TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2023

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Special meeting

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

320 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:04 Hello, hello, test, test. Okay. Okay, you got it. Okay. I have no idea. That'd be a good question for Ms. Helms. Do you have a paper copy of the agenda? No, no, no. Good. Yeah? Traveling like crazy. Oh. Just supervisor traveling? Yeah. Not fun? Well, and a little bit of fun. Okay. Okay. But I did Sacramento, Mendocino, Chico, Reno. How'd you get to Mendocino? Did you drive? Yeah.

3:49 But I was already in Sacramento. But still far. Still far. Yeah. Oh, awesome. Perfect. I need to get acrobat on this thing. That's annoying. Is that the city one? Yeah, but I don't have acrobat on this. Okay, is everybody ready? Good morning. I'm going to call the Friday, April 21st meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to order.

4:36 The first item of agenda is the roll call, please. Supervisor Griffiths? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Councilmember Oral? Here. I'm sorry, that was Supervisor Oral. It's okay. I apologize for that. You're doing a new job. Supervisor Salcedo is not joining the meeting as a board member today. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Schwartz? Here.

5:10 And Council Member Mohove? Yeah, here. Thank you. You got it. Okay, item number two is the Pledge of Allegiance. I'm going to ask Ashley Helms to lead us in the pledge. The United States of America, the one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice. Item number three is public comment. Do we have any comment on items that are not calendared on the agenda? I am not seeing any in the room. Is there any online?

5:52 I do. Magnolia Barra, let me change this real quick, and you should be able to go ahead and unmute and give your comment now. Good morning. Can you guys hear me? We can. Okay, good morning. I just wanted to just quickly introduce myself. My name is Magnolia Barra. I am a resident of Mammoth Lakes, California, and I am the new

6:24 Eastside Project Navigator for the SURF project. I know that we will be working very closely in this project moving forward here in the next couple of months, and I just wanted to introduce myself and for all of you guys to see my face, although I'm not able to be there in person, but I just wanted to do just a quick introduction and looking forward from

6:53 the Sierra Business Council side to be working with all of you, and I will be that link between Sierra Business Council, the SURF project, and ESCOG, hopefully bringing us all together into this project moving forward. I know we will be doing a presentation in the next couple months later on for all of you, but for now, I just wanted to introduce myself for all of you guys to know me.

7:23 Wonderful. Thank you. Where are you based out of Magnolia? I am in Mammoth Lakes, California. Okay. So I will be the east side person for all of you to contact with anything that you might have any questions, although I just started myself, so I'm getting just familiar with everything that's happening, but I am going to be that person for all of you guys. Wonderful. We'll look forward to meeting you in person someday. Yes, likewise.

7:53 Thank you. Is there any other public comment? No other comments at this time. Okay, wonderful. Item number four is the consent agenda. These items are considered routine. Is there anyone who would like to pull one for more discussion or can we just pass it? Pass it. I will move, Mr. Chair, to approve the consent agenda. Items 4.1, 4.2 as presented. I'll second. Motion is second. No further comment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carries.

8:25 We'll move on to item number 5.1, which is an introduction of the Inyamono Broadband Coalition Regional Broadband Coordinator, Scott Armstrong, and receive a report on IMBC activities. Morning, Scott. Hey, hey. I guess I'm live now. Good morning. My name is Scott Armstrong, and I'm pleased to meet you in person. I wanted to give you a little bit of an update on what we're doing, but first, I should tell you who I am.

8:57 I've been in this role for a couple of months now, getting up to speed, hopefully making a difference soon. My previous six years, I was the Information Services Director. Prior to that, I worked for Marin County as our Chief Assistant Director of Information Services and Technology for a little over a year. And before that, I had a career. I actually retired from a community college in Illinois where I was the IT Director and Chief Information. Before that, I served in the Air Force.

9:30 I was in service for 21 years. I started out as a German linguist in intelligence. When the wall fell, my job went away, so I had to retrain, so I chose Russian because that's what my wife was. She was a Russian linguist as well. Served a couple more years in intelligence, and then I switched over to arms control treaty implementation, which is a very rewarding job. So I lived in Moscow, Berlin, D.C. area. I was in Monterey, California for five years of my career. Terrible, so.

10:00 So, I wanted to talk a little bit about the things that we've done. The biggest, most of my work in the first couple of weeks was updating the information on the website. IMBC has a website. It's connectedeasternsierra.net. And you can find that on the ESCOG website. So if you go to the What We Do page, there should be a link for the Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium. Underneath that, there's a resources page.

10:29 If you can't remember, connect to the eastern Sierra.net. You can find it on the ESCOG site. The information that we have includes much of the information from the previous iteration of the IMBC. I'll try to find a better place, a better page for that, because the focus of the IMBC has changed a little bit. There was more adoption before, and now it's primarily expansion.

11:00 Some of the pages that I've updated include the homepage. We had some data that referenced adoption based on the census block data that we had. So in the past, census blocks indicated whether a region was covered, even though there were locations that weren't. Since this is now, the maps are now location-based, you can have unserved locations within a census block.

11:31 So that's no longer accurate. So we took some of the latest information that came out a couple weeks back and updated that to indicate the percentage of served locations in the county of Mono and then served locations in Inyo County. Additionally, those that are served, unserved, and then also adoption based on those who have service.

11:59 So the numbers are interesting, but it gives us data to work with so we can measure progress in the future. So what I hope to see in the future is our served locations getting closer and closer to 95%, 98%, and then again adoption, hopefully we can keep that in the upper 90s. Adoptions is essentially people subscribing to existing for services available. I also uploaded the work plan for the IMBC, so it shows a list of all the stuff that I'm doing for your organization and for the counties.

12:29 The city and town. I added some subpages under the broadband page, and those subpages include expansion, which currently doesn't have a lot of data, but I'll populate that with each of the locations in the counties so that we can have an inventory, a visible inventory of which areas are served, how many households it's going to affect, and things like that. You've got to find the right structure for the data because it's a lot of information.

12:57 I also included a ramps page. Right now that has... Right now that has... John, unmute yourself. Mute. Oh. Oh. He's logged out to the Zoom. I'm going to leave. Be present. We're here.

13:38 So I also have grants page, and I've got a handful of grants identified right now. What I hope to do is have state and federal grants that are applicable to our efforts right now with a short description, and those will include information on who can apply, what it can be used for, things like that. I also am working on a matrix that identifies a lot of information. That's just way too busy to put on the website, so I may find a different approach for that.

14:08 Also included maps because we now have more than just two maps to look at. We have about four or five. And so those are on there as well to look at. And I wanted to talk briefly about the grants. Going back to the grants, we've already gone through the local agency technical assistance grant process and our regions were awarded grants for that. The city, the town of Mammoth and the county of Mono.

14:37 are working through the RCRC with theirs. Inyo is doing it a little bit differently. But we've all been awarded grants for that. The anticipated follow-on construction grant for that is the federal funding account grant. And those grants can be applied for by only providers, those that are authorized by law to provide broadband internet service, which means we kind of need to rely on the service providers to do that.

15:05 Part of the scoring for that grant is establishing partnerships with us. So I've already reached out to the local providers that we have, including RACE, to try to encourage them to work with us, work on the areas that we need to have connected with the FFA grant. Just for reference, Mono County, the allocation for Mono County was calculated using a formula.

15:34 Mono County's allocation is $10,600,000, give or take, and Inyo County's allocation is $13,220,000. So in our region, we've got about $23,000, almost $24,000,000 to work with. So hopefully we can get some areas connected that we haven't gotten connected in the past. It's going to require some effort. The grant window, I believe, opens up June 30th and closes on August 31st.

16:12 Everybody can get connected with the Starlink, but what's interesting about the grants from the state right now is they talk about reliable service, the threshold being 25 megabits per second download, 3 megabits upload, and they say reliable, so it's wireline service. So the fixed wireless and satellite don't knock you out of competition, don't knock out the eligibility.

16:41 The state wants to have wireline connectivity to as many households as possible. And yes, the fixed wireless providers and satellite providers can still offer their services because there will always be that niche. Let's see. So the window closes August 31st, so I'm going to have a busy summer working with the different organizations to see what we can get done. The grant that we hear most about is the California Advanced Services Fund Infrastructure Account Grant.

17:10 Infrastructure account grant is also one that can only be applied for by providers. And that's the one that they, the biggest changes to the maps will affect the most. I reached out to both Suddenly Optimum and Frontier, let them know that that's changed, and they have to rework their grant applications that were due. A few weeks ago, the grant period was extended. They extended the grant.

17:37 So their applications now no longer reference census blocks, they're going to identify specific locations, which I think is really a wonderful change for us. It opens up the opportunity to hit those neighborhoods that we haven't been able to serve yet. Another grant, I think I mentioned this in a message a few days ago, is USDA opened up a grant, the Rural Development.

18:03 Rural Development Broadband Technical Assistance Grant, which is very similar to the LADA grant, with the exception of companies, providers can also apply for it, whereas the LADA grant was just for counties and cities. There's a USDA Community Connect grant out there. That one, the big requirement is setting up a community center and providing internet service. So we have a lot of locations that could be possibilities.

18:32 But those areas don't have, they're not close to middle mile yet, so providing internet service would still be difficult. But as we inventory the locations that we hope to hit, we can identify those that we might be able to use a similar grant for, because it looks like this is a recurring grant. And then BEAD, the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Grant, which is a federal grant that only states can apply for, states and territories, is ongoing and the state's working on that.

19:01 Related to the Bede Grant, I'm working with Tuolumne County and CDT and their contractor to, along with Alpine County and some others, to join Tuolumne's public session to provide input on the state's digital equity plan for the Bede Grant. Right now they're planning for in-person

19:32 So we're working on that so that we can join remotely. That would involve setting up a physical location either in Mono or Inyo County. I think it's prettier up here right now, so maybe we'll do it up here. But we will invite the community leaders, the governmental leaders, the public to in

20:02 to be in a session, and we'll have work groups, and we'll have four and a half hour session on the 30th of May, and I believe both boards, both county boards are dark that day, I think it's a Tuesday, so that will work out well for us. More information on that in the future. And then a couple other notes, just random notes, the FFA grant in particular includes scoring points for collaborative

20:33 Grant applications so that provider getting support from a county or city toward a grant. That's going to probably involve at least some letters of support and I've already had providers asking me for money so they're looking for money support. So as I get some more information over the next couple of weeks I'll put out some recommendations on if the boards would like to set aside some funding.

21:03 to provide monetary support for these future grants, what that might look like. I don't know that it's absolutely necessary, but I know that it will help. I'm having regular meetings with the California Department of Technology, with Mono County, Mammoth, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Inyo County, Newcom Alliance, which is an alliance of four tribes. I think it's Lone Pine Bishop, Mono Lake, and Bridgeport tribes.

21:33 So we meet with them. I also am on the NTIA calendar every month, and I have regular meetings and conversations with RCRC. And my big effort right now is to itemize each of the locations and the needs that we have. So it's a lot of information. I haven't succeeded in delivering Internet service to anybody yet, but I know it's going to take some time. So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions you have. Thank you, Scott. I'm just curious.

22:09 The state of California seems to be really eager to provide service, which is great, but there seems to be multiple efforts on different fronts. One entity that I didn't hear you mention in meetings was Caltrans, because I know that they've also been given a significant amount of money to also lay line, and so are these efforts coordinated? They are.

22:40 And related to Caltrans, the state has a Middle Mile Broadband Initiative that was kicked off by the SB 156. And California Department of Technology has been charged with making the network happen and running it. And they use Caltrans as their on-the-ground cable installer, cable constructor. So there is coordination. There's not always agreement in what...

23:09 One organization thinks the other one needs to do, but the conversations are regular, and there actually is an MMBI session at 10 o'clock today, so meeting's done, I'm going to be in that. But yeah, there are multiple prongs to this effort, and I see some coordination both in the state side and the federal side, but everything seems to have a very particular purpose. I think we're going to see some additional

23:40 Grants and Requirements once the state receives its bead allocation after they get the public input and decide how they want to provide those funds for broadband, those will come with requirements limitations. Does that help? Yes. The website looks fantastic.

