TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2025

Town Council

at 16:00 · recording 3 hr 17 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

411 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:40 Well, we'll give her another minute. Hi. Congratulations. Thank you so much. Oh, making me feel bad. All right. All right. She's setting the bar high.

2:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:20 Thank you.

2:50 Alright, this is Chris. Chris is here. Alright.

3:19 Did you make cookies, Chris? Did you make cookies? Yes. Aww. Okay, that allows a brace. Okay. I'm sorry I'm late, but there are cookies. All right, it's four o'clock. We're going to start, and Jamie, can we do the roll call, please? I apologize for being here. It's okay.

3:46 Councilmember Bubser. That's why I was here. Councilmember Salzer. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Here. Mayor Pro Tem Truax. Here. Mayor Rice. Here. And Councilmember Truax is going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance tonight. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.

4:15 One Nation, under God, Invisible, with Liberty and Justice for All. I should have called you Miracle. Sorry. Okay. This is the public comment. If you have something to say that's not on the agenda, we invite you to come and address the town council. Good afternoon, council. Brianna Goyko with the Chamber of Commerce.

4:38 I wanted to update you on a couple things going on for us. We have a sold-out women in business event tomorrow at Limelight. So 50 people, it's the most I've had at a women in business holiday mixer, so looking forward to that.

4:52 A few other things. I mentioned that we're doing the Career Expo. I mentioned that at Council before in January. So really excited to have that. We have a keynote that's going to do a talk in front of all 400 students. Mr. Neil Fox with Sierra STEM. So I think he'll be very animated for our young people and hopefully keep them engaged. And then two other things. One, you'll notice that we put up a banner at the foot.

5:21 I know there's probably an official name for it. I always just say Footloose Corner. But the corner. We put up a banner. I just noticed over the last few years during the holidays there is no banner, no animation there. There's nothing there. And now it's an empty business.

5:36 Not a great looking corner when people come to town. So we quickly designed something. Stu quickly approved it. Thank you, Stu. And we were able to get that up. So that'll be up over the holidays. And we specifically chose the messaging. It says, thank you for choosing Mammoth. So that is visitors, locals who live here, businesses that operate their business here. So glad we got that up. That'll be up through a little bit after the new year. And then we have been

6:02 Our community foundation, the Mammoth Community Foundation, has at this point collected a little over $200,000 in the PAC Fire Relief Fund. So thank you to anyone that has donated. And we started distributing those checks this week to 24 households. I think I have two more to do. And the response from those that have come in to receive the checks has been just immense appreciation.

6:31 Interacting and speaking, you know, disaster relief is not my usual realm or my job and it's been humbling, I guess, to talk to these people and them share everything that's going on and very emotional. So just thank you to the community for

6:50 Trusting us with those funds and we're getting them out to those that were impacted. So at this point, each household has received a little over 6,000. We'll probably do another run of a couple thousand in January per household. So I think that's it for the chamber. Thank you so much for that update and thank you for doing that for the PACFIRE families.

7:16 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Council. Betsy Truax, Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I do really want to commend Brianna and Gina for, you know, all the support that the Chambers Foundation has provided to the PACFIRE victims, and I know that sometimes those are not easy conversations, but I know that everyone coming through has been extremely grateful for the generosity of our community, so. Huge, huge kudos to you guys.

7:44 Just wanted to mention quickly, special events funding closed for Mammoth Lakes Tourism on Monday at 5 o'clock. We received almost $800,000 of requests.

7:54 for the $350,000 of available funding. So that will be a challenging but fulfilling process, I'm sure, for our four-person committee. There are 24 returning events and nine new events applying for funding. Only two of those events are actually new. The other seven are existing events that are now applying for funding.

8:14 We have our last community coffee of 2025 is tomorrow at 8.30 a.m. We'll have a winter update and a holiday operations update from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. The featured coffee shop is Stellar Brew, so please tune in. If you can't make it at 8.30, we do make that recording available, so please check that out.

8:32 Finally, our printed annual report has dropped in our local PO boxes. It's also been sent to second homeowners with non-local mailing addresses but who own property in Mammoth Lake. So we're super proud of the piece. It really, I think, does a good job of demonstrating the power of visitor dollars and then what the town is able to do in terms of projects like

8:57 Almost $40 million of investment in housing and park and recreation facilities, wildfire mitigation efforts. So all those great things. Really proud to be able to demonstrate that to the community. Also in the annual report is the QR code for our resident sentiment survey that will remain open through the holidays. We've had over 113 responses to date and really just look forward to hearing from more of our community. So thanks very much. Thank you for the update.

9:26 Any other public comments? Anyone in the room? Online, Jamie? No. No? Okay, then we will move on to item number four. Are there any additions to the agenda? No, Madam Mayor, there are no modifications to the agenda this evening. Okay, great. We will move on to item 5.1, recognition of Mammoth Lakes Tourism President and CEO John Urdi for his years of service to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Come on up. The next contestant. Did you send me a response, by the way? My phone's open.

9:57 Good evening, everyone. This is Rob Patterson, Town Manager at the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Nice to see you all tonight. And I want to talk about the wonderful Mr. John Urdi, who has been here, I would assume, for quite a long time now. I didn't get the exact date when you started. July 26, 2010. 2010. So, gosh, that's a long time. That's a long time. That's a great amount of time.

10:23 We had a great celebration for recognizing you and your time in the community. I thought it would be good to have one here at the council, sort of recognize some of the accomplishments that have been achieved under your time with us, and I think it's lengthy. So I do want to read a lot of these because they're not only significant achievements, but they have a significant impact on our community and the success of...

10:48 Our community and across the years. And so I want to thank John as well as the MLT staff who were able to pull a lot of this stuff off. But I know what it means to be a leader in that space and how much work needs to get done. And I know, John, you were instrumental in literally all of this. So thank you before I start. First and foremost, sort of rebranding Mammoth Lakes to give the town its own identity. Going from a world-class ski resort with a town to a world-class town with a ski resort.

11:18 That was equal in stature. Sort of took a dive into TBID. If you know, we were not one of the first to TBID, but we were the very first TBID to include other areas like lodging, restaurants, retail, and ski, and then later on adding golf to that. That was the first in the state of California. Then once TBID was secured, you know, that sort of gave us a solid foundation for where funding, you know, would help.

11:46 Provide funds for our marketing efforts. The funding budget went from $2 million to $10 million in marketing and sales communication and education on an annual basis. That had a direct impact. If you look at our TOT numbers across time, they're fairly flat for a period of time. And then as soon as TBID kicked in, they started to go in a trajectory that has

12:10 Essentially, there was an average of around $10.5 million from 2004 to 2014, and that went, now we're approaching $30 million. Our averages are close to the mid-high 20s. So a lot has gone on in that space, and investment is critical. Some other things, COVID, you know, COVID gives us opportunities. I always told John, we'll test the strength of our marketing when we have...

12:36 Headwinds and challenges, right? Not just enjoying the things that are popular. And across time, we've had our fair share of those. And, you know, as COVID hit, MLT raised more than $300,000 to operate food banks for nearly three months. Local workforce opening and after a shutdown. So it's really challenging.

12:58 It also activated 184 food banks for volunteers to help run vaccine clinics. And so that sort of mobilization, getting things done, having the capacity capability to do stuff like that is really incredible. Really focused on providing for the businesses. You know, there were some challenges with the tax on, you know, TBIG dollars and came up with some really good solutions that I think supported that.

13:26 Impact the businesses negatively, but still provided what was important for us to receive. Air service growth, both Mammoth and Bishop, and the relocation of commercial service to Bishop was really successful. We had zero cancellations for winter of 24-25. Always responsive to anything that comes our way, any calamity, whether it be drought, whether it be...

13:47 Successes of huge snow to too much snow to we're drowning in snow. All those things, it's responsiveness to the needs of the community and the messaging needs, right? You guys are our voice, have always been our voice. And so you need to project outwardly the things that we are feeling and we've done an excellent job, you know, with that. We've worked, you work to support the special events growing from 50,000, I think, when you started to 350,000.

14:16 I'm in the latest year as far as support for those events. Worked with the Chamber of Commerce, you know, sort of taking them on through that role and then worked to help them grow to a standalone entity that they are today and they're doing a fabulous job in that space. Really, and I talked about outwardly the messaging, stewardship has been the main message for the last six years, right? How to respect, how to appropriately engage with our wonderful amenities.

14:41 And you guys have done a fabulous job with that, really understanding the need and engaging in that correctly. I think you've got some good campaigns that are keyed up to come out. I look forward to seeing what those look like. And other fundraising events like Clean Up the Lake and other things like that that have been sort of showing that we have a connection to keeping these amenities safe, and especially from overvisitation. And now we're working on currently the destination stewardship plan.

15:09 That's expected to be adopted in June of 2026. Really, you guys bringing that forward, John, making sure that that happens is important. I think that's going to be sort of our culminating effort from a broad sense of the town, other parts of the community, and I think it's going to be successful and certainly guide our efforts. All of that, there's a huge accomplishments in there. They had a significant impact on our organization and our community.

15:34 And I want to thank you for that. I know you're going to go do great things when you go down south. I will still visit you and still see you while you're down there. But I just wanted to thank you from the community for all of the work and effort that you've done for all of the years for us. So thank you for that. Great. Thank you very much. I really appreciate this. It's been an honor to represent this community for the last 15 plus years. Really appreciate the support from the community, from the businesses.

16:08 From the council, from the town staff. I really need to thank my team. Most of my team is here. And my team's over the years. We've had a few people come and go. I'd like to also thank all of our current board members and all of our past board members. John Morris was one of the founders of this organization back in the day, back in 2009, when they started looking at what a DMO was and what it meant to really

16:37 Thank you.

17:06 The 15 years we've had many, many, many ups and downs. We have gone from, you know, the first year that I was here in 10-11, we had a fantastic winter. Then we went into three, four years of drought. Then we started having fires and smoke. We had the Aspen Fire, the Creek Fire, the Rim Fire, all of those things that affected us. And, you know, the Creek Fire was the largest single ignition fire in California history until recently. That was scary. And that was something that really was something we had to affect.

17:36 I'll always go back to Bill reflecting on the fact that we are a flexible and a nimble organization and we change as things are needed. You know, we get a global pandemic, we have a board meeting on a Monday, we stand up a food bank the following Monday. You know, we were here to help the community make sure that we had those people when we were getting back open so that we could still run as a community. Moving forward, we are a community based on recreation and activity. We can't lose sight of that.

18:04 We have a huge opportunity to continue to educate our visitors that are coming in here and to make sure that our residents are taken care of. And that's really a big responsibility of Mammoth Lakes Tourism working in conjunction with the town and most importantly, the council. So please, please, please keep focus on that. It is something that is our lifeblood. We need to continue to bring people here and we need to make sure that they treat the community and the environment with the respect that it deserves. So with that, I thank you for the 15 plus years of letting me stand here.

18:34 Yap at you about air service and about TBIDS and about TOT growth, etc. It's been a pleasure and I thank you all. John, all these years. Absolutely, it's my pleasure. Oh, goodbye. Madam Mayor, can we add a couple comments to what was said? Sure. I just want to say a couple things about John. John, when I first came to this town,

19:31 And I know he said it before, I was looking for a place to live and John happened to be like, I'm moving to a house, I got a house on Davison. First of all, they never told me about Davison or what Davison was or anything about Davison. But during my time on the MLT board and through all my interactions with John, you know, there's times when John and I have disagreed about certain things, but one thing about John is, John cares about this community.

19:55 John cares about making it a better community and evolving it into the place it should be. And that has always come through to me in every interaction. And I appreciate, John, for everything you've done because, you know, people are going to leave and 20 years from now they're going, John did that, John did that, John did that. You know, it's true, you did do it. So thank you. Anyone else? You know, I will add to that. I wrote a quick note here. Some people think that marketing didn't occur here prior to John, but there was a marketing department within the town.

20:25 And the note that I wrote to myself here, it was in-house and in trouble. Completely lacked focus. And John, inheriting a bunch of those employees into his organization, by force originally, was able to turn this around and make an organization that I keep harping on, has been incredibly nimble. Through all the things, the fires, the on and on. So we were blessed to have someone

20:55 And he's been blessed to find the proper staff to move it forward for the town's behalf. And I hope it can continue as well and be as nimble he has left it in great shape and left us in great shape. We look at our T.O.T. That's what's building your parks. That's what's doing it all. And we have been very successful through all of this. So, John, thank you. And I'm sure we will get together in the future.

21:22 Because you're going to be at the beach. Does he have room for trailer there? Anyone else? Yeah. I think this is my 17th round of thank yous and congratulations and maturity. John, consider it 18. And just echoing everything that everybody said and just a little bit more. So thank you. Good luck. Chris, would you like to add anything? Okay. Thank you so much for your service. We will all miss you.

21:55 Okay. So the only thing I want to add is if the MLT people have to leave, don't be shy. Please help yourself to cookies. They're for everybody. And, you know, just a way to say thank you, you know, to everyone. But, but John, yeah, thank you. Thank you. Okay. We'll be moving on to item number six, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. It's a race. Take them to the back. What kind of cookies did you make?

22:29 Bork, huh? Yeah, y'all get this. I see John didn't hesitate for a cookie, everybody else. That's so sweet. All right, is anyone approaching the podium? They're coming out. Okay. Cookies disrupted. Cookies are, uh... All right, Mr. Stu Brown. Finding my arrival with the departure. You didn't even go for a cookie. You're allowed. It's a casual meeting. It's the last meeting of the year. They're right in front of us, aren't we? Yep. Yep.

23:09 Yeah, welcome, thank you, Madam Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of Council, Town Staff, and our community members, bless our MLT team, Betsy. Just thank you for the community coming out for community tree lighting ceremony. Just wonderful to see the community join us to celebrate the winter season, which will be coming hopefully next week, along with Christmas. You know, as far as metrics goes and number of people...

23:37 You know, I thought the deck was really well attended. We had a wonderful, you know, experience on the ice. And I think we gave out approximately 300 hot chocolates. So, but a few kids probably had a few too many. So if you kind of run it down, it's probably about 200 people enjoyed that evening. So I think that was really well attended and we appreciate councils and the mayor's attendance in our community. So thank you. The next one coming up is the opportunity to skate with Santa.

24:06 Before he heads off to the North Pole. So that's going to be this Saturday from 5.30 to 7.30. Again, you can come and have your photos taken from 5.30 to 6 o'clock. We have a whole little Santa chair and arrangement. So please come and get those last minute photos. And then we have ice skating again from 6 to 7.30 for the community. And tonight, if you're a member of our Parks and Recreation membership program, there is that members only event from 7 to 9.

24:34 A little bit weird. We've got hot cocoa and hot dogs. That's a thing now. So we'll kind of see how we go with that arrangement. And then free ice skating for those members as well. But what I do want to talk about tonight is our Parks and Recreation Master Plan survey. Hopefully everyone received a survey in their mail box here at our wonderful post office. You've completed that, sent it back. We have about 330.

25:03 And I think there's, what, about 3,000 mailboxes in town? Anybody? Anybody? So, you know, we'd like to kind of see that number increase. But we have just recently rolled out the online survey. So this is a little bit of a shorter survey, and it's really kind of targeted towards our transient population, our workforce, people coming and going that still utilize our facilities, all those folks that didn't receive that printed mail piece in their mailbox.

25:33 Again, a lot of information going out. I emailed the world yesterday. I apologise if you've got multiple emails. We have social media going out as well. We've got postcards everywhere. We've got little, you know, business cards. So please take some time to contribute to that survey. It really helps us plan and inform our wonderful master plan process that is ongoing. That survey will be open until April 30th. Okay, so I'll be coming a lot to talk about.

26:02 I think Betsy talked about the sentiment survey, right? We're good with that. And I think that's it from us. So thank you and happy holidays. Wonderful. Thank you for the update. Welcome. Thank you. Good evening, council. I'm excited to announce that the town received notification at the end of last week or beginning of this week that Pacific and the town did receive the tax credits for Kingfisher 2.2 award.

26:37 So that award is providing approximately $33.3 million for the second phase of the Kingfisher. So 72 additional units, which will be in addition to the 76 that are currently under construction. So I know with that, their plan is to begin construction this spring, and then those units would be completed approximately two years after that. So it's exciting news to see that project continue to move forward. Wonderful. Thank you.

