Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2022
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
199 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:22 How's the weather up there? I'll call to order the Mammoth Lake Housing Board meeting for Monday, November 7, 2022, 6 p.m. Roll call. Brian, were you guys able to hear the call to order? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. President Stapp? Here. Vice President Kreitz? Present. Board Member Barksdale? Here. Board Member Hodges? Here. Board Member Vianzen? Board Member Perkins?
7:04 Present. Board Member Steenstra. Here. Board Member DeAndrea. Here. And Board Member Nuttall. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item two, assembly bill 361, findings adopt resolution 2022-25 to allow virtual board meetings to continue during the COVID-19 pandemic declared emergency. If I can have a motion. I'll move to approve.
7:39 I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? I just want to, if I may, we did get a report out from our county council, and maybe you have as well at the town council, but it sounds like that's going to go away in February? Yeah. Of the coming year. So just something to be aware of as a board, and we'll probably need to agendize that for discussion on how, just some information item.
8:09 I think it might be helpful since we have a lot of members that do participate remotely. That's all. Thank you. Any other discussion? If not, we need to adopt the resolution. Roll call. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra?
8:42 Yes. And board member DeAndrea. Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item number four, consent agenda, move to approve the minutes from the regular meeting, October 3, 2022, board meeting, and approve the minutes from the special meeting, 26, 2022, board meeting. Discussion? And we did pass over public comments. Item number three is public comment. Did we have a public comment? I thought I...
9:15 I don't see any, but I didn't hear you call for public comments. I just wanted, in case anybody was watching that wanted to make a comment. Yeah, we didn't have any public comments. Okay. So I called for it in my mind. And we have no public comments. Okay, any public comments? None at this time. It was close. It was very close. All right. Consent agenda. Anybody want to poll?
9:48 Consent agendas, item 4-1 and 4-2. I'd make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Any discussion? Roll call. President Stepp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea?
10:21 Yes. Thank you. We'll move to policy matters. Policy matter 5.1, the board will consider a proposal from the Ineo County to partner on CalEPA grant for environmental assessment, consulting at a potential housing site in Lone Pine.
10:44 Thank you, President Stapp. This item is before the board this evening as a result of a request from Inyo County regarding a potential housing site in Lone Pine that may have some environmental remediation that needs to occur.
11:04 This site is a four parcel site in downtown Lone Pine. Two of the sites are owned by Inyo County and two of the parcels are owned by LADWP. The four parcel site is currently being used as a road yard by Inyo County.
11:26 And so because the potential environmental degradation may have been caused by the current use of it being used as a road yard, Inyo County is not eligible to be the applicant for the grant. So Inyo County has asked us as a housing partner to partner with them on the grant application to apply for funding to hire a consultant to do the environmental analysis on this location.
11:58 The site is currently being rezoned to, let's see, to R3, which is residential high density, with the hopes that it could be used as a site for housing. I provided some visuals of where the site is located. Inyo County believes that this site is ideal for housing due to its central location. And we do have
12:38 attending this evening staff from Inyo County Planning Department and the Inyo County Administrative Office who may want to make comments regarding this request. But I have had a conversation with our legal counsel regarding liability to Mammoth Lakes Housing in the event that we were to participate in this grant application. It doesn't appear as if
13:04 The only other consideration I think
13:36 Well, I guess, you know, I did provide some information about the regional housing needs assessment for unincorporated Inyo County. It looks like by in the next six years, unincorporated Inyo County would need 205 units and the breakdown of the AMI levels is in the staff report.
13:58 This partnership does seem to be in line with our strategic plan, which emphasizes a regional role and strengthening partnerships throughout our service area. Lastly, I think an important consideration is potential costs to Mammoth Lakes Housing for staff time. I provided a rough estimate.
14:25 However, I'm sure Inyo County staff can speak to their desire to commit staff time to this issue. And so there's a number of ways we could charge for any fees that are necessary. In the past we have charged a flat fee for grant applications around maybe $25, $100 in the past. Or we could charge hourly.
14:54 If there's time spent on either producing the application or ongoing reporting requirements, I think that if Mammoth Lakes Housing is to have our name on the grant application, we would want to have some oversight over the quality of the grant reporting or any documents that go back to Cal EPA with our name on them. And so there is some time.
15:22 I think that's all I have. I'm happy to answer any questions from the board or if Megan McCammon or Catherine would like to speak on behalf of Inyo County, they're here as well in the Zoom. Have they raised their hands? Could we promote her to a panelist? Please. I do have a question.
16:04 Patricia, so beyond the applying for the grant, I mean, would we have any other ongoing involvement in the development down the road?
16:14 I think that's a great question. I think that is an unknown at this time. This is sort of an upfront risk, if you will, to strengthen and develop this partnership. I do think that it's the intention for Inyo County to work with us on a potential future housing development there on that site. They've expressed that to me. I don't think either of us could say for certain if that would be the ultimate outcome. Okay. So this is in the interest of getting the site evaluated and cleaned up?
16:44 Yeah, and I think it demonstrates to the Inyo County Board of Supervisors our willingness to play a role in their area. Great. Megan, would you like to add anything? And I just note that Sarah is joining us. Over to the chair. Yeah, thank you. And I think Patricia really gave a great outline of all the salient policy points. I do just want to note that
17:12 In regards to the question that was just asked, you know, we don't have a Mammoth Lakes Housing working in Inyo County right now, so we really do look to Patricia, and she's been awesome about sharing her expertise and providing technical assistance and partnering with us and our COC. So we, I definitely foresee working with Mammoth Lakes Housing in the future. We don't have any other options, though if we did, we'd still want to.
17:40 But I do just want to note that we recognize that Mammoth Lakes Housing has taken off a huge amount of work with the transition of the COC and with all of the new developments that are going on up in Mono County. So our goal would be to absolutely minimize the amount of pressure or staff time that is put on Mammoth Lakes Housing through this. We really just need a
18:10 Rubber stamp of putting someone else's name on the application to pass it through, but I would foresee taking on the bulk of the staff time load within Inyo County and minimizing that with Patricia and her staff. Ryan? Hi. Thank you, Patricia and Megan, for the presentation. This sounds very interesting and encouraging to me. I'm just wondering from a
18:44 application perspective, if Mammoth Lakes Housing serves as the applicant, what our interest in the deal is that allows us to serve as applicant, do we need to have some form of site control or some form of an MOU with the county and or LADWP to meet any site control requirements for the Cal-EPA grant?
19:10 I don't know if Catherine, our planning director, has applied for one of these before, so she might have detailed information, but I will say that we do intend and we have already requested or put on LADWP's radar a right of entry for an applicant to come in or a consultant to come in and do the Brownsfield testing on the DWP portions of the site, and we would provide that same thing from Inyo County for the two parcels that we own.
