Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2022
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
249 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:42 President, staff? Vice President Kreitz? Present. Board Member Barksdale? Here. Board Member Hodges? Here. Board Member Vianzen? Board Member Perkins? Present. Board Member Steenstra? Board Member DeAndrea? Present. And Board Member Nettle? Thank you. Do you want to make any comments? No, we have an update on this item under Policy Matters. Okay. Do we need to adopt it though?
5:02 I think so, yeah, that's what I was asking. Okay, I'll make a motion to adopt resolution. I'll second. 2226. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Thank you. Move to public comments. Are there any public comments? No public comments at this time.
5:41 I have a comment. I wanted to ask the president if we could move item 5.12 to directly following item 5.7. We'll move to policy items. I'm jumping ahead of myself. Approve the, if there are any corrections, any additions to the consent agenda, if I can have a motion.
6:34 I move to approve the minutes from the November 7th meeting 2022. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Roll call, please. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to policy item 5.1.
7:08 5.1, the board will receive an update on the COVID-19 public hearing, Emergency Brown Act Amendment, AB 361, ending February 28, 2023. Great. This is an update that was requested by the board of directors at our last meeting in November regarding the expiration of the
7:38 Public Health Emergency and the amendments made to the Public Meetings Act, also known as the Brown Act. Under AB 361, remote or hybrid meetings were generally accepted under this process of adopting the Public Health Emergency Resolution every 30 days. After February 28th, AB 361 will expire and we'll go back to
8:09 The rules under the original previous Brown Act requirements. Those requirements are that you may still attend remotely. However, it needs to be in a publicly accessible location and it needs to be advertised on the agenda as a location where the public can join you and make public comment if they so wished.
8:42 And so we will, after February 28th, we will need to go back to our previous meeting traditions of meeting in person unless otherwise noticed on the agenda for the public to attend elsewhere. This is an informational item for the board, but I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions from the board?
9:13 I guess I just want to confirm, because this is actually news to me, and I shared this with our county council, that you had an either-or. I was under the impression you had to fall under the new AB 2449. So I was glad to read this, because the Brown Act prior to AB 2449 was actually, I think, more lenient in some way, because there was no limit on how many times you could
9:43 But if should something happen, an emergency,
10:13 Because there are those two caveats, emergency and accommodations, I believe, for a shorter notice without having to declare your location or allowing the public in. So it sounds like we could use either. So anyway, that's more of a comment, I guess, a little bit, or if I'm misunderstanding it, let me know. But that was my interpretation of what Goldfarb had created for us. Yeah, that's correct.
10:44 I do think that there is some more nuance in the memo that I didn't mention, but I do hope that the board reads the memo, and if they have any questions to let me know. Yeah, just to sort of clarify on that, because the remote sort of emergency situation is limited to two times per calendar year. Is that correct? But if you have sort of, you know you won't say you're out of town.
11:15 You can put on the agenda your location and there's no limit to that number of times doing it. That would be like the previous pre-COVID way. Yes, that's correct. Perfect. Yeah, thank you. Are there discussion? Looking at the memo, it does make note that one of the other conditions was so long as a quorum of members of MLH's board of directors is participating from locations within the agency's jurisdiction.
11:50 Like tonight, there's four of us here, Tony's and Bishop, which is within our jurisdiction, correct? Is that stipulated or does it have to be feet on the ground here in suite Z? See, but it also, a further up paragraph mentions, to utilize the provisions of AB 2449, a majority of the members of the legislative body must participate in person from the same physical location identified in the agenda posted for the meeting. So that, I...
12:20 I've heard that from our county council, like you have to be at that location. It would need to be at least five of us here to have a quorum. Yeah, a quorum. A majority, yeah, which would be a quorum, yes. Yeah. Okay. If we're using AB 2449. And I think the Brown Act is just the same, actually, I believe. You couldn't have a quorum remoting in. It would have to be less than a quorum remoting in.
12:53 Yes, which was our traditional way of doing it. Exactly. Yes. Okay. Do we need to do some sort of RSVP for meetings, just to confirm then beforehand that we'll have enough people in person, or do you have a handle on that? Yes, normally when I send out the agenda packet, I ask folks to RSVP so I know how many dinners to get. I don't always get RSVPs, so I suppose if, well, if you're planning to attend remotely,
13:24 For a reason unknown to me in advance, I would still need to know at least a week before so I could notice the meeting appropriately. Otherwise, you can be absent from, I think, three meetings. So it's not a requirement that you remote in. Unless we need a quorum. But things happen, so you can't predict everything. Looks like Brian's going to do more skiing this winter.
13:57 He wishes. Maybe you can split it. I'm rubbing my head around this. Half and half. Other discussion? Do we need to take any action on this? No. Just information? I guess I just would just state the obvious maybe and for the benefit of everyone is that we won't have to deal with this until the first meeting in March or until our regular meeting in March.
14:29 We're good for January and February meetings and it might not be a bad idea to, I don't know, maybe even just have this as an informational item again on our February agenda just in case any other questions or new revelations come up between now and then so that we're ready to go right into our March meeting. Yeah, that's great. So we can kind of digest the information and figure out what strategies. And we might learn new things. I mean, I feel like anytime you're kicking off a new...
14:59 New policy, if you will. Yeah, it could be a little wobbly. Thank you. Sorry to interrupt. We'll move to agenda item 5.2, review and approve the Mammoth Lake Housing, Sierra Housing Advocates, LLC, fiscal year 21-22, fourth quarter draft financial statements. Patricia. Thank you. We did spend some time putting these together. We've had some technical difficulties, which delayed.
15:33 Delayed my review of the financials, but we were able to put something together to show the board this evening. The first report that you'll see is the Mammoth X Housing Statement of Financial Position. You see the cash went up from the end of the last fiscal year, June 30th, to the end of the first quarter, September 30th, about $40,000.
16:06 You'll see our HBA Cal Home Loans balance going down as our clients make their payments. You'll see our properties, 238 Sierra Manor Road, the Meridian Court Condominium, and the Star Apartments. And then you'll see the investments in the LLCs. And so I've been working with our legal counsel to establish sole member LLCs for all of our affordable housing projects.
16:42 And so at the moment we have Valley Apartments LLC, which you'll see the $10,000 deposit to escrow. Sierra Housing Advocates is where we're holding the Birch Creek Condo in June Lake and the Innsbruck Lodge LLC. So these are monies that MLH has invested on behalf of these LLCs since
17:13 The Valley Apartments, LLC, and the Innsbruck Lodge, LLC, don't currently have any assets of their own, except in the case of Innsbruck, the property itself.
17:30 Financial Report, because it's the end of June, and it was purchased in September, I believe, or August? It will be on the Innsbruck Lodge LLC financial statement. Oh, okay. Which we don't have this quarter. There just hasn't been a lot of activity, and so we can provide that in the next quarter if that's something the board would like to see. But this $61,000 will stay on the books here? Yeah, so...
17:55 Talking with the accountant, we have historically logged all of MLH's investments in the LLCs on the MLH books as an investment. I think in some years past, we have reconciled them during the audit and put them to zero at the direction of the board, I believe. So I think it's just a matter of how the board wants to see it, I think, on paper. So for now, it's showing as an investment.
18:25 of money, of actual money, into the LLCs for those projects. And if at some point we don't feel like it's necessary to see how much MLH has invested, we could reconcile it during the audit or at another time. And then each LLC will have its own financial statement. And if you think about moving forward in the next couple of years, those financial statements will become more complex.
18:55 Similar to the Sierra Housing Advocates LLC, but will show rental revenue, expenses, depreciation, and all of those things for each project independently. So we can anticipate you spending more time on these with the accountant, it sounds like. Yes, so we did broach that conversation when I was speaking to her, and she's...
19:25 She assured me that she has the capacity and it certainly will add some time to my plate. I think not necessarily in the near term as much, but definitely in the next couple of years. And then does her time get broken out by LLC as well? We talked about that also because I do think that we need to allocate those types of expenses across the portfolio.
19:49 So we talked about a couple of different ways we could do that, and so we haven't landed on the best practice that we've chosen yet, but we are throwing that idea around. I also think that each asset should contribute to legal expenses and also the annual audit. All of those expenses can now be allocated across the portfolio. I'm no expert, so is this more just me just asking questions?
20:18 As I think about the growth of the organization and the additional expenses of having more LLCs, I know that, for example, the Star Apartments, they pay asset management fee and management fee, and so I would imagine that those costs are recouped out of those fees, and I don't know if a similar fee could be structured for each LLC, then you wouldn't have to.
