TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2023

Town Council

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

288 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

9:24 Bill's doing good. That's right. Yes. Well, even worse, I was only 15 minutes away from my brother's house. So I called him to pick me up and he wasn't home. He was out of town. I'm going to change my account, Jamie. We're right with you folks. Just a couple of technical things here. We'll get going.

10:40 Okay, I think we're ready to get started. So I'm going to call to order this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, October 4th. Jamie, if you could call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice. Here. Mayor Pro Tem Souser. Present. Mayor Wentworth. Here. Sergeant Heilman, if you could lead us in the pledge this evening. Very much appreciate that. Thank you.

12:10 Thank you very much. Okay, we'll get started with public comments. If anybody has a comment, public comment for something that's not otherwise on the agenda. Mr. Brangle, good evening. I haven't been here in a while, so I might as well come up and say something. Yeah, sure, please. Actually, Mr. Souser asked me to...

12:41 Bring up a program that we're having on October 24th at the high school. We're doing a career expo in which the whole high school, all the high school students locally as well as Colville and Lee Vining will be attending. To start talking about kind of what do you have to do? What's the next level? Everybody, when you graduate from high school, there's something that happens afterwards.

13:08 And so we are trying to make sure the kids are looking at what those options are. We're going to start with the General Assembly on tourism and hospitality as that is the basis of our economy. And so we need to, we're going to kind of do that with a panel and do that as a General Assembly so all the students will be going through that. And then over the next three periods we'll have 15 different breakouts.

13:34 Ranging from healthcare, you know, being a nurse, a police officer, you know, IT, entrepreneurship, we have a couple of business people being willing to talk about that. So the kids will each be able to rotate three different subjects over that period of time. So we're looking forward to it. This is the first year we've tried it, but we think it's going to be something that we'll do every year to help the kids prepare for that next level once they...

14:04 Whether they're staying and working or whether they're going to college. Just want to let you know about it. We hope maybe you guys would stop by. We're also going to have kind of a luncheon afterwards. After that, it's a short day that they do. I'm trying to know what they call it. Pardon? Yeah, minimum day. That's it. Thank you, Amanda. But it is something, you know, that at the end, I think the lunch is around noon.

14:33 We're going to have some pizza and stuff for the kids and stuff. So you're more than welcome to come and kind of hear. I have a person from Angels Baseball that's going to talk about the different careers that are available in pro sports other than the 100th of 1% that make the team. There are a lot of other ways to be involved. So he may be doing a video at that point in time. So love to have you guys there.

15:01 Excellent. Thank you very much, Ken. Thanks for bringing that phone. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Just public comment for things that are not otherwise on the agenda. Not seeing anybody in the room. Jamie, anybody out in the virtual? No? Okay. So let's move on then to any additions to the agenda. The agenda, Mr. Holler. Yeah, no additions this evening. Okay, good. Reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Mr. Reif, good evening. Hello.

15:31 Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. A few updates for you all. A quick update on the timber work going on around town. You may have noticed some work in Shady Rest. That is all completed as well. We had a temporary detour on the mops. That is all reopened. So again, go take a look. Looks like great work. The next phase will be in the Mammoth Lakes Basin, primarily east, east of the pack station.

15:58 And then kind of Dragon's Back Trail area by Horseshoe. It will result in maybe a three-day closure of the Dragon's Back, which we will take care of starting on the 9th of this month. And then that timber work in the basin as a whole will go for about a month, we're estimating. We're airing on the longer side, could be less than that. So I wanted to provide that update for you.

16:22 I also wanted to provide a brief update on our archaeological work going on at the base of the Sherwins as part of the Sharp Trails. That work has been completed by our archaeology contractor. They are going to dot their T's, cross their I's, get that information to the Inyo National Forest, and we'll then continue the process. So things are rolling, which we are very, very happy about. And then what might be on all of your minds is broadcast burns.

16:47 As you can see, we have smoke on the landscape. I spoke to Jeff Carl today, who's leading this effort for the Forest Service, and I wrote it down on my phone. Their goal right now, they're doing a broadcast burn, which is stretching all the way to 395. They are planning on burning on Thursday, tomorrow, in that area as well, with the hope that they finish it all up Thursday, do mop-up efforts and efforts to reduce the smoke on Friday.

17:15 Now, again, that will depend on how things go Thursday. Then the wind's supposed to switch. Come out of the south, right? Then I think we have some pretty big recreational activities going on this weekend. The winds will switch. They are then going to move to Smokey Bear Flat, north of town. So I would like to think it all goes according to plan. We shouldn't have much in the way of smoke impacts this weekend. Again, it will depend on the wind. It will depend on how things go tomorrow as well.

17:44 Any questions for me? Nope, don't see any. Thank you very much. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Nolan Bobaroff, Acting Community and Economic Development Director. A few updates. We still have an ongoing wood stove replacement program. This, with funding from the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District, provides eligible households with either $2,000 or $4,000 to low-income households to replace older wood-burning fireplaces.

18:17 To check eligibility or for more information, just contact planning staff at the town. That program is ongoing until the funding has all been expended. Also a highlight, the town, mainly Sandra Moberly, the previous director, was awarded from APA for our Mammoth Retreat, the Mammoth Field Trip last year for the APA Central California District.

18:47 Everyone who attended loved it. Everyone thanked. John Wentworth participated, I think, in the main lodge part. Jeff Griffiths was there from Inyo County. It was really a region-wide effort, but very well received and got an award for it. And also, the town has hired a new code compliance officer to replace our previous officer. That person starts October 16th in a few weeks, and we have a pile of projects lining up for them to start working on. So, thank you. Excellent. Thank you, Nolan.

19:17 Any questions for Nolan? Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Otherwise, I'll turn to Mr. Holler. If you've got anything to add, Dan. Yeah. Two different items. One is we have two grants out there for our biomass plant work in partnership with the donut project, if you will, in terms of the fuel reduction work. One of the key elements there is to have a facility that can take on the material that comes out of.

19:49 The forest, we have a $10 million grant ask in and a $3 million ask out. Total project costs are just under $26 million estimated at this point, so very significant investment if we can help with that. That timing moves in when some of that work may be accomplished. The other element we move forward with followed up with a contract regarding economic analysis in the community here related to our short-term rental market.

20:17 We basically piggybacked along with the county who's having a very similar study done utilizing the same firm. And so instead of being out of sync with that, going together made a lot of sense in terms of looking at Mono County as a whole and the town specifically as well. So that contract is out. And then we'll talk more about it here. We'll want another item here, but I do want to spend a little time on the federal shutdown issue. Okay. All right. Anybody else for?

20:47 From commissions or departments. I'm not seeing anybody here, so we're going to move on then to agenda items 6.1, the October 2023 Public Works Engineering CIP update. Hayes, anything you want to add? I had just a couple notes. Anybody have any notes on this? A couple notes. Lakes Basin Path. Lakes Basin Path. There's something up there called the Lake Mary Road Mop. I don't know what that is. Lakes Basin Path.

21:19 Parcel going well there. Main Street landscaping, still no luck getting anybody to fight at that, huh? Actually, we've made some headway in the last week or so with a local contractor. If everything goes according to plan, they may pothole this fall, kind of looking to make sure the infrastructure is where they anticipate it or they expect it, and they would hit it hard in the spring with a contract goal being done before 4th of July. Oh, good. That's good news.

21:49 And then we're going to get a CRC update coming. Dan explained there's some language in the Foundation Child Care language that makes it sound like we're just building a shell, but Dan's reassured me it's part of a whole holistic program, so that whole thing will come together, so that's good to know. And congratulations on all your work this summer. Streets, roads, parcel, the whole team. It's just great to see all this amazing amount of public works activity moving forward, so thank you all for that.

22:18 Okay, so move on then to did you know dogs? Is anybody going to speak to did you know dogs? I know dogs. I know councilmember Buffster knows dogs. Do you know dogs? Oh, boy. Timing is perfect, huh? Okay, do you know dogs? I do. Okay, good. Anything you want to add to this, Dan? I just want to make it clear to the community that we do have rules and regulations about dogs and what you do with them and how you manage them.

22:48 It's good to know. Thanks for getting that out. And then the other piece of collateral, which is item 6.3, did you know that the town is working hard to enhance our recreation amenities? Yes, and on this one, we're going to touch on just real briefly, beginning of this meeting, we did have two ribbon cuttings. Yes. But great time at the tennis court, new material up there, new sport court material.

23:13 Initial response from the majority of people playing on it. They like the material. We have a little leveling out to do in the courts, but it will happen hopefully this fall, if not next spring. And then the new pickleball court complex there by the library at the old ice rink site, a great partnership with the school district in repurposing that court into six pickleball courts. We anticipate that to be very heavily utilized until the snow flies. Obviously next.

23:42 Spring, Summer, etc. Okay, good. Any thoughts on any of this? I think it's just a real credit to the creativity of the whole team, the town staff team, finding opportunities and really doing some great work with some things that might not have made any sense before we started this, but yeah, Bill. One question, Dan, and I'm sure I know the answer to it, but don't remember it. Do we have any time constraints on our usage there during school hours? I think the school has a priority if they wish to utilize it. We can work with them on that. I think they have a priority, but not...

24:15 There would be no – there's no element saying we have to not utilize it or open it. But if they came to us and said, hey, we want to do a PE class or something, we'd work with them accordingly. Do they have a pickleball team or – Not that I know of. Because we – I think we could field quite a team. Okay. Okay, good. Well, thanks for that. And moving then on then to a planning update on the potential federal government shutdown, which has taken –

24:44 A number of interesting twists and turns of the last 48 hours. So, Dan, what do you got? We put this on the agenda, you know, with the potential shutdown that was looming a week ago, not knowing where that would go. As council's aware, they did end up with a continuing resolution, et cetera, in order to keep the government open. I want to talk a little bit about this, because what we do on these types of incidents, we'll see that coming, we'll sit down, we meet with our partners, we had a good meeting with Forest Service leadership.

25:13 On how do we partner up and what services can we step in and help provide to meet the needs of our community and our guests that are coming up during that time frame, such as, you know, additional restrooms and trash services in the lake space and being a key one that you could talk about. And we had a number of other areas as well, as noted in the staff report. We're continuing to keep all of that in play right now because we don't know what's going to happen in the next 45 days. Assuming they'll be back in a similar

25:42 Situation. Frankly, I would say from a personal perspective looking at it, I'd not be surprised if we're not facing another shutdown within that time frame. No idea how long it'll take the House of Representatives to pick their leadership to be able to move these items through. They have, I think it's eight outstanding funding bills to move through in a very short time, and whether or not a continuing resolution would be successful with the change there is unknown.

26:13 So at this point in time, we will continue to look at these issues and be ready to step in should we need to. One of the nice parts on it is with at least a little bit of a delay, a lot of like the campgrounds in the basin and stuff, they have more opportunities to close those up appropriately, getting their water lines cleared out and those types of issues. So hopefully if it is a shutdown, it's less impactful, but we'll also be ready to continue to move into support mode if need be.

26:43 Yeah, it's been a disturbing 48 hours. And just for the edification of all of us here, I know the council members are aware of this. While the town is 25 square miles, 75 percent of that is managed by the federal government. So our destiny, our future is inexorably entwined with what happens back in Washington, D.C. It might be an intuitive, not an intuitive thing to think about, but that's the reality of who we are and how we function. Thanks for that. I'm sure we'll be watching all this as we get in. The date is November 17th. Is that right?

27:13 I think that's a Friday, I'm pretty sure. Okay. All right. So from the miserable, the dysfunctional, and the most unhappy, let's now move on to the introduction of a key new member of our team. We're going to meet Canine Jax. If Mr. Jax could please come forward. Good afternoon. Hey, Jax.

