Town Council
at 16:00 · recording 2 hr 24 min
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- Mammoth Lakes Recreation: $192,000 Measure R allocation in 2018; contract set to expire June 30, 2026 Elections and Governance
- Smaller details: the camera rate, Raven coverage, and Raven performance claims License Plate Readers (Flock)
- A December 2025 agenda packet says the Town is in discussions about a six-month Fish and Wildlife contract for a dedicated Wildlife Officer Wildlife Specialist (Wildlife Management, Dept 426)
Transcript
305 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:16 I've looked at an old, there's, Jamie will send you a thing, think about it before it comes up, because I was a little bit like, oh no, and also, people, I was like giving it to groups, but they really just, they like it to be people, you know, a person, you know, because they're a team. I'll say hi to them.
2:39 Thank you.
3:05 So, when we get to switching out the airships, and going through the positions, I don't think it's a lot of changes, but it's just a question. Instead of just having people what they'd like to, do you want to go through? Yes. I think it'll be wrong.
3:34 I'm going to hit my gavel soon because I want to. I have it. Yeah, I'll give it to you. Yeah, that's what I do. I can also. We should have talked. I'll just tell you a few things that were useful. What I wish I knew. Councilmember Truax, please join us at the front. Welcome, welcome everyone to this joyous.
4:03 Meeting of, yeah, it's joyous. It's my last, which makes it very joyful. Wednesday, December 3rd, it's a regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council at 4 o'clock p.m., so we will call the meeting to order. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Here. Mayor Bubzer? Here. Thank you. And so, let's see.
4:33 I was thinking that Rob Patterson might lead us in the pledge this evening. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. Moving along, we are now at the point of our agenda. We will take public comments for anything not otherwise on tonight's agenda.
5:14 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. I'm Betsy Truax. I'm the Vice President of Community Engagement at Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and I just have a couple of quick updates for everyone. Mammoth Lakes Tourism is very proud to be kicking off our Shop Local campaign just in time for the holidays.
5:32 I'll leave these little passports at the back of the room. But through December 14th, we're encouraging residents and visitors to patronize local businesses who are partnering with us by providing some special offers. We're promoting that through our social and email channels in partnership with the participating businesses. One of my favorite things, our annual resident sentiment survey is live. It can be accessed at visitmammoth.com slash community.
5:58 And you'll also be receiving a QR code to that on your annual report, which should land in your mailboxes any day now. We're using a new vendor this year who also does national and regional resident sentiment for the US and Canada. So we'll be able to compare our results against those.
6:14 And to take the survey in Spanish, people just need to have their browsers set in Spanish as the default language, and we're also working on an event with translation. Trying to garner enough responses to conclude the survey on December 23rd. If we don't have a sufficient sample size by then, we'll actually close the survey over the holidays and then reopen it afterward.
6:35 Big news at MLT, of course, is John Urdi's departure, and everyone in the community is invited to a Going Away Celebration for John on Thursday, December 11th from 5 to 8 p.m. at Bar Sierra. So please come join us in wishing John well. Our next community coffee is on Thursday, December 18th, and we'll have a winter update from Mammoth Mountain.
6:54 And last but not least, our special event funding application process is currently open and it will close on December 15th promptly at 5 p.m. If anyone has any questions or would like more information about that, they can reach out to me, Betsy Truax at Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you. Thank you very much. Good evening. I'm Billy Stade, resident homeowner of Mammoth Lakes. I addressed the council last session regarding a new concept at the village.
7:28 at the never activated for 27 years dormant peninsula location and I want to report that the landlord has agreed to and is very positive on activating the space and animating reanimating the village and I'd like to request a community well I'd like to approach each
7:55 Thank you. Thank you.
8:25 Be a humble servant to town, and again, thank you very much. Thank you. Jamie, is there anyone online? Okay, great. Anyone else? If not, we will go on to item four, and that is additions to the agenda. Yes, Madam Mayor, we actually do have an addition to the agenda this evening. We...
8:52 We have pursuant to government code section 54954.2b2, council hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for action came to the attention of the town subsequent to the agenda being posted. And the said item is a closed session item, and this is a conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation of significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph 3.
9:21 Subdivision D of Section 54956.9, and that's one case. So what we'd need tonight is for Council to have a motion, second, and a vote to add this item to the agenda as a closed session item after our policy matters. Thank you. Any questions? No. I could entertain a motion. We do need to approve this. So moved. I'll second it. Okay. Jamie, could you please call the roll?
9:50 Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Thank you. The motion carries. That will be added in closed session. So next we are on to item five. This is an introduction of our new sustainability coordinator. I think that's Pam. Good afternoon, council members. Pam Kobylarz, assistant to the town manager. It is my pleasure today to introduce our new sustainability coordinator, Emily Jaszewski.
10:24 Emily graduated from the University of Denver with a double major in Environmental Science and Anthropology as well as a minor in GIS. I'm really excited about the opportunity to potentially start utilizing GIS in some of our sustainability programs as we utilize it across a lot of our other programs within the town.
10:42 Emily previously spent a season working for ski school, so she is familiar with life here in Mammoth Lakes in the wintertime. She also spent the last three summers as an interpretive ranger in Tuolumne Meadows in Yosemite. We were very impressed with a lot of the creative and innovative work she had done with campfire programs and other interpretive ranger programs there at Yosemite.
11:05 As well as she interacted with people from around the world, so very comfortable engaging with people, educating people, and we're really excited to utilize her expertise and skills to help grow and develop some of our education and outreach campaigns related to all of our sustainability initiatives, as well as working to develop and continue to grow our sustainability programs here at the town. So with that, welcome to the town, Emily. We're really happy to have you. Thank you. Happy to be here and happy to meet all of you today.
11:34 Great. Anything else you want to say? Not really. I'm just very excited to be here and to meet all of you all. That's okay. I always just like to give you a chance. Yes, that was my next, but sometimes I forget to say to let you talk first. Welcome. We're delighted you're here. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you. Don't forget those guys. I will. Ladies first, John. Mayor first. Thank you. All right. Moving right along.
12:07 I am very excited and privileged to make a presentation. So, Rob, do we usually have the awardees come to the podium? How do you like to do this? Should I go to the podium? No, you're good right where you are. I think you should start saying the wonderful things you'd like to say about the nominations you have for the Spirit of Mammoth Award, and they may come up to the podium if they like, or just come up after you're done talking and receive the award and take the photos. All right, thank you.
