Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2024
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
170 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:28 All right. Good evening, everybody. Calling to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges. Present.
2:03 Vice President Barksdale, Treasurer Nuttall. Present. Board Member Stepp. Present. Board Member Kreitz. Here. Board Member Perkins. Present. Board Member Steenstra. Board Member DeAndrea. Thank you. Did you call Rice? I'm at the end of the list. Your name is in a weird spot. Yes, Board Member Rice. Thank you so much. Okay, looks like we have a quorum.
2:38 So we will continue. Moving on to item two, the agenda, public comments. This is established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public desiring to speak on a matter appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may also be submitted to the executive director at Patricia at ESCHHousing.org or the clerk at
3:08 townmouthlakes.ca.gov before or during the meeting or may be made in person here in Suite Z by raising your hand or by raising your hand in Zoom. Angie, do we have any public comments? No comments at this time. Okay. Seeing none here in Suite Z, we'll move on to Item 3, Consent Agenda. Item 3.1, Approval of the Minutes from the June 3, 2024 Regular Board Meeting. I'll entertain a motion.
3:38 I move that we approve the consent agenda. I'll second the motion. You want to turn your mic on, Kirk? I'll turn the mic on. Second the motion. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Seeing none, we'll take a roll call, please, Angie. President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes.
4:12 And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Terrific. Moving right along here on to agenda item four, policy matters. Item 4.1. The board will discuss and provide staff direction regarding the strategic investment of potential developer fees and will review the draft net revenue and one-time fund investment guidelines and provide feedback. Patricia. Thank you. This item was requested to be agendized at our last meeting.
4:43 When the board was reviewing the developer fees associated with the Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments developments, developer fees are one-time fees that developers collect as compensation for producing the product. The board had a conversation about what was the best way to allocate those funds.
5:16 When we were reviewing the budget for the 24-25 fiscal year. The board also had this conversation in August of last year. So it's been about a year since we had last had that conversation. And at that time, there was some consensus that those fees should be used for strategic priorities.
5:49 specifically creating new housing units. There was a suggestion that the board possibly adopt some guidelines about how to invest one-time revenue sources. Specifically, I'm thinking of developer fees, which are one-time sources of revenue, and also any net proceeds from a previous fiscal year.
6:20 The Board has allocated those in the past towards operations in the fiscal year moving forward. That would be a one-time source of revenue if there were net savings in the fiscal year. But there could be other sources of one-time revenue as well. I did some research around guidelines for this type of strategic investment.
6:54 And provided a really rough draft of a document which outlines some priorities, including the mission of the organization and what the board might consider when deciding to put funds into a certain line item in the budget. For example, does that purpose meet the
7:26 Goals of the strategic plan. Does that investment have any donor requirements that would require it be invested in a certain way? And so I outlined some of those examples in this draft document. And my suggestion is that I would love to take feedback on these guidelines.
7:54 And then bring back a more refined draft for the board to consider. But I'm happy to take direction as necessary. OK. Is there any comments from the board, the staff report, Patricia's report? I think we are missing a few key members of the board here. And I don't think we're looking to come to any decisions tonight.
8:34 As much as we can provide any input for what you have drafted and so forth. I mean, I'll start off and just say, you know, I'm definitely supportive of the direction of, you know, kind of using this seed money for future developments. You know, a lot of times we're at risk in the initial sort of due diligence or analysis of a development opportunity and, you know, we'll have to put funds out.
8:58 Up front with no guarantee of reimbursement for those if things don't work out. But I think that's very appropriate in sort of the course of being a developer, right? You're going to have those opportunities. You need to spend some time deciding whether it's something you want to make sense to pursue, which then requires, again, some due diligence time, whether it's initial appraisals or property condition assessments, things like this that you have to go through and evaluate whether it's
9:27 Worthwhile opportunity to continue to pursue. So, I mean, I certainly think that makes sense in my mind. I think you also made mention, too, that possibly in the course, you know, access apartments in particular, will there be some monies coming back to us through the construction efforts that will refund us for our upfront costs on that, that we're out right now. You know, we'll have a fairly significant amount of money coming back to the organization that we may not have an immediate need for. So I think, you know,
9:57 Finding a liquid but interest-bearing account that we could put it in would make sense. Some other HOAs I'm involved with take a similar approach, whether it's a money market account or something. But I think the key issue there is that the money can be liquidated fairly quickly if needed. So I think it makes sense to pursue those opportunities.
10:26 Yeah, I think those are my initial thoughts in terms of I think you've outlined those things in your notes here in the staff report. Thanks, Patricia. I also agree that I like the idea of seeing it be used for development, but especially right now at this stage when we're still focusing so much attention on access apartments until we get our feet on the ground a little more with that, I definitely want to see
11:00 Some focus on expanding our regional presence that we've rebranded toward, and so if we could use some of that funds toward getting a greater presence in Inyo County and Alpine County especially, I think would be great. I guess I would like to see any money that we're able to put aside for future projects.
11:36 And I don't know if that would be, you know, that we're saving money for a while until we have a big enough pot to do something, or I would think that we'd be able to be more agile with like acquiring a property before we had maybe grants or something to develop a property. So I would be in favor of putting one-time revenue aside until we have enough to do something, do a project. What is that?
12:11 Thank you. Thank you. I think it looks good. It is broad enough that it allows a lot of flexibility. I think it's broad enough that it touches on everything that we've talked about in this room tonight so far on this. So I think it gives us broad framework. I wonder if it's...
12:42 Wouldn't be helpful to put something in here about reviewing this during the annual budget process, and maybe it's in here, but I'm just looking through the expenditures, and it says that it would be expended with, make sure it's with the strategic plan and economic conditions.
