Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2024
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
176 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:10 Okay, good evening. Apologies for the delay in starting the meeting. I'd like to call to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Please note that Board Member Brian DeAndrea will attend this meeting remotely from the following address, 1000 Corporate Point, Suite 200, Culver City, California, 90...
0:39 2-3-0. Roll call please, Angie. President Hodges? Present. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall, I think I have you, yeah, Treasurer Nuttall is not here. Board Member Stapp? Present. Board Member Kreitz? Present. Board Member Perkins? Here. Board Member Steenstra? Here. Board Member DeAndrea? Present. And Board Member Rice? Thank you.
1:28 Okay. We have a quorum. We will continue. Moving on to item two of the agenda, public comments. This is established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public desiring to speak on a matter appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Alternatively, public comments may be submitted to the executive director at Patricia at ESCH.
1:57 or ESCHousing.org or clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov during the meeting or may be made in person here in Suite Z by raising your hand or by raising your hand in Zoom. Are there any public comments, Angie? No public comments at this time. Okay. With that, then we will move on to agenda item three, consent agenda. Item 3.1, approval of the minutes from the May 6, 2024 regular board meeting.
2:29 We'll entertain a motion. Move to approve. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. So now we'll move on to agenda item four, policy matters. Item 4.1, the board will receive updates on current construction projects.
3:06 Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments. Patricia and staff. Oh, thank you. I'm going to pass this over to Eric and then share some comments when he's finished. Yep. So let's start with Innsbruck Lodge. That's the most exciting one that we have. So again, background has all stayed the same. There's been no changes on that. Funding stacks still.
3:40 Fairly the same. Our development budget. So this that we spent today, we have 86% spent today and that includes all soft cost developments and then contingency and acquisition. Our construction budget, that we spent 76% as of May 2024. Then here are some of the renovated units. So you can see they're labeled by
4:15 What the unit number is, they look pretty well, pretty well done, and we currently have tenants already in four out of five of them, so they are being occupied right now. Here's an update, so our project updates, we have the temporary certificate occupancy, or TCO, that was issued on 5-2-2024, and then expires on 1-30.
4:43 And then, again, electrical equipment, that has been ordered. It was ordered on October of last year.
5:13 And then we expect an arrival date of July or October of this year. And then the exciting part is that the lift was installed and inspected by the state, so it passed inspection, so the ADA unit can be used. And then the thing left is the town of Mammoth Lakes needs to review and inspect it. I believe they've already done that, but I double-checked on that. And then the last place is that we're working on the fireplace with Nolan to see if we can
5:43 Thank you.
6:13 I think of $5,000 toward a new wood stove that meets EPA regulations. Yes, and that's one of the sources that we've been looking at. Thank you. Any other comments from the board? I just had a couple of updates. As Eric mentioned, four of the five units that were approved under the Temporary Certificate of Occupancy signed lease agreements last Friday and moved in.
6:49 So we currently have four tenants on site. Last week was a really busy week, obviously, because of that. ESARA had to coordinate these packets of information with the move-in guide, house rules, the lease agreement, resources. And so each tenant got a complete packet of all that information. We went through it page by page with them and initialed.
7:20 Everything so that they understood the agreement. And, you know, it was just really great, you know, working as a team and getting some of our most vulnerable community members into permanent housing. We were able to occupy the ADA unit with someone who is in a wheelchair, and so that...
7:46 ADA wheelchair lift will be utilized on a daily basis, so we're all really happy about that, and I know that that tenant is extremely grateful, so that was exciting, and ISARA was able to use a cash donation that we had received to compile some little welcome kits for the units that included
8:12 Just some basic necessities like a roll of toilet paper just to get you started so that when they moved in right away that it was livable. They didn't have to go to the store or anything. So that was really exciting. And then also last week we held interviews for the on-site property manager and so we interviewed three applicants and I made
8:38 An employment offer today, and so I'm waiting to just hear back from that person to see if they've accepted the position. And the unit is ready to occupy. As far as I'm aware, I haven't seen it ready to be occupied, but I've heard that it's ready. So we'll double check on that this week, make sure everything's good for the on-site manager so that they're able to move in.
9:06 I spoke to our attorneys today who are finalizing the employment agreement since it's a very specific type of agreement since housing is being provided as part of the compensation. I think that's everything. Did I miss anything? Okay, that's all. Great. Well, a huge congratulations to the team. That's impressive to get there, to get units occupied and first units, I think, for
9:37 And, yeah, Jennifer and I had a chance to tour the property a week ago, and, yeah, it was just really, really exciting and gratifying to see it all come together. And, like you said, I mean, most of all, just hearing the stories of the people who were able to have a place to live and some of the stories behind that, you know, was really, you know,
10:07 Again, very gratifying to know that we're really taking care of the people out there in the community. And so, yeah, well done. And looking forward to the rest of the units coming online here once the switchgear shows up and we can finish the electrical work, but in short order soon enough. So, yeah, thank you. Any other comments from the ward? Okay. With that, I think we can move on to access. The next one, once it shares. Oh, there we go.
10:56 So the next one is Access Departments. That's our other project that we are currently working on. Again, background is staying the same. That hasn't changed. Funding sources, it's still the same. We're currently working on finalizing that. Development budget. So we, as of May 2024, we have currently used up 23% of it. Again, that includes soft cost development and then contingency and acquisition.
11:36 Yeah, and then any VE stuff that we've done, which is value engineering on the property. So our pre-developed milestones, so we got in contact with SCE. They submitted the signs to Eastern Sierra Community Housing for three-phase power, and then Kevin, which is our consultant, our property, our project manager, is currently following up on that with them. Permits, in terms of permits, structural permits were submitted.
12:06 And then the MEP, which is Mechanical Engineering and Plumbing, and Civil, were all submitted, are going to be submitted next. And then the fire sprinklers are under review. And those are all being reviewed by a third party, which is PPR. So we should be getting some comments back soon. The permit, the water permit was cleared on 4-19-2024. And then the fire permits are submitted currently. So we're just waiting on to hear back from them.
