TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2022

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

247 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:14 I will let my colleagues know that you do need to make sure that you activate your microphone. There's a little button right there that says push. So good morning. Let's call this regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to order for Friday, October 14th, 8.33 a.m. And with that, if you could call the roll, please, Angie. Council Member Wentworth? Present. Supervisor Totharo is absent. Council Member Schwartz?

1:45 Here. Supervisor Corliss. Here. Supervisor Gardner. Here. Supervisor Griffiths. Here. Councilmember Ellis. I believe it's absent. Councilmember Salcedo. Here. I think we're good. Good. Thank you. So we have a quorum. We're all in business. Destin, I'm wondering if you would mind leaning into the Pledge of Allegiance. It's the price you have to pay for coming up the hill. Thank you very much. To the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic.

2:30 Thank you. Angie, any public comments that you have in the virtual environment? I don't see any public commenters here in Suite Z. No comments at this time. Okay, thank you. We're going to move on now to the consent agenda.

2:55 Where we will approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 12th, 2022. Approve the minutes of the special meeting of September 9th, 2022. Approve the minutes of the special meeting of October 7th, 2022. Also consider approving a letter of support for the Whitebark Institute grant application to the Wildfire Covering Forest Resilience Directed Grant Program. And we will consider a resolution of the Board of Directors of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments.

3:23 Regarding the need for continued virtual meetings to protect public health, AB 361. Does anybody wish to pull any of these items? No, but I would make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Okay, let me just check. Does anybody out there in the virtual universe want to pull any of these items? No, they do not. Thank you. I'm sorry, Supervisor Quillis. I believe I heard a motion. Is that correct? Yes. And we have a second. Okay, any additional discussion?

3:49 Not hearing any. Angie, please call the roll on this item for the approval of the consent agenda. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. And Council Member Salcido? Yes. Thank you. So we've unanimously approved the consent agenda. I just want to make a comment on what a handsome sweater Supervisor Griffiths is sporting this morning.

4:18 Well done. Yeah, yeah, are we fishing? Are we, no, we're, okay. We will now move on to our policy matters, and we'll start with item 5.1, Executive Director Update on ESCOG Community Economic Resilience Fund Pilot Program. Elaine. Good morning, board. It's very nice to be able to join you this morning in Mammoth.

4:46 I wanted to provide you an update on the Community Economic Resilience Fund pilot program. At our August meeting, your board approved a resolution and gave direction to staff to go to our member agencies to seek approval for enacting this new program of work that will allow for ESCOG to participate in phase one of the surf planning program. And we received a unanimous approval at all four of the member agencies. So that program is now enacted.

5:16 With regards to initiating the work, we haven't heard an official award. We do know that the Sierra Business Council was the only applicant to serve as the convener for the Eastern Sierra sub-region.

5:33 While we anticipate the state making their announcement of who the conveners will be across all 13 regions, I think that pushes the timeline for kickoff and implementation into January of next year. I'm happy to take additional questions on this item. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions for Elaine or for Grace? Grace, I guess, Elaine, do we have to do anything? Or is the program now in effect? Any action we have to take? So it is now in effect.

6:02 We did things a little differently than our previous programs of work. This time, the ESCOG approved a resolution, and then we went out to all four member agencies. I think our previous program of work was the other way around. We went to all four member agencies first, and then ESCOG approved. But it can go in either direction, and we are now all done. Great. So, well, congratulations to all the ESCOG members. We now have a Community Economic Resiliency Fund pilot program. So, thank you, Elaine, for all your work, and you, Grace, as well.

6:32 So, good. On we go. So, next, we're going to move on now to receive a presentation from Nick Wilbrook, Chief Operations Officer at Blue Forest Conservation. Nick, we can see you, and we can also see Annapurna. So, hope that everything's good on your end. So, good morning, welcome, and we look forward to your presentation. Thank you. Thank you, ESCOG. Thank you, Council Member Wentworth. Thank you, all members and elected officials. It's a real privilege to present and share a bit about Blue Forest today.

7:04 And our hope to collaborate and support your vision for regional resiliency. About to share a few slides. So one moment here. Can everyone see the slides at present? Yes, we can. Thank you. This is going to be fantastic. Well, I've been instructed, and it's quite a privilege, but been instructed to 10 minutes. So we have roughly 10 slides. And that might leave some time for questions then as well.

7:35 Apologies for moving through some of this quickly. There's no doubt going to be some questions, and those are really welcomed. My name is Nick Wolbrock. I'm a Chief Operating Officer and Co-Founder of Blue Forest Conservation, joined by Annapurna Holtzapil. Annapurna, do you want to introduce yourself? Sure. Thank you, Nick, and thank you, everyone. It's really great to be here. My name is Annapurna Holtzapil. I'm a Project Analyst at Blue Forest. My background is in fire ecology, and I'm excited about this.

8:06 Great. Thank you, Manapurna. So without further ado, I wanted to share a little bit. Blue Forest is a 501c3 nonprofit. We're a little over 20 employees. We have MOUs with the Forest Service on a national level. We were actually approached by the Inyo National Forest to help consider how might there be alternative and innovative funding approaches to try and achieve landscape resilience. But what we're going to present a bit today is not just a model that might support forest restoration.

8:35 But really could be a model to support regional collaboration and resilience projects extending infrastructure finance to natural infrastructure. This could be a host of benefits, resilience to wildfire and climate change, but also resilience and opportunity for economic development with respect to recreation and other project visions that you all have. Blue Forest doesn't plan projects, but we look to help support projects that the local leadership

9:05 and that local social license direct. A little bit about why are we talking about financing ecosystem resilience? So again, Blue Forest is a non-profit, but we're talking about conservation finance, and that's a unique, innovative model in some ways. It's also sort of a boring model in other ways, too. If we think about, well, we use finance every day.

9:29 We use it to be able to extend home ownership opportunities. We use it for building out our built infrastructure as well. Without some of those financial tools, we wouldn't have the amazing infrastructure that we enjoy in the US. But for far too often, we haven't used those tools to try and extend towards climate resilience and natural resource protection and economic development from a natural sense. So part of Blue Forest's mission

9:59 is to help extend infrastructure financing to natural infrastructure. We think that can help enable and accelerate the pace of restoration and resilience and provide a host of community benefits along the way and be economically viable and attractive for all parties that participate. So what do we mean about that in part? Well, Blue Forest, we work with a lot of economists, we have a lot of academic groups, and together ourselves, we're financial professionals, foresters, scientists.

10:28 We're an interdisciplinary group that likes to look at the multiple benefits of restoration. Many things that you all are more familiar with than anyone as well with respect to the resilient needs in your landscape. Restoration of watersheds, for example, reduces wildfire severity, can help maintain carbon stability, protect water quality, enhance water quantity, provide recreational benefits, reduce flooding risk.

10:57 And more, protect habitat, all sorts of opportunities. And again, Blue Forest doesn't plan projects, but we look to support the projects that others have planned and to highlight many of the co-benefits that restoration would provide. Conservation finance, in many ways, it's not new. It's just extending a tool that we already have to protect natural resources and achieve landscape resilience.

11:26 So the goals of Conservation Finance are to accelerate the scale of restoration projects. I think that can happen by having more capital up front so that local contractors can be paid very promptly, can accelerate their work, can have confidence and reliability on their cash flow and payment. We think it can also facilitate collaboration on a landscape scale because it can help support weaving different public funds, local funds, federal funds.

11:56 All together, where each of those funding sources have different legal authorities, different constraints, but by having a financed opportunity with ultra low, in fact, below market interest rates, can actually help support different cash flow reimbursements coming in at different timescales, when, while that's all necessary and important, doing more work now and faster is going to provide tremendous returns to the community and to achieving resilience goals.

12:26 Conservation Finance supports a regional collaboration vision and work across boundaries and management ownership and management jurisdictions, facilitates collaboration amongst many different funding sources. It exists really to support that landscape scale type of vision and it can support many different types of projects. We're going to present one that was presented to us.

12:52 But it's by no means exclusive to is that why Blue Forest is here. We want to see resilience and investment increased according to the vision that is local and according to the vision of what could be achieved at scale. It's a unique model that can support many projects. Importantly, too, when I look at infrastructure projects, that supports local economies and jobs.

13:17 And I also like to think of infrastructure should be natural infrastructure as well, all of the ecosystem services and benefits. So in part, how do we achieve connecting, making something look like a bond or look like a loan or look like a financial opportunity for investment? And when we talk about investors, we're trying to think about the same type of investor that would be investing in a bridge expansion or a school district expansion or for facilities.

13:45 They're not hedge funds, they're not venture capital. These are fixed income investors like a pension fund, as well as like foundations that like to put on their investment hat and provide money to communities for projects that are going to have multiple public benefits. So to connect investment capital to good projects, so connecting the right to the left, when we think about good projects and programs of work, we think about what are the ecosystem services, both social

14:14 and environmental, that that project would help confer to the community and outside of the community as well. Regional, as we all know, as someone who's personally enjoyed recreating around the town of Mammoth Lakes, and while I live in Oakland, your region is very important to me and has been a part of time that my wife and I have really enjoyed. So finding a regional connection for that benefit is

14:42 is very clear and very easy to make, and that part of that is recreation, but it's also wildfire risk resilience, water quality, the types of benefits that an insurance company or a collection of insurance companies might appreciate, or water quality and water quantity benefits, and recreation benefits, those are all of economic significance. So to create a resilience bond, we as partners of a consortium, ideally,

15:08 We'll help evaluate what those benefits would be, not just environmentally and socially, but what's the financial value of some of those benefits, both in risk reduction and revenue enhancement. We help develop the agreements and contracts that would allow for contributing funds and resources towards those projects that would help reimburse or repay investors who provide the capital up front. And when we can put that together, we can attract investor outside investment capital at low

15:38 Fixed Income Rates that almost looks no more complicated than a mortgage, for example, that could bring more resources forward and then have a path for repayment and reimbursement over time. We'll explain a little bit more how that works. Graphically, we're talking about after a project has been planned and permitted, and again, Blue Forest does not plan or permit that, so rest assured, we're not going to say do this, don't do that. We're going to follow your lead and the lead of the collaboration and consortium you're a part of.

