TransparentMammoth

Short-Term Rental Committee · 2023

Short-Term Rental Committee Special meeting

at 17:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

234 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:40 We will go ahead and call the meeting of the short-term rental advisory committee together, 504. Jamie, can I get a roll call? Committee Member Avery? Here. Committee Member Bubzer? Here. Committee Member Gardner? Here. Committee Member Harper? Here. Committee Member Kellogg? Here. Committee Member Ocampo? Here.

3:08 Committee Member Rice? Here. Vice Chair Fleming? Here. Chair Morris? Here. Awesome. Thanks, everybody, for coming. It's great to see everybody here tonight. Jamie, do we have any public comment? Sorry, is there any public comment from the audience here? Not on the agenda, sorry. Hi there. I'm Sandy Hogan, and I'm here as a cheerleader, okay? I know you've heard enough of the other.

3:41 But I was one of the ones who has spoken out in favor of the moratorium for the last two town council meetings for one reason, because, oh gosh, 11, 12, what was it, John? How many years ago were you on that task force? Yeah. Yeah. It was a while back. I became aware of people who were serving on the task force to improve our enforcement. And ever since then, I've tracked it.

4:10 And especially the numbers, of course, because I'm a firm believer in TOT. And I know the best way to get TOT is to have a really good program. And I've seen for years what happened as a result of that. I was a member of the infamous Measure Z Committee, 12 of us, that decided we needed to...

4:35 Make sure that our residential areas were protected from STRs because we were starting to see, you know, the results of partying, bachelor parties, all that kind of stuff. And Measure Z actually supported TOT and we supported STRs. We just wanted them in the right place because we knew this town was built on TOT. And I mean, your figures, you...

5:03 You guys have a job ahead of you. I could see it. And it's wonderful. And I'm glad to see it. And I know that you are going to be in good hands. Because your leaders are two people who are problem solvers. And that's what you need, is problem solving mentality and going afterward. Cynthia is your vice chair, and John is your chair.

5:32 And I knew our two council members here. They are problem solvers. And that's the mentality to attack this with. Rob is one of the best staff I've ever worked with. He is, you know, he's objective. And I've worked with him on some things that were, you know, maybe controversial. He just gives me the facts. And that's what you want. And that's what you'll get. So congratulations on being on these committees, this committee.

6:02 And your subcommittees, I know you have a lot of hard work in short time. And I think Chris was right when she asked for February deadline, not January, because, you know, the council meetings are 1st and 3rd January. So even if you had worked all January, you couldn't get to the council until February. So hopefully staff and...

6:31 You know, and council will reflect upon that. And maybe the first week in January you can get all this work accomplished. So thank you for what you're doing. I may end up leaving if I'm having trouble hearing. I'm hard of hearing. And sometimes the workshops, when people don't grab the mic and speak right into it, it's really hard. And I'm better off watching you on TV. But otherwise, I will be here. So thank you again.

6:59 Thank you, Sandy. Any other public comment from anyone in the room here? Jamie, anybody in the virtual world? Okay. I just wanted to go over, I know we changed this committee to only being a short-term rental and it took out the housing portion for locals and I really think that we need to add that back in because short-term rentals, I think the reason we...

7:28 are trying to limit them is to try to help locals get housing, and I have a number of ideas that we can implement that will help locals get housing, and I think that's really important because that's why we're here, is to help locals, and so I wanted to see if we can throw that back on the table. Okay, we can certainly talk about that. So one of the things, if I can address that real quick, certainly it's hard to bifurcate these, right, because they're related, but I think the concern was if we

7:58 Sort of take on the role of tackling housing. That's we're never going to get done, right? It's a very large thing. So what we recognize there's a lot of good ideas in that. We have a parking lot that we will populate with those things so we can keep that stuff going forward. And I think there'll be some ancillary work programs that start to define that a little bit further. So it's not completely off the table, but really that focus onto the management side of the short-term rental stuff is really where we want to focus.

8:28 But we'll take all that stuff in, and then when we have time, we'll talk about it. One thing I noticed that, excuse me, that was not on the agenda, normally we have committee member comments. No? Yes, no? Okay, great. Since no more public comments, we're close. Can I add one thing on the short-term rental versus housing? Yeah. I think you have a point, but I think we could also look at, because we're looking at enforcing short-term rentals and the way we manage it, maybe we can...

8:58 Focus on points that would help any of those housing things and add it into the short-term rental management plan, you know, maybe a tax or something, increased fees, something like that. I have a feeling we're going to find a lot of things that are going to dovetail right into it. So yeah, even though technically we're not having a housing discussion, I think those things are really going to result. But I agree with you 100% that it's super important. Any other comments from anyone on the committee?

9:28 The last two weeks? Okay. Let's see. The only comment I had is I had a great meeting with Dan and Rob a couple weeks ago after the previous council meeting, and we went over sort of the tools that the town has as far as enforcement and how far you can kind of push things like fees and fines and other kinds of revenue-generated. I'm very interested in the revenue-generating side of things to try to rep.

9:55 generate revenue for housing. So we had a really good discussion about that and some other things. So thank you guys for the time on that. With that, I'll turn it over to Rob and Dan for the staff presentation, kind of going over what our stuff is. Sure. Can I do something? Oh, sorry. Actually, consent agenda is before that, if you look at the agenda. Sorry, I'm lost tonight. Yes, we do. Although my...

10:25 Staff presentations before consent agenda. Got it. Ann, do you want to put your microphone on? Sorry about that, guys. Yeah. Okay. Consent agenda. So approve the minutes of the November 13th meeting. Do I have a motion? I move to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of November 13th. Excellent. Do I have a second? I'll second. Okay. Second. Any discussion? Okay. Jamie, can I have roll call, please? Committee member Avery.

10:57 I vote to approve them? Yeah, say yes or no. Yes. Committee Member Bubzer? Yes. Committee Member Gardner? Yes. Committee Member Harper? Yes. Committee Member Kellogg? Yes. Committee Member Ocampo? Yes. Committee Member Rice? Yes. Vice Chair Fleming? Yes. Chair Morris? Yes. All right. Policy matters. Get back in order here. Okay, so we... Of course. Jamie, do you see...

11:30 The town attorney is struggling to join Zoom, but there's eight other people on Zoom, so I'm pretty sure it's working. Figure out how to text that to him. It's your problem. Are you, okay, thank you. All right, so first on the agenda is the appointment of two members to the advisory committee. So Isora was good enough to, not good enough, she put her name in and the council voted her in last night, so we appreciate your volunteering for it. So we are back to nine.

12:06 Carey's position who could not stay on. So we are at nine. As it was stated at the very beginning, we do have the discretion to add two more members to make it an 11-member board. So assuming that the group is good with that, we do have quite a few people who have expressed interest and I think actually do fit into the categories that we...

12:30 that we had left for the two categories that are open. One is a member of the Hispanic community and the other is an at-large position which was directed by the council not to be from either lodging or real estate. And so that's basically what our directive is. I personally am fine with expanding to 11 people. I think the only danger with that is

12:57 Making sure that we have a quorum at any given time, which would mean we'd need to have at least six people at any given meeting to be able to have the meeting. And as long as, well, we have everybody here tonight, and as long as it stays that way, it will be no problem. Is there any concern within the group of expanding the committee? Any doubts or concerns or anything? I guess my feelings, I feel that Isara sort of can feel, she's kind of feeling two seats. I feel like you're,

13:27 Giving a voice to the Hispanic community, and then you've also dealt with housing challenges. So I would be comfortable keeping it this size committee, but I don't know how everyone else feels. I think based on public comments and concerns from the public, it might be wise to add a short-term rental owner to the committee. There are several on the list.

13:56 Vicki Tatton, I don't know any of them, so forgive me. John Herzog, Mary Beth Erickson. She removed her name. She did, okay. Jim Prusch. And Jason Herbst. Yeah, I'll say Jim no longer owns his short-term rental. Okay. And what we wanted, what we wanted to is to be sure that we had, we had somebody from the, if it's a short-term rental owner, I...

14:26 I think the council wanted us to try to stay away from adding more people from the lodging business. I'm looking at it from the standpoint of we do have a very good applicant from the Hispanic community. We also have, I think, a few folks on here who are just homeowners, which having a member of the public, it's just a...

14:53 Just a homeowner in town. It certainly is a good voice, which we don't really have a general public homeowner on this. So I could go either way with it. I think nine is a good number. Eleven also works. But I guess we just have to move through this as quickly as we can. So if anybody...

15:15 Would like to make a motion. Chair, you also have public comment to take. Oh, I'm sorry. Before you make a motion, please. Thank you. Sorry about that. Public comments on this matter. Yes, go ahead. Can you step up to the podium and talk into the mic? Thank you. Hi, my name is Christina Avery, and I am a short-term rental owner. I did live here between 2010 and 2017, so I have sort of some mixed opinions of

15:42 I understand the local community. I have a lot of love for the local community, lots of friends here. But I also am a short-term rental owner, and my family's owned here for over 40 years. And I did write to get my name as one of the options to get on the committee. And I'm absolutely willing to drive up every other week to come to a committee meeting. So just want to put that in. Thanks, Christine. Appreciate it. Okay. Anybody else? Yep.

16:13 Andrew, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Are you speaking to me, Andrea? Oh, sorry, Andrea. Yeah, my bad. Yeah, yeah. I would join the committee, be number 11. I am a condo owner recently, March 22, and we had hoped to get a permit and just took our time enjoying it without.

16:39 Having rentals, just understanding the town and such. But I think I would be a good blend because now I'm locked out of getting a permit. And I would love to get one for even just maybe a couple of weekends of a month or, you know, keeping it mostly for family. But I would put my name in the hat. Thank you for your comments. What was your full name again? Sorry. Andrea Makshanov. I'm...

