TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2025

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

673 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

5:04 Welcome, everyone. Are mics working? Yeah, I hear myself echoing. This is Wednesday, February 19th at 4 o'clock. So, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Present. Councilmember Truax? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Here. Mayor Bubzer? Here. Now, I have asked Mayor Pro Tem Rice to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Stand and put your right hand over your heart. Ready, begin.

5:41 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. So I'd like to ask people to come up for public comments for items not otherwise on the agenda. Good afternoon. Brianna Goyko, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce.

6:14 Just a few updates on things going on at the Chamber. Next week we have our February Business After Hours at Distant Brewing in partnership with Systems Process People. So that's next Tuesday, February 25th, 5 to 7 at Distant. So always a good mixer for the business community and broader community. We've had some really great Power Lunch programs lately. We've had one on AI that Dr. Karch did for us back in January. We just had one.

6:43 Thank you so much for joining us.

7:13 25 different business owners there. We partnered with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, did some, talked a little bit about TBID and exactly what it is and what it does for the business community and specifically for these business owners. We also had Lupita Lopez from the town finance department speak about how to remit and speak to that side of the process. So really great kind of first step in engaging more with our Hispanic business community.

7:43 A couple weeks ago, two weeks ago, I think, we attended the Western Association of Chamber of Commerce Executives.

7:52 Conference, excuse me, long acronym, held in Henderson, Nevada, and we were awarded the best e-newsletter for a small chamber of commerce, so very exciting. I think really speaks to the work that we've done to make sure our newsletter is as concise as possible, and Gina Van Hest, our communications manager, has done really great work in making it read well and be easy and quick to consume.

8:20 So, and then last thing, I know that you all are used to presenting plaques and awards to others, but we actually have one for you tonight. Just to thank you as a President Circle member of the Chamber, obviously one of our highest investor of the Chamber, I just wanted to thank all of you for your commitment to the Chamber and the business community in Mammoth Lakes, so I want to present this to you. I'll just come and give it to Chris, if that's okay. Thank you.

8:47 I was going to say, give it to Brent. Thank you. Thank you. And I'm going to give it to Rob. Thank you. Thank you very much. Next.

9:20 Good evening, Council. Good evening, everyone. Betsy Truax, Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Our board chair, Pat Foster, will give you an update on some of our board activities a little later, but I wanted to, for the benefit of the community, just talk about a couple of things. Community coffee. So last month's community coffee, we talked about wildfire resilience. Really appreciated everyone's participation in that, and I wanted to let you all know that all of our community coffee recordings are archived at Visit Mammoth Lakes.

9:50 So if you want to go back and watch, that's always an option. And then next month on Thursday, February 27th at 8.30 a.m., we will have a sustainability-focused community coffee. So we will have the sustainability coordinators from Mammoth Disposal and from the Town of Mammoth Lakes talking about some of the new regulations that are coming into place and how those are being implemented. So really looking forward to that.

10:15 And our next community skate night will be on March 5th from 7.30 to 9 o'clock. We will have free ice skating, free ice skating rentals, and free hot chocolate. The February community skate night was our most successful to date with around 100 attendees. We gave out around 70 cups of hot chocolate. So just really want to encourage the community to come on out. Really appreciate the partnership with the town on that. So come on out and enjoy our amazing ice rink. So thank you very much.

10:45 Thank you. I highly recommend going back and listening to the Wildfire Community Coffee. You can find it at the Mammoth Lakes Tourism, so visit mammoth.com or at the chamber because they co-sponsor, if I'm correct, and I highly, highly recommend watching that. It was an excellent program. Jamie, any public comments online? Anyone else? Last chance. Okay, no one's approaching the podium, so we will go off.

11:14 Are there any additions to the agenda this evening? No, Madam Mayor, there are not. Okay. Then we will proceed with our item 5.1, a joint workshop with the board of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. So welcome. We're glad you're here. Thanks for having us. Great. Do we need to ensure you have a quorum of your board or anything? Yeah, I think we have a quorum with Amanda. And Jennifer is on her way. Is somebody online or we don't have a quorum?

11:55 Oh, four. One short, it appears. I have one on the way, but I don't know how long. Maybe we take it out of order if there's something that we could do instead of waiting. We could do that, or is there anything, well, there's nothing in your presentation that you can talk about without it. Right now, it's just a council meeting. It's on the SCH meeting. You can get started.

12:31 So in the absence of the forum, you can continue with the discussion as a council meeting. Sure. Okay. And I don't think there's actionable items on tonight's discussion. Right. I don't think there was any. Okay. I think especially if you have somebody en route, then you're probably in good shape to proceed with that. Fantastic. So please go ahead, Nolan. Great.

12:54 So this meeting really is an opportunity to get the town council together with the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors. The agenda here highlighting some new, what's new at ESCH, what's new at the town regarding housing, and then to highlight some of the ongoing projects and programs, mainly on the rental side and the ownership side. And then

13:23 There's also some discussion topics related to ownership and some changes that we're considering related to kind of mainly with the bridge program and some of the programs going forward and then a discussion related to the upcoming contract negotiations since the ESCH contract is up this coming June. I just wanted to highlight a few things, what's going on at Eastern Sierra Community Housing.

13:50 Briefly, I'm working on our annual report so that we can let all of our community and funders know what we've been doing and accomplished in 2024. And as I was working through that, I wanted to share with the town council that we did adopt a new three-year strategic plan for the organization in 2024. We have partnered with a credit card processor to...

14:18 To partner with local businesses to create a new way for businesses to donate to housing causes without affecting their bottom line. And we're growing that program. I think right now we have two businesses signed up and one in the works. And then I also wanted to just highlight that we are, you'll hear a little bit more about our current construction projects, but our upcoming project will be

14:46 In acquisition rehab in the city of Bishop called the Valley Apartments, we were awarded almost a $5 million grant to rehabilitate 19 studio apartments in Bishop. And so that will be our next big project in the pipeline.

15:04 Great. And just to highlight a few items related to the town's housing program. So we are getting ready to go out with the recruitment of the housing manager. This position is to replace my prior position, which was senior planner and housing coordinator. We did go out with a recruitment on that previously. And the candidate that we'd ultimately selected on that ended up backing out. And so we did take an opportunity to really review that.

15:32 That job description and what it is that we were hoping to find in a housing person and the role before was kind of a hybrid of planning and housing and I think with the goal is to really shift that to just be as someone who focuses solely on the housing program and building out that program. So we're excited to go live with that recruitment here in the next few weeks.

15:56 We also have kicked off the housing, the regional housing needs study for the Eastern Sierra. It's a combined effort between Inyo County, Mono County, City of Bishop and the town of Mammoth Lakes to develop a regional housing needs assessment so it'll look at each entity individually but also across the region to identify some trends and gaps and also identify, come up with an action plan to hopefully

16:26 Not only assist projects here in Mammoth, but across the region to really address the workforce housing challenges here. So we do have the first stakeholder meeting or workshop scheduled for next Thursday. There will be additional information going out on social media and a press release this week. It's from 9 to 10 a.m. next Thursday, and it will be entirely on

16:51 On Zoom. And then future stakeholder meetings will be in person. We're also looking to do a very targeted outreach across the region to really bring the Hispanic community in. So engaging with that community through we're kind of reviewing the options, whether it's a dedicated workshop in Spanish to get feedback from.

17:13 Most folks, but that is also being included in that. All the materials for the workshop will be translated and available in Spanish as well. And then lastly, on what's new in the town is the Measure L, which was passed in November. The town council has committed that 100% of the funds raised through Measure L will be dedicated to housing. So it's exciting that there is a...

17:37 A dedicated housing or dedicated funding stream for housing going forward so we can begin to program and implement projects with those funds. So moving on to just a highlight on rental projects and programs. Patricia will highlight the two projects that ESCH currently has under construction and then the town will provide an update on our projects. Great, thank you. The Innsbruck Lodge we acquired in August of 2022.

18:13 Using a $4.4 million grant from the State of California through the Project Home Key Program, along with a substantial contribution from the Town of Mammoth Lakes and other contributions from Mono County and the Regional Continuum of Care. This project will deliver 15 units homes for homelessness prevention and one manager's unit. We received a temporary certificate of occupancy in June 2024.

18:44 to occupy five units with tenants and also the manager's unit. We pursued the temporary certificate of occupancy due to a delay in the delivery of the electrical equipment in order to support the additional 10 full-time residents. We expect that equipment has now arrived and we expect to be able to fill the remaining units by April 1st. This has been a

19:14 Grand undertaking, but it's really been eye-opening and successful. Along with expanding our staff to two additional housing navigators, we're able to meet with the community one-on-one more frequently, understand what the needs are, access the regional coordinated entry system, which is a database of households with high needs, including housing.

19:44 And currently there's 250 households in the region in the coordinated entry system that are in need of housing and 120 of those are in Mono County. These are all different members of our community including families, workforce, young adults that grew up here and youth and single parents and so it really is

20:14 Really, you know, housing affects everybody, right, because everybody needs a home. You can go to the next slide. Here's just some highlights, but I also wanted to mention that we received approximately $60,000 in rental subsidy funding through the ESG program, through the continuum of care for rental subsidy and deposits for those that are unable to afford a housing deposit.

20:46 Specifically for the Innsbruck Lodge Project. And an additional $25,000 from U.S. Bank for the same purpose. At our March meeting, we'll be asking our board of directors to approve a resolution to apply for additional funds through that program. We'll be asking for somewhere around $500,000 over a three-year period. And that would...

21:14 And that we would broaden that program so that it's not specific to Innsbruck Lodge but that we would also serve other housing opportunities with that program. Actually, we are the only independent agency providing these types of resources in the region specifically for the general population. The last thing on this project I just wanted to highlight was that we did have to relocate our gas supply from

21:50 The rear of the building where it was a shared supply with our neighbor, when they started doing grading work, they removed the gas tank, and so we needed to move our gas tank into the parking lot. It's not ideal. It's taking up at least two parking spaces, and so I think a goal for the future that we have for this project is to try to connect to the main gas line in the village, which is so close yet so far. So I just wanted to...

22:20 It's not the prettiest right now, but we do have goals for how we could improve that in the future. Can I ask a question on this project? Sure. So who owns the building and then who's managing? These are rental units, correct? So who's managing? Who's doing the property management? We are self-managing that project. And do you guys own the building? Yes, we own the building through a sole purpose LLC.

22:48 Okay, and you own the dirt, you own the lot, you own the whole thing? Yes. And you're doing the property management? Yes. Okay, good. Thank you. For the total development cost per unit? I could get you that information. No. Go ahead. This is our next project that we've been working on, the access apartments, which is the acquisition and conversion of the old country glass building.

23:32 This project will produce studios and one bedrooms and also provide garage spaces for tenants to rent as well. This project is the result of a $7 million CDBG award and substantial contributions from the town and our other partners, including $200,000 in private donations.

24:07 Here's just some updates on the construction progress. We broke ground over the summer, and we are expecting occupancy to be in the fall of 2025. About this year? Yeah. Questions? Goes by so fast. The CDBG are federal grants, correct? Correct, through the state. But are they, was it fully funded, like you already have received all those funds and you're not awaiting any?

24:36 The state has the funds. It's a reimbursement program. Okay. So it's our understanding that the state has been awarded those funds and that we will get them on a reimbursement basis. Just to follow up, I think the inference of a question is, is the funding secured? Yes. So I understand the current grants that the state has the funds on hand.

25:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

25:30 Approaching so that we have a clear understanding of at least how risky some projects are. I would imagine things are different. One of the presentations I'll have later on today talks a little bit about the inventory of dependency on these federal programs and talks about having eyes on the visibility of where those vulnerabilities are. Thank you.

25:53 To that point, the rental subsidy program I mentioned earlier is also federal funds. And so we're in a current open grant cycle and our board will have this discussion on March 3rd to decide whether to apply. So that could impact our ability to help people pay for deposits and rent. I hear you say that the garages would be for rent extra than the rent.

26:17 On the units? We actually haven't determined, I haven't determined the rent schedule. Some of the units are different sizes and so we're working out what the rents would be in, you know, in relative terms. So how would that, and maybe this isn't for today, but then how would that work out if somebody is in the 80 percentile AMI and they qualify for X amount of dollars of rent of the unit, then how does that affect that if they're going to pay extra for the garage? And without them do you have...

26:48 My fear is there are so many places in town that have been built with garages that are rentable. The tenants don't rent them, then they get rented by someone else and it creates an even larger parking problem than you would have anyway. Without the garages, are there adequate parking spaces for all the units? No, without the garages, no. Right, so we have to look at coupling them with the units. Yes. Right, so then how does that affect the AMI percentages?

27:17 And the rents that you charge for that? Right. The rent will be based on the unit. And if a household decides to spend discretionary income on a garage, then they have the ability to do that. And I think the access permits, that allows a few households of up to 120% AMI. Three units, yeah. Right. And how many garages? I thought it was five. Is your mic on, Bill?

27:42 No, but I'm talking loud. Are you? I don't know. Seven units will be for 80% AMI and six will be for 120% AMI. Right, but it's still the same thing. 120% pays a percentage of their income. If we add the garage cost on top of that and they refuse that, then there is not parking for them, so I'm hoping we get that figured out. I see your worry or the potential problem that it could create, but I think that...

28:09 The goal is to have everyone have a parking space there, but, you know, like, it's not decided as to what units will get the garages. And so there's still, you know, we're going to figure that out and, you know, make sure that it works and that everyone can park, but it's not set in stone. Yeah. Thank you. And one other thing I'd highlight on the question about the federal funding and whether it's secure, we had a, what I would call a unique surprise come up in July.

28:39 Yeah, July of last year, where HCD actually approached the town and said, we have excess CDBG dollars on hand that we need to commit to a project, a shovel-ready project, because they're undersubscribed on other programs, so they actually had extra funding to commit out on hand, which then we were able to tap into and secure for this project. So it decided that these funds were funds that this...

29:08 Already been provided to the state. We're in the state's coffer to then distribute out to eligible jurisdictions. I remember when that happened. It was very exciting. It was like winning a lottery. So that's fantastic. Yeah, we just hope that stream will continue because it allows us to do great work. So thank you. This is just a few updates. We walked the structure. And since then, they've been putting in drywall.

29:39 The medal will be arriving for the roof and the siding and will be on schedule, like I said. And then I just included a slide that shows the income levels that we'll be serving and household sizes. So there will be two studio apartments and 11 one-bedroom apartments. How many parking spaces are there? I believe there's 10 plus an ADA space. 10 spaces including garage spaces? Yes. Okay. So 10 total?

30:12 Plus an ADA, and if no one is ADA in the building, no one can park there? Correct. Well, I see your worry, Bill. Yes, parking was a big conversation during both of these projects, and both of these projects were approved under SB35, Streamline Processing through the town, which didn't require us to provide the standard amount of parking due to our location close by to a transit stop. And I understand that. It doesn't mean the people who...

30:45 Working this town don't have cars. Of course. And the garages are actually a result of public feedback that we receive from the community, so I hope tenants will rent them. Patricia, maybe for the public's benefit on the AMI chart there, the allowable rents would be what percentage of the income levels? No more than 30% of their gross monthly income. So you can do the math.

31:18 See what the rent potentials would be for the units. I would just add that I've had an opportunity to walk the property on a couple occasions. In fact, yesterday I was out there with our project manager and toured it. And yeah, they're working on putting the metal roof in. We have a great contractor who's been pushed. He started fairly late in the summer just because of getting all our ducks in a row with the funding and so forth and final approvals from council. But we're able to start in August. And they were able to push things along.

31:48 And continue to work through this winter season. They easily have not made it, had Mother Nature thrown in a couple of big storms like we just had early on. But fortunately, that wasn't the case for the purpose of this project, unfortunately. And in any event, they're moving right along. So they're anticipating to be done by sort of mid-summer time frame and making great progress. Units are just really...

32:12 Cool and unique units there because of the fact that it's an adaptive reuse project. But I think people that went again there are going to be pretty excited to see the opportunity. Thank you. So jumping over to highlight some of the town's rental projects, we recently or last summer completed the first phase of the parcel. So that's 81 units. Those units were completely leased up as of December 2024, the 81 units.

32:42 We have been having ongoing conversations with the property manager and other entities out there just dealing with issues as they've come up and trying to address those. It's not a town-owned project or a town-managed project, but we're obviously very heavily involved and want to see the success of that project. So we have been working closely with the property manager, Buckingham, and the property owner, both on that first phase and then the subsequent phases to that project.

33:12 The next phase that's under construction is the Kingfisher. There's 76 units in phase 2.1. And then there's an additional 72 units that are through the entitlement phase and are awaiting funding. And so as soon as that they were, if they're able to secure funding through tax credits or other funding sources, then they would proceed with construction on those 72 units. We will see

33:41 Continued work this coming spring, summer and fall on the 76 units. Our understanding is since it is a modular project, all of the units have already been completed and are built and are awaiting shipping here. So they're out in Idaho waiting to be trucked out here. So we anticipate seeing those start to arrive this summer and then going up on the site.

34:04 All the rental phases of the parcel include a mix of rental units from 30 to 80 percent AMI. Majority of that spread of units in the mix is required by the funding sources. So in this case it was the tax credits or the LIHTC program requires that mix of units and then

34:24 Just for kind of to Tom's point earlier, what the rents for those mean, the rents range from $400 to $1,800 depending on the AMI group and household size within the parcel project. The next rental project is a unique project in that it's not providing a permanent... So you're going to van life? Yes. So before we go to that, because I'm assuming this is your regular monthly...

34:52 Or your meeting update on the parcel project. Yes. So some of us, I haven't talked to my fellow council members, we've got some phone calls about snow removal at the parcel. Obviously this is a workforce project and I hope that, I know it's on the priority list to start talking about snow management programs, but I think it's going to be important probably to prioritize snow removal there so those folks can get out. I know this is the first winter with the project, but

35:20 So there's that. There's also some questions about elevators, also some questions about law enforcement having to do with some of the county units. Who's accountable for that? Is it us? We don't own the proper project. How do we navigate those things to make sure that those issues get addressed? Sure. So I think we can start on snow removal. So within the kind of project itself, so coming out of their driveways, that's...

35:46 Part of their project and their responsibility to maintain those kind of exact driveways. However, once you get out to Tavern Road and then Inyo Street, those are public roads. The town is doing snow removal throughout all the main public areas of the project. So that's on the town regular snow removal routes there. Okay, so I would just, again, for future discussion, it may make sense to start, when we start talking about the snow management plan, which I know has been an idea to come forward, that might be something to be thinking about.

36:13 So is there an on-site property manager who's doing snow removal in those pathways that lead to the street? It's my understanding that it falls to Buckingham to remove that, how it's being done. I can definitely follow up with the council on who's doing that. There is an on-site property manager that's living on the site. That was a question that came up a few weeks ago. There's a...

36:36 A district supervisor for Buckingham that is in the area that's managing all their projects here in Mammoth as well as outside of Mammoth. I think they have one project down in Inyo County. And then there is an on-site property manager who lives full-time at the Sawyer who is there to really handle those any tenant issues that arise and other issues that arise. We have heard of the issues with the elevator from

37:04 The fire district getting regularly called out there as people either gotten stuck in the elevator. I understand through the property management, it's somewhat related to, as they say, kids jumping up and down the elevator. Somehow that breaks the elevator. I'm not sure exactly. I'm not good at it. And they are working through kind of a protocol to deal with that. My understanding is the property manager does not have the ability or the...

37:34 Thank you. Thank you.

37:59 Just clarify on that one, so the property managers there, who at the town staff is the point contact for that property manager? Is that you or is that Rob or somebody else? I mean, since the town is, we have no ownership in the project, they, so we get told of the issues, but really it's, our role in it is to provide, provide to the upper level management at Buckingham the issues that are brought up.

38:25 So as issues, as we're told of issues like the elevator, as we're told of issues related to the law enforcement, we then convey those to the kind of the district level manager for Buckingham and the property owner, which is Pacific West of, hey, these are the issues we're hearing with your project. Is there, I mean, I remember being a kid jumping in elevators and I never broke the elevator. Like, is that standard? It's a brand new elevator.

38:52 Like, I feel like this is something we should contact the developer about, you know, that kids jumping in the elevator is breaking it. That seems like, I mean, I'm not an elevator technician, but that to me seems like shouldn't happen. So, like, what recourse do we have or how do we help? So, let's kind of address some of the things that Nolan's been talking about with regard to our involvement with that facility. When these things have been brought to our attention, we have immediately picked up the phone and had conversations with Buckingham.

39:21 We don't, I think, have anything we can compel them with other than our expectations of the project and the success of that project. I know we've addressed a few things thus far, and we will also take these forward yet again with them and try to figure that out. I'm not sure about the jumping up and down in the elevator component. I think that may be some anecdotal stuff we've heard on that. But we can get to the bottom of it. I think what we're trying to do is we're compelling a third party who's responsible for that to

39:50 Make corrective actions. And that's where it's a little bit challenging for us. But we certainly understand the importance. And frankly, how while we're not responsible for anything in that project, that we ultimately are for the success of that all the way around. So that's how we've kind of addressed it with them to say this has to be different than reality that we're seeing. Is that something that we've brought up with Pacific also? I mean, to me, I know Buckingham didn't build the building. Like, that seems like.

40:20 Yeah, so when we were told of the initial problems, we immediately brought them up with Buckingham and Pacific. Pacific is the developer, but they're also the long-term owner of the project, so they're obviously invested in making sure the project is built to a certain quality and it's going to last throughout the, you know, obviously not just the near term, but they have a 55-year.

40:44 Regulatory Agreement, which not only specifies the terms related to like the affordability restrictions, but it also outlines requirements for how much money they're setting aside for the ongoing maintenance and operations of the project. So they're obviously, they're committed for the long term to see that project not fall apart. So it, like I said, we...

41:07 When we're told the problems, immediately bring it up with them and then kind of having a follow-up meetings with them to hopefully get to a resolution on the items, not just tell it to them and then have it ignored. And so the elevator issues, like I said, that was the initial response from them was that what was causing the issues, also that their property manager is indeed on site. So I was also a concern from before that there wasn't a property manager living there. I said there's two different, there's the district kind of supervisor who,

41:37 Thank you. Thank you.

42:07 I know they're required to have one on site, but is that a full-time manager? It is a full-time manager. He lives there, but I know a lot of situations where managers live there yet have other jobs and are not dedicated just to that, so they aren't there to shovel the walkways, they aren't there to maintain, so we're certain that that manager is a full-time worker on site. I can follow up on that. My understanding is there's...

42:34 The manager maintains kind of regular office hours where they're there eight to five and then they're also living there on site. Yeah. And that was one of those areas where we talked about addressing things because that was a problem once before and I think I don't remember the last time we had that conversation but since then that has been rectified. Okay. Then on the law enforcement issues our understanding is you know it some of the challenges of mixing when you have

43:03 Across the state, the state's made a big effort to include supportive housing units in housing projects throughout the state. And so that a lot of the supportive housing units are the 30% AMI units included in that kind of mix of units when we say the 30 to 80%. They were committed to Mono County Behavioral Health for their clients. And then...

43:30 Many of them do have various issues, whether it be kind of behavioral or mental issues. So there is that possibility for some challenges between the other tenants and then the Mono County Behavioral Health tenants. Our understanding is PD has been out there pretty regularly. Mono County Behavioral Health is aware of the issues. They have staff and caseworkers that are on site full-time that

43:58 Are intended to really provide that buffer between and help with those issues. However, we have heard that they continue to come up, so it's an ongoing problem that we're working through with Buckingham. They're definitely aware of it. Mona County Behavioral Health is aware of it. Hopefully, we'll see some progress there once this is also Mona County's first kind of project or first.

44:26 I don't know if Chief wants to weigh in on some of the issues or calls they've had going out there.

44:56 But that's our understanding is primarily with those tenants. And you're working obviously too with Amanda. Correct. So we've responded quite a, it's been pretty frequent out to the parcel units for behavioral health issues. Behavioral health being on site, this is the first I've heard of it. When we do have issues, regardless of where it's at, we will contact behavioral health.

45:24 When we do contact behavioral health at the parcel, there's been no mention of anybody being on site. If that's the case, that would be great. Maybe they're supposed to be there, but we just deal with it the way that we usually deal with behavioral health issues and try to get a hold of behavioral health or take them to Mammoth Hospital for evaluation. So, but yeah, I'll follow up on that as well to see if there's anybody on site, because if that's the case, that would be huge for our organization. I'm not sure if she's there full time, but she hasn't.

45:53 I'm not sure. When it happens, it's not during office hours. Right. They don't live there. If there's damage done over there on the property, we're not responsible as a community to pay for that, but how do we make sure it's maintained in a proper fashion after that damage has been done? Sure. So they're required to provide an annual report on the project that documents not only

46:22 For the income certification and the tenant eligibility, but it also includes the property assessment report, which is a third-party review to review kind of exactly the maintenance, any damage, and then through that a follow-up report as they tap into their capital or the reserve funds to make repairs for anything that's damaged.

46:49 Throughout the term of the regulatory agreement, that's required to ensure that the property is being maintained. Great. So the next rental project to highlight here is what we call the van life project. This is kind of a pilot program that we're working on implementing. It's a partnership program with Mono County, the town, and the ski area. Really the basic premise of it is leasing of spaces for vehicle parking. So that would be for overnight parking. They would lease that space.

47:25 Those tenants would, that would be their committed space for the period of the lease. The site we're looking at is the Sheriff's substation site down by the 203 and 395. The site control was obtained by Mono County at the end of December 2024. The previous tenant had vacated the site, and so Mono County...

