Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
212 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:29 Testing, testing, testing, testing, testing. All right. No, I got a mute and I can mute it. Everybody? Everybody here almost? Almost. Okay. Linda, we're waiting on councilmember staff. Okay. No worries. Sounds fine. Perhaps we should go ahead and convene the meeting. Oh, there's Kirk. Okay.
10:27 Okay, are we all settled? Everybody can hear me okay? Yes, we can. Okay, thank you. All right, good afternoon and welcome to the Town Council meeting of Wednesday, April 6, 2022. First off, let's do...
11:00 Pledge of Allegiance, and I was going to ask Andy, but Andy flipped away from us here. Can we do roll call, Mayor Salcido? I'm sorry, I'm sorry, did you want to do roll call first, Jamie? Fine, thank you. Yes, please. Council Member Wray is absent. Council Member Souser? Present. Council Member Staff? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Present. Mayor Salcido? Here. Thank you. Okay, now for the Pledge of Allegiance, I'm just going to go ahead and ask Dan Holler, if you'd leave some pledge, please.
11:33 If you'd please stand and join me in the pledge to our flag. Again, I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. So thank you, Dan. So this afternoon, while it's good to be here and see everybody, I am not going to be facilitating this meeting. I'm a little under the weather and so I'm going to be mostly hanging back here on Zoom and be both off and on camera regularly, I'm sure.
12:19 So if our Mayor Pro Tem is willing to conduct this meeting, that would be great. All right. Thank you, John. I appreciate it. Of course. Thank you very much. We'll be watching for you for your participation this afternoon, Lynda. But take it easy in a nice virtual remote world. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. So we'll proceed. Let's start with public comments. It's so nice to see you all.
12:50 And it's so nice to be a room where we can all see each other. So welcome back. I think this is our first meeting with actual human beings in the room. It was a beautiful afternoon. Any public comment for items that are otherwise not on the agenda? Not seeing any? Okay. John? Mammie? Of course. Sure. I'm actually going to impose on a couple members in our audience potentially. But for those who made it out to the play Women, I think that was the right title, the last few weeks and stuff, they did a great job. And two of the...
13:21 Actresses are here in the audience, so I just wanted to recognize them for the work. But anyway, it was a great play, it was a lot of fun, and kudos to those who pulled it off and stuff like that. I just wanted to make that note. I did get out to it and just reminded me of the actresses in the audience, if they want to raise their hand and take a bow. Or just stand and say hello. Welcome to the Grammys or something. I don't know. Thank you very much. Okay, good. Thank you. So with that, we'll move on to Dan.
13:52 No additions to the agenda this evening, correct? No, no additions, thank you. Okay, good. So reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Step up departments. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. I'm glad to be here in person. A couple of updates for the council. I wanted to let the council and the members of the public know that we received a letter from the Mono Lake Kutzadika Tribe requesting
14:23 Nomination for inclusion of the Camp High Sierra Milling Station into the California Register of Historical Resources. And we have until about mid-May to provide comments on this request. So staff is currently researching the request. We're going to talk to the property owner. And at the pleasure of the council, we can bring it back for an item for further discussion and a determination as to whether or not the council would like to provide a formal letter on this. So we can bring that back to you.
14:53 And then the other item is just a heads up that the parcel, the contractor's back out to work on the parcel, removing snow, and we're actually having a construction kickoff meeting tomorrow with a contractor to really get back out there in earnest, looking to set building pads as soon as possible. And then finally, the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be meeting next week.
15:16 There's a pretty big agenda for them. They have a handful of different public hearings. They will be considering the Residence Inn, which is a new hotel up in the North Village. They will be considering a parking management plan for the Sierra Nevada Resort. That was a condition of approval on the previously considered project. The Villas 3, which is the project, basically the north end of Obsidian, that item will be continued.
15:41 There will still be an opportunity for public comment. However, the applicant has asked for a continuance. So we'll bring that item back to the commission in May. And then ESTA will be conducting their unmet needs public requests. So really kind of looking for any needs in the community that are not being met by our current transit service. And that's all I have. I'm happy to answer any questions. Any questions? Sandra, the property where the stone is, the grinding stones.
16:08 That's LADWP property now, right? But it's under lease to Mammoth Mountain Ski Area? Correct. Have we looked at it enough yet to know what the consequence of moving forward with this is? It is an important piece. We have not, yeah. So that's kind of what we're looking at, really trying to understand. This is our first kind of foray into this area. So we're going to talk to LADWP, make sure that they're aware of this request. I'm assuming they are. Talk to the Mountain who has the lease and really try to understand what this means.
16:38 You know, Mammoth Mountain has some ideas for that site. I think they have, I don't think they have anything formal, but really trying to understand how this impacts any future development there. So when we come back to the council for discussion on this item, we'll have answers to kind of all those questions. Good. Linda, anything for Sandra? Can you hear us, Linda? Sandra, on that first letter, you guys froze up a little bit, but was that the letter that we had received a couple weeks ago on the
17:15 The grinding rocks out there at the campsite? Yes. That was the same letter we had received before? Yes. Yes, it was. Okay, thanks. Okay, thanks. No, no other questions. Thank you. Thank you. I think it's Kudzetica. Kudzetica? Kudzetica. Kudzetica. Okay. And is it LADWP or is it L.A. County Parks? I thought it was, oh, L.A. County Parks. L.A. City. L.A. City, right? It's not LADWP. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That's...
17:45 Who the mountain leases the property from. Thank you. I'm good. Thank you very much. Okay. Thank you. Yes. Thank you. Council. I'm Emily Bryant, Office Manager and Marketing Assistant for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And I'm just here to provide you an update from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So to start for air service, I wanted to provide everybody with an winter air service recap. Winter air service came to an end earlier this week.
18:15 And overall, the season was very successful. We saw 4,656 round-trip passengers on advanced airlines between the three markets of Carlsbad, Burbank, and Hawthorne. United had a total of 16,594 round-trips between Denver, San Francisco, and the LA markets. This was down slightly from the...
18:40 20,128 round trips in 2019, 2020. So this is, you know, air travel is still rebuilding from the peaks of the pandemic. United Airlines had zero cancellations due to weather in Bishop this entire season. Quite a feat. March just had one cancellation for LAX due to mechanical issues.
19:04 Advanced Airlines saw no cancellations or diversions in March and overall the blended cancellation rate combining both airlines is less than 3%. So very successful and we're very excited to announce that we will have summer service into both the Mammoth Airport as well as the Bishop Airport. So for the Mammoth Airport, Advanced Airlines is contracting service to serve Carlsbad and Hawthorne. Those flights will be running June 16th through September 12th.
19:32 Thursday, Friday, Sunday, and Monday. And they are offering an early booking discount if you book before May 30th, 20% discount. United Airlines is loaded and bookable, and we're going to fly to San Francisco only for the summertime out of Bishop. So for June 4th, 5th, 11th, 12th, 18th, and 19th, they're going to be flying basically Saturday and Sunday only through most of the month.
20:01 Most of the month of June. And then starting on June 24th, the service goes six days a week, but it does exclude Saturday. And again, our local discounts offered for United. And if you need any of that information, you can email us at flylocal at visitmammoth.com. I will answer your local's request as well. So on the marketing side, we have a photo shoot for a new brand new campaign that...
20:28 took place this last week of March. The new campaign will roll out in October with a focus on sustainability messaging. Brian Wright, our Director of Marketing, is at the Mountain Travel Summit this week representing Mammoth Lakes to international and domestic travel agencies. And then on the local side, I know the ski season is still...
20:49 You know, upon us and the conditions are really great out there. But fishing season is actually right around the corner. So we're going to be producing some Fishmas materials as we always have, welcoming the anglers back to town. They include a window cling as well as a business postcard that has fishing events throughout the season and retail locations where you can purchase, rent or get your fishing license throughout town. So if anybody needs any of those, you can email us at info at visitmammoth.com.
21:20 In the events world, Mammoth Lakes Tourism has awarded nearly $230,000 worth of events grants for the 2022 event season. On the international side, we're conducting sales training with travel trade from Spain and Italy to promote international travel for the summers of 2022 and 2023. All of our international partners are reporting high interest in travel to California.
21:48 So Mammoth Lakes Tourism is also conducting international desk side media visits. The goal here is to produce international media coverage for Mammoth Lakes and drive demand for future travel here to Mammoth Lakes.
22:01 And finally, I have an update from content and communications. We're switching everything on visitmammoth.com right now to spring and summer. So you'll see a lot of our imagery is changing from winter image to summer image. We are also trying to keep a blog up to date with all the seasonal openings and closings. So if you have questions about that, we have that right on our website right now.
