TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2024

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 09:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

459 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:43 So I'm darting down to L.A. after this. Sorry to hear that. And so I'm missing out on this weekend. I got nine o'clock. Supposedly he's coming. I don't know. Hey, Nolan, I've got nine o'clock. I won't either. I gave him a heads up.

2:46 Well, good morning, everyone. I'd like to call to order the February 14th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Happy Valentine's Day, everyone. Jamie, may we please have a vote? Commissioner Chang is absent. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you, Jamie. I'd like to ask everyone to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Nolan, would you care to lead us, please?

3:16 Thank you, Nolan. So our first order of business will be public comment. I will ask if anybody does have public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda, that you wait to give your public comment when we open up that agenda item.

3:47 Having said that, is there any public comment that is not tied to today's agenda? Jamie, did we have anyone on Zoom that wanted to give general public comment? No. Then I will close the public comment section and open up the public hearing. We'll open up with item 4.1, which was continued from the November 8, 2023 meeting. It's a public hearing and consideration of a use permit application 23-

4:20 002 for the construction of an 80-foot tall stealth monopine cell tower located at fire station number two. And I think kind of the way we'd like to have this meeting kind of organized is what we're going to do first, just so everyone understands. Good morning. We're going to have staff give a presentation and then we will hear from the applicant as well as our town attorney.

4:50 The commission at that time will have the opportunity to give out some questions or anything they might want to express. We're going to have a presentation from the fire department after that, and then we'll open it up to public comment. And public comment will be limited to three minutes per individual, with the exception of the gentlemen that approach staff.

5:12 A little earlier that said he was representing a very big bulk of the public comment we've received. I do want to let everyone know that we did receive a fair number of public comment letters and we have done our due diligence and we have reviewed them all. So please feel comfortable knowing that we have read your letters. So if you are planning on just coming up to the podium and talking about your letter, the contents of it.

5:40 Know that they have been read and they have been heard. So having said that, I will now hand it over to staff and I believe Michael is our contact on this one. Yes, and just a few clarifications in the order. We will have Andy Morris give a quick overview introduction of just the role of the commission on public hearing items and what their purview is for reviewing, considering applications.

6:09 Then we will have also a presentation from BBK staff giving an overview of just the telecom regulatory framework as kind of to frame this item for then the public hearing that follows. Also, I just wanted to thank all the public, everyone else, for all the comments we've received. To reiterate, Chair Vanderhurst, prior to the November meeting and today's meeting, we have received them all and read them and provided them all to the commission.

6:38 With that, I will hand it over to Andy Morris. Thanks, Nolan. My name is Andy Morris. I am the town's attorney. I represent the town on most of its matters, for those of you who I haven't met yet. And because this is something that could be, this process could be unfamiliar for a lot of members of the public, I'm just going to review, for the benefit of the public and for the commission, what the commission's role is today. So the Planning Commission's role is not to decide whether this is a good project or a bad project.

7:09 It's not to decide whether members of the commission like the project or don't like the project. The commission's role is to decide whether specific findings can be made with respect to the project. The town's municipal code and state law require that certain findings be made if the commission is going to approve this application. If you decide that you can make those findings, then you can approve it. If you decide that you cannot make the findings, then you would deny the application.

7:37 But you have to be able to articulate in what way you think the findings cannot be made if you think that you're inclined to deny it. So Michael's staff report spells out what those findings are in brief, and I think that he'll be covering that in more detail. But on page two of his staff report, he has a little section called Key Issues, and the Key Issues section says that the question is, can you make the findings required by Chapter 17.68 of the town's municipal code

8:07 for the issuance of a use permit, because that's what this is, it's an application for a use permit, and then can you make the findings in sections 17.52.280 that are required in the town's code with respect to telecommunications facilities, and then there are some other findings required under California's environmental law, the California Environmental Quality Act, but that's really the way to think about this. It's not

8:31 Does the commission like the project? It's not. Is it a good or bad project? It really is. Can the findings be made? So I would encourage the commission to be thinking about this along those lines, and for members of the public, be aware that that's really the framework in which the commission needs to operate. So with that, I'll turn it over to, I don't know who's going first, but we have Bennett Gibbons, who's a telecommunications law expert from my former firm, and we have my friend Alicia Wintersweik, who's the best.

8:59 Environmental lawyer I know, and will be helping the commission understand its obligations under the California Environmental Quality Act. So take it away, Bennett or Alicia. Perfect. Hi, everyone. I'm Bennett Gibbons. Thank you, Andy, for the introduction. I'm going to be giving a short presentation on the town's authority with respect to the siting of wireless facilities. Then I'll hand it over to Alicia, who'll discuss the CEQA issues.

9:25 Give me a moment while I share my screen for the presentation and we'll get off to the races. All right. Can everyone see my screen? We've got you. Okay, excellent. Thank you. So, as I mentioned, today we'll be going through the town's authority with respect to wireless facilities. This largely covers a number of items that we discussed at the last hearing in November, but I also added some

10:10 responses and discussion in regards to some of the public comment that's been received over the last few months. So this slide is the main takeaway slide on federal policy with regard to the siting of wireless facilities. If there's any one slide that I'd like you to take home with you today, this is the information on it. It will be this slide. Generally, no local decision or regulation can prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services.

10:41 The FCC has sole authority to determine and set standards for RF emissions. Localities cannot regulate placement of wireless facilities based on RF emissions except to ensure that the applicant has shown that it has complied with the FCC standards.

11:03 Here the applicant has provided a certification and demonstrated that the proposed facility would comply with the FCC standards. Timely action is required. The FCC has established a number of shot clocks for action for the town to reach a final decision on an application. These range from 60 to 150 days. We're dealing with a 150-day shot clock with regard to this application.

11:33 All denials need to be in writing and based on substantial evidence on the record and be provided to the applicant as soon as practical after the decision has been made. Applicants are entitled to expedited appeals in federal court should they challenge a decision. And there are certain mandatory approvals that the town has no discretion and must approve.

12:02 If they qualify, these are known as eligible facilities requests. General legal framework on the federal side, the main watershed act in the wireless space is the Telecommunications Act of 1996. It established two main provisions that are at play and relevant for today's discussion, section 332 and section 253. These outline the

12:32 Town's authority and preempts all local regulations that prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting any entity to provide personal wireless services in 332 and telecommunication services in 253. Section 332 also recognizes and preserves local zoning authority to control the placement of personal wireless facilities subject to certain substantive

13:01 and procedural limits. The town has exercised this authority by adopting its wireless regulations that we were discussing this morning. In addition, the next main act is the Middle Class Tax and Relief Act of 2012. This established eligible facilities requests. These are those modifications that the town has no discretion and must approve if they qualify.

13:30 In addition, one of the main sources of law in this area are FCC regulations which carry the force of law. One of which I'd like to discuss at the start is in 2018 the FCC adopted a moratoria ban. The town is prohibited from restricting wireless facilities or setting

13:58 a limit on the number of wireless facilities in the town itself or prohibiting wireless facilities altogether. As I mentioned, the Section 332 requires localities to act on applications within a reasonable period of time. The FCC has interpreted this provision to set forth a number of shot clocks.

14:29 Ranging from 60 to 150 days. Here we are dealing with the 150 day shot clock. In regards to the shot clock itself, as you probably have seen in the staff report, the town and the applicant have entered into a tolling agreement and have mutually agreed to extend the end date of the shot clock until April 19th. So we have some time available for continued review.

15:00 One of the other main aspects of FCC authority and federal authority is that no state or local entity may regulate the placement, construction, and modification of personal wireless services on the basis of environmental effects of radio frequency emissions to the extent that the facilities comply with the commission's standards. The Telecommunications Act directed

15:30 The FCC to create these standards and monitor them. In regards to FCC and regulations and on our emissions and their wide preemption of local authority, there's also been some case law which has limited what can serve as substantial evidence to support a decision by a locality.

15:57 Direct or indirect concerns over the perceived health effects of RF emissions may not serve as substantial evidence to support the denial of an application where the applicant has already demonstrated compliance with the FCC standards for RF emissions, which is the case here.

16:14 In addition, claims that a proposed wireless facility will result in diminished property values that are rooted in a concern about the perceived effects of RF emissions cannot constitute substantial evidence supporting a denial of a wireless application. In addition, recent case law has determined that hypersensitivity to RF emissions does not require accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act.

16:48 As I mentioned, there are certain modifications to an existing wireless facility that the town has no discretion and must approve. These are called eligible facilities requests. There's been some public comment concerning whether the applicant can increase the size of the tower through subsequent modifications. The FCC has set a number of criteria which limit what can qualify as an eligible facilities request.

17:17 And which would limit the amount of height that can be increased or protrusion or the number of cabinets that can be added on the ground among many other criteria that the FCC has established. I would ask that the applicant would describe how co-location would work on this tower during their comment, whether or not further a noose co-located.

17:43 Wireless tenant would go above or below the current antennas and how the tower would be set up for future co-locations, if that's even available. As part of the eligible facilities request process, there's been three main FCC orders. Most recently, the two in 2020 have had the general effect of expanding what qualifies as an eligible facilities request.

18:11 and limiting what types of concealment requirements must be carried through and preserved from existing conditions of approval in subsequent modifications. In addition, state law has also jumped into the fray to provide a number of other regulations for wireless facilities, in particular with the adoption of AB 357 last year.

18:43 We now have the net effect in California that all wireless application types have a deemed approved remedy if the town misses the FCC shot clock. There is an exception for fire department facilities. Here, because the proposed facility is on a fire district property, the deemed approved remedy under state law is not available. However,

19:10 The applicant may still pursue litigation and seek an approval as a court-ordered remedy on an expedited basis. State laws also establish that wireless permits cannot be for less than 10 years unless they're specific public safety or land use reasons for a shorter time frame, cannot require escrow deposits, cannot require that all facilities are located on sites on bar particular parties.

19:37 And there is wide acknowledgement on the state level of the FCC's and federal government's wide preemption in the field of RF emissions. Now I wanted to shift gears and address a few concerns that were raised in recent public comments regards to application requirements and what the applicant actually needs to demonstrate. I believe a public comment generally overstated what is required.

20:09 So the wireless specific application requirements are contained in section 1752.120. And there's two main requirements that I'd like to discuss today, the coverage map requirement and the alternate site analysis.

20:28 Applicant was required, and this is a direct quote, what you're reading here is a direct quote from the code, a map showing planned and or anticipated future needs of wireless communication services and facilities within and throughout the town, including a discussion of existing local network facilities and service gaps. This requirement does not require the applicant to demonstrate that a significant gap exists.

20:56 A significant gap test is a judicially created test used to determine whether a local entity's action has prohibited or has the effect of prohibiting personal wireless services. That is not the requirement under the code to demonstrate a significant gap. Only a discussion of existing local network facilities and existing service gaps is all that's required. Hey, Bennett, may I interrupt you really quick? Is this state or federal code?

21:25 That you're reading off. This is the town's code. Got it. Thank you. That's an important distinction. This is the town's code requirements and wireless-specific application requirements. In addition, some public comment has raised that the code that drive tests or other hard data is required to support these network and service gap

21:56 documents and that code does not require a drive test or hard data. That is a separate legal issue that is not required under the town's code. Second, we have the alternate site analysis. Again, quoting from the town code, an alternate site analysis must be, well, must be submitted detailing the specific steps undertaken to determine the applicant's selection of a particular site.

22:25 consistent with subsection 1752 180 F2. I've reproduced that below in bullet point three site selection. This application requirement requires the applicant to submit information detailing their specific steps taken to select the current site that they are proposing and to describe

22:54 why more preferred sites were not available. There is no requirement that the applicant pursue or enter into agreements with multiple property owners to secure potential sites, and they need only describe their process in selecting a site consistent with this application requirement. And at this

23:22 point, I will hand it over to Alicia to discuss some CEQA requirements and discussion relating to this application. Thank you, Bennett, and thank you, Chair and Commission for having us today. As Bennett mentioned, I'm going to go over some of the basics with respect to the town's CEQA authority on this application.

23:49 So as you all are aware, anytime that the town commission or council takes an action, a discretionary action, the town must consider whether that action has the potential to result either in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect impact to the environment.

24:11 And when we're conducting CEQA review, we engage in a three-step process. Step one of the process is to ask if we have a project that's subject to the act. And here we do have a project that is subject to the act. Today you're being asked to make a discretionary decision with respect to the telecom facility and whether or not to approve it. You're exercising your discretion over that request.

24:37 Step two of the process is to ask whether your discretionary decision today is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. The act itself sets forth both statutory and categorical exemptions. Statutory exemptions are absolute. Categorical exemptions are qualified.

24:58 Here, staff is recommending that the town council, excuse me, that the town commission, the PEDC, adopt a categorical exemption under state CEQA guidelines section 15303. And this is a class referred to as a class three categorical exemption.

25:18 This exemption is specifically outlined in the regulations to include construction and location of limited numbers of new small facilities and structures, among other things. But we're going to focus here today on the construction and location of limited numbers of new small facilities and structures, as well as the installation of small new equipment and facilities in small structures.

25:48 So if the town is able to identify evidence that demonstrates the project fits within the four corners of this class three exemption, the project is exempt no matter how significant the environmental impacts of the action are. And those environmental impacts could include aesthetic impacts, for example.

26:13 You have read quite a bit in public comments that have been submitted in writing as well as have heard comments that were submitted at the November 8th meeting about concerns, aesthetic impact concerns that may occur as a result of the project. Like I said, if the project fits within the four corners of the class three categorical exemption, it doesn't matter how significant those impacts are, CEQA exempts that from environmental review.

26:43 So again here, as Andy mentioned at the beginning of his remarks, the commission's goal today is not to state whether or not you think that an aesthetic impact is good or bad. Your goal is to identify whether the project fits within the class three criteria. So we need to focus on whether this proposal involves the construction of a limited number of new small facilities or structures.

27:12 and or involves the installation of a small new equipment and facilities in small structures. In public comments, you have heard concerns about whether the monopine itself is a small facility or structure. Your task today is to determine whether in fact you believe that findings can be made that the monopine is a small facility. Staff has indicated in the staff report and you will hear more today in the staff verbal presentation about

27:41 Why the structure standing at 80 feet tall, staff believes qualifies as a small facility. If you look to the surrounding context of the regulation in 15303, you'll see that the Natural Resources Agency has identified certain square footage limitations or total

28:04 Excuse me, I just lost my wording. Floor area, sorry. Floor area limitations for certain types of projects that may qualify for a class three exemption. And specifically, if we're looking at a commercial facility, if that commercial facility is 2,500 square feet of gross floor area or less, then the project

28:32 is presumed to fit within the four corners of a class three categorical exemption. Here, the monopine, though it does stand at 80 feet tall, is only 680 square feet of total floor area. In addition to that, there is only one monopine that is proposed, so the number of facilities that are proposed is limited. It's limited to the fire district property.

29:02 and is focused alone to be installed in that area. In addition, staff will speak to the fact that the monopine standing at the proposed height would be similar to, though admittedly not identical to, other structures in the surrounding area. And contrary to a case that was cited by some commenters,

29:31 In advance of the last hearing on this matter on November 8th, this facility will actually be camouflaged and aesthetically designed so as to blend with the surrounding area. The reason I point that out is because commenters in the past have pointed to the St. Ignatius case, which is not binding precedent if that case comes up today.

29:59 The commission should be aware that it is not binding law in California. We cannot cite it in court, but I think it is important to note that the facts of that case involve a 90-foot light standard that was proposed at an athletic field, and there the court, in looking at the surrounding environment and area in which that 90-foot hole would be erected and illuminated,

30:28 found that the illuminated structure standing at that height far exceeded any of the surrounding areas improvements in the area that the city in that case had cited to. And so the court in that case found that the class three categorical exemption did not apply. But like I said, that case is not binding on the town. It is distinguishable factually because

30:58 There it was dealing with a light standard, not a telecom facility, so different background regulatory scheme. But with respect to the actual structure, it is also factually distinguishable in our case from the St. Ignatius case because there will be this camouflaging, blending and treatment to the facility to try to harmonize the facility with the surrounding area.

31:26 So if the commission believes that it can make that finding that the project fits within that class three categorical exemption, there is an implied finding that none of the exceptions to the exemptions in state CEQA guidelines section 15300.2 applies. The reason that that is important and the reason I bring it up is because you will see in your staff report that staff has actually taken an additional step to explain

31:54 why it is that none of those exceptions to the exemptions are triggered. And that is important because if an exception is triggered, then under CEQA, that means we move out of step two and into step three of this three-step process. Step three of the three-step process is to actually conduct environmental review on the proposal by engaging in an initial study and then determining whether we need to prepare a mitigated NIGDEC or an EIR.

