TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2023

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 09:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

155 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:39 All right, I have 9 a.m. I'd like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting of November 8th here in Suite Z. Jamie, may we please have roll call. Commissioner Chang is absent. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst? Here. Thank you. Everyone please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Michael, would you care to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Thank you, Michael.

3:23 So just a heads up for everyone out there in the audience, we did have a little change to today's agenda. Before I open general public comment, I will ask Nolan to maybe give us an update with what the adjustments are. Great. So regarding the cell tower item, which is the item that the majority of the public is here for, will be continued to December 13th.

3:50 It was brought to our attention late last night. There was a noticing issue with the radius of where the public comments went. The required noticing is if it touches a common area of a condo complex, all owners within that complex are to be notified of the upcoming public hearing. However, when the parcels for phases two and three of Snow Creek seven were drawn by the assessor on the final map,

4:18 Additional parcels were created which then caused an issue where certain parcels were excluded. So the item today we will still give a brief overview of the project on the town's authority on cell towers. The public hearing will be open for anyone from the public wishing to provide comments today. There will be no action being taken by the commissioners on that item. So it will be re-noticed as a new public hearing for December 13th. Thank you, Nolan.

4:46 So I am going to open up the general public comment, and I would ask if you do have public comment on a matter on today's agenda that you hold off until the public comment for that specific agenda item has been opened, and we will have public comment on the cell tower agenda item today, so you will have an opportunity to speak, and we look forward to that. But I am going to open up the general public comment right now.

5:14 Great. Nolan Bobroff, Acting Community Development Director. I wanted to introduce our new code compliance officer to the commission. We have Mike Marder here. Mike's been a resident of Mammoth and Mono County since 1998. Prior to coming to work for the town, he worked for a large HOA as their on-site property manager. In that role, he dealt with many of the similar issues that he deals with now as the code compliance officer.

5:40 So his experience is very applicable to his current role. When he's not enjoying his time at work as the code compliance officer, he also works part-time as a ski instructor up at the mountain. So that'll introduce Mike. Do you want to say anything or just say hello? Yeah, thanks for the opportunity. I started on October 16th and I've mostly been working on clearing the red and yellow tags from last winter's damage for the last month, along with some other

6:12 Welcome to the team. Thank you. You prefer Mike or Michael? Mike's fine. Okay. Any questions for Mike? No? Glad to have you. Glad to have you. Big shoes to fill. Any other general public comment? A's? So Nolan asked me to give you guys a quick update on where we're at with the CRC.

6:49 There is a fury of activity out there. These pictures were taken about an hour ago. They're working on the front patio in this photo. That'll be concrete just in time for us to remove snow from it next week. Nolan's running my slideshow because we're, I didn't get an invite. Another photo of the patio. It's got a retaining wall that kind of integrates with the playground and so forth. So that's all kind of coming together.

7:19 From the inside, it's actually starting to look the part, so dasher boards are in, netting's in, lighting's in. On the right-hand side, you see some tenting, they're heating up the floor, flooring's going in tomorrow. On the right-hand side, you can see the pallets of flooring. Looking from the other dimension, other direction, again, everything's kind of coming together. You can kind of see all the pieces that would, you know, represent an ice rink.

7:47 Just looking from the inside, looking towards the east, you can see the scoreboard's up, all that's been tested, so all the systems are working. And our mechanical, sitting above all of our back of house, if you will, all runs. Some of our boards have facing. We sold 33 boards for advertising inside the structure. On the back of house, they don't have a face, so you can see how the aluminum's kind of attached. Pretty robust system, and that's like...

8:17 Glass. Our old ice rink was plastic. This is glass, much higher quality boards. They tested the ice rink chiller system a little over a week ago. This is kind of how that system looks in our mechanical room. Everything worked fine. And here's a picture. Go ahead. You can see, I don't know if you can see it, but the rink is sitting at 43 degrees. So kind of our next steps on Friday.

8:49 Or Saturday morning, we're going to start pulling down the ice rink, stepping down the temperatures to about 18 to 15 degrees. On Monday, we'll start making ice. At the same time, contractor will be working on finishes. We'll have a soft opening on the 18th with a camp from the LA Kings. And then we'll do a couple cleanup items to get things set up. And then we'll open to the public on the 24th for free skate. So the 18th is a soft opening with a youth camp, youth team, and then the 24th is public.

9:19 Public, okay. Will the 24th also be like a ribbon-cutting kind of thing? A preliminary ribbon-cutting, just kind of acknowledging what's going on, and then we'll have a larger, more grand opening in January with dignitaries from the Kings and a lot more folks, and we'll do a more formal, but I'm sure Stu will have things to say on the 24th. And that item is, it's a notice.

9:44 Council meeting to have all the council and because it's a public event, Jamie, correct me if I want, it's not a notice public meeting, but because it's a public event, the commissioners are invited to attend that. We've been counting on the 24th and it wouldn't be a Brown Act issue if you were all in attendance. As long as you don't discuss any town business together. That's my story. I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have. Any questions for Hayes? Hayes, it's been a long road to get to where we're at right now.

10:17 Where we've come in the last month, I think that you have a lot to do with that, and thank you for all your hard work, because I would never have guessed a month ago when you came to us that it would look like this today. So great work. Thank you. Any other comments or questions for Hayes? I'll definitely concur with the commercial boroughs. It's a good town win. The town needs a win. Thank you for pushing the ball across the goal line, Hayes, and I look forward to seeing the finished product in January. Yep, it's going to be fun. Thank you. Thank you.

10:47 Any other general public comment? Jamie, do we have any virtual public comment? No. I will close public comment. We will start with our public hearing. It has been asked that we flip-flop business matter 5.1 and 4.1. I thank the audience in advance for your patience. Item 5.1 should be pretty brief, so it shouldn't take up too much of your time.

