TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2022

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 11:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

4 findings

Transcript

153 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:04 Okay, this is Greg Eckert. Can you hear me? Yes, Greg. Thanks for joining. We can hear you. Good morning. Thank you, everyone, for coming to the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for December 13th. And at this time, I would like to call to order. Jamie, can we get a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Present.

1:52 Commissioner Kennedy is absent. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. And Chair Vanderhurst is absent. Thank you. At this time, we'll do the Pledge of Allegiance, and I just want to make note that Commissioner Kennedy just arrived. Paul, would you lead us in Pledge of Allegiance, please? Sure. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

2:19 Thank you. At this time, I'd like to open it up for public comments. This is for any public comments for items that are not on the agenda. Is there any public comment? Okay. I see on Zoom land we have Jenna Carter.

2:50 Thank you very much, Jenna Carter, Town of Mammoth Lakes Code Compliance. I just wanted to give you all a quick code compliance update. Since I was here last month, I'll do a quick screen share to show you my statistics. You should be now seeing a pie chart on the screen. Half the cases I'm working on are unpermitted construction.

3:12 I've been issuing a lot of stop work notices. This time of year, it's a lot of decks, a lot of re-roofs, some window changeouts, which all do require permits, and so we're following up on those. Then you can see trash, the bears are out, so the trash cans are still getting into. Please latch to your guys' dumpsters and make sure the trash is all secured. We're trying to get those bears to hibernate now, and this just kind of gives you an idea of the split of the rest of the cases. They're pretty even there. Last meeting.

3:41 I was asked to bring an update about Mammoth Creek Inn, and I just wanted to let the group know I have since mailed out a letter formally requesting an update from that project, asking when the windows will be installed, asking when the purple will be covered up with siding, and asking when the project will be completed if they do still intend to meet the March deadline. I have not received a response yet, so I'm sorry to not have any answers for you yet.

4:07 I expect if they don't receive a response in the next three days, so by the end of this week, I will continue formal code compliance, and we're lined up, we've warned them at Mammoth Creek Inn that if they continue and don't finish the project in March, that there's a possibility of receivership where the town would take over the project. If anyone has any questions, I'm available. Thank you. Are there any questions from the commissioners? Okay. Thank you, Jenna.

4:40 Jamie, are there any other public comments in Zoom? Okay. Vice Chair Burroughs, we do have Andy Morris, our city attorney, on Zoom, and I'd like to ask him to unmute and provide a comment at this time about the AB 361. Andy, are you there? I am. Sorry, my camera does not appear to be working, but I can hear you, and hopefully you can hear me. We can hear you. Okay.

5:07 All right. So Sandra asked me to give you a little overview of how the Brown Act requirements about teleconferencing are changing starting in January. And I'll try to keep this brief, but the way the law is set up is a little bit complicated, so stick with me. So for a long time, long time, decades, the Brown Act has had teleconferencing provisions that allow members of a legislative body like the PEDC to conference in.

5:37 But there was some kind of goofy things that went with it. You had to post an agenda that lists all the teleconference locations. You had to physically post an agenda at each of those locations. And you had to let members of the public go to each of those locations and participate in the meeting from there. So in the past, I've had council members in other cities that were in the hospital and wanted to participate. So in theory, members of the public could go perch on the end of their bed and, you know,

6:06 Join along in the meeting with them. Then when COVID hit, the governor issued an executive order that suspended all that, but instead you could just do teleconferencing without all the hoops to jump through. But the legislature recognized that that was kind of a blunt and hasty solution. So then we got AB 361, which is what we've been operating under ever since it was adopted in late 2021. AB 361 says you can do teleconferencing.

6:36 In the way that we've been doing it. But there's some caveats to that. It has to be during a declared emergency. And you have to, every 30 days, you have to make findings again that there's still an emergency. And so it's not great. And so what the legislature did late last year was they adopted AB 2449, which has yet another way now to teleconference remotely.

7:03 And I should mention that because the state of emergency that we've been operating under for a lot of contexts about COVID is scheduled to be probably rescinded early next year, the AB 361 procedures are not going to be available anymore once the state of emergency is rescinded. So now we've got AB 2449. And it's kind of a complicated bit of law, some tricky drafting.

7:29 It's been a little bit confusingly reported. It does not get rid of the old, original Brown Act teleconferencing provisions. So if you're willing to say exactly where you're going to be and you're willing to let members of the public come and sit on your hospital bed or be in your cruise ship cabin, then you can still use that old Brown Act teleconferencing provision. But what 2449 does is it says,

7:59 That in a limited way, you can, individual members can teleconference without doing those things, without having people on your hospital bed or in your cruise ship cabin, but there are limits on how often you can do it. So the way they have this set up, there's a couple different ways you can do it. You can have a member of the legislative body that has what the law says is just cause to participate remotely, which the law says is something like a childcare situation, a contagious illness,

8:29 Or you're out of town on official business, like if you go to a league conference, you can do it that way. You have to explain in public on the record what your just cause is, you know, why you're going to participate remotely, and you can't use it more than twice in a calendar year. The other way that 2449 says you can participate remotely is under emergency circumstances, which again is a little bit vague, and you have to explain them on the record in public.

8:58 Every time. And you have to ask the permission of the rest of the body to be able to participate remotely because of emergency circumstances. The law specifically says it's a new request for every meeting. And it's also intended not to be used all that much. So what the law says is you, although it's not limited to twice a year, like the just cause participation is, the law says that the combination of just cause remote participation

9:27 And emergency circumstances, remote participation, can't be used for more than three consecutive months. So if you only meet once a month, you wouldn't be able to do it for four meetings in a row, only three. And you can't use it for more than 20% of your regular meetings in a calendar year. Or if you regularly meet less than 10 times a year, you can't use it more than twice a year.