12:35 And then the exciting part, which is our letter of interest, our project manager, Kevin, provided comments to Menemcha about some exhibits, the schedule, and the SOB. So we'll hopefully be getting that back. And then we signed a letter of interest with Menemcha on 5-17 for the amount not to cede $100,000. And that's all pre-development, so nothing of construction, no shovels on the ground. So that's the exciting part of it.
13:02 Project updates. So we're still having ongoing, they're called OAC, so owner, architect, and contractor meetings. Those are being done on a weekly basis, as well as financial calls with the home team. So we submitted a project draft report to them on 424, and then we're just following up with them and giving them comments back on whatever they need. So in our estimated construction date, so it was pushed a little bit back.
13:32 to mid-June instead of, you know, June 6th, I think it was before. So that's being pushed back just because we need to get home funds, you know, in hand. And then our general contract, like I mentioned before, we submitted the letter of interest to them for an amount not to see $100,000, and that includes pre-construction activities, again, which involves physical construction on the site.
13:56 And then our SMA occupancy date is still set for fall of 2025. That has not changed. Any questions or comments from the board for staff? Okay. Yeah, I'd just make mention real quick on just a few things for clarity. So the home grant money is our last funds to secure. We have to basically close on loan documents with them. And so we're going through the last steps of
14:31 Getting that issue to us. We're anticipating it here any day. We'll get those docks from them. And at that point, we'll be in a position to secure those funds, which we want to have that in place before we start construction on ground. Likewise, we're waiting for the permit to get finalized so we can have a building permit to start. So everything's kind of coming together all at the same time. But as mentioned, we issued a letter of
15:01 Intent to Manitia Construction to at least start some pre-construction efforts on their side and prep, you know, their subcontract documents and so forth so that they can hopefully, when we're ready to actually issue a notice to proceed, they can respond quickly and start construction as quickly as possible. So it's, you know, I think it's just the continued, you know, challenge of the complexity of the project with multiple layers of funding.
15:28 Putting all those into place in concurrence with getting the permit issued with the town, the building department, and just bringing everything together at once. So again, not an easy task and a lot of moving parts there, but we're very, very close and hopefully by our next board meeting we'll all be maybe attending a groundbreaking ceremony or at least put a shovel or something around it. So that's kind of the overall context of everything that's going on right now. Okay.
16:01 Any further comments, questions? All right. And we will move on to agenda item 4.2. Get my glasses on here. Review and possibly approve the Mammoth Lakes Housing Draft 2024-2025 fiscal year budget. Patricia. Thank you. I have prepared for you and updated
16:32 2024-25 fiscal year operating budget for the organization. So everybody has an updated version, and I know that has been provided on the website for the public. There were just a few minor changes, which I can call out as we get there. On the proposed revenue side, you'll see the town contract services is the same amount of $336.
17:04 Mono County Housing Navigator is $100,000 for the fiscal year. And then the Alpine County Housing Navigator, I have budgeted here at $50,000, which is half of the year in the event that Alpine County does wish to recruit a new
17:28 A new employee for that position. I estimated that it could take that long to fill the position. So it previously took a year, I think. So I'm working on coordinating with Alpine County to see how they'd like to move forward. This is the last year of that contract. So I want to make sure that we touch base with them before we start recruitment. But that is how I've estimated it on the revenue and expense side. Under developer fee,
17:58 We had previously budgeted developer fee towards operating costs in fiscal year 22-23. You'll see under the forecast actual that some of that was realized this current fiscal year, 5,200. But I have not budgeted for any developer fee towards operating expenses in this version. I'm happy to hear your feedback.
18:26 You'll see that our property management fees have decreased. This is due to taking 238 Sierra Manor Road offline, and so tenants have already vacated that property. It's currently empty. It won't be generating any more revenue, and we will not be collecting any management fees from that property. So this management fee line item includes star apartments, and then I think
18:57 Well, I'll have to double check, but I'm not sure if that includes the entire year for Innsbruck Lodge or just a portion of it, considering we're currently not collecting a full month's worth of rent for 15 units. We're only collecting a small portion. So I can confirm that. You'll also see that we're expecting to collect some
19:26 Fees for providing supportive services to clients at the Innsbruck Lodge and so that will come from rents as well to help support our staff time with case management. Contract income other is typically budgeted at $14,700 for a few smaller contracts that we have. This fiscal year we also earned an additional $5,000 for partnering with
19:56 The Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and Sierra Business Council on the California Jobs First Initiative. And so you'll see in this fiscal year that it's slightly larger. Our fundraising line item, we have been modestly budgeting about $1,000 in revenue. This fiscal year, we generated around $30,000 in fundraising efforts.
20:26 Those funds are going directly to our projects and so don't actually go towards our operating budget, although it is still logged as revenue. And then you'll see application revenue is always around the same amount of applications that we receive in process. Miscellaneous revenue is typically real estate commissions for different types of transactions that we do or other miscellaneous.
20:56 Donations possibly could be if it was for operations specifically. Last year I didn't budget anything for that line item but we did earn $7,500 and so I do foresee with our homeownership programs being very active right now that we probably will do at least two real estate transactions that generate a commission including
21:22 The Nordica unit, which will be in escrow shortly. And then you'll see the operating subsidy. We didn't use any of that last year, and we hadn't budgeted for any, although I believe it was the prior fiscal year that we did budget, I think, $20,000 of net revenue towards operations. And so in this draft, I've allocated $90,000 from the current fiscal year's net proceeds to operations of the organization.
21:54 Next fiscal year. And then we have some grant administration fees that we have an unopened CDBG award for homeownership with the town and then we also have our CalHome grant that has some activity delivery associated with it and so there's a small amount considering that they might generate a small amount of revenue. Let's see if you go to the next page.
22:38 A lot of the numbers remain similar or the same. Under advertising and marketing, I have moved, that is supposed to now include also design and copy editing services, which is why that line item is over budget in this actual fiscal year because I combine them.
23:17 So instead of having it under professional services as a specific call-out, I've lumped it in with advertising and marketing. It felt more like a natural fit there. So that's included there. That's for things like the annual report. We do some Facebook advertising for events, and then that would include any other newspaper advertisements or anything that we needed to do for the organization. Board development, we had budgeted $5,000 this fiscal year.