11:13 Nolan, I cannot remember who is staff contact for the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project. Okay, so we have Kim Cook on Zoom. She's our senior planner, and we also have our contract planner, Jen Murillo, with Lisa Wise Consulting, and Jen will be providing a quick overview of the status of the main launch project. Great.

11:36 Thanks, Nolan. Good morning, Chair Vanderhurst and Commissioners. Good to be here this morning. Thank you for flopping the agenda for me. I appreciate it. So I'm the contract planner for the main base redevelopment project. Due to the size and significance of this project, we're providing regular updates to commission and to council. We're trying to do that on a monthly basis. And we're focusing on the items that have

12:04 changed or more recent ongoings in the regular updates. So I just have a few things to touch on today. The first being that environmental field work for the project is essentially complete. We did, we had the environmental consulting team complete surveys for botany, cultural, wetlands and wildlife. So that

12:32 Those fieldwork, the fieldwork results will be put into technical reports that feed into the environmental analysis that will be required for this project. Also, we continue to work with the applicant to solidify an outreach strategy. We look pretty close to confirming a joint commission and council meeting at the end of this month.

12:56 We've had a few of those joint meetings on this project over the years, and now we are hoping to see the project ramp up, and that's why we're looking to schedule this meeting with you, this joint meeting toward the end of the month. Lastly, Senate Bill 606. This bill was spearheaded by the applicant team. This bill allows for all or a portion of State Route 203 within the town limit, so Maine going

13:26 Minaret to Main Lodge to be relinquished from Caltrans to the town. This bill was approved by the legislature and signed by the governor about a month ago and becomes effective on January 1st. This bill does not require that Caltrans relinquish any or all of 203 to the town and it does not commit the town

13:50 to accepting any or all of 203. What it allows is for the relinquishment to be evaluated. So the next step in this process is for Caltrans to conduct a relinquishment assessment report to understand implications, concerns, issues with a relinquishment.

14:15 So for Caltrans to begin that assessment, the town needs to formally request that that be done. We're hoping that a letter will go to the council in December to start that process with Caltrans. I don't know how long that relinquishment assessment will take. I don't imagine it is quick. I think it'll take a considerable amount of time. But we can keep you updated on the timing of that as we move forward with other.

14:44 updates. So with that, I'd be happy to take any questions you have. Thank you. Any questions for Jen on the Maine Lodge redevelopment? No? Jamie, do we have any public comment? Anybody like to give public comment on the Maine Lodge redevelopment update? Short and sweet. Appreciate it. Thank you very much. All right. With that, I'll close business matter 5.1 and we'll go back to public hearing 4.1, which is the

15:18 the public hearing and consideration of a use permit that is going to be continued for into December 13th. Nolan, how would you like to proceed with this this morning? Because we do have members of the public that I'm sure would love to offer public comment. Absolutely. So as we said, due to the noticing issue, this item is being continued, so we're not having the...

15:42 The traditional public hearing or presentations on the item today, just a short overview of the project, it is an 80-foot tall stealth monopine proposed for the Old Mammoth Road fire station. The location proposed per the zoning code is in the back, approximately northeast corner of the site, set back 20 feet from all property lines. That location was selected primarily so that

16:09 The fire district use of the site, maneuvering their vehicles in and out could continue. So as we did note earlier, due to the public noticing, not including all of the parcels within the common areas of phases two and three, this item is being continued, but we are going to have Bennett Gibbons from BBK Law Firm. He's a contract attorney with the town giving a brief overview of just the kind of

16:39 Legal authority the town has over cell phone tower sighting. Then after that we will open the public hearing to allow members of the public both here in Suite Z and on Zoom to give public comments and then we'll close the public hearing. There won't be any deliberation by the commission or other presentations today. That will all happen on December 13th and a new notice.

17:05 will be sent out to all the property owners as well as be posted in the newspaper. So with that, I will hand it over to Bennett Givens. Thank you, Nolan. All right, great. Thanks, Nolan. Hi, I'm Bennett Givens from Best Best in Krieger. I'm here to present. Let me share my screen with some slides to talk through the town's authority with regard to wireless facilities.

17:34 So we'll, I'll just start at the beginning and we will hold for questions at the end if you'd like to discuss that and then we can get into the public comment items. So first, so this is going to be a brief overview of town's authority. We'll start with the, there we go.

18:04 The national policy on wireless deployments. This is essentially a brief overview of federal law as it currently exists with regard to siting wireless facilities. Currently, if there's any one page that the commission can bring home and recall later, this is the one page to do it.

18:32 So first, no local decision or regulation can prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services. This is the main aspect of the Telecommunications Act that limits local authority and it comes up in litigation for denials or other types of prohibition that claim by the wireless industry.

18:59 Next, the National RF Emissions Guidelines. The FCC has the sole authority to set RF emissions safety standards, and they have occupied the field and preempt all local regulation of RF emissions. Localities cannot regulate the placement of wireless facilities based on their RF emissions, except to ensure that the applicant is in compliance with the FCC standards.

19:28 In addition, the FCC has also issued a number of orders requiring the town and all other local jurisdictions to process applications within a shot clock period. These range from 60 days to 150 days. Due to recent updates in state law, there's now a deemed approval remedy for

19:54 Applicants, if the town misses any of the shot clocks, the application can be deemed approved by operation of law. All denials need to be written in, must be in writing and provided to the applicant as soon as possible after a denial and the denial must be based on substantial evidence in the record.

20:18 There's also a prohibition against discrimination among providers of a functionally equivalent services, expedited appeals, and for certain modifications to existing wireless facilities known as eligible facilities requests, the town has no discretion and must approve them.

20:42 Here is the general legal framework on the federal side. As I mentioned, the Telecommunications Act of 1996 is the genesis for most of this prohibitions on the town's authority and generally prohibits the town from prohibiting or preempting the town from imposing regulations that prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting.

