TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2022

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 14:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

4 findings

Transcript

612 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:07 Can we do roll call first? Yeah, let's do roll call first. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst? Present.

2:56 All right, so now I'm going to open up public comment, and I will ask if you are here to give public comment on an item that's on our agenda, that you hold your public comment until that item is before the commission. So if there is anybody in Suite Z who would like to give public comment on an item unrelated to today's agenda, please come up to the podium and just tell us your name and what you'd like to talk about. I don't see anybody. Is there anybody from town staff that would like to submit public comment? I see Jenna. Please, Jenna.

3:29 Thank you very much. I'll be quick here. I know you're a busy meeting. You have a busy meeting. Quick reminder that town cleanup day is this weekend, starting Friday and Saturday, Friday the 13th, Saturday the 14th, starting at 8 and going until 3.30. You can pick up orange bags at the town offices, at Footloose, or at the transfer station from Mammoth Disposal. And then, real quick, I just wanted to share my statistics right here. Let's see. Well.

4:02 This is basically it. You should see an Excel screen. Sorry, it's not as presentable, but you can see a quarter of my work is on unpermitted right now and a quarter is on substandard. There's a taking less of my time. And that is it from code compliance. I'll stop sharing now. That was just a quick update. If anyone has any questions. Anyone on the commission have questions for Jenna? No? Anybody on Zoom up there? Hey, Jenna, are you still enforcing the sign compliance?

4:34 I am still working on that, yes. It's been a little slow going, but I have not been really pushing hard on citing anybody or anything. I'm just still in that notification education phase. Got it. Thank you, Jen. I appreciate it. Thanks for your time. Anyone else from town staff? I don't see anyone in person or nobody up towards the...

4:58 The kiosk now closed public hearing and we will go to our first agenda item. It's a public hearing in consideration of tentative tract map 21-001, use permit 22-002, use permit 21-001, design review 21-001 and adjustment 21-006 for the Villas 3 subdivision and proposed 33 unit.

5:25 Residential development located on 100 Callahan Way. And I believe today our staff contact will be Michael. Just for everyone in the audience who may be sitting in for the first time on one of these, the way these meetings usually happen is we get an update from staff, a staff report, and then we have the applicant give any testimony or statement or opinions they'd like to give.

5:51 The commission will then have the opportunity to ask questions of staff or the applicant, and then we'll open it up to public comment. And because we do have quite a bit of public comment, we're going to limit public comment to three minutes each. So we definitely want to hear from you guys, but we have a lot to talk about, and we have a very full agenda. So with that, Michael? Just really quickly, kind of following on what you just said, is that public comment should generally be addressed to the...

6:20 Commission. Correct. And then at the commission's discretion, staff can respond to the comments at the end of kind of the public comment period. Correct. Just to summarize that, so any questions that might arise at a public comment that pertain to staff, they will compile the questions throughout the public comment session, and then they will answer those questions at the conclusion of public comment. Thank you.

6:44 And then the other item is just a note that Commissioner Eckert is conflicted out of this item, so he will not be participating in the item. And with that, I'll hand it over to Michael for the staff presentation. All right. Good afternoon, Commissioners. This item is the continued public hearing of the Billows 3 Subdivision Entitlement Package. Since the initial PEDC meeting, I'm not used to being in person. Yeah.

7:12 The entitlement package consists of the following components, tentative tract map, 21-001 to subdivide the parcel into 33 lots, design review, 21-001 for the single family and duplex designs, adjustment, 21-006 to allow a two and a half foot increase to the building height for the three single family residences which are located at the far southern end of the project, use permit, 21-001 to allow transient rental use.

7:41 And use permit 22-002 to allow a gate on Callahan Way, which is a private street. This is a new application that was not included in previous PEDC meetings, and I'll provide some additional detail on the gate later in my presentation. The project is located at 100 Callahan Way on an undeveloped 4.07-acre parcel. The property is located in Development Area 2 of the Lodestar at Mammoth Master Plan.

8:10 The proposed Villas 3 subdivision is a planned unit development consisting of three single-family residences and 15 duplexes for a total of 33 units. The development will be accessed through a new private road that will connect the existing private streets of Callahan Way and Obsidian Place. Additionally, the project involves relocating the existing multi-use path and installing public storm drain infrastructure.

8:36 Since the initial PEDC meeting on February 9th, there have been many changes to the project plans, primarily in response to comments from the public. As part of the mitigation measures from the 1991 Lodestar at Mammoth EIR, all roads within 50 feet of residential zones are required to have a noise barrier. This project is proposing a six-foot-tall wooden fence to reduce roadway noise for the residential areas to the east of the project. This has been done for previous phases of Obsidian as well.

9:06 3 project was originally proposing a solid wood fence for the entire length of the property. But in response to public comments about the impacts to wildlife movements, the applicant has agreed to instead install a single rail fence for areas that are greater than 50 feet from the roadway. The approximate area of the single rail fence is highlighted in green on this map, and the solid fence is highlighted in red.

9:35 In response to public comments and conversations with the applicant in regards to how the site will function and be accessed, it was determined that the parcel is considered a through lot. This means that the front setback of 25 feet must be applied to both the north and south property lines. This increased the setback on the north end of the project behind San Joaquin Villas from the originally proposed 20 feet to 25 feet. And this can be seen on a portion of the track map on the left of this slide.

10:05 To further address comments from the public about the design of the units nearest San Joaquin Villas, the applicant has modified the design of several of the duplex buildings. For the units directly behind San Joaquin Villas, all rear balconies have been removed and the third floor has been stepped back in the rear. The new design for these units can be seen on the right on this slide. Additionally, the applicant has agreed to work with San Joaquin Villas HOA to reach an agreement to pay up to $30,000.

10:32 for additional landscaping between the units and San Joaquin Villas. Since the last continued public hearing, the applicant has submitted a use permit application for a gate at the north end of the project on Callahan Way. Use permits are required for gates to be installed on private streets. Callahan Way is a private street which is owned by the applicant. The gate application has been reviewed by Public Works and the Fire District, who provided conditions of approval.

11:04 The gate is proposed to be located just south of the property line, which will provide approximately 40 feet of space for vehicles between the gate and the entrance to San Joaquin Villas. The gate will not feature a call box or alarm to limit noise impacts to neighbors, and all residents, guests, and delivery drivers will have a transponder to open the gate. And now I'm going to pass it up to Sandra, who's going to talk about our site visit yesterday.

11:34 Okay. Thanks, Michael. So, town staff sent out an email last week and let the, everyone basically that we had email addresses for who had provided public comments on this item, let them know that we were going to meet out at the site yesterday at 5 p.m. to talk to the public about their concerns and walk the site and try to gather additional information to provide this to the commission to assist you in making your decision.

12:02 So we were out there for about an hour and a half last night. It was pretty chilly. Everyone was a little cold. But we did make it through there and talked about a lot of the different items that the neighbors, the concerns that they had. So the first concern that we talked about last night was concerns regarding the gate. As Michael mentioned, this is a new item from the previous Planning Commission meetings. So there were some concerns, questions about how the gate would function.

12:31 And concerns from the San Joaquin Villas residents regarding turnaround. And so concern about how would if someone gets all the way to the gate, how would they actually turn around? Would they have to back up into San Joaquin Villas? So staff this morning talked about this and is recommending that the commission include an additional condition of approval that would require the applicant to coordinate that final gate design.

12:58 with the Public Works Department in order to meet those requirements, including the provision of the adequate turnaround space. So we heard what the citizen said, and we think it's important to make sure that there is adequate turnaround space for this gate. So we recommended that condition of approval. Next slide. So the next item that we talked about was the concern, which you've seen in your letter, the letters from the

13:22 The residents concerned about the setback between the San Joaquin Villas and the Villas 3 and a desire to see that setback increased or just the distance between the buildings increased. And so these photos show generally the area between San Joaquin Villas and the proposed proposed project. And the picture on the right kind of is generally probably about where between where myself and Eric are standing there is where the new buildings look like they're about to be proposed.

13:51 So in our response, you know, we did talk about this at length with the residents out there last night and the applicant is meeting those setback requirements per the Low Star Master Plan. So it's difficult for the town to compel them to provide additional setbacks for those areas there. Next slide. There was a comment about access to Callahan from Main Street and the Frontage Road and just some

14:20 Concerns about the way snow removal is done during the winter and how you have to kind of make an S-curve to kind of come from Main Street, get onto Callahan. And so Public Works is going to review the access for Main Street and the Frontage Road and work with our snow removal crew to look about ways to change the way we store snow there to make that a safer entrance, improve the access to that area.

14:46 And then the last item was that the adjustment, which Michael mentioned was for those two buildings at the south end of the project, some concerns about whether that would affect the residences on Joaquin. So those are the buildings that are about two and a half feet taller, and they're approximately 60 feet from the properties on Joaquin, and so it's staff's opinion that the shading impacts from that two and a half height increase would be negligible.

15:15 So with that, I'm going to pass it on to Alicia Winterswick to talk about CEQA. Alicia, I think you're on Zoom. I am. I am here. Can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you and we can see you. Thank you. Okay, great. Thank you very much, Sandra and Michael, Chair and the Balance of the Planning Commission.

15:35 It's my pleasure to be here today to talk to you about the CEQA process for this project. As you know, based on the information in your agenda packet today, town staff has evaluated the project and determined that an addendum to the 1991 Modestar Master Plan Certified Environmental Impact Report was the appropriate CEQA document for this project.

16:02 There have been questions raised throughout the process as to how the town got here and whether an addendum is the appropriate document to prepare for this particular subdivision within the master plan area.

16:18 And the purpose of this slide is to demonstrate to you that the addendum is the appropriate vehicle to evaluate this proposal within the context of the larger Lodestar Master Plan. So under CEQA and the state CEQA guidelines, when a lead agency has certified an environmental document, particularly an EIR for a project, the lead agency is prohibited actually.

16:47 from requiring subsequent environmental review unless one of three conditions occur. Those three conditions are spelled out in the bullet points there under item number one. And I think what's important to point out about those three bullet points is that we're not only talking about a substantial change in either the project or circumstances or new information that's presented alone.

17:14 It is one of those three conditions, either a change in the project, a change in circumstances or new information that was previously not available, that suggests that a new significant impact would result from this modification to the project. So if there is evidence in the record that a new environmental impact would result based on one of these three conditions, then in that case, subsequent environmental review is appropriate.

17:44 Here, when the town engaged its environmental consultant to prepare the environmental analysis for this project, it was determined that the environmental impacts or scope of impacts for the entirety of the project fell within the bounds of the 1991.

18:03 EIR and the assumptions that were outlined therein, and that the mitigation measures from that document, if imposed on this project, which they would be, would be sufficient to mitigate any environmental effects that would occur as a result of the 33-unit subdivision.

18:20 There have been some comments presented about the passage of time and how can the town rely upon a document that is so old. Under Sequa, the passage of time alone is not enough to show that there would be a significant impact on the environment. As I mentioned, it is the test that's outlined in item number one that we have to utilize to determine what is the appropriate vehicle here.

18:43 Because we have some project changes we're discussing, particularly the adjustment that both Michael and Sandra just addressed, as well as the general layout of the project and the actual development plan for the site, which were not previously available at the time the 1991 EIR.

19:03 was prepared, but we have this additional analysis that shows that those plans do not result in any additional environmental effects that require further mitigation under state CEQA guidelines section 15164 an addendum is the appropriate document to prepare. Next slide. And so this particular slide just goes into that history and explains how the 33 unit

19:31 Subdivision is consistent with the master plan. This is a development that was contemplated in the master plan, but for, you know, this change of in height and some slight tweaks to the trail, there probably would be very little deviation from the concept that was identified in the 1991 master plan document.

19:56 So the addendum itself documents the town's decision that the project does not meet the criteria for preparing a subsequent EIR or negative declaration, and that is in your packet tonight for your consideration, or today for your consideration. Cool. Thanks. Thanks, Alicia. Sure. And that brings us to the recommended action, which is to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolutions.

20:28 Making the required CEQA, a state known at loss law, state subdivision map act, and municipal code findings, and approving tentative tract map 21-001, use permit 22-002, use permit 21-001, design review 21-001, and adjustment 21-006, with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Next, I'm going to pass it off to the applicant.

20:55 Mark Raffa and his team, and they're going to provide some additional information on the project. First of all, I'd like to thank everyone in staff and council for all of the time and the consideration, as well as everybody who showed up yesterday in the snow and gave us your feedback. And it was great to meet all of you in person and put faces behind the name. So again, thanks a lot for that. I wanted to first touch on

21:28 Our construction staging plan, I know that there's been some questions and comments about that, particularly with the neighbors on Joaquin. What we're intending to do initially is to get all of the road infrastructure and to do all of the dirt work as soon as possible. And our intention would be to have traffic flow from north to south, which would mitigate the reliance on Dorrance.

21:58 And it should be, you know, our goal is to be able to mitigate the impact on the day-to-day lives of those neighbors. The other thing that we're going to be doing, and most of, you know, we had talked about it before, but 70% of this project, actually more than 70%, but 30 of the units are going to be built off-site. By building it off-site, it should...

22:22 Michael Vanderhoof, Ph.D.: Mitigate a lot of the construction noise and it'll also shorten our project timeline we should be able to finish the project from start to finish in under 24 months, and so you know that would that would reduce the ongoing construction. Michael Vanderhoof, Ph.D.: By building it off site it also reduces the amount of storage traffic trucks and Labor that will have on site so you know putting those all together it should be a much less intrusive or.

22:52 of impact for the neighboring homes. And we've been in contact with some of the neighbors. And again, if you have any questions, you can ask specifics, but where we intend to have all of our storage, well, the majority of the storage that we can have offsite, we will store most of the materials offsite. I'm going to turn it over to Purva to talk a little bit about some of the design changes we made based on the comments that we received from the San Joaquin, owners of the San Joaquin Villas.

23:23 So go ahead, Porva. Thank you, Mark. Hi, everybody. I will briefly touch on our site plan and the new prototype that we have, which is prototype B2. Looking right here, this is our most updated tract map, which highlights the different prototypes that we have in the project. Prototype A, which is the original duplex design, is lots 4 through 21.

23:50 Prototype B is lots 26 to 33, and then Prototype B2 is lots 22 to 25. This is our original Prototype A. We've got Level 1, 2, and 3. The original design, it consists of three levels. We have an enclosed garage on Level 1. The approximate square footage is about 2,700 square feet of livable area.

24:17 And on this one, on level two, we have an open floor plan with a deck on the backside. And same thing for level three, we have a deck that's outside the master bedroom. I pointed those things out because those are some of the main changes that we've made on our prototype B2. The first thing we did was shrunk the size of the footprint by approximately six and a half feet on the front.

24:47 And that is mostly to accommodate for the additional five foot setback that we have on the north end of the property. Once we do that, we did have to, you know, lay out some of the bedrooms again. So the bedroom on the ground floor shrunk a little bit. And on level two, we got rid of the deck on the back and that moved to the front and it's a slightly smaller and a different size.

25:16 And then on level three, which is mostly the biggest change, is we have a 13 foot 10 inch offset from the back, which reduces the area. And we now have the office space on the third floor isn't there anymore, and it's basically just two bedrooms and two bathrooms.

25:42 That's the main change here. If you have any questions about any of these, any specifics, we can answer them later. And I'll briefly go on to our prototype B, which is basically very similar to prototype B2, but it's a mirror on the third floor. But the footprint and everything remains the same. All right, that's all I have right now. And just let us know if you have any questions. Thank you. Mark, is there anybody else on your team that would like to address the commission?

26:21 Not at this time. Just any questions that you guys have, we'd love to answer them. Okay. Thank you. So I'm going to open it up to questions from the commission for either staff or the applicant. Jessica Kennedy, you're top left on the screen. So I might let you lead off. Sure. I do have a couple questions. Thanks, everyone. So one question I have is...

26:44 If someone, I don't remember if you mentioned this or if it's just in the staff report, but the landscaping plan that's been mentioned, just curious if you, Michael, or someone else can chat a little bit more about what that entails. Mark, do you want to talk more about it? Besides what I've already said? Are you referring to the original landscape plan or are you talking about the additional landscaping that we were discussing with the, for the San Joaquin Villas on that side of it?

27:16 This was the additional one, and specifically there was a public comment that mentioned using non-native plants. I hadn't seen that anywhere, but just curious if you've gone down that road of what the landscaping would look like or just preliminary discussions. It's been really preliminary. Porva, I'll let you actually answer that question since you've been... It's quite preliminary, and I can pull up the landscape line if you like. At least I can find it, but...

27:45 We're mostly going by the arborist report that we have, which recommends all the trees that need to be removed, the trees that would be impacted by construction. That's just the basis of the landscaping. We are proposing a decent amount of landscape, additional landscaping along the bike path to mitigate some of the trees that are going to be removed. And then...

28:12 The minimum requirement around all the houses, which is about 500 square feet or less for the landscaping, that's what we're doing for each unit. But it's very basic right now. Yeah. And Commissioner Kennedy, this is Sandra. Just a response also that the final landscape plan, it's a condition of approval that we review and approve that final landscape plan. And we go through and take a look at all the plants that are included and make sure that they meet our requirements for planting.

28:39 If there was something shown on there, which sometimes will happen, applicants will show something that doesn't meet our requirements, we go through with a fine-tooth comb when we check the landscape plans prior to the issuance of the building permit. Perfect. And that's for the landscaping just in general on the project as well as the additional landscaping between, the additional landscaping fund between San Joaquin Villas and Villas 3? Yes. Okay.

29:06 Perfect. Thank you. My other question was about maybe a public works question. Curious about the construction traffic and Dorrance and how that fits in now. I think Mark addressed this a bit. But just curious, I think there was mention of having construction traffic be approved by the town if it needs to go through Dorrance.

29:34 I wonder if someone could speak to that aspect. Sure. This is Amy. I'm the engineering manager. We did include, as a condition of approval of the project, that construction traffic should minimize disturbance to residential neighborhoods to the greatest extent possible.

29:53 That being said, that does leave a bit of flexibility. However, that construction access is also required to be included on the project's construction staging and management plan, which is required as part of the grading permit application package. Perfect. Thank you for that. And then my one other question was, there was a public comment that brought up snow storage concerns about the amount of snow storage on this property. Just wondering if anyone from town staff can

30:24 address that or share any more about the snow storage calculations? Sure. So one thing we notice is that the snow storage on the plan was indicating that 75% of the paved areas was required, but in further review of the project documents, it's actually 75%. Is that in it? Excuse me. 70%. So

30:51 Those, the plans were based on a number that was a little bit larger. On top of that, we tend to, at this stage, slightly more qualitatively analyze the snow storage, and while at this point there are some...

31:08 Areas that are shown for snow storage that are less than 10 feet so that they technically don't meet the letter of the code. There are also areas on the plan that are available for snow storage that aren't being utilized. So when the client is ready to submit detailed grading plans for grading permit application, those drawings, we require that those drawings be updated and we review them in much more detail at that time.

31:33 So at this point, we are confident based on our review that they can meet the snow storage requirements of 70%. Perfect. Thank you so much. That's all the questions from me. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions for either staff or the applicant at this time? I have a question for Alicia, if I may. I want to summarize what Alicia said earlier, and I'm hoping that I'm not oversimplifying what she said.

32:06 was that in regards to passage of time, it is not a consideration to this project because there's no substantial changes in terms of the intensity used of this project. Is that a correct explanation, summary?

32:31 Yes, very, very, very nicely stated, Commissioner Chang. And the only thing I would add to that is that not only is the passage of time unrelated to the ultimate determination of whether or not subsequent environmental review is required, it would be that

32:57 The project changes and changes in circumstances or any new information that could have bubbled up in the time between 1991 when the EIR was certified and present, that any of that information would not show that the project itself would have a new or more intense

33:19 So we all know that with the passage of time, there is additional information and things that change, right, just in the general vicinity, but a change alone isn't enough. And assuming changes over the passage of time is not enough to trigger subsequent environmental review, there has to be some change in circumstance or change in the project or new information that shows the project has a new significant effect.

33:51 And Commissioner Chang, this is Sandra. Just to kind of follow up on what Alicia is saying is that this area back when it was considered under the EIR was intended to be much more intense. So I think originally we were looking at up to 131 units on this site and now we're looking at 33. So it's been significantly reduced from what was considered under the EIR. Thank you, Sandra and Alicia. The other question I have.

34:23 Is the gate, the proposed gate on Doran for purpose of construction, I believe, construction access? Is there a reason why construction access is not through the egress from on Meridian? Instead, going through

34:57 The neighboring project. So the impact primarily is on the neighboring project, but not on the project itself, traffic-wise. Is there a reason for that? Commissioner Chang, is that a question for staff or the applicant? For staff. I'm assuming that's something that staff require applicant to do.

35:29 Unless I'm incorrect about that. Michael, this is Amy. Our condition leaves it open to the applicant, but with the caveat that we've asked them to minimize impact to residential neighborhoods as much as possible. And as I stated earlier, their hall routes and access routes

35:57 Will be provided in more detail on the construction, staging, and management plan that is part of the grading permit application. Mark, I'm not sure if you wanted to just say a few words. Before Mark responds, Amy, I just want to clarify. The access that took place on Phase II, Villa II, I believe that's what it's called, that took five years.

36:28 So you're telling me that in five years, construction traffic was through to the neighboring project. That was because of the applicant's decision, not the town's decision? When you say neighboring project, are you referring to the neighborhood to the east from Dorrance and Joaquin? Yes. Okay. That was not...

