TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2023

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) Special meeting

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

329 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

7:47 I'll call to order the special meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation 501C3 Mammoth Lake Housing, whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Roll call? Okay, hold on. President Stapp? Here. Vice President Hodges? Here. Treasurer Barksdale? Board Member Kreitz? Present. Board Member Perkins?

8:31 Board Member Steenstra? Here. Board Member DeAndrea? Present. Board Member Nuttall? Here. And Board Member Rice? Here. Thank you. Oh, and I did just want to let everybody know that Board Member Perkins is on his way, so when he gets here, Angie, you could just take note. We'll move to agenda item number two, which is public comment. Are there any public comments? I see no public comments at this time. If there are no public comments,

9:07 Public comments. We'll move to policy matter 3.1. Consider approval of the loan agreement and acknowledgement of the debt with Mono County in its substantial form for the advance of mortgage assistant funding to support the ongoing mortgage assistant program funded through the 2021 Cal Home Award of Mammoth Lake Housing. Any comments? Thank you, President Stapp.

9:39 This item is on the agenda this evening as sort of an effort to make sure that our first-time homebuyer programs don't get stalled between the time that we submitted a request for funds to the state and the time that we'll actually get reimbursed from the state. And so this is in relation to our 2021 Cal Home Grant, which serves the area of Mono County, including

10:06 The town and all of its unincorporated areas with mortgage assistance, owner-occupied rehab and ADU construction loans. Eric has been working really hard to process a number of homebuyer clients and figuring out which programs will work for them and which income levels they fall into and through his efforts, we've identified two homebuyer households in the unincorporated area of Mono County.

10:36 qualify for the CalHome funds. And so we initiated a funds request to the state, but one of our clients is already in escrow, and so in order to not delay their escrow, I reached out to Mono County to ask if they would loan us the funds in advance and that we would pay them back once the state funds our request through the grant. And so the Board of Supervisors did approve this agreement this morning.

11:06 And so I'm happy to answer any questions, but that's sort of the gist of what this ask is. Any comments? If not? I can make a motion to approve. Yes, thank you. I recommend the, or make a motion to, for the recommended action as stated on the agenda. I'll second. I'll move and second for the discussion. Roll call. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Hodges? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes.

11:48 Board member Steenstra? Yes. Board member DeAndrea? Yes. Board member Nuttall? Yes. And board member Rice? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item policy matter 3.2. The board will participate in this strategic planning session with Zena Doherty of Agnew Beck to update the organization's five-year strategic plan. Did I mess that up? Oh, yeah. What is it? Doherty. Shauna Doherty.

12:23 Thank everybody for helping to schedule this event. We haven't had a strategic planning session since 2018, I believe. We adopted the strategic plan in 2019.

12:55 And that was for a period 2019 to 2023. And so, you know, we could have postponed it, but I feel like the organization is growing at a really great pace and that now is a good time to sit down with some of our new board members and talk about where we want to go and how we want to move forward into the future. And so we, I invited Shauna Doherty to come back and help us update our strategic plan for the next three to five years.

13:25 And so I know I'm very excited to hear feedback from the board. And I know that our staff probably has some input that they'd like to make and contribute to this process. So thank you, Shawna, for being here. All right. Does that sound good? Oh, I guess just for housekeeping. We do have lots of snacks and beverages and dinner should be arriving around 5 p.m. Okay. Great. Well, I'm excited to be here, like Kirk said.

14:02 I'm Shawna Doherty. I'm now, lots happened since I was last in this room, I'm sure with all of you as well as me. But before we get going, I wanted just to do, so I understand who's here and then who's online. I'm pretty focused on the group that's in this room. I designed the workshop as, you know, you guys know because you've worked with me is that you, this is really,

14:32 Hope, the hope in the next four hours is that it's fun, it's brainstorming, we get to sort of some discussions, we have the amount of time that you don't have the luxury to have in regular board meetings because it's, you know, agenda and policy and protocol and this is, my role is as facilitator is to keep us on time, keep us on track, get to the end result which is your feedback on the priorities over the next.

15:00 I'm saying not five years. I'm suggesting that we say three years so that we can update the draft and send it back to you. That being said, we are going to be moving around and working in small groups and taking breaks, and so hopefully it feels a lot different than sort of a regular board meeting. That being said, I do know we have people listening in, and so what I'd like to do right now is just invite them.

15:27 to be part of this introductory exercise. So just to start off with, you have all picked an object, and for those who are online, I just invite you to, when we get to, when I call on you, just to introduce yourself. But what I want you to do is just say your name, and then how the object that you picked represents what thinking or mindset you're bringing to this workshop.

15:57 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And then if you guys could do me a favor because I don't know all of your names. I know names on paper. I know some of you. And then just put your first name a little square in front just for me. So I'll go first just to role play. So I'm Shawna. My role today is I'm a facilitator. My background is in strategic planning.

16:26 And I'm a trained facilitator, so I really see my role as this cup. I am here not to steer anything. I'm just here to create a space for the conversation. And so I'm the cup, and I'm wrapping my arms around all of you and all your work and all of your ideas and trying to help move those ideas forward. I really, the other thing I want to add is that I set the room up in this.

16:52 way purposefully because to be inclusive so I know staff sort of ask questions like what's our role ultimately the strategic plan is the role of the board but this is set up so that everybody participates so I just encourage staff to be part of the discussion and I'm going to put you in small groups and you're part of the group today. Okay so that is me so anyone else want to go? Sure. Okay. So I picked the whale.

17:24 Although I was thinking of something different. So anyway, whales are big, right? Biggest thing in the ocean. And I think we're at an interesting point in the evolution of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I think it's maybe an opportunity for us to come up with some big ideas today. And we're expanding our vision. We always say we service the tri-counties.

17:52 Alpine Mono and Inyo counties, but now we're going to change our name to reflect that, and I think it's an opportunity to really, you know, focus on that opportunity for us as an organization moving forward, and, you know, we are starting to reach out and do, have some opportunities down in Inyo County, but I think, you know, as things move forward and as these different types of funds that are out there, whether it's through some of the federal

18:22 Programs that are starting to become available and, you know, it just creates some interesting opportunities for us to, you know, chase some other monies that are out there and some other projects to really support affordable housing in our, in our eastern Sierra. And I don't know about you guys, but I always think of my home starting at Lone Pine and going all the way to, to cross the Nevada state line. That feels like it's all the same to me, you know, Mammoth, Fish, I mean, all the eastern Sierra, right, feels like one home to me and that's who we're servicing.

18:51 So I think it's important for us to consider that as we look at updating our strategies. Okay. So I'm just going to clarify, Tom, excellent job, but what I want you to do is just tell us, like, one thing about you and what – so I got – you know, just what your – so my cup, what I'm bringing is just holding the space. And so Tom – I put Tom is – Tom is – Yeah, big ideas. I'm putting Shawna. So I'm holding –

19:20 Space for process. Okay. We're going to have lots of time to share views of sort of where you think the organization should go and everything. So this is just about you. I have this item and this is what I bring to the group today. And this item reflects it. Short. Hi, welcome. I'll explain what the exercise is in just a minute. Okay.

19:51 Brian, do you want to go next? Sure. I picked the starfish because, like the starfish, I'm not from here. But I'm humbled to be here. And I love it here. And I'm happy to share my experience and knowledge with the organization to help us grow. From the ocean?

20:29 Well, I'll go. So I'm Patricia Robertson. I'm the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I was drawn to the dragon. I think that, I don't know a lot about dragons, but they're big and colorful and creative and maybe, yeah, don't always take no for an answer. So that's why I picked the dragon.

21:00 Okay. I'll go. My name is Ole Agorif, and I'm one of the housing navigators at Mammoth Lakes Housing. I actually picked the closest object to me, which was a bridge, but I feel like that's very fitting. And I am bridging services and people and connecting people, so I feel like I'll bring the same today. You guys are getting the hang of it. Okay. So, Tony, you understand you pick an object, and then you introduce yourself and how the object works.

21:36 Relates to you. Yeah. Yeah. Anyone else want to go? Okay. My name's Amanda, and I have a crystal ball here to see the future, because housing is super important in our future. Jennifer Kreitz. I have a compass, and I'm looking for some direction. Not giving it, but looking for it. I'm part of a team. We're all going to come up with a direction together.

22:18 I can go. My name is Sarah. I picked the turtle, honestly, because it was shiny and gold and had little mirrors on the back. But I do like turtles. They're one of my most favorite ocean creatures. And I'm excited today to be here. My first strategic planning session. So excited to see how this all kind of unfolds and shapes up.

22:49 See where my little turtle will lead me on my exploration today. Okay. Okay. I'm Isaura. I'm the housing navigator for Mono County, and I chose the light bulb. I feel like my position brings a lot of light to our community, specifically our homeless community here in town, as well as our Hispanic community. So, yeah. Okay. Okay. I'm Heidi. I picked a grinder. I don't know if it's a pepper.

23:29 But there's a lot of detail to it, and a grinder grinds, so detail and grinding. I can go next. So my name's Eric. I got the elephant and the baby elephant. I think it's for growth on the programs in MLH. Okay, so you're the...

24:04 You're the, um, Eric is the growth? Big growth? Yeah. Go big. Go big, Eric. Yeah. My name is Tony Perkins. I chose this little calico critter because my children love calico critters. Um, to me, this calico critter is like a hedgehog because it's fast, but it's also like a porcupine because it's not always the friendliest one. Prickly? Prickly and fast.

24:41 Okay. Great. Thanks. Kurt? Okay, you got the bull. Somebody put a bull in front of me. I keep thinking of another word that attaches to it all the time. You get the bull, you get the horn, right? There's another end of the bull that comes out. So I'm just here to participate, and I've been doing this for a long time. Okay, so longevity.

25:15 Longevity. Okay. Head fast. Okay. Okay. Wisdom. There you go. Okay. Did we get everybody? Oh, yes. Good, everyone. So how about some introductions online? Hi, Nolan. Hello. Nolan Vaparoff. I'm with Townham Mount Lakes, their housing coordinator. I'm really just here to listen all about the strategic planning efforts.

25:50 I don't have any animals to pick here. Anyone else online? Yeah, I'm Sandra Moberly, the Community and Economic Development Director for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and I'm here in the spirit of collaboration. Great. Hi, Sandra. Anyone else? Great. Well, welcome, everybody. Well, thank you for that. Just helps me to get to know you all a little bit. A little bit about our agenda.

26:37 I'm going to put this over here. We are here for until 6 p.m., right? 7 p.m.? 7. Okay. Yeah. Okay. And we will take breaks in there, but we did our public comment. We did – I'm going to do a little bit more on introductions. I'm going to show a few slides just to sort of ground us in sort of this situation today before –

27:06 I know there's a lot of new board members, there's new staff, so before we start really thinking about where we want to go in the future, we want to get grounded in sort of where we're at today and make sure we all have the same information moving forward. And then we're going to do some work. There's a document that's been passed out. We transitioned the 2019 strategic plan over to a little bit user-friendly document.

27:32 And we're going to do some work together talking about that based on sort of what comes out of the discussion around current conditions. So that's a little bit of the agenda. So before we get going, I have to start. Again, I'm just getting to know you. You're getting to know me. But what are some, as we're here for the next, I don't know the dynamics of this group, but I'd always like to set the meeting with some.

28:01 Intention around a meeting agreement, so how we're going to work together and how we're going to speak to each other and if a new idea comes up, what do we think about the new idea? So what if, just put some meeting agreements that will make this a productive time together. Listen and be open to any idea or suggestion. Okay, so let's listen and be open to all ideas. Okay. Okay, other ones? No judgment.

28:36 Yep. Okay. Give the person the time to express their viewpoint. So give each other time, I guess. Okay. Okay. I sort of said something. Tony, go ahead. Think outside the box. Yep. Great.

29:23 I set this meeting up and I'm going to call on, if you're someone who's just be warned, if you're someone who's generally quiet in these meetings, I will be calling on you because one of my meeting agreements is that I'll participate. So just you might want to proactively say things. So anyone else? Yes. I'm tying into that just creating space for participation.

30:02 Well, thank you for doing that. And then just as part of the interview process, who was not able to do an interview with either myself or Allison? That's pretty good. And I know we started out in February with some of them and then your roads got closed and then we continued some of them. I remember. I know, I know. We were about to come down and your roads were closed and it was going to take me like, and it was just, and you guys were having like roof, you were dealing with a lot of damage on all the.

30:35 And I was like, we don't do strategic planning when there's like critical like hazards and then you were like trying to get you to come up from LA and so yeah you still have, we do too in Truckee, we do too. So what about, so part of the interview is we asked you sort of what do you want to get out of today and so I want to re-ask that question just we have about three and a half hours together and Tommy started on that sort of what do you hope you walk away from

31:05 Either from the experience with this group or just sort of like you and your role as staff or board or a product. So what are your goals? I would say some clearly defined objectives that we can help guide us over the next two to three years that are measurable, you know, who's responsible generally.