24:06 Thank you. That was a little bit of a band-aided effort by a bunch of us several years ago, and it really looks great. Thanks for that. And it's great to see it integrated into the ESCOG website. So this is great to see these pieces all coming together. One thing that we could maybe follow up offline a little bit, it's a somewhat tangential endeavor, but it's related to all the obvious great work you're going to be doing.

24:31 It has to do with the recreation economy. ESCOG has something called the SHRMP, the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program. And out of an effort called the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative that wrapped up a couple years ago, there is something produced called the Visitor Connection Package, which is a framework, an opportunity for all of us to be connecting to millions of people that come up here all the time. And it would be interesting to have a conversation about the role.

24:58 That the broadband opportunity we have here can be tied into wireless, cellular, all those other kinds of things. We've got a lot of nonprofits, a lot of agencies are getting grants to put signs on the ground, to put infrastructure kind of scattered all over the landscape. Well, I think it'd be a really innovative and smart thing to start looking at how can we leverage that technology to get information to the visitors in a more efficient and less impactful way.

25:24 At the same time, we acknowledge there's going to be a need for analog stuff on the ground and those kinds of things. But I'd love to follow up with you on that. I know there's some NGOs listening today. They're getting significant grants. There's a lot of money coming out. None of that stuff is coordinated. So it'd be a good conversation to have one. Thanks. Yeah, thank you. That's it. I'm done. Thank you. Okay. I've got a couple questions. So first is University of California Cooperative Extension. Yes. They have a position that they're

25:53 Flying that I think had a failed recruitment. And I guess that's for, can you tell me even what it is? It's confusing. So in 2021, UC Extension Office approached us, the Mono and Inyo counties, with a conversation about possibly putting somebody out here for economic development and broadband deployment. This was before we had the serious push for broadband from the state.

26:23 CAO Greenberg and I were both involved in conversations. Leslie was as well when she was here. We had Dustin Blakely, UC Extension Office, works for Inyo County now in conversations as well. We worked with UC to put together a job description for someone who could help us in the region apply for grants and do research and do some economic development work as well. So they flew that position first in December 2021.

26:53 I believe they probably didn't get any takers or didn't hire anybody because I think that Inyo County was going to be the person to house that position. I think we were looking at Cerro Coso as maybe a location. So it looks like they've reposted that one. Salary's a little bit better. Requires a master's degree. That's the part that I thought. I don't know how that's going to find somebody. We've actually advertised that out in Illinois to see if somebody wants to come on here and keep bragging about it.

27:23 So, but yes, that, if they can find somebody in that position, it would be very helpful for me and for our economic development efforts because it would be another person with another set of eyes to do some research tasks, to do some PR, and really to focus on how broadband can influence and assist the economic development efforts. So, it was something we started before all of this. It's nice to see if they advertise it again.

27:53 It's, they may have a difficult time. Maybe we'll find somebody who loves this area, just graduated from the university, and wants to come out to be a great, great place for them to start. Okay, thanks. And can you give us an update on Frontier's efforts in Inyo County, at least? Sure. I looked at the, I look regularly at the map.

28:20 the FCC broadband map because it shows detail. I just looked at it for my house. Yeah, so maybe I looked at it for your house as well. I met with Frontier yesterday to talk about, to see if I can get some information on the neighborhoods that they're going to hit next because if you look at the map, they're doing neighborhoods and unfortunately they're doing neighborhoods where somebody across the street from the neighborhoods getting connected doesn't

28:50 Isn't able to sign up yet. That sounds like you're in that case. And I think Megan is as well. So I met with them and they're going to see if they can share some of that with me. It'll be under an NDA. But at least I'll know which regions they're going to cover and maybe I can give some idea on which neighborhood's going to be next. That'll also help me as we look at FFA grants to know which neighborhoods Frontier's going to cover so we don't have to spend money on them as well.

29:20 What does FFA stand for? Federal Funding Account. It's the CPUC CASA Federal Funding Account, which is the follow-on grant for the local agency technical assistance grant. And that's the one that opens up. Right. They could have picked a different one. What's that? Because we're already, like, when Ashley gets her presentation, we're going to confuse FFA and FAA. Yeah. Now there's another FFA. I grew up in the Midwest, and FFA to me is future farmers.

29:50 Yeah, I would just mention, you know, in Metropolitan June Lake, we have both Frontier and Optiman. We have actually both of them. And it's spotty. It's just what you say. In other words, the Frontier thing box was right down the street at Whispering Pines. And so somebody said, well, you could call them and hook up. And we called them a year or so ago. And they said, oh, yeah, we can do you. But then somebody up the hill, oh, no, no, no, no, you're too far away.

30:17 Now maybe that's changed, but Frontier is great in June Lake. And Optimum is like, oh, I guess we better clean up Iraq. So it's been this sort of back and forth. And that's, like I say, you know, Metropolitan June Lake. The thing I wanted to catch up with you on, I think you covered at the beginning, Scott, was for the average resident in the whole Eastern Sierra, it's the two things you mentioned.

30:37 When am I going to get served? And when can I sign up? And it sounds like I didn't go to the website. Maybe you did. But I guess at any given time, whether you're speaking to us or whether we're going to that website, if we can always have that sort of dashboard, here's where we stand. We're making progress. And I know a lot of stuff in the weeds that get us there. But for a lot of people who don't understand all this, the bottom line is, when am I going to get internet? And how are we doing as a region getting better?

31:06 And if we can always have that be part of the conversation in this, that way we're connecting what all this money and everything's doing with serving and increasing the quality of life. Thank you. Any other questions for Scott? Thank you, Mr. Armstrong. Thank you for letting me take your time. Absolutely. Okay, moving right along. Item 5.2 is to receive a presentation from Kristen Feiler, Inyo County Wildfire Preparedness Coordinator regarding regional wildfire resiliency planning. Good morning, Ms. Feiler. Good morning.

31:41 Thanks for having me. Let me just, I think if I just share my screen, you can see a presentation. Sorry, I wrote this on my way home from Sacramento yesterday, so. Good morning, my name is Kristen Feiler. I am the Wildfire Preparedness Coordinator for Inyo County. Today, I'll give you a brief overview of the county coordinator position.

32:45 What's been happening in Inyo County related to wildfire and then speak a little bit to some of the regional efforts and how we're partnering. The county coordinator position is a new position across the state. Each county has their own coordinator. Some are housed within the counties and some are in resource conservation districts, some are in non-profits like fire safe councils. So it kind of looks differently across the state.

33:16 Both Inyo and Mono County Coordinator positions are housed within the county in the Office of Emergency Services. These positions are grant-funded through CAL FIRE, the California Climate Investments Program, and the California State Fire Safe Council. And I do have some exciting news. At this conference that I was at, which was a convening of all the county coordinators across the state, they announced that they were going to extend the grant funding for another year.

33:44 We have funding now through March 2025, which is exciting. And a little bit of the messaging I heard at this conference was that the intention of this position is to be a sort of conduit for what's happening within the counties and then regionally and kind of like trying to get things done. So that involves a lot of building collaboration and coordination, trying to increase capacity.

34:19 Largely building relationships is a huge piece of this and making sure that those solutions are equitable across the county, not just for who's loudest or who has the most funding, that kind of thing. And then really working with our partners to align projects and funding to match our strategic plans and a lot of the funding sources that are coming out. And just as a little update, I've

34:50 My salary so far I've spent $30,000 just on my position and in six months been able to bring in $20,000 in grants for the Wilkerson Fire Safe Council and just got another grant awarded to us for $3,000 plus like an outreach kit which is exciting so slightly paying off. So how are we going to go about

35:21 And so one of the big pieces

35:53 that I've been focusing on are the fire adapted communities. And this is a great tool provided by the fire adapted network and the state uses it as well in their plans and such. And so kind of in the blue are kind of the big strategies and then in the green are kind of the components that might address some of those strategies.

36:21 And so in Inyo, we've really started with the policies and plans piece. When I started, the communities of 40 Acres and Independence were starting their community wildfire protection plans. And so jumped into that to really help foster relationships and help with community engagement and outreach. And our county is actually starting our own.

36:49 Community Wildfire Protection Plan update right now. And, you know, there's so many plans, like a big piece of this is trying to align those efforts. Everyone's so tapped for time, so we have our hazard mitigation plans that are happening right now, those updates, and so trying to coordinate public outreach in those meetings is a big piece of that. I'm also working with Tyson Sparrow and City of Bishop to work on some code updates.

37:19 for fire code and just kind of realigning some of those so it's a little clearer in our code structure. We've also got some recovery efforts happening from these storms dealing with emergency operations and planning for flooding and such like that. We've got a lot of I guess working within some of the communities to help identify what their

37:55 So an example of that is the community of Starlight. Next month we're going to be going up there and just talking about likely fire scenarios and what they need to do to prepare for those and where they're going to go, what resources are in the community, things like that. Similarly, this resident mitigation piece.

38:27 Thanks to Supervisor Griffiths, I was able to get connected with Jana Valachovic, who does a lot of the home-hardening education across the state, and brought her in to give a really great lecture and a site visit with the Bishop Hyatt Tribe, and that really sparked a lot of community interest. We were able to get a lot of people in attendance there.

38:56 And so we're kind of working with the White Bark Institute to bring her in again in June and kind of continue those efforts. Similarly in this one, I am applying for some grants to help address the home-hardening and defensible space within the communities. Kristen, so I saw Yana at CSAC Ledge Conference last week, and she said that one of the things that came up in her last site visit was a mobile home.

39:27 Yeah, that's so neat. That's really, yeah, I know, typically the answer, you know, for those is just kind of like, well, let's

39:57 Early notification and get out of there as fast as you can because there's not a lot you can do so that's really exciting. And that's kind of something that I'm helping with too is kind of our emergency operations planning like we have a lot of communities that are only one way in one way out and so kind of looking at those ingress egress components and building those into the plans too so that is really exciting.

40:26 And then there's partnerships and community engagement. We do have quite a few collaborative groups that have been started. Tribal collaborative group with our emergency operations teams. We have the access and functional needs collaborative groups to try to figure out what are some of those specific needs for some of our more vulnerable populations.

40:55 And then we've got some fuel breaks planned, and we've had a lot of really cool successes. Granite View is a really great success story. I think of, I guess, well-placed and timed fuel breaks. And then, yeah, just building a lot of furniture. And then, you know, regional efforts. I have a really great working relationship with Wendy Graseski, who's my counterpart for Mono County.

41:30 She's wonderful, and we talk a lot and are coordinating a lot of efforts there. We had just applied for a big grant together, actually, for home-hardening, defensible space-type stuff. Similarly with the Whitebark Institute, they're one of the key players in implementation and planning in the area. And then the BLM, Forest Service, DWP,

41:59 All of those partners, Cal Fire especially, really working to build awesome relationships with them, and everyone kind of has the same need of wanting to collaborate, coordinate, and get things done. And then we did just recently start the Inyo Mono RCD. It reignited, and so we are looking for ways to help them get going.

42:30 Yeah, that'll be exciting. One of the cool opportunities that we have right now is there's funding to develop this potential operational delineations structure, which actually this is a picture of what that looks like. They call them pods. And it's a concept that started with the Forest Service as a way to break up the landscape on a large scale into smaller pieces to strategize and

43:00 coordinate, you know, effective treatments on the land. And so they've realized that, you know, fires don't just happen in the forest, they happen, you know, across jurisdictional boundaries. So we just had a workshop in February to draw these pods for the rest of the Owens Valley and Mono County. And so those are being finalized right now, and we're looking to really utilize those to help create a strategic plan forward.

43:30 Not have these random treatments everywhere, but really focus on a good action plan for treatments across the landscape. And then I coordinate with the California Fire Safe Council. Quite often they have great resources. They're the ones who are supplying a lot of the outreach materials for us. And then there is coming a tool called Planscape.

44:02 I don't know if you all are familiar with that or have heard of that, but it should be a way to also strategize larger landscape-level projects and coordinate efforts. And then, of course, the Regional Forest and Fire Capacity Program, which is largely run from the Whitebark Institute. But I think some of the things that are coming out of that program are

44:36 Like prior to me getting here, there were some projects identified, and so there's funding to move a lot of these projects into planning so that we can get shovel-ready projects is kind of one of the key pieces. So we have a project in Lone Pine and a project in Bishop that were recommended for this cycle of planning grants through them. And then, I don't know, do you want me to talk about the white barks or do you want to talk about...