27:08 Any questions? Nolan, can you remind me of after Kingfisher I, how many total units we will have at the parcel? And then after Kingfisher II, I was trying to tell someone and couldn't remember. So between the Sawyer, Kingfisher I, and Kingfisher II, there'll be 230 low-income units there. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments or questions for Nolan? No? Okay. Thank you. Any other updates? Not seeing anyone? Okay.

27:40 We will move on to item seven, staff presentation, oh, 6.1, December 2025, Public Works Engineering CIP update. Is this just an initial? That was written only. Okay. There was an error on that that we did notice that one of the write-ups for listed as a parcel provided information that was associated with our roundabout minaret. Okay. So that is the only change on that, but it is written for your consideration. Thank you. Okay. Are there any questions or comments?

28:10 For that one? No. Okay. Then we will move right along to Item 7, Staff Presentations. 7.1, Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Task Force Year in Review. Is that Lawson? It is. All right. Hello. Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Today we wanted to share with you our year in review for the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Task Force. As you all may recall, initially due to some of the events in Los Angeles,

28:43 Town Manager, as well as Town Council convened this Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Task Force. Obviously, we've had some recent events as well that I think highlight the need for some of these efforts. But just want to go over kind of some of the basics here at the beginning, who we are, the main partners in this project, of course, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, the Whitebark Institute, Mammoth Disposal, and Mammoth Community Water District.

29:10 Just really briefly, how all of these kind of entities tie together. I think both the town and Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District are pretty self-explanatory, but the White Park Institute is obviously the main party involved in the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, trying to create kind of that circle of forest health around Mammoth Lakes, with us being tasked to deal with the donut hole colloquially.

29:37 Mammoth Community Water District, obviously in charge of the water infrastructure, key partner as it relates to this. Just an example, we're all trying to work collaboratively now with our forest partners to get some fire hydrants in strategic locations around town. But again, as managers of the water resources in town, we wanted to have them be part of this. And then Mammoth Disposal, who's been a really, really great partner in the realms of green waste, green waste removal.

30:03 Green waste receptacles, things of that nature. So this is the team. And I would like to think that the town manager as well as council made it very clear that the goal of this was to get work done on the ground. I think you will see at the end of this presentation, we still have a lot to learn. We have a lot to improve on. But just want to go through kind of some of the highlights with you for this year.

30:30 We will talk about these inspections. We've talked about them with you before, kind of highlighting what these involve, the nexus to these inspections, but going through some highlights, over 2,000 properties inspected, over 5,000 plus hours invested by the community in defensible space and green waste removal. That is a statistic through the fire aside program that we will talk about.

30:52 Over $1 million invested by the community in defensible space and green waste removal. Again, this is based on work hours spent and estimated by fireside, very similar to how a public entity such as Town of Mammoth or the federal government will estimate a volunteer hour, right, and prescribe a dollar value to that hour. Over 13,000 personalized recommendations. These are, again, the results of the assessments we did. Over 536 acres of land inspected.

31:21 And over 136 completed green waste pickups. So lots of work on the ground. Division Chief Mike McCarthy will go over some of these things with you here in more detail. To give you a bit of a timeline of events, things happened quickly. Again, that was the goal of this. We saw what happened, I think, again, in Los Angeles and other places throughout California and throughout the western U.S. primarily. And I would like to think we reacted quickly.

31:51 In February, kind of convening this task force. April, again, as you can see, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District hiring eight seasonal crew and additional four with funding from the town. I do want to emphasize the importance of that and those additional four and how those allowed us to really achieve some great work on the ground. I think a big part of hiring some of these seasonal firefighters is the big draw is getting out on fires. Often that's where firefighters make their money.

32:19 These folks want to facilitate that, right? But this extra additional four really allowed for strategic deployment of folks to larger fire events while still having people here in town to accomplish this really, really important work. So I want to emphasize the importance of that. Fuels reduction work and projects started around town in May. Home evaluations in June. And then here we go in September, over 2,000 evaluations completed. October.

32:47 A cumulative 240 plus tons of fuels removed from the town of Mammoth Lakes and roughly within the town boundary of the town of Mammoth Lakes. In November, the ending of the seasonal crew work.

33:01 And as we're going to move into the following spring, active planning for prevention prior to the fire season. So we will talk about here at the end of this presentation some things we want to improve on, things we want to work on, how we want to continue to grow to do great work on the ground. But in the meantime, I do want to hand it over to Division Chief with Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, Mike McCarthy. Good evening, Mike McCarthy. So what I'll do today is just talk a little bit more detail on...

33:29 Some of the home evaluations that we did and some of the green waste projects we did before Lawson finishes up where we're headed next. So we talk about, you know, doing these street side, and they're really evaluations more than they are inspections, right? We're just doing these from the street. We're not coming on people's property. We're not doing a full 360 around their house. So we're just trying to give them, and they're informational only. There's no punitive actions.

33:57 That come about because of these recommendations. They're just recommendations of what people could do better. In our interactions with people, we really found out that a lot of people are willing to do the work, they just don't know what they should do. And so part of this is helping them prioritize what work they should do. We talk about the Fireside Program. It is a software program. It was set up to do this kind of firework.

34:23 Marin County uses it. A lot of the Tahoe areas around trucking and stuff like that use it. It really is just helpful at presenting the information in an understandable format for homeowners. So we do this stuff on the back end to carry out the evaluations, and it does a pretty good job of pushing it out to the homeowner and engaging them. You know, it's really set up so that we can identify things. Homeowners can look at it.

34:49 Hire or do the work themselves and submit proof of correction and we can review it without even having to go back out on site. We can look at pictures, review it, or we can go back out on site and re-inspect it and it starts kind of a cycle of going through that to get people to do the work. And it really becomes a database to track what's happening. You know, it's nothing too much fancier than that, really. It's just a pretty slick system for consolidating all this work and tracking it.

35:18 You know, lots of talks about the highlights. I think this heat map is kind of cool. This shows you that we did about just over 2,000 inspections. We did prioritize single-family homes this first year. This next season, we're going to move into the condo complexes. But we prioritize single-family homes. We also prioritize trying to get it around the perimeter of town. We tried to get, you know, that's where the wildfire comes from, from the surrounding area. These homes are the ones we want defensible action taken sooner.

35:48 Each of the reports has a number of things that our inspectors identified. And really, when people start to do work and submit the results, you can sort of track how many hours they've spent on doing this work. And it really is about homeowners doing the work themselves. This is not about us coming in to do it or the magic pine needle fairies that come in and rake up your pine needles while you're sleeping. This is about homeowners doing the work.

36:17 If you wanted to get a flavor for what we're finding, these boxes show kind of proportional to how often we found identified these conditions. It shouldn't come as any surprise. Trees are our biggest issue here in Mammoth, right? Trees that overhang the structures, trees that have dead limbs that need to be limbed up, trees that need more spacing between them. Yes, pine needle litter on the ground too.

36:42 But those three or four on the left-hand side, those are the biggest ones that we find, and it's nothing surprising, right? We have a lot of trees, and we could use a little more spacing between ground shrubbery and trees and removing some of the dead. The timeline on the right was just kind of another little key thing to show some of the milestones, but we really did, at Rob's direction, hit the ground running hard.

37:09 And, you know, we made some flubs along the way. We did some inspections that weren't complete. We did some, we identified some wrong things. We had to go back and work with some homeowners to go back and say, oh, we kind of messed that up. But we got going and we got people out there. Of our seasonal crew, we had at least two people every single day doing inspections. And so we were able to pivot to other people doing fuels reduction work, but we had at least two of our staff walking streets.

37:37 Conducting evaluations every day. Can I just ask you that last black box on the right, it says combust, I can't read the right, what does it say? First of all, it's a smaller box because it wasn't identified that much, but it's combustible materials within 10 feet of a propane tank. Combustible materials within 10 feet of a propane tank, okay, thank you. So we do have a lot of propane tanks, so that is something.

38:01 But in fact, this next picture in the bottom right there, you can see there's an example of where one of the inspections would identify that to remove some of the fuels around the propane tanks. The combustible materials could just be trees. It could be trees. Other times people actually have wood stacked there and stuff like that there, you know, but just and healthy mature trees themselves limbed up are fine to be there because they're not the big hazard for it. It's hard to start a trunk of a tree on fire. It's the smaller stuff.

38:31 And dead stuff and low, flashier stuff on the ground, that's more of a risk. Because I was going to ask, because isn't that a piece of wood laying across the propane tanks? It is. It is, right? So some of that is, you know, it's turned into a storage area, right? And we're trying to get people to clean that up. But as I said, you know, these are kind of examples. When you get the report, they've got a picture. We try to identify on the picture what they need to be done, whether it's dead limbs in the trees.

39:00 Or trees that are overhanging the chimney or the structure too closely, or just too dense of vegetation. You know, we really want, the science says we really want some space between vegetation so it's harder for fuel to be carried along like a fence. And the fire science, you know, it continues to evolve, but it does seem to keep reinforcing that defensible space and home hardening are actually important. You know, they continue to do some studies down south from the

39:29 Eaton and Palisades Fires. You know, and trying to look at, and no study is perfect, but they tried to look at the homes that had defensible space versus those that not. And, you know, the odds are not great in terms of, they found some of the numbers were like a one in five chance your house would survive in those extreme wildfire conditions if you did not have defensible space. And more like a two in five chance if you did have the best place. So, it's sort of...

39:57 Doom and gloom, but it doubles the chance that your house is going to survive in those extreme behaviors. And again, no science is perfect, and that's not the end-all be-all of the science study or anything, but that's the most recent one that came out of the Palisades and Eaton fires, that it is making a difference. I think we saw that in the PAC fire, honestly, firsthand, that the houses that had not a lot of trees up close to them, that had spacing around the stuff, some of those were newer homes with good home hardening as well.

40:25 And those were the trees that our crew were able to sit there and defend and keep safe. A lot of fireside is about encouraging the resident and the owner to get engaged and do the work. And so there's examples up here of sort of before and after where we would come out, flag something on the left, the owner would take action and send a photo in through the system, and we can mark it off as resolved and it goes away from their inspection report as a completed item instead of something to be done.

40:56 And this is really, you know, sounds corny, but it takes a village to do this, right? This is not a small team of five people working for Mammoth Fire that goes and does all this work. This is about all the residents doing work on their property, you know? And none of it is that hard, but there's some dramatic differences when people actually have taken action to clean up and minimize how thick the vegetation is around their home. So I have a question there. Were they actually violations, or were you just, they were falling upon recommendations?

41:24 So we have everything we've done in our inspections so far, their evaluations are just recommendations. Now technically the defensible space stuff, the majority of it is actually in our ordinances as things that are required for people to do. The home hardening is not, that is all recommendations. That's required on new construction, but it's not required for anybody to go back and retrofit their home with any of the home hardening, like putting screens over their vents or non-combustible decking or siding.

41:52 If you're building a new home, those are part of the code requirements, but some of those come in here as recommendations, and they're clear that they're recommendations. The defensible space, I said, technically they are violations, the majority of them, because they're in our ordinance, but everything we've done so far is just educating the homeowner about it. They have not triggered us to start a clock on people or to cite people or to go back and threaten them with violations or anything else. We're just trying to get people to move in the right direction.

42:18 And Fireside has had some experience with this in other communities. So far, they say the carrot is working better than the stick. If you educate people and tell them what they need to do, they're getting a higher response than the people that come in heavy-handed and threaten to come back if they don't get it fixed. So that's the approach we're taking so far. I hope we can continue on that approach. I think that would be challenging if we approach it in a different way, but we're still trying to give a result, but I appreciate it. I mean, WS, the...

42:48 People we engage with more often were the people that were interested in doing the work and stuff like that, but there was definitely, you know, I think it's hit home in California pretty hard for people on this, and people are very motivated to get stuff done. Again, the people that interact with us are the people that are more likely doing that than the people that are just ignoring us, but I'm seeing a high amount of interest in people to know what the right thing to do is and start it. I'd like to add just a little bit to that. You know, we're going to talk at the end here about

43:17 changes for next year and this will be ongoing into the future and I do appreciate the work that's been done this far and exactly the approach that we have taken. One of the things that this Wildfire Task Force is doing is the engagement with the community and so there will be an effort that goes back around to people who maybe have received something but not engaged with that to try and get the maximum amount of utilization but I don't anticipate any

43:43 You know, the second part of,

44:08 We did the evaluations to educate people. The other part was actually getting green waste and getting fuel out of the community, right? So we continued a curbside chipping program that we've been doing for several years now. It's free to homeowners. They can make a reservation through the fireside software. This year we did Wednesdays, so every Wednesday we'd send a crew out, a crew of typically three people at least, to go out and chip into a dump truck and haul away the green waste that they had left curbside.

44:38 And, you know, this program has gone up and down in volumes. After the big winter, there was a lot of blowdown. There was a lot of chipping that next year. This year was more moderate year. But as we get the home inspection valuations out there, people are more interested in doing some more work, too. So I think we'll see the volume go up in this. But it's still a pretty popular program because we all know how hard it is to get rid of trash and green waste.

45:05 You know, so they get it to the street side and we come and take it away. It's that simple. Another thing, two things we tried this year that turned out to be pretty successful was we created a couple assistance programs. So the first one was kind of what we call ladder fuels. Ladder fuels are that, in defensible space terms, it's that continuity of fuel between stuff on the ground up into the trees that creates kind of a ladder for fire to go up.

45:36 From the ground up into the trees. So you try to break that continuity by have spacing between brush on the ground and branches on the trees. And so we started a program where we would try to come in and help prioritize for residents where we would do some of the harder work in limbing up some of the bigger trees or taller trees that they perhaps weren't the tip of the homeowner might not have the tools or the equipment or ability to do. We didn't come in and rake people's pine needles or

46:04 Take out little small brushes. We did the harder stuff to do. And we, you know, it is time consuming. You go meet with the owner, you agree what to do, you send a crew out there to do the work. But it was a pretty successful program in terms of community receptiveness to it and excited. The pictures here on the left show a house, you know, from a similar advantage in the backyard. That same house is there in both pictures, even though you can't even see it much in the first one.

46:33 And in the end, they still have 50, 100 trees on their property. We did not go in there and take out all of their trees, but we took out a lot of the small saplings down low, and now there's kind of a space between the ground and those lower branches that makes it more resilient to fire. We also had a free firewood tarps program, so people that have firewood stored during the summer, you're required to have a tarp with a fire retardant tarp.

47:04 To try to reduce the chance that embers could land there and start the fire, the big source of fire. That program was enabled through a Whitebark Institute-directed grant program that's funded by Edison. And so we bought 70-something tarps and have been giving them away to people through this program to qualify. We got kind of a slow start mid-summer on that, but we have kind of a backup now of people that are asking for it. So we may look at expanding that program in the future.

47:31 But I will say that both of these were super positive, just people like, wow, you're going to, like, I did what I could, but you're going to come help me do the next part. You know, and we're not competing with tree services. We're not going in and dropping 150-foot trees that are right next to the property. That's outside our skill set, too. We're trying to help that in-between barrier of a little more than typical homeowners can do, a little more than they're comfortable with doing on a ladder with chainsaws, but not into the...

47:58 The tree services, really. So I think we'll look at trying to make it more efficient, but probably expand that program. And then for the firewood tarp program, are people just talking to you guys for that? Or how are we telling people about that? So what we originally set up, when you get an evaluation through the fireside program, if the inspector had noticed that you had firewood that was uncovered, they would target, they would mark that.

48:28 And that would make you eligible to apply for getting a free tarp from us. And then if they didn't, I mean, because it started halfway through the inspections. It started halfway through and we got it in there, but so if they saw that, they would see right below it a money assistance grant may be available. We also realized from doing street side evaluations, a lot of people have their firewoods stored on the back deck or somewhere where we couldn't see it. So partway through the summer, we opened it up so our people could apply. So we got more applications then because people actually had.

48:58 Okay, thank you.

49:24 Here's another example of a work that was in progress where somebody reached out to us and said to me, look, we've done what we can. Can you help us do the rest? And, you know, it's a big property. And this is just not really a before and after. It's a before and during. But, you know, we came in and helped mark trees and took down small trees. And in the end, they still have a lot of trees in their property, but they have better spacing. The small and dead stuff is gone. The little spindly stuff that wasn't healthy. And there's just better spacing between their trees now and their property.

