need to do to some of the signage and the stops and so forth. It's not 100% vague, but the concepts are sound. If you want us to move forward, we will. If you want us to have follow-up meetings, we can.
2:38:22 The question is to you. Okay, so Bill, you have a question? Yeah, what I would like to see come back, Phil and Hayes both, is to look at what hours of the night trolley we're actually looking at for that route so that we can answer that question and see how we can negate the headlight issue and some of that to some extent. Okay, thank you. Yes. Okay, I think I will sort of speak for the council. I think the consensus is to move forward.
2:38:52 And I think with any caveats that we have here, I think our assumption is that the footprint of this turnaround is going to be as minimal as possible. It will be designed to maximize safety. We talked about things about a mirror so that people coming out of Woodman can see what's happening on the traffic coming both ways on Old Mammoth Road. But unless I'm mishearing things, I think the consensus from all of us is to move forward. Yes. Okay. Yes. Nodding heads. Okay, good.
2:39:23 Thank you very much. We apologize for the difficult nature of this topic, but I think it's the contents of the council to move forward. One time? Yeah. So thank you all. We're going to take a little break. Just get ready. We're going to take a little break. Rob, I have a question for you. The FAQ that you sent out earlier this week on this next agenda item, did you print copies of that? Okay, good. So while we take a couple minutes, just get ready for the next item. There's some FAQs on the back.
2:39:53 I think it would be very helpful when we have our next discussion about potential moratorium. Thank you all. We'll come back here at 6. Don't let me break my mallet. Okay. Ladies and gentlemen, for the main event. Okay. If you could all please take your seats. I'm looking for Mr. Sauser. Is he in the left? Oh, here he comes. Okay. All right. Ladies and gentlemen. Ladies and gentlemen.
2:56:10 Bill, please join us. Thank you. Okay. Okay. Please, if you have conversations, you can take them out in the hall. We can move on to the next item now. Okay. We're moving on now to item 10.2, short-term rental program review in consideration of an urgency ordinance for temporary moratorium on the issuance of transient occupancy registration certificates. Mr. Holler.
2:56:41 Thank you. I'll kick it off and then I'll turn it over to Rob Patterson for some additional information to work through this. The items coming before you based on discussions we've had over short-term rentals on a number of areas looking at, we'll touch on some issues related to quality of life and ongoing work in that area. Also, in the last couple of housing discussions, one of the questions has come up a couple times is the impact of short-term rentals, which is not fully known. We're looking to get better data on that.
2:57:10 We've also had questions in terms of pausing the issuance of new permits, not impacting any existing permits. We'll walk through that a little bit, what that means. So we actually have time to look at this and not look at it in an era of, I've got to do something quickly. We know when we put this out, we've had well over, I think, well over 60 new permits come in. So if it extends out, we expect quite a few more as well as we begin to look at this.
2:57:39 I don't know as if there's much debate over the challenges on housing in our community and the things we're looking at and a lot of the work the town's done investment-wise and some of the other challenges that we see there. We hear that pretty regular from employees. We hear it from businesses. We face it with our own employees, as does other public agencies we're aware of, of attracting quality employees and getting them here and actually having a place to live. So we're not looking at this as a panacea for defects.
2:58:09 Potentially leads us in some decision-making that could assist that if it goes forward. The item before you is twofold is some direction related to the ongoing work we're looking at in what we call a Certified Properties Program. Secondly, looking at the potential for an urgency ordinance that would limit the issuance of any new TOT certificates. It does not impact anybody who currently has one. We'll speak to it later, too. We do have a...
2:58:39 Proposed amendment that would exclude properties that are in escrow or give them additional 60 days in order to secure a permit. So there's a timeline for that to address that issue. A number of other things have come up. We'll try to touch on those as we walk through. Rob will spend some time, walk through some of the details for that. We were going to spend a lot of time on the housing piece. We can speak to the details that are in the staff report as need be. We don't want to run down, I guess, a red herring in one sense of arguing over it.
2:59:09 $10,000 or $20,000 or $30,000 difference depending what year you're looking at at this point. Those types of issues in there, we can definitely have that discussion as needed. I think we're really looking at the other thing that we're asking at the end of this, almost regardless whether you approve to adopt the urgency ordinance or not, we would like to set up a community group to actually sit down and look at this, have input from the community that we can work through and look at are there any legitimate reasonable
2:59:41 Limits or changes that we want to see considered at a future meeting. So let me pause with that. I'll turn over to Rob and have him walk through a little more of the staff report side of it and then be glad to address questions from council. And obviously we have a number of people here to speak on this as well. So thank you. Thank you very much. Mr. Patterson. Thank you. So Dan did kind of cover a lot of the items I was hoping to cover myself just from the standpoint of.
3:00:08 Being respectful of all the people that have come here for public comment tonight. As you read in the staff report, we put a great deal of time and effort into how that staff report lays out some of the reasons behind things, some of the updates. As I have sort of read a lot of letters coming in on the last couple of days, I wanted to address a few things just to make some clarifying points. First and foremost, we are not proposing to ban short-term rentals in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
3:00:37 I have read hundreds of letters that have said we're banning short-term rentals. I'm not sure where that information may have come from or whether they may have not necessarily read the staff report, but perhaps provided some information and they responded to that. What I did want to clarify, and we did, my office put out a letter to all operators in town. That was the frequently asked questions.
3:01:03 Just clarifying those points, and I'll walk through them briefly here. I talked about not being a ban on short-term rentals in the town of Mammoth Lakes. It also does not affect, if you're operating with a licensed legal business right now, it will not affect you. And as far as the renewals, so we're coming up on renewal season, there'll be no impact on the renewals for 24 or 25 if we...
3:01:31 Do happen to have the moratorium in place that far, which we don't plan to, but it depends on how we go through the process. And we just added this comment about the escrow. So the way we worded it, and I'll read through that here shortly, if you're in escrow currently, in any zone that is permitted for short-term rentals, and you can then submit an application within 60 days of closing that transaction.
3:02:01 And that application will go through normal processes as long as it's in the permitted zone. What the moratorium would address is it would prohibit the issuance of new BCCs, which is the term that we use within my office is business tax certificates. This is the business license for operating a short-term rental in the zones outside of resort, North Village specific and Clearwater specific plans.
3:02:29 Those three are excluded from the moratorium as it's written. But if you're seeking a new operator permit outside of those zones, that would be covered by the moratorium. Some questions that came up, too, about people that may have a legitimate current rental, but it's with another operator, meaning it's with a lodging operator that services a lot of different...
3:02:59 So we recognize the town has a long history of short-term rentals. A lot of the lodging
3:03:29 Units in the areas that are in discussion were specifically built probably to support that. We're also keenly aware of the value of short-term rentals to our town. I've been here about seven and a half years prior to my arrival, just prior to my arrival, pushed through the quality of life ordinance, measure Z. That happened right before. That was one attempt to address short-term rentals.
3:03:57 Rental impacts, perhaps, more to the quality of life in the organization. We have a very robust enforcement group. We have a team of four that works on the enforcement of that activity. There was some letters going around about McGranicus host compliance component. We used to utilize host compliance. We worked very closely with the man who developed host. His name is Erlich Benzer.
3:04:26 And he wanted to come to town. He wanted to work with us because of the volume of activity we had and the amount of enforcement activity we performed. We contracted with them. We worked through them for several years. Once they sold to Granicus, we kind of moved on to Deckard Technologies Rentalscape. It's our current process. So we have a very, really good electronic tracking system. We know what's going on in town. There are still, I'm not saying we've got it all solved. There are still some issues with...
3:04:54 People underground, people trying to rent illegally. It's a very tough process when we come across that. And it's tough on them, it's tough on my team, but we get through it and the idea is leveling the playing field for all. My point in talking about these enforcement efforts is, you know, to address that this is a multifaceted approach. In this particular case, the moratorium and potential efforts that come from that is not a silver bullet.
3:05:23 It's not going to address the problem. It's not going to solve the problem. But it's an incremental step to move these things along. In any program we have with the town, there are times when you have to review those, make adjustments across time. You have either new technology, new understanding, things like that that come about. And that's essentially what we're doing here tonight. In that conclusion on that Granicus letter, it talked about, you know, it was focusing on all-out bans.
3:05:51 And saying instead of doing an all outbound, perhaps you should work on a legal framework that would be structured to support both short-term rentals and the community needs. So I believe that's what we're focusing on and trying to do. So what is in the staff report? I'm not going to go through that in great detail. There are a couple of key components. Number one is a hiring of an economist to do some study on our SDR impacts.
3:06:20 And we've already completed that. We haven't completed the study. We've contracted and got that process rolling. That same individual will be providing us some analysis on short-term language, short-term rental landscape and policy in similar jurisdictions. We went through some processes before where we go out and take a look at how other people are doing things. We've been in the business longer than most, so our processes are fairly robust, but people come in, they're creative, they have new ideas.
3:06:49 We implement what we can. This particular element will be drawing that in from a third party and bringing that process in. The most important component I want to talk about with the staff report is regarding the formation of a basically advisory committee. We put together that list of representatives. It's supposed to be broad. It's supposed to cover all aspects of the community from businesses.
3:07:20 I think there are some things missing on here, and we'll make some recommendations that we do adjust that. I think that's written in some of the recommendations, but later. But the idea is these folks will come together and discuss the impacts. They will bring points of view to each of those areas that are important to them, important to other people within the community, important to folks that are in the audience. These meetings are going to be public meetings. They are Brown Act meetings because they do involve
3:07:49 Several council, a few council members will be in part of that. They will be appointed, I believe, to that. And we would be seeking a broad breadth of folks that cover these various areas and have the ability to have that time commitment because it's going to take, these meetings are going to be a couple of hours long and there's probably going to be four to five of them, hopefully between now and in January, February timeframe. We don't want to draw this out. We want to get this resolved as quickly as possible.
3:08:18 That the input that comes in from this advisory committee will come to the town council. And town council will make some final determinations on what managing changes occur within STRs. And there will be changes that occur from this process. And I know people are concerned about that. The moratorium may not affect someone who's a current holder now, but the changes that come from this process could in long-term impact that. So I want to address that.
3:08:47 You know, be cognizant of that as well. So I hope that we all have good comments tonight. I think we've got good feedback and information. I'm not going to reiterate anything more other than I want to read, and I'll put it up on here for everybody to see the changes to the ordinance itself that we're recommending. And this is a red line version, so red line and blue.
3:09:19 That talks about that. So we added a recital as the Town Council recognizes some properties in Mammoth Lakes are in the process of being sold with escrows having been open prior to the adoption of the urgency ordinance that buyers and some such properties may have entered into contracts to purchase the properties intending to obtain a transient occupancy tax registration certificate and that buyers should be provided an opportunity to do so with notwithstanding the moratorium enacted by this urgency ordinance. In addition to that.
3:09:49 In section two, we modified it to provide the specifics. So, and I'll just read the blue parts, the edited parts of section two. This moratorium shall not prohibit the issuance of a new transient occupancy registration certificate for a dwelling unit that would be eligible to obtain such a certificate, absent the enactment of the moratorium. If a binding agreement for the purchase and sale of the dwelling unit was executed prior to
3:10:19 We also set a renewal for 2025 in the idea that this could be
3:10:50 Remain in effect still through that process. Would not prohibit the receipt of a renewal certificate if you were an existing operator. So that's the extent of what I wanted to present this evening. Again, the staff report provides a great deal of detail on that. Andy may have some additional items you may want to add. Questions? I do have just a few things. I haven't seen all the public comments, but I have seen some of them. And there were some wondering about what is this 45-day thing? What is a moratorium? Why are we doing this?
3:11:21 So California law says that cities and counties can adopt a moratorium, which is like a pause. A moratorium is a way of just freezing the status quo for a little bit of time while you figure out what you're going to do. And the statute that allows you to do this says it has to be some kind of land use proposal or regulation that you're going to study. And the 45 days come straight from the law. All moratoria are initially 45 days. After that, you can extend it once for up to 10 and a half months.
3:11:49 And then you can extend it one more time for a total of up to, well, the second one is up to a year, for a total of two years. As Rob said, I don't think anyone wants this to take two years. So there are a lot of ways that cities can regulate short-term rentals. For at least 30 years, California courts have recognized that cities can do just about anything up to and including banning them entirely, which nobody is talking about here. And I only mention that to point out that because the courts have said that you can completely ban them.
