TransparentMammoth

Short-Term Rental Committee · 2023

Short-Term Rental Committee

at 17:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

282 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:18 Oh, I'll kick it off. I just, we're still missing one person. Let's give her another couple of minutes. If not, we'll start. Carrie? Yeah. Okay. I hadn't heard, so. Green light is good. Red light ain't speaking off. Speaking directly into it is probably better than... If it doesn't work, we get texts about... Oh, sure. Good idea. Halfway. We'll go ahead and get started.

3:44 For those that don't know me, I'm Dan Holler, the town manager. I'll kind of kick it off. We'll get started through the agenda. And one of those will ultimately select the chair and vice chair for the committee. But we'll notice that. But I'm going to have the clerk do a roll call of committee members so we know who it all is here. Committee member Avery? Here. Committee member Bubzer? Here. Committee member Burke is absent. Committee member Fleming? Here. Committee member Gardner? Here. Committee member Harper?

4:15 Here. Committee Member Kellogg? Here. Committee Member Morris? Here. Committee Member Rice? Here. Thank you. We do have a quorum of the meeting here with only one absent. The beginning of that is if we have any public comments for items that are not on tonight's agenda, if somebody in the public wishes to address the committee, they may at this time. I can't see if anybody's online. Nobody's got their hand raised. All right. We'll jump into the policy matters.

4:52 And the first item deals really with kind of the organization of the committee. Some of you will be familiar with this items, some maybe not. But what I want to do before we kick it off in detail, I did want to just go around the room and if you introduce yourself, I don't know if you all know each other or not, so just in case. But then we have staff and we have a couple online also. We wanted to kind of get those introductions and then we'll move into.

5:20 Some of their other action items and update on what it means to be on a legislative body, so to speak. I'm going to start with Nolan from our staff. Nolan Barbaroff, Acting Community and Economic Development Director. Prior to that, I was also the Housing Coordinator for the town, still am, so I coordinate a lot of the data and oversee the affordable housing programs and projects. My name is Alisa Moeckler-Harper.

5:50 I've been in town almost 20 years, and my family's been here since the 80s. I co-own the Warming Hut restaurant in town. We employ about 45 local people, and I'm just ready to approach with an open mind and get down and make some good moves for our community. John Morris from Snow Creek Resort. Tonight I'm here on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association. I'm the chairman. My name's Amanda Rice, and I'm on town council.

6:24 Chris Bubster, Town Council. Cynthia Fleming, realtor and owner of a property management company. Kelly Gardner with American Pacific Mortgage and I work a lot with the Mammoth Housing Group. My name is Matthew Avery. I'm the general manager at the 1849 Condos. We run a property management short-term rental and I also do the HOA as well. Good evening. Jason Kellogg, general manager of the Village and the Village Lodge. Good evening. My name is Danny Earls. I'm a revenue accountant for the town.

7:04 I work closely with the business community and a collection of TOT, TBID, business tax, user utility tax. And I'm Rob Patterson, Admin Services Finance Director for the Town of Mammoth Lakes and sort of manage Danny's group in the collection of not only just a collection of our taxes but administration of new businesses and interpretation of municipal code and enforcement activities as well. Thank you. I think we have a couple people online.

7:36 Aaron, I'm going to mess up his last name, Nicene, he's on Aaron with BAE, he's with the economics firm we brought on board to assist, I wanted him to introduce himself, and also Andy Morris, our town attorney, was going to join this evening as well, so you can all be introduced to Andy as well. So, yeah, Aaron, if you want to start, then I'll go to Andy. Hello, everyone, my name is Aaron Nussain, I'm a principal with BAE Urban Economics.

8:03 I've had the privilege of being retained by the town of Mammoth Lakes as well as Mono County to do some research into the relationships between short-term rentals and the availability and pricing of long-term housing. Wish I could be there with you tonight, and I look forward to working with you further moving forward. And my name is Andy Morris. I am the town attorney. I'm also the town attorney for the town of Truckee, and Truckee just went through this exercise of looking at how to regulate STRs.

8:36 three or three years ago, so I'm pretty familiar with the issue, and Truckee did have Mr. Nussain along for the ride as part of Truckee's study of it, so we're happy to have him, and I can tell you that Truckee had a similar committee to this. We think that it worked really, really well, and the work of the committee went well in Truckee because all the members of the committee were willing to put in the work to understand

9:04 What the issues are. And I was really gratified to see that in Truckee, at least, the members of the committee, whether they were realtors or property managers or others, everyone really seemed to kind of come together and were able to think about the issues, not just from the perspective of their industry, but from a broader perspective of the community as a whole. And I'm hoping for the same from this committee. Thank you, Andy and Aaron. I was going to have Andy kind of dive in and talk about what it means to be a member of a legislative body.

9:36 It puts a lot of restrictions on what you can do from a discussion standpoint and other things. For that, he has a memo that was attached to the staff report that he would do a quick walk through that. It's what we'll often hear us refer to as the Brown Act, or there's a public records component. There's a bunch of other elements that limit and guide how a public body operates. So, Andy, if you want to kind of walk through the key elements of this, we will...

10:07 Get that. If there's any Q&A on that then too. If I may talk a little bit about the books before we start really quickly. So what we put in front of you is a binder that trying to bring all the information together. Under tab number one is where you'll find some of the staff report and stuff for this evening's meeting. So when you talk about the memo that Andy's about to discuss, that's under tab number one as well as most of the other elements.

10:36 for tonight's meeting. Tab number two is a report that we're required to provide to council 10 days before the close of our 45-day moratorium, and that's set to go to council on the 15th, along with a, just kind of outlines a little bit about what we've done so far and the work that we're undertaking, along with the moratorium, I'm sorry, the urgency ordinance that was passed on the 18th of October.

11:05 Following that, tab three includes chapters three and five, which are the two chapters that govern short-term rental activities within the town. So that gives you the laws and regulations that we have currently and certainly things that will likely be updated as we go through this process. Tab number four includes the full-text ordinance of Measure Z that was passed within the town and just sort of as referenced activities.

11:31 And under tab five, we have the California legislative information, which basically provides detail on the authority the town has to set rules and regulations on this process. And then the final tab is all of the different articles that were produced or have been sort of reviewed addressing the impacts of short-term rental activity. So just all in one place for your reference. Thank you. Thank you.

12:04 Andy, if you want to kind of walk through the do's and don'ts of being on a public body. Sure, happy to. So welcome to being on a public legislative body. And if any of you have watched council meetings or planning and economic development commission meetings and wondered, why do the meetings work the way they do? Why can't they talk about things that the members of the public raise during the meeting?

12:33 Why are there all these meetings and agendas? The reason is that there are a whole bunch of laws that govern local governments in California. So you're subject to a bunch of the same rules that the town council, PDC, the rec commission, county board supervisors, anybody like that is governed by some laws, and now you are as well. So the two that I want to talk about a little bit are the Brown Act, which is the open meeting law, then a little bit on the Public Records Act.

13:01 So what the Brown Act says is that you have to do your business in public. This committee has to make all of its decisions and engage in all of its deliberations in public. And that means in a meeting like the one you're in right now, where there's an agenda, the doors are open, anybody can come in. And so that seems to make sense. But the part that may not be readily apparent, the flip side of that is you can't do anything not in public.

13:29 And what that means is that you can't have a majority of this group communicating with each other outside of a meeting. Since there are, I think, nine of you, that means that two or three of you could talk or even four outside of a meeting, but you can't have five of you talking together about anything related to STRs outside of a meeting. And in the little memo that I put together, I gave you some examples. I mean, so you could have...

13:59 It would not be okay for committee member A to talk to B, then talk to C, then talk to D, then talk to E, because you've had five involved. Likewise, you can't have A talk to B, and then A talk to C, and A talk to D, and A talk to E, because you've still had five involved. So the advice that we give to the council and the PDC and others is if you want to have

14:25 A buddy, or in this case, maybe two buddies, who are on the committee that you can talk to about stuff outside the meetings, that's okay. But you're going to have to kind of stick with that buddy. You can't say, well, this week or this month, my buddy for talking about STR issues outside of meetings is one committee member or two, and then next month decide, oh, it's going to be a different group talking about the same issues.

14:52 I hope this makes sense. It is a little bit counterintuitive for people that haven't dealt with it before, but hopefully you'll get accustomed to it quickly and you'll see why it really works best if everything is discussed in public. And I should point out that this applies not only to in-person conversations, it applies to emails, it applies to texts, it applies to anything. Any way of communicating is something that you have to be careful about. And it's also possible for

15:21 People who are not even members of the committee to facilitate a violation. So if some member of the public who cares deeply about this issue talks to three of you and then goes and talks to another two of you and tells the second two what the first three said, well, that's created a violation and that's a problem. The remedies and penalties for a Brown Act violation, you don't go to jail unless it's something that's really, really intentional. It doesn't happen very often.

15:49 Any decision that was made based on information that got passed outside the meeting has to be redone. You can, you know, a court can say, well, that decision was invalid and you have to go back and do it over. We're trying to avoid that. So just as much as you can, don't talk to more than one or two of your colleagues outside of a meeting. Don't let members of the public tell you what other members of the committee have told them. And if you have any questions at all, I mean, ask the staff.

16:17 And staff can relay questions to me if they need to. So in addition to that basic idea of try not to talk to each other outside meetings, the Brown Act has some requirements about what happens in a meeting. There has to be an agenda, has to be published in advance. You're not allowed to talk about something in a meeting that wasn't on the agenda, except in very rare circumstances. And so if a member of the public raises something interesting just during public comment, but it's not really part of an agenda item,

16:46 You're not going to be able to talk about it. So what you could do is ask staff to put it on the agenda for your next meeting, and then you can talk about it at that time. We have to let members of the public come to these meetings. People can record the meetings. They just can't disrupt the meetings. We have to let members of the public talk about things that are not on the agenda, as well as each item that is on the agenda. And we can have time limits for that. Generally, it's five minutes. We can also limit it to three if there are a whole bunch of people wanting to talk.

17:16 There are some rules allowing remote participation, but for this particular committee, probably you're going to need to mostly be there in person. There's some pretty severe restrictions on the rules about zooming in, so just plan to be there in person for all these meetings. And as I pointed out in the memo, the Brown Act is fairly complicated. I mean, we're just kind of scratching the surface here.

17:42 And just giving you the thumbnail sketch of it. So if you have any other questions about things, as I said, just ask staff. And if they need to relay the question to me, they will. Then the other law I wanted to touch on is the Public Records Act. Basically, just about anything that the town does, and that includes you, is a matter of public record. So any email that any of you send or receive relating to your work on the STR committee is a matter of public record.

18:12 And it doesn't matter if it comes from a town email account or goes to a town email account or from your own personal one. I have suggested that we try to get all of you town email accounts because that way if we get a records request, it's easy to just go harvest all those emails rather than asking you to go burrow through your personal email accounts to find all the relevant ones. But because anybody can get copies of all these emails or text messages or memos or anything else at any time, just...

18:41 Bear that in mind before you put anything in writing that has to do with STR regulation. I mean, if you are thinking to yourself, this effort is a terrible idea and nobody knows what they're doing. Well, if you put that in writing and Ted or somebody at the sheet asks for it, they're going to get and they're going to see it. So just, you know, be a little bit mindful about what you put in writing. And the town will maintain records of this. You don't have to necessarily maintain them yourself.

19:11 But you can't delete any emails that you send or receive pertaining to STR regulation because since those are public records, we have laws that govern how long we have to keep them for. So just bear that in mind. Have fun. Remember that this is supposed to be public, supposed to be transparent, and you're going to be doing this in the public eye. If anybody has any questions at this point, I'd be happy to answer them. Any questions for Andy?