21:11 Any entity to provide telecom services. We have the Middle Class Tax Relief Act of 2012, also known as 6409 or eligible facilities requests. These are certain modifications that if they qualify, the town has no discretion and must approve them. The other large area of federal regulation, it comes through FCC orders.

21:40 And they carry the force of law. So the next couple slides are going to go through a few of the more recent FCC orders that impact town authority. The first being a 2018 moratoria ban. This essentially prohibits the town from placing moratoria or general ban on wireless facilities, deployments, or even limits on the number of facilities that can be deployed within the town.

22:11 We have the 2018 small cell order. This created an expedited process for reviewing small wireless facilities. It's a defined term in federal regulations. Essentially, these are smaller facilities that are no larger than 28 cubic feet in volume.

22:35 There typically you'd see these deployed within the public right-of-way on top of street lights or utility poles and they were largely used for deployment of the new 5G technology and they have generally a smaller range than a large macro facility such as the one proposed by AT&T. The small cell order

23:05 Also placed limits on fees and rents that the town could charge for use of the public right-of-way and use of city-owned infrastructure in the public right-of-way. The small cell order also imposed some restrictions on the type of aesthetic requirements that the town can impose on small wireless facilities due to recent Ninth Circuit opinion.

23:35 in the City of Portland v. United States. A number of these requirements have been struck down, so now the aesthetic requirements need to be reasonable and published in advance. Originally, a lot of jurisdictions that jumped into action after the small cell order had a difficult time crafting design standards that were objective or no more burdensome than those applied to other types of infrastructure.

24:04 The Ninth Circuit acknowledged that, you know, wireless facilities are different and that local jurisdictions need some level of discretion and ability to craft some design requirements and struck down two of those requirements. You see X out there in red. As I mentioned before, the FCC has established a number of shot clocks. These are the reasonable time frames within

24:33 A local jurisdiction has to process and issue all permits required for the proposed facility. This also includes appeals as well to reach a final decision. These range from 60 days to 150 days.

24:53 The AT&T facility that is up for discussion today is subject to the 150-day shot clock because it does not qualify under the other applicable categories. There's also part of the FCC shot clock is that there is a timeline to request missing information and a very constrained process for doing so.

25:24 If an application is incomplete, the shot clock will still start, but it's incumbent upon the local jurisdiction to review the submittals and issue a notice of incompleteness or NOI within the time frame set forth by the FCC. Generally, that's within the first 30 days, and for certain facilities, it's within the first 10 days.

25:49 And the shot clock would then toll until the applicant provides the missing information. Again, I'm just providing a general overview today. There are a lot of wrinkles and additional clarifications with many of these slides, but I want to give you a brief overview to kind of set your mind when reviewing this application and any future wireless facility application.

26:19 So under the Middle Class Tax Relief Act of 2012, the Section 6409 was adopted by Congress and the FCC have adopted three, well, really four orders on eligible facilities requests to establish the qualifications for those, the process and generally have expanded the reach of what qualifies.

26:45 as an eligible facility to request that the town has no authority and must approve if it qualifies. State law also has imposed a number of limitations in general. These are recently the adoption of AB 537, the net effect being there are now deemed approved remedies for every FCC shot clerk type.

27:14 Currently, federal law only has a deemed approval for eligible facilities requests, but the state has supplemented that and added a deemed approved remedy for all wireless facilities. Permits can be no permit term for any wireless facility cannot be any less than 10 years. There's certain bonding and security maturity limitations under state law.

27:43 You cannot require that all facilities are located on sites owned by particular parties, including the town or particular entities. And also state law recognizes the general preemption over our definitions.

28:03 In addition, there are a lot of other additional restrictions for wireless facilities in the public right of way. Generally speaking, I know this is a facility outside of the right of way that we're discussing today. So I'll just go over these items quickly. The telecom companies have a state franchise right to be in the public right of way.

28:27 They are, their main limitations that under the public utilities code is that they cannot incommode the public use of the road or highway. There are a number of cases that define, you know, the boundaries of what it means to incommode the public use. But there is an acknowledgement that local jurisdictions retain the ability to regulate the time, place, and manner in which the public right-of-way is accessed by wireless facilities.

28:58 This RF emissions question comes up quite a bit. The town's authority is largely preempted in regards to dealing with RF emissions. Once the applicant demonstrates compliance with the FCC standards, the town has no discretion but to deny the

29:23 application for concerns over RF emissions and the perceived health effects of RF emissions cannot constitute substantial evidence to support a denial of an application. This slide addresses some recent claims by folks in community groups about RF emissions being recognized under the ADA.

29:53 Recent case law has found that RF emissions is not recognized by the ADA as an area requiring accommodation or under the ADA. In addition, state law imposes a number of restrictions on what fees that you can charge for wireless facility applications.

30:24 Generally limits all fees to be cost-based when acting in your regulatory capacity and reviewing permit applications. Next, I wanted to talk through the CEQA findings for today's item. Just go through quickly. The town is ability to...

30:47 conduct environmental review. This project is constrained. It can only conduct environmental review on those parts of the wireless facility over which the town can exercise local discretion. As explained in the previous slides, the town's discretionary review is limited to time, place, manner and aesthetics of the wireless facility subject to the town's reasonable standards as permitted under federal law.

31:14 So the town has reviewed this project under CEQA and determined that the project qualifies for a class three categorical exemption for the construction location of limited numbers of new small facilities or structures and the installation of new small equipment and facilities and small structures. None of the exceptions to the exemption, categorical exemption apply. And with that, that concludes my presentation.

31:43 And I will stop sharing my screen and take any questions that you may have. Thank you. Appreciate it. Before I ask if anyone on the commission has questions for either staff or for Bennett, just a reminder to the people who came in a little bit late that this item has been continued to our December meeting. So just a heads up, but we will open public comment today on this item. So you will have a chance to address us. Any questions for either staff or for Bennett?

