Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- March 2023 Town document estimated a summer 2023 opening after construction took longer than planned Multi-Use Facility / Community Recreation Center
Transcript
451 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:37 Back in the snow globe. Oh, there's Chris. There's Chris. Good afternoon.
2:56 Good afternoon. Microphone's on. Welcome to this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, March 1st. The meeting is called to order. Jamie, if you could call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Present. Mayor Wentworth? Present. Fred Wong, would you mind leading us the Pledge of Allegiance this evening? Thank you.
3:49 Thank you, Mr. District Ranger. Moving on now to public comments. Are there any comments from members of the public on items that are not on this evening's agenda? I don't see anybody here in Sweet Z, anybody in the virtual? Okay, no public comment this evening. Moving on then, Dan, any additions to the agenda? No, Mr. Mayor, no additions. Okay, good. Reports from commissions and or departments. I see. Mr. Hayes, yeah.
4:27 I think you have the information we'd all like to be hearing about, so please, Haislip Hayes. So Dan asked me to give an update on snow-related operations. If you weren't aware, it's been snowing just a little bit of late, and we've been busy. So our operators, the town staff, have been working 24-7 on 12-hour shifts since the storm started over a week ago. At this time, only closures are the Scenic Loop and Sherwin Creek Road.
5:15 Equipment-wise, we're down one loader, one blower, one trackless in the holder. We have sufficient backups to keep us moving. We have equipment, excuse me, the parts inbound. This stuff was available last week. We were planning on picking it up in Reno along with our brand-new trackless machine. It seemed like a really good idea at the time, but unfortunately Mother Nature had other plans, and we weren't able to pick that up, but we'll have our parts inbound tomorrow, and going into this next round of storage, we'll have all of our equipment back.
5:45 During the road closures, 395, we've been hosting our hotels, excuse me, our staff in hotels. Dan's been coordinating that with Sierra Nevada Lodge. We appreciate that effort. Both the public works staff and the police department have been shacking up in town on the highway. I've got just a few photos. You guys are all familiar with this. You've been seeing this around town. But kind of what we're facing right now are narrow roads. It's very difficult to blow the snow this high.
6:16 And this light, because it just falls right back in the roadway, so we've been doing a lot more plowing activity, which is effectively narrowing the roads. But at this time, everything's pretty navigable. A lot of the arterials and collectors are well buffed out, and the residential narrowed overheads, they're narrow, but they're navigable and they're clear. Snow banks are getting very, very large. It's becoming very, very challenging to throw snow up on top of it. Our cut slopes are getting large, you know, 6, 7, 8 feet in areas.
6:45 Throughout this, Snow Patrol has been supporting PD and our plow drivers. They took this photo this morning. It's kind of hard to see the photo, but there's a white flag posted there. They surrendered. They've given up. This is over by Rainbow Lane. There are no shortage of issues out there, but it has been somewhat quiet pulling vehicles out. I think people are listening to the messaging and the highway closures are probably helping because we haven't been pulling out as many.
7:14 But we've been dealing with other fun stuff, like a tour bus that had its chains wrapped around its axle in the middle of the highway. Caltrans left us some treasure in the downhill lanes, pushing people into the suicide lane. We spray painted this with arrows and then called Caltrans and asked them to come clean that up. The usual abandoned Prius on Davison, which is a common occurrence, parking all over the place, wherever people feel, and then, you know, just
7:43 Leave your vehicle right in the middle of the road if you so desire. So Snow Patrol's been busy dealing with these types of issues and helping to move these vehicles out of the way to keep our operators moving snow and keeping police work. You may have heard we did escort some services into town. This is something that was coordinated over the last couple of days, something we have done before. This morning we did escort two fuel trucks and there was a tanker and a couple of bonds trucks in tow.
8:15 Just before they opened the highway. We were trying to coordinate this yesterday, but the drivers timed out. There were issues bringing in the fuel to Bishop from out of the area, which made it impossible to bring it to Mammoth. Lon Adams, our fleet manager, did a great job of coordinating. He does reach out to the other companies that deliver fuel to Druid and so on. We don't control who that fuel goes to. I don't know what their distribution network is, but we did reach out and let them know that we were going to be
8:50 We also encouraged CHP to let others know that if food services needed to get up, we were happy to ask. We did take delivery of two trucks today, 4,000 gallons, we have another 30 tomorrow, so we will be in great shape next storm. We do burn a lot of fuel, 800 to 1,000 gallons a shift, so 1,600 to 2,000 gallons a day. We have capacity for five or six days, but we also fuel our partners. Critical, this was done big.
9:32 We also participated in a rescue mission on Benton Crossing Road. There was a large multi-agency effort to rescue a number of drivers that were trapped on Benton Crossing Road. Our team supported from the west side after Saar and Mono County and the Mountain had gone out and rescued a few. Sabian from the airport ran a Kodiak. Tom and Todd from the road and airport ran 296.
10:02 And then Lon and I took a support vehicle out. Big thanks to those guys. They did not flinch at coming in on a Saturday and going into uncharted territory for us to help out these stranded drivers. Took us about four and a half hours to plow out to where they were, about 14 miles up on Benton Crossing Road up on Watterson. It was some tough going, huge drifts, difficult situation. Just a couple photos from that effort. We got really lucky with the weather.
10:32 By the time we get out there, the winds had died down. We were really worried it was going to blow in behind us, and it was going to be an effort of blowing in and blowing back out. That's why we took a lot of vehicle support. So we had backups on our backups because we just didn't. We got there about 7.30 at night. Turns out they were really happy to see us. We were pretty ecstatic. Spent about an hour digging them out. They had drifts 7, 8 feet all around their vehicle.
11:03 We worked with them to pull all the vehicles out. We got all the cars out, all the people out by about, and then everybody made it home safe. And this last picture is some of the wreckage we found along the way. This is Mono County equipment. And I'm putting this up here not to tease them, but to tell them good job. They threw everything they had at this. Every piece of equipment they had went out there. Every staff member they had in South County went out there. Only about 50% of the equipment they had made.
11:36 Thank you, Hayes.
12:09 One of the things that we've been doing since end of last week, the request with the county, Chris McCrassick is the head of the Office of Emergency Services that we created underneath the county. So we've been working with him to have regular check-ins and meetings, and that has involved a number of people on those calls. So Chris will be there, other county reps, other town reps. We'll have Caltrans, CHP.
12:36 Other regional reps that will all be together kind of walking through the situations we're at. Matt Provo from SCE is generally on those calls. And so we will walk through that and get kind of the updates for known issues out there and looking forward. They've been, there's actually one going on right now. They've been meeting at four o'clock each day. And so from that, generally we'll do a quick little update through bullet points, key points out to town council. You'll see those coming out for myself.
13:03 And trying to let you know some of the key elements we're working on. We will talk through closures. The Sheriff's Department, PD Department are on those calls as well. So there's about 20-some folks, 25 folks are involved in that. We really started this as the storm started to kick in stronger and some of the other issues to make sure we're all talking to each other consistently. And that's very important as we work through this.
13:29 A call today, we had actually went with Chris, went with Mary Brewer from the county, different elements. The county's currently working through Cal OES and discussion with Caltrans and NDOT, the Nevada Department of Transportation, in looking at trying to get some additional clearing on 182 out of Bridgeport into Nevada and 167 into Nevada. So both of those, I think, Caltrans has cleared out to the state line.
13:57 They haven't come up on the other side all the way in yet connecting that clearing. A couple days ago they had challenges on six. It was open out of Bishop going up and it got closed on the Nevada side. There actually was a pretty bad accident with that to where a Caltrans plow was hit and destroyed. No injuries that I know of so that was good but Caltrans lost another piece of equipment. So that's always a challenge through that stuff.
14:22 The other question that's come up a lot is two things. One for the town is on declaring our own declaration of emergency. We have not totally exhausted all of our own resources at this point, so we're not quite there, but we're definitely, I'll say, on the edge, and we can move forward with that. As we look out the next week, starting on the 4th, we're looking at another storm series, maybe the 3rd. Any good weather forecasters in here? Get it right.
14:50 Anyway, and then also looking to the 10th, maybe even the atmospheric river coming in. So if we start to see that level of activity coming in, that may kick us into that mode. We'll be watching the next day or so, and so you may see a declaration declared. The process on that can go for myself to make that declaration. Council would have to ratify it within seven days. So if there's some...
15:14 Serious issues we see in our equipment and staffing issues and things of that nature that would drive us okay, we may have to start requesting additional resources and that would drive that declaration in there. The other thing we've had a lot of calls on is calling in the National Guard. While I think that sounds really good, one, they don't have the heavy equipment to come in and help move snow, and I doubt they're trained on snow removal operations.
15:43 The other side in discussions on that, if we did get something out of that, it would probably be, you know, half a dozen, dozen people with some shovels, a backhoe, and a small dump truck. So the actual effectiveness would be pretty limited. In our experience, it was the last one, the previous one, we had them in town. They did bring in some trucks to help haul with. Again, because they're not equipped and experienced in hauling snow, it helped, but it wasn't all that effective.
16:10 And then also generally they do not do work just on private residents and businesses with no, I'll say no damage. It would be different if we had rescue missions, hey, we have collapsed buildings, we've got a lot of other things happening that way, or we're filling sandbags for flooding activities and actually have disaster stuff moving forward that's hitting us versus a preventive side that's always a question, well, aren't there adequate private sources that can provide those services?
16:40 We've looked at that, again, in the past we've done that. We've also had the fire crews come in before out of Bishop Berry there, Owens Valley, and we've also had the Triple C crews come in, Conservation Corps. They come up, they have dug out fire hydrants and generally help with snow clearing off of public, quasi-public buildings. Again, they don't do private facilities, they don't do somebody's home or private business.
17:08 One or two exceptions where we knew we had a busted collapse in place. So I think we had some help in those areas on one facility. So we look at those resources, getting them here, and then there's generally, with some of those, there's actually a cost to the town. I think the one event we did it, I can't recall, we submitted, Rob may know, about maybe $300,000 in requests, got made $25,000 or $30,000, and may have spent $30,000 or $40,000 to get that. So anyway.
17:37 Not a lot of huge value to that with the snow events, but it is something that we will be looking at. If the next storm starts to roll in and we look like there may be an atmospheric river, the declaration of the local emergency does give some flexibility to town on how quickly we can react and how we can do some things very, very quickly. One of the areas we're looking at right now, even, it'd be a modification of agreement with
18:05 Our contractor for the snow storage pit to look at actually reducing those prices down somewhat as we're getting a lot of questions from HOAs, private and businesses just in terms of that cost is going to be astronomical just given the number of truckloads of snow that's gone out. And so we are looking at some ways to do that with the goal back to those people hauling that needs to be an offset cost back to those who are paying that bill.
18:33 So we've had some of those in terms of those types of requests from business owners as well as HOAs and others. We've also had notifications in some places where your roofs are leaking because of weight and dripping in water and that's something that we can't.
19:02 Just go out and then shovel a roof for private residents at that point, even in those areas. So a lot of activity going on that way, a lot of coordination effort, as Hayes mentioned, as well as making sure that our own crews and equipment are taken care of and ready to go. It's been a horrendous winter so far, and it's not over. So glad to answer any questions there, and or if Hayes, if you have anything to add to that. Yeah, I'll have one more thing to say.
19:32 Please, any questions? Great, thank you very much. Councilmembers, any questions? For Hayes or for Dan? Questions? Chris does. Any questions? First of all, I just want to thank you and all your teams and everybody who's been taking care of people. This has been really tough. Dan, I think this question is for you. You know, I'm starting to see that that atmospheric river could be a rain on snow event, so how do we prepare for that? I don't mean to chuckle, but we've had them. We're hoping it stays cold.
20:03 First of all, then, in terms of snow, which we can deal with. The rain on snow event, there's two different issues we do on that. One, we'll be looking at it in terms of the amount of snow we have in town. There's a fairly high absorption of rain. Secondly, we are equipped. We have a large number of and a large pile of cinders, which we use for sandbags. And it would become a sandbagging effort. We have certain areas we know that can't have flooding. And with the snow issue, depending how that directs water, et cetera. And so we would be...
20:32 We'll be watching that, too. That's one of the key issues.
21:03 Again, we know we have certain areas that have the potential to flood. I may add a couple things. Some of the engineering staff got together this morning and we're kind of talking about this and we're hoping to jinx it by talking about it because these are various serious types of events, these rain on snow events. We've talked about grabbing our GIS system and we have documented where all of our drains are, where all of our inlets are.
21:28 And then we would work to uncover those. We would move from snow patrol to a chipping great patrol and making sure that all of our drains are accessible. We would cut channels in our lower areas where we know we have issues. But you can't predict where a lot of this water is going to go. It's going to get channelized in the street. And we will do our best to try to convey it to our known storm drain locations.
21:53 But these can be very nerve-wracking events for the engineering team because we just cannot predict how things are going to transpire. And Dan mentioned we'll probably start, you know, we start seeing this, we'll start building sandbags and have them palletized at the shop. And then we'll probably, through Stu, put that on social media when those are available if we do get in that situation. But hopefully talking about it, we're jinxing it, and we're just going to get more champagne powder. I love that. That's great. But I think that that's the time where we can ask for extra help because that's a flood.
22:22 Yeah, if it wipes out our resources that we can't overwhelm. And then, as I was going to mention the same thing on Hayes, one of the challenges in the flooding side is the fact that the storm drains are iced up and or a couple, six inches to, it is a lot of movement that, and that does add additional weight. Okay, hang on one second. Anything from you, Amanda? You're good? Okay, Stu, before I get to you, a couple things. One is, the question about the rain and snow events goes to a need for advocacy.
23:00 Because OES, I don't know if it's Cal OES or National OES does not recognize rain on snow events as being an emergency. Maybe that's changed. But if that has not changed, I think that's a very important point of advocacy that we should work with the county on. I think also the reality of snow, these types of events, certainly given the larger framework of climate change and the state's interest in this, this is my observation that I think this may not be the last of these things. And it may be an increasingly manic.
23:29 Thank you. Thank you.
23:59 Thank you. Thank you.
24:26 May have some other limits on there as well. Okay, do we know anybody in the state that maybe we could call to say, look, we'd like to have a statewide state of emergency declared? There was messaging that came out from Congressman Riley, Kevin Kiley, whatever his name is, saying that he's paying attention to Mono County, he's paying attention to the avalanche slides. I think we need to be advocating at all levels, federal and state levels. If we start going into what we're talking about, I don't think we can be sitting here saying, oh, gee, wish we had a state of emergency declared.
24:55 So perhaps that's something we could be working on. I have to walk through the language in there again, but I'm not sure if Andy was on that. I mean, we can still use the old rules where we don't even have to have a quorum in the same room. We just have to have a quorum of the council within the town of Mammoth Lakes. The only issue, of course, is that we have to disclose everyone's locations. They all have to be publicly accessible. And you have to let people come sit next to you during the meeting.
25:22 Okay, so we'll figure all that out. But I think, obviously, Hayes, to your point, you guys are going to keep talking about this, but we really don't have that much control over what's going to happen. So I think that if, Dan, if you need us, I think we'll all be here. But just let's get ready for that. And if you need us to convene and do things and take actions, we'll certainly be available to do that. As I mentioned, after the local emergency, definitely we can declare that and then we have some time to figure out to get the council together for ratification. Okay, and I believe Mr. Kiley is going to be in Bishop, I think, next week.
25:53 Okay. He said that there's a meeting in Bishop. He's going to be having a meeting in Bishop that's coming by, I think, March 11th. Okay, good. So we can all go down and visit Mr. Kyler and say, look, we could use your help in these circumstances. Yeah, good. And Stu, just to segue into you, I think one of the things that's really important is in terms of that situation that happened with the traffic backup, there's an old saying that, you know, culture eats policy for breakfast, and it does it every day.
26:25 And I think when we get into situations like that where everybody's running around saying there's too many tourists in town, this is a tourism problem with too many people in here, I think it's incumbent upon us as elected officials to really let's look into this and see what actually happened and look at the reality of coordination between CHP and Caltrans and the town and all the rest of it. I think we really need to be able to be proactive with our constituents and with the community, with our larger audience.
26:51 What's happening here? What really went on? The need, we've reached out to the Mono County LTC. That may not be the best venue to do that, but to get our partners together, let's get everybody talking and figure these things out. This is not simply kind of a hopeful sign if we had a fire event, for example, in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. Other things like this we need to be preparing for. Again, in any era of climate change, these are things we've got to be thinking about. Sorry, Stu, go ahead. Your hand is, it's not tired, it's virtual.
27:20 Thank you. Mayor, I'm coming to you from the world of Zoom in acknowledgement recognition of the ending, if we all knew, of the state of emergency for COVID. So I just thought I'd just do it one more time from the land of Zoom. I'm just going to follow up on Council comment about the AR event. Fortunately, Chris allows me to text him.
27:46 This is Chris Smallcomb from National Weather Service. I've got his personal cell phone and we text frequently, if not every day. And I posed that same question to Chris a couple of days ago. And he says, there's a lot of uncertainty about the AR event. Some models have them into California while others do not. It will be a colder type of AR. Snow level at this time is around five to five and a half thousand feet, right? So if we're at seven plus.
28:14 At this time, unless it changes, we're going to be okay. Snow is going to be a little bit heavier, 10 to 12 to 1, which is kind of the ratio. I think this week it's been probably 18, 19, 20 to 1. So a little bit heavier, certainly, but he's not seeing a kind of rain on snow event at this time. So I did want to convey that, but I'll just keep everybody updated. And like Dan indicated, we're on those emergency calls every day. And Chris joins us.
28:42 When he can, and he'll probably do that again beginning of next week with a more perhaps closer realistic update to that event. So Dan and I did, Mr. Mayor, draft a response to the weekend's traffic congestion. So that's with the town manager at this point. And we'll just see how we go sharing that with our community. And to your point, certainly.