19:40 Yeah, I just finally got on here. Sorry, it took a minute. My internet's a little slow tonight, and I don't have a camera going. But, and the one I applied for before, we were the applicant for CDFW, and all I did was fill out the application, and I've had to do absolutely nothing since. There's no responsibility on the county for any of it. What happens is that the EPA sends in their own consultant on the actual project.
20:08 So as long as the county and DWP sign the right of entry, they go in and they do everything. Mammoth Lakes Housing probably won't have to do anything and we'd be more than happy to help with the application and like Megan very eloquently said, kind of a rubber stamp. So that's kind of more like what we're looking at. Did that answer your question? Yes, I think so. It sounds like we would have a right of entry, but we...
20:39 Our organization is not necessarily going to be engaging the consultants to go out and do the testing that the county would take that on. I guess if this satisfies the site control requirements of the grant application, great. Yeah, as the property owner, we would really be more involved in that process. You can be if you choose, but if Mammoth Lakes Housing doesn't have the time or the staff resources, you certainly don't have to. Further discussion? Patricia, you want a motion on this?
21:17 No, I think that the staff report maybe calls for staff direction. From the discussion, do you have a direction? I'm supportive of us being the applicant for the purposes of the grant application. Do we have a feeling as a board on charging a fee? That was one of the questions proposed. I don't have an idea for that, but I'm just curious if other board members do.
21:55 I would say it's really at Patricia's discretion if she wants to put a budget on her time and ask for a fee after X amount of hours, that would be good to ensure that she doesn't get herself into too much commitment than she expects to. Yeah, I support this and I think it's a good idea to put some kind of a checkpoint, whether it's a flat fee,
22:29 and you know is amenable to that or an hourly rate that's agreed upon just so that there's there's no there's no
22:42 Assumption of services without compensation. I think it sends the right message to our other partners that pay a fee for services that, you know, we're consistent across the board about, you know, we value our staff and we value the time and we know Inyo County does too as well as other agencies and so I don't, it doesn't sound like it would be very significant but I
23:09 I would support that. I support both a fee for either whatever you presume to be best, so whether that's a flat rate or whatever works, you know, between you and INYO. But I think this is great. I'm very happy to hear that INYO's found such an avenue that could work. So, yay. Yeah, fingers crossed, right? We agree with the yay. Further discussion? Patricia, you need a motion on this?
23:47 No, I think I have staff direction. Thank you. Thank you, Catherine and Megan. Thanks for having us. Thank you for agreeing to participate. This is great. Have a good night. You too. We'll move to policy matter 5.1. 2. Pardon? 5.2. Sorry. That's okay. Discussion of fire development impact fees for access apartment and Innsbruck Lodge. Patricia.
24:31 Yes, so this item is a result of some ongoing conversations that I've been having with our Fire Chief, Alish Tomer, and sort of stemmed from the fact that we have two current development projects in the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Access Apartments and the Innsbruck Lodge, which both have fire development impact fees associated with those developments in the total amount of approximately $18,000.
25:01 Those projects, as you all know, are compiled of a myriad of funding sources, and every penny really does count at this point. And so, even though $18,000 doesn't seem like a lot, I think, at least from my perspective, it is another drop in the bucket towards making these projects successful.
25:29 Alice and I have been talking about what sort of compromise we could come to in terms of these fees that our developments would owe the fire department and came up with the rough idea of a potential
25:49 fees in lieu of services to help the fire department solve some of their housing issues, which I think is something that we have been wanting to do for a long time and would like to do regardless of if we had these fees to pay or not. So I think it's really a ripe conversation to have about
26:13 Different options we might have available to us and to the fire district to partner and help both of our goals come to fruition. We want to make these projects happen and the fire district wants to solve for their housing issues, but we also want to solve for the fire district's issues. So we wanted to bring this item before the board for a possible
26:41 discussion so that Alish would be able to bring some direction to his board to see if they would be amenable to an MOU or some sort of agreement to memorialize an exchange of services for the fees that we owe at these two developments. I did provide some rough ideas of what that could look like.
27:12 Although I think, you know, that's up for refinement between the two parties. Let's see. So the next steps, I guess, are for the MLH Board to have this conversation. And then the Fire Protection Board is meeting on November 15th. So if there is any update from this evening, then we would be able to bring those comments to that meeting on November 15th.
27:45 But it is urgent in some ways because we do want to pull our building permit for Access Apartments and Innsbruck Lodge first and Access Apartments in April. So we want to make sure we pay all our fees because we have to pay our fees before we can pull our building permit. So this is a very timely discussion to be having and our fire chief is here this evening to speak with us.
28:16 Good evening, Alex Tamire, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, Fire Chief. So, if I could just have a little bit of time, I promise I'll be brief, but I'll start kind of general and I'll zoom in on this specific issue. In the past, my board has been very hesitant to waive diff fees, especially when they see that something might have implications for diff fees in general. So, that's kind of been their general stance. That being said, we clearly understand the housing mission. I think we have a lot of shared mission.
28:46 We have to work through. I would argue that the fire district actually has the hardest housing situation in the community, and that's due to the fact that running a fire department is a horrible business model. I have to put 20 people on a fire scene right now, which is really hard. We get compared to places like Tahoe quite a bit, but the way that they do that is actually through mutual aid. So we have a budget that's similar to like Squaw Valley, which has about a $4 million budget. They have one fire engine that's on.
29:16 Can't put out a structure fire with one fire engine. I guarantee you that. Usually they recommend about 20 people for an incident. So the way that Mammoth Fire does that, obviously, if you're not familiar with it, is kind of a volunteer accommodation department. We're one of the few left in California. It's a pretty tough model to run, especially in California. And housing becomes extremely difficult. We have to have, again, if you have full-time...
29:42 Firefighters, you would require three battalions, so you'd have to have 60 of them if they're living down in Bishop like PD does, and that's, you know, obviously economically not feasible. We have to hold on to our staff in Mammoth Lakes. So we're aware of the housing situation. We have to fix it. We're probably, as far as, again, we're not part of the town. We're a special district. We're significantly behind the water district or the hospital who actually have residences. We have a lot on Joaquin that we haven't developed.
30:11 And we haven't been putting a significant amount of funding towards a project, so that's something we'll be working towards. But again, I have an incredibly small staff. We have a full-time staff of eight, and they're firefighters who are also mechanics, IT people, payroll, HR. We're kind of doing a little bit of everything, so I don't always know what I don't know. What I know about housing is that, you know, you really want to leverage opportunities, like it's essentially the way that you get things built, that sort of thing.
30:37 What we're proposing is a, and again, I think what we do is for one year, we're not trying to put a huge burden on your staff. We're also trying to cover base for our board, who is very hesitant to waive any fees, and really just kind of help have housing explore options with us and look into, you know, what might be some possible avenues for us. Because it is a little different from what the town has to do. If the town has a unit that's subsidized, it transfers to someone else.