32:14 Please. Thank you for your presentation. When you were just reviewing the CEQA, you mentioned an exemption for small structures. I presume that's the cell phone tower itself. Is there? Yes, correct. Is there like a height limit or a size limit under that guideline?

32:36 I am not aware of a height limit for the Class 3 categorical exemption, but the Towns and Staff's Review has found it to comply with that exemption. And then also just wanted to clarify that we cannot make any decisions based on RF admissions. Is that correct?

33:05 Provided that the applicant is demonstrated, the facility will comply with FCC standards. You cannot make a denial of the application or cannot deny the application over concerns over RF commissions. I've reviewed the applicant's materials and they have provided a certification that the facility, once constructed, would comply with the FCC standards for RF commissions. Thank you. Commissioner Kennedy, any?

33:35 Questions? No? My only question, Bennett, would be, now that your deck is public record, can we get that in our hands? Sure, certainly, yeah, I'll work with Nolan to be able to provide you with a copy. Excellent, thank you. Before I open public comment, Chief, would you like to make a comment or are you good? We'll add, we will post that presentation onto the agenda on eScribe and we can also email it out to the commissioners.

34:03 Also, one clarification on the shot clock date. This project is subject to that 150-day shot clock. The deadline we calculated for that is January 21st, 2024 for that shot clock. So we are within that window still. The December 13th doesn't impact that date, but just to make everyone aware of it. Thank you. Thanks, Noel. Morning. Alex Tamire, Fire Chief, Mammoth, Ex-Fire Protection District. Thank you for your time.

34:32 So I'll give a full presentation on December 13th at the following meeting. That being said, I'll give a little bit of what the position of the fire district is. Again, I can't speak to the aesthetics of it. I completely understand people's opinions on that based off where it is relative to their personal aesthetics and that sort of thing. The fire district's looking at this purely from a public safety perspective, primarily from the first responder side as well as from the public. This goes back to...

35:03 Essentially, the district's been working on this issue for a long time. As most of you are aware, communications in this community are very difficult. There's a multifaceted approach to attempt to fix those, both on the public safety side as well as on the public side. This is a piece of that solution, and I'll speak as to why that's the case at the next meeting. But again, I kind of had two things of direction from the board. One is making sure that the public has the opportunity to speak.

35:32 I do apologize just to give some reference for those of you that are new to this. I did speak at town council to make sure that people came to our board meetings and were aware. We also reached out through the same process as far as getting to any homeowners that might be impacted. Sounds like there were some issues with that from the assessment side, but we did.

35:53 Go above and beyond kind of the standard necessary as well as putting in the paper. So one of the things is while we do believe in the validity and the strength of this project, we want to have that discussion on why we're doing that. So again, hopefully this is providing that opportunity and at the next meeting we intend to get into a little bit more of the details. But again, from the fire district perspective, there are no other ways to provide.

36:18 The proper service into primarily what we're looking at is the lakes based and down into the old Mammoth area which is a canyon. I would encourage anybody who has thoughts or opinions on this to really do the research and understand what the limitations are on as far as, you know, there's been comments given as far as raising other sites or creating infrastructure in other sites. A lot of those are limitations just based off landscape so it's my understanding that

36:46 Thank you, Chief. Any questions for Chief? Nope. Appreciate that. Thank you. All right, then I'm going to open up public comment. Feel free to come on up here and let us know your thoughts. Good morning. My name is Ron Homer. I'm a member of the Creek House Home Owners Association Board.

37:20 and a homeowner. I live at 1371 Timber Creek Road and I'm here to express the board and my personal as well as many homeowners who have signed our board's letter objecting to this. We're limited to the aesthetic grounds but we're talking about an 80-foot tower in a low-rise residential neighborhood which would become essentially the dominant feature aesthetically of our neighborhood.

37:49 We think this is completely inappropriate. It's not something any of us would want anywhere near our homes. And we urge that either another site or perhaps a much smaller tower that might meet the technical needs of providing for the community for the EMS cell phone be found. You know, despite the limitations on discussing things like public safety or

38:19 I have an addendum that we were because of

38:46 Late notification and only partial notification. I do have signatures of many members of our community. Should I email the addended letter to you at this time? I think that would be the most appropriate. Okay. Yeah, and I'll look to Jamie whether she needs a physical copy for the clerk or if an email will be fine. It will get added to the record. Okay. And just, you know, my last thing, not something I thought about saying, but it's amazing to me in discussion with the attorneys that this is considered a small structure. I mean, we're talking about a seven...

39:15 Storytower. I'm not, I'm not aware of it other than Mammoth Mountain of any structure that big here in town and it's going to be a few feet from many homes in our community. So I would urge you to think about the hundred plus families that live in our community and the nearby communities and try to find a better solution to this problem. Thank you. Hi, good morning. I'm Chuck Landy with Snow Creek. After receiving this notice on Monday,

39:51 I've had numerous conversations with the chief and with Nolan and town manager, et cetera, trying to figure out what some options are here. Putting this tower in somebody's front door isn't a great surprise to have. So a question I have for town council or town attorney, this clearly is a life safety communication issue and as such, does that allow you to amend?

40:19 Zoning codes or make exceptions or variances to zoning codes based on life safety issues? Well, no. My name is Andy Morris. I'm the town attorney for the town of Mammoth Lakes. No, we can amend the zoning code at any time, but we can't simply make exceptions to the zoning code based on life safety issues. And also, I'm not entirely sure what the life safety issue would be other than, I mean, if you're talking about the fire district's need for communications.

40:48 That by itself doesn't justify a variance. So if there were a desire to amend the zoning code, that could be done, but it would take a long time. It would take us well outside the shot clock deadline for this project. Are there other ways that you can provide a variance? Currently, the zoning code allows cell towers. And I'm sorry, I missed the first part of the presentation you made. I thought this agenda item was postponed completely.