9:53 That's kind of where we are. I mean, if you have somebody that needs to participate remotely pretty regularly, then you can do a little bit of that with the new 2449 provisions, but you might have to use the old school, tell all the members of the public what your address is and let them into your living room way of doing teleconferencing as well, because that one is still available and there are no limits on how often you can use that.

10:21 So that's where we are. It's a little complicated, a little confusing, but there are still options available for people that need to teleconference for whatever reason. All right. Thank you, Andy. Are there any questions from commissioners? Jamie, do you see any hands up? Jessica? All right. Thank you for that. You're welcome. Any other public comments?

10:53 Okay, seeing none, I will close the public comment portion and move on to item number four on our agenda, presentation, and this is 4.1, presentation of the five-year capital improvement plan, and I believe Hayes is going to present this? Yes, I am. There we go. All right, so, Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works, we're kicking off CIP season.

11:34 Because summer is coming. It's going to be here before you know it. And so we're starting to plan for our upcoming construction season. And part of our ongoing process is to introduce and provide an opportunity to the various commissions to make recommendations on projects and programs going into the next season.

12:00 So I'll kind of walk through, and this is nothing new. You guys have seen this a couple times now, and it may seem somewhat well rehearsed. But it's an important process that we're kicking off to focus and direct our funding sources into our infrastructure projects and programs. I'm going to quickly walk through just a couple of these slides, just some of these highlights, just as a reminder.

12:28 The five-year CIP is for development, maintenance, and improvement, and acquisition of infrastructure projects. These are non-reoccurring projects with a long service life. Expenditures are beyond the scope of our normal operating and maintenance expenditures, and we do not include vehicles, technology, software, emergency-type stopgap work that lives in other budgets.

12:54 The key point here is the CIP does not appropriate funds. This is a short to mid-range planning tool that identifies projects and coordinates financing and timing. So just because it is in the CIP doesn't mean it's real. It's not real until the town council provides the funding for the projects to move forward and authorizes the construction and so forth. We put projects in CIP categories to address a number of different needs, whether that's ADA, safety requirements.

13:24 It's maintenance for extending the useful life of our various infrastructure like mops and sidewalks. We use it to address deferred maintenance like in parks or the airport or other town facilities. Trying to enhance our mandated and core services from everything from communication to pedestrian improvements, transit and so forth. We use it to expand and improve our amenities such as the CRC and the MAC.

13:52 And to identify community needs and try to meet the council's strategic priorities like housing. Process and schedule. So we're right at number one. I did a similar presentation to the Recreation Commission a few weeks ago, letting them know that we're kicking off this process and we're looking for input. I'll be looking for consensus input. It needs to be the group that makes a recommendation.

14:21 We'll take those recommendations and tie it into a draft CIP document. We'll try to align that with the Town Council's strategic priorities and some of our additional needs and things that have popped up since we adopted this in July. Over the late winter, early spring, we'll review again with the Council Commissions. We'll bring back any changes that have been identified.

14:47 May, June, as part of the budget process, we'll appropriate funding to the projects, and then we'll come back to you once we have a draft, because the Planning Commission needs to adopt a resolution that the CIP is consistent with town policies and procedures, and then we'll bring it back to town council for adoption. So that will happen in July. So it takes almost nine months to work for this process. So it feels like I'm...

15:18 Always working on this, because we just finished it. But a lot of good has come out of this process. And we continue to meet regularly on it. We bring this forward to Town Council at pretty much every adjustment. We're doing well on TOT, and so we'll take that opportunity for, or provide the opportunity for Town Council to appropriate that funding to the priority projects they've identified in the CIP. Because as we've discussed previously,

15:49 You know, 22, 23 season is pretty well baked, but when you start looking into like 24, there's a lot of gaps. And so they'll use the, you know, opportunity to appropriate, you know, excess TOT or other grant sources to projects in those outer years or to add or remove projects as necessary. I provided all of the CIP tables in the packet. I am not going to walk through them in a lot of detail. You are welcome to stop me and ask questions about

16:20 Any of the projects, these are some pretty lengthy lists of things we have going on. I think there's somewhere around $130 or $140 million worth of infrastructure the town is either directly responsible for or indirectly responsible for. I don't even think I included Red's Meadow, which I just found out is going to hopefully be approved to the tune of $30 million in the next couple of weeks.

16:49 But some of the key highlights, some of the things we're continuing to work on, the CRC is still an active project. We're still working on our HSIP projects. We're trying to get that out to bed. We believe we can work for winter. That's our pedestrian beacons on Main Street. The parcel is still moving forward. Interior spaces are still being built out. But the rest of our projects are pretty much under winter suspension. Laurel Mountain.

17:17 Chaparral Road, some of our other parks and rec improvements are all under winter suspension. Going into 2022-23, the list doesn't get any shorter. We're in the process of designing and developing our plans and specifications to bid out these projects here over the next few months moving into summer. Some of the key highlights, we're going to be kicking off the child care facility, hopefully tipping that up this summer.

17:49 We're going to build out the dog park and the parking areas, multimodal parking areas that support that. We're continuing to work on our landscaping projects. We did bid those to the tune of three quarters of a million dollars. Didn't get any bids, but we're still working with contractors trying to negotiate a deal to get that work done. And we are looking at bidding phase two of the Main Street improvements. And yeah, and continuing on our multimodal stuff.

18:21 Hey, Hayes. Yeah, go ahead. What is Creative Housing Initiative? How does that differ from a partial phase two? Well, it's a completely different project? Yeah, it's actually a bucket of money that allows the town and Nolan, more specifically, to be nimble and take advantage of opportunities, whether that is

18:48 Buying units or buying land. It's just money that's been set aside for housing purposes, but it's not really defined. Got it. Thank you. Any other questions on what I've covered so far? I know two pretty large tables. 22-23, as you can see, a lot of general fund has been put towards

19:19 Our projects, and like I said, that is that excess TOT that we see appropriated during the budget process and quarterly adjustments. The only uncommitted funding gap is for a pedestrian project, and we're negotiating with the private party on that, so that's still ongoing, but the rest of the projects are fully funded and moving forward through the 23 season. Beyond that, again, you're going to see going 23, 24, so really these are projects almost a year and a half out.