29:10 Interagency communication is kind of top on that list that we're addressing each and every day with our emergency meetings. So I did want to pass that on and happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much. And for the, there's a ESSRP, the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership meeting coming up on Monday, and Mr. Smolcombe will be at that meeting and he'll give hopefully probably more detail, be a little closer to the event, have some information to share with all the regional partners. Okay. Anybody else?
29:41 We good? We're all ready? It'd be kind of nice to get to the world record snowfall without having to declare a state of emergency. That'd be kind of cute, but we'll save that for another day. Any public comment? Jamie, anything out there? No? What's that? Yeah, yeah, okay, good. So we'll move on now to our next reports. Lawson, Rob, who wants to go next? Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. I will be extremely brief.
30:15 If anybody was interested in doing some cross-country skiing, it's going to be a minute. So if anybody has any questions related to that, we will need to wait for our forest partners most likely to get their groomer out to deal with the road crossing, which is about 20 feet on either side right now. And it's deep out there. Our equipment cannot handle that. So we will do the best we can.
30:37 And then lastly, we are in the process right now. We recently put out an RFQ for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System contractor, and we received one applicant. So we will move forward with that applicant, and I may have a contract as early as the 15th to bring to all of you. So we will stay in touch about that, but that is all I have. Good luck out there. Keep shoveling.
31:09 Thank you. Councilmembers, Rob Patterson, Admin Service, Finance Director. I wanted to follow up with some things that Hayes had talked about and really maybe focus a little bit more on the airport. So as the storm was coming in for the airport, we actually closed on Friday and Saturday in advance, letting folks know that with the expected winds and weather that we were not really going to be able to keep the airport open. And that helps the aviation industry and groups really kind of know what to do and how to respond and where maybe they need to go.
31:38 I think that we got good response for making that call early. Our plan was to get it open on Sunday morning. As you heard from Hayes, very proud of Sabine and Tom combining with Hayes and team to get out there and really want to get involved in that rescue. That kept them out all night, really took the opportunity to open the airport on Sunday out, even though it was a beautiful day that day. So, unfortunately, the advanced air flights were canceled.
32:08 Friday through Monday, because even down in Bishop, the roads being closed and such, just no opportunity for that. But yeah, I'll talk a little bit about the strength of the performance this year in our flights when we give an airport presentation here shortly. But I wanted to publicly say thank you to my airport team for the work they did on Saturday.
32:33 I'd like to add to that to thank Rob as well and the Mono County Search and Rescue Team because he was personally involved in that on his own sled, going out to check on the people in the cars and take water and food to them and let them know that help was coming. So our staff really puts their best foot forward for this community. Okay, Mr. Urdie. Good afternoon. I'll try and read beer, but we have a lot of stuff to talk about.
33:03 First thing I want to talk about, and we discussed it at our board meeting today, was the sales tax on TBID challenge. Thank you, Councilmember Rice, for helping me at least solve one of the problems. Unfortunately, we had multiple systems that we could not figure out, and so we've kind of reverted back to the original solution of businesses collecting 1.5 percent, remitting 1.38 percent, just because while we figured out some of the bigger programs, there are multiple, multiple programs that we couldn't figure out, and it was going to be...
33:32 Presenting challenges to the business community. So moving forward, we are going to finalize and dot all the T's and cross all the I's with our, wait, dot all the I's and cross all the T's with our attorneys. That's why I have attorneys. And make sure that all of that is ready to go. We will actually modify the current management district plan, even though it expires in August 31st, in order to have this be in place as soon as possible so that businesses can comply.
33:59 We'll have to modify that. It's probably a three, four-week process that we'll have to involve the council with as well to rewrite that, and then the new district plan moving forward, we'll have it written in. We will also, if we have businesses that get audited and get assessed back three years, as we've heard, or two years or even a year, we will work with them on their appeal. We have a tax expert from Cohn and Resnick.
34:24 Krista Shipp, who we will pay for an hour's worth of time to work with the businesses to make sure that they go back with the proper appeal of the audit. And then once we work that down as far as possible, it'll come back to our board and we will work to approve helping the business with the fees and any penalties and interest that we can't get rid of. Recognize this is because of the TBID. It's not something that the business did. Only specifically for the TBID-related item, not for anything else that's part of the audit.
34:52 So that's it for that side of the TBID. We will also be going out, once I get the management district plan, the new management district plan has to have some adjustments done to it. Once that's finalized and I can get it to Dan for final approval and Andy Morris, we will go out for the petition process. We have kind of moved the time frame. We've moved it a few times. The next move right now is we want to try and meet with you folks for April 5th for the resolution of intent.
35:20 The resolution of intent to form is really the first step of getting this going. We present you the number that we have for the petitions. In the past, it's been over 60%. That's our goal this year as well. And then we can go through the renewal process. We did have a very good Mammoth Lake Tourism Board meeting today. We had a lot of discussions. We talked about our strategic planning moving forward.
35:43 And really, we haven't changed our strategy moving forward wholeheartedly, but there are some very, very major changes within the three areas that we focus on. The first piece was outreach to our community. And we've really expanded the community from being, it's not just residents, it's second homeowners, it's visitors, it's businesses, it's the town. That is the community. We need to make sure that that is focused on as the community.
36:09 And outreach to that group and making sure that they're aware of what we're doing, how we're doing it, why we're doing it, and what they can do to be part of help moving forward. The second is education, which we continue to do. I think there are still a bunch of people out there that think that we are just opening floodgates and inviting people to come here in droves. We are not. We are really recognizing that...
36:29 Yes, we are going to invite people to come here during the need times, but during the peak times, we're going to ask them to behave themselves, and we're going to tell them, you know, a little bit more about how they can respect the community and the environment. And then lastly is really focusing on the off-peak visitation. So a lot of that has to do with destination. A lot of it has to do with air service and, you know, the reformed MIWAG, if it ever went away, the Mono Inyo Air Working Group, as well as working with our other agencies.
36:57 That destination visitor has proven very good for us. It helps us fill the midweeks. It helps bring longer stays, all those different pieces. But filling off peak visitation includes spring, fall, midweek, winter, all those different pieces. We're very fortunate in a winter like this where midweek visitation fills in because weekends are sold out. One of the other things that we've really been highlighting is the partnership with you, you being council and the town on...
37:24 Thank you so much.
37:52 And so if we can add new bus service, microtransit, bus shelters, whatever it is, yes, it's good for our visitors, but it also really benefits our locals as well. So we really want to work with you on that partnership. We want to commit some dollars to that as well to make sure that we can work together on that. Good. I've got a couple thoughts. Any questions for John? Questions? No? So I was fortunate to listen to your board meeting today, and it was really, really, really useful.
38:23 Very reassuring, and especially reassuring in that it really made me understand, as if I didn't know already, that the board and you are out there, we are working on parallel tracks to get to the same aims and the same goals. For the new members of the council, I'm going to recommend to Dan and to Rob, we had a very fruitful and interesting town council workshop with the MLT board last June 1st.
38:52 And we really came to some really important key agreements having to do with roles and responsibilities, having to do, this was a part of the conversation to cap the Measure A dollars that were going to MLT. And in that we divined, okay, the town has roles and responsibilities. And John spoke very eloquently today about MLT is not going to build cell towers. MLT is not going to get into the infrastructure business. That's frankly, it's the Forest Service and the town. We have to work together to
39:21 Create a sustainable infrastructure environment for all the guests that are coming up here. So we have to work together on that. It was great to hear a reassertment of that from your board. And you're putting together some kind of a committee that's going to bring back to the council for the visitation experience. These are the specific recommendations coming from the MLT board to the council with the resources that we have to move this thing forward. And what was really put together that meeting June 1st was housing is the top priority.
39:51 And that has allowed us to put millions of dollars into housing programs here locally. But it's not the only priority. And this conversation is something that we set up to be continued. So I think it's really important, Rob, we've had conversations about this, to make sure that it's coming back to the council, what's coming from the MLT board, what are their priorities, so we move forward together. We cannot afford to go backwards and pretend that June 1st didn't happen. We can't afford that.
40:18 We need to build partnerships. If we drift a little bit, we drift a little bit. We need to come back together. And certainly, Fred, you and the Park Service as well, there's a very critical role for your public agencies to be playing in this. The people are coming to these public lands, whether we market to them or not. They're all coming here. We all have to work together for the benefit and the health of the natural resources and for the visitor experiences of the people. And I would encourage council members, if you haven't listened to these board meetings, I would really encourage you to do that.
40:48 You can listen to them live. They happen in Wednesday meetings or you can do the recording. This last one, I think, would be very helpful as we get ready for these workshops. And you've got a contract. Is there a contract renewal coming up this year? Correct. So that's going to be part of this. And Dan, you and John and Rob, you have some real work to do to figure out the sequencing of TBID renewals, contract renewals, priorities and goals. We've got a lot of work to do with them. Those are my thoughts. I'm sorry if I went on to. John, the PowerPoint, is that available on our website? Yeah, it's all part of the board packet, so it's all in there.
41:21 Okay. Absolutely. It might help if you sent that around to council. Sure. So they could take a look. Yeah, absolutely. And I think to Mayor Wenworth's comments, I think that this is one of the things that could put us at great risk if we don't figure these things out. You know, I think that we have two options. We can either stop inviting people to come here or we can figure out how to manage them when they come so that it doesn't impact our residents negatively and that we don't have to turn away the business. So we're here to partner with you and look forward to the conversations moving forward.
41:53 Thank you very much. Thank you. Mr. Casabian, interim, what is your title right now? Good evening, Cal. Okay. Interim, acting. Acting, good, thank you. Just a quick update on the weekend and the storms and stuff like that. I will make it brief. Going back to the Sunday backup that we had, it's a simple fix. It's as easy as communication. And management team, as well as myself, we're in communication with Caltrans at CHP.
42:24 Just a few calls that we had over the weekend. We had two arrests. Luckily, they were at...
42:53 Good timing that we were able to get them north to Bridgeport before we had the catastrophe we've had up there. And we didn't have any arrests where we had to go south. We couldn't go south. We couldn't go north. Rows were closed. But over the weekend, we had multiple abandoned vehicles, hit and runs, four alarm calls, lots of citizens' assists, 20 motorists assists, 11 traffic accidents, six parking complaints, which resulted in seven tickets.
43:23 But over the entire month from February 1st to March 1st, we're looking at about 185 for the entire month. And then some other minor calls, disruptions, missing persons. We had a structure file that the fire department was able to handle on Callahan. That's about it on the calls. I want to kind of echo what Hayes was saying and what Rob was saying about the dedication and commitment to the entire organization as a whole.
43:49 The police department, you know, they had a window. Our day shift and night shift had a window to get out of here on Monday and go back down. If that would have happened, we wouldn't, well, it would have been hard to fill our patrol staff because they would not have been able to come back up. So great job with the police department and everybody there. That's all I have. Do you have any questions? Questions? No, I think we're good. Thank you very much. Thank you. Anybody else? No? Good. I just think on behalf of the council, the community, the effort on Benton Crossing, you guys really did us proud.
44:21 And thank you again, I think from all of us. Okay, so let's move on then to a recognition, a council presentation, recognition of police officer Daniel Hansen for a 15-year anniversary award. Put the band back together, please. Thank you. Daniel, this is, we have something for you. Please come forward. Thank you.
44:50 Hey, Council, I'm honored to be here to recognize and celebrate the outstanding job that Daniel's done with his 15 years of service to our community. Throughout his career, Officer Hansen has constantly demonstrated strong judgment and unwavering dedication to uphold the law and protect our community. Officer Hansen has also made significant contributions to our community outreach efforts. He's participated in a community...
45:15 Where was I? Oh, yeah. Community policing programs, including youth mentorship, school resource officer, explorer program, and the list goes on and on. And just to touch on that a little bit with the explorer program, which is, as everybody knows, we're in the process of recruiting. And one of the recruits that we're bringing in is an explorer of four or five years. How long was she in there? A little over five years, which is a great circle there, where she, you know, full circle.
45:43 Daniel's dedication and hard work has not gotten unnoticed by his management staff, his colleagues, and our citizens. It is with great pleasure that I present Daniel Hansen with his 15-year service award. And what's really funny about this is when he got to the station, I was his FTO. And I remember seeing him sitting in the passenger side. I had a police canine at the time, Brutus, in the back seat 15 years ago.
46:08 And he's sitting there, white-knuckled, in the car, not really, you know, nervous. They're all nervous. And the dog starts barking, and that just kind of broke the ice. So it's just, it's crazy to see him, you know, 15 years later and all of his accomplishments is great. You know, I appreciate your service, man, and dedication to our community, protecting our community, and dedication to the organization. Thank you. Yeah, I appreciate it. Thank you. Daniel, would you like to, let's all, you stay right there. We're going to come down and we're shaking up.
46:39 So moving on now to staff presentations, an update on the Reds Matter Road project.
47:50 Mr. Haislip Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This has been a long time coming. I was kind of looking back at the numbers, and it was 2016, 2017 that we started having conversations about this project, and it was March of 2018 that we received notification that we were successful in our FLAP grant to get the funding to move this project forward. And just the scope of the project, for those who may not be familiar,
48:21 includes 2.5 miles of the upper Reds Meadow Road to be completely reconstructed, widened, realigned, retaining walls, stabilization, and then the lower portion of Reds Meadow Road will receive what's a 3R, a pole Verizon repave. Central Federal Lands will lead the project delivery, the construction.
48:43 And the contract administration for this project. And Dustin Robbins, our liaison with Federal Lands, is on the call. I'm going to hand it over to him to kind of talk about what we can expect moving forward. Thank you. Welcome. Hey, everybody. Hi, everybody. Good to talk with you all. So I just exactly, Hayes, good introduction there. Just as far as a status update and, you know, the project was
49:14 We've advertised, we received bids late this fall, and we're able to award as of January 13th. And a notice to proceed has been given to the contractor as of February 1st. Now, that doesn't mean that they're allowed to go out there and start doing anything at this moment. That really just frees them up, start working on some of their preliminary submittals and things like that. So they're working on some of that right now.
49:44 So starting really the communication with our team. And I guess what we probably want to share here today is really just so everybody's aware of what's in the contract as far as traffic management, traffic closures, those sorts of things. That was really developed over years of communication on this one when meeting with stakeholders.
50:13 And so what the contract allows is starting on May 15th, the contractor would have the right to get in there and begin work. Now that doesn't mean it'll be efficient for them. Sounds like you guys had some pretty tremendous snow. I've been watching the meeting here. So that may or may not
50:41 The contract does give them the ability to get in there as early as May 15th, and they'd be able to work kind of unencumbered between May 15th and June 1st. Now, once June 1st hits, they are required, if they're going to be working, they're required to have public traffic open between the hours of 11 a.m. and 7 p.m.
51:10 And then they're able to close the project down between 7 p.m. and 11 a.m. overnight. So that period rolls through June 1st. This is probably really hard for you guys to remember all of this. I guess the big takeaway, I don't know if we need to remember dates, I guess, but the big takeaway is that throughout the beginning of the, throughout the summer up to near the end of September, we have the third Sunday of September,
51:40 Public traffic has to be maintained between 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. with the exception of up to a 30-minute delay. So traffic can still go through, but there will be delays during that time. And those delays are at a set of a maximum 30 minutes. And then once we get toward the end of September, the contractor is allowed to work during the week with a full closure.
52:06 Up until the point where, you know, we would have what we call a winter shutdown, where the weather is just, you know, too poor to continue working in an effective manner. And they would be required to maintain public traffic during the weekends after that period. So Hays has all this information. This is what's in the contract. And I've got, you know, even the tables and things that we put together to make this a little bit simpler.
52:34 That's what we expect. We'll be having some more communication with the contractor. I'm sure they'll be monitoring weather and the conditions and all that here over the next month or two as they start to develop their plan on when they want to hit the ground. And we will be in communication with Hayes on all of that. We'll kind of be our liaison there. Remind everybody this is a two-season project, so we plan to start work.
53:03 This season, this summer, and finish work at the end of next summer. I don't know if there's anything else you'd like me to cover. Any questions? Hayes, did I miss anything? Hayes, anything you want to add? No, I just want to add, and thank you for all of that, that this plan, this closure plan, was put together over many, many stakeholder meetings that involved all of the parties. And Fred Wong,
53:32 Just real quick, when you say stakeholders, perhaps for the benefit of the council, I know that involve people from different counties and permittees, maybe just give an idea of who's in that group of stakeholders. Yeah, absolutely. So the Forest Service, the Park Service, the Town, Federal Highways, some of the concessionaires that are down in the valley, the ski area, we're all involved in putting together this plan, and importantly, ESTA, who provides the bus service down there. So we all were communicating early on.
54:01 And trying to find the best way to still provide the public access to Red's Meadow and the beautiful areas down there, but also give the contractor the most amount of time to efficiently get this project done, because it is a very, very significant project. And any delays we cause to them just makes the project last longer. And we feel it's probably best to rip the Band-Aid off and suffer for a couple of years instead of having this dragged on for multiple years.
54:27 I do want to talk a little bit. We have Fred Wong with Forest Service and Rebecca Carr Wong with Park Service here. Fred will be leading a lot of the communications effort. And, of course, we'll all be working together to support that. But I don't know if you have anything you want to add about your plans. Yeah, please come forward. And Fred and Rebecca, just because you both work for federal agencies. Sometimes you appear in public together.
54:54 How do you, is there a way you like to be introduced or just, we just go with your District Ranger, Fred Wong and Rebecca, I don't know, is that how we should? That sounds good. Is that okay? Yeah. Okay, good, thank you. So, you know, the Forest Service, Lisa Cox, our public affairs person, is working on a communications plan. We're almost done with it. We're about ready to roll it out to our stakeholders, kind of our inner circle, which is the town, the county, and some other close stakeholders to review and comment on.
55:24 I don't know exactly when it's going to come out, but it's going to be coming out soon. And so, you know, essentially what Dustin had mentioned is kind of like the wide side boards that we were told by Federal Highways that let's convey that message to the public. And if there's any adjustments to that, we'll adjust our message based on that.