47:50 And then staff from the town and ski area were able to get on the site in January 2025 to look at the condition of the facilities there and really just the site overall to start working towards launching this project. So we continue to work with the ski area and the county on defining the roles and responsibilities. So with this project, we envision that the county would lease the site to the town and then we would execute

48:18 An agreement with the ski area to then operate the site on our behalf. The ski area has expertise in working with more of a seasonal workforce and those who are coming and going, so I think it's a good fit for this project as well for kind of what we see. Van life is typically those who, you know, some are in that situation because they can't find other permanent housing, but others are in that situation because they choose to live.

48:48 Have that kind of flexibility to come and go. So we think it's a good fit working with the ski area on this project. Some of the amenities we see that we intend to provide on the site include restrooms, trash facilities, and snow removal. And we're looking into the feasibility of providing showers and potable water, whether that be through a trailer or there's a well on site. So there's ongoing review as to what

49:16 What amenities should be provided? We're also looking to stand it up as what's called a low barrier navigation center. The state provided a kind of very specific CEQA exemption if you qualify under that criteria. What it requires is that there's being services provided to the tenants to connect them with opportunities for permanent housing through the coordinated entry system.

49:42 So Patricia touched on that earlier. It's the same system used to place tenants into the Innsbruck Lodge. So we would be looking to ESCH to provide those services out there. Our understanding of that exemption, it doesn't require someone onsite permanently. It just requires routine visits by a staff person who's then providing that information to those tenants on how to get registered in the coordinated entry system and how to, if they desire, work towards permanent housing. So we think it's a very,

50:12 Well fits with the intent of the project. We are continuing to meet regularly with Mono County staff and the ski area staff on this project to hopefully get it live here in the next few months is our goal.

50:27 Is there any way we can move that any faster? Can we help in any way? Because I've been asking about this several times about the RV park and where we can do and help with van life. I see it's an opportunity that we can take care of some situations we have around the town and the community, and it'd be great to have it up and going. It's exciting to see that we're moving in this direction. If there's anything we can do to help move this faster? Find extra staff people and we can get it done quick. No, it's definitely on our priority list.

50:53 Hayes and I were actually talking about this morning really needing to sit down and hammer out the kind of just basic project description. You know, we have all the bullet points of what it is we want to do and how we want it to operate. And so we really just need to put that in words and then move the agreement with the ski area, kind of finalize that. So I think we're pretty close to getting it going. One question. I asked where the location was. I don't...

51:26 It would merit mentioning if you hadn't. Sure, it's the sheriff's substation. So it was previously the dog sledding operation site. That tenant has vacated the site, so it's currently vacant. And so my next question then would be, I know it says the site's going to include restrooms, trash, snow removal, and tentatively showers and potable water because there's a building there. But would we be required to wait for any build out or could it start as soon as the other parts are worked out?

51:56 Sure. So we anticipate, see it really as a pilot program initially, and so not putting, not fixing the building up. So the restrooms would be port-a-body or a trailer. Obviously they have to be winterized ones or capable with the weather. Same with trash would be dumpster snow removal. The county is already plowing that road and so working with them, they see that it'd be very easy just to blade that out. Like I said, the showers and potable water would be kind of...

52:25 Nice to have. It's just a matter of, is that feasible? Can a trailer be brought in that provides that? Can the well be, there's some arsenic issues, our understanding that can be dealt with, which is just a fairly simple filter system. So we feel that those improvements could be done very quickly. And then down the road, if we see if it's successful, we want to continue it, looking into, can there be permanent upgrades to the building?

52:53 The building will need quite a bit of kind of remediation for just rodents and other issues there. But we also see an opportunity where that could be, you know, with fairly minimal investment, a warming center could have a community kitchen, could have various amenities on there. Like the structure of the building is sound. It just needs, yeah. All right, thank you. So yeah, the initial pilot program is not looking to

53:21 Put, you know, permanent infrastructure in there. It's really temporary infrastructure to get it stood up and operating. Stepping over to the ownership projects that we have ongoing, all these projects really are working closely with ESCH on their existing wait lists, those in their queue, and also utilizing them with their real estate services to then facilitate on both the acquisition of units and the sale of units.

53:56 So the first project on the screen here is our Joaquin project. It's located at 60 Joaquin. It's four units. That'll be ownership units that are nearing completion. Talking with Public Works this morning, since it is a capital project, we are scheduling both the certificate of occupancy inspections but also the punch walk to look on the site from the owner's kind of viewpoint of anything we want them to fix or correct.

54:25 We anticipate that happening here in the next two weeks. So then following that punch walk, they would then be addressing any of those issues that we've identified. So we really think that the units, I'd say, in the next six weeks, and that's...

54:42 Hopefully it's a lot shorter. We'll be completed with the CFO, and we can then really move forward on the marketing and the sale of those units. We do anticipate working through ESCH to market those units. Right now the marketing plan is looking to utilize kind of social media outreach, social media to advertise those units. We also envision reaching out through the chamber to then engage with the business community of the availability of units.

55:12 And at the level of interest on those units, again, it's only four units, deciding whether we do it through a lottery process to select who we kind of have the first opportunity or is it going to be a first come, first serve based on the interest list. There's pros and cons to each, but we are very excited to be moving this forward. We do see this as kind of our first endeavor into building our own units rather than

55:38 Purchasing existing units out there, which is what the bridge program's for. Right now, we've kind of identified a preliminary purchase price of around $550,000. They are two-bedroom units with an additional space that could be a guest room, could be an office, could be a family room, could be a dining room. They're two and a half bathrooms, and they do have a two-car garage. And so the purchase price isn't set in stone. Working really with ESCH on, is that a

56:07 A viable price for the target households. We are looking at for the AMIs, whether it's 150% or up to 200% AMI for the target households on that project. Moving on to the parcel. This would be phase three of the parcel. We've talked with council heavily about this project. We had a pretty intensive workshop with them a few meetings ago, really, to get feedback on what the vision is for this site.

56:36 We then took that feedback and conveyed it to the developer, which in this case is specific, on what our desires are for how that site will look and feel. So the direction we gave them was to look at a range of 35 to 40 units on that site and a mixture of two, three, and four-plex structures to mix up the look and feel.

57:04 And the target for those would be in that 150 to 200% AMI range. And so working with the developer, our initial kind of efforts is really to get the site layout figured out with them. And then from there, we can then really dive into the financials of the project and what those subsidies might look like for the units. But first, we have to get the design worked out.

57:29 Moving on to the bridge program. This program we've had in place for a few years now. Really, it's focusing on utilizing existing housing stock to provide affordable ownership opportunities for the local workforce. Through this program, we have sold eight units. There's currently one in escrow. It's anticipated to close next week. There's two units currently for sale, and there's one unit that's currently being used as a long-term rental that we hope to then

58:00 Provide as a list for sale in the near future. When we stood up the program, we had a goal of having the average subsidy across the kind of sale of all the units to be below $150,000. Thus far, based on the units sold and the anticipated sales prices for those additional units, we're at $135,000 average. So we're definitely meeting what that kind of set goal was.

58:28 And then I'll let Patricia talk a little bit about the clients that have been placed in those units. Thank you, Nolan. Well, so we've helped eight households, and we will help one more next week. These households have employees in food and beverage, trades, Mono County, the school district, nonprofit administration.

58:59 Public Employment, and Property Management. So a broad range of workforce participating in the program. Currently we have 12 applications in the queue at various different income levels. I think the majority, the largest group that we're seeing I think is single households just over the 80% AMI level.

59:33 So at that point, you no longer qualify for large down payment assistance programs. And prices are sometimes at the higher end of the spectrum for that income group. So Nolan and I are working on how do we make sure that the whole range of the income group is being served and not just one portion. On the next slide.

1:00:03 I just wanted to say that this program is, I would say, staff intensive. It's really hard work to run this program, and I think all of us have been doing a really great job collectively. And I just, you know, real estate can be highly emotionally charged. First-time homebuyers need a lot of extra help. There's tight timelines.

1:00:31 Big decisions that need to be made. And I just wanted everyone to know that the recipients of this program are very grateful to have housing stability and an improved quality of life. So that's why I added those. Can I add, I mean, you mentioned, Patricia, that the current wait list for homeownership is how deep at the moment? Twelve. Twelve, okay. So in view of the four units at Joaquin that will be coming available soon?

1:01:02 Phase through the parcel, which I think would be the summer after this, right? I believe is the delivery timeframe on that, if I understood correctly. There's a lot of units right there, right? In that 150 to 200. So I would just encourage members of the public who are looking for housing, who would recognize they're in that income level, that, you know, go ahead and get your application in. You basically get income qualified.

1:01:27 You're being standing for all these projects as they become available in the future. So there's no need to wait. And so just a little plug there, just people realize that the opportunity is coming quick and the sooner you can get all of your paperwork squared away because they do have to go through sort of the verification of incomes and stuff and make sure you fit within those slotted income levels. You know, just all the better off you'll be in terms of first come, first serve or priority or how things go. So, yeah.

1:01:56 Is that a true statement, Nolan, Patricia? Definitely. We, you know, I think hear about a lot of people who say, oh, we can't afford anything. We can't. And then you ask them, like, well, have you gone and talked to the staff over at Eastern Sierra Community Housing to learn what opportunities are out there? And usually the answer is no. So we constantly encourage those to reach out to their staff to learn about what opportunities are out there and then how to get on the wait list for future opportunities that come up.

1:02:25 So quick question. If there are 12 people on the wait list and Joaquin's coming online but the units at the parcel are still a bit away if someone's ready now, are there additional units that we could put into the bridge program? Because I thought we had funding. I thought we had allocated funding for that. There is. So we're constantly looking kind of what's coming on currently for sale as to whether they, you know, are a good fit for the program.

1:02:55 The slide that's actually on the screen here touches on some of that on some potential changes to how we approach the program and how we look at units. So I think it's a great segue into this next slide. Thanks. So I think Patricia will just touch on some of the challenges that we've seen with the ownership program. These aren't, they're not surprises. They're not new challenges. It's just that

1:03:22 The kind of nature of real estate and that it's constantly changing. Yeah, so when Nolan and I are looking for units that meet the needs of our households on the waiting list, we have to take into consideration the HOAs and unknown increases that could be happening tomorrow in terms of insurance and rising monthly HOA costs.

1:03:52 But what's really difficult is that you have to have the right client and the right unit and the right purchase price all come together at the same time. So even though we have 12 households in the queue, I would say the vast majority of those we've been in contact with and run numbers with and some of them can't afford the units that we have available right now.

1:04:19 And so we're always negotiating on if there's additional subsidy, what other programs can they use? Can we buy down the interest rate? How can we factor that in to make the payment more affordable? So it's really a puzzle. And the challenge comes when you need the subsidy and the market prices are high and the subsidy needed is so much.

1:04:51 I find a lot of the pushback when I'm trying to put the pieces together. But I also do worry a lot about the HOAs. And so we're looking for, you know, complexes that have low HOAs maybe today, but that's not forever. Thank you. Then, yeah, then touching over to some of the, like I said, the ideas and concepts we have as this program continues to evolve, the nice thing about the bridge program and then even the Joaquin units or the

1:05:26 The phase through the parcel is that we're not taking state funding to either acquire those units or develop those units. So we really have the flexibility to design the program as we see fit or how it will best serve the community. And then if something's not working, have the ability to quickly make changes to the program to improve its use. And so some of the ideas and concepts that we're working through.

1:05:55 I'll let Patricia talk about the lease to own. We've also had an inquiry whether remote workers should be eligible to purchase units through this program. Again, the program really was stood up to serve the workforce and the needs of the community, so that was an issue. The last two is the direct sale to clients and the option for equity share to remove the deed restrictions. So I'll let Patricia start with the lease to own concept.

1:06:23 We are looking for feedback from both the council and the board on ideas and thoughts on these topics. The lease to own option came up when working with a household client interested in one of our bridge units who at the time didn't have down payment. And if they had some down payment, it would have gotten them a better interest rate and it would have worked out in the end. And so in an effort to try to make it work,

1:06:53 I was thinking maybe you could do a lease to own where part of their rent goes towards savings for their down payment. And at the time it wasn't because they didn't have savings, it was because they had a medical emergency that drained their savings. And so that happens to a lot of Americans. So I knew that they were able to save. And so how could we make it work? Could we set up a lease to own program where

1:07:22 For 12 months, part of your rent goes to save to your down payment, and then if you want to buy it, you have to do it within 12 months, or maybe it's 24 months, or whatever the timeline is, and then part of that money goes towards their closing, you know, that savings part goes towards their closing costs, or goes towards their down payment to help make, buy down the rate, or whatever they need to do at that time.

1:07:50 We haven't done it. It hasn't worked out, but it was just an idea that's come up in conversation. So it would be a short-term lease to own, not like a carrying it for 30 years lease to own. You're talking about a short-term lease to own. Yes, and I think because the intention of the unit in the bridge program is for home ownership, a time limit I think would be important to make sure we keep the unit for the intended purpose. So if it was a lease to own,

1:08:18 Would you be buying the unit and then be the leasee? Yes, it was a unit that we currently own. I think that's an interesting idea for units that are harder to fill also. You know, units that are in maybe lower AMI levels that we have a hard time, you know, it's like you have to have enough need to qualify for the unit, but then you're supposed to have a pile of cash to purchase.

1:08:48 So that one, to me, is interesting, knowing that it would be a short lease and not that we're leasing it for 30 years to somebody to own it. You want everyone's thoughts about these ideas, right? And it's not uncommon for the lease to own. It's been out there for other people, other agencies. I think it's an option to look at for providing housing. I think I recall once trying it when I was at then MLH.

1:09:25 Didn't end up working for various reasons. It is, it does require a little more, it's a little more intensive because you have to manage the unit, which, you know, you guys are already managing units, but accounting for the funds as well because you're creating like an escrow account specifically for their funds. So it's just a little bit more complicated, something to weigh,

1:09:56 For the organization and capacity, I think. But I think we have to have, you know, all these options on the table and give them, I love having all the eyes around the table to think about it and minds around the table to think about it and eyes to look at it because I think that's where we come up with some really good creative solutions. So I wouldn't throw it off by any means. Worth exploring.

1:10:30 I agree. I think it's definitely worth exploring. Thanks. Great. So the next bullet point on there is a consideration of whether a remote worker, so this would be someone who lives here in the region but is not working for a local business, whether there's a desire to open up any of the workforce housing programs to remote workers. And this really came up as

1:10:59 A discussion about how much subsidy is needed because we have households in queue who would purchase this unit but they need more subsidy. Well, the next person in the queue is a remote employee and they don't need as much subsidy but they can afford it. So do we want to increase the average amount of subsidy that we can use or potentially just not hold on to units but sell them to community members? So I have some thoughts on this.

1:11:32 And it gets a little bit tangential, but a long time ago we set up the Community and Economic Development Department with the Community and Economic Development Commission. And certainly a lot of planning work is going on. You guys doing a lot of work in that area. But the economic development piece of that really kind of fallen by the wayside. And I think that before we start getting into these discussions about remote work, which gets down a very significant and important economic development route,

1:12:00 I think we need to start really thinking about that. Anecdotally, in my experience, when I'm out in the woods doing the things that I do, the only people I'm running out to, I'm not running into ski bums anymore, I'm running into people who have jobs, five, six-figure gigs working with tech companies in the Bay Area.

1:12:17 They are here for the lifestyle. They love doing it. But there's a lot of stuff to be talked about with remote work. And we do have this very significant with $40 million broadband project coming up here. We're going to be fully gig wired. The air service is working. It's stable. We've got a foundation for that. So there's a lot of ingredients that go into that. And I would really like to get some policy.

1:12:41 Thinking about what that looks like and what that means before we start subsidizing remote workers. Not saying we shouldn't, but, and I think I've heard from a lot of people as well that those folks, whatever the ski bump culture has turned into, they're looking at the parcel, they're looking at our housing program, how can I game it?

1:12:59 You know, how can I get in there? How can I kind of sneak my way in there, do all the things I love to do? And they're not contributing to the community. So I think it's a topic that needs to be explored, but we've got some exploration to do. And it's a good thing to look at down the road. For me right now, the utmost importance is what does my current community need, not how do I create economic development. For me, economic development right now is finding workers.

1:13:26 So that our restaurants can be open as much as they would like to be. Not inviting other workers into town who don't fill those needs. So look at it down the road. Absolutely. When we have, you know, 500 units on the parcel and we have other housing projects going in. But I think the town's need currently is for employees to fill the positions that the businesses currently cannot fill. And for that, we need to look at people who hold regular,

1:13:56 I would also just add a discussion in regards to the home ownership side and affordability and maybe the need to think about whether you guys would raise your average subsidy just given current market conditions and whether you want to keep this particular bridge program moving forward, right? But that's a different discussion than remote work, right? Correct. Correct. I'm sorry.

1:14:21 Now I'm going tangential. I get that, but I think what I'm hearing with Bill. Yeah, yeah, no, I agree 100% Bill. But yeah, serving the members of our community who are living and working here, I think is probably priority number one. But recognizing the interest rates going from where they were where the program started were still probably 4% or less, 3% range, and now they're 7%, right? And values have only continued to rise. They haven't recessed at all.

1:14:50 All those things just obviously create affordability. Even the gap just continues to grow. So the subsidy would need to grow, right? There's no strong indication that interest rates are going to drop dramatically this year. And so I don't see the parameters or the metrics of that being very different by the end of this year. So I don't know. I mean, I think you've got to play the law averages.

1:15:17 You know, we did well early in the program and it was some really good moves you guys made on that and good work for sure. But by the same token, if you can get a home into a local's hands, even with a $250,000 subsidy, that's still a lot cheaper than building new. So, I mean, that's one of the great things about that program because the cost of new construction is enormous these days. And I'll agree with you, except for on building new,

1:15:47 Chances are, if we build it as the Joaquin Project is being built, the homeowner fees, which you talked about earlier, are not going to be as extreme. So in some cases, building new, we're going to subsidize to the same level versus buying existing stock, because the existing stock, you know, the HOA fees have gone way beyond anything that inflation dreamed of to make a... Certainly, absolutely. And then if they have, if the reserves are up to snuff, which...

1:16:17 Hopefully a lot of, a lot of police are getting, you know, pressure from the state, obviously, to have all those things in better shape than they used to be in the past, but those are all considerations. And then, you know, the, I mean, some of the other older condo units obviously have, are as efficient on utilities and so forth as well. So there's all things that have to be factored in. And I think, as Patricia pointed out, with, with, you know, the ones, the units that we have been able to accommodate, I mean, you're basically creating a custom solution for every client.

1:16:42 So it's not one shoe fits all. All of them have unique circumstances to deal with. And, you know, it takes a bit of time and it's challenging. So I really commend Patricia's efforts and staff for getting through those things and getting people into homes. And, you know, like we always say, right, this initiative of affordable housing for the community is a long road to hoe. There's no silver bullet. And it's literally one unit at a time. But it's a battle we're fighting, I think, for sure. And just to weigh in on that.

1:17:12 The portion of remote workers that would be in alignment where the existing council members' comments already align on that, that we need to service what we have now in town first and then go from there. And I would just say with the question of potentially looking at increased subsidies, I think that's something that would be valuable to bring to us. We've all been kind of waiting and hoping for interest rates to come down and they're not. And in the meantime, people need roofs over their heads.

1:17:37 You know, we, we, this program started in a time of artificially low interest rates. We are lucky for a while. But I think we have to just face the fact that if we need to get roots over people's heads, we may need to look at options. I would just say, too, it seems to me that less and less people are able to remote work. I think that is shrinking as well. I mean, I agree. I don't think that's who the policy in the program was intended to serve. And so it would be.

1:18:07 That would be a big stretch, I would say, to start housing other people that are working for outside employers when, like Bill mentioned, you know, our small business owners, even the county can't seem to hire people to fill jobs. And people all want to work remotely. And we're like, no, we don't want any remote workers. We want you to come here.

1:18:31 How do we align, you know, and maybe that's part of the effort too is the additional subsidy but also the marketing of the program. How are we marketing to our HR departments around the counties, the region to say, oh, well, we do have units available too. If you recruit someone, make sure they're aware of the program. Okay, so I don't know if you need my opinion too, but I'm not.

1:19:01 I'm not in support of opening up the bridge program to remote workers. And I'm sorry, I thought we had moved on from that, so I was just talking about interest rates. I was specifically talking about the question of would we need to give bigger subsidies to our locals? So I just want to make sure that's clear, because I think people circled back to remote workers. I thought we had moved on. So it seems like you're unanimous on let's house the people that work here and are essential first, and then

1:19:30 But my comment was specifically about for those if we do need bigger subsidies. So I don't know if anyone else wants to weigh in on that. Otherwise, go ahead. Yeah, we can definitely bring an item back to council that really dives into the subsidies on a future meeting. I think that would be a good item. And so the last one, too, on here, at least, the direct sale to clients. When we established the bridge program, it is at a time when interest rates.

1:19:58 Interest rates were very low, and also cash buyers were very prevalent, and so we stood it up with the kind of in the way where the town or ESCH would acquire the units, then we would work to find a household to sell that unit to. That's primarily so that we could compete directly with the cash buyers. Units were

1:20:22 Coming on the market and would only be on the market for a day or two before they'd be put under contract. So there was a need to act very quickly to put an offer on those units. We were going after them aggressively as all cash buyers with a short escrow so that we would hopefully beat out a potential investment buyer on those units. As with interest rates climbing and other factors,

1:20:47 The market has seemed to slow a little. Units are still selling, but they're not selling as quickly. And so we had one client where they actually brought a unit to Patricia or to ESCH that they were interested in. They did qualify at the 150% AMI level. And we were able to work it out where we essentially bought the deed restriction through the sale of the property.

1:21:15 The sale of the property went directly from the previous owner to the new owner without the town or ESCH being kind of the middle owner. The benefit to that is we don't have the carrying cost during that interim period for the unit of HOA fees and other factors. We also only have one closing cost then. So it did work out very well in that case and we think it's a good model or at least going forward having the option to kind of

1:21:43 Have both options out there. One being we could a client or we could identify a unit and match it with a client as someone who might be interested. And if we think that a unit is at risk of being snatched up by somebody else that we really want, having the option to buy it ourselves and then resell it. Is there a reason why you're concerned about that? It's not really a concern. It's really just looking for feedback, whether the council and the board is

1:22:12 Good with that direction. Like I said, when we stood it up, the idea was that we would purchase the unit, be the kind of interim owner, or ESDH would be the interim owner to then resell it. That was the bridge. Right, but there's no additional liability or other obligations that we would be incurring. In fact, it would be less than what we currently have now. Yeah, it would be less liability, less cost, because there's not the interim carrying cost. With us buying that deed restriction,

1:22:41 The assessed sales price is at the reduced price per the deed restrictions. So they're not paying higher property taxes. They're paying at that kind of affordable indexed price. So really, I don't see any negatives to that approach. I think it sounds wonderful. And I also think that, you know, how you were saying, Patricia, you have a list of people who are interested, but finding the right...

1:23:06 Unit for the right house. You know, if someone's able to bring a unit forward that they are interested in purchasing and need assistance from the town to purchase it, I think that this is a creative solution to get more people into housing. That is one of the benefits. The other ones, we're searching for both the opportunity to acquire something and who will buy it from us. In this particular case, they're doing that legwork and having the fit.

1:23:34 And bringing it forward. It's just a little bit different than we had originally designed the program, but I think ultimately very successful. I think the main thing is it's always in the details, right? And so the closer you get to each different scenario, the more creative you're getting in your solutions, and I really appreciate that. And then the last bullet point on here is what we've seen is

1:24:04 Come up as an option for an equity share to remove the deed restriction. And so what we in this scenario would be some where if during a specified period of time they wanted to refinance that their purchase and were able to pull out money to buy out the deed restriction, whether that's a benefit.

1:24:33 You know, I think from one perspective we looked at is the goal just to increase the deed restriction portfolio in the community or is the goal to increase kind of a stepping stone ownership opportunities for the local workforce and creating opportunities for them to either move out of their unit because they've realized an increase in equity or kind of grow in their unit. And so in this model, that equity share repayment would be the initial

1:25:02 I'm just knee jerk. I haven't thought about this before, but my knee jerk here is.

1:25:32 We need, moving forward, always affordable housing. We remove the deed restriction. We remove that unit from affordable housing. Our ability to build our way out of this is already extremely limited because of the land mass area and everything else, unless all of a sudden the federal government wants to.

1:25:50 You know, give us a whole lot of land to use for this. They might. And they might. We don't know that. Give or sell. But my knee jerk is it makes no sense. We need those deed restrictions in place in the long term to maintain affordability for our workforce. Our workforce is going to continue to grow. The number of housing units available to them is going to pretty much stay static. I'm with Bill on that one. Yeah. I agree 100% as well. I think it...

1:26:17 It just sort of sounds like it maybe makes it a good sweetheart deal for the original buyer, but at the end of the day, we're losing a unit in the perpetuity. And, you know, I think part of the goal, ideally, is if people can mature out of the program and be able to go buy market rate, right? I've known a number of people have done that. And, you know, maybe not the circumstances at the moment, but the economy goes up and down and things change and whatever. But, you know, I think ultimately that would be, you know, it's your foot in the door.

1:26:45 Start building some equity just through making your mortgage payments and maybe your employment circumstances change and then you're eventually able to go into the regular market and buy a home. So I agree 100%. I think we should always try to preserve and maintain our deed restricted units. And I know that's one of the reasons we have the other program, the revolving loan plan, to make sure we...

1:27:09 I think we were trying to figure out essentially there could be multiple goals, right? That building that inventory of affordable housing units that can be transferred to other homes is one. We also had a goal of having home ownership by people who are working in the community, right? So if we're promoting that home ownership, even in this process where we're maybe providing funds for a short period of time but then pulling them back.