12:35 Really, really excited. I think one of the greatest privileges of serving as the mayor of the town of Mammoth Lakes is that that year you get to award the Spirit of Mammoth Award. And so it is my absolute honor to welcome you this afternoon to recognize two exceptional members of our community, Rebecca Hang and Brian Schulte, as the 2025 recipients of the Spirit of Mammoth Award.
13:03 For more than a quarter century, Rebecca and Brian, I don't want to make you sound old, but it's really, this is just really unbelievable. You have enriched the cultural life of Mammoth Lakes and the entire Eastern Sierra community through your vision, your artistry, and your dedication to the arts education and specifically the music education of our community. So for those who don't know, since 1998,
13:27 Their organization, Chamber Music Unbound, of which their chair of the board, Joyce Kaufman, is also here this evening to honor them. Since 1998, their organization has brought world-class musicians and unforgettable performances to our mountain town. And these are truly world-class musicians. I don't know if any of you know, but my husband's parents are classical musicians. And a student of his dad's came and performed in Mammoth.
13:56 Amazing to see these unbelievable musicians come and perform here, particularly those who are, who have like our woodwinds, because can you imagine rolling up to 8,000 feet and Brian and Rebecca, I don't know how you prepare them, but it's really unbelievable. So this began, and I really want to call out that Brian and Rebecca brought an
14:18 NEA, National Endowment for the Arts Grant. They got a rural residency many years ago for their trio, their other one of many organizations, the Felici Piano Trio, and this blossomed into an annual summer festival that draws music lovers from near and far. So this year, the 26th Chamber Music Unbound Festival, if I have that correct, will once again fill our town with music that spans centuries and connects hearts. So beyond their
14:45 Impact for the just performance. We also are so grateful for their teaching and outreach programs. They have inspired generations of young musicians, so their music schools train more than 125 violin students, and they also lead the Mammoth High School Honor Orchestra, which is why we put them in this part of the agenda and are rushing them out because they have rehearsal tonight. So they have helped countless children
15:13 Discover their talent and confidence. And so thanks to their leadership, their creativity, the grants that they have brought here, you know, they've leveraged all of this to make the program sustainable and accessible to all. And if you've never been to a Felici Trio or Chamber Music Unbound concert, well, first of all, why not? And secondly, see me. I will even take you as my guest. I would love to be able to introduce more people to this amazing resource we have.
15:43 The other thing is that they bring our community together in such beautiful ways, and they also lead the Fourth of July Pops Concert, which many, many people enjoy and experience in the various parks where it has moved over the years. And finally, I just want to say, Rebecca's program notes and the pedagogy that she shares brings everything to life in a way that you just have to experience it, because she tells you the story of the composer.
16:13 Highlights female composers. You know, who knew that, was it Strauss's wife was, who was it? Come on, help me out. It was, there was, anyway, I don't want to get it wrong, I'll just humiliate myself, but last year there was this unbelievable story you told us about, and just on and on.
16:45 Come to the podium so people can hear, because this is really fun. First of all, thank you so much, but I just want to pick up where we left off. So Louise Tharanque was a lady composer who had the fortune of growing up in a kind of Bohemian family, like not a family with an everyday life like most of us have, but a family that kind of...
17:09 Made a living being sculptors and visual artists and she grew up just exploring the piano and at one point she knew that her love for music was going to sustain her for the rest of her life and her life story like many individual life stories was not always cheerful and happy she had some really sad moments and yet she was able to overcome the sadness in her life through her music making and when she found out
17:35 How good she was by performing all around her country. And she was called upon to teach at the famous French National Conservatory in Paris. She took the job and after she found out that she wasn't receiving equal pay, she stood up and she stood up for herself and she said, no, I know the year is only 1885, but I deserve to be paid the same as my colleagues. So we try when we pick our composers to
18:04 To not just entertain with beautiful music, which is one of the things that we want to do and do, but we also want to highlight through their life experiences the human experience that we all share and that we can relate to and where we can find uplift and comfort and joy in times when things are not so great.
18:29 But I want to say a huge thank you to you all. I didn't share with too many people before today that we got this phone call when we were with family in Seattle, and it's so nice occasionally to get a pat on the shoulder, to hear that the work is appreciated. We sense it every day in our everyday work with the children in the community and when we perform for you all.
18:55 Usually we don't talk, we come and we play for you and we want to do this, but it doesn't happen today because of the rehearsal. Being an artist and coming to a community that invites you to come, as happened to us with the Rural Residencies Grant in 1998,
19:14 It's a big moment. We didn't know what to expect. For us, Mammoth was a blind date. So we weren't drawn by the mountains and the adventure that the mountains promise and the natural beauty. We didn't know about any of this. We came because we wanted to help contribute to community life. And we wanted to do so through making music and sharing our skills and knowledge.
19:39 What we didn't know at the time, because we were young and unexperienced, is that what you give, you get even more back. And so we just want to say a huge thank you to the entire community for having it made possible for us to be here for the last 27 years.
19:57 We had our children here. Our children went to school here. We had so much support from friends and community that we will never be able to say all the thank yous that we owe you. But here we are, and it comes from the heart when we say thank you so much for letting us make our home here. Absolutely. And I'll just close by saying that both of you, Rebecca and Brian, have shown us what it means to live the spirit of Mammoth.
20:24 Mammoth, you create beauty, you create community. The beautiful words you just said is exactly why we think you are so deserving this year. So I would just like to say that could you please join me in celebrating the 2025 Spirit of Mammoth Award recipients, Rebecca Hung and Brian Schulz.
21:06 I think I'm going to be buying a lot of tickets to go to, but that's okay. I'm happy. Nothing would make me happier. All right. There you are, Chief Casabian.
22:16 You are, item 6.2, recognition of our retiring code compliance officer, Rick Bellis. So I am up here for Rick Bellis to recognize him, and I'm just going to imagine him standing here. He got so excited for retirement, he is off and running. So they are in Arizona, but I still feel it's very important to be able to recognize him in front of our community, in front of council. So thank you for being here. So Rick's probably, you know what, I'm sure Rick is watching.
22:45 Yeah, I bet he is. Hi, Rick. You know, Rick is a big loss to the organization, to the PD, to the town. He did a lot for us. He was kind of like a Swiss Army knife. Anything we asked him to do, he was able to do. And obviously, he specialized in wildlife and, you know, having some of that background in fishing wildlife or fishing game back then. But I wrote a little something on Rick. Rick joined our agency in 2016.