55:50 Okay, and then Rebecca, maybe, I don't know if you've been in front of the council before, maybe you could introduce yourself and let everybody know. I have not been before the council before, but I've met many of you and worked with several of you. So I'm the site manager for the National Monument, so that's equivalent to the superintendent. I work for the superintendent at Yosemite.
56:13 Yeah, our concerns are really just making sure that it's efficient transportation up and down the hill for the visitors, making sure that we're still giving them a good experience. And we also have most of our staff actually resides down in Reds Meadows, so of course our concerns are going to be how does this affect the administrative access and when can we start getting down there and turning on our water system and getting things ready for the summer. So looking forward to working with everyone and feel free to contact me.
56:42 Okay, great. Thank you. Any questions from Council for Hayes? Is Dustin still with us? Dustin still with us? Yes, I'm still here. Great. Okay. Any questions? Let's start with Chris down here at the end. Bill can go first. So, just so I'm clear, so the buses won't start heading down there until 11 a.m. on weekdays. Is that correct? Did I hear that right? Correct. That's the plan. So, this is a question, I think, for Mr. Wong.
57:14 District Ranger, right? So the question is, a lot of backpackers head out to start their trips early in the morning. How will we communicate to them when they pull their permit that this is a different situation? We've had experience with this last year with the Reds Meadow kind of preliminary work with the tree cutting. So on our website, we will notify people.
57:40 That of some of their certain restrictions, some people will, you know, change their plans and go to different routes on the backpackers. So that's easily changeable. And last year that was similar. It's just that they kind of need to know ahead of time. We're a little bit late on some of this rollout of this communications, but they can adjust pretty easily based on what they see on the website. And also we have their email addresses. And so if there's any changes in their entry or exit point conditions.
58:10 They will be notified through email. Okay. Are you good? Okay. No, please. A couple quick. I'm assuming that in the contractor's contract, starting on May 15th, that he would be allowed to remove snow if he could? Would the mountain be able to say, no, we still have snow on the Miracle Mile, so you can't? Or would that be overridden by the contractor's need to get down there?
58:41 You take that one. Ultimately, Caltrans has the jurisdiction over Highway 203 through that agreement they have with Mammoth Mountain, but in the past, I suspect we would find some sort of way to accommodate both parties. For example, if traffic were needed to go through there, I suspect Mammoth Mountain would try to accommodate that and have the traffic go through their parking lot.
59:08 I know some of those turns are a little bit tight, but in the past, our large trucks could make it through that area, and so I suspect the same for their construction equipment, too. Yeah, I'm not worried about the parking lot area. The road is used as a ski run for a good deal of the year, so it's not a necessary run. I just want to make sure that you've thought about that now, and we've dealt with it now, not at that time, so we know who can pull the plug on what.
59:39 A couple more. I'm assuming that while regular transportation is from 11 to 7, we have an emergency plan in place in case there is a fire or medical emergency. It's not Mono County, but the need to get in and out with emergency service is going to be there. So I don't know how that works with the construction when it's the only road in and out.
1:00:04 I can speak. So the contractor does have to provide for emergency access. So that is written into the contract. So whatever work that they're doing, they have to have provisions for emergency access. And so all of that coordination will be reviewed and approved by our contract administrator. So that will be taken care of. That is a standard
1:00:34 So, you know, our approach, and really, Hayes might be able to give some more background on this, because just for...
1:00:56 For your information, I became a project manager later in the game after these decisions were already made. So I wasn't in the room when the decisions were made. But the way the contract is written, the contractor does have the right to get in there. So they would coordinate with the ski run and all of that, but they would have the right to remove that snow and start doing more.
1:01:25 And that, and I believe that has been communicated. So everything should be clear there. Thank you. You know, just going, I was focusing on that initial run, but you're right. In that area, the Forest Service manages that part of the road from, from the parking lot to, through the Minaret Vista. And, you know, in the past, Mammoth Mountain also has been very cooperative as far as, you know.
1:01:53 Saving, harvesting that snow and allowing traffic to go on that one lane. It's a little bit narrow, but I suspect trucks could probably fit through there as well. Yeah, I just wanted to make sure that we aren't figuring this out on the 15th. We have this in advance. The other thing, we know that one of these supervisors from Madeira got his nose bent out of shape a little bit previously because he thought we weren't communicating enough. So I'm assuming that Madeira has been added into the loop on all of this throughout so that we don't end up with any...
1:02:23 Conflicts there as well. Other than that, I think I'm good, John. Thank you. Good. Okay. Thank you. Just a couple of follow-up questions. So, Dustin, just to be clear, are you with Federal Highways? Yes. So, I work, I'm a federal employee. I work for Federal Highways, Central Federal Lands Division. Okay. So, who is the contractor? So, the contractor is Herbac Engineering. How do you spell that? H-E-R-B-A-C-K.
1:02:56 Okay, and where are they out of? You know, I don't know off the top of my head. Give me one second here and I will get that information. But I can tell you, although they've never worked on one of my projects, they had worked on several of ours. And they, you know, they've been a successful bidder. They bid on a lot of projects in this region. And my understanding is that they've done very good work in the past. And so our team was actually pretty excited to see that they had ended up as the low bidder on this.
1:03:27 Looks like they are out of Minden, Nevada. I'm not sure exactly where Minden is, but it must be somewhere in the region. It's right in the neighborhood. We know where they are. So just going forward for all of you, who is the, I guess, Hayes, from a contracting perspective, from the physical work, who will we be hearing from? Will we hear from you? Will we hear from who's going to be the council's point of contact to understand what's happening with the project itself?
1:03:57 For the town side, you're welcome to contact me with any questions, but for the contract, it's all within central federal lands. They're responsible for the project delivery, the contracting, and the contract administration. So they're responsible for pretty much all of the project delivery. Just think about it as, like, we will eventually be the owner. You're welcome to send me questions, and if I can answer them, I will, and if not, I can always shepherd them to the appropriate party to get them. Okay, so is Dustin, are you central?
1:04:26 Federal Public Lands? Okay. So that's good to know. And then for the communication side, who is the lead on the communications program? And Fred, I'm assuming perhaps it's Lisa, but then we are looking between Mammoth Lake tourism, the Mammoth Lake trail system, the town, all the various communication channels, that the message will come from Lisa, but we've got to have all these other different channels that are going to be getting the word out. Is that fair to say?
1:04:56 Lisa will roll out the communication plan. And it's not just we need input from you guys, all the stakeholders. Of course, the counties, ESTA, the town are kind of like the key stakeholders. And then after we develop that final communication plans with the close stakeholders, then we roll it out to the other more periphery stakeholders. Okay. Lisa, is she permanent or she's? She is permanent, yes. She's permanent now.
1:05:24 So she's not going anywhere. She's not going to go into detail or anything, right? Okay. That's good to know. And I think, I guess my final question, Dustin, do these, I'm assuming these folks in Minden, Nevada are familiar with snow. I was looking at some posts today from folks looking at Yosemite National Park in July, late July of 2017, and there was still three feet of snow on the ground.
1:05:52 So I don't know how this works with the contract. I don't know if this would be considered a force majeure or something like that. But I think the idea of anybody getting anywhere near the project site by the middle of May, I don't want to use the adjectives that are going in my mind right now. But those of us who've seen Caltrans up there plowing the road from the main lodge, I mean, it's a serious operation. I hope that there are contingencies in the contract, in the agreement.
1:06:21 They're going to allow for this. Because I just, it seems, I'll use the word laughable at this point, to be able to think that anybody's going to do any meaningful work on this project until July, August? I just, it's an editorial comment, but I just, I throw that out there. Well, and I'll just, I will add, and yeah, we are aware. We knew the May 15th date would be in a situation where, you know,
1:06:51 It was a special year in that there was very little snow. We figured, you know, June would be kind of typical. And then, you know, July in extreme cases. So the contractor would definitely be aware of this. In fact, they've worked on several of our Yosemite projects. In addition, you know, the way that we have handled this in the contract, I'll just say that there are methods to handle this.
1:07:17 That's fine. We work in a lot of mountainous regions and we encounter this sort of thing often. And I will add to Fred on the communications. So everybody's aware, you know, the contractor will be holding weekly meetings. We will have, you know, the forest, the town, the park service, everybody will be
1:07:47 And so I would go back and look at your contracts, look at your agreements and I would just.
1:08:16 Again, I'm just a layperson here, but I would really encourage you to start looking at those things because these will be exceptional circumstances. And I think even trying to get this thing done in a two-year term, I don't know. Again, but just a friendly, perhaps piece of advice from a small-town elected official. Is that the time frame? Two summers? It's a two-summer time frame. And if you're going to lose one summer or 50% or more of one summer,
1:08:46 I don't know, just go look at your fine print and talk with your council and make sure that everybody's going to be able to figure out how to do this. But with that being said, any other comments or questions? Public comments? Yeah, please. Claylin Hoff, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, this is a thank you to all. This is a project very close to my heart since I've been driving that road for
1:09:18 You guys are so wrong on every point of this. I know where you're going. It was going to be a two-year plan. I am very concerned right now because I don't think that anyone on town council has an idea of what that road is about and the amount of traffic that we're taking down there. We could have gotten another year.
1:09:48 I'm just scared that you guys have not looked at this project and really driven the road and seeing what needs to be done. What
1:10:17 And now there's a new person. I don't even know this face. But we have to look back in the last couple of years and go, oh, okay, who's been working on this? Who has been taking care of this? Who is making this happen? And it hasn't been. When this was put before town council, when I was on town council.
1:10:43 We were not even given the correct information to vote on. It was something that was kind of just put out to us like, well, you have A, B, and C, this being the best account, B being, you know, the next best C being. And I'm pretty upset with what everyone has gone with. And you bring up Andara County.
1:11:13 Madera County is not looped in on this whatsoever. This is Forest Service land with Town of Mammoth Lakes tarmac put on top of it. And then we're going to have whatever entity looking after this. I am putting it out to you right now, everyone. Amanda, I see you. John.
1:11:42 You know better than anyone. Bill, I know where your thoughts are. And then the other gal, I don't know where your thoughts are. But I'm just telling you right now, this is a bigger thing than you guys are accepting right now. This is something that is getting access to lands that people need access to. And.
1:12:08 If you want any more clarification, I have worked down there in Red's Meadow for the last two years in the summertime, and I know what type of, I can give you pictures of the multitude of people that are having to try to just get to our lovely lands. You guys need to update yourselves on this situation. This is not cool.
1:12:38 And so thank you for listening to me, but this is one subject that if as a town council, you are not going to educate yourselves and talk to the main person, Bobby Tanner, down at Red's Meadow, then you are not looking into what is going on down there. Excellent. Thank you very much, Cleland.
1:13:11 Any additional public comment? Okay. Well, thank you all. Best of luck. I think everybody's going to need it. And we will look forward, Hais, I guess, to coordinating updates. As soon as we get into the season, I would imagine once the contractor gets a sense of the expense and the logistical complexity, you'd be surprised if we get an update saying there may be a little bit of a change in plan. But we look forward to that. So thank you, Fred. And thank you from the Park Service for being here. We really appreciate it. Thank you.
1:13:43 Okay, so we'll move on then. And now we're going to talk about, this is item 7.2, a quarterly presentation by airport core management team for the winter of 2020. Thank you, Mayor. One of the things that I did want to say with my update, and apparently skipped that line in my notes, was that Sabine Spring, who's working as our airport operations manager right now is temporary replacement, was supposed to be here tonight to work with us on this presentation, but she is...
1:14:19 Busy trying to get the airport open for the flights in the morning. Our goal is to have advanced air flights, which I believe arrived about 824, 830, to be able to land and offload passengers and take new out. So she's down there working hard to get that completed. So finish that process. Let me share my screen real quickly. And I'll just introduce myself in the meantime. I'm a Sierra Schultz. I'm the deputy airport manager down at the airport.
1:14:54 And, yeah, they've been working very hard. So, that was our priority. Go work on that. And, you know, I'll be covering the presentation with Rob tonight. Thank you. Okay. What's your money shot right there? There's a lot of money shots that are available from the airport. Yeah, you guys should see my phone. That was, I think, January. So, yeah, no shortage of content. Yep. Just a brief reminder.
1:15:23 You know, we've kind of been doing this for about a year now, and our goal with these quarterly presentations is really we focus on the operational activities that occur at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. We talk about sort of a seasonal approach to the activities out there, and it's really to make sure that both the town, government, and community understand, you know, what goes on at the airport and what are the more challenging aspects of performing out there and just how we go about doing that business.
1:15:52 We have a core management team, which is comprised of myself, who just really provides oversight and sort of executive director level work, work with outside agencies and others. And then we've got Sierra Schultz, as you just introduced herself, deputy airport manager and really, you know, working her way up to airport manager through a process. You know, we decided when we had a vacancy in that role to build from within for that particular
1:16:20 Position, and so a great candidate, worked very hard on a lot of projects out at the airport, and very diligent worker, and ready to go. We had Vince Maniachi, as I talked about a couple of meetings ago. He departed in late January, and right now we have an interim replacement of Sabine Spring.
1:16:42 And we are working to solidify that job description a little bit and figure out a little bit of an internal recruitment. And Sabine will definitely be first in line for something along those lines. So that's our core team, really operations, more administrative, and then executive oversight. Rob kind of touched on these quarterly presentations. So really, we just want to be able to connect with our council and the public.
1:17:13 So this is essentially what the ARF and Snow Removal Equipment Building looks like.
1:17:45 The ARF is the aircraft rescue and firefighting vehicle that we have down at the airport. So this project's been in the works for a few years. We spent years doing environmental documents and everything leading up to this point. There are seven bays, five of which hold snow removal equipment, and then two are dedicated to the ARF, one to park it and then one to do maintenance on the ARF. On kind of that western portion.
1:18:13 That looks a little bit more unique than the rest of it. That also includes our support rooms, such as a watch room up top to kind of look out over the airfield, keep an eye on safety items. And then there's an office for us to be able to badge people who are badged at the airport, which we currently don't have access from the non-secure area. So if someone needs to get their badge, we have to escort them in to come get a new badge. So they'll have better access.
1:18:41 There's other rooms. There's offices in there as well and a kitchen and a few. So this project was approved by PEDC on January 10th. So shortly after we kind of wrapped up our plans and we went out to bid on February 10th. So currently our bid opening is March 9th, so next Thursday, but we are going to push that two weeks to the 23rd by request of potential bidders.
1:19:08 We want to make sure we get as many bidders as possible, so we're willing to accommodate that as much as we can. So I did want to also mention on this project that on kind of that southern lower portion over the five bays, we intended for that to be prepped for future solar, so the building codes do call for being solar ready.
1:19:35 So that was always intended, but we did add an alternate to the project that won't affect the low bidder, but it is for solar to be on the roof. So if we, depending where number's coming at, if we're able to fund that, we're looking to put solar on the building right away. And my last point on this is that we originally had, we were requesting about $6.1 million from the FAA.
1:20:03 And that was kind of just a placeholder in our airport capital improvement program for years. And then once we really dug into design and accounted for inflation over the last few years, we were looking at about $8.4 million in our request to the FAA in our November pre-applications. So I did talk with the FAA in January, and it looks like they were able to find the additional funding. So nothing is really set in stone until we have a signed grant, and there's plenty of people.
1:20:33 Who would like that money rather than us, but they have fought for us really hard and will likely be able to provide the full $8.4 million. And there will be a town match on this project of about $1 million, and that includes the sponsor match of $850,000 about, and then an additional $150,000 for the 7th Bay, which was not FAA eligible. Are those numbers budgeted somewhere?
1:21:02 We have $1.3 million in our capital improvement fund for the airport, so it would be coming out of that. Okay, so it's on the ledger, it's a counter for anticipated. Okay, thank you. And as far as the timing of which, you know, we'll know for certain the grant amount. Yeah, so once we open bids, that's when we'll work on doing our final application. So all of our bids, which we have a couple other projects going on at the airport as well.
1:21:31 I did not include in this presentation, but I'm always happy to talk about them. We have to have bids open by May 1st and final applications into the FAA shortly after. So we'll know the final numbers on this in a few weeks, about three weeks, and move into final applications. And the FAA sounds like we'll be hearing back on our grant July 20th, probably. They do have a release date in June, but given our timing of bidding and whatnot, we're likely going to hear back in July.
1:21:59 And then hopefully award early August. Good. Yeah, and maybe break ground this season. It really just depends. There is about 16 weeks allotted for submittals, and it's a pre-engineered building, so there is a pretty long time frame of the contractor providing those deferred submittals to the building department and going through that. So we'll see if we're able to break ground this year or not. Good. Thank you.
1:22:30 Oh, these next few slides, they're really just talking about our winter snow removal operations. We do not do overnight snow removal, so we're typically operating between 7 a.m. and 4.30 p.m. Times like this where it's excessive, you know, they are snowshoeing out there to get to our equipment at more like 5.30, 6 a.m. and pushing through for flights probably, you know, 13-hour days.
1:22:58 So, but that's not standard. We're typically operating more in between these times. We get a lot of calls. I've had a ton of calls already today about status of the airport when we're opening, and the best way to track that is really to go on the NOTAM website. So, you can just, the website's listed here, but you can just Google NOTAMs and just put in MMH for our airport, and you can always see kind of current status.
1:23:25 I also put our town website up here, which you can go to that, and there's webcams, there's the NOTAM page link, and some other helpful information. A lot of that to do, and I don't know if you have a slide on staffing or not, we don't have as large a staff to go 24-7 or the need to staff that up. I mean, talk about the expenditures at the airport, the bulk of that is staffing. And so we maintain what we need to have seven-day-a-week coverage for flights.
1:23:57 And then we augment up in the wintertime with part-time individuals for helping snow removal. But we don't have a crew large enough to do the 12-hour shifts like you see here. Yeah, it often wouldn't be needed. Right now we're a little short-staffed, so they're working extra hard. So just actually real quickly, just going back to this slide, I did just want to mention
1:24:26 For any pilots or anyone looking for information, those are just our Unicom frequencies and AWOS frequencies listed. So the AWOS is the automated weather observation system. So that gives pretty detailed feedback on the current status of the weather. And then the Unicom is what pilots and people would call into Mammoth traffic to correspond back and forth.