19:49 Setting aside money, and we're in the development of plans and specifications for the new Civic Center and Town Hall. We're working in our partnership with the MAC. They're looking at bringing their first phase to development this year, but that is a private project. The town will take on the public side of that, which is really looking at 24. And then trying to gear up for a larger streets and MUP rehabilitation project, similar to what we did.

20:18 Last season. Stop here. Is there any questions on kind of what we got going on future years? Okay. As you can see, the amount of money uncommitted is quite large. This is closing. We'll see this close over this year, moving into the budget cycle. This will narrow. Probably by July 23, 24, we'll be probably completely baked, and most of the projects will be fully funded. Otherwise, we'll be pushing them into further years.

20:51 Just a reminder, when we start talking about even beyond 24, 25, two and a half years out, these are longer-term goals. These projects are less developed. Funding most likely does not exist, and they're kind of placeholders, but they represent our immediate goals and aspirations. We'll be working to allocate these funds.

21:17 Some of these projects may get moved to longer-term CIP. We do have kind of a 20-year vision, but depending on the council's strategic priorities and the needs of the community will kind of determine whether or not they live in that two-and-a-half to three-year vision or if they move further out. This document is dynamic and is regularly changed to meet the needs of the community and the will of the council. So just kind of wrap it up. The town is making

21:49 Huge investments in housing, recreation, child care. As always, we are looking to take advantage of every color of money we can get our hands on. We meet monthly with our consultants on grant opportunities and apply for anything that is reasonable and can help to meet our needs. I do want to mention that staff capacity is a concern.

22:15 So that is the extent of...

22:45 My presentation. What I'm hoping to get out of the commission today is any consensus type projects, anything you would want us to carry forward in our future conversations with town council. A number of things that were brought up, and this was in the staff report or the action sheet. There were a couple items that were identified by the commission that were carried forward out of the last year. Some high priority stuff like child care.

23:15 We're shepherded and have manifested in real projects. So we do take your comments seriously and we do appreciate them. With that, I'll stop rambling and invite you to discuss. Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate that report. I'm going to open it up to the commissioners for questions or comments. Commissioner Kennedy, do you have any? I don't. Thank you. Thanks, Hayes. Thank you. Any recommendations for Hayes on what priorities?

23:47 No, I think you captured it well. I don't see anything standing out as missing in my end. Thanks. Thank you. Commissioner Chang. Thanks, Chair. Two questions. First one is the child care programs that you guys are focusing on, the town is focusing on. Is that primarily going to be located as part of the parcel development or will that be distributed throughout town?

24:20 So we have two projects identified. We have the project at the parcel that is built into that development. And then we have another project in a partnership with Mammoth Lakes Foundation. We are using some of their vacant land to relocate a number of portables that are going to be available to the town to use as part of the

24:49 Modernization of the high school. We are looking to repurpose six of those units on the site right next to the Edison Theater to provide additional childcare facility. We haven't really gotten to the details on how that will be operated or managed. The town is really not in that business, but we are in the infrastructure business and believe we can capitalize on the opportunity to get those structures and create an opportunity site for the community.

25:18 So those are the two projects that we're working on. So the town is still trying to figure out, you know, how the programming on the operating side, how that's going to work, whether they're going to do it themselves or find a third party as a kind of a partnership program? Is that what they're thinking? Yeah, I think that's really the goal is to partner with like Mammoth.

25:48 Mono County Office of Education or potentially a third party under contract to manage the facility. It's not something the town is really, we don't really have the resources to do that. I think our goal here is really just to provide the facilities and the opportunity with the resources that we have. And the resources, the staffing resources you're talking about.

26:13 Is it primarily with your department or planning department or is it recreational department or is it all of the above? There's definitely a lot of parties involved with the development of these projects. I think the planning department has been really working to negotiate a lot of the work on the parcel. I believe the assistant to the town manager has been working on some of the negotiations on who's going to operate.

26:41 The engineering staff is really working to develop and build the infrastructure. So there's a lot of parties involved with trying to bring this forward and provide these opportunity sites. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Eckert? Yeah, Hayes, on the portables that are going to be retrofeited or harvested or whatever, I know some private...

27:13 Use has been made of those. At least the laundry took one or two of those buildings. I would just like to see that when it does come time to relocate and, you know, do the infrastructure on them, you know, people have already done them. It's kind of like peeling an onion doing that kind of work. And that maybe we could consult with people who have already done it to see what pitfalls they found so we might avoid them.

27:41 Thank you for that comment. I personally have discussed that project that repurposed those portables. So that's a great comment and something we have done and got a lot of great information. I will add our architects, AP architects, actually built the spa building and do a lot of work in portables. They also worked on the Cerro Coso College, so they have a lot of experience in this area and a lot of experience working with portables.

28:11 Commissioner Eckert is 100% correct. These things are like peeling an onion. Once you get into them, you're going to find surprises, and we have baked in significant contingencies to deal with that, because we do expect buildings of that vintage to have issues, but the price is right, so it's worth it to us. All right. Thank you. Anything else, Commissioner Eckert? No, that was it. Okay. Thank you. We do have a couple questions for you.

28:42 I recognize, as you mentioned, that this involves a lot of staff hours, and I know that the parcel is taking up an enormous amount of your time. I appreciate all that you do. Is there any discussion about perhaps adding another position to support your team? We have discussed it, and at this time, we don't believe that is the best option.

29:09 We like to keep the staffing what I call recession-proof. We would hate to be in a position to see the economy take a downturn. We've been through this before and would hate to be in that position again. We have, myself and the engineering manager, Amy, we've expanded our capabilities by hiring contract services. We have five engineering firms with pretty deep benches for a variety of different services.