37:01 That was not specifically a town directive. I can, just to add to that, Paul, one is, I mean, I don't know what was happening before we bought it, but I think we didn't start construction until 2019. And at this point, the truck, some of the trucks that are going to be going through there, they don't have the ability to turn around. And so now with, if we have the ability to go out through Callahan, we can then,

37:34 Have trucks come in through Meridian and then exit through there. And for the most part, a lot of this is dictated by the size of the vehicle and whether or not they can get through. And so if they can't, you know, if the Meridian access or the Callanhan access isn't wide enough for some of the trucks, then they'll, you know, our intention is to mitigate using Dorrance at all and try to keep everything north to south. But it's going to get, it'll be dictated by just the,

38:05 Restraints that we have based on the truck sizes and what needs to move in and out. I mean, we're going to be built putting mods up and so those boxes will be delivered to the site and there'll be a crane set up. So it shouldn't be ongoing like it was with Dorrance where we had ongoing construction and that became, you know, the main artery instead of what we're going to be going out through Meridian on this project.

38:29 as much as possible, but we'll be submitting the plan based on the actual vendors that we're going to be working with to the town with all of the construction routes and they've made it clear to us that they, you know, they want us to avoid going through Joaquin or Dorrance for this project. Thank you, Mark. Is that proposed gate will be up before construction phase three or is that after construction?

39:00 The gate on Dorrance or the gate on Callahan? Dorrance. So we're waiting on approval. So we submitted it. So if we can get our permit approved, then we'll be building it before. And will that gate sit on the inside of your project, not on the outside of the project where the bike path is? Am I correct?

39:34 I believe it's just inside. That's correct. Okay. All right. But I actually, Corva, do we have a copy of the submission for that? We don't have a final okay from the fire department yet. Okay. So once we get that, we can circulate that. But yeah, our intention is to, you know, we're not going to be able to, we're not going to obstruct the pedestrian path with the gate. Understood. The other question, another question about

40:03 Callahan Gate. One of the comments that I read had to do with the turnaround. The turnaround is going to take place on the neighboring property, on the San Joaquin property versus on your property. So I was a little confused about that. I don't know if maybe staff or the architect can demonstrate and show maybe on the map.

40:37 the concerns that they were talking about and that may perhaps that you have addressed that with the neighbors. Thanks, Commissioner. If that makes sense. Yeah, so just kind of going back to the condition that we're recommending be included is to have that final gate design and that adequate turnaround space subject to approval of the Public Works Department.

41:11 I don't know, Amy, if you want to speak any more to that. But because of that issue that came up, we're recommending we include this condition of approval to make sure that there aren't impacts, turnaround impacts on the adjacent properties. Thanks, Sandra. So, Sandra, are you saying that then that decision rests on public works, not during this meeting? Right. So it would be a condition of approval that the final gate design come back for approval.

41:42 with the Public Works Department, which is something that we do very commonly for kind of detailed plans that need additional analysis, like the landscape plan, building permits, grading permits, that kind of thing, that the final approval would come back to Public Works, the final configuration of the gate and the turnaround. And I'm assuming that Public Works and staff will work with the applicant and the San Joaquin owners

42:14 to come up with a suitable solutions for this. Correct. That's the intent of the condition. Okay. Thank you. That's all I have for now. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Burroughs, did you have any questions for staff or the applicant? Yeah, I have a few. Thank you. Not to hammer on the Dorrance, but I'm going to hammer on the Dorrance. It has been quite a disruption for homeowners in that area.

42:46 Am I correct in the understanding that that was a condition of the Obsidian 2 project and then it was supposed to, the gate was supposed to be installed, it did not have anything to do with the Obsidian 3? Yes, that's true. So the gate is related to the previous project that is not a part of this project here. The intent is, I can't remember when the trigger for the final gate, is it prior to? It's prior to the first certificate of occupancy.

43:16 For the first of the two duplexes that were part of the remainder parcel entitlement package that came before you last fall, which they're currently under construction at this time. Okay. And then if this project gets approved, I think that it's really important that the developer and everyone understands the impact that this project has had on that neighborhood and the big trucks and...

43:45 and the construction that has gone down Dorrance and through that neighborhood and how unsafe that is to have those big trucks and I would really, really strongly advise limiting that access as much as possible because that's just not right for that to continue on another several years if another phase is built.

44:11 Another question I had, or just wanted to clarify, you said that the original density for this area was a lot of 131 units and we're proposing 33, is that correct? Yes. Okay. And then setbacks, the developer has increased the setback to 25 feet from 20 feet, correct?

44:37 And then it's also my understanding that the San Joaquin Villas, when their project was approved, they asked for a decrease in setbacks. So they were supposed to be at 20 and they're at 15. Is that correct? Yes. Okay. And then I wanted to ask about TOTs in that area. How much of the current Obsidian complex has nightly rental business certificates?

45:06 Approximately? Approximately a third of the existing properties have DOT certificates. And then how often, are those used like 100% of the time, would you say? I don't have data on that specifically, but in conversations with the applicant, it sounds like it's well below full occupancy, and even a number of the units that are available for nightly rental are very rarely rented out.

45:36 On a nightly basis. Okay. And has there been any noise complaints out of that area? Do we know? No. Well, we talked to both the police department and code compliance at the town, and there have not been any noise complaints related to nightly rentals at any of the Obsidian properties or the Gray Bear properties directly to the east that are a similar type development. Okay.

46:02 And then just to clarify based on the renderings, I saw it appears that all the balconies that were originally on those units closest to the San Joaquin Villas, those balconies have been removed from facing that side, that's correct? Correct. Okay. And I think that is all the questions. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. I just have a couple. First one is for staff, probably Amy. Amy, would you just kind of clarify in plain speak?

46:34 What the timeline is and the trigger points when Dorrance will no longer be an access point for construction and the access points will be east and west. Sure. So the condition of approval for the previous project stated that that gate needed to be constructed and operational before the first certificate of occupancy for that previous phase. So that was the...

47:02 We called it the remainder phase that had two duplex buildings. Those are under construction or the grading permit has been issued for those. The building permit should be issued shortly for those. And so prior to them requesting certificate of occupancy, that gate will have to be installed and operational. Mark, do you have any idea of what your timeline is on that, the build out of those two remaining duplexes?

47:31 If assuming we can get our building permit shortly, I mean, we're thinking that it'll be done by next spring. Our intention also too is when we get the actual permit approval for the gate there. I mean, we're trying to get it done before the end of this building season. So before the end of the summer or by fall. Right, so they could complete the gate, have it operational and stop using that for access sooner than the construction.

48:02 CMO, and that's what Mark just referred to. Okay. Yeah, I mean, you know, right now we only have one, you know, if a truck's too big to turn around, right now there's no other way to get them out. So even if they come in through Meridian, you know, right now the only exit is through Dorrance, but if once we have Callahan graded out, then we'll have another exit. So we would be able to not have to use Dorrance. Okay.

48:29 Sandra, this is probably a question for you. The documents you were referring to that are going to be additional documents that are part of the conditions of approval that we were talking about today, referring to the landscaping, including the $30,000 of additional landscaping between the two complexes, and the public works document that's going to have to be approved addressing the gate and the turnaround on Callahan. What is the process for the public to have a chance to just...

48:58 See those documents. Thanks, Chair Vanderhurst. Typically, we don't have a public process that we go through for those types of permits. However, knowing the concerns here, we can reach out to the public, make it available for them to review, talk to them about it as we go through that process. So it's generally a staff-level approval, but we can certainly engage the public.

49:24 Those final approvals. Certainly the landscaping, I think that it's really a kind of an agreement between Mark and the San Joaquin Villas about the landscaping that they're going to put in together. So they'll be engaged kind of outside of our process in designing the landscaping and determining what they want in that area. But that additional landscaping will still be subject to the town's requirements in terms of, you know, what type of trees, what type of broaches, all that kind of stuff. Okay.

49:53 Last question for the moment. It's going to be for you, Mark. Maybe you can explain why you need that gate at Callahan. The first reason is just even in talking to the residents is that people drive up through there. And so it's to they're going to drive in and then get stuck and then have to make a turnaround. So it's to limit cars going in and out of there. It's also to mitigate kind of speed so people don't jet right through there.

50:24 I mean, that's really the emphasis of why we want the gate there. So speed control and to limit access, is that kind of what I'm hearing? Yeah, I mean, if, you know, some of the neighbors yesterday had mentioned that there's not even a road there now and people drive onto that, are driving on the pedestrian path there. And so it would be to eliminate that issue. Got it.

50:50 Okay, unless there's any other questions from the commission for either staff or the applicant, I'd love to open up to public comment. We've got some very patient people here. So any other questions from the commission? Anybody up there in the Zoom world? Nope. Okay, I'd like to open it up to public comment. I will let everyone know that we have received all of your written public comment, and I can assure you the commission has read all of it, including what came in today up to two hours ago. So rest assured of that. But please.

51:19 Come up to the podium if you'd like to give us some public comment. Just tell us your name and we'd love to hear you. Chair Vanderhurst, we received a request from a person on Zoom that has to attend a meeting. Do you mind if we take his comment first? Nope. Okay, thank you. Please. Jamie Pollack, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Great, there we go. Are you able to hear me now? Yep. Okay, cool. So thanks again for letting me speak. I just wanted to make sure that...

51:57 The information I'm going to say makes it into a public record. We all know things can change dramatically over the time of this project and everything that goes into a town that's progressing like this. I think it's critical that we have a lot of this information in the record. So first of all, I wanted to thank everybody. I know there's been a lot of time and energy put into all of this. If you look back when we started,

52:24 You know, it was basically a quick ram through to get this approved, and I think everyone seemed surprised that there were real concerns. So if you just take a step back and look at the progress that we made, I think it's important. I still do have a few points I think that really need to be addressed, though. I am adamant that there is a conflict of interest with Mr. Vandenhurst, and I respect Andy's response to the law here, but I think of, you know.

52:54 A $500 sort of benchmark is impossible. It really is close to the line here with Mr. Vanderhurst's work. And I think if you look back, it was another ramp through of just trying to get this thing passed without allowing people to even properly speak. And I know some of my neighbors came down to the offices to ask about the process and they were shooed away. So I do think that that's a result of a conflict of interest.

53:23 Secondly, I think a major point is that, you know, in speaking to Mark, the builder, the developer, there was definitely a lot of room early on in this process for him to help us together to figure this out. I know he was willing to do much further setbacks than we have now for the entire development, he told me that, but there was never really a proper forum to discuss these changes and these possibilities together.

53:51 You know, there's always a flag that's raised that we can't do this because of that, but there are exceptions. San Joaquin Village has setbacks that are exceptions. So I think that sort of, you know, feeds into the fact that the other sort of major issue is that this addendum is not appropriate vehicle for these changes. And I think with all due respect, the discussions that you're having on the CEQA laws and, you know, this environmental...

54:20 It is based upon substantial changes. And that definition includes a lot of things. It's not just the passage of time. It's a very broad definition of what's happening, of how this challenge is changing and how the people, you know, the workforce there and many other factors. So I think in speaking to local attorneys who are actually involved in writing the CEQA laws originally in Sacramento and some of the local judges in Mammoth,

54:49 If this case was brought before them, they would absolutely disagree with all of the legal advice that the town is getting. And then I think the final comments I just want to make is I appreciate that there was a walkthrough, but to do it the night before the hearing, you know, it seems a little disingenuous. I mean, what, you know, you had months to do this. What changes really could be effectuated by doing this the night before the hearing? I think I appreciate some of the concessions that the developer is making.

55:18 And finally, I just note, you know, it took all of this to get some sense of fairness in this process. You know, we appreciate the no balconies. We appreciate some setback and some planting. Please wrap up your comments. Your time is up. This process has been a travesty. Thank you very much. Thank you for your comments. Any other public comment at this time? Please. And Jamie, we'll address the concerns you have.

55:48 At the conclusion of public comment. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm here with a pre-recorded comment from Chelsea, who is unable to be here due to the time of day. I will play that now. Good afternoon, commissioners. Thank you for your time today. My name is Chelsea Glendy, and I am a teacher at Mammoth Elementary School. Thus, I am unable to attend this meeting in person. I have written three letters regarding the Villa's three developments.

56:21 And I hope you have had a chance to read all three. I live on Joaquin and my backyard directly butts up to the acreage to be developed. As you can imagine, this is devastating for me as I am losing my open space, my sun and my view. And my neighborhood will never be the same once construction begins. Throughout this process, those of us directly impacted by Villas 3 have made requests that are reasonable and should be honored.

56:50 One of those requests is to please deny short-term rentals. We do not need more short-term rentals in Mammoth Lakes. Town cannot sustain more short-term rentals, and short-term rentals would even further degrade our neighborhood. I will say that I greatly appreciate the changes that the developer has already made to accommodate our requests and lessen the impact of this development. However, there need to be drastic changes still.

57:20 Thank you. Thank you.

57:49 That it's absurd to even suggest, but I truly believe that construction of the units directly adjacent to them should be denied. Those units should not be built. As I have stated in all of my letters, the locals are the ones that you should fight for. Make this development the least impactful possible, please. And I'm sure the bears, squirrels and coyotes would appreciate it too.

58:19 In closing, I respectfully ask that you choose the locals over the developer, the tourists and the money that may be collected through permits, fees, short-term rentals and taxes. Please do what you can to allow us locals to continue to enjoy the place that we have made home. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm Kimberly Taylor.

58:49 We've raised a number of issues with these development plans. Many of these still remain unresolved. Some of these have been brushed off by town staff as either inconsequential or immaterial. In fact, they're very relevant to this proposed project, as Chelsea just stated. First off, the proposed gate, let's be honest, there is no demonstrated need. This is truly a want. This gate won't stop speeders. The gate will slow the speeder at the gate.

59:19 The gate has no bearing on what they do throughout the rest of the development. It's unrealistic. It doesn't prevent through traffic. There's already a gated obsidian that does that. It doesn't improve safety or security. The excess traffic that Mark just spoke of will be driven into our neighborhood, into our private property where we have small children and pets playing. It creates a more dangerous situation for SJV.

59:44 You know, prevent those people from getting into Villas 3, but it has no improved safety for us. If there is a gate, it needs to meet code, it needs to have the turnaround, it needs to mitigate the noise that will impact SJV with the keypad that was mentioned in the staff report and the gate operation when it's operating in the middle of the night with all of these guests coming in. It needs to be quiet. It cannot bang against

1:00:10 You know, when at its full open position, the keypad must be silent or whatever mechanism is used for guests. If there is a gate, it should be moved either farther back up Callahan to also protect the rest of us or further into the new development to allow for that appropriate turnaround space. Where it is right now is inappropriate. Second, the setback, it's still far too close. It will literally ruin our quality of life.

1:00:40 We appreciate the balconies were removed. Thank you. But that's just a small improvement. We also appreciate the duplex B2 modification pushing that third story back a little bit to give us a little bit more sun. It's not enough. These are still unreasonably close to SJV. Neither we nor those potential future buyers want to be crammed on top of each other. This is not why we're here. We're here to enjoy the nature, not stare at a solid wall.

1:01:09 The duplex building height at this distance will still put us in the E building in perpetual shadow in the winter months. The shadow study that was provided misrepresents the size of these buildings. It doesn't use factual dimensions. It falsely implies that Villas 3 is smaller than the reality. In last night's on-site discussion, I found it highly ironic that as we spoke outside on a sunny May evening,

1:01:39 While standing in the permanent shadow between the two SJV buildings 40 feet apart, exactly what will be put under in this new Villas 3 building, that it took three minutes for staff to request that we move into the sun. The duplexes that will be built will create that very same effect for us throughout the winter months, and we don't have the ability to pick up our building and move it into the sun. We will be trapped in that shade.

1:02:08 in perpetual shade for the winter months if these are built until the end of time. Mark, please take our advice from what we've recommended the additional 13 feet that we've shown can be moved. We request that it be moved back even more. Jamie mentioned, you know, the additional setbacks that could be done. The driveways could be shortened from 20 feet to 10 feet. There's lots of opportunity there to continue to move these back. Or better yet, don't build them.

1:02:37 Make it a green space. That would increase the value for the entire Villas 3 development and all of the community. Please do the right thing. Just because you can doesn't mean you should. We respectfully request that you think about the locals as well. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Lindsay Barksdale. I thank the commissioners for their thorough evaluation of this project and for taking...

1:03:15 Your time to talk to me individually previously. My husband Ian Burrell and I bought our San Joaquin Villas Home or SJV in 2007 through Mammoth Lakes Housing. We've lived and worked in town for 17 years. Our son attends Mammoth Elementary. We love the environment in and around SJV. Our quality of life has been great and my neighbors say the same.

1:03:36 The town of Mammoth Lakes has a shared community vision of, and I quote, providing the very highest quality of life for our residents, end quote. The proposed Villas 3 units, numbers 22 through 25, are extremely close to SJV and will significantly diminish the quality of life for residents due to loss of privacy, sunlight, peace and quiet. This goes against everything our town is trying to achieve for its residents. Here's why it's so bad.

1:04:03 The back windows and walls for units 22 through 25 squarely face SJV building ease, back windows and deck. SJV units are townhomes with only one living space that combines our living room, kitchen and dining room. The only natural light into this living space and the view out comes from one sliding glass door to the south. There are no other windows, only a sliding glass door.

1:04:26 If units 22 through 25 are built with only a 25 foot setback, it will block the sunlight, all views and privacy.

1:04:34 The developer can increase this setback between their units and SJV by 13 feet. That will make a huge difference to our quality of life. Their new duplex model B2 units are 6.5 feet shorter than the original duplexes, and this increases the unbuilt space on their parcel. Please utilize this unbuilt space to move units 22 through 25 another 13 feet to the south. The Villa's three units do not want to look at us any more than we want to look at them.

1:05:02 An additional 13 feet will increase everyone's quality of life. On a separate but very related note and disclaimer, I do sit on the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. This lot was once deemed appropriate for affordable housing. Now it is fully market rate homes. Local affordable housing programs are dramatically underfunded because developer housing mitigation fees have not substantially increased since 2015 when they were decreased to encourage development.

1:05:29 I call on town officials to update the ordinance and require an increased housing mitigation commitment by developers before approving a project. In summary, please require Villas 3, Units 22 through 25, to be set back even an additional 50 feet, or completely remove these units from the plan, or turn them so they are not square to the existing SJV Building E.

1:05:54 Thank you very much. Thank you. I'm Robert Fritchell. I live with my wife at

1:06:39 E2 in San Juan, California Villas. We have two littles. I want to thank everybody for the opportunity to speak and everybody who came yesterday to walk around the properties. I do apologize. I'm not used to this kind of environment, so if I'm a little edgy, I do apologize. A lot of what I have to bring up has to do with some of the things that were already mentioned by my neighbors, and I just want to make sure that

1:07:10 My voice and my family's voice is heard in this hearing. I do know a lot of time and effort has been put in there by town staff and by the developer and by myself, mainly my neighbors, on what kind of concessions and things we can come up with. So I do acknowledge all the time you guys have put in. My concerns come from the noise with having the units so close.

1:07:39 I have two littles. They're in elementary school. I've got to get to the school by like 7.40, as anyone with kids knows. My wife is a nurse at the hospital in a PACU ward and many times has to start at 6 o'clock in the morning. And we really need to get our sleep, which leads me to the use permit for nightly rentals.

1:08:04 Attractions to San Joaquin Villas for us when we purchased was that they did not have night in the rentals and with littles they need to get they need to get sleep and we start our days early. I'm really concerned about the privacy with them being so close and look right in with the walkthrough yesterday at the additional 13 foot recessment that we had talked about by shortening the unit you could see right into where my family was eating dinner.

1:08:34 Last night, while I was out with the group, just kind of making sure everyone was understanding where we were all coming from. I am also concerned with the sunlight and the shade. The snow is going to be an issue. I think I submitted some photos in a previous letter that showed the size of the snow hill at the end of Joaquin. It is massive. Some of the photos were taken from the second story window of my son's room. Looking out back, that tractor was

1:09:04 Above the window level. So on a year of 450 inches or more, we're talking about a two, three story hill of snow. We've had the luxury of watching a mama bear have babies for a few seasons now since we've moved in and I request that any concessions to save as much land space and trees would be great because those bears

1:09:33 Migrate through that parcel of land. They spend time in the trees. We see them in the mornings. We see them in the afternoons. And I'll make it real quick. A lot of this stuff has been mentioned before, but it's the noise, it's the gate. Thank you for your time. Thank you. So Judith Goddard. Good afternoon, commissioners, town staff. This afternoon, I have new information to provide to you.

1:10:15 To bring to your attention a major oversight which must prevent the resolution from being approved today. As this is all new information not submitted in any earlier letter, I will do my best to explain it clearly and I may need some of the five minutes that was in the published agenda rather than the three minutes. So snow storage for the existing Callahan Way has been completely overlooked in this process. As a reminder,

1:10:45 Callahan Way is a private road owned by the applicant and is the only access road to San Joaquin Villas. As Vice Chair Burroughs confirmed at the February 9th hearing, the owner of existing Callahan Way is responsible for snow removal. So this post-construction fully approved record drawing for San Joaquin Villas

1:11:08 Details the area of Callahan Way as 16,370 square feet. It requires 75% or 12,280 square feet of snow storage for compliance with code. This is an enormous amount of snow. Anyone who has visited Callahan Way in winter or spring and seen the huge snow pile at the end of the street can attest to this.

1:11:40 The need for snow storage was provided for during the planning of SJV in 2005. At that time, IntraWest owned the parcel that SJV is built on, in addition to owning both Callahan Way and the parcel proposed for the Villa 3's development.

1:12:00 Storage for snow ploughed from Callahan Way as it exists now was required as a condition for approval of SJV's development and was documented in the associated resolution. So the reason that this is directly relevant to the application today is that the April 2005 resolution and the record drawing from 2008 identify a large area

1:12:30 Directly south of SJV's parcel line, as conditioned for Callahan Way's snow storage. This area is within the applicant's Willis III parcel. The facts I have presented are supported by the filed and recorded resolution from 2005, which states that the majority of Callahan Way's snow storage, almost 8,000 square feet, shall be, and let me quote,

1:13:00 from the resolution, provided mainly in an off-site area to the south of Building 5. Building 5 is now SJV's E building. Continuing in the quote, this off-site snow storage area that is owned by the applicant, IntraWest, shall remain exclusively for roadway snow storage, end quote. We have been reminded during this process of the need to comply with the rules.