1:24:50 We also have our airport number, and a lot of people have my number as well, and they can always call and kind of get a visual status on what's going out there, and Hot Creek Aviation is very helpful with constantly talking with pilots and giving on-the-ground feedback. So before the storm, really leading up to storms, we do a lot of prep work of just paying attention to the weather forecast, kind of seeing where things are going. Our staff...
1:25:25 It's in constant communication. We're often texting at night or early morning, kind of what time we're going to be able to get out there, who's doing what, and scheduling ahead of time and just making sure we're ready to respond in a timely fashion. Basically, there's a few factors that can determine really how quickly we're able to respond. There is a lot of asphalt out there. It might seem like it's, you know.
1:25:59 Could be cleared quickly, but it does take a while, so it really depends, you know, storm duration and forecast, the snow amount and type of snow predicted, how heavy it is, what time of season it is, and the warmth in the air and solar factors, snowfall timing, like time of day, is it falling really late at night when no one's out there clearing, or is it mostly during the day where we're keeping up on it, or having to come in just the next morning to find it.
1:26:27 Staff and equipment availability. Even this morning we had quite a morning with flat tires and wires breaking on our blower and the blower was stuck and we were even out there for about two hours shoveling just to get in on airport road. So it started a little rough but it's ending well and I think we'll make flights tomorrow.
1:26:50 Airport Road is also a big item. Our staff has been working more closely with the county lately, just discussing if they need backup, if they need help, because we do have an MOU that gives us the right to go out there if needed and under emergency circumstances, but it's not on our priority list of things that we would address prior to an airfield, so there's no expectation that we're doing that, so we've just been trying to work a little more closely with them.
1:27:18 Get our priorities in line and see if they need help and then, you know, see how we can help get access out there. Just to be clear, the road going to the airport is a county road maintained by the county. Okay. So this morning, a good example of that, the county called, I think, was working with Sabine the day before and indicated with the broken down equipment, as Hayes showed in his slides, they did not have the ability to clear the airport road. So after they snowshoed in.
1:27:46 Grabbed a piece of equipment and cleared the road to get the rest of the crew in. So that encountered a few problems. I mean, when you take a piece of equipment off of its normal general area, you do end up with challenges, especially if you're going to somewhere new. And so you can get stuck in some interesting areas. There's cattle guards to worry about and other things that you don't typically come across. So it's a bit of a challenge, but good coordination. Yeah. So these are the priority areas. So these are FAA mandated areas.
1:28:16 At the bottom there you can see the advisory circular number that dictates what the FAA priorities are. But our top priority is really the runway, doing the full length and width of the runway. Then taxiway A, which parallels the runway. And three of the connectors. The other two connectors between the taxiway and the runway are a second priority. The other first priorities are
1:28:44 The north commercial ramp, so this is right adjacent to the terminal, and the east GA ramp, which is just south of the FBO building, which is where we park, where Hot Creek parks the general aviation. And then also the emergency access road, so coming off of 395, we do have a gate and a little access road that connects to the runway as a secondary access.
1:29:10 Priority two is the south commercial ramp, which is just farther south of the terminal building, and the other two taxiway connectors, and the west GA ramp, which is farther to the west than the east, so it's a little bit closer to all of the hangars and not as close to the FBO building. And then priority three are the hangars.
1:29:35 So those are in our snow plan. And here is a map on the next. And I'll talk about this really quick, too. This is one of the challenges that we had this year. You know, we've got a lot of people that utilize the airport. They have hangers. They're hangar owners. They want access to those fairly frequently. And as you kind of saw here, that's priority three for operating an airport and getting the snow removal completed. While they are patrons of the airport and very, very important to us,
1:30:05 We are required by this FAA plan to start in this process. And so while snow removal is done all over our region and fairly knowledgeable people about snow removal have good ideas, at the end of the day, a 14-page or 15-page plan approved by the FAA is what we have to follow. So at the end of the day, it provided a little bit of frustration, I think, this year, but the crew is doing exactly what they're supposed to do.
1:30:32 And I think some time and some impacts on equipment and folks, you know, may have delayed access to hangers that caused a bit of consternation. I know some council members did hear from patrons out of the airport. Yeah, and I think sometimes it can look clear, like they see a strip down the runway and it's like, oh, it mostly looks clear. But that doesn't mean that the shoulders are, you know, within...
1:30:56 That we're not able to land aircraft because of how big the shoulders are. We need to cut them back or blow them back farther before we can open up the airport. So sometimes it melts out quickly. Once it's clear, you know, it does get pretty warm down there. So it'll look like clear asphalt, but that really doesn't mean it's ready to go and we can just open the airport. Yeah, so this is just kind of a map showing those areas. So you can see kind of the priority ones. It's really the ramp by the FBO building in the terminal.
1:31:27 The taxiway, and the runway. And then priority two are the other ramp areas and the extra connectors. So resources that we have out there at the airport right now, and these are, I believe all of these, maybe most of them are, did receive FAA funding for these, so they are airport equipment. So we have three 966 loaders, a Peterbilt snowplow truck.
1:31:57 And then two blowers and a loader and a tool, or two loaders and a tool. We do coordinate very well with the vehicle replacement program is if we have some either backup equipment or equipment that we're replacing in the town, we are able to take it down to the airport and provide that. There's not the same vehicle replacement program down there because as Sierra indicated, a lot of these are grant funded. So we have a very small vehicle replacement program and these are not really a part of that. So they get a lot of...
1:32:27 Hand-Me-Down Equipment, but for their purposes it works quite well. And I did mention earlier the ARF building, there was the seventh bay that was not FAA eligible. They are very strict on what they are willing. They will only pay for building covering equipment that is eligible for funding as well and is used for top priority. So we have a whole report of assessments on how much equipment is needed to clear a certain amount.
1:32:56 And they basically say, well, it takes this much equipment, so we'll pay to cover those, even though the other pieces of equipment were paid for by the FAA, they're not the top priority, so they're not eligible. So it's an interesting, very kind of black and white when it comes to their roles. So this is just a little bit more about our NOTAMs. Really, yeah, before you fly, of course, check the weather and...
1:33:28 We get calls constantly of people seeing when they're able to come in. We have our NOTAM link. Sorry, bear with me for a moment since I wasn't going to cover this one. I need to remind myself what's in it. But this is really just restating the UNICOM frequencies and the time of operations. And really a NOTAM is basically pilots can see this information from their flight information.
1:33:57 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:34:26 So I wanted to include here, even though we talked really about operations for the primary focus, is a little bit about the passenger activity year over year for Mammoth. As you know, we've pushed really hard this year on a number of fronts to work early on with MLT and Advanced Air to set some good pricing for our fares and to try to be more competitive this year, to come up with promotional activities such as 10-packs.
1:34:55 They've been very, very successful. We also stood up the terminal building for customer experience and worked with local businesses to be present on the flight in order to immerse our passengers in the Mammoth experience as soon as they get on the plane. We are trying to put pulling out of the stops this year, if you will, to get really people hooked on utilization of the flight. And we've been very, very successful this year. This number, I just got updated numbers today. We're up to 6,006.
1:35:24 Booked flights for the year. And we're seeing, you know, an 83% increase in December activity. Very strong. It was a little bit of November, but that's really not that much to talk about, just a few days. In January as well, you know, up almost 60%. These are really, really good numbers. When we talk about air subsidies and the cost of those, you're always seeking somewhere in the low 70% load factors in order to make a flight worthwhile to the operator.
1:35:53 The highest load factor we saw this year was Carroll's bat at 77.1%. That's much, much higher than we'd ever achieved last year. So I think all in all, all those efforts have been a very strong win. We've seen similar activity down in Bishop. They had a little stronger year last year than we did, so their increases are not quite as much. But their numbers up through today are at 16,000 flights for the winter.
1:36:21 And they were seeking that for the entire year last year, trying to get about 10,000. So it's been a very strong year. I think everybody, second year in, people are really going to take advantage of this. I just have a quick question, excuse me, about December. Last year, December, was that when we were, like, shut down for the month for COVID things? Or was that the December before? That would have been before, yeah. This was all post-COVID. Okay, I just couldn't remember.
1:36:51 I just remember there was one December where essentially the whole town had to shut down, and so I wasn't sure if that was compared to that year or the year before. Commercial flights came into Mammoth in 2020 was the last full year where they were in the town, and then when the pandemic hit, there were no commercial flights, and so this would have been December of 2021, would have been what our comparisons are, and that's when we stood up both.
1:37:21 Mammoth Assembly with Advanced, and then Bishop was first year of operations as well. That concludes our presentation. Are there any other questions? Any questions for staff on this? No, the terminal building looks great. They gave me a tour of it not long ago. They've done a great job down there. And it's not a question, but just a, I believe this year we have bettered the number of people coming out of, I think, Hawthorne.
1:37:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:38:17 You know, projection of where you think we'll end up this year? You said we're like at 6,000 flights out of 12,000, but that's actually booked. Where do you think we'll end up? Yeah, so we have, we typically see bookings start to decline as, you know, we get a little deeper into the winter season, if you will. We have flights going through the first week of April, and so I would expect those flights to be fairly robust based on the activity that we see. So I think...
1:38:45 My goal is to finish somewhere around 7,500 to 8,000 flights, which is very, very strong. That's over-performing expectation of all of the experts that were basically trying to tamp me down a little bit on getting to that 10,000 in planements, but no, I think we'll be close to 8,000. One quick question. So then, as far as airport subsidies, what load factor?
1:39:15 Do those taper off, right? You know, like if we're getting 8,000 out of 12,000 seats filled, do you know those numbers? It's really difficult to lay down. The world of air subsidies is fairly complex. What you do is you negotiate the cap on what you're willing to spend, and then they'll work through the cost of operations as well as the load factors. So there's a number of things that go into it.
1:39:42 The final numbers aren't really known until the end of the year. All we established in the beginning is the maximum amount that we would be willing to spend, and then we'll go through the process of determining the actual cost of operations, which, to give you a good example, this time last year when the war broke out and the cost of fuel was quite a bit higher, so all the calculations and all those types of things sort of...
1:40:05 So it's a very fluid calculation, if you will. It's not something we can say, here's a specific number we need to hit, and then we're clear, and no more subsidy is necessary. That's pretty hard to get to. Rob, if I'm correct here, it is not based on load factor, although originally that's how it was presented. It is based on cost of flight plus a certain percentage profit. So when we lower rates to increase percentages,
1:40:34 That doesn't necessarily equate to less subsidy because we have more people coming. That is true, Bill. When they were talking recently about the increases in flight activity, they did note that there was a 14% decline in revenue per passenger this year because of those efforts, and so that's a good point you make. It is a financial equation more than...
1:41:02 There's simply a load factor, but that's sort of usually the yardstick for success or not. Right, but I think that the larger question is at what point do these routes become profitable, and at what point is the town and the council looking at it from a budget perspective, are we going to continue to subsidize this? Because that's, you're not subsidizing internally unless you make a informed decision to do that. The idea is to subsidize, you know,
1:41:33 Get the thing going and then get it to be profitable and then it works. So I think at some point we'll need to have that discussion at some point, but I know that things are getting going. It looks like good progress is being made. Yeah, and from our world, too, and John, as we talk about the MIWAG and different areas where we spend a whole lot more time talking about air service and activities is that from our perspective, we're trying to get to a point where we'll get maybe 10,000 in planements. That means about a million dollars a year.
1:42:02 Capital investment from FAA in our airport, and that's helpful to us. What I would look at in an air subsidy concept is once we get these routes established and profitable is where can we expand air service to get up to the point where we have maybe 16,000 available flights and we've got that 10,000 in the back. Yeah, I think the council will be very interested in understanding when this initial route gets to be profitable. I mean, let's go one step at a time. Let's get something that works.
1:42:31 And then we have to have that conversation. Then we can get into the subsequent conversation. You brought up the issue on the Miwag. And Dan, I know that the ESCOG has established and made their appointees now to the Miwag. We need to be having this regional conversation. And I'm assuming that some combination of you and staff and Dan or whoever is going to be at that representing Mammoth as part of that. Do we have that correct? Yeah, that's correct. That's a coordination with Inyo County staff.
1:43:02 Okay, good. So we need to, and those conversations will be coming up soon. Those conversations go back to the TBID, the issue of the subsidy coming out of the TBID for the service in Bishop. A lot of moving parts here, and I know we all are aware that we have to bring all these things together and make good decisions about this stuff. So, is there any public comment out there, Jamie? Not. Okay, any last questions, thoughts? Everybody's happy? Good. Thank you both very much. Thank you, Sarah. Thank you, Rob. Yep.
1:43:33 Okay, so we'll move on then to the quarterly TOT enforcement update, second quarter fiscal year 2223. Rob, that sounds like you. Yeah, sorry, I do apologize this evening. You're going to get a lot of time with Rob. But let me grab the changing gears here just briefly. I tried to get my staff to come in and give this second presentation, but no takers. Okay, so...
1:44:21 Our quarterly presentation on TOT enforcement is really to keep council informed of the activities that the enforcement team is conducting for the TOT collections and trends that we're seeing, activities that we were able to accomplish, and just kind of keep you guys abreast with the activity of the team.
1:44:46 It's been a while since we talked. I think our last update was in August of last year, so we did cover one and two in this particular one. So to that end, I kind of asked staff to do a bit more of a narrative in hopes that you read this in advance and maybe have some questions about that. I'll talk briefly about them, but I'm not going to read them essentially to us. The first bullet point is essentially the increased activity that we see whenever we have larger snow years.
1:45:16 The opportunity to rent becomes much more lucrative, and therefore we end up with more zoning operators that come into play. They typically don't get as involved as other revenue folks, but it's all about the availability and just how hyped up the snow year is. So that's what we're kind of seeing this year is a little bit more increase in that particular area.
1:45:45 We do see a decrease in revenue violators, which I'll clarify the difference between the two. A zoning violator is one in which they're in a zone in town where they're not allowed to rent. But a revenue violator is one who's in a zone that's allowed to rent. They just haven't gone through the process to get the legal rental activity and they're not remitting to us taxes. We've seen a sharp decline in this and we think it has to do a lot with the education and outreach programs that we're doing.
1:46:11 There's a lot of airplay we get for either activity on some of our enforcement cases or the did you know that we put in the newspaper and those types of things where we believe education is a big process of preventing illegal activity. So just really think that that's a benefit is to have the education that we're providing and we're glad to see that decline in the number of revenue violators.
1:46:41 With regard to Rentalscape, they're really getting out in front of capturing the data and providing that for us. We had a unique experience recently where I think it was a doctor from Southern California created his own website and it was really out of any monitoring systems anywhere and something that Rentalscape was able to find. They ferreted it out and this particular...
1:47:09 The individual we started contacting him regarding the activity, he was quite shocked that we were able to find it because it was something that was much underground, but it just goes to the strength of the development of Rentalscape and really how strong their technical systems are to figure that out. One of the big challenges that we have
1:47:33 Is higher than average number of operators who start doing business and then they decide to tail off and not remit. So if you are an active or if you're any business tax certificate holder, you are required to remit to the town on a monthly basis, even if it's zero. You need to tell us what you did or just confirm that you're still in business. And when someone stops doing that, we have to assume that they're deciding to no longer conduct business.
1:48:02 There's about a three-month process we go through by which we send them notifications. It's kind of a laborious effort on our part to make sure that they're deciding to go out of business or are they just falling off the wagon and maybe disappearing. But after three months of communicating with them, we actually close their account. So at that point, someone can become an enforcement case if they were in fact continuing to rent without remitting to us.
1:48:29 And continuing. And I'll talk a little bit later about trends that we're seeing. But many, I'd say about 40% of our enforcement cases for revenue involve people who were once legal and fell off that process. We talked a little bit about it. They wanted to kind of remind the folks about one of our final things in an enforcement case is a lien on the property. This is if someone has not fallen through with the process. Most of our enforcement cases will pay up.
1:49:03 They will basically get a notice of determination of exactly what is owed. They will make a payment to us or make a payment plan over six months to a year to repay that. But if someone chooses not to do that, we will lien the property. So we file it with Mono County. And I guess we had one just recently. It was filed back in 2013 that we just collected on. So it is an effective tool. It is, I will call, almost our most important weapon or our most final weapon that we have. We'll talk a little bit about.
1:49:33 Nuisance lawsuits here shortly, but those liens are an important function for our team. As is utilization of a settlement agreement, we have people who it's often considered the cost of doing business if they are unable to rent in their particular zone. It's just the cost of doing business to pay us the fines and the fees when they're caught.
1:49:58 One of the things that we decided to put together was a settlement agreement that clarified the conditions by which we'll end this enforcement case, the things that they need to follow through on, and they frankly give a little bit more teeth and a little bit more pain to a reoccurrence of the enforcement activity. And so the settlement agreements have been very effective. As indicated on the footnote here, we have not had one who's become a repeat offender from
1:50:28 From an enforcement activity. So that's a good process. And Andy Morris helped us work through developing that program. And we've utilized it quite extensively. But the other thing I wanted to talk about is audit candidates. You know, we have people that stop communicating with us, and they go through the three-month process I described above. And then we have folks that call us up and say, hey, you know what? I decided I no longer want to have a business. I'm going to stop renting my property.
1:50:58 We've recently noticed, as we've gone back through the hundred or so who have canceled their BTCs, that there's a lot of enforcement cases in there. A lot of people have decided to close their business, but yet are going back in. So we're now going through every single business that's closed over the last three years. We're monitoring all online activity, looking for rental activity, looking for reviews and other things like that. We've had a number of enforcement cases associated with that.
1:51:27 And it's kind of a growing trend. We do a lot of trend analysis on what we see within the activity. This is a standard chart where we kind of show the activity with the number of cases open. I'm just going to talk about the numbers on the right-hand side, which is for the cumulative two quarter period. We had 36 cases for that period of time. We issued 51 citations.