23:13 Coming to us from the Department of Fish and Wildlife after obtaining a bachelor's degree in business administration at Cal State Fullerton. Rick spent most of his career patrolling the high desert mountains of San Bernardino. Rick was introduced to the Eastern Sierra on a backpacking trip at Hilton Lake in 1981. And then he just continued to come up here from 1981 and eventually made his way up here.
23:34 In 2021, Rick was promoted to co-compliance officer with a specialty in handling wildlife calls. Last year, Rick received the Spirit of Mammoth Award for his exemplary service in assisting with wildlife and domesticated animal issues throughout the year in addition to outstanding community relations efforts. Rick and his family are now beginning a new adventure in Arizona. And when I asked him, I said, what are you going to miss most about mammoth? He said,
24:03 He changed the subject and he flipped it on me and he said, the thing I'm not going to miss is the snow. So he's down in Arizona enjoying his life and you know, on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Police Department, we wish him the best and a huge thank you for his service to the town. Thank you. Thank you so much. And Rick, if you're watching, thank you and all the best. All right. Next we are on item seven, reports from commissions and or departments.
24:44 Good evening. Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works. Back on September 3rd during the CIP presentation, we discussed the installation of a gate on Davison to mitigate the numerous accidents we've seen there in the last couple of years. I want to report that we've completed the majority of that installation. The signs just went in. The gate has been installed. I think we've got one more sign to put up top. We also sent a letter to all of the residents. And so we're starting to get some feedback from people who are unaware. I've taken a few phone calls.
25:13 Mostly understanding one extremely negative. But I expect that will continue throughout the season. So I just wanted to remind you folks that we have made that change and that we are continuing to look for feedback. And if you hear something from the public, we at Public Works would like to hear from you on your experience. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions on that? Is the berm not going to happen anymore?
25:38 Correct. Because the berm was permanent and it didn't allow for emergency services. So we transitioned to a gate, which we constructed ourselves and just completed the installation, which will allow, you know, police, fire, public works to navigate the closure during an emergency. And the gate's up at the top? The gate is near the top, kind of in the flat spot. There was a map we put out that kind of showed where all the infrastructure was being installed. I don't know if I said, did you guys see that map?
26:06 I don't know if I saw that one. And who's got the keys? That's a secret. No, all the emergency service workers have it. It's our universal key. So if there's an emergency, someone calls 911, the police department. Everybody who needs to have access will have access. Okay. Thank you. So, Hayes, is this a permanent winter closure or is this a storm closure we're doing? Great question. Just so the people out there know. I think it's going to be different year by year.
26:33 I think we're learning through this process. Again, this is mitigation. If it's a big year, it could remain closed. If it's like this and it's kind of off and on, we will try to keep the gate open as much as possible. We're also trying to influence the maps, the Google Maps, the Apple Maps, to try to discourage the bypass traffic from, you know, Canyon Lodge.
26:59 We're trying to find a good, happy spot because we understand the impact of the community and the circulation patterns for those residents, but we also want to try to keep it safe. So we're kind of balancing. So it could go either which way. So that being said, the signs at the bottom, Lakeview and Davidson, will be like a chain sign so you can turn them and say, don't go up, stupid. Sorry.
27:29 To let people know. Yeah, absolutely. And they're not quite that blunt. But they are changeable signs. They flip open just like our chain controls. We had a custom flashing mechanism built so we can turn them on so they are a flashing beacon. It says something to the effect of not a through street, no ski area access. So it's kind of two signs. There are two going up and then one with a similar message downhill that says not a through street.
27:54 And so when we see inclement weather or we see that Davidson is too icy, we'll work together, emergency services, and make a decision to turn that on and we'll flip those signs around and close the gate. And then we have a methodology that we're trying to notify Google Maps. We'll see if it works out. I'm assuming the gate is far enough down so that the people in the flat section at the top of Davidson can access that from the Lakeview side, yet it's in a spot where turnaround is easy.
28:24 Yes, and that there is no perfect spot, so we did have to make a difficult decision, and we did work with those nearby property owners. We had a conversation with their property manager about that. So we understand the impact. Thank you. Thank you. Welcome. Good evening, Council. I'm Pat Foster. I just wanted to give you a brief update on our transition for John Urdi. As Betsy mentioned, we're going to have a gathering at our Sierra on the 11th. Love to have you all there.
28:57 John's actual last day is the 19th. At that point, we have appointed Sarah Winters to be the interim CEO. So she's going to help us run a day-to-day. And then she is also going to help us with the recruitment process. We put together an ad hoc committee of Mary Beth Harrison, John Mandel, Eric Clark, and myself. And we've got a recruitment package that we're just putting some final touches on, and we're hoping to have that live by Friday.
29:26 So I just wanted to keep you guys posted on our progress and I will continue to do so. Thank you. Any other reports? Seeing none, we will go on to our staff presentations. So we're at item 8.1, Town Council Strategic Priorities. Thank you, Mayor Bubzer. So tonight, as you remember, last year we had a fairly extensive
29:57 Presentation, our sort of process we worked through to develop the strategic priorities. I've got a few folks joining me up here at the council table tonight or the staff table tonight to kind of hear some thoughts that you guys may have. But the purpose of tonight is really to talk about the accomplishments that we did achieve with regard to the town council strategic priorities in 2025.
30:22 They were fairly extensive. The staff report alone online is around 10 pages long with details of what was accomplished in each of the specific categories. I'm not going to read through those in detail tonight. I will show you a little brief PowerPoint here in a second that kind of goes through each of the sections. I will talk about some highlights of that. The purpose of tonight, again, is to review what was accomplished, and it will lead into a
30:52 Better discussion at the second meeting in December where we have a policy item on the agenda and staff's going to kind of bring in some recommended modifications to these. I think the very extensive process we used last year should have developed a set of strategic priorities that have some pretty long legs and they could last a few years for us. And so I only anticipate minor modifications to these priorities going into the future.
31:18 But I will say there were some things that were substantially completed, so they'll likely come off. But then again, each of these buckets would remain. So let me get this shown here real quickly, and then we will go into the presentation on that. Okay, so this is a long delay. Okay, this is the item in its final form for the year. And again, it was really...
31:59 Designed in four quadrants, public safety, community investment, municipal services, and recreational amenities and programs. Under each of those had a number of key areas of focus. And again, in the staff report, we kind of go through each of those. I'm going to just drop down here and go through each of the quadrants, if you will, and talk a little bit about some of the components in there. So emergency management, obviously, that's a really critical aspect for the town.
32:29 That's how we engage with anything that comes up, which would be all hazards that could affect both residents and visitors at any point in time. In that specific area, I think we sort of identified really key points that the town needed our County Office of Emergency Services to sort of engage with us on. We went through sort of a 17-point document.