13:21 I just feel like that's the time when we should talk about for sure like the expenditure of them in advance of the budget or a mid-year budget review is also an opportunity. Obviously anytime we can make budget adjustments as a board with you know with the help of the staff but I think that's a great opportunity to revisit it if we haven't already I mean
13:48 At minimum, like maybe that's like something in here. At minimum, we discuss this, you know, the standing of those carryover balance or whatever that is at budgeting time. Just so that we don't lose sight of them as a board. Because sometimes, you know, we have like a risk reserve and we have all these different reserves and I know they're on our balance sheet, but.
14:17 I think at budgeting time, since budget is really symbolic of your priorities and your strategic plan, it's a great time to say, oh, well, we have these and, you know, these are our plans or we're thinking, you know, whatever. It's just a good time to maybe incorporate that. At minimum, we discuss the use of them and the balances at budget. But this is great.
14:43 Does it help you? I think that's the big part. Like, does it help staff? Does it help you think about how to use the funds and how to bring forward policy options for us? Or is it too broad for you? I mean, I don't know. No, I think, you know, historically, I think it's been much broader. And so this at least puts a little structure around it. And if, you know, we have questions about how we should
15:11 What we should be moving forward with the new project or opportunity. This gives us a structure in order to bring it to the board and say staff recommends this because it meets these criteria of this policy. Okay, good. I would note also in your report there you did also include possible organizational operational deficits.
15:42 For me, that would be like a last resort of use of those funds, like if we were really coming up short. By the same token, I mean recognizing the fact that staff is deeply involved in the projects and recognizing that the developer fee helps pay for those costs as well. So it's one of those things where obviously we want to be all transparent about it in those discussions and so forth.
16:12 And by the same token, too, you know, as we get, if we grow our organization and we have more development projects as we move forward, you know, the need for, you know, having staff that's, you know, working specifically on development projects. I think back to the early years of Mammoth Lakes Housing and I think on staff, you guys had a construction manager at one point, right, and project managers and so forth. So, you know,
16:41 Again, depending on the scale and scope of what's going on, there may be appropriate. You know, I guess in that case, I would say, OK, hey, that's specifically going towards a project. We're hiring somebody. It's, you know, construction manager because you've got that volume of work where you need that type of expertise on staff. Right now, we're kind of third-partying it as a project expense. But, you know, stuff like that would, you know, in my mind be appropriate. But, again, just, you know, I think it's, I'm not saying we should, I think it's fine to have it included because it's, you know, we need to have that broadness and flexibility.
17:10 Obviously reviewed by the board and discussed. Are there any other comments for Patricia? I'll just say thank you for bringing it back so quickly. Obviously, if it came up a year ago, it's a recurring thing. So this is great progress on getting it kind of at least in some structure, some framework. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. And I think you say, well, look maybe to bring this back to the next month's meeting.
17:44 Yeah, I can bring back a refined draft and agendize it as an action item. Yeah. Okay, great. Sounds good. Thank you. Okay, so Eric brought dinner back. Do we want to recess quickly for that and take a break or do you guys want to continue? Let's grab some pizza. Okay, we'll take a short recess, Angie, if you don't mind. Okay. Thanks, everybody.
24:09 Move on now to Agenda Item 4.2. The Board will review the adopted 24-25 fiscal year budget. Patricia. Thank you. This budget, I believe, should be exactly the same as the budget you saw at our last meeting. I know I mentioned that there are some refinements I'd like to make in terms of allocating some of the costs to the LLCs.
24:41 but there's still a lot of work to do around setting up bank accounts for the LLCs and those journal entries in the accounting system that will automatically allocate those recurring costs to the right location and so I do have a meeting this week with the
25:08 Business representative from U.S. Bank to talk about setting up some new accounts for the LLCs and what that looks like. And then I'm also in contact with our accountants so that I can make sure that whatever I'm talking about with the bank meets the needs of the accountants and that we're all on the same page. So a lot of that work is still happening. So I didn't change the budget. It was approved at the last board meeting.
25:36 But I did add the line items that the board requested, which was a revenue source of the one-time funds that were allocated from the current fiscal year to the next fiscal year in revenue. And then I added an expense line item called strategic plan investments.
26:08 If we were pursuing a new project with the funds that we just discussed in the last line item, this would be a place to add an expense for pre-development costs or acquisition costs up front before we are able to allocate those to a separate LLC. This could be for appraisals or escrow fees or...
26:34 strategic investments that the board would like to make in pursuit of a new development, which is what I'm hearing at the moment is a priority for one-time sources of revenue. So I added that there as an expense line item. It wasn't originally, it didn't have any expenses in the budget that I presented at the last meeting, and so I didn't add any expenses in the line item for you today. But we can certainly
27:06 You know, we can certainly have this at, you know, our next meeting, and we can do a mid-year budget review if that's necessary, but this is the informational item that I have regarding the fiscal year 24-25 operating budget. Let me ask you a quick question. I'm sorry, I missed the last meeting. It looks like the Alpine County Housing Navigator Services got cut in half, or?
27:35 Yeah, I did reduce that line item by half estimating that it would take some time to recruit a new person and so that we may not in the fiscal year achieve 100% of that contract. Okay. And would that save us some money on the salary as well? Like that, I mean, that goes directly to someone's paycheck. Okay. And just looking...
28:00 I'm sorry I missed the last meeting, but just looking over the budget, I guess I feel mostly concerned, you know, that the $88,000, it looks like we just barely, we're barely in the red for the $24,000, $25,000 budget, including the $88,000, right? So to me, I'm wondering, like, how do we cover our budget?
28:29 Basic costs so that we will be able to use one-time revenue for projects and not to just cover our costs. Yeah, that's a great question. The board did have a conversation around that at the last meeting. What does that look like? Do we need more contracts with other partnering jurisdictions? Are there some contracts that have
28:57 Dwindled, so to speak, because of inflation over the past 10 or 15 years at the same amount. You know, this year we received a capacity grant for $45,000 that helped pay for some of the costs of access apartments up front that we're paying. So that helps at least a little bit with things like that. But I don't think we have
29:30 Come up with the ongoing dependable solution for that. Okay. And how long has the town of Mammoth Lakes been contributing $336,000? I believe it was in the past one or two fiscal years that it went up $6,000. Prior to that, it had been $330,000 since I started, which was in 2013, and probably prior to that. Okay. Okay.