45:11 If you would like to go ahead and provide an overview, I think you're more, you work more closely with it, but I'm happy to fill in gaps and add a couple things at the end. Thank you. Okay. Yeah, I already kind of touched on the wildfire protection plans for 40 acres and independence, and those wildfire protection plans are really kind of the guiding light for how to get things done, like what, it's an inventory of...

45:51 What the risks are and the hazards and what needs to be done and then it is meant to be an ever-evolving tool for us to actually get things done. The goal is to make those really accessible via story maps and ArcGIS website type stuff so that we can have community engagement with those. Similarly,

46:22 There's a lot of great fuels reduction projects happening around 40 acres, which the CWPP really helped bring some understanding to the community about why they're doing those projects and helped to get people on board with some of those. They're also having a grant to do visitor education and outreach, which is a huge...

46:50 Peace for Wildfire Tourism, Campfires, Vehicles, etc. So we're partnering with Crystal Medhurst to really bring that program up. I think there might be some collaborations there with Camp Like a Pro as well. And then another kind of piece of this is it's not super clear what, you know, CEQA or NEPA or anything, how that applies to tribal lands.

47:21 And so CAL FIRE reached out to the White Bark Institute, and they want to kind of do a study to really figure out what's needed to implement projects there. And so that's kind of what this project is about. And then they also received another grant for more the home hardening type of work, so working from the home outward. And again, partnering with...

47:52 with them on that and bringing in Yana to really help with the messaging on that piece. Any questions about those? Yeah, I had a question. I'm glad to hear that White Bark Institute is definitely focusing on some projects down south. And I guess one of my questions is how is it decided which areas to focus on?

48:21 You mentioned 40 acres, and you mentioned Lone Pine, so I'm just curious, what is that process that they go through to decide which areas to focus on? Yeah, largely, it's kind of who's the loudest, like where is the motivation? Right now, that's kind of how it's been going. So, we have three fire-safe councils in Inyo County, 40 acres, Wilkerson, and Independence, that are active. And so,

48:52 When I first came in, it was kind of like, what's happening with those, and are there projects that are started, and how can I help build capacity to make sure that those are going through? The Community Wildfire Protection Plan for the county will really help address what are all the needs across the county, and then we can prioritize based on

49:22 You know, subject matter input from, you know, where is the greatest risk? Where is the greatest, like, ability to bring in funding for those? It's kind of multifaceted, but I would say motivation is a big piece for getting a lot of these projects done. And so that's part of your role to kind of look at the science and identify which are the areas that are most at risk and have the biggest impact on people.

49:49 And then make those recommendations for how to prioritize. Okay. And then the other question that I have with that is I see, I'm happy to see there's lots of collaboration with other entities. I'm just curious, is there any coordination with DWP in particular for riparian area fire mitigation since those are the ones that are most likely to take off in the near future?

50:18 Yes, definitely. I actually have a meeting with DWP at 1.30 today to kind of just get their annual plans or the operating plans for what they have for vegetation management. The riparian areas are kind of a tricky situation anyways. We don't have great solutions for fire mitigation for riparian areas in this area. So there is a working group set up that is, you know, it's

50:49 The BLM, I think, is going to be piloting kind of some projects to identify some good solutions forward with that. But yes, DWP is, we're trying to really build that relationship and figure out how to actually get some work done on the ground in those areas. Yeah, especially this year with the flows, there won't be any ground to actually take dozers into.

51:18 And then the other question I have is, like, this is a lot on your plate, it seems like, so how do you prioritize your efforts for your day-to-day? That's a great question. Yeah. Largely, I don't know if I have a great answer to that, to be honest. Like, right now it feels like every, I'm just kind of, like, casting every, what's that term?

51:52 Fire, iron into the fire, you know, and just really trying to figure out, okay, what's needed here, what's needed here, what's needed here, but I think through the, you know, the planning efforts, I'm able to align, I'm starting to see, like, okay, these, you know, outreach efforts can really be aligned with this community wildfire protection plan.

52:17 And so I'm starting to kind of be able to group efforts into larger initiatives. But it is a lot, and I feel pretty scattered a lot of the time. So it's a great, great question. Do you have any tips or things that you're really looking for? I mean, at the end of the day, just remember what we want to do is keep people safe. I would always think like that is your North Star.

52:48 Yeah. And I do think we have a lot of people working in this space, and so really leaning on our collaboratives and our agencies is really helpful in that way, too. So, yeah, I agree. Thank you. I appreciate this information and appreciate your collaborative efforts. And this is easier to ask than it is to answer, perhaps similar. But, again, the anxiety that is resonant in the...

53:23 Average resident and visitor. There's a need to constantly say, here's how we're doing. And to the extent that in all this, working with the partners and the plans, we can try to develop basic information that says, here's the progress we're making. Here's where we stand in terms of, you know, this many abilities to get to defensible space information or whatever, so that we answer the simple question, which is the one we seem to get all the time. How are we doing? What's we doing? Are things getting better?

53:53 You know, there's clearly, at least in my sense, there's more money being devoted to this now. There's more effort being devoted to this now. But from an average resident or even visitor standpoint, it's so what? You know, and we are, you know, we are treating. We're doing people's treatment. We're doing thinning. We're doing briefings. We're doing a lot of things. But where do we stand on that? How much progress are we making? And so in all of this, if we can move towards, and I hate to continue to use the same word, some kind of a dashboard that gets to results.

54:21 So that we can say to people, hey, we were here, and we're here now, and with the money we have, we're going to be able to get to here or whatever, so that we constantly are communicating back to the results of what we've been doing with these investments and with the collaboration. I think that's huge to be able to build the confidence, the safety sense for our citizens and visitors. Yeah, absolutely. And I am building a website, the Ready Inyo website, and that's kind of a question that

54:49 I have is where to house some of this information that's pertinent to both counties, like a dashboard in terms of that. So is the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance page kind of the page? But I hear you for sure. And that is a priority. And I think we are kind of set up in a way to, at least through the Inyo County CWPP, we will have kind of a project identification map and a project track.

55:24 That will have a dashboard to it. So in terms of the kind of one of the outputs of the CWPP is a mitigation strategies for all those three, the landscape treatments, the fire adapted communities. And so we will be able to kind of start to quantify like what efforts are going towards projects and how that equates to residents. But I think

55:58 Another piece of that is we can share some of these success stories like when we go up to Starlight and we talk about literally walk through the neighborhood and kind of like point out little pieces that residents can do here or there that will really increase their chance of surviving the next wildfire. Those types of moments I think really empower people and that's kind of a metric that's hard to measure and hard to gauge sometimes but that's kind of

56:29 I think where I've seen people's perspectives change and kind of like seeing the spark in their eyes like, oh, there's hope or something. Yeah, and I would hope that that's a good example that you do that in Stardust. The same thing could be done in Mono City. And so sharing that with Wendy and saying, hey, we just did this, you know, again, it's a regional thing. And if we can be, you know, defer or default almost on a regional basis so we don't end up duplicating or missing out on the learning that we can do across the region. Yeah, and

57:01 That reminds me. I am trying to kind of partner with Bree Chappelle-Montgomery on the Neighborfest, Neighborhood Fest or something like that. I just barely learned about that. But that's kind of another example of, you know, I was kind of starting this community engagement piece, but, you know, there's already some programming going on, so we can really start to align efforts that way so we're not all duplicating.

57:31 Great. Thank you. A couple thoughts. I know we've got a lot to get to today, so I'll try to be succinct. I want to follow up with you on a recently published joint strategy from the Wildfire Task Force. This is the California's Joint Strategy for Sustainable Outdoor Recreation and Wildfire Resilience. This is something that is germane to all of us. This is a statewide effort, but it comes down to the ground, and there will hopefully be state money associated with all that.

58:01 And obviously I refer back to SHRIMP, our Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program, sweet spot right there. The other piece is Plantscape. We got some news. It's kind of a day job I have that a statewide database of all recreation infrastructure throughout the entire state is now going to be elevated and moved into Plantscape. I'm going to be at a 30 by 30 session next Thursday in Truckee with Secretary Crowfoot.

58:25 Jennifer Norris from the 30 by 30 initiative along with Catherine Tolley is doing the Access for All initiative. So there'll be a statewide database of all those recreation infrastructure pieces that can start to be tied into all this stuff. So I think from a regional perspective, we'll have some good tools to work with.

58:41 Communications piece, again, I refer back to the visitor connection package. I mean, there's so many different disparate efforts. It's so great to see the energy coming up from the ground, but the degree to which we can align things, and to your point, not be duplicating, not be overlapping, but leveraging all of our collective social resources will be super awesome. A little kind of a word of caution, again, I know you're doing a lot of state stuff these days, OPR.

59:05 I serve on that technical advisory council for the ICARP for the climate change program. And somebody mentioned, well, we have to do something about, because Caltransit no longer wants to build more lanes. If you build more lanes on a road, that encourages more traffic, more climate issues. We don't want to do that. Okay, we're not going to do that stuff anymore. And it was brought up, the issue about egress routes, emergency egress routes. And the OPR people were very quick to say, no, we're not going to, you know.

59:31 No more roads. We're not doing any more kind of stuff. And I kind of raised my hand and said, well, hang on a second. Those of us out here where we only have one road and you're not going to allow us to be able to start building the necessary emergency egress infrastructure that we need, that's something if the world circles you running around and maybe, hang on a second here. Let's make sure we can get the road infrastructure in place so that we don't have paradise situations. We don't have those kinds of things out here.

59:58 That would be important. And finally, as all this great work, the planning work starts coming up to the ground, and all of our communities are going to get money to do fuels treatment work. And we want to offer whatever lessons we're learning in Mammoth, how the town, how it jurisdictions engages with this thing, because you go from a $100,000 planning grant to a $3 million implementation thing, cash flow issues, what roles the towns, the counties can play to make sure these things happen.

1:00:24 So we're here to share any of that kind of stuff as we wanted to go forward. So, sorry, thank you. Yeah, and I think like looking forward to some of these funds that are coming down, like making sure that we have the infrastructure to be able to utilize that funding. So, you know, like there's money coming in to retrofit homes for, you know, home hardening efforts. Do we have the contractor, you know, base to be able to actually

1:00:53 Implement something like that. Those are kinds of things for sure that we're kind of thinking about. Go ahead. Thanks so much. I love that you're going out into communities. And when you do that, if you could just even make like short videos, 15 seconds that you put up, then the rest of us can share it. Because I think, you know, there's all these great things happening and we're such a vast region people just don't even know.

1:01:18 What's going on? And the second is, would it be possible to get, for us to get a copy of your PowerPoint? Because I'd love to have that as talking points. Thanks. And then one, yeah, just the, I don't, I don't mean to harp on this point, but like, it would, because I know you're, you're, you're at this point, you're starting the position, you're just getting all caught up in everything and learning the lay of the land.

1:01:43 But in particular, I'm looking at the Eastern Sierra Nevada Regional Forest and Fire Capacity Program, sub-regional plan that was included here. And box one terrifies me, where there is the sub-region project priorities, and there are like 10 or 12 of them, and they're just listed in alphabetical order. And as we know, when everything's a priority, nothing's a priority. And so I just want to...

1:02:12 Caution. Let's not go that route. Yeah, definitely. I'm not very familiar with that plan because I just received it as part of this packet. Okay. But there is the, you know, going back to the State Wildfire Task Force, there are some regional toolkits that have been made and a part of that is data and metrics. And I could...

1:02:42 Pull that up if you want, but I, when I, when I first started, I kind of looked at what our region and specifically the east side of our region, those metrics were and one of the, and it does kind of like give a way to prioritize some of those bigger pieces. Okay, maybe this is a dumb question, but I was looking through this plan and in the Inyo County Community Wildfire Protection 2005, it lists an organization called the Eastern Sierra Region Fire Safe Council.

1:03:17 Did that exist? What is that? Oh, it did exist at one point. Rick Cattleman with the White Bark Institute actually told me about this and sent me just one document about them, but I don't think it really got traction. So I'm not sure exactly what you're aiming for there, but one of the things that I do find across...