1:13:27 The Villa 3 application does not comply. It does not meet existing resolution and record-drawing obligations for the existing Callahan Ways conditioned snow storage. For the public record, I am providing a copy of this statement and a supporting letter that identifies the official documents that I have referred to. I'll give those to Jamie. So, in conclusion...

1:13:55 The Villas 3 application cannot be approved until this major oversight is addressed. The application must be updated to include the area conditioned for snow storage on the Villas 3 parcel immediately south of the property line at SJV's E building. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners. My name is Eric Taylor.

1:14:32 Last night and today I've had the opportunity to pour through the documents that Judith just referenced and I can say I've reviewed in detail the record drawings and the resolution in her statement is exactly right. The massive snow pile where the gate is planned has been completely overlooked even though residents pointed this out on February 2nd and over 15 times in public comments and photos since that time.

1:15:01 Everyone who has been down Callahan Way in winter is aware of this huge pile of snow. Most of the commissioners have seen this during their visits. I included photos in my letter today. That snow pile lasts through spring every year and town staff saw the remains of it yesterday, May 10th. We know the developer owns the existing Callahan Way and is responsible for plowing and snow storage.

1:15:31 To be clear, this is the existing Callahan Way snow storage requirement, not the four-acre parcel snow storage in the Villas 3 Project Plans and Staff Report. Those four acres have a completely separate snow storage problem that Amy was referencing earlier, as detailed in Sue Farley's letter this week. When you review SJV's record drawings and resolution, you will see that the existing Callahan Way's dedicated snow storage is located

1:15:59 on the Villas 3 parcel, where units 22 through 25 are proposed, and the resolution exactly matches the record drawings. As history, InterWest built SJV on its own land as their housing mitigation that enabled them to build the Westin.

1:16:17 Interwest permanently dedicated almost 8,000 square feet of the existing Callahan Way's required snow storage onto the first 55 feet of land directly south of SJV. The location was carefully planned and agreed to by the developer, Interwest, by town planners, and by the planning commission. Your predecessors voted unanimously to approve the application by Interwest, who wanted to...

1:16:45 Make this dedicated land on their property at the time. The storage location was very intentional. It complies with the snow storage code for a south-facing location. It's the ideal location at the bottom of the downhill Callahan Way for easy plowing and storage. The location provides a buffer zone for at least 75 feet between workforce housing and whatever eventually gets built to itself, currently planned for Villas 3. In exchange,

1:17:14 Interwest was allowed an exception to build with a setback of 10 feet on SJP's property rather than 20 feet. So as you can see, the resolution snow storage was planned very thoughtfully. Now by mistake, the villas three proposed units 22, 23, 24, and 25 are in the middle of the land that is dedicated for snow storage. This is obviously an error and it must be corrected.

1:17:42 Now, I believe it's an honest mistake. Having talked with Mark and having staff visited yesterday, there seemed to be a very sincere misunderstanding of the huge snow pile that wasn't there yesterday, but that has been there all winter long. So I believe it's an honest mistake, but albeit it's a very large mistake. So, in conclusion, the Villas 3 application, tentative tract plan, and

1:18:10 Thank you for your time. Thank you.

1:18:47 Any other public comment? Please. With the area code number was 714 ending in 1035, please unmute yourself and give your comments. We heard you for a moment, but now you're muted. Please give your comments. I missed all of that. She was saying that she couldn't see the diagrams and pictures on Zoom. During our presentations, we shared screens so the Zoom users could see it.

1:20:10 However, I think when members of the public are commenting and talking about, you know, locations, they can't see that, but they're not showing us any maps either, so I think we're all kind of in the same. Okay. Jade? Sorry. Michelle, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Yes, hi, I'm Michelle Lussier, and I own 74 Joaquin. I'm right behind the San Joaquin Villas.

1:20:40 I just want to let you know, I've been in Mammoth since 2005. The reason I bought the house on Joaquin is because I love Mammoth Lakes, the process, you know, raking leaves, well not leaves, pine needles, removing snow. I love Mammoth Lakes. I have lived and worked in Mammoth Lakes since 2005. The reason I bought on Joaquin, I had a choice between that house and one back on Pinecrest, which is a four-bedroom.

1:21:08 Would have been a much better investment, but I'm sorry, I love the ghetto. It's the historic district. It's an unbelievable community. And like I said, I've been there since 2005. And regarding this development, I'm sorry, I'm really emotional. I've been crying ever since Chelsea talked, because I feel the same way. And I respect.

1:21:30 The builder, Mark, I know it's your business. I work part-time in construction, but I just think it's kind of dense and overkill, and I'm talking in regards to buildings. Sorry, I'm nervous. 26, 27, and 32, and 33, they're right on top of the houses on Joaquin. I will lose my view. I'm going to lose my privacy. Those balconies are going to look right down on my bedroom.

1:21:58 You know, they're going to be up higher, my quality of life. I have worked so hard. I'm from a family of nine kids on the East Coast. I've worked hard for everything I have. And I decided that I wanted Mammoth Lakes to be my home. And I love my house. I rake the pine needles. I got one of the cleanest yards in the ghetto. I just love living there. And to have these, basically these upscale vacation rentals come in, it's just absolutely devastating.

1:22:28 I just please, I just please beg the commission to hear the people, hear the community of Mammoth Lakes. We're not part-time, is that just come up? We live here, we work here, we contribute to the community. One of the things that breaks my heart is, you know, I work at the Mogul and the owner can't even keep the place open seven days a week because of lack of staff. People cannot afford to live in Mammoth and now this development just bringing in more vacation rentals.

1:22:56 So one of the things I notice when I run on the bike path pretty much every day, because I love that area, the original obsidian units, they're so far away from the houses on Joaquin, there's a road, there's trees, they got to be, you know, 150 feet away. That's why there's no noise issues. And thank you for asking that, Commissioner Borrows, because they're far enough away.

1:23:19 Four buildings you have, 26 through 33, are just, they're so dense and they're so on top of our houses on Joaquin that it's unbelievably intrusive. Could you put two there? Could you make that a grass area? Like someone said, it would increase the value of it. Keep some nature in there. I'm going to miss the bears in my backyard.

1:23:42 So anyway, I just respectfully ask you to please not approve these plans until you augment those four buildings that are...

1:23:51 Well, the two buildings, it's 26, 27 and 32 and 33. They're right on top of the bike path. They're right in my backyard. I'm the one that's going to take the noise from the gate. I'm the house beside it. I don't know if you've noticed, but I had to put railroad ties up there because the fence ends 10 feet from where my property does. So I have people cutting through my property all the time to get to the bike path. And the way you're doing this fence, it's not going to resolve the issue. I'm just going to have a hug.

1:24:20 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:24:38 Money is going to be made here because I've heard that these are even more expensive than Snow Creek. Please wrap up your comments. I will. So if you can please just reduce those four houses in the corner to two and keep them away from the bike path and away from the residence of Joaquin, I would be forever grateful. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any more? That is all of the public comments. Anybody else from the audience want to submit public comment?

1:25:10 And I will close public comment. Another one popped up, sorry. Okay. As soon as I said no. Gina, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. My name is Gina Fariaski. I have submitted two written public comments already regarding the bears, and I just want to add, I'll try not to be redundant, but I just want to add, we need to do a better job at protecting our natural resources.

1:25:43 That includes forest, open spaces, plant and animal habitat, and water. Global warning, a global pandemic, extreme wildfires, extreme drought, a war in Europe, and the threat of nuclear war are indicative to how we use, abuse, and compete for resources. Local governments can start by taking a responsible role

1:26:13 Rather than using a 30-year-old environmental impact report as an excuse to continue business as usual. Mammoth does not need more luxury housing taking up precious and priceless wildlife habitat to sit vacant more than half of the year. That is wasteful. That is shameful. That's all. Thank you. Any more on Zoom? No.

1:26:46 Any more from the Suite Z? And I'm going to go ahead and close public comment. Sandra, would you and your team like to address some of the questions raised? Yes, we would. I think, do we want to start with the snow storage issue on Callahan? Sure. It addresses the snow storage on Callahan Way, and it does allow for provision of an alternative location. It states that...

1:27:23 The off-site snow storage area that is owned by the applicant shall remain exclusively for roadway snow storage unless an acceptable alternate off-site snow storage area be identified and approved by the public works and community. So given this, I think it would be possible to suggest a condition of approval that allows the applicant to submit a snow storage management plan similar to the way we have handled many other projects throughout town.

1:27:57 Suggest some language here once I work a little magic on the computer. Figure out how to share a screen with you. But I believe that we could allow them to submit a snow storage management plan to provide alternate snow storage area for Callahan. And that was called out in that condition of approval that Amy read. The next item, I think, maybe Alicia, could you?

1:28:27 respond to some of the CEQA issues that were raised by Jamie Pollack. Sandra and Chair, if I may real quick before Alicia answer a provided response. I was confused about Amy's response for the Callahan snow storage. Are you responding to Eric and Judith?

1:29:00 mentioned of the IntraWest resolution. Is that what your response? Yes. And so in fully reading the resolution condition of approval for that project, it does allow the proposal of an alternate off-site snow storage area for Callahan Way. So when IntraWest first, or when IntraWest provided a JV,

1:29:33 And that resolution indicated that specifically there was an alternative method that can be offered? Yes. Okay, thank you. And Amy, when you say off-site, we're talking about trucking snow out? Is that kind of what we're talking about? Or an alternate site? That would be one thing to infer from the comment. Trucking to the snow storage pit, trucking to an alternate site.

1:30:01 It could also be offsite, meaning on the Villas 3 parcel, should the applicant be able to figure out how to do that. Sandra? Yes, so I think we'll turn to Alicia, and then I think Andy has a response as well. Great, thank you, Sandra. I will just say that...

1:30:26 In Mr. Pellick's comments, he did disagree that the addendum is the appropriate document. He disagreed with the approach that was taken by the town here and believes that a subsequent EIR is required. And in response to that, I would say that a disagreement about approach is one that is fine to raise, but we need...

1:30:53 to understand what specifically

1:30:57 is faulty in the addendum and the additional environmental analysis that the town has prepared in order to meaningfully respond to that. And Mr. Pollack hasn't identified anything specifically in the addendum that is lacking or any of the conclusions that were reached that are not supported by substantial evidence in the record. So each of the conclusions that are contained within the addendum are supported by facts, expert opinions.

1:31:24 Supported by facts and reasonable assumptions predicated on facts, all of which are evidence under CEQA with respect to determining whether or not an impact would occur that is more severe or new as compared to what was analyzed in the 1991 EIR. So I do still believe that the information that is in the record before the commission today is complete and does comply with CEQA.

1:31:58 And I would just like to address Mr. Pollack's initial complaint that Chair Vanderhurst has a conflict of interest. Chair Vanderhurst does not have a conflict of interest. There are very specific state laws and FPPC regulations defining when a public official does have a conflict of interest. Those standards are not met in this case. As I explained to Mr. Pollack in a letter previously, Chair Vanderhurst could have a conflict if his personal finances were going to be affected by at least $500.

1:32:28 Chair Vanderhurst does work for MLT, but there's no link between this project and Chair Vanderhurst getting any additional money from MLT. The other way there could be a conflict is if this project wanted to generate a simply enormous amount of additional revenue for MLT, equal to at least 5% of its annual revenues, and it won't. The town has more than 3,200 registered short-term rental units. This project proposes 33, so even if you assume that all of them would be rented,

1:32:56 Thank you, Andy. Hey, Sandra, maybe somebody on your team could just kind of summarize one of the concerns that Lindsay brought up about.

1:33:26 How this parcel had been zoned for workforce housing at one time or had a certain component of it was zoned for workforce housing and why that situation has changed? Yep, so this project was originally built and intended for workforce housing. I think it was completed mid-2000s.

1:33:48 And due to the market changes at the time, those units ended up converting from affordable housing units to market rate units. I don't know, Nolan, if you can provide any additional kind of summary on that, but it was really a loss of that affordable housing after the project was completed. And so some of the units, I think, remained...

1:34:14 Deed restricted. I think that there's a number of units in that project that are deed restricted, but the majority of those units are now not deed restricted, and I don't know, Nolan, if you can add to that for me. Yes. Yeah, my question is about the Villa of Threes. Oh, I apologize. I remember we had a conversation in an earlier meeting where that was zoned, the Villa's three parcel was zoned in a certain way. Okay, sorry. I thought you were talking about silencing Villas. Certainly, I can respond to the no net loss.

1:34:46 So the general plan housing element requires that the town view land in town that could be used for affordable housing. So the general plan includes a map that shows a number of projects in town, land in town that could be used for affordable housing. So one of those lots is this current Villas 3 lot and some other lots include the parcel, the 25 acres of the parcel.

1:35:11 And the reason why we included the Villas 3 lot when we updated, when we did our housing element was because at one time in the past it had been discussed that this lot could be used for affordable housing. It was never required for affordable housing. It was never conditioned as affordable housing. But InterWest in their discussions had talked about this potentially being an affordable housing lot.

1:35:37 As this lot is moving forward for this project, it requires that we, the state requires that we re-evaluate our map, it's in our general plan housing element, to make sure that there is enough housing in our community to satisfy the regional housing needs allocation that is assigned to us by the state. So the state assigns every city in California a number of units, I think over the course of seven years, that you're supposed to try to help achieve.

1:36:06 The town doesn't actually have to build those units. We just have to basically get out of the way of developers to allow those units to occur. So because this lot is included in our housing element, we have to make a finding that there is adequate space in the rest of town to accommodate our regional housing needs allocation, which I think is 190 units. I can't quite remember. Around 180, 190 units. So we have included findings in this staff report.

1:36:34 in the resolution that meet that because we do have significant affordable space for affordable housing. We have 81 units under construction right now that will be delivered next year at the parcel. The parcel can accommodate anywhere between 450 and 580 units. So that is way outweigh exceeds the number of units that are assigned by the arena. So I don't know, Nolan, if you have anything to add to that, if that makes sense. It is somewhat complicated and a little bit confusing.

1:37:04 So there's this housing element requirement, and then there's also the applicants need to satisfy affordable housing requirements for their specific project, which they will be doing. So they will be paying an affordable housing fee, which will be used to fund our affordable housing program. And then we have this no net loss finding that we need to make in order to just say that we have additional space in town that can accommodate affordable housing. So it's a little bit complicated. Hopefully that makes sense.

1:37:35 Nolan, did you want to add anything on that? No, I think the only clarification is that no net loss doesn't require us to identify additional space, it just requires us to certify or affirm that the other sites identifying the housing element have the adequate space to accommodate the full arena, which they do. And that's an administrative decision by staff.

1:38:01 It's a finding that you have to make as a part of this approval, and we've included all of the finding language. Were there any other questions that came up during public comment that you guys would like to address? I don't think we have any other comments or anything else to respond to. Okay. Then I'm going to bring it back to the Commission for conversation, opinions, deliberation, any further questions that you may have. Why don't we go to the Zoom world first. Commissioner Kennedy, what are your thoughts?

1:38:36 Sure, I'll start. I have a couple thoughts. Thanks, Chairman Vanderhurst. First thing to say is that I discussed with Camille Miller and Lindsay Barksdale, both on this project, just to let everyone know, and also saw and read all the public comments from everyone, and I'm super appreciative for the amount of public comments that we got. I also had several meetings with Sandra Moberly and Michael Paterka on...

1:39:00 This project, trying to make sure I'm really wrapping my head around it. So thank you for getting me all that clarity. The thing that I keep coming back to with this project is that our job as planning commissioners is to review these applications to ensure that they are in line with the general plan and any other relevant planning documents and codes that we have before us. Like I said, I'm so appreciative of all the members of the public.

1:39:27 We submitted comments, came to meetings, and I understand that this has caused a lot of stress for people, so it's really unfortunate that people have had to go through this. One thing I wanted to ask for the people who did submit public comments is encourage you to keep submitting public comments both to us and to the town council, especially if there are issues that we heard today or in previous meetings that are really important to you on a town-wide basis. We are an advisory board to the town council.

1:39:56 So if we hear things frequently, we can advise the town council and we can advise staff to take direction or to bring us back some research and that sort of thing. So if people feel that, you know, several things that came up were we don't need more short-term rentals in this town or we don't need new developments. So if those things are important town-wide, I just encourage people to keep bringing those to us and to town council and make changes with the bodies that can actually make changes to the codes.

1:40:24 You know, governing documents that we're following. I just wanted to share that I feel the frustrations and disappointments. I don't, I can't find reason to deny this application. Happy to continue talking about it with commissioners in this deliberation period. One thing I want to say is I understand that our role and the town's role, we can't require any additional setback. I wish that we could. I wish that

1:40:50 This project was going to have more space between the two developments. And I trust and ask Mark that if you find that there's space to make additional setback and room between the developments while you're in the process of figuring things out, that you do that. I trust that you'll continue to be a good neighbor and figure this out. So I encourage that.

1:41:11 And I also want to say I appreciate the adjustments that the developer that Mark and his team have made to this project. I think each time it's come before us, it's had a little bit better reflection of what the neighborhood is looking for. Even the step back of the third floor feels like it makes a lot of sense and really fits this a lot better into the town's plans and codes. And from there, I'm happy to...

1:41:38 Share what I feel about the, I guess, four or five different approvals before us or bounce it back to other commissioners and circle back and I can share my thoughts on making a motion to go forward with this. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Chang, what are your thoughts? Thanks, Chair. I appreciate the applicant's work, in particular, the sit back.

1:42:13 adjustments and the size of the building reduction and the third floor recessed balcony area. I think this is a really difficult project for me to consider given that there is such a strong opinions from the community, in particular SJV.

1:42:46 members of the communities from there and the impact they will be subject to. However, it is difficult. You know, we don't own the view. We don't own, unfortunately, you know, we don't own some of the concerns that they talked about. And yes, it is a problem in my opinion.

1:43:19 That oftentimes we look at these projects and thinking that bringing additional TOT dollars or attracting second homeowners to the community is a better solution than supporting the members of our communities. And it's a very difficult decision on this particular project.

1:43:50 And at the same time, I can understand that, you know, if you look at just simply looking at some of the numbers, for example, the intensity that has been reduced dramatically based on previous environmental studies versus what the applicant currently is offering. I mean, we're talking about 100 unit difference. That's a big change. And so it's hard to

1:44:21 Also ignore that, you know, some of those numbers. And, you know, what the one thing I would say to the applicant about the Callahan gate is that I think that gate might be a little too far out on the property boundary line. I think perhaps, you know, that needs to be

1:44:55 Have a further recess into the property itself versus sitting out on the boundary line. So that's all the comments I have at this time. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Burroughs, do you have some thoughts? Thank you. When I voted no on this project last time, I really felt like we needed to take a pause and look at this a little bit further. I heard your concerns. I've read all your emails.

1:45:26 I've read all your letters. I've taken phone calls. I've walked the property. And I feel like we have done our due diligence on this to better understand the project, not rush it through. And I feel like the public process, with your voices, your concerns, have made this project better. And it's made more things palpable on this project. It's not perfect. There's no project that's ever going to be perfect.

1:45:55 This developer owns his property. He has the right to build on his property. He has, he could have 131 units. Instead, he has 33. Can you imagine what 131 units would look like there? I'm grateful that it's only 33. I have really taken this to heart. I have looked around, driven around this town, looked at different neighborhoods with different setbacks.

1:46:19 I've looked at different houses that are close together. I've looked at south-facing houses that are shaded by other houses. And it's not just a San Joaquin Villas issue. There's houses all over this community that have the same problem. I've talked to staff. I've asked about setbacks. I asked if we have done the right thing, if our setbacks need to be greater in general.

1:46:48 We have gone from five foot to 20 feet over a period of time to increase the space between houses and buildings. And I really feel like we have done the best that we can do here. Again, not everything is perfect. This developer has tried to listen to the concerns of the residents and to meet their needs as much as possible.

1:47:18 Every change he makes costs him a ton of money. It does not affect me at all, but we have to listen to both sides. Our job is to be an advisory body, like Jessica said, and we have to listen and we have to make sure we're doing due diligence, not only to our community, but to the people who own their land and want to build on their land. They have those rights too, and we have to look at both sides.

1:47:45 And I really think that we have done that here. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Pretty much every thought and opinion I was going to express has been already summarized by my fellow commissioners from the idea of a compromise, from the adjustments that the developer has made to the project. So I don't want to belabor this any more than everyone's time will allow. So like I said, all of my thoughts and opinions have been summarized.

1:48:18 So with that, would anybody like to put forth a motion? I'm happy to, but not sure of the language. Maybe staff could help me out because I know there was a couple of different conditions. Sure. Commissioner Kennedy, we will, Michael will share his screen so we have the language on the screen there.

1:48:47 And then we were looking at additional conditions as read by Amy regarding the gate and regarding the snow storage for Callahan. We can read those conditions back to you if you would like. Was the landscaping included as an additional condition or not? I think it's already a condition. The landscaping is already a condition. Correct. The additional landscaping. Yes. And just for full clarity, that is still subject to the town.

1:49:18 Town code in terms of what is planted in between. Yes. Okay, go ahead. So the recommended action is on your screen, and I can read the first condition. Prior to the issuance of the building permit, applicant shall submit a snow removal storage management plan for the Callahan Way access parcel in accordance with municipal code section 17.36.110.3 A.

1:49:51 to the Community and Economic Development Department and Public Works Department for approval. The plan shall be in the form of a recorded document mutually agreed to between the property owner and the town and shall describe features such as, but not limited to, location of snow storage areas, the method of snow hauling, frequency of pickups, pickup areas, haul routes, hours of hauling operations, and snow deposit areas. This plan shall be included in the CCNRs prior to final map.

1:50:20 Approval by town staff. And then can you just go to the other condition? So then the other conditions on your screen here, which would say prior to the issuance of grading permit, applicant shall coordinate final gate design, including location, configuration, and any appropriate signage to the satisfaction of the Public Works Department in order to meet the Municipal Code operational requirements, including provision of adequate turnaround space. So I believe those were the two additional conditions of approval that we discussed.

