TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2022

Town Council

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

448 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 I don't know if it's a heat pump version. I've just been reading a lot on it. Does it tell you how much

0:29 How are you using just for the heat? Well, you can figure it out. What's interesting, Bill, is when you get into these things, the math brain, not the trigonometry, but geometry, basic, like general contractor math. You're adding into this, you're doing that, there's a lot of math that goes on. So you can tell when you have a bunch of stuff on.

0:57 You said, look, oh, it's about, oh, it's about a 1.5 kilowatt. Then it's draining. Turn everything off, it's a half kilowatt. Okay. Okay, where's my babysitter? Oh, come here.

1:21 Yeah, and I'd have to go back on and redo it so that it says, Inyo and Mama County instead of the first step. Oh, okay. Okay. I also, I told Nancy, maybe, if you have a ride, we'll make our ride, and maybe we'll just have a signal. Okay. No.

1:44 Oh, there she is. She's right there.

2:11 Hi, Linda. I felt better.

2:34 Well, this is going to be hard. I've got my computer right in front of me so I can see everything. If I'm sitting here, I feel good.

2:53 Mr. Avery? John, how are you? John, how are you? John, how are you? I'm all right? I saw that. I saw that. I saw that you look like a foot of snow. You know, as long as we live here, it's the picker.

3:10 It's always winter's revenge, especially on years like this, where it's a mellow winter, so, you know, we never have an experience. I've got this figured out. Do you? So, I have more pictures of me barbecuing for opening weeks here in the snow than without snow, and legally, until last year, the opening is officially the last full weekend of... Not the last Saturday. Not the last Saturday. Dan, the last Saturday is the last full weekend. Great. Is that okay?

3:39 Okay, now I'm not sure anybody can hear me right now, but it's three o'clock, so let's get going, I think. You guys, I can only see a few of you, so if someone wants to say something, either Bill or John or Kirk are going to have to signal me, because those are the only people I can see. That's better, but then I can't tell who they are. Anyway, let's just try it. You guys can help me out here.

4:10 Maybe you can get a little bit closer. Go ahead. Okay, that helps a little bit. I think I can mostly recognize everybody from there. Sorry I'm not there in person, but whatever I have, I don't want to share with anybody, so I'm going to stay put here. I put what looks like a cheerful background on my screen here. So it's 3 o'clock, 3.01, so I'm going to go ahead and begin the town council meeting of...

4:46 April 20th, 2022 at 3 p.m. That being said, Jamie, can we do roll call, please, for Town Council? Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Sauser? Yo. Councilmember Stapp? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Present. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Okay, John Urdi, since you're here, could you help us do the Pledge of Allegiance today, please? I pledge allegiance. Thank you, John.

5:28 Now, we're going to go ahead and add joint. The public comments would be in regards to that. Comment. General comment. For all items. Even after this, in regards to any items that are not. I am the president, air, and for the state agreement in grants and field program across the JMT region. First is to thank you, hard to have to grant money, wide-scale restoration across the JMT territory. We take up the JMT plus its.

5:58 contributing trails from Yosemite Valley to south of Mount Whitney. It's a big job and there's a great deal of wilderness restoration that needs to be done in the backcountry. We started in Inyo National Forest and it was by virtue of letters from this town council and several other regions in the area that I think we were successful at getting a pretty substantial grant from the state of California to start that work.

6:24 It also helped me mobilize and we're another to begin so we can get enough within a day and a half. We have to have these and sponsor it. Here's of that request several directly jammed late. So I thought I would introduce very quickly what we are doing. Any comments you might have. Senators, the two senators that we're looking at as co-sponsors for the light item earmark that may be added to the state budget are Josh Becker.

6:54 The second is Senator Andres Barajas, which I assume you all would know.

7:22 He covers the counties for the Central Sierra Nevada, and we are speaking with him and his staff tomorrow to get them briefed. There are four elements to what we're asking. I had a summary itemization of that sent to all of you, so you should have it, the council members and to Mayor Salcido. The major elements are roughly $30 million, over 15 years rollout.

7:50 of wilderness restoration, focusing on the meadow wetland restoration work. The second piece was high elevation trailhead facilities that need to be transferred to sustainable technologies, where as you know, at very high elevation where the trailheads end, there's no water, there's no possibility of an engineered septic, and the standard to date has been pittletrines, which are really not manageable for sustainable.

8:19 The third piece was in collaboration with the Inyo National Forest and with Devil's Postpile National Monument taking on eight major campsites from Agnews Meadow to Red Meadow where they need substantial infusion of money to wholesale refurbish them and restore the surrounding terrain. There is a fairly long patch of

8:46 There are also several interpretive trails that highlight underserved communities and indigenous cultures in the area that had been abandoned for lack of the ability to maintain them. We're trying to bring dollars in to get those reinstated and restored. And then there are a growing number of social trails in that area.

9:16 That the Inyo National Forest would like to retire the ones that shouldn't be active, reorganize them into a manageable, sustainable trail network. The last piece involves Yosemite National Park and the Yosemite Conservancy. I spoke with them yesterday or the day before. It is to do something similar in collaboration with them for the triangle at Tuolumne Meadows to the Cathedral Trail.

9:45 To Vogelsang High Sierra Cap, and then back down the Lyle Creek Trail. Sort of a triangle of six miles there where the same issues are present. Some significant major campsite work, some significant wilderness restoration around those areas, and sustainable facilities that we want to upgrade outside of the visitor's center. So there are several areas. So we have received pretty good widespread support across the board.

10:15 Any questions? I think roughly what would come...

10:48 Mammoth Lakes Way is somewhere around $14 to $17 million, depending on how you view those trailhead facilities. Most of them are on the eastern side. They're very high elevation. A lot of them affect the recreational economy on the west side. So if you consider those plus the $11 million for campsite trail and interpretive trail, renovation in Red's Meadow plus the restoration of San Joaquin.

11:18 Thank you very much for that short presentation. I know we didn't have this on the regular agenda, so our ability to ask any end-of questions is pretty limited. So if we have a few sort of top-level questions we could ask, otherwise I think we should ask that we re-agendize this for a presentation at a later date.

11:44 Because I don't want to take up too much time within this workshop. So is there anybody with any questions? Yeah, I would just advise, and I talk to the town manager about this, that we've provided a number of letter of support. I've reached out to you. I've never heard back from you, unfortunately. But I think with the scale and the scope of this proposal, I think this is going to be something that the town is going to have to actively consider and engage with. We have a number of local and regional priorities. So I'd anticipate a pretty...

12:13 There are discussion on this, and I think having the opportunity to meet with you and your team, whoever, to really get a sense of what exactly this is about. When you see Senator Borges and his staff, please say hello for us. We don't get a chance to say hi to him very often. So we look forward to having further discussion. Perfect. The one thing to keep in mind is timing the schedule. I kind of reached out to every community, every agency about the same time.

12:40 So it's been under consideration since mid-February. Well, we just got this this morning. Correct. I just got this this morning. So we're very active in the space. We do a lot of work with this. We've got a regional partnership that we're working on a number of different things. We work very closely with Indian National Forest. We have an office of outdoor recreation here now in the town. Yes. So we look forward to having them engaged in a quite thorough conversation. Perfect. Just from the state side, just to let you know, we're a small organization, so our hands are pretty full.

13:09 And the state is going to be making decisions about this, I would say, in the first two weeks of May. I think they kind of meet for their big legislative session to decide what line items appear. Ours is very small, but it is real money, so I think it's getting a good brush. And it will get voted on. I think the budget bill is coming up for a vote on June 7th in a joint session of the state legislature, just so you're aware of timing.

13:38 One quick question. Yes. As someone who has used the river trail in San Joaquin for the last 60 years and health-wise cannot do it any longer, when I hear you talking about working on the campsites along the river, there are several sites along that river that are my favorite sites. Are you talking about restoring them, cleaning up the fire range? Are you talking about elimination? Because every time I hear somebody say they're going to restore something, as the Indian National Forest did with dispersed camping, you know,

14:07 30 of my sites that I've been using traditionally for decades disappeared. It may be some of them do disappear. There are no guarantees. We defer to the Inyo National Forest biologists and botanists and ecologists to make judgment calls on that. We are a funding and organization mechanism. Don't like to play a role there. But what we have seen across the region, from the Inyo to the Sierra National Forest to now Kings Canyon,

14:33 Is that they bring a variety of strategies to bear. Sometimes it's rerouting the trail. Sometimes it's restoring campsites. Sometimes it's emphasizing others, trying to get illegal campsites under each jurisdiction's rules off of handheld apps. It's better enforcement, better advising. I think it's a suite of things that take place. A lot of times in the restoration work, we close things because we think it's better if they're closed.

15:02 And then people come along and make their new campsites and create far more damage than the old sites were creating. So this is what I would like to not see happen. So if we're going to take them out to you on a map, if you're going to start taking some of those away, there sort of needs to be some signage and some replacement, or we end up creating, you know, beware of the unintended consequences. Correct. And again, as I said, it's a holistic approach.

15:31 There are actually far more legal campsites and really beautiful ones that people can't see readily. So getting those populated on devices so people can readily get to them. Dealing with only the ones that are most damaging really to water systems and habitat. You have to be careful about water systems and habitat.

15:49 So I'd like to, if we may, we're already 15 minutes into this and we have a big agenda here tonight. So what would be the next steps on this? Dan, can you maybe give us some guidance on this, what you would like to see to be next steps, what we could agree on would be the next way to approach this? Yeah, we can get additional information on it. For any action, we need to come back to Council for any support or other comments related to it. So we need to come back to Council for that discussion.

16:19 So that would be whatever the next meeting time would allow us to do that and time to get information accordingly. Okay, very good. All right, thank you for being here with us and giving us this preview and we will be in touch, I'm sure. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor. All right, I'm going to move on to, first of all, any other public comments, Jamie? No, there are not. Okay, thank you. Any additions to the agenda? No, Madam Mayor, there is not. Actually, there is another public comment now. Okay. No, there's not.

16:52 Yes, there is. No, there's not. Awesome. John Guatelli, do you want to unmute yourself and give your comments? Yes, thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much. Good afternoon, everybody. Thanks for letting me enter comments in the public record. Yeah, that's right. I'm John Guatelli. I'm a homeowner on Woodman Street, and my comments concern the proposed bus turnaround at Woodman, Old Mammoth. We in the neighborhood were aware the town's obtained an engineering safety report regarding the proposed Woodman site.

17:23 This indicates to us the town's continuing intention to develop the site. Notwithstanding the findings of that report, many of us remain strongly opposed to the site. Our opposition is due to the common sense safety concerns we've said before and the negative impact on the environment of our neighborhood and the lack of ridership at the Woodman site. We emphasized last year we understand the need for public transportation and particularly the need to serve residents of Aspen Village. We support this.

17:50 We also understand that many issues, logistical and practical, surround the alternatives to running the red line to Woodman, and I had a very nice conversation with Bill Sauser last week about that. Thank you, Bill. Finally, we recognize and believe this is indeed the case, that the primary purpose of the Woodman site is not to serve the Woodman neighborhood, but rather to provide a way to turn the red line buses around after serving their current ridership. We said last year we want to be part of the solution.

18:18 So to this end, we have made some inquiries. Based on these, we propose the best way to solve this problem is to use, instead of Woodman, the site east of the fire station on Old Mammoth Road. This site, as you know, was originally proposed by Chadmark to fulfill their obligation to provide a bus turnaround. This site is on Chadmark property. It remains available, and it very importantly fulfills the service need. Plans exist for this site, but they've never been disclosed.

18:47 Nor has, to our knowledge, an engineering safety study been done to fully evaluate it. Using this site can potentially solve the red line turnaround problem without loss of service and without degrading the environment of our neighborhood. It should be a win for everybody. So what are we asking of the town? The following. Please disclose the plans for the Chadmore site east of the fire station. If those plans are not sufficiently detailed to evaluate the site, please obtain ones that are.

19:17 Obtain an engineering safety report based on such appropriate plans, like the one that's been obtained for Woodman. Then, with all this information, complete information, please compare the two sites and then decide what you think best fulfills the actual transportation needs while minimally impacting the environment of old mammals. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you for being here, Mr. Vitale. All right. Jamie, is that it?

19:48 I believe so. Okay, before we step into the workshop here, Jamie, could you take a roll call for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, please? Next on the agenda is additions to the agenda, followed by the workshop. Oh, I thought we already answered that, yes. Any additions to the agenda? No? No, Madam Mayor, there is none. Thank you. Okay, thank you. All right. Okay, Chair Goico? Present. Vice Chair Foster? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here. Secretary Mendel? Is absent.

20:18 Board Member Clark, Board Member Crabb, Board Member Radcliffe, Board Member Souser, Board Member Magner. Okay, thank you. Thank you very much, Jamie. All right, I think we're going to turn this over to both Rob and to John and lead us out on this. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So, please, too, to lead off on this particular item.

20:52 You know, as we've got together on a quarterly basis to provide both opportunity for Mammoth Lakes Tourism to address Town Council as well as Town Council to have a good open dialogue with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on the process that we need to do for our marketing and our efforts in town. So we met back in January and Town Council had really had the desire at that point to give input on

21:20 What marketing focuses for MLT and their strategic plan and how they want to build for next fiscal year's marketing plan to have input into that. So we met on January 26th of this year and Town Council provided four bullet point items of focus and I'm not going to read through them in detail because they are in the packet on the sort of action sheet introducing this item.

21:47 But it's important to understand there were some overarching goals. You know, we were talking about really sustainable destination and natural resources and, you know, enjoyed by the current and future generations. Just making sure that this particular amenity we have, which is the town of Mammoth Lakes, definitely survives the visitation that we hope to have and to invite other folks. We also wanted to focus on education, both visitor and resident.

22:13 To make sure that, you know, we were addressing all needs out there and there's bullet points into that. Re-energizing the destination visitation and local community marketing focus and then a developer for successful measurements alongside that. So the measurements have a couple of different opportunities for folks to weigh in on and really it's designed

22:37 to have voices heard. I think MLT is very good at understanding input from different resources that are out there, and I think giving both guests, business, and residents opportunities to address that is really effective, not only in having informed decisions by Mammoth Lakes Tourism, but also that connection between Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the community. I think that was kind of a major element to this. So in our annual plan of meetings, we have

23:06 After our January meeting, it was really a review of the deliverables that are planned for next fiscal year. So that's the intent of this meeting tonight. And that is that Mammoth Lakes Tourism has put together a set of deliverables. This is associated with the contract that they have with the town and the specifics of what they're delivering for the monies that are provided to them for marketing.

23:30 And so tonight it is a draft review of that. I think it's gone through MLT's board. And so, John, I'll turn it over to you for presentation and discussion. Absolutely. Thank you. As you mentioned, part of our planning calendar with the town has us presenting our goals and strategies and then also the first draft of the liberals. And so we'll hop right into this. So this is the goals and strategies and the strategic framework that we presented to our board.

24:00 Back at our March meeting, followed by the April meeting where we presented the first draft and the deliverables, received feedback from our board, and then created the document that's been sent out to this group for discussion today. As Rob had mentioned, all of the pieces that we're talking about here tie back to those four focus points that were discussed and mutually agreed upon on the 26th of January.

24:21 And so hopefully we can all work with that. Moving forward, my staff and I have talked about when we come to Town Council and do monthly presentations or updates, we will tie back and show what we're doing. So if we're hosting a writer for a certain reason, we'll tie back to education, we'll tie back to destination traffic so that we can show how that always comes back to the four focus points that we've been talking about.

24:46 So I'm going to move through these pieces fairly quickly and then we'll get into the deliverables. And when we do, we'll just talk about the overarching deliverables, not necessarily all the departmental deliverables. So we'll go through kind of where we are right now, the strategic framework, and then the detail on each of the goals and strategies. And feel free to ask questions as we move through here. And if folks are on Zoom, Linda, if you have questions, please feel free to just interrupt me.

25:13 So really where we were in fiscal year of 21-22, we still had a lot of COVID uncertainty when we went through the budgeting process last spring, weren't sure what was going to happen with variants. Obviously, we came into the fiscal year with somewhat reduced restrictions on us, and we really saw that people were still trying to escape the cities and get back to nature, get away from the close contact in the cities. Really working on our messaging, our main message was visitor education.

25:42 Making sure people came here and appreciated and respected the community and the environment. Really worked last year to try and disperse visitors past all the normal hot spots. Everybody wants to go up to Duck Lake. We try to direct them other places via trail challenges, etc. Really, we had a very brief but pretty impactful forest closure in the fall.

26:04 You know, last year, two years ago, it was closed right after Labor Day. This year, it closed right before Labor Day. So we lost a pretty, pretty big weekend for us in that September timeframe. So while it was shorter, I think it had a bigger impact. We did have limited fire and smoke impacts last year, so that was a big thing. You know, I think that, fortunately, we didn't suffer as we did the year before with the Creek Fire. Our friends to the north in Tahoe definitely had challenges with the fire up there as well.