1:51:55 And collected about $163,250 in violations in other activities. So it's a pretty lucrative program. It certainly pays for itself. The benefit of transient occupancy tax enforcement is to gain the trust and understanding from the existing operators and the ones that are operating legally that we have their back and we are trying to level the playing field for
1:52:23 Everyone is operating within the same parameters for short-term rentals, and if someone decides to do it illegally, it's going to be very painful and very costly. So that's the activity report on that. I'll talk a little bit about the current focus. I mentioned briefly this nuisance lawsuits. This is effectively turning the tides a little bit on the operator themselves and
1:52:51 While we go out in enforcement cases, we typically just follow a process by which we identify the activity that was conducted and require them to pay that. In some cases, they don't give us their activity, so we do what's called an assessment where we provide them a planned out algorithm for determining the value of that. But this third component here is where we actually open a lawsuit against them as a nuisance.
1:53:20 Andrew Morris, our attorney, had been very successful with this in Truckee and brought it down to us. We employed this tactic on one very stubborn and challenging case that we had, and it worked great. It's basically our attorney reaches out to them and says, you know, you're being sued for the activity, illegal activity within the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:53:44 And then typically there's a lawyer that gets involved in there, and it's a pretty short and simple conversation. We do have an outside agency that we utilize for this, so it does cost us a little bit, but we are able to add some of the fees and costs, at least for enforcement activity, into the settlement agreement and the final determination on that.
1:54:10 We continue to monitor the remittance trends and recognize operators who are reporting revenues inaccurately. I talked about the trend analysis. There is a very consistent and sort of identifiable set of traits that people utilize, and what we do from that is we'll turn that into a spot audit. We'll do a spot audit of about three months of activity. If there's anything that raises our concern in that spot audit, we will turn it into a full three-year audit, which is the extent of which we can go back.
1:54:39 But it is fairly consistent, the ways you can sort of cheat the system and the things that are identified. And so the team's been very good at working on that. We've also been working with Deckard on our certified properties program. You know, I've talked about, I thought that was sort of an off-the-shelf program that they had, and we were employing that to really improve our communication with the owners of the property.
1:55:07 Right now our connection is directly with the operator who is the business tax certificate holder, and an operator may be a rental agency, so they may not actually be the ultimate responsible party. So with the certified properties, we actually will develop a relationship with the owner of the property and their rental agency. That helps us in a number of ways if there are problems at the facility, if there are quality of life issues with their rental activity.
1:55:33 We have direct contact with the owner and can actually park them for a bit of time and say you are no longer able to perform rentals. And so I think that's a very good process. Now, Deckard has been working, we've been working with them for about six months on this. We wanted to launch it earlier than we have. We'll probably be closer to summertime when we're ready to launch that program.
1:55:54 And finally, we have a program where
1:56:20 You know, homeowners associations do reach out to us from time to time and they want my staff or myself to attend their annual meetings and provide them with an update on the activity that we do for particularly if they're having challenges with short-term rentals in their particular area or if
1:56:40 They really want to understand the process a little bit more by how complaints are handled in process. So we make ourselves available to these HOAs. We've had a number of them that we've gone out and visited. I've done that personally. And we'll continue that process. I think it's helpful the more information and education that we get out there. So that's all for my current focus update. I do have a number of questions, and we get this often about data around the activity and conversions and so forth.
1:57:07 We are working to compile. We started, I believe it was in June of 2020, we started collecting the data on every property that comes in, exactly what occurs with that property, what its previous disposition was, was it a short-term rental, long-term rental, is it transitioning? So we've collected that data, we're pulling it together, and Dan asked me to augment that a little bit and provide more detail.
1:57:34 We're also working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. They recently acquired, it's called AirDNA, and it's a series of analysis that goes back to 2014. It looks at a number of properties. It has a breakdown for those properties. It has a breakdown for the average daily rate, even the rental activity. So we're diving through that detailed information to try to get more reportable functions.
1:58:02 Community and Economic Development is also working on, you know, a matching of TOT certs to sales. And so they're really doing their own wholly different area of analysis. It's kind of an all-hands-on-deck approach to providing information to you on just the activity that's out there and maybe the changing trends in the SDR. Thank you very much. So questions for Rob. I have a question. Yeah, go ahead. Is there a spot where...
1:58:29 Everyday people can look up and see if a rental is appropriately zoned, like a rental next door, if it's appropriately zoned and if they have a business permit. That is a part of our certified property portal that we will be launching and there'll be a customer facing area where you can go in, look at a map and actually call it up and see information about it, who to contact and whether it's illegal or not.
1:58:57 If that does, if that's not there, then that would be one to call into the hotline and say, hey, this is occurring at this particular address. Can you guys check that out? But yes, that will be a part of the certified property. So that will be coming? That will be coming. Okay. Well, Council Member Rice, that ability is already there, at least for the zoning question.
1:59:17 Members of the public can look at the town's zoning map, figure out what zone the property question is in, and can figure out whether that's an area where short-term rentals are even allowed in the first place. They're not allowed in single-family zones. They are allowed in resort. They're allowed in, Sandra, I think it's RMF2, not RMF1, or maybe it's the other way around. But there's not one easy page where you can find that. But if you're willing to look at the zoning map, you can figure it out. But we also, we went back.
1:59:47 I think it was last summer and presented to council what that really looks like. We looked at the city of Scottsdale, Arizona, and they have a map of their city and they have every legal renter as a bullet point on that map. And that's exactly what ours will be. So you'll be able to look at the town of Mammoth Lakes and see all of the legal. Do you know when that will be up? We're targeting probably May timeframe. It's really dependent upon the activity here. I think we had a protocol of that out there.
2:00:15 And it may be because we're working with Mono County GIS on that activity. They're taking the GIS file and loading it into our map. But I would say probably by late spring. Okay. And then I do know I did find a website that I don't know if it's related to the county or the town, but you can put in an address and it will tell you if it's zoned for nightly rentals or not. I don't know, a parcel. Parcel viewer. Parcel viewer for Mono County. Correct.
2:00:40 So people could see if it's zoned correctly, but they can't, at this point, they can't see if someone has a business license. That's correct. And that, basically, what our portal, it pulls some of that data out of Parcel Viewer. It pulls some of the data out of the issued BTC and the TOT cert. And now, in this case, the certified property, that's where it gets a little bit tighter. And it just, we know the specific location, and it allows us to put that on the map. But then links to the business tax certificate.
2:01:09 The operator, all that contact information would also be available to them. Great. And then I have one other question. For, like I saw the nuisance lawsuits on there. Yes. For units that are having like over occupancy problems, are there other, like what are the steps taken if someone's complained about over occupancy in certain units? Yeah, so we recently had a fairly significant one that occurred in Snow Creek.
2:01:41 You know, we'll research exactly what we see going on. We'll talk to all the people involved. I think it was someone who came into the council, in fact. What we did with that is we actually reached out to the operator and brought them in, had a direct conversation about what we were seeing out there. They, in this particular case, it was a regional agency. They had an entirely different process by which they would rent this particular unit.
2:02:08 It's really communicating with our team. We've got a number of different functions that work for this, and each situation is unique, so we'd have to reach out to that. But that particular one, a very responsive operator, they changed the rental process. They actually took it off of Airbnb so it was only on their site so they could control everybody who was coming through because it was a particularly problematic one. I think it was associated with some ski clubs down south, and they were...
2:02:36 Selling spots, maybe a spot on the floor, if you will. Thank you. Questions? Oh, good? Okay. So, a couple things. I have to share that I think that over a couple councils, I think we're starting to kind of run out of patience on this data thing. And the things I'm hearing from constituents, it's nice that you're talking to HOA managers.
2:03:10 I'm getting emails and communication from folks saying the HOA managers and the board is in cahoots with people who are renting units legally, probably. They're doing upgrades to their units. They're not getting permits. The quality of life stuff is starting to get extreme. And I think there's a basic thing that we have to recognize, which is Mammoth is a very valuable place to go to.
2:03:37 It's a very desirable place to go to, and it's profitable. If you have a condominium and you can get a legal certificate, you can make a lot of money doing this. And this is starting to put, it's pushing people in our community who've lived their entire lives, some of them, in condominium complexes. They've owned their complex. Now they own their unit. Now the quality of life stuff is getting out of control. And there's no other place for them to go.
2:04:04 They can't go any other place in the county. They're looking at having to leave the region. And I think while the enforcement work has been excellent, the team, your team has done an excellent job. I think councils reinforce that repeatedly. I don't think we've ever given any leniency to anybody coming on appeal in front of the council to, oh yeah, those circumstances are okay. You know, the ward has always stood. But I think there's two things here. One is the quality of life ordinance. We need, that needs to come back.
2:04:31 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:05:01 Because it's profitable. And we're getting to a point where we can't make good policy decisions because we're waiting for this data. We're waiting for these programs. We can't wait anymore. We're losing the community. We're losing people who've lived in these places for their entire lives. They can't do it anymore. And frankly, as I mentioned, a lot of the boards of the HOAs are in on this.
2:05:27 They're seeing these complexes becoming profit centers. So I just, whatever I think we can do to encourage getting that data in a way in front of the council so we can start making policy decisions, we gotta have it. I mean, this has been going on for years, frankly. And, you know, there's been talk about moratoriums and things like that. I've resisted that. I don't think that's a good way to go. We need this information. We've gotta start making decisions because it's...
2:05:56 Mammoth is a valuable place for all kinds of different reasons, but certainly with Airbnb and the preponderance of condominiums we have in this town, these profit centers are exploding, and we've got some real challenges here, so please, whatever we can do to start getting those things in front of us would be helpful. Yeah, Chris. It would be helpful for me if we could be...
2:06:17 A little more clear on what we mean in terms of data because I know I'm asking for things. I think different people are asking for different things. So I think it'd be really helpful when you say data. What specifically do you mean so that I'm sure I'm clear what you're asking? I'm referring back to the Community Housing Action Plan, which was adopted several years ago, which there was a GIS component in there that was going to be able to advise the council on the trends.
2:06:41 Okay, I appreciate that, because yes, so I've been asking for, and I think, you know, we all want to understand, for me, the denominator is, how many,
2:07:11 How many units are even available in town that could either be nightly or long-term rentals? So that's the thing that we've been going back and forth on. So first of all is that denominator. And then how has the application of that changed over time? And what I mean by that is how many units, and people keep saying 2006. It doesn't have to be 2006, but it has to be over a long enough period of time of
2:07:40 How many units were originally able or how many do we know from the business certificate how many have changed from long-term rentals to nightly rentals? And it seems to me like we should be able to get that. But I think that first thing is just the basis of how many units do we even have in town. So I've been talking to realtors about it because they seem to have that. So it seems to me like maybe if we came together with different constituencies,
2:08:11 Then that might be something. However, the problem goes way beyond that. You can't, data alone can't make our decisions for it. We have to look into our own community and we have to ask those questions. A lot of what's happening right now, and very few condos have ever been long-term rentals. Some of the really old complexes that have been held by the same family for generations now can afford to do that. But the condos were built originally as short-term rentals. That's every project in town with, I think, the diamond run at the corner.
2:08:44 So the problem...
2:09:18 However, however.
2:09:58 And I think, Bill, your point is valid. I'm getting a lot of calls from people who say, but it used to be easy for people who lived in town to rent, and now it's hard. And we need some
2:11:10 And I think just trying to get that gap of like, is this true? Have we lost 400 units of housing? And do we have to make that up? And we have the parcel and we have,
2:11:40 You know, small other programs, but, you know, we can't buy our way out of 400 condos. So I really do want to understand what these numbers look like as we try to budget, because otherwise it's just really hard to make decisions because it doesn't feel like it's based in fact. I have a question. Would you all be open to, like, national data on short-term rentals, like Airbnb, or you feel like it has to be?
2:12:10 The numbers in Mammoth compared to how many rentals we had, you know, or like do we take a survey and ask people how many of you have been kicked out of your long-term rental for it to be converted to a short-term? It's got to be local. Every market is idiocy. We have what the number we have in the state. I mean, it's a unique market. And it's knowable. I mean, every single property is in that parcel. It is a knowable thing. And we can know, we know how they're all zoned.
2:12:47 We know what they all are, and we've been asking for it. Going back, I don't know if I want to say, what is the trend? So if I'm renting my condo long-term, I don't even have to get a business license. So there is no way to get the data as to how many long-term rentals there were. To ask for that is to ask staff to put in a lot of hours and spend a lot of our budgetary time on something we can never learn. So if we want to ask staff to start keeping track as best as we can.
2:13:20 I suppose we could pass an ordinance requiring anybody doing long-term rentals to have a business that makes sense to me. But then we can track from today to see what the trend is. But we can't go back to the past, especially on long-term rentals, and say, what did we have? It just isn't there. It's not obtainable. So if I can kind of bring it back a little bit. Yeah, I do appreciate the conversation because it does help me narrow down some of this data request. In all honesty, it's 2006 to now.
2:13:59 I don't know that. I don't have a way of obtaining the data. I understand because of public records. I get it now. But, you know, that's what I'm hearing from people is, you know, that period of time to this period of time. But as long as it's a reasonably long period of time. Yeah, and I mean, it's almost a leading question. Did Airbnb impact our local housing? Airbnb was in 2008. So in that time period, absolutely. But the questions that you guys are talking about with regard to
2:14:31 Transition. What I said back in 2020 is when we started capturing that. So if someone wanted to come in and obtain a business tax certificate, we asked them a whole series of questions. Exactly what was the disposition of this property for the last five years? And, you know, oftentimes they were. But where did it transition from? You know, was it a long-term that was transitioned? We did not see a lot of that activity. There were six in the last time we reported this data. That was a 14-month collection. There were six that converted.
2:15:06 I'm hearing now that some of that data is questionable and whether that was true. We do have a lot of people. There's a lot of activity that changes hands. There's a lot of short-term that go to short-term. There is some things that were previously not a rental of any sort, as Bill was bringing up. It's a family transition. Someone passes away. They obtain ownership. They're now going to do something different. They're deciding to do that to short-term rental for the profitability of it.
2:15:38 Not to go to a long-term, because they still want to utilize the property occasionally for themselves. But what I'm not seeing out of the data that we've been collecting, and I'll say it's close to three years now, is a strong conversion, long-term to short-term. It's there, and there are people that have had some activity occur that has been very impactful, but it's not something that we're seeing a ton of. So that's the frustrating part for me, is this decision is not going to be made, I think.
2:16:10 And I'm collecting as much as I can. Now, the information I heard tonight about the number of units and the number of units that are in the rental program, I can have that for you by tomorrow. That data is out there. So let's have a conversation. Let's agenda something, because you've been asking for it. I've been asking for it. We're all asking for it. And we can work a little bit with Dan to figure out exactly what the most useful way to present that's going to look like. And again, it's about informing.
2:16:39 Policy decisions and informing investment in community housing. And we just need something to do with that. The other thing just to add is the quality of life ordinance and the real concern around building permits and people going to Lancaster, picking up a bunch of plywood, showing up, prettying up a unit. And I'm frankly worried about safety, fire hazard, all that kind of stuff. And that's, again, these are profitable things. These are profitable.
2:17:07 You know, enterprises. So we have options there, too. So we were turned on to Deckard by Mono County Assessor's Office because they were utilizing that to find unpermitted activity, unpermitted building activity. So I'm fairly certain that I can get a list of that activity that goes on, you know, from a partnership with that. So we've got a lot of tools. It's just exactly what you're seeking, we can engage in. But just saying we need data, I struggle with that. Okay, so you guys, you know what's being asked for.
2:17:38 Can I add one more thing? Yeah, go ahead, Amanda, but then we're moving. Yeah, sure. I just, I guess one other thing for data that pops up into my mind that is, you know, somewhat easy to collect is looking at how many businesses are short-staffed. How is that easy to collect? Well, like looking in the sheet. I feel like you look in there and...
2:18:00 You know, everybody's hiring. The town has said they're short-staffed. They'd like to hire people full-time, and there's just not people here. And I think that goes back to there's no housing for these people. So, you know, I feel like that is something to consider. You know, just... I mean, that affects this whole of the issues we're having with snow and Caltrans. Caltrans can't hire drivers. There's no place for anybody to live. Fred can't hire people. Fred's sending emails to me saying, hey, look, man, I got somebody.
2:18:31 Can you house somebody somewhere? That's known. Again, in this town, there used to be apartments built by private investors. But when the cost of building, partly because we are required by the state and others to have certain specifications for our buildings, when the cost of doing any building in Mammoth is $600 a square foot, so to what end, other than creating the parcel and the other things we're doing, how do you get anyone to build?
2:19:05 You can't build a market rate and be profitable. So how do we get that? Getting more data doesn't do me any good. Bring me a plan, somebody, that tells me how I can build apartments at a buck and a quarter a foot, which is what it costs everywhere else in the world to build. And I will be a really happy camper and invest a lot of money in it. Our parcel is, you know, 800 bucks a foot. Can you add this to the list? How do we get building costs down?
2:19:36 How much, what do you want? Yeah. About 25 a foot? Okay. But we will move on now. I think it's a good conversation. Hang on, we're going to move on. Well, I just want to, one thing to what Amanda said, because I thought it was a really good point. The chamber has, you know, if we go to the chamber and a couple other places, we can gather an estimate of what our under stock, under housing stock is for the businesses that are currently operating. I mean, so I do think that was valid.
2:20:06 Good. So let's move on then. Good discussion. And staff, you got some thoughts there. So we're going to move on now to the consent agenda. We're going to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of February 15, 2023, and accept check register 02 for February 15, 2023 in the amount of $318,970.51. Would anybody like to pull anything from the consent agenda? No?
2:20:36 Anybody out there want to pull anything? Okay, I would entertain a motion to approve. I move to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. Thank you. In a second, I need to. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all. Okay, we're going to move on to a public hearing. There's a little bit of a unique public hearing. This has to do with the Transit Community Facilities District CFD number 2013-3, annexation number 7.