23:49 2,000 towards the strategic planning effort, and so I've lowered that line item to 2,000 in the next new fiscal year. We spent a little less on office supplies this year. We didn't invest in too much new equipment or furniture, and so I left that line item at the same budgeted amount.
24:21 Estimating that our, you know, there may be other expenses. I think Eric probably needs a new computer. You know, if we onboard a property manager, we may use that line item to buy them a computer or anything like that. And I think we want some new office chairs, potentially. Is it okay if we ask questions now or do you want to hold them to the end? Sure. What's your pleasure? I think if we can ask while we go, it would be
24:56 If that's okay. Okay. Would the property manager's equipment not fall to the property itself and not out of our general fund? Yes. That is something that I have been thinking about, possibly a portion of it, especially if we ask them to do any other.
25:17 property management perhaps for star apartments for example. We could maybe allocate on a per unit basis those types of costs because and this may be a question to think about but because the Innsbruck Lodge isn't generating a lot of revenue at the moment I'm working on an operating budget but I'm concerned that
25:43 The expenses are going to be greater than the revenue that we're generating today. And so I might allocate that expense to a line item in our operating budget. I don't, this isn't really, this is really just a thought that I'm having, not that I expect an answer or I'm sure you've contemplated this and it just occurred to me, you know, that you have.
26:11 Utilities still for construction, you have utilities for tenants, and part of the utilities for construction fall to the construction budget, and how do you separate those? I don't know. I'm sure you're handling all that, but it sounds like it could be complicated thinking about the expense side of operating, how it's not 100% occupied, but it's also not 100% falling to the property because some of it's still under construction. Anyway, good luck.
26:42 Thank you. Thanks for calling that out. You give me some ideas. So onto software, you'll see I kept the amount the same. This is an estimated amount that includes a couple of different softwares that we use, but also an estimate for utilizing a new software for homeownership counseling.
27:14 That will meet the HUD requirements, and there's a fee associated with that onboarding process, and I've sort of left it in the budget here. We didn't get to it this year. It's a goal that we have, so I did leave it in there, but we can always, that's a line item we could always reduce if we needed to. And then deed restriction subsidy is a line item that we historically have in our budget, and that's used to process deed restricted resales.
27:49 That it can include transactional costs and also rehabilitation. So we typically leave that, leave something in that line item if possible. The insurance here, I have estimated an 8% increase. I think that should cover it. And then you'll notice on our office HOA fees that they were high this current fiscal year. That was for
28:23 Snow removal during the big winter, we had a special assessment, and so the estimate under this line item is that we are going back to our normal HOA fees, and this is the current normal amount for 12 months. Are we ready for the last page? Okay. On the last page, there are two line items that look different from the budget that was in your packet. On salaries and wages, I reduced that slightly.
29:05 After taking another look at it, and this includes three full-time employees, one half of a full-time housing navigator, and then one part-time real estate transaction coordinator admin person at 10 hours per week. Our home ownership program has really grown.
29:34 With the growth of the bridge program and the town's funding of that program and their desire to expand that program and get our community members into homeownership and stabilize them so that they can stay in the community.
29:53 We have probably more than a handful of units that are in various stages of needing to be in some sort of transaction, whether we're acquiring it or processing home buyers to buy it or selling it or doing a deed restriction buyback. And so I think that
30:15 As much as I would love to be spending more time on that, we have a lot of other things that I would love to be spending my time on, like access apartments, Innsbruck Lodge, wrap that up, access apartments, and then also looking for our next opportunity. So I thought that we may have some room in the budget for a part-time person to help with some of these real estate transactions. So just mostly the paperwork side, that would be part-time, no benefits.
30:45 And it would just be an hourly wage. And so that is budgeted in here. It's around $23,000. So that's certainly a place that we can have a conversation around. The only other thing that I think was a critical change from what was published is the accounting line item under professional services.
31:14 This estimate includes a monthly fee for our third-party accounting firm to do all of our bank reconciliations, quarterly financial reports, taxes, everything included with keeping all of our LLCs and the organization fiscally sound is included in that line item.
31:44 I think it also includes our QuickBooks subscription fees. I think that's probably it. But now that I'm saying this out loud, I think it needs to be prorated per project because this is the lump sum for all LLCs. So that has not been done. And, you know, I didn't, they didn't provide me an estimate in that way, so I just put the lump sum in because that's what they gave me.
32:18 I did follow up with them and say that ideally moving forward that we would be able to track this by company. I think that's it for the 24-25 proposed budget, but I did want to point out in the 23-24 forecast actual that it's showing a net revenue of about $150,000. But I wanted to make sure everyone was aware that because fundraising
32:52 Dollars are not going towards the operations of the organization but are showing up as a revenue source in this budget. If you subtract them out it will be a more accurate net revenue because that revenue has already been spent on projects and has been invested in projects. And then also along those lines 238 Sierra Manor Road.
33:20 had expenses higher than the rents that were generated at that project this year, and so there's an operating subsidy that the organization has provided to maintain that asset in the amount of around $26,000, and so that's not shown here as an expense in this operating budget, and so if you subtract that out, the forecast actual net
33:47 Revenue is around $93,000 or $94,000 or $5,000. And so that's the $90,000 that I've allocated to operations in the next fiscal year. All right, Patricia, thank you. Any questions from the board for Patricia? I have a couple of questions. Sure, go ahead, Brian. So am I going to go first? Yeah, please go ahead. Thanks. Okay. As it relates to the audit fees, Patricia, I think you're
34:27 on the right track that those, especially those that relate to Innsbruck and 238, that those are ultimately are kind of project or property specific costs and should be borne by those operating entities, not by Eastern Sierra Community Housing as kind of a corporate entity. So those should be parsed and allocated out, in my opinion. I'm curious to hear your logic as it relates
34:57 to developer fee. I know we're anticipating to defer a portion of it, but we account on an accrual basis. So I think we should be accruing the developer fee, even if it's not completely realized in terms of cash. We'd love to hear your feedback on that. And then maybe the last question, and I'll pause, is on the $90,000. So that's an internal operating subsidy that the corporation is
35:26 kind of committing, I suppose, we're drawing from our cash resources that have been generated and amassed in part due to the performance of the past fiscal year. But I think absent that, we would be in the negative. And so my question and maybe concern going forward is how are we planning to address that structural deficit such that we're not continually drawing on internal resources? I know there's a limit to how much cash we have
35:57 In the bank and our ability to do that on a recurring basis. Yes, so to your first point, I think that, you know, organizationally we still have a little bit of cleanup to do around setting up some of the LLCs and then parsing out those costs to each entity. For example, the star apartments that we own and operate.