26:31 We had really strong business and government revenues coming out of this fiscal year, and with the mountain opening early in October, I think it's the first time they've opened in October since I've been here in 12 years, that gave us tremendous momentum, which was great when we had the huge snowfall in December, but we all know what's happened since then. We'll probably have more snow in the next two days than we had in January, February, March combined, which is always challenging. And then really the last thing is just the successful launch of air service in Bishop.

27:00 And the relaunch at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Both were, you know, had their own challenges, again, to go back to some of the uncertainties with COVID, but we felt that both were successful relaunches and the Bishop Air Service was very successful with no cancellations down there for weather. So we talk about the strategic framework. We talk about three pieces that really tie into the four focus points that were presented, as Rob had mentioned before. Outreach to our community.

27:31 Focus on Education, and then Driving Quality Visitation. And so each one of these, we'll just go through fairly quickly here. Goal number one, and I think the, one of the things that I learned today was that I didn't tie the goals to the focus points. So I have a little different order of things. So goal number one ties to focus item number three of community, local community focus.

27:56 And I'll adjust that as we move forward. But really reflecting the community values in our intended visitor experience. So again, respecting the community and environment. Really understanding the local and the visitor perspective. Note that I didn't use the word, you know, the resident sentiment is something that I think we all know. I think

28:21 Regardless of the fact that we live and die on visitation, sentiment towards visitation is not always great. I think the perspective is what we need to understand. Why are people coming here? Why do people live here? And it's pretty much the same reason. We all moved here for the same reason that people come to visit us. And so we need to figure out how to work within that.

28:40 We want to work with the town and the other NGOs really minimize the impacts from visitation and how we can mitigate some of those. I think we've had a lot of good discussions so far. And as we move forward, we want to be a big part of that conversation as well. Again, stewardship is a huge thing for us. Continue to cultivate community relationships. You know, the town of Mammoth Lakes has been a great partner working with the Chamber of Commerce to form a restaurant association, working with the lodging association on John's side.

29:09 You know, making sure that we have strong communication throughout town as to what we need and what we can do to help. Supporting special events. We have just come through the funding cycle this year. We've been able to contribute about $230,000 towards community events for this summer. Our goal for next year would be to budget for about $300,000 to assist with community events, special events during the season.

29:37 Continue the commitment to environmental sustainability. So when we use sustainability, I know there's some question as to what we're referring to. In this case, when we're talking about environmental sustainability, it's to use a resource without depleting or permanently damaging it. And so we want to make sure, again, when our visitors come here, that we're not trampling off trail, that we're not parking on wildflowers, that we're not creating our own restrooms in the forest, et cetera.

30:02 Working locally as much as we can here with all of our local vendors and then having our board be a lot more in tune with their constituents on communication. I think right now that is evident with the town council meetings. Once a month you have a staff member from MLT come to present and once a month you're going to have a board member come to present.

30:23 As to what's going on. Again, the idea is that we will tie back to those four focus points when we say that we're doing XYZ with air service or XYZ with media or XYZ with marketing. We'll tie it back to why that ties into the four focus points that we've talked about. Talking to the community members through the council and all the different various channels, the five and five, the community coffees, all of those different pieces that have been very successful over the last two years. And making sure that people understand what we're doing, why we're doing it, and again, how it all ties back.

30:53 And the last thing which I think is really an important one is to assist the town with defining the local infrastructure improvements that we need to do. Going through this one fairly quickly too, focus on education. And really this is a piece that all of our summer efforts for marketing and communication go back to, focusing on mitigating the visitor impacts. How can we encourage our visitors to be stewards for us?

31:23 And how can we get them to go past the normal places that they would think to go and maybe check out a new area so we're not overcrowding certain areas? It's really pretty straightforward, heavily promote the stewardship and try and really push the idea of the benefits of coming on off-peak times, you know, whether it's midweek winter or shoulder season, fall, spring.

31:47 The experience that you can have, the pricing, et cetera, that becomes more attractive and then trying to spread out that traffic. So it's not all just coming in a 45-day period from July 1 to August 15. Goal number three, support residents and businesses by creating opportunities during the slower periods. This is where we talk about the driving quality visitation and really re-energizing the destination market. So the international markets are starting to move again.

32:15 I think it was very interesting. I was in Vons on Saturday, and there was not a lot of English being spoken. I'm not sure exactly where everybody was coming from or whether they were from L.A. and just speaking different languages or whether they were coming from overseas yet. But international will come back, and it will come back strong. Midweek will continue to be a major focus for us. You know, we've got a huge natural resource up on the mountain in the wintertime that sits fairly idle when you talk about Tuesday, Wednesday.

32:46 Thursday's picked up, but Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, it's definitely got opportunities. Restaurants have seats available, and we want to definitely try and spread that out. When we talk shoulder seasons, really it's fall. I think as we've learned, spring is pretty variable. April is an interesting month here where we may have more snow than we had in the winter. So not really an easy time to plan. Fall is a little bit more consistent.

33:13 And at least we know that we've got bare ground for a certain while. Destination is huge. And this is where when we come back with our plans and our budgets for next year, our focus will be working to get people from further distances that are coming to stay with us. They're going to be here on Tuesday and Wednesday. They're going to be here spending a lot more money. And they're going to be helping our businesses survive during those midweek downtimes.

33:36 So destination will be a major focus. Again, when we talk about our plans and budgets, we'll be presenting our draft plan and budget to the board at our May 4th board meeting with the final approval from our board on the 1st of June. And I think we're coming back to you in that second meeting of June for a presentation to give to council, not as a workshop, but just as a presentation. The ease of access messaging.

33:59 Whether it's through Commercial Air Service to BIH or through Mammoth Yosemite Airport, just how easy it is to get here. That was actually when we did our surveying for the winter of the air service. That was the number one piece was convenience of flying. Whether it was the distance to travel or just the convenience of flying. So we want to make sure that that ease of access message is very clear. Looking forward, this next fiscal year, we will be working very, very hard for the fiscal year after that.

34:28 of 2023-24 looking at new carriers, new routes, whether that's American Airlines or Delta Airlines or both, we will continue to look at that and we'll also be looking within Mammoth Yosemite Airport at additional routes for scheduled charter as additional as also additional carriers.

34:47 We've worked with JSX in the past. We've talked with a company called Contour in the past. We've got a number of different options, working closely with Pat and his team down at the airport, looking to see how we can bring those things in. And then year-round service for both. I think everybody knows that we're running June through September service in both airports this summer. The goal is ultimately to get back to year-round service, even if it's four days a week in the off-seasons. The challenge with the off-seasons is that it's pretty expensive.

35:19 So we want to make sure that we're doing it right. And then really promoting the entire Eastern Sierra region. This is really, again, to help drive that national message with the national parks, the Forest Service land and the public lands to make sure that people understand what sort of a playground we have here and the access through BIH and through MMH year-round. And then lastly, encouraging and supporting the events and activities to promote the off-season visitation. So those are really the three main

35:48 Okay, thank you very much, John.

36:18 Speak when no one else is speaking, please. Yeah, real quick comments, John. When we're talking about the impacts of visitation, we need to include in that also, as we have in all of the other points, the local impacts as well. You know, we've had a huge to-do about dispersed camping, but when we look at where the problems are, it is the locals that are living in their cars, and we hope to give them a solution to that soon.

36:48 Along the scenic loop and out the shady road, they're creating the issues. It's not really the tourists coming and dispersed camping, except for a short period during COVID there where we had everybody wanting to get in the forest. But traditionally, it really isn't the visitor. So the impacts of the local are just as important as we need to point that out. The other thing we need to encourage, there's a local sentiment anyway.

37:15 Okay, thank you, Bill. Others? I have a comment here.

37:45 When I was reading through the agenda packet, it says 100% occupancy is no longer the goal. You're shifting to a quality of experience? Correct.

37:57 I think the challenge right now between staffing, and I think John could even speak to it from a lodging standpoint, I think that the properties would have a really hard time flipping 100% of their rooms every night right now, and I think that even last year we started to talk about the fact that you want to talk about a quality visitation. You know, it has shown up in this year's TOT numbers being where they are, where you're seeing higher ADRs, probably lower occupancy, so less people, more money coming in, which allows lodging properties to maybe

38:26 Take care of the three or four housekeepers that they still have until, I mean, 100% occupancy could become another, could come back if we have the resources to be able to maintain and to service it. It's a labor infrastructure that is. I think that's a big piece of it.

38:46 Well, and I think that's, I think that's a big piece of it. And I think the other piece is that, you know, as we have seen at least again during the 45 days of summer, where if we are 100% sold across the board, including the Airbnbs and all the lodging properties, then we start to run into other capacity issues around town and on trails, et cetera. So I think that looking at that kind of 70 to 80% occupancy rate alleviates some of that as well. Partly why I make the comment is I'm a mammoth like housing and obviously

39:18 Housing, the working staff, the workload, a friend of mine and her community, going back and forth on unit prices down there and the rent rates down there, even driving them further out of town. It just kind of comments, these are the things that I'm experiencing weekly. And get those first 81 units built, but it's critical. We're all 450. I mean, we've had it happen with our staff.

40:19 You know, we've got staff that are, that are, for all intents and purposes, being kicked out of their units because they're being sold or that they're being exorbitantly increased. So, you know, it's touched everyone. You know, Ken Brangle from the Chamber, Ken had a tough time when he lost his housing finding another housing. So, I think that it's definitely the root of a lot of things here in town. And that's why I think that when we look at a situation where a property may have 80 rooms and three housekeepers, they can't flip 80 rooms a night. And it's just not feasible. And I know that in

40:48 I won't speak for John, but I know in his case that they've maintained the 24-hour wait period between stays for that reason so that they don't have to flip every single room. I think a lot of our businesses, especially in lodging, have we've basically just scaled our businesses back to our staffing capacity. And so that's where the whole ...

41:08 100%, not focusing on 100% occupancy, but focusing on a really good quality experience for the guests that are here. Yes, it's a little more expensive during the peak times for them to come here, but that also goes to the, you know, what we see out in the woods and everything. We're 100% booked all the time, and this, you know, I hate to say it, but this area is going to get beat up pretty quick. So we really have to be looking at that. Is that really the best thing for our communities to have all these people here at the time, or is it a better experience for everybody and helping, you know, really being mindful of it?

41:40 of the environment. So kind of that blend. It's not so much finding as many people as possible to come up here as finding the right customers to come up here, right? You know, those that are going to be here for a longer stay, you know, and take advantage of the activities, you know, that Mammoth presents. So, you know, it's a change in focus for our organization for sure. So longer stays is a major problem.

42:09 Yeah, and that's where we talk about the destination. So from our air study that we did down at the airport this year, I think we had 750 surveys that we did down there. You know, the average stay, the average length of stay from those surveyed is four and a half nights. The average length of stay in our visitor profile for just general is three nights. So it's about a 50% uptick as far as the amount of people, the length of time that people are staying when they fly in. And it has lower impact on lodging because it's less impact as far as housekeeping.

42:37 And, you know, it's not a quicker flip. It should also improve the customer service and customer experience. You know, and we were able to see that at our business. And I know the Mountain has, you know, reported that their NPS scores are fantastic. You know, and we've seen that at our business that we've done things to limit volume to enhance the experience for our guests.

43:15 So that they come back and we see that. Important though, at least from my perspective, while we don't want 100% occupancy on all the weekends, what the effort is not to reduce the total number of people, but to achieve a 62% or so occupancy on an annualized week-to-week basis. So I don't want to confuse people.

43:37 We also have to be really careful about saying we want to make sure we have the right kind of people coming here. I've seen several of those fights in the last 60 years up here. All of them fell by the wayside pretty soon, pretty quick, because of the ever-changing, not just demographic, but use patterns of the people who come here. I'm not sure there is a right kind of person.

43:58 No, and that's why we say it's quality visitation versus being the right person. It's just the people that are, again, respecting the community and also those folks that are coming in from a longer distance or staying longer, spending more money. Chances are if you're flying in from New York, you're not going to be going to Vons and buying pasta for your condo. Chances are you're going to go check out all the restaurants in town and you're going to buy your souvenirs and you're going to take advantage of the different services. If they're coming on the plane, John, how are they going to lock themselves out of their cars? They'll lock themselves out of the condo, don't worry. Sorry.

44:30 So is there more, are we just talking with each other at this point? So this is basically the goals and strategies. We can get into the deliverables next, but if you have questions on the overarching goals and strategies, those kind of three bullet points. I'll just, I'll save my comments for the end, but I do want to make sure I get a couple minutes at the end. Okay, so John, you're going to move on to the deliverables then? Did you have any, well, did you have any comments on the, okay? Not so far.

44:59 I think I'll hold those to the end. The only confusing part for me is that there's three goals and four focus areas. I was having a hard time coordinating which numbers went with which. So maybe you could give a little like the first focus area was goal two, you said, but then what about two, three, and four? I could really confuse you if you want. So goal number two ties to focus item number one. Goal number one ties to focus item number three.

45:27 And goal number three ties to focus item number two. And focus item number four is really kind of overarching when it comes to research and metrics and data. So that is something that's kind of tied into everything. Okay. All right. That being said, okay, why don't we move on to deliverables so we can hold our questions and get through this first. Okay.

45:58 So when we talk about the deliverables, again, when we go back to the four mutually agreed upon focus points from the January 26th board meeting, setting high level goals and strategies and then really developing the overarching MLT organization goals and then secondary department deliverables. And then next we would create our plans and budgets from this.

46:22 So when we come in here, we talk about, I don't need to do PowerPoint karaoke here, but that the town of Mammoth Lakes continues to thrive as a tourism-based destination from the revenues associated with visitation. Mammoth Lakes Tourism will continue to work to maximize revenues for our businesses and the town while taking the lead role in education, stewardship, and responsible travel, balancing resident quality of life, environmental protection, and economic prosperity will be an ongoing focus.

46:52 Considering staffing challenges throughout the town, and this goes to Councilmember Stapp's point, more people or 100% occupancy is no longer the goal right now. Instead, we'll focus on enhancing the guest experience for our visitors and our locals while maximizing those revenues. And then, you know, because we brought it up at our board meeting last week when we talk about sustainable revenue generation, there are two...

47:14 There are two distinct definitions for sustainable. The first one I gave you, which was to do not deplete or permanently damage our resources. The other is to be able to maintain a certain level or rate. I think that that's when we start talking about sustainability. Being able to maintain a certain level or a rate could be $20 million in TOT. It could be...

47:34 Certain ADRs could be certain occupancies of 62% plus. It could be a lot of different things. So being sustainable has two different purposes here, one being environmental and one being economic. And so when we talk about these, we've broken these down into kind of three overarching organization pieces, increasing brand and community awareness, enhancing community engagement and communications, and then access and mobility awareness and expansion. So my goal here is to talk about

48:03 Roman numeral three, which is seven bullet points that talk about really the overarching Mammoth Lakes tourism goals. And this is what I would come back in September to report back on you. The other deliverables that are listed beyond that are really departmental deliverables. And we are more than happy to chat about any of those individually. But I don't plan on going through and talking about the fact that we're going to raise our newsletter by 5%.

48:31 The subscription. So at this point I can go through the overarching deliverables and we can have conversation on that and make sure that we're hitting the right points. These are what we as a team and our board had felt were the high marks for our MLT deliverables in general. And the first one being to achieve $23 million in TOT revenues for the 22-23 fiscal year with six months at $2 million and at least five months at $1 million. I think this year we've seen

49:00 We've seen our first $4 million a month. We've seen some consistency in some $3 million months. But I think at this point, you know, being able to manage at least the excess of $2 million in certain months. And then achieving $6 million in TBID revenues, we should come in this year, my guess is about $6.4 million. Next year for the budget, I'm planning on presenting about $6 million, estimating that we may see some drop in ADR.

49:25 I think that right now we're still a little bit of a honeymoon with a lot of folks trying to escape to the mountains and willing to pay more. I think we are going to see some of that come back. I don't think it's going to come back all the way to pre-COVID levels, but it may be a 20% reduction. I think right now on the TBID side, I've budgeted for about a 12.5% reduction in the revenue coming in from lodging.

49:49 And then I think it's only, it's less than 5% in the other three categories because I don't think that those are going to take as much of a hit. This is a big one because I think that it really speaks to that idea of leveling out the peaks and valleys, increasing the midweek blended occupancy in January, February, and March. Right now it's about 59.5%, raising that to about 62% by really focusing our investment on destination marketing. And again, the destination marketing ties right back into the air service opportunities.