27:46 Good afternoon, Council. Dan Casabian, Interim Chief of Police, Matt West, our newest canine officer, and our newest member of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Canine Jacks. So, in order to, when we started talking about bringing the dog on and getting another dog for the police department, Matt took the reins on that.

28:10 Matt took the reins on that and worked with the community and businesses around the community and was able to raise quite a bit of money in order to start this project. So I do want to give a huge thanks to Four Paws. It's Four, Four Paws, ran by Stacey Bartfeld. She did a lot of work on this and really helped us out and made this happen. Other than that, I think what I'm going to do is I'm going to turn it over to Matt. But one thing I do want to say is...

28:39 He's a three-year-old German shepherd that comes from Switzerland. And not only is he now a police canine officer, he is also a retired veteran from the Swedish Army. So I'll let Matt say a few words and then we'll do a swearing in. Evening, Council. So like Chief was saying, yeah, he comes from Switzerland. So he was born and raised in Germany. And then he worked in the Swiss Army for a little bit. And we got him back July 24th.

29:13 And started the training. It was seven weeks long. And he did really, really well. He's cross-trained in a lot of things like locating suspects, apprehension, handler protection. You can tell he wants to go have some fun right now. He's like, this is, come on now. So what canines are, they're locating tools. So really what we do is we use them to locate suspects, articles, narcotics, things like that. So if we've got a suspect that runs into, say,

29:42 Vons or the County Building or any large house, something like that, even a small house, what they can do is actually locate that suspect behind, let's say, like a closed door where it would take my partners and I, you know, it takes us a while to go through an entire house and clear room by room or a big open field. He can find the human odor very, very quickly. So it actually reduces the amount of time that officers are out there on the call.

30:07 Like in articles that he can find too are like, you know, firearms, knives, but even like my watch, I'll go out to an open field, I'll go drop my watch somewhere. I did it the other day, I might have broke it, but I tossed it out there and he was able to locate that. They can locate things as small as a ring down to like, you know, a key, something small, as long as it has human odor on it, they're able to locate it. And so it's definitely useful for, you know, a suspect were to toss a firearm or something like that, we can go out and he can locate it.

30:36 They've got an extremely strong nose, and that's how you can locate that. And he also loves obedience. So we'll show you here after the swearing in some of his obedience. See, you can tell he wants to do it right now. So, all right. Thank you. Thank you very much. Just real quick, when Matt was talking about odor, just to kind of put it in perspective, if you take a million $1 bills and you pull one of those off, that's our sense of smell. The rest of it is the dog's.

31:05 So he's able to find people pretty quickly. So let's go ahead and swear him in. Thanks, Jamie. Now we'll pin his badge.

33:24 Thank you, council. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. He looks more intelligent than a lot of us. Jax, welcome. It's good to know we have our canine is fluent in German. That's going to come in handy. Don't quite know how yet, but it's going to come in handy. So with that, we're going to move on now to a council presentation, and this is item 8.1, recognition of town manager Daniel C. Holler for 10 years of service.

33:58 Dan, this is the effect you have on the public. Everybody gets up and leaves. Thank you all. No, no, we're all here for the dog, too. It is tight. And I know that my fellow council members will recognize that there was nothing in the packet, in our agenda packet for this item. There's something on the agenda, but there's no there there. So I've taken the liberty to assemble just a couple notes.

34:27 Dan Holler, Daniel C. Holler, a native son of Cody, Wyoming, on the northwest corner of Wyoming, with Yellowstone National Park as a nearby outdoor recreation playground. Now we know where he gets it from. He and his wife, Claudia, have been eyeing Mammoth Lakes for many years when Dan was working up at Douglas County in Nevada. Dan arrived in October of 2013 as an interim town manager.

34:54 And was permanently hired in February of 2014. So the 10 years includes months of interim ship. So it's not, it's maybe 10 years, Dan, but February 2024, that's 10 years. So that will be truly 10 years. The council at the time was Mayor Rick Wood, Joe Bacon, Matt Lehman, Michael Raimondo, John Eastman. And the town and Dan inherited

35:19 A bankruptcy settlement that was been in place, that was in place. It was the darkest, probably the darkest period in the short history of the town of Mammoth Lakes. And this, Dan inherited a culture of staff that was fearful, anxious with good reason, national attention, one of the few cities in the whole country that was potentially going through federal bankruptcy. The town's financial position was tentative, to say the least.

35:45 There was kind of a national black eye on the town and the community. And leading out of all of that was a critical charge to Dan, the council, to the team, to the staff, to bring us out of all that. And the road that we all traveled with Dan, we all traveled together, was to address the financial program coming out of the difficult times. The budget that we're all working with today came out of that time. And really looking to address the culture of the town as an organization. Inward looking.

36:15 Perhaps tentative, not sure what was going to happen next, to try to get in a position of stability and productivity, with an emphasis on being initiative-driven, entrepreneurial, and creative. We saw a lot of those efforts this afternoon, pickleball courts, new tennis courts, all kinds of initiatives happening from an empowered staff. To provide stable leadership, working with the council to establish strategic priorities, and to make this organization community-centric.

36:41 We could talk about the emergencies. We could talk about our good friend.

37:11 Mr. COVID. And managing and running a community that's on the front lines of climate change, of the changing climate. Wildfire to the winter. We just had this last year. This is a fascinating and interesting and challenging position. And Dan has certainly risen to all the occasions that came with that. But what's so endearing, I would say, about Dan and the culture he brings to this is that what he really enjoys doing is delivering sandbags to widows.

37:39 To reaching out to people in the community who need it. He does it with a smile. He does it with joy. He does it with bliss. And frankly, it really has inspired us all. So Dan, I don't know, is there a plaque or something? Do we give Dan something? Oh, it's right here. It's underneath the mail, Dan. I'm sorry. So this is a certificate of appreciation for Daniel C. Holler in recognition of 10 years of dedicated service to the citizens of Mammoth Lakes, October 1, 2023.

38:08 So I guess I'll ask my fellow council members to come down. Someone take a picture. We'll give this nice thing to Dan. Good for a moment. Yes, please, Bill. I want to reiterate what you said about the stability that Dan has brought to the organization and things that people don't see. I want to show much appreciation for his ability to take a diverse group of individuals and turn us into cohesive groups and to bring those things forward in a good and reasonable way.

39:54 A lot of our town managers haven't been able to do that. The continuity of having him for 10 years has been huge, and I just want to make sure that he understands our appreciation. I'd just like to add something, if I might. So I've been the town attorney for 13 years. The first three years I was here, we had three town managers, and then the last 10 years with Dan, and the town is in much better shape than we were when we were changing town managers every day.

40:22 Andy, I believe that you were the one that tipped Mr. Holler off that there was an opening down in Mammoth Lakes. Is that fair to say? I think there might have been something to that. Back in the day. Back in the day. Well, thank you for that. Okay, so moving on then. We're going to now get an October Community Recreation Center CRC update. Hayes and Stuart are here to walk us through this. Thank you. Yeah, we'll celebrate what feels like 10 years of construction.

40:54 So I've got a slide up here about the background, but I think we're all pretty familiar with the stats on this project. What I really want to accomplish today is to talk about what's happened in the last month and what's going to happen in the next month and give some dates on when we're planning to open this thing up. So since our last update, contractors have been working on the interior of the structure. They've done a lot of drywall and tile work. They've begun painting. We have interior doors.

41:24 They completed the HVAC system this afternoon. We have electricity now. As of a couple days ago, we have power, which is a monumental challenge to get that done. Our water and fire systems are complete and ready for testing. They have not done much work on the exterior. I think that's obvious for anybody who's driven by. That contractor only started working there a few days ago, but they've made some great progress.

41:50 And we are now deep into a commissioning plan, and we're coordinating with a number of people to make ice, both the contractor's people and the number of consultants and people that we work with. So near term, contractor, like I said, is working on the exterior work. They're starting to clean up. They've made arrangements to get some more bins, take off the trash, haul off some of the old material. They've got a crew that's going around the site kind of cleaning up all the debris, the dirt, and so forth.

42:21 Next week, they'll start installing the exterior windows and doors, so it'll start looking a lot more complete. Next week, they're going to install the seal between the ice rink and the existing concrete, which will allow us to put up the boards the week thereafter. Interior plumbing fixtures will follow the flooring in about two and a half to three weeks, and then we're going to make ice. In about three to four weeks, we'll be making ice. Longer-term items, sprung shield.

42:49 We've come to an agreement with the contractor to remediate some of the damage caused from their snow removal activities to put aluminum sheeting on the entire exterior of the building. That has a six to eight week lead time. We're working with the contractor to continue to do that through winter, make that happen. And then there will be punch list items. So little ticky tacky things, the dings on the wall, the scratches in the paint, little things will happen for probably four to six months is my gut.

43:17 We are working with the contractor to take, air quotes, ownership of the facility early so that we can operate. It's more important for us to have this facility functioning for the community than it being perfect. So schedule. We're hoping to be substantially complete by the end of October and get a certificate of occupancy. That'll allow Stu and his crew to start to move in and start to prep, get ready for operations.

43:45 We are targeting a soft opening the weekend of November 18th for a camp that's coming up. And then a public opening on November 24th. And then we'll do a big grand opening probably sometime in January, you know, get some dignitaries up here and, you know, kind of celebrate the facility. But it's a little – we don't have a lot of time to prepare for that, so we're just going to try to get open, start skating, start using the facility. I don't know if you have anything you want to add to the opening.

44:15 Yeah, we're kind of walking into this cautiously. You know, it's been a while. Hayes and his team and the contractor are making great progress. Our team has been working, as you know, for several months, well, several years, honestly, with our programming. We provide updates to the Parks and Recreation Commission every month, and then we'll be in front of you in November, and we'll kind of do the same thing.

44:41 Bring our programming update, how it's going to look, what we're going to be doing. I think that's really informative for the community. How's it look, you know, pre-Christmas versus post-Christmas, things like that. What we can, kind of what we can't do. Understanding that facility's going to be still ramping up over that kind of next period of time as well. But it's really important, you know, really excited to see this. This is kind of the first public, you know, awareness of the dates. I think that's really exciting for our community to get behind. I'm very excited.

45:09 So for us, the little soft opening is kind of a LA Kings high school hockey league. We've got some teams coming up to play on that weekend, which is a great way to kind of break into it. We'll kind of start through with kind of our local kids, get them on the ice for that week. And then we'd like to try and do a public opening before the Christmas tree lighting ceremony in the village. So we'll try and do something around four o'clock, just to kind of warm up the scissors again and see if we can kind of cut some more ribbon.

45:35 And then just kind of open it up to the community for a free skate night. So that's kind of how it looks up to that window of time. So really exciting. Thank you. Okay. Here we go. So I've got a few photos to walk you through. So again, there's an open invitation to all the council to go and tour the site. Just give me a phone call if you want to go walk around and see it firsthand. But you can see here that they've, you know, they got drywall up. The site's starting to get a little bit cleaner.

46:03 There's some paint on the walls. This is the men's and women's restroom. Our HVAC system is in. You can see the heating and so forth kind of on the restrooms and so forth. Data room. There's still a lot of cleanup that needs to happen, a lot of materials out there. Those of you who can really pay attention can see that there's curbing and framing on that main entrance in the front, getting prepared for the storefront and the doors.

46:28 That's the HVAC system I was talking about. Only a few rooms in this facility have heat, the locker rooms and the restrooms. I gave an image of this a month ago, and you can see all the plumbing. Now those walls have been finished and painted. There's tile in the bathrooms. It's covered in plastic to protect it, but it's been tiled and painted in all of the restrooms. You can see the big, huge HVAC system in the background there. Hallways are done. They've been painting the doors.

