Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2022
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 14:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- A 2022 Town document says a 2009 EIR analyzed up to 742 rooms for Mammoth Crossing's three development areas Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
Transcript
327 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you, Sandra. You're welcome. Yes. You can. And, Michael, I let everyone else know that Paul will be about 15 minutes late, so once it's 2 o'clock, I think we can start. We have three of the other commissioners here in Sweet Z. I see that. I see Greg, I see Jen, and I see Commissioner Kennedy. So, yeah, once we hit 2, which we just did. Okay. I'm going to go ahead and call this meeting to order, the meeting of the Planning and Economic Development Commission.
1:12 for April 13th, 2022. Commissioner Eckert, would you care to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please? Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. Angie, may we please have roll call? Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Commissioner Chang, it will be late. Commissioner Kennedy? Present. And Commissioner Eckert. Thank you. Thank you, Angie.
1:59 I would like now to open up the public comment part of our agenda. I will ask if you have, if you like to submit public comment to a matter that is on today's agenda, that you wait until that agenda item has been open, and we would love to hear your public comment then. If you do have public comment pertaining to a matter that is not on today's agenda, then that would be the appropriate time to submit that public comment.
2:27 And we do also have some town staff here who I believe would like to submit some public comment as well. So Jenna, would you care to lead us off? Thank you very much. Jenna Carter with the town of Mammoth Lakes Code Compliance. I'll share my screen for some graphics to show you the last month's new caseload. So you should see a pie chart now. Yep.
2:51 You'll see I'm still focusing on signs and substandard conditions do take a lot of my attention. There are a lot of rentals in town that I'm still working on. But in general, between signs and substandard, those are my focuses. It was about 20 new cases last month. If anyone has any questions, that was the summary of my caseload. Any questions for Jenna from the other commissioners?
3:21 I don't see any. Hey, Jenna, can you just give us a quick explanation of what dust means? Dust, I've received complaints from some of the demo jobs in town, some neighbors. So there was one commercial building that was taken down in the middle of town. There was a little bit of dust complaint that came from that. And the other one would be a dust complaint about an interior paint job at a commercial space where dust was observed on windows and surfaces.
3:51 Although a concern, that's not something that the town oversees. We don't, so they were concerned about lead paint dust in that one, lead. Got it. I had to investigate both and everything and they were fine. Okay. Thank you, Jenna. I appreciate it. I don't think there's any questions from my other commissioners. So we appreciate your hard work and keeping us updated today. Thank you, Jenna. Thank you. I hope you have a great meeting. Do we have any other members of town staff that would like to submit public comment at this time?
4:22 I see a couple of names on there, but I don't know if they have something they want to put forward. I don't think we have anything else from town staff. Okay. Angie, do we have any members of the public, either on Zoom or personally there in Suite Z that would like to submit public comment on a matter that is not on today's agenda? I have no comments at this time. All right. I think I'll close public comment then, and we will move to the public hearing portion of today's meeting.
4:55 Item 4.1. I think everyone is aware of the fact that this item has been continued to our May meeting. We have received quite a bit of written public comments submitted, and I understand there are some members of the public that are present in Sweet Z at this time that do want to submit public comment on this matter, otherwise known as the Villas 3 subdivision. We would love to hear your...
5:23 Public comment right now. Angie, I am going to put a three-minute cap on it as we do have a pretty full agenda today. If you are just summarizing public comment that you have already submitted to the commission and town staff in a written format, if you want to summarize it really quickly, that'd be fine, but do know we have read everything that's been submitted to us in the last couple of weeks and in previous meetings.
5:50 Anybody from the public that wants to submit public comment now on the Villas 3 subdivision? And Chair Vanderhurst, just a note for this item that Commissioner Eckert has left the room as he has recused or conflicted out on this item. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. Mr. Taylor, you can come up and provide your public comment. Good afternoon, Commissioners. My name is Eric Taylor, and I oppose the Villas 3 plan and specifically the two duplex buildings pressed up against San Joaquin Villas.
6:26 Units 23 through 25 are unreasonably close and will severely degrade quality of life for my neighbors and my family.
6:35 They stare directly into our windows and onto our deck, stealing our privacy. They will block our sunlight, chill our homes, increase heating costs, delay snowmelt. Their huge shadows on us become that much larger when rooftop snow piles up. Then that snow will blow and be shoveled onto our property and block our back emergency exit.
6:58 Most of you visited San Joaquin Villas in March and witnessed the wall of snow that forms beside our buildings and doesn't melt until summer. Their units, so close to SJV, will create a similar wall of snow behind our building that blocks our emergency exit and is a safety hazard. And then there's the noise problem. The noise at night keeping us awake. Their balconies and open windows will project and amplify sounds directly at us.
7:26 The sound problems become significantly worse if you approve the overnight use permit. Please don't do that. Don't doom us and Joaquin Road neighbors with loud, inconsiderate renters every night. These partiers will be just feet from our bedrooms and when we need to sleep and rise early for work. The Lodestar Master Plan does not guarantee that these rentals have a use permit.
7:54 The Planning Commission and Mammoth Lakes Housing approved our subdivision, San Joaquin Villas, on condition of no overnight rentals. Intrawest built SJV as its housing mitigation commitment and that allowed them to build the Westin. The Planning Commission needs to honor the spirit of that agreement and not destroy our quality of life. Now there's another issue that has not yet been discussed.
8:22 Our neighborhood has been given the impression that there's a buffer zone south of SJV property that prevents buildings this close. For this, I cite the town's Sierra Star neighborhood plan, which shows it's impossible to build within 60 feet of SJV. As a reference, I've included that map in my letter submitted today. Also, in 2011, town planners wanted to build a multi-use path 50 feet south of SJV.
8:52 And town council discussed it right here in suite Z. That map, that path was to be exactly where units 22 through 25 are now planned. So for years the town communicated that a buffer zone existed south of us. Now, without warning, the planners are eager to approve the subdivision jammed, this subdivision jammed up onto us. This isn't right and these need to be removed. And we've seen this last year.
9:20 Prices in Mammoth for real estate have skyrocketed. They're up 25 to 35 percent over the last year, and this directly benefits the developer. Don't get me wrong, I'm good with the developer making good, huge profits on this project. You know, it's an American dream. I support it on the condition that it's done fairly. I ask you to please, please consider the hundreds of residents here in town
9:50 with their own American dream here in Mammoth close to this project. Please do not crush our dreams simply because we have one individual who is looking to accumulate wealth at our expense. Thank you for your consideration. Thank you, Mr. Taylor. Thank you, Mr. Taylor. Appreciate it. Any other public comment in person from Sweet Seed? We have one other public comment. Please.
10:27 Good afternoon, Commissioners. My name is Judith Goddard. I'm also a Samarkin Villas resident, Unit B4. My first comment is really related to the process. My concern is that a 2 p.m. weekday hearing, it really appears like it's deliberately designed to exclude the workforce community that is going to be directly impacted by this project. So I really ask that you think about that. Additionally, the timing of the document release.
10:57 It doesn't allow the public or the commissioners a reasonable time to review and digest the vast quantities of documents that are going to be released and that they won't show changes that have been made. So I just think that it's not fair or reasonable on anyone involved in the process to force a 33-unit development to be reviewed in the same timeline as a single-family home is given.
11:26 So with that, this is my second time requesting that we have an updated timeline and get at least one week to review the documents when they are released to the public. So I would like to make that a formal request, please. So I'm a five-year board member at San Joaquin Villas. I'm very aware that we have deed-restricted units and a majority of full-time local workforce owners and residents.
11:56 It's likely none of whom have the luxury or the financial means to simply move when the Villas 3 development absolutely destroys their quality of life. So the planning department and you as commissioners, you hold these people's futures in your hands as you make decisions related to the Villas 3 application. Please, I ask you, do not destroy this thriving neighbourhood.
12:24 with a short-sighted determination to maximize TOT income. Require meaningful change to the previously submitted plans and building designs. I request that you require the buildings immediately south of SJV's E building be moved a reasonable distance away from the existing homes. And to me, 75 to 100 feet sounds reasonable.
12:51 Only allow balconies on the side of buildings that face into the villa's development or face the golf course. Please do not approve the requested height deviation, the height adjustment for the three single-family homes. We're all aware that plenty of developers in town have successfully met the existing height requirement. Do not approve the use permit.
13:18 As my friend and neighbour has already said, the Low Star Master Plan is quite clear. There is no guarantee of a use permit for the location that's under development. And the vast number of concerns that you've received from the public really demonstrate that a use permit is not appropriate for this location adjoining workforce housing and also residential neighbourhoods on Joaquin Road.
13:45 A new EIR is essential. We've seen an extensive addendum to a 32-year-old EIR, which demonstrates it's simply not an appropriate approach. Lastly, with the resulting increased flow of traffic, I ask that you require mitigation from the developer to address this significant road safety hazard at the dangerous staggered junction that we have.
14:12 where Callahan, the Frontage Road and Main Street intersect. So thank you all for your time and attention this afternoon. I truly hope that the next time we meet we will have fair and reasonable plans before us that have truly taken into consideration the many public comments raised and that the plans show meaningful change. Thank you. Thank you, Judith. Appreciate your time today.
14:42 Any other public comment in person in suite G, either Sandra or Angie? I believe we have one more public comment. My neighbor Donna Mercer, Mercer is currently driving the school bus. She asked if I could play her recorded message. Good afternoon, my name is Donna Mercer. I have come to you with this pre-recorded message. I cannot attend today's hearing because I am working for the school district.
15:14 Maybe you could have a hearing at 7 p.m. like most cities do in all of California so all of us in the community can attend. I have many concerns but I only have three minutes and I'll focus on a few. First, the planning process is biased against town residents and pro for the developer and the public's request to change this has been completely ignored and here are three examples. One, the hearing schedule.
15:43 The people most impacted by Villa 3 needs to work at the time of these PEDC daytime meetings. At San Joaquin Villa is workforce housing, as you know, and the PEDC and planning division approved our neighborhood. We asked a dozen times, please schedule these hearings in the evening so residents can attend. Two, the short time to review the staff report.
16:11 Staff has five weeks to prepare for today's hearing and has an additional four more weeks. Yet us residents, we will only get four days to review all documents and then generate a written response. This process suppresses public comment and this is bias for the developer. Example three, the March 3rd staff report choose to include a fake so-called shadow in solar study.
16:41 to bias the commissioners. I request that study be removed and the town staff acknowledge that report is full of errors. Don't use my tax dollars to enforce false information and then use it against the residents. My second and biggest concern is the negative quality of life impacted by Villas 3. Please read my written letter submitted April 7th that details the outrageous problems with units 22 through 25. Loss of sleep.
17:12 Loss of sunshine, loss of privacy, loss of an emergency exit. These two duplexes should not be built and the use permit should not be approved. Please listen to the community. My letters include 150 plus signatures on a petition opposing Villas 3. My third big issue is the flagrant disregard of the CEQA and ERI requirements for this project.
17:41 At the very minimum, the 31 plus years the town is legally required to perform a new initial study with subsequent public review period. Any expert and lawyer would agree. Please see my letter March 2nd in public comments that include the analyst of an expert who has EIR experience from L.A. County. He has over several decades of experience in dealing with ERI issues.
18:11 Encourage public participation as one of the fundamental objectives of CEQA. The town needs to show it cares about the public participation in the environment by requiring a new initial study. So much has changed in the past three decades that it is not addressed in the amendum. Several drought, skyrocketing, greenhouse gas emissions, sickness in dying trees, impact on wildlife, and so much more.
18:42 Do not simply rubber stamp another amendment and cover up the environmental issues related to this project. It is wrong. I will stop here only because my hearing time is up. To summarize, please don't be biased against the residents who give all for our town. And please don't allow units 22 through 25 to be built and ruin our quality of life. Please require a new EIR study that allows public...
19:13 Thank you. Thank you, Eric. Would you please let Donna know that her recording was heard by the commission today? I most definitely will. Thank you. Thank you. Angie, any other in-person public comment on agenda item 4.1? I see none at this time.
19:46 Do we have any new written public comments since the last email you sent out approximately an hour ago? Last written comment on this item would have been from Eric Taylor and Kimberly Taylor. Got it. And we have received that and read it. Anybody wants to submit public comment via Zoom? Angie? I have no hands raised at this time. Thank you. All right. Then I'm going to close public comment on item 4.1.