31:40 Or we can flesh that out, I guess, later. But really, you know, something that kind of creates some framework for where we're going and that we agree and there's some ownership. I think along those lines, I'm looking for the board's vision for the organization's growth or not growth or whatever the board envisions for that. And then, I guess, the direction or how to...

32:14 get there, right, which maybe is the defined objectives in between. I'd like to have a regional focus to set a framework for Eastern Sierra Community Housing rather than a local focus for Mammoth Lakes Housing. To second that as well.

32:44 I am looking to have more clear guidelines for the housing navigation portion of what we do, and I think that really ties in well with the regional aspect of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. I have one more, and it may be a little bit, well, I don't want to upset anyone, but I'd like to talk about the name change and get some clarity on that. Okay, so you're, I think that it's critical, it's come up, and

33:26 Just now with the regional focus and I just have some thoughts on this that I would like to discuss in the workshop. Okay. Just so you know, I did make assumptions that you guys were past that. So when we get to the information around, I'm going to just share information, the facts as I know them, and then I'm going to lead a discussion and that would be a perfect time, Jennifer, to be like, based on that fact that you just stated, I would like to...

33:54 Have a conversation around that. So I don't have an agenda item that's like, revisit the rebrand. It's just sort of like, I have slides on sort of, here are the facts. Does everyone agree with these facts before we move forward into planning? And that would be one of the facts that we should talk about there. So I would say yes, that is on the agenda. I just don't have it as specific. Yes, Kurt? One of the facts is that, what are our current needs? How many people are on the wait list? How many people are living in the woods?

34:24 Many people are, you know, just transiting through. So what about your goals for the workshop, though? So how does that translate to what your goals are? Because I think we need to address that. So your goal is to understand the need and how we address the need? Yes. Okay. Okay. Can I possibly add to that? But I think that there's, like, the current need and then potentially the future need. And, like, again, kind of as we grow a little bit, but I second that.

35:04 Exactly. There are quite a few of them. And the stacking and everything else. And again, this is valuable time, so you just want to know what's valuable for you. Yeah, Brian? An understanding of the process for codifying the strategic plan. I know we're today at a retreat. What is the end game? When do we expect or hope that this plan will be completed by? And what additional steps beyond today do we need to take to get there?

35:38 We'll talk about that, especially here. Anyone else? I'm curious. I don't know if this falls into if there's going to be an answer or just an understanding of where we come up with goals and objectives. What is the financial then requirement for everything that we want to do? Your goal is that

36:06 Whatever we come up with in the strategic plan, that there's a financial, there's a budget to go with it. Correct. Okay. And how do we get that budget? I would just like to add that we can, something that I would personally like to take from the workshop, personally for me and my position, would be networking, strengthening relationships between the counties, since we are going to be a tri-county.

36:45 Organization, I think, strengthening the relationships between Mono Inua and Alpine is key to meeting those needs, like Kirk had said, so in order for us to meet needs, we need to have partners who can help us meet those needs. Yes, Tom. I wanted to also make sure that we do have a bit of a discussion about, you know, our status as a community housing development organization at Choto, and in just the board's interest and desire to, you know,

37:23 Pursue further efforts to become, you know, an active developer of units, so to speak. Because we have the towns doing a lot of stuff, right? We have some projects we're working on. A lot of very challenging work, for sure. It takes a lot of time and effort and probably understaffed even for our current efforts. So I just think it's worthy of discussion in terms of our aspirations for being a chodo and to what degree

37:52 You know, we think we can actually be the developer of units of affordable housing units in the tri-county areas and in our ability to, you know, staff appropriately. So that is a lot of, Eric, I want to hear you. I was just going to add something. Yes. That goes with Tom's point. It's just maybe thinking about maybe creating some programs or expanding some of the programs that we have or the opposite would be. Oh, I'm going to say programs. Yeah. So,

38:32 It's interesting for me to hear all of your goals. I cannot promise that we are going to, in the next three and a half hours, get to all of those, but I think we can, the design that we have for today and the process will certainly touch on a lot of those things, but I will keep, I use it as something to check with. So it is, I don't know, Isora? Am I saying it right? Isora? Or one of the staff, do you, when?

39:03 You guys can help me with the PowerPoint. Okay, so I'm going to get a few slides up that is the current conditions, the conversation around sort of like where are we at. And I'm going to have, it's by no means comprehensive. And also, just to also set expectations as far as what our role is, this strategic planning is, you guys had a $5,000 budget. And so,

39:31 As far as what to expect with our role is we did some interviews before. We transferred all of your old strategic plan into a new format that gets to one of those goals, which is clear objectives. There's a table in the end that has roles and responsibilities. And we're going to focus today on sort of right-sizing this.

39:58 Are these still the right strategic focus areas? Is this still the right, you know, are these still the right goals? And then we're going to dive into sort of resetting those objectives. The detail underneath sort of last time we went into really, really a lot of details on like tasks and staff did some of that. I'm going to talk a little bit about roles, but really today if we walked out of here with clarity around the goals and the objectives.

40:25 And it's going to be really messy for those, if you guys, Kirk and Tom can remember from last time. And Patricia, it's super messy. Like, we're going to use poster paper, and there's going to be a lot of ideas. And then we take all that, and we put it into this framework. And then you all, I think you brought it back to the board for further discussion and clarification. But really, staff goes back and puts some of the details in there from your ideas.

40:55 So that, and then we give this back to you, and then we're, that's all of our budget for this phase of work. So that's just a little bit as far as Brian, I think it took maybe two meetings to go back and forth, but I'm hoping that this, we've been using this framework with a lot of non-profits recently with the table behind.

41:19 Some people want to just stay in the high level and some people really want the detail and then you also need to be able to have it so that your outside partners like the town and those listening in can pick it up and read it and understand like at a high level what your priorities are but then you know so it's a balance between the details and the high level stuff. Note that what's in here now is again 2019 goals and objectives and then

41:48 We put in there the results since then. And we're going to spend some time doing that, but I wanted to just start with this. Can I ask a question before we get started? So I know these goals and objectives are kind of guidelines for all the decisions we make as board members. Are there specific documents that we're referring directly to these when we're...

42:17 Writing out. I know in the past, as a board member, we've referred specifically. Are there documents and stuff that we're specifically writing these out and refining it as we go? Back when we did it originally? Excuse me? Back in 2019. I'm not sure I was part of it in 2019. I think it was done right before I joined.

42:49 But if nothing comes to mind that there's specific things that we're writing this out on an annual basis rather than just a no. Well, we used to revisit the strategic priorities on an annual basis. We haven't been doing that for the past two or so years. But that's certainly something we could continue to do. Thank you.

43:22 An email that people online can hear me, but they can't hear all of you, so I'm just reminding you guys to use your speakers. So was the question, Tony, how do we use the strategic plan? Yeah, how we're using it, and when I'm making decisions, if I am debating something as a board member, I just go back and read through these specific plan goals and objectives again, but I was...

43:53 Just curious if there was specific documents that we work on regularly that I am always going to need to directly refer to. That is an excellent, you're already thinking, and that's an excellent question. Sometimes what we do, so I'm just going to explain, and those of you who are experienced with strategic plans can chime in here. Where I've seen strategic plans be the most effective is

44:22 When they're used all the time, even your agenda, every staff report, so we just work with the airport district up in Truckee, and they do a strategic plan, and they're going to change their staff report so that when the board gets an item from staff, it references strategic area one, goal two, objective three, right? And then you would know, so you would know that

44:49 Staff is presenting you with something that drives the strategic plan that you're all collectively trying to drive the work towards versus a random, like this is take the topic that, and you missed it, but today there was a policy topic about something to do with a loan from, loan for some type of housing, right? That's great, but what I find challenging for decision makers is you guys get thrown a lot of information. And what the strategic plan does is it creates an architecture.

45:18 For all the information to fit into so that you all know where you're going, right? And so ideally on the agenda if there's a new topic being presented or any topic actually that you would know that it fits into sort of a goal area like getting people in housing, okay? So that's a goal and so there's a request by staff to create some flexibility about timing of a loan and you know that it fits in with

45:47 And then the other thing is we do attachments. If there's key documents that has, like, an example would be, like, to Kirk's point, a summary of needs data. And not all of it, but if there were, like, four slides that had relevant housing needs data that was just an attachment or something you referenced all the time, or AMI levels for each county. I don't know what you guys need to reference, but you can talk about that.

46:17 As far as like having your, this is like a, it's supposed to be a blueprint for the board to help your decision making so that if a new thing comes forward, here's a perfect example, right? Like Jennifer's bringing up the rebranding. If you all made a decision in your strategic plan, then you can have a conversation around that topic, but you could reference the strategic plan versus it being sort of like a personal thing. It just becomes sort of like

46:45 Are we changing our decision? What do we do about that? Does that make sense? So as far as, so use the word codify. So you guys are 501c3, so strategic plans aren't really, they get approved by the board, and that's what we did last time, is we said this was approved, the 219 one had a date, and it said this strategic plan was approved on March.

47:14 2019 by the board, and then all the board's names were in there, and that was the approval. It's not really ever codified, per se. It's just a guiding document, not a binding document. All right. Can you guys see? Can you guys see this slide? You can turn around. So I don't have a lot of slides. We're mostly going to get into the work. But what I wanted to do is

47:51 When I show some of these slides, I'm sure it's going to trigger a lot of discussion because it's incomplete. Because we weren't budgeted to do a deep assessment of your organization and look at all the needs. So it's just high-level facts about what we're seeing about your organization. And then I would have some blank sheets. If we want to fill in more information, that would be helpful. So if you can do the next slide.

48:24 We already did that. So we, I forgot to do this at the beginning, but we always like to start our meetings with land acknowledgments, acknowledging the ancestral, cultural, traditional, and unceded territory of the Paiute, Shoshone, and Timbisha people standing today. A little bit about Agnew Beck, the company I now work for. Last time I was here, I had my own company, and then I went.

48:52 I worked with Nolan a lot. I worked at the town of Truckee as starting their housing department. So I'm a little bit unique in that I'm a facilitator with quite a bit of depth with housing work in resort towns. So I worked at the town for two years. And then it wasn't like the perfect fit. I learned a lot. And then I wanted to go back out with a

49:18 Larger company, so Agnew Beck is based in Anchorage, Alaska. It's 20 years old. I'm in the Truckee office. There's three of us, and there's eight in Boise. Since I saw you, I've worked in Ketchum, Idaho, in Whitefish, Montana, in Washoe, Tahoe, and I think that's it. But very similar dynamics to here. I would say maybe a little bit.

49:53 Even more challenging here because of the isolation, but like Whitefish's, Montana, as many of you may know, there's no taxing, there's no rules around restricting anything, so, and they have a huge number of short-term rental, so very similar dynamics in all of these places. Next slide. We did that. I was just explaining because some of you know me from a different setting. We did that already. Next slide. Next slide.

50:26 Next slide. So this is a little bit of the timeline. So we started in March, and then we took a pause, but I did some meetings with Patricia. We started to do some interviews. We reviewed some of your documents. We're here today. And then we're going to pretty quickly turn around the feedback that you got, and I'm sure at your next board meeting, which is when is your next board meeting, Patricia?

50:55 We are scheduled to meet on July 3rd, but it might be canceled. Okay. I would say from our end, we're going to have a draft to you by your next board meeting, and you need it the week before. Yeah, it's fast because we did the pre-work ahead of time. We just found, and I created that last one, so I'm just criticizing myself that it was pretty, and you guys all did a lot of work on that 219, but...

51:22 It's very hard to update, and it's hard for the board to sort of like get their, roll up their sleeves and get in there and do the work because it was in that Canva format. So this is just in Word, and it's much easier to update in things. Okay, next slide. A little bit about roles. I touched on this, but I just want to remind, you know, the board, this is one of the key roles of the board, you know, financial responsibility, policy decisions, setting the strategic plan, hiring the executive director. Those are your key roles.

51:53 When we start to get into the nitty gritty of what fees should be charged or programmatic things, that really is where you can provide some feedback, but that will be really more of the staff's job to wrestle that out. So next step. Next slide. So what I wanted to do is just play back.

52:18 In our interviews, we talk to everyone except for Olya, and we summarize sort of from, this is usually how we start, you know, like, so what are we all saying about ourselves? Last time I did this, I interviewed outside partners, but this is just all of you sort of, where is their alignment and where is their difference? Okay, so if you go, next slide. So I'm starting to use the new name.

52:48 Again, that's a conversation piece, but that's what my understanding was is that you were rolling out that new name. So Eastern Sierra Community Housing and your vision is, this is again not your feedback, just grounding foundational facts about the organization. So the vision is communities in the Eastern Sierra thrive because everyone has access to safe, affordable, quality housing. I think we did that, updated that at the last workshop.