50:19 Employment goals for fiscal year 22-23 of 4,500 at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. This is the same number that we had for a goal this year. We achieved about 2,800 so far, and we'll probably get over 3,000 to 3,500 during the summer to get that number up there, but I think 4,500 for the fiscal year next year at MMH is realistic. And then 15,000 at VIH this year was just shy. This year was about 10,000. Oh, no, I'm sorry, it was about...

50:48 I think it was $13,000 down at VIH. Renewing the TBID, you know, we're working on that to renew by September of 2022. It expires in September of 2023, so we are working to have that renewed for a 10-year term, and we are looking to have that renewed a year in advance. It won't go into place a year in advance, but getting that locked in for the 10 years, I think that also helps us when we go back to the town to work on our contract, which expires a year from this June.

51:17 So the goal would be to work with the town on a 10-year contract as well to tie into that T-bid. Letter F here is really important. Coordinating with the town, housing, recreation, the ski area, the Forest Service, and other entities to develop a comprehensive, sustainable destination management plan for our future success.

51:37 You know, we have talked about this in the past. I think when I presented this maybe four years ago, it was not a priority. I think as we look at the challenges that we have with visitation coming in, some of the traffic flow issues that we have, I think the Sustainable Destination Management Plan is something that we really want to look at. And I think it gets everyone involved from our residents to our visitors to our businesses to all of the major entities. I think right now the move is to try and get at least the major entities together to make sure that everybody can play.

52:06 So that would be the goal initially. Jackson Hole is working on a sustainable destination management plan right now that is very comprehensive. I like the format that they've chosen. The gentleman who's running the program used to run the Jackson Hole Chamber of Commerce. I sat on his board for a number of years. My team and I had a chat with him maybe three or four weeks ago about, you know, how we go about really getting everyone involved and learning from the pitfalls that they may have.

52:36 Suffered in Jackson Hole with their process. The process is about a 12-month-plus process to really help try and define what needs to be done. You know, look at this as a long-term plan as to what happens in 2025, what happens in 2028, what are the plans, and then really hold ourselves to them. If that's adding roundabouts on the roadways, if that's adding restrooms or trash pickup or parking lots, what's the time frame, where the dollars come from, who's heading it up?

53:02 Aspen has also just finished a destination or is in the process of finishing a destination management plan that I think will also be interesting to look at. So looking for town council and town to work on that and support. This would not be an MLT program. It's just something that we feel is very important to bring forward. This needs to be owned by the community. It needs to be owned by the residents. It needs to be owned by the Forest Service. It needs to be owned by the town. It needs to be owned by all of the players involved. And then lastly,

53:31 Net promoter scores are not really done on a destination basis. They're usually done on a business basis. You know, the ski area has a net promoter score. How likely are you to recommend Mammoth Mountain to your friends? And it's very easy to determine a net promoter score. You take the people that give you 9 and 10s and you subtract the people that give you 1 through 6s and that gives you where you are on the net promoter score side. We will be looking to set that baseline.

53:57 For Net Promoter, meaning how likely are you to recommend Mammoth Lakes as a destination? And I do think that there's actually an opportunity there for us to also work with the residents on a similar question of how likely are you to recommend Mammoth Lakes as a place to live? And we know it's probably going to be a very small number based on some of the challenges, but we need to have the local perspective of why you live here. Yes, it's expensive. Yes, it's hard to find housing, but look at your backyard.

54:27 And so I think that a net promoter score for residents could be another thing that we look at in conjunction with the town. So those are the seven overarching organizational deliverables. And if anybody has any questions about the departmental specific deliverables, please let us know. A lot of those research pieces are in the departmental specific places. But I also think the SDMP, the Sustainable Destination Management Plan, speaks to a lot of that gaining.

54:57 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

55:27 So I'd like to, if I could, Madam Mayor, just thank you. So it goes to your, which we've talked about, I think that we as a community with our ability and plan, whatever you want to say, and we talked very specifically, the council took action, which I'm very hard, you know, communication data met to that conversation of the responsibility that the town has.

55:54 To be able to implement a lot of the critical programs and infrastructure development that is going to be on us. This is a really seismic change in the culture of this town and this community. And I don't think any of this should be taken that lightly. And I think as we look, I look forward to the next meeting as we get together with this kind of a group, you're not, it's not just you guys talking to the council, it's you guys and the leads from the towns.

56:20 Office of Outdoor Recreation, the types of infrastructure investments we're going to be making based on what we all agree is going to be a vision of sustainability for this place. And frankly, this work starts this summer. It starts with toilets. It starts with trash pickup. It starts with the host program, whoever's managing that, the engagement with the visitors. It starts right now. A couple other thoughts, sort of perhaps cautionary thoughts.

56:50 A lot of the words, the language that you're using in these presentations are the right words and words that we aspire to. But I think it's important not to set expectations with the community that somehow MLT is going to be running the stewardship program or MLT is responsible for the sustainability. We need to start spreading that responsibility around and really understand where all those different things lie.

57:19 And so I'm really looking forward to this. It's a lift for us on the town side. We've never, and it's not to say that this was MOT's responsibility before and now it's going over to the town. I just don't think we've ever staffed down and said who owns what. I think we're in a position now, certainly the COVID here has taught us everything, anything. We're all building things while we're flying them and doing all these things at the same time. So I don't think we need to get into a, it'll be good to have a plan at some point, but your point about getting the buy-in.

57:48 Of the agencies that are responsible for this, Forest Service, Mountain, Town, you guys, everybody, we got to start with that, we got to make sure that there's plenty of toilets, things are clean, that the level of experience we can provide this summer, next winter, we get going with that. So just caution about the semantics of who owns what, the presentations is important. I think also the, we're all members of CAS now, the California Association, sorry, the Colorado Association of Ski Towns.

58:18 I know the county is and the town is. And this is emblematic of that paradigm shift. We're not looking at peer resorts. How do we get to be like Vail? We're part of this group. What do we learn from Vail? What do we learn from all these other destinations that are dealing with the same economic, the same social, the same environmental challenges? It's a peer learning group. I think we really need to figure out how to bring that into what we're doing. We're not alone here. We're not doing this by ourselves.

58:46 And that's going to be a critical thing, just so we're all educated and informed on that stuff. I think you and I have talked a little bit about air service, TBID, those are future discussions. I think we've all seen, I hope we've all seen what's happened in places like Whitefish, Montana, where when you have a reliable air service thing, how things just are going to explode. And we have to start thinking about that and thinking about the air service from a regional perspective.

59:14 We've got two airports, two different missions perhaps, two different things we're doing. We've got to start really thinking and working those kinds of things regionally. And that's what I got. Thank you. And thank you for the comments on the sustainability and the stewardship side. It's just like special events. We're only as we can get.

59:38 When it was up in July, they said, and then we promoted. And so I think that you're right. This is what you should be doing when you're camping, and this is what you should be doing. We have a better resource to get us the information. The messaging with things so we are together. Which is hugely important there. I get a little and then we're going to set up a importantly is we have to be better as working as a team. So if there's something that needs to be done, staff can talk with staff and figure out, okay, today.

1:00:09 You are better tomorrow. Maybe I'm the one that should be doing the same task. So I don't want to get down to that level of granularity in our roles and responsibilities because we need to be, as some might say, a lean, mean fighting machine. So we have to be working together to get the information and then to get the product out there. I think, Bill, to that point is that I think from the council's perspective, we would like to see the net results of that, of the team.

1:00:38 The team working together, Townsend, we got these things happening over here, these things are happening, this is how it's all working together. Bring us the net of all that, because that's where we get into policy making decisions. Yeah, and I think that even in the last...

1:00:53 Six months to a year. I'd say that that communication has been fantastic. I mean, Rob and I meet regularly. Hayes has been phenomenal as far as working with Dakota on different projects. And so I think we're getting a lot more of that synergy, and I do think that you will see a lot more coming to you packaged with a bow on it than you trying to sit up on the dais and create something yourself. Well, bring us the message too. That's probably what we need to see. Bill, do you have anything else you wanted to add right now? No, I'm good. Thank you. Okay, Kirk, anything else?

1:01:30 Our relationship with them? Yeah. Yeah, it's very symbiotic. I mean, we worked with them, you know, we work with them to make sure that we're not duplicating efforts, that we're not wasting money in certain areas. You know, in the past, we've really been the focus on destination, so going into the northeast and marketing the air service. We've been working with them. Our goal is to potentially even double the amount that we have going into the east coast.

1:02:02 And we really want them to come in behind us with their brand message as well. And so we are working with them to make that happen because the amount of icon pass holders, et cetera. And then, you know, in the summertime, they're just, you know, they're another partner with mountain biking and scenic gondolas, et cetera. But they are, we have been working very closely with them. Brian Wright, our new marketing director, has made sure that that relationship is as strong as possible.

1:02:28 We want to make sure we're leveraging as much as we can and that we're getting the biggest bang for the buck. Just like we would market horseback riding or anything else in the summertime, it's another amenity that we put out there. It's a big amenity at 85 miles of trails, but it's a big piece, and mountain biking is obviously a huge piece, but it falls right in with fishing as far as the value.

1:03:00 It's one thing we have an embarrassment of riches as far as the amount of things that we need to promote that are desirable to a lot of people. Nice problem to have. Okay, I had a couple of questions here, a couple of comments. So if those overarching organizational deliverables are the, you know, six main focuses of what you're going to measure, and we get back to the end of 2023,

1:03:31 And, you know, come tell us about what you have done. So do you see that MLT reporting primarily off on those or going into some of the departmental goals as you call them and talking about, for example, let's see. So expand board members' engagements, including their roles and expectations within the community. How will you tell us or how will you tell the community how that happened?

1:04:01 Well, I think as far as the September reporting, my goal would be to report back on the seven items, the overarching organizational deliverables. If there are questions specifically on any of the departmental deliverables, you know, I'm more than happy to answer those and it's not something that I would need to do any sort of research to. I can tell you exactly how we had the board members outreaching, whether it's from the TBID or town council or open houses or weekly meetings, etc.

1:04:27 Again, I didn't think we needed to go through all the departmental pieces or the backup deliverables, but I can answer any of those at any time, and we can also give you updates throughout the course of the year with our presentations to council on a monthly basis. And I, for one, do appreciate MLT staffing at the council meetings for an update. I think that, you know, that kind of keeps us from feeling like we don't.

1:04:53 Talk to you more than quarterly or something. And I appreciate the time and the effort that it's taken to do that. I, for one, appreciate that. Thank you. And I think the other piece, Ms. Mayor, is that my door is always open. My phone is always on. So if there are specific things that you are looking for information on, whether it's at a

1:05:14 Okay, thank you.

1:05:44 Long and hard about, you know, people coming here, spending their money, how much TBD, how much TOT we have. And I think letting our community understand that they are an important piece of this. You know, how does it impact their lives? How does it impact your life? John Morris, you said, for example, you know, you can't expect your housekeepers to do these same-day flips, you know, over and over and over again because you're just running out of capacity for that.

1:06:10 So, however we weave that in, I think, you know, one question is how likely are you to recommend Mammoth as a vacation destination, but, you know, how likely are you to recommend Mammoth as a place to work and live and raise your family? I think that's important, too, and I think we don't want to lose sight of that. Granted, you know, housing is on the horizon, and that's going to help some, but the price of things like rentals right now, especially some of the upper end, you know, a house on.

1:06:39 So-and-so for, you know, $5,500 a month. You know, that's not going to be someone, you know, working in our restaurants and our tourism industry for sure. So, you know, keeping an eye on the people who live here, work to raise their families here, how they're feeling, and if you can step out into that, I think that would be super important. Yeah, and I think that resident perspective is something that is definitely, I think that should be a joint.

1:07:08 Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Town of Mammoth Lakes discussion with our community. You know, again, we are mainly visitor-based, but we also understand that the visitor base has impacts on our residents. And so I think that that should be something that we do jointly with you. And as I mentioned before, when we talked about the net promoter score for the community from a visitor standpoint, I do think that the good news of doing a net promoter score for our residents is that it's probably going to be in single digits with only one way to go.

1:07:33 And I do think, to your point, once we start adding housing back in, once we start adding some of these other amenities and maybe some more convenient bus service or other pieces to the puzzle that make their lives better, that starts to climb and starts to climb. So I think that that's setting that baseline. We anticipate that it's probably a low number.

1:07:52 But again, the opportunity is to grow on that number each year, and so we can start to look back at that and say, yeah, we started out as 12% of the people saying that they were going to promote this place as a place to live, and we're at 35, whatever the number ends up being. Thank you. I mean, I think we do a lot of things from the town, for example, our parks and recreation. That's a stellar example, I think, of how we try to improve the life of people who live here, that those things are available.

1:08:22 Promoting those and making sure, you know, children and families have a chance to do that. That's just one small example. But another thing I wanted to go to was the midweek blended average occupancy. So when you work in conjunction with, you know, Chamber and Lodging Association, everybody, you know, is talking about this. When we promote people coming here midweek, what are some of the tools we use to say it's a really good example or it's a really good

1:08:55 Way to enjoy here coming here in the midweek, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. And what are the incentives to do that other than there's less people here? Can we be more, you know, help businesses understand how they could promote their businesses for more midweek visits?

1:09:16 Yeah, and now we're getting into the tactical stuff, but I mean, if you look at the deals and offers that we've been putting out this year, we've been looking at the flight discounts, we've been looking at all those different pieces, obviously the experience for a visitor coming on a Tuesday, if you've ever skied on a Saturday and then gone skiing on a Tuesday, it's night and day. And really that visitor experience is what we're trying to promote as far as, you know, take advantage of the...

1:09:41 The lighter traffic days of the week, you're going to pay less on lodging, you're going to pay less on, you're not going to have to wait for an hour in a restaurant, etc. So, you know, we do work with the community, we do work with the chamber to make sure that we have those offers out there trying to incentivize people coming in Sunday through Thursday, Sunday night through Thursday night as far as occupancy, and we'll continue to do such. And that will all be part of our plan. Yes, it reminds me a little bit that we still have so much, I mean, that there's...

1:10:06 Still little and, you know, smaller numbers in midweek than on, and I guess part of that is school driven. The schools still go Monday through Friday, even if people can work at any time, people can work anywhere. I think maybe schools and families is driving that, you know, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Yeah, absolutely. And I mean, we are far from alone in this. I mean, this is the conundrum for the ski industry across the world. You know, there are very few places that will tell you that they're busier midweek than they are on the same, or even doing the same amount of business on a...

1:10:33 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:11:03 to come midweek. That was a big effort that the U.S. Travel started a few years ago. You know, if you're going to take a day off, may as well take a Tuesday off and come skiing and riding and makes a big difference. So I think we've had the comments from town council. What about comments from the MLT board? Anything you'd like to say to council around these documents? I'll start. I'm relatively new to the board.

1:11:38 But I do like the fact that the organization is committing to those overarching deliverables, those six that we no longer get in the discussion about or the comments about we don't know what they're doing or how do we measure what's going on and those kinds of things. The tactics underneath them, I think, support. If we fail at delivering any one of those things, then we ought to go back and look and say,

1:12:09 Why? What happened? How do we change it? And how do we go after it again? So I think from a process standpoint, I would say I was really impressed with how the board approached this with John in terms of laying these out to be really succinct. It's always tough to get down to commit to a strategic few, but I think for my two cents.

1:12:38 From the private sector, this is a business plan that I would accept running a large organization because I can measure this and I think the town can measure it too. So real quick, you said six items? It's seven. Seven, sorry. A through G is six, right? Thank you. Well, of the seven, six are metric, you know, and one of them is, you know, to coordinate

1:13:05 With Town of Mammoth, housing, recreation, there's not really a metric there, but we felt that was so important that we had to put that, you know, as an overarching deliverable. Well, and I would just, from my perspective as one Councilmember, that is by far the most important one. Sure. And that's something that we can measure all these things along the way, but the net of all this is what's in that thing. Sure. And I think, John, the point that you brought up about getting the authorities. Yes.

1:13:35 Your point about Mammoth Resorts, Forest Service, Park Service, the authorities that are responsible for this, they've all got to own that. And we've got to get that group together and start figuring out how we're going to do this. And I'm happy to herd the cats. I just need some help. You know, I think the mountain is ready to come to the table. The town is ready to come to the table. The council is ready to come to the table. I'm sure housing is ready to come to the table. I'm sure recreation is ready. The Forest Service, some of the federals. Nobody's going to help you with the forest.

1:14:02 Some of the town rules. Well, and I'm hoping that the change on the guard... Actually, I was being late. The town, that is our role. Yeah. And that has been articulated by the Forest Service. As you hopefully all know, the town produces a list of specific priorities that goes to the Forest Supervisor that hopefully gets into their annual work plan. We'll see how that's going to work out. But that's on the town to bring the Park Service and the Forest Service to the table. So that's something we...