1:27:34 And re-employing them through the programs, that might have a similar effect, you know, increasing the number of homes owned by the community workforce. So that's why it was kind of an interesting question we had to ask. Yeah. Go ahead. Okay. The one thing that I would say is I would not do that with anything that we had built.

1:27:57 But for the bridge program where we take existing units, it's a way to get cash back into the program so it's not held up and then more people. So I do think there's, to me I'd explore it. I think there's a time value of money that you have to consider. And while you get the money now, or you get the money, you spend the money now, you get it later and it doesn't go as far because...

1:28:23 I think it's a challenge in that regard. One of the things maybe to consider is looking at the Vale Indeed program or other programs like that that don't have an income restriction.

1:28:41 But it's a program that's more based on you must live and work. I think Telluride has a program too. Maybe there's programs like that that can work that don't have such heavy-handed...

1:28:54 I mean, I think, I think this interesting, this, this option.

1:29:20 Is worth thinking about and exploring because I know you're saying, oh, well, the price, you won't be able to buy as much for it and, you know, if it's 10 years down the road, but if you're getting an equity share along with your investment, then I would be interested to see, you know, if that would pencil out to then being able to purchase another unit because I know, like, I purchased a condo in 2009 and I looked into MLH and, you know, it was kind of like, well,

1:29:47 You want to be able to grow your equity like that. That's how Americans pass down wealth, and that's how most Americans, their wealth is tied up in the equity of their house. And so, you know, I think looking into this option, you know, you might secure housing for a local employee for 10 years, and then if they want to buy out the deed restriction, that doesn't mean that they're leaving town and maybe you're able to turn around and get another unit. So maybe you've put two locals.

1:30:15 Yeah, but it also opens up the flipping market. Well, maybe you could put in restrictions saying that it can't be sold and used as a short-term rental, or, you know, like, maybe you could...

1:30:30 Maybe we could make it work for us. I really think the veil indeed might be a good solution. I mean, something, some kind of model like that. I think they're having great success with it. And I think it allows a little more equity, but it keeps it local. And I think that's what, I think what I'm hearing. We don't want it to, for an equity windfall, okay, well equity, if you get the equity, that's fine. But if you're selling it to a second homeowner, that doesn't really help us out. That really wasn't the intention. That's what I think I'm hearing.

1:30:58 Yeah, my understanding on the Vail, indeed, we had talked with the, he's now actually the housing director for Vail, previously was the housing director for Summit County, which includes Breckenridge, and they had a similar program. It essentially buys the value of the property down in exchange for a restriction that, yeah, it's going to be a local worker in the community and it's their primary residence, there's no AMI cap on it.

1:31:24 It does require the future sale of it to go to, again, a local working household. They found just having that restriction on there reduced the value by approximately, I want to say it was about like 12 or 13 percent, not having it just be on open market that could go to everyone. So it did effectively bring down that value to kind of be affordable for a local workforce without putting a...

1:31:53 A hard cap on the AMI or the price. Again, it's tied a little bit more to the market and then what that, you know, what a local worker could afford. So it does in theory kind of keep those prices to a cap. One thing to be really helpful, I know this question came up on the parcel, are we selling or subsidizing people in the parcel who don't work here? I mean, I think the definition of what a local is

1:32:21 It would go into a program like that. I think it'd be nice to bring that forward sooner than later because that is something that could maybe feed into these things. I don't know if we ever close the loop on that. For the parcel or for ownership one? So my understanding on the parcel, again, it kind of... You don't have to ask the question now. I'm just saying that we stumbled over that a couple months ago and I think it'd be a good thing to maybe bring something like that back. Sure. So I'm hearing on this one is...

1:32:51 Not so much in favor of just allowing for the restriction on bridge program units, but maybe researching more on whether a program similar to Vale and Deed or some other similar program that provides that ownership opportunities that's maybe not AMI restricted if that's something we might want to stand up as a separate program. Yeah, sir, just to weigh in because I haven't weighed in yet, I kind of concur with Bill's comments. We only have so much inventory. You know, I'd like to think that everybody's going to get ahead, but if we help somebody assist them with a unit,

1:33:23 They're able to grow that unit. I want to keep that unit for workforce housing right now, and I appreciate that they're growing the equity, but there's a reason we helped them get into the unit to begin with. That's part of the program. Great. Any other thoughts on ownership before we move on to the contract slide? Hearing none. So this is really just an introduction to the upcoming contract discussion.

1:33:55 The contract between the town and ESCH is up for renewal this coming June, I believe on July 1 or June 30th, the current contract will expire. Some of the issues that have come up at some of the ESCH meetings is the role of the Brown Act and how that impacts their ability or kind of how they operate.

1:34:23 And so there's been some discussions of whether to change the contract or change the kind of formation or relationship between the town and ESCH so that ESCH could operate outside the Brown Act. It would obviously change various factors such as how the town council appoints members to their board, what their meeting requirements are, what their transparency requirements are. Can I just ask a question?

1:34:53 Because this has been a topic that's been around for a couple of years now. Has the board, have you guys weighed in? I mean, do you like, not want to be a brown act? Is it too much of a burden? Well, I think that there's both, that we're 50-50, and I think the conversation just is ongoing. Last time I checked in with the board, it was a half and half. One, you know, one half believes that we could be more nimble without and save staff time.

1:35:22 And the other half thinks it's important and obviously cares a lot about transparency, which we all do, and thinks the Brown Act should stay. So I think that's why we put it on here as a renewal conversation. Well, I get it, because that's an important issue. Because I'm also hearing things like the way that the meetings are being conducted, Brown Act compliance is getting it kind of a little bit goofy. And I think that may be just an indication of the culture of the organization, saying we don't want to be constrained by that anymore. We want...

1:35:51 You're doing great work. It's a regional organization. You're working in Bishop all over the place. I think it would be helpful to really, I don't think you can be 50-50 on this thing. I think you've got to say, look, we want to be Brown Act. We want to, for whatever reasons, the Brown Act is valuable. Or, you know, we want to be cut free. We've got new opportunities. We're doing different things. We don't need it anymore. I don't know if we can be 50-50. A little bit of it, John, was that, you know, we do have, we have one board member who resides in Bishop. We have another one that actually lives in Southern California.

1:36:19 Who's been a tremendous board member, a very knowledgeable, skilled individual. And, you know, complying with, you know, the noticing requirements and location and so forth. But, you know, the board members have expressed, like, I don't want to, like, publish my home address. So, you know, to your point, you know, we are, we are spreading wings a little bit in terms of regional. We've changed our name. We've got a project of Bishop now that we're going to get moving on.

1:36:46 So it's not just limited to Mammoth Lakes specifically. And, you know, we're representing, you know, in Yomono and Alpine counties, you know, and we'd love to have membership from all areas that we're serving. So it's just tough then to say, hey, drive to Mammoth, you know, from Lone Pine or whatever. I'm just making an example. But, you know, that's sort of the practical side of it, I suppose. You know, there's ways to overcome it. Like, hey, go to a public area that you can.

1:37:15 You know, coffee shop or whatever. I'm going to be at that address at this time, you know, to comply with the Brown Act. So, you know, we're, it's been, you know, challenging conversation and, you know, like Patricia says, I think we're a little bit split on it at the moment. Well, I think we just wanted to bring it to the council because it is a requirement of our contract that we're currently under that we are Brown Act and also

1:37:42 It's in our bylaws, so that's a separate issue that we would need to address. But as part of a contract discussion, we want to hear from the council if it's important and if we need to put it in the contract, then we don't need to worry about if we're going to do it or not. Well, I think, you know, I serve on the Eastern Sierra Continue of Care Board and the AMACA Board, and both of those have really good representation from...

1:38:07 I'll pine all the way down to Inyo, and they're not Brown Act bodies, and they have had other elected officials on their boards, but they're never appointed, right? That's the trick, if you will. It's not a trick, but that's the key is not to have it that the elected body is appointing the member to serve, but you have an open seat.

1:38:30 And you could limit so many government people or, you know, public service or low income, whatever, however you want to design your bylaws and, you know, each of those bodies has their own. But I think that it is, you know, as we think about the region and we are a region and we all intersect at some degree.

1:38:57 How do we make sure that this organization is representative of the region? And I think that only makes the organization better. It makes it better to serve everyone when we have more eyes and ears and lived experiences from the entire region participating.

1:39:20 Aren't coffee shops open at 6 p.m. in Bishop. I was just there Saturday, and there aren't any. So it's really hard to find a place to go because people don't want to post their home address, and I respect that. Yeah, and I would just say, look, we've all been really encouraged by the success and the growth that this organization is taking on, and the regional thing is really important.

1:39:47 And I would encourage the board, you can have your own discussions, but I would not let something like the Brown Act or an appointment from the town of Mammoth Lakes be something that's inhibiting or getting in the way of the growth of the things that you want to do. It's got to be something that's additive to it. So again, I don't expect you guys to come up with a decision this evening, but I think it's something that I think this council member would like to hear.

1:40:11 Yeah, I think, you know, I've been around for a long time and some of the other board members and I just, there was an impetus to this that started with the town and there was a reason and I just want to be sure that that's, is that an issue for, I'd like to hear from the council, is that an issue anymore? Do you need that mandated judiciary oversight? From my perspective, no, because I think the value, the services that you're providing.

1:40:37 As an organization would be easy to contract with. And I think we can do that without having to worry about the Brown Act and that connection to the town. This goes back to the foundation of MLH many, many, many, many, many, many years ago. Look at all the success that's happened. Look at the growth you're taking on. Look at where you're going. And let's look at some new ways of doing this. That's my two cents. And if I can interject, there are a few different ways that ESCH could not be subject to the Brown Act.

1:41:05 It could either be a council member is on the board but not appointed by the council, instead appointed by the rest of the ESCH board, that would do it, or have a town representative who's not a council member, the town could appoint somebody who's a staff member or a member of the community, that would do it, or you could have a council member appointed but no longer receiving funding, ESCH no longer receiving funding, that would do it as well, that's probably not viable for other reasons. So anyway, there are at least three different ways.

1:41:33 To get to that outcome. So we don't have to sever the relationship between the town and ESCH in order to give them more operating flexibility. I'd like to add a couple of things to it, though. The reason that that did come about initially, you know, it used to be Mammoth Lakes Housing, right? And they were funded by, I think, almost, I don't know, maybe even exclusively by the town at that point in time to provide their operating revenue and funds. And so there was a desire to have an input from our governing body.

1:42:03 And someone appointed to that. And I think that's the purpose. So at this point, and as we work through the negotiation aspects, I've asked Nolan to kind of understand just what contracts are existing with MLH, or I'm sorry, with Eastern Sierra Community Housing and other entities, both funding provided as well as expectations and tasks that are performed for those entities.

1:42:26 Because we still have, you know, the town funding $336,000, I think, a year for the operation. And so there's that equity of funding versus voice and say. And so I think that's still there to agree. I think what John said earlier was very good, but had some clear points to it is if you get to a contract basis, then it's not, you know, you're performing for services and you're getting compensated for those activities.

1:42:54 More so than you are sort of having blanket funding that are standing things up. So I think, you know, from our perspective, it comes down to how much funds are contributed and how much say is in that. So if there's a change in that process, I think that would probably easily free up a need to have that representation and simply we could do it a little bit differently. So I think there's a lot to be worked through as we go.

1:43:18 On this contract negotiation and just really trying to figure out what you need as an organization and what we can supply as a town. So on a contract basis, that would be changing the way we've currently done business. I don't have any real issue with that. If you want to be a regional player and the town has certain needs, then we would contract with you to fulfill those needs if you're the least expensive alternative to fulfill those needs. Because the first thing I got to do is

1:43:50 Watch the purse strings for the people of the town of Mammoth Lake. So I have no problem with the concept coming forward, but I would need to see what that contract would look like, what the rates would look like. Then do we need to, if we're not going to have direct representation in that fashion, do we need to go out to an RFP to other people that do the same things and see what that all looks like as it fits into our budget?

1:44:17 Eastern Sierra Community Housing is going to become more of a regional player, then they're just, you can probably hear the confusion in my voice. There's a whole lot of things that we have to look at there. And how do we best spend those tax dollars? I would just suggest that Eastern Sierra Community Housing already is a regional player. It's not whether they, you know, that's where we're all at. And we have a contract. What's that? We have a contract.

1:44:47 Yeah, but does that contract change if we change from being a Brown Act and having a council member appointed to the board? Yeah, I mean, to your point, Bill, I mean, call a spade a spade, I mean, you're paying for services, right? Correct. And I think there's a pretty clear explanation of those services in the contract, so we're definitely going to work towards showing that, you know, what's being asked of us and the staff at time it takes and try to put a value to that so that it's clear.

1:45:17 What you're getting there. So, yeah, I mean, I think, you know, it's good to hear that you guys are potentially open to that idea. You know, it's, like I said, we would have to go back and amend our bylaws because it was written in there that there would be a member of council, a member of the county supervisors on our board, which it is, has been ever since the beginning, which is great. And it's actually nice to have that. I think we like having that. If it's just the, you know, to Andy's point of, well, we could say, hey, well, let's let up amend our...

1:45:46 Well, on our board, we'd love to have a man on our board. I mean, we would continue to do that, but so, yeah, it's a bit to think about, you know, we don't have, like I say, we're not going to answer the question today, but we certainly understand the need to be transparent about what it is you're paying for and what that cost is. Because the other option is you just in-house it and you hire staff and do that, if they can find housing. Well, and to weigh in on it, too, there's a couple different things here. One is, under the current structure,

1:46:14 Last I checked, workforce housing is the number one issue we have in this community. And to say we don't have representation from a town or a board there makes me very concerned from that standpoint. If it changes structure, that goes to a different thing. But right now, this is the number one issue. We sit here as a council and represent many different organizations and on several subcommittees, et cetera. If you can tell me any of those are more important than workforce housing right now, I would beg to differ. But at the same time...

1:46:42 Let me finish this portion. But at the same time, if it's a contractual relationship that changes how we fund or do something different, that changes the whole paradigm. Well, I think at the end of the day, it's what is the most effective way to be delivering services and achieve the goals we're trying to achieve? And a lot has changed since MLH was established, and there's a lot of... I don't disagree, but at the same time, I would like to know what's going on with housing, and I don't want to be meetings that I find out four months later that they've decided to do something at this point in time, the way the structure is.

1:47:12 That we don't know because they find the Brown Act to be challenging. We all deal with certain things. I think the Brown Act was put for a reason and that's a legitimate reason so we as a community can see what's happening is my portion. Now, if it changes organization and we hire them as a contractor and go to what other council members are saying that, hey, maybe we can hire for different services, it's RFP, I'm not against that either. I'm saying as a structure, if we're funding the way we are.

1:47:39 I would not be in favor of changing representation. All right. Well, I don't think we have to decide tonight, so I would love to move on. We have a couple more bullets, I think, and then... Yeah, so the rest of this is really just highlighting the current services and the contract. The contract discussion, I know ESCH has appointed a negotiating committee of their board to really discuss...

1:48:06 What they're desiring in the contract renewal. For our side, we'll likely bring an item to a future council meeting to discuss with the council how they want us to proceed in that negotiation, whether they want it to be kind of comprised of Rob and I or whether we want to appoint council members or kind of set up an ad hoc committee to then engage with the ESCH board. So we'll bring that forward at a future council meeting to discuss.

1:48:34 Regardless, if it's just Nolan and I, we would be engaged with you all on your intentions and desires for the contract. Okay. All right. So then what? The conclusion of what we had intended for the discussion, if there's any additional comments or questions, if not, we can wrap up. Just to be clear, as the president of the board, we have every intention to be an integral partner of the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's long into the future. So it's our mission.

1:49:05 It's in our bylaws and we're going to continue to work closely with everybody on council and town staff and continue our great relationship and help bring more units to fruition. We have 39 units getting delivered this year. Not through our combined efforts, but a lot of heavy lifting by Patricia, getting a lot of work with the state and getting those grants secured along with Nolan. We wouldn't do it alone either.

1:49:34 But, you know, there's some great progress being made and there's some good relationships, you know, at all levels, including the state, that I think, you know, we certainly want to continue to bring to the table for everybody's benefit. Thank you. Before we end the workshop, do we need to take public comment? So would now be the time. Does anybody in the room want to make any comment on the workshop or what we discussed? Or anybody online, Jamie? All right.

1:50:04 Terrific. Well, thank you so much. I think there is a lot to celebrate and we look forward to continued work together. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for coming. Thank you. I'm sorry I was late. Oh, no, no problem. I think we'll take five minutes before we go on to our next agenda item. Well, I didn't have my massager. I was very heartbroken. I have an incredible on-fire right shoulder. Let us begin.

1:57:24 Thank you all for taking your seats. Our next item. Where is our clerk? We need our Jamie. I was starting without Jamie. I can't do that. Where is... We need her. She's essential. Especially because I don't know if we're turned off. Okay. Who's keeping Jamie? Give her back to us. I just like beating on the gavel.

1:58:12 John, you need to silence your devices, man. It's late. Hello. Oh, we didn't want to. We didn't want to start without you. All right, so item 6.1, we are pleased to welcome President Tom Parker, the CEO of Mammoth Hospital.

1:58:47 to give us a presentation about the North Wing Project. Thank you very much for your time today. It's a pleasure for me to talk about the hospital in any context, but certainly this has been one that we've been looking forward to. I'm going to run through some slides to just orient everybody to the project, and that's really my purpose here today, to educate the community.

1:59:13 And we're on a, I say we because Caroline has been wonderful in setting these up for us. We are presenting to a number of organizations over the next couple of months to orient our community to this project. What I'm going to do is I'm going to talk a little bit about the history of the project and its purpose, hit on some milestones for the project, its design, and then I'll finish up with how are we going to pay for this.

1:59:42 Starting out with the history of the project. The hospital that now houses the inpatient unit and some of the clinical ancillary support services for our inpatients was built in 1978. By the time we are done with this project, we'll be close to, if not at, 50 years old for that original hospital building. If you click one more time, Caroline, there's some...

2:00:08 Yeah, there we go. There's the original hospital building. It has served us well, but as some of you do know, in 1994, SB 1953 was passed, which requires hospitals to meet new seismic code for both structural and non-structural.

2:00:30 And what we did is we took a look at what it would cost for us to retrofit the existing building, and our architects helped us to understand you'd be spending about 80% of new construction to retrofit what's eventually going to be a 50-year-old building by the time we're done with the new project. So we figured it was better to spend on new and give ourselves that next 50-plus years of life out of a new facility.

2:00:56 The deadline for that is January 1, 2030, so we're confident that we're going to be able to make that, but the clock is ticking, as it is for other hospitals in the state. Next slide. One more on our history. Well, I didn't mention that that.

2:01:16 Original hospital build had two ICU rooms and it had six double occupancy rooms and one single occupancy room. So while some people really get along with their roommates, not everybody these days love having a roommate when you're in the hospital. Next slide. We have been down this path a few times.

2:01:45 Trying to get a hospital replacement facility built. And we ran into some snags along the way. As most of you know, when you start a new project or you get excited about building something, there can be scope growth. And we saw that in a number of iterations on replacing the old hospital building. And with that scope growth came costs related to...

2:02:09 Doing more than we just needed to do in order to meet the seismic code. There were other projects that came along. A big one was the establishment of a totally integrated electronic medical record, taking all the disparate systems that we had throughout the hospital and bringing that under a single system. That consumed a lot of time, effort, and funds. And then our clinics really needed attention. Look at me. I'm in stereo now.

2:02:39 The clinics were busting at the seams and we're coming close to having finished up a number of projects that expand our capacity in our clinics. So for example, our family medicine clinic, we are moving from having 10 exam rooms to 18 exam rooms to keep up with the demand. So these projects have consumed our efforts and of course our capital.

2:03:05 We just didn't have the cash reserves at the time that we made our previous efforts. And now, and I'll show you in a subsequent slide here, we've been able to use that time to build reserves in order to pay for most of the project ourselves. Just a note, you can see in these pictures, the building is functional, but it is outdated. You can clean only so much, but things that wear out.

2:03:34 Don't look nice. And so it's not a great impression for our patients and their family members. It's worn out. It's dim. It's cramped. It's just really outdated. And then all those double occupancy rooms, we'd like to be able to have more single occupancy space for our patients. Next slide.

2:03:55 We have six principles that have been guiding us on the design of the project, and they're here. I'll go through each one. I won't read that list because I'm going to talk about each one individually. But we have been working with our design-build company to help them understand that this is what's important for us as we work on the design of the project. First is functionality.

2:04:16 We want to make sure that the creation of both private and semi-private rooms in North Wing provide patients, families, and staff with ample room during inpatient stays while offering the flexibility in some rooms to have patients, to have two patients during times of high occupancy. We call these super single rooms and we're building out

2:04:38 Some of the rooms to be able to house two beds if necessary down the road. Initially, when we build out the building, they will not have two beds in them. They will have one, but it is that future capacity building that we've had in mind. We'll be going from a total of 15 rooms that we operate today, both ICU and med-surg rooms, to 18. You may say, well, that's a modest.

2:05:03 Increase, and I won't go through the graph here, but we expect very modest growth in inpatient. Most of the growth that's going to happen for hospitals nationwide is going to be in outpatient services, and there's a lot of focus on serving our outpatient needs in this new facility. I'll talk about that in a second here. Right here.

2:05:23 Functionality also is the creation of the Outpatient Services Center. It provides expanded capacity for outpatient services that are expected to be the area for growth. The OSC will allow for centralization of dispersed services that occur in the hospital and in the clinics and pave the way for future expansion of our surgical services as we relocate what's called the post-anesthesia care unit. I grew up with it. That was called recovery.

2:05:51 But it's the PACU. Just a note here, this is the kind of growth we're seeing in outpatient services. Endoscopy procedure volume has grown from 197 cases in 2014 to 637 cases in 2024. This is a great example of what's happening on the outpatient side. What this all means is that we want to make sure that we are focused on the area where there's growth.

2:06:21 And where there's opportunity for consolidation. So we have some procedures happening in the PACU. We have some procedures happening in the clinics. And if we bring that all together into the new outpatient services center, we free up capacity in the clinics. We also free up capacity in the PACU, which really is the area that throttles our ability to grow surgical services. So it gets pretty crowded in the PACU on some days.

2:06:51 You guys just talked about this, so I'm not going to go into it, but there are a lot of projects online right now bringing more visitors and residents to this area. We want to make sure that the hospital is prepared for that and that we are growing our capacity to meet those future needs. Next slide. Affordability. The size and the scope of this project was really driven by two things. First is what we needed in order to move departments out of the old building.

2:07:20 That is no longer going to be seismic compliant as of 2030. And then the other is to create operational adjacencies for patient flow. So for example, if we're going to have the outpatient services center, what goes hand in hand with that? Well, we found that the PACU would go hand in hand with that. So we're actually relocating the PACU out of the building that we...

2:07:46 Build out in 2007. That's the building that houses the emergency department, surgical services, medical imaging, and the PACU is going to be moving over into the north wing. And flow is going to happen over sky bridges, and I'll talk about that in just a minute. But we found that those adjacencies was another goal that we wanted to fulfill without moving a whole lot out of the 2007 building. Next slide.

2:08:19 Durability, certainly meet the seismic code, but the other point is we wanted to make sure that this building handles winters. So we've had a lot of conversation with our design build company to make sure that they understand what it means to build in Mammoth versus other places where they have built them. They've got good experience building here in Mammoth. They've worked with the school on their project, so we're confident that that's going to happen. We learned some lessons from the 2007 building in terms of some of the

2:08:49 Next slide. Consistency. You see some pictures here. The first one in the upper left is an aerial view of the campus as it will exist.

2:09:07 That building to the far left is the north wing. That doesn't exist today. But we wanted to make sure that there's nice compatibility, and we've been working with Town on the exterior color, make sure it is complementary of what we have and fits with the palette, with Town's palette. That center picture is the lobby in the existing 2007 building, and you can...

2:09:30 Get a sense in that right-hand picture, which is mock-up for the north wing lobby, this consistency of the palette for the campus. We want to make sure it all flows really well. Next slide. Sustainability. We will use environmentally friendly materials. Our HVAC system lighting.

2:09:51 More windows, better insulation, all will help reduce our energy consumption. And then we'll be building in such a way that we're going to reduce and eliminate volatile organic compounds, red list chemicals. If you ask me to give you a quotation of what's on the list, I'd have to come back to you later. But we are going to be using materials that are friendly to the environment and we're going to be landscaping in such a way that we're going to have low use on water.

2:10:20 Aesthetics. I won't read that whole thing, but what I've told the design-build company is I want it to look nice, but no more than that. This is not about ego. This is not about building a monument to something other than our patients, making it functional for our patients, making it functional for our staff. That is the primary goal here. But we do want it to look nice, but only just nice enough.

2:10:48 That is an attractive environment for everybody who works there. A few milestones, and that is we did an RFQ, request for qualification for design build companies. They came back, we then qualified a handful of them that got RFPs. When we received the bids, we then took one company, and that's Clark Sullivan.

2:11:12 Through the process of validating that bid and we cut some of the costs down through design revisions and value engineering. At this time, and we have a contract now with the design build company for a guaranteed maximum price of $131 million on the project. That does not take into account $20 million that are non-guaranteed maximum price, non-GMP costs. Those are costs that we're incurring.

2:11:41 For example, we had to completely redo the South Parking Lot to expand its capacity because we're going to be taking up employee parking with the new project. That South Parking Lot project is part of the $20 million. Also, what's in that $20 million is fixtures, equipment, furnishings. That's going to be costs that we have that are not part of the GMP contract. Next slide.

