TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2022

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

235 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 So we're going to honor our guests who traveled many miles to be here. We will have the significant members of the ESCOG listening into the presentation. Anyway, there's some actions that staff can take on the home, which will not concern you guys. I'll turn it over to Grace to sort of help us figure out what we do procedurally. Thank you. Sure. So as Chairperson Wentworth mentioned, we don't have a quorum today. And so what that means is that the board cannot take any action.

0:30 And thankfully, however, a majority of the items on the agenda today are not actually action items. They're just informational. So what we will need to do without a quorum is we will have to skip the consent agenda because that's an action item. So number four will be stricken from the agenda. And also item...

0:52 5.4 will have to be stricken because that is the adoption of a meeting schedule for 2023 and that would also require a vote. I think Elaine may have a further discussion with the board about a January meeting to take care of that because we do need to adopt the 2023 meeting schedule prior to meeting in 2023. And then finally, I believe that for items

1:18 5.5 and 5.6. Those are currently agendized as action items. However, those items do not actually require a board vote. Those are matters that I think Elaine chose to bring to the board for vote just as sort of an option but not a legal requirement. So we will instead be treating 5.5 and 5.6 just as informational rather than voting items.

1:47 And everything else on the agenda doesn't require any modification because it was purely informational even prior to the forum issues we're having today. Okay, good. So we're not going to call the meeting to order. We're not going to do any of that stuff, right? Right. Because we're not having a meeting. But we're going to have some fabulous presentations, aren't we? Yes, we are. So with all that being said, Elaine, anything else you want to add to this? Thank you.

2:20 Good morning, Board, and good morning to our guests. I really appreciate that everyone has joined us this morning. As Grace said, I will circle around with the Board to hold a special meeting in January so that we can adopt the calendar for February. Because AB 361 is no longer in effect, I'll just remind the Board that you'll need to be present in person. As for the other items, we can discuss those further when we get to them. Thank you very much.

2:50 So thank you all. We apologize. It's a tricky environment for all kinds of reasons. With that being said, would the representatives of the Sierra Business Council like to proceed and offer your presentation? I will advise that representatives of all jurisdictions are present and your time will be well spent. And we thank you very much for coming down. We look forward to seeing your presentation if you're willing to give it. And if I can just interject.

3:19 From up here in Mammoth, just so I know exactly what we're doing. So are we not doing a roll call or a pledge or public comments? We are not having a, I mean, we are not, I mean, Grace, I defer to you, but we're not. So we, Pledge of Allegiance is, I would say, at the Chair's discretion. We can run the meeting however we'd like. I do think, though, it would be wise to follow the agenda as laid out. So perhaps maybe let's.

3:49 Take public comment as item number three, skip number four, and then move on to items 5.1 onward. Okay, so we'll do, we're going to do this. But we are not doing roll call, is that correct? There would be no need to call roll, given that, yeah, we're not actually meeting. Okay, thank you. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to, I'm going to lead everybody in the Pledge of Allegiance, and then we're going to do, see if there's any public comment, and then we'll.

4:19 Please repeat after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And Angie, I think I would like just to call the rolls so we know who's here in whatever iteration they're here in.

4:51 Can you hear me, Angie? Yeah, okay, so we are calling roll. Yeah, let's just call the roll. Okay. Chair Wentworth? Present. Supervisor Tothero? Council Member Schwartz? Here. Supervisor Corliss? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Supervisor Griffiths is not participating. Council Member Ellis? Council Member Salcedo?

5:22 And do we have Council Member Mahovey there at this time? No. And we could maybe call him and tell him. He doesn't have to come in. And just for the record, Angie, Supervisor Gardner, I think, is on the phone, and Supervisor Griffith is listening, is on Zoom. I understand that, but I'm going to defer to Grace. I do not believe they will be recorded on the roll call since we do not have an AB 361 resolution in place for this meeting. Grace?

5:54 Yeah, that would be correct. Any board member is welcome to participate remotely, but they would essentially be considered a member of the audience. Thank you. Rather than present. And we just wanted to know for the record, Council Member Salcedo is no longer a member of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. Yeah, it's the funny season. Anyway, so thank you all. Welcome. Hope you had a beautiful drive this morning or yesterday.

6:24 Please introduce yourselves and proceed, and we're looking forward to this, so thank you. My name is Erica Harvey. I'm the Director of the Economic Empowerment Team at Sierra Business Council, and this is my colleague. My name is Hailey Reynolds. I'm the Program Manager of Sierra Camp, which is administered by this Council. And we are going to be presenting to you the Sierra Nevada Regional Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment. Excellent. Just real quick, can we, Angie, can you hear all that okay? Do they need to speak?

6:55 Closer to the mics or anything? If they could speak a little closer to the mics, I had a lot of trouble hearing them. Okay, thank you. This is important information, so you guys, you gotta get friendly with that microphone. Yeah, heads on. Okay, so this project was ignited by the passing of SB 379 and the evolving climate emergency. So SB 379 has many parts.

7:20 And this project is just focusing on one part of that bill. So the requirement of a vulnerability assessment that identifies the risks that climate change poses to local jurisdictions and geographic areas, vulnerable to climate change impacts, which I know a lot of you are well familiar with already. So these are our project boundaries. Inyo and Mono County fall with Alpine County in the Eastern Sierra sub-region of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy.

7:57 So this report was created to bring jurisdictions into compliance with SB 379 and also build capacity in the region and help communities evaluate risk. Many of our key findings are also published in the Eastern Sierra VA that John Wentworth and his group with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. Bingo. Published. And we are very grateful. John Wentworth met with us a lot. We had a lot of email chains.

8:25 Zoom calls found that our priorities with our report and their report were very well aligned. So we're hoping that our report can build off of their report and give more of a regional context of climate threats to Inyo Mono County within the region. So we have created profiles for all the counties. So we'll start with...

8:56 The Mono County profile. This is just kind of like a brief overview. This is a tool that can be used for jurisdictions to update their plans. It just gives like a snippet of the climate and economic and social impacts that each county faces. We also have scores. So don't get too hung up on the numbers. It's just supposed to give you an idea of what the risk is.

9:21 So for the climate hazard risk for Mono County, it's a 7.4 out of 10. And then the human impact score is a 3.4 out of 10. In Inyo County, we essentially see the inverse relationship between the climate risk and the human impact scores. So this, instead of using these scores to compare these two counties or the rest of the counties in the report, it's more used to help communities decide where the most resources should go. And we think about the Mono County scores.

9:56 The climate risk is really high, but the population may have more capacity overall to deal with those hazards, where in Inyo County, that's reversed. We may see less dramatic increases, basically due to the landscape and a lot of the desert. So the change may be less intense, but the population may be more vulnerable to those changes and have less capacity to deal with the changes that do happen. Okay, so before we dive into some of the climate data,

10:29 This is just want to make sure everyone's always on the same page in these presentations. So these projections are just based on the best available data that we had at the time. It's just supposed to be illustrating scenarios that could happen, not necessarily will happen. This project is intended to be a capacity builder to assist planners in updating their climate adaptation and resilience strategies and the safety elements of their general plans.

10:56 So it's not trying to, like I said, project the will and will not. It's just an objective survey simply highlighting a profile of risks and options that jurisdictions could face. Posing the question, whatever your system, however you define your system, is it prepared for these changes? So the first data set that we've included, oh sorry, could you go back one? Is, this is the heat day.

11:30 Data Set. So, on average, heat days are expected to increase throughout the region in the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. But in this map, it shows that the lower elevations will experience more extreme heat days during the mid-century and some experiencing up to more than 56 heat days a year than the baseline. And a lot of us, we already kind of know this, but it just kind of shows that extreme change in elevation.

12:01 And then the next data set is the warm nights. Warm nights are also expected to increase throughout the region. This map shows, once again, the lower elevations will experience more extreme heat nights during the mid-century. Some areas going up to 52 more warm nights a year from historical baseline. So this next data set is kind of more of a climate economic impact data set. So we've included

12:33 We chose the January 1st date because that's when ski resorts typically open or are opened by. And then the little triangles on the map represent the ski resorts in the region. So for this region, I think it says, put my glasses on, it will decrease up to 100%. So with that being said, though, taken to, that's averaged across the region. So that could be from

13:03 Low elevations that didn't have very much snow previously to the higher elevations. So for the annual maximum SWE change, this is once again showing that we're going to see significant decreases in snowpack throughout the mid-century. Sorry, what is SWE? A water equivalent. And of course we can't...

13:35 Not talk about fire. So, on average, the Sierra Nevada Conservancy region can expect to experience a 48% increase from historical in acres burned during the mid-century. Now, we are already seeing these increases. So, as you can see on the map, Mono County can expect, I think it's a 77% increase throughout the mid-century.

14:05 Whereas Inyo County is just a little bit less. And it's just because there's more forest cover in Mono than Inyo. So the economy in Mono, Inyo County will be impacted by the climate hazards that Erica has just shared. Across the region in the Sierra, the four main economic drivers are tourism, recreation, natural resources, and ag. And all four of these are at risk from even slight changes in climate. And these will be impacted by changing in visitation or how land use.

14:39 Laws and appliances passed and the availability of natural resources. In the Eastern Sierra VA, there's a deep dive into how these impacts, climate impacts will affect the recreation and tourism industry in the area. And your report, John, Chairman Wentworth, is- Thank you. Calculates that recreation in the Eastern Sierra brings in over $2 billion. So thinking how-

15:05 That may shift and be forced to change and how we may need to adapt to maintain that level and what other sustainable options there will be. So if we look more at the household economics for the area in Inyo County, we see that leisure and hospitality industry, which here I think we more closely know it as tourism recreation industry, is the second largest employer, but as you can see, it pays the lowest wages.