3:12:16 It follows then that cities can do just about anything short of completely banning them. And there are a lot of different ways that cities have chosen to regulate short-term rentals, and there's no one right solution. The solutions are kind of all over the map. In South Lake Tahoe, the voters said you can't have any outside the tourist court. In Santa Monica, it has to be only in someone's primary residence, and the resident has to be there at the time. Carmel has prohibited them for 30 years. In Truckee,
3:12:46 Which I have some familiarity with. They're still allowed everywhere, but they're subject to an overall cap. The Truckee Town Council decided they looked at how many do we have now? Great. Let's stick it at there. We're not going to do more than that ever. Then there's a waiting list. So you can do an aggregate cap. You can allow them in some areas. You can cap them in some areas. You can encourage them to be in other places. You can have a cooling off period after a property changes hands where people have to wait before they can get one. The point is there are a lot of different ways to do this.
3:13:16 Nobody knows what the right solution for Mammoth is at this point. We don't know the answer. We're not suggesting anything. We're not recommending anything to the town council. The whole point is to just freeze the status quo in place, allow people that are currently operating continue to do that, buy us a little bit of time to figure things out. The economist that Rob has hired is somebody that did, well, he donated his time to Truckee, and he was really, really good.
3:13:41 He's worked for other jurisdictions as well, including Placer County. The truck, he did go through this process a couple years ago. It was really hard. It was really divisive. The community was really, really concerned about it, really upset. I think where they ended up was pretty good. I lived it, and I'm about to live it again. But they also had a committee formed of stakeholders, and the lodging stakeholders in that committee, they were eloquent, and they were persuasive, and they got a lot of what they were asking for.
3:14:09 So I think that a committee, if done right, which I think this one would be, is great. I mean, hear the voices of the community, hear representatives of the lodging community, hear property managers, hear everybody. And after a lot of study and a lot of talk and a lot of pondering what makes the most sense for Mammoth, then maybe we can develop some recommendations. But it is really, really important to hear the voices of the people that are in this room and others. So that's just the background.
3:14:37 No answers tonight. No real decisions other than do you want to put a pause on things for a bit. And that's where the 45 days comes from. That's what a moratorium is. Okay. Please. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. So we'll start off some technical questions from counsel to staff. See if there's any questions people have. I hope you all got Rob's FAQ. I didn't get it. Do you have an extra copy of that somewhere? Just when you get a second because I couldn't. It wasn't printable on my printer.
3:15:08 Okay, so any questions from Council, Amanda? What's that? Okay, Rob, can you address that? If you have to make some more copies or something? Yeah, so if you're an operator in our system, we have constant contact email solutions. We're on to about 1,200 people. We had an 81% open rate. I can get people's contact information. I did print out about 20 to put them on the back there.
3:15:42 It's simply a letter that talks a little bit about what I presented just a few minutes ago about what it's not, essentially, because that's what I was seeing in the letters as folks were concerned. Rob, real quick, if someone could just go make maybe 20 more copies, we can hand them out to the audience. Yeah, we can do that. Yeah, they'll be helpful for the conversation, so we've got some, we all kind of know what we're talking about. Okay, while Dan's out, someone's out making copies. Any questions, Amanda, Sarah, for technical nature?
3:16:11 I guess, did you say we got 60 new applications in the last five days? The last time I looked, which was yesterday afternoon, we had 65 applications since Friday. Thanks. Questions? Technical? Yeah, go ahead. Thanks. So, Rob, I don't expect you to have this answer right now. I know we talked about it a little bit in the past, but I think it would be illuminating for us through this process.
3:16:44 To determine what percent of the TOT for the town comes just from RMF2. And again, I don't think you have that at your fingertips, but when I looked at the proposal for the consultant, I wanted to make sure that was in there. And if you have any illumination at all, please answer, but I don't want to put you on the spot. Yeah, Chris, I don't have the details in front of me right now. We have put together charts.
3:17:12 I know exactly what the revenue is by each complex in town. We've got that level of detail, and it would be very simple to add that other piece in there to provide that to you, but I don't have it in front of me.
3:17:29 Okay, because there were a lot of comments that this was going to really impact our TOT. And, you know, we just want to, you know, I work with facts and data. So we need to get as many facts and data for the public as possible. So we don't have, there's just a lot of misconceptions. The second question I have is for Andy. A lot of people have written in their public comment that this would take away their property rights. Can you comment on that? Sure. So the classic law school analogy of property rights is it's a bundle of sticks.
3:17:59 As a property owner, you can live in your property if it's residential, you can sell it, you can rent it, you can rent it short-term, you can rent it long-term, you can let your friends and family use it for free. And the courts have said in the specific context of regulating STRs that taking away someone's ability to short-term rent their property is not what's called a compensable taking. You can take away that one stick out of the bundle. It doesn't deprive a property owner of their other rights. Courts have said cities have the ability to do that.
3:18:28 Because people can still sell. They can still rent long-term. They can still use the property themselves. They could still let somebody occupy it for free, which is not maybe all that helpful. But the courts have said these are the things they can do. So it's not taking away anybody's rights in a way that is against the law. It's taking away one stick out of the bundle. OK, thanks. Another thing is that we're talking about this advisory committee.
3:18:55 Did receive some suggestions that why isn't the Planning Commission doing this work? So could you just illuminate, first of all, why it's council and, you know, not the planning and a committee and not the Planning Commission? And then secondly, would there be any conflict to place a member of our PEDC on this committee because it wasn't contemplated in the initial proposal? Well, I mean, procedurally, only the town council can adopt a moratorium.
3:19:27 The PEDC doesn't have the authority to do that. So this action that you're considering tonight is one that only you can take. If you were so inclined to appoint a PEDC member to that committee, you could. It's not a conflict. This is not the kind of decision where somebody participates early on and then can't participate later. This is a legislative decision, not a quasi-adjudicatory decision. You're engaged in the process of making law for the community.
3:19:58 We're not, but that's the kind of thing it is. So if you want to add a PEDC member, you sure could. I'd like to add to that as well. Through this process, there may be recommendations of zoning adjustments. That would go directly to the PEDC for review. So I think those are still available assets and resources for this process. Thank you. Those are all my questions. Okay, thank you. Bill, any questions? You know, my one question is about this whole procedure.
3:20:28 First, I will say there's a whole bunch of good stuff in this report and a whole lot of stuff that we need to be looking at. There is no question about that. What I question is, should we even have the ability to look at a moratorium on an emergency basis based on the fact that we don't have enough housing in town because I see no evidence showing that this would ever create more housing. So that is my question, Andy, for you.
3:20:59 The way that the moratorium works is it doesn't require you to have the answers at the time you adopt the moratorium. It only requires you to have identified an issue that you think you'd like to study. And that's what I think the findings do if you decide to adopt the findings. Thank you. Okay. Good. Okay. So let's show some respect. Thank you. Not just respect for Bill. Okay. So we are going to now let's go into public comment. Let's see what folks have to say. One observation. Hang on a second.
3:21:31 One observation. We want to thank you all for all of your communications and all of your ideas. And what you've heard from Rob and Dan here is the principal desire, if we go forward with this, is to harvest your ideas, your expertise, and your experience to right-size, to look at our current SDR program and to get it right. We don't know what we don't know.
3:22:00 So this is an attempt, if we go forward with this, to take all of your knowledge, all of your experience to address which is the larger challenge that we all know about, which is housing. We are all in the business of fighting for this community. We want to have a community. We don't want to be just a pass-through to a beautiful ski resort. So please keep that in mind. Say whatever you want, but constructive ideas, things you might, if you're on this advisory committee, the kinds of ideas you would bring forward.
3:22:30 Those are the kinds of things that will be most helpful. So please, Mr. Brangle. Thank you. Mr. Mayor. Sorry, before you get started. So it is five minutes for every comment, but as we just went through the last, I understand. As we just went through the last exercise, if someone has said what you wanted to say in an elegant manner, just I support what that person said. We don't have to say it again. Just kind of keep those kinds of things in mind. But please, Ken, go ahead. Ken Brangle, Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce.
3:23:00 And this is, in any other way, say an emotional issue. I mean, there's probably a split on my board itself about the short-term rentals and workforce development. And the real issue and what the chamber has decided to do, we're not in a position to take one way or the other on this right now, but we do want to weigh in on it.
3:23:28 So we are going to create a task force after we've got a few things coming up the next few weeks. We get past November 1st. We are going to bring our membership together, ask a number of people who are probably sitting in this room that are members to sit down and talk about the issue of workforce housing, workforce development, and workforce acquisition. And that's the question that we have.
3:23:55 Does restriction of short-term rentals provide workforce housing? And we think we've got some expertise in the chamber that will be able to help answer that question. So we will be developing a task force after November 1st, and we'll hopefully be able to provide some input to your committee that you're creating now for this. But we think it has to be discussed.
3:24:23 We really want it to revolve around, will this really create workforce housing? Excellent. Thank you very much. Mr. Morris. Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, I, John Morris, Chairman of the Lodging Association. I will raise my hand. I want to be on that committee. Sign me up right now. Okay. Rob Patterson, is that guy right there? Yeah, okay. I'll be happy to give you all the information you want that you don't already have.
3:24:49 And we appreciate you guys. I know this is a difficult, difficult situation. Everybody in this room, I'm sure there's not a single person in here that will say that workforce housing and long-term rentals are not the most important issue that our town is facing. Nobody in here is going to say that. It's how we go about finding it. So, quickly, I like to do a pro and con. So what would be the effect of this pause? The pro that I can see, a moratorium on new short-term rental licenses in the various areas outlined would...
3:25:18 Legally prevent a homeowner currently renting long-term from converting to a short-term. That is true. Unfortunately, that's the only positive that I can see. The cons are it won't protect against the loss of a long-term rental due to the sale of a property if the tenant is given proper notice. You can't protect against that. It will most likely send homeowners who want to rent their place short-term to do so illegally. We saw it during COVID.
3:25:44 Even when, Rob can attest to this, even when faced with an unknown illness and potentially even death from it, people still rented their place illegally. So what do you think that this is going to stop them from doing that? It's going to continue. And in fact, my assertion is a ban on people who are currently zoned for short-term rentals who want to rent short-term that now can't, are going to have lots of friends and family, and the enforcement effort is going to be even worse. You guys do a great job, but...
3:26:13 This is going to make it a lot tougher. Another thing is that currently there is no evidence that this measure will increase, as Ken said, long-term rentals. The biggest thing, and some of the realtors and my friends here in the room will attest to, it will most certainly lower property values in areas that are currently zoned for STRs, and that's leading, I know Andy talked about it, but that will lead to legal challenges. The town may be bulletproof on this, but...
3:26:41 That doesn't mean that people won't file lawsuits and, you know, they take time, they take resources. Do we really want to go down that road? Other cities and towns have documented the negative outcomes of STR bans. I really hope we've looked at all the examples of these things so we don't make the same mistakes. Given all the data that we already have, I'm a little leery of what the study is going to come up with, what we're going to find that we don't already know. I'm a little questionable about that, but I'm happy to participate in the process if it will make it better.
3:27:10 Bottom line is there are three ways to increase workforce housing and to increase long-term rentals. Build it, buy it, or subsidize it. So to date, the town has made great strides towards the first two with construction of the parcel and the purchase of existing properties in Mammoth.
3:27:26 But I can't find that there's been any serious effort to investigate the interest among Mammoth homeowners, not just short-term rentals, but all Mammoth homeowners, regarding rental subsidies. I would suggest spending the time and resources investigating the potential long-term rentals that might be out there if owners were given a positive financial incentive to rent long-term. You can't say that rental subsidies don't work without doing the legwork first. And this would be a much more positive approach.
3:27:57 To putting a dent in the current housing crisis and it has been documented and it works in other committees. So I hope you consider that. Thank you for your time. I appreciate it. Thank you very much. Hi. Hello, Mayor and City Council members. Rob, you guys over there. My name is Dale Mott and I'm a full-time resident at Mammoth Lakes. I have a business degree specializing in real estate economics and finance from the University of Idaho.
