Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2022
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
360 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 As a body? Yes. I think it's kind of time. Yeah, I mean, it's not on the agenda. However, you can come and be in person at any point, right? So if there was a desire, you could come back. Whoever wants to could come back in April. My thought is that we'll add that to the April agenda. Okay, that sounds good. But whoever wants to at this point can be here in person. Also, it was on the Recreation Commission agenda yesterday, and they did decide to meet
0:30 in person in April at their next meeting. But yeah, you don't have to actually take any action. You can just, you guys can just come back if you want. Got it. But yeah, go ahead. I was going to bring it up. Hey, Jamie, how about town council? Are they meeting in suite Z in person? Council member staff has always been in the room with us, but nobody else is, no. Got it. Hi, everybody. Morning, Steve. Good morning. Good to see everybody. Appreciate your patience on this matter, bud.
1:06 It's because of you, Michael. I feel like a little bit of a betrayal going on right now because I'm sitting in front of Big Sky Montana Ski Resort while I'm doing this. Big Sky, I've had a chance to ski there. It actually skis quite a bit like Mammoth. Oh, totally, totally. It's a big mountain too. Yeah, big mountain. The only drawback is, I've always nicknamed it, is you better bring a book.
1:40 Why do you say that? I'm curious. The base area could use some expansion. Yeah, they've, when's the last time you were here? Last winter, I did a boys trip out there. I've got a good buddy of mine that relocated from Brentwood to Bozeman, and so we all went out for a visit. Nice. It is a great mountain, though. Nothing like Mammoth, though. Nothing like Mammoth. I am biased. Hi, Nolan. Hey, Steve. How are you? Great. How are you?
2:14 Ed, finally here to commission. When did we start on this project? Two years ago? We've been crossing to us when we at least wrote the density bonus program about it, so. Before. Hey, Sandra, do we know if all the commissioners will be present today? Yes, they should all be present today. Is anybody conflicted out of Steve's project? I think...
2:56 Greg Eckert is, I believe. Yeah, I think Greg is. Yeah, and that's it, so just Greg. Amy, besides Sandra and Jen, is there anybody else in Sweet Z at the moment? Yes, there is. Good morning, Commissioner Kennedy. Morning, Amy. Morning, Michael. Morning. How's the not-so-little one? She's a firecracker. Yeah, thank you. She's four, keeping us on our toes. I was going to say, keeping you honest.
4:30 Yes, indeed. Wait till they turn 13. Oh, God. I'm scared. I really am scared. I was too until they turned 13. I'm like, oh, they're okay. We got through this okay. Oh, man. So, Michael, are the kids in the big ski race next week that you thought they were in? They are. My daughter is on the high school ski team and she qualified for both GS and slalom. Oh, my goodness. So, we'll see how she does. She's pretty excited.
5:12 Congratulations. Yeah, it was good. Yeah, excellent. Mammoth High is on a little bit of a roll right now. You probably saw the girls varsity soccer team won the state championship. I did see that. The boys Nordic team won the state championship. Wow. The high school boys basketball team made the playoffs. The football team was one game away from the state championship. Wow. That's pretty impressive for our little community.
5:42 Not too bad, that's for sure. Yeah, especially for the non-snow sports that maybe we don't, you know, think about it. Play year-round. So, Sandra, I've got 9 o'clock on the nose. It looks like we have a quorum. I saw Commissioner Chang jump on. So, I'm going to go ahead and call this meeting to order the, what do we got? March 2nd Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we have roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Sure.
6:14 Commissioner Eckert, absent. Commissioner Kennedy, your Vice Chair Burroughs, present. Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you, Jamie. And just for the public's knowledge, I believe Commissioner Eckert will be joining us, but he has conflicted out from the first agenda item. So I would imagine he'll be joining us after we finish with that matter. So now if everyone minds standing and Nolan, would you mind leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance today?
6:46 I pledge allegiance to the flag, United States of America, to the republic for which we stand, one nation under God, indivisible, liberty in all. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate it. All right, I'd like to open up public comment right now. I will ask that if you have public comment on a matter that pertains to an item on our agenda, that you hold off in your public comment until that matter comes before the commission.
7:18 And I also want to let the public know that item number 4.2, otherwise known as the Villas 3 project, has been continued to the April PEDC meeting. So you're more than welcome to give us your public comment on that matter, or you can reframe until our April meeting. Jamie, let's limit public comment at three minutes each.
7:47 If you did submit written public comment, I will let you know that we have read, we have reviewed all of the written comment, so you don't necessarily have to read your public comment that was submitted already verbatim, just to kind of keep this meeting moving. So with that, I'll open up public comment. First, we'll, if there's any staff reports, let's jump into that first. Jenna, please, you're our lead off hitter.
8:16 Thank you. So, Jenna Carter, Code Compliance for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll keep this short real quick. I know you have a long meeting. Real quick screen share. You should see a pie chart now that shows the work that I've been working on. You can see signs is now still the priority, and I've added more signs to that. I also wanted to quickly mention noise, about how to respond to noise and how we respond to noise. We do get noise complaints.
8:45 I did look through the files just at this project that's going on, and I've only received three complaints in the last three years, just so that the group knows, and two of those complaints were from a golf course, or from golf course noise, so they were not, the complaints I receive are not party complaints, they're not nightly rental complaints. If someone has a complaint about nightly rentals, they can reach out to a hotline here we have. I'll leave it on the screen for a minute.
9:10 It's the T.O.T. hotline. We also have a T.O.T. email that people can reach out to with any complaints about short-term rental concerns. If it's after 10 p.m., the Mammoth Lakes Police Department does respond to noise complaints, and they have reports on that. This is a non-emergency dispatch phone number.
9:29 And if it is an emergency, you can call 911. But the non-emergency dispatch number works great. They communicate directly with our officers in town. The officers go out and make site visits and talk to people and they make notes. So I have, I think there were three records of noise complaints from this area of Obsidian area, Joaquin area in the last also about five years or so. So some information for you all, the decibels right here real quick.
9:58 In our municipal code, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., the noise limits are 45. Then it's actually about the noise level of a refrigerator hum. I have it here so that everyone can see. It's pretty quiet. 10 p.m., the nighttime, the 35 decibels is like a whisper. It's like a rustling leaves. So just to kind of put it into perspective. Real quick here, I'll share one more time so that everyone can see my sign project.
10:28 Just real quick, where did it go? Well, if I can't find it in three seconds, I will move on. Here we go. There we go. You should see the Menau map with dots on it. So as a visual, back to signs, my sign priority. Red dots are out of compliance signs. Out of compliance signs. They're unpermitted. They're banners. There's some...
10:53 Like flutter flags, a couple. And then the blue are all compliant signs. So just as a visual, most of the town is compliant, but there are several pockets where I need to focus on some education and get some applications in for some of those signs. And I'm open for questions if anybody has any, that's it for me. I don't have any questions. Does anybody on the commission have a question for Jenna? Jenna, just a quick one. I thought of something. For the non-compliant signs, I'm assuming you're giving the businesses
11:27 Verbal warning? Yes, it's all starting with a verbal warning. Nothing citation or anything yet. We want more education, pardon me. It's more about education right now. And yeah, it's softball. Got it. Thank you, Jen. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you for the hard work. Were there any other staff reports that would like to be submitted now before the commission? Okay, seeing none. Yeah, I'll open up to public hearing. If you do have...
12:01 If you do want to give public comment on the Villa 3 project, I will ask you, I'll reopen public comment after we go over item 4.1, which is the 377 Manzanita Road project. So if you do want to submit public comment on the Villa 3 today, I'm going to ask for you to wait until we get to 4.2. And again, that item has been continued to our April meeting.
12:28 Having said that, is there any public comment? Yes, there is. One moment. Michael, Ted Carlton, with due respect, you've got a bunch of people in the audience. I know that you, being on Zoom, that you can't see them, but I'm sure that people who want to make public comment should make public comment now on Villas 3 so you can spare them their time. Thank you. Thank you, Ted. I appreciate that. But in total fairness to Steve as the applicant at 377 Manzanita.
13:04 His item has been continued multiple times, so I am going to ask public comment for the Bill of Three to be submitted when that does come before us on the agenda. Thank you, Ted. Yeah, that's insulting to the people here, but of course you wouldn't care because you're home in front of your screen. I'm actually at the office, Ted, but I appreciate the sentiment. All right, Jamie, any other public comment not pertaining to anything on the agenda?
13:38 Somebody else want to make public comment on something that's not on the agenda? No, there is not. And I will put a closed public comment and we will go to public hearing. Item 4.1 is the consideration of a use permit and design review application for a proposed six unit multifamily residential apartment project located at 377 Manzanita Road. And I believe our staff contact is Kim. Yes, thank you. I'm going to share my screen.
14:14 Okay, can we all see the presentation? I think it's, yeah, just came up. Okay, great. Thank you. Good morning, commissioners. The item before you is a public hearing for consideration of a use permit and design review application. This is for a proposed six-unit multifamily residential apartment project located at 377 Manzanita Road. A use permit is required for this project because the application includes a density bonus request.
14:50 The proposed apartment project is a six-unit multifamily structure located on a nearly one-quarter acre vacant lot in the residential multifamily one zoning district. The apartment building is comprised of a single three-story building with understructure parking, an exterior covered stairway access, as well as elevator access, and each unit is assigned two tandem parking spaces.
15:16 The site plan provides three exterior guest parking spaces and two extra tandem parking spaces within the shared garage. So the project does meet the parking requirement and provides two extra spaces within the garage that may be assigned as needed to one of the units.
15:36 A town density bonus is requested to permit an additional three units, which is the maximum density bonus that may be requested through the town density bonus ordinance because it accomplishes double density on the site. A use permit is required to approve the density bonus, so the required entitlements for this project include a use permit and a major design review. This project would result in rental units, no ownership units, and there is no subdivision proposed as part of this project.
16:08 The project site is located within the residential multifamily one zoning district, which permits multifamily uses at a density of 12 units per acre. The site is 0.23 acres, nearly a quarter acre. So the permitted density in the zone allows a maximum of three dwelling units on the site. This is a just a context slide. This is the vacant parcel. It shows the street view. The site is undeveloped and features several large Jeffrey pine trees throughout the site.
16:40 The surrounding land uses include a five-unit apartment building on the north side, and the adjacent lot to the south is vacant, but located next to that lot is a 14-unit development apartment project, which is Mammoth Mountain Ski Area housing. A currently vacant lot abuts the property on the east side, with multifamily apartments located on either side of that lot.
17:09 Vacant lot was approved for a six-unit multifamily planned unit development in 2019 and included approval of a town density bonus for two units. So the applicant is requesting double the base density of three units for a total of six units. The affordability level proposed is the occupancy restricted category, which is the least restrictive affordability level because it is not an income-based restriction.
17:40 This requires the largest number of deed-restricted units to be provided in order to be eligible for the requested density bonus. And it results in a requirement of a minimum of 85% of the base density must be restricted to that income category. So that rounds up to a minimum of three dwelling units are required.
18:07 Despite that, all six units are proposed to be deed restricted, which exceeds the standard requirement. And in exchange for the extra three units being deed restricted, the applicant is requesting two additional concessions to the applicable development standards for the project. So what does the occupancy restricted income category mean? This income category requires a qualified resident.
18:36 to occupy the unit as his or her principal place of residence. This resident must be a natural person who works an average of 30 hours or more per week at a business located within the boundaries of Mono or Inyo County. And for example, if this person worked 60 hours per week for one half of the year at a business within Mono or Inyo County,
19:02 They could potentially work elsewhere for the other half of the year and this person would still be a qualified resident. The resident must also be a natural person at the time of application who lives in the boundaries of Mono or Inyo County. So either of those categories would be eligible.
19:25 Implementation of the occupancy restriction requires that rental units may be rented only to households certified by the town or its designee as satisfying the eligibility requirements specified in the town density bonus ordinance. At least one occupant of the unit must be a qualified resident as defined by the ordinance and each required workforce housing unit
19:52 shall be reserved for qualified households for a minimum of 55 years, and the town or its designee will monitor the rental or workforce housing units for compliance with the workforce housing agreement. So the applicant is requesting three incentives slash concessions, which is allowed through the town density bonus ordinance. The project is automatically eligible for one of the allowed concessions specified in the ordinance, and that
20:26 Requested concession is an increase in lot coverage from the standard 50% to 65% approximately. An additional concession that is requested is a 20% reduction in the required setbacks. This specific concession is listed as one of the allowable concessions that an applicant can request. And then as an alternative concession, the applicant is requesting that the town permit.
20:55 one guest parking space located within the front setback. In addition, a reduction in the required snow storage is allowed through the town density bonus ordinance. It is not considered a concession. It is just that these projects are automatically eligible to request that a snow management plan, which would allow hauling of snow off site, to be allowed and approved. This was included as a condition of approval.
21:26 Number 41. And the project site still provides some amount of snow storage. It provides about 1,386 square feet, where 2,486 would be required. So this is the project site plan. I just wanted to quickly identify the proposed concessions. This parking space is the alternative concession requested. Reduced front setback of 16 feet.
21:59 Reduced setback here of eight feet, the covered stairway entry is allowed to encroach three feet into that reduced setback, so they are showing a five foot setback here, and a reduced eight foot setback on the south side for the driveway, and the rear setback is not being reduced. And then the overall lot coverage does exceed the standard 50%.
22:30 So the floor plan for each unit is the same. Each unit provides approximately 980 square feet of living area, which includes three bedrooms, two bathrooms, one office, and not included in the living space are the two assigned parking spaces. So on to the design review portion. The building form has a modern aesthetic with a simple shed roof line.
22:58 The building facades provide variation in visual interest through the provision of recessed balconies, metal window awnings, accent, colors, and materials, and the use of a variety of window shapes and sizes. A distinction between stories is provided through a change in siding material used on the first floor and the upper floors. A split-base concrete masonry block is used on the first floor to establish the building base.