1:50:53 Perfect. Thank you. And I have one other question. I have a couple of things that I'd love to direct staff on that are separate from this motion. Should that be after the motion or should I share them now? Is it relevant to this agenda item, Commissioner Kennedy? It is, yeah. Then why don't we talk about them now, please? Perfect. So my three things on my list about staff was hoping that similar to the residents in project traffic.

1:51:20 Concerns that we had talked about, wondering if staff can consider that intersection that was brought up in comments about Frontage, Main Street and Callahan, and maybe include that in traffic discussions that we would have next time, just that intersection being an issue. Second was hoping to encourage staff to avoid construction traffic going through Dorrance. Sounds like we've covered that, but that's my pitch for it. And then third was to, I think Sandra had mentioned,

1:51:49 Engage the public on final approvals of those documents, and I would like to encourage staff to do that if the commission feels like that's the direction to go. And those were the landscaping and turnaround gate operating plans. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Do you still wish to make a motion? Yes, happy to. Can it go back on my screen? It disappeared. We're pulling it up right now.

1:52:22 Thank you. It takes a minute. Thank you. I will make a motion to adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolutions making the required CEQA, State No Net Lost Law, State Subdivision Map Act, and Municipal Code Findings, and approving tentative tract map 21-001, use permit 22-002, use permit 21-001, design review 21-001.

1:53:00 And adjustment 21-006 with conditions as recommended by staff. And that covers the two additional conditions. Including the two conditions that I read aloud. Okay. Do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Commissioner Chang, Commissioner Kennedy, none? Jamie, we have a vote, please. Commissioner Chang? No. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes.

1:53:36 Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Passes 3-1. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. I think I'm going to recommend a 10-minute break now to get everyone a chance to stretch their legs. I'm sorry? Sure, 5-minute break works for me. So I've got 3-52. Let's get back here just before 4 o'clock, please. Thank you. Found it? Yeah, thank you. That's the...

1:58:08 Yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah. On Zoom? Sandra, do you want me to wait for Andy or? Okay. Got it. All right, everybody, I'm going to call this meeting back to order.

2:01:34 We're going to move to our second agenda item during the public hearing. Do we still have Commissioner Chang and Commissioner Kennedy? There's Commissioner Kennedy. I'm here. And Commissioner Chang. Thank you. All right. 4.2 is consideration of tentative tract map TTM 22-002, use permit UPA 22-001.

2:02:04 And major design review, 22-001, for approval of the Limelight Hotel Development Project located at the northwest corner of Canyon Boulevard and Lake Mary Road. And I believe Kim is our staff contact today. Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. And just before Kim starts, a note that Commissioner Chang is conflicted out of this item due to his ownership in a business that is adjacent to this project.

2:02:33 He will not be participating. Do we have Greg back on then? Greg is back on. I believe he's on and he's unmuted, but he doesn't have his video shared, but he is not conflicted out of this item and is available to participate. Greg, can you just confirm you're with us? I am here. Thank you. With that, I'll hand it over to. Thank you. Good afternoon. Let me just share my screen. So this is the public hearing for consideration of the Limelight Hotel entitlement application.

2:03:22 The applicant is the Aspen Skiing Company and the property owner is Limelight Mammoth LLC. The project site is located at the northwest corner of Lake Mary Road and Canyon Boulevard. The project is comprised of seven individual vacant parcels with a combined area of 6.91 acres. The site is forested with sloping topography and some existing areas of disturbance where the site has

2:03:54 been historically accessed and used for construction staging in the past. The entire project site is located within the North Village specific plan area and is zoned Plaza Resort and specialty lodging. The general plan land use designation is North Village specific plan. The site surroundings, this is just a site context slide and the

2:04:24 It gives you an idea of the forested nature of the site and the upward slope from the street frontages. The abutting property to the west is developed with the Helios South condominiums. Property to the north is developed with the Westin Monashay condominium hotel. Abutting property to the southwest is developed with the Mammoth View Villas condominiums. And properties to the east across Canyon Boulevard include the Village Plaza, the Gondola Building,

2:04:54 The 8050 condominiums, fireside condominiums and a real estate office. The project under consideration today is phase one of potentially two phases of development. Phase one is a six story 185,754 square foot condominium hotel, which will be called the Limelight Hotel. The hotel features a mix of

2:05:23 True hotel rooms and residential uses consisting of 151 hotel room accommodations and 15 for sale residential condominium units. Parking for the development is located within an understructure parking garage that can accommodate up to 179 vehicles with permanent full-time valet staff managing parking within that structure. Amenities are oriented to hotel guests.

2:05:52 and residential owners and include a hotel lobby, hotel lobby and bar, town hall dining area, living room, meeting and conference rooms, kids area, a ski club lounge, fitness center, outdoor pool, an outdoor pool and jacuzzi deck and other outdoor seating and activity areas. The project includes the

2:06:19 Development of a geothermal well system to provide a renewable source of heat and electricity solely for the use within the project site. The proposed condominium hotel use of the site is a permitted use in the PR and SL zones of the North Village specific plan. And the proposed use of geothermal energy on the site is supported by the North Village specific plan conservation and open space element. Under that category.

2:06:47 Within the land use and energy standards, that section states that passive solar features are encouraged in the design of all developments within the North Village and that the use of alternative energy sources such as geothermal or solar should be incorporated if practical in all major development proposals such as heating, pedestrian areas, space heating and snow melting where feasible.

2:07:20 So the purpose of the public hearing today is to consider approval of the entitlement application for the Limelight Hotel development. There are four components of the entitlement application, which include a tentative tract map, and the PEDC is requested to consider whether the TTM is consistent with the state subdivision map act. A use permit is required, so determining whether the proposed use

2:07:49 meets the required findings pursuant to the municipal code, and a designer view, and CEQA. So the CEQA determination will be whether the proposed project is consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act. So I'll walk through each of those in greater detail. The proposed tentative tract map will result in two lots to provide separate lots for phase one and phase two.

2:08:18 Lot one will be comprised of four acres and will be further subdivided into 15 residential condominium units within the limelight hotel footprint. Affirmative findings of fact must be made consistent with the state subdivision map act and that includes that the proposed map is consistent with applicable general plan and specific plans, that the design or improvement of the proposed subdivision is consistent with applicable general and specific plans.

2:08:49 The site is physically suitable for the type of development. The site is physically suitable for the proposed density of development. The design of the subdivision or the proposed improvements are not likely to cause substantial environmental damage or substantially and unavoidably injure fish or wildlife or their habitat. The design of the subdivision and types of improvements is not likely to cause serious health problems.

2:09:16 And finally, the design of the subdivision and the type of improvements will not conflict with easements acquired by the public at large for access through or use of the property within the proposed subdivision. So in the draft resolution prepared, affirmative findings for these required areas has been made. And additionally, a use permit is required for the project because the use includes the creation of 15 residential condominium units.

2:09:49 The hotel use is permitted within the zoning district. However, the NBSP development and design standards basically establishes a minimum parcel size for the various zoning districts. And in this case, the PR zone establishes a minimum 20,000 square foot parcel size and a 15,000 square foot parcel size within the SL district.

2:10:21 Since subdivisions for condominium uses and other common interest developments involve the creation of additional parcels that would be smaller than those established minimum parcel sizes, a use permit is required to approve the parcels for a condominium subdivision. So three findings of approval are required to approve the use permit application. They are whether the proposed use

2:10:49 with all applicable sections of the general plan and title 17 and is consistent with the north village specific plan. Whether the proposed use and the conditions under which it would be operated or maintained will not be detrimental to the public health and safety nor materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity and that the commission shall make other such findings as deemed necessary to support approval or denial of the proposed.

2:11:20 use affirmative findings for these areas have have been included in the draft resolution. And then the last permit application is for a major design review. Major design review applications for projects that are deemed significant by the community and economic development department require review by the advisory design panel prior to consideration by the planning and economic development commission.

2:11:51 The role of the ADP is to provide impartial professional feedback to town staff and the applicant on site planning and building design based on the applicable development standards and design guidelines. ADP recommendations are typically used to make changes that improve a project's conformance with the applicable guiding documents, and in this case, those documents are the North Village specific plan and the village design guidelines. So we held an ADP meeting on March 7th.

2:12:22 2022 to consider the project design. The ADP provided consensus comments and recommended modifications to better meet the intent of the village design guidelines. The applicant has modified the project in response to those and has included a second pedestrian access provided off of Canyon Boulevard via a stairway. They have added festoon lights.

2:12:52 Over the outdoor event areas on the pedestrian promenade level, which was intended to provide a transition from the pedestrian space up to the building facade. The applicant has added awnings provided above the extended upper level balconies. Tie back rods as a architectural detail have been added to all extended balconies to

2:13:26 to show structural detail and express support and attachment to the building wall. One of the colors proposed for the siding for the facade has been eliminated. There was a very light gray color and it was recommended that it be eliminated to simplify the color palette for the facade. And finally, the applicant has improved the roof design at the north end of the building.

2:13:55 So from these images, the top is the final design that's being proposed that incorporates all of the recommendations that are provided by ADP. The very bottom rendering was the first, the middle of this new design and staff commented that the color palette was too cool. So they did warm that up and add some additional detail to the stone base and ADP reviewed the middle.

2:14:26 So the exterior color and material boards that you see, they were originally submitted in digital format, mostly because we were having virtual meetings at that point. And once we did receive the physical color material samples, staff met with two of the ADP panelists that indicated they would want to comment on the physical samples. And based on staff's review and the additional review by those two ADP,

2:15:10 Thank you. Thank you.

2:15:38 to be included that would ensure the design is consistent with the North Village design standards and ADP recommendations. I'll read through these conditions that are recommended. The color and finish for the anodized aluminum screen surrounding visible portions of the parking garage shall be changed to a darker color such as a dark bronze and shall have a non-reflective finish. And this would be replacing a very light

2:16:09 Almost just unfinished metal color that does have some reflective qualities. The second one is the color of the proposed drive-it ephist with wood grain finish. Siding materials shall be changed to a darker wood tone with wood grain finish that has less orange peach tone. The third is that the applicant shall provide a three foot by three foot mock-up of the proposed stone material and installation to provide a realistic repeat.

2:16:41 Representation for review and approval by the Community and Economic Development Director. This was requested because we were provided with one piece of stone, which didn't really give a detailed depiction of what it would look like installed on the wall. It was also recommended that the applicant shall provide a detailed elevation of the proposed retaining wall located at the corner of Canyon Boulevard and Lake Mary Road.

2:17:17 And this would be intended to ensure that the design diminishes the appearance of the overall height of that wall and provides pedestrian scale as recommended by ADP. And finally, the applicant shall provide the proposed gate or roll-up door design for the service entrance portal off Canyon Boulevard for review and approval. So in reviewing the proposed site plan prior to presenting the project to ADP,

2:17:53 Staff went through and confirmed that the proposed project would meet the applicable development standards. So that includes project density, site coverage, building area, setbacks, parking, location of access, location of parking, and all of that. And I did include a consistency table, table three in your staff reports.

2:18:22 which identify each of the applicable development standards and how the project complies with those standards. So based on that, the project is found to be consistent with all of the applicable zoning requirements of the North Village specific plan for the Plaza Resort and specialty lodging zones. And so for the major design review application, I've listed the required findings for approval. I can read through them fairly quickly.

2:18:58 But we were able to make affirmative findings for approval in your staff report and in the draft resolution for all of these topic areas. And so they start with the project is consistent with the applicable standards and requirements of the municipal code. The project is consistent with the general plan and any applicable specific plan or master plan. The project is consistent with the town of Mammoth Lakes design guidelines. The project is consistent with the

2:19:28 Additional design criteria, and those include that the site and building design elements, including the architectural style, size, design, quality, use of building materials, and similar elements combine together an attractive and visually cohesive manner that is applicable with and complements the desired architectural and or aesthetic character of the area and a mountain resort community.

2:19:58 and encourages increased pedestrian activity and promotes compatibility among neighboring land uses. Second one is that the design of streetscapes, including street trees, lighting, and pedestrian furniture is consistent with the character of commercial districts and nearby residential neighborhoods. That parking areas are located, designed, and developed to foster and implement the planned mobility system for the area, buffer surrounding land uses.

2:20:27 Minimize visibility, prevent conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians and cyclists, minimize stormwater runoff and the heat island effect and achieve a safe, efficient and harmonious development. Down-directed and shielded lighting and lighting fixtures are designed to complement buildings, be of appropriate scale, provide adequate light over walkways and parking areas to create a sense of pedestrian safety, minimize light.

2:20:58 So the proposed

2:21:37 Geothermal system for the project would involve the installation of two geothermal wells, a production well and an injection well at the Limelight Hotel site to serve as a source of renewable energy to solely serve the uses on site. The proposed geothermal system would provide heat and electricity.

2:22:02 And the two drilled geothermal wells would connect to the existing underground geothermal reservoir located between 1,400 to 2,000 feet below ground surface. The production well would extract geothermal fluids to the surface while the injection well would pump cooled geothermal fluid back into the reservoir to maintain the reservoir pressure. The geothermal wells would have cemented casing through the shallow warm water aquifer.

2:22:32 and any other shallow potable aquifers to eliminate the possibility of interaction with the aquifer that is used for municipal water. The project phases include site preparation, geothermal well drilling, geothermal well testing, and ongoing geothermal well operations, which are regulated by CalGEM, which is the state agency that oversees geothermal operations.

2:23:00 The CEQA Addendum identifies the required permits for the proposed project, which includes permits for the drilling, operation, and permanent sealing and closure at the end of the well, wait, at the end of the well's useful life under state requirements and procedures of CalGEM, and also includes MCWD and Mono County well permit requirements. In addition to any grading permit requirements,

2:23:33 from the town. So for the CEQA analysis that was required, with the exception of the proposed renewable direct use geothermal system that is proposed to offset the use of other fuels for building systems, the Limelight Hotel application is consistent with the Mammoth Hillside project that was analyzed in the Mammoth Hillside Addendum, which was approved in 2017. The proposed geothermal well system is the subject of the CEQA Addendum that was prepared for the Limelight Hotel project.

2:24:08 And for the purpose of this new analysis, the proposed project modification, which is the geothermal well system, it was compared to the certified 1999 supplemental program EIR development scenario and the approved Mammoth Hillside Addendum development scenario. I did go through the permitting requirements that would still be in place even with the approval of this addendum.

2:24:38 for the entitlement applications. And the conclusion of the addendum supports the conclusion that the proposed addition of the geothermal well system to the proposed limelight hotel development would not result in any new significant environmental effects or a substantial increase in the severity of previously identified significant effects. No new information has become available and no substantial changes to the circumstances.

2:25:07 circumstances under which the project was being undertaken since the certification of the 1999 Supplemental Program EIR and the Mammoth Hillside Addendum has occurred. There are no new measures, no new mitigation measures required and no new alternatives available that would substantially reduce the environmental effects beyond those previously described in the certified SPEIR and the Mammoth Hillside Addendum.

2:25:40 So additionally, we wanted to touch on the housing mitigation requirements for this project. The project was reviewed for consistency with the affordable housing goals and policies in the North Village specific plan and the town zoning code. And the limelight hotel project was found to be consistent with the NBSP objectives and policies because the project applicant has indicated that they will pay an in-loop fee the current

2:26:09 affordable housing in Luffy at the town's current rates. This fee will be placed in a separate fund and will be used to administer, subdivise, subsidize, or develop workforce housing. I've included the formula on the right-hand side at the bottom of that table. The table is our current fee that would apply based on the use. So we have 15.

2:26:37 Residential condominium units that are at the fee at the top, which is $6,420 per unit. And then we have the 151 hotel rooms that are proposed that would be charged the $4,280 per room. So the resulting amount for that calculation is $742,500 some odd dollars. It's cut off because of $580. Thank you.

2:27:10 So that would be the housing mitigation required for development of the proposed phase one. A public notice for this public hearing was mailed out to 680 property owners and it was also published in the sheet on April 30th and May 7th. We did receive verbal comments from the Mammoth Community Water District and during this meeting we received this as well. A written letter regarding concerns about approval of the proposed geothermal.

2:27:45 Well system as part of the project with the level of secret review that was conducted. We also received two other written public comments from owners at the Westin Monoshe. One of those letters included a compilation of comments from other owners at the Westin during and some of the primary concerns that were expressed in those letters included concerns about noise level.

2:28:15 That might come from the roof-mounted mechanical equipment. There are also concerns about visibility of the mechanical equipment from the west end unit, the lower end of the building on the north end. And finally, the other concerns regarding the building height and potential impacts to views, among some other things. With that, based on the affirmative findings for applications,

2:28:57 Staff recommends the Planning and Economic Development Commission, adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings, and approving tentative tract map, TTM 22-002, use permit, UPA 22-001, and major design review, DR 22-001, with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. That concludes my presentation.

2:29:28 If you have any questions for me, I'm available. The applicant team is on Zoom. Sure. So I think I'm going to ask the commission to hold off on their questions for staff until after the applicant team has had a chance to address us. Who's the lead off hitter? That's me, Andy Reid here. Happy to have the opportunity to speak with everyone. Really appreciate the time. Let me share my screen for a moment.

2:30:09 I just wanted to give everybody a little bit of an overview about the company, Asken Skiing Company and the Little Nell Hotel Group, as well as the Limelight brand and touch on our goals for Limelight Mammoth, hopefully, to provide everybody with a little bit of context into the property and what we're hoping to do here. Again, thank you for everybody's time and appreciate the opportunity. The Little Nell Hotel Group.

2:30:36 is the hospitality division of Aspen Skiing Company. We're privately held and we own, operate, brand, manage properties under the Little Mel brand as well as the Limelight brand. We've got properties in Aspen, Ketchum, Snowmass and starting construction shortly in Boulder, Colorado and hopefully at some point in the future in Mammoth.

2:31:02 And we are long-term holders. We're not looking to build and sell, which is part of the reason that we're designing a hotel instead of a condo hotel primarily. So with 151 hotel rooms, they are true hotel keys supplemented by a few residential units, but primarily at the end of the day, it's 151 room true hotel that we hope to own forever.

2:31:28 The Little Nell Hotel Group, a little bit about us as well. Sustainability is extremely important to us, not just from an environmental standpoint, but from a community standpoint as well. We were recently awarded the Governor's Citizenship Medal in Colorado. We've been involved in every piece of climate legislation in Colorado since 2004. We've developed over time. We've been in business.

2:31:56 quite some years, but over time, I've developed, and now own, 1,000 employee housing beds. We recently finished one that's an all-electric building with 150 beds and continuing to look to develop more. We were pretty innovative, we think, in terms of coal methane transfer plant that we invested in to convert waste methane into electricity.

2:32:21 And we've got a variety of funds that supplement support community initiatives in the markets that we operate in. The property in Boulder, similar to the property in Mammoth, hopefully, is intended to be an all-electric hotel. And the Limelight Snowmass, which is our most recently opened property, was featured on the Urban Land Institute's most recent sustainability issue. With respect to Mammoth,

2:32:50 It's 151 true hotel rooms, 15 residences, food and beverage, parking that exceeds the required level of parking. And we hope really at the end of the day this translates into a hub of sorts. We're right on the bus line, right across from the gondola and we're hoping that this property becomes a focal point within the community and that guests and residents and members

2:33:20 of the community can come here, park once, or hopefully never park at all, and access all of the best that Mammoth has to offer. We do intend to be all electric, which we're really excited about, because as the grid gets greener, our property will inherently be along for the ride and get greener as well, and we're hoping to explore geothermal, as Kim had mentioned.

2:33:47 Subject to acquiring all the permits. And we're also hoping to facilitate conversations with the town around the potential bridge, which we think would be a good enhancement to this area. So not our project necessarily, but hopefully something that we can help facilitate in some small way. We bought the land in 2019. Again, all electric and hopefully geothermal.

2:34:18 We understand we've got to get a variety of permits and are, of course, willing to do that. I'm looking forward to the process. And I touched on this as well with respect to the CEQA documentation, and I think Kim did. But as it relates to the Westin, we did present our plans to their Homeowners Association roughly a year ago.

2:34:46 And part of the design of our building is actually a function of the Westin's height covenant. So the Westin has a covenant on our property that limits the height of the building in front of their building. So the way that our architects have designed the property with respect to its height is a function of what the Westin sort of limited us to with the height covenant.

2:35:15 And just wanted to say thanks to the ADP. We did have multiple meetings with the ADP and they provide a really great input that I think improved the project at the end of the day. The town of Mammoth and their staff are working so hard on this and we're looking forward to being part of the community. So a couple just pictures of other limelight properties really briefly. The limelight aspen, limelight ketchup.

2:35:45 and limelight snowmass. So we're really excited about the opportunity and looking forward to getting going, hopefully. And everybody's welcome to reach out to me with questions, comments, concerns. My email's up here. Feel free. Happy to answer any questions that might be out there. I did want to just give a quick opportunity to our architect, WATG, to

2:36:14 Just touch on the site plan a little bit so that everybody can get an understanding of how we're oriented. I'll stop my screen share. Dan, if you wouldn't mind. Hello, my name is Dan Patton. I'm with WHU Architecture. I'm the senior project architect on this job and project manager. I am very happy to be here today and I thank the Planning Commission for taking time to listen to us and consider these designs.

2:36:47 This effect on the village area there in Mammoth. I'd also like to thank Public Works Department. Amy has been great in helping us out, Fire Department as well, as well as the Planning Department. Kim and Sandra have been very helpful over the last two years and very responsible in helping us to meet guidelines and comply with city or town regulations. So thank you very much, everyone, for all your assistance and efforts on this project. I want to get a quick...

2:37:17 Understanding of the design of the project. At WJG, we tried to provide a contemporary alpine architecture in a California spirit that draws upon the nature of the town of Mammoth and the surrounding areas from the minarets to the surrounding mountains. We've been encouraged to provide a warm palette utilizing materials from neighboring buildings.