16:09 But when a project has been planned, we help raise outside investment to capitalize the implementation of a project through implementation partners that could be trusted nonprofit partners, indigenous communities, local governments that all have authority and permission from the land managers to take on that restoration work. And that can all be made possible because of contracts and agreements that beneficiaries on a local

16:39 Regional and Federal level have all signed through their existing legal authorities or through innovative contracts that we've developed to repay and reimburse that forest resilience bond and then reimburse investors. But it starts with your project vision and why we're so excited in part and also see such a tremendous opportunity is because there is a landscape scale project that you are all a part of.

17:08 The planning and vision for 55, 56,000 acres of restoration work around the town of Mammoth Lakes is immense. I mean, that would be innovative on a national level. Estimated costs until contracts and bids are conferred, it's unclear, but it's going to be in the many, many, potentially $100 million or more with a large funding gap to date. And so finding

17:36 a novel way to attract capital to implement that restoration is going to be fairly helpful to achieve success. Now, again, this was a project that was presented, in fact, the Inyo National Forest said, hey, could you think about how we might approach this? Blue Forest by no means is exclusively interested only in this work. If there are other opportunities in the ESCOG region, we think this funding mechanism could help support those as well, and we welcome that.

18:05 Just a couple more slides to share. Blue Forest has a track record working with the North Yuba Forest Partnership. In fact, we started before the North Yuba Forest Partnership existed with the Yuba Pilot Forest Resilience Bond. Part of how we put that together, it's in the upper right, the Forest Service said we have a project that's unfunded and we're not sure how it's going to be funded or if there's resources to do it. It was protecting 15,000 acres and

18:35 It had an estimated cost of a little over $4 million after all of the NEPA and project planning. Part of Blue Forest's engagement was to model some of the environmental benefits that would come from that work. And then we approached the Yuba Water Agency collectively with the Sierra Nevada Research Institute, the World Resources Institute, the National Forest Foundation, in that case was the trusted implementation entity of the Tahoe National Forest. That could be different elsewhere, it could be the same.

19:04 We approached the Yuba Water Agency with an economic case on how a long-term yearly payment contract from them would both help fund some of the project work on the ground and help support some of the interest on the investment so that we could leverage public funding that was available but not complete to support the full implementation of the project and certainly couldn't be accelerated or advanced beyond invoicing as project work was completed.

19:32 From implementing that work, actually two years into a four-year project, the Yuba Water Agency said, wow, that was easier than we had expected. How can we protect the whole watershed? And the North Yuba Forest Partnership was supported by that interest, the Nature Conservancy, a handful of parties who signed an MOU, and we're underway now with the second forest resilience bond project, which gratefully is much larger than the first one.

20:01 But we have more to do. So this is a platform for how can we accelerate that restoration work. We'd like to bring that and support your vision for how landscape scale restoration of a host of projects could be achieved in your region. I'll just end with this quote here, then we'll look for some questions if there's any. The local district ranger said, typically a large restoration project such as Yuba would take over 10 years if ever fully implemented. Instead, we will complete it within four years.

20:31 This means a healthier, more resilient forest before insects disease or wildfire would negate our planning and before our communities are adversely impacted. And we couldn't agree more. Accelerating this work and finding ways to pay for it, I think is perfectly aligned with what we've heard from the consortium working on the donut or the ESCCRP project and your vision in how that might be achieved. Thank you very much for the time to present. We look forward to answering questions now and sharing these slides if they can be helpful later.

21:01 Thank you. Nick, thank you very much. Very much appreciated a tailored presentation to this body, and I think we're all very interested in the work you're doing and the opportunities that might be in front of us. So I'm going to look at my colleagues here. Who's got an insightful, probing, regionally specific question for Nick and the Blue Forest team? Okay, fine, go ahead. Thank you. Good morning, Nick, and thank you for your presentation. I find myself a little bit...

21:33 Behind the knowledge curve here because there was nothing in our packet about this. So the background you gave us, the information was useful, but I have some questions that are probably beyond what we want to talk about here even. Can we make sure that we have your contact information so that I could reach out to you? Would you be open to a conversation such as that? I would be thrilled for that opportunity. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, of course. Thanks.

22:02 I saw this presentation as part of the ESCCRP Financial Advisory Committee. So a little more familiar with it. But one suggestion, not really a question. Thank you for this. I think there are a lot of unknowns with something like this. Who would the investors be? Could you bring, for instance, LADWP on board with a model like this? We probably need to.

22:31 But I think having the wonderful example of the North Yuba Partnership at the recent Wildfire Task Force meeting, there was a presentation on how that project got planned, and now we are learning more about how it's being funded. I would suggest if we really want to dig in and maybe get to some of your questions offline or even...

22:54 At some point, if we form a, I probably won't be here, so if you all form a committee of some kind, you know, maybe, or have ESCOG represented at the ESCCRP Finance Committee, involve the North Yuba Water Agency, which is also the Yuba County Board of Supervisors. I have some great contacts on that board. And I think, kind of from, and Jeff made two, you know, just from

23:19 Super, you know, kind of local elected official to local elected official. I think it would be really interesting to hear their side of the story. Haven't heard that yet. You know, heard at the task force, we heard from the forest supervisor. And so it's, you know, Forest Service is fully on board with it. But what, how does this work from a local elected stance? And, you know, how did they, am I correct, Nick, in thinking in North Yuba, you have an ag end user as an investor, right? Like an almond?

23:49 There are, there are, Silk, Danone is now a payer. We, yeah, great, great questions. We'd love to, the Yuba Water Agency made up of Yuba County elected officials have been just, that's a great connection. We'd love to facilitate or support, encourage that discussion. We've learned a lot from working with them and it's been really joyful. So, but yeah, there's many payers. I will add,

24:20 As you mentioned, who might be investors and who might be payers. As a finance entity, I'll just share, I cut out quite a bit out of necessity for time and have a much longer presentation we can share with more of those details and also just in conversation. The investment for the first project was AAA of California, the insurance company. They said, hey, we have wildfire risk exposure sometimes and we're interested in this.

24:47 They were an investor, not a payer for the work, but they said, we're going to put our money in and want our money back, plus that 4% interest in their case. The same with Calvert's impact capital. These were market rates at the time in part. And we blended that with foundations, which were the Rockefeller Foundation and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, who were receiving 1% interest rate returns. And they each put an equal amount, so there was a 2.5% interest rate.

25:16 We even used something called a delayed drop term loan, so the effective interest rate was even lower than all of that. And it was repaid by multiple sources, reimbursements from federal funds, from state CCI grant money, which is sometimes hard to get out the door. And then Yuba Water Agency made a million and a half dollar commitment towards that $4 million project. The second project, they made a $6 million commitment.

25:42 Some of the niceties of this type of engagement I think the Yuba Water Agency particularly appreciated was their contract was 22 pages, so pretty short. The latter 10 were all just sort of risk clauses. And they have a contract now to say if the work deviates or isn't up to what was contractually agreed towards.

26:05 They have a reason to say, we're holding off on payment. So the true public-private partnership that can work really well is when we shift risk to investors. Not shift risk to the public sector, but have the investors sort of game in ways, but actually shift risk to the private sector and have the public be able to achieve some efficiencies from that type of arrangement. So happy to share more. We have pro bono attorneys.

26:31 who help us develop the agreements and contracts. There's a lot more resources that can come into this that we could describe in more detail. Can I backtrack a little bit and just get some context of how we're here having a conversation? Was it the Forest Service that reached out to your organization based on this pace and accelerator project to make it go faster?

27:00 I'll share a little bit locally. So this is coming out of this Mammoth Donut Project. Yes. And Blue Forest is a likely contributor partner to help with that project. Because the grant isn't enough money or we just want it to get done faster? Exactly. The number to keep in mind here is $150 million. Okay. And the grant money that's come in so far is...

27:25 Elaine can speak to that a little bit, but what the grant that we've got so far, again, Elaine can speak to this, is do the environmental work, all the NEPA work necessary to make the project go forward, but then to actually do the work on the ground. We don't have the money for it. Yeah, that's when we get into the hundreds of millions, and now we're trying to figure out how do we finance this thing. So, Elaine, I'm sure you've got something to add. I do. Thank you very much, Chair, and my apologies, Marisol Cedo, that I didn't provide a little bit more context in the staff report for you.

27:53 So as Mr. Wentworth described, the grant that we have now is for the environmental planning, which will enable the project to be implemented in the future and for the landscape restoration to occur. And there is not funding in place at this time to implement that body of work. And the Inyo National Forest created an introduction between Blue Forest and their innovative finance model.

28:21 with Whitebark Institute and other partners who will be working on implementing the Donut Project. I don't know necessarily that I've had a few conversations with Blue Forest, and I don't know necessarily that that will be facilitated or transacted through the ESCOG at all, but I did ask Blue Forest to come today and provide an informational presentation to your board since, one, we are

28:46 Currently administering funding for the NEPA Donut Project, so we're certainly interfacing with that project on some level and want to be engaged with its successful implementation. Secondly, because as provided in this presentation, I think this innovative finance model for funding both forest restoration projects as well as other infrastructure projects that we're looking at through the SHRIMP program throughout the forest

29:15 It's certainly novel to me. And so if you if it feels like a lot coming at she really fast, that's because it's it is I think it's a completely novel program. And so wanted your board to sort of be aware that that model is out there in this Blue Forest isn't the the only organization who's looking at these types of new models for financing work on federal lands in our region.

29:42 And then thirdly, and maybe Annick and Annapurna can speak to this a little bit, I think that the scope of implementation of the project and the budget that is going to be required for doing it will have interesting implications as Blue Forest is identifying different payers for that program who will be paying back those initial investors.