23:25 Upper floors are clad with hardy lab siding in a wood textured finish, and stucco siding is used on specific locations to provide variation. The building design is compatible with the existing uses and development on surrounding properties. This shows the street view, the west and east elevations, and this is the north and south elevation of the project.
23:56 The proposed colors and materials consist of a variation, gray-tone stucco, tan split-based block, medium-width tone with grain on the cementous siding, and a dark rust red and dark green accent color. The combination of these colors and materials does provide appropriate contrast between the trim, fascia, and primary siding materials.
24:21 A landscape documentation package will be required prior to issuance of a building permit because the applicant is proposing permanently irrigated areas on the site that exceed 500 square feet. Generally, the proposed landscape preserves three native pine trees and proposes shrubs and small tree species that are appropriate to Mammoth Lakes. This slide I thought would be interesting. It represents evolution of the building elevation of the project.
24:53 It illustrates really how the project has kind of improved through discussions with the applicant team and the applicant has been receptive to incorporating design changes based on staff's comments. And then this is just showing the same thing, just a more complete building elevation. So the proposed site layout and project design was reviewed by PEDC.
25:26 by the design committee on December 29, 2022. The design committee indicated that they support approval of the site layout and building design and no revisions to the plans were requested. One public comment letter was received by staff in response to the public notice that was published in the sheet for the February 9th PEDC meeting. In summary, the main points in that comment letter really
25:55 was that the author had concerns regarding a lack of play areas for children and that children within these neighborhoods tend to play in the streets because there's not area for playground and she is worried that that is a safety concern. Another concern is snow storage and that being a cost that is passed on to the tenants of the project because of the requirement for hauling snow off-site.
26:24 The author also indicated that she feels the density of the site, the ideal density is the three units, and that the potential for up to 18 to 36 residents is too dense for the size of the site. This public hearing was re-noticed from the last PEDC hearing date because we exceeded the time allotted for that meeting.
26:52 And we have not received any additional public comments for this item. So with that, based on the information included in your staff reports and the resolution, staff finds that the project meets the applicable requirements and recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving use permit application number 20-002.
27:25 and design review application number DR 20-004 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. That concludes my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions from the commission. Stephen Seltzer is the project applicant and he is on the call today. Thank you, Kim. Appreciate that. I'm going to ask the commission to hold off on your questions for staff. I'd like to give Steve a chance to
27:55 Maybe make a statement or a presentation on his project. Michael, thank you very much for the introduction. Kim, thank you for doing a great job of doing the overview on this project. As most everybody knows, this has been a passion project for me. I created the Starbucks in town and there was a real crisis for workforce housing and that nobody was really focusing on how to solve the problem for workforce housing.
28:20 As you know, the staff has created this double density bonus program to be able to allow properties like this quarter acre projects to go from a three unit density to a six unit density. But as you can see, and thank you, Kim, for putting all those drawings out there. We've gone through many reiterations of this drawing to make sure that we fit this puzzle piece properly on this project.
28:45 That is part, you know, the main part of this. I just want to give special thanks to everybody in the staff. Dan, I want to thank Sandra and Nolan and Kim and everybody that's involved, you know, the PEDC. And thank you guys very much for this opportunity. Thank you, Steve. Appreciate that. Any questions for staff or for the applicant from the commission? I have a question, Michael. Please, Jen.
29:20 One of the concerns from the community member that sent in the letter was the cost of trucking and the snow storage and the cost of trucking the snow out would be put on the renters as a burden. Can we confirm or deny this? You're asking if we get, this is what we were going to be doing is adding the snow storage program just like I did in Starbucks.
29:52 Same thing, we will be adding this into the project detail for sure. Okay, but who's going to pay for it, I guess is the question. It will be coming through the tenants, yes. Okay, thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions from the commission for either staff or Steve? I'm not seeing either Commissioner Kennedy or Commissioner Chang unmuting themselves, so I'm assuming not.
30:24 Hey, Kim, I just have a couple of quick questions, and then I have a question for Steve as well. Could you just reiterate again whose responsibility it is to verify the qualifications for the renters at this project to make sure that they meet all the criteria for workforce housing tenants? So it would be the town or its designee. So right now, I believe it is.
30:55 Nolan, as our housing coordinator at the town. It's possible in the future that it could be Mammoth Lakes Housing. Nolan, do you have any comments on that? So that would be a requirement of the restriction that goes on the property with the, it's required to be recorded untitled, requiring that all the tenants prior to occupancy, the owner or whoever is managing the project.
31:24 Verify their eligibility through the town or our designees. That's a requirement prior to occupancy. And then on an annual basis, that's verified again. We send out monitoring letters to then requires the owner submit that information back to the town with the information on their tenants to certify that they remain qualified tenants. Got it. So that will be reviewed on an annual basis. Is that what I just heard? Yes.
31:54 Got it. And Kim, this project that Steve has before us, these will be rental units. These will not be sold as private property, correct? That's correct. Could you just briefly touch on what the process would be if Steve decided to sell his project down the road to another party and how that deed restricted?
32:21 condition would remain with the property with the new owner? So the deed restrictions are recorded on title for the property. Steve would not be able to sell the units individually. That would require that he go through the condominium conversion process, which is difficult to do right now with the number of rental units that are available is so low.
32:52 If he were to sell the whole project to a different management company or a different individual, these restrictions are on title for the property. So they will be passed on to the next owner. And that deed restriction has a shelf life of, did I hear 55 years? Yes. Got it. So that would stay with the project no matter the ownership? Correct. Got it. Okay. So any other questions from the commission? I have one more, Michael.
33:23 Please, Jen. How is the rent determined? With deed restriction, is there a maximum amount that the rent can be? Or does Steve decide that? Who decides what the rent is going to be on these? So the restriction for these units is occupancy restricted. It is not an income-based restriction. So these would be market rate units, how they are proposed currently.
33:55 Okay, thank you. With that, I'm going to open it up to public comment on the 377 Manzanita project. Jamie, do we have anybody that would like to submit public comment on this project? Yes, we do. Go ahead. I'm Alan Walker. I have two lots down from this project. We get snow from the road right now from the project next door, the fiveplex.
34:25 It has no parking because the town allowed them to split that lot and build the three-plex next to my house. The three-plex, when they allowed it, and Karen Johnson allowed them to split that lot, the five-plex is a foot onto the lot of the property they allowed to be built, the three-plex. The three-plex, when they get a water leak in the wintertime, they unload their roof onto my roof because I'm only...
34:55 I don't know how they're going to remove the snow on the back of that building next to that five-plex. There's no way. And then I don't see where the trash is going to be on that property. I don't see if it has gas where the propane tank is and how they're going to have their snow storage all the way behind the building and then have a truck come in and then take it all away, let alone a parking spot in the street in the front 20-foot setback.
35:24 And then have the snow come off the street and go on top of that car. And right now, the snow comes down the street and they can't put it in the five-plex because they park in the five-plex, there's 10 units or 10 bedrooms. They must have 20 cars. So they park five across and four deep in there. So there's no snow storage on that property at all. So all that snow comes down, it goes in my front yard and ruins my fence every year.
35:55 So I don't see where any of this even fits on this property. I don't see, in fact, they've neglected to even put the disposal, the trash can on the property. I don't even see it. And then somehow, now it's going to be, the rule used to be it had to be off the 20-foot setback in an enclosure. And they don't even put it on here.
36:17 And then I heard something about where now it's going to be up to the town and the road department and the trash disposal company to decide where the disposal goes. Right now we see what the town has approved. I bought my house in 85 when the town purchased, you know, became incorporated. And it's gotten worse. Everything this town does has made everything worse as far as over-densitizing everything.
36:47 Karen told me that dumpster would never be on the street in the 20-foot setback next to my house. That thing, within a year, was on the front. And then they had a parking spot in the front. It was illegal. She had the parking thing removed and the pavement taken up because that's where they put their snow. But they parked there in the summer on the dirt, which is fine, but you're always supposed to have a non-percolating surface when you have a parking space. It shouldn't be in the dirt.
37:17 So they took that away, but they still park there in the summer, but in the wintertime they can't because that's actually where Crockett puts the snow. And as far as the one you're proposing now, there's no way that any snow from the street is going to go in that front. If it does, then it'll bury a car and they won't have a parking space. So if they say it has a parking space, it won't have a parking space. Because there's no way they're going to take that little snow every storm and put it in the back.
37:44 And then all of a sudden, like, you know, we get a big winter like we just had in December. Where is it all going to go? In the meantime, we couldn't get out of our driveway for three days because the town didn't come down and plow it. So I don't know how they're going to take the snow and truck it out when you can't even get in there to plow it. It just doesn't make sense. Why you guys are always over densitizing. You know, before you had this understructure parking.
38:12 You had a density that fit, and people parked outside. Nobody parks in these garages. You have a 7-foot, 8-inch, 10-inch garage opening? Come on, no one's going to park in there. It looks like it has tandem parking in there. I don't even know where the office space is. What's an office space for in an affordable housing unit project? Right now, some of Eckert's...
38:39 Who's on the Planning Commission. Go look at his properties. Drive through the Sierra Valley sites first thing in the morning, 5 o'clock, and look at what you've got now. You've got four plexes on about the same size as his property that nobody parks inside. The whole driveway has cars parked in it. You know, there's so many things missing. I just, I can't believe that if you even consider this stuff because we need this affordable housing, well, you're making it so no one will live in it.
39:06 If you can find somebody around here that'll live in that kind of stuff, you know, it just doesn't fit. I mean, the bedrooms look like they're so small you can barely put a bed and a dresser in it. I mean, it's just crazy. You know, it's unbelievable that I'm here discussing this thing and yet you can drive down the street and see what doesn't work. The Meridian Villas.
39:28 Where Ted Carlton was the manager when it first was built. All those cars now was an affordable housing project on Meridian and Mono Street. All the cars park out on the street in the summertime. I don't know what they do in the winter because there's only one parking spot for them in a little garage that they can barely put the cars in. So there's a lot of problems and I really wish that you guys would get out and look at what's already been passed and how it fits.
39:58 And if you think it fits, then you should get a different job because it doesn't fit. I mean, the one that I was just saying. Can you please wrap it up? He's got a three place and all his people are, he has a lot of landscapers with trailers and they park all over the street now to where everybody that lives there now, they're moving their street property and barricading the street because people are parking there. Right now, this project has a car that's parked on it that's been there all winter.
40:27 And the guy shovels it out, and he's from another apartment building across the street that they won't let him park. He has three cars in a two-bedroom. And he has a garage. Sir, we appreciate your public comment. But in fairness to anybody else who might want to submit public comment, we're going to... I don't even see anything on here that shows you where the propane bank is. We can respond to your questions. Or where the trash is going to sit. We can have Kim and our staff respond. Okay.
40:54 So if you want to, you can have a seat in case there's anyone else who wants to provide public comment. Yeah, let's have everyone who wants to submit public comment on this project submit it before we have Kim reply. Thank you. Jamie, is there any other public comment either written or in person in Suite Z on the 377 Manzanita? Tom Hodges, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yeah, thank you. Can you hear me? Yeah. Yeah, good morning, Commission. Thanks for allowing me to comment.
41:29 So I just wanted to express our support for Steve and his efforts on this project as the adjacent neighbor. I'm sorry, Tom Hodge is on VP of Planning and Development at the ski area. We own the adjacent property on Manzanita to the south. And I just wanted to comment that Steve's been very proactive in reaching out to us and sharing his plans with us. We've provided him a lot of feedback over, gosh, Steve, I don't know, it's been...
41:58 I think he's been working on this for close to a year. So, you know, just a couple things I'll point out that I think Steve did a good job in terms of site planning. You know, the driveway is on the south side of the property, so it is going to get good solar exposure in terms of the driveway. You know, not to say that when we have our big dumps, there's, you know, still going to be snow removal concerns, but you do have some solar benefit there that's going to help with.
42:25 Melting snow over time, reducing ice buildup and so forth to make it more functional from the perspective of the driveway and the access into the garages. I think the flat roof is a good design feature on this property. It's very low pitch. It really should hold the snow. I don't think you're going to get snow shedding to the north side of the property. By and large, it'll fall on the roof. A lot of it will blow. I mean, in our experience with flat roofs, they
42:55 You know, to whatever degree you get wind, they're going to, it'll blow and drift off the roof. But you won't get, I don't think you're going to get any substantial shedding off the north side of the roof. So I don't think that's a concern. And, you know, I guess the other thing I wanted to just point out is, you know, Steve is following the rules. And, you know, the town did pass the density bonus program with the goal to provide more housing for the community. And, you know, I think.
43:23 To Steve's credit, he's followed those parameters and the rules that are adopted and come up with a solution to do this. And I know it's been a hard challenge, as Steve pointed out. He's worked several different scenarios on this to come up with a solution that would work. And he's got something there that meets, checks all those boxes. So I just want to commend his efforts on that. It's not easy. I get it.
43:51 And, you know, and I think they're part of this that is commendable is, you know, Steve's a private developer and he's trying to figure out, like you said, he's got a passion for Mammoth. He's trying to figure out a way to follow the rules, meet the code and provide housing for the community. So, you know, I want to recognize his efforts to do that. And again, I just also want to, again, reiterate our support for his efforts and hope that you find your ability to approve the project moving forward. Thank you.
44:20 Thank you, Tom. Appreciate it. Jamie, any other public comment on 377 Manzanita, either in person or via Zoom? No, there is not. Kim, would you like to take a moment to address some of the gentleman's concerns? Sure. I'll just quickly point out on the site plan, the proposed location for the propane tank is here. It's located the correct distance from existing from the proposed structure, which is 10 feet.
44:51 Required. So it is in an appropriate location. The trash enclosure is proposed within the rear setback area, which is allowed by the municipal code. They are proposing an enclosure. Gates are not necessarily required. They're showing them here. But that is an appropriate location. We can work with Mammoth Disposal on finalizing that location. And for the...