47:02 And kind of cleaning up some of the CMU and so forth in the hallways. This doesn't look like much. This is a big deal for me. They dug a big hole in our retention basin. That little bit of water you see on the path there is just the condensation in the morning. There's enough. This thing's an acre of impervious area. It puts off enough water just in the dew to actually drain off into the retention basin. So getting this site work done has been really important for the public works team. And they made some pretty good headway today.

47:36 On the south side of the facility. And they started installing the roof on our very large trash enclosure and mechanical rooms. That's all I got. Happy to answer any questions. Like Stu said, we'll be back in a month with another update with firming up dates and times and programming.

48:10 Glad to hear that perhaps we will have ice before the first of the year. That is truly exciting. The playground, I know we had to pull all of the material out of there and it all has to be replaced. Is that going to be happening this year still prior to snow? We don't believe so. We put our attention elsewhere. A significant amount of work needs to be done on the exterior of the entire site to make it safe for children to play.

48:39 Nails and broken glass that need to be cleaned up all around from the storm removal activities that occurred. They started on that only a couple days ago. I don't really see that getting completed and them getting out of our way to make it safe for children to play in that area. Oh yeah, there's an entire patio concrete area that gets built as part of the site work adjacent to it. The pickup list, and I'm sure it will be a long one, are we going to be able to do that work while we are open?

49:08 So we're working with our contractor. We're coming to terms on how that's actually going to play out. They understand our needs, our goals, our aspirations to get this facility open in November, and they're willing to work with us to continue working on those punch lists on an extended timeline, and we're coming to terms on kind of how that's exactly going to work out. I think for now that's about it. Okay. Chris, good. Amanda? Good. Okay. Thank you. Thank you guys very much for all your great work. All right. Moving on then to...

49:42 The consent agenda. Item 10.1 to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 6, 2023. Item 10.2 accept the project closeout report for Ballfield's rehabilitation project. Item 10.3 approve the resolution authorizing the town's participation in the CSCDA commercial open property assessed clean energy PACE program to provide commercial property owners.

50:08 Access to financing for renewable energy and building efficiency upgrades. Item 10.4, accept check register from August 30, 2023 in the amount of $530,400.24. Accept check register from September 7, 2023 in the amount of $793,992.39. Accept check register from September 14, 2023 in the amount of $3,433,620.93.

50:38 And accept check register from September 19th, the amount of $44,574.68. And accept check register from the 27th of September in the amount of $1,689,112.75. And I would entertain a motion. Move to approve as presented. I'll second. Excellent. Thank you. Any additional discussion? No. Any comments out there, Jamie? No. No. Okay. Roll call, please.

51:07 Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all. Moving on now to our policy matters. Item 11.1, waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter 10.12, parking. Thank you. Rob Patterson is joining us via Zoom. I think he's going to jump into this item. Or Sierra Schultz, they're both on.

51:35 So I'll defer to them, but the item before you is the parking element. It deals with the airport and that location. I think for some issues there we've been working through in order to manage the parking area in a manner that allows us to go after FAA grants for repair work and to clean up the parking area there. And so we did have to put some standards in there as it becomes a modified use, if you will, for lack of a better term, around the airport. The details of that, Sarah, Rob, if you want to jump into that.

52:04 Not. I'll walk through the staff report briefly and touch on those items there. But that's the primary elements we're looking at there to accommodate the FAA requirements of the airport. And Andy's also worked on the ordinance there, so there's some comments there. Yeah, I just wanted to suggest that you make a couple small changes to make the ordinance gender neutral. There are a few places where it says his, and I think we're now saying his slash her. So that shows up in Section 086.

52:35 Okay, is that, is the staff present? I don't see, she's, oh, hi, Sarah. Hi, yeah, I'm just online today, so, yeah, thanks, Dan, for the introduction, and good afternoon, counsel. So, I'll just give a little bit of background about the proposed changes to Chapter 10.12 of the Municipal Code.

53:07 Some of these changes are just a cleanup of our practices that we've been conducting for years, such as no RV parking, no trailer parking out at the airport. And then some of this language is new language to reflect some changes in kind of the practices out there.

53:26 We did request a grant to do the design of the parking lot to reconstruct it, and then we're going to be going after construction funds next fiscal year. And part of the FAA's eligibility language is that you're not collecting funds on a parking lot at our type of airport. Otherwise, you're ineligible to receive that funding. So our previous language did...

53:53 Have a fee of $8 a night included. So we did take that nightly fee away, and now it'll just be by a permit for airport users. So that's kind of where the changes are coming from in this language. We did coordinate with the public works director, police department, and the FBO as well, because they're going to help us with this permitting process.

54:20 Other than that, it's pretty straightforward. But if you guys have any questions or like to see any changes in the language, you know, please let us know. Okay. Thank you, Sarah. Any questions? I just have one coincidental observation. I read an article in San Francisco about the amount of money that the city of San Francisco is spending on one individual. So I think while we are a long way from that type of an area for all kinds of different reasons.

54:59 But I think Sierra and Dan and others, I think the definition of what an airport user is, the definition of the overnight parking process, what's actually going to be allowed out there is going to be important. We have an audience of lots of people coming here for all kinds of reasons and vehicles that are self-sufficient. They can sleep in them overnight and things like that. So I just want to make sure that you're confident that you can enforce and regulate these uses in a way that's going to be consistent with what we're doing.

55:29 Do you guys feel confident you can do that? I feel confident that we can do that. We are going to work closely with the FBO for issuing these permits. So as far as an airport user, really, it's going to be defined as somebody that has legitimate purposes at the airport. This really coincides with the FAA's intentions of the use of an airport parking lot, as well as avoiding any conflicts that we've seen of people leaving broken down cars.

56:00 Cars that are waiting for parts coming and so people are just staging them while they're waiting to get fixed, people camping, and just really in the winter as well, they're leaving trailers that might not be loaded so you can't see them under the snow. So a lot of this language is coming from a place of trying to correct and just clarify to the users really what's permitted and understanding why we're kind of doing what we're doing.

56:29 And as far as the permit process, anyone who has legitimate purpose, such as their passenger on a flight, their pilot or FBO business, town business, I mean, they'll all be welcome to park there as needed. Or if somebody is renting a car because their vehicle.

56:48 Can't leave town. Maybe it's just not up to par. They can leave it while they're renting the vehicle. So I think there's a few details to work out on how we're going to administer this, but we've all coordinated and I think it should be fine. Okay. All right. Any public comment on this item? I'm not hearing, seeing any additional discussion, otherwise I'd entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion to waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending municipal code.

57:20 Chapter 10.12 parking with the changes recommended by Town Attorney. I'll second. Okay, thank you. Additional discussion? No. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all for that. Moving on now to item 11.2, Inyo National Forest OSV Subpart C Engagement and Public Comment. Mr. Reef.

57:54 Hello, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Give me a moment to share my screen, please. Excellent. Before I jump into this, as you can see in your packet, I think the goal of this today is for you all to review, comment, and provide direction as a body to provide a public comment for OSV subpart C, which is due October 20th. So with that in mind, I want to go through.

58:39 Some information related to this project. Some of this stuff I'm going to move through pretty quickly. You will see that basically I hijacked the PowerPoint that the Forest Service used to inform some of the process information and how this all works. So if you do have any questions, kind of at the beginning part, feel free to chime in, but I will go through this stuff relatively quickly.

59:08 But again, we will talk about the rules and requirements as it relates to subpart C, what is the proposed action, how to submit comments and timelines, and Mammoth-specific info. Now, one thing I will say as well before I jump in is included in your packet were Mammoth-specific maps along with the proposed action. You may have noticed the letter from Leslie Yen in there. There's a link in there that will get you all the information for the proposed action, but I did not want to give you guys 200 pages of...

59:37 Copy proposed action. I tried to put in what was pertinent. All right. Rules and requirements. Again, the goal of OSV subpart C, provide access and recreational opportunities, ensure that OSV use is designated only where adequate, safety of all users, minimize impacts to natural and cultural resources, and minimize conflicts.

1:00:01 Again, this is part of the travel management rules that requires the Inyo National Forest to take on this process. And again, what else does the rule say? Over the snow vehicle use, National Forest Systems roads, trails, and lands shall be designated by the responsible official, who is the forest supervisor, to basically outline where this OSV use is allowed and where snowfall use is adequate to allow that use to occur.

1:00:31 Again, just moving through this area quickly, I think, again, translation, we'll just look at that part here for right now. All areas not specifically designated for OSV use are closed to OSV use. That will be the end result of this. And please think of the end result of this process as a map. Where can you go? Where can you not go? What is included in the proposed action? Again, want to move through this stuff relatively quickly.

1:01:00 But it only applies to public recreational users, such as any of us. It will apply to only motorized OSV use. So again, this is not a process for non-motorized. It's a process for motorized only. As you can see, authority to consider class of vehicle, season of use. And again, OSV management, not general winter recreation management. Current situation, entire forest is open OSV use, except where it is specifically prohibited.

1:01:31 I.E. Wilderness, RNAs, Resource Natural Areas, places like that. And due to that and what was mentioned prior, it does not meet the travel management rule as it currently sits. Again, areas with adequate snowfall. The Indian National Forest made this determination using remote sensing lab data. And then they are saying that areas that receive at least 12 inches of snow on average for at least five days per year

1:02:01 Receive adequate snowfall for cross-country OSV use and were considered OSV area designation, meaning those are the only areas that they are going to consider for OSV use are those areas that receive at least 12 inches of snow on average for at least five days per year. And again, how did we develop the proposed action? I took this directly from the NEO, so it was not me or us.

1:02:29 Determine which areas could not be designated based on law, regulation, and the forest plan, right? So all those are automatically not going to be a part of the process. Determine which areas had adequate snowfall. Determine where there could be adverse impacts to natural or cultural resources. Determine whether those impacts could be reasonably minimized. And if so, prescribe management requirements to minimize those impacts. Oh, I went back, I believe. Oh, no.

1:02:58 Areas were not considered at all. We talked a lot about the ski areas, bristlecone pines, resources, natural areas. Again, we'll move through this quickly. Basically, here are the areas that they proposed designating as part of this initial proposed action. Again, here we can see the Mammoth Lakes area and what that looks like. These maps are in your packet as well. I actually have very, very large hard copy maps that I bought from the forest as well, which I actually forgot to.

1:03:25 Bring here with me. But I can provide those as well if folks want to look at them. But it is nice to look at it on a computer, zoom in, and take a look. Again, here we are, Mammoth Lakes area. What you can see on the map may look a little familiar, and we'll talk about this as well. Here is the Tamarack area. I just wanted to conclude that, which also shows the area of the Sherwins on the right. And how does this prepare to existing management?

1:03:55 Roughly, roughly, and we'll talk about a few exceptions, status quo, status quo. So generally the same as current management with some exceptions. What happened to current OSV closures? Again, this talks a bit about the process that was used to determine, for instance, the April 17th opening date for the Mammoth Lakes Basin, why there is no OSV use at Obsidian Dome, shady Nordic Trails, things of that nature. And these all remain in effect.

1:04:28 Through the proposed action, although Rock Creek may look a little different. I know out of our jurisdiction, but I wanted to point that out. All right, we'll move through this very, very quickly as well. Just talk about process here real quick. How do you submit comments? Basically, you go to a website and you submit your comments. I don't want to get too in-depth here. Again, I can provide more information. I think the meat and potatoes of this is your interaction as it relates to this process. Again, just...

1:04:58 Providing info of what this looks like. If any of you have any questions about this, you can obviously reach out to me as well. Again, just how to comment. All of that information listed right here. How to comment effectively and appropriately as well. As the Forest Service has brought up, I don't like snowmobiling is probably not the best way to comment. Let's talk about user conflict.