32:24 Here staff does not believe that going to step three is necessary because number one, we fit within the four corners of the categorical exemption with respect to this particular proposal and number two, none of the exceptions to the exemptions applies. You may hear today in public comment, comment about concerns on aesthetic impacts, impacts to views from private properties adjacent

32:53 property owners through the site and up to the mountains or out across the property leading up to the mountains. And so I think it's important to keep in mind there that the town's code and CEQA, most importantly, do not protect private views to the extent that there's any consideration given to views in an actual in-depth environmental analysis.

33:21 That analysis is focused on impacts to public views or scenic vistas or scenic resources from public vantage points. Again, we're not getting to that level of detail because an environmental impact report and an MND are not being prepared here because none of the exceptions to the exemptions apply. But as you're thinking through those comments and needing and wanting to respond to them,

33:50 Keep in mind that if we were in environmental review realm where we were doing an EIR and MND, we would need to focus on impacts to views from public vantage points. Thank you, Bennett. I think now I will be turning it over to Michael. Thanks, Alicia and Bennett. Michael, I might ask that when you're giving your presentation that you pause occasionally in case anybody on the commission might have questions in regards to

34:30 The ground you just covered. Okay. Yeah, just let me know. Thank you. The AT&T cell tower project at fire station number two consists of one planning entitlement for a use permit. This item was continued from the November 8, 2023 PEDC meeting due to an error in the public noticing that inadvertently resulted in a number of property owners not receiving the public hearing notice. This issue was resolved and a notice was sent to all property owners within 400 feet of the project parcel

35:03 Prior to today's meeting. In the time since the November 8th meeting, a tolling agreement was executed between the town and the applicant to pause the FCC mandated shot clock. The additional time allowed for the neighboring Snow Creek 7 HOA and the applicant to discuss alternatives for the project, but their discussions did not result in AT&T pursuing a different location for the monopine. The Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, who is a land...

35:36 owner is working with Yukon Group, the applicant and consultant for AT&T. They have submitted an application for an 80-foot tall stealth monopine cell tower that will be located at fire station number two on Old Mammoth Road. The tower is intended to expand service in the area that currently has poor service and improve public safety and emergency communications for the fire district and other first responders. The tower will initially be used by AT&T.

36:02 And there will be the option for other service providers to co-locate their equipment on the tower through the approval of a subsequent use permit. The project parcel is shown here and is located at 1574 Old Mammoth Road. The size of the parcel is 0.91 acres and it is located in the resort zoning district. The project site is zoned resort and is part of the Snow Creek Master Plan area. The resort zone is not just a residential zone as it allows for various uses including residential,

36:39 Professional and administrative offices, hotels, recreational facilities, and public or quasi-public uses. The zone also lists utilities as a permitted use, which the cell tower is considered. The Snow Creek Master Plan does not contain development standards for telecommunication facilities, and instead relies on the standards specified in the municipal code. The master plan states, where the master plan is silent on development standards, other regulations, other, sorry,

37:09 Where the master plan is silent on development standards or other regulations, other provisions of the town's municipal code apply. The municipal code includes development standards for telecommunications facilities. First is site selection, which is focused on the old Mammoth area due to the significant gap in acceptable coverage in the area. When considering potential sites, the code specifies the following order of preference. Number one, on or within existing structures, including church steeples,

37:45 Rift top stairwells or equipment enclosures or two, co-location of facilities such as locating equipment with another provider on a single facility. Both of these were not possible as there's no existing structures or towers that can accommodate the area's needs. Instead, the applicant worked to find a new location that meets the third and fourth selection criteria. This includes a location that has existing topography, vegetation or other structures to provide screening.

38:12 and will not require significant visual mitigation. The proposed location is in the rear of the property and is screened from view from public or out of way, as it's important to note that the town zoning code does not protect views from private property or private streets. Also, the stealth monopine design was chosen to best blend in with the site. The code requires that projects being located near existing utility poles, trees, or other similar objects

38:42 And consists of colors and materials that best blend with the background and also requires that it be located in the rear portion of the property. Municipal code does not establish a maximum height for cellular facilities and instead specifies that the maximum height is to be determined through the use permit, which is a height that is necessary to provide adequate coverage. For this project, a height of 80 feet was determined to be adequate and the applicant has provided analysis for different heights, which shows that 80 feet is needed to provide the necessary coverage.

39:18 To note, the antennas will be located at approximately 74 feet, but a total height of 80 feet is needed to create the cone-shaped treetop. As far as setbacks, the resort zone does not establish setbacks for cellular facilities, so the setbacks of 20 feet are based on the public and quasi-public zone, since this is the zone that most closely matches the use on the site. Also on this slide is a portion of the site plan that shows the location of the tower.

39:47 As well as the mechanical equipment that will be located next to the existing fire station. Staff has received a number of written comments on the project that have been provided to the commission and made available to the public. These comments have been reviewed and grouped into the general categories of concerns of visual impacts, concerns related to health and safety of radio frequency, and comments that other locations should be considered. In response to visual impacts,

40:25 The project meets the standards for telecommunication facilities in the zoning code. These include locating the facility near the rear of the property, which is not visible from public right-of-way, and screening the tower as a faux pine tree to blend in with the surroundings. Once again, it's important to note that the town's zoning code does not protect views from private property. In response to the health and safety concerns, Bennett covered this in his presentation earlier, but pursuant to the Telecommunications Act of 1996,

40:53 The town is not able to consider the environmental effects of radio frequency, including health, when regulating the placement of a cell tower, provided the FCC guidelines for maximum exposure and radio frequency are adhered to. This project meets those guidelines based on the radio frequency safety report that was prepared for the project. In response to other locations being considered, AT&T and their consultant Yukon Group performed a thorough set analysis and determined that fire station number two is the best site for the monopine cell tower.

41:25 Other sites that were considered include St. Joseph's Catholic Church located at 58 Ranch Road and the Snow Creek Athletic Club located at 51 Club Drive. The church site is not a viable option because it is zoned residential multifamily 2 and telecommunications facilities are not permitted in residential zones. The Snow Creek Athletic Club was not pursued due to lack of landlord interest at the time.

41:52 that AT&T was conducting their alternative site analysis. With that being said, the staff recommendation before you is that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the resolution making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings and approving use permit 23-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Next, I'm going to pass it off to Sonal from UConn Group for a

42:23 presentation from her team. If we could pause that for just one second, I just want to see if anyone on the commission has any questions from Michael or Nolan on the staff report that was just presented to us. We will have the opportunity to circle back on this, but if anyone has a burning question at the moment. Sorry, Michael, please pass it off to the applicant. Sonal, feel free to share your screen. Please bear with me while I share my screen. Good morning, Chair Vanderhert and members of the Planning Commission. My name is

43:24 Sonal Takwar. I am with Yukon Group representing AT&T's AT&T Mobility. As mentioned, the proposed project is at 1574 Old Mammoth Road on the Fire Protection District Station 2 property. The existing site coverage is shown on this map.

43:56 The AT&T site ID is CSL04615, this area here, and these surrounding sites are currently on-air and AT&T sites. There is currently a lack of coverage and AT&T is looking to fill that and address those coverage needs in order for the network to work better in

44:27 conjunction with the other sites and other sites in the Mono County area. This is the search ring area where AT&T's RF engineers need to provide coverage along Old Mammoth Road as well as to the various resort and residential uses to the north, south, east, and west of Old Mammoth Road. When selecting a site to

45:00 propose a candidate for AT&T, we need to determine if there are five different categories that can be achieved. The first is whether or not the site is zonable, meaning whether or not we can comply with the town or city's development standards in their municipal code. Secondly, we have to determine if there is landlord interest and ultimately if AT&T and the landlord can

45:29 negotiate and come to agreement on terms to result in a fully executed lease. Third, we need to be able to assure that the site itself will be designed and be able to meet the RF engineer's coverage objectives for the area and the overall AT&T network. The fourth requirement is to assure that the site that is designed

45:58 can be constructed and is feasible to comply with the Uniform Building Code and all other City Department requirements. And fifth, the site needs to comply with regulatory requirements, both at the local level, the state level, and federal. The proposed facility at the fire station has been able to comply with these five categories. Additionally, we need to be able to

46:30 This is a snippet of the zoning code or zoning map for the

47:02 Coverage Area or the Search Wing Area. As you will see, this is Old Mammoth Road and to the north, the area in pink is the resort zone where cellular facilities may be approved and proposed. To the north, there are residential multifamily, single-family residential, similarly more residential zones to the west and to the south of Old Mammoth Road.

47:32 The town's code prohibits siting any cellular facilities in those residential zones. Therefore, our focus was to this resort zone area in the pink. This map shows the various alternative candidates as well as the proposed candidate that AT&T and UConn analyzed in order to determine which parcel and which property would be.

48:03 best meet the coverage objectives and comply with all of the five categories of proposing a facility. This teal balloon here is where the proposed 80-foot monopine tower is located on the fire station property. The blue pins, three of these blue pins, are alternative locations on the fire property that were analyzed and

48:33 Considered. The four yellow pins are alternative candidates on alternate properties separate of the fire district. The red balloons just show locations where residential zones and uses are located, which again are not properties and areas that are allowed to host wireless facilities based on the town of Mammoth Lakes code.

49:06 And then these pink balloons show resort zones, but these are where there are existing townhome developments. The proposed facility on Fire District Station 2 property is the 80-foot monoplane, which is shown in this photo simulation. This is the Fire Protection District property or building. This is where the 80-foot monoplane would be situated.

49:39 and it is surrounded by other existing live pines. The pine would be disguised with faux branches as well as pine needle socks and painting of the antennas and equipment on the tower to simulate a more realistic pine tree. The 80 feet is also proposed so that the top five feet of the tower would have a more conical shape.

50:07 As opposed to being flat and look less realistic. As mentioned in staff's report, Fire Station 2 has a public institution quasi-public use and their sole function is to protect public health and life safety. The top of the steel and top of the tower would be at 75 feet and again the five additional

50:38 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

51:10 There is also a 200 square foot equipment enclosure that is proposed in association with the tower.

51:42 located to the west against the elevation of the fire station building. The Monopine Tower is located at the rear portion of the property per the municipal code. The tower does not encroach into any required parking, loading, or pedestrian circulation areas, and it also is out of the way of any areas that are needed for fire station 2 operations. The equipment enclosure is located

52:15 Located south of an existing pad-mounted transformer on the west side of the fire station building. And this allows for AT&T's network operations to be able to access not only the equipment enclosure but the pine tree through a clear path of access and with the shortest distance. This is especially important in any emergencies or for any

52:44 Routine maintenance that may be required that could not be addressed remotely. AT&T also selected this location on Fire Station 2 property because there is an additional layer of 24-7 security surveillance of the AT&T equipment with the fact that fire personnel are on site and their primary function is to address

53:14 calls and concerns for public safety. The 80-foot cell tower is appropriate and compatible with the fire station to use on this property because utilities are permitted and they work in conjunction with the role of first responders. Clear communication and coverage is very critical for first responders as I'm sure the fire chief will.

53:45 present in his presentation. This candidate was an optimal location for AT&T's RF engineers in order to achieve their network coverage objectives. This tower will also provide FirstNet service for first responders on this tower. Additionally, this project has been years in the making. AT&T and the fire district were able to

54:16 Fully negotiated the late lease that was backed by the fire board. And the fire station also would have the ability to use this AT&T tower to locate fire equipment in the future. The alternative locations on the fire station property are shown with the blue pins. Alternative A is here. It is located in the landscape planner in the property frontage. However, this location is not permitted by code.

54:49 The town's code requires that cellular facilities need to be located in the rear portion of the parcel, so this location was rejected. Alternative B is behind the fire station adjacent to the training tower as well as adjacent to the two-car garage that the fire trucks come out of.

55:20 A 75-foot non-stealth monopole was analyzed. Just a 75-foot monopole behind the fire station was analyzed at the request of the Creek House HOA. Photo sims were generated. However, there was no response that was provided back with those simulations and that evaluation.

55:51 AT&T, however, was not able, cannot support this location. It is not viable for AT&T due to their concern and risk that their equipment would be damaged. The tower being proximate to the fire training tower and the fire station garages results in many concerns for AT&T and it potentially could result in damage that would impact AT&T's tower and equipment.

56:21 Additionally, there's several manholes in this area of the fire station that would be associated with underground utilities, which AT&T cannot support. Alternative C would be to locate to the east of the fire station building. Photosims of this alternative location were provided to the city and the creek house, an 80-foot monopine as well as a 75-foot

56:53 Tall monopole that was non-stealth were provided for review. No input or response was provided back. However, this location would not comply with the town's code because it requires cell facilities to be in the rear portion of the parcel. This location is still close to the public right-of-way and the front of the parcel and it is not as far from the right-of-way.

57:22 as the proposed candidate. The proposed AT&T candidate, therefore, on this fire station property is optimal and complies with the code. Alternative one was St. Joseph's Catholic Church. This is zoned residential multiple family with a church and a single family residence. However, based upon the town's code, cellular facilities are not

57:50 permitted to be located on the property of residential zones. Additionally, AT&T's RF engineer had evaluated this candidate and rejected it due to its lower elevation. The second alternative was the Snow Creek Athletic Club. It is zoned resort, has uses like gym, spa, restaurant, and it has an outdoor pool and tennis courts. If AT&T

58:20 were to have located on this property, the cell facility would need to be located in the rear of the property and also could not be located in any required parking, loading, maneuvering, or vehicular pedestrian circulation areas. AT&T's RF engineer evaluated this candidate and rejected it due to the lower elevation than Fire Station 2.

58:51 A tower was able to be located at this Snow Creek Athletic Club in the rear portion. It would still be in the vicinity or areas for pedestrian circulation. Similarly, it would be proximate to the tennis courts and the pools, but the biggest concern would be that it would be proximate to these existing townhomes. I believe it's Snow Creek Phase 4 to the north.

59:21 and the residential apartments to the west Aspen Village. Additionally, the tower and 200 square foot equipment enclosure would not have as clear a path and direct access for AT&T's network operations as the current proposed property at Fire Station 2. Locating at the Snow Creek Athletic Club,

59:49 Also would not provide a less intrusive means of providing coverage than the proposed Fire Station 2 property as it just moves the tower closer to other townhomes and apartments in the resort zone and is an example of NIMBYism. Fire Station 2 is still the optimal and preferred candidate for the AT&T RF engineers to meet their coverage objectives for the network. Alternative 3 was Aspen Village Apartments.

1:00:21 It too has the resort zone and is developed with residential departments. This location is too far west from the center of the RF Engineer's coverage objective area. Locating on Alternative 3 does not provide a less intrusive means of providing coverage than the proposed Fire Station 2 property. It too moves the tower and the associated equipment enclosure closer to Snow Creek 4 townhomes to the north.

1:00:51 and the apartments in this resort zone and is another example of NIMBYism. It just moves the tower elsewhere next to the same types of uses. Fire Station 2 is still the optimal candidate and preferred for AT&T's RF engineers so that they can meet their coverage objectives. Alternative 4 is the water district. To the west, there are residential zoned parcels that are

1:01:23 residential single-family area, which is not, which cell sites are not permitted to locate upon, and to the north, you still have the Aspen Village Apartments, and further north of that would be the Snow Creek for townhomes. Additionally, to the south of Mammoth Road is residential multifamily one, another residential area where cellular facilities are not permitted. This

1:01:57 Also brings the tower closer to these residential uses, which tend to be occupied by residents and individuals who would live there as their primary residence in comparison to a larger volume of the units in the resort zone being secondary homes or vacation rentals.

1:02:28 The town of Mammoth Lakes Code prohibits cell facilities on these residential zones, so moving the tower to this water facility district would not be a less intrusive means of providing coverage. Fire Station 2 allows AT&T's RF engineers to successfully meet their objectives and strengthen the network. It also provides the critically needed coverage for the town and the first responders.

1:03:00 So that the public's general welfare and life safety can be protected, especially in emergencies as the town has experienced for several years, be it from rain, snow, fires or any other emergencies. The proposed candidate is feasible from a zoning standpoint, leasing standpoint and does comply with all federal, state and local regulations.

1:03:30 We utilize the least intrusive means of providing coverage with a stealth camouflaged pine and locating on the Fire Station 2 property we feel is the most appropriate and compatible with the land use and operations of the Fire District. The entire objective of proposing this facility was to provide reliable, strong coverage at all levels of service.

1:03:59 at the pedestrian level, in vehicles and within buildings to not only the first responders, but to residents, business and tourists of the town of Mammoth Lakes. These are photo simulations showing the existing conditions and what the proposed monopine would look like once installed. Currently, this is the view looking north from Old Mammoth Road with the installation of the 80-foot monopine.

1:04:35 This is the view. This is a view looking northwest from Old Mammoth Road. This is what it would look like after the monoplying was installed. I would like to mention that these photo simulations were prepared and generated by Artistic Engineering, which is a third-party vendor that creates photo sims. They did submit a statement of accuracy and certification.