17:13 M-A-K-S-H-A-N-O-F-F. Thank you very much. We appreciate it. Sandy? I was going to give two names if you decided to go to 11, but I understand the importance of sometimes keeping, you know, the size down. But, and one of mine happened to be in real estate, but if there's no real estate, that was Grace, because she's a big supporter of, you know.

17:53 affordable housing for folks. But Alonso Escovar is a very worthy candidate. I mean, he's on the board, you know, Mammoth Unified School District board. I think he's been president. He's not now. And he's grown up here. So he, you know, along with Isaura, can really give us. So I would suggest if you go to two,

18:21 You make him one of the two. Any other public comment? No. Jimmy, no? Okay. Okay. Yes, of course. I noticed her name's not on any list. Christina, apologies. It came in late. We just pulled what we had from before, so we may well have. We did not reach out to the folks to confirm their interest. So I guess we really have two questions. Go ahead. I'm happy to explain a little bit about that.

18:55 If you do, you need to go to the podium. That's okay. Procedure. Sorry about that. So I worked here in the town for seven years. I was a middle school teacher and worked as a maternity sub for multiple teachers in the district. I was the high school softball coach for a few years and also worked on the mountains. So I do have a vested interest in not only the families in town, but also the mountain.

19:25 And like what they're bringing to the town and like with tourism. Like I said, my family is owned here for 40 plus years. I think we're the oldest owners at the Big Wood Complex. And I have lived here and worked here and love it. We did have the amazing moment of being in the middle of a remodel so we didn't get our permit in in time. I'll fully disclose that. But I also

19:53 When I want a permit, it's because I want family and friend to be able to come up here and also do it in a legal way, so I feel like I'm supporting the town. It matters a lot to me to support this town, and when I have friends and family in town, I tell them we're going to locally owned restaurants, I told my construction crew we're ordering from local businesses all of our materials, so I sort of have a mix of the short-term rental, but also a lot of love.

20:22 Any questions, I'm happy to take them. Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Okay, so, you know, I may have jumped the gun a little bit. I guess the first question is, for the group, is, are we satisfied that the nine that we have is a good representation of the community? And do we feel that we need to expand? We're not mandated to do so as an option. So it's simply a matter of, you know, if we feel we're good with what we've got and want to move forward, we can do that.

20:54 That's not, yeah. Do we need, will we need to vote on that or can we just discuss that or show of hands? I think if it's just a consensus by the board to not add, that's fine. If you do want to add, then you can take the action as recommended to a point. Okay. Up to two members. Okay. Could somebody, if there isn't general conversation, make a motion on what direction they want to go?

21:19 You can make a motion on our consensus if you just want to do a roundtable real quick and see what people's interests are. Yeah, I would like to do that, just by consensus. So if we can just go around and just make sure your microphone's on. Jason, the question is, should we stay at a nine-member group or should we look to expand to 11? So, Jason? I do feel comfortable with the nine that we have. I think it is a good representation of the town. Chris?

21:48 I think we're good with the nine that we have now that we have. Forgive me, but I look around and I see a lot of us are involved in short-term rentals or real estate. It's not necessarily the same thing. I would be interested in potentially getting more homeowners or community members involved. I think we could expand. I don't think it would hurt us terribly if we didn't, but I do think we should consider a few of these applicants to add to the...

22:20 I'd like to see a second homeowner on the committee, so bringing it to 11, well, then we'll fill the 10th spot, but I honestly can go either way. It doesn't really bother to me, so whatever you guys decide. Any preference one way or the other? Not at all. I think I'm in the same boat. I don't have anything against adding another person, and I'm not completely opposed to keeping it with the group that we have, so indecisive. Okay.

22:55 All right. I guess I'm like up and open for adding another person if it's necessary. Well, I guess my feelings are it's a public meeting. Like you're welcome to come as a member of the public and share. And I think that we have, you know, Cynthia runs a short-term rental management company. John does as well. And you're from hotels and you are representing like

23:25 The 1849 condo owners? Well, I manage the HOA and the 1849 company, so short-term owners, second home owners. Okay. So, I mean, I guess my personal feeling is it's going to slow us down trying to add more people and if, you know, we pick two people and then they can't do it and then we've added one and we've got to add somebody else. I feel like it's an open public meeting. People can come and...

23:54 Tell us they love our ideas or hate our ideas and we can listen to them. And, you know, we are putting ideas before the council. We are not, you know, yeah, we're not like the final end-all be-all decision makers. So that's why I feel like we're in this and let's just, you know, we all want to hurry this along. So I think that will slow us down. So that would be voting for nine? Nine, yeah. Okay, Lisa?

24:22 I would vote to add two committee members, but I hear what you're saying, Amanda, and I agree with you, and I am okay with it at nine as well. And, yeah, since that's five, I'm neutral on it either, but I think smaller is better, so. Let's see, we need a, we would actually need a vote on this. Up to you. I mean, if it's general consensus, leave it at nine. I think you're okay, but if you want to have a vote, you can do that as well.

24:55 If it's not necessary, then I don't think we need to. If there's consensus that we'll stay at 9, then we should stay at 9. Is that your own consensus? Okay. Okay, so our consensus is that we'll stay at 9. Christina, thank you very much, and please come to the meetings or give us your comments. We really appreciate it. Okay, thank you. All right. Item 5.2, so our work program.

25:21 Dan, do you want to take a lead on this one? Yeah. I'll dive into it, and then we'll have some additional information as well from Rob on elements of it. I'm hoping you had a chance to look at the staff reports. Somebody just got it late, and we didn't get it out too early, just given the workload. But basically, what we wanted to try to do is start to break the work program down in some, I'll say, more bite-sized pieces, and also to use some subcommittees to dive into some of the detailed work.

25:50 Element in here, you have a couple of recommendations. We'll touch on those and walk through a little bit what that means. One, the first one was really looking at the certified properties program. And we have information in the staff report walking through that. Rob can spend a little more detailed time on that. But the whole idea there is to try to get that program up and running. There's some changes in the code that need to happen. And that does not have to wait until all the work at the committee is done either. It could go when it's ready. It can go.

26:17 One of the big issues where we've heard from and need to look at is that whole idea of how do we deal with permits that are underneath a management company and not owned by an owner, so to speak. We're running into that of transferring and those issues. A number of other pieces to that as well. So I'm just going to give a highlight on these and we can dive back into them in detail. So one of the recommendations there is to get committee members and these can be three or four.

26:44 Member Committees. You go to five, then you got a quorum, so it doesn't work. So up to the group, how many people you want to assign to these, but the maximum is four. And it's a subcommittee, so they meet, they can meet whenever, wherever, they don't have to, it's not a notice meeting of that group. You can do that if you like, but it's not a requirement to have a notice meeting. It allows a lot more functionality. I mean, you can do a Zoom meeting, you can make rooms available to town, you can go to a coffee shop.

27:14 Never a bad idea. Or a restaurant. Anyway, you can do things that way to do that, but really the focus would be on that certified properties program and Rob's staff would be helping them lead that subcommittee. The second one really starts to look at some of the zoning issues that have come up in this discussion as well. And one of those has been that whole discussion on a big chunk of the area of the community.

27:42 That really has been built out and designed to be more of a resort-based, condo-hotel-type structure. We think there's a lot of sense in that, and one of the elements that we started to look at is, does it make sense to bifurcate out part of the zoning to make it more, it's housing, you know, residential uses are allowed, but the real focus would be on the short-term rental side, and there's likely parts of other portions of the town that might be short-term rentals are allowed, but there's a

28:12 Plus, it's maybe it should be more housing focused. But where that bifurcation comes in, it seemed like it was simpler to take a look at the resort side component to that. And there'll be some slight modifications in zoning, not a lot, and ideas to keep that focused so we can actually move it forward relatively quickly from a zoning standpoint. And a lot of that was looking at the portals, you know, how do you access, you know, Mammoth Mountain and some of the recreation areas, you know, winter, summer.

28:42 elements that are in there, and starting to look on that, and then if you go to the other side, as this gets into some of the housing discussion, if you look at some of the other zoning questions, you start to say, are there methods, incentives, and other elements to help drive some housing out of the current stock, as well as looking at, you know, we've got a lot of programs out there, let's go build housing, that just needs millions of dollars, but otherwise we're in good shape to do some of those types of things.

29:12 And so, again, without walking through a lot of details, my first question is just taking those two big chunks, if that's something that the committee sees as a work program that has smaller committee groups that you would like to dive into and say, let's take a hard look at the zoning element and where that's at, especially from the portal side. Let's take a hard look at the certified property program.

29:39 The nice part about that is the meeting schedules and that can happen very quickly. There's not as much paperwork and coordination on the front end. So it can get a lot of work done. Then you come back and report out to the full committee. And then you get buy-in for your recommendations or change them as the committee goes. So I think it can be an effective way to get some of the key work elements moving. And then as we go through this, if there's some other areas to nail down.

30:05 And focus in on, we can do the same thing. You can create a different committee. The first couple like this, what you don't do as we're running those is having multiple people on the same, on different committees because then you end up with a majority of the, like if you had, you know, a four-member committee and one person serving on both and technically you have five and you're into a problem that way. So you serve on one at a time, one committee. If it's done, then you can do another one. But at three-member committees, we can have three, put it that way.

30:35 Those elements. So let me pause there. Just one, does that, does the approach make sense to the committee? If it does, then we can dive in and provide additional information of what each committee might look at. Or if you're comfortable with that approach, we can move kind of quickly through that process. I just want to reiterate one point, is by not being on a particular topic, it does not mean that you won't have the opportunity to weigh in on that, right? When it reports back, there's deliberations, discussions.

31:03 Feedback provided at that time. So everyone will address everything. These working groups, and they're not trying to be done outside of a public setting, it's just the brainstorming work, all of the small committee work is very arduous and long and takes time. So we're hoping that there's more frequent meetings. You know, you're coming in, meeting with staff and sitting down in our conference rooms and we're going through stuff and we're spending time to get through that. So it is a way of getting things done faster.

