TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2023

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

311 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you.

0:36 Testing, testing. My mic is not on. I'm Bob Gardner, and I'm on the Mono County Board of Supervisors, and it's great to be here to be a part of ESCOG, and I haven't been here for a long time, so let's get on with it. Okay, great. Chris. I'm Chris Bubzer, new member of Mammoth Town Council, and I'm delighted to be here with all of you.

7:25 Karen Schwartz, City of Bishop. John Wentworth, Town of Mammoth Lakes. Steven Mohove, City of Bishop. I'm a nerd. Good. I'm Linda Salcido. I'm a member of the, a new member of the Mawag County Board of Supervisors, and I know this room well because I just finished four years being on Town Council, and it's really good to see you. Hi, I'm Trina Oral. I am a member of the Inyo County Board of Supervisors, and I am excited to be joining this incredible

7:57 Okay, so now Jeff, where's Jeff? I'm here. I don't know why they won't let you see my beautiful face. I am joining remotely from our nation's capital. Thanks, Jeff. Thanks for figuring out how to plug all those things in. Okay, so then now we will, we have a request.

8:29 from Supervisor Griffiths to enable his remote participation in this February 10th meeting of the ESCOG pursuant to AB2449. I believe that staff has the proper language that we should bring into the record here. Let's start that again. So we are here today for our first AB2449 request from a board member.

9:09 AB 2449 is our replacement for AB 361, which is going to go away effective February 28th when the governor lifts the COVID-related state of emergency. However, your board has not been adopting AB 361 resolutions for, I would say, a couple meetings now, so we're currently operating under 2449, which is the new remote participation method.

9:36 And while more limited than AB 361, AB 2449 does permit remote participation by a board member if that board member has just cause or an emergency circumstance for appearing remotely. As outlined in the staff report, Supervisor Griffiths is currently in Washington, D.C., traveling for the 2023 National Association of Counties Legislative Conference, and he's doing that on behalf of Inyo County.

10:03 So that falls within the just cause exception for appearing remotely, which includes travel while on official business of a legislative body. So staff would request that your board consider this request by Supervisor Griffiths to appear remotely and vote to approve it so that Supervisor Griffiths can participate in today's meeting. That sounds kind of like a motion. Does anybody want to take that as a motion? Thank you. Is there a second? Thank you. The 18.

10:33 Any additional discussion? Not hearing any. Jamie, please. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Chair, why does it say Chair Griffiths on the agenda? Is that correct? We'll get to that later. Okay. Chair Griffiths? Can or cannot vote on this? I don't know that I can vote yet. It's actually unclear whether a supervisor can vote on his or her own request. I would recommend not voting. Okay. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo?

11:04 Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Councilmember Muhovey? Yes. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Great, thank you. Jeff, welcome to the club. We will now move on to the Pledge of Allegiance, and Dan Holler, if you could please lead us in the pledge. Okay, any public comments? I don't see any here in Sweet Z, Jamie, any in the Zoomosphere? No. Yes.

11:52 We do have a member of the public who wishes to make a public comment. They've been corresponding with me a little bit that they're having some issues hearing the meeting. Can you hear them? Fabulous question. Give me a moment and I'll see if they're able to unmute. Carolyn Plummer is in the attendees list. If you could please promote her. Carolyn, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

12:31 I believe I have successfully unmuted. Can you hear me? This is Carolyn Plummer. Very well done, Carolyn. Thank you. All right. Great. Good morning. I am Carolyn Plummer with Caltrans headquarters in Sacramento, and I'm here to briefly share information about a pilot test that Caltrans is starting next month in March. We are studying a potential replacement for the gas tax, potential mileage tax, and have

13:00 test of GPS technology that we are looking to understand if it can differentiate between a public road and a private road. So we're seeking drivers from rural communities where there is that situation in day-to-day life of quite a bit of roads that may be on private land. So,

13:27 I have a few slides about the challenge with the gas tax and why we are studying potential mileage tax. And then I have a couple of slides on the pilot. And thank you very much for this opportunity to hear a little bit about this. So Caltrans receives the majority of funding for transportation, road maintenance from the gas tax. And there are challenges now with this tax simply because

13:56 Vehicles are more fuel efficient, so they need to purchase less gas, which means less tax coming in to the state. Additionally, zero emission vehicles, which are like electric vehicles or plug-in hybrids, are anticipated to increase greatly in the next 10 years. There's regulations that have been passed recently where manufacturers will be required to put a lot more of these types of vehicles on the lots for sale.

14:25 to Californians. We, as everybody must know, the federal gas tax is not changed for many years, so our money we receive in federal funding side could reduce in the future as well. Right now, the Highway Trust Fund doesn't get enough from gas tax to give out to all the states their obligations, so Congress backfills with regular federal taxes, and so we're made whole.

14:55 But that could change in the future. And then for California, SB1 did allow us to adjust our tax per gallon for inflation. But this is kind of changing as well, kind of the tax burden that a person would pay because it depends on what type of vehicle you drive. So this next slide will show that I had a sample of these vehicles are driving the same amount of miles per month.

15:25 But they're not paying into the state the same burden, the same amount of taxes to pay for transportation. This is definitely something that we're all aware of, but it's not necessarily something that we're paying attention to simply because we have to buy gas and it is there in the cost of what we pay for getting our cars to drive down the road. You'll see on this slide that the electric car obviously does not.

15:55 By gas, but there is an annual registration fee of about $100. So they are contributing a bit to transportation funding. So on the next slide, a road charge is a concept of taxing per mile, as opposed to taxing per gallon. And the idea would be to have one rate for all kind of passenger cars so that it evens out that tax burden. The state's not looking to really increase taxes per se.

16:25 Just to stabilize the funding for when gas is purchased less and less and less in the future. So the next slide shows kind of the concept that it would be an even tax burden across all vehicles no matter what you choose to drive and how many gallons of fuel efficiency it gets. So that kind of sums up

16:53 Perhaps why the state has, the legislature has directed Caltrans to look into something other than the gas tax. Caltrans has done two pilots already, one in 2017 and one in 2021. This is our third pilot and it's getting a little bit more into the understanding if current technology can even help us understand when a vehicle's traveling down the road on a private road or a public road.

17:21 with the intent to not charge someone a mileage tax if they're driving on their own property. So this is an opportunity as well, we feel, to hear from rural communities and tribal communities as well. We're outreaching to what it's like to have a device in your car and what your feedback is. Any feedback is perfect for research.

17:47 We don't know what we don't know, and we don't know what you feel about it or drivers feel about it actually living your day-to-day lives without inviting you guys to participate and test the concept. So the pilot itself is simple. It is just a device that plugs into the dash of the vehicle. Nothing else is needed from the driver other than to drive seven months of time and then take two surveys.

18:16 So, yes, please, that last slide does talk about the fact that we will even compensate someone for participating up to $250. The way to sign up is on our website, caroadcharge.com on the Contact Us page. And our program manager has been speaking to, I believe, Mono County Transportation Representatives last month and was recently at Inyo County's Board of Supervisors meeting.

18:45 Perhaps this is familiar to you, but we did want to reach to as many places that we could and encourage to help us recruit or sign up yourself, or even Lauren is willing to meet with some community groups that you may want to invite her to. Definitely, definitely appreciate your time to hear this quick, brief information. I don't know if I'm given the opportunity to answer questions, but of course, I will be happy to do that.

19:15 Carolyn, thank you very much. You did sneak in here through public comments, so we presented quite beautifully. Thank you very much. And we'll ask staff to get this information shared out with members of people in the follow-up, and we can follow up as we will. Maybe someone wants to have a little device in their car for $250 for seven months. Thank you very much, Carolyn. Thanks for thinking of us, reaching out, and best of luck to you. Great. Thank you very much. Okay. Thank you.

19:42 Okay, so we're going to move on now to our consent agenda. I'm going to read out the items. We will consider approving the minutes of the regular meeting of October 14, 2022, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 9, 2022, approve the 2023 ESCOG meeting calendar, and file the fiscal year 21-22 financial report. Anybody want to pull anything? Questions? Everybody's happy?

20:09 With that being said, I would entertain a motion. I'll move to approve. Thank you. Any thoughts from staff? You guys okay? Okay. Thank you. We have a motion? Second. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Jamie, please. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Supervisor Muhalvey? Yes.

20:39 Council Member Bubzer. I'll abstain. Excellent. Thank you all. So we'll move on to our first policy matter. This is item 5.1, approved staffing contract with Inyo County for Executive Director of Regional Coordination Position. And Elaine, who will speak to this item? I'll provide just a very brief background on this item. Okay. Then I'll turn it over to Mr. Haller and Mr. Greenberg. And this is true.

21:10 Perhaps want to introduce that we will be taking the agenda out of order. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. Yeah, let me, let me, I'll advise that. So for those in the public following along, there was a request from Inyo County, I think from the town of Mammoth Lakes, to shuffle, reshuffle the items in the agenda a little bit. I believe the ESCOG board is aware of this, but we will be taking things out of order. I'm not sure what the previous number was for this item, but I'll repeat the name of it just so it's clear. This is consideration of approving the staffing contract with Inyo County.

21:42 for Executive Director, Regional Coordination Position. And Elaine, please. Thank you. So for the last several months, for maybe about six months, there was direction from the ESCOG board to identify a path to create a full-time employee to staff the ESCOG currently. I serve as the staff, the Executive Director staff for the ESCOG under an independent contract.

22:12 And the goal was to bring staff within one of the member agencies so that there's full-time dedicated staff that also provided benefits. So with that, I will turn it over to Mr. Holler and Mr. Greenberg to discuss how that and the path forward on this. Thank you. This is County Manager Dan Holler. I was going to give a little overview. We got here, then Nate was going to walk through the proposal with...

22:41 Mono County, or with Inyo County for housing and providing the structure for the position. As Elaine noted several months ago, we've been looking how do we fully staff up the Executive Director position. Within the ESCOG, we had also looked at some future admin help, et cetera, all kind of driven by grant work and other elements and expectations of the ESCOG operating side and needing staffing to do that.

23:10 At this juncture, what we're looking at is a recommendation that transition Elaine into an employee of Inyo County and a full-time executive director. The proposed cost structure, Nate will walk through that, but it meets kind of the high-end level. We looked at the budget. It does not allow funding at this point for some admin help, and so the managers have had some additional discussions looking at a request going into the next year's budget.

23:37 The idea there would be to increase each agency's contribution by maybe $2,500. Then we have a reduction in some of the services Town of Mammoth Lakes provides. But we should put about $15,000 back into the budget. So if we do need some part-time admin help, we'd have some budget to do that. It also provides a little cushion in the budget accordingly. And so that would be a future item and a request as we look into the budget year.

24:03 I think the idea of having the full-time Executive Director on board, given the workload we have going forward, is a high priority and has been for the organization, so this would allow us to move forward. I'll have Nate, if he wants to walk through that, the structure of it and the funding request, then as we get into the contract, we'll need a number filled into that contract as we make the approval today. And this was previously item 5.2 on the agenda. Thank you.

24:32 Great. Thank you, Dan. Mae Greenberg, Inyo County Administrative Officer. And yeah, as Elaine and Dan articulated well, you know, this has been a conversation that has evolved over the last several months. It's taken us a little while to get to this point. But through a number of conversations internally with my team here at Inyo, as well as between the other three agency managers, we felt like this was

25:00 sort of the best approach and best place to land. We recognize at Inyo County that there are a little, I guess there are a few sort of complications or moving parts with this, namely that Inyo is not the fiscal agent and there will need to be some moving of money between the fiscal agent and Inyo to cover some of the billing and internal charges associated with this position being housed in Inyo, but based on a number of different

25:30 conversations and considerations, we felt like this was probably the most efficient and logical way to sort of structure things. Given that, the team here sort of has talked to Elaine and looked at sort of the comparables with regard to this position within the overall organizational structure and made some recommendations to Elaine and ultimately are bringing that back to the ESCOG board today.