30:06 And I thought it was important to bring to this regional body's attention who some of those potential payers would be. And so that you are aware, as we all have relationships with state and federal and other municipal agencies in the region, that those conversations would be happening. No, I appreciate that. And I think for myself as an elected official,

30:32 I would like to be able to coherently explain this to someone who asked me a question about it, and right now my level of information and knowledge of this would be to say it's a magical financing arrangement that will provide funding to do this really important work, and I'd like to understand it at a deeper level than that. So thank you for this, and I look forward to a conversation. Yeah, and I think one thing that's helpful to understand for all of us is Nick mentioned the Yuba, and Stacey mentioned the Yuba

31:02 County Board of Supervisors. In that area, the governance was pretty clear. You had a water agency, a board of supervisors, Forest Service, the party. The same agency, it's one at the same town. Exactly. It was all, everybody stood in one house. I think one of the work that Whitebark is doing, and this is meeting, and Stacy and I went to for the Finance Committee, is assembling the governance, assembling the partners who have an interest in doing this work on the donut project. Things like Mammoth Resorts, things like the town of Mammoth Lakes.

31:30 How are we going to assemble the various partners here to figure out if we're going to engage with something like this, which is going to help bring the money in to get the project? But I think it's fair to say we're not quite at that point yet where we know exactly who the players are going to be. That's good to start setting the stage for that so that we have an index forward so this was definitely a block. Exactly, yeah. That's kind of where we're at. Does that sound about right? Okay, any additional questions? Nick, any comments? Thank you. I love all of those questions. I might even add...

32:01 How we approached the Yuba Water Agency was Supervisor Randy Fletcher saw us present at a Sierra Nevada Conservancy meeting, and he said, could you come and share this with us? So local leadership is absolutely essential for comfort and for introductions and for exploring how this model can work.

32:27 I'll only add, and there's a lot more detail to share, there's a lot of guardrails on governance, and while we have a great template, and it's been proven to replicate, we're also mission-oriented, where however this can be modified, if that adds comfort, transparency, clarity, we're a non-profit wanting to see landscape scale achieved, and truly believe finding more ways to direct those resources to achieve resilience is going to be a fundamental to success.

32:57 Even in the light of a lot of grant programs from, and folks might say, well, with a lot of grants, why might we need to finance this? Grants are hard to get out the door, partly because implementers don't have the working capital in hand to say, oh, I have a $5 million award. It's hard to go do $5 million worth of work.

33:17 Pay contractors promptly and all sorts of things. So by financing aspects of much of this, it can really accelerate getting that money out the door. So this is truly sort of a blending and public-private partnership type of approach that can be a win-win-win across the board when there's good projects. And I think we have a really good project that you've all envisioned. So thank you. And I see a question from Bob Gardner. Angie, is there a question from Bob Gardner?

33:46 Yes, there is. Yes, there is. And I apologize. I'm sort of juggling here. I'm sitting in the parking lot of the Double Eagle while they're replacing the poles behind our house and they kicked us out of our house. So I'm juggling things and keeping my video off so that I can keep my internet going. Anyway, is it safe to simplify this and say this is like a municipal bond where investors invest, get a rate of return, and good things happen with the use of the money that investors...

34:15 Invest in. Is that too much of a simplification just for a different purpose? It's perfect, except I'm going to give two value adds on that. At least in the case of the forest resilience bonds we've done, it's as simple as a municipal bond, but even simpler. There was no municipal issuance. There was no tax lien put on properties or assessed on property taxes. We set up a private placement loan.

34:43 And through loan agreements, have it paid back. But it is as simple. So it's even, it's not a multiple hundred page municipal offering. It's a series of contracts that are all less than 25 pages each, pretty clear. And it's just loans paying back something like this. So even simpler is what I want to say. But yes, it's a fixed, it's a stated fixed return. There is opportunity for complexity. So if an insurance, a consortium of insurance companies say, look,

35:12 We get that reducing wildfire risk is going to let us avoid cancellations or might save us money in future payouts. We like what you guys are trying, all of you, but unless you can truly lower our fire score, we're not going to pay as much. And we can say, okay, we hear you. Can we shift that risk to lenders and not for the Forest Service or the state contracts, but for some insurance contributions actually have their payments?

35:41 Tied to a measurable outcome, like lowering a FIRE score. That is the type of flexibility and complexity that isn't like a municipal bond, and I hesitate to add that opportunity, but that actually might be what's a necessary level of detail from a payer's standpoint if they were to contemplate contributing from their perspective. And we handle all of that. It's all public, and the lenders, the investors, take on that risk.

36:09 It's sort of of no risk to any other party in that mix that makes a case. So I see another question. Yeah, thanks. So do you have to have all of the payers known before you are able to complete the process? We don't. The more the better. We have to have repayment identified to be able to access the committed capital.

36:40 The case of getting Danone and Silk, the almond milk brand, to support the Yuba 2 project, the Yuba 2 project was already under contract, but not fully envisioned on how it would be funded for it to start. So phasing that type of implementation is possible based on known resources. It is helpful if we can have a handful of contingent contributions.

37:09 committed, saying, okay, I get it's $100 million, but we want to take a $20 million bite off of that, and we have some money, we have a few million we could commit spread out over the next 10 years. Our commitment is contingent on finding those other contributions at some leverage that is necessary. That also helps us go to those other parties and say, look, this is also in your interest for wildfire risk reduction. We can't

37:38 collectively access that other contingent money unless you put in. In effect, it's almost like a fundraiser where everyone's trying to make sure we fill that thermometer to get to the whatever is necessary to build the wing on the church or in the school and doesn't make sense to start. We can break that up into phases. But making a compelling economic case to beneficiaries is really essential for that. So thank you. Great. Thank you.

38:10 Good. Yes, Elaine. Thank you. Nick, could you also maybe talk a little bit about some of the payers that would be repaying that investment that you think is appropriate for this region? Absolutely. Thank you. So now, with only hesitation, if I mention potential types of payers, there's no commitments yet?

38:35 And there wouldn't be a commitment until there is a commitment. In fact, this type of mechanism is a way to explore, is there an economic case for their participation in a way that doesn't have them committed yet? I think that actually allows for that exploration of might it be committing or might it be compelling to contribute. When thinking about ski and recreation, large fires present a really big risk in having to be shut down.

39:05 Having to be shut down because of future hazard trees or loss of infrastructure. Now, I don't think the recreation industry in aggregate is going to be able to cover a $100 million project or $150 million project, but it certainly could be a small slice that helps cover the interest on financing some of the federal and state money and bring that forward. Additional payments, I mean, the NIFWF through the SCCRP also helped

39:35 fund an incredible type of environmental analysis that suggested, and I'll let them speak in more detail about it, but significant water quantity benefits from implementing this restoration work. Now, water quantity that flows downstream seems like a significant benefit to parties that are not immediately within the local watershed but are beneficiaries downstream.

40:02 Water quantity, water quality, wildfire risk reduction to infrastructure. So utilities are thought of for that as well. Insurance companies and the collection of insurance consortium, I'm not sure how we would get them in a room. And I think local leadership could provide tremendous value on strategizing how might we get three or four of the predominant insurers in the area in a room to say,

40:30 We think we have an offering that's going to be economically compelling to you all. How would they define success? Can we do that transparently and put that in a short contract and help get a commitment of some amount of money on a yearly basis that we could finance against now to do this work? Air quality and emissions, departments of transportation and other beneficiaries that others may think of

41:00 That we can collectively put an economic case together for with the World Resources Institute are all opportunities. Even carbon credits and biochar and biomass handling interests might be, you know, the one thing local infrastructure is looking for is a long-term supply of those slash piles or of that biomass. It's very hard to finance local infrastructure on a

41:29 Forest Management approach for the ecological restoration without some certainty that that ecological restoration is going to be implemented. So this is very much a part of a system that could also support workforce development, housing in the area from some of that biomass, from some of the system in place. So it's nascent. We are not leading that effort, but would want to help me.

41:57 Marketing any of the co-benefits from this work to beneficiaries who, if the project doesn't advance, we all miss out, including them as beneficiaries on what that risk reduction or revenue enhancement or ecosystem service would be if the project were implemented. And that's how we approach this. And Nick, I would add also both another payer or group that I think benefits from this work in this area is recreation.

42:28 And there's a lot of opportunity there. Apologies. Your connection is maybe going in and out a little bit, but I will echo that as well. Yeah, recreation benefits writ large, how to make that case of what would the loss to the economy in part or to those parties be if there was an unfortunate fire event as well. And none of this is for

43:00 Scaring or any of that respect. It's really to try and have what is the best available science, what does the fire risk mapping suggest, and how can we approach a party and say, yeah, we've been nervous about fire too. Okay, how can we evaluate not what the value, well, partly what would the value of that risk reduction be? Not so if one can be charged, hey, that was worth a buck, you're paying a buck. The whole goal here is how can a dime of prevention be worth a pound, a dollar of cure in the future?

43:29 In that avoidance of that dollar of restoration work or recovery work that might be required. And so we welcome that. I know some of that was a little more brainstorming and not as tight as the presentation might have been as well. But thank you for entertaining some of those answers. No, of course. And I think, yeah, go ahead. Thank you. I just wanted to add also to alleviate maybe any anxieties about commitments.

44:00 Blue Forest has been, since their introduction to the international forest to the ESCCRP project, extremely diligent in laying the groundwork for just doing introductions to the stakeholders and being very transparent in providing information about this. So again, the item today is informational and largely an introduction. So I would be very, very happy to put you in touch directly with

44:28 with Nick and Annapurna for additional information. Thank you. Yeah, so this is an introduction. Nick, thank you very much. Thank you, Annapurna. It's an introduction to the types of, these are the types of solutions when we're engaging the types of challenges we have locally as a region. This is the kind of stuff we're going to be dealing with. Yeah, go ahead, Nick. One last thought. One last thought. Thank you, council members. I would say Blue Forest.

44:56 has our own funding to do this work, by the way, as a nonprofit. So we're, this is, there's no pitch for a contract or anything like that. And I'd also say, we're not local. We never will be the owners, motivators of the important relationships that are local. Any asks to beneficiaries would first be through talking to you all about how might there be an introduction? Can we go together? What information would help you?

45:25 make that ask or someone at the ES, a member of the ESCCRP. So I want to alleviate any hesitation that we're coming in and saying, who has money, where is it going and all of that. This is a slower process and we are supportive in the background. So thank you very much. Good. Okay, thank you. Well, good. Thank you all very much. This is interesting and this is some of the things we have to look forward to. So thank you all.

