Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2024
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
61 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Per federal regulations, we actually had to go through a legislative amendment to it. Literally had to go through Congress, a bill through Congress. And Rusty and Ron Cohen at the time made several visits to Washington, D.C. and lobbied our representatives there, our senators and congressional representatives to facilitate the approval of this very brief language for this legislative land exchange components. We're just...
0:28 Allowing a higher cash equalization payment on the overall exchange because the value of the main lodge was fairly high, the land, and the properties that we could exchange that the Forest Service wanted didn't quite get to the threshold of not exceeding a 25% cash equalization payment, so that was kind of one of the big things. And then at the request of the Forest Service, there was a couple of parcels outside of the Forest Service boundary that they wanted that didn't comply with regulations. So long story short,
0:56 We died in committee twice and got through on a third attempt on the 2014 omnibus land bill that was approved, or it was Defense Authorization Act of 2014 in December during the lame duck session of Congress and on an omnibus land bill. And anyway, very, very lengthy, complex process, involved a lot of politics and, I mean, literally to get like a three-sentence legislative legislation approved for our exchange that enabled that to start.
1:26 And we started back in earnest on the land exchange in 2015, and then worked through completing the land exchange, and speaking of COVID, March of 2020. So we, like, two weeks, it was March 3rd of 2020, two weeks before we shut down for a couple weeks to take a pause for COVID, right, we completed the land exchange and secured the land in parcel A and B that you saw in the presentation.
1:55 So I think it's just, you know, important to look back at what was the foundation of this. But at the end of the day, you know, this is a hugely important project to us, to the resort, right? You guys go to Main Lodge, you know what it looks like. And like I said, Jeff Bailey said 25 years ago, you guys really need to replace your facilities. And here we are 25 years later and we have the same facility. So, you know, we have the land, it's unentitled, that's why we're going through this process.
2:22 It involves improvements on the Forest Service land as well as the private. So it is a very complex joint, you know, federal and town process of a joint NEPA, CEQA regulations that we have to go through in a joint document. So, you know, it's about as complicated as you can get in terms of that process. And it's lengthy. And I know a lot of people kind of go, well, what's going on with the Maine Lodge? Why is it taking so long? And where nobody's, you know,
2:51 Holding back here, we're trying to go through this as efficiently and as quickly as we can, but, you know, we obviously have to follow the process, and it's a complex process, and so we're, you know, as you may remember, we did have the first public noticing of scoping was, I'm trying to remember now, was that two years ago or a year ago, a year ago, I think, and so we got public comment then, and now we're working on compiling the draft EREIS document, and, you know, at this point,
3:22 We're anticipating that'll be published for comment sometime in later 24, like fall of 2024, so it's still nine months away, and that'll really be sort of the kickoff of the opportunity for the public to make official comments on the record, on the project, and not that we haven't obviously been getting feedback, and as Jen pointed out, there is those websites where you can already sign up so that you're, be sure to be emailed, notified when these official
3:52 Parts of the process occur and then you can make comment at that time, but I think you can already make comments and so forth as well. So, you know, we want to make it as much of a transparent process as we possibly can and we welcome, you know, wholeheartedly all the feedback from the public. You know, this is a project for the community. It's not, you know, it's hugely important to us, of course, but it's hugely important to the community. You know, the main lodge is really, is
4:19 You know, the backbone of our tourism in, you know, winter and summer, right? It's the first lodge to open, the last to close for winter operations. You know, it's the base of the bike park, scenic rides to the top of the mountain. And, you know, we sorely need to make these improvements. And, you know, one of the things I want to point out, I mean, you look at the plan and you look, you know, some people go, oh, my God, it looks huge. But it's like, go look at what's there now. Every single building that's there is getting replaced.
4:48 In the new development, including the main lodge, every single building. And so that's all in that footprint you're seeing there. So that's, all that existing stuff is part of all that, which is a lot, is a huge component of all that, right? The main lodge is a 150,000 square foot building. I mean, we're going to build a new building that's the new main lodge. It will actually be slightly smaller. Other uses in the existing main lodge will get included in sort of the ground floor retail in the village area. So it'll just make for a much better experience for the guests.