36:27 is still held under Mammoth Lakes Housing's name, and so that's on the to-do list of things is to move that into the LLC, which has been established, but we haven't moved it over yet, and so those costs are still being booked, you know, under MLH's accounting system, not in this budget specifically, but in an operating budget for the organization. And so, yes, I agree that I think all that needs to happen, and we're sort of
36:57 Just having our little growing pains here during that process. Your second point about the developer fee is we have invoiced Innsbruck Lodge for the full amount of the developer fee. And so if we ran a balance sheet on an accrual basis, you would see that the Innsbruck Lodge owes Mammoth Lakes Housing a certain amount of money. I think it's
37:25 Whatever the developer fee was minus whatever we used in operations last fiscal year or the previous fiscal year. And so that is a balance due to Eastern Sierra Community Housing. And I think that that's working. So if we need more detailed information about that or we want to look at the balance sheet, I'm happy to bring that to the next meeting.
38:06 Lastly, your point about the operational deficit is a great point, and I'm happy to hear feedback from the board about that. I'm not an accountant, but in terms of, maybe Brian, you know the answer is, at what point would you accrue the developer fee? At the onset of the project, or because you know it's going to be due, or would it be recognized at the
38:38 At the completion. I think that customary practice is at the point at which you start construction, you close on your construction financing and you start construction, you would begin to accrue it, and we typically would accrue it on a straight line basis. So let's just say it's a 12-month project and it's $120,000 of developer fee, you would accrue, you know, $10,000 a month until completion. Okay. That's helpful. Thanks.
39:10 Because we potentially then would, we have Innsbruck, but we also potentially could have access in that respect then. Yes, yeah, and Diane had helped me set up a process to accrue the developer fee on a quarterly basis, and when she left, we had only up to a certain amount that was completed, and we hadn't, we haven't continued that.
39:35 And so I think with Access and our new accounting firm, I can have that set up immediately once we start construction. If, yeah. So are the, excuse me, are the additional fees you budgeted for accounting and audit in an effort to clean up these discrepancies or whatnot?
40:00 It includes the cost of the third-party accounting firm, which we're estimating to be somewhere between $1,500 and $1,900 a month for all of the LLCs combined. Okay. And then that also includes the financial audit, which typically we've paid for as an operating cost, but can also be divided up between the businesses. Thank you. Any other questions? Brian, did you have a follow-up on your?
40:38 Line questions? No, I guess on Innsbruck, it sounds like, I mean, we're reaching the end of construction. It sounds like theoretically that fee would have already been accrued, but I'm not seeing it in the forecast actual for 2324 here other than the 5200. So I understand it's showing up as a...
41:04 Yes, and I think the reason why I haven't forecast it as revenue is because I
41:34 I don't think I had direction from the board to allocate 100% of the developer fee towards operations, and so that's probably why I didn't show it as projected revenue. The $5,200 is left over from what was not collected from the prior fiscal year in the amount that the board had allocated towards operations. So I think that this is where
42:07 I think we attempted to have a policy discussion around developer fee, didn't we? And I don't recall if we landed with direction, but that's where I think the revenue would show up in our operating budget, but within there would also be a line item where the policy is for that to go.
42:40 on the expense side, at least that's how I'm conceptualizing it, that it would be, well, Phil, you know, we had a policy direction that the developer fee was going to go into a seed fund for future projects, for example, then that would be called, you know, funding for future projects, and we would put that on our expense side, I think, for example, perhaps, within our budget.
43:09 So that you could show, you could have the revenue and then you could have our policy direction on where that revenue goes. But maybe we didn't come to a consensus. Maybe we had further discussion. Do you recall? I don't recall. I believe the end of the conversation was that we wanted to fund future projects. But I didn't incorporate that into this operating budget. So perhaps
43:41 You know, as in a, you know, pleasure of the board, but a future agenda item where we actually take action and we adopt a resolution stating what our intentions are and it doesn't have, or that, or we adopt guidelines and, you know, for them.
44:03 That we can change at any time, but that just give you, the staff, some guidance on what we would want, what we believe is the highest and best use, or whatever that language would be. I know it's a tool to help guide decisions for staff and ourselves, hold ourselves accountable.
44:31 Some kind of guidelines for how we want to appropriate our recognized developer fee. I think that would be a good thing to do. I'll stop there. I think I may have other comments, but I'll stop there. Yeah, I think that's great feedback, Jennifer. And as much as, you know, that part, the development part of the
45:03 Of the entity is, you know, the development part, right? And so any net income we generate off of that, you know, I think it's sensible that, you know, it would go towards future endeavors that are related to future development projects. And as we know, there's sometimes dead ends there and you're spending money that doesn't manifest in a project and you're taking a cost, you know, with no commensurate revenue on the other side. But we know that's part of the business, right? There's going to be some...
45:29 Some dead ends you're going to run into for sure. So anyway, I would support that we agendize that maybe for our next meeting possibly if there's room on the agenda we could fit that in and have that discussion since it'll be timely with recognizing that revenue for Innsbruck. I guess as much as Innsbruck's won't be completely finished until October, November, you know, maybe there's a portion of that that can be recognized in the 24-25 fiscal year.
45:56 Budget, and then obviously a portion should probably go into 23-24, I would think. But then certainly I think if we get access off the ground here, you know, some proportion of that potentially we can accrue on a, you know, whether you want to go monthly or if that's the better practice versus quarterly, you know, I'm not sure. But one other question that I had on income, the Mammoth Mountain ski area contribution, is that in the
46:23 Either contract income other or the miscellaneous revenue, do you know off the top of your head? Yes, I believe it's under contract income other. Okay. But I'm going to confirm. That's where it should be and I believe it's $10,500. Yeah, okay. I just want to make sure that was in there. Okay. Any further questions from the board? Yes, I had one question just about interpreter services.
