TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2026

Town Council

at 16:00 · recording 3 hr 28 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

5 findings

Transcript

416 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:46 That's nice. Is that going to turn on more? Yes, because my problem is back. Oh, sorry. Well, it's okay. But I was in the car all day because I had a doctor yesterday. Well, let me know when you're ready. I'm ready. You're ready. Okay. Okay, we are ready to begin our council meeting. Jamie, can we have a call to order and roll call, please? Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Salzer? Yes.

4:13 Councilmember Wentworth is absent. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Here. Mayor Rice? Here. We're going to do the Pledge of Allegiance and Bill Sauser will lead us this evening. Please join us. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, invisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, we are at public commons. If there's a member of the public.

4:45 Who has anything to say that is not currently on our agenda? Please approach us at the podium and make your comments. And if you're online, you can raise your hand. Hi, Betsy. Good evening, everyone. Good evening, Council, Madam Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of the public. I'm Betsy Truax. I'm the Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And I just wanted to share that we're very excited to launch our Sierra Summer Night Series.

5:13 This is going to be a really fun community gathering. It's a partnership between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Tourism to celebrate the vibrancy of our community. And the first one will be Thursday, June 11th from 4 to 8 p.m. at Mammoth Creek Park. We'll have food trucks. We'll have some vendors, some local craft vendors, some kind of farmer's market type vendors. The Mono Mags are the reggae band who are playing. And Mammoth Brewing Company will be the brewery. They'll be there.

5:40 With beer for purchase and also working with them on maybe doing some root beer floats courtesy of Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the first hundred people. So hope to see everyone out there. Please help us spread the word. I'll leave a couple of flyers in the back. And hopefully I'm not stealing any thunder from Lawson later, but we also will kick off Trashy Thursdays on Thursday, June 25th. Trashy Thursdays this year will be one Thursday a month, the last Thursday of the month.

6:06 Thank you so much, Betsy. Okay. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No? Okay.

6:37 We are on to item four, additions to the agenda. Rob, is there anything to add this evening? No, Mayor Rice. There are no modifications to the agenda this evening. Okay, thank you. So we're on to item five, town council presentations. 5.1, recognition of senior planner Kim Cook for 10 years of service to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Great. So I'm excited to celebrate Kim Cook on her 10-year anniversary working here with the town. We're excited. We didn't really steal her from down south.

7:06 She came up here on her own from the city of Azusa and then took a two-year break after her first son was born. We were excited when she decided she wanted to go back into public service and we had an opening then at that time as well. So she applied and it's been great. I think I started maybe right a little bit before that. So we've been working together most of my time here as well. So we're excited to celebrate 10 years. Thank you so much. Do you have any comments?

7:36 I'm happy to be here and grateful for the steady work, so thank you. Thank you so much for your service. Kim, do you want to come on up here? We'll get a photo and I have a certificate for you.

8:17 Congratulations. Thank you for being here. Thank you. Thank you. Congratulations and thank you for all you do. Okay, and now we're on to item 5.2, recognition of Police Sergeant Joe Vetter for 10 years of service and retirement from the town of Mammoth Lakes. Good evening, Councilor Dan Casabian, Chief of Police. Joe wanted to be here, but he is moving his family to their new location.

9:06 So wish him the best. But a few things about Joe tonight. I'd like to recognize Sergeant Joe Vetter for his 10 years of service with the town of Mammoth Lakes and congratulate him on his retirement after an incredible 28-year career in law enforcement. It's a long time in law enforcement. Throughout his career, Joe has served the communities he's worked with, professional, worked with in, let me try that again. Throughout his career, Joe has served the communities he's worked in with professionalism, integrity, and dedication.

9:35 During his time with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, he has been a steady leader, mentor, and trusted partner to both the department and the community we serve. He also had this humor about him that when you walked into the station, he would brighten your day for sure, especially if you're having a bad day. You always had something funny to say, and always out there with the community. Law enforcement is not an easy profession, and reaching 28 years of service is a tremendous accomplishment that reflects a lifelong commitment to public service and helping others.

10:04 On behalf of the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, we thank Sergeant Better for his years of service and wish him and his family nothing but the best in retirement. And on top of that, his children and his wife get their daddy back and off to retirement and enjoying life. So they're also a hero. You know, being a wife in law enforcement is tough. The support that she showed Jo throughout the years was tremendous. So congratulations to both of them.

10:32 And we wish them a happy retirement. Thank you. Can you give him a round of applause? You can give him a round of applause. Okay. And can I give you his certificate or should we mail this to him? You can give it to me. I'll find him. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for those kind words. Thanks, Chief. We really appreciate him. Okay. We are on to item 5.3, approve the proclamation proclaiming June 2026 as Pride Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes. So I read this first and then we vote or do we vote first? You can read it.

11:05 Okay. Okay. So, whereas the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, California recognizes and proclaims the month of June 2026 as two-spirit, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, intersex, asexual, and plus, Pride Month throughout the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and whereas celebrating Pride Month influences awareness and provides support and advocacy for the town's 2SLGBTQIAP plus community,

11:34 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

12:02 2026 at Canyon Lodge. Hi. Welcome. Will you be accepting this tonight? Thank you so much for coming. Fantastic. Would you like to do a photo? Oh, okay. We always forget to vote. Sorry. We're a little premature. I knew we had to vote at some point. I move to approve the proclamation with great pleasure. I will second that with great pleasure. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

12:39 Yes. And if you don't have your tickets for this weekend yet, I'm sure they're still available and it is great fun. All right. Now a photo? Yes. Okay. All right. Three, two, one. One more. Awesome.

13:12 Thank you so much. Nice to meet you. Thanks for coming. Thank you. We'll see you this weekend. Thanks, everyone. Oh, yeah. Just for my glasses. No, it's just for my glasses, I swear. Yep, yep, yep. Okay. I'm believing you. Yep. Okay.

13:37 We are on to item six, public presentations. Item 6.1, California Department of Fish and Wildlife update. Thank you, Mayor Rice. I will kind of just introduce real quickly, obviously California Department of Fish and Wildlife is a great partner of ours. They do have a great responsibility within the town in the work that they perform. I want to express my appreciation for their partnership.

14:08 We have occasional meetings and talk about ways we can improve things. Their willingness to come and talk to the community and speak to us about this important topic is invaluable to our success.

14:25 Appreciate them coming down today. This is similar to last year where they spent a great deal of time talking to us about the efforts and educating us on this process. So happy to add a little bit more afterwards if there's any questions on town efforts outside of the work that CDFW is doing. But anyway, appreciate it. And I'll turn it over to our presenter tonight. Thank you so much. Hello. Thanks for having me.

16:00 My name is Michael Brown. I'm an environmental scientist and bear biologist with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. Based out of Bishop, but work a lot in Mammoth Lakes and all throughout Inuamona County. So today, I wanted to talk to you all and I'm grateful for the opportunity to kind of present on current bear behavior and activities that are going on this time of year and just an update on what we as CDFW are doing in relation

16:34 to bear and why we're doing some of these activities. Some of this may be familiar or repetitive to many of you, but the goal is to come and present at these events a few times throughout the year, especially during bear season. And so this being the first one of the year, I just wanted to recap some aspects that are relevant to conflict and what's going on right now of bear behavior and also various

17:05 information that's valuable to us and how that influences our response and furthermore the involvement of the entire community and all the different agencies we work really closely with to keep these bears as wild as possible and hopefully facilitate the mitigation of human bear conflict and facilitate reporting of incidences as they're coming up. So bears have very seasonal

17:40 Behavioral Patterns. Right now, we are in the breeding season. During this time of year, bears are going to be overlapping one another, specifically males following females around. And just to recap on bear reproductive cycles, as it can be relevant to the kind of animals you're seeing right now and what those animals are doing, bears with adequate resources can generally females, that is, reproduce every other year. They'll breed this time of year.

18:09 And then in the winter, they'll enter a den to give birth to a litter of generally one to four cubs. Out here across the board, we see very much an average of two that are born, but sometimes singles and triplets make their way off. And so once those cubs emerge with their mother, they're going to be remaining with that female for a year and then again for a second time as yearlings or one-year-old bears.

18:38 They'll emerge a second time and right around the breeding season or shortly after emergence, those yearling one and a half year old bears are going to be pushed off from their mother and begin their lives as newly independent young bears. And I put up this picture here because this is an example of a young yearling bear. If you familiarize yourself with what to look for, it can be quite noticeable. And I'll circle back to...

19:07 Why I'm focusing on yearlings in particular a little bit further in the presentation. But this is just a really sensitive period for learning in their life and can be really important as it relates to conflict and the kind of behaviors that these bears learn in the trajectory they can go down. As we move later in the year, towards the end of summer and into fall, we're going to enter a stage called hyperphagia.

19:36 Is a time when all breeding has, the breeding season has ended and bears motivations have really changed to trying to obtain as many calories as possible to get ready for the winter season and to build up those fat reserves. And so that can also have really real conflict potential during that time because especially bears that are in close proximity or maybe have previous experience.

20:05 In and around development and anthropogenic activities, you know, they can be really driven towards these anthropogenic food sources as they're just incredibly valuable for bears. So I just wanted you all to keep that in mind in terms of the bears you're seeing on the landscape right now. If you're seeing an adult with small, you know, 10, 20 pound bears with it, that's going to be a female.

20:33 With cubs that were born this year in January or February, and they'll remain with those mothers for this year. If you're seeing lone individuals, if they're adults, likely going to be a male or a female. If you can recognize these smaller, more juvenile-looking bears, those are going to be these yearlings that are just now dispersed and independent. Starting.

20:59 What year will bears start to reproduce? Will females actually reproduce? That's a really good question, and I think it varies depending on where you're looking at in terms of black bears are incredibly widely dispersed across North America. Around here, you know, the general consensus is between the ages of three and six is when they're going to for females, and that's more or less what we've seen.

21:28 We've been really focusing on reproduction and getting these vital rates for the last three years now pretty closely by looking at individuals and their reproductive success, and we're seeing right around that three- or four-year-old mark as they're starting to have the first litters of cups. And so CDFW, both statewide and locally here in the eastern Sierra, have been conducting bear research for a long time.

22:02 One of our main objectives is just to monitor bear populations, the trends in those populations over time, and another characteristic of looking at space use parameters, habitat selection, habitat fragmentation, connectivity, all going towards the conservation of bears as a population within California. However, we do conduct activities that overlap with urban areas and with

22:31 Conflict specifically, as well as just responding to conflict situations directly. And we use a series of tools and techniques. I just wanted to go over kind of the main ones that people might see us out and about using and provide some information and some clarity and transparency about what we're doing, why we're conducting these activities, and what actually is going on and what that means for the animals involved.

23:00 And so we primarily use traps, and these are going to be trailered or culvert style traps that either go on the ground or are towed behind a vehicle and park somewhere. These are non-lethal traps. They aim not to hurt the bear. Basically, animal goes in, there's a bait, pulls the trigger, door closes. And these traps are monitored very, very closely when we are using them.

23:28 And they're also used to transport animals around. If we have to move a bear to the nearest suitable wild habitat, or also if we're conducting a welfare check or assessing the health of an animal that could be injured or is of concern, we'll also use these to transport animals around. But we also use them in conflict mitigation, and that also contributes to research.

23:58 We definitely prioritize non-lethal measures over a last resort of a lethal response. But yeah, the main point to take away is that these traps are used across the board in a non-lethal setting for research and data collection and conflict. And so as I mentioned, we'll collect data about the health of the animal.

24:25 We'll also sometimes fit animals with GPS collars or ear tags and that facilitates in data collection looking at movement, space use parameters such as habitat selection, home range, core areas, seasonal movement patterns, density of animals in this area and that reproductive success. All of these variables are really important into monitoring and having a good idea of what bear populations are doing. Some of the markings that you'll see.

24:58 On an animal, when we handle or immobilize, chemically immobilize an animal for a capture and release, we'll generally mark these animals with various pieces of equipment. Primarily, this can involve a pit tag, which is more like a microchip that you would use on a dog or a cat, an ear tag, which is used for individual identification, and for an animal that

25:27 Is feasible and that we want to track its movements for a period of time, we'll place a temporary GPS collar on that there. And so these GPS collars, again, are temporary. They're programmed to automatically drop off the animal after a pre-programmed set of time. We can also remotely drop them from a computer. And then they also have a backup on them, which is a cotton spacer, which over time deteriorates and will break the collar off.

25:56 Itself as kind of a fail safe. And so I wanted to talk a few about a few misconceptions that I commonly hear from people in the public and visitors alike is that, you know, these ear tags or these collars bear any significance other than individual identification. The color, the location, the size, the number, whether it's collared or not.

26:20 These are solely for data collection purposes, and they're just to facilitate individual identification of those animals, either for research or for conflict. And so if we tag an animal or mark it with a microchip and that animal shows up in the future, we're able to tell that this was the animal and this was the history of that animal.

26:46 That helps with survival. I just want to say thanks for clearing that up because I've got several questions I've had in the past. They think the tagged bear is a nuisance bear and it was not the only reason it was tagged because it was a nuisance bear. Yeah, absolutely. And same with collars, you know, and that kind of brings to my next point of, you know, the misconception around reporting is that people are sometimes hesitant to report sightings of these bears or even even

27:10 You know, conflict related to these bears because they have a tag and the tag was red or it has a collar and so that means if you report an animal that's been marked it's going to lead to euthanasia of that animal and that's not the case at all. In many ways marking these animals is an initial step to avoid any future conflict and curb behavior and intervene as early as possible in the development of this.

27:38 Problematic behavior that overall is hopefully of the benefit of the animal and encouraging that animal to go wild bear. So just to share a little bit of movement data and this again relates to some misconceptions that I hear sometimes. So over the course of this local project we've collected spatial data from over 90 collared individuals.

28:10 Twenty of those animals at some period of their life or some period of the monitoring duration spent a proportion of time within the boundary of Mammoth Lakes. This next slide here will illustrate kind of the variability of that proportional data where some bears towards the right-hand side of the screen have a relatively high proportion of use of the GPS points that we

28:39 And these next figures I think are really interesting good examples

29:09 And really go to show the value of some of the tools we use and some of the data we collect. Sorry, just an odd question as to on the two slides before. One of the data points goes across Crawley Lake. Did they swim across the lake? It was frozen. Oh, it was frozen. Frozen. Good catch, though.

29:34 I thought the same thing when I was like, wait a second. But they're good swimmers. They can swim pretty far, right? They certainly can swim, yeah. I was just thinking they could walk around, but okay, frozen lake, got it. Yeah, that bear was coming, traversing from, or moving from McGee, Mount McGee to the Glass Mountains in the middle of winter. So does that mean that bear was not hibernating in winter, or it was like an early freeze, or? That bear, it was a large female. She spent some time.

30:06 In Mammoth. And actually, interestingly enough, you know, her collar dropped off and someone, it dropped off in a place where it couldn't transmit and just recently someone found it under their house in Mammoth. So she had moved into Mammoth, out of Mammoth, and back. But to answer your question, she was not, it was not a reproductive year for that female, but she was very much a reproductive age, old, healthy female.

30:36 So M.H.G. either had just weaned yearlings that year or bears exhibit delayed implantation where they essentially take or can become pregnant in response to their body condition and how.

31:02 But they, like, all the black bears hibernate in the winter? Or, like, I just am surprised by your question, saying that the lake was frozen and it walked across. Yeah, okay, sorry. So black bears aren't true, necessary, you know, it's, what's the word I'm looking for? Yeah, they don't have to hibernate every year. Obligate. Yeah, they're not obligate to hibernate very soon. So if they, if it's a year with, you know, low snow.