1:03:47 The state is they typically have larger fire safe councils and within them fire wise communities because kind of the admin burden of running a fire safe council is what's kind of causing some of these like lone pine fire safe councils no longer, you know, like big pine no more. Like it is taxing for sure for all of our volunteers. So that is kind of a question that we have moving forward is

1:04:18 Yeah, and...

1:04:56 I agree, 100%. And that's kind of what I'm hearing from the state, too, or from all of our, you know, different partners around the state. For a while, it was more promoting the smaller community-based fire safety council. Yeah. Yeah, I think. Agreed. Okay, I want to be mindful of time. Any other questions? Thank you so much, Kristen. Thank you. Thanks for driving all the way up here.

1:05:23 We will move on to the next item, which is the Inyo Mono Airport Working Group Committee Report for the meeting held on April 7, 2023. Good morning, Chair Griffiths and your board. Pleasure to be in Mammoth this morning. At our last meeting, we re-established the Mammoth Inyo Air Working Group, the Miag.

1:05:55 It was stated to me that we should adopt the loose acronym, Working W-O, so like MIWOG, and it rhymes with ESCOG. Committee, that subcommittee had their first meeting on April 7th to discuss regional air issues related to sustainable, reliable air service at the Bishop Airport. The agenda was structured largely around three...

1:06:21 policy questions. The first is determining the governance and funding structure for air service subsidies at the Bishop Regional Airport. The second was defining success for current and future air service. And the final policy question that was put to the committee was planning for airport infrastructure and operations. What would be required to support regional air service and which parties would be responsible for

1:06:51 paying for that. Coming out of that committee meeting, there was some broad direction that was provided by the committee. Generally, there was enthusiasm and support from all of the member agencies that Air Service and Bishop has been successful and provides value to the region and to the communities, but that there does need to be a working group established.

1:07:20 Formalized at a staff level to be able to coordinate and plan for all the different components that go into making regional air service work, including planning for commercial service, what the subsidy structure would look like, which parties would be involved, and that that would need to be a staff group so that they could be nimble and responsive and being able to meet and do research, but that there should potentially be ongoing tiered

1:07:49 Governance that would include that new log committee so that that information is getting reported back to elected elected officials and is in a public forum so that there's transparency back to the community. It was also established that although there's generally enthusiasm and support and that regional air service is currently considered a success, that definition of success really does need to be defined as North Star to guide that committee work.

1:08:19 And then finally, as it relates to ongoing operations and infrastructure, there was direction from the committee that some strategic plan needs to be put together to look at the different strategies, look at different funding models from other regional airports, look at governance models from other regions, and bring that back to the MIWAG and tailor it so it's appropriate for the service we need in the Eastern Sierra.

1:08:46 So that provides, that's my overview of that meeting. At this point, I would turn it over to Mr. Greenberg. Mr. Deshaun has stepped out for the moment. And the Miwag committee members to provide any additional information from that meeting, answer questions you may have. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine. Nate Greenberg, Inyo County CAO. And you did a great job of basically saying pretty much everything I was just going to say. So I'm not sure exactly what I'll add, but I will just sprinkle a few things in.

1:09:20 You know, I think it is worth saying that in addition to the four committee members, Supervisors Oral and Gardner, Council Member Wentworth and Schwartz, we had key staff in the room, myself, Ashley Helms, City Manager, Sean, John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Ron Cohen from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So there was a good and robust conversation from a variety of different stakeholders and interests around these policy questions. You know, as Dan Holler and I were working to sort of

1:09:50 Build out and try to tee up this group. We were really trying to figure out what the right way to structure the questions. And there's a lot to this conversation. And I have continued to sort of, well, obviously, first I will say that I think the majority of the conversation was aimed at Bishop Airport and primarily the air subsidy around the commercial air service, although there was a certain amount of conversation with respect to Advanced Air and the Mammoth Airport and certainly.

1:10:19 Rob Patterson is here and has to Dan if there are questions or things on that topic. But with respect to commercial air service at the Bishop Airport, we've been kind of articulating it as a three-legged stool and that three-legged stool consists of air service and that's the partnership with the airline itself, the cost of the ticket, the schedule, the market, those types of things.

1:10:44 The second leg would be the airports themselves. That's the infrastructure and the needs to actually be able to support air service as a whole. And the third is the subsidy. And no matter which one of those three topics you want to start into a conversation on, it sort of drives the conversation in the other two. You can't talk about expanding markets without also having a conversation about the subsidy that's necessary to support that expanded market.

1:11:09 Or the infrastructure necessary to basically be able to handle additional enplanements or planes. You want to talk about subsidy? Well, it's going to drive some of those other conversations. So it's really a question of what are we really trying to ask and solve for and what are we really trying to head towards as a whole? And I think Elaine said it well. What is the strategy? What is the North Star? How do we have a conversation that's thoughtful and robust? And so those three policy questions that were posed, I think,

1:11:39 We're designed to start that conversation. And I think, you know, first and foremost, I think that the question of governance is really principal in this, in that we as the four agencies have a very necessary interest. I mean, the county of Inyo around the airport itself and the capital infrastructure needs associated with that, I think the four agencies with respect to the subsidy component, we know that

1:12:09 The T-bid can only cover a certain element of traveler and that it's an expectation that we find some other funding mechanism to cover those non-tourist-based travelers that are coming in, or sorry, that are using the service from within the area. And ultimately, what does that governance structure look like is, I think, the thing that we've all sort of been struggling with. It was clearly decided that for the time being, the Miwag is the only real entity for that. I have said that

1:12:38 I do question longer term as we sort of move through this. There may need to be some cleaning up of some of that governance given the way that the ESCOG works in relation to our four agencies and then the delegates down to the MIWOG being an even more refined version of that. There's a little bit of potential clumsiness that's there, but I think we can sort of work our way through that. I do think that the comment that Elaine made quickly about the need for

1:13:06 Separation between a policy-level conversation like the MiWOG and a staff-level working group that exists and has existed for quite some time, which basically is a collaboration of the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, Inyo County, and the City of Bishop, really aimed at how we are doing air planning and some of those strategic decisions. That is a necessity, but I think an integration between them is something that has been a little bit...

1:13:32 I think we all sort of have agreed that there needs to be a little better connection between those and what that looks like. We can continue to noodle on and evolve, whether it's a regular report out to the ESCOG or integration with the MIWOG occasionally. I mean, I think that there's room for some of that. I think the bottom line, you know, the seven or so questions that were sort of stated there at the bottom end of the staff report did a good job of summarizing it.

1:14:02 I think that there are more questions than answers as a whole around this and that I see it as, no pun intended, a need for us to kind of build the plane and fly it at the same time because we are already making commitments to air service schedules and requesting what we are going to be looking for for next year while we are still working through and finishing up this year. We don't even know the final numbers for winter. We're going to be taking a break and going into summer.

1:14:29 You know, all of that sort of drives, I think, a little bit of uneasiness from all of our positions around what are going to be the obligations financially, how are we going to work on sharing those costs and when it's appropriate. All of that is still stuff that needs to be worked out. So I believe, really, we're at a point where there's some conversations that we'll need to come back to probably our individual boards and have some more robust discussion around.

1:14:55 And certainly we don't have a next MIWOG meeting, but I think that we wanted to bring something back to this group first and be able to see there were specific questions, further direction, other asks, and sort of use that as a framework for going into those next conversations. I will say that Ashley and I have been starting to work on some just very, very rudimentary, high-level sort of framework.

1:15:23 around what the key questions would be going into a strategy document and really understanding what it would look like to continue to sustain service as it is now, sort of the one end of continuum and then to expand markets, what that would look like. And I think given that three-legged stool sort of analogy, in each one of those decisions or potential lanes, there are interesting and critical

1:15:51 Questions and decisions that need to be made. And, you know, it's important to recognize that the desire to expand air service and build a terminal is something that will have a long lead time and require probably action sooner than later if we want to see something in the next seven to ten years. And so that's not taken lightly, and I think it needs to be done thoughtfully and carefully. But, yeah, I think that that's, in summary, some of what we were discussing and certainly happy to answer questions.

1:16:21 Fill in other blanks if needed. Mr. Chair, if I could. So from the Mammoth Lakes perspective, there are two tracks that we're wrestling with. The first I want to say is I really want to be as complimentary as I can to our partners in Inyo and Bishop and all of our partners in the region to have had that conversation and to start getting this process.

1:16:51 Moving and rolling. Town of Mammoth Lakes, backing up one step, here in Mammoth Lakes, there's a town, a community of Mammoth Lakes. There's also a significant ski area, a significant recreation driver to the region, an economic driver to the region, that is owned and managed by something called the Alterra Mountain Company that's based out of Denver. And one of the things that was very helpful in the Miwag meeting,

1:17:16 is the beginning to start to chart of who is in what lane and who has what capacity to do what. So it was very helpful to have, Nate, as you mentioned, all those various players at the table because those are truly the players at the table. And if a significant private sector entity such as Altera wants to start driving conversations for more markets or more things, great. I think that's identified now. They have a role and a lane to play in all this.

1:17:45 The Town of Mammoth Lakes perspective. We are now going through the process of considering the renewal of a TBID, and there's been some very active conversations with the council and the community and Mammoth Lakes Tourism about moving that forward. Chris and I are working very closely on that. We've been having some very good and specific conversations with our staff about coming up with a program for the TBID and its renewal that I think we both feel we've got a way forward. We've got to track

1:18:14 That's going to help advance and move that thing forward. And that Miwok discussion was really important as part of that. And just for our regional partners to understand, there will be, through MLT and that TBID, there's going to be some money for air service subsidy. But it's going to be capped. It's not going to cover everything. And I think that's intentional because it has to do with local community needs.

1:18:38 But also, this is about what can we all afford capacity-wise to do air service in this region. To Nate's point, we've all got to start working together and talking together to figure out how that's going to work. So I think on behalf of us in the town, we have our own airport here. We've got obligations from FAA grants, all kinds of other things that we have to meet. These are some of the things we had to put in play to get to reliable regional air service at Bishop.

1:19:05 We're happy we did it. We know that the airport bishop is going to work. It's going to be successful. But we've all got to be working together to advance all this stuff. So we want to thank you for that MiWOG meeting. It answered a lot of questions. It helped us figure out how to frame up this TBID, how to structure it in a way that we think it's going to be successful. It's critically important to our community and our town. We want to move it forward. But to your point, there's a lot of work to do to make this whole thing work. And I was...

1:19:34 We talked yesterday, Elaine, a little, there is no action associated with this. But I think what's clear is we need to figure out what these next steps are going to look like. We must be talking with each other. And we must be hearing what the various needs are of the various communities that we all represent to right-size this, to find the sweet spot to figure out what we can afford, what's desired, and what we can do. So I'll leave it at that. But thank you all very much for participating in that. Thank you.

1:19:59 Thanks. And I'll say thank you to the folks who participated in that. I listened in and I was multitasking a little bit, but it was a productive meeting. Some thoughts that I have is when we started ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, it was a thoughtful, intentional idea that it was a regional network and that to divide it out 100 percent.

1:20:27 This much service is in this region, therefore this much contribution monetarily needs to be made, that we were going to run a regional system and strive for equity, but that that was impossible and that the goal was to create the regional network. And I think there's a little bit of that that needs to happen for air service. However, I do think we need to strive to make it as equitable as possible.

1:20:56 And I think there's going to be some challenges with that in that, you know, there's no perfect way or clean way to divide all of that up. You know, even if you divide it by, even if you knew exactly where every passenger was going, you know, the economic impact of a family of four skiing for a week in Mammoth is different than a family of four backpacking in June Lake, you know, or...

1:21:24 Hiding out in the desert of Death Valley. So how do you figure all of that out? And then, you know, what is the North Star, the final goal for people in Inyo County or people in northern Inyo County versus southern Inyo County versus Altera? And, you know, from a political standpoint and an equity standpoint, you know, I think...

1:21:49 We would, all of us down south would get recalled immediately if we were subsidizing a large corporation. Probably as you would as well. Exactly. Exactly. And so it's going to... We've had to divine it. We are divining that. We are establishing our boundaries around those types of questions. Right. And, you know, I think if you... Nate is correct that we are building the plane as it's taking off. You know, I think Inyo County has, you know, we...