22:24 We're planning a writers' conference for the fall, and we're doing a pre-event for that on May 2nd to promote that conference with writers. And then we will be planning an open house for the public on May 10th. So that's all I have if you have any questions. Excellent. Thank you very much. Oh, you're welcome. Bill, questions? I'm good. Kirk? Linda, are you good? No questions. Fantastic. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Welcome.
23:00 Madam Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of council, good to see everybody in person. I'm going to read from my computer because I haven't quite migrated back to paper yet, which is probably a good idea. Just going to update you on recreation, parks maintenance, a little bit on COVID at the end. Summer camp pre-registration went well on Monday. We opened up our camps for one camp or swim lesson per person, just to kind of meet the overwhelming demand, as you know.
23:30 377 camp and swim lesson registrations were made out of a possible 756, so just over 50%. Open registration for all the remaining products opens Monday, April 11. Quick, don't dawdle. Annual spring egg and candy hunt begin promptly at 3.15 Shady Rest Park on April 15th, so that's not too far away, next week, end of next week.
23:58 We'll have a separate area for preschoolers, grades TK through 1 and grades 2 to 5. Don't be late, eggs go fast. Registration is also open for Little Sluggers. That program commences April 27th. That's also at Shady Rose Park. Just a quick update on parks maintenance. That's probably the busiest time right now for that crew. So they're busy preparing our parks facilities and trails. This month, crews will be performing crack repair on the tennis courts, preparing the pool for opening on May 11.
24:27 We're going to spend some time upgrading some sprinkler heads at Shady Rest Park and clearing and sweeping many of our mups and sidewalks. A lot of demand for those trails out there. And then also going to start removing the glass and the dasher boards from the ice rink. Long time coming. And then we provide these updates every Thursday, as everybody knows, in Recreation this week. Recreation Commission meeting was rescheduled to next Tuesday, April 12th.
24:56 Commissioners will be making their youth sports funding recommendations. This year, nine organisations requested just under $50,000 in financial support. For this year's budget, commissioners are recommending $36,800 in financial support. And staff are including a budget amount of $45,000 in next year's budget for council consideration. I just got these numbers from Emily Janoff, hot off the press, for COVID. Last week's case rate was 3.1.
25:26 There we go. Positivity is hovering around 4%. I think everybody's understanding that testing numbers are way down is to be expected. But you said public health, like everyone else, are monitoring the situation with BA2. At this point, public health does not believe there is any cause for concern or major surge expected. And then, finally, OptumServe testing is now at Fire Station 2. Same day, same hours, 11 to 7, Monday, Wednesday, and Saturday. That's all I had. Excellent. Thank you. Questions?
25:59 I'm good. Linda, you all set? I'm good. Let's do a couple quick things. One, a request. I know you guys prioritize internally where you plow and clean off the mups. Yeah. But the folks from Waterford Bridge up to Eagle, they're anxious to... Very aware of that problem. Okay, good. Not problem, but yes, just time to get up there and get that done. Excellent. I don't know if anybody from MLR is here, but there was a question raised about youth sports funding and...
26:28 Thank you very much. Thank you.
27:01 Who's next? Sandra's coming back for some more. Thank you, Sandra Moberly again. And I believe Jenna Carter, our code enforcement officer, is on Zoom. Okay. And she was going to give you an update on code enforcement activities at the time. Excellent. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, Jenna. Hello, Mayor and Town Council and Mayor Pro Tem. My name is Jenna Carter. I'm a town code compliance officer. I am here to present a little project I've been working on and show some of you some code compliance data.
27:33 So for the last several weeks, I've been going around town collecting sign data. I'm going to share my screen for a moment to show you. You should see a map now with some dots all over it, colored dots. Not yet? Okay, thank you. This is Field Maps. So it's a GIS-based application that allows me to go around and collect points and GIS map those points. So this is every business in the town of Mammoth Lakes and their business sign.
28:02 And I was able to share this with the planning department. And now when I click on a point, for example, I just wanted to show you guys. It's a good example. For example, here we have, this is a compliant sign. I just clicked on one and I'm able to collect some data, photo and visually represent whether it's compliant or not. So the most common violation I found were banners around.
28:32 The pandemic, we had a moratorium around allowing banners around the town of Mammoth Lakes to invite, you know, outdoor dining only or those kind of messages. Well, that moratorium did expire. And so now I'm working on going around town and educating everybody about the code and saying banners are not allowed anymore. You do have to apply for a sign permit when you are a new business moving into a new spot. So a lot of this is education.
28:59 And right now I'm just starting out going out telling the businesses that they're if they're out of compliance and letting them know what the code is. That is my presentation. If anyone has any questions, I'm ready. Thank you, Jen. Any questions? The red dots on the map, are those the out of compliance? Correct. Red is out of compliance and blue is compliant. And can we get a can you email us a copy of this map? I can.
29:30 Yes. That would be great. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you. Linda, can I just see you waving your hand? Me? Linda? Yes. I'm here. Jenna, on these, when you identify a sign that is out of compliance, what is the timelines that you give people to correct that problem? We're very generous. Unless it's like a banner, it's simple. A banner can easily be removed. I just talk to them and work with them.
30:02 Do you have someone available to remove the banner? And those, yes, that's been like the same week has been available. Other ones, when it's a permanent sign, you know, that is costly and people have to get signs designed and materials and everything. So I 100% work with people and businesses. Our goal is voluntary compliance. So we're not looking to fine people or issue notices a violation. But in the end, we have that.
30:29 Ability, we could possibly issue notices of violation to the business and the property owner as well. Okay, so as far as the time, it's variable, is that what you're saying? Variable, it is variable, but it's very, I would say, generous. My goal is to work with the businesses, so they need more time. And no more signs along the sidewalk, those have been, we've gotten rid of all those now.
30:57 Correct. They're actually allowed on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street with a permit, with an encroachment permit on certain days. Okay. But right now, those are pretty compliant. When I'm going around town, those are not a problem right now. Okay. All right. Thanks, Jenna. Appreciate it. Thanks. Jenna, thank you very much. Great example of the power and utility of the GIS suite of products and looking forward to seeing a lot more of this kind of stuff.
31:25 It's very helpful for the council to be able to visualize for the community as well to be able to see what's going on on the ground. Thank you. Have a great day. Yeah, you too. Okay, anything else? Departments? Seeing nobody jumping up, so let's move on then to council presentations. I believe Mr. Haislip Hayes, is that, am I correct? And you're going to introduce us to new assistant engineer Pamela Smythman, or Smithman, or it's going to be, I'm sorry.
31:56 He's going to punt that to Amy, our new engineering manager. So, thank you. Apologies, Amy. He's still sitting down back there. I'm sorry. Amy Callanan, engineering manager. Great to see you all here in person. Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, thank you very much. I am very pleased to be here to introduce to you our new assistant engineer, Pam Smithyman.
32:18 She started about a week and a half ago and has come to us most recently as a project manager from Mono County, where she worked for the last three, let me do the math, say three plus almost four years, I believe. She was project manager in the Public Works Department of Mono County working in facilities and some of her projects at the county included working on the banner in Bridgeport across Highway 395, electric vehicle chargers and solar installations.
32:48 The Mono County Civic Center, and various community center improvements, and she also performed some management of the various Mono County cemeteries. Prior to working for Mono County, she worked for Mammoth Community Water District, and prior to that on the East Coast in Pennsylvania and Maryland at Wilson Construction and Turner Construction. She is a fellow Pennsylvanian, so I'm very happy to have one here from Temple University.
33:17 With a BS in mechanical engineering. We anticipate her work program with us at the town to continue to include EV charging stations and also helping us with building permit reviews and taking over management of our assessment districts as well as the various duties associated with our capital projects. So she moved here five, six or so years ago with her
33:44 Then future, now current husband, and enjoys most of the outdoor activities that we all do, hiking, mountain biking, snowboarding, and we are very excited to have her as part of the team. Excellent. Great. Well, thank you very much. Why don't you come up here and shake some hands? We can do that. Thank you. Next, Sandra, I believe you're going to, promotions are in order. Yes, thank you.
34:28 Exciting afternoon here. It's my pleasure to congratulate Kim Cook on her promotion to senior planner. I'm sure Kim's a familiar face to you all. Kim's been here for a little bit over five years. She started as an assistant planner, was promoted to associate, and now promoted to senior. She's done a lot of great work since she's been here at the town. She worked on the airport sequineba project. She updated our general plan housing element, which was a huge, huge work program.