45:51 So let's move on then, if we could, to item 5.3, to approve an agreement between Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and Alta Planning and Design for the provision of trails planning services for the Eastern Sierra Towns to Trails Plan. This is a project that came out of the ESSRP and the SNC. I'm going to accuse myself from this item. I serve on the board of MLTPA, which is partnering with Alta on this. So I'm going to go into a little room over there, and someone will let me know I'm free to return. Karen, are you running the meeting?

46:23 So Elaine asked me to lead this. I don't need to if somebody there is all excited about it. But why don't you go ahead and introduce the item, Elaine. Good morning, Mr. Griffith. Thank you for the introduction.

46:45 As described, this item is to approve an agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and ALTA Planning and Design for the provision of trails planning services for the Eastern Sierra Towns to Trails Project. At our August meeting, your board authorized staff to issue an RFP for this work. This is a planning project that's funded through a Sierra Nevada Conservancy Grant to develop a trails network.

47:12 of a soft surface infrastructure between northern Mono County and Lone Pine Elantia area. And the project will identify the existing infrastructure and then gaps to make it a trail network. One question that has come up, and so I'll just address it here, is whether that'll be a multi-use.

47:34 And I think that that's something that will be identified as part of the planning process is where there's segments that would be appropriate for multi-use. Staff noticed the request for proposals on August 18th for 30 days in the INU register and in the sheet, and we received one responsive proposal from Alta Planning and Design. The proposal met all the qualifications for the scope of work, and the cost proposal was within budget.

48:02 The budget amount for the planning work is $322,125, and the cost proposal coming in from Alta was $321,768, so they are within budget. I hope that you had an opportunity to maybe look through the proposal that was included in the agenda packet. Alta has demonstrated that they have extensive amount of relevant trails.

48:29 planning work that will be valuable to the project, as well as several projects that they have completed in the area locally, so they do have a relationship throughout the Eastern Sierra Region as well. At this time, staff would request that the ESCOG Board approve and authorize staff to execute an agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and Alta Planning and Design for the provision of trail planning services for the Towns to Trails Plan for an amount not to exceed

48:58 $321,768. I'm happy to take any questions you have on this item. Thank you. A question. When you say they're already present locally, what are they working on locally that we know about? They have worked on trails planning projects around the Mammoth Lakes area. They did a downtown plan for Elantia in anticipation of the 395 bypass that will move.

49:28 395 out of Olantia. And that re-envisions Olantia as a gateway community to Death Valley National Park and included trails planning and kiosks that would direct people from Olantia to the Owens Valley Dry Lake and other areas of interest, which was a very creative project that I really enjoyed. And then most recently, they developed the downtown-specific plan and mixed-use overlay for the city of Bishop.

49:57 So you worked with them? I have worked with them. I have worked with the project manager that's proposed for this project, as well as there's two main points of contact. I've worked with both of them, and I have found them to be absolutely excellent to work with, wonderful project management, extremely flexible, providing very high quality of work, and both of them are very invested in the Eastern Sierra.

50:24 and spend a great deal of time up here recreating. Thank you. That's what I picked up from the report here. Thank you. I have a few questions. They have on page 59, they talk about their on-the-ground pilot projects for implementation, but it didn't get into specifics of what that meant, like what would be an example of a pilot project that they would...

50:52 And I apologize, I don't have more detail on what on the ground means. I do know that one of the project managers in his resume, I saw that he has a prior experience in tactical urbanism, which is when you go in and you don't implement the project, but you sort of set it up so that the community and stakeholders could have a sense of what the project would look like and how it would work.

51:22 And then in the proposal, like in like the finals trail plan, are they going to provide a recommendation on who would manage this project, like who would be in charge of this project? Do they give us information on how it would be maintained? The plan will include information on maintenance and implementation because I think...

51:48 The plan will be identifying existing infrastructure, and then there are going to be gaps, and I think the next phase will, you know, in order to implement the project, will be identifying who responsible parties are. I don't think they specifically addressed ongoing maintenance within their RFP, but it's something that we can include with them as something we'd like to see in a delivery. Okay. And then, you know, it has here that MLTPA is partnering with them, but it doesn't talk about, like,

52:17 How they're partnering? How is MLTPA part of this project? I think that MLTPA is going to be providing a lot of on-the-ground support, doing a lot of the ground-truthing. So part of this will be a desktop analysis project of taking existing GIS information, which I think MLTPA has also included their GIS staff.

52:44 within their project team, so I think they'll be doing a lot of the GIS support, but then also being locally based, they will be doing the ground truthing so that you're not just looking on a map and thinking like, oh, it goes, it's 35 miles to Fresno, but then actually, you know, going out and seeing what the conditions of the proposed trail networks might be and what the infrastructure. So then does like MLTPA invoice also planning for their time? That's correct. Okay.

53:13 This planning, they would invoice them. And so it looks like a good number of staff from MLTPA are listed here and will be working with them, which is, you know, why John needs to accuse himself. That is true. And for the record, if you look in the cost proposal, it does include Councilman Wentworth as one of the staff people, it would be included, but with zero compensation.

53:43 Okay, yeah, that was one of my questions. He talks about a little bit here, but thank you. Okay, those are all my questions. I think it's a wonderfully laid out, comprehensive plan that they provided. I look forward to seeing it come to fruition. And you will be the primary contact for them, correct? That is correct. In kind of tracking their deliverables and all that within the tasks. What's the term again? Remind me what the term is.

54:16 It's December 31st, 2026. 20 what? 26. Okay, are there any more questions on this? Does someone care to make a motion? Make a motion that we approve the agreement between ESCOG and Alta Planning and Design for Trails Planning and Provision of Trails Planning. Second. Okay, motion is second. May we have the roll call vote, please? Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner?

55:02 Supervisor. Yes. Thank you. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. Council Member Salcedo. Yes. And Chair Wentworth has recused himself. Thank you. Great. Someone I want to tell John that he's allowed to come back in. Sorry, just cover. Yeah. It's a nice room. Any public comment? We have no public comments in person, written, or virtually. Thank you. It's sufficiently thick. It's nice.

56:20 All right, well, thank you very much. Who, did you leave that item? Jeff. Jeff, thank you very much. Appreciate that. So we're going to move on now to item 5.4 to approve the contract amendment number one to the agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Whitebark Institute of Interdisciplinary Environmental Services for the provision of National Environmental Policy Act services for the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator and

56:47 Approve contract amendment number one to the agreement between Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Whitebark Institute of Interdisciplinary Environmental Services for the provision of project management services for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator. We will certainly defer to staff on this. Elaine, thank you. Good morning again. Thank you. As Chair Wentworth introduced, staff is looking for your board to approve the first contract amendment between

57:17 for the two agreements we have between the ESCOG and the Whitebark Institute for implementation of the CDFW grant, both for the NEPA Environmental Planning Services, as well as for Project Management Services. In the original contract negotiations, we had agreed to provide that Whitebark would invoice the ESCOG

57:42 Thank you.

58:12 I also have one clerical item I would like to correct.

58:40 I'm happy to take questions on this item. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions for Elaine? Any questions? Bob, any questions? No, sir. Okay. Just an observation. I think this

59:13 Request to go from a monthly invoice, sorry, from a quarterly invoice to a monthly invoice is the kind of thing that Blue Forest is talking about. I think if you think of Blue Forest as being a facilitator of cash flow, because you start doing a $150 million project, you're talking on a monthly basis, a lot of money for contractors and things like that. So just an observation. So if there's no other questions for staff, certainly entertain a motion for this item. I'll move to approve the recommendation. I'll second. Thank you. We have a motion in a second.

59:48 Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. That's what happens when you get ignored. You think nobody cares. Is there any public comment, Angie, on this item, either virtually? I don't see anybody in person. No public comment at this time. Okay, thank you. Thanks for the reminder. I appreciate that. So we have a motion and a second, and absent any further discussion, Angie, if you could please call the roll on this question. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Excuse me, Council Member Schwartz?

1:00:17 Yes. Supervisor Corliss. Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. And Council Member Salcedo. Yes. Thank you. The item is approved unanimously. Thank you very much. Okay. On the move, item 5.5, receive an update on ESCOG staffing from staff and regional managers. Elaine. Good morning again. We've had, for the last couple of meetings, a discussion about

1:00:49 Transitioning to having full-time staff for the ESCOG. At the direction of your board, I've been in conversation with regional managers regarding the logistics largely of how to make that transition. At our August meeting, I presented a financial plan that indicated that through the existing grant sources we have, as well as the current member agency contributions, there's a sufficient budget

1:01:18 to accommodate a full-time executive director position. Since the August meeting, I've met with regional managers again. Inyo County has gained a new county administrative officer, Mr. Nate Greenberg, and we had a nice conversation to sit down and debrief on all of the ESCOG's activities as well as the board's direction to move towards having a full-time executive director.

1:01:48 In the conversations with the regional managers over the last couple of months, the tentative direction that seems to be best for accommodating that position is to house the position within one of the member agencies to accommodate all of the auxiliary requirements that come with a full-time position, such as benefits,

1:02:15 Professional Insurance. And then also to institutionalize the position and the ESCOG within an organization for sustainability. And within those conversations, largely what has been determined is that Inyo County is the best suited organization to be housing full-time ESCOG staff. So I've had that conversation with Mr. Greenberg. He's been very

1:02:44 Willing to work with us to sort the logistics out, obviously coming on board sort of in the middle of this bi-monthly meeting schedule. He has many other priorities he needs to be investing his time in. So that is one of the influencing factors on the timeline for implementing this plan. Also within that bi-monthly term.

