TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2023

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

at 18:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

167 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:49 I'll call to order the Mammoth Lake House Board Meeting for Monday, June 5, 2023. Roll call. Patricia, you want me to? President Stapp? Oh, okay. Yes, I'm here. Vice President Hodges? Treasurer Barksdale is absent. Board Member Kreitz? Here. Board Member Perkins is absent. Board Member Steenstra is absent. Board Member DeAndrea? Present.

1:27 And Board Member Nuttall is absent. Board Member Rice? Here. Thank you. Okay, we'll move to, let's get this straightened out. I'll call the order, are there public comments? Are there any? No public comments at this time. We'll move to the consent agenda. Is there any corrections, deletions? If not, I will move to approve the minutes from April 3, 2023, regular board meeting. Second.

2:09 Then moved and seconded. Roll call. President Stapp. Yes. Vice President Hodges. Yes. Board Member Kreitz. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Board Member Nuttall is absent. I'm not sure why that's marked like that, sorry. Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay, we'll move to policy matters, 4.1.

2:37 Consider adoption of Resolution 2304 to formally adopt the organization's change of name as part of the 20th anniversary rebranding process. Great, thank you. This item is part of our rebranding efforts to be more inclusive of our regional partners in the work that we do to provide safe and affordable housing for our communities.

3:06 The board has seen this resolution previously, and so there hasn't been a change since the board last reviewed this. We're hoping that the board will take this action this evening so that when we are prepared to launch the website this summer and partake in the 4th of July parade with the new name, that that will all be formalized.

3:37 Through this action. And once that action is formalized here by the board, we can work with legal on the back end to start informing our contractors and going through any necessary legal changes on the back end. In discussions with our legal counsel, they didn't feel as though this action needed to come at a very specific time, but that

4:06 It was more of sort of a natural process, and so once we check this off the list, we can continue to move forward with the rebranding effort. The board has allocated funding to this effort over the past two fiscal years, and so we're really excited and looking forward to all the final changes and details, I suppose, to

4:38 Take place, including a new sign at the office, new business cards, a new trifold pamphlet describing our services, and new website, obviously, so we're really excited about this, and we did have a public comment on this item, but we can share when it's appropriate. Question from the board? Do we want to share the new name with the public? Oh, sure.

5:14 So the request is for the board to formally adopt a resolution changing the organization's name to Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Any comments on Eastern Sierra Community Housing? Yeah, I just, I want to say I think, you know, our fellow board members did a great job of working through the process and everybody spent a lot of time on it and I think it's fitting for what our mission is and the communities that we serve, you know, all the tri-counties.

5:47 Alpine, Mono, and Inyo counties, and I think it helps inform the public that we're here to serve the whole entire Eastern Sierra and not just Mammoth Lakes, so I'm very supportive of the change. I also have one public comment to read as well, if you guys will, now's the appropriate time. It's from Megan McCammon, Assistant County Administrator, County of Inyo. She says,

6:14 We in Inyo County have been eagerly awaiting this name change for some time. In the summer of 2020, Inyo County began working with MLH on the development of a rehabilitation and JADU development loan program, which is finally coming to fruition with the recent award of our permanent local housing allocation. Since that time, we have seen MLH as a key partner in furthering our housing efforts and in helping to maintain some capacity as our continuum of care transitioned.

6:43 to the county and AMACA closed its housing programs. MLH has served such an important role in the Inyo County and the City of Bishop by taking on the development of the Silver Peak's affordable housing complex, your fight to keep Valley Apartments open, your willingness to serve as a partner in helping us clear a brownfield in Lone Pine for housing. You are really serving all of us in a capacity that we hope to see grow in the future.

7:09 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

7:42 Thank you. If I can have a motion. Sure, I'll make a motion to adopt Resolution 23-04, Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. authorizing resolution regarding amendments to articles of incorporation and bylaws to change incorporation name. I'll second. I'll move and second. Do you want to mention the name? Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc. I've been moved and seconded for the discussion. Roll call, please.

8:18 President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Hodges? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to Agenda Item 4.2. The Board will consider rescheduling the July 3, 2023 regular meeting. Yes, thank you. So in the staff report, you will notice that

8:54 Our July regular meeting is scheduled for July 3rd, which is not a recognized holiday, however July 4th is. If the board desires to keep the July 3rd meeting, that's completely acceptable. I had some concerns that folks may be taking the week off or traveling.

9:19 I'm not, and staff, we're planning to participate in the 4th of July parade on the following day. We will also be meeting on June 20th for our strategic planning session. That's not scheduled as a regular meeting, although if we have any emergency business items, we could certainly take care of those at that meeting.

9:45 But if the board would like to reschedule the July meeting for another time in July, we could do that this evening. Discussion? I'll be here on July 3rd, so I could go either way. Likewise for me, I'm available, but I'm certainly willing to accommodate other board members if they have other plans. I'm available.

10:10 Yeah, I'll be here. You know, for me, I just always think about, well, if there's material matters that need to be addressed, obviously, let's have a meeting. But if it's one of those things where there's nothing pressing that we need to do, then, you know, I'm okay with not meeting. I don't see the need to meet if there's not material that's, you know, that needs to be addressed. Do we have anything on the edge? Pardon?

10:44 Brian? I'll defer to all of you. I think I could be available that day. I think the, I know Patricia's going to be busy in the next couple of weeks with the big super NOFA application. I don't know if that factors in as well in terms of board preparations. You know, I would suggest, I mean, to Jennifer's point, if there isn't enough business to really schedule something, I mean, we could always defer for a couple of weeks.

11:20 Okay, so I think maybe let's just keep it on the agenda for now and then

11:43 As the next couple of weeks pass, I can see if there is anything urgent that we can't address at the strategic planning session, you know, if it's something quick or easy. And then we could make sure we'll have a quorum and possibly meet on July 3rd if we need it, and if not, then I can cancel it. We'll move to agenda item 4.3, presentation by staff on neighbor works.

12:18 Training Institute. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Our staff, Olia, Isara, and Eric, all attended a week-long NeighborWorks Training Institute during the month of May in San Francisco. And, you know, I remember attending one of these trainings, I think, in 2014, which just seems like a long time ago. I wasn't able to attend with them this time, but...