45:21 Temporary snow storage areas, we have approximately 247 square feet here within the front setback, and then at the rear of the property, which is accessible through the proposed parking areas, snow storage, 730 some odd square feet in the rear setback area, access to the snow storage areas seems reasonable.
45:46 And the proposed parking space within the front setback, if you look here, you can see the existing edge of pavement is actually located about 15 feet from the front property line. So the town's snow storage from the street will primarily be located here and hopefully won't impact the space too much. However, they will be removing snow from the site and pushing snow into this temporary storage area. I think that kind of covers
46:17 Most of those comments, the one comment that Tom brought up about the snow shed onto the north side, we did verify, so the roof material proposed is an asphalt shingle, and that material doesn't tend to shed as dramatically as metal roofs, so that will also help that condition on the north. Thank you, Kim, appreciate it. Sandra, did you want to add anything, or you're good? No, I don't have anything to add on that. Thank you.
46:47 Okay, I'll close public comment on 377 Manzanita. I'll bring it back to the commission for thoughts, opinions. Chair, I've got a question for Kim. Please, Commissioner Chain. Kim, you just mentioned about town's snowplow process. And can you show that photo, that picture again, where that temporary storage space?
47:22 Snow Storage Space? Right here. And that's on the east, northeast? So this is on the northwest corner. Northwest, okay. And this is Manzanita Road here. And this line is indicating the edge of pavement. Okay. Do you know, so, and town is going to handle all snow removal within the project?
48:06 Or just a road in front of it? Right. So the town's no pause will only clear man's need a road. And my comment regarding the location of the edge of fame, it was really to show that there is space for the snow that is piled off the road that won't necessarily impact the parking space here. I mean, it may on big years, but
48:39 They will be clearing snow. The town does not have a responsibility to clear snow off of the project site. The applicant will have to submit a snow management plan, which identifies basically when they anticipate or what hauling contract would be in place. That gets approved and recorded on title for the project.
49:11 I think... So I'm curious, I think we have in the past, we have approved a few projects that require a snow management plan. Yes. And have you run into any issues where there are deficiency of snow removal from any of those projects in the past within the last couple of years? And how are you going to...
49:46 either enforce or provide oversight on that type of snow removal. And the reason I ask that question is because you require snow storage for this project is over 2,000, right? Right. And we're reducing snow storage by 50%, over 50%. Am I correct? Yes.
50:20 So can you give us a little insight as to how the town enforce and oversee this type of activities? Kim, I can respond to that one. Okay, thank you. So I think the snow and maybe Amy can also respond as well, but the hauling requirement for residential properties is relatively new. So we don't have a lot of residential properties that have been approved.
50:51 through this process to haul snow. However, there are a number of residential properties that actually do this on an ongoing basis just because it does become an issue. So we don't really have a lot of experience with this regulatory environment in the residential zone. However, we do have a number of commercial properties that have been approved for snow storage or snow hauling.
51:12 In the commercial areas. And occasionally there are issues and we really deal with those through the code enforcement process. So it's really, we receive a complaint, Jenna goes out and lets them know and requires that the snow be removed. And in the commercial area, we've generally had pretty good responses when that issue has occurred. But like I said, we don't have a lot of experience with this in the residential zones. And I don't know, Amy, if you have anything to add to that.
51:42 I don't think I really have anything to add. Sandra, you hit the nail on the head there. The document being recorded against the property, it allows us to provide some level of enforcement via the co-compliance process. Yes, other properties have been cooperative in the past. It's in property owner's best interest to comply. I'm not aware of us having significant issues. In this particular case, will the
52:12 Does this mean that if the tenants have issued with snow storage or snow removal, do they first go to, of course, the owner and if the owner won't be able to provide solutions or is not able to provide enough to solution that the tenants requested, they'll go to public works or do they go to the PDC? How does that work?
52:43 They could contact the town, they could contact public works or planning, we would refer it to code compliance, which is part of the community and economic development department. I do want to mention to, I think, to help alleviate the quantity of snow storage, there is a portion of the back, the east part of the site there, that hasn't officially been designated as snow storage, however, it does.
53:14 It could be, and it does supply, you know, another couple few hundred square feet of snow storage. They just haven't calculated in their numbers. You're talking about the... Kim is showing it... As a 10-foot sit-back area? Yeah, exactly. So that space is also available and easily accessible for snow storage, as is the area to the south of the site.
53:42 We all know that there's going to be snow stored there. However, because that area is not technically 10 feet or greater, our code does not allow that to be used in the snow storage calculation. Another question about the enforcement of qualifying tenants. Has the town have any experience in a situation like this where
54:23 There are no income limit restrictions on this. So essentially, these are market rent, market rate units. And PEDC will be the, will be the unit that handles all of that type of management of these tenants' approvals? No, the PEDC does not review the qualified tenants.
54:57 So just to clarify, the property owner.
55:16 We'll review and qualify the tenants and the town monitors this on an annual basis. So we're actually monitoring, we're not qualifying tenants, we're not kind of going through that process, but we're monitoring this on an annual basis. Just to add to that, so since these require, the eligibility to be for one of these units requires that you live in the unit full-time and that you work within the region. So part of that review criteria requires that they provide one,
55:48 Utility statement that shows, because obviously our mailing uses PO boxes, but it requires them to show their physical address on that, so we verify it through that for living in the unit, and then we also require that they provide their most recent pay stubs to certify that they remain employed in the region. Is there a requirement for number of occupants allowed in these units?
56:23 I mean, not through the deed restriction, but there is just the limitability restrictions that limit how many people can be in a bedroom that becomes a code compliance item if they exceed that. But it does require, you know, we can't allow overcrowding of housing or anything to that nature. Okay. The applicant you mentioned earlier, and this is for, I think, Kim or Sandra.
56:55 That the tenant, that the applicant have the ability, can turn this into a condo map in the future if they would like to. Even though that process might be a bit difficult, but that's the possibility. Am I correct? It is a possibility. However, it is extremely difficult to do that once the project has been occupied.
57:28 Because the town requires, we have some parameters for converting apartments to condos. And those are really intended to preserve apartments in our community. And one of the parameters is that we have to have less than or more than a 5% vacancy rate of apartments. And since I've been here for 15 years, I don't think we've had less than a 5% vacancy rate. So it's just very, very difficult to do. Or the property has to be vacant for two years. Those are the two things.
57:57 If Steve built this project, occupied it, and he wanted to convert it to condos, either we would have to have more than a 5% vacancy rate or the project would have to be vacant for two years before he proceeded with the condo conversion process. So we just really... And how long does that 5% vacancy rate has to happen?
58:22 That's a community-wide vacancy rate. So we check every January. Oh, so not just with this project itself. No, it's a, sorry, I apologize. A community-wide vacancy rate. We do monitor that. We conduct a review every January to determine the vacancy rate. And, I mean, I think it's just less than a half a percent in every year. I mean, it's very, very low. So I can realize a whole entire project has to be vacant for two years.
58:52 For two units minimum. Those are the two, those are the kind of the two alternatives if you wanted to convert apartments to condos. Either their town-wide vacancy rate needs to be less than, more than 5%, or this project itself needs to be vacant for two years before they convert it. Can I add to that? Sure. So yeah, as Sandra said, we monitor that every January. In the past few years, we've been less than
59:23 Between about half percent to one percent. For 2022, I just got the report last week, we're actually at zero percent currently. For the month of January, there are no apartments listed for rent in any of the local resources, any of the local classified or rental resources. So we're actually at zero percent currently. And then, as Sandra said,
59:47 If he did want to pursue a conversion, he would have to then leave all the entire project vacant for two years and then apply for a use permit and a tentative tract map, which then would come to commission for approval. So it is very difficult to convert once they're occupied. Okay. The next question, this final question I have is for either the applicant or public works, when will this take place if it's approved?
1:00:21 construction-wise, great ground, and where will the staging area be? Because in this particular area, the streets are so narrow, so tight, and what kind of impact that would have to this particular neighborhood and to all the occupants in the area? Paul, I can answer that.
1:00:52 The conditions of approval include a condition that the grading plans for the project include a construction, staging, and management plan, and that is required to address parking of construction worker vehicles, equipment, staging materials, and whatnot. Typically, this all occurs on the site, and if that
1:01:21 Doesn't provide enough space for a contractor to do the work. They are free to negotiate with individual property owners, but that's private party agreement. But typically those types of things occur on the site. We have had a couple of projects in this particular area. Have you had any experience about a disruption that the construction had happened in the area?
1:01:54 I'm sorry, are you asking if we have had any complaints about disruption? Right. Of all that, you know, during construction time? I am not aware of anything. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Any other questions for staff or the applicant from the commission or anybody have any thoughts, opinions? I have thoughts. I have a couple thoughts, Michael. Go ahead. Please, Commissioner Kennedy.
1:02:31 First, I just want to say thanks to staff and to the applicant for providing all these updates. And I did notice looking at it initially that that yellow color was changed since we last saw it. And I appreciate that. It looks much better now. I am a little bit concerned about the trucking of snow, but similar to a lot of things we deal with, the fact that this is an allowed process, I don't think is grounds for.
1:03:00 Shifting anything around, and I appreciate the comments and the additional snow storage, but especially after, I think it was Michael, your comments around the holidays of snow storage around the big storm being a difficult thing, and I'm a little concerned, you know, we can't find enough drivers for ESTA, we probably can't find enough drivers for snow storage, so it's, we're kind of dealing with all these different things that all play into housing, and here we are with some housing on the table for the local workforce, so.
1:03:28 I appreciate that. And I think it's really fortunate for us to have a chance to consider a plan that focuses specifically on housing for the local workforce. So just wanted to say thank you to everyone for that. That's all I've got. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Anybody else have any thoughts or opinions or questions from the commission? I do. Please, Commissioner Burroughs. I'd like to echo what Jessica said about...
1:03:55 Being able to supply housing for our workforce, we've identified for quite a while that this is a continued problem and it's the number one problem that our town has identified. And being able to provide more units is really important. I think that Steve has done a good job being responsible about it. He's provided parking for each of these spots.
1:04:22 Mammoth Lakes Housing has identified that people in workforce housing really want garages and we are supplying garages here and so I think that's essential to this project. I would like staff, if possible, to follow up with the surrounding properties that the gentleman discussed about possible parking violations and
1:04:50 Lack of snow removal and to determine if there's an issue going on there. And I think that's all I have. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. My thoughts are pretty much you guys have kind of nailed all of my thoughts. You know, obviously we've identified workforce housing or lack of workforce housing as one of the critical needs for this community. And, you know, as everyone knows, that trickles on down. If you can't afford to live here, you can't afford to work.
1:05:22 Employers have serious issues with staffing, whether it's the mountain all the way down to smaller mom-pa operations. So I think we all recognize that this is a product that this community is in desperate need of right now. I agree that the trucking of the snow from the residential project, I can see some concerns there, but
1:05:52 You know, for this project to pencil out on this lot, you know, some concessions had to be made and, you know, the trucking of snow and the snow management plan was one of them. So I am in favor of this project and unless somebody has any other questions or opinions for staff or the applicant, I would be happy to hear a motion. I'll make a motion to...
1:06:23 Adopt to attach PEDC resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings, and approving use permit application UPA 20-002 and design review application DR 20-004 with conditions as recommended by staff. Do I have a second? I'll second. So we have a motion, we have a second. Is there any other discussion? Any other thoughts, opinions?
1:06:55 No? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Project passes 4-0. Congratulations, Steve. And thank you for bringing this product to the community. As we all four have mentioned, workforce housing is critically important for the future success of Mammoth Lakes. So thank you, Steve. And thank you for your patience.
1:07:24 Thank you all. I really, really, really appreciate it. Okay, we will move on now to item 4.2, and I'll reiterate the fact that this agenda item has been continued to the April PEDC meeting, but we would be more than happy to hear public comment if anybody would like to submit it now. Good morning, commissioners. My name is Kimberly Taylor. I've commented previously. My comments today will include the inclusion of...
1:08:05 Two additional comments. The first, I am providing a pre-recorded statement from one of our residents who is unable to be here. This pre-recorded message is from Judith Goddard, San Joaquin Villa's unit. Not surprisingly, I'm unable to attend a 9 a.m. weekday public hearing in person. I'd like to thank you for collectively taking your foot off the gas and allowing time for a thorough and fair review.
1:08:39 Thank you.
1:09:09 Thank you.
1:09:41 I request that documents provided for the April 13th PEDC meeting clearly identify all changes that have been made. It is not fair or reasonable to expect public review to have to start from scratch for a third time, trying to identify any and all changes to the vast quantity of documents. Secondly, I request that the documents should be made available to the public a full week
1:10:10 Thank you very much for your time and attention this morning. In addition, I'd like to read a comment provided by the Board of Directors of the San Joaquin Villas Homeowners Association, which states that the Board of San Joaquin Villas Homeowners Association believe that the majority of owners of San Joaquin Villas HOA support that the units 22 through 25
1:10:40 of Villas III not be built due to the reasons brought up previously. And in closing, my personal comments are that I concur with everything that I have presented here today. I have presented my statements previously. I also ask that we be given appropriate time prior to the April 13th meeting. I understand staff has continued this due to the additional five-week time that you'd like to have time to review and assess these.
1:11:10 We ask for similar courtesy in doing that. In providing updated documents, again, it is thousands of pages. If we reread the CEQA and all of the other attachments attached there, it's very difficult for people who have full-time jobs to suddenly catch up on that in three days, and I think really unrealistic. So, again, I appreciate your thoughtful approach. I look forward to the April 13th meeting. Thank you.
1:11:38 Thank you, Kimberly. Kimberly, please let Judith know we also received her written public comment. I believe it came in this morning. Good morning. My name is Eric Taylor. I want to first thank Vice Chair Burroughs and Commissioner Chang for the opportunity to speak this morning by voting no just three weeks ago today on this particular project.