2:12:10 Talk about how we're going to pay for this. This is just to give you perspective of where we have been over the last 10 years financially. And I'll just tell you, the FY25 year to date, that very last bullet point, that's only the first six months of the year. So year after year, we have had a positive net income. That has allowed us to grow our cash reserves, which has allowed us then to plan for a building that we can pay for mostly out of those reserves.

2:12:40 Next slide. Those consistent positive net income years, year over year, has resulted in us being able to grow our cash. And you can see that on this slide where our cash reserves are today. In that year 2020, we did receive some COVID funds. That was helpful. But most of this growth in cash has come out of our own operations and being able to have a positive net income.

2:13:09 With that cash reserve, next slide, we plan to pay for 67% of the project out of our own cash reserves. That will not take our cash reserves down to a level that would be concerning to our bond raters. We have S&P A- rating, and we expect to be able to, at the lowest point, be somewhere between 150 and 180 days cash on hand.

2:13:36 Even while we're paying for two-thirds of the project out of our own reserves. The other third of the project will be done on borrowing. That'll either be a tax-exempt revenue bond or that will be a USDA-funded bond. And we're working on both of those options simultaneously. That is an overview of the project. And I know I've taken up a bit of time here.

2:14:03 I'm passionate about this and wanted you to see what we're working on. I'm happy to take any questions. Absolutely. Thank you so much. We're all passionate about it, too, obviously. We all treasure our hospital and your staff. Anybody have questions? I've got just a couple quick questions. Tom, with the change in the facility, how many new staff will you be adding to the complex? Yeah, because this is a replacement facility, not a new facility,

2:14:31 We don't plan to be adding much on staff. We have one position on the second floor of the North Wing that's pretty much a guide for navigation, so we'll be adding a staff person there. Can I do a shameless plug for the hospital? Sure. They need a one-bedroom rental for four months for physicians coming to town. It was just sent out to the Lodging Association, so if anybody knows of anybody that can have a four-month rental, they could really use somebody. Thank you very much.

2:15:02 Awesome. I just have a couple quick questions. So, you know, your financials are super admirable and we're very fortunate. My question is, what percent of the revenue of the hospital is from Medi-Cal specifically because I do have some concerns about what's going to happen with that program? As do we. Percentage of Medi-Cal is about 7%, 8%. Okay, it's small.

2:15:31 And yes, that is a concern because there are federal dollars that come into the state for Medi-Cal and there are programs we call the supplemental programs where we draw down federal dollars for the Medi-Cal patients that we and many other hospitals in the state. We are working with, we have a membership organization called the District Hospital Leadership.

2:16:01 We're very fortunate we have what we call a very

2:16:30 Favorable payer mix, meaning we have a large number of commercial covered patients. But not all hospitals have that. There are other hospitals whose Medi-Cal percent of revenue is much higher than ours. I was surprised to hear yours because I've heard 40% as an average. No, no. No, no, but just as an average. Absolutely. So there are hospitals in the state that

2:16:58 It would become a viability issue for them if they lost the federal funding. Well, thank you. I'm going to sleep much better at night with that information. And then the only... I'll just say, it's not that we wouldn't take a hit. We'd take a hit, and our CFO and I have been having multiple conversations, and we have been modeling what it would do should we lose that funding. But it wouldn't put us in a situation where we wouldn't be viable. We just have to probably make some changes, potentially, in scope of services.

2:17:26 Well, as you're talking to legislators, if you need help from us, we will be happy to advocate on our community's behalf because, you know, in remote communities like this, they really need to understand what those impacts are. We don't have anywhere else to go, so we do have to be supportive. The other question I have is, I noticed in the PACU there's, you know, a certain number of beds, and I'm just thinking about the fact that, and I talk to our PD about this quite often as well,

2:17:55 We are a town of 7,500 plus or minus, but we are also a town of 40,000 at times. And so does that allow for flexibility for things that are... For a mass casualty event? Yes. Thank you. I said the genius of the 2007 building was the building out of the overflow bays in the emergency department. During shoulder season, a lot of times those bays sit quiet.

2:18:25 But there are other times when everyone is full, and having that flexibility right in the emergency department has been wonderful. But if we had to overflow the emergency department, as we did during COVID planning, we know where the patients could go. Even today, using every nook and cranny, we know that we could house a lot more patients than we have license for, and we enjoyed some state

2:18:55 I'm blanking on the word, but where they allowed us to have more than our license for a period of time. And we went through that exercise. We know where we'd put them if we had to. Thank you so much. Are there any questions? What's that? Yes. Are there any questions from anyone in the room or online? Well, thank you so much. We're very looking forward to see this progress.

2:19:24 May is our plan groundbreaking. All right. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Next, we have the 2024 annual report from Mammoth Disposal. So welcome. Good evening, board, and hello, everyone. My name is Cassidy, and I'm the sustainability coordinator at Mammoth Disposal. Today, I will be sharing our annual review.

2:19:58 Just going to wait for it to get up on the board here so you guys can see it. You can go to the next slide. All right, so first off, I'll start with some quick introductions. In 2024, we welcomed some new employees. To list a few, we have Blake, who's our new customer service representative, Myra, who works at the transfer station, and myself.

2:20:36 We also had two leadership organizational changes with Maui going from just office manager to managing the transfer station and buyback center. We also have Javier who was promoted from a driver to an operations supervisor. In total, we have six recycle center employees, five transfer station staff, ten drivers, two mechanics,

2:21:02 Two customer service representatives, and six leadership positions. These people are the backbone of our operations, and none of this work would be possible without them. You can go to the next slide. All right, so jumping into some overall tonnages, Mammoth Disposal Company accepted an estimated 11,936 tons of material from the town of Mammoth Lakes.

2:21:29 Almost 950 mattresses through the Mattress Recycling Council of California. Most of those were actually accepted at no cost to the customer. We had two successful town cleanup and collection events where we accepted both green and e-waste. Most of the e-waste was sent up to Full Circle Compost in Carson City, Nevada, but we did keep some local as mandatory ground cover at the Pumice Valley Landfill.

2:21:59 All of the e-waste was sent to Cal Micro Recycling in Ontario, California. Our next cleanup event is being held in May, so stay tuned on more information about that and what's going to be accepted. You can go to the next slide. On a similar note, we have our diversion report, meaning everything we prevented from ending up in a landfill. Our overall diversion rate average is 14.89%.

2:22:27 We were happy to see that this amount increased from last year, and we hope this trend will continue into 2025. More specifically, this percentage includes the diversion of 671 tons of recyclable material, 184 tons of green waste, and 203 tons of metal that were processed at our facility. You can go to the next slide. Compared to 2023, the number of customer counts went up by about 100.

2:22:57 Our number of cardboard bins being serviced also went up, so here's a quick reminder to be separating that cardboard out. And we were also pleased to find that our customer complaints have gone down by 63%, with most being about bin repairs. We hope that these continue to decrease, but are committed to getting these types of calls resolved as quickly as possible. Next slide. Per our franchise contract,

2:23:27 New rates get established the first of every year, and this is based on the Consumer Price Index. These rates are set for the remainder of the year. We also have a fuel surcharge, which is determined separately from other rates and is based on the current fuel price index. As of February 1st, it went down to 4.35%.

2:23:50 The fuel surcharge gets readjusted every six months if needed and is used to help us account for shipping costs and all of these rates just kind of ensure that we are here and making vital operations happen. You can go to the next slide, please. This year, we purchased new equipment that allows us to operate more securely and efficiently. As you can see, this ranges from supplies for our transfer station to a new four-wheel drive truck

2:24:21 That will allow us to service the less accessible roads around town. You can go to the next slide. All right. Super quickly, if I could see a show of hands in the room, how many people here have seen, heard of, or attended one of our outreach presentations? Great. It's great to see that there's some familiarity in the room. And if you haven't engaged, I highly recommend. Our community outreach includes informal

2:24:51 Informational presentations and weekly social media posts on trash and recycling. Under SB 1383, we hold regular food waste prevention meetings and have garden programs with the Mammoth Unified School District. We also have some recycle right magnets, which I did bring. They're located on that back table over there if anybody is interested in grabbing one. Other notable events include Earth Day collaborations, Trashy Thursday collections,

2:25:20 And community cleanup days. Our next event is actually happening tomorrow at 9 a.m. for the Food Waste Prevention Recovery and Redistribution Task Force. If you want the Zoom link, you can find that on the Chamber of Commerce website, or you can let me know after this presentation, and I can definitely add you guys to the list. We would love to see board members or other community members show up to that. You can go to the next slide. Next, I'll go over some state mandates.

2:25:51 As a quick reminder, Mammoth Lakes has two exemptions, one for our rural population and one for our high elevation. The two mandates that this affects is SB 1383, known as California's short-lived climate reduction strategy, and AB 1826, mandatory commercial organics recycling, which both mandate food and green waste composting.

2:26:19 For the time being, it is not economically or operationally feasible to have a commercial composting facility in Mammoth for many different reasons. But we do have special diversion projects that we take on whenever possible. We are also still required to do outreach and education regarding organic waste prevention and best practices.

2:26:47 What affects the town of Mammoth Lakes is the AB 2902, which extends our rule exemption to 2037. It makes reassessment of this less frequent. We are not exempt from AB 341, which states any commercial or public entity that generates four or more cubic yards. So for reference, this is about 24 standard trash bags. They are required to subscribe

2:27:15 If your business has any questions on if it qualifies, we do offer free waste assessments to help determine the best course of action. Lastly, we have AB 939, known as the California Integrated Waste Management Act.

2:27:44 Operation, Inspections, and Sets Diversion Minimums. Next slide, please. On a more local laborator report, restaurants in the town of Mammoth Lakes are almost completely styrofoam-free. In November of this past year, we had 13 non-compliant businesses, but now all of them are working to use up their current stock and have purchased more eco-friendly alternatives.

2:28:14 Huge thanks to local restaurants because we didn't need to issue any fines for styrofoam use, which was a really big deal and we were happy that that didn't have to happen. Local restaurants have also been informed of AB 1276, which requires for them to only provide single-use foodware and condiments by customer request. Lastly, lodging establishments are aware of AB 1162.

2:28:45 Which bans all single-use hotel toiletries, regardless of the number of rooms they have. This also applies to private short-term rentals like Airbnb and VRBO. Next slide. Alright, so now we're going to be moving ahead into projects that we will be focusing on more within this next year. First off, we are revamping our household hazardous waste program.

2:29:11 We just got a new facility that is dedicated to storing household chemicals. We will be changing when we collect these materials so you guys can expect to hear more information on what qualifies as household hazardous waste, why we don't want it in the waste stream, and how to dispose of it properly. As previously mentioned,

2:29:37 We will also be working on our current process for tracking and enforcing AB 341, or mandatory commercial recycling. This will include meeting with businesses to help establish if they are required and what service option would be a good fit. We will also be reaching out to businesses who are documented as self-haul service to ensure that these drop-offs are actually happening. The goal of this is to get that diversion rate up even more.

2:30:11 We're implementing some new systems. Starting on March 1st, we have our new program coming in called Recycle Guard. Some changes customers will see is check redemption instead of cash, an improved ID verification process, and electronic signature capture. There are currently no changes to accepted materials for recycling or their redemption values. Our last software update.

2:30:43 There will be a new program called Third Eye, which was implemented back on January 1st. This system uses cameras on the force of the trucks to identify when a bin is overfilled. As the picture on the screen shows, it will take a picture and then alert us. Here, you will receive an educational phone call to better understand why we want to prevent this.

2:31:09 Repeat offenses will eventually lead to a charge, but that is dependent on the amount of times that it has been overfilled and how much that can is overflowing by. This program is part of our effort to reduce the amount of trash that falls out of the dumpsters and is blown around town. We appreciate all the efforts in helping to keep Mammoth Lakes litter-free whenever possible.

2:31:38 For continued updates, please follow us on our Facebook page. It's at me at its disposal. I also have my contact listed on that slide. Thank you so much for listening, and please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you so much, Cassidy. Any questions? Go ahead. Cassidy, this is a very...

2:32:06 Insightful and detailed presentation. Thank you very much. Can you talk to us a little bit about where Mono County fits into all this? Do you interface with Mono County? I know that waste is a countywide issue. Maybe you could fill us in on what that's looking like. Yeah, so our...

2:32:24 Our relationship with Mono County looks a little bit different than it does with the town of Mammoth Lakes in Inyo County. We do meet with them every single month to make sure that we are at least on the same page. When it comes to fitting in, it really depends on what type of material you're talking about. So if it's specifically trash or recycling or one of our other programs that we run, it kind of just depends on what context it's in.

2:32:53 Okay, is there anything that we need to know about what Mono County is up to? At the time being, no, but I will look into that and make sure that that is the correct answer and that there's nothing that you guys need to be aware of. So I'll follow up on that for sure. That'll be great. Thank you very much. Yes, of course. Just one quick question. In the past, some of the larger items were not accepted locally and the facilities changed. I'm not sure.

2:33:21 Even I know what you could take locally, whether it's a refrigerator, I know you've got the mattress program, or hot water heaters, those type of things. Is there a way that we can get an updated list of where we go to know what is accepted now and where to go and bring those others?

2:33:36 So our website is currently under some revisions and pretty soon here it will be updated with all of our new information. I don't have a current timeline on that but I will alert you as soon as that new website's up so that is one resource. The other thing you can do is always stop by our transfer station. I promise you those workers are very friendly and they will let you know what can and can't be.

2:34:01 And usually if it's something that can't be accepted here, we do have resources that you can reach out to and we can find a way to get rid of that properly. Our main priority is making sure that these items end up in responsible hands and not somewhere where they're not supposed to be. I just had a quick question. Are all residential units in the town of Mammoth Lakes required to have an account? Yes. So that is actually a town ordinance that they...

2:34:31 And my question, I'm so excited about the Third Eye tracking system. And so it's really a question for you as well as staff. It seems like there's a good plan now. We'll be able to identify when there's overflowing bins. And I don't know that you'll be able to answer this now, but I would love to see.

2:34:59 Much more specifics around how many repeat offenses and when that starts to become something where there is a consequence because that will help tremendously with our challenges with wildlife. Yeah, so that's one of the great things about this program is it's meant to track that sort of stuff.

2:35:19 So no super specific answer to your question right now, but I'm sure as we use this program more, we can kind of work out how we can use it to our advantage. Will they be able to also track the dumpsters that you see that aren't properly closed? Even though they might not be overflowing, you know they're not locked because you can tell when you're driving down the street. Yes and no.

2:35:48 Basically has an idea of what a closed dumpster looks like, and it will take a picture if there's something that's preventing it from closing all the way. So if an item is sticking up out of the container and making it so it's a less square shape, then yes, I don't think that it will necessarily pick up the carabiners, unfortunately. I wish that it would. That would be awesome. But I'll look into that and see if there's something we could do for that. Thank you so much.

2:36:18 Are there any comments, public comments on this item? And how about online, Jamie? I'd like to add some comments. Okay, great. So first off, I was going to thank Mammoth Disposal for their partnership that we bring to the town. There are two specific areas that we're working on right now. One of them is specific to wildlife.

2:36:46 And we meet monthly with them as well. And Pam is sort of our contact with that. And so we've been working for several months on a wildlife response process. And Mammoth Disposal is assisting in that.

2:36:59 We will be bringing before Council some Municipal Code updates on the March 5th meeting that are tied directly to the support received from Mammoth Disposal in that area. We will be looking to augment our ability to write fines and tickets for people who are not securing the dumpsters appropriately to protect our wildlife. But my point in making a comment at this time was

2:37:24 The fact that Mammoth Disposal is a willing participant in that process and has been very helpful. The second one is, as you know from the community coffee that we provided as an update for wildfire, the town along with the fire protection district and the water district and Whitebark are working on a

2:37:46 Town-wide program. We've actually now folded in Mammoth Disposal as their services are going to be instrumental in the success of that type of a program. And on our first call with them, they were absolutely ecstatic about being a part of that process and participating in that. So a lot to come on that. I'll provide you a little bit more of an update later on in Department Head updates with regard to the efforts there. But I just wanted to thank Mammoth Disposal for their continued partnership in this important effort.

2:38:16 And thank you to the town of Mammoth Lakes. We love working with you guys, and it's great, so thank you. Thank you. Any final questions or comments? Okay, terrific. Thank you. So when it comes to the wildlife thing and the dumpsters and locking and not locking, I have a dumpster at my residence. Most residents don't, but I do.

2:38:42 And I don't put a padlock on it. So when people go by with their doggy waste bags, they can put it in my dumpster. Or I would rather have an open dumpster than Coke cans and beer bottles strewn from the liquor store down to whatever residence they have. Have we looked into or is anything available in a can that would latch itself when closed? So the carabiner, people will open it. They'll put their trash in. But then they won't hook that back up under the new policies that everyone's pushing.

2:39:13 I get fined because I'm a nice guy and leave my dumpster available for people to put stuff in. So how do we fix that? Do I actually have to put a padlock on and let the litter increase on my street? Yeah, that seems to be like a big question. The best thing that we can kind of do right now is just outreach, saying, hey, make sure you're locking those dumpsters regardless of whose dumpster it is.

2:39:41 I will look into if there are any other self-locking mechanisms that we could be putting on our bins. I do know that our main company that we were using to get our bins did actually go out of business, so that made things a little bit more difficult, but I will look into that. Thank you. Let me help answer that question. This is our district. A little bit more. Yes, he has an answer.

2:40:15 Good job, Cassidy. That was her little premier go-around, so thank you very much for that. Absolutely. Thank you, Cassidy. Bins, the bare bins that are used, they currently only lock with the chain. If you went to a regular bin, which you don't have, then yes, you can get auto locks on those and you can put a padlock on it. We can just pick it up and we don't have to worry about getting out, having keys and doing those types of things. Currently with the bare saber bins, they don't make that.

2:40:44 So it's something that you see in the industry and they've worked on. They've come out. Last year they came out with some kind of preliminary looks at stuff like that. But the bear bin, the way the lid goes off, that's the easiest way to keep it closed so animals and obviously bears can't get into it. Thank you. All right. Thanks. Thank you so much. All right. So next we will move on to item 7.1.

2:41:15 This is a staff presentation on local impacts from federal actions. Yes, thank you, Mayor Boebser. This is my item, and I did plan on providing this as an update as a staff presentation simply to allow for council's dialogue in this area as well because this is obviously a pretty important discussion point that we have coming up, and this came about

2:41:42 Well, as we know with administrative changes that we've had within Washington, D.C. And we've talked to several times tonight about the impacts of federal funding, the impacts of federal staffing, and those types of things. And so the intent of this discussion tonight is really to talk about what the town is doing.

2:42:03 To monitor those activities and inform the community on different areas, as well as what we are doing to mitigate some of those impacts. And I'm not talking about, you know, the daily sort of information that's coming down, but more the true actual activities that occur that we can respond to and have a space where we need to lean in and provide services that may be lost.

2:42:31 That's the intent of this discussion here tonight. It's not going to be, you know, very, very comprehensive because things are changing on a daily basis, as you know, but I wanted to address two main areas, and that would be fiscal impacts and staffing. So first and foremost, fiscal impacts. We have dependency on the federal government funding. You guys have mentioned that a couple of times this evening.

2:42:57 30% of the state of California's budget is provided for by federal funding. And so a lot of those services are passed through to the town. Now when we look at the pass through to the town, not much of it comes to the town of Mammoth Lakes government, but it does come through services provided by the county. And I'm including those in this conversation today because essentially while those services

2:43:26 are not something we provide. They're services that affect the constituents in the community. So that's of importance. I myself have regular meetings with the CAO for both Mono and Inyo counties to understand those impacts and those efforts. They have lobbyists in Washington, D.C. that have been providing special reports on really trying to detail what those impacts are with facts and understanding, you know, what we can expect. So in the short term,

2:43:55 We talked about earlier tonight, in fact, allocations that are already submitted, right? The allocations exist, the grants have been funded and awarded. Those cannot be clawed back through the executive branch actions. Things that are in process or in application process or in development, those do have some vulnerabilities to what the federal government can do. So when you look at long-term funding,

2:44:21 And long-term impacts, there's some great concern there. There's an opportunity for those to be impacted. Right now, we're sort of watching. I've got the feelers out within those organizations and looking at those impacts. We don't have anything more to add on anything. In the short term, we're probably okay. In the long term, we still have to monitor and address those as they come about. With regard to staff, so that's...

2:44:51 The staff of the federal government is definitely under the executive branch and the ability for them to make adjustments is fairly easy for the president to make those changes. I would say that we have had some direct impacts locally. I'll go back prior to this administration change. The federal government had provided a notification that their seasonal temporary staff would not be funded this year if they were outside of.

2:45:19 The fire protection world. So we are heavily dependent on that, not just us, but even the national park systems. But our ranger district, our visitor center, those types of things, our ability to service through recreation technicians that take care of trash and other aspects around the town, which are a direct impact on our visitation, we're going to be impacted by that activity. And this is prior to the administration's, I'm going to say, very

2:45:47 I'm going to say blunt force reduction in force efforts that they're currently engaged in. I would like to think that there's some strategy involved in this, but I will tell you there does not seem to be any. It's just a numbers game and a reduction in that. And so the Indian National Forest has lost 10 staff members this week with regard to terminations that have occurred.

2:46:17 There are three within the Mammoth Ranger District. I am working directly with our federal partners on how that will impact the services and what we can do. I think that may slightly increase the requests that come to town council through our budget process to fill in the gaps.

2:46:39 If you will, with recreation technicians, as again, I talked earlier about the impact it can have on our visitation and our visitor's experience. We, through the prior administrations not funding a part-time staff, we, you know, we're probably going to have to find a way to fund a recreation technician level position that would be a town employee. This is going to be a part of the request of our initial budget processes with council.

2:47:07 In the month of March. And with these new loss of staff, likely would have to do two of those. But beyond that, there's not a lot of additional impacts at the moment, right? But this is changing fairly frequently. I am meeting with federal partners on a regular basis. I have had conversations with local ranger. They're not sharing a lot of information because there's a great deal of fear.

2:47:35 I'm going to say that out loud. There's people that are fearful of things. They're sharing what they can, but there's not a lot they can share. I have a meeting this coming Friday potentially with our acting forest supervisor as well as trying to understand those impacts and convey our support for this process. I mean, as you know, with our being completely surrounded by federal service, forest service,

2:48:01 And dependent upon their success of their organization. We've been fighting for years to get a pay equity adjustments for them, things that would provide, make that organization stronger. And so they were struggling to deliver services prior to these impacts, and we expect that they will then further be struggling with that. And a very great deal of uncertainty, a great deal of uncertainty about what can come next.

2:48:28 And so what I'd like to convey is we're working on it. We are communicating with folks. The letters that we are writing are essentially around focus. You know, we can't really say, hey, don't fire people in our area, but we can ask the questions and demand to know how they plan to deliver services. You know, they have the land. There are protections in place where we are unable to really do some certain things in the absence of their presence.

2:48:57 And so I want to know what are they doing to provide those services so that they do not impact our viability. I'm also working with Congressman Kiley's office. I had a call with them today. And I'm getting assistance from them. Primarily, the main focus right now is looking at they're sort of vetting out some of the things that are coming forward and making sure some things are out there that are conjecture.

2:49:24 We're trying to help understand which ones are real and which ones are still in process and not necessarily coming to fruition. So I think there's a long road. This will be a long road. I wanted to let the community know that the town is focused on that. We are getting inputs from various sources on just those impacts that are coming forward. And it is a collaborative effort to make sure that we're prepared and responding.

2:49:52 We can't control everything, but we can just have our eyes open and understand where we need to lean in on that. So I'm going to stop there. This came about it as a request from last council meeting to see, you know, do you guys want us to bring this forward on a regular basis? And so we will, as things come up for discussion, and be looking for if there's policy questions and issues for the council to address, those will be on the council, the next council meeting. So I'm happy to answer any questions or entertain.

2:50:21 Any comments? I think that others may have more to add. Thank you. Questions from the council? Madam Mayor, when it's appropriate, I've compiled some things that go a little bit beyond sort of addition to what Rob's talking about, kind of the larger threat environment. Rob, I think, has provided a very good, concise, sort of measured sense of where the town's at with that, but if there's an appropriate moment, I just got a couple things I'd like to share with my fellow members. Absolutely. I think maybe let's gather questions first and then... Yeah, I don't have any questions.

2:50:52 So, Rob, and I don't want to get too much in the weeds here, but you hit a very high overview in regards to county services that may be impacted. Is it possible for us in one of these follow-up meetings to get a better list of what that means? Because right now, what I'm hearing is the county may suffer some services, but not likely a lot. I don't know what that means. I don't know if we're talking mental health. I don't know if we're talking police officers. It's a very vague statement from that standpoint. Yeah, so, and really,

2:51:20 By design, because we're currently in the process of taking inventory, if you will, on those impacts, right? Really what is funded. When you look at the county, they do not only have funds that are from the federal government that provide funding directly out to constituents, but some of the positions that they have within the organization are funded by federal agencies. And so that impact can be great, but yes, we are doing an inventory of those vulnerabilities.

2:51:49 Associated with that, and that would be not just within our organization, but also with the county. That'll help us understand exactly what programs that are delivered to the community could be at risk. And then the second question, you know, when we look at the staffing levels, what's going on, do you have a range of dollars that we're talking about at this moment if we were to cover the positions that you think might be coming, needed to be backfilled, so to speak, at this moment, given what we know today?

2:52:19 I don't have that specific number. I would say it's somewhere between $70,000 and $100,000 per year. And I think that's probably on the high side because it's just an estimate at this point because these are, you know, temporary or seasonal positions. And with two seasonal positions, I think it's probably closer to the $70,000 range. But I have staff, I mean, Lawson.