15:34 So this, along with the high cost of living and changing demographics during COVID and changing economies, this may explain the wage discrepancy in the graph on the right there. So the median household income in Inyo County earns nearly $20,000 less than the calculated living wage for a two-income family with one child. And in Mono County, we see similar

16:04 Trends here, the leisure, hospitality, tourism industry is the number one employer and the second lowest wages. And the median household income in Mono is higher than Inyo, but so is the cost of living. And so that discrepancy between the median household income and living wage is the same, also $20,000 less for a two-income family with one child.

16:29 But what communities and groups are the most at risk? And across the Sierra Nevada region, the most common vulnerable populations are residents without broadband access, the housing burdened, people of color, and folks 65 years and older. The same is true in Mono and Inyo counties. The green columns on this represent Inyo County and the purple gray is Mono County. So we can use the populations of vulnerable or disinvested communities to help us understand

16:57 Where resources will be required to ensure that everyone can adapt and thrive during these extreme climate change scenarios. And when we get within smaller communities or census tracts, there may be different groups that have higher need or higher vulnerability. So it will need to be also determined at a local level. So part of this project included community capacity assessments. SBC partnered with Sierra Institute in doing this. So Sierra Institute.

17:30 helped conduct all these workshops, collected data, and then they produced these maps, which we've included in the report. Overall, the SNC region rates as a three out of five on Sierra Institute's rating scale. So that's kind of like a medium-ish capacity in the region. So for the Mono County workshops, the average across

18:02 It was broken by, it was grouped census blocks. So these boundaries were created based on areas that might be similar, and that feedback was all given in the workshops, just as a heads up. So for Mono, it was a 3.2 out of 5, which is slightly higher than the rated Inyo County, which on average was rated as a 2.6 out of 5.

18:31 So using this report, what do we do with this data?

19:02 Because it was used to bring jurisdictions into compliance with 379, I know Mono and Inyo County have both just updated their safety elements in their general plan in 2021. Mono County's hazard mitigation plan was updated in 2019, but Inyo County is updated in 2017. They do have a five-year expiration to qualify for FEMA funding. So if that's not being worked on yet, and it is in the pipeline, using data from

19:28 The risk profile, so that chapter six, those first profiles we showed, the overall regional context of the vulnerability assessment and using the Eastern Sierra vulnerability assessment, that data can be directly used. There doesn't need to be another vulnerability assessment that's done to meet those qualifications. This data is up to date and will meet those FEMA requirements. There's also a ton of state funding coming out, I'm sure as most of you are aware, and a lot of this funding through

19:58 Natural Resources Agency, Labor and Workforce Development Grants, Air Resource Board Grants, they all are requiring climate resilience and climate impacts and how the communities are going to be impacted by that. And this regional report really lays it out and draws a pretty straight line of like, these are the impacts, this is how the economy is going to be impacted, these are how communities are going to be impacted, and then gives you that regional breakdown. So we have a lot of that data, we don't have to recreate the wheel on those grants, copy and paste.

20:27 We are more than happy to be quoted in your grant applications. And also thinking that, you know, a lot of state grants rely on other tools that the state has created like CalEnviroScreen. I think most of us in this room know that we are not big fans of CalEnviroScreen in the Sierra Nevada. And so having a tool where we can show different risks.

20:53 And how those risks will impact our region specifically is going to be really important. And if we can elevate that, you know, if everyone in the region starts including this type of data in their grant applications and their comment letters, you can kind of shift that culture of how the state evaluates some of the risk or if there's ways or reasons to evaluate different regions differently. So I think the regional report can really help make that argument and also is completely

21:20 Usable in the beginning of the report, we give a breakdown for how planners should use it, the way that you should, you know, jump around the report so you don't spend many days reading 400 pages, but reading your profile, going back, picking those key climate impacts that you know will impact your region the most, getting that data really refined, and then going into the vulnerable populations chapter and looking at like, okay, in my census tract or my neighborhood, what are the most

21:49 And what are the hazards going to impact them the most? And kind of doing a little reference there of like, okay, yes, we're going to have those impacts. And yes, I have this population. So now I need to focus a lot of resources on that population and how we're going to help them do outreach to them and build our plans around that. So that's really how we foresee the report being used. And if anybody is working on grant applications or different types of reporting or your plans, we're happy to.

22:17 assist and point out where that data can be found. So, what happens next? How can SURF and other funding opportunities like the SGC's Regional Climate Collaboratives Program and programs like Sierra Camp help identify gaps in knowledge and barriers to success? So, ultimately, what we would like to know is what are ESCOG's big priorities for climate adaptation and sustainable economic growth? We would like to hear from you.

22:50 Is that a cue? Are there any questions? Oh, questions, yeah, I was waiting for the slide. Okay, so, Grace, are the only people who are allowed to ask questions, the three of us sitting up here at the dais? Okay, okay. So, if, Elaine, can you see who, can you see the, Jeff and Bob and, there we go, okay. So,

23:27 I guess if anybody has a question, just raise your hand. We'll do this sort of virtually and in person. We'll start with folks in person. And if anybody in the virtual world wants to ask a question, just raise your hand using your Zoom tool. Questions? I'm a little overwhelmed. I mean, I just have more comments. Yeah, comment away. I don't have any questions. Well, I have a lot of larger questions. But it's really gratifying to, you know, we've talked.

24:01 But to see your report come forward, I've looked through it, it's big, there's a lot of stuff in it. But I think it's incredibly valuable for us, I think for the ESCOG, for all the member agencies, to figure out how we can use the Eastern Sierra VA and your work, because they're discreet in many ways, which is really valuable. And I think we have some work to do to figure out how to aggregate that stuff, and probably around the grant, you know, the grant,

24:31 Some middle things you're talking about. I think that would be incredibly valuable next step if we can figure out a way to do that. And if we can find a way to do that, then the ESCOG perhaps serve as a little bit of a clearinghouse with our member agencies to say, here's just some great, here's a five or 10 page cut and paste exercise, I said it, that could be really useful for jurisdictions and NGOs and others. I know Stacey's been involved in

25:00 A lot of the stuff with the state and now in a new role certainly is even probably more so. But it's a very challenging environment. I think as we all know, there's a lot of money, but getting that money from whatever agency bank account it's living in and getting it on the ground in a meaningful way is going to be a really significant set of challenges. And I think the things that we're hearing is that the agencies are saying you've got to go through a grant writing process. Any desires and hopes about block grants?

25:28 You know, agencies sharing, pulling resources to help facilitate getting that stuff to the ground. It seems that the political will is missing. And I think if any of us knows leadership in the state of California, perhaps we could take them out to lunch and say, look, fellas, let's get this thing going here. But I think there's some enormous opportunities. And I think we're going to be on some kind of a panel in April. Is that right? Yeah.

25:53 So I think that's something we could certainly start working on. That's down the road a little bit, but I think that's the kind of message we could be getting out to the entire region, pool these resources to move these things forward. So it's tremendously exciting. I don't know how we can figure a way to follow up to kind of maybe aggregate those resources, but we can maybe talk after this a little bit and figure a way to do that. Comments? Yeah, and one thing, this is kind of a softball question. I mean, I didn't tell them in advance that I was going to ask it, but I just thought of it. Could you elaborate a little bit?

26:25 I think it's really important for everyone here, and we have the administrators of both our counties on, and we have the project lead of our big forest resilience project that ESCOG is working on. Could you talk a little bit about the relationship with the Sierra Nevada Conservancy? Obviously, they're the funder, but in this case, it seems to me that it's more than just

26:54 Oh, SBC had this great idea to do a region-wide vulnerability assessment. There was a need identified for this. Could you talk a little bit more about discussions you've had? Well, I know you presented at the SNC board, but how this can really serve as a baseline for kind of building on what John was saying for the Sierra Nevada region to direct investments and just kind of the vision of Sierra Nevada Conservancy for this document. Yeah, so I think

27:25 To answer your question, this document originally got started probably four, almost five years ago now. Time flies. And at that time, there were no other Sierra Nevada-specific regional assessments in the making. So it's kind of been in that very short period of time. A lot of documents have started coming out, which is great. But in terms of how...

27:51 kind of this document can be envisioned is it can really start to fill some of those research, a lot of the research gaps, but we've also identified more that even the state hasn't identified because we're here boots on the ground. And so, you know, this document kind of addresses some of the questions that are raised by, you know, people in the region that from CalEnviroScreen because they identify us as very low risk.

28:19 And many of us know that that's not true. It's just different. The risks are different. And so this can be used specifically with other regional documents supporting, all supporting each other and showing how high of a risk the Sierra, the Southern Cascades here in Nevada province.

28:41 is facing in terms of snowpack and fire and, you know, a lot of risks that the valley and the coast just doesn't quite have on their radar. I know we gave a presentation somewhere and they had asked us, they were like, why isn't sea level on there? I was like, well, not addressing issues at the moment. Right now we're a little more worried about fire. So I don't know.