1:22:18 Committed to supporting the subsidy this year that is perhaps greater than our share, perhaps less than our share. I don't know what it is, but, you know, because nobody knows what it is, but we've made that commitment for this year. And we have also committed a tremendous amount in the past and moving forward to upgrades and operations of the airport. So it will be a challenge to put all of that into a magic formula and come out with something that's...

1:22:47 Equitable for everybody. I'll just add to that. I mean, as part of our discussions here, I've done research into all this. There are tools and methods to get the policy bodies the information they need to make those decisions. This is not something that no one's ever done before. And I think that's something that, I mean, if you look at just the basics of it, our base population is 30,000 people. Is it a population of what? Compare that with what goes on in Reno.

1:23:17 600,000 people, major interstate highways, and all kinds of things going on. There's ways to do that analysis. I think it is part of what we do going forward. I think it would make a lot of sense when we start trying to do that. We've all got some tools to work with to make the kinds of tough decisions you're talking about. Yeah, and I think looking backwards out of necessity, a lot of this was happening on the fly and happening at a staff level. And that had to happen because we had the goal of creating commercial.

1:23:46 We have achieved that goal. But moving forward, just at base level, determining what the equitable and sustainable support for this is, and then looking forward to any sort of expansion, I agree that it needs to be a more public process and full discussion from all of the communities that are contributing to this.

1:24:12 So I think that meeting was the good first step, and I look forward to a much stronger public process. Just very quickly, I do want to reinforce a couple things that Nate said. Number one, your effort to begin to do kind of a strategy document, one status quo, one perhaps more expansive, I think is good in whatever context it goes, but that planning and that work is important. So we have a sense.

1:24:39 in detail in terms of good staff work about our options. And then number two, your point about the governance. I think we need to move on that sooner rather than later just because if we're going to four different entities as we begin to go through all these things, that'll drive us all crazy.

1:24:53 And your point about Estes is a good one. At a certain point, you know, he said, okay, this is a regional thing. We got to do this differently. And I think we're getting to that point. So I would say on those two things, I totally support that and reinforce what you're saying in terms of moving ahead in terms of a strategy document, which would begin to get to strategy options. And then number two, saying, okay, so where is this going from a governance standpoint so that we really, you know, can act at a higher tier in terms of making decisions, providing public opportunities.

1:25:23 You know, from a transparency standpoint. Mr. Chair, if I could, just as we wrap up, great meeting. Okay, what's next? I mean, for Mammoth, I think we told you, we're going to be going through this TBID process. It's attenuated. It's going to take months, public hearings, public meetings. Chris and I, again, we're working closely. We think we've got our way forward here. But in terms of this whole effort, I guess maybe there's no answer at this moment, but I think we're all looking forward to, okay, what's the next little baby step? How do we build on that momentum?

1:25:53 Keep this thing going forward. I know there's no action here with the agenda item, but I think we're all eager and interested to see what that's going to look like. The other thing that we didn't talk about at the MIWAG, which I started thinking about afterwards, is all of the rural, commercially-based airports in the country. So there's communities that have air service with communities smaller than ours that are eligible to apply for grants. I know like...

1:26:22 For instance, Arcata, which is bigger than ours, but areas that don't have huge multinational corporations that are driving an airport in our community, but there's small communities in Arizona, I mean, all across the country that you can apply for money to help subsidize infrastructure, help subsidize air service. So I think we should be talking about

1:26:48 That is what our constituents want is not a subsidy for, you know, skiers to come to Mammoth, but a subsidy for us from the federal government to, like, have a regional airport that little puddle jumpers, you know, could go. Like, my husband, what made me start thinking about it is he ended up flying into Ketchikan, Alaska, and I know Alaska is totally different because there's no roads anywhere, but still, like, that's a super small airport that was, like, from Seattle.

1:27:16 So I appreciate everything that we've said here today about this, but the one thing that...

1:27:48 I'm ever cognizant of is that our counterparts on our four different boards are getting questions from their constituents as well. And I think that the MiWOG meeting was extraordinarily effective and really started that conversation. But I think the very next step is going back to those separate entities and saying, OK, what is our commitment level?

1:28:18 What do we, in our specific space, define it as so that when we come back together as Mewog, we can say, here is our North Star, here is our four points. And that way we're not running back and forth constantly and we're not chasing our tails. I think we need to front load with those conversations, much like Town of Mammoth Lakes is already doing through their TBID process. Just one clarification.

1:28:47 That T bid is not the town. I understand. You know what I mean? It's a separate thing from us. We'll make our own investments. But those types of conversations need to be happening at our separate boards at this juncture so that we are extraordinarily purposeful and cautious so that we don't get a mile down the road and think we got to back up. So that is the one thing that I'm ever cognizant of.

1:29:17 I would agree with that. In addition, what do you want? What is the level of service that you want? And how much does that cost? Because everybody's for more service until there's a price tag that's associated with it. You know, and they're going to ask for data points and what is our economic impact? And so I think those are questions that staff is more than capable.

1:29:46 Okay, and in the interest of time and getting through our agenda, are there any other comments?

1:30:21 Ashley, is there any pressing stuff that you need to tell us? You drove all the way up here. Okay. I mean, Karen, you're absolutely right. There are Department of Transportation subsidies if you're an essential line, and we do qualify for those. Have we looked into actually getting those?

1:30:52 Go ahead, Ashley. I was just looking at my phone at the... Checking out which lifts are open? No. Well, the small... I think it's maybe one of the programs you were looking at. Whether we... The small community grant application. Is that what Arcata got? Yeah, yeah. It's the SCASVP. Yeah. The essential routes, essential air service, yeah.

1:31:22 So that program is different from the Essential Air Service program. We don't qualify for Essential Air Service. Why not? Because that was a program that was created during the 1978 airline, it's also the ADA, the decentralization. Regulation. Regulation, thank you. And so there was a list of airports who were eligible at that time who had

1:31:55 Air service, and we're going to lose air service because of the deregulation. So that fairly large list at the time of eligible airports has been whittled down through the last many decades. So the eligibility list is quite small actually at the moment. There's four airports in California that are eligible. Salia is one of them. I don't remember the other three. There's none in Nevada. But new airports don't become eligible for that.

1:32:29 Right, so that's why they've been, the federal government's been trying to scale down, so if you don't meet a certain number of employments.

1:32:59 At that airport, then you lose eligibility or certain other. Okay. But I will look more into the other program that Arcata was eligible for. Yeah, I mean, I read, like, every year you can apply for grants. Every year you can apply for grants. And, you know, even as small as $100,000 up to a couple million. So, I'm sorry.

1:33:22 I'm sure, I have a loud voice, I project. Okay, thanks. Okay, thanks, Ashley. So, I think we will move on from this one. I have a number 5.4 is discuss regional parks and recreation collaboration, and maybe I'll set the table on this. Please feel welcome to you, Mr. Chair, but if I could just back up for a moment to the previous item. Even though there wasn't direction requested from the board on this item, I think we did hear a couple of things.

1:33:50 I will coordinate with the regional managers to start to move forward with some of that strategic plan, probably in parallel with efforts to coordinate discussions with each of the regional entities so that you have that information or some of that information for those discussions. I just wanted to make sure that there was direction that was heard for staff there. Thank you for that. Thank you. Okay. I have number 5.4, the regional parks and recreation. Okay. Sorry. Go ahead.

1:34:18 Just trying to take it a little bit further, and I'm not even exactly sure if this is the right venue to bring this up, but the Bishop City Park is really being impacted by sports, which is a good thing, obviously. That's what I was going to do for the introduction of this. What's that? I was going to talk about that in the introduction. Hold that thought for just a second. I thought we were just moving on here. I was like, wait.

1:34:44 Okay, so for the Regional Parks and Recreation Collaboration, it was something that ESCOG talked about, I don't know, six years ago or eight years ago or something like that. And the idea was that there's lots of crossover people driving north and south with their kids for camps and recreation activities and sports and all of that stuff. And it was decided that everybody should do their own thing back then.

1:35:13 Recently, it's been brought to my attention by my city colleagues over and over again, and also folks that are with Little League and AYSO. Pickleball. Pickleball. So for various reasons, one, that all of your sports fields are covered in snow up here, particularly right now, and for various reasons, the...

1:35:40 The decrepit state of Mill Pond Park that we don't need to get into now, but there's reasons that it's a challenge to fix up the fields there, that everything gets focused on the city of Bishop. And there are not enough fields, cost a lot of money to maintain those fields, there's not lights for some of the fields, and there's literally not enough time for all of the different...

1:36:06 Youth activities to be able to do that. So that's why I put it on. And now, Destin, you can talk about City of Bishop Park. That had summed it up pretty well, Jeff. And this winter really exasperated how bad that it has become with, you know, teams as far north as Lee Vining trying to scramble to find a place to have a baseball or a softball game.

1:36:33 We started talking about this probably maybe a year ago in our city-county liaison with Inyo County and just at our most recent meeting, is how do we get Millpond back into play shape at the standards of high school sports, I think is what we try to go build everything to. And so it was brought up that maybe it would be a big expense.

1:36:59 Probably not enough staff. So how can we manage this all? And we started thinking, well, can we work, you know, through the ESCOG to the schools and how can we share this cost to bring them, you know, because right now we're even looking at expanding sports beyond high school is the high school age kids that just don't play the organized baseball, soccer, you know, but want to continue playing sports. We can't even entertain the idea right now because we don't have anywhere to put them besides the fact that softball.

1:37:28 Pardon, not softball. Soccer and baseball kind of doing this. They're making their season start or they last longer, adding seasons, you know, and so how do we accommodate that down there? And we've had some early talks, like I said, is it a matter of hiring another employee that we share costs of to maintain it? The city, Dan McElroy, who runs the parks, is going to meet with the county next week and just kind of start assessing.

1:37:54 Because it's been 20 years since those fields have been utilized by any organized sports. I guess the girls' youth softball is using it this year, and it's pretty bad. They don't hit the ball far enough to worry about all the gopher holes in the outfield and the below-grade dugouts that have no fences in front of them. So we're looking at it, and we just want to kind of put on the radar of this group is how can we get everyone involved maybe to utilize it.

1:38:24 Heck, you know, 10 minutes closer to Mammoth, too. I remember when I was in high school, Mammoth did utilize those fields. So it just seems like a real great idea to start looking at as a region-wide thing. So just one more point of why Mill Pond is in the state that it's in is that the dirt there is owned by the city of Los Angeles.

1:38:49 And we have not had a viable lease on that for a very long time. And leave it to your imagination of why that is. But so all of the Prop 64, Prop 68 grants, we were not eligible for that because we did not have tenure to the land.

1:39:14 And even if we did have a lease, they're not the 30 years that are required for infrastructure grants. So if we are going to rehabilitate them, it's going to take some private fundraising, which I think, you know, pickleball, although be careful. Stacy Corliss was labeled Supervisor Pickleball. You could be the heir apparent to that. But, you know, I think we could get some private fundraising. And if we had...

1:39:43 contributions from the various entities in our region that have youth and adults that are pinched for space right now, I think that it's something that's achievable. Yeah, and again, maybe that sounded bad on the county. When that fields were in good shape, there was a concessionaire out there, Browns, and they took care of all those fields. Nobody's had the staff, nor the time.

1:40:10 Money, anything, to take care of them government-wise. So it's been 20 years since Brown's has, so that's how long it's been since they've really been maintained, as is that, what, mowing the grass, probably. Right, and there's also no alcohol allowed in the Bishop City Park, but you can sell beer at Mill Park. Oh, no, we have, like, at the Friends of the Fair, we did a little selling of alcohol. We'll let it happen on Fourth of July. Oh, okay. Okay, take it back. I also just wanted to say that just...

1:40:40 From my own personal experience, I know that there's a lot of young youth in Mammoth that want to be playing soccer year-round. And one, there's no fields in Mammoth in the winter. But two, Bishop doesn't even have the capacity to, like our Bishop AYSO doesn't have the capacity to host these players down here. So I think that if we were to put some collaborative effort into Millpond, we could be having

1:41:08 The Mammoth, Mono County youth who want to be active in the winter when it's not winter sports, we could be accommodating them because otherwise, you know, if they're not playing their high school sport, then they're out of luck, you know, if they're not skiers or hockey players, you know, like I feel like hockey really is the only sport that you can play if you're not, you know, everyone gets to play hockey. It's not like it's selective, so. Well, speaking of hockey.