12:56 It's such an important experience and they were able to attend some really relevant and important courses including home ownership counseling and homelessness counseling and so I thought this would be a great opportunity. I know we don't have a really large agenda so that they could speak a little bit about their key takeaways and favorite parts or what they got out of the experience.

13:24 And so they did prepare a PowerPoint. I'm just trying to figure out how to pull it up. So I'll get it on the screen and then they can speak to it. Okay, with that I will turn it over to our staff. So yeah, so we attended the San Francisco NeighborWorks training on May 1st to the 5th in San Francisco. So here's myself. I'll present the first, I think, three slides.

16:15 Because I took three classes while I was there. So the first one that I took was asset-based community development, also A, B, C, D. And this was a community building course. So asset-based community development, the vision is to really shift the way that we are viewing our communities to focus on assets or opportunities rather than sort of counting up the problems that we see in the community. An example of this could be like unhoused 10 communities in probably more of a city not.

16:49 Not quite relevant to Mammoth Lakes or the region. But ultimately, the goal is to empower your community to take action with an emphasis on the skills of your community members. So this could look like mobilizing a group of artists in the community to teach the youth, for example. One approach under ABCD is called learning conversations, and these are one-on-one conversations that are about 45 minutes.

17:17 That are really looking to build a personal relationship with the client, the stakeholder, or the community member that you're engaging with. It looks to identify gifts, talents and passions, hopes and concerns, different association involvement, connections, and just possibilities for the community, really. So an example question is, you know, something, what do you love to do and never get bored by?

17:42 So within the conversation you could ask that as one of the introduction questions. Or what is your biggest concern about the next five years? And so really getting down to values and what that person dreams of for the community, maybe what their interests are and so forth. I actually was personally able to practice this with a classmate and I found that it was really crucial to building a strong relationship built on values.

18:11 And our interests rather than discussing our job title or our roles in the organization and so forth. I think that really it pointed to what brought both of us to the table and what brought us to the work that we're doing. Again, rather than discussing sort of the job title and how you kind of like fell into it, it shows a little bit more of your background by having a learning conversation.

18:38 And I think something that was really important is that I still remember the conversation and I remember his name, even though it was a 45-minute long conversation and we were only in the class for two days. I still remember Stanley. So I think that says something about having this type of conversation. And I think just generally this is a useful tactic for public engagement, especially when it comes to building regional goals or developing partnerships with other stakeholders.

19:06 I can kind of relate this back to what Isawara and I are doing, but we are working on a housing partnership program and working with some property management companies. And so developing those more personal relationships with them is really important when we're looking to potentially house some of our community members. So yeah. This is a little, I just wanted to include a picture, but someone in our class asked to take a picture, so I got one. The next class I took.

19:37 was counseling those experiencing homelessness and those at risk. So this course was really focused on empowering the houseless population by setting attainable goals. And because of this course and sort of, I guess, lessons learned that I included on there and just tips that we were provided, we, Sawada and I created our own client action plans for Mono and Alpine.

20:07 And so I think that it kind of establishes what services are available, you know, what the staff can do, what the client can do, and really upholding, you know, what you agree to as well because we kind of write it down and sign it and stuff. So it makes it a little bit more official and I think it helps.

20:37 The client leave feeling that they actually did something and that we have things to work on together as a team. So it's kind of building that team framework. The next class that I took was intergenerational community building. And this was definitely one of my favorite classes. I really was fascinated by it.

20:59 Really, it boiled down to that community engagement should involve all ages to not only increase social connection, but to also increase learning across different generations. So a couple examples, youth kind of organizing to help the elderly to use their technology at like a senior center, for example. So the youth gathering and then doing some sort of lesson with seniors. Or a different example could be an intergenerational board to help.

21:25 To help design a local community park that would be accessible to all ages. So, you know, giving feedback on what, you know, the young ones would want, you know, what kind of playground they would want, but also what the elderly would want. Like maybe they would want benches and maybe some folk would want a dog park or something like that. So having those types of interactions. I think one really big takeaway that I thought was interesting was it taught me to provide

21:55 the youth a position of leadership when it's applicable or to create space for the youth to interact with adults and I think that's kind of key when we look at workforce development and involving the youth for example so even if it's something as doing like a shadow day or something like that but I think it also can really be crucial to teaching that individual how to be a leader ultimately in their early ages.

22:23 And while, you know, sort of being able to guide decision making with their, you know, their young lived experiences. So, yeah, that is the slide. Oh, and I think the last thing I can point out is the theme of the class was to engage the lost, the least, and the left out. And I think this was a really big part of making sure that, you know, certain age groups are engaged with.

22:59 and kind of figuring out how to make an event inclusive of all ages. Hi, sorry. Okay, so I took two different, I took two classes throughout the week. I had to take my baby and that's the only reason why I only took two classes. But both of them were, I think I got the best classes, I would have to say. So the first class was SB320, Community Organization.

23:45 And that is founded on values and conflicts. Next slide. The values and conflicts. So what are your personal values, professional values? So it would be personal or professional. In this course, we discussed a lot of what makes an organization worthy of being included in our community. And that is all based on value. So I think

24:16 I mean, I would like to assume that our organization's value is on community building and it is surrounded by family. When I was taking this course, a lot of the people that is there, those are the top two main values, which was community building and family orientation or oriented. They were all family oriented. They had a lot of kids and they were all married. And they all lived in small communities. Even the ones that were worked in bigger communities were all for

24:44 Building something even though it's very large and they probably won't get to everybody, they still wanted to have something for a larger range of people. So like I said, in order for our community organization to be achievable, it needs to be driven by values. These are values that have changed or altered in the way you look at life, values that are moral to your specific person, whether that be religion, politics even.

25:10 So values that impact your performance in work. These are values that make you love the type of work that you have. The values you have should reflect your passion for the kind of work that you do. Me, for example, I am also very family-oriented. I grew up here in Mammoth, so me having a family really, really close by, that's a huge part. Having this organization help my family, so that's my personal relationship to the organization.