49:54 And again, another place where the homeowners were, like, we raked up 200 bags of pine needles, but we're not capable of taking down these small, even these small trees, you know, and so we were able to help them with that next little step. The last thing we did was a couple bigger project work, projects in town. When we first talked to town council, we talked about strategic fuel breaks around the edge of the town. We talked about these inspections to get people to do work on their own. We talked about some key geographical areas.

50:27 I kind of had mentioned like the Valentine Reserve down through Mammoth Creek down to the ice rink as kind of a natural geographical draw where fire could come down in a hurry because of the geographical feature. And so we talked about hitting some of these larger parcels. We started off, we did do some work on building fire breaks on the edge of town. This was outside off the trails neighborhood. We tried to give the MUPS trail and make a little clearance around that so that if we needed to send fire apparatus down there to try to hold the line.

50:57 Right outside the houses. That'd be a little safer for apparatus to get in there and hold that line with lower flame lengths. We had plans to do a lot more of this, you know, connecting from behind the bowling alley all the way up to the bluffs. But we were testing the grounds here a little bit too and trying to learn what equipment works best. And we now have a draft agreement with the Forest Service that we're working through. So it seems like we'll be good to go next summer to pick that back this next season to pick that back up and try to make that break on the whole.

51:27 Kind of south edge of town there. The parcel that Nolan talked about, you know, a lot of that is slated for development, but some of it is many years out. So we went in and worked closer to the businesses along Center Street and closer to the houses along Mono Street and tried to thin and create a little break, not a break, but thin out the forest in there.

51:54 Closer to where the homes and surrounding businesses are. Again, to give us a chance to better defend it. But it's still a big parcel that's heavily forested in there. And so we went in there and made some progress. There's piles that are in there that we're going to burn probably next year. There's a few piles that are old that will burn this year when the snow hits. But the other piles we probably won't burn until next year because they need to season for a while to make sure they're dry enough to burn efficiently. And not to get sidetracked, but...

52:23 We are doing, we will be doing some pile burning. You know, there's a kind of a prescription and a process to go through to get through it done. It has to do with how long the wood seasons before we can burn it to make sure it will burn cleanly with minimal smoke. And then there's a lot of conditions that we impose and others impose on air quality, the conditions, enough snow on the ground so that any embers that get out, you know, they're basically little mini bonfires that we have, but we do them under very controlled conditions and only when the conditions are right.

52:52 Go, no-go checklists and decisions made every single day when you go to do those things. But once we do get some snow on the ground, there's probably about a dozen piles behind the businesses on Center Street that we will burn. And then in the next fall, there will probably be another couple dozen. This might be a silly question, but it's, I mean, we bucked the wood and

53:16 Given away the firewood that is usable? In a lot of cases, the bigger wood, yes. If the wood wasn't rotten or small diameter, we bucked it up, got it away. Okay, and we're giving it away? Yes. Okay, good. Thank you. Camp High Sierra is up kind of near, you know, it's also one of the geographical areas. It's another big parcel, 11 acres, that's kind of heavily forested, right? So it's one of the few key parcels in town that has a lot of land, forested land.

53:50 No kidding, we've dropped over 300 trees in there. We spent a good five, six weeks in there removing wood. And if you haven't been through there to walk your dog or anything like that stuff above the campground, it's a remarkable difference once we got that wood on the ground and out of there. There is no piles left in there. There's no pile burning. There's nothing left there. Everything that was dropped was taken out. And you can see the actual meadow that it used to be.

54:19 All right.

54:50 Big tasks that we tried to accomplish, obviously, in this space. Mike's talked quite a bit about fire aside and a big part of what we're trying to do is get a word out. Get the word out on what we're trying to do out here on the landscape. Get the word out about how we can help through these assistance programs and really promote folks kind of signing up and taking their assessments seriously. We had...

55:16 Four community barbecues this summer where we just went out into neighborhoods and just engaged folks proactively to the best of our ability. Obviously some free food helps and try to educate folks on basically what we're trying to do and how this is different from things we've done before.

55:34 I felt these barbecues were quite successful. They seemed to rise in numbers, each neighborhood that we went into. We were pretty visible out there. We'd get some signage out there. But I think an even bigger success with these community barbecues was we would work with our partners at Mammoth Disposal and get green waste gumsters out in these neighborhoods, usually about two to three days before the barbecue and leave them there two to three days after.

56:02 And people went crazy with these things, filled them up constantly. We had to get numerous dumps of these in pretty much every neighborhood in which we put them. So that was an immense, immense success. Obviously, as we talk about what's next, I think how we can be more strategic with these things moving into the future will obviously be a big topic of conversation for us.

56:25 We also try to support Inyo National Forest Fire Restrictions. Again, always a big worry on the adjacent wildland-urban interface, whether that's with dispersed camping, things of that nature, people having campfires. So we try to support that as well through information campaigns, getting out a ton of different signage.

56:44 So much so that the Forest Service actually reached out to us to get some of our signage to put in other strategic locations. So really just trying to do what we can out there on the landscape. I believe some of you were in a meeting as well earlier this year where we were discussing dispersed camping and how we can potentially mitigate some of those imminent dangers that are occurring kind of right outside of town here.

57:08 Again, the Wildland Urban Interface, obviously White Barks doing a lot of great work there, leveraging a lot of White Barks materials, things of that nature to try to educate the public. We had Firewise communities at these barbecues as well. So again, trying to engage and embed ourselves within existing community organizations, I think is a priority as well. And this all ties into what we're going to do next here. And I think

57:37 Mike has talked a lot about the great, great work on the ground, the tons and tons of fuels removed from the community, which cannot be underestimated. But what Mike said also was, you know, we're going to skin our knees a little bit. We're going to fail. We're going to figure things out. We're going to see what worked and what didn't. I think we took the town manager and all of your direction to heart.

58:02 When we wanted to hit the ground running and get some work done. I think based on what we presented here, we got work done. And now it's time to really just take a step back here, think critically, what can we do? How can we improve? And I think a big part of that is, again, increasing our overall engagement with the community through fireside. You saw the other heat map up there before.

58:29 Basically, now you're looking at all of the people who engaged with Fireside once they got their assessment versus those who did not. And you can see there's a good amount of gray in there, right? How do we engage those folks? How do we get those folks to, you know, take a look at their assessments, open those emails, and take seriously what we want to accomplish on the landscape? But along those same lines, how do we reinforce positive behavior?

58:57 Right? I think it's two-fold. And again, we're taking that carrot-not-stick approach. But whether it's Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Disposal, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, we can't just be operating in a vacuum, right? We need the community. We need folks to engage with us in this space. And as Mike said, through the various assistance programs, we will help you. And I think another thing that we really want to look into is we have a lot of second homes.

59:26 Here in town of Mammoth Lake. So how can we utilize the local workforce, specifically landscape companies, and provide an avenue for people through Fireside to get their assessment and see a button that says click if you need to get help with this work, right? And it'll bring you to us. Go ahead. So just I want to ask just a quick question. On this map, so you've got engaged, not yet. Yep. And there's a lot of buildings that are neither. Those have not been inspected yet.

59:55 Okay, so they've assessed. Let me rephrase. Sorry. Okay, so they haven't been, have they been outreached to? No. Right now, no, because the only outreach has been to people that have had an inspection, an evaluation done. These are the 2,000 inspections. So we did it through email, and then we didn't have email for everybody, right? So we did a lot of postcard mailings. So everything, it's not...

1:00:18 Orange or Gray still is to come. Yet to be inspected for the first time. Our goal was to hit about a third of the 4,500 properties, so 1,500. We hit 2,000. But again, we targeted single-family homes, condo complexes. There's a lot of them. Each one will take longer than a single-family home, but you're hitting 80 of them or 100 of them with one inspection. Okay. Thank you. That's good. Thank you. Yeah, and I think to Council Member Wentworth's point,

1:00:46 Still a lot of work to be done. Still a lot of engagement to be done in this space. Like I said before, how can we create avenues to...

1:00:55 Make things simple for people. So you get an assessment, we'll talk about the assistance programs, we talked about them briefly, how we can potentially expand those, but having a button there. Hey, have a homeowner service, right? Come to your house, maybe, if you're a second homeowner, and rake your pine needles, maybe help deal with some of these ladder fuels if they have the skill set to do so. But it falls to us, I think, to maybe help those entities in terms of what right looks like, right? If we say, oh, you know, we need to deal with ladder fuels.

1:01:24 Having those folks know and understand what that is supposed to look like. So we've thought about bringing as many of these homeowner services who are qualified to do so together for a meeting at the fire station where we talk about these different things. We talk about this fire aside program and see if we can get some buy-in in that regard and engage the local community and local businesses who do this type of work. So again, lots of different things that need to be done. Expanding resident engagement, I think, is one of them.

1:01:54 Also, something that we will discuss here coming up as well, how can we either through marketing, website development, branding, you know, reach some of these other folks who are maybe not yet engaging with the Fire Aside program. And these are all things we're going to be working through in the, quote, off-season, although there isn't much snow on the ground right now. We're also looking into how to initially contact a lot of these folks. Like Mike said, through Fire Aside, they offer this postcard program where they will mail you.

1:02:23 You know, a postcard that says, hey, you know, we assessed your property or check your assessment. How can we reach as many people as humanly possible? We have a lot of folks who rent their homes, right? And maybe live somewhere else who might have a proclivity, and I'm not saying all to maybe not pass that along to their renters, that this is important. So how can we engage those folks as well? As we move into 2026, and I'll spend here a little bit of time on this slide here.

1:02:52 Obviously, we want to continue our strategic fire breaks on the edge of town. This is going to be partially dependent on our partners at the Inyo National Forest, and as Mike said, there's draft agreement in place, but also with some private landowners who bump up against the edges of town, who would be willing to let the fire protection district come to their property to do potentially some mowing or mastication.

1:03:17 So kind of working through those areas as well and doing more in that space. And I think we're kind of set up to do so. Another one is green waste. Green waste, I think, is going to become an issue for a lot of reasons. Number one is disposal of green waste, right? And that's kind of the large scale. I guess I'm taking the large scale first. Long term, how do we deal with all this green waste we're going to be pulling here out of town?

1:03:47 I believe the county just received a grant for a curtain burner, so that's one option that we could approach. I know we've talked about biomass facilities, things of that nature, but putting green waste in landfills generally lowers the lifespan of a landfill. So how do we deal with all the green waste that's coming out of here? We obviously then have kind of the curbside green waste removal and the neighborhood waste removal as well.

1:04:13 Fire Protection District just received a grant as well for a grapple truck or for dollars that will be used for a grapple truck, which should make this green waste removal more efficient on the street side. What's a grapple truck? You want to explain it? It's basically a dump truck with a big robotic arm where instead of standing there and hand-feeding stuff into a chipper to make it go away, we pick it up with a claw, drop it in the truck, and drive away.

1:04:42 And it's quicker, more efficient, and we're, I would love to say we invented it, but no, we are copying Truckee who has learned to get away from chipping and move to this as a faster, easier way to get through neighborhoods and get it out of there. Thank you. Thanks for asking, because originally I thought I heard it say gravel truck, and I was like, what's special about gravel? We're going to pave everything. Pave everything.

1:05:04 So again, that'll make our curbside much more efficient. It can maybe be done with less bodies as well. But at the neighborhood level, we talked about the dumpster program. How can we make that better? Maybe doing it earlier in the season, timing it with town cleanup day, moving it in the neighborhoods that melt out first up into the higher elevations. But I think mainly one of the things we learned is...

1:05:24 Probably doing that stuff earlier in the season when a lot of folks are actually out on the ground removing the green waste rather than tying it to our barbecues, which happened throughout the year. So looking into ways to make that process more efficient as well. I think another big one that I've alluded to is refining our mission, our brand voice, our marketing, our public outreach. Obviously, again, our goal this year was

1:05:52 Getting things done on the ground, right? But how do we make our efforts clear to the community? How do we engage with the community more efficiently? Whether that's through a website, enhanced marketing, education. And then I think a big part of that is how do we engage with all of these other entities that are doing firework on the ground? Many of which you all know of, whether that is...

1:06:18 The Firewise communities, the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, who's doing great work in this space, Whitebark and many, many others. How do we potentially take a look at what they're doing or consolidate efforts or eliminate duplication? Because, you know, we did hit the ground running pretty quickly and these are all things that we really want to think about as we move into the future. Obviously, we want to target the condo complexes for these home evaluations coming up.

1:06:45 I think that might be a slightly easier lift in terms of it's not an individual home with an individual owner that you have to get a hold of. Most of them have HOA boards. I would like to think we can get in communication with them relatively easily. Many of them as well have dedicated homeowner services type companies that help manicure their particular landscapes. So really looking forward to that engagement and ultimately as well commercial entities in town.

1:07:10 It's not just the private entities, you know, that may have trees or defensible space things that we want addressed. We can move into the commercial realm as well and do evaluations on those properties. Another big one as a part of this, what other assistance programs could we help create within the community? We've taken a look around at some of what other communities done. There's a program, I believe, through FEMA that will provide a...

1:07:38 Scholarship or a fund, quote unquote, to help folks who have cedar shake shingle roofs, replace those with metal roofs. Those are a huge, huge hazard. And I talked to some folks down in, I believe, San Bernardino area, and they said that program was immensely successful. Possibly expanding some of our existing assistance programs, whether that's the wood tarps, ladder fuels, things of that nature. And then ultimately, kind of the problem that Mike talked about of big trees. You know, those are often the most glamorous.

1:08:07 Although the science says a lot of that other little stuff is equally, if not more important, but is there a way in the future to set up a fund for folks to utilize professional tree service companies here in town to maybe put some of those largest hazards on the ground, which we are certainly not qualified to do. These are all things that we're thinking about, ways to continue to improve this program and move it forward. And obviously, lastly,

1:08:33 Fuels reduction on key and large high hazard parcels. We talk about these geographic zones where fire can rip through extremely efficiently, whether that's Mill City, Woss Lining, Valentine, Mammoth Creek. How do we address these particular parcels, many of which include a lot of private land? I don't have the answers to those questions right now, but I think these are things that we need to explore if we want to be very, very comprehensive in our...

1:09:02 Kind of protection of the community and doing what we can here in the donut hole, so to speak. All right, we've talked a lot. Any comments, questions for us? And thank you again for your time as well. I'd like to make some comments, if I may, just to close up some of this. First and foremost, I want to thank Blosson and the team for responding so quickly and so effectively to the needs of the community and so our request in this process. We did.

1:09:32 Know that this was going to be a little bit quick and dirty, and that was the intent for year one. I will say that we're committed to this project for multiple years until we feel like either we've exhausted the efforts or we're pretty well prepared, and I think even at that point it will morph into something slightly different.

1:09:49 We talked a lot about how we are engaging directly with the homeowners. This is a community-wide project. The Wildfire Task Force is the facilitator to get this stuff done. They're providing the tools, they're providing the expertise, providing the solutions. But I need the community to step up and do their part. That's what's going to make this ultimately successful. The work that we're doing in year two, as you can see, the refinements that are suggested are really, really good. We spent a lot of time on that.

1:10:18 Looking at how it needs to be changed, some things that could work a little bit better. Again, more time, if you will, having a great opportunity to build a better product. And these guys are doing a fabulous job. So I want to commend them on that. And I think we're committed to this. We're committed to making sure this is successful. And I just want to thank them for the absolute quick response and really effective first year implementation. Thank you. Questions or comments? Quick comment.

1:10:48 Your comment on large trees is well taken. On my mind, my property was one of those that was appraised, although I haven't talked to anybody about it. One of the things I was dinged for was having very large trees within X number of feet of the buildings. Local tree services are great. I would love to have them come in. However, they are hideously expensive. My insurance won't cover it. And I'm sure there are a whole lot of other people in the area that will have that same issue. So if that's something that can be worked on.

1:11:17 That would be appreciated. The only other ding, I think when this all started, we were told that the inspectors, when they were inspecting your property, if someone was at home, would have that conversation with them. There's always someone home at my house. No one talked to me. No one said anything. No one came by. The only notification that I got was the postcard. And I understand this is hot. I'm just telling you where the shortcomings have been from my side of it.