31:33 But you will have the opportunity to weigh in on something if you're not on that committee. Yeah, the committee doesn't have any authority, decision-making authority ultimately, it comes back to this body. Quick, before we move forward with our comments, are there any public comments regarding this topic? I want to make sure. As to the room. Anybody in the room, sorry. I'm talking two spheres here. Okay, great.

32:01 A quick question, actually a quick comment on the zoning part. My only concern, and maybe this, Dan, if you're kind of helping us through this part, my only concern about the zoning is I'm a little concerned about going too deep into zoning before we get the results back from BAE on the study that's being done, because if the study basically comes back and says,

32:28 There is no correlation between short-term rentals and lack of housing in town. Does that change the calculus of what we're doing with zoning? I don't know. I mean, if it's, you know, that's a, I'm not sure if those things are necessarily related, but I just don't want to get too far into the weeds on that. Go ahead. I guess, I feel like we're trying to do this in a hurry.

32:54 And I just had a flash of like, oh yeah, the COVID vaccine, like they ran all the trials simultaneously, like we need to form these subcommittees so we can do this work to get it done on time and to, you know, otherwise we're going to have a meeting and argue for or discuss things for three hours and then, you know, that will only be one topic. And I feel that if we have a mix of people on each subcommittee, we can flesh out all the ideas and kind of

33:23 Break it into more manageable pieces, and decisions won't be made until, like you're saying, we have everything. We're not going to put the cart before the horse. But I think that it would be super beneficial, and I think that time is of the essence, and we want to get this done, and we should break into small groups, divvy up the work, and then when we come back at these meetings, we'll get more accomplished. I don't have a hard finish date.

33:53 The goal is try to have it before our December meeting. It's a matter of getting the data and working through that and just crunching it through. As long as, again, I get the concern. Yeah, it's not really so much a concern. I just, I would hate to go down a road and then have the study come back and tell us something completely different and then we go, whoops, we should have done that. We could waste our time, but I mean. There's always that possibility, right? You can, yeah. You'll never get those minutes back. I think it's nice about, though.

34:24 Just getting, given the comments that we received, it almost, it really does look like there's a portion of the community that the uses on those particular product is different, if I can put it that way. I can pick on Nolan. First of all, do you all know Nolan? He's our acting community economic development director, so he's our planning guru at the table, so as, and also he's our housing person as well.

34:54 For elements. So he can speak to that zoning issue in that question when a lot of the properties were developed in some of the types of elements. I think that may be a good informational regardless for looking forward. Fair enough. Yeah, I kind of just want to make that point that that gets into some other interesting things depending on what the study says. But you're right. I mean, it certainly is a worthy exercise. I would want to add on the zoning side.

35:22 Regardless of all the time to prepare all the reports and analyze and come up with what the proposal would be, once it gets to the Planning Commission level for a public hearing, it's roughly 45 to 60 days to kind of get through the process at that point to getting probably a little bit longer because it's a public hearing at the Planning Commission and then has to be noticed for a public hearing at Town Council for a first reading and then has to go for a second reading and then it would become effective.

35:50 30 days after that point. So there is kind of that to think through with all this as well. There's kind of timing built in to implement any zoning changes. Zoning changes affect house sales. Probably a nightmare. No, I mean like what we're exploring actually is a good thing. Yeah, so what would the benefits be? Can you tell us that? Why would we want to change the zoning code?

36:21 Well, I think we need to change the zoning code to protect the people who purchase properties near the resort corridors like Canyon and Eagle and the village. So to me, when you drive around up there, and I'm happy to take anyone and everyone at this table on a tour to point out that it's really not appropriate for locals to be living, nor would they want to be living at 1849. Sorry, I know you live there, and it's aggravating. But then there's other parts of our community that make a lot more sense.

36:51 And frankly, even from a nightly runner perspective, like, does a guest really want to stay in the outskirts of town? You know, maybe not as often. So just to be clear, we're not talking about taking these properties out of the moratorium. This is a long-term vision. Thank you. It would be looking at the timing element, because by the time you take this type of element, you do the work, it goes to the planning commission. There's some findings they have to do.

37:24 And then it moves on through that process. So the timing, it wouldn't take them out at this point, but it would allow us to look at some bifurcation of how we look at short-term rentals. Right now it's a broad brush, and I think that would be beneficial. As mentioned, some of them were more designed, almost truly, they're not called it, but they could almost be a condo hotel by definition.

37:44 Well, and a lot of banks consider them condo hotels. So again, we have to keep that in mind. What I keep emphasizing is that a lot of these complexes are condo hotels, which means that currently today, what, 8.49% interest rate with 25% down? Higher than that. Higher than that, yeah. And so I wanted to kind of add my little information on that. So I have a list of items that, or a list of complexes that are already listed as condo hotels that, like 1849, it is a condo hotel.

38:13 If you can't get nightly rental business license for it, then, and you can't really live there, so it's kind of in a dead zone right now. So there is a number of complexes, and I have a whole list that we could try to look at the zoning for those, since they are actually condotels on the lending side. Like, people can come in and pay cash for it, and it's not going to matter, but on the lending side, there is a big list that are condotels. So I really like the idea of two subcommittees. Elisa, one thing.

38:46 is the first subcommittee for recommendation one can go a lot faster, and that's really what we're going to commit to finishing by February, so that we make the recommendation, council, and this is all towards making sure the moratorium does not have to get extended again, so that's what that committee's about, and then I think the zoning is super important.

39:07 Because that's more looking long-term at some things that probably should have been fixed a long time ago, so let's do it while we're doing this. The other thing that I really like about recommendation two is that, you know, at the bottom of the first paragraph, it says, with a focus on programs to transition units towards supporting community housing. So right there, we are addressing housing. It's just with a very direct ask.

39:35 That will be the most impactful for what we need to do. So that's why I think this is a great path forward. The one thing I would ask to add to recommendation two, so the second subcommittee, is we've talked about really understanding what the need is. So you know that we have the list of Buckingham properties with more than 400 people on.

40:04 Applying for the parcel, we have Eastern Sierra Community Housing's list, and then we have other data, so I would just really like to get that into the work plan if we could. Mickey, why am I, yes, I've only known her since forever. Mickey Brown had some good ideas about this, and she had volunteered to come to that subcommittee meeting and help us tackle that specific thing, and I think that that would just really.

40:34 Help people understand what we're talking about because I still think that no matter how much we talk about it, people don't understand that we don't have enough programs for the missing middle and there are no state or federal funds. I keep saying it because I'm hoping it'll finally make it into the sheet that there's nothing that can help this community except ourselves with helping missing middle get housing and I think that the more specific we are, the

41:04 The more we can help our community understand what we're trying to do. Thanks. I'd like to throw one more thing out in here, and I don't know if, and just whatever the group thinks about it, I don't know whether this is a third committee or if it can be kind of wrapped up into the first one, but where I see this with the short-term run, sort of with the program, are two parts. The first part, I feel...

41:31 that we'll look at are sort of the rules and regulations, and that's quality of life ordinance, the proposed certified property program, things like the short-term rental, the violation structure and fees and so forth, and just making sure that

41:50 You know, you guys probably know how I feel. I don't have a lot of sympathy for people who violate the rules because I think they all know them. And I think without getting too far off, it's just like parking tickets, and I'm glad the town has gone this direction, you have to make it a deterrent so people won't do it. If you just ding somebody for $200 a night and they're making $1,000 a night,

42:09 They're going to keep doing it until you pull their license away or make it cost-ineffective for them to do it. So there's that and any other structural changes. The second part of that is something that I'm really very interested in trying to help the town with, and that's sort of a fees and revenue potential from the short-term rental program. Things like...

42:31 With the business tax licenses, the current fees, and Rob and I and Dan and I had a good conversation about that. You know, how, and I think Mayor Wentworth brought this up at the previous meeting or so. Yeah, you. And he had said, you know, looking at the actual cost of running the short-term program, you've obviously got staff, you've got Rob, you've got his staff, you've got other pieces that are involved with that. What does it really cost per unit to run the program? The current fees of...

43:00 So there's that. I mean, there's the cost of it. And then there's also sort of the what tools do the town have? How high can you make that fee so that it's actually a revenue stream? And the reason I say that is because this is currently TOT is 60% of our town funds plus. And if we're looking at ways to

43:29 To solve housing issues, the main way we need to do that is we need to have more funds to be able to do that. So we really need to be looking at funding mechanisms of being able to do that. So that's one. The other thing is the potential increase in TOT. That is a vote of the voting public here in town, but TOT can be increased, and that's a political commitment, and that can go towards the council can vote to put

43:58 To increase TOT, a point, two points, whatever it is, half a point, and have those funds go towards a specific item. So there are some things there that we can talk about. Now, if the group feels that that can all be done under one committee, and we can kind of look at all that, the rules and regs, and also the, because they kind of, they intertwine a little bit, that's great. I just don't want to bite off too much unless we need, and if we don't need a third committee, go ahead, Chris. I feel like in the

44:26 Staff report in the analysis, the certified properties program, what you're talking about is included in here, because it's the fifth bullet violations of the municipal code, and then it talks about, or no, I'm sorry, it wasn't that one, it was, where is it? I saw it. While you look for that, Chris, I think John. Oh, it's at the top of page four. Okay. So it's basically like how we're going to determine the fees. So the fees, I.

44:53 I'm comfortable with being the subject matter expert on the certified properties. I think the fee component and all of those aspects, because they're fairly complex, the rules and regulations around that, I think that can actually live within the certified properties discussion. Okay, great. The TOT rate increase would be a parking lot item, I think, that we would possibly have an option to discuss on the housing side. That may be a second subcommittee or a second group.

45:22 Or general conversation, I don't know. Okay. You have a fee that you can put in place. It has to cover the cost of the program. If it's just a fee for the sake of generating revenue, that's a tax, which then you can't impose that. The differential on that is...