41:17 The current zoning, as I understand it, allows it to go in the resort zone, which the fire station site has zoned, but it requires it for that zoning to go at the back of the lot versus anywhere else in the lot, thus the location right in front of people's homes. How do you, via variance or some other method, how do you put it, for instance, out on Old Mammoth Road so it's away from the homes as opposed to in the back of the lot? I'm not aware of a way to do that.

41:47 Through a variance or any other procedure other than amending the zoning code. A variance can only be issued where the unique circumstances of a parcel make it impossible to develop. There are no unique circumstances on the parcel. It's simply that there are other considerations that people have raised. But there's no reason logistically why a tower could not go on this parcel in the area where it's required to go. So that's why a variance is not appropriate.

42:15 As I said, I'm not aware of anything else other than amending the zoning code. I mean, logically, it can go and notice or receive notices back in June that they started this process. That would have given six months for town staff, the community, as well as the fire department to work together and possibly effectuate a zoning change that would allow this. There are really only three sites that this can go as I see it in this old Mammoth area. One is the church site.

42:53 which is zoned residential. One is the athletic club site, zoned resort, and the fire station site, zoned resort. So here trying to do everything in a week or two is pretty tough and not really fair. Thank you. Good morning. Thank you for your time. My name is Sabine Lee. I'm a 1380 Timber Creek. I'm an attorney, but I'm not acting as an attorney here. I'm acting as an individual.

43:24 Just wanted you to be aware of that. And I have some comments for the attorney on the Zoom call here. My wife, Peggy Liu, also submitted comments. We've looked at this issue and looked at the regulations, the statute, specifically on the Telecommunications Act of 1996, Section 704. And I think Bennett's slide said this, that the city can only deny, or sorry, the city cannot deny

43:52 If it's on the basis of environmental effects of radio frequency emissions. And so my understanding is that the city can deny the application if it's for other reasons. So aesthetics is a reason. But I also believe that there can be other environmental effects that are not due to radio frequency emissions that can be the basis of denial. For example, fire danger, wind damage, that could happen with a giant tower like this. If I could, I'd like to ask Bennett if he could address that.

44:20 Tell me if I'm correct on that or not. Yeah, the city has to, the town has to apply its code and make the findings for approval. And if the findings for approval cannot be met, then the town can deny the application. You are correct in your reference to the RF admissions standards. If the facility complies with the FCC standards, then the...

44:50 Town cannot deny the application on that, on an over concerns over RF emissions. So my understanding is that the city can deny if there's a substantial record established for other reasons that can include aesthetics and can include other environmental effects as long as it's not based on RF emissions. So I think, Bennett, you're agreeing with that and I wanted to make sure the city is understanding that as well. Thank you. Okay. I wanted to address CEQA. So the city,

45:23 indicated that the exemption, there's a categorical exemption to CEQA under 15303 for new construction or conversion of small structures. And the question came up as to isn't 80 feet tall not a small structure. The city's application or the AT&T's application indicates that it's a small area of I think 640 square feet and ignores the height. There is actually a recent case on this in the California appellate court.

45:52 And so, Bennett, I would ask if you've looked at this case. It's called Ignatius Neighborhood Association versus the City and County of San Francisco. In that case, the appeals court ruled in favor of the neighborhood association where the city was trying to erect a 90-foot-tall light fixture. And they said, with such a tall light fixture, comparing it to other structures in the area, essentially, this light fixture would be much higher tower over everything else. And I think that's what we have here as well.

46:22 80-foot monopole compared to the other trees in the area that I think they're trying to say are going to be similar to this monopole, I think are measured at 55 to 65 feet. I'd even question, Nolan, when I looked at some of the photos, the drawings of the monopole structure look like they're shown to be at about the same height as the trees, but then some of the drawings, I think on the AT&T sketches, they look like they're three times taller than the adjacent trees.

46:51 And by the way, my home, my master bedroom looks directly out onto where this location is. It's going to be a direct barrier to my view of the mountains. And so I think aesthetically it's very imposing. But I do believe that the categorical exemption does not apply here because an 80-foot pole is much, much greater than the neighboring trees in the area. My last, and maybe just for Bennett, have you looked at that case or are you aware of that case?

47:22 I have not reviewed that case in connection with this application, but we will review it and we can discuss it at the next meeting. Great, thank you. So, Nolan, back to you. Just in terms of the- Excuse me, sir. Yes. Just out of respect for everyone else who wants to give public comment, I think your time is just about up. I was timed. And I don't really want to get back into a Q&A with staff or with the attorney record. Understood. Can I just make one more- Please. A comment.

47:52 My cell signal has been generally fine. I live at 1380, of course, so my signal, I was getting 5G signal this morning. I was walking on Old Mammoth Road, and so I questioned whether there is a significant need for an 80-foot pole, and so there were other alternatives, smaller structures, maybe different locations, so I would ask the city to explore these other options as well. Thank you. And I apologize not notifying the public that we did have a time limit on public comment. Thank you.

48:23 I'm Sonya Bush, and I'm a member of the Creek House Board and also a resident in Creek House, and I heard the meeting had been postponed, so I went off about my business and someone said they're talking about it, so excuse me for having to read from my notes because I left the folder. And just for your knowledge, you will have a chance as well at our December meeting.

48:42 Well, I'll talk again. You can count on that. All right. So bear with me for just a second. First of all, thank you for allowing the public comment. I want to highlight a couple of things. Some of you I know, but you might not know this about me. Before moving to Mammoth, I was in the cellular industry for 28 years. I've been on the other side of this issue. I've had people come to my house. They've tracked me down and saying, you can't put a cell tower. It's going to kill my chickens. You brought my chickens to the house. It's crazy. So I understand all the need for improved communications from both perspectives.

49:11 I also understand the public safety issue. My husband's a volunteer for Mono County Sheriff Search and Rescue. He's an ops leader and communication is critical for all those first responders. I do appreciate the concerns raised by my neighbors. I can't speak as eloquently to some of the quotes of the law, but balancing these concerns with the necessity for a tower to address communications is not easy. I understand that. But my concern, and so do many of my neighbors, lies in the fact that it's an 80-foot tower. You've heard us say this again.