1:05:26 Let's talk about noise. Let's talk about some tangible type items in our public comments that are not value judgments in a sense on the activity itself. And I think we all know that, but again, wanted to provide this information. And another one, what does this timeline look like? This is going to go through several public comment periods.

1:05:51 A larger scale objection period and objection review until a final decision notice is released. Again, I don't want to go through this in every minute detail. The bottom line is we're looking at around 2025. If everything goes smoothly for this map that we were talking about before, that will actually outline where you can and can't go. Now we'll move in briefly here as well to Mammoth specific information before we have a dialogue with you all.

1:06:22 Do any town recreational or planning documents reference OSV use? And I want to clarify here on one thing. You will see here this is from the Sherwin's Working Group, which became a part of the Sherwin's Area Recreation Plan, which then was adopted by town council as part of the trail system master plan. So what I am about to say and what you will see here is

1:06:52 Adopted by Town Council through the Trail System Master Plan and through the Sherwin's Working Group and subsequently the Sherwin Area Recreation Plan. Again, if there's any questions about that, please let me know. But basically this says if the town is going to groom a system at the base of the Sherwin's, primarily in the Sherwin's Meadow, that the recommendation of this document would be

1:07:19 Open to non-motorized use only. And you can see that basically three lines up after sea summer map ID number eight. You will see that listed there. Again, I don't think I need to read this entire thing right now, but that was the only, for lack of a better word, town document or council approved document that I could find that really referenced or spoke to OSV use. Of course, if anybody knows of something I may have missed, please let me know.

1:07:49 So, in the proposed action,

1:08:19 They are now listed as open, which includes some areas around Earthquake Dome, although not Earthquake Dome itself. Further north, the Cherry Stem as you get up to the Obsidian Nordic Trails as well. Some areas south of there, of course, not the Nordic Trail area itself. Some areas north of that area as well as Saddlebag Lake and some areas around Tioga Lake. This is, again, a proposed action. It is a...

1:08:47 This initial proposed action, a tabula rasa of sorts, a blank slate, although not completely, based on forest rules and regulations.

1:08:56 Again, as part of this process, I wanted to remind everyone that expanded grooming that we would propose as the Town of Mammoth Lakes would be a part of this process and would need to go through a NEPA process. You probably did not see anything related to this in the initial proposed action, but the Inyo National Forest is looking at this with us, and we are continuing to truth some items on the ground before we submit this as part of this.

1:09:22 For lack of a better word, first comment period. I wouldn't call it a public comment. The INEO just wants to re-get this information from us to ensure that any NEPA processes that do occur through this would occur related to these trails. One thing you will see in the proposed action, I think that is a little bit different, and we'll talk about this. This exact map is not in there, was a staging area down there in the lower left hand at New Shady Rest Dump Station.

1:09:53 That would be OSV staging to provide a delineation of uses between motorized and non-motorized in one of the busier areas for both of those uses here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. As you all know, Shady Rest, big staging area, right, for these types of uses. But what the INYO did propose in their proposed action wasn't necessarily

1:10:21 The best method to maybe achieve this delineation on the ground. What they proposed basically is going on the opposite side of sawmill cutoff road. It gets very hilly, off camber, many trees. I don't even believe their groomer can make it through. So as a result, we met with their NEPA planner, Aaron Nesser, and proposed to them the red line right there would be OSV following the existing MUP, multi-use pathway, crossing over the road that goes into the park.

1:10:49 Going all the way around the top of the park and connecting with the A-Trail, which is the yellow line in the top right. That would eliminate all OSV use within Shady Rest Park proper, right? This was our proposal to them in order for us to not lose our mileage of groomed cross-country ski trail because some of our trail followed that red line. We would bump our trail over to the east, which the INYO supports, and that's the yellow line in the middle.

1:11:18 To allow us to not lose any of our non-motorized, for lack of a better word, cross-country ski trails, even though other uses use those as well. So I think you will see something in the next proposed action after this first round of public comments that would look something like this in the shady rest area. And we do feel this could eliminate some conflict, delineate the user groups, and create...

1:11:45 To the best of our ability, staging for each of those groups, although I don't believe we can say this is snowmobiles only, this is non-motorized only. We can encourage that, though. And again, moving forward, other items to consider. You may not have seen on this proposed action a high elevation staging area. Would you all as a body want to recommend something like that as part of your public comment, i.e. the cinder shed?

1:12:13 Scenic Loop Staging Area. Are there any areas on the Scenic Loop where maybe we could provide some access? Other locations for delineation of uses. We talked about the Sherwins briefly. There were a lot of conversations about the Minaret Vista area when we met as a group prior to discuss these things with the Forest Service. Are there other locations that you can think of that are maybe hotbeds for, for lack of a better word, conflict? Or even if...

1:12:43 Maybe direct conflict isn't present, areas that just make sense, where we could maybe delineate some of these uses. Sherwin's Working Group, part of the Trail System Master Plan, as mentioned before, that recommendation. Would Council want to move forward with that recommendation as part of this public comment, being that it is part of an adopted town document? And, of course, other ideas and recommendations.

1:13:10 So that is all I had. I went a little more long-winded than I wanted. But again, I would love for you all to review this, comment, provide direction. I don't necessarily want to tell you how to do this, but maybe one at a time. Folks could go through and provide information on what they think. Okay, so I think what we're going to do is, if there are any technical questions for Lawson, we'll ask those now. Turn it over to public comment. Then maybe some people want to provide some information on that. Then we'll bring it back from some...

1:13:40 Deliberation. And I think it's important to make clear this is not, this is just the beginning of this effort. This is by no means the end. I think we certainly will want to hear from the community. The community is already pretty engaged with this. A lot of comments are already being posted. And I think we can, we can provide some initial direction. Sure. And one initial comment or question is that we, the town, is providing comments that we will have standing as part of this process, correct?

1:14:05 Yes, and we are through an MOU, an official, for lack of a better word, cooperator or partner in this process, but you all as a body, as the town of Mammoth Lakes, have the opportunity to comment on this process. Okay, so I'll open up to any questions, any technical questions, process questions? Yes, Ms. Bubser. Quick, October 20th. October 20th. Thank you. Thank you so much.

1:14:33 And I just want to note that I attended the online and the in-person meetings because I wanted to make sure that I saw what the feelings were with the public. And so, Lawson, I do have just a couple of questions. First of all, can you talk a little bit more about the cinder shed? Because I've heard a lot of, you know, discussion around the cinder shed. There needs to be an access area that's at a higher elevation. But what are the sort of...

1:15:01 Pros and cons as you see it to putting an OSV trailhead at the cindershed. Well, so right now there is no official mechanism that I know of that authorizes that as a current high elevation staging area with an appropriate agreement for plowing.

1:15:23 Of that area. And I know Mr. Sauser here has a good amount of experience with the cinder shed as well. But based on what I know about it, it was a handshake agreement at one time to basically clear that area for OSB use. Now that we are going through subpart C, now is the time to either authorize that in the most appropriate manner possible or move on. I think there's going to be two things that affect that. Number one is the expansion of Woolies.

1:15:51 What will that look like? Will that expansion allow for an effective parking area in that location? Then I think the other one is who is going to maintain it? Who will actually do that plowing? Who will provide that maintenance after storms?

1:16:11 Full disclosure, I have a snowmobile. I've used that parking area before. I think it can be an effective parking area. I think some leveling would need to occur. I think eventually paving that site would probably be very beneficial, providing maybe a little bit of a better avenue for trailers there, things of that nature. But in terms of a standalone location on its own, I think it does.

1:16:39 Meet the needs of a solid OSV staging area. But there are other considerations at play, which includes Woolies, that expansion, who would provide that maintenance, is that maintenance feasible, things of that nature. But I think in and of itself, it does provide a nice high elevation access point and connects directly to the existing groom trail system. I need to make a few comments here.

1:17:08 I just want to make sure we get kind of the technical questions out of the way. If it's a technical matter, let's do that. This is how the cinder shed became in the first place. My problem is normally I would meet with all of you separately and give you this history because I don't need to bore you all with it here. But by law, I'm not allowed to do that. So this is bringing up an issue for me. How can I – I lived this. Me and my organization created the Orange Diamond Trail System. We created the grooming program.

1:17:38 That groomed both for motorized and non-motorized. So I have information that normally I would not disseminate here or now, but I can't talk to one of you about it otherwise. Stay away from deliberation, but just share what you've got to share. So the cinder shed happened because the forest service used to require Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to have a parking lot behind the inn for over-snow vehicles.

1:18:06 Because that's all Forest Service land. That was part of their permit. The Mountain came to me and said, this doesn't work for us. What about we move it to the Cinder Shed? The Forest Service gave me permission to go up there with my own loader and clear the stumps. What the Cinder Shed was originally was a landing for a logging operation. So there were stumps and we cleared the debris and we flattened it out.

1:18:35 And I plowed the snow for three years. Then we ended up, on our own dime, being the person I worked for, then the mountain ended up entering into a handshake agreement that they would plow it. And that happened for several years. Much to my dismay, as with a lot of the stuff I've done with the Forest Service, they are now telling us there's no documentation of any of this. They can't find it. This has been a recurring theme with our forest up here. So that's how we got there.

1:19:04 So that's the history of it and how we got there. Again, I wish I could take you all...

1:19:34 Yeah, very helpful. Thank you. Yes, please. Okay. So then, you know, the bullet about an alternative staging area on the scenic loop, I know that the community has a lot of thoughts about the Inyo craters and uses there, so I would just recommend that before we put our letter in, we make sure that we really hear what the community's concerns and issues are around that area.

1:20:06 So I'm glad that was in there. I see that the recommendation of the Sherwin's Working Group wasn't included. So I see you've noted that. The wait a minute at Vista, I'm glad you brought that up because in the second meeting where we were in person with the Forest Service staff, they talked about having an impression that there isn't room for there to be sort of a bifurcated trail where half could be for over snow and the other half is for hikers.

1:20:36 And cross-country skiers. And it seems to me like we need to correct that misconception. And then, let's see, there's a bullet here that talks about the snow depth requirement. And the INYO has chosen to do 12 inches, but statewide, the snow depth is 18 inches. And I'm just curious if we're going to comment on that, because in the bullet, it just...

1:21:04 That they chose 12, but the rest of the states chose an 18, so I don't understand. Yeah, and that is for grooming, specifically, as far as I know. That 18-inch requirement is for winter grooming, for winter grooming. Okay, okay, so. Because that involves state funds, right? And through the groomer is paid for by the state, through the state program, and part of their regulation is that 18 inches. Okay, so.

1:21:32 We probably won't have anything to say about what snow depth the Inyo chose for places that are in and out of the proposal. Yes, but being that I think there are areas within your purview as a town council member, I think you would be well within your right to say we would recommend matching the state at 18 inches.

1:22:00 You could still say that or that could still be your recommendation if you also desired. It just seems more consistent to me. So then finally, those are all my questions. So thank you for it's a very thorough review that you did. And I appreciate it. OK, questions. Amanda, do you have any questions? Well, thanks for the overview of everything. I personally had a very difficult time reading the maps. So I just I.

1:22:32 Looked at it. I don't know. It was just really difficult to tell. And I don't do OSB stuff, but I know that a lot of people in town do, and they care about this. And so, you know, I would love to hear from people if they have an opinion about this. But I, you know, and I don't know if I could meet with you with your large maps and go over that, but I really had a hard time reading the maps.

1:23:03 Copy. Yeah, we could certainly meet and discuss if needed. And again, I want to be very clear, too. This is, while obviously very important, first step in the public comment process. And the INEO has already more or less said that many of the things that we may be, whether it is those delineation of uses in the Sherwins, right, they are already thinking about that, too, in terms of their alternatives to this proposed action, which they will release.