20:17 Appreciate all of your time there in Suite Z. And again, this item has been continued to our May, Sandra, what's the date on that? May 11th? May 11th, yes. Our May 11th meeting. So I look forward to seeing you guys then. So I'm going to have to move, I'm going to move on to 4.2 and I'm actually going to have to recuse myself from this agenda item due to a personal conflict. So I believe Vice Chair Burroughs is going to take it.
20:47 from here, and I am going to turn off camera and turn off microphone. Thank you, and we'll note that Commissioner Eckert is returning to the room. Thank you, Michael. Thank you, Sandra. Up next, as Michael said, is item number 4.2, consideration of tentative tract map 21-003, use permit 21-004.
21:16 And major design review 21-004 for approval of the residence in boutique by Marriott development project located at 94 and 150 Burner Street in the specialty lodging. And I think our staff report goes to Kim, if I'm not correct. Thank you. I'm going to share my screen. All right. Thank you. This is the public hearing for the consideration of the proposed residence in Kotel by Marriott.
22:12 located in the North Village specific plan area. I'm going to start off with the project location. The subject property is located at the southeast corner of Burner Street and Forest Trail. Just one other note that Commissioner Chang is also conflicted out of this item, so he has turned off his video and muted himself as well. Sorry about that. Thank you.
22:42 So the property consists of two individual parcels and with a combined area of 2.1 acres. The property is within the specialty lodging zone of the North Village specific plan and the site is currently developed with four commercial industrial style buildings as well as one unoccupied single family residential structure. All of the existing development of the site would be removed including
23:10 existing asphalt pavement in order to accommodate the proposed development. The developed portion of the site is relatively level along the south and west portions of the property, but the northern portion of the site features a significant slope, upward slope, with an approximate grade change of 40 feet from the north property line to the south property line. The northern portion of the property fronts on Forest Trail.
23:38 and features a stand of approximately 100 Jeffrey Pine trees and some fir trees, which the site plan indicates will be preserved. So I'm going to go through a summary of the proposed project. The proposed hotel is a four-story condominium hotel consisting of 101 condominium units, which are hotel rooms.
24:09 The tentative tract map is proposed to approve the condominium subdivision for a whole ownership unit type. Each guest room features a kitchenette with a built-in refrigerator, cooking range, sink, and microwave, as well as a dining area, work desk, closed closet, vanity area, and bathroom with a shower. The units feature a sofa seating area with a flat screen television.
24:37 And different room types offer a variation of beds, including king or double queen beds and rooms with accessory bunk beds that would better accommodate families. There is understructure parking provided on the first two levels of the hotel.
24:56 provides for 109 vehicle parking spaces in just a standard configuration that would allow all guests to self-park and would not require any valet services for the operation of the hotel. The hotel also includes on-site amenities oriented to guests at the hotel and that includes a lobby with a bar and lounge, a great room dining area, an outdoor covered patio with seating and fire features,
25:25 Fitness Center, an indoor pool with a jacuzzi, and a fourth floor covered viewing balcony with seating and fire feature. The project density is 101 hotel guest rooms, which equates to 48 rooms per acre. This is the maximum allowed density within the specialty lodging zone of the North Village Pacific Plan, and the project is consistent with that standard.
25:57 So this slide shows some of the site context of the surroundings. All of the surrounding properties are located within the North Village specific plan. So this is not a perimeter site. The property is bounded by Forest Trail on the north side, Burner Street to the south and west, and two specialty lodging zoned parcels along the east property line. The two adjacent SL...
26:25 Zone parcels are developed with the Innsbruck Lodge and the Kitzbühel Apartments. The area north of the site across Forest Trail is a town-owned community center property developed with tennis courts and surface parking. And the Berner Street surface parking lot is located on three separate parcels to the west of the site across Berner Street. Properties located to the south of the site are all zoned Resort General.
26:54 One is a vacant parcel, and two are developed with single-family homes. The project site is physically separated from the main village center, however, along the existing Berner Street parking lot, there is a pedestrian easement that runs along the south end of that parking lot, and that provides a direct connection to the signaled pedestrian crosswalk on Minaret Road.
27:23 Okay, so a little bit of site history. In 2009, the Vista Point Project was approved for the site, and this development was a resort condominium project consisting of 28 resort condominium units with a total of 101 bedrooms. So there was a mixture of three and four bedroom units in that project. The illustrations shown here are of the south and west elevations and the southwest corner of the project.
27:56 The previously approved project does feature similar heights and massing as the current proposed hotel structure. Since the existing tentative vesting tentative tract map and use permit for the Vista Point project will not expire until November 2023, the existing entitlements will need to be rescinded concurrently with the approval of the new tentative tract map use permit and design review.
28:23 Staff would record the agreement that was included in your packets for a voluntary rescission of those entitlements. We would record that agreement prior to recording any PEDC approval resolution to ensure that that happens. So some background on the review for this project. We have
28:50 Major design review applications on projects that are deemed significant by the community and economic development department are required to go through a review with our advisory design panel prior to being considered by PEDC. The role of the ADP is to provide impartial professional feedback to town staff and the applicant on site planning and building design based on the applicable development standards and design guidelines.
29:19 ADP recommendations are typically used to make changes that improve a project's conformance with the applicable guiding documents, which are the North Village Pacific Plan and the Village Design Guidelines for this project. We held an ADP meeting on January 7, 2022 to consider the project design, and the ADP provided consensus comments and recommended modifications.
29:48 to the project to better meet the intent of the village design guidelines. So on the left side of this page we have the project that was reviewed by ADP and on the right hand side we have the revised project that responded to the comments provided by ADP. Some of the comments that were received that were considered consensus comments required incorporation of a warmer color palette.
30:20 And to eliminate the light gray stucco color for the exterior wall material, to incorporate natural stone for the building-based material instead of cultured stone, to enhance windows on all sides of the buildings through the incorporation of a darker window frame, an addition of a sill or deeper recessed window. I should go through and just kind of mention how they've changed the design to meet these comments.
30:51 The design on the right did incorporate more natural wood, which provides a more warm color palette, and the windows have been enhanced through the incorporation of extended and recessed balconies along all of the facades of the building. This provides a deeper recess for the window, and in addition they've added some
31:21 Shed roof shelter at the top of some of the balcony structures, which adds some additional architectural detail. Another comment was to add decorative metal screening, the full length of the parking structure openings along Burner Street frontages and at the southeast end of the structure that abuts the Kitzbühel apartments. The applicant has incorporated that change.
31:50 The portico chair design should be revised so that the roof does not directly abut the lobby windows. They did revise the design of the portico chair and it does not directly abut the windows any longer or interrupt the full length of the window. Another comment was to add a trellis structure roof element over the outdoor patio area. That element has been added to the design. Enhance and enlarge the cornice detail at roof edges.
32:22 The applicant has increased the size of the cornice detail on the flat roof parapet walls. The corner shed roof elements appear to be an afterthought and should be tied in more cohesively with the overall building design. So the applicant has enhanced the design of the embellished roof elements on the three corners of the hotel structure. They've extended the length of the wood.
32:54 Struts that attach to the hotel wall to make those appear to be a more significant structural element. Mitigate the building height at the southeast corner of the structure to provide a more effective transition to the adjacent residential apartment building to the east. So the southeast corner of the lot is the lowest elevation area of the lot. There had previously been an exposed foundation wall at that corner.
33:29 Since this comment, the applicant has chosen to build up the dirt work in that area to bury the foundation wall and that brings up the soil so that the landscaping would basically become effective more quickly because the level there will be higher than it was previously and overall the building height would appear a little bit lower than it had previously.
33:59 So that kind of sums up the changes that were made. And staff felt that the changes to the plans had successfully addressed the ADP's recommendations. And because of that, we did not have a second ADP meeting. So the final design of the structure combines a contemporary building form with Mountain Lodge architectural details, including exposed wood beams, wood struts.
34:30 Stone building-based material and composite wood-like siding. The three corners of the hotel feature the embellished tower design with the upward sloping shed roof supported by substantial wood beams. Additional shed roof elements featuring the wood beams and exposed rafters are provided to shelter hotel room balconies as well as the outdoor patio and port-a-cachere design.
34:59 So in your staff reports, I did include a consistency analysis table to go through each of the applicable development standards that are identified in the North Village specific plan. The project is consistent with all of those applicable development standards as well as the zoning requirements included in the North Village specific plan. I would like to just point out
35:25 Two of those, which kind of have additional discussion related to them. The first one is building height. So the tallest ridgeline on the proposed structure is at the corner towers with the shed roof. And the tallest ridgeline there is 55 feet in height. The maximum allowed height in the specialty lodging zone is 40 feet.
35:52 And the North Village specific plan states that when all or a portion of a building sits above a parking garage, the building height is measured from the garage roof elevation at the perimeter of the building. Built parking garages are not allowed to be any taller than 20 feet at any point. So when we subtract 20 feet from that 55 foot at the highest ridgeline, we get a building height of 35 feet, which meets
36:22 The applicable development standard. The other standard I would like to just point out is the required parking ratio. These are all considered studio or one-bedroom units, and those size units require 1.05 space per unit. So with the 101 units proposed, that would require 106 parking spaces.
36:50 The project proposes 109 parking spaces provided within the understructure parking garage. That includes, I believe, three van-accessible ADA parking spaces. And on the exterior, next to the port-a-cachere, there are four check-in vehicle parking spaces. And there is also one tour bus parking space, which will feature an electrical hookup.
37:23 And that is required for new lodging uses in the North Village Pacific Plan if they are planning to book any hotel guests that will utilize a tour bus for their transportation. We have received a number of public comments for this project. In total, we've received seven public comment letters prior to this public hearing.
37:59 The common theme within the comment letters have been traffic-related, concerns regarding increases in traffic. Some of the comments indicated that the project height was very tall and didn't seem to fit within the Mountain Village setting. And staff, being me and Amy, we did go to the site.
38:26 to meet with three residents that live east of the project in the residential neighborhood there. And we discussed their concerns about some of the existing traffic signage that exists out at the site. And we discussed their concerns about increases in traffic moving east on Berner Street. So in response to those comments, we have included conditions of approval 119.
38:55 and 120, which require that prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy, the property owner agrees that any promotional or informational reference, read it, referencing the means of travel or directions to or from the project must promote vehicular access via Forest Trail west of Burner Street and shall deter access via Forest Trail east of Burner Street.
39:28 Rusty Lane, Alpine Circle, or Mountain Boulevard. And condition number 120 states that the applicant shall coordinate final driveway design and any appropriate signage, including right turn only to Village, Main Street, and Downtown signage to the satisfaction of the Public Works Department in order to physically direct traffic west and north on Burner Street towards Forest Trail and Minaret Road rather than
39:58 towards streets such as Alpine Circle, Rusty Lane and Mountain Boulevard. In addition to these conditions of approval, our Public Works Department will evaluate the appropriateness of maintaining the seasonal snow berm closure on Alpine Circle to alleviate any existing traffic concerns that stem from issues where people aren't aware that that closure exists.
40:30 So that sums up the public comments for the project. With that and based on the information included in your staff reports, staff is recommending that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution.
40:58 Making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving tentative tract map number 21-003, use permit, UPA 21-002 and major design review number DR 21-003 with conditions as recommended or with modifications. That was a typo. The applicant team is on the Zoom call if you have any questions for the applicant.
41:31 I know that they would like to introduce themselves and talk a bit about the project and their company and turn it over to you. Thank you. If we can have the applicant give any comments or explanations. Yeah, I just had a, you know, just a real brief intro that I'd like to do and if now is appropriate then I'll go ahead from my side. Please go ahead. Thank you.
42:05 I wanted to start off by saying good afternoon to the Planning and Economic Development Commission, the city staff and all the local constituents involved in this project. I want to thank you guys for having us here this afternoon. My name is Atman Kadakia and I'm the managing principal here for Greens Development. We're based in Irvine, California and we have over 30 hotels either open for business, in construction.
42:32 We're in development and we are very excited to develop this hotel here in the town of Mammoth Lakes nearby the Village Lodge. One of the things that makes us very unique is that we are not only the developer but we are also the general contractor and ultimately we are the operator of all of our projects. We very rarely sell our properties and so we're highly invested in things that affect the backbone of the project such as parking, traffic circulation, access and ultimately we just take a great deal of pride.