49:39 Correct me if I'm wrong, how tall is the Westin? It's not 70 feet, is it? So it would be the tallest structure in town. The general plan, this is where I really come into play, the general plan for Mammoth Lakes includes bullet points about the community vision, right? There's several bullet points. Specifically, item number six emphasizes the importance of designs and developments that complement the Eastern Sierra Nevada mountain setting, maintaining a village in the trees.

50:08 With small town charm. Remember seeing that on the community vision. An 80 foot tower doesn't seem to align with this vision. Given my industry experience, I believe alternative options which are intentional and something that looks like it belongs and fits in should be explored. One idea is a clock tower design, a cross design at the church across the street. There are options that would better fit the environment. The idea of camouflaging the tower as a tree is impractical and really quite offensive given the beauty of our area.

50:38 And the absence of any 80-foot trees anywhere nearby. I've contacted St. Joseph Church, of which I'm a member, and while they were approached eight years ago, and they declined at that time, no one has approached them in any of the near, any since then. And when I spoke to them, they are interested in revisiting the issue, and I've already made calls to the diocese to see if that would be appropriate.

51:01 Again, a clock tower or a cross on their big hill would be much more desirable and aligned with their community vision. So I guess it's a summary. I recommend postponing the decision and seeing if the St. Joseph's option can be thoroughly explored. If it proves unfeasible, I suggest creating a mock-up, such as using balloons, to visualize the actual tower height before implementation. Let's take a step back and make sure we maintain our village and the trees with small town charm.

51:31 Thank you for your consideration. Thank you. Appreciate it. My name is Eric Larson. I live at 1465 Boulder Creek, probably one of the five closest homes to this tower. Just a few points. I understand the safety issue that they talked about, but when I look at this cell tower, I gotta wonder, first of all, how safe is it for the fire department that are actually stationed there? It is a training facility. I see them

52:08 All the time out there running around with ladders and fighting fires that they've made. Cell towers get struck by lightning more often than natural structures do, trees, etc. You know, it's only 20 feet from a house. I don't know what cell towers can catch on fire. Are they going to be able to put it out?

52:29 The International Association of Firefighters, which has 332,000 members, and there are only 360,000 firefighters in all of America that are full-time, this is Canada and America, they oppose the combination of cell towers and fire stations being used because of the lack of research and the safety issues that it represents to their members.

52:54 So the whole safety thing, I understand for the town's communications, I don't know if it's not just being replaced by other issues that are going to cause even greater health and safety issues, despite not even going into the whole RF radiation issues. I don't know if property values are a reason. You know, the National Association of Realtors and many studies show that properties that are adjacent to a cell tower will lose 15 to 20 percent of their value. That's $281,000 to $350,000 for me.

53:24 If you're within sight, 9%, and it dissipates until there's no longer a loss in value once you're .44 miles away. So you're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars in homes that could be affected value-wise, which directly translates into property taxes. So I don't know if it becomes costly for a town, if that's a reason to actually disapprove a project, but there will be massive loss of property tax revenues from the loss of values that...

53:53 Many studies have shown happens. Finally, I noticed that those cell towers, that cell tower they want to put in is loaded with C-band antenna. C-band is brand new. The FAA has a real issue with C-band. The problem with the C-band is that it runs in the same wavelength as altimeters do in older airplanes. So I'm just wondering, has the town looked into what impact there is going to be from the...

54:21 Small airport we have over here, planes flying right overhead. The FAA has disallowed any C-band being installed within two miles of an airport. So there's obviously great risk involved. And, you know, our town, their flying altimeter flying over these mountains around here in bad weather. You know, all of them have to, the FAA has already said that all airplanes are going to have to have all their altimeters replaced in order to coexist with C-band.

54:51 So I would hope that the town would actually look at that as well and see what kind of risk it represents for our small little airport out here. That's it for now. Thank you. Any other public comment in person? Jamie, do we have any virtual? Yes. Tara Connor, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Tara Connor? Sorry, can you hear me now? Yes. My question was actually for the fire chief, but I think it got answered. I was wondering when the application actually...

55:33 was reviewed by the Town Council, and I believe it was June of this year. I'm wondering, I'm a recent, we purchased closed escrow on 1581 Clear Creek in March 2023. I'm wondering when this proposal was first surfaced to the Town Council. Nolan, you want to take that? And again, I really don't want to make this a Q&A.

56:03 for public comment between staff and the people who are giving public comment. It's just a question. It's just a date question. Sure, absolutely. There was an original submittal that had the tower in a different location that came in in late 2022, and then that application was withdrawn by AT&T and the fire district. The was not an active application during the June. That was a fire district item to review the potential

56:31 for the tower and consider a lease with AT&T. The fire district is a separate entity from the town, so we don't have any ability in those lease agreements. The current submittal was submitted in September of 2023 to the town. September 2023, so very recent. Okay, thank you for that. And that's subject as I'm not sure if you heard the beginning part of the presentation regarding the 150-day shot clock and that the deadline for any decisions would then fall to January of 2021.

57:02 January of 2024 due to that 150-day limitation that the FCC has put on review of these types of projects. I got that. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Jamie, is that it? Any other public comment that has not been spoken today? And I will, we have a virtual? Yep. Several more virtuals. Okay. Greg, Aggie, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

57:54 Wendy Blades, please unmute yourself. Can you hear me now? Hello? Yeah, we got you. Okay, I have, I bought a place at 1595 Clear Creek and I can't tell you how disappointed I am that I purchased it right now and I just wanted you to know that I will put mine on the market if this passes and will not be back to Mammoth. I'm wondering on the time frame,

58:26 I noticed online that there was a meeting with the fire department based on this that I was not notified about. I mean, are we going to reset the clock so that we can go back and be at the meetings from the beginning since none of us was notified of this? What about the fire chief that is in the paper in 2013 that he said he would not want to subject his firefighters?