2:52:43 Is definitely taking the lead on the work that's going on with this process because I, you know, we talk about capacities. We as a thin organization don't necessarily have capacities to dedicate either staff full-time to this effort or my own personal bandwidth to that. So Lawson's taking the lead on this with my help. And I just want to bring up one more question, even though you know I talked about it earlier, but there was rumor in regards to the visitor center being closed.

2:53:13 To your knowledge, at this point in time, Visitor Center is not going to be impacted at this moment? Well, so the Visitor Center definitely was going to be impacted from the efforts of no seasonal support, right? Because almost all of the staff is seasonal there. But a few local partners, we've been working on that solution since mid-November. I remember we had a meeting on November 19th that talked about these impacts and challenges with different partners.

2:53:42 And ECF, who's now Sierra Forever, has stepped up and is providing the funding to make sure that the Visitor Center is staffed. And so I want to appreciate partnerships that are recognizing the need for those things and leaning into that space. So the Visitor Center will be staffed and will be open. So, Rob, if I may, this is a huge topic. It's all winding its way through the courts. We don't know what the final...

2:54:11 Outcome of this is all going to be. However, the lack of Forest Service seasonal employees affects not only us but our partners at the county. I'm assuming then that we are going to have some collaboration with them and seek their help as our guests and theirs recreate often outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes but on federal properties. Yeah, I haven't had those conversations yet, Bill.

2:54:36 Honestly, with the county and what they may be able to provide in that space or willing to provide. What we've sort of determined from a number of different events is that the town often has to solve for the problem and be our own safety net. So we're working very hard in that space and I'll look for partnerships where we can find them. Well, Rob, as you know, that was less of a question and more of a shout out to the county as to what you're going to do. So there we have it.

2:55:05 Mayor Pro Tem Rice? I don't have any questions, but I just wanted to say thank you for, you know, looking into this and everything. And, you know, I think that for all of us up here, it's important that we, you know, protect our lands and that people can come and visit and not have, you know, things just not being taken care of. So thank you for preparing this. Okay. Councilman Burroughs, go ahead and.

2:55:37 You'll do your part. Then I will need to take public comment, but I want you to go ahead and share your... Okay, so just, I make an assumption when I serve on this council that we as council members understand that the economy of this town and this community is a recreation-based tourism economy. We could be an arts and culture-based tourism economy or a fishing-based tourism economy, but outdoor recreation is what we do. And I'm assuming there's consensus on that.

2:56:07 Okay. So that activity, that sector is a $650 billion sector of the U.S. economy. So just to put this in some kind of context, it's larger than farming, mining, and utilities. And this is based on the federal analysis that goes on at higher levels. And so this thing that's happening across the nation, it's coming right down to us. And it's going to affect us.

2:56:37 And just some things to keep in mind as we as we start thinking about what does this threat look like? Where is it coming from? It's not this is not a definitive it can report out, but these are the components of it. So massive staffing cuts, Rob mentioned 10% of the Forest Service workforce is gone. This happened over the holiday weekend, more to come 10% of an agency that was already stressed. Seasonal workers, we've talked about that.

2:57:04 Rob mentioned the anecdotal numbers of what's happening on the Inyo, but there's a project called Towns to Trails, as some of you may be aware of, funded by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. It's in its final stages of a feasibility analysis that's wrapping up. The District Ranger in Bridgeport.

2:57:21 With a final meeting, I'd love to meet with you guys. I lost five of my staff this morning. I can't talk to you anymore. So start thinking about green sticker funds. All those things that come to the state that the Forest Service manages, their capacity to deal with all that stuff is literally evaporating. Yosemite National Park lost 23 permanent positions that had already been hired.

2:57:44 From Washington, all that got canceled. All their seasonal staff was gone. Imagine what that's going to look like this summer with millions of people showing up with no capacity to deal with that. That affects us. That's part of our recreation product that we deal with. There are regional, I think there are nine regions of the Forest Service nationwide. Word is that about half of those regional foresters have quit. A lot of the senior management is quitting and leaving. Think of all the institutional knowledge that goes with that.

2:58:13 On the wildfire front, and this is interesting, Senator Padilla, our senator from California, is co-sponsoring legislation with two senators from Montana and also one, I think, from Colorado to move all of the money that's in the Forest Service budget, out of the Forest Service budget into potentially a new agency. Think of like a national cal fire thing. So imagine if that...

2:58:38 Moves out of the Forest Service. What's going to happen to recreation, resource management, all those other kinds of things? And this goes back, and Bill, you know this very well, this goes back to 100 years with the establishment of the Forest Service and folks who've wanted to get rid of it for a very long time. And along those lines, Senator Rosen from Nevada has already introduced legislation to start transferring land, federal public lands to communities.

2:59:04 You can, I don't, you can have an opinion one way or the other, but for things like housing, conservation work for tribal interests. So land transfers might be in the mix with this as well. And so that's, I just wanted to share briefly, I mean, this is kind of the larger context. I spend a fair amount of time in this world and use the kinds of things that are happening. And I think in terms of our engagement with, as a town, Sandy Hogan was here, you know, our last meeting, we need to write a letter.

2:59:31 And I think anything, I would hope we would be giving direction to Rob and the staff to be as active as possible to be engaging with our federal representatives because this is going to affect us. So thank you for your time. I just wanted to share some components of the larger context at least that I'm seeing. If I could add to that just a little bit. Sure. John brings up a great point. Is your microphone on? It is. Oh, good. The OHVMR, referred to as the Green Sticker Fund.

2:59:59 Funds a few hundred thousand dollars worth of things on the forest. We have already taken over one of those grants in the winter grooming grant. I would love to see, Rob, and I don't know if it's appropriate or not to have Lawson or somebody else look into the, because there's a summer OHV grant that does a lot more than just provide OHV recreation. It provides signage. It provides, it's a huge piece. And if they cannot staff it, it...

3:00:28 They can staff it because the money comes in for it. If they don't have the staff to manage who they could, then perhaps we need to look at taking over and maybe with Mono County in partnership or push it on to Mono County to take over some of those green sticker grant funded things.

3:00:48 And I think that's a great point that you're making, Bill. There's a lot of stuff that's in the hopper, that's in the pipeline, that's out there that we're going to have to, and I look forward to staff and the Office of Outdoor Recreation to be doing that kind of due diligence to start bringing these things forward because the visitation that comes to our town pays for this government, pays for this community, pays for housing, pays for all the things we want to do.

3:01:12 We can't let that get compromised. And can I add into one more thing there? As I'm understanding, Yosemite is right now planning not to take reservations. Yeah. The experience by people coming here could be not so great. And we could be impacted by that impact. Yeah, and also like in Tahoe, like no campgrounds are going to be open this summer. So you talk about visitation. I came out of two great days with Mammoth Lake Tourism, all the things that we're talking about.

3:01:40 They do great work. The product, the thing that they're encouraging people coming to do are the experiences that they have on public lands. And no campgrounds, no reservations, Yosemite's a disaster. You know, that's going to affect us. So just so I can clarify, you said in Tahoe there won't be any campgrounds open this summer. These are, there are campgrounds.

3:02:01 The campgrounds on the Forest Service are either managed by concessionaires, but some of them are managed by the Forest Service itself. So up in Tahoe, they have lost the entire staff that was managing the Forest Service campgrounds in Tahoe. But our campgrounds are concessionaires. Ours are concessionaires, as far as I know, but again, it's this kind of this due diligence. I would point out also that the state of Hawaii and the state of California are actively recruiting and hiring federal employees who've been let go. There's an enormous amount of institutional knowledge.

3:02:31 With those people being let go, and that's something that could be an opportunity for us to think about. And Mayor Pro Tem, Rice, you were about to ask, I didn't want to cut you off, but. I have the same question as you. Are the campgrounds in Mammoth going to be open or in fashion? The four services manages at least three campgrounds here that are not managed by concessionaires that I know of. And those are the simple fee dirt road campgrounds, upper and lower dead man. And I think the one up on the Glass Creek Road.

3:03:00 The group campground? It's an OHV campground. Glass Creek campground? It's escaping me at the moment, but I know there's at least three that they manage. I have not heard anything about whether they would be open or closed. Well, to me, it seems like as a town, we can't open up their campgrounds, but I don't know if we can empty the dumpsters or clean bathrooms or, you know, do things to mitigate problems. That's what those rec techs would do.

3:03:23 Honestly, that's the function that they perform. And, you know, Bill, to answer your question earlier, I'm laughing because that would be Lawson, and we literally had a conversation earlier today about those summer programs and how they tie into the winter program that we're doing. These are on the same surfaces, essentially, just, but literally had that conversation. I rise on this for sure, and we've got some resources that are capable of addressing that.

3:03:52 And just for, you know, as we're going through this, one of my goals as I look at it is we have to be prepared to provide more resources than we think we're going to provide. And I'm concerned that, and that's why I want to have this conversation to begin with, we may be talking about $100,000, but we may be talking half a million dollars. I'm just saying we don't know where some of this portion, and I'm not... I want to echo that because we don't know how far this is going to go. And so I think it's nice, okay, a couple of rectects, we can maybe talk about that now.

3:04:20 But there may be opportunities for us. What if there is federal land disposition for housing and things like that? There may be all kinds of opportunities in this, but I think you're right. We have to keep our eyes open and see what's happening. And where I was going with that was maybe there's a snow pit and something that comes down the road. Exactly right. I'm just saying we've got to be prepared to be able to act on that if it comes available. Exactly right. Okay, so a couple of things.

3:04:46 There are examples, and this isn't a question. Well, I'm turning it into a question. In the past, we know that there was a government shutdown in 2019, and we have some examples of kinds of things we faced then. And the other thing is that the INEO has had to close during Great Fire Danger. I think that was probably 2020 and 2021. So let's make sure we look at those prior situations to inform us for what may be coming.

3:05:15 Those are things we would know. Did you want to? Yeah, I just would like to address that. I mean, we had a number of programs that we're working on with the Forest Service. You talk about the snow pit. We also have a number of land acquisition elements that we've been working on for years, right? We have those things already identified and out there. And then with regard to Lawson, new to our team in the last three years, he has experienced directly what those impacts are when those closures occur.

3:05:44 And so I do want to appreciate the Forest Service for the work they do with us. And so I hope that the meeting I have scheduled for Friday afternoon would address some of those questions and concerns with regard to what that means and what we need to be prepared for. Thank you. Just one last thought. We have a town attorney. I don't know to what degree you are familiar with federal.

3:06:12 Yeah, I mean, I'm following along with what's happening, and the overall theme seems to be that

3:06:42 Everything's changing almost every day. And so it's hard to discern exactly what we should do. The NEPA thing that you mentioned is interesting because the statute would remain in effect. Right. Because that was enacted by Congress, but all the implementing regulations for the last 50 years could go away. And, you know, CEQA is a parallel. CEQA is the California version. And I'd say, you know, half of what CEQA is is really in the regulations, not in the statute. And it was kind of the same way. So it's a brave new world.

3:07:10 I think a lot of litigation is going to ensue over a lot of things that are happening, and we'll just have to see where we end up. But believe me, I am paying attention to everything from a legal standpoint and keeping in touch with my counterparts around the state. Thank you. Thank you. So is there any public comment on this item? Nobody in the room seems to be getting up, so how about online, Jamie? Yes. Janet, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi there, can you hear me? Yes.

3:07:43 Great. This is Janet Hatfield from the White Bark Institute. I just wanted to add, I think some of you are aware, but the federal, what's happening in the federal landscape is also going to likely significantly impact the vegetation management work that we had funded and planned for implementation this summer.

3:08:09 To what degree it is still unclear. So we'll be talking about that more in greater detail at a special small meeting that we've sort of designed to help with some of the financial challenges of implementing this type of work at this scale, but just wanted to flag that's also a massive issue that's being really drastically impacted.

3:08:36 By what's happening in Washington, D.C. right now. So thanks. Thank you. Anyone else, Jamie? No. All right. Well, thank you very much. It sounds like this will be a topic we'll be discussing at length in the future. Next, we have item eight, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. So I don't know if anyone know.

3:09:04 Everyone is refusing to get up because it's too much. Yeah, there we go. Hello. Good evening, Council. Pat Foster, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I got a few things for you, but I'll keep it brief. Historically, our regular meeting has been on the first Wednesday of the month. We're running into a number of scheduling conflicts, and at our meeting today, we passed a resolution to move our meeting to the third Wednesday of the month.

3:09:35 Hopefully that eliminates some conflicts and maybe that works better for the community. Hoping to pack the room at our next meeting. Kind of dovetailing on your strategic planning efforts, we had a strategic planning session with the board and the staff yesterday. We spent seven hours together. Between the board and the staff, our facilitator, maybe 16 or 17 of us in the room, Rob came by for a while. That was great to have him there.

3:10:05 I don't think Ted from the sheets here, but Ted came by, gave us some input. Really good process, really worthwhile. Kind of next steps on that is Matthew Landkammer, who is our facilitator, will take all of our data back, compile it. We have another scheduled three-hour session, at least with the staff, to kind of go through it again, take another bite at the apple, with the goal being to have a finished product in time for our March 19th.

3:10:35 If that all happens, we'd also like to come give you a brief presentation, and of course you guys will get the finished product as will the staff. And then the last item I have is in about two weeks we have the Visit California Outlook Forum. I joined the staff last year, learned a ton. It was an amazing experience. I had no plans of going again this year, but with the

3:11:04 What is the evolving landscape that we're seeing? I reached out to John and said, hey, listen, I'd really like to join. I would love to hear firsthand what the state of California's marketing arm sees coming down the pipe, how they plan to deal with that. Also, it's a great opportunity to interact with our California counterparts. One of the things that really struck me last year was how big the industry is.

3:11:29 But at the same time, what a tight-knit community it is. These are destinations and attractions that we're competing with aggressively. But everybody works very well together. They cooperate very well. And I think that's going to be important moving forward. Another thing to note is Visit California is not funded by the federal government. And I think that's going to be really important for us moving forward.

3:11:57 This is an organization that has $157 million annual budget. And so cultivating that relationship is going to be important. And I plan to come back on March 19th at the council meeting and give you an update on my experience. So that's all I've got. Thank you so much. Thank you.

3:12:22 Any other reports? I just was going to give one more of a discussion with regard to the wildfire efforts that the town is undertaking for the spring. As you know, we have a number of things that we do as a community, and the goal of this effort for the spring into this early summer of 25 is to engage the community directly in that. That was part of the community conversation.

3:12:49 That we went through. This is more a parcel level efforts. So I talked before about the participants, which is the Town of Mammoth Lakes, followed by the Fire Protection District, White Park Institute, Mammoth Water District, and Mammoth Disposal thus far. And we are meeting on a regular basis. Lawson is pulling us together on that, as well as we have a

3:13:13 Formation document for what we're trying to achieve and working in coordination with other efforts that are going on. So we've got, you know, meetings with, that White Bark is already doing in another, a number of other areas. We have one tomorrow, I think, with a RAF meeting. But we're really looking to engage with the community in this space, as I talked about in that community coffee, and provide them with really task-oriented efforts that they can do either at a neighborhood level, community level.

3:13:42 Things like that where they can do their part to support the sort of internal of the town parcel risks and concerns. There'll be some education components, but mainly it'll be built around providing specific tasks that they can engage with their neighbors to protect. So I'm excited about that. The goal is to kind of have something meaningful that we can put through the community and have that sort of culminate by

3:14:12 Late part of June, if you will. And we're not trying to sort of invent the wheel here. There's some people that have done this elsewhere and we're engaged directly with them through ALISH.

3:14:24 I think Marin County is one that has a really good program that's really more of a long-term aspirational aspect that is so strong. But also up in Tahoe, they have some really good efforts. So we've got a little small contingency that's probably going to take a field trip and talk to those people about those efforts. But just wanted to let the community know again that there'll be an opportunity for them to do their part. And we as a group of organizations is pulling that together so that they know.

3:14:52 How they can be of benefit. So that's my only update. Can I go quick, excuse me, but Council Member Wentworth beat me his hand was up first. Go ahead. Oh, just a note from the public. Apparently the lights on the entrance sign coming into town are not working. So just passing that on. This would be the colored Christmas lighty ones or the regular white ones? The big entrance sign when you come into town, the entrance sign, the lights aren't working. Stu's got it. Thank you. Okay.

3:15:23 And specific to your point about what we're going to be doing to do our own town hardening, if you will, will you be looking at implementing neighborhood by neighborhood firewise communities? Because I know that's been successful in some other areas as well. That could be a component of it. I mean, we haven't...

3:15:43 Specifically engage that entity, but we did have them at a few of the summertime events and were around talking and trying to create interest in that. I think there's value for sure, but we haven't discussed that thus far. Okay, thank you. So with that, we are on to item nine. Now I have to do some reading. This is the consent agenda.

3:16:12 Do I ask to pull matters first or do I read the consent agenda first? Okay, so item 9.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of February 5th, 2025. 9.2, adopt the resolution amending the guide to town council processes and procedures, changing the public comment time to three minutes. 9.3, waive the reading and adopt by title only ordinance authorizing the levy of special taxes in community facilities.

3:16:39 And 9.5, accept check...

3:17:02 So does anyone need to pull anything from the consent agenda? I would like to pull 9.2, thank you. All right. Anybody else? All right, then.

3:17:30 We shall, Jamie, could you call the roll on the... Somebody needs to make a motion and somebody needs a second. I would make a motion to approve 9.1, 9.3, 9.4, and 9.5. Thank you. I'll second. All right. Now, Jamie, can you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes, but I need to accuse myself of 9.3. Okay. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right.

3:18:00 So item 9.2, which is the resolution amending the guide to town council processes and procedures, changing the public comment time to three minutes. So I pulled this because the only feedback I've gotten from the public on this has all been incredibly negative. So we don't need to go into any great discussion. I just pulled it so I could vote no instead of yes with the rest of consent. All right. Are you making a motion?

3:18:30 I think, shouldn't we let other people have a chance to ask questions? Sure, of course. And take public comment? Yes. Questions? No questions. Okay, is there anyone in the room that wants to make a comment on this item? Anyone online? All right. Council Member Wentworth, did you have... No, I was going to, I was not going to pull the item, but I have had the same reaction from the public, and I...

3:19:03 Was ambivalent last week when we had this discussion, and I'm, Bill, if you would, I don't know what the motion would be, but I would incur. I think we'd have to discuss first, like, can't we all get our thoughts and deliberate? Absolutely, sure. I've thought about this more, and the thing that bothers me about the, you have five minutes to speak, but when there's a lot of people here, it's cut down to three minutes.

3:19:34 I guess, I'm sorry. I'm tired. I'm not speaking so eloquently. But what I'm trying to say is I think it's better to give everyone three minutes and to be graceful and to let people go over rather than you get five minutes, but when people are here, you get three. So I think that as a council, we need to either decide to be fair across the board and give everyone five minutes all the time, even when it's packed in here with 100 people.

3:20:03 You know, that we always give everyone five minutes or we give everyone three minutes and we're graceful when somebody goes over. Like, I just, I don't, I don't, I really dislike the, the room is full, we're cutting your time almost in half. Yeah, and I think just sticking with the five minutes is where I was going here. But, I mean, because I do feel like in the past when the room is full, people's time gets cut down to three minutes. And I know it's happened. We've only done that, I think, once.

3:20:32 Twice. But for the amount of times that we have those size crowds, I'm willing to put up with the extra time that it takes and honor their desire to speak. If everybody prepared in advance and had a written piece that they had rehearsed in front of their mirror and knew that they could do it in three minutes, that would be fine. But the majority of the folks who come up and talk aren't...

3:21:01 Big public speakers. They aren't going to create that list or whatever that they need to give their presentation and it just takes them longer. So just based on the feedback, I would keep it as it is. What are your thoughts, Chris? Does anyone else want to go first? Because I will. I only had one public comment. I spoke to that individual and then they understood. I think the challenge here is that

3:21:32 When there is something controversial and it takes many hours, we have our staff and our police chief and often our fire chief is here who are also held and, you know, I really have studied this issue around the rest of our state and we're one of the only municipalities that gives that much time. So I think that it's not about our

3:22:00 Not willing, not being willing to stay for as many hours as it is, but as a practical matter, like this is our community's meeting and we owe it to have some structure around it for everyone involved, not just the council and not just the speakers. I mean, if this weren't standard practice and we were being unreasonable, I think it would be different, but it's very standard.

3:22:30 From my standpoint, I just stand by where I made my argument for. I think it should be five minutes for everybody, and that's what we should keep it as. All right. Well, I guess someone will need to make a motion. Or not. It can just die for lack of motion, or someone needs to make a motion. No motion is required if there's no interest in moving ahead. If anybody is interested in adopting it, you can make a motion to that effect. I'd like to hear from you some more, John. No, I think, thank you.

3:23:06 I just feel in the times that we're in that I think it is in the interest of the council and the interest of the community to say you get five minutes. We want to hear from you. And I don't think it's a burden on the council. I don't think it's a burden on the community. But I think we need to be erring on the side of we want to hear it, bring it. It's important to hear it.

3:23:34 But I would like to say, too, is that this, during council meetings, is not the only opportunity for the public to talk to the council. You know, it's like all of our email addresses are posted, all of our phone numbers are posted, we are available to meet with the public and hear from them on a, you know, frequently. So it's not just you have three minutes to talk to all of us. People are welcome.

3:24:02 To engage with their local public elected officials. But to be clear, they only have one opportunity to speak to all of us at the same time. And if they speak to one of us individually, we are, I'm certainly cautioning them, careful of the serial meeting, don't tell me what anybody else is saying. But they're allowed to tell, I mean, someone meets with you because they have a concern. Sure. Not because they want your opinion. I mean, everybody loves your opinion, but they don't want your opinion. They're telling you.

3:24:29 They have a concern. And so for them, they are allowed to go and meet with you and tell you their concern and meet with me and tell me their concern and do it down the line. It's not very efficient, though. That's five different meetings. And they can come here and they can just talk to all of us. They can tell us what they want. They can share that concern once in front of all five of us. I mean, it's, I just think it's difficult for me to say less, less speech, less, less.

3:24:58 From the public. That's just me. But it does happen when the room is full of people. And it's happened. I mean, I feel like I've been on the council for two years, and I feel like, you know, it's happened every few months. My assumption, by not moving this forward, that the mayor, whoever's acting as the mayor of the meeting, still has that discretion. And if the mayor were to say, Chris, if we get a big pot...

3:25:22 Thing that comes in here and you want to say, you know what, I got 35 people in the room, I want to cut it to three minutes, I'm not going to have a problem with that. All right, we hear you. I just think that's the opposite of respect for the people who come here to give public comment, but we'll agree to disagree because you seem to feel differently, but I think what's published is what we owe to the community. So that was why we brought it forth in the first place.

3:25:55 And I do, I personally think that it's worse. You know, I feel like it's better to, you have three minutes and then someone goes over and you listen to them for five minutes. But it's worse to someone has taken the time and shown up here and they're ready to talk for five minutes and then you cut it down that night to three minutes. Like if it's just standard practice that it's three minutes and if someone hasn't gotten their point across and you give them grace and let them talk a little longer, what's the harm in that? But to me, the...

3:26:24 The optics of it's a full room and we're cutting your time in half look bad. But I think cutting the time down is optional. That doesn't have to happen. You have a full room of people. You don't have to say you only get three minutes. You could say don't repeat yourselves. Isn't it fun? Madam Mayor, I think we are now deliberating an item that is not before us. If someone would like to make a motion for deliberation, that would be great.

3:26:57 Kill it for lack thereof. Well, I don't know. I can count, but I'll still make a motion. I move that we change the public comment time from five minutes to three minutes and approve this. I don't know. I don't have it pulled up. The resolution. The resolution. And approve the resolution. And I will second. So, Jamie, will we please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? No. Councilmember Truax? No. Councilmember Wentworth? No. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes.

3:27:29 Mayor Bubzer. Yes. All right. That's a first for this council. So thank you, everyone. Moving along, we will go to item 10, public hearings. So 10.1, we'll talk about the 25 to 26 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So I'm before you this evening to present the 2025-26 fee schedule.

3:27:57 Parks and Recreation Programs and Services. What I'd like to do is just give a brief introduction. I'm not going to get into the line by line of the fee schedule. But what I would like to do is kind of unveil the membership program, which is a really large part of the fee schedule and the staff report. This is kind of the first official public unveiling of this program. And we've spent a lot of time working on this program. We're really excited to unveil it to the community.

3:28:27 But I'll just start by saying, you know, we started this process at the end of each summer. We bring it before you kind of in February and March. And that's a pretty exhaustive process of kind of compiling the results, you know, the impacts, the surveys, the comments. We weave that into kind of the annual programming menu for the upcoming year, which we presented to the Commission at the last meeting. And then we kind of align it with...

3:28:54 Kind of where the Town Council's strategic priorities are and where we believe the Department's priorities are moving to as well. We want to make sure they're aligned. So I think we're at that point. The fee schedule completes, you know, all of that necessary to deliver all of our programs and services for our community and many visitors. So a lot of work goes into it and I do want to kind of applaud and recognise the team for putting this together. A lot of work's gone into this. So the Municipal Code requires an annual review by Town Council.

3:29:24 Uptown fees and services. The Parks and Recreation Department has conducted an extensive analysis, as I've mentioned, of its services, the costs reasonably borne of providing those services, the beneficiaries of those services, and the revenues produced by those paying fees and charges for these services. So in accordance with the Municipal Code, public testimony was received by the Parks and Recreation Commission on February 4th, and the fee schedule presented to you this evening was unanimously approved by motion.

3:29:53 A summary of the proposed fee schedule amendments for the facilities, admissions and camps and programs can be reviewed on pages five, six and seven of your staff report. And staff also prepared, just to kind of provide some context, we prepared a one-page camp comparison that really kind of highlights kind of where we're at with our peer resorts and towns. So we find that very helpful for us. It's something we kind of do as our annual process.