53:17 Does that, the question I have to use, does that still hold? It's interesting that you had that Eastern Sierra in there back then, not knowing necessarily that you were going to change the name. So our mission is Mammoth Lakes Housing supports community housing for a viable economy and a sustainability. So that's all over your stuff. I'm not suggesting at all that you change it, but I've just, today we're just grounding in the basic facts. Any comments on these two or?

53:52 I still think they speak to core vision and mission is, for sure, other than just changing the name. Yeah. I know that it's really fun for someone like me who work with you all and then come back years later and see that I know this work is incredibly hard and you always come up and feel like it's never enough, it's never enough, it's there and the work is here and it's slow, but for me it's fun to come back and see the progress.

54:26 Thank you.

55:16 Thank you.

56:09 Shauna, before you go on, I just want to remind the board if they could please speak into the microphone because those that are online are having difficulty hearing. And Shauna, excuse me, I have someone who has also let me know that they're having some trouble hearing. I just had mine off because I was drinking water. Okay, thank you. I'm just so excited that people online really want to hear us. That's so great. Okay, next slide.

56:44 So this is a little bit small. I apologize for that, but I was just taking what was in the graphic from the 219. So again, at the end of the day, you want to be able to translate what you do to a broader community, right? And so people, as you all know, like when you start, and especially staff, you start talking to people about like deed restrictions and AMI levels and like people just like, what? Right?

57:09 We can all talk about that stuff, which is exciting when you come across people that can talk about like AMI levels and all these things, but for the majority of people, they just want to know, what are you doing about getting people into housing, right? And then your partners want to know, like, what do you do and what do you do compared to the town and what do you do compared to that? And so we kind of last time broke it down and I actually think it's still really great labels. So, you know, Cora, you know, what do we do?

57:38 What's our value? How are we different? So you get people into housing. You keep people in housing. You facilitate and create new housing. You attract capital. So that's the grant. You collaborate to accelerate and bring community voice. I changed community engagement to community voice. So getting people into housing, services, helping. Navigators are always helping people to get into housing, whether it's the...

58:05 The inventory that you have or other housing or naturally occurring, you're brokering and helping people with that. You're advocating and then your down payment assistance to me is really about getting people into housing. You're keeping people in housing. All of the rental assistance work that you did during COVID is like help, you know, that's helping people stay in their housing. You also just, again, services, problem solving, helping people come up with like strategies to help them stay in their houses.

58:35 Managing the deed, that could either be, that could go into either, I was thinking of deed management as sort of like, by you stewarding the deeds, then that house doesn't get lost, right? Yeah, I like the term stewardship. Yeah. Yep. Because I have worked, so again, I worked in Washoe, Tahoe, and they have lost.

59:03 They've lost deed restrictions, right? Like it's, you guys do, and I know when we first, anyway, that's a whole thing, deed stewardship, but, and you do it, and it's incredibly valuable, and I've worked in communities where they're not doing it, and they don't know how many they have, and I know that was a situation, and you might still have that situation, but you have capacity and skills to even understand what those words mean, and that is

59:32 That's pretty far evolution compared to other communities. Did you want to say something, Jennifer? Well, I just don't, I don't, I don't think, yeah, we can't gloss over it. We need to make sure we're talking about it, doing it, highlighting its importance, which you just mentioned, but I was even on a call last week and it came up, like,

59:51 It's a big deal, and it's not like every organization does it, right? A lot of people contract out to other organizations to do the stewardship, so just something to make sure we don't lose sight of, because I think it's easy to be like, oh, we created the home, and there it is, but no, it could go away like that. Yeah, every single community we work in, we always, always, always add, and if we're doing a strategic plan or an action plan, we always put deed stewardship and enforcement.

1:00:20 As an action that if they don't know what it means, then we train them and then we say there's no point in building housing if you don't have someone on the other end managing the deed stewardship because you just end up losing them and all that money and the time to going into creating them is diluted. So I think for Mammoth Lakes Housing or Eastern Sierra Community Housing, it's a bit of a dual role for us. It's not only doing the work but making sure our partners know the importance of it.

1:00:49 And so that they do it. Because I think for me, working at the board level at the county of Mono, you know, that's one of the things that it's like, oh, sometimes people are like, well, we don't want to have to have that ongoing expense. We just want, you know, we want to create the units, but we don't want the ongoing liability to steward these. But we just can't do one without doing the other. So I think some of it is on MLH, too.

1:01:18 to do that work to make sure we educate our partners. Absolutely. Facilitate and create new housing. So that is the conversations that come in. You all get calls from City of Bishop or whoever, like, we have this idea, we want to do this, or we want to do that. And there's conversations around how can we use our existing model to help create solutions throughout the Eastern Sierra. So that is just

1:01:50 Something that happens. Grants, so the funding. Collaborating. Again, sometimes you're sitting down with partners to do the work and sometimes you're just answering a question and then you're bringing community voice. You're known for bringing the Latinx to the process and the go-to for, you know, with the rental assistance and throughout the region. This is from 2018. You might

1:02:19 Consider we might want to update this or consolidate it a little bit, but I wanted to share sort of this was in the plan. I found that in having interviews with all of you, it wasn't the same vocabulary that all of you are using, but you were talking about the work in the boxes. And so it might be helpful as you're going forward and you're building your communications to do that. So any reactions to that? Has anyone seen that before?

1:02:52 I heard Jennifer's point of the deed restriction piece or deed stewardship is a really critical role that you all play. Okay, next slide. So a little bit on your current org chart. So this has to do with the conversation around capacity to do all of this work. I mean, every time we look at what we want to create, we have to right-size it with sort of what is our capacity. So right now the board is...

1:03:25 In charge of this organization, you have an ED, you have a part-time bookkeeper, and then the three of you, right? So this is, I think, the biggest staff you've ever had in the past 10 years, right? So that is amazing. And I know it's recent. It's very recent. And then as we look at, and I know you have, the navigators have very specific roles based on the funding.

1:03:52 And, but as you look at, I wanted to put this up, because as you, as we build the strategic plan, we might want to look at sort of in the next three years, you know, are there some boxes we want to add, or do we need to look at, because at the end of the day, you need the staff to be able to do this work, and so, and that has the same to do with the board as well, and that kind of goes to Tom's point of, this is the time to relook at your kind of roots of your structure.

1:04:22 And do you have the power in the organization? We can think of a lot of things we want to do, but at the end of the day, it's the people and it's the money. And so the board, do you have the right board structure or do you have the right staff structure to do all these amazing things that you know there's a need for? There's no doubt there's a need. And so that's kind of the conversation that this workshop is good for. Do you have any idea? Everyone's so quiet.

1:04:51 There's some pretty big juicy comments that I just said. I mean, staffing, in my opinion, it falls out of our agreed upon strategic goals and objectives, right? And then recognition of where that slots in with existing staffing and then what that would imply for, you know, where we go with our strategic plan and how we can support that knowing what everything else, you know, that we're doing right now and then making sure everything we're doing now is still a priority too, right?

1:05:22 Well, I would just add that, you know, when we talk about growing the org chart, it's not just money, but it's also people and the availability of people and the lack thereof. You know, I think that that's one of the things I've seen folks in this region be challenged with is recruiting for housing roles, whether, you know, at different levels throughout the jurisdictions or even MLH.

1:05:49 been challenged with that, and so it's not just budget, it's also capacity to recruit is a huge challenge, and do we look at remote work, and you know, those are policy decisions that we can contemplate when we get there, but it's a big nut to crack. Yep, yep, that's everywhere. Yeah, sure. Okay, next slide. So we took your budget and just simplified it, because I always find it, you know,

1:06:20 If you don't have a financial background, and your budget is actually really easy to understand, but you're sure somebody's put it into chunks. So it was really easy, but I think when you're thinking about strategy, and you guys already know this, but obviously the town is putting in the way it's always been, which is the town is your largest contract, but you now have two other contracts.

1:06:47 With Mono County and Alpine County for the navigator roles. And then small things like you have your project profit, which is your developer fee piece that you know about. And then a tiny bit on all the other things. I think one of the things that it's actually a great display, I'm glad you did that, because I mean it does kind of when you consider our service area, you know, and Bishop.

1:07:18 Notably not on there. So maybe an area of opportunity to seek a little bit more of an annual funding from those entities to support our efforts, which we have been making specific efforts down in Bishop. So what you're saying is that if you were standing in this room in three years, you would like that pie chart to be equal share from Inyo and Bishop, Inyo County and Bishop, City of Bishop.

1:07:49 It's affordability is an issue down there as well now. It used to be that that was affordable, now it's not. So it's out of reach of most everybody. So again, the need stretches across the entire service area of the tri-counties. I guess just this slide and the previous slide, I don't want to be like Debbie Downer, but you know, we have or I have or I think collectively we have a lot of

1:08:19 Opportunities and we're excited to do a lot of things and the org chart and the budget feels really stifling so I think expanding ongoing sources for admin funds I think is probably a critical piece to that. There's a lot of moving parts I think especially in that part of our service area.

1:09:09 Inyo County recently took over the administration of the Continuum of Care, which is the regional homelessness prevention, and so they have that as an added capacity drain, and then, you know, I have been in conversations with the jurisdictions about the preservation of Valley Apartments and the ongoing need for operating subsidy there, and so those conversations are happening, but very specific and not limited.

1:09:38 Well, I know as one board member, I made an ask that in our budget this year that we look at a contract with MLH because they do provide services, resources to the county, whether all kinds of things, like they'll just call them and be like, oh, what can you tell us about this? And that's a direct ask of information and services. And if we're going to do that, you know, my ask of the county is to

1:10:06 Create some kind of contract of services. It's my understanding that Patricia's been in contact with the DAO, but it's something that I think is a direct need for both entities. It benefits both. Yeah. Yeah, it's a program expense. Yeah, that's a great point. I would like to add, sorry. I know that...

1:12:05 Jennifer talked a little bit about Ineo County, I'm assuming. I'm not sure which county you were referring to. For Mono, right? Okay. So my question was, or not necessarily a question, but more of a comment. We get a lot of people from Ineo County calling our office. We don't have a partnership with them. And I don't know if that's more of Ineo County or is that more on our side for Mono? But I think just kind of building that relationship with Ineo,

1:12:35 If INEO is going to be calling us for either services or just resources, that we have that available to them to deposit into INEO County a little bit since we will be Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Maybe if something is created with one jurisdiction, it could be...

1:12:56 It could be modified and used as a presentation and a conversation with other jurisdictions to, you know, or we're going out scouring for support from everyone. You know, I use the example of when IMACA was failing and they came to all the jurisdictions and asked for a $100,000 grant and everybody gave it to them and, well, how do we do that kind of work to sustain and grow MLHE?

1:13:22 You know, that's the question that I think we need to be discussing as a board and with our partners in the region so that everybody, again, really does win in that kind of scenario. Well, I just want a thought that came to me is, you know, I know for Mono County and I know for, you know, the town which has contracted services with

1:15:55 So it's totally separate than when you think about the counties or the town or the city of Bishop but or Alpine County but this organization is written into their housing elements as providing solutions to their their goals and their plans and their objectives I mean that right there you're saying we need to work with you as a partner and therefore that

1:16:20 You have an invested interest if you're going that far as to putting your planning document, which is codified. So maybe this strategic plan could be a start to, we want to do everything in this plan for us to be able to do it. We have a new budget and it includes more capacity and we would like you to consider helping, being a partner for this. We need 100 from you and we need for the next, and not one year. We need like

1:16:50 Whatever, and 100 is not enough, but you would just take the strategic plan in your new budget and then go out for an ask. And there is something to be said just from the work with those seven public agencies where they are aware of what the other is putting in and there's like a little bit of, I want to be, you know, so that could be, so we're getting into the doing. Well, and I guess one point is that our mission statement does have the term sustainable economy and I think that relates directly back to

1:17:22 Our businesses and their sustainability if they have employees or not. Right. I will make a point because I'm sure some of you have noticed this and you're not maybe saying it is. The line of private donations is very tiny, right? So when we show the pie chart and fundraising here is extremely challenging. I know it was a goal of yours before, but there's just staff capacity to

1:17:53 Do all the work and do all the deals and all the partners. Potentially, you could think about, I have, so I showed you the org chart and then I'm going to show you, you know, an idea of like another box, you know, if you were to expand your capacity, would that free up some senior level person to be able to do more of that, which would be appealing to your partners as far as like long-term sustainability and not.

1:18:19 Signing up to, you know, that everyone's trying to show up at the table to be part of funding this organization. Can I ask a quick question in your other hat that you talked about? The housing hat? Yeah, yeah. You said our operating budget, you mentioned the nut, the number. Is that a typical budget? Is it high? Is it low? In your experience? You mean like $6.46? Yeah.