34:56 And currently she's processing the residence in hotel and the limelight hotel. So a lot of pretty big projects and she does a great job with her project. She's very thoughtful when dealing with issues and incredibly detail-oriented, which I really enjoy working with her and just want to congratulate her and I'm very grateful for this opportunity. Thank you. I think one of the other things Kim you've worked on is the donut, the big fuels reduction project involved in that.
35:28 And just to get onto your guys' radar, the SNC board meeting will be here the 1st and 2nd of June. And we've been having some discussions about the tour for that, and that's going to involve this bringing together outdoor recreation, infrastructure and opportunities with the fuel treatment work. I think it's something maybe to get on our calendars. That would be very important if you guys would be able to show up. Thank you. Yeah, shake. No one's shaking in a while. Thank you all.
36:09 Now we're going to move on to some public presentations. We have some proclamations, and I will read relevant excerpts in the proclamations, and these will be resolutions for the council to consider and to vote on. So we'll start with a proclamation of the town council of the town of Mammoth Lakes for Fair Housing Month, whereas April 11, 2022 marks the 54th anniversary of the passage of the Fair Housing Act.
36:38 Title 8 of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 is amended, which enunciates a national policy of fair housing that prohibits discrimination in housing based on race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, and disability, and commits recipients of federal funding to affirmatively further fair housing in their communities. And whereas the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors and the Mammoth Lakes Housing Inc. are committed to highlight the Fair Housing Act by continuing to address discrimination in our community.
37:05 To support programs that will educate the public about the right to equal housing opportunities for all, and to plan partnership efforts and other organizations to help assure everyone of their right to fair housing. I'm going to go and read the therefore be it resolved section, and then we'll entertain any comments, and then a motion and a presentation.
37:24 Therefore, be it resolved that the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, California, hereby proclaims that the month of April 2022 is Fair Housing Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and they're just all citizens to wholeheartedly recognize this commemoration of the Fair Housing Act throughout the year, proclaimed this 6th day of April 2022. Any thoughts, questions from Councilmembers? No, I think we have some in motion yet. Yeah, Patricia Robertson, you probably want to say something about this, so please go ahead. Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth.
37:57 Thank you everybody for having me here today. I'm sorry I couldn't be there in person. I'm excited to accept this proclamation on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors and Mammoth Lakes Housing. The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination by housing providers based on somebody's race or color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, and disability.
38:28 But despite the Fair Housing Act, which was passed in 1968, it's still extremely difficult for many to achieve safe, affordable, quality housing throughout the United States. In Mono County, you probably know that we have a severe lack of legal aid resources for landlords and tenants, and we also have a lack of fair housing testing in our region.
38:54 There is not a single organization that has Mono County as part of their service area that provides these services. Mammoth Lakes Housing is dedicated to bringing those resources to our community. We provide resources on our website. We provide referrals to folks to different organizations that have legal capacity to help folks with those needs. And historically, we have held community office hours where volunteer attorneys have heard
39:25 of the needs of our local residents related to their landlord issues. Most recently we have partnered with California Indian Legal Services to host virtual legal aid hours in our office where folks can come in and Zoom with an attorney who will be employed by California Indian Legal Services but we would have that connection for them here in Mammoth Lakes.
39:56 I want to thank the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors for their partnership and the Town of Mammoth Lakes for recognizing April as Fair Housing Month and appreciate all that you do. So thank you. Thank you very much, Patricia. Any additional public comment? Anybody else want to say anything on this? Okay. I would entertain a motion. To approve as presented. Thank you. Second. Second the motion. We have a motion in a second. Jamie, please call the roll on this question. Councilmember Sauser.
40:28 Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. The motion, the resolution is approved, 4-0. Patricia, it's signed by Lyndon, it's right here. Who should I give it to? I can pick it up. Okay, I'm going to give it to Jamie. Jamie's going to have it, and then you can pick it up from Jamie. Thank you so much. Of course, thank you very much.
40:56 Okay, moving on to our next resolution. This is a proclamation of the Town Council of Town of Mammoth Lakes declaring April 2022 as Child Abuse Prevention Month. Whereas child abuse and neglect can be prevented in the Town of Mammoth Lakes through partnerships between community members, human service agencies, schools, faith communities, health care providers, civic organizations, law enforcement agencies, and the business community.
41:22 Therefore, be it proclaimed that in recognition of the important work done by Monroe County CAPC and all human service providers in the town of Mammoth Lakes, the Mammoth Lakes Town Council hereby proclaims April 2022's Child Abuse Prevention Month in Mammoth Lakes and urges all citizens to recognize this month by dedicating ourselves to the task of improving the quality of life for children and families. That's why you guys are here, is that right? Please, let us know why this is important to you.
41:53 First, I'd like to introduce myself. My name is Courtney Walsh, and I work at the Mono County Office of Education, and I'm excited to actually be here. This is my first in-person proclamation since I started in 2019. So I'm excited to be here, and I would also like to say thank you on behalf of the Mono County Child Abuse Prevention Council for considering April as Child Abuse Prevention Month. 33 years ago today, April was first declared Child Abuse Prevention Month by presidential proclamation.
42:21 Since then, April has become a time to acknowledge the importance of families and communities working together to prevent child abuse and neglect. Working together to prevent child abuse and neglect and promote the social and emotional well-being of children and our families. The Mono County Child Abuse Prevention Council works year-round to ensure that we lead a community-wide effort to reduce child abuse and neglect through supporting trainings, activities.
42:49 Resources and programs that support safe, healthy and resilient families. This year in a collaborative effort, we hosted the Children's Memorial Flag Raising Ceremony on April 1st. We have also distributed over 25 blue pinwheel displays, around 625 resources to the libraries and the schools, and 15 yard signs with the reporting hotline.
43:15 And lastly, three banners, one of which is here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. So I just want to say thank you for that. In addition, as a community, we all play an important role in the prevention process by ensuring the safety and well-being of our children and families by strengthening them. Together, we can strengthen the families of this community by providing concrete supports in time of need, fostering parental resilience.
43:40 Nurturing the knowledge of child development and parenting, bringing awareness to a child's social and emotional confidence, and promoting social connections. Together, as a community, we can prevent child abuse and neglect through early supports that strengthen the families of Mono County. I'm going to turn it over to Michelle. Thank you for recognizing this month. My name is Michelle Roust. I'm Program Manager for Mono County Child Welfare Services.
44:09 A lot of our work obviously happens here in the town, being the population center. I do want to ditto what Courtney said. We, over the years, have tried to get a banner placed as you enter town, and we're met with a little tug and pull, and this year we were able to get that up. And it is a very small thing, but when I drove into work the other day and saw it there, it was refreshing to see a message as you come into town that is...
44:35 You know, a statement of this community's value on families and children and not just a place where you come to play. We are a community. So I do appreciate the town support in letting us hang that symbol this year and hopefully into future years. And I just wanted to take one moment to plug an event that will be happening this summer on July 13th.
45:05 Supervisor Gardner and Superintendent Adler have kind of joined forces with a group of leaders to put on what they're calling a children's summit. And the idea behind that will be to bring community leaders together to really look at wellness indicators for children in Mono County and put together like a data dashboard that can be...
45:26 Maintained over time so we can kind of be looking at measures in a more holistic way, not so hodgepodge as we all do in our different departments and in the schools, but kind of bringing all of those things together and making some agreements on what are the outcome measures that our communities want to track and look at over time. So I'm not sure how the Brown Act rules will work, if all of you could be there or not.
45:55 Councilmember members will certainly be invited to that. And just want to take a minute to plug all of our workforce. We have been, I'm so, so grateful for our social workers who have been carrying out this work investigating child abuse reports throughout the pandemic. We've been uniquely lucky in our county to keep a stable workforce. That's not true in most counties.
46:22 Really hard work. It's work that really, it's not a checklist job. It's a job that requires a lot of curiosity and creativity. So thank you for your support and have a good meeting. Thank you. Don't go anywhere. Oh, any questions? Any questions from Council? No. Linda, any questions from you? I just had a comment and I just wanted to echo what Michelle is saying, that this is some of the hardest work.
46:52 Thank you. And I think Vanessa Hayes from Wild Iris might be on Zoom to address the Sexual Assault Awareness Month. Yeah, I'm here.
47:25 Good. Okay. So any additional comment from the public? Not seeing any. I would certainly entertain a motion. I would move to approve the proclamation as presented. Thank you. Do we have a second? I'll second that. Zoom. Beat you to it. Motion from Bill and a second from Linda. So Jamie, please call the roll. Councilmember Salzer? Yep. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes.