1:11:46 Certainly anyone in the fire department would know how to get a hold of me. So just things that we can work on. Thank you. Who's next? Brent? Oh, sure. Comments and a couple questions. One of my questions is going to be about communicating to homeowners, and I hope we do outreach because it seems like this day and age between the county, us, voter registration, et cetera, we can get a hold of almost everybody in this community. How are we closing the loop? I mean...

1:12:11 When I look at this in terms of what you've done and all the work that's been done and the owners you've already talked to and will be talking to as we go forward, how are we going back and evaluating have we seen owners actually do a specific amount of that work? I didn't see any kind of closure of the loop on this analysis that we've got here. So the program is set up for people to be able to resolve their own issues by submitting photos of the after work.

1:12:40 And so we saw a couple examples of that. There were several hundred, you know, so maybe 10%, 15% of the people that did something like that. In other areas, we're in track where they've been using the program longer, they get a higher number of people that are going back through the system and showing proof that they did it. And a lot of those have worked with the local landscapers and homeowner service that are doing the work for some people. They work with the homeowner.

1:13:07 Get access to the report and they're the ones actually submitting the after photos. So I believe there's a higher percentage of people that actually did work but didn't know or bother to go through the extra effort of taking pictures of their after work and showing it to us to resolve it. No, that's what I'm wondering is because there may be a fair amount of work done but we're thinking it's only 10% or 20% and it might be 80% but we don't know. We don't know. So one mechanism was as people get more familiar with the system and learn about it. The other mechanism is re-inspections.

1:13:36 As we come through on a, you know, ideally we'd be on something like a three-year cycle for inspections, which is based on how much we got done, I think it's not implausible, but then on that cycle you could start to see if you're digging people for the same things or they've actually resolved things and they go down. So it is, it's, it's something we know is we want to be able to see a higher success or a completion rate.

1:13:59 And then my third one is to comment to my question because are you working with any of the people doing insurance inspections because I understand that right now there's only two or three people doing inspections for insurance companies in town. In my property, part of it, in order to renew, we were required to eliminate some brush that was near the building before they would renew the insurance. I haven't submitted that to anybody. We haven't documented it to anybody, but we've already made adjustments because the insurance company required it. So I don't know if you were having any conversations through this interaction with them.

1:14:29 We have not. We're aware of it, and a lot of homeowners have reached out to us because they have gotten our report, and they're like, oh, by the way, my insurance is also asking me to do something above and beyond that, you know, and those kind of questions, and more about educational, but we haven't had an interaction with the insurance companies themselves or tried to align anything. We don't give our information to the insurance companies either, right? Like, the only person we share it with is the homeowner. But, and again, it's their right to be able to.

1:14:59 To ask you to do more things. I'm just trying to collaborate efforts where we can. I understand. Yeah. And there's such so few people that are doing it, I understand right now that it's just a potential opportunity. You know, frankly, we've probably tried to stay away from the insurance company because they're usually not bringing good news to the homeowner. And we really didn't want to get associated with them. But I don't disagree that there's overlap in a lot of times what we're asking them to do and what the insurance company is asking them to do.

1:15:29 Yeah, and I think, too, just jumping in real quick, how can we, you know, do a better job of re-engaging those folks, to your point? You know, Fireside offers a lot of services, whether it's mailers, things like that, but another big thing that we want to work on as part of this process as well is, you know, getting a website up and, like, all those kind of soft things where we hope we can really...

1:15:51 Engage the community, even those folks who may have gotten an assessment already, folks who haven't, that maybe an assessment is coming. And this is the type of feedback that we're looking for, right, to help inform how we can do this better, how we can engage the community to make this more successful in the future. My understanding with FireAside is that it gives us an overall risk assessment for the community, and that will change over time based on the work that we do. Is that correct?

1:16:21 The fireside software itself doesn't do that or program is it, but it works well to export its data into other software programs that can model the risk. So we are working, White Bark has used some of those for some of the modeling around town. Areas like Truckee are using some of those other ones. So we're looking into that possibility because that's what we'd like to be able to do is show the community over time, have a time lapse, if you will, and show that as people do stuff in neighborhoods.

1:16:50 They see more properties transition from red to orange to yellow or something like that. But it's not, it's, Fireside itself doesn't do that. It's more a, it does, it is able to export the data to support some of the other land planning tools. And then I just want to say to the task force, thank you so much for, you know, I see you back there, Chief DeMeyer, and everybody who,

1:17:14 Participated in this because I feel like we've made huge strides in one year and that's so gratifying. So thank you. John, do you have any comments or questions? Yeah, a couple things. I think I would recommend you do what you think is best but I think that the idea of kind of the legacy idea of a fire season is maybe something that you might want to scrub because we know it's a year-round thing and whether things are happening in the field or you guys are doing work, this is a year-round proposition.

1:17:45 The question that Chris asked about Fireside, you're talking about platforms like Vibrant Planet and those kinds of things, right? Those are the things we get to, very expensive. Okay. And then a question on Camp High Sierra, that's kind of an interesting piece of property. It's L.A. Parks, as I understand, with a lease. The mountains have got a lease on it, and there's some tribal interest in there. Can you engage with...

1:18:13 Complex properties and landscapes like that? You know, obviously we were foraying into some of those bigger projects this year and kind of seeing where the skill level of our thing is. Because of those complexities, that parcel is not one where you could really come in and, like a professional logging company, what comes in with machinery and cuts and drags things out of there. This had to be done by hand. So nobody really wanted to bid on the work, which is why we kind of stepped up to do it. But yes, we engaged the local tribe relationship.

1:18:43 We worked with a registered professional forester that was kind of going through their marketing. We had some biologists come in there and help. It's labor intensive. It was labor intensive, but it's such an area that's, again, one of the few big geographical parcels that we felt would be worth kind of testing the waters with it. And I'd like to say it was pretty successful, but it was hard work. Yeah, yeah. And the mountain was, they were,

1:19:12 Cooperative and they worked well with you guys, right? Yes, they were. I mean, there was some resistance a while ago. There was some. There was and, you know, we worked not right in the campsites. We were working above the campsites. Right. But yes, they're trying to protect the experience for campers and stuff like that. And so, but as you've seen, as we've seen with homeowners, everybody's kind of position and attitude is evolving. Right. Right. And they realize that you can kind of clean this stuff up.

1:19:38 And we still live in a forest with a whole bunch of trees. Right. Final question, on the federal side, outside of the hole in the donut, the federal government has announced the formation of something called the U.S. Wildland Fire Service. Are you guys monitoring the development of that? At the same time, are we talking with our partners in the Indian National Forest? We'll talk about this a bit later when we start talking about strategies and things like that.

1:20:06 A lot of the federal capacity is being dismantled on like every front you can think of. Are we factoring those kinds of things into the work that you're doing? Will you be at a point to be able to advise the council and the community what that situation looks like and if we have to take more aggressive steps in the interest of public safety? Yeah, I think we're going to keep an eye on that. I don't know how that's exactly going to look at this point, but I think

1:20:35 We've all seen, I think, whether it's Fire Protection District or Town of Mammoth Lakes take a more active role as it relates to the federal infrastructure, whether that's more in my world of kind of recreation. Obviously, we've seen Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District often be some of the first to respond, even if there's a little cigarette butt fire in the median, you know, north of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Fire is always there. So we are certainly monitoring that situation.

1:21:02 Trying to see how that will affect the capacity in this area, and then hopefully be able to bring that to you all and make the best decisions possible. But I'd like to think that, you know, with the situation that's occurred at the federal level, especially more in my world, right, that's what we've seen some of those immediate impacts in recreation that we're kind of diving in.

1:21:20 To create the level of service that we want, and we want to do that same sort of thing as it relates to public safety. Okay, because I know we've talked at the beginning of this, we talked a lot about who could respond and who can go different places. I think at some point if we get down the road with this to really have a situational awareness for the council and the community, look, if something happens here, this is how we're going to deal with it, because no fire can start, I think, is the end of the day. And I'm sure, Lawson, that joint strategy for sustainable recreation is dust-free on your desk and work.

1:21:47 Of course it is. Of course it is. Yeah. We're seeing how we can incorporate that strategically. We'll be a part of all kind of existing projects and new projects as we move forward with hopefully some new projects in the pipeline, hopefully as we move through and complete projects like that. Yeah, because these are all multi-benefit things. Yeah, 100%. John, just to clarify, I will clarify one thing. We talked about where we finally have a draft agreement. It's not in place yet, but a draft agreement with the Forest Service that we're working on getting finalized.

1:22:15 That really enables us to do fuels reduction work on federal land. It also deals with our fire response. But to be clear, we haven't had one for the past year and a half. We still go to every fire. And we will go to a fire. Whether that agreement is in place or not, we will work and honor our deal with the Forest Service, even that existed before that agreement expired. And we do respond off scenic loop, off 385, federal land.

1:22:41 They respond to stuff here close to town. We respond as well. It has not stopped anything on the fire response service. Understood. But as capacities change and things move around, this is a conversation we need to deal with ongoing. And I have a few comments for you as well. So I guess with the next step that we're going to be looking at is inspecting condos, I guess I anticipate that we need to get their permission to go on their property because I think, you know, like,

1:23:10 The condo that I own, you can't really see very much from the street. So I think a lot of these condo, I think a lot of the condos, the inspections would be so much more helpful if you were allowed to walk around the complex and see. So that's one of my comments. Thank you so much for putting this together. I know that you guys did this in a hurry. And then, so I do have some feedback from my personal home inspection.

1:23:40 I don't know that the general public knows that you need to be invited onto their property. So for my inspection, my husband happened to be outside. And so he was talking to the person that was doing the inspection. And, you know, like we have our wood uncovered in the backyard. I know I need to buy a tarp, but it's, to be honest, I feel like looking on, shopping online for it, I'm like, I don't know what the requirements are. I don't know how big of one I need. So there's just kind of.

1:24:08 I've been procrastinating on that because there's some things that make it difficult for me personally to do that. So, you know, like my husband did chat with him and say, oh yeah, you know, our wood's uncovered. And the person, you know, I think we were maybe one of the first ones because the guy's response was, oh, well, my wood is too. You know, he didn't put it in the report. We didn't know about the free tarp program. And...

1:24:32 Then when I got the report, I just think it would be, I don't know if this is possible, but it would be super simple if you got a letter that was like X, Y, and Z needs to be done. So, because I got the postcard and then it took me a few days to be like, okay, I got to log into this and then I had to like create a username and it was a little bit tedious and then looking at my personal report, one of the things was very clear.

1:24:57 about like the violation or you know what could be corrected and then the second thing I didn't know what it was telling me that I should do and I didn't really I didn't understand what the problem was or how to correct it and it didn't have a lot more information and then I did like send an email to the email listed and I didn't get a response and so I just want to make sure you know with all this effort that we're putting in that

1:25:26 We get the most benefit to the community. And if people don't understand their reports or it's tedious to get the information or they lost the postcard. And now at this point, like I would like to log back in, but I've lost the postcard and I don't have that information. So, you know, I think like sending a follow-up letter.

1:25:48 With this information to re-log back in, especially if people have not logged in, you know, I think that would be really helpful. I've heard really wonderful things about the chipping program. People are really happy with that, and I would love to continue doing that. I do have a neighbor who always complains about pine needles, that you're limited in how many pine needles you can bring on a daily basis, and so it's cumbersome for her.

1:26:17 So I don't know, you know, if we had a spot to bring pine needles all the time and it was unlimited or something, I think that would be great. Let's see. And then I think the firewood tarp covering program is amazing. I think limbing trees for people and cutting down dead trees should be a priority. And I kind of wonder.

1:26:43 In my neighborhood, I've noticed there are some dead trees that are kind of near property lines, and I don't know that people always know whose responsibility. Certain trees, like whose property they're on and who should get them cut down, and, you know, there is a significant cost involved in getting large dead trees taken out. So, you know, I think those are all

1:27:07 Good things to look into. And the shake roofs, I think, you know, my neighbor has a shake roof and it's very close to another neighbor who's done a lot of home hardening. And, you know, but that roof is about 10 feet or less away from their house. And so they really feel vulnerable and they're, you know, they can't buy their neighbor a new roof, but it would benefit the neighborhood. And, you know, I know that we're doing all these fire-wise communities. And so I think that...

1:27:37 You know, we're stronger. Like, we're only as strong as our weakest link. So, you know, this really needs to be a community effort to keep us as safe as we can be. And then I think that's, I think those were all of my notes. But thank you so much for coming. Are there any other comments or public comments on this item? Anyone online? No? Are we good? Okay, wonderful. Thank you, gentlemen, for coming. So we'll be moving on to the consent agenda.

1:28:08 Would anyone like to pull anything before I read through it? No? Okay, so we have 8.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 3rd, 2025. 8.2, adopt the resolution approving an updated credit card policy for the town of Mammoth Lakes. 8.3, adopt the resolution approving the development impact fees report pursuant to the Mitigation Fee Act AB 1600.

1:28:34 8.4, continue approval of emergency contract for town yard waste oil tank replacement. 8.5, accept check register November 26, 25 in the amount of $129,075.76. I would entertain a motion. I move to approve as read. I'll second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes.

1:29:02 Mayor Pro Temp Turex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, motion passes. And now we will be moving on to agenda item number nine, public hearings. Thank you. Madam Mayor, again, I have to recuse from this because my property is evidently within too close of a proximity. Well, we will miss you. So, Councilmember Salzer will recuse himself and we're moving on to 9.1.

1:29:33 Public hearing for the consideration of an appeal of the October 8, 2025 Planning and Economic Development Commission, decision to approve the 54 Mono Street Apartments entitlement application, consisting of use permit 24-003, design review 24-006, and adjustment 25-005. Thank you, Mayor Rice. I will sort of introduce a little bit of this. If you remember this particular public hearing,

1:30:04 The Town Council engaged in this back on November 19th and I think at that time we received a presentation from staff and there were comments received from both the appellant and the property owner at 54 Mono Street with regard to their positions. At that point in time through much of the deliberations in what was received

1:30:30 It was requested of counsel, I think by the appellant's attorney, to provide for some time with which things could get worked out and potentially better understood. So there was a request for a 30-day extension in that process, and that is what the counsel granted that evening. And so I think I'd like to ask if a solution has been reached thus far.

1:31:04 You made an offer to the project proponent to go to court and resolve this very quickly. That was, and I think you've seen that in the letters that you've received. That was rejected by the proponent who said it would take a year and a half to two years and $200,000 to litigate this. So we were not successful in that regard. Okay. Hi, this is attorney Hanif Hirji on behalf of Mr. Bipin Morari.

1:31:38 As all of you are aware, if offering to litigate something is not offering a settlement, if me and somebody have an issue between ourselves and we're trying to resolve something, it's not a settlement offer for me to say, sue me. And that's basically the settlement offer we did receive. Our client, on the other hand, made lots of settlement offers to the Ericsons, including

1:32:08 Offering to sell the land at his cost and walk away without even a penny of profit after spending three years getting plans prepared, getting them approved by the Planning Commission. We even offered to bring all the utilities of sewer and water to their property for free since they don't have sewer lines and water lines as part of the construction. They did not accept that either.

1:32:35 We even offered to build the entire paved driveway at our cost and maintain it for all future years. They did not accept that. We even tried to appease their concerns about people parking on the driveway and blocking the ingress, egress by letting them know that all the driveways would be parked, would be painted red, there'd be signs that say no parking, violators to be towed away. Our client even offered to engage.

1:33:05 A local toll service to enforce this no parking. I mean, we actually made settlement offers that you can consider settlement offers. They basically told us go to court and we're sure we can resolve this in court in two months. If anybody's ever been to court, they know there's no such thing as filing a lawsuit and having a resolution achieved within 60 days unless you're watching a TV show.

1:33:32 So, unfortunately, we engaged in good faith settlement. They engaged in go to court and see you later. So I just want to make sure that's clear to the Council, to the Honorary Council. Thank you. Thank you for those comments from both parties. I appreciate that. As that was the request made of Council, and I think Council granted that extra time for some potential discussion back and forth and consideration.