43:02 in the quality of our products. I want to take a moment to thank staff for all their hard work on this project and commend the whole city team for having the vision to support a project like the one we're proposing, which will not only help support tourism for the town of Mammoth Lakes, but will also help serve the needs of many residents, visitors, and businesses of the city. Specifically, I want to thank Nolan Bobroff and Dan Holler, who were vested early on, as well as Sandra Moberly.
43:31 who helped make this project a reality throughout. Lastly, I want to thank Kimberly Cook, who has been extremely helpful, very responsive, and has methodically worked with us on this project. The advisory design panel has also been very helpful, as they were able to help improve our architectural design considerably by sharing ideas on how our project could be more compatible with the neighborhood and the surrounding community.
43:57 On our team, I want to thank my entire development team at Greens for their hard work over the past three years on the project. To my entire consultant team, including our landscape architect, Josephine McProud, our engineer, Tom Platt, our architect, Kelsey and Bob. And I also want to thank Matthew Lehman, who has been instrumental in not only helping us find this property,
44:25 Thank you so much for joining us today.
44:51 That is certainly not our vision. We have never proposed a paper project, and we carefully have focused and analyzed the project that we're proposing to the cost to develop versus the product to ensure that this project becomes a reality. We're proposing a residence inn by Marriott, which is an extended stay hotel within the Marriott family. All of our rooms will have full kitchens along with high-quality finishes. The hotel is designed to serve the needs of many businesses and families.
45:21 including displaced from their homes during fires, floods, or simply may just be between homes. We also expect to invest $40 million to develop this hotel, and we are anticipating that the hotel will generate over a million and a half a year directly back to the city's general fund, which the city can then utilize to provide other community benefits and services.
45:47 Once again, I want to thank you all for your time this afternoon, and we look forward to the next steps. Great, thank you. This time I'd like to open up to the commission for questions for the applicant. I have a couple questions for Steve. I wonder if you could say a little bit about the traffic for this project and any project goes through various other departments, just at that. Sure. So the traffic evaluation that was submitted with the application did evaluate the
46:44 Traffic, the new trips that would be generated by this use. And the conclusion of the traffic evaluation was that the number of AM and PM peak trips was less than 100 and did not rise above the threshold to require a more significant track based on those numbers.
47:13 That traffic evaluation was reviewed by our public works and was accepted and the North Village specific plan identifies specific traffic and circulation improvements or considerations for improvements by our public works department and the traffic evaluation that was submitted did go through that list of
47:43 So, based on that,
48:14 We didn't find that the project specifically triggered any additional mitigation measures aside from what's already been adopted in the specific plan program EIR and was sufficient to address the circulation and additional traffic for this project. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Eckert? Kim, you said that the 100 trips a day is under the threshold. What is the threshold? I'm not a traffic engineer.
48:54 I would defer to the applicant's consultant, who I believe is on the call. If he can answer to that general standard threshold for traffic studies, that would be really helpful. Yeah, hi, Kimberly. This is Atman Kadakia. So our traffic engineer is double booked, actually has another commission as well. So he'll be joining in a little bit.
49:23 But what I can say is that the threshold is 100 peak trips per day. So we are below that threshold. As far as the exact amount that were below the threshold, I don't have that in front of me, but that was part of the analysis done by the traffic engineer. I just got a message from somebody on my team here saying that we are at 47 trips in the a.m. and we're at 60 in the p.m., which is well below
49:52 The threshold, which is 100 peak trips per day. Thank you. Commissioner Ecker, I have a quick question. Have we studied how many people will be walking around that area since it is village specific and not using their car, like just parking their car there? Yeah, so this is Atman. I can speak to that as the operator of the hotel.
50:33 One of the things we intend to have as an operational item in the hotel is a shuttle during the season, notably the ski season. And even though we are walking distance to the gondola, we would also provide that shuttle service just given the type of guests who stay with us to provide an additional form of convenience.
50:58 So to your point, there will, in our opinion, be very few folk who actually use their vehicle once they come up to the hotel during the peak tourism market season, excuse me. And so as it's very walkable to the Village Lodge, which is a primary source of destination, dining, entertainment, we don't anticipate our customers.
51:26 Getting in their car and doing a lot of driving once they're up in the hotel. I just want to confirm that that shuttle would not be going through the residential areas, but in fact going on our main streets. No, absolutely not. So this is a very important thing. I just want to speak to this. We're very focused on operating the hotel in a manner that supports the community, works for the community.
51:56 And also is a very, very convenient to our hotel guests. We don't believe it's good for our hotel guests to go down Burner Street and head towards Alpine Circle. It's also not good to go down Forest Trail and head down through the residential neighborhoods. That is not the roads that are groomed as frequently and as well as the roads that are on Minaret and Main Street. They're not the roads that we recommend our guests.
52:24 So one of the things that we would do operationally is at the front desk when you check into the hotel, similar to checking into other hotels where they give you material on where the local dining options are, what to do, what the know-how within the community, we would have a disclaimer that is in every single hotel guest check-in packet that basically advises them that when you exit the parking garage from our hotel,
52:49 We recommend that you take a right. You are prohibited from going down Burner Street towards Alpine Circle. You're prohibited to go down Forest Trail. We don't believe that it's safe for our guests to go down through these roads that don't get the same level of service from the public departments of things like snow removal, etc. And so we advise all of our guests to go down Burner Street and we'd have a map that we would show how they should circulate within the town.
53:17 We find that when you have guests who come in from out of town, they look at that as feedback and it's very unlikely that they would disobey all of our signage, disobey everything that we put there, as well as the informational packet, the advisory packet that we would present to them at check-in. Any additional comments from the commissioners? Being none, let's open it up to public comment. Yes, my major concern is traffic. Forest Trail is already a nightmare.
54:14 The town has any sort of plans to like a traffic circle or something on Minaret and Forest Trail or there needs to be something done. Also we've been over the years we've had lots of comments on you know can we reduce the speed limit on Forest Trail. We find it ridiculous that it's at 35 miles an hour when it should be 25 like it is on Upper Forest Trail. I'm glad that the developer is considering you know
54:49 Not sending his customers down Forest Trail. Like he said, you know, the terrain's pretty sketchy, as we all know. But still, to get everybody to do a left turn towards Minaret, it's just going to add to the existing traffic. I'm sure you guys already know that the traffic in front of the village on a weekend, it gets backed up sometimes all the way up to the scenic road. Well, how is his customers going to get out?
55:18 and about, or a shuttle bus, or whatever. So I think the town needs to sort of step it up and figure out a more realistic traffic pattern in order to get people out of there before this, I mean, no offense to the developer, but I think the town needs to figure something out here. Let me see, what else is there? I think that's about it.
55:46 I just have questions for you guys. How are you going to deal with it? Or for even like future developments, it's a problem already. Oh, my other question is, you guys have mentioned that we're under this 100 car threshold. Could you clarify that for me, please? So typically we take public comments and then if the Planning Commission asks us to respond, we'll respond to all the comments at the end if that works. All right.
56:19 Okay. That's all I have for now. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other members of the public who wish to speak? Thank you. My name is Lita Minguez. I live at 50 Rusty Lane. Excuse me. 50 Rusty Lane with my husband, Ariel, and I. And we purchased in 2018. And I'm really excited about this project going in. It's a good thing. I know that.
56:55 But one thing I would like to emphasize is that being on Rusty, it's one of the streets that does not get the snow removal as quick as other places in town. So there's a downward slope from Forest Trail and what happens there in the winter is a ton of traffic goes sliding down to the bottom of the hill.
57:21 And my husband and my kids or whoever's visiting end up having to pull them out from the bottom of the hill. So it happens often. And if the hotel visitors come that way off a forest trail going east on Rusty, they're going to end up at the bottom of the hill waiting for a AAA, which takes a long time to get there, and or my husband and his truck to pull.
57:49 So I just wanted to emphasize that, that the traffic pattern there, especially in the winter, is going to be a problem, especially if there's 100 visitors and they all have one car and they all come down on a Friday night, there's going to be a pileup right there on the corner. So I just want to emphasize that. I also wanted to add our names to a letter. You had seven letters you noted regarding...
58:18 Possible review of the traffic mitigation, and I'd like to add our name to that, to one of those same letters, if that's okay. For me, in agreement that some mitigation and or further discussion as to other possibilities of traffic, I know it's difficult, but I'm sure with all the professionals here that there is going to be a way to at least the flow as much off the quiet and peaceful residents in the area.
58:53 Somehow, so we appreciate that. Thank you. I'm Nicole Godoy, resident on Mala Uli. I want to do, Monica, additional comments to the traffic mitigation. We were also promised by the town when they did do a change the entrance and exit to the village parking that there would be signage. Signage did get put in place, one little left turn only sign. It has not worked.
59:27 Residents or visitors do not read signage. You go and you look at the village parking lot and even just the little kiosk has 20 signs on there. People are so over reading signs. I mean, I love the project. I'm totally for it. But we need to have some additional mitigation for traffic into the neighborhood. I live on Alpine Circle. Nicole just mentioned when you guys, when the parking lot entrance was changed.
1:00:13 What that also does, especially on busy weekend days, because people are lined up to get into the parking lot, you cannot even drive down Burner Street to get onto Alpine Circle. So you have to drive on the wrong side of the road if you want to get past the line of traffic that's trying to get into the parking lot. The signs that were put up, as Nicole said, didn't do anything.
1:00:43 I would really like to see Burner Street closed off so that people cannot come down our street. But then that just makes the problem worse for the other directions too. And if people do read the signs and are not turning right onto Forest Trail, then they're turning left onto Forest Trail and then you can't get out onto Minaret.
1:01:12 There's got to be a better solution. I'm not sure what it is, whether it's a roundabout or something else. I am in favour of the project as well, but the traffic is going to be huge. We all, in all of those streets, have cars in our driveways. We've been hit just turning into our driveway because people can't stop coming down the hill when it's slippery. There's got to be a different solution.
1:01:49 Any other members? We've got another one coming. Judith Goddard, still at San Joaquin Villas. My observations on that would be the parking, the 100, 109 parking spaces seems very ideal, very idealized. It doesn't seem to allow for any employee parking anywhere, so I wonder if that's been taken into consideration at all, because that's got a likelihood to impact the neighboring community as well.
1:02:20 And they're just on a very minor thing with the ADP recommending a warmer color palette. I was kind of surprised to see so much blue still left because that doesn't seem like a very warm color. So thank you. Thank you. Angie, do we have any members of the public on Zoom? We do. Christy Williams, you can go ahead and make your comment. Thank you. My name is Christy Williams. Oops.
1:02:51 Apologies. I live at 52 Mali Ulysse, which is a little cul-de-sac that's off of Alpine Circle in just a couple of blocks from the proposed development site. And I am a signatory on the group comment, but since the agenda packet came out and it was published, I've had a chance to review some of the materials and I have an additional comment. So I've wanted to start off by saying I do think the project's beautiful. I want to commend staff and the ADP of doing a really great job in reviewing the design elements to make some
1:03:18 really nice improvements, and I don't oppose the project itself. Again, my concern is the traffic as per the group comment, and I was a little surprised at what came out in your agenda packet, and what you'll see in the materials in front of you and that were presented today, it indicates and it assumes that the additional traffic that the project will create
1:03:38 will be at acceptable levels, and it makes the assumption the residents and guests will seek driving directions from the property itself, not from GPS, and will read and obey the signage. And with all due respect to Mr. Kadakia, we know that's not true of our local guests. It's not happening currently.
1:03:57 You're being asked to sign off on a project that will be adding traffic from 101 guest rooms potentially into our small neighborhood streets and the only traffic mitigation measures required of the property and the developer are signage and messaging. Points 119, 120 on your draft resolution.
1:04:17 I saw in the agenda materials that a good and very specific review of how the project fits within the North Village specific plan occurred, and I commend that. But our neighborhood, which is only a few blocks away, is not in the North Village. We're actually in a different district altogether, and the intersection is not planned for in the NVSP. So there doesn't seem to be
1:04:43 Any detailed review of how the project affects the general plan. At least I didn't see it if it was done. And I believe the general plan is the default document for our neighborhood since we do not have a Knowles district plan.