1:23:34 Most likely at least two alternatives to the proposed action. After this first public comment period, there will be opportunities to comment again as well. So you won't be done with me as it relates to this process. Questions? No questions because I've lived this. The only other comment in the, we talk about creating a new staging area at the new Shady Rest. Actually, that was the staging area for years and years, plowed by the Forest Service.

1:24:07 The bathrooms were cleaned by a volunteer group that we put together. It is the only place where you can create a staging area where there is already a winterized bathroom. So it doesn't have to be blue boxes. It's very, very certain. But it has been a staging area for literally decades. So my only questions are, as we discussed, this is the beginning of the process. And so the council...

1:24:34 Does not, we're not under any obligation to provide, you know, prescriptive, specific, because I think we, I think we all want to hear from constituents and those kinds of things. So this is just the beginning. When do you anticipate the, the first, when will they publish their first set of alternatives? You said 2024 sometime? Yeah, I need to, here, let me go back and just double check. I didn't have that date memorized.

1:24:59 Uh, so they're talking about after this first public comment, uh, and scoping period, uh, they will develop alternatives in 2023 with the hope of then, uh, beginning their effects analysis as well in late 2023, um, but I would anticipate the next document for folks to comment on in early 2024. Okay, and I've, uh, I think we've all heard that the, uh, international forest lead on this project, woman named Erin Nesser, is leaving.

1:25:28 Do you have any information about how the Forest Service is going to do with the continuity with this effort? So I don't know all of the insights, but what I will say is there is currently a North Zone NEPA planner, North Zone meaning Mammoth and Mona Lake Ranger districts. A NEPA planner is the position that Aaron is in, and they have a staff person and are planning on having that staff person take the lead. As far as I know, with Aaron still being here to relay information.

1:25:56 To that person. But yes, unfortunately, Aaron is leaving. Okay. All right. I have any more questions. I think at this point, if there's any public comment or folks who'd like to speak, yes, please, David, come forward. Yeah, I'll try to keep myself to the three minutes. I'm David Page. Five minutes? Five minutes. We're five minutes these days. Yeah, Council, Mr. Mayor, Bill, Chris, Amanda, good to see you, staff. I'm a local resident for 17 years.

1:26:30 Also the Executive Director of an organization called Winter Wildlands Alliance. We've been involved in this process on a dozen forests for about seven or eight years, so I've seen the process from beginning to end. So just a couple things to say about what I think of as my own forest. Thanks, Lawson, for a really good overview. I think you covered everything really well. I was going to clarify that bit about the two or three alternatives.

1:26:59 But you hit it. I think that's one place where there's a real opportunity right now, as specific as we can get now, the more likely those things are to be incorporated in one of those alternatives for the public to react to. I think my sense of the timeline is that that EA would come out basically a year from now, in October of 2024. So basically they'll take all of our public comments from October 20th.

1:27:28 And then spend a year creating those alternatives and coming up with the EA. And then we'll get another public comment period in a year. And hopefully that'll be, you know, there's alternative A, B, C, and people can say, well, I like this part of alternative A, but not this part. So, again, really appreciate you guys coming on as a cooperating agency because I think the data you have, the experience, the ground truth.

1:27:52 The Forest Service doesn't necessarily have it, so being able to share that as specifically as possible, as early as possible in the process will lead to a map that we can all be really happy with. So, you know, and we've spent, having been on the Trails Committee, I know we've spent millions of dollars over the decades in terms of planning efforts, master plans for trails and recreation management, and often that...

1:28:20 Falls on deaf ears by the time we get to the Forest Service. We've had that experience on a number of levels, and this one is coming at us from them, so it's a really cool opportunity for us to engage and actually land something on the ground. One other thing just to highlight, because it wasn't in Aaron's slides and wasn't necessarily clarified in Lawson's, but there are a bunch of what they call minimization criteria that the Forest Service has to follow, has to sort of put it through a test.

1:28:50 And two of them, I think, that are really relevant to us as a community are minimizing conflicts between uses. So where is it appropriate for snowmobiles? Where is it appropriate for cross-country skiing, backcountry skiing, snowshoeing, camping, all the other things? So even though, yes, it's designating for OSV use, it is also obviously creating a management plan for all the other uses at the same time.

1:29:15 Impacts to neighborhoods and congested or populated areas is another minimization criteria. So they need to think about how does motorized use impact neighborhoods. So that's another thing for us in this town to think about, especially with their first proposed action. Basically, when you get to look at the map, Amanda, and their interactive map on the Forest Service website is actually pretty good. You can zoom in and really see right where your particular zone, where it's designated.

1:29:48 But their first proposal is basically right up to the edge of town, all the way around town, is open to motorized use. So that's something to just think about. Like, should we have, you know, we have, let's say, 20% of our town boundary is ski area, 80% is going to be open to motorized uses, with the one exception of the...

1:30:12 The parking at the top of Lake Mary Road, which is only open to OSV after April 16th. But that has, you know, 17 to 20 parking spots as a very busy zone. So should we have non-motorized trailheads as well? I think so. So that's something to think about. And just quickly, three numbers for you to hold in your heads.

1:30:33 These are the latest numbers from Snowsports Industries of America and the Ski Areas Association and the Snowmobile Association of America. There are 12 million resort skiers and snowboarders nationally, 12 million. There are 27 million non-motorized, non-resort winter recreationists, so snowshoers, fat bikers, backcountry skiers, Nordic skiers, whatever, walking their dogs.

1:30:59 27 million. So more than twice as many of those as resort skiers. And then there are 1.26 million registered snowmobiles in the U.S. So it's a very small number. The Forest Service National Visitor Use Monitoring number has snowmobiling at 1% of forest uses, which is not to say that we should do away with snowmobiling. It's an important use on this forest.

1:31:27 But I think we can find ways. I was going to talk about shady rest. I think it's an awesome idea. We've been on the ground, looked at it. One quick thing to say about that, the forest supervisor seems open to the idea of starting right away this winter, plowing shady rest as a test. And so possibly we could get the town involved in starting that right away and see how that goes. And then I think we have a similar way of separating uses that could happen.

1:31:55 At the propane tanks. Excellent. Thank you, David. Okay, so I think what I'd like to do, Lawson, if you could put up the slide that lists the town, kind of those high-level recommendations. And with the understanding that this is just the beginning. Yeah, if I may on that too, you have that list and that's page one and two of the staff report bullet points in there. Okay.

1:32:22 Thank you.

1:32:49 Link back into some of the comments made and back into some of our own documentation. Okay. Yeah, that one. Exactly. And does this align pretty much with the order that's in the staff report? I'm assuming it probably does. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, there's a couple more items in the staff report, but yes. Okay. Well, should we work off the staff report or work off the slide? Staff report. Staff report. Okay. Let's do that. All right. We'll have this up here just because it's...

1:33:18 Pretty picture looks nice. Okay. So I think what we're looking for is just a general consensus of these ideas. I think the caveat would be is that we all want to hear from the public. We know that there is a program within the Office of Outdoor Recreation for the Mammoth Trails, you know, the Confederation of User Groups, which I think is meeting at the end of October. I wanted to jump in. We do have a meeting at the end of October, but it would be after this public comment period. Understood.

1:33:48 We're planning on obviously bringing this topic up at that time, but it would be after. That's fine. We can start with this. Council, in a general sense, is looking at these kinds of things, but I think we really want to take advantage of that community forum. Hey, the council's saying this. What do you guys think? Well, we like this. We don't like this. This is unusable. And just develop this as we go forward so by the time these next alternatives come out, we've got a more focused way to kind of engage with that.

1:34:17 All right, so I'll just read through these things and you can, we'll do sort of a thumbs up. This is page 77 of 189. Do you know which number it is under 11.2? One, two, three. Sorry, I'm trying to pull it up. Oh, it's under analysis? It's like it's 77 of the packet, if that helps. Yeah, page 77 of the packet. It's the very first page of this item. Okay, thank you. John, before we go through the bullets,

1:34:46 It seems to me like what I've been hearing at the two meetings I attended and then when talking to people is that there's a principle that we're trying to sort of hold to in the town of Mammoth Lakes that there is room for all uses on our very large forest, but that the thing that is really important for us is for public safety and for pleasantness of uses to try to make it so that

1:35:16 When people are going out from a common area, like a common staging area, that we just make sure that the uses are as clearly delineated as possible so you don't have dogs and snowshoers running into OSVs. And I do think that, I don't know that we've ever stated it that plainly, but I think that would help the Forest Service understand a lot of the...

1:35:45 Questions I've heard from townsfolk. So how do you achieve that? You've got a grooming goal. Yeah. Then how do you separate that out? Are you saying we need to groom four different trails? And how do you do that? The Forest Service currently uses motorized dollars. Yeah. And with support from us, they do some non-motorized grooming as well. So I think the example was the proposal at Shady Rust. Because that meets that criteria, which is...

1:36:16 That as the OSVs go around the park, they can still get where they wanted to go, but we are encouraging folks to just take a different path to get there. But allowing them to use any path they wish. Well, that's why I said the principle is to... Right, an awful lot of users choose to exist. It is fringes on both ends that choose... Well, I think what we could do is I think that the comment about, just a very high-level comment about public safety and...

1:36:50 Valued experience for all users. We could just kind of go forward with that, and then it's obviously going to be in the details of how, to your point, how do those values get implemented and realized. Encouraging, not requiring. I said encouraging. I want to make sure, as we all look at this, historically, the uses have all been going on here for literally decades. Has there been an actual problem with actual conflict?

1:37:19 Is there that issue or is there an adequate space already designed for both if they choose to do that? To say that there is huge conflict so we have to separate the conflict eliminates the history of the programs and how hard several of us have worked to create this program, the political fight to get the grooming money. I would hate to see it all go to waste and I will tell you from my standpoint we are at the verge of losing some very important programs.

1:37:49 So I think it's how we operate this. We've got two years to kind of get into the, but I think if we step those kind of high level values, you know, safety, quality experiences for all users, that's what the council at a high level is looking for. That's fine, John, but you're going to continue to hear me comment on the history and where we've been versus the rhetoric that's being put forward to a lot of us. The calls to action on emails.

1:38:18 That are less than truthful. All right. Let's go through these bullets, and we'll just kind of get a sense of, you know, so you heard an expression about safety and quality experiences for all users. Okay, so the first bullet is the industry proposed a trailhead at new Shady Rest dump station parking area, along with a groomed trail to the Shady Rest park area. Staff recommends supporting this proposed action. Final alignment and separation from groomed trails that need to be addressed. I would generally

1:38:49 Support that. I don't know what anybody else thinks, but I would generally support that idea. Yes, and keeping in mind as well, logistics related to that in terms of plowing. Generally, that seems like a good idea. Anybody else? I agree. Okay, so we're good with that one. All right. In this initial proposed action, there is no reference to higher elevation trailhead. Staff is recommending that such a trailhead be supported with the proposed location at the Cinder Shed off of Highway 203. Again, I would generally support that.

1:39:21 That's a reasonable thing to do. Yeah? We're good? Don't let me, if you may have got things otherwise, let me know. Okay, there's no reference to an alternative staging area on the scenic loop. Staff supports consideration for staging area off of the scenic loop to enhance safety and reduce potential conflict areas. I would generally support that. Go ahead.

1:39:45 My only concern with the scenic loop is sledding. I feel like we, a lot of, my family, we go sledding out there. There's only been once or twice where, you know, we were sledding and somebody came by on a snowmobile unexpectedly. I think the recommendation on our end would be not to put a staging area anywhere near where that lane, that extra lane is, right, where everybody parks and sleds. My recommendation,

1:40:15 Would be further down the scenic loop away from where many of those uses occur. Okay, I would be supportive of that. I think our biggest concern there is that it was silent to that. Do you think there needs to be staging areas on the scenic loop that's probably adequate for that? We didn't want to prescribe one generally for a supportive one that's still, but I think that needs to be analyzed on that.