2:37:44 including the stone and the upper wood levels. We would look to break up the overall mass of the building to try to show individual smaller massing of buildings as a distinctive providing massing for a human scale and feel of different buildings moving in and out along the whole Canyon Boulevard. We're looking to provide a good

2:38:12 Guest experience as well as public experience from that pedestrian level so that people are invited, as Andy had mentioned, to make it a hub area for people to come participate and be a part of community activities and be involved in the area to enhance the area of the whole Mammoth public area. Overall, on the site, we're oriented to fit within the

2:38:44 the steep mountainside area and to do that we've placed the building gently on the site and extended it more than what the required setbacks are for the site. We're looking to provide excellent views for our guests but also maintain the existing views as outlined by the covenants that have been set in the area. We are working closely with staff to provide

2:39:15 an environment and a plan that fits very well into the overall neighborhood and provide a living room for the overall community. Just to give a quick outline of the floor plan, the typical limelight hotels provide a town hall atmosphere that allows guests and other public to come in and be a part of the

2:39:46 The environment and feel of the whole facility. The programming does provide for meeting space, to provide outlets for people to have events and utilize the program that's within the facility to provide skis or bicycles for different activities, but also kind of a private atmosphere as well for guests and for residents as needed. But overall, we're hoping to

2:40:16 Help improve the overall environment and add to it and make it a better, more economically sustainable and good place to be at and improve the quality of life in the area. So we're here to help answer any questions from the council, the commission and from the community as needed. So please let us know any questions or anything and we'll be able to answer.

2:40:50 Was there anyone else from the team that wanted to address the commission or you guys just want to start fielding questions? We're available to start answering any questions. Awesome. So at this point, I'd like to ask the commission if they have any questions for either staff or for the applicant team. Now is a great time. Greg, since you are our new rival, why don't you lead us off? We know if Greg is still on the line. He's still on the line. He's just muted. Greg, I think you're muted.

2:41:38 Commissioner Kennedy, while Greg is figuring out his Zoom settings, why don't you start off? Sure. My only questions, I guess first I want to say thank you to the applicant and to staff for working on this. My questions are related to the letters of public comment. Oh, there's Greg. Greg, we'll come back to you, Greg. Don't mute yourself. Just hang tight. No worries. So the...

2:42:06 The one was a letter from the Mammoth Community Water District about their concerns about the geothermal well, and then the other one was the Westin homeowners being concerned about the roof. I guess I'm wondering what, for the Westin concern, first of all, what are we looking at in terms of codes or guidelines for the top of a building? I don't think I've seen an issue with the roof of a building before, so I guess maybe we'll start there.

2:42:36 Staff maybe have any insight on the roof guidelines? I'm going to address that. So the mechanical equipment and top itself would be required to be painted a dark. At this point, it isn't clear that any additional screening is provided to surround themselves. So if the applicant could either confirm that, we could consider any other ideas.

2:43:22 Perfect. But it sounds like there's nothing the town requires in terms of the mechanical equipment and stuff that's not being met with this proposal. Right. So usually for rooftop mechanical equipment, it requires that it is screened from view of the pedestrians, so from street view. In this case, because the parapet walls are tall enough to screen them from street view, we're really only dealing with views from buildings that are taller.

2:43:54 And the standards really aren't written to apply in those situations, but the North Village Specific Plan guidelines do specifically require that they be painted a darker color. Got it. Okay, thank you. And then my second was the, just curious if staff can speak a little bit to the Water District letter that I think it just came through like an hour ago or hour and a half. And I guess curious where that,

2:44:27 I don't know. I guess my question is curious if you guys have thoughts on the Water District letter and what you suggest moving on from here with that in mind. Yes, Commissioner Kennedy, we can, I can maybe just provide a brief introduction.

2:44:59 The project before you today is the entitlement for the hotel project, and geothermal is a component of that hotel project. So we are not issuing a separate use permit for geothermal. It's simply a component of this hotel. If this project is approved, the applicant, as been mentioned a couple times, will need to go through subsequent permitting through CalGEM.

2:45:27 which is the state agency that regulates geothermal wells, and any other necessary permitting, whether it be with the water district or the county. Regarding the CEQA questions that were raised by MCWD, I'd like to turn that over to Alicia Winterswick, our CEQA attorney from Vespas Krieger, who can respond to those comments.

2:45:50 Thank you, Sandra. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy, Chair and the Balance of the Planning Commission. With respect to the district's letter and the process that is forthcoming, I think what's important to keep in mind is that for purposes of the hotel project, the town is the lead agency for CEQA purposes. So we are making a determination or...

2:46:13 The Planning Commission will make a determination today with respect to the addendum as lead agency for that component of the project.

2:46:23 When the applicant moves forward to CalGEM and or to the district to seek permits from those agencies, they will be seeking those permits from those agencies as responsible agencies because those agencies have some permit authority over the project, but they don't control the bulk of the project, meaning the bulk of the hotel project for which this geothermal.

2:46:46 resource would be incorporated. So in conducting their analysis under state secret guidelines section 15096, the agencies have an obligation to review the environmental document that we have prepared as lead agency and to make a determination on their own as to whether or not they believe that document is sufficient to give clearance for them to issue the permits they need to issue.

2:47:12 In the event that the responsible agency, either CalGEM or the district, believe that our CEQA document is lacking, then they can fill in those holes at that time in a couple of ways. There are several ways that are outlined in the guidelines, but the two most common ways are either to supplement the document by doing further environmental review under 15162 of the state CEQA guidelines or to take over as lead agency.

2:47:39 They can say, well, we're the lead with respect to the geothermal component, and we are going to just handle CEQA ourselves for that piece. And there is procedure in the guidelines for them to do that. So to the extent that the district does express interest in the project and concerns about the analysis and specifics about...

2:48:01 Technical information that is within its jurisdiction and purview, it will have an opportunity most certainly to do that analysis and it is really the body that is most appropriately suited to conduct that analysis because it has all of that technical information, it has its urban water management plan, it can look into it and see, you know, what other resources are available in the area that might be impacted by this well, etc. So I think

2:48:28 From the town's perspective, we appreciate and definitely understand where the district is coming from, but this is not the end of the process. There is much more to come. Perfect. Thank you so much. That's all for me. Did that answer your question, Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah. If I'm not mistaken, what I just heard is no matter the outcome decided today, there will be further stops along the way where this will be re-evaluated. Is that correct?

2:49:01 Yes, that's correct, Chair. Thank you. Greg, you're up. All right, let's try this again. Okay, so there will be further stops along the way. The geothermal is handled by the state. Are there any required stops locally? You know, I understood that the district and the county will have their crack for their appropriate times.

2:49:30 But what are their appropriate times? In other words, if they, if the county and the water district come up with issues, is it in their purview to stop that well, or is that outside their purview? I would, you know, there are members of the Mammoth Community Water District here to provide public comment on this item, so I would defer to them. It's my understanding that they have some sort of a permit process to grant a permit in this area.

2:50:00 And CalGem also has the ability to review and approve the permit for geothermal as well. So those permits are the future review authority and it gives them the ability to review it and to consider it throughout their process. So, sorry, does that make sense, Commissioner Eckert? It does, but I'm still vague on whose process is whose. In other words, I don't have a problem with us approving a CEQA idea on a...

2:50:29 on a building and a hotel. But, you know, if this is going to be a new geothermal plant in the middle of town, you know, I would say that's somewhat of a change and ought to be looked at accordingly. I would also like to see that, and they have, they've indicated such, but that it'd be required that whatever geothermal generation they do do does not exceed

2:50:56 Their use does not get sold to anybody, does not get expanded, that this is something solely to keep them green and not to be a revenue source. And that's our understanding currently of the proposed use of geothermal for this project. I'd just like to see our understanding become a requirement. Before you jump in, Garrett, Andy, can you address the issue of possible excess energy being sold?

2:51:24 Yeah, we're not looking to profit off of geothermal in any way. We're just trying to be as environmentally aware and conscious as we possibly can. There's not an intent to sell utilities in any manner or fashion. Would it be appropriate for that to be a condition? Fine with me. So, and just one additional point is if the Limelight Hotel were to sell power or

2:51:57 Got it. So there was another check and balance. Okay. Garrett, please, just introduce yourself. Sure. I'm Garrett Heigert. I'm the district engineer. We address the future permit. The CEQA document, the addendum, does address that. And CalGEM is, there's a reference in there to Mammoth Hill about after business hours yesterday. I thought that mistakenly that the water district did have that being.

2:53:19 said, you know, the concern about potable drinking water reached down into all of it, all of that. In essence, it's what they're proposing to do is extract and then re-inject. It's essentially a mini format is doing CD4, but both town and only about 12 are production well set woodside source of. So that is one of our concerns because the water to see appropriate negation in this project to make.

2:55:01 in the process. Also, you know, we have been provided information on details of this project just basically as when you got it, I got it. I got it out of the packet as I was reading through pretty much. So we've been responding to understand the details of the proposed project and also reaching out to CalGEM to understand their supplemental CEQA process.

2:55:42 There can ensure that our concerns are addressed. Maybe just hang tight. I've got a couple of more commissioners that want to have some questions answered. Commissioner Eckert, did you have any other questions? I will give somebody else a shot. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs.

2:57:30 Stress test specification before this thing ramps up into full production. Stakeholders there to on wells to what relation. Geothermal aquifers are really about a balance of pressures. They have pressure imbalances. Water can, it's a bunch of fractured rock in between. So if there were pressure imbalances, there is the potential that it's not just blocked off down below. If the wells are constructed well with good.

2:58:25 I'm hopeful that this process we can really work with CalGEM accomplish here but because we have not had a chance to really

2:59:09 We include a note in the mitigation measures that

2:59:51 All permits that are required to be obtained are obtained. So CalGEM is the state agency responsible for geothermal investigation, and they go through a whole separate process. So we can't really, I guess, tell CalGEM how to do their process, but it's understood that they are taking into account. Right, and we also can't layer in additional town requirements on the CalGEM process. We can't sort of quasi hijack their process. We just don't have the authority.

3:00:31 I've got a few questions and I'll kind of throw my geothermal questions out first since you're at the podium, Garrett. Did CalGEM have any sort of role in permitting the ORMAT project you're referring to? Have they played any sort of regulatory role? I don't think so because that project is all on federal land. My understanding is that CalGEM's authority or any mining

3:01:06 Natural resource underneath on private land for the ORMAT project has been BLM. Got it. The ORMAT facility that you mentioned, I think you said number four? Yeah. You said that also punches through a cold water aquifer to get to the geothermal source below it. Is that what I heard? Yes. Is that cold water aquifer also our drinking water source? No, it's down gradient from the sources that we use. Okay.

3:01:45 It's flowing in that direction, and so it's further away. But that's one of the reasons why we have partnered with the BLM, HES, to drill additional monitoring wells in between wells and town to sort of work as a canary in the coal mine, right? In the monitoring wells, if we see signals, then take action prior to impacts. Kim, I...

3:02:27 Apologize, maybe I just didn't scrutinize the staff report close enough, but were there monitoring wells in the staff report? There's no monitoring well. Okay. Andy, this is a question for you or somebody on your team. Any of your other limelight hotels, especially the ones that you say are green and electric, do you use geothermal energy sources there? We haven't had the opportunity to, given the

3:02:59 The land and the minerals underneath those properties. Mammoth is unique, as Gary indicated, with the opportunity to leverage those renewable resources in a safe way. And I do appreciate the conversation. I know it's a difficult one, and I know that we all have the same goals in mind at the end of the day of a safe water system. So I appreciate that this is...

3:03:27 There's a lot of nuances to this. And if CalGEM does require you guys to install the monitoring wells in addition to the geothermal wells, are you guys prepared to do that or would that cause you to abandon that aspect of this concept?

3:03:46 Whatever we need to do to get the permit from Calgem and the other permits that are required, we'll certainly do our best to do that. And if we feel like at some point it's not feasible to do that, then we'll have to make a decision and perhaps drop it and power it without geothermal. But certainly if it's a permitting requirement, absolutely. And maybe this is a question for both Garrett and for Andy.

3:04:15 Just so I understand what I'm hearing correctly, at the end of the day, CalGEM has the overarching permitting authority, and that's a state agency. We're not really sure what the water district's role is in that. Is that kind of what I'm hearing? Or you guys, you can't supersede anything they do, but do you have a voice, or do you have a seat at the table, in other words? We just don't know. Well, I think that MCWD, like any member of the public, public or private,

3:04:46 Can certainly be in contact with Calgem, can make their concerns known, can request that Calgem impose whatever conditions the Water District thinks are appropriate. So whether or not they have a formal role to play as part of the process, they can certainly participate in the sense that they can contact Calgem and talk to them. Got it. Okay. In your history at the Water District, Garrett, or anybody else, has anybody worked closely with Calgem on projects? No, not closely. Okay. Calgem has,

3:05:19 Been involved in some of the monitoring, Long Valley hydrologic. We have not worked closely with CalGEM. So this is all very new to us. We've been working on establishing the contacts and try to, and also to understand more about their CEQA process and whether or not they feel that there is a need to EIR. Additional work really should be done. And the addition of this to the project really...

3:06:24 Does represent a substantial change, potential, the potential for new significance. Got it. Okay, I'm just going to switch gears here a little bit on the questions. Kim, can you explain really quickly what the difference is between the 151 traditional hotel rooms and the 15 condo units? Are those 15 condo units available for nightly rental? Or are those privately owned only for use by the private owners? Right, so the 15...

3:06:59 Condominium hotel units will be subdivided and they will be for sale units so they can be owned individually and those individual owners can put their units on the market. I don't know, Andy, is there a program that Limelight handles those rentals? There is. It's not a requirement of the purchaser of the real estate to participate in our rental program. In our experience, about a third of

3:07:30 Our unit owners participate in the rental program and the balance either lives there or elect not to participate in a rental program. So it's optional. And for the hotel rooms, the true hotel rooms, those will always be short-term rental. And there's a condition of approval included in under the planning division conditions that require the true hotel rooms to be rented no more than 30 days at a time. Okay. To ensure that they stay short-term rentals. Got it, okay.

3:08:04 Hey, and Andy, I don't mean to bang on you guys so hard, but what are you guys kind of envisioning at this point for phase two? We're trying not to commit necessarily to what phase two looks like, given that I mentioned during our introduction that we're really long-term holders and we're not trying to build and flip and sell. We'd like to build phase one and understand.

3:08:33 What works, what doesn't work. Maybe it makes sense not to build anything for some time. Maybe the hotel does extremely well and, you know, the community could benefit from an additional hotel or maybe there's some type of residential use that would make sense. So to answer your question, we're focused on phase one. We're going to be around for a long time and not trying to figure out too much at one time with phase one alone.

3:09:01 The order of magnitude of the construction size is significant, and that's our primary focus. Thank you. And I'm assuming that the piece of land, the parcel, that phase two, would subject to town code, what can be built there? Yes. Last question. Just to clarify for maybe somebody who's listening at home or somebody in the audience. The workforce housing in Luffy will go to a dedicated source and does not go to town general fund.

3:09:35 That is true, yes. Thank you. That's all my questions for now. Any other questions from the commissioners for staff or the applicant? If not, I'm going to open it up to public comment. Public comment, please. Anybody in the audience that would like to address the commission, just say your name and speak your piece.

3:10:23 Really unsure where our, with CalGen, how much control we have, just asking the council really to delay this until that we're on solid footing here because, you know, to lose some of the water supply would just be really catastrophic for controlling this. You know, there's likely mitigation measures, but it's also possible that we're only 1,200 feet away that that's just simply too.

3:11:14 Any other public comment from Sweet Z? Please. This afternoon, I realize this is quite a process balancing the status quo. You talked about the aesthetics, but I didn't hear noise, so that would be from the HVAC, because, for example, if it's a warm summer evening and you're sitting out on your patio, you hear fans blowing. And as an aside, I actually do work with Cal Gym. Thank you for that insight, actually. Any other public comment? Mr. Hodges. Good evening. Almost evening.

3:12:43 Gosh, pleasure to be here. It's been, what, pre-COVID since I stood at this podium. So Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. Great to see everybody in person again and glad to be here. I think it goes without saying that, you know, I'm speaking in strong support of the project. You know, I think there's a few things that haven't been mentioned yet that I just want to highlight for everybody. You know, I guess first and foremost is the quality of developer you have at the table here. I mean...

3:13:10 You know, have you ever seen a more responsible, environmentally responsible developer come to Mammoth Lakes? You know, I think you'd be hard-pressed to find somebody else who's more committed than the Limelight Group and the Aspen Ski Company. So, you know, fantastic to have them here in our community. Obviously, they're also owners in Altera and, you know, but they are a separate entity and, but I also wanted to mention that, you know, we, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, have been

3:13:40 Very involved with Andy and his team since they first came to town and first acquired the property. We've participated with them in several different sort of design kickoff meetings. We've provided them our input and feedback on their program and what they're trying to achieve with the property and given them the benefit of our insight of all our years of operating the resort, both the ski area and the hospitality and the village that we operate.

3:14:06 And so I think they've come up with a fantastic plan that is really going to speak to our guests and the demographics of our guests. From everything we see, this project is going to be wildly successful in terms of the lodging, the hospitality. I think other things that are just so refreshing to see is the amount of amenities that are included in the project with respect to...

3:14:34 The town, sort of the town hall meeting area on the ground floor, the whole floor, the whole ground floor of this property is effectively public area and, you know, between the F&B element, you know, there's going to be a retail shop, there's conference rooms that will be available, you know, assumed to the public at large as well to be utilized. So, you know, it's just a fantastic resort amenity and I think at a great location that's obviously, you know, prime frontage there in the village and well situated.

3:15:04 I think the other thing, too, that I really want to point out is, and you guys have seen this now, you know, these are hot beds, right? You've got 151 hotel rooms that are owned by Limelight. You've got a developer, owner, developer, operator, who is here for the long run. So, I mean, these are unique aspects of this project that I think we really need to appreciate it as a community. You know, I just did a back-in-the-envelope sort of rough estimate on, you know, what kind of TOT this property is going to drive.

3:15:34 You know, it's easily going to hit a million, if not more, year over year over year. That's an annuity to this community that can be used at the discretion of town council, however it fits our priorities. So I think, you know, that's worthy of noting and it shouldn't be overlooked. So a couple of things I just wanted to mention. We, you know, again, we've been involved in all these discussions. There was a mention, a brief mention of the possibility of

3:16:02 You know, maybe a community facility district pursuing the development of a pedestrian bridge across Canyon. That would probably service both the existing West End, the town's parking lot, obviously this property. The thought is to bring that over to the gondola building. I just want you guys to know that we're very involved in those discussions and will continue to be so and want to do everything we can to help facilitate the realization of that pedestrian bridge in the future. And that's all. Thank you very much. Thank you, Tom. Appreciate it. Anybody else in suite to me with public comment?

3:16:34 Jamie, do we have any on Zoom? We have quite a few. Leisha, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, thank you. I believe actually Bruce Favish had requested to speak first, if that's okay. Unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon, commissioners and the Limelight team. Thank you for your time. I'm an owner of number 642 in the Westin, who's one of the original purchasers, selected the unit because of its view.

3:17:15 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

3:17:42 The impact will be on the views from the different levels of the west and facing the limelight. And unfortunately, there don't seem to be any diagrams or graphics or any views which were generated, which would have been relatively easy to do, which would have provided that information. And I'm going to just, everyone has asked that we make that request of the applicant team. It would be very helpful.

3:18:11 Thank you so much.

3:18:41 I think, and a number of people commented, I mean, we've all seen those kinds of vistas. We live in a mountain community, not a warehouse district, and we're concerned what that will look like. And I want to push back on the conclusion that the applicable codes and design guidelines don't contemplate or arguably include the owners and residents of the Westin as members of the public.

3:19:11 who will be affected by the design choices. I know that, for example, I'm just, I'm not going to have time to recite everything, but in the Municipal Code, Chapter 1736090 dealing with screening, it says, rooftop mechanical equipment will be screened from public view. And I would submit that the views of people in the Westin, the guests, people in the restaurant, people walking the halls, are members of the public.

3:19:40 Thank you so much.

3:20:11 Point of the Westin folks. We have 230 residential units and about 25 to 30 percent of them are going to be facing the limelight. Some of those people are going to be looking at walls, granted a distance away and down grade, but they're going to be looking into the limelight. The project proposes to remove 152 trees, I think right off the bat, which is going to further kind of denude the hillside and make the views more

3:20:40 Problematic. And the new trees are going to take years to mature. So those are concerns. We feel that there could have been much more outreach and questions answered earlier. I know other people are going to be speaking to these issues. And I would point out, we also see the 8050 roof from our building. That's an attractive roof. They have a rooftop.

3:21:07 Pool and Spa. There are things I think that could be done from a design and a functional standpoint that would mitigate the impact of a very large expanse of flat roof. And we're also, you know, we're talking about people, literally tens of millions of dollars just in the people, the real property values looking down for the limelight. So it's a very, very substantial interest, easily as great as that of a pedestrian walking along Canyon Boulevard who would look up at a parapet.

3:21:36 Thank you, Bruce. We appreciate your public comment. I understand we have a pretty long list of people that want to submit as well. Thank you. Alicia, please give your comments. Thank you. Hello, my name is Alicia Baldwin, and I am the Commercial Director for the Monashay Homeowner Association, as well as the General Manager for the Western Monashay. I echo Tom's thoughts earlier. I'm so excited to welcome our future neighbors and look forward to working with them as the...

3:22:07 project progresses. However, from the hotel standpoint and the homeowner perspective, we are concerned about the prospect of the mechanical systems that appear to be located on the roof of the limelight. Two major concerns, the appearance of the roof to the Monashay guests and owners, as well as potential noise. I apologize, Andy, I feel like we're bringing these concerns up at the last minute, but when we saw the designs, the aerial design wasn't available, so this kind of just came to our attention.

3:22:36 last week. In regards to appearance, we are concerned that the rooftop mechanical systems may negatively affect the desirability of the units on the southeast side. Those units are often our most requested rooms due to the views, and the rooms on the sixth and seventh floor, we actually sell at a premium rate.