29:08 Does that kind of answer? Yeah, and the reason I kind of wanted to cue that up because just one comment I want to make, especially for ESCOG, and this is my last meeting on ESCOG, I am already joining Erica and Kaylee at Sierra Business Council and advocating for the region, you know, at the state level. But using this document, if we obviously throughout the region, but especially through ESCOG in this eastern Sierra region can use this to elevate

29:36 the voice of the Sierra at the state level and just be coordinated in how we use this information and build on this information. It's really important. And something came up in a meeting that both John and I were on yesterday regarding the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, specifically funding, and the work that's being done there and that has been done in the Eastern Sierra vulnerability assessment to

30:06 to try to quantify not only what's at risk, which has been done, you know, quantify the value of the, you know, the places for our tourism and recreation economy, but to quantify the ecosystem services that this region provides to the entire state. This is key. I think this is, we have our esteemed director of Mammoth Lakes Tourism here. I mean, I think it's so key for us as we, especially as we move into the

30:35 Surf process where, you know, I don't think it's going to be a surprise if we see the tourism and recreation emerge. It's something we need to invest in. But again, so, you know, the key here is building on this. How do we use this information and keep growing it and really work together to quantify the values that we're providing to the entire state through water, through carbon, through clean air, but also through

31:05 Recreation and Tourism and what we're contributing. And all that data is there through Visit California, what we're providing to the entire state. So that's what I'm leaving you. I'll miss you. I hope you do that. See you later. I'll keep coming to public comment. Have you done that yet? Stacey, oh, sorry. Yeah, go ahead. You mentioned surf. And I think that, yeah, it's a great example of how like projects coming down the pipeline, it was kind of a coincidence that this project was finishing as that project was kind of.

31:35 Starting to ramp up a little bit, although we're still waiting on contracts. And, but we're kind of ahead of the ball a little bit. We're kind of ahead of all the other regions that we've heard. We've been in listening sessions and the regions of communities meetings. And a lot of the other regions are really stressed about their socioeconomic data, their climate data, like how are they going to collect that? Who's going to do it? And we're kind of sitting back like, ooh.

32:00 We're already, we've already done that. We already have, we're, we're a little bit, we're ready to hit the ground running. And so when this process picks up very quickly, we're going to be able to start identifying projects and applying for, we're starting that planning and implementation process much quicker, I think, than everyone else. That's the hope. I'm going to follow up quickly with something you said, and then anybody out there in the virtual world, if you want to raise a hand, let me know, otherwise I'll assume there are any questions.

32:28 First question is, has SNC adopted this? I mean, is their board, because this coincides with their program area, have they done, has the board taken some formal step to say, we're incorporating this? So there's been conversation, I think it's been a little this fall, they've had some turnover, and so their staff's been a little bit behind on some things, but I think the idea is that this document will be available on their website.

32:57 But it also points also available on our website. So it's a publicly accessible document. Anyone can read it. Anyone can download it. So the other thing I want, I want to just follow up what you said about competitive advantage. And you don't normally think of the Eastern Sierra and competitive advantage in the state of California in the same breath. But I think it's important to recognize that we are positioned that way.

33:23 The work that you've done, the work that we did with the SSRP up here, the work that Janet Halffield's doing up with the Mammoth Donut Project, and the idea around ecosystem services, just so if anybody's listening, well, what the hell is an ecosystem service? The water that comes out of the Eastern Sierra that irrigates, or I don't know what you do with it in Los Angeles, but that is an ecosystem service, and that is worth an enormous amount of money.

33:51 Especially given what's happening in the Colorado River Basin and all the rest of it. Climate change is conspiring to make the kinds of ecosystem services we have in our region increasingly valuable. And there was a component in the SSRPs, vulnerable assessment that we did, that we talked about. And I think the degree to which we keep this momentum going and keep this focus moving forward, as Stacey is saying, because the state is trying to do.

34:20 Block grants. They're trying to do multi-sector. They're trying to do a bunch of different things at the same time. And the degree to which we're telling the story, well, this region exports, I mean, the numbers in the report was like a couple hundred billion dollars worth of ecosystem services every year. This starts to frame what our economic and certainly policy advantage can look like. So I will stop. But I think we're all kind of on the same page of seeing how these things can work. So there's a hand raised in the virtual world.

34:50 Ms. Janet Hatfield, if somebody could unmute her and let her speak. There she is. Hi. Can you hear me, John? Yes, we can hear you. Thank you. Oh, excuse me, Chair Whitworth. Yeah, so I just, first of all, thanks, Stacey, for bringing up the meeting we had yesterday around fundraising really at a broader level at the regional scale.

35:14 how we can use sort of the Los Angeles community to help elevate maybe our voice where seems to be that voice in the past at least has been difficult to get the state's attention. So I think given the recent report about the water benefits to the city in particular, we could use that and I will trust that you all can navigate that political landscape. But there's one map that caught my attention that was shown and I just

35:43 I'm sure you're all paying attention to it, but I just wanted to say it out loud, but it was looking at the increases in wildfire in Inyo and Mono counties, but what really caught my attention is just due west of us, one of those areas is in the 90th percentile, where I think Mono County was in the 70th percentile and Inyo the 40th, but I just wanted to say is even if we can get our forests in a resilient state,

36:11 I've just encouraged this group to be thinking bigger picture because we all know that the westerly flow has significant economic impacts for smoke and we saw that during the Creek Fire and we talked at that time about reaching sort of across the divide to the folks on the west side who in a really a collaborative effort to look at that air quality because it absolutely

36:36 has massive impacts how the forests due west of us are also managed on our local economy. And I think we all know that. But that map in particular just caught my attention. And so as we make this pitch, yes, we've got our work cut out for us here on our little pieces of dirt. But to the degree we can help our neighbors to the west, I think it's going to help our economic viability in the longer term as well. And Janet, you bring up an excellent point.

37:06 Again, ESCOG, this is a Joint Powers Authority. Have you guys been in touch with the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District at all? Okay. It's because I know some of us have been on that board for a while, and this discussion about smoke from the west side and how the air sort of reorienting the air districts around these types of threats, these climate change types of threats. We've talked a lot about that, and I think that Janet's point, that's something we emphasize with them. Absolutely. I mean, that's something that we've been saying since the beginning is,

37:41 We were trying to create a document that was easy to use for planners from a city-county jurisdiction perspective, but also offered that regional aspect, that big picture, holistic, like Mother Nature doesn't care about boundaries. She doesn't care that there's a city here and a city there. Like if you've got, you know, the neighboring county, Alpine County, I think is probably what Jen was referring to, has the most risk, 97% increase right now.

38:10 in wildfire risk, which is just north. So if we get a little wind and it blows the wrong way, then everybody else is smoked out. So thanks for highlighting that. Yeah. Okay. Are there any other questions? Very exciting work. Thank you so much for coming down. I just want to acknowledge just in case it wasn't clear that Kaylee and Erica are the authors of this document and just did incredible work. So thank you. You got a round of applause.

38:38 So if there, I don't see any other questions. So thank you all very much. And we do have some follow-up things to do, obviously. So we're going to move on then to our next presentation, which is going to be a presentation from Team Air, Airport and Air Service. And I don't know who wants to go first. Ashley, if you want to start her. Okay. Well, I think we...

39:30 We've come a couple times over the last year to give air service updates, but we were here early last December talking about how excited we were for the first flight coming in on December 19th. So Elaine invited us back this December to just touch on a couple things that are happening in the next year or two at the airport. So if you could go to the next slide.

40:03 Next slide. Is it not advancing up there? No. Ah, that's the issue. Give me just a moment. Well, that slide will be up in a moment, but I can start talking about what it is. So, big thank you to the City of Bishop, particularly Nora Gamino and Gary Millicy, who

40:53 partnered with us out at the airport to do the slide calls a baggage claim area beautification. We have a zone within our like new sidewalk area for the baggage claim that didn't have great drainage, the one rainstorm we got last year and had our lawn in that area didn't really come back after the traffic last winter. So

41:23 Nora and I met out there a couple weeks ago and we came up with a plan and Gary, who's the lead superintendent, yeah, excuse me, for public works for the city, came in to help us execute the plan very quickly and it was very much appreciated. So we removed all of the old sod there that didn't make it and

41:54 Put in a drainage structure. In the photo there, you can see a little black hole, our grate hasn't come yet, should be delivered today. But there's a new drainage structure in there, so we shouldn't have any issues with standing water, should we have our once or twice a year rainstorm. And then cover the whole area with decomposed granite, make it, you know, prevent.

42:22 the whole area from turning into a mud pit. We did bring in some lovely rocks that they had left over from a project in City Park and to create some seeding options and just a little more interest. And this project will continue in the spring. We'll be planting some native drought-resistant plants along the outskirts. But we do want to keep that area as very usable space because when there is a whole plane load of folks there waiting for their bags.

42:51 We want to make sure there's plenty of room for everyone. That's also a popular area when it's nice outside for friends and family to wait for the flight to arrive and watch the flight land. We also have a local metalsmith creating a welcome to Bishop sign that will have the Bishop skyline on it to complement our beautiful metalwork sign that's around on the front side of the building that was created last year.

43:20 In addition to these improvements, I'd like to also thank the Bishop Chamber of Commerce and Julie Faber. They have a Visit Bishop kiosk that will be arriving right before the start of flights. It's going to be up in the terminal and it's an interactive kiosk. I don't know exactly what will be on it. I think there's a version of it on the website, but you can explore different things to do within the area.

43:51 You're waiting for your flight to come or go, I suppose. Julie has also arranged for a few local photographers to donate their photos. We're going to have them printed and put up around the outgoing passenger terminal. And each photo, like the artwork we have in there now, will have little notes about the author and how you can get to their...

44:27 Or not the author, pardon me, the photographer or the artist to take it to their website and promote our local artists. Okay, next slide. So this is a topic that we have brought before the ESCOG Board a few times before, but I just wanted to give an update on the new approach procedures that are being created for the E-175, which is the new regional jet that United will be switching to in the summer of 2023.