47:54 Thank you. The resolution is unanimously approved. We're going to try something we haven't done in like a decade. We're going to ask you to come up here and accept the proclamation and someone's going to take a picture. Let's see if we can remember how to do this stuff. Share it. Thank you all very much. Thank you. Okay. We shall now move on to a proclamation of the council of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
48:56 Declaring April 2022 as Sexual Assault Awareness Month. Whereas rape, sexual assault, and sexual harassment harm our communities and statistics show that one in six women and one in 33 men will experience attempted or completed rape during their lifetimes. And whereas it is important to recognize the compassion and dedication of the individuals who provide services to victims of sexual assault and work to increase public understanding of this significant problem.
49:25 Therefore, be it proclaimed to recognition of the important work by Wild Iris and all victims, services, providers of Mammoth Lakes that the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes hereby proclaims the month of April 2022 as Sexual Assault Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And we have somebody from Wild Iris, I believe, right? Hi, yeah, I'm Vanessa Hayes. I'm the interim executive director for Wild Iris. And I would really like to thank the council for...
49:52 And accepting this proclamation, we have been working very closely with Michelle, with CPS, and then also with the hospital and law enforcement all through the pandemic to try to address issues of sexual assault in our community. You know, it's very hard to come forward when you've experienced that victimization, and we work really hard to provide services to survivors.
50:18 Thank you for being here. I would now entertain a motion from
50:48 The Council Member to move this resolution forward. Now, therefore, then, therefore, be in, sorry, be it proclaimed in recognition of the important work done by Wild Iris and all victim service providers in Mammoth Lake that the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lake hereby proclaim the month of April 2022 as Sexual Assault Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lake. Well read. Is there a second? Second.
51:24 A second from Mr. Sauser, so Jamie, please call the roll on this question. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you. So, Vanessa, I think this is headed your way. I'm going to pass it over to Jamie Gray, our clerk, and she'll make sure that if you need to come by, pick it up, she'll have it for you. So thank you very much for coming today. Thank you. Yes, thank you all. Okay, so we're going to move on now to the...
51:55 Item 7.4, the Mammoth Hospital Cares Community Engagement Presentation from Mammoth Hospital Chief Executive Officer Tom Parker. Good afternoon, Tom. Good afternoon, Council. Thank you very much for allowing me a few minutes on your agenda today. Did a community survey back in December assessing what people want and what people need care of services generally. And I want to first express my gratitude to the survey.
52:36 It gave us some really good information, which I'll talk about in just a minute. Naturally, we care about, there are a lot of people who have healthy lives, and that's where we want them to be, but we want to hear their voice as well. And so that was what we set out to do back in December. And we're now launching what we call Join the Conversation, which is continuatory and surveying of people. And I'll have some information about how people get online for brief questions to keep that information coming to us. Why are we doing that?
53:15 We have a vision for provision of inpatient services for the hospital. We currently are seeing 10,000 people a year through our emergency, 50,000 people into our clinics. So we're a busy facility, and we want to think about that facility morphing over time and growing. We want to make sure that we're... And so we're putting together plans for that. And they really are around... Next slide.
53:53 And then we want to continue to
54:31 We want to continue to be that place that is a place of refuge. During the fires,
55:06 We work with our fire response and designating our site to be kind of a last place of refuge in place. Next slide. Mammoth Hospital wants to expand access to health care by expanding and centralizing services such as our outpatient procedures, their screenings, read that as colonoscopy, chemotherapy, IV medications, and all of our services for chronic. We have that a bit scattered around on our campus.
55:48 Outpatient Services Center. We don't want people to travel. We've been really recruiting more specialists and expanded capacity of our specialty clinic. And so as we grow, we want our design for providing the services to the community for three hours to Reno or five or six hours down south. And to prepare for these challenges in the future, we're working to create a plan, as I mentioned, so that we're ready to address the health care needs of our residents and our families. Next slide.
56:25 So let me tell you what we heard in this first round in our survey. The community recently identified these priorities, maintaining advanced local patient medical care, continuing to attract, retain, retain the most qualified, well-trained doctors, nurses, and specialists, maintaining our own local health care services here, and interestingly, what ranked high among the, we do have some older facilities.
57:03 Thank you very much. Any questions from Councilmembers? No questions, just a comment.
57:41 As one of those 10,000 emergency patients last year, and the great staff, Dr. Kral in particularly, I can still use my right arm this year, so the hospital gets high rankings in my mind. You guys run a good facility. Lynda, anything from you? No, echo Bill's sentiments. We're very, very fortunate to have a facility of this quality in our small community, and just thank you for keeping it going and continuing to make it better all the time. Thank you.
58:16 Thank you, Mr. Parker, Dr. Parker? Mr. Mr. Parker, thank you very much. Thank you, and I'll just, parting comment, is it's great to be back in this room, person to person, and not talking about COVID. Not talking about COVID yet. Yeah, which I was here doing in earnest two years ago. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so now we'll move on to the consent agenda, and I'll read the items, and everybody can...
58:45 Consider if there's anything here worth some further attention. Item 8.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of March 16, 2022. 8.2, approve the minutes of the special meeting of March 30, 2022. 8.3, approve the resolution reauthorizing the Town Council to meet virtually during the COVID-19 pandemic declared emergency. 8.4, appoint the three applicants to serve as members of the Building Advisory Committee Board of Appeals with terms expiring on April 1, 2026.
59:14 8.5, authorize the town manager to dedicate right of way for street purposes within the parcel. 8.6, resolution to approve the fiscal year 22-23 project list to be submitted to the California Transportation Commission for funding from the road maintenance and rehabilitation account funds under streets and highways code section 2034. 8.7, authorize professional services agreement with BPR consulting group for building plan check services.
59:42 8.8, award contract for the 2022 Bluffs Slurry Seal Project to Intermountain Slurry Seal, Inc. 8.9, waive the reading and approve by title only the ordinance amending chapter 2.40 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. And item 8.10, accept payment approvals, approval report number 22-37, the amount of $313,854.73.
1:00:08 Accept payment approval report number 22-38 in the amount of $1,162,479.02. Accept payment approval report number 22-39 in the amount of $773,823.93. And accept payment approval report number 20-40 in the amount of $675,608.38. Anybody wishing to pull anything from the consent agenda items is red.
1:00:38 Nothing from staff. Okay. Everybody's okay? Council's good? Okay. I would entertain a motion then to approve the consent agenda as presented. Move to approve consent as presented. I'll second the motion. Thank you. Jamie, please call the roll on this question. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you all. So we'll move on now to a public hearing. And...
1:01:08 This public hearing is to the introduction of an ordinance establishing underground utility district UUD 2022-01. Hayes, I believe this is you're going to lead us through this. I'm going to open the public hearing before you start your presentation. So a subtle tap of the mallet, please. Thank you. Thank you. So I can see my screen and I can hear my voice. And so I think I've done this correctly. Thank you for your patience for my first time using Zoom.
1:01:38 So we're here as a continuation of our item last month where we defined our intent to create an underground utility district. Today we're introducing an ordinance establishing this district. The recommendation in front of council is to conduct the public hearing and introduce by title only the ordinance. Quick background on what we're going to do today. We'll talk about the formation process just to bring you up to speed where we're at.
1:02:11 Look at the actual extent of the district, and then I'm going to go over very loosely the ordinance and code chapters. So where are we at today? We're about halfway through the process. Our last meeting, like I said, we adopted our resolution of intent. We did publish another notice of public hearing. We did mail that to all of the residents adjacent to the district with a copy of the resolution.
1:02:42 So this meeting is the first reading. The second reading will be, just to remind you of the extent, we're looking at undergrounding the utilities from Main Street along Laurel Mountain to the intersection of Tavern. We will capture the poles near the fire station and the entire intersection of Tavern Road in Laurel Mountain. So the ordinance that's before you, pretty straightforward, includes the recitals of how we got here today, talks about the CEQA exemption.
1:03:13 Makes findings why this project is in the public's interest, why it's necessary, health, safety, welfare of the public, how this project implements our general plan, and it does create a new chapter in our municipal code. Andy put that chapter together for us, includes a lot of stuff that I'm not going to go over in detail, but if you have questions on those specifics, Andy is here to answer. So that is the extent of my presentation, and I'm happy to field any questions.
1:03:44 Thank you very much. Let's get some questions from the Council. If there are any, then we'll turn to any questions from the public. I guess, Lynda, I'll just start with you. In the virtual universe, any questions for Hayes on this item? No, I have no questions. Thank you. Thank you. Bill, Kirk, anything? Why are you undergrounding my utilities again? That question is not your name of the topic at hand. Thanks. Nice try. Thanks anyway. Bill, you're very far down on the list. Yes, I am.