30:03 Thank you. Any other questions from the board? Sorry, just one quick question. I also missed the meeting. Apologies. I think it's the property management fee line item, if I'm sort of following correct. Decreased, you had $30,000 and now it's $13,072. Very specific number there. Yes, that's a great question.
30:46 Again, apologies if you guys already talked about this. No, we didn't. I don't think. But this is specifically related to the projects that we currently have in construction. So when Access Apartments was occupied by commercial tenants, we were collecting rents and taking a management fee from those rents to support our staff time. They're no longer paying rent and they're no longer occupying the building, so we're no longer achieving that management fee.
31:16 And then I have an estimate in here for some amount of a management fee that we're going to collect from Innsbruck Lodge once it's fully occupied. But right now I feel like it's in a transition phase and we're not collecting 100% of that management fee today. So that is factored in there for Innsbruck Lodge and Star Apartments. Okay, thank you. Any other questions or comments from the board?
32:02 You know, I think as a, you know, with regards to the one-time revenue, excess revenue from the, you know, carryover from last year, you know, I think to a degree that, you know, we've had a long start up here to getting access going and getting funded. And so, you know, we have been in a little bit of a deficit there. And, you know, we are going to, as we'll see here in the remainder of the meeting, there's, you know, a lot of good news.
32:30 Now about getting that kicked off and some of the funding opportunities that have changed. So point being is we are going to be collecting some income on the project, development income here. And I think in that particular case, I know Eric's been doing a lot of work on some of the front end of the project as well. And so there's certainly some, again, some sort of upfront costs that we've been sucking up, so to speak.
33:00 You know, I think are justifiable to put some feet towards. So anyway, enough said, I suppose, for now. But as we move forward, I think one of the things we had said, too, was, you know, maybe this upcoming fiscal year we could pursue, you know, a bit of a similar agreement, maybe as we have with the town, with, you know, City of Bishop, for example, as we look to kind of start to initiate some projects down there with Valley.
33:29 Some of the other opportunities that might present themselves and so forth. So as we get more engaged in that area of our service area, there might be hopefully increased interest from other entities that might consider supporting an annual operating agreement with us. So I think it's something we should make an initiative for pursuing as we move forward here, which will certainly help. Okay. Any other?
34:01 Comments or questions? So this is just a touch base back on the update. Patricia, nothing else to do? Yeah. Okay. That's right. All right. Well, then we'll move on to agenda item 4.3. The board will receive updates on current construction projects, Innsbruck Lodge, and Access Apartments. I think Eric's going to take this one? Yes. Eric's going to provide the project updates, and then I'll jump in at the end for more on Access Apartments. Yep.
34:37 So let's start with Instruct, that is our project. So just switching it up here, the background, you guys have seen this a couple of times, but it's good to go over it again. So we got our funding from Homekeep round two, and that was $4.5 million. And then we acquired the property in August of 2022, finished demo in March of 2023.
35:02 And then we got our permits issued in June of 2023. And then more exciting, recently we got six units in May of 2024, and then we're expecting the rest of the other units for fall of 2024. This is just another breakdown of the funding. On the right side, they are going down by the amounts, highest to lowest. And yeah, the development budget, so as of right now, we spent 91.
35:38 And then just some project updates, so I think the...
36:09 Most interesting one is the punch block list. So that we are doing, we did on 529 and then it should be finished within the next 30 days. That is what our GC said. And then the lift was installed in past inspection. So now it's being used by one of our tenants that's in the ADA unit. I expected delivery for our electrical equipment still.
36:39 I have a quick question for you. So with regards to Innsbruck, in terms of the overall construction budget, you know, anticipated at completion, are we looking to be on budget or within our funding for the project at this point? Yes, I think we're still
37:10 Within the budget that we had anticipated and we have requested the additional $400,000 from the Town of Mammoth Lakes that was committed last February or the February before. So we're waiting for that to come in and then that will go towards the final components of the construction. There were some change orders including some really large pieces of glass and
37:40 There's an issue with the gas supply. So with those things, that's an additional $60,000, but it doesn't seem like it's too far off of what we had anticipated. Okay. Yeah, so maybe it'd be helpful for me if in the monthly updates we could also have a slide for just, you know, where we are with overall spend and anticipated change orders and revised construction costs versus our funding just to see where we are.
38:17 May I ask you a quick question, too? I'm sorry. Did you want to answer his question, or did you have something to say before? No. No? Okay. We'll add it to the next month. I just had a quick question. Who filled the six units? How did we decide? Yeah.
38:39 The project is mandated to use the coordinated entry system, which is the homelessness database for the Tri-County region. And so those with the greatest need are offered the units first. We have, you know, the housing navigators designed a process so that we could make sure that even if they are the highest need household, that they still met the other requirements of the project, including income limit.
39:08 So we went through that process, and we were able to fill the five units with two clients from Mono County, two clients from Inyo County, and one client from Alpine County. Okay, thank you. And is there, are there six units? The sixth unit is the manager's unit. Oh, okay, thank you. Yep. Which have you hired, and that's being occupied or not yet?
39:41 Yes, so we have made an employment offer and our attorneys are going to get us the contracts back this week so we can sign those and he can move in. Great. So now is access. Again, so just the background on this one. A little bit more extensive, but you guys can read it. So funding sources, again, it was, I did a new format on it and then you will notice that home is not on there anymore, which we'll talk about.
40:34 The later slides. Development sources, so we've used, we spent up to 38% of the total budget on development budgets, and that's all pre-development, so we haven't done any construction yet, and we've done a couple of VE. And then some milestones, so we met with SCE last week. We sent the drawings to Sean, which is our SCE rep, and then we're just pending easements that he's gonna be sending us.