45:00 Since we last spoke, the new approach procedures and departure procedures were designed. The successful flight validation occurred on September 14th. This is a photo of the E-175 on the ramp at Bishop. It's a similar, you know, as we had discussed before, it's a similar size aircraft. It has 76 seats versus 70 seats.

45:29 in the CRJ 700, but it is a much newer fleet. They have a lot more of them, and it has the second highest passenger satisfaction rating in the whole fleet of United Aircraft. So we're very excited for that switch. The procedure package was put together after the flight validation and submitted to the FAA on October 26th. Review times with the FAA can range

46:00 Quite a bit, from two months to more than five months, but I was pleased a few days ago to find out that it is already scheduled for an FAA review in front of their Procedure Review Board on December 15th. So we are well on track to have that approach, to have all of those procedures ready for use by late spring of 2023. Likely the actual switch to the new aircraft won't happen until summer service. Next slide.

46:32 And just a few upcoming projects in the next couple years at the airport. The main construction project being the runway 1230 safety area improvement project. Runway 1230 is our primary runway at the airport. The safety area is the zone around the runway that is

47:04 Graded and compacted to allow an aircraft in the event of a runway overshoot or undershoot to pass into that area without damage to the aircraft. The safety area improvements at the Bishop Airport are, or the runway safety area improvements at the Bishop Airport are to extend the safety areas further beyond the ends of the runway. Currently to be

47:36 Our safety areas are compliant with FAA design standards because we have effectively shortened the length of the runway. So instead of 7,500 feet of asphalt, which we have, the pilots are told to assume that they have 400 feet less than that to account for the shortened runway safety area.

48:10 So we're excited for this project. It will allow for more. It will allow pilots to use the entire length of the runway. Another planning project that will move forward in 2024. Oh, sorry. Let me jump back for a moment. We are currently in the process of doing the environmental assessment and initial study for NEPA and CEQA for that runway safety area improvement project. The draft of that

48:40 of those two documents should be coming out this summer, so you can expect to see those around June or July. Once that environmental review period is complete, design will be carried out and construction is planned for the fall of 2024. That project's still a little ways out in the future. Okay, and then we also are looking forward to in 2024 moving forward with a master plan update.

49:10 This is a planning document that looks at the facility inventory, what we have at the airport. There'll be an aviation demand forecast included. We did submit to the FAA a demand forecast a few years ago, but the updated forecast will have two plus years of actual passenger data.

49:42 from commercial service at the Bishop Airport. So that will better be able to predict what we expect our demand to be in the next 10 to 15 years. The master plan also will make recommendations for future development at the airport, provide alternatives, and at the end, suggest a capital improvement program for the next 10 years.

50:14 I also have a note there that we, on November 1st, the county entered into a five-year on-call contract for airport planning, engineering, and architectural services with Armstrong Consultants. So they will be a consultant company carrying out the master plan update, the runway safety area project, and any other projects that happen in the next five years. And that's what's going on at the airport right now.

50:47 Excellent. Thank you very much. I think we'll just, if there's any questions or discussion, no, at the end, yeah. And because there's two components to this. There's airports and there's air service. Excellent airport update. Now, I think someone might want to talk to us about air service. Is that right? Absolutely. Good morning, John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And yeah, we're going to talk about air service. So to separate the physical structure from the actual routes and planning.

51:15 And as Ashley mentioned, our service down here in Bishop will start on December 15th. We're flying Denver and San Francisco this year. We did eliminate the Los Angeles flight last year. We anticipated that it wouldn't be as used because of the fact that the drive time from Los Angeles, the majority of the folks that took the Los Angeles flight in the past were from Los Angeles, not really connecting. And so we knew that that wasn't going to be as much of a draw. Last year's service was down substantially, and so it was eliminated this year.

51:43 And then at Mammoth Yosemite Airport, we started our service with Advanced Airlines on the 23rd, so the Wednesday right before Thanksgiving. Great load factors, almost full planes coming in on all three flights from Carlsbad.

51:54 Burbank and Hawthorne. So it was a great start to the season. I have Pat Foster with me today from Hutt Creek Aviation. He's going to go over a couple of things that they've been doing with Advanced Airlines and also at the physical plant of the airport in Mammoth, which is really exciting. So what I wanted to talk about a little bit here, really the load factors and kind of where we are. I think last year we were... What's a load factor? A load factor is the percentage of the plane that's full. How many people...

52:21 Yeah. Or on the planes. Exactly. So if it's 35 people on a 70 passenger plane, it's 50% load factor. And so I'm actually going to talk passenger counts more than actual load factors at this point. And so last year going into the season, you know, we had a lot of excitement because of the opening of the new airport. We got a lot of uncertainties as well. We hadn't flown in a year and a half to either airport and opening up a brand new airport, utilizing...

52:45 You know, having coming out of COVID, it was a struggle. We went into the holiday season last year with a lot of Omicron issues, and so we were challenged. Right now, where we're looking at from a booking standpoint, we are well ahead in all markets, which is fantastic. So the Denver flight last year, as of this past Tuesday, so I compare year-over-year bookings, last year at this point, we had 2,465 passengers coming in. This year, we're at 4,621. These are round trips.

53:13 So the difference there is 2,156. So Denver's up 87%. So it's almost double. It's almost double where we were last year. San Francisco is up about 765 round trips, which is a 52% increase to last year. And then as we go up into Mammoth, the Carlsbad flight, which has been really a very successful flight for us, is up 464 passengers.

53:37 And the numbers are lower than we see in Denver, but we're also talking about a 30-passenger plane. So being up 464 passengers is pretty substantial. And so that's an 85% increase. Hawthorne, which is where Advanced Airlines is based out of, Hawthorne is right next to LAX. It's not Nevada. We get a lot of people asking, why are you flying to Hawthorne, Nevada? So Hawthorne... When did you fly to Hawthorne, Nevada? Hawthorne is 10 miles from LAX, and it's a really easy commute over.

54:06 I'll talk a little bit about a promotion we did yesterday. Burbank, which has been the lagger, which is interesting because when we did fly that route to Mammoth with JSX, we were upwards of 80% load factor on that 30-passenger plane. And so we think that one will come back in, especially with the elimination of the Los Angeles flight, but that's up 146 passengers roundtrip, so it's about 37%.

54:32 We have been doing quite a bit in the marketing world. I think I mentioned maybe the last time we were talking that last year we spent about $550,000 on air service marketing. This year we increased that to $1.25 million. So we've really put quite a bit more out there. Really a lot of it is focused on the East Coast. Right now we have a 60-foot billboard running in Times Square that I've had multiple people sending me pictures and videos of.

54:59 And, you know, that'll run through December 21. So it ran from the start of November right through to December 21. So we basically got all the Thanksgiving traffic, all the holiday traffic. And so that'll be a great piece. We've got advertising in the Denver airports, all the folks that are flying out to go skiing in that other state. We'll see why they should come here. And then we've got billboards in Massachusetts and Boston talking about the wicked unreal snow that we have here in California.

55:27 The other thing that we did this year with Advanced Airlines is that we came up with a 10-pack. So we had done a 10-pack with Alaska Airlines back in the day. It's 10 one-way segments. And so these one-way segments can be used to fly Mammoth to Carlsbad. They can fly Burbank to Mammoth, whatever it is. They're fully transferable. So if you have a family of five and you're all flying up, you can actually use them round trip and eliminate them all at once. So we went through a first phase with that. We really didn't even get the promotion out and sold them out.

55:56 And so now we have a new phase of that unrestricted ticket, meaning that you can fly in on a Thursday or Friday and out on Sunday, Monday, which are the peak days. That's available on the Advanced Airlines website. We are still working through some technical challenges with Advanced Airlines to offer a locals deal. The locals deal will be at the original price for the 10-pack, but it'll be good for directional use, meaning outbound on Thursday and Friday.

56:22 Planes come in full on Thursday and Friday. They usually leave fairly empty because we don't have as much outbound traffic on those days. So the outbound traffic is what we're trying to drive. So if our locals want to utilize the service, outbound Thursday, Friday, and then coming back in on Sunday, Monday, because the planes on Sunday, Monday going out are typically full. So those should be, we're hoping, we're hoping to have that information by today, anticipate hopefully by the end of next week that we can launch that locals 10 pack and make that available.

56:50 Yesterday, we did a great promotion. We have partnered with Glenn Plake, the extreme skier, with the Mohawk, if everybody remembers that. So we had him with what they say is Hawk Up yesterday. And he was flying to an event in Michigan. And so we actually skied with him during the day yesterday, picked him up in a shuttle, took him to Mammoth Yosemite Airport, did some great shots there, hopped the plane, went to Hawthorne.

57:15 followed him through the process, including the shuttle. There's a free shuttle from Hawthorne Airport to LAX with Advanced Airlines. If you notify them in advance, you can get that either picked up at LAX and brought to Hawthorne, or as we did with Glenn yesterday, they picked him up at Hawthorne and brought him to his gate at LAX so that he could fly out to Michigan. So we documented that just to show how easy the process is. And what it basically shows is that

57:42 for our locals, but also for our visitors, that LAX is not off the table. You can still connect anywhere in the world from LAX, just fly down through Hawthorne, take the free shuttle over. Again, it's a 10-mile ride. I can't believe that we've got two airports that close to each other, but okay. And so that was a great, great opportunity yesterday to get that promotion out there. And one of the things that I'd like to talk about, too, is that we have a working group right now that is, it meets monthly. It has representatives from City of Bishop, Inyo County.

58:12 Mammoth Lakes, the airports in both markets, and then some of the marketing partners, myself involved, the mountain, et cetera. And so we meet on a monthly basis to talk about kind of where we are with things. We do a pacing report every week that goes out to show these year-over-year numbers, and we talk about the future of service. I think one of the things that I'd like to see us do is to expand that group quite a bit. And really, there are two things.