25:57 Within our salary structure, what we've proposed is to bring her into what is a range 80 in the Inyo County structure. That comes in at a total cost of about $129,000 that is consisting of $95,000 worth of salary, $25,000 worth of benefits, taxes, and then administrative and overhead charges on top of that.

26:25 The total cost that we have sketched out is $148,743.59. And so what is before you today, this morning, is essentially a contract that would be between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and Inyo County that would basically

26:50 provide the services of the Executive Director back to the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. And I've got Grace in the room up there as well, who is certainly far more aware of and comfortable with this agreement if there are specific questions around that. If there are more general questions around sort of the structure or the employment on the Inyo County side, I'm happy to try to address those to the ESCOG Board.

27:19 Excellent. Thank you very much. So, ESCOG members, any questions for Nate, Dan, legal counsel? We previously were in a contract with Eastern Sierra Planning, but now is it just, is Eastern Sierra Planning no longer, or is it Eastern, yeah. So ESCOG is currently under contract with Eastern Sierra Planning to provide Executive Director services. That would sunset once,

27:50 The ESCOG Board is under contract with Inyo County for this Executive Director. And you're an employee then of Inyo County? Yes. Good. If I may, actually, one element that I did leave out of here was sort of a timing on this transition, and so just sort of sequence of events quickly would be if your board approves this today, it will be coming back to the Inyo County Board of Supervisors officially as part of our mid-year budget on the 21st of February.

28:19 And then the intent would be to transition Elaine into the position on the 2nd of March. Okay, and there is, we do have another item on the agenda that addresses sort of the bridge of the sequencing. Okay, I don't see any other questions. Is there any public comment on this? I'm not hearing any, so. So real quick, on page 49, the 148,000 is that would be.

28:44 In place of the XXXX. Yeah. I was going to recommend if you put it not to exceed of 150 in case there's some other increases or other elements we're not aware of as we get into the future year. Again, we're looking at current numbers. I'm not sure if they have some, I'll say, any type of negotiated changes or state-imposed type changes, a couple of the dollars may be helpful, but if we could round that to 150,000 as a not-to-exceed amount, that would be

29:15 It's viable within ESCOG, and I think it provides a little bit of a cushion there, not much. And I'll have to defer to Nate to make sure that's okay, too, with having a round number. I think that's smart, yes. I would give a staff recommendation to fill that in, as if not to exceed 150,000. Okay, good, thank you. Yes, another question. Nate, this question's primarily for you. Good morning. So, Elaine becomes an Inyo County employee.

29:43 With all the benefits of an employee and you're placing her somewhere on your sort of employee matrix, would that be accurate? Yeah, that's correct. So structurally within the county, Elaine will be part of the administration department. She'll be working in concert with the assistant CAO and myself. Her day-to-day workload is being directed based on the work plan of the ESCOG.

30:13 Okay, so she's not at will within Inyo County? She would be at will within Inyo County, but it is still within our matrix as a whole. Okay, okay, and her complete job description then will be just ESCOG related? That's correct. Okay, thank you very much. And one comment that I have on this, the Executive Director of Services, this job description, I mean, I know Elaine is super...

30:45 Capable, but this seems kind of ridiculous to expect of one person. Just saying. Elaine, any thoughts on that? You know, I definitely understand that this seems like a very tremendous scope of work. Largely, it describes the work that's being done now in working on staffing.

31:17 the SURF, doing outreach for that, programs and grants that we're administering under the Sustainable Recreation Ego System Management Program. And at this point, I have been managing these projects on a part-time basis while also serving at the City of Bishop and managing a number of long-term projects there as well. So I think in the near term,

31:42 The intent of this agreement is to build capacity for the ESCOG to accomplish these things. A couple of outliers are that we will be having to, because the financing mechanism for this full-time agreement is largely through grant revenues,

32:01 There will have to be at some point an increase in looking for and applying for grants successfully to make this sustainable. So there's something that the board needs to be aware of. The financial model I put together puts that out in about three years. We have a funding runway through the grants we have now in about three years. So in about three years, we'll definitely need to put a year and a half given the grant cycles.

32:29 putting emphasis on identifying additional funding sources. Of course, that is one of the missions and visions of the ESCOG is bringing those resources into the Eastern Sierra. And then the other thing, and this will play into some of the items later in the agenda, is that the board will have to be careful and considerate in additional project work as it relates to the capacity we have. But for where the ESCOG is now, I'm comfortable with this job description. Thank you.

32:59 All right. Well, absent any other questions or further discussion, I would certainly entertain a motion for this item. So moved. Second. Thank you. And just to be clear, Bob, the motion would be the board authorized the chair to execute the agreement regarding executive director services to be provided by the Inyo County to the Eastern Sierra Council Governments Joint Powers Authority. Right. And with the change that town manager Haller suggested and

33:29 and CAO Greenberg to, up to, not to exceed $150,000. Got it, okay, thank you. So we have a motion, a second, and no additional discussion, so Jamie. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Councilmember Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Supervisor Muhove? Yes. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes.

34:02 Good. Thank you all very much. Dan, Nate, thank you both very, very much. And Elaine, I know this has been a somewhat arduous process, but thank you for your patience and your persistence. And we very much appreciate that. We're very happy to have Elaine on track to have a full-time legitimate job with benefits. So congratulations. So thank you. We'll now move on to the next item where we will appoint

34:28 ESCOG members, the Mono Inyo Working Air Group. That's the right name for the right acronym. And this is, I'll just say the name of the item again in case folks are trying to figure out where we are on the previous published agenda. Appointing ESCOG members to the Mono Inyo Working Air Group. So, Elaine. Thank you very much, Chair Wentworth. I'm going to go ahead and allow Town Manager Holler and Mr. Greenberg to handle this item. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you.

35:01 Dan, Nate, who wants to go? I'll dive into it and then Nate can dive into that as well then. Town manager Dan Holler, this was previously item 5.5 on the agenda. It was published that we've moved it up accordingly to accommodate our schedules here. The request here is really looking back. ESCOG established what we refer to as the MIWAG, Inyo Inyo Working Air Group. Acronyms are our life, I think.

35:30 The group was set up as a subcommittee to really have a form of the four agencies to talk about air service. A lot of this came up as we began to look at the transition of commercial air service from the Mammoth Airport to the Inyo County Airport at Bishop, BIH. And so that process went through. We did a lot of work with that, a lot of work with the FAA. As that began to settle out, the committee basically stopped meeting. Not really in need at that point. It was at the...

35:59 Staff levels, FAA level, and then working with other partners in terms of the funding and structures that way. As we look to the future, a lot of discussions again coming up in terms of the regional air service, what does that look like, the funding structures for it in terms of subsidy, ongoing charter level service at the Mammoth Airport. And as we begin to look at that, okay, all of a sudden we're having the discussion about needing to really be able to set the table again with the various

36:29 Public bodies, the four entities, Bishop, Mono, Inyo, and Town of Mammoth Lakes. And so this seemed to be a good forum to be able to do that. And as that group can come together, then we can invite in the other partners, whether it's other funding agencies, the other tourism base, other business agencies, et cetera, to be providing input in how do we begin to look at some policy questions that's come up in terms of looking forward with air service.

36:59 But the item before today is really, one, do you see this as a form to be able to have those discussions and have the four public agencies and formalized, you know, meetings that can be able to come together in these discussions and then invite in the other partners? It seems to make a lot of sense from the staff point to be able to have this group back in a position, if you will, to do that. And then we would go forward, reach back out, look at some meetings into the future and those types of things. So kind of two questions. One is,

37:29 Do you agree this is the right forum? If so, then what we're requesting is that we have one member from ESCOG from each agency be appointed to serve on the working group as we begin to look at air service into the future. So not a discussion on air service today, but really looking at is this the right forum? And we think it works from a staff perspective, but we definitely wanted to bring it forward for discussion here. And I'll turn to Nate if you want to add to that, Nate.

37:57 Please dive in. I think you framed it really well. I mean, I will just add that I know that the ESCOG as well as I think each of the member agencies is eager to have a discussion, a further discussion and a deeper level of conversation with regard to air service and airports. And that is something that staff is actively working to develop and certainly is happy to engage in in the future. But I think Dan laid out the purpose of this item.

38:26 Very clearly, which is to establish some governance where formal conversations can happen around the facets of air service and the subsidy and minimum revenue guarantee and other things like that. Excellent. Thank you. Any questions for any of the presenters? No? Yes? I'm just curious about can it only be one member per jurisdiction or is it possible that we could have multiple if there are more of us who are interested?

38:59 I think the two elements to that one is, yeah, you can have more of them. The goal has been trying to keep it to one each for representation and also just for the sake of organizing meetings. They get more complicated as we add more people to them. The other side to that is a formal subcommittee. It'd be a standing committee. We'd structure it that way to where anybody can attend. You wouldn't be participating necessarily as a committee member, but you can definitely be in the room and in the dialogue. Anybody can do that.

39:27 For these meetings. Like this meeting here, any other board member, council member could show up and sit and listen and make even a public comment. So allow that. If we start to put too many more on, then we may well just make it a committee of the whole and just have ESCOG do it, which again gets a little more cumbersome just in terms of managing meetings and meeting quorums. And as we come back to ESCOG, generally we need a positive vote from each group, from each agency to move stuff forward.

39:56 Tends to balance it out in terms of the operating side of that. So the recommendation would still be the one, but definitely if somebody wants to attend and listen and be informed, if you will, or part of that discussion, more than welcome to join the meetings and we can make sure everybody's aware of them. That'd be the recommendation versus otherwise you may as well just do it as a committee. That's a good question. I think for all of us, I mean, these are issues of such import for the region that

40:25 Okay, there's one designated person, but people are listening, people are participating as they can. I think maybe if there are people from, they're designated, they can't make the meeting, maybe the other person could serve as an alternate. Would that be possible? Defer to Grace, but my assumption would be you could appoint an alternate. You could have each agent have their other member be the alternate would be my assumption. Okay.

41:00 That will not happen. Okay. All right, good.

41:30 Any additional questions? Yeah, Chris. So the alternate would be a voting member when they're replacing the appointed member? True. Okay. Fair enough. Thank you. Good. Okay. Any additional questions? I think we're good. Any public comment on this? Not hearing or seeing any. So, okay, let's go around the room. Who's going to be who from who? Chris, I think you and I have talked about it. If it's okay, if I go ahead, I'll be the appointee.

42:08 And you and I will be in cahoots, as it were. And then let's move over to, yes, Lillow County. I would suggest that Supervisor Gardner, you know, be the primary person, and I would be happy to fill in when he's not able. A city bishop is negotiating right here. You want to rush Mammoth? I don't care. I'd be happy to do it, but if you have, you know.

42:34 Okay, so Inyo County, in a virtual analog discussion. Actually, we have previously discussed this, and as long as Supervisor Griffiths still agrees, I will take on the role. Oh, good. And he will be our alternate. Excellent, thank you. So, we have from Mono County, it will be Supervisor Gardner.

43:02 Town of Mammoth Lakes would be myself, City of Bishop, with Karen, and from Inyo County. Okay, so... Can we frame that up as a formal motion with the appointees? Yes. And then noting who the alternates are from each agency as well in a formal motion? Yes. So I will make a motion that the ESCOG appoint the following representatives of each agency to serve as representative to the MiWOG. From Mammoth County, Supervisor Gardner, Town of Mammoth Lakes, John Wentworth, City of Bishop, Karen Schwartz.

43:31 And inyo County, Trina, what's your last name? Oral. Oral, I'm sorry, Trina Oral. And that would be the motion. Would you like to second? I will second. Thank you very much. We have a motion and a second, so unless there's any further discussion, Jamie, please. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes, ma'am. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Supervisor Muhal?

44:00 Mwhove? I'm going to get it right eventually, I promise. Council Member. He's a Council Member. Council Member Mwhove. Oh, sorry, Council Member Mwhove. Don't promote him yet. I'm going to get it right eventually. Council Member Bubzer. Yes. Thank you. Thank you all very much. Again, Dan and Nate, thank you all very much for that. The formal appointment of the alternates. I think that just makes it very clear of the rule. Okay, so in addition to that motion, I would move that the alternates for the Mwag be.