25:39 These values should reflect upon questions on the next floor, which is, what events led to your commitment to this field of work? How do your values impact the community and the organization? What values do I add to this field? What do I continue to do? Why do I continue to do this work? So like I said, everything is driven by values. Your personal...

26:06 Intertwine with the professional aspect of work. And that is a reason why I believe our organization works very well together. That and because we're all very close. And there's not a lot of us either. So next slide, please. This next slide, I will start off with a quote. If there is no struggle, there is no progress by Frederick Douglass. I believe that is very true. In order for organizations to make a very big impact, we have to have disagreements.

26:37 Sometimes they're for the greater good of our community, and sometimes people won't look at it that way, but in the end, that is what we're trying to achieve. When a person articulates their personal values, he or she can then contribute better to the organizational values, therefore knowing how to manage your personal and professional and linking them to make a better organization, that is what makes the organization great. The next one is values are important and significant to a person, group, and community.

27:07 Like I said, the values, whether they be personal or professional, is what makes communities stand out. A big part of ethical leadership is knowing your core values and having the courage to act on them on behalf of the common good. Whether you think that this is the right way or whether you don't think this is the right way, it's merging those and finding the good and the bad and working with what we have.

27:32 With common values, we can identify our group's mission and the steps we need to take in order to make change. In this chart right here, this chart was the main part of our class, which was somebody who is more agenda-oriented. That's the high value. And then someone whose low value is agenda. They have to find a way to work together. And that is through relationships. So some people might not think relationships at work are a very important thing, and other people...

28:02 Think that relationships are. So they have to find, like, their crossover, which is their agenda and high value. They, sorry, they value agendas, they want everything organized, and they value relationships that is cooperating. Or whereas relationships, they don't think relationships are that important, and they don't think agendas are that important, so they tend to avoid, they tend to be like, okay, you can take care of it, and I'll take care of something else, or you tell me what to do, and then I'll do that. And that is part of harmonizing.

28:32 So just finding a way to manage the way that we all work. Even though our office is not very big, we've all had to adjust to the way that we work. And I think me and Olia have done that recently. So that is how I took this class into practice was specifically for our job in having two navigators, one for Alpine, one for Ineo. Sorry, Mono, sorry. Where Mono is a little bit bigger in...

29:00 Their residents, whereas Alpine, it's smaller, and Alpine is more close-knit, where they only have two caseworkers, and then, and then Mono has like 10, 15, so that's how the very, there's a very big difference in what our counties want, so finding that correlation is what will help us. And then the second class, which is HO218, counseling those experiencing homelessness and those at risk.

29:28 That is knowing how to work with our homeless population here in Mammoth. As I think we all know, our homeless population looks a lot different than bigger cities' homeless populations. We have families who are living in their cars. We have families who are working through two or three jobs and are never really in their family, per se, whereas they get off and they spend time with their families. Most of these families can't afford that. So it's finding a way to work with them.

29:56 These are two out of four points, which is understanding homelessness, what causes homelessness, and what causes displacement. The next one is the areas more susceptible to homelessness. This is more of a bigger county, so this was more focused on counties out of state, LA County, where it's what communities, what cities are more prone to have homeless people. The types of housing for these experiencing homelessness, which means

30:26 Someone is going through a problem with drugs, we're not going to house them in a safe house where there are other drug addicts. We want to make sure that they are apart from that or finding a way to accommodate them so that they don't fall back into what led them to displacement. The role of the counselors is crucial to stable housing. Having someone that they can relate to or having someone that they can express their needs or their emotions also has a lot to do with how we

30:55 Deal and how we partner with them to make a better living situation for them. The next point is effective counseling and referrals. Traditional housing counseling and not just homelessness counseling. We don't want to sit with them, oh, you're homeless and we want to do this and some of this. It's more of, okay, why were you here? Understanding what brought them here, understanding what they're, if they have kids, okay, your kids, how well are they doing in school? We don't want to just make it, okay, well, we can put you in this home or we can put you in this table.

31:24 Safe Haven for right now and then we'll figure it out later. It's making a plan with them. So characteristics of effective counseling and then workflow process model or client action plans, which is what we, me and Olia as a housing navigators have been working with, especially with our community members who were displaced due to snow damage. We've been making client action plans where they get in touch with their landlord or the property manager to find other solutions for housing. And then building respect and trust with clients. A lot of homeless

31:55 People or displaced people do not think that their case workers or people who work in housing, per se, don't respect them because they have this mentality of, okay, well, you don't have to worry about that problem because you have a house, you have an apartment. So I think for you, it's just, oh, I'll do my job and go home. And I think that creates a stigma of, okay, they're not really here to help me, they're just trying to get paid.

32:22 And I've heard that before, so I think that that's, building respect and trust with them is a very important thing to do with our clients. Next slide. And then these are the final two points, which is financial recovery and rebuilding. So it's defining financial recovery for clients before making, whether that be talking to Eric about their finances, how to manage their credit, or to apply to credit cards. We want to make sure that those options are available to them.

32:53 Third point, counseling concepts for better financial rebuilding, which is the same thing, counseling them to make sure that their finances are in order. Resources available for financial stability, knowing what's out there either statewide, nationwide, or even countywide that can help them financially, which is EBT, SNAP, women with children can apply for WIC, and that's not something that are requirements for them, making sure that those, that they know of those resources. And then rent.

33:22 Rental Council for Stable Housing, which hopefully we will be initiating with Innsbruck Lodge. We want to make sure that they know how to pay their rent on time if they think they won't make rent on time to pay it in advance so that they are stable and that they stay there and not just be kicked out because they haven't paid their rent in four months. So it's responsibility when it comes to money. Rental resources, exposing them to other property managers, other

33:50 Landlords who might have units available, we are also partnering with the town of Mammoth to find property managers or Airbnbs that we can house people in. Seeing if they have any available units, we want to make sure that we know about them so we can offer them to anybody who has been displaced or anybody who is homeless. And then last point, which is accessibility to meetings about rental and permanent housing solutions. We want to make sure that me and Olia have calendars put together so that we

34:20 If I'm not in the office or she's not in the office, they can meet with someone regarding housing options that are available in town. I believe that's it. So I will give it over to Eric. So my class was home ownership counseling, principles, practices, and techniques. This was a week-long class. So I'm going to try to condense it to as little slides as possible. So the initial question is, what is a home counselor? This is a trained professional that helps.