1:41:35 I think this is a great idea. I'm really glad this is coming forward. Theoretically, we're opening up an enclosed year-round recreation facility that will have a hockey component. Theoretically, because it's been an interesting winter. But I think we should absolutely start having these conversations and look at the assets, the recreation assets that we have regionally. Who's got what? What are the regional needs? I know that we...

1:42:03 All the work we do down there is a joint venture between the town and the county. That's got an LEDWP lease on it. I think this is a nice topic to bring up at the ESSRP, the Sustainable Recreation Partnership. LEDWP tends to sit at those tables, and they've got an interest in water yield and fire for their watershed. Well, okay, recreation, we get into this kind of stuff. So I think it's an excellent idea, and I think we should absolutely be pursuing this. Destin.

1:42:33 Have the schools been a part of this conversation? We're just starting to have them. So we were kind of hoping that it would kind of flood out information to each schools in the region from this group and that we could start having it. Yeah. I ask because I know that previously there was a collaboration between Bishop Unified and the city to create more fields for soccer at the back of the park.

1:43:00 Yes. And the educational entities are, they have access to monies, one-time monies that a lot of others do not. Correct, yeah. Bishop High School paid for all the irrigation, the majority of those fields along Hamby Street. They don't use them now, but they paid for all that, so. Okay, great. I'm going to throw out one other idea that I threw out before that I still think is good. This was when I had kids of age, but Mammoth.

1:43:34 Parks and Recreation has a lot of great programming and the City of Bishop has a lot of great programming. Wouldn't it be great to cross catalog all of those and there would be like one list that the kids could sign up for?

1:43:48 Well, at the risk of repeating, it's a regional, it's a region, dammit. And, you know, we raised our kids in Northern Virginia. The Northern Virginia Regional Park Authority was a wonderful resource in all of Northern Virginia. Parks, programs, and all our kids grew up. And that was because all those jurisdictions said, we're not going to duplicate all this. And they got them together in the same room, formed a JPA to fund it, added a revenue source, and the thing just takes care of itself.

1:44:16 To this day, those are huge parks, beautiful parks. And we're smaller, but we could, you know, that's, if you really want to take those steps, you got to start down that road because it is a regional thing. And I think, you know, even Mono County, I had somebody say to me literally last year, yesterday, I don't think, you know, we're going to have Little League this year because our fields aren't in good shape and we'd have to go to Bishop and I'm not sure we can get the field. And so we're not sure we're going to do that. Well, if, you know, if we...

1:44:43 Get something better going. Then they say, oh, yeah, that's what we do. Or it's more than just going to Bishop, or it depends on stuff. So I just think it's, again, it's a, what do we want to do? Do we have the will to head in that direction on a regional basis and create the revenue structure to support it and get on with it? Well, it's also an economic driver. Like, lots of communities are, one of their huge economic engines are tournaments. It's huge, and people will travel.

1:45:11 You know, historically, we've never been a region to host tournaments because our fields haven't, we don't have enough space and we're hard to get to, but I think if we had Mill Pond as like this amazing venue, we could get, tournaments are a big driver. People are really into their kids' sports. I think we did back in the day. We used to have tournaments out of Mill Pond 30 years ago. Yeah, I don't remember any youth tournaments, but there were a lot of adult softball and stuff that brought a lot of teams to town.

1:45:40 Yeah, it's a great way to bring different types of visitors to the community, kind of like the rodeo, you know, that brings a whole other type of visitor to Bishop for a whole week. Yeah, and me being in the rodeo part, it's just crazy, but everybody wants to come to Bishop, you know, or to the region. If there's an excuse that they get to come for a softball tournament, they make it into a week-long trip. Karen, you read my mind. I've spent way too much time in Norco, so, like, why, you know, we could get enough fields, people would love this. Oh, yeah.

1:46:10 And the other thing is, you know, a lot of this is regional, so people are driving from Nevada and, you know, all over the West Coast for these. Right. Yeah, and taking it even further, if it gained enough steam, really, Millpon could be reimagined of how to create more fields out there with soccer, and there's a lot of grass out there, a lot of space, but, you know, and they only utilize a little bit of it, but again, it takes a lot of, it takes people and money. So, as far as next steps,

1:46:40 Does this board think that it's good to advocate that the regional managers get together and start discussions of this and put some numbers into what these types of things would look like? Yes. Yes. Great. Thank you. Yes. Thank you. Okay. I think I'm doing okay on keeping things moving along. 5.5 is approve modified ESCOG schedule. Ms. Kabbala. Good morning again.

1:47:11 This item was requested by Chair Griffith. As we know, he's taken an important position with CSAC that will require travel throughout the year. Supervisor Oral also represents Inyo County at CSAC. The structure of the ESCOG JPA requires that a quorum consists of one.

1:47:34 Representative from each member agency plus one. So with both of them traveling and having conflicts with the already established ESCOG schedule, we would not have a quorum for any of those days. So staff has put together a revised schedule for your consideration today, which moves each of the remaining ESCOG dates out one week and to Thursday instead of Friday at the request of the town of Mammoth Lakes because their clerk staff

1:48:02 is not available on Fridays, so we would request to move that to Thursday. I've reached out to ESTA because our meetings typically correspond to the ESTA calendar. Mr. Griffiths is, I think, not required for their quorum, so they might coordinate. It sounds like they're pulling their board, and there may be coordination in the future, but at this time, they hadn't gotten back to me indicating that they were going to adjust their schedule to meet this.

1:48:31 I propose calendar. So I'm happy to take any questions on this item, but I am requesting that the ESCOG board discuss these modifications and approve the modified calendar as presented. Thank you. Just an update on that. I have had some initial conversations with Phil about modifying the ESCOG schedule, so we'll look into see how that can happen. But I'm not chair there, so it's kind of less important, right? And we do not need for a quorum.

1:49:01 Thoughts? Works for me. I'm good. Yeah, the states are great. Okay. Motion? Motion to approve the revised ESCOG schedules presented. Second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carries unanimously. Item number 5.6, approve the memorandum of understanding with the Sierra Business Council for the purpose of the Community Economic Resiliency Fund. Good morning, again.

1:49:31 We have had conversations about the Community Economic Resilience Fund for about a year now. I'll provide just a quick overview regardless. So this is a fund made available through the state of California to develop a regional economic development plan. The state was divided into 13 regions, and Inyo and Mono counties are within the eastern Sierra region, which also includes Alpine County.

1:49:58 in four counties on the west side. The funding will be, there's $5 million available for the phase one planning phase of the SURF grant, and that $5 million has been allocated to the Sierra Business Council, who will serve as the fiscal agent and the convener overseeing the implementation of that process in the eastern Sierra. As part of their application to the state, they provided a million dollars

1:50:24 They budgeted $1 million towards community outreach, which was bifurcated to the east side and the west side communities so that there would be on-the-ground coordination within those communities to elevate our economic development priorities. $250,000 of that budget was allocated to the ESCOG to be coordinating with the communities, NGOs, and other partners in the eastern Sierra.

1:50:49 to participate with the CERF and be identifying and elevating those economic development priorities. The Memorandum of Understanding before your board for consideration today formalizes that agreement for SBC to provide $250,000 to the ESCOG JPA to provide for the services I've described, which is participating on the high roads...

1:51:15 High Road Transition Commission, which is the governance structure, building relationships in the Eastern Sierra, particularly with the sort of disadvantaged communities that don't typically get to come or are hard to get to come and participate in that type of outreach effort, facilitate data collection, and provide other services to inform the surf planning phase for the SBC.

1:51:40 I'm happy to take questions on this item, but I'm requesting that your board approve this MOU with the Sierra Business Council for the purpose of providing community coordination to support the surf effort in the eastern Sierra. Thank you. Looks good. No questions. Can I ask for an amendment on item C, that the first deliverable due date specify a year? Yes. Thank you so much. And to answer that question, that's 2023, but I will modify it. Good catch. Thank you.

1:52:25 Okay. Everybody amenable to that? Yes. So unless there's any public comment on this, Mr. Chair, I'm prepared to make a motion. Okay, go for it. That the ESCOG approve the Memorandum of Understanding with the Sierra Business Council for the purpose of the Community Economic Resilience Fund and authorize the Board Chair to sign. I'll second. Okay. Motion and a second. Any further communication comment? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye.

1:52:57 Motion carries. And I just have a question. Mr. Gardner has left, so we don't have a Mono County Supervisor present for the vote. Okay. I'd like to ask one other question. Do we need a roll call for this? This is a financial item, and I think the ESCOG has expectations that the Sierra Business Council will show up and pay the money, and I think it might make sense to have a roll call vote on this. Right. Okay.

1:53:39 Well, and Bob's coming back at some point here. So let's hold off on the vote on that and move on to item 5.7. You're coming back. You have to be seated to vote. So we will do another vote. And there's been a roll call vote requested. So may we have a roll call vote, please? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes.

1:54:13 Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Schwartz? Yes. And Councilmember Muhovey? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. Item number 5.7 is discussion of the submission of a comprehensive economic development strategy, SEDS, and I request that every time either of these come up, you tell us the difference between the SEDS and the SERF.

1:54:42 And it will be my pleasure to do so. I forget who I was speaking with the other day, but the Eastern Sierra is, I think, unique in that we're running these two parallel efforts that are very similar and have extremely similar acronyms. And so one of the efforts from staff on this is definitely going to be to keep that straight in the community as we kick off these projects. So this item is with respect to the SEDS, which is a comprehensive economic development strategy.

1:55:09 As I said, it's a parallel effort to the development of the surf, but it is a distinct and entirely separate process and document at the end. The SEDS, where the surf is a state process, the SEDS is a federally required document to apply for certain funding for economic development and resiliency projects in the Eastern Sierra. So we as a region,

1:55:34 The jurisdictions within the Eastern Sierra are not able to apply for funding through the EDA or certain types of funding through the USDA or the SBA without having a SEDS in place. It's the first question before you're even allowed to submit an application. The Rural County Representatives of California, RCRC, identified a grant for the development of a SEDS in Inyo, Mono, and Alpine counties, and the economic development staff for each of those jurisdictions has been...

1:56:04 participating in the development of that SEDS strategy for a couple of months. An important update related to that, the SEDS consulting team, Thomas P. Miller and Associates, will be in the region for their community engagement meetings next week. There will be sessions in Inyo County on Monday. Southern Inyo will be in Independence Monday morning. And then there will be meetings in the city of Bishop at the county office building.

1:56:32 on Monday afternoon. They'll be in Mono County on Tuesday, so Mammoth here in Sweet Z in the morning, and then in Bridgeport in the afternoon, and then they'll be going to Alpine County and doing community outreach on Wednesday with a Zoom option available for Western Alpine County on Friday. So if you are able to attend, be aware and cognizant of any

1:56:52 Any sort of Brown Act conflicts that that may present, but if you're able to attend, please do. You can get that information from me. I'll send it out in an email later today as well and invite the community to participate. In the development of this SEDS document, one of the items that has come up is when the document is completed, there needs to be a regional entity that submits the document to the EDA for approval.

1:57:22 And that that strategy is then housed within the entity. And that comes with annual reporting requirements that demonstrate any project work that's being done to implement the SEDS, any funding that's being brought in, and then a requirement that it's updated every five years to remain current. What we have heard from rural county representatives of California

1:57:48 From our consultants, what I have heard from the other economic development staff in the region is that the ESCOG is a logical entity that serves as a regional body to be submitting this document to the EDA for approval. And Alpine County has, even though they're not within the ESCOG GPA, they also agree that that is logical for their organization as well. If it were not to be the ESCOG, we would have to identify another single point entity that would.

1:58:16 So perhaps Mono County would then serve to submit the SEDS on behalf of the region, or Inyo County would have to do it. But there is general concurrence that it would make sense for the ESCOG to be that entity. And if the ESCOG, if the board gives me direction to continue coordinating that submittal through the ESCOG, it wouldn't...