29:38 Thank you. My other question, or I'd like to give you a list of my priorities. I think that housing,

30:09 Does need to continue to be a priority. And then childcare, like you mentioned, is also priority. People are having a hard time. I know the hospital just has an employee daycare that's really helped significantly, but I think overall our town is struggling with that. And for my own personal and for other members of the community that I hear, that dog park moving forward is really important. I know that.

30:35 There's a lot of complaints about dogs at Shady Rest and whatnot, so I think that's a really important project going forward as well. And I'd like to see the MAC finally come to fruition at some point, so that would be really amazing. And then I have something else I wanted just to say. Thank you to Public Works for all your snow removal. You guys did an amazing job over the last storm and cleared our roads in a timely manner.

31:02 And I especially have noted the bike pass, the multi-use pass behind the college and whatnot, that you guys have been keeping those clear. And that's just amazing to be able to allow our community to still get out there and walk safely and enjoy our community. So thank you guys for all your work on that. Thank you. I'll make sure that the team receives those comments. Okay, thank you. Any public comment on this topic? Okay.

31:33 Any other comments from commissioners? Okay. Then we will close this topic and we will move on to item 4, 4.2, housing now presentation. And Nolan, we're going to tag team the presentation. So Nolan and I have been kind of going around town to different service groups, different organizations.

32:01 on our kind of hat we're calling a housing roadshow so kind of telling everybody about what the housing now program is what we're doing because you know we push a lot of information out through community updates through various other ways but we still hear from community members that they don't know what's going on with housing as an example yesterday I overheard someone talking about the parcel and talking about trying to contact a realtor to buy units in the parcel

32:29 It's all rental. So we're just trying to get out and just get to as many groups as we can. So bringing this to the commission, we've gone to the Board of Realtors, the Fire District Board, Lions Club, Rotary, probably one other that I'm forgetting. But our goal is to get to kind of all the service groups, all the different organizations over the next couple months. So with that, I don't remember. So I'll hand it over to Nolan and he can start.

32:57 Sure, so when we're talking about the program, this initial slide is really just kind of a precursor to the overall affordable housing program, really, in that every program, every project uses area median income as the baseline for deciding who gets to live there, what funding, what requirements are triggered, everything else. Area median income is defined as the median income for a region.

33:25 So our region is based on Mono County as a whole. And then that income, all the other percentages are based on a household size of four is defined as the median income household size. And so our median income here is $81,200 for a household of four. From there, all the different categories break out based on percentages, categories from extremely low, very low and low, then all the way up to moderate.

33:55 You also hear terms above moderate, missing middle, a variety of terms that go into that. So just when we're talking about programs as well, we have on the bottom what we call our housing bridge. It kind of shows the spectrum of programs from low on the left and the orange up to upper incomes on the right and the red. So in the orange is typically going to be your housing programs and projects that are supported by state and federal grant funds.

34:22 Also, that orange is usually 80% AMI and below, so 80% of the area median income is the kind of maximum qualifying amount to live in those projects. As you get in the middle, that's your turquoise. Here we call it the moderate or upper middle incomes. This category is critical because this group cannot afford market rate both on ownership and rental, but they're also not supported by state and federal programs.

34:50 Grant dollars. So this is really where local funds, town general fund and other sources can step in to assist those in those middle income categories. Then the far right you have your upper incomes. It's assumed that those in that category can afford market rate both on ownership and rental. So we'll talk a little bit about the parcel project. I think the commission is really familiar with the project.

35:20 Up to 450 affordable units. The town purchased the property, the 25-acre property, in 2018. And target income levels for this project are 80% and below. So you all reviewed both Phase 1 and Phase 2, but just a refresher, Phase 1 is 81 units, 80 affordable units, one manager's unit. A variety of different unit types, so studio, one, two, three bedroom units throughout the project.

35:50 And it is a $50 million project with both state and local funds, so the town put money into it, but a majority of the project is funded through state funding. We're still looking at occupancy next fall, and the project will include a park and a child care facility. So this is the child care facility that Commissioner Chang was referring to, which will have up to 34 children there, including infants, toddlers, and preschool-aged children.

36:19 Phase 2 is 148 units, same kind of unit composition with ranging from studio to three bedroom units. This is a $95 million project that will include both state and local funds. We have been applying for low-income housing tax credit funding, which is a federal program, and we found out last month that we didn't get awarded the first round.

36:47 We, it's really, I think you can apply three times a year, and so we're just going to apply again in February, and that's the same thing we did for phase one. We applied, I think, three times. We were, you know, didn't receive the funding three times, and then we were able to access some new funding from the state of California called the California Housing Accelerator Funding. It was, it was just for projects like ours that hadn't gotten the LIHTC funding but was shovel ready.

37:14 So, and then, you know, we don't really have a construction timeline until we get the LIHTC funding, so. Next slide. So just some photos of the project, you know, here on the left-hand side you see the elevations that were included as part of the approval, and on the right-hand side, you know, the project being stacked. And they completed modular stacking in late, mid-

37:44 Mid to late November. There was 100 modules and it took them, you know, less than a month to stack all those. In fact, they stacked the smaller building, I think, in just like three days. So it's a really fast process once they get going on it. So I was able to go to Boise in May to visit the modular factory. So all of the modules are, you know, pre-built, pre-inspected.

38:11 And include, you know, countertops, cabinets, all of the appliances, everything's in those when they leave the factory. They basically seal them up and then ship them here and then unwrap them on the site. So it's a very efficient process and it's, you know, nice that they're just kind of completely done. So you can see me on the lower right-hand corner standing in one of the...

38:36 Modules, and it was just really kind of moving to be able to be there and to put my hands on those countertops and to like know that one of our community members is going to be living in that unit at some point. So it was really a really great experience. And Amy also went with me and had a lot. We learned a lot on those tours. So just some more photos of the modules. You can see that...