32:54 Outlining exactly what modifications that we were seeking in that space and how we could provide for, you know, really just a better response for the community. We continue to build our emergency messaging capacities, you know, working really closely with Genesis and the Office of Emergency Services to make sure that we can push out information to our community very timely and accurately.
33:20 In November 2025, as you know, we had a fairly significant fire just south of us in Crowley Lake. And the town was sort of first, not the first on scene, but really the first sort of management group to show up and support that because of our proximity, right? It was right in our neighborhood. We had a lot of us that were personally affected by the evacuations and just the concern of the fire. So we were down there.
33:50 The discussions post sort of a debrief on what we can do better, and I think we've outlined a lot of adjustments that we can make personally, and sort of a quick modification of our approach as a debrief. And so we went through that process, and what you should see from that is over the next sort of one month, there was a list of things we needed to be accomplished.
34:14 Three months, another set of items to be accomplished, and then 12 months, fully system integration for what we think we need for not only the town, but just surrounding areas. We also plan to do an extensive amount of training in the evacuation perspective. When I attended the CJPIA conference in early October, I came away from that. It was a big debrief on the fire. It really talked about the importance of not only
34:42 Training and practicing on your evacuation, but also educating the community on exactly how that functions, right? It's not just us executing, it's the community responding. So I think what we're looking for is quarterly evacuation training and practices for the entire community. And so that's something that you see more of in 2026. And I would say that this particular emergency management section of public safety is...
35:11 Is going to stay on here for 2026 and probably be augmented with really significant modification from the county's perspective as well as the town in making this a little bit safer. And risk mitigation, that was another big area. We were trying to figure out just how we are working as a team to identify what are the risks and what are the possible
35:39 Thank you. Thank you.
35:56 They're really just working on identifying any hazards that can happen, what are the potential for those hazards, and then what are the mitigating efforts that we can make now to minimize the impact of them. And then a community wildfire protection plan is really a necessary document that outlines the need for concerns around wildlife, especially in the WUI, which is the wild land interface with the town environment, and it helps us get grant funding. Both of those help us with state and federal grant funding.
36:26 To support mitigation efforts in that space. And if you don't have those things, you really sometimes don't qualify for grant funding, especially at the federal level. At the same time, we set up the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Task Force and really focusing on the community preparedness. I think that was really, really successful last year, thanks in part to Lawson Reef, our Office of Outdoor Recreation Manager, who took the lead from a town's perspective, and Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, who not only
36:56 Sort of engaged in that, but also went through the process of doing evaluations on properties. I think they did about 4,500 property evaluations. I think some of the feedback I've received that we do need to do some additional follow-up maybe in what is necessary.
37:11 To be accomplished at each of those points, but it was really a great effort. We had some good community meetings, some barbecues and things like that where we got the community out and talking about the plan and talking about even fire safe communities. So that was really, really strong. We look to augment that into 2026. We're going to continue to do the efforts, but we've learned a lot and we're going to modify our approach slightly. We also engage with White Bark, Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resilience Project.
37:38 Providing them about $1.2 million in funding for specific treatments and then operational and organizational strength of their effort. And that's just direct town funding involved in that allocation. And we also provided about $200,000 towards Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District to have wildland firefighters increase the number from 8 to 12 for 2025 season. And they really are the ones that assist in the parcel level work in that space.
38:08 And then finally in this public safety area I'll talk about facility utilization and this is all really focused around Mammoth Yosemite Airport and I'll commend the team at the airport for doing such a tremendous job in not only keeping that facility in tip-top shape but looking towards the future and what it really could be for our community. Over the last year we saw a lot of opportunity for multi-agency needs to be addressed.
38:35 And that's the direction that we're going. So right now the team is working very, very closely with our consultants and a number of the, I'll say first responder networks in the area to see what sort of emergency response capabilities can be brought to our area. Our goal is to get firefighting capabilities, air resources staged at the airport so they have a very quick turn.
39:01 You know, roughly 20 minutes from an ignition to the point where it's being addressed by aircraft. That, I think, will be what helps provide for safety of the town in a very significant way. They're also building into that space training facilities, training apparatus, larger communal areas where either EOCs could be stood up if necessary, or there's just a proximity of
39:29 Each of these agencies a place where they will be able to reside in our area. So we're trying to be welcoming and open and utilizing sort of the land side of the airport to bring these folks in here. There's a, there's a, CAL FIRE has an initiative where they're responsible now for much of sections within the Eastern Sierra. So they're expanding into our area. They want a fire station at the top of the grade. So we're trying to accommodate that at the airport.
39:58 And so a lot is being done in that space. There's, you know, like 20 items that were listed on the accomplishments tab in there as well as talking about the flight crews, medevac aircraft that is being staged out at the airport and just the work that they've been done. So more work to be done in that. I would say all of the elements that are under public safety will have more work to be done for 2026.
40:24 And I think only minor modifications, probably just enhancing some of the areas that we know where we need to focus for the next 12 months. So that's coming in that space. Municipal services. Do you think, would it be okay if we had questions and any discussion maybe for each of the specific? You certainly can. Because I feel like by the end we might forget.
40:52 If you had any questions or clarification or anything you wanted to ask, it might be good to do it. For me, that would depend on whether we are taking this as a presentation for us to discuss at a later meeting or whether actually this is time for input. That's a good question. Yeah, the intent of tonight is a presentation on what was accomplished, but it's also designed to kind of remind you guys and I think bring up an opportunity to share some thoughts, if you'd like, around
41:22 You know, directionally, where we need to go with the goals. The next meeting, we will have the policy item, as I discussed, and that's where we'll have a deep dive into modifications of the specific language. But I think if based upon the things that we accomplished, it spurs a question or discussion. Chris, I'd like to hear those. Mayor Bubzer, I'd like to hear those. The goal of this effort is really to cover what was accomplished. We will do the deeper dive on the modification of the
41:49 Goals in the next meeting. And in the third meeting, we will have a final sort of wordsmithing and adoption of the goals for 2026. So we've got, you know, two more meetings in which we'll be discussing these at length. Tonight's was really sort of in the transition of council celebration of what was achieved and sort of a reminder of that. So you guys can take that. If you have questions, I'd love to address them, please.