19:46 The general rule is it's open in public, so it kind of governs a lot of what you have to be able to do and what can happen. As part of the work of the committee, if, you know, we may end up wanting two or three to work on a particular topic or something like that, we can do some subcommittee assignments that way, very focused. But as mentioned, if you're off, you know, afterwards, everybody's running up to, you know, a clock tower or something to hang out and figure out what you're going to do at the next meeting, that's probably not a good idea. So, or something similar to that.

20:16 And we will provide guidance as we go. If you have questions, feel free to ask, and we can work through those types of items and have that. As mentioned, participating remotely is difficult. There's posting requirements and stuff. For example, as we're talking, we got an email from Carrie Burke, who's not here this evening. Flight got delayed, so she's stuck somewhere else. She goes, okay, so can I listen in and not participate? So she'll be listening to the meeting.

20:46 Will not be engaged in any of the discussion. So from that perspective. With that, the other thing just in terms of managing the committee organizationally here, we would like to have committee members select among yourselves a chair and vice chair just for helping run the meeting. Those just type of elements that need to happen. So that would be open up to the committee to select somebody to serve in those.

21:15 Roll individually or at the same time from action by the board. Any type of vote from the board requires a majority of a quorum to approve something, which at this point is five. So nine-member committee. So with that, we would open up the floor to any nominations for a chairperson to help kind of run the committee. And if you've had experience doing this, that would be helpful. But please feel free to...

21:45 Make a nomination and get a second. We'll take a vote. Mr. Morris, may I nominate you? I'll second that. Any other? We'll call them closed. And we have a motion and a second to appoint John Morris as the chair of the STR Advisory Committee. And Jamie, if you want to do a roll call vote, please. Committee Member Avery? Yes. Yes. Or no. Or no.

22:23 Committee Member Bubser? Yes. Committee Member Fleming? Yes. Committee Member Gardner? Yes. Committee Member Harper? Yes. Committee Member Kellogg? Yes. Committee Member Morris? Yes. Committee Member Rice? Yes. All right. Mr. Morris is appointed as the chair. So, John, I'll turn it over to you if you want to take a motion for a vice chair. Sure. Do we have a nomination for a vice chair? I'd like to nominate Cynthia Fleming. Do we have a second?

23:07 I'll second. Second by Elisa. Any discussion? Committee member Avery? Yes. Committee member Bubzer? Yes. Committee member Burke? Sorry. Committee member Fleming? Yes. Committee member Gardner? Yes. Committee member Harper? Yes. Committee member Kellogg? Yes. Committee member Rice? Yes. Chair Morris? Absolutely. All right. Thank you.

23:43 If I may, I'll kind of jump through this and then turn it to John for discussion and what have you there, but getting that stuff set up, the meetings will be in this room, unless there's some reason why we can't meet here. We'll do that accordingly. The next thing we really want to walk through is the meeting schedule. It's relatively aggressive over the next several weeks. We've had a couple tweaks to it already that have come up. You'll notice we have a regular scheduled meetings and we've called out special meetings.

24:07 The regular scheduled meetings are important to be able to have those. They do require the agenda to be out 72 hours in advance of the meeting. This is on page 4 of the total packet or page 2 of the staff report. You'll kind of see a list of meetings there. We have in two places actually in the reports. The special meetings, one, you can call a special meeting throughout the process. If we need to have additional meetings, you can do that.

24:35 They do require a minute of a 24-hour notice to have a special meeting. So we structure these accordingly. Our goal is to get the information out to the committee as soon as possible prior to meetings, but the schedules are pretty tight, so some of that may have a lot of time prior to the meeting to digest everything for that. But if there's a substantial number of people, i.e. we don't have a quorum for any of the listed meetings, if we know that, then we can make some adjustments that everybody's aware of.

25:04 What we're looking at for a meeting schedule. When we put this together with the number of people on the committee, high likelihood that yes, you will miss a meeting, if not two meetings potentially, but the goal is hopefully as few as possible. But we do want to be mindful of that. It goes through the holidays, so some conflicts there potentially, with the goal of having some recommendations ready to go to town council in February. So it's a pretty aggressive schedule to work through. So with that,

25:33 You all can kick around yourself among those meetings and dates if that looks like it's going to work or if we need to modify one or two, please speak up. So, John, I'll turn it back to you for the discussion. Yeah, sure, Dan. Thanks. Just a quick question for the group, really. What are we thinking about as far as time frames for limits on the meeting? Are we going two hours max? I was assuming starting at 5, it would probably be an hour and a half to two-hour meetings. If we need to go longer, I think that depends on the committee's...

26:03 Willing us to continue through an item, you'd hate to stop arbitrarily in the middle of a good discussion. If we end sooner, that's fine, too. Does that seem reasonable for everybody, an hour and a half to two hours? We'll try to keep it there if we can. Yeah. Don't run into too much nighttime. Okay, great. And any issues with, I mean, I realize that's all the way out to February, so I don't know if we all know what we're doing.

26:30 We did structure the 7th of the council meeting to make a report out. If we had to modify that, we could do that as well. But the other side for the Tuesday evenings and the way we did some of these and move around was also making sure we didn't have conflict with other meetings in this room. So we're a little trying to manage that as well.

26:59 And I think, you know, the other thing to add, as far as the special meetings go, they're listed on here as sort of a scheduled regular meeting, but the classification means a lot, as Dan talked about. There can also be more special meetings called, right? We talked about setting this up. Because the expectation is there's going to be some work to be done between meetings, we wanted to have an appropriate pace to get things accomplished, but we can add to that, right, if there's a need to.

27:27 We try to provide the bookends, and we'll talk a little bit more about that. I do have a quick question for staff. January 11th, I think council has some other obligations already. Is that in conflict with the 5 to 7 meeting? On the 11th, I'll confirm that, Chris. Okay, thanks. So at this point, I guess we don't, too early to do any additional committee. Oh, I'm sorry. One of the items that was on here is...

28:10 The possibility of adding additional committee members. One was an at-large position, which was, I believe, earmarked not from either lodging or real estate. So that was another possible addition to this group. And then also a member of the Hispanic community. So I think if any of the committee members at this time, if you know of anyone,

28:35 That you'd like to nominate or discuss? We've had a couple of numbers come in, but we haven't been able to follow up with the individuals yet to see if they're available. But we can do that. If you have somebody that you would like us, if you let us know, we can reach out. Working on other people's schedules and other meetings and elements that way, we've had a couple different names come forward to staff at least, which we can reach out to and make sure that they can be available.

29:01 We do currently have, correct me if I'm wrong, nine members on the board, right?

29:30 And I don't know if anybody else has an issue. It doesn't really bother me if we come up with an even number. It's all about having the right people. So if we want to go to 10, sometimes that could be a problem. But I don't anticipate that being an issue with this group. I think we'll all agree on enough stuff that we'll be able to get things passed with an even number. Anybody have any issues with that if we do go to 10? I think just if we're missing a few people, then that could make it difficult. That's a good point. It's having a quorum. Yeah, that's a good point.

30:01 Because we need six for the quorum, and then if there's any, you know, people are, have a difference of opinion, it might be hard. Yeah, that's a good point. Yeah. I guess the important thing is try to make all the meetings so we don't run into those situations. Or go to 11. Or go to, yeah, if we can, if we can hold the two more, that we just, you know, one is, one is tricky. Sure. But I would leave it up to the group to decide if we can find one more member who we think is really good.

30:31 And we've had a couple that have expressed interest. Are those in both seats or one? We've had a couple interest. I think for two, if we bring them forward, but we had the meeting tonight and a couple we just haven't connected with and say, hey, this is the meeting schedule. Does that work? And I'd rather have them know what they're walking into versus saying, hey, show up. So if anybody in the community knows of anyone.

31:02 It's those descriptions. Chair Morris? Yeah, sure. We have some virtual public comments whenever you want to. Oh, sure. Yeah, public comments. Nancy, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good evening. Thank you for allowing me this time. I did write in a comment, and I'm not sure if this is the right time in the meeting to talk about the impact.

31:39 The current impact on STR. Can someone please advise me if this is the right time? I think the next item on the agenda, we're actually talking about more of the work program and the look at the work of the committee would probably be more appropriate. Okay, great. I can hold my comments until later then. I guess the one question would be if it's about the moratorium, that's really not an agenda item and that would be appropriate in the front end if that's what the comments are referred to. Okay.

32:13 Do you know when comments will be acceptable on the moratorium? So since the moratorium is not a part of the agenda for tonight, it would be appropriate to bring that up right now as public comment at the beginning of the meeting. If you wanted to discuss that now, you're certainly welcome to. Oh, thank you. I appreciate that. I just want to put this out there. I have a...

32:43 I own a condo. I've had a condo in Mammoth for 10 years. And I did rent it. And then it became for friends and family. And then I became sick. And I'm trying to sell my condo because I need surgery. And I need the funds because, unfortunately, Medicare will not cover the kind of surgery that I need. My condo went into escrow. And as soon as they found out about the moratorium, they canceled.

33:11 The second people that made an offer, as soon as they found out about the moratorium, they canceled. So I'm one of those rare, very unusual cases where this moratorium actually has a health issue crisis component to someone like me. So I just wanted to put that out there. I just wanted the committee to know what I'm personally going through. And I feel like all of a sudden I...

33:39 Can't sell my condo because of this moratorium. And this was an interesting thing for me because even though I used it for friends and family, initially I did to help me pay for the condo, rent it out. It's having a tremendous impact, I think, on people that absolutely have to sell their home in Mammoth. I mean, someday I'd like to buy back in, but to be honest with you, I need my surgery more than I need this condo right now.

34:09 So that's it. That's all I wanted to share with the committee. Thank you very much for your comments. We really appreciate that. Thank you. Andrea, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes. I had questions earlier, and I've had my hand up for a while, but I'd like to put that aside for a second and also reiterate what this woman had just said. It makes it very awkward. My daughter and I bought...

34:47 Over a year and a half ago, and we've been enjoying it, and we don't want to rent it out very often because we still enjoy it, but we do have to because HOA fees have almost doubled. So there are concerns, big concerns, and that's the reason why I'm in this meeting. And to that point, who are the lodging group representatives? Are they from?

35:19 Which organization are you from? Cynthia Fleming. I own Ready for Rentals, and I'm also a realtor in town. Okay, but is there any representatives from people who are homeowners? Or, I heard Snow Creek represented earlier. No? No? Yeah. Well, I think your committee needs to be a little bit larger, frankly.

35:47 It needs to also include representatives from people who are having to fall underneath the moratorium and like this woman that was just speaking. And my second concern is that what is the notification process to the public on this? This is a very, very important issue for many, many homeowners in Mammoth. You will have our addresses.

36:18 You know, you can easily get them from, you know, the assessor's office. I think we should have been notified about the coming moratorium. Maybe you didn't want a big rush on permits, because I would have been there. I understand that, but I don't know how legal that is, frankly. And if your meetings are going to be laid out and you, are you still, I heard the, maybe you were joking about a two-hour notice. Okay, so.

36:51 I'll turn it over to you to get some answers. So that was a two-hour meeting, Lane. The notices go out either 72 hours prior or a minimum of 24 hours prior, depending on the type of meeting. To the extent we can put them out sooner than that, we will. You can actually sign up, I believe, on our town website, notify me. You can actually sign up for notices of the meetings. And as they're posted, you'll be emailed a link to the meeting so you can attend accordingly.

37:21 Or if you're in town, you can come in person. Thank you very much for your comments. We really appreciate it. That's it. All right. Then we can move on to item 3.2, which is the discussion and review of information and direction on many goals and work program. Dan, you and Rob want to? Yeah, we'll take Team Tag Disable and Rob kick it off, and we'll dive into some of the issues and items there. And also, we do have Aaron will provide some input as well from the economic side. So, yeah, thank you.