20:47 But I don't know. And I trust you and the accountant and other board input on how best to do that. I don't have the answers. It's more me thinking, brainstorming, and I apologize if that's off the mark. No, that's helpful. We do collect an asset management fee, and we have budgeted those into our new projects as well. And so I guess it's a matter of digging into how we want to spend those fees collected. But that's a good question, something to think about.
21:21 Brian may have some experience and suggestions and so I don't presume to know it all. You know, I don't know if these LLCs we've set up will require financial audits. I think they probably do based on the funding sources that we've received. So if that's the case, then certainly the cost of preparing the audit will become an operating cost that we need to budget for on an ongoing basis.
21:52 And to the extent there's any additional accounting fees or costs that we incur that we wish to allocate, I think we would just push those through on some type of an allocated basis as an operating cost and get MLH reimbursed. Great. Thank you. Moving down the report, you'll see our liabilities. And so you see our loan for 238 Sierra Manor Road and the payments that we've been making. You'll see the loan for Star Apartments is the 853.
22:30 And you'll see the Oak Valley loan is our mortgage on our office space. And then you'll see at the bottom our assets. So we have a risk reserve, a replacement reserve for Star Apartments, a reserve for 238 Sierra Manor Road, which we have been using for project costs for construction in progress. And then we have
23:02 An operating reserve of $60,000, which is for the Access Apartments project and was a grant we received from the Continuum of Care, previously operated by IMACA, and so that $60,000 is an operating reserve to help cover any vacancies or issues with not collecting the full amount of rents that we're able to collect.
23:30 So that's there to protect us in that case. We do have a reserve for CalHome program reuse. We actually have a standard agreement for our current CalHome award that we received for all of Mono County for rehab or ADU construction loans and also first-time homebuyer mortgage assistance loans.
24:01 Or actually mortgage assistance loans. I don't think you have to be a first-time homebuyer. Anyways, we're working to set up the guidelines right now, and so that's sort of a work priority at the moment as we get everything we need to meet our setup conditions and get that grant ready to use. And so we can't use our CalHom reuse at the moment, but once we set up the new grant, I think then we'll be able to use it more freely. Okay, well that's the first report. Let's see.
24:33 The next one is the statement of activities. Oh, okay, so there is one thing we didn't move on here. I guess I hadn't planned to make a lot of comments on this report just because it's only the first quarter and it's hard to gauge where we'll be next quarter. However, you will see under revenue emergency rent assistance $50,000. That's actually
25:04 An advance from Mono County for the housing navigator position. And so we just need to put that in the right place. And you can see there is a line item for navigator services, Mono County, and that line item is zero. I don't have any other comments at this time unless there's any questions. Questions from the board? Patricia, just a very minor cleanup. I think the header of the statements should say,
25:43 For quarter ending September 30th, 2022, right? Yes. Okay. No other comments or questions, though. I think this looks good to me. Thank you. Yeah, just one other small edit. The column 930 says 2023 on it. Yes. And so we did talk about some of these corrections already. I think the accountant was having a hard time with our technical difficulties.
26:18 I apologize for those minor typos. Moving on, we have the forecast, which is so small you probably can't read it unless you zoom in. Diane and I haven't had a chance to really fill in the blanks on this, and so when I see her tomorrow, we can discuss putting in some numbers to try to predict where we can be at the end of the fiscal year. And then the statement of cash flow is a very interesting report.
26:57 That calculates back in non-cash or financing activities back into the balance sheet. And so you'll see depreciation, prepaid insurance, things like that being added back in and then cash investments going back out or investment activities being
27:27 Subtracted. And then at the end, you can see the net change in cash, which is that $40,000. We can go to Sierra Housing Advocates, which has traditionally been our LLC for real estate transactions. Let's see. We have some loans with the town of Mammoth Lakes that you'll see coming and going on this statement.
28:08 We paid off the San Joaquin Villas C5 loan when we sold that unit to an eligible household. And then you'll see we still have the La Vista Blanc loan through the bridge program with the town of Mammoth Lakes. Then you'll also see rental properties. So these are assets held by this LLC. One is a condo at Meridian Court and one is, yeah, is the Birch Creek condo in June Lake.
28:52 And then at the bottom you'll see members' equity, which is negative. And we had a conversation about this and now it slipped my mind and I don't have my notes with me. So that would be the line item that would show the amount that MLH as the member has invested into the LLC. There is a reason why it's negative and it has something to do with, I think, the reimbursement from escrow.
29:32 That was deposited into the MLH account, but that was owed to Sierra Housing Advocates, and so I'm pretty sure that's what it has to do with for the Birch Creek condo. And then you'll see on the Statement of Activities, normally
29:56 This LLC does not have a lot of income or revenue, but you will see $30,000 coming in. That is a replacement reserve that was invested by Mono County to ensure that the property was maintained, brought up to standard at acquisition, and so we have done a few.
30:21 Minor repairs there, but there is a long-term tenant, and so those funds are to, you know, maintain the property. There's a few things that need to be done in the long term, including replacing the carpet, fixing the staircase, which is not to code, and a few things that we want to take care of, and so that's what that $30,000 is for. And then you will see now a small amount of rental revenue, which is coming in from our tenant at Birch Creek Condo.
31:01 Is on the wait list for the parcel? I don't know off the top of my head if he's on the wait list for the parcel, but he is on our waiting list for permanent affordable housing. It might be worth giving them that number or encouraging them to apply for the parcel wait list, since that will be available pretty soon, relatively soon. Just a thought, since it's a transitional unit. Yeah, absolutely.
31:41 Well, I mean, I'll mention since we're on that item, there is some risk of having a transitional unit because it will continue to incur costs without rental revenue. And we are, we, we.
32:00 IMACA did allocate some funds for an operating reserve at this location that are still in limbo after they sort of closed down their housing programs. And so I've been trying to figure out the status of those operating funds because I think that's a key component of holding a transitional unit and being able to cover those operating expenses. But yes, it's certainly not transitional if you're in it.
32:30 He's been in about just over a year, I believe. That's all I have on the financial statements. Questions? Do you need a motion on this? Yes, I think actually we do normally approve the financials with the motion and the motion could include, you know, I have to make a few typo corrections, obviously. I've moved to approve the items.
33:14 Under agenda item 5.2 with the stated corrections. All second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? President Snap? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Nuttall? Yes. Thank you.
33:48 Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item 5.3, adopt resolution 2022-27 to apply for funding through the portfolio reinvestment program in an amount not to exceed $5 million for the Valley Apartment Preservation Project in Bishop.
34:10 Thank you. These two items, 5.3 and 5.4, are a result of our submission of our application to the Portfolio Reinvestment Program for the possible acquisition of the Valley Apartments in Bishop. This grant will allow us to rehabilitate the property and bring it up to standard before renegotiating the existing debt on the property with
34:40 The State Department of Housing and Community Development. And so after we submitted our grant application, we got a very prompt email, which I was very happy about, with a few outstanding items. One included these resolutions, which the board has previously adopted. However, there's been a change to the date of the NOFA, I think. And so there really is no change other than
35:12 A minor correction of the date. HCD had posted a new template resolution to their website before we went back, after we adopted the resolutions, basically. And before we realized it was there and we submitted the application and now we need these revised resolutions. That's how it works. And so,
35:47 One, this resolution is from the board of Mammoth Lakes Housing, and the next item is from the Valley Apartments LLC, which we've established authorizing the grant application. Yes. Do you want to make a motion? I'll make a motion to adopt resolution 2022-27 to apply for funding through the portfolio reinvestment program in an amount.
36:25 Not to exceed $5 million for the Valley Apartments Preservation Project in Bishop, California. I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Berksdell? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes.
37:11 And Board Member Nuttall. Yes. Thank you. We'll move to Agenda Item 5.4. Adopt Resolution 2022-28 to allow the Valley Apartment Affordable Housing, LSE, to participate in the application for funding through the Portfolio Reinvestment Program in amount not to exceed $5 million for the Valley Apartments Preservation Project in Bishop.
37:39 And so this is the similar resolution which the board has previously adopted with the amended NOFA date and this resolution is coming from the Valley Apartments Affordable Housing LLC which has been established as a sole member LLC by Mammoth Lakes Housing. So I'll make a motion to adopt resolution 2022-28.
38:07 to authorize Valley Apartments, affordable housing, LLC, to participate in the PRP funding program and the amount not to exceed $5 million for Valley Apartments. I'll second the motion. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? I guess, I just, do we know an ETA, when the program's over the counter, I believe, right? Any ideas? I will submit our outstanding items tomorrow morning.