5:17 You know, much improved transit arrival and drop-off, separating people from the cars and not having people having a, you know, cross paths with vehicles and stuff like we do now. Obviously moving the highway, not having that run through the middle of all the resort operations in the summertime where literally people bombing through there sometimes at 60 miles an hour and it's just, you know, you know, it will be a much improved situation where we'll have the
5:45 Resort operation, more engaged with the mountain and a better experience for our guests. And then, you know, really, again, at the end of the day, is, you know, we're trying to create a, you know, world-class experience for our guests. You know, this is where our guests want this, right? We hear it constantly. We know we need to, you know, replace the main lodge. You know, people recognize it every single day. And it's like, we know. We know we need to do that. We're working on it. This is a lengthy process that we have to go through, you know, and...
6:14 We'll get there. And I think the other good thing to understand is that being part of Altera really gives us the access to the necessary capital to do the work. So when it comes down to this project being done, we're going to move forward, we're going to implement, and the work's going to get done. And it's just going to move the needle for the community so dramatically. And it'll be an amazing achievement for all of us, the whole community.
6:42 Not just the ski area. I mean, we're all in this together, right? So anyway, those are just the overall thoughts. You know, I really think, you know, you can get so ground into the details and so forth. And we, you know, absolutely God's in the details and we, you know, we're going to figure all that out. And I think we've gotten a long way towards that already. And so, but, you know, always take the step back to the big view of what this means for everybody in the community.
7:10 And S as a resort and the long, you know, really the long-term, you know, economic sustainability for our community and what we need to achieve as a, you know, a destination resort in the industry. So that's, those are my comments. I'm happy to take any questions you guys might have. Commissioners, any questions? Okay. Great. Thank you, Tom. Yeah, thanks, Tom. Appreciate the background. That's helpful. Also, thanks, Jen. That was an excellent recap of a very complex project.
7:45 One of the key topics. Can you state your name? Tyler Lee, non-resort program manager. I'm filling in for Fred Wong, who's the district ranger, and Leslie Yen, who's the forest supervisor and the authorized official for the project. Thank you. I just wanted to add one of the key topics for the Forest Service is whitebark pine. It was listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act last year. Specifically in the Big Bend area, there are several hundred.
8:12 So that's one of the main things that is driving alternatives for the Forest Service for resource impacts. So right now we're looking at different ways to configure the project to reduce impacts to White Park Pine in that area. Also we share some of the concerns with State Road 203. We need to be able to take our logging trucks down that road as well as our fire equipment. Also we need to have access for the public and the Forest Service to get to the post pile as well as our permittees such as the Mammoth Mountain Chalets.
8:42 Other than that, I'm happy to take any questions for the Forest Service. Thank you. Commissioners, any questions for Mr. Lee? Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments from the applicant? Okay. I'll open it up to discussion with the commissioners at this point. Commissioner Kennedy, would you like to go first? Yeah, I don't have much to share. I agree this was a really thorough presentation, so thanks, and thank you for redoing it for us planning commissioners as well. They couldn't make it to that original one, so.
9:17 Yeah, thank you, and keep going. It's looking great, I think. Thank you. Commissioner Kinney? Commissioner Chang? The only thing I have is the November meeting. I believe that was the first presentation. That was a very in-depth meeting, and I encourage the commissioners to listen to that one. You'll get a lot more feedback from the town councils as to what their thoughts are. I think it's it.
9:47 Certainly it's a great project. It's a long time coming. Certainly there's a lot of considerations that we have to, as a resident of this community, everyone I think should all be participating. So thank you. Great, thank you. I just have a few topics that I wanted to bring up. I know that housing is kind of tabled into, until another discussion, but I really think that that's an important discussion that we need to have as a community because with that,
10:17 That increase in hotel occupancy and whatnot, I can foresee more employees that are going to be needed going up and down the mountain and that leads me into my next topic is getting up there along the 203 and how much traffic that there already is going up and down. I mean, I know that we've had traffic studies and they say, oh, it's
10:47 Just around Christmas time that we get the 40 minute backup coming down the mountain, but it's not just during Christmas time. I think anybody with kids on the skier snowboard team knows that it's quite a bit during the winter. And so I hope that that gets addressed, traffic solutions, backing up into the village and whatnot. I think that's a really big discussion that needs to be.