37:56 One of the things I wanted to address really quickly is this advisory committee is convened to review the changes that they want to recommend for council. It's not to weigh the merits or the challenges of the moratorium that's currently in place. That's why I mentioned earlier that that was a part of not really on the agenda because this meeting will not address the validity of that.

38:25 Moratorium won't address the components of the moratorium. We won't address the details of how it's engaged right now with the community. What we will do, and as you've seen in the meeting schedule, is we've set a really aggressive pace. We've set a pace so that we can get through this process as quickly as possible.

38:51 The end of this process, and I'll walk through that just shortly here, will result in the lifting of the moratorium. Once everything is in place and finalized, that moratorium will be lifted. The rules and regulations that council adopts as a recommendation from this advisory committee will be in place at that point in time. As I mentioned earlier, the meeting schedule is set fairly aggressive. We talked about the different types of meetings.

39:22 But really there will be a lot of work that you all will be performing along with staff in between the meetings. So we wanted to give an appropriate amount of time to get work accomplished as well as to get data brought in and fed out through the group. When we actually bring this before council, which on the last meeting scheduled, the February 7th meeting, that will be a presentation.

39:51 Hopefully, to Town Council of the recommendations from this committee. It will be in a number of different areas, not just STRs, but also STRs and housing solutions, right? We're looking for a multifaceted approach. The municipal code updates, which will likely occur along with this, have a very specific process by which they flow through Town Council. There is a, there's, first off,

40:19 The recommendations will come to council along about the first part of the first meeting of February. There'll be probably 30 days, and there are two different meetings by which staff is working with council on some final updates and edits. We're going to be looking at how the recommendations that the committee makes sort of feed into the municipal code as it's written today, what edits will need to be made to that.

40:47 And then that will be laid out to council on what's called a first reading. So our target would be 30 days after we present that, so about March 6th, which is another town council meeting, where we do the first reading of any municipal code edits and updates. The process after that is at least 15 days. Subsequent to that is a second reading, so probably not the next meeting in March, but the first meeting in April.

41:17 It's likely when that will occur. And then after that second reading, and all of these things have to be properly noticed in the paper, and there's other reviews to that. After the second reading, there's a 30-day time period before implementation. Then after the 30 days is up, that will be implemented. So with regard to these changes, I think the fastest this committee can move, as well as the process by which updates will be made, would land us somewhere in the 1st of May.

41:46 When we have everything in place. I think our recommendation, so on the moratorium itself, you know, initial moratorium requires a 45, it's a 45-day window, right? So we have to go before town council. I think that's scheduled for Wednesday night. We're reporting on the activity that's occurred. We're reporting on some additional elements for that moratorium, and we will be recommending an extension of that.

42:16 We have the ability to do an extension for up to 10 and a half months. I believe, Dan, you've put this at May 31st, right? So we're forgoing four and a half of those months and saying, here is the timeline by which we want this committee to complete, timeline by which we want to have everything resolved as quickly as we possibly can. So I think the planned extension would be through 531 of 24.

42:42 And that will work if everything that I just outlined lines up the way it's supposed to. So that's kind of the best case scenario. Now, if we miss that point, we can extend the moratorium beyond that for up to 12 months. But again, we'll be foregoing the opportunity for four and a half of those. Quick question. Yep. What is the maximum amount of time that it can be extended?

43:08 Two years. Yeah, together two years, but you can only extend it twice regardless. So if you're short two years, then you're short two years. You don't make it. So in that scenario, then, yeah, we'd be short four and a half months to 24, so just under 19 and a half. With regard to... Yes, sir. And the rationale for that is to...

43:33 Make it clear to everyone of our sense of urgency of this process and that we don't want it to drag on, correct? That's correct. If everything works well, we have no second extension. Yeah, we're really trying to put out here, the one thing that I've been on the phone a lot with folks about is we can commit to trying to get through this process as quickly as possible, right? That's the one thing that I can commit to. And I think that this outline that we've laid out will accomplish that.

44:04 And that's why I kind of want to walk through the details of that and just how the process works. So folks will understand when we say, you know, we're trying to get through it very quickly, but it's still going to put us till almost June 1st before that's done. So another aspect of the moratorium with regard to this effort is once that 30 days has been completed, that implementation, you know, 30 days after second reading, then

44:33 If we have the appropriate rules and regulations in place, that moratorium can be lifted by council action, even if that's prior to the time period in which we extend it out to. As soon as they decide, it will be lifted. Any questions on, I'm going to say process? Next thing I want to kind of go into is... Sorry, Rob. I'm sorry? You said as soon as the council decides... You'll have to take an action to lift the moratorium. Correct, but can that be...

45:06 But not before the ordinance has been read twice and passed. Correct. Yeah. So it would be the late May once everything's... It could be as early as your second meeting in May you could lift the ordinance. Okay. If not, you could let it terminate at the end of the month or you could do an extension. Thank you. Any other questions? I'll try to actually pause this time and look around. First thing, I kind of want to dive into this is a little bit more now about some content, right?

45:39 And I want to talk, I want to start off with some acknowledgements. You know, the first and foremost thing, we are a resort community, and our success depends on visitation. That, when I say success, I mean the funding of our organization, the activity that we provide for the community, the snow removal, the police services, all of that stuff, depends heavily on visitation. I, as finance director, have always...

46:08 Would love to find a way to diversify our revenue streams and find other ways for us to exist. But the fact of the matter is that is our business. That is what we do as a community. But that also requires us to be able to fulfill that role. We also have a housing problem. We have an inability to have housing for our workforce.

46:37 And I say housing, I mean sheer numbers of housing and availability of affordable housing. So that's a challenge, right? Those two are an issue. And that impacts our visitor experience. It impacts our community experience. The ability for people to be here and their desire to be here. So that is an acknowledgement that we all say. This is a multifaceted approach.

47:05 Many of the things that I've heard over the last couple of weeks is that this won't solve the problem. And I agree with that. This is one of many things that must occur for us to come to, I think, incremental improvements that will overall have a strong benefit on this process. The town itself is already doing a lot. We have a lot of housing programs, a lot of things that we're investing in. But we do know that

47:35 This process will provide incremental benefit, right? So acknowledging that there's no silver bullets out there, this is not going to solve the problem, but it will make things better. I mean, just from the standpoint of updating regulations and management aspects of things, that's always really good to do for a municipality from time to time to make sure that we're reviewing the processes and we're updating those.

48:00 That, I think, will be a benefit in the solution we achieve. And the final acknowledgement is this is a complex issue, right? The STR activity is not the only influence on our challenges for housing, right? That is just one aspect of it. And as you'll hear maybe a little bit later on from our economist, Aaron, this is dependent upon the community. There's a multi-approach angle. There's multiple different aspects.

48:28 That caused that. So it's complex, and we only need to acknowledge that. This is a difficult problem to address. So any questions, thoughts about acknowledgments, anything that we may have missed? Just sort of kind of level set a little bit before we dive in deeper. Another thing I'd add to Rob's discussion on some of that acknowledgment stuff is we've had a lot of discussions on the short-term rental market and what it is and isn't.

48:59 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

49:27 There's been different regulatory structures out there that impact just like I'm just going to hold on to a certificate forever and never use it. They can actually be lost or not. There's all kinds of different elements to be looked at because, again, the value to the short-term rentals is part of that tourist accommodation unit. At the same time, knowing that one of the focuses, and this will help kind of maybe narrow some of the discussions here,

49:52 We'd be looking at, you know, from a housing standpoint, one of the key areas that we do not have a lot of influence over is what we refer to as the missing middle of our employee base in the community. If you're making 80% of area median income and there's information, one of the attachments there, what that means, we can spend more time on it. But certain income levels, there's a fair amount of federal and state programs out there that says, hey, these programs will help you address that particular income strata.

50:20 And that really is the focus of the parcel that we're working on right now, 80 units coming online. Ultimately, the majority of that project will focus on an average of 60% of Airbnb income. They have some very low, they have the 80%, and then they have a gap in the middle there. And that's structured on how they're financed and how they're funded.

50:41 They have some obligations to meet under those guidelines. And so when you look at that lower, I'll say the lower income spectrum of that and those elements, and again, there's guidelines and they're tied to size of household, et cetera. No one's our expert on this. You can walk through some of that if you need to. But looking at that parcel from that area and the things we have going is primarily focused on low income because that's where money has been.

51:06 So knowing that this program probably isn't going to end up with someone going, great, I'll rent my unit for $800 a month and I'll make up the other $3,000 off of my investment income somewhere else. So we recognize that element of it, but when you start to look at people that we're dealing with for our own employees, we deal with that with the Forest Service, I know the school district's going through this, Mono County, they just...

51:32 Hired a housing person. They called us and said, do you have housing for them? Those types of questions. And decent-paying jobs, and people are not able to secure a place either by rent and or something that even if they have some capital coming with them that they can actually afford to purchase. Those are folks making anywhere, it could be $100,000 to $175,000 a year, not being able to secure housing. I think so. Part of this focus, we've really started to look at it.

52:01 It's kind of narrowed that focus for where we think we can make a difference in the housing market. It's probably more in that missing middle than I would say the low income. And to some degree, maybe more in the ownership versus rental, although both of those may be elements that we can look at as we walk through this. When we did the moratorium, we made the argument in terms of looking at public benefit and public concerns, standard of health and welfare, public...

52:30 Elements there. And really looking at the lack of housing, what does that mean to our community? If we don't have a workforce, what does that do? If you don't have really economic sustainability tied to employees, what happens? We walked through some of the reports, a lot of things we've looked at, had discussions with the Forest Service, there's a potential there, probably in somewhere between 10 years or longer.

52:54 A couple years ago, we had some serious discussions with the city of Bishop on looking at some land that they were looking at potentially for housing as well, owned by Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. That's like a forever process, if not a hair longer, in terms of securing that type of property. Plus, that's looking at their own employees and their challenges. They're not just in Mammoth Lakes. We actually were kind of a backup buyer on property in Crowley.

53:20 Where you can put housing. We've looked at a number of different elements outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes as well as in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And we can walk through some of the housing programs later as need be and how those might overlay into some of the dialogue here. The same thing as Rob noted, we know there's not a single answer to housing. We think there's a potential in the STR element for a piece of it. The other element to look at in there and

53:46 I'll have Aaron speak in just a second on some of the economics of this. But there may be elements, you know, we adopted the ordinance, we looked at defined areas, mainly the multifamily residential, residential multifamily, RMF2, zoning area with some of the commercial areas as well that have a lot of short-term rental and other housing in there. I think it's a good opportunity, as Rob was saying, you take a look at your regulations and what do we look and see what's working well.

54:16 There may be aspects of that zoning district that say it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to be the same across the community. There may be areas that this makes a whole lot of sense to be maybe that multifamily but with a resort component to it as well. Are there areas that just it's just not designed or developed that supports the housing element? Other places may be much more supportive of what that could look like.

54:40 So I think there's a lot of options you start to narrow down and say, how do we make a difference in those areas? Then ultimately, a little later on, either tonight or the next meeting, is how would we begin to define success as we look at short-term rental market and with our housing? The other element, as Rob mentioned, too, regarding short-term rentals is just the regulatory element. We've done a lot of work in that area on noise and litter and parking.

55:10 Those things. We still get overcrowding complaints. We still get parking complaints. We've gotten more, I'll say, in this last year somewhat probably due to the snowstorm, illegal construction going on in short-term rentals as well as other places. And one of those questions has come up as, well, if they're a business and they're doing that, do we have any additional enforcement tools? Do we look at those types of elements too? If you're running a business, which, again, may not be profitable in one sense, but it's a business.