3:22:56 because of the view. So the hotel and the homeowners face potential loss of income if we can't charge that premium any longer. We're hoping that there's aesthetic measures, maybe such as enclosures or rooftop plannings that limelight can take to kind of lessen the impact with those mechanical systems.

3:23:17 Even more so than the views, my staff and I are hearing from many homeowners who are extremely concerned regarding the level of noise that might occur from the mechanical equipment sitting out on the roof.

3:23:29 And we are concerned about that as well from the hotel perspective. I worked at the Village for many years, listening to guests and owners share their disappointing experiences due to noise, whether it was from commercial spaces or exhaust fans, things like that. And listening to how it ruined their stay, I feel this could potentially cause substantial loss of revenue, as well as enjoyment of ownership. So we're curious if, you know.

3:23:55 Have noise studies been conducted? Or are there any noise mitigation issues under consideration? Again, I think that there are solutions that could be implemented to alleviate potential noise pollution. And thank you for your consideration. Jeff, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Okay, can you hear me? Yeah, we got you, Jeff. Okay, can I share my screen, possibly? I don't believe so. Okay.

3:24:33 Well, I'd like to thank you for the opportunity to comment. My name is Jeff Marchioro. I'm the owner of Weston Monashay, Unit 605. I'm a registered civil engineer in the state of California. My review of Line Lights project has been focused on proposed improvements and grading near the shared property line with the Weston Monashay. My first comment is that proposed retaining walls and a cobble swale appear to

3:25:00 Encroach onto Interwest Crane Footing and Interwest Soil Pins Easements that are described in construction easement document number 2004-006-1.

3:25:16 019, recorded by the county in June of 2004. The easements are located on Limelight's parcel for the benefit of InterWest and the Westin Monashay. The agreement paragraph six describes that.

3:25:32 All easements expired in April of this year except for crane footing and soil pins easements. Paragraphs 2.5b and 2.6b of the easement agreements describe the crane footing and soil pins easements as perpetual. The easement agreement includes figures showing the easements along the shared property line between the Westin Monashay and Limelight.

3:25:57 We respectfully request that the crane footing and soil pins easements be preserved. The easements are located on limelice parcel, as I mentioned, for the benefit of the Montage. They may be needed for rebuilding major construction projects or maintenance of the Weston Montage building in the future.

3:26:18 Second, I'd like to request clarification regarding setback requirements as related to retaining walls. Limelight's April plan set sheet number AP0-010 shows definitely one and possibly two retaining walls within a 30-foot setback. The setback dimension is clearly shown in a red color.

3:26:47 along the property line running in the north-south direction. And then there's, it's unclear whether those setbacks turn around the corner for the property line that goes in the east-west direction. The setback, sorry, losing my place here.

3:27:14 So the walls may need to be moved if they're affected by the setback.

3:27:21 And regardless of where the retaining walls will ultimately be constructed, the Western Monashay requests reassurance that the required excavation to build the limelight proposed retaining walls will not affect slope stability, supporting the Western Monashay existing utilities, yard improvements in the general Monashay structure.

3:27:46 And finally, one last comment. I just wanted to comment on the trees. You know, Mammoth is a very special place. Given that, I think it'd be prudent to hold off on cutting down the trees as long as possible. Developments can be delayed. There's a possible change in the economy coming and possible downcurrent.

3:28:05 downtown. It would be a shame if the lot was clear cut and the parcel remains treeless while limelight works out the kinks or waits for a better time if the economy does take a downturn. So with that, I'd like to thank you for the opportunity to be able to comment. And that concludes my presentation. Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. Deborah, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:28:33 Good evening, everyone. My name is Deborah Ernst, and my husband and I own Westin-Lanashi Unit No. 426. I would like to ask that by the comments made tonight that we would consider not moving forward with the permit or resolution as currently presented. I, too, am a homeowner that is concerned about the issues of visual and auditory.

3:29:01 as it relates to the mechanical devices on the roof and would really hope that part of a revision would require that the limelight ensure that those acoustical and visual issues be mitigated. I want to echo Jeff's concern that we maintain our full access to the easements as they are so vital to maintaining our property on a regular schedule as well as dealing with any forthcoming

3:29:31 I think overall, I would just want to say that

3:30:02 I value the perspective of the pedestrian or the car that drives by or the person on the bike that goes by the property and they're passing by. But for those of us that in all of the residential units that surround the limelight, we are there 24-7 looking at the property. So I would really like to go forward and say thank you in advance.

3:30:30 for taking in what we are looking at as part of getting this and some of these amendments in place before it is fully authorized to go forward. Thank you. Rob, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yeah, hello? Can you hear me now? Yeah. Yeah, I guess my concern is that I noticed the forestry permit would allow the clear cutting of

3:31:14 I would also assume they were planning to do grading at the same time. I would hope that they would not do any work or grading or moving the trees on site two until site one was completely occupied in use. That's one of my concerns. It's right adjacent to our pool area. It's right adjacent to the main area of the Western Monashay Complex.

3:31:49 Yeah, so I was just concerned that the permit would allow them to clear cut and then start grading the second section and it would be left barren for years until it actually got occupied or constructed. Rob, we appreciate it. Steve, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Steve, are you out there? Hi, I am here. Can you hear me? Yep. Okay, great. Hi, my name is Steve Bernard. I'm the current president of the Monashay Homeowners Association.

3:32:32 Commonly referred to as a Westin or Westin Monashay. I represent 230 of the Monashay condominium unit owners, whether they're in the Westin rental program or not. I like to start off addressing a couple of things. One was the geothermal. And if you've been in Mammoth, you've driven down Minaret Boulevard, you see aside, this is earthquake fault. And yeah, we're sitting in a big caldera.

3:32:57 So when I hear about geothermal going down 1,400 or 2,000 feet into fractured rock, and you think of an earthquake that we had like in the 80s, it could be some significant issues. So I hope we address that very, very carefully. And additionally, as Jeff said, the earthquake studies should be done to all the retaining walls as well. So the retaining walls don't have, there's no possibility of an earthquake.

3:33:27 Barring a gigantic uncontrollable one, to take out their building. And while I'm on retaining walls, I'm looking at sheet T8, and it appears to be a retaining wall. It's about 18 feet high. And I don't know who's responsible for putting a fence on it, but I assume Limelight would be the ones who would put a fence on that, so people walking their dogs wouldn't lose them.

3:34:01 Steve, we appreciate your public comment. Can I keep going? I haven't seen my five minutes yet? Yep, just keep going. Okay. So, like, first I want to say thanks to Bruce and Jeff. They worked really hard and the people who have contributed to these meetings. But some of the original owners, like Bruce said, saw drawings of the Rich Carlton with, you know, an elegant roof line and sort of a more polished appearance.

3:34:34 And now we're looking at having a wall 80 feet from our windows. And those lower windows used to have beautiful views, and they could be compromised by the hotel being there. So I'm just reiterating that point that's going on. Many of the drawings show a less than five foot variance was never proposed to the HOA board and was never approved. I'm not sure why it's still on there. It's a mystery to me.

3:35:03 Also reiterate Alicia's point of the units that don't have a view anymore. A Marriott Bonvoy member is going to walk into one of those rooms and look down over the rooftop and say, I think I'll call down and get a different room. And future buyers equally discriminating and will probably lose some value in all the units on that side. Regarding parking,

3:35:32 The plans show somewhat of a split-level parking structure, whereas I thought the city codes required underground, so it seems that pushing those parking lots down out of sight would provide a couple of things. One, they would be officially underground parking, and they could lower the overall roof height and buy some of the lower units more view. Please wrap up your comments. Okay.

3:36:01 So I'm excited to have this thing go on. I just feel that using every square inch of land and every cubic foot allowed of airspace is not the right thing for Mammoth. I just think we just need a little more space. So thank you for listening and thanks for all the people at the Monashay who have contributed their comments. I'm done. Thank you, Steve. Please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon. Thanks for having me. Do you hear me? Yeah, we got you, Damon. 446 at the Monashay.

3:36:42 And I think the town and some of the previous reviews making the change to the parking entrance was very smart and very good. Like other owners of the Monashay, I'm concerned about some of the retaining walls on the upslope side from the limelight. And also, you know, the roof, like everybody else.

3:37:14 The commissioners and everybody on the board when talking about the roof, there's a reason why they want a flat roof and a parapet. They're getting the most elevation out of the building that they can and they have a right to go to wherever. I understand that. But I ask you all to go to Google and Google an aerial image of the town of Mammoth, particularly the village, and you will see a pitched roof with not a lot of mechanical equipment on...

3:37:43 Any building in the entire town. So when we're talking about DRBs and CRBs and all these things about what are standards, there's a reason why in a snowy place, a pitched roof is a standard of design. And there's a reason why they want a flat roof. And I think there's a reason why you shouldn't allow them to have a flat roof. That's all I have to say today. Thank you. Thank you, Damon. Appreciate it. Sean, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:38:20 Hi, can you hear me? Yeah, we got you, Sean. Hi, thank you for letting me talk and make some comments. I'm the homeowner, I'm at the fifth floor, the corner unit, southeast corner, and some of the concern for other homeowners already, I don't want to repeat myself, but I just have two comments. One is I'm relatively on the higher level, but

3:38:45 For some homeowners on the lower level, I think their view will be very affected. So if there is some rendering that the architect can generate, they'll be really appreciated to let other people see how their view will be affected. You know, in Southern California, some area like Malibu, they have actually poles and the ropes and, you know, to kind of give people some idea where the highest point of the building will be.

3:39:12 I don't know if it's feasible, but that can probably help people to realize how it would look like. The other thing about the Louvre, I want to make a quick comment. You know, when our guests, for example, look at your Louvre, they may potentially be your guests too. So, I mean, make the top nice looking, you know, aesthetically appealing is actually probably to your benefit to shield the sound away from Western and also make it look nice.

3:39:42 That's all I'm going to say. Thank you. Thank you, Sean. Susan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. My name is Susan Hoffman. I own several units at the Westin, but for purposes of this discussion, the most important units I want to talk about are units 740 and 742. I waited a long time to get to next.

3:40:12 Side-by-side units on the seventh floor in that particular location. And I paid a real premium to get those units because they have a beautiful view and they face away from the swimming pool. So it's very quiet. And I love those two units. And I've always assumed that eventually I'll move into them full time. The idea that I'm now going to look down on this equipment.

3:40:41 That's probably not going to be very attractive and that it's going to be potentially noisy is just really upsetting to me. This is going to affect the value of my condos to me, my own enjoyment. It's going to affect the rental value, as other people have mentioned, and it's going to drastically affect my resale value. So this is a huge personal and economic thing for me. And part of my problem is I just don't have enough information.

3:41:10 Thank you. Thank you, Susan.

3:41:41 Michelle, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, this is Michelle Sullivan. Can you hear me? Yeah, we can hear you, Michelle. Oh, okay, great. Hey, yes, I've been coming to Mammoth for, oh, about 40 years now and have lived through many of the changes. I don't know how long you all have been living in Mammoth, but it's a beautiful place. I have a picture that I wanted to show you of

3:42:11 The balcony off the unit that I have that just is absolutely gorgeous. Unfortunately, though, I'm on the second floor and I had no idea until just recently as of just this week, actually, we've not been given much of any information about this build. And I don't know if that's my fault, but I'm just sensing from the conversation here that a lot of people were not really informed.

3:42:40 I think Altera definitely and Aspen have been working a long time on this and have a lot more information. But even the pictures that are shown, they don't show anything from the back side. So I'm on the second floor. I have this gorgeous view. I have trees that are right outside my balcony. And I want to make sure that those trees, if any of them are on the setback, that they are saved. It's just...

3:43:08 I'm not quite sure if I was permanently living in Mammoth. I would hope that you guys really consider the long term here about how this is going to change the look and feel of the village, about the mountains. I'm a snowboarder and I can tell you that in the last two years I've been hit by another skier or snowboarder because it's so crowded on the mountain anymore. And bringing more beds, yeah.

3:43:37 Financially, a million dollars, hey, that's great, right? I've been paying my taxes and doing everything for Mammoth that I can, but I can tell you the changes of increasing the amount of beds in Mammoth and putting up large structures like this is a huge, huge structure, guys, right? It's really going to change the look and feel. I just, I feel for you, actually. I hope that you make the right decision here on what gets put in, how it's put in.

3:44:06 And you keep some of the beautiful part of Mammoth still there, a lot of trees on this lot that I'd hate to see taken out for quite honestly a very ugly building, an industrial looking thing that doesn't really form at all with any of the other buildings in that area. So I'm not quite sure who was saying that it's aesthetically similar to all the other structures. I would say it's totally not. It looks to me like a very cheap build.

3:44:35 And with garages that are upstairs versus down in the underground, like all the other structures that have it underground. I don't know. I just, I feel like we're allowing a lot here for the purpose of money and greed. I hate to say, but it is your city. I would love to have called it home, but honestly, the way things are going, it's not looking good for me. But good luck to you. Thanks for your time. Thank you, Michelle.

3:45:05 Willie, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes, hi. My name is Willie Lou. I'm also an owner at the West End Unit 616. And although my unit isn't really facing the limelight, I have friends and family. I go there probably 20, 30 times a season. And I definitely have times where I have friends and family that rent out a unit that face the limelight. And I can tell you that if it's a flat roof,

3:45:37 With all the mechanicals there, it's not, no matter what, it's not going to look good, because I just bought a condo in Hawaii, and it's on the 24th floor, but it faces a really beautiful view. On the other side of the building, it faces a flat roof, and it's just ugly. It's got the mechanicals, it's wide, it's just unsightly. And I don't understand why the actual value is not that much of a difference.

3:46:05 That's another issue. I just wanted to point that out, for one. And also, no one pointed this out, but it was brought up in our HOA meetings, is that the traffic, I think it was slightly touched upon, is the traffic issue. With 151 or whatever, 170, 80 units, the traffic, I would think, is going to be quite a bit more. Has anybody done any traffic studies on that? And also,

3:46:35 Talking about the crowds, I agree. I mean, I've been going to Mammoth for decades and I just feel like it's getting more and more crowded and especially with the gondola coming down the village. I have to wait. I have, I asked my type to pick me up now because I can't, I have to wait like half an hour to an hour to get down and with all these additional units, I just feel like it's

3:47:03 Just going to make it much worse. I don't know if maybe Tom Hodges can address that issue or if the town of Mammoth can help with that if this development goes through. I hope so. But one other thing I want to bring up is the bridge. I know there's been talks of that. And I don't know. I feel like it can help with the West End.

3:47:31 You know, have Weston guests can have access to that bridge and not have to walk all the way down back up and just have a smooth level to go to the gondola. It would help a little bit with my opposition to this development. So that's all. That's all I have to say. Thanks for listening and thanks for your considerations. Thank you, Willie. Okay, so I'm going to close public comment and bring it back to the commissioner.

3:48:04 That is all, everybody else raises their hands. Okay, let's see. Julia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, good evening. My name is Julia Alzerhofer and I'm the owner of Unit 542 at the West in Monashay. And my unit, like many of the other units of, my unit, like many of the other units of the property is a condominium which is rented. And I really only found out about this meeting over the last...

3:48:36 A few days over the last week or so. And I think the view impacts, the environmental impacts, the flat roof and the not pitched roof impacts, including the visual and the acoustical issues with the rooftop mechanical equipment, construction staging mitigation impacts, they really haven't simply not been looked at.

3:48:56 As a member of the community, I'd like the opportunity to review the project and discuss any concerns with the applicant. And so I'm asking the Planning Commission to not take any action today to allow for further conversation between, yeah, to allow for further conversation. Thank you. Thank you, Julia. Dave, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Dave Solmarsh, Unit 644. I am concerned about the noise. Year-round from our unit,

3:49:29 We can leave the window open and we maybe hear a little noise from the street down there, but that's it. Having a H-grack unit will put a complete into that. And I know it would probably not be the most cost-effective thing for them to do, but having a pitch roof would be...

3:49:49 Very helpful for that. And it's something I would like to say. I don't like the fact that we're on an earthquake fault right there. That's always a concern for people to live up there. That is something that I'm very concerned about. And I know Andy and Dawn, you definitely have all kinds of drawings and everything that's put together. The ones that you provided.

3:50:09 We're obviously street level and the angle makes it look like you can barely see the western. So it's a very favorable rendition. And I understand the reason for doing that. But I would ask that you, before anybody makes any decisions on that, supply the views that you have to the rest of us so we can get a fair view of what's going on and how things would look from the western. And like was mentioned, the public, whether or not they're staying there as guests.

3:50:37 or owners or people that walk through there. I think they have to be considered for this. Thank you so much. Rob, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes, I had one additional comment. I was wondering in terms of when they actually do the construction and all the work, is there a time period that they're limited doing it or are they allowed to do it on the weekends where it might interfere operations with the Westin and adjacent properties or how does that work out?

3:51:10 Thank you so much. My name is Heidi Wu. I am a new owner for the Western Munaki 342. I thank you for this opportunity because I'm learning by listening to the CD point of view and the owner and

3:51:49 The hotel, the new developer, and I'm hoping there's a win-win solution for the city, for the owners, for the new developer, because I think win-win is the best solution. I don't have any, I guess I don't have any suggestion at this point. I did feel sad a little bit because I feel the pain of the owner on the top, the seven level and the six.

3:52:17 Because they have a great view and look like they're going to face in something that's not really attractive and it's going to hurt them in the future for sure. My level 342 is a lower level and I feel a bit sad because I know that I'm going to lose the trees, I'm going to lose the bird because I wake up in the morning, I love to see the trees and the birds and the sunrise and the energy and the beautiful light. I felt that it's going to be, I'm going to lose that.

3:52:45 So I'm thinking about selling the condo because of that. But I feel sad. So I hope the city will take into consideration of the owners. And I thank you for that. Thank you, Heidi. Tim, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Tim, are you out there? We can't hear you. Tim, you need to unmute yourself. The 714 phone number ending in 8720. Please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:53:48 Hi, yes, I'm the owner for Unit 741 at Westin. I have two questions. One is that we are paying a substantial amount of the HOA fee for the village. With a new limelight coming in, and they're probably going to be using quite a bit of this too, are they going to be sharing that expense with us?

3:54:17 That's question number one. And the number two question is that I think one of the gentlemen mentioned earlier about the traffic flow. When's the last time we studied, you know, this between Canyon and Lake Mary and with a big project like this, you know, the traffic and all that stuff. These are the two concerns that I have. I hope that builder or the city can answer that question. Thank you.

3:54:47 Thank you. No more raised hands. All right, closing public comment. Let's, I'll bounce it back to staff. Would you like to address any of the questions that were brought up? Yes. So a number of us will be responding to different. Okay. So I'll start. A question came up about the noise or a number of the condition 38 of the noise generation generated by the project shall meet the requirement and or the town's regulations. If the commission would like to add a belt.

3:55:34 Spenders on that, we could study, ensure that that meets the, so that is something that's in the commission. I'll also respond to views. We've had a lot of comment views and public, and the town considers public views and is very specific where public views are considered from in any other previous projects, which is why we don't see any analysis from the Weston building. So that's something that we have been consistent on in our projects. And so with that, I'll pass it over to.

3:56:25 Kim, do you want to respond to a couple of the different items and then Amy and then we can pass it on to the applicant team? I think there was a comment made about setbacks to the retaining wall. There is a section in the North Village specific plan which states that within the PR district, no setbacks shall be required on internal side and rear lot line. And I believe the lot line that was being discussed in that comment was an internal side lot line.

3:57:03 So the project is providing a much larger setback than would be required. So that was the setback. And then on the retaining wall question about whether a railing would be required, building code will require a railing on retaining walls over a certain height. On the parking structure, there was a comment about the fact that it wasn't entirely subterranean. And the language in the North Village-specific plan states that for new

3:57:36 New lodging uses, the parking shall be predominantly under structure. So we've interpreted that to allow for above ground structured parking located under the... Amy, do you want to respond to the public? So there was a question regarding removal of trees too, or just removal of trees in general. So tree removal would be removed as part of the... And removal on the phase two property would need to... That's related to tree removal associated with the construction of phase two.

3:58:27 We are not approving about hours of work. Municipal code permitted hours of work are Monday, Saturday from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. and hours outside of those times, hours on Sunday would be limited permission between typical hours of work also exclude. Yeah, let's see. I have a couple other items as well. I was hoping from the applicant team, sorry to surprise you, Mark and Dan.

3:59:20 Mark Carney, possibly could you talk about the easement question that came up during public comment? Sure, Sandra, I'd be happy to. I'm Mark Carney. I'm the local land use attorney for the applicant. There was a question raised about the InterWest Crane footing easement. Basically, way back when in 2004, the owner of what's now the Aspen property and InterWest is the owner of the Weston property got into essentially a mutual easement agreement to

3:59:51 to assist each other in the development of their respective properties. And among the things they did is created mutual crane easements, crane footing easements, the purpose of which was to create an area, in this case, on the Aspen property to enable interest in the construction of the Westin to install a crane on the Aspen property.

4:00:20 in order for InterWest to be able to build the Westin Loanishing. In order to do that, InterWest needed to get an easement from the prior owner of the Aspen property to put that crane pad and crane footing on the InterWest property within the easement area. And the purpose of that was to attach a tower crane in order to help build the Westin.

4:00:50 What the contract says is that it is a perpetual and non-exclusive easement. Those are important words. Perpetual obviously means forever. Well, why is it forever? The reason it's forever is to, number one, to ensure that it wasn't a requirement to dig that back up after it was utilized. Instead, what the document itself says, that within 60 days after the completion of the building,

4:01:19 Inner West will cause the crane footings to be buried below the natural grade. And that's a much more efficient way to deal with those footings than it would be to have to actually rip them up. The second presumable reason was in the unlikely event that there would be some reason to rebuild the Westin, those crane footings would be available to be essentially unearthed and reutilized. And so in the meantime,

4:01:49 Andrew's obligation as what's called the servient tenement of the easement, the person burdened by the easement, is make sure that it doesn't do anything to interfere with Weston's reasonable use of that crane easement. So they basically can't do anything which would prevent the easement from being effectuated, from it being used the way it was intended to be used. And so nothing that Aspen is doing

4:02:19 is going to get away in any future, get in the way of any future use of that crane footing. And so it's a non-exclusive easement, means it's still Aspen's property. They can do with it what they want to do as long as they don't unreasonably interfere with the intended use of that easement, which they don't intend to do. Is that responsive to your question, Sandra? Yes, thank you. You're welcome. And possibly your rationale for the flat roof.