41:08 Construction, so we ended up getting the architectural plan signed off and we're ready to pull the permits. Our next step is to provide the town with three hard copies of the permit fees and then pay those outstanding. And those include the town of Mammoth Lakes and then the Mammoth Unified School District. Again, a lot of interest was given to our GC.
41:36 Which is our general contractor, Manemcha, on 517, and that's the amount not to seat, $100,000. You mentioned about the superintendent being in town. Oh, yeah, and then our superintendent is going to be in town, so I'm going to be with him tomorrow on site, and then we're just going to walk through the property and then do some, he wanted to talk about parking issues, so you guys are welcome to be there if you want. I can send you guys a meeting invite, but yeah, that'll be held tomorrow.
42:10 And that work currently is falling within that $100,000 scope of pre-construction activities not to exceed amount. And which company is he from? It's Mnemsha. Mnemsha. Mnemsha. And have we signed the contract with them yet? No, we have not. Waiting on the CDBG to be formalized? Yes, and...
42:42 We've had some back and forth with the contract, but I think it should be ready to go. I think the last thing we were waiting for was an updated schedule. So we will bring that to you when we have it. We haven't already authorized you to execute that contract. We did authorize a resolution that said that I should move forward with any and all documentation to break ground on access apartments.
43:15 Is that not sufficient? I think that's sufficient. Yeah, I mean, otherwise we'd have to have a special session to approve the contract, but I think if that was what we had done, then I think we should proceed. Yeah, I think that was the item that was requested regarding the contract, this letter, notice to proceed. Right. We gave them the notice of intent, right, to contract. Right, notice of intent, that's right. Yeah, yeah. Okay. I can send that.
43:50 Out to everybody, so they have it. Yeah, I mean, I think if, I felt like we authorized you to do that, but if we haven't, I mean, I'd have to go back through the minutes and see, but I trust that that's what happened. Because I know we're trying to get this going as soon as possible, so it sounds like we have the building permit once we get the fees and... Plan check's done, you're saying. We got through plan check 100%, so...
44:25 Yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay, continuing on. So we are still having our ongoing architecture contract meetings, and that is on a weekly basis. And then with our building permit approved, we're still tracking to start in July of 2024. So it's going to be this year, this month. So estimated occupancy is still fall of 2025.
44:53 And then the home closing, which I mentioned before, home is a lot longer funding the project, but CDBG is now covering the full 7.1 million. And I was on one of the calls with CDBG, and they seemed amenable to pushing closing out until spring or summer of 2026, allowing that to happen since we're getting a late start. Is that still the case? Yes, and that will be in the towns.
45:25 amended standard agreement, which we are not a party to, but that the town will inform us of any changes to the timeline or the amount of the funding, which is increasing in those items. So we'll be working directly with the town instead of directly with the state. Yeah, yeah. Okay, great. Oh, and then I have a couple more updates on access apartments. No, I'm just going to read them here.
45:56 We are anticipating to break ground this month, hopefully not this week, maybe next week, so hopefully in the next two weeks. And then there was a change in the funding structure. The home award was a 2019 grant that me and Diane and our intern Jake, I believe, worked on.
46:24 That we were awarded, I think the original amount was $2.4 million. It came with $100,000 in operating funds for the organization. We were awarded that as a certified community housing development organization. And then through some delays through COVID, they awarded us an additional million. And then they had also committed an additional $800,000.
46:53 when we added the two studio apartments. So working through all of the really complicated and extensive documentation that the home program needed and realizing that the home program was not going to be able to facilitate the closing of these funds within our construction timeline and that this had been delaying us.
47:23 for quite some time now. The state decided that they would be able to utilize some unspent CDBG funds to replace the home award. And so the CDBG funds will be easier to administer. We'll only be doing drawdowns from one source of funding, and we'll work directly with the town.
47:49 on the drawdown, so we'll invoice the town for the funds to pay for the construction, and then the town will invoice the state to get reimbursed by the CDBG grant. Another benefit of this is that the home program really incentivizes deep income targeting, and so within those
48:14 Constraints, I think we were providing two 50% AMI units, six 60% AMI units, and a handful of 80% AMI units. Now with the CDBG funding, we'll be able to do seven units at 80% AMI and six units at 120% of the area median income. And so that is beneficial to
48:43 The project, in a couple of ways, it was the intention of the project to serve 80% AMI from the beginning, but also it helps the town because they also have a requirement to have deed restricted units at the 120% AMI level. It's a state requirement through the regional housing needs allocation.
49:09 And so the town is happy to have these units restricted to 120% of the area median income. This is something that I don't think anybody else is doing, so I'm really excited about it. And it's beneficial for the project because it is a small project. We were having some issues with the operating budget and having it pencil with those really low rents. And so now with being able to charge higher rents, the project
49:40 We took a look at it today. The project is penciling out for 25 years right now. And we're proposing to charge rents that are 80% of the maximum of what we could charge. So I think that helps average out those folks who may not be making exactly 80% AMI so that the rent will be affordable to a range of household incomes.
50:10 That's really exciting. Oh, and then we are proposing to defer, well, it just depends, but in the budget as it stands today, we're proposing to defer 100% of our developer fee, which is $416,000. Board member DeAndrea often calls it the contingency of last resort. So in the budget, we have it as a deferred source.
50:39 But with these new rents and the projected operating costs, I believe we'll be able to pay ourselves back over a nine-year period, which is not too long. And then if we defer less of it, it will be less time to accrue it back. And then I am extremely excited about getting this project.
51:03 And so I wanted to ask the board if there was any other excitement in having a groundbreaking ceremony or if we wanted to just wait for some other milestone to celebrate the progress of this project. I'm just personally invested because I've been working on it for seven years. It's been a really long road.
51:33 The minute that shovel goes in the ground is really important to me, but I'm happy to wait if we feel like it's too much right now. Well, I mean, I think it's certainly a worthy champagne milestone that we should celebrate and definitely think we should have a groundbreaking ceremony, absolutely. You know, I just want to commend you for your efforts and kind of, you know.