1:12:16 I also want to thank all four commissioners and Mayor Salcedo for taking the time to speak with SJV residents over the last couple weeks since the hearing. Director Moberly and Michael, I want to thank you for choosing to continue this hearing for an additional five weeks to review and update the plans. I echo Judith's request.
1:12:43 as well as Kimberly's, that the planners provide the next staff report in advance. I would appreciate that. I'm calling for that to be released Friday, April 1st. I'm going to keep my comments brief, and I have just one request. And I don't know if Mark is on the line. I wrote this and used the term the developer.
1:13:14 Mark, I didn't think through that you were going to be on the line. If you are out there, no disrespect intended, but I'm going to be to you as the developer. Okay, for my request, Mayor Salcedo, Director Moberly, and all four commissioners working on this project, please ask the developer, Mark, to perform an internal pro forma analysis of this project without units 22 through 25.
1:13:46 I know that may sound crazy, but hear me out. Removing these four units will not hurt the developer's bottom line. Please consider the benefits for everyone. The four units, if built, are going to sell for far less than the other 29, I think for obvious reasons that we've been talking about here in the last several weeks. Yet the cost of building
1:14:18 is going to be the same as the other 29. So there's going to be very little profit, if any, in these four units. If built, vacationers aren't going to want to rent them because they face workforce housing. Not that there's anything wrong with us, but it's not a luxury view, and that's what these people are coming for. There's going to be less DOT generated because people won't be staying there.
1:14:50 And with these four built, everyone loses. Now if they're removed, on the other hand, the developer is going to benefit from fast approval and support from the community. A tentative tract plan will only need very minor changes. Just remove these two duplexes. The land where these units would, you know, are planned for.
1:15:19 This land between the planned road and the north line is a perfect location for snow storage for both Callahan Way and the new road. This will give Villa's guests more space to enjoy and less snow clogging their roadways and between their buildings. This snow storage area will make a
1:15:45 Perfect visual barrier for the villa's three guests and a sense of exclusivity that those guests are going to love. Each of the 29 units will sell for more than originally planned and produce more TOT due to higher rental prices. In late spring to early fall, this area can double as a green belt and a natural crossing for wildlife. This is good for CEQA,
1:16:18 And Ville's guests will have a private, all-natural space to enjoy. Most importantly, the area provides the perfect location for snow storage for Callahan Way. As everyone knows, this existing one acre of pavement stretches 250 feet from the frontage road next to main, downhill, snow that is plowed.
1:16:46 is piled up at the end of Callahan where the project is supposed to begin. Remember, Callahan Way is SJB's, San Joaquin Villas, only entrance and exit for vehicles. And it has always needed plowing after every snowfall for safety. So like always, this snow should be plowed downhill.
1:17:12 And should be deposited on Villas 3 property between the new road and the northern border. And the Villas 3 neighborhood sign is moving back a little further, giving a greater sense of exclusivity that guests will love. And investors or individuals will pay more for to purchase in the first place. So, Mark, if you're out there, I think that when you
1:17:47 Try to pencil that out with a pro forma. You're going to find that this path actually makes more profits for you. The town will earn more TOT than with these units. And additionally, law enforcement resources won't be wasted on noise complaints. The project gets done faster before interest rates skyrocket, before investors disappear, hopefully not World War III starts.
1:18:20 It's a win-win-win. Please consider my request to remove these four units from the project. Again, please consider removing these four units. It's not a profitable opportunity. Everybody loses by having them there. You have the addition of the badly needed snow storage right on your northern property, and everybody wins. So please reach out to me if you have any questions or want to discuss.
1:18:56 We look forward to working with the commissioners, the planners, and Mark Yu, the developer, to make this a very successful project. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Eric. Appreciate it. And thank you for submitting your written public comment as well. Good morning, everyone. My name is Donna Mercer, and I live in San Joaquin Villas. And I tell you.
1:19:37 We really want to make changes. We really want to work with the developer, Mark, and the Planning Commission. There's a lot of things that are very good about this project, but there are a lot of things that are not really good about this project. I'm going to go ahead and read those now. So regarding the last staff report that came out,
1:20:03 I found that there is so many issues that have basically been brushed off with the staff report March 2nd and the resolution number PEDC 2022-03 that came out February 25th, 2022. I don't see any changes except for some tiny modifications. Other than that, the developer staff have made no changes to the project to address previous public comments.
1:20:33 Staff has added extra text to the report in an attempt to address those comments, but in the end has not made any changes. The neighbors and the community are looking for some modest changes to the project to mitigate the impacts of the adjacent properties, but it seems the town is going to steamroll the neighbors' concerns in order to wholly accommodate the developer. I also feel the town has skirted the public participation's objectives of CEQA by modifying a 30...
1:21:05 plus year old EIR, and the lengthy addendment included four technical apprentices, I have submitted more lengthy comments regarding the CEQA process of my additional letter. Also, I'm sorry, also, I'd like to comment about the early, I think it's Jenna, Jenica, I'm not sure the name, that provided comment on the noise coming from Obsidian for the last five years. That in regard has, it has
1:21:37 Basically, no reference to what is being built right now. And I'm going to say that because Obsidian faces the golf course and faces away from Joaquin Street where the duplex is going to be built. And then the duplexes on top of that are going to be really on top of Joaquin Street and San Joaquin. So there can be no comparison about noise coming from Obsidian.
1:22:05 Compared to the duplexes that are being built very close to us right now. Also, my last comment is going to be about why the Planning Commission is meeting in the middle of the day to where the public cannot respond. I have spoken to many, many people regarding this development. In town,
1:22:31 At least over, I went to 11 businesses in town and spoke to lots of employees so I can get their input. I suggest City Council and maybe Planning Commission does the same because a lot of these people are not being heard and I was going to actually have someone who is speaking Spanish and can translate a lot of what's going on to the Hispanic community which is also left out in a lot of what's going on here and not aware.
1:23:00 So with that being said, there's a lot more comments that I think people, you know, are going to bring forward. A lot of people that commented also upon this are very, very concerned about having a village atmosphere in our neighborhood. And that's pretty much all I'm going to say about that. So there's a lot more things that hopefully we can work out with the developers and the Planning Commission to make this work for everyone in the community.
1:23:29 So thank you for your time. Thank you, Donna. Thank you for submitting your written public comment as well. There are no further public comments. Jamie, besides the written public comment that was in our packet, has anything new come in in the last couple hours? No. Is there anybody that wants to give public comment via Zoom, Jamie? No. Thank you. Then I will close public comment on item 4.2. The bill is three.
1:24:09 Subdivision and we will move on to staff presentation 5.1. Presentation on. Sorry, sorry, Chair Vanderhurst. Just a clarification that this item is continued to a date certain and that date certain is April 13th. So there will be no new public notice provided for this. However, we will continue to send emails out to the members of the public who have provided comment just to let them know. So just to clarify that. Thank you.
1:24:37 Thank you, Sandra. Appreciate that. Staff presentation. We have a presentation from Hayes on the 2022 slash 23 five-year and long-range CIP projects. Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. Go ahead and share my screen. Can you see my screen? We've got it, Hayes. Is it the full presentation or is it the PowerPoint? PowerPoint. Thank you very much.
1:25:23 Yeah, so I'm on my CIP Roadshow. I'm here today to talk about the draft 2223 five-year CIP and introduce the 2223 long-range CIP. Today I'm going to go over the recommendation to the PEDC. A little introduction and background on the process and schedule. Discuss the 2223 five-year project updates. We'll dive deep into the 2223 long-range projects.
1:25:52 And then we'll circle around to some discussion and hopefully get some direction from this group. So today I'm looking for you to basically receive this presentation and then provide comments on the five-year CIP and comments on the long-range CIP. And specifically, I'm looking for consensus from the commission on the projects. I don't need the timing to be specific at this point. I need to let you know that there are no...
1:26:19 There's no funding or budget identified for most of the projects. These are pretty long-range projects. And then I want you to identify anything missing or anything that should be removed in your opinion. So five-year capital improvement plan includes development, maintenance, improvement, and the acquisition of infrastructure assets. Projects, including the CIP, are typically major non-reoccurring projects that have a long service life that will be
1:26:50 Underway during the five-year cycle or in the case of long-range CIP up to 20 years. CIP expenditures are considered beyond the scope of normal annual operating or maintenance expenses. And most importantly, the CIP does not appropriate funds. It is a short to mid-range planning and budget tool that identifies project and coordinates financing and timing. The town budget is what appropriates funding towards projects.
1:27:18 And finally, the CIP does not include vehicles, technology, software, and emergency and stopgap work. Stopgap work is things like filling popples. The CIP has a number of contents. Similar to last year, it's got an introduction, identifies the different categories, talks about the process and development. It does highlight previous year's work, goes deep with project narratives into current projects.
1:27:48 has an outlook on future budget, talks about an outlook into the future budget to help town council make decisions, and then it has a comprehensive five-year plan with project narratives. The long-range CIP that we're proposing will identify projects in years six through 20. This will help us to coordinate infrastructure development on a much longer timeline, will align with longer-range strategic planning.
1:28:17 It informs the development impact fee process, which is something that the staff is working on right now on a parallel track. And like the five-year CIP, it will be dynamic. It will be updated as the town's needs change and as the needs of the community change. Where are we at in the schedule? We started with a meeting with the Recreation Commission back in February. This item was continued from February as well. So we're meeting today just to kind of...
1:28:49 introduce the projects, get your feedback. We'll take it to Town Council for review on March 16th. And then once we've got the final list, we will be back before PEDC to ensure that the project list conforms with the general plan. And then we'll incorporate the current year projects, future year projects into the budget process in May.
1:29:12 So the 22-23 draft project list, what has changed? While we removed the completed projects such as the Sierra Business Park, some of the airport projects, transit shelters, we have a couple of carryover projects from 21-22 such as the CRC, the road rehabilitation and MUT project that will continue in April. We updated project budgets and we updated some schedules.
1:29:38 Key changes for projects for the five-year CIP, we added a community center at the parcel, which is part of the parcel project, a municipal bouldering park that has no specific schedule or budget, an outdoor amphitheater, which was a recommendation to submission out of the last round of the CIP. Again, no specific schedule or budget. Dog park moved $100,000 to 2324 with the intent to construct next summer.
1:30:07 A park at the parcel, which is part of the master planning process. Again, no specific schedule or budget at this time, but we do believe that will be resolved in 22-23 and will be incorporated in that project next summer, that parcel project next summer. We also moved the old Mammoth Road Bonds Transit Shelter to 23-24. We have some issues we need to resolve as far as land acquisition.
1:30:35 And we deleted the town hall improvements. I'll stop here. Any questions on kind of the changes, key changes for the five-year CIP? Any questions for Hayes at this point, guys, from the commission? Where is the dog park going to? I'm sorry? Where is the dog park going to be placed? Thank you. Got it. We have not identified the final location of dog park. We have a couple of alternatives that are being vetted at this time.
1:31:15 The floor is yours, Hayes. Thank you. So, what do we have planned for construction this summer? So, like I mentioned, the continuation of the CRC and the road and mutt project. 60 Joaquin are hoping to break ground on that floor plex. Our storage building at the airport just basically secure a place for our firefighting equipment and some of our snow removal equipment at the airport.
1:31:45 We need to replace our fuel island at the town yard. It has exceeded its useful life, and obviously we need diesel to do snow removal. We're looking to advance the MAC project. We've got a number of park maintenance and improvements that we're working with Stu's deferred maintenance budget. Big project, Laurel Mountain Sidewalks, reconstructing the majority of the road, adding bike lanes, sidewalk, coordinating that work with the parcel, coordinating that work with the HSIP.
1:32:15 And also an undergrounding project that is a couple of years out. We'll be managing a number of aspects of the parcel, mostly related to rights-of-way. We will be bidding as a town the Chaparral Extension in managing that project. That developer will not be managing that component. We've got two beautification projects planned, one for the Old Mammoth Road corridor and one for the Main Street corridor, adding
1:32:41 Some hardscape, plantings, irrigation, a number of different things, and that's slated for this summer. Doing a slurry seal project for all the bluffs, and then finally, highway safety improvement program grant, we'll be adding a pedestrian beacon at Mountain Boulevard and Main Street, and then redoing the two existing beacons at Laurel Mountain Post Office with high visibility rapid flash beacons. That's kind of our...
1:33:10 The gist of our work program for this summer and a lot of these projects will probably spill into next summer as well. Hey Hayes, before you go to the next slide, would you mind just going back for one slide to the projects you've got on, could you just maybe touch on the timing of the old Mammoth Road and Main Street beautification projects? You know, obviously the 4th of July parade is a big deal in this community. It's a high visibility event and I'm just wondering if
1:33:40 Those projects are, if you're foreseeing them being concluded before the 4th of July? I do not see them being completed before the 4th of July. These are pretty significant projects. Specifically on Main Street, we have to install irrigation for the entire length. There's no irrigation out there right now. That was all removed and intended to be replaced as part of the sidewalk project. So we have some significant undergrounding work to do before we even get to planting.
1:34:10 There's still some additional design work, bidding process. I don't suspect we'll be working on that project until July. It'll probably be a late summer project with the intent of buttoning it up by the beginning of fall. And it's a similar timeline for Old Mammoth Road. Got it. And then can you just maybe expand a little bit on the Advance the MAC project? Yeah, there's a lot of conversations going on regarding the...
1:34:40 Arts and Cultural Center, and we're, town is working with the foundation on some of the designs and development, and if it's the pleasure of the town council to continue advancing that project, it's likely that staff will be in charge of the construction, the bidding process, and so forth. So we have this as a placeholder for staffing resources and so forth. Got it. Thank you, Hayes. Any additional questions on the current project list? Commissioner Chang?