58:38 Back when we put the T-Bit in place in 2013, we loosely formed a group called the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance. At that time, it was really Mammoth Lakes and Mono County. It was meant to talk about the funding of air subsidy more than anything else. But now, obviously, since we've got Inyo and Bishop involved, I'd like to resurrect that group. And I'd really like to even formalize that Eastern Sierra Air Alliance to potentially be a 501c3. I moved here from Jackson Hole area.

59:08 I was part of the Jacksonville Air Board, which was a, I want to say a 12-member board with an executive director and a fundraiser that really focused on the air service. So in the future here, air service is going to get bigger than I can handle, just time-wise more than anything else. And so I really want to look at how we prepare ourselves for a new entity that could potentially have its own executive director, potentially have a fundraiser.

59:32 You know, the whole nine yards so that we are able to grow this service as we grow with the airport, as Ashley mentioned. But one of the big things that I'd like to do sooner than later is incorporate elected officials. I don't know how we do that. That's up to you. But I would like to get the electeds involved because I think that there's oftentimes conversations where the municipalities don't necessarily know what's going on behind the scenes or either don't think there's something going on behind the scenes when there is.

1:00:00 And so I want to make sure they're part of the conversation. And so I would bring that to this group. I know that we have the MiWOG, the Mono Inyo Air Working Group. I think that that would be a good place to start. And I don't want to overload it with elected officials. Why not? Moving at the speed of government is sometimes challenging. But we would like to look at how we can incorporate elected so that you guys understand what we're doing, why we're doing it, how we're doing it, and what the...

1:00:30 Okay, let's talk about that maybe. Is Pat having that to add? Pat is going to, yeah, he's going to add some stuff. And I think the other thing we're going to do is show you a video of the former commercial air service terminal at Mammoth and the great work that Pat and Summer have done to convert that over to a really incredible experience. So if folks haven't flown out on advance yet this year, when they do, they're going to be pretty impressed by what he's done. So I'd love to bring up Pat and then we can talk. Yeah, let's talk about that idea. Thank you.

1:01:03 Hello, everybody. Pat Foster with Hot Creek Aviation. As John said, we, so Hot Creek Aviation is the FBO in Mammoth. Basically, we provide all the services for the private jets and private planes. Pat, what's an FBO? So FBO stands for Fixed Base Operation. Yeah, yeah. It comes with sound effects. It comes with sound effects. Yeah, so basically we're the service provider. But we also handle all of the scheduled 135. We worked with JetSuiteX for a couple of years pre-COVID.

1:01:35 And now we're working with Advanced Air. And for those of you that may not be familiar with Advanced Air, it's a pretty slick model. It's called Scheduled 135, Scheduled 135 Charter. And basically it's limited to 30 passenger planes. And 30 passengers is the magic number that gets you under all the TSA regulations that we typically see at commercial airports. So not to say there's not significant TSA. We're in our second day of audits with TSA today as we do.

1:02:04 Annually, but to the customer, it's really no impact. So it allows passengers to arrive about 30 minutes before the flight. We check them in, we check in their bags, give them just enough time to grab a coffee or something, take in the views, and then we're loading them up and they're in Southern California within an hour or so. So really, really cool model. We really enjoy it. So the last few years, we've been running this service out of Hot Creek Aviation, our private terminal.

1:02:34 Really nice feel, fireplace, very comfortable. However, with 30 passengers, it gets pretty crowded. And it kind of does a disservice to our private customers coming in. They pay several thousand dollars an hour to not have to deal with other traffic. You know, people recognizing them. We get a lot of Hollywood celebrities coming through. They want that discretion. So with air service going down to Bishop, we had the terminal building empty.

1:03:00 Spent a lot of time working with Rob and Dan from the town. We put together a deal to where we're going to run the scheduled 135 charter out of the terminal. John gave me too much credit, worked a lot with the town staff on getting the terminal building ready. My wife has a really good eye for these types of things. She got together with Sierra, who's the airport manager, Sabah and Spring. They all had some really good vision.

1:03:28 Pot Creek Aviation in the town all did what we were told and put together a really cool, comfortable terminal building. All the TSA equipment is basically out. We've got kind of a lounge type feel. It's very comfortable, very quiet, very private feel. So the scheduled 135 model just gives you, you're nearly on a private jet at a fraction of the cost. And like John was saying, some of the tin packs and these types of things, we're talking about 160 bucks.

1:03:58 For this type of great service. So with that, maybe we'll just run the video. And this is just a quick walkthrough. I'd love to have you guys come through and see the terminal. It continues to evolve. Like I said, the town did a great job getting this done for us to start our service on Wednesday before Thanksgiving. The video's here. The video's here. We've heard that it's there. I just need to find it. Give me a moment, please. The helicopter in the background.

1:04:30 It's not showing here, unfortunately. Great, opening it again. You're able to see that picture a second ago, that photo there. This is actually the second iteration for this building. When I got there in 1999, this was a maintenance facility, and those big windows were roll-up doors where the town would pull their loaders in and there are equipment. Then they turned it into a terminal in 2008, and now we've adjusted it again. Going to do a quick walk through the new terminal.

1:05:32 Check in with Ashley. My friend Ashley there works a few days a week with us and she also works in Bishop for United. So that doesn't scream regional cooperation. I don't know. I don't know what that. We've partnered with Mono Art Council so we can showcase local artists and have put together an agreement where we can actually sell the art for them. People really enjoy seeing the local artists. So just a quick, quick preview for you. But like I said, I'd love for you to come down and join us sometime.

1:06:50 That room has a lot of unfortunate memories for a lot of us who are on the other side of the TSA and was sitting in that little fishbowl while flights got canceled and things like that. It actually looks like a place I might actually might want to go back and visit. So that's the beauty of the Scheduled 135 is because we are under a lot of the TSA regulations. If that flight needs to divert, it can go to Bishop. We check folks in and then we just go ahead and load them up on shuttles and they go down to Bishop.

1:07:19 I have a team waiting in Bishop. I have a team in Mammoth. So we facilitate both sides. So you're nearly guaranteed to go out. You just might have a little drive. And we did have to utilize that twice so far this year. And very, very fortunate that we have that option. Well, thanks for that, Pat. Thanks for your hard work. Thank you. I'd like to come back to this discussion about this air alliance thing you're talking about.

1:07:46 Offer just a little personal observation on this. We, the Mammoth Lakes Town Council certified our election this week. Welcome to new members of the council. I was sworn in as the mayor. But before we could get going on anything, we had to entertain an urgency item from our attorney who said, well, we have to go meet in closed session. Well, that's interesting. What are we meeting in closed session about? Well, it's someone who's suing us, suing the town about TOT and TBIT issues. And as we all know,

1:08:16 Mammoth Lakes has got a history with litigation and air. And I think that it's very clear to everybody that this airport and Bishop is going to be successful. There's no doubt about that. But I think your point about there are people, there's staff working on a lot of these issues coming forward, that we need to get the people, as represented by the electives, at a table where we can hear what's happening holistically and region-wide on behalf of air service.

1:08:46 ESCOG played, you know, a leading role, and I don't know what impact it had, but reliable regional air service. And that's something that we were all very interested in, invested in, and wherever, you know, the electives provided our voice to try to make that thing happen. It's happening. But at Mammoth, we get reports on our airport, we don't hear what's happening officially. We don't hear what's happening regionally. We hear we get lawsuits, you know, nice.

1:09:15 I think it would be enormously useful and enormously helpful if this thing that you're talking about, if we can figure out a way to start getting everybody at the table to really work together the way, the beautiful way that Pat, you've demonstrated working in Mammoth, and we're all working together to make this thing happen. We got to get everybody at the table because we're going to run into problems if we don't. So obviously we can't take any action today in any of this, but I think, I mean, Nate's listening in on this. I don't see anybody from the town here, but I think if there's a way to...

1:09:43 Follow up on this so that we're all talking with each other so we can be efficient, we can work together. That would be really a great thing. Nate, I see your hand is up. There he is. Yeah, thank you. I appreciate that comment and I fully agree. I will tell you that my team and some folks from the town have been talking about this and we fully recognize the need to get in front of all four elected bodies with a formal presentation.

1:10:12 That was really outside of the scope of the discussion and the, you know, impetus behind the conversation today, but I think John's comments with regard to getting the working group together make perfect sense, as well as a higher level briefing to the four elected bodies, and so that's something we're committed to probably taking on early next year. Okay, that'll be great, because I, Nate, as you know, and John, as you know, the Mammoth Lakes...

1:10:37 Council will be considering a renewal of the TBID, which is going to be a key component of this whole thing. And again, we're dealing with litigation, all kinds of unpleasant things like that. We need to all get together to really understand the value of it, how it's going to work, what role a very significant player, such as the Altera Mountain Company, is going to be playing in all this, so that we are successful in the infrastructure side, in the air service side, but in the political and social buy-in to this thing.

1:11:06 To make sure it's going to be successful, because it's going to be successful. We don't want to screw it up because we're just not talking with each other. We're not, we're miscommunicating. There's some, you know, regional rivalries start popping up with some nonsense like that. We want to, we want to get together and do this. So I guess, obviously, we can't take an action today. I don't know if it makes sense to you guys to maybe pursue something like this. But let's, let's see what we can do, Nate. I guess let's, let's, we'll figure it out in a, in a, outside of an informational setting.