38:43 The rep was very responsive, so I know she's already taken a preliminary look at our application, so I was hopeful at that, and so I think once I send these things, she's going to assess if we pass threshold and then go from there, so I think it could be sometime in January. Okay. I'm very hopeful. Yeah, me too. Thank you. It could also be six months from now.
39:14 All right. Thank you. Further discussion? Okay. Roll call. Roll call. President Stepp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Berksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Board Member Nuttall? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item. Which one is it?
39:49 5.5. Adopt resolution 2022-29, authorizing a loan extension for loan number 19, PDLP, 14481, California Housing and Community Development, a pre-development loan for Silver Peaks. Thank you. This is another very interesting business item for us to consider this evening.
40:15 As you know, Mammoth Lakes Housing entered a partnership agreement with Visionary Home Builders for the pending affordable housing development in Bishop, California called Silver Peaks. The project will provide 70 low-income affordable apartments and two manager's units. For your background information,
40:42 We entered this partnership during IMACA's dissolution of their housing programs, and so we stepped in to take the place of IMACA in this partnership. The partnership agreement has been executed and is in place, and so the partnership took out two pre-development loans which were used to help acquire the land for this project.
41:10 Which also was the result of very lengthy negotiations with LADWP. And so these pre-development loans have both, or will both become due very shortly. And the partnership, both members of the partnership need to agree to the extension of these loans in order to continue to apply for funding for this project. I guess in terms of the timeline, I could let you know that the
41:43 The Visionary Home Builders did apply in the last round for a multifamily housing program for $19.5 million. It's unknown at this time if that grant will be received, but if it is, then they're going to move forward in the first round of tax credits and then also apply for the next round of home funds and hope to start construction in quarter one of 2024.
42:11 So, it's a very exciting opportunity, and I know I'm excited about it, and Visionary's very excited about it, and so this is our timeline as of now. Obviously, if we don't get awarded funds, the timeline can change, but imminently, we need to consider approving these loan extensions so that we don't have to pay back the loans at this time. The only asset
42:40 That the partnership owns is the land, and so if we don't agree to the loan extension, the loans would have to be paid off, and the only asset is really the land. And so I'm recommending that the board approve the loan extension. This loan through the State Department of Housing and Community Development is, the current balance is $844,666.
43:09 And is accruing interest at 3%. And I provided the loan modification terms for your reference. And I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions from the board? Patricia has, out of curiosity, has Visionary already approved these extension requests?
43:36 Yes, that's correct. They had approved them and then sent to me for my signature, and I let them know that we needed to work through the board to get the loan extensions approved, and so they're just waiting on us. Thank you. Well, it's the pleasure of the board. I make a motion to adopt Resolution 22-30, authorizing the loan extension for this pre-development loan for Silver Peak's estate in the agenda.
44:16 29. 29. Oh, you're right, I sure did. Look at us. Yep. Yeah. 2022. I'll second the motion to adopt resolution 2022-29. Roll call. President Stapp. Yes. Vice President Kreitz. Yes. Board Member Berkstow. Yes. Board Member Hodges. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. And Board Member Nuttall.
44:53 Yes. Thank you. Motion passes. We'll move to agenda item 5.6, adopt resolution 2022-30, authorizing a loan extension for loan number 6316-SP-01, Rural Community Assistance Corporation, a pre-development loan for Silver Peaks. Great. And so under this item, you'll see the same staff report, which outlines
45:22 The two loans that the partnership currently has for this project in place. This loan is with Rural Communities Assistance Corporation. The total amount is $236,450. It is accruing interest at 5.25%, and Visionary Home Builders is making interest-only payments to date.
45:52 So the loan balance remains the same. And RCAC has agreed to a loan extension through July 2024. Discussion? Just a date check. It says in here, this modification letter agreement is open to acceptance by the borrower until 5 p.m. on November 23, 2022.
46:25 Yes, and so they've given us extra time to hold our board meeting. Okay. And our CAC is aware that we're having this meeting this evening, and they didn't want to amend the letter. They just said, send us what you have when you get it. Perfect. Thank you. I'll make a motion to adopt the resolution, this time 2022-30, as stated in the agenda. I'll second the motion. And moved and seconded. Further discussion? President and staff? Yes.
47:02 Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Nuttall? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item 5.7. The board will receive an update regarding the project Home Key Innsbruck Lodge affordable housing project. I'm sorry, I can't hear. Sorry, my microphone was off.
47:52 So, as you know, Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town of Mammoth Lakes did apply and were awarded round two project home key funds in the amount of $4.56 million. However, $150,000 of that would only be given to us if we acquired full occupancy within eight months, which we know we're not going to achieve. And so here I've put the amount as $4.41 million.
48:17 And this was for the acquisition and rehabilitation of the Innsbruck Lodge into 15 studio apartments and one manager's unit. I have the timeline of the project in the staff report. I think where we're at right now is December, January. We have a funding gap, which I can get to in a moment. And so we'll be looking to fill that funding gap.
48:46 As soon as possible so that we can start construction. The funding gap does have the potential to delay the project. And so we'll be working on filling that gap as soon as possible. Also, we are planning to acquire some storage containers to put all the furniture, remove all the furniture from the building so that the rehab can take place.
49:16 And it sounds like we could get some containers here by December 19th. So that's a staff work program item that we're working on to execute a contract with the storage container provider and then get some movers into the property to remove the furniture. And then ASAP, once we have all of the funding secured, we would like to execute the contract with the general contractor.
49:47 The board will approve the contract for execution, and then we can pull our building permit and start demo, you know, optimistically, I think, probably early February, and so we just want to work quickly, and we have had some delay at the building permit level with some
50:20 Questions about whether or not we need to bring the building up to current building code standards and whether or not the design guidelines provided by the state are sufficient. And so we've had some back and forth and that just takes time. And so we're working through that and hopefully we'll be able to pull the building permit as soon as we fill the funding gap. We are expected to complete construction by May 17th.
50:54 which is 12 months from the date of award. We will be asking for an extension. I can't think of what it is off the top of my head, but we are submitting a grant report, and in that report, it does ask if you have any timeline requests, and so we'll be putting those in that report, which is due the end of this week, I think. Anyways, Diane and I are working on that.
51:24 And then we are expected to achieve full occupancy by July 17th, and so we'll be asking for an extension on that just to make sure we have enough time to complete everything we'd like to complete. And we hadn't considered how long it would take to get through the building permit process, and so that is just causing some delay.
51:52 We did choose a general contractor and we have been working with the development committee through a value engineering process to bring down the cost of the rehab. I think it originally came in at 2.7 and we're down to about 2.3 so we have found some cost savings and I appreciate all the time and effort that the development committee has put into trying to
52:20 Find cost savings as a way to help fill the ultimate funding gap. On the next page of this staff report you'll see the budget. The most important column I think really is the final development budget. You'll see the acquisition had some acquisition costs associated with it. We have the rehab down to 2.3. This will be pending
52:57 Our response from the town on whether or not we can interpret the building code maybe more loosely in light of the funding for this project. It just depends on where there's flexibility and where there's not. But that's the number we're hopeful for. And then you'll see soft costs, permit fees. And so we did hear from the fire chief at our last meeting about a possible fee waiver.
53:29 A fee in lieu of services. And so I need to circle back with him because we could potentially have some cost savings there. I have moved, in our original application we had allocated $30,000 to operating reserve. But because this project should pencil and generate revenue, I'm going to ask to move that $30,000 into rehab line item. And so that's why it's zero in that column.
54:06 And then we have contingency of $120,000 for a total development cost of $6.7 million. And then as you can see in the column to the left, which is the awarded budget, this is the amount of funding that we have access to at the moment, which is $6.3 million. And you'll see the funding gap is $480,111. The second, oh, do you have a comment, Tony?
54:37 Yeah, I noticed the biggest difference is in the architecture and the soft cost. We already invested a significant amount of that and why are the architecture fees so high? The line item includes a lot of things. I don't have it pulled up but I could provide a breakdown of that. Let me see if I can find that and I can provide a breakdown of that. Sure.
55:34 Has a lot of that been invested already, or is there a way we can maybe figure out how to cut back some of those architectural fees? Yes, I mean, we have been paying the architects and the development consultants, project manager, out of the soft cost line item, and I think the idea is that MLH would be reimbursed for those costs spent up front. Thanks.
56:11 The second table just shows the sources of funding that we've been able to secure. So you'll see the Project Home Key Grant from the state, the $1 million contributed from the town, $550,000 from Mono County, and $343,000 from the Continuum of Care. For those of you who don't know, and I've been trying to...