51:58 I think the board member DeAndrea is not present, but he's a professional in this industry, and he said that, quite frankly, what you guys pulled off with the switch to CDBG from home was a coup and unheard of in his experience. So it's a big deal that you guys were able to do that, cut a lot of red tape. Also, the home funds was a loan, right? And CDBG is a grant, so there's no payback. So it's just an amazing...
52:27 Transition here. And, you know, that this all came together in just short order was incredible. So kudos to you guys. Congratulations. Huge, huge win for the organization, for the community. We'll get this project kicked off here, subject to a couple more of our agenda items here and town council actions this week, hopefully, and we can get this project started. So, yeah, just, wow, good job, great job.
52:54 And absolutely schedule a groundbreaking ceremony. Any other comments from the board? When is the groundbreaking ceremony? Yeah, you let us know. I'm going to be at a conference next week, and you said the next week or two. Okay, all right. Okay, perfect. I'll be back on the 15th or 16th. Love to be there if I can, but don't hold it up for me, and congratulations.
53:30 Okay. We'll move on then to... I'm sorry. Go ahead. I think this is so wonderful. I'm super excited about the six units at 120% AMI. Great job. And then may I just ask, like, how are we going to decide who gets these units? Is it different criteria than the Innsbruck?
53:49 How do we decide? Yes, that's a great question. We manage a waiting list of households that are interested in occupying units that we are a party to, and so we will use that waiting list for these units, and you need to be within the income restriction for each unit that's available before you're offered to enter a lease agreement, and so if there are interested
54:18 Households, they can come to our office and get an application. Yeah, just one last round of kudos and congratulations. And obviously it could have been a huge, you know, detour in the other direction. So, yeah, great, great job on getting that. And again, I think that's really awesome that there aren't the restrictions that the home funds had and that we now have the six and the seven and the six at 80 and at 120.
54:49 I think that also fits. Obviously, that's great because the time needs that requirement, but great to have a project that's meeting different needs than other projects that are happening in town. Huge well done. Definitely will be at the groundbreaking ceremony. I would like to add to that. I mean, I think it's incredible because state and federal dollars only go to projects with up to 80% AMI.
55:15 As far as I know, all the projects, you know, we do, the town has the bridge program and the housing now that we're able to target with local tax dollars, we're able to target like the 80 to 150 percent. So, you know, I think it's really remarkable that we're able to get six units at 120 percent AMI. So, great job. Yeah. Thank you. That's CDBG. That's the beauty of that funding source. So, you know, if you talk to your federal representative, let them know we keep funding that through the HUD program because it's...
55:44 It's a really user-friendly, and it's only for, in California, it's only for rural communities that we compete for it at the state level, so, yeah. Thank you. Just one more question I wanted to ask. Is there going to be a difference in rent between the 80% AMI and the 120% AMI? Yes, yeah, so,
56:14 The rents will be based on an assumed household size. So for a studio, that's two household size of two. And for a one bedroom, it's household size of three. And then you look at the maximum income level for those household sizes at those income levels and figure out what 30% of that income would be for that household per month.
56:46 We took 80% of the maximum that we could charge. And so each unit will have a different rent. Whether it's a studio, it will be different. And if it's an 80% unit, it will be different than if it's a 120% unit. And do you know what those numbers are off the top of your head? I have the numbers that we used in the current estimate of the operating budget.
57:15 But they're going to change. This is like two years out, and they go up every year as the incomes go up, right? Yes. So it's kind of a... Yeah, we won't be occupying until 2025, so they will be different. Right, yeah, right, 2026, exactly. But right now, like I would say, the studio apartments are trending around $1,000, which is what we're charging at the Innsbruck Lodge, so I think they're relative to...
57:45 Other similar units. Great. That's cheaper than Bishop. That's great. I love that you used that 80% of the cap. I think that's always something that I thought we should strive for, but it's not always possible because you...
58:03 A lot of times you need that income to help make the project pencil, the operating budget, so you just have to get right up to the 80% AMI, but getting there really creates more affordability, so kudos for doing that. Thanks. Yeah, I think just for further clarification, the 30% is the gross, so that's rent and utilities, so I think in our calculations, the
58:31 The rent was about 25% of the median income amount. So, and again, at the 80% of what would be the maximum of that income range as defined by the state, right? So, definitely in the affordable for those income ranges and with, you know, breaks, like you say, so we can, maybe somebody's not exactly 80 or 70 or whatever, they can still qualify. So, yeah, just, I mean, all around, just a fantastic outcome for, you know.
59:01 Every aspect of it. Well, Trevick, good news. Great stuff. Okay, well then, moving along with this discussion, there's a couple things here on the agenda that we need to review and approve. So moving on to item 4.4 of the agenda, review and approve addendum amendment number one to the sub-recipient agreement.
59:27 For 21 CDBG-HA-00015. Patricia. Great, thank you. The next two items, as Board Member Hodges mentioned, are requirements in order for us and the town to be able to start accessing those CDBG funds for the access environments. And so this subrecipient agreement amendment is a short document explaining
59:58 The increase in the amount of CDBG funding allocated to this project and then some of the restrictions that come with that funding. And then behind the amendment, I provided the original executed subrecipient agreement, which includes all the details about insurance requirements and liability and everything else that we've agreed to for this project. And so...
1:00:25 By entering into this or authorizing this amendment, we can show to the state that we are working together with the town and that we all would like to get this project completed. Yeah, I just point out, you know, the chapter and verse there is in section paragraph two that, you know, speaks to the income ranges that are allowed in the unit, the number of units for, again, the 80% of seven units and the remaining can be at the 120. So,
1:01:01 It's pretty straightforward. So any questions from the board? I just noticed it has the wrong town manager on the agreement, says Daniel C. Holler. I think that's the old agreement, though, isn't it?
1:01:20 The one that he already signed. No, I think the amendment form also has it. So I meet with Nolan tomorrow at 11. We'll go through some of this stuff and I'll let him know that. Since both of these two items will go before the town council this week on Wednesday. Okay, so do we need a vote of the board? Yes, please. I'd make a motion to approve the agenda item as presented. I'll second.