1:14:31 You know, there is one group that's never mentioned in here that has been an important group and whose members have dwindled because, I believe, of the way they have handled it, and that is Fish and Game. They aren't Fish and Game anymore. Fish and Wildlife. Fish and Wildlife. Because their stocking program has always had a direct result on our number of visitors, and we've seen the number of fishing licenses sold decrease by 60 percent because the fish product is not there anymore. So that's another...

1:15:01 large government group that somehow we have to bring to the table. Absolutely. Well, and I think to Councilmember Wormworth, I think the opportunity, I've had conversations with Leslie Yen just in general, and I think that the changing of the guard with her coming on board, Fred Wong coming on board, I think we have the opportunity to really change that paradigm.

1:15:25 Whether it's a relationship that I can bring, the town can bring, now with Lawson coming on in the recreation role that he can bring, you're absolutely right. We have to get everybody to the table to say, hey, if we are moving in this direction, are you going to help us move in this direction? Yeah, and I would think that that kind of falls on the town. Yeah. I think Dan, that's probably something you've had those initial conversations. Well, and I think right now I'm...

1:15:50 I'm acting as instigator to make this happen. Sure. Because you and I have talked about it. We've talked about it four years ago. If we're, I don't want to be talking about this five years from now. No, no, no. We're complaining about the things that have happened. I want to look at what we've been able to solve. Yeah, absolutely. Five years from now. I think there's been a good number of things that we've done. Sorry. Pardon me. I think there's been a number of things you've been improved on in the last couple of years particularly, especially around summer activities and summer actions and proactivity.

1:16:18 Concerning some of the issues we were having, and I think it's a good start. I think we're on the right path, and you're right, John, you can't be the single convener, but you can certainly be one of the other very important partners at the table and bringing other people to the table also. Well, it goes back to the sustainability side. I mean, whether it's environmental sustainable or economic sustainable, neither one is going to happen if we can't figure out some of these problems. Yeah. Right, exactly. All right, is there any other comment from either the council or

1:16:47 The Board of MLT, and then we'll ask if there's any public comments. Jeremy was sharing his ecstasy. I just wanted to communicate that, sorry, Madam Mayor, to interrupt you, but I just wanted to communicate that, you know, we're excited that this is a priority for Council.

1:17:05 Because this is a priority for our organization as well. And talking to some of, I can tell you, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, it's a priority for them as well because we've had talks with them and they want to see improvement in that area. So I agree with you. I think even though that isn't necessarily a metric, it is probably the most important thing on there for us. Absolutely.

1:17:34 We have a lot of partners. First of all, we have to learn how to spell them, and we have to learn what they mean, and we have to get them to the table. Okay, Jamie, is there any public comment on this issue? No, there is not. Okay, so next steps, Rob, and where would we go after this then? Actually, I do have a couple comments myself I'd like to make based on the feedback I'm hearing.

1:18:00 You know, part of this is an iterative process. You know, last year we had, you know, some connectivity issues, I think, between MLT and the council. We were trying to find a better way to engage in discussions like this today. And I think so, you know, part of that process was hearing that and making adjustments, allowing for council to provide that input in January.

1:18:23 Sort of inform direction on what MLT was doing. So I think a lot of success here. John Wentworth and I have had some good conversations around this roles and responsibilities process. And so we understand, you know, what that means and sort of the larger picture of where that's going. What I'd like to address a couple of things I heard when you talk about coming back and discussing the success of this, I think.

1:18:47 We need to talk about how each of the focus points were addressed and whether they were addressed successfully. Hopefully, as we all sort of observe within town, we see that success. But I think that's also an iterative process where council, those focus points will morph into maybe slightly different elements next year.

1:19:12 And so I think it's important that we really honor those items that were presented and come back to them with here's what we were able to achieve and here's what we observed with that. So that's informing council on sort of how to adjust those and move forward. The second item is, you know, back to this, the surveys on the community. I talk about, you know, we're trying to solve problems. I know, John, you and I are working together. It's really how do we fix things we see as an issue. And I think...

1:19:41 For the community itself and some of the challenges I've heard, you know, about what is MLT doing and there may be overfunded, all those types of things that are just in the air, getting that voice heard, getting people hearing it, not to, you know, the town, but hearing it to MLT, I think gives, the desire there was to give them a voice and maybe sort of curb some of that.

1:20:07 Folks have the fact that they're addressing things directly with MLT. They may be able to drive direction of some of the efforts that they have going on that it will feel a little bit more inclusive. And that's kind of the process that I was hoping to achieve with that particular item. So just wanted to make that point. It's really important. And I think I like the whole net promoter score with regard to where we are as a community. I think what

1:20:33 John Wentworth's direction on roles and responsibilities is going to build a larger community focus, and so I'm really excited about all that process, but just a couple points I wanted to make, so thank you for that. Thank you. Madam Mayor, if I made one comment, just back to that, Rob, and something that John Wentworth said, that's why I think it's really important to get clarity on who is responsible for what and for the public to know. You know, anecdotally, we heard lots of stuff in December. I'm going to Vines and I hear

1:21:03 What are you guys doing at MLT? Why are you bringing all these people? We don't have enough staff. It's all your fault. And yes, that's an anecdote. But the point is, again, who owns what?

1:21:14 Who's responsible for what? And making sure that our community understands that. I try to talk to as many people as I can, you know, in business and let them know what we're doing and, you know, town's responsibility. But overall, as a community, if we understand who is responsible for what and why MLT gets funded the way it does and whatever the amounts are and that sort of thing, that's just really critical so that the community does have a good idea really.

1:21:40 Who is doing what and who is responsible? And that's one of the reasons, obviously, why we have some of these number metrics so that at the end of the day, we can come back and say, here's what we presented, here were our goals, here's how we did. And it's not sort of, it's not fuzzy or squishy as Mr. Mendel would say. Just to add one point to that is I think also the community, we all need to understand the larger context of this. And this goes back to the Colorado Association of Ski Towns and the larger public lands environment they're in.

1:22:09 I know our good friend Mr. Carlton has pointed this out to me many times. The human beings are going to places like this. And this is almost, it borders on an existential prerogative. You've got COVID, you've got hints of World War III, you've got all kinds of things that are stressing people all over the place. This is their refuge. This is their respite. And that's, and telling the story of that larger context, I think is important.

1:22:40 To be able to say, look, we're not the only destination like this in the world that's dealing with these types of challenges, and they're understandable, and we need to be welcoming in that environment, in that context. And that's something that the community, I think we all would benefit from having maybe a larger understanding. And I think to John Morris' point, I think the biggest thing for us from MLT's standpoint is making sure that we understand what our responsibilities are. Sure.

1:23:10 say this in jest, I don't care what your responsibilities are. I know what your responsibilities are, but I need to know what our responsibilities are.

1:23:16 If it's not building housing or building toilets, we want, and that's what these four focus points, we're focused on these points. We're focused on education, we're focused on destination, we're focused on outreach, and I think that we are here to be part of the housing solutions, we're here to be part of the bathroom solutions, we're here to be part of the parking solutions, we're here to be part of all of those things.

1:23:35 There is a problem in town that...

1:23:40 Maybe your organization can work on better than ours. So people hit you up in the supermarket and ask, well, what are you doing? Well, how come you're bringing so many people here? People hit me up in the supermarket and ask me the same kinds of questions because somehow we haven't yet found an effective way to communicate with the majority of our locals. I certainly don't know how to do it other than, you know, sitting in front of Vons in a chair at a table.

1:24:08 Asking him to sign a petition because they'll stop and do that. But it is an issue. I think that probably half the people in this town don't understand who pays the bills. I mean, we are a tourist economy. And everybody says, yes, no, I understand that. But we want less tourists. But we want a CRC. We want our roads plowed. And that relationship, while it used to be not only acknowledged but really pushed forward by the citizens of this town,

1:24:38 It is not anymore. There's a breach in that relationship. So how do we create a strategy to actually bring them out, to communicate with them? This is an important meeting. How many people do we have in the audience? I mean, it's easier for me to kid around with only a few people here, but, you know, it's an issue. So perhaps that's one of the things as a group we have to work on. How do we bring them in? How do we bring our Hispanic population up?

1:25:07 So that they understand what we're doing. I'm old, so I mess this stuff up all the time. But it's a huge problem for me. Yeah. And we have a lot of those outreach pieces out there, whether it's the 5 and 5 that goes out every week, whether it's the Tourism Insight that goes out once a month, whether it's the monthly town council, whether it's the open house, whether it's community coffee. We've got a number of things out there. We will be presenting our draft.

1:25:34 We'll be coming back to our budget and draft plan to our board on May 4th. We'll be coming back to the council, whatever the second meeting of June is to present that to you. You know, I think part of it too is that we need to make sure that we have, that we're influencing the influencer, training the trainer. So that when someone comes to a council member and says, why is ML2 doing XYZ? You have the firepower to say, they're not, they're doing X.

1:25:56 And so I think that you I think that making sure that you're armed with as much information as you possibly can be, just like anyone else on our board, our staff or our supporters in town can go back and say, hey, you know, last summer, three quarters of a million dollars were spent on trying to educate people on stewardship and and responsible travel.

1:26:14 So that it's not just a, oh, well, they're just bringing all these people. Well, no, they're not. They're doing this. And that's where the plan comes in. And the plan will be published. It's on the website. It's on the town's website. It lives everywhere. And people can see exactly what we're doing and what we're not. And sure what we're doing is we constantly unite.

1:26:40 Budgeting this way with the available resources that way to benefit the community. And I think what we need to do is start then tying that a lot closer to the messaging that we're providing. And that's where we would reach into like, how do you help us message this a little bit more to get credit for the fact that all of these things were provided for by the visitation that we're talking about. And so that's where we're going to start to get a little bit of traction there, hopefully. And I think that's coming to us very soon.

1:27:09 Yeah, thanks, Rob. That brings up a really good point, is that, you know, one of the issues that our working families and people that work in our accommodations industry and service industry is just child care. You know, there's a lot happening there right now. You know, it seems like we're making some inroads onto that, and it's getting that work out into the community again that, you know, it's taken longer than we wish it did, but...

1:27:33 Something looks like it might be happening here, so that a little bit of hope, it's like you're drowning, but just hold on, I'm building the boat, I'll get to you in a minute, so, you know, it is sort of, that what it is, but this, you know, communicating that is one other thing that we can all work on together, you know, getting that out into our community, making people aware of what it is we're doing, our community update, if people...

1:27:55 If people would read that, that would help. If they would, you know, attend some of the copies or, you know, read the stuff. It's hard when you're working and don't have time to do that. But anyway, that's just a little off topic, but it is another thing that we need to be aware of. What does drive people's opinions and attitudes about trying to live and work here? It's more than just a lot of tour of visitors. It's a lot about, you know, the stuff that we don't have in order for families yet either. So we can keep working.

1:28:21 In the last year, we have worked with the town. We worked with Nolan and Sandra on the housing projects that are going on because you do have a lot going on that the people in town don't know about. I didn't know about and I'm pretty close to it. And it's just I think there's a lack of promotion. I think it goes back to the idea that the parcel is called the parcel. You know, that's not marketing.

1:28:41 And so I think we're here to help with those projects. We're working with MLH on some different efforts to try and fundraise for them. So we are here to be a support partner. Housing Now. Housing Now. With an exclamation mark and a nice little graphic. Very creative. You're on the right path. You're on the right path. Should we have just called it the Shady Tract?

1:29:11 I suggested we do that. Nobody cared. Nobody wanted to do that. We'll call the buildings buildings. All right. I have enough of this. Should we move on? You guys, thank you for being here. If nobody has any other comments, we can kind of end our workshop and move on unless there's any public comment. No? Jimmy? No, there is not. Okay. Are we all good then? Yeah. Next steps? Know what time we're going to get together next?

1:29:41 It's coming up in June. Quarterly visually. Yeah. Thank you, Al, for serving on the board and doing your hard work and coming to meet with us. So thank you, everybody. If we can take a short break, Madame Meredith, break down the room here. Yeah. Yeah, we'll take it at 10. 1.40. All right. I'm sorry. We'll be back at 4.40. Thank you. Thank you.

1:30:20 No, it's all good. We're in good shape. We're in good shape. That went very well. I knew you wanted to be here and planned to be here, so I just wanted to touch base with you. The other members we knew weren't going to be here, and we were just like, I misunderstood what John said. We'll probably do it sometime from 4 to 6. I was like, okay. But I didn't realize it was at 3 o'clock, so I just put it in the face of the product.

1:30:52 No worries. I should have played it. I'll play it for you. I'll play that one for you. It's a good one.

1:31:46 Thank you.

1:35:07 Okay, we're still missing a couple of people here. Are you guys able to hear my voice okay? Is the volume correct?

1:40:09 Okay, are we ready to restart? Ready? Yep, I am ready. Are we ready to go here? So if everyone could find their seat, we'll move on to item number six, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. You guys able to hear me? Barely. Okay. Just because of all the talking in here, not because of you. Okay, thanks, Jimmy. It's hard for me to tell here.

1:41:05 All right, reports from commissions and departments as needed. Who would like to go first? I can't see the podium, so Jamie, you might have to hug. Yeah, we do have Kim from MLR coming up for a comment here. Madam Mayor, thank you. Okay, thank you. Okay, go ahead. Okay, well, thank you for a few minutes of your time this afternoon. Kim Anaclario, Program Director for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Thanks for letting me go first. I do have a little one to go pick up.

1:42:02 Quickly after this. Couple updates from Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Starting with last week, I just want to let you know, where's the Zoom? Okay, thanks. Last week, the Forest Service was invited to the Mammoth Trails Committee meeting, and they gave an update on the OSV designation planning, or subpart C. It was very informative and

1:42:33 resulting in future collaboration between the two groups, which will be nice as that process moves forward. Looking into next week, there is a Mammoth Trails Community Meeting. That will be the third one of this fiscal year. That's going to be next Wednesday, April 27th, 5.30 p.m. at Mammoth Brewing Company.

1:42:55 We'll be discussing the winter successes, the preview of summer projects, which will include the Sharp Trails and Trailheads, that's the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan, the Lake Basin, Lake Basin Connector Trails, and the Shady Rest and Inyo Craters Planning Project. That one...

1:43:17 has been in the works for quite a while. It's been a grant-funded OHV, California State Department of Off-Highway Vehicles grant-funded project. Looking forward to discussing that further. At the meeting, representatives from the Forest Service, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mono County, and Mammoth Lakes Trail System will all be there.

1:43:40 And unfortunately, I won't be here for our next presentation, but ORMAT, you're certainly welcome to join us at that meeting and come discuss the project further. Also next week, on the 26th, Mammoth Lakes Recreation will be part of the Chamber Power Lunch. It's focused on sustainability and stewardship, and we'll be highlighting the Tangle Free Waters Program. Just in time for fishing opener.

1:44:06 On that note, we're continuing to grow the program thanks to a renewed sponsorship with Los Angeles Department of Water Power to install new stations and signage. Also recently added a map of the station locations for recycling your fishing line at TangleFreeWaters.org. Those are my updates. Any questions from Council? Thanks for coming down, Kim. Very much appreciate seeing you here, and we look forward to seeing you on a regular basis.

1:44:49 Evening. Evening. Madam Mayor, Council Members. We're all here. Mayor Pro Tem, I know, never know where to look anymore. I am just going to give you a little brief update on Parks and Rec, Parks Maintenance, and then kind of wrap it up with Commission and COVID update, if I may. Pre-registration, summer camps opened, I think it was before your last meeting, opened on April 4th, and then we, with all remaining inventory,

1:45:18 Opened the remaining on April 11th. So far 550 children have registered for our summer activities, which is great. Majority of remaining inventory consists of swim lessons, 6th to 12th grade camp products, but all TK 1st, 2nd to 5th camp products were sold out, and they were sold out within pretty much 30 minutes of opening. We have 174 children on a wait list.

1:45:48 You know, remember a couple of years ago it was upwards of 200 plus, so we're probably getting there again, and then we are just trying to work through our hiring to make sure we can have enough staff to deliver those programs, so pretty similar thing, but fingers crossed we'll get there. Tony Colisato Scholarship Fund awarded 22 scholarships, totaling just under $2,500 for kids in the community who were unable to afford those programs.

1:46:17 A fun event was on Friday. That was the annual Spring Egg and Candy Hunt. That was April 15 at Shady Rest Park. That was kind of the pre-wind event day. We had separate areas for preschoolers, grades TK to 1 and grades 2 to 5, really elementary age children. We had each grade, each kind of separate area on our field and our forest, which was great. Participation, I think, exceeded expectation. Everyone had a great time.

1:46:45 We had about 200 plus children hunting for about 2,000 pieces of candy. When I say about 2,000 pieces of candy, there was a few missing from a few people of our volunteers that helped, appointing anyone in particular, but anyway, it was really well received. And then they also hunted for our golden eggs. We had nine golden eggs and each of those winners received a large chocolate bunny. And something that was really cool, I think, that was received very well was a pool party this year for 10 people at the Whitmore Pool.