42:15 Absolutely. So, yeah, I don't think we wanted this to be a deep dive, but I, for example, would be curious if any of the other council members wanted clarification or more information on any of this. So, does anybody, and I do think taking it one section at a time would make it easier to, you know, remember. So, does anybody have any questions? Because if you don't, then we can continue on. So,
42:43 A little disjunct, but yes, I do have several questions in the public safety area. Yeah, so please. Just three questions, I think. One is in the report, it talks about the debrief on the 2025 PAC fire. Just want to make sure that you're coming back in December, if there's going to be additional financial resources needed to help with any of that. Do you foresee there being a request coming forward? No, I don't think there will be a financial request coming forward at the next meeting. The meeting that...
43:11 We'll be talking about really the goal of 2026 is how we would modify the emergency management response. I think the PAC fire created a very lengthy and extensive list of things for us to do, and I would see that coming back to council as a presentation at a subsequent meeting, and I would fund that during the second quarter, which would probably be a February-March time frame.
43:41 As I said, there's a one-month, three-month, 12-month approach to how we would be prepared for that. And I think the financial needs and costs are going to be in the latter end of that, if you will. And a lot of it up front is talking about organizational structure, assignments, those types of things. There might be some training associated with that. What we're trying not to do is trying not to do this on our own.
44:08 And we want to connect with Mono County Office of Education Office of Emergency Services in order to make sure that what we do is got more broad reach throughout the region. And so it's going to be a little bit broader than the town of Mammoth Lakes. But I will tell you that we had a number of sort of follow-on assignments associated with that.
44:31 And that's why we try to narrow it down into what do we need to do within the next 30 days, right, to protect ourselves a little bit better? What do we need to do then in the next three months? And so forth. So it's a little bit of an iterative process, but we continue to work on that now. Next one is just, is it typical, it just kind of took me aback when I saw there was 182 medical flights out of the airport this year already. Is that a typical year? It just, that seems like a lot of flights.
44:59 I see the airport operations manager shaking your head no. It is not typical. It's the most that we've had and it's due to that aircraft being staged at Mammoth. So it's the availability there combined with, I hope I'm not misinterpreting this, but combined with the fact that with new requirements, cardiac and neurological patients are flown.
45:29 And this is the first year, so we have a contract where we lease the sprung structure at the airport to the flight crew for the Sierra Life Flight. And they fly up from Bishop every morning, stage the aircraft, crew go to quarters, and then they're processing flights all through the day and night.
45:57 Hot Creek is supporting them along with our staff. But that's sort of the intent, right, of having resources staged on our airport so that they're really able for rapid response. Good question. And then a double apart question. So I thought, maybe I missed it here, we were doing an analysis of looking at our crosswalks within the community and I didn't see that listed because
46:23 There's still some areas that probably need attention within the community, but I think that was something that was being worked on, and something that has come back to me in its report as an overall, and I salute the school for doing a much better job of bikes, and bikes, helmets, apparently, has been much more enforced, but still, several people have been concerned about, still a lot of kids in town riding about bikes, so something as we go forward. Riding about bike helmets? Like not riding about bike helmets, but apparently at the school they've been like...
46:50 They've implemented new rules that if a kid is riding the bike up to the school without a helmet, they're not allowed to do that. And they've held to that rule, which I salute the school for being firm. But I believe we are doing something for crosswalks. Okay. Go ahead. I don't know how you'd like to do this, but I have a couple thoughts in terms of what we would do next.
47:20 To follow up on this, I could make a quick comment now, and then we can follow up next week. Is it about public safety specifically? Yes, it's about public safety. We can skip it. We can just do it next week. No, go ahead. No, it's fine. I think the main thing is that I'm trying to make sure we don't just get a presentation where them, any points of clarification or not. I'll reserve my comments for the next time, but I do have some ideas on this, and we'll get to that next time.
47:42 Yeah, thanks for that. I know it's a little bit clunky what we're doing tonight, but essentially this is sort of a review of that and if it jogs a discussion, that's good, but we will have a deeper dive in each one of these categories for more. And so I just have a couple questions. They're points of clarification. They're not for discussion tonight, but one is, and it sounds like you're planning this, but I would like to see more specifics around the learnings from the PAC fire, just because I think there's...
48:09 There's a lot of rich opportunities for us to, you know, not only for the staff and of the different first responder organizations to learn from, but also to share with the public. I think there's just a big opportunity for the public to get a little bit better informed about what their responsibilities are. The other thing is, I think talking about the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance is great. And just to add,
48:37 More about the $4.2 million wildfire grant that will provide additional funding for community-based efforts. I want to make sure the public is ready for next summer, and you have been talking about it, just to make sure we get it into the strategic priorities. So those were the two I had. So we'll move on to municipal services. Thank you. Sure. Thanks for that. End of the municipal services, you know, the first thing we had was community engagement.
49:11 We've really done a lot this year with our social media presence. We contracted with a content specialist who formerly worked for Mammoth Lakes Tourism and is an independent consultant to really assist us with consistent messaging. We ended up with a Thursday drop of
49:40 Really what's going on in the community, updates like that, things of importance. During the summertime, we added a Tuesday drop, which was all of the capital projects that were in flight, where you could expect to find issues and challenges, and those have been really wildly successful. I think we've elevated our game significantly with regard to posts on all the platforms.
50:06 That our Facebook has grown more than 2,000 followers in the past year. We currently have just under 11,000. Our Instagram has grown by approximately 5,000 followers, and we're currently at 6,700. And so we've been able to really grow our programs and our outreach, and I think beyond that, it's really been a highly professional presentation to do that.
50:29 We're also now starting to migrate for the wintertime into messaging around either things that are really important that are going on in the community, like if there's a snow event or something along those lines or something of significance. We're trying to get a lot of video content out there. During the summer, we had a fish stocking video that went absolutely viral, probably added most of these followers that we got. So we're kind of looking for something that people can engage with. Just to clarify.
50:57 Instagram went from 1,000 to 6,000? It did. Wow. Yeah, it grew by 5,000 from 6,000 to 680. But if you remember, we weren't really that active prior to that in Instagram. I think we just kind of got into it the year before more significantly. But yeah, it grew quite a bit. We're also working a lot in our host program.
51:22 We're working on our master plan updates. Stu, Hayes, and team have put together a really good plan that's duplicatable across our master planning efforts that really engages the community, gets them involved in the discussion points. We're utilizing the Parks and Rec master planning process as a test of proof of concept for what will be really an update of subsequent master plans going forward and how we roll it all together.
51:51 In our ultimate plan. But I think that being centered, focused on really community engagement, hopefully you all received your mailed packets. I know I received more than one at my house, but I promise I only fill that one. But it was really extensive, right? It was really comprehensive and attempted to gather really great information. I talked about our host program. That continues to be a shining star in our Office of Outdoor Recreation, being run by Gretchen.