31:30 ...levels or high food abundance or, I mean... Warm. ...yeah, very warm. I've worked in areas too where, you know, in developed areas where there's a lot of anthropogenic food around. You know, some bears, especially males, just won't bend up. But then the last two winters, for example, there were relatively warm spells throughout it. And if a female doesn't have tiny dependent cubs of the year that aren't very mobile or has yearlings or either virus help...

32:00 They might get up and move and go and forage during those warm spells. They might have three, four dens during that season before they... Okay, that makes sense. Thank you. Yeah, and so this is an example of another winter capture. This was a female who had some yearlings who was moving around and was involved in some conflict here in town. She was fitted with a GPS collar and had...

32:31 She's been monitored for the last couple of years. And again, she spent a lot of time in town, but also would take these annual adventures up over the crest and either for denning or during hyperphasia to go feed on natural foods out there and then return back to Mammoth. And then on the other end of the spectrum, we have a bear like this one, which is an old female.

32:57 Bear who spends the vast majority of her home range is located out in the Glass Mountains with only very infrequent small ventures into Mammoth. And that's markings just for one bear? Yeah, that was just from one bear over a period of two years. So Mammoth does exist in excellent bear habitat and has been suggested to support

33:30 Two times the density of bears than a similar wildland area. And we see there's also a lot of recreation that occurs out here. There's a lot of visitation annually. And for this reason, we have really high levels and probabilities of human-bear conflict. And this is an aspect that we deal with.

34:00 Quite heavily this time of year especially as bears are out moving around people are recreating more in this area and there's just a lot of overlap and unfortunately a lot of conflict and so CDFW policy first and foremost is to store and manage attractants and food and not getting bears the opportunity to obtain human food and

34:29 Begin these behaviors of habituation and food conditioning and food seeking behaviors. Quick question on that. When you're looking at the activity from the collared bears, can you zoom in when you see them in Mammoth, you know, you've got the size of the map here. Can you zoom that in to see what areas in Mammoth they are frequenting most? Absolutely. Because I believe that would help with people who are baiting or feeding. It would be easier for you and us to then

34:59 Enforce that? Because we used to have several people in town that literally would leave 50-pound bags of dog food out. Sure, yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's a little more complicated than that. The way, like, it's never going to replace people on the ground saying, this is occurring in this campsite at this place or in this location. We're regularly seeing bears. I mean, we also only, at the moment, we only have four bears with GPS collars.

35:31 In and around Mammoth, one of which is that female who's up over the crest right now. But the way these collars work is they collect data at an interval of fixes. And so it's also a balance with battery life. If we in real time were getting data from these collars, they would last a couple of days. So to get the duration of data, we have a fixed rate. And for animals that we need to

36:00 Monitor more closely, we can increase that fixed rate, but generally that's, we're getting data once a day, and so we'll get a drop of maybe six, ten points, and from what we can tell from that data, oh, this bear's frequenting, say, this campground, and that's corresponding, or correlating with these reports we're getting, and that fits the description of this animal, but also can very much show us where problems.

36:28 If we're not getting reports in a certain area, but we're noticing that a bear that we know has exhibited these kind of behaviors and has learned to get food off people in the past, and it's continuously clustering in one area, there's probably something going on there that is worth going to look like baiting or some kind of food or attractant management issues. Yeah, that's a very good point, but these are

36:59 These are just tools, and they come with limitations, and it's really part of what I wanted to convey is that by us using these tools in collaboration with all of you and all of the community members, they can really be helpful as a cohesive unit. So again, we prioritize non-lethal actions and responses to bears, especially

37:28 Early in the development of these behaviors where we can stop the progression of these conflict-related behaviors, that can include negative conditioning and closely monitoring animals to try to really focus on specific areas in a specific animal. However, a depredation permit process does exist within CDFW where members of the public can

37:57 Apply for depredation permits through the department and those can be either lethal or non-lethal. Wildlife depredation permits and non-lethal permit is fairly common for a species like a bear when someone's having damages occur. Generally that's the initial permit that someone will get which will essentially allow the permittee to use negative conditioning tactics that they otherwise might not.

38:28 Be able to and like less than lethal projectile rounds, but that's also more often than not going to come with a attractant management discussion with that property owner as well. A question about that. In town, you wouldn't be issuing permits like that. Yeah, it becomes very challenging in communities that don't have

38:57 Well, you can't discharge a firearm in Mammoth or any of these Eastern Sierra communities. So that does become very challenging. But in those cases, you know, we're documenting this. We're also visiting these sites and we're looking at the situation as a whole. And there are tools you can use that we can include on the depredation permits that can protect the property owner from

39:27 You know, allegations of wildlife harassment or the legal ramifications like that. But an individual can't really discharge any kind of firearm or even non-lethal firearm in town, correct? Is that Chief? I noticed the question was directed at me when Michael turned and looked at me. So can you repeat the question, please? Yeah, of course. I'm sorry. Oh, I was asking because Michael was talking about these

40:07 Depredation? Depredation permits, thank you. And I said, though, for a private citizen in the town, there's no, like, option for them to be discharging any kind of firearm, lethal or non-lethal in town, correct? Within town limits, that's correct. So, okay, so this would be, like, outside of town. I mean, we issue these within town, too, but, you know, there are non-firearms related. Right.

40:38 So there would be no scenario where there was a lethal permit given to a member in town? Like, that's just not a thing. Pretty. I mean, Danny Gammons. My name's Danny Gammons. I'm the supervisor down at Bishop. It's a difficult question to answer. I don't want to say no, never, because when we issue depredation permits to the public, it's the public's

41:13 responsibility to understand, you know, whatever jurisdiction, whatever the laws are of their local area, the department is not going to decide those things for them. Having said that, you know, because it, we're aware that there are limitations to what people can and can't do within town.

41:38 I don't know if that clears things up a lot, but I think the important thing is that the responsibility for knowing what the rules are lies with the landowner, and we can advise as much as we can. Okay. It would just, go ahead, Bill, because I'm curious what you have to say about this. Interesting because what we're hearing here is that you can't discharge a firearm in town, and of course we have codes against that. However, it was for self-protection.

42:04 But, yeah, public safety threat, you know, if they have a depredation permit or if they don't have a depredation permit and a bear is in a house and threatening the lives of the family, the family is going to do what they need to do to protect themselves and their family. Okay. I do think it would be really important for us to clarify for the community because, like, I hadn't really thought about that before, but, you know, wherever possible to make it super clear, like, what you can and can't do in town because...

42:37 You can't recreationally discharge a firearm in town. You can't go target shooting in town. That's kind of a specific question, but are you allowed to shoot a bear with a BB gun if a bear is on your property or no? No. No. Like if he's breaking into your house, you could shoot it with a BB gun or...

42:59 No, I don't know. This comes up because I... Look, it's extenuating circumstances, right? So we can what if it all night long, but it depends on what the homeowner is feeling at the time. If the homeowner believes that that level of force is justified, they're going to have to justify it in the court of law as well. Okay. Not saying that anybody's going to be arrested. They may or may not be, depending on the circumstances for discharging a firearm in town or cited for discharging a firearm in town.

43:29 But it's extenuating circumstances and it really depends on what that person is feeling at the time they feel their life is threatened. Okay. And I don't think a BB gun is going to do much. Well, but that's included in our firearm, like in the ban of using firearms in town. A BB gun is included. Well, a BB gun and a pellet gun are usually allowed. They are allowed. Yeah, if they're, you know.

43:57 Safe and kids or family members or parents are with them. Well, don't tell my kids. But a firearm being, being a, you know, something that has a little bit more behind it than a BB gun. Okay, not a BB gun. So you can't shoot a BB gun in town if you're being supervised by your parents. Yes. Is a shotgun a BB gun? Sorry, I couldn't resist. Okay. Thank you.

44:25 That being said, I wouldn't use a BB gun or a pellet gun to try to haze a bear either because, you know, while it's not going to likely kill an animal, it certainly would embed an injury potentially. So, yeah, also included in, you know, our response to conflict in a call that we get and respond to is what we refer to as no harm, no foul animal, and that's an animal which is basically outside of natural habitat.

44:57 Say, in development, sometimes animals become trapped in structures or something like that, and we will capture the animal and move it to the nearest suitable habitat for release. Again, any animal that we're handling, we're more than likely going to mark for future monitoring. It doesn't necessarily mean a GPS collar, but usually at least a gear tag and a pin tag so that animal can be identified in the future.

45:26 And, you know, all these conflict situations are evaluated and responded to on a case-by-case basis. There's no if X occurs, then Y is happening, or a strike system, or anything of that sort. This is all situation-dependent, and these are decisions that are being made by a response guidance team, dependent on the circumstances and the animal involved.

45:57 I'd like to talk about an aspect of bear behavior that I think is very important as it relates to conflict, and that's habituation and food conditioning and the differentiation between these two behavioral types. So bears innately have a fear of humans and they tend to avoid development and people in general. However, over repeated exposure,

46:26 To people and development based on experience or the lack of negative interactions, they can lose this weariness of people and essentially just become comfortable in and around development and people. And it doesn't necessarily mean that that animal is causing damage or it's getting into food or being rewarded by human food at all.

46:54 It just means that it has now lost that fear of people and it is though at higher risk of obtaining those foods just because of proximity. And it very often leads to what is referred to as food conditioning. And this is a learned behavior where a bear has learned and made an association between people and anthropogenic food, which is incredibly valuable to a bear.

47:22 And will start to change its behavior to seek out and obtain that food. And they can become very persistent and aggressive in obtaining that food when that food conditioning occurs, even at a very low frequency. The obtaining human food and the high...

47:50 Caloric reward event is just incredibly powerful to a bear. And therein lies the conflict and that progression from habituation to food conditioning. And so just to reiterate, habituation is the precursor to food conditioning in conflict in that bears that are comfortable in and around development are at a much higher risk of running across unsecured food.

48:19 And obtaining that food, becoming food conditioned, and thus conflict. And then bears that are habituated or food conditioned are just at higher risk in general of mortality, whether that be through depredation, vehicle collisions, or injury itself from the foods or poisons they're eating or the structures they're exploiting to get in here, to get into that food.

48:46 And so discouraging habituation and hearing about it and getting these reports is something that I really want to stress. And I try to tell people because I think that is something that is not necessarily that obvious to a lot of people if a bear is just being seen, maybe walking through town, regularly showing up at campgrounds, but very comfortable with people and not getting into.

49:17 What do you think is important for us to be able to do that?

49:47 And I wanted to show, you know, this is a good example of a butchered bear. This is from Yosemite Valley, but this very well could be Mammoth Lakes. It's a scene that I'm sure many of us have seen where there's a bear that is completely unreactive to people walking through large crowds or maybe even being surrounded by people and may not be getting into food or causing any damages or certainly not being aggressive towards anyone, but especially in an area where

50:18 Food storage and attracting storage is just not completely locked down or anywhere near as good as it could be in a national park. Like the opportunity for a bear to get into that food is just so high. So I mentioned early intervention. At this habituation stage and at these very initial food-seeking behaviors before they're getting food conditioned or the earlier we can intervene, the better.

50:51 And the better chance at curbing that behavior before it progresses and becomes too ingrained, the better those chances are. And so the reaction of that bear can depend on various things, including the experience that bear has had with human development, getting food before, the negative interactions it's had with people, and the consistency of these interactions. Also, the natural food availability on the landscape. If we're going through a drought, and say some of our...

51:19 Natural food crops such as mast, pinions, or acorns are low that year during this hyperphagia stage, especially bears that have experience with human food may be more likely to return to anthropogenic sources too. May I ask a question with this picture? What's happening in the photo? Yeah, so this is a young bear that was caught in town.

51:47 And it is being released just outside of town and is being negatively conditioned with a paintball gun and released with a GPS collar and a tag. So the paintball gun, it doesn't hurt them, but it's like loud and it hurts or how does it? It provides a little bit of physical stimulation. Definitely doesn't hurt the bear. But I mean, it doesn't like injure them, but it doesn't injure the bear. It provides some uncomfortable.

52:16 Discomfort to the animal to some degree. And, you know, it's also just a, it's an aggressive action that we as humans can take that isn't going to harm the bear, but it's going to hopefully reinforce that. Instill a fear of humans? Yeah, exactly. Okay. Thank you. You know, for more of the life history of the bear, such as the age, I mentioned those yearlings before.

52:43 You know, those newly dispersed yearlings, if they're starting to be seen regularly in campgrounds and starting to come in and around people and perhaps maybe even getting a little bit of food, that period of time, that sensitive period is probably the most successful we can be for that, especially for that age class because they're really finding their own home range, finding their own foraging patterns.

53:12 You know, ingraining that behavior and the behavioral trajectory that they're on. And then reproductive status, cubs that are reared from bears in development, around development, and especially been taught and involved in conflict by their mother are much, much more likely to continue that behavior as they progress through life.

53:42 So I thought this was a really good local example of early intervention. This was that bear from a previous slide. And so this bear, through early reporting, we were able to get reports of this bear regularly occurring on porches, approaching residents, approaching people.

54:10 Was getting into some bird feeders, hadn't necessarily started getting into human food, but was one of these typical young bears that was starting to exhibit these highly habituated and slightly food-seeking behaviors. So we were able to trap this animal, fit it with a GPS collar, and release it just outside of town by this orange dot over here. And as you can see from this GPS,

54:40 This bear never returned to Mammoth Lakes, and it still remains to this day up above the lakes basin and is currently right there right there right now. You know interestingly enough this is one that was highly publicized and it you know was was really communicated a lot of information over social media about how

55:07 This bear and another bear that was captured at this residence were euthanized and that's why you don't see them anymore and whatnot. And the fact that we can follow this bear with this GPS data and really illustrate this success story is, I think, a really valuable piece of information and a really great example of how early intervention, especially with these young bears, can be really successful.

55:37 And so I briefly talked about this generational transfer of behavior with females teaching their cubs these behaviors of obtaining anthropogenic food and causing damages such as breaking into cars, breaking into houses, approaching people. And that can just be really, really powerful. And we've seen this time and time again where a bear has cubs, raises cubs, teaches them.

56:08 How to do this. The cubs then disperse his yearlings and just perpetuate that behavior and that's all they know and it can become really, really difficult to change those bears' behavior once that behavior has just become so ingrained their whole life and there's an association with development and this really valuable food reward. And so this is another example of just that where we have

56:39 This bear is currently up at Mammoth Mountain, but for the last year now, she has been frequenting the parking lots up in Mammoth Mountain and breaking into vehicles. Last year she was captured with two cubs who were also involved in all of those conflicts, and those cubs have scents.

57:06 The map I put on here just to kind of illustrate that while she does make

57:34 These movements out into the backcountry and spend time in the wild. Once she returns to town, you know, these behaviors are just very ingrained and she goes right back to doing exactly what she was doing when we captured her. So we record human bear conflict. This figure on the left is able to compile reports that we've received just this year.

58:07 As you can see, Mammoth Lakes is the highest source of conflicts. And we also record these incidents by damage type and severity. And so it's something that is fairly suggestive of that progression of behavioral severity, for a better word, where you're having a much higher number of these lower level just attracting.

58:36 Bears obtaining human food or lower level damages and fewer higher severity cases like vehicle break-ins and home break-ins. So am I reading that right that you got one report of a vehicle break-in last year in Mammoth Lakes? That's this year. That's this year. And so I do want to follow that up by I am very confident that this is not

59:06 Exactly all of what is going on. Have you read the police sheet? Yeah. This is just what we've been reported. Okay. And, you know, what I really hope I can get across is just the importance of reporting and the importance of reporting in a timely measure because, you know, I could see these numbers occurring on a nightly basis. Mm-hmm. And so.