1:11:36 And I do know that Nate has a meeting with Destin from Bishop as well as Rob and Dan from coming up here in the next week or so. And so I know that that could also be a great opportunity for us to talk about how we include the electives so that the group that is out there right now represents operations, it represents marketing, and it represents government, but it doesn't represent electives. And I think that really that's where the rubber hits the road when we start talking about what we need to do moving forward and getting sign-off and approval.

1:12:05 And getting everybody to understand the value. And to that point, we will start right with December 15th, first flights, we will start our survey programs again this winter to make sure that we understand. And then last year for the summer, we really expanded to ask more questions about people spending money in Bishop Bonino as well.

1:12:24 You know, I think it was really something that we looked at from our purposes of the air service itself, and then we worked with Taney and the Bishop Chamber to make sure that we had questions that would help understand the economic impacts for the town and the county down here as well. This is truly about reliable regional air service, and we've all got an interest in that. Absolutely. All right, well, good. Look forward to following up on that. Eastern Sierra, was it Eastern Sierra Air Alliance? ESAA.

1:12:53 It's, it's, it's, I'm a reductive mind, what can I tell you? What, which, which one is that? Agency on Aging. Ooh, okay, okay, well, good to see, you gotta get into the, into the acronym soup to figure out who's actually out there. And if, and if I may, I want to offer a quick compliment to team and on the advanced air service and the experience at Mammoth Airport right now is quite lovely.

1:13:25 My mother also, John, loved the red carpet on the Thanksgiving, pre-Thanksgiving flights. She thought that was very special. Every day there's a red carpet. Oh, where are you going? Where? The brewery. Okay, cool. We'll be done here shortly, I think. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you very much.

1:13:56 And next year, I'm not missing out on that 10-pack. And I just wanted to clarify, there's still a locals discount, too, on the advanced air. Correct. There's actually locals discounts on both airlines. The locals discount for advanced air is M&A. Cool. And then for the United discount, you actually have to send an email to Emily in our office. And the website has the discount page that you can get into.

1:14:19 And the 10-pack, so the first phase of the unrestricted 10-pack sold out, the second phase of the unrestricted 10-pack is now available, but we will still have the locals 10-pack, which we were hoping to have weeks ago. Unfortunately, the systems, we're just trying to make sure the systems can differentiate between the local pack and the directional use of it. So those hopefully will be available next week, and that will be at the original price of the 10-pack. So I think it was $13.59 for...

1:14:48 Burbank and Hawthorne and then slightly more, maybe 15, 59 for Carlsbad just because of the added distance and cost. But those will be available to locals again to fly out on Thursday, Friday and on Sunday, Monday. And we'll make sure as soon as we get that word, we'll make sure that both counties are well aware of the discounts. Excellent. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so what do you suggest we do at this point in this informational setting?

1:15:19 Anything else we can talk about while we're here? Yeah. I don't even know what Brown Act level we're at at this point. Well, I first would like to maybe request that we take a five-minute recess, and then I would leave it to your board if you want to cover the rest of the informational items. Before you all leave, I forgot just before all the people leave, sorry to interrupt, but since it's not really a meeting. Sure, it's not really a meeting.

1:15:46 I'm going to consider this a five-minute recess. Okay, we're on a five-minute, we'll be back at 10 o'clock. I should have waited. You should have waited, but we didn't know. It's not a meeting, it doesn't matter. It's not a meeting, you give out oranges, go to the bathroom, do whatever you want. No idea.

1:18:09 I hope you're feeling better. Thank you for making it to our not meeting. I don't know if you were actually meeting. Sorry.

1:19:27 COVID party. Did you have the COVID, you had the total COVID party last night? Elaine, you're not muted. It's now 10. What would we like to do? Does staff got something we need to pay attention to? Sure. Okay, so according to council, we can proceed with any informational items, and I would leave that at the board's discretion. So we can discuss the election.

1:22:08 Clearly, Ms. Salcido is no longer with the Town Council. And we cannot adopt the meeting schedule. We can discuss the Burpee RFP, which I do not need a formal vote of the board to issue. And I would like to be able to send out, since there is a horizon on that grant for getting that project underway.

1:22:38 And then we could also discuss the award for website design services, and I can provide an update on the different activities of the SREMP and some of the other projects that we have going. So none of those items require board approval, though I do, for the record, like to put the things like the RFPs and the website on the agenda, you know, for transparency and for public information, particularly since we have.

1:23:04 Other meetings every other month and one staff person. So the more people that we can get those in front of, you know, the better the outcome of those projects are. So I would leave it to your board as to how you think. Okay, so why don't we just go through the items and just see if there's any questions from members of the council. Is there a council of governments? Yeah. Any questions on the council? If there aren't, we'll just proceed and we'll just see where we go. So let's start with

1:23:32 Where are we starting election results? Congratulations. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you very much. Boom. Yeah. Nice work. Boom. Yeah. Congratulations, everybody. Any questions? I mean, I guess we, yeah. How do you guys body our pending from the... Yeah, I mean, there's all... Yeah, we're in the beginning of the funny season because...

1:24:00 Who gets seated, who's certified, who's not, all that kind of stuff. So maybe we could actually talk a little bit about this. So the City of Bishop did not have any newly elected officials. We'll have the same five council members there, which is fortunate. Inyo County, we'll be seating two new supervisors. I'm going to include in your map, those are both supervisors that serve the area immediately around Bishop.

1:24:27 Also, they had a T.O.T. measure. It would have expanded T.O.T. collection to campgrounds and RV parks, which failed. Mono County will be sadly losing Supervisor Corliss. She'll be taking on new responsibilities in representing the region, but gaining Council Member Salcedo as a supervisor. So they will have one new supervisor. And the Town of Mammoth Lakes has elected three new council members, including

1:24:56 incumbent, Mr. Wentworth. So what does that mean for us? What that means is that we will have quite a considerable shuffling on the ESCOG board because we will have at least one new representative from Inyo County, one new representative from Town of Mammoth Lakes, and potentially one new representative from Mono County. Maybe there will be continuity there.

1:25:23 And so I just want to, as you are all returning to the member agencies to be making board appointments, to be aware that we are going to be bringing on new board members. And if you can, you know, communicate, I'll certainly be watching those appointments and then doing outreach to the new board members to, you know, bring them up to speed on ESCOG activities once they're appointed.

1:25:51 Yeah, I don't, we'll just have to figure, I don't know when the appointments are going to happen. I mean, Mammoth, our appointments aren't going to happen until January, I think. I know for Mono County, typically those are done on the first day of the new, once the new board is seated, so that will likely be January 3rd. Okay, so it's, we're going to have to kind of let the dust settle and figure out what we're dealing with. When is the next formal ESCOG meeting? February 10th. February 10th, okay. Okay, good.

1:26:21 In terms of the next item, the meeting schedule, do you anticipate having a need to have a special meeting so we can adopt the meeting schedule so that we can actually meet? Yes, we will need to have a special meeting. Before February? Before February. I will push that out until after the new year into January, given that everyone has lots of...

1:26:45 conflicts between now and the new year. Right, and it might also be interesting to schedule that meeting once all four member agencies have seated or designated their new people, because then when the meeting schedule gets adopted, you're dealing with a bunch of people who is actually going to be the board. We could have maybe just a quick meeting, introduce everybody, hi, this is what the schedule is going to be, thank you, maybe something like that. Okay.

1:27:13 And we just sneak a couple things in there we could if we had to. Yeah, I appreciate that input. Thank you. Yeah. Okay, so maybe mid-January, once they've all got their stuff together. Okay. Okay, the Burpee RFP. So, since we're not looking for board action, I'll just provide a summary, particularly as it relates to the process of issuing the

1:27:44 RFP and some of the feedback that we have, or as the case may be, have not received on it. So the ESCOG received a grant from the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation to do this project. And by this project, I'm referring to the two phases of the buttermilk infrastructure and recreation planning project. So phase one was installation of the toilet facilities. Those have been ordered.

1:28:12 We don't have a delivery date yet, but we at least have a confirmation on how much it would cost, allowing us to move into phase two with security around how much money would remain available for the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Planning Initiative. So what this RFP outlines is a very high-level conceptual planning effort that would establish GIS mapping of trails.

1:28:39 And roads infrastructure and some of the existing soft surface parking infrastructure and some of the dispersed camping issues for the Buttermilk bouldering area and then also the environs looking into the greater Buttermilk area and then the parking lots for the happy boulders and the sad boulders. The larger component of that project would be stakeholder outreach and having a professional facilitator who can meet with the different

1:29:08 User groups, not just within the climbing community, but all the user groups of the Buttermilk, and be able to document the current user impacts, opportunities, constraints.

1:29:25 for addressing some potential mitigation efforts, which could look like trail delineation, parking delineation, dispersed camping site delineation, and then informational signage as appropriate. And this would be done in partnership with the appropriate land management agencies. There are, in Buttermilk, there's several different jurisdictions that are engaged with that.

1:29:53 And then it would also incorporate and build upon some of the concurrent efforts that are happening in the exact same vein, since there is a lot of user impact in the buttermilks. So, Supervisor Rozier, Inyo County, the buttermilk area is within her district, and she has been spearheading

1:30:17 I've had conversations with impacted communities in the area, like the neighborhood of Starlight, to talk to residents about their concerns as it relates to things like road degradation and dispersed camping and wildfire. So I have had conversations with some of the people facilitating those meetings to say, you know, this effort is upcoming and it will be formalized and we'll want to include your input and we'll be invited as key stakeholders into that process.

1:30:46 This will really incorporate and build upon those efforts. Also, the Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association got a small grant to do like visitor counts and some trail mapping for Pine Creek and Buttermilk climbing areas. And so, you know, I think I've spoken with them and we'd also want to be able to include the data that they're developing within the study since it certainly fits within the scope of what the intended output for this is.