2:21:15 And per my specific instructions, this is the time and place for the public hearing for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Community Facilities District, Number 2013-3, Transit Services, Annexation Number 7. The hearing is to inquire into the annexation of property into the district and the levy of special taxes for town-wide transit services within or adjacent to the district. Before I formally open the hearing, are there any property owners or registered voters in the district?
2:21:44 The hearing is now open. We will first have presentations by staff about the annexation of territory to the district. After that, we will receive comments and questions in any oral protest from any interested persons. When all comments have been received, the hearing will be closed.
2:22:22 Who's that, Dan? Are you presenting? Thank you. Yeah, this will be a short presentation on this. You've seen these similar items before. These are really structured for any new transit property that are being developed in particular areas within that district that's been defined in the town. The goal on this was a way to help fund the transit system, which then services the nightly rental properties. A lot of us focus on the village area, for example. There's a number of areas in town.
2:22:52 That the district applies to. So the item before you, we have the two projects coming forward as property owners, the Limelight Hotel and the Residence Inn Hotel in Burns Street. As transient rental properties with the condo complexes and their hotel elements, they are required to annex into the district. So the normal process of this is those property owners and single owners generally will come forward as part of their conditions of approval to be annexed into the district.
2:23:22 There is a formal process to go forward with that voting, if you will, which will be the next item here. So the property owners have done that. They've come forward. We understand we have to comply. The request will be annexed into the district. This is the process it takes to go through that. So with that, unless there's a particular question on the district or the two properties we're looking at, there's a map in the packet. We can proceed with the hearing process and ultimately the voting and action accordingly.
2:23:53 Any questions for Dan on what we're doing here? Okay. Are there any comments, questions, or oral protests from any interested persons? Nope. Nothing virtually, nothing in the room. Okay. So with that, we will close the hearing. And staff makes presentations. Sorry, the hearing is closed. We may now consider and adopt the resolution authorizing the annexation of territory into a community facilities district.
2:24:23 Authorizing the levy of a special tax and submitting the levy of a special tax to qualified electors. Any comments, thoughts from council? Everybody's happy? Okay. So we will consider a motion to adopt. The motion is as follows, and I'll read it. A resolution of the town council, town of Mammoth Lake, state of California, authorizing the annexation of territory into a community facilities district, authorizing the levy of a special tax and submitting the levy.
2:24:52 of special tax to qualified electors. Will the clerk please announce the results of the property owner's vote? Okay, got it. Okay, so then we will, I will then, that's the motion. Is there a second for that motion? Okay, do we have a motion in a second? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser. Yes. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Okay, so will the clerk please announce the results of the property owner vote? Yes, of course you do.
2:25:35 Because they're secret. Both ballots have a yes vote. Okay, thank you. The record shows that at least two-thirds of the property owner votes are in favor of the annexation of territory and levy of the special tax. We may now proceed with the final actions for the annexation of territory to the district. So council will now consider a resolution to adopt a resolution of the town council of the town of Mammoth Lake, state of California, to amend the owner election, determining validity of priorities and directing them. I'll second.
2:26:34 Any additional discussion? Hearing none, Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Moving on then to the final piece of this, Council shall consider an ordinance of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, sorry, an ordinance of the Town Council of the Town, authorizing the levy. We have a motion in a second. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. End of item. Thank you. Okay.
2:27:28 Moving on now to policy matters. Considering consideration to approve memorandum of understanding MOU with the Inyo National Forest, designating Town of Mammoth Lakes as a cooperating agency for over-snowed vehicles planning efforts under subpart C of the travel management. Thank you. We touched on this item at your last meeting. We were looking at public input and kind of a pre-scoping work regarding the over-snowed vehicle planning process that's being undertaken by the
2:28:03 In your national forest. As through that process and follow-up to that, the town was asked whether or not we would be interested in serving as a participating designated cooperating agency with the Forest Service through this process. Based on that discussion previously, the direction is a good thing to do to move forward with an MOU. Draft MOU is in the packet. It still has to go through final review by the Forest Service and approval.
2:28:32 Element that brought really forward was taking a look at the impact in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Obviously, the snowmobile activity and other over-snow vehicle planning is larger than the town, but there's a lot of expertise that the town can bring to the table with the Forest Service as we look at our planning documents, as we look at other knowledge we have in working with our host program and activity in different locations and things of that nature. Based on that and the discussions with the Forest Service,
2:29:01 Was positive, you know, from the town to say, yeah, we think it would be great to be designated as a cooperating agency that allows us some additional input. Ultimately, the final decision is that of the Forest Service. So we don't override that or it's not, you know, our decision-making process, but we are engaged in that process. And throughout the process, there is opportunity for public input, comments on proposed actions, et cetera, through that process.
2:29:29 The attached agreement, I highlighted a couple of areas in there, I guess where I talked about the types of things that we bring to the table and the plans we'd be reviewing and looking at and incompatibility with what the town has either as adopted plans, accepted plans, and like our general plan and different elements under that nature that provides guidance and then a lot of work that we've done out on the field with data collection, those types of elements. So from the staff standpoint, unless there's specific details in here that we can speak to or that...
2:29:58 The Forest Service representatives can speak to. The staff is recommending that it's approved. I would add that giving the manager the authority to sign the MOU once approved by the Forest Service. But before we dive into that, if there's questions, I would like to give the Forest Service staff who are here, either District Ranger Wong or Chris, if you want to speak to it, there's our rec officer out there. Either way, in terms of input from the Forest Service before final action.
2:30:28 Please, Fred or Chris. Yeah, I just wanted to mention, you know, it's very common for, you know, the Forest Service to ask other agencies as a cooperating agency when, especially when they do have more expertise. You know, even though, you know, Chris has been a long-time local here, and I've only been here a year, but we value your, you know, the town's staff input on a lot of things. I know you guys can...
2:30:59 Collect a lot of data, especially on some of the staging areas and entry points and exit points within the town boundaries. And we would really appreciate the town's input on some of that stuff because that can help us develop alternatives. And this is really what this document is about is developing the impact and alternatives. And as Dan mentioned, the actual decision is a different document.
2:31:28 That the record of decision that's ultimately may be made by the Forest Service, but we need your help in helping us analyze the impacts and develop the alternatives. Excellent. Thank you. Chris, anything to add from Chris? Chris is good. Okay. Any questions from Council for either District Ranger Wong or Town Manager? No. I would just say that I'm excited beyond what I probably should be for this, so I would encourage this. Any public comment? Winter Wildlands Alliance, also Mammoth.
2:32:18 Mammoth Lakes resident. Some of you know I was on Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors for about six years. Good to see you all. I'm with Bill. I'm really supportive of this. I really am encouraged to see a new partnership between the town and the forest. I think there's a lot of expertise that's gone into winter recreation over the years on the town side, and I think that's going to be great to inform this process. I've been through this process on six other forests, and it hasn't
2:32:48 Always gone really smoothly, and I think we're teed up to have a much better process here on this process with some of the pre-scoping we've done and the stakeholder meetings and some of the planning that's already happened. So again, just generally really encouraged. I would just encourage that as we move forward, I hope that whoever's representing the town in whatever meetings happen and when there's full representation of the broad constituency of users,
2:33:18 I spoke with Stephanie Heller yesterday, who's the district ranger on the Mona Lake District, and apparently is the lead on this process, and I was encouraged to hear that I think based on some of the stakeholder meetings, it sounds like there's some appetite to broaden the scope to more than just OSV designation, and to be able to look at some of the parking and staging issues that we have, and I think this winter, of all winners, we've all seen that there are some issues.
2:33:47 Shady Rest, End of Lake Mary Road, Sherwin's Meadow, Propane Tank. So I think there's some real opportunity to solve some issues and solve some conflicts through some parking planning, staging planning, and it's just great to have the town. Great, thank you, Rob. I'm available as a resource. Again, I've been through this process on a lot of forests, so I'm happy to speak with anybody about how the process has worked and what the pitfalls have been and the positive side has been.
2:34:19 And just one quick note of optimism, the Stanislaus has been the first forest to reach a map, like to get to the end of this process where they have an over-snow vehicle use map. And I know that both sides, all sides have been unhappy with the way the process played out and some of the designations that happened. But I have been encouraged as that forest moves into implementation to see more money coming to that forest for winter recreation, for winter rec techs, for signage.
2:34:48 And I think on that forest, which has a much, obviously, a narrower winter recreation product than we do, and only really two roads going in, but they're finally able to manage winter recreation in a way that they've, I think, wanted to do for a couple decades, and they had to get through this planning process first, and now they're doing it, and so I'm really looking forward to coming out the back end as a town and really doing a better job managing it. Great, thank you very much.
2:35:21 Thank you. Any comments in the sphere? Okay. Any discussion? We'll make a motion to approve and authorize the town manager to sign a memorandum of understanding with the Indian National Forest designating town of Mammoth Lakes as a cooperating agency for OSV planning efforts under subpart C of the travel management rule subject to final USFS approval. I'll second. Thank you. We have a motion to second additional discussion.
2:35:54 I would like to add one thing that, is that okay with you? Yes. Okay, good. With that amendment. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all very much. Fred, thank you for being here tonight. It's wonderful to see you and Chris. Thank you for coming. We hope to see more of you in the future. Yes. Thank you both very much. Yeah, let's take, there's been a request for a break. I don't even know what those things are. Ten minutes, would that work?
2:36:37 6.45? Okay, we will be on break for 10 minutes. Thank you all. Okay, we've been talking snow science, but it's time to get back to work. We are now on item 10.2, which is an agreements, plural, with Mammoth Unified School District, MUSD, Ammono County Office of Education, MCOE, for a one-month lease extension and a five-year lease.
2:49:54 To convert the existing ice rink to a community pickleball and multi-use complex. Dan, am I right? Stu's going to do this. I'm sorry, Stu. He's got a presentation, unless there's no questions or items, depending how much he wants to speak to this. I know it's been going on for a while this evening. We do have a background on it. We brought this before. It's a great opportunity for us to be able to maximize the asset that we have on the ground there versus spending dollars.
2:50:23 Take that concrete out of it. And so this has kind of been the process to get us to that point to add additional recreational amenities in the community. Stu? Yes, thank you, Dan. So I don't know if you can see my screen. It looks awfully white for me. How about for you guys? All we've got is a white screen. Let me ask the question of the council first real quick, Stuart. If you've gone through the packet, are there specific questions? And I can have Stu address some of the nuances of this project. There you go. Your mic's not on. Okay. Sounds perfect. Yeah.
2:51:11 Chris, you go with that? I'm good with that as well. Let's listen to Stuart and get whatever we need to hear from Stuart, but I think the council is predisposed to want to hear your presentation and maybe move this thing forward. Don't say anything to make me change my mind. Yeah, well, I'll just do a really quick walkthrough. Hopefully it's on your screen right now. I try to do it full screen, but it obviously just freaks out. But I'll kind of go back here and you're exactly right. The school.
2:51:41 The board have been nothing but generous through this whole 16-year agreement that we've had with them. So I do want to acknowledge the board of trustees and Shanna Stapp and our new superintendent.
2:51:56 And certainly working with Gary Taylor. I mean, that whole crew have been wonderful. So I'm just going to kind of throw some kudos to the school. So, you know, just really in a really quick background. I mean, you understand that winter operations have been severely impacted. We haven't really been able to operate much at all. So the one month lease extension will just kind of get us through the end of March, which will be just wonderful. Hopefully for the community, we'll be able to come back out when it stops snowing.
2:52:26 And enjoy some curling, some hockey, some public skating. We can kind of finish off our season as we should before we transition to the CRC. It's likely that we're not going to be opening the CRC for ice operations this year. There's just been too much of a delay. I think you understand with the significant snow and the vendors and the contractors.
2:52:48 At the CRC. So this will allow some goodwill in the community and get us through the end of March. And again, this was approved by the school district on February 16th unanimously with that whole board. The second one, I'll just jump here and then I'll just get to the recommendation at the end, if I may. The second one.
2:53:09 Is one we've been working with the School District Hayes, worked with BrookBN and worked with the previous administration on this deal. We've been back and forth. There's been several different iterations of the amendments. But essentially, we reached out to the school and said, look, is there, do you have any plans for this parcel of land, which we have before you? It's 2.5 acres. It's right adjacent to the Mammoth Lakes Library.
2:53:35 Do you have any plans for this property in the next five years? They indicated that they did not. They might have some opportunity. They're going to work with Sandra and the housing team on in the future. But right now there's no immediate plans. So we had the opportunity then to kind of jump in and say, well, we really see a need for a community pickleball court and complex. So that's kind of how we started the conversation. Again, we'll work with them.
2:54:01 As we kind of firm up our plans, which is kind of our second item before you. But essentially, it'll be six regulation pickleball courts. And we'll also be able to kind of program horseshoes, cornhole and similar games and activities in a maintained kind of picnic area with restrooms, trash and lights. You can see here, we'll make it available to the public on first come first serve. It'll be free.
2:54:26 We're not going to charge any fees unless there's kind of a tournament where we'll have kind of some direct cost expense for the town. It's a wonderful partnership. That's all I can say. It's not just a lease agreement. This is really a partnership with the school district and MCOE. It's a five-year term. We have one-year time periods that we can extend by mutual agreement. When I say it's only a dollar a year and what Hayes will kind of be...
2:54:54 Shaking his head over there because he actually has to pay the snow removal cost. That could be anywhere. And I'll say here it's an average of 30. This year it's probably up to 40 to 50,000 by the time we kind of finish that. But over the years that we've kind of been operating on that side, it's an average of about 30,000. And you can see here we've just got various conditions in the lease agreement.
2:55:19 And then that brings us just to those recommendations, Mr. Mayor. So they're the recommendations before you. And we appreciate your consideration and your support of this partnership with the school district and Mernie County Office of Education. Okay, Stuart, thank you very much. Is there any public comment or public interest in this? There's interest, obviously, but no public comment. Okay. So with that, I would entertain a motion. Office of Education. Authorize the manager to sign those. Authorize the manager to sign those agreements.
2:56:07 I'll second. Thank you. We have a motion to second any additional discussion. Jamie, please call the roll. Thank you. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all. Thank you, Dan and Stu and Hayes for your efforts on this. It's a great use of what's left, what will be left of the ice rink. Moving on now to item 10.3.
2:56:37 This is an agreement with All Sport America Inc. for the installation of a sport court modular overlay surface on community tennis courts, five and six, and the installation of six regulation pickleball courts on the existing ice rink site. So kind of a hybrid item here. Stu, Dan, who's, Stu, you're up, I guess. I'm up again, and I'll jump into what I'll do is that same presentation, and if I may, and I'll just kind of roll into.
2:57:08 This next section, hopefully everyone can see it there. So Mr. Mayor, as you indicated, we have two work items with one agreement with All Sport America Inc. So one is, as you can see there, a nice beautiful photo of a modular overlay surface on somebody's tennis court somewhere in California. And then you'll see a six kind of regulation pickleball court again in some future complex, not here in California, Mammoth Lakes.
2:57:41 So we're just going to jump in and talk about the tennis court challenge that we've been facing over the last several years up at the community tennis courts. Town council recognized the challenge that we're facing and then allocated $175,000 from the fourth quarter on September 7th to designate to repair those courts. We went through a public review process. We invited the tennis community.
2:58:10 Up to the Community Center Tennis Courts last October. We had various vendors provide us and send us different types of material. We also investigated the use of a post-tension concrete slab, which we mentioned in the staff report was anywhere upwards of three to four hundred thousand. So as we went round these different alternatives for the court, we settled on and with the Parks and Recreation Commission's support.
2:58:39 Settled on the new sport game pickleball surface. And this is kind of a brand new surface. Even though it references pickleball, it's really, what really does is provide the premium balance and surface for kind of court sports in general. So that would include tennis and pickleball. All Sport America and Sport Court is the leading multi-sport flooring system.
2:59:03 And essentially why we selected Sport Court is it eliminates the cracks, offers excellent traction, ball response and superior shock absorption, along with that lateral forgiveness, which is really important for our tennis players. More importantly, the tiles, 100% recyclable, are made in the USA and come with a 15 year warranty. And why that's really important is that we couldn't find many...
2:59:27 Providers and many vendors that were able to provide a 15-year warranty, all they were really willing to commit to was kind of a five-year warranty, which if you invest 175, you know, 200 plus thousand, you really want to see a longer-term warranty. So we're very pleased to be able to provide this surface. Just as a little bit of background, if you're not familiar with the way we number these courts, and if you haven't been up there, hopefully this diagram is very helpful. This kind of describes the scope of work with AllSport.
2:59:57 And that's essentially repairing, levelling the surface of courts five and six before they'll go in and actually lay the sport court modular surface on it. So they'll essentially scrape down, level it, lay kind of a concrete in all the fills and the cracks, lay a fabric surface and then lay the modular surface on top of that. So that's what's going to happen to courts five and six. We're also, because we're really a multi-sport community,
3:00:23 We are going to install one fixed height glass basketball system on court number one, which is the left side of courts one and two. We'll also stripe that for a basketball key. And we're going to put another pickleball stripe court on number two. So once we're kind of finished with our six community tennis courts, we'll have four dedicated tennis courts. And then we'll have two.
3:00:50 This is kind of what the surface looks like. Again, this is not our surface, but ours is actually worse than this. This was up in...
3:01:20 Tahoe, very similar court surface. It's an asphalt court. You see a lot of cracking. They're about two inches wide. We've repaired our courts several times, and this kind of appears to be the treatment that we're really looking for. What it does, it kind of overlays or is suspended over that asphalt surface. So if you do get any cracks that come through, all you're going to do is take up the modular surface.
3:01:45 Repair those cracks and relay the modular surface back over it again. So it really gives you a lot of extended longevity with our asphalt courts before we need to kind of fully replace them over time. So moving on to the multi-use complex and pickleball court with the five-year lease agreement, we're able to kind of put these six regulation pickleball courts down. So why we're doing this with All Sport America is it's the same company. They can provide this same service as well.