1:41:22 One thing I would add to this is that, and I think that they should now go back to this one about the very first one, the new Shady Rest. Previous District Ranger, you know, made a decision about putting an OSV, OHV trail edge staging area somewhere out on Sawmill Cutoff Road. It would be helpful, I think, for all of us to know, what is the status of this? And that we don't get, you know, all tangled up. Well, we've already got one over there, blah, blah, blah.

1:42:08 Because I think to clean up the records that have or have not been established. So I think we're good with that one. This is the shady rest. Okay. The recommendations of the Sherman's Working Group was not included in the initial proposed action as noted above. My only comment with that is we should change the language of the Sherman Area Recreation Plan, right, which is the adopted policy. I think it's supportive, especially because the town is now, you guys are.

1:42:44 And currently we have what has been a multi-year pilot program effectively grooming one line in that meadow currently, which in the map I showed in your packet I believe should be the one blue line that you see out at the base of the Shermans. So in terms of our comment with the town, this is sort of a question about the proposed grooming. Do we want to make any kind of a statement about we support

1:43:15 So my comment on the Sharp proposal is that it would close the, in my memory, it would close the entire Meadow area.

1:43:52 Effectively, as I understood it, you can use Telebowls as that marker and more or less everything west of Telebowls. So the problem I have with that is once the Lakes Basin opens on the 17th of April, the best access, although the Forest Service hasn't allowed us to sign it or use it or anything else, we're creating a staging area out here that actually will have parking. And the best access to the basin will be from that lot on Old Mammoth Road.

1:44:26 So a corridor through it or allowing an open date for motorized to go through it that ties into the lake's basin plan makes great sense to me. Otherwise, you know, the poaching issues, however you want to deal with it, that will be the staging area for that area. And while it is not hugely important to snowmobilers in general when the basin is closed, when it is open,

1:44:56 I think it's something worth considering.

1:45:46 So I think what we could do, I'm willing to say, let's go and let's entertain, let's look at.

1:46:37 Something that's some kind of an alignment to be something that's connected from the Sherwin's Trailhead up to the, you know, up to the basin after April 17th. But it needs, it needs, we need, you know, as a general idea, let's take a look at it. But I don't know what I'm looking at. May I ask Bill, what do you do now? Like, where do people stage currently snowmobiling up to Lakes Basin after April 17th? All over the place. Uh-huh. You'll see them parked at the end of the last several times I've accessed the Lakes Basin. It's been from the borough pit.

1:47:13 I will say also in my experience with users that are less OSB users that are less savvy than Mr. Sauser, Lake Mary Gate. Lake Mary Gate is often where you see folks going, especially who don't have that knowledge to know. You could even go to Old Mammoth Road or park at the tanks.

1:47:53 Go over the top. I'd be comfortable looking at some kind of a corridor, something like that, but not just opening. Grooming out there, we've still got a lot of snow, and people are used to being out there, and they're on the groom, never doing whatever they're doing, corridor, some sort of way to make. And also, Bill, you are an extremely professional-grade snowman. A fat old man at this point. Well, once upon a time. But imagine people who just show up, and, oh, I mean, I can get from here to there, and they don't know it, and it's...

1:48:32 Yeah, so you mark the trails, and they go up. The summer activities, the forest only allows us to show certain trails when we have, you know, we have trails that go down Mammoth Creek that are great trails. We're not allowed to even show those in a map. The reason that this route doesn't get used is because we've never been allowed to put it. Okay, so let's put the sharp recommendation with considerate someone to come up with a, we'll figure that out when we get, we've got a recommendation. Okay, everybody happy? Amanda's thinking, you're good? I'm good. Okay.

1:49:14 All right. No delineation of uses was included on the way to Minaret and Vista. This is a heavily used route, and some used delineation will be beneficial to the... And I would really agree with that. That's anybody who uses that corridor, I mean, everybody's up there. We need to, I don't know, but I think we need to figure out some way to manage that. It's more of like a, it's like a, it's like a arterial. I mean, the sledders are heading up to the ridge up there, cross-country skiers that may be just doing...

1:49:47 The problem with that would be some routes that I am told now are overgrown that we use. The problem becomes all of the area to the right of motorized recreation. Even though it's not wilderness and it's not used by others, that was closed out a long time ago. So as a motorized group, we are limited to the road. So perhaps we can create a blue diamond trail off the road down the hill.

1:50:27 I believe the initial proposed action, again, the initial proposed action would open that area that you're speaking about. Yes. So the question then becomes the original road that used to go through, is it still passable? And if not, you know, and it probably is not. The last time I was in there before they closed it, there were an awful lot of little five-foot trees already. So if you're on 20, that would be something I would really want to look at. How do you create that separation?

1:51:01 I will also say that the use of the Minaret Summit area became what it is today when we got the grooming dollars and the Forest Service started grooming the snowmobile trail around the back of the inn into Minaret Summit. We created a lot of great opportunities now we're being not have access in. So I have no problem with the separation if we can make it occur at some expense other than the motorized grooming program. So it's kind of a technical question. Grooming right now, I believe the skier... Yes.

1:51:40 Are they doing that under a permit? I believe that they are in support of their snowmobile operations. Okay. And that's when it changed hands. Part of that is now driven by the mountain. The Forest Service still goes over some of it on occasions. Not often. Not often. And I think another dynamic to this, which I didn't bring into the equation just as it relates to timing, is Mammoth Main Lodge redevelopment. Yeah, exactly. And that's an excellent point, I think, for all of us, like the cinder shed and this conversation right here.

1:52:18 These are things that I think if we're establishing access, safety, good recreation experiences, these are values that we would bring into the discussion around the main lodge redevelopment without having to get super specific about exactly what and where. But look, this needs to happen. This needs to happen. As general values, I think will help us inform this. So if we may on this one, the idea wasn't to come up with a solution, but referencing that right now it's free for all on that road.

1:52:54 A little better delineation there would probably make it a very better experience for everybody. I think there's adequate space and room up there, just defining some routes. I think our statement here is it was silent, but looking at delineation there, it's not saying end of use, it's saying let them all use it together, but let's figure something out. I think there is some delineation there. Good. Yeah, I think we're good with that. Okay.

1:53:27 The INIO used a snow depth requirement to determine if an area would be eligible to be considered for OSV use. Data was compiled from the NOAA Snow Data Assimilation System to model average snow depth. In this initial proposed action, only areas receiving on average at least 12 inches of snow five days per year were considered. Was there staff have a thought on that? Yeah, I think we're making a statement there. This, I think, is the overall use area, not the green trail issue which has that different snow level.

1:53:57 So this is how the use area is being defined based on... Is council basically comfortable with... When you look at the overall... I think it's looking at the overall open areas that has to have that level of snow area in order to be designated for... It's not necessarily the groomed trails that has the higher standard. I think that's the differential in the two. The original Forest Service thought on this was to create an elevation, and we talked about that.

1:54:42 Because when we have a 17 or when we have a 23, the snow goes, it is rideable much lower. So they came up with this snow depth rather than a hard closure and elevation. And for me, this works really well. Okay, I'm agnostic. I don't know one way or the other. I don't know. I have no expertise in this. I'm going to say it works. It works. I don't know. It was more of, I guess, a comfort level with that. It went back around a lot of discussions. How do you measure where and what?

1:55:21 Yeah, and I think comparing it to the existing condition, right? So the existing condition is, you know, basically if there's snow, you can go anywhere. But what this would say is it would effectively preclude areas on maybe only those biggest years that might be available on only those biggest years. They might be precluded from access due to this.

1:55:49 And we want to ensure that everybody is comfortable with that. So I think comparing it to the existing conditions is the best way to think about it. Maybe there's that one area that only gets snow every so often. That area would not have allowed OSV use based on this. So just another way to think about it. Statistically, what are they using? Are they averaging the last 50 years or something?

1:56:18 I honestly don't know the answer to that. I'm not sure how many years of data they took from this lab data that is mentioned in here. Unfortunately, I don't have that information. Because all the data looking backwards is not going to take it. Last year is going to mess up the average. So you guys have, you're good with the bill? Yeah, it seems fine with me. It seems reasonable. All right. I think the goal of that is to exclude areas that don't get snow, and I think that's wise.

1:56:54 It makes, but also, I mean, if you think, if you, are you going to take a $50,000 snowmobile? Yeah, that's, I'm not going to. That's, I think, I mean, this looks like, I mean. Right, but, you know, there is a major principle going forward, which is in the past, any area that wasn't on the map, you could ride a snowmobile or OSV in, and now, going forward, this will be the only places where you are allowed, so it is, it's the negative.

1:57:25 And it's really important that we are just clear with folks. That's why I say I'm kind of a, because I don't, I'm sort of agnostic about it. If this goes into effect and they draw the map and, okay, it's all out here. And then we start, what happens? We start, and then all of a sudden you've got enforcement issues. You go, oh, you can't go over there because this is basically land. This will end up in the land management plan. It normally will be every 10 years or something, but it's usually about every 25 years. Well, the last, yeah, last time it took them from, was in 1985.

1:58:20 I can't even do the math in my head. Close to 40. Thank you. Yeah, so it's a, it's a, but you're right, Chris, this is an important kind of a thing. I don't have enough information to be able to say any intelligence. Personally? Yeah. I would allow snowmobile use where the depth meets, regardless of elevation or how much it gets on a manual basis. Right. Because the rule through lawsuits has been changed. So that being said, I will be happy with a place that has an average of 12 inches a whole year.

1:59:09 I mean, I think that most of Mono County gets 12 inches of snow five days per year. I mean, I feel like. I believe in the proposed action packet. There is a map that is color-coded. These are all the areas that fit this criteria. Finally, compliance with OSV-related requirements in the Casa Diablo 4 Geothermal Development Project.

1:59:39 2-67, June 13. That's the EIR? The final EI says should also be reviewed for consistency with the proposed action. We'd certainly support that. My problem with it, John, is the idea that the Casa Diablo project somehow is going to run sway over our recreational activities, be it spring or fall. They should be doing what is necessary to mitigate their effect on recreation. We shouldn't be complying with their...

2:00:12 EIR desires. Okay, that's, this is a very interesting point, because in the EIR, the intent is that they have to comply with the EIR there. I mean, there's talks about how do you protect the pipeline or sign it so you know where it is? Yeah, so, yeah, I think what I meant in this comment is do you all, again, as a body in this first public comment period, want to mention safety as it relates to that pipeline and mitigation as it relates to that pipeline?

2:00:41 As part of this subpart C process. Yeah, not so much that the EIR would dictate the uses, but I think more safe pipeline being there, but also looking through the EIR, EIS to make sure that everything that Casa Diablo said they would do that helps benefit people use their... Using this process to ensure. Yeah, yeah, and I, if I... That I'm comfortable with. Yeah, because... As long as it's worded so that they become... Because we...

2:01:15 This goes back to Mammoth Trails, that confederation of user groups. There were meetings over that whole process, and the only thing that we could get into that EIR was that page that refers specifically to, so then if we do this and bring that up, then Lawson, that's going to give Lawson and his shop some leverage and a leg to stand on to say, it's not just USGS, it's all those alphabet soup of agencies out there making all the mischief.

2:01:54 Yeah, and I think another side note and another reason why I wanted to bring this up was they have every right to comment on this process as well. And I am sure they will be commenting on this process. EIR is law. I mean, the language that's in that EIR is law. The problem we've been having is just no one's paying attention, no one's enforcing anything.