3:28:29 And I've been in mortgage and real estate since 1990. I currently own a mortgage bank, started it in 2009. And I've funded hundreds of loans in Mammoth Lakes over the past few years. And I have a good understanding of the situation, the current market that we're in. I'm also president of the board at Mount Shadows HOA, who's going to be affected by this moratorium. You know, and we've had...
3:28:58 A studio loft and a one-bedroom both sell for $560,000 and $570,000. They closed last month. I know that because I did the financing on it. This is going to ruin their values because they're second homes and they plan on getting a TOT license. And they might be able to, but guess what? When they want to sell the property, three years down the road, they're going to get crushed because people, they can't sell it the same way. Please. Thank you.
3:29:27 I have grave concern about this discussion for a temporary moratorium. You guys said it yourself. You can do it up for two years. You're not going to learn anything in 45 days. The county's got one. They just extended it because they're not learning anything. And the county doesn't really have a good transient base like Mammoth Lakes does. I've also financed just recently in La Vista Blanc, Unit 65 that the town owned, that they sold.
3:29:55 Which was a real challenge to get close because interest rates are now over 8%. And with the income restrictions, it was a real headache. And we had to get massive approvals. But I understand that program. I think the point that was just made about incentivizing owners who have current nightly rentals, if the town wants to offer $12,000 a year, that's all it would take for somebody that has a studio.
3:30:25 The valid points against it are...
3:30:52 Buying condos in Mammoth Lakes is not profitable as a full-time rental, especially with today's mortgage rates. So you're going to be losing thousands of dollars a year. There's no way you're going to buy a condo for $570,000 and rent it out for enough money to even break even, let alone make a profit. So nobody's going to buy condos in those areas. It's discrimination. It's going to hurt the condo's owner's ability to sell and drive down values big time.
3:31:21 It's going to take individual rights away from owners. And it's discriminatory because it only affects some condos. I see a class action lawsuit from some L.A. lawyer that owns in those areas. It's going to happen. The town needs to think about that. So the real estate market's already tough enough right now. So now you've got realtors in here. You've got mortgage people that are suffering from a downward trend. And now the town's going to add to it. So that area.
3:31:52 That you're talking about is going to get hit hard. Nobody's going to buy there. My suggestion is if the town wants me to rent my condo, give me an incentive or build new housing just like was mentioned. I'm going to hold the mountain accountable for housing solutions. I know that the mountains purchased some older hotels converting them into seasonal lodging so the town can help the mountain get them ready to live in. But taking away condo.
3:32:24 owner's rights is not the solution. So I highly recommend not approving this moratorium because I think it's just opening a can of worms that is going to turn into Pandora's box and I'd be happy to help with my own free time to help the town figure something out but this isn't the solution. So thank you. Thank you very much.
3:32:55 Hi, Cynthia Fleming, Realtor and Property Manager in town. Town Council, I believe you all have the best intentions to find housing for locals. Those of us here today opposing the ban also stand with you on the need for workforce housing. Unfortunately, you're not going about this correctly, and let me point out why. Is it just a fluke? The Village, the Westin, Limelight, Juniper Springs Lodge, Main Lodge, Snow Creek, and the 1,000-unit Snow Creek Development do not fall within this proposed ban.
3:33:22 Your proposed ban will only drive up daily rates and occupancy for InterWest Mammoth Mountain and their investors. The middle-class families who want to purchase a second home here in Mammoth so their kids can enjoy our community on a regular basis are the ones being punished, along with all the local small businesses they employ. Property managers, maids, handymen, contractors, the list is endless. Our buyers are not investors. They are purchasing condos here so their kids can ski more, get off their devices, and enjoy the great outdoors.
3:33:49 Every single one of my current owners, roughly 100, and multiple real estate clients all use their condos at least once a month. The Airbnb income does not cover their expenses but helps with their HOA insurance and utilities. New buyers want to use their places, not offer long-term leases to locals. An $800,000 two-bedroom condo purchase costs a new buyer $6,400 a month now. That's mortgage payment, taxes, and HOA. The going rent for a local for that two-bedroom condo is roughly $3,000 a month.
3:34:18 Who in their right mind is going to be in the red for $3,400 a month? This ban is opening up our community to lawsuits, and we all know our track record with lawsuits. You are blindsiding 72 new buyers who closed escrow this summer who may not have applied for licenses because they are remodeling. You have blindsided the Obsidian developer who is developing on the corner of Joaquin and Meridian. His buyers will not be able to get rental license, and that will gravely affect the value of his units.
3:34:45 What about current owners who may need to sell and can't because a license cannot be transferred to a new owner? They purchased under the current zoning and now their property is unsellable. This is the most important point today, guys. Real estate prices will plummet in the banned areas. We know this is exactly what you all want because you're under the false impression locals will be able to afford a condo. Let me explain why you're sadly mistaken and it may already be too late thanks to this proposed ban being public knowledge.
3:35:12 When lending on a property, lending institutions not only approve the buyer, they also approve the complex. Complexes that are deemed condo hotels are very difficult to lend in. For example, the Village, the Westin, Juniper Springs are all considered condo hotels due to their front desks. In 2021, Fannie Mae created new criteria for condo hotels. Any complex that is transient in nature has units that advertise daily rates and located in resort communities.
3:35:38 We have been quietly flying under the radar until you propose this ban. Why is this important to locals? A first-time homebuyer could buy a $650,000 condo today with 3% down, $19,000, and today's rate is 7.5% for them. Now the cat is out of the bag, and Fannie Mae will categorize all Mammoth condos as condo hotels. This is going to affect all buyers.
3:36:02 A local will now have to put 25% down, which is $162,000, and their rate jumps to 8.75%. This ban will make it impossible for locals to buy a condo here, so you're screwing over the exact people you want to help. The only people who will buy up condos at a discount are the elite who can either afford to not rent them at all, pay cash, or simply run illegally like the COVID days. The solutions are not simple, but they are possible.
3:36:28 Number one, work with Mono County on reducing property taxes to owners who rent to locals. Number two, not only offer single-family homeowners approved plans for ADUs, offer them money to build them. Number three, approach the Forest Service on allowing us to build affordable units outside of town. If the main lodge land trade happened, anything is possible. Number four, offer the rare condo owner who doesn't use their property a monthly subsidy if they offer long-term leases. Number five, explore Crowley and Bishop as alternatives.
3:36:57 Number six, increase the annual rental license fee to $1,000. My math alone, that will bring in $3 million annually that you can put towards housing. Number seven, look into establishing a local real estate transfer tax. We have a county tax, not a local tax. That tax can go towards a down payment assistance program for locals only with relaxed income requirements, unlike the grant-funded affordable housing division we currently have. Our second homeowners certainly have a responsibility to support our local community.
3:37:27 Bottom line is this. You five council members should not be allowed to artificially control the real estate market here. Individuals' property rights and open us up to lawsuits. You let the U.S. economy organically control the market. By passing this ban, even temporarily, while you assemble committees and have meetings about meetings, you will single-handedly decimate the real estate market, all while not creating workforce housing and sabotaging the chance for locals to buy affordable properties with reasonable down payments.
3:37:56 You are only enabling the leap to prosper here. Thank you very much. I'm Jason Herbst with Mammoth Five-Store Lodging. We manage about 90 properties in town. The company's been around for about 35 years. My partner, Megan, acquired it in 2005. She's been doing this for 18 years. I've been doing it for 10. I also was a loan officer until a few years ago, and I can agree with everything that the two prior speakers said. 3% as a first-time buyer down payment as a federal
3:38:35 Assistance Program that is not available in a condo hotel complex. Before I read what I prepared to say, I just wanted to say the idea that owning a home is a bag of sticks and it's one stick is true. My own lawyer gave me a similar example when I asked him what to say to you. It is the biggest stick in this bundle of sticks by far. The value of these homes is supported by the revenue potential like any business. The owner of a vacation rental.
3:39:03 Owns a small business. It's something I try to educate them about when they sign up with us so they understand their obligations to the guest and why they have to accept service animals. The problem here is the urgency ordinance. There is no impending emergency. If someone was here proposing to initiate a development of some disruptive service in residential neighborhood like a bus stop, somebody might want to institute a 45-day pause while they discuss whether that's a good idea.
3:39:34 In this case, the business of vacation rentals in Mammoth has been ongoing for generations. You're simply choosing to stick your finger in the carousel and stop the business now because you want to. There is no urgency that's new, and putting a 45-day moratorium is going to do nothing but injure the owners of the existing homes. It is not going to cause anyone who just spent $800,000 on a two-bedroom condo to decide to take an enormous loss and offer it.
3:40:02 For long-term rental. They bought it so they could go skiing. Dear members of the town council at Mammoth Five Star Lodging, we are deeply familiar with the housing challenges confronting our community. After 18 frustrating months following COVID, advertising locally to fill our several open positions with virtually no response, we realized we would have to focus on recruiting from outside the area.
3:40:27 To make this possible, we had to first acquire housing and make it realistic for our new hires. We have to subsidize the cost to ensure affordability for our employees. Our firsthand experience makes this issue deeply personal. We spend tens of thousands of dollars a year to subsidize housing for our employees. We are encouraged that the town is taking the situation seriously. We need a solution.
3:40:49 We genuinely respect the town's commitment to balancing community needs with the growth in tourism, and we understand that any decision this council makes is bound to displease someone. Furthermore, we recognize the town's concerns about flooding the finance office with new entrants into the market, exacerbating the problem we are all seeking to solve. As community stakeholders, we approach the proposed STR moratorium with the desire to craft a solution that considers all facets of our community's needs.
3:41:16 We are concerned that the proposed urgency ordinance, which enacts an immediate 45-day moratorium on short-term rental licenses, could inadvertently harm multiple stakeholders, especially those in the process of significant financial and life-altering decisions. Our key concerns include disruption to existing business and life plans. The current ordinance overlooks stakeholders who have already initiated business ventures based on the previous rules. There are properties that have been advertised for sale, are in escrow, or are under change in property management.
3:41:46 Disrupting these plans might not only harm individuals but could also hurt the town's reputation as a business-friendly community. Timing and seasonal impact. Considering Mammoth's unique seasonal dynamics, a blanket 45-day ban during this time, effectively equates to a much longer ban than due to the peak ski season. Let me pause from the written stuff here and point out, as an operator, there are two seasons a year when you can onboard a property onto your program, spring and fall. It takes approximately four weeks.
3:42:15 From the time an owner signs a contract until they are marketed and up and running. Between the inspection for safety, the TOT process, the photographer's schedule, whatever changes the owner needs to make to accommodate guests, it is a long process. We are in the middle of that season now. A blanket 45-day ban during this time effectively equates to a much longer ban due to the peak ski season.
3:42:39 This will disproportionately affect businesses that rely on the onboarding period for seasonal vacation rentals, effectively making your 45-day ban six to nine months because no one will onboard a property again until May. To address these concerns and provide a measured approach, we propose an alternative tiered structure for this moratorium if you decide to do it, which, by the way, I do not think you should do. But if you do, we propose...
3:43:05 That you immediately implement a moratorium for properties in this proposed zone that are not currently used for vacation renting and are not advertised for sale or in escrow. In other words, no one in that situation is counting on vacation rentals either to uphold the value they're selling their property at or the value they're buying their property at. They're not in the business. Freeze those people. If you could just wrap it up because a lot of people want to speak.
3:43:30 After 45 days, extend the moratorium to properties within the zone that are not in escrow. That would give the advertised properties that haven't found a deal yet an opportunity to make a deal. They've already spent the money to market their property. Those realtors are already advertising them. Don't cut them out of their business. After 90 days, fully implement the moratorium to encompass all properties within the zone that are not used as vacation rentals, ensuring those in escrow then continue to have time to conclude their business.
3:44:00 I don't think there's anybody that's come up here and spoken so far that
3:44:34 Doesn't agree that workforce housing is paramount and something that needs to be put on the forefront of all of our minds and our agendas. I think the problem is this particular circumstance is not going to work. There's a number of reasons, I think, for a moratorium in certain places, but this isn't one of them. Just in my experience, just in the last few days, I had a person that wanted to come up here and buy. They wanted to buy a place to rent.
3:45:02 A couple of the properties they were looking at were in RMF2 zoning. They backed out, and they left just because of this proposal, just because this might happen. I think the writing's on the wall. What the real agenda is, we've talked about it in the past, and the idea was to put a ban of some sort in certain zonings, et cetera. So I think that's a concern that people have. And I think when we bring things like this up and we put them out there, it sends a sign of instability.