39:00 The refrigerators are all there. Everything works. And these are after they have been stacked here in Mammoth Lakes. These photos came from inside the building. And then just some more photos of the process. The upper left-hand corner is a photo of one of the modules coming down Tavern Road into the site. And then, you know, you can see the modules on the lower level already all stacked. And the upper right-hand corner is a picture of the crane.

39:30 An action shot of the crane dropping the module onto the building. Okay, so we have a time-lapse photo. It's from mid-October to mid-November. So go ahead and push play. And we have a time-lapse camera out there. And so we're, it's pretty, pretty interesting to be able to see the building change so much. I'll bring back another time-lapse showing, you know, kind of the tail end of it at one of your future meetings. But this is the,

40:01 The time when they really started finishing, finishing the, they started stacking, you can see at the back they're stacking all of the units. We had our snow, which slowed down the stacking process, but it's a really kind of compelling story to see how fast everything went. See there they go all stacked, and that's it. Yeah, it just starts replaying over and over again, if you don't stop it. So just a quick summary on the phase two called the Kingfisher, again 148 units.

40:42 219 parking spaces with a central open space, a central green for that project. And then the funding, as I mentioned, most of the funding is coming from grant funding. So you can see here we're leveraging local dollars, one to five. So for every dollar that we put in locally, we're getting five dollars from other sources. So the town is funded about 17%, almost 18% of the project, with the majority of the funding from the California Housing Accelerator, a big chunk.

41:11 There, and the infill infrastructure grant was also a really big chunk too, and that's the, the infill infrastructure grant is for the entire project, all of the phases, so it's a little bit, a little bit confusing, but you can see on the right-hand side all of the, all of the different funding sources that have gone in, and so, you know, a little bit over 77 million dollars going into this project at this point. Okay.

41:37 So transitioning away from the parcel to start talking about some of the other projects we have going as well. The first one is what we're calling our small site development. This is somewhat of a model that we're diving into the development world and hoping to replicate on future sites as well. So the first site we're working on is a vacant site on Joaquin Road, 60 Joaquin Road. The town purchased the site in 2020.

42:05 I believe, late 2020. Then really dived into figuring out what we wanted to build on the site. We entered into or went through a design build process. So that's where we brought on a design build entity. They're responsible for the design as well as the construction. So the hope is that by doing it, that process, it's a more streamlined process to deliver a project without as many

42:33 Changes, you know, if you do design bid build, you have a lot of changes and not as much control once you get to the construction side. So this is a four-unit project. They're going to be ownership units, two duplex buildings. There's a $2.4 million bid award. We are actually meeting with the entity this afternoon to review their final kind of design package before they submit for their entitlement. So hopefully that will be coming before the commission in the next

43:03 few months for consideration on the design, the use permit, and the tentative map. Target income for these projects, we're targeting 150% AMI. It's on that bridge that's going to be in that turquoise, that's that area that's not supported by state and federal dollars. So that's really, as we said, where the local dollars can support these projects. It's critical for us to not bring in any grant dollars because we don't want to

43:29 Reduce that AMI target. We really want to be able to hit those middle income groups. Currently, the plan is still targeting occupancy in fall and fall of 2023. We will hopefully have a better understanding of that exact timeline once we get their design package submitted. Also, as we mentioned, this model is replicable, so we're continuing to look at other sites in the community to basically put these

43:57 These duplex models on because we will own the plans once we go through the process. That kind of aligns with Hayes' CIP piece where he said the creative housing bucket within the CIP. And this project will come to the commission for consideration for design review, I think? Design review, use permit for density bonus, and tentative map since it'll be a subdivision. Another piece of our program is what we call the bridge program. So this program essentially

44:28 We go out, we purchase market rate units. It's a partnership project with Mammoth Lakes Housing. We then reduce the price to an affordable price for households earning 120% of the area median income and working through MLH's wait list as well as through just the local MLS have been marketing these units for sale at that affordable price. They do require a deed restriction. So it requires the households be income eligible.

44:58 Work in the region and live in the unit full time. The subsidy so far is between $100,000 to $150,000 per unit. That was our target within the program. Funding for this program came from $1.4 million allocated by the town council in fiscal year 21-22. Our goal with that $1.4 million is to acquire 12 units. And every time we acquire and sell our unit,

45:28 That $1.4 million shrinks some because of the subsidy. But so far we've acquired five units. Three have been sold to eligible households and two are currently for sale. So there's a two-bedroom unit at La Vista Blanc and one-bedroom unit at Marine Corps currently for sale through Mammoth Lakes Housing. Also on the top, just to illustrate the need.

45:55 For the bridge program and the gap between market rate and what's considered affordable. On the top chart, you have the median condo prices from 2021 through, I think, June of 2022 for one, two and three bedroom condos. And then below that, you have the affordable price for three person households and two person households, 200% AMI, 150% AMI and 120% AMI.

46:24 As you can see, the affordable price is below the median price for all but the 200% three-person household. A few other pieces of our program, as we're placing more deed-restricted units in the community, and then in addition to all the existing deed-restricted units that Mammoth Lakes Housing monitors, as well as the ones the town monitors, we maintain a revolving loan fund of $600,000 to

46:56 Have ready for the opportunities to buy back deed restricted units should they come up. With the deed restriction, there's a timeline for how long the household can look for a qualified household before we run the risk of losing that deed restriction. So by having this dedicated funding, we can quickly act on those units to buy them back. And then we're not under that same timeline to find an eligible household.