59:35 This is just what we've gathered this year so far. And, you know, it is just really important and really, really a challenge that we all need to work together with in the communities to, to, you know, get these reports, but also, you know, have people comfortable in reporting these to us. So yeah, that's a good segue into what can we all do. So number one at the root of all of this,

1:00:09 is food and attractant storages, and that can be incredibly challenging in a place like mammals. Not providing the opportunities for these animals to become food conditioned in the first place is the number one thing we can do to protect these bears and to keep these bears as wild animals. But additionally, reporting any bear instances that include

1:00:38 Damages, conflict, that kind of thing, but also habituation to us as promptly and timely as that occurs. If we're getting reports as they're happening, that allows us to be reactive. While it's great to get reports in general, if we get reports months down the line or even weeks past when something was a problem,

1:01:05 That situation has likely already escalated into something else. And the chances of us being effective with that animal, it just makes it a lot more challenging. And so timely reporting is something that's really valuable to us. And the point I really wanted to make with the habituation and food conditioning discussion is that

1:01:33 By not tolerating habituated bears in and around development and actively discouraging them and getting community members on board with this as well, regardless of what this behavior is, if they're causing damages or not, that can just be a really important first step in stopping any of these behaviors before they progress and become ingrained and just reinstilling that fear of humans into these wild bears.

1:02:05 And education and communication with the visitors, with working together with all the agencies. We've been really fortunate to have such great discussions and interactions with all of these agencies and the town of Mammoth Lakes to really work together on getting this information out there, being transparent about what we're doing, what the goal is, and getting everyone.

1:02:34 On board and on the same page. So yeah, treat these bears with respect and to keep them as wild animals. And yeah, just to kind of reiterate a few points, once bears become food conditioned, even these well, even food that's stored properly in RVs and houses, places that should be secured food storage areas.

1:03:01 Those are, once a bear learns that it can break into RVs, it can break into houses. At that point, though, even well-secured food isn't safe, and that just becomes a really challenging situation. And for that reason, early reporting, timely, is something that's really important. So that allows us to intervene early with non-legal corrective measures to really curb that behavior before it becomes ingrained.

1:03:30 Tractant storage. I know that can be really challenging here, but getting people to report malfunctioning dumpsters or baiting situations or just repeated areas that are constantly having food storage issues. So we can work together to fix those and those aren't an opportunity for wild and naive bears who happen through town to.

1:03:59 Get into that food and create that association and become food condition bearers. And so these are the avenues we have for the department for reporting. We have our HWC hotline, which is a number anyone can call any time of day. It goes directly to a voicemail. They can leave a message with details of the incident, details about the

1:04:29 The animal that was involved. We'd prefer a contact number so that we could follow up and get any pertinent information, but if someone wants to anonymously labor report, that's a place you can do it as well. Similarly, we have our WIR system, our incident reporting system that is accessible at wildlife.ca.gov and following those links here.

1:04:58 Again, we ask that trash management and dumpster issues, those kind of things are reported to town in order to do us as well, just so we can get that taken care of and try to take a preventative approach. Thank you. I have one question for you. Of course. Do you have, like, your success rate for bears that you've relocated? I know you had that one story of a local bear. You know, we all remember which bear it is.

1:05:27 You know, and that seems like a successful bear relocation. Like, do you, like, I guess my question is, when the bears are relocated, you know, is it a suitable habitat always? Like, is there confrontation with other bears that are already in that habitat? Like, what's your success rate for relocating problem bears? Or do they just come back? Like, I thought that they had to go, I thought they had to be brought really far away in order to not just find their way back to town.

1:05:57 Yeah, I mean, we don't have the biggest sample size yet. It's something we're building off right now. And the success of these efforts really depend on the animal, the situation, and the experience of that animal. These younger animals that we catch early are generally a lot more successful than a really, really...

1:06:28 Ingrained behaviorally bear like that. But just to kind of focus on the aspect of relocation, when we're releasing a bear just out of town, we're not necessarily relocating that animal. A relocation is what we would consider basically taking an animal outside of its home range and putting it in a completely different home range.

1:06:56 And while that can certainly have a place with certain animals, specifically younger ones, or animals that aren't very progressed, generally we try to move away from relocation, especially with older animals or ones that are really, have really ingrained and progressed behaviors because

1:07:26 Either, just like you said, an animal, especially a male, is going to have, they have really strong homing mechanisms and they will travel large distances to get back and, you know, the few that we have done with those kind of animals, that's exactly what you see, that the animal just beelines it right back to its home range, or you're just moving the problem to a different community and then all of a sudden a bear that was, you know, heavily involved in

1:07:57 In terms of the success, you know, it really does depend on the animal. I think to put numbers to it,

1:08:29 It would be more appropriate to add variables in there like experience, age, sex, and the situational circumstances. Okay, thank you. Well, let's take questions from us and we'll do public comment. I think Brent has a question. Brent? Oh, just one question. See, now I know why they say there's one Uber driver in town and why they don't answer their phone. But when you say the numbers here contact, I just want to make sure we're clear on how we're...

1:08:58 Messaging to the public. If somebody has a dumpster that's being taken down or whatever, is that a call to wildlife or a call to the police department for animal control? I just want to make sure we're clear on what message we're given. We're both. I just want to make sure we're all on the same page of how we are sending a message back to the public. So as far as the police department's concerned, if we do get a call on a dumpster overflowing after hours, when I say after hours, it would be after the community service officer.

1:09:29 Or a police services technician are off duty. Our officers will respond to the area. What we usually do is it's a CAD entry. A CAD entry means it's within our system. So it was a call for service within our system. That call for service within our system then gets sent to Fish and Wildlife. So whether the officer takes action or not when they're at the dumpster and it's overflowing.

1:09:55 That information still goes back to Fish and Wildlife. So we compile our calls for service for bear calls on a weekly basis. We send those over to Fish and Wildlife to review. So if I need a call, it's best to call? Yeah, you would, any issue within town, you'd call us, and then we will contact Fish and Wildlife. I just want to make sure we're on the same. And again, that's just a little bit about tracking the animal behavior and that type of thing.

1:10:23 A lot of activity going on within the managing of the dumpsters and other trash issues like that. We've got, you know, code enforcement and other things that would follow up on that with, you know, human behavior that needs to be modified in order to prevent that. But I think this is tracking more just the wildlife aspect of it. Any other questions? I have a few, actually. One, more of a statement that hopefully you can back me up on. As we get better at training our bears so they don't become habituated.

1:10:54 We would expect them, it seems to me, to go back to more of their wild instincts. And we wouldn't see them in town as much because their foraging would occur at hours that are not common for people to be up. And they would range further than what we used to see. So, you know, we're told as council members that the reason we're not seeing any bears is because they've been killed. And I keep telling people, no, part of the reason we're not seeing any bears...

1:11:26 Is because our training has been good and they've gone back to a natural bear type pattern. Yeah, I mean, ideally that would be the case. I think certainly as bears are developing these levels of habituation and getting more and more involved in conflict, they're going to become more visible. So, you know, I think that...

1:12:00 You know, a very experienced and a bear with very ingrained conflict-related behavioral patterns is just going to be seen around town a lot more often. And so the fact that we're not seeing that is, yes, definitely a good thing. I don't think that means that bears are not getting in to attractants or bears aren't causing problems. I mean...

1:12:31 I think bears are still being seen, but also, you know, they have a nocturnal component as well, where especially if they are, you know, getting involved in conflict but are still have a little bit of wariness around people and aren't, you know, just overly bold, you know, they may change their behavior to be completely nocturnal or to be, you know.

1:12:59 Bears can be super elusive if they want to. I mean, I spend most of my time looking for bears. I don't see them that often. But yeah, I mean, definitely. And I do want to kind of make the point that seeing bears is awesome. I love seeing bears. Everyone loves seeing bears. Many people come to mammals to see bears. It's a major part of living in the woods and living in bear country. And it's just a...

1:13:28 They're just an amazing animal. And I'm not trying to discourage people from seeing bears. What I would encourage is that we maintain the ability to see these bears as wild animals in their wild natural environment.

1:13:50 I just, you know, I think it's disrespectful to bears. I think it's sad when I see an animal that has completely changed its behavior to be dependent on human food and is eating nothing but trash. I mean, I'm sure many of you have seen the aftermath of, you know, a bear that's regularly been getting in a dumpster and strewn food and trash and all kinds of things everywhere.

1:14:19 I mean, the things that I've found in bear scat is just incredible. And I'd like to just, you know, make that clear that, you know, seeing bears is an important part of living in bear country. And it's a positive thing when we don't want to see bears not acting like bears. So, moving on from that, should, I do, should people be hazing bears?

1:14:50 to help keep them afraid, and what technique would you recommend then to haze those bears away safely? Yeah, and so I'm not asking everyone to, you know, go out of their way and put themselves at, you know, potential risk or in a very confrontational situation with a bear by actively going around and, you know, chasing bears away. It can, but that being said, the consistency

1:15:19 And frequency of these negative interactions and this negative conditioning is incredibly important for bears and that coming from multiple sources. I mean, me or Chief Casabian or the Mammoth PD or anyone going around and hazing a bear once or twice that's getting into a bear locker probably is going to result in that bear being avoidant of Mammoth PD vehicles.

1:15:49 Fish and Wildlife personnel and then not really changing that bear's behavior at all because the vast majority of the interactions it's having with people are positive and it's gaining rewards from that. So what I will say is that the simple act of if a bear is walking into development or in and around the campground or

1:16:17 Something like that, or even getting into food. Just being loud, yelling at the animal, get out of here, bear. You know, if the majority of the time, like, if that bear is not super habituated, that bear is going to run off, and that's going to be an important event. Not necessarily just once, but, you know, that consistency of happening every time it interacts with people.

1:16:44 You know, those are the associations that can be made and can be really helpful. Any more questions, Bill? No, I think that'll do it. Thank you. Do you have a question? Brent asked my main question. But I guess, yeah, like yelling at the bear and telling it to get out of here, is it noise? Like, do they, or is it the human that they're responding to? I'm just curious, because, like, could you beep your horn if they're, like, you know, set off your car alarm to make it? Yeah, car alarms.

1:17:14 And so, you know, they're just being aggressive. Okay. I am dominant. I am, I am, like, here to chase you away. So, I want to go back on that one more time. So, in my house, I have three different spots where I keep air horns with cans under them. Yeah. Almost no space. So, that's what I was asking. Is it recommended that those be used to help?

1:17:43 Train the bear to be afraid of those humans. Not all of us can stand up and make the bear think we're bigger than that. Yeah, an air horn will certainly be, I would certainly suggest using that. Any other questions? No. Okay. Can we take public comment? Real quick, I did want to mention one thing. Just want to reiterate some of the efforts that we're continuing to try to do, in particular in the Mammoth Lakes Basin, obviously a pretty high area of

1:18:14 Human-Bear interaction, lots of campers, things like that. We'll continue our efforts with education directly in those campgrounds through the host program on weekends, holiday Mondays, things of that nature. The chief was there as well, as well as Danny and Michael. We went and spoke to all of the camp hosts, gave them an ungodly amount of handouts to give to people, which involved reporting forms, how to behave, how to store your food properly. And I think that really highlights just...

1:18:44 Collaboration with all of us and getting all on the same page, developing that rapport, that mutual understanding of what we're all facing here in this community and moving forward from there in a really positive manner. I think the other thing is obviously knowledge is power, right, in these circumstances, getting this information from the folks who manage these bears for a living.

1:19:06 I think it's really, really beneficial for all of us. And again, I want to reiterate to folks, and we reiterated this to the camp hosts as well, who actually shared this feeling. There seems to be a sentiment, and this was mentioned before, that if you report on a bear, that will result in the bear getting euthanized. That cannot be further from the truth. In fact, reporting on that bear as quickly, as early as possible, as we've learned this evening, can often save that bear's life. So I do want to reiterate that. The chief had a few words as well.

1:19:34 Just real quick, I'd like to go back to the depredation permit just to give council and our public a clear understanding of how that works. And I'll ask Danny to come up in just a second. But with my experience with depredation permits in law enforcement, we're notified, we have been in the past notified, not with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department or town. I'm not sure if any depredation permit's been issued in the town. But we're usually notified if a depredation permit is issued.

1:20:01 Whether it's lethal or less lethal. So with that said, I'd like Danny to come up and maybe explain just a little bit on how a depredation permit works. I appreciate it, Danny. Thank you.

1:20:13 Yeah, sure, no problem. Again, my name's Danny, Danny Gammon, Supervisor in the Bishop Office. So what did, especially on a lethal depredation permit, is what we're talking about specifically here, what that is, is in Fish and Game Code, you cannot legally shoot a bear unless you have a hunting license and it's in bear season and you're using all legal take methods and all that kind of stuff. So...

1:20:37 What a depredation permit is, is that it exempts you from the section of Fish and Game Code that says, you know, you poached that bear. So, you know, you can take it out of season. It doesn't have anything to do with firearms or anything like that, or local ordinances, or it's an exemption from Fish and Game Code.

1:20:57 And one thing that I should have clarified earlier, and I don't, Mike, you did, I'm not sure, but I think it's important to understand about how the process works is when a homeowner, if a homeowner calls and says, hey, I got a bear on my property, I want a depredation permit, it's not quite so simple. The first thing that we're going to do is we're going to look at

1:21:20 What has been done to mitigate the problem in the first place? And if attractants aren't being managed, if there's garbage unsecured, I mean, we'll just right off the bat, it won't happen. It's a give and take. The landowner has got to put some serious effort into mitigating the problem in the first place. And then beyond that, if it does get to a stage where alternatives have been exhausted,

1:21:49 And we're moving towards a potential for allowing a lethal take of an animal. We locally, myself, my supervisor, we do not make that decision. We have what's called a response guidance team that covers the entire state. So all requests for lethal depredation permits go through them. Those decisions are not even made locally.

1:22:16 Those are made by a team comprised of, there's usually a law enforcement person on there, a wildlife person. And to be completely honest, I'm not even sure who all is on the response guidance team exactly. But I know we will make recommendations at the local level here in Bishop and then the responses given back by that team. So all decisions are made.

1:22:44 I think more or less consistently across the state. And so hopefully that helps. Thank you. Mayor Rice, I'd like to add a couple things just if I may. You know, because obviously this is a lot about bear behavior, bear activity. And so what the town has been working on, you know, what else is the town doing? Allison just talked about our host program and that.

1:23:11 You know, sort of effective engagement up in these high interaction areas.

1:23:15 But we also have made modifications to our enforcement abilities within trash management. And our partnerships with Mammoth Disposal have been very helpful in identifying repetitive problems, especially the dumpsters and things that people get into. The Third Eye program is one in which the vehicle picking up the trash will actually take a picture of a dumpster if it's an irregular shape, meaning that it's open or somehow overflowing.

1:23:42 And we will get an update of that every week. It shows who was it, shows the picture of it, the address where the service was located. And then our code enforcement team logs that in our tracking so we know exactly what it is. And they will interact with every single one of those to make sure that situations were sort of understood, people are clear about that. And if there's a problem, we start issuing citations. In the last year, we've issued citations up to $1,000.

1:24:10 for repetitive problems and those have been brought into better compliance through those efforts. And again, our efforts are really for compliance more than they are for fines. But I want to kind of add that in. There's more of a human conditioning element here as well that we're working on within the town and prioritizing that with town effort. So I wanted to add that to this conversation. So thank you. Thank you. Any public comment from anyone in the room?

1:24:39 Is there any public comment from anyone online? So I would, I'd just love to hear, I have a little, a couple more thoughts. I don't know if you guys have any thoughts to share or everybody got their questions out. Thank you so much for coming tonight. I feel like seeing this presentation, you know, it helps with the transparency. My personal opinion on the matter is I feel like the general feeling of people in town is, you know, like people don't see anything wrong with,

1:25:09 Seeing a bear on the golf course during the middle of the day. Like, you know, it's hard. I feel like the bears hold such a special place in everyone's heart in town that it's hard to see, you know, like the bear walking down my street or I have a bear that sometimes walks behind my house. It's hard to see that that is like a problematic interaction or it's hard to kind of connect that that could potentially be harmful for the bear. You know, I guess.