11:13 had, especially if we're, again, adding more employees, adding more people up there, it's only gonna get worse. Further, Mono County, a couple years ago, in conjunction with other entities, did a disaster drill to determine how quickly and what would be needed to get people out of Devil's Postpile in the event of a fire, and it was noted that we couldn't get everyone out. And so, having so many people
11:43 In an emergency and only having one road in and out on the 203 is a little concerning for me if we're going to be adding more people. So please consider including that in your discussions. And then the maintenance of the 203, that portion behind the project, I have concerns about the town taking that over. And I know that this is all in discussion.
12:12 What are the maintenance costs going to be for the town? Do we have enough plow drivers to maintain that during the winter? And is the mountain going to, because it benefits the mountain, is the mountain going to support any of those costs or any services? And then finally, we talked about the parking up there and how the parking lots would change. There would be parking underground and then additional parking. Again,
12:42 If we're going to add more parking, which probably needs to be done, we need to look at the impact on the 203 coming back into town because it's going to have a huge impact and it's already bad. So please address those and that is all the topics I have for now. Is there any public comment on this? Okay. Jamie says no public comment. So any other comments from
13:11 Applicant or commissioners? Okay. Nolan, do you have everything you need on this topic? We do, thank you. Okay. So, with that being said, I'm going to turn the diocese back to Commissioner Vanderhurst to take over. Thank you. Thank you, Vice Chair Burroughs. I wanted to go over there and keep it alive.
13:57 With that, we will close the presentation portion of this agenda and we will go to public hearing and we have been informed by Nolan that item 5.1 has been continued to a future meeting. Correct. So we did come across an issue yesterday that required some additional review by staff on this item. So we did talk with the applicant team and the applicant and the
14:26 Property owner decided to continue it to a date certain, so that will be, the public hearing will be continued to February 14, 2024. However, since it is a notice public hearing, we do open the public hearing to provide an opportunity for anyone here to comment or weigh in on it. Got it. With that being said, is there any public comment from Suite Z? Jamie, is there any public comment via Zoom? So no public comment. So we will...
14:58 Close 5.1 to a future meeting. Which brings us to the consent agenda, which is the approval of the minutes of the November 8, 2023 meeting. Any edits or do I have a motion? Make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? I'll second. Jamie, may we please have a vote? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Consent agenda passes.
15:29 We will move on to Commissioner Reports, and I'll go to my left. Commissioner Kennedy, anything to report out? I don't believe I have any reports. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs. Yes, we had a design committee meeting, I think it was last week. Yeah, I think it was last week. And we discussed the sign for Bar Sierra and what was previously the Sierra Nevada Resort. So that, we had some changes that we suggested, so that will be coming back to us.
15:59 So we'll keep you informed on that. But other than that, I have nothing else to report. Perfect. Thank you. And thank you for representing this commission with the design committee. Commissioner Chang, anything to report out? Nothing for me. Thank you, sir. Thank you. And I don't really have anything to report out as well, so we will move to director's report. Great. I just want to give a brief update on...
16:27 The short-term rental committee meetings that have been ongoing related to the STR moratorium. The STR committee meeting group is meeting tomorrow, January 11th at 5 p.m. here in Suite Z. Those meetings are on Zoom so anyone who chooses to watch can either watch live or after the fact or come and participate in person, listen to those meetings. Then there will be follow-up meetings to that on January 23rd and January 30th.
16:56 And then at the February 7th Town Council meeting there will be a report out from the committees on the work and recommendations coming out of the committees. So the STR committee was broken up into three groups. One group was focused on the certified properties work efforts coming from finance. The group was working on what we're calling the carrots and sticks, so essentially incentives to potentially convert into long-term housing and then also
17:24 Additional restrictions that might come down on STR properties. And the third committee was a zoning group that was looking at some possible changes to zoning and designations, mainly looking at the kind of resort nodes or the resort hubs at near, so properties near Canyon Eagle and the Village, looking at some possible zoning changes there. So those recommendations will be again discussed tomorrow and then presented at that February 7th town council meeting.