2:02:43 Here's our chance. Yeah, exactly. Okay, so I think we like that one. Yeah, and I just want to go back to the snow death requirements because I think what that brings up is a really important principle that we joked about a little, but I'd like to see it in the letter, which is there should be a more regular of this on the annual because as our conditions are changing so dramatically, rather than

2:03:10 Putting something in place and leaving it for 30 years and then having it be so historically inaccurate. Let's just make sure that that we build in. It's almost like our resiliency plan, right? Like, how are we going to make sure that we keep this up to date? Okay, so I think you've heard some high level of general kind of consensus on things. Is that helpful? Yeah, we'll get something drafted up and get it ready to go out. If we can, we'll throw it at least in the correspondence side of my 18th agenda. Okay. If it's ready in time.

2:03:48 As we work through this, you can see it, but it is due by the 20th, so we want to make sure it's out in a timely manner. Everybody happy? Okay, thank you. Okay, we're going to move on now to Council finds and determines that emergency work authorized by Resolution 23-29 and 23-54 continues to be necessary for public welfare and safety. Is there, I guess, is there a consensus of the Council that, or Danny, you want to... Yeah, let me just make one comment. You've seen this before.

2:04:21 Okay, so I think there's consensus of the council. Oh, okay.

2:05:06 I'll second. I'll second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Now moving to our next to last item. This is 11.4 Review of Town Manager Recruitment Information and Schedule. Can we take a short break? Want to take a short break? Sure. Let's say 6.10. I want Roberta to spend a little more time with us.

2:06:23 She's so cute. She's so cute.

2:06:49 I can't get a normal dog. My wife's not a dog person. I'm not a cat person. I am. I love cats. I'm allergic to cats. I've had them my whole life. So, what, we lost our last animal five years ago or so, and we've made the decision just not to do animals. If for some reason we need to leave, then you gotta, they're like having perennial toddlers. In your case, you have them.

2:07:19 So it doesn't hold you back as much as it does us, but believe me, I love animals, I love pets, I've always had them, but it just is, at this point, my life is not settled enough for that. Trust me, David can't leave because I can't walk the dog. Right. Yeah. So he raised up a run for me on the back. So what exactly do you have done? I know you've told me before. You had your rotator.

2:07:48 Oh my God. They all look very different. This one looks like a Rottweiler. Yeah. What did you get? We got this one right here. Aren't they so cute? A bit of this, a bit of that. Oh. Look, this dog looks like a Rottweiler. Yeah.

2:08:10 And there's like a cow-looking one. What shelters? That one has cat eyes. Big Pine got them. Oh, not Big Pine. See that one, doesn't that? It has cat eyes? Yeah. I think they were younger than eight weeks. Yeah. I like this one. It looks cute, too. But we wanted a girl. Yeah. So, again, this one looks like a cow. Dad? There's more than one dad in that litter. And then there were like three that I look like.

2:08:41 I think so. I think 20 minutes. Who asked for this? Dan asked for the break, right? Dan's disappeared. Oh, it's so nice. Sweet.

2:09:46 Okay. Is Mr. Holler in the room? We're kind of ready here. It's 6.10. Two minutes. Okay. Beautiful. Congratulations.

2:11:28 Where's Dan?

2:11:57 Dan, don't go anywhere. Thank you. Dan, are you, we ready? Yes, we are. Okay, we have, council members have made commitments. Okay, so this item is item 11.4, review of town manager recruitment information and schedule. Yes, I'll introduce it quickly and turn it over to...

2:12:57 Roberta Greathouse with Peckham McKinney, our recruitment firm. The item before you is kind of an outline or a rough draft of what would be the primary text in a recruitment brochure. I think the key items for this evening, the general discussion about the community and stuff and something that could be cleaned up in that area, but really looking at the position and the ideal candidate statements, trying to make sure that that is.

2:13:26 Very comfortable with the council is looking at those key elements as people look at the position. Do they understand and know what the council is looking for in a future town manager? Then the other write-up stuff we can definitely work through, and if you have comments there, that's fine as well. But I think the goal is really, as you're putting something out, defining what you're looking for, do people understand kind of what the council is desiring in a new future town manager?

2:13:57 So with that, I'll turn it over to Roberta with Peckham McKinney, and she can kind of walk through how we got here and then the process of walking through the information that's in the packet. Thank you. Good evening. Welcome. Good evening. Thank you so much for having me. So as you know, after a competitive process, you chose Peckham and McKinney for your executive recruitment for the town manager, and I am your recruiter, and I will be your point of contact and the candidate point of contact throughout the whole entire process.

2:14:26 So tonight, as Dan said, we're going to review and discuss the brochure. There are the two areas that he pointed out that we really need the council's consensus on. All of the background and those other things, we can wordsmith as we go along and we can get that off to everybody offline. But it really is those education experience and the ideal candidate characteristics that we really want to make sure that we have nailed down tonight.

2:14:52 We will also review the search schedule. I was looking at moving and requesting to move the 12-13 closed session to the 14th. Honestly, I'm not sure that really matters because today when I looked at the Bishop flight schedules, it looks like it's not going to open until the 21st. So I think I'm driving either way. So I think we can leave it wherever the council is most comfortable. So the draft brochure, as you noticed, it talks about the organization, the department, the position.

2:15:20 The ideal candidate characteristics, education experience, compensation, and the recruitment process. The draft education experience and ideal candidate characteristics, those I came up with accumulation of the meetings that I had with the council, key community identified community leaders, staff, and also a review of your key documents.

2:15:42 And then after all of this is wordsmith, it will be put together in a very pretty brochure with pictures that Dan is putting together, and it will be a very attractive marketing tool. So this is in, you know, all of the great details are in your packet, but for the highlights, educational experience, what we have in there is local government executive management experience with a bachelor's degree in public or business education or related field.

2:16:10 Highly desirable tourism-related or resort community experience, working with federal agencies, a record of community service, and a master's degree. We have identified that residency in Mammoth Lake's or an adjacent community is strongly desired. As you know, state law doesn't allow us to mandate folks to live within our community. And the goal in this is really to cast as large a net as possible so that

2:16:40 We can bring you a pool of candidates that you can look at and make a decision about which ones are best fit for your community. Ideal characteristics, these were really the ones that I heard, I would say, several times. Outstanding management skills and technical knowledge, a collaborative relationship builder who works to build consensus, and this is not just out in the community, but also with the city council or the town council.

2:17:07 Courageous leader is experiencing crisis management and is not afraid to make difficult decisions or say no. Emotionally intelligent and politically savvy and ethical and honest with a strong moral compass. So I will go back. Actually, I will stop here and maybe we can backtrack and the council can talk to me about what your thoughts were with what's in that draft document. Okay, so you're looking for just general comments on the text that we've seen. It was a little...

2:17:36 Confusing because it was in the staff reports that a brochure was going to be attached and all that we got. Well, what we have is text part of the brochure. Do you have the text part? Okay, so any comments from council members? Roberta, I gave you some comments last night. You asked me to bring them forward tonight, but they're on the whole text. Is that still good? Do you want to take those? Oh, yeah, we'll take those. Absolutely. So starting with the first paragraph, 8,000.

2:18:06 Why don't we use the number that's in the new sets?

2:18:34 Well, there'll be in the new census. That should be the census data, I would think. Yeah. Well, there's the, after the census, then every year they do, there's like a survey and it's supposed to be a little more accurate. So, yeah, and we just published that and we're about to vote on it in two weeks. We might as well make it consistent. And this isn't something that I thought would be added, but Roberta should know for her, the last sentence of that first paragraph, permanent population is the county's primary employment and service center. And I said tax producer.

2:19:06 Doesn't have to go in the brochure, but I thought it was kind of important. Then going to the second page, in the position, there's just a typo, on, on, in the last sentence. In the first sentence, the town of Mammoth Lakes seeks an experienced municipal leader management skills throughout a small rural resort community I would love to see added at 8,000 feet. In the brochure, we put that the town is 7,000 to 9,000 feet.

2:19:38 8,000 feet makes a huge difference. I want them to understand what they're getting into when they come. Under the ideal candidate, the second bullet point, conservative fiscal steward and strategically manage the town's limited resources to improve the quality of life for residents and quality of experience for visitors. I would love to have added in there because I want them to understand where we make our living.

2:20:13 Only other thing, looking at the qualifications, the need for a master's degree, I would always temper that depending on experience. You know, there are those without a master's degree that are far more qualified than those with a master's degree because of 30 plus years or whatever than I would always consider. Other than that, I think I'm pretty good. Amanda, Chris? Chris, do you want to go first? No, I'll let you go. I don't have a lot. Okay. The highly desirable, highly desirable.

2:20:54 I guess the only thing I'm confused about is in the copy document for the brochure,

2:21:28 It doesn't have, that's the ideal candidate, but I don't see the delineation between desirable and required. If there's an education paragraph, it'll talk about, the first sentence there talks about what it says, higher desirable qualities include. Okay, okay. All right. That's the only place where it's everything else is, okay. Everything else is just calling out what ideal would be versus, you know. I thought.

2:22:00 I think that you captured this very well, so I didn't have any changes, but I wanted to clarify that. Okay, so I think that the nuts and bolts, but I have to say that I was really put off by the prose and the sloppiness of the text, things being capitalized, the grammar not being right. I thought if I just picked this up and read it, and I thought I didn't know much about Mammoth Lakes, I would look at this thing and say,

2:22:36 So I would really encourage, I don't know who your writer is, who your copy editor is, whoever, that it really needs a polish, and it needs to be consistent, and it really needs to make sense. In terms of just the internal consistencies of the terms being used, one of the things I would just point out, for example, is in the paragraph about the position, I think the ideal candidate captures things pretty well. But in the paragraph on the position, it says the next town manager will be a visionary leader who's...

2:23:07 Profoundly entrepreneurial approaches, all issues, creative, inventive, and out-of-the-box mindset. Most of that is true, but I don't think, again, Dan, you're the only town manager I've worked with, but I think we've said earlier, it's an organizational consensus-based way of working. We're not looking for someone to come in here and tell us what to do. And I think that that, it's just the example of the pros in there sort of indicates, we don't know what we're doing, we need someone who's...

2:23:37 Who's a visionary leader is going to tell us how to do everything and we don't have any idea what we're doing. I think that the organization, I think the council, at least this present council, I think we're working really well together and I think we need someone who's going to be, who's going to fit into this culture that right now, it's those examples of the pros that threw me. So that's just my general overall sense. I think the nuts and bolts of the things

2:24:09 We're good, but I'm very concerned that we represent with this brochure, with this document, we're professional, we know how to spell, we know good grammars, like, I think it gives it, it's very important, people might say, well, there are a bunch of people, every step that we take, we have to be represented at the highest level of, I was put off, I was thrown by the, John, I would differ with you, although we do know what we're doing, aspect of what this council would not, we still need a leader who has ideas, is able to talk to all of,

2:25:09 You know, I talked to Roberta about this before. In here, the importance is to suss out those and listening to what you're saying, you know, ensure that they're going to be able to... The confidence I've always had with Mr. Holler is that when he finds and identifies opportunity, I've always been confident. So I think that that is the kind of... I don't think that we need... Hey, you haven't even thought of doing this. That's a place I don't think... But again, I couldn't agree with you more. I don't think we need... We're not looking for... Well, I...

2:26:18 I know what to do, and we've all done this together. We need someone with all the things you've got in there. That's all true. And I think, John, kind of what I think that you're saying is we want somebody who is going to take our ideas and make them a reality rather than tell us what we should be doing. In the most crudest sense, you're exactly right. Well, thank you. But you're exactly right. We want to, the manager needs to take what the elected body is, be creative, visionary, do all kinds of things.

2:27:13 Starting with whatever consensus that town manager, as opposed to just showing up and saying, well, you guys never thought about this, but I think you should start this and this. Because then we start getting into this sort of a competition. We don't want to be doing this with our mayor. And I think that being said, we want somebody who, you know, I have this idea X and this town manager is going to say, I'm going to help you get there. These are the steps that we're going to take to get you there. Right. So, you know, maybe some creative out-of-the-box thinking.