44:29 From Mono County, Linda Salcedo, County of Mammoth Lakes, Chris Bubzer, from the City of Bishop, Stephen Mohove, Council Member Stephen Mohove, and from Inyo County, Supervisor Jeff Griffiths. Can I get a second? I'll second. Thank you. Any additional discussion? Not hearing any. Jamie, please. Thank you. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo? Yes. Supervisor Oral?

44:59 Yes. Council Member Muhove. Yes. Council Member Bubzer. Yes. Excellent. Thank you all very much. We're getting there. Okay. Thank you. And again, Nate, Dan, thank you very much for taking this on and really giving this the seriousness and the weight that it deserves. We've got a lot of really important discussions to have as a region, and so we're looking forward to it. Thank you all very much. All right. Moving on now to the revised agenda, item 5.3.

45:28 We will now consider approving the California Advanced Services Fund grant disbursement schedule and consent forms and approve agreement between Inyo County and the ESCOG JPA as the board of the Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium regarding the processing of reimbursement requests under the CASF grant. Sounds like a Nate Greenberg kind of a thing. But Elaine, please go ahead.

45:51 I am happy to take the lead on it, and I will lean on Scott Armstrong from my team as well as Grace Kukla for some of the legal matters if there are questions there. But I will happily just sort of frame this up. And as your board hopefully remembers and is aware, last year we put in for a new three-year grant to the California Public Utilities Commission.

46:21 to reboot, if you will, the Inyamono Broadband Consortium. Some of you may recall the Inyamono Broadband Consortium was a product or a project under the ESCOG a number of years ago. It has been dormant effectively for the last several years. However, with the recent legislation and investment in broadband statewide and really nationwide, primarily through pieces of legislation like SB 156,

46:49 There's a tremendous amount of money coming into the Eastern Sierra. And the purpose of the Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium and the CPUC Consortium grants is to basically establish capacity and structure to help counties and local agencies apply for and access that money and ultimately construct broadband projects within the regions.

47:18 Given our history in this space as a region with Digital 385 and just some of the opportunities that are in front of us, it was the joint thought of myself when I was sitting in the CIO role up at Mono County, Scott Armstrong, who is the IS Director in Inyo County, at the time, CIO down here at Inyo County, Leslie Chapman, to basically look at a way to

47:48 Reposition Inyo and Mono Counties and, you know, as a inclusive extension, the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the City of Bishop to have staffing and capacity to be able to bring projects forward and sort of have some consistency regionally as that makes sense. So there are a couple of things happening here that I'll just discuss briefly. I mean, one is

48:11 Formally, the acceptance of this grant award, which is a total of $600,000 over a three-year period or $200,000 per year. And the intent is to leverage that money to create a new position within Inyo County that will serve as the regional broadband coordinator in support of the Inyo and Mammoth Broadband Consortium under the ESCOG. The intent is also to transition Scott Armstrong, our

48:40 current IS Director into that new role of the regional broadband coordinator. And in that new role, Scott would be assisting Mono Inyo counties, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and the City of Bishop in looking at implementing broadband strategies in the form of future broadband projects, taking advantage of monies coming through programs like the local area technical assistance grants, as well as money for last mile broadband construction.

49:10 in all of our jurisdictions. And so this item is the ESCOG basically formally accepting these grants and then endorsing or otherwise supporting this transition and move to basically establish the regional broadband coordinator position and carry that effort forward. So happy to answer questions if there are any. And again, Grace and Scott can back that up if either of you have anything to add or to correct.

49:40 Thank you very much, Nate. Elaine, Grace, anything you guys want to add? So one thing that I think I will chime in to explain, your board will notice that at the end of this staff report, I believe is attachment D, there is an agreement between Inyo County and the ESCOG regarding submitting reimbursement requests. And I just wanted to sort of briefly explain why this is here and why we all felt this was necessary. So the...

50:13 IMBC, from a legal perspective, is a bit of an odd duck in that it's not really legally a thing, right? I can't say it's a JPA, it's a council, it doesn't have a name that we can give it to sort of ascribe it a legal entity. And this is why the IMBC has a fiscal agent.

50:37 This is why- Grace, IMBC stands for Inyo Mono. Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium. Just checking. Yes. And so this is why there was a fiscal agent for the IMBC in Inyo County, why your board is the board of the IMBC. Essentially, the IMBC needs all of these other entities to come in and do the legal tasks that a formal legal entity would otherwise be able to do. And now your board, as the board of the IMBC, is-

51:09 Responsible and in control of the grant. You know, theoretically, if something goes awry with the grant and the money is spent wrong or something like that, you know, it would be the ESCO board that has to answer for that. However, from the way the IMBC grant and fiscal agent is set up and from the way that Mr. Armstrong's employment is set up as an employee of Inyo County, you know,

51:35 Scott is an employee of Inyo County, so Inyo County tells Scott what to do on a day-to-day basis. And additionally, the fiscal agent of the IMBC is Inyo County. So under all of the forms that Inyo County submits to be reimbursed for the salary that it pays Scott for the work that Inyo County directs Scott to do, those forms are signed off on only by the fiscal agent of Inyo County.

52:00 So from the way, if you followed that very long chain I just pieced together, the moral of it is that essentially, simply sort of because of the way the forms are set up, Inyo County would theoretically be purely in control of the funds and how they're spent and what's got done. And that's not sort of what we want to do. The IMDC is an incredibly important group. You as the ESCOG board are, you know, an incredibly important sort of...

52:30 think tank and body that we want to be directing and advising Scott's work and how the grant funds are spent. And ultimately, as I mentioned earlier, if Inyo County were to go rogue and decide to spend all these IMBC funds on something not permitted under the grant, the irony of it is that while Inyo could sign off on that, the ESCOG board would be the one to answer for that.

52:57 So in order to just create a more sort of formal oversight and reporting structure, I guess, so to speak, between Inyo County and ESCOG, we created this agreement, whereby Inyo County will run all reimbursement requests by ESCOG, and I should say by Elaine as the Executive Director of ESCOG, because the reimbursement requests will need to be submitted more frequently than your board needs.

53:23 So we couldn't allow that to be a holdup in Inyo County being reimbursed. But what this agreement essentially does is sort of formalize what we think will practically happen, right? You know, Inyo County's not going to go rogue. Inyo County and Scott are going to talk to your board and Lane before they spend any money and before they decide what projects to embark on. But really just for ESCOG's protection and to ensure that everything is as transparent and public as possible, we're putting this agreement in place.

53:52 Thank you very much. Nice to have that pointed out. Any questions for Grace? So a point of clarification, this grant is effectively for Scott to do a bunch of the planning around broadband across the whole region. And that involves identifying where it's

54:19 needed and coming up with trying to identify partners who will do the actual work, but it's not actually involving any of the actual work of getting broadband implemented. Sorry, I'll invite Mr. Armstrong to speak to it in more detail, but yes, this grant is largely a staffing and a planning grant. And then...

54:44 It's my understanding from Mr. Armstrong that it works in conjunction with other grants that will focus a bit more on implementation. Please go ahead, Scott. Okay, thanks. For some clarification, I'm going to show you some slides that will, some pages that will help describe the types of activities that I'll be engaged in. So I'm going to share my screen here.

55:10 So we have, I think, five or six objectives in our grant, and essentially it's to map and document the priorities of the agency, which is ESCOG. Public engagement to make sure that we've got the right priorities for each area identified. Oops, too fast. So we've got the right priorities identified. Okay, I'm going backwards. Page 10, I'm supposed to be on page 10. Here we go. Yeah, even an IT guy can mess up in presentations. So public engagement.

55:42 Making sure we've got the right priorities set because we all know that everybody wants broadband now, but we can only do certain things at certain times with certain amounts of funding. So another objective is infrastructure projects. So coordinating with regional providers. We know that we have some. We know that we have some that we're not pleased with. We know that we have some that are getting better. Working with Digital 385, I'm closely engaged with them and also with the state.

56:09 And making sure we have good tools for the public and tracking legislative funding. That's something that in my current position, I just haven't had time to do. So my intent with this is to make sure that I'm kept abreast of all of the possible fundings that might be applicable for our areas and make sure that you know about them so that we can prioritize which ones we want to go after. Comprehensive project list. And we're starting off in Inyo County with a

56:38 an everything approach for our local agency technical assistance grant, and I hope to have the same for the entire region so that we can just keep track of every area. It just makes it easier when grants pop up that have a one-month period to apply for. And I'll be working on grant applications as well. So far, I'm batting 1,000. I put in one grant and got it awarded, so that's a good start. Agency coordination.

57:05 For broadband policies and costs, public assets. So we have those of us who are right on 395 for the properties on 395. Some of those are going through public plans. And an agency broadband strategy for our, excuse me, our Eastern Sierra region, which is quite a bit different than Southern California, the North Coast and such. And then

57:34 Data collection is something that the state has challenges with. And so we can work to get local speed tests to verify that what providers are claiming is actually accurate. And if they're not accurate, we'll have to find some way to solve that. And then we can also support the state and federal speed test data. And I hope to have something in the next couple of weeks to share with everybody so that we can make sure that we've got the right priorities. So if the speed tests

58:03 Say that we're getting 100 megabits both directions in a certain area, and we know darn well they're getting 20 megabits down and five megabits up, then we know that they don't hit the thresholds that we're looking for. We can verify that, change it, and get our priorities straight. So there's a lot going on, and looking at that list, that's going to keep me busy for several years, and I expect to make some measured progress, and when they talk about

58:33 getting funding from when we submit our funding request to the CPUC, they're going to approve or deny those based on whether they meet. So I won't be out buying a Tesla. It'll all be broadband work and all of our boards. One other question. In the objective two that they have for the rules of this grant, it talks about achieving the goal of reaching 98% broadband deployment.

59:01 Can you, do you know offhand what that actually means in terms of metrics and how we currently stand in the area? Looking at older data, I think, depending on which area, we had some at about 80% reaching the threshold that was in place and some over 90%, 95% or so. And that was, that metric, I think, at the time was

59:31 20 megabits per second or so, but the state's new metric is 100 megabits symmetrical, which means 100 megabits download and 100 megabits upload. And I think, I know that Inyo County is nowhere close to that, so we're probably below 50% at that point right now. Mono County's ahead. We had a provider who did a nice job connecting a lot of areas already, and I think Mammoth is due to

1:00:01 Have some additional broadband instruction put in. So what we'll do is we've got an Eastern Sierra or connected Eastern Sierra website. And so we'll keep that up to date with our metrics. We'll try to do our best to make sure that they're all valid. And I think it might actually be good to track those metrics over time too so we can see our progress. So I will mark that as an early task to get on.

1:00:29 Thanks. And the 98%, that's presumably to population, right? It's going to include all of our census block data. So if we have five people out in the middle of our region, that counts as our percentage, connected or not. So it's all of us. And that's what's good for us in the rural areas, is while we're not going to make a huge dent on the state's number of 98%, when we get to 98% in our county, we're going to be in really good shape.

1:01:01 in our region. Council Member Mohove, if I could just add to that, I think Scott articulated it well. I mean, the 98% has been a longstanding state objective. It's been out there really, I think, for the better part of a decade. And the initial intent behind establishing the broadband consortia and those programs, you know, the better part of a decade ago was really to try to leverage local knowledge and capacity to

1:01:29 move the needle, if you will, to reach those underserved and unserved communities, which Scott was referring to. And so I think he said it well, which is that if we're able to achieve 98% within our region, within our counties, we're going to actually be doing an incredibly good job. I believe the number in Mono County is in the low 90s, 93, 94%. I think Scott articulated it well for Inyo County.

1:01:54 So both have a ways to go, but the state has a fair ways longer to go in terms of actual numbers. And they continue to just use the 98% as a threshold, which they would like to see achieved on a statewide level. Good. I've got a couple quick, anybody got anything else? Just a couple things. Scott, some of us were involved in the IMBC way back in the day.