1:05:08 and that these photosims were in fact generated from plants submitted to the town and utilizing pictures that were taken December 21st of 2023. This is a view from looking southwest from Timber Creek Road and here's what it would look like with the photo with the pine tree installed. Looking east from Club Drive and the view of the monopine with surrounding trees and

1:05:46 being screened and having context. Again, this is a coverage map generated by AT&T's RF engineers showing the existing conditions in the surrounding area and more importantly in this coverage objective area. You see that there are marginal and poor levels of outdoor signal, in vehicle signal and indoor signal. This shows what the coverage would be

1:06:21 If this proposed site was turned on air and constructed, all of the other existing sites in the surrounding area are turned off just to show the coverage provided. And this map shows how this network would work in conjunction with the other sites in the surrounding area. It has been described that cellular networks work similar to

1:06:51 Kind of a bee's honeycomb, and they send and receive signal and communicate with one another for seamless transfer of signal. I would also like to mention that Scott Heffernan with Fox Hill Telecom, who is an RF engineer, is also available. He and his company conducted an independent analysis of AT&T's designed model pine.

1:07:22 and utilize the plans and information that were provided to the city. Their conclusion was that the proposed facility does comply with FCC regulations and he is available to answer any questions that the public or planning commission may have. To conclude, this proposed facility once again does comply with the town's code and development standards.

1:07:51 We believe the least intrusive location and means were utilized. No alternative candidate or location is of a higher preference, nor do they employ less intrusive means of providing coverage. And moving the tower and equipment facility to another location from the alternatives that were discussed in the resort zone is simply just NIMBYism.

1:08:18 The proposed facility does address the public safety concerns and will improve coverage and provide connectivity for first responders. It will also have AT&T's FirstNet, which is critically needed for fire, police and other emergency services. And with the on-air deployment of this facility, there will be an improved and noticeable

1:08:48 Improvement to pedestrian, in-vehicle and in-building coverage levels, both for fire and all the residents of the town. A noteworthy point is that this tower, again, is co-locatable. So AT&T would propose their antennas at the top of the structure, the top of the steel pole and the antennas would be at 75 feet and a future carrier.

1:09:19 could co-locate below AT&T on this 80-foot tower, and this would delay any time that it is needed for additional construction for proposing a extended pole because the height is already there. It allows for quick

1:09:39 installation of a second carrier. However, that second carrier would still need to submit an application to the city to review for compliance and secure any required permits. In many of the comments from the public, they did comment that the opposition concedes improvements in connectivity are in fact needed in the surrounding area, but

1:10:11 With the installation of this facility, the site and those improvements will increase property values. There were general concerns that were made about aesthetics. However, they're insufficient as a matter of law to support denying AT&T's application. And several of the comments from the nearby homeowners raised concerns based on the premise of fears about RF emissions.

1:10:36 AT&T has demonstrated that the proposed facility will comply with the FCC's RF exposure standards, and so its application cannot be rejected whether health concerns are raised explicitly or indirectly through some proxies as property values. This concludes my presentation. As I mentioned, Scott Heffernan with Fox Hill Telecom is available to answer any questions.

1:11:03 And concerns the public may have, but he does have a brief presentation. Scott, are you on? Are you going to give your presentation now? Sonal, I don't think we have Scott on. There we go. And you're muted, Scott. Did we lose him, Jamie? Got it. Trying to log back on. We'll give him a couple of seconds here. I appreciate the public's patience on this. We may let him come back in a little bit later this morning.

1:12:34 But in the interest of everyone's time, maybe we'll take this moment. Does anybody on the commission have any questions for the applicant, for the AT&T applicant and her presentation? Sonal, are you still with us if we do have any questions? Yes, I am still here. Does anybody have any questions for the applicant at this time? I do. Please. Commissioner Chang. This is Paul. Good morning. Good morning. Just a quick question about the

1:13:09 proposed location. Why now? Why does AT&T want to do this now when we haven't had coverage here in this particular area for many years? Why? I apologize for interrupting. No, that's okay. Go ahead. I was going to say AT&T has actually been trying to get coverage to this area of Mammoth Lakes that I'm aware of.

1:13:42 I'd say well over a decade, but it does take time for that to occur. I believe there were many conversations and meetings directly with Mono County in general in order to try to create coverage for the entire county. So it's not only to provide coverage to Mammoth Lakes, but work in conjunction with other

1:14:09 AT&T sites in the county and making sure that Mammoth Lakes and this overall area does have the coverage they need for the topography. So it's not for lack of effort. There's always been a desire to improve this area. Has AT&T communicated with other carriers about having additional services for other carriers?

1:14:42 Do you mean, has AT&T communicated with other carriers to co-locate on this proposed tower? Correct. AT&T would not go to, would not reach out to other carriers to advise they should come on this tower. However, it is my understanding that Verizon Wireless, another competing major carrier, has expressed interest to the fire station and fire chief directly.

1:15:12 Alesh Tomer may answer that question. Thank you. That's all I have. Thank you. Any other questions for the applicant at this time? Please. Commissioner Eckert. So this tower has been proposed for 10 years, a decade, as you said. Back in the day, it was supposed to be 45 feet. Now it's supposed to be 75 feet, visually 80 feet. Why is it when the equipment, technology, et cetera,

1:15:41 In theory, it's getting better that the tower needs to be taller to have the same service. I can say that for this facility, this is the one I've worked on, the AT&T engineers did analyze the surrounding topography, the need for coverage, conducted tests to see what elevation would be required to provide that coverage, and additionally, as the town's code requires.

1:16:14 It did allow for, it does allow for co-location of a second carrier, and that was also a need and concern that was expressed by the fire department. They wanted to make sure that a second carrier could in fact locate on that tower. As far as, and I think Scott can also provide some insight in regards to the technology aspect of your question.

1:16:47 Can you hear me now? We got you, Scott. Thank you. I apologize, but I have no idea what happened with the audio. It's a little embarrassing. With regard to that question, I know that this question comes up quite a bit with technology having great enhancements and new equipment being rolled out. The reason that the additional height is needed now,

1:17:16 I'm not sure what the original objective of this ring was. We were brought on by AT&T to handle three separate things to determine whether or not it was compliant with the federal regulations with regard to emissions. Number two, to make sure that there would be no interference issues, to rule out any interference issues between public safety and AT&T's equipment if they were to install.

1:17:44 Third, to verify the coverage maps as they pertain to the objective that we were given and how it fits in with the existing coverage. I know that there was an application a while back for a shorter height. However, analyzing the network as it is now and knowing the technologies that are being rolled out with the finite frequency bands that AT&T is licensed for,

1:18:12 We've concluded that 70 feet would be the minimal height to meet the minimum design criteria for this coverage objective and to allow it to be co-locatable for one additional tenant. Some of these minimum design requirements have become a little more stringent only because when you start to roll out services like 5G services, enhanced LTE services, services that carry

1:18:41 A lot of streaming video, very large data transfers. It's a completely different animal than comparing it to, you know, an old school GSM network that were very forgiving at low received signal strengths. So based upon that, you do require a certain level of robust coverage, a much greater robust footprint.

1:19:06 than you would typically need in the past to meet the requirements of these services. So based upon that, that's really where we come up with that minimum design height of 70 feet to allow for the two carrier co-locatable pole. Really, and the way we backed into that is that because of the terrain issues in the area and the low height that we're considering, 60 feet is where we really overcame a lot of the terrain.

1:19:36 Hinderances as you head east towards the existing footprint. So realizing that 60 feet is the minimum height that we need where we start to make that connection with the existing footprint at reliable in-building service, that really sets our baseline. So knowing that we need that as a minimum height and then adding in a second carrier, we add an additional 10 feet onto the AT&T platform to figure out where that height would be to

1:20:06 to allow for two carriers to provide the same level of service with similar frequencies. So what you're saying is that second, that last 15 feet of tower is to allow for co-location, but if it were a 60 foot tower without co-location, the one initial would work the same as your second one coming up with an 80 foot tower.

1:20:30 The reason for the 80-foot tower is to allow AT&T to mount their antennas with a center line of 70 feet, which would then have the top of the antennas at about 74, 75 feet. The top 5 or 6 feet will be a cone structure to mimic the top of a tree, the pointed pyramid at the top of a tree. So the antennas will not go all the way up to the top of the 80-foot tower.

1:20:57 In fact, the top carrier of a two carrier pole here designed to meet that minimum design requirement would be 70 feet to the center line. Everything above that is for aesthetics purposes. I guess what I'm asking you to do is give me a comparison between a two-party tower at 80 feet and a one-party tower at 60 feet. A one-party tower would have to be 70 feet only because the antennas would be at 60 feet and the top of the tower would extend up to 70 feet.

1:21:31 There might be a little bit of confusion because when I reference the antenna center line, that is not the actual top of the structure. So that would be the dead center vertically of the antennas in the array for either carrier. So 70 feet would be midway up the antenna, typically where the antenna is attached to the mounting bracket for the pole, and then they extend up typically three or four feet above that.

1:21:59 which would put the top of the AT&T antennas, if they were to be mounted at 60 feet, top of those antennas would be 64 feet, at 70 feet, they would go up to 74 feet, and then you would, again, have roughly six feet or so for the branches of the tree to roll out the shape of the tree. I'm good. Hey, Scott, this is Paul. Just for clarification, if I want to hear, I'm not sure if I heard you correctly, at 70 feet,

1:22:29 It will allow you to have one additional carrier. Am I correct? 70 feet to the center line of the antenna. When I talk about the minimum design height for the AT&T antennas, that's the height of the antenna alone. So strip away the fake branches on the monopalm, or the monopine, I should say. And if it was just a steel monopole out there, yes, the middle of the AT&T antennas would be at 70 feet.

1:22:58 So at the proposed height of 80 feet, how many carriers can you have? It's still two, because you would have one at 60, one at 70, and then everything above that would not be usable only because the branches start to narrow in towards the top of, I would use like a pyramid type structure, typically how you, almost like the top of a Christmas tree where it comes to a point. So you couldn't really put anything above 70 feet.

1:23:28 Because the antennas would stick out beyond where the branches start to narrow. Thank you. Any other questions for the applicant? Commissioner Kennedy? Yeah, I've got just a couple, I think, that are applicant questions. My first is maybe a wild one. Can height be added on later if another carrier wants to participate? Or is that a one and done thing?

1:23:54 No, typically that would have to be known at the time of design of the tower. If it were to be made expandable, and this is done in a lot of cases where for future considerations you might say, well, we would like it to be expandable up to 100 feet or 120 feet. That would be given to the tower manufacturer. They would design the foundation, the base plate, and the tube of the tower structure.

1:24:21 to accommodate a bolt-on section at the top. But again, that's something that should be factored in at the beginning and maybe part of the decision. Okay, great. Thank you. My second question is, there were some images in one of those presentations about, I don't remember if it was one that Sonal had gone over, but.

1:24:41 80 versus 65 versus 35 feet towers. And I was wondering why the 35 feet tower was being included. Is it a consideration? Is it a suggestion from AT&T? Or was that just to show, I guess, the reduction in coverage that would come from 35 feet? It's done for a couple of reasons. It is done to show the effect at lowering heights from the initial starting point of 70 feet.

1:25:10 But as part of it, we anticipated the question of could you just put antennas on top of the fire station? So we tried to come up with a ballpark height for the center line of what those antennas would look like on the fire station or building nearby of that height. But it did prove out that at 35 feet, anything below that 60 foot level, the terrain does become a problem as you start to head east along the...

1:25:39 Old Mammoth Road Corridor. Got it. So it's in there more for demonstration purposes. Awesome. Very helpful to know. Thank you. And then one more, I think, applicant question is, there was a public comment about the ongoing maintenance of the monopine structure, and just curious if that, does that fall, and maybe town is, maybe this is the town question more, but who deals with the maintenance of that as things break and fall apart and visually look bad on the monopine? That would be AT&T.

1:26:09 Okay. Thank you. That's it for me. Commissioner Burrows, any questions for the applicant at this time? I have a quick question for the applicant. I don't know if it's Scott's world or Sonal's world, but in the presentation Sonal, you gave us the simulations depicted of the monopine, you know, the tree is very, very robust looking, and I'm sure

1:26:33 I can speak for a lot of people who are in this room. As we drive up and down the highways and freeways of California, we have seen monopine structures where it's a very sad attempt to camouflage the pole into the natural environment. So I'm wondering, are there different levels of monopine equipment? And if you could please touch on what you're proposing to put in Fire Station 2.

1:27:00 Yes, we are, AT&T is very mindful and sensitive to the surrounding area and we too want to make sure that the monopine that is ultimately constructed does look realistic, is screened and does so in the best way possible. We too over the years have seen some very sad examples of monopines. So cell trees would be the tower manufacturer that would

1:27:29 Fabricate this pole, makes the faux pine branches, and they too would be involved with the installation of the branches. They are very familiar with how concerned Mammoth Lakes and their residents would be that this is a robust looking tree. They've done pine facilities all over the state. I will say as an example, City of Irvine with the Irvine Company is a very

1:27:59 Stringent jurisdiction and Irvine Company is very particular in what they would allow on their property in the public rights of way and CellTrees has done work for them. CellTrees has also provided us with a matrix they're working on. I do not have it available at this moment in time but can submit it to staff. That would show the branch density.

1:28:27 And about how many branches would be needed in order to make sure that ultimately what's constructed is, you know, is sensitive to the topography and views. And is that a conversation you'll have with staff down the road or is like, I'm just wondering how available that information will be to the general public? I can make it available to the general public, would need to have it.

1:28:55 That's also material that would be provided with the construction drawings if approved and when we submit to building plan check. That is all factored into the structural engineering. So the building department engineering would also look at all of that detail on the plans. But in advance of that, I can provide that information to the city's planning division. Thank you.

1:29:21 And with that, I think our final presentation is from the fire district and chief. That is correct. And then we will open this up to public comment. So I appreciate your patience. We got it. Thanks for your time. A couple things. Ultimately, I think you have a pretty good idea of what at this point. I'm really here to talk about the why. I'm going to go a little bit into kind of history, what's been done to date.

1:31:50 Okay, so just a little bit of history. Again, it's been alluded to. This isn't the first time it's actually made it. We have reached it for two years. Prior to me was Chief Freehold, who was here. Part of him was Chief Harder. The first time that at that time, things were a little different, I'll be honest with you. The initial lot has changed since Velvet. So, you know, for me, a big one was the Thomas Fire. If you're not familiar with it, it was in 2007 Ventura.

1:32:47 Is that better? Thank you, Jamie. Let me know if it's not better. What happened is as you drove into an area basically

1:33:33 Your cell phone would alert you that you are entering a fire area. And, you know, the changes that we have to protect our public have been dramatic in the last decade as far as what's available for tools to protect our citizens. And it's important because as we've had new tools, we've also had new hazards. I don't think it's lost on anybody here. I don't have to get into Lahaina Fire or the Campfire in Paradise as far as...

1:33:55 what we're facing today. I'm going to get a little bit into what we have as a community as well and why communications is such a key piece for protecting our citizens. It's also been used, I'm going to get into a little bit what's referred to as IPAWS essentially, but you've probably seen it if you've been in Mono County for the last year when we had the winter storm emergencies and we had tourists coming up who didn't

1:34:18 know what they were getting into. We were sending out alerts about the explosions and the propane leaks we had just so that people were entering an environment with some situational awareness. It's been used for avalanches in the area. So, you know, things have changed for the last time that the district looked at this. This isn't just something that the fire district has been looking at. So what I'm going to point you to is in 2019-2020, Mono County put together a grand jury investigation or report that basically looked at

1:34:47 And this was dealing with the power safety public safety power shutoffs at the time. I'm not sure if you're familiar, but when Edison and companies first started those, it was at a time that people weren't prepared. So the cellular providers started losing their backup power. We started losing communications and had issues with the systems.

1:35:07 The county actually has significant communication issues that go far beyond cellular. I'm going to touch on those a little bit because I think it speaks to the importance of these, especially in a rural area. But what the grand jury found at that time for the Mona County grand jury report is essentially that there's kind of, and this was kind of bulletin three, which is communications, internal communications between local first responders had issues as well as the ability to communicate with the public. And I'm just going to really read this so everybody kind of understands the importance of this.

1:35:36 The other side of the communication coin is emergency responders must also, in times of widespread emergencies such as wildfire or pandemic, communicate with the public at large or with a group of people that might be affected in an emergency. In this case, they have very few options. One is a government alert system called IPAWS, Integrated Public Alert and Warning System. And again, those are the systems that you essentially can't in or out of, right, to where you, as soon as you show up, it's almost like an amber alert and it goes off.

1:36:04 They're extremely vital for communities like ours where you have quite a large influx of tourists who don't understand the area as well as you might if you're local. They don't have the same social media connections where your Facebook might go off unless you know there's a fire going. So it really reaches the entire public regardless of whether they're residents or visitors.