45:51 Andy can speak to this too. If you do a fine, that's something different, like we have the penalties and interest and those types of charges. But for an actual fee, like to file for a permit, we can walk through and say, this is what that costs, this is what this program costs to manage that permit, and we can charge accordingly. The tax element you can get in, there's a number of different things that we can do for taxes, some we can't as a local government. But the tax requires, and you have to put that on a ballot.

46:20 And it goes to the voters accordingly. And you add either it's a dedicated tax like Measure R, Measure U, if you're familiar with those in the community for recreation and arts and culture and those types of things. Those were ballot measures and they were two-thirds of vote. And so they are restricted just for the purposes that are defined in those particular ballots. If you do a general tax at 51% approval instead of 66% or supermajority, that can be politically committed.

46:49 But it's not bound by that. It's should they do this tax, and it can be used for these purposes, but it's actually general fund revenue. And the current TOT basically falls into those categories of that nature, of that general fund with commitments going out to different things. And right now, a lot of those dollars are going to housing. So they are two different areas. So if you want to look at funding for housing, I think that would be that topic, as Rob said. We set aside for a minute and come back. Here's funding.

47:18 Other alternatives, here's a way to use dollars we have, here's the programs are in place, that might be a whole separate discussion or small group to tackle that as well down the road here. We have been working on solutions around the fee structures. We have been since that time and have some pretty good ideas about things, but they're all incorporated with that certified property component. I just wanted to kind of throw those things out there because it's...

47:48 There's some intertwined things there, and I just want to make sure that we look at that, because it's important. I mean, that's, you know, we know that the way that, again, the way that we're going to help solve the housing problem, it takes a lot of money to do that, and so there has to be a way to generate that. And, again, looking at that missing middle, which I know we all are struggling with as far as trying to find employees and so forth to fill positions, they're mostly in that missing middle, and there is no real government funding for that.

48:17 So as Chris said, we're on our own, right? I just want to back you up on that, John. That's something that I am looking for through this is to maybe find a way to fund housing through short-term rentals, and I think there is room for that. I don't know if that's something to put aside for now or if that is something that this committee should be working on. I kind of feel like it's something this committee should be working on. And if it's wrapped into the certified...

48:48 What's it called? Certified properties. Certified properties, then yes, but I want us to definitely be paying attention to it as we're... And just keep in mind as we look at that, how you do that from a fee charge, it has to be related to a service provided. You can't just be the rate, you can't do it, I want to raise money to go do housing because it has nothing to do with the service being provided. Right, I understand that. So the... The tax elements, so then they would be broadly construed to whoever's, it's hard to carve out a... Can I make a suggestion?

49:20 I have nine board members. Optimal committee size is three, so that's enough for three committees. If we appoint three to zoning and three to the enforcement or the certified properties, the other three could spend their time maybe looking into options for tax or exploring programs. I know it's not necessarily a direct thing that we were directed by town council to do, but it is sort of related.

49:50 So perhaps we need to form a third committee and put people on that. Matt, what I would suggest if you do that, and it was to Chris's comment related to kind of a second half of that, part two, if you will. If we look at it and say, how do we provide carrots and sticks, if you will, to transition existing housing over and create new housing? Yeah, and funding options. Or it's the subsidy for renting or it's buying a deed. There's a number of elements that go into that that usually all involve money.

50:20 We could take that piece and say, have a group actually look at that. That's a heavy lift, frankly, but it is something that I think fits in with the short-term rental element. It doesn't necessarily affect the outcomes of our recommendations for short-term rental new enforcement program or lifting of the moratorium, but it could be something we start working on.

50:46 And maybe continue after the moratorium. The other thing we can do, too, is certainly we can have a maximum of four people on any one committee. Yeah, if you do three by three or you can do two, it doesn't matter. And you can have people on... You can't have on... If you have four people and they're overlapping, then you've actually got five people talking about an item that potentially you're running through some conflicts. Got it. So you can't have four people on one committee and four people on another committee. Yeah, because you're going to have overlap and as soon as you...

51:13 Start talking about something that interchanges with the other committee, you're running afoul, so it would just, and I hate to say just the way committees work, I'll guarantee you that'll happen. Do we have, I mean, it sounds like we can have up to three committees.

51:30 See the need for two committees right now at this meeting. We could do a third. We could do a third, like, as it presents itself. Or you could do that tonight, frankly. That would be all right with that. And then if we found the need for more committees, would it just be divvying up the work to those three committees? Could you do that? Yeah, you could give them another topic and assignment. What we're hoping is we capture the larger areas and that once we dig into that, there's going to be certainly some fine-tuning and things that float to the surface. So we could be, but they'd be.

52:01 Probably within those areas. I don't think there's going to be a whole new work stream that shows up. Keep in mind, all this has to come back to the full board here, the full committee for action and recommendations and then moving up, depending on the item, moving up to the planning commission, up to town council. It seems best to do three people to a committee and then we could possibly have three committees instead of bounding ourselves to two committees. And it sounds like you have three general topic areas that can work very well. It's great because, truthfully, this...

52:31 The zoning is a big lift on its own, and the carrots and sticks committee, which sounds fun. I want to be on the carrots. I think that's great. I think it's going to flow really well. The other thing is, the first committee, which is the certified properties, has already, you know, on the staff report, you see that it's laid out really well, and that's a committee that needs to get together, get moving, make recommendations, come back to us, because I feel like that

53:01 Committee, the faster it goes, the more we're going to show success for everything we're trying to do, and, you know, that's the committee that ends the moratorium, right? The subcommittee. That action is what, because the other things naturally take longer, and they're not going, I mean, they just realistically can't be completed by May, but they are not rate-limiting steps for us, because

53:30 I think what we're all trying to do is move together as a community as effectively as possible. Yeah, to address that, and I will kind of say that nothing we do in here affects the moratorium and its existence, but you're talking about taking to counsel the ability to end it sooner rather than later. Correct. And what this means is these are regulations by which the management will happen, right? One of the concerns I've had with certified properties is

53:58 Especially over the last couple of weeks. So much has been thrust upon that that it's like that's the one thing, right? It's certified properties and we'll all be magical. The fact of the matter is certified properties is an administration of a program tool, right? My crew has come up with this a year and a half ago on how we need to manage this. And I'm prepared with either the committee or the larger group here tonight.

54:23 To go through the reasons why we addressed each and every one of those points. So folks would kind of understand that. But what it isn't is it isn't all management of it, right? So when you talk about management, you're talking about a connection to the zoning side, a connection to the right, to rent side. So I want to kind of make that point is that certified properties is maybe more narrow than people believe it to be, but it's got huge ramifications that are beneficial. But there's still that other component of management.

54:52 Of short-term rental, or short-term rentals, that's maybe a little bit outside of that certified property, so you're aware of that. Sure, sure. You're my guest. Yeah, go ahead, Christina. Go ahead, Christina. Yeah. So these subcommittees that you guys are creating, are other people allowed to be on those committees, or do they have to be comprised of this group? It's actually comprised of this group. If we actually start, if we point other people to it, then it becomes a public meeting, and you're...

55:23 Running it just like you do this one. There's an agenda, there's a meeting time and date, it's out, and the committee has to stay to the item on the agenda, and it's more of a formalized process. You couldn't just say, hey, let's all get together tomorrow at your place. That's why I'm asking. So it's like, if I want to have input into a zoning committee, you're saying there's no way for me to do that. It'd be difficult for that. It all comes back here.

55:49 That's where you then say, hey, here's some recommendations or here's where we're at. Dan, wouldn't she be able to speak with somebody on that committee as a member of the public and just say, hey, these are my thoughts or worries? That's where I understand the concern about growing the committee. Obviously, more voices is there. If nobody here is actually a second-hand homeowner, I feel like that voice should be heard. So this meeting, like you're doing right now, this is the opportunity to address that. And each one of these topics will be brought up.

56:20 Here. Like these topics, the subcommittee topics will be brought up here and then you'd be able to, you know, voice your concerns at that point before it goes to town council or anything. But certainly, you know, any member of the public can come to me and give me their comments and I can either, you know, I can bring them to the subcommittee or the general committee or whatever. So that's still completely an option if you want to do it that way. You can talk to somebody that way.

56:46 I'll get all of your numbers later. You can't do the additional appointments. That just changes what they are. You can save some gas money and just call. You don't have to drive up. We have an additional public comment. Okay, great. Go ahead. Dan, please unmute yourself and give your comment. Oh, I just want to say that I think you guys are doing a great job. I really appreciate you guys volunteering your time. Just a few suggestions.

57:17 I think the ideas to solving the housing affordability problem for local residents is important, obviously. It was very important to the town council, and that's why they instituted this more occurring, more short-term rental permits. I think it's important to try to come up with ideas and then quantify the cost.

57:42 Let's say there's 300 units. I mean, it's affordability and availability of housing that's a problem. And let's say there's 300 units that need to be subsidized. And let's say it's $10,000 a year. So that's $3 million. And then that way, you know, OK, we need $3 million extra revenue. And you can propose the sources of revenue to fund whatever you think is needed to.

58:07 To subsidize the housing or to do Section 8 housing or whatever, make agreements with local hotels or property owners or whatnot to make that housing available to homeowners. Just figure out a solution there, what the cost is, and then propose that to the town council so they can raise the revenue to solve that problem. Because I don't think limiting short-term rental permits is going to solve any housing problem, in my personal opinion.

58:37 I do think that permits should be issued on short-term rentals. It should be issued to homeowners, as was sort of suggested here. And the permits should be issued to homeowners. Whoever is on the deed should be on the permit. And then the management company essentially acts as the agent for the homeowner. And then the permits, it just makes things much easier. It's easier to switch management companies. And the permit resides with the homeowner and they're responsible for maintaining it. And then when a new property is sold.

59:06 The new owner must go and apply for the new permit. I think would be the best way to go there on that. On the resort side of zoning, I do totally agree with what's been brought up as far as the corridors. I'm in Mammoth Estates. We have a front office. We're 800 feet from the village gondola.