1:02:23 with scotch tape and colored Sharpies and that kind of stuff. So I'm glad you mentioned the website, the Eastern Sierra Connect website. I'm assuming that all the consortium stuff, even though it's been dormant for a while, all that's going to move forward and that will be available to you as you do your program. Is that fair to say? It is already, yes. Okay, good. Because that website, it's got a lot of potential and I think I really like the way you're saying to use that as a tool. I think for all of our agencies, it's an easy link to be able to say to

1:02:53 I was just going to add that even though I wasn't on the IMBC when I started here with Inyo, I was able to attend most of the meetings, so I was at least aware of what they were doing, saw the challenges that they had, and broadband has always been a big interest of mine.

1:03:22 I'm not jumping into this cold. Yeah, good. The other thing is, here in Mammoth, we have a grant that you may be aware of that has to do with sort of a feasibility analysis of our current sort of odd coax cable single provider situation. I'm wondering if that project, which you may or may not be aware of, would that fall under your portfolio to some degree, at least maybe get some technical advice or another set of eyes on it? I think so. Okay, that's good.

1:03:54 Okay, good. Those are my questions. Yeah, Chris. I might have missed it, but under the work plan, I didn't see grant writing to sort of take this past the three years. So is that contemplated somewhere in the process? It is. We have one of our activities is to develop project grant applications. So as we're moving forward, the federal funding account grants should become available in the next...

1:04:24 A few months, maybe a few weeks. And I'd be happy to be engaged with each entity that wants to partner with our organizations to get those grants off the ground. I expect that the CPC funding for Broadband Consortium will continue. Don't know for how long, but there could and should be future opportunities for us to

1:04:52 secure grant funding for additional projects, things that aren't within the federal funding account grant guidelines, things that are outside of the LATA grant guidelines. So that's part of what I'll be doing as well. Thank you. Okay, good. Any additional questions? Everybody's happy? Okay, so any public comment? Let's see any. Okay, well, I would entertain a motion. Jana has her hand raised. Go ahead. I'm sorry. Thank you.

1:05:21 I just want to, Janet Dutcher, Fiscal Agent for ESCOG, ESCOG Finance Director for Mono County, I just want to provide some additional information for your board and ESCOG staff. For all intents and purposes, ESCOG is the owner of this grant, and what that means is the grant revenues and expenditures should be included in the ESCOG budget, as well as our financial report.

1:05:49 And I will work with Nate and his team over there, probably Amy Shepard, who's the auditor controller in Inyo County, to make sure that I get transactional reports so that we can record these transactions on the ESCOG financial record, even though the cash doesn't flow through my hands or change hands within Inyo County. So just wanted to clarify and add that information. Excellent, Jan. Thanks very much for that. That's good to know.

1:06:17 Okay, with that, I'm going to, Elaine, are you happy that your hand didn't go up, did it? You're adjusting your glasses. Okay, great, thank you. So I'm just going to make the motions. It's a little bit weedy here. So I would move that the ESCOG Board accept the cast of grants, sign the Appendix B Consortium Grant forms, and authorize the chair to execute the agreement between Inyo County and the ESCOG JPA.

1:06:42 As the Board of the Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium regarding the processing of reimbursement requested under the California Advanced Services Fund Grant. Second, there's a motion and a second. Any additional discussion? Everybody good? So Jamie, please. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcido? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Council Member Muhove? Yes.

1:07:12 Council Member Bubzer. Yes. Good. Unanimously approved. Again, Nate Inyo County, everybody who's been involved in this effort for many, many years. It's great to see this thing living again. And, Scott, to see you driving this thing. I think it's going to be a very exciting development for all of us. So thank you. Thank you. All right. Thank you all. So we're going to move on now. And we're kind of getting sort of back to our original order of the agenda. And it's my pleasure to introduce Sandra Moberly and...

1:07:43 Who's going to be presenting today? So myself and Noel and Bob Ruff are going to be presenting. So thank you, ESCOG, for having us here. We're happy to come here and talk to you all about the Town's Housing Now housing program. Some of you in this room have seen this presentation before, so if you'd like to take a coffee break, we will not be offended. But just to start, I'm Sandra Moberly. I'm the Community and Economic Development Director here at the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:08:10 And we, Nolan and I kind of have been working on this housing program for a while, and we'd be out in the community, we'd hear people say, what is the town doing for housing? What are you doing? You're not doing anything. And so we kind of started this road show to go to different organizations, different service groups, to just really inform people about what we're doing here at the town of Mammoth Lakes, and really offering to give this information to other agencies or other groups as they need it. So you want to introduce yourself?

1:08:37 I'm Nolan Babara, the Town's Senior Planner and Housing Coordinator. I'm in charge of all the housing programs, both grant-funded and town-funded. That will jump right into the presentation. So this first slide is really just a framework or to frame the rest of the conversation when we're talking about housing programs, area median income, AMI. Area median income is the median income for a region.

1:09:02 Or median household income for a region. Our region is defined as Mono County as a whole. And so then that income is used based on percentages to dictate the income for eligibility for various programs. So our median income for a household of four is $81,200. On the screen here, it breaks out, it shows on the top your lower income brackets. Those are your affordable groups that are usually funded or supported by grant programs from the federal and state.

1:09:30 Such as CDBG, Home, Home Key. Then in the middle, you have your turquoise on the bridge. That's your moderate and upper middle income, middle income, missing middle are some terms you often hear. This area is unique because it's not supported by federal or state grants typically. They still need assistance both on ownership and rental to afford housing here in the area.

1:09:57 So that's where local programs, local funding can step in to help support incomes within those brackets. On the far right, you have your upper income. Generally, that's defined as kind of 150% on up. However, what we're seeing here is that even in those AMI brackets, they still need assistance both on ownership and rental based on at least pricing here in Mammoth.

1:10:21 So we'll just talk a little bit about the parcel affordable housing project, which is kind of the town's showcase project that we're working on. It's up to 450 units on a 25-acre piece of property. The town purchased the property in 2018, went through some conceptual land use planning and then entitlements, and started construction on that project about a year, a little bit over a year ago. And we expect to deliver phase one at the end of this year or in the fall of this year.

1:10:51 So phase one is 81 units, 80 units of affordable, one manager's unit. On the left-hand side of the screen, you see the entitlement plans. On the right-hand side of the screen, you see the project being put together. It's a modular project, so all of the modules are built in a factory up in Boise, and then they were all shipped here and then basically assembled on site. And the benefit of modular construction is it allows us to be doing site work.

1:11:17 And building what we ultimately kind of stack on the site at the same time. And those units arrive completely, you know, furnished, basically. They have their refrigerator, the sinks, cabinets, everything's in them already. All the water, electricity, all of that already works. So that's a really great way to do work in a community like ours, where basically six months of the year we can't, you know, work because of the snow. Phase two will be 148 units total.

1:11:45 You can see on the right-hand side, those are the entitlement, the design review plans that were approved. A little bit of a different look. We wanted to have kind of a different theme in each neighborhood in the parcel. And we were able to design the project to maintain kind of a large, passive open space at the center of the project, which will be really nice for the residents there. And the parcel itself, you can see...

1:12:09 We're bringing in a lot of funding for the parcel. Some of this is specifically for phase one. Some of it is for the project as a whole. But we're bringing in a little bit over or almost $78 million for this project. And if you think about how much money the town's put into it, we're leveraging local dollars one to five. So for every $1 of money the town puts in, we're bringing in $5 from outside sources. So really great opportunity to bring money in from outside.

1:12:35 And I think all these bullet points give you an idea of how complex affordable housing development really is. It takes, and each one of these is a huge lift, you know, applications, coordination with state agencies, coordination with other agencies, and even coordination with Mono County. Mono County came in and is bringing money into this project as well. So really a truly kind of partnership project, showing partnerships at the local level, partnerships at the state level.

1:13:01 A lot of people kind of coming together to make this project a reality. So stepping away from the parcel, some of the other projects the town has been focusing on within the housing world. We have what we're calling our small site development concept. This is a pilot project where we've gone on and designed a duplex structure, so two units, and then figuring out how to fit those on, one, the site that we've purchased, as well as future sites as they become available.

1:13:31 The first site we purchased, it's at 60 Joaquin Road, it's a .2 acre site. We've come up with a design to fit four units on that site, so two of those duplex structures. And these units are very livable. They're two car garages, two bedroom with an office, and two and a half bath units on the design. Currently in the design review phase or entitlement phase for this first project with construction hopefully beginning this spring once we get through the entitlement phase on that.

1:14:00 Project was made possible from a $2.4 million allocation from Town Council. The bid for this initial construction came in at $2.4 million, with site acquisition at $200,000. Our goal for these units is to then resell them to 150% AMI households. So that involves taking, you know, the construction costs, which is around $650,000, and the ultimate sales price will be, our goal is to keep it around $480,000.

1:14:30 So that subsidy comes out of that allocation from the town council to bring it down to the affordable level. The resale will have a deed restriction in place. That deed restriction requires that the units be sold to income-eligible households and that they live in it as their primary residence and work here in the region. And then that deed restriction will renew at every time they sell in the future. So the goal is to keep them basically deed restricted in perpetuity.

1:14:58 As we said, with that duplex model, it's replicable and scalable. So as we identify other sites, both small and large, the hope is that we could continue to build additional affordable units here in the community. This program is what we call a bridge program. The goal of this is to really unlock existing housing in the community that's already built, already occupied, and to make it affordable and occupied by the local workforce. So we're out there purchasing market rate units.

1:15:28 Then working in a partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, reducing the price to an affordable level, and reselling those units to income-eligible households. Target income for this group is 120%. Important to note, both on this program and the previous small site development, it's entirely funded with town general fund dollars. We don't have the same restrictions that the parcel...

1:15:51 This program was made possible by a $1.4 million allocation from Town Council.

1:16:21 Our goal is to secure and de-district 12 units from that allocation. With every kind of purchase and resale, that allocation shrinks some because of the subsidy going into making the units affordable. Our goal is to have the average subsidy be $150,000 kind of across the program. Right now, after six units acquired with four of those having been resold, our subsidy right now is $138,000.

1:16:49 We're right within our average that we want to be. Currently, we have also, for anyone who's listening, a two-bedroom currently for sale through Mammoth Lakes Housing, and we just closed, we're closing escrow today on a sixth unit that will then be available for resale as well, and that's a two-bedroom unit as well. So a couple other programs to highlight, our Revolving Loan Fund is in place to really support and maintain, keep our deed-restricted units deed-restricted.

1:17:19 In the past, we did not have funding available as a unit came up for sale to purchase that unit back to ensure it remains deed restricted. Within the terms of the deed restriction, there's the ability if they can't find an eligible household that the deed restriction can be removed and then sold at market rate. So to ensure that doesn't happen, the town has a $600,000 pot of money set aside strictly restricted to just the purchase of deed restricted buy backing.

1:17:48 to buy back deed restricted units. It's also supported by a $300,000 pot of money made available from Mono County for the same purpose here in the town. This is really done through a partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing. It's really been successful and kind of as units become available, we can purchase them and then work with the community to find the right household for that unit without that same time frame as the deed restriction. Also on the slide we highlight the town maintains

1:18:17 A number of employee housing units is really intended to be interim housing for town employees and outside agency employees as needed. So either new staff coming to town or staff who has some housing issues who needs interim housing. Our goal is to kind of keep an employee in there for roughly six months while they find other housing and then they move on so that they're constantly available as needed. So this slide is really highlighting our partnership projects.

1:18:47 As kind of the previous slide indicated, it's really hard to do an affordable housing project just on your own, so you really need to look across the spectrum of who you can partner with, where you can get grant money from for these projects. The first one is the access apartments. This is a Mammoth Lakes housing project that's converting two existing commercial buildings into 11 one-bedroom apartments. The town's committed $1.5 million to this project.

1:19:14 And the town was also successful on a CDBG grant for $3 million for the project. Mammoth Lakes Housing acquired another $3.4 million in a home grant funds. This project's currently out to bid to bring a contractor on with the goal of starting construction in April. And then occupancy would be about 12 to 18 months later, so spring, summer of 2024. The next project on here is the Home Key Project. It's a conversion of Innsbruck Lodge.