1:36:24 A little bit more on the grand jury recommendations. The grand jury recommended that Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes continue to support Mono County's participation in the FirstNet communication system and any appropriate improvements to the system as resources allow. The grand jury further recommended that these improvements be made within the scope of a unified plan for the entire county. So again, zooming out a little bit, this isn't just a Mammoth-centric, it's a whole Mono County area that we've been supporting on prior to me being fire chief.

1:36:53 There's a couple components to this. I don't know if you're familiar with the federal engineering study, but there's a study done on internal communications that looked at about a $20 million fix to fix our communications. Again, we have times when 911 completely has gone down here, and nobody has an ability to call 911. If that happened in Los Angeles, it would be a significant issue. So communications as a whole in our rural area needs work, and this is a piece of that.

1:37:23 Probably answer some of the questions that you alluded to, but again, feel free if some of this doesn't make sense or move further on. So again, kind of what we've done since that grand jury report came out. And I'm going to split this out into first responders, such as your firefighters, your law enforcement. Law enforcement is actually critical in situations such as wildfire because they have the ultimate responsibility for the evacuations, although generally when there's a fire moving through, we're not putting out fires, we're trying to evacuate people.

1:37:53 And then into kind of communications for the public. And shrink this down so I can see it. There. So for the first responder network, we've been working with the state and basically 19 million was a non-starter for a community of our size as far as a fix. You know, that's a tough one. We were looking at potentially looking bond measures. And even with that 19 million, there was a price tag to keep that system up about.

1:38:23 700,000 a year, if I'm correct, on the Federal Engineering Study. So, trying to find another way to kind of crack that nut. And really, what we found is that the state was putting in what's referred to as the CRIS system. It's the California Radio Interoperable System. And that was in the first phase. We were able to work with Cal OES to...

1:38:43 Get Mono County added on an earlier phase. We're supposed to be about phase three, which would be a few years from now. They said, look, there's truly a need in this area for a communication system for the first responders. And they bumped us up. So currently those repeaters are getting put in. The county was able to secure a federal earmark, which helped pay for the repeaters that the county was putting in. Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, as well as the town is supporting that effort. And basically instead of having

1:39:12 One chunk. What we're doing is we're utilizing existing state repeater systems, putting in a couple of our owns where the state ultimately has responsibility for the highways, so it doesn't have the exact same interests as we do, but it helps cover this area and adding our own equipment in to create a network that's going to work. That should be probably up within the next year, but it's kind of in the process, fixing the first responder side. This system has a

1:39:39 Motorola Core and it is designed to work with FirstNet and FirstNet is essentially what ended up happening is and we are kind of ambiguous as far as preparing AT&T, Verizon, any other providers. I think we have to look at capacity and size of those providers but AT&T ended up winning the federal contract.

1:39:59 for first responders. So the FirstNet system works directly with the CREST system and can support our network. And that's just for really the radio to radio, which is kind of the basic communications. Those are vital, but there, as you're aware, there's other types of communications that are going on. I'm going to hit on those kind of from the public side, a little bit from the public safety side as well.

1:40:21 So I've got that kind of piece established. At the same time, and this was really under Chief Freevault, we were working following those grand jury recommendations with FirstNet. There's an individual, Steve Devine, from the FirstNet side that, you know, we made an argument at Western Fire Chiefs that Mono County really represents an area that AT&T has to put some efforts into it. And I'm not going to ask you to raise your hands, but I would assume that most of the people in front of me have either Verizon or AT&T. And Verizon has...

1:40:49 AT&T might disagree with me, had stronger rural coverage, but AT&T really worked to catch up on that. And again, we said, you know, because of this first night, you have a responsibility to be covering this whole area. So I've got a list of sites here that have been put in since this grand jury report. It was up in Crowley, a bunch in Mammoth, June Lake, Levining, Bridgeport. They're still working on Tri-Valley and Colville, but ultimately the site that we're referring to is a piece of this kind of honeycomb as some will refer to it.

1:41:18 Leave it at that for now. So a little bit about why the tower is where it is and why it is at the height that it is. So we have a different interest than AT&T. And I'm also not an attorney. I'm not going to give you, you know, I'm going to give you how I understand it operationally. And ultimately, you know, what we went to AT&T and said is we need a tower that's going to provide coverage into this area.

1:41:48 AT&T doesn't work with Verizon. They're just competitors. The other thing that's a little difficult is this iPOS system. The way that it's designed, it doesn't work across carriers. So basically there's a requirement for AT&T to push out that messaging. But if you don't have an AT&T phone, it's not going to hit you. So really looking at it from the public safety side, we said it's great that we're going to hit.

1:42:12 AT&T, and that's a big piece, but we really want to try to get as much messaging out to everybody. And ultimately, you know, it'd be great if T-Mobile was interested as well. They have absolutely no interest. So we're looking at trying to cover 90% of the people, and that is our goal. So when we looked at them to propose a site, we said, look, give us an honest estimate of what would work that would provide coverage for you.

1:42:36 As well as coverage for a secondary provider. So they could have come in here and put a shorter tower, but eventually what ends up happening is I have a lease and I'll cover a little bit of room for a second provider. I've expressed interest, placed that there, and ultimately that is our intent. A little bit on the history there again. Initially we said no, we really don't really want to sell tower. To a certain extent we are a provider of masters. We're going to take a look at this, and this takes years.

1:43:33 I've been working on it for the last two years in developing the agreement side of consultants to make sure they're interested. The questions that you've had, we have the same questions. We basically have in the writing that this is the highest quality tree you can put in. The tree every few years, if the color starts in the best of our ability, file... Hey, Alish, while you're flipping pages, I've got a really quick question for you. It's a little bit more on the nuts and bolts side of things.

1:44:19 Sonal had mentioned that there is also an equipment shed that's going to supply the, I guess, hard equipment to help operate this tower. Are you guys in charge of the snow removal for that? Yeah, and so a couple things is, again, we didn't, AT&T came to us with the number, we have to do a snow removal on site regardless, but we came back, that would be it, so we already do our own snow removal. This would not change our...

1:44:46 process too much, but ultimately what we did want to make sure is that we are being appropriately accommodated for that process. So the nice thing about the station is, and I will correct Saul's presentation, station two is actually not staffed 24-7 in the sense that we are still primarily a volunteer department. It's kind of one of the concerns I can get into for why we need good communications. But we do have people that regularly are there responding and we keep that station.

1:45:13 in good conditions so that we can get our fire apparatus out. The town assists us with some of the plowing, but ultimately keeping that equipment

1:45:21 Properly protected and dug out, you know, would be on the district. And it's part of our lease agreement is to make sure that it's done appropriately. And also now anything new has to have the appropriate backup generator equipment. We had discussed doing some joint backup equipment, but ultimately Station 2 has good equipment and we decided it was easier to keep that separate but make sure they have appropriate equipment on their side. We did place it in the planter area we thought would be the least obtrusive area to...

1:45:49 Both for our operations as well as just impact, so ultimately there's just a fake tree in the back of the station. Not going to hit on this too much today because it got covered fairly well by AT&T's presentation, but ultimately, you know, so with the site, we tried to work with kind of all parties that have an interest to make sure that

1:46:12 We're trying to be accommodative as much as possible. We did work with AT&T to try to push them towards kind of the shot clock stop to look at alternatives. We went through the same alternatives that we had looked at internally again just to see if there's a better spot to kind of make most people happy. This could be 75 feet if you didn't provide the fake tree. I still think, you know, when we looked at it, our board...

1:46:36 Ended up putting up our ladder truck, which is 75 feet, and then we drove all over town. Previously, we'd had a board member who lives up at Snowcrest Ridgeway, where you're kind of looking over the Snowcrest down into the area, and she had concerns about the views, so I really wanted to get as close as possible to what this will actually look like in reality. A little irrelevant, but we've been working closely with Mr. Jordan, who represents the HOA, to try to do anything we can to make it

1:47:06 More appealing. I completely understand, especially since the project went in, most of the more mature trees got taken out of that area. So, you know, one of the things we'd want to do down the line is add some trees. You really have to add trees that are very mature just to deal with the snow loading, but it's something that I've expressed interest in doing and cleaning up the site as far as that chair towel and that sort of thing to, again, make it as, you know, visually aesthetically relevant as possible. So, excuse me.

1:47:40 Again, we've already seen these pictures, so I'm not going to go into this too much. Other than the fact that we did really work in trying to look at the community as a whole and, you know, minimum impacts from all the way up Old Mammoth, looked at it from all the other phases of Snow Creek and kind of above Snow Creek to see what the impact of this would be. I will be the first to, you know, admit that if it's right next to you, then yes, you are the individual that's most impacted by that tower.

1:48:11 So this is kind of the key slide for what I think is important and why we're here today. What you're looking at is mapping from a program called Zone Haven. Zone Haven is basically, and again, Zone Haven didn't exist really in large use five years ago, but it speaks to where technology is just a huge part of public safety today. So what Zone Haven does is it's a mapping program that ties in with

1:48:41 the IPAS system, and you can create evacuation zones and provide information to your public to, in an emergency, take appropriate steps. So, you know, our number one hazard is wildfire, so that's clearly the one I talked to, but just for reference, in the county, it's been used when we had communities in Crowley or June Lake where we had concerns about avalanches coming into the residential communities. That's certainly something where we've had our

1:49:09 Avalanche areas in Old Mammoth where homes are built differently. These were alerts to get sent out and provide specific information that's more than just text. It's rich information that includes mapping and that sort of thing for how to get out safely. The zones that we're most concerned about are obviously 74, 75, and 76, which is our Old Mammoth area and the lakes basin. Doesn't take...

1:49:36 me up here to explain kind of a lot of those hazards and what they are, but I think it's really important and I've been working the fire service for about 23 years, but I'm not an expert on wildland the way that some other people are. I'm more, I start on the structure side, I deal with emergency medical services, a lot of propane unfortunately, but I've been in wildland for a long period of time. That being said, we have Chief Jeff Hinson here. What Chief Jeff Hinson does is

1:50:05 He works for an incident management team. Incident management, and he's the operations chief, so he is ultimately responsible for the operations on large wildfire incidents. He's going to just touch base on why we think this area specifically needs good communications in a wildfire scenario. Again, it's not the only scenario, but from a wildfire perspective, he is as good as it gets. And he wouldn't say this, but, you know,

1:50:32 These incident management teams travel to the most complex incidents and handle them, and he is the one that's running operations. So I'm going to turn it over to him real quick, and then I can get back to my presentation. Yeah, so my name's Jeff Hinson. Just a little background on myself. I was currently or formerly the fire management officer for the Mammoth Lakes Ranging District of the INEO, and I also worked on the Mona Lakes Basin Ranging Unit of the INEO for a while.

1:51:02 Chief Tomari said I'm an operations section chief on the incident management team in California. We typically travel to larger incidents around the state or in the country, typically five to six incidents a year for the team that I'm on. I think having...

1:51:19 The technology piece that I was talking about, how it's, you know, we all know it's become more and more popular, or technology has become more important to all of us over the last five or ten years. And wildland firefighting, unbelievably, it's number one. Everything we do is based on technology and having service on the fire we're at, from the incident management team to the group, to the troops on the ground working. Number one, radio frequencies, you know, we talked about, we come in and we set up radio frequencies specifically for a fire.

1:51:48 But there's potentially 1,500 firefighters on one particular fire and everybody's on the radio. And so cell phones and being able to text and talk to each other has been, I use my phone more than my radio nowadays is I guess what I'm trying to say. And especially when I'm coming into a community that I'm not used to and I don't know all the players, like the fire chief or the police chief or the sheriff, where they're maybe not even on the same radio frequency as we are.

1:52:15 It's cell phones that are important. Going back to troops on the ground nowadays, the mapping systems that we use are all live. Forgive me, I'm not a techno specialist here, but as they're mapping things and finding hazards out on the fire ground and they're putting them on their phone or their apparatus, it's coming straight to me on my apparatus. Does that make sense? You know, it's live timing. I'm not waiting for the end of the day, 1800.

1:52:43 At the end of the day, when they're coming off shift to give me that data, I'm getting it live time right now. And so if there's a structure fire within our wild land incident, they can tell me exactly where it is and I can get a hold of the local with the structure firefighters to send them there or whatnot. It's just, it's real time. It's not open radio or over a phone. Like I'm seeing a lure on my phone right now. As far as the evacuations go, when I come in, if I'm going, if I'm coming from

1:53:11 Reading to Mammoth Lakes on the fire as an operations sector chief. I have nothing, no idea what Mammoth looks like. To be able to come in and have the local FMOs and chiefs and the county sheriff already having this evacuation zone set up and everybody in those zones knowing what zone they're in. And so when they get that call, that stuff's happening. It's not for someone like myself coming in and trying to come up with a strategy to fight fire, but also coming up with a strategy to

1:53:39 to evacuate everybody at the same time. We're counting on the local folks to already kind of have this game plan in place where they can come in and just hand me their document that shows me exactly how the evacuations are going to happen. So yeah, I think just the technology part of it as far as being able to have this evacuation system already set up and people knowing and having that communication between law enforcement and fire.

1:54:07 and other local government that needs to be involved has become a huge piece of it, whereas before it was just our team would show up, we would take over management of the fire, we wouldn't even talk to everybody, but nowadays we're talking to everybody, everybody's getting real-time information, which is helping us give better public information about the fire, whereas before we were always kind of 12 hours behind the curve as far as getting public information out, but now we can get it out real-time, right now.

1:54:37 What else? Thanks, Chief. If I could hit a little bit more, appreciate your time, and he'll be available for a little bit for questions. So, Old Mammoth specifically. So, again, we have to work with the tools that we can control, such as communications. There's things that are outside of our control and the things I'm actively working on to improve. One is access. You know, Old Mammoth is relatively limited in access.

1:55:02 Couple different access routes, but you see very quickly, you have one accident on Old Mammoth as people are trying to exit, have the same concerns about Red's Meadow, then you can bring that place to a halt. So access is already an issue that we can't control. And remember, you've got first responders going one way while the public's trying to go the other way. The second one is just lack of firefighting resources. This place looks incredibly similar to Lake Tahoe. It is vastly, vastly different from a firefighting perspective.

1:55:32 Make no mistake, we are an island in the middle of a desert from a resource perspective. You have a primarily combination volunteer department serving talent. It's a good one, but it's incredibly small and, you know, incredibly task. Currently, there are two firefighters that are on duty today. If the Mono County paramedics run a medical call,

1:55:52 They're going to step in and take the next ambulance. After that, people get paged in as volunteers. The Forest Service does have some resources here, but they often get drawn off on other incidents. So on any given day, we will be fighting with very few resources for that first operational period, which is generally 12 hours. Realistically, we might get some things here in eight, but as you're aware with a lot of these wind-driven fires, game's over by that point. So we really need to be working on those first 12 hours.

1:56:19 Same thing with law enforcement personnel. It's a little bit better from a law enforcement perspective, but the sheriffs are not on at night. The campfire from Paradise, 6.15 in the morning. There are a couple PD units that are on. The CHP is somewhere on the highway they would come in, but it would take a while to help with those evacuations.

1:56:39 My biggest concern here is a wind-driven fire. When you have a wind-driven fire, you don't have air resources that can come in, unfortunately. And then just the continuity of the fuels. Again, that's my job is to work on that piece as well. But in today's environment, Old Mammoth presents a pretty significant hazard from that perspective. And then again, the type of population that we have here that is transient just doesn't understand the escape routes. If Old Mammoth is blocked, I might know to go around and take

1:57:08 You could take Waterford Bridge if it's open and go out the other way. You're not going to have a tourist make that similar decision just because they don't have that information where really good mapping is going to be critical. So a couple of things again, why are we working on this? What are the project goals? Ultimately, improving AT&T coverage through that general area that we refer to, but it'll have some additional effects on the Snow Creek Crest as well as Lakes Basin.

1:57:38 Addition of Band 14 to Public Safety. So Band 14 is what this FirstNet project is. Again, I'm not going to get too technical with it, but ultimately it's a different wavelength that is specifically for public safety, and it's what FirstNet is built on. And what FirstNet does is I've got a computer and mobile data transmitter in my car. We have...

1:58:05 A couple things that we can do because of how the system is built. We get preemption on the tower, so ultimately what you want is Chief Henson and I to be able to communicate during an emergency to the highest level. So our calls and our data is getting pushed higher in that network than everything else. We also have...

1:58:27 something called HPUE. So, we started testing this, and again, this is where it ties back to that CRIS system that the state's putting in, where we have phones that can now talk on that very high frequency radio, and they...