1:33:58 It brings us back to the task at hand this evening, which is the appeal provided to the council for determination of whether the planning and economic development decision is in any question. So I will then turn it back to you. There's no staff presentation unless there are questions that you have this evening. I think based on it being a public hearing, there's an opening and closing. Is that correct? Yes, I think that the council should accept public comment again.

1:34:26 Although the hearing had been closed last time, but just in the spirit of transparency, I'd suggest that you allow the parties to speak. Okay, wonderful. The public hearing is now open. Following all public comments, staff will provide responses to any issues raised or questions asked. Good evening. My name is Paul Rudder. I'm appearing on behalf of the appellants. I'd like to thank the council for listening.

1:34:57 to our concerns for reading all those letters that have gone back and forth, the response to the response to the response and so forth. I want to apologize to the council because I feel like I put you in a difficult spot. I've asked you to do what I think is right by the Eriksons. I think your council is going to advise you or already has to do what he believes is a safe thing. And as a council, your position

1:35:27 More often than not is that you just have to do the safe thing. I understand that. And to the extent that I've created any concerns or anxiety, once again, I apologize. I do want to point out something, though. The most recent letter from Mr. Hanif contains some misstatements of fact and some threats against the town that I believe is what someone does when they realize they don't have a good case.

1:35:57 Mr. Hanif says that we offered to grant an easement to their entire project. Nothing in my letter says that. We have an obligation when you have a landlocked parcel under the law to allow the landlocked parcel to have access. We have offered to give them that access, not to allow a giant real estate development, but to give them some access at the beginning of the property. Whether or not that's sufficient for their...

1:36:25 Real estate development is neither here nor there under the law. We offer them the minimum access that the law requires. Mr. Neff also said that if you have the temerity to deny the project proponent's request, the town might as well buy their parcel for $295,000.

1:36:50 We make no such threats. We have no intention of suing the town. We will go to court to protect the Ericsson's rights in this matter. But we have no intention of suing the town. Nothing could be further from our minds. I do, once again, I appreciate the town council hearing all of this, considering all of this. I know that's what you do. I think you do it very well. And the Ericssons appreciate it, and so do I.

1:37:20 Thank you. Hi, this is attorney Hanif Hirji again, and I'll keep this really, really brief. I'm not sure if the city council does or does not record its Zoom meetings, but if you go back to the last meeting, Mr. Rudder specifically stated that if the project goes forward, then his clients are going to sue the city. So what he just stated right now was a misstatement.

1:37:55 And the recent email I wrote, I clearly quoted the language he put in his email stating they would give as much of the easement back as the fire department deems necessary for the project. So if the fire department was to state that 50 feet by 50 feet is needed, then the Ericsson's agree. But let's get back to the real bottom line. The dispute is not between the council and the Ericsson's.

1:38:24 The dispute is between Erickson and the person who sold them the property for putting in language in the deed that the Erickson's interpret as giving them the sole right to use the easement versus what's a normal interpretation. That means both the landowner and Erickson's can use the driveway because without that the landowner himself would be landlocked. But the dispute is between the Erickson's

1:38:54 And Sonderman. The city from day one when they approved the subdivision clearly stated in the conditions. It's the first condition that was listed on the list of conditions when they gave the approval for the subdivision that the driveway will be shared. So the city's never, the town has never taken an inconsistent position with that point. In 2023, almost two years ago,

1:39:24 When this dispute arose, the city manager researched it with other members of the town and drafted a letter stating clearly that it was the town's position, that the driveway was always shared as per the original conditions and that they would have no way allowed an easement that in effect would landlock.

1:39:53 The very parcel that granted the easement, and he signed it along with Mr. Saunderman. And the Eriksons knew about that letter because they received a copy. They did not object to that letter. They didn't go up and down screaming to court saying the town manager has signed a document that goes against our rights on the easement. So the town again took a position consistent with the original conditions that the driveway will be shared.

1:40:22 And then, the Planning Commission, in approving these permits, also researched and reviewed the entire history of this parcel, the subdivision approval, and everything that's occurred, and they also reached a conclusion that this driveway is shared. Now, all three parts of the town leading up to this meeting, this public hearing in front of the council, have already determined

1:40:53 That the driveway is shared. So it would be, it would put the council in a position to say that the original subdivision conditions are wrong. We're determining that today. That the town manager was wrong when he signed a letter saying that the driveway is shared. And even our planning commission this year after listening to the Ericsson's and still approving the permits is also wrong in granting the permits.

1:41:24 Which to me, if already three different departments over a period of 30, 35 years have determined that the driveway is shared, the council should not overrule that extensive research and work that's been done by so many people. And let's look at the facts. Are the Erickson's going to be impeded in ingress on egress to their property by this development? No.

1:41:53 They're going to have the same ability to ingress and egress to their property. In fact, they're going to have a better ingress and egress because there'll be a nice paved road that will be built at no expense to them, that will be maintained at no expense to them. And our client went all out of his way to go ahead and make all kinds of settlement offers. My statement as far as

1:42:21 Stating that if the council decides to uphold the appeal and go against all the prior rulings of the town going back to 1990, 2023, and recently in 2025, states that our client is landlocked and cannot develop his land, then the council should... Can you please finish your thought? Your five minute timer just beeped. I apologize. I'm done.

1:42:49 Oh, thank you so much. I'm truly done. Everything I've stated has already been in my emails. I appreciate your time. Thank you so much. I think it's time for the council just to make a vote. Okay, thank you for your comments. Are there any more public comments? No, you may not. You have five minutes of public comment? I won't read five. You already had your five minutes of public comment. You had your five minutes of public comment, and then he had his five minutes of public comment. Are there any other five minutes of public comment? Would anyone else like to approach the podium?

1:43:20 No? Okay. Are there any public comments online? No? Okay. Since there are no more public comments, the hearing is closed. We may now deliberate on the topic or consider a motion. Would anyone like to share their thoughts? If we're in deliberation, just a couple different things. I try to word it and I've kind of...

1:43:48 Think of how to express it. Oh, I guess, I guess, I'm sorry. I'm going to do comments and questions. Are there any comments or questions for the council? And then we'll deliberate. I have no questions. A question. Is there a vote threshold for this? Two. The municipal code says that a tie vote will result in denying the appeal and upholding the PEDC decision. But it's a simple majority. It's not a four-fifths. That's right. Okay, thank you. Are there any other questions? No? Okay, I'll take comments.

1:44:19 All right. What I was starting to say is, you know, when the council voted a month ago to extend and come back tonight, and this is a little bit personal versus all that we've heard, it's disappointing in some ways that the parties have not been able to at least engage in a more productive, amiable solution. I thought there might be more dialogue and verbiage that might have taken place. It is what it is, but I just have one part of the deliberation that I'm...

1:44:48 I wrote it down so I kind of get my words where I want it to be. You know, while the possibility of future litigation is understandably a concern for the parties involved, references to potential legal action, liability exposure, or anticipated court outcomes are not, in themselves, grounds for appeal under the municipal code. As council members, our responsibility is to base our decision on the applicable code, provisions, and the administrative record before us.

1:45:15 Rather than on speculative or contingent legal scenarios that may arise out of this process. So with that, I have a challenge seeking that there's been new evidence that's come forth that would make me want to reverse the commission's decision, and I'd be looking forward to uphold the decision and reject the appeal. Okay. I think I understood what you said. So you would be in favor of denying the appeal? Correct. Okay. Are there any other?

1:45:46 Deliberations on this side and comments? Do you have any comments? Go ahead. This dispute is not within the jurisdiction of the council to resolve. The town has a difficult and painful history with these types of disputes in which the town has courts, Supreme Court of the State of California has ruled that the town was liable for egregious errors.

1:46:18 And so I'm disappointed and I'm leery of the process that was used and how this was presented to the council. We got delivered kind of a burning fire. And I would hope that in the future, planning commission and staff would make it really point these kinds of things out, that there's an active contested dispute.

1:46:47 Having to do with the decision that may be coming to the council. It didn't really come to us that way, but that would be helpful in the future. That being said, given the fact that there was an opportunity for parties to get together and try to figure something out, I'm going to very reluctantly go along with what you're saying, Brent, to deny the appeal. And I think this is not in our bailiwick. We don't have any jurisdiction on this. If you all got to go to court.

1:47:14 Go to court. But this is not anything that we have any jurisdiction over. So those are my thoughts. Yes? And not to be too repetitive, but, you know, I think it's important for everyone to understand that I think all the members of the council have spent a lot of time and energy trying to understand this issue and then trying to make sure we come to the best decision. So ultimately, my takeaways are that this is a land use appeal only, and so we can only address those issues.

1:47:44 That exclusive easements exist, but I really went deep on this. They are rare, narrowly construed, and cannot be enforced by this council in the absence of much more information. So, you know, I think that what we're determining was whether the PEDC

1:48:04 acted correctly within the law and based on substantial evidence, which they did. So I think it's very important for us to understand that our responsibility as a council is to affirm the PEDC decision and deny the appeal. Thank you. I'm not hearing further discussion, so I'd entertain a motion. Okay. Would you like this? You have it.

1:48:31 I would move that we deny the appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Commission decision and affirm the approval of Use Permit 24-003, Design Review 24-006, and Adjustment 25-005. I'll second. Jamie, roll call please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Reluctantly, yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Can I...

1:49:02 Ask a clarifying question. Did that motion include adoption of the resolution attached to the staff report in the packet? No. Do we need to add that in? It might be helpful to adopt that resolution if the resolution is consistent with your findings. And affirm the approval of use permit 24? Yes. Well, it did say deny the appeal and affirm the approval of use permit.

1:49:30 I think it would be helpful to have a record in the form of this resolution if the resolution reflects your findings. And affirm the resolution. And adopt the resolution. Adopt the resolution. Okay. Do I need to make a new motion or do I need to amend my original motion? Well, your motion's already been acted upon, so I think you would need a new motion. I would make a new motion that for the...

1:49:58 Council denied the appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Commission decision and affirmed the approval of Use Permit 24-003, Design Review 24-006, and Adjustment 25-005, and affirmed the resolution. I think you have to adopt the resolution. And adopt the resolution attached. Attached in the staff report. Is that enough? Okay. Okay. Do we have a motion? I'll second. Janie?

1:50:29 Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Reluctantly, once again, yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, moving on. Would you like to, can we go get Bill back in here? Oh yeah. Okay, we'll wait for a Bill. It is, we missed you.

1:51:20 No, we missed you. Okay. We are moving on to item 9.2, consideration of second reading and adoption of an ordinance amending Title 15 of the Municipal Code for the purpose of adopting the 2025 California Building Standards Code. Tom Perry is, oh, oh, sorry. Oops, I got to flip my paper. Okay. And, well, are you going to make, okay.

1:51:49 So yes, this is the public hearing for the consideration of the ordinance to amend Title 15 of the Municipal Code for adopting the 2025 California Building Standards Code. This item was introduced at the December 3rd Town Council meeting where a presentation on the proposed changes was made. Additional information on the code changes is available in the staff report as well. This public hearing is intended to provide an opportunity for public comments prior to Town Council action.

1:52:19 With that, the mayor already opened the public hearing, so I'll ask that the mayor then invite anyone who wishes to provide public comments to make those. Are there any comments online? I don't see any comments in the room. So I will now close the hearing. We may now deliberate on the topic or consider a motion to adopt the ordinance. Any comments? Move to adopt as presented. Second. Okay. Jamie, roll call, please.

1:52:53 Council Member Bubzer? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, motion passes. And we are moving on to item 10, policy matters. 10.1, authorize the town manager to execute a contract to purchase partition walls and casework for the town hall. As Tom Perry goes away, he's like, that was the easiest hearing I've ever had. I wasn't even ready. Good evening.

1:53:25 For you tonight is a request to authorize the town manager to execute a contract to partition the partition walls for the Civic Center. And this could have gone on consent, but I'd be remiss if I didn't take an opportunity to provide you a chance to ask questions about the Civic Center project and kind of talk a little bit more about what is a pretty large purchase that we discussed quite some time ago.

1:53:50 Dirt partition wall system was something we identified early on as an option to maintain flexible workspaces. We had a conversation at town council about removing the hard walls in the larger offices and using flexible partition walls so that over time we can adapt and change. We determined that the cost of the partition walls was slightly cheaper than the hard surface walls and about, you know, pretty good comparable price.

1:54:18 So it made a lot of sense at that time. But it is a separate contract. It is something that we have to get approval from you distinctly and separately from the construction contract. Financially, the project is in really good shape. We identified a healthy contingency early on to support the construction, and we've done a pretty good job of managing that this far. We had set aside money specifically for furniture and this partition wall that is still in reserves.

1:54:47 However, we're not asking to use those funds. What we're recommending is using the contingency so that we're staying within that original budget. We believe we will be pretty close to that dollar amount. We do believe we will have to go into the reserve funding for some of the furniture that was anticipated, but we like the idea of reserving that capital for other projects in the future and really trying to work within that contingency.

1:55:11 Additionally, we're using a CMAS contract for the purchase and the installation of this because it is independent of our construction contract. We work with the town attorney on what that process looks like. They pay prevailing wages. But the CMAS process basically, they negotiate contracts on behalf of other agencies. And so they get really, really good pricing. I did not have the dollars and cents in the staff report because I did not have them.

1:55:41 I actually got them this morning. The price tag was just about $890,000 all in for the construction, delivery, all the products, freight, and taxes, you name it. So we were expecting it to be slightly higher, so we were actually pretty happy with that number. We were thinking it was going to be in the neighborhood of just over a million. With that, happy to answer any questions you have. Any questions? Just answer my question. Once this is installed,

1:56:11 Staff will have the ability to move things around and modify and do what you need to do with it should you need to do something with it. Yeah, within, it takes some work. We can move things around. You have to order parts and so forth, but it's a kit of parts. So once it's installed, if we want to move some office around or combine some spaces, they have everything in their system. It's all bar-coded, and we can say, hey, we want to move this or change this, and they can produce it and set it down, and then we can install it.

1:56:39 But would they have to come up here to do it, or is that something we can do all in-house? It depends on the complexity. They have a process where they train staff to use their system. It is kind of proprietary. We do anticipate having one of our staff members train to do certain activities. If it was a large rehab, like we're stripping it down and kind of moving our Legos around to be something different, we'd probably contract that out just for efficiency. I'd like to add something to that, too. Just the utilization of this product alone.

1:57:09 It gives it flexibility into the future, right? This building is going to be ours for the rest of our lifetime, and I think we want it to be able to be morphed as needs change across time, and so rather than building in specific walls and units, this product was selected because it can be completely removed and jettisoned if that becomes necessary for some other use. It's basically a large shell with some

1:57:36 Built-in areas where we need good insulation from sound and so forth, but it's really modularity inside, and so I think that's maybe what you're alluding to. It does have flexibility to be reconfigured into something into the future, but again, it would require large-scale, and I think Hayes answered that appropriately. If you were going to do something very large-scale like that, it would be probably contracted to be done, but minor modifications would be something we would try to do ourselves. Yeah, but it would be cheaper, even if a major modification would probably be cheaper than having to...

1:58:04 Thank you very much. So if you decide in the future we want a completely open plan situation, you could do it. I think it's been a while since we reviewed the plans with all of you. I would say they're largely very open.

1:58:19 The building itself has glass features and walls for a lot of natural lighting. And then the design that Hayes and team have been putting together is designed to capture that and spread it throughout the entire facility. So the bulk of the workspaces are open and not inside of one of these. So it's definitely open already. And I can't imagine it being much more open, but that's possible. But it does give us flexibility for the future, which is important. Great. Thank you. And also thank you for bringing this to us because

1:58:49 I guess these are still questions, but, you know, I prefer to have somebody at this not on consent because it just reminds us about things that we might forget about otherwise. So thank you. I do have one more question. Are the walls envisioned to be solid walls? Because dirt makes a variety of ones where there's glass and other things. Are these solid partitions?

1:59:14 Yeah, they're solid, and they have a variety of different textures depending on where they're going. Some of them have whiteboards, magnet boards, fabric for acoustics, wood paneling for different looks and feel. It's sharp, but it's tailored to exactly the use for the different offices and spaces. I forgot to mention, we tested this at the CRC. The offices that were built for the recreation staff are the same product.