59:31 So I really think that, like, you look at any development along Lakeview there, most of the condo developments, I mean, those are all short-term rentals. I mean, 1849 is the same. I mean, you're, you know, whatever, 600 feet from walking to the, you know, to the canyon lodge there. So proximity to canyon, proximity to eagle, proximity to the village, those should be sort of, you know, that seems pretty, I mean, I think we should make the criteria clear, but.

59:57 Nobody's going to want to live there full-time and it's very expensive to live there full-time and most people have gone through the expense of developing their units and made big investments as I have to make it, you know, attractive to other, to people wanting to do short-term renting. So I think Certified Rental Program is perfect just for safety. That sounds great. And that's it. I think you guys are doing a great job. That's all I want to say. Those are my sort of main points there.

1:00:25 So thanks very much for letting me speak. Thank you, Dan, for those comments. Really appreciate it. Any other discussion before we, you know, is there anything that we, anybody feels that we're really missing? Yes. Please go ahead, go for it. And I'm assuming this will fall under the certified, you know, committee, but it is imperative that we work as quickly as possible to release these licenses that are frozen in place.

1:00:53 And, I mean, Chris and I already discussed this. This has to happen immediately. And so I think whoever is on that committee for the Certified Property Program, that's the first thing you need to tackle. I mean, I just got a call today from an owner that hasn't been running with me for six months and she wants to go on her own. She was sobbing to me on the phone because she's frozen. And anyway, we just can't string these people out until May. That would be, how does that coordinate? It's not actually something that...

1:01:24 That we can address in here, okay? We are working through, and Chris said it very well, we've got to get through the certified properties component, which is the updates to how these things are managed, and we need to get that in place. That's going to take the same process, not exactly the same process of what Nolan had mentioned, but it's going to take the first reading, second reading, 30-day implementation for those rules and regulations to take effect. Once that occurs, those rules and regulations will be in effect.

1:01:52 The certified properties will be a part of that. Everything is outlined here as far as who owns the certificate. That will be addressed. And as quickly as we can get that done is exactly when that can be solved for. We don't have the ability to say, that's a problem. We need to solve for that because that would require us to go through and then make other ancillary changes to the municipal code, which we could put those forward, but then that's first reading, second reading, 30-day implementation. It's almost the same thing. Okay.

1:02:22 Cynthia, I totally agree, and I know that was discussed at the council last night that that was a very unfortunate, unintended consequence of the moratorium was this situation where people are kind of stuck in the middle. But it sounds like, I hate to say it is what it is, but it is what it is. Sorry, one more. I hate to keep stringing this out. BAE's report, you said hopefully by December meeting? Yeah, it was depending on the data.

1:02:52 Getting the data together, getting it crunched. The timeline was originally we looked at trying to get something that by mid-December, so the 12th meeting it could be. If it's done before then, we'll ship it out. If it's done, if it gets after that, we'll ship it when it's ready. We'll put it out, whatever we have together. There's a couple ways. They have a draft and ultimately a final, so a draft out for comment and then understanding that and then going forward. Maybe we should table the third committee until after the BAE report and see what they say.

1:03:22 And just worry about the two that we have now, knock them out, and then we are able to make our recommendation, and then based on whatever the BAE reports, we might revise zoning, or probably not going to change the certified properties program that much at that point, because you guys have been working on it, it seems pretty well thought out. Maybe we focus on those two committees. At that meeting, we get the BAE report, we re-look at zoning.

1:03:50 And then we consider if we want to focus on at that point, the certified properties will be finished, hopefully. I mean, it seems pretty well flushed out. So I don't know, maybe we have a couple thoughts and processes. We can't increase fines without running afoul of laws. We can't add taxes. So there's not a whole lot we can do to the certified properties other than look at the day-to-day aspects. So like what it does to the homeowners.

1:04:18 Who are renting and how the management companies are going to be affected by it? Those are pretty much the only two things I see that we can really make change. Well, there's actually quite a bit of stuff that can be done within the certified properties world. When we generated that originally, it was to solve problems that we had, right? And you asked me to put together a list of what we were trying to solve for, and I have that to discuss. But as we've been working through this and sort of talking about quality of life challenges,

1:04:46 Talking about safety challenges, talking about those things that are community-based. There are adjustments that can be made within certified properties that would address that. So there is quite a few things with regard to this committee needs to discuss and talk about that we'll bring forward and how that's finally shaped. The fees for that program, right? So the fee to obtain a certificate, we've worked through some different approaches to that, right? And so there's discussions around that.

1:05:15 What happens when a sale occurs? You know, that comes forward, too. I mean, there's a lot of finer points that do need to be worked out. While we addressed a lot of things, and I'll walk through that at some point, either in this broader group or as a subcommittee, why we did what we did. But I kind of put in here, here's everything we were going to do, and then here's some items in bold that I see opportunities. So there's quite a bit to do. Do you think it's realistic that we could have it done by around the same time as the BAE report, or do you think we're...

1:05:43 I'm targeting sometime in January, so I think we can do that, honestly. I think a couple of good sit-down meetings, we can definitely get through everything on the table, which would frame up the thought process around what we're trying to achieve, and I think give people the opportunity to say, here's a solution, here's a suggestion, and from that, get to a finer point pretty quick. I think the goal there is... I've been leaving it on now, Kate.

1:06:23 Can I make a suggestion for the committees? Would either of the chairs mind heading zoning potentially or you're also involved in the other one? This is a tough one. I wish I could be on both because, you know, just to explain my property management company, it's quite different than you, the two of you. It's just my partner and I and then I have one employee and so we wear all hats.

1:06:44 I mean, I am working with renters every day. I am setting rates. I am, you know, working with owners because I've sold them the property and I'm setting the property up, you know, to be rented. And then I'm working with Rob and Danny in the town to pay my taxes and making sure my licenses are correct. So I add a lot of value to the Certified Property Management Program, but you've already made a lot of headway with it. And then on the flip side, then there's a zoning. And, I mean, I sell all that real estate. And so I think I am definitely a...

1:07:14 Far more suitable for the zoning portion of it. But it pains me to not participate with a certified property program. And keep in mind, all of it comes back. Participate, just not in the subcommittee. Yeah, okay. But, Jennifer, can suggest two things. One would be, I think, based on all the comments, I kind of lean to maybe putting that third committee in place, because I think that's another area we can begin working on and start bringing data forward. It actually may help inform even the BAA work with somebody like that to help. So we're not...

1:07:45 lagging behind in one area. I guess my question this evening before we carve up the teams and stuff, do you want to hear Rob's a relatively brief overview of the Certified Properties Program? And that may help people go, yes, that's something I would like to be engaged with, or I'd like to volunteer somebody else to do it.

1:08:07 Well, I think it would be really helpful because I'm very familiar with the Quality of Life Program. It would be wonderful if you could touch briefly on what that is, then the Certified Property Program and what the difference is between the two because I've been asked that a lot and there's some confusion. But just real quick before you do that, I just want to make sure we're talking about different committee numbers. So the first committee would be looking at the Certified Property Program.

1:08:32 The second committee, as I see it, is the zoning committee? And then the third committee would be the sort of the fees and... Oh, it's revenue and stuff. Carrots and sticks. Carrots and sticks. Carrots and sticks. I like it. It's a really good name. Oh, it's great. I love that. It's how do we look at some transition to housing, how do we look at housing opportunities. So carrots and sticks, I think. I just want to make sure I knew one, two, three. Sure, with that, yeah, Rob, please go through your presentation. Yes. I think it'll help people choose what they want to work on.

1:09:02 I hope. I was fearful it was going to be a popularity contest and Nolan was going to get all the staff. Okay, certified properties. So I'm going to walk through this, and I'm hoping you all have read a lot of the details. I know we've represented the program a few times, but this is in the context of what we were trying to achieve. So first and foremost is safety. So we...

1:09:35 Our inspection program right now exists if you are a new operator or a new owner, your properties are inspected. When this was first initiated, we had a number of properties that were not, they were grandfathered in, right? So a lot of them have not been inspected ever. We see in our daily jobs challenges when something changes hands and it hasn't been inspected or it's been inspected maybe too long ago, a couple of years.

1:10:03 Four or five years ago, a lot of the safety elements are not there, right? Fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, all the things that are really required. And if you have to think about it as this is a business which is housing occupants that are not aware of the dangers that this can pose. Go back to the winter, right? We had these very unique situations with propane and snow on roofs. So it's kind of a unique situation. We need to have...

1:10:33 This stuff as safe as possible. So that frequency of the inspection program was one of the key elements. It basically said there are no grandfathering in. Every unit has to be inspected. The inspection schedules, in order to be able to accomplish that with our inspection crew, which we only have, like, there's five now. Okay, good. Is that if 25% of the properties, roughly 880 properties a year have to be inspected, every four years is an appropriate time. But that would just be the regular generation.

1:11:04 That was the desire to do that. So we were basically saying, hey, every property gets inspected and every property gets inspected every four years. Subsequent to that, now this is where the bolded items come in, is an extension of the safety element, right? So then looking back at the storms that occurred. So these are businesses. These are things that may or may not fit.

1:11:32 normal expectations of residents. For example, if you have a business, perhaps you need a roof shoveling plan for heavy winters. Perhaps that you need to be able to bring your condo or unit up to current standards for propane service protection, right, the dog houses that are over that. Perhaps there needs to be a propane shutoff valve in the front.

1:12:00 Area for your house, not currently required. But these are things to sort of discuss, and that talks back to the safety of elements, and that would be then a part of the inspection program. Not only the inspection program, but the requirements for that. So a little bit of expansion. Really also looking at how do we improve quality of life impacts in protecting neighbors. So there are noise mitigation aspects that need to be added.

1:12:27 Maybe signage and check-in practices for time of day and so forth. And just how do we improve the visitor experience? That's a whole other larger nebulous thing. I think part of this process is this is our main business. We need to sort of understand are there minimum standards of what is a quality experience for our visitor, meaning the unit itself. All that stuff wraps up into this inspection program, right, is options.