31:04 That's essentially not a problem because they're trying to solve that umbrella. You know, for us, it's really unique to kind of our firefighters and if they move out of town in a snowstorm, it's going to be a problem. So I believe that, again, not trying to create a huge stress on your staff. We will write up an agreement that would be more of kind of a pilot program for one year and an opportunity to see if, you know, there are some possibilities to where we can leverage some of the knowledge and expertise that, you know, your staff has.
31:33 to help us with us, and do it in a way that our board is comfortable with releasing some of these fees, so. Questions from the board? I don't have so much question as a comment. I mean, I think that certainly, I think the development committee could certainly, you know, help evaluate their, your property that you have on Joaquin, maybe provide you with some, you know, our assessment of what could be developed in the site and some, you know, backing envelope pro forma cost types.
32:08 Evaluations that would be helpful, I think, for you guys. And then, you know, whether, Patricia, if we're aware of, you know, some potential grants or some other avenues of funding that might be available to assist that. I mean, I certainly see there's ways we could help you guys, for sure. Yeah, absolutely. And again, I think the point that I want to stress is, you know, there's no intent to put Patricia and staff in some sort of, you know, high hourly work setting, you know, the...
32:35 Like I said, we try it out for a year, see if there's value on both sides for it, and then kind of go from there. I had a couple questions, Patricia, on the ideas that you put in under the analysis. It's page 29 for me, page one of two it also says on there. But one of them is preference for fire district employees at some rental units. I think the word preference made me pause a little bit, that I would be cautious to set.
33:08 A precedent that we would give preferential treatment to various groups to get into affordable housing. And so, and I'm not sure what you meant by on a temporary or transitional basis. So maybe you could explain that bullet point a little more. Yeah, and this was sort of just a jumping off point. I think obviously at our federally and state funded projects, we can't give preference to anybody except for how
33:37 Our program operates is first come, first serve. And then at the Innsbruck Lodge, it will operate through the coordinated entry system, which is to help prevent homelessness. So all of our clients will be preferenced based on their homelessness status. But I think this was trying to think about, you know, do we or do we want to own a unit that's not restricted by those sources and somehow
34:06 Write up some guidelines that put a preference for fire employees. I don't know. It was sort of, you know, a jumping off point to think about some creative solutions that we don't currently have but that might be feasible. Yeah, Lindsay, I certainly understand your concerns and obviously everything we'd have to vet through legal through both sides. We're looking for, again, all sorts of them.
34:31 For example, I've got a kind of an association union, and one of the things that they mentioned is there's a lot of times when they have their housing fall out on them, and then there's this rush to find another housing. That happens to the town quite a bit. I just, I know the other kind of senior staff works with Dan Holler, who lost his housing situation, and they were able to get into another unit. So there might be opportunities where if you have something available, where we're looking for like a three-month bridge to get somebody.
34:58 And again, it's got to obviously work within the constraints of whatever that property is. So we understand a lot of times your hands are tied as well. But situations like that where it might be one of those things where obviously my association request was, well, let's have a unit that the district purchases and just sits there open forever. That's obviously not something that financially makes a lot of sense. That being said, if you have three or four units and one that can be tied up for three months, it doesn't legally bind you to anything and you're allowed to do that, that might be a huge resource for us as far as
35:28 Meeting association needs. So again, just looking for kind of opportunities of leveraging where we both have, you know, vested interests and opportunities just based off our knowledge base and tools that we have. So certainly I believe that my board would be in the same position where obviously everything has to be done legal. They might argue for putting firefighters first. I've heard that quite a few times. But I do understand that a lot of these constraints are state and federal. And even if we wanted to do that, we couldn't.
35:57 Obviously not all opportunities are going to work, but there might be some. Thank you both for explaining. I appreciate it. I have a couple of questions. I'm not familiar with the average AMI of your staff. Is it higher income, lower income, middle? It's a great question, and actually I'm going to be doing some surveys here shortly. I would argue that we're kind of across the spectrum. A lot of people start as ski patrollers, but we also have some
36:29 You know, well above average individuals as well. Most of the people who work for the fire department just want to serve this community. That's been kind of the driving factor that's made Mammoth Fire work. We also have about four or five individuals that are living in their cars right now. So I was trying to figure out if I can put them on the walking lot. So I would say our problems are very representative of this community as a whole. That being said, the unique thing is I can put a waiter in Crowley.
37:03 Right, right. Well, you know, there could be some Cal HFA programs that might work for some of the higher income folks. I know that they've got some funding that are trying to do home ownership more. I really applaud the collaborative approach to problem solving here.
37:31 You know, we have the jail on our agenda tomorrow, and since March 1st, that project's gone up almost $2 million. So, really, every penny does count because cost escalation is just through the roof on those projects that Patricia mentioned for us. So, I really applaud you both for working together, and thank you. Sure, and obviously, I can't make any promises for my board decision, but- Right.
37:58 I believe we could put something together that'll make sense for both boards. Yeah, thanks a lot. I agree. I think that we could really do something to work together to that would justify offsetting the cost that we would otherwise be paying to you for that and work together for
38:20 for grant programs and maybe help you develop the lot or get a plan in motion to start developing the lot that you guys have and maybe help apply for grant funding and we'd be utilizing the best of both of our services here and if you do have staff that is not
38:45 If that is homeless currently or living out of their car, then I think that puts them as qualified for the transitional housing. So we'd be eager to help you out as soon as possible with those services as well. Thank you. Further discussion from the board? I think they have a partner. We're going to try. Sounds good to me. Thank you. Thank you. We'll move to
39:28 workshop, the board will participate in, is this? Yep. Yes. The board, the board will participate in a workshop regarding the 20th anniversary rebranding and logo design for Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Patricia? Thank you. Here is an update about our rebranding process. The marketing committee has been working very diligently to get this before you this evening.
40:02 Can everyone see my screen? Okay, great. Here's our rebranding update for November 7th. The Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors has been undergoing a 20th anniversary rebranding process to help better incorporate our tri-county service area. We recognize that housing is a regional issue that is impacting all of our communities that we serve.
40:36 We prefer not to work in silos but to strengthen our regional relationships and recognize that it can be difficult to strengthen these relationships when our name reflects only one of the jurisdictions in the region. So our goal for this process was to clearly and correctly identify our service area to the public and we wanted the name and the brand to reflect
41:07 To be geographically specific, but not too specific. A little update on this timeline is that on October 3rd, the board approved a name change to Eastern Sierra Community Housing. And so this is an opportunity for the board this evening to
41:31 Take a look at a few of the logo designs that the marketing committee has been working on and provide feedback and comments for us to take back to the graphic designer. As you know, we've had a lot of community input around the name and here we are in the next steps. So here this evening we'll see a short list of the logo designs and then we'll move into the website redesign.