3:30:22 Just to kind of see where our baseline is, you know, where our camp pricing is, where kind of wages are moving. So you can kind of see in that kind of one page highlight at the back of the staff report there. Kind of gives you kind of a broad overview of kind of some municipalities, what's happening in Truckee, Vail, and our resorts as well in Southern California. So again, very helpful. At this time, what I'd like to do, if there's no questions...

3:30:47 On that element, I'll kind of jump into the membership program, and then we can kind of maybe go through some questions, some comments, and if you have any recommended changes or edits to the fee schedule, we can kind of capture that after this presentation. That'll be okay? Okay, thank you. Got it queued up here, so let's see if this works. Okay, great. Here we go. So this is our annual membership program presentation.

3:31:25 You can see a little bit of kind of a background on the fundamental and the purpose of the Parks and Recreation Department. You know, all about high quality, you know, recreation facilities, diverse programming, all leading to an enhanced quality of life. We always start with that one. This is kind of our mission statement. If we're all a bit kind of unsure of kind of where we're headed towards, the direction of council. So multi-purpose, year-round indoor-outdoor, recreation opportunities accessible to all residents and visitors.

3:31:54 So this is kind of the highlight of the membership overview. We kind of like the images. We started with this back in October, if you remember. Actually, we started actually in summer a little bit, but we started with the Winterscape membership. We've rolled out the summer play membership. So really the natural evolution is to kind of weave these two together and kind of pull together an annual membership program, right? So you can kind of see there, it's really trying to combine the value of that product itself.

3:32:23 With some added membership benefits for the community and our many visitors. So that's kind of the graphic there. It's just some highlights of the goals of the program. It's really kind of driving towards greater access, availability and affordability for our many facilities. Trying to build community through families, increase awareness and utilisation of our many parks and recreation facilities. Still to this day, I still think we...

3:32:49 See and we certainly hear people are still unaware that we have a beautiful 25 metre six lane pool at Whitmore. And then, you know, people are still kind of introducing themselves to the Mammoth Rec Zone. And again, we hope through this program that we'll see not only increased utilisation, but increased participation in many programs, camps, leagues and community events as well. So really trying to drive our visitors, community into these kind of programs and our facilities. So a couple of highlights here that I've just kind of...

3:33:17 Put it on kind of a bullet form. So really it's combining the ice rink, LA Kings Ice, the Whitmore Pool and the Mammoth Rec Zone. So you can kind of participate in all of those facilities on one annual membership. The biggest one that we really found was when we sold the Winterscape membership of the 650 passes that we sold, only four were purchased by families and one was by Councilmember Rice. So we really believe, you know, to really build community.

3:33:47 We've really got to build families and make sure that they have the opportunity to kind of stay together and play together. And that's what we're really kind of pulling this together for. So this program means that with any two paid adult memberships, kids 17 and younger, 17 years and younger can skate, swim and play for free. Pretty exciting program. Save 50% on the annual membership program like last year and the Winter Skate membership in person during months of October or May.

3:34:15 So the way that will probably work in May, people interested in kind of visiting, utilising the Whitmore Pool and Mammoth Rec Zone will probably buy that pass at that time. And then if you're really synced up to pay and utilise the ice rink at the CIC, you'll probably purchase a membership in October. You have the flexibility to pay at one time or over four instalments, or now you have the option to purchase it each month. Each month is really kind of targeted towards...

3:34:44 Certainly a more affordable product if you didn't want to commit to the full price, but also for a transient workforce in our community that live here and work here now have the option if they just want to kind of participate, play hockey, you know, join us at the public skate sessions at the rink, they can just buy that during the month of winter, months of winter, or conversely during summer. It includes lots of annual, sorry, lots of added benefits, which we'll talk about. It's Tony Colisoto scholarship eligible.

3:35:12 So for instance, local K-12 students can play for only $10 a month. Can't beat that. So here it is, drum roll. I know everyone's excited. So this is kind of how it looks. So you can kind of see the columns on the left is really kind of our age categories. You can see a couple of changes there. You'll see family. So that's two adults. And that's really two adults in the household. So that could be, you know, mum and grandma, mum and granddad.

3:35:40 Father and Granddad, Grandma, right? So as long as they're part of the same household and they buy two adult memberships, all their children are free. So if you're Doug Gephardt and you have six children, all his kids are free. He's very excited. For adults, 18 to 64, pretty standard. Senior age category, we went kind of back and forth on this, but that's 65 to 79. That includes military, active in our veterans, college students, and we've also introduced for the first time.

3:36:09 Our first responders. Seniors, 80 years and plus, I know it's been a long time coming, but we're finally allowing our 80 active seniors free admission to our facilities, which is really exciting, and it's taken a while. Youth five to seven category, infants four and under are free, and as I said, the Inyo Mono K through 12 students there. So a regular fee on the left, the discounted 50% fee in the middle, and the monthly fee is a 25% premium.

3:36:38 Just added to the monthly rate. So again, you can kind of break down where you're at in kind of that age category. But again, if you have two adults, you're just going to spend $300 annually. And then all your kids are free if they're 17 years and younger. So really exciting program. So membership benefits. So this is kind of where we kind of leaned in and really trying to kind of provide that extra value to this membership, even if we even needed it, based on kind of where that pricing goes.

3:37:09 You can kind of see family memberships and it's broken up into the annual and the monthly, the way it works. I'm just going to run through these. You can kind of just see how we're doing here. But we had a lot of interest in complimentary admission. So if you have a membership, you can join us for our many special events, the Haunted Rink, Tree Lightning Ceremony, those type of things. You'll get discounts off facility birthday party rentals, 20% off skate rentals. Skate rentals, for instance, is included in your Mono K-12 student pass.

3:37:38 But if you're an adult and you haven't bought a pair of ice skates yet, you'll still get 20% discount. And that's off skate sharpening, the skate aids as well and so forth. 20% off lessons, exclusive special events. Doug will come and cook a pancake breakfast for you at the rink or he can kind of join us at the pool. Many things like that. Early skate, you know, holiday skates, things like that. Early access, like we talked about. You get one free skating lesson.

3:38:04 That Winter Play Pass that was $120 will now only be $100 if you've got a membership. We'll give you two complimentary facility passes. And then, as I said, all K-12 students will receive, and we actually started that this year, we'll receive three free skate aids and then complimentary skate rentals. So that's kind of the package of the membership.

3:38:28 Program details, these are just some of the highlights that we've talked about. I think the biggest one that we want to reiterate to the public is that the membership is access to the town-owned facilities or managed facilities, i.e. the CRC, the Whitmore Pool. It doesn't provide access to the program's drop-in sessions, pick-up games or instructional classes. So that would be that play pass. So you've got the membership that will get you in the facility.

3:38:55 And then the passes or the punch passes will get you access to all our programs. So that's hopefully pretty straightforward for everybody. You'll just need to kind of create or update your DaySmart profile. That's easy. As I said, you can purchase them by families or individually. I think we've talked about that. We've talked about the premium price there of 20% added to the monthly rate. You can purchase it during the months of October, May at 50% discount in person only.

3:39:23 You can have it over four installments, but you have to do that in person. Auto-renew, so the monthly membership will auto-renew, but the annual membership will not. And then you can still purchase the five-visit punch pass for use at Whitmore Pool. A lot of our lap swimmers still like that product, so that's still available. And again, memberships are available through the scholarship fund, which we see a lot of...

3:39:52 Redemption from the program last year. And again, they'll be at 50, 75 and 90 percent with the goal of actually publishing those levels. Is that the wind? Yeah. Couldn't win. With the goal of publishing the levels that the people would be eligible for just to minimize any confusion or ambiguity with that process. So that is kind of in a nutshell and very briefly membership program. Happy to answer any questions.

3:40:22 On that, will the staff report itself. Thank you. Thank you. Questions? I have a question. Go ahead. I would love to propose keeping the inaugural student daily rate at $5 instead of increasing it to $6. And would that include the skate rental like it did this year? It does. Yes. I'd like to propose that. And then also publishing the Tony Colosardo income guidelines so that families feel more comfortable applying.

3:40:51 And, you know, then we kind of know. Where room fits. Yeah, where you fit in there. Yeah. Appreciate that. Thank you. Other questions? All right. Then with no questions from Council, any public comment on this item? No one in the room is getting up. Jamie, anyone online? No. Okay. So any discussion needed? Does anyone want to? I'll say something. Go ahead. Thank you so much for putting this together.

3:41:21 I really appreciate it, and I really hope that our local families will utilize this family pass, and I hope to see everybody at the pool and ice skating. Thank you very much. Yeah, and I'd like to reiterate, I missed out on getting the ice skating pass in October because I forgot, but now you can go monthly until the next year. So I just love the flexibility. And you can tell that there's a lot of time and effort and thought put into it. So thank you. My team did a great job.

3:41:50 Yes, I agree. So with that, I guess, do we, is this, yes, there's a resolution. So would someone like to make a motion? And if not, I have it pulled up. Here you go. It's here. I make a motion that we adopt resolution 2025 to 2026, or XX, authorizing the town manager to expend general funds in partnership with the Mono County.

3:42:17 Is this the truth? This is the wrong one. I'm sorry. It doesn't say wrong. Is it just on your paper? I sold you. No, it's not. How about if I help out here? Are you on it, Bill? It's back here. I apologize. I would make a motion that we approve by resolution the 2526 Park and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments with the change requested by our council member.

3:42:44 Your Mayor Pro Tem. Mayor Pro Tem, yeah, I'm stuck here. I'm trying to figure out how to add this in. Amanda's change. How's that? I'll second. Great, thank you. Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes.

3:43:09 All right. Thank you so much. That carries. And we will go on to, sorry, I went through the presentation. I was on to the next. All right. Welcome, Chief Casabian. So this is policy matter 11.1, a resolution to purchase two TrueMark devices in partnership with the Mono County Sheriff and the District Attorney's Office. Thank you, Mayor. Dan Casabian, Chief of Police. And I'll make this quick.

3:43:35 So we were approached by the DA's office asking about TrueNARC. Coincidentally, just a few days prior to that, Ryan Tanaka, our co-compliance officer, mentioned TrueNARC as well. What TrueNARC is, is it's a device that has a laser on it and it can identify over 500 different types of narcotics. And our specific ones being the ones we're usually looking for, cocaine, methamphetamine.

3:44:05 Fentanyl, and heroin. And then it can also identify pills. But the issue that we're having, so back in 2014, Prop 47 went into effect. And what Prop 47 did was basically make any type of possession of a narcotic a misdemeanor. And we would write a citation, we would confiscate the narcotic, write a citation, and they would be on their way. It wasn't a bookable offense. And that was back in 2014.

3:44:32 2024, November, Prop 36 went into effect, which made it a felony again. So Prop 47 made it a misdemeanor, Prop 36 in November made it a felony. And what happens with that is, so a lot of decreased drug arrests between those last 10 years. And when we did make arrests, we confiscated it, we would send the drugs to DOJ. DOJ would test them and send them back. It's about a three-week to one-month leeway there to get those back.

3:45:00 But when somebody's arrested for a felony, which Prop 36 now makes it a felony again, they're entitled to a preliminary hearing. And that preliminary hearing has to happen within 10 days. So what we need to do is get a presumptive test of the narcotics that we seized for the DA's office to successfully go in with that evidence and put forward their case. So how we used to do it back...

3:45:27 Prior to 2014 was with what we call a knit kit. And it's this little plastic thing here. We would seize the narcotics. They're usually in a plastic bag or a bindle. And we would undo the bindle, expose the narcotics. We would take our little stick. We would stick it into the narcotics. We would dump it into this thing. We would seal it up.

3:45:49 We would squeeze these little glass things in here, and if it turned a certain color, that's good enough for presumptive, right? We would take a picture of that, we would add it to the report, send it off to the DA's office, good to go. But what happened within those 10 years is we've been introduced to fentanyl, and the slightest exposure of fentanyl is deadly. So for the safety of our officers, we wanted to try to get away from it, so there was actually a directive that came down.

3:46:15 A few years back, 2018, 2019, not to use NIT kits anymore because of the dangers of fentanyl. Well, this device has been around, I would say, six, seven years, eight years, somewhere around there. And what it does is we no longer would have to expose our officers to the narcotic to get the presumptive test. We would still send it to DOJ for the testing done at DOJ, but we would have the presumptive test immediately.

3:46:42 And not have to wait for DOJ to come within a month to give us their results. So what it looks like is it's this device here. It's simple. You turn it on. It's not really drugs, but you take your drugs. You take your drugs, you use the laser, push a button, and within 30 seconds, it scans it, reads it, and tells you what it is.

3:47:08 That gets downloaded onto a computer, you print the result out, you send that over to the DA's office, and that's good for the presumptive. So what we're looking at doing is partnering with the Mono County Sheriff's Department, the DA's office, as well as ourself, and requesting that the town manager can spend up to $25,000 for this device. This device is a $30,000 device, $31,000, $32,000, somewhere around there after taxes.

3:47:34 We're looking at purchasing two. So with the three entities going in on two devices, one device lives in Bridgeport, one device lives at the PD. It would be available for the Sheriff's Department, for any law enforcement, CHP, that needs to do some sort of test to come to the station. And it's actually, we can take it out in the field and use it on the field. We've just had a success story on it. Took it out there on a parolee that had narcotics.

3:48:01 Tested it, came back positive for methamphetamine. We had the presumptive right away. Didn't even have to open it or anything. And this is a, what do they call this? A sample or a lower? A demo. A demo, yeah. That's what I mean. Thank you. It's a demo. So the request is to be able to purchase or spend up to $25,000 to purchase two of these in partnerships with the Sheriff's Department as well as the DA's office. And what it does is helps the DA's office in

3:48:31 It helps protect our officers from exposure of any type of narcotic. Thank you. Any questions? Questions? All right. Any public comment on this item? Hello again, Council. Pat Foster with the Chief's Advisory Committee. So at our regular meeting last month, we were introduced to this device in concept. We didn't have it in-house yet.

3:49:09 And the, while I can't speak on behalf of the entire committee, everybody that I could, I could tell that everybody was very supportive of this idea. A few days later, the device actually showed up and we got called back in for a demonstration with real drugs. And we were very, very impressed with the device.

3:49:32 The only comments that I heard that weren't absolutely supportive of what the chief wanted to do was at the time it was one device and Mono County and Mammoth were going to share it. Everybody that I heard comments said we need two. Obviously we're not writing a check for it. We don't have a checkbook. But when you think about keeping our officers safe and making it easier for them to get dangerous drugs and bad people off the streets.

3:50:01 Absolutely. We're absolutely supportive of this. Thank you very much. Any other comments in the room or Jamie, anyone online? Terrific. Well, I would just like to add that I had first talked to our officers about fentanyl a couple of years ago because we know that literally you open a trunk and if there's any airborne fentanyl, an officer can go down. So I...

3:50:27 Personally, I'm just delighted that we can use technology to keep our officers safer. And so thank you for, you know, finding this opportunity and then bringing it to us. And I, too, was at the demo where we said, why aren't we getting two? It's a big county. And, you know, if the unit's up in Bridgeport, that's a long wait. So with that.

3:50:48 I'm ready. Oh, great. I move that we adopt a resolution 2025 XX authorizing the town manager to expend general funds in partnership with the Mono County Sheriff and District Attorney's offices to purchase two Thermo Fisher Scientific True Narc handheld narcotics analyzers with two-year warranties and training in the amount not to exceed $65,000.

3:51:12 With expected reimbursement from Mono County Sheriff's Office and Mono County District Attorney's Office of $42,135.96 in total. Thank you. We have a motion. Okay. Jamie, we have a motion and a second. So if you could. Point of order. No deliberation. Oh. I had a fun thing to say and then I got. I apologize. I kept looking. So go on. No, I was going to say it because I asked the same question in regards to scene one or two and I really thought to myself.

3:51:40 As John would say, we are a recreational community. We need two to test this tone. Okay. There you go. All right. Now we have a motion and a second. Jamie, can you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right. The motion carries. Thank you very much. Thank you. Use it in good health. Next.

3:52:06 Item 11.2 to approve the official Town of Mammoth Lakes logo. Good evening, Council. The item tonight before you is approve the official Town of Mammoth Lakes logo. I would like to start my presentation by just clarifying that the current Mammoth Lakes logo is not proposed to change in any way.

3:52:42 In terms of design, distribution and use of that logo. That is the logo for Mammoth Lakes as a community. It's the marketing logo and it will remain as such. What's being proposed today is an official logo for the town of Mammoth Lakes as a government entity. Sometime in 2023 we were conducting kind of a comprehensive review of our municipal code and it came to our attention.

3:53:07 That we weren't actually in compliance with several sections of our code regarding use of the logo for official use. Specifically, our code states that the town logo is a design used for the purpose of symbolically representing the authority of the town and the capacity of its officers, employees, and agents as representatives of the town. Because the current Mammoth Lakes logo is so widely distributed and well-known,

3:53:33 And the marketing campaign for that logo has been so successful.

3:53:38 It's not something that we can use just for our organization as a government entity in an official capacity. And so that started the exercise of going down this road of developing a logo that would meet that intent. We brought this item to town council in September of 2023, and at that time the council authorized staff to develop a new logo for the town of Mammoth Lakes using an iteration of the current town logo that clearly defines the town of Mammoth.

3:54:08 They also directed staff to work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and bring the item back to council for implementation. And so here we are today. Since that time, staff has been working with our contract graphic design firm, Mammoth Lakes Creative. They are here today to answer questions if you might have any.

3:54:25 We've been working with Mammoth Lakes Creative since 2019, and since that time, they've done a lot of informal branding work for the town of Mammoth Lakes in terms of color schemes, font types, and things like that to give all of our collateral and public-facing information a cohesive look that represents our organization. It made sense to build on these branding efforts as we worked to develop a logo that was both consisting with those

3:54:52 The branding as well as complementary to the existing Mammoth Lakes logo. Through the process, a design committee was established that consisted of two council members, Mayor Bubser and Councilmember Rice, as well as three staff members and John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

3:55:08 We went through approximately nine revisions through the process with Mammoth Lakes Creative. We were presented with several preliminary designs and then worked with them to refine those down into one design and then the final product that is in your packet today, which was approved by that design committee. The existing Mammoth Lakes marketing logo, as I said, is not intended to change in terms of its use or public facing.

3:55:37 Branding and marketing efforts for Mammoth Lakes. How I like to consider it to differentiate them is that the current logo is the Mammoth Lakes logo for our community and the proposed logo would be the town of Mammoth Lakes logo for our organization. This is a little bit different than how we've ever had our logos in the past because we've only ever had one logo for the town as an organization and for the community and its marketing.

3:56:02 So it's going to be a little bit of a shift in mindset in how we approach the implementation of this logo. We anticipate that this would be used for official town purposes. So that would be things like signage in this room in these meetings, our town business cards, town vehicles. When we have employees out in the field doing inspections or working at our facilities, they would have uniforms with the official town logo.

3:56:28 That's not to say that the existing logo is going to go away. Obviously, we have a lot of public-facing signage and facilities. The CRC has a giant logo on the side of it, and we're not going to tear that down and put a new logo up. And there might be instances where both logos are utilized in various places, particularly signage, I think, is something where we anticipate that to happen.

3:56:50 So in saying that, the next steps, once the primary logo is approved by Town Council, assuming that decision happens, we would work with Mammoth Lakes Creative at a staff level to design and approve one to two supplemental logos with different layouts. So like with our current Mammoth Lakes logo, there's three different iterations of that for different use cases.

3:57:15 Possibly one thing we've considered is color schemes for different departments. We will be developing branding guidelines as well as use and implementation guidelines and policy, kind of what I just discussed. And also things like updating business cards, letterhead, etc. So we haven't developed any implementation plan yet. That is part of the next steps. But the decision before you today is to approve this primary logo design.

3:57:45 And that is staff's recommendation. We do have Katie Drake here from Mammoth Lakes Creative. If there's any questions about the design process or the design itself, she can answer those questions. And I or Rob are happy to answer any additional questions that you might have. Thank you. Thank you so much. Any questions? Go ahead. Go ahead. Oh. And I'm joining into, as part of coming to the backside a little bit, but I've done a lot of logos over the years for many different empties.

3:58:15 Is this the only draft we're looking at? Do we have any other materials that would suggest any other alternatives that might be available? Because you get a sense of where I'm going with this. Sure. As I mentioned, we went through a pretty extensive design review process with the design committee that did include two council members. The intent today is not to be providing design direction to the designer from the dais, but council may provide whatever input.

3:58:43 They have consensus on. I don't have a question. I got deliberation, but I don't have questions. Okay. So if you hold that, I'll make sure we... My only question, the original direction, as you stated perfectly, was using the current logo. Where did we leave that idea behind?

3:59:10 Sure, I can address that a little bit. The intent was not to use the current logo. The intent was to provide a logo that was complementary and an iteration of the Mammoth Lakes logo. As we went through the design process, the way that we incorporated that was by using the font type that's in the current logo, as well as the color. The town blue color is prominently featured.

3:59:33 In the new proposed design as well as additional complementary colors that have been used on the town's website and a variety of other town collateral that's been going out over the past few years to the public. And I think to add just a little bit more to that too, Pam said it earlier with regard to this particular seal being representative of the town's authority and the

3:59:55 The branding, marketing one being available for sale in Vons, by the way, which is Vons is beautiful today in their grand opening. But you can purchase that in that space. And I think if the iterations are too close, meaning using the existing with maybe say a circle around it or other smaller components, the differentiation would not be great enough. So there has to be some level of differentiation while it's still, you know, let's say it's a distant cousin of it.

4:00:23 I think it is the intent of that. Any other clarifying questions? Questions? So I appreciate the need. I appreciate what's written in the code. What we are proving tonight is there will be no implementation. There will be no use of this logo. I think, Rob, we talked about you would be coming back with an implementation program, correct? And, you know, look, I'm just a little council member.

4:00:57 I don't want to, you know, be overstepping my bounds, but I'm seeing a lot of opportunities for confusion here, intended or otherwise. I would, so I'll kind of leave it at that. But so all we're doing tonight is just approving the graphic. Is that correct? Well, I think, I don't think there was a desire that we wouldn't be able to start utilization of this. There will be an implementation plan because of the cost associated with rolling this out. And then as Pam indicated,

4:01:25 The unique perspective of having essentially two logos, one associated with marketing and the other one associated with the town authority and some of the idiosyncrasies that need to be addressed. And I think that's what you're bringing up with your concern about confusion because that does exist. So I think where it has conflicting points, that would not be implemented. But we would begin with conversion of stuff probably pretty much right away.

4:01:55 Okay, so let me ask a question to the town attorney. So this is a legal, this graphic is a legal thing, correct? I mean, it's tied in the representations in the town code, the town must have a, it's like a seal, right? Well, there's a difference between a seal and a logo, technically. What we're adopting, even though we're calling it kind of a logo, it's really a seal. It's a seal, okay, good. Yeah, for most purposes. So theoretically, the seal would need to be,

4:02:26 Would it be associated with like infrastructure or things that the town owns? Like the signage thing, for example. Is there a need to associate the seal with infrastructure and things like that or no? It can be used in that way if that's the preference of council, but it doesn't have to be. All right. I'll stop right there. I may have a thought for deliberation, but I'll leave it right there. No questions. Okay.

4:02:57 I'm just looking to see, so nobody says I didn't let them ask their last question. All right, public comment from anyone in the room. Hello, Brianna Goiko. I need to get up. Brianna Goiko, Chamber of Commerce. As an organization that often uses both logos, our logo was based off Mammoth Lakes, the towns, Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

4:03:21 Maybe that's what that becomes. Their logo, I think it is very important to separate the two because we are often adding text at the bottom of the logos trying to clarify Mammoth Lakes Tourism. This is Town of Mammoth Lakes. So we also are very interested. My staff has mentioned wanting to redo our logo as well to differentiate it a little bit more as well. So anyway, very supportive of looking to something different just for the town. Thank you. Anyone online?

4:03:51 Okay. Then we will go to deliberation. I did get one public comment that I just want to share, and that is that I heard from someone that the script, because young people don't learn cursive anymore, that, you know, and we do have to

4:04:18 Realize like that's a thing. They just thought that the S might be misinterpreted by young people. I share that. It's also I understand in the, you know, it's the one branding element we were carrying through, but I thought I should mention it because at a minimum in the future we should think about the fact that young people don't learn cursive anymore. Well, that's changed.

4:04:42 The state of California requires teaching curvy letters to students. Okay, thank you. And again, I just, you know, people take the time to reach out. I want to make sure that they're, you know, that when they do, they're heard. So with that, deliberation, where shall we begin? Well, I'll just follow up on your, I think we probably heard from the same constituent. When I look at the logo again, it's an observation. The S at the end of the word, I...

4:05:10 Can write script. Looks a little weird. When it's on a straight line, when it's underneath a horizontal logo, you kind of get it. But when it's curved up like that, it starts to look like an R. I don't know. It's just a, it's an observation. And I think, again, I have, I'm confused about the implementation program. And I don't know if it's council's business, where it's not.

4:05:36 It's our business to get in there and tell you how to implement something, but what is town? Someone could look at a sign and see the old logo. Why is Mammoth Lakes Tourism putting that sign up there? Because that logo is associated with them. You may have to implement far and wide, and that could get really expensive. But I just offer that as a cautionary note. I think it's a nice-looking logo. I think it's a beautiful piece of work. It's very distinctive. It's very different than we have.

4:06:05 All the right things are there, but I would be cautious about how that implementation is going to work because I can see a lot of confusion happening. Yeah, John, I want to acknowledge that you're correct. There's some challenge in this space, and that's when I was addressing, you know, there's some things we probably have to bring back to council to discuss on the implementation, but it doesn't mean all implementation, right? There's some very clear cut.