1:04:58 So over the past couple of days, I found out that there is a whole 108-page mobility element of the general plan, and within that document, there is some really great direction as to address this issue. There's multiple points, but since I only have a few minutes, I most specifically want to call your attention to Action M.3.2.1, which talks about holding traffic management workshops with neighborhood groups.
1:05:24 So my concern here is that nobody is looking at the project from a bigger picture. It's being looked at very myopically as a single project, specifically through the traffic lens, only looking at how many additional visits will be generated. And all week, I've been trying to figure out who has the responsibility to make sure we are looking at the bigger picture and that we are following the general plan. So last night, I looked at the Planning Commission website.
1:05:51 And I'm going to quote because I saw on there that it says the Planning and Economic Development Commission acts as an advisory body to the Town Council on all planning and development policy issues and is charged with the preparation, maintenance and implementation of the Town's general plan. So I think it's you. I think that it may be the responsibility of the PEDC to be the ones who are looking at this for its overarching effects on the Town and how
1:06:20 It affects the other neighborhoods and not just specifically the North Village. So I ask that before you approve the project, you do further traffic analysis. I will tell you that I agree that signage and messaging is a very good start, but it will not be effective in keeping the traffic out of our neighborhood streets. Thank you very much. Thank you, Christy. Andy, do we have anyone else? Oh, Kirk Schaubmeyer, you can mute yourself and give your comment. Hello. Thank you, everybody.
1:06:57 I'm sitting here with my brother Robert Schaubmeyer, Kirk Schaubmeyer, Schaubmeyer and Stacey Schaubmeyer representing the Alpenhoff Lodge. Thank you for having us today. We too are in support of this concept. I would just like to echo the other comments. I think Christy said it well. I think
1:07:24 Other voices in the community have put it out there. And it's something that we observe on a day-to-day basis. And those issues are traffic flow and parking. I'd like to see your math on this parking situation because I think 109, if that's what I heard, are there about 101 units with 109 spots. It doesn't pencil for me knowing.
1:07:53 the amount of employee parking that we need here at the Alpenhof for our restaurant, bar, lodging employees and guests, in addition to everybody else wanting to park here as being one of the most convenient spots to poach, if you will, for North Village access and parking. So anyway, yeah.
1:08:20 A little more clarification and investigation, I guess, on the parking situation, the traffic flow. We used to live on Holiday Way and are very familiar with Forest Trail and the flow of traffic there, in addition to growing up in this town and seeing it on a day-to-day basis from the mountain to that intersection of Forest Trail and Minaret.
1:08:50 Going to the stoplight and so forth. You know, it's a series of positive problems that we're talking about here. There are a lot of issues with visitation, and this is just one of them. And I feel it's very important that that gets addressed a little bit further. Robert, do you have anything to add to that? No. Thank you very much for the time. Yes, thank you very much.
1:09:22 Thank you, Sean Myers. Angie? Yes. Sean Orlowitz, you can unmute and give your comment. Thank you for your time. I'll be very brief. Sean Orlowitz, also a resident at 203 Alpine Circle. And I just want to echo some of the comments our colleagues have made.
1:09:48 Just and really want to focus on the safety aspect. I appreciate all the work that's being done. This is a very exciting program. But if you were to sit at the proposed location and put in an address into town on the...
1:10:03 On the main part of town, you would be directed towards Alpine Circle and in our neighborhood. And something from experience, based on my address, the grade and the gradient and the slope at the corner of Berner and Alpine Circle is one that's quite dangerous during snowstorms. I can tell you that...
1:10:23 During any snowstorm, I can expect one to two cars to slide out of control into my driveway. So we're happy to help out the people that are visiting and the tourists, but as we put more traffic through there, there's going to be a major safety issue for those people that are heading towards town from the proposed residence. I agree with some of my colleagues or my neighbors here. I don't think signage is really going to be enough.
1:10:49 I really think there's going to have to be some evaluation, some other options there. So thank you for your time. It's a great idea, but I think I support everyone in saying more work needs to be done on the traffic situation. Thank you. No more public comments at this time. Thank you. At this time, I'd like to give the applicant a chance to give any comments on the public feedback. Okay, still here. Yeah, hi, good. Yeah, this is Atman Kadakia, and I just wanted to take a moment to, you know, thank
1:11:28 I really want to assure you or try to assure you on a couple of things. You know, first of all,
1:11:57 The concept of just putting up signage and advising our guests and the idea that it doesn't work, while it may be the case in other situations, operationally, we're very different than others. We're very hands-on. And this particular item, the item of sliding, the steepness, sliding in ice, I mean, these are safety issues for our guests that we, quite frankly,
1:12:26 So this won't just be something that is, you know, there's a sign out there and hopefully people follow it. I mean, this is something that our staff will be trained to address at check-in with every customer who comes in. There's been one comment made regarding the direction of what Google Maps or Apple Maps does. Google Maps and Apple Maps will actually work with projects to go from a
1:12:55 The default route to a route that actually may make more sense based on safety hazards or other things. So we will work with that. We will reach out to Google, to Apple, the main two mapping companies out there to try to find a way to get these directions changed. Additionally, I want to mention one thing that
1:13:25 I don't think was specifically a condition of our project. Now, it is a condition of our project to work with public works to figure out the best way to manage the traffic. But one of the things that I'd like to offer up to the community here is a concept of installing physical pork chops on our property as you exit our property.
1:13:50 The physical pork chop would basically be like a concrete pork chop where you would literally have to drive over curb to make that left turn. So by installing these physical pork chops and we'd have to work with our engineer and public works to design it correctly. This would physically force beyond signage, beyond what we would do at the front desk. This would physically force the customers to take a physical right turn.
1:14:22 to exit out of the facility. So this is something that I'm willing to offer up that I don't think was necessarily a condition as of yet, but I'm happy to add that in and make that something that we specifically do in our design. There was another comment that came to mind regarding parking. We have 109 spots for 101 guest rooms, I believe, operationally as a hotel.
1:14:52 Most hotels by the hotel brand code operate at one-to-one, and that includes the guest parking, that includes anything else, that includes the employee parking. The code here is 1.05. We exceed that code. I can tell you operationally, we won't be anywhere near one-to-one. Many vehicles come up here in some of the oversized vehicles like the Chevy Suburbans of the world, and they take two, three rooms.
1:15:22 with one car. So I can tell you, even on a peak sold-out night, from our experience, having 30 hotels across many different markets, we're operationally closer to 0.75 to 0.8, even on a peak night. We don't have any facilities that cater to the outside guests, so we don't have a meeting space.
1:15:45 We don't have a bar or restaurant that caters to folk who are coming from the outside. Everything we're doing is designed for our guests only. And so we don't generate the additional traffic or trips that you would typically expect to generate out of the more traditional hotels, such as a West Inn or such as a Village Lodge, for example. These are different types of properties. We're not operating that particular type of property.
1:16:12 So those are some of the questions that come to mind. I may not have answered all of them, but I can certainly appreciate the local constituents' concerns and points of view. And I can tell you that besides just the design and the project quality and what it brings economically, it is important, very important for us to fit in with the community and making sure that we address these concerns operationally and take it very seriously.
1:16:38 is going to be a major aspect of how we run our business and our property. So those are my responses. Thank you. Additional public comments at this time? No comments at this time. Okay. I'd like to close public comment and open it up to the commissioners for any questions. Commissioner Eckert. So pork shop is just generally something we have a plate not on a map, but I'm assuming what they're talking about is a radius curb that, you know, as opposed to being like such,
1:17:18 It would go like so. Is that what he's referring to? Yes. And it would also help to turn, to physically turn and physically direct the traffic to make that right turn and make it fairly difficult to even attempt to make a left turn. I'd definitely like to see those in there. The other item was, I thought I saw something about a roof deck. Is there a rooftop deck on here? There is not a rooftop deck. There is a fourth.
1:17:52 Floor covered a viewing balcony. Commissioner Kennedy? I do have a couple more questions, I think, for staff. One is the, well, we already addressed parking requirements, actually, with the applicant. The second one was, Kim, I think you had, it was in the staff report, the mention of the blue color being changed, and that was one of the conditions you're recommending for approval. Could you speak to that a little bit? Sure, thank you for reminding me. I did bring the physical color material board here.
1:18:28 Yes, we see revised package. The color scheme was a little bit different. The blue color that was proposed was a much darker blue-gray sort of color, and the ADP really liked that and commented that they wanted to see that continued color scheme. But when we received the revised design package and these physical samples, it's a lot brighter blue than we were anticipating.
1:19:27 So in the conditions of approval for the special planning conditions, we did require, so we included three separate conditions to try to accomplish exactly what we had intended from that ADP meeting. And so the first one is the award blue color proposed for the metal cladding material.
1:19:58 Should be changed to the color that was reviewed by ADP, labeled Dun & Edwards Black. The revised award blue color is a brilliant blue as opposed to the muted dark blue and shall be changed to match the darker shade. The final dark blue sighting color shall be reviewed by the development director prior to issuance of a bill. The second condition was related to the stone-based material. The ADP is very much opposed to using stone in our climate.
1:20:34 In their experience, it doesn't hold up well and it does crumble over time. So we did include a condition that requires that the cultured stone material be replaced with the natural stone materials recommended by the material will be reviewed in issuance. And then the final one, the proposed parking garage screening material. In all of the renderings, it appeared to have a matte finish. It's a raw metal finish.
1:21:16 Which is reflective. And so we would be requiring that they provide a matte gray finish and provide the metal decorative design. A couple other, I guess, thoughts or questions on the parking side of things, just so the commission and the public knows, I met with a few of the residents who had reached out who live in the Alpine Circle area yesterday to talk about their concerns. Everything we talked about was included in their public comments, except the one thing that we hadn't.
1:21:53 talked about yet was in the staff report and was the moving of the no through traffic sign to the other side. I think that was included. But I guess my curiosity to staff with the traffic standpoint is what kind of process would happen to change traffic flow either with this project or without. I'm with I think the pork chop idea sounds like a great solution. And between that and signage, I think.
1:22:22 That that accomplishes a lot of what the residents are looking for and a lot of what the visitors need to get to the right places. But I'm curious from staff, you know, one of the things the residents had proposed was changing Burner into a dead-end road and just curious what that would look like from a public work standpoint and or is that something that the commission would deal with or that's dealt with more internally with town staff? Do you want to field that, Amy, or would you like I take that? Yeah, do you want to jump in? That would be great.
1:23:02 Okay, I couldn't see the table, so I wasn't sure you were looking to speak. So, Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works. First, I want to say I appreciate the commission separating the impacts of the project and looking specifically at, you know, mitigating the traffic patterns of our new guests at this potential new hotel and managing existing traffic issues. I think they're definitely distinct.
1:23:29 We do know that there are existing conditions out there that could be remedied with a number of different treatments. I would say that Public Works is open to discussing all the options available to the public to try to mitigate traffic. I can tell you that we do study a number of different things in this area, including cut-through traffic. So we do have a good feel for what is happening out there, specific to changing a road.
1:23:58 That is not something that has been taken to a commission or a council. I think we would probably struggle to find a justification for minimizing the ability for the public to navigate the town, but it's not something that's completely off the table, but would require a significant amount of study and work to validate whether or not that would be a successful treatment. I know you're the man for the job.
1:24:36 You know, we've known for a while that the traffic at the Village and Forest Trail area is a problem, and we've talked about different ways to mitigate that, you know, with a roundabout or other mitigation. I think, I can only speak for myself, I think we like the project itself, but...
1:25:00 I think that we really need to take a look at the traffic in that area and make it more of a priority for us to mitigate it because that area is only going to get busier and grow. Just a couple questions. Is there a possibility of that portion of Burner Street where the hotel is to make that a one-way section and then as you get closer to like Alpine Circle it's not one-way anymore?
1:25:29 Is that an option? Like I said, all these ideas would require a significant amount of study and evaluation. We do have a field, we do have traffic counters that are permanent in some of these areas, and we do have traffic counts for select areas along Forest Trail, and there is one on Burner Street, but that doesn't really paint the picture of that area to a point where we would really feel comfortable.
1:26:01 Making a recommendation of one-way or closing road. All these things have pluses and minuses. We have, you know, one-way rainbow up in, by Canyon, and it's a great idea, but we do have challenges with it. It works at certain times and sometimes it just doesn't. So I'm not going to say that they're completely off the table, but I also can't confidently say that it's going to function. It would be something that we would need direction from commission and council.