2:27:53 To get to those steps, you know, to get to the end product, but, you know, somebody that knows how to get some sort of consensus here and to get things done. That's exactly right. Chris? It might help because we talk about the organization, the department, the position, and then the ideal candidate, and maybe just cutting down that position paragraph a little bit because what I think John reacted to was it's a little internally inconsistent to say

2:28:29 That they're profoundly entrepreneurial while at the same time solving today's problems while anticipating and planning for local, regional, and global changes. So maybe if we just, I mean, I understand, Bill, that we want someone who has vision, but I think that position is conflating things. And if we just got it down to, you know, they have to solve today's problems and anticipate the future in this complex world.

2:28:59 And then say what the council priorities are, it would, and anything else that's a personal attribute moved down to the ideal candidate would help with that internal inconsistency and would probably be, we'd be good to go. Yeah, that's exactly the thing. I was just thrown by those kinds of inconsistencies within the document. I'll just sit. Donate, the lawyer is donating his time. Do you have a, I want to make sure I'm clear on what the council is.

2:29:58 Would you like this highlighted sentence moved down into the ideal candidate or struck? I'd strike it. Yeah, I think struck just because you get at it in other ways, but it could get us, that's the kind of thing that could get us in trouble. Chris, I think you might want the next one struck as well, right? That's okay with me because you do have to talk about,

2:30:29 You know, what are they supposed to be doing? They're supposed to solve today's problems, plan for the future, and oh, by the way, here are the council priorities. I think it's okay. I mean, I just, I think an important skill that we're looking for is not someone who will just delegate everything to other people. Maybe like in a large city that the town manager just, I do X, Y, and Z, and I just delegate this to everyone else. In a small town like this,

2:30:59 All of the businesses around town, you end up doing things that you wouldn't do in a big city and you learn other areas and build your skills that way. It's just I think that we need somebody that will be able to delegate but also be able to be hands-on and do things that they probably wouldn't be doing in a large city as the city manager.

2:31:32 So to add on to that, they will enjoy doing it. It's not burdensome. This is what a small community is like. This is how small communities are. Can we add in there also that they need to be willing to work the hours that Dan does? No. Can I throw that in? No, I'm scared. Yeah, I've had chats with Dan about that. Sometimes you need to rest and whatever it's called. Thank you. Anything else for us?

2:32:16 What I think I'm hearing is we're okay with the education experience and the ideal characteristics, and we will go back and wordsmith the other things about the agency and about the position. Okay, outstanding. Mr. Morris has volunteered to be of assistance. Be fantastic. Take all the assistance. And then the last part of this was just to go to refresh everyone's memory on the recruitment schedule. It will open on or about the 10th. It will close November the 12th. I will do the preliminary review.

2:32:48 Thank you.

2:33:18 And that will be their resumes, their supplemental questionnaires, and any other materials. I'll ask them for writing samples and so on and so forth. Then we will have the panel interviews January 11th and the finalist interviews January 12th, and those will also be in person, and I will be here for those as well. Will we see the brochure before it gets published, the full final brochure? Yes, you will. I think we're good. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for your hard work. And, Andy, thank you very much for, I think, going to put that kind of local lens on. I think it would be very helpful.

2:33:55 Okay, so with that, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports. And we haven't seen each other in a while, so maybe we have something to say, maybe we don't. Do you want to go first? Sure, I'll go first. Okay, thank you. Well, you all heard we got a puppy last week. She's adorable. That's big news. Yes, her name is Sandy. Sandy. Yes. And then other things, I went to the Mammoth Lakes Housing meeting last month, and...

2:34:24 We are trying to close the funding gap for the access apartments to get that project moving forward. I don't know that they're escalating, but we don't have the total funding to get the project moving forward at this point. Nothing to report other than I attended, as I mentioned, the two Forest Service meetings, one on Zoom, one in person, and I found it really helpful to hear.

2:35:00 From community members. So I look forward to our having more opportunities to talk with the community about this very important, you know, whatever it's called, advisor. Process and decision that the Forest Service will be making. Because I think it's important that we all work together and that's how we'll get the best possible solution. Attended. You and a scooter and a trolley track were all in Sacramento together. Yes, indeed.

2:35:36 And I will tell you, I've been asked several times if it was worth it, and it was. I would get on a scooter again. It wasn't the scooter's fault. It wasn't even my fault, in my opinion. I was feeling great. There was a problem on the road there. Rob went back and looked, saw my dent. It was not a regular road. It was bricks which stick up, which is why I think this bone got broken. But anyway, I did that. John can tell you more. Wednesdays, we did attend some good...

2:36:06 Some good stuff and talk to some people. Attended the MLT meeting today. We did the director performance review. I won't go into any great detail on that. You'll all be hearing about that outcome. The obstacle course world championships, known as OCRWC, will be going on this weekend. Just under 2,000 entries from 50 different countries and all 50 states will be represented by the people working out there. Going through that, the

2:36:37 Occupancy rates aren't up where they thought they would be, but there's many reasons for that, partly because I don't think we can yet capture the online services, which is huge. So your foreign visitors especially go immediately to those reservation services anyway. A new website should be coming on shortly for MLT, the first time in a long time, and we got a little preview of it today. I think it's going to be great.

2:37:05 And according to the people at the mountain, there's 36 days to the official mountain opener. Frankly, I hope it stays warm longer than that for my own personal reasons, but that is pretty much where we're at. And I thank you all. One sort of observation is the big event that MLT's worked really hard to bring into town. We've got a controlled burn going on at the same time. I mean...

2:37:34 Isn't there some way to coordinate these things a little bit? It's part of the obstacles, John. Huh? It's part of the obstacles. Well, okay. Yeah, you'll be running in PM10. Yeah. All right. Well, speaking of PM10, so September 7th, I attended the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting. The first item was the adoption and approval of the 2023 Town of Mammoth Lakes PMT planning area's second 10-year maintenance plan.

2:38:04 An exceptional event demonstration for wildfire smoke impacts on Mammoth Lakes. This is a pretty big deal. They did a very, very big thorough thing. And what's going on is the identification of big wildfire events as being exceptional events to the PM10 that used to come out of cinders and those kinds of things. This is part of wildfire climate stuff that's going on. So it's pretty interesting. That was the most significant thing that happened at the meeting.

2:38:30 Towns and Trails meeting. I attended Inyo County. I certainly provide more detail if you want. The Burpee meeting. This is the Buttermilk Infrastructure Planning Initiative. City of Bishop and Inyo County have never done things like this before. We talked earlier about the Sherman Zuri Group and the Sharp. We've had experience doing those kinds of things. This is kind of their first whack at all this, and it's a big deal, and it's important because the air service is going to play into that, them as a recreation destination. Very well attended. Packed room. No.

2:38:58 I mean, everybody's terrified. People can come and yell and scream at each other, but people sat down and talked and had come up with some great ideas, so it was good. Towns of Trails in Alpine County, those folks, they're into trails, and they're all about it and about connecting this region to Tahoe, so that's a big thing. That's going to be interesting. On the 14th, I attended the White Park Financial Advisory Team Committee meeting. I know, Chris, you've been part of that.

2:39:25 That group is coming together. This is a $150 million, 20-year project. We're going to need to figure out some way for the town to be really supporting at least that financial advisory group because we need to figure out how we're going to be doing this over time. So that's going to be interesting. Then I attended the Mono County Townsend Trails meeting, and then I went on the 19th, before we went to Sacramento, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection Board District board meeting.

2:39:52 Just to let them know, at least as one councilmember, I'm going to do everything I can to help them with their tax measure that's going to come out next year. I think they've got an amazing story to tell with this last winter. It's not just fire, folks. It's propane tanks. It's all the stuff they've been doing. I don't know legally how we support them, but this is one councilmember I'm supportive. Yeah. And the town could pass a resolution of support or something.

2:40:23 I mean, any of the four of you, five of you, can do whatever you want in your own time and in your personal capacities. Okay. At some point, we may want to consider a resolution of support. Sure. Yeah. Okay. And then League of Cities. So, with my dear friend, Mr. Sauser, we attended the Inland Empire Desert Mountain Division Lunch. Bill is a recipient of recognition and awards from that group. Fiona Ma, the state treasurer, was there.

2:40:50 And speaking to everybody, just handing out her cell phone number. Call me, call me, call me. I got billions of dollars to give away. Okay, well, we got her number. I then attended a number of sessions, which, you know, we may wonder, why do we go to the California, why do we go to these meetings? Because when we go to them, they're never directly about us and never directly benefit us. It's always, what angle do we take?

2:41:16 In these relative meetings. And instead of hit or miss as to which ones are actually going to be relevant, building in economically challenging times was actually an eye-opening meeting because there was three people on the panel. One of them was an executive with HCD. And the first person had a really nicely prepared presentation. The next person had a really nicely prepared presentation. The one from HCD just kind of showed up and kind of winged it.

2:41:42 And I'm thinking, okay, this is not exactly how you're welcomed in our neighborhood. That's kind of interesting. Then they went to Q&A, and the line was out the door. Real ire, real anger, profound distrust, basically coming around to the fact that you are not an enabling agency, you're an enforcement agency. You're sending out these general plans, and you're coming to our communities and our cities and saying, you must build.

2:42:14 Billions of dollars worth of housing, and you're not helping getting any of this done. So there's a real interesting tension going on between the cities and the communities and the state and the policy stuff coming out of Sacramento. That was interesting. Then a session on JPAs, which I thought would be interesting for a small regional JPA, but it's all about how do you invest the hundreds of millions of dollars you have in your JPA's bank account. Huh, that's interesting. I guess we don't roll with that crew.

2:42:45 Then there was a session on storms, the storms of 2023. Oh, we've got a story to tell, but it was all the coasts, rain, mudslides, no one even want to talk about snow. Okay, well, we'll move on from that one. Then we had an interesting discussion around rural city information exchange. There's some interesting discussions about authorities. I asked about EIFDs and how we could use those for housing and that the housing...

2:43:14 Fire EIFD. None of the panelists ever heard of that thing before. So I've talked with Dan. We need to dig in and out before we ever meet with Mono County to talk about that. So interesting. And then I went to the BBK event. I got some free hors d'oeuvres. And I asked for our Stacey. Rob told me the name of the person to speak with. Yes. And she wasn't there. But then I got my ethics. I got my harassment training on Friday morning. Thank you very much. And I came home.

2:43:44 It's interesting. In a lot of ways, in a counterintuitive way, it's interesting. But you do get some information of what's happening with other cities and the rest of the state. But it also helps to inform us of where we don't fit, where we might fit, where we don't fit. So it really underscores the need for us to be self-reliant, to be looking out for our interests, to be able to get by with what we've got. Because there's a lot of adversarial stuff going on in the state writ large. But we're doing pretty well on our own.

2:44:17 That was my takeaway. So that was it. Okay, so with that, do we have any other outstanding business? I mentioned one item was brought to my attention is I know the chamber is doing their annual business recognition gala on the 1st of November, which is our meeting date. The majority of their it's about 630 or 7. They would love it if council members could attend, but they also recognize the meeting. So we can work around that or if you can start early, whatever. We'll try to take a look at that. I don't know how heavy that meeting is at this point.

2:44:55 If you're interested in that, just let me know if you're interested, try to time that to where you could go up for a good portion of that event if you're interested. Okay, good, thank you. All right, with that, I guess we're done? Yes? Okay, we're going to adjourn until our next regular meeting, which is on 18th? Oh, I'm sorry. 17th, we'll have a joint meeting with Mono County. Okay, good. And then a regular meeting, a council regular meeting, we'll join to that special meeting, joint meeting with Mono County. Great, thank you. Thank you, Amanda.

2:45:29 So we're joining to...