1:01:53 Okay, it's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Yeah, I mean, it's a draft, yeah. Okay, correction of the town manager, signatory. Okay, it's been moved and seconded. No further discussion. Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Step? Yes. Excuse me. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Prokens? Yes.
1:02:29 And Board Member Rice. Yes. Motion passes unanimously. Okay, then we will move on to agenda item 4.5, review and approve the regulatory agreement between the town Mammoth Lakes and Access Apartments Affordable Housing LLC for access apartments to 38 Sierra Manor Road, Mammoth Lakes, California. Patricia. Great, thank you. This regulatory agreement is the only restrictive
1:03:09 Covenant that will be recorded against this property now that we've switched over to CDBG funds. And so the town and I have, well, yeah, we've gone back and forth on a draft. Nolan really fleshed it out quite a bit and I really appreciate that. The draft in your packet has been updated and I sent another draft via email just now.
1:03:40 I think there are a couple printed copies at the front if you want me to grab you one. There's a few extra. I grabbed a few. Oh, great. Thank you. But I guess what I'll say is that this document is what requires us to provide the units that we have agreed to over a term of 55 years. It also outlines
1:04:07 The maximum rents that we can charge, how those are calculated, and insurance requirements, and some annual budget and reports that are required by the town to make sure that the project's on track and continues to be sustainable. Board Member Hodges and I, or President Hodges and I, walked through this extensively with our attorneys.
1:04:39 I feel pretty good about it. I also walked through it again with Nolan this afternoon. He feels good about the changes that we've made. There is one, I think one or a few places where we need some more clarification specifically around the town monitoring fee. There's a mention of an annual monitoring fee, but there's not an amount. And so in order to be able to budget, I'd like to have some
1:05:07 Yeah, so...
1:05:39 As Patricia mentioned, I participated in a call with our attorney today on this as well and reviewing it and I think we kind of really covered all the issues. I'd point out that, you know, there's requirements in here for replacement reserve account, you know, so for just the ongoing long-term capital upkeep of the property over time. There's operating reserve requirements.
1:06:09 There's also terms for the distribution of residual receipts, which includes our deferred developer fee repayment, our asset management fees, property management fees, so all things that are going to generate some income back to MLH.
1:06:36 You know, and all falls within the cash flow analysis that's showing us being, you know, positive cash through through year 25. So I think we're in pretty good shape here and just wanted to make sure the board was aware of that. I mean, if you get into all the chapter numbers here, but, you know, I think that, you know, the particulars are pretty well spelled out, subject to just some fine-tuning. And CDBG staff has reviewed this and?
1:07:07 And so really they're fine with this? Yeah, so Nolan used a template that CDBG staff had given him and made sure to incorporate all the items. And the residual receipts were acceptable? I think the section on residual receipts says that, oh, acceptable to CDBG, that 100% would go to the owner. Right, and not program income? This is...
1:07:36 The document Nolan gave me, but I'll ask him tomorrow. Well, I mean, if they've approved it, they've approved it. So that's why I ask. Well, I don't think they approved it after he flushed it out. Okay, well, we'll see what they say. Okay, any further questions or comments from the board? So you need a motion or an action on this as well? Yes, please. And so I will entertain a motion.
1:08:17 I'll make a motion to approve the agenda item as presented. I'll second. Okay. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stack? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. All right. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move on to
1:08:51 Oh, you know, I should have asked if there was any public comment. We have no public comments at this time. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, terrific. Moving on then to item 4.6 of the agenda. The board will receive a resolution from Senator Alvarado Gill declaring Eastern Sierra Community Housing as the 2024 Nonprofit of the Year. Yes. Thank you. Wow.
1:09:21 Eastern Sierra Community Housing was nominated and received the Nonprofit of the Year Award from our State Senator District 4. She represents 13 counties in the region, and so we were selected as the Nonprofit of the Year for her region. And on June 5th,
1:09:44 I believe it was. Board Member Kreitz and I were able to travel to Sacramento and meet with the Senator and receive the award. There was a luncheon and a lot of great inspirational comments from other nonprofits across the state. And I brought the framed resolution so everyone could see it. That's so beautiful. Wow. Nice. Very nice.
1:10:23 The senator was very appreciative of the work of the organization, citing the work to help keep our workforce housed and in our communities and how challenging that is in this day and age and just really appreciated the work of Mammoth Lakes Housing and Eastern Sierra Community Housing, yeah. And so it was a lovely afternoon with her.
1:10:51 We would like to invite her to groundbreaking ceremonies, so I'm not sure if she'll make the access apartment one, but maybe when we do one for Innsbruck, but we certainly invite her and her staff. Craig, congratulations to everybody on that, and thank you especially to Patricia and the staff. Yes, the senator did mention that
1:11:29 You know, she really appreciated the results that we have delivered and, you know, the grants that we have achieved and the, you know, all of the results, I guess she did say that word. So I guess I will just thank the board who guides the organization and makes the decisions and guides the staff in the work that we do. And we're a great team. So thank you. You're here. Terrific. Thank you so much. All right.
1:12:00 Well, great to have some accolades here today. It's terrific. Okay, we'll move on then to agenda item 4.7, Mammoth Lakes Housing Programs Update. I didn't provide a staff report for this item. I have just a few, a handful of updates, and I'm happy to take any questions. My first update is that I have started recruitment for our open housing navigator position. I have...
1:12:28 I received some communication from one interested party, so I'm working with him to make sure he has the application materials and if he has any questions to contact me. I'm working with some renewing some of our smaller contracts with the City of Bishop, so that's...
1:12:52 important. That's part of our revenue source and part of our work program. So making sure those contracts are renewed and continue to be relevant. And then I did want to mention that we have been receiving a flurry of community members in our office in the past two weeks. I'm concerned that folks are moving into the parcel.