55:37 How do we take a look at that element as well and those types of things? So there's a lot of pieces to this. It's a very broad topic, and part of our goal is to kind of narrow it down. And Aaron, if I can impose on you to talk a little about just the economics on it and the impact that we see in short-term rental and influences on economics, not just here in Mammoth at this point. He's doing some analysis for us there. A little broader than that, and then we'll come back to an open discussion as well. Okay, Dan, we did have one.

56:07 Yeah, so Aaron, if you want to walk through that a little bit, then we can come back into some public comment on kind of this opening discussion, and we'll start to narrow it in a little bit. Great. Thank you very much, Dan. I think both you and Rob did a great job of sort of generally framing a lot of the issues that we see in the short-term rental space. I'll keep my comments relatively brief.

56:32 I am very excited to have been invited to work with the Town of Mammoth Lakes and this committee to better understand the nature of the short-term rental market in the community. I'm also working with Modo County on similar research at the same time. I think that provides good synergy given that Modo County and Town of Mammoth Lakes in many ways function as the same market and the same destination.

57:00 I've had the privilege of doing similar research in a variety of other communities. Most recently, I completed research in Mariposa County. I've also done work in North Lake Tahoe and a variety of other locations. Through that research, I've noticed a variety of common themes in terms of the ways that short-term rental function within the broader market.

57:23 First and foremost, I want to acknowledge that short-term rentals are a core and important component of the tourist accommodations inventory in these types of tourist and destination economies. They provide some important value in that they're instantaneous supply of tourist accommodations that can come on and off the market as needed. And so they provide much needed and important flexibility within the tourist accommodation market.

57:53 That said, we've also noticed in a variety of jurisdictions that in some cases restriction on short-term rentals can also incentivize or induce additional reinvestment in the existing hotel inventory. In particular, a good case of that is the city of South Lake Tahoe. Also in North Lake Tahoe, they hadn't seen a new hotel unit built in about 70 years. They now have about four hotel projects on deck for construction.

58:20 So one of the important roles of short-term rental regulation is to make sure and ensure an adequate supply of tourist accommodations and to provide tools that the community can use to balance the type of the inventory that's in place. Now, in prior research, we've done quite a bit of review of the academic literature on the relationship between short-term rentals and the housing market. There's a relatively strong consensus that relationship does exist.

58:49 And that generally coincides with lived experience in most communities. The way that we've seen short-term rentals function from an economic standpoint is mainly to provide additional revenue that can facilitate second homeownership. And so in many resort communities, what we really see is the fundamental market distortion is both an undersupply of housing generally, as well as excessive demand originating from the second home market.

59:17 Those second-home buyers and owners oftentimes have incomes and accumulated wealth that exceeds what is available to local workforce households, particularly in cases where workforce households are employed in service and retail-type industries. And so over time, it eats away at the housing stock, reducing availability and, in some cases, increasing pricing.

59:43 So really what we're looking at with regard to the role of short-term rental regulation in the housing market is influencing second home purchase and whole decisions. It's essentially working at the margins of the housing inventory. If there are other ways to get at increasing the supply, in some cases restricting occupancy of units to limit the attractiveness of those units to second home buyers.

1:00:12 Those interventions and policies can also have more direct impact on the availability of workforce housing. So really, the way we see workforce housing regulation implemented successfully is as part of a broader toolkit, a broader sort of assortment of policies and regulations that contribute to a more balanced market.

1:00:37 My role moving forward in this process will be to conduct research specific to the town of Mammoth Lakes. We'll be comparing that to the data we're collecting from Mammoth County and really providing the committee with information to consider as you move forward discussing what the community priorities are with regard to short-term rentals, how they fit within the tourist accommodation inventory as well as the housing market in large. Aaron, thank you. Rob had a few more comments if you want to make those first or open up for some public comments.

1:01:12 We can open up for public comment. Any public comment? Anyone in the room? Jamie, do we have anybody in the virtual world? No? Okay. Any other, any questions or comments from the committee members as well? Trying to lay out kind of a framework for us to work from the goal of this. Robert, are you going to touch on the certified property program? A little bit, yeah. Okay, great. For sure. Are you going to go through the whole staff report? No.

1:01:45 Matthew Lehman. I guess one of my questions, in hearing all this, it just sounds like we're going to go through a process and then there's going to be a decision made at the end. Since this has all come up, and even talking to other people, it's like the decision's already made. I mean, and we're just really going through the process to back into what's going to happen.

1:02:19 And I really, I mean, I've looked at this every which way I can and talk to people about it at length and it just really makes me wonder, is this really going to solve any housing issues? Rob, you pointed it out, it may not, but I don't think it is. And we're going to be wasting resources and we all want workforce housing. I think there's no, you know, there's no real question about that from anybody. But are we going to waste time and resources going down this path?

1:02:49 You know, moratoriums and ultimately an ordinance, which yeah, it'll go away, but it'll probably result in a ban. And, you know, it's, I can almost tell you what this report's going to say. You know, we're going to back into a decision here. He's going to come back and say, oh yeah, there's going to be some problems, but there's some workforce that was created and whatnot. But, you know, there's a lot of time, money, and resources that could be going elsewhere to housing. What impacts, you know, we're one of the towns that has one of the highest reliances on

1:03:19 revenue of any municipality in California. So, you know, we're going to cut off our nose here, and that revenue that we're going to be getting rid of is actually revenue that goes to workforce housing. And, you know, a lot of people have brought up that maybe just the tourism component, you know, is one of the things that the council's trying to get rid of. And if that's the case, why are we using our Measure A money to go to marketing? Let's just get that money and bond it and put it toward housing.

1:03:48 I mean, we're already, what, $3 million, $4 million behind on the first phase of seven phases? I mean, it just seems like that's something that's already in place. And I understand this isn't a silver bullet, but it doesn't seem like it's a bullet at all. It just doesn't seem like there's any solution to this. It's really going to produce any type of housing whatsoever. It's going to make a lot of people upset. It's going to divide our community.

1:04:16 I hope that as we go through this process, that should be the forefront of our question, is this even going to create any workforce housing? And what housing are we depriving by wasting our resources on this? So I think that's all I really want to say today. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Any other comments? Thank you. So as we were talking about introductory elements, one of the things that I wanted to kind of establish is goals. The way that

1:04:52 We look at this, and I'll say, you know, both Dan and I kind of been living in this for the last couple of weeks, right, daily in this process, and I will say even in that period of time, suggestions, ideas, thoughts have come forward, right, new things, right, things that people may have been talking about for a while and we just couldn't figure out how it would benefit. I mean, we have a limited amount of resources, and so I think a lot of good is going to come from this discussion. There are no predetermined...

1:05:22 Outcomes of this. This committee is going to bring forward suggestions on things that we should do. So first and foremost on the goals, reviewing the STR management plan, right? So we have a set of municipal code guidelines which are in tab three of your book. Those are our current rules and regulations that are there. Certified properties, I believe that is under tab two. A little bit of a discussion on that.

1:05:51 I want to talk a little bit about certified properties. So that was my team's approach on how do we sort of address challenges within the lodging community, right? We've got, I'm going to say, a mismatch between, we've got an old system, antiquated way of identifying properties. So right now, today, we have someone who comes to us, they have a business tax certificate.

1:06:17 So they're an operator within the town. They can legally operate a short-term rental. They're either an individual operator, meaning they're the owner-operator of the property, or they contract with an organization who does like a management company. And so they will then be the operator for that. Substant to that is what's called a TOT certificate. The TOT certificate belongs to the operator, right? So the business owner, not the owner of the home.

1:06:47 But the actual business owner. And the TOT certificate lists important things like occupancy volumes, things like who are the 24-hour contact, those critical elements that are important. But again, it's a disconnect from the actual property owner. When we, if someone would like to move around, and we've got a lot of questions on that during this moratorium, but the actual TOT certificate, which is the current

1:07:16 Item that's no longer allowed to be issued in certain zones. That lives with, as I said earlier, the operator, the BTC holder. In their certified properties, a number of things would happen. So each individual unit that would be allowed to be rented would be required to go through an inspection process. Right now we have a number of those that have been grandfathered in back from 2015, I believe.

1:07:43 So they haven't ever been inspected. So we've got a challenge there. That process means that if you're a certified property, you would go through a regular rotation of inspections. What we have seen is over time, properties fall out of compliance. Things become unsafe, right? This is a matter of having good product to provide a good customer experience, but it's also safe. That's a critical element of this process.

1:08:12 What we're looking for as a town is establishing a relationship with the property owner. So the certified properties would be something that belongs specifically to the property and the owner of that property. If there are issues and challenges with the rental activity of that property and someone needs to be put in park for a period of time, it would be done at that level, right? So it gives us more teeth to how those things are regulated. It gives us more teeth on problem.

1:08:42 Operators in town are problem units, right? If someone's not following through with some of the rules. So we have a better connection to the actual owner. And it's very important for us because we always go back to the fact the owner of the property is the responsible party, regardless of if they're using a management company or anything like that. When it comes down to either a lien or some sort of enforcement activity, it's directly to the responsible party, which is the homeowner.

1:09:12 This establishes that connection to us. It allows us to be able to reach out and contact them if we need to for anything. Heaven forbid we have another health emergency or something along those lines where we have to communicate. But we'll have a good, clear path of communication. So this certified properties was our role of sort of flipping it from this TOT certificate that belongs to an operator to a property that belongs to its owner.

1:09:40 That can then be put into the rental market. So it's really trying to address some of the challenges that we've seen over my last seven years with the town. And it's an effective element, but we've been having problems implementing. We contracted with a company, and their desire was to try to build a program for us. That has been a year in the making and has not come to fruition.

1:10:09 We're going now to a second opportunity, a second vendor to try to get that solution created. It's going to provide us a lot more data, a lot more statistical information about what's out there. Instead of now, like an operator that may have 100 properties, we get one lump sum dollar amount, and we're going to get information by individual unit, so we'll know exactly what each unit is producing and the amount of activity that it's generating, so how often is it rented.

1:10:37 But we have to find a way to make that easy for people to enter, right? That can't be something that can be arduous enough that we won't get good data. So that's the work that's being done right now. So that's a little bit about certified properties. The other goals, and I'll kind of back up just a little bit. I talked about buckets, or maybe I didn't talk about buckets, but I see this as we have sort of the STR management side of things, and then we have some housing solution side of things, right? And I think that

1:11:05 This committee is going to be where we operate in those two areas. And I don't know how that's going to look as far as working groups or those types of things, but I think everyone should have the opportunity to maybe work in both areas. The way the staff is laid out here, we have the sort of short-term rental expertise on this side, and Danny and I live in this every day, and we've got the housing expertise on this side with those types of activities.

1:11:32 Understanding certified properties to a degree of providing input to us on whether there's blind spots or things that need to be updated. From that, I talked earlier about refreshing the municipal code. Our municipal code was originally built off of probably an extraction of another municipal code somewhere within the state, and we've made edits to it through time, but I think making it fine-tuned and match this...

1:11:58 Is going to be helpful, right? A clear set of rules and processes that make sense are really helpful for everybody involved, even operators as well as town government. Dan mentioned earlier about zoning updates. Through the process, and we know this, right? We're familiar with the activity. We actually have very good data. We know rental activity in RMF2 for sure, down to the different...

1:12:27 Condo complexes, right? We know exactly what activity is going on in each of those and kind of determine that volume. We know when we talk about these resort zones, I mean, a lot of those things are specific to our core business, right? We're resort elements. We want to kind of look at those zoning and is there updates that we can recommend that are made to that that make more sense, right? Where have things that maybe were created in 1984 don't necessarily jive well today with the way

1:12:57 You know, the portals to the mountain have been established, right? And does that need to be updated? And so I would hope that this team brings forward recommendations on that. And then finally, and you know, I'm just going to be blunt, there's possibility for restrictions, right? There's restrictions, limitations, caps, all kinds of things to be discussed. Nothing is decided. But these are elements to be discussed as part of the solution.