1:18:50 I don't think your staff's being paid, like, exorbitant salaries. No, I'm just asking, like, the total budget, like, from your experience in looking at other organizations. Yeah. I mean, it's a great question. I think it's in line with our service area, obviously, and I'm sure all that comes into it. Yeah, I mean, it depends. I don't know what people are being paid individually, and then I don't know the inventory of work that you're, I don't have a, I don't know what the day-to-day, like, how much.

1:19:20 There's places that have higher budgets and they have more inventory to manage and they're building, like they might be doing more construction. So I also just worked in Big Sky, Montana. Their budget, I just, they have two staff and I think their budget is similar to yours. But they have the resort tax board and there's just millions of dollars coming into that organization. Yep.

1:19:53 The 501c3 Big Sky Community Housing Trust, and they have the resort tax board, which I think is like, I think it's like, it generates like $25 million a year, and they're, they get, they give out money, and housing is one of the number one priorities there. I mean, it's a town of 2,000. So much money.

1:20:21 Billionaires who live up there. This is a little bit different. Yellowstone Club. Yeah, that's a very interesting place. Yellowstone Club is there. Well, and I don't know, but I think our budget's pretty lean, I think, for the services, the amount of services that we provide and the amount of work that we're doing, because I think we could probably have another full-time person, and that would increase the operating budget. I mean, I think about other, like...

1:20:50 So there's, you know, there's a number of, you know, there's the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, there's the College Foundation, there's a bunch of foundations, there's a community foundation, and so we are a little bit spread thin here in that respect. I think, you know, I think of the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation specifically, their, you know, charges to support, you know, athletics and, you know, snow athletics.

1:21:18 Specifically, they actually do a really good job of an annual fundraising gala event, and they do raise a lot of money through that, but it's like all they do, that's the only thing they do to raise money, and they spend the whole year planning that event, and they do that event, but it takes, there's a full-time executive director and a couple other people to help out, and other assistants as well, so it's a big production to get that thing, it makes a lot of money, but yeah, that's just, I think, the struggle for us, it's like, okay, we're so spread thin to do just,

1:21:48 Normal stuff we're working with. To have a real aggressive, active fundraising leg, it's just, we're supposed to think big, but I don't know, it's a whole other kettle of fish for us at this point. Yeah, I mean, there's four community foundations in Big Sky, and they're really involved with housing, and each of those communities that I've worked in have had really strong community foundations that are involved in community issues.

1:22:22 I've always been really surprised that the community foundation here is still really focused on skiing, because that is a lot of, isn't that mostly second home? And that's just the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, and there's the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, there's several others, but like you said, they all have a specific focus, that's just one. There isn't a community foundation representing all needs.

1:22:52 Well, you know, maybe that's a good point. It's like, you know, maybe that's a little bit more of a political effort to say, okay, let's get all these diverse groups and say, hey, look, why don't we have one foundation for the whole entire community? But that's Mammoth. We're serving the tri-counties, so, you know, where do you go from there? But it's a good point because, you know, everybody's grabbing from the same pot, right? Yeah. So there's, okay, whose mission are we getting, you know, who's sending the email today of what fundraiser they're doing next?

1:23:22 You know, it is pretty scattered. Yeah. Tony, did you have something to say? Yeah, so there's a lot of great ideas bouncing around. My thought is, how do we turn all these ideas, what are we doing right now to build this strategic plan? Yeah, we're going to get to that. That's mostly what we're going to do, but what we're doing in the beginning is just kind of...

1:23:51 Think of us as farmers and we're just tilling the soil right now. Okay. We're just like, we got you guys, we got to sort of like start to think about like, huh, that's, so when I send you off into small groups, because I'm going to stop talking here soon and you're going to work in small groups and you're going to take that draft and you're going to say, I'm going to give you a blank sheet of paper and I'm going to say, okay, so what do you want to do? And so I'm hoping this, these kind of conversations stimulate the groups thinking around like the possibilities. Okay. Yeah.

1:24:20 I realize that, and I have a lot that I want to contribute, but for the sake of time, we could spend three and a half hours, and not to be rude of anybody, but there's a lot of ideas to bounce around, and I love all the ideas, but I'm not writing them down right now. I see a couple people taking notes, but I just want to know how this is.

1:24:49 Going to build into something. Yep. So... Sorry, can I add real quick to what Tony said? So I think, yes, there is a lot of ideas, and even though Altair Mountain, or their community foundation that they have is only for specific needs, it's part of that partnering with the community and those foundations, whereas us as housing navigators, that's what we did. We were able to raise up $30,000 for specific people, sorry, for people who are in financial hardships.

1:25:18 But part of that is the partnering and the linking together of the services we provide with the foundations who have specific requirements, but we can bend them for people in our community. So it's like, they are ideas, we are trying to implement them, it's little by little, but I just want to make it clear, we are partnering as much as we can as housing navigators. So again, we could have, I could have just,

1:25:51 I sent you guys all off, but again, because we have new board members, and we all want to make sure that we have the same song sheet, and we're starting with the same information, but I promise we will be spending most of the time getting into this document and defining what our priorities are based on our current capacity. So part of that, Tony, if you can just bear with me, is I want to play back to you sort of

1:26:20 Before we start moving into the doing, reflecting on sort of what are we doing well, where are our gaps, so that when you're thinking about your plan, you're not sideswiped by like, you know, the realities of sort of areas of gaps, right? So I have like five more or six more slides. So strengths, you guys have a really good reputation and trust, okay? So you are known.

1:26:49 Especially in the Latino community, which is 50% of your community, you're trusted, and that includes both documented and undocumented. That is not something that other people, other organizations can say. And your staff is known and respected, and you have a long-time standing executive director. You're known for being, again, this is what you all said to me when we asked you, what are the strengths? And you all, this is us summarizing that feedback.

1:27:19 You're known for being resourceful, flexible, and responsive. And you have a strong board and effective management. So you're known for sort of managing your affordable housing stock and the lodge. Next slide. Your challenges, and these continue to be, this is both, and not any insult or criticism of Nolan and Sandra.

1:27:51 But, you know, the relationship with the town, there's a lot of cooks in the kitchen. So you all get called about the parcel, people are unclear, the community's a little unclear, you guys all know this, but this just continues to be a challenge of like, what's our role, what's their role, and the community gets confused. Limited community, so that goes to sort of like your strengths, and then also just challenges.

1:28:16 And then you deciding, well, what are we going to do with that moving forward? Are we going to put that in our plan and address it? Or is it just the nature of the conditions and we're just going to, it's a boulder in our river and we're just going to kind of work around it? I did notice on the town's website that they're doing, having an effort of trying to create that clarity, like call MLH for this, this is what we do. And so I do see efforts being made, but it's just going to be a constant thing you're going to need to work on.

1:28:48 So I think that what you all said is that it's sometimes overwhelming. I get stopped in the grocery store and people know there's a major problem and they think we're the ones that we have to solve it all because you have the name Mammoth Lakes Housing or Eastern Sierra Community Housing. So therefore you must be the holder of the entire problem. And you all know that you have a piece of the pie, right?

1:29:16 A problem, and you're doing part of it, and the town's doing part of it, and each, you know, everyone's doing a piece of it, but the community doesn't know that, and so you feel a bit of sort of disconnect between expectations and what you can actually do with your capacity. And then your organizational capacity, just challenge with the need is so high and what you guys can do is limited. Next slide. So future opportunities, what do we want to do moving forward?

1:29:44 There was energy, you know, talking about growing the organization, increasing our staff, trying to get some local sources of funding so we can not be so restricted by some of our grants that require that we work in lower income levels. Obviously, diversifying our funding, finding, re-looking at the, it did get brought up a couple times by, you know, re-looking at the structure of the board.

1:30:11 Bring in a project or construction management on a contract basis. Programs, develop a centralized housing resource center, a single hub for all housing programs, and this kind of speaks to the value to maybe the counties, right? If you are the resource in the region and you sort of package yourself up for that and you're in the housing elements, could that be something valuable to you? And you're doing that a lot already.

1:30:40 Continue to explore funding for creative housing programs, campgrounds, RV spaces, refurbishing old buildings, working with Buckingham properties, you know, the lease to locals program. I know there's something going on at the chamber, so doing more of that. Partnership is a, again, you guys already started to talk about this, but partnerships being something that you really want to start.

1:31:11 You know, continuing to focus on. Next slide. So advocacy, marketing, and outreach. Again, this was something that you talked about at the last time, but, you know, is there, you're sort of, your hands are tied because of the CHOTA and also with your contracts with the regulatory agencies. So it's not really good form to sort of show up at a county commissioner or town council meeting.

1:31:43 And advocate for a policy, right? That's always been the tension of this organization, right? You might, so there's no inclusionary housing policy in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And yet, what if this board decides that that's something they think is really valuable to moving solutions forward? So what do you do in that situation to advocate for a policy change that goes against the town? So what do you do now? Nothing. You don't do that, right?

1:32:25 I'm not saying, I'm not advocating for you guys to do it, I'm just saying it's an inherent, I'm just naming like the inherent tension that you have through your relationship with your contracts and like a traditional non-profit housing organization does advocacy work, but you guys have to sort of like do that. It's true and I find myself holding my tongue at town council meetings because I know I'm representing

1:32:52 Mammoth Lakes Housing, so I don't want to create any bad vibes, but I also feel like I'm representing as a low-income community member who's living in an apartment 50 miles away and finding myself working up here, part-time, seasonal positions. Right, right. I mean, I think that we need to find a way to communicate to the town council.

1:33:21 The shortfalls in our housing and what other towns are doing to solve that with regards to STRs and everything. I think that Patricia has a wealth of knowledge and how do we kind of inform the council of the difficulties that we're facing and possible solutions that would work for our town. Wouldn't a possible solution look like what other nonprofits do when it's time to

1:33:51 Lobby. They have a separate pot of funds that they use for that, right? I'm thinking of like CCRH, I'm on their board, and there's a lot of funding that we can't use to advocate for bills and legislature, but we do have a lobbyist that we hire, but it's a certain pot of funds that we use specific for that. I mean, potentially, maybe something like that could be designed if that's an important...

1:34:20 You mean like a 501c4 or something, like an arm? Yeah. Yeah. I don't think you need a separate arm. I mean, that's not my experience at CCRH. We don't have a separate arm. It's within the regular budget. It's just we can't use certain funding for that. So I was in a situation similar to you all where I ran a housing coalition and the funders were the town and everybody.

1:34:53 So what we did is, and the community foundation was the fiscal agent, and they had a very strict no advocacy policy, but I was allowed to go to town council and do exactly what you just said, which was, there would be a project, and I couldn't advocate for a project, but I could go and say, I just want to remind you all that there is a huge waiting list, and there's a huge need, and this project appears to be sort of addressing that. I'm not here to advocate for that.

1:35:22 That being said, we also did white papers. So we would do educational workshops and research on a policy topic and then share that information. So it would be on short-term rentals. We did it. We brought all the data together. And then our committee made recommendations of ways that it could be addressing the solution. And the staff used that, the staff at the town.

1:35:50 You know, when you're at the town and you have to do a staff report, you have to do a lot of research, put it all together, and if an outside organization already did the research and you can attach it to your staff report, that is really a great partnership. Because you've done all the research of like, here's the 10 communities that have done things about short-term rentals, and this is our view from, as Eastern Sierra Community Housing on this topic, and then staff can use that as a tool.

1:36:19 For moving a conversation forward. It's just another way that's not necessarily in, you know, advocacy, adversarial, but it's a role, potentially. So I'm just putting, and then another thing, I've seen nonprofits that have to tiptoe around advocacy, is they're just very clear about, let's just say it's a topic inclusionary. I'm not saying, whoever's on the line listening, we're not saying we're moving inclusionary housing forward.

1:36:51 But let's just say inclusionary housing is something that you all think proves to be useful in other communities. So you pick like three policy topics that you would like to have conversations around. And maybe it's inclusionary housing. And then you talk about like what are your, what are you, you create a advocacy matrix. So you educate, shape.

1:37:23 Advocate. Okay? And you say, okay, we're going to take on three topics this year or in the next three years. Inclusionary housing. Our role in this is we're going to do education and that's all. That's what we're going to do. So that your partners are very clear on what your role is. You didn't check the box that said, like, we're going to show up and try to push it through, but we're going to try to raise the conversation up because we'd like to have that conversation. Because I think last time in 2018 we just...

1:37:55 We didn't touch that area because we didn't want to touch it. I'm just saying if you, I know that it is a potential role and how do you work around that role. Okay, so next slide. So I just want, these are my last slides. These are just reminders of that whole, there's many swim lanes. You're not the only game in town. There's a lot of cooks in the kitchen. That is fabulous. Are you all working together? Sometimes. Is the community confused? Yes.