1:47:16 So if you're one of those lucky kids that won, if you're lucky enough to have a birthday party in summer, you could celebrate that at the Whitmore Pool. So I think it was really well received. The community had a great time. So again, just want to thank our Parks and Rec team for putting that on. On the Parks Maintenance Front, as you know, very busy. Pending the incoming storm, Whitmore Recreation Area is fully open. The pool is planned to open May 12th.

1:47:44 Skate Park is open, lots of debris, as you can imagine. Fields at Shady Rest are open, along with the smaller bathrooms. And the crew's going to work on, probably post-storm, opening up the rest of the water and the restrooms out there to get things going. All trails have been blown. I think everybody's seen those and swept up to Majestic Pines and Lake Mary. And then crews will be performing crack repairs on the tennis courts after the storm, so they'll get going in May. Recreation Commission.

1:48:14 It's scheduled to meet May 3rd in Suite Z. We're in person at 1.30. We'll be presenting the ice rink season presentation, What Happened, 2022 Whitmore Pool Operating Plan. We'll do a monthly department report, the CRC update, and then we'll kind of brief the commission on kind of our proposed budget for fiscal year 22-23. Just wrapping things up, COVID.

1:48:43 So we ended last week, according to Brian, with a case rate of 18. As you know, the previous week was 8.1, and the previous week before that was 3. So clearly there's an escalation in cases. Mammoth Hospital still not seeing any hospitalisations, and most of the cases are mild. Testing is now at Canyon Lodge, same day, same hours, Monday, Wednesday, Saturday. And then just to provide an update, I think everyone was seeing this on the news.

1:49:12 Masking requirements for public transit. Transportation's hubs is no longer in effect. CDPH does strongly recommend those individuals in those settings continue to wear masks. And that also includes our local ESTA transit services as well. But masks, however, is still required. I know everyone thinks, you know, I don't need to wear masks anymore. But if you're in homeless shelters, emergency shelters, cooling, heating centres, health care settings...

1:49:39 State, local, correctional facilities, detention centers, long-term care centers, and adult and senior care facilities masks are still required. And just wrapping up quickly, free community cleanup bags for our town cleanup day. Weekend is May 13th and 14th, so those bags are available from the town offices from May 2nd. Any questions for Stu? Linda, I don't know, can you hear us? Can you see us? I don't know what... I can't see you. No, I can see Stu.

1:50:17 Okay, so I have a, I have a, I don't want to jump over Bill or Kirk, but I have a couple of questions. Okay, go ahead. May 13, May 14th. You're welcome. Okay, first item on COVID testing. Yes. I know the town manager has sort of anecdotally advised us that, hey, council members, you should perhaps be tested or test yourselves before you came in.

1:50:46 I would suggest that we formalize that so that the public will understand that if they're going to come into this room, council members, we've tested ourselves. If we're not here, it's because perhaps we're positive. But also understand that the staff has tested themselves and that so they're coming, you know, there's some groundwork for that. I think that would be helpful. I think the...

1:51:13 The second thing I just wanted to point out, the youth sports funding. Yes. I had a little bit of council member regret about that, and I thought that I would have liked to have pushed harder for more money going to those groups. I don't want to mix up the apple cart or make a mess out of anything, but I think we could have done much better with that. And if there's any opportunity to revisit that, I know we're heading into budget season. That's going to be difficult, problematic, but I think we could have done better by that.

1:51:42 That's it. Thank you very much. We'll be for you on the May 4th meeting with those recommendations. Yeah. And then staff will have a comment about those financial considerations as well. Okay. Again, I should have spoken up perhaps. Perhaps there would have been more consensus from Council, but I think we could have done better. Thank you. Good. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you, Stu. Good afternoon.

1:52:18 Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, Amy Callanan, Engineering Manager. I thought I would come here today to give a brief update on some of our capital projects we have planned for this summer. Starting with landscaping projects on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. These projects have been in the works for a couple of years and took a back seat when COVID hit us a couple of years ago, but they are very much alive and well. Old Mammoth Road are...

1:52:47 The plan is to bid out a phase one of the project consisting of rehabilitation of the irrigation along Old Mammoth Road, now that that's between Main Street and Mammoth Creek Park, replacing any spray irrigation that exists with drip irrigation, installing select areas of in-ground plantings primarily at intersection locations, and installing planter boxes.

1:53:16 And this phasing ensures that all the business owners and any residents along Old Mammoth Road benefit from plantings this year as opposed to portioning just sections of Old Mammoth Road. This phase of the project is fully funded. However, phase two, which would replace those dirt strips of land with pavers and concrete, we would anticipate doing that next year and may require some additional funding.

1:53:47 Main Street, the plan is similar to rehabilitate the mainline irrigation along Main Street between Old Mammoth Road and approximately Callahan Way, replacing any existing spray irrigation with drip irrigation and selecting...

1:54:12 Selecting certain intersection and planting areas to plant this year with in-ground plantings and providing a phase two next year to complete further in-ground plantings. You may have heard that the Mammoth Community Water District is considering increasing their water use restrictions from a current phase or level one restriction to a level two restriction. My understanding is that they are intending to...

1:54:41 Address this at their board meeting tomorrow at 530. Phase three water restrictions would limit watering to two days per week at two separate times during those two days. And we've consulted with our landscape architect and the water district. We understand that it's often difficult to establish plants with those types of restrictions, but there are mitigation measures that we can do as far as soil amendments.

1:55:10 Mulching, selecting drought tolerant plants, which is already included in our plans, and perhaps supplementing watering days, our allowed watering days with watering from the recycled water supply, which would have to be trucked to site for watering. So we're committed to at least some level of landscaping projects this summer. We will see what the Water District says at their board meeting tomorrow, but we believe that we can provide some level of landscaping project.

1:55:41 Happy to move on to other projects unless you have any specific questions about landscaping before I do that. My understanding is that they are considering enacting Level 3 water restrictions at their board meeting tomorrow and Level 3 limits watering to two days a week. Thank you. I wanted to be clear on that.

1:56:17 Thank you. I know that they have some additional information on their website. I'm not the authority on watering and water use. One quick question that following up on our joint meeting with MLT. I've heard from MLT about the concern about the appearance of the town, how the town looks. This landscaping thing is obviously going to be part of that. If the drought keeps doing what it's going to be doing, this could be a long-term program.

1:56:45 Talked with them or had any conversation with them about this landscaping program? With MLT? Yeah. Not that I'm aware of. Not since I've been working on the project. I understand. I would suggest that perhaps just reach out to them and say, hey, this is what we're going to be doing. This is what the town's going to look like. You guys got any thoughts on this? Again, it's part of that working together kind of a program to kind of make sure that if they have any thoughts or comments that they've been asked. Absolutely. We can do that.

1:57:15 And then just moving on briefly to touch on our other capital projects. I'm not sure if it's a record, but we have, I think, 12 capital projects on our agenda for the summer. And we are going to be stretched.

1:57:29 Okay, now it's going to snow two feet when tomorrow.

1:57:56 Of course. That's because we scheduled the delivery of the sprawling structure. Okay, good. That's what... Okay. Thank you for that. The parcel...

1:58:07 While it is not technically a capital project that we are managing due to the relationship with the developer, we do have a vested interest in the construction of the public infrastructure and will be maintaining site presence and monitoring that project. They resumed work on site this week with earthwork on the building pads, is my understanding, and they intend to dive into utility trenching and utility work in the near future.

1:58:38 Our road rehabilitation project, which we started last year, last year we got through Commerce Circle and the various multi-use paths that were part of the project. This year we are intending to finish Mountain Boulevard, Red Fur, a portion of Monterey Pine and a portion of Majestic Pine.

1:58:59 The word on the street is that the asphalt plant is not going to start up until mid to late May at the earliest, so we're at the mercy of the asphalt plant as far as when that work gets started again. In addition, we are coordinating with Amerigas, or the contractor is coordinating with Amerigas for some installation of gas lines, gas mains and laterals along Majestic Pine and perhaps Mountain Burble Bight as well.

1:59:29 Our Bluffs Slurry Seal Project was awarded at the last Town Council meeting. That was to Intermountain Slurry Seal. We are working on negotiating a start time. It's going to be a relatively short project. The Ball Fields Rehabilitation Project is on today's agenda for award, and construction involves rehabilitation at the Whitmore Fields, and likely to start after the 4th of July once.

1:59:59 Little League season is finished. We have a Main Street Intersection Safety Improvement Project. That's a grant-funded project from the Highway Safety Improvement Program. We are upgrading the pedestrian flashing beacons across Main Street at both Laurel Mountain Road and the post office. And we are installing a new beacon and a crosswalk with a new pedestrian ramp at Mountain Boulevard that connects to Callahan Way.

2:00:30 We anticipate that one going to bid in a month or two and construction starting after the 4th of July. Two other projects connected to the parcel are the Chaparral Extension and Laurel Mountain Road Sidewalk and Rehabilitation.

2:00:51 At about 90% design for both of those projects, we are intending to put those out to bid towards the end of May and award in July with construction anticipating to start in August. Notwithstanding any difficulties seen with materials acquisition, fingers crossed there.

2:01:14 And then last but not least, we have the town's fuel island, and we are planning to replace the, rather we are planning to install new fuel tanks for diesel and unleaded in order to at some point replace the existing underground fuel tanks at the fuel island. So we have a lot going on. Please let us know if you have any questions, comments, concerns.

2:01:45 Okay. Anybody on council right now who would like to ask a question? Sarah? Amy, I don't want you to do any extra work or anything, but could you send me maybe a synopsis of the old Mammoth Road project, maybe just like anything you wrote up for today? I just, I have a constituent who's really interested in that, and I would love to pass that on to them. Absolutely. I'll send you something your way. Thank you so much. Okay. Any other council members? I have two quick questions.

2:02:17 Of course. Okay. The MUPS, did you guys not finish those last fall? We finished the paving. There is some additional work that needs to be done as far as compacting the shoulders with some additional compacted base, and we need to install the truncated dome pavers at the road intersections and bollards. Okay, and you're coordinating with the trails program? Does Joel know that this is happening and when this work might be happening on the MUPS? Do you know when this is happening on the MUPS?

2:02:49 We had been in, we haven't reached out recently because we don't have a set schedule, but we have in the past, so we will continue. That'll happen in the summer because there'll be a lot of traffic on those things that'll be important. Okay. Second thing is there's a cloud not bringing snow, but bringing confusion and some concern from some of the folks in Old Mammoth as to what's happening with the turnaround out at Woodman.

2:03:14 I don't want to put you on the spot now, but I'm hoping we can get an update, Town Manager, Engineering Department, what is going on out there, because people are starting to get suspicious, and I think it would be very transparency, being forthright would be very helpful. So perhaps at the next meeting we can get an update on that. That is getting scheduled to come to the council for a public discussion. I can't remember if it's the May 4th or 18th agenda. We're more likely to be able to bring it to the May 18th meeting. Okay. We're waiting for some additional

2:03:43 Okay, we'll look forward to that, but I think there's just, we've been starting to get some emails and the buzzing is starting to happen, so I think it'd be helpful to. Yeah, I mean, feel free to reach out directly to Hayes or myself. That'd be great, thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Jamie, is that it as far as department heads? Yes, that is all. Okay, fine, thank you.

2:04:25 All right, let's go on to item number seven then, public presentations. We have a item ORMAT presentation on Casa Diablo 4 project and integration of the work program with planned and potential recreational uses. Dan. Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll kick this off briefly and then turn it over to some of the ORMAT representatives that have joined us this afternoon.

2:04:48 We wanted to have an item on. It's an update looking at the pipeline project, the status of that, nearing completion, or then the planning to get it moving into just regular operations between the wells, the pipeline, and the energy production plant. Also, looking at the work done in the shady rest area, we really believe there's some opportunities to do some coordination on challenges and opportunities, if you will, just in the pipeline and forest service roads or

2:05:18 A lot of trail system that doesn't exist out there at this point, but a lot of the work and planning work under the Schrick Plan, the Shady Rastino Craters Planning Project. We really believe there's some opportunities that we can work together and work with the Forest Service and BLM in order to deal with some enhanced recreation defined areas out there and actually trying to blend that into some of the remediation.

2:05:44 Okay, thanks and welcome.

2:06:14 Thank you. Good afternoon, Madam Mayor, the Board. My name is Eyal Youssef. I'm acting as the project manager for the construction of the Casa Diablo 4 project. I've been executing projects for ORMAT in the U.S. since 2008 in a couple of states, including California. The project is, as you said, at the last stages of construction. We are in the midst of testing.

2:06:44 A couple of the major items this week and we hope to complete construction 100% within a few weeks. Currently we are a little bit behind waiting for SCE to provide us with backfeed power. Basically without SCE we build the big plants that can do nothing.

2:07:07 So, we're a little bit behind, but we're working with them to try to expedite the schedule as much as possible. They have some COVID delays and so on and so forth. Currently, we hope that in early May, we would have backfeed power from SCE, at which point we would start running our production wells, which are located on both sides of the Shady Rest Park. We flow everything slowly.

2:07:36 Make sure everything runs well, our pumps run well, everything runs well, and then we'll get the power plant itself up and running and start generating electricity. The project should make enough power to run 20,000 to 30,000 homes in California on renewable, clean energy that doesn't take any fresh water or doesn't have any emissions.

2:08:06 So all in all, I personally believe, and I think I speak for the whole company, is that we believe we're doing something good. I do realize that having the pipeline go through the Shady Rest Park is an inconvenience. I completely understand that. I personally love hiking, and I enjoy snowshoeing, and every time I come here in the summer, I rent the mountain bikes here.

2:08:34 Don't tell anyone I take the one with the electrical motor. It's okay. It's okay. It's legal out there. And we have been doing everything we can to keep it as low profile as possible and to keep our disturbance as limited as possible. It's not always easy, but we have been doing our best. We hope that the plant would be in...

2:09:04 In commercial operation by mid-June, if everything goes well. At that point it would turn over to Joey, which is the plant manager that runs the entire complex. Between mid-June and end of August we would be doing the reclamations, trying to make the pipeline as invisible as possible.

2:09:31 Cleaning up after ourselves and all that. We are working very closely with Jim Paulus. I don't know if you guys know him, but he's been involved with this project and with the Casa Diablo and the Mammoth Complex for many years. We work with him closely. We meet every week to make sure we minimize impact on wildlife, biological resources, archaeological resources.

2:10:02 As far as an update, I hope it wasn't too technical or too boring. No, thank you. Thank you for your presentation now. There may be some questions. So, counsel, if there are people with questions, I can't see you, so please go ahead. May I? Yeah, go ahead. So, I have some questions and I have some comments. One, it would appear that the pipes you're putting in now versus the ones that were put in years ago for the other plant, or for this plant, I don't know which.

2:10:33 Are much higher off the ground. Is there a reason for that? The main reason is that on this permit, unlike the previous one, the electrical and control cable are not buried. They are elevated. And we could not have them too low because that would be a safety hazard in case of any kind of fire. It would immediately destroy it or could have damage.

2:11:00 So that's why that section of the pipe is a little bit higher. And the other reason is that the old section of the pipe is designed to be joined using the same system, so it's at the same elevation, and the other one is an independent one. Zero emissions, if I understand it correctly, that plant has lost tons of isobutane over the years, so you fixed all of those leak issues.

2:11:34 So we're not putting that into the air anymore? I would let Joey respond on that. Yeah, it just brought a smile to my face. That's all. Well, you know, basically the entire plant is, when we're done with it, we do what we call a vacuum test, which we did. We basically pull a vacuum on the entire system to test it for integrity to make sure there's no leaks on top of that.

2:12:03 As part of our day-to-day activities, we have sensors to help us identify if there is a leak so we can address it. Whether... Thank you. The next is just a comment on the way things have happened over the last year. So I've been involved in recreation in Mammoth and snowmobile use, OHV use, hiking, all sorts of things. I was on the rec commission for a number of years. And the old company, I think it was Pacific before you, was that right?

2:12:34 It sought me out to get my opinion on how it was going to affect recreation and what we could do to mitigate those things, and your company has not been a good player there. I don't expect, I am no one, you know, all that special, but I would expect reaching out to the town and reaching out to the public to let them know what was going to happen, how it's going to be going on in the future, how we can live together out there should be a hugely important thing.

2:13:04 I am incredibly disappointed in how ORMAT has handled all of this. It has almost been, from my perception only, folks, it's been almost a bully approach. We're going to do this, and we're going to ask your forgiveness later. I would love to see us start sitting down at the table together, and I don't know who, whether it's you or whether it's Joey, that we need to do that with, so that we can plan for grooming operations, so we can plan for...