1:25:39 From your presentation tonight, it's more about the bear's perception of me. If I'm sitting outside of my house and the bear's walking by and gets close to me and just keeps walking, that's problematic. But maybe if I'm in my house and the bear's walking by and there are no people around, then that's not problematic. I feel like there's kind of a lack of trust by the citizens of Mammoth and that...

1:26:06 There's definitely a worry where it's like that bear that is a success story for you, you know, from everyone else's point of view, the bear is here and then you take it and then the bear is gone and they don't see it again. So they kind of, you know, like that informational piece of the bear is doing great. Here's a picture of that same bear. The bear is alive and well. Please don't worry. Like this was the best case scenario for this bear and it's thriving. So just for me, I feel like this presentation is super helpful, but I feel like

1:26:34 You know, the town, like we all kind of need to work on the public perception of how you guys manage the bears and that you're not trying to kill the bears. You know, like you're not like, oh, that bears, I mean, you did a great job tonight saying like, oh, the ear tags don't mean, oh, it's on its second, that's its second ding. And if you call, then the bear is going to be put down. So I really appreciate all your knowledge.

1:27:00 You know, you're really professional. And I hope that we can kind of build some trust with the public and that people can feel confident making reported sightings of bears so that we can keep our bears safe. And it seems like the best practice is keeping the yearlings from being habituated to human activity. So thank you so much for coming tonight. Are there any other comments? Nope.

1:27:31 Okay. Thank you so much. So we are going to move right along to item seven, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Hi, welcome. Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Councilmembers and members of the public.

1:27:58 I'm Emily Zajewski. I'm the Sustainability Coordinator for the town. And I'm here with Cassidy from Mammoth Disposal and Lawson also from the town. And we're here to provide an update on Town Cleanup Day 2026. Who wants to start? Can we go first? You go first. You got the big stuff.

1:28:18 Good evening, Council. Nice to see you. So today I will be reporting on the collection event at the Transfer Station and Town Yard on May 15th and 16th. We trialed a new layout and check-in process this year, which proved to be efficient. At the Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station, we collected roughly 49 tires, 23 mattresses, 45 pounds of batteries, 280 gallons of paint,

1:28:46 And one ton of electronics. At the town yard, volunteers collected 12 tons of miscellaneous metal waste and just under 18 tons of bulky materials. We did about 20 loads to Pumice Valley landfill with some specialty materials staying to be processed at Mammoth disposal. Overall, we collected about 1,000 tons of waste, all at no cost to Town of Mammoth Lakes residents.

1:29:13 As we continue refining the drop-off flow and building stronger volunteer engagement, we're excited to carry that momentum into future cleanup events. And I think we have a little bit more to share about our other specialty collections, too. Can I? Question? Yeah. So one of the issues, I took several cans of paint down that didn't have labels, so they were refused. And at the paint store when I was in there yesterday, a family came in trying to get rid of stuff that Disposal had refused.

1:29:43 How do you get rid of that? Yes, that is a great question. So part of the reason why we have to refuse some stuff is because this is actually a state-ran program called Paint Care, and they set limitations on the size and what types of paints we are allowed to accept. One of those being if it's unmarked, we cannot take it and test it. So it's better to just turn those away, but Pumice Valley Landfill in Lee Vining does accept those. Thank you.

1:30:15 Hello, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Another component we tried to build into Town Cleanup Day this year is through the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Task Force and removal of green waste from our community, something that we've been targeting since the creation of the task force, and I just wanted to provide some numbers with the caveat being what was a little bit different this year is we put out roughly 17 green waste roll-off dumpsters, huge ones, all across town.

1:30:43 And as a result of that, just to paint a little picture, I believe in recent memory, 2023 was our biggest year for green waste. There was 41 tons. This year we had, and that was all at the transfer station, right? No green waste roll-offs. This year we had 26 tons go through this transfer station and then another 52 tons from the roll-offs, totaling 78 tons.

1:31:09 of green waste pulled out of the community in effectively one weekend. Again, to paint a picture from our Wildfire Task Force presentations last year, we pulled out roughly 240 tons from the community through all of those efforts throughout the summer. So really in one weekend, we got basically a quarter of what we pulled out last year. So incredibly successful. I don't say this to, you know, pat the towns back or pat Mammoth Fire Protection Districts back, but the members of this community.

1:31:39 They are the ones who got rid of this green waste, brought this to either the transfer station or the green waste facilities. Obviously, again, always appreciate the help from Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, but I just want to give a huge thanks to the community for utilizing those facilities and getting green waste off the landscape. And last time, were people pretty good about just putting green waste into those facilities? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. And speaking of awesome community efforts,

1:32:11 We had our community cleanup that was held only on Saturday based out of the Community Recreation Center at the CRC combined with the second annual sustainability fair. This year we had much better weather compared to last year if you all remember the windy, cold, snowy, very strange day that had occurred last year. So all in all we had very many different groups of volunteers representing multiple different community organizations from teams, businesses, professional associations, schools, the hospital, hospitality and tourism.

1:32:41 Thank you so much.

1:32:50 And due to the work of these amazing volunteers, we pulled over one ton of litter on Saturday alone that was delivered to the CRC. Cassidy and I weighed a majority of that, but the things that we couldn't weigh were large metal pipes, heavy metal items, mangled shopping carts, and the teeny tiny little bits of plastic that people very meticulously removed from our trails, pathways, and roadways around town. So again, have to give a huge shout out to the community for showing up on Saturday.

1:33:19 The sustainability fair was also a success. We had about 150 to 200 people show up, ranging from very, very small young folks to older community members, which was great to see how many people wanted to come out and engage with sustainability, whether that was in the kind of the

1:33:37 Realm of waste, wildfire, water, public utilities, transportation, recreation, or just overall community and education and wellness as well. So that was really amazing to see. We had 19 different organizations participate in the fair representing all of those different groups as well. So huge thank you to everyone who helped out during the day, whether you were a volunteer, town staff, Mammoth Disposal, shout out to the truck drivers who were

1:34:01 Traveling around town. And thank you to those that also helped grill and support those very hardworking and tired and hungry volunteers. So this event was a great success. Thank you to the community. We couldn't have done it without you all and from your support. So I'm excited to run it back again next year. Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you for the update. Are you coming back up, Lawson? Indeed. Lawson Reif, Outdoor Recreation Manager. I am sure many of you have noticed various closures.

1:34:33 And impacts from the forest health work going on in our community. I wanted to provide some updates on those for you. The first thing I want to reiterate is this has certainly been a collaborative effort between White Park, obviously Public Works, Parks and Recreation for things going on in Shady Rast. So I want to thank all those entities as well for helping with all of this. So let's start with the Mammoth Scenic Loop. That one's been going on for a little bit. We are hoping to have that work completed this Friday.

1:35:02 That is the goal. I'm going to have some meetings tomorrow to hopefully clarify that. But the goal is to be done with any of the tree removal work that could impact the road and public safety by Friday with the hope of reopening that for the weekend. I will keep everyone posted and hopefully for one of Rob's weekend updates for everyone as well.

1:35:24 So scenic loop hopefully coming to an end. The work looks very, very good out there. And I think it will be a little bit of a different change for folks if they've seen some of the other work going on in the area, but it looks very, very good out there. Shady rest. Shady rest. So sawmill cutoff road was closed this Monday and it will be closed through 5 p.m. this Friday. It will then reopen for the weekend.

1:35:54 Close Monday at 7 a.m. next Monday through Friday at 5 p.m. We are hoping the work, that is the longest stretch that that will be closed. We are hoping all of the work is completed in a much shorter time frame than that. But that is what we are looking at right now. So again, it will be open this weekend. They have already started work. They're moving very, very efficiently.

1:36:16 We thank members of the community for respecting the closure and using the detour on sawmill unpaved road into the backside of the park. So we are very, very grateful for that. Then when this is done, it will phase out to the eastern sections. So basically all the stuff that's open now and the detour will then be closed, which will include sawmill dirt road, the disc golf course will remain closed, and some of those eastern portions of the park will be worked on.

1:36:46 And as a result of that, you know, sawmill cutoff, the paved road, the normal way into the park will be open. Then there will be a third phase that occurs more on national forest land north of the park. That could have some impacts to the Knowles Loop, which of course we will mitigate those impacts to the best of our ability. So again, I know this has some pretty drastic impacts on folks. Huge thanks to Mammoth Lakes Mammoth Fire for running a shuttle for the kids.

1:37:16 To get to either baseball games or baseball practice. Again, that leaves from Station 1 right there on Main Street at 4 o'clock and then pick up from Shady Breast Park at 7.15 p.m. So again, we are very, very grateful for that. But this is not done. Starting next Monday, which is June 8th, I believe, work on Lake Mary Road will be commencing. And that work on Lake Mary Road will result in up to 15 to 30 minute delays.

1:37:45 Traffic Control Provided by Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. This work will be happening starting on, sorry I'm getting to my notes here, the 8th through the 11th, which is Monday through Thursday, where there will be that temporary traffic control, delays up to 15 to 30 minutes, then it will be open Friday through the weekend, and then again the following week, Monday through Thursday.

1:38:12 But we do sincerely believe that it is entirely possible, and I will keep folks posted, that this work could be completed in that first week. That is what we are going to be shooting for. Whitebark will be going door to door with residents affected along Lake Mary Road, primarily Juniper Road, and knocking on every single door of either apartment complexes or homes in that area to relay that information to them. So again, big thanks to...

1:38:40 Big thanks to White Park for that. Also, some trails on Mammoth Mountain will be closed and affected because of that, which would include Juniper Trail, Lakes Trail, and Paper Route that will be closed during the time that this work is occurring. So where on Lake Mary Road is that? This will basically be between Juniper all the way up to the Twin Lakes parking area bus stop turnaround. Yep. To do some immediately adjacent to the road. Forest Health work.

1:39:10 Okay. And then the Shady Rest closure, are the soccer fields open or only the baseball diamonds are open? So right now, let me make sure I have my things straight here. Right now the soccer fields are not open, but when this is done the next phase, the soccer fields will be open because they're working on the eastern side of the park. And the baseball diamonds will be open during that next phase as well? Okay. Yep, yep.

1:39:36 We tried our hardest. We know how important Shady Rest Park is to the community. We know how important it is to the children of this community as well as the parents and tried to do our best to keep the access open. I know it's difficult to keep track of everything. If you do go to Town of Mammoth Lake's website right on the homepage, there will be a bubble that says Shady Rest Park and the impacts that will be occurring there. You can click on that bubble and get the most up-to-date information. I've taken the road twice already this week. It's not terrible.

1:40:05 It's pretty good. There's a couple little narrow spots, but it was better than expected, and it wasn't as slow as I thought it was. Yeah, I coordinated with the county. That is a county-maintained road to get that road graded prior to this work, and then Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District is actually going out with their water truck and just watering it lightly, not too much, because then it'll get rutted out to keep that dust down, hopefully make things a little smoother. Well, thank you. Thank you. Any question? Yeah, just remind us, though, you threw out a lot of closures in that whole statement of things.

1:40:35 Where am I looking to find out all information once upon? Town of Mammoth Lakes, social medias. That's going to be one of your, that's going to be your best location to get all of this information. We piggyback on that with our kind of trail specific one, the Mammoth Lakes trail system. But Town of Mammoth Lakes social media is a great place to get all of that information. We'll also be updating the website as details are worked out on closures later down the road. Great.

1:41:05 Anything else? Anybody? Do you have more? Yes. Real quick, Trashy Thursday was mentioned. I want to plug some of our stewardship programs that will be occurring here. Trashy Thursday will be occurring coming up the last Thursday of the month. We have Trail Days this weekend, so Friday we have Trails Trivia and the beer release at 6 p.m. It's a single track red at Mammoth Brewing Company, so please join us for some trivia and that beer release.

1:41:33 And then for National Trails Day, we will be at Sherwin Meadows Trailhead at 9 a.m. As you all know, we are building brand new trail out there. So go build some trail. Trails Program Manager Andrew Mulford will also be installing trail signage that will support these trails. So please come out with us. What was the date on that? The trail? Pardon? You said it was National Trails Day, but I admit I do not know what the date is for National Trails Day. National Trails Day is technically the Saturday, which is... The 6th? June 6th? 6th. Okay. Yep.

1:42:02 Thank you. And then our first Wednesday work night will be coming up on June 10th. You can sign up for those and again go out and work on some new trail with Andrew. And then June 16th, Tangle Free Waters, clean the line, clean up at Convict Lake at 5 p.m. Great. Thank you. Thank you so much. Austin, will there be, this is just the first I've heard of work being done on Lake Mary and I feel like

1:42:29 All the other Whitebark things, we usually have a lot more notice. Is this a Whitebark program, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, or some combo? Yeah, it is part of the ESCCRP. Okay. We did know this work was coming. We just had no details in terms of when it would happen this summer, along with kind of the restrictions involved around it. We really just found out last week. Some of these things happened pretty quickly. We did put an initial social post out last week.

1:42:59 To try to alert the community and we will continue with that as well. Because people could reroute and go through the neighborhood and out past Eagle Lodge. Like they don't have to use...

1:43:11 Lake Mary. I think you'd have to use Old Mammoth Road. Like you're talking about past the Brit. It's like past the Eagle Lodge. It's past there. Oh, it's okay. I was thinking about. It's past the Eagle Lodge. So it doesn't impact the people in the neighborhood like the Eagle Lodge. That's what I was worried about. Yeah, around Eagle, it will. Juniper Ridge only has that one road. Yeah. We are hoping that impact to Juniper will be one day. Okay. And that will be done on the first day to get that over with to mitigate the impacts to those residents. Okay, but like, yeah, so.

1:43:38 Anybody in the lake basin will just be going down Old Mammoth Road during that time. Or doing the 15-minute delay. Yeah. But 15 to 30. Yeah, I generally want to be a little bit careful about Old Mammoth Road. That road's, you know, not the widest road and oftentimes not in the best shape. I think maybe putting some signage there because, like, we use Old Mammoth Road all the time.

1:44:01 To get up to the lakes basin. And people walk on it and they don't really realize that they're risking their lives. So maybe a little bit of that just to warn them that because some of those curves like by Mammoth Rock Trail, you know, it's pretty. So anyway, just a thought because I think it's really going to have impacts even during the week. I don't think you want people to take that as a detour. But then I'm saying put signage for the...

1:44:23 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:44:53 I appreciate you bringing up the desire to have a longer understanding of that. We recognize, certainly with the impacts of Shady Rest, that while we do have a pretty long notification of that, what the town needs to do is spend a little bit more time looking at anticipated impacts and developing strategies around that and trying to get that outwardly.

1:45:15 Condone the efforts of Lawson to get a lot of this stuff done in a very short amount of time. But I think the collective team needs to be working on this. And so we met with Whitebark the other day and decided that we were going to meet more frequently, talk about their plans as they're coming up, look at the anticipated impacts, develop programs and communication plans longer in advance, and get those things out into the community. So we recognize the current efforts.

1:45:45 Are probably putting too much stress on the community, and we're making modifications to that effort. Thank you. And you did say the Lake Mary Road, that was midweek, that it would be fully open on the weekends? Yeah, Monday through Thursday. Okay, thank you. And I just wanted to kind of reiterate where Chris was going, because someone comes visiting town, I'm used to go down to Shady Rest, put my kids down there, I can't go to Shady Rest, oh, let's go to Lake Space, and oh, I can't go to Lake Space, and now, oh, let's go to the scenic loop, I can't go to the scenic loop, so it's...