35:00 Clients shop for the home that fits their needs. You know, as we know, people vibe with what they want, not what they need. So, they'll go for a luxury house when they can't afford it, and that just puts them in a bad position for the future. And how does it do, how do we do that? So, I'll take a look at their budgets, their credit, I'll do some credit counseling, more affordability, and finances, and also sit down with them and do some loan documents and closing documents, basically.

35:29 Look at it, see if it's, you know, affordable for them, and if they're getting, hopefully they're not getting. So, what's a home ownership counseling overview? It's a lot of, you know, back-end work. You really don't meet the client until it's the pre-purchase counseling portion of it. That's when you start sitting down with them and going over their budget. They bring in their, you know, their income documents, so that could be anything.

36:03 W-2, taxes, pay subs, 1099s, anything like that. And then you'll look at them, or I guess we'll sit down together, we'll see where they need work on, and then we'll create an action plan, it depends on what it is, so if they need help on budget, you know, we create a budget sheet for them, spending sheet, basically what it is. If they need help with the credit, we'll take a look at the credit report and help them with that, you know, get their

36:35 Yeah, I mean, that's the most important part of that one. The most important part for us is the document client progress. That's how we'll get paid. All right, so what are the next steps for me? So I recently took and passed the HRA 250 test, which we need to score 80% or higher. And then the next one is taking the HRA 250 test.

37:10 109 course, which is foreclosure basics. Once I do that, that's a self-guided course. I think it's pretty easy. Patricia took it last time, so it shouldn't take that long. And then after that, I'll apply for the home ownership counseling certification. That is usually going to take around six to eight weeks for them to answer back to us. But once all that's done, we'll be officially a home ownership counseling agency, and we can start counseling people that

37:40 Not only people that are looking for affordable housing ownership, but anybody that's looking for questions. Well, I don't know if I have a question. I think I just have comments. I guess I'll start with Olia. And I think your first class she took talked about relationship building, really, I believe, and asking questions about values and concerns as well. And I know that was really, it sounded like it was more

38:22 Like professional to professional, building those professional relationships, but I really see it intersecting with your clients as you create case management plans and helping people feel like, and I think, yeah, it's really loud. The rain is really loud and I apologize. I'll get really close.

38:54 You know, like, I think one of you mentioned that there can be this sense of a stigma between the clients and yourselves because you have homes, but I think, you know, using some of those tools would help people to build those relationships because you're asking questions and such.

39:14 I think, you know, especially when we, you know, we just exited Mental Health Awareness Month and so much of what goes on with folks homeless or, you know, challenged with housing really hits on our mental well-being and

39:33 You know, one of the things our behavioral health director always says is just ask people how they're doing, check in with people, check in with your neighbors, but you know, the fact that you can ask these kinds of questions, what are your concerns, what are your values, you know, just so people feel heard in a time where they're probably feeling pretty vulnerable and scared and anxious, I think it's great. I love the thought of all of this coming together and I'm sure, you know, we could all use that class.

40:02 I've taken those classes, Eric, those are great classes, a little, you know, kind of long, a long week, but it's good, it's good stuff, and I know you'll use it in your, in the field with the, with all the clients of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing, so thank you all for doing these classes, and I think,

40:28 That's one of the beauties of Mammoth Lakes Housing, I think, is that they really invest in staff and continuing education. So I think you're really lucky, and we're really lucky. That's all I have. Are there discussion, comments? Yeah, I just want to commend you guys on taking the classes. Obviously, it was some really good, useful information, real practical for what you're doing here.

40:56 Yeah, in terms of communication, you know, there's so many ways to communicate these days, and I find more and more people rely on electronic communication, which I honestly have to tell you, I think the best way to communicate with people is to talk to them, and preferably in person. So keep that in mind as you grow your careers, and, you know, what really makes a difference is making a personal connection with people, you know, face-to-face if you can, and if not, then by phone, but, you know, I would do that first before you rely on texts or emails.

41:24 And because I know too many people get too used to, I sent an email and I communicated, it's not really communication a lot of times. So I would encourage you guys as you grow your careers here and to do that, you know, to try to make those personal connections and have those personal conversations with people and continue to grow your skill sets. And yeah, I'm really thankful that you guys are on our team and it's clear that things are really starting to move and there's a lot going on. So good work. I was going to say, I appreciated the

41:57 The updates and the report outs. Thank you. It looks like it was a great week. And, you know, separately, I think that type of engagement with NeighborWorks is really important, especially as we continue to explore the feasibility of becoming a NeighborWorks affiliate, which could open up other capacity building and financial resources to the organization. Patricia and I started a conversation with the Western States Director last year. And while

42:27 I don't believe there are any open slots. I think we're an organization that is, you know, certainly has potential to become an affiliate at some point. So thank you for representing us so well. Agenda item, Mammoth Lake Housing Program update. This is our regular programs update on all the work items that MLH has been undertaking since our last meeting. And Eric has taken the lead on this report for the most part, and I'll jump in towards the end.

43:25 But if you have any questions, I think you can pause after each main section so that you have an opportunity to jump in before we get too far away. I have some questions. So let's start with the rental program. We still haven't had any unit turnover, so to date we have 170. We're working with Marvin to funnel that down a little bit to see who's on the list that's already been housed so we can take them off and we give opportunities on the list.

44:03 That being said, we have 495 individuals, and next section is our homeless intervention and housing navigator at this point. So the housing navigators have worked really hard. So they've been tabling at the FEMA Resource Center here and in Bridgeport. They've also been distributing emergency funding from Altera, which to date it's $23,000 that they've distributed. And then they've also been working with the town.

44:41 Or town housing allocation for displaced individuals. They've worked with 10 people or 10 households to temporarily house them, and that totals to $22,000 to date. I don't know if they want to add anything to it or not. I think the only thing I'll add is that we've built client plans with everyone that don't know when they can move back. So the client action plans, like Isara had mentioned, are super, super key to that because we're sort of, again, building next steps.