3:45:31 In our community. And it will have an impact on value. A couple different ways that we impact, or excuse me, we value property is through cost, income, and obviously comparable properties. As soon as one of them starts to fall, then the others are going to be compared to that, and that's going to start setting the value for the next one. And then also a lot of people looking at property, they are looking at the income stream because they're trying to offset their expenses, as has been mentioned before.
3:46:00 I think this is a potential, as I think Cynthia said, about maybe increasing unemployment, solving our workforce problem that way, because we're going to send people out of town, because a lot of the people that work for these companies aren't going to be working for them anymore. I think a result, what are some of the unintended consequences? There'll be a decline, obviously, in revenues to the town, decline in property taxes coming in, because those property values will be... Anyway...
3:46:34 So it's discouraging. I think that, you know, there's a lot I could go through. I think one of the, instead of hearing all the negatives, I'd like to provide a couple of solutions that I think might help. We talked about 580 units coming online and 480 applicants thus far. It sounds like part of our problem is we don't have our housing that we have planned built yet, and we need to focus on that. We talked a little bit earlier, a couple months ago in the summer, about
3:47:02 Maybe some of this funding going to Measure A, going to help backfund these projects that were outlined in this ordinance here, that we're not going to have enough funds to finish out the projects. Well, maybe we need to revisit that. I think we need to stop focusing on government solutions, maybe turning a little bit to the private sector, as one of the other speakers mentioned. I think there are a number of areas in the RMF-2, RMF-1 zonings that are underdeveloped.
3:47:32 They were intended to be multifamily, and some of them have houses on them. Now, certainly it's that person's right to have a single-family home, but maybe we can incentivize those that might be on the fence about building out their properties. If they have a half an acre and they can build six units on it, maybe we incentivize them to do eight. Maybe we get rid of some of the tax taxes or other development impact fees, things like that. We talked about working with the county. I think using the carrot instead of the stick would be really helpful.
3:48:01 In some of these cases, and perhaps we can revisit that. I could go on for quite a while. One last thing I would like to point out, though, and we talk about doing long-term rentals and people doing that, and this isn't the fault of the council, but it is the fault of the state. There were some laws that were passed that were supposed to help tenants out, and those laws really made evictions almost impossible, and they put limitations on what owners could increase their property values to.
3:48:29 While it sounds like it would help a tenant out, it does not. Those owners that may have otherwise left rents low because they like the tenant are almost being forced to increase them because if they get too far behind, they can't keep their property incomes up to market value and they get themselves in a pickle. So I was one of those people. I had a tenant that down south I kept for many years. I kept for $1,300 for a place we rented and the market rate was about $2,000.
3:48:58 But we kept it low because she was a great tenant. She lived right there across from my mother, and it was a nice situation. But it got to a point when this law was enacted, we actually had to ask her to leave because it was going to actually have a long-term impact on the property itself. So anyway, there's a lot of things we could go on. I think it's going to be good to have a workshop on it. And anyway, just thank you and thank the other speakers for the comments. Thank you. Hi, I'm Michael.
3:49:30 I live with Mammoth Lakes. I've been here 34 years, and I don't have much to say about this other than the things you're talking about with your rental and stuff. There's all realtors right here. You all make your money off. We're just poor dirt farmers. We want to live here. And when you guys give somebody else the right, when someone lives in town and has five condos, rent them out, Airbnb, and they don't even live in town. They live in San Francisco, and then they worry about us. Okay, look, you can listen to me for about a second. All I'm saying is, please.
3:49:58 Control the Airbnb bullshit because it's getting overwhelming and it's getting, we can't live here. We can't afford to live here. $2,000, I'm telling you, a two-bedroom, $2,000, are you kidding me? For something that, rental property is taking my garage, they're charging me more and more and more. There's not going to be one person here to pour a cup of coffee for you if this keeps going. We need to slow it down, get a grip, tax the people that don't live here.
3:50:28 Make him pay to play. Make him pay to play. Give him a little more back to the town. You know, I mean, you guys, yes, yes, build, whatever. Look, you're building out of our... But you know what? There's not going to be one person that can afford to pour you a cup of coffee in the morning because they can't afford to live here. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right, eighth inning, guys. We're getting close. Patrick Bernard, Mayor Wentworth, Council, thank you very much.
3:51:00 I'm the property manager at Snowbird Condos. Snowbird Condos was built 10 years, 12 years before the Townsend Corporation. In the last 30 years, well, I have owners been there 50, but I have documentation that nobody's lived at my condo long-term ever, especially in the last 30 years. I live in the on-site manager place. So I'm going to read this from one of my owners very quickly, and then I'm going to read some bullet points from my owners.
3:51:27 My name is Valerie Garcia. I'm an owner at Snowbird Condos. We bought this condo because it is a condo hotel with on-site manager ability for short-term rental. I'm going to preface this by saying this person has never rented short-term. They've given my family free places to stay, and they allow friends and family to stay there all the time for free, never charging anybody, which gives me a chance to see my family. In fact, it was not easy to obtain a loan because this is zoned as a condo hotel. It's not zoned as a condo hotel, but that's how it's financed.
3:51:53 My place is a condotel. You cannot get a 30-year loan. You get a 10-year loan. I live on site. I live in the manager property. So that affects how you purchase a property. So in fact, it was not easy to obtain a loan because it is zoned as a condotel. I do not feel it is legal to change the zoning of stowbridge, especially without owner's input. The property value is also reflected in short-term rental ability, although we don't rent. If the town is considering a moratorium, those of us affected should be notified and given a chance to rebuttal.
3:52:22 Most moratoriums have extended over 45 days. San Diego, Palm Springs, Cathedral City, La Quinta, who are not zoned correctly as we were, and our property has been zoned for short-term for over 50 years and allowed for 50 years. Short-term rental is not a privilege. It should be taken away. In fact, given Snowbird location, it alleviates parking situations during the toughest times of the year. We provide parking for mountain employees. Guests walk to use the mountain and gondola.
3:52:51 And so just a couple of points from me. So this is our rates. This is printed on Kodak paper. This is when we had a 714 area code. So this is the late 70s. $450 a week in the winter for a one bedroom. $900 a week in the winter for a four bedroom. $250 a week in the summer for the largest one bedrooms. Obviously, we've increased in the summer rates. But way back when, that's $3,600 a month. Nobody would have paid that.
3:53:22 So that's probably one of the reasons why nobody lives there. Places by Canyon Lodge are next to the mountain. Nobody lives at 1849. I've seen one long-term person in the seven years that I worked there. So last couple points from my owners, and these are from lawyers, teachers, everything. Is this a ploy to depress property values located near Canyon Lodge? Specifically, this is not affecting Snow Creek.
3:54:16 This is not affecting any of the mountain properties, juniper, or the village which are developed decades past ours. To affect the town, what we have, we deal with illegal parking. The town has increased illegal parking. We chose, our owners chose to live in a resort. Somebody made a comment about living under a gondola. My owners chose that. They chose to live under the gondola. They chose to have people pee in front of their house, leave beer.
3:54:41 Poop. Come inside my deeded parking garage for deeded pee inside the garage. Got it on video if you guys would ever like to see. I called you guys and we had 18 accidents over the winter. Craziest winter. But we've been there a long time. Measure Z was specifically brought in. Measure Z is close to what happened in all these other areas. San Diego, Pacific Beach, Mission Beach, La Quinta. Measure Z was meant to stop short-term rentals. But our property was built prior to short-term rentals.
3:55:09 Gondolas flying over is what we had. We've historically had zero long-term tenants. We're a condo hotel. This is 55 days before Canyon Lodge opens, a 45-day moratorium, we'll put it behind that. Our owners feel it would depress property values, and we live slopeside, so we're impacted by the resort people no matter what. If you don't feel that we're a resort next to Canyon Lodge, but we're going to deal with everybody that parks illegally in our place and goes to have fun at the resort, well, I guess we're not resort zoning.
3:55:39 Me, personally, I feel for everybody. I live in my living room. I chose to take my job for this reason. I've been there seven years. Part of my family is displaced to Bishop. I have a daughter who drives half the time from Bishop for Mammoth High School. Just the way it goes, it really sucks. I love Mammoth. I want it to be affordable. When I moved here 13 years ago, property values were $135,000. Now that condo is $500,000. So I wish you guys luck. There's no perfect answer.
3:56:07 But for the Board of Snowbird Condos, they would not like you to pass the 45-day moratorium. Thank you. Thank you very much. Ms. Terry Stelick, good evening. Terry Stelick, I am a property manager. I have a rental agency, so just to kind of preface that. I'm going to start out by saying thank you for what you guys are trying to do to start with. It's kind of taking longer than anticipated and more money, but...
3:56:34 At least it is moving forward. There's a couple points that I'd like to do on this background of short-term rental history. It says that the sales price of our affordable housing units, so we're calling the condos that were built a long time ago our affordable housing units. They were never built as affordable housing units. They were zoned for nightly rentals, and so that's what they were zoned for way back when.
3:56:57 It says that one of the impacts on affordable housing is the short-term rentals. Is it truly short-term rentals that is causing that issue? And I don't think we need to have a 45-day moratorium to try to figure out that answer. I think we have that answer. Even if our real estate prices went back to 1970 prices, you're going to have to have somebody that's going to be buying the property.
3:57:25 Thank you so much.
3:57:53 You know, what are we trying to accomplish as far as that goes? You know, I have a hard time that we're not, we have not followed suit with forcing any development in the North Village to put the proper amount of housing on their property as they're building. I went back and looked at Limelight and I read that they kept referring to the 1999 sphere. And so I went back to read what it says, the North Village specific plan.
3:58:23 And basically it says employment created from the hotel and commercial development North Village specific plan will increase the population of town and Mammoth Lakes and its surrounding area by as much as 2,828 people with an accompanying housing demand of 1,230 units. This is a significant impact. So the mitigation measures where 100% of the housing for employees generated by uses within the project shall be provided on site. So anyhow.
3:58:54 You know, so these are some of the things, and then I would also like to kind of what somebody else says is look at the 45-day emergency moratorium. You know, the emergency is immediate threat to public health, safety, and welfare associated with the lack of long-term housing. Unfortunately, our town has gone through long-term housing issues throughout the years. My husband and I, back when properties were a lot cheaper, were able to purchase a couple properties so that I do have property.
3:59:24 To help my employees out and provide some housing at a discounted rate if I need it. And so I started looking at, you know, what were other town's issues? And I kind of went, okay, most of them are zoning issues. And so we've kind of already identified our zoning issues and we've done the quality of life. We have a lot of those things already in place. So I started looking at what are the solutions?
3:59:51 You know, what are people doing out there for the solutions? And one of them is, is the big word out there for all the solutions is collaboration. So if we're putting this group together, that's the collaboration that we need. Do we need to, we're saying, well, we didn't want to start a firestorm of applications coming in. Well, that's exactly what you just did. So by putting this out here, you put this firestorm that's going to be there.
4:00:21 Went, okay, let's figure out what our issues are and figure out what our solutions are and let's collaborate and let's work together as a community, which we've done so many times and we can do again. You wouldn't have this firestorm, but you've created this firestorm and no matter what, that firestorm is there. But I think we need to deal with it. I still don't believe that a 45-day moratorium is where you need to go because I also agree it isn't going to be 45 days. It's going to go on and you've just, it's going to create far more issues.
4:00:50 Thank you. Looks like I'm the last one. So good evening, everyone.
4:01:26 My name's Jeremy Abraham. Some of you may know me. I'm a local lawyer in town. Some of you have talked on the phone. Probably never met me in person. The one thing I don't understand is why the town wants to bite the hand that feeds them. This town, in their general revenue, gets 58.9% of their general funds from T.O.T. $30 million of general fund. You guys projected...
4:01:59 $18 million in your next budget from TOT. And yet, you're going to have a moratorium. 45 days. Again, like everyone said, it's not going to be 45 days, we all know that. Likely 10 months, if not longer. But, what you're looking to do is say, okay, every year we've increased the TOT. There's 3,400 plus properties, I think, on the rental program right now. That'll stay.