1:46:12 Not just local, it's about visitor expectations. Well, it's four days. Yeah, it'll be fine. As long, I think, you know. We need a fire fuel reduction, it'll be fine. You know, I totally agree. I think the main thing is, at this point, it's happening, so communication. It's always about communication, right? It's never about the thing. It's about how you tell people and if they feel heard and understood, right? You know, it's the same thing with our CDFW.

1:46:41 Colleagues, it's all about transparency and communication, and there's chance to do that with signage, and, you know, people will forgive you if you explain it to them. Yeah, and that's partially why I've been myself staffing the closure on sawmill cutoff, to communicate with those people directly that I'm turning around, telling them why we're doing this, telling them that there are other options, and...

1:47:03 Apologizing for the inconvenience. Absolutely. And that's great because, you know, yes, this work has to be done and we're getting it done during the week before 4th of July. So that's positive. Great. Any other updates? No? Okay. Thank you. Welcome. Oh, sorry. We're holding you hostage here. Thanks again. Thanks for coming, Michael. He's too polite.

1:47:28 Michael, you are too polite. Mayor Rice, I've got a few more things to add here. Okay. In particular, we've been working on this update to missing middle housing for the last several months, and we wanted to take a little bit of a pause at this council meeting just to kind of backtrack a little bit and level set what we're trying to achieve.

1:47:54 With this series, I think Marcus and Nolan have done an excellent job of putting this together. It's a very complex topic. And our goal is really to discuss it in enough detail that we get people to start understanding really what it means when we're talking about missing metal, what that challenge is, and then how we are hoping to approach that.

1:48:19 Because it is a little bit different than other models that we've used in town before, right, where they're highly subsidized. This one's really going to more focus around adding inventory to a specific price point that would allow for, you know, better accessibility for the community.

1:48:39 And just how we get through that process, right? And so these guys have put together really a good, thoughtful layout of, I'm going to say, bite-sized and consumable amounts of information at each of these presentation points. You know, really talking about it as a need, talking about, you know, what the ranges are in the incomes and what we're targeting, the rental rates that we're targeting, those types of things. And really, the last one, I think, was on the difficulty of getting this financed and accomplished.

1:49:08 At the end of this whole presentation, there's obviously a desire to understand council's perspective. We're really going to seek authorization from council. Is this a prioritized effort, right? Do we want to put all of our housing energies into this particular space? Because it's going to take that level of commitment to be able to do the things that are going to be required to be successful.

1:49:38 I wanted to pause instead of just continuing to hammer home a lot of these elements to say like this is a, I don't say a paradigm shift, but is a very significant discussion around what missing metal means and the direction that we need from council on actually going after that. So I'll pause there and see if either Marcus or Nolan have anything else to add for this particular today's presentation. But we did put it in the packet a little bit late that came out.

1:50:08 For you guys today, but it's real simple, one pager. But Nolan or Marcus? Nothing to add? Okay. And happy to answer any questions that you all have. We will re-engage with the presentations at the next council meeting and continue that process through to really what a program would look like. And again, just that level of commitment is substantial. And so understanding that that's the direction that council wants to go.

1:50:40 And understanding the severity of the situation and just the process and steps necessary is really imperative to make those decisions. Great, you have some questions? Mark, a little bit of just my thoughts on, without going into, I know you're going to look for deliberation, but I would appreciate when we look at the next time in terms of ranges because this talks about, I recognize we need 560 units, but that's a big commitment.

1:51:04 So I'll be looking to see, okay, what is the ranges? Because right now the prediction is our population is declining in the town. And is there, you know, the housing studies was very clear about our needs in all different categories. Is that amount really where we put all of our eggs in a basket? You know, I'm looking for us to carry the discussion where you're talking about, but, you know, what scale is really an appropriate scale given, like, entry, middle, and full bore kind of a discussion.

1:51:38 Are you asking us or are you asking staff that? No, I'm just saying, as a general portion, obviously we're not engaging this evening because they're going to come back and have a conversation, so I'm just looking for enough clarity when we have this discussion. Well, isn't this the discussion that we're having? Well, next meeting we're going to have a model project, which I think will address a lot of what you're talking about, the size and where it would go and what the rents, it gets into details of a model project, so I think that'll address a lot. Probably not going to do 560 all at once.

1:52:07 Yeah, and Skip, but also I appreciate, you know, you mentioned in here in terms of public-private partnerships because I think one also has to look at alternatives and how you fund certain things and what, at the other day, our resources are. We still have certain monies that are available, but how far do we want to leverage ourselves in that arena given how important this area is? What is the right response? Because I think that's a very good discussion to have. Sure.

1:52:33 I guess my feelings on this is that this is currently missing in our arsenal. The things that we're doing for housing, we have our bridge program, we have our homeownership bridge program where people can purchase units depending on what AMI they're in. We have low-income rentals at the parcel, but we don't have any middle-income rentals. And so I think that...

1:53:01 And this, it's kind of a hard puzzle piece to get because there are no state and federal dollars for it. And so, you know, I think personally for me, I would like to continue going after state and federal dollars for other projects that would qualify. But I think that like this is kind of the big ask that we're going to have to do on our own. The federal government and the state government are not coming to help us solve for this product.

1:53:29 You know, and I think that, I mean, I hear complaints about housing from people all the time in town. You know, that's kind of like the number one complaint. And I don't think, you know, looking at this, like, I kind of feel like it's hard, it's hard for me to give a lot of direction because there's no numbers or, you know, it's kind of like, well, I don't know, is this, would this project be?

1:53:57 Would it be $50 million? Would it be $5 million? It's kind of just kind of vague, but I feel like my general feelings are that this is missing from the current programs that we offer. So if there is a way for us to do this in a fiscally responsible way, but providing these products to our citizens, I would just love to do that. So those are my feelings.

1:54:27 So while Rob's filling with his... One second, please. This is a department head update. Okay. Good. It just said discussion item only. So I thought you wanted some discussion. It was supposed to be an agendized item and some miscommunications. It was moved. So we just wanted to kind of reiterate that point. But this is really a department head update. So there's no expectations back from council. And really, I think the level of dialogue we've had thus far is probably...

1:54:57 Getting us a little bit in, just making Andy switch in his chair a little bit. Oh, sorry. Okay. I didn't get that either. We missed that. I know. Sorry. It's because of my presentation. You missed that. But yeah, just know that we're working towards that. We know it's an important aspect of the needs of the community. I think, you know, to address some of the comments you made with regard to

1:55:24 Wanting to focus elsewhere, I think we're saying that a lot of times the level of effort this is going to take is probably going to narrow our ability to do other things. And so that's kind of a clear point I wanted to make. But look forward to the next presentation, which will be agendized, and you'll have more opportunity to engage with us at that point. Okay, perfect. Thank you. Do I have to take public comment on this since we discussed it? All right, any public comment from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No? Okay. Okay.

1:55:54 Thank you. So we will move along to the consent agenda. Item 8.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 20, 2026. 8.2, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance adopting Municipal Code 8.40 regarding aquatic invasive species. 8.3, accept, check, register 5-21-26 in the amount of $259,586.15.

1:56:22 Accept check register 528.26 in the amount of $1,343,483.48. I would entertain a motion. Does anyone want to pull anything? Nothing to pull, and I'll move to approve as read. I'll second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. Shall we take a five-minute break before we get to the policy matters? Do you want to take a short break?

1:56:52 Yes. Yes, short break. Okay. Okay, five minute break. Back at 6 p.m. Brent, I was like, are you sharing that dramax? And then nothing, you ghosted me. Chris, there's nothing. I got nothing. Okay, our five minutes was up two minutes ago. We are going to come back into session.

2:05:16 And we are on to item nine, policy matters. Item 9.1, update and contract negotiation with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, MLR. Kim? Well, I'm going to start this one off for staff. Oh, Andy! And then Kim will jump in. Okay. So, as you recall, you appointed Councilmember Sauser and Councilmember Truax to be a council committee to negotiate with MLR with a little bit of help from me. And so we've had several meetings.

2:05:43 And there's really good news. And the really good news is that I think everyone agrees that we want this relationship to continue. I think from the staff perspective, and I don't want to speak for the council members, but I think the perspective is we really appreciate MLR. We value the work they do. We want to continue working on that.

2:05:58 I think MLR also wants to continue working with the town. So we're all on the same page conceptually. Where we still are trying to figure things out a little bit is the scope of MLR's work and therefore the amount of money that the town would be paying them to do that. MLR has provided a couple of different proposals to the committee at the committee's request. The committee did say, well, what do you have in mind?

2:06:23 And so Lamar has given us a couple of different ideas. They would like to expand their scope, and I'm not going to speak for Kim. I'll let Kim speak for Kim. But they would like to expand their scope, do more things, and get paid a little bit more. And I think that the committee may see things slightly differently, but that's what we're here to talk about. So take it away, Kim. Okay. Share my screen. I have just a couple slides for you tonight.

2:06:57 Thank you. Kim Manaclario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Thanks to Andy and Bill and Brent for taking the time to go through this process. Tonight I just wanted to talk about the process that we did go through and an overview of the document that was in your packet. We had a total of three meetings and at our first meeting

2:07:22 It was discussed that there was interest by council to sort of just roll over the current MLR contract for the immediate and amend as necessary when needs arose. So, but since we had the team together, we decided to move forward with this process and use it as an exercise to work through various strong points of MLR and opportunities where we could help the town fulfill strategic goals, priorities.

2:07:51 And, you know, we felt that this was a good opportunity to do that and present some options to you. So I will show these first numbers. Not necessarily toot our own horn, but a little bit, I suppose. Somebody's got two. But the real reason I'm putting this up is we're looking at 2020-2021 is when...

2:08:24 I became the director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and we're sort of looking at this organization from here on. That's our starting point for these discussions. And we've had a very successful last five years. You know, the town has invested $500,000 into the organization, and we've returned with over $2 million in projects and programs that are funded for the town.

2:08:56 So we were asked to come up with a number to continue working at a basic status quo level with a slight increase for COLA, etc. And so MLR proposed a 6.5% increase over our current contract to roll over with the existing deliverables. Like I said, we also took the opportunity to look at some areas where we felt were our strong points and where we could really deliver successful.

2:09:24 Thank you so much. Thank you.

2:09:53 You know, to get this program off the ground, we'd have to inventory existing infrastructure, identification of new infrastructure to be part of the program, develop the program guidelines, roles and responsibilities of town and MLR, and building the website and associated back-end needs. So we estimated this rollout and relaunch at $25,000.

2:10:18 So this program, also like Adopt-A-Trail and Tangle Free Waters, we anticipate will become self-sustaining within five years with a small ROI seen after year two. We also presented the need for stewardship program staff to keep the growth and the momentum going.

2:10:42 With the MLR Managed Volunteer and Sponsorship Program. So we've refined and streamlined these programs over the last five years and feel really good about the impact that these programs have had on the landscape and also for building ownership by the people who are participating within them.

2:11:03 So we've grown to 58 locations for the Eastern Sierra Dock Patrol just within the town of Mammoth Lakes. So there's a significant amount of program maintenance, repair out in the field, replacement of infrastructure, and also several layers of administrative tasks that need to be done continually to keep these programs running. We feel a dedicated staff to perform these tasks.

2:11:33 And also included in the, we could include the amenities program, if that gets going, would ensure the continued success and the positive benefits that we've seen. You know, this is a positive benefit not only for the landscape, but it's also an unrestricted funding source that is generated for town use. And so the last sentence is what I feel is really beneficial.

2:11:58 Because this unrestricted funds generated are just that. As long as they're in the realms of outdoor recreation and trails, they can be spent as seen fit. And so the last one, you know, MLR is offering as a possible benefit the community forums. And we've put this in just as part of the exercise of something to look beyond right now and tonight, but something in the future that we could offer as council goes through exercises and decides how.

2:12:29 So just to put some numbers in front of you for the base contract.

2:13:01 With nothing added, and the 6.5% increase for this current year one, 115, and then we propose a 3% increase year over year for the next two. And if you're interested in the expanded scope, the base would be 150 and the one-time funding of $25,000 for the launch of the Parks and Recreation Amenities Enhancement Program. From there on out.

2:13:31 A 3% increase on the base. And I'm ready for questions. Okay, questions? Chris, do you have questions? Go ahead. Not so much questions, but we're just going to add in discussions and other... That comes after public comment, though, right? Okay, okay. Okay, while your presentation is done. Yeah, can you put that back up? Yeah, I just... So, I didn't write down...

2:14:03 As quickly as I wanted to. Your current contract was, did you say it was 108,000 this year and then it's a six and a half percent? Yeah. Okay, so the currently it's 108,500. And then I just had some clarifying questions. So if we went with the base contract plus the amenities, you are hiring another person. My understanding is you are your own, you're the only employee.

2:14:29 That's correct. Of MLR. So you currently wear a lot of hats and do everything. So with this three-year contract with the amenities enhancement program, you would hire someone else to then help you? Because I just kind of worry about like how much, what you can handle. We are at capacity and ready to hire a part-time staff person. Okay. And then MLR uses Measure U and Measure R funds and distributes them.

2:14:59 For programming and arts and trails, right? Is that oversimplifying? As one of our functions? Yes. Yes. So we are the recommending body for measures RNU. Okay. And then what's the, like, I just wanted to kind of understand where you got the 500,000 invested, which has resulted in 200, 2 million.

2:15:22 Worth of funding. Sure. So the investment is our contracts for the last five years, which started at $12,000 and then currently is $108,000. Okay. And then the return is grants that MLR has secured for town projects. So that $2 million does not include Measure U or Measure R funding. It's outside of Measure R and U. Okay, that wasn't clear to me on here. Okay, great. Thank you. Chris, do you have questions?

2:15:50 No, that was a good question. It does build your questions. Do you have questions? I've got a little thing to add, if I may. Okay. With regard to the funding. So when we talk about is, you know, the town's been talking about some funding challenges. When you look at how this allocation of funding to support MLR is an allocation of funding from Measure R and from you, a little bit from you as well. Yeah.

2:16:22 So there's really not any general fund contributions going to that. It's just an allocation of those existing funds that are there that are sort of restricted for this kind of a use. So as you know, R&U can't be used for everything, but it can be used essentially to support the administrative needs of the organization. And when that recommendation comes from council, it's an allocation of primarily R but a little bit of U.

2:16:49 Thank you. And then can I ask, can you just kind of elaborate on what is the Recreation Amenity Enhancement Program? Like what is that? I would love to. So currently you'll probably know it as the Bench Program. Okay. Which is on hold, lack of staff capacity within the Parks and Recreation Department to administer and grow that program. And so...

2:17:17 You know, like I said, it's very in line and similar with our adopted trail and tingle free waters program. So it feels a very natural fit for Mammoth Lakes Recreation to take over that program and manage and run it in the same way. Okay. So we need a $25,000 initial investment to get that program? Just to develop it. Like there's no, there really is no program. You know, there's not a lot of guidelines, documents, who does this, who does that.

2:17:46 What's it for? How long is amenity sponsored for? So really total redevelopment of the program and then implementation. Okay, thank you. And yeah, there are like existing benches that might need upkeep and I'm curious about... That would have to be dealt with, yeah. Right, because the expectation, like when someone donates a bench, have we been clear in the past about...

2:18:15 And I don't think, I'm not asking you necessarily, like I'm just asking the collective. My understanding is everything was, you know, bought in perpetuity, which would change moving forward. We'd have, yeah, like that's even a good thing to just be able to. Not necessarily with like existing benches, you know, we want to honor what was promised in part of the program, but anything new that was brought in would be under a different circumstance.

2:18:44 Right. It does feel like that's, there's a gap. Originally, the bench program, and a lot of work was early on put into this. Yeah. But the bench program, we identified places on the trail system where benches could be appropriate. Sure. Then if you wanted to pay homage to somebody or if you wanted to do something, and a good example is the one up on Lake Mary, which is for Roy.