42:08 Our attorney did confirm that at any point the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors could pass the name change resolution and that wouldn't affect any legal status on any of our open contracts until we have filed that name change with the Secretary of State but before we do that we would notify all of our contract holders and send out all of those letters and
42:38 We'll give explanations to our partners before we file that change legally at the state level. So the resolution can happen at any point. We'll work through noticing everybody and then we'll file the name change legally. So there's still a lot of steps in between. And then once we have the color palette, the logo and the website is undergoing its
43:09 Refreshing. Then we will try to do a comprehensive relaunch and everyone can start using the new name and the new logo. So right now we're in a little bit of an interim place but at least we're far from where we started. So one step at a time. I wanted to let the board know that the committee has been very active as I said. We met at least three times as a group to
43:41 Review 10 main logo concepts with additional iterations on many of those. And so those have all been discussed thoroughly, ranked and rated for different reasons. And so we've come to the two that we have this evening because of the process that we've been through.
44:00 All of the comments from the committee were delivered to the graphic designer who incorporated all those comments and sent back new iterations and we would meet again and then that was sort of the process we went through. The committee is happy with the two options that we are discussing this evening but we are very excited to receive any feedback from the board to either if there's a preference or if there's
44:28 If there's any other comments that we can take back to the designer to refine the final product. I guess what we should do is look at each one individually and take comments on each one and then take any final or overarching comments afterwards. This is called logo number nine and it is one of the first
45:05 Logos that was provided to us by the graphic designer in a little bit of a different form. The mountain had more of like an emoji kind of look to it where there were some paths coming down the mountain which made it look like a ski mountain which we didn't quite like. We wanted it to be more of like a generic mountain.
45:36 The original design didn't have roof eaves, and so it didn't look as much like a house as it does this evening. That was something we added. And then we recently made the windows bigger. They were much smaller before, but we were concerned that as the logo got smaller on business cards, for example,
46:00 You would lose the window feel and it would turn into a blurred square. So the windows are bigger, which helps bring that house feeling forward and those changes have been made. This color, this grayish slate, greenish blue is a color that the committee has felt drawn to. It's not
46:29 Blue like the town of Mammoth Lakes, but it's not green like the Forest Service, so we felt like it didn't represent anyone else, which was good, so that we felt like it wasn't taken, and so that's sort of the color we've been leaning to, but we're happy to take any feedback on color options.
46:56 The font is also a font that we've been sort of leaning towards. We felt like it was professional and clean, but also a little bit friendly, not like Times New Roman, for example. And we didn't want to look like a bank, so we felt like this font represented what we were trying to put forward, that we were professional and trustworthy, but that we were also friendly.
47:28 The color options on the right-hand side of the screen are just some test examples of different colors. We were thinking, you know, previously we had these monochromatic options and we were thinking, okay, what is the color palette going to look like? We wanted to see how the logo could incorporate the palette that we're moving towards. I don't think necessarily the committee...
47:58 maybe feels either way on these particular colors, but this was just to give the board an idea of what we could do with this logo in terms of coloration. I think that, and I'll open it up to the committee if you'd like to add anything, that was a little bit of an overview, and then if the committee is finished, we could open it up to the board. Thanks, Patricia. Yeah, so we
48:35 went over and over again with a bunch of different designs and iterations of different designs and we narrowed it down to two options and so basically rather than give us too much feedback and go over lots of different iterations we kind of want you to choose one or the other and when you choose one we have a
49:05 A few different fonts, like as you see in this one, or ways to lay out the font. And I think it's all fairly interchangeable. For example, on the left here, you see the font is next to the next to the logo. And that I imagine more of a letterhead versus the one in the middle has the the text underneath it. And that's
49:34 can be used when there's more room and you're not just trying to keep it at the top and the black and white versus the blue and white or the negative space with the solid background versus the colored with the white background those are all interchangeable so you can give us some feedback but what we're really looking at is to pick logo number nine or
50:03 What was it, number six was the next one? Yeah, do we want to provide comments on this one or do we want to move to the next one and then provide comments at the end? I think the latter just because we're comparing the two. Okay, that makes sense. We're picking one of the two. Yeah, that makes sense.
50:39 Okay, so here is logo number six, and I apologize, it does look a little bit grainy in the presentation, but I think that's because I took a screenshot of a PDF, so it's not actually supposed to be so soft, soft focus. So this, this logo originally was, I think it was maybe a little bit skinnier.
51:10 and taller, and it didn't have any roof eaves, and it was just trees with no mountain in the background, so it looked sort of like a forest or a Forest Service logo, and so we added the roof eaves, it became stubbier, shorter, and now we have the negative space of the mountains in the background.
51:39 And here we see it in that same color, but obviously we're open to suggestions. I don't know if there's anything else on this one. I would point out there are, like Tony referred to, there are two different fonts and Tony is really the font guy. So if there are more than two, Tony, let us know. I'm only seeing two. So that would be something as well as you're noticing not only logo but font, like Tony had said. So I think all of the...
52:15 fonts in these two logos are the same, except for some appear in lowercase. So the Eastern Sierra is one font, and community housing is the other font. Well, but if you look at logo number nine and number four, the black and white, look at the G on housing. The two G's are different. So that makes me feel like they're different fonts. Oh, you're right. That one might have, that G is different.
52:47 The top one on number four has a little more modern of a font, and the one on the bottom has a little more traditional of a font. They're both fairly casual, and I think the comparison she made with the Times New Roman, all the stuff with the Seraphs was a little too formal, so this is a little more...
53:13 Casual, but like for number four, the one on the top is a little more modern than the one on the bottom. Yes, okay, that is, that one is different. Yeah, and then the lower cases are actually different between logo number nine and logo number six as well. If you look at like the T in number six has a little hook in community and it doesn't in the other. So anyway, they are just a touch different so we can kind of
53:44 see what maybe we prefer there. So these are the details we've been nitpicking on for the last three months trying to bring you something to choose from. So if you guys want to take a look or have any questions then I'll be happy to give you my opinion. Discussion? I don't know if the board wants to hear.
54:17 I think we have a very diverse committee, and so I think we have diverse opinions, but I don't know if the board wants to hear the committee's reference before you comment or if you want to comment first. These have come a really long way, so I'm really excited to see what you guys think. We've talked about them for a long time. Were the mountain silhouettes meant to approximate any
54:54 local peaks, or were they meant just to be kind of generic mountain silhouettes? They were meant to be generic. We talked about maybe trying to emulate Mammoth Mountain or something else, but I think we're just trying to keep it fairly generic. Do the four little windows, is that signifying our four regions? I can see both of them side by side. Yes, let me work on that. One second.