1:13:23 To address this and how those are implemented, right? Are they implemented at all, first and foremost, but are they over time through attrition? There's all kinds of things that we can address. The second bucket is housing solutions. You know, multifaceted approach, we've already talked a little bit about that. In the staff reports, you'll find a lot about what we're doing. And what we hope from this committee is that

1:13:50 Giving you the materials to review that between now and the next meeting that you would have an opportunity to read through this stuff and get a better understanding of exactly what processes are out there. Dan mentioned earlier that our target, which is a little bit different than most of these programs, our target is the middle income folks, right? If we solve for and provide solutions to their challenges, we think it would actually free up some other housing, right? That peripheral effect.

1:14:17 Will be a benefit for that. And that's not something that any of our Housing Now initiatives really have focused that much on. A little bit about that. There's been discussion about, you know, subsidized long-term stuff. We've been putting our heads together about how that could look, right? Maybe we have a million dollars we set aside for that program on an annual basis. We, as a town, through Council Direction, we've invested a lot of money in housing. We have still, and hopefully, opportunity to do that in the future.

1:14:46 We can kind of carve out little bits and pieces of it and say, okay, we've got the bridge program, but now we need a little bit of dollars over here. So I think we're going to have a little bit broader approach to that. When I talk about the solutions and ideas as staff, we're here, number one, to kind of level set any questions that may exist, but we're also going to interject thoughts, right, discussion points for you guys to kind of weigh in on. So when you look at what we're doing, think about how it can be augmented.

1:15:15 How things can be changed? What might be missing? What are we not doing? And that's what we're really looking for. And then I think, you know, as far as the goals go, I really think it's important for you all to share what you hope, what success looks like for you in this process, what an outcome would look like for you in this process. That'll help us all kind of understand, and I don't know, Dan, or John, how you gonna want to walk through something along those lines, but...

1:15:43 Those are kind of the goals, right? When we're trying to define what are we trying to achieve here, I think it's really those two main areas. Do you have anything to add to that? A couple of items to that. Kind of the attachment to your report here is when going to council on Wednesday, walks through a lot of the housing need, and I think, frankly, it needs to be something to confirm shortly here with the group in terms of what do you see as that housing need in the community, I'm assuming. If you don't see one, yeah, it'd be great to speak up.

1:16:13 Some folks, to be honest, have had those conversations. People have got to figure out their own life, and that's not the government's role to provide housing. So we've had that discussion, a very small fraction, but it's there. Those types of issues in terms of that need, we kind of go through a lot of the studies that have been done in the town and the needs there and some of where we're at with the missing numbers, be that low income, missing middle income, looking at that, a number of different elements.

1:16:42 Our housing element walks through certain elements. That's a state law requirement to have that. It has certain targets that we're actually doing very well in that area, just in terms of those, although they're relatively light in terms of what we probably need in the community from a practical standpoint. We do spend time walking through where we're at and some of those construction elements. Nolan has pulled a lot of this data together. We have looked at a lot of the housing costs in the RMF, too.

1:17:10 Zoning districts, just trying to, because at one point I think that was more affordable for that missing middle group, and others as they look at housing there, so that's kind of why the focus on that particular zoning district, is that still reality? Maybe it's not, maybe it is. Different elements that that can actually work to see that happen. And then we talk, we have a lot of information on what the town has done. We have put...

1:17:34 Close to $30 million into housing in various ways since 17, 18. Some of that was emergency work in COVID. Some of that was just recent snowmageddon we went through in the winter of 23. Then other elements that we've worked on in terms of the parcel and moving the affordable housing through, partnerships with Mammoth Lakes Housing, now Eastern Sierra Community Housing. One of our own programs has really been called the Bridge Program. It's how do we...

1:18:04 Provide that transition from long-term rental to home ownership. How do you bridge that financial gap for, again, a lot of that missing middle group? And we've got, I think, five people we've placed. We've got one unit in the works. Small number there, but I think it's a program that can be relatively effective in a number of different areas to do those elements. And so we see a lot of that. I mentioned earlier, we actually have gone out and looked at places outside of the town boundary for housing, unsuccessfully, frankly.

1:18:33 We've started some partnership discussions with Mono County on a housing for those who are living in their vehicles, some by necessity, others, frankly, by choice. I've got a Sprinter van and this is my home. Where do they park it safe that has sanitation that allows them to not be chased out of parking lots around town? In the wintertime, it's not unusual to see anywhere from one or two to five or six in the parking lot right here by Vons.

1:19:03 Mall management has raised issues with that on that. What can we do to enforce that? We don't want to become a parking lot for nightly places to live. So those types of issues. So there's a whole variety of that. You deal with people camping and just in tents as well. So a whole variety of elements in that piece that we're working through. We have collected some data. We know that people are out there in those categories looking for housing, both for ownership and for rent.

1:19:32 So I won't spend a lot of time walking through the data here, but that is available. If there's questions on that, we can begin to address that. We've looked at a lot of different STR, short-term rental management policies from other cities. You'll see some of that in the report here. There's other documents on that. And they run a full gamut. Some communities are coming back and going, yep, that's made a difference. We've actually seen an enhancement of affordable housing. When I say affordable, don't think of that just low income.

1:20:01 Attainable by the community that's in that environment. So that housing that way. Others have not seen as much. Some of that maybe it's newer or it's just the community's different. So there's been a mix and match of that element out there. And so there's a number of different elements to look at. How does it work? And again, Mammoth will have its own uniquenesses that we will need to work through. One of those key elements is just

1:20:30 We're not completely unique here, but our footprint of where we can actually build housing. We're surrounded by national forest for the most part, which limits our own footprint. We have other zoning tools and places in place that can do different things. Ultimately, the group here, a question came up the other day, and looking at it was we use floor area ratio for a lot of our commercial zones, which means how much

1:20:58 I think it's like if you have a 40,000 square foot lot, you could do 80,000 2.0 ratio in terms of construction. That can have a mixed use between business and residential uses and stuff. Where the questions came up, well, if somebody wants to do that, can it be 100% transient rental housing? I think the answer in the current code would be yes. Is that something you'd look at and say, well, no, we don't want that to be 100% transient if it was part?

1:21:26 Whatever that split could be for home, it has to be long-term ownership, whether it's second home or people living here, but you take the transient piece out of that, unless it's actually a hotel, motel, designed for those things. So there's a number of different elements, and we don't know them all, and we haven't learned more about this from other agencies out there than you can imagine here in the last six months, so what a lot of different communities are doing, but it's not unique in terms of the struggle that we're looking at.

1:21:56 A lot of places have what they'll call down valley or up valley solutions. That's much more limited here, depending on how far down valley you go, I guess. Then we deal with commuting issues. But those types of elements. And so, you know, it's really not a single solution process. We understand it's created its own turmoil in the community. And so that's one of the reasons of how do we work quickly, hopefully, and come up with solutions as soon as possible.

1:22:25 If they're sooner than what we have laid out, perfect. If there's things out there that people say, yeah, well, this here would make sense to implement or this would make sense to do. And it could be done in advance of even completing some of the work if that's beneficial. As Rob mentioned with the certified property thing, if you're a management company and you have transient certificates there for things, if I want to move from point A to point B, well, currently you can't because that's a new issuance. Can't we address that in advance versus waiting?

1:22:53 If that is something that says, yeah, that's a problem for us, how do we step into some of those things and do some, if we have time and effort to do some solutions as well. But let me pause there and we'll ask for some additional clarity too as we look at work programs and stuff on that. But one, I would love to just get a feel that this is, I guess, some general agreement on the challenge of housing in Mammoth.

1:23:19 And as we look at short-term rentals, again, unless there's a disagreement here, it probably is more of a focused look at the type of income levels or families or the community we're looking at versus everybody. I'm not sure how many condo complexes have a large parking lot where you can just park a van overnight on a regular basis unless it snows.

1:23:42 Anyway, that's a little off topic there, but we've actually had people ask about that. Hey, can I rent out parking spaces for people who want to spend the night? Maybe. Anyway, throw it out there. You know, if you want to be hanging out, do they have access to your jacuzzi and your laundry? I don't know. So you can have that discussion. But looking at the need from a housing standpoint, and then is there a role, what we'd like to, you know, the discussion here, several people are at the layman's comments.

1:24:14 I don't see how this is going to help solve housing at all. Great. Let's put that on the table if that's one of the concerns and issues. And then some steps moving forward, your own perspectives and ideas as well on that. And if you have any questions on the town programs or some of the data provided, Nolan can speak to some of the details on our own projects and programs that we have in place going forward. So we'd love to have that type of discussion. And John, I'll let you lead that off as a chair.

1:24:41 Get your own input and thoughts and pros and cons and glad I'm here, glad I'm not here, take your pick. I'll volunteer. That's what you want to get out of it, right? Yeah, and then end of the day, we do want to come back and look at how do we define success through this process? It may be that everything we have works just fine and people are unknown for housing, so I don't want to prejudge, I guess, an outcome from that perspective. I might be a little harsh on that statement, but...

1:25:10 If there's some goals or how you would define a successful outcome, it would be really good to hear. It doesn't have to be a group decision at this point, but knowing your own thoughts and perspectives on the short-term rental relationship and housing in a broader context as well. So with that, I'll come. Thanks, Dan. Thanks, Rob. What I'd love to do, I mean, I don't want to take up too much time, but what I'd love to do is just go around the room, Jason, if I can start with you, and just get your thoughts on

1:25:38 And I'm glad to hear, just quickly, I'm really glad to hear about the housing component of this. I was a little concerned it was going to be just kind of STR focused because these two things are meshed together. So it doesn't make sense, in my opinion, to work on one without the other. So I'm glad to hear that. But Jason, if you want to go ahead and let's go around the room, unmute your mic and give us your thoughts, your top of mind issues, and if you have any questions with these guys, what you'd like to see out of this.

1:26:08 Well, there's definitely an issue with that middle level, I guess, middle income. And so I've, you know, personally experienced that. I know a lot of my employees have. And so I think coming up with good solutions in order to bridge that gap, as they all said, I think that's going to be important.

1:26:28 But I know I commute to the north end of the county every day in a couple hours, so don't get me wrong, I love where I live now, but I think it's important to address that with, you know, for my staff and for everybody, so. And I don't know what the solution is just yet, so I guess we'll come to that later. Thank you. So basically, you're the prime example of the missing middle who is, can you ask where you live? Live up in Bridgeport.

1:26:59 Last winner was fun. Yes. I think we all agree that the housing issue is a big issue. Obviously, it affects almost everyone. I did have a question for clarification. You guys had mentioned with the certified property. I noticed we have a lot of stuff in here about the housing stuff, and that's great, and I'm glad we have that. But since we're bringing up short-term rental regulation,

1:27:31 I don't see a list of issues that the town is experiencing that we might be able to maybe help you address as part of this component. So I'm curious, is there any hot topic issue? Is it just taxes? Is it noise? Does it pertain to the Measure Z stuff from years ago? Is that something maybe we could put together, a short list of items you would like to see?

1:27:58 hit upon and see how those play together with the housing aspect. I'm leaning towards some kind of subsidy in the interim until we can complete the parcel. I don't know where we'd find the budget for that, but I know the town of Truckee has a lease to locals program that I think is really intriguing, and I've actually reached out to them already to try to get more info. I'm sure you're already more intimate with it than I am.