1:04:15 Questions from you, Kirk? No questions. No questions from me. I think it was a good presentation last time. So any questions from the public? Seeing none, we'll close the public hearing. And we will, council will deliberate or certainly entertain a motion if that's appropriate at this time. I would make a motion to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance as presented. Thank you. I'll second the motion. Motion and a second. Any further discussion?
1:04:50 Seeing none, Jamie, roll please. Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you. So we'll see you for the second reading in later in April. All right. Thank you very much. Now we're going to move on to a public hearing with a slightly longer name. So excuse me while I meet this. Sure. I need to recuse.
1:05:21 From this item, as it pertains to the parcel, and I live within 500 feet of the parcel, before my rights to speak on this issue have been taken from me. Okay, so you're going to go in that little room over there and close the door. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Bill. So the Town Council will now conduct a public hearing under the Tax and Equity Fiscal Responsibility Act, or TEFRA.
1:06:01 In connection with the proposed issuance of revenue bonds by the California Municipal Finance Authority, the CMFA, a joint exercise of powers, authority, and public entity of the state of California, in an amount not to exceed $50 million, the bonds, to finance or refinance the acquisition, construction, improvement, and equipment of a multifamily rental housing project located at Tavern Road and Center Street.
1:06:25 APN 035-010-020, Mammoth Lakes, California, The Project, and adopt a resolution to become a member of the CMFA and to approve the financing of the project by the CMFA. So Sandra Moberly, perhaps, I'm going to open the public hearing and then perhaps you can introduce us to what this is all about.
1:06:46 Yes, I would be happy to. Thank you. Thank you. So as you introduce the item, we are here for a public hearing pursuant to the Federal Tax Equity and Financial, I'm sorry, Fiscal Responsibility Act, or TEFRA. So TEFRA requires that any time an agency is going to pursue a project financed with tax-exempt financing, we conduct a public hearing by the governing body of the jurisdiction.
1:07:11 Pacific West Communities, who is our development partner for the parcel, has asked that the California Municipal Finance Authority, CMFA, be the issuer of this tax-exempt financing in an amount not to exceed $50 million. And this financing is going to be used for the acquisition, construction, improvement, and equipping of a multifamily rental, affordable multifamily rental housing project at Tapper Gronin Center Street, also known as the parcel.
1:07:41 The CMFA is a joint powers authority, and it was formed to assist local governments, non-profit organizations, and businesses with the issuance of both taxable and tax-exempt debt. So just to note that the debt that's issued by the CMFA is the sole responsibility of the borrower, and the town of Mammoth Lakes has no financial or legal obligations or responsibilities with regard to the repayment of this debt.
1:08:07 All financing documents will carry disclaimers that the loan is not an obligation of the town and the town will bear no costs in the issuance of the proposed debt. So with that, we recommend that the town council adopt the resolution approving the issuance of the bonds by the CMFA for the benefit of the borrower. And this adoption is solely for the purposes of satisfying the requirements of TEFRA, the code and California government code section 6500.
1:08:37 The resolution will also authorize the mayor or mayor's designee to execute the joint exercise of powers agreement with the CMFA. We do have a representative from CMFA on the Zoom call, and we also have Sheldon Rodriguez from the applicant who is representing the applicant on Zoom as well. If you have any questions, detailed questions for either of them. And that concludes my presentation. Excellent. Thank you. Jamie, can we promote those people?
1:09:04 I think Anthony Stubbs is here from CMFA, and I think Shellen is probably on as a, probably just needs to be promoted. Okay. So we do have Anthony Stubbs here from CMFA. He's on Zoom. I don't see him. Oh, I don't see him up there. Let me check over here. Yeah, it's just because he's not, he doesn't have his camera on. Oh, I got you. Okay. Hi, Anthony. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Thank you. Well, let's, I'll go to council first to see if we have any questions, and then if we're missing anything or something you think we should know, you can.
1:09:37 Fill us in on that. Sure. Kirk, anything to have any questions? I'm very supportive of the resolution. Yes, I understand. Linda, anything from you? No, we'd welcome any further illumination, but as far as I can tell, this is an absolutely appropriate thing to do. Okay. I'll just ask Sandra and the town, is everything associated with this item consistent with the work that you guys have done with the parcel to date?
1:10:05 Everything's consistent. Everything aligns. It's consistent with what we're trying to do with this project. Yes. Yes. Okay. With that, is there any comment or thoughts on the public? Don't see or hear any, so I'm going to close the public hearing. And we'll move to council deliberation. I would certainly entertain a motion. Anthony, nice of you to stop by and be here with us today. Anything you'd like to add to the conversation or anything you think the council should know at this point? None.
1:10:41 Nothing more. Just we appreciate the work that staff has done and the council to put this on the agenda. Thank you very much. Okay. And Ms. Schellen, she's not on. No, she is having internet issues. Oh, okay. Sorry to hear that. All right. Well, with that, I would certainly entertain a motion to move this forward if that's what we're doing here this evening. So I can, Kirk, you want to go ahead? I can go ahead and do it. I'll move to adopt the resolution as presented. Thank you. I'll second that.
1:11:12 Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Jamie, please call the roll on this question. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you all very much. Thank you. And thanks for everybody's hard work for moving this thing forward. Okay, so move on now to policy matters. Item 10.1 is billed. Did you? I just got it. Okay. I apologize. It had a long title, but it didn't take much to get it done.
1:11:49 So we're going to move to policy matter 10.1, which is to consider the acceptance of the final draft mobility hub study program. And who's our staff person speaking to this? Sandra, is this you? Yes, I'm happy to speak to it. Thank you very much. Thank you. So at your last meeting, staff provided a presentation on the mobility hub study. And so...
1:12:14 At that time, we received a number of public comments asking for additional time to review the study and to provide comments. So we did continue the item to tonight's meeting. We have received probably more than 10 different public comments on the item. They have all been provided to the council. A broad range of comments, but in general, really, I think what the comments are basically surrounding the community center site up in the North Village.
1:12:42 And concerns about placing a mobility hub study there. I think there's the impression that this document is really just authorizing, you know, moving forward with that process. And really this document is simply a planning process looking at different options for mobility hubs in town. And any work that we would do up in the community center area up in the North Village would require additional town council discussion, direction, CEQA, all of those types of things.
1:13:10 We don't have a formal presentation on this. We're happy to take public comments if anyone would like to provide public comments now, any questions from the council. And we did provide direction that the council can consider accepting this document. The council could also just receive and file that document as well. So certainly options by the council, but I'm happy to answer any questions that you have on this item. Thank you. Any questions for Sandra? Okay. Any questions? Questions?
1:13:42 I don't have any questions. I have some observations. Is there any public comment then on this? I really appreciate the effort going into mobility planning. I wasn't clear on what acceptance or receipt was on this particular study. As a set of data points, I think, you know, it seems like something worthwhile taking in and reading, having read it.
1:14:17 There's about 50 people surveyed in it, and half of them were at Bluesapalooza a couple years ago. I'm not sure what level of sobriety they had when they answered, but, you know, as a basis for planning, I would hope we could do more and more in-depth and more current review of what we're looking for. We've seen some real big changes. This thing, I think, got done before COVID.
1:14:45 And now we've come through two years later. We have some big changes that have happened in communities like ours with people moving in full time and really changing the dynamic of how people work. We have more people working from home and whether they were here before or not. You know, there's some conclusions reached in the document. I think one of the conclusions is that
1:15:14 The majority of people who work in the town of Mammoth Lakes don't live in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'm not sure that's a factually accurate conclusion and obviously has a lot of impact on what we do about mobility planning. I think some of the other things we've seen recently as well in similarly situated communities Andy's aware of what's going on up in
1:15:40 North Lake Tahoe with planning around microtransit. And that really wasn't something that was on the table for discussion when the study was done. And now we have all these new models. I'm still on mailing lists from Tahoe. And I got one today for the CCC. And one of the items on the agenda was microtransit for the Truckee area.
1:16:07 And, you know, and so that's following what we did in Olympic Valley and Alpine Meadows and what TART adopted in North Lake Tahoe. It's an incredibly powerful and successful model to supplement things that are already working here, like our really excellent free public transportation system. And so, you know, trying to fold in things like that, I think, are really important from a planning perspective.
1:16:34 I also noticed in the document it seemed like there was maybe not as much clarity as to the difference in mobility during snow periods and non-snow periods. And maybe that was a little bit lost on the folks from San Diego when they were applying their models to what we do here. So, you know, from the ski area's perspective, we're obviously a partner in transportation.