1:19:42 into permanent housing. This project was made possible by the state through their Home Key Grant Program, which is really targeting rapidly rehousing the homeless population. And so across the state, you really see jurisdictions going after hotels because it's kind of the easiest type of project to convert to permanent housing. So with this, it will be 16 units. 15 of those units are affordable. Also highlighted on here that the

1:20:12 The town committed $1 million and the county committed an additional $550,000. There is an ask going to council next week for some additional funding for the project. Construction costs have evolved just in the year since we submitted the application. However, this project is currently under construction. I was there on Monday. Everything is fully demoed on the inside. It's taken down to the studs on the inside of the building. Their goal is to then start the

1:20:40 Rehabilitation work next month to start going towards occupancy with their goal being November of 2023 to have it fully occupied. Also on this slide we highlight our Chamber of Commerce Program, Tenant-Landlord Matching Program. Program, this goal is to, as the name implies, to be a matchmaker. They're taking a list of local employees who are looking for housing. They're running background checks on those employees.

1:21:09 Also vetting that they're locally employed. So as then landlords who register with the program that they have a room, a unit, a house, an accessory dwelling unit, whatever they want to rent, they can pair them with an employee who's already kind of been vetted. It's not just putting an ad out there and seeing what you get if you have a room to rent.

1:21:31 This slide just kind of summarizes all of the different grants that we've received over just the past couple of years. So these are pretty recent, and we're looking at almost $75 million in grant awards. If you think about the population of Mammoth Lakes being around 7,200 as of the last census, that's over $100,000 per person in town that we're bringing in just for housing. This doesn't count kind of all of the other grant work that we've done.

1:21:56 I'm pretty impressive, and we're really proud of really kind of going out and bringing this money in to help further affordable housing in our community. One other program that we've worked on is the Accessory Dwelling Unit Program, and that's prescribed designs for accessory dwelling units. We did work with Mono County on this. Mono County received a grant for this, and so put together prescribed designs that work both in Mono County and Mammoth Lakes that are designed to accommodate our snow loads.

1:22:26 So I think they look really good, really good designs, really livable units, a range of sizes from relatively small units up to, I think, 1,400 square feet, 12, somewhere around there. Yeah, around 1,200. Yeah, 1,200 square feet. So really livable designs, something that would really work, I think. The biggest issue, I think, is construction costs. We're still seeing that even though we've already taken a significant burden off of the plate of having to...

1:22:54 Put together the designs and do the engineering for these projects or for these types of units. We're still seeing kind of not a lot of movement in this area, and I really just think it comes to construction costs. But hopefully we'll have some people who will do these units in our town, show that they can actually be built, and then I think that will kind of start getting the ball rolling. But like I said, you can use the designs in Mammoth County as well.

1:23:17 The last item is we put together a did-you-know kind of publication for the members of the public talking about our housing program and the fact that we'll be delivering 272 units of workforce housing in the next 12 to 24 months. And that really depends, highly dependent on us getting funding for phase two of the parcel. But even without that, it's pretty significant, the numbers that we're delivering.

1:23:42 We've pushed this out to members of the public. There is a QR code that takes you right to our Housing Now webpage. If anyone navigates to the town's website, it is just a quick link on the bottom of our page. So if anyone has any questions, this is really what I usually hand out to people because they can get to the right places. With that, that concludes our presentation. We're happy to answer any questions that you have. Thank you both very much. Questions? I have a couple of questions. First, I want to commend you because, yeah, that's very impressive work.

1:24:12 And kudos definitely to you and your staff. A couple of questions that came up, because I think I'm one of the only ones who hasn't seen this, so bear with me, everybody. What is the typical lifetime of those modular units that are being built? I mean, it's the same as a standard. I think it, I don't really know the typical life cycle of those. I would say it's at least as long as a typical stick built, if not longer. They are built in a factory, so they're not exposed to any weather.

1:24:44 So, you know, like if you're building something out here in the weather, it's getting, you know, wet or cold or hot, that kind of thing. This is all built in a factory. But these buildings, I mean, I would say at least 50 years, you know. I mean, at least a typical life cycle is no longer. And, you know, we have other slides that show kind of like, you know, construction from start to finish. But, I mean, they're all stick-filled just in the factory, so they're still framed with wood. In some instances, they're almost more kind of efficient because...

1:25:12 You're actually getting a double-loaded floor, because you're essentially getting a box, so it's got a fully sealed top to the box, and then when the next unit stacks on top, it has a fully sealed bottom, so you're actually, in some ways, probably almost stronger design on the flooring and the separations. And for those, the town of Mammoth Lake retains ownership of those apartment buildings, right? Hold phase one to the developer.

1:25:39 And that's kind of the program. In order to get the funding for it, it just makes sense competitively to get funding for that. So we've sold the first phase. However, we have a disposition development agreement with a master developer for the parcel. So we can choose phase by phase whether we do that or not. We've done that for the first phase. We would likely do it for the second phase. The parcel does include some opportunities for ownership.

1:26:03 You know, so that would be ownership, you know, by individual parties. So we'll kind of, you know, explore that as we move forward. But that's the program for the first couple of phases. And I guess my other question is the, can you comment a little bit on the deed restrictions that you have? I mean, at this point you're talking about income eligible, the person needs to demonstrate that they are working in the area. How are you guys actually checking that and enforcing that? Sure, so there's two different...

1:26:32 Kind of deed restrictions in place. There's the ownership deed restrictions, and then there's rental restrictions or regulatory agreements for the rental projects. So on an ownership one, through Mammoth Lakes Housing, at the time they want to purchase it, they have to bring in all their information to verify and demonstrate their income, so tax returns, pay stubs, any other source of income.

1:26:57 Prove that they make less than whatever that AMI limit is for the household size. And then also to demonstrate that they're employed in the region and that then they certify they're going to live in full-time as their primary residence. And going forward for the ownership units, they get verified annually that they continue to work in the region and live in it as their primary residence or they don't have to requalify income every year for ownership just at the time of purchase. Then for the rental side,

1:27:26 They have to remain qualified for the life of the time they're in that unit. So they get re-verified annually on income and that they work here and that's their primary residence. There's some flexibility usually in the regulatory agreements for some upward motion in income where, let's say it's an 80% unit, they might be able to go up to 100% AMI and still remain in the unit. Then usually their rent might adjust.

1:27:54 I guess in particular I was curious about the proving that it's your primary residence. It's really a self-certification on the ownership, you know, it's that you're claiming the

1:28:22 The homeowner's exemption on your property tax bill, that it's your primary residence is one way to demonstrate that. Others, we've seen is, you know, where your utility bills are getting mailed to, that it's the local post office. But the property tax one's probably the most, I say, the verifiable, because you're signing with penalty of perjury on your tax bill, that it's your primary residence. And maybe I'm not understanding something in this.

1:28:54 Thank you for the deed restriction answer. That was actually part of my question. Presumably, somebody qualifies, they work 25 years, they retire, and they're still income eligible, but they're retired. Usually the deed restriction does allow retirees to be eligible as well for that. A retiree could come in that is income eligible at the time. They can demonstrate they're retired and live in it as their primary residence.

1:29:23 Depending on the deed restriction language, some have language that, oh, you had to have worked, like, five of the previous ten years in the area. Each one's structured a little different, but it does allow retirees. That's a very good question, because Aspen, Colorado, is a very interesting case study where they've got a lot of retirees living in the units and no one's moving and the stock is all occupied and you've got young people going, hey, I need a place to live. Anybody else?

1:29:52 Yeah, Bob. Yeah, I had a question. I appreciate your presentation. It's good, like many things, to see it again because then you see things you didn't see the first time. On the modular units, do the numbers work financially if you drop down to like 10 or 15 or 20? Because that would be our situation if we were going to do something like that, I would think in the county is that, you know, can you do it with, can you do, can you buy like 10 or 15 or 20 or does the, is there some economies of scale issue that are required?

1:30:22 I think there's certainly a kind of deal. I don't know what that magic number is. The nice thing, I think, about modular construction, and so if Mono County was going to do a 15-year project, maybe there's the opportunity to partner with somebody else who's doing another 15 or 20-unit project and have the modules, have them all kind of built the same factory here. So as you go forward, I mean, I would encourage whoever's working on housing for Mono County to just kind of keep in contact with the town.

1:30:57 And that way, you know, if we do get funding for phase two, I mean, maybe that's an opportunity to put that developer in their factory. We do also have, as Nolan mentioned, project is going to be, and that's that same situation where that, that, it's about the modules for that are going to be, the developers going to, and so that's the only way. Okay, so it may make sense for us if we say we have needs in June Lake and Levining and Bridgeport and Walker-Coleville, and they're anywhere from 10 to 15, maybe we can have the numbers work, but just have them be placed in different places.

1:31:41 All the modules are just projects, so that is the nice thing about modules. I think each manufacturer is a little bit different, but if you're working with the same manufacturer, you're kind of working with that same size of a box, and so that makes it a lot easier for building those and setting the modules. Thank you. I think it, too, on that is somewhat market-driven, depending on the market. Six months ago, two years ago, when...

1:32:09 Interest rates were low, you couldn't build units fast enough. Those modular plants were saying, no, we're only taking in projects of X number of units that, you know, are of scale, anything too small, we're not. I was talking with the developer of our 60 Joaquin project yesterday. They're doing another 33 unit market rate development here in town that is mostly modular. And six months ago, they were going to have to bring

1:32:37 All those 33 units to market at the same time, just get in the modular factory to build all those at the same time, and now they're saying, no, we're going to go forward with approximately four of their duplexes, so eight plus our 60 Joaquin project, and the factory is willing to do that now, just because the stuff has slowed down. One last question. Just to get a sense of when you're talking about the

1:33:04 The Sawyer Phase 1 with like 100 modules total. What is the actual footprint of the land that that's being built on? How many acres? A little bit over two acres. Linda. A couple comments. Yes, this is multiple times I've seen it, but that's okay because, as Bob said, every time you see it, you see a little something different. And this is more of a comment like when you're out talking to people. The money that the town spent to buy this property

1:33:34 Initially, I think should be referred to because how much was that again that we paid? How much? Yeah, six million, which now seems like, whoa, what a deal. But back then, that was pretty, that was a lot of money to put at this. So I think it's good to note that that that was also an initial investment in this project by the town.

1:33:53 Yeah, we noted in the project funding slide, but I should... Yeah, I think it's important, yeah. We're trying to kind of shorten this down for you to get... Yeah, yeah, that's right, yeah. The other thing is that noting that some money was also received in specific from behavioral health around a certain, you know, how did we phrase that? People at risk of homelessness? Supportive housing. I'm sorry? Supportive housing. Yeah, so I think that's important. And the one more thing, a little caveat that we were able to get in was it's a non-smoking...

1:34:22 Completely non-smoking project, which I think was a good thing. But yeah, this is a great presentation. I would like to make this required reading for every resident in Mammoth Lakes because I still hear, well, when's town going to do something about housing? Well, gosh, you know? So, yeah. Yeah, thank you guys. It was great. Okay, anybody else? Yeah, Elaine.

1:34:47 Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to add first main appreciation to Sandra and Nolan for providing this presentation. Some while ago, your board had requested that staff work to put together a regional roundtable to discuss housing issues, and it was very...

1:35:04 Difficult to understand how that kind of single event would produce something really tangible in ongoing information sharing. So it kind of never materialized. But with this first presentation on housing from the town of Mammoth Lakes, it's something that staff would like to bring back on a regular basis to your board from each of the jurisdictions to discuss both the housing opportunities and what's being done as well as the constraints for each jurisdiction.

1:35:30 Thank you. That's a very good idea. And I think, obviously, this is a presentation that's a little bit, you know, community mammoth-centric. Hey, we're doing something, believe it or not. But I think in the spirit of regional cooperation and regional sharing, steal, take, learn. Find what's applicable. Yeah, just because we are all these little islands surrounded by federal land.