1:59:42 So that was a case study to make sure that we were happy with the look, feel, texture, structural stability of the system, and we're quite pleased with it. It's working out well. We will have some differences in an office, you know, for acoustics and, you know, sound and privacy, but we were pretty happy with how it came out. Great. Any other questions or comments? Any public comment? No one in the room? Anyone online? No? Okay.

2:00:12 I will entertain a motion. I move that we authorize the town manager to finalize terms and execute a contract to acquire dirt partition walls and case work for the town hall. Second. Can I do a point of order? Can we put the price in there? So there's a... I think if there's any change in tax or anything, it will have to come back to us then.

2:00:41 I mean, I thought it was using the contingency, so it's not using any more dollars. No, I understand, but we're authorizing the town manager to sign an open-ended contract. Well, you could put an NTE of 1.1, which gives them, you know, leeway. I'm not super worried, but usually they put a constraint on it. If I may, the reason we left it open-ended, like I said, we didn't have the final number.

2:01:03 And so I didn't want to shortchange it, and that's why we put it within the contingency. That would be within Rob's ability to expand up to that dollar amount. I know, but just going on the other side, and technically by authorizing this, Rob could spend $5 million. I'm just saying, we're authorizing him to do that, and it could change price. I'll amend my motion to say that we will authorize the manager to finalize terms the next year of the contract.

2:01:30 To acquire the dirt partition walls and case work for the town hall up to the amount of the contingency. Is that acceptable? Yes. Okay. I'll amend my second. Is it a third now or is it a second? No. Roll call please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes.

2:01:58 Okay, and we are on to item number 10.2, discuss amendments to Town Council's strategic priorities for 2026. Oh, yay, you're the best, Chris. Oh, wow, thank you so much. And Jamie, she couldn't get there either. Thank you very much. Oh, thank you. What is that, Ginger? Mayor Rice, would you like to take a five-minute break? Do we want to take a five-minute break? Let's take a five-minute break. Okay, five-minute break.

2:02:27 See you all at 6.05. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, so this is one kind. This is two kinds. And this is three kinds. There we go.

2:02:55 You want some chocolate chip? You want some chocolate chip? No, that's okay.

2:03:20 Hey Keith, how you doing?

2:03:40 All right. Cheese! I got a cookie in my hand. Thank you. Yeah, I know. We're all, like, chowing down.

2:08:18 All right. Very ironic. I have it printed out for you, but I'll give it to you. Okay. I think we are ready to begin, and we are on item number 10.2. If you'd like to continue any conversations in the hall, we'd love to keep going here. Thank you very much. Thank you. We are on item number 10.2, discuss amendments to town council strategic priorities for 2026.

2:08:45 Thank you, Mayor Rice. Yes, this evening we are going to discuss modifications, if necessary, to our strategic priorities from Council priorities for 2026. If you remember last meeting, we did talk a little bit about the accomplishments serving to inform our modifications that may be necessary. In the staff report, let me get this pulled up here, if I may.

2:09:17 We were able to kind of walk through each of the strategic priorities as they were defined by council in 2025 and suggest modifications from the staff's perspective on how things have modified, what has been substantially completed, what needed to be slightly updated, if you will, and then just our recommendations. And this was purely what was provided by staff. I do apologize in the staff report itself. I uploaded that.

2:09:47 With the red line version, my intent was to provide to the council what the original one, the red line version of that, which means the original wording there, but lined through along with what was suggested for modifications. I understand, Stu helped me with the upload on that, that once I uploaded it, all the sort of

2:10:08 Redlined elements disappeared, so Stu went in and manually redlined it for me, and I appreciate that effort. I do think that there were some things lost in there, like the original content of the item. So on the actual slides that we're going to go through here in a minute, you will see the original redlined versions that I intended for you to see. I just apologize, it was a little bit complex as we went through.

2:10:34 This, for all folks that may be watching, is our council strategic priorities. We like it to be to one page. It has four quadrants, public safety, community investment, municipal services, recreation amenities and programs. And underneath those, there were a number of bullet points that supported those statements. We realized when we spent a very long time last year,

2:11:01 And what I would like to hear from Council is either an affirmation that

2:11:30 These modifications or no modifications are intended. Or if there are council members who would like to make modifications, I'd like to hear that. And then you guys can weigh and discuss those individually. And I'd like to see consensus, which would mean three or more saying yes, we would like to see those modifications. We are not adopting this tonight. We're not voting on this tonight. We're seeking input from them. What staff will do is take that input back

2:12:00 We will provide another opportunity the first meeting of January to do a final review of the language, potential additional wordsmithing if necessary, and then we would seek adoption in that particular council meeting. So are there any questions before I go into this? Okay. This is the first item, which was public safety and protection. As we talked about the suggested edits in this,

2:12:28 We do have several emergency plans currently in place. We had a need for a strike team or response team, emergency response team, and the development of more defined training capacity and practice materials that we've decided that we need to build. So I kind of changed the word to develop in there and then added the response team.

2:12:55 And then augmenting the emergency management operations. Those are fairly consistent and sort of wanted to add the component of education because we do believe that in this emergency management, it's not just the strength of what the town's response is going to be. It's going to be the strength of the community's engagement with that and how they know what to do and when to do it based upon practicing and other sort of training exercises community-wide.

2:13:25 So I'd like to entertain if there's any suggestions on these modifications. John? Okay, so just to be clear here, if I get this wrong, your proposed language would be, develop the town's emergency response team and augment emergency management operations, public notification and education. That's correct. So the paragraph down below is just informational, it's not anything to be intended?

2:13:55 It's not a part of the item at all. It's just a narrative to explain why either the modifications were necessary or no modifications were suggested. Okay, so a minor question is the last sentence says all of these plans, but these aren't plans, right? This is capacity is what you're talking about. Yeah, what I was referencing there is I had communicated to council before that this strike team format.

2:14:22 Had a series of sort of timelines that I was trying to meet that included identification of the team, initiation of the training, development of the training and testing within the community and then sort of implementation of all. And I wanted to have that completed within 12 months and so I was referring to those plans to being that particular plan. Okay, it's like lower P plans, not somebody to adopt or... Correct.

2:14:52 Thank you. That's my only question. Anyone else? No? Okay. I'm happy with these changes. Uh-huh. All right. So this one was under public safety, enhancing wildfire, natural disaster safety, resilience through collaborative and integrated framework partners to complete and implement necessary mitigation plans. We really had no recommended edits for this.

2:15:20 We do, you did receive a very comprehensive update from the task force this evening. We have indicated the modifications that we need to make to that program. And so I think we still think it's valid and can move forward. Okay? Moving on to the facility optimization. So the Mammoth Yosemite Airport team has been working very diligently on this particular

2:15:51 And that is really modifying the use of the airport, the capacities and capabilities of the airport, even with infrastructure development that could make it much more viable for fast emergency response. The work that's been done has really been to engage with a lot of our partners who may want to cohabitate on the airfield, at least the land side of that, with their facilities.

2:16:17 And engage with air resources on air side. And that's been the majority of the work. So I just wanted to provide, you know, regional support for those services because I think that's where I see the most work being accomplished. And this is going to be a fairly long road, but I think it's a really strong one that we've started down. And there's really good engagement thus far, but it's a regional one. And then we changed the word utilization to optimization also, right? I just on my...

2:16:48 I just noticed from my laminated copy it said facility utilization, right? Yeah, I must have changed that too. Apologize for not putting that in the red line. That's okay. Any comments on this? When you say provide regional, is there any financial component to that or is this just providing infrastructure that can serve on a regional basis if it's needed? What we're seeking when we talk to the partnerships and partners at the table are

2:17:20 Cal Fire and the CHP, a lot of the local agencies, Mono County as well. And what we're offering to them is sort of a concept and a plan and they can choose to engage in that and they would be providing funding for the development of infrastructure they want to build there. But it's really sort of getting a campus together that really can come and work on some similar emergency response or regional training center type efforts.

2:17:49 And so we're asking them to come in both with support financially and in the concept. Okay. At this point, this is the concept. Yeah, we're still building this out. And I think it has evolved quite a bit throughout 2025, and I know it will in 2026. I do hope to start receiving some commitments from agencies as we get this a little bit more. I think...

2:18:16 Presentable is what we're looking for, is getting this to be something we can really start to share outwardly and get people to buy into. And certainly I would assume with Monroe County. Yeah, Monroe County's been communicated with and they're a part of, there's potential for some infrastructure that they need to be relocated in their area. That's a possibility for sure. All right, and this is all consistent with the zoning uses at the airport.

2:18:41 Yes. It's aviation. It's kind of an aviation axis. Yeah, land side, it's got a little bit more flexibility, and so what these agencies are, though, they do have air resources, so they would be engaged almost in dual purposes.

2:18:57 But they're really more emergency response units. If you think about from law enforcement through CHP, through, you know, the medevac, medical, people that are already leasing space out in the airport, they're involved in that. CAL FIRE would be fire resources. They're required. I think their mission is to provide a fire station or fire response north of the grade. And so there's finding a location for that. And then just, you know, the whole...

2:19:25 Training facility needs, which would encompass most of Mono County's sort of disparate fire agencies that are out there. Certainly Long Valley, who really services the airport, would be a part of that. But it's just getting all those groups together for the training. Okay. So I think as we all know, there are, with the airport for the FAA, there are conditions about what kinds of uses we can do out there.

2:19:53 So it's broad enough as we can follow the law. For sure. And I agree, John, because I had a question before earlier. With Rob in regards to provide, I was trying to find a little slightly different word, but I'm good with the explanation. Yeah. Municipal services. We had no recommended edits to this. Basically, community engagement, increased community engagement and outreach efforts, including a focus on accountability and Spanish language offering. I think in this particular area, we've done quite a bit.

2:20:25 Especially with all of our engagement tools around planning projects that we have in place. The Spanish language work that was done by the town was extensive with regard to documentation. We have really good staff at the town that are a part of the Spanish-speaking community and what I would look to augment in that is more engagement opportunities and their ideas and thoughts around how that could be more effective.

2:20:54 Really, I think this is still all relevant. So I have a suggestion for this. And this is something I think I've been thinking about that we've all been thinking about for a while. It came up today in the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Meeting. And the proposal... Can you turn your microphone on, John? Sure. I do have an idea or suggestion for this. Okay. Something I've been thinking about, I'm sure we've all been thinking about for a while. And it's come up, the last two Mammoth Lakes Tourism Meetings is a need that I think, and maybe this is a place to put it. So I would...

2:21:25 Proposed a change to read as follow. Increased community engagement and outreach efforts, including a focus on accessibility in Spanish language offerings, along with the development and publication of AI values, that's artificial intelligence values, and policies to be used by the town. And I'm happy to have a discussion about this one. Who would be setting those policies? Town? Attorney? We are living in the age of artificial intelligence.

2:21:58 We're having discussions. It is going to upend Mammoth Lakes Tourism and how they do their work. It's not clear to the public or I think to any of us how the town is going to be engaging with artificial intelligence. It's a big lift, but I think we need to engage with this. I agree with that as a concept, but I just question whether it belongs in community engagement or if it belongs in townwide vision plans and services.

2:22:25 Put it anywhere you want. I was trying to keep this as simple as possible, but if this needs to go to another place, put it in another place. So I sort of think that it's already there. Thank you. I'm handicapped, you know. I think it's sort of already there in the broad scope of how this is written. I don't think we need to get into the, you know, we're going to have to deal with artificial intelligence, but this is part of the community engagement, increased community engagement, outreach efforts.

2:22:53 I think that the work that needs to be done already fits into how we have this in here. I like the idea that we keep it concise and quick and don't try to wordsmith it or put so much in that it doesn't fit on a page. Okay, well, help me find a home. Again, I was trying to do this as simply as possible. That I think we need to establish a direction from the council that we need to develop and articulate.

2:23:20 The values of how the town's going to use artificial intelligence and how the organization uses it. Are you talking about town staff during their daily duties and stuff? Town staff, whatever the town would think to be, the town's an organization. I mean, every organization in the country, in the world, is having to address this. The examples that are coming up right now with Mammoth Lakes Tourism is in their website, they want to be able to tell people about, they have a chat bot. They want to be able to have the bot tell people,

2:23:50 How to do things, whatever they're going to do. The chatbot right now is only consuming data from the Mammoth Lakes Tourism website. That chatbot, if the town comes up with these types of artificial intelligence policies, could be consuming data from the town. So that what's a visitor coming to the town, if they want to go to a destination, they want to do things that are related to things that town has as policies.

2:24:16 The data gets absorbed and consumed and becomes part of the outreach portal. I think at this point, it's getting to the point of being irresponsible that the town does not have a proactive statement, engagement, development, goal, aspiration to figure out how it's going to engage with artificial intelligence going forward.

2:24:38 Can I impose on you to read your sentence one more time? What's that? Can I impose on you to read your sentence one more time? Sure, and I'll read, I'll emphasize the relevant section. Again, I was trying to keep this simple, just put it in places where, to increase community engagement and outreach efforts, including a focus on accessibility in Spanish language offerings, along with the development and publication of artificial intelligence values and policies to be used by the town. See you.

2:25:06 I don't disagree with the statement. I kind of agree with this one. I don't know. I'm trying to figure out where it would fit because that's kind of an overarching principle for many. So if I may, let me help a little bit. You want to do a parking lot thing? We could put it in a parking lot, figure out where to put it. I've got a suggestion for you guys. So this is a strategic priority planning session. I think what I'm hearing is from Councilmember Wentworth, there's a desire to have a future council agenda item that addresses a policy around use of AI.

2:25:35 Uh, in, for the town services. So I think that can be, uh, as simply as directing staff to kind of come forward with that as a council, uh, council, um, lost my word, uh, with regard to consensus, uh, to, to bring that forward. I don't know that it needs to be put into the strategic priority. Uh, it might just be simply for me to bring this forward and I can do that. Okay, but I, and I would agree with that.

2:26:05 I believe it's already here. And with your concerns being noted by staff, staff would then bring us back something to deal with that as part of this piece. That would be fine. I think it's a little more than just right there, though. I think it is...

2:26:21 It's a separate entity in its own, and I think that's what it needs to kind of come up as a policy discussion for council. And I think that's what's being requested. And so I recognize that and can make those future items. I think that would be fine. Thank you. Thank you, Rob. I think it's a bigger thing. Yeah, if we can get started on it, then that's great. So thank you. So the next aye.

2:26:58 The next item is public safety, continuing to evaluate public safety needs to protect our community visitors and officers. We have no evidence to this, but it's really written broadly enough to encompass the work that we're trying to get accomplished. The focus for 2026 really needed to get our recruitment strategies and attract personnel to our police department. That's kind of been a big challenge for us and some modifications are attempted.

2:27:28 That would improve that. So recommending no modifications to this. Okay. I have one, it's a semantic question, but we have a previous section that is all public safety, and it's maybe not clear that this is public safety related to law enforcement and those kinds of things. Yeah, it's a little bit broadly written. I appreciate that comment. It is.

2:28:02 It is a part of our core services and it is sort of focused in on, you know, the delivery of police services in the community. So that's why it ended up in municipal services. Well, could you maybe just add, consider adding just public safety and law enforcement so that it's clear? So it's a little clearer? Just, yeah, just kind of a suggestion so it's clear what it is, what it's about. It does have officers on there also. I know, but that's, you get to, that's at the very, it's the last word in there and you're not.

2:28:33 I mean, I was confused in this. I kept, because I've been looking at the previous section, I thought it had to do with the things we're talking about with fire and all the rest of it. We can take a stab at clarifying that just a little bit to bring that into the police realm. Yeah. I think that'd probably be a good idea. Okay. So this one involved a multitude of items.

2:29:00 I will say that we really didn't update the Town's vision statement. That needs to be an agendized policy discussion with Council. But we did make some recommended modifications to focus in on the general planned update and really acknowledge a lot of the work that was done last year was around defining the process by which we were going to modify our general plans. And that work was largely completed with the

2:29:29 Parks and Recreation Master Planning effort. While that is just beginning in process, the overall design of how we were going to accomplish that was largely completed and that we wanted a consistent approach across all of those that we will undertake over the next several years. So I think the majority of this was accomplished. But I think what we identified is how are they going to tie into the general plan?

2:29:53 And developing that schedule further, including a funding strategy, because it's really going to cost a lot to get this accomplished, and I think we don't, right now we're funding it from our quarterly review process, and we can continue to do that, but we just think we need to acknowledge that it's going to have a high cost in the overall accomplishment of this goal, and just...