52:21 Really effective in engaging with our community and making sure that our visitor community, making sure they are taken care of when they're out on the trails and they're at our amenities, but also able to understand what the needs are of them, right? When you talk about wildlife and other things like that, there was a lot of education that went on. We've been reaching out in a number of surveys. In fact, I had to tell people on our social media, like, hey, let's...
52:47 Lay off the surveys. We had a lot of surveys consistently going on out there for a period of time because we're really trying to gain feedback from the community, right? And then what follows along with that is the actions that come from that, right? You don't do well with any surveys if you don't have action items associated with them.
53:04 And then in this particular section of community outreach, we had a specific area about Spanish language offerings, right? And so a lot of what you see, almost all of our communications going out are dual language, so you'll see another one in Spanish as well. We have a fabulous Spanish-speaking staff at the town, so our core services, when someone walks into the town, they are immediately greeted.
53:31 By someone who is capable of communicating with them effectively. And it's very welcoming. It's automatic. I've watched people come in and they just look across. They probably know the folks that are working for us in that space that are capable of communicating with them. They just start right in. And services are improving significantly, especially in the business tax world. But we've always had great coverage in our building, planning.
53:58 And that process. So we're sort of augmenting that. And I'm really, really proud about how the town has that look and feel where we're just seamless across the communication styles. And that goes from our police force through our public works teams all the way through our offices. So a lot that we are engaged with in that particular space. Public safety was within the municipal services in its own section.
54:27 In that particular area, one of the highlights is the Raven, which is the gunshot detection system. It's part of the Flock Safety Program that we have in the town. If you remember, we have Flock Safety, which is a license plate reader program across the town. But Raven is designed to pinpoint any gunshots around very sensitive areas. So they're around the school systems, they're around the hospital.
54:53 And they provide our officers with a very close proximity to where the shot would have occurred. We partnered with Mammoth Unified School District, Mammoth County Office of Education, Syracuse Community College, and the hospital in implementing that. They provided funding for that program, and we're able to get that out there. And it extends...
55:17 Far enough to include the schools and all the way to the child care center that's at the parcel. We've also updated our Axon fleet, our in-car camera systems on our patrol vehicles, captures most activities.
55:33 That's from the officer's perspective whenever one of our vehicles is present. We've worked on less lethal components of our law enforcement activities and so forth really to make sure that those guys are equipped with the tools that they need and they're able to respond effectively to our community needs. We also partnered with Mono County Sheriff in purchasing two TrueNARC devices which are designed for substance testing without risking our officers' safety in doing so.
56:02 And then finally, the updates to the Municipal Code and enhancement of bike safety through our e-bikes within our community. As you know, e-bikes are growing usage. They can be used in a negative way with regard to how fast they move effortlessly through the area. We've had some issues with that. We've had some things that we've had to address. That's why this was on here. And so I think there's probably more that we need to do in that space in the coming.
56:31 Thank you. Thank you.
57:01 That's currently underway. But we didn't really engage in the bringing this to council, what's our town-wide vision, and so forth, and developing that visioning statement. So I think that's going to have to remain on there a little bit further and be able to work on that for next year. The environmental sustainability, again, this is all within municipal services still.
57:29 We were awarded the Caltrans Sustainable Transportation Planning Grant and the Climate Adaptation Action Plan. So we are working to develop that as part of that planning grant. And so that really helps guide the town in efforts of addressing climate change and its impacts. It will serve as a roadmap for the town to adopt climate change as well as to adopt...
57:53 Adapt to climate change as well as equitably achieve the state's goals of carbon neutrality by 2045. I think we're in a unique situation with the town of Mammoth Lakes and our elevation, where we are within California, that our sort of distinguishing features, if you will, especially when it involves potential warming climates, will require us to focus a whole lot more on
58:20 Our differentiation and how we may somehow be one of the only ski resorts possibly receiving snow on the West Coast in the near future. And so I think we're going to have to be prepared for a lot of that and I think that's a target that we will be seeking to focus on in that differentiation. We did implement the single-use plastic water ban for municipal government and then sourced an economical solution for our event planning. I'm excited about that.
58:47 These metal water bottles that we have going throughout the community, we're just about to launch those. They'll really be designed to be sold at our special events and utilized by the town. They have a QR code on them where people can fund local fundraising efforts like clean up the lake and other things associated with that. So a lot of good environmental sustainability components that we focused on. And then finally, capital projects, right? So Hayes and team,
59:17 Always does a great job of providing information about the capital projects that we have. You know, we're blessed to have the visitor base that we do, the visitor dollars that come to us that really fund our organization, but they also fund all the capital improvement projects that we've been able to accomplish. We had a very comprehensive review of that.
59:38 This year, and again, the entire summer was built with construction projects throughout town, a lot of work being done on the roads throughout the area, and I think you can see it just about anywhere you look from the work that's going on at the Articultural Center to our municipal town hall that's being developed to the CRC improvements. All across town, those things are there, and I have a whole list of the...
1:00:06 construction projects that we were able to accomplish, and they're very significant, and I think that's one of the things that I'm most proud of. I hear that from the community most often, that we're doing a lot of work, we're doing a lot of good for the community, and that makes me proud because that ties in not only with us being responsive to the needs of the community and really doing our jobs in that core area, but also being able to work on our funding, work on our budgeting processes, work on our
1:00:34 Fiscal discipline to be able to have those dollars available to invest back into the community. And so I know I'm grateful for Mammoth Lakes Tourism's work in trying to highlight this year that these things are created by tourism dollars available to us and really celebrating that fact. I think it's always important for us to really focus on.
1:00:57 What our core services are, also what our core business is as a community, and I think we've done a really, really good job of that in delivering the municipal services. So, Mayor Bubser, I'll pause there if there are any questions in the municipal services section. Questions on municipal services? No questions, but Rob, you'll be able to share this deck with us? Yes. Because it's not in our packet. It'd be helpful for the next meeting. What's that? No, but all these, this, that. That's what I'm looking for.
1:01:23 Well, it was this. Is that literally what this is? There's no changes to this? There's no changes to it. Okay. All right. Thank you. Questions? Okay. Just a very quick few questions. For municipal services, I think that we have had a renewed commitment to making sure that we are accessible and serving our Spanish-speaking community. And I would like us to just...