1:13:22 But that they haven't received their call back, and nobody's answering the phone, and what can we do to help, and they keep coming and coming, and you know, we've been trying to help them the best we can, but we don't really have any additional information. We've made phone calls on their behalf, but we get the same process. So I did email a representative from Buckingham today.
1:13:49 and the town to let them know that, you know, it's really taking away from our staff time, really, it is. I had to go home to work today because there were too many people in the office. So, and they're frustrated and they're nervous and they're worried and of course we want to help them but we really can't do anything. So, it's frustrating for all parties involved and so I did email them today to see if there was any additional information they could provide so that we could
1:14:19 So I wanted to let you know that was taking a lot of our time in the past two weeks. And then I guess I have, I don't really have another update on Valley Apartments, just that I'm trying to connect with HCD. It sounds like we are going to be awarded the PRP award to acquire and rehabilitate the Valley Apartments in the City of Bishop.
1:14:50 So as soon as I get that notice of award, I will update the board, but I believe that that's going to be our next project in the pipeline. I think that's the closest one. We're still in escrow with IMACA to purchase that property, so I think as soon as these funds come through, we can close that escrow and see if we need to do an RFP for GC.
1:15:20 Or what that process looks like. I'm sorry, what are we doing with the value apartments? Acquiring it from IMACA and then rehabilitating it. Just the overall renovation? Yeah. Sounds like it'd be costly. That place is a little run down. Yeah, I think our grant application was for around $5 million. Okay. And the acquisition cost is zero. That's good.
1:15:55 Oh, just going to mention, Tony, I mean, to my comment earlier about sort of the pre-development due diligence expenses, we, on that property, we did, I think, pay for a property condition assessment that kind of gave us some guidance of how much the repairs would be that helped sort of inform the grant request. So a perfect example, actually, of where we put some money up front with no guarantee of whether things are going to come through, but we thought it was, you know, worthy of our effort.
1:16:25 to preserve the property. Definitely. Are any of the residents going to be displaced during the rehabilitation? Yes. So part of this process will be to update a relocation plan. We were initially thinking that we would do it on a rolling basis so that only some tenants would be displaced at any one time. We'll have to see if that's still viable. But we will have to relocate the tenants while the units are being renovated.
1:16:53 And that's just the temporary relocation in one of the motels or something in Bishop? Yes, I believe you have to relocate to a similar unit, similar unit type. That might be tricky too. Yes, it will be. It's going to be a great fun project. And with the people coming in and asking about the parcel, I remember when that first went through, I felt like we were entitled to a stake.
1:17:29 in that project and I was very disappointed when a non-profit from out of town was awarded the opportunity to manage that with them. Is there any way that the town would help maybe encourage or would it even be possible for the developer to reconsider that partnership?
1:17:56 Give us an opportunity or an additional partnership that we could be because I think obviously we're better served than the other organization to coordinate with the community and deal with local residents and help with their questions and concerns and et cetera. Yeah, thank you for reminding us about that process.
1:18:27 You know, I know that the town's also frustrated, and we're on the same page, so that's good, but I'm thinking maybe this is an area where we can negotiate, you know, when we renegotiate our contract with the town, that this is additional work that we're doing that we were never compensated for, or considered to be compensated for. We should have been, it should have been required that we were part of that, and
1:18:57 You're obviously spending a lot of staff time and the community is not being served as well as they could be if we were in that position. So if there's another way to address it, I mean, if there's no other way to include it in an updated piece of the town contract, but I would think that there...
1:19:23 Might still be some opportunity for us to have some stake in that development and an active role as coordinator. And then my question to that would be, with one navigator done, do you guys actually have the capacity to do that? Well, not today. Not today we didn't. Not without hiring additional staff, for sure. No, we don't. It's a lot of work.
1:19:58 Do you send them to the town offices for guidance? I mean, that seems like the logical step because they would be able to help just as much, if not more, than you because they're actually a party to the development. Yes, so I have sent a few to, I think, clients to the town offices, but I don't think they actually go. Well, that's, yeah. Would you be able to?
1:20:26 Post something on your door and lock your door and, you know, like open by appointment only and I don't know, like just kind of a quick fix to get you guys to be able to finish your work week and everything. Yes, I did tell Eric to lock the door when I left. I mean, you could like maybe post a sign and say, you know, contact Buckingham, we're not, you know, like just kind of passing on the information and saying like, you know, we're not involved in this, this is where you can get more information or.
1:20:53 You know, something pointing them in the right direction so that you can continue on your daily tasks. Yeah, I think that's the direction that we're headed. It's just not the kind of customer service that we like to provide. And I know, I mean, I think Buckingham has a Facebook page that they update every once in a while, like having them look at that. I've heard that the 100...
1:21:24 A hundred applicants have been contacted for the spaces, and I know we have 15 people in the first building, and they're looking to fill the 65 other units. So I think it's chaotic right now, and I don't think that Buckingham has the, I mean, they definitely don't have face-to-face service, but they maybe have not been the best at communicating how everything's working out, and so people are feeling
1:21:54 You know, insecure about housing and don't want to miss out on this opportunity. Yeah, I was thinking that today. I just feel like the level of community desperation was really underestimated. And so, you know, your co-worker got a unit, you didn't get a unit panic button. So we're getting a lot of that panic. Interesting. Well, maybe the town and the developer will do a better job on phase two.
1:22:28 I think that's a good idea to have a sign made up because I understand that that's not the community spirit or customer service that you guys are used to being provided, but it sounds like it's pretty overwhelming. And also if Eric's like in the office by yourself as well, then that's a lot to manage whilst trying to do your job. So I think, yeah, like Amanda suggested.
1:23:04 A sign that directs them exactly where to go. If there is no Buckingham office or anywhere on site at the parcel for them to visit, then I guess post the address of the town offices. And I also think, you know, hopefully all the units will be filled and that foot traffic should diminish. Ideally, yes. All right. Any further program updates? No, those are all my updates. Perfect.