1:17:03 And how we might get into new types of services like
1:17:32 So, you know, accept, receive, I'm not sure what that exactly what that means in this context. I do think it's, you know, we've probably paid for it. And so it's a set of data points that are out there. But from a planning perspective, I'd love to see us do some new, some contemporaneous review, maybe a little more detail, maybe a little more applicable to with some of the knowledge that's here locally.
1:18:02 Before we start making plans for our cube. So appreciate the chance for public. Thank you, Ron. Thank you very much. Anybody else wishing to comment? Is anybody in the virtual universe? No. Well, we had a number of comments came in by email and letters to the council. So I guess I'll just turn to my colleagues here if you have any thoughts, comments for staff. A couple of things. Sitting in this chair versus being a member of the public.
1:18:35 Learn different things. Reading all of the emails that came in on this, all of the comments on this, I think there's a misunderstanding about what this meant. For it to be an adopted plan, we would have to go through a full sequel process and everything else to bring it in, and no one has suggested. Because there is something suggested in this plan, doesn't mean it would ever come to fruition, because again, it has to come back to us and it has to go through it. So it was never the horrible pill that people were perceiving it to be.
1:19:10 And after listening to all of those comments, I think the appropriate thing for us to do at this point, that nobody gets, it's still a database that staff can use to plan moving forward, but so that nobody gets the misunderstanding that this is written in stone and these are the things we're going to do, I think simply receiving this and taking no other action is the appropriate function. I would agree with Bill and I, you know, there's other databases out there and being on Mammoth Lake Housing Board.
1:19:46 Thank you. Linda, anything from you? No, I have nothing to add to those two comments. I would agree. Okay, so I'm in agreement, Bill, with your recommendation about how the Town and the Council should accept, I'm sure you should receive this item. I think it's important to point out to the public,
1:20:21 That this study was the second attempt at a study that is a component of a planning effort called Walk, Bike, Ride that we've talked about. And I think to Mr. Cohen's comments about more, let's look for more contemporaneous, more contemporary solutions for the kinds of things we're talking about, there's a lot of stuff in that Walk, Bike, Ride plan that I think we really need to start looking at to bringing forward.
1:20:46 And I would point out to the folks who wrote comments on this bill that you mentioned that the council did provide direction to the public work staff and others to start looking at using, as was mentioned in some of the letters, the adoptive plans of the town, one of them being the trail system master plan, which has a very good inventory of all the nodes in the town that connect the community to the public lands that surround us.
1:21:11 But that's a very good place to start and to overlay the recommendations from Walk, Bike, Ride into those nodes that already have a programmatic CEQA document on top of them so we can start moving some of this stuff forward. So, Ron, it's welcome back. It's great to have you back in town in the community. I think there are going to be some very important opportunities to move forward on those kinds of things. I think we very much look forward to keeping you engaged with that. I think your insights about the snow, non-snow pieces can be very important.
1:21:38 I think a lot of the lessons you learned up north are going to be very helpful with all that. But I think we have a way to move forward with all this work. And I'm very much looking forward to seeing what the Office of Outdoor Recreation comes up with as they make recommendations for this variety of nodes. And it's one of the many complications with COVID that we started this thing with a lot of momentum before COVID happened and things have gotten attenuated and stretched out.
1:22:04 So I don't have anything to add to that other than this is a component of a process. One other thing I would point out is I think we have a project that may be coming in front of us in the North Village with the limelight project that may be coming in front of us. And we talked many years ago, I think at this point, about that transportation and mobility challenge, the interface of that project and the North Village, and that those are going to be some things we're going to have to, hopefully we can bring some of the things out of the walk, bike ride to help us. We have talked about it in our plans.
1:22:33 Thank you. Thank you.
1:23:02 Okay, we won't ask you to come to the microphone to repeat those comments. So with all of that being said, Bill, do you want to make some sort of a motion about? I don't think we need a motion, John. It's not a consensus you can receive and file. Consensus to receive. I think we've already achieved that. Okay, good. All right, well, thank you all for that. And so now we're going to move on to...
1:23:28 Item number 10.2 to award a design build contract for the 60 Joaquin housing project. I see. Thank you, Ron. Thanks for coming down. The musical chairs are moving around. There is no music, just the shuffling of chairs. Hayes. Yes? Actually, we have Nolan from the planning department. He's out in the Zoom world, so Nolan will walk through this, and Hayes is also here for some of the questions on the actual design build side process.
1:24:05 Nolan. Great. Thank you, Council. So Hayes and I will kind of both be presenting on this item. As noted, this is the bid award for the town's proposed housing project located at 60 Joaquin Road. Just a quick overview of the presentation. We'll touch a little on the background and the overall concept for the project. Touch on the design build process.
1:24:35 Go over the award and the proposal and then the recommendation. As noted, this project really is one of the key components of the Town's Housing Now initiative, which is a series of programs directed at providing community workforce housing. The Housing Now program includes provision of new affordable housing development and also unlocking existing housing opportunities such as the bridge program.
1:25:04 And then on the new development side, we have what we're calling our small site development, which is the acquisition of smaller sites throughout the community that then we'll propose affordable housing projects on. And then on the larger side, we have the parcel going on. So on the small site development, the first site that we've acquired is 60 Joaquin Road. We acquired the site in July 2021, 0.20 acre vacant site looking in the RMF1 district.
1:25:35 The zoning on the site allows for four units with the town density bonus. The design inspiration that we came up with internally as staff is ownership units targeting the moderate income households. So down here on the lower right up, the housing bridge. Right there in the middle is the desired target income, those 120% AMI households. They also known as the middle income. All units will be deed restricted.
1:26:03 The deed restriction will require the owners to be income eligible at the time of occupancy and then will require that they live in the unit full time and work in the region on an ongoing basis. That's monitored annually. Another design inspiration, we were focused on creating a very livable two-bedroom unit with the garage, with washer-dryer hookups, small decks, small outdoor spaces.
1:26:31 The model we came up with was the plan unit development model, which the property owners will own the land that's underneath the building. This also allows for them to have small yards that are beyond the property. We also focused on this model because it's replicable and scalable. If we get larger sites, we can take a similar building design, complete the site design layout, and then go right into the construction process rather than having to go back through the full design, build,
1:27:01 Process to get a design since we already have a design that we know works. Just touch on the design build process. We gave a summary of this to the town council in December of 2021. The design build, the two, basically the two construction methods. You have design build, then you have design bid build.
1:27:25 Why the design-build process is preferable is because it provides a single point for design and construction services, so it streamlines that, provides cost certainty in that when they come in with the best value, guaranteed maximum price, and we execute the contract, that is all that we will pay for the project. Some other key components of the design-build process, it's all contained within public contract code 22160. This was combined in a single point of legislation a few years ago by the state to try to
1:27:55 Streamline and encourage the use of the design build. A few of the high-level pieces of it requires a conflict of interest policy. We adopted this back in November 2021. This simply identifies the entities out there who are ineligible to propose on the design build because they have some conflict of interest. Then from there, we issue a request for qualifications. It's a process intended to pre-qualify the proposers who might then submit.
1:28:24 On a future RFP. Also highlights the scope of the project. From there, another key critical component of the design build process, bridging documents. This is a set of documents developed by a certified design professional that shows the scope of the project, shows what required amenities the town expects or the jurisdiction expects to see in the proposal.
1:28:50 For that, we did bring on H&C Architects. They provided those bridging documents in February 2022. Since they provided bridging documents, they're conflicted out of participating in the RFQ or RFP process. Then from there, the next step in the process is to issue the RFP, the request for proposal. That RFP is only sent to the short list of firms qualified through the RFQ process.
1:29:16 We also, in there, identify whether it's going to be a best value versus low bid procurement. For our project, we went with best value. Also, it highlights the labor requirements and provides the draft contract. One critical piece of the labor requirements is that it requires profiling wage and a skilled and trained workforce for the project. And if anyone has any questions, feel free to cut Hayes or I off throughout this presentation.
1:29:47 Past the summer of the design-build process, I will hand it over to Hayes to talk about the proposed award and project. Thanks, Nolan. I want to point out, it was only November that we approached Council with this aggressive plan to provide housing, and I want to thank the Council for allowing us to try this new methodology. This is a process that we have not...
1:30:13 I tried here in Public Works to acquire a contractor to build. I need to thank Andy and his team for putting together the requisite documents. Without them, we would not have been able to move forward. I also need to acknowledge Nolan and Amy's hard work and diligence to execute this aggressive plan to turn a vacant piece of land into housing units.
1:30:33 With that, the award is pretty straightforward. This is not anything you haven't seen before. We've gone through the proposal. We've looked at all the bonding, all the measures, and so forth, and we've found it to be complete. The recommendation in front of you is to award the contract to MMI Consulting for a guaranteed maximum price of $2.42 million, authorizing myself to execute the contract and to accept the project when complete. Okay. Good.