1:58:44 Remove any authority from the individual member agencies to be submitting projects through the SEDS for their own independent initiatives. It wouldn't require that all projects would need to come to the ESCOG. Each independent agency still has individual authority to be able to leverage that SEDS to get projects done within your communities. In your document, I provided an example of a SEDS. It was something that I'd heard from the board a few times that

1:59:14 People weren't entirely sure what the end product might look like, so I had a really nice example provided to me from Northern California, just included that in there for your reference, and then for your consideration about what organizational capacity would look like for that annual reporting compliance included.

1:59:33 An example template for that as well. And it is a template. If you look through it, you'll see there's a lot of sort of boilerplate pages that just regurgitate what the goals and the policies are. With that, I'm happy to take any questions. But today what I'm looking for is discussion and direction from your board to work with our regional partners to move forward to submit the SEDS through the ESCOG to the EDA.

2:00:02 At the end, at the conclusion of the SEDS process, the document needs to be adopted by the boards of supervisors by resolution. The counties can adopt the SEDS on behalf of the incorporated jurisdictions within the county. And we can, within that resolution, include direction from the member agencies authorizing the ESCOG to serve in this capacity.

2:00:30 And that it's consistent with the surf pilot project authorities that we have in place currently. It would require that we would need to go to the City of Bishop and the Town of Mammoth Lakes with that authorizing resolution in addition to the two counties and Alpine County. So that concludes my presentation. I'm happy to take questions. Again, requesting that your board authorize me to move forward to coordinate submitting the sets to the ESCOG. Okay.

2:00:59 Questions, discussion? Fully supported. I would assume that we all do. But that question, Grace, we don't have to get into this now, but the authority of the ESCOG certainly was a pilot something or other, so we need to come back. ESCOG has a somewhat unique structure where before they can undertake a program of work, ESCOG does have to go ask for permission from all of the member agencies. And there is right now an economic development program of work in place.

2:01:36 The guide rails on that resolution are essentially that in conjunction with member agencies, ESCOG may work on the CERF and the SEDS. So the resolution is phrased such that ESCOG really shouldn't be out there doing anything totally independently, but ESCOG is authorized to work in conjunction with the member agency. And the good news is that the CERF and the SEDS programs are very much set up such that the program itself requires ESCOG to work in conjunction with the member agency.

2:02:05 I mean, I think as Elaine just outlined, ESCOG is potentially going to be working to create this SEDS, but then it has to go to each member agency to adopt the SEDS. So there's that, you know, in conjunction with PARTS, as the resolution requires. But there's a time limit on the current authority we're working under. Yeah. So the time limit that the current authority we are working under is a little nebulous. It's not specific. And it is the planning horizon.

2:02:35 for phase one of the CERF, and that currently is projected to be 20, what year are we in? 2024, summer of 2024. And so I do hear what you're saying, which is that I think to submit the CEDS, we would probably, we're fine to do it within the existing resolution. To extend that horizon, we would need to go back to the boards. When we originally went to each of the boards and the councils,

2:03:04 to get engaged with these regional planning efforts under the resolution that's in place currently. It was established as a pilot project specifically to provide assurances to each of those member agencies that there wasn't too broad a scope, that it could be pulled back if necessary, and that the development of the SEDS and the development of the CERF would in and of themselves develop the strategies.

2:03:32 That would further define how the ESCOG would be engaged with those agencies. So I think this is- I just think that, I mean, we're seeing a lot of success out of these things. We'll see how the surf goes. But certainly with the SEDS process so far, successful. So down the road, let's roll this into something that's going to be consistent with the longevity and the need to have an ongoing maintenance of the SEDS program that ESCOG's going to be submitting it. That that horizon is not-

2:04:00 You know, we could pull the whole thing out in six months or something like that. We need to... Anyway, I fully support it. I'm prepared to make a motion, Mr. Chairman, if you're ready. More conversation? Yes, direction. Thank you. I would move that the ESCOG direct staff to coordinate with each county to prepare a resolution authorizing the ESCOG to submit these SEDs on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Region. I'll second. Okay, is there any further discussion or public comment?

2:04:37 No public comments at this time. If not, all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Thank you to staff. All laying the great work you've been doing that with our partners. This one's looking really good. Okay. Item 5.8 is a discussion of expanding ESCOG JPA to include Alpine County. Ms. Kavala?

2:05:45 Thank you.

2:07:10 I'm sorry. Is that me? Yeah, it's you. My microphone was off. Okay. Now my microphone's unplugged, which I think is okay. Okay. Thank you very much, Councilman Bubzer. So what Alpine County has seen is that there's this increased capacity for regional coordination and that we're already working with Alpine County on a number of those initiatives like the SEDS and the SURF. And similar to the conversation we were just having about the resolution.

2:07:38 The authorizing resolution that allows ESCOG to engage in those efforts, Alpine County sees the value in that coordination, sees the value in participating in it, but doesn't feel like it's appropriate at this time to engage formally with the JPA. So what he said is it could be a logical progression, but this is not the time to be doing it now. But he said that he is very interested in continuing to coordinate.

2:08:06 Bob, this is your fault.

2:08:37 Well, my interest in this is basically to say you're invited to the party. If basically the response is, thank you for your invitation, we're already attending some of your parties, but we may not want to have to attend the parties, all the parties, fine. But what I don't want to get into, especially as a lot of these things...

2:08:57 develop and a lot more and more of them are developing that involve Alpine or at least involve a regional thing that should involve Alpine. There's going to be issues where we're making decisions which affect Alpine and they could come up that that county says, gee, we don't have a seat at the table. So this goes down, you know, as a record of saying you're invited to the table. It's not without, you know, some implications understood, but you are always invited to the table. Obviously, we've got to

2:09:27 I agree on that, but we wanted to make that invitation. I had a conversation with David Griffith at least a couple years ago, and he said, understand completely, but not now. And at that time, he'd had a conversation with his colleagues. That's why I wanted to bring it up again, because it's at least been a couple years. But I struggle with issues where somebody gets involved in an issue, and then at a certain point, you don't talk about the substance, you argue about the process. And the process is, I wasn't involved.

2:09:56 So this is an effort to say we don't want to get in a position where Alpine County is involved in some of these things, but they didn't have a chance to join ESCOG and have a role in making some of these overall decisions. That's where I'm coming from. I don't know how anybody else feels. So my thoughts on this are I know four of the Alpine supervisors really well and they're very engaged. And I agree that the region concerns are it's already a challenge to get a quorum.

2:10:33 Let me clarify, let me clarify, Grace.

2:11:12 If it is put into the agenda at every meeting that Terry Withrow is going to be at X location, she could do that remotely under existing law. Okay, so nobody ever has to be physically somewhere if you notice based on the law. And that's something we need to remember after our COVID thing. As long as you notice it appropriately, you never have to be in the room. Right, so the public can snowmobile into Terry's house. That's right.

2:11:41 Anyway, but regardless of that, I do think that we should be very thoughtful and careful about official status and what the implement to maintaining a quorum use of. Yeah, and I think that you can do a lot of things without being, and I think if there are things, I mean, certainly they're your neighbors, and if something, if we have at least this level, you know, we're here, we're here, something's coming up, you could, you guys certainly remember, if there's something coming up about.

2:12:27 I mean, it's a big burden to get into the, I hear what you're saying, but I think there's a way to, you know, they come to the ESSRP meetings every month, I mean, they're engaged, they're in the air district, and there's all kinds of different things. I think we're okay, but I appreciate the sentiment, our door's open. Okay. Yeah. I mean, I think, I think that that's kind of what I'm thinking, that, yeah, we've made it clear that the door is open, but I don't think we want to drag people in if they don't want to come.

2:12:57 And so I think at this point it's great. They should be participating in all of the discussions that are relevant. But the ball's in their court. And to take this up again, I think it would behoove them to show up at a meeting and ask to join. Then we can reopen that. I agree with Council Member Wentworth.

2:13:27 Perhaps go one step further, though, and request that they do designate somebody to attend our meetings just so that there isn't that, well, we didn't know, we're surprised. So if we at least have one body remotely paying attention, disseminating that information back, there's some level of consistent engagement. And then we also know

2:13:57 Who is engaging us so that if we want to engage them, we have that point of contact. I don't think we should require that they attend a meeting or anything like that. That's not our place to do. I said ask. I said ask. Our ability to compel is hopefully relatively modest. Ask that there be somebody as a liaison. Okay.

2:14:25 Okay, does everybody feel satisfied and does staff have sufficient direction? Yes, thank you. Okay. 1045. I think I should get bonus points for moving this thing along.

2:14:52 5.9 is discussion regarding ESCOG administration of Sierra Nevada Conservancy Landscape Investment Pilot Project. Okay. A lot of discussion items today. So the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is considering restructuring how they distribute certain grant funds in the Sierra Nevada region.

2:15:21 To make it more efficient to administer those grants, to apply for those grants, and for them to administer as well. So they've established a pilot project, which is known as the Landscape Investment Strategy, where they would provide block grants to regional projects that serve multiple benefits. So rather than making applicants apply for smaller project-specific grants,

2:15:50 And then have to apply and apply and apply. There would be a larger project, and they would get block grant funding from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy to implement this larger amount of funding. And then one of the requirements in how the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is proposing to structure this is that it also then wouldn't be for a single project scope of work, but rather there would be multiple different

2:16:14 project categories of priorities that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is seeking to implement through that block grant. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy reached out to the Whitebark Institute as one of the potential projects that they would award this pilot funding to for implementation of the donut project on the ground. They reached out with an offer for a $10 million block grant.

2:16:43 And then also requested that the Whitebark Institute identify a recreation component to sort of satisfy some of those multiple priorities. The recreation project that was identified as a shovel-ready plan to take off the shelf project was

2:17:01 Much overdue campground improvements in the Lakes Basin and trailhead improvements and parking improvements. And that would be an additional $2 million on top of the $10 million that is proposed. There's currently four pilot projects that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is considering awarding this funding to. An award hasn't been announced yet, obviously, so I don't know if the Whitebark Institute's grant proposal is the one that will be accepted after those four are not.

2:17:29 However, in anticipation of that, Lightbark reached out to the ESCOG to see if there is interest from this board of housing and administering that grant within the ESCOG. They haven't yet identified which agency would administer that program. Obviously, there's a $12 million project contingent, so it would require some organization with substantial enough budget to be able to handle a project of that size.

2:17:59 Some of the benefits that could come from housing this project within the ESCOG is that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is very favorable towards projects like this being championed by local governments and in particular the sort of cross-jurisdictional support. So I think that if we were successful in administering that project through the ESCOG,

2:18:28 It would provide good standing in the future for additional potential landscape scale projects through the ESCOG through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Block Grant Program. It will also provide ongoing revenue support for the ESCOG. I forget exactly what the administrative...

2:18:51 So I'm bringing this to your board today for consideration if we would like to

2:19:20 House if this grant were awarded to Whitebark if we would like to house that within the ESCOG and be the receiving agency for that. The announcement will be made in June from the SNC board and so that would be our timeline for wanting to have a formal approval from this board if that we want to be the submitting organization administering the grant to the ESCOG. I'm happy to take questions. I have a question.

2:19:49 Wouldn't we have to submit like an RFP? Like wouldn't it have to be similar to, yeah, so it really wouldn't be the White Burke Institute getting it, we'd have to like put it out there, right? So there's a few ways that we could deal with that.

2:20:07 We use the Town of Mammoth Lakes public procurement procedures. And so this is what we have done in the past for an open and transparent process is run in RFP. Because of how this project in particular is structured, that it's a relationship with whitebark that's already established, that whitebark has submitted the grant, that whitebark is overseeing the implementation of this forest resiliency project.

2:20:35 The board could consider a sole source recommendation as well. Just offer a little background on this. From the ESCOG's perspective, this is a very significant opportunity. This is being driven by state policy. This is the wildfire task force. We've got to treat millions of acres. They want to get to scale. They want to go big and do anything like this. And this is just a pilot. But I think...

2:21:04 The great presentation we heard earlier, I know Bishop Inyo's, you know, concerns about wildfire and when we get some, we need to do some work down there. This is a kind of an engine that if this thing can come through the ESCOG and the work that we do to start bringing projects forward, we already know how to do this and there's no other rural part of the state that's doing this. The other thing I bring up is this, the level of work that's going on here now is attracting national attention.