58:56 If they ever did stay in there, to these cell towers, it wasn't worth it. Plus, there could be additional carriers. And so, yeah, hold on, prior, yeah, so the prior denial and the timeframe of the whole thing, sorry if I'm reading some of my notes here, but, you know, what made this time, this shot clock started?

59:32 Who decided that this was a location that the shot clock could even start? You know, wouldn't it have been better if the community was involved in picking the location? So now we're under this clock because the fire department decided, does the fire department communicate with AT&T? Do they all have AT&T phones? Is that how they talk? Did I lose you? No, you're still there.

1:00:03 Oh, yeah. So is that how they, do they communicate with radios or do they use cell phones? Sir, what we're going to do, I think, is maybe just have staff jot down these questions and provide answers at the next meeting. I don't want to make this a Q&A right now. Well, I don't know what else we're going to make it. You know, I've spent, you know, a lot of money on this place that I don't even want. In fact, I don't even want to come back to the community if this is going to be approved.

1:00:31 And so it's very difficult. And also, kid, just, I'm not part of the homeowners, you know, I am part of the homeowners association, but I'm not on the board. What if we just pay the fire department the rent? How much are they getting per month for the rent? I mean, it'd be like $50 a month, we give them, you know, $7,000 a month. I mean, why can't we just rent the space? I mean, is it about money? What's this really about? I have Verizon. I don't need AT&T. My phone works fine. I mean, does anybody answer all the questions? I mean,

1:01:05 Are we going to start over again and start back at the fire department at the meeting that we all missed? Like I asked earlier, Nolan, perhaps you guys could jot down these questions and provide answers at a subsequent time. Any other comments, sir? No, I think that that's it. Again, that I'm just disappointed. The last question I have and I would like an answer. Because we sent many emails to the planner.

1:01:39 And you never responded on how this timeframe works. So you have a meeting on the 13th of December. When do you guys vote on this? When is this finalized? I believe action will be taken on the 13th of December. So you guys will make your decision at the 13th meeting? Correct. Unless it's continued again. Thank you, sir. I'm sorry. The 13th of December will be when action is taken unless this item is continued again. All right. Thank you. Thank you.

1:02:15 Wendy Blades, please give your comments. Good morning. Thank you very much for taking my comments. Excuse me. I'll be brief. My husband and I own the home at 1553 Clear Creek Road in the Creek House community. To us, this proposed cell tower would be a blatantly obvious industrial eyesore.

1:02:46 containing a minimum of 31 antennas. It could potentially contain many, many more. This is incompatible in a residential low-rise community and will tower 45 feet over the adjacent townhomes, some only feet away. At 80 feet, this tower will be more than twice as tall as the housing it borders.

1:03:09 Rather than shielded from the public right-of-way, it will be 40 feet from Timber Creek Road, with no screening between all the plantings in the Creek House community that are new and very small. The lower antenna location available for lease will be at the 35-foot level. This is exactly the same roof height as the townhome's only 40 feet away. The planning equipment.

1:03:36 The planned equipment reaches from 35 feet up to 74 feet on the pole. That's 39 feet of equipment spanning that pole. This pole is scheduled to be installed at the back corner of fire station number two. From there, it's literally in the back corner where the two easements come together, the property easements. From there, the 20-foot easement for easements on both sides for the fire department.

1:04:07 And the 20-foot easement of the neighboring property would indicate a 40-foot space to the nearest townhome. But, in fact, if you read AT&T's plan carefully, the antennas are planned to project nine feet out from the pole, only leaving 30 to 31 feet of space. The fake tree branches are planned to project even further to cover the antennas.

1:04:33 This is an industrial installation, not natural foliage, and should not be allowed to encroach into the property easement in any way. It's not a natural tree. While more reliable cell service is something everyone would appreciate, an 80-foot tower in this location would be clearly visible throughout much of our very scenic town. This is not the type of landmark the city should be approving.

1:05:02 It is contrary to the general plan. Snow Creek 7 is a beautiful neighborhood that is an asset to Mammoth Lakes. Let's be careful not to mess this up with a poorly conceived location for a cell tower. A more appropriate location needs to be identified. This is very much a David versus Goliath situation, but the planning department and city council must do what is right for the community and not be steamrolled by AT&T.

1:05:32 Please vote this down. Also, I would like to comment that to have a public meeting again on December 13th, where there will be again public comments and then the vote will be that day means that anyone who speaks at the December 13th meeting, their testimony will realistically not be considered by the planning department.

1:05:57 Please change this and vote this down, but do the timing differently. Thank you. Thank you, Wendy. All right. Then I will close public comment. I am going to ask staff and our town attorney to maybe go through some of the questions that were asked today and provide answers. There were quite a few questions, and unfortunately, we didn't get a chance to really get into the Q&A, but I think that the public deserves some answers. Great.

1:06:29 So I apologize if I missed any questions as trying to take down all the questions asked, the ones I have noted here. The antenna issues regarding the CBAN and other potential issues with the broadcast, one of the requirements of the application is a report outside engineer with the applicant that there would be no issues on other communications equipments from the fire district agency.

1:06:59 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:07:28 I'll let the fire district respond to that.

1:07:57 It's not part of the town's review of the cell phone issue as to how they communicate. Regarding the June meeting and the shot clock, that's part of the reason we did request that they delay submitting their application until they had a project that they had a lease with the fire district and those to the town because as soon as they do submit to the town, that then starts the shot clock. Had the shot clock been started prior to the June meeting,

1:08:27 This item would have been pushed back because that 150-day shot clock doesn't extend or change depending on when it's submitted. It starts the day it's submitted. So pushing that as far back or far forward is a benefit to the rest of the community so that we are within that 150-day window there. That is the questions I had.