1:35:12 Yeah, on the old Mammoth Road and beautification project, from what I can see, you guys did a pretty good job already. What else do you guys have to do, really, to it? Is it simply because you've got to put storm drainage? So the scope of the old Mammoth Road beautification project is from Main Street all the way down to Mammoth Creek Park.
1:35:44 There's a, there were, in the original project back in 2004, there were a number of landscape strips that were originally planted with grass. And because of changes with watering and irrigation, we really can't maintain those areas. So we've been working with a landscape architect to provide a number of different treatments for those kind of dead spaces between the curb and gutter and the sidewalk. That includes a combination of hardscape,
1:36:14 which would be filling it with concrete to kind of expand the width of the sidewalk, using pavers to kind of give it some articulation, and then some additional plantings that would be more in line with annuals, perennials, and so forth, in strategic areas. We're also looking at providing planter boxes, which would have annual plantings in some of those landscape areas to kind of break up the concrete.
1:36:42 The potential paver areas. There's also some irrigation work and a few other things that are associated with it as well. Given that this is a project for 2022 and 2023, I'm assuming that you have some of the funding or most of the funding available for all these projects? Correct. The key projects? These projects are...
1:37:10 Pretty much fully funded. Some of the projects have set asides and may need some because the full budget wasn't complete at the time the town council allocated funding. So there may be an additional ask going into the budget cycle, which I mentioned is going to happen in May. But for the most part, with the exception of the MAC, which the town is not really in charge of the funding, town council has allocated the funds.
1:37:39 for or a grant is providing the funds for all these projects. Do you have dollar amounts attached to all these key projects that we may see? Yes, I believe it was in the packet. There's a table with the five-year CIP that was included that has the budget numbers for each of these projects. I got it. Thank you. Yeah, sorry about that. No worries. Thank you. Hey, Hayes, before you jump off this slide,
1:38:11 Could you just kind of expand upon the MUP project expansion? Like where are we talking new MUPs? So it's a continuation of last year's work. So we had $2.7 million worth of road work and MUP rehabilitation. That work was not completed before winter hit. And so we have three sections of road, mountain boulevard, majestic pines, and a small piece of red fir.
1:38:42 that need to be constructed or reconstructed this summer as part of last year's project. So these are just continuations of previous work. Got it. Any other questions on this slide, guys? If not, feel free to steam ahead, Hayes. All right. So we're going to take a deeper dive into the longer range projects. And this base list was developed by compiling
1:39:12 All of the projects in adopted plants. These projects and ideas were, some of these ideas were not reflected explicitly, but considered by council, commissions, and unadopted documents as well. So we've kind of looked at the battery of work, planning work over almost two decades and compiled that into a single list and started to distill that down based on.
1:39:39 Council, strategic planning, kind of realistic funding opportunities, oftentimes just necessity and kind of order of operations just to make things work for connectivity and so forth or the nature of storm drains water flowing downhill. So from that, it was about 235 projects and I'm going to go through this in detail. I know it's including your packet, but I'm going to walk through these slides so we have an opportunity to discuss each one. We did the same.
1:40:09 process with the Recreation Commission, and I just wanted to relay their comments. One, they wanted to, excuse me, ensure that the wayfinding project included the town loop on Main Street, and they wanted to prioritize the following projects, but they didn't really, like I said, we don't need any timing, they just wanted to make sure the town council knew that they thought these were important. One is the Old Mammoth Road Mupp, and that would be a continuation of a multi-use path from Waterford.
1:40:38 up into past the bluffs, connecting to kind of the terminus at Mill City. Development of the bell-shaped parcel, both in housing and for park purposes. Development of an urban snow play area and an outdoor event center. So those were kind of their priority projects out of the list I'm about to go through. So I've broken this long-range project list down into components that are consistent with the five-year CIP.
1:41:10 And with this year's CIP, we did add an affordable housing component because that is a very important strategic priority for the town council. So we wanted to identify those projects separately. So staff put together this list of potential housing projects looking, and these are, like I said, these are not specific to timing or budget. They're just, these are long-term, long-range goals. So working on the bell-shaped parcel.
1:41:39 Working with the foundation on their housing, looking at advancing something at the community center, working with the forest service on their administrative site. And then we've had this in our existing CIP and it's in our existing budget, just undefined housing projects, just putting money away for opportunities. And then obviously future phases of the parcel. And then I'll stop at the end of this slide to kind of talk about these in more detail. The airport.
1:42:09 That has its separate ACIP. Sierra has brought that forward. There's nothing longer range than that with the airport that needs to be included in this document. General facilities, looking at building a new town hall and ceasing renting this building. Expansion of the town yard, creating storage building. Right now, we do store equipment and shelf out in the wintertime. Town-wide EV charging infrastructure, a hot topic for mobility.
1:42:40 Fleet expansion, with the parcel, we need to look at additional trackless loaders, blowers, and electric vehicles for fleet, childcare center, and then additions, an additional community center. So I'll stop there. Again, I'm looking for consensus direction, consensus comments on the long range projects. Any questions or opinions right now for Hayes from anybody on the commission on just this slide specifically?
1:43:13 Hey, so I've got a question. So a couple times now the bell-shaped parcel has come up and clearly it looks like the town has identified that parcel for future, I'm assuming workforce housing. Is that a correct assumption? It has not been identified for anything at this time. It is an opportunity site that we believe warrants future discussion. So there's been no direction to staff to do anything with the site.
1:43:42 But we believe it needs to be on the table as a conversation piece. Got it. So it hasn't been, nothing has been designated for the Belchia parcel specifically. There's been a lot of ideas over the years, but no formal direction. Got it. And then on the general facilities, the community center, are we looking to add a second community center or?
1:44:13 We're talking about the community center that's located adjacent to the village, correct? Yes. When you're looking at a 20-year horizon, that building will probably be at the end of its useful life and we'll need to look at replacing it and then identifying a location to replace it. It could be in the same location or it could be maybe on the parcel or any other opportunity site that we have in town. It's something that we need to consider on a time frame of 20 years.
1:44:43 Got it. And when we talk about that community center, the current location, does that also include the tennis courts? Yes. And Hayes, at what point would you like us, if we have any projects that were not listed on that spreadsheet that was in our packet, at what point would you like to hear from us on that? If we could hold that to the end and get through the list, and then I can compile any consensus additions to the list at that time, that'd be.
1:45:14 Easiest for me if that's okay with you. Absolutely. Last question on this slide though, Hayes. How long is the current lease the town has for the office space there in Minaret Village? I believe it is up this year and lease negotiations are ongoing. Generally, are those leases, do they go year by year or is it multi-year lease? They're typically multi-year. And the town I'm assuming has the...
1:45:45 The option to exit the lease if so wants to. I am not party to the negotiations. I think it would be inappropriate for me to comment on those lease negotiations. If we need to take a deeper dive into that, I would need to include Dan. No worries. And our apologies for putting you on the spot there. No worries. Any other questions on this slide, guys, from the commission? Feel free to move ahead, Hayes. All right.
1:46:17 And thank you for bearing with me. I know this is a healthy list, but I think this is important stuff, and I do appreciate your comments on these projects. So moving on to the police department, in 20 years, we'll need to consider an addition to the PD building, potentially for dispatch services, and that building was designed for a future addition. Specific to Parks and Recreation, I'm sure you're all aware we're in negotiations on an expansion of our lease with LADWP, and we'll be looking to expand the Whitmore Complex.
1:46:47 We're also, we've actually applied for a grant to build out a track locker room and some training space. The pool is going to need upgrades in the next 20 years. In the next 20 years, we're going to hit our 100-year anniversary on that pool. Also, we talked about the bell-shaped parcel space as far as housing, but it also is a consideration for other uses, which it could include.
1:47:12 Tennis courts or multi-use courts, dog parks, amphitheaters. That's not specific. We're just kind of putting out some general potential parks and rec uses. We do need to consider the outdoor event center for replacement of Sam's Wood Site. There's been a number of plans that have kind of called for some type of urban snow play area. So identifying a permanent snow play area safe with, you know, restrooms and parking. OHV.
1:47:41 OSV staging and trails, road designations, subpart C's ongoing. This is a topic that's been discussed in multiple documents over multiple years. And then storm drain projects. Town has a storm drain master plan. We have a storm water master plan. And we also are party to a regional storm water plan. The high priority projects are all in the John Muir Davison area.
1:48:10 As well as down in the parcel. We've kind of, obviously, water flows downhill. We know that much of the town's flooding risk actually stems from the John Muir and Davidson area. So those are the priority projects. So I'll stop here and receive any comments you may have on any questions or comments from the commission on this slide. The only question I have, Chair, is urban snow play.
1:48:41 Which, I guess, because, you know, I love the Mammoth, every area that I see, it's a snow play in the wintertime. So, I'm a little confused why this is kind of on the list. What's the reason behind this? So, the intent is to designate a location for people to take their children, their families, to play in the snow, someplace that has
1:49:12 Appropriate parking, has facilities. Right now, I think we're all pretty well aware that there's a lot of bandit snow play that goes on on private property, off the side of the road, people sledding into the road, and it's long been considered that a lot of those practices could be unsafe or hazardous. So the idea is to find a location where we can send people to say, yeah, we have, here's our snow play park.
1:49:41 And it's a safe location that provides those opportunities for our residents and our guests. Thank you. I have one question. Please. Hayes, can you expand a little bit on that first one, the police department expansion slash dispatch, what that would be for? And my question is mostly since their building is so new, just curious what that item is planned for. Yeah. And keep in mind, we're talking about a 20-year horizon. So we're considering things on a much longer scale.
1:50:14 The PD building was designed for a future expansion and there may be a need for the town to provide dispatch services on a 20-year horizon. So if that need came through conversations with, you know, Mono County, the Sheriff's Department that we needed to provide those services, this would be the placeholder for those infrastructure improvements.
1:50:41 Got it. Perfect. And that, like you said, the building was initially planned with thoughts of an expansion down the line. Yeah, the easterly side of the building is basically designed so that it could be built out. Aha. Good to know. Thank you. Hayes, I don't think you're going to make your CRC meeting, bud. Yeah. Are you seeing this screen? Are you seeing my...
1:51:09 You're sharing your, I think you're sharing your left, like one of your monitors. So we're actually seeing the PowerPoint kind of not as a presentation. Oh, I asked that question. Yeah, you, and I think Chair Vanderhurst responded that we were seeing your PowerPoint. Okay, and I interpreted that you were actually, okay, I apologize. No worries. Hey, Hayes, can you go back to the previous slide really quick? Yeah, sorry, I lost my spot when I started realizing I was not.
1:51:38 Actually working from the right place. No worries. Hey, on the storm drain projects, I was asked by some residents who live in the trails why that storm drain was not included. I think historically there's been some flooding issues down there. Can you just maybe touch on that? Yeah. So within a 20-year horizon, we're only going to be able to accomplish so much.
1:52:13 Storm drain projects are very expensive and the funding is difficult to come by. And so when you're prioritizing these projects, you need to look for what parts of town are going to have the biggest impact. I know that the residences there have concerns, but historically those issues are not as
1:52:41 The consequences of those issues are not as severe as they are in the John Muir or Davison area. The water that comes off of those areas as identified in the three plans I talked about is significant and is the impetus for flooding in other parts of town. Whereas in the trails, those issues are isolated and are often related to not historic storm drain issues.
1:53:12 They could be more related to topography or other improvements that have been made by the residents. Okay. All right. Thank you. Yeah. And I'm going to try to fix this. I apologize. Probably unshare and then reshare again. That's usually the easiest way to do it. Is that better? Much cleaner. Yeah. Sorry about that. I'm going to find my spot again. There we go. All right.
1:54:01 So moving on. So streetscape and signage, looking at improvements to Meridian Corridor and Tavern Road, conversation about a permanent CMS town messaging, creation of, excuse me, expansion of the signage and wayfinding program into the Lakes Basin, Reds Meadow and the Scenic Loop. On the streets,
1:54:30 A rehab program, I'm sure you're all aware that town has a pavement management system. We annually track changes to the pavement condition index and then make recommendations on treatments throughout town. This is just an annual placeholder for street and mop maintenance. We've also discussed the idea, there's an ongoing conversation.
1:54:56 regarding evacuation routes, and there may need to be some improvements to some Forest Service roads to potentially use other exit points or entrance points to town. Consideration of a Meridian road diet, we did a road diet on the segment between Old Mammoth and Minaret, and there's been a conversation about potentially
1:55:21 Providing additional pedestrian connectivity along the Meridian section between Evil Lodge and Minaret, and that would be part of a road diet, reducing the number of lanes. Also, Minaret-Meridian intersection improvements. I think we're all very well aware of how well that signal functions for everybody, and we need to look at replacing that, as well as some improvements at the Forest Trail-Minaret intersection. Those are...
1:55:47 A lot of those improvements could be tied to future development in the North Village Pacific Plan or developments in the main lodge area, but it's something the town needs to consider on 20-year horizon because it is a bottleneck area. And then we have a slew of potential sidewalk projects. These are all identified in the mobility element and the pedestrian master plan, Chateau Road, Arrowhead, Chaparral, Sierra Nevada to support the parcel, Azimuth, Sierra Manor Road, Center Street.
1:56:15 Sierra Valley Site Roads, we've been looking at how we could provide better connectivity in Sierra Valley Sites, and then the south side of Meridian, and I'll stop there and receive any comments you may have. Any comments or questions for Hayes from the Commission on this slide? Hayes, the Lakes Basin Reds Meadows Signage Scenic Loop, the expansion of the wayfinding, is that also, I know Joel and Mammoth Lakes Trails,
1:56:52 They're attempting to clean up the spaghetti bowl of trails, hiking trails that connect the lakes and the lake spacing. Would that eventually live in your world or does that not live in your world? So that lives in Joel's world unless it's a public works project that needs to be bid. The work he's been doing has not risen to the scope of necessitating a public bidding process at this time.