1:38:28 All the community cares about is that at the end of the day, people are staying in their house, new units are being created, and it's confusing when there's all these different players. So this is just the facts, and I'm just stating the facts. So you have the chamber. I don't know what's happening with their program, but this is on their website. So from an outside perspective, you have other people doing this work. So next slide. This is in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:38:55 And they're on their website, you guys already know this, but again, they are also, and you know, much to Sandra and Nolan's credit, they're doing, you know, I remember when Nolan first started, and I was just starting, and it's amazing to see the work, so you have great, you have increased capacity, you know, all tide, what is it, all tides float, all boats, what's the, what's the? Rising tide, raising tides. Raises all ships.

1:39:24 Raises all ships, right? So this is a great thing. It's just, and I know that Patricia and Nolan, there's a lot of, with the town and with your organization, there's like, we're here in the chamber, there's a constant, but, you know, the question is, as you move forward and create your plans, this still is the conditions that you're working in. Yeah, I guess from a staff perspective, I think.

1:39:53 This is one of the challenges we face on a daily basis. The community assumes we are doing all of these things. And so I think we struggle with communicating what our role actually is in some of these projects and how we are helping maybe some of these projects. There's a lot of gray area for the community at large. And I think when people come in and say, what's going on with the parcel? And we're like, we have no idea.

1:40:21 You know, we don't have, like, an elevator pitch about what to say. Yeah. Or, here's the phone number. So, I just think we struggle with that every day. Yep. You know, I mean, call a spade a spade. I mean, you know, the town collects the tax revenues, right? I mean, they have the T.O.T. That's basically the slush fund that's bought the parcel. It's providing the gap funding for that, that facilitated the private affordable housing developer to come in.

1:40:53 Mammoth Lakes Housing, you know, we don't have those revenue sources. So, you know, we certainly, I think, continue to be a partner in that. And the council's discretion was they wanted to pursue that, you know, through their means. So anyway, it's interesting, you know, but at the end of the day, it's, you know, they have the pot of money and we don't. And, you know, they give us money to do the services we provide with a very focused list of services that we do provide through our contract.

1:41:23 But, you know, I mean, to our, to Patricia's credit and the board and so forth, you know, the opportunity of Innsbruck, for example, was something that was, you know, brought to us and that we've taken, you know, through the steps to, to implement it. And so, so in any event, it's, you know, those are the, those are the challenges and I, you know, I think it's, it is, you know, particularly in the Parcel, it's a very confusing thing to the community for sure.

1:41:50 Yeah, and I think I just meant like as a communication strategy or how do we better inform the public of what we can do or what we are doing instead of what we're not doing. Yeah, yeah. I think it's kind of a yes and. I mean, it's great that there's lots of people working on this issue throughout the community.

1:42:12 And I think you're right, whoever said it, at the end of the day, the public just wants to make sure that there's units, new units coming online, people are staying in their homes, and that when an employer posts a job listing, they get at least, you know, 10 applicants that have a home already in Mammoth, or can get a home in Mammoth, because, you know, that's that part about the, or in the region, excuse me, but really that's the...

1:42:38 The economic part of it. So I don't think we're that unusual. I mean, look at the state of California. They have seven different entities that fund affordable housing, and it's a real mess. So we're just par for the course. I mean, I was just going to add. So, yeah, a lot of people are doing or do have their own homeless or housing program, but it just doesn't seem like that's their focus. Like, for example, Chamber of Commerce, they're not really focused on housing. They do have a housing.

1:43:09 element to it, but that's not their focus, so I just think the funds that are being used for them, you know, could go to some other entity like us that were housing focused and let them handle the chamber part of it or the commerce part of it. And I think Patricia mentioned this earlier, but to that end, we spend a lot of time.

1:43:33 Helping people with other programs, and I think that that can be somewhat problematic in that sense because we're not receiving those funds at all. So there's countless times where I've helped people call the parcel or call separate housing programs, and I feel like we're not really focusing on Mammoth Lakes Housing and our services sometimes. Like, my hands are really tied some weeks. And if we're...

1:43:56 Bringing up staff capacity, which we are a lot, then to me that's an issue that our staff that comes out of our budget are not prioritizing or not able to and not focusing on our programs because they're dealing with other partners' programs that they're trying to communicate, educate, whatever, spread the word, but it's all good information and that's good for the community, but it's maybe not so good for

1:44:21 For our priorities. And I think just to the point of what you said, Eric, I, you know, yes, what was it, the strong tides bring ships up, whatever the saying was. Rising tides. Rising tides. Rising tides. So, and it's all going to the same goal, but I agree that it's very disjointed and there doesn't seem to be a lot of alignment or

1:44:48 strategic vision in the planning process of, okay, this organization is going to do that. This organization is there to do that, there to serve, there to, you know, focus on this. Oh, and let's just throw the chamber in there as well. Like, it just doesn't, you know, that's not this board or this organization's issue, but could we play a bigger role in actually trying to bring it together a little bit more? I think Tony was next, and then we'll go to you.

1:45:18 Still think that we're entitled to a stake in the parcel. I'm still upset that we weren't given a stake in it. And personally, if I were a staff member and people were calling me about it, I'd say, sorry, not my problem. She's got other things to do. Give them the phone number and end the conversation right there. And that's not fair to the community. But at the same time, it's not fair to us to...

1:45:46 Dedicate so much resources to something that we're getting nothing in return other than just the humble feeling in our hearts that we're meeting the same goal. Right. Yeah, that's a tough one. Brian? I was just going to say, building on the conversation about the number of different actors, and we're one actor of multiple actors on this housing crisis issue, and there's this

1:46:14 There's this whole world and literature around this concept of collective impact, which is kind of this practice of different players coming together to solve problems that no one agency organization can solve on their own. Homelessness is a good example of this. Housing is a good example of this. And one of the conditions of successful collective impact initiatives is the notion of a backbone organization, an organization that holds everyone together.

1:46:41 Everyone commits to communication, everyone having clarity of role and purpose, clarity of mission, shared measurement. There's five or six conditions of collective impact. I'll share one of the articles about it, but what I'm hearing is that maybe right now, you know, there's probably five or six agencies here in town that are playing some type of a housing role, the county, chamber, town, us, right, the mountain.

1:47:10 But who is holding it all together? Who is the backbone of that larger effort? I'm not suggesting that MLH should be the backbone, but that could be perhaps a conversation. Because I think it is confusing. And again, I think that's all this conversation is really focused within Mammoth, right? The town of Mammoth is really what we're talking about. So again, part of me is like, to Jennifer's point, it's like...

1:47:38 It is what it is, right? So I don't know that we need to waste a lot of energy, you know, expressing sour grapes about, oh, we should be on point for all this stuff. But at the end of the day, you know, we need to move forward, seek opportunities. You know, we're serving the, you know, all three counties. There's, you know, funding out there that can be utilized in all these communities. And again, you know, Tony, you live down in Bishop. I mean, I've lived down south.

1:48:06 County before I, you know, for many years I lived out of town and I've got plenty of other friends and people, associates that will live down in Bishop that work at the mountains. So it's, again, it's, you know, I think for me it's sort of, you know, a lot of that just depends on the political leadership and that's where things are now. There's probably a lot of things potentially, you know, opportunities for evolution in the coming year or so with some big moves in higher

1:48:36 Leadership positions within the town, the county, so, you know, who knows where things will evolve, but I think we just need to always be a willing partner is the most important thing and make the effects where we can, certainly, and I think we've made progress in that respect in the last couple years. That's why I think my, one of my strongest goals for this strategic plan is to become less reliant on our contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes and

1:49:06 Do as much as we can for ourselves and feel like the less reliant we are on that Town of Mammoth Lakes contract, the more we can do for ourselves and the less sour grapes we'll have about not having a role in these other projects that are leading to the same goal. So I just want to go back to that. So thanks all for those comments. So I think what to clarify this back to if you put the community at the center, right?

1:49:37 Because we're all, everybody's trying to serve, right, the community, and we have these different organizations who are doing it. I think what we were talking about, not just, we're not trying to focus on Mammoth Lakes town, we're just talking about you all being a region, and there's every, there's all these different entities doing a little piece of it, and the community at the end of the day just wants to know, like, roll it all up and just tell me, like, what the dashboard is.

1:50:05 They don't really care exactly who's doing it. They just want to know, like, oh, 80 over there and 20 over there and there's that available and I know there's a great place I can call and they provide services in English and Spanish. And so this is a collective impact model that I worked on for three years and there are 25 partners. I know I've talked to some of you about this, but the point is that there's 25 partners. You can't see this very well, but it was the city and the towns and the

1:50:35 PUD and the ski areas and all sorts of different throughout the whole Tahoe Truckee region. And this project for three years under the community foundations, we did nothing. We did no programs. We did no housing building. We just, every quarter I would collect everybody's information and then we would share out what everybody, all those things were like.

1:51:00 These guys are doing four units, and the grocery outlet has three apartments because of the inclusionary requirement, and on the back side were our goals. So we're trying to build 300 units in three years and raise $10 million and whatever. We had like five metrics. And then my job as the project manager is to roll all this up and then push it out in a really simple way so that

1:51:27 The people there could share it with their boards and their staff and we could share it with the media and then in the community and it would highlight the roles of those individual partners. So each person got, each entity got credit. Nobody was trying to like wipe us, you know, wipe it and take credit, though I got pushback that Mountain Housing Council was trying to take credit. But if you look, it was like the town did 50 and Placer County did 70 and

1:51:56 These guys did their little thing. They changed their fee schedule. The Squaw Valley Public Utility District changed their fee schedule. Yay, that makes it easier for developers. And so they did their piece. And so that's, I think, what Brian's talking about is, and we talked about this before, when there was a comment in there on, like, what could we be in the future? And this all ties to, like, if we're trying to...

1:52:23 Create a value to some of these other funders of what we're going to do. I'm not trying to add, I'm sure Patricia's having a heart attack over here. But, I know, I know. But, if you got $300,000 more from, I don't know, each of the, collectively from the counties, and you could say, you show them a tool that says, we're going to start doing this and bringing, maybe it's twice a year.

1:52:51 And you're bringing everyone together to kind of talk about like, okay, chamber, you got 70, you're placing 70 people in your houses. So then it becomes less of, gosh, the chamber is annoying. They're doing what was told, they were, you guys, don't forget, there was a housing action plan, and they took, there was a column that said the chamber should take that job, and MLH should do that, and the town should do that, and everyone's kind of doing what they were asked to do.

1:53:18 And it never was envisioned that you all were going to do everything. But what's missing is nobody's, just like Brian said, the goal was that you all were going to start getting together quarterly to talk about what you're each doing and then roll it up into some summary of what your collective results have. And that's the part that you haven't done. And so now it's resulted is, why are they doing that and they're doing that? Because there's no summary of what everyone's doing. And so then it's confusing.

1:53:48 Right? So, and you're just never going to get to, even the town with their, no one is ever going to get down the road as far as you want to go unless you're all doing a piece of the pie. Right? And so. They all need to row in the same direction. They need to row, yeah. Somebody needs to take on that job. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, this was. I think it happens. It just happens in a disjointed way.

1:54:18 Because the town council meets with every one of those entities, right? But not collectively. There's not a collective get-together with the chamber and MLH and the all-around housing and the mountain and all. All the players don't come together and have a conversation or share a document. It's just these sidebars.

1:54:42 So I want to tell you guys, that exact document, so that was copied by like three communities. I've shown that, and they're copying it. You can just write it in PowerPoint. So the point being that you have, before we talked about this, we talked about the 2018 strategic plan, and it felt uncomfortable because you guys were like, well, how can we collect up all the information from the region if we're Mammoth Lakes Housing?

1:55:11 We're like really Mammoth Lakes focused. But you've changed your name and you now have these relationships and these contracts. No one else is better suited to do it. So when we're talking about roles and what you're best at and what no one else is doing, no one else can do that. The town of Mammoth Lakes cannot create a regional dashboard of what's happening with housing. The counties are not going to do that. You guys are suited and it's valuable and it's...

1:55:38 Potentially shows what you already do behind, you already do it. You already do all that work. Patricia's already talking to all those people. Well, in all fairness, Shauna, I mean, MLH has been a chodo serving Alpine in Yomono County since like 2013. That's why the Eastern Sierra has always been, since you were here in 2019 or 18, that's why that's, that's not a new concept. The name change is catching up with reality. Correct. Yeah.

1:56:07 But I think even in 2018, we talked about this, and, you know, the dragon or the lighter or whatever I had at that meeting didn't want to sit around and have more meetings or do data collection, right? We wanted to do things, and we've done a lot, and we've grown a lot, and maybe now it's time to think about having meetings and doing data collection, but also we have all this other stuff on our plate now.