2:19:15 Then we would allow people to do that and then they would pay for the installation of the bench and the bench and all of that. So there has been a program. Right. I did not know that that program had ceased. I was under the impression that it was being done and the benches were being maintained by our normal maintenance and park staff. This was new to me. It was new to me that MLR had been asked to take over that program.

2:19:45 That was disconcerting for me anyway at that point. I'd like to add something to that because it is town staff that performing that and, you know, to our efforts thus far, and I think, Chris, you mentioned, you know, actively managing the program. So we have the program initially to get it stood up, like if someone wanted to buy a bench.

2:20:11 That was kind of the extent of what the town was able to achieve, right? We acquired it, we got it installed, and that was sort of the end of it. We talked a little bit about enhancing the program with more management of it in subsequent years, more maintenance of that, more sort of development of the program around that. And when town staff is really struggling with more of a capacity issue and it isn't a decision that's made.

2:20:41 You know, at whatever staff level saying, hey, I don't have time to do that. What they pose to me is like, I have limited time. Is this what you want me to work on, Rob, the town manager? And if you do, then, you know, what other areas are we going to be able to cut to get this accomplished? So I kind of recognize it as we haven't done a good job as an organization of making a good program. And probably, Bill, even going back many, many years, it's a struggle to develop a good program associated with this.

2:21:07 And this is an opportunity to determine an enhancement very specifically, right? So I think that's kind of the issue at hand. And again, at the end of the day, if this doesn't become an added contract element for MLR, it's likely something the town will continue. But I'll have to find resources to get that to be done. Sure. And also, it just feels to me, I want this to be posed as a question.

2:21:39 And Betsy, you have been to many, many parks and rec meetings in your life, so maybe you could answer this too. It does feel like something that more of an NGO would do than a town. I don't know why I think that, but it just sort of feels like it does. I don't know. Does any, do you all? So, I'm waiting.

2:22:01 Yeah, I know. I'm trying not to deliberate, but I'm trying to understand, like, what's a best practice. I guess that's... Well, maybe we should take public comment and then we can... So it was asked of the Historical Society back when that started... Sure. ...to try and help the town come up with who would we allow to put memorial plaques out, who qualified for memorial plaque and who didn't, and none of that work was ever finished, so could it go to an NGO? I have no problem with that. My focus today is that...

2:22:29 Because we're just going through, maybe not appropriate yet, but I'm sorry, Madam Mayor, I'm getting carried away. These are questions only, Bill. Yeah, well, we could. I tried, I was playing Jeopardy. I was trying to make it a question, really. Well, let's take public comment, and then we can hear the rest of your story. Public comments? Anyone in the room? Hi, my name's Eric Walshman, and I'm here tonight representing Mammoth Lakes Recreation as a board member. Just wanted to make a couple comments.

2:23:04 First, I'd like to express our sincere gratitude to the town staff and town council for your hard work in finalizing our baseline contract. Securing this agreement is a step forward in our relationship. While this baseline contract establishes a great starting point, we view it as just that, a foundation. As we look to the future, MLR is incredibly eager to expand our partnership and upcoming projects and enhance services. We firmly believe

2:23:33 That certain community incentives can be executed more nimbly, efficiently, and innovatively when managed outside the traditional boundaries of local government. And as your partners, our goal is to leverage this flexibility to deliver maximum value, seamless project execution, and outstanding recreational experiences for our community, as you were saying, Chris, but maybe it's more on the NGO side. We look forward to working closely with you to expand our scope and to show just how much we can accomplish together

2:24:03 Thank you for your time, for your continued partnership, and your service to the community. So, and, you know, basically what I was going to say is, this is a baseline. We're looking, you know, we want to start here, but there's a lot of projects that we have ideas for that we think that we could do better, faster, cheaper as an NGO than a municipality, and we'd love to have further communication with members of council and staff to see if we can go there in the future, but we're happy for it.

2:24:32 The contract that's on the table right now. Thank you. Thanks, guys. Any other comments from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No. Okay, Bill, let's hear the rest of your story. You know, we don't need to go down there. This could easily be done by a non-profit. Where I'm at with this is that I support fully the 115, which is the 6.5 for this year, and 3.3 after that.

2:25:00 As a council, we keep talking about getting together and having meetings where we discuss what the best use of our NGOs are and where it's going to be and who should have the argument now whether something should be in the NGO or whether it should be in our own house. Those are conversations we haven't yet had. And knowing that this is going to be a tough financial world, I don't know that all the things that MLR is proposing are appropriate for Measure R, so we may have to dip into General Fund.

2:25:30 To do some of these things. And where we are with our budget right now, I'm just uncomfortable. I'm very comfortable going forward with a continuation of the contract. Kim is an amazing asset and does an incredible job and has done an incredible job since she first took over. So I'm not bad-mouthing or poo-pooing the organization. I'm just saying at this point where we are as a council,

2:25:57 We have not yet made the decisions as to what we want and who we want doing things, and I think we need to do that. We need to get down to the nuts and bolts for all of our organizations, housing, tourism, and this organization, which has shined brightly for what we've paid them. Can I ask one quick question? The 6.533, how do we come to those numbers? Can I ask you, gentlemen?

2:26:26 This is their original ask was for six and a half when we were talking about maybe only doing a one year. And looking at what we have done for our employees here, you know, the majority of their money has to go because they only have one employee. That seemed like a very legitimate course to move forward. So I was very comfortable with that.

2:26:52 And I have told them in our conversations that any time they have a program that they think is absolutely stellar, that I would look forward, whether it's contract time or not, I would look forward to them bringing that forward to see how council went. All contracts are changeable at any point in time. That's why we have to have the Andes of the world. Are they changeable at any point in time? I don't know. Are they? But it doesn't happen? It can.

2:27:21 All we have to do is say we want to add something. You're saying for things that are not in the current scope of the contract. You're saying for additional items. If the parties agree. What we're saying is that if everyone's on the same page that want to change the scope, add some stuff, add some money, sure, we can amend the contract at any time. Could we, could you elaborate a little bit more? I'm curious about which of these things would be outside the scope of Measure R and Measure U funds? Sure, as soon as I get a nut in my head. Sorry, I'm sorry. I don't know. I would have to look.

2:27:55 I can use an example, the bench program, which is something that the town had previously funded, whether they fund it now or not, it's sort of irrelevant. That would be a supplanting issue with Measure R. Measure R can't pay for anything the town has paid for in the past or is paying for. That's in Measure R? No, but if we made an expenditure through a general fund to do something and now we're maybe moving that to Measure R, that would be supplanting town funds and that could be...

2:28:28 We'd have to check on the legality of that and how we do certain things. Can I just go and just, before we get into sub-details, just a broad scope, because through negotiations, you know, and I say negotiations, we're trying to look at where does MLR fit into what the town's vision is and where the destination vision plan comes out, where we are going. And to me, I echo where Bill is at with, I'm comfortable with the base proposal, but I...

2:28:56 Very cautious about taking one little piece of items and just moving it over. This is what we're trying to not do anymore. We're trying to say, what is the role of an organization? What should they be doing and where they fit in? We sat as a council, what, a month ago? A month and a half ago? Talking about this very item in terms of where's our priorities? Where does everybody fit into this? We all agreed and said, hey.

2:29:19 Let's look at the umbrella. Then Rob had a slide with 4,000 organizations on it, and then we said, whoa, maybe that's a bigger umbrella than we need to tackle them with. We said, let's start with our NGOs. Let's talk about where the priorities are because, I don't know, at the end of the day, there may be more that's supposed to be in MLR, I shouldn't say, there may be more that is a discussion with MLR that MLR may want to take on that is bigger than just what the ask is today. I recognize that the challenge is MLR is limited to staffing.

2:29:46 They're trying to figure out how do we get things done without staff, which is the quintessential challenge of the world. But at this moment, I'd be comfortable moving ahead with the ask and contract, but also making it a priority to say, where does MLR fit in? If this ends up being the one item, then we discuss that, is that the best thing? But I think there's other things that we should throw into that discussion. Where is MLR doing? Who's taking over certain areas?

2:30:12 Does MLR's role change in other things and have that as a full discussion and then come back and say, okay, this is what MLR's responsibility is. This is what the cost of that is. Do we want to move forward with those items? I think that we constantly take a piece one at a time and we address it over here, over there. We seem like it's resolved. It's not resolved. We've got issues with housing. We've got issues with other areas. And we still have to bring these all back together and say, okay, what's our real conclusion? And by just taking one little piece,

2:30:39 We're just doing the same thing. We're not really resolving the issue. And I understand the challenges, but for me, it's a fundamental look at where each NGO stands, what is their role, what is the real role of the NGO, and fund that appropriately. And might mean that, might mean Rob loses money in terms of operational budget in some areas because it really belongs somewhere else. And it's not just a, hey, we're going to ask somebody else, but we've got to have an economic shift of what funds that. So that's my point.

2:31:08 Totally hear you. So my only question then would be, if this is a three-year contract, because I did clarify that with Rob on my call today, I'm just hesitant because what happens is, and you know, through no fault of anybody's, it's just how we've been operating, that then it's a three-year contract and it doesn't get readdressed.

2:31:31 Would it make sense? And I'm not trying to make this harder, but like do a one-year contract. So we really do force ourselves to go through the exercise because a lot of times we talk about things we aspire to as a council, but then it doesn't really happen. And I just want to guard against that. So that would be my thought. No, and I agree with that standpoint. We had a lot of discussion on that. I think it is better to have a three-year contract. I think that it sets message for here. I was looking for language in the contract that forces us to

2:32:00 Say, let's talk these points right away. Let's not wait a year to talk this conversation. Let's start talking about where these go. And to me, I kind of, in my head, related to where does destination vision come out? Is there things that we take from that? So I was envisioning over the next couple months, this is a conversation we have, to see where does this fit and not wait a year. I agree. It can easily wait a year if we don't, you know, something else comes more important and, oh, it was great, and then it's the same situation.

2:32:30 But I think it is important because I think that's a conversation we need to have not with MLR but MLT, you know, Eastern Sierra Community Housing. There's just things that exist there that all of us have to have a conversation, I think, sooner rather than later. Interesting you say that because my first knee-jerk and my first presentation, my first talk with Andy as part of this group was that I wanted to do a one-year. But then I start looking at where we are and how successful MLR has become in the last five years.

2:32:58 Didn't start out laugh that way, but they became this. I don't want to risk losing them. So I want to show them that we are going to stand by them regardless for at least a three-year period. I hear you. I feel like I just really worry about the things getting kicked down the road. So this is the opposite of that to me, which is force us to decide what we want it to be.

2:33:27 Like, it's pretty strong, it's pretty compelling to say, like, that for the investment we've made, we've gotten two million dollars of projects that we wouldn't have otherwise, because there's no capacity in the town staff, and it's nobody's job, really, to, at this moment, to be writing those grants, so, I don't know, I just, um, Can you elaborate on, like, what was the two-minute, like,

2:33:51 What grants or projects? I don't know. Because I guess my personal concern with MLR is that Kim is a one-woman show, and if getting her additional funding would get her an employee, and I just worry about her workload. I don't know. I don't see you during the week. I don't know. You always seem very calm, so maybe it's not too much work for you.

2:34:17 Yeah, what, like, what are, what are some examples? So those grants that were listed, if I remember correctly, so we, most recently, the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Grant for the Golden Muscle Stations up in the Lakes Basin, so that was $150,000 to purchase three trailers. The new Sherwins Meadow Trailhead, a little over $900,000 was used for that construction. All the planning efforts that are continuing in the Sherwins for more new trails.

2:34:46 A little over $500,000 during COVID. And that's from state grants? Those three were SNC, yeah. So Sierra Nevada Conservancy is the, you know, like, it's the whole Sierra Nevada. It starts up, and it's actually more than the Sierra Nevada. And it is the funding mechanism for the state of California to give money to places like...

2:35:09 This. And so Jennifer Kreitz is our local representative because county supervisors sit on the board. But it is like, by the way, Sierra Nevada Conservancy is getting the Prop 4 funds. So the billion or 4 billion, 10 billion, I don't know, lots and lots of money is going to be coming through there. So other people see grants from Sierra Nevada Conservancy as well, like Whitebark and others. But it's like, I mean, if we don't have the capacity.

2:35:38 To be there at these, you know, to make the request when they become available, that's a big missed opportunity. Another grant we were awarded was from the National Endowments of the Arts during COVID when our local arts agencies were not making any income. So we got a grant, just a sub-grant out back to them to cover operating expenses only to keep the doors open.

2:36:08 You know, we act as a pass-through for the LA Kings ice at Mammoth Lakes. The Kings will not contribute to a municipality. There's been a lot of private donors that have given specifically to Mammoth Lakes trail system. We've raised over $170,000 to the Eastern Sierra Adopted Trail specifically for Mammoth Lakes.

2:36:32 I think those are the ones I had listed. There's a slew of other grants we get. We've gotten funding from Southern California Edison, Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, several grants from the Mono County Fish Find Fund just to keep these programs and, you know, amenities operating. One of my favorites that shows their ability was the simple little bridge at Horseshoe because there became a huge issue and immediately they were able to go out and find it.

2:37:03 Private funding that we probably wouldn't have been able to source and get that bridge replaced and built. So I've never said they weren't a very important ally. You know, Councilmember Bubser, I hear your concern about not wanting this to just get lost or dropped. And I think that one way that you could address that, if you're so inclined, is the council could direct your committee, Councilmember Souser and Councilmember Truax, to find time to meet with MLR.

2:37:30 To keep these discussions going about the scope of the contract. You could get the, you could if you were so inclined, get this contract in place and then tell them at the other end of the dais, hey, your job is to meet with them sometime this summer or whatever you think the time frame would be. And if you tell Bill and Brent to do that, they're not going to forget and I won't forget and we can have those conversations if that's something that would help. And then like...

2:37:59 Add on to the contract. Like, you're suggesting that we renew the existing scope and then potentially continue to have a print and bill? I think that's an approach. I mean, it's up to the council, of course. I mean, if at least three of you can agree on one scope of work, great, do that. But this would be an approach of getting something in place because they're going to be out of contract here at the end of the month. And we can't pay them anymore after that.

2:38:27 That was the lawyer answer. Okay. Fair enough. You know, that's a fair point. Amanda, we get to tell the guys at the end of the dais, do your job. Just a point of clarification, is there any, is that okay to continue on as a committee without having to do an action? I'm just trying to make sure that's, because we agree to do that already, so I'm just trying to make sure we're.

2:38:58 Don't have to do any other action. Nope. If you're still up for it, you can continue doing it, and certainly the council as a whole can say, we want this temporary ad hoc committee to continue, and please go out and do these things. Yes, you can do that. And just since you brought up the portion, I'm not going to speak for Bill, but I'm okay with that, and I would be okay with setting a date and say, we want to report back by X. I know that's not required, but I agree. What do we want to report back by?

2:39:26 Mayor Rice? I don't want to lose focus either because I think it is important that we resolve and see where is MLR going to be because it is a challenge and it should be addressed. Absolutely. And I just totally support what Mayor Rice has said repeatedly. Like, what are we missing by not having this really important partner of ours be

2:39:52 Have the capacity to even look up and see what's possible out there. We don't need, you know, I'm sure, you know, I mean, I don't want to put words in your mouth, Kim, but I can imagine that, you know, these things come fast and furious. I started getting this year Nevada Conservancy's bulletin because I was curious because I want to see when the Prop 4 funds are coming. And it's like all the time. I'm like, I don't even have time to read it. How do you have time to respond? So I just think that

2:40:21 A deeper dive into what's possible and what that might give us because I don't want us to be penny wise and pound foolish. Yep. No, I just want to be realistic, but also the time frame is also one of the things that concerns me just trying to get this done because I think there's other things we need to talk about with the MLR and come back and say where do they fit in with

2:40:45 Many different things. So since you're the negotiators and you're the mayor, I guess to move this forward, I should make a, do we need to make a motion? The contract will come up on next council meeting. Oh, okay. That would be the time to do it. Okay. And at that time, I would ask us to consider not telling us to move forward until we get through the budget, which will actually be at that meeting anyway. Town's budget will be adopted on the 17th of June.