47:03 For $600, do we, is that a in-person or an online service or what is, what do we do for that? I see the notes in there about materials and things. I think that's budgeted at $200 per meeting for up to three meetings and historically we have used live interpreters for Zoom webinars on tenants' rights and it's been more difficult to find it in person.
47:30 And so this fiscal year we didn't utilize it at all. Okay. Thank you. And then I had just one question about looking at the way the subtotals are in the travel and training that's now down to zero but the subtotal still shows at $15,000? Yes. I didn't call it out. I didn't call out each line item. I personally felt it was a little too much but I'm happy to add an estimate back in.
48:01 I have been doing some research on some property management training, what do you call it, platforms where you can take ongoing education and that we could get up to a certain number of licenses for staff to use. And so things like that, I mean, I guess you could put under registration fees or something, but I didn't do an
48:30 In-depth analysis on the per line item for travel and training. No worries. Okay, so that $15,000, I got really excited that there was just, we needed to make that a zero and then add it to revenue, but it's just a lump sum for travel. No worries. Thank you. I guess I, I think we should go back and look at the meeting we had where we discussed the developer fees, just so we're not starting over. I just want to say that because
49:02 I think we probably gave some feedback then that we could incorporate into our next discussion as groundwork that's already been done. But getting back to the deficit, I think Brian raises a really good concern that we should all be concerned about and we should be thinking about how we solve that. It's not, you know, I was thinking, oh, well.
49:31 If you just continually use the revenue from your work for your next year's operating, what happens when you don't have that, right? That's where you get into trouble. That's where you end up, like I mock, coming to agencies asking for bailout money because you haven't, you know, you've gotten in over your head.
50:04 And it's better to do the work now to prevent that from happening. That's where I think the town is leaving us a little bit in the fray, potential fray, because of not increasing our budget, our contract amount annually to keep up with inflation and cost of operations.
50:33 We've been watching our HOA go up. We've been watching our insurance go up. Health insurance has gone up. You know, salaries go up. Electricity is more expensive. You know, things are more expensive today than they were when that $336,000 was first put into play for the organization with the town contract. And so I think...
51:01 It behooves the town to come to terms with the need to increase that. Better to do that incrementally than to wait until we are not able to backfill that for whatever reason, because we hit a great recession or whatever, and then ask them for, you know, $100,000.
51:26 It's easier to incrementally increase fees and costs than a big lump ask. So I know that, and I appreciate Tom and Patricia have been working with the town to review our contract with them. I would really encourage the town to be mindful of the
51:54 The relationship and the value of the organization. I was thinking about it just the other day, driving down the street and thinking, wow, you know, Innsbruck Lodge is the first one to lease up.
52:07 And I know it's a home key project, but it started later than the parcel, than Sawyer, and the Sawyer still hasn't leased up. And not to poo-poo anybody, but like kudos, you know, like let's honor and celebrate the successes of our community partners. And Eastern Sierra has really stepped up. And so I really hope the town can see that it's in their best interest to...
52:33 Ensure the health and well-being of the organization through an equitable and fair contract. So the contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes, was that how Mammoth Lakes Housing started with that contract? There was some startup funds collected, I think, between the town and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to fund a staff person to start the organization.
53:15 And then I'm not sure when the annual contract for a flat amount began. Because I'm thinking since we're a regional organization now, if we could put an effort into trying to secure contracts like that with the county, not necessarily just for housing navigator services, which is great, but for more widespread use.
53:44 And with the City of Bishop as well, I think if we could secure that kind of funding, that would help secure our place as a regional organization functionally rather than just in name and branding. But the purpose behind the rebranding is to expand and it's going to be hard to expand if we don't get something like that with.
54:10 Inyo County, Alpine County, and Mono County, and also with the City of Bishop. I think that's a great point, Tony. I was actually going to say the same thing, and it may be hard to budget for it, but I think it's something we should pursue in this coming fiscal year for certain, especially as we are talking about other projects in Inyo County, potentially at large in Mono County.
54:45 You know, there's probably opportunity there. I guess one other question I had on with respect to like developer fee revenue that we haven't recognized here in this draft budget, but you know, I'm wondering what proportion of that might cover that deficit on, because you certainly have staff time that's going into the project management and so forth, right? So I guess my point is that if you're recognizing those
55:13 Related developer fees, that would cover some proportion of that amount. To go back and see what were in those individual project budgets for developer fees or what remains, I guess, I'd be curious to know. But I wouldn't be surprised if that's enough to cover the 90. Well, I think my comments are I think a lot of our staff time administering the Project Home Key Award
55:45 And delivering those units is covered under the town contract because that grant didn't come with any admin fees other than the developer fee. And the same is partially true, I think, for some of the grants associated with the access apartments. But even if we allocated developer fee to cover the deficit, the net revenue
56:25 Or even if we put developer fee as a revenue and an expense and we said we want the developer fee to go to new projects and we didn't spend any of it that year and then there's a net revenue that includes 100% of the developer fee and then it's almost like we can spend it in the fiscal year budget or we can carry it over to next year but is that really what we want to do with it I guess is the question. Okay, well again I think
56:58 To Jennifer's earlier point about maybe having a more specific policy discussion on a future agenda to kind of really pin this down from a policy perspective and how we want to account for it is probably a good idea. Yeah, I'll go back and see. Because it's both on the revenue side as well as the accounting for staff time on the expense side, right? Right. So, okay. Any further questions from the board on the draft budget? So, Patricia, I don't know that.
57:32 You don't specifically need an action on this, correct? Well, if the board is happy with this draft, they can adopt the budget and we can start using this as we move into July. If there are substantial comments and you'd like me to take another look at it, I can bring it back to the July meeting. But typically the board would adopt the budget.