1:26:28 to hire consultants and actually take a real deep dive into evaluating, studying the impacts of making pretty significant changes to traffic flow. Thank you. I think it was Christy Williams who brought it up that it is the Planning Commission's overall responsibility to provide guidance for our planning in our community. And as I mentioned, we know that the village traffic is a problem.
1:26:59 So I would like to direct staff that we put this on an agenda for another time to perhaps discuss this further and see if we need to put together a study or figure out some mitigation for it. Any other comments? I think what we've got here is a good project that is sort of tearing the scab off of a problem that hasn't really been kept up to snuff yet.
1:27:37 I don't think that it should be, it's my own personal opinion, that this developer should be held accountable for our lack of a good plan for the overall area. I think that there definitely needs to be a request to staff that does the study, the council that pays the bills, to have a traffic study here that isn't just a village study, but it is a forest trail study, it is an alpine circle study.
1:28:07 It is something that incorporates the whole thing instead of just piecemealing it project by project. I agree with that as well. And I agree with your point, Jen, about staff having, you know, opening up some sort of bigger discussion about traffic and what we can do from a commission standpoint because I know there's traffic issues in a lot of other areas in town. I know we just did the mobility hub study and all of that sort of thing, but I don't know that that...
1:28:41 Anyway, there may be more opportunity for discussion that would come up, so I'd love to see that as well. I agree with Commissioner Eckert that this, I think this project looks really good. I also really appreciate the applicant being flexible and willing to update things and work with us and listen to local feedback. I think that's really important and a good foot to start out on. I think the pork chop idea is a great call. Any way we can work past signage to get people...
1:29:10 Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh!
1:30:12 Resolution, making the required tentative tract map, use permit, design review, and CEQA, tentative tract map, application TTM 21-003, use permit, UPA 21-004, and design review, DR 21-004, with conditions, I guess the ones that you mentioned, Kim. Right, the three I mentioned are included in, I guess the outstanding question. Sorry, for the record, that was Vice Chair Burroughs, I was muted.
1:31:40 Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Three zero. And we can work with the Public Works Department to bring back a discussion on these traffic issues. I think it would be helpful for the commission and the community to understand the ongoing traffic monitoring we do up there. And there are some provisions that are triggered if traffic exceeds certain levels that other things need to occur up there. So I think it would be helpful for us to bring that back so we can commit. Thank you so much. And I think at this time,
1:32:14 Chair Vanderhurst is back and so is Commissioner Chang, so I will hand over the gavel to Chair Vanderhurst. Thank you, Vice Chair Burroughs. We will now move on to agenda item 4.3, which is consideration of the unmet transit needs within the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I believe Amy is our staff contact on this one, or is it Hayes? It's gonna be Hayes.
1:32:44 Okay, Hayes, take it away. And I believe we have Phil Moores with ESTA on the line as well. So we'll be opening a public hearing. Chair? Yes, we are opening a public hearing. So take it away, Hayes. Thank you. So we are hosting today's public hearing to solicit input from the community on unmet transit needs. Unmet transit needs for the purpose of this public hearing has a very specific definition and scope.
1:33:17 This would be needs of the community's elderly, disabled, low-income, youth, and other transit-dependent groups for transit service that is currently not available. And if provided for, would enable the transit-dependent person to obtain the basic necessities of life within Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes. Necessities of life are defined as trips necessary for medical and dental services, essential personal business, employment,
1:33:47 Social service appointments, shopping for food or clothing and social and recreational purposes. State law provides a citizen participation process that requires the local transportation commission to hold at least one public hearing to ensure broad community participation and solicit the input of transit dependent and transit disadvantaged persons. Similar public hearings have been held throughout Mono County at regional planning advisory community meetings.
1:34:16 Including Long Valley, Antelope Valley, Bridgeport Valley, June Lake, and the Mono Basin. Mono County staff also met with the Social Service Technical Advisory Committee, and an unmet transit needs meeting was held at the Local Transportation Commission meeting. Public hearing on unmet transit needs is required prior to the Local Transportation Commission allocating any funds not directly related to public transportation services, specialized transportation services,
1:34:45 or facilities provided for the exclusive use of pedestrians and bicycles. The purpose of the unmet transit needs hearing is to solicit comments on unmet transit needs that may exist within Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes and that might be reasonably met by establishing or contracting for new public transportation or specialized transportation services or by expanding existing services. Service is considered reasonable when can be
1:35:14 operationally feasible, can demonstrate community acceptance, would be available to the general public, can be proven to be economical, and can demonstrate cost-effectiveness. Staff recommends that the Commission receive public input at this public hearing, provide feedback to staff about the evaluation of unmet needs, and provide any other direction to staff regarding unmet needs or transit services. We will be meeting to adopt our unmet transit needs process.
1:35:43 at the May Local Transportation Commission meeting. That is the end of my presentation, and I am happy to field any questions or solicit any comments at this time. Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate it. Bill, would you like to make a statement before we throw it back to the commission? Thank you, Chair Van Hurst and the commissioners. Good afternoon. Hayes covered all the important details. This is just a...
1:36:10 One of many, like you said, public hearings we had. I think I've counted nine hearings in total that we have for Mono County. Seems like a lot, but gives plenty of opportunity for people to comment. So while we do have a pretty mature system here, and we've been through this process for many, many years, there's always new ideas. So does anyone here, either on the commission or members of the public or any attendees, have any
1:36:38 unmet transit needs, know anybody that needs additional transportation that's not provided at this time. So, Phil, before we open it up to the public, I'm going to allow my fellow commissioners to ask any questions of either yourself or Hayes. Anybody on the commission have any questions or any obvious unmet transit needs they'd like to discuss? Please.
1:37:07 I don't know that it's unmet, but I wanna make sure that it continues to be met. I think that it's really important to have the line that goes to the Aspen Village out to Snow Creek area, and we talked about having a stop out there, but I think that we need to continue to provide access to that area of the community. A lot of workforce housing is in Aspen Village, and...
1:37:36 They are part of our underserved population and we need to make sure that we continue to provide transportation for them. I'm really glad to hear you say that. We were just out there yesterday, Hayes and myself and Mayor Souser were out there at Snow Creek yesterday. We have some challenges with that bus stop. Developers are overtaking the existing bus stop. So we're looking for ways and alternatives to serve that community. We're actively looking for that now.
1:38:06 And, yeah, you know, our long-term plans are to go a little further up Old Mammoth than we do now and serve that Aspen Village community. And there's also some, you know, just some rentals and some motels and places up there where guests have called and asked how they can get down into the slopes and down into the town. So while there is some resistance we have from the neighborhood, there are some folks that
1:38:34 that need and want that service. Thank you for advocating for that. Any other questions? Yeah, please, fire away. This is kind of more regional, but wondering if there's any transit from the community of Ravanna up to Mammoth or down to Bishop? I get requests throughout the year, every year, about expanding our 395 service that runs
1:39:10 Up and down, really, from Lancaster to Reno and Sparks, Nevada. That route that goes up that direction can't really be stretched to new communities because of the driver limitations of time. It's a really long route. We do have some express surfaces that are shorter, but we have not diverted at this time to Ravana.
1:39:38 Have you had this request, Commissioner Kennedy? I haven't. I'm always checking out rentals in the Bishop area, and Ravanna seems to be places that's affordable, hardly anymore. It's leaving affordability, but I imagine that we may have some workforce that lives there and works in Mammoth that should possibly be considered. Maybe not from Mammoth Lakes. I guess it's Mono County. Well, they may be Inyo County. Anyways, from a regional kind of standpoint. So I haven't heard it, but I just wondered if that was a missing piece.
1:40:10 Unfortunately, there are several communities up and down 395 who, because they're somewhat off the highway, it makes diversion of routes difficult. So, you know, we're really cautious and careful about that. I'm open to expanding our services when it makes sense and when there's a number of people that are represented for the need. But Robana has not been...
1:40:41 High on our list. We haven't gotten a lot of comments, any that I know of from Ravana. Commissioner Eckert, did you have any questions for Phil or Hayes about unmet transit needs? Not today. Perfect. Hey, Phil, I've got a couple of quick questions, and this might be a little under the umbrella of the broader scope of the S to service. I know you came before us at the beginning of the winter and explained
1:41:12 The situation that was facing ESTA in regards to a lack of drivers available due to the financial resources at your disposal to pay them what your competitors are paying them. Could you just give us a brief summary of how, if that situation is still the same or if it has changed and how you managed this last winter? Well, we're still in it.
1:41:43 The Mountain Resort doesn't really shut down until, is it Memorial Day or Labor Day? I was getting confused. It's Memorial Day coming up. Right? Yeah. And so, yeah, so we're still, you know, working on our winter service. And we've been able to cover everything. You know, there was a few wait times, I think, at some of the peak periods, but we were able to get all of it done.
1:42:12 We were able to increase wages. And it's dependent on Red's Meadow. Honestly, I mean, Red's Meadow, we really need a good Red's Meadow summer. And that means having drivers. And right now we're short. We've been campaigning. Some of you may have gotten our mailers in your PO boxes and other places we're trying. We increased the rate by almost $3 an hour. It was about a $350,000.
1:42:42 Annual expense increase, which is a little scary. And we need to have a good red summer to make it work. So I took a little bit of a risk. The board did in my recommendation. So we're trying. Right now, we're not ready for summer. I think red meadow will probably start around July 1st. I don't know if the Forest Service will get everything together in June or not. July 1st is a Friday, right before the holiday on Monday.
1:43:12 That's probably what we're looking at for that Reds Meadow business getting going. It's still a problem, though. You know, it's like for so many. We can't seem to find the people we need to run our businesses. So we'll see. I'm still a little worried about it. Got it. So you were able to increase the hourly wage for your drivers? We did. We matched the mountains.
1:43:39 And some other competitors that kind of came and was able to be a little more nimble in the market because they're not government organizations. They were able to move quicker, but we caught up and we made some changes and got the drivers and some of the dispatchers and utility folks a significant increase, hoping that that'll help. And we'll see, huh? So kind of a follow-up question for me then, Phil, is can you just like briefly talk about your strategy?
1:44:09 either this winter or going forward on how ESTA can be scalable during peak times, during holiday mornings, holiday afternoons, weekend mornings, weekend afternoons, mainly it's the red line getting people up to Maine and up to the village and the red line getting people back down from Maine and back down into town. So if you're talking about winter, so the red line is a winter
1:44:40 Service, replaced by the town trolley in the summer. So, you know, the two services, both the town trolley and the red line do the same thing at different parts of the year. As the ski season winds down, the red line will convert to the town trolley. As far as scalability, you're talking about cutting services or are you talking about expanding? What's your question in regards to that? I'm talking about expanding service and, you know,
1:45:11 Let's say, for example, a Saturday morning in January when the bus kiosk, the bus stops are overflowing and, you know, the guest perception is full buses are going by them and they want to use public transportation, but sometimes that can leave a bad taste in their mouth for future visits. Well, you know, waiting for, this is a complicated answer. There's a lot I can.
1:45:39 Talk about, but just to bullet point some things for you. We have a system where we can inject what are called trippers into the regular service. So say you have regular 30-minute service on a route and we're experiencing heavy loads. Like at the end of the day, when the lifts close up the main lodge, they try to shut them down and step them and close them gradually.
1:46:06 So that there's not a huge impact to transit, but a lot of times there is wait times up there. And so when we see that, we have cameras on those stops, our dispatchers are plugged into the customer visitor experience at the stop level. And when they see long wait times, they see that we're passing people by, they'll go out and drive and they'll get other people to drive. We got people standing by that can get in a bus and go help with that load.
1:46:33 That is just kind of as temporary. It's like you said, a peak. And so we're pretty flexible and we react to that with what are called tripper services that can increase the capacity on that route. Yeah, so that's one way of addressing long wait times when they occur. Expansion on a real level like a new route or expanding hours,
1:47:06 Or frequencies on routes for like a permanent regular thing is not on the table right now because we simply don't have the resources to do it. But we can send out trippers and support when we get busy and that's what we do. So does that answer your question? It does, I guess, and I appreciate your time and I don't want to belabor this, but. No, no, I've been waiting for all this time to talk to you. I'm glad I'm talking.