1:57:22 What we're talking about here is the municipal wayfinding program. These are the signs we put up a few years ago all over town, the very large format signs. They were designed to reach into these areas. We just at that time did not have the funding or the approvals to build that signage in these three areas. And so we'd like to look at doing that on a longer-term horizon to expand that consistent messaging.
1:57:51 Into the basin and Red's Meadow. Got it. Thank you. On the road diet, on Meridian, are you referring from Minaret, intersection of Minaret and Meridian all the way to Eagle? Yes. Thank you. Yeah. Right now there's, I believe, five lanes in some of those segments and it was similar to the section.
1:58:22 To the east and we remove some of those lanes to provide sidewalks and bike lanes. So another consideration to do something similar on the westerly side. Would additional parking be also part of that consideration, Hais? I think everything's on the table when we're having that conversation. It's just five lanes doesn't support the traffic volume and there may be a better way to utilize that real estate to provide.
1:58:51 Like I said, pedestrian connectivity, maybe transit connectivity, multi-use paths, and even parking. Thank you. I believe this is my last slide related to projects. So trails, Sherwin Trailhead and the connections for the Sharp Work, Old Mammoth Road Mupp, which I discussed as was a recommendation coming out of the Rec Commission, Lake Mary Trail Mupp.
1:59:20 Coming up with a way to work with the Forest Service to provide some more trails in the Lakes Basin. And then the Lake George Trail Mupp, which has actually been designed, but we are still looking for final approval to connect the trail that's at Lake Mary right now up into Lake George. On the transit and mobility front, looking at trying to find a way to provide a mobility hub or better connectivity to the Lakes Basin.
1:59:50 Expanding our pedestrian-activated crosswalks. These are the crosswalks you see on, like, Old Mammoth Road. We're looking at maybe Voodoo Chute and Davidson across Lake Mary. We talked about bell-shaped parcel, Eagle Lodge, creating some type of mobility hub to serve that area. That would be part of a road diet. That'd be a multi-pronged project.
2:00:13 Village Mobility Hub. I think we're all well aware of the mobility constraints in the village. We need to continuously look for opportunities there. Subtype of intercept lot. This is in a number of different documents, trying to find a way to capture traffic before it even hits town and then put them into transit or other multimodal ways of reaching their destination. Expansion of the hillside parking lot to support the village and even provide additional EV opportunities.
2:00:42 Some type of transit intercept lot for yards, Estelle, longer distance buses. Right now, they're just kind of dumping off on the side of the road, on the side of 203, and I think we can do a better job of serving those users. There's long been a need for tour bus parking, overnight tour bus parking, finding some location to park those buses. Expanding our transit shelters, like I mentioned, where we have the old Mammoth Road bonds, bus shelter has moved to
2:01:11 Next year for reconstruction, that is our last existing transit shelter that is not in the current configuration that doesn't meet our current standards. Once we reconstruct that bus shelter, we'll be looking to expand to the highest profile, highest used bus stops. And then we have a need for long-term paid overnight parking or even long-term free overnight parking. There's just a need, a desperate need for parking expansion in town.
2:01:43 So, again, that's the totality of the long-range CIP list. Thank you for your patients working through that list. I'm happy to receive comments on this specific segment and then receive your comments on anything that might be missing or should you recommend being deleted. Again, I'm looking for consensus on these items.
2:02:09 specific to long range or the five year that we previously talked about. Got it. So any questions or comments for Hayes from the commission, not only on this final slide, but on the entire presentation? Are there any projects that you guys see are clearly missing or any projects that maybe you want to have a little bit more emphasis on or priority on? I think this is the time to
2:02:41 Let Hayes know exactly what everyone is thinking. I can jump in if you want, Michael. Please. No questions, Hayes, but I did write down my kind of most, the ones that stood out to me as the most important in the five-year plan and the longer-range plan. I think, I don't see anything missing and I, there's obviously importance on every one of them, but the ones that stood out to me were the intelligent transit system, this is the five-year plan one.
2:03:12 Real-time transit information. I know that that's been a major part of why I don't take public transit much in this town and why I don't often recommend it to people because of the lack of that. The pedestrian beacons, I think is a great, great call on Main Street. The Laurel Mountain sidewalks, which I think was already, you already mentioned is in motion. And then the CRC, continuing to build that. And then all things housing, couldn't really pick out one that was most important, but.
2:03:41 Just all the housing stuff. In the long-range plan, the things that stood out to me were, again, all things housing, child care center, wayfinding. I think that was Lake Space End, but overall in the town. And then I just wrote down mobility stuff overall. Hard to pick one of those, but I do think with the discussions we've had about the parcel and even the items that we've seen today in commission, the parking continues.
2:04:07 With the parking provided as, you know, meeting the town codes, I do think this is an area where people want to drive to Trailheads and to Bishop and to June Lake and all that. And so I do think having some more developed off-site parking, whether it's out of town or I think that was in your last item on this slide, the long-term paid overnight or long-term parking, especially for people who are visiting, but also for residents as we continue to develop projects that
2:04:36 May, people may, in that three-bedroom house, or three-bedroom unit we were talking about earlier, there may well be three cars, four cars, and so where can we have people put those long-term? And that's all I had. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, did you have some comments? Yeah, you know, Pace, thank you for the presentation. I think the only thing that really stands out to me is storm drains among this list, and I think, you know, it's something that's unseen.
2:05:09 And, you know, people don't realize how important this is until, you know, we run into problems. And I think this is something that, you know, we should definitely focus on in addition to maybe the location that either the chair had mentioned or some of the residents around the Meridian area, you know, around the parcel area.
2:05:38 I think those are kind of the areas that we really need to focus on if funding is available. And I understand. I heard you. Funding is difficult to get on this. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs, did you have any thoughts, questions? I'll echo what Jessica pointed out. She had a lot of good priorities there. I also would like to add the dog park. I know that that's a...
2:06:08 been a big community need and ask for a while and I like the idea of it at the Whitmore area and expand the Whitmore complex. I think that would be a really great thing for our community. I also think it's really important and Jessica mentioned with mobility to continue the sidewalks.
2:06:32 As in the plan, we're trying to make our community more of a foot first pedestrian community and discourage the use of cars. And I think providing more sidewalks and places for people to walk around and view our beautiful town will help encourage that. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. So, Hayes, I've just got a couple things I want to throw at you really quick here.
2:07:02 On this slide specifically, the new transit shelters, you know, one, and I'm sure you've noticed this yourself, Hayes, one of the number one attractions for visitors and locals alike in Mammoth Lakes during spring, summer and fall is that Lakes Basin Trolley. People love that experience. They love going up there. You know, it's an amazing way to show off, you know, Mother Nature in our backyard. However,
2:07:33 That experience of people queuing up at the bottom of the west end stairs in the sun, possibly during the thunder, it's really, really beneath us. We can do better than what people are currently experiencing. So I would like to see some sort of a solution for that transit stop at the bottom of the west end stairs within the five year. To me, that's a big priority. The other question I had is,
2:08:02 The document that you put in our packet, the spreadsheet, listed the snow pit acquisition, but I don't remember seeing it on any of your PowerPoints here. Did I miss that, Haze, or was it in your presentation today? That was not in my presentation, and I apologize. I put that stuff together back over a month and a half ago, so I don't recall where that came from.
2:08:32 What was the context in the spreadsheet? I think it was, there was no budget allocated for the five years. I think it just said, explore snow pit acquisition. I think something along that verbiage. Okay, and if I pulled that out, that was not intentional. That is something that we are actively looking for, an alternative to the snow pit, whether that's the acquisition of the land or an alternative location, because that...
2:09:00 The snow pit is prohibitively expensive for the town to operate and I believe there's probably a better way we can do that. Got it. Okay. And then a couple of things. I think identifying a future event site needs to be pretty high on the priority list. At some point, we all know access to Sam's Woods is probably going to go away and
2:09:29 You know, the lifeblood of this community in the summertime and the autumn are special events. It's a huge draw, brings a lot of people to town. It would be very, very detrimental if we lost any sort of an outdoor event space. So I think that's got to get bumped up the food chain quite a bit. And then the other one, Hazen, this probably isn't even in your world, so I apologize now, but I just wanted to get it kind of on record.
2:09:58 You know, every year we have those meetings with the Forest Service to talk about, you know, opening up the lake space and the timing of it, the plowing of the roads, all that stuff. And a couple of years ago, I remember part of the conversation was to explore the possibility of making the road around Lake Mary a one-way road. I think that that is something we should continue talking about. I understand it's a Forest Service road. You know, it's not a town road. Am I correct with that?
2:10:29 Correct. But I think that that would really enhance the overall experience in the Lakes Basin. It would take some of the pressure off that road as well. I mean, we've all driven up there when we have to pull off to the shoulder because the trolley's trying to get around and there's quite a few choke points on that road. So I think the long-term solution is to talk about the possibility of making that a one-way around Lake Mary. And that's about it on my end. Okay.
2:11:07 Thank you. If I may distill this down and just kind of get a thumbs up from the group. So on the five-year CIP, what I will take to town council is there's a recommendation for the intelligent transportation system to be bumped up along with the development of a lakes basin trolley stop. Can I have a thumbs up on that from the group? Yeah.
2:11:34 Thumbs, the Lake Space and Trolley Stop at the bottom of the Westin Stairs. Yep. Correct. Thumbs up on that. Okay. And then the priorities from the group, the long-range CIP are childcare, wayfinding, mobility improvements, specifically off-site, long-term parking, development of sidewalks and storm drains and events site. Michael, I will add that that Lake Mary Loop Trail Mupp, that design did include a one-way.
2:12:05 So I'll add that just to the descriptor because the plan that we have did include that. It just wasn't approved ultimately by the Forest Service. Thank you, Hayes. Does that all sound good? Any comments or thoughts, guys? Speak now or forever hold your peace. All right. We appreciate you coming before us, Hayes. We appreciate the patience. I know you got continued here a couple times on this one, but this is super important stuff.
2:12:43 Very much appreciate the presentation. No problem. No, I think I appreciate your patience. I know this was kind of a long-winded presentation, but this is important, important stuff. I'm going to shepherd your comments to the town council and then with their approval of the list, I will be back seeking your, seeking approval and your, your opinion on its conformance. The project, oh man, the.
2:13:11 The list conformance with the general plan. Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate it. Thank you, everybody. All right. We're going to move on to business matters 6.1. Consider the final draft mobility hub study and program. And Sandra, are you our staff contact on this one? I am. And let's see if I can share my screen here. Okay. Looks like we can all see it. So I'm here to provide the commission with an update and introduce this mobility hub study and program.
2:13:49 And Hayes is going to stay on the line here and also help out a little bit as well. So I'll just start with describing a little bit about what a mobility hub is. It's a place, it's a location for members of the public, for visitors to connect, seamlessly connect with different transportation options. It's also a place where people can arrive and see other transportation options.
2:14:18 So it's a good spot where people show up maybe to take the transit, but they see a bird scooter display there and they decide to also use that or use that at a later date, that type of thing. It's an opportunity for people to get onto the public transit and to access kind of all those different transportation options.
2:14:41 Just a little bit about the benefits of mobility hubs is that we provide all those services in one location. So that's kind of a central spot where everybody can come together and access those services. People using mobility hubs serves to alleviate congestion in town and grouping those services allows us to save money because we can possibly provide administration for different services kind of all in one area.
2:15:07 It gets people out of the cars and in different areas it brings people to that location. So some mobility hubs might be located near an amenity like the CRC and so people might come to get on the bird scooters but then they might stop and go ice skating afterwards, something like that. So I wanted to also talk a little bit about what we're looking to achieve and so what we're looking for at this point is to
2:15:33 Build on our previous work. So we've done a lot of good mobility work in town. A lot of our different previous studies have talked about mobility hubs, like the Main Street plan, walk, bike, ride, and the general plan mobility element. And we're really kind of with these mobility hubs in this work is focusing on our urban core of town. And so not really kind of looking at mobility hubs outside of kind of the urban growth boundary, but really focusing on where we can place mobility hubs within the urban core of town.
2:16:01 And then build something, right? So we're kind of trying to identify projects that we can actually build. So a little bit of background on this process. We had a previous, or we had a kind of phase one of our mobility hub work done in 2019, 2020. That was funded by a sustainable transportation planning grant. That grant was received through Caltrans. The goal of that grant was to promote efficient mobility, reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
2:16:30 Use technology to improve the performance of transportation systems and support social equity in transportation. So we have completed that grant process. We've closed out the grant with Caltrans. We did present kind of phase one of this process to the public in February of 2021. And then at that February 2021 meeting, we really kind of got a lot of questions, a lot of...
2:16:55 comments from the public, and it really made us kind of rethink our strategy and step back and look at more of an on-the-ground pilot project type study. So we hired Fair and Pierce, which is a transportation consultant, to prepare the Mobility Hub Study and program. And so they took the data that Kim Lee Horn developed through their Mobility Hub Study, and then they added the stakeholder input that we received over the summer, and then they came up with some pilot projects and some quick builds.
2:17:24 And so just a little bit about the community engagement. They had some in-person engagement. They had an online survey. And ultimately, what their recommendations were is to look at two pilot project locations, the CRC and our Tavern Row Park and Ride. So just a little bit of background on the community outreach that they've conducted. They were out at Bluesapalooza, actually, talked to a number of different people attending that event.
2:17:50 And what they found through that event and from our online surveys is that people generally prefer to travel around town without a car. Now that might be because a lot of the people who responded to this were visitors. So I think when visitors come here, you know, it's nice to just leave your car and to get on transit or get on a bike, do that kind of thing.
2:18:08 But what they did find is that we really need to push out more information about our transportation options. And this kind of goes back to the intelligent transportation system discussion in the previous item, is really people need to understand where they can find transportation, they need to understand about our transit, and we need reliable transit service. So they need to know that if they're standing out there on the corner waiting for the bus, that the bus is coming and it is going to be able to pick them up.