57:56 And we can always make mid-year changes or if we need to update it later in the fiscal year, we can do that as well. I do think we have a policy that says we'll adopt a budget in June, by June, by the end of June. I was trying to remember whether we do? Yeah, we do. We do have a policy that we'll see a draft in May and adopt by the end of June. Right. I mean, I think
58:27 You've mentioned some things that need to be changed and culled. I don't hear any, I guess other than the accounting for the LLCs, like that would come off of our expense side and go on to the LLC expense side. So we're going to see a reduction in cost there.
58:56 And then the develop, we're not adopting the forecasted actuals. It sounds like there might be some challenges there with the, but that's not what we're actually, that's just a forecast actual to give us some perspective on this. But I guess the developer fee may come into play. It's not on here as a revenue.
59:21 But that is what that is. That's not anything that we can change. Whatever that amount is is what that amount is because of the prescription of the developer fee. Right? Am I right on that? On those particular projects? Yeah. So my point being that I'd be fine adopting this knowing that we're not looking at any significant costs, changes. We may be looking at additional revenue.
59:50 from the developer fee, and then doing some kind of an adjustment in the budget once we've maybe made some policy or policy changes perhaps to the developer fee, if we want to direct staff to add a line item on the expense side for the developer fee to go into. I don't know. I'm trying to think of a way to get us to be able to adopt this, to be consistent with our policy. Yeah, Brian.
1:00:21 Maybe whatever the developer fee revenue is, we could just show kind of the cash portion of that as an offset on the expense side and label that expense something like, you know, board-driven policy regarding developer fee expenditure or something like that. Just kind of a catch-all that allows us time to figure out how we're going to allocate those resources.
1:00:48 I like that. I like that. I think, you know, I think about, like, on the Board of Supervisors side, when we have some excess revenue at the end of the year, we will, we have some guidelines, and it usually aligns with our strategic priorities. So I think that's another, yeah.
1:01:10 Kind of another catchphrase that we could put in there that, you know, it's our policy direction and priorities or something. But yeah, I think that works. Okay, I can add that. And I can always bring, I mean, if you want to see the final final, we can just have it in the packet as adopted. Yeah, I think we could put it on the consent agenda, maybe even, or just an information item. I guess it really isn't anything we would approve, but you could.
1:01:38 And it is an information item to the agenda next month. Yeah, just so you can see where it, what it looks like. And then you'll have the LLC financials pulled out and cleaned up. Yep, I would like to work on that. I will work on that. And then, you know, you'll be doing a quarterly reporting to the board on the? Yes, I've been working with the accounting firm to get them, you know, caught up to be.
1:02:05 to start presenting the quarterly financials for us, but it was tax season and they're just not ready. Okay, but point being is we'll be able to monitor as we move forward, right? Yep. Was that a motion? Yeah, a motion to adopt the budget with the suggested amendments. It's been moved by Jennifer and seconded by Kirk. Any further discussion?
1:02:44 Okay, see none. Angie, you'll take roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Yes. Thank you. Okay, motion passes. With that, we'll move on to Agenda Item 4.3, MLH Programs Update, or ESCH Programs Update.
1:03:18 Take lead on that. So rental programs, we still have had no unit turnover. It is expected that with the parcel leasing up soon, some of the units at the ones that we manage the waitlist for will be open since we'll have families moving from those out into the parcel project. As of right now, we have 201 households. Could you move your microphone just a little closer, please? I'm having a little trouble hearing you. No, it's okay. Thank you.
1:03:46 89% of the households are under 80% AMI. I know that was kind of the question last meeting. We have 541 households and 293 minors. Moving on to, or I guess no questions on the rental portion or the management, the waitlist management. Okay. Homelessness intervention and housing navigation.
1:04:12 As of right now, we are still working on the mainstream voucher, building that connection with San Jose Regional Housing Authority. We are expected to have at least three mainstream vouchers submitted by the end of July. One of them was submitted. We're still kind of pending. Another...
1:04:34 We're also using other resources to see if we can find rental subsidies in other places. CalAIM is one of them. We did submit an application for the Housing Choice Voucher, which is the in-placement voucher, which is very different from the mainstream voucher, which mainstream is going into housing. HCV is placement in housing with rental subsidy. As for our transitional unit, it is still currently occupied.
1:04:59 Have an expected new occupant, hopefully by the fall of this year. Hopefully after some repairs. Can I ask a question under the coordinated entry? I looked at this and I was confused by the figures in the first two bullets. Can you help me understand? So the second bullet was not supposed to be there. Okay. That clears that up. Thank you.
1:05:24 Yeah, I was looking at it again. I was like, oh, that was not supposed to be there. But yeah, there are 73 households in the coordinate entry system and 246 households regionally. So that is Inyo, Alpine, and Mono. The 73 households is households that we, our office, has inputted in the, yeah, has entered since we have started inputting households into the coordinate entry system. You wouldn't happen to know, just off the top of your head, how many of those 246 are Mono?
1:05:54 Or is it because they're homeless or that they're maybe fluid between the region? They are. So since these households are transient people, they go from Inyo to Mono or from Inyo all the way to Alpine, Alpine to Mono. So some of those households are...
1:06:14 Yeah, it's not designated one county specific. We have entered 73 households in Mono County in our office. I know that the county staff tries to do at least like the beginning portion of the intake sometimes and then we finish the rest of the SPDAT. But yeah, these clients are transitional so they do not live in one county specifically. They'll go down south for the winter and then move back up north for the winter.
1:06:40 Last time we ran a report, I think it was 65, Mono County residents had active assessments in coordinated entry. And I shared that data with California Housing Partnerships in response to their report. And so those would have been folks, I think, who claim residency in a specific county or receive benefits in the county.
1:07:17 Because we have a lot of clients who, like I said, go down south for the winter, so they'll still be receiving benefits from Mono County, even though they're in Inyo County. So as of right now, we have two Inyo County clients and then two Mono County clients in the Innsbruck Lodge. So it's pretty even, and then we're working on getting there.
1:07:38 Benefits transferred from whatever county they're coming from to Mono County so that services are more easily accessible. So one of the clients who is occupying the ADA unit, we are working on getting his benefits transferred from Inyo County, which is IHSS, which is in-house supportive services, and having them do it in Mono County. So have a Mono County staff person go to Innsbruck Lodge to help him with any house necessities that he might need.