1:12:56 This is where it's, and hopefully this illustrates enough, I had solutions we were solving for us. That's the first section. These are all ancillary and more to quality of life for the community, quality of life for the visitors, and safety. So that's the safety umbrella. Penalties. So, you know, basically the original intent was bad operators can lose their certification and the ability to rent.

1:13:22 That's first and foremost. Operators who fail to adequately address visitor problems, they could also lose their certificate. Violations to health, safety, fire, building, noise, parking, occupancy, trash, all of the things that are required, just sort of running afoul of that stuff. And I'm not talking about, oh, I stubbed my toe and this person missed it and we snagged your certificate. It is a failure to adequately address these things, right?

1:13:51 I mean, we have issues sometimes with the visitors are often part of the problem, right? I mean, they're coming up and having maybe, say, in a noise ordinance, for example. We're not going to say, you know, hey, you're an operator and you had, your visitors had a noisy party and therefore you're going to lose your certificate. It's more, this is a common problem. You have failed to address it either through other processes and things like that. So that's where we've got to get your attention one way or another.

1:14:21 That was the original intent. Expansion of that, again, back into the other section, could be operators who perform remodels or construction without a permit. You know, that's out there. Failed audit results. And when we see, we do audits a lot, and we see two, when we have findings or significant findings, we see two things. It is education. I didn't know. And it's clear to us whether that's true or not.

1:14:49 And then there's the, we're just fudging the numbers, right? And there's, I don't know what the mixture is on those two, but they both exist. And I think if you are, back to John's comment earlier, if you're willfully fudging your numbers, the possibility of losing your certificate is great, right? That's a thing. So, and in this stuff, I mean, there's all kinds of things to discuss.

1:15:17 What is the process, right? Is it a three-month? Is it a six-month? Is it a 12-month? What's the trigger points? What determines that? I mean, I, as a tax collector, which these things would be my job to implement, I need that definition of when that goes into place. What's the process for review? Like, maybe there's a committee review, an appeal to counsel, typically those types of things, duration parameters, etc. So there's a lot of things to, that's a very powerful tool. We see it.

1:15:46 I'll be honest. One of the challenges we have is the extent of our teeth today in enforcement is a lean on the property. We can get to that point and we lean the property. That's fairly successful, but it's not absolute. This is a threat of loss of revenue that's immediate, and it's really powerful. It's really powerful, not only for adhering to the processes, but just trying to not run afoul anywhere else in the element.

1:16:17 So that's the penalties side of things. Another element is an interactive map. So what we were trying to solve for is, this goes back to then the experience of the neighbors, right, quality of life. If I don't know where the properties are renting, right, I want to be able to look at a map and see if my neighbor's property is a legal rental, right? I know there's somebody there renting it, but I don't know if it's a legal rental. So the idea was a...

1:16:46 It wasn't our own, but we captured, I think, from Scottsdale. But they have a map of the town. They have dots where there's legal rental activity. You click on that dot, you get this list of information. We have that out in beta right now. That's on our website. You can actually see that. But there's some things to work through that, like what level of information do we want to see, right?

1:17:12 What should we share? Right now, it's sort of the 24-hour contact. That would be critical for someone who may be having a problem. It's like, who do I call to get that resolved for a noisy party or something along those lines other than just the police? But that interactive map is designed to address that. Emergency contacts. We struggle with the 24-hour contact. That's something that's required in your current process today. The 24-hour contact is...

1:17:38 Some people have a business to do that. There's like some folks we call up and say, you can contract with this person, you pay them and they will be your 24-hour contact. Otherwise, you have to be someone who's local and in the area. And a lot of these things are owned and operated from afar. So that's kind of a challenge. So beefing that up was part of the certified process. That would be a larger, not only are you providing the name, but we're vetting it out. We're going through and contacting, confirming and so forth.

1:18:08 The other element, and this kind of came up, you know, probably from some of the health care, health order type things, was cleaning services, right? Make sure that we have an actual licensed business doing your cleaning in town, right? So there's not, yeah, or laundry or things like that. I mean, things that we can reach in and understand what the quality of the service is.

1:18:35 That's a safety issue for the visitors, right, going back to the health order issue. So the cleaning businesses, they are actually registered with us, and they would be a part of the certified properties. They would be designated as such in that. So both of those items could be published in the interactive map. I don't know that the cleaning one needs to be, but that's an important part of it. So property owners are the responsible party, okay?

1:19:01 You know, management companies do a wonderful job of helping people run these things. And trust me, as someone who has to deal with people who don't run them very well sometimes, that's a blessing that that happens. But they also insulate the clients to the point where they don't really understand they are running a business, right? They don't understand that their property being rented out has these extra layers of expectation, extra layers of liability.

1:19:29 And so that insulation isn't helpful when it comes to our only solution is a lien on the property, right? Because the responsible party then is the homeowner. And regardless of the activities and things that occur at the property management company level, the property owner is the final responsible party for that. So what this certified properties was to do is to establish a relationship with that owner, right?

1:19:58 When we talk about the TOT certificates, and I went through this last night if everybody was watching, but a certificate is issued to someone who holds an operator in town, which is a business owner. That business owner can be the owner of the condo, but they've registered with the town. We're flipping that upside down and saying the owner of the property is the one who owns the certificate.

1:20:22 Another thing, too, right now with a TOT cert, there can be multiple, and in many cases there are several multiple TOT certs for one property. That's a management nightmare for us, you know, because it's down to the operator. So if a management company had it, they have a TOT certificate for it. If a subsequent manager, they change management companies, that subsequent manager had to go get a TOT certificate for it. So it's just a, it's not a very well laid out program, and it's, I don't know the history of it.

1:20:50 It's been there longer than either one of us have been here. And so it was developed, you know, best-case scenarios back in the day. So this, flipping it upside down and saying, we're going to go through all this process of inspecting the property, establishing that they're an owner, that they're a business, maybe even adding those elements of expectation with regard to, you know, safety of their occupants. But that's going to be at the property level. And then the certificate is issued for that property.

1:21:20 That certificate belongs to the owner of the property, and they can then shop around for whatever management company they want to do, but just all we ask is that in the advertisement for whatever management company that is operating that, they list that certified property number, right, that we would issue. There's some deeper, I don't want to get too deep in the weeds, but you do have to have somebody running your business, right? You can't just have a certificate and not have it attached to a business.

1:21:50 And there's really specific reasons for that. One of the biggest enforcement opportunities we have, we call it falling off the wagon. Someone opens a business, they start renting for three or four months, they stop remitting taxes, they stop remitting returns. What we find is they just decided to stop paying us and continue to do business. And that's probably 75 or 80 percent of our enforcement activity.

1:22:16 Honestly. And so if we were allowing a certificate to exist without attaching it to a program, we would sort of augment that bad behavior, right? Right now, they have to file. And as an operator, you have to file with the town every single month, even if you have no activity. So what we end up with is zero returns filed when, in fact,

1:22:41 We've got, you know, Rentalscape does an excellent job of identifying exactly how much rental activity is going on. So we can look at the two and go, huh, that's weird. You're saying zero, but we're seeing all these reviews. We're seeing all this revenue being generated online. So what's the difference here, right? So they've committed themselves with this submission of a zero return without having them be attached to some sort of a...

1:23:08 So, again, back to the relationship. We would capture their contact information. We use constant contact to send out mass emails. We know when a mass email is opened and read. That's very helpful. We have enforcement cases where we say, I didn't know about the health order. Well, on Tuesday at 7 a.m., you read it. Somebody did. That's your house.

1:23:39 So there's a lot of very cool functions that we can kind of have clarity around. And that certificate ownership, you know, is really the key element to it. I mean, it adds the responsibility, it adds the connection, it adds the portability. Now let's get to fee collection, right? So in the fee collection world, it's called the cost-born to produce the service, technical.

1:24:08 Wizardry. And so right now the fees are built on how much time does it take Danny to receive an applicant, walk somebody through it, process that, go through the analysis processes, because fire signs off on it, public health signs off on it, all these different elements. How long does that take? What's the collective cost of that experience? And that's the fee. So that's what defines it, right?

1:24:37 That would exist today in business tax certificates, and that will remain in business tax certificates, and that's the issuing of the license to operate. Under the Certified Properties Program, we're looking at it a little bit differently and saying, okay, I've got a percentage of my time. I've got a full percentage of several members of my team. There's a total of three full-time, one part-time in the revenue collection team.

1:25:05 And then my oversight to that. What we would probably end up doing is augmenting that with maybe some additional staff, maybe an additional full-time person and maybe a part-time person. The part-time does a lot of the enforcement activity. But collecting the overall cost of that entire group, cost of salary and benefits, cost of the monitoring program, which is originally what we tied the certified properties fee to. It's like, hey, the monitoring program is going to cost this amount.

1:25:34 So it's $45 per unit, right? That'll be rolled up. Any contract services that we do to support this activity, that will be in the pot, if you will. And then you've got to look at, okay, how many units do we have? 35, 72 today? What's, you know, maybe we go 3650 is the number of units that we would divide that total up against. And that comes up to a number of around $200 per certificate.

1:26:05 I can stand behind that from the rules and regulations required of me to determine a fee comfortably, right? I can say, you know, we've got crew, you know, I'd carve out one of my staff who would be doing a lot of the other non, not associated with this activity, mainly the other business tax stuff. But that's, I can stand behind, right? That seems to be something I can live with and that would place that fee at $200 instead of $45.

1:26:35 That's kind of what we've done so far within that certified property. So as you can see, there's originally designed to be specifically the administration of it, and now it can grow into more of the customer experience, more of the life safety, more of the quality of life. All of these things are governed by the municipal code. So if you look at the big red book, right there is one. That has all the rules and regulations. Whatever these...