1:03:12 The city of Bishop has advertised for a replacement associate planner or senior planner and unfortunately was not able to recruit a candidate to that position. I think it's important for me to be transparent that it would want to ensure Bishop's continued success in their community development department and so I have had conversations with the regional managers, the city administrator at Deshaun about

1:03:41 Transferring to the ESCOG, if you'll have me, as a full-time Executive Director in the future, but being available for the City of Bishop to continue to assist them with a successful transition with their staff as well. So between Mr. Greenberg coming on board, working with the City of Bishop to ensure that they have adequate staffing, and sorting through the logistics to create this position within Inyo County, it would look like the

1:04:11 Timeline for implementing a full-time Executive Director for ESCOG would be in January of 2023. So that's my update on the conversations that we've been having with the regional managers regarding ESCOG staffing. I'm happy to take questions and we're joined here today by all of the regional managers if you have specific questions for them as well. Thank you. Thank you very much. I think before we go into our questions, I think it would be great to hear from the managers. We have three of the four.

1:04:39 I don't know, Nate, if you want to go first, if you've been mentioned, Inyo County has been referred to several times in staff's update here. Sure, I'd be happy to yield to Destin, however, since he's in the room and, you know, he's going to be the one that is most directly impacted. I mean, I will just underscore everything that Elaine said. I mean, my number one concern through all of this is to not leave a hole in the city of Bishop and, you know, essentially in...

1:05:07 in light of just propping up ESCOG, and so I have been very careful to navigate that process, and I think I want to continue to honor and respect the need of the city to operate in the wake of Elaine making that transition. I'm happy to talk more about the absorption side of that, but Dustin, if you have anything you'd like to add before I go there, I'm happy to provide that opportunity. Thank you.

1:05:35 Yeah, good morning. So, yes, we've had a number of discussions about this, and it's not going very fast finding a planner. As we went through the process once unsuccessfully, I think Elaine and I are going to Monday, we've looked at some different job descriptions, maybe tone the job down a little bit. We were trying to find somebody the caliber of Elaine.

1:06:00 Obviously isn't going to happen right now in this environment of bringing people into the valley especially. So hopefully we can maybe find somebody that would be interested maybe right out of college with some interest and then as long as your board will allow it, you know, this probably won't happen, we'd be lucky if it was by January, but that we may be able to use some of Elaine's time going forward to just a day or two a week to be able to bring this person up to speed.

1:06:30 And I think all the managers were in agreement that that could work as long as it works for you all. Yeah, I think, obviously I don't want to speak for the board, but I think that certainly would be our intent and our desire. And I think we don't, as we all respond to opportunities that are sort of timely and once in a generation, we want to make sure we do this in the right way and not leave gaping voids and holes in places and cause consternation for all of our partner agencies.

1:07:00 Yeah, and we truly appreciate it. And believe me, I've tried how many times in the last month, Elaine, to just convince her, just stay with the city. You know, it was evident through our process that we have a job description that is very fitting to Elaine and what her capabilities and what she has. And we're not finding that person. We're not going to find Elaine again. So I've tried to keep her over here. I did want to...

1:07:29 Mess with the ESCOG, but at the same time, she's valuable, so you guys are lucky to get who you're getting. And we appreciate being able to work with everybody and bringing someone up to speed that hopefully she can have a great influence on. Yeah. We'll do everything we can to support that process. Thank you. It's in all of our interests. Yeah, sure. Absolutely support this and appreciate all the agencies, member agencies working together on it. Just a thought.

1:07:59 I think with Elaine hopefully soon moving into the role of Executive Director, but with her planning expertise and background, I know Mono County is struggling right now in community development capacity and is short-staffed. I just wonder if community development isn't an area that ESCOG might want to look at somehow sharing regional capacity since at least two of the four agencies seem to really be struggling in that room. Interesting idea.

1:08:31 I was having similar thoughts to that, Stacey, and I suppose that's worthy of future discussions. Yes, and I'm getting a spoiler alert, but in my report, I'm going to request or suggest that ESCOG do a planning process that might address that and other issues. No, and I think it's a timely thing for all of us to start talking about. We've been, in the country, we've been in this weird, unique...

1:09:02 Employment situation where it's been incredibly difficult for everybody to find employees. Who knows what's going to happen with interest rates and recessions and maybe that will change things. Who knows? But I think it's certainly a very good, important, timely discussion to start having to benefit all of us. Dan, anything you want to add? Or Nate, Mr. Greenberg, I'll go back to you if you have anything you want to add on this process. And again, the board is deferring and we are very appreciative of your time and your effort with all of this. And we are really looking to your

1:09:32 New leadership is how to best proceed. Yeah, thank you. Dan Holler, the town manager for Mammoth Lakes. As noted, we've had a lot of manager discussions on it. Several of us have had one-on-ones with Elaine as well. And I think we're looking for what is that best transitional path forward. We've had the discussions with Nate, with Porino County, too, looking at maybe providing some admin support or bringing out a part-time, a couple different ways to look at that, to be able to maximize Elaine's time.

1:10:01 On the ESCOG side, but also if there is additional time for transition with Bishop, that that worked as well. We have the same interest in all of us being successful, and frankly, I think the success in doing that adds credibility back to the work of any one partner kind of lagging behind other resources. I know on the planning side, I think all of us are stretched pretty tight from that perspective, and the last recruitment we did was difficult too. We ended up finding somebody, but it's definitely a competitive market out there.

1:10:35 So I think we're all on board with it from the manager level. I know CAO Lawton was on earlier, not sure if he's still on, but we had that discussion there as well in terms of how do we transition this forward and effective both through ESCOG. And again, we look at Bishop's success there as a success for the region. I think we're all moving that same direction and we'll be able to step in and help it. Thanks. So I have a nuts and bolts question. Would we then...

1:11:04 You know, in anticipation of the City of Bishop not having someone to replace Elaine, would then the City of Bishop enter a contract with ESCOG? It would probably be through, I'll speak, Nate can speak to it too, whether it be with ESCOG or whether it actually be with Inyo County. The structure we're looking at is to actually, Elaine would actually be an Inyo County employee. That's so we don't have to set up an HR department in ESCOG and other costs associated with that. Okay. And so it may be a contract back that way or it may just be a,

1:11:35 An agreement contract of the staff shared time. Got it. So we'll have to work through the nuts and bolts to that because same thing if we do some part-time support, is that build back like to grants primarily, those types of issues. Same thing with Elaine's time, we'll need to work through the financial elements there of how we're billing out time. ESCOG partners as well are gearing up, they're already into, but gearing up to get into even more of it to be able to support those. And so then would like the support

1:12:07 Support staff, like we had looked at in August, like having administrative assistant support Elaine and then the broadband consortium, would those all be Inyo County employees? At this point, Nate can speak to the broadband, they're absorbing that, that was always the plan all along to have that in there. The discussions we had is trying not to have ESCOG actually own full-time employees and others just because there's a whole other cost and liability related with it.

1:12:33 Right, right, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, at this point, we're looking at Inyo to be the primary location for those. Again, if there's capacity with existing staff or vacancies and things of that nature, we've had some discussions that way. Is there a way to leverage that? Similar like we're doing with Mammoth Lakes, providing clerking services. That's just an agreement about ESCOG and there's an offset of cost, but we provide all the other support, office, et cetera, equipment. Okay. It'd be similar to that.

1:13:04 Yes. There's also, I mean, this is a bit long, long into the future, but ESCO Sierra Planning would also have the ability to bring someone under that wing and then oversee that employee as they did work in the region also. That would be another. If I may just sort of add a few comments. I think that Dan, you know, highlighted it really well. I think Dustin sort of added some very

1:13:37 Salient comments. You know, just speaking to the HR and admin pieces for a moment, you know, Inyo County is prepared and willing to take on the HR aspect of housing this position, housing the Executive Director position as well as the admin assistant. I think there's a few just fairly perfunctory things that we need to work through here, namely, you know, modifying our

1:14:03 our workforce, you know, our allocation list effectively so that we can apply that position and make that higher, you know, a simple budget amendment and some things like that. Internally, I believe we're going to need to work out some of how the bill back, you know, since Mono County will remain the fiscal agent effectively for ESCOG and most of the grant revenue will be landing within that agency. We'll just need to deal with the billing across agencies to

1:14:30 I believe that with regard to the secondary position, you know, the admin assistant in a conversation recently with the four administrators and Elaine, Dan articulated that there may be value in actually bringing that other person on that was, I think, envisioned, you know, maybe a year out from now or six months out from now on sooner because it could help

1:14:59 alleviate some of those capacity concerns that we've been speaking to and provide a little bit of breathing room that if something did come up and the City of Bishop did need some support that there would be the ability for Elaine to sort of be leased back, if you will. So we have some ideas internally at Inyo for that. There's a few people that are kind of moving around a couple of different positions right now and we're waiting to see where the dust will settle and so we may actually have capacity on the team here already that could be.

1:15:28 You know, relevant or step into that role sooner than later. You know, it may be that we actually do do a recruitment. I think those are small details that I feel like we can probably work through with Elaine over the next few months. I think the idea about sharing services, if you will, and a regionalization approach is smart. Dustin and I have spoke about that. Dan and I have spoke about that. You know, I wasn't sure to what extent, you know, Mono County had an interest in that. I mean, it does seem like...

1:15:57 In the world of planning, there's sort of layers of work and need and responsibility. And I think first and foremost, the piece that is going to be missing from the city of Bishop is an actual body in the office for when somebody walks in off the street. Beyond that, I think at the other end of the continuum is a lot of the stuff that we're talking about and working on right now at an ESCOG level, which is far more strategic planning at a regional level. And clearly a lot of that work could be transitioned over and absorbed and it makes sense to continue.

1:16:26 to look in that direction. But I think it's kind of in the middle piece that we're struggling with and the actual physical bodies in an office that we're struggling a bit with. And I believe it all deserves some consideration and something that if we're all committed to, we can probably find a solution for in the next year or so. Okay. I think we have an agenda item coming up after this, which is connected to this.

1:16:52 The only other thing I would want to add is the Forest Service position through the Challenge Cost Share Agreement. I'm assuming that that is part of these discussions as well. Excuse me, that hasn't been part of these discussions. Okay. It's just something for the town manager for you guys to be aware of. There's a, Elaine could explain it all to you, but there's a body that's coming forward that's being funded through a Challenge Cost Share Agreement within your national forest that, Nate, as you're describing the various moving chairs that may be able to fit into this in a way that can help out with some of this stuff as well.