56:36 Say it at every meeting, but the continuum of care is our regional homelessness prevention consortium, and so it has the same service area as Mammoth X Housing, which is in Yomono and Alpine counties, and they do have a board and stakeholders that participate in their meetings, but they do have access to
57:03 Different funding sources that we don't necessarily have direct access to. And so I've been able to partner with the Continuum of Care to identify resources that they have access to that could potentially benefit our permanent affordable housing projects. And so in this line item, the Continuum of Care had some homelessness and housing assistance program dollars from around
57:35 One and round two left over that hadn't been allocated. And so they had a budget process where they allocated those resources to some of our projects and also had a line item for cost overruns at permanent affordable housing projects. And so this amount is an amount that we agreed upon that they could support this project because this project will serve primarily
58:06 Homeless individuals or households who are potentially living in their cars or in other unhealthy situations. The goal of the Project Home Key Grant is to house homeless individuals. And so we will be required to select our tenants from the Coordinated Entry System, which is a regional waiting list of individuals prioritized by need.
58:35 And we'll be taking all of our tenants for Innsbruck Lodge from that list. And we've already entered two clients onto that list, and we have another appointment on Wednesday to enter a third client. So I don't see a problem. I mean, I don't think we're going to have a problem filling those units with folks experiencing homelessness. But that's where that $343,000 comes from. And that results in...
59:04 The gap of $480,111. Let's see. I think this is an update item, so I think we can talk about this project, or if you have any questions or comments or suggestions, we can talk about that. Question from the board. Patricia, I see that the request for the funding
59:50 amount from Altera Company was denied. Is it worth going back with a lower amount or the request as a whole was denied? So the request as a whole was denied and I think in some ways we were very fortunate to receive the contribution that they made to access apartments. What I was told was that their community foundation is really for
1:00:19 Individuals or small businesses or community organizations in crisis. And so individuals facing homelessness could apply. I don't know, maybe a business that had a fire maybe could apply. But that it wasn't really for investments in projects.
1:00:49 You know, that's not in crisis, although you could say that it is, I feel like it is, it feels like a crisis to me. But from their perspective, it wasn't the type of opportunity that they wanted to spend their funds on. Thank you. Any other questions? Are there any other grants or requests that could be submitted at this time, or do you already have a sense of
1:01:26 How we close that funding gap? Is it something that we can assist it all with? That's a great question. So we have four Access Apartments applied for grants through our local banking institutions. Both Union Bank and Eastern Sierra Community Bank have contributed to Access Apartments fundraising initiative.
1:01:56 Small amounts, I think, under $10,000 each. And so I've been sort of thinking about the time it would take me to, you know, fundraise those dollars and is it worth my time or should I be focusing my time on the building permit and getting the furniture out and because it's not a good return on our investment of my time, I don't think, but
1:02:25 If there are specific fundraising requests that the board would like me to pursue, I'm happy to do that. It's just sort of been moving full steam ahead and it doesn't seem like the kind of project we can wait around and do fundraising for. And so I am planning to...
1:02:51 Get on the Town Council agenda for one of their meetings in January to ask if there are any additional funds that the Town would like to contribute to this project. This project is a joint project between Mammoth Lakes Housing and the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and we're both equally liable to fulfill our contractual obligations to the state under the grant program.
1:03:18 And so I think it's just a matter of collaboration and cooperating on trying to fill this funding gap. Patricia, I can just add from kind of the industry perspective that what we're experiencing at MLH on Homekey is actually, it's become a very common issue across Homekey awardees, the amount of time it's taking to get to local building permits.
1:03:50 The escalation pressures that we're all facing in the industry. I know my own organization has had to go back and work with the county and the state to secure additional resources and extensions of time. Yeah, and I'll just add on to Brian, I mean, just from my professional perspective that, you know, the construction, the escalation of construction costs this year has been extraordinary and just beyond the ability to predict. I mean, it's really...
1:04:27 You might as well go gamble in Las Vegas because there's just no, it's just so hard to, you know, nothing's stable about it. It's just been increasing considerably. And obviously in view of the overall climate of inflation, but then, you know, on the construction industry, there's other issues that are causing even higher inflation levels, you know, resource restraints, you know, labor forces and so forth are dwindling.
1:04:56 So it's just getting harder and harder and more expensive as time goes on, clearly. And, yeah, that's, and I know being, having looked at our scope of work and things we tried to do and, you know, we did everything we could, but then there's things that the, necessarily that the, the building, the regulatory agencies, the building department's case or the California Building Code requires that you have to do that you wouldn't think you'd have to, but you do.
1:05:24 Those add scope work. So, you know, scope work, added scope on top of added inflation, and it's just an impossible task to guess where those prices are going to end up when you're putting out an app, fulfilling a grant application a year prior, right? It's just, the market's so volatile right now.
1:05:42 Yeah, thank you, and I was going to say, you know, just for reference, I didn't have it on the project timeline, but we did submit this application in January of last year, and so we're 12 months from the date of application, and at the date of application would have been when we assessed what we thought the cost would be, and
1:06:04 I had a conversation with our attorney about this today, and he's like, there's really no way you can even predict or build it into the budget in some ways because the state's going to ask for your documented cost estimate, okay, so you put your documented cost estimate into the application, and it has to match, the numbers have to match, you can't account for inflation or time, and so it's really not fair in many ways, but
1:06:35 That's how it works, I guess. Right, and the contingency doesn't even come close to touching it, right? There is a contingency line item. Right, and traditionally it's about 10%, and if you make it 50% or 100%, then it's not going to be accepted. Oh, yeah, of course not. Right, and so, you know, we put in a contingency of 10%, which seemed reasonable at the time and acceptable, and now, you know, costs are different and the reality is different.
1:07:03 And I think we'll be having a similar conversation about access apartments probably very shortly. But, you know, this gap, I think, is achievable. And so, you know, it's nerve-wracking, but I think we can get there. Further discussion? Do you need a motion or a direct, just simply information? Yes, this is informational. We'll move to, did you want to go to 5.12?
1:07:48 Yeah, that's probably a good time. Thank you. Oh. Consideration, consider approval of demolition contract for 913 Forest Trail Project Home Key site with Christian Hansen in the amount of $62,312. Okay, thank you. And so I think I have some more additional information on this item that's not in the staff report, but.
1:08:41 I am having weekly meetings with our project manager, Kevin Sherada from Zen Development Consultants, as well as our architects and the general contractor. During these meetings, we've been talking about the value engineering process, the building permit process, you know, and everything under the sun. So, you know, during those meetings, I think we started to feel like the momentum had
1:09:10 Slowed, and you know, we were just waiting for plan check comments, and it was like, well, can't we do anything while we're waiting, and you know, it stinks to just be sitting around, basically, and so we thought, well, maybe we could just start the demo, and I think there's a lot of pros and cons to that opportunity, and then I had my weekly meeting with the development committee, and we sort of
1:09:45 Talked about what it would take to actually start the demo and realized we need to have the storage containers, we need to get the furniture out before anything can get started. And so as of today, I think I can get the storage containers delivered by December 19th and the movers could probably get some, maybe finish moving everything out the following week before Christmas.
1:10:14 Or maybe after Christmas, before the new year. But then we're in January. And so in January, we're planning to have a conversation with the town about the funding gap. And also, yes, that's what I was going to say. And so then we should have our building permit. I'm like, what's the other thing? So we should have our building permit. And so then we could just start. And so I did put this item.
1:10:52 In the agenda packet to let the board know that the development team is anxious to get started, we're ready to go, we have a scope of work for the demo that could be started today if we had all the furniture out of the building. And so I think if the board would like, we could talk about the pros and cons of the demo, but it's really at the will of the board.
1:11:30 I think it's a good idea to get the ball rolling. The more we get the ball rolling, the less likely we are to be held up by the funding gap, in my opinion. And it says here that the risk of doing that is jeopardizing future options if we were to have to sell the property.
1:12:03 That's last option. So let's start moving forward. And I think even if we did, I think the demolition we're doing is going to be necessary for whoever bought it anyway. So if anything, it would be a good thing if we were to have to resort to selling the property again. But we get the ball rolling and that'll help.
1:12:34 see things in action and then we can hopefully resolve the problems and maybe the town will see that we're not in construction but we're in the process of doing this and they can do what they can to help us fill that funding gap. Yeah, I definitely agree with you, Tony, on that and having done projects for a long, long time and
1:13:02 Often having pulled demo permits myself, just to get started because things drag on, getting the full building permit and so forth, and you can buy yourself some time in the overall schedule. You know, we're asking for some relief from the state on the time frame, but we haven't gotten that yet. We think reasonably we should be getting that, but you know, even if it's buying us two weeks of effort in the field or three weeks,
1:13:31 I think it's worthwhile myself, and we're only going to obligate ourselves to this initial amount for this portion of the contract, and it's work that needs to be done. It shows commitment on our part, which hopefully will make the town supportive of considering some additional funding to help get this project over the hump. So I think there's a lot of good reasons to do it.