1:08:53 And Andy and Bennett, I'll ask if you guys wouldn't mind taking a peek at the recording of this meeting. There was a gentleman that brought up a couple of legal questions concerning decided law. I believe it was a case in San Francisco. Yeah, we will take a look at that. That is a case from last year, and we will review both the case and the use of the Class III categorical exemption. Thank you. Sonia, I'll ask you to make it brief, but I would love to hear your thoughts.

1:09:27 That was the other one I meant to respond to and did not note down. So we did look further into that site this week through conversations with Chuck Landy and others, and it was noted that, yes, AT&T had reached out on their site analysis to the church, to the athletic club, and to the fire district. The church is actually within the RMF2 zoning district, so it's a residential zoned property, where the athletic club and the fire district site are in the resort zone. So that...

1:09:53 Correct. Based on the current zoning, it cannot go on the church site. Thank you, Sonia, for bringing that back up. All right, with that, I'm going to close public comment, and we will move on from business matter five, I'm sorry, public hearing item 4.1. I'd like to thank everyone who took the time to attend here in person. I apologize that this item got continued, but I appreciate all your thoughts and opinions.

1:10:23 Yeah, please, if you have the ability to attend the December 13th meeting, please do. We'll also add to any letters provided prior to today's meeting or from today's meeting. I know, Ron, you had an additional letter you wanted to submit. Please do submit those. They will get added to the record. Then any other comments provided between now and December 13th will also be included in the record. There will be a new...

1:10:51 Public notice that goes out in the mail and in the newspaper approximately 10 to 14 days prior to the hearing. Thank you. All right, we will move on to the, what do we got here, the consent agenda. It's a pretty light one, 6.1, it's approval of the meeting, of the minutes of the October 11th meeting. Do I have a motion or would anybody like to offer edits? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the.

1:11:21 Regular meeting of October 11th, or sorry, just approve the consent agenda. Sure. I have a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Commissioner Eckert. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Consent agenda passes. We will move on to commissioner reports, and I'll start on my left. Commissioner Kennedy, do you have anything you'd like to report out? Commissioner Burroughs. We recently had an ADP meeting regarding, what did we discuss?

1:11:54 6060 Minaret Road Project. Thank you. 6060 Minaret Road Project, which was the old Yotel pad, and what that building will potentially look like. It looks pretty good so far. We've added a few comments that they could do to improve the design of it, and that should be coming to us pretty soon, right?

1:12:23 All I have to report. What would be your best guess on timing on that, Nolan? They've indicated they're looking to resubmit in the next few weeks to the town. Once we get that resubmitted, we will then work to schedule an ADP meeting for their review of the changes that occurred, and then it would be coming forward to the commission after that. I would anticipate likely in the January or potentially February meeting, just based on timing. Thank you, Nolan.

1:12:52 Commissioner Eckerd, anything you'd like to report out on? All right, I'll make mine brief. Reminder that the mountain opens on Friday. And you can see driving around, it's white. And I believe they've been cranking the guns just about every night for a week. So it should be pretty good conditions. I kind of heard through the grapevine. Possibly two or three lifts open on Friday. So just a reminder on that. All right, let's move to the director's report. And Nolan, you are the man up.

1:13:23 Great. So a few updates. One was to touch on the project for 6060 Minaret that the commissioners had mentioned was at the ADP review. So really gave that highlight already. Just a few highlights of that project. It is a replacement of the Yotel pad projects on the corner of Main and Minaret Road, the old Novato site there. It does encompass all three parcels.

1:13:48 It's proposed to include 118 resort condominium units as well as a on-site restaurant and other amenities there oriented to the guest. It will operate much the same as Westin or the Village in that it will be a resort condominium project. So once we do get the formal submittal in, it will be reviewed by staff for completeness and then taken to ADP and then pending the results of the ADP meeting and if there's

1:14:18 Recommendation to move it forward, it would then come to the commission. And they are looking to start this next spring and summer with kind of site grading based on their other, the developers' other projects in town. We do feel it's a viable project that would likely move forward. A few other updates, we sent out a request or a meeting for the joint meeting on the main lodge project with the town council.

1:14:48 They're looking at a date of November 29th at 3 p.m. Thank you to the commissioners who have. Let me know their status of whether they can attend. It sounds like that meeting will still happen, regardless if there's a quorum or not, so it'll just depend whether it's a joint meeting or a town council meeting with members of the commission in attendance. Also, we talked about earlier the ice rink opening on Friday, 11, November 24th at 3 p.m. The commission is welcome to attend.

1:15:17 Again, it's not, wouldn't it be a Brown Act violation if everyone is in attendance. There is parking on site. There's also transit available with the new transit stop there. I walked the site on Monday. I was kind of as blown away as everyone else is by Hayes' photos that it really does look like an ice rink when you go inside now. So it's exciting to see. And then a quick comment on the council items. There is a council meeting next Wednesday, November 15th.

1:15:46 They will be providing a report out on the short-term rental moratorium that was adopted last month at the town council meeting. So that moratorium currently is in a 45-day moratorium on the issuance of new short-term rental permits. So that's anyone who currently does not have a permit. There's no new permits being issued if you're within the RMF2 or commercial zoning districts. The council did

1:16:12 vote to exclude the resort, North Village, and Clearwater specific plan from that moratorium as it's currently written. And then that would be an update just on the work program that's gone on and then a little bit update on the short-term rental committee that was appointed by the town council that's working to study potential additional management objectives and changes to how we manage short-term rentals here.

1:16:40 There will not be an extension of that moratorium at that meeting. That has been agendized for potentially looking at a later meeting in November, but it will be extended beyond the 45 days for how long is to be determined at that meeting. With that, that is all I have. Thank you, Nolan. With that, I'm going to go ahead and adjourn today's meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which is on December 13, 2023. Thank you, everyone, for being here.

1:17:16 Ice rink opening.