1:58:41 Put out a higher wattage than your standard cell phone. So your standard cell phone is designed to give off a specific wattage. Chris might be able to answer what it is. But for public safety, they actually let us use a higher wattage to communicate back with those towers and make sure that we keep communications going at the time. And then improve data speeds. In the past, I would say that's a little irrelevant. We just have to get some messaging out to people. But the reality is most of you have tried to ski here on President's Day weekend. You understand how the system can get.

1:59:11 Bogged down really quickly. And we're not just trying to send out a text anymore. We're trying to send out mapping. We're trying to send out links with information. So data is more prevalent and relevant than it was 10 years ago. So again, for the public side, this will be tying into the iPaws and Genesis system.

1:59:33 Not going to get too detailed on these unless you guys have any questions. The Zone Haven is the mapping evacuation system that the county has chosen, but ultimately is being used across most of California at this point. This will have improved coverage and capacity for AT&T subscribers. That is not the goal of the district. Ours is to cover as much of the community as possible, which is why we want this thing built to a specification that allows for Verizon as well, and they do have interest.

2:00:00 And, you know, that's how we're asking that it be built. For us, it is improved coverage, capacity and data speed. I've already hit on the first net aspect of that as an automatic backup generator that just, those things didn't exist in the past but are required now. We do have the opportunity to place future equipment on the tower if we need. We don't have a current plan to do that, but we did write that into the contracts. We would have that ability if there was a need for that. There is a

2:00:29 License revenue fee that the district receives for this. I did go out and make sure that that is a fair rate working with an external consultant. That being said, that in no way is my priority. The district is, in my opinion, understaffed and has a tough time meeting the mission. This isn't going to change that. Ultimately, for me, this is a communication issue and making sure we can safely communicate with the public and in between first responders. Again, just a little bit on how our systems work. We receive our data from

2:01:00 CAD, which is computer-aided dispatching that comes in from the county. On my iPad, I can see where all the other apparatus are. So like Chief Henson mentioned, if there is a fire or an incident within an incident, I know where all my units are and which ones can respond to best assist in that subtask in that larger mission. We receive first net priority for first responders. We actually use this because our...

2:01:25 System is primarily combination volunteer. We depend on that to bring people in to respond on the incident. So all of our first responders, firefighters, have a system called Active 911, which takes all that dispatching information, sends it to them so that they know that there's an incident occurring and can come in and staff the engine companies. And I've already hit on the CRIS system as far as tying that in with basically push-to-talk system that is provided by FirstNet.

2:01:55 I know I covered quite a bit there. I think that, again, this kind of explains why the fire district is moving in this direction, but I know there's a lot of periphery questions, so if there's anything I didn't cover in my presentation, please ask me. I'm going to lean on the experts. I don't claim to be an expert in everything.

2:02:16 As far as RF, you know, we work closely with them, but I will trust the engineers on those, and we did work to make sure that we are keeping our firefighters safe. We use station quite a bit, especially the training tie rock back, to make sure that the emissions are above, because, again, I do want to keep my firefighters safe. Like I said, you know, we've been working on this for about 15 years. It's gone a while before it got to your commission, but that just speaks to kind of the...

2:02:43 The size of this endeavor and why it takes so long. Any questions? Any questions at this time from the commission for either Chief Tomer or Chief Henson? Please, Greg. So you said it's not a significant amount of income, it's not your priority, but I'm sure it matters. It absolutely matters. What is the cost of the, what is the revenue from the lease and how much, if any, will it go up if there is a second use on the tower?

2:03:13 Good question, sir. So it's and

2:03:17 Don't quote me on this, but it's about $45,000 to $48,000 a year is what we would receive from AT&T. There is no contract with Verizon. We have spoken with them, but generally working with the, and again, it's not that I don't trust but verify, we're working with an external consultant that deals with cell towers on a regular basis. You generally see about 30% come in from that second provider, so we'd be looking at about another $15,000.

2:03:47 So we're looking at somewhere between 50 and potentially $70,000 a year. Just to put some perspective on that, we recently ordered a water tender, which is a very small engine. It's a $400,000 piece of equipment. A ladder truck costs about $1.5 million today. Firefighters are extremely expensive, which is why we depend on our volunteers and part-time staff. So, you know, this will absolutely...

2:04:13 be a piece that we will utilize for public safety and will help. That being said, it's not going to make a huge difference on our budget from a larger perspective. It's about 1% of our annual operating budget. And what do you see, I'm sure you've looked at the maps a lot more in depth than I have, what do you see as increased coverage in the Lakes Basin as a result of this tower versus without this tower?

2:04:40 And where, if any, difference would it be if this was a single-use 60- or 70-foot tower versus a dual-use 80-foot tower? Sure. So, great question. And again, the reason we went with, I wouldn't be excited about it because ultimately any time we add multiple towers, you're taking away operational space for working. If you were to put two towers, you would essentially achieve the same result if you had them at the same height.

2:05:09 Ultimately, that's not my understanding of the planning intent and the intent of the town is as much as possible, put these all on one tower, you know, so that you have the minimal impact from having multiple towers there. My understanding is that on the school district side, they have to place a second tower and it's not ideally how the town would like to move forward. So our goal was to put two providers on one tower to

2:05:36 Work within the intent of the code as we understand it and ultimately have the same impact as two towers at 70. And again, that's where some of the numbers can get a little confusing. I don't remember specifically, but I believe you that 45 was the original height. You know, that was most likely a standalone tower without the fake tree. So this one being essentially 75 feet with fake five feet above it gets you

2:06:04 That first provider, their antenna from where the engineer is looking at it is kind of in the middle of the antenna, so at 70 feet, and you have to go down, there's a spacing that's required between the two providers, and you hit the provider below that. So to answer your question for the lake spacing, the lake spacing, and I will certainly defer to any professional expert testimony that the RF engineer will have.

2:06:30 It's not as significant as Old Mammoth. We have a responsibility for both, ideally. It's kind of a long, complicated discussion. I don't know if you want to get into. I learned a lot about how these things work, and it's not my natural intuition on how I would have thought they work. With the fire service, we actually try to put these things as high as possible to hit as large of an area, but deals with the type of wavelength that we're using and the rights that we have.

2:07:00 to do that. Really the honeycomb pattern that Sarnell explained is probably the best analogy for how cell towers have to work and they really have to be at a specific elevation to be hitting kind of longitudinally across that community and then they have a certain hit wave like they hit. So you know that kind of brings up you know they mentioned it but they didn't really explain in layman's terms if you put something at

2:07:25 The Snow Creek Athletic Club, you'd still, because it's a lower site, you would have to get up to the same wavelengths, you would potentially end up with a taller tower to hit that same horizontal plateau, if that makes sense.

2:07:38 Ultimately, again, I'll defer to Chris, the RF engineer, but I believe the vast majority of the improvement would be in Old Mammoth, but there would be some residual improvement in the lake space as well, more probably for just getting that single text out than providing any kind of data information. If you've ever noticed on your cell phone, you know, you'll have times when you will not be able to get any kind of mapping or anything, but you'll still get a text through. I think you'll see that as you get more peripheral, but you won't have kind of that data

2:08:07 Heavy component that you'll see more in the old Mammoth area. Does that answer your question? Well enough, thank you. Thank you. Any other questions for either fire chief? Please. Chief, just one question about the communication side between carriers using, I guess AT&T is using first respond, first net to improve your first responder centric to 5G system.

2:08:36 But at the same time earlier you said, because AT&T and Verizon and T-Mobile, they don't communicate with one another. So when you push out the message, you only reach a portion of the population. So great, let me answer it. Yeah, so a couple things. FirstNet is essentially a, and I'll get corrected by AT&T, kind of a sub-company of AT&T. So if you have,

2:09:08 FirstNet, it will work on the AT&T spectrum, but you also have this additional spectrum for first responders, and other people have access to it. I talked to one of the ER doctors, they're considered first responders, so there's a larger network that that works, but ultimately, if you look at it kind of from like a Venn diagram, AT&T is the big one, and FirstNet fits inside of it. Verizon is completely separate, totally different Venn diagram.

2:09:32 What iPause lets us do is hit all of those providers to send out messaging. What it doesn't let you do is say, hey, AT&T somehow hit all the cell phones in this site. You know, there is no mechanism to do that. The carrier still only can work through their customers. And that's why ultimately it's so important for us to have both Verizon and AT&T.

2:09:56 at the table, because ultimately, if we just deal with AT&T, it will fix the public safety side. We will have our communications, but if we're trying to help the public out, you really need to have both providers in order to reach the public. Now, for clarification, you showed the zone map, the evacuation zone map. I noticed the coverage based on this SONA provided earlier. It looks like it's covering 70,

2:10:26 70, 71, 72, 74, 75, a portion of 75, but not 76. I would agree with that, but I would actually, so let me just go to full screen mode here. So, a couple things on how, and again, I'm not an expert, you can tie in with Chris and he can correct me, but there,

2:10:48 Radio waves travel through stuff, right? So, and it actually referred to it on their mapping. What they talked about, I think it was three things. There was, you know, in-building coverage, vehicle coverage, and then general outside coverage. So, what this site does is really kind of looking at zones 74 and 75 provide better coverage, but recognizing there is a difference between somebody standing in their street and somebody inside their...

2:11:16 Log cabin as far as that signal being able to come in. So we really want in-building coverage for those areas. Again, the lakes basin, I'm in no way claiming is going to benefit from this the way that 74 and 75 are, but you do have more people in tents and people out hiking to where they will see some improvement in their services as well. But ultimately, I'm not going to say the golden stand, but what we're trying to achieve is being able to hit people inside their homes if they're sleeping, you know, and have that go off as opposed to

2:11:45 If you ever play the game, we're having to go outside, and you can do that. You can go out, and your phone will work, but we're trying to get a quality enough signal that can carry into people's homes. Thank you, Chief. Any questions for either fire chief from either of you commissioners? No? I have a really quick clarification question for you, Alish. You mentioned a little bit earlier that there is the possibility down the road of you guys installing your equipment on this monopine, but...

2:12:14 Would that be below the secondary provider equipment? So, yep. And so basically, you know, we try to do everything that we could to protect our rights as a district. Ultimately, when you sign all these leases, you are held to the standard agreement that you have signed. So again, we had our own attorneys work on that.

2:12:36 The most likely site for it would be below, but it is a different type of frequency. It's called VHF, essentially, and has a different type of wavelength. VHF gets used in areas, if you went down to Los Angeles, you'd mostly see fire services using what's called 800 megahertz. It's a different kind of wavelength. It works really well, but it doesn't work as well in topography such as ours. So what VHF allows you to do is it's a different wavelength, and it can get through topography.

2:13:03 Better in some ways. The problem with VHF, and this is where this ties in, you know, systems are improving so much, the VHF can carry very limited data, so it's essentially carrying voice, and I can talk to Chief Henson on our radios. What it can't do well is anything that's...

2:13:20 More data, so pictures, there's new systems that are being built that basically can tell you where every one of your firefighters is in your building, but that doesn't work on VHF because it doesn't have the capacity to, you know, so all of these different wavelengths have different pluses and negatives. The beauty of VHF is it will work through the mountains, it can sit a lot lower on the tower, it'll still get our radio communication out. I won't be able to send a picture of the map to Chief Henson on it, so, and that's what FirstNet does allow me to do.

2:13:48 So just for 100% disclosure, there is no thought or plan of installing your equipment north of the AT&T on the tower. 100% no plan to install it north of the equipment. And again, I have, the district has no plans to install anything today, but we did give ourselves the ability to do that at a point in the future. The current CRIS system,

2:14:15 Repeaters are extremely expensive. They're about half a million dollars on the low side to put in a repeater for these Motorola cores. So we did a site analysis that looked at a significant number of sites and wanting to have coverage into buildings and this larger area coverage. What we found would work best for our systems is our existing tower at Station 1 and Lincoln Mountain providing kind of that wider area coverage. But again, now we're speaking on VHF systems that are completely different from cell tower systems.

2:14:45 What worked for that is totally different from what works for a cell provider, if that makes sense. Got it. Any other questions for either chief? Nolan, is that their final presentation? That is, yes. All right. Then right now I'd like to open it up to public comment. And I appreciate if everyone who gave a presentation remains available, whether that's our legal consultants, our applicant consultant.

2:15:13 The fire department as well as town staff. What I am going to request is public comment is not going to be Q&A. Any questions you may have for anyone who gave a presentation today, the appropriate party will note down your question and then at the end of public comment, once we've closed it, we will listen to the answers from the appropriate expert in that matter. I'm also going to request that public comment for each person who's

2:15:43 Addressing us individually will be three minutes and that'll be monitored by Jamie. I do believe there was a gentleman in the back. When you do come up and give public comment, if you wouldn't mind letting us know how many parties you're representing and we will extend your time appropriately. So with that, public comment is open. Thank you. Chuck Landy with Snow Creek. Maybe the best thing for me to do is just address a little bit of history.

2:16:15 Because we do, we did do own the majority of that resort zone corridor. We were approached over 10 years ago when this was first brought up, or at least first of our knowledge. And we were part of the process with the fire department and their board. And in fact, did not think a tower was appropriate here. We worked with them. They, I think unanimously, declined to proceed with it.

2:16:43 About five or six years ago, I was called by possibly UConn or AT&T saying, hey, we want to revisit this. Can we talk to you? I said, no, it wasn't appropriate then. It isn't appropriate now. Unfortunately, it started up again. And, Elish, I feel sorry for you with all the work you've put in, but whether it started six months ago or two years ago, a process went on. There was no notice sent out.

2:17:11 Or we did not receive a notice, let's put it that way. The first we heard of this pursuit was just before the November 8th hearing, we did get a notice. And I called Nolan and said, geez, what's going on here? This is supposed to be a public process. Why didn't we get this? And in fact, the notices were sent out. They were sent to the wrong address, an 18-month-old address. Interestingly, though, most of the homeowners didn't get a notice either.

2:17:39 So that was the reason we asked for the postponement of the November 8 hearing so that we could work with the town and with AT&T. The town, of course, doesn't want to be drug through the mud, so to speak. They're processing paper. I understand that. We did reach out to AT&T, let's say AT&T, UConn, and ALISH after that continuance of the November 8th and said, hey, can we have 90 days to get up to speed and work with you?

2:18:08 60 was granted. Unfortunately, 30 of the 60 or more was Christmas and New Year's. But nonetheless, we did last week come up with two alternative sites and letters from those property owners, actually three, that could move forward. We asked to speak with AT&T on Monday. David Jordan, who you'll meet in a minute, and I were able to meet or talk to AT&T. They had a nice discussion, said thank you. We'll get back to you. They didn't. It's okay. We're here today.

2:18:38 So that's a little bit of the background, unfortunately. It would have been nice if we could have been engaged like we were 10 years ago in this process. Life safety is critical, no question, but it would be nice to work together to come up with a solution. After the November 8th hearing, I went out, got in the car, started driving around saying, okay, how do we solve this? How do we help the chief, but yet do the right thing for the community? Because to me, 80, 85 foot

2:19:08 Tree is an eyesore, right? This is a pristine area that we've all loved. I did go to Aspen Village, and I looked around, and of course a comment has been made, oh, you're going to take it from the rich and give it to the poor, which I kind of took offensively, to tell you the truth. I looked around, their landscaping was in bad shape, fences were falling down. I said, wow, is this a group, this is workforce housing.

2:19:36 with a low HOA and maybe, you know, four to seven thousand a month can help them boost their maintenance costs and upgrade the facility. It's tight in there. I went to the water district, said, hey, you've got two acres, so somehow between you and the HOA, if they're amenable, we could work together and come up with a solution. And unofficially, because it didn't go to the board, they said, yeah, let's work together and see if we can do that. We've got some complexities.

2:20:05 You know, we did have two point, I think it was 2.3 acres originally. They gave up part of that for Aspen Village to be created. But if Aspen Village wanted to work with them, we could work together and figure something out. The Aspen Village HOA president kind of caught him off guard to tell you the truth, but he said we'd be willing to talk. And I think there's some correspondence which staff has that says that. The athletic club was another logical spot, not where it was proposed.

2:20:35 On the map, but I thought in the northeast corner because you've got a big grove of pines in there. So we went to the athletic club, said, hey, have they talked to you? No, nobody's talked to me in five or six years. So the same time I was contacted last, they were. Would you be open to having a discussion and putting it in that northwest corner? Sure. You know, money's money. If it doesn't interrupt our operation, we'd be glad to have that conversation. I, quite frankly, also went to the church.

2:21:05 It was a potential site. I understand it's not zoned. They too had not been talked to in five or six years. They certainly wanted the income. Yes, it would have to go through a rezone, but it's part of the process. So, you know, a lot has gone in here. I guess what I resent on behalf of ourselves as a landowner and the homeowners is this wasn't an engaged process like it should be.

2:21:30 I understand the shot clock. I understand the law. I understand they can ramrod it through. This is the easiest site to do so, but it's not fair, right? This isn't how the process is supposed to work. We'd be glad to continue to work and help solve this. Alish, I understand life safety is always an issue. There has to be a solution here somewhere, but sticking it in front of people's front door is horrendous, and I guess...