1:13:58 There's never a development project that doesn't have some element of risk involved, and I consider this fairly low, in my opinion. And, you know, we need to, I think I said in the development committee, and I always said, you have to cut peaches to make peach pie, and this is our time to start cutting peaches, so I think we need to get started. You know, I think we've done a lot of due diligence, and the contractor's ready to go, his resources are available.
1:14:28 And I don't see a reason to wait, in my opinion. Further discussion? Patricia, do you have a direction? I think I'd like to hear from all of the board if there's other comments. Any other comments from the board? I think Tom did a great job of summarizing kind of where the development committee concluded. So I'm supportive of proceeding.
1:15:08 Can you take action since this is a contract that exceeds your approval amount? Yes, and I spoke with our attorney about this this morning, and he said that the board could delegate authority to the executive director to negotiate the contract, maybe not to exceed the number in the staff report so that we have some public parameters to work around. So I think something like that would...
1:15:40 Suffice. I think a motion to delegate authority. I'll make a motion to delegate authority to the Executive Director to negotiate a demolition-only contract with Christian Hansen Construction, Inc. for the Project Home Key site at 913 Forest Trail in an amount in accordance with the staff report in the published agenda.
1:16:16 I'll second the motion. Further discussion from the board? Roll call. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Nuttall? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to
1:16:49 Agenda 5.8, the board will consider the merits of an application to the California Coalition for Rural Housing, Rural West Internship Program for Diversity and Non-Profit Housing and Community Development. Great, thank you. So I was recently notified that the application to CCRH to apply to host an intern in the coming year.
1:17:20 was open and that they were accepting applications, I think until December 18th. I sort of went back and forth in my mind about whether or not I was going to agendize this item, but I think being 50-50, it's a good time for the board to talk about if hosting an intern is a good thing to do at this time. We have hosted three interns in the past and this would be
1:17:50 Our fourth intern. Last year, we weren't able to successfully recruit an intern, but our current program and project associate, Eric Guzman, is our full-time employee that we were able to hire after he completed his internship. So it does show that the program is successful in developing young professionals in the community and housing development field. I think
1:18:23 Most of you are familiar with the program. I think I'll go to the budget analysis. So I took a quick look at the budget just regarding this item and in the current fiscal year we did allocate some developer fee to organizational operations which we haven't done in the past.
1:18:52 And so that's a subsidy of Mammoth Lakes Housing to just keep the doors open. And it's not an investment necessarily in new housing, so to speak. We did that in order to balance the budget so that we wouldn't have a negative net revenue at the end of the year. In addition,
1:19:23 Mammoth Lakes Housing also allocated $20,000 in net proceeds from the prior year towards operations as well. And so those are funds that we could be using to acquire new land or assets or pre-development costs on a project in Bridgeport or, you know, whatever creative idea we might have.
1:19:47 We've invested, the board decided to invest those funds in the operations of Mammoth Lakes Housing in the current fiscal year. I just sort of estimated what I thought our fiscal year 23-24 budget would look like if it was exactly the same. And I took out the developer fee and the Mammoth Lakes Housing investment and operations and I gave you an estimate of what our net income would be.
1:20:21 With an intern and without an intern. I will say I budgeted very conservatively on the grant administration side. I think in the recent year or two our grant admin funds have waned a little bit as we've sort of focused more on projects and less a little bit on programs. And so I
1:20:48 I put zero. That's really conservative. I think we will get some operating funds from the home grant for access apartments. I believe that's $100,000. I don't know when we can draw that. So it might not be. I think it could be right away. So if we are able to break ground and fill the funding gap, start construction on access in April, we could potentially get those funds right away from the home program.
1:21:20 However, I anticipate a funding gap at that site, and so I don't know if we're going to be able to break ground as soon as I would like in April. That could delay those funds, so we could get them, we might not. And so that's why I budgeted zero, which is pretty conservative, but I guess I wanted to sort of present maybe the worst case, what I thought might be the worst case scenario.
1:21:51 Have the board maybe think about what we want to do with our developer fee. I think it's okay if now is not the time, but strategically, is that an investment we want to continue to make in the organization? I think if the board is interested in hosting an intern, we could probably make it work. I like to be an optimist. But, you know, I said I was 50-50.
1:22:27 It is a lot of work to mentor an intern. We already have Eric, who I'm spending a lot of time with, and we also have a new housing navigator who will be coming on full-time in early February, and so we have two full-time staff people that I will be spending a lot of time with already, so I was sort of on the fence about the internship, but I wanted to discuss it with the board. I guess also I hadn't
1:23:07 Totally wrap my head around where they would sit in the office. So I was just thinking, wait, where are they going to sit? And Diane is only in the office one day a week now, so they would have to share her desk with her. It's valuable real estate. Desk space. Further discussion from the board? Patricia, you want a motion on this, or is it just a direction? Yeah, I think I'd like to hear if the board has an opinion either way.
1:23:42 The application is due December 16th. It's very easy. This will be my fourth or fifth time filling it out. The program operator, administrator is very familiar. We have a good relationship. And so I don't think doing the application is going to be an issue. And so if the board is interested in having an intern, I'm happy to fill out the application. A question about thinking about Eric and how he was a prior intern.
1:24:12 his role now at Mammoth Lakes Housing and would it be possible to look at the intern as shadowing Eric instead of taking your time to train but that they're really more shadowing him and he's more of the trainee or the trainer for the since he's been through that program? Yeah, that's something that could potentially work that I hadn't thought about.
1:24:41 I think I would have sincere reservation about supporting this if it meant you would have to be the primary trainer considering all the demands on your time at this time. But I think the program is really beneficial to our community, to our region, to affordable housing as a whole.
1:25:15 It wants to breed, if you will, affordable housing, developers, advocates, but more so, you know, operators of programs and creators of housing through development and with a focus on minorities and lower socioeconomic folks, I believe. That's my, yeah.
1:25:41 It is, and so I think that, you know, it's really noble, and it can be really helpful in our region. It's great that we've got Eric, and I know that I can't think of the other gentleman that went through the program, but, you know, that's knowledge still gained here, and so if we think we could find somebody that would want to do it, and it's possible for Eric to be kind of the lead, and I don't know if that's possible within his work, his work job description, but
1:26:11 That could be really great. That's all I have. That's an idea worth considering if you think Eric's ready to lead an intern, but otherwise it kind of sounds like it might be too much on your plate and might not be worth the time and effort. So I personally would let you take the lead on it.
1:26:44 Whatever you're the most comfortable with. Further discussion? Yes, please. Do you have any thoughts, Patricia, on why we were unsuccessful getting somebody in the last round? And are there things that we can change as we advertise for this program? And because I think as well, I would not want to really even spend any time on an application if we don't think we're going to find anybody.
1:27:22 It's a really good question. And, you know, we've been advertising our housing navigator positions for, I don't know, at least a year with, you know, difficulty filling those positions, and we have filled one, which is excellent. So I think that there's just a lot of jobs open, and this position is only 20 hours a week.
1:27:49 And I think you saw the hourly rate is only $18 an hour, which they did raise from last year, so that's good. But it's still not as much as you could make with tips or cleaning hotel rooms. So I think that's probably part of it. I think even young people, you know, at the college have jobs that they're probably making more.
1:28:22 And maybe if this isn't their field, or maybe they don't, maybe this isn't, you know, we don't have a community development department at the college, and so maybe this isn't their dream field, and it is complicated, and maybe they don't know, maybe we could, I could do, I could go, I could do a talk, maybe, that's something that we haven't done to explain what it is.
1:28:55 But those are my thoughts. Yeah, and that makes total sense. I mean, now many of the starting wage for a lot of jobs at the mountain is $20 an hour. Do we have any room? It does say maximum wages eligible. Is that $18 per hour? Do we have any ability to kick in more money from Mammoth Lakes Housing to increase that? Or is that a hard maximum to make it more?
1:29:25 That's a good question. I don't know, but I think it's a hard maximum because, well, you know, I'd have to ask. But then it brings me back to the budget. Are we mostly recruiting for this position from the community college, from students? We recruit at the Bishop Indian Job Center Workforce Development.