1:35:57 Anything we can do to be leveraging all of our resources? Well, four years ago, if we remember, we had our housing summit up at the lodge up there, and it was outstanding. And while that was, I know, an enormous amount of work. I'd been on town council like 20 minutes when that happened. But that was, I mean, we can take from that, I think, what some of the things we did there and replicate that, because that was...

1:36:26 Very, very useful. And there's links to that. Elaine, we can get you some links to that. It's basic stuff, looking at other, you know, Colorado, a lot of other regions and areas, sort of recreation, tourism-based kind of places, a lot of federal land bases, how is everybody else doing it? And there's a lot to learn. I think another thing we have in common is a common perception, perhaps, of the California Department of Housing and Community Development. And these guys have done great work with this project, but

1:36:56 Wrangling, wrestling, dealing with the state of California is perhaps a common theme for all of us to try to get reimbursements, to try to get documents signed, and perhaps there may be an advocacy opportunity at some point for us as a region to be able to say, look, what the hell is going on over there? And they should have to give us a lot of money when they steal our employees. Yeah, well, that'll be an added bonus. Jeff, I know that's something you have an interest in, and I think with your leadership, I think that's something we can maybe pull something like that together.

1:37:26 It's my lifelong quest. Good. Mr. Coat and Tie, we shall join you on your quest. We look forward to that. Well, good. Well, thank you very much for that presentation. Very much appreciate it. And looking forward to regional efforts as we all work together to address one of these common, seemingly insurmountable challenges. So with that, we're going to move on now to approve a contract amendment.

1:37:54 with Eastern Sierra Planning, LLC to extend until April 15th, 2023. Karen, this is the bridge thing we're talking about earlier, so Elaine. First, I'd like to say good morning. I didn't take an opportunity to do that when we got started. Well, good morning. Good morning. Welcome to our new ESCOG board members.

1:38:16 So pleased to have you. Second, I'd like to take advantage of this opportunity to just thank you for your confidence and endorsement in establishing full-time staff for the ESCOG. I'm very excited to continue working with you.

1:38:31 So this item is the Fifth Amendment to agreement between Eastern Sierra Planning, LLC, which is me providing services as Executive Director to the ESCOG. The amendment just provides a bridge between when my current contract expires on the 15th of February.

1:38:54 to, after the next meeting, to allow for all of the administrative things that need to be done to finalize the contract within Inyo County to occur. That concludes my overview of this item. Happy to take any questions, but I would request that the ESCOG Board approve amendment number five to this agreement. Thank you. Number five. Okay, good. Noted. Any questions for staff? Not seeing any. Go move, Mr. Chair.

1:39:24 I'm sorry, what was that? I moved to approve, Mr. Chair. Okay, we have to ask for public comment first, but I appreciate your enthusiasm for this item. Is there any public comment on this item? If we don't approve, does this mean Elaine gets a two-month vacation? Kind of. Okay, seeing no public comment. Any additional questions? Nope. Okay, so we have a motion from Supervisor Griffith. A second. And we have a second from Councilmember Mahovey. So, Jamie, please.

1:39:52 Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. Councilmember Schwartz. Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Salcido. Yes. Supervisor Oral. Yes. Councilmember Muhove. Yes. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Thank you all very much. Elaine, again, thank you for your patience and persistence seeing us through all this. This next item is to award a contract for Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative.

1:40:20 I'm going to recuse myself from this item. I serve on the board of MLTPA, which is a subcontractor to this. I don't take any financial compensation, but just to keep the air fresh and clean, I'm going to step off here. Jeff, would you be able to manage this item for me while I step into the room? You got it, boss. Thank you very much. Take it away, Elaine.

1:40:59 Good morning. Some time ago, the ESCOG was awarded a grant to the National Fish and Wildlife Federation for the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative. There are two phases to this project. The first was installation of toilet infrastructure in the Buttermilk Bouldering Area, and the second is a conceptual recreation planning effort to meet with interested stakeholders and land managers.

1:41:28 to identify some of the issues that the buttermilk is experiencing with increased climbing activity, dispersed camping, trail proliferation. So we have, phase one is under contract, the toilet is being manufactured and should be delivered in April. We prepared an RFP for consideration by your board.

1:41:55 That was considered in December. That was released and published in January. It was published in the Inyo Register for 21 days, consistent with the ESCOG procurement, public procurement procedures. We received one proposal from Alta Planning and Design. Alta Planning and Design is already on contract with the ESCOG as a recreation planning consultant for the Towns to Trails Project as well.

1:42:22 The proposal intends to include conceptual recreation plan development with an emphasis on public outreach with stakeholders and land management agencies, and that will include targeted collaboration with a lot of the volunteer groups that are already doing work in the Buttermilk area, including the Climbers Coalition, the Access Fund, and the Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association.

1:42:49 On the basis of the constraints and opportunities identified through that work, recommendations will be made for trail implementation, signage implementation, parking and dispersed camping implementation. All of the implementation activities will be subject to approval from the land managers, specifically the U.S. Forest Service, to ensure that there's...

1:43:13 No further environmental decisions that are required, though the proposal does include a small budget for NEPA compliance if necessary on the basis of those recommendations. Their outreach proposal includes three public meetings with stakeholders and public managers. One of the opportunities that's presented by this proposal coming from Alta is the ability to reduce capacity issues for land management partners by streamlining those interactions.

1:43:42 for having Towns to Trails meetings and then also being able to talk to them about burpee issues so that one of the concerns that I've heard from land management agencies is that they already have capacity issues and they don't want to be attending multiple meetings so I'm pleased that we might gain some efficiency there. The proposal also includes a $5,000 stipend for volunteer engagement. The total proposal from Alta is 127.

1:44:09 As Mr. Wentworth noted before leaving the room, MLTPA is a sub-consultant, but he does not receive any compensation from that agreement. At this time, I'm happy to take questions, but staff would recommend that the ESCOG Board award the project to Alta Planning and Design and

1:44:37 Authorize the Executive Director to negotiate that agreement. Thank you. Happy to take your questions. Okay. Go ahead, folks. The comment I had was that it's notable that they have also done a number of projects in Inyo County to date, and that the experience that, you know, is being had with them has been, that we have had with them has been positive. So I think that's important to... Yeah.

1:45:08 They just did our downtown specific plan. They did a great job there. So, I mean, I have no issues with selecting them. My one concern is that this buttermilk project area seems extremely large and that the use groups

1:45:30 Go beyond just the ones that you mentioned that are specifically called out for outreach. So, I mean, in particular, along the Tungsten Hills and the Buttermilk area, there is a large number of OHV users that are out there. And so I wanted to make sure that this actually incorporates reaching out to those groups as well as equestrian groups and those sorts of things.

1:45:59 Yes, we have had those conversations. I can't remember if there's an actual name of the volunteer group, but the group that put together the Adventure Trails, the OHV group, they submitted a letter of support for this grant application. And I've also had conversations with Supervisor Rozier from Inyo County. This is within her district, to also be cognizant of ranching leases that are there.

1:46:29 Also the Starlight Community who has a large concern given their proximity to the area. So I think the volunteer groups that are identified in here are already doing work really focused in the bouldering area, but it will be within the scope of this work to make sure we're doing outreach to all of the user groups in the Buttermilk area. Obviously that's a place that's very special for all the people to recreate in and around Bishop.

1:46:57 And I also agree with your observation about the size of the project area. And I think that there will be high-level strategies and recommendations that can be consistently applied through a lot of the planning area. And then as it relates specifically to some of those high-use areas like the buttermilk area, where we'll be talking probably more specifically about signage that talks about best practices.

1:47:26 And trail proliferation, a lot of that information and educational material can also be used consistently at the other trail heads identified in the project area. Yeah, I mean, I think one of the one things that assuages my concern a little bit is that this same group is also working on the whole trail map system for the area, so there's definitely synergies there. One practical concern I have is, I mean, we all saw how much snow and rain we got.

1:47:56 How is the toilet going to get out to the Buttermilk Road at this point? Because it is demolished. To be perfectly forthcoming, that gives me a huge amount of anxiety as well. We have until April. And the previous former forest engineer, Nora Gamino, assured me at the time that the toilet was ordered that

1:48:26 They have dealt with much worse conditions than toilet delay. And I will invite her to be on-site to help Supervis. Okay. I guess I'll ask at the LTC next week if there are any plans to do any work on their road. To be fixing the road. Yeah, we'll be needing to coordinate with Inyo County to make sure that that's the case. And I'm on the other side coordinating with the manufacturer so that when it's delivered, the road's in condition to deliver it.

1:48:57 Elaine, what are the dates on the contract? Thank you for asking that question. I don't think I included that in my staff report. But the contract for the conceptual recreation planning would sunset like September 30th because the overall NIFWF contract expires at the end of 2023. So that would give us- It's a very fast term. Yes.

1:49:26 Apparently they're doing a kickoff meeting right now. Yeah, I had no idea. Is that just, that's the deliverable date? Like they have to have this in our hand by then? Yes, that is the deliverable date. It is a very short grant window, which is part of the reason it was a slightly expedited procurement schedule from our standard 30 days.

1:49:55 But I'd also say, as opposed to something like Towns to Trails, which is like a $400,000 grant that looks at a regional, this is a much more focused area and a much higher level of planning. And so without any formal action necessarily being taken, environmental work needs to be finished and adopted and so on and so forth. So it'll be a hustle, but I believe we can get it done.

1:50:28 Okay, are there any other questions for staff, or are we ready for a motion? Public comment. I just have a really very quick question. I'm just curious, is it a composting toilet? It's a vault toilet. Okay. It said that, but I didn't know if that, like... Well, yeah, it's like a septic... Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's probably pretty good. It was New County to... They're gonna have to get out there now.

1:51:06 I've been on some of those discussions and they're like, well, we want to, some of the residents complain about the dust, so if we let the road be in disarray, people go slower. Oh, I know. But yeah, no, we'll bring it up. All right, Mr. Barnett, I see he has illuminated himself. Do you have something to say?

1:51:37 Yeah, just on the public comment side. So just so folks are aware that although the funding for this project comes through NIFWF, National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, the actual money is from LADWP. So this is a pilot project that the Forest Service helped negotiate with DWP to start the process of getting

1:52:00 DWP investing in recreation management in the surrounding areas. So this is a next step in a longer process of hopefully implementing recreation management with support from LA. Thanks. Thanks, Adam. Okay, any further public comment? No, there is not.

1:52:27 I'll move to award the project to Alta Planning and Design and authorize staff to negotiate and execute a professional services agreement between the ESCOG and Alta Planning and Design for the provision of recreation planning services for the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative for an amount not to exceed 127,411. Okay, so as we have a motion and a second, if there's no further comment, can we have the vote, please? Supervisor Griffiths? Yes.

1:53:01 Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcido? Yes. Supervisor Oral? Yes. Council Member Muhove? Yes. Council Member Bubzer? Yes. Okay, great. Someone can get John, and I will give everyone a 10-minute warning before I have to leave for my next thing. Thank you, Washington. So we'll move on now to another

1:53:41 Item of interest, the consideration of the Master Challenge Cost Share Agreement with U.S. Forest Service, Inyo National Forest. Elaine. Thank you. As introduced, this item is in regards to consideration of a cost share, master cost share agreement between the ESCOG and the Inyo National Forest. Cost share agreements are standard agreement vehicles for the Forest Service to do work in partnership with a non-federal agency. This

1:54:12 agreement specifically would allow the ESCOG to continue work on sustainable recreation projects and wildfire resiliency projects and it really just formalizes that partnership that we've been establishing to be able to collaborate on that type of work. It also allows

1:54:31 The obligations of the ESCOG

1:54:58 Under this agreement is that we would work with the Forest Service in a timely fashion to consider verbal and written Forest Service proposals, identify planning and environmental review needs for projects that would be located on non-federal lands, explore funding to support wildfire and sustainable recreation implementation, and have timely communications regarding staffing and budget in response to the Forest Service requests.

1:55:27 There was also the provision that ESCOG would have access to Forest Service vehicles as appropriate. The responsibilities on the Forest Service would be the same in reverse, which is that they would communicate with us in a timely fashion, collaborate with us on projects for sustainable recreation and wildfire resiliency.