2:13:31 Non-motorized bikes, non-e-bikes, e-bikes, the whole spectrum. You know, the trailhead for the winter use used to be out by 203. It was moved to the Shady Rest Park at the request of ORMAT because they wanted to plow that whole road. There are ways that we could have had it there and worked together as partners, but somehow that didn't occur. So I'm encouraging you, please, in my neighborhood, be good neighbors.

2:14:01 Come to us. Let's work these things out in advance. Let's make a plan for winter and summer that will work for you and for us, whether it is not plowing some of your roads unless it's absolutely necessary, whether it's accessing them via snowcat when you're doing light maintenance and you don't need the heavy equipment, whatever it is, please, let's try to be better neighbors. Sorry, I generally don't go off on a negative tangent, but I got to express it while you're in the room.

2:14:31 Thank you. That's it for me. Done. Okay, Madam Mayor, I guess you need to hear my voice in order to be recognized. Is that correct? I can hear your voice. Okay. Bill, I share all of your sentiments. Thank you. I will add, I'll do the yes and thing, is since we had challenges over the winter, I won't...

2:14:59 We're all aware of what happened this winter, which is a repeat of something that happened five years ago that actually put members of the recreation public in the range of threat of physical harm. We have been meeting with the District Ranger here for the Forest Service every Thursday afternoon, myself, Supervisor Stacey Corliss from Mono County, BLM, Forest Service, to try to figure out what is going on out there.

2:15:27 The sense at this point is that ORMAT, you have done a professional job working under the authority of the BLM to build your pipeline and do what it is that you went through all the effort to do. You built your infrastructure, good. I think that there is a lot of air to be cleared around the litigation that came from the Mammoth Community Water District, which was not the town.

2:15:55 It's a separate agency. It's a whole different group of people. Leadership has moved on. It's a different culture over there. So that's kind of gone away. Monitoring wells are there to keep an eye on things. So good. The challenges that Bill has identified at this point are now a threat to your interests. And they are that way because our dear friends and partners in the federal agencies

2:16:26 You guys have built a pipeline. You've built a plant. The Forest Service, how many district rangers are we now on in the last six or nine months? How many different roles of engagement if BLM is there in the six or nine months? Your colleague, someone's got your back. So for all of our interests, we need you. We need you to engage.

2:16:56 For your own self-interest, you need to engage. And the opportunity that we have, there is a grant that was awarded by the California OHV Fund that is planning in that specific geography. That if we can work, we need to work something out. Because otherwise, you're going to have mountain bikers, quads, razors, hikers, birders, snowmobiles.

2:17:26 Being targeted at your infrastructure. Because there's no way to advise them of where to go and where not to go. It is an unmanaged free-for-all out there. And that is a direct threat to your interests. I just had some things come up this morning that, where's my map, that just the trails program, just some very basic

2:17:56 GIS analysis of where a road is, where your pipe goes, data gaps, things like travel management that you don't know anything about. It's a mess. So I think we're just reaching out on behalf of the town. As you heard earlier, we bring people up here to recreate. And they have an expectation that they're going to go out in places like Shady Rest. There's going to be signs. There'll be official system trails and roads. It's cognizable. It makes sense.

2:18:25 They're not going to get lost. They're going to have a good time. And they're not going to be damaging the very important infrastructure that you guys have created to power 20,000 homes with hopefully no emissions. I'll get off my box, but we need to work together to follow up on this thing to make sense out of chaos out there. And while we're about thinking for a second, I'll just remind the council. Oh, this is our lawyer, by the way.

2:18:52 The council directed me to look at the EIR EIS document, which is an 806-page document. Board of Supervisors directed Stacey Simon, County Council, to do the same thing. We have begun doing that. We're taking really good notes. We're going through 800 pages with fine-tooth comb so that the town and the county have a good understanding of all of ORMAT's obligations and that we can share those obligations with the federal agencies and with ORMAT themselves so that we all are on the same page about what ORMAT is supposed to be doing. Perfect.

2:19:22 However, the comment I was trying to make goes well beyond that. It goes beyond being a good player in the neighborhood. I would love to have the opportunity to meet with you guys and give you some of my thoughts and concerns on how some of this could be handled. But it hasn't happened. So, irregardless of the environmental documents that are out there, we need to step up beyond that as good neighbors.

2:19:50 Bill's inviting to his house for dinner. And he can cook. So rather than pile on and say one more word other than if we're on a soapbox, then make it a little bit bigger because I'm climbing up there too because this has been surprising, disappointing, and not what I would expect out of a company or Matt's experience certainly. So urging everyone to come to the table.

2:20:20 to be the better partner and to exercise those things that are in the agreement that stand now. So that's all I have to say. Sarah, anything from you? Nothing that wouldn't be repetitive. I agree. And Kirk? I also agree with Bill's comments, especially what's happened in the past. Okay, thank you. All right, that being said, I think we are back to ORMAT.

2:20:54 Madam Mayor and the council members, this is Scott Nichols. I'm with Ormat Technologies. Your point is well taken. That is all I can say to that. I recognize your concerns. I empathize with those concerns and recognize that we have, over a period of years or over just this construction period, it doesn't really matter, there should have been much better coordination.

2:21:24 Thank you, John.

2:21:58 And I make that comment.

2:22:27 I don't make those comments lightly. In all honesty, that is a responsibility that we need to step up to the plate, and we will work with you on that. Whether the ball was dropped in the past or not, I can't describe or don't know of all the history there. I do know that CD4 was permitted many years ago. I think it was permitted almost 10 years ago, and it was...

2:22:56 Planned and then not planned and was going to go forward and didn't go forward. And so when I was introduced to the project, it was right before construction. But that being said, we will work with you to resolve those concerns and plan forward. My experience, I will tell you that rode mountain bikes most of my life. I've converted to mules. So I love to be in the woods, ride mules, hike.

2:23:27 Man, I look at the mountains here and I think, God, I want to be at the top of those. Four-legged mules or four-wheeled mules? Four-legged mules. I've been a couple times through Shady Rest Park now, and I am surprised at the myriad of trails that are just, yeah, we need to work with you and figure out what, and the Forest Service, and it's going to be clear that, it is clear that we need to get the Forest Service to the table and do some better.

2:23:57 Thank you. Thank you.

2:24:28 800-page environmental document that was, you know, intensely litigated, not just by the Mammoth Community Water District, but by labor unions. There's a lot of background behind this. The complexity of the project to get us to where we are is reflected in the landscape that's out there. The landscape out there is as complicated, if not more complicated, than...

2:24:54 The documents and the process that took us to get us here. So I think we take your representation sincerely, but it's going to take, as you said, a concerted effort with accountability on both sides to get the kind of solutions that we're going to need. And so I don't speak for anybody, but I think we're looking forward to engaging with you with that level of engagement. One other thing, just to be clear, the town has no jurisdiction over that landscape. We just deliver

2:25:23 And just to be clear, you know, Eyal was

2:25:54 Dedicated to build this project. I think it was, you know, they said, they actually signed Eyal to come down and work on the project without him having prior knowledge of all of the background there. But that being said, I want you to know that there is a handoff at the company here. As Eyal's operations wind down in construction and reclamation and commissioning of the plant and the actual generation of power, you know, when that process is done, the actual...

2:26:22 The operations of the plant is handed off to Joey Catania and his staff. And the Reno office. And the Reno office. And I will be engaged from this point forward. Eyal has staff who is a resident here in the community that will work with you on construction, I'm sure, and has been in the past. But going forward as we go into planning for the future and with Joey, I will work with Joey.

2:26:53 And yourselves to do that planning. So I'm assuming at this point on the construction side that the pipe laying, the tree removal, the well drilling, if we're expecting to get the plant up by June, is going to be over before the end of the summer, before we go into the next winter season. So well before that, I'm hoping we can get together and talking what operationally it looks like, what is actually required so we can see how to manage the winter trails

2:27:23 Prior, well prior to next winter getting here. I don't want to speak on the owl's behalf, and he can correct me where I'm wrong, but everything's completed. There are no additional wells. There's no additional pipeline delay. We are literally into reclamation, commissioning, and power delivery at this point. So we do know what we have to work with, what we have to work with going forward. I look forward to those conversations. Likewise. Thank you, Bill. Thank you, John.

2:27:55 Thank you for being here. It's not easy to step into this, but appreciate you being here, hearing us out, and look forward to the solution and mitigation of these issues as a team. Thank you. Under the umbrella of mitigation, there was landscaping years ago, and the trees that were planted all died out there, and they were never replaced. Just a comment.

2:28:22 And a lot of those trees were planted in the CO2 release zone. Yes. And you met our lawyer, right? I have not met Andrew, but I have. Andy Morris, fine young man. I heard that. Yeah. You heard it from us. Laura said so. It's quite good. It's quite good. Okay. Thank you. Sorry. Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you all. Thank you. Yeah, thank you for letting me vent. You're welcome. Okay.

2:28:54 Let's proceed then to item number eight, which is consent agenda. All right, we have the following items. Item 8.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 6, 2022. Item 8.2, adopt the resolutions calling and giving notice of the holding of the general municipal election on Tuesday, November 8, 2022, for the election of three members of the town council and requesting

2:29:22 Let the Mona County Board of Supervisors consolidate the election. Item 8.3, accept payment approval report number 22-41 in the amount of $482,144.89. Item 8.4, approve professional service agreement for airport management support services at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. 8.5, second reading of an ordinance creating underground utility district.

2:29:50 2022-01, and Item 8.6, Award Contract for the Ball Field Rehabilitation Project to Walker Industries, Inc. Are there any items here that anyone would like to pull off for further consideration? No. No. Okay. That being said, I would entertain a motion. I would make a motion to approve consent as presented. I'll second the motion. All right. We have a first by...

2:30:20 Bill Sauser, second by Kirk Stapp. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. And did you get, I'm sorry, you got Sarah Rae, correct? Yes, she was first. Okay, gotcha. All right, we're good. All right, next item is policy matters.

2:30:48 Item 9.1, AB 481, Military Equipment Use Policy. Town Manager. Yes, thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm going to have Andy Morris walk into this. This is being presented and brought forward due to recent legislation that was passed at the state level, and so we're working through the compliance side, and Andy can walk through the details and the requirements that we have to meet. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Dan. So last year the legislature decided that

2:31:19 That police departments around the state had a lot of equipment that might be thought of as military in nature. So the result was this bill, AB 481, that requires any law enforcement agency in California that has anything on this list to adopt a policy governing its use. Now, most of the things on this list are things that we don't have and never will have and there's no reason to have, like armored vehicles or armed drones.

2:31:47 Weaponized boats. I mean, it's things like that that we just, we don't have. But there are a few things on the list that Mammoth Lakes PD does have. And by the way, Truckee PD has the same things, essentially. Things like bean backgrounds, which are mostly used for wildlife deterrence. I think there are some rubber bullets.

2:32:06 PD is talking about getting a drone or two. Truckee PD has a couple drones, and it's really just to be able to check on traffic or if somebody is reported missing in the woods, you can kind of try to search that way. So none of the things that Mammoth Lakes PD has are scary things. They're just defined as military equipment by this new law. So we have to have a policy. And so Alan, his staff, and I have worked on a policy. There's a model policy that Lexapol put out that we've adapted a little bit.

2:32:36 And that's what it's going to be. So the law says that the policy has to be up on the PD website for 30 days before the council can consider adopting it. We've put it up on the website, but it hasn't been 30 days yet, so we can't have you adopt the policy just yet. We wanted to come and let the council and the public know that this will be coming forward.

2:32:55 At the first and second May council meetings. The policy is already up on the PD website if anyone wants to take a look at it. And it essentially just says, here are the things we have. There's a list of the items that MLPD has. And then some guidance about how those things can be used. And that's essentially it.

2:33:15 This is kind of a bigger issue in other parts of the state, not really a big issue here because we don't have the scary stuff, but we are complying with the law, and I think that Al and his team and I would be happy to answer any questions from the council, and I'm sure that Al and his team would be happy to answer any questions from the community about what we have and how we use it and what this is all about. Thank you, Andy. If I may, Linda? Of course.

2:33:44 Andrew, you say we don't carry anything scary, but you've never been close to one of those pepper balls when they hit, have you? Well, I mean, in comparison to an armed boat or an armored personnel carrier, not as scary. And they are absolutely necessary and they are used to great effectiveness. I just, they scare me. Well, yeah, but it's all relative. Okay, other council member questions for Andy? Yeah, Andy, on the drones, I, there are,

2:34:15 A month ago I saw a program where how do you protect privacy? Where is the line drawn on flying over people's private property, flying up and down the meadow or whatever? Well, there's a couple things. I mean, there's the legal answer, which is that you can generally, you're allowed to look at, you know, whatever you can see. But then there's the practical answer and the practical issue, which is that

2:34:43 You have to rely on your PD to have effective leadership, which of course we have, to not use them for bad things. And the agencies that have drones, I think, have largely been pretty good about, I mean, they're not peeking in windows. I mean, anyone who's doing that should be disciplined or maybe fired. So I think that the PD, if they acquire drones, I think they will have policies about, here's what we use them for, here's what we don't use them for.

2:35:08 But, like I said, in Truckee, where they've had drones for about three years, it's, I think the last one was an elderly woman was reported missing somewhere along the river, and so the PD flew their drone. They could cover quite a bit of river or shoreline pretty quickly to look for somebody. Up there, they've also used them. We've heard that traffic is pretty backed up in areas where Caltrans doesn't have cameras. Let's go send the drone out and see just how bad it looks.

2:35:34 And what the flow looks like. It's things like that, stuff that's pretty innocuous and doesn't really raise privacy concerns. And I haven't talked to Chief Davis about it, but I imagine that here, if the PD acquires drones, they'd be used in those kinds of ways rather than anything that would be concerning. Thank you. Well, and I'm assuming now that they might be used as well in pursuit of bears. One of the things I've been harping on, on Board Chief,

2:36:03 Davis, about is we need to know the behavior of bear before they do something bad so that we can mitigate that, and I'm assuming we could use it for that purpose as well. We could. We've used Daniel Hansen's private drone twice this last year, once to get aerial photographs of the major traffic collision scene, and then the other when we had the high risk of fire danger. We dispersed camping, so we took his drone out.

2:36:28 He looked all around. But I've used them in Ventura in SWAT situations where we can look in safely into windows. It would have been on the Jolly case. It would have saved us numerous hours if we had one to be able to make entry into the house because the door was open and would have saved several hours of being out there on a barricaded incident. But there's several uses. And the idea of trying to look at people's backyards for anything is not anywhere close to the radar.

2:36:56 It's essentially a force multiplier. We no longer have the cert team who was trained for searches. We'll be able to do a whole lot more in a much shorter time. And, you know, that's the whole plan going forward. I think, didn't we engage with a drone policy that Stu brought forward a while? Yeah, it was like five, maybe six years ago. It was a while. It was discussed for in town. Because one of the issues, I think, was that...

2:37:25 They were flying over Shady Rest and kids were distracted, you know, watch a thing playing soccer. Technically, I believe Shady Rest is within five miles of the airport and it can't be flown within five miles of the airport unless it's an emergency, you know, police department or whoever did search and rescue. Well, a great example is SCE has stopped using helicopters to check all the lines in town for fire dangers and they're using drones. Yeah. Yep. So I've heard them in my neighborhood twice already this year. Did you do anything about it?

2:37:55 Sorry. Nothing that I'm going to talk about in public, John. Just an aside. I apologize. So we're not looking for any action from the council tonight, although, of course, if you'd like to give us any direction, you can. But essentially, we're just telling you that this will be coming back to you in May and giving the council and the public a heads up. Okay. Sarah, you had a comment?

2:38:19 Yeah, I appreciate the heads up. I just, I wish I had that the actual policy had been maybe included in the board packet because I'm looking at it now. It's on page 499 out of 696 pages of the MLPD policy manual. And I just, I want to mention that like it's listed military equipment includes, but it's not limited to the following.

2:38:46 Mine resistant ambush protective vehicles, kinetic energy weapons and munitions. So like, I want, I understand that all you're asking is, you know, to have these potential bear deterrence and this drone, but I wish I'd had a chance to look at this policy previously, but I guess we can discuss later. But yeah, the policy sounds a little spooky.

2:39:17 Thank you. Thank you, Councilmember Rae. I can tell you that those categories are the ones that are listed in the law. So they're not anything that MLPD came up with, not anything that MLPD intends to acquire at any point. And the policy itself is really structured around the specific requirements of the law. So it might look scary, but...

2:39:40 Essentially, the policy is just doing the things that the legislature has told us that we have to do, trying to make it as simple as possible. And I don't think that the PD is ever going to acquire any of the scary things on the list, probably ever, but I don't think that they will be looking to expand beyond kind of what they have without talking to council about it. So I would be shocked if Chief Davis or any of his future successors

2:40:08 Is ever trying to sneak in the scary stuff without telling the council what's going on and making sure the council is okay with it. And probably not even when they want to. Thank you, Andy. I would love to know what the procedure for acquiring future items would be. Sounds like it would come to council, but is that expressly spelled out? I haven't had a chance to really look at the policy. The policy doesn't.