1:29:59 Program, which is housed, I believe, at the Cerro Coso in Bishop. We recruit at the college here in Mammoth. And we've also recruited in the past at Sierra College, which I believe is close to Lake Tahoe. We also put ads in the Chamber newsletter. I think last year Eric took the flyer to the Lions Club. We posted flyers. We put it on our Facebook.
1:30:30 Have we reached out to the broader, like, Kern Community College that oversees Cerro Coso to try to get more of their students that aren't here on Mammoth or Bishop campuses? I don't think for the internship, but we did post on their job board the housing navigator position, so that's something I could expand. We run the risk of bringing somebody in who doesn't have housing. Right.
1:31:01 Well, the other thing that CCRH has been flexible with us in the past and has said that we're willing to take any, really, you don't have to be a student. You could be a young person who wants to change careers, maybe just wants to taste, you know, what it's like. Maybe they don't want to, ultimately, maybe they don't want to stay on, that's up to them. But CCRH has allowed us to be more flexible in that way since we don't have direct access to a large population of
1:31:31 Students. Thank you. Further discussion? One more question, Patricia, just to confirm that the application, there's no cost to other than time commitment, correct? Yes, that's correct. Thank you. In thinking about the, because we have one housing navigator position available still, correct? Yes. In thinking about priorities, because potentially we're drawing the same people.
1:32:13 Is it more important to try to recruit for the housing navigator position or for this intern? That's a great question. I believe it would be more important to recruit for the housing navigator position because we have a contract with Alpine County to fulfill the services that we agreed to and that contract is $100,000 each for three years.
1:32:45 Which I think, just in terms of building our staff capacity, you know, we have clients coming in the door all day long, and having the navigators be able to be the first line of defense so that Eric and I can work on projects and programs, I think would be huge. I mean, right now Eric's really the front line, but he could certainly be focusing more on projects and programs.
1:33:18 Do you feel that it's the same candidates, though, that would be applying for an internship versus a housing navigator position? It could possibly be. The housing navigator that we just hired is a young college student. She applied for the housing navigator position and we offered her a full-time position. So it could potentially be. So if we had the intern, they couldn't.
1:33:56 Hold two positions, because the internship, the CCRH covers part of their wages, right? Yes, so the internship. If they wanted more hours, maybe we could get some from the intern position and some from the housing navigator position? Oh, hire one person for both positions? Yeah. I would have to ask that. So let me make a note.
1:34:34 And potentially ask, would that still, that maximum hourly rate still be restricted? Right. Further discussion? Yeah, I mean, I guess I'm still feeling a bit undecided about how I feel about this. I think the housing navigator position is also, like you said, funded for three years, where the internship is only one year, and then we would need, if we wanted to bring somebody on, we need to find funding for them.
1:35:22 I'm leaning a little bit toward really focusing on the navigator position, getting it filled, getting somebody on a longer term, but I do really appreciate this internship, like you've said, and Jennifer as well, that getting more people educated and experienced in housing is a great thing, so I'm feeling a bit torn on direction. I think I agree. The more we talk about this, the more I feel like this maybe isn't
1:35:54 Jennifer, I would echo that.
1:36:28 I think it's okay to say no this year, given our capacity challenges, the need to fill the navigator positions, we can always come back and reapply when Patricia has more capacity to take this on. You've got a lot on your plate in the year ahead with these construction projects, not to mention the new staff that you have already to both seat and manage. Any other discussion from the board? Patricia, do you have a direction? It sounds like I think we'll wait this year and
1:37:06 And talk about it again next December. Thank you. One last comment, Patricia, would be that perhaps there were some good ideas there about the places that you would advertise the internship and who you may go talk to. Maybe if perhaps you're not doing some of those areas right now for that housing navigator position, there's nothing stopping us from still going to those avenues and going but using those channels.
1:37:37 to try to fill the position that we're currently focused on trying to fill. Yes, thank you. It's a great reminder and I will do that because it's a priority to fill that position. Further discussion? Seeing any raised hands, we'll move to agenda item 5.9. The board will receive a presentation on the 20th anniversary rebranding. Patricia?
1:38:15 Thank you. In the packet I provided some slightly revised versions of the logo that the board sort of chose, I guess, at I think our last meeting with a few different color options. I know that the board had discussed the slate blue being acceptable.
1:38:43 But when I went back to the graphic designer, she felt like it was too much like the town, which is why she provided the town logo here. And then I sort of, you know, even though originally I was like, yeah, that's fine. And then I was like, well, maybe it's not. So I think, I think what I'm looking for is to see if there's a preference of color or if somebody really doesn't like.
1:39:13 I think it would be good to know that. Since we're moving forward with this logo, the next step is, you know, the color palette. And I think then we're going to jump into website. And so having those colors decided upon is pretty important. And I don't want to make a decision if somebody's like, no, I absolutely hate that. So I think it would just be good to know if you feel strongly either way.
1:39:43 And then I guess I'm leaning towards the bottom color palette with maybe a blue and an orange or a reddish orange to contrast. So if somebody really doesn't like that, it would be good to know. But I'm happy to hear the board's comments. And then the next page, I just sort of threw together some options about the windows. The board had discussed
1:40:14 Possibly deciding upon some values to represent the four windows in the logo. And I think a lot of times we say live, work, play, thrive. So that's in there. I try to use the thesaurus and find other words. We have partner, advocate, steward, innovation, resilience.
1:40:45 I don't know, those are kind of long and PhD, but anyways, they're in the packet for discussion if the board feels like it's time to do that, and if not, we could always talk about it at a later time. This isn't as urgent maybe as the colors, I guess is what I was trying to say. I personally don't like the color on the bottom row, that teal green. The dark green is okay, but I still like that.
1:41:23 Slate Blue, the best, and just the black and white as well. Any other comments? Well, I don't know if we're taking a vote, but I agree with Tony. I personally don't see any harm in having a color that's similar to the town of Mammoth Lakes, and it's not exactly the same. It's a little darker, but it's not like we're jockeying their style or trying to...
1:42:02 Steal anything from them, so I think the color is perfectly fine with me. I would just say that bottom one is out of the running, personally. And I don't know, the green, the green is okay, that dark green, but I don't see why it would be any better. Further discussion? Well, go ahead. I'd say that I really like the blue kind of drop.
1:43:02 And nondescript. Personally, I really like the color palette in the lower right-hand corner. So I would support using colors off of that wheel. I would agree. Further discussion? I'm not really any help. I kind of like them all. I don't have a strong opinion either way. I do like that color palette. I'm just trying to think about uses of the logo, you know, a big sign over the office.
1:43:49 You need to see if we see from Old Mammoth Road what really kind of sticks out. The building is brown. Most of the buildings in Mammoth are brown. So kind of what's a coordinating color to that and what kind of pops. Thinking about our website and other sort of just colors that might go in for accents and things. So that's sort of how I'm looking at it, thinking about it.
1:44:19 So, but I do like that whole palette on the lower right. Further discussion? Patricia, if you needed to wear a uniform, what color would you want to wear? If you needed a polo, polo shirt with some white embroidery, what color? Or a hat, a baseball cap. But like the town does black. Yeah, I was going to say black and white, maybe. Yeah, black and white or maybe the dark green on the bottom of the palette, I don't know.
1:45:02 Further discussion? I would just add that I think that that top C4421A is beautiful and I love the contrast of that and I think that it just is the right amount of orange, the right amount of red. I'm not a huge fan of the color below it, the kind of
1:45:31 Peachy one, I think it's a little washed out, personally. The rest of the colors on that color chart, I think are great. I would say I'm not as drawing towards the green, the second from the bottom, but I think that they're all very strong candidates. Well, I just like the top red. I mean, it's kind of not...
1:46:03 Super red, but that's what I like about it, actually. Yeah, it's like burnt sienna. Just the top, the top one on the chart. Yeah. What's that? Adobe. Yeah, I would say burnt sienna. And the last time we were talking about colors, I'm like, I really miss the red, so I'm a little partial myself. I think it's the right amount of red. I was not as partial to the peachy.
1:46:30 I like that color too. I'm not sure it would work so well with the logo though. And the bottom row, the teal green, and I don't mind it as the background, but when we have it as the font and the logo, I think it's just too light. It would probably work well with the color palette, but if we were to have that on a piece of paper with a white background, I think that
1:47:00 Teal green is too light and maybe too weak. That's great feedback. Thank you. And with regard to the red, in the process of looking at logos, we ruled out the sort of red, sienna, burnt sienna, whatever, because it's really the color of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation logo. Well, they are like fire engine red, I think. Kind of, but I'm just looking at their website right now, and it doesn't look that fire engine red.