3:02:16 As the tennis courts. So it makes sense to kind of put these two items together. Funding for this project was approved by town council in your last kind of town budget process back in June of 2022. So we have $100,000 set aside. And these funds are really in lieu of removing the existing improvements. So if the school district wasn't willing to move forward with this five-year agreement,
3:02:45 We would be using the $100,000 to return the site to or regenerate the site back to kind of where it was prior to our lease agreement in 2007. So we're able to, thanks to the partnership with the school district, use these funds to turn this into a wonderful pickleball and multi-use complex. So that's kind of how the layout would look. That's just one regulation pickleball court. And you can see here we'll be able to size them appropriately.
3:03:13 On the ice rink slab. That's all the dimensions there. What's really unique about this Cushion Extreme product is this is the premium surface for pickleball. Very impressive. We're thankfully working with Allsport who was able to provide this surface, but you can see here it's got multiple layers. You've got six to eight layers of cushion pads that starts with the concrete surface, then the seal, this rubber Cushion Extreme.
3:03:42 Then sand, and then you've got the painted surface over the top. So it really provides a great cushion surface for all our kind of all our recreation enthusiasts there. Also included in that agreement is the installation of six pickleball sleeves and nets. We're going to sleeve these posts because essentially in wintertime, i.e. now, we can actually remove those nets, clear the surface and kind of be open.
3:04:09 During summer activities, we can pull those nets and use it for a multi-use program as well over the summer. So that's kind of the scope of work with AllSport America. So it's essentially a $100,000 agreement for the pickleball courts. It's $175,000 for the tennis courts for a total of $275,000.
3:04:39 Contingency of $10,600. And as we know with many of our products, contingencies are a good thing to be included in the scope of work. And that is the ask for you this evening for town council consideration. Happy to answer any questions, Mr. Mayor. Any questions, no questions. Stu, I have two questions. One is...
3:05:06 That last slide you had up there on the contingency, there's a request in there to do something with a basketball backboard somewhere. So what we want to do, yeah, if I may, Mr. Mayor, what we'd want to do is if we have a $10,000, $600 contingency not to exceed, we understand that some of the net posts at courts five and six may need to be replaced. So that would be where the funds would be dedicated.
3:05:31 If there are funds remaining, what we're asking council is to use those existing funds to replace the Shady Rest Park basketball backboard. And if you've been out there, I can see everybody nodding. That's in really bad shape. So this company would be able to do that as well while they're here at the same time. So if the funds are available, we'd like to use those funds to replace that basketball system there at Shady Rest Park. The other question is, do we trust the
3:06:05 Parks and Recreation Commission to select the color of the pickleball court surfaces. That's a great question. Is there any recommendation from council? No, we're not picking colors. We're not doing that. I think the Mammoth Lake sign is a nice blue. You know, like the Mammoth Lake's logo, it's a nice blue color. Okay, so there's a suggestion perhaps from Councilmember Rice that the...
3:06:36 The blue in the Mammoth Lakes logo is perhaps a good place to start. Yeah. I think whatever the Pickleball Association standard colors are, so it can be used for tournaments and everything else, it would be an appropriate place. And if that blue is in there, then we can... And the ability to program them for Pickleball is growing. Pickleball Tournament, Seven Courts. The other park is... Chris, you've a favorite color. No, she doesn't. Okay, with that, I think any public comments?
3:07:19 And just to be clear, Dan, this goes back to, I believe we had a CIP discussion and some folks came forward very concerned about the tennis court, but this is the solution for that. Yeah, absolutely. This gives us an option to try a less costly repair work. If it actually works out and the tennis community is utilizing it and sees that it works well, then it is an option that we could look at on the other courts. Okay, so this is really important.
3:07:54 So I'm really excited to see how this works on those two courts that we have done. I mean, we have cut foot-wide trenches to try and stop the heat. We live in Mammoth Lake. It's not dry even. It is not. So I'm really excited to get these in and see how they stand up to time. And if they work well, then it's out of the way. Would you care to make a motion?
3:08:34 I certainly will. Okay. I would move to authorize the town manager to execute an agreement with All Sport America, Inc., for the installation of a sport court modular overlay surface on community tennis courts 5-6 and the installation of six regulation pickleball courts on the district MCOE ice rink wreck zone site in the amount of $275,000. That includes a contingency of $10,600. If there are funds left from the $10,600...
3:09:03 I would then authorize them to be used to replace the backboards and basketball facility at Shady Rest Park. I'll second. Motion in a second. Any additional discussion? I just have one question I wouldn't forgive myself if I didn't ask. Is this surface that's similar to the asphalt in terms of playing, you know, similarity for tennis? I just hadn't asked and all of a sudden I was having regrets. Stu, I believe...
3:09:32 Go ahead. I mean, the representation was it. It's high quality, but go ahead. Councilmember Bubsa, are you referring to the courts five and six, not the pickleball courts, right? Correct. Yeah. So it actually has, it's rated at five, which is fast, and it's consistent with USTA.
3:09:56 programs as well. So it's fully endorsed by United States Tennis Association, has a similar bounce pattern. But what's favorable about this surface, which is kind of what our communication was with our many tennis advocates was its forgiveness. You know, once you start playing on a concrete surface, you really don't have a lot of that kind of forgiveness or that lateral.
3:10:20 Flexibility with this tile surface. So they found it very appealing and I think our active adults will as well. So I'm personally going to be, I'm very personally very excited about playing. People will be fighting over it like the rare clay court. Thank you. I appreciate it. You're very welcome. Thank you very much. Good question. Thank you. Thank you. We have a motion in a second. So Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes.
3:10:49 Okay, moving on now to item 10.4, presentation on budget performance of the period, sorry, through the second quarter fiscal year 2223 and approval of budget amendments. Rob. Thank you, Mayor Wentworth. I just wanted to point out for those that may not be able to see at home, typical presentation for budget ends up drawing quite a crowd inside. Well, Rob, this has been the crowd all evening, so it's good company.
3:11:20 I'll share my screen real quick. Okay, so the presentation I'm going to walk through today is a little bit, it's exactly what you read in the staff report, and as you may have recognized through the staff report detail, there's quite a bit more information that's provided in the staff report than we talk about in the presentation format. This will be more about just
3:12:05 Walking through the process, walking through some of the details and happy to answer any questions that you may have encountered as you went through that. So launching right into it, we'll start with transient occupancy tax. This was put together probably about 10 days ago now based upon the timing for preparing the agenda item. So looking at January 4.4, it's actually going to come in closer to 4.7 and a half or 4.8. So things have kind of changed a little bit since then.
3:12:36 But what I'd like to show here is, number one, what was the budget? How did we distribute expectations? And it's really based upon what we received in the last three years of activity. So we kind of know how to distribute that money across there. And then looking at the actuals, you see the variance that we have. So year to date through January, we're $7.2 million ahead of our $16 million budget. But it's a little bit false in that perspective that we haven't acquired.
3:13:05 Some of the other months as of yet, so February through June are still really out there to be predicted. So in that far column of the estimate, I try to give you an idea of what I think it's going to be based upon trends and activity, highlighted in green those that I believe will be records, as well as what was previously a record. So all told, I do expect TOT to come in if we stay on the exact trend that we are now.
3:13:29 And the weather certainly seems to be supporting that. We should be just north of $27 million for the year. What I like to do in these quarterly presentations is not necessarily realize, obviously, that aggressively, that much revenue. But I did break that into three. So we'll probably realize something similar to the $4 million in not only the second quarter, which we're discussing today, but the third and fourth as well. And you guys will be able to allocate those funds as they come about.
3:14:00 This is just a little different representation of that, but it's also showing the political commitments for the reserve components of that, so tourism, transit, housing reserves. We maintain a council direction and policy of allocation of any excess TOT that we receive will go into these reserve buckets at the same rates that they are originally allocated during the budget process.
3:14:24 The $4 million that we're realizing would generate $723,000 for tourism reserve, $261,000 for both housing and transit. If someone has a question, I'll pause her. I guess I have a question. So the 2.35 points for the tourism reserve, so is that, I mean, can we allocate those things differently, like, you know, give more points to housing or transit rather than the tourism reserve?
3:15:00 So that was, this was actually a long process to get to this point of where these actual rates have come from. Back a few years ago, council took upon themselves to review whether that was accurate or not and any adjustments that they want to make. That is the ratio of distribution that was allocated during that last review. I think John could speak to that. He was part of that process. That is something that would come forward, not in a process of this.
3:15:30 So while it may not be labeled as such, it's really effectively going there.
3:15:59 Thank you. I think that's good to point out. When we review, and I kind of talked about this a little bit in the staff report, there's not a whole lot to discuss usually by the second quarter unless we have a strong winner like we're encountering. I do have another revenue item here I'll speak just briefly about. It doesn't require a lot of detail, and that's interest. We increased, just recently we changed the policy where we can invest in camp.
3:16:33 Which is another version of California Asset Management, which is a California state program for municipalities to invest in. It's returning about 4.5% versus LEIF, which is another version of a similar vehicle, which is returning just above 2%. So we put money, we put $20 million into CAMP just recently, and it's going to return quite a bit more interest.
3:17:02 Interest revenue is one of those things that's very, very tricky. It obviously goes up and down with fiscal policy within the federal government. And so it's not something that we were going to hang our hat on from an annual budgeting perspective. We'll always budget very conservatively and realize when we've actually received it. So in this case, I'm upping it $150,000. So the total, instead of $4 million for TOT, it's $4,150,000 in total revenue.
3:17:29 I listed out the way I am on this particular screen so I can show the political commitments as coming out of that available funds of $4.15 million, and that leaves us an available funds for allocation of $2.903,900. I started to talk a little bit about the expenditure review that we do for the year. We just have really two general fund elements that I want to focus in on. Number one would be police overtime.
3:17:58 As you know, we've had certainly impacts from storm coverage, but we also had a recent shift coverage going to a 20-hour day. That does have some automatic overtime elements in that, and in general, we thought we needed to bump that up, so incrementing that by 50,000. And then finally, on the facilities side, so the facilities for the town offices have common area maintenance. Much of that is driven by the amount of snow removal that occurs out in the parking lot.
3:18:26 And we have a certain percentage of that. So I do expect the common area maintenance or CAM charges for the year to be way in excess of what they are normally. So I'm adding another $75,000 to that. And so that, from a general fund perspective, those are the only adjustments that are recommended for the second quarter, which leaves about $2,778,900 for allocation to programs.
3:18:50 As you remember my presentation back in February, this is sort of the benefit of the budgeting process that we use. And through this process, we've kind of listened not only to what are the council priorities, but as you see, Dan's got copious amounts of notes for tonight. It's what actually are the discussion points that occur at a council meeting and where should we be allocating these funding. That's where it comes with these staff recommendations.
3:19:17 We have a whole list of recommendations that will fully utilize the excess funding of $2,778,000, and I'll walk through those real briefly. First one, and I have them in the list in order of the size of contribution that we're seeking tonight for the Housing Now programs. In total, about $1,784,000. That's comprised of three components, a million of general fund, excess revenue.
3:19:46 523,000 of tourism revenue and 261,500 of housing reserve. Rob, if I could just stop you right there. So that's at 523, right? Measure A, political commitment, and the 261 from the housing reserve measure A also. Okay, good. Thank you. 723, not 523. It's 523 because I have 200,000 that I'm recommending from tourism reserve that actually goes to another element. Thanks. Yep.
3:20:17 But this particular one, and Chris, this is a comment that you made last time too with regard to the housing programs. There are a number of programs out there which we talk about. There's land acquisition, there's a bridge program, things that we can invest in different vehicles that are there. But this money, what I'm saying is undesignated to a specific program means that it goes into Fund 245, which is our Housing Now program. But it's really available for any one of those.
3:20:47 We have the opportunity to repurpose some.
3:21:16 We had set aside 1.5 to 1.6 million last year.
3:21:39 To accommodate this, what we're doing is recommending another $300,000. This is how we'll slowly build a war chest to actually have that fully completed when the time comes right. So the recommendation is for $300,000 for that specific project. We also are recommending $300,000 for the child care, sorry, for restrooms at the foundation property. Stu and team have been working on sort of sourcing an option for
3:22:08 Restrooms that are sort of a modular unit and a two unit cost is $300,000 and that would support roughly 90 people per hour. We think that that would be adequately servicing potential outdoor amphitheater as well as dog park and other things in that general area. So very important for that. Future capital is a funding mechanism we utilize where we usually take the round, I'm going to call it rounding.
3:22:37 But $213,900 is not necessarily a rounding number. But it is the remaining balance after the other identified items that we would put into this future capital fund. And some of the work that we do in setting these things aside and calling them out is because we actually move them from the general fund into a specified and segregated fund so that they can't be utilized for anything else but this.
3:23:00 And so when I talk about future capital, it would be taking that $213,900 and setting it aside in future capital so that it can be applied to a capital project that comes up in the future that may need some additional funding or may need some seed funding to actually get initiated through our CIP program. So that's the recommendation, and that is the remainder of unallocated funds at the end here. It's just in the order of amounts, it came in that high.
3:23:30 Next item is restroom at Park at the Parcel. So we've allocated quite a bit of funds to standing up a park in the new development. And this particular one would provide a single unit modular restroom for about 45 people per hour. It's probably adequate for what we think will occur at the park. And certainly if you know the proximity to the park, it's very close to the homes that it will be servicing.
3:23:57 Not necessarily a standalone as like out at shady res, but more ancillary to the actual units themselves. So I think that's adequate. We have an addition to the fleet, which is a technical term, meaning that it's a piece of equipment we'd like to acquire that we don't have set-aside funding through our vehicle replacement program to achieve. So we're actually adding a new item. Once this is purchased, it actually will be a part of the vehicle replacement program.
3:24:24 In the year one, we start accumulating funds to replace that. In this particular case, it's either a 10- or a 15-year item based upon the fact it's snow removal. But it is a very flexible piece of equipment that we believe would help in clearing around the CRC as well as some elements of the parcel. So these are incremental core services that we don't have today. So we need to add typically both equipment and sometimes bodies essentially to run that equipment.
3:24:54 For servicing those needs. The police recruits, you heard Sergeant Kasabian mentioned that earlier, that we had two police recruits that we are attending to send to the academy. The $100,000 that I have listed here is the wage that we expect for this fiscal year, as well as some of the housing costs and academy fees. There will be an incremental cost to this next year when we have
3:25:23 The remainder of that, because this will just cover us essentially through June 30 of this year. Airport capital maintenance of $100,000. That, as you heard tonight, we have a project out there, the ARF building that's going in. We would like to set aside some contingency for that, even though we have a capital fund of $1.3 million. We also have some maintenance items, as you can imagine, the impacts of this type of a winter at the airport.
3:25:50 There are a lot of things to repair. Currently our water system is down because unfortunately a piece of electronics failed that shut off heat tape that shut off the ability to keep our water system active out there. So there's a lot of maintenance items that are necessary for that type of facility and we think 100,000 would be adequate to augment that program for the year. That's why the recommendations are there. So I'll pause there. These are, I will say, staffs.
3:26:19 Thank you so much, Rob. So a couple of questions. The one thing you said about the
3:26:50 $300,000 for the implementation of the acquired units for the child care. You said, you know, I know that there's been some delay with the school still needing it for another year. What's the timeline that we're sort of working under for the child care facility and how has that changed? And then the second part of the question, because you said when the time comes, is that enough?
3:27:17 To get us where we need to go? Or are we going to need to continue to fund this? Yeah, thank you, Chris. I'll respond to that. We did an estimate on the front end of about $1.65 million with the idea for infrastructure, foundation, relocation of buildings. The buildings were being donated to the town, basically, to be able to do that. It was pretty rough in terms of an estimate. It was also based on available funding. And so what we're seeing now,
3:27:45 The vast majority of that will probably go into the core services just to get the building there. If we have some in there for, we have to do a fencing and a playground, which we'll probably be short on. And then we haven't really tried to estimate out how much will be necessary or if it'll be an obligation to town for tables and chairs and furniture and fixtures within the building itself. We are also, once we move the buildings, we have to do residing and roofing.
3:28:16 And that's still a little bit unknown because depending how well they transport and what we find. So there's some unknowns in that. So the idea would be the goal is to get a solid structure in place. The current funding, adding some to it allows us to make sure we can look at the playground area as a mandated requirement. And then if we need to, we can come back and look and say, okay, we're going to need another X dollars to fill out the facility. Depending on who our partner becomes for operations, we're not looking to town to operate this.
3:28:46 Either Mono County Office of Ed or a private sector level. Ideally, we were going to get everything moved this year because they were supposed to be going to be off the high school site in June. And so by the, I would say by the starting of school, but reality is probably mid-year to the end of the school year for fully operationally for the child care, give or take, I think, 75 kids based on square footage in that ballpark or maybe a little more how you work them through the day, there's more kids involved.
3:29:17 And so looking through that, and then it's going to be just that factor of when we get the buildings, how much outside work, and we'll be looking through design review. It's still going to look like a square building from where it's coming from, but we do need to make sure that it has a facility look to it that belongs there with the foundation property. So there could be an additional ask down the road. We have not tried to estimate that at this point.
3:29:47 And there may be some potential grant funding as well for this. So if I heard you correctly, you're thinking that we'll get the units next year. So it'll be partway through next year, school year, or the year after? It's a little goofy yet in terms of their construction schedule and when they're actually going to say, yes, we need the buildings out of here. Okay. It ties to some work they're doing in the gym and other things in their construction. We need to be, we're charging ahead. We need to be prepared to move them when they pull the trigger. Right.
3:30:16 Because they'll need them out of there. So we're hoping for sooner than later, frankly, because we know child care is a key need in our working community here in terms of families and challenges on child care. So we will move that quickly as soon as they, hey, they're yours, we'll dive in there. And then we will be coming back and looking what's the actual hard cost on that move project and that lay-in, and then what's the additional need that we may run into. And again, we'll be looking for some grants and partners in some of this area as well.