4:06:32 Yeah. Aspects that are straightforward. Yeah. Easy things you could get going on, but there's some things out there that could get tricky. No, absolutely. And I think that's what I was trying to acknowledge earlier in my comments is that while, you know, we do have some things to work out with implementation, we acknowledge that on what presence they have because, as Pam indicated, you know, this marketing and branding is something very important to the town. And I think if you ask visitors what they recognize as far as coming to the town of Mammoth Lakes,

4:07:02 It is our marketing logo. And so that's going to have a presence in that forward facing. But then also, you know, designing the town's authority. For example, on the landscape, you know, the authority to have the sign out there is the town of Mammoth Lakes's authority to have that because of the contracts with the Forest Service and Dust Forces. You know very well about that. So it might have both. But those are the discussions that we would need to have from a policymaking standpoint with council.

4:07:30 And I just didn't want to say earlier that we would stop all implementation until we solve for that. It's just those are acknowledging those things need to be worked out. I think also in the communities sort of general confusion about Mammoth Lakes tourism and the town and who's who and who does what, I would hate to have the public starting to see there's a town logo and well everything else is somehow. It's a seal and that is a big distinction.

4:07:59 So I do, but let's start like using the, and I didn't mean to interrupt, but I think it's really important that we call it a seal because it's a seal and that's a very, it's a different thing. No, I get all that, but again, I just wanted to point out this other point about what's going to be left over is the old logo on a lot of things that looks exactly like, which is the Mammoth Lakes Tourism logo and our community looking at that saying,

4:08:21 Is that the town? Is that Mammoth Lakes Tourism? I don't know. I think that confusion exists. Can I give you one example that's really so obvious to me that might help? On ESCOG letterhead, you have the four entities, and we're the only one that's using the tourism and that we don't have our own town seal. Oh, sure, it's fine. But maybe if we just start to think about it that way, it will help people. I mean, Mayor Pro Tem Rice, you look like you had a word coming out of your mouth. Okay.

4:08:49 Then I want to turn to this side of the dais. My only comment, so far I haven't liked any of the town logos going back to the original. Seal. Seals, whatever you want to call it. No, it matters. Words matter because that's how we. The only thing I will say, I'm appreciative of the fact that at least the outline of the mountain looks something like Mammoth. I would have preferred something that represented one of our lakes or trees that actually represented maybe a Jeffrey Pine kind of tree.

4:09:18 Again, not a hill to die on, so we had a committee go through a lot of work on this, and if that's what they came up with, I feel the need to somehow support it, but I'm going to keep wearing these shirts. Okay. Well, you're allowed because that's, you can buy that in Vons. So, Councilmember Truax. Yes, a number of things. One is, and I appreciate if I'm saying it's not.

4:09:45 comments, design, which we've already given you design comments from other council members up here. All of us carry a different set of expertise. I've used Mammoth Lace Creative a number of times to create logos. I didn't call them seals because they're not official government, but to create logos. There are a number of components in here that I would not personally design into something and have concerns about it carrying forward in this design that is reiterated here. I'll leave it at that only because there's just a number of elements from

4:10:15 Do you have anything to add? Well, I was on the committee that selected this.

4:10:49 John, I did echo your thoughts with the S. Did you? At one point, yes. And John Urdi was very adamant that we not change the script at all. So it would be his fault. It would be his fault, yes. But I do agree with you that when the S is like that, it makes it harder to read. And I was open to playing with that font, but was shot down. But I like the seal.

4:11:17 And I think it's a big upgrade from our previous town seal. So I would be ready to move forward with this today. Okay, my turn. I was really impressed with the professionalism of the staff. And we went through nine iterations. And in the process, each time, it got better and better. And I think there comes a point where, you know,

4:11:47 The graphics were optimized. I can firmly attest to in my own experience, which is long and in advertising for many, many years, but that was not what I think was a remarkable thing about this process was that we had different representation from staff to Mr. Erdi and, you know, worked as a team very patiently.

4:12:15 And deliberately to get to something that is truly optimized. And I think the most important thing is that we need a town seal. We need a town seal for a number of reasons, mostly legal. And so here we are. And this is unusual. I don't usually like to do this, but I would like to move that we approve the official town of Mammoth Lakes logo this evening. Seal. Seal. It said logo in the staff report. It said, yeah, staff report.

4:12:44 You threw me under the bus. I would like to terminology about seals and logos that are slightly different, even though we're using this kind as a seal. Yes, let's just call it that. It'll make it to be a seal. Yes, this will make our life easier. So may I redo. I would like to approve the official Town of Mammoth Lakes seal. I second. You second. I second. Yes. Jamie, can you please call the roll?

4:13:12 Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. All right. Moving along. We are now to... How's everyone doing? I would love a quick break. Let's take five minutes so we'll be back at 8.17. Let the fun begin. We've been having fun the whole time. Ooh.

4:21:57 I think I'm alright. I got me some water. Alright. Welcome back to those who are still hanging with us for item 11.3, the 2025 Town Council Strategic Planning Series. This is the final review of key objectives. And so I gather that staff will begin. Thank you.

4:22:28 Pam's going to pull this up really quick and project it on the screen so we have something to visualize as we kind of walk through this a little bit. As you know, this strategic planning series began in early November and has gone through a number of different data gathering points from community input to staff input to a community input exercise online.

4:22:58 As well as the town council with an all-day off-site strategic planning series where they got a chance to address some of these elements, bring them into specific components, right? That's what you all did on the 22nd of January that really reflected areas of intent and focus.

4:23:21 From that, we brought back what we had captured as notes, which was the discussion that occurred on February 5th, and the crew led you through that with an intent of understanding exactly had we captured accurately what you guys wanted to focus on for the year 2025. The work that was done since that meeting, because I think clarifications occurred, we had four different people taking notes.

4:23:50 The team went through those notes. They were able to compile summarized versions that captured the intent of those components but sort of rolled up into a higher level. That was one of the things we heard loud and clear is we wanted a high-level interpretation of those tasks. The other two elements, so that's what we did in putting these into these buckets. The other two components that you'll see that I'm going to say frankly you're seeing tonight for the very first time.

4:24:18 is the overall layout and format. And that is because we wanted a different look and feel than the previous ones, which were called the strategic planning and key initiatives. This particular, or key objectives, I'm sorry. This particular document, you know, as we've gone through the strategic planning series, we did focus in on a lot of this is task-oriented work and less about the higher level

4:24:47 Sort of directional components that we had in the previous version of this. And so it's really more focused on executable tasks for the year 2025. And so we did narrow it down to council key objectives. Okay. The other thing that's in here is a short-term visioning statement, which is on that top line item.

4:25:08 And I know we've got an element in there later on where we talk about building, you know, more of a community-wide visioning statement on broader senses of where the community is going, especially when we do work like new planning series and those types of things. But this particular comment was laid out to sort of bring all the elements on that page into one clarifying statement.

4:25:34 And that's how we brought that together. Of course, all this is up for Council's interpretation, review, edit, wordsmithing, whatever you'd like. And we, you know, this is our effort to bring this forward. So what we hope to receive tonight from the present, from this discussion with Council is either, you know, small refinements adoptions of, small refinements of this, bringing it to an adoption, or

4:26:03 All right. Thank you.

4:26:36 So just a point of process. There's several different ways to go through this. We'll need to get questions and clarification, and then we'll need deliberation, and in the meantime, we want to make sure we leave time for public comment. Should we be trying to tackle this one section at a time as the document in its entirety?

4:27:02 Does anybody have any strong opinions about... I would just offer that I've come prepared to go one section at a time. I don't know how anybody else is prepared, but that's how I've prepared myself for this evening. So, in terms of my mic, it's not on again. Maybe put it a little closer, too, in case people are online. A little closer. Sorry, it is getting late.

4:27:40 So what I'm prepared to do is say I think that a quality job has been done with everything that we gave the consultants and staff to put this together. Does it contain things that I probably wouldn't put in there? Yes. Would I add some things if it was just I? Yes. But I am very happy with how all of our thoughts and times have been condensed into this one document.

4:28:09 The process allowed us to get a better understanding of each other going through it, which to me is the important part of the process anyway. So for me, I would just, unless there are things very specific we want to change, I don't know that I would bother to spend the time going through it, you know, bullet point by bullet point. Okay. Just from my standpoint, what I was hoping to do is at least start with, are we all good with the overall picture before we get through each line?

4:28:37 It's a change from where it was before and the CIP projects, et cetera. Is this the format we wanted in is kind of where I was thinking originally and then going to whatever detail from there. Okay. Got it. And so Mayor Pro Tem? I have minimal feedback. Okay. So I could do it however to you are pleasing. Okay. So I think since it doesn't seem there are a lot of questions but there's more comments that are more of a deliberative nature.

4:29:06 I would go straight to public comment, online and in the room, and then we can give our feedback, you know, and I am happy with starting broad, high level, and then if people want to go through, then that's totally fine as well. Is everyone comfortable with that? Staff, is that acceptable to you since there aren't any really comments?

4:29:31 I saw you not paying attention. I appreciate that approach, Mayor Bobser. I want to clarify maybe a statement I said opening this up. We will bring this back for adoption on May 5th. I'm sorry, March 5th, not May 5th. March 5th, as the recommended motion says. So there is, we will bring it back for adoption later. So tonight we're just getting consensus on that final review. Terrific.

4:30:00 So with that, I'd like to ask if there's any public comment from anyone in the room? Anyone online? Okay, then, I think I'll go to hearing from council members. It seems like, Councilmember Truax, would you like to go first? Because it seems like you have some thoughts about the format. Actually, I like where the format's gone, and I think it's very readable from that standpoint. There's some formatting stuff in terms of full justified, etc.

4:30:32 There was a conversation before about visioning statement, where we are, are we including that? So I just want to make sure, in my mind, are we all in agreement? I like the visioning statement up there, but there was questions before that we all kind of had back and forth, and I don't know if that was, everybody was in agreement of where, how we're outlining the top format. In terms of the other panels for that, I'm fine. It's a little bit more just optics from that standpoint, but I like the format. Great.

4:31:00 I'm glad you brought up the visioning statement. I would like to hear from everybody what your thoughts are on that because it has evolved from the prior version. So, Councilmember Sauser? I like it. I think the whole thing was put together very well with all of our thoughts put into it. Okay. Mayor Pro Tem? I like the vision statement. That was my only little tweak is the last word for visitors.

4:31:29 Preferred it saying like for all rather than just it says we aim to enhance municipal services, expand housing opportunities and improve recreational offerings, ensuring a balance between quality of life for residents and exceptional experiences for all instead of for visitors. Okay. Okay. Thank you. And then Councilmember Wentworth. We're just talking about the visiting statement. Okay. So the visiting, I had a problem with the visiting statement.

4:31:57 Because in the meeting, and this is something I've been sort of kind of, we've been talking about for a while, the point of the vision statement was to address the vision statement that's in the general plan. It was a point to have a discussion and, you know, reshape and redo that. And that is captured in the, where's it captured? In the planning.

4:32:26 Community plans and all that, which one is that? It's the third bullet point of the municipal services. Yeah, so that idea is captured there. That's appropriate. So my suggestion would be to remove the vision statement for the moment because the intention of what happened in the meeting we were all together was to take a look at that vision statement from the general plan and then once we do that, then add that to this.

4:32:54 But when I look at the vision statement here, it's a nice maybe sort of summation exercise, but it is not a vision statement. So I would suggest just take it out for now. When we get to that point of redoing the vision statement, then add it into this once we get to that. And before you go, because I want to make sure that every one of us, and I'm next. So for me, for the vision statement, I don't think it's essential for our

4:33:24 So I would just say.

4:33:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

4:34:13 Really want us to say strategic priorities, not key objectives. I know it sounds, you know, nitpicky, but those are very different things in my mind from where I come from in my prior professional life. So strategic priorities is a higher level, and that's what we've done. So I feel like it's more correct. If I can address a couple of those things. So certainly recognize that the third bullet point did include that.

4:34:43 Town-wide vision plans and services. So that when we look at the overarching long-term vision, that's more of a visioning statement that is described. What we intended with this, because our previous one also had a short-term, it was actually labeled as short-term vision. And what it serves is as a talking point to sort of summarize, I think, John, you said this.

4:35:11 Well, summarizes the overall intent of that focus. So that was the thing we were putting together as a short-term, not to usurp any efforts that are building a long-term vision, because that has longer legs across multiple years. This one would be referenced for 2025's focus. The other aspect, and I think with regard to the difference between strategic planning as a document and key objectives,

4:35:38 Is just what you described in that strategic planning, it's a higher level focus. And so when we looked at this, and again, with an effort of task-oriented accomplishments for the year, that's why we kind of came up with key objectives. So I'm just explaining a little bit of that background, where staff came from on that, and not to sort of say that we don't agree with you on that. It's just that was the reason we came to these conclusions. And, you know, I don't know if anybody else feels strongly.

4:36:07 Obviously, I can go either way. I just, you know, this is our chance to... I feel a little bit stronger. I mean, I appreciate that explanation. My approach to this has always been strategic priorities. And the comments that I made and the participation was always about putting priorities in here. And I think the direction that was giving you guys about high levels, such that it could be additive and all that kind of stuff, it's a priority. And I think if the document is labeled as strategic priorities,

4:36:36 And then the four elements within here are the objectives and the, you know, the things within below those are the objectives. That makes sense. But it's, from my mind, I was always involved in this process as a priority-setting exercise. Well, for me, I kind of like the vision statement there because it's like the preamble. I agree with John, though, because we talked about changing it. So I'm kind of like, it needs to be modified, but I'm actually good with it there at the moment. We could call it summary instead because it is. It's a summary of the.

4:37:07 Well, again, it's, again, and I, you know, I've, we've all been through a number of these processes. Typically, the facilitator, something like a vision statement is something that we would have been, with a facilitator, we would have been doing that work to come up with something that represented what we would describe as a vision statement. This is something, it's a summary statement that we did not create, and I don't,

4:37:32 I just don't feel comfortable. I'll just take it out. I'll put the vision statement from the current general plan in there. It's not something that we did. I like this vision statement. I have no problem with it. Taking it in or out doesn't make any difference to me. The key objectives, I think, is more demonstrates what we are doing. This is a one-year objective. These are not our visions for five years off.

4:38:03 I have an idea. Yes, Mayor Pro Tem.

4:38:32 If we could do Chris's idea of strategic priorities, like replacing key objectives, putting strategic priorities there, and then erasing the vision statement and writing like key objectives would kind of, I mean, because I feel like you're saying we didn't write the vision statement, but I do feel like these were all ideas that we talked about that have been put together, but it's, you know, it's not.

4:38:55 John Wentworth's vision statement. Well, it's not the council's vision statement. So I think, let's just take it out. There's no confusion about it. Well, I guess I would just relabel that as key objectives, like move the key objectives to where the vision statement is.

4:39:09 So it would say key objectives, create a resilient, vibrant, and sustainable community that promotes civic engagement and foster strong partnerships. We aim to enhance municipal services, expand housing opportunities, and improve recreational offerings, ensuring a balance between quality of life for residents and exceptional experiences for all, and then put Chris's strategic priorities up where key objectives currently is. To me, that's just pablum. Pablum? Pablum.

4:39:36 You've got to define that for me. It's SAT work, John. It ain't much. Yeah. It ain't much. So, okay. And it certainly is a vision. Maybe we could come back to it at the end. Let's come back to it. Okay. Just on the same portion. As I think about it here, in my mind, John's right. Either you take the 2007 plan, put the vision statement there, or right now, take it out.

4:39:59 That's what I would get. But isn't this, this is the vision statement. You want to put all. No, no, no. Just that. Just this little. Community vision. And that doesn't say vision statement. It says community vision. Surrounded by uniquely spectacular scenery and diverse four-season recreational opportunities, the community of Mammoth Lakes is committed to providing the very highest quality of life for our residents and the highest quality of experience for our visitors.

4:40:24 It's from the general plan. It's old. It needs to be updated. Yeah. That's the community's vision. That's something. Well, I'd rather just cut the vision statement out than put this from 20 years ago. Can you live with cutting it up? I have no problem with cutting it up. That's it. I'd be okay taking it out. Okay. But I do really want to make the point that when we revisit it and as we are...

4:40:47 Because that did summarize a lot of what's in the document. I really want to make sure that public safety gets elevated because I feel like that was missing from that statement and I don't want that to get lost. Okay. So maybe these are a couple suggestions in light of what our discussions this evening and things that I think we've been all sort of seeing. A couple suggestions just to move key objective statements as written.

4:41:16 Just move them into some different sections. So this is what I would propose for your consideration. The first one would be to take the community resilience section. At this point, and like Chris, I think I agree with you about public safety wildfire. Also the statement about taking the improvements to the airport, which is about wildfire as well. That's about public safety.

4:41:59 Those statements, emergency management, augment the town's emergency management operations and public notifications efforts with no change to the text, risk mitigation, enhance the fire safety and resilience through collaborative integrated framework, again, no change to the text, and facility utilization, take those three and move those into community investment. Move them out of community resilience and move them into community investment. Because I think

4:42:28 That my sense, but I defer to your better judgment, is that these are things that we want to invest in and we want to do. And when they stay in the resilience section, to me, it seems passive. It seems like it's sort of a nice idea, we'll kind of do it. But I think it would be better reflective, I think, of where I think we're at, to say we want to invest in these things, we want to do them.

4:42:53 I feel like we are paying for all of these things. I mean, maybe you want to change the community investment. That, to me, seems easier than moving all of those into community investment. Maybe the community investment, what's another way to describe building community or enhancing community or something like that? I just feel like...

4:43:21 We're going to be paying for all of these things. And I would be against moving all of the community resilience things into community investment. Because I feel like community investment is more like building community and housing. I would agree. Okay, wait, I want to try to make sure. So, yes, Council Member Souser, now, are you good? Because I want to, okay, go ahead. If you're worried about the investment being there and denigrating the rest of it.

4:43:48 I don't like moving resilience over.

4:44:19 To try and make it more important or whatever. I feel like it takes away from it, though, because community resilience. Let's hear from Councilmember Truax. Let's hear from Councilmember Truax and then. Yeah, because in my lens, I look at it as we elevated it into its own category. That's how important it is. I feel like if we move it back, it's kind of portion. The only thing I would say, though, in terms of the risk management, to me, is not just fire safety, but risk.

4:44:46 It's all resiliency. It's fire, snow. So I was trying to figure out how to make sure we incorporate that into resiliency. So let me make a suggestion. What if we changed from resilience, called public safety and resilience? So then it would stay in the same place, but then it's a little bit more than just, well, we want to be resilient. It's like, no, these are critical things coming at us. I would be okay with that. Except it's all already in there. I mean... But can I...

4:45:15 I don't mean to interrupt. I just interrupted you. Go ahead, finish, and then. No, that's fine. We have resilience, enhancement, safety written in all over the place in here. Risk mitigation, emergency management. We go down to municipal services, continue to evaluate public safety, needs to protect our community. When I read that, I just protect against wildfires, protect against drug use, protect against balding old men.

4:45:45 I totally hear you, but here's where I got stuck, okay? I totally hear you. I felt like we spent a lot of time in the strategic priorities meeting talking about wildfire, and we really all got that this is the biggest threat to our community. And in the past, and I am a huge advocate of housing, but in the past, it sort of felt like our strategic priorities were housing, housing, housing, and then all the other things.

4:46:15 It feels very urgent to me based on that meeting and what I've heard from our community that, you know, the risk of the climate crisis is ever present and getting worse in our community and, you know, the fact that we have 7,500 people a lot of the time, about 40,000 on the weekends with two or three officers on, like, that we really want to refocus our efforts on public safety. So it was actually the headline that really just

4:46:44 Stuck for me because I felt like it's all there, but it didn't get the same level of attention and that just, I was struggling with it. Can I make a suggestion though? Yeah. It may be semantics, but what if we took community resilience and move it to the left top?

4:47:02 It's not that. I think the new title of Public Safety and Resilience. People read it. I'm just saying. No, I'm not here, but I think. Are you okay with Public Safety and Resilience? I think Public Safety and Resilience. I'm not Community Resilience and Public Safety. It flows better. Okay, we'll go with the public. That's true. And to me, based on the meeting that I heard, I think yes and. I think a more pointed title and it should be on the left. That's what I think.

4:47:31 And then I can go home, so then you guys keep going with the rest. No, because there's, okay. No, I'm kidding, but let's, okay, so that is, felt like a big win. So do you want to, does any, should we just let Councilmember Warrenworth keep going with some of the other? What was the consensus that you heard there? That we move it to the left, we call it. And give it. I would like to let the team work out the words, because. Well, the words, I think we should do the words. Okay.

4:48:01 Okay, okay, you do the words, go for it. Community resilience and public safety, keep it as it is, move it over to the left. Okay. And what about for community investment, community sustainability? I don't know, I feel like you don't, I'm okay with investment, but it sounds like. Community sustainability, that sounds fine. Can we finish up the resilience one first? Yeah. Go ahead. No, I like that shorter, but I'm okay with the binocular of where you're going.

4:48:28 Okay. I just like to keep it, I'm trying to keep it so simple so we can fit lots of things underneath it, but I don't think it limits it. What if we said just public, not community resilience, we just call it public safety? Yeah, I like that better personally, but that's just me. Okay, let's go. I'm good with that. That's fine. Okay. And then my only other thought with the bullet points underneath that was the facility utilization. That was the only one that I read it and I kind of felt like

4:48:57 I think I know what they're talking about, but I don't. Let me tell you what they're talking about. Well, I know what they're talking about, but I'm just saying it wasn't clear to me. Increased utilization of the Mammoth Yosemite Airport facilities to further protect the community. From the threat of wildfire. Yeah, I just felt like it needed a little more. If we add that, right? Yeah. But it's about more than that. It's about using it for the air ambulance services. It's about using it. How about facility optimization? Because that's what it is. It's not just using it. It's using it well.

4:49:26 So, facility optimization. Well, I think Bill's got a good point. Bill, what you're saying, what, air ambulance, and I think that the threat of wildfire is one piece, because I know, we know that that's one piece. Yeah. But what's the other thing you were saying that we could add to that? Well, we use it all the time. Yeah. I've been flown out of it. It's a health...

4:49:50 Resource, it's the air ambulance. And what's that called, air flight? What do you call that? Life flight. Life flight is one company. Okay. There's more than one company that flies in and out. What's the generic third term for that service? Rob knows, what is it? Air ambulance, right? Medivac. Medivac and threats from wildfire. Yeah, why didn't I look back there sooner? Medivac. That's fine. Medivac and threats from wildfire. Okay.

4:50:20 That's good. Good. Okay, so there's one other thought I'd like to get in front of you very quick. Okay. And this has to do with the things we were talking about earlier, which is around outdoor recreation. Because in the recreation amenities and programs, community recreation, community, you know, that's all very important. That's community focused. The outdoor recreation that is our economic driver.

4:50:49 is under the same types of threats as we have, I think, with wildfire. So I've proposed a key objective, and we can figure out where to put it in there. We just changed the language from the public lands thing, and I have something to read to share with you. Okay. So just so everyone's clear, we're on recreation amenities and programs? Exactly. Okay, you guys good with that? Okay, thanks.

4:51:18 Work with federal partners to ensure the delivery of sustainable outdoor recreation experiences that drive visitation and enhance quality of life for the community, invest in wildlife management including public outreach, and enhance the town's on the ground presence to inform visitors and local residents. John, the problem I have with that is we're being too specific. I like this to be high enough so that it can do those things.

4:51:47 But we aren't saying specifically, here's what we're going to do. The way you've got that worded is we are dictating now exactly how we're going to accomplish that versus work with federal and state partners is how I'd do the public land. But you're adding in, for me, too much specificity in your verbiage. Could I? I actually commented on this one as well. Can I make a proposal and then? Yeah, sure.

4:52:14 But I didn't find that so, I didn't find it too specific, but I said work with federal and state partners because CDFW were at their mercy a lot. So work with federal and state partners to ensure the delivery of sustainable recreation amenities, services.

4:52:32 And wildlife management strategies and public outreach. I did like the way John worded that a bit better. And determine where gaps exist and how to fill them because that's the part for me that's new with the federal government, you know, having these massive... But the way you just worded that, determine where they are and then try to fill it, leaves it high level. So could you live with that? Yeah, I think the thing that I'm missing in that is visitation.

4:52:59 And the connection of the outdoor recreation, to differentiate the outdoor recreation that is our economic driver from municipal recreation. And I appreciate that, that you know I do. Yeah. So I just want to make sure that we word that, it's late, we can figure out a way to do it, but I think we need to get something in there. Do you want to read yours one more time? I'll read it one more time, you guys can hack it up. Okay. Go slow, okay? Okay.

4:53:30 Sustainable outdoor recreation, and I'm going to add the words that I've heard that make sense for you guys. Sustainable outdoor recreation work with federal and state partners to ensure the delivery of sustainable outdoor recreation experiences that drive visitation, invest in wildlife management, including public outreach, and enhance the town's on-the-ground presence to inform visitors and local residents.

4:54:04 To me, I almost split that in two different categories. It's similar, but you're trying to separate out what is non-municipal recreation, and your first sentence and a half there is almost by itself. You know, almost if you reworded that second part to be similar, because I agree with Bill, I'm trying to remain that it all falls under, but keep it a higher level. And I'm just suggesting maybe there's two different bullet points there. Well, actually, two bullet points works.

4:54:35 Because if we move this over to the left, we've got to create a little more. So let's make it into two bullet points. So let's make it into two bullet points. So the first bullet would be work with federal and state partners to ensure the delivery of sustainable outdoor recreation experiences that drive visitation, period. Yes, I like that.