45:17 So if they are displaced because their housing was red tagged, is the financial burden that they're paying rent in two different places? No, most of them are not required to pay rent. We haven't heard of anyone that has had to pay rent since they've been displaced and red tagged. We've referred pretty much everyone also to legal aid as well.

45:58 I think that's a key point, because I think that there's kind of that conversation of who's liable, but due to the state of emergency, it's a little unclear, I'll say. But they are not paying double rent. We are covering their temporary housing costs. So they're not paying any rent then? That's correct. Thank you. For the discussion? Let me... They're still going. They're just doing... You're not done, are you? No.

46:31 Can I ask you a quick question about the 172 households on the wait list? Are those individuals, I know this is separate from you guys, but like for the parcel that the town has, are those individuals also being advised to get on the wait list there? Yeah, we've advised all of them to get on the waiting list for both places, just because we don't know when we'll have a unit turnover, so we tell them to apply with them as well so they can get it.

47:02 Chance either with them or with us. And I would just like to add that a lot of the, a good 20% of the people who are on the wait list have not been answering phones or haven't turned stuff in, so we still don't, we don't discourage people from applying to our rental wait list with that many people. So let's say there is 176 households that are on the wait list, 172.

47:29 But let's say the first 20 or 30 people have either been housed, and that's why we're getting in touch with Marvin, regarding what people have been housed, in which people have not turned any of their documents in. So they're on the wait list, but they're not, we won't call them if they don't answer their votes. Right, so I think we plan on this summer sending out a letter to everybody on the waiting list to make sure that they still want to be on the waiting list and make sure we can get a more accurate count.

47:58 Filling out the parcel or calling the parcel waiting list is part of the client action plans that they're doing with everybody who comes in the door and the staff have produced a couple of different resource sheets with all the different housing resources and they walk through it with every client, call this person, call this person, and last comment, but we're also partnering with a lot of

48:22 In the following months, we will be partnering with several property managers here in town who are renting out airbies who have vacant units to see if they're up for renting the units on a short-term lease for clients who are still on our wait list and can't find housing. That is a project that we are currently working on. We are going to be calling property managers in the next couple of weeks to see if we can partner with them and see if that's something that they're interested in to help our community.

48:52 get stable housing. I'm going to, just to clarify what the wait list is and what it is, we have a wait list management of 172 households that are there, 495 individuals, including 225 children under 18, 26% are households of two, 69% are

49:23 Households of one, two, and three, and 46% have income below the 50% AMI. And I think that's important to put into the record just so people understand the needs and where the focus is. Further discussion, comments? You know, when I saw this going through prepping for the meeting and I saw the 46% are below 50% AMI.

49:53 I was a little surprised at how high that was because I know we've been talking a lot about some deeper targeting in our projects and we hear a lot about the missing middle but that's almost 50% of those households that are very low income or extremely low because it could be 30% AMI so that's a tough

50:21 Row to hoe when you're trying to pay rent in Mammoth with that kind of income. Further discussion from the board? Not to belabor the subject too long, but, you know, I think it is encouraging, though, that the first phase of the parcel will be delivering, you know, 81 units that are targeted to, I think, an average of 50% AMI, right? 80 below, but I think the average is 50, I believe, because there's extremely low, low, extremely low, low, and...

50:55 So, and then, you know, the next phase of the parcel is, you know, way funny, but that's another 144 units that is going to also target those lower income levels. So, I think we'll be making progress here in the near future, which is great. Not to say that it is sort of, I was sort of surprised by that number as well, to be honest. For the discussion, if not, we'll move to agenda item. I'm going to finish the report. Sorry, Eric, I didn't mean to cut you off. It's all good.

51:28 All right, so same on this section. The housing operators have done some business outreach and that they did that for Affordable Housing Month, which was last month. And then they're also having regular meetings or they're starting to have regular meetings with both Mono and Inyo departments. So that should be Mono and Alpine. That should be, you know, picking up and they should be working with them closely. And then they're also doing...

51:56 They're also building a housing database with partners, which I was mentioning about that. And then the other portion that they're also working on is coordinated entry. So to date, MLH staff has entered 40 households into coordinated entry. And then they're currently on the coordinated entry site. There are 273 clients, 160 households. Of those households, 91 children are under 18 years of age.

52:25 And we're still inputting people or transferring them from the current system that we put them into to the SPDAT system, which is new. We just implemented it. Okay, transitional housing, Birch Creek, that is still currently occupied. We're looking at the reserves. Oh, yeah. So we do have a replacement reserve for that property that was funded by Mono County at the time of transfer of ownership to Mammoth Lakes Housing.

52:59 And we have used some of those funds to replace some heating devices, and we'd like to get some windows replaced this summer. And so we'll be accessing those funds for that. And then I am currently in conversations with Mono County about some funding that they may be able to draw down to help start funding an operational reserve. This property hasn't had an operational reserve since we acquired it.

53:27 In June of last year. And so we do have a long-term tenant in that unit at the moment, but the intention of the program is to have it as a transitional housing available to those experiencing homelessness as they transition into permanent housing. And so regular steady income from that property is not guaranteed under the way that transitional housing works.

53:55 And so I'll be continuing to have conversations with Mono County about how, you know, they've offered some funding to go towards that, and then also there's probably resources available through the regional continuum of care that has specific funding for homelessness prevention that we could use for an operating reserve there as well. Questions from the board? Go ahead, Eric. So let's move on to the ownership program. This is our deed restriction retention and land trust expansion.

54:35 That's basically the bridge program for the town of Mammoth Lakes. We are starting to do annual monitoring for those. This will be for them to bring in Exhibit B and supporting documents that state that this is their primary residence. That being said, there are numerous reasons why we have a lot of people on the waiting list. The main ones that I hear come up a lot is that the maximum eye levels are too low.

55:05 For our programs, and then that the interest rates are high, nearly 7%. So those are the two limiting factors that I hear the most. That being said, we do have 10 people on our waiting list, and they're at different phases. So just a quick rundown. So there's three people, or three households at 80% AMI, five households at 120% AMI, and then two households at 150% AMI. And then our units.