1:56:45 So then, yeah, I think that's it on the slide. Yeah, so, no, no, so, so this is what, yeah. I'm trying to think about how you guys get more money from the count, make a case for value for the work you already do that is, it's a fundraising strategy too. It's not just more meetings and data collection. It, it, I'm not saying it didn't take me a lot of work, but it was, you don't have to have 25 partners. It could be like six phone calls and

1:57:18 You can ask Eric to do that, and you just say, hey, you know, tell me what you've done in the last, I would send them an email and say, please just fill out the survey with your results, and it never worked, so I had to call them, which is fine, because it's relationship, and I would get that information, and then I would put it into that dashboard, and so. Yeah, I mean, that's like something that we already did. We were starting to talk to Chamber of Commerce, see what their program was, where we could help them. The only problem was that.

1:57:48 You know, not to badmouth them, but they didn't really know the specifics of their own data, so it was kind of hard to get around that. But, I mean, yeah, it's something that definitely we could do. It seems possible and easy to do. I'm just saying that all those partners, 15 of them put money in and they use the dashboard to go to their board to ask for the money. So it's just a tool for showing the collective impact that you're measuring.

1:58:17 You don't have to do it. I'm just, it just, based on some of the things you guys want to do and the challenge of fundraising and, you know, going, making a case to the other city and the other county for, like, what your role is and, you know, for my role today of, like, this, maybe something to think about your role is holding, being the holder of, and I just be careful about the word data because I am not a data person and I put that document together.

1:58:48 So it would be things like the North Tahoe PUD is looking at their land to potentially create employee housing. And we would be like, good for you, great, we're putting it down in print because you said you might start to do something. Right? So, okay. This is my last slide. So, again, in my conversation with Patricia and looking forward and also the realities of

1:59:19 One of the key foundational questions after the break we're going to talk about is when I was here in 2018, the board said, grow. We really want to grow. And it was a very ambitious strategic plan and staff just like went for it. You have three new staff. You've done a lot. And now you're at this point where I think Patricia said it at the start of this meeting is like it's not really sustainable at this current level.

1:59:48 As far as impacts on staff. And so direction on staff, excuse me, from the board, are we, you know, we grew? Are we going to stay like this for the next three years? Or is the next, are you giving guidance that I need to keep pushing? And if we're going to keep pushing and growing, then we need to start thinking about more money and more capacity to do that. And what does that look like? Because sometimes you can talk about things like,

2:00:15 More staff, or whatever. And so I asked, Patricia, like, specifically, you know, between the three staff you have and then your role, what's going on and what is that? If you could dream the dream and have the money today, what parts could you, you know, to help staff thrive and, like, do the things you do? And so we played around with the idea of a director of operations. Could you get that person? Could you afford it? I don't know. But just for you all to think about.

2:00:44 The next three years and supporting the staff you have, you know, that's what we played around with. I don't know if now is the time, but at some point I'd be curious to hear about the thought behind that whenever the right time is. Do you want to speak to that before we go on break? What can I say about that? Well, Shauna asked me what we needed and I think it would be

2:01:18 Well, I guess it depends. And that's why I said I think vision and direction from the board is really important for the strategic plan because I'm going to keep pushing and growing and doing more if you don't tell me to stop. So if we want to do that and I need to know that, we can't do it with what we have. And so I think that that person would be support for me on things like operational things like

2:01:46 The budget's an example. I'm great at the budget, but it takes a lot of time, someone to collaborate with, bounce ideas off of, share that responsibility. Maybe that could be a board member, right, but we don't operate in that way today. But also things just like insurance policies for our properties, annual tax exemption documents, like things that just like fall through.

2:02:16 Or just get in my inbox, right? Like things that are really important that aren't getting the attention because I'm in meetings or I'm asking for money or I'm strategizing the next move. So those are some examples, but I think there's probably more we could add to that. But those were some thoughts that came to mind. I mean, I asked her yesterday and we just started to play around with it. So this isn't like a deeply thought out. It's just more of like presenting something to the board so you had something a little bit more.

2:02:46 Concrete to think about. Or the dashboard, the collective impact dashboard. Yeah. But I do want to just say that I feel like the board has been pretty unified in saying, whoa, don't take that on. We don't have capacity. Or, hey, do you? Who's going to do that? I feel like those questions come up. So I would just...

2:03:19 Counter a little bit that we're not like, yeah, go, go, go. I mean, I think we are trying to gauge capacity. I think we're very cognizant of it. So I just, I want to make sure that you're hearing what I'm hearing. But I think that's a great input. And, you know, I think it's a way for us to look at, okay, you know, where do we want to go over the next three years and capacity like, you know, like an assistant ED or something of that nature or.

2:03:49 Something. I think it's a great food for thought. I appreciate it. Yeah, and I think to go back to the, I'm obviously fixated on this, but going back to the ask, you know, going and asking the missing county in the city for ongoing operational funds to support this organization, having something, making a case for, like, capacity and having a budget, like, what are you going to ask for? Like, as is, or?

2:04:20 And saying, like, we really want to be able to serve the full range of needs in the county and be able to be pulling together in one cohesive way once a year the summary of results. And to do all that, we're going to need to increase our budget and we're asking for everyone to chip in. And so that's all tied in with that whole, right, yeah. And if they say no, they say no. But, like, you have an exciting ask versus, like, will you fund what we're already doing?

2:04:51 On that note, we are going to take a break, and then we are all going to be all about you guys doing the work, starting to set priorities. Yeah, awesome, thank you. So we're going to take a recess, or a short break, and we're going to go into recess, and then we're going to break up into small groups, and there'll be a staff person assisting each group, and then Shawna and I will float, I think, are we doing three groups? Yeah, three groups, so, and we'll be in recess, and then after the group.

2:05:22 Exercise is done. We'll come back from recess. I think she'll explain it when we get back. I'm going to work on that in the break. We're going to come back in 10 minutes. So 5.20. Is that the right time? Okay. So I just thought dinner, is it showing up here? Yeah. Okay. Great. 10 minutes. Okay. So before we break up into these are the three groups. So there's the bear group, the coyote group, and the eagle group.

2:18:08 Right now, we're going to move into the actual existing strategic plan. There's six strategic focus areas. So your group, I'm just telling you this now because if you know that that's your group, I'm going to do a quick run through on the screen of the actual strategic plan so that when you go into your groups, you've had a briefing of it. Okay, so...

2:18:34 So to Tony's point, if you are, so Tom and Sarah and Olya, you guys have to go, when you go into your small groups, you are going to be tasked with focusing on focus area one and two and going through all those objectives and the goals and having discussion and updating that. So when I go through this, you should pay particular attention to the conversation that happens around your focus area and taking those notes with you into the small group.

2:19:07 No, you're not going to rotate. There's not enough time. So what we're going to do is we're going to work in small groups on each of you are going to get two focus areas, and then we're going to come back, and you're going to share out your suggested edits, and then everybody will be able to provide some comments on that. If you look at that focus area, I mean, Patricia came up with these groupings based on knowing all of you.

2:19:39 If there is a particular focus area that you want to be in, I don't know them off the top of my head, but you're just like, I really want to be in programs, or I really want to be in whatever, we'll do that. So I'm assuming, and you guys can, that it would be helpful to have a briefing on the actual strategic plan, do a walkthrough together for clarification, instead of just sending you into small groups.

2:20:10 Are you asking us? Yes, I'm asking you. Well, I mean, you have it here, so I think it's pretty, so. But you've been on the board a long time, so. Right, and you helped do that one. So I guess, like, I'm looking at the new board members. Would it be helpful if I put this up on the screen and I sort of just walk through the thinking of it so you understand how we got to it? Like, 10, 15 minutes? Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. All right. So I'm going to do that.

2:20:42 And what we're going to do is I'm going to do a run through. This is going to be kind of like getting ready for finals. Then you're going to go in your small group. You're going to grab dinner and then go in your small groups and work on your particular focus area and then be prepared to report out. So I'm going to give you a piece of poster paper. And I want you to put focus area objectives, goals, objectives. You can use this strategic plan as a reference. You can move it over exactly. You can start fresh.

2:21:12 Now everybody knows that you're looking at that closely. Okay. So can everybody see this? Okay. So blah, blah, blah, the same part. So this is the strategic focus areas. There's six of them that we created last time. So here's my question for you. Do we still, and I guess I would ask, in general, was this strategic plan

2:21:59 The right size for this organization? Was it too little, too much? Because this is the time to have an overarching comment around, like, it was too ambitious and we never got to, like, 30% of it, so can we please only have four focus areas? Or is there a focus area you're just not doing anymore? So they are build and facilitate community housing. So here's my question. Are you building?

2:22:30 Are you going to build? I know this is a big question. I remember you, Tom. I remember this conversation. Because we were all fired up about building. Oh, so I have this mic on. So here's my question is, for the group that is in charge of strategic focus area one, or A, would you change that to facilitate community housing? And sometimes, I don't want you guys to create a strategic plan where every day you wake up and go,

2:22:58 We said we were going to do that. We're not doing it. We're falling short. Like, let's be aspirational, but pragmatic. So, I mean, to that specifically, I think we are. I mean, we got Innsbruck going, and we actually are, and we're actively trying to get another development off the ground. So, I very much feel of what we are, continuing on that. Yeah. I guess I just want to stop. Oh, I'm sorry.

2:23:25 Use your mics, guys. Yeah, I just want to say that I came on the board in 2019 or 2020, I think it was 2019, yeah, and we were doing like a one-year review, I think, of the strategic plan, and I felt like there was a bunch that we were like, no, we're not doing that, we're not going to focus on that. We kind of tabled a bunch of stuff because it was just too much, too much for our little staff, too much that we weren't.

2:23:50 We really just, we had to prioritize because we just couldn't do it all. So I feel like there was a time when we, and maybe that was the last time we reviewed it, Patricia, because that was right before the pandemic. And it was just, it was a little too far reaching. So that, so based on that sentiment, I don't know if anyone else, Kirk, you were there, Tom, you were there. I mean, I guess the way I feel about it is I believe everything that is on there.

2:24:20 is relevant to what we aspire to do, and therefore, I like to see it on there, but I do think we need to make a prioritization of what we can achieve. Okay. So, thank you. So, when you, Kirk, did you want to add anything? Okay. So, when you go into small groups, you have permission to get rid of some stuff. So, based on what the collective group is saying, when you go into your small groups, think about that.

2:24:51 And really try to be like, these are the essential things. We want to be aspirational but pragmatic and reference this, but consider if there's something on there that you say, that must have been a great idea in 2018. We did not touch it. I don't even know what it means. Do not move it over to the new plan. I don't want to limit ourselves to what we think we can achieve currently, but strategize on how we can achieve what we want to, what it's going to take to get there, not just

2:25:22 We don't, we can't do that now. Don't worry about it. We want to do this. What is it going to take to get there? Absolutely. So I'm going to keep the six. So if you look at the screen, there's six strategic, the strategic plan, I'm proposing you do not change the structure. This is just an update. We're not creating a new one. So you created a good enduring structure. There's six strategic focus areas.

2:25:49 That's reasonable. And then there's underneath each one, there's goals and objectives. All you guys need to focus on today in your small groups is, is this the right goal statement? And are these the right objectives to get there? Okay? And then you're going to bring that back and share that. You're going to reference this, use a big piece of poster paper to update.

2:26:18 Your two focus areas, the goals and the objectives in those. And then you're going to share that back with the large group for additional feedback. So even though you're not touching all six strategic focus areas and you're honing in on two, you are going to ask, you're going to get feedback from the group. So you will have a chance to touch the different ones. So this one was about, there was a lot of conversation at the last one about

2:26:44 Build and facilitate community housing and at that point we didn't have a metric because there was a desire to do additional work. We were talking about development rubrics. I can't 100% remember what that was. I don't know if you guys did that. But we were trying to get to a number like in five years we're going to create 300 units and we couldn't do it at that particular meeting and so it was a follow-up item based on adding up

2:27:14 All of the different inventory of the different projects you were touching. And I would say great aspiration didn't really go that way, so maybe that group doesn't keep that in there. So Patricia went through this and added some results from 2019, just so you know what's already in the work. I think there's stuff missing, like pursuing development opportunities. You could probably put specific projects in there.

2:27:49 I'm just going to read these. Pursue development opportunities. Collaborate with regional partners. You might, you know, to reach goals. Create strategy to engage the development community. Identify, does anyone have questions, and if you have questions, ask me, especially for those who are assigned to this area. If you don't know, this is a clarifying. But we put people in your group that have the history, and we're going to float around. So for the...

2:28:18 Real estate development, obviously Brian's the expert on that subject, so are we, is he assigned to a different focus area for a specific reason? That's one topic I'm most passionate about, and I'd love to contribute, but I think he'd be more valuable contributing to that, and there's, I don't know, at least one out of every group that I'm super passionate about, but

2:28:49 I personally think his expertise would be valuable in that subject, if you don't mind me saying that, Brian. No offense, Tom. I mean, don't forget, you're just going to be in this group for about 45 minutes, and then the whole group's going to chime in, and then you're going to look at it as a whole board and, like, really dive into it. So it's just, it doesn't mean people aren't going to have impact on it, but if you guys want to do that.