2:41:17 Otherwise, we have to just shut down business on July 1. Other larger governments do that. No. Pay people and then everybody gets upset. Okay. So, you have a question? We're good. Did you have another comment? Yeah, I just want to articulate more as a board member where our purview is. We wanted to really let Kim shine. So right now, like you guys were saying, she's a one-woman show.

2:41:44 With some additional funding, we'd be able to hire some additional help so that Kim could focus on getting more grants, getting more things that provide more ROI on your investments. At the committee level, we've discussed some other verticals that we have for revenue that we were not prepared to bring to council tonight. We will continue to discuss that privately. However, we negotiated in good faith that council and us would continue those.

2:42:09 Continue those conversations, and I think when it's brought back to council, you'll like what you see. We want to be self-sufficient, generating more revenue that does involve a partnership with the town that I think would be able to provide the income to do some of these things that we'd like to do that will only enhance the investment. Thank you. You're welcome. Okay. You have something else to say, Brent? No, no. I just didn't know if you need to be telling us to continue on or...

2:42:36 Is that, is that the, is that, I just make it sure I'm clear in terms of. That would be at the next meeting, right? Yeah, or you're going to do that at the next meeting after the approved budget and say. I think that would be, I mean, it just said it was informational, like an update, right? Yeah. Jamie, we don't need any direction on that, right? And that wouldn't be in action, right Andy? No. It was just, the mayor just tell us. Okay. You can make it part of the motion at the next meeting if you like. Okay. So there's a record. I just like to make it clear to everybody that we don't drop it. We're going to follow up on you, Brent. You better not.

2:43:04 Okay, we are on to item 9.2, approve agreements with California Department of Forestry and Firefighting to station resources at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Sabian, welcome. Thank you. Thank you for coming. I'll kind of give Sabian just a little bit of a brief introduction here. This is, you know, this is an item, obviously, that involves signing a lease agreement.

2:43:33 There's aircraft associated with a use agreement where they're paying us money for being on station. These are things that really wanted to bring before council mainly to talk about the value of the program and just to get the awareness for council on this funds. We would be receiving money from each of these contracts, whether it be the aircraft on station or the lease of our facilities.

2:44:03 And so it's a positive thing. We're bringing money in on that. So Sabine, you want to take it from there? In continuing with the airport's focus on town council's strategic priorities of public safety facility optimization, we have this opportunity to work with CAL FIRE. It is unprecedented for them. They are faced with...

2:44:35 They have extended state responsibility areas, 800,000 acres up in our region that are until now uncovered by their air mobility group and from an engine standpoint. Their goal is to keep fires at 10 acres or less 90% of the time in their responsibility areas.

2:45:02 They typically go outside of those areas unless their areas are threatened or they're invited or called for help. And as part of their recognition of a year-round fire threat, they have transitioned to year-round staffing in some of their stations rather than seasonal fire staffing. And they've picked

2:45:31 Mammoth, this area as one of those places where there is a need. They do hope to continue to have one or two more stations up north of Mammoth on 395. And they are starting with the airport as a South County top of the grade mobilization. We're lucky to have them.

2:46:02 It is a true win-win situation. They provide protection and training, much needed training for the airport itself. We are firefighters, so aircraft rescue and firefighting certified crew, who as I'm sure you've heard Chief Tom Meyer talk about incidents in our area being high hazard, low frequency.

2:46:31 It's difficult to maintain preparation for those incidents. As an ARF crew who's also doing pavement maintenance and snow removal and all the other things we do from the outside of the obvious public safety benefit to the South County region, we really appreciate it as an airport crew that this

2:47:01 To have new tenants that will train with us and keep us current in our own responsibilities. So I'll add just to facilitate this lease, this lease is of what was formerly the airport office, so Sabine's crew, their home, if you will. And so that is a key part of getting this.

2:47:31 This deal available is to give the crew quarters and sort of their headquarters converting into a crew quarters for Cal Fire. So this item in the next is slightly related, but really just seeking for approval to engage in this lease agreement primarily. We've already kind of contracted with the aircraft.

2:47:55 But the lease agreement being three years and then of that duration, just having that awareness to the council. So I think if there are any other questions or welcome to entertain a motion if there are no questions. Any questions? No. There's discussion. Public comment? Anyone in the room? Anyone online? Okay. Brent? Just discussion. I'm just going to put there in terms of you think of all the things that we can do in this town to help and prepare for what might come. This seems to me is one of the most proactive.

2:48:26 Most helpful, most impactful potentially for this area. And if we have to take dollars from somewhere else to pay for this, I think it's worth every dime to how important this is. We're doing other things in town and firewise, et cetera. This really has a significant impact and it's just truly remarkable that we're able to have them here and to have a crew on site for emergency. So I just...

2:48:54 Highly, highly support this. And I know it's probably going to be a motion anyways, but I just think it's important that we recognize just how significant this is. Thank you. Any other comments? Nope. I'd entertain a motion. I would move to approve agreements between the California Department of Forestry and Firefighting and the Town of Mammoth Lakes for emergency use of facilities, contract for aircraft on station, and a lease agreement for living quarters for an engine company located at Mammoth Yosemite Airport.

2:49:24 I will second that. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. Thank you, Sabian. Okay, so we are on to item 9.3, resolution finding emergency circumstances justify the award of emergency contracts at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Thank you. So, as we've just allocated the ability to lease that facility, we have to make some improvements on that.

2:49:52 And really what we're looking for, you know, we have to get a lot done in a very short amount of time. The contracts with CAL FIRE are also done under an emergency sort of classification within CAL FIRE. So we are looking for work basically to make improvements on crew quarters, installing air conditioning, electrical system, improvement plumbing work that would really support

2:50:21 More people than have been at our headquarters prior as what you'll see there is with that engine company and I think a little bit of the support from the aircraft folks is going to be a whole lot more people in that room and that carrying capacity of that facility needs to be enhanced and there's a very, very short amount of time in which to get that accomplished. So what we're proposing tonight is a resolution for this emergency contract work to get performed.

2:50:49 And that's what is before you tonight. So happy to answer any questions. If this is approved, this resolution will go forward. You will see it on future council agendas as a consent agenda item to continue this until the work is completed.

2:51:06 We do think since there is an urgent need to get this work completed that it will be done relatively quickly, but it does depend upon emergency contracts that would need to be worked through and sort of lead times and so forth for equipment. And so determining exactly how quickly that will get done is not possible this evening. However, how quickly it can be done is based upon this emergency resolution. So happy to answer any questions or entertain a motion. Any questions? Yes.

2:51:35 Just one question. We allocated funds before. I thought we already allocated and approved the purchase of the trailer before. So I'm just trying to make sure the sequence is correct. I'm fully supportive of where we're going, but I just want to make sure the process. Yeah, so the funds were allocated during the second quarter to the tune of $90,000 to get the work accomplished.

2:51:58 But that doesn't start the process by which the work to get accomplished and the contracts required to have that work done. And that would begin now. And I think that's a very protracted process through contract code. And so this resolution to provide this as an emergency contract eliminates the time delay in beginning that. So it's not a funding source. It's really more of a

2:52:27 Really, we're trying to, it's a timing issue is getting that done quickly. That's right, and one of the reasons that this is appearing now is we weren't aware of what the timing would be for this project. We knew it was coming, and we're therefore asking for funds, but we didn't know it would be right now. Okay. I would entertain a motion. I would move to approve. Oh, I should take public comment first. Public comment?

2:52:58 Anyone online? No. Okay. Now I would entertain a motion. I move to approve the resolution finding that emergency circumstances justify awarding contracts for installation of air conditioning, electrical system, improvements, and plumbing work to facilitate Cal Fire's lease of the existing airport office. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. And so we are on to item. Thank you.

2:53:28 Sabian, thank you for coming. And I do want to extend an extra thank you for giving up your office space. We all greatly appreciate that, and I feel a little safer knowing that there are resources going to be right there at the airport for us. So thank you very much. Thank you. Okay. We are on to item 9.4, fiscal year 2026-27, tentative budget. Manager recommended. Thank you, Mayor Rice.

2:54:00 Have been busy with this budget. This has given me a little bit of extra area of concern and work to get accomplished this year. As we know, if you were tuned in to the last presentation, we had a very significant gap between our expenditures and what I see to, I was believing to be a very appropriate growth of revenue expectations. And so

2:54:26 What I've been doing for the last couple of weeks has been looking at, you know, just refining the budget a little bit tighter, and there isn't a lot of reduction in this particular budget, because we do budget very thinly to begin with, and so I think minor modifications that I do suggest, which we'll walk through here shortly, it's really more of a comfort level from Council of increasing the revenue expectations to address these shortfalls. I will dive right into

2:54:56 Sort of how I went about making this adjustment. And if you want to go sit down, you're okay. I appreciate your respect for not wanting to interrupt my presentation. Is really just as we look through this, I always reconcile the differences. So as you saw at the top there, I had $35 million, $688, $350 in the preliminary budget we did on May 20th.

2:55:24 What I'm recommending tonight is that we increment that by about 2.9 million in a couple of different revenue streams. TOT going up 2 million, that's going to go from 21, which was already at, I think, an appropriate growth level to 23. Prior year we had 19.5 was our budgeted revenue. So it's going up fairly significantly at 3.5 million over last year at this time. And that, again, is to address...

2:55:53 Really highly climbing cost outside of just labor, but also in some insurance and other aspects. When you allocate TOT, there's also an allocation to tourism, transit, and housing, which is automatic. I'll go through that here shortly. That $2 million allocation actually increased my expenses, even with net of other reductions that I'm proposing, which I'll cover here shortly.

2:56:19 The other couple of items that I've addressed were with property tax. Property tax is a little bit less volatile and a little bit more consistent, but we do, we have removed the, that really doesn't project how much the change was, right? We went from 3.66 million to 4.16 million, so it is half a million dollars.

2:56:46 We removed the safety margin on that just a little bit, so going up that half a million dollars, all of that is allocated directly to the needs of the town as far as general fund. There's no allocation of those funds. Sales tax, sales tax is really dependent upon visitation. As you know, prices and so forth are elevated right now, so that does sort of serve to increase sales tax slightly, but it does require people to be here. Over the last few years, we've climbed up fairly steadily.

2:57:14 In the last two years, for sure, we've been above the $3.5 million number consistently, and I think getting up to that number is not giving me too much heartburn, but it is something that we just have pulled out some of our conservative estimates. And then finally, as Councilmember Truax noted last time, the transfer in from Measure U, $300,000 for supporting

2:57:43 David and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Center when it's operational. I did pull that in for the full amount this year, and that's typically you would consider that to be an operational support for an entire year. However, I'm justifying the full amount for this year based upon the fact that that facility, the costs are going to start as soon as we hire the manager of that facility, which will be in July.

2:58:12 And the facility's ability to generate revenue won't occur until it's operational, which is probably in May or late May time frame. So we're going to have more than $300,000 expense currently sitting in the general fund to support the operations of that facility and really no ability for it to generate revenue to support itself.

2:58:33 I think it's justified to transfer the full $300,000 from Measure U for support of that facility, and that in total brings our revenue up $2.9 million to $38,588,350. This is the main point of my desire to get feedback from Council tonight, is whether there's comfort level on making these modifications, and so I'm going to pause here and see if there's any thoughts, or we can take them out at the end.

2:59:02 But I think it's appropriate maybe to discuss now. Yep, I get my thoughts because I spent a lot of time going through numbers overall. I have no problems with the overall. I don't like the fact that we have to raise the TOT by that much. But as you say, Rob, there's certain things that payroll, health insurance, I mean, that's like 92% of what we're talking about is pre-described expenses. I think it's going to foster conversations down the road in terms of where we're going because.

2:59:33 We're going to have some challenges in the next several years, but you don't have any choice but to take it to cover the expenses, and we can talk separately. I think there might be some opportunities for some, but some means, okay, maybe $100,000. We're not talking a million dollars. I spent quite a while going through a lot of the budget, and there's just not a lot of flexibility. So I don't like to see it, but I think it's a necessary evil.

3:00:04 For me, am I comfortable with it? Absolutely not. Is it something that with the current state of where we are, we have to do? It is. My caution is moving forward that we are going to have to try and stay at this level as a town with our services and everything else until we get back to the point where our projections on TOT don't have to be so close to what actuality is.

3:00:33 Putting in $23 million. Two years ago, we received a great year. It was $26 million. One little downturn, and we won't reach that $23 million. So for the first time in years, I am uncomfortable with how much snow we're going to get and everything else. We could see having to make cuts that previous times I didn't even have to consider. I have faith in MLT. They're going to bring business here.

3:01:04 Chris, do you have comments? So these aren't questions, these are comments, right? Just making sure. Well, I guess I'm going to do public comment at the end of the presentation. That's fine. Okay. Thank you. You know, we've known that costs are rising. There's been inflation. We've had a bunch of different contracts that have gone forward and they've...

3:01:35 You know, involved increases for our staff, for the police department, and so we knew this was coming. So, you know, I'm comfortable because we made those decisions knowing full well what the implication would be. So, I'm absolutely comfortable. But I just think we all have to acknowledge and understand that, like, as we're facing inflation,

3:02:02 We have to continue to keep our staff whole and our staff staffed. And so here we are. I mean, we've always known this was coming, but. And to me, I guess it makes sense to do it this way. I mean, and then also, you know, with our budgeting, I feel like we're very bare bones. And then projects that we have to do are not budgeted for until we have unbudgeted TOT money. And so I feel like if there is an economic downturn.

3:02:31 You know, I hope that we have enough of the, you know, we have some money in our reserves for economic uncertainty. Sure. You know, this, it's, that's a really large budget and, I don't know, I know that we've had a couple record-breaking TOT years this year. I think that, to me, it makes sense to come up with this budget and then if there is a large economic downturn, then we have to adjust.

3:03:02 As appropriate. But, you know, I'm going to say it. John's not here. So we're getting to the inflection point. People, we're getting there. Everybody slow down. We're getting there. John will appreciate that. Yes. And if I could add to that, because I think what you're saying is, in my mind, the same thing. When we come to a quarterly update, it may mean that we have to be very judicious about unallocated resources and what we...

3:03:28 Holden Reserve. Yeah, I think that's something that I've been thinking a lot about through this process is, you know, we have those unallocated resources now. We need to really be efficient about that. I will say, you know, while we do have a lot of our reserves funded, the one thing that I do not have in this budget and I won't have the ability to accomplish in this budget is to maintain our reserve policy.

3:03:53 As we've been doing over the last several years where I'm allocating funds directly from the budget to make sure we stay on policy. That policy is driven by a baseline revenue number, which I typically match similar to wherever we are for total general funds. So in this particular case, I would make a recommendation to say it's $38,600,000 would be our new baseline. And then I've got to hit 25% of that as reserve dollars.

3:04:22 I think the current baseline is $33,500,000. So adding a pretty significant amount of money, $5 million to that, is $1,250,000 when it comes to the additional reserve requirements that we would have. So I think that that's something that I'm going to have to fund through quarterly review and throughout the year.

3:04:50 And I think that'll be a council direction on whether we want to stay on close on that policy or not. But I appreciate your comments. I'll move on so we can get through the end of this. Measure L money. Measure L is not included in this. This is only the general fund elements. So Measure L council action directed 100% of those funds to be in Fund 245 housing now. And so that's not reflected in when I say TOT numbers right here of 23 million. That's not included. Thank you so much. Thank you.