1:28:27 But I think that might help bridge the gap until we can complete the parcel and complete all the other housing initiatives that we've had. I could be wrong. I don't think I've got the answer figured out. But that's where I'm inclined to lean. So that's kind of my thoughts on the matter. I have a few bullet points that I just kind of wanted to go over. You guys had mentioned that you guys have a meeting on Wednesday that's going to go over housing. And I just wanted to make some comments on

1:29:02 Some proposals that I believe are going to be coming up. There's a lot of projects that are shovel-ready, such as the 238 Sierra Manners project. I've heard the town has been recommending to underfund that project, which could potentially lose $6 million in funding. That would go to another community. So there's projects like that. That project is for lower-income people, but right now on the Mammoth Lakes Housing, there's 200 people that are on the list waiting for housing.

1:29:32 And about 90% of the people would qualify for this program if we can get this housing through. So there is a number of projects that we can continue to work on for rentals. And then a big proponent that I would like to hopefully get through is get down payment assistance for first-time homebuyers or just any kind of buyers in Mammoth Lakes that are not in the 80% and below. So it is that 80%.

1:30:00 FHA actually has a limit of, I believe it's 189,000 and if we met that, so it's like you can go all the way up to that income and you might need to get a big chunk though, like 20% down payment assistance really is not going to do anything. So if we can get enough funds to be able to do a really large down payment and we can do like a shared appreciation where the town is actually making money on these funds that you're doing the down payment assistant on. I can go into that into more detail when we have more time, but that's kind of.

1:30:29 I see my role here just being a realtor and educating this committee on each condo complex and the communities that they reside in, which ones are condo hotels, which ones are not, and really focus on maybe rezoning some areas and then also creating some stronger income streams to support a program like Kelly was just talking about. So that's really my focus here. So

1:31:08 I really like the question that you said, you know, what our goals should be, and I like hearing everybody's thoughts now. I would strongly request a formal process at the next meeting where we actually try to have some concrete goals. And let me give you an example. So when you look at the housing need, it looks like...

1:31:34 And I really want my chart, I want this all put into a chart so we can count units. Because I think that the more that we get very specific, the more that people in town will be able to judge whether we were successful and they will understand our intent much better. Because I'm just always surprised by a lot of the misconceptions I'm still hearing. So that's on us. We're not communicating it well enough. And this is a really good opportunity. So an example is this.

1:32:03 Housing needs assessment that was conducted by the town with lots of good advisors said that we needed 595 units through 2022. But then our housing element production requirement, and I realize the state is very lenient, but it was only for 155 units. And so, you know, I believe our assessment, the thing that then...

1:32:28 creates a big red flag for me is we have done an extraordinary job on the 80% AMI and below the parcel. And we're going to continue to do that. We're going to continue to provide that housing. But I think Rob and Dan alluded to this. I can't state it clearly enough. The state and federal government provides zero dollars to help with missing middle housing. And that's our biggest problem. And there's nowhere for us to go but on our own.

1:32:56 I realize that, you know, it sounds like why can't we just build that housing? But the answer is that, you know, we're getting close to a million dollars a unit. Is that right, Nolan, when it's all said none, when we're trying to provide this housing? It's a range average of about 500,000 to a million units. Okay, so even at 500,000, you can imagine that the money's gone really quickly. So I just want us all...

1:33:25 to be very clear on what's possible in this iteration. And I think it's very important for us to say that even the state government, which was very lenient, said we needed 99 units for people between 80 and over 80%. So the people from 80 to 120 and 120 and above. And when you look at what we've been able to produce, and this is no criticism to the town.

1:33:55 It's probably 12 units or so when you think about Joaquin and, you know, I'm talking about just the ones that would, and the bridge program for missing middle. Is that, it's around that. Units above 80, correct? Yeah. So you see, like, to me, that's our biggest problem and there's also a nice flow that if you get these middle-income families into housing, sorry, then there's more.

1:34:23 opportunity available. So I guess I'll leave it there, but my point is we've been provided with tons of data. These are real-world challenges that we're having. The fun thing about local government is it's not hypothetical anymore. You can name people and you can name a piece of land and you can put this together and you can put someone in a house.

1:34:48 You can't do that when it's hypothetical at the state or federal level. But I just want us to all be super realistic and clear about, and I'm focusing on the housing part because that's what drove this. That's how this all got started, right? There's other things we need to clean up because we're a grown-up town now and we want to have our...

1:35:08 You know, processes catch up to the good work we're doing. But in terms of like, why did this happen? It happened because we have people who are leaving this community and they can't come back. And so I really hope that as a committee, we can agree that we're going to get very focused, very specific so that people will understand. And then one other thing I want to say is the town is doing a lot. And I just want to make a plea to members of the community.

1:35:37 If one more person says, why don't you just, I swear I'm leaving town and I'm not coming back either because none of this is simple. We have hardworking, really intelligent folks who spend all week, every week working on these challenges and so federal lands. The federal government doesn't give anything away. There's literally been one parcel of land that, and it was somewhere where there was a

1:36:04 Very specific reason. We have asked and we've asked again. So I want to make sure that I want to encourage ideas, but I also want us to accept that when we, you know, then talk about why that's not happening anytime soon, that it's true. And we're not, you know, it's not that for lack of trying. And there's many other things like that. So let's get super focused on what we can do. Let's lay it out.

1:36:30 And then let's tell anyone who will listen so that they understand all the effort that is being made and thank you. You're a hard act to follow, Chris. Well, I would just like to say that I'm really glad that we're having this conversation. I feel that, you know, I think the majority of people in town would agree that we have a housing crisis happening and I don't think...

1:37:03 You know, a 45-day moratorium is going to create more housing. But I think that we need to look at everything that we're doing. And, you know, as Nolan and Dan said, we're building the parcel. You know, those are hitting the extremely low, very low, and low AMIs. And the above, you know, above moderate AMIs, they're buying places, the Snow Creek, the nice brand-new places.

1:37:30 But, you know, we just need to look at all the tools in our tool chest and see what we as a community are willing to do to keep our community, you know, because I do feel like at the end of the day it boils down to businesses can't fill positions, you know, the hospital, you can't deliver a baby here anymore. I feel that we're losing our community and I don't want...

1:37:58 You know, I don't think that for Mammoth it's a sustainable plan. You know, other ski resorts have a large kind of suburb close by that has affordable housing where people live and Bridgeport is an hour and I wouldn't say that that's an affordable suburb. You know, Bishop is landlocked. You know, we don't have that.

1:38:23 Close community where we can house our workforce and especially our missing middle. So I'm just I'm glad that we're all at the table and I'm open. I don't have a set agenda of this is the one thing that's going to solve every problem that we have. So I just feel like we're doing our best trying to, you know, triage this crisis. So I really want to go back to the question of how do we define success?

1:38:56 I think that's a good place for us to be setting our sights. And for me, that's affordability for all local residents to live in this community while still maintaining a thriving tourism economy because that's what feeds us. So there has to be a way to do that. I really appreciate that.

1:39:13 People know that this committee is not to decide yes or no on the moratorium. That's not the end-all answer. We're here to really hash this out and creatively think about solutions for this community in many different ways. I like the idea of two different buckets, the housing solutions and the STR, short-term rental maintenance. And I think maybe we need to form some subcommittees to really dig down into those issues.

1:39:43 Oh, I want to recognize the town for the work they're already doing on affordable housing and appreciate that affordable housing means affordable to all different income levels, not just low-income housing. There's a lot out there that the town is already doing. The parcel should be coming online soon. I do have concerns about people being able to qualify for the parcel. The income limits are very low.

1:40:11 You know, they are what they are. And I do have concerns for the housing that's going to open up when the parcel does become occupied, that those units become available to locals and don't get swooped up by investors to put on the short-term rental market. So those are just a few of the things that rattle around in my brain. Thank you, everybody, for all of your comments. Just a few more things to add. Yeah, the missing middle. No question about it. I am losing my...

1:40:42 Last maintenance person next month moving to Carson City, buying a house, been here 10 years, can't make it work. And that's what we face. If we're lucky enough to have staff, trying to keep them when there are other opportunities because some people just don't want to rent forever and if there's no opportunity to buy, they're going to go somewhere else because there are other wonderful places to live. So, you know, that's reality. I know all of us, I won't sermon here too much, but I know all of us who have.

1:41:10 Staffing issues also recognize the fact that we've all been to various places in town and we have not had the greatest service. Everybody's experienced that. And that's awful for all of us. And it's nobody's fault. It's just, you know, I've always had good service in the restaurant, so I'll start with that. But I'm just saying, when you, you know, if you go into a restaurant and there's a long wait and you see empty tables, patrons get mad because they're like, why am I, why am I waiting when there's empty tables? I have one server.

1:41:37 You know, and luckily you've got him or her to come in on their day off or whatever. So we all have those stories. Every one of us can share them and we won't go into too much of that. But that's what we're fighting too. We're giving, you know, we're inviting people here. We're not giving them the greatest service. We're doing them a disservice and we're doing ourselves a disservice in our own businesses. So how do we fight that? I just, you know, I look at some of these numbers and I'm probably off by a little bit, but there's somewhere around 10,000-ish.

1:42:06 Homes, condos, whatever in this town. Approximately maybe 3,000 of them-ish have short-term rental licenses. There are a lot of places that are either vacant, second homes, maybe people come up once a while, maybe they rent, maybe they don't. There's a lot of opportunity. There's a lot of opportunity. There's a lot of, you know, we talk about building. There is a ton of inventory in this town that

1:42:32 It could be available. We have to find a way to make it available, make it interesting, to make, you know, to make a pitch to some of those homeowners of, hey, how can we get you to rent long-term? What is it going to take to make that work? And we all know that recently, a lot of people who have purchased, they have no interest in renting short-term, excuse me, long-term. They are, you know, they purchase their places because they want to use it themselves, they want to come up with their families, they want to enjoy Mammoth, all that stuff. We get that.

1:43:00 But there are also a lot of people who have owned homes in town for a very long time. And have we reached out to them? Do we know what their plans are? Would they be interested in a subsidy? When we start talking about subsidy, we can't talk about that with how do we come up with income for it? Because it doesn't make sense to pull money away from the programs the town's doing, which are great. We need a lot more money to be able to supplement that. How do we do that? I'll throw them all out there. Do we increase TOT?

1:43:29 Do we put a small tax on real estate transactions? Do we charge $1,000 a year for a TOT certificate? What do we do? What are the levers? What are the things that we can work on that, and this is critically important to me, that don't negatively affect locals? We've already had enough issue with TBID. I'm on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, and I understand that part of it. I totally understand the TBID side for locals. I'll digress on this.

1:43:59 So I'm not in favor of doing anything that's going to be a burden for the people that live here and work here full-time. But there are, you know, possible things. Some of these things might not be able to be implemented without a vote. Okay, that's fine. Let's see what that's going to take. But I think it's, so it's that two-part thing. Like we've all said, we work on the short-term rental side. What do we need to clean up? How can we make that better? Rob, I love the certified property thing. I love that because, you know, it...

1:44:25 It drives me crazy when I hear stories of people who come to town who rent a place that's, pardon me, a dump, and there's no one for them to contact, and they have a terrible experience that looks bad for all of us. So trying to clean that up a bit and making it a better experience for everybody is super important. And then on the other side, how do we use all the levers that we possibly have to bring in more income devoted to different housing aspects, whether it's a subsidy, whether it's purchasing property, whatever it might be,

1:44:55 To try to find a way to open up those long-term rental avenues and maybe some sort of a buyer assistance program where there's a way where people can get in and buy at a lower rate or whatever. And Cynthia, I certainly appreciate your input on that because I'm not as well-versed on that stuff.

1:45:17 So yeah, I think that those are two kind of prongs. I like the two buckets. I'm super happy to hear that from you guys, that that's where you want us to go. That all being said, I agree, Chris. I think having some very concrete goals and things that we can, instead of just talking about it, let's get a punch list. Let's make sure we're going in the right direction and getting this stuff done and getting all the ideas out there on the table and working through them.