47:22 Mark them, have them listed until we find that right household that fits with the unit. In addition to our $600,000, the county also has $300,000 dedicated to a revolving loan fund for use here in the town. Then the town has always had two housing units for a number of years, but we've recently expanded the number of employee housing units the town owns up to six units. So we have three studio units, one

47:53 One-bedroom unit and two two-bedroom units. These units are intended to be interim housing for town employees and outside agency employees. So we've housed Mono County staff, we've housed fire staff. We're, I believe, working with the Forest Service to house some of their staff. So it really opened up to other agencies as they reach out to say, hey, we have an employee who needs a six-month

48:18 Unit as they transition here into town or looking for housing, do you have anything available? So we've been really flexible with that to house other agencies as well. And our partnership projects, so these are projects, the first two are being managed, are Mammoth Lakes housing projects that the town is a partner in, both in funding and just overall management of the process to get them to completion. The first one is access apartments.

48:49 It's at 238 Sierra Manor Road. It's the old country glass building. They are in the process of converting them into 11 one-bedroom apartments. This project has been in the works for a number of years as they've looked to close the funding gap on it. The town has committed $1.5 million to the project. The town was successful in a $3 million CDBG grant. Mammoth Lakes Housing was successful in a $3.4 million home grant for the project.

49:18 So currently the project is fully funded. They are getting ready to release their construction bid in the next few weeks to then bring on a contractor in early 2023 with the hopes of starting construction in April on this project. And then the next one is the Home Key project.

49:41 Mammoth Lakes Housing was successful in acquiring the Innsbruck Lodge at 913 Forest Trail. So this is an existing hotel that's going to be converted to residential use. The plan is for 15 affordable units and one manager's unit. This project was successful through a grant that was awarded to the town of Mammoth Lakes Housing through the state's Home Key project. So the state awarded us $4.7 million for the project.

50:10 Then the town committed $1 million and Mono County committed $550,000. The project is currently, they're currently doing demo at the site. They've removed all the furniture and are doing demo and then they're working through the building permit process with the town right now to get the building permit. They have a contractor on board and once that permit's issued, they'll be moving right ahead with construction. The goal is for occupancy in

50:39 Summer of 2023, Summer to Fall of 2023. In both these projects, all the units will be deed restricted to 80% AMI and below, again, because of the funding sources require that lower AMI. And the last one on the screen is the Chamber of Commerce. It has a tenant-landlord matching program. So their goal is tenants and businesses are able to register with the Chamber. They do a background check on those tenants.

51:07 And then landlords who have a room, a house, a unit, an ADU, anything that they want to rent can also register with the chamber. And then the goal is to successfully match those tenants and landlords. It's beneficial to the landlords because the tenants have been vetted. They have a background check. They also have the employer confirming that they're locally employed. So I anticipate that it's a little less risky than just putting an ad out there looking.

51:36 As a landlord saying, hey, I have a room available this way, it's kind of, there's a vetting process. Do you have a question? Are those, can you go back to the, the Homekey and Access Apartments, those are both rentals only or is Homekey sale? They're rental only. Rental only, okay, thank you. The Homekey is really, it's a statewide program that was intended to rapidly address and respond to homelessness issues. Got it.

52:02 We worked with the state extensively to really define our homeless population as not your traditional homeless population that you see in major cities. Ours are more people sleeping in their cars, overcrowding in units, couch surfing, and also that our AMIs, even for that group, are higher than what you often see, say, in down south, where other areas that got home key are limited to 30% AMI and below.

52:28 We were able to get the state to allow us to go up to 80% AMI and below. Awesome. And that home key project, the Innsbruck Lodge, when are those studio units? Do you know? Studio and one-bedroom units. Awesome. Thank you. This last grant is just to really highlight how successful the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing have been in bringing a large amount of grant dollars to a rural region in the last...

52:58 Really, 18 months, we've brought in close to $75 million in grant awards. A large chunk of that is for the parcel, but also, as we indicated, funding for the Access Apartments Project and the Home Key Project. So we think this slide's, I mean, just to really highlight how successful the community, both the town and organizations have been in getting these funding dollars. And if you think about it, our population over the last, at the last census was like 7,200 people. So we're bringing in

53:27 In the last 18 months, more than $100,000 per person in this community. So then another piece of it that's not so much relying on funding coming from the town or us actually taking the project on, but just to highlight accessory dwelling units. So these are allowed in all zones that allow single-family or multifamily residences.

53:51 Also through a partnership with Mono County, we were able to get prescribed designs. So we have five designs available. They have two different kind of architectural styles, a rural mountain and a high desert. All five designs are engineered for mammoth snow loads and other building code requirements. And these are also have been fully plan checked and engineered. So these are ready to go.

54:20 Applicant has to bring in a site plan with how the building will fit on their site, but they do not have to bring in the architectural plans or go through the plan check process for that because it's already been approved. These are free for use to the public. They are available on our website. For some reason, my...

54:38 Appearance in my PowerPoint is off, but in the upper right-hand corner is a link to the pre-approved plans, and there's also a link to the accessory ADU code section within our zoning code. And also, we committed at the staff level for an expedited review of anyone coming in with the ADU using the prescribed designs. That's expedited on the building and the planning side to really get these through the process and under construction.

55:08 And just to note those links to our code, they are on our web, they are in the PowerPoint slide that was uploaded as a part of the packet, I'm not sure why they're not showing here, but they are available in the PowerPoint. The last slide, this was in your packet, but this was, the town puts out a did you know on a monthly basis to highlight various topics and put out information of what the town's up to. So this was the September did you know.

55:37 Really highlighting the housing programs, but I think the critical message is really in that initial line is that the town will have an additional 272 units of workforce housing in the next 12 to 24 months. So when you think about the kind of the needs assessment from 2017, identifying how many units need to be coming online the next 5 to 10 years, the constant message of we need housing, we need more housing.

56:08 I think that message puts out, it's pretty powerful sounding when we have 272 units coming online. Housing Now presentation. Any questions or... Hey, Chair, I heard someone talking, but it sounded like really far away. My mic's not on, sorry. My bad. I was just asking if you had any questions or comments for Nolan or Sandra. I do have a couple.