1:01:54 Continue to push ourselves to make sure that we are as helpful as possible. So, for example, just to ask the question, because I, and the reason I want to do this now is I want the rest of the council to hear, but like, should there be translators available if someone wanted to come and speak to us? Like, many municipalities that have the population of Spanish speakers that we do, do things bilingually or at least have translation live on their Zoom. So, I just,
1:02:21 I'm not asking the staff to address that now. I'm just saying that that's something I'll be asking about in the subsequent two conversations. The other thing is that more and more communities are really questioning and moving away from flock cameras because of some challenges that have happened in a few municipalities. And so I will want to ask about what
1:02:47 You know, Flock has done to respond to us about those very specific questions we had about our data and I just wanted to let everyone know that that I'll be pushing on that when we go forward and then e-bikes are constantly in the news. I just had an article forwarded to me by a member of the public who talked about how Marin County has gotten much more strict about different classifications.
1:03:12 And it seems like the state might solve the problem for us by creating legislation, but if they don't, just to know that we're staying on top of that issue, because it's moving target. If I could just say that I'm not getting any discussion now, but to broaden, perhaps broaden that discussion beyond e-bikes into e-motorcycles. There's an article we talked about that at ESSRP on Monday. It's way beyond the classification system the state already has, but if you want to bring that up, I would encourage you to.
1:03:38 I thought those were not allowed on town roads, right? Well, that's, it's, it's, the problem that the mayor is talking about is proliferating everywhere, but it's much, it's much more than just e-bikes, class one, two, three e-bikes, it's now into electric motorcycles and all that other kind of stuff. Yeah, and I think the point we're just making to let staff know is that these are things on our minds, so.
1:03:59 So that it doesn't come up as a surprise. And then all of a sudden we're trying to discuss our strategic priorities for 26 and there's still a lot of discussion. So that's all. Yeah, I think I appreciate that. And, you know, we'll dive deeper on that. Staff is, you know, aware and working on some of that stuff. And I think we do need to have some clarification about some of the new products. As you're right, the electric motorcycles are a different animal entirely. But staff's got more to come. We'll probably dive deeper on that in the next meeting.
1:04:28 Sure. And then we had that great presentation from High Sierra Energy Foundation last meeting. And, you know, I just think that it's very important for us to stay on top of how we as a town move towards electrification, even though we get a lot of, there's a lot of carve-outs of regulations that we get because of our altitude and other things. I think it's something we just really want to stay abreast of. We don't want to be left behind and be the last town.
1:04:58 In America with propane. So I think those were just points that I wanted to make sure were raised. And so community investment? Sure. So under community investment, you know, affordable housing, obviously that's really a critical thing that we've been working on for a number of years and will be really on our discussion plates for the next decade, if not more.
1:05:29 Because that problem is very, very difficult to solve for. Staff did engage with BAE Economics on the development of an updated housing needs assessment. That's really kind of commissioned, if you will, after the parcel was opened to try to understand the impacts that the parcel had on our housing needs and those updates. And then it kind of morphed into a more regional discussion from Mono County, Inyo County, and City of Bishop also being included in this study.
1:05:59 Because they're all kind of interconnected in how we provide housing in our area. We continue with the parcel, right? There's a lot going on in that space. As you remember, the last couple of meetings we had phase two, we authorized additional funding for that. All in all, phase two and one and two should develop about 230 low-income affordable rental units.
1:06:27 And we're looking now to focus our energies on the missing metal. You know, staff has done a great job of looking at a multitude of ways of addressing this. Our bridge program, which is the acquisition of market rate houses, selling them at a deed restricted subsidized rate, making them affordable for workforce in the area, has been successful for a number of years. We just completed our first, you know, sort of
1:06:54 We call it small site development, which is where we're building units to be sold, where the town is sort of the funding of the contractor to build the units. We've got opportunities to expand that in a number of areas within town, and I think that we are really focused on that. We're looking at and evaluating a comprehensive review of our missing middle approach, right? We've talked about this 80 to 120 being a
1:07:22 A gap in which we don't have a lot of activity outside of leasing to locals going on, and we really need to define that strategy for 2026. We have some excellent staff work going on to, you know, really play out what different options there are available to us, and what that's highlighted to me is we really need to define as an organization what we want to achieve because there's...
1:07:47 The partnerships and leveraging partnerships in that space. One of the key areas that we are working with is
1:08:16 Department of Fish and Wildlife, we're continuing to strengthen those relationships this year. We worked very closely with them to really identify long-term sustainable solution for wildlife management in the town. As you know, that's a very complex and multifaceted issue that we need to address with wildlife. The town really is relying on CDFW not only for sort of the
1:08:46 Sort of law aspect of managing the wildlife, but really the biological review, as you saw in one of our presentations mid-summer, there was a tremendous presentation from CDFW on their biologists and the analysis they do on the herds and the animals that are migrating through our area. I think that was really educational and just how closely they're monitoring that stuff. And we, you know, are doing our part with regard to educating staff.
1:09:15 We're educating visitors through our hosting staff as well as work that we're doing in Mammoth Disposal and managing our trash to protect wildlife. So it's really quite a few areas that we're working on in that particular issue. So the other thing that we're doing is really partnering with Mono County, right? So we have a lot of similarities, especially when it comes to
1:09:46 I want to say more life safety elements, where you're talking about snow removal, you're talking about maintenance, other things like that, that we've got our directors of public works working closely on fleets, right? What fleets do we have and how do we combine those guys so we can share, if needed, resources, equipment, materials, parts, tools?
1:10:07 And sometimes even staffing to get things done, right? One of the mottos of the Eastern Sierra is we're sort of out here on an island and we need to be self-sufficient and this is a great way of sort of pooling our resources and getting that accomplished. And so another one I'd like to just highlight I'm particularly proud of, the town did respond quickly with Mono County in providing a funding gap, emergency gap for SNAP funds and really allocated a lot.
1:10:35 To that, but thankfully it came on really quickly, but it was more about how close we worked together and how we were able to just jump into action when necessary. And so I think that's enough in the partnership section. So community funding, developing capacity for community foundations. So in this particular area, you know, we had a couple of things that
1:11:02 We are also...
1:11:27 We finished the purchase and sale agreement with Mammoth Lakes Foundation property to provide for the construction of the performing arts center. And we're working also with Mono County Office of Education, Mountain Ski Area, Mono County, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and Mammoth Hospital in developing a child care solution across the region. As you know, we stood up a
1:11:51 Facility development, and now we're working on just how the program would work across multiple agencies with in-kind support as well as some financial support to really make our child care stuff affordable for the working families in the area. I think right now we're kind of struggling with utilization because the cost is high and that effort is really important to bring that down so that we get more people engaged in that.