55:44 So, most of them have been sold. The most important ones are Louis de Blanc. It's currently in escrow. It was extended to the 30th, but hopefully it'll close sooner. And then we have the Marine Corps. That one's still under rehab. We're trying to get it up and going. And then we're looking for potential units. We're working on acquiring more properties to add into our programs.

56:14 Our mortgage assistance programs. We have several programs. I guess the interesting ones is home reuse and home. Those were currently extended by the state. And we're going to have conversations with the state on possibly new guidelines. So that's coming up. We'll keep you guys updated on that. And we still have the CalHOME program, which we could use for mortgage assistance, rehab, and ADU loans.

56:46 So that's still ongoing. And we have two clients pre-qualified, income qualified to utilize CalHome for mortgage assistance in the unincorporated county, Mono County. Look at the median home prices. Are those households on the home ownership wait list? Yeah, those are in Mono County. Right. I just wanted to make sure there was those lining up. Yeah. Yeah.

57:27 When you mentioned those clients, that those were, I made sense that the 80% clients, I would think all, yeah, okay, thanks. No problem. So, next are meeting home prices. I updated a portion of it. I'll just give you guys a review. So, Moda County residential homes are up by 14%. Town homes or town condos are down by 0.3%.

58:01 And then town single-family homes are up by 7.5. If we look at the next chart, it's the housing affordability in Mono County. We can see a huge jump on the town at the residential single-family homes where the gap now goes up to $1 million around that. So that's a huge gap. The gap is a million? Yeah, it's a million. The gap's a million from what the affordable price is. And we see

58:37 That it's increased over time. So on the other charts, it's just been increasing. So help them out. Do you guys have questions? Just some comments. I mean, you know, again, you know, I think, you know, thinking about the parcel and the master plan of the parcel, there will be, I think there was intentions in the future phases to be some homeownership opportunities there with some townhomes.

59:18 You know, we're really relying on local funding for that to get that one to go. But, you know, that's something that could find some legs in the near future, I think, possibly. So, you know, again, it just depends on political will of our community. But, you know, I've always encouraged people who are looking for homes to get on the waiting list that are, you know, interested in being homeowners. And, you know, there's only 10 people on there right now.

59:46 You know, if one of the phases in the parcels to go, I think it's earmarked for 28 units or something like that. So there could be a lot of opportunities coming up in the next several years and it's never too early to kind of get your name on there and, you know, things pop up. I mean, we've been, I've been surprised by how many things have come back on occasion so that we've had come back into our program and have flipped, you know, several units in a year kind of thing.

1:00:14 So I just encourage people not to give up and keep after it. And I think more and more as we continue to be focused as a community on this problem and we'll continue to find more solutions. The town's going to be building those four units on San Joaquin, for example. Those will be coming into the program maybe within a year. So again, please, if you're out there and you're listening and you want to, don't give up, get your name on the list. There will be opportunities.

1:00:43 You know, starting to come up in the near future, I think. Any other comments from the board? So we can move on to projects. So we have Inspirk Lodge. I guess the key points on here is that the demolition is completed. And we're having weekly calls with the GC, the property manager, project management, and the architects. That being said, Kevin is going to come up this next week? Friday. Friday. So you should be here. We'll be...

1:01:21 You can walk through Insport Lodge, and we'll see what comes from that. And then our building permit is approved. We're just pending school fees and the fire permit. So we're working on that. And then Access Apartments, I guess the point is that we're analyzing different funding sources. So we're working on the Super NOFA, and that's due by July 12th. And we're also working on the Enterprise Grant, which is used for capacity building affordable housing.

1:01:53 We're thinking of using that for consultants, and that we submitted the application, and we'll know the award status at the beginning of June. Valley Apartments, we extended escrow for another year, and then the other thing is that CSAC, which is the California State Association of Counties, has been proposing a budget amendment to forgive the existing loan, so that should be good. Last month, there's no update.

1:02:25 And then Silver Peaks, they're also working on Super NOFA, which, again, is due by July 12th. Maybe, maybe if you wouldn't mind briefly explaining the opportunity with the Super NOFA? Oh, the Super NOFA is HCD's effort to streamline some of the funding applications and programs, and it combines multifamily housing program, veterans housing program,

1:03:03 Infill infrastructure and one other source. We are looking at the super NOFA under the multi-family housing program to help fill the gap, the budget gap in the development costs that came about after we did the bidding process for the general contractor. So I think there's some opportunity under this grant application.

1:03:36 To possibly fill the gap, we have some competitive edge, I think. We're looking at applying possibly under the emergent developer category, which there will be a set aside specifically for small community-based developers to compete so that they don't have to compete with everybody else. And then also I think that there's some boost points for, I'm not sure if it's rural or high amenity.

1:04:06 So with those extra points, I think we can get an extra $25,000 per unit, for example. So I think we're looking at, I think it's possibly about $225,000 per unit from multifamily housing program. And so Eric and I will be looking at that.

1:04:32 in more detail in the next couple of weeks. But we are working with California Housing Partnership to make sure that that competitive analysis is accurate and that it's worth our time and effort to submit this application. And also we are working with Zen Development Consultants who we had previously hired to help with the financial closing on

1:04:57 Preparing, possibly preparing the super NOFA application so there's an extra staff person helping with the checklists and getting all the documents in order so that we can submit on time. Does that answer your question? Yes, thank you. And what would be the anticipated award date for success? Winter, so December 2023. So they give you six weeks to apply and then they take six months to let you know if you got it. Oh, so, you know.

1:05:32 The hope would be if we are successful, we would be in a position to potentially start the Access Apartments project next spring. Yes, that's right. So we've lined it up so that this setback puts us back approximately just about 12 months. Other comments, questions? If there's nothing else on projects, I'll just jump in and finish up the report.