1:17:22 And so, again, thank you all very much for your attention to this. This is an ongoing effort. I think that once we get through the next couple months, get things kind of settled, we should be good, hopefully, for a couple of years as we go through the SURF process, through that next program of work, which has just been approved. We'll see how things go with that. We'll see what comes out of that. And then I think the next time we'd have to really come back and address all that is hopefully going to be 18 months or two years out.

1:17:51 So I think we're getting set up for the next couple of years worth of work and then we'll see where we're at in a couple of years. Elaine, anything else you'd like any other direction or any other comment from the board at this point before we go on to the next item? I think that we have sufficient direction to continue these conversations and I would just want to thank Nate and Destin, Dan and Bob for their generous time in helping to solve for the capacity issues at the ESCOG.

1:18:21 Also thank your board for your patience and your insights. Okay. And I think, but the points being made about regional planning, which is interesting, I look forward to hearing your thoughts about that, and Verminion County as well. As we knit this region together, and there are things that are happening that we do need to, in fact, weave and knit and bring all these things together, think about airports, air service.

1:18:45 Regional Recreation, the type of bringing a blue forest in that can work not just a Mammoth, but can be working for the benefit of the City of Bishop for all the communities in Mono County. So we'll balance this knitting and weaving as we go forward, but it's obviously very important. So with that, thank you all very much for this item, and we'll move on then to, I don't think we need any public comment on this, do we? Yeah, Angie, I can't, and for those virtually, we're not quite seeing everybody, so we don't quite know exactly who's out there, so Angie, is anybody with a hand raised or a?

1:19:19 No comments at this time. Okay, good. All right, so let's move on then to item 5.6. Yes, correct. 5.6. Approve Contracting Amendment No. 4 for Administrative Services with Eastern Sierra Planning, LLC. Elaine. Good morning again. So, the contract that I currently have with it, ESCOG to provide administrative services.

1:19:50 It comes up for its six-month expiration tomorrow. As described in the last item, I don't think we clearly have work to do still to figure out where an executive director is going to live and the logistics of that. So at this time, I'm requesting your board approve an amendment that would extend the existing contract through January 15, 2023 as a bridge while we sort through the logistics for a permanent

1:20:19 Thank you. So one just quick logistical question. January 15th.

1:20:49 How does that align with the ESCO's meeting schedule? Badly. Thank you for asking. Okay. There you go. Yeah. Yeah, the first regular meeting of 2023 is in February. Do we, should we consider, based on the statement you just made, should we consider extending that term until February, the date after our next regular meeting, just so we don't have to call a special meeting along the way or something? Is that...

1:21:20 So I would just consider that in your questions in our motions. Any questions from the Board? Jeff, Bob, any public comment out there, Angie? I'm okay. No comments at this time. Okay. So I guess I would entertain a motion. So I would move that we approve the contract amendment number four for administrative services would be revision to the date to be February 15, 2023. Okay.

1:21:57 We have a motion to second. Any additional discussion? Hearing none, Angie, please call the roll. And I apologize, I was typing the amendment date. Who made the second on that? I did. Karen Schwartz. Karen, thank you so much. Chair Wentworth. Yes. Council Member Schwartz. Yes. Supervisor Corliss. Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. And Council Member Salcedo. Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine. Thank you for all your consideration of this and work in this advancing these.

1:22:31 Interest of all parties as we move forward with the ESCOG. Okay, moving on now to item 5.7. Receive an update on Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Fair Political Practice Commission Conflict of Interest Code. I believe, Grace, this is yours. I'm sorry, we can't. We don't know how to do that. So as I was saying, if you can think back to two years ago, which, you know.

1:23:08 Chair Wentworth may be struggling a bit with that, but you'll be reminded in this resolution that you have in front of you. Back in July of 2020, your board passed a resolution adopting a conflict of interest code for the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. Every local entity, be it a JPA, a water board, the board of supervisors, a town council, must have a conflict of interest.

1:23:37 After your board adopted that code, it was forwarded to the FPPC, the Fair Political Practices Commission, for review and approval. The FPPC is the code reviewing body for multi-agency entities such as ESCOG. It has been a lengthy process of me emailing back and forth with FPPC staff attorneys regarding modifications that they want to see to the Conflict of Interest Code. Finally, on August 25th,

1:24:08 I received what I believe to be the FPPC's final round of edits to our conflict of interest. That is what is before your board today for review and potential adoption. I have no problem with their edits. Somewhat interestingly, their primary edits were to lower the amount of disclosure required by various entities.

1:24:38 We had drafted the Conflict of Interest Code to essentially say everybody must disclose everything. But the FPPC wanted to tighten it up a bit. That said, the disclosure required of all sorts of our various board members or staff members or contractors is still quite broad and I don't really think poses any problems. Also, all of...

1:25:05 Board members for ESCOG are council members or board members of other entities, so all of your board discloses everything anyway. So with that, I'm happy to take any questions about this new conflict of interest code, and I should also note there is one very important edit that I would like to make. I noted a typo after this agenda was published. Within appendix A of the conflict of interest code,

1:25:34 Board members are noted as disclosure category two. They should be noted as disclosure category one because board members really should be the ones making the absolute broadest and most open disclosure. So I would offer this resolution and this proposed conflict of interest code with that edit to your board for adoption. Thank you. Questions for Grace. This is more of a nuts and bolts question. I found when filing you could

1:26:06 Fill out your form, ESCOG, and with the City of Bishop, they were able to accept it all, but ESCOG had to sign a wet signature and send it to Angie. Is there a way we can get the ESCOG one as part of all the other ones that you're working on? Yes. So, yes, this is the primary issue with Conflict Ventures Code. No one actually cares about the code, but filing your Form 700 is a headache of epic proportions.

1:26:35 And so unfortunately, it really depends on what your home entity uses for their filing system. So, you know, I think that for you, it would depend on what the City of Bishop uses. And I don't think ESCOG is in a place where ESCOG would independently be hosting some sort of e-filing system for Form 700s. So unfortunately, it's kind of difficult for me to answer those questions because it...

1:27:03 It just depends, I think, on what each, you know, Town of Mammoth, Bishop, Mono, and Inyo use for everyone to file their 700s. I mean, it wasn't bad, but yeah, it was one extra step. And it can be a bit annoying to get these 700s into all the places they need to be. Supervisor Close, any questions? Supervisors Griffith and Gardner in the virtual world. I'm prepared to make a motion. Bob? I'm prepared to second it. Okay.

1:27:39 Why don't you guys go ahead and do that? I've got one question, but go ahead. So we have a motion from Supervisor Griffith and a second from Supervisor Gardner, correct? Okay. I would like that we may perhaps follow up on this filing question a little bit. I think for public officials now to understand if you're stepping into the ESCOG, you're not stepping into some extraordinary universe, and I think it'll be helpful to encourage participation and people being part of the boards. We can maybe follow up on that. I've run into the same things with...

1:28:09 with the Air District Board that I serve on. It's just kind of weird, but we can follow up on that a little bit. Absolutely. I can reach out to all of the individuals who manage the Form 700s for the various jurisdictions and maybe try to get some clarity on how each board member from each member entity can go about filing a 700 for us. Okay. So we have a motion on the table. Before we proceed, is there any public comment on this item, Angie? No, there is not. And there's no public comment here in the room.

1:28:38 Motion and a second. Any additional discussion? Not hearing any. Angie, please call the roll on this question. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffith? Yes. And Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Thank you all very much. We will move on now to receive an update on Assembly Bill 2449. Now, do we want this update?

1:29:10 Okay, we're going to get it whether we like it or not. So please, Grace, Elaine. Yes, so I'll be handling this update for your board. This, you know, I know remote meetings have been of particular interest to ESCOG, given that we do represent such a large and dispersed region. And we've had some brief discussions when AB 361 came around.

1:29:34 And also some follow-up discussions of legislation that was sort of in the hopper but not yet passed regarding remote meetings. So the first thing I guess I should start out by saying is that AB 2449 does not change AB 360. So the process that we've all become very accustomed to of having these special meetings every 30 days in order to keep the door open to remote meetings, that still remains, that is still available and open to us until what is the

1:30:05 Expiration date, January 1st, 2024. That is the sunset date for AB 360. So we've got two more years of it. I'm sorry, one more year of it. Now though, we also have AB 2449 available to talk. And 361 and 2449 can be used concurrently. So we now have these two options available. AB 2449 was one of those bills that was sort of in the hopper previously and it looked very promising.

1:30:35 It actually seems to provide broad authority with some guardrails in place to ensure public participation for members of a Brown Act body to meet remotely. Unfortunately, it seems to be one of those bills where various interest groups got a hold of it, and after that, it reflects a series of compromises that kind of make nobody happy, is where things landed.

1:31:02 But it's not all bad news. It's not entirely useless. I don't want to give that impression. What AB 2449 does at its core is list out a series of circumstances, which the bill calls just cause or emergency circumstances that allow a board member to participate remotely. And just cause is defined to include a child care need, a contagious illness, a physical or mental disability,

1:31:30 or travel while on business of the legislative body. An emergency circumstance is a physical or family medical emergency. So essentially if any board member is experiencing one of those five things you may participate remotely in the meeting even if there has been no prior AB 361 findings of any kind. There are some limits on how you can invoke this. The first is that the board member seeking to participate remotely for one of these five reasons

1:32:00 has to submit a short statement outlining the facts to the board and the other board members have to vote on it to decide whether it meets the just cause or emergency circumstances and, you know, really whether they think it's a good idea to allow that person to participate remotely. That request does not need to be agendized. So your board is free to take action on an item not on the agenda if it is one of these last-minute emergencies.

1:32:28 Each board member, however, is only allowed to invoke this just cause or emergency circumstance situation two times per year if the body meets fewer than 10 times per year, and that would be the situation. ESCOG falls in, and this is only regular meetings, not special meetings. If you are on a board that meets more often, you're only allowed to invoke it for 20% of a meeting. And then finally, if you do participate remotely under AB 2449,

1:32:59 You must use both audio and video. So you have to be in a location where the internet is good enough for that to work. So, you know, what this is, is I think it's a powerful tool for true emergency circumstances. You know, that this is not carte blanche to participate remotely like AB 361. But this really works well for these last-minute, unforeseen, you know, oh my gosh, sick child or, you know, someone's traveling to RCRC, right, and needs to participate remotely for that.