1:45:46 So what I'd love to propose is for the next meeting, I mean, everybody, if you haven't had a chance, read through here, bring back any comments you have, but let's at the next meeting, let's really dive into this, like, what action items do we really want to take, and where do we want to go, and do we need to split it into different committees to do that, can we do it as a group, whatever works, I don't care, it doesn't matter to me. Those are my thoughts.

1:46:13 Yeah, absolutely, please. Rob, I feel like earlier you mentioned the problem that we're having with TOT or BTC certificate holders and TOT, you know, properties not being able to switch to new property management. If we address that...

1:46:36 I guess my question for the town council, you know, would it be also the flip side of that is I've heard realtors saying, oh, well, this TOT certificate is held by the property company and so they could sell their unit and then the TOT certificate would transfer with the sale. So I guess my opinion is if we are going to allow those units to change

1:47:04 Property management that they should not also be privileged to transfer their TOT certificate during the moratorium. Yeah, so I, you know, when the moratorium first launched, and, you know, I'll kind of acknowledge that fixing or solving for the moratorium components isn't necessarily a focus of the group, but it can be. We had to go through and interpret the letter of the law. How do we operate currently?

1:47:34 How do we issue certificates? Who owns them? All those components alongside of how the languages of the moratorium, right? What was it preventing? And so that's where we came to those conclusions. When we were sitting in the meeting and talking about the moratorium, the idea of it logically makes sense that people will be able to move around if you're already in an operating component. But what we have to disconnect from is sort of the general intent or

1:48:04 Good ideas or good thoughts or to actually the letter of the law, right? That's what we have to implement. So that's where we came to, okay, this is the defining component. It is the TOT cert, which has those two-fold effects as you've described. It means that you can't move around because it belongs to the operator and the operator is the one you would be switching away from. And it also means that a sale of a property

1:48:32 Where it's managed by a third party, where the third party owns the business act certificate and the TOT certificate. As long as they contract with them to continue to rent, that would still be in place. So those are facts associated with the way it is laid out right now and the way we're approaching that. I would have to defer to Andy for a process by which how a moratorium, which now that's council direction and decision, this committee is providing

1:49:01 recommendations to council on how those adjustments are made. And so how that looks would be up to council on how that goes. But Andy would have to walk through exactly how that would occur. Well, I can say that the council could modify the moratorium. It wouldn't extend the moratorium because once you adopt a moratorium, those end dates kind of are what they are, but they could modify it if they chose to.

1:49:31 But outside the moratorium, I mean the council could at any time amend the ordinance on STR certificates to modify who they belong to, who they're held by, how they work, how they're transferable, how they expire, etc. Just to piggyback on that, yeah, because the moratorium was on the issuance of a new, and so once you've made that definition, what constitutes new is where it got into the challenge of nope, that's a new certificate, it can't be issued. Existing.

1:50:04 It transferred because of the owner of that certificate. But that would be when you come back to talking about our short-term rental market and management of the market. Is that an area we want to change of who actually is the operator and the owner of the certificate? As Rob mentioned, under the certified property program, the goal is to have the owner of the property really have their name on the certificate so they're ultimately responsible. It doesn't mean they can contract with whoever to help.

1:50:34 Manage, collect, help, you know, do things. But we do get better data in. One of the questions that comes up is, what is the average daily rate across short-term rental? Well, it's a whole bunch of money from a operator, but how much of that is by unit, we don't know. Or how many total nights are actually available at any given time in the marketplace? This goes back to, I think, Aaron's comment earlier. What is our transient rental?

1:51:01 Market capacity in the community is quite high, frankly, and then it's back to unused and when and how and all those types of elements and those types of pieces to that. So as we get into the idea of managing short-term rentals, I think all of these things come into play. And part of that being, yeah, what does that look like in a total night available, a total ADR, average daily rate type issue on that? And that allows you to look at the question. It's a difficult one.

1:51:28 Is that just wide open? We don't just however many we get in town, we get in town, it's good? Or do you look at, is there any area that we look at a limit of short-term rentals and managing in that perspective for housing-related issues or for managing just the capacity of units in the community? There's a whole lot of issues that start to fall into that discussion. And if they're just, do they become a commodity like a liquor license, right? Kind of actually sell it to the next guy down the street, which...

1:51:57 A whole other issue is it becomes a commodity, and there's been discussions that way as a revenue generator. You know, you can sell a commodity and it's worth X, and that's a whole other can of worms, if you will, or another management tool that's out there that folks have looked at in different communities and stuff. It's that short-term rental certificate actually become a commodity, which, not suggesting we go down that road, but it's definitely something that's out there for folks, those types of elements.

1:52:25 I do like the idea of coming back, if I can summarize quickly. A lot of the comments there, really, you know, I think everybody, more or less, I think there's a general consensus on the missing middle challenge. There's a need just for housing, I think, in general is out there. Dealing with short-term rental challenges, yes, we do have a list. I mean, we deal with parking issues all the time. We deal with overcrowding issues.

1:52:52 They may spend eight hours there that night, but they weren't spending the night, apparently. Anyway, we do run into those, and I'll give a couple examples. We've dealt with one in Snow Creek. John's familiar with it in that area where we've had consistently marketing that actually drives overcrowding. Not internally. Yeah. The other side of that was, remember the explosion we had up on Juniper?

1:53:21 Storm event. Tragic there for that house blowing up. But two properties up evacuated a home that had 20-plus people in there on what they should have had a maximum of 8 or 10, I forget, but nightly rental. And so do we see challenges like that? Do we see that overcrowding? Which, that one, it freaked us out. What happens if that house would have caught fire from the other one? We could have been in a very mass casualty element.

1:53:48 Seeing what was happening there. So we run into those types of challenges. A little bit less on trash. That was a big issue a few years back, just the garbage being left out, those elements. We do have challenge at times on the 24-hour contact, you know? You start calling these places and say, hey, I'm calling to check on, and nobody answers the phone. Those types of issues. That's where you go back to a good management company. Hopefully it solves that for a lot of our guests here.

1:54:19 Who do they call? I'll say personal experience is watching people trying to figure out a code on a door, and then they're on their phone trying to call somebody because they wrote it down wrong or whatever the issues are. And that'll be a half-hour, hour experience of them trying to figure out how to get into their unit. Snowstorm, we had a couple front doors buried and people couldn't find them, which was legitimate. But again, who do I call? Those issues come up.

1:54:46 There's others like that I mentioned earlier. We have illegal building activity going on. And who do we go after for that? Is that the owner? Is that the management company? Is it HOA? What happens in those types of things of that nature? So trying to lay those out, I think it's a good comment, Matt. I guess that issue, what issues? As we look at STR management, short-term rental management, what types of issues do we need to continue to address and look at? Question of subsidies has come up. We've looked at some of those. The question is, are we looking at short-term solution or long-term?

1:55:14 Type solutions on those. Other projects and proposals out there, 238 Sierra Mammoth is one that will be discussed shortly with the town council. Down payment assistance as a way of getting in. Think about if you're managing short-term rentals, but you could actually say, the one lady that was speaking earlier in the meeting, if you're trying to sell a unit, yes, it fell out because you didn't have a short-term rental opportunity. Is that something you could actually provide some additional subsidy to to make that a viable sale?

1:55:44 Don't know the answer. Don't know how much they're asking for. Our housing, our bridge program under the Housing Now initiative takes a look at that and says, here's a unit for X. We'll actually buy down the market value of that so we can get somebody into it from an affordability standpoint, which has included some, I'll call it silent second down payment assistance as well as just direct subsidizing the cost of housing in that. Impact of different condos and what we really have is a...

1:56:12 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:56:40 Very much about what are those hard, you know, Chris, the goals, what are we looking at? What are those measurements we can talk about? How much of that is good management of short-term rentals? And if we have some housing targets and goals, what do those begin to look like? And I think, John, you made the same comment on that to a degree of what is that goal we're looking for? And this is a tool in the toolbox. I'm going off to Amanda's comment.

1:57:07 This is not going to solve all of our housing issues, but hopefully it'll solve some of the challenges we see in the short-term rental market. And doing that, how many people have a buy and hold and how much of that is influenced by, yes, I can make some income, it's not enough to pay for the mortgage, if you will, but the decision to buy and hold is impacted by what can I do from a revenue side of it to some degree, how much, the realtors know this better than we do, how much of that decision's in there.

1:57:35 What does that do to the value of a home? We got a lot of emails with the moratorium, hey, you're going to reduce my home value with this going, well, why is it being reduced? Well, because I can't sell it for an income related with the price of that unit. So those elements start to get into play and say, how do we begin to manage that short-term rental market in those areas? And it's tricky and it's different for every community. So, again.

1:58:01 The stuff I'm hearing, I guess, I'm trying to walk through my notes to make sure we've got some of this stuff in place, but, you know, yeah, how do we provide housing for people who live and work here and recognize the need for our TOT revenues and our tourism? How do we balance that sustainable community with the need for a tourism-based economy? And I think that's probably the succinct way of saying those are the two challenges we're really running against.

1:58:30 How do we make this a sustainable community and viable economically and still support that very industry that funds most everything for us, elements in those areas? Some of that, the unused inventory, we did that with the chamber, with the mail-out to everybody that we could think of. Hey, would you rent it out short-term? Would you rent out a room? Would you...

1:58:55 So a ton of ideas and ways, and then a goal will be how we begin to narrow that down. I think we come back.

1:59:24 Your comment on, let's start nailing down kind of where we're at in that goal standpoint on the management of short-term rentals. How does that flow down into housing management and what levels are those issues? If you're subsidizing somebody who can short-term rent and longer-term rent, if you have people, hey, I'm only there in the summer. I gave up skiing because my knees gave out. I'd gladly rent my place for three or four months in the winter.

1:59:52 If I make sure I have quality renters, that's the other issue we hear from folks. Sometimes the damage at the end of a rental season is higher than what they made it with. So you balance those types of issues off on the short-term rental market as well. So I think walking through that, though, and kind of balancing those things of the STR management, how that relates to housing, as well as these other community issues.

2:00:22 What changes, if any, in our programs and rules that we really should be looking at? Certified property program to stronger limits or management of the short-term rental market that's in this community today. That's kind of my summary from the notes I heard, if we caught those. One thing I'd just like to add that is off in my head, I'm not quite sure how we'd get this information, but we can discuss it as a group, is the need for, you know, is it all year-round? Is it seasonal? Because when I first moved here, it was

2:00:52 Pretty much seasonal. 10% of our business was summertime. It's a little different now. And I know we're striving for a year-round community, but I mean, what portion of housing needs to be available for just winter season versus just, you know, versus full-time year-round? So that's always a challenge. We see a lot of employers stepping into that market. I know rental companies themselves are actually putting their employees up in housing that they're paying for, helping. And if not, is there a lot of that in terms of additional housing and other elements that they're putting on the ground?

2:01:23 The number of units that they operate, including they are one that has found success in going to Bishop for the winter, because they don't, they're not full at that point in time. And so they're able to lease those out and move them for employee housing, for example. So that seasonality of employee demand is a key one as well. And I believe like in the parcel, for example, real quick on that one, we've asked that the federal dollars that are tax credits require 12 completion.

2:01:52 So that doesn't really focus on that seasonal employee standpoint. Chris, do you have a question? Yeah, I just, I don't think everybody on the committee got the cast, which is the Colorado. We can just provide a link to it. We didn't print out the 62 pages. Yeah.

2:02:12 It's in the email, I think. Okay, good. I just highly recommend you taking a little bit of time with this. There's great data in here that just helps you frame your thinking. So these were my favorite three. I only printed these three pages. Yeah, I'll just touch on that real briefly as well. It's really good information, not only for statistical data, but what other communities are doing to solve for this. And so there's a lot of key ideas. I know when it came out, I assigned my staff to go.