1:47:32 It looks a lot like that top color on their website. So I don't know whether that... The color wheel on the bottom right though, these are just like secondary colors, right? That's what I was assuming. I'm not suggesting that the logo should be that red. I assumed that the primary color is one of the four and then the bottom right is a secondary and...
1:47:59 Yes. Third, whatever the word for that is, color chart. Yes, yeah. Right? Or was I like, did I misunderstand that? Yeah, no, I think your interpretation is right, and I think taking Tony's comments, maybe that bottom color in the palette is darker and, you know, could be more of the lead color, and the teal could be more of an accent if it's too light on white paper, for example, which I think is really good feedback.
1:48:29 So maybe I'll just take these comments and maybe try one more time. I mean, I think I have good direction and I heard what everybody said, but I don't want to make any bad decisions by myself. I kind of think you should go with it. I don't know. I mean, I don't think we need to be micromanaging. We gave you some impact. For me personally, I don't need to. Okay, we'll see what it looks like and then I'll decide. Yeah.
1:48:59 I do like that green when you type in the like 16594A and start to see it a little bit more. It has a nice... Yes, I do too. And just to confirm, sorry, I'm looking at it on a screen, so maybe in print it's better, but is the 16594A, which is the bottom right, is it? It's different from the green logo that's second from the bottom, right? Same. It looks like it's... Yeah.
1:49:28 I thought they were different as well. It's got a little bit more teal in it, but it's a little hard to tell. Yeah, I could definitely work with the designer on that to confirm. And then even maybe she can find some colors in between those two that just aren't here that maybe leads to a blue or green instead of a slate. So I think that's helpful.
1:49:56 Can I ask what's her opinion? What's the professional's opinion? She does like the bottom row. She's happy with the logo choice, and I think she likes the palette on the bottom as well. We always do have a favorite. We were going to use that bottom right color in that color palette.
1:50:34 Which I'm equating to the second row up from the bottom as the primary logo color and then the rest of those colors in the palette to complement it on the website. That would work for me. Tony, say that. Which one did you like? Sorry. The bottom right color, the 165948, if that's the color for the logo. And then the rest of the colors are complementary colors on the website.
1:51:06 The other colors in that palette, then that would work for me. But I think that one, that bottom color, 1659, is really the only one in that color palette that would work as the logo. Yes, thank you. All right, we'll move to agenda item 5.10, Mammoth Lake Housing Program update. Thank you. I'm trying to think.
1:51:51 Wasn't maybe going to go through this item by item unless somebody wants to, or we could just address specific concerns. You know, we had a Project Home Key update. I've mentioned, you know, the status of Access Apartments. We are working to hopefully break ground in April, but I'm waiting for some new cost estimates, which will inform if we have all the funding that we need or not.
1:52:29 I guess I would like the board to know that we did submit our renewal application for our community housing development organization status. So it's been three years already since we renewed last time and Eric was able to submit that application. We're just waiting for approval. The PRP application was submitted for Valley Apartments. We had the heaters replaced at the Birch Creek condo.
1:53:00 So that was very good. We've entered two clients into the coordinated entry system and we have another client we're meeting with on Wednesday. Oh, one thing, we had our first client utilize the virtual legal aid station in our office and he was very satisfied and very happy with the result. Even though he's not eligible for ongoing services, he felt like he got the information that he needed and he was very happy, so that was exciting.
1:53:40 I wanted to mention under upcoming agenda items, or upcoming work program items, I wanted to let you know that I am working to get a consultant on board for our strategic planning update, and that could happen as soon as March, but I'll keep you posted as soon as I know so that we can get it in our calendars so that we can hopefully all contribute.
1:54:10 To that. And then our strategic plan is a five-year plan, and so we'll be in the fifth year of our current plan and renew for the next five years. But anyways, my last update is that I did receive a resignation letter from Agnes today, effective immediately, and so we do have an open seat on the board.
1:54:46 Her position was member at large, and so we'll have to think about maybe at our next meeting if we want to set up a nominations committee. Those were my exciting updates, but I'm happy to answer any questions. Any questions of the exciting update? Just one comment, one question.
1:55:18 I feel like it's maybe new on the wait list management, looking at the numbers of individuals and children, and I think that's a really powerful number. Looking at 450 individuals on the waiting list is a big number, and that 210 children under the age of 18. So I appreciate that being on there. Thank you. It's just kind of like one more thing to spur me on how important this work is.
1:55:44 And then a question about La Vista Blanc, number 65, your little comment says, consider renting, and is that something that you would need us to vote on, or can you kind of take that and make that decision on your own? I have broached the topic with the town. They are the lender, and so I would want to make sure that it was acceptable to them. I did check our loan documents, and I didn't see an expiration or a term, which...
1:56:12 I've asked Nolan to double check because I would think that loan would be coming due soon. So we're in active conversations about that unit and we do have a number of ownership applications that Eric is painstakingly trying to work with clients to get their documents submitted so that if they're eligible they can move forward and purchase it. And his time is being pulled in a lot of directions, especially Innsbruck Lodge.
1:56:42 We're just trying to get somebody in that unit. And if none of those applicants work out, then the town is aware that renting it could be an option. That's all for me. Thank you. Any other questions from the board? We'll move to 5.11. Oh, and I guess I didn't answer your question, actually. I think if we were to decide to rent the asset instead of selling it, I do think that board direction about
1:57:15 That would be important, considering we have a large liability, and so I think that would be appropriate for the board to weigh in on and vote on. 5.11, reschedule regular January board meeting. So our January board meeting is on the 2nd, which is a paid holiday, and
1:57:57 I was having a conversation, and I can confirm this with our legal counsel, but that we wouldn't necessarily need to have a special meeting to adopt AB 361 again, that we would be able to meet at a later date and just reaffirm the resolution that we passed today for AB 361, and I'll have to confirm that, and I'll let the board know if we need a special meeting or not. I was thinking,
1:58:29 Maybe we could push it to, and I need to, I need to confirm the town council schedule, but I was thinking we could push it later in the month potentially, and then not have a February meeting? I think it's acceptable. Okay. Do we want to, should I send a poll or do we want to decide? I haven't looked at the calendar. I mean, I'm available, but. Maybe send a poll if you don't know yet.
1:59:11 I don't know if you feel like you have a date. Well, I just wonder, is like Monday, is Monday generally good for folks? The 19th? I don't know. We could just... That's a Thursday? Oh, sorry. The 18th? I'm in the wrong month. That's a Wednesday? Oh, I meant the 16th. 16th, MLK. Okay, the 23rd? Go in once. Go in once. Good with me. Yeah, that's good with me, the 23rd. Yeah.
1:59:47 Okay, I think that's good because it's far enough, you know, it's far into the month so that we can cancel. Hopefully, we won't need a meeting in February. And if we do, we can have one. But maybe if it's okay. You had a note in your staff court that if the board wishes to continue with hybrid meetings after this date, a special meeting will need to be scheduled before January 5th.
2:00:15 Angie wasn't sure if that was accurate, so I'm going to check with legal counsel, and hopefully we won't need one, and if we need one, we could do something quick. Yeah, I guess if that works for you. Oh, thank you. Discussion? We'll move to agenda six, committee reports. Do we have any committee reports? I have an update on the agenda.
2:01:07 ED evaluation committee had been disbanded, but Brian and Sarah and I had met to talk about how we could improve the ED evaluation process in the future. And so we were talking about modifying the ED evaluation system to give it a little more structure and provide some milestones for
2:01:38 Evaluation. So when we're talking about wage increases and bonuses, we can have something a little more specific to tie it to. So we were talking about meeting with the executive director and having a little more specific one-year goals that would come from the five-year strategic plan. And every year we could renegotiate those goals. And the goals would
2:02:12 Stem from organizational goals and personal and professional development goals. We talked about the term SMART goals with the, how do you say, abbreviation, that's not the word I'm looking for, the acronym for strategic, measurable, achievable, realistic, and time bound. So I think
2:02:42 Brian and Sarah and I want to meet again and create some kind of draft template for that in the future. I was also on the evaluation committee last year and I had to kind of dig up some of our old materials to see how we did it the year before and kind of have to remember what the pros and cons were. So I think it's beneficial for us to
2:03:12 Go over it now so we can create a little more structure now and then next year we can be a little more organized with the ED evaluation process and make it a little more relatable for the Executive Director and for the rest of the committee. So if any of the board members have any ideas they want to contribute, some feedback about the
2:03:40 process we had now and how you think we could improve it in the future and that'd be appreciated. I think we're going to use that. Well, Tony, this is Jennifer and I just, you know, we're a Brown Act body and we can't just have board members meeting without some formal.