1:55:54 Identify funding opportunities for implementation and identify the planning needs for projects and environmental review for projects that are located on federal Forest Service lands. With that, I'm happy to take questions you have on this item. Adam Barnett from the Forest Service and Nathan Sill from the Forest Service are both available this morning as well to answer questions you have. At this time, staff would recommend that your board...

1:56:23 Authorize the staff to execute the Master Challenge Cost Share Agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Inyo National Forest. Thank you. Thank you very much. Nathan, Adam, anything you want to add to Elaine's presentation? I guess what I would add is that this seems like the, you know, a very next logical step for our relationship with the ESCOG in being able to build some

1:56:54 instruments and opportunities to really capitalize on some funding and financing opportunities that are coming through the state and the federal agencies. And so I think this sets us up really well to be able to jump on any opportunities to fund both sustainable recreation projects as well as forest health, forest resilience and wildfire resilience funding coming through these various entities. Thank you. And Adam, anything you want to add to that?

1:57:25 Only that just from a practical standpoint, this just helps expedite the process of actually moving funds when we do have a project that we're going to work together on. And I'll just point out that the ESCOG program, the ecosystem management, sustainable recreation ecosystem management program, the SHREP, Adam is from the Forest Service side. He's the recreation guy. And Nathan is the fuels ecosystem management side.

1:57:54 Two sides from the Forest Service that speak directly to the program that we're doing. Okay, any questions? Yeah, Linda. Can we speak to just what is sort of the history of this kind of agreement with the Forest Service in general and how these have been used and why it's important to have them and what the purpose of this is? Sure, I mean...

1:58:14 Elaine, but I mean, this is a, it's the standard agreement that the Forest Service has if you're going to exchange any money for any purpose. Okay, so this is how it works, but Elaine and these guys are experts in that, so. I am, I'm an expert. No, I, I, having originally come to the ESCOG and knowing nothing about the Forest Service, I had the same question. It took me forever to understand all the adjectives that are applied to the agreement.

1:58:39 But it is, this isn't just a standard vehicle. There's only a few templates that the Forest Service uses to establish partnerships to do work, and this is one of them. And what this does is it's largely just an umbrella agreement that facilitates, as has been provided, the ability to work together to do work. And that's one thing I kind of left out of my staff report that I would like to emphasize is that

1:59:04 The initial program of work that the ESCOG was empowered to work on was sustainable recreation and ecosystem management. And I think as the ESCOG has evolved, we've sort of established that those two programs of work are

1:59:21 an important regional shared value that supports our economy and the resilience of our communities. And one of the things that the ESCOG seeks to do is not just build bridges between the four agencies, but between all of the agencies in the Eastern Sierra so we can be working together to get things done. And that's really what this agreement will do is formalize that partnership and make it more efficient to be able to do that work in the future.

1:59:51 And it is absolutely necessary for us to be able to work with the Forest Service, to be able to work on any type of recreation projects in our area. So this question is sort of for either Adam or Nathan. A few months ago, I sort of randomly received this letter from Randy Moore that was sent out in regards to direction to the Forest Service of, you know,

2:00:18 continuing to establish relationships and partnerships with local members, what that meant. Can you speak to kind of the attitude at the top level of the Forest Service in regards to these agreements and why they're important? Do you expect to see more of them? I mean, what has been sort of your direction from the top in regards to this?

2:00:43 Well, I suppose I can jump in on the ecosystem services side. You know, our agency has put out a strategic plan that talks about the services and goods that we're to provide to local communities. And I think this agreement in particular is trying to achieve that and trying to set us up so that we can be successful to not only help provide the services that our, you know, local constituents want,

2:01:12 But also make it more streamlined and be able to capitalize on the funds that are coming from the agency, especially around fuels and forest health work. I will defer to Adam on the recreation piece. I mean, the same applies for recreation, only difference being, of course, that, you know, fire community protection from wildfire is always going to be the top priority for the agency and recreation is going to be number two. That's it.

2:01:45 a reality, but we have a tremendous amount of money that's been coming through from Congress for both recreation and, you know, forest resilience and wildfire protection, and this is one of the ways that we can try to use that money on the ground to actually do something. Thank you. You know, one other thing I would add is that, you know, I think there's a recognition in the agency, especially at the Washington office level, that

2:02:14 We just don't have the capacity to do business in the way we have in the past, either funding or staffing. And so I think there's a real intentional effort to try and leverage, you know, funds at the state level as well as at the federal level to get more work done on the ground. And hopefully we can achieve that here through this. I look forward to that too. Thank you. I'll go to Jeff first and then come back to Stephen. Jeff, your hand is raised.

2:02:41 Yeah, so very good timing there. So I just got back from visiting with Randy Moore, the Chief of the Forest Service, right before this meeting. And we had that very discussion and talked about, even though that there's historic investments in both infrastructure and fuels reduction, ecosystem management, there's still a prioritization that needs to happen. There's still...

2:03:08 Not enough to take care of all of the needs. And this effort that we're doing here regionally in the Eastern Sierra is noticed in DC and in the regional office. And this agreement is just, you know, just one more.

2:03:27 statement that we are committed to working regionally and leveraging resources from all different areas in order to take care of the needs. So this really does put us more towards the top of the list when it comes to prioritizing these projects. We heard it live from D.C. Steven. Just since I'm new here and I've heard a bunch of things in passing, can you?

2:03:57 comment on how this relates to how it would have an impact on, say, the donut project that's been going on with, like, wildfire resiliency on Forest Service land? Nathan, go ahead. Yeah, I see this as this agreement in particular as a way to really help us implement that project once the planning work is done. So in 2025,

2:04:25 We expect that planning effort to be completed. And so through this agreement, I could see this as being a streamlined vehicle for us to capture funds and get those funds spent on the ground to implement that work. Does that answer your question? Yeah, I think so. And I guess one other question, does every government agency kind of have these sorts of agreements that they end up signing with entities, i.e. Bureau of Land Management?

2:04:56 Yes, I believe that the BLM has, well, so they may have separate authorities. This challenge cost share agreement, this agreement is an agreement that we use to implement certain authorities that are given to the agency to exchange funds between non-Fed governments or entities. And so I can't speak to what authorities they have, but they do have similar instruments.

2:05:24 to exchange funds, yeah. Because I'm obviously thinking, I mean, the Donut Project is a great project for wildfire resiliency, but in the last decade, the majority of the wildfires that have actually gotten close to towns have been down in the valley. So it would be great if we could have that sorts of... So the thing they mentioned about the supplemental agreements, this is the master, right? But then we get something in Bishop, supplemental agreement.

2:05:54 Donut Supplemental Agreement. It's like all of those individual things tier from this overarching. Yeah. And I will do some homework on what that looks like with the BLM. Thanks. Just because Forest Service is a little further from where things are burning down in the valley. And it's mostly BLM and DWP. Okay. Any additional questions or thoughts? I think we're good. I think it's time to see if there's any public comment.

2:06:25 Anything out there? Nope. Okay, so let's, I would entertain a motion to advance this item. So moved. Okay, is there a second? I'll second. Okay, there's a second. So we have a motion from Supervisor Gardner and a second from Council Member Schwartz. Jamie, please. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Salcedo? Yes.

2:06:57 Supervisor Oral? Yes. Councilmember Muhove? Yes. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Thank you. Adam, Nathan, great to see you guys. Thanks very much for coming in and sharing your insights and your expertise. And Jeff, thanks, as always, for the live feed from D.C. Okay, we'll move on now. We'll see you all when I get back. Okay, thank you very much.

2:07:20 We will now move on to the consideration of a memorandum of understanding between the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership and the ESCOG. This is an information item. I believe there's no action requested. Is that right? There's no action requested. Okay, good. So, Elaine, thank you. Okay. Many members of your board are familiar with and participate with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, or the ESSRP.

2:07:47 For those who do not participate with that organization on a monthly basis, I'll provide some background that informs the purpose of the MOU. So the ESSRP is a coalition of all the different jurisdictions, entities, organizations that interface with land management and recreation throughout the Eastern Sierra region. It includes all four jurisdictions of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments.

2:08:17 Alpine County, the National Parks, the districts of the Forest Service, BLM, DWP is invited. They come together on a monthly basis for information sharing to discuss the activities of each organization as it relates to recreation or also sometimes things that just interface with community development or economic development more broadly. It was established, I believe, before...

2:08:47 So before my period of understanding, but it was established through one of these cost-share agreements between the town of Mammoth Lakes and the Inyo National Forest, and it is staffed by the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation, or MLTPA, and they provide all of the background and the structure for that on a monthly basis. The agreement that holds that in place will expire in June 2023 of this year. So this MOU seeks to...

2:09:13 Formalize that partnership between each of those agencies that participates on a regular basis. And the intent is to continue to advance collaboration, identification of projects and collaboration for implementation on all of the things that relate to recreation in the Eastern Sierra. That can include permitting facilitation, maintenance and staffing of visitor centers, hard infrastructure, soft infrastructure projects, planning.

2:09:41 Local Government Recreation, Environmental Review. There's nothing in the MOU that's binding. There's no financial ask of the MOU. It's largely just to formalize that spirit of partnership between each of the agencies and continue to facilitate that conversation. There is one point, there's one

2:10:05 Section of the MOU that pertains specifically to the ESCOG that I would like to pull out for your board's consideration, which reads, the ESCOG will endeavor upon approval or direction of its board and the boards of the four member agencies with consideration of available capacity to leverage its position as a regional entity to pursue funding opportunities that may not be accessible to other parties whose jurisdiction is limited to one specific national park.

2:10:34 National Forest City, etc. ESCOG will attempt to pursue funding opportunities that are related to the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program or any other future programs that may be authorized by the ESCOG Board and all of its member agencies. And I pull that out specifically for your consideration because I think that the MOU for the ESSRP is largely

2:10:54 Beneficial to the region to continue to promote that conversation. But going back to Councilman Mahoby's previous concerns about the capacity of staff at the ESCOG, this is a point that as projects arise from this regional collaboration and come before your ESCOG board to be cognizant of the other projects that we've undertaken and sensitive to the capacity that we may or may not have. I'm otherwise comfortable with this provision. I think that's the intent of the ESCOG is to be able to identify

2:11:22 one of the intents of ESCOG to be able to identify these funding opportunities and work with all the different land management agencies and jurisdictions in the regions to get these things done. So with that, I'm happy to take any questions on this item. As introduced, we are not looking for action from the board today. We're looking for discussion.

2:11:42 Thank you very much. Any questions, comments, observations? I do believe that the National Park Service, the five units of the Park Service, have reviewed this and they're comfortable with this language. So at least that's

2:12:12 Move forward. Yeah. Yosemite. Yeah. Is that listed as a party? It's in the recitals. Who signs it when it becomes effective? Termination. So that effective data lane, 6.4 last pages, right before the signature pages?

2:12:49 Are those all the signatories? No. That's a good question. I don't know that I can answer that. Give me a moment. I'm just curious. I mean, there's no, you know, there's nothing in this that's going to hurt anybody, but yet it's not, just doesn't list all the partners. Yeah, I think that effective date includes just the parties to the

2:13:22 Yeah, I think this is great. This is where we've been headed, and it's good to get to this point.

2:13:53 And let's get on with it. You know, when you think about where we were, where we are, and where we need to go, this is a big part of it. So great to get this on the table and to move it forward. So I certainly support this, and I know we don't have to take action, but I'm glad that we're at this stage at this point, given everything that's anticipated regarding recreation. And I appreciate the sensitivity in terms of workload.

2:14:22 That's important, and we need to be careful of that as we move ahead. Okay, so Elaine, I'm assuming that there will be, as the MAU has further developed, these types of comments about, you know, listing all, getting the formatting proper and all the rest of it. At some point, it will come back to the ESCOG for action. Yeah, if there's no other modifications from the board at this time, we'll bring it back for your consideration. Okay. All right, good. Well, that's a good information, good piece of information to have.