55:29 Just so I can look back and forth. Sarah, sorry, say that again. You were asking about the four windows. We didn't hear the end of that. Is there some sort of something that they signify? Is that the four regions that we're serving? Or is it just windows? Just windows. I don't think it had any specific interpretation to it, although we can surely make something up.
56:04 My other question is, is the intention that there will be a monochromatic version in black and white and a color version? So whichever logo we pick, there will be, you know, we can use either one depending on the application? Or if we're going with the one that only has logo six, that only has the teal option, is it teal or nothing?
56:36 I asked Patricia to go over, I'd have to review the contract with the graphic designer on what we have with that, because even some of the other options that we passed up, I'd love to use in certain instances, but if we have the right to use it with the graphic designer, to use it with the monochromatic or the different colors, I would prefer to have that availability.
57:05 We did use it with the teal. It's going to get printed in black and white anyway. It's not always going to be just in teal, so I say monochrome is always going to be an option, but whether we have the other color options like we were showing is debatable. Okay.
57:29 Yes, we can have different layouts and we can have different color variations. So mostly I think the focus is on the icon and potentially if there's comments on the font and or the color, this slate color. I think those are the main components. Well, I will put in my comments then.
58:07 I personally don't really I prefer the all uppercase font. I don't like it when it's the uppercase Eastern Sierra and the lowercase community housing. I think it feels a little community center-ish. I'm not sure. Just something about it sort of feels a little more
58:39 Childlike for some reason. I also kind of think that if you're, I just like the consistency of if it's more of a title or it's more of kind of, you know, that's the name. I don't think you should mix the Eastern Sierra being in all uppercase community housing being lower. So that's just my take on the font that it should be in all caps.
59:09 The layout of the type. I personally prefer the more block layouts where it's the, so I guess on logo nine, it would be like the second version of number four. On logo number six, it would be the, where it says number three, where it's one block of type and it's not.
59:37 Like all the different, it's not bouncing around like number, like number two does. I kind of feel as well like the Eastern Sphere on the top left and number four of logo nine, it's too small. I think it gets lost. Whereas again, the bottom one, it's like more prominent, but not as prominent as community housing. And then my final comment would be,
1:00:07 I personally prefer the icon of logo number six. I actually really like them both. Logo number nine's icon is feeling a little kind of state farm insurance for me. I think that number six is a little bit more representative of the house, the mountains, the forest, our location, you know, the fact that it's a housing.
1:00:40 Thank you, Sarah.
1:01:07 I will just say on the committee we liked the feel of the badge just because we felt like it could be like an Association of Ski Instructors badge or it could be a Forest Service badge but that's like the point like this is our badge and so we leaned towards that one because we felt like
1:01:32 We're surrounded by other people that have badges, and so I think that's why we kind of went with that one, but I could see that it also could be viewed not in like a happy way. Yeah, we could have pins. Everybody could have a pin. Yeah, like I'm not part of that badge or that association, but that makes sense as well. And yes, we could have pins. Are there suggestions?
1:02:06 Well, I'll, I'll, I'm not, this is certainly not my wheelhouse or my area of expertise. This is purely just my opinion. But, you know, it's funny, you know, Sarah, at first I was like, oh yeah, I like six better, but then the more I've been looking at these, I actually do prefer nine, local nine, number nine. And I do agree that it should be the all caps for both Eastern Sierra and community housing. And,
1:02:34 I don't know, this is just me, but I do prefer in logo number nine, the one that's labeled four, I think it is, where the community housing is the same size font, so it's not equally justified across, but it's the same size. It kind of actually feels better to me that way. And I like the variety, I mean, that would be great for letterhead, and then the other one where it's the
1:03:06 Logo above, Eastern Sierra, Community Housing on one line below, like the negative space example, or not. I think they look great. And then just options of having either it's the multiple tones there with the same color, or you go to the different color, highlight the mountain. I think they're going to look great. So I know those are, that's my preference, but.
1:03:32 I'm happy to go with the majority. Right, it's a democracy. We're voting tomorrow. Well, I'm going to chime in and just since I'm sitting here and ready to speak, I do like the font that's a little more modern. So on logo nine, that would be number four, the top. I like that font better.
1:04:05 It's more fresh and it feels more current. You know, I like the way it looks in number two as well on number nine. In that box, I think it looks cool. And I like number nine. It's not a circle, right, but it's a little closer to a circle. I don't really like the boxiness of the house over on logo six.
1:04:34 Something about this one just feels more original. I feel like the house, when I look at that blue house, I feel like I see that at conferences. I feel like I've seen that somewhere. And this other one, six, or nine, excuse me, is more original. And I think we kind of want that. We want to stand out. So I would vote nine and that font and trust the committee to, you know.
1:05:03 choose whatever colors, you know, I'm fine with the colors you've presented, not particularly partial one way or the other. I guess if I am partial, it might be a little bit to the red. I'm kind of bummed to see the red go. I like the MLH red roof. Are there discussion from the board? Yes. I was just waiting to see if anybody online had anything, but Tony, I actually have a question for you.
1:05:44 As a font person, using Logo 9's font, that number four, the top one, Kai, you said it was the more modern font, would you think that you'd be able to squish community to be the same size as housing to square it up more like the bottom logo is? You could have the same justification, but we'd have to play with it to see if community would be too tight or if Eastern Sierra would be too spaced out.
1:06:14 I've definitely heard a lot of people say, and Tony, you were one who said that in our process, that you liked it when the writing was more sort of in a box. I think that's what I justified. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, I personally prefer it, and I think it kind of scales up. You see Eastern Sierra just as boldly on the other one. The Eastern Sierra is kind of a small side note, and then Community is...
1:06:39 still big and prominent, and housing is the biggest, most prominent word there. So that's my preference, and we would be able to bring that modern font into a similar justification. Heidi has her hand raised. Heidi? Oh, I just wanted to just kind of give my thoughts on the options.
1:07:14 Number, you took it off the screen, so now I can't remember, I forgot. The first one you showed, I believe it was number nine, with the, I guess, with the windows in it. Is that the correct one? There, can you see it now? Yes, okay, I did remember. Okay, thank you. That's kind of the one that I lean towards. I like that the...
1:07:45 It's almost like you're looking through the house to see the mountains is how I first initially saw it. And I just like the clean, crisp, sharp edges of it. Color-wise, I don't mind the blue. As I sit here and look at the town logo behind the dais, it does still kind of look similar to the town. Blue.
1:08:16 It's a little bit more teal, but that's, you know, doesn't bother me too much. Font, I do like the block, like Tony was just saying, the block making everything the same, the Eastern Sierra Community Housing all the same size so that it all is represented equally. That's my thought.