4:02:30 Your last year's numbers were $16.9 million. This year you projected an increase of an additional $1.1. You may or may not have that. Yet your revenues go up each year. Police departments over $5 million. They don't want to cut ice skating rink. Over budget, I don't know how much. You're going to cut that? No. You want to have all these recreations. You want to have everything to provide to the people of this town.
4:03:01 But yet you're going to cut off one of your major sources of revenue. It's been coming up here since the 90s, before Airbnb, before internet. You call up some sort of property management company, Mammoth Reservations, whatever, ended up staying at the summit. Can't do that anymore. That's not part of it. Unlike other people here, I know why the resort zoning is the resort zoning. I understand the master plans. I understand how they came about.
4:03:31 My partner was one of the ones that created one of the master plans. We did Lodestar. So I get it. Why Canyon's not a resort? This town is piecemealed together. It's piecemealed zoning. It's piecemealed condos. It's been that way. Certain people had foresight. Lodestar was a foresight property. Snow Creek, they had foresight. That's why they're resorted. But what I still don't get is why this town...
4:04:01 Who wants to grow their revenues or say they do, want to grow their expenses by adding all these revenues, sorry, by adding all these amenities is not doing so. And yet now from here on out, starting with a 45 demoratorium, you are going to decrease your major source of revenue, which is a TOT. So I hope the town considers that. I hope this town really considers not imposing a moratorium. Get an impact statement.
4:04:31 If you have an economist, if you're going to have a task force, if you're going to have a committee, find out what is the economic impact to this town. I assure you it's going to be negative by doing a moratorium for this entire one. Thank you. Hi, my name is Tracy Spencer. We have a house in town as well as three condos that we rent. I went through and read your staff report in a fair amount of detail.
4:05:04 And I, like Chris, am very much of a numbers person. And the thing that I did not see was how many new licenses did we process in November, December, January, February of 2020, 2021, 2022? What impact do we expect the current real estate market to have on the number of licenses that we process in 2023? And that, to me, seems to be such a fundamental piece.
4:05:32 of deciding whether or not you're going to impose an auditorium that it seems crazy to even consider it without having that information because I think we have that information now. So that's point one is I don't think we have the facts to make that decision. The other part, and I think people have probably heard me on this soapbox before, but second homeowners are a key constituent for Mammoth Lakes. They are part of the fabric of our town. They pay taxes.
4:06:02 They fund our schools, our hospitals, our police department. And this is a slap in the face to those people who have owned properties in town for a number of years for no solid reason except for the fact that maybe we can because they don't vote. And that feels wrong. Thank you very much.
4:06:26 Is it nap time yet? I think so. My name is Sonia Bush, and I'm a realtor, and I really appreciate the changes to the ordinance about the existing owners. That makes a difference. I'm not going to add on or pile on because it's all been said much better than I could, but I would ask each of you to ask yourself these three questions before you vote. Number one, how will this moratorium or even a long-term implementation impact workforce housing? How will it impact it?
4:06:53 I've asked this numerous times to many of you and haven't gotten an answer. Number two, any decision needs to be associated with a risk assessment. The staff report was excellent, but I saw no risk assessment on what the impact of this moratorium will do. Not the long term. What is the impact of doing this moratorium? Ask yourself what those risks are. And finally, how will this program be measured? How will the success of this program be measured?
4:07:22 So please consider those questions before you vote. Thank you. Thank you very much. I'll be short. My name is Jay Cole, Town Council. Thank you for your time. I'm curious, what is the goal of the actual moratorium? Why 45 days? Why can't we do whatever we want to do without the moratorium? Without causing all this scare? How many long-term rentals do you...
4:07:54 Hope to yield as a result of just the short-term moratorium. How many long-term rentals are we going to yield? One? Ten? Hundred? Nice. Hundred. First of all, I have only, hopefully just as sort of new stuff, all the other, everyone else that came up and spoke earlier on both sides of the spectrum have great points. Don't need to reiterate those.
4:08:25 Something along the lines, though, with the resort corridor and Jeremy, right, mention is that, yeah, the resort corridor is immune, right? It's written in law. Andrew, is that right? Andy? Under the current draft, yeah. All right. The RMF2 is the target because you can. That's it. It's a simple answer. All right. Why are realtors here?
4:08:54 Not so much their business. I mean, yeah, of course. We make money, whether prices sell high or low, whatever. That's not the dog we, you know, in the race. It's the reason why the realtors are here, because they know how property values work and how affordability works. And it's just, it's just not that simple. Lowering property values, even if they went down 50%, still yields, you know, a two-bedroom condo somewhere.
4:09:24 It's still going to be $350,000, right? Plus $750 HOA, so that's a $3,500 a month mortgage, plus $750, plus your electric and everything else. So that's pretty expensive by most standards. And even if you did get that awesome job, sitting behind the desk over here and you can afford that, then
4:09:55 I lost my point on that one. Forget that one. But the point is, it's still, oh, I know what it is. Someone else made the point earlier that there are going to be other people that are just rich, you know, and they're just going to come up and buy property at low value. And you're not going to really solve anything. So anyways, the moratorium, I don't think it's going to do anything for you.
4:10:25 I do agree, and we all agree, that if we can figure out how to get more affordable housing in town so we can have a better community all around, that's where we should go. If you want to look way back, maybe Bill has been longer than here than me. Definitely got a couple years on me. But the point is, my parents owned the newspaper back in the 70s. And if you look at the first issue of
4:10:55 Our paper back in 1972, front page article, affordable housing. Okay, so it really has been something that's just, it's not like we're just going to fix it with some study that someone's going to come up with and say, somehow you're going to turn people that want to come up and own a condo and recover some of their, recoup some of their costs and long-term rent. They're just not going to buy for a long-term rent. No, not many people do that.
4:11:25 I don't think you're going to get the result that you want. It certainly would be nice to know what the goals are and when we achieve them. And also, you know, I think to do it, you've got to plan now for 20, 30 years out. You've got to go find some land. You've got to swap it out with the Forest Service. And you've got to build. You've got to do what McCoy did down at the college. And you've got to build those apartments like the college.
4:11:55 The plan is right there. It's already been done. He did it. It took 30 years. Thank you. Thank you very much. Hello. My name is Gina. I own a condo here that I rent out. I've rented it out long-term since 2001. Yesterday, I applied for a TOT, short-term rental business permit, just in case I am forced.
4:12:31 to kick my long-term tenant out because of an Airbnb investor below me. I am being threatened to be sued for lost revenue because my tenant lives there and makes noise. He walks around, he goes up and down the stairs, he lives in his condo. But because of Airbnb reviews,
4:13:01 Because this guy didn't do his due diligence, this investor did not do his due diligence to find out that he was buying in a janky old building, but charging $772 a night for a studio? Of course people are complaining that they've got somebody living above them. They're not for or against a moratorium.
4:13:31 Because I don't think it's going to do too much good, but I think you guys ought to look at putting a cap on short-term rental properties or business licenses. Put a cap on it. Start renting. Making some of these people, I wonder how many here have multiple, are they all night time or nightly rentals or are they long-term rentals? Do any of you in here rent long-term to anybody? Yeah. Fourth estate.
4:14:05 Okay, let's bring it back here, bring it back here. Thank you. Okay, so put a cap on how many short-term rentals there are or nightly rentals. Put a cap on that and give some of these people that do have long-term rentals some incentive to keep renting it long-term.
4:14:50 So give us some incentive. I've been doing it from 2001. I have a good tenant. He's been in there 10 years. And in the last three years, because of an investor downstairs gets bad complaints because there's noise in his unit, I'm looking at maybe having to possibly evict my long-term, 10-year, lifelong residence of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Hi, everyone. My name's Carrie. I hate public speaking. And I know we're all tired.
4:15:26 I just wanted to write something up really quick, kind of in response to what everybody's been saying. Like Gina said, I'm not really for or opposed to this point, at this point, because I've actually learned a lot about the real estate market in the last four hours. I actually genuinely appreciate that. I've learned a ton. But I want to say I don't have a lot of experience in this topic, and I do know I'm in the minority that I'm not a property owner in this room.
4:15:53 I just want to reiterate that if you do move forward with a moratorium, it is absolutely crucial that you find a real way to hear from the community members that can't make it to these meetings. Everybody that stood up and spoke here has very valid points, but there is a large portion of your community that I know you all want to represent as well, both sides, that are quite frankly working doubles most of the week because they want to pay.
4:16:22 For a room they don't know if they will have in two months. I myself move four times in eight months, and it might happen again. I don't know. That's just how it is. I know that now. But my point being, I'm not trying to paint a sob story. I'm just trying to express that I hear what everyone is saying. I think they're really valid points. I learned a lot. But if this does go into place, I just want to reiterate that there is...
4:16:48 Another half of your community that is underrepresented, unfortunately, because they're not able to make these meetings. And frankly, that is why I sat here for four hours and why I come to these meetings. Because I know that many of my friends want to know how this meeting went because they can't be here tonight. So my only other comment, thank you, my only other comment is in response to the folks that mentioned second homeowners paying taxes.
4:17:15 And supporting this community. And I completely see that, and I acknowledge it, and I thank you for that. But I do want to acknowledge also that if there isn't a tangible housing result that comes into place in a time frame that makes sense, you might not have communities to support with those taxes in the long term. You're not going to have young families trying to grow here. You're not going to have kids that can go to school here long term with those taxes.
4:17:41 That's all I have to say. I know it's not pro or against, but I just wanted to voice that. Thank you. Thank you so much. Hello, Mr. Mayor. My name is Pat Kepsel, and I'm a realtor here in Mammoth. And I only have one very strong request. If you insist on voting for this measure, then I ask you please to include all condominium complexes and not eliminate those.
4:18:14 Owned by the Mountain. Be fair to all of the owners in this town. I represent buyers and sellers and it is my ethics to be fair and down the middle for both sides. And I request that you insist on voting for this, that you do it with all complexes under one umbrella. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Town Council. Martin Kleinbard.
4:18:49 Probably been many years since I've gotten up here and voiced my opinion. I think that what's going on here is pretty serious. I think, just like somebody said, we're chopping off the hands that feed us. I'm a local contractor, and over the past two days I've heard so much banter from customers, condo managers. I think the big thing is, is I don't think there's enough people on staff anymore.
4:19:17 That including council that have been here for many decades that know that all those properties that are encompassed in this moratorium that wants to turn into a ban were all zoned for this nightly rentals. It's not like I believe these other areas and maybe states as well that have banned short-term rentals. I don't know that those properties
4:19:47 We're zoned and purposely built for nightly rentals like our town was zoned in those properties. And then to pick and choose which zones are going to not have, are going to be included in this band is absolutely ridiculous. Then the potential litigation, I mean, Andy, where you sit? I've seen other town attorneys that sit here and tell the council, oh, nothing's going to happen. It'll be okay.
4:20:18 They don't know what they're doing. Well, let's see. The first big one, what was that one? That was a redevelopment agency set a state precedent, kind of wiped out redevelopment. Our little town wiped out redevelopment agencies for the entire state of California. There are states, there are, yes, I know there are cities that still have their existing redevelopments.
4:20:47 Not exactly. But yeah, there was a lawsuit that wiped out the town's attempt to form a redevelopment. And others as well. It curbed a lot. It really stifled. Then there was the 40, which probably is more like 50 plus million dollars, which was the airport litigation. So I guess if the town wants to step their foot into big town loss number three, I mean, go ahead. And what somebody made a comment to me back there.
4:21:16 With the way that it's structured with the zoning that are allowed and aren't allowed, there may be an equal protection clause issued, too. So, how about it? Anyway, thank you for letting me comment. Thank you, Martin. Good to see you again. My name is Liberty Elliott, and I've lived in Mammoth Lake since 2004. And I am a bookkeeper for several local businesses in town. And my impression is that...
4:21:50 This is obviously a really top issue for everybody, but as I can see it, more short-term rentals is not a critical issue for the survival of our town, but available workforce housing is. And I have lived in nine different houses or ghetto apartments, whatever you want to call it, in the course of my life. I'm still a renter, and it's not only affordability that is impossible, but it is inventory.
4:22:18 I don't know what a 45-day cap on short-term rentals will do without a longer strategy, but I would be more encouragement of a longer-term either moratorium or cap, and I agree with people saying that it should not target certain areas in town, but the issue is that we heard a great presentation about the Sawyer-Buckingham property, which sounds very good, but it's also...