1:31:02 Good. Okay. Questions from Council. Why can't we have it by the end of this summer? Okay. Sorry. We got some eager beavers here. Lynda, please go ahead. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for the presentation. Two questions. Is there any kind of a concept or a drawing of the back of the building? We see what's in the front here. Are they just flat in the back? There's no balconies or anything off the back?
1:31:28 Yeah, yeah, we actually have a full set of renderings of the concept plan. Nolan, I don't know if you can drive and bring those up. Well, can you do that, Nolan? Yes, just one second here. We'll get those up on the screen. Just curious, you know, given some of our past questions on this, I just kind of wanted to know. And then while we're looking at that, what, if you could remind us, what backs up to these, I think one side's three, other two sides is lots, and then what's in the back?
1:31:58 On the back side of these. There's another complex to the north. I think it's a four or sixplex. To the south, it's a single-family residence on a large lot. To the east and west, we have the road. While no one's bringing that up, I will add that the proposal is just that. It's just a proposal. This is not set to stone.
1:32:20 The contractor will be required to go through the typical entitlement process and will have to go through. So what you see here today is not the final renderings but can give you a good idea of what they're able to accomplish. Okay, thank you. That's a good clarification. I appreciate that. And I think those are the main questions I had right now. Are we still on track as the completion date we discussed when this was approved by the council?
1:32:47 What the contractor has proposed is breaking ground in August with the completion one year thereafter. So we'd be looking at August, July 31st of 23 as the date they put in their proposal. Good. I'm just looking for the rear of the building. That's it right there. So yeah, on the screen here, you can see that the rear as well as one of the side views. So it's fairly flat on the backside. It does have a shed roof near the bottom.
1:33:23 There is a door leading out of the garage to the small yard area as we indicated that all these units would have. They are able to provide some breaking up in the mass and with variations in materials as shown here. That's one example. Obviously, the colors and everything else we can tweak and refine through the design review process, the entitlement process. This is really showing that the design works, it fits on the site, and it hits all the
1:33:53 Okay, thanks. That's all I needed. I appreciate that. Thank you. Bill, any questions from you? Yeah. Okay. On the lot, are these garages facing south? Those are facing south. Yeah. This is a test to see if staff understands snow and sun. Thank you. The only other concern I have, and I've talked this over with Dan, is in the deed restrictions.
1:34:30 In the past, Mammoth has gotten millions of dollars to build housing, and we've lost an awful lot of the deed restrictions because perhaps they were not written in stone in the first place. So, and we weren't able to buy them back as we have a program now to do. Always be in that position to buy back. Can we put a deed restriction on these, at least for workforce viability, that they will stay deed restricted for those 50 years, whatever that term is?
1:35:03 Because that's really what's necessary here. Let me take a stab at that. So the issue with the deed restrictions is that lenders generally don't want to lend unless their lien will be senior in preference or priority over the deed restriction. And when that happens, if they foreclose, the deed restriction gets wiped out. It is possible to refuse to subordinate the deed restriction to the financing.
1:35:30 But it then becomes difficult to find a lender willing to lend. You have to deal with kind of specialized lenders who understand how this stuff works. So that's always a tricky decision to make. And you don't have to necessarily make it for all time. You can agree to subordinate once and then not agree to subordinate for a future buyer. But it is a trade-off. And so the best thing to do is to sometimes you have to subordinate, but then you have to write something in saying we get a right of first refusal.
1:36:00 If we get notice that the lender's going to foreclose, then you have to be prepared with a pot of money to step in and just cure the default or buy the unit back so you don't lose your deed restriction. However, Andy, if we build them to certain, and I don't know if it's qualifications or specifications, there are lending companies if it qualifies for it. So if we make sure it qualifies there, then we should be able to maintain the deed restriction.
1:36:31 Being misled, Dan? No, you're right. You're right. There are lenders that understand how this stuff works and they're willing to do it. What sometimes happens or has happened in the past is that buyers will say, I want to work with this lender. I want to work with Bank of America. I want to work with somebody I know. I don't want to have to work with one of these specialty lenders that have hoops to jump through, that might not have rates that are quite as good, that might be far away, that might have a longer process, et cetera. And so that's when public agencies, including the town, have sometimes said,
1:37:00 So there's not a perfect solution either way, but what we can do is kind of be aware of the issue and require notice if we do agree to subordinate and be prepared to step in and buy the unit so that the date restriction is not lost in foreclosure. But this is an issue that every jurisdiction in the state
1:37:31 That deals with affordable housing and has deed restrictions as space. It's a huge problem. I believe in the first go-around, we had people buying these units on the premise that if they sold at the right time, it wouldn't sell within a certain number of months. They would lose the deed restriction and they wouldn't sell it at a profit. Well, that's the other issue that has happened in the past, and I don't know about here, but it has happened in some places where in an effort to entice people to buy units, sometimes
1:37:57 Jurisdictions have done deed restrictions that worked exactly like that, that gave a relatively brief window for a sale, and then it was like, okay, fine, if it doesn't happen, if there's no sale, then it goes away. And that was a way of trying to get people into the units and encouraging them to buy, and people in deed restricted units might need to get their money out of them and might be trying to move into another deed restricted unit elsewhere. And so that's another trade-off. I mean, if you have that kind of
1:38:26 of ticking time clock on the deed restriction, it can help the buyer, but it's not so good for the town in the long run. So I think the current thinking in that field is you don't want to have those sort of self-imposed time restrictions on a sale. I mean, it's not as good for the buyer or for the owner, but you generally want to say, no, you can't sell it for more than the right price no matter how long it takes you. And that way you're not, you don't lose it that way. You'd only lose it in the case of foreclosure.
1:38:58 The only other thing is a comment. If we can make these come in as good as the artist's rendering, I'll be happy. And don't let my questions fool you. I am a huge proponent of this and have been from the beginning. I want to see this thing move forward as fast as we can move. Because this is a critical part that we cannot get grant funding for. And we have to find a solution. And I think this is a great thing. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. John, if I can add. The only thing I wanted to add, and we addressed it in the staff report.
1:39:32 Right now, we originally set this program really looking at targeting people up to 120% of every median income limit. Given the recent changes in the real estate market, rates are now, depending where you're at, 5% or better on interest for a home loan. We have looked at the potential of going to 150% of AMI. I think it opens that window up a little better, probably gives people a better chance to have the right down payment and be able to make a mortgage payment.
1:40:03 And also would reduce the amount of a discount that we would have to provide in some of the dollars to get back into the program again. And it's just been this change, I think, within the last, you know, couple of months. We just went over the 5% mark, I think, the first time since, like, earlier, I forget. But anyway, so just FYI on that, when we talk about this, we're talking the 120, it may be up to that 150 level as we come back with some policy questions as it gets under construction.
1:40:32 Just to open up that window a little better and hopefully not have to discount the prices as much off of the construction costs. We will have to do that. To follow up on that, how is inflation being built into this? The best way to say is that price of 2.42, it is a guaranteed maximum price. It can't go higher. There's no inflation adjustment in there or anything? No. The way we wrote the...
1:41:03 So if you have a contract and proposal, they're guaranteeing that they will bring the project to fruition for that price. In whatever the dollars are? In whatever the market looks like. Okay. So kind of the second question is I think we all know we're entering into a period of probably potentially unimaginable volatility. There are forces at work on all sectors.
1:41:28 Who on the staff side is going to be tracking all this? So if we go to the point about the deed restrictions, my understanding is typically that when you get into foreclosures is when the market, if the market were to take a dive. Right now the Federal Reserve has already said we're going to fight inflation, it's going to be going like this. Who on the staff side is going to be tracking this such that we can make sure we have the reserves? If we have to be buying back deed restricted stuff, we're making sure that we've got enough reserves there to be able to anticipate something like that. Who owns all that?
1:41:59 That's within the housing work. I'll say it's a joint ownership of the problem there, but really it will drop into our housing program, which currently would be with Nolan, overseen by Sandra. Looking at that thing, like right now, we retain a $600,000 reserve for the buyback program. We do have other dollars in there, and we've made the commitment to use funding to make sure that we retain that dollar amount.
1:42:24 If we sell something and it comes in at a lower level than we had to buy back for, then we would re-up the reserve. Because I'm just thinking as we do more of these units, if this works, we need to be monitoring to make sure that we're having the reserves that we're going to need, and those are going to have to be inflation adjusted. Because the problem, as you say, is we have a lot of deed restricted units, and if the economy sort of goes in the toilet and people start getting foreclosed on, it's not going to be just one unit. Exactly.