56:58 San Joaquin, you said that was $2.4 million total? The 60 Joaquin site, yes. Say that again? The 60 Joaquin site, you mean? Correct. Yes. Sorry, 60 Joaquin, not San Joaquin, sorry. Yes, the bid award for that is $2.4 million. Okay. And then you have funding for that, you said? That's fully funded, yes. Okay.

57:31 So that's for four units. So we're talking about what? It's about $600,000. So we're talking about $600,000 per unit on this project? To build them, yes. And then the sales price will be likely in the high fours, $480,000 to $490,000 based on that 150% AMI. So it comes out to about $150,000 subsidy assumed on that project per unit. And I'm assuming that's de-restricted.

58:09 Correct. It will be deed restricted to that AMI group. So it will require the household be income eligible at time of purchase and then work in the region and live in the unit full time to remain eligible to live in that unit. And parcel phase one, that's total of 77.8 million for 81 units. So we were talking about close to a million dollar per unit.

58:41 Phase one, I think, was 50 million. So, but the 77 million was showing kind of all of the different funding sources and some of those funding sources are spread across the entire project so that like infrastructure that will benefit all of the phases of the parcel, not just. Okay, so we're talking about part of that 77 million includes the horizontals construction.

59:11 for future phases. Yes. Okay. Got it. That's all I have for now. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Eckert, do you have any questions or comments? Yeah. On the Joaquin, the 2.4 million is construction cost, right? How much more was the acquisition in any infrastructure that goes in besides the construction cost?

59:40 So the infrastructure is within that $2.4 million, that's all part of the construction and the land purchase was $200,000. How many hundred? $200. So we got roughly $650 a unit going back out at $450,000. So it's about a $200,000 cost per unit. No, the sales price would be around $490,000 with that deed restricted price. So it's about $100,000.

1:00:14 50 to 160,000 per unit. Okay. Anything else, Commissioner Eckert? No, that's it. All right. Commissioner Kennedy? Thank you. I think this is incredible. Fantastic presentation. Thank you guys so much. I think it really captures what's going on, and I think that anyone who's out there thinking that the town's not doing anything on housing should maybe pay better attention. So, really exciting to see all this put together, and I think...

1:00:47 Like the others have mentioned, I was just calculating those like six to seven hundred thousand per unit. I think that's just the reality of creating affordable housing and I think we all, I know there's been a lot of talk in the community about wanting those to be cheaper and that's just not going to happen so I think that's fantastic that those are all working out and that we're dedicating the funds to doing that. I think the

1:01:11 Parcel units are beautiful. That window that you show, that picture, it's a really beautiful space and I think it's also really cool that we're doing this in a beautiful, functional way and not cheaping out on this affordable housing thing. So I appreciate the care and attention that we've put into that and you guys have put into that. And then my one other question, maybe because of you guys don't have enough going on, is this incredible?

1:01:38 Are other communities doing this to this extent? I know that this has been a conversation in mountain towns, but I just think this and that number Nolan mentioned, the 272 units, for the town to listen to what we need, provide it, and then be here, it just feels really incredible, and I wish we could get some media attention, but I know that's hard, but I just think it's inspirational, it seems to me, for other communities maybe, and I think staff went to a mountain town.

1:02:06 Housing Conference type thing, and I'm sure you guys are playing this up, but just think it's really incredible from what I've heard compared to other communities, so thank you. Did you have any feedback? Yeah, I think it's, there's a widespread of what other communities are doing, and I think on the one end when we kind of at that conference were talking about projects we have underway, some communities are like, wow, we have nothing, like how do you get funding? I think a lot of that is, you know, support from our town council,

1:02:41 And then being able to leverage that to be successful in the state and federal grant programs. And then other programs do have more robust programs. However, we did not hear from anyone that has a 25-acre site in the center of town that's dedicated solely to affordable housing. I was going to report during Director's Report that I just went to Steamboat Springs last week. I was on an advisory services panel for the Urban Land Institute, which is a nonprofit real estate.

1:03:13 Firm or nonprofit. And so we were there, they assembled a panel of seven people, seven experts in different aspects of real estate development to go to Steamboat Springs to evaluate a 2,300 unit affordable housing project that they're building. So the housing authority there received an anonymous donation of about $35 million and they purchased

1:03:40 534 acres of land just outside of the city. And so they're at the very beginning stages of this process, but they're looking to deliver those units over 20 years. And so we were there basically to just test their ideas and see whether we thought that it was doable and just provide them with different recommendations of ways to go about the process.

1:04:03 We interviewed, you know, a number of stakeholders, over 120 stakeholders in that community. We did a site tour. We wrote a report, and then we provided a presentation to the community last Friday. The report is going to be assembled and put together, and it'll be ready in about a month and a half, two months, and I'll provide the commissioners with a copy when it's done. But, so there are, you know, before we went to Steamboat, before I went to Steamboat, I wasn't aware of any other city doing such a big project.

1:04:31 And this is just kind of a, so other cities are really kind of, this is actually being done by the housing authority there, but there are, there is one project bigger than ours that we're aware of. So, but they are, it's going to be, you know, along, like I said, they're delivering those projects, those units over 20 years. So it's just going to be kind of doing that, but they're having the same, you know, they're having, you know, issues, very similar affordable housing issues.

1:04:56 Worse than ours, I would say, in Steamboat Springs and worse childcare. It was very difficult childcare. So the story that we're hearing with housing, childcare in these resort towns, mountain towns, we're not unique, but it was nice to know that we're at least in a better position. We have all of these units that we're delivering from all of these different sources. So it's nice to know that we're kind of moving the needle on the issues here in our community. Really, thank you all so much for all of this.