1:06:09 I just wanted to mention that Eric and I will be out of the office this week for a training in Los Angeles for another possible funding source that we can use in the Tri-County region. I'm looking forward to learning more about that program and also just maybe meeting some other community-based developers in the field and getting back out there in the conference world. So I think that will be really good, especially because this

1:06:37 This cohort that we've been accepted in is only for community-based developers and developers who are strongly rooted in their communities and serving minority and low-income communities. And so I think there's probably a lot to learn from my colleagues in that area. So we have an all-day training on Wednesday, and then on Thursday we're going on a tour of some

1:07:05 Some projects in Los Angeles. So I think that will be good. We'll be back in the office on Friday. And then we just have a lot going on. So it's all in the report. We have our strategic planning coming up on the 20th. I'm trying to push along the rebranding as fast as I can. We do have Inyo County reaching out to help administer their

1:07:35 Rehab and ADU program. So we'll be bringing that back to the board as appropriate. And I think that's it for now. Questions from the board? Thank you. Move to agenda 4.5, review and possible approve the Mammoth Lake Housing draft 2023-24, fiscal year budget. Okay, thank you. To preface this item, this is the first.

1:08:19 Draft of the budget. Since publishing the agenda, I have had a few more days to think about a few adjustments that I need to make. I'll try to point those out. I guess that's the main point. I think that there's possibly some increased expenses that I need to factor in, in terms of our HOA for the office. Obviously, it's going to have some snow assessment impacts.

1:08:52 I know what that will look like for the next seven months, so I'll try to estimate that conservatively for the year, I think. And then, well, I can't remember off the top of my head, so I'll just go through some of the items that I think are the most interesting. On the revenue side, you'll see some familiar sources. We have our regular contracts for services with our partner agencies.

1:09:27 We do have the developer fee line item here. I've entered into here, and so this is a strategic conversation for the board to have, but I've projected zero here for general fund operations of developer fee. In the current fiscal year, we allocated $112,000 of developer fee just towards operations of the organization. That's something that we should discuss as we move through this budget process.

1:09:58 And then I've added property management and asset management fees for both Innsbruck Lodge and Star Apartments here, so that's why you see an increase in that item over the current year for adding Innsbruck Lodge. And then I've added a line item which is the payroll for a potential property management employee.

1:10:29 That would be paid for by the rents generated at the properties in proportion to how many units each property has. And that those projects would reimburse Mammoth Lakes Housing to pay for payroll and benefits for that employee. And we can talk more in depth about this at another meeting, but I have assumed that this would be a full-time benefited employee and that

1:10:58 That their role would be to provide management services, not only for the Hinsburgh Lodge, but also Star Apartments, Birch Creek Condo in June Lake, and possibly Access Apartments as it comes online. I'm also trying to conceptualize how that person may be able to also support Valley Apartments in the event that that acquisition is completed.

1:11:25 That's how I envisioned it, but I'm happy to hear any feedback from the board. We also have an additional revenue item for supportive services and case management from the Innsbruck Lodge budget, and all the Innsbruck items are only budgeted for seven months since the new fiscal year starts in July, and Innsbruck won't probably come on until about December, so I haven't budgeted that for the full 12 months for Innsbruck Lodge.

1:12:01 So any revenue from Innsbruck Lodge is only projected to be for half of the fiscal year, since the property doesn't come online until halfway through the fiscal year. Yes. That's why it's on the low side. For a full-time person, it would be much higher. Contract income other includes some smaller contracts that we have with the City of Bishop. And I usually budget the...

1:12:41 ongoing contribution from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area under this item, which is currently $10,500 for the past, I think, two years. We have a small allocation for fundraising and then our estimate of how many rental applications we'll process. And then below that is all of our grant admin. And so I have estimated

1:13:17 That we will receive some activity delivery for our current Cal Home Award. And I think this is estimated for just one processing, one loan, and then also the admin fees that the grant will reimburse us. I think that's conservative, but I also believe it will happen at least once, so I think that's pretty accurate. Are we ready to move to expenses?

1:13:58 Are we going to take questions on revenue separate, or are we going to go through everything and discuss it at the end? We can take it now. Well, I just feel trepidatious about a full-time manager for 19 units, especially considering the age of those 19 units with the remodel and such. It just seems heavy to me on property management.

1:14:31 For Valley? Or for the, for? Star and Innsbruck. Okay. Yeah. Just knowing, who knows where Valley is. You know, I, and it's not to double, double, or to doubt, I just.

1:14:49 That my gut tells me that's a lot of money for 19 units and that maybe we grow into full-time or consider it. I would just ask that we continue to contemplate that. That's all I wanted to say on the revenue side since it came up, even though it's an expense, but it's a, yeah. Yeah, and I have been having this thought in my

1:15:18 conversation in my head. We could, you know, we can do whatever is appropriate. And the only thing is, is that in this analysis, it's really a net zero because it's on the income side and it's on the expense side. So it's paid for by the properties and it's in the Innsbruck Lodge budget. We have to take a closer look at the Star Apartments budget to see how that factors in. We haven't gotten that far.

1:15:50 Yeah, we could certainly reassess what we do with that position. Is there also housing? Like, I guess I remember that Innsbruck has a manager's unit? Yes. Okay, so maybe it would be possibly less than that if their housing, you know, if their housing is included. Yeah, I, the salary is, the housing, cost of the housing is factored into the total salary.

1:16:17 Package, and so the total amount I think comes out to, I think it's about $25 an hour, all inclusive of the wages and housing, and then benefits would be on top of that. It's probably, you know, just a little bit too of like an analysis of time. I know the Star Apartments, you know, there's only four. It was pretty much a full gut and remodel.

1:16:47 I don't know. Yeah, I think...

1:17:17 Thinking about what we could offload, Eric and I, you know, includes calling the snow removal company over and over to make sure we're on the trucking wait list or going to assess damage. Those things have come up recently. You know, Birch Creek does have some needs, ongoing needs. You know, helping with rehab. Birch Creek is going to need, you know, a few things here and there over a long period of time.

1:17:50 Maybe that person takes the lead on the rehab component of replacing the windows, working with Mammoth Screen and Glass. All those things that take a lot of time and a lot of constant following up with people, I certainly envision trying to take that off of our plate. Understood, thank you. Yeah, but I think what I want to do is run another analysis so that we have a better picture of what that all looks like. That's revenue.

1:18:23 Before you leave revenue real quick, so you left developer fee at zero because of the delay in access and realizing some of the anticipated budget we had in that for developer fee, I'm assuming, and will we realize anything out of Injbrook during this fiscal year? So I left it at zero because this represents the organization's operating budget, so overhead.