2:04:04 Creation of a body, because as you mentioned, the ad hoc committee is done, and ad hoc committee has a specific task, and once that task is achieved, then it's disbanded, and we don't have an ED evaluation ongoing standing committee in our, we have a governance committee, I don't know, they're all right here.
2:04:30 But we would have to, the board would have to create another ad hoc committee with this intention and then recruit members to be on it, which, you know, there just needs to be a formal process. We can't just start sending you our thoughts on this without going through that. So I think maybe you should meet with the chair or the executive director to kind of approach this. That would be my recommendation.
2:05:00 Okay, because I didn't realize that it was officially over once we had made a recommendation last month about that, but like I said, there was still a little bit of afterthought about our evaluation process, and while we still had it fresh in our minds, we thought it was
2:05:29 um good to reflect on the process we took and how we can improve it for next year so yeah maybe that's something that the government's committee could do I mean it might but again I think it I would recommend you meet with the executive director and come up with a path forward that's my recommendation as one board member if there's not an end date
2:05:59 I mean, there is an end, an ending to an ad hoc committee, but not necessarily an end date. Seems like this is still, like we don't officially do anything to disband an ad hoc committee. Once the objective is achieved, it is disbanded. There is no action taken. And this can't fall under still working with the Executive Director's performance review? No, because the evaluation is done. This is process. This is policy. This is not her.
2:06:30 Her evaluation is done. We've already done that. So this is really a policy item. I think perhaps what we can do is follow up with Patricia and suggest that at a future meeting we kind of reconstitute some type of an executive director evaluation committee to consider the ideas that we...
2:07:07 We're kicking around following the past year's process and then we can pick this up at a future time. Yeah, the board would have to appoint the ad hoc committee and then the suggestions would have to come back. I mean, just from my experience, they would have to come back to the board for approval. Anytime you guys can't make policy, the board makes policy and ad hoc committee can only get together and make suggestions and then the board would approve them or not.
2:07:34 And that was the intention. We thought we were kind of operating under the existing charter of the committee, but if that's not the case, we can certainly nominate ourselves to participate if the board, the larger board, wishes for that to happen. But in any event, we think we can share the ideas we have with whoever sits on the future committee. You could also agendize the topic.
2:08:06 Yes. To brainstorm as a big group with the executive director. Maybe it's a little quicker and easier, more efficient. I don't know. Yeah. Yeah, I'm not sure we need, honestly, an ad hoc group to discuss policy recommendations. I feel like the whole board should be part of any kind of a policy. Which we would eventually, I guess, as recommendations came in. But yeah, anyway, I think.
2:08:36 Well, again, we're really going deep into something that isn't on the agenda. I don't know, that makes me a little uncomfortable, so maybe we should agendize it for our January meeting and a discussion on this item. I agree. I can do that. All right. Any other board member reports or committee reports? Just thinking about committee reports, I was looking with Agnes' resignation. Agnes sits on the governance committee and the marketing committee.
2:09:14 I don't know if we need to think about adding people to those or they haven't, the marketing committee now isn't as busy, but if you can foresee anything for that and if the governance committee with strategic planning process and things like that needs to do anything maybe. Yeah, thanks, that's a good reminder. I maybe thought about that fleetingly, but I was probably thinking maybe we should wait until we make sure we have a full board and then, because if we have a new person and then.
2:09:47 That just might be more streamlined. Right. We will get a new town council member. Our board's going to go through changes, so there's probably a good time after that to reassess. Yeah. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah. I do have a board member report, but I don't know if you're on agenda item seven or if you're- Yeah, I was moving to agenda item seven, board member reports. Okay. I do have a report. All right. Thank you. I wasn't sure if we were on six or seven. Thank you, Chair Stapp. I do want to just thank
2:10:23 Thank you, Kirk, for your service as our town council representative these past, what, four years? And then some, right? But on this, like, this last stint has been under the town council. And thank you for your leadership. Has it been, were you, I think it was just four, was it? It was just four, because we were elected in 2018 together. Yes, yes. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I know you were on it before that, but just this last pass.
2:10:51 Past cycle. So thank you for all your leadership, for chairing our meetings, putting up with me for sure, right here to your left. And enduring COVID, being the chair during COVID and how challenging that was. Readings are a challenge, I know, because I chaired during that time. And it's not easy to navigate the Hollywood squares and run a meeting.
2:11:21 Otherwise, I want to just a couple of things that I think are pertinent to the group. Tomorrow, the Board of Supervisors are meeting and one of the items on our agenda is consideration of RVs as housing in certain land use designations and whether or not we want to look at.
2:11:46 Allowing that, and some land use, all land use, not at all. What are the parameters? It's an opportunity to give some staff feedback on where we want to go. We won't be approving any policies, but really giving some strong staff direction, I think, on where we want to go with that. That's tomorrow. I will say that the county had planned to do a housing.
2:12:16 workshop this month, but we, our housing manager, coordinator, manager, and I'm terrible with the title, it's gone through a lot of iterations, but is no longer with the county, so we're putting that off until January, we'll have a housing strategy workshop in January.
2:12:43 I was in D.C. a couple weeks ago serving on the NACO Housing Task Force, and I thought that was a really great event. There's 30 of us from across the nation working, and I was paired up with folks from other rural and resort communities, so Juneau, Teton, Park County, Colorado, and
2:13:11 I can't remember the name of the county where Tamarack is in Idaho. So another resort community. And we just talked a lot about solutions, challenges, and it gave me some appreciation for our latitude here. Idaho State has a lot of constraints on what local jurisdictions and governments can do versus the state says, no, you can't touch short-term rentals.
2:13:35 We control that, whereas we have some leeway, so that's nice. I will say that Jackson is doing a lot and pretty impressive, and I think we could learn a lot from them. They have a lot higher land values than we do here in Mammoth and similar constraints with public land. For example, they're doing a $57 million development right now.
2:14:05 For 57 units. It's expensive to develop there, so it does make me feel a little bit better about our situation. I do want to thank Patricia. She came and spoke at the CSAC, California State Association of Counties, annual conference a couple weeks ago.
2:14:28 In Disneyland, of all places, and she came and spoke about some of the things that we do here in Mono County and Mammoth, and there were three people on the panel, one from San Diego, one from Placer, and then Patricia, and they all were well-received, and I really appreciate you coming and sharing some of our successes. One of the things that came out of that was the concept of a strike fund, which I think the town has with their bridge program.
2:14:57 You know, being able to act quickly to buy real estate, but I think, you know, something I would kind of like to see Mono County do, because real estate moves quickly, and you have to be able to jump on it because of the environment of it. I think, you know, I did hear today, and you know, we don't weigh a lot in on state policy, but there is...
2:15:26 You know, the new legislative cycle just started today at the state, and heard from California Housing Partnership today at the CCRH-led committee that they're looking at a bill that would create a one-stop shop for funding for affordable housing, which I think is interesting, and then it would create a panel of folks, five people, so it would be the
2:15:54 TCAC Director, SIDLAC Director, the HCD Director, the Comptroller, and I think College FAA Director, would review all of the applications and make funding recommendations for tax credits, MHP, it's all for rental housing, and they were looking for feedback from us, but we'll see where the bill goes and how it evolves.
2:16:23 Evolved, but I think we may want to chime in. I have some concerns about rural development. I shared those with Mark Stivers, the CPH, California Housing Partnership staff today. So the only other item that they're looking to build, they're looking to sponsor, which we may want to weigh in, though I'm not sure, is the local housing.
2:16:52 Patricia, you know about this because you just asked staff about it, the local housing fund that the, yes, that one, that they maybe want to create a grant application cycle so that there'd be more funding. Might be something you want to weigh in on because I know you expressed interest on Mono counties and I'm a little skeptical of it, but so there, you know, we're going to be seeing new bills coming about and I think if there's
2:17:22 If it's relevant and pertinent to this body, that we should participate in some way. And I think that is it for me. Thank you. Thank you. Further reports? If not, we're... I was just going to make a quick comment. I mean, I just wanted to point out that we're having a strong start to the ski season. Visitations November was a record for us. Obviously, the snow conditions are fantastic.
2:17:55 Fully expect and past sales are strong. So, you know, we certainly expect a pretty bullish season, which I think portends well for TOT collections. So, and as those being a part of discretionary funding for the town council to allocate, possibly there'll be more funding for housing this year as a result. So, there you go. If not, Patricia, do you have anything else you want to add? No.
2:18:30 I'm good for today. Thank you, everybody. Thank you.