1:31:16 We have sent the draft of this RFP to Forest Service and BLM and the Climbers Coalition and Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association. I haven't received any comments back on it at this time. I know the land managers did have an opportunity, the Forest Service and the BLM had an opportunity to look at the grant and the scope included within the RFP.

1:31:44 All, you know, largely just mirrors what was within the grant application as well. So I'll go ahead and stop talking for a second and take questions. But I mean, do we have an answer to when people address the road with this? I mean, are we just going to say that's not part of it? I don't think it is possible to have a conversation about use in the buttermilks.

1:32:14 And not talk about the road. But because this is like a high level conceptual planning document that will mostly be sort of documenting the input in the conversations, I don't see any reason that we couldn't include the conversations about the road. Yeah, without proposing solutions, necessarily. I know that that was like the core conversation that was being had with the Starlight residents was, you know, what do you think about?

1:32:42 Paving it. What do you think about this? And I think just sort of it's not a huge increase in scope for us to be documenting that within this plan. Okay. Just so you know, I think Nate and Jeff have visualized themselves. They may want to say something. Sorry, Nate, you want to go ahead and then Jeff? I will defer to Jeff. Okay, Jeff, so you want to go ahead? Jeff's saying he's going to defer to me. I'll defer to you. I think Elaine.

1:33:12 Made my point. Like, I just wanted to make sure that local input was. I think that's what it's all about. And that's fundamentally, this is about a, it's conceptual, bring in the public, everybody get, you know, let's start figuring out what needs to be done out there. That's kind of what it's about. I think that's my reading of it. That is exactly what it is. Yes. Yeah, I find it. I really appreciate this. And Elaine, thank you for bringing it forward. And I really...

1:33:43 And I think fundamentally the process is extremely important.

1:34:12 And I think that the stakeholder engagement is the most important aspect of that. Overall, I think that the general points in the RFP seem pretty solid. Maybe we could just chat offline. There's just a few little things that we thought might be worth including just in terms of cleaning up some language just to make sure that.

1:34:37 There's clarity for whoever would be responding to the RFP just around how some of that stakeholder engagement would happen and a few things like that. And some of the comments that I've heard is that individuals are not necessarily always very well engaged, but there are certainly user communities and other interested groups that certainly would be. Just a few little aspects like that. And then with regard to the road, I do think that it's an important part of this conversation.

1:35:04 As you all know, an exceptionally complicated component of all of this as well. And, you know, certainly Inyo County and the forest are right in line with one another in terms of how that gets worked out. And there's a lot of pressure on both of us to try to resolve that. And so I think the extent that it is put into the conversation without blowing up the rest of the process, it's important. So I think, Elaine, you and, I mean,

1:35:32 Your interested parties at this point are you've heard Inyo County showed up and they've got a couple of things they want to talk with about and you've represented no other parties. You've talked, we've sent it out to other people, you've got whatever input you need. You don't need the approval of the board to send it out there. So we can certainly work with Inyo County offline to make sure that the RFP is revised to, you know, reflect any of their concerns. And I think if there's anything that

1:36:01 Inyo County, you feel like you need to come back to the board, fine, but I can't imagine that'd be the case, but if you guys are okay going ahead with it, just get it out there, because this is obviously really important. We got air service having people coming in from all over the world to go drive down that road. They do. They do. Yeah, they got boulders to climb. Yeah. Jeff, are you happy with all this? Yep. Okay. All right, good. Well, thank you very much. Thanks for showing up, visualizing yourselves.

1:36:32 Should we move to the next item? Yes, please. Okay. And so we finally have some staff capacity to kick off a website update. I requested that ESCOG had put aside $10,000 in this year's budget to design a new website. So I had requested quotes from three web designers with local preference. We received two proposals back. Both were within our budget.

1:37:02 And it's staff's recommendation that we would select Pinion Ranch Consulting for the website design. And this is on the basis that their proposal was just like much more tailored to the ESCOG and much savvier to what our needs are as a government organization with less emphasis on, you know, advertising and Facebook and Instagram and corporation, which is...

1:37:31 You know, not the services that we necessarily need. I was, you know, I thought that all of their website design looked clean. Their proposal was completely responsive to everything that we had put out in our, we put together fairly detailed, like, scope of work, rather than just requesting quotes, and they were very responsive to what was within that scope of work.

1:38:00 So that is, within the proposal, they proposed a not-to-exceed amount of $8,800, but I did not see that they'd included ADA compatibility in there, which is obviously an important issue as a semi-government organization, and so I had followed up with him afterwards, and that would be an increase of $500.

1:38:26 So the total amount would be $9,300 not to exceed. That is within my spending authority to approve that contract services without board approval. So I will go ahead and do that because I'm very excited to have a new website, one that will function better for our clerking staff. And I just want to thank Angie for struggling through her current website month over month for us.

1:38:55 A note, it will be more user-friendly for staff. It'll be able to accommodate all of our agendas and our minutes. It's within the scope of work to make sure that all of that's transferred from our website archive. And then we'll also have project landing pages for each of the programs of work and projects that ESCOG is working on currently, which will be really...

1:39:15 Good, because we do have people who have heard about the Burpee Grant, or they've heard about Towns to Trails, and they want to be engaged, and they want to get on the mailing list, and we'll finally have a platform to be able to accommodate that. Okay, so is there anything, Elaine, I think that, again, in this sort of informal setting from your director's report you just want to share to timely that you think is important? Well, certainly. Thank you, Chair Wentworth. You're probably here.

1:39:52 from your staff at each of your distinct member agencies. But RCRC did award a contract for the Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy work that was awarded on December 2nd to Thomas P. Miller. And so all four of the member, the economic development staff within all four of the member agencies was involved in the selection of that. It was the most efficient conference call you've ever been on in 20 minutes.

1:40:22 And so all of the member agencies will be independently engaged in the development of that strategy. There's a kickoff for that before the end of the year, and the horizon for the project deliverable is June. So that will be happening in the next six months. There is no update on...

1:40:47 Regarding a contract from the state to the Sierra Business Council for the SURF project. If it's completed in June, does it have to be adopted by anybody? That includes the timeline for adoption. Who adopts it? I think it's the EDA. There's a 30-day public comment period. Do the local agencies have to adopt it? I don't know. I'll have to get back to you. So with the SURF, there's no contract in place or project kickoff.

1:41:18 for the planning phase of that project. But the state did announce a $50 million pilot project for implementation. And they have requested input on the guidelines that they've put out, which are not very comprehensive at this time. We expect them in January for full release, and they want to have an application back.

1:41:49 Within four weeks is what they're proposing right now. And so I would just offer it out there. You know, there was a lot of comments I think they probably received on that timeline and the sort of unexpected nature of this pot of funding becoming available. Nonetheless, if there's a project that, you know, makes sense, would serve to regional benefit for implementation, and we may want to consider putting something together.

1:42:18 I just offer that we might start thinking about what those opportunities might look like. And we can discuss that at our next meeting in more detail. Yes, this is the part that completely confuses me on the whole SURF process and even the presentation that we had from the Sierra Business Council is there's all these like high level goals and, you know, the scope is very high level.

1:42:45 Like, how do we get it from there to the actual people that need to be served? Like, that's the part that I don't, I don't, there's like a disconnect for me. Like, for instance, air quality and we have, I mean, this is just like a random, but like, we come up with a project and we say, oh, all low-income residents need to go from swamp cooler to AC because swamp coolers are no longer efficient for cooling and they pump in smoke. But like,

1:43:13 How do we even go from that to serve the actual people that need the money to this like high level? I don't, I do not have, it's not connected for me. Right. And I think that that's a frustration that's probably shared is that the state of California rolled out something that is very, very ambitious.

1:43:35 And I think that's part of the reason that they put so much funding into the planning phase, is that it is supposed to be... Do we come up with like... We do. So the planning phase is going to involve, and that's really what the ESCOG is going to be facilitating, is a huge amount of outreach to stakeholders in the community, be it local government, tribes, NGOs, trying to paint a...

1:44:02 Portrait a picture of what the economic conditions are across this entire very large, you know, this very large reason, and then developing those projects that are priorities for economic development that also will address things like climate change and equity. So, I mean, I wouldn't feel alone where you're like, okay. But as the Sierra Business Council said, I mean, I think that it's...

1:44:30 Certainly something I've heard that we're like a little bit better, in a slightly better position, maybe other regions in California, because we're already starting to have some conversations about what that looks like for a region. Sure, sure. So. Not that complicated, there's not a whole lot of us. Yeah, we're, I mean, that's a big advantage that the population in our seven county region is a lot smaller. Right, right. And, but, but everyone has expressed, I mean.

1:44:59 Any of the surf calls soliciting feedback, information from participants, everyone is confused. And as a matter of fact, the Little Hoover Commission, which is a state body that provides oversight on specific state programs, recently published a document about equitable

1:45:25 Equitable Economic Development in California and talked about CERF and really outlined all of these things like, you know, the state needs to provide more oversight. It needs to be clear how this is going to be equitable and how actual projects will come through. So it's, I think the main message is to people to participate and it is a tremendous opportunity for our region if we work hard, take advantage of it. There's everything that comes to it. This is not one of those things where the state's going to say, here's what you do.

1:45:54 It's going to be, it's going to be, it's going to be wild. It's like a money grab. Like we're all just sort of like, no, look, the opportunity for us is to get in there and just all get together and figure out what do we, what do we need? No, unfortunately, no money for projects. Right. Money for planning. Right. And then there's money for projects coming in the second phase. And if we go, if we do the planning right, okay, there's 500 million for the state. That's nice. Who knows how far that will go, but.