2:02:41 through and review and kind of pick out some things that we think are transferable, things that we can bring forward. And so we will be interjecting some of those into the discussion points here, but it's a really good document. So we have all of you in a group, an email group, and we will make sure, I will make sure that comes out to you.

2:03:14 In the interest of keeping this moving forward, how do we set our agenda items for our upcoming meetings? Is that something that we can email the town and the town will set the agenda and then pass it all out? Or is that something that the committee here needs to decide prior to the next meeting? Yeah, we can do a bit of both. If you have particular topics, if you want to send them there, myself or Rob.

2:03:42 Okay. We'll coordinate for building that, but I think at the end of meetings or that process, what agenda items do we need to have on from the group, we can actually have time to do that, to be able to set those things and keep the expectations realistic in terms of as we move forward with that and information. So I would just say that for next meeting, let's make sure we bring, really bring, there's a lot of different options.

2:04:37 It's a great group. Here are all the options and start working on that. You can get off topic and we've all been there. Yes. I'd also suggest if you want, you know, we have just if you want to take a look at them and stuff, but the maps on the back wall here kind of show you the zoning, different elements that are out there. If you're not familiar with that, there it is. I had one other question. I'm sorry, was it BAE, the study group?

2:05:14 Have they commenced studying anything? Do we already have any studies from previous years? Or are they just starting the ball rolling right now? Yeah, we just brought them online a few weeks ago, or a month, a little over a month ago. They've started some of the data analysis, and especially the literature analysis. Aaron can speak to that, but yeah, he actually has a scope of work that we're hoping to have a lot of that done earlier in the process, like the first part of December, so you're not waiting for some economic analysis. So we're looking at a month, month and a half, roughly. A month, yeah. I mean, not to...

2:05:44 Pin it down to a concrete timeline, but just, we think, a month to a month and a half before we have that report. It's certainly meant to be a component of this team's work, right? That information is going to inform you all, and he talked earlier about the sort of nuances of what the issue is within the town. I think it's going to help us formulate that. So I would certainly look for it early on in the process sometime in December if we can. Yeah, Aaron's there. You can speak to that.

2:06:13 Go ahead, Aaron is going to answer the question. Yeah, I'm just curious. Yes, but thank you for the question. I think, in general, your timing's about right. We have done similar research in other jurisdictions, so we're leaning on some of that a little bit, in particular as it pertains to the review of the academic literature, which is sort of the cornerstone of at least some of this research. But then I really want to collect as much data as we can that's really specific to the town of Mammoth Lakes. We've already commenced this

2:06:43 The collection of mostly census data related to the housing stock, housing stock utilization, vacancy rates, seasonal vacancy rates, and those types of things. We're just now starting to get data from the town and Mono County related specifically to STRs, the number of permanent STRs, their occupancy figures, some of those data points that will be critical of the analysis. So some of that's still coming in.

2:07:08 But we are moving forward with the analysis and are hoping to get you some data as soon as we reasonably can. Can I ask you one more question? Are we going to be able to compare our local data, which is obviously unique to us in some aspects, can we compare it to other towns that we consider to be a more apples-to-apples comparison? I don't know what that would be exactly. Maybe it's in Colorado, maybe it's Truckee, maybe it's South Lake Tahoe.

2:07:34 I'm not intimately familiar with any of these, but will we have anything to compare it against in other towns to see what they've done and how it's worked? What strategies have created better benefit to the community? Yeah, that's a great question. So one thing that we've done in other cases and something that we're stoked to do as part of this analysis is look at program and policy components implemented in other jurisdictions.

2:08:00 From my experience, there really isn't a lot of data that can be used to gauge the effectiveness of specific tools or policy provisions, and that's for a variety of reasons. One is just that most STR policies and regulatory programs are quite complicated with lots of different components, and so parsing out the effectiveness of one provision is quite difficult. Also, generally speaking,

2:08:28 The statistical models that are required to calculate the actual impact of, say, a certain change in the number of STRs on housing availability and pricing are very, very complex, require a ton of data. And most of those analyses end up being done

2:08:47 Either at the state level or for large metropolitan areas. And that's mainly due to data availability. And most of the jurisdictions we're talking about and looking at as potential peer communities for places like Mammoth Lakes are much smaller, much more comparable in size. And so the data just doesn't really exist to do that robust of analysis. But we do conduct interviews with stakeholders, policymakers, industry representatives in at least some peer communities.

2:09:16 Try to get their sense of how effective certain policy provisions have been. Admittedly, it's somewhat anecdotal, but it's still helpful information. We've got the list of jurisdictions we've looked at previously. We can fold that into this research, and then we're working to identify other communities that staff, as well as this committee, identify as potential fears. Thank you.

2:09:48 I had one other question on the incentivization side. Is there any countywide or statewide programs that we haven't explored? I assume you've been dealing with this for a long time. Is there maybe a list of things that we've already looked at as the town and decided not viable or provides no benefit so we can kind of look at that and go,

2:10:37 These aren't really options that we can consider and these are the reasons why? Or I don't mean to drag this out, I'm just... Yeah, so statewide programs are, you know, we pretty much look at every kind of grant that comes out for housing. The majority of them, as we talked about earlier, really address that 80% AMI below. There are a few programs. We have one currently in the works that does address up to 120% for down payment assistance. We're working on the guidelines and then getting that approved to the state.

2:11:08 Pretty much kind of any grant funding program that comes out, we at least get our eyes on it and then analyze, is this something that's viable for the community? A lot of them, you know, have put out the dollar amount and then when you dig into it, it might be that there's a minimum ask or minimum project size or once you get into the details as to, you know, know that we don't qualify or know it's not, we won't be competitive. But we can definitely kind of provide a summary as to what

2:11:36 Any programs we've looked at, what programs we've applied for and been successful in? Would any sort of property tax, you know, like for new homebuyers, like you could incentivize them somehow? I don't know, this might fall into a state level, and so we may not be able to actually do this, but is there any way that we can explore at a county level? Have you been working with the county on this? I assume you have in some regard. Is that a viable option to look at like an incentivization?

2:12:05 So you sell your house and you put it as a long-term rental for two years, you don't pay property taxes. Yeah, we don't have that authority. We can't do that. We can't do that. One second, Matt, real quick. Andy? Well, we can't give anyone a tax holiday. Generally, when anyone talks about, oh, let's get people the ability to not pay a fee or a tax, really what that means is the town having to pay it. We don't have the ability.

2:12:33 To just say, yeah, you're not going to pay property taxes on that. I mean, the town would have to sort of make it up. So in essence, the town would end up paying for it. And then if there was any thought of getting any kind of new tax, that, of course, requires voter approval. So I think for maybe the next meeting, we might be able to come up with some more strategies. I mean, Truckee had a whole bunch of strategies, and we can kind of comb through those on housing, that is. And other jurisdictions have had a bunch of strategies as well.

2:13:02 I do think that it might be helpful to bear in mind that the primary focus of this committee, I think, is not exactly on housing, as I understand it, and maybe we can get direction from the council on Wednesday, but I think the primary focus of this committee is really on how to regulate STRs, and the housing issues are related to those, and there may be some tangential discussion of housing, but I think, and please someone tell me if I'm wrong, but I think really we're trying to talk about STRs.

2:13:37 I sort of thought we were talking about both. Yeah, that was from Chris, Andy. I think the element where it got into that was looking at the STR management in relationship to what does that mean for our housing program. And so they are linked, but it does break out a little bit into both buckets, if you were both categories. Well, perhaps the council can help us figure out exactly what the focus is on Wednesday, because there seem to be some different ideas in the room. So, I mean, if council member Bubzer...

2:14:10 I think it's both. That's terrific. And maybe we can get a discussion of what the scope of that is on Wednesday, and then we'll have a clearer idea going forward. The only thing I'd like to add, just to address your question, I don't think anything is off the table, right? We have some key elements that no one knows the detail about we're out seeking, but we'll give you an example of subsidized long-term renting.

2:14:42 That's something I haven't been a fan of, haven't been supportive of because it doesn't produce anything long-term, but it takes resources, right? You talked about it's pulling away resources that we have that are going to convert into true home ownership, maybe deed restrictions, those types of things. But in the process, you know, kind of coming up with if we carved out a certain amount on an annual basis with a program that said we're trying to hit 50 units,

2:15:11 And this is the amount of money we're willing to spend on that. These are the caps and so forth for rent, those types of things. Something could be presented, right, as an option to add to our housing elements, add to our housing components. So I think that's where there's more thinking to be done about it in ways that we can address these things. So nothing is off the table. I understand what you're coming from with the subsidy thing, and I totally get it. It's just a ballooning cost that never ends.

2:15:42 I was just thinking until all the housing programs that the town has explored come to fruition, we need something to bridge the gap between where we are now and where we'd like to be. And so that's where I was thinking that might be a viable alternative because the parcel is going to be a, what, 10 more years, something like that, maybe more. I mean, if the first phase is any indication. I'm not saying maybe the second.

2:16:11 Third, fourth, fifth phases will go quicker, but it doesn't produce enough housing right now to solve our problems. So I think that was kind of my focus on the whole thing was what can we do right now to alleviate the strain, doesn't break the bank, and potentially, like he said, maybe we need to add one or two or three, I don't know what the math would be, maybe that's way too high, tax on short-term rentals only.

2:16:38 to then fund not only this temporary program, but all other long-term housing as well. It just seems like that would be a great way to generate revenue, not hurt the locals, and potentially speed up processes and programs that we're already running. Obviously, that sort of thing would be a tax. It would have to go to vote. I don't think it's something that we can say is we should do this, but maybe that...

2:17:09 That's kind of where my head is with it. Thank you for entertaining all my questions. Sorry to keep you all. That's good. I'd like to say I would like to recommend if next meeting we could maybe each have three bullet points that we want to go through so then it's like I have some ideas that I want to discuss we'll go through in a line and then everybody gets their ideas out and then we can vote on who we want to talk about on which bullet points we want to talk more about on the next meeting. Any other comments?

2:17:42 I just have a point of clarification because I don't want to leave people with the wrong impression. I think I misunderstood what our town attorney Morris said. And so this is housing with regard to short-term rentals and short-term rentals with regard to housing, and it's not a whole separate. So when I said both, I meant the two together.

2:18:13 So that we don't leave with a wrong impression. Thanks. All right. If there aren't any other questions or comments. Oh, yeah. Go ahead, Mr. Mayor. Good evening. Thank you all first very much for your participation in this effort. It's very important. I will be succinct. This is one Brown Act body. I'm not going to offer any comments or ideas in this context, but the council will be meeting on Wednesday night. And I would appreciate that, if you can, if you have the time to listen to our discussion, the same way that the council needs to be listening.

2:18:59 We can't cross-pollinate for Brown Act purposes, but just wanted to thank you all for that. And I think, John, just from a meeting management perspective, there are a lot of people watching this. And I think to identify individual members by name would be helpful, you know, so that people know who's speaking, because it's hard in this room to see who's doing what. That would be helpful. And again, public comment, public engagement is always welcome. Thank you all very much. Seriously, thank you all very much. Thank you. Mayor Wentworth.

2:19:29 Yeah, ask one more question with regards to what he just mentioned, the Brown Act. Are you going to be assigning us all town emails? We've got a request out to our IT department, see if we can do that. I'm sure you'll let us know as it develops. Yeah, if we can. And the concept on that is if we're going to be exchanging information and somebody goes, hey, I want to see all the information, X and Y, or between the two, it's easy for us to pull that. And a request there is obviously not to use your own personal discussions on this, but it goes, hey, well, I got this email.

2:20:07 You have to open yourself up to that scrutiny. All right, with that then, let's see, do we have a motion to adjourn? Second. And we are adjourned to our next meeting, which will be Tuesday, November 28th at 5 p.m. Thanks, everybody. We'll give you more paper.