2:14:51 I do have a little bit of an eye on the clock because I know some of you have to go into ESTA. So we will move on then to Elaine, some updates on community economic development strategy submittal by ESCOG and California Economic Resiliency Fund update. I will look at the clock. We have about 15 minutes. So I don't know if we want to prioritize our updates and things like that. But I defer to you if you have priorities you have for the final minutes we have left.

2:15:19 And I will share this because

2:15:57 As Supervisor Salcido had said about the Town of Mammoth Lakes presentation, it's sometimes useful to see the information again. And the thing with the SEDS is that we have these two opportunities running in parallel to each other, and they have largely the same acronym, and they're very similar.

2:16:27 And so I just want to provide a little more context so that we can continue to keep the lanes clean. So the ESCOG is empowered to be working on two different economic development projects through a program of work known as the Community Economic Resilience Fund Pilot Program that allows the ESCOG to engage with both the SEDS effort and the SURF effort. So I'll provide you with an update on the SEDS effort first.

2:16:56 A SEDS is a comprehensive economic development strategy, and it's something that the Eastern Sierra doesn't have in place currently. We're one of the very few regions, I think, in the country that doesn't have a SEDS, and it's a mandatory requirement to access funding from the Economic Development Administration, though also often for other economic development activities as well, such as through the USDA. It is a regional planning effort.

2:17:24 And it requires a lead agency to submit to the Economic Development Administration as part of their file. I'll come back to that in a moment. It is also a requirement to establish an economic development district, which is a federally funded program to work on economic development activities in a region. East Sierra does not have an economic development district in place either.

2:17:49 The Rural County Representatives of California, RCRC, received a grant some time ago from the Economic Development Administration to provide a SEDS for the Eastern Sierra Region, which includes Inyo, Mono, and Alpine counties. That kicked off in December. We selected Thomas P. Miller and Associates as our consultant. They're based out of the Midwest.

2:18:11 We have bi-weekly meetings with them, with a steering committee that includes all of the economic development staff from each of the member agency organizations, as well as Alpine County and the ESCOG. Right now they're doing their background research, so they're pulling together all their foundational documents and census information and having conversations with us. It's really fun to talk about the Eastern Sierra with these people from the Midwest. They're just like...

2:18:36 They're trying to plan their wardrobe for their visit in April. It goes from Alpine County to Death Valley, so have fun. And they're working on developing their outreach strategy right now, which will kick off in March. There's going to be three tiers to that. The first is one-on-one interviews with regional leadership, so your staff is actively populating contact information about who should be.

2:19:01 I've reached out to with emphasis on a few key people that will have those one-to-one interviews. Let me know if you are in particular interested. There will be public workshops that are currently planned to be held the week of April 24th, and their plan is to hold two community workshops per county.

2:19:21 Over a course of maybe three days, now that they look at the geography, they might extend that trip a bit. And they're planning to do one east side, west side, Alpine County, northern Mono, southern Mono, northern Inyo, and southern Inyo over that time. And then they'll do online surveys that will be available April through May. And we're planning to have those translated into Spanish as well. The Community Economic Resilience Fund is a state opportunity, also related to developing this regional

2:19:51 Economic Development Plan to Guide the Region. It is a one-time use of $600 million that was originally related to COVID funding. There's two phases associated with this plan. The first is the planning phase, which provides grants of $5 million to each of the 13 regions in California. The Eastern Sierra is illustrated on this slide and includes four counties that are in the Western Sierra. The second phase is the implementation phase.

2:20:19 which has $5 million available enrolling competitive grants. There is currently a phase open, it was like a surprise phase, for a pilot project that has $50 million available for pilot projects to demonstrate how the surf will work. So we can discuss if there's appropriate project opportunities for that. The Sierra Business Council was selected as the convener for the Eastern Sierra Region.

2:20:49 Thank you.

2:21:19 Also the high ambitions to address equity issues and climate resiliency. Their proposal is to bifurcate the east side and the west side communities because there's not a lot of economic overlap between the two due to our geography. And they've proposed $500,000 for outreach efforts within the eastern Sierra Inyo Mono Alpine, specifically with $250,000 available to the ESCOG to be facilitating that outreach in the eastern Sierra.

2:21:50 So there is no update there. That's the take-home message, is we're still waiting for that agreement from the SBC to really pull in that $250,000 and understand the scope of services the ESCOG will be providing. But the state of California has not provided the agreement to SBC, and so SBC has not advanced an agreement with the ESCOG at this time, and so we're just all waiting for the state to move forward.

2:22:18 In the interim, Sierra Business Council is trying to get going to hit the ground running, and so this is their governance model for how the plan will be established and how projects will be elevated and selected for that implementation phase. It's called the High Road Transition Collaborative. We'll have 21 voting members with seven subcommittees.

2:22:42 Subcommittees are identified up there. They're having, lo and behold, having a hard time getting people to sign up for this. And in particular, from the Eastern Sierra, and it is very important that we want to have representation on here.

2:23:06 Such that this plan that will be used by the state of California to advance funding to our region in the future really reflects our needs and is as comprehensive as possible. And so I just want to encourage your board to consider if you would like to have a seat on this committee. It is a like one and a half hour commitment.

2:23:27 I think they said like 10 hours a month for a while. So they're expecting a pretty decent commitment. But there will be stipends available for participation for non-government agencies. So if you are interested in applying to this commission, they are looking for people to do that now. Or if you know of people who would be interested and would be appropriate, I just would like to encourage that we have adequate representation from the Eastern Sierra on this.

2:23:53 That concludes my overview of the SEDS and SURF. Happy to take questions on that item. Thank you. Thank you. Go ahead. So, Elaine, I mean, there will be people that sign up for maybe the council and then the government because if you are already doing stuff, you're like, oh, yeah, I'll do that too. So maybe that. But I think in the business sectors and some of those other sectors,

2:24:15 You need to, I think, put a special effort into getting some really good representatives in those places. I agree. Also, I want to do targeted outreach, personal outreach to tribal members to be able to participate. There is a set-aside for tribal funding and participation as well. And I'd also like to work with some of our active NGO partners in the region so that they are empowered to be doing work outside of government agencies as well.

2:24:44 I think Sierra's Business Council could maybe, I mean, like have a one-pager, like, this is what is going on, this is how you can help, this is where you could, you know, you know, to kind of be able to talk to people and say, here, you know. They have a website that might provide some of that. I can do some homework and send it over to you as well. Like local business owners, I think, would be really important to have. Yeah, that's a really good point.

2:25:13 If you come to them with that diagram, you're like, no. And I'm like, hold that point. What are you trying to do? Here's how you can help. And one thing I might say about the governance matrix that I threw up there is I don't think that you can request to sit on a particular council, but SBC will be policing people. Well, thank you very much for that update.

2:25:41 And I know we're all tracking and monitoring this, but it needs to be, as both of you are pointing out, this needs to be a lot more than just a bunch of folks like us showing up at this thing. We've got to get other people on this thing. So Elaine, I'm going to defer the Executive Director Report and the Board Member Agency Reports for our final action item of the morning, which is the selection of a chair and vice chair with the minutes we have remaining. So I see that...

2:26:10 Supervisor Griffiths is no longer with us, so I would like to nominate Supervisor Griffiths to be the next chair. I'll second that. Huh? We've got nine seconds. I want to second that. Oh, go ahead. Okay. Yeah. I want to second that one. Okay. Okay. So there's a motion to nominate Supervisor Griffiths for myself and a second from Inyo County Supervisor Trina Oral to second that. Is there any public comment?

2:26:40 No. None. Not even a little bit. None. Okay, good. No public comment. Any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Thank you. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Council Member Schwartz. Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Salcido. Yes. Supervisor Oral. Yes. Council Member Muhove. Yes. Council Member Bubzer. Yes. Thank you. So Jeff's sent him a text or something.

2:27:12 Oh, yeah. Congratulations. And then we need to sit now. Thanks for doing it. Last year. Oh, it's fun. For the one meeting. Yeah, right. Thanks for doing it. Yeah, exactly. The vice chair, this is on a rotating basis. So it's Inyo County. So the next will be coming from the city of Bishop, I believe. It's Mono County. Is it Mono County? Okay, I'm sorry. I would love to do a nomination.

2:27:41 Oh. Supervisor Bob Gardner. Second. Wow. Wow. Nine seconds as well. So we have a motion from Supervisor Associate. Do I have a second? Second. Second from Council Member Schwartz. Thank you very much. Any public comment? None. Okay, great. Angie, please. I'm sorry. Jamie. Whoever you are. Yes. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Council Member Schwartz. Yes. Supervisor Gardner.

2:28:10 Yes. Supervisor Salcedo. Supervisor Salcedo. Yes. Supervisor Oral. Yes. Councilmember Mojave. Yes. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Now an acceptance speech, please, from Supervisor Bubzer. I think he's demurring on that one. So with a couple minutes left, Elaine, any quick thing from your report, and then we'll just have a, we'll go down the dais and just say goodbye and what a great time we've all had together.

2:28:40 Please go ahead. I apologize. My favorite part of the meeting is to hear you guys talk. Yes, a couple of project updates really quick. Towns to Trails has kicked off. We're working with our wonderful consulting team. They're doing their background research, and we are anticipating that we'll have our stakeholder kickoff meeting in April for that project. And then on the NEPA for the donut project.

2:29:03 East and Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator. They are working on finalizing their proposed action. They're completing their scoping report for the International Forest. Most importantly, what I want to just highlight for your board is that they continue to have issues with revolving staff at the International Forest. That is key for working on that interdisciplinary team for supporting that work, specifically that the International Forest has lost as civil culturist.

2:29:32 Which makes the decision on their forestry decisions. And the White Bark team has, I think, pivoted very creatively to try and build that capacity with their own staff in partnership with the forest to accommodate that need. We are working with CDFW to make sure that that shift in staffing and funding is consistent with the grant. We received good news from CDFW yesterday that they approved White Bark's proposal for that staffing.

2:30:02 Thank you. So let's do a little lightning round down the dais from soon-to-be Vice Chair Gardner. Could we put on the agenda for the future, we did this a few years ago, and I did it informally, inviting our neighbors to the north of Pine County to perhaps be members of the ESCOG. We did this a few years ago, and I reached out and they said...

2:30:28 I think that's a great suggestion. I don't have anything else to add.

2:30:57 We are having some EMS disruption issues in our northern Bishop area, so we are actively seeking solutions right now and hopefully we'll come to some very soon. And then I have some sad news that Silver Preak's project, which was our low-income building project, did not get funded. Was that from HCD? Yeah, it was...

2:31:26 Visionary Home Builders was the one that owned most of the project and they just didn't get funded. When can they apply again? Next year. Because we had those issues too. Yeah, you just, you gotta go around and around and around and around. Sorry. Yeah, it was a bummer. Supervisor Oral. Beautiful, thank you. Supervisor Estosito. Nope, that's not enough, thank you. Uh, I don't.

2:31:51 Have anything except a future agenda item? I know now Inyo County and Mono County have hired a fire deputy in each of those counties, and so it'd be great since we're taking on our resiliency here under whatever term is appropriate to use. Yeah, that we could maybe invite them and have a discussion about how to come up with a solution that addresses.

2:32:21 And I will just say thank you very much. It's been a pleasure serving this capacity for this year. This is a really wonderful organization. I don't know what the hell it is, but it's nice. It's fun. It's great to be able to get together with everybody. And welcome to the new members. And really, really welcome you guys a lot. And looking forward to what comes next.

2:32:50 Thank you, John. You've done a great job. Oh, thank you very much. Thank you. With that, I believe we can adjourn. Kind of on time and a little bit close to being on budget. Let's adjourn. Thank you all. Yeah, thank you. Thank you, Lane.

2:33:04 Yes, of course. Okay, so after the, not just the most recent ESSRP, but the one with that, and I had mentioned trying to figure out a trailhead service, this one from the Forest Service, like, sent me this huge, long, and it's gone. Like, I, like, went back onto Zoom to, like, figure out. Was it in the chat? It was in the chat.