1:23:37 Okay, moving on then to agenda item five, committee reports. Do we have any reports from our various committees? I'll just mention in the development committee, obviously we've been very engaged with all the different steps and meetings and so forth with the state and this sort of transition and the funding and getting the project to the finish line here. So it's been quite a few meetings going on on a weekly basis with that. But we're almost there, so it's great.
1:24:07 Great commitment there. Any other committee reports? I think Brian potentially mentioned it in the last meeting, but the Performance Evaluation Committee have met a few times over the last few months and should be in a position to bring something back to the board for review by the next meeting. Terrific. Okay. No further committee reports. Any individual board member reports? Item number six on the agenda.
1:24:43 I was going to report that the parcel is opening. Everybody heard that already. The town will be breaking ground on the next phase of the parcel in August, and I've been pressing for Buckingham and Pacific to sort of explain.
1:25:04 You know, how people, if they're interested, if we're going to do another wait list again, or if we're going to wait until we're closer to occupancy to do a wait list, or if, you know, the current wait list that still has so many names on it, if that will be used at all, but I haven't really gotten any answers on that. So, you know, I think that information would be helpful because, you know, I think it just speaks to the housing needs that we have in this town.
1:25:33 That's all I have to report. I guess I'm sure folks are aware of what's happening with the budget, the state budget and housing. There were some wins and some losses, but I think, you know, the HHAP, which is helping fund both Innsbruck and Access Apartments 5.0 or...
1:26:07 I think it's around six is getting funding. They put one billion in, so that's really good. The COC administers that program for our region, the allocation of it out to organizations. But it's been a really great program, so I'm glad that they're funding that again, reallocating that one. And the state housing tax credits also received another 500.
1:26:36 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:27:06 Every five years, they have to update their plan for how they're going to roll out the CDBG Home National Housing Trust Fund and Emergency Solutions Grants to people who apply like we apply, like our town applied for CDBG. And within that con plan, there are
1:27:31 It talks about how they're going to roll the funds out to the people who apply in the state. So it's a listening session. It's an opportunity for folks up and down the Eastern Sierra who work in housing and use those programs to give input on what's working, what's not, what they'd like to see. So I think we're shooting for a meeting with them in either the end of July or early August. It'll be a Zoom meeting. But just having one specific to the Eastern Sierra is, I think, unique. And I look forward to it.
1:28:01 to having our voices heard in Sacramento, because they go Northern California, they go to Southern California, like down to the Inland Empire, they go to the Central Valley, and they go to Sacramento and do listening sessions, but they never come to the Eastern Sierra, but it'll be Zoom, but still, it'll be something, so that's exciting. That's all I have.
1:28:26 I just had a question more for you, Jennifer. I read that there was discussion between the town and the county about joining efforts on the needs assessment. Yes. Right, which was great. Yes. And that was funding available. No, I don't know about the funding. From the, not the White Bark Institute, that's something different. I thought there was funding, anyway.
1:28:53 Whatever, about the funding part. My question was more about the, is there any type of timeline that was discussed on when that might? Yeah, so last I heard, the Board of Supervisors, we have a housing ad hoc committee and we met on Friday and it sounds like there is consensus amongst
1:29:18 Inyo County, the City of Bishop, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and the County of Mono to all cooperate on a needs assessment, which is huge. And I think they're all, we're working full steam ahead to try to get some outlines from consultants to do the work, because the scope's changed a little bit from where we started.
1:29:43 But when we met, had our joint meeting, we were throwing out, you know, within, you know, with get started as soon as possible. So, you know, within 12 months, we would hopefully have one done. Yeah, it takes some time. It just, a lot of it's going to depend on how elaborate the needs assessment is. And so, but it's, they're talking. Inyo County as well. Yeah. Yeah. Right.
1:30:11 I mean, the last time they participated in a needs assessment was outside of a housing element. It was 2003. So it's really exciting. Thank you for the update. Questions? And I can just add, I know the town wanted to get the first phase of the parcel filled up before we did the housing needs assessment. So it was going to be at least four to six months, but that's within your 12-month window. Yeah. OK. Great.
1:30:48 Running into people at the athletic club and restaurants and Vons, I mean, they're all staff short. So if you, you know, be patient with, you know, if you're going out or whatever it happens to be because it's happening all over town. Even at Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Yeah.
1:31:21 President Hodges, we do have a hand raised, Nolan Bobroff would like to make a comment. Okay, terrific. Nolan. Go ahead, Nolan. You're on mute. You're muted. Audio. I can't hear you. Muted myself, then unmuted myself, or the other way around. I missed public comments, just wanted to make two quick comments. Amanda mentioned the groundbreaking and ribbon cutting. So that is being scheduled for August 7th at noon.
1:31:53 It's a Wednesday. It is a special council meeting. So all the council members will be able to be there as a regular meeting. And I believe that then extends to other commissions and boards to attend special events of council meetings. So invite the board to come out. We're proposing to have it as a community event with Mammoth Lakes Police Department barbecuing there. We hope to have the park equipment installed prior to August 7th.
1:32:23 And we also hope to have Building A Habits CFO prior to August 7th as well. But that is scheduled for that date. And the other bit of news, I did get a contact, I can share this with Patricia as well, for anyone who is trying to get information from Buckingham on the parcel, we encourage them to email the sawyer at buckinghampm.com.
1:32:53 At least the email I was given to give out to people who are trying to get information on the lease-up. And that is all I have. Great. Thank you, Nolan. We'll look forward to seeing you on Wednesday. All right. Terrific. Yeah, I guess to that point, we are on the agenda for Wednesday, or I should say the sub-reciivity and agreement review and approval by town council. So, yep. Yeah, and the regulatory agreement.
1:33:28 I'll plan to attend. Okay, great. I appreciate it. Lend you a hand if needed. All right. Well, terrific, everybody. I think that brings us to adjournment to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which I believe will be August 5th, first Monday of August. And we'll see you then. Thank you. Thank you.