2:30:17 Exactly how we want to prioritize that in the needs, right? We always bump up against priorities of how we allocate those fundings, and I think it's important to address that. So those were the reasons for the modifications that suggested. John? Yeah, so, or Brett, do you want to go ahead? This one, I think we need to make, in order to get to the success component of this, I think that we need to split off.

2:30:44 The town's vision statement defining our general plan update focus from this larger effort to develop a schedule and funding strategy for identified plan updates. This has been in front of us for a couple of years now, and I think the need to articulate a vision for the town and the community in light of the times that we're living in where things are changing so rapidly and so quickly that I think it would make sense to

2:31:12 Keep them both in there, but make a separation so that the vision process is not tied into the thing you're talking about, Rob with money and all the rest of that stuff. I think, you know, we talk about in the vision statement now in a village in the trees. Well, we spent an hour today talking about what the different meaning of trees in Mammoth Lakes. And with a number of social pressures larger beyond us, I think it would be a good idea to

2:31:41 You know, make a differentiation there. So we can get that vision thing on a track to get that done. And you can keep doing the other stuff you're working on. So, John, if I understand, are you, you're indicating essentially that the town, because we try to tie them all together because that really informs the plans and services. Is it just the policy item of a town-wide vision getting done? Yes. Okay. Absolutely. That can, that can be.

2:32:07 As far as a modification of that, I don't know what you mean by separating them out, but I can certainly put that on the upcoming attractions or something. Just to clarify that, because this has been lumped together with all that work with the other plans, and that's been going on for a couple of years. And fine, you guys do what you got to do. But I think for the council and the community to start to weigh in to re-articulate that vision with the focus is going to be for the general plan to just not have it connected to.

2:32:37 Budgets, money, you know, aggregating a bunch of other municipal plans. I think it's getting to the point where it's kind of critically important to be doing that and have the council be setting a vision for, you know, where we're going and who we are. But, John, we have this in our priorities here. How does that lessen its priority? I mean, how does it increase the priority if we just create another bullet point that pretty much says what we already are saying here? I'm not...

2:33:04 All I'm suggesting is, to your point, make it a separate bullet point so that when Rob's looking at that, it's not tied into a larger effort, which is ongoing, to take all of the plans that Public Works has been working on for a long time to aggregate and pull all the plans together and figure a way to fund it for a general plan update, which is important, that's got to get done, but to just, you know, call out, cut out, make discreet that visioning process.

2:33:34 That we need to inform where we're going and what we're doing because right now we're working off of something that's 20 years old. You feel like it's not getting done because it's tied into a larger tedious job and if it were a checklist on its own, then we could check it off. Exactly. That's what you're saying. That's all I'm saying. Brent, you had something to say. Well, and it's a little bit different but similar because when I read it before, I was...

2:33:59 I'm fairly good with it, but as I read it, it's saying, defining a general plan update focus. It just reads kind of, okay. Well, I think what that's saying is to articulate a vision that could be directed at a general plan update as a formal process, but at least get that done initially. I think you're also just talking about the verb, that it should say define instead of defining, because it's update, develop, streamline. It should be defined instead of defining.

2:34:28 That's kind of where I was going. Yeah. It's really, I think someone just said a minute ago, you know, updating the town's vision statement, defining our general family update focus is, if they're tied together and that's causing a problem, we can certainly separate them. I look at it as a particular task, similar to one we talked about earlier in this process about addressing a need to get that done. That can be a staff assignment.

2:34:56 Happy to receive any modifications you're suggesting. Yeah, I just think if we just separate that out, I mean, so that, again, it's not tied to, I'm not going to characterize this as being a tedious process, but it's a laborious process. It takes a lot of work. It takes a lot of time. Meanwhile, time is going by. The world is changing quite rapidly, and I think it's going to be helpful for the council to put some direction. However, the vision statement has always been a part of the general plan, and, in fact, it informs the general plan.

2:35:24 So why wouldn't we have it as the first part as it is here in redoing the general plan? I mean, it is an integral part of it defining what the general plan is then going to be. Is it not? I agree completely. I just, I go back to the mayor's point about, you know, uncoupling it from this other process that's going on that's aggregating all of the plans in the town, which is taking a lot of time. Well, I think since we're trying to keep this to one page,

2:35:55 My suggestion would be if Rob could separate that into a separate bullet point while still keeping it on the same page, I'd be okay with that. And if he's not, then I trust him to get that on our to-do list and check it off. Yeah, and I think it's as simple as just making it two sentences. If I could ask for what would be the sentence for that, if you could help me. I'll provide it to you.

2:36:24 I mean, maybe it would just be update the town's vision statement, period. Exactly. And then define our general plan, update focus, and then, you know, the second sentence would be the rest of yours. Yeah, I just wanted to see what your intention was on that particular sentence associated with the vision plan. So, understood. We can see how that fits. Are people okay with that? I'm good. Yeah, that's all. Just put a period right there, and then the second sentence is the other stuff. And I echo what you're saying, John, or town plan is what year was it? 2007. 2007.

2:36:54 This is 2026. Yeah. We're coming up with 20 years. Come on. We could do the 20th anniversary. We could update it. Okay. Next one. So this one, we added the component at the end. And what I'm trying to tie this to is the destination stewardship plan work that we're doing. And you'll hear me often say, you know, we need to be prepared for as things change.

2:37:25 What it may look like for us if we are the only California ski resort, potentially, based on our elevation, to be active. And so that's a part of this particular modification, and it ties into the work that we're doing with the destination stewardship plan, really trying to provide a little bit more detail. Are there any comments on this one? I had some thoughts on it, but this I think will get to it. Works for you? Okay.

2:37:54 My other comment, this is a little bit where John was going before in terms of just making sure people understand this is a municipal services part because we have a whole subsection on resiliency above just reinforcing that. But I'm not looking for a change. I'm good with it. Do you think that in the descriptive sort of category, the category description that we can do a better job of defining what the municipal services are intended to do? That's kind of what I was thinking is overall just one blanket statement or somehow to do.

2:38:24 Without adding a whole lot of language to it. Okay. Yeah, what it says basically is municipal services supported vibrant, sustainable, and cohesive community. It talks about the goal, but it doesn't talk about the who. Okay. Asterix and put it on the backside. Capital projects, no modifications requested in this. Any other thoughts? Hang on one second. No, it's good. I thought the staff did a good job on the whole project. Give me one second here.

2:39:09 Municipal. Municipal Services? That's the one? So, John, I went back to the one we just talked about. I think you did, the notes you shared with me had a modification you intended to make. On this one? This one. Because we're on environmental sustainability. Okay. So. What the notes you shared with me said proactively engage with the natural environment to ensure a sustainable future.

2:39:39 Yeah, that's right. And your language, I think, captures that. Okay. So I'm fine with that. Thanks. Oh, you were modifying the unmodified. I got you. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. We just talked about this one. No modifications. Any updates? This is CIP. Okay. Moving on to the next one. Community investment. Affordable housing. So this one, we went around and around. Obviously, there is a lot.

2:40:08 In this particular space, you can see the efforts that we've done in 2025 to sort of refocus our energies onto the missing metal component with the work we did at the parcel as far as trying to get that DDA ended with the first two phases, the work that we're doing with acquiring stuff. But I think what we need to do is start to define a little bit more about our strategy.

2:40:37 And I think the housing staff, Nolan and Marcus, along with Hayes, are really working on a good solution for that. And I think we want to flesh that out a whole lot more to really define what it means to be missing middle in our approach and what we're really targeting. So I think that's what I was trying to capture in here. But honestly, the way it was worded originally does not need to change in order for us to perform those functions. And what we've kind of talked about today is there's a few points where

2:41:06 Almost tasks can get inserted into the strategy when the strategy itself is overarching and the tasks fall below them but they're not on the page, right? So I think some of that was difficult for me to get to exactly what modifications were necessary but at the end of the day it reads right in our opinion. Yeah, I think as we've talked about housing things recently is to keep it

2:41:34 The policy, the task, whatever is being done on a more granular level in the context of the Housing Now initiative, and then you can bring things, whatever we got to engage with, but it's called out as a strategic priority. So I think we're good. I think you're right. I think the language covers it. We also have no recommended edits. The next one, which is the under-community investment, enhancing growth and development of our quality of our citizens, that's the cap in the overall chain.

2:42:07 Partnerships, leveraged partnerships to increase opportunities and enhanced services. That's going to be a continuous and ongoing effort. I think there's more work to be done in that space. We just had no modifications here. Next item, also no modifications. This was community funding, develops capacity for community foundations to support town initiatives. A little bit of work was done in that space, but I think more is necessary to get it successful.

2:42:39 So I have a thought on this one. We've had conversations about community foundations, and we still, we can all not sit up here and say, what is the Mammoth Community Foundation? What does it do? We know there's something over the chamber that a disaster strikes and it can do something. So my suggestion for this would be, however long it's going to take to figure that out, the mountains involved in this, it's tricky.

2:43:05 Would be to change the language to say develop the capacity of community foundations and community-based nonprofit organizations to support town initiatives. So we can get a little broader than just the community foundation so we don't, frankly, we don't even know what that, we kind of know what it is, but it's pretty confusing to us and to the public. I have no problem with that in the nonprofit piece. That's fine. I'm slightly hesitant. I'm not against it just because it broadens up to everybody that's out there versus ones that may be.

2:43:36 You know, you may have somebody that just does scheme, and it may not have anything to do with what we're doing, but you're not necessarily saying they have to, so I'm not against it. I think until the community foundation thing gets resolved, which that could take until we're all dead, so.

2:43:52 Let's maybe open up, be able to bring more capacity to the town to provide capacity to help out to get the things done we need to get done. And I think it does say, like, to support town initiatives. Yeah. Right. So it's not just, like, willy-nilly we're helping. I don't know. That phrase myself, I was just trying to make sure was contained. Yeah. I'm okay with that. Me too. Okay. Okay, thank you. Thank you. And then in community investment, again, we are...

2:44:20 Not recommending any modifications to our community development, maximize community benefit when considering and approving development projects and continued townwide beautification efforts. I once again have a thought on this one. Really? Yes, I do. I'm surprised. I saved all my thoughts. Go ahead. Let's hear it. Okay, so my concern with this statement is maximize community benefits when considering and approving development projects.

2:44:49 By the time we get to considering and approving development projects, it's too late to really develop to deliver meaningful community benefits. So my suggestion would be to proactively maximize opportunities for community benefits in advance of the consideration and approval of development projects that continue townwide beautification efforts. So we really put an emphasis on the council and staff proactively looking at

2:45:19 Things that we can do before we even get to the point of approving things. Because when you're approving it, you can't do anything. You're talking about like that we should look at the requirements that we have for developments and see if they're in line with our goals and where we want to be. And the needs of the community and those kinds of things to get ahead of the curve. So we've.

2:45:41 So when we get into approving big projects and development and stuff like that, we've done our homework in advance and we've got something to work with. So I'm just thinking about working because sometimes when projects come forward, we don't know what it's going to look like and what they're bringing. So I'm trying to match that in advance. Yes, we'd like something, but what if the project doesn't fit something? Well, but it's not something, it's not like we want like a little toy for Christmas. It's like we want certain mitigations for housing. Inclusive housing.

2:46:06 Yeah, there are policy things that we know are going to benefit the community. We don't even know if the projects are going to come forward, but to try to get ahead of the curve, get ahead of things, so that when we're making decisions, we've got something to make a decision about. So are you saying then we want to change our priorities here to changing our zoning areas and issues around town to get the largest benefit? Because, you know, it's built-in zoning now.

2:46:34 To change that community benefit thing, you've got to change the zoning so that it makes a requirement that they do X, Y, and Z, right? The housing, it is all, so I'm not sure exactly what you're... Well, like the in-lieu fee program for housing or the diff program or what our diff fees are, you know, we're ahead of the curve, you know? I feel like we've been chatting about that we want to...

2:47:00 Examine those and see if we need to make any changes. Yeah. And you don't think that exists in the maximized community benefit? Well, I understand what he's saying is that by the time that the plans are in front of the PEDC for approval, that's not the time to have big requests of a project. So I think what you're saying is to, like, examine our requirements. I mean, I don't know the...

2:47:28 Verbiage, but to examine our requirements for developments. Yeah, our policies. Our diff fees, housing mitigation, whatever things are appropriate, but to do that proactively. Because again, as a council, projects can come in front of us and if we're dealing with something that's 20 years old, it hasn't been looked at and we haven't updated things and oh, here's a project, we want them to do X, Y, and Z, we'll turn to Andy and Andy will say, you can't.

2:47:54 What you've got on paper is what you've got on paper. It's too late to change it. So maybe it's update policies to maximize community benefit? Because what I think we're trying to capture here is have we examined it recently to see if we are maximizing? Right. Yeah, and that's a proactive piece is to get ahead of it. So if I may, when I originally read your suggested edits, John, I kind of

2:48:24 Just consider that it basically says the same thing, but you're talking about sort of planning in advance of any of these things to come forward. And that can go a number of different ways, right? We can have a whole workshop on what areas do we want to focus on in the upcoming developments that we may see in the community. It's really difficult to understand what's coming forward. I mean, right now we've got sort of a vision of what we have out there.

2:48:53 But do you envision this to be sort of a plan put together for what we think the needs are, so almost like a hit list of accomplishments the town needs to achieve, more so than just simply maximizing the benefit by a little bit of pre-planning and focus on that as the primary.

2:49:14 Effort the town staff need to take in review of development projects, which is why I first read it. It's just, hey, when you're reviewing development projects, the first thing you consider is the opportunities and benefit to the community versus what says in the current one, which is maximize that. It's slightly worded differently, but it kind of means the same thing. But what I'm hearing in this deliberation is it's almost like an exercise in going through and identifying what those needs may be.

2:49:43 And then where they may be achieved. Exactly. And to do that independently of a given project. It's assumed that staff is dealing with a development project. You guys are looking out for the community's best interest. That's not going to be in front of us. There's deal making that goes on with that. But to have the policy in place, this is what our housing mitigation fee structure looks like. This is what the in lieu fee program looks like. This is what our diff schedule is. So that we're ready and we're ahead of the...

2:50:11 We're ahead of things before these things even get to us. We'll take a stab at making this look beautiful for the next review and adoption. Can I ask clarification? Sure. Because I thought we had previously talked about one of the things we will be looking at is diff fees. Was that incorporated anywhere else on the document other than this? I'm just trying to make sure we haven't duplicated it. No, no, I don't think so. I didn't see it anywhere else. I don't think so, but I honestly don't see this page as our to-do list for...

2:50:41 The next six months. Yeah, right? Like, I feel like there are things that you're going to bring before us that are not just stated on this, and this is, like, our guiding which way. There's five of us trying to drive the boat, and so this is, like, we're all trying to go this direction and get these things done. Mm-hmm. Yeah, this is the guiding light. This isn't the task list, for sure. Yeah. And you have five words for me. Yeah.

2:51:04 Okay. Yeah, and I think the goal just for this, Rob, is just so that the council doesn't, we don't find ourselves in a position, oh, here comes a big project. What's on the books? This, this, and this. Oh, but that's, it's out of date. Doesn't, we wish we had something better in place. Well, maybe, I think that maybe we would feel most comfortable with, like, having a timeline for when do you want to discuss those, you know, diff fees and, or potentially, like, inclusive housing or, you know, because I feel like we've been, that's been.

2:51:34 In the past we've said we're going to do that and we haven't. Yeah, I think we're conflating a couple of different things, right? I mean, some of that stuff is work plans that are built and baked and they're not, we don't modify them like that, right? I mean, we set a diff fee schedule, that's what we have and that's what we run with. I think this sort of looks at a list of benefits and maybe where it will fit the most with whatever particular type of project that presents itself and being prepared for that. I'm ready to

2:52:04 Come forward for you guys in the next council meeting with some suggestions here that you can modify. Because it's written as reactionary, not proactive. Yeah, exactly. Leaving this as is and addressing that. Well, he's going to bring something back to us. Let me bring something back. Councilmember Truax just kind of hit it on the head. It's really just a timing of the same statement, but it's an emphasis on being proactive to it. So understand what you're trying to achieve, and I think we can make some suggestions.