2:40:38 specifically require the PD to come back to Council before acquiring new categories. I mean, we could certainly add that to the policy. I mean, as a practical matter, I don't think the PD ever would because it would be not a good way to stay in good with the Council. But if that's something that you'd like to have made clearer in the policy, we can certainly do it. I would really appreciate that. Thank you.

2:41:04 Yes, I would concur with that. Obviously, all of us are not going to be here forever, and we can't assure necessarily who follows in our steps, so that would not be a bad thing to have in policy. Yes, Bill? Yeah, you know, I don't think that that is such a critical issue. Most of the stuff that is in there that is military grade of anything that we would be scared of, the chief does not have enough in his budget to buy, so he would have to be coming to us.

2:41:31 to amend his budget in order to get them, so I think the process already exists for that, so I'm not terribly concerned about it. Thank you. Any other comments? No. Okay. I think we heard two people that think it's kind of a good idea, and not everyone else has been heard from, so that's where we are at the moment. Andy, we can dice that up later, okay? We can add something, and again, as we bring the policy back, you can amend it.

2:42:05 One way or the other. Okay. Sounds like a good idea. Thank you. All right. Moving on to the next policy matter. Thank you guys for being here and commenting on that. 9.2. Ordinance adding section 15.04.180 to the town municipal code related to expedited permitting procedures for electric vehicle charging stations as required by government code section 65850.7. Andy, that has a lot of numbers. That must be you.

2:42:35 Well, Tom's going to handle the substance of this one because it's his baby, but I just wanted to apologize to the council because I think that you've gotten a new version of this today. That was my request. There was some really good stuff that Tom had in the draft ordinance. It was kind of in the recitals, and I thought maybe that should be in the codified part so that it...

2:42:55 So tonight's item 9.2 is an ordinance that's going to be adding language to our local construction code, if you will.

2:43:23 Thank you very much. Thank you.

2:43:50 California, as you may know, for quite a while now, and continues to put a high importance or high value on renewable energy. We do have kind of an ongoing energy crisis, if you will, according to the state. So to underscore the seriousness of the state's efforts to promote these kind of renewable energy technologies, they have amended the California Government Code and actually created a

2:44:14 An actual Assembly Bill, Assembly Bill 1236, that requires local jurisdictions to have an expedited permit process in their local code for electric vehicle charging stations. We are late to the party. This was supposed to be done originally on or before September 30, 2017. Just, you know, really just being very busy. Maybe limited staffing may have been the reasons why we haven't got.

2:44:42 We have been doing this to it until now, but knowing that this was legally required, we have been expediting these permits, whether it be mostly being done in-house when we can take it on, or if we're busy, which we do get later in the season, we would send it out for review, and they would get reviewed fairly quickly.

2:45:01 Also, as identified in the documents, this ordinance has been vetted with both the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association and the Building Advisory Group.

2:45:11 Building Advisory Committee, and they did not have any comments of any substance at all, any actually to add to it, so they approved both of it, they were okay with it, and really that's about the size of it, pretty straightforward. I'll turn this back over to the Town Council for any comments and questions you may have with regard to this item. Thank you very much, Tom. Council? If I may, Linda?

2:45:39 Does this pertain mostly to commercial type or in-home charging stations? This would be residential. Residential. Mainly, yeah. We do see, well, we do see a lot of these going in like condos. So it's a residential, that's like a multifamily type application. But we are seeing these individual charging stations going in parking garages or condo complexes and in single-family dwellings. And that's what it's really geared toward is that.

2:46:06 Is there any conflict with the homeowners associations? I'm supportive of this, and I was just curious, with their CC&Rs and everything, their rules. Well, we haven't detected that yet, but the assembly bill actually does preclude association approval, similar to how there's certain planning things that are exempted or excluded from this as well.

2:46:33 We have required, you know, HOA approval. It's never been an issue. But per this ordinance and per the AEB that's behind it, HOA approval is not required in order to provide the ministerial approval for these permits. Thank you for that clarification. However, the HOA has to approve the money to bill this. Right. They have a hand at it anyway. Yeah, regardless. Right. So they're not totally out. Right. Exactly. Yeah. I know they have them at 1849.

2:47:05 So does this have anything to do with level two chargers? Industrial, commercial charging stuff? You know, not really. I can't answer that readily right off the top, but I do know that this really is geared for the smaller systems. Knowing that, like the larger ones, it's hard to expedite them the bigger they get. So I do believe that these are smaller systems, but I'd have to get back to you on the

2:47:37 I think the concern that the council's had is the diversity of vendors that are providing charging options and the diversity of vehicles that can charge here in town. And that's, you know, but if you have a company like Tesla that's aggressive, they could take advantage of an expedited permitting process and take the available opportunities, this may not have anything to do with that. Right, right.

2:48:08 Yeah, the systems we're seeing in town are all very small. So I'm trying to envision maybe one of the larger, bigger developments we have. We'll probably have several charging stations associated with like Lion White. That's a really big job coming up. Does this policy apply to what we put into the... Yes. Yes, I believe it does. But that's going to be, of course, that component is reviewed along with a lot of other stuff. I understand.

2:48:37 Andy, I mean, is there any way that we can, you know, we have an interest in providing a diversity of charging opportunities. Yeah, so this law is kind of provider agnostic. It's just that anyone who comes in, no matter who they are, which standard or what kind of car, gets expedited permitting. And so that's really all this is trying to do is say

2:49:07 Yeah, we'll expedite stuff, because that's what we're required to do. Obviously, on the town's own facilities, like the CRC, we're free to negotiate with whoever we want and brand whoever we want. Well, and this is just really to bring us in compliance with current state regulations in our code, so. Correct. Yes. No further questions. Okay. So, any more questions for Tom? Seeing none. Tom, thank you very much for explaining this all. Of course. Okay.

2:49:43 All right. Council, I think we have an ordinance here to make a motion on unless there's any public comment on this. No, there is not. So, Madam Mayor, if I may, I would make a motion to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance which enacts expedited permitting procedures for electric vehicle charging stations and adding section 15.04.180 to the municipal code. I'll second the motion.

2:50:15 And we have a motion and a second. Jamie, roll call. Councilmember Rae. I'm sorry, Jamie, any other further discussion or questions? None? Okay, go ahead, Jamie. Councilmember Rae. Yes. Councilmember Sauser. Yes. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Salcido. Yes. All right, motion passes 5-0. Thank you, everyone, for this. All right.

2:50:40 And Tom's not leaving, which means I think he's going to be here for the next one, too. So item 9.3 is ordinance of the town council of the town of Mammoth Lakes adding section 15.04.170 to the town municipal code relating to expedited permitting procedures for small residential rooftop solar systems. Either Andy or Tom. Yeah, I'll take it. I'll take it from here.

2:51:09 This next item is specific to residential rooftop solar systems. Small systems, these are fairly defined, 10 kW or smaller, and very similar to what we just went through in our discussion with electric vehicle charging stations. I would, you know, no formatting changes or anything like the electric vehicle. What you have in your packet is identical to what we have for our final version. But I would, you know, what's unique about this is that this went,

2:51:38 This actually got through with the town council back in 2015. And then I was hired in 2016 and there was a number of updates that I did to the town code then. And unbeknownst to me, in the copy of the town code I had, I didn't even know this was in there. So when I did my updates in 2016, it wasn't included. So we get to do a do-over on it. So that's what we're doing tonight. But same thing, very similar. It's required by the state.

2:52:05 The government code's been amended to require this expedited permitting for residential rooftop solar systems. This one was socially done on or before September of 2015. It is associated with an assembly bill. Assembly Bill 2188 is the driving force that compels the local jurisdiction to have this ordinance included into their local construction code. And like before, Bailey was a huge help.

2:52:34 Thank you. Thank you.

2:53:04 And again, like the electrical vehicle charging stations, this was vetted with both Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association and the building advisory group. They liked it. No comments or edits that they suggested on their end. So with that, I'll turn it back over to town council for anything you may have with this item. One question, Linda, from the cheap seats here. Okay. Snow load? Yes.

2:53:36 Applicable, yes. So, good point. Yeah, they do, code does require, it's pretty straightforward, they do require that these, this componentry of rooftop solar systems be designed with standard snow loads. That's pretty straightforward. Over the years, I've worked with the local solar contractors to get it to a point where they have a product that meets our snow loading. So, that's been ironed out a while back.

2:54:04 There is one company, maybe two out there that with a three rail system can meet our flat roof snow load of about 161 pounds a square foot. So that has been addressed and the submittals I'm getting are addressing that. But I have to give Tom credit because he worked with his counterparts in a bunch of other mountain town jurisdictions to get the California Energy Commission to issue a very rarely granted kind of waiver so that if there are situations where there is no product that will meet the snow load,

2:54:34 That alternative means of being energy efficient can be used, which is a big help because for a while there, there was nothing on the market that can meet snow load here, Truckee, South Lake Tahoe. And so Tom and the building working group did a really good job of getting the energy commission to kind of see reason. Did they get a piece of fresh fruit?

2:54:56 Still waiting for that fruit basket, actually. We'll follow up on that. Thank you. Yeah, yeah. But, yeah, thank you, Andy. We started that pre-COVID, and then, of course, it got delayed like everything else in the world with COVID. But the concern was that, you know, some of these, you're going to get situations, especially in Donner, where they have 400-plus pound snow loads, which are extreme, where these systems simply don't work. And if it, so, working with the Energy Commission, you know, we wanted...

2:55:24 They also gave an out, which I think is another option.

2:55:53 If the engineer of a specific project finds issues with the design for the solar system on their roof relative to snow loading specific to their structure that they design, they can make a case to me, the building official, that the system will not perform structurally given our snow loads. So that's there too. So that is one exception in addition to the shading exception that was already in the code that people could utilize if they want to try to get out of it. Naturally, I get the...

2:56:22 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:56:53 That here in some of the mountain jurisdictions, we really need to have different ways of approaching things. It boiled down to having one receptive year. Does Tom get the fruit basket then? I'll take whatever I can get. But it takes just one receptive year with the Energy Commission. And that's what it took. And by the way, the guy that was a receptive year, his name is Javier Perez. He was the same guy that came here a few years ago and did a...

2:57:21 More than willing to come all the way here to Mammoth to do an energy code presentation for this code cycle. I'm trying to get them here again for the next one. So just it's amazing what one single person and their attitude in the receptive year and decision-making role can make. So luckily we had that at the Energy Commission. So thanks, Andy. Okay. Any questions from the council members on this? No. We're all good. All right. Given that, I would entertain a motion then.

2:57:57 Unless there's any public comment? Am I reading it again? Madam Mayor, I will make a motion to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance which enacts expedited permitting procedures for small residential rooftop solar systems and adding section 15.04.170 to the municipal code. Thank you. I'll second the motion. Was that a second? Yes. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Jamie? Councilmember Wray?

2:58:30 Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you, everybody. Okay. Thank you, Tom. Thank you. All right. Now we have item 9.4, which is approve the 2022 through 2024 Information Technology Strategic Plan. And right on cue, there's Nate. Hi, Nate. Good evening.

2:59:00 Thank you very much, Madam Mayor and Councilmembers. Apologize for not being there in person, but I really appreciate the opportunity for bringing this item before you. And, you know, really the intent here is, I guess, twofold. One is I'd like to just take a few minutes and reflect on the last several years and the 2019 to 2021 strategic plan and some of the key achievements that have come out of that. And then highlight some of the key points, I guess, in the

2:59:29 Next three-year plan and at least sort of focus in on some of the places that we sort of see IT heading for both the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County. So if I share my screen with you all, I'm just going to walk through a few things and just verify that you're able to see my screen. All right, great. Yeah, it's really, really small. Well, let me see if I can help that a little bit.

3:00:01 Is this the same thing that's in the packet? This is just a quick summary of a handful of achievements from 2019, and then we'll focus in on the 2022 to 2024 plan, which is in the packet. Okay, thank you. So this is the IT Performance Management dashboard. There are links to this from the Mono Kenny website under the IT department. And I just want to touch on a few things that are here.

3:00:28 You know, in that three-year strategic plan that covered 19, 20, and 21, we had six major strategic initiatives, customer success, infrastructure and security, communication, and then we had three that were dedicated more to GIS. And across those, about 60 different kind of initiatives that were sort of identified, and we really, through

3:00:57 The thick of COVID and sort of everything else that I think we've been faced with over the last few years achieved pretty much everything that we set out to accomplish, which I'm extremely proud of my team for and very, very grateful for my team for. And, you know, I think that it's worth just taking a minute to sort of highlight the fact that we were as organizations

3:01:23 And I think our ability to transition to remote work and to hybrid, to continue to operate council meetings, to stand up emergency operation center, respond to the pandemic and a variety of other events throughout is indicative of a long commitment to IT as an organization, as organizations. And I really thank and applaud council for the ongoing

3:01:53 And so just, you know, a handful of things that are kind of worth highlighting, I think is, you know, we've largely cut down on printing costs and the number of pages printed.

3:02:20 We're tremendously improved in terms of our security posture with regard to being resistant to phishing attacks and responsive to various other security threats and concerns that have emerged. Through a variety of different initiatives, we've improved our infrastructure as a whole and our network uptime and overall outages for phone systems and other

3:02:50 Network and Internet dependent devices have gone way down. And we did, as you all are very aware, a tremendous amount of work with regard to citizen engagement, public facing portals, other resources and dashboards and tools that were put out for a variety of the natural disasters as well as through COVID were all initiatives which we had speculated in one fashion or another in 2018 when we were writing this plan, but certainly

3:03:18 Manifested in many different ways. And I think it's worth just showing that well over 300 projects have been completed over the last several years, and those range in size from very small to quite large. And a lot of the work that we do has been focused on customer success, and that's a variety of different initiatives, but all of them have generally been aimed at providing staff.

3:03:47 And ultimately the constituents with the knowledge, the capability and the tools to leverage technology effectively in performing their daily jobs or accessing town services as a whole. And that is also to say that we've done a tremendous amount of work with regard to supporting those individuals. This is looking at service requests, tickets that have been opened within IT over the last three years. And we have basically resolved

3:04:17 I think that we are appropriately staffed, but those staff are stressed and stretched thin and certainly they do a lot to support the organizations and the requests that are coming up. And the thing that I think I'm maybe the most proud of is looking at the satisfaction within our customers and how that

3:04:47 has improved consistently over the last five years. And really, I think our dedication to continuing to provide high quality support and services, to listening to feedback and concerns that have been raised by our customers, and then trying to address those things head on, has led to, for the last couple of years, at least a 90% satisfaction within the town and the county as a whole. And that's something that I think the team as a whole is extremely proud of.

3:05:17 So looking forward, I want to just kind of highlight some of the key points of the next three-year plan. And I guess I'll pause for just a second and say that this is the third strategic plan that has ever been adopted in Mono County's history. The first one, which did influence the town, but the town was not directly implicated on, was really focused mostly on stability and infrastructure improvements.

3:05:44 And just making sure that kind of the core functionality was there and was stable. The last, the 19, 20 and 21 strategic plan was written fully with the town and the county, you know, basically working together through those initiatives. And that was really focused on trying to move us forward and really modernize a lot of our infrastructure, focused on mobility, focused on.

3:06:13 And I think that for the first time in our history as organizations, we have a mature IT presence and a set of tools which are really allowing us to transform the organizations and focus on new ways of providing service delivery

3:06:43 Not only to our staff and internal folks that we support, but also the constituents as a whole. So one of the main things that we did with regard to the 2022-2024 strategic plan was respond to some input and feedback that we've been getting where essentially there is an increased demand in the need for systems, applications, data, tools to be able to do

3:07:12 Our jobs to streamline and improve business operations and efficiency as a whole. And in the 2019 to 2021 plan, we sort of had two different plans. One was for more kind of core IT services and the other was more for GIS and applications. And this plan homogenizes those things and does so in sort of four major new initiatives. The first is still customer success.

3:07:39 The second is focusing again on security and infrastructure. The third really is honing in on systems, applications, and data more holistically as a whole. And the fourth is communications. And so just to sort of clip the treetops, if you will, within each of these, I think you can just walk through some of what we're setting out to do. So within the space of customer success, one of the things that we've consistently heard over the last couple of years is that

3:08:09 The breadth of technology that exists within the organization is almost overwhelming in some times and that we don't maybe always do the best job that we could in terms of introducing especially new incoming staff into the organization to that technology. And so what we want to do is really improve the way that new staff coming into our organizations are introduced to technology, that we're providing them the resources and the capacity that they need to leverage that.