1:27:04 Edits are, would have to be adjustments to specific languages in, I think it's three and five and maybe some of eight sections, chapters of the codebook. So we would make those edits and they would align with exactly what we intend to do and they would just be written in such a way that this is the rules, the laws that expect it, that's how it's done. And that's the part that you build that up and then that's what we bring to council, that starts the first reading.

1:27:34 15 days later, second reading, 30 days later, implementation. So that's the extent of certified properties in some of the ancillary fees. Any questions? Yeah, that's great, Rob. Thanks for walking through that. I think from my perspective, not to get too much in the weeds here, but the contracting with the owner, because with all of us, we're renting the property, but our contract is with that homeowner. And I have a lot of homeowners that say, well, I'm going to...

1:28:03 I'm going to sell in 14 days and the new guy is just going to take over. I go, no, it's with you. It's not transferable because if the person that's buying the property decides they just don't want to go on the rental program or they want to, you know.

1:28:16 Try to put 18 beds in the place or some crazy thing, whatever, then they just can't own those bookings, and those bookings have to be moved somewhere else, and that person's just, that unit's done until we get a new, and we do the same thing, a new inspection, new information, all that. So it makes sense, certainly, that it goes, that it does go with the owner and not the properties. It has been suggested that that would be a way to do it, but the property is also going to potentially change with the owner. Things will change, like you mentioned.

1:28:46 Let's see. One question I did have, and I think I know the answer to this, but if the committee that's getting together, if they decide, hey, we'd really like to see these things every three years, obviously that's an increase in staff, and that's an increase in the cost. But that's all scalable, right? I mean, provided you can find housing for the people that you need to hire. Inspections are contracted. Yeah, they're third parties, because it requires specific skill sets. Basically? Okay.

1:29:15 Yeah. So we- They're out there, yes. Yeah. Okay. Understood. They have to be licensed, you know, business. Okay. And the only other question I have is- Real quick, the other thing adding to that that we've talked about is we have, we saw that with the moratorium, a lot of people getting certificates not utilizing them. So you can think about it, okay, I'm going to get one from the place I live in, I don't like to use it. You're still going to get inspected. And so we're going to walk through your personal home and go, by the way, here's your violations.

1:29:44 So you could get dinged and just go, wait a minute, but I'm not renting. Correct, but you're in the position to rent, which would be, the other night somebody suggested, you know, looking at people who don't utilize it, they're still under those, they still have to file every month, and they would still be under that inspection and those types of elements they'd have to go through. And for some folks that, they may not want a town contract inspector tromping through their home. Hey, by the way, where's your fire extinguisher?

1:30:12 I don't know, the kids were playing with it. Ancillary to that as well, you know, and again, if it goes back to, this is outside of certified properties, if there's a discussion around caps in the number of properties, then I think there will be a lot of discussion around minimum usage and that type of thing, because you're sitting on a commodity at that point, right? And so that's a different element than certified properties, but it's a management of STR's components.

1:30:40 I think, yeah, there's a minimum expectation. You don't just get to get a certificate and sit on it, even if you go through the processes. But again, that's a little bit outside of... I would agree. I'm glad you mentioned that because I had that on my notes that until there's a determination that there's going to be a cap, it doesn't make sense to discuss that stuff. Any other questions about the program? Yeah, Chris, go ahead. Thanks. On page three, the first bullet, violations of municipal code may result in a revocation of certificate.

1:31:13 What happens to those who rent without a certificate? I think it would be, I think it's just helpful for everybody to understand, because I know, like I was looking at the code, but I think it'd be helpful for us to have that level set. Sure, sure. So we're doing a number of things, right? So right now you have to have your BTC indicated on your rental, okay? So the system itself tells us when there's a missing one.

1:31:44 We go out and let's say we find somebody who's doing this illegally, right? They don't have a permit to do this. And there's two of those, right? There's two different possibilities. It's a zoning violator, which means you're not zoned for that. So you're in a quality of life area that doesn't allow short-term rentals, but you're renting. Or there's what's called a revenue violator, which is someone who has the ability to get a certificate but does not. My team will go through and we make initial contact. We use a citation.

1:32:14 And that's governed, we do the maximum allowable citation amounts, and the first one is $500 still? It's $1,500? Okay. So $1,500 fine for your first one. You have 15 days to contact us, that fine was, that is waived, that citation is waived. What we do in that first 15 days is we say, give us your rental data, right?

1:32:40 We've got a good idea at what the rental data is because of what Rentalscape provides to us, but we want to have information from the operator to tell us exactly what their rental were. That takes a bit of time sometimes. That takes a long time. Let's say that somebody doesn't get back to us in the 15 days. The first thing that we do then is we issue a subsequent, the second citation, which is $3,000 as well as an assessment.

1:33:08 As well as an assessment. So an assessment is, and we've had this once or twice in my lifetime where someone said, yeah, we'll just pay the assessment. But the assessment is taking a hotel and saying, how much occupancy do you have in a room? How frequently is it booked? And it's pretty frequent. And that's what's your nightly rate that's advertised. So if it's $800 a night, then we say, for the last three years, this is your rental activity.

1:33:36 Astronomical sometimes, right, if they're large. And it's really, all this stuff is designed to get someone's attention. It's like, if you choose not to talk to me about what your rental activity is, we have a program for that that will assign a value. That's the assessment side of things. Oftentimes, like I said, most people say, okay, well, here's my actuals, right? Because that's just an algorithm to determine the value of the rental activity.

1:34:05 And so we want to know the real activity. We want to get that stuff. So then we get reports from their rental platform, right? That's what we request. We ask for that data. We can compare that to what was reported to us on Rentalscape. That's pretty accurate on that stuff. We put it into a spreadsheet. It calculates all of the late fees, all of the penalties, all of the interest for both TOT and TBID.

1:34:33 Then there are enforcement charges and whatever citations were initiated. So let's say someone doesn't, even after that, we give them three, two days? It's a cooling period? Yeah, so, well, it's the mail period. So we, you know, mail in Mammoth isn't exactly super quick, right? So we do have to give people the opportunity to receive the mail and make effort. That effort looks like a call to us or removal of your ad.

1:34:59 That's the first thing we tell you to do, and we highlight all of that in writing. But if you don't do that, we've got to give people a chance to receive that mailing. They get the mailing in two ways, a certified mailing and first class. First class. And people sometimes don't accept certified mail, but first class, if it's not returned to us, is determined delivered. That's part of the municipal code element, right? If you read that, it says that we will consider it to be received if not returned.

1:35:29 And that works pretty good. Now, if you do not respond after the two days you have from the $3,000 citation, you get a $5,000 citation. We have the ability and the authority to submit a $5,000 citation every single day until we hear you, per unit, until we hear from you. And we do that. If you talk about going fast, it gets serious in a heartbeat. So sometimes, yes.

1:36:01 These are attention getters, right? These are things that we've got to get you, we implore you to contact us. We have two things as an appeal. We have a citation hearing, so that's done with a hearing officer within the town, not me. I'm sort of the plaintiff in this, and they're the defendant. But we present our case, we go through the detail of exactly what we did.

1:36:26 Questions will be asked about why they didn't respond, why they went through those things, and sometimes there's legitimate reasons, and the hearing officer can reduce the citations. That's all they can do is reduce citations. But oftentimes, I mean, if there's just like, hey, no, I was just thumbing my nose, then there'll be no relief, right? And then subsequent to that is an appeal to town council. You have to come to council, you have to explain why you were doing the illegal activity you were doing, why you think this is egregious.

1:36:54 And council makes a decision on whether to provide relief at all. But those are the processes by which we go through that. It's very effective. I heard it last night. Someone said, well, I'm just going to not tell you about it. We've got a program for that, and it's painful. It is absolutely painful. Don't look at me. I follow the rules, okay?

1:37:17 But you know how painful it could be. I have a serious question to ask. If, okay, your little fancy system that you have that goes after these people, how do you go after them when they have private Facebook accounts, private Instagram, they're advertising their property under the table within their company?

1:37:36 Private company email addresses. How do you catch that person? And especially now, because it's one thing to catch a person renting their cute little A-frame off of Mono Street, because we know that that's illegal. But how do you capture somebody in 1849, which is like the neighbors are not going to tattle on that person. They have no idea who's coming and going. Yeah. There's a lot of identifiers of when activity is going on.

1:38:06 Put it that way. And there are a lot of people that are looking for that. I'm not going to go through the detail about how we may do some of that stuff because it's a tool. You know, we can rent properties. We rent properties. We go to the properties and we look at them and we take a look at the guest book. We get all kinds of information from that. But there's a lot of things that we've seen out there.

1:38:35 To a point to some level, if it's truly, truly underground, underground, it's hard to catch. Generally, somewhere along the line, they screw up. Or we will get a complaint. We'll get somebody else. And you go back to that map thing. Hey, I just want to look and say, is this actually a legal rental? And the answer is no, but there's a different group of people there every weekend. Yeah. I just think that underground black market that has been created now due to this moratorium is going to be really tough.

1:39:02 It's a huge risk, though. I'm just telling you. I don't support it. I want to be clear. I'm just, I'm the messenger. There's no way on earth that anything that we do is foolproof. It's not perfect. But when it comes down, it comes down hard. And one of the questions to that, and this here would be something for, we will hear that from people. Well, I know so-and-so is doing this, but I'm not going to tell anybody. Well, I hate to say, but that's kind of shame on us for actually not.

1:39:30 Well, I guess I'm guilty of that because I do have my clients that are now telling me, like, but they're telling me I'm just going to rent to my friends and family. Like, so you can't rent their condo to their cousin? That is correct. They cannot. Well, I mean, I will pass that message along, but I am. No, people can, they can use your condo, but there can be no rumination. There's no payment. No exchange of value. No exchange of monies. We do get those, yeah. And then when they do get caught.

1:40:02 It's very, very painful for them to have a, you know, we've seen stuff. Oh, I know, you're getting a big check next week from someone, so. Well, yeah, we look at that, and I mean, we've had somebody, you know, it's a while back, but it's nothing to have a $25,000, $30,000, $40,000, okay, here you go, I'll pay it. A lot of them are a lot smaller than that, and others are on payment plans because of the size of them. And? What percentage of rental activity is happening illegally?