1:18:53 You know, overhead and the cost to run the organization. You know, and maybe I should have provided another sheet that shows how much developer fee we will be collecting because I didn't provide that. But right now I think we are collecting, I think it's about $117,000 per quarter for the Innsbruck Lodge. That's not represented here. I left it off because I think that's a conversation.

1:19:21 And I can certainly agendize that for the next meeting that the board should have about how we want to invest those developer fees. Do we just want to use it as a short-term subsidy to keep Mammoth Lakes Housing with staff and utilities? Or do we want to invest that in a new acquisition or pre-development costs? That's why I left it at zero.

1:19:54 But I guess if there is a desire, I will make a priority to agendize that for the next meeting. Yeah, I mean, I don't think it's something we should discuss at some point. You know, I know there's also some potential, you know, cost overruns in Innsbruck in my encounter that we don't have, you know, covered at this point, things like that. So, you know, it would be nice to have an operating reserve as well, right, moving forward.

1:20:26 Yes, yeah, absolutely. And so we did open a separate bank account into which I was planning to deposit all the developer fee revenue that's not budgeted for operations so that we can look at that amount and decide how to invest it strategically. Yeah, that's a great idea. I had a question that partially answered my question about developer fee and we can...

1:21:01 Hold off for a few weeks until we meet. But where did you say that you budgeted the asset management fees that will be assessed to the housing partnerships or entities? Under property asset management fees. Under, okay. Is that in the property management fees line, the $36,924? Yes. Okay. All right. That, just in terms of the description, you probably could just add property management and asset management fees, just to clarify that.

1:21:36 It's two different revenue streams, right? There's two different agreements. There'll be an asset management fee agreement and then separately a property management agreement. Yes, and I can separate them out if that's more clear. Okay, so it's time to put our heads together under expenses. Let's see. So a lot of these, well, some of these numbers this fiscal year are projected, I think, to come in below what we budgeted. And so in many cases, I've left them the same as what we budgeted last year.

1:22:25 Down to, we increased meeting expense since we are back in person. Let's see, deed restriction, deed restriction subsidy. We did spend more this year than budgeted, but part of that is due to the bridge program, and we were reimbursed for those repairs through our program with the town.

1:23:12 So it looks higher, and so I left it at what we had budgeted last year at $28,000. Insurance is on here. We had some ups and downs with our insurance this year, and I foresee having that again around the end of the summer. So I left it here as the same amount that we budgeted for last year. Here you'll see property taxes and HOA fees.

1:23:58 Going up. I have an estimate. Oh, no, here it's not going up. So this is something I need to take another stab at. And then our loan interest on the office space. And so salaries and wages includes four full-time employees, one hourly employee, and seven months of a full-time property manager, but no intern. So perhaps

1:24:34 For the next time we see this, I will take another look at that and maybe provide what two separate scenarios might look like. You'll see in this fiscal year, we are projected to have lower expenses under this line item than was budgeted, and that has to do with the timing of when the housing navigators were hired. And so...

1:25:04 We had projected that they would be here for the entire fiscal year and in some cases just came on in the last couple of months. We have a line item here for design and copy editing services for marketing materials, website maintenance and tech support, which we do use and have been using regularly, interpreter services, which we haven't used this year, but I think it's important to keep in the budget.

1:25:44 And then our accounting and legal. Travel and training is the same that we had budgeted for last year because that included travel and training for full-time employees and that some of those expenses are paid for through our contracts with Mono and Alpine counties for the housing navigators. That's a general overview but I'm happy to address any items specifically.

1:26:31 In this version, I'm showing a deficit. I have a couple different. Patricia, did you say the anticipated snow removal fees you might get assessed would be part of the HOA fees? Yes. So that number might be low? Yes. Do you have any idea of order of magnitude of what that might be? The HOA for the office is going to double the monthly assessment, which is, I think, about...

1:27:19 It's about $4.50 maybe, for seven months to cover the costs from the previous winter, and then we lost our snow storage site across the street, and so we are going to be looking at what increased costs there may be for more trucking next year, possibly. So I don't know, I'm not sure how or if that will impact the

1:27:52 The monthly assessment, I only know what we'll be paying for for last season. Okay. And then, I know in the past you had mentioned that you guys needed some new hardware, like computers. Have you guys addressed that now? Have you got new systems that you need? Or is that a budget for? Do we need a budget for that? I really don't like technology, so I don't like to change my technology. But ISARA has a new computer.

1:28:24 Eric and I's computer, I think, are four years old. Eric just got some new RAM and a new battery. I need to do something as well. But I think that we can include that under, I feel like that's included under office supplies. I didn't call out a specific line item, but I think you've woefully underspent this year. So there's certainly money.

1:28:58 In this month, to buy some, based on your forecast versus budget, to buy them under this current fiscal year. If time is available. Or roll some of that over. I don't know. I mean, we're coming out with a positive NOI. It looks like forecasted. It's just tech and insurance are not things I like to deal with. But I appreciate you bringing that up.

1:29:49 Are we in a position where we need to adopt the budget this month or next meeting we have to adopt it in July? I think last year we adopted it at the July meeting. So I think if there's any specific concerns that I'd like to go back and make a few adjustments, I'll provide maybe two scenarios with two different property manager scenarios. I'll be more specific with the property and asset management fees. I have a few other tweaks.

1:30:19 to make, but if you have any items you'd like me to take a closer look at, I can do that for the next round. Okay, and like you mentioned, we'll discuss possibly the development, developer fees and our strategic retreat in a few weeks. Yes, I will make sure we do that. Questions, discussion? If not, we'll move to agenda 4.5, review and possible approval of the Mammoth Lake Housing Draft 2023.

1:31:02 We just did that one. I'm not, I'm not, we're moving into closed session. Okay. Thank you. Paying attention to the draft. See you on a minute. Yeah. No. So reporting, reporting out from the closed session was just simply staff direction. There's nothing to report. No reportable action. No reportable action.

2:20:12 We ready? All right. Next agenda. We're back in open session. The next agenda item is board member reports. Do I have any reports? I would just let everyone know that the county is looking at allocating...

2:20:42 Thank you, everyone. Thank you.