1:08:48 Thanks, Heidi. Further thoughts? I'd like to get everyone to weigh in if they have any opinion whatsoever. Yeah, just I don't have a whole lot to add. I think I'm partial as well to Logo 9. I think they're both handsome and the committee and our consultants did a great job with this. I like the modern sans-serif fonts that are being
1:09:27 used here. I think my only maybe other question would be something that Sarah mentioned at the beginning about the windows and whether they should be or could be representative of either the counties we serve, which I think is just three counties right now, or regions. I kind of like the symbolism of a logo and I think it'd be nice to have some explanation as to what that represents.
1:09:57 Yeah, I think that we should maybe discuss that at the committee level and see if we could come up with something, you know, at the final adoption of the logo or, you know, at a later meeting. It doesn't even have to be about the jurisdictions, right? It could be about our values, our four values, or something to do with
1:10:35 You know, live, work, play, you know, thrive or something, you know, I don't know, but it could be something along that line as well. It's a little more less stuffy. Not that, you know, I mean, I work for a jurisdiction, but I don't mean to put anybody down, but, you know, it just doesn't have as much feeling or heart to it, I think, as it could potentially. Those are my thoughts.
1:11:18 I'll weigh in as well, I guess. I prefer logo number nine. And Sarah, I'll say, I did not at the beginning. At the beginning, it looked like a ski area map, the way it was. And it was like you would just picture a ski area. But so it's come a long way.
1:11:37 My other question, I guess, to the board is, and these are things that we can change for different uses, but having the writing to the side or underneath or above the logo, those are some things just to keep in mind as you think about a sign outside the office or letterhead or various things. I think that we have...
1:11:58 The ability to move that around. One thing we talked about in the reason why in logo number nine for the top one Eastern Sierra being small is what we figured was that quite often you would be in the Eastern Sierra so you wouldn't need that title as much but what you really wanted to have pop was community housing to know that that's
1:12:20 What we are and what we do and not have that Eastern Sierra part take over. So I still go back and forth a little, although I did see as it was on the screen a ways away from me and thinking about like the sign at the office or something, you couldn't read Eastern Sierra at all at the size it is being small. So I do like it. I do like it a bit bigger. And then to Tony's point earlier, where all the font is a bit more of the similar size, but housing really.
1:12:48 is the big one and does seem like it pops so I can get behind a bigger Eastern Sierra and have them all a little bit more even but really have housing pop. One person told me one time when looking at colors and logos and things you have to squint your eyes and then sort of it was Bill Cockroft and said squint your eyes and sort of see what comes out when you're looking at posters and things and so that's what I why it looks like I'm squinting all the time trying to see it. So and
1:13:16 Yeah, I think as all the colors we looked at, one thing with red, to your point Jennifer, is the MLR logo is red, and so we actually had one that was very red, and we thought, oh no, that looks too much like MLR, and so this is kind of in just looking at different colors, we had one that was purple for a while, that we all really kind of liked purple, and then that went away, one was yellow, and that seemed good, and then we weren't sure you would see that from far away, so yeah, I think color definitely is something to think about.
1:13:46 As we're talking personally, I don't mind. I like the teal. I like this color. It sort of fits in with our community, but it still stands alone and is different. Kirk, what about you? Teal. Teal. Which logo? That's the hard part. Yeah, he does. He likes the one we have. I'll go with the group. I'm a terrible, I was a terrible artist in school. I think Lindsay makes some good points. I mean, thinking about, you know,
1:14:20 How you fine-tune the font sizes for readability, both for signage, that's very important, and then also for small reprints of the logo in print for whatever purposes, right, that it's still also legible. That was one of the things, actually, with the original Wooly Mammoth Mountain logo, there was like in the ski magazine ads and stuff, and they would have like all the ski areas logos across the bottom.
1:14:48 The Mammoth Wooly got, you couldn't, you could see the wooly, but you couldn't read Mammoth Mountain. That was a big reason why we changed the logo to the current one, the crown logo, just so that it was just more emblematic and just easier to read, because when you do put a bunch of them across and you, you just, you know, that one got so lost because it was just so fine when it got squeezed down small, so, so I think that's something to keep in mind as you guys kind of fine tune.
1:15:15 To Lindsay Point about the Eastern Sierra, maybe I would agree it's a little bit bigger, so it's a little more legible, but yeah, great job. Yeah, great job. Thank you, committee. We have one outsider in the house, Angie, do you have a preference? I don't know if we get to ask you since you're, no, she sits in the, she's here, she's in the room. I just think, because people will see it, I mean, really, it's the non-professional people. Ooh, she's holding up nine. She likes number nine. Okay.
1:15:48 Because it really is our people that we want to make sure that feel comfortable. And Patricia alluded to that it represents that we are trustworthy, an organization that can help and people can trust. Can I ask one last quick question to the committee? Did you guys try logo number nine? Did it ever not have the windows? Yes.
1:16:18 I can maybe pull one up, maybe, let me see. And I'm sorry, you said earlier something about making the windows bolder. I just wasn't sure if it, if you have a version that doesn't have the windows. It's not a huge deal, it just is quite Microsoft-like, because that's what Microsoft's logo is. And I think that, to the point earlier, I think that
1:16:45 Two points. Heidi said it too, that it's like you're looking out of the window, out to the mountains, you're looking out of your house. So then the windows sort of being there is a little bit confusing if I'm looking out as such. If we're going to keep the windows, then I do think they need to represent something because I actually wonder, will people realize what they are sitting on top of the mountains? And I think people will think, what are the four little boxes?
1:17:14 What does that mean? And the only reason on the map, there's like your four little pins for the four region, for the four, yes, for the four regions served to not counties, because yes, there's only three. So my only comment would just be like, if we're keeping the windows, which is fine. I think we should figure out what do those represent, even if that's us kind of deciding ourselves, if it's the,
1:17:45 The values or the regions or as Jennifer spoke about something else. So here you can see the windows were smaller in the beginning and I think we liked the windows because otherwise we didn't know if it reflected enough of a house but you do see a version here and I don't know if they're too small but
1:18:18 Where we tried something else instead of windows, sorry. And we liked these colored options, however we thought maybe, you know, this is a variation for a sticker or a t-shirt, but not necessarily an iconic image for letterhead.
1:18:58 The hexagon, right? That's what it was. It was. I mean, so, so the eaves and the windows is what make the house, make it a house, and I really like having a house on our logo, personally, and part of our title is what we're, we're about home, about creating homes, so. I mean, as much as that one's really pretty with the river runs through it to the sun, that's for like a clothing line. A clothing line. I agree.
1:19:34 Yeah, I mean, we didn't, we saw, instead of the four boxes, we did at one point, or at least the way that when I zoomed in on my computer, it went to just a square box, like one window, and that also seemed a bit confusing. It was just like, why is this big black box there? So then we...