2:21:32 And not necessarily in a good way. There are national interests that would say to Whitebark, hey, we can be your nonprofit sponsor. We can provide the administration for this. And I think to Whitebark's credit, I mean, going back to the beginning of this stuff, local jobs, local economic development, and the work that has been going on in Inyo County and City of Bishop about doing economic development type work, these are the sectors that we can work in.

2:22:01 I think it's for a number of reasons that we may haven't considered yet that, yeah, we want this here. We want this to be for us. I guess my one question is, what's the downside? I think that there's a few downsides. You know, $10 million, $12 million is a pretty considerable amount of grant funding to be managing. I think at that point, depending again on what the administrative budget would be,

2:22:31 We might consider hiring dedicated staff for that project because that would be beyond the scope of the capacity we have now. One of the things that I would want to do if I get board direction to sort of investigate this further, Mono County serves as our fiscal agent for the ESCOG, and I think with the scope of grant work we have now, you know, the ability to...

2:22:56 Cashflow of those projects is relative to the amount of grant funding we have, and that relationship is working. But I would want to make sure that our fiscal agent is comfortable with a $12 million project over the lifetime of how long that might be. But I also think that this project, the time frame of the project is much more considerable. So obviously those payments aren't going to come in really significant chunks. Those are the two concerns that I have.

2:23:21 And to elaborate a little bit on what Mr. Wentworth was saying, and I didn't have a chance to say this earlier with Ms. Filer presenting, it is really good to see this strategic work that's being done in Inyo County. I'm really happy to hear sort of coming out of that RFFCP plan that's in your agenda that looks at firefighting capacity on a regional level that Inyo County is working on a county-wide

2:23:49 Community Wildfire Protection Plan that will be able to refine those priorities and identify specific projects. But once we identify those projects, the question does become, how do we pay for them? And then who actually does that work? And the ability that we have to be able to bring in funding at scale to do that workforce development around the project as large as the donut, theoretically, the

2:24:12 hope and endeavor there is that then we have the workforce capacity who can be working on those projects in the ground while Mammoth is buried under 25 feet of snow in Mono County. So I do see that there's regional benefit, certainly, in bringing this through the ESCOG. Certainly we'll need more details on the application as how it would influence cash flow and capacity. One other point to add to that is we have this ongoing...

2:24:39 Effort to establish a master challenge cost share agreement with the U.S. Forest Service has been resubmitted. And this, when that finally gets approved, that comes back. We are now in a position to be able to consume federal, state. There's a lot of money in wildfire. I mean, I think it's great. We should just make sure that there's either funding for those administrative purposes or that are current.

2:25:08 Fiscal partners and everything are able to handle it if there isn't. One other minor thought, sorry, Chris. Airports, how much do airports cost? And if we start getting into, if the SEDS, that moves forward, other things, other, we need to be thinking, not that we're going to do it, but be thinking big like that. I mean, if multi-million dollar infrastructure projects start coming through, we need to be anticipating those kinds of opportunities. Sorry, Chris, go ahead.

2:25:37 Oh, no, that's okay. One other question that I'm asking on behalf of Supervisor Salcido is where else could this be placed? What other options would even be available? Or some federal nonprofit that's eyeing this money? Yeah, I mean, again, it's like this is one of those things that this is what we set this up to do. And we are starting to see, you know, various types of reptiles kind of sniffing a little bit of blood and saying, oh, we, you know, yeah, to your point, Stephen, that's exactly right.

2:26:18 I don't think we want to let them in. It sounds like it's an incredible opportunity for the region and I have no opposition to it. I just want to make sure that if we are moving forward that we're being proactive in making sure that we have a clear path to hiring staff because I don't want to see you get into a position where

2:26:52 Well put. Okay.

2:27:26 Do you feel like you have sufficient direction? I have sufficient direction. I really appreciate the board being available largely to just sort of vet this opportunity and put considerations on what some of the concerns might be. Because our next meeting is until June and we might need to have more clear direction before then, I will be working to develop more information around these items and I might be...

2:27:52 communication with your board, possibly for further direction in the interim, just so that we are prepared in June with very clear direction about next steps. Thank you. Okay, excellent. 5.10 is the Executive Director update. Thank you. I will keep these last comments very brief as we're approaching 11 o'clock.

2:28:14 Basically, two project updates. One, we have our consultants on board for the Buttermilk Infrastructure Recreation Plan, planning a project kickoff on the next couple of weeks with them for the recreation planning component of that. Buttermilk Road was basically destroyed this winter.

2:28:35 And that has made it very complicated to coordinate the delivery of the toilet infrastructure. I've been speaking with the manufacturers for that. They're aware of that constraint. So the delivery has been postponed until there is resolution on how the road will be repaired such that we can get toilet infrastructure to the location. I'm also speaking with the National Wildlife.

2:29:03 National Forest, I can't remember the acronym. National Fish and Wildlife. Fish and Wildlife, thank you. Don't forget the fish. National Fire Fish. You just had a nice fish metaphor. Sorry, I digress. At any rate, they manage the grant for us. They're a grant agency, so I've been having conversations with them to get a grant extension. I haven't heard back from them. They said they would get back to me next week. This was a month ago. They have to, that they'd get back to me in the week of the 28th.

2:29:32 Thank you so much.

2:29:55 keenly aware of the issues on the ground and want to see the project done. So hopefully it won't be an administrative burden to get a grant extension for that. Second item is with regards to towns to trails. That project is also gaining lots of momentum. We had a kickoff meeting with each of the land management agencies and also inviting the tribes.

2:30:16 Two weeks ago, that included land management agencies from Inyo, Mono, and Alpine counties. We had actually wonderful turnout and attendance for that. And there was good participation. It seemed that each of those agencies is certainly coming to the table in support of developing the plan, which is a good place to start. Did Los Angeles attend that? LADWP did attend that. And they also provided us with the data files requested to inform what's on the ground, which I thought was a huge show of support. Great.

2:30:46 Yes, wonderful. And so we'll be announcing public outreach that will occur in each of the counties, looking out probably about a month from now. Happy to provide updates on any other items, but otherwise I thank you for your time today. It's very nice to see you all. Hey, wonderful. Mr. Chair, I'm going to have to, I booked a meeting at 11 based on the ESCO schedule, so I have to go. Chris, I'm going to leave it to you if that's okay. See ya. Okay. Okay. Great to see you all. Have fun. Let's see you too. Okay.

2:31:20 Elaine, just on comment on that, from the Inyo County LTC meeting the other day, I did ask about what Inyo County Public Works was planning for Buttermilk Road, and they are going to assess the damage next week, and then they'd be able to have a better plan on what to do. And I have been invited into that discussion.

2:31:49 With Inyo County, so I, which is wonderful, because I will appreciate sort of timely updates to make sure that the manufacturers, that we can coordinate delivery of the toilet. Thank you. Or expect it anytime soon. The destruction of that road may be a good thing in the long run in that it finally will convince all of the park people involved to develop an appropriate maintenance plan. Your staff should talk to the park people, to the forest people. The forest people, they are, there has been,

2:32:19 There's been a lot of this. But this, I believe, is the impetus to create more of this. It is. It's just bringing us together. Yes. It's my understanding. Everyone's really excited about this toilet infrastructure in a way that I couldn't have anticipated. We're all going to rally for the cause and figure out how to get it out there. Or it's bringing people together. Bad joke. Bad joke. I like that one.

2:32:48 Okay, item number six, board member and agency reports, and by my math, if we stick to four minutes, well now five minutes because Wentworth's gone, then we can get out of here on time. So. Very quickly, the only thing I'd have to say is that June Mountain closed on the 9th, but is open tomorrow and Sunday in a bonus weekend. Two days only. June Mountain, part of the mountain will be open. Okay, today's the last day to get your pass, right? That was yesterday. That was yesterday.

2:33:17 We have new medians in Bishop along our main street and everyone's a little concerned about what's going to happen with mule days and where the mules are going to go but I think they'll be fine.

2:33:45 I can actually speak to that. Oh, okay. I'm the parade chairman for Mule Day. Oh, okay. What's going to happen? They're going to go around them. Oh, okay. All right. Oh, wow. So agile. We did have discussions about that in depth, and it was decided once they were finally in that the two lanes are more than sufficient.

2:34:12 And that will be included in each participant's letter so that they're aware. Be able to see them? Yes. Okay, well good. That is sorted. We have Earth Day in the park tomorrow. Bob's coming down. There'll be food, music, fun. It's supposed to be beautiful in the 80s. And that's it for my report.

2:34:37 No big reports. I believe we are getting, we are not going to have a lapse in EMS service. That's a big win. Well, it's been an exciting winter here in the town of Mammoth Lakes, as you all know, and you know, I'm just really grateful to our town staff for all of their efforts to sort of keep us going.

2:35:04 We had FEMA up here, I believe, last week, and we're trying to figure out whether we get the major disaster declaration because that will provide additional funds to put our town back together. And just, you know, to remind people in Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County to fill out your damage assessments because we need that information in order to...

2:35:26 And so stay tuned. We're working hard.

2:35:56 Thanks. I think our main focus right now is runoff and being prepared because it's coming. Yep. Okay. So I'll be quick. And for the runoff, you know, we had some pretty severe damage that we've already talked about. Chalk Bluff Road is also severely damaged and it doesn't look like that's going to be accessible for quite some time. A statistic that I heard that the runoff is going to be a million acre feet, which is equivalent to

2:36:30 Four Lake Crowley's. Five Lake Crowley's. Six Lake Crowley's. Five Lake Crowley's. A lot of water coming down. And even if things go perfectly, we know that at least in Inyo County, we're going to have some severe damage that happens. So trying to coordinate with Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and who we need to. Oh, yeah. And so there's a lot of constituents are asking what

2:36:59 What they need to do to prepare. And so we are having a community meeting. When is it? Thursday, the 27th, 5 p.m., Home Ec Building at the Fairgrounds. And, you know, part of that discussion is every egress and entry to Inyo County, at least, is probably Mono County, too, is at risk of being closed, perhaps, for a significant period of time.

2:37:33 So preparing food, medicine, pet food, that type of thing. Mono City, I already experienced it. But yeah, we need to get that message out and figure out exactly what that is and prepare. Would it be possible for that meeting to be on Zoom? Because I think, oh, fantastic, thanks. Okay. The flip side of that is we had our meeting in Death Valley.

2:38:07 This week. And the flowers are incredible. So if y'all are tired of the snow. Nice. It's lovely. It's warm. It's dry. So a snow issue that I want to bring up to the Mammoth folks is Glass Mountain Apartments, which is the Amaka-run affordable housing complex up here. It's already had two units that are red-tagged. They were able to place one family into a vacant unit.

2:38:37 There's no other vacant units, so another family's in a hotel. If y'all could coordinate with AMACA for when and if damage, just in that entire process. Writing myself a note. I don't know if funding is going to be available, but I think it's going to be hundreds of thousands of dollars to fix the roof trusses that are broken. They're worried that there may be more. Yeah.

2:39:08 Thank you. Absolutely, which is why we're trying to make sure we can get as much funding as possible. And then also the town of Mammoth Lakes did a $100,000 grant for supporting families who have been displaced. And that's being administered through Mammoth Lakes Housing. So the first stop for anybody in need should be to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Rob, did I get that right? Okay, thanks. Yeah, I think they spent $75,000 on snow removal at Glass Mountain.

2:39:35 Definitely interesting. Two new employees that we have at Inyo County is we have the new Scott, new IT Director, which is Noam Shandar, and Water Director, which is familiar to all of us, is Holly Alpert.

2:39:52 Just reiterate what Stephen said earlier that it looks like we will not have a lapse in EMS coverage and thankful for the collaboration between City of Bishop and Health and Human Services and administration at Inyo County and Isoma at making that happen and Inyo County continues to work on housing efforts including partnering with City of Bishop and

2:40:18 on the Silver Peaks Project, where we're looking at reviving the veterans housing component of that, and it's pretty exciting. That's all I have at the top of my brain. Any other last words? Okay, we are adjourned, and we'll see you all next time.