1:47:36 So you guys do have a plan in place. Like, let's say, when you guys get the occupancy report, I'm assuming you get the occupancy report that the town and Mammoth Lakes Tourism furnishes, and you see our occupancy for this, you know, any one weekend, let's say, is extremely high, and you know we're going to be dense and full and a lot of people. You guys can put a plan in place that you've already kind of vetted to increase the frequency of public transit.
1:48:06 Specifically, I'm talking winter red line. Yeah, I mean, it's not written, but it's an operational protocol that we operate under and always have. The transit is faced with peak periods and rushes that require extra service, and we do what we can to fill that service. If we have the drivers available and the buses and everything we can, we put them out there and we reduce the wait times.
1:48:36 for visitors as much as we can. We know that that's an important aspect of what we do. And yeah, we definitely are proactive in knowing when it's going to be busy. The Occupancy Report is only one resource. There are many, because of our years of experience in dealing with the crowds and the ebbs and the flows of visitors and visitation, we're pretty familiar with peak periods and when we might need extra people.
1:49:04 And we put them on the schedule and we anticipate that. Appreciate that, Phil. Yeah, no problem. And Hayes and I are also looking at some electronic information signs at bus stops that we just installed new GPS trackers on all the buses. And we can buy some signs that will scroll, digital scroll signs that will give you a number of minutes until the next bus arrives. We also have...
1:49:34 The transit app you can download onto your phone and that will also give you an estimated time of arrival for the next bus at your stop. So we have some tools that we've put into people's hands. I just ordered some new signs that have information, more information for guests than they currently have and they can text or call and give this bus stop number wherever they may be.
1:50:02 And it'll give them an estimate of an arrival time. So we're doing all we can to communicate and we're thinking of new ways to do it as well. Great. Angie, do we have any public comment on this, either in person or through Zoom? We do have a Zoom person, Chad Phillips. You can go ahead and unmute and make your comment. So Chad, I see you're unmuted, but we can't hear you, Chad. Can anyone hear him? No. We can not hear him in Sweet Z. How about the chat?
1:50:51 Can you get into chat? Do we have chat on this? I don't see it. There is no chat on this meeting. Chad, do you want to try unmuting? Well, you know, Chad, if you're struggling with technology, send me an email. My email is my first initial P, and my last name, Moores, you can see it on the screen there, pmores at estransit.com. pmores at estransit.com. We'll make sure your comments get included in the notes for the meeting.
1:51:29 Yeah, and Phil, I'm going to actually ask him to maybe CC you on that. He should send it directly to the town clerk. Okay, that's fine. Yeah, whoever, send it to somebody somehow. Send it to Angie. Angie, Chad, do you, I'm assuming your microphone on your laptop or computer is on, so. He can go ahead and send an email to the clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.org.
1:52:00 G-O-V, and that is an email that Town Clerk and myself both have access to. So either way, one of us will be able to receive that and forward that on. Thanks, Angie. Any other public comment, Angie? Either Zoom or in public? None in public, none in Zoom. I did forward one to the commission, I believe, yesterday. Yeah, from Aspen Village. Aspen Village resident.
1:52:32 Fairly sure we got it and we all read it. So thank you for that. Any other last questions or thoughts for Phil or Hayes on unmet transit needs from the PEDC and fellow commissioners? I just have one question, Chair. Please. Can ESTA or the Transportation Planning Agency work with private entities to provide
1:53:03 Transportation Service. Has that ever been done in any parts of the country that you have seen in the past? Yeah, it's really common. It's called contracted service. So what ESSA performs is called directly operated, meaning that all the people that operate our services are public employees and work and are employees of ESSA. The other way of approaching public transit is through contracted services. You may have heard of first transit via
1:53:33 There's a few big names out there that have built a private company based on that model. And so, yeah, we could, instead of directly operating it, we could hire a contractor and manage that contract and they would be required to fulfill our services. Whether we supply the buses, usually we would, and they would supply drivers. Thank you. You're welcome. Another question, Michael? Please. Well, I guess a comment first is,
1:54:07 Yeah, thank you, Commissioner Kennedy.
1:54:36 A good point. Two points, really. First point is we do accept and consider transportation suggestions throughout the year, whether they fit the unmet needs transportation definition or not. Hayes and I have talked about having a general transportation meeting later this summer. That is not part of the unmet transit needs process necessarily.
1:55:06 But something may come from that that might fit the definition. But when it doesn't, we still, you know, follow through and track good ideas and think about, you know, how we can implement those. Can you repeat the question again? I think I've gotten off track. No worries. I appreciate that insight. Just wondering if there was anything notable from the survey that you wanted to share with the Commission, since I don't think I'd heard any update on it.
1:55:35 I probably forgot because I can't remember anything specific. I'm sorry. Nothing popped into my head, but when you started talking about other processes and surveys and other things, it kind of reminded me that, hey, we love good ideas and we take them all, regardless of the venue. We've taken several surveys. One was an ADA accessibility survey that we completed.
1:56:03 to make sure that we're paying attention to the disabled and just the people that struggle with mobility in your community. And we got some surveys collected and those ideas are considered. Everything is actually doing really well. We didn't have any serious deficiencies. We didn't have any deficiencies as far as the services we provide to that community.
1:56:32 Yeah, you know, we do surveys every once in a while, and we get things like more comfortable seats. Okay, so somebody from, was it First Five, really wanted us to have some better Spanish-speaking capabilities with our system. Also, the idea of young parents, maybe single parents carrying child seats.
1:57:04 is a burden, right? So some things that ESTA is doing to address those needs that came up in other processes are we have a Spanish dispatcher now in Bishop, a Spanish-speaking dispatcher. We also have our website that you can hit the little Mexican flag up in the corner and everything magically becomes Spanish on our website. And we also have a service that we can use to help us translate if needed.
1:57:34 And we're buying buses with integrated child seats. So new buses will come and you'll be able to pull a piece out of the normal bus seat and it'll have straps and they'll have better securement for children going forward. So there's a couple of things that have come outside of our existing process of unmet transit needs that we've addressed. Thank you so much. That's all for me, Michael. Any other questions for Phil or Hayes at this time from the commission?
1:58:10 Nada. All right, then I'm going to close this public hearing. We appreciate the time from both of you. Hayes, did you get what you needed from us today? Got exactly what I needed. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, guys. Appreciate it. That I'll close 4.3 and we'll move on to the business matters part of the agenda. 5.1, consideration of approval for the parking management plan for the use permit 21-005.
1:58:38 The Sierra Nevada Resort Phase One Redevelopment, and I believe Gina is going to be our staff contact on this. And Chair Vanderhurst, I'll just note that Commissioner Kennedy is conflicted out of this item, so she has left the Sweet C. Thank you. Okay, let me share my screen. All right, can everybody see the title page? Yep. Yep. Great. Hi, everybody. I will be presenting the parking management plan under the
1:59:16 approved use permit 21005 for the Sierra Nevada Resort redevelopment. So I'll present and I'll let the applicant team weigh in if they need to and then open it up to discussion. So the parking management plan is part of the approved Sierra Nevada Resort redevelopment project. The project proposes 186 space surface parking lot to serve
1:59:57 A proposed hotel, restaurant, and related uses, which would result in a 34 space deficit per the Clearwater Specific Plan, amended phase one parking standards. This site plan shows the 186 surface parking lot along with all the other proposed improvements, including the renovation of the current 149 unit hotel with both interior and exterior improvements. The addition of the new, of the
2:00:25 of 30 new resort cabins for revised total of 179 hotel rooms, the enhancements of the old Mammoth Road frontage and improvements to the site amenities. So the project's entitlements, design review 21-005 and use permit 21-005, which included the parking reduction, were approved at the February 9th, 2022 PDC hearing with the condition that the parking management plan
2:00:55 Would require an additional PDC approval to address the parking deficit. So I will go into that now. So this is the condition that was written into the February 9th resolution. The condition asked the applicant to address parking for hotel, restaurant, and special event uses. It also asked to consider solutions such as valet parking, oversized vehicle parking, shuttles, and off-site parking. So the parking management plan goals.
2:01:25 During the previous entitlement phase, we had received concerns from PDC commissioners and a comment from the public about the parking deficit. The parking management plan is intended to be a response to those concerns by ensuring that parking will be easily available to guests and that overflow parking would be managed by Sierra Nevada Resort through valet service in order to avoid any illegal parking in adjacent neighborhoods.
2:01:53 Employing creative solutions to parking, such as a management plan, also allows the project to fulfill other priorities set by the town staff, such as activating the old Mammoth Road by designing public gathering spaces along the frontage as opposed to dedicating it to additional parking. The parking management plan includes a valet program. The valet will be triggered at 83% hotel occupancy or 149 rooms.
2:02:23 So the staff report and parking plan state 85%, but after double checking the math, it actually pencils out to 83%. This will be revised in the parking management plan. So the percentage of occupancy that would trigger valet parking was determined based on the percentage of total rooms that allow the project to meet existing parking requirements, including the required restaurant parking.
2:02:49 When occupancy is at 83%, 186 parking spaces meets the zoning requirements for 149 rooms plus 5,840 square feet of restaurant, which breaks down to 149 hotel spaces at one space per room and 39 restaurant spaces at one space per 150 square feet. So there will be three valet attendants for parking and retrieval.
2:03:20 Service would be complimentary for hotel and restaurant guests, and valet would prioritize accommodating short-term guest vehicles on site, while long-term guests would have vehicles off site. Short-term guests who would like to self park would also be directed to off site local public parking options. So here you can see the three different options for off site parking.
2:03:52 The projects, the project will be able to utilize 10 future on-street parking public spaces on Royal Mountain Road, which would be constructed in 2022. This includes a condition that requires the applicant to take responsibility for the removal and storage of snow from sidewalk and parking spaces. Valet would also utilize the 50 spaces of the town park and ride lot. And the plan includes a lot at 3721 Main Street as a tertiary.
2:04:21 Backup plan in the event that the first two lots are full. Sierra Nevada Resort would not be able to reserve parking in the public parking lots and they would not be allowed to park overnight in the public lots. So here you can see a diagram that shows where the valet staging would be and be coned off to provide 150 feet of queuing capacity. Also along Laurel Mountain Road there would be
2:04:51 Bus designated areas for tour buses. A typical bus is 45 feet in length, approximately five parking spaces, and consists of up to 25 rooms of occupancy, which would create additional available parking for other guests. During the time valet parking is in place, signs would be placed at all four entrances, directing guests to the valet attendance.
2:05:22 And I'd also like to note that a parking analysis was provided by the applicant and included in the staff report for the approved use permit. The analysis determined that there are differences in time of day parking demand based on uses, which means that the restaurant peak parking is during lunch early evening and hotel peak parking is overnight. According to 2019 data, 26 to 79 percent of Raptors patrons
2:05:51 We're also hotel guests. Therefore, based on average utilization rates, peak park demand for the site is only 185 spaces. Staff recognizes that neither valet nor the parking demand study alone are sufficient solutions to the parking deficit. However, considering both in tandem provides sufficient evidence that parking needs will be met at the site as proposed.
2:06:18 And with that, staff finds that the proposed parking management plan meets the applicable requirements and recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission approve the attached parking management plan meeting the requirements of condition number 30 of resolution number PADC 2022-06. Thank you, Gina. Appreciate that. Before we open it up for questions from the commission, I'd like to give the applicant a chance to
2:06:49 Make a statement if they'd like. Brett, would it be you or is it going to be somebody else? I can do it. Also, we have Matt Marion on for Waterton here as part of the Waterton Hospitality. But no, I just want to thank everybody for the hard work to get this done. Thank you, Gina, particularly and Amy and everybody on PDEC. But I think we've got a plan here that addresses what was brought forth before and takes care of the parking needs for the project. But I don't have anything else at this time. Matt, did you want to make a statement?
2:07:19 Are you good? I'm not good, Michael. Thank you. I think Brent said it well. Okay. Then I'll open it up to questions from the commission. Does anybody have a question for either Gina or Amy or the applicant representatives? I do, Michael. Please. I just want to ask Brent and company, you know, we have a staff shortage throughout the community. How can you guarantee?
2:07:53 That you will be able to have staff for the valet parking to ensure this service during peak times. I don't think there's anything that's going to be 100% guarantee, but from the standpoint of you know how I operate properties, if it has to be me that's valet parking, I'll be their one valet parking. So if I need to cover from that standpoint, the intention is we have dedicated staff for that. That's one of the reasons why we have the seven workforce housing units on property to try to make sure we have.