4:03:04 Yeah, I'll jump in and then flip it to Dan. But there is a covenant on our property for the benefit of the West End that limits our height to be substantially less than what the zoning allows for. And we are complying with that covenant. So we're substantially lower than the zoning would have otherwise allowed for. So the roof level.

4:03:28 that the Weston homeowners are speaking about. That's a function of the covenant that they've got on our property. So it's sort of predetermined in a sense as to where our roof line would land through an agreement that the Weston has onto our property that limits the height. The flat roof, there's a variety of benefits to it.

4:03:54 In our mind, the safest roof with respect to snow load and any potential snow that could fall onto pedestrians below. And Dan, as far as design intent, if you'd like to speak to the flat roof, that would be great. Thank you, Andy. Yes, for the overall height limit, we are under that.

4:04:25 Height limit and that extra five feet that's mentioned there is for roof elements and mechanical units and such to be allowed and that's what that additional five number was indicating. As for the flat roof, it does maintain a better support of the structure of the snow and we're able to

4:04:45 Accommodate for that. There are several other buildings around. The gondola building, the mountaineering building across the street as well are also flat roofs as well as other condos directly across the canyon boulevard that have those flat roofs. And it is a normal type of roof to use there as it does control the shedding of snow much better. We do have licensed California structural engineers that are very aware of the high snow loads of over 230 pounds per square foot.

4:05:15 on the building, and the building is oversized for that reason, for snow loads as well as for seismic loads. Same thing with the retaining walls and shoring walls. They'll be definitely designed by specialized engineers and local engineers, civil and structural, that can help with that. If you'd like, I can also speak to the mechanical on the roof as well. Sure, that'd be great.

4:05:45 The great thing about this project is we're trying to be very sustainable and minimize the amount of mechanical and equipment that we have on the roofs. With the geothermal, we're able to really reduce the overall amount of units.

4:06:01 As we don't have to worry about the heat loads, and it's only cooling loads that we're considering and having to worry about. So this will mitigate a lot of the equipment. A lot of it still goes down in the lower basements and all the pumps and such that use the geothermal energy. So we're really trying to eliminate a lot of the sound that could be there and using high efficient equipment to help in that effort.

4:06:28 We're able to minimize and current designs are about 16 units on that wing of the building. So compared to what it could be with 150 total units in the building, we've really been able to bring that down and address the sound and the equipment that's up there to try to minimize that. So we're doing our best with all these systems and designs that we're working on to really create an efficient building and something that's not obtrusive to the community.

4:07:01 Last, I think just asking Alicia to reiterate the process and the appropriate agency for considering the geothermal impact. Sure, thank you, Sandra. So the CalGEM agency itself does have a form that it will require the applicant to complete.

4:07:27 conjunction with the addendum that the town prepares. So CalGEM is used to being a responsible agency as part of its application process. CalGEM asks specifically for the lead agency's CEQA document. It will...

4:07:43 look at and rely upon our document to the extent that it believes that it can, and then it supplements that analysis with a separate form that it asks very specific and particularized questions related to the geothermal activity, which the applicant will then have to address and provide additional study and substantiation.

4:08:06 in connection with. So CalGEM does have a very defined process. It will take an action as responsible agency. It will have to make responsible agency CEQA findings. And in that context, we'll have a public process, as Andy mentioned, Andy Morris, town attorney mentioned, that folks can participate in to the extent that they are concerned about the details.

4:08:31 of the geothermal processing. But tonight, the town's focus is on the land use applications that are before you and the specific land use permits that are requested. Those land use permits themselves do not necessarily authorize the applicant to go out and drill any wells. So even though we talk about there being geothermal or potential geothermal as part of this project,

4:09:00 in the project description that is for informational purposes to disclose what we know at this time based on the application we have received as staff from the applicant, but there are more steps to be completed before the applicant can actually go out there and do any sort of geothermal work. Thank you, Alicia, and that concludes the staff's responses to the public comments. Sandra, actually, if I may, I just want to clarify my response about working hours because of project...

4:09:42 So the drilling can go on 24 hours a day for 15 days in a row? That is correct. And there are other mitigation measures not associated with it. All right. Let's throw it back to the commission here. Thoughts? Comments? How about we go with Greg? Greg, you want to lead us off? All right. I guess this should be a question for the developer. Let's just say you drill a bunch of dry holes. What is the backup heat source in this place?

4:10:30 All electric, with hopefully the benefit of geothermal, but we're not using any propane or other uses. Is there a propane boiler or any other way you could heat this glycol or whatever you're going to be using to get this into the rooms? Electric boiler. Well, I've lived here a long time. I sure don't like electric heat. Geothermal might be good, but...

4:11:02 I've got some real concerns about having the okay outside of local control and with a industry advocacy group. Just personally, what I'd like to see is have some sort of a review by our local water district. And I don't know if this is possible because I know we tried with ORMAP. That was feds and this is state.

4:11:30 But, you know, having a geothermal plant in the middle of town is very green and very nice, but, you know, we only got so much water and I don't want to be having a cistern on my house. Yeah, I do believe the, you know, clarifying if I could, that the wells after drilling only protrude a few feet from the surface, so they won't be visible in any way.

4:12:01 from, you know, from the public. As well, I think the order of magnitude that we're talking about here for the geothermal supplement to power for a property, 151 hotel rooms is substantially less than what's being used at the ORMAT facility.

4:12:21 And lastly, I do appreciate the concern, Greg. I mean, we, again, have the same goals in terms of protecting water. Everything that we do with our sustainability efforts is in an effort to protect water, among other things. But the water source being used for the geothermal is not the same source as the drinking water. So it wouldn't have an impact to the drinking water reserves.

4:12:50 Well, it's my understanding you're going to have to go through that drinking water to get to the hot water. That's correct. And it's a relatively common practice for geothermal wells to do that. And the level at which CalGEM monitors and approves these permits is pretty extreme. So we, again, would have to go and get every needed permit.

4:13:20 That is out there to make sure that we don't have any negative impact. So you're saying that if there's in the future a monitoring well that turns up cross-contamination, this entire project is going to be running off of the electrical grid at electrical kilowatt rates, normal in Mammoth, and that's going to be their heat source. If we fail to secure geothermal power, we will be at this point

4:13:51 Planning to be powered all electric. We understand it's an added cost to the project, but we believe it to be the appropriate and right thing to do in the long term from an environmental standpoint because as the electric grid gets greener, our building will be green as opposed to using propane, which is less expensive from an initial capital standpoint as well as an ongoing operational standpoint. But while it would make better financial

4:14:18 decisions and rationale to use propane. That's not our hope. Our hope is to go all electric, which we believe to be the right thing to do. Add an added cost to our project. That's all I've got right now. Thank you, Greg. Commissioner Kennedy, any thoughts, opinions, questions? No questions. I appreciate the applicant's commitment to keeping this project green, and I think if we've talked a lot about the

4:14:50 sustainability of our community, and I think this is an opportunity to put our money where our mouth is and go with a sustainable developer, so I'm excited about this possibility. I am concerned, I think, with the other commissioners about the geothermal aspect, although I think if this could be done really well, it would be cool to see future developments use this sort of renewable energy too, but I don't, I am not concerned beyond

4:15:19 I guess I have faith in what I've heard of CalGym and them figuring things out. And then as far as the sound, I could go either way. I think Sandra had mentioned the doing a study or some sort of test thing to see about the sound, but that it's going to have to meet sound codes anyways. So I could go with whatever the commission wants to do on doing that study or not. But that's all for me. Thanks, Michael. Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Burroughs. Thank you. I do have about the groundwater.

4:15:51 I know that we've had noise studies in that area.

4:16:19 Over the years, especially with Sam's Wood Site, and we want to make sure that, you know, we're being respectful of all our community members there. And like Jessica said, or Commissioner, sorry, I'm blanking. Jessica works. Jessica said, I appreciate that we're looking at doing an eco-friendly hotel, and it's been through the ADP, and

4:16:49 Through that process for quite a while, and I've been part of that, and I think that the design is appropriate for our community, and I'm interested to see this move forward. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. I'm in support of this project. Like everyone else has mentioned, I'm definitely nervous about the geothermal drilling and piercing our cold water aquifer. We've heard some comments today that CalGEM is going to be the lead agency, but that they're...

4:17:21 Very involved and they're very experienced and that they will be reaching out to our local water district for their expertise and their local knowledge. And we've also heard that there are going to be multiple steps along the way, checks and balances to make sure that this geothermal system is not something that is going to adversely affect our town's drinking water. So that gives me a little bit of reassurance that, you know, if...

4:17:49 Once we go down this road, if it doesn't look sustainable, that we can take a left. I am very familiar with this product, the Limelight. It's an amazing product. They have an incredible reputation. They provide an incredible guest experience. And in reality, it's a missing level of our lodging offerings that we can offer our visitors.

4:18:18 Whether they're domestic or international. So it would be a wonderful addition to our other lodging partners here in town. So I would be in support of this project. And I agree we probably should do a noise study, I guess is the word. I can suggest language prior to the issuance of a building permit. The applicant shall provide evidence that the rooftop equipment meets the town's noise ordinance. Okay. So with that being said, would anybody like to put forth a motion? I can.

4:18:54 Two in a row, way to go, Commissioner Kennedy. I will move, let me make sure I'm looking at the right one, move to adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving tentative tract map, TTM 22-002, use permit, UPA 22-001.

4:19:20 And major designer view DR 22-001 with conditions as recommended by staff, read by Sandra. And that would include the noise. Yes, that's the condition I suggested. Do we have a second? Commissioner Burroughs seconds. Any other conversation, discussion? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Eckert? I like the project, but I can't vote for a geothermal plant. No. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes.

4:19:58 Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Project passes 3-1. We'll move on. Are we moving on to? We should move on to the next item. Okay. Let's move on to item 4.3. Consideration of tentative tract map 22-001 for approval of the creation of 14 lots for future affordable housing uses, three lots for open space and parks, and public street dedications to complete the westerly extension of Tavern Road.

4:20:31 And I believe our staff contact is Gina. Yes, and I will just a brief introduction. Gina's going to join the Zoom meeting because you can't broadcast. So just briefly wanted to let the Commission know that Commissioner Eckhart. Oh, great. Commissioner Eckhart, you're not muted. Commissioner Eckhart. Good conversations.

4:21:10 Thank you, Andy, for making the trip. Are we waiting for something? Yeah, staff is putting together, I think, a presentation.

4:22:30 Apologies, we're just trying to, I'm trying to share my screen right now. I thought maybe my computer froze. No, we're just trying to share screen. We all froze, Paul. Yeah, my internet's not working. Right, I think our internet, we're having some internet issues. Call Sentinel's tech support. I'm not quite sure why I cannot share the screen. I have their number on speed dial. Yeah, I'm sorry, commissioners. We are working. Thank you for your patience.

4:24:19 All right, the applicants of the Parcel Affordable Housing Project are requesting a tentative tract map for approval of the creation of 14 lots for future affordable housing uses, three lots for open space and parks, and public street dedications to complete the westerly extension of Tavern Road, the creation of Inyo Street connecting Center Street and Tavern Road, and the northerly extension of Chaparral Road.

4:24:45 The requested tentative tract map is for subdivision purposes only and no development is proposed as part of this application. The project site is a vacant forested site within the parcel master plan zoning district and is surrounded by commercial and residential development on all sides. The site consists of a total of 22.69 acres and pursuant to CEQA guidelines and infill environmental checklists was previously approved so no further analysis is needed.

4:25:22 So I'm sure many of you are familiar with the project already, but I'll give a brief background. The parcel has been slated for affordable housing since the 1991 Shady Rest Master Plan was approved and an affordable housing overlay was placed on the site. The town of Mammoth Lakes purchased the property in 2018 and throughout 2019 engaged in a community outreach process to create a preferred conceptual land use plan, also known as the preferred plan.

4:25:48 The preferred plan was accepted by the town council in December of 2019 and soon after the town partnered with the developer Pacific West Communities. On January 6, 2021, the parcel master plan was adopted which replaces the previous residential multifamily one zoning and affordable housing overlay and provides the current development standards for the site. Additionally, an entitlement package including a major design review, use permit and lot line adjustment for phase one of the parcel.

4:26:17 was approved in 2021. Phase one, residential and public right-of-way site work has already been initiated. So the objectives of the subdivision. The project is requesting to subdivide the site into a total of 17 lots in order to allow for a phased development approach to building out the full site according to the parcel master plan. Development of the parcel will be dictated by availability of the public and private financing for affordable housing.

4:26:46 The lots have been subdivided as such to meet the parcel master plan requirements while also allowing for flexibility to be developed when funding is secured for individual projects on each lot. Seen here is the proposed tentative tract map. This includes the 14 affordable housing lots that range in size from about 17,000 square feet to 112,000 square feet. The three open space and park lots, lots A, B, and C, range in size from

4:27:16 About 24,000 square feet to 45,000 square feet. Lots A and B are designated as jurisdictional wetlands, while lot C is designated as public park per the master plan. Public street dedications amount to about 175,000 square feet, which includes necessary primary streets for vehicular and pedestrian circulation. This would include the extension of Chaparral Road, Tavern Road, and the creation of Inyo Street.

4:27:48 The following are the list of findings that have been made to be consistent with the state subdivision math act. The design of the subdivision and uses are consistent with the applicable general and specific plans because the residential subdivision complies with the parcel master plan and municipal code development standards, which implement the goals and policies of the general plan. The site is physically suitable for the site.

4:28:14 For this type of development, because the site is 22.69 acres in size and residential uses are an allowable land use in the parcel master plan zone. The proposed project density is consistent with the permitted density of 24 dwelling units per acre, with a total not to exceed 580 dwelling units. The design of the subdivision and the proposed improvements are not likely to cause substantial environmental damage.

4:28:38 Not likely to substantially injure fish or wildlife or their habitat and not likely to cause serious health problems because the infill environmental checklist determined that potential direct, indirect, and cumulative environmental effects associated with the project were previously and adequately analyzed. And finally, the design of the subdivision will not conflict with easements acquired by the public at large for access through or use of the property within

4:29:06 The proposed subdivision because all easements are shown on the tentative map and future development of the lots would comply with those easements. Resolution number PDC 2020-22-15 goes into further detail on how the project meets those findings. This project is also consistent with CEQA because pursuant to CEQA guidelines section 15183.3 streamlining for infill projects and infill environmental checklist was approved. The infill

4:29:39 Environmental Checklist determine the potential direct, indirect, and cumulative environmental effects associated with the project were previously inadequately analyzed. No further CEQA analysis is required for this project. In public comments, a public notice for the project was published in the sheet on Saturday, April 30th. Notices were mailed on April 26th to a total of 246 property owners within a 300-foot radius of the project site.

4:30:09 No public comments were received. So based on the analysis of the project provided in the staff report and the TTM findings for approval, staff recommends the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required Subdivision Map Act and Municipal Code findings and approving tentative tract map 22-001.

4:30:40 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Thank you. And I'm assuming there is no applicant because you guys are the applicant. We are the applicant as well as Pacific West. Got it. Okay. We do have Shellen Rodriguez on the Zoom if there's any questions. Okay. I'll throw it back to the commission now. Does anybody in the commission have any questions for staff or for the applicant? Commissioner Chang, please. This proposal is because it's

4:31:17 I mean, I read the document, but I'm assuming it's primarily financing driven, public financing driven, or is why is it so important to have 14 specific parcels? So Commissioner Chang, I'll maybe start responding to that and let Sean kind of finish. Yes, the reason to have all those parcels is financing driven. And as the town looks to develop each kind of

4:31:47 When you said financing, you were talking about public financing. No.

4:32:16 Towns provide a financing. The project, the future phases of the parcel, current and future phases of the parcel will include a mix of public financing from grants or different types of public financing sources. The town also will be contributing money to each phase. So we are contributing in the form of land loans, diff loans, and likely we'll have to contribute.

4:32:46 Straight cash to some of the phases. Thank you. Ellen, did you want to add to that or was that answer sufficient? I think, thank you for the opportunity and I would just, I would just add that answer is sufficient. The only thing I would add is that it, in addition to the public and private financing, it allows us flexibility in the type of housing that we're providing in regards to multifamily or

4:33:20 More smaller, like duplex, triplex, you know, sixplex type of thing, and then also ownership and rental opportunities. So those, the conglomeration of different size lots allows us just more flexibility overall. Commissioner Kennedy, did you have any questions for either staff or the applicant? Commissioner Burroughs? Any questions, thank you. Really, my only question is by subdividing this, the parcel into 14 smaller lots, is this in any way slowed down our build out out there?

4:34:00 No, it does not. Okay. But it has the opportunity, it could have the advantage of speeding up the build out down there. Is that correct? Yes. Because we might be able to access funds from different ways, different places. Yes. But each subsequent phase of the parcel still will come before this commission and town council for approval. Is that correct? So each subsequent phase will come before the commission for design review. Okay. That is not.

4:34:30 Got it. And that process,

4:35:00 applies to each, let's say a phase, I'm just trying to pull on numbers, let's say a phase compiled, comprised six smaller lots, let's say you guys tapped into some grant funding that let you build out two of those smaller lots, not the whole phase, does that process still in place where it comes before us for? Yes. Okay. Yes, so, I mean, the design review, so it's potential, the commission, we're anticipating bringing phase two to the commission.

4:35:30 in June. And so the Phase 2 has a number of different buildings. Phase 2 will actually be, I think, three lots through this subdivision. But four lots through this subdivision. So while the commission is going to improve the entirety of Phase 2 design-wise, we could go out and try to get funding for maybe Building A of Phase 2 or Building B of Phase 2. But the commission would look at Phase 2 as a whole. And I think that's the way we would proceed with each of the different phases.

4:36:01 But kind of short answer to your question, yes, the commission will see every different phase that's built throughout this project. Jamie, did we have any public comment on this? Sir, would you like to submit some public comment on this? You're our last standing man. Michelle, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm Michelle Morrison. I back up to the woods behind me. And this new, my question is, you want to build through Chaparral Road. Are you going to be clearing that?

4:36:37 of everything as you do that. And my other concerns are when this was first presented, it was a multi-use area. I was going to have two cottages behind me. Then it went to two-story buildings. And then at one of our last meetings, I was told that you could build whatever you wanted to behind me. And I'm hearing that

4:37:01 The villas went from 131 down to 33, and we're going from 250 to 580 units. It doesn't make sense to me why we're bearing the brunt of that. And the other thing is, what I've noticed is working on Sundays with special permits, that's not fair to any of us that live here, the constant beeping, the anxiety it causes, we have no quiet time throughout our whole week, none. My house literally vibrates.

4:37:31 I need a day off from that. The other thing is, I've been noticing dust devils back there. It's not being taken care of well enough. And there's been dust flying everywhere. So when I start opening up my windows this spring and summer, I'm going to have dust in my house from improper dust abatement. So that's it. That's what I needed to say. I just, I got so upset when I was listening to the Villa 3s. I'm going, wait, what about us?

4:38:01 You know, I mean, we have bears too, and we're like going from 250 units to 580, and you guys went less? How did you do that? So anyway, okay, I'm done. Thank you. Thank you, Michelle. Jamie, any other public comment? No, there is not. I'm going to close public comment, and Sandra, did you want to address, or Amy, I guess it's more your world, any of those questions that were brought up? I can maybe start in big picture. Just to kind of reiterate what Gina went through is this project, the

4:38:34 The master plan for the parcel was approved. So the entitlements, the overall zoning for the site has been set. The number of units have been set. And what you're seeing before you today is subdivision of the property that isn't related to any development. So this consideration today doesn't actually result in any development. All of the overarching zoning authority to allow was completed.

4:39:13 The only discretionary items needed in order to allow, so that's really looking at the colors, materials of the building, the placement of what's on the site, looking at how those buildings, adjacent properties, those, so just kind of a clarification about where we are in this process and what, and I think Amy. Sure, there was a question about tree removal, chaparral, and as far as hours of work on the parcel, hours of work are subject to our municipal, but that was not permission to work on Sundays. Sandra, anything else?

4:41:43 Back to the Commission. Anybody have any thoughts, opinions, any discussions or questions for staff or the applicant at this time? Please raise your hand. No, I see a couple of heads nodding no. Commissioner Burroughs? Then I'd be happy to entertain a motion at this time. Adopt the attached Planning and Economic Commission resolution making the required Subdivision Map Act.

4:42:26 Municipal code findings and approving tentative tract map number TTM 22-001 with conditions recommended by staff. Did I need to add that part? No. Thank you. Do we have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation amongst the commission? Jamie, may we have a vote please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy?

4:42:59 Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes 4-0. Good luck with the financing. Sandra, the rest of this agenda. We're going to get through it. Michael Paterka is coming back to present item 4. I'm happy to do that. Was I in brain lock there for a moment? That's okay. Item 4.4, consider approval of variance 21-001 for a 47.5% reduction in the rear setback.

4:43:38 to allow for a 10-foot, 6-inch setback for the proposed single-family residence and attached garage at 182 Davidson Road. The proposed action includes finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Guidelines Section 15303, New Construction of Small Structures. Michael.

4:44:00 Thank you. Sorry. Just before we start this item, I'd like to welcome Commissioner Eckert back as he is not conflicted out of this item and there are no conflicts on any of the future items. So just to know that all of the commissioners can participate. Hello again. All right. The property owner at 182 Davidson Road is requesting variance 21-001 for a 47.5% reduction to the rear guard setback.