2:21:59 As somebody that's enjoyed this basin for the last 60 plus years, it's just weird to me to go put, it's like putting, you know, when they said, you know, you can put something, I forget the exact language, but per that class three, can I build a high rise if it doesn't do this and doesn't do, I mean, that's dumb, right? Why are you going to put this big pole, big pine, fake pine, and we've all seen a million of them, 80 feet in the air, 85 feet in the air, it's ridiculous. Anyway.

2:22:28 Be glad to help if I can. Thank you, Mr. Landy. Dear commissioners, thank you for the opportunity to speak. I've got an 1130, so I'll be real quick. Whenever an issue comes up in the community of Mammoth Lakes, how many times are the issues pitted against the personal wishes of a few individuals versus moving forward with something that benefits the greater community? The answer is often.

2:23:04 Such as the new recreation facility, affordable housing, bus routes, and now a cell tower. As one of the original town council members, Greg Newbury, once said, it is the responsibility of the local governing body, yourselves, to make their decision based upon what is the best decision for the greatest number of people.

2:23:31 There will almost always be a segment of the community that is against some particular issue, and oftentimes they become very vocal, but in the end the decision should be based upon what is best for the most amount of people, and such is the case today. But the main reason that this body should pass this proposal today is that it is a public safety issue.

2:24:00 Adequate cell service is a key ingredient to our ability to perform timely public service calls. We have all experienced the poor cell service, the numerous drop calls when the population soars during heavy use weekends. And if I can't get my 911 call through because of inadequate cell service, then we have a problem. We have accidents in Mammoth Lakes.

2:24:34 Last winter, we had fires. Snow Creek Phase 5 had a duplex fire. Just last winter, we had two explosions in town, one at Betsy and Hank Thuman's house up at Juniper Ridge and one at Valdezir's manager's condo unit. Without the ability to have dependable cell service, we have problems. The most important thing that a local government provides is service.

2:25:09 That service, whether it's emergency services or law enforcement, exists to make our lives safe and better. What is not the responsibility of local government is to protect someone's view from their property. Protecting someone's view is not a health and safety issue. Mammoth Lakes has governing bodies in our municipality

2:25:40 Public Safety is the number one, not the number three, not the number five, not the number 10, but the number one responsibility of the municipality. So above all else, this decision today should be based upon public safety. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Eastman. Hi, good morning. Thank you. I'll be brief as well. My name is John Mendel. I've been resident in Mammoth since 1999 and full-time.

2:26:15 24-7 since 2013, and I'm representing the fire district today as chairman of the board of commissioners. As Chief Tomiter mentioned, first responders, police, fire, EMS need fast, efficient, and reliable communications to provide their services. Back in 2003, when the National Center for Health Statistics started collecting data on cell phones versus landlines, because I've heard

2:26:44 A number of things said, well, we can just call people on landlines, you know, to get the message out. Nearly 95% of adults in 2003 had a landline. At the end of 2022, fewer than 27% had it. In 2007, when the iPhone debuted, about one in seven adults had a cellular service. By the end of 2022, adults ditching their landlines and using cell phones had risen to nearly eight in ten.

2:27:16 Nearly 9 in 10 adults age 25 to 34, many of our visitors, have cell phone service alone. No landline, no nothing else. Clearly cellular technology has supplanted and reduced traditional landlines as the primary medium for communications. Our household reflects that trend and I imagine many of yours do as well. So why is this? A couple reasons. First, cost.

2:27:46 Landline, basic landline from AT&T today for standard long-distance service can cost about $90 a month. Landline costs have risen. The Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics shows a 31% increase from May 2011 to May 2021. Mobile service costs have actually gone down in the same 10-year period by 20%. Reliability. Landlines have lost their vaunted reliability. Phone companies don't want to support them as they switch to fiber optic.

2:28:17 Cables and have been accused of discouraging landlines according to customer complaints right here in California. Getting a landline repaired can take several months. And third, technology. Most importantly, 911 support for cell phones has improved vastly because of advancements in iPhones, GPS technology, carrier services, which we're talking about today, and dispatching equipment. Emergency services can now easily pinpoint

2:28:46 Wireless calls to within 150 feet of where the caller is. Phone companies have been trying to write their own obituaries for their own landline services for years. One example is if you try to sign up for a voice line at a typical operator, and I'll use Consolidated Communications, which does business in 20 states, you'll automatically be routed to a page offering either voiceover or internet protocol or cellular service.

2:29:13 Approval of this cell tower should not be an economic or even aesthetic consideration. It's a matter of public safety and providing much-needed coverage to the community. There's no way to put a cost on a human life. I know that when I pick up the phone for an emergency, I want it to work, and I'm sure you do as well. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mando. Good morning, commissioners and chairman, staff. David Jordan, I'm a resident and homeowner.

2:29:50 In Creek House and I am speaking on behalf of the entire Creek House homeowners group. That's about 100 people. I don't need that much time. Nine or 10 minutes should be more than sufficient. And we're more than happy to extend 10 minutes. Thank you. And an effort for us to be respectful and efficient in your time. Hopefully that means that the rest of us do not need to be speaking.

2:30:13 Handed you a very late, and I apologize for that, we'll discuss a very comprehensive and I think compelling package as to our concerns with the cell tower as proposed currently. I apologize for the late arrival of that. We've been working diligently to try and put together this comprehensive package. It really is a matter of time. It was not...

2:30:35 I've heard NIMBY a lot.

2:31:04 I'm a real estate developer. I've been at it for the better part of 30 years. Right now it would be disingenuous for me to sit up here as a developer and speaking on behalf of the community that we're NIMBYs. We're not NIMBYs. I would hope that our package that we've provided you today shows that we're trying to help you and come up with a solution. We don't want to be opposition. We'd like to be a supporting and a constructive part of this process. We're opposition right now because of what is proposed and how it's being proposed.

2:31:34 Fire life, health safety concerns are at the forefront for all of us too. I mean, whether we like it or not, we all live by this right now. Rather we didn't, but we do. And the health and safety concerns are paramount for us as well. And they're very legitimate. We want, the Creek House community wants good cell phone coverage and we need good cell coverage.

2:32:02 It's how we go about that and to get adequate coverage that is really, I think, in question today. I will also just touch on some of the things that I've saw in the materials really gets my blood pressure up as a developer. I found them very disingenuous. Some of the packages, and I won't get into all the details, but it's what makes my life so difficult when I'm standing in front of commissions.

2:32:24 I have done this many times. I've always had unanimous approval on my projects. It's because I do a consensus-driven process, which is the exact opposite of what we're doing today. So why do we oppose the cell tower and why are we requesting today that you deny this project? The Telecommunications Act is very clear that this should be a zoning and land use issue at the locality. And that's what this is and how it should be determined.

2:32:51 And there are many compelling reasons for you to deny the project today. The general plan, the Snow Creek Master Plan, as well as the cell tower codes, I know that staff has said that it has been matched or the findings are there. We vigorously disagree with this. When you look at the actual language and the intent behind the general code, it is very clear about the aesthetic needs and the protection as all of us as stewards of this beautiful area.

2:33:21 And the specific codes on the cell tower also discuss hiding it, mitigating it, putting it behind certain areas. We do have a board here that I think are examples. One is where an actual cell tower is behind the Napa Valley Auto Parts, currently on Main Street. We also went ahead and did a photo simulation for you of the tower, the Monopine, if it was put behind the Snow Creek Athletic Club.

2:33:50 Again, to show that these are much more appropriate within the code as written and following the letter of the law. What we have right now at the fire station does not meet these requirements, and that alone would give you the power to deny this project. There's been some discussion with CEQA, all too familiar with CEQA, but in our legal memo as we've presented to you,

2:34:21 You do have the ability, just under general zoning, not getting into CEQA and whether it's an MND or what is the level or status, to deny a project if there are adverse, unnecessary impacts to aesthetics. The letters that are in the package that we've provided you from the Creek House are provided, put in place and provided to you because there is case law that shows and states that the people that are most directly impacted should be the ones that are

2:34:50 The most directly affected should be the ones that you should be looking at as to these aesthetic impacts. Again, I've put these boards up because what UConn AT&T has provided in these photo sims, they're always hiding them behind trees or they're looking at them from down behind at this level. But what really should be looked at is what is the direct impact on so many of the homes in our neighborhood.

2:35:15 And that's what we've tried to do with our photo sims and also to compare those to the fire engine ladder that has been placed there, thankfully. Thank you, Elesh. So that we do believe we're at scale and it does show the impact. Could we do more? Could we really show what these look like from kitchens, bedrooms, bathrooms, people living in their living rooms? We could do that. We were just trying to be concise and give you a flavor.

2:35:40 One of the items within the code and also addresses this is this idea that this is in the back. This is not in the back. It's in the front of the Creek House. There are so many units around this and people are looking directly at this. These are not private roads. It's not a gated community. These are public right-of-ways. People can walk through these areas. They can use the meadow that is provided along a large portion of these areas. So I think in the spirit of the law to say that this isn't back is just incorrect.

2:36:08 It's in the front for too many people. That alone, unnecessary adverse aesthetics impacts is enough for you to be able to deny a project. That doesn't have to get into CEQA. That can just be across the general zoning codes that we already have in place in the beautiful town. There is some confusion, I think, as to whether value impacts can be addressed.

2:36:35 We all deal with the price of homes and affordable housing. We have the affordable housing behind here. But the fact is that there is a severe value impact already underway inside Creek House. We have provided you letters from multiple real estate agents with specific examples of people who have dropped out of escrow or are no longer looking. Broad brush, there is a few units that might become literally valueless.

2:37:02 But the overall impact, and just a broad brush, could be anywhere from 10 to 30% on the values in these properties. When you look at where these properties have traded, that quickly runs into tens of millions of dollars. That's bad for the town of Mammoth Lakes, obviously bad for the creek house. It's a significant amount of money, and it needs to be taken into account, and it can also be a reason to reject or deny the proposed cell tower as it is currently proposed.

2:37:30 And then finally, just touching on, as Chuck already mentioned, so I don't want to reiterate, we have found some legitimate alternatives that have not been explored. And to say that they're NIMBYs, or to put up on the TV an idea that they didn't even show our units there. It was all dirt on the one screen that you were looking at. And to say that, oh, we're just trying to put it next to homes. It's already at homes here. We're looking.

2:37:58 to give legitimate alternatives. And this should be explored before any decision is made on this. And that does touch on also this need and the mapping. The mapping is a computer projection. Yes, that's just the base level I think that is required. But the town can ask and should ask, what is the actual situation? What are the problems in this area? And get the detailed data.

2:38:26 AT&T has that. We were told it's proprietary information, but they have that to understand what is the best alternative, what is the best location, all their other ideas that could work to satisfy all the legitimate health and safety needs and the needs for all of us to be able to have adequate cell phone coverage. Those maps are

2:38:47 are easily manipulated. I'm sure experts can say they're great. Others can say that they're not. But the actual data is difficult to manipulate. And we should have that prior to making any decisions. And we have not had that today. So in conclusion, in summary, we're opposing this project as it is currently.

2:39:07 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:39:34 Protecting the health and life safety of everybody in the community. So thank you. And I'm available for any questions. Thank you. And thank you for representing so many voices. Appreciate it. Thank you. I would like to address a document that I think is very helpful. It's part of your staff's package. And that is Planning Division Conditions Exhibit A as part of your package. And there's I have 20 years of a

2:40:08 experience as a business analyst and I denunciated contracts and wrote numerous statements of works and I think it might be helpful to you in this case in comforting to me as a homeowner less than 300 feet away from this thing the direct view of this proposed to consider improving this document and this may impact future cellular things that you are faced with in the future and some specific situations with this particular

2:40:37 statement of work that I believe need to be improved. So with your permission, I'll propose a couple of things. The first one is related to section six, which we heard some comments from the board about maintenance and maintenance responsibilities and troubled by the thought of another vendor coming into AT&T's tower.

2:41:03 And where AT&T has said that they're going to be responsible for maintenance of all this camouflage. That's their term. And my wife and I drove through, where were we getting? What was the town? Lancaster. They have a cellular forest of these monopines. And it is the most, I have photos of it, it's the most hideous looking maintenance mesh you could ever imagine.

2:41:31 And the design, I don't know how good the original thing was, but I'm troubled with the word good in section six. It says, be maintained a condition of good repair and appearance. One of their criteria that they mentioned verbatim was least visual intrusive. Views being a separate issue, the visual camouflage on this tree is very important.

2:42:00 And these things deteriorate very rapidly and they become hideous looking. I mean, they're really awful. You would not want one of these next, lived next to one of these things. So I would recommend that your staff review that clause and say, and put two criteria in. One is an annual inspection. The other is that they would bring, that the criteria would be that they would bring the monopine back to

2:42:30 The original appearance as the day it was new. Because these things deteriorate, the plastic falls off, becomes another matter. So that's just my suggestion. Second issue is lighting. I used to live at another homeowner's and I was on the board there and lighting was a big thing when we remodeled. So the terms that the town typically uses for these projects is there, that's great.

2:42:59 But here's the challenge. When you have an 80-foot tall tree, or model pine, there's no requirement for the FAA under 400 feet, right? So we're well under any governmental things as far as lighting. There should be no need for lighting on that tree other than for emergency purposes. So my objection is that you would add that the operators cannot have the lighting operated on the tree, which is a...

2:43:29 The last one is probably the one that's been knocked around the most today and discussed the most and that's the thought of another

2:43:56 The need, the town requirement, as the applicant has said, the town requirement to have a second provider on the tower. And that's, I want to point out some inconsistencies. Okay, the fire department said the same thing. Maybe it was their idea. But this is a really bad idea. So, okay, when you look at their design document, which is A6,

2:44:21 And they talked about a 65, I don't know where that number came from. It conflicts with this document. AT&T wants the height between 53 feet and 74 feet for their antennas. That includes their, they call it a, I don't know if I can read this without my glasses. I've got the wrong glasses here. It's a microwave antenna at the bottom, right?

2:44:49 So it gets them down to, the microwave antenna is about, you know, four feet around, so knock another two feet off, and they want, everything from 43 feet, which would be where the bottom of their antenna array is needed. They claim that to meet their objectives, they need to be that high, but they also need to be that low. And so both of those things are criteria.

2:45:18 When you subtract the 10 feet of clearance that they want for, you know, other people's antennas, that only allows Verizon 8 feet between 43 feet and 35 feet. They're only going to have 8 feet. Well, AT&T needs 19 feet. So when they set AT&T's expert...

2:45:44 said that, well, we need to be at that 60 or 70 feet thing. Well, when Verizon comes in, they're not going to have enough room. Would AT&T trade places with Verizon if the town wanted to conduct a coin flip? I doubt it. So I'm wondering why we even need a town requirement for an 85-foot tower to have another provider on there when

2:46:13 They have testified late this morning that they need all this height, even, notwithstanding that this is all new technology, which is a little bit illogical, but they say because of the new technology, they need to be higher. So how can Verizon operate at a lower height when, why would we impose a requirement on Verizon to be on that tower at a lower height when it's just creating more problems for us, creating more emissions for us?

2:46:41 It's giving the fire department, they testified this morning that they may want to reserve some space down below. I would ask the town to remove the requirement in... Sir, I might ask you to summarize just out of respect for other people that may want to submit public comment. That's my last piece. My last piece was the requirement that talks about having a second provider, a town requirement.

2:47:10 It's not required by federal law. It's not required by state law. It's a local requirement. It's within your discretion to remove that need for a second provider on that tower because it becomes technically infeasible based on the applicant's drawings. And I submit that it would be to the benefit of me, you know, 300 feet away from this thing, not to have more emission coming at me, whether or not that's a criteria you can use or not.

2:47:39 But simply, basically, it doesn't work in the design as well. So I'm requesting that you remove that requirement and not allow Horizon to come on the site. Because it's not going to, if their technology is the same, and it is, all this LTE and all this generation stuff, their requirements are going to be the same as AT&T's. They're using the same type of technology. My brother was in the business for 30 years. And the last piece is, so I would say, please remove that as a consideration.

2:48:09 If you prove this, if somehow this thing gets approved, or if any other future ones do, consider the impact, and this is their drawing, and their technology. The last piece is in the future. So technology changes, and the technology dependencies are going to continue to change. 6G is all coming from space, right? So one of their criterias to meet their thing was the lack of least amount of visual appearance.

2:48:36 Would you consider adding another item here that says in the future if technology doesn't require cellular towers and they become obsolete to have the petitioner or the applicant remove the technology if it's no longer technologically required to provide the service and the safety that we need? Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. And I'm sure the appropriate parties took down some notes for questions to be answered.