4:54:57 Invest in wildlife management, including public outreach, and enhance the town's on-the-ground presence to inform visitors and local residents. And where I'm stuck a little bit is on-the-ground presence. Is there another way to phrase that that can leave you a little higher? Yeah, that's too much specificity. Okay. Invest in wildlife management, including public outreach, and just leave it like that. That's fine. Okay.

4:55:22 Yeah, that's good. And then we can skip the part I say because I don't care. Yeah. And since we're on that category, can I comment on community connectivity? Yeah. Because it says augment wayfinding. I was trying to find another word because augment by itself to me means we're just increasing wayfinding. Yeah. I was looking for a better word than augment is what I was looking for. I do not have one. Enhance. Enhance. Yeah, just do enhance. Enhance is fine by me. Enhance is improve.

4:55:50 And it might be more. It might be more and it might be better. Okay, I like it. And we didn't even have to get the thesaurus out. Okay, so. Pablum. Look it up. Did you get a 1600 on the SAT job? I did, actually, yeah. Yeah, thanks for checking. He didn't in math. You said Pablum? Pablum. Pablum. Pablum. I know.

4:56:22 Who got a higher verbal SAT, John? Okay. So let's see. How about... So those were my notes that I've shared with you. Can I share a couple more that are small, but... Okay. So under community enhancement or whatever we're calling it, housing now, affordable housing is good, partnerships. I was just a little confused.

4:56:52 I would maybe make sub-bullets because I feel like increasing childcare ability and then the middle and last mile fiber projects, it just, I don't know, I struggled that they were in the same thing. And giving opportunities of community foundations to support town initiatives, that I was pretty confused by. That's addressing the desire to have, to explore, developing a community.

4:57:21 We're looking for an opportunity for people to invest or to provide funding for the town to respond to a number of different things, right? It's really more town augmentation, right? When we talk about foundations, I think it needs to have the ability to provide grant funding to specific areas, and we're just looking for an opportunity for people who really want to invest in Mammoth. I hear this all the time. I love Mammoth.

4:57:51 Find a way to help. And so standing up an actual foundation that specifically addresses those needs is what we're trying to achieve there. So a separate bullet that said explore opportunities for community foundations to support. Yeah, that is a bit of a potpourri one. I'll give you that.

4:58:15 Throwing everything in the pot, trying to get it condensed. Making that a separate bullet, that one for sure a separate bullet. I would just do all three. They're all good and they're all important, but they have nothing to do with each other. And so. And partnerships. The partnerships there, where I was struggling was, I thought we were talking about partnerships with multiple entities, and it kind of narrows it down to a couple of entities on child care and fiber.

4:58:43 I was trying to make it much brighter, like we're working with all of our partners. Fair enough. And I felt there was a little too confining on it. I don't know that we have to say child care and broadband because they're happening anyway. That's kind of, well...

4:58:56 If you look at those, those are specific bullet points that we tried to put into a similar bucket, right? We're not going to be able to do this on our own. It's going to take a level of effort with a multitude of people, and that's why it ended up that way, but I agree. Totally agree. I think, though, Councilmember Truax has the answer, which is pull it up to, say, explore partnerships. And I might, I think having community foundations in there is...

4:59:23 Valuable because it's something we aren't doing that, so, but I think, where are you going? Okay. Okay. Sorry? All right. It's over there. Out there. So, is everyone feeling? Yeah, so I agree that, again, for me, calling out exactly what we're doing there is too much specificity. Okay. Last mile fiber project, child care.

4:59:55 We work on so many things. How do we say that? And it's too late for me to come up with it. Betsy, how do we say that? But that's where I'm at there. So it really is about working with community partners to increase opportunities. And then that would get the foundations just, you'll remember. I can say leverage. Yeah. Because when you've got multiple partners, you're leveraging the efforts of many for the success of

5:00:29 But are you going to still keep those three? No, they don't need to. And I think Bill's saying the right thing. As long as we will remember what that is, and we're pulling it up so that it's more consistently high enough level that if something dramatically changed, we could do it and not feel like we had not been true to our plan. Okay. Okay.

5:00:55 I struggled with quality of life, continued town-wide beautification efforts. For me, that's less quality of life and more, I don't know, and maybe it goes somewhere else. I felt like that's more of a visitor thing. But we all want our town to be beautiful. I just don't know. If you're looking for something to cut, we're always going to be doing that. Actually, one of my areas, too, was I was trying to figure out where to put that. Yeah. It feels lonely. It feels lonely.

5:01:26 I agree. We'll let you guys decide. Okay. Can we, well, Jim, are you trying to capture all this? This is recorded. Thankfully, this is recorded and we're going to go back. Okay, so you'll take it off for recording? I just want to make sure we capture it. Yes, and by the way, I have...

5:01:52 I wrote it all down too, so you can certainly consult with me. The one last thing I have is under public safety, I'll be vetoed if necessary, but it's continue to evaluate public safety needs to protect our community visitors and officers. I added and work closely with county departments such as public health and behavioral health. I feel like there is a great opportunity to enhance those

5:02:21 Relationships because I feel like sometimes it's not happening the way we wish it did and I don't see a problem with calling it out so that our county partners understand we need more. I think the way it is, I would leave it the way it is with the same thing we just talked about that that's part of the things that we need to do. And I'm fine with that. I just wanted to say it in this room so everybody heard it because it's something I learned recently and I think we need to do better.

5:02:51 So that's fine. I'm cool. Because I'm going to throw out the same type of thing and I'll get vetoed. That's okay. Go for it. It's on community engagement. I'm trying to figure out how to increase community engagement and outreach efforts, including a focus on Spanish language. I was trying to think of how to broaden that because as I bring in my disabled sports perspective, it's people with disabilities as well. Sure. It's not just Spanish. I'm trying to figure out how to.

5:03:16 Make that a little broader. Accessible. Accessible. Language accessible to our whole community, something like that. Something that addresses it at the same time. I have no problem with that. But I think that, I mean, to me, the Spanish language offerings is that, you know, like half of our community speaks Spanish and the website to sign up for recreation is only in English. And, you know, like the Tony Colosado scholarship is only in English. And so I feel like we could make...

5:03:46 We could have our camps be more inclusive for kids with disabilities or something as well, but I feel like to me it's really important that we can take those little steps to include, you know, half of our community. And I was trying to add to it because I was on a disabled sports meeting the other day and I had a board member who has multiple disabilities and realizing that even our conversation that was taking place was difficult.

5:04:14 Just thinking at a broader spectrum, if someone has disabilities, it's not just, I recognize this is Latino focused, but it's community engagement, and I was trying to add in for people with other non-language accessible challenges. I feel like there were two parts in there, and I feel like what Brent's saying is pulling it up higher, but certainly, yes, under this, if it said language accessible to the community,

5:04:39 That would make our website English and Spanish, but for example, I work with people who are visually impaired, and when you make presentations, or if somebody is hearing impaired, there's a lot you can do to make things more accessible, so I feel like it wouldn't preclude us from making sure that we're translating a lot more and everything is in English and Spanish, but that it's...

5:05:04 So I would actually break that out, though, because there's two parts to it. One is the language of just being better about making sure we translate everything. But the other, the Latino community engagement, that's a different effort that we need to be doing. And it's how do we make it so that, you know, our community comes to more things or that we are being more sensitive to, you know, our entire community. So I would break it into two bullets.

5:05:36 Inclusivity of disabilities as well? Well, so what we said was language accessible to, we could say the entire community, and that captures all the ADA stuff too. Stop right there. You got it. Walk away. Okay. Mic drop. Oh my God, we've worn out Wentworth. Wentworth is done. Oh my God. Let's keep going. Let's keep going. Okay. Councilmember Sauser. Yes, ma'am. Do you have...

5:06:05 Is there anything else? I know you were content at the beginning, but thank you for bearing with us. Yes, I'll come and rattle your cage at 2 in the morning so that you can't sleep either. But anyway, no, I'm fine. I'm anxious to see what comes back. Okay. Yeah. I just had one other comment. I thought possibly the community development maximized community benefit when considering and approving development projects. I don't know if that's better under, like, the community investment.

5:06:36 Oh, what do you all think? I would change it from development projects, because I heard about this at the MLT meeting yesterday, to just general permitting. And maybe we combine and have community development maximize community benefit when considering permitting and continue town-wide beautification efforts. That would be good. Okay.

5:07:07 And I'm sorry, but you brought it up, so now you open the door. Community benefit agreements is a term of art that municipalities use to make sure that people are using union labor and things like that. So I just want to caution us that to think about that language, Hayes is looking at me, so I know he knows what I'm talking about. So just...

5:07:35 Think carefully about whether we really want to use that exact wording. It's up to you guys. It could make... We should discuss, is that what we mean by that or no? Well, is that what we mean? Do you guys know what I'm talking about? Community development agreement? Or community benefit, I mean. Is that what we mean or do we just mean maximizing the... See, now you're going to repair this box because I was going to leave it alone with maximize because I was trying...

5:08:03 There's a perception there in terms of what's maximizing. Is maximizing getting the most money from somebody or is it making sure that we have a need and this is what it drives to? And I struggled with that a little bit in terms of was going to suggest that whole suggestion and then I left alone because I didn't come up with a better solution to it. Well, what a benefit was amenities. Maximize community amenities when considering and approving.

5:08:31 I don't know. I would take that whole thing out of there. That thing, that's like... It's very simplistic. It has actually, as it reads... That's not a priority. That's an obligation. Yeah. If we're not doing that, that's not, you know, we're not doing our job. Yeah, but I have no problem with it being there. I think it reads fine. Okay, fine. Well, then just, you know... I'd be happy to take it out, too. Because when I look at the budget, it has nothing, you know, if we're going into where this leads us for this year.

5:09:00 That doesn't help me line up anything for this coming year. But like it makes us maybe think about our diff fees or other, you know, like how do we make, how do we make those things? Let's leave it in there as a reminder. So it's what we're supposed to be doing. Okay. I'll stand down. So, Councilmember Truax, anything else from you? That's all my comments. Just going back to the one on risk mitigation note.

5:09:26 We still left as fire safety, and I was looking for it to be slightly broader in terms of that it's risk management is for fire, snow, all safety. Sure. You're right. So. They don't want to take fire out because I think fire is significant. Yeah. You talked and even your wife left. She's still here. She's here. She's just filling her water. Yeah, but she's leaving the room. It's, you know. Enhance. There's a clue in there. I'm used to it, John.

5:09:56 Mayor Boebser, can I ask some clarification? Because we were deep in a conversation earlier about the vision statement and those top line elements. I want to try to reiterate what I thought I heard. Okay, but before you do, Councilmember Truax was halfway through fire safety and resilience and he wanted to add more.

5:10:22 Kind of emergencies. So I want to make sure we capture his thought before we do and then we'll get to the. Would everybody be okay if we just add fire and snow at this moment and then leave it at that? Why don't you say fire and other natural disasters. There you go. Great. Okay. Now go ahead, Rob. Yeah, I just, so I captured that we want to.

5:10:44 Remove key objectives. I'm not talking about the top line title of that and call it strategic priorities. So it'll be town council strategic priorities across the top. And what I heard mixed emotions about was the value of either the summary statement or what we call the short-term visioning statement. Do we want to keep that summarized statement?

5:11:13 With the edits that we did here and maybe change the introduction and don't call it a visioning statement or is it just out entirely? I just need clarification. I'd like to go down the line because we decided that we're going to put it on pause. Councilmember Sauser, in or out? I can go either way. I liked it. Are you okay calling it summary instead of vision just so that we don't? Okay.

5:11:42 Councilmember Truax. I agreed to take it out, so I'm staying with that. You want it out? Yeah, right now, I think that I agree with John that when we talk about vision statement, we need to either take the 2007 town plan or a company new statement. Mayor Pro Tem. I leave it in and feel like you can rename it or I feel like it's a summary. Out. Okay. So we have two in and two out, so I am the tiebreaker. Hmm. I would leave it in and call it summary.

5:12:13 Anyone going to throw themselves out of their chair with that solution? Well, what I just heard is the staff is going to rewrite it as a summary statement. Right? Based on the changes, or is it going to be exactly the same language? It's going to have one word change, which is from visitors to all. And also public safety. It was going to elevate public safety.

5:12:36 Suggesting, now that you're keeping it in, that the staff rewrite the summary statement and not use a vision statement, which they're trying to do here, but just write a summary statement. Yeah, with no title. No title. Don't call it anything. Just write something. Just write it as a summary statement and reword the whole thing. But they're not even going to call it summary. This used to be a vision statement. Now you've got me wordsmithing again. If we're going to take out visitors and put all there, then we don't need residents in either. Quality of life.

5:13:05 Exceptional experiences for all. If we're going to not call out, we are a two-tier community, visitors and locals. Quality of life and exceptional experiences. I think that's nice. Do you guys understand what council members are saying? Okay, everyone's happy. Happy, happy, happy.

5:13:23 All right. If I could, Mayor Bubser, before we move on, we heard a lot of discussion and I just wanted to summarize the consensus items that I heard and make sure that we are capturing the right things for the final draft that's going to come to you at your next meeting. Is that okay? Yes. So the two things that Rob just went over, I won't reiterate. For the community resilience header, we want to change it to public safety and move it to the top left hand corner of the document. Okay.

5:13:52 For risk management, the second bullet under the current community resilience header, we wanted to, instead of just fire safety, address fire and other natural disasters. There was consensus on that item. Yes. Correct. Facility utilization, which is the third bullet point under that same section.

5:14:16 I heard a few things. What I noted was change it to facility optimization and specifically reference medevac and wildfire threat under that bullet point. Is that what we had consensus on? That's correct. That's what I have written down. Okay. Okay. Great. The next one is the last bullet point on the left-hand side, currently public lands. We're going to break that into two bullet points.

5:14:44 John came up with some specific language that everyone agreed on that I didn't write down, but it's in the video, so we will go back and reference that. And there was discussion about changing the heading to sustainable outdoor recreation. Maybe since we're breaking it into two bullet points, that'll be the heading of one of the bullet points. I don't think there's any discussion about changing recreation amenities and programs. I don't think there's any... The public land heading. No, the sub-bullet. The public lands heading. Yeah.

5:15:12 Sustainable Outdoor Recreation. Okay. Okay, we have that captured. Community connectivity, the second bullet point under recreation, change augment to enhance. Correct. Okay. For partnerships, the second bullet point under community investments, my note was to take out specific references and keep partnerships broad. Leverage.

5:15:39 And then leveraging partnerships to create opportunities and enhance services. I feel like didn't we say something about community foundations? Was that going to be a separate thing or just two sentences under that? I thought we were doing foundations at the time. I'm so concerned about that, but just I thought that was still there as a separate tag. I thought we had made that a separate bullet that addressed exploring community foundations because it's something we're not currently doing. Okay.

5:16:08 Got it. Foundations is a separate bullet. Yes. Under community engagement, which is the first bullet point under municipal services, we are going to break that out into two bullet points. One will remain kind of the first part of this, which is specifically focused on Spanish language offerings. And then outreach to the Latino community, in addition to including accessibility and inclusivity, would be a separate bullet.

5:16:38 Did I capture that correctly? I had that differently. What Councilmember Truax said was increased community engagement and outreach efforts, including a focus on language accessible to the entire community. And then the second one was increased Latino community engagement. Did I get that right? Yeah, I think we have one other word different, but that's not just. You can change the word. I don't remember what the word is. Okay.

5:17:08 It's recorded. Okay. Thank you. And then the last item that I had was the community development bullet that we just discussed. Move that to community investment header and change, and I said change it to general permitting instead of development projects and combine it with the beautification efforts bullet. Is that correct? Yes. That's what we, yes, you are correct. Great. Thank you. That's all I have. Thank you so much.

5:17:39 And everything else we said before. So that was it. This does not require a vote. It was a discussion. So thank you everyone for hanging in there. But I think this is super important and I'm grateful because it looks like, let's see some nods. One thing that may be helpful is if, you know, when you guys get a draft circulated as soon as it's ready, that will be just a good proactive measure. So when we come in here next week, it's, you know.

5:18:09 In two weeks. Or two weeks. I'll be in the country in two weeks. I don't know what that means. I will not. She knows what that means. I will not. I will be. This will be your debut. There you go. There you go. I tried to text you that earlier, but my phone didn't send it. I appreciate that effort. That was a lot of heavy lifting to get to that process. I think this is one of the most important things we do because then when the.

5:18:36 Team goes to do the budgeting. It's much clearer, so I'm grateful for everyone for hanging with us. Okay, so that was 11.3. 11.4, 2025 Youth Sports Funding Award. Hello, Mr. Brown. Thank you again. I feel like we should have actually finished on that last one. That was a really good item, but hey, this is a really good feel-good award before you. I'm not going to really get into a lot of detail. I think the staff report kind of covered it.

5:19:05 Happy to answer any questions, but do want to just acknowledge the Council's support of our youth sports funding organizations in town on behalf of all of these groups that deliver really important services that we don't, right? So they really augment or enhance a lot of our services that I think go a long way to our programs and services. So with that, it's a pretty straightforward process. It's never easy.

5:19:34 We've experienced this. The commission and staff dig in and put a lot of effort into kind of the methodology that's kind of included in that packet. It's never easy. It's always a little bit subjective as well as objective. I think they do a great job. The recommendations before you kind of changed a little bit with some organisations not applying for funding again from previous years. So there was a little additional money that went to those organisations, which will just be kind of a one year.

5:20:04 And then we've kept some money aside for those organizations that may acquire or reacquire their non-profit status to be able to kind of function again this year as well. So with that, I'm just going to stop there and happy to answer any questions and just look for a recommendation to approve the award made by the Parks and Recreation Commission on February 4th. And, Madam Mayor, I've got a point forward to a question for Andy. Only because I do stand on the Disabled Sports Board, I have no financial interest, but I want to make sure I...

5:20:34 I'm okay. No conflict here, even perceptually-wise. What's the nature of your involvement? I'm on the board for Disabled Supports, and they're a recommended party here. You don't get any compensation? I get no compensation. But you're on the board. Yep, I'm on the board. Please sit this one out. If you gave me five or ten minutes, I could figure this out. But if you want to take a vote right now, please sit this one out. Yep. Do you want me to have a conversation? I don't know that there's going to be a discussion. Okay.

5:21:03 Are you taking, yeah, wait, are there any questions? No. Any public comment? Any public comment online? No. Any discussion? Then, if. I move that we award town funds to eight local youth sports organizations. Second. All right, we have a motion and a second. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Yes. Councilmember Sauser. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice. Yes. Mayor Bubzer. Yes. All right.

5:21:34 Thank you. So, we are on to Councilmember Reports. Who would like to begin? I'll go first. I have nothing to report. Okay. Okay. I attended the LTC meeting where somehow a Mammoth representative got voted in as the new chair. I'm sorry. Is that you, Bill? Yeah. Oh, sorry, Bill.

5:22:01 We did hear something about possible issues with the reservation system due to a lack of personnel with Yosemite. More to come on that later. I also missed an estimating due to other obligations. Okay. Who's next? I'll go next. And there was also LTC meeting, so Bill already covered that. But just trying to think about a phrase in the right way. I attended last night, bingo.

5:22:32 Appreciation for the Mammoth Ski Patrol alumni. A lot of things have been happening with that. Some people seriously hurt and just want to make sure we as a community support those individuals once somebody is in time of need that we're there as a community to support each other. And it was a great evening and I don't know what the final total was. My guess was $12,000 was raised last night. So just a great evening. Councilmember Wentworth.

5:22:59 Hi, good evening. I'd like to start with a really nice article in the SF Gate, the San Francisco Gate, about ESTA and about our public transportation. Do you all see that? Yep. Great article, again, but it just underlines that there's this focus starting to go on Mammoth Lakes as the place to go. Tahoe and Truckee is a disaster. Oh, you should check this Mammoth Lake, you know, Mammoth Lakes place out. But it's about ESTA, public transit, free public transit.

5:23:28 How it works and how good it is. So that was, that was a great thing. Yesterday, I was in a day-long Mammoth Lakes Tourism, day-long strategic planning session. Pat gave sort of an update on that. We did a political, economic, sociological, technological, legal, and environmental exercise, which was very interesting. Very well facilitated, very well done. I provided kind of a setup comment to my fellow council members about this basic understanding that our economy is about outdoor recreation.

5:23:57 That's what drives it. And a key thing coming out of this strategic work with Mammoth Lake Tourism is the absolute need for MLT, its board, and us as the town to be in lockstep. They're promoting, doing what they do. The thing that they are driving people to is within our purview. That's sustainable outdoor recreation. If anybody has authority over that in the town, it's us. The Forest Service, when there used to be a Forest Service,

5:24:26 Made it very clear that they wanted to deal with the town and its authorities. So that's something that we really need to focus on. The TBID projects that are in the works, we need to do a lot of work on that. We really need to get joined at the hip, for better or worse, but we need to be joined at the hip with that group. So that was interesting. A couple things from the MOT board meeting today.

5:24:50 There was some comments about the remittance program that's gone in place of Measure L, but there's some typos in the documents, but I guess they got that all figured out. You heard about the changing of the date of the MOT monthly meetings. Hayes gave a great update on the projects that was, you know, welcomed, and thank you for your comments on the TBID projects. But again, these are things that we need. That's the connective tissue that's going to get all of us working together and get us on the same page, which is really important.

5:25:19 There's a request from a gentleman for some additional marketing money for Bluza Palooza. And the, as Pat mentioned, they'll be back on the 19th. MOT will to give an update on their strategic plan. We'll see it in advance. Air service. Air service is going quite well. Air service in Bishop is stabilizing. There's three years worth of data that shows this is working.

5:25:44 This is going to be something for all of us to build from and to build on. And I look forward to them giving you all an update on what's going on with that. They've reached that 10,000 employments number at Bishop, which means that opens up the dollars coming out of the FAA. So things are going very well with that. Important thing for us to keep an eye on. The Measure L reporting.

5:26:05 The reporting that MLT does with the TOT numbers, Measure L, the collection started in January, so the charts that we see are going to get all kind of cattywampus for a little bit, but that's because the Measure L increase to TOT is going to be included in there. On styrofoam, it was pointed out that there are restaurants in this town, even though styrofoam use is illegal, that are still using it.

5:26:30 The question was, how is that being enforced and how are we going to, what are we going to do about that? So I sort of bring that to our attention. We're not, just because we, you know, someone passes a law or says you can't do that anymore, it's still happening. And the people who are complying, we're not happy about that. And we're going to have challenges because, hey, we're in California, so we're okay. But the rest of the USA is not.

5:26:59 Not looking so good to our friends and neighbors around the globe. That may affect visitation. That's another thing that may be complicating visitation as we go forward. So that's it, Madam Mayor. Thank you. All right. So I guess I am... Everyone went, right? And Mayor Pro Tem did not have anything to report. So I did attend the ESTA meeting, and I am looking very quickly because the employee of the quarter for ESTA...

5:27:28 Is one of our local Mammoth people. And I even saw him. Oh, yes, Tom Hawkrain. And we presented him with his plaque. And then I got to ride up to the mountain with him on the red line. And he showed me that he was probably wearing his shirt. It was just such a feel-good thing. You know, we should always remember to appreciate ESTA as much as possible.

5:27:55 I, too, attended the bingo for the Mammoth Mountain Ski Patrol alumni, and I wanted to add that Volunteer Eastern Sierra is an amazing organization, and they have bingo every month. It's super fun, and they pick such worthwhile causes, and it's just such an amazing community builder, so I just want to give them a shout-out because they are always, no matter what kind of things our community is going through, they're always there for us.

5:28:24 Next, I went to the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance meeting last Thursday. That is a really remarkable group that is spearheaded by the Whitebark Institute, but entities from across the Eastern Sierra, both fire, Cal Fire, one of the entities is from San Bernardino, but it's a Cal Fire person who leads.

5:28:51 Some crews that do things in Southern Inyo County, for example, just remarkable, all the work that's happening, and I just want to highlight that we are participating in that because it's so essential to our collective future. Several of us attended the Vons ribbon cutting today. It was delightful, and it's just really nice to show our Vons team how much we appreciate them, and, you know,

5:29:17 They thought that their project took quite a long time to complete, but it was record for us because they didn't realize that snow would be so challenging, but it was just a delightful way to all come together as a community.

5:29:32 Finally, I will be holding my first office hours. I've been meaning to do it for quite a while. So tomorrow at Stellar Brew from 9 to 10, any member of the community who would like to come and chat, I will be sitting in the corner from 9 to 10. I'll be doing that.

5:29:49 Every Thursday, unless I'm out of town, and I'll post my schedule at the beginning of every month because I'm going to rotate coffee shops to spread the love. So come and join me and tell me what's on your mind, and I will be all ears. And with that, we will... Madam Mayor, just one...

5:30:09 Question of the Town Attorney. So the federal government, the executive branch, has just issued an executive order to ensure lawful governance in implementing the President's Department of Government Efficiency deregulatory initiative, which appears to ask every agency in the federal government to analyze and get rid of all the regulations that have been imposed. That might be something we might want to look at. I'll take a look. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Well, how about that? The Full Employment Act for Town Attorneys.

5:30:39 Okay, so we will be moving into closed session. And do I have to read the whole thing? Okay, so 13.1, moving into closed session, pursuant to government code section 54957.6A, we're having a conference with labor negotiators.

5:31:00 And the council will meet with its representatives, Town Manager, Rob Patterson, Police Chief, Dan Casabian, and HR Manager, the patient, Amanda Pelham, with respect to the following employee organizations, Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association and the Mammoth Lakes Sergeants Association. One clarification to that, it says in error that Chief Dan Casabian will be involved in this. He will not. Okay. Thank you for the correction. For those who are leaving, good night.