2:52:36 Okay, we are on to recreation amenities programs, deliver high quality affordable and sustainable recreation program and amenities. So the community recreation is continued to expand access availability and affordability to parks and recreation amenity programs and services. So that's just really sort of acknowledging that.

2:53:04 We already have a lot of programs, and we've done a lot of work last year. If you remember, the whole setting up with the membership, the play pass products, other things like that, that we're trying to get as many people as possible in there. I think what we're looking here is just expanding the offerings that may be available and allow for more people to engage that. So otherwise, no other modifications. You know, on this one, the only thing I think I might add in there somewhere, although it works like it is for everything.

2:53:36 But we've put access, availability, and maybe diversity of park and recreation amenities. I mean, it fits. Even if we don't add it, I don't mean to be just words. Yeah, no, if you want to emphasize that, I think that's something. Yeah, I think that's a good point. So it's not a monolithic program. It's got a wide diversity of opportunities, yeah.

2:54:03 All good with that? I'm going back to, it's funny that we're going back to this because there's, I have notes on this same word to expand or to enhance, and we had a discussion previously on it, so I'm not good with it. All right, I will add that. In that same area, community connectivity, enhancing wayfinding mobility plans and upgrades. We have no recommended edits to this. We believe it still captures the work that needs to be accomplished in 2026. So I've got a thought on this one.

2:54:35 And this is certainly being informed by, and I won't get into this now, but what's going on with our federal partners. And the suggested language would be to enhance wayfinding and mobility plans and upgrades that include connectivity to the public landscape that defines our culture and drives our economy. So that we ensure that we are physically connecting to the public landscape that surrounds us because that's going to be very important as we go into the future and the...

2:55:05 Public land agencies are being dismantled. I guess I think I would put in half of your sentence, but not the second half. So enhance wayfinding and mobility plans and upgrades include connectivity to the public landscape. Yeah, fine. That makes sense. Yeah, I got that. Okay, next item. You don't think, John, that that exists already in the next bullet point? No, I've got an idea for that one, too.

2:55:47 John, were you really bored one day or something, buddy? He lives for this. Yeah, I kind of dig it. It's kind of his whole deal. All right. The next item. Staff had no recommended edits. This would be public lands. Work with federal and state partners to ensure the delivery of sustainable outdoor recreation experiences that drive visitation. This obviously is something we really leaned into last year. It's certainly supporting our...

2:56:16 Our federal partners and I think the destination stewardship plan is really bringing this together. Um, but, uh, council member went with? Yeah, I've just got a thought on this, um, to add at the beginning of this sentence to actively advocate and work with. Uh, I think the ad, the advocacy piece is going to get increasingly important. A lot of the work we did, the public land sales, that was coming from council members, it was coming from the public, but I think we need to start.

2:56:43 You know, really prioritizing for staff to say, look, you've got to be looking at this. You guys are on the ground. You're dealing with this stuff. And to bring recommendations for advocacy. Because the advocacy could be congressional. It's going to be federal. But I think it would be a wise move to start incorporating that into what we're doing. John, I'm not going to argue with you on this one. Advocate and work.

2:57:06 I would just add the one. You heard it from Santa. He's delivering the, we're being nice, right? Are you advocating with federal and state partners? No, no, you're advocating. You're advocating. Advocate and work with federal and state partners. No, that's what I'm asking him because then the with. You're advocating on behalf of the town and the community to the federal partners. Advocate to and work with federal. Yeah.

2:57:32 But Advocate, too, it's already built in there. But if we could add that if you want. Advocate. I guess what I do understand what you're trying to say, but it does sort of significantly change the action here where what we originally had is really partnering with these folks to accomplish things in our space that help us build these recreational amenities.

2:58:02 When you say to advocate, that means that we are going to speak in support of what? I mean, it's a little too broad for me, I guess. So I think that it is incumbent on us, given where we sit in the world and what's happening, that we become the stewards of these lands because there's really so much happening around us. And so ultimately,

2:58:33 What I think it's saying is that for us to take on that role of making sure that if policies that we think would be harmful to the lands that we're stewarding, we become aware of them and we have to be looking for it because these things are coming so quickly.

2:58:59 There's a mining bill that was going to be voted on this week. We only found out about that last week. Like those kinds of things. I think it's incumbent on us to be looking for that and doing the advocacy. So I'm struggling with the actively advocate because it's not us working with the Forest Service or the BLM. It's us going to our electeds at the state and federal level and saying, hey, this is a bad thing. And we...

2:59:25 Want you to not to do it. Well, but it's advocating at this point to just try to work with the federal agency. If the federal government is dismantling the federal agency, you're not going to have anybody to work with. So the idea is to be able to engage with the partners we have. But if we need to talk to like all the great work you did with Congressman Kiley, Rob, I mean, to be able to say, look, we're trying to do this to steward the landscape.

2:59:52 But the policy environment is getting to the point where we can't... Can I give an example, maybe? So, for example, like, if the Inyo National Forest is in disarray, then could we work with Friends of the Inyo and Trust for Public Lands or whomever? You know, that there are NGOs that we might have to cooperate with in order to make sure the policies don't... Well, I think we've covered that earlier in the idea of about...

3:00:22 You know, community-based non, you know, non-profit organizations we can work with. The point I'm saying about the advocacy is, is to be able, so if Lawson's got a project that's a trailhead we're trying to do, or Hayes has got a trailhead, a capital project we're trying to do, we have some sort of an agreement or arrangement with the Forest Service to do something, the Forest Service starts to evaporate, they can't honor the commitments they've made or the things Rob, do you deal with the Forest Service all the time on, that we are, it's, it's, we're,

3:00:51 Encouraging you to advocate with whoever you need to advocate to get these things done. Maybe it would be an additional sentence after this sentence. So work with federal and state partners to ensure that delivery of sustainable outdoor recreation experiences that drive visitation and then advocate on behalf of our programs. Yeah, advocate for ourselves.

3:01:16 I honestly believe that the intent you're trying to make is baked into the original statement because it's broadly written to the point where we're working with federal and state partners. And this was created, if you remember, in response to anticipating, because we were doing this in February, we adopted this in February, March, that the impacts of the federal partners, right? So this was really backfilling and, you know, our core service is to always advocate for our needs.

3:01:45 And get that accomplished. I think it's largely unnecessary to change this at all. Well, I would just, I would ask you to reflect on that and reflect on the last year because it's not, you know, if council members or other parties are not doing that advocacy, there's going to be a gap. And I think it's something that we need to kind of start building into the work program. So when you're hearing from your folks on the ground, staff on the ground, it rolls up and it's we will advocate.

3:02:14 Town Manager, Council will advocate on behalf of our programs as we try to do things in an environment that is disintegrating. Yeah, Rob, I think that for me, the simple way is just to put advocate and work. It opens up the advocacy part to work with others than just the federal and state agencies. Advocate and work, I'm good with that. But I think it just is the simple two words added in there that gives that leeway to advocate. We have always advocated for our programs.

3:02:44 There would be no disc golf if we hadn't advocated for that program at Shady because they told us we would never be able to improve that park or make it bigger than what it was. So I agree. But what you said, I'm in complete agreement. Advocate and work. Yeah. And I think that calls out what we are all looking for without getting into a huge wordsmithing. Yeah, because otherwise I'd be concerned where if we used advocate in a separate sentence, it might open up a lot of other things, but this defines and comes back.

3:03:12 I like that comment because that was exactly what I was worried about, that opening it up to a much larger function that isn't really a town staff sort of work plan, but I understand where you were trying to go with it. I just think I thought it was read appropriately. I'm okay adding advocate and work with federal partners. I think that's just an emphasis on some things that we were already

3:03:43 Thank you for that. Yep.

3:04:17 Edits to this. I'm good with that. John? Go for it. Come on. Come on. I think that, you know, last year, wildlife management was a thing. It still is a thing. But to say somehow sustainable outdoor recreation and then just invest in wildlife management, why not just say wildlife management? I mean, why? I mean, if you're going to say sustainable outdoor recreation, I would go, I would.

3:04:48 Want to open that up a little bit and broaden that, but we've already got that covered in other places. So just, it just, it, you know, maybe I would, maybe rather than just saying sustainable outdoor recreation, maybe just say wildlife management and left invested wildlife management, including public outreach and those kinds of things. So that the scale of the introduction and the sentence are appropriate. And I'm okay, wait, I got, I got, I got, we're going by this one.

3:05:14 I think the idea was basically that's, you know, an important aspect of sustaining it is wildlife management. But you think that, so your suggestion is to remove sustainable outdoor recreation as sort of the, it's the sub point and then the descriptor is invest in wildlife management including public outreach and enhance the towns on the ground presence. So it's just wildlife management? Yeah. Okay.

3:05:43 Because I think sustainable outdoor recreation is covered in other places. I think we already got that. Well, my only thought about that is I feel like the town's position has been that our job is to manage the people problem with wildlife and that CDFW, no, I don't know. CDFW. Is that okay? Right. That their job is to manage the actual animals. So I don't know. I'm fine with that.

3:06:14 Thank you very much, Rob.

3:06:49 Thank you very much. That's good. We're moving on to item 11, council member reports. Who would like to go first? I will if you'd like. Okay, Mr. Sauser. On the 8th, I attended the LTC meeting. And it was one of the shortest meetings we've ever had. How perfect is that? On the 11th, I attended the ESTA meeting remotely, which didn't go as well as I would have liked.

3:07:18 And on the 12th, with the rest of you, I attended the tree lighting, which was a great event out at our park. And that's it. Okay. Brett, would you like to go next? I'll keep mine simple. Go down the line. Okay. I did tour in cuttings with the chair of commerce for businesses, some to relocate from the village to on Main Street with the community tree lighting. I've attended a couple different going-away parties for Mr. Erdi.

3:07:46 Went to Night of Lights and also went to the Access Mammoth annual main event for their annual gala up at the main lodge. Wonderful. Thank you. Chris? Last week we had our ESCOG meeting and there we talked about some really important issues. One is the challenge of the golden muscle. I think you all are aware that these little buggers can live in places that none of the other invasive species could.

3:08:16 CDFW and LADWP have really taken the lead with lots of other agencies to figure out plans for this summer so that we don't have an infestation in our area because once it's here, it's here. So just stay tuned. It's not so much a town of Mammoth Lakes thing specifically, but it would absolutely have catastrophic impacts on us. Well, when I say that, I mean it's not

3:08:46 Literally in our town, but the lakes basin would have a huge impact. And so just stay tuned. You know, we're glad that this was brought to our attention. It's going to take some figuring out. ESCOG doesn't really have capacity right now to take this on, but we're going to be pursuing grants. So we may come back for funding or we may need an ordinance.

3:09:12 Did I describe that adequately, Rob? I know you were there. Okay. The other thing is that Christian Feiler presented an environmental protection plan for expanded regional riparian vegetation management, and this is a great thing. They got a grant that will help do riparian management. So, for example, the Creek Fire, although that

3:09:38 Area isn't eligible for this grant because it's coming from federal land. Those types of places where, you know, fires come down a riparian canyon into our areas will be addressed and it's really comprehensive and, again, based on a grant. And then finally, you're all aware of the USDA Wildfire Defense Grant, but they're really ramping up and that will be administered through ESCOG. So I think ESCOG's really come into its own.

3:10:08 You know, proven that as a region we are much stronger together and we can get some grants that we weren't so successful getting in the past. Do you want to add anything? Because I kind of took all of this cog. No, that's fine. Do you have anything else to add on your report? I just have to do ESTA. Okay. Do you want to do ESTA? I'll do ESTA and then you can, okay, great. Because I didn't talk about it. It's all good, but basically, you know, ESTA got to

3:10:33 Amazing grants for almost $11 million, $3 million for a new maintenance facility down in Bishop, and almost $8 million for new buses, and I think that that has a direct impact on us because we were going to be providing more than $2 million for new buses, and now we don't have to because they won this grant. Hooray! Yes, very good. And then...

3:10:57 The other thing was ESTA joined a hydrogen JPA in Lancaster. So Lancaster and the City of Industry are trying to get out in the lead on green hydrogen and why this is, you know, hydrogen is going to be the future for a lot of transportation and other things. But the other thing is that the hydrogen they're going to be creating is going to be out of, you know, a lot of solar in the Mojave. So it's green hydrogen. So it's even more.

3:11:26 And we joined the JPA so we could have access to better rates. And that is my report. Thank you. Okay. So to add one thing, one highlight of the ESCOG meeting was the report that John Urdi and Pat Foster provided on air service. And it was a very

3:11:44 A detailed, focused, directed report that really told the story of how air service, with statistics and numbers, is supporting everybody in the region. And I think we really felt there in the room, we really have turned a corner. Bishop Inyo County residents are using it as much as anybody else is.

3:12:04 We're on the path to getting to year-round service. Maybe someday it's going to take a while. Solid platform, solid reliable service down at the Bishop Airport. So it was really good presentation, a lot of buying from regional partners, which was great. That was, I attended that with Chris. And then today I attended the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Meeting. And we got some details about how the process will work for the new, for the person to replace John Urdi.

3:12:33 The job description's posted on the Visit Mammoth website, and it's on the careers page. Be open through January 15th. There'll be an interview process. There's an executive committee, which is going to probably focus it down to the desired candidates. They'll probably bring in a couple folks in to meet the board and things like that, but the full board will vote on the final candidate.

3:12:56 So the town will have a voice in that. I'm sure, Rob, you'll be meeting whoever those people are. I'm sure you guys will be meeting those candidates as well. So stay tuned for that. But they want to get that figured out later in January. The fall season went really well. A lot of very super sophisticated technological stuff. That organization is technology. Those are the tools that they use to do things.

3:13:22 As I mentioned, we did have these conversations about artificial intelligence and how it's affecting what they do and how it's working. And then I think in order for us to have this effective partnership with them, we got to have our game up so we can figure out how we can combine forces to work out for the best interest of the town. And there's a question, Rob, about the limelight and whether at what date the town is collecting data from.

3:13:49 I guess TOT data from the limelight. You don't have to answer that question, but that kind of came up. Yeah, I mean, so they would be reporting as of any transactional date, right? So if they were open in November, we would expect to see some activity coming to us on our collection period, which is December 20th, and we would know a bit more about what they are. So they have their own business tax certificate, and they would be providing...

3:14:15 You know, details on their revenues at that point. Yeah, there's just some question with the, you know, when is, when is, when is, in MOT's reporting, when do they start, when does the town start? It's just something to maybe talk to MOT about. And that's about it. They're getting ready for new leadership over there, and they're doing good, and the team's in good shape, and on we go. So thank you. Okay, great. So I attended the tree lighting ceremony in Night of Lights, and I also did a second ribbon cutting at the Limelight, which was...

3:14:47 Kind of fun. And then sort of some a bummer news about Access Apartments. They were getting the final inspection for their certificate of occupancy. And it appears that the contractor used the wrong size screws in the roof.

3:15:10 Bar, I don't know what the proper name of it is, and they were supposed to be one and a half inch screws, and they were one inch screws, and so that's delayed the opening of access apartments. I was over at the warming hut today, and Lisa was asking me, hey, when are the people moving in? And I said, well, I thought they've already got the candidate listed. So they have their tenants selected. Hopefully they're going to be getting them in at the end, like between now and the end of this month. But yeah, it was...

3:15:39 Disappointing that the contractor used the wrong size screws. So it's not a month's delay, it was a week's delay. Yes. Thank you. I haven't heard if they've gotten the final certificate of occupancy yet, but there was another delay. Okay. All right. I think that's all I have to report, everyone else. Sorry. Okay. So we're on to item 12 for closed session. Do I get to read these? Right? Yes. Okay.

3:16:09 12.1, Public Employee Discipline, Dismissal Release, Government Code, Section 54957. 12.2, Conference with Legal Counsel, Existing Litigation. Do I have to read everything in the parentheses? Yeah. Paragraph 1, Subdivision of Section 54956.9, Name of Case, Natasha Mitchell v. City of Mammoth Lakes.

3:16:30 12.3, Conference with Legal Counsel, Existing Litigation, Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9, Name of Case Hugelman v. Town of Mammoth Lakes, Case 21UCM10. Okay. Okay. Thank you all so much for coming. We'll let you know if there's anything to report.