2:49:05 Upon the conclusion of public comment, any other public comment from Suite Z at this time? Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? If we could remind the people that are communicating with us via Zoom that we are capping individual public comment at three minutes. Eric, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Boulder Creek, Eric? Can anybody address the, besides the visual impact I'm going to experience?

2:49:56 The audible impact and how that fits with the town's noise ordinance. Again, Eric, this is not going to be a Q&A. Your question will be noted and addressed upon the conclusion of public comment. Thank you. Is that the entirety of your public comment? That is it for now. Thank you. Appreciate it. Todd, please unmute yourself and give your comments. This is Todd Tenning. I just wanted to say I would yield my time back to David Jordan. I don't know if he was done. I don't have any further comments if he's done then.

2:50:31 We can move on. One thing I would add, per the telecommunications lot, this tower can be raised by another 20 feet with no input at all. So it can easily get up to 100 feet. And as a developer, to say that that has to be designed initially, that's just untrue. I do structural upgrades across commercial office buildings all the time. You add extra rebar, you add extra structure, you can do that at a later date. It does not have to be designed on the first day. Thanks. Sorry.

2:51:05 Yep. Any other public comment via Zoom? No. Last chance, anyone else, sweet Z, please. Mr. Newberry. Greg Newberry, a neighbor, I'm within a distance, a homeowner. I wholly endorse this, I think it's needed. And the irony of Landy to talk, this wall of buildings and the greatness of trees, I'd rather his buildings weren't there. And we better have trees. But we live in a resort. The buildings are there, they should be there.

2:51:39 We're expanding technology. It's changed dramatically. We can't put cell towers underground. They have to be what they are. I agree with the use permit recommendation that there should be something in there that should become unfeasible. It should be returned back to its natural state and reduced and removed altogether. That may be in the use permit anyway. But as a resort, we need this technology. And I thought the presentation was really good in regards to why it's 80 feet.

2:52:08 Where it is, and to put it down on the Snow Creek property, you have to be at about 130 feet. And to put it near the church, again, 120 feet. And to make it, you know, 60 feet so it's only one carrier, that's kind of ridiculous in regards to where we're going as a technology and needing to have various carriers in the area. I highly endorse it. I do believe that...

2:52:32 I hate the term NIMBY because it's derogatory, but I think anybody who has something next to them, they deserve to have the loudest voice. They deserve to be heard the most, unquestionably. But the silent voice, the biggest voice that you don't hear is the public good. And that overrides the neighbors who simply don't like it in their backyard. And I understand that. I probably wouldn't like it right outside my window either. But if it were outside my window...

2:52:58 I wouldn't oppose it, but I wouldn't endorse it either. I think it's needed. I think it's important. And pursuant to the law, the view is from the public standpoint, not from the view of the individual owners. That's the law. So anyway, thank you very much. And last is, I really appreciate all of you and the generous time you spend volunteering to help our community be a better community. Thank you for your services. Thank you. Appreciate it. Anyone else in Sweet Z like to give public comment? Any last-minute Zoom?

2:53:29 Participants. Then I will close public comment. And at this time, any questions that were raised in public comment, would the appropriate expert care to address those questions? Yes, I would ask that Bennett Givens, if he could respond to the comments on the alternative site analysis, just reiterating the criteria used for that, as well as potential impacts on property values as it relates to the telecom law and what we're tasked with.

2:54:01 reviewing here. Yes, certainly. Thanks, Nolan. So, in regards to the alternative site analysis, the public comment overstates what is required under the town code, and so you're really focused on what does the code actually require.

2:54:22 The alternate site analysis requires the applicant to provide some analysis detailing the specific steps undertaken to determine the applicant's selection of a particular site consistent with the preference sheet for site selection. The applicant is not required to pursue a rundown of every alternative that comes forward. This application requirement only requires that a

2:54:51 I also want to address a few other comments that were made in regard to noise regulations and also maybe Nolan will want to add as well.

2:55:12 But any noise emitted by the facility would have to comply with any existing town requirements or noise ordinances. There was a comment about future modifications to the tower. So during my presentation, I discussed eligible facilities requests. These are certain qualifying modifications to an existing wireless facility.

2:55:38 that the town has no discretion and must approve if they do qualify. Under that process, there is a potential that the tower itself can go up an additional 20 feet, which is the height criteria and limitation under the eligible facilities process. So that is something that could occur in the future.

2:56:03 We've heard testimony today from the applicant that they believe the most likely co-location location for an additional tenant onto this tower would be underneath the AT&T array. Again, we don't have the competitors or other wireless entities here to confirm that. In addition, I'd also like to address some of the concerns raised

2:56:30 And kind of reiterate some points that I made earlier about property values and the effect of RF emissions. As you know, the applicant has demonstrated that this facility would comply with the FCC's regulation for RF emissions. So concerns over the direct or indirect health effects of RF emissions may not serve as substantial evidence to support a denial of this application.

2:57:00 In addition, where there are claims that a proposed facility will not result in diminished property values that are rooted in a concern about the perceived health effects of RF emissions cannot constitute substantial evidence supporting a denial. Those are the main areas that I wanted to confirm. And one last point, this was raised in the fire district presentation.

2:57:28 But there's a note that there will be backup power at this site. That is a requirement from the California Public Utilities Commission. They require all macro sites, this would be a macro site, located within tier two or three high fire threat zones, maintain at least 72 hours of mandatory backup power.

2:57:50 This property is located in a tier two zone and so that requirement is from the CPUC and they would need to maintain backup power. Thank you, Bennett. Nolan, was there any other questions that you wanted to farm out to one of our experts? No, that was currently the issues raised or the comments made. We are drafting a few conditions in response to, I apologize, I did not get your name.

2:58:23 The last speaker. The gentleman in the front that had the diagram. Staff just wants to get your name so that we can put it in there. John Heidelman. John Heidelman. All right, great. You'll see if I contact you. So I am drafting a few conditions in response to Mr. Heidelman's comments there. Thank you. All right, then I'll throw it back on the commission for conversation, opinions, thoughts. Why don't we start to the far left here. Commissioner Kennedy. Wow, thanks, Michael.

2:58:56 Can I ask a couple questions? Absolutely. This is, yeah. Perfect. Just to confirm, I think these are Nolan questions, maybe, or Michael. The shot clock that we're up against has been extended to April, but from my understanding, if we did not approve this and miss that deadline, it would happen anyways. Is that correct? Or could happen anyways? Could be approved.

2:59:23 AT&T did extend the tolling agreement to April 19th. However, that shot clock does include all relevant appeal periods and any other actions by the town that are permitted within it. So if we did not approve or continued it and then there was an appeal and then that shot clock ended, we would still be up against that. Because it's the fire district site, the automatic deemed approved remedy is not an available option.

2:59:52 However, the applicant can still then approach the court for court order to if the shot clock was ended. So the shot clock is still in effect, but the deemed remedy approval does not apply in this case. Perfect. Thank you. Maybe these were in what you were talking about, but there were the two questions about is the town requiring a second provider on the tower? And then, well, I guess I'll let you answer that one first, then I'll say the second one.

3:00:21 So the town does not require a second provider. We can't go out there and make a second provider co-locate on the structure. However, the code, as far as criteria, does encourage co-location because that reduces the need for a separate tower. Additionally, with the telecom law, we cannot discriminate against other carriers.

3:00:46 So if we were to, say, approve a lower tower and then Verizon submitted an application because they want to provide coverage in this area, they could, one, increase that of the tower or we would have to consider a second tower on any available site in the area to allow them into the area. Awesome. Thank you. And then I guess my other question is, and maybe I missed this at some point, but the...

3:01:13 The gentleman who presented these signs and had the longer public comment, there were images in that document of the regular cell tower, not the stealth monopine. Is that on the table to consider? And I don't know if I can ask this, but is that what this group of homeowners is? Is that an option that they would prefer? Or does it have to be a stealth monopine based on our zoning and code and everything?

3:01:39 So after the November 8th hearing, one of the follow-up discussions was that to provide from the HOA group was request to provide what a mono, just a mono tower would look like versus a mono pine. And also looking at the site to the east of the fire station as well as directly against the fire station. That came from a meeting on the site with the fire district and the HOA group of other possible.

3:02:08 Locations out there and what those appearances would look like. So AT&T did produce those photo sims for that purposes. Did not produce the one directly north of the tower because they said it would not work with just their engineering to have a tower that close to the building. So those were provided to the group. And then the kind of response received was just we should be looking at other sites.

3:02:33 And we produced our own photo sims because theirs were not accurate. Gotcha. But in theory, a regular, what do you call it, mono tower could be considered for this. It doesn't have to be a stealth monopine. It did. It could require some additional analysis just to review how it complies with more of the screening from the public view, public right-of-ways, which are the old Mammoth Road, and on that side is considered the public right-of-way. Gotcha. Okay.

3:03:03 Perfect. Should I share my opinions? If I may interrupt you really quickly, Commissioner Kennedy. Chief Alish, would you mind just addressing in a really quick summary why it's preferable for the fire district to have two service providers on that tower and why you're currently speaking with Verizon? Yeah, absolutely. So thank you. A couple things. There is, and I understand the concerns.

3:03:29 There is no intent on any kind of bait and switch here. I tend to be very forefront as far as what we're trying to accomplish. I serve at the pleasure of my board. But that being said, the intent of the fire district is truly to provide communications in Old Mammoth. So from day one, we looked at what this tower would have to be designed for in order to achieve that goal. We've worked with Verizon on this as well. What we've told them, they were actually going to submit

3:03:58 plan permits and start working on the process. But they've gone so far as to look at the plans with permission from AT&T, agree that they are fine with that second position on the poll. Ultimately, my ask was, what is going to be required to provide for two providers? If Verizon had not been comfortable with that position, I'd be asking you for a higher height here. I'm just being honest. So what the project that is before you today

3:04:27 is built and designed with the intent to provide communication across Old Mammoth for all providers that are interested, who are both AT&T and Verizon. An official Verizon permit has not been pulled yet, but they have walked the site, they have seen the plans. We agreed to essentially 30% of what AT&T is getting. So the lease, while does not exist yet, is in theory agreed to. I understand that, you know, that...

3:04:54 May not make some people 100% comfortable, but that is the intent. To speak a little further on this, yeah, I would not come before this commission or any other commission with a 55-foot tree knowing that I can extend it by 30 feet three months later. That's just not how I operate. So what you see before you is what we believe serves for public safety and still tries to work with aesthetics and that sort of thing. There is no intent for the fire district to put

3:05:24 Any communication equipment above that. I was also very careful to protect the fire district. The initial lease that we put in with AT&T had a longer time period. We went to the shortest time period so that if the interests of the district at some point, the gentleman is 100% correct. Times change. You know, Elon Musk may invent something that's beaming information to all of us. At that point, I can go back to my agreement and look at change that.

3:05:50 That's not going to happen today. We have to provide for public safety today. But do it in some manner so that we have opportunities in the future to adjust as things change. That being said, you know, the project as you see it is really kind of the intent of the district. There is no intent to raise this poll and it provides coverage. I can't speak to the specifics for where the providers are, but I can tell you is that Verizon was comfortable with that secondary spot on the poll and wanted to move forward.

3:06:17 And just for clarity, secondary position on the poll, south, below AT&T. And AT&T is going to do what's in the best, everyone's going to work in their own best interest. AT&T is going to want the highest position on the poll. Got it. Thank you. You know, before we get to the opinions, maybe I'll just make sure if there's any other questions from the commission before we, yeah, please. Mr. Shane. I think this is,

3:06:48 Based on Bennett and Alicia's presentation, and I think this, what I gathered from the presentation, basically FCC said aesthetic is not a consideration, view is not a consideration, property value is not a consideration, I think I'm missing RF was not a consideration.

3:07:21 Did you say height was not a consideration? Or can height be a consideration? Yeah, so I'd clarify that aesthetics are a permissible consideration in addition to height. On the property values and our permissions items, if the applicant demonstrates that compliance that they have with the FCC standards.

3:07:52 Okay. Alicia mentioned

3:08:20 The 90 plus foot illumination, that was a consideration. So if this thing goes up to 100 feet with no illumination, the applicant could easily do that without town's objection or neighboring residents' objection. Am I correct? Yes. Okay.

3:08:52 On the height, on the lighting, I will say the town can condition lighting restrictions. However, there are requirements by the FCC and the FAA which require some minimal lighting requirements based on their own criteria. The town cannot preempt those requirements. So you can limit it, any lighting on the tower to the extent

3:09:21 if it was required by federal and state law. Will there be any lighting on this thing? There is currently no lighting proposed on the plans and that's also one of the conditions that recommending conditions that I've drafted is additionally prohibits any lighting of the tower except as required by state or federal law. But potentially they can put lighting on for safety reason without because FCC, they're saying that they can do it

3:09:52 But you're telling me that town said they cannot do it. There are, as far as I know, through an 80-foot tower, there's not a requirement to have the lighting for aerial obstructions because it doesn't exceed that height. So our condition would prohibit any lighting except any other requirements by state or federal law that can obscure or that go beyond what we can require. So how difficult can the applicant put this up to 100 feet?

3:10:23 What is that process? So there is a I have to look it up this section. There's a section of the FCC code which allows for what they call minor modifications or increases in height of cellular facilities which I don't have the code section in front of me but I believe it's up to a maximum of 20 foot increase that is approved administratively and I'll look to Bennett who specializes in this if I

3:10:52 Miss that reference to the FCC law and the increases in height. No, that's correct, Nolan. So there are two ways modifications can go to increase the height for an existing structure. Number one is based on federal law. It's called an eligible facilities request. If it does qualify as an eligible facilities request, the town has no discretion and must approve it.

3:11:19 That process allows a height increase of 20 feet. If a proposed modification to increase the height does not qualify as an eligible facilities request, the town would retain its full authority to apply any other height restrictions in its review of that application. So you would not be required to permit the height increase.

3:11:46 The applicant could potentially claim that a denial of their height increase would violate federal law and prohibit their provision of personal wireless services, but you would not be as so constrained as you would under the eligible facilities request process. Thank you. That's all I have. Any other questions from the commission? If not, I'll pick on you again, Commissioner Kennedy. Sure. Thoughts, opinions?

3:12:18 Yeah, I guess first I just want to thank all the members of the public who wrote and emailed and came today and came to our last meeting. I know this has been a big spend of your time and energy, so thank you for all that. I want to say too that we take public comment really seriously and really appreciate having it, so thank you for that. I think, honestly, this situation sucks all around.

3:12:42 We need better cell service and most of us wouldn't want this right outside of our house. So I totally understand that, you know, the passion that you guys have brought to this issue. I personally think the Mono Tower looks better than the Monopine, but I know we're pretty much talking about the Monopine, but just wanted to throw that out there. I also wanted to thank the people who've presented today and helped us all get a better understanding of

3:13:06 What we're talking about and what we're able to make comments on and make decisions on and this is complex stuff so I appreciate everyone's help getting us to this point. Like a few of the public commenters and the commenters said our job here is to go for the public good and to work within the documents and the systems and the codes and everything that we have here so with those things in mind after the discussion today I support this project and based on the key issues that we've

3:13:34 were being asked to consider today. I don't see a valid reason to deny approval of the project, but yeah, I thank you all for being here. Thank you for helping us figure out a solution to this. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Burroughs. I want to echo what Commissioner Kennedy has stated about you being all here today. It's been a long process, and I appreciate your input, your thoughts. I have read your comments, and thank you for spending the time on this.

3:14:03 I do want to mention to the AT&T representative that I feel like the use of NIMBY was used a little too much and could be considered somewhat offensive. Understanding what you were trying to mean, that people don't want this in their backyard, nobody does, but maybe we could tone it down on that sometime in the future if we're giving that presentation again. Our job here was to identify the class three

3:14:33 to see if this project meets the class three categorical exemptions and in my opinion it does and I think working as a public safety person myself I think that it is way more important to be able to provide cell phone service for the health and safety of our community than it is to

3:15:02 Be as concerned over the aesthetics of a tree or it being in our backyard. I would not want it in my backyard. I understand that you don't want it in your backyard. But if it came down to whether my neighbor died of a heart attack because we didn't have proper cell phone coverage and they could call 911 or that tree was in my backyard, I would save my neighbor's life in a heartbeat in a minute without a doubt. So in my mind, that is the most important thing here.

3:15:31 I think that it's a little disingenuous stating that this proposed cell phone tower has already reduced values of homes. Let's be honest, we have a short-term rental moratorium that is destroying our property values, and we have interest rates that are at 8% for mortgages. So that is what's driving our property values down right now. It's not just in your neighborhood, it's across this town. Data does not...

3:15:58 I understand there's been some concerns about the RF frequencies, but the data just does not indicate that that's going to cause any harm to the community. So with all this in mind, I am forward, I am going to support this. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Eckert, thoughts, opinions? Excuse me, like my fellow commissioners, you know, clearly.