2:29:21 Well, and I think it was less about who has the most experience with each focus area and more about interacting with people that maybe you don't always get to interact with. Yeah, that's what it's about. So there was, I don't know why, Tom, I'm just remembering our conversation. I think I was in your group for this, but there was a whole strategy about to develop, like, proactively. So you guys are, you are, I'll just say this. I'm going to step over in the hat, the hat about, you know.

2:29:52 Facilitator and then knowing you guys a little bit. So you are responsive. You get calls and you respond. This was about you all being very proactive, like doing a land inventory and then trying to figure out identifying sites and then getting developers to be interested in things. So this was coming up with some proactive role for you.

2:30:22 And Brian, if you wanted, do you have anything to add to that? I mean, do you think that's a helpful strategy? Or, like, for the group that's going to go off and do that, this is the time to be like, yes, that is a great thing, or that's not a good role for us, or... I definitely... Yeah. Not to dwell on this one too much, but I definitely have ideas on this, so... Yeah. Is this your group? Yeah. Oh, great. Okay. So we're going to keep that, and then Brian...

2:30:58 Did I cut you off? Okay, so when we come back, you can chime in. Okay, funding, you guys are always doing that. So then now we're into focus area two, grow housing programs and services. So you're already doing that. So manage the housing loan program, grow your deed restriction program, provide property management services. There was an idea back then to sort of be...

2:31:24 Have a revenue stream where you would offer your own property management services to other property managers as a way to generate revenue. I don't know. I don't think that went anywhere. So just if that grew. Exactly. Okay. Take it off. Add something else. Provide educational referral services to match and keep people in housing. That's all the stuff you're already doing. There was another goal, a rehab loan, long-term rental inspection program.

2:31:54 Did that never happen? Right. Okay, so for the people in that group, you could remove it, do something else. Eric, you are in that group. Eric, you are in this group, so if you have new ideas. Isn't Eric in this? Okay. Eric's in three and four with me. Okay. He's in the last one. Okay. Well, you can chime in later. So this is, so up here, yeah, you'll have a chance. So goal two under this, we talked, I remember, it's all coming back to me.

2:32:26 Ideas. We talked about, like, setting up a whole arm of creating a mission-driven property management service model. Yeah, looked into it. So, again, would that be valuable to your partners? Partner to build employee-employee online matching program. That's kind of what the chamber's doing. You guys can decide. Okay, now we're on focus area three. Foster collaboration and partnerships.

2:32:54 One goal is to strengthen relationship with partners in order to get work together to create housing. So create tool to clarify and solidify partnership and collaboration. So that's where we were talking about the tool, which was the dashboard, right? So that's still there. Create a work plan and strategic plan. Expand your reach in the region. You're doing that. Okay. Then focus area four, funding.

2:33:20 You set a goal to raise $20,000 in five years from private donations. Looks like $70,000 came in. So work with fund development, you're doing a lot of that. I don't know, what does ESCH mean? We keep using it? Oh, great. It all got changed, right? I thought it was the matrix. Raise funds for, yeah, raise money. You're doing that.

2:33:50 Okay, focus area five, communications and outreach. A marketing plan, website, roadshows and coffee talks, serve the Latino community, that was a big focus. Focus area five, strengthen organizational capacity. Board committees, annual board governance, topic calendar, strategic topic board calendar. There was a, I'm reminding you all that

2:34:20 Staff, supporting staff.

2:34:51 Coordinate with the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Housing Coordinator, Performance Reviews, Grant Fund, Intern Positions. Obviously, the people in this group are going to have to redo the goals, objectives, because you've done a lot of it. Internal systems, database for deed restrictions, homebuyer assistance loans. Any updates on that? No, a database for managing that stuff. We're working on it.

2:35:25 Yes, it's in, we have it. Okay. I am using this one, yeah. There was an online housing application intake form. That was a, well, so the question is, do you, can you speak to that? I think we, I think we want to do more on the internal systems, but that is an area that we don't have a lot of time to spend on or funding allocated for outside consultants.

2:36:01 But you would love to have something like that? I think we would. I think we need it. Okay. And what about online rental payment? I think that's sort of all part of it. Okay. Okay. So if whoever's in that group, don't get rid of that. Well, you tell me in that moment. Yeah. Yeah. Does anyone have any clarifying questions? It's pretty straightforward. So how do we break out? Are we going to different rooms? Okay. So how you're going to break out is...

2:36:33 You are going to grab your dinner. Yes. And you're going to find a spot with your, we have to have, we have to have one group stay here so that they're on the camera or something like that? Yes. But mics will be off. Okay, so Patricia's not in a group. She's a floater. So she can, if there's questions, we kind of put new board members with older board, you know, long-standing board members mixed together for the context. But a couple things when you go into your small groups.

2:37:04 Use the strategic plan as a reference, not as like, you don't have to like cut and paste it, unless it's something you think is like, that needs to happen, let's keep doing it. This is a time for new ideas. Remember Tony's idea, this is a time for innovation. And then aspirational, and then check with like capacity. And then remember in the back side of this, don't worry about, just get the ideas down, and then what's going to happen.

2:37:35 It's going to be like, okay, well, we can't do it all in the next six months. I love that idea, but let's put it in, like, year three. And then staff can be like, oh, okay, we're not losing that idea. We're just going to, like, right-size it. So here's what I want you to do in your small groups. Okay, I'm going to give you an example. Each group's going to get, I want one of these sheets for a focus area. So you can do it like this. I'm going to say,

2:38:12 So the goal is where you're trying to get to. The objective is the steps to get there. So try not to have 10 of them. You don't have to be like, change the form. Don't go into that level of detail. So goal. And then I would say, if you can add, if you have time,

2:38:49 This would be really helpful for when we fill this out is time frame. So you would say this objective would be year one. This objective here would be this is like a year two or year three. So we're going to do a three year time frame. So one piece of paper, one poster per focus area. And your small group has to do this exercise twice. If you have other ideas when you're brainstorming,

2:39:35 I wouldn't worry so much about like, oh, we really love that idea. I'm not sure if it's an objective or what. We can deal with the notes. We just want to collect all of your ideas when we leave this room and then we're going to make sausage and put it into that strategic plan framework and then spit it back to you and you're going to see everyone's ideas and be like, oh, let's adjust that or what does that mean or let's add some more detail. This is just the first phase of it. Yes. How specific do you want the objectives to be?

2:40:08 Medium. Kind of just like summing it up in like a sentence of what it is. I would say I would prefer a little more specificity than you have in there right now. Like create an online, you know, like I would say like it would be helpful to say things like identify software for managing deed restrictions. I don't know.

2:40:40 This, again, first step, and we can add more specifics later, so most important is getting your ideas down. And this is about, again, I know this is, it seems like focus areas, goals, but really this is like a temperature of what the priorities are of this group. That's what we're trying to ascertain. Okay? So, you're going to, the directions are group, Tom's group, which is bears, are going to stay here.

2:41:08 So they can come on either side. And then we're going to put those three small tables are going to be the coyotes. And then this section below the Mammoth Lakes, California side is going to be the eagles. And you need to take pens and you need to have a poster and grab your dinner. And you're going to go over there for 30 minutes. Okay, can everybody come back?

3:32:15 No, you're going to do that, your group. Okay, everyone, back to your seats, please. And what is the name of your group again? Coyotes. Okay, coyotes are going first. Coyotes are going first. Patricia. Patricia. Patricia. Patricia. Okay, guys, if you want to get out by seven, you need to move. Patricia. We'll be done. I have to drive back to Turkey. Patricia. There's candy. Okay.

3:33:17 Okay. Eric, do you mind sitting down? And then you'll go next after. Hoodies are up. Okay, Patricia. Everybody come down here. So each group is going to present what their focus area was. And then we're going to have a quick round of feedback for them to add if you have any to their notes. And then I'm going to take the notes and we're going to squish them into the structure. Okay.

3:33:46 So, what's the name of your team? Hi, we were the Coyotes, and we had focus areas three and four. Focus area three is foster collaboration and partnership. I'll just preface this with please excuse my very poor spelling.

3:34:05 We really felt like this foster collaboration and partnership should be embedded in every focus area and that it does not need its own. It's rather redundant that every...

3:34:21 So now we have less focus areas. Yay! More like a guiding principle. It's like how you do your work. And if I can speak to that, I think it would be great if everybody put that as a goal for each of the other focus areas. And you can put objectives that are more specific to reach those goals. And because we were thinking about what these goals are for that, building partnerships and collaboration, and we're looking just at the other.

3:34:52 Focus areas, so we don't need that to be its own. If everybody, if every focus area had that as a goal, we could get more refined. That's how you do your, it's how you do your business. It's a value. Exactly. Okay.

3:35:12 All right, I'm cognizant of the time constraints, and so coyotes are going to keep moving. We're going to go on to our next focus area, four, which I didn't write down, but it's got to do with funding, diversify funding, I think.

3:35:29 And so, well, we had written down a goal of to, because we had raised $70,000. We thought, oh, at first we were like, oh, let's do $100,000 the next three years. And then we're like, no, I didn't cross it out. But scrap that. Let's have a goal of to get our annual operating budget to $1 million over the next three years through.

3:35:53 Donations and jurisdiction contributions, partnerships, contracts that are ongoing. And then another goal would be to leverage fees into new developments. And I think that's great. And I think there's other ways. I don't want to limit it to just a couple.

3:36:21 So, are there any comments that the

3:36:51 Other groups want to add that you want to make sure gets included in this? I love it. You love it? Great. Yeah. I was just going to say one thought in terms of expanding the funding would be if we could find a benefactor to help create an endowment that the earnings from an endowment could help to subsidize and bolster our annual operating budget. So I added that. Any other things you want it to be included in the notes? Good job, Coyotes.

3:37:35 Okay, next group. Who's going from this team right over here? You guys were the, what were you guys? Eagles, okay, Eagles up, Eagles up. How about the team coming up with Eric? Where's Kirk? Kirk, you gotta go stand in solidarity. You guys have the mic. Okay, so we had two different focus areas. Our first one was enhanced communication outreach. So we really focused on developing a communication plan with everybody. So we're talking about doing like an email blast for

3:38:40 Everybody, every 30 days, every month, doing something like that. And then yearly reports for all of our partners that we focus on or, you know, for the town, anything like that. And then weekly social posts. I know we have been starting to do a lot of that recently, but, you know, we can still do something better or do something more constant. And then CRM tool, which is something that Brian brought up that's a good idea. Span on it.

3:39:29 And then our second goal was to launch our name. We're thinking it's going to be the end of 2023. That's mostly on making programs that make our website easier to, I guess, manage adding widgets. So if we post on our Instagram, it goes to our Facebook and the website, or if we post on LinkedIn or any other social media site, that can be added into it. So we have less work to do.

3:39:59 Third goal was outreach, so attend existing meetings. I think we're just, you know, trying to get funding for that portion of it, letting people know what we're doing, developing relationships with other cities and organizations, that would be more on the lines that we were talking about, creating a dashboard part of it, and then including other members, so MLT, Chamber, the college, I know that's something we haven't.

3:40:34 And the other one was our Latino community. That's a two-year span that is just basically maintaining awareness that we serve the Latino community in our office. So making them comfortable that they can come in, they can talk to us, we can give them the services that they need. And then a big one for that was serving the community to see where we can improve on what services we can offer them and what...

3:41:02 We've been doing good and what we can improve on. Our second area was strengthening our organization capacity. Our first goal was on nurturing and maintaining communities. That's a big one where I know we have some board members that participate a lot in it, but I know we have a couple board members that want to start participating.

3:41:31 Want to have some training on that. Second goal was to preserve our Neighborhood Works Registration Affiliate Designation, and that's just maintaining contact with the Western State Representative, maybe every six months, something like that. Our goal three was to continue staff and board education, so that's attending a conference every year or more if we can. And then goal four was to revisit the bylaws.

3:42:01 Which would be the ground act in our geography area. And then pursue an internship on, our next goal was to pursue internships or other field of study programs. So we have the CCRH program. That would be a good thing where we can get somebody else from the college or somebody that wants to just change their field that they could go into it and we can expand on that. Anyone from the group want to add anything to highlight? Were there any big shifts for you?

3:42:33 Or did you miss, I mean, I know you guys didn't, I don't know if you finished, so did you? Ryan, I was going to ask you to touch on the Brown Act, your thoughts on that, you had some good thoughts, I just can't remember them all. I think it's opportunity in that it, being subject to the Brown Act gives us a exposure to the community, but I think there's also some constraints that come along with it.