1:40:33 Is it just a ballpark, or do you think it's pretty minimal? No, you know, I would say it's less than 10%. You know what I mean? I've heard people say, oh, you're not even capturing half of it. It's like, that's not true. But, you know, to your point, there is definitely some elements of it out there. I mean, we have upwards of 50. I mean, how many different enforcement cases would you say we're running a year, typically? Generally around 50, annually, yeah.

1:41:02 So that's a fair amount. Most of them are revenue violators. There's only ones we can do nothing for, right? You're in a zone you can't rent. That's tougher to deal with. Yeah, so we do about 50 a year. I think our revenue is somewhere just south of half a million dollars.

1:41:26 And penalties, interest. And that only includes the actual back taxes that are owed with penalties and interest. We don't count the stuff moving forward once they become a legal operator. Part of the general. I mean, and so we do see we're adding to the TOT with they become a good operator. You don't see a lot of repeat offenders. Oh, yes. Well, we go back to the fall off the wagon program where they start as an enforcement case. We get them up, we get them running, and then they trip and fall and become an enforcement case again. Start the process all over again.

1:41:54 It's fairly common that there's three, four iterations of that. Is that typically people who are... Absolutely. And we recommend they find a property manager that can handle that for them. That'd answer me to another question. I mean, of course, this benefits, you know, me and all the property managers in town. But, I mean, is it something that the town can, like, really force an owner to use a property management company? Because they're allowed to just... You can't mandate it. You can't mandate it, yeah.

1:42:28 I just want to be mindful of time. I know some people have a hard stop at 7, so hopefully that's helpful, and I don't know if that helps you say yes, I'd love to dive into this, or no, please leave me out of that one. I was just going to say, I'd like to volunteer for the Certified Program Subcommittee. I don't know how we're going to do this. No, that's great. Before we go into that, are there any, just to make sure, any other questions, yes, Chris, or comments or anything? Okay.

1:42:58 I have a quick question. So are we going to have the three committees? It's the first two that we've talked about, and then we're going to have the housing committee as well. And if we are having the three, if like, because there's two I'm really interested in, can I be on one and then next meeting switch to the other? So it's, you have to stay on the only one. The whole idea is that we can't have a larger quorum in this whole conversation going across the committee outside of this room.

1:43:26 I almost guarantee you, if you do that, you will run afoul of talking about things that now we have a quorum of the board actually having a discussion outside of the board. For people that may not understand why we're so, yeah, the Brown Act is what dictates how public meetings are conducted and what definition of a public meeting is. It's very, very narrow, and so we, well, it's very broad. Not getting you in trouble. Correct. Or ourselves. So just to be clear, we have, we will have three different.

1:43:56 Committees, three groups. The first one is going to be, is going to focus on the certified properties in that program. The second is going to focus more on zoning with also a focus on housing and housing element of that, how that can help out long-term housing, community housing. And then the third will be more of a, will be the carrots and sticks committee, which I love. And we'll look at the revenue side of that and that sort of thing and incentives and so forth. So with that,

1:44:26 Let's see. I think the first one was the, that was the certified property. So Matt, you said you want to do that one? I'd be interested. Okay. So I'm going to put Matt on that. Is there anybody else that has a burning desire to be on that one? Team Rob. I do. Okay. Thank you. Sure.

1:44:43 Anyone else? And you don't have to, you can wait your turn and see what shows up where. We would like one person. Should we also talk about scheduling? Like, you know, if people, or I'm just saying, like, if people, like, you know, if some people work nights and some people work days, maybe we don't put them on the same committee or, you know, just like a general. Yeah, I would say if we could. Are these meetings from 9 to 5, Monday to Friday, or are we leaving that open? You can meet wherever the committee wants to meet. Okay.

1:45:08 I guess what I'd like to do is get a list of who would like to be in each one, and then quickly each group can go, hey, can we meet on a Tuesday or whatever, and if it seems like that's going to work out, great, because it may be, I mean, our next meeting is the 12th of December, so that's two weeks from tonight, or two weeks from Tuesday, last Tuesday. Okay, so we got 10 days, 12 days. 12 plus days. 12 plus days. So it may be, you know, if we can get a couple.

1:45:33 Depending on how long you want to meet and so forth, maybe it's only a couple of meetings, you know, hopefully two or three and we're good before the next meeting. Yeah, at least get a report out. Yeah, get a report out. Okay, anybody else for number one? I'm flexible. I don't know. Okay. All right, well, we'll go down to two. So, for the zoning. I feel like, Kelly, you might be a good fit on that one since you all the- You want to see the other one? The housing-

1:46:05 I know, I, I, it's tough, um, because I, I have the list, I can handle the list as well. That's okay, we can, we can, we can circle back. That's true. Yeah, that's true. If people have, if people have, if people really want to be on one, then, then that's fine. Yeah, I think I'd rather do, because I have a number of ideas to help out with locals in housing, so I think I'd rather be on the number three. Number three, okay. And then I'll give you the list. Okay. Yeah. Okay, so, yeah. Yeah, I'll do group number three. I think I have more experience in community housing than I do when. Number three.

1:46:35 Also when it comes to short-term rentals. So yeah, I think. Great. I'm flexible. I don't know. Let somebody else go first. I prefer three, but I'm flexible. Chris? I'll get assigned to whatever's left. John, what's your preference? Well, my first preference would be number three.

1:47:10 We have three good people on that. So, you know, I'm really interested in the certified properties, so I'd like to be on that one. Yeah, which would? Chris and I on the zoning. Chris and I on the zoning. Is that okay for Chris? Yeah, absolutely. Are we allowed to? Yeah. Yeah, it doesn't matter. There's no decision being made. All right, Cynthia, you get us guys. I memorized the property tour. I don't have to go again.

1:47:46 Zoning would be, we'll come back to all these, I just want to make sure. Sure, zoning was Cynthia, Chris, and Amanda. And the first was Matt, Jason, and myself, and the third is Kelly, Esora, and Zoning, Cynthia, Chris, and Amanda. Who's the third one again, sorry. Oh, I'm sorry, it's Kelly, Esora, and Alisa. I think maybe what we would do is...

1:48:22 Should we adjourn? And then go to our individual groups? And then if there's an issue, we can switch, but hopefully everybody can. Want any public comment? Oh, yeah, yeah. I'm sorry. Excuse me. Another quick question before. Will staff be coming to the subcommittee meetings to help support us? Okay, great. Okay. And then also, there was a quick question that we had, which is, Jamie, do you know how many people were participating on Zoom tonight?

1:48:50 Is there any way to know that? Okay, thanks. They dropped off after that. They fell right asleep. I have a question for the group. Not that it has to be all about me, but I do have a commitment on Tuesday the 12th, and I was wondering if we could move the meeting to 4 o'clock instead of 5. That's great for me. Tuesday the 12th? Yeah, that works. Okay, great.

1:49:37 Yeah, no problem. Let's do that. Let's do that to four. Great. Any other public comment? Jamie, anybody online? Dan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thanks very much. I just had a quick comment on, and this is kind of backing up to what was talked about a bit earlier, that there could be an underground market if you restrict the short-term rentals too much. I do think that is a valid point.

1:50:12 I actually think that short-term rentals should not be limited to zones, and that really the best answer really is to make it economic for short-term renter owners to move to monthly renting, and you're probably not going to get much of that in the areas around the resort areas like the village, but in town, if you have short-term rentals in town, maybe you have a town subsidized program that makes it more profitable for owners who

1:50:41 You're looking just to rent their properties. Maybe it makes it more economic for them to participate in that program because that's headache and they can just go with a monthly rental program that's subsidized by the town. So I think really an economic, you just got to make it economic for current owners to rent monthly. That's the problem. I think there's available housing. It's just you got to make it economic for...

1:51:05 Short-term rentals to move to that direction. I don't know that in the village I would have that. But anyway, that's my suggestion is just to not even have zones and have everybody who wants to do it, you know, sign up and it shouldn't be determined upon usage. If they want to pay the fees and get the inspections and have the permits, then let them do it. And, you know, the town will monitor it. So that's my two cents on that. I don't even think there should be zones. I think you're better off.

1:51:32 Just letting the market determine the best, the highest and best use for the property, so let the owners do it. Some owners maybe want to use the property part-time, so they would never want to do monthly rental. So that's my two cents. Thanks very much. Thank you, Dan. Appreciate the comments. Anyone else, Jamie? Marina, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:51:53 Hi, thanks. I'm glad I had the opportunity to watch. I wasn't going to say anything, but I'm so glad the last speaker said that about incentivizing property owners to provide longer-term rentals, because I would absolutely be interested in that as a property owner who's currently a short-term rental owner. But I find that it's a lot. It's a lot of work, and there's not always a lot of profit in it.

1:52:21 Anything that, first of all, would really closely look at how appealing it is to have a short-term rental for people who are thinking about it and the realities of what those profit margins might be versus what you could do with a longer-term rental, I think that could be something that the Carrots and Sticks Subcommittee could look at, hopefully. Thanks again. Thanks, Maureen. Appreciate those comments. Dave, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:52:56 Yes, actually, just a quick comment. Earlier, you guys were talking about the issue with people just having a long-term permit that they're sitting, or a short-term rental permit that they're sitting on and not actually using. But I think with the Certified Property Program, especially with having more rigorous inspection, if there's more cost to the permits, those people might self-select themselves out of that pool. In other words, if you set the system up,

1:53:25 To disincentivize people who just want to sit on a permit, I think you can accomplish that kind of through whatever you come up with with a certified property program. Any other comments? With that, I have a motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn. Second. Chris, great. We adjourned. Thanks, everybody. Appreciate it. Yes, always freezing. They're trying to get us in here. You had to bring all your clothes. Same place.

1:54:28 There was one meeting where...