4:44:30 which would allow a 10-foot-6-inch setback for the construction of a new single-family residence with an attached garage. 182 Davison is located in the Residential Multifamily 2 Zoning District, or RMF2. The existing conditions on the site consist of a 933-square-foot residence that was constructed in 1964. There is currently no covered or paved parking, and the lot size of 9,696 square feet is considered substandard for the RMF2 zone.

4:45:00 which has a standard lot size of 40,000 square feet. In addition to this parcel being substandard, Davidson Road is considered a substandard street. As a result, the property owner is required to provide a 10-foot irrevocable offer of dedication, or IOD, for the property. The IOD will be used for future street improvements on Davidson Road. When the IOD is accepted, the town will acquire the front 10 feet of the property.

4:45:29 The project is proposing a variance to reduce the standard 20-foot setback to a 10-foot, 6-inch setback to allow construction of a new single-family residence in an attached four-car garage. The project also consists of a new paved driveway and one paved outdoor parking space on a lot where no covered or paved parking currently exists. Additionally, the existing single-family residence will be converted to an accessory dwelling unit. And prior to certificate of occupancy for the new single-family residence,

4:45:58 A deed restriction will be required that prohibits the accessory dwelling unit from being rented nightly. Here we have the proposed site plan as well as south and east elevations for the project. The existing residence is located here. They'll be converted to the accessory dwelling unit. The garage and new single-family residence is located here.

4:46:35 Thank you.

4:47:09 Staff has determined that the findings for the variance can be met and recommends the adoption of the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approved variance 21-001 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modification. That concludes my presentation. I believe the applicant, Elliot Brainerd, is on if he is needed to. Elliot, did you want to address the commission or are you good? You may not be here.

4:48:02 We've got you out there as a panelist, so you are open to speak or make a presentation if you like or just answer questions. I think you can hear me now, right? Yep. Oh, great. First, thank all of you for a very long meeting. You guys have been at it for, you know, almost record time today. So I'll just make it brief, but I appreciate the opportunity to have this come to the commission.

4:48:31 The goal of this is to actually provide an ADU on this property, which is something that is a benefit to everybody, I think, in town. And this is for a full-time resident who does live at this location, which is great. And he's very excited to add, you know, the unit. So he has an additional long-term rental space.

4:49:00 He just wanted to get through the limitations on this property, which are unusual, obviously, the way the house was placed on the property, the original house, and being able to put in a new building has been a little bit of a challenge.

4:49:24 I think this will be a much improved option with a new driveway and turnaround space, covered and uncovered parking for both the proposed single family residence and the existing house, which gets converted to the ADU. And, you know, it maintains over a 10 foot, you know, 10 foot six setback in between a mountain back to the north and all the other

4:49:54 Appreciate it, Elliot.

4:50:24 At this time, I'm going to throw it back on the commission. Anybody have any questions for either the applicant or staff? Anybody out there in the Zoom world? Greg, do you have any questions for either person? Nope, I'm good on this one. Commissioner Chang, do you have questions for staff or for the applicant? I have one question for Elliot, please. Sure. Elliot, hey, thank you for the presentation. I just, real quick, I'm assuming the applicant is doing this instead of gutting the existing unit.

4:50:58 Is simply because for construction cost reasons and also for having additional unit on the property as available housing and additional income for the property? Yeah, the property is zoned RMF2, so it's a multifamily zone to begin with. And that existing house is the one,

4:51:31 You know, it's a one-story house. It's been renovated on the inside already, and so it's pretty limited into its remodel capability, and he really wants to add a garage because so far the property has nothing, doesn't even have a paved driveway or anything, which is pretty difficult and challenging for him. So he said, hey, let's add a bigger,

4:52:01 Residence for himself, and he'll move into the new building and have parking and doesn't want to obviously tear down the existing building. So it seemed like the best way to go. The new one is what, about 15 and change, 100 square feet? No, it's only 11, a little under 1,200 square feet, 1178, I believe, is the number for the livable portion. Got it.

4:52:30 Thank you. That's all I have. Commissioner Kennedy, any questions for staff or the applicant? Nothing for me. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs, I don't have any questions either. Any public comment on this, Jamie? No, there is not. All right. Then I'll throw it back on the commission. Unless somebody has any questions for staff or the applicant, I'd be willing to hear a motion at this time. I'll make a motion. Take it away, Greg.

4:53:02 I do propose that we adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings to approve variance 21-001 with conditions as recommended by staff, and I vote yes. I'll second. We have a second. Jamie, we have a vote, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. I'm going to make you say it again. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy?

4:53:33 Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 5-0. Congratulations. Thank you to all of you and hope you don't have to stay too much later. Thank you to Michael. We worked hard on this at the staff level and everybody, so much appreciated. We're going to move on to item 4.5, public hearing and consideration of a variance request to permit a zero-foot front yard setback.

4:54:04 A 100% reduction of the 20-foot front setback requirement for the construction of a detached single-car garage located in front of an existing single-family residence at 31 Malayus. The project is reviewed under Application Number Variance 2020-001 and is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Guidelines 15301E.

4:54:35 existing facilities. And I believe our staff contact is Kim. Thank you. And I have to say I misunderstood Sandra and I dismissed the applicant's representative, Mike Britton, who's the architect. So I'm going to do my best to answer all the questions if there are any. But I'll go ahead and share my screen. Is he on Zoom? Yay. Okay. Is he a panelist?

4:55:37 This is a public hearing for a variance request for 31 Mala Ulyse. The subject property is located at 31 Mala Ulyse in the residential single-family zoning district. The current assessor's record indicates that the existing single-family residence is approximately 1,546 square feet and was originally built in 1964.

4:56:05 The residence does not currently have any enclosed parking and two exterior parking spaces are provided in a tandem configuration within an approximately 40 foot deep paved driveway located along the east property line. This existing driveway was constructed on the east property line and the retaining wall on the east side of the driveway actually encroaches approximately two feet into the adjacent property to the east.

4:56:38 The variance application requests a 100% reduction of the front setback to allow a zero foot front setback for the construction of a new detached single car garage and this would be located in front of the existing single family home and it would utilize the existing retaining wall system and existing driveways for parking directly next to the proposed garage.

4:57:08 The interior dimensions of the proposed garage are 22 feet 9 inches in depth and 13 feet in width, and the total size of the proposed structure is 328 square feet. The placement of the proposed garage on the site utilizes, like I said, the existing retaining wall system located on the east and north sides of the driveway. The existing retaining wall located on the west side of the driveway would be removed in conjunction with the garage construction. The project architect, Mike Britton,

4:57:41 provided staff an explanation of specific development challenges that would result from moving the garage closer to the existing single-family home, and some of these challenges would include the need to shore up the house to demolish the existing foundation and install a new retaining foundation that extends down to the driveway level.

4:58:07 The architect has indicated that while this is a possible option, the costs associated with that additional work are really not aligned with the value of a single car garage and would be financially impractical for this project. The project narrative also indicates that the slope of the lot is just six inches shy of the minimum elevation gain required to allow an automatic reduced front setback of five feet for a residential garage.

4:58:38 This is a standard allowance for steep upsloping lots that is permitted in our municipal code based on the grade change of a site and the proposed zero foot front setback requested through this variance application would result in maintaining a 12.36 foot distance between the edge of the roadway pavement and the proposed garage structure.

4:59:05 This distance from the edge of pavement is comparable in some cases and greater in other cases to other properties that have been granted the automatic reduced five-foot front setback for steep-up sloping lots. So that distance from the edge of pavement is not untypical or is not much smaller than other cases where we've allowed a reduced front setback. And I have seen examples

4:59:39 of other properties located on John Muir Road to edge of pavement, their garages. Our engineering staff has reviewed this application and is supportive of the variance with incorporation of two specific conditions of approval. The first would require that the property owner execute a hold harmless agreement with the town which would release the town from any liability for damage to vehicles parked within the right-of-way.

5:00:08 As a result of snow removal operations or any other construction or maintenance of the right-of-way. The second is a 10-foot wide non-exclusive easement to the town which would be required for purposes of snow storage and would be located along the Southerly property line adjacent to Mala Ulysse and west of the proposed building footprint. These are included as conditions 25 and 26 in the draft PEDC resolution. I have included some images of the site to...

5:00:40 to better illustrate the existing foundation system for the single-family residents. The garage footprint proposed was shifted two feet to the west of its original position in response to staff's comments to ensure that an exterior 10 foot by 20 foot parking space would be maintained on the property in the event.

5:01:11 That the retaining wall on the east side of the driveway was removed for some reason. Because we can't consider the two feet that the property utilizes of the adjacent property, we can't count that as permanent area that would be available to this single-family home. The proposed design of the garage is compatible with the design of the existing home and is similar to the garage design on the adjacent property to the west, shown in this image here.

5:01:45 That garage also features a flat roof with a roof deck that is incorporated into the existing front deck of the home. And the garage design features a single car garage. So the proposed garage design features a single car garage door and rock siding on the east facing. The overall height of the garage is 15 proposed deck railing. Variance application was noticed. 82 notices were mailed at the site. It was also published in the...

5:02:31 On April 30th and May 7th, public comments have been... So in your draft resolution, the required findings for approval of a variance have been made. There are seven of them, and I've listed them here. I go through them. But essentially, we want to make sure that there are special circumstances applicable to the property. There are special circumstances applicable to this property, specific to topography.

5:03:12 The existing retaining wall system for the site due to the topography, granting the variance would not authorize a use which is not otherwise expressly allowed with the zoning district because covered parking is required for single-family residential uses. And the approval of the variance does not constitute a grant of special privileges in consistent same zone because if we see...

5:03:49 As we've seen, the adjacent property to the west features a similar sloping topography and has a reduced front setback as well for a similarly designed garage. The Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving variance number VAR22-001 with conditions as recommended by staff.

5:04:26 Thank you, Kim. Is the applicant on Zoom, Jamie? Hello, this is Mike Britton. Can you hear me? Yep. Okay. Let me know if you have any questions. I'd be glad to answer. Any explanations? I want to thank you guys for getting this in tonight. And thank you, Kim and Amy, from joining me at the start of the project out at the site to best discuss a way to move forward with this.

5:05:00 There were a lot of challenges. We looked at different options. And what we've come up with, I think, is the most feasible option and sensitive to the trees on the property, et cetera. And utilizing the existing hardscape or driveway space that is there. So I'm glad to answer any questions. Thank you, Mike. Appreciate it. Throw it back to the commission.

5:05:28 Anybody have any questions for either staff or for the applicant being represented by Mike? I'll start with Commissioner Chang. I just have a quick question for the applicant. The existing parking carport, tandem parking, that, what do you call it, a retaining wall is two feet past the boundary line. I'm assuming they're going to continue, the applicant's going to continue to use.

5:06:01 That area is for parking. Is that the case? That is correct. And originally we submitted plans that located the garage 10 plus feet from that retaining wall. But as Kim mentioned, we cannot guarantee that that space that encroaches in the neighbor's yard will

5:06:31 be available for the foreseeable future. So we moved the garage two feet to the west, which essentially gave us 12 foot plus of existing driveway. And that gives us the 10 by 20 parking space. So they are going to utilize that retaining wall and driveway as it is, unless they are directed by the neighbor not to.

5:07:01 Understood. Thank you. That's all I have. Commissioner Eckert, any questions for staff or the applicant? I have a question for the applicant. Please. Was there any thought given to building an ADU on top of this garage? There was not. Okay. That was my question. Yep. Commissioner Kennedy, any questions for either staff or for the applicant? Nope. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs. And I don't have any either. Jamie, do we have any public comment on this?

5:07:43 All right, and I'm assuming you're not here for public comment on this matter, right, sir? Okay. Then with that, I will throw it out for a motion if anybody wants to make a motion. Commission, resolution making the required CEQA and municipal findings in 22-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. Do we have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert?

5:08:29 I'm going to be a no because I think the zero setback ought to have some sort of benefit to the community. If this had an ADU on it, I'd be a yes. But putting something right on the street, I think it's a bad precedent. It's for economic versus there's just no public game in it. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 4-1.

5:09:01 All right. Thank you all, and have a good evening. Thank you, Mike. 4.6, public hearing variance 22.002 request to permit a 65% reduction of the required 20-foot front yard setback to allow for a 7-foot setback and adjustment 22-002 request a 9.3% building height increase to allow for a building height of 38 feet and 3 inches.

5:09:34 for the reconstruction of an attached garage and a single-family residence located at 751 Majestic Pines Drive. The project is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15303, new construction or conversion of small structures. And I believe our staff contact is Gina. Thank you.

5:09:59 So the property owner of 751 Majestic Pines is requesting a variance for a 65% reduction of the required 20-foot front setback, which would allow for a 7-foot front setback for the construction of an attached garage. The property owner is also requesting an adjustment to allow a 9.3% building height increase for an average building height of 38 feet and 3 inches for the reconstruction of a single-family residence.

5:10:28 751 Majestic Pines is located in the residential single-family zoning district. The site consists of a .23-acre site that slopes downward from the street at approximately 27%. The lot was previously developed with a single-family residence. In April 2017, the structure was destroyed by a fire caused by a propane leak on the property, and houses on both the subject property and the adjacent property were destroyed.

5:10:54 Due to the damage from the fire, the structure was demolished and the destruction exceeded 50% of the replacement value. Therefore, the rebuild of the structure either requires full conformance with the regulations of the RSF zone or approval of a variance and adjustment since, as previously mentioned, the proposed reconstruction of the residence does not conform to the current RSF development standards for setbacks or building height. The subject property and the majority of the surrounding properties are developed with single-family residence.

5:11:24 And the property to the south is open space that is part of the Aspen Creek condominiums and associated with the Mammoth Creek open space corridor. The requested 65% reduction of the front setback and 9.3% building height increase would enable the applicant to reconstruct a single-family residence and an attached garage. The proposed single-family residence is 4,042 square feet of habitable space, which consists of two floors with one master bedroom.

5:11:55 Living room, dining room and kitchen on the upper floor and four bedrooms on the lower floor. There is also an underfloor storage area under the structure which is non-conditioned, non-habitable. The total size of the garage structure is 697 square feet and does not include any conditioned living space. The proposed residence has an average height of 38 feet and 3 inches and the tallest ridge of the proposed residence is 46 feet above natural grade. Conditions of approval have been

5:12:24 So, for the reduced front setback, the property features an average downward slope of 27%.

5:12:53 Staff has determined that locating the structure further back on the property would only increase the overall height of the structure since the vertical distance from the street to the ground increases as the slope drops down. The standard 20-foot setback would push the structure further back, requiring additional grading and site disturbance in the rear of the property, which is adjacent to the Mammoth Creek open space corridor and would not be consistent with the general plan policies regarding preservation of natural features.

5:13:20 Several other single-family homes built on the same street have reduced front setbacks and properties that feature similar topography. These properties include the four properties directly to the west of the subject site, which were granted reduced front yard setbacks for garages in the reduced setback ranges from 5 to 10 feet. Therefore, this approval would not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and within the same zone.

5:13:56 So as far as the increased building height, the design of the single-family residence consists only of two habitable floors, but because the topography drops off dramatically from the front of the house to the back of the house, the building depth would need to be significantly shorter than neighboring structures in order to meet the 35-foot maximum building height, thus decreasing the overall habitable square footage that would otherwise be permitted on the property.

5:14:21 Also, the proposed residence is consistent in size and design with residents in the same vicinity and zone. The proposed single-family residence is 4,042 square feet with a three-car garage, two habitable floors and an eight-foot storage area at the bottom level. The adjacent properties have between two and three habitable floors and are similar in height to the proposed residence. The height would be well below the maximum height from the street level.

5:14:48 And finally, the building height increase would allow for a desirable roof pitch and design, which would be more functional for snow shedding compared to a lower pitched roof. This slide provides photos to illustrate the topography of the site. The photos include a view from the east side of the property looking west, the rear of the property looking up, and the Majestic Pines Drive, and from Majestic Pines Drive looking down. This slide provides photo, oh, sorry. This slide shows an image provided by the applicant that illustrates the height of surroundings.

5:15:22 of the surrounding residences. The image was taken prior to the 2017 fire and shows the previously constructed residence as well. Public notice for this project was published in the sheet on Saturday, April 30th. Notices were mailed on Wednesday, April 26th to a total of 108 property owners within a 300-foot radius of the project site and no public comments were received. Based on the analysis of the project,

5:15:53 Provided in the staff report and the variance findings for approval, staff recommends the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving variance 22-002 and adjustment 22-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or modifications. Thank you. Is the, are you, sir, are you the applicant? Please feel free to.

5:16:24 Come up here, let us know your name, and if you'd like to make a short statement. My name is Larry Gable, and we've purchased this lot right after it was demolished by fire from the existing owner. We've been residents of Mammoth since 1985, owning condos on the street adjacent to Majestic Pines. We're trying to rebuild a structure very similar to the house that was there.

5:16:54 We unfortunately don't have the plans of the house that used to be there because they went up and smoked with the house. We're building a house very similar to the one that was there. I'm here to answer any questions you might have. The setback we're requiring, we're requesting is the same setback that all four homes next to us have going up the hill because of the steep topography of the lot. So we're not asking for anything that anyone else doesn't already have on this lot.

5:17:26 I'm sorry, on the street. Can I answer any questions? Yeah, why don't you hang tight? I'll see if anybody has some. All right, I'm going to throw it back to the commission. Any questions for either staff or for Larry, the applicant? Commissioner Kennedy, how about I start with you? No questions. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, any questions for either? There's just one question. Are all the properties, adjacent properties, like similar size in terms of, you know, square footage?

5:17:59 Yes, sir. Actually, mine's probably the smallest. The one next to me that also burned is 5,700 square feet, and they're beginning construction. So all the rest of the homes to the west of me are larger than this one. Thank you. That's all I have. Commissioner Eckert, any questions for either staff or the applicant? Well, the applicant indicated he did not have plans, but I was wondering if staff...

5:18:27 Okay.

5:19:01 Well, assuming that what we're really talking about here is rebuilding a structure that, you know, burned down that was previously approved. And, you know, we certainly don't want to put a burden, or at least I don't want to put a burden on somebody who was struck by that kind of calamity. Personally, I feel that, you know, we ought to try and make it easier for people to rebuild after a horrible event like that.

5:19:28 And my only concern would be that we have some sort of restriction that does not allow the understorage below the house to be converted later into more living space. Well, that's it. Thank you. Appreciate it. Jamie, was there a public comment on this? No, there is not. Sandra, would you care to address the concern by Commissioner Eckert? Sure. Or Gina? I can try.

5:20:15 I'm just going to bring up some elevations that show that eight-foot understory, and just by, so it's eight feet, and it, as you, as it goes upslope, it gets shorter and shorter, so I don't really even think that the feasibility of that would be likely, but. We could include a condition of approval, any commission, so desired. The issue, I guess, is that it's.

5:20:44 The condition of approval should be added, should be kind of relative or related to the variance findings. So if there's a thought that additional habitable square footage of that lower level would change the kind of direction of the commission, then I think we can add that condition. However, if you feel that ultimately if you knew that that was going to become habitable, which it sounds like logistically it really probably can't, you would make a different decision than I would say we would.

5:21:14 Commissioner Eckert, how strongly do you feel about us adding a condition about that, your concern? I suppose if they really dug it out, there would have to be some sort of a violation of a grading permit for all that fill to go to. I'm not that concerned about it, but I am more in favor of the applicant's position of rebuilding an existing structure. Do plan to use that downstairs area, third floor area.

5:21:51 For storage, for our patio furniture, our barbecue, et cetera. However, there are other homes on that street that have a third story. And the home that burned, before it burned, they came in and the only thing that the city has for records is that that existing homeowner came in and asked for the third floor to be built out. And they were given approval to do that.

5:22:20 And shortly after that is when the house burnt. So I don't know why there would be a restriction if we decide to, if my family grows, if we decide to take the steps of building out that third floor. I don't know why that should be a problem when other homes on the street have that and the home that used to be there did have a built-out third floor. Any thoughts on that, ladies? Any additional thoughts? I think ultimately it comes back to the commission being able to make the findings for the variance.

5:22:53 The applicant did want to build out, subsequently build out that third floor. Like Gina was saying, it slopes, it cuts back into the slope, so I'm assuming you meant the headspace gets shorter and shorter and shorter. Yeah. He would need to pull a permit to grade it. Yes. It could just be something he would do on a weekend. Yes. Do you understand that, Larry? Absolutely. Okay. With that being said, I heard no public comment, correct? Correct. All right. Close public comment, and I'll throw it back in the commission.

5:23:23 Have any questions for staff or does somebody want to put a motion forth or Greg, did you want to put something? Well, we kind of heard from staff that there are restrictions to utilizing that third, that lower floor for living space unless they get secondary approval from the town. So any motions out there? I'll make a motion to

5:23:53 Adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving variance 22-002 and adjustment 22-002. That's it, I think. No conditions. Do we have a second? Second. Any further conversation? Just to clarify, Commissioner Kennedy made no additional conditions, but... Yes, thank you. You're welcome. Okay.

5:24:28 Jamie, may we please have a vote. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes 5-0. Congratulations, sir. Okay, we're going to put this in a warp drive. I'm going to make a motion that we approve the consent agenda in its entirety. Do we have a second? I'll second. Second. Do we have any conversation? Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert?

5:25:00 Yes. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Thank you. I'm going to say we skipped the commissioner reports in the hope of all of our evenings coming together. Sandra, director's report? I have about a 30-minute director's report. I hope every... No, the only note is that the commission is having a special meeting with the...

5:25:28 Town Council on May 25th, and I cannot recall the time right now off the top of my head, but I will send out, Commissioner Eckert, it's for the parcel, so Commissioner Eckert is conflicted out of that item, but I will send out a meeting invite to all of you so you have it on your calendars, and that's all I have. And just a heads up, Vice Chair, I will not be in town for that meeting, so you'll be leading the charge on behalf of this commission for that workshop.

5:25:55 All right, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting until our next regularly scheduled Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, which is held on June 8, 2022. Thank you, everyone. Thank you.