3:43:02 There's a burden to the town that comes along with it. And I think there have been some conversations about looking at revisiting our bylaws to explore whether there might be other mechanisms to incorporate the involvement of public agencies, but also thinking about some of the surrounding geographies if we're looking to expand into Alpine and Inyo counties. Do we want to try to...

3:43:31 incorporate board members from those regions, right, that can speak to their stakeholder needs, perhaps better than we may be able to hear from where we sit. So I just want to make a couple notes because I've heard from some of my colleagues on the board and one of them from the North County.

3:43:58 Is really interested in, with the new name, having representation on the board from the north, potentially. He's not 100% sure that there would be somebody who could be actively involved, but, you know, from where he sits, he wants to see how can they participate. So I think it's a great note, you know, I think, I'm already hearing that, Brian, that people want that.

3:44:26 And then I'll just add another note that I'm now on the IMACA Board of Directors, and I sit on it with a colleague from Mono County Board of Supervisors and a supervisor from Inyo County, so there's three elected officials on that board, and they do not follow the Brown Act, and the way they do that is they're not appointed by their bodies. That's what triggers it, is that we get appointed by our bodies.

3:44:54 They just, they, they're not nominated. They just apply. There's a vacancy and they, and we apply. And then the board appoints, the IMACA board appoints us, not our boards. So there would be an order, because you have to update and get, and update your bylaws to not include the Brown Act. And then based on that, you could expand your board. Right now you can't. They thought there was a requirement under the CHOTO that we have to have comply with Brown Act. No, no, no.

3:45:24 Chodo doesn't require that. Chodo. Yours looks like it's dead. Here you go. Chodo would only require that less than one-third of the board be public official or public employee. So less than one-third. Or one-third or less. No more than one-third. Okay. All right. Anyone have anything, other comments? That was helpful, Jennifer, just to have like a reaction to. And then if you have notes from your handout that you weren't able to share but you want to give to me to make sure we incorporate them.

3:46:01 Please do that. Okay. Good job, Eagle Group. Okay. All right. So, what are you guys? Yeah. You guys are the bears. So, the bears. So, the first focus area was build a facility at community housing. My notes on my page. All right. So, our goal one was to get a little more specific and just narrow in on identifying three priority projects in the next three years.

3:47:08 In the regional service area. So, again, kind of looking towards serving not just Mammoth, but Inno and Alpine counties. Let's see. So then, objective under that goal is to establish an evaluation criteria within the one to three year time frame to find a willing partner, find identified funding sources, time frame being implementing over three years.

3:47:40 And what are the resources that we have available to implement? So then moving on to, right, I think, yeah, again, to the point that we had the whole idea of creating a development rubric before, we never got to it because it was, you know, it was sort of like, okay, let's go through and look at the town and say, okay, is that parcel available for development? We never got to it, right, because again, too far reaching.

3:49:02 You know, the couple projects that have come to us have been through third parties who have approached us and say, hey, we're interested in possibly, you know, working out a way to convert this property to our trust to, you know, benefit the community, that kind of thing, right? So those happen. And then, I don't know, we've had some other developers or property owners who have approached us about properties as well. So there's that. So, you know, there's, you know, likely there'll be more people like that as, you know, the awareness of, like, how the Innsbruck Lodge deal.

3:49:32 You know, was facilitated and come together. You know, maybe it'll be more like that. But then, again, if we also have the ability on our own to go out and identify. But knowing how, you know, much work each of these projects is, is, okay, trying to be realistic about what we could actually achieve. So, you know, if we could initiate three projects in three years, one a year kind of roughly seems like it's a pretty realistic pace until we can, you know, grow more staff.

3:49:59 And keep in mind, too, with the projects, with the funding, so like in the case of Innsbruck, where the Home Key opportunity serendipitously kind of coincided with that opportunity, and, you know, we're able to build funding into the grant request to cover the cost of the development management and project management, right? So we can generate some additional revenues that way, so that's another.

3:50:24 So, any event, so going, moving on then to goal number two, collaborate with regional partners, counties and cities, you guys sort of spoke to that in the other one, so I don't know whether that's repetitive or duplicative. Yeah, so it sort of fits into the sort of the funding or the resources and funding as well on the prior objective, I guess.

3:50:56 Okay, so then goal number three, this is something I brought to the table, because I know about it, and it's a big project, obviously, that I'm involved in working in the ski areas, the main launch redevelopment, very, very large, ambitious project, and it's going to involve a specific plan approval and the EIREIS approvals, that's going to include a housing mitigation plan, so it's a substantial project, and I know that we want to engage Mammoth Lakes Housing on that, and I think the point being is that

3:51:26 It's a very tangible project with a definitive time frame of a couple years to get through the approvals and the specific plan entitlements and a great opportunity for MLH to collaborate on that and help create what is the objective of the framework of that specific housing mitigation as it relates to that project because it's so substantial. So I think that should definitely be on the list. So that was really it for that particular focus area. We didn't...

3:51:55 We're now time to write it up on the other one, but we went on to our next focus area. Yeah, so sorry, we didn't have time to write up focus area two, but if you just use the table that's in the packet, I'll just walk through the notes because we could have talked about this one the whole time. Okay, so the focus areas, grow housing programs and services. Goal 2.1 remains the same.

3:52:27 Ongoing objectives still continue to be manage housing loan programs, manage and grow deed restriction program. We did, or just going back to our conversation earlier about stewardship, who kind of, that maybe should be factored into the wording and language there. C, provide property management services for existing ESCH rental units.

3:52:50 That was a little bit of a discussion topic. Maybe we can circle back to that in a second. And then D, the education referral services. So those all stay as is. 2.2, again, a point for discussion, the deliver on existing rehabilitation loan program and grow in future years. There was a bit of a debate of whether this should stay or go because nobody is using it, but that was circumstantial.

3:53:19 So let me come back to that. We did propose to remove F, implement long-term rental inspection program, since we're not doing it. And we didn't think that that was necessary to be listed as an objective. Sorry, I'm going through this quickly. 2.3, this explore ideas of expanding ESCH mission-driven service model. We want to...

3:53:48 Add some language in wraparound service model. That one actually needs built out. So I think we should get together with Patricia and the staff to put out that objective more so that it includes a lot of the different services for displacements and the emergency rent payment. And we talked about a lot of other wraparound services. And then we thought it best to take out, remove each partner to build.

3:54:17 Online matching program, because Chamber's already doing that, so we thought we would leave it to them. I think I have maybe two comments, or three. I think that the rehab loan program could probably just be lumped in with 2.1A, which is housing loan programs, so we could pursue it as an opportunity if it seems like a good idea at the time, or there's a need. I agree with that totally, so that would actually get rid of 2.2 completely.

3:54:49 Yeah, potentially. And then I had an idea, I had the thought that Mammoth Lakes Housing does provide some monitoring services for existing affordable housing units. That's a service we provide that's not in the strategic plan per se, but it is sort of like a program or a fee for service that we offer. I don't know if we want to just maintain that, get rid of it, expand it, make sure jurisdictions know that we could do that.

3:55:20 That's just something that occurred to me when I was reading through this. I guess that would be under 2.2 or improved living or something about existing rental stocks, stewardship of existing rental stocks. That wouldn't fall under 2.1c? It's not property management. What are you doing? It's monitoring of the regulatory agreement to make sure that they're complying with the affordability requirements. Okay. So the question is, I understand what you're saying, but the question is,

3:55:57 Is it just a requirement and not an objective? Because it's a housing service, which is focus area two. Does it fall into the funding section then? Well, yeah, you can. Yeah, I think that you're already doing that, right? I mean, whenever we sign a contract like on the Davison House, it's part of the contract, right? Right, but so this is grow housing services. Do we want to grow that area? I guess.

3:57:23 And then the other discussion point was about the property management services for existing units. Patricia was saying we already do it for Star Apartments and we're going to be doing it for Innsbruck. So I don't know if anyone has any input on whether we should continue to offer that. Well, we'll either have to or contract it out to somebody. Sorry, that was the question. Yes, do we keep it internal or do we explore contracting it out?

3:57:53 Look at external resources. I think it's a case-by-case basis, honestly. I mean, just from my experience with the development committee, that's kind of how we look at it, is do we have the capacity? How many units? I don't know. Okay. I think that's it. Sounds like it, yeah. Innsbruck's going to have an on-site manager spot for it, so presumably we will be doing that. But we could outsource that position. I was going to say, that's another option. Yes.

3:58:35 Obviously to the funding availability, right? And the thought was if you just had it for Innsbruck, it's probably less than a halftime job, right? So there might be, if we did say, okay, we're going to go ahead and commit an apartment to support that person's position and a salary, and then there's potential to add additional units to that person's role. So like if we were to get 238 Sierra Manor commissioned and on, you know, there's another.

3:59:09 11 units potentially could come online the next couple of years on top of Innsbruck. So then it might start to make sense, right, because you've got enough critical mass. So again, it is kind of boiled down to the individual projects and opportunities and funding availability. And almost in some ways it's probably a longer term strategy because maybe in the next three years we'll have the number of units that we need to make it a viable business decision, whereas right now we don't really know how that's going to work out.

3:59:39 So maybe that's like a five-year thing, not a three-year thing. And then the only other thing was you mentioned the mission-driven property management. I think that's the thing we're just talking about. So maybe we scrap that or put it on the longer term. But you said services. And I think the housing navigator position is a new position. And this frontline service model that we've sort of developed since COVID, which we never really had before.

4:00:08 Is something that sort of organically has grown, and I don't know if that's something we see ourselves growing into more in the future as a program or a service that we provide, or if that's maybe not as big of a priority, but maybe that's something. Yeah, we need to put, I think it'd be important to put the navigators in this area. Yeah, that was actually my, that was my biggest one, I think, is like our role as housing navigators, because to what extent are we going to be working with clients? And I think, I think I mentioned this maybe.

4:00:37 Briefly, but just the fact that I think we have the most foot traffic and, you know, we're sitting with clients and working through client action plans and making sure that they get the other services they need aside from housing. So, I don't know. Yeah, and I think it's something that I think, you know, we've gotten a lot of accolades for. We sort of are, you know, the housing services entity and I think...

4:01:08 That's something I'm quite proud of. But how we want to use that or how we want to grow or keep that in line with the other developments that we're doing I think is a conversation, an ongoing conversation to have. Okay, I just want to make, there's no mention of the navigators in here because we didn't have them in the 19, so I just need somebody to write the, I'll put it in, but we just want to make sure we're capturing that it exists and it's happening, right, because

4:01:40 It does. And so, yeah, and I know you guys had a huge two focus areas, so good job. Yeah, very good. Okay, good job. Good job. Okay. Okay, so I apologize. I don't like to be over on meetings. So, 7.05 and... Can I raise the naming issue real quick?

4:02:06 If I could, I just want to put it on the floor. So, like two minutes, because everyone, like. So, you've heard me say, Ash, is that it? And can we have a discussion at the board about what, because people still, MLH, was at a meeting last week, people are like, oh, we have a lot of Eastern Sierra stuff, we're adding another one, oh, no. So, I'm just having a little bit of like, oh, shit.

4:02:33 Oh, snap. What did we do? And, you know, I'm like, maybe we should have been like AIM Housing, Alpine Inyo Mono Housing. It's easier. It rolls off the tongue. It's got housing in it. Because Eastern Sierra Community Housing is long to say. MLH just rolls off. So I have some concerns about the housing. So name. So future agenda. Yeah. And it seemed like strategic planning was the right time to talk about that. I mean, I didn't.

4:03:03 Didn't we go, didn't they go through all those other options of names? I know I only was joined on the logo presentation, so I missed the naming options, but I thought there was a few others that were presented and we didn't want to like limit it to the specific counties or. Yeah, so like on all transparency, I sit on the board, I voted, right? I'm not.

4:03:25 Not not taking ownership. I'm just saying we haven't paid for any republication of anything. I know we paid for a graphic designer, but like if we're going to do if we're going to talk about or maybe consider a change, this would be the time to do it. But if we're good with Esch or we're good with saying Eastern Sierra Community Housing every time, but we but we have to start making the change.

4:03:48 So thank you, everybody, for your amazing thoughts and contributions. Next step is we're going to take these notes, and if you could hand in anything that had additional notes, that would be great. And if you could put your name on it so I know who did that. And then we will work with Patricia and staff to sort of put it in the right place, fill in some of the details, and then get you all a draft to

4:04:17 Patricia will get you all a draft to have it on the agenda to have the conversation. Sorry it was rushed in the end. It always tends to be like that. And it was great working with you. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah, it was intense. The time went really fast. Yeah. Kirk, you have to adjourn the meeting. The meeting is adjourned. You have to turn your mic on.

4:04:51 If there's no further discussion or any issues, I adjourn the meeting. Thank you for being here.