3:05:20 Rob, sorry, you just made a little light go off in my head. Do we include Measure L when we're looking at our reserves? At 25%, do we add that in? So we're going to add $5 million over our... No, because it's not tied to the actual revenue created by DOT. It's tied to a baseline number, which...

3:05:47 I come up with, I'm just telling you what the strategy was that I'd used before, that approximates the general fund revenue, because really that's the revenue that would support our operations, and that revenue, having 25% of that as a reserve is a really appropriate reserve amount, and so that's the number that I'm targeting, essentially, so it has nothing to do with that. Thank you.

3:06:13 You know, you can see here that 4.911850 is the total increase in revenues. Again, that's across from last year's adopted budget to this year's proposed budget, so it doesn't necessarily include just what changed now. It included what changed prior to that when I did the preliminary budget presentation. And so that's basically 14.6% increase in revenues.

3:06:42 I always share this approximation. Councilmember Bubser, I haven't put the percentages in there yet. It's all good. It's good. I can do it. That's okay. In my head. I think you wanted in the expenses more than you wanted in whatever. Yeah, I'm more interested in the expenses, to be honest. And so we're on to expenses now. A couple of things I want to talk about here.

3:07:05 The first three items that you see on here is transfers out to housing, transit, and tourism, and those are all allocated based upon the additional $2 million in TOT that we realized, right? So both transit and housing are at a 6.54% of that number, and then tourism is at 18.08%. So that's another $600,000 in expense that we added just by adding the $2 million in TOT.

3:07:35 And that's reflected in there. So those numbers, those monies go into reserves. Those reserves have been allocated by council to housing, to fire mitigation, to EMS support, to additional air service. They've been allocated to many things, but they're available in those buckets for allocation. They're not going to be allocated as part of this budget. They will simply increase those reserve accounts. The other...

3:08:01 The modification I made here is this year we made a fairly significant change to vehicle replacement and that had an almost doubling effect, if you will, of the charges for each of the departments. And so I backed off of that a little bit and basically a 12.5% reduction off of what I had originally proposed, which all in for all departments was just under a million dollars for our vehicle replacement. I'm backing that down to eight.

3:08:31 And that's just a way of kind of saving a little bit of money, mainly because we have some significant balances that are untied to vehicles in there. And I think I want to go through and do a deeper analysis on that. So I'm comfortable that I will be able to fund whatever we need as far as a replacement, even if it's unexpected and early in the life. So I think that fund is in pretty good shape. I'm not so worried about it. I'm using this opportunity to give myself a little bit of room.

3:08:57 And then the transfers out, there's two modifications there, equal just about $270,000. I had a placeholder in there for other reserves. This was last year's amount we had to increment in order to stay on target. Our reserves are constantly earning interest, and so that's why they're growing throughout the year. But we have to tee that up based upon how much our revenue growths go up. In this particular case, I had those in there as placeholders, knowing I was going to have something in there, but I've removed it entirely.

3:09:26 And then the $180,000, this is something I missed last year in my initial presentation as well. And that is because most of the general fund supports most of the debt service that we have, unless it's an assessment district, if you will. And in the purchase of the property from the foundation for the Edison Theater and the David and Roman McCoy Arts and Cultural Center, there was a stipulation that

3:09:55 Some money from Measure U was going to cover the debt service to the tune of about $180,000 for a few years within the payment cycle. And so I hadn't included that, so General Fund was funding the entire debt service. And so what I did here is I said, okay, $180,000 is coming from Measure U. I saw that when I did the Measure U element, which is part of the tentative budget. And so I incorporated that and reduced the expectations of General Fund. All told,

3:10:24 Our expenses went up $229,860,000, so it is at $38,710,000. So we've got $122,000 as of this particular budget. Still is a deficit, but I can manage that fairly easily. I will do a little bit more reduction in allocated expenses and increases that we had anticipated.

3:10:47 But I also have more expenses coming in. I've got the IT budget came in the other day, and this is supplied to me by Mono County. It was about $150,000 higher than I had budgeted for growth that they have in that particular area, so I'm still working through that. This budget is very dynamic as far as I don't do it all at once and then go back and make modifications. I'm doing sections of the budget, so there's impacts that sort of flow in.

3:11:12 But all of this has to be done by the 17th of June when we will adopt the budget. And so there's more work to be done, but we're kind of getting through it. I'm getting through it. Showing you the expenditures and how they flow out. Someday, Chris, I'll get the percentages in there for everyone to see. But real quick, I'm going to back up. The one thing I did not do is I did not modify any of our budgeted...

3:11:40 And that includes the six vacant police officer positions that we have, which are some of our highest cost positions that we have. I could have easily justified saying that we were going to take those six positions and only fund them at 75% of the year because honestly, if I got a good application today, bringing that person online in the next three months.

3:12:07 It's probably a quick get, right? I think it was 62 days we talked about as a very, very fast process. So it's justifiable that I could have lowered those down to be three quarters of the year. That would have produced a very significant savings. I am not comfortable doing that because what happens then in the next year is with the same allocated positions,

3:12:29 We would then have a fairly significant gross in full-time equivalents and look like our organization itself was growing. We've also had a fairly public level of discussion around our police services and our funding of that. And I think reducing those costs or positions doesn't send the right message. So if anyone's listening out there, we are fully funding the positions that we have allocated to the police department and just working through obtaining applicants for that.

3:12:59 So that was just something I wanted to put out to Council and just let folks know on that. I'm comfortable with these modifications. I think that they are successful. There will be further modifications as I get to the final budget, but nothing too dramatic associated with this. Gas tax. So the only changes that happened in gas tax, really it was impacted by the...

3:13:22 Vehicle replacement, because most of the heavy-duty, very expensive equipment is in gas tax, so that made a minor modification. As you see, these two, both revenue and expenditures, are in balance, because I utilize general fund transfers to support that. They're both at $5,760,199. That gives you an indication of just exactly how the expenses lay out, and you can see that

3:13:49 You know, vehicle operational costs there, you know, fairly significant chunk in that teal colored blue, but then snow removal clearly is a cost in street maintenance and so forth. So talk about Measure R and U. So Measure R has been producing revenue of around $2 million a year. In that particular expenditure, we have a set.

3:14:16 Group of expenditures. You can see a transfer to trails of $300,000. We've been doing that for the full 10 years that I've been here. Community Recreation Center support, that $112,000, that was something that we modified a few years ago when it used to cover trails costs, but that's going to support the CRC operational expense. We've got a lot of our funding for trails managers, trails manager, if you will, and

3:14:45 And so forth, so that $100,000. I have in here a budget of $105,000. That was, this was put together prior to, obviously, tonight when that was increased to $115,000, it sounds like. So I'll make the modification here and that'll go up just slightly. And then there's, you know, transfers to support trails program managers. Really, basically, the Office of Outdoor Recreation is supported a lot by Measure R and a little bit by Measure U as well.

3:15:12 And then you see the CRC financing payment down below the 615-126. That changes every year. We have one more payment after this particular payment, and that debt is fully paid off, the $5.5 million. What is that date? That date of payment, I think, will be October of 27, when the final payment's made. As you see with those revenues and expenditures identified, there's still $659,374 available in Measure R.

3:15:42 So when I increase that budget from $105,000 to $115,000, it'll still have almost $650,000 available. And that can accumulate to the fund balance and be allocated to programs and other things and so forth. I talked about the $300,000 allocation to trails. That has a little bit of a reconciliation on the right. You can see the revenues coming in at $300,000. Staff and labor, it's really our trails construction labor crews.

3:16:09 And then we've got a little bit of contractual services and other things associated with that, miscellaneous expenses and so forth. I always show this as a balanced budget, but if there are any expenditures that do not occur in there, the fund balance will remain in Fund 215, which is for Measure Our Trails, and so that could be used for future projects. But I like to show a balanced budget so we, you know, we're basically allocating funds that we're intending to use for that purpose. Does that...

3:16:39 The MLR contract that we were just discussing tonight, we were discussing at like $115,000. Is that cost accounted for? Is that $105,000 in there? So the $105,000 is in there, yeah, and I said, as I indicated, I would update that to $115,000. The thing that, and I'm sorry, I'm actually, I'm actually, it's actually fine. Let me tell you why. When I said that the funding for the MLR agreement is

3:17:09 Mainly out of Measure R and then a subsequent out of Measure U. It's $10,000 that comes from Measure U. So that's where that number equals 150. Great. Thank you. Yep. So I'll give myself more credit next time. It's on the next page. Yeah, so that's down at the next part you see right here, the $10,000. So that's the other increment for that. Measure U has used utility tax revenues. So that's gone up a little bit in the last few years. It is really based upon visitation.

3:17:41 Because of utilization of those particular utilities in town. So $1,110,000 is a pretty good number, and it's grown up. It used to be about $900,000, and sort of languished around that number for quite a while, but it's increased over the last few years. I'm showing in that first line item the $300,000 for the operating expense. That's a transfer out to general fund.

3:18:06 That previously was indicated as a placeholder for the last several years, but now it's actually in the expense column. Programming is $225,000. Again, more support for the Office of Outdoor Recreation and two allocations of $25,000. Special projects, that's really something that resides in the MLR board, can come up with a special project to allocate those funds to, but that's been really dedicated to project work. It's never really pushed into the operational world.

3:18:36 I'm not sure what's happening here. Let's go back. And so, yeah, the $10,000 for the administration component and then audits and so forth. Down below, you see the land acquisition. So for the MAC payments for 13 years, we're going to allocate $180,000. And that really approximates the total purchase of that land and coming from that part of the facility. If you remember, our debt financing for the town hall included $4,500.

3:19:04 Million dollars for the purchase of that property, and that's where the Dave and Roman McCoy Arts and Cultural Center will be located. Capital Improvement Plan, if you review the staff report, Hayes and team put together a really nice write-up that goes through each of the projects, has illustrations, and goes through that. This is, you know, sort of a funding plan for

3:19:30 What we think we will expend our projects in flight, if you will, for fiscal year 26-27. When you look at the MAC or the town hall, those are the total allocations for those particular facilities. Obviously, we've expended a lot this current fiscal year and I think in both of those cases.

3:19:50 The remaining budget should be expended within 26-27 as those projects are expected to be completed in that time frame. There might be some carryover contingency associated with those. But the rest of the projects, if you will, would refer folks to the staff report in order to get more clarification on exactly what those contents are. But these funds, we really...

3:20:12 When we needed allocation, we did that during second quarter. So anything that needed a general fund allocation came from the second quarter review. So there's really no funds associated with this particular budget presentation where I'm asking for more to have these actually covered. So really that's part of that one-time funding that we talked about and the accomplishments there.

3:20:33 The diff accounts, this is one of those things, obviously, development impact fees are associated with our building contracts, so they're tied to building permits that are taken out with the town. Depending upon the elements of the permit, they will trigger some of these components. I tried to give you the estimated fund balance for each of these particular areas, and then what the expected revenue is for the fiscal year. This is really sort of a...

3:20:59 You know, indication of what we do. If you want to read more about it, I think the staff report provides a better understanding, again, with regard to the purpose of these funds and the purposes obviously are listed on the screen here, but just exactly how we accumulate those and really support other agencies within the community with this effort. I know the fire receives quite a bit from that, but also, you know, different components like child care and library and so forth.

3:21:29 That is the extent of the presentation for this evening. And happy to answer any questions on that. I will bring forward a balanced final budget that will incorporate a few more funds that we have yet to discuss. I don't anticipate anything of significance in those, but I will again reconcile differences between what was presented tonight.

3:21:54 And what you will see in the final budget adoption on June 17th. I will also have all of the policies updated and included in that staff report, and those policies will need to be part of the resolution associated with that. In that particular budget, you do get a printout of the final line item detail of the budget and how it looks. Thus far, you've only seen summaries by departments because that's the best way to digest this information sort of at a macro level.

3:22:22 But, yeah, looking forward to having this process sort of come to an end once it's finally adopted. We will load it into our systems and begin a fiscal year 26-27 on July 1. Happy to answer any questions. Questions? I have a question that just came to mind, so I don't expect you to be able to answer it this evening, but maybe it's something we can address before we finalize. Historically,

3:22:52 You know, there's been a lot of things that were nice to have in the town that we budgeted through the quarterly allocations. So, you know, again, I don't expect you to be able to answer this at the moment, but I'm just thinking about, now, historically, we also put a lot of that towards housing before Measure L passed. So Measure L does provide us some level of protection, at least on the housing part.

3:23:22 But what projects or programs in the future could you foresee, and again, this is for you to answer maybe next time, that we wouldn't be able to do? Yeah, Chris, I appreciate that. It's really going to require a whole lot more discipline and analysis and strategic planning for how we invest. I have been thinking about this over the last six weeks of time and how I consider this a bit of a paradigm shift.

3:23:54 From our approach we've had for the last 10 years where we've been blessed with a lot of unallocated revenue, where we were able to make sort of more macro level decisions, I think we're going to have to consider whether or not spending on something will dramatically change the outcome of what I think will inevitably occur through the normal socialization of other changes that are in the community.

3:24:20 That's kind of a mouthful to say, but I have really been thinking a lot about that. The town itself has spent their way out of a lot of challenges, and we've been absolutely blessed to do that. I think our spending has created some very significant headwinds for us as well with regard to expectations of members of our staff, members of the community, expectations that things will forever be.

3:24:46 All those things that have been really the cornerstone of our budgeting are going to significantly change. And I think it just is going to feel and look a little bit different. I think...

3:25:03 Primarily, I want to focus on operational excellence, making sure that we're performing the duties for the community just as tight as we've ever done them, and we're getting that accomplished. But when decisions come up about capital projects, things that we can do, a whole lot more discussion, a whole lot more prioritization, the strategic priorities provided by council are going to have to play a very strong role in those decision-making processes.

3:25:28 But yes, I lay awake at night thinking about just that very question. So thank you for asking it. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? My question is, since we're all looking at numbers, I hope you have, is your schedule more open on our normal meet time? Because I'm going to need more time when we discuss this, because I got a feeling there's going to be a lot more questions that go into this. When the council looks at it and decides what's appropriate and what's not appropriate, it's going to be, we're going to digest the same thing you just discussed and trying to figure things out.

3:25:58 I don't have any more questions on it. Bill? No, I'm good. Thank you. Are there any public comments? No one online? No? Put them to sleep. Okay. All right. Thank you. Appreciate that. Thank you. So we are on to item 10, council member reports. Who would like to kick us off? Anyone? I will if you want me to. Sure. I online attended the seasonal trails transition meeting.

3:26:37 For the new, the change in the website. Went to the MLT unveiling of their new program and three meetings with MLR on the item you guys heard us talk about tonight. Okay. That's it. Brent? I provided individual support for the pamper pedal. It was a great crew and I was glad that Bishop was not at 100 degrees.

3:27:07 Just a reminder, Bing Hunt's Celebration of Life is 1 p.m. Saturday at Shady Rose. Okay. And the road will be open? The road's supposed to be open. Yeah. Okay. Chris? I don't have anything to report, thanks. Okay. Our Eastern Sierra Community Housing meeting got bumped from Monday night. It's going to be later in the month. But I've been having weekly meetings with...

3:27:35 The hiring committee that I'm on, so we're making some progress there, so that's good. And that's all that I have to report. So we will move on to item 11, requests for future agenda items. Anyone have any requests? No? Okay.

3:27:54 So we are going to move on to item number 12, closed session. Item 12.1, pursuant to government code section 54957, the town council will hold a conference to consider evaluation of a public employee town manager. Did you bang anything? No. Okay. Thank you all for coming.