1:42:53 So we need to be, Nolan, hi, Nolan. We're going to be looking forward to those updates and tracking of all that stuff. And to understand, I think, from the council's perspective, what does our exposure look like? To Bill's point, we have X number of de-restricted units. If things were to tank, and we're okay with bad news, but I think we need to know what the exposure looks like so we can make sure.
1:43:15 That's correct. The zoning is RMF1, so just by zoning, they cannot rent nightly. Also, when you
1:43:47 Utilize the Town Density Bonus. Any project that receives a Town Density Bonus, all the units are restricted from being rented nightly. And then thirdly, you have the deed restriction that also prevents them from being nightly rentals. So there's a whole series of ways if any unit ever was identified as being rented nightly, we can ding them with through the enforcement side. Also, to John's point on tracking, in the past, we just had the deed restrictions.
1:44:15 Where now we record a deed restriction, a notice of default, and a deed of trust securing the deed restriction. The notice of default gives us early notification if basically at the second lender submits that they're going to foreclose, we get notified of that potential. So then we can start looking into how to address that, whether we come in and purchase out the remaining
1:44:45 Value of what they're behind on, take ownership, there's various options. And also with the deed restriction specifies the initial sales price and identifies how those go up in value, whether it's tied to the CPI index or tied to the appraised value. So we generally know at any point in time exactly what the sales price of that unit would be, should it go into foreclosure and report.
1:45:11 Should it come up for sale and we want to purchase it back with a revolving loan fund. So we generally, regardless of what inflation does, it doesn't necessarily affect that value directly there. So we have a sense there as to what the kind of exposure would be to purchase back a unit at risk. Yeah, and I just think, I hope hearing consensus from the council that the tracking of this, of the idiosyncrasies of our market versus inflation versus all the
1:45:41 External and exterior forces that are at work in this that we have an expectation that you guys are going to keep us appraised in this. Bring us the bad news if it's coming so we can make decisions and deal with the reserves and do the things we've got to do. I fully support this. Dan, thank you very much in the comments, the 150 and the 120 AMI. I think that's very important. This missing middle thing, that's going to be a moving target as well. That's going to be going to places we didn't expect. And finally, I think it would be helpful for council when these renderings come forward, just have a map so we know where the property is going to be.
1:46:11 Ted, a thought. Oh, thank you. Or a couple. I see guaranteed maximum price. Is there a guaranteed minimum quality or any sort of size on these things? I mean, it's a nice picture, but it says nothing about what they're supposed to build. Yeah. So we didn't want to come forward with the design and set some expectations that were not in line. Like we said, the process will go through the full entitlement.
1:46:43 But the proposal did align with our bridging documents. So there is a size, there's a garage, there's a number of bedrooms, bathrooms, some minimum quality kind of components. So we have that that was baked into their proposal. But we didn't want to come forward and be like, here's everything and kind of show you and then set an expectation and have some things change when it actually goes through the entitlement process.
1:47:04 Maybe the colors are in the articulation in the buildings and such. So once they do their final design and they're entitled, does that come back to the PEDC? That will go through PEDC. Okay. And we're happy to bring that back to town council just to share, you know, because we're pretty excited about this and I think we want to promote this project. I think I'll just kind of debrief, I mean, scalability is nice, and if there's a set of plans that can be replicated, I think it'd be good to get kind of a debrief of what do we learn, did it work, was it successful, what do we have to tweak going forward, and obviously we don't want to have...
1:47:33 And it'd be nice to have 50 of these things. I don't know if we want 150 of them, but let's do our due diligence and see how it worked out, what we learned and how we can do that. Yeah, to Ted's comment, I hope that they are very livable. Some of our first designs, in my opinion, were not. So hopefully we've learned the lessons there. All right, well, with that, I think, yeah, I'm sorry. Oh, Linda, I'm sorry. Yeah, that's okay, I'm out of question.
1:48:03 Dan, on the last slide or two where you talked about the money and everything, I wanted to make sure that we're being clear about the ultimate result of this bridge program. That the bridge program is we front the money up, we sell them to the buyer, we recoup a lot of that cost and what is our final outlay as opposed to what it is to build them. And I wanted to make sure that we're going to
1:48:31 Call attention to that so that it's not viewed as a really big expenditure without the bridge program being factored in. Yeah, if I can speak to that. We don't know exactly on that. It'll depend on as we get into it. We know what the total cost of the project will be. The sales price will be a factor of the income limits, the down payment program that's in place for the buyers, and obviously the interest rates on...
1:49:01 Mortgage Loans. And I'll say the income is really important because we say up to 150. So something could be said at 130%, 120%. And so we work with buyers on that. We can do, depending if they're a first-time home buyer, for example, we can actually, in the town side, if it's over the limits from grants, we could actually provide a 30-year loan out or a 20-year loan out additional that would get paid back upon the sale of the property.
1:49:30 So there's some ways to work through that, but ideally these will probably end up being subsidized anywhere $125,000 to $175,000 a unit. We just don't know yet based on the market and the final income levels that we see. But those will be dollars. And so, you know, just to keep that in the conversation so that, you know, the understanding is that these are the bridge program helping people of these, you know, higher incomes qualify and be able to also.
1:49:59 How much otherwise they would not be able to do and that the total cost of that is not borne completely by the town, but will be backed by the loans that these buyers take, which then leaves us with a total outlay of, like you said, maybe up to $175,000 to $200,000 per unit, but not the entire cost. So thank you for that. And I think we just need to keep pointing that out however we can. Our goal, that money then stays in with the housing program so it can get reinvested accordingly. Correct. Absolutely.
1:50:31 Okay, thank you. Okay, so I'm thinking we're, I think we're in pretty good shape. Yeah? Is there a motion somewhere? John, I would move that we award the design-build contract to MMI Consultant, LLC, for a guaranteed maximum price of $2,420,000 and further authorize Public Works Director to execute the contract and accept the project upon completion. I'll second the motion. Thank you. Motion and a second. Jamie, please call the roll on this question.
1:51:03 Councilmember Sauser, Yes. Councilmember Sauser, Yes. Councilmember Sauser, Yes. Councilmember Sauser, Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Wentworth, Yes. Mayor Sauser, Yes. Mayor Sauser, Yes.
1:51:11 Thank you. So with that, we're going to move on to our Councilmember reports. We'll then head into a closed session. Linda, do you want to go first with your report?
1:51:21 Um, sure, um, I, um,
1:51:25 Don't have a lot to report. I was out of commission for a couple of these weeks, so I'm glad to be back here. Looking forward to hopefully getting back to the next meeting with real people. It's time. And other than that, I did attend the ESSRP meeting, mostly on Monday. There was a, sorry, that's probably all I have to report for now. Thanks. Good. Thank you very much. Kirk Kennedy?
1:51:51 Just an information item for the council and for the public. The Mammoth Lake Housing wait list has bumped up again. It's at 133. Mammoth Lake Housing is hiring two full-time people to work with the people to get their applications in. And the salary for those individuals is paid by Mono and Alpine counties. It's good. We're working with other agencies.
1:52:21 You know, just trying to deal with the influx of issues, of housing issues. Thank you. Bill. I met with MLT this afternoon. Primary focus was contract with the town. And that's coming to us April 20th, I believe. April 20th, we're having a joint meeting. Okay, good. March 25th, I attended the Governor's Office of Planning and Research ICARP TAC meeting. This is the statewide board that deals with the climate program.
1:53:06 There's lots and lots and lots of money that's tied. They're working on the grant guidelines, and that's yet another big state program money that's coming our way, and hopefully more to come on that. And I've attended a couple of meetings with the new district ranger on the Shady Rest Geothermal Project, gradually getting that thing untangled. I think one piece of interesting news is that the ORMAT project is a lease. It's a mineral lease.
1:53:37 To BLM. So BLM really is driving this whole thing. We may be concerned with the Forest Service, but the BLM staff, Department of Interior, that's where the action's happening. And District Ranger Wong, Fred Wong, has done a pretty good job getting the meetings, getting us through things pretty quickly. We've got a lot of work to do still, but it's moving forward in the one thing. And that's what I've got. So I think we're done, right, with the regular meeting? Yes, we are. If you give us about five minutes and we'll...
1:54:07 Get logged in for a little less than five minutes. Get logged in with Lynda for the closed session. Excellent. So thank you all. Thanks to the public that showed up. All 127 people out there, thank you all so much for coming. And we're looking forward to seeing you at the next meeting. So thank you all very much. And we'll adjourn for the moment and head into closed session. Thank you. Thank you, John, for doing the meeting. Appreciate it. Of course. My pleasure. Thank you, Lynda.