3:30:47 Thank you. Good. Thank you. Good. Just one other quick one on the restroom for the foundation property. I get the park at the parcel, but for the foundation property, is that something where we're going to be implementing it like next summer or this summer? Partly with the orders of them and stuff and what we can get in those. Okay. I think we take them both. Looking at where it'll land on the foundation, we have to nail that down.
3:31:22 Initially, we had looked at it to go with the dog park primarily, but that's going to be a temporary use housing there. So we need to put it someplace where it will be permanent. Servicing, if you have the small amphitheater there is the goal. That's moving slowly forward. You could have 100, maybe 500 people in there if it worked out well. But smaller events, you need restrooms, then you're still going to do port-toilets. Also, that is a popular, we're putting in additional parking area. It's a popular trailhead. People do.
3:31:52 Come looking for restrooms around there. If they don't find one, they tend to find one. So having that type of facility, supporting that activity within that area by a bus stop there as well, the bus stop area. So we see that as real value for events. We see it as a value for users at the site. And if we are able to, you know, the different economic or the activities in event space, having a decent flush toilet there is always nice.
3:32:20 For sure. I was just thinking, I'm really asking about the timing. Like, will we be able to install it next summer? Like, so we're spending the money now because we need to. Yeah, we're allocating those dollars to it. Ideally, we'd order them together when we do the one. Makes sense. Thank you. Site work is important, too. Yeah. Site work there and location of it and making sure we know. It's not uncommon for us to set aside. Hang on one second. Any questions from you? Yeah, not uncommon for us to set aside things, just a little bit in advance. I mean, this project was expected.
3:32:56 You know, in June of this year, and so the last-minute delay is a little bit. But we want to make sure we fully fund something, and then we'll move on to the next funding. Thank you. Okay, we're good. So next. So this is a gas tax review. Gas tax is labeled as such because 50% of the revenue or a portion of the revenue we receive for this fund comes from gas tax collected for sales of gasoline within California, and it's our portion of that.
3:33:28 Our portion is designated based upon a lot of factors with regard to visitation, travel, miles, and so forth, but also the expenditure of snow removal expense in the prior year. So last year's snow removal expense is revenue for this year for the gas tax review, gas tax fund. The general fund is what fills in the gaps in between and pays for
3:33:53 More than 50% of the cost of this particular fund. So every year in our budget process, you'll see a transfer of funds from the general fund to gas tax to cover costs of snow removal, street maintenance, and those types of things. What I'm recommending here, what's all I've got to really utilize, except for maybe fund balances, is take some of this money and put it in, take some general fund money and put it into gas tax to cover these specific items that were identified as shortfalls so far this year.
3:34:23 Mainly at the top in street maintenance, there's a little bit of overtime and a little bit of public utility. Utilities have actually gone up quite a bit this year, and we did increment that from a budget perspective, but it is needing to be more, as we're seeing on this request. We're expecting it's going to actually be double what it was in the prior year. With regard to snow removal in 452, we had an overtime wages above.
3:34:51 Budget at $125,000. We're adding another $100,000. That's based on the severity of the storm. Again, we budget in this particular fund at a typical year or a general snowfall year. So in this particular case, it's quite a bit more. So $100,000 for overtime. Special operational, that's costs associated with time worked. So it would either be meal periods or other things like that that are generated for staff. So there's an increment to that volume of overtime work as well.
3:35:20 So I have that listed under general snow removal, but that's what it's affiliated with. And then finally contract, contract services. These are for shoveling contracts and other things that we have around town, and those are obviously well over budget. We had $200,000 budget in here. I didn't have that completed on this particular chart, but actually it's going to exceed that and more. So we thought $88,000 was probably good to cover.
3:35:47 For this, some of these things are still pending, meaning where these are estimates. So there may be some additional adjustments. That goes into the next category here. So winter equipment, we consider the equipment in its own category, even though this is snow removal equipment, it's associated with the extra cost of diesel or the extra utilization of diesel. We talked about using, you know, almost 1,500 gallons a day or 1,000 gallons a day.
3:36:13 During these heavy removal periods of time, so another $110,000 expected for diesel cost. And then repair and maintenance. The more they're out there, the more things break. And everything on these things is incredibly expensive. So another $50,000 for that. So in total, our estimate for gas snow removal impacts is around $400,000. And that was also a general fund transfer. So as a part of that, when you read through the document, that listed it out. Any questions on gas tax or snow removal?
3:36:43 And then finally on this one, I kind of combined housing and tourism reserve in one area. Earlier we talked about the Measure A allocations. Amanda, you asked the question about that. We had an allocation to housing of $261,000. I'm recommending that that amount be earmarked to go to the Housing Now programs in 245. That's what we discussed earlier, that $1,723,000, I think it was, or $780,000.
3:37:13 The next item is Tourism Reserve, and that had a total allocation of $723,100. The recommendation earlier we discussed of $523,000 to the housing programs. And then there's $200,000, which is the town's contribution to some of the pricing and promotions that we're doing on air subsidy. So most of the air subsidy funds are covered out of MLT and TBID.
3:37:41 And this particular one would be our desire to cover some of the local costs because, as you know, tourism can only cover really tourism activity. But we are getting local seats, local butts in seats with these promotional programs that are out there. And that, when we decided to pursue that, that had an incremental cost. And we're estimating that to be $200,000 as our full commitment to winter. And anything unexpended would
3:38:11 Fall into summer air subsidy coverages. So a natural place for that to come from is tourism reserve. And it's a similar allocation from that activity. So that's the recommendation that we have. And I kind of give a little blurb on that. So any thoughts, any questions? Sorry, Amanda. I don't have any questions at this point. Go ahead. Ask your question.
3:38:47 Totally, like I understand that the air subsidy, you know, when the budget was approved, it was a long time ago. Things are fluctuating. But I sort of feel like going forward, I would much prefer to see all of that accounted for ahead of time, because that's not like a change. Do you know what I mean? It's just, so I guess that's really what it is for me. I'm just super sensitive to air subsidies, so. Yeah, I mean, it's, I think, I mean, and I think as we go forward, as the.
3:39:23 The air program that we're doing from our airport matures, we have discussions with the Miwag and all the rest of it. I think that this will be something that staff will be able to do in a more way. It's going to have to be. Yeah, it's a little bit about timing as well. The negotiation and discussion on the cost of air service occurs September, October time frame. We establish the budgets. And this was, you know, we certainly go at it with an anticipation, but.
3:39:59 As I kind of opened up my presentation on the airport is that we really wanted to lean in this year with the pricing and those other areas. So that was actually a town direction. Dan and I sort of leaning in and saying, hey, this is where we want this to go. We want actual better pricing. We want better utilization. And so that's where that incrementally. Can I ask annually, what is the air subsidy that the town is paying to the airport?
3:40:30 Is that $200,000, that's what we'll be paying for the air subsidy for the whole year, or is that just for this quarter? That would be the extent of which the town would contribute town funds to air subsidy. The entire year? Okay. Okay, so I think, Rob, we've stopped for questions along the way. At this point, I think we're looking for any additional discussion, or I think it's time to make a motion. I'm going to check to see if there's any public engagement, comment, nothing. Okay, thank you.
3:41:05 Before we do, I just have one comment. Because we hear a lot of feedback from the community that we're not spending our money on our local needs. And, you know, most of these requests are for things that will directly benefit our community. So I just want to say thank you for bringing us a package of things that really are very community focused.
3:41:38 For sure, but what I'm talking about is that you often hear, you know, so much is done around tourism, and it's just important to point out that. That comment I made earlier about culture-eating policy, it's something that we need. We're in the policy-making business, and you can see it. Culture, and that's a little bit on us to go out there and get people to. Yeah, to try and get people to understand what it is we actually do. Which is why I took this moment to say it right now. Yes, thank you.
3:42:16 Thank you, Chris Bubser. Yeah, I want to thank you too, Chris. You know, some comments that I've heard, and you actually mentioned one a couple weeks ago when we were talking about, you know, the community sometimes wonders, well, you know, you've got $60 million in excess TOT across the last six or seven years, whatever happened with that. And from my perspective, what happened with that is 28 nights like tonight. That's how many quarterly presentations that occurred.
3:42:44 And I doubt they're watching tonight. I mean, they may be. I hope they are. But I don't know if it's a sense of we don't care to know the facts or we're comfortable with the way things are going. And I hope it's the latter. But thank you for your comments and thank you for your continued support. Everybody wants to complain about the government. So we hear all the time, you're not spending enough on the locals. Bring me the program you want to see that we aren't spending money on. And if it makes sense, then we will, you know. Consider it.
3:43:13 Consider it, yeah. If you're going to complain, give me your solution so that we have something to work with. That being said, I would make a motion to adopt the proposed resolution amending the fiscal year 22-23 budget as recommended in attachment A, budget adjustments. Nice motion, Bill. Is there a second? I would happily second that. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Any additional discussion? Not hearing or seeing any? Jamie, please.
3:43:41 Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you very much, Rob. And thank you to you and the staff for these timely and well-considered recommendations. Thank you. Okay, we're now going to move on to item 10.5, Ordinance Relating to Electronic and Paperless Filing of Fair Political Practices Commission FPPC Campaign Disclosure Statements. Jamie. Yeah, so exciting.
3:44:11 So the town recently contracted with Netfile for electronic filing of campaign disclosure statements and Form 700s. In order to require electronic filing of campaign disclosure statements, the proposed ordinance needs to be adopted by the town council. Nothing further needs to be done to require that Form 700s be filed electronically, and the clerk's department has already started the process and sent out the emails for the town's Form 700 filers to file electronically through the new system.
3:44:39 The new system provides the benefit of electronic instead of paper filing, which saves the information and allows a user to edit their information from year to year and makes it possible for the clerk's department to add all of the agencies that a user would potentially need. The new electronic system will not only benefit the clerk's department, but will also benefit the users by saving time and allowing access to information already submitted. So with that, the staff recommends that the town council waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance adding chapter 2.
3:45:09 8.80, electronic and paperless filing of campaign disclosure statements and statements of economic interest to the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. Do you have any questions? Easy. Sounds like a good idea. Any questions? Any public comment? Okay. We have a motion from Bill. I'll second. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Any additional discussion? Seeing any.
3:45:40 Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you very much for that, Jamie. Okay, item 10.6, approval of updated agreement with Axon Enterprise, Inc. for provision of public safety body cameras, data storage, software tasers, taser supplies, and related items in an amount not to exceed $150,000 over five... Mr. Holler. Thank you. The staff report kind of lays out the item and the need for...
3:46:13 A ongoing program that manages our body cameras. And also, we currently have an older style or older remake on tasers. We do not have a program before us has been looked at over the last several months of how do we move that program forward plus address body cameras in terms of ongoing plus necessary storage and some added capacity to be able to collect evidence through the body camera element.
3:46:47 Thank you.
3:47:14 Not to exceed amount is slightly more than the budget in there. We may be in a position where we need to pick up one more body camera, depending how we want to allocate any with our code enforcement. They currently share one. We're looking at three officers. Maybe we may want to look at two in there. So there is a little bit of a room for something of that nature that we would work with the Axon company on. The proposals there, it walks through. It does provide us an opportunity to have a train-to-trainer program twice.
3:47:44 So you're not missing any of that recording, both for us and...
3:48:13 Others that we're dealing with in that activity. Acting Chief Casabian is here, can speak to some of the details if you have particular questions on that. It does walk through the options within the staff report. So I'll pause there. If there's any questions that we need to address, we'll do that. Otherwise, the recommendation from staff is to move forward.
3:48:37 Andy Morris is still on. This is very similar, the same company, frankly, in work. I know they recently did in Truckee as well, so I know Andy was involved with the same company in the deal. And our goal was hoping that we had a little better deal than Truckee got. Well, we better have. Well, I don't remember the pricing on that one, but I did get Axon to, I think, kind of moderate some of their terms and conditions, which I had concerns about.
3:49:03 So I'm trying to find that document. Truckee lost some documents in a cyber attack, but I'm trying to find what Axon agreed to a few years ago, and if I can get them to agree to similar improvements to their terms and conditions, I'd like to try to do that. And if not, we'll run with what they've got, but I'd like to at least nibble around the edges and see if we can make this a little bit better. Okay, thank you. Any questions for Dan or Andy on this item? Any public comment? Andy, Truckee having some problem with...
3:49:41 The cyber attack. I guess with that, Dan, I don't know if there's any questions for their acting chief, but I don't think there are. So I think if we'd have the motion that would have the approval subject to final legal review and authorize the manager to sign the agreement. Okay. Okay. I would move that the town council approve an updated agreement with Axon Enterprise Inc. for provision of public safety, body cameras, data storage, software, tasers.
3:50:14 Taser supplies and related items in an amount not to exceed $150,000 over a five-year period, pending final legal review and authorizing the town manager to sign once that legal review is completed. I'll second. I'll beat you to a bill. Amanda Rice, ladies and gentlemen. Any additional discussion? Not seeing any. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you.
3:50:46 Thank you, staff. Now is the time for the town council members to report. Okay, please. Can I get one of the old tasers? No. Okay, strike that from the record. We will not be entertaining that. Thank you. It would be a great thing to have here when I'm arguing a point. Bill, with your opinionating, you've just nominated yourself to go first for the council member report. Oh, gosh.
3:51:15 Mr. Urdi gave a great presentation of the MLT meeting I attended earlier today. Other than that, you may not have noticed, but it has snowed. Yes, noted. And we're looking for a white Fourth of July. All right, Amanda, I'm going to turn to you. I have nothing to report. I've been enjoying shoveling and working on my muscles. Okay, we're working with Councilmember Bubser.
3:51:44 I always have too much to say. We did have the Mono County and Town of Mammoth Lakes Liaison Committee, so it's mostly information sharing, but we concluded that it would be good to get the two bodies together because there's some potential tax financing situations we might be looking at and other infrastructure where we might want to collaborate. So I think Mr. Haller will be setting that up.
3:52:12 Real quick, if I can add to that comment from Chris would be, the consensus was to look at the third Tuesday in May and October and kind of set those as standing joint meetings. So we were working through calendars and chances are at least one person is going to be gone. So, but would you set them in advance and kind of hold to the calendar so we actually conduct the meetings. As Chris mentioned, EFIDs is a financing one topic and a few others that we'll end up working through to put that joint meeting together.
3:52:42 I bet you can't wait. And then I also just wanted to thank Matt Perullo from Southern California Edison because he invited me in to learn more about how they function in our community. And, you know, the couple things that we know is about how they prepare for emergencies, but also talking about tree removal, hazard trees, and why things are the way they are. So I think there's always opportunities for us to talk to our constituents about those things because there's always a reason.
3:53:11 You know, we discuss that the better. And I met with Janet Hatfield from Whitebark. You know, I had seen her presentations on the project before, but it's really nice to see where they're headed and how much opportunity we really have with that project to protect our town. So I'm grateful for those opportunities. Thank you. So following up on your meeting with Janet Hatfield, I've been working with Janet Whitebark in your national forest.
3:53:39 The Sierra Nevada Conservancy, which could lead to a very important infusion of money into the donut project, but it could also lead to about $2 million of planning and engineering work for all of the campgrounds in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. And what's significant about this, this is part of a pilot project that the state is mandating for landscape-scale investment strategies around wildfire.
3:54:08 And what's encouraging is that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is saying we want to see multi-sector projects. We don't want to just see wildfire fuel reduction stuff. We want to see that plus recreation plus workforce development, which is consistent with state policy. So we'll see what happens. They had a big thing in Shindig and Sacramento today in their board meeting. Bill, we missed you at the LTC meeting. We did...
3:54:36 Approved. There's a study. I think Hayes-Est is doing that for microtransit. Or is that right? Okay, so there's a microtransit study that's in the works. That's happening. The June Lake Active Transportation Plan was approved. That needs to get integrated in the overall work program. And Jerry LeFrancois is coming back to help out with capacity for Monaco. They've lost some staff. Jerry's coming back. And Caltrans.
3:55:06 Now, Caltrans shared something which I think we need to pay attention to, which is a major repair and maintenance program for Highway 203. And it's major. It's gutters, drains, full asphalt, the whole deal. And this thing is maybe four to eight years out. But when we talk about main lodge, rebuilding, this road thing we heard about down to Red's Meadow, there's some important sequencing that's got to go on with all this stuff where the whole thing's going to turn into.
3:55:38 I mean, this is, this is, it affects every single sector, every agency.
3:56:14 It's just, it's existential at this point. Interesting update from YARTS, they've got some brand new buses. I don't know where they're getting all that money, but man, they're nice looking buses. Big, blue, North Atlantic City kind of buses. Quite, quite inspiring. What do they run on? You know, carbon, fossil fuels. But they're really nice buses. We also talked, towards the end of the being, talked a lot, a fair amount.
3:56:43 The need to start for staff, LTC staff, to start bringing the climate funding opportunities to the, it seems to be kind of falling through the cracks. There's so much money and opportunity coming out of the state. They said they'd revisit that and they'd take a look at that. Finally, I listened in to the MOT board meeting today. I thought it was a really, really, and again, I encourage all of us just listen in on those things. There's cultural issues around tourism in Mammoth Lakes.
3:57:15 So we're now going to move into closed session. So I'm going to read the items that we will be considering in closed session. Pursuant to, this is item 12.1, Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957, the council hold a conference to consider evaluation of a public employee town manager. Item 12.2, conference with legal counsel, existing litigation.
3:57:51 Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9. Name of case Jill Randolph et al. v. Town of Mammoth Lakes. Case number 22, UCM 102. Item 12.3, Conference with Legal Counsel Existing Litigation. Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9. Name of case Lewis and Pimtram Cohen v. Town of Mammoth Lakes.
3:58:20 Case number 22, UCM 103, an item 12.4, Conference with Legal Counsel, Existing Litigation, Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9, name of case, Main Street Taxpayer Association versus Town of Mammoth Lakes. Any public interest comment? Nothing? Okay. So with that, we will then now go into closed session. And if there's any reportable action, we will certainly let you know about it.
3:58:50 So we'll take a couple of minutes and move the chairs around.