17:55 I was going to give a little bit more detailed update on the parcel, but Amy highlighted majority of the construction efforts ongoing there. There will be a presentation on the construction updates to town council on January 7th and February 21st. At the January 17th meeting, we will have a representative from the developer group there to answer any questions and provide information. At the February update, we'll have
18:23 The developer representative and a representative from Buckingham Property Management. They're the property management group there to provide an update because we hope that as of the February 21st meeting they'll begin reaching out to future tenants is our hope since that's kind of within the 60 days of their target occupancy date.
18:48 Quick update on the funding. I know Amy mentioned we were awarded funding for Phase 2. So we received approximately a $26 million award for Phase 2.2. So that'll be the initial phase of Phase 2 under construction. It's 76 units. They're looking to begin construction in June of 2024, at least get the permit in hand and break ground because that's tied back to they have to
19:16 Have the permit in hand within 180 days of the award date. So they're under the pressure to get their permit submitted and through plan check and break ground, which is exciting. Phase 2.1, which is 72 units, they're going through some creative financing efforts. They were awarded tax credit financing for Phase 1 to Sawyer in this last financing round. So their hope is to...
19:43 refinance phase one and then that'll free up some of the housing accelerator money that were previously awarded a few years ago to then move that to phase 2.1 to move that forward so they're hoping to complete all that here in the first quarter of 2024 that refinancing efforts that we'll hopefully know by March or April whether both phases will move forward this summer or not 2.1 and 2.2 correct but 2.2 is absolutely moving forward and their hope is to
20:12 At least kind of break ground the 2.1 and get permits by the, if not middle of summer, end of summer with financing once it's secured. Does 2.1 and 2.2, have you guys given it a snappy nickname like the Sawyer? Yeah, both phases together, so all of phase two is called the Kingfisher. Kingfisher, thank you. And that is all I have. Any questions for Nolan in Director's Report? One question.
20:48 In regards to refinance, does that elevate the cost? No. For the following phase? No. So it's given the, you know, you got over 500 basis points of interest rates. How does that impact the cost of future development?
21:18 It's not a true refinancing, like they're not going to a bank and getting a new loan. They had previously applied for tax credits for the Sawyer, and they weren't successful previously, and then the state stepped in a few years ago with a program called the Housing Accelerator Program, which was when the state had surplus cash that set it aside to fund shovel-ready projects that weren't successful for tax credit financing.
21:44 So they were awarded funding for the Sawyer through that efforts. In the most recent tax credit applications, they put in another tax credit award for phase one, even though it was already fully funded, with the goal of, if they're successful in that application, using those funds to free up those housing accelerator funds, and then they'll move the housing accelerator funds to phase 2.1. So it's just kind of shuffling around.
22:13 Financing they've been awarded for different uses. Without additional tax burden or liability burden. Correct. Thank you, Chair. Any other questions for Nolan? Please. In regards to the short-term rental committees, you had mentioned that they're going to be discussing change of zoning in canyon areas. Will that come to us as well?
22:40 It will. So the recommendations, once they get hammered out, that piece won't be finalized at Council first. It then has to come through the traditional planning efforts of public hearing with the Planning Commission and then public hearings with the Town Council.
22:58 I have one question. I just wanted to confirm, you emailed us back in December, but it sounds like we'll talk about the cell tower issue next month. Is that still the plan? That is the plan. We have a meeting with the Alpine group tomorrow, and then following that meeting, we'll then take that information to the HOA group to discuss with them, and then it's still the plan that we're shooting for us in February. A couple of quick questions, and I apologize in advance for putting you on the spot with this one.
23:25 Any sort of an update with what's going on with the remodel, the conversion of the kind of traditional old hotel up by the village that is going into workforce housing? I believe it's called Turnkey? Homekey Project. Homekey. Yeah, so that project still under construction inside. They gave an update. Mammoth Lakes Housing gave an update to their board on Monday night. They're still targeting...