1:19:52 Increase the size. But I do, Sarah, to your question, Patricia, at the beginning of your staff report, there's a map saying our service area, and it has four blue marks. Were those four marks for something? I was trying to picture. Those could be, it could just be the pins for the counties. One is, yeah, so there's,
1:20:29 I think it's a pin, yeah, there's Mammoth, Mono County, Alpine County, and I think that's Bishop. So, actually, this is an old map, I think. Yeah. Is Bishop the bottom one? Yes. So, Inyo County's not highlighted on this map. Sorry. That's Mono, the one in the middle is just Mono. It's like, that one's Mono, that's Alpine.
1:21:05 Mine, that's Mammoth, that's Bishop. Oh, right. Oh, right. Which, maybe, I guess, because we have our offices in Mammoth and we represent three counties, makes our four. It's limiting, though. Yeah, it still then defeats our purpose of Eastern Sierra. Yeah. I kind of like your idea of coming up with... ...and come up with some super cool definition behind that once we get it all formalized.
1:21:35 Yeah, four core values of our organization or, yeah, something. Great, well, thanks everybody for your feedback. I think that gives us plenty of direction where to take it now and the graphic designer might be relieved to stop getting so many revisions and get something done here. But I think I want to thank her. I don't think she's listening, but I want to thank her for all the work she's put into it.
1:22:10 I've been nitpicking about all these different things and it's great to finally narrow it down to what we really like as a group here. Thank you, Tony. Yeah, we can, I can bring these comments back to the graphic designer and then perhaps, or perhaps the committee should meet and then we should formalize our feedback. Sure. I think so.
1:22:39 I did want to point out to the board, Agnes is on the committee as well. She's just not here this evening, but she played a big part in this process as well. True. So I'll reach out and we can figure out what the next steps are. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. Patricia, are we ready for 5.4? Yes. Discussion of possible approval of the fiscal year ending June 30, 2022, draft audit financial statement.
1:23:25 Thank you. So our auditors visited in October and spent a day in our office reviewing all of our files and then off-site they also review all of our bookkeeping and all of our contracts as well as all of our real estate transactions and so this is a result of
1:23:55 That work that they performed. And it's an exciting time of year so that we can approve our audit. There were no findings by the auditor in regards to any of our bookkeeping or financial status. And so that's the results of the audit, that there were no findings. So that's great.
1:24:23 And then I think I wanted to maybe just point out maybe one or two things and then I'm happy to answer any questions. I think the first thing I'll point out is on page three of the audit, well you'll see under total assets,
1:25:03 In 2021, our total assets were $3.2 million. And in 2022, our total assets are just over $4 million. So that's an improvement. Although you'll also see that our total liabilities are up. That, I think, is actually a result of the current loan that we have.
1:25:29 The bridge loan we have through the town of Mammoth Lakes for the acquisition of the La Vista Blanc unit is still outstanding at the end of this audit period, and that's almost $500,000, which looks to be about somewhere around that number, so that would make sense. I think the only other thing I'll point out is that if you go to page 13 of the audit,
1:26:17 You will see a breakout of all of the limited liability companies that Mammoth Lakes Housing has established to hold our assets. So the general operations column is the MLH column. Sierra Housing Advocates was previously our only LLC, which we used to buy and sell real estate, but also now currently owns the Birch Creek Condo in June Lake.
1:26:47 You'll see the Innsbruck Affordable Housing LLC and the Valley Apartments LLC. Soon to be added to this will be an LLC for Access Apartments and also for the Star Apartments. We're going to move, at the direction of the board, we'll be able to move Star Apartments into a sole member LLC, if that's the will of the board.
1:27:21 I think those are the highlights for me, but I'm happy to answer any questions. If there are no questions. We typically approve the audit, if that's the will of the board, by a vote. Make a motion to approve the fiscal year ending June 30, 2022. Audited financial statements. I'll second that. Moved and seconded. Further discussion? Roll call? President Stapp? Yes.
1:28:12 Vice President Kreitz, aye. Board Member Barkstone, yes. Board Member Hodges, yes. Board Member Perkins, yes. Board Member Steenstra, yes. Board Member DeAndrea, yes. And Board Member Nettle, yes. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item 5.5, Mammoth Lake Housing Program update. Thank you, everybody.
1:28:47 Okay, here is our program update. We have not had any rental unit turnover, and our waiting list for affordable housing is currently 153 households. I will add that we did hire a full-time housing navigator for the Mono County position, and she started at the beginning of October.
1:29:17 We set up all of her technology and we met our partners at Inyo County as well as Mono County. Part of that has to do with the continuum of care and learning how to operate the coordinated entry database which is currently administered by Inyo County. So we met with our partners there and we had some training.
1:29:46 She was helping process some waitlist applications that had sort of stacked up, and so she really did get her hands dirty in those couple of weeks, but she has gone on maternity leave, and she'll be coming back in January.
1:30:08 So I am working to enter our first homeless client into the coordinated entry system. I was supposed to meet with him on Friday, but I was ill, so I'll be meeting with him as soon as possible to work through that coordinated entry interview, which is about a 45-minute interview process, to enter a client into coordinated entry for homelessness preference, which we will need to use for the Innsbruck Lodge.
1:30:38 I mean, it sounds like I should reach out to the fire department and maybe other employers who have folks living in their cars who may or may not be on our waiting list to get them entered into that system. So Eric has also been participating in those trainings, and so we'll work on that together in the interim. We're also under ownership. We had a lot of applications a couple of months ago, which we processed. We had a couple of clients interested in
1:31:08 Our units, and that didn't work out for numerous reasons. Some had preferences that the units didn't meet their needs. We had a DACA recipient who couldn't get an FHA loan. Interest rates are pricing out our clients. We don't have any down payment assistance available.
1:31:30 And I foresee monthly HOA rates going up in the near term as fire insurance policies expire and either get dropped or renewed with increased rates. I feel like there's another reason why people can't get into housing. That's a handful of them there.
1:31:56 Oh, okay, so we had a bunch of clients that didn't work out, but now we actually have a whole handful more, so Eric and I are going to spend some time tomorrow going through all of our applications, making sure we have everything we need, income qualifying on a first-come, first-served basis, and trying to get some of them into escrow on some of our units. I think our priority right now is the La Vista Blanc unit, which is a two-bedroom condo and
1:32:26 I think if we can't get any of these clients to work out that we might make a proposal to potentially rent it because right now it's just been sitting vacant and with the way that the market is right now and the unavailability of down payment assistance, we're going to work through the clients we have but we're just not sure if it's going to work out. On the next page you'll see an update on some of the units we've been working on.
1:33:06 We are doing some rehab. Oh, so we did enter escrow on the town-owned one-bedroom condo at Meridian Court, so I'm working through that with the client and the town. And then the town owns another unit. There's a lot of units here. I don't even think this is all of them. So also we have our E-301 unit, which we talked about at our last board meeting.