4:22:46 We heard from a community member who's been waiting for years to get in there. And also when you look at the average medium income metrics for being able to qualify, if it's a two person, it's under $80,000. We all know that the Mountain made their entry level wage $20 an hour because we're all trying to afford gas and groceries in this economy as well. So two people making $20 an hour are going to make over $80,000. They won't even qualify.
4:23:15 Thank you very much. Hi, my name is Vicki Taten.
4:23:49 And I'm not a realtor. I'm not a lodging owner. I am just a citizen with a condo. And we have rented our condo short-term and long-term. And there are pluses and minuses to both. I am in support of the moratorium because I don't think it's ever a bad idea to take a breath.
4:24:16 And evaluate things. And I feel like Mammoth has been a part of the wild, wild west of ski resorts and short-term rentals and the explosion of Airbnb, VRBO type rentals. So I don't think it's a bad idea to just take a break. And specifically, I would like the committee, if the moratorium is...
4:24:43 approved and the committee is formed to take a look at specifically those with multiple properties that are specifically purchased for short-term rental revenue. I feel like this guts our community and I think as a community we have to address that.
4:25:08 And so those are my concerns.
4:25:38 Thank you. Thank you very much. Who is that beneath that? Deja vu, man. It's really weird. Shields Richardson, good evening. Good evening. Good evening, yeah. Mayor, councilmembers, my name is Shields Richardson. I'm a recovering town councilmember. I'm in the fifth year of an eight-year program. I think... A lot of great things have been said today, and everybody knows there's a problem.
4:26:14 And the big question is, you know, how do we take care of it? And it's not an easy answer. But, but, there is a long-term solution on the books, and it's happening. The parcel. And that is based on a 2017 study that said we needed 585 units. Well, we're going to get 585 units with the parcel and everything else. So what we're working with is a short-term, in my opinion, relatively short-term problem.
4:26:45 So how do we take care of it? I believe that it's not the second homeowner's problem. It's a town problem. And I believe the town should take a look at, and John Morris brought it up, very rightly so, to incentivize and subsidize those people that need housing, our workforce. Because our workforce benefits our whole town. And our town has to step up.
4:27:18 And I'm talking about the town of Mammoth Lakes and not the owners of the properties necessary because they're taxed. They pay their TOT. And with the money that they pay in the TOT, which has been pretty good the last few years, as I understand, we should take some of that money and subsidize housing for these guys. So I think there's a solution. And, you know, and I agree with having...
4:27:50 You know, what do you want to call them? Programs where we're going to sit down and talk about stuff. But we all know in 45 days, nothing happens in 45 days. All right. And I wish it did. But it doesn't. And it's going to be longer. My suggestion is you don't go into a moratorium. You go directly into, you know, putting together the groups that need to be put together so that we can come up with a collective.
4:28:19 Nice to see you again.
4:28:46 Oh, can I leave now? It's way past my bedtime. Mine too. How's it going? My name is Matt Avery, and I represent the 1849 Condos and the 1849 Mountain Rentals. And I really just had a question. Pretty much everyone touched on the points I came here to speak about, so thank you for that. Do I understand correctly that...
4:29:17 Someone who currently has a cert cannot transfer to another management company. Is that an amendment that we made recently? No, that would be fine. I would do that. What I was referring to is someone who did not possess their own BTC, so if they wanted to get their own BTC, that would be a preventive move. But if someone, anyone who has a BTC, an operator, would...
4:29:44 Would be able to service. People could still transfer ownership or rental management companies. Right. I don't want to waste anyone else's time. Thank you. I just wanted to clarify that. Thank you very much. That was the point I forgot to bring up earlier, if I may. So you said earlier somebody who wanted to change managers would not be allowed to. And I meant to address that when I was up here before and it slipped my mind. That is critical because you would be taking away the owners.
4:30:09 Leverage in their relationship with the manager to say, do a bad job and I'm going to fire you and find someone else if they can't change managers. Yeah, that was not the intent. The intent was that it, because questions came up and someone said, hey, I'm currently with a property management company. I, can I get my own certificate? Because it's already in the rental pool. The answer to that is no. Got it. Okay. Sorry, I'm trying to spoke. And by the way, sign me up for that group too. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you all. Any more public comment in the room? Yes, please.
4:30:39 So I have a theory that I should never follow shields, but he got it before me, so now I have to follow shields and I won't look so good. Just one thing. I have long-term properties that I rent and I have short-term properties that I rent. And I'm, sounds like, one of the lucky few in this room that my short-term are in the village. So I should be happy because my short-terms...
4:31:08 Values are going to go up because no one is going to want to buy anywhere else except for in the village. So I should be happy and I should be saying this moratorium is a good idea. But I'm not going to say that. The reason I'm here is that, boy, I remember about 10, 15 years ago, John Wentworth called me up and he said, hey, I want to do this bike path and we're going to council and I need people to support it. And I said to John, you know, John,
4:31:37 I'm not a bike rider, but I think it's the best idea I've seen in Mammoth since I've been living here, so of course I'm going to support it. So I think you have to come up and say what you think as a local, and even though the moratorium may actually help me, I don't want to see it hurt everyone else in Mammoth that's in an RF2 and can't sell the properties and people start losing their jobs.
4:32:06 So I think sometimes you've just got to say what you think about it. And I think that the moratorium is a bad idea. But the committee and things that you were saying earlier.
4:32:18 Is a good idea. And maybe it's such a good idea because I can't believe how eloquent all these speakers were. So you're going to have no problem finding people who know way more than I do about this issue and can really do something. And the other thing, as I think 100% of the people up here have said, that workforce housing has to be our number one issue. So it's not like it's going to get swept under the table.
4:32:44 But don't put the moratorium out there now and have a whole bunch of consequences that we just can't even envisage right now for that going forward would be my recommendation. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, any other? Please, thank you. I hope this is the last one. My name is Joseph Bograd. Thank you for your service and attention. So four years ago, I was making $20 an hour.
4:33:17 That was 2019, and that was when prices were about half of what they are now, and interest rates were also about half of what they are now. I couldn't afford anything to buy, and that was my drive. I really wanted to buy a property, and I couldn't. Prices were too high. In 2019, I asked Mammoth Lakes Housing for help. They couldn't. Not because Mammoth is making $20 an hour. They're 20% down. Just still couldn't. I couldn't apply for enough mortgage.
4:33:49 To afford something, making $20 an hour. And I just say that because even if prices do fall 50%, who can get a place? And there is a missing middle there, and maybe a hospital workers, SCE workers, and they do deserve attention and a place to call home. And there is a solution, another solution here on top of the parcel, and it's the access apartments.
4:34:22 Which I hope the county and town council can support the gap that Mammoth X Housing needs to fund the access apartments. If they don't get that type of funding from the town or county, they could lose about $6 million in grants. And not only to mention, over $200,000 from local support from Altera, U.S. Bank, Vacasa, and plenty of the community here who has donated to them. So thank you so much. Thank you very much.
4:34:53 Thank you, Councilor Nicole Godot. He was not the last one. Okay. But follow-up, his point, there is a six-unit derelict building down at the bottom of my hill, and it needs to get rehabbed, and we have six new units for more tenants. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much. So anybody else in the room? I'm sure we have some people online, probably. Okay, so let's go virtual, shall we? Ms. Klein, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm Bita Klein.
4:35:26 I own an Altus. And the reason we bought the place is so we can enjoy the mountains. And when we're not there, we do rent it short-term. So we're not going to ever be a long-term unit. That area is, from what I understand, I have to talk to my neighbor who's a, I hate to say this, but he's a class action lawsuit guy.
4:35:55 And I have to talk to him because I believe we're in our deeds, we're zoned for, you know, resort. And I don't know what's happening. I mean, I'm, first of all, I feel like we were left out. Us homeowners that are sitting on our Zoom calls that are not there.
4:36:19 Did not get a chance to talk for the last two hours where you're hearing all the real estate agents. And I do appreciate a lot of good points that the real estate agents have made. But I'm the one that every day I personally rent my unit and I personally love renting my unit because I like dealing with people. And you're taking that away. I don't know what's going to happen with Altus, but.
4:36:48 I do it for my family. I do it because we can afford that house when we want to go on vacation. And when we are not on vacation, we do the Airbnb or whatever, VRBO. But I would never rent it long-term, never. I would sell it before I would rent it long-term. And if you think that's going to help you, go ahead. Put your things in place.
4:37:19 I just, I just, my, my housekeeper just raised my rates 30% saying he has to pay the employees. Where is all this money going to? Maybe you guys need to figure it out. My, I'm paying, you know, $350 for cleaning a two, a two, three bedroom unit, depending on how many people come stay at my place.
4:37:44 And for that lady to say somebody's making $700 for Airbnb, I'm sorry, ma'am, you need to look at the economics. People don't just throw out $700 out there. People go out and see what they can rent it to. I have a very beautiful place, and I cannot get that much money. You know, it depends on the time of the year, yes. If you're talking President's Day weekend, yes. But not...
4:38:14 Not in the middle of the summer, the guy's getting $700. We're just dealing with economics. My housekeeper comes to me and says my workers need more money because Mammoth is expensive. I go, do what you gotta do. If you gotta give him 30% more money, give him 30% more money. I just raise my Airbnb rates. That's what I do. I mean, and I would never, ever, ever, those real estate agents,
4:38:44 I cannot rent this Airbnb, then I will sell it, so please contact me. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you for your patience. Okay, who's next? Mark, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, can you all hear me? Yes, we can, Mark. Great. Thank you, everybody, for the chance to speak, and I've been listening in. A lot of tricky problems. Lots of ski resorts have faced the same issues and have struggled with this.
4:39:15 I'd just like to kind of take us through a scenario. What would happen if we enact this moratorium and act on that? By the way, I have been coming to Mammoth as a skier for like 50 years. We just bought two or three years ago. We come up about a month or two a year ourselves and rent it out short-term otherwise. So that's kind of a context I'm coming from. So the goal of the moratorium, obviously, is to stop short-term rentals to some extent.
4:39:45 Because you're taking them out of the market. Let's think what happens when that happens. So property owner, let's say we decide we have enough money, we'll just come up and use it on our own. When we're not renting it, we're not paying any DOT taxes. Someone else has already commented on that. Additionally, no one has commented on this. We don't have renters coming. Where will they stay if there are no short-term rentals? If they're not coming up to spend money at the resort or at the hotels,
4:40:15 Or at the restaurants or at the mountain, nobody's going to have any money and there'll be less employees. Properties will be rented long-term. It's unlikely anyone's going to rent long-term that's a short-term property owner because we mostly come up because we like to use the place ourselves part of the time and rent it part of the time. And if it's still not rented long-term, there's still no place for people to stay. So again, fewer people spending money up here at Mammoth.
4:40:45 What then happens? You try to sell the property. Several of the brokers have commented on the fact that this will lower values. Well, that's not good if you're an owner. Might sound great if you're a potential buyer. I would buy a lot more places and rent them out if prices were lower myself. But what happens with lower prices? You have lower property taxes because the price is based on the sell price. You have potential loan defaults because people have mortgaged and expected.
4:41:13 And require and depend on some of the rental income to pay for their mortgages. So you have, again, a potential significant impact to financial institutions in the community that have loaned money, millions of dollars on these properties. And again, if you sell it, it can't be rented. So no visitors to come and spend money in Mammoth. So we have to think through the consequences of what we're doing.
4:41:42 I see no positive consequences from this moratorium, only negative ones. I agree there are serious problems. I am surprised we built the subsidized housing in the middle of town, which I assume the land is fairly valuable and could be converted into higher return properties or uses. But I don't know enough to comment more than that. There's huge areas outside of town, out by the airport.
4:42:12 I don't know what the status of those are, what it would take if it's Forest Service land, but building a lower cost housing out there, that's something other ski resorts have done to try and resolve the problem of employee housing. Investing property seems to make more sense than killing the golden goose. Great. Excellent. Thank you very much. Thanks for your comments. That's it. Okay.
4:42:45 Thank you. Thank you, Town Council and everyone. And everyone's opinions and point of views are taken into account. And I just want to share one quickly because most of the things I wanted to say were said. But a second homeowner, we come up every month. We've been coming to Mammoth for 40 years. Again, we would never, we're up in Chamonix, so.