1:05:27 That's all for me. Thank you. I'd like to echo what Commissioner Kennedy mentioned about all the great work you guys are doing and what stood out to me was the $75 million in donation or grant money that we've received. I mean, that was really just, it is a strong testament to all the work that you guys are putting into this. So thank you so much. I just had, I guess I think one of the most important questions is if

1:05:57 People who are listening are interested in any of these programs. Do they go through Mammoth Lakes Housing or is there another method for them to go through to try and qualify for one of these units? It depends on the program. For the parcel, everything's going through the property managers for the parcel. So they've already got a long list of interested parties.

1:06:24 They basically just kind of are taking names and information and then once it gets closer to delivery of the units, they'll actually qualify those people. So kind of just taking people's word for it on how much they make that kind of thing, doing kind of a very preliminary qualification, but then going through the more, you know, showing pay stubs and that kind of stuff closer to when the units are going to be delivered.

1:06:46 And then the Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments is through Mammoth Lakes Housing and also, as Nolan mentioned, the bridge units that we're selling are through Mammoth Lakes Housing as well. So most of it at this point is through Mammoth Lakes Housing with the exception of the parcel. Great, thank you. I have no further questions. Are there any questions from the public, Jamie? And there's no one in Suite Z.

1:07:16 Currently. So are there any other comments from commissioners? Okay. Hearing none, we will close item 4.2 and move on to item 5, the consent agenda. Does anyone care to make a motion? I will move to approve the consent agenda. I'll second it. Okay. Jamie, can we get a roll call? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes.

1:07:57 Consent agenda passes 4-0. Moving on to item number 6, Commissioner Reports. We'll start off with Commissioner Eckert. Do you have any reports for us today? I'm just trying to deal with cleanup. I'm sorry, I couldn't hear you. Could you repeat that? No, just dealing with the cleanup of all the snow. It's nice to see all this beautiful water on the ground. Yes, it is. Thank you. Commissioner Chang. I had a...

1:08:31 As I would say, local transportation meeting yesterday. And I think the, you know, Hayes' team is definitely, you know, working hard, those guys. But one of the Caltran reports item, one of the items that the Caltran report talked about was the Awancha Highway.

1:08:56 Completion time looks like it's probably going to take take place around spring of 2024. So it's really not that far away. So which which I'm happy to see. So but anyhow, there's, you know, there were definitely talks about, you know, you know, various funding sources or various Caltrain projects and also the

1:09:26 Access road down to Redsk Meadow. And I think Hayes talked about, you know, looks like, you know, they're going to have additional funding sources. So that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Kennedy. Hayes is gone, but I wanted to echo what Jen said about the snow removal. I thought it was fantastic in this last storm and especially the sidewalk clearing, especially near where I live, was...

1:09:55 Was just clear immediately. And that's amazing. I think if, you know, all of the town talk and plans about walk, bike, ride, having those paths cleared is really important. So really pleased with that. And then I had a question. I don't know if maybe this is, you know, we're always circling back to the internet issue, but maybe an update for a future meeting. I just heard about something called Earthlink. I don't know if anyone knows Earthlink.

1:10:20 As an internet provider here, I think it's probably not great, probably a frontier type. And I know Suddenlink has become optimum, so maybe in the next few months, if there's any updates that you guys know of on the internet side of things, that would be great. We can bring something to you. Thank you. Great, thank you. I have nothing to report at this time. Hey, Chair. Yes. So, if I just can,

1:10:52 Asked maybe everybody here a separate issue here. Similar to Sunlink, Amerigas, I believe, also has a franchise agreement with the town, right? Yes. Okay. So I called the other day, asked them to send an installer or a text.

1:11:20 You know, even just trying to get a tech support to get those guys on the phone. And their excuse to me that they don't have a tech and they have to get a third-party tech to help me to do some test for propane-related at the property, their excuse was because due to COVID, they have no local office around our area. Am I?

1:11:52 Is that true? That they have a franchise agreement with the town of Mammoth Lakes and serving probably a pretty big community here, probably between, you know, both in Yoramono County. They don't have a local office that can support the community? Commissioner Chang, I don't know the answer to your question. I would have to...

1:12:23 Maybe talk to Hayes. Hayes and Amy both left. So talk to them or Pam who manages our franchise agreements and maybe come back with a report to you. Okay. So I just thought that was interesting. You know, I felt like when I was talking to them on the phone, I felt like, you know, we're dealing with another Centlink situation so that they don't have.

1:12:53 Any type of technicians here in town or around Mono Lake that can help the community here. It's mind-boggling to me. It seems hard to believe that they don't have technicians to help here. But yeah, I'll do some digging and get back with the commission on the answer. Thank you. That's all I have. Thanks, Chair. Thank you. Any other comments from commissioners? Okay.

1:13:26 We'll close item six and move to item seven, director report. Thank you. So I already provided my report about my week in Steamboat Springs. I did, just a side note, I did take vacation time, so the town wasn't paying for me to be there. And I did it as a volunteer opportunity, and it was a really amazing opportunity to meet some really heavy hitters in the affordable housing world.

1:13:54 Come into a community from the outside and really help them with their issues. So that was a positive experience for me. Also, I sent the commission out an email about the 2023 Planning Commissioner's Academy. It's March 29th through the 31st in Garden Grove. Vice Chair Burroughs, Commissioner Chang and I went a couple years right before COVID.

1:14:22 in Sacramento, I believe. So it was a good experience. If any of the commissioners are interested in attending that training, just let me know. We do have budget for you all to go to training, not probably for everyone to go to this training, but if any of you are interested, just please let me know. And that's all I have. Thank you. I would highly encourage any of my fellow commissioners who have the time to go to please go.

1:14:50 I learned a lot there. It was worth going. So I definitely recommend that. Thank you for that, Sandra. And that moves us to item number eight, adjournment. And we will adjourn the meeting to our next regularly scheduled Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting on January 10, 2023. I can't believe we're almost there already. It's hard to believe. And at our regular scheduled time of 9 a.m.

1:15:23 Close the meeting. I don't have a gavel. Thank you. Thank you.