2:18:35 It was interesting that a lot of the people that participated at Balooza Palooza and online did not know that our transit service is free. It seems like we continue to get that comment over and over, no matter how often we advertise the fact that it's free. And we did hear that we need more electric vehicle charging stations throughout town and also more secure bicycle parking at key destinations. Those were kind of some of the things that we heard.
2:19:02 And so some, I think I was going to turn it back over to Hayes. You just heard a really kind of long or, you know, detailed presentation about the CIP. But just maybe, Hayes, can you talk a little bit about the relationship between the CIP and this Mobility Hub study? Yeah, and a couple bullet points here. Just remember the CIP is just a planning and budgeting tool, and we're looking to include short-term and long-term infrastructure investments in that document.
2:19:30 And that document is dynamic and will be reviewed like we just did, providing opportunity for inclusion of new projects. So this study, if it is approved and it identifies opportunities, those projects could be included in a future CIP for development of that infrastructure. So just like all of our previous planning work that is getting incorporated in the current CIP and our long-range plan once this document moves through the system,
2:19:59 Any clearly identified projects could be incorporated and constructed. Okay, thanks. So just kind of getting into the document a little bit, the document talks about different mobility hub types, so primary hubs and destination hubs, where primary hubs are kind of bigger. This is where kind of people come first. They might leave their car here for the whole duration of their trip. There's no time restrictions, minimal cost, or free parking.
2:20:29 And then there's destination hubs, which are kind of really someone's coming to a destination. There's limited time, limited parking, but can help someone access those high visitation areas like Canyon or Eagle. And then just briefly, the staff report, I'm sorry, the actual, the attached document, the mobility hub document includes a laundry list of amenities that you would include in these hubs.
2:20:55 So just to hit a little bit, you know, parking, charging, vehicle charging, taxi, rideshare service, bike racks, seating area, restrooms, and then this is for the destination hub as well. So just a little bit less parking, limited parking and charging, but still a lot of the same amenities that you would expect in a primary hub. And so the consultant made a couple recommendations for mobility hub locations. They were recommending locations kind of throughout the town.
2:21:24 At our Community Center, at the Village, somewhere up there, at the Visitor Center, at the CRC, somewhere in the Old Mammoth Road Commercial District, Canyon, Main Street, and along 203 and along Meridian. And the map is a little hard to see. It's a pretty zoomed out map, but you can kind of see those locations here on the map and really a pretty good distribution of hubs throughout the town.
2:21:54 And then, as I mentioned previously, we did look at mobility hub pilot projects, and I think pilot projects are really important, not only with mobility hubs, but kind of with different other projects, where it gives you an idea, it gives you an opportunity to, on a smaller scale, build a project where you can use that project as a learning moment, right? So we could build some amenities and then survey the people who use those amenities, survey people who use the hubs.
2:22:22 To see what's missing, what do you need, and, you know, it's possible that mobility hubs here might need something that we hadn't thought of, you know, but that's, this is the opportunity to learn by having a pilot project. And through that process, we can really determine what are the highest impact amenities. So we might find out that maybe the restrooms, everyone comes there and uses those restrooms, and maybe this helps us to say,
2:22:46 Gosh, for every future project, for every future mobility hub, we need to have restrooms, something along those lines. Allows us to collect data and user feedback, as I was mentioning. And a note for some of these mobility hubs is that we can monitor the transit ridership and just kind of get a gauge on where people are getting on, getting off. We also are able to access charging data from Tesla.
2:23:11 for the electric vehicle chargers, so we can get an idea of how many people are coming to charge their cars, how long they're there, and that helps us to kind of to turn, I guess, understand the turnover and how vehicles are moving throughout the site, and then bird scooters also allows us to monitor the scooter usage.
2:23:30 Okay, so Hayes, it might be good, I think, for you to talk a little bit about the study identified two pilot projects, one at the CRC and one at the Tavern Road Park and Ride. And so if you could walk through maybe these two pilot projects, I think that would be helpful. Yeah, no problem. And, you know, the pilot projects were chosen primarily because they're feasible and one's existing and one's already in development.
2:23:57 We're working on the mobility hub for the CRC in tandem with the development of that structure. That will include a significant amount of parking, almost 100 spaces. It will have a bus turnout, bus shelter that will have capacity for two buses at one time. It will have electric vehicle charging. Town Council approved the lease agreement with Tesla.
2:24:24 to provide 12 supercharging stations and four free J1772 universal chargers, which will work with most other electric vehicles. It also has, you know, bike parking and the typical amenities that you would have for park services, but it's also in close proximity to our multi-use path network. It connects to the old Mammoth Road corridor, so it's easy access to
2:24:51 Commercial opportunities, retail, restaurants, and so forth. So it's a great location to start evaluating which of these amenities are most used, most important, so that we can apply that knowledge to future projects. Next slide. And the other location is the parking lot. Again, it's existing, but we're looking at providing some additional amenities there.
2:25:20 Right now there's the Tesla supercharging stations and parking, but looking at potentially a bathroom, information kiosk, additional bike parking and trash facilities. It does have a transit shelter, but we could also bolster that with additional information. And then again, monitor that for successes so that we can apply that to other locations. Perfect. Thanks, Hayes. So just kind of next steps for this mobility hub.
2:25:50 You know, process is implementing pilot projects, you know, kind of monitoring that usage, updating our program as needed, and like I said previously, using the information we learned through this to frame and move future projects forward. I didn't include it on here, but we are bringing this item to town council on March 16th, so that's kind of the, I guess, public process of the Mobility Hub study.
2:26:18 So I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. And I guess just a little side note is that it is a lengthy document. You did have a lot of other items on your agenda today. So we're happy to use this as an opportunity to introduce the item, to get some questions and comments from the commissioners. We could bring this back on your April 13th meeting if you'd like.
2:26:44 So maybe just gauging the interest of the commission and whether or not you feel like you have enough time or you are ready to provide comments on this or whether you'd like to kind of have some time to let it sink in and then come back in April. So with that, that closes my presentation and Hayes and I are happy to answer questions if you have them. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you, Hayes. Well, first of all, does anybody on the commission have any questions on the mobility hub study?
2:27:14 that was just presented to us for either Sandra or Hayes? I do. Please, Commissioner Shane. Chair, I think this question is about Tesla or EV charging stations. Why should that be free and subsidized by the town? So yeah, let me clarify that. So the Tesla charging stations that were approved by town council at the CRC, that lease agreement
2:27:45 With them, these spaces are non-exclusive. So we're providing an opportunity for Tesla charging. The universal chargers, the four universal chargers, are free to anybody with an electric vehicle. That is paid for by Tesla. The town is not providing any funding for the installation. Actually, Tesla is providing the funding to cover their costs.
2:28:14 And the delta between the installations for the CRC and their installations. So they're actually financially putting in more money than, well, the town's not putting any money into it. We're just providing an opportunity. But like I said, they're not exclusive. Anybody can park in these spaces and anybody can use the charger at Tesla's cost. And does that happen in perpetuity?
2:28:44 Or is there some type of contract that says, okay, Tesla will do this and then over time it becomes a pay charging space? So the supercharging stations are based on whatever deal the Tesla owners have with Tesla because those are specific to that manufacturer. Our contract with Tesla, our lease agreement is in five-year increments.
2:29:13 So it can be reviewed every five years. We have options to, you know, ask them to leave or, you know, do things differently at those five-year blocks. But those free chargers are free for those five-year terms. There's nothing in the contract that changes any of that opportunity for the public. Got it. And that contract went to town council, I think it was the first meeting in February.
2:29:45 And the terms of that deal were a part of the packet. Got it. Thank you, Hais. Second question about transit questions, survey questions that I saw here. You know, I can't help to see the sample that was taken on this. The top three items, the questions here. People didn't know it existed. People didn't know it was free. People didn't know the wrap schedule.
2:30:19 I can understand the route schedule, but it seems like this is mostly probably provided by tourists, visitors in this town, not so much by residents of this town. So I'm curious for this particular mobility study, with this mobility study, I'm assuming it's to benefit both the community that are living here full-time and
2:30:51 And perhaps also to help with alleviate traffic by providing additional services or information to our visitors. But at the same time, I can't help to see that the survey was done with over 50% of it was done by visitors and tourists, not so much by the community.
2:31:24 Yeah, I think the sample size, it's clearly not a scientific study, and the sample was based on kind of who was around at the time when we were doing that, doing the in-person and the online survey, who responded to the online survey. But I do think we do hear from our, from members of the public, members, people who live here, residents, that they share some of those same issues and concerns about the transit. So I don't, while I think the sample was
2:31:56 Did come from a lot of visitors. I do think we do hear very similar things from members of our community. Thank you. Any other thoughts, questions from the rest of the commission for either Hayes or Sandra? No? Hey, Hayes, I've got a quick question. I think you alluded to the yards pickup spot out there on the 203, and that is just such a substandard experience for anybody who's waiting to get on that yards bus. So I'm assuming that that will move
2:32:36 to one of the pilot mobility hub locations, either the park and ride or the CRC? That could be a recommendation that we make. Ultimately, those transit providers get to make the decision on where they pick up and drop off as a function of their headway and how deep into town they want to drive. But we would definitely provide those opportunities to all of those agencies to have a better quality experience for those transit users. Got it. Okay.
2:33:05 And then my only other suggestion, and I know you probably just put it on the diagram for the CRC and the park and ride as a placeholder, but I would suggest that you triple the amount of bike parking that you had on there. Copy that. Sandra, what do you need from this commission right now in regards to the mobility hub study? I understand you kind of gave us some options, but I have a feeling that that April meeting is going to be pretty
2:33:38 Pretty busy. So what can we do today with this Mobility Hub Study? The Mobility Hub Study, I guess we're here just really to take your comments on it. I heard, we heard your comments, heard some of the questions about the study. We can pass that on to the Town Council. Ultimately, the Town Council will be accepting the document. It's not going to be an approved document so that it's regulation.
2:34:07 It's really kind of helping to inform the way we invest our funds and kind of helping, like Hayes mentioned, to inform the CIP. So if there are any other comments, we're happy to take them. If the commission feels like the study is generally fine and you've given us all of your comments, then we don't need to bring this back to you in April. I just, I wanted to make sure that the commission had enough time to actually read it. Like I said, I know this was a big packet and we just wanted to make sure you didn't feel rushed. Got it.
2:34:37 I feel comfortable with where we are with the Mobility Hub Study. I'd like to hear from the rest of the Commission, though, if they're comfortable with this moving on with our input today. I feel pretty comfortable. I have a couple of, go ahead, Jen. She said go ahead. You're good. I was just going to say I have a couple of, two notes on it, and I feel good moving ahead with it as well. I did.
2:35:03 Read over it and it all looks and feels good to me. My only two comments on it were, one, it talks about a better transit app instead of the current one. And it was saying somewhere that consideration of, oh, it says investigate if the app can utilize GPS module data instead of crowdsource data. I think that is absolutely critical, the crowdsource data thing.
2:35:29 I don't see that working at all. And the bus apps, transit apps that I've used that have worked well have had GPSs. So maybe that could be like a little more forceful or rather than investigate, like let's do that. And then my other comment was I'm picturing how often.
2:35:51 In the busy times here, cell service doesn't work, so I don't know if having Wi-Fi is an option, and I don't remember seeing that in here, but maybe it was listed, but either having Wi-Fi or really good communication for people to download the app that they'd be using either while they're at their lodging or like a billboard on 395.
2:36:13 Whatever, like before they get to the bus stop and try to download the app and then are totally thwarted. That does happen a lot. And I would love to think self-service will improve here, but I don't know that it will. So just making sure people can get the app when they need it. But I feel good moving forward with it and appreciate this document. It looks great to me. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Burroughs. I'm okay moving forward. I have no additional comments. Commissioner Chang. No other comments for me.
2:36:47 Thank you. I'm okay with this document. Thank you. So I think you've got consensus, Sandra, to move forward with this. I just want to say I love the idea that you guys are utilizing existing infrastructure for the two pilot locations. I think that's fantastic. And, you know, I've always felt that that park and ride space was underutilized. So I love the idea that we're going to really start essentially programming that location.
2:37:18 Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. Chair Vanderhurst, we have a member of the public who has a comment? Please. Tom Hodges, please unmute yourself and give your comment. Okay, thanks. I was hoping you wouldn't miss my hand being raised there. Appreciate the opportunity to comment again on this item. So, first of all, I wanted to commend the staff for proceeding with this initiative. I know it kind of stalled out for a little bit, but I do like the direction things are going with this updated study.
2:37:50 You know, I think that, you know, the notion of mobility hubs being, you know, park once and then find alternative methods of getting around modes of multimodal modes of getting around the community to get to our amenities is very logical, makes total sense. And, you know, even to the extent that maybe visitors in the future that are...
2:38:10 Staying overnight could park once at one of these locations and access their properties. As we start looking towards the building of the community, these kind of things are going to be important. Real quick, I wanted to make sure that everybody recognizes that this is part of the bigger picture as it relates to our community-wide planning, in particular, our downtown revitalization in past discussions about community parking.
2:38:40 Or district parking, if you will, support downtown revitalization. And, you know, one of the things I think that, you know, because I know this kind of evolved out of sort of that notion of where are we going to put a, you know, centralized parking for our commercial zones and so forth. That was sort of where this had started, which had grown out of the downtown revitalization efforts back in, you know, 2014 to 2016.
2:39:07 So anyway, I think everything's on a good path. I just think that everyone needs to consider that bigger picture. And that, you know, I think in some prior studies that had been, if you look at, you know, the potential to redevelop our downtown core, old Main Street, old Mammoth, you know, the underdevelopment of those commercial areas and hopefully interest in the future for redevelopment. But, you know, one of the biggest ways we can facilitate that in terms of the...
2:39:35 Private developers is to take a bit of that public parking burden off of the individual development parcels or commercial parcels and aggregate or provide that commercial parking in sort of centralized locations. So, you know, I think if you look at some of the past information out there, you know, there's stuff that says that possibly up to 300 public parking stalls would be necessary to really be a robust program to support our commercial downtown area.