1:08:13 Yeah, so Innsbruck Lodge, like it's been mentioned, we have four out of five. We are expected for the fifth tenant to hopefully be moved in by June, but that is a very big F. Like I said, some of these people are very transient, so it's hard to get a hold of them sometimes. The property management and tenant selection plan was finalized, and the coordinated managed care plan opportunities for Innsbruck Lodge, that includes adding
1:08:44 Or being given security deposits to tenants that might be moving in in the future. So that it's, we're still working on building that connection with all of those actually. So Calium and the managed care plan. Other exciting things, so Patricia will be attending a ceremony in Sacramento for Nonprofit of the Year, which is very exciting. So, yippee. And then...
1:09:14 Our organization is still doing outreach. We just finished last month attending the Cal Jobs seminar. We had a good turnout. There was a lot of community members from different aspects, different jobs, different positions, who added to a very good conversation in the afternoon. We do have a book club, which we are reading from the ashes, which is the story of a ex-homelessness individual who lived in Canada. It is very...
1:09:43 heart-wrenching story at times, but it makes for a great conversation and good perspective on the people that we are currently working with. And then I think that is it, unless Eric or Patricia want to add anything. I guess I'll just give a quick update on our other housing development opportunities. I have been in conversations with the state around our valley.
1:10:11 I'm hoping to have a call with them shortly to understand if this means that we're likely to be awarded or
1:10:41 Are we expected to do this updated relocation plan not knowing if we're going to be awarded or not? So hopefully I'll have some more information on that and maybe we'll run into some folks in Sacramento. Silver Peaks is...
1:11:05 I'm working to plan an in-person meeting with the City of Bishop and Visionary Home Builders, who's the lead developer on that project, so that we can all get on the same page in terms of the expectations of that project in anticipation of applying for the next round of affordable housing and sustainable communities, which could bring many, many millions of dollars to the city for not only housing, but also transportation infrastructure.
1:11:35 I really think it has the potential to be an economic development success if we were able to get that application funded. Can I ask a question on that? Sure. Sorry. Are members of the Programs and Housing Development Committee going to be attending that with you, or is that just you one-on-one with the developer?
1:12:02 Yeah, I think it would be, yes, I will invite at least one person, I think, from the board to attend that meeting to represent the board in that capacity. Great, thanks. Yeah, of course. And it will be the developer as well as representatives from the City of Bishop. And then for Star Apartments, which is our existing four-unit project that we own and operate,
1:12:34 We are working through the insurance process and we have a contractor lined up for this summer to repair, work on some roof repairs and hopefully replace the deck on that property. That's an insurance claim? Yes. Okay. Just an added work program item. Okay. Any further questions from the board on the program's update? Thank you. Thank you.
1:13:11 Okay, with that, we will move to agenda item five, committee reports. A chance for our board members that are participating in... You covered it. Thanks, Brian. Sounds great. So I will mention that myself and Jennifer actually attended the Mono County Partnership Discovery Committee, which is sort of the focus on the Mono Basin affordable housing opportunities.
1:14:36 Had another good meeting with Paul McFarland, Erin, Ellen Young, and Jake Stupa. And yeah, you know, there's, we had some just sort of discussions about potential opportunities in sort of the Mono Basin area, you know, Levining in particular area, Mono City and so forth.
1:15:06 You know, there was a recognition of a couple parcels in particular out there that might have some opportunity. One particular with the school district up there in Levining has a fairly significant parcel that, you know, could be opportunity there. You know, it sounds like, you know, the school district is sort of earmarking it towards staff housing. And, you know, when you think about 12 acres in comparison to the...
1:15:35 The parcel here in Mammoth is 25, and that's about half the size and, you know, could be a significant opportunity, depending. So anyway, we're going to research that more and see what's out there, maybe talk to their superintendent and maybe one or two of their board members and see, you know, if there's something there where we could help. But I guess to the point earlier, a discussion about revenue sources and so forth, I mean, if something like that was to actually get some legs, clearly that would be, you know, a development project, a fairly significant size that would, you know, have
1:16:04 You know, some opportunity there. So, so anyway, we'll see how things go, but it's exciting to know that there's, you know, there might, there's, there's some interesting things and more continuous discussion, you know, in respect to, you know, what are other opportunities that could happen in the near term and really sort of using the town's bridge program as a model might, might be something that's applicable up in, in the Mono Basin area as well, because they're seeing a lot of turnover in, in owned homes up there that are.
1:16:32 People who are retiring, leaving the community, potentially, and then those units being snapped up by second homeowners and so forth. So there may be some funds. I couldn't tell you the acronym for the funds that the county may have some access to. There might be some opportunities there to maybe look at some, in the near term, some potential bridge unit program there. So we're going to research that some more as well. So anyway, fairly exciting, actually, I thought that there were some potential opportunities there. We'll continue to meet on a monthly basis.
1:17:09 Anybody else? Are you on five or six? I'm sorry. I'm still on the committee reports. Okay, yeah. Any other reports from any committees? Okay. Okay, hearing none, and we'll move on to item six on the agenda, board member reports. I guess I would want to, I'll start with most recent. Today, the California Coalition for Rural Housing Legislative Committee met.
1:17:43 And we discussed with the budget, the state budget, which for housing hasn't been super promising. The governor did add in, after taking out $500 million for state LIHTC, low-income housing tax credit, did add it back in, so that's good. And then the legislature has come up.
1:18:10 with their own budget, which includes that, as well as MHP funding, which was stripped out, and a billion dollars for the HHAP of round six. And then now,
1:18:33 The governor and the legislature will hammer out how legally they have to adopt a budget by June 15th, Saturday. But, you know, they have in the past had these trailer bills that go into the summer that change the budget, so we'll see where things go.
1:18:57 So there was talk for a while about Buffy Wicks has a bill for a bond, but there's bond competition for the November ballot. There's a housing bond been kicked around, a climate bond, and a school and infrastructure bond. And according to the state, there's not enough available bonding to do all of them.