1:33:44 That is undergoing some substantial rehab at the moment. It will be having some water damage repair, new carpet and paint. And so we're just working on getting all those scheduled and happening so that we can make a decision on what we want to do with that unit. Are there any questions on that part? So
1:34:21 The next table is our down payment assistance funding, which at the moment is frozen. Well, so it's either frozen or the balance is zero. But Mammoth Lakes Housing does have $50,000 in CalHome reuse that we can use as down payment assistance for our mobile home program. And that can also be used for rehab.
1:34:54 So we did have a potential client for mobile home rehab for some roof repairs, but they didn't submit their complete application, so we need to follow up with them. Let's see. The next section of the report is the median home sales prices. So right now in the town of Mammoth Lakes, the median single-family home is $1.26 million. The median condo is $762,000.
1:35:39 And in Mono County, this median single family home is 640, and the median condo is 673. So, let's see. In those assumptions, you'll see the gap for 120% AMI household that is a size of four. So, the gap is quite large, and as we know, most of our clients need below market rate pricing and down payment assistance.
1:36:25 If there's no comments or questions on that, I'll move to some of our projects. Oh, Brian. Yeah, a quick question on La Vista Blanc. Was that condo taken down with the town bridge financing? Yes. Okay, and when does that mature, that loan? Actually, I don't know off the top of my head. Okay. You know, in light of the conversation we had earlier, I think someone alluded to this.
1:37:02 But, you know, wondering whether there's perhaps, if we're having a hard time sourcing a buyer and or tenant, whether there could be, we could think about first responders as being another population to reach out to. For ownership. Yes. Yes, that's a great point. Or for transitional use. Yeah, it's interesting because I know the fire chief is aware of that unit.
1:37:41 But maybe hasn't shared it with his staff, so maybe I could just work on that communication. Yes, so I think as we move through those clients that we have, if there's a need for that, then I will definitely access that. The next part of the staff report is some of the outstand or grants that we currently have.
1:38:35 mostly related to some projects that we have ongoing. The first is Access Apartments. We've been working with our financial consultant through Zen Development Consultants to work towards the financial closing for this project. So we've been meeting bi-weekly with the construction lender. I need to order an updated appraisal.
1:39:02 And we need to get updated cost estimates so that we can get everything in line for an April closing and construction start. So that's something I've been spending time doing, refining the construction loan budget, how the sources are going to work in parallel.
1:39:28 And then getting everybody to the table. So we're planning to have our first all-on-board financial closing call the first week in December. And then in concert with that, we're also working towards opening the public bid process for the general contractors to bid on that project in December as well.
1:39:57 So there's been some work ongoing around the bid packet and what that process looks like so that we can get the general contractors to submit their bids and have a bid opening and working with the town to help facilitate that. I think that's it on Access Apartments unless there's any specific questions. Moving forward to Project Home Key.
1:40:40 We, let's see, we've been, the development committee has been very active working with the general contractor and the subcontractors to get some value engineering done on the bid. The bid came in about, it's approximately a million dollars over what was in the budget. So we've been working through that and
1:41:11 We have submitted our plans for the first round of plan check comments to get the building permit and those have come back so the architect has been working through those. You'll notice at the end of the staff report I put together a little overview of the project because I have been trying to do a little
1:41:35 Fundraising to try and fill that million-dollar gap, so I did reach out to the Altera community, Altera company, Altera Mountain Company Community Foundation, and I asked them to throw in $200,000, and then I found out that their maximum grant is only $50,000, but I said, well, just whatever you have, so I'll let you know if they are going to contribute.
1:42:03 We also are working with the Continuum of Care to get some funding potentially for cost overruns at this project from some sources that they have available. And you can see the budget in the back and front handout that I supplied in the packet. But I think probably one of the most imminent issues around this project right now is we'd like to pull the demo permit
1:42:37 Because we can do that before we pull the construction permit. But we think the demo, I think the demo contract is something like $60,000. But we don't necessarily want to sign off on that if we know that we're facing a million dollar gap. So there's a little like chicken or the egg and some risk there. And so...
1:43:04 I think imminently we'll be having some conversations with the town around the value engineering opportunities and what cost savings we might have and if there's any funding available to help support this project move forward. Are there any questions about that? Okay. So we were awarded a Cal Home Award for mortgage assistance and ADU construction loans.
1:43:42 As well as rehabilitation loans. And I'm in the process of setting that up with HCD. So hopefully that will be available soon. And if not soon, then hopefully definitely by the spring so people can start doing construction. Let's see.
1:44:14 Oh, I guess the last thing I wanted to say in my update was I appreciated everybody coordinating on the special meeting that we had on October 26th regarding a potential property acquisition and I wanted to let the board know that unfortunately that opportunity fell through and the seller opted to go with another buyer and so we don't have that opportunity.
1:44:42 to acquire 14 one-bedroom apartments in June Lake. I think ultimately it came down to the owner's inability to self-manage it into the winter with our proposed 90-day escrow period and the other buyer waived the appraisal and the inspection and so for the seller it just turned out
1:45:12 to be a better opportunity. And I think that they're going to actually close escrow very early in December, which gives the seller that security of not having to maintain it through our proposed escrow period, which I believe was 90 days. So I just wanted to thank everybody for that. I thought that it was pretty amazing how quickly Mono County
1:45:42 Was able to authorize a potential acquisition loan, and how quickly the MLH Board was able to assemble and support that possible acquisition, so unfortunately that didn't work out. I think that's probably the most exciting stuff in my staff report, but I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions? No questions? I'm not seeing any hands. We'll move to...
1:46:21 Committee reports, not seeing any hands. If there are no committee reports, board member reports, if there are no board member reports, we'll move to closed session. Pursuant to government code section 54957, the board will hold a closed session to consider the evaluation of performance of an employee title executive director.
1:47:06 So we have two closed sessions. Two closed, I'm not going to read the second one. It's quite lengthy. It's the executive director's fringe benefits and salary. And so for those online, I sent a separate Zoom link, and so you can join that link now, and then you'll have to rejoin the public link when we come back to open session. Thank you. Thank you.
2:45:13 Well, it just sounds like they make two announcements. Agenda item number nine, consideration of merit pay increase for the executive director based on the performance evaluation conducted by the board of directors in accordance with the organization policy, as well as consideration of the cost of living increase. The board has gone into closed session and has made two proposals. One is a
2:46:21 Base salary increase of $13,652, and a bonus of $5,000. Okay, so I just want to confirm you went to item 9, but is that your report out on the closed session then? Correct. And then we'll go to... No, because it has to be agendized. So I would make a motion to approve the figures presented by Chair Stapp. I'll second.
2:47:01 Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Can I just have you read the dollar amounts and what the different amounts are? The base salary increase is $13,652 and the bonus is $5,000. Lindsay, second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Roll call. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Greitz? Aye. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes.
2:47:54 Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Nettle? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. That's the end of the business for this evening. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everyone.