4:43:17 We're on our HOA board. We're very involved where we can be. So I too can't see the purpose or the benefit of it because like most people have said, the problem is housing, workforce housing. And I have a unique perspective in that my daughter was a lift operator in Vail. All ski resorts have these issues. And just to piggyback on the last comment that I love the parcel.
4:43:45 But again, that property in town's expensive. And when she was a lift operator in Vail, they actually had an apartment complex in the city next to them and had bus service that would bring them back and forth. So they were able to double the housing because the price was half and able to provide that service. So the problem is the workforce housing. It's not necessarily second homeowners who are trying to enjoy the town and help with the expense of their unit.
4:44:15 It's not going to solve the problem. We too would never long-term rental it because we can't enjoy it. So I think the town needs to grab some of these people from the meeting tonight, make a committee, and look at options outside of the city too to help all the workers. And thank you again. Thank you very much. Thanks for your patience. Please unmute yourself and give your comments.
4:44:46 Thanks. It's me again, Jennifer Kreitz. Thanks for your time. I just, I looked through the staff report and my one suggestion is, is that we add some folks to the committee that represent just everyday workforce, like maybe Liberty that spoke earlier or some of the other folks that spoke that, that are working and not part of any of the committees identified in your list so far. That's my one request. Thanks so much and good luck. Thank you very much.
4:45:30 Public comment is closed. Thank you, Jamie. Thanks, everybody, for being in the room. Thank you all. Thanks for your patience. Okay. So at this point, we shall deliberate. And we shall make a decision. Yes, Mr. Holler. As you deliberate, bear in mind that like all moratoria, this one requires four votes in favor to pass. So it's not a 3-2. That's not going to do it. This would require four. Okay, good. Thank you. Okay. Who wants to start? John, I'm more than happy to.
4:46:00 Throw my voice out there. Thank you, Bill. As long as my fellow council member promised not to throw anything too heavy or hard. So what we're dealing with are several things here. One, I want to know from staff, if this doesn't pass tonight, I am assuming that the other scope of work that is all in this packet will continue to move forward. Because to me, that is imperative. We need to find solutions. The intent would be to continue with the economic analysis and also with the certified property program as discussed.
4:46:29 Yes, the Certified Property Program is hugely important. I support that wholeheartedly. We're looking at trying to create a solution for workforce housing. Everyone's talking about second homeowners. They're talking about property values going down. I've never seen property values go below what the cost of building is because people want to live in Mammoth. Currently, if you want to build a place with linoleum floors and linoleum countertops, you can do it for about $600 a square foot, not counting land prices.
4:47:00 Which means the cost to build a 500 square foot for them, it costs more for us because of government regulations, is $300,000. The condo prices are not going to come below that. The average person in Mammoth cannot afford that. So I don't see this as a solution to our workforce housing problem. 48% of the units in the RMF2 zoning don't rent short-term now.
4:47:30 That's going to go down because by even introducing this, we've caused so many, far more than probably would have tried to get short-term certificates in the next year. We've created an exacerbation of the own problem that we started with. So I have problems with that. I have a whole list of things here, but at one point in time, Mr. John Hooper was building fourplexes all over Mammoth. It was laughing referred to as Hooperville. He was doing that.
4:47:59 Specifically because he could build at a price that he could sell those for and the owners could make money renting. It's an easy economic figure. We don't see any of those fourplexes being built today because they would literally cost millions of dollars to build. So it's not profitable for private to do that. We have stepped into that and we're building out the parcel and we have a Housing Now program. I believe we are not giving it enough time to succeed
4:48:31 To see whether this is even necessary. So that's where I'm at on this. I am not for a moratorium. I am for moving the rest of this forward, including the group to get together and see if there are other solutions out there. Also, I will say I've heard from several people tonight about subsidizing homeowners to rent long-term. I have a huge problem with that. From my standpoint in all of my years in Mammoth, I want permanent solutions.
4:48:59 And if we take money to subsidize condo owners to rent, we have to pull money from what we can add to things like the parcel to make it more attractive to get funding. So I just don't see that as a viable alternative. And believe me, I've given it lots of thought. It sounds good, but that money has to come from a pot and that pot's going to be our housing pot and we're going to reduce that. So I will stop there. You guys have heard enough and I've heard enough.
4:49:29 Okay, thank you. Anybody else want to weigh in on this? Just out of curiosity, can I get a realtor show of hands? So I'm really bad at math, but I crunched a couple numbers. So in 2022, there was 3 million people who held active real estate licenses in the U.S., a population of like 338 million in the U.S., so about .009 realtors per U.S. resident.
4:50:03 According to some of the letters I received this week, there are 218 realtors in Mammoth Lake. So if we compare that, our population of 7,000, 2022, that's a ratio of 0.03. So that's three times as many realtors per capita in Mammoth as in the United States as a whole. Just interesting. Who's become a realtor since 2015? Everyone's been a realtor since then. You know, Bill talks about Hooper building these fourplexes and I...
4:50:36 For nightly rentals, and I feel like Hooper building fourplexes couldn't have foreseen Airbnb like the Second Amendment can't foresee an AK-47. You know, it's just, it was just a really different world. I got a lot of letters from people this week who took the time to show their work and show how they could not afford their condo if they didn't rent it short-term. They couldn't afford their home.
4:51:06 Pleading with us that, you know, that this, they would not, they would have to sell, they wouldn't be able to do it and I just, I just feel like we're running face first into the point and I appreciate the sentiment but, you know, again, we're running face first into the point and we talk about subsidizing and I feel like it's very obvious that these short-term rentals are artificially inflating the cost of housing in Mammoth.
4:51:36 We don't need to hire the consultant. I have it here in my inbox. It's very obvious to me. And I don't feel like we, as a town, should be in the business of subsidizing commissions for realtors and subsidizing people's rents so that they will... Hang on a second. Hang on. Please. Please. Let the council members speak. Thank you. The bottom line is that nightly rentals, the proliferation of nightly rentals is...
4:52:07 You know, I heard a lot of ideas tonight about solutions that people would put forward.
4:52:39 If you've been paying attention across the country, you're not surprised by a moratorium. You know, San Francisco has restricted STRs. New York has restricted STRs. San Diego has. Mono County has. I feel that seeing that we've gotten 65 applications in three days, we're not open on the weekends, right? So we had Friday, Monday, Tuesday.
4:53:09 We had 65 applications in three days. I feel that it's imperative that we take a pause and see what we are willing to do as a community to fix our housing crisis. You know, I feel that we need a multifaceted approach. We are building the parcel. You know, we're buying units and subsidizing them for people with up to, I think, 150% AMI.
4:53:37 So I think that, you know, I'm not against tourism. I feel that this is a responsible thing to do, is to take a pause and see what we're willing to do as a community to address our housing problem. Okay, Chris? We've all been sitting here for five hours now. Is that right? Because we all love this town. You know, we're...
4:54:11 Fighting for the life of this community. Let's not kid ourselves. Just because we don't have a lot of people who are struggling to find housing doesn't mean they're not here. They're here. So when we fight for the life of this community, it means for everyone.
4:54:28 You know, the urgency, because somebody said there's no urgency here. There's urgency here. I have young friends who are leaving and they aren't coming back. And that's the future of this place. So we are hollowing out this community. And the man who said there's not going to be anyone to pour you a cup of coffee. Like, let's be honest. We've heard about people who aren't.
4:54:50 We're not able to buy a new place here, but we've also heard about restaurateurs who really wanted to come to Mammoth and then they look at our nuts and bolts of how this town is working and they don't come. So I'm not suggesting that we have all the answers, but this is a crisis any way you look at it. So I just want to remind people that the only thing we're talking about tonight
4:55:17 Is a 45-day pause so that we can do the hard work. Okay, fine. So maybe it's a 45-day and then a few more months. But the problem is, no, don't, you know what? We listen to you for three hours. So I think it's really important that you listen to us. You know, it's not like we just roll up here and haven't done homework. We have been studying this and talking about it since I joined the council.
4:55:46 And so we have started the process. We have to see it through. So the challenge is that if we don't do the pause, then the number of new certificate applications could be you throw out a number. And that's important. I mean, we have to be methodical about this. So we talk about facts and we talk about data. And this gives us the time to compile it. So, you know, nobody's saying this is obvious or clear. No one's saying
4:56:24 What we're going to do at the end of this. You know, the one thing is that I like the list of people who would be on the commission, but it was missing a glaringly obvious couple of people, realtor, at least, and a person who has struggled to find housing. And until that group of community members sits down together and looks each other in the eye and says, how are we going to solve this together? Then we are going to talk at each other.
4:56:52 For eternity. So that's what we need to do. And I believe that this is the path that we're on and we have to see it through. And I do thank you all for being here. Nothing is falling on deaf ears, but this is where we are. And if we don't do something now, we know exactly what we'll have in five or 10 years. So thank you.
4:57:18 And I also do want to thank the chamber for their initiative because that's what we need. We need people coming with solutions. And these are super valuable things. So thank you. Okay. Well, my thoughts on this are in the same vein as what we've been hearing here, with perhaps a little bit of a nuance. This is not a question about the housing crisis.
4:57:50 We all know we have a housing crisis. This is a question about a specific sector that didn't exist how many years ago? Okay, so 10, 13, whatever. This is being promulgated by something we refer to as big tech. Big tech is not democratic. Big tech does not provide options. It dictates. Okay, how do we respond to that?
4:58:24 This moratorium is specifically about taking the time to figure out how do we right-size that particular sector and how do we then make sure that we hear from the expertise in this community about how to address this specific thing. And what I'm so encouraged by is what I've heard in all the emails that I've read. All things have come in are the suggestions.
4:58:53 The ideas, the recognition that there's a crisis, and the ideas that come from the expertise in the community to address it. And Bill, I very much appreciate your idea about all the other things that are in here, but I think this is the moment for us to address this particular component of our housing and our economic situation. I think one of the things about Mammoth that's always impressed me is how
4:59:24 Is the lack of self-confidence that this community had in the value of its place? I think what we're hopefully all starting to realize, this is an incredibly valuable place. If we take this time, which I would hope by the middle of January, by the first part of the year, that the committee will come back and provide recommendations, which is what we want, and these recommendations should not be limited to the nightly rental stuff. Is our enforcement adequate?
4:59:54 Do we need to actually look at our enforcement program? The quality of life thing seems like it's pretty good. I'm not convinced that we're enforcing our current quality of life ordinance as effectively as we should. If this committee comes back and says, you know what? It's perfect the way it is. Don't touch a thing. Bring it back to the council. Let's focus. Let's collaborate. Let's take a pause. Let's address this. It's not an option. This is not something we can ignore. This is not something we can say.
5:00:25 We're just not going to touch this thing. There's no good time to do it. Let's do it now. Let's do it deliberately. And let's do it quickly. And let's make this happen. Those are my thoughts. Of course, please come forward. Ask a question. A question for Ms. Stellick. Thank you. This vote is going to be a 4-1 vote. What do you think that this moratorium is going to do? Don't you think that we can move forward? Don't you think that we are a competent enough community?
5:01:02 We haven't done that. It's being only rented with, I mean, we,
5:01:32 I'm sure there's still some illegal rentals. I know there are. But for the most part, we've stepped forward and put our programs together. But now we're saying that the only way that we can actually move forward as a community to solve this issue is to put a moratorium on our short-term rentals and new applications. So I just think that that really...
5:01:58 It's kind of a slap in the face. It's pretty much saying that we are not capable of moving forward, that your staff is not capable of moving forward without putting this pause on there. I will speak only for myself. I won't speak for the rest of the council. But I appreciate that this moratorium provides a unique opportunity for focus, to do the things that we need to do, to do it quickly, to do it efficiently, and get this over with and get this done as soon as possible. Bring those recommendations back to the council. Let's see what they are.
5:02:28 Let's get this thing done. Thank you. That's my suggestion. One comment, please. Come forward. Multi-family, too. Win most of that by Canyon Lodge. You target my owners, who are the biggest donors in youth hockey, who built L.A. We have great people. I only have three with mortgages. You target them specifically, not everybody else. The Mountain, Chadmar Development, who I work for. And I know it's been tough. That's where we're at.