1:19:24 And then, you know, and then we just had Prop 1, which was $10 billion for housing, well, for behavioral health housing. So there's limits on bonds, and it sounds like the housing bond is dying or dead. And now it's up, it's between a climate bond and a school and infrastructure bond.
1:19:45 There's no housing in either of those bonds, unfortunately, which it seems to me, after, you know, what, like you just mentioned about the school, and then I know our school district here in town, all talking about how we need housing for teachers, that that would be a great place to stick some money into your school and infrastructure bond for housing, but I don't think that they are so far interested in that, but if you, if you, you know, want to.
1:20:13 Well, we're going to be in Sacramento meeting with our senator, so I'll be sure to mention to her that I think it would be something to advocate for getting that in there. And then I appreciate your report out on our Discovery Partnership Committee meeting. It was the first one I'd been able to attend, and it was really good. I thought there was great momentum there, and it's nice to have all those folks.
1:20:45 I did meet today with town staff, county staff, and two representatives from USDA, from the state of California, to talk about USDA funding for child care, but they also have money, you know, for projects and facilities, so it's good just to keep those communications and those relationships open.
1:21:16 They seem to feel like they can find financing for any priority we have. So if we had something, you know, they do a direct loan, which is at 3.5% right now for 38 years. So they have some good terms. So something to bear in mind as we start to look at other projects, whether big or small.
1:21:46 Let's see. The town council and the board of supervisors had a joint meeting a few weeks ago, a couple weeks ago, and we did talk about the housing needs assessment, and the county and the town agreed to work together to do a housing needs assessment sooner than later, and so we're working with the consultants to try to find the best tune-up.
1:22:11 for the needs assessment. Our current one that we all have was done in 2017. It was a five-year needs assessment. So it's not super outdated, but it's a little outdated. So it needs a refresh, and we're just trying to hone in on exactly what the best use of time and resources is to get us the data we think we need. I guess that's it. Thank you. That's quite a lot. Anybody else? Briefly. Go ahead.
1:22:47 A couple of boards. An association, Homeowners Association Board, and we are in contact with other boards, and the issue of housing has come up, and we've talked about buying a unit within our own project, building a unit above the spa for employees, but it has become
1:23:15 You know, and I'm repeating myself for others, but I mean, it really is becoming a problem finding employees because of the housing issue. I just wanted to keep repeating that because it is really becoming critical to a lot of associations. Thank you. Thanks, Kirk. If I may, I just...
1:23:41 Because this is links back to associations. The Whitebark Institute does have a grant application available and HOAs are eligible for doing fire resilience work, which could be of interest to perhaps, I don't know, any HOA. It could be any of them or nonprofit to, you know, do all kinds of different things.
1:24:12 It's due by the end of June 20th of this month. It's $5,000. But if your HOA or any HOAs want to do some thinning or whatever it should be to make you safer from fires, it's an opportunity that I thought I'd share. I'm happy to share more information, too. Thanks. Yeah, so I kind of reported on everything already through the committee stuff. You know, I just, in terms of sort of overall development in town, I mean,
1:24:43 Clearly, there's some big projects going on up in the village. You know, limelight's roaring along here. We'll probably continue on to completion in the fall of 25. So about 16, 18 months from now, that project will be coming online and clearly will have employee demand. You know, these bigger projects are, you know, looking somewhere around 100 employees, roughly. Across the street in the former Novato site, there's...
1:25:10 There's a project called Rock Springs that, as you've probably noticed, has got construction fencing up. They completed demolition of the old restaurant building and the Dempsey Realty office. They're intending to continue on with construction here shortly. You're just waiting on some permits. And they'll be going gangbusters here by some point this summer. And probably will be delivering in 26, that project. And then the other project of significance up in the village that's...
1:25:39 Likely to start some groundwork this summer, fall, is the proposed Marriott Residence Inn on Berner Street. So, and that'll probably be about a two-year build. So, you know, there's, you know, several large projects that'll all be coming online here in 18 months to 36 months from now that'll create, you know, incremental employee demand. You know, I think that, I mean, I hope, I'm hopeful that the, you know, the parcel will obviously be delivering new units and will help, you know, address.
1:26:07 Some of that incremental demand and maybe be in, you know, by the time those are delivering that at least the second phase might be completed, which, you know, be another 144 units, I believe, on top of the 81, you know, would likely meet that demand. So, because as you guys know, there's not a lot of other undeveloped land out here in Mammoth and opportunities to develop more housing in this community. You know, so certainly getting the parcel.
1:26:35 Built out is important, I think, to the future of the community for housing and economic, you know, our economic growth and sustainability as well. So, so anyway, just, I just want to bring that to attention. It's just these, these things you can't ignore, you know, have to pay attention to what's happening here at the, in the larger evolution of our community, right? And how it affects everything, so. And I do understand that from what at least what I'm hearing is that the Parcel phase one.
1:27:05 It's hopefully going to get occupancy this summer. I know there was some hang-ups on some home stuff that they had, hurdles they had to get through in order to be able to take occupancy, but it sounded like it was more of an issue with that and getting to the finish line, but imminently here, from what I understand, they're going to, hopefully those units will be occupiable. That's all I got. Are those projects required to include any affordable housing element in it when they're... Yeah. Yeah, I mean, they,
1:27:37 They, at the time, they went through development review with the town and use permit and so forth, and they were evaluated against the town's housing ordinance requirements and were found to comply. So I think most of those, from what I understand, I think paid fee-in-lieu that are in a currently adopted housing ordinance on the books. So that money would, in theory, go towards housing and likely to parcel. So they just pay the town?
1:28:06 The town allocates it how they see fit. Through their, yeah, secure developer fees and the reserves that they keep for those funds, yeah. Okay, with that, we, unless there's any further reports, we will adjourn to our next meeting. Question. July 1? Yeah, our meeting is scheduled for July 1. Is that, does that still work for everybody? Yes. Yep. Okay, great. I'll be out of town, but that's all right if we have enough people, sounds like.
1:28:40 Yeah, I think so. Okay. I'll just confirm. Yeah. Just in case. Okay. Well, good evening, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. My association was really hurting for employees. Yeah. It's tough for everybody. I know. Restaurants, accommodations.