3:16:29 Won't use the N-word, but public safety trumps just about everything else. I would really love it if we had this type of participation in most of our meetings that didn't involve the 500 yards next to their property. It's nice to see public participation. It's also very rare. And I appreciate very much that you folks have come out. I would, too.

3:17:00 I do support a cell tower out there for all the already repeated reasons. I do also think that this thing's damn ugly. And there's got to be a way to balance the public need for communication with better aesthetics than that. So my thought is, and we'll throw it back to the majority, my thought is, is

3:17:30 If there's a spot on this tower at 55 feet that is functional enough for Verizon to pay for it, maybe that should be what we're using. And if in the future there is a second group that wants to come in and use another cell tower, maybe we could have them put it somewhere where we get even better coverage. Maybe we could have them put it over, you know, by the bridges or somewhere where we can get it better going back up into the...

3:18:03 up into the Lakes Basin as well. Now, while this is the least bad way to get two towers, I think we would be better off with a tower here and a tower somewhere that expanded service than have them both here, especially when it requires this thing being just hideously ugly. That's my comment. Commissioner Chain, opinions, thoughts? Thanks, Chair.

3:18:38 Unfortunately, our hands are tied. You got a big government telling us, you know, a lot of things we cannot consider here. And however, nothing is perfect. And public safety is certainly trump almost everything else, in my opinion on this. And so I do support this project cautiously.

3:19:12 Way to hedge it. I'm going to support this project for a lot of the reasons that were listed up here. You know, we've had some great presentations this morning from some experts, but I think the one that I find the most value in was the presentation by the fire department, the fire district. I agree with a lot of the comments that were made that in the nature of the public well-being, that has to supersede everything else.

3:19:42 We are very limited in our maneuverability here with federal law, state law, FCC. We don't have a whole lot of room here to move. But before we get to me asking for a motion on this, Nolan, would you just quickly summarize the conditions that you've kind of written up on the fly here a bit? Yes, I did.

3:20:10 In response to the comments made, drafted four additional conditions that we would recommend be included in the resolution. And I can read those for the record, and I can provide a copy to the town clerk of the conditions as well. So those are the branch density, color, and final design of the faux monopine shall be reviewed by the Community and Economic Development Design Committee.

3:20:35 Prior to building permit issuance, provided that the location height and mass of the monopine does not change from the plans dated January 12, 2024, the permittee shall install and maintain during the entire duration of the use permit a sufficient density of faux branches to completely conceal all transmission equipment, antennas, conduits, and wires installed on the monopine. Final approval of the design shall be made by the director based on the recommendations of the design committee.

3:21:05 Additional condition number two, the permittee may not maintain lighting on their wireless facility except as required by state or federal law. Additional condition number three, the owner and any future owner of the Monopine Tower shall conduct an annual inspection of the tower to ensure that the tower's appearance is maintained in substantial conformance with the appearance of the tower as originally installed.

3:21:31 Any deterioration of the tower's physical appearance that substantially changes from the appearance of what was originally installed shall be remedied by the owner of the tower within 90 days of the annual inspection of the tower. Condition number four, the installation of the facility and the ongoing operation of the facility shall adhere to all town noise regulations pursuant to Municipal Code Chapter 8.16. Thank you. Any questions on the four conditions?

3:22:01 Put forth by Nolan? Would anybody like to put a motion forth, either with or without the modified conditions? I will. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings approving use permit application 23-002 with conditions as recommended by staff. Do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation on it?

3:22:32 on this agenda item before we put it to vote. Jamie, would we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 5-0. Why don't we take a five-minute personal break for you? All right. Now that we are confronted with an empty sweet Z, we'll go on and continue on with our meeting.

3:30:08 Let's go to public hearing item 4.2, which has also continued from the January 10th, 2024 meeting, and we are to consider approval of variance 23-001 for a 40% reduction of the front setback and a 34% reduction of the rear setback to allow for a new single-family residence at 13 Davidson Road.

3:30:37 The proposed action includes finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Guidelines Section 15303, new construction of small structures. And I believe our staff contact, I've gone blank on it, guys. Michael. Sure. Variance 23-002 for 13 Davidson Road was originally scheduled for a public hearing at the January 10th, 2024.

3:31:08 PEDC meeting. However, due to additional staff review, the item was continued to today's meeting. The project, like Michael said, is requesting a variance of a 40% reduction to the front setback and a 34% reduction to the rear setback to allow for a new single-family residence. This would result in a 15-foot front setback where 25 feet is otherwise required and a 13-foot, 9-inch rear setback where 20 feet is otherwise required.

3:31:43 13 Davison Road is located in the residential multifamily 2 zone. The property has numerous physical constraints that limit the development potential of the site. These include being substandard in size. The size of the lot is 8,660 square feet, where the standard minimum parcel size in the RMF 2 zone is 40,000 square feet.

3:32:06 It has a buildable area that's substantially smaller than the required minimum buildable area of 24,000 square feet in the RMF2 zone. It has a lot width of 95 feet and a depth of 97 feet, which are less than the minimum width and depth of 150 feet required in the RMF2 zone. It has an irregular triangle shape, and the town also requires a 10-foot irrevocable offer of dedication.

3:32:35 along the front property line due to Davison Road being a substandard street. This further reduces the buildable area on the parcel. Here we have a proposed site plan for the project that identifies the reduced setbacks. It's important to note that the project meets the parking requirements and is able to accommodate all of the parking spaces without them encroaching into the setbacks. The project also consists of a large retaining wall behind the house to mitigate the risk of erosion.

3:33:09 And all of the surrounding property owners within 300 feet were notified of the proposed variance. And as of today's meeting, staff has not received any comments from the public. With that, the staff recommendation before you is to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Guild findings and approve variance 23-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications.

3:33:37 With that, we can open up to questions. Also, the applicant is available on Zoom if they're needed to answer any of your questions. Does the applicant want to address the commission or just answer questions as needed? Just answer questions as needed. Okay, thank you. Any questions from the commission for staff on this matter? Commissioner Chang? The only question I have is the design of the property. I'm assuming that the shape of the building

3:34:13 was really based on the restriction of the setbacks. Am I correct? Yeah, Matt, would you mind touching on that? He's the architect for the project. Yeah, thank you for hearing this project. Yeah, it was, you know, with any project like this, there's a number of different variables and considerations that go into

3:34:44 The decision-making behind the design. So one of those certainly was the shape of the property itself and the limitations and constraints of the irregular shape of the property. And so the round house was an elegant solution that's going to provide a beautiful addition to the township as well as a

3:35:13 Yeah, a workable solution for the site itself. Thank you. That's all I have. Jessica, or Commissioner Kennedy, you look like you have a question about to jump right out of your mouth. Is that the house behind you? It looks quite similar to the house. Is that the house behind you? Your Zoom backdrop, is that the house rendering? That's an earlier version. That's a house that was built about 12 years ago. Awesome. Thank you. That's it. I have a quick question for staff. So just...

3:35:47 For 100% clarity, the applicant is meeting all of their snow storage requirements and their parking requirements by the town. Yeah, that's correct. They're required to have four parking spaces, two of which are enclosed, or required to be enclosed, two of which are able to be in the driveway. Like I said earlier, they don't encroach into the setbacks at all. And they also meet the 70% requirement for snow storage on the site. Got it.

3:36:13 And Michael, would you quickly just address, or maybe the applicant wants to, the retaining wall on the property and how it will affect Lake Mary Road, if at all? How? That there won't be issues with erosion because of the placement of the retaining wall specifically onto Lake Mary Road. Matt, is that something that you can talk about? Are you asking me?

3:36:50 Would you care to address it as the primary architect? The reason for the retaining wall and how it relates to possible erosion from this lot down onto Lake Mary Road? Yeah, the reason we selected a retaining wall of between 8 and 9 feet is, first of all, this site itself looks like it's been impacted in the past by some

3:37:17 Digging and earth movement and so it's a very irregular topography and rather so the options were really build a foundation a daylight basement type foundation into the hillside that retains the earth behind the house at you know some elevation or to level out the site itself and just build on a flat site.

3:37:45 And that's where we brought in the Ready Rock Retaining Well Solution. And so I think that is going to really help and go a long way towards mitigating any erosion considerations because at the end of the day, we're basically building on a flat site. Got it. And that was acceptable, that plan for staff and town ordinance.

3:38:15 Yeah, the project has been reviewed by engineering and they did not have any, public works in engineering, they did not have any comments about erosion issues specifically related to public right-of-way or on the site in general. Got it, thank you. Alex, I'm assuming you're not going to submit public comment on this agenda item. Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? All right, then I will close public comment. Any further questions for either the applicant or for staff on this?

3:38:49 If not, I'll entertain a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required variance, findings with conditions, if any, recommended by staff. Were there any additional conditions? Not for this one, no. Got it. Do I have a second? Second. I have a second. Any further conversation? No. Jamie, may we please have a vote? Commissioner Chang.

3:39:22 Yes. Commissioner Eckert. Yes. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Approved 5-0. Congratulations. I got to say, I love the aesthetics of the house. That's a corner that I think you'll get a lot of eyeballs on. So congratulations. Thank you so much. Thank you for your time. All right. With that, we will close public hearing and go to business matters 5.1. Consider approval of time extension requests.

3:39:54 24-001 for a one-year time extension of the Residence Inn Boutique Hotel by Marriott Project Entitlement, located at 94 and 150 Burner Street. And I believe Kim, the patient Kim, is our staff contact on this one. Thank you. So as you just said, the application before the commission is a time extension request.

3:40:21 The entitlement for this project included a tentative tract map for the proposed subdivision of the units within the resort condominium hotel. It also includes a use permit and a major design review. The residence in project consists of a four-story, 101-room resort condominium hotel with guest amenities and understructure parking for 109 vehicles. The project entitlements were

3:40:48 approved by the Planning and Economic Development Commission on April 13, 2022. Since that time, the applicant has made a good faith effort in exercising the entitlements. The first kind of effort was that the applicant did submit a building permit application and construction plans for building permit plan check. Those were actually submitted in 2022. I know that they have responded to the first round of comments.

3:41:18 On that, the applicant also completed its role in annexation into the Transit Community Facilities District, as well as the Applicable Maintenance Community Facilities District, and these were requirements from the Engineering Division's conditions of approval for the project. I believe that was required prior to final map.

3:41:43 And lastly, the applicant did submit a final map application to the town in February of 2023. That is tentatively scheduled for consideration at your next meeting in March. Without approval of the...

3:42:01 Time extension request, the entitlement will expire on April 13th, 2024, unless an automatic extension is granted through an alternative process, such as when the final map is approved, that process would automatically extend the life of the entitlement for an additional year. While we believe, while staff believes that the final map approval is on track,

3:42:25 for approval. The applicant team wants to proceed cautiously and ensure the entitlement does not expire for any unforeseen reason. The application team is requesting one year to the life of their entitlement, which extends the life of the project entitlement to April 13, 2025. The project applicant has not requested any changes to the approved project at this time.

3:42:53 And it is worth noting that upon approval of the final map, all other approvals in conjunction with the tentative tract map are granted one additional year of life, which means that the entitlement would remain valid for one additional year, so into 2026. The approval will be deemed exercised when the applicant has obtained a building permit and has commenced construction.

3:43:20 We staff was able to make affirmative findings for approval. And we base those findings for approval on the fact that the request is consistent with the length of time permitted by the town's municipal code, which allows up to six years for a time extension request.

3:43:40 The project approvals were found to be consistent with the general plan and the North Village specific plan and no changes have occurred to the project since the approval by PEDC. The applicant has made significant progress towards exercising the entitlement since the project was approved in 2022. No changes to the applicable regulatory documents or site-specific conditions have occurred that would impact the approval.

3:44:10 And it is worth noting that one abandoned residential building on the north side of the property was demolished last year due to significant damage that was sustained from our extreme winter. And since that structure has been removed, none of the situations requiring denial or addition of new conditions of approval are present.

3:44:33 And with these findings being satisfied, staff believes a time extension request meets the applicable requirements and recommends the PEDC adopt the Attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required municipal code findings and approving time extension request 24-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. That does it for me. I know that we have the applicant on Zoom if you have any questions.

3:45:03 Would the applicant like to make a statement or just answer questions as they arise? Yeah, I'd like to just make one statement as the applicant here. My name is Atman Kadaki. I'm the managing principal at Greens. We'll definitely answer questions as they arise, but I just wanted to take a moment to thank the city manager, the city staff. I want to thank Kimberly, I want to thank Nolan. They've worked tirelessly on this project.

3:45:32 Since the beginning, been very supportive and we are trying our best to proceed as quickly as possible on the project and really appreciate the consideration for the additional time to protect our entitlements. Thank you. Any questions from the commission for either the applicant or staff? Just one question for Kim is this extension is to extending from 24 to 25, right?

3:46:05 That's correct. But then automatically give you another year to 26. So this time extension request is for one year. When a final map is approved, that process automatically extends the life of an entitlement for one year. So on top of this requested time extension, we would anticipate that one year would be added when the final map gets approved. Got it. Because that's a standard thing that happens.

3:46:36 with the final map. Thank you. That's all I have. I have a comment. Please. If this is approved, I would just ask the applicant if they would consider extending the leases of those businesses that are currently in place. I know that those businesses are kind of in limbo and would like to stay there as long as possible, so please consider that if you're not going to demolish the building soon. Thank you.

3:47:11 Commissioner Kennedy, any questions for either staff or the applicant? Nope. Would the applicant care to address the comments by Commissioner Burroughs? Yeah, I definitely would. So we're small business owners ourselves, and we have leases on other businesses of ours in many markets. We certainly sympathize and understand the current tenant's predicament.

3:47:42 with our notices to vacate, you know, it is our goal and it is our intention to try to break ground as quickly as possible. The tenants do pay a considerable sum of money so by vacating them, you know, it does cost us quite a bit of money as well to take that risk. That's all in the spirit of moving this project forward as quickly as possible.

3:48:05 So the time extension that we are seeking is really to protect the entitlement and in the event we're not able to start in time of when our permits expire, but we do want to get this project in the ground as quickly as we can. So we did give notices, as you know, as you described, to the tenants.

3:48:29 We are working with certain tenants to work out their seasonality or work out things to assist them the best we can. And again, we do sympathize. It's not something we're dismissing. It's just from a perspective of really the spirit of breaking ground on this hotel and moving it forward, we felt that it was the best case for us to go ahead and issue those notices.

3:48:55 Now, Matthew is the broker who represented us on the purchase of the property. He's also assisting some of these tenants in finding other locations as are other brokers. And so, I mean, I think we're doing our best and we're trying to do our best to accommodate the concerns of those tenants. But I just wanted you to have the full picture on that and address your concerns. Thank you. Thank you.

3:49:23 Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom on this matter? No, we do not, but I have an email from Matthew Lehman. He says, I came in to speak in favor of item 5.1, but given another meeting, I cannot wait any longer. Can you please pass on my support to the commissioners for the extension, particularly in the wake of a very heavy winter last year? The applicant has been making steady progress to move forward with the project and the best intentions to see it through.

3:49:54 Perfect. And that'll get incorporated into the public record. Sweet Z, any public comment? Crickets, crickets. Then I will close public comment and I'll bring it back to the commission. If anyone has opinions or thoughts, now would be the time. If not, feel free to put a motion forth. I don't have anything, so I'll make a motion to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required municipal code findings and approving.

3:50:25 Time extension request 24-001 with condition, oh sorry, yeah, with conditions as recommended? No, we don't need conditions. I don't believe any conditions. No conditions. Do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Jamie, may we have a vote please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 5-0.

3:50:51 Congratulations, but we do hope to see you active on that site sooner than later. Thank you. I really appreciate your support. And I just wanted to say before I forget, I also want to thank Tom Plax and my architect, Kevin Hobbs and Bob Tuttle. They've also worked very hard. It's a team effort. And we really do hope to break ground here soon on the project. Thank you for your support. Thank you. Appreciate it. With that, we'll close business matters. We'll go to the consent agenda.

3:51:20 Unless there are any modifications or edits from the approved minutes of the January 10th, 2024 meeting, then let's have a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? I'll second. Jamie. Commissioner Chang. Yes. Commissioner Eckert. Abstain. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst.

3:51:48 Yes, my bad. Did I miss it? No, no, I jumped in there real quick. In lieu of the fact that this was a pretty long meeting and a little bit emotional and passionate, I would like to see us maybe skip over commissioner reports and we can do updates the next time around. Nolan, are you comfortable skipping over the director report or would you like to address something you think is time sensitive?

3:52:16 No, we can skip over that to our next meeting. All right, then with that, I will adjourn today's meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting on March 13th, 2024. I've already notified staff that I will not be present for that March meeting. I will be traveling that week for work. So just a heads up. And I do think we have another member of the commission who will not be present for the March 13th meeting. With that, we'll close. Thank you, everyone, for...