3:08:39 And that throughout their time at the organization, we're serving them. We're making sure that they're supported. But we're going beyond just the traditional response that would come from a request into looking at improving business processes and really helping work with departments to leverage the tools that have been put out there and to implement them in ways that can really move the needle. And then also to make sure that we're continuing to train staff because the landscape keeps changing.

3:09:08 And we certainly know that unless we continue to sort of educate folks on the tools and resources available, we're not taking full advantage of it. And we know full well that the application of technology into emergency service preparedness and response is huge. And so we're going to continue to dedicate a fair amount of effort into those areas and in some ways kind of double down on them. Moving to security and infrastructure.

3:09:37 Really, this is sort of just furthering our investments in those spaces. Security is one of these places that is a never-ending challenge and is something that we are continually challenged on. It's going to be a place that requires not only continual investment in terms of spend, but also in terms of time and is likely an area that we're going to need to

3:10:05 Bring in some additional capacity and staff to sort of assist us with into the future. So, you know, really we are trying very hard through not only internal staff level oriented training to continue to keep people sharp and on the lookout for things, but also implement technology within the more IT controlled space.

3:10:31 That is mitigating those attacks, providing us a better opportunity to react to and respond if we are sort of attacked. Part of that is sort of doubling down on our leveraging of the cloud and our utilization of Office 365 and the Microsoft landscape I think is a great example of this and we're continuing to move other services and resources that were traditionally on-premise.

3:11:00 And last but certainly not least is really just to continue to

3:11:26 develop capacity internally within IT as well as within our organizations as a whole to effectively respond to and react to security incidents if they do arise. The new kind of shiny one in this plan, if you will, is the systems applications and data initiative. And really, I think that the best way to sort of describe this is in what has been seen by many through

3:11:55 And really what we're seeing

3:12:22 Is kind of four more modern enterprise platforms being Quick Base, the Office 365 Environment, Laserfiche and GIS sort of joined at the hip to allow us to put tools out there that really do move the needle for our operations and do so very quickly at a very low cost and certainly much more.

3:12:49 And again, use that technology to

3:13:19 Deploy tools that are going to help respond to emergencies and create a better disaster preparedness set of efforts. And then ultimately, you know, data is becoming increasingly valuable to us as organizations. And that can be as fundamental as financial data or, you know, it can be a little less tactical but still important around.

3:13:44 And so we believe that there's a need to continue to leverage subject matter experts within the organization to help build out initiatives in those areas as a whole. Last, but certainly not least, is communications. And there's kind of two major components to this. The first is really around the public safety radio system, which we know the town is committed to

3:14:14 The state's Chris system. And so we are here to support through that effort and know that there are resources to bear there, but to continue to focus on a holistic approach to radio services, the integration with dispatch and all these other communication tools that we're working to put out. The other piece of this is really making sure that

3:14:42 And then, certainly, not least,

3:15:12 is the broadband initiatives as a whole. And we know that this is a big issue to the town, to town residents, to businesses, and it's certainly something that we will continue to put effort into throughout the county, but certainly the town is included within that. So with that, I am happy to answer any questions, but I am appreciative of the opportunity to bring this forward and certainly

3:15:39 Thankful again of the support from Council over the years in terms of investments in IT and trying to establish a very modern environment in which we can all work. Okay, thank you, Nate. Good presentation. I especially appreciate the format in which you present things. Very clear to understand. I think we should adopt this as a town model for how to do reports such as this. Good job.

3:16:09 I'm going to hold the mic for just a second here. Just quickly, I wanted to call out again, I think I mentioned it last year also, if we did this, was the fact that during COVID, while other small counties particularly were struggling either with the state, which was abysmal, or with just a lack of infrastructure and how to track what was going on in COVID, Nate and his team stepped up and built us a beautiful, basically a whole data

3:16:39 Hello, Nate. What's the word? Program for tracking absolutely everything that happened, investigations, cases. It was beyond. Other counties would see it and look at it and go, we want that. Why don't you guys market that? Because it was that good.

3:16:55 So just kudos again, Nate, to your team and the capacity of the people that you have with you and well done. I mean, it was really, really wonderful. And I have one other additional question. That was when a couple weeks ago we started getting notices from government agencies and stuff. There's going to be cyber attacks. You know, we need to be really careful. Were there any additional steps you took then or were we already placed in a position that you felt we were well protected? Well, I...

3:17:26 I'm reluctant to answer the second part of that in a way that is indicative of forecasting anything, but we did not take any additional steps. I think that our position with regard to the technology that's implemented has evolved over the last couple of years. We've purchased a handful of pieces of new hardware that have helped with some of this, but I've

3:17:56 You know, one of the things that I said to the Board of Supervisors when we rolled the strategic plan out a little over a month ago to them was that we are likely going to be needing to invest more money in technology, hardware and software, and probably ultimately people to help with continuing to expand our security response. I mean, it's, you know, a lot of people within the industry say it's an arms race because you implement a piece of technology only for the bad actors to figure out how to

3:18:26 Circumvent that or, you know, take advantage of the vulnerability in it. And it's, you know, it's a never ending thing. But I think the biggest piece from my standpoint is awareness at the user level. And I really appreciate and applaud users in both organizations taking this seriously. One of the things that we have done is just continue to

3:18:52 We react very vigilantly whenever anything is support or sorry, is escalated to us and brought to our attention. And so while it's not a piece of hardware, it is probably something that has allowed us to sort of look into things that have emerged even, you know, through the most recent events. And that's something that we'll just continue to sort of invest in, I guess, at many levels.

3:19:17 And I will point out that I put Nate in touch with an IT director who had responded to a pretty significant ransomware incident in another jurisdiction that I'm familiar with last year, and Nate and one of his staff did talk to that person about, you know, what happened, lessons to be learned from that, because it was a relatively common kind of ransomware incident, and I'm sure that Nate and his staff kind of internalized those lessons and made use of that kind of

3:19:46 Unfortunate, but very recent, very practical experience. All right, okay, great. All right, questions from other, comments from other council members? Nate, just again, thank you very much. You set a very, very high bar for all of us and all of our systems, and we're very lucky to have you on the team. I run into colleagues of yours across the state. Your reputation precede you all over the place.

3:20:22 Just in case you hadn't heard. Just sort of a simple question. Is there any constraint on our broadband, on our backbone through Digital 395, or is that giving you everything that we need to be able to? Yeah, great question. No. There are no constraints from a backbone or backhaul perspective. You know, just to make...

3:20:53 This very clear. I mean, we receive service as a town, as a county, as municipal entities directly from Digital 395 without a middleman, so to speak, without a last mile provider. We currently leverage gigabit service and we are looking to continue to grow that, likely moving to 10 gig in the next couple of years. And that is in response to not only the service offering that is coming to us from Digital 395.

3:21:22 But also the demand from network utilization and continuing to move things to the cloud. And so I'll say that we would not be where we are today. We would not be in as sophisticated of a position or the ability to leverage a lot of the tools that we have if it was not for Digital 395. And so we're extremely lucky from that standpoint. And it's not lost on me that many of the other customers that are downstream and the private space are not.

3:21:50 And are you feeling good about security for elections coming up? You know, election security is an interesting question. And what I'll say is that elections are secure.

3:22:19 It is extremely, extremely difficult, if not impossible, to tamper with an election in terms of the technology or the way in which votes are cast, tallied and reported. Election tampering, you know, is through more social channels and other things that are influential, but those systems are air-gapped, they are protected, they are double and triple backed up.

3:22:47 I'm sorry, any public comment? No, there is not. Okay, I think we need to

3:23:22 Do a motion here to approve this. Do you hear a motion? Madam Mayor, I would make a motion to approve the 22-24 Information Technology Strategic Plan. I second the motion. Okay, thank you. We have a motion and a second. Jamie? Council Member Wray? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido?

3:23:49 Yes, and thank you very much, Nate, for your presentation and all the good work you do. Thank you, Nate. Okay, that then brings us to item 10, council member reports. So, Bill, why don't we start with your end of the table there? Okay, so since our last meeting, I have attended an LTC meeting with John as well. I will let him cover any specifics he would like to. He's got all of his notes there.

3:24:20 We covered a lot of different topics. Mammoth Trails meeting, where we discussed many things, including an idea from me that I'm not sure staff appreciated to potentially move a grooming machine onto our CIP process. An estimating, nothing great came out of that. And that's about it for me. Thank you. Okay, thank you, sir. John? Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3:24:52 I'm just pulling up one quick document. A couple meetings, but some important stuff. So I'll start with the ESCOG meeting that happened back on April 8th. And there are a couple of important acronyms that give you the full titles of these things that the council needs to be aware of because they are tied to lots and lots and lots of funding. The first one,

3:25:22 The second is a comprehensive economic development strategy or a SEDS. RCRC put in a grant which has been provisionally funded to set up a SEDS for the three counties of Alpine and Yuleen counties. You have to have a SEDS to get to that federal money. So that's happening. The second thing is a state program, the Community Economic Resilience Fund or the SERF.

3:25:53 $600 million in funding that the state, having figured out its regions in a pretty clumsy and awkward way, but they've drawn them out, this is going to be coming our way. It's going to be affecting us. And there'll be more to come on that in the coming months. I think for our region, we're in something called the Eastern Sierra Region. There's a very good presentation that one of the staffers from Inyo County, Megan, I can't remember her last name.

3:26:24 She's the Deputy CEO of Indio County. But I think we should get that presentation at some point so we can all look together on the same page. And that we can anticipate that the Sierra Business Council will likely be an applicant to kind of lead that process for our region. But that's coming our way. The other thing is there has been established in Bishop a small business resource center, which you may or may not know about, but this is for small business development.

3:26:53 It's been happening in Bishop and has been sort of incubated down there, but this is a regional, something which will have a regional scope. And again, the folks behind that, this comes out of some economic development expertise out of Colorado, out of the Intermountain West, which is kind of the world that we're in, has started to identify the economic industry sectors that we work in. This is important because we need to connect it to the money that's coming our way.

3:27:21 Things like forestry, fire mitigation and fuels treatments, natural resources management, environmental science, think NEPA documents, all that kind of stuff, sustainable recreation, alternative energy solutions like our friends from Wormat, desert ecosystem preservation. So we're starting to build what our economic profile looks like, the sectors, so that we can consume these opportunities coming our way. So that, good presentation on that.

3:27:52 And the sense from the SCOG is that the SCOG needs to consider putting together a program of work similar to what we did before with the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program, some kind of an economic development program so that the SCOG on behalf of the region can engage with all this stuff. Right now, it can't do that because it doesn't have the authority to do it. So I would guess in the coming months,

3:28:22 There's going to be a resolution. I think the ESCOG will be looking at that in June at the June meeting. They'll probably coming back to the four different jurisdictions. The timing of this is that we want to have things in place, I would say, by August, September. That's when the SURF money is going to start flowing. This stuff will be happening. So that's coming our way. International Forest is setting up a contract relationship with the ESCOG to be able to work.

3:28:51 For example, the Donut Project, they got that big $3 million grant. They're getting all that stuff lined up and set up. This goes back to Leslie Yen's commitment to be doing third-party NEPA. And this is how this stuff is going to work. So there was discussion about that. Also, there was consideration of an RFP that they put out, but we weren't ready to vote on it yet. And so that's about it. So there's some things happening at the SCOG that we're all going to need to be able to pay.

3:29:19 Just a couple of quick comments to put on that, John. One of the things that scares me, and as council members, a lot of people out there may not get this, but we get an inordinate amount of email about economic development. How could it create jobs in your neighborhood? And as long as SCOG is cognizant of the fact that right now our greatest development for economics needs to be finding a way to clone employees.

3:29:46 Because our greatest need are employees, and it's all over the state. At this point, while I'm a pro-business guy, I'm not too interested in creating many more jobs or even more businesses until we can find a way to come up with the employees to staff said businesses. That is a critically important lens to bring to all of this coming forward.

3:30:10 And I think we will all discover in the long run that it's not just housing. Housing is a critical need for us here, but there's a whole gamut there. And the thing that's important is that these other big state programs, the climate programs, 30 by 30, the state has taken a real interest in rural California because we have the nature-based solutions, we have the things that they're interested in. So it hasn't been there before, but it's coming in the coming months.

3:30:37 That's an excellent, I mean, that's the kind of perspective we need to bring to these opportunities. On the LTC, there's a big change in staffing. Jerry LeFrancois is retiring. Wendy Sugimura, I believe we heard, is going to be the lead of the... Well, the co-chair with Hayes. Co-chair with Hayes, yeah. Should be the co-chair with Hayes of the Mono County LTC. A lot of discussion around the...

3:31:08 We're going to talk about the overall work program, which is moving forward. Discussions about connectivity between June, Crowley, Mammoth Lakes, and there's some things happening with that. That was trail connectivity. Trail connectivity, and I followed up with Supervisor Kreitz on that. Folks know what the MOU projects were. This is high-level, big-time, kind of old-school state money from the California Transportation Commission. Hey, we'll give you

3:31:37 $20 million worth of credits if you build part of our highway and you give us. That whole culture, it sounds like, is coming to an end at this point. And we're going to have to do some reconciling with that to kind of tally up the books with that process. And I brought that up at the meeting itself. It's a situation that is almost dire to me. We have given credits for money that would have been coming to our county to do work in other counties.

3:32:06 That benefits us, but in return there was supposed to be money coming back here and now the main players have bailed on that commitment. Yeah, so we haven't, we've asked the LDC to come back with recommendations on how we're going to settle all that up, but that's, it's an era that's kind of coming to an end. So that was pretty interesting and got some very interesting updates from the National Park Service about what's going to be going on up in Tuolumne this summer.

3:32:34 Major campground rebuilding. I think they're redoing the road through the park. It's going to be a real mess up there. It's going to go on for a couple of years. Yeah, the Tuolumne Meadows campground is going to be closed for two years. That's going to be a huge problem. Yeah. So that's just something for all of us to be aware of. And there is a reservation system up there, so that's going to be in place. Interesting update, Reds Meadow Road project, which is that comes to us.

3:33:04 Interesting that the judge said no one's got to wear masks in public transportation anymore. We'll see what happens with that, but that's Fairbox revenue coming back to us that we need to keep an eye on. And I think that was about it. Good updates from MESTA and Caltrans, but I think that's about it, right? Good job, John. Okay. That's it, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much. Kirk.

3:33:31 Yeah, brief update. John cuts out a lot of the issues that I had written down. But here at Mammoth Lake Housing, the wait list continues to slowly creep up. 138 people have filled out all the applications and, you know, to try to find, you know, try to get into some units. The employees, from talking to some of the business community in town, especially

3:34:00 I'm glad you brought up climate change.

3:34:27 You know, I don't know if there's anything we can do about it other than electric vehicles and try to support them. But, you know, the charging stations are important and working with the state to implement as much of that as we can. That's all I have to report. Thank you. Okay, thank you. And on to Sarah. Thanks, Linda. All I have to report is attending the new Workforce Housing Committee meeting.

3:34:56 And we had the occasion to be invited by Emily Peters, who's the new chamber employee. But that's all I have. Okay, thank you very much. For myself, other than what John said about ESCOG, I attended the, actually I listened a little bit later, the first session of the Fire Academy that they're holding, sponsored by ESCOG. And it was really good. Dave Carl talked about the history of fire in the Eastern Sierra.

3:35:26 And looking forward to the next session. If you haven't already heard about it or read about it, you might want to think about looking in on it. It's definitely an important kind of asset for people to click into. And Dan, I see your hand is up. Yes, if I may, I'm just going to piggyback on Kirk's discussion on the housing. We had a meeting with ACD on our CDBG application, which is conditionally approved. So we're working through that to not finalize across the final T's, if you will.

3:35:55 That's for the Access Apartments, that project. And also we did a follow-up with the Home Key project as well. Same thing there, working through some information requests from the state. I think that all got sent off last week to them or the person this week to clean that application up. It sounds very promising to get funded. And then the...

3:36:19 Home application that Mammoth Lakes Housing had put in for as a total for funding on access apartments. Sounded like it was going to get an additional, I think, $1.2 million added to it. So that project is dramatically closer to being fully funded with the grants that are being approved at this point. Great. Good news. All right. Seeing nothing else then, we are going to take a break while we move into closed session. That is 11.1.

3:36:50 And it is pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8. The Town Council will hold a conference with its representatives in regard to lease negotiations pertaining to property 100100 College Drive and 10 Wagon Wheel Road, Mammoth Lakes, California, 93546. Agency negotiators being Daniel C. Holler and Rob Patterson. Negotiating parties.

3:37:19 Town of Mammoth Lakes and Luan Mendel, Board Chair and Betsy Truax, Executive Director, representing the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Under negotiation is lease price and terms. All right, what do we need? 10 minutes, take a little break, stretch your legs and meet back here at 6.48. All right. Oh, and everyone should have a different link for that.