5:03:38 Target. Hang on, let's just be clear. Anybody who has a certificate in those areas, keep working, keep doing what you're doing. This is just about new certificates. If we can get this done in two or three months. Absolutely. But my owners will be infighting. Just like you guys said, it's very interesting because 11 of mine don't rent, 12 do. So we have more that don't rent. It's very similar to what you had on the residential. It was actually like 48% rent. But my owners.
5:04:07 Are going to be absolutely fighting because the one across the way that has that TOT, whether it's 45 days a year, whatever, they have the ability to market and do their property that they want. The other ones don't. So like I said, it's not going to open anything at my place. Nobody's going to get a place to live at Snowbird. It's too damn expensive. But we are by the mountain. I have an owner who bought 40 years ago. He paid 200 grand for it. And he saw when he was at Warming Hut 2, he saw a for sale sign. He was sick of taking this.
5:04:33 Family over there and spending two hours getting them ready at Snow Creek One. He's not an original homeowner. He's a second homeowner. But that was in the 80s. You know, so there's a reason why my owner's Canyon Lodge is next to a resort. My property, it abuts forest service. The mountain has allowed 50,000 cubic yards of snow to be put on their property from Hooper's Place across the way. Maybe we need to have on-site housing if people need to be built.
5:05:02 Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so with that, I think we've deliberated, we've heard comments from Council, so I guess at this point I'd entertain a motion. Do you want to discuss why we're not doing this all over the place? Personally, I think that this is about charging a committee. We're taking a pause. We know this market and know this, and this is not about
5:05:43 I'm looking for the recommendation to come back. If the committee were to say, we have to do something town-wide, that's what I want to hear. Okay, well, again, I want to be, well, you just heard my response. Well, again, my, my, okay, look, I don't want to, I want to be careful here. I want to stick with, sure. I can't answer that question. I don't know why we're not proposing to do this town-wide. It seems like it's more fair. I would, I would. We have shown all of you a great amount of respect, regardless how each of us feel here.
5:06:38 Just as in the last thing that took a lot, show us that same respect. I did not talk out while you were talking. Thank you. Okay, so to your question, my response would be I think that that gets beyond the scope, A, what's been recommended by staff. And I think also I'm looking for the recommendations. If the advisory committee would say, look, to be the woman said, you need to look at this whole thing. I would want to hear it from a group who would know a lot more about it.
5:07:13 And I would, again, it's, I would be looking for, as I mentioned, things about enforcement. I don't have 100% confidence that our enforcement program is really doing what it should be doing. I want to make sure that this committee has as wide a scope of possible to bring back the recommendations that they... Rob, can you speak to why we excluded the resort zones? There are specifics written into those zones that are for resort activities. That was the reason...
5:07:52 That I put it on the documents. It doesn't mean it has to stay that way. But those specific zones that were called out were considered resort zones within the town or specifically for resort. I know RMF2, you know, was way back in the day, originally started as that. But our recent developments around resort components are those three. Andy, do you see any?
5:08:23 Question is, is there a legal issue with carving out those zones? No, I don't believe so. Well, I don't want to derail, you know, a possible vote, but what if I were to make a motion to enact the moratorium to include those zones? I would make that motion and I would include the red lines on our ordinance that we have here. Fails and fails. No, no, of course, that's what we do. It seems fair. Can you restate that, please? Sorry. Yeah, I would.
5:09:00 Thank you. I would move to adopt urgency ordinance 2023-10, establishing a 45-day moratorium on the issuance of new short-term rental registration certificates pursuant to Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Chapter 5.0, including updated language in the ordinance allowing properties in escrow prior to adoption of the ordinance to complete an application within 60 days, and also including
5:09:31 Included resort zones, CSP. Include the specific plans as well as the resort zones. North Village specific plan. All zones. All zones. I mean, I might as well throw it out there. Sure. It's a fair suggestion. We have a motion. Is there a sound? The one conflict you'd have where it would not apply. We do have some areas that have a development agreement that locks in the current zoning, so they would still be able to operate.
5:10:04 Under that agreement, I believe, so you would not be creating a violation of the agreement. So is that a reason that we exempted those zones? Yeah, there's a section in there that some of the specific plan work that was done, like in the North Village is probably the biggest one, where it really spoke to the special zoning that was created there for that. Without looking at the development agreements, I can't tell you what they do or don't say as I sit here, what rights might be vested, notwithstanding a moratorium. You could amend that just to say,
5:10:40 Sorry, Jamie. To exclude any zoning that's been otherwise precluded by a development agreement. Very elegant motion. I have a motion. Is there a second? I'll second. Okay. Any additional discussion? We've been at this for a long time, and I didn't contemplate or analyze how I would vote on something like this because
5:11:24 Now we are starting to talk about having a major impact on TOT. I know this is only for 45 days and I know it's only more. Don't laugh. It's not funny. Like this is serious, everybody. And the truth of the matter is that I feel very uncomfortable being asked to vote on a motion on something this important where people spent five hours of their time giving public comment and then having it change.
5:11:52 In a way that I haven't had a chance to talk to or think through with constituents what those unintended consequences could be. I'm really uncomfortable. That's fair. Personally, I couldn't answer the question. And that's mea culpa. I couldn't answer that question as to why we excluded those zones. We have a motion to the table. We're delivering that. And we're going to call for a vote in a second. Any other thoughts on this? No. As I mentioned, I'm sort of within the same vote with Chris. I can't. It gets way too.
5:12:32 Beyond what I think the focus of this is, what the public has understood, we're going to be. I'm the first to admit my statement. Sure, okay. Do you want to vote on this? Do you want to withdraw the motion? Or we can call and call the question. Well, the maker of the motion can withdraw it if there hasn't been a second. I'm not sure that I heard a second. Okay, so there's a motion to second. Jamie, let's call the question. Councilmember Bubzer? No. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Mayor Wentworth?
5:13:20 So I would like to make a motion to adopt the urgency ordinance 2023-10, establishing 45-day moratorium on the issuance of new short-term rental registration certificates pursuant to Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Chapter 5.4, including updated language in the ordinance allowing properties in escrow prior to adoption of the ordinance to complete an application within 60 days. I'll second. Can I make one small parliamentary procedure observation? Generally,
5:13:52 That motion would be proper coming from somebody who was on the short end of the first motion. I'm not sure if we're operating actually under Roberts or Rosenberg's. Rosenberg's. Rosenberg's. It may not make any difference. Carry on. Okay, so I made my motion. Second. Okay, further discussion? I read the paper. First motion. I have a question. The question I have about the motion is about the nature, the formation of the advisory committee. I think that's the second motion. Good. Okay.
5:14:34 Motion to second. Any further discussion? Good question, please. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Councilmember Ray. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser. No. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Okay, so there is a second item which has to do with the establishment of the advisory committee. Motion draft in front of us. Sure. I make a motion that the town council direct staff to establish an advisory committee.
5:15:04 As outlined in the staff report with representatives from each of the identified categories, in addition to those categories, add one representative from a real estate business, one representative from that's disadvantaged at housing or that is... A member of the public that has faced housing challenges. A member of the public who's faced housing challenges, two at-large members, constituents interested in serving... Do I have to read that part?
5:15:34 Constituents interested in serving on this advisory committee should submit a letter of interest to the clerk of the town of Mammoth Lakes by 5 p.m. October 25th. Committee to be appointed at the November 1st meeting. Okay. Is there a second? Second. Okay. Any further discussion? Okay. We have a motion and a second. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser? No. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. The motion is agreed.
5:16:09 Okay. Well, thank you very much. Thanks, everybody, for being here. I had the same question, but yeah. Okay. Thank you all for being here. Thanks for your comments. Looking forward to bringing forward this committee. Thank you. We're going to take a quick break and then regroup. Thank you. Okay. Ladies and gentlemen, nothing like donating to the inkwell. Thank you very much. Okay. How about that? All right. Okay. We're moving on now to item 10.3.
5:31:07 We adopt a resolution accepting the Eastern Sierra Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy, otherwise known as SEDS. Staff, who's going to? Thank you. Thank you. We've had this item discussed in the past. Excuse me. The Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy, funded by a grant from EDA through SCOG. It's looking at multiple counties in Yomono and Alpine. The purpose of the SEDS is to lay out a five-year vision, at least, and every five years it's renewed.
5:31:39 I tend to look beyond that. The purpose of the SEDS, frankly, is primarily to get kind of a common vision, but then it becomes a document that we can work from as far as going after a number of federal grants. Without one, you're not eligible. And so that's a lot of the drive for that. And walking through this before with the Planning Commission and others is really looking at the first few pages in there, pages six and seven, lay out kind of the core goals of the SEDS.
5:32:08 But I think they align pretty well with the council's priorities historically and also a lot of things that we're currently working on. It talks about broadband. It talks about housing. It talks about workforce development. There's a lot of elements that fit into things that the town has been looking at and or actively engaged in. So I think it aligns pretty well with what we're doing. The actual implementation side and some of those strategies, the one caution there that talks a lot about what the...
5:32:37 Should do, will do type things. And the caution there is it's not committing us day one to go like, hey, we've got to go fund all these things. It really goes back to how do we leverage other revenues, how do we take things we're working on if we can go after those additional funding sources, which would be a great benefit in a lot of areas. One of the key ones, for example, is expanded broadband in the region, which is a tough one. So the item tonight is for council to approve it. It'll actually end up going to ESCOG.
5:33:07 In the morning. So unless there's a real significant amendment, it probably won't get made. The last review will be by EDA, who then would bless it before it becomes effective. Okay. Any questions for Dan on the SEDS? Good? It was a stimulating read, I'm sure. A question for Dan. I want to reiterate everything he said about not having to follow all of the, I'll call them action items. So those questions, any public comment of concern on this matter?
5:33:50 Okay, with that, I would entertain a motion. I move to adopt a resolution accepting the Eastern Sierra Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy. I'll second. Okay, can you repeat that motion, please? I move to adopt a resolution accepting the Eastern Sierra Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy. Thank you. I'll second. Any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer?
5:34:22 Yes. Councilmember Rae. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser. You. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Thank you very much. Thank you for that, Dan. Item 10.4, Continuation of Emergency Work Authorized Under Resolutions 2329 and 2354. If I may, you've seen this before, so we're requesting one more extension of these resolutions. It looks like all the projects will be wrapped up with an outstanding check. The right is all by the next meeting. At that point, we will be terminating.
5:34:53 Okay, so you're essentially, staff is asking for a continuation of this emergency. Okay. Any questions for Dan? Public comment? Not hearing any. With that, I'd entertain a motion. I'll second. Thank you. Motion to second. Any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth?
5:35:28 Yes. Thank you for that. Okay. Councilmember reports. Who's got anything to share? Nothing. Chris went to Lafco for me because she's an angel. That's all I would have had. No. Okay. Amanda? Nothing left. Nope. Nope. Bill? I attended the Mammoth Trails Committee meeting. Okay. I attended a, I serve on the Projects Committee of the surf process.
5:36:18 We had a meeting about that, which was, and I think we all attended a joint meeting with, which I have to share was, it was a disappointing meeting, and I think, Dan, we need to have a conversation with the county. This relationship is not going in the realm, and there are, there are issues that the town brought forward that are of really life and death in Port Community, literally from the fire perspective, and I don't think we heard anything from the county that was a true acknowledgement of how seriously we take these things. I think we'd like to get a little bit of a follow-up with Sandra.
5:37:09 To the supervisors. One question I have is, do we all know whose district we live in? Creight's district? Creight's? I don't know. Gardner, I think. That makes sense for us at some point to start thinking about having conversations with folks in our mammoth residents who are in the districts of those supervisors and maybe start talking with them. So I think with that, we're done with our council member. Does that sound about right? Okay. Yes.
5:38:11 Okay, so the council is going to now head into closed session considering item 12.1, conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, initiation of litigation pursuant to paragraph 4 of subdivision D of section 54956.91 case. Section 12.2, conference with legal counsel, existing litigation, paragraph 1 of subdivision D of section 54956.9, name of case, Main Street Taxpayer Association versus
5:38:41 Town of Mammoth Lakes, case number 23UCM12. We'll go into a closed section. If there's any action to report, we shall do so. Thank you all very much. We'll see you shortly. Yeah, so just take a break because we shut things down. No, I'm kidding. I'm joking.