1:33:31 So it works in those situations, but it is not particularly broad, and therefore I think should not be something that we rely on on a regular basis. And if your board wants to continue to leave the remote meeting option open, we should continue with AB3C. So with that, I'm happy to take any questions, but we just wanted to provide this brief update about this new remote meeting option that is out there. So a quick question before we go to the board.

1:33:59 Are we being asked to make a choice? Is there an action here? Or is this just there? No, this is purely informational. If your board has direction, you know, if you decide that in light of 2449 you don't want to keep doing these AB 361 meetings, that's something we could talk about and you could provide staff direction today. But, you know, for now this is just to let you know this is out there and potentially discuss any changes if we want to make. So this is in effect.

1:34:29 Yes, absolutely. Per the state legislature. Okay. Questions? Thank you for that update. What will happen then after, you said it's 26? 24. 24. This will be then only one of two items, two things, ruling over meeting absences, and so what's currently in effect will remain. Okay, how do these play in and when? Yes, so there's different sunset dates.

1:35:01 For each law. So AB 361 sunsets January 1st, 2024. 2449 sunsets January 1st, 2025. So until January 1st, 2024, we have both. Then for the year of 2024, we have only 2449. Then as of January 1st, 2025, we have nothing except the normal pre-COVID Brown Act. I'm sure the legislation, their wisdom will.

1:35:31 Jeff, Bob, are you there in the virtual space? Yeah, I just want to clarify, Grace, nothing in that would change the existing Brown Act requirements which allow remote but require posting of the agenda and those procedures which we lived with

1:36:10 Before COVID, right? Yes, absolutely. So through all of these twists and turns and new bills, we still have, you know, the good old pre-COVID Brown Act. Okay. Okay. So nothing would preclude remote participation if you follow those old Brown Act procedures? Correct. You know, if a board member wants to participate from their living room and wants to post that address on the agenda and wants to open up their front door, that is absolutely fine. Thank you.

1:36:41 Okay, Supervisor Griffith. And I believe we have lost Supervisor Griffith. Have we lost a quorum? We, in the City of Bishop, we're not doing ESCOG in our council chambers because we don't have the staffing to do it. Are you guys doing ESCOG here? Like when, like can you guys come here and participate in an ESCOG when it's at the City of Bishop or do you just do it from your... That's a really complicated question. Let me ask though, if we've lost Supervisor Griffith, have we lost a quorum?

1:37:08 We have, but this is not an action item, so it's okay to proceed. Okay, fine, I'm sorry. So, so, so with the City of Bishop, you know, we're not participating from our council chambers because we don't have the staff to administer the, um, the stuff. Tech, yeah. What about you guys? Like, are you guys, can you guys come here or do you guys either participate from your, wherever you are or? Depends on how the meetings go. Yeah, and that's, I mean, that's a question. Right. So, um, I guess my understanding is that

1:37:39 The Bishop Council Chambers, we would not open that to the public or the board or how, what are the staffing capabilities there? None, right? Okay. Yeah. So, yeah, so if that's the case, if, you know, we just don't have the ability to have, you know, any sort of, any people there, then we just simply wouldn't list the Bishop Council Chambers on the agenda and that would not be available for public or board participation. But in Mammoth, if the meeting is in Bishop, we could use Mammoth as a remote location.

1:38:11 Dan, if we can staff it, does that sound about right? Yes, although we shouldn't be agendizing a meeting for Bishop if it's not open to the public because listing an address on the agenda means you're telling the public you can come. Okay. And so, for instance, for today, the Bishop Chambers aren't open and the Bishop Chambers not listed on the agenda. This is the location. And then all the various rules apply to one location.

1:38:42 But if we're having a meeting in Bishop, theoretically Mammoth could be listed because there's a staffing to be able to provide it as a remote location. But that would be up to staff to figure out whether or not we want to do that. Yes, absolutely. So that's correct. If we get the staffing such that we can open up the Bishop Chambers and we want to list a Mammoth and we want to list a June Lake and we want to list a Dependents, I mean, we can, you know, add however many locations we want if we can make it work. That's beautiful.

1:39:10 I have one question, which is Elaine and I talked a little bit about this. Would there be, and we don't have to answer this question now, but would there be an advantage to the ESCOG to modify our regular meeting schedule in such a way that could be advantageous given all this legislation coming out of the state? Even if we don't meet all those times, but we say we're going to be meeting every once a month and we could cancel meetings.

1:39:38 If that might be something that could be advantage to all these different rules. That could provide an advantage in the sense that it would open up the ability for board members to use 2449 more often because right now you guys are hard capped at two times per year to use that and so if we were to publish a schedule that had more regular meetings that allows more 2449 usage.

1:40:06 But other than that, I mean, I think I would probably mostly defer to Elaine and Angie as to whether they prefer special versus regular meetings for AB 361. And I believe you also mentioned under AB 2449 that there's a 20% cap. So even if we went to having monthly meetings. Yeah. All right. Well, just to find some way to make this a little bit easier for folks to navigate. And I would defer to your board if you wanted continuing with the AB 361 meeting.

1:40:49 Yeah, I think that's probably the consensus of the board at this point. Okay, well, thank you for that, and we shall survive. So, item 5.9, the Executive Director Update Report. Elaine. Good morning once more. I was going to provide an update on our ongoing projects under the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program. I'll go ahead and start with some of the activities.

1:41:18 from our CDFW grant for the NEPA services. So I'll provide a summary of the report that was given by Ms. Hatfield, who's our project manager for that. The Whitebark Institute has refined the proposed actions with the Inyo National Forest collaboration for the NEPA work to be completed. And those have been accepted by the Inyo National Forest and are ready to share with the public.

1:41:48 That being the case, the Whitebark Institute will begin their public scoping shortly, so that's the opportunity for the public to come and comment on potential environmental impacts and concerns associated with the project that will guide the NEPA process and the work that's done. Those notices are anticipated to go out next week, with the tentative dates being November 2nd,

1:42:18 for a virtual public scoping meeting. It will be held from 10 to 11.30 a.m. and then November 3rd for a physical public scoping meeting. It will be held in the Mono County Civic Center from 6 p.m. You can follow up with your board and provide those notices when they be coming. That would be helpful, thank you. And then I wanted to also provide you an update on the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative. Your board had authorized me to move forward.

1:42:49 with purchasing the toilet for replacement. I've been working closely with the Forest Service to, before placing that purchase order, determine if there are any logistics issues associated with delivery. In particular, there's one sharp right-angle turn at the very end to deliver it to the site. And so we were working with the

1:43:13 A selected contractor and their logistics team, they feel confident that there shouldn't be any issues associated with the road and with delivery, and they've extended the bid through October 31st, so I anticipate we just heard from the logistics team yesterday, so I think that we'll be able to go ahead and place that order next week. Looking forward to doing that. Delivery is still anticipated to be in April, which is appropriate for not doing

1:43:42 Concrete work and digging work during winter months at that location, and then I'll be able to return to your board with a request for proposals for the recreation planning component once we have confidence in the budgeted amount with that order being placed. Just one thought on that. I'm wondering for a future agenda item if you might want to share with the board your thoughts about the ESCOG getting involved in project implementation.

1:44:08 I would be happy to provide that as an update now, but if you'd like me to agendize it in the future, I could do that as well. I think maybe just agendize that in the future a little bit. I think it's important for all of us to understand the realities of ESCOG as an organization getting involved in actual bidding, implementing, you know, building things. And I think, Elaine, I think it would be very useful for all of us to hear your thoughts on that. I will go ahead and agendize that in the future. Thank you. Great. Thank you.

1:44:36 That's my update on the SREMP activities since our last meeting. I'm happy to take additional questions. Thank you. Okay. Any additional questions or thoughts? Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much. We'll move on now to our board member agency reports. And I guess we'll start here, and then we'll go to the virtual. I will turn to my right.

1:45:06 Supervisor Corliss, are you prepared to give a report? Yes, I will defer to the chair of our board, Mr. Gardner, for county-specific items, but just want to note, since we last met some state activities, the Wildfire and Forest Resilience Task Force, I just really encourage everyone to go to the website. They just post a really easy-to-read meeting summary. This was the meeting on September 28th,

1:45:38 Grass Valley focused specifically on the Sierra Nevada region. So, of course, all the meetings are fascinating and a ton of information, but all of this was focused specifically on the Sierra Nevada region. So, wildfiretaskforce.org is the website. Of course, there was a presentation by our own esteemed ESCOG Board Chair. I highly recommend watching that, relating a strategy around recreation in fire and forest resilience.

1:46:07 So that and then the very next day there was a state natural resources agency kickoff meeting for the 30 by 30 partnership program. 30 by 30 is a state initiative to conserve 30 percent of the state's land and coastal waters by 2030. So it delved a little bit more into the kind of the vision and the types of programs. There's a lot of funding associated with that. So you can go to

1:46:37 I don't remember the exact URL, but it's California Nature, and sign up for their news list. They're doing a series of virtual presentations with a number of departments within the resources agency on funding opportunities, but I think this might be of interest to the ESCOG, given the fact that this initiative is associated with some funding, so more grants! But I can send Elaine at the exact website.

1:47:09 Some of the upcoming. Excellent. Thank you. Bob, are you with us? Is your hotspot with us? I am. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm juggling iPads and phones and everything. Yeah. I don't have a lot to add. We did have a lively discussion. We had a short meeting. We had a lively discussion about the reservation system in Yosemite, and it sounds like there's more to be discussed on that.

1:47:47 Especially after going to the partnership meeting yesterday, they did not announce anything on that yesterday. There's also an interesting article in today's San Francisco Chronicle about wild horses in the Mono Basin, which is lighting up everybody's email stream. And other than that, unless our CAO Bob Lawton can remind me of something I've missed, I think that's basically all I have. Okay, thank you. Mr. Lawton, are you with us?