2:08:20 those staff available on property and be able to have them available for those need time frames. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, I thought I saw your hand up. Mr. Chair. This question is probably for Gina or Sandra or additional staff members there. I didn't understand the concept of having additional 70 parking spaces off-site counted as part of the
2:08:53 management, parking management requirement in that they're directing the public to park there instead of parking at their spot if they chose not to do valet. Is that what I just heard? I'll clarify that. So those, the public parking along Laurel Mountain in the parking ride would actually be used by valet. So valet would take those cars, guest cars, and park them there.
2:09:25 We understand that Sierra Nevada can't reserve those spaces, but if those spaces are available, they would choose them first because they're just closer to the hotel and more convenient for valet operators. I think it's a, okay, so can you explain that, how do you differentiate using a public space for a private entity's use?
2:09:58 How does that work? Does that mean, do they have a contract with the town to use that space or is this just? So with Laurel Mountain, Amy might be able to explain it a little further, but they would be going into an agreement with the town because they would maintain those spaces during snow removal and with that be allowed to use those spaces as valet.
2:10:32 You're saying that the applicant will maintain snow removals for those two sites? For Laurel Mountain. Gina, do you want me to hop in here? Sure. So, Paul, this is Amy. So, one of the conditions of approval that was already approved for the project was that the Sierra Nevada Resort would enter into an agreement to
2:11:06 Maintain the sidewalk and the parking spaces, sorry, just perform the snow removal adjacent to the property on Laurel Mountain Road, not on the Tavern Road, but those parking spaces remain public and the sidewalk also remains public. So as Gina said, if Sierra Nevada Resort is at a capacity where it is undergoing valet operations and I guess
2:11:37 comes and wants to have their car parked with the valet. The valet has the ability to use those public parking spaces. They are open to the public. But if a guest of the hotel or of the restaurant wanted to park in one of those spaces themselves, they could do that as well because they're open to the public. Either way, though, those spaces have the ability to serve the hotel. And does the applicant have to provide snow removal services for those?
2:12:09 Public spaces. Approval to enter into an agreement to perform snow removal on those spaces. Now, we haven't executed that agreement yet. I think the trigger for that was, I can't remember if it was certificate of occupancy. That's likely what it was. But they did agree to enter into an agreement to perform the snow removal on those spaces. Thank you. That's all I have. Amy, was that just Laurel Mountain Road or was that Laurel Mountain Road and the parking ride? Just Laurel Mountain Road. Okay.
2:12:50 That is in addition to actually constructing the sidewalk and those spaces. Commissioner Eckert, did you have any other questions or thoughts? I was just confused. I've got a quick question and it probably is for either Gina or Amy. So in this staff report, the presentation you gave us, Gina, this is the first time I've seen that parking area on Main Street called out specifically. And I think it was 10 spaces. Is that the old La Sierra space?
2:13:27 No, this is 3721 Main Street. It's a little further down the road from La Sierra. And I thought I had that in the staff report. Maybe because they haven't made it. It is in the staff report. They were still working on locking down a property pretty recently. So it wasn't finalized.
2:13:59 until recently, and we will require a shared use agreement before certificate of occupancy. So, Brett, I guess my follow-up question to you will be operationally, if you guys are, if that occupancy trigger point is hit and your valet system goes into place and the parking spots on Laurel Mountain and the park and ride have become either full or they're not available to you.
2:14:28 That space up on Main Street is a hell of a walk away from the property. How are you going to get that valet driver back? Well, and that's why we need three because we're going to have to have the shuttle driver. So we'll have an on-property shuttle all the time for that. We'll use that for that time period to shuttle back and forth. Got it. So that is part of your strategy is that you'll have secondary transportation to get that driver back. Or if someone wants to self-park long-term up there, let's say they're up for a week.
2:14:59 I mean, our goal is to be able to bring people back in terms of if at the end of the day we're closing down, the restaurants closed, that parking lot opens up is to bring all the cars we can back to property would be the ideal scenario for us. Got it. Okay. Any other, not seeing any hands up, Angie, I'm going to open it up to public comment. Do we have anybody in Suite Z or on Zoom that has public comment on the parking management plan for the Sierra Nevada?
2:15:29 Yes, we do. Linda Scott, you may unmute yourself and provide your comment. Hi, I'm Linda Scott from Sierra Park Villas, and I'm very concerned about the parking issue. I'm very happy with the project. Looks good. On the... I can't imagine that you're going to be able to find enough valet parkers. I read the job description. It sounds like...
2:15:57 These would be great guys, but I don't know where you're going to find them. The next subject is the parking on Laurel Mountain. Will that be 24 hours a day? Because that's where my overflow parking can go then. Is it 24 hours a day or is it only during the day? The intent right now is that parking would not be overnight parking. It would be similar to the other public parking spaces around town.
2:16:26 which I believe is no parking between 2 a.m. and 6 a.m. So the worst nights are Friday and Saturday night in a snowstorm where there is no place to park and everyone is arriving. It's a problem we have regularly. What happens when you can't park because there's too much snow and you can't park overnight? If I can, well, sorry, I won't need an answer, Commissioner.
2:17:04 Yeah, jump in there. So, you know, we're responsible for the snow on property. You know, there's times when it's snow. We've always, during the winter time, we can't park on the street before that standpoint. But during normal operations, the restaurant's going to close around 10 o'clock at night. It's not going to be a late night restaurant. And there's no more of that overnight, you know, late night entertainment type things that we used to have in the past. So we're going to have that whole rafters parking lot available to move back into as we have activities.
2:17:33 And yes, there can be challenges with snow. Like this year, there was challenges the first part of the year, then there was zero challenges for the rest of the winter. But our attention is everything has to come back on property, other than that, or it goes up the other far away lot, where that would be a potential for us to be overnight if we need to use it. But the public lot and the road will be cleared each night. Okay. That's what I understood.
2:17:57 And it does seem that the plan that you have is more apropos to this summertime availability. It will work in the summer, but I don't think it will work in the winter, but I'm hoping. It's going to look a lot better than what I look at now. Thank you, Linda. Appreciate it. Thank you. Any other public comment, Angie? No comments at this time.
2:18:30 All right, then I will close public comment on this matter and any thoughts or opinions from my fellow commissioners on this parking management plan? I don't see any hands raised, so I'm assuming we need an action on this, correct, Amy? What kind of penalties if it doesn't work? Linda, I'm going to ask you to mute yourself, please. Sorry. So I believe a motion is our next course of action. Would anybody like to put forth a motion? Okay. Nobody. No, I'm working on it. I was pulling it up.
2:19:21 I make a motion to approve the resolution of the Mammoth Lakes Planning and Economic Development Commission, approving design review 21-005, do I have the right one? Yes. And use permit 21-005 and revoking vesting tentative tract map 16-001. That's the wrong one. It says Sierra Nevada Project on it. I can pull it by.
2:19:50 PowerPoint. It's just the parking management plan that was under. Yeah, that's what came up on my resolution for the parking management. Sorry. We'll double check. I think it's an action to approve the parking management plan of use permit UP 21-005 with conditions as recommended by staff. Okay. So I make a motion to approve the parking management plan.
2:20:19 Use permit, UP21-005 with conditions as recommended by staff. Do we have a second? Second. All right, we have a first and a second. Any further conversation? See none. Angie, may we have a vote, please? Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Yes. Matter passes 4-0. Congratulations, gentlemen. I truly, truly hope.
2:20:54 You constantly hit that valet trigger. Thank you for everybody's efforts of time. Thank you, everyone. Thanks. All right, we'll move on to 5.2 discussion regarding returning to in-person PEDC meetings. And Sandra, are you our contact on this? I am. Thank you. And for the record, Commissioner Kennedy is returning from the hallway. And can I interject real quick?
2:21:22 The gentleman who was trying to make a public comment earlier, right after that item closed, he did send in a public comment. Did you want me to just upload that and forward it to you, or did you want that read into the record? Let's maybe forward it to us, Angie. All right, thank you. Thank you. So on item 5.2, discussion of returning to in-person PEDC meetings, we wanted to provide this item for the commission to discuss potentially returning to an all-in-person meeting.
2:21:55 from hybrids, so there's a number of different options for the commission. Clearly we're in a hybrid mode right now where commissioners can attend the meeting if they're available and attend via Zoom if they're not. What that does require is that we adopt a resolution for AB 361, which is on your consent agenda for today, so we're fine doing that today. Just a question and, you know, giving the floor to the commission to discuss how you feel about returning to in-person meetings.
2:22:25 That's all I have. I'm happy to answer any questions. Got it. So I'll open it up to the commission to hear your thoughts. And clearly, I think the majority of us are comfortable in person. I would have been there in person today, but I had a one to two o'clock meeting that I knew was going to run tight up against this one. So, Commissioner Eckert, what are your thoughts on going back to the dais, in person, suite Z?
2:22:53 I don't see any reason why we shouldn't. I think that it would be, if we're going to get anything out of this mess we've gone through, it would be to add this icing on the cake to where we can have Zoom meetings at any time and not just have to be absent or unavailable. I'm not sure exactly what the COVID protocols are and all the other horse pucky that goes with it, but if we can get it to where, if we are out of town or sick or whatever, that any of us could attend any meeting by Zoom, but the norm would be.
2:23:23 in-person meetings. Got it. So kind of a hybrid approach in case circumstances dictate. Yeah. Commissioner Borough or Vice Chair Boroughs. I'm supportive of a hybrid approach. I think that as Commissioner Eckert says, it's nice that we can, if we're out of town, we can still join these meetings. You know, especially you travel a lot for work and you really want to be a part of this and are committed to it. I also think
2:23:54 That we're providing access to other people that we wouldn't normally be able to provide access to. Not everybody can come in person, but it's much easier to join a Zoom meeting from wherever you're at. So I think that the access part of it is great for our community. Okay. Commissioner Kennedy. The other commissioners have said I do think it's helpful to have the option for Zoom, especially
2:24:28 for some of these things that, I mean, we had a couple on the agenda today that we were down to three commissioners on because two were conflicted out and that sort of thing would have to be pushed off for a month or two at a time, which I think is kind of a disservice to the community, if we can avoid that by having the Zoom capabilities, but I'm all for in person whenever possible. So yeah, I wonder if there's a hybrid option that fits that, meets that need. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Chang. Thanks, Chair.
2:24:58 I think in-person is antiquated. I think hybrid is the flexibility that we all need in this day and age. And especially when things that happens to people, life happens to people. And so I think it's important that we have that flexibility and allow people to do hybrid meetings via Zoom or in-person. Thank you.
2:25:30 Perfect. So I'm hearing consensus, Sandra, that all of us agree we want to come back to in person, but we want the flexibility of a hybrid approach where somebody could, you know, let's say I'm on the road or, you know, somebody is visiting family down south or, you know, someone's under the weather, but they still want to participate. I think my only hesitation with the hybrid approach, Sandra, and maybe you can walk us through it. I know pre-pandemic, if one of us was going to be calling in,
2:25:59 This is before we've ever heard of Zoom. One of us was going to be calling into a meeting. We had to post the physical address of our location. So if any members of the public wanted to join, they had a right to. And, you know, if I'm in a hotel room or I get a kid home sick with the flu, you know, I'm not opening my door to let members of the public come into my house to join the meeting. So what's our approach to?
2:26:27 Have the hybrid meeting, but without that component. Yeah, so as long as there is a state of emergency declared, which there is currently, we can continue to do this AB 361 process where you don't have to post your location for members of the public. Once that is lifted, though, we would have to go back to those old procedures where if you were going to zoom in, we would have to know in advance and you would have to post your location with a notice so that the members of the public
2:26:57 Public would know where you were and would be able to attend at your location if desired. So with that being said, I think that the state is looking at different options for Zoom meetings for this type of event. I think this has really shifted the way we have public meetings. And so I think that we should expect probably some changes from the governor, but we just don't know what they are at this point.
2:27:26 But at this point, what we'll do as staff is we'll continue to put the AB 361 item on your agenda, which allows for this hybrid approach. If all of you are in attendance, we just don't need to adopt that resolution. And another note is just that we will continue to provide Zoom for members of the public, regardless of whether you're here or not.