2:40:02 You know, in view of it redeveloping to utilizing the unutilized floor, you know, densities that are available there in the FAR that are in our downtown or in our commercial zoning code. So I just want to bring that to light. You know, I think things that come to my mind is, you know, again, just walking distance from those centralized locations, 1,000 feet, I think it's sort of the planning metric. Thinking about that in relationship to Main Street and Old Mammoth and how people can get to those locations.
2:40:32 From, you know, and again, this would, you know, be future sort of longer-term vision of this program. The Civic Center site, I know that sounds like the town doesn't have immediate plans to look at building their town hall, but, you know, is that a good location for a regional mobility hub? You know, the park and ride makes sense, it's close by, it's a quick win, but long-term, you know, it seems like maybe the Civic Center site would be a good location for that. I don't see that identified in the study.
2:41:02 And as well as I think about the hospital has their on-surface parking lot that they developed a couple years ago that's, you know, 100 plus parking spaces on grade, you know, maybe there's opportunity to partner with the hospital to go multi-story there in the future and support a larger parking structure that could then, you know, support downtown revitalization in terms of the commercial parking. So just want to bring that to light.
2:41:30 Let's see. And then just in respect to the mountains portals, you know, we're certainly supportive, obviously, of participating in this effort, have every intention of including that in our main lodge redevelopment plans is, you know, we have in our draft plans, I think we've already shared with you and as we're refining them, we're certainly looking at that being a very robust transportation hub with main lodge, certainly can include other features that were alluded to in the presentation today.
2:41:59 We're all ears and want to participate in that and make that the best solution for the community. And I'd point out too, like the work we did at Canyon Lodge the year before with rebuilding our arrival there and the transit drop-off, the drop-off zone in the area in front of the lodge, you know, that was I think a really great improvement that functions very well. So I don't want to lose sight of the fact that we've done stuff and that it has been a benefit to
2:42:28 Our guests as well as our community as a whole. And certainly at Eagle Lodge as well. We are starting to dust the plans off there. Hopefully we'll be getting back into that planning possibly even this year. And as you guys know, in the prior plan, there was plans for an enhanced transit arrival or transit hub there as well. So again, we are absolutely participating in that discussion moving forward, have every intention of providing those enhancements on our property.
2:42:58 And look forward to continuing to participate with everyone. Thanks, Tom. Appreciate it. Jamie, was there any other public comment? Kind of skipped over that. No, there was not. Thank you. So, Sandra, do you have enough direction? Yep, I think we have what we need. We really appreciate the comments and we'll pass all this on to the Town Council. Excellent. Thank you. So, I'll close 6.1 and we'll move to 6.2, which is the Town of Mammoth Lakes development highlights. And I'm assuming, Sandra, you're our...
2:43:32 Staff contact again? Yes, I am. So this will be very brief. I just wanted to provide the Planning and Economic Development Commission with, let me see if I can, I'm trying to share my screen here, with an update on the development highlights that we prepared. I don't know if we've brought this to you before in the past. Okay, here we go. So the town staff, community and economic development.
2:44:01 Department staff on an annual basis prepares a document called the Development Highlights Document. And the intent is really to, we publish this on our website, we do kind of send it out to local media, but really just let the community know what's happening in Mammoth Lakes regarding development. So the document was attached to your packet. I don't, you all have participated in every, pretty much every single one of these projects, but I just wanted to.
2:44:30 Show you the document and let you know that this is something that we do on an annual basis and we do use this often and so if you as commissioners get questions about projects or questions about kind of what's going on in town you can refer people to this document and I can send out the link where it is on our website but just briefly just kind of I'm just kind of scrolling through as I'm talking you know some of the previous projects we you approved, Yotel, Pad, Mammoth.
2:44:58 Just a brief summary. We didn't include some of the real older projects. We didn't include them, the photos, but their entitlements are still valid. And then some of the residential projects that you all have been a part of. So this is all kind of very familiar to all of the commissioners, but just a heads up that this is a document we prepare. Gina Monte Carlo, our assistant planner, prepared this and always does a great job putting this together.
2:45:22 We'll continue to do this on an annual basis, and if needed, we may need to do it more often, depending on how much things are changing in the development world. So that's all I wanted to do, bring this to the commission. We did bring this to town council at their last meeting, and I just thought it would be good to bring it to the commission and let you know what we're doing. Excellent. Thank you, Sandra. Any questions on this development document? Everyone's good? So I gotta ask you, Sandra, the very first item on there, I think it was...
2:45:56 Is it 50, 40? It says 12 out of the 13 units. Yes, 540. John Hooper has, I see building materials out there. I know that he is looking to build that project hopefully, that last piece hopefully this summer. So that's the last that I've heard from him. And like I said, they have ordered materials. So, but I can follow up with him and kind of give the commission an update. I think I did that a couple, maybe in the winter.
2:46:25 But that is a big piece of that project that needs to be finished, and I think that'll really change the look of the whole project. Thank you, Sandra. I apologize for putting you on the spot there. No problem. So do you need any action from us, Sandra, or is this just an informational presentation? This is just information only. And just a note, I heard from one of the planners that John is actively working on the plans for the front building and is planning to submit it soon. So it sounds like it is in the works.
2:46:55 Got it. Hey, Jamie, do we have any public comment on this, on this matter? No, we do not. Thank you. Then I'm going to go ahead and close 6.2 and move to 6.3, selection of planning and economic development commission officers and committee appointments. Thank you. So I apologize for this item. Normally we bring this to you in August after usually there's new commissioners that have been appointed or they're...
2:47:21 We used to have our elections in June and so that August was a good time and I just, I apologize, it just kind of slipped my list and so we're back here to talk to the commissioners about vice chair and vice chair and your committee member appointments. So we, the staff report just kind of has information about your committees and your officers and we're really recommending that the commission
2:47:48 Adopt, appoint members to the chair, vice chair, design committee and mobility committee. This is also an opportunity to discuss whether or not there are committees that you need to establish that are not already established. Staff doesn't have any recommended committees, but this is an opportunity for the commission to talk about that. If there's something you think you need to talk about on an ongoing basis, then we can establish a committee for that.
2:48:12 So with that, I think I'll turn it back over to you, Chair Vanderhurst and to the Commission to discuss your appointments. Perfect. Thank you, Sandra. Appreciate that. I'll just open up with a quick comment that unless somebody else wants the big chair, I'm more than happy to serve another term as chair of this at the D.C. Commission. Does anybody else want to crack at it? It's an awful lot of fun.
2:48:47 You can have it. Please. I nominate you for that position. All right. So do we need a vote on this, Sandra? I think we can talk about it all, come to consensus with each one, and then we can do one vote. Is that, Jamie, does that work for you? Yes. Yeah. Okay. So I'm hearing crickets on anybody who wants to take over the chair. So I'd be more than happy to put my name in there again.
2:49:18 Vice Chair, Vice Chair Burroughs, what are your thoughts? I would be happy to do it again, but if anyone wants to take it over, please do. Does anybody want the Vice Chair position or should we straight arm Jen again? I'm not seeing any hands. Jessica, you're quiet over there. Paul, you're quiet. So I think we're good on Chair and Vice Chair. How about the committee appointments?
2:50:02 Paul and Jen, are you guys still comfortable doing another term as the design review representatives from the BEDC? Chair Vanderhurst, I just noted that Commissioner Eckert was an attendee on our Zoom meeting, so we just promoted him. So just a side note that if we're talking about committee appointments, he's now a part of our meeting. Excellent. Hey, Greg, thanks for joining us. Appreciate that.
2:50:30 I think, Jessica, you and I are the two representatives for the Mobility Committee, and I'm more than happy to continue my representation. How are you feeling? Same here, yeah. I think there's some exciting stuff on the horizon for mobility with the two pilot programs that were previously discussed. So since you and I have kind of put in the slog work.
2:50:59 to get to this point, I'm excited to see some concrete results. So unless I hear anything else from any of the other commissioners, I think the status quo, Sandra, and we're probably good to go on a vote on it. Great. I have one other thing I'd like to add, the Transportation Commission. That is actually not a position that's appointed by the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Jamie, how about a vote? And we're voting that...
2:51:35 The chair, the vice chair, and the committee appointments remain the same that they are as of today. Correct. Can I ask one? Sorry. Does Greg want any position? Does he want to be on design committee? Greg, you're quiet out there. I don't know if you can hear us. And you're muted, so you'll need to unmute yourself. Now he's on his phone. Are you able to unmute him? I just, I hit ask to unmute, but I can't. Oh, there he goes. There we go. Did that work?
2:52:12 Yep. Yeah, we got you, Greg. All right. I love technology. No, I'm fine with the way things are. I think everybody's been doing a very good job on it, and, you know, to turn around and try and come up to speed with people who have already been on it for a couple years doesn't make any sense to me. Thank you, Greg. Jamie, we'll take a vote now, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yeah. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs?
2:52:46 Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 5-0. I just want to thank all of you for the time that you put into not only what we do as a commission, but these committee appointments. It's really invaluable to get your insights on the different developments in town. Okay. Consent agenda. Does anybody have any corrections to the meetings or would somebody like to make a motion to approve?
2:53:16 the minutes of the Feb 9th, 2022 PEDC. I'll make motion to approve the minutes as written. I'll second. Do I have a second? I'll second. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Thank you. Commissioner reports.
2:53:52 You know, we've had kind of a lengthy meeting here. If anybody does want to submit a commission report, feel free to raise your hand or jump on in. I would, I don't necessarily have a report. I would like to suggest that we consider all meeting in person. Again, you know, COVID rates are pretty low. The mask mandate has gone away. And I got to tell you from sitting in this room in person today,
2:54:21 It's a different feel and you forget about that. You forget you can kind of feel the emotions from the people in this room and I think that's something that we lack on Zoom. I don't think that the Zoom should totally go away because I think it's a good opportunity for other people to be able to experience the meeting who can't be here in person. So I'd just like everyone to consider that and maybe it can be a discussion at the next meeting. I would back that 100%, Sandra.
2:54:51 Would it be possible to have that placed on the April agenda? Yes, certainly we can place it on the April agenda and commissioners are welcome to attend at any point. So if all five commissioners just decide to show up for the April meeting, that's fine, that would work. We will always continue to have the Zoom option for members of our public to comment or staff to present, that kind of thing. But at this point, there's nothing that says you cannot come and attend in person.
2:55:19 I think if all five commissioners are here in person, we don't need to do the AB 361 findings. However, if any commissioners are not going to be here in person, then we would continue to need to do those. So I will place it on the April agenda for discussion. But in the meantime, if you'd like to show up here at two o'clock on April 13th, you're welcome to do that. Hey, Sandra, if somebody does want to remain in a Zoom mode for our meetings, do they have to publicly disclose their location?
2:55:49 Not right now with AB 361 still in place. So right now we just have to continue to make those findings that there is an emergency and so the findings that you've made in the past and we can, the member of the commission can participate via Zoom and they don't have to disclose their location or post a notice. Once that AB 361 is rescinded or however that changes, I'm not quite sure.
2:56:15 Then you would, if you were going to zoom in from somewhere outside of suite Z, you would have to post a notice at your location. So members of the public could, I guess, come to your location and sit there with you as you attend the meeting. Thank you, Sandra. Any other commissioner reports? Greg, I thought I heard you about to start on one. Yeah, it's not so much report. It was just a comment that I wanted to make earlier, but I couldn't make the phone work.
2:56:46 When we were talking about mobility hubs, one spot that I think is very centrally located and used a lot is the post office. And I know it's a bitch dealing with the federal government, but the way they're doing their snow removal over there, a third or more of that lot is useless at this point. And if we could come up with some deal with them to...
2:57:17 You know, when we're hauling Main Street, haul those spaces off and use those spaces as a mobility hub. It's damn near a freebie. So I just wanted to throw that on the list of potential places. Thank you, Greg. Appreciate that. And I have noticed the lack of a proper snow management plan at the post office has really limited the available parking. So I'll definitely agree with that. Any other commissioner reports?
2:57:51 All right, Sandra, Director's Report. Thank you. I will be very brief today. Just a note, I don't think I mentioned it. I don't think I had known this at our February meeting, but the town did receive funding for Phase I of the parcel from the California Housing Accelerator Project of $38.6 million. So Phase I of the parcel is fully funded. And that, right now, it's under winter suspension, but they'll be out there shortly, hopefully.
2:58:21 If the weather holds, I guess, and we don't get any more snow, they may be out there back in April. But Phase 1 is fully funded. We did receive an application for Phase 2 from our development partner, Pacific Companies. So that will be coming before you sometime in the next several months. But we are moving forward with Phase 1 and Phase 2 is on the horizon. So just an update on that. And that's all I have. That's fantastic news, Sandra. Please congratulate your entire team on it.
2:58:49 The successful grant application. That's a big chunk of money. Hey, Small Curveball, do you have any sort of an update on the, I think it's called the Turnkey Workforce Housing Project? Homekey? Homekey, yeah, my bad. Homekey, we haven't received, I think we'll find out about that, the grant mid-March, I think we're looking for March 15th for a,
2:59:18 Response from the state. And that's actually, for the other commissioners that might not be aware, Home Key is a program that allows cities to basically purchase, rehab old hotels and convert those into affordable housing. And so we have a project that we're looking at converting up in the North Village to affordable housing.
2:59:42 And so we, in conjunction with Mammoth Lakes Housing, applied for a home key grant for that project. So hopefully we'll know in the next couple weeks and definitely by the next Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, we'll have something to report on that. Fingers crossed. It's a new item on the town's development highlights. Yes. All right. With that, I'll close the director's report. Thank you, Sandra, for that. And I'm going to go ahead and adjourn today's meeting. It was a pretty lengthy one.
3:00:11 Thank you. Thanks, guys. Thank you.