1:48:27 Okay, well, Bob, the microphone's open if you want to come back. I think at that, Jeff Griffiths, if you're there, if you want to give us an update from Inyo County. Jeff is gone, so no update from Inyo County. Okay, so I'll go to the other end here of the dais. Council Member Salcedo. I will, to you, John, to take it. If you forget anything, I'll put it. Thank you very much. Council Member Schwartz. The City of Bishop remains really busy with a small sample size of Sage to summit. There's lots of tourists still in town, so that's great.

1:48:58 And the City of Bishop sent a letter to DWP a few months ago requesting some parcels near the Silver Peaks Project, which is by Pizza Factory, if you guys are familiar with it. I mean, who isn't familiar with Pizza Factory? And they are, and Dustin can speak to this more, but I'm working really well with Dustin on lighting speed, potential selling of the parcels that we will see if it's true, but that's pretty exciting.

1:49:29 And we had a lunch with the Bishop Tribe yesterday, and it was a great, very, it was an informal conversation, but turned into just a great collaboration of their having similar housing issues as we are, and they also talked a lot about their issues with drug prevention and what to do with some of the tribal members, and not even just tribal members, but we also have that in Inyo County and in Bishop.

1:49:58 How to bring people who have left the community and have gone through prevention and then they come back and how do they re-assimilate into their communities without reverting back to previous habits and it's a big issue and apparently there's really no solutions whatsoever that they could identify. But it was a great meeting and it got me into thinking

1:50:28 And I think we talked about this years ago, about having tribal representation on the ESCOG. And I think at least the Bishop Tribe, based on just talking to all the members, they're a really engaged bunch. And I would anticipate that they probably would enjoy a seat at this board. I don't know what that would take or how that would happen. But my guess, based on just interacting with them yesterday, that there would be a hard yes.

1:50:59 I don't know if that's an agenda item that we would want to talk about in the future, if that makes sense for this board. No, I think I would certainly support that if that's something, Grace, if you wanted, given who we are, to maybe advise the board in our next meeting what those opportunities might look like. Because it wouldn't just be the Bishop Tribe, right? It would be, we have, I don't know how many tribes are in this Inyo-Mo area, but there's quite a few. But I guess it could be who wants to participate, right? But I don't know if that would then make it.

1:51:27 A crazy large board, and it'd be too much, so I don't know what that would look like. Well, we'll start with what's possible legally and where we can start, and then we can have a discussion from that. Okay, that's it. Okay. I see Town Manager Holler is here with us in the room, and I'll share a couple things with Dan. I'm sure you have some more detailed things to share. On the housing front, the parcel, if...

1:51:55 Those of you who are in town on your way out, you can see where the concrete pedestals have been constructed. As you drive by the airport, you'll see 15 large, white, rectilinear things. Those are actually the housing units. And those units, this is modular, will be placed on those podiums in the podium within the next couple weeks. And again, we...

1:52:21 Always are eager to share whatever lessons we're learning with all this. The parcel is part of a larger program called Housing Now, which involves a lot of other things we're trying to do to help alleviate housing issues in town. So Dan can certainly speak to more detail about that if that's appropriate. We have elections going on up here. I'm up for re-election. I don't know if anybody else is. Well, you. Yeah, so that's going on.

1:52:50 We're really enjoying a classic Eastern Sierra Fall. I know all of us are without any smoke, without any, you know, existential disasters coming our way, forests being closed and things like that. So that's been interesting. I did take a little adventure out of Onion Valley last weekend. The Onion Valley parking lot was packed. The two, the grays of campgrounds were packed. And I think it's important to keep in mind the Southern California audience, you know, those day hikers, those weekend people can get there.

1:53:19 They can get to Lone Pine, they can get to Onion Valley, and that's in their itinerary. It's in the things that they think about. And I know that Elaine and I have been talking a number of different things, things like the visitor connection package and communicating with that audience, things that are out there.

1:53:34 But I think that's all I've really got from the town of Mammoth Lakes, Dan, I'm sure you've... Linda, what did I miss? A few things, just in regards to... Thank you. Okay, sure, no problem. Okay, go ahead. Just in regards to the modular sitting down at the airport, we had a tour yesterday, and we got to go down and climb inside of them, which was fun to see, and for me, I went away with it, that it appears that the products that they used are really high quality. There's pre-laid fluorine.

1:54:01 The appliances were all in, the bathrooms were in, the countertops were in, and all of those things appeared to be very nice, high quality product. So that was really nice. They're not all there yet, all 81 are not there yet, but it was pretty amazing to see them all wrapped up and just open a little doorway and everybody got to crawl in the little crawl space and go in and out of several of them. And it was heartening to see how close it

1:54:31 I want to go back a second to the discussion about ALTA.

1:55:08 I realize I have done a lot of work locally, too, but I was looking for someone who had personally most recently completely lost my mind, but yes, thank you for that. I have no idea what you're talking about. That's all right. It does sound important. Dan. Yes, thank you. On the housing front, we get a lot of questions about this, and obviously, with the political season, a lot of questions regarding housing and that effort. I know it's something that ESCOG has looked at at some levels, but over the next 24 months or so, we hope to see some 200 plus, up to 270 units.

1:55:40 Mammoth Lakes on the ground. That includes the 80 plus at the parcel right now, phase two, at least the first half of that is about 70 in total of 100 units there. We're also in our other programs, we're actually buying units and reselling them at a subsidized rate. We have what we just opened escrow yesterday on, for example, for local residents. That's been a, we call it a bridge program. It's fairly effective in working with that missing middle group, which is market rate housing.

1:56:14 A couple other programs we have, as well as that, there's a home key project going forward, ejecting partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing for AXA Town. So, a number of things out in the housing front. The other thing I did want to note, if you're aware, Red's Meadow is now closed, that closed on the 11th. They have a fair amount of fire operations planned for that area, so heads up, if you see smoke or get phone calls, there's planned fire down there, there's some pile burning and then some broadcast burning, as well as ongoing tree clearing for the

1:56:47 future road construction, reconstruction of the red zone commencing here 23-24, 24-25. It's a two-year construction project to keep the road at least open with limited construction period. So that'll be a huge project. We've also will be expanding our grooming project for winter trails. We did some pilot work last year. We've got some additional equipment on board to help with that out by the Sherwin Creek Trailhead where the propane tanks are here in town.

1:57:22 Access areas out there for groomed trails, then ongoing grooming with area out of shady rest, and then also working with the Forest Service on the snowmobile trails and grooming this year, the last year that we saw, and then we're coordinating with ORMAT and USGS on access to places and trying to make sure that that doesn't impact those trails. USGS access, it looks like they'll be going out in November and then again in March, so there's only one real winter disruption.

1:57:52 Or Matt will still have to plow out. They actually have to check their wells every 12 hours. So those roads will continue to be plowed out to a couple wells there if you're people out there. But we're working with them to make sure that there's some safety precautions up as if we get a lot of snow. Hopefully we do. Those roads get kind of like a Divya Canyon. If you're not careful, you can do one. So there's some marking and stuff that way on the trail. We just celebrated the opening of new trails up in the Lakes Basin, the recreational front.

1:58:23 That activity going on. We also are looking at grant work through SNC for the Sherwin's area. I'm not sure if we've asked for letters of support for all those in the works. We've got initial positive recommendations from staff. That'll be going December for the Sherwin's area for the next phase in the trail program there. Some exciting stuff happening that way. We had a fire the other night. Yeah, there was a fire yesterday morning out by Ormat. There was an electrical fire. I don't know. It didn't start a bigger fire.

1:59:02 Did not start a big one, correct. Very fortunate. Okay, good. Well, thank you, Dan. We will now consider future agenda items. And Elaine, between now and January, do we have one meeting? One meeting. Special meetings. Okay, and when is that next meeting? Is it December? 9th. 9th. 9th, okay. Just trying to get some things here. So I think we heard Supervisor Corliss request from you for a future agenda item.

1:59:35 Yeah, this is something I think our board has maybe briefly and openly discussed this year, but I had a great conversation with Elaine about, and that is the idea of doing another ESCOG planning session, similar to one we did back in, I think it was 2016. And magically, as Elaine and I were discussing this, an email came through to my county account from the Institute for Local Government.

2:00:05 who was the facilitator for our planning session back several years ago, saying that they are, you know, reminding their local government partners that ILG is available for facilitation. So I would like to suggest that for our December 9th meeting, you know, we have Elaine, contact ILG and just, you know, look at and see what the scope of that might be and cost, and obviously I won't be on the board anymore, but I found that.

2:00:36 Three of us now, I think we're there, to be a really valuable exercise. And even though ESCOG does have these clear programs of work, really looking at setting priorities within that and looking at what other issues might be. Yeah, so I think there's consensus for that. The other thing that I would like to see if we could squeeze in is an airport air service update. We're getting, in the town, we get updates on what's going on at the Mammoth Airport and things like that. We get sort of tangential things about

2:01:08 Well, MLT and Bishop, and it sounds, it comes in kind of a weird way. And I think we have, you know, we have this Miwag thing set up at the ESCOG. I think it'd be helpful to start, well, it's daylight, let's see what's going on, how are we doing and who's doing what. The other thing that I think would be helpful, Elaine, is to start to coordinate and provide something to the board about all of the money that's in the state.

2:01:38 That you mentioned the 30 by 30 and the wildfire group and what's coming out of OPR. Just so that a lot of this exists already. But just to share as part of the packet so the ESCOG understands this is where all this money generally is and this is where all these things that might tie into surf conversation. It's a good setup to get ready for the surf process. I can help you with that, Elaine. Yeah, see? Otherwise that's pretty daunting. Yeah, yeah. No, we haven't.

2:02:06 People do things in their spare time. Who knew? But I think that would be helpful with the ESCOG. Just to have, yeah, thank you. To have a general sense of the landscape. And this may only be, I mean, this was in this last legislative session. If we go into, if recessions and things like that happen, we probably won't be seeing that again, but it's good to know where all of it is. And these are the kinds of things that would be opportunities for this or for the ESCOG. So, was there anything else? Okay.

2:02:39 Okay, so we will be adjourned now until our next meeting December 9th, correct? And then will that be in Bishop, in the City of Bishop? Okay, great. Thank you all very much. Thank you. We might go to San Francisco and buy a fiddle for Cosmo.