2:27:52 We recognize that it does bring in a segment of our community that wasn't able to participate previously. So we will continue to offer that. So I think that I hear some consensus and we'll just continue to keep doing the hybrid approach and look forward to seeing you all here or on Zoom as it happens over the next couple months. So you got the action out of this commission that you needed, Sandra? Do you need anything further? Nope, I don't need anything else.
2:28:22 This is great. Thank you. Great. Great. And I will say, I look forward to seeing all of you in person. I think there is a component to the in-person meeting that we do miss virtually. And this is probably one of the last bodies that I participate in that has not gone back to full-time in-person meetings. So I think people are becoming a little bit more comfortable with it. So thank you, you all. And I do...
2:28:49 Honestly appreciate the flexibility of the hybrid approach on it too. All right, we're gonna move on to the consent agenda. At this time, is there, of the three items on the consent agenda, is there any one item that anyone would like to pull or do we have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do we have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation on the consent agenda? I see none.
2:29:24 Angie, vote please. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes, approved. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. And Commissioner Eckert? All right, consent agenda is approved. We'll move to Commissioner Reports. And I am going to lead off with Commissioner Eckert. Anything exciting out in your world, Greg, that you want to bring us up to speed on? This isn't really a report, it's more of an idea.
2:29:58 You know, we're the PEDC. I'm sure everybody that talks to you says, oh, you're on the Planning Commission. It's been, I won't say frustration of mine, but it's something that it seems like we do a lot of work regarding planning, but with the exception of housing, we don't do much in regard to economic development. And I was just wondering if there's any other...
2:30:26 Commissioners that had any ideas about how we might try to push that a little bit. Yeah, I'm all in favor of that. And just to go back to some of our earlier conversations, Greg, I think the vein that I would think would be relevant would be when we had some pretty heated conversations with Suddenlink about the service they provide to this community.
2:30:59 The potential to diversify our local economy from such a tourism-based economy to something that has different segments feeding into it. I would definitely be in favor of maybe broadening our scope a bit. I'm assuming that's kind of where you're coming from. Yeah, with all respect to Tom Cage and John Mueller, I think we've got plenty of ski shops and pizza parlors. It'd be nice if we had some people that had jobs that
2:31:28 Made them want to live here for 20 years and raise kids instead of be here for two or three and then move on. And we have so many service businesses, they can't get employees. And it would be nice if we could find a way to, I don't know, some sort of a job incubator or something that would promote more permanent, higher wage type of employment that is different from what we have now. And I have no magic pills exactly how to do that, but, you know.
2:32:00 We can improve colors every week for the rest of our lives, but it's not going to make any difference in the long run. There is some stuff happening down in Bishop. They're doing a business resource center with the SBDC that's focused on entrepreneurship, and I'm not sure if that sort of thing is worth considering. I also don't have any thoughts off the top of my head. I don't know if there's a way that we could, I don't know, have kind of a brainstorm or something. I guess I'm thinking of the...
2:32:32 Recently talking to Mara Salcedo about the TOT.
2:33:03 Discussions are taking place about the moratorium on the potential moratorium or the discussion. And I know that they were planning on having a workshop on that. And I've asked that we be included in that conversation in that workshop because we are the economic planning and economic. I think that our TOT is a seat at that table. So that you're right. I think that we need to move more towards economy as well as planning. And there's a lot of different things.
2:33:39 And just for clarity, Vice Chair Burroughs, you're talking about the moratorium on short-term rentals. Yeah, I'm sorry. I said TOT. Commissioner Chang, any thoughts on this discussion? I think it's a very relevant discussion. Sure. Thanks, Chair. You know, some of you do know that I'm self-employed, I'm an entrepreneur, and my business does not, 99% of my business does not involve
2:34:11 It's not dependent on the town's tourism economy and the folks that I talk to, the few folks that I talk to in town that do similar to what I do and I think they share similar frustrations that Greg talked about, just mentioned and
2:34:41 I think the town really focused more on tourism than bringing other folks into this town, and I understand why. So I think perhaps this is something that not just PDC, but town councils really have to focus on in having some sort of a discussion or task force.
2:35:08 That can make that happen to bring these folks into this town. And of course, you know, a lot of these folks that they want to come in here, they're so concerned about because of school or because of internet connections or transportation reliabilities and so forth, you know, and weathers. And, you know, these are all the things that we need to kind of, we need to talk about. We need to just
2:35:37 I think, you know, can we think outside the box and see how do we make this work for the newcomers and that they will continue to stay here for many years? Sandra, do you have any thoughts on this? I'd love to hear them. Yeah, I mean, I think I don't want to spend too much time on it just because it's not an agendized item, but we typically in Mammoth Lakes have kind of approached economic development, you know, as
2:36:08 Facilitating development, really helping people get through the development process. We don't go out to conferences and try to recruit new businesses here. We don't do that. Mono County does do some of that. And we have partnered with Mono County on some economic development projects. So I think what would be good is to have an item, a future meeting, probably not the next meeting, but maybe the June meeting where we can talk more about economic development, what we currently do.
2:36:37 What other cities do. But just noting that we at this point have a limited staff and we couldn't add any staff members to kind of add tasks on this specific topic. But I think that it would be helpful to have a conversation about kind of what economic development is because it really is a lot of different things. It's not just recruiting new businesses. There's just a lot of different things you can do in that field. So I think
2:37:03 You know, if the commission is supportive, I think I would recommend bringing it back to commission to have a discussion, you know, with all of you and talk a little bit more about this and get some ideas that you have. Yeah, that sounds like what we're looking for. Okay. Does anybody disagree? Like Commissioner Kennedy said, I think we're all in favor. We just don't know where to start, where that first step is into this and, you know, having it on our June agenda just to...
2:37:34 Start the basic conversation of how we can help facilitate, I think would be great. I would also think that the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce would be a partner at some level in that conversation. Of course, yes, that would be good. I can include Ken and staff in that meeting. Okay. Any other commissioner reports? That was a good one, Commissioner Eckert. Please.
2:38:14 Request or interest in having PEDC change times and Sandra gave me a good response. I wonder if you could share it with the commission of the history so it wasn't always at 2 p.m. and then what the process would be. Sure, yes, so the planning commission, I've been here for almost 16 years and when I started here, the planning commission met at 9 a.m. and we received a lot of comments from members of the public that that wasn't a good time for them.
2:38:45 And through a process with members of the public, we came on this 2 o'clock meeting time because it was really after, it was a lot of the members of the public that were talking about the meeting times were service workers who would possibly work a morning shift or work the lunch shift and the dinner shift and this was a good time in between kind of those shifts. So we really responded to public comments and changed our time to 2 o'clock.
2:39:14 Thank you.
2:39:44 There's commissioners that think that this time doesn't work for most of our public. I guess I should say I bring it up not thinking that we should change our time, just thinking that we should look into it, and that's why I asked Sandra, but I personally don't think we'd get more public comment or involvement at another time, but I'm open to what the rest of the commission... Commissioner Eckert, are you interested in having that conversation? Have it on a future agenda? I think two o'clock's worked out really well.
2:40:14 Commissioner, Vice Chair, Burroughs. Looking at this, I do.
2:40:49 Do know that, you know, I've been on the commission, I think six years, and this is, this is the first time we've ever had anyone complain about our time that I can remember. And I think Greg is, Commissioner Ecker is right in that, I think it was you, I don't remember at this point, that people are going to come out when they have a hot topic.
2:41:18 They're, I mean, they're just not going to show up for our meeting for just to show up. So it's going to be a hot topic. And if, and if we, you know, have it that it's carrying over like this obsidian project, for example, maybe we do need to, after two or three times, look at trying to change a time to make it more convenient for those people who are, who are
2:41:41 Very concerned about the project. That being said, you know, we also can't please everyone all the time. So while many of the obsidian people are or the sand working villas are working, some aren't and maybe an evening time won't work for them. So we got to take a lot of things into consideration, but I'm open to the discussion. Commissioner Chang, what are your thoughts on it? No issue from me. I don't have any comments on this.
2:42:11 I'll just, my two cents is, I think the two o'clock time works well. I couldn't agree any stronger with Vice Chair Burroughs. If someone has a hot topic on our agenda, somehow or another they're going to show up. And people can submit written public comment. We do read them. I mean, it's not like it's a wasted effort. So I understand everyone's schedule is not the same. I also understand that you're not going to please everyone.
2:42:41 All the time. So whatever time we set this meeting, it's not going to fit into everyone's schedule. Now, having said that, Sandra, maybe we do have, you know, an occasion in the future where we can hold a special meeting. I think we've done that in the past where we can try to, you know, time it so it works a little bit more conveniently for like the traditional workday schedule, kind of a nine to five day.
2:43:09 Maybe we can have a special meeting, you know, after five or something along those lines. But I honestly think we have to take that on a case by case basis. Okay, thank you. All right, with that, then we'll go to the director's report. Thank you very much. I just wanted to remind you all, I think I sent all of you an email with the updated League of California Cities or Institute for Local Government Planning Commissioner book. You all received the old version when you started as commissioners. So if you're
2:43:43 Board and want to take a look at it, you can look at the revised version. And also a note that we will be bringing Planning Commissioner training here to Mammoth Lakes, here to Sweet Z on Friday, August 12th, this summer. So it'll be a full day of training. We'll provide lunch, but it'll be a really great opportunity and, you know, for all of you to get some Commissioner training. We're going to bring Commissioners from, hopefully, from Mono County and New County, Bishop, and maybe as far as Alpine.
2:44:11 Just to try to have some training. So it won't just be commissioners. It'll be staff as well. But it'll be a really great opportunity to have some training. And we just, I can't think of any time that they have ever come here to provide this kind of training. So I feel pretty fortunate that we're getting that. Also, a question kind of circling back to our meeting times. I was looking at our May 11th agenda for the next Planning Commission meeting. It is pretty full. We will have the Limelight Hotel.
2:44:41 Variance on Davison, actually three different variances. And now the Villa's three continued items. So I was originally hoping to request that the commission consider starting at one o'clock that day. However, you know, based on the public comments today, I can poll you if there's maybe a desire to have an evening meeting just for the Villa's three item, which might make it nice for commissioners who are conflicted out of that item.
2:45:11 But if we wanted to maybe look at pulling that one off separately, maybe having our regular scheduled meeting on May 11th for the other items, maybe we have that meeting later that night or something like that, I'm happy to do that. But I just have a feeling that that meeting is going to go long. So I guess maybe just a heads up, I will send an email out to the commissioners, maybe I'll talk to staff and try to finalize that time for that meeting.
2:45:37 And obviously we would let the members of the public know in advance if there was any changes to the time. Could we do it as easy as just instead of starting at two, starting at three and putting that the last thing on the agenda so it ends up being an evening thing anyway? We could. We could. So the Mammoth County, they do do items on their agenda that is time certain. So we could have the Planning Commission meeting where that item was a time certain start, you know, maybe later that night.
2:46:08 We were also looking to try to have a joint meeting with the town council possibly that day to give a presentation to the commission and to the council on the phase two parcel project, which will be coming to you for public hearing in June. So that's going to be a really busy day that May 11th. So a lot of stuff going on, but it's possible that we could do it later that night.
2:46:38 But maybe we'll just need to think a little bit about the schedule and then get back to you on it and maybe reach out to a handful of members of the public and see if another time worked better. But clearly it has to work for the commissioner's times. So, Sandra, you'll just reach out to us individually? Yeah, I'll reach out to you. So, yeah, look out for that email and that's all I have. Any questions for Sandra from the commission?
2:47:09 I would say if we're going to incorporate a workshop, a town council, then clear your calendars for the 11th. Commissioner Chang, did you have something? I saw you unmuted yourself. Oh, sorry. Sandra, do you know what's happening with the Yotel project? Is construction going to take place this year? No, I don't think so on that project. I don't think we've received any resubmittals. I think they're... I wouldn't expect anything to be happening with that project anytime soon, but...
2:47:49 Oftentimes property owners will surprise me. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions for Sandra from the commission? All right, guys, I appreciate your time today. I'm going to adjourn today's meeting, the April 13th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, and we will adjourn to our next scheduled meeting, which is May 11th, 2022, time of starting TBD. Thank you.
2:48:24 Thank you, everyone. Appreciate it.