23:52 Occupancy date for approximately six of the 15 units by the end of March, and then the remaining units would be by the end of the year, and that's primarily everything, all the construction will more or less be done in March, but they're waiting on some switchgear, which the electrical panels, which is kind of a nationwide supply chain issue, getting those in place to fully electrify all the remaining units.
24:20 By the end of March, they're still shooting for six of the 15, which includes one manager's unit to be ready for occupancy. Got it, okay. And on a different topic, again, apologies. I think I read in the, Stu puts out a weekly town summary of the different things that happen within the town, whether it's town council or community or parks and rec, and I believe I saw town council approve 2.2 million to go towards the country glass Mammoth Lakes housing project.
24:50 Does that completely fill in the missing gap in funding, or are they still looking for additional funding above and beyond the town's 2.2? No, so that 2.2 included the previously committed 1.5 million that town council had previously committed, and then they'd come to the town, or approach the town with, there was a pretty significant gap, and we worked with them to identify some areas to cut cost.
25:18 in the overall budget and reduced it to an additional $700,000 from the town, so that brought the total commitment to $2.2 million. And then part of that, their funding gap was tied back to they were looking to be fully reimbursed on costs that had already sunk into the project, so they paid off approximately 80% of the loan on the acquisition of the property, and then they had design costs and others, and so we
25:48 Worked with them and they committed to putting in approximately 120,000 of their own equity into the project to close that gap. So at this point it's fully funded. They're working on some just revisions to the building permits and value engineering efforts they looked at. And through those efforts they also determined they could increase the unit count from 11 to 13 units. So they're working on those changes and they'll get the building permit resubmitted and they hope to break ground.
26:17 Spring of 2024 this year. Does that project come before us at all or is our role done with it? It never came before the commission because it came through the SB35 streamlining efforts. There was a state law passed a few years ago that's specific to affordable housing projects which regulate that we can only impose objective standards on it. So your traditional zoning standards and there's no...
26:46 Additional approvals required for SB35 projects. Got it. So you mentioned they're hoping to break ground in the spring of 2024. Yep, and there is a contingency built into their budget and others, so they're hopeful that it's fully funded and it's not going to exceed that budget. Long time coming, but that is good news to hear that they're about to break ground. Yeah, and it'll be exciting because it's actually, instead of 11, it's 13 units. The one other piece that...
27:16 What came to mind was they also, working with the state, so on the home grant and the CDBG grant, identified that not all of the units have to be 80% and below. They're able to adjust some of those AMIs up, so there'll be, I want to say at least three, potentially four units that'll be 120% AMI, which helps the town kind of address, you know, working towards that missing middle gap that we're trying to.
27:47 Trying to address. So I think through all the efforts, it's, you know, exciting changes that came to the project. It's just taken many years to get there. Yeah. Well, congratulations to all parties involved. I know it's been Herculean in the effort to get that project moving. My last, this is a bit of a request, and I don't know if we can do it, and you're more than welcome to say no. I don't know how we would fall into the Brown Act restrictions, but is there any way, and I'm not speaking for anyone else on the commission.
28:16 But is there any way that we can get a site tour sometime in March before the occupancy of the parcel takes place to see the finished product before the tenants move in? Yes, I will look into it. One extreme would be we can take up to two commissioners out there at a time and do a site tour, and that doesn't violate any Brown Act, or we can agendize it as a ribbon-cutting site tour on the agenda with a full commission.
28:47 So I can look into both options and get back to you. Whatever. And the most important thing is whatever we do that we don't slow down construction in any way, shape, or form with some dog and pony show from this commission. But I would find it interesting. I really would. And it's been a big community effort, a big push. And I would love to see what those units look like. So with that, any other comments or questions?
29:15 Then I will go ahead and close today's meeting and adjourn it to the next regularly scheduled meeting on February 14th, 2024. Perfect. And I think we're here for a big chunk of the day in February. Thank you. Thanks, guys. Appreciate it. Perfect.