1:46:24 With the SEDS thing, now we can go and get federal projects. We can go get federal money. So yeah, that helps. Right? So we're going to kind of figure out what we need, what we want, and then, okay, let's go over here, let's go over there and get it. I mean, if Bishop, if there's airport things or infrastructure projects, crap like that, we can, at least we can say, we went through this process. We all figured out what we needed. There's consensus. We all want the same thing. Give us $8 billion to go do something. Okay. Exactly. And so the, it's the,

1:46:51 Where we're at right now is there is $5 million coming to the Eastern Sierra for developing this plan, whether we choose to participate in it or not, and I would hope that we do because then it's this foundational, and that's the real value of all those plans is you can't access certain funding unless you can say,

1:47:13 You know, we did our due diligence, we did the stakeholder input, we did our priorities. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. And just be clear, there's five million for the, they're calling it the Eastern Sierra, but it's really the Eastern and Western slope of the Central Sierra. Sure, sure, sure. It's Eastern Sierra Plus. Okay, great. It's not Western Sierra Plus, it's Eastern Sierra Plus. Okay.

1:47:35 Okay, so I mentioned that we've got the toilet on order for the buttermilks. We did a kickoff yesterday with our consultants for the Towns to Trails project. Yeah, so there's a sort of three-month initial phase for them to do due diligence and do some mapping before we'll start looking at stakeholder engagement, and I think that'll be really, really valuable to have.

1:48:03 You know, have to be going out to the public with, you know, some kind of like framework of what existing conditions are. And the only other thing I add is Stacy, Sandra, sorry, Sandra Moberly from the town of Mammoth Lakes had asked to do a presentation on Mammoth Housing efforts. And so that will be scheduled out for February. So I look forward to coming back to you with that. Also the...

1:48:33 The scoping period for the NEPA process for the donut project has closed. They received 12 comments the White Bark Institute will use to shape what the environmental issues are for focusing in that NEPA project. And then they also have mentioned that they are having some issues with the U.S. Forest Service who has lost what's called a silver culturist.

1:49:01 which is one of their forestry team members who focuses on trees and whitebark is working very creatively to develop like a supplemental staffing plan in collaboration with the Forest Service so that they can fill that need to keep the NEPA project on track. And then also separate from

1:49:26 our NEPA project that we're collaborating with Whitebark on, they're working on, they're working with different representatives throughout the region to develop a strategy for biomass once implementation starts, and they're working with ORMAT to identify an appropriate location for

1:49:54 Energy production using biomass and trying to tie that into the energy grid. And it may make sense for them in the future to go out and find a consultant who can really help them navigate that whole effort of trying to figure out what to do on the biomass side as they're taking the fuels out of the forest. So those are all of my items for just an update on the activities that have been happening in the last couple of months.

1:50:22 Happy to take additional questions on this. Thank you. Okay, if any questions for Lane. Otherwise, well, this is the last meeting of this iteration of the ESCOG. Right. So, it's been real, folks. Jeff, you got any words of wisdom now that you're a high-level, high-ranking, state, important, official-type person?

1:50:56 Words of wisdom. That seems like a lot of pressure. No, I just say that it's exciting. It's been a really great run with our current board, and I'm excited to see what we can come up with. Yeah. Could I say something since it is my last meeting? Well, of course. It's expected. Eight years. I mean, thinking, really, it's great.

1:51:27 Maybe Bob Gardner's out there somewhere. He came on a couple of years later, but the four of us really, you know, I feel like in the last eight years, we set an intention from the get-go, like, hey, let's make ESCOG do something, you know, let's turn this into, you know, something that really is addressing the big issues of our region. So I'm really proud to have, now we're going to like start crying. Oh, shedding tears over the ESCOG.

1:51:57 Say goodbye to everyone. I'm not really saying goodbye, but just because it is the four of you, the three of you, the four of us. I mean, it really is gratifying to look back and think, you know what? The airport. Yeah. Yeah. No. We had an ice summit. You missed that one. It was fun. What was the ice summit? Oh, thank you. Remember the ice summit about the airport? Like, we've got to do something. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yes. Rock. Yes. Yes. I was not there.

1:52:26 No, you missed that one. That was up Rock Creek. Yeah. On Rock Creek, yeah. On the county line. Yeah, that's right. We all met on the county line. But I think it just, you know, not that anybody on a future ESCOG or governing body is listening, but the way, you know, approaching something really...

1:52:51 Systematically, you know, look at what are we now? What do we want to try to do? Getting the facilitation help to figure that out, which I really hope you guys, that this body does engage in something like that in 2023. And then, and figuring out the ways to do it and not kind of letting it be beyond personalities, beyond current configuration, tying it back to

1:53:18 So what we really, what's our vision for this place and what we want to do and just insisting that we work regionally with, of course, Mr. Gardner's famous saying, we're a region, damn it, but the ESCOG has really proven that out. So I look forward to working with you all in a different capacity, but yeah. What Stacey just said is really important.

1:53:43 Because, you know, people don't want to talk about institutional knowledge. They don't want to talk about history. They don't talk about where things came from and what they did. But you said it. I mean, we all got together and we've driven this thing forward. Yes. And there's staff. There's lawyers. Oh, my goodness gracious me. There's going to be a new website? You're kidding me. Robin, you know, Robin did. There's going to be a toilet?

1:54:14 No, no, she won't be offended. I was like, Robin, just download WordPress and just put some stuff up there, and she did it. No, Robin was great. But I think it would be a good idea. Now, at our next meeting, counselor, do we do a transition from the old board to the new one? I would like to do that. I would like to do that. And I would like whatever the configuration, whoever is on or off, to stay to your point. I mean, there is some continuity at this point that needs to be acknowledged and respected.

1:54:55 And I think that would be, if you're willing to, I mean, we know you're not going to be back, Linda, but if you're willing to come back. Yeah, but whatever. Yeah, and to come back and to say, look, there's a very specific, unique charge to the folks that serve on this thing. And to remind us and to keep that continuity going of the purpose of the value of what we're doing, because it is extremely important. I was just thinking a little while ago, when you're talking all these surf questions.

1:55:23 What if we weren't here? I mean, what if there wasn't something like this to do this and crazy comes at us and we'll disappear back into our corners? Well, I don't know. Don't bother me with this stuff. Yeah, I know. For something like CERF, it would be really challenging because if there weren't a council of governments that functions differently than councils of governments do in different areas, although it's my understanding, I think, on the west side, they don't have even a COG.

1:55:53 Well, Kern's got a card. But they're not in our search region. Oh, no, exactly right. Yeah. That it would be harder because then it's sort of like, okay, who's going to play that role? And if it's a government agency, the fear is, oh, you're looking out for your interests and not our collective interests. But now we, because we have ESCOG positioned to take this on. And yet another piece of that is with all this money that's in the state that's trying to get to the ground,

1:56:24 The fact that we're organized in some way that we can speak on behalf of four, you know, four significant agencies in the region to say, look, you want nature-based solutions, we can get you nature-based solutions, but you, you know, you gotta, and we've got, we can process money, we can, we can process funds, you know, we can, we can do those kinds of things. We can try to process money. We can tell someone we can process money and we'll figure it out later. Yeah, 27 million, no problem, just send it over.

1:56:53 Well, I think for Bishop, being a part of ESCOG has been huge, because normally, I think before I came on the council, Bishop didn't see, at least from my perspective, I could be wrong, they didn't see much purpose in the participation in the greater region. They just kind of looked at themselves as, you know, a community that's two square miles, and why do we need to worry about what's going on in Mammoth, you know, and I think being part of this has been...

1:57:18 Really valuable for us, especially with the airport. Yeah, you got an airport. It's been pretty huge. Yeah, an airport with the new planes. Or access to, you know, what, you know, I mean, just the fact that, like, John Urdi and Justin talk, I mean, that is phenomenal. And that's the stuff we need to be facilitating. Yeah, and that, I mean, I give ESCOG credit for a lot of that. Yeah. Going through that process, identify that as the priority, so, you know. And there was some resistance.

1:57:48 There was a lot of resistance. Bring it on. Yeah, there was, but that was all right. Okay, well, thank you, Stacey, very much for that. Yes. Really appreciate that. Jeff, are you there? Are you frozen? Your eyes are blanking. Oh, you're looking at your phone. Okay, there. He's multi-tapped, as we all get so good at these, unfortunately. Okay, well, is there anything else, or do you want to? But I, so I guess we'll, we never convene, so we won't, I guess we can say goodbye.

1:58:19 But I think, Elaine, let's talk about that meeting in January that would be set the schedule, but bring ESCOG members and do a handoff, do a sort of a continuity conversation. Thank you, guys. Thanks for your patience with your wacky, lagging electeds. Jeff, good luck with the phone. Jeff, when are you back? Erica was here. She's the project manager. Okay. I'm off the blazer. Yeah. Okay.

1:58:52 And so my role, I think, is just going to be making sure we're connecting the dots and getting people there and going to the meetings and doing all the technical right. I mean, there's so much to the, like, forming this High Road Collaborative. The name alone. Okay, let's turn on. Okay, we're going to adjourn. When you get back, let's get together, shall we? I'm back on Monday.

1:59:23 Okay, good. I look forward to, are you going to be going? Yeah, you're back on Monday. Okay, great. We'll see you. Thank you. We're going to adjourn. Bye, guys. Happy holidays. I'm turning off Zoom now. Thanks, Angie. Thank you. Bye, Bob. Bye, everybody.