1:12:20 And then finally in community development, there's a broad term of community development, really what that means and who's engaged in that space. I think the accomplishments of last year involved Snow Creek Development Agreement, and that was kind of a heavy lift, took a long time to get that completed. We had our first new hotel, Limelight, in approximately 20 years was completed.
1:12:45 We've got the second hotel at the Residence Inn has begun, as well as Rock Springs Lodge came into play this year. So pretty significant financial investment by outside agencies or outside entities into the town of Mammoth Lakes. Those are multi, multi, multi-million dollar investment in our community, and they really will help us grow as a town, help our overall business model be more successful.
1:13:14 And I think that's been a really strong year, strongest year I've ever seen in the town with regard to investment and development. And there's a lot of other people interested in building in other areas. We're currently engaged in some of the areas of North Village Pacific Plan. That alone is creating some other opportunities for us.
1:13:37 When we look at traffic management and other challenges that this growth will bring to us, and I know our staff is very focused on that, I think we'll see some highlighted sort of modifications, if you will, to the plans for 2026 that look at how we go about that. And I'd also say within the community development, I think really more definition of what community development means for our town.
1:14:03 And then what are the players that are involved in that, right? The town is just one entity involved. There's the chamber, there's businesses themselves, and a multitude of others. So we need to kind of define what that looks like, and that's probably some modifications to the goals for 2026. So I'll pause there for community investment, and I'll offer questions. Any questions? No? Go ahead. Well, just another, if I'm looking forward to getting the slide deck, or you can send me an editable document.
1:14:33 Yeah, it's interesting. We did launch a program this year. We were trying to
1:15:05 Really analyze a buy local campaign and it was more, you know, when you're talking about businesses like the town itself, our municipal government and others utilizing the town's resources to, you know, get product services and things that we need, that morphed into working with the chamber on what are the needs of the business community or what are the unmet needs of the community.
1:15:34 So that we could almost start to steer that into maybe a business opportunity, maybe something the town has a grant to help stand this business up that starts to get local businesses development in the town to provide self-service across the town. So that's a little bit of the change in that space. What you described though as far as
1:15:58 It goes from we need another pharmacy to how do we augment that. It's so broad, that's why we need to spend a little bit more time defining what that is. Because I think it's going to turn out that, you know, the town has a role in some of them, but not all of them. And really, our role is probably going to be identifying the needs and getting others into action. Questions? I'm good. Okay.
1:16:24 Just a couple. In terms of affordable housing, the question that I hope we can start to talk about is what should we ask of federal and state representatives to ease the burden of communities like ours? You know, when we come back to the missing middle housing problem, I just think that it's a pretty big expectation that communities like ours are on our own for that. So wherever we can ask for that assistance be reasonable.
1:16:52 And then the other one is I was really glad that we pledged $100,000 to address the food insecurity issue when SNAP benefits ran out. And I, you know, it did raise the question, you know, what can we do? Maybe as a town, maybe not. It's the same thing. Like, maybe it's just we identify this and figure out how to help NGOs or nonprofits, but to have more consistent and comprehensive ways to manage food insecurity. We have some...
1:17:20 Some folks doing that and I think that we could just make it a little more consistent and that would be beneficial. So that's all I had on that. So then we can move on to recreation amenities and programs. Thank you. So and I wish Stu Brown was here with us tonight. He's in Australia helping his family with some medical issues. So we send all our prayers to him. But
1:17:51 In recreation amenities and programs, one of the key things, this is obviously a very important aspect of our service delivery, both for the community visitors and all of that, and I think I want to commend the work that was done this year in providing access, accessibility, affordability to our recreation amenities. They developed an annual membership program.
1:18:16 Worked really closely through that and did a great job of identifying where prices need to be modified, services needed to be added, built a really good program, then got additional feedback of, you know, how do we make it even more affordable, right? And I think they responded in all aspects to that and really, I think we have a great product now, right? I mean, we have to balance this, I will say, and I'll put my finance hat on for a minute.
1:18:42 You know, this is a very expensive, the CRC, the aquatic center, the pool, are very expensive systems to run, and we need to balance the ability to cover the cost of those as well as making them affordable, and that's a very delicate balance. I think the approach that they achieved in this was thoughtful. We, I say we in the finance world, are still sort of continuing to
1:19:09 Educate on just how much things like that cost, how we need to be aware of those program developments and other things that we're doing in that space. But some other accomplishments I think were thoughtful are conversion of the ice rink to an NHL-sized ice rink for enhancing the play of hockey and also developing a dedicating curling lane. I think that was pretty good.
1:19:31 Staff made some modifications to the camps in the fall programs, really sort of learning about what some of the hang-ups, hiccups, and challenges were in the previous year and saying, you know, I need to modify these camps to make them weekly, right, make them something someone can engage with. And that was really successful. I heard nothing but great feedback from the community about that and really appreciate the efforts that were done there. And then finally they made a small little bike park next to the CRC just as an added amenity that
1:20:01 It's pretty fun to watch the kids ripping around on that track because it's developmental, right? It's at the very beginning so people are learning, you know, really how to engage with that and that hopefully will lead us to a larger bike park facility in our community soon. Under the community connectivity, you know, wayfinding in the area is a big issue. You know, we've updated all of our multi-youth path regulatory signage to improve safety.
1:20:30 Our parks and municipal signage that we're currently updating, the sliders, which are those things are really sort of disposable, removable components of a much more robust sign that is throughout town for wayfinding. And then really one of the biggest crowning achievements was the Sherwin Area Recreation Plan Trailhead Facility Project. So right outside of town, that project built a beautiful trailhead.
1:20:59 Great sort of interpretive sign program and it's world class aside from the sticks of trees that are out there that we still need to address. But that process itself really helped upgrade our wayfinding mobility and other plans in that space. Public lands, federal partners and state partners, you know, this year was challenging from the federal government's perspective and the town stepped right in.
1:21:27 Providing the gaps in services where federal government were not able to provide to make sure that our town did not suffer any negative circumstances from our visitor's experience or anything else. And I'm really proud of our ability to do that. We did seasonal trail clearing.
1:21:49 Outside of our municipal boundaries in order to support Forest Service personnel. We had recreation technicians that came in and provided bathroom cleaning and miscellaneous maintenance projects to get that done. And at the same time, we're writing letters of support for our public partners and federal partners. I know they felt really supported by our efforts, and I'm still hearing today the support and appreciation for that. I'm so happy that we were able to lean into that space.
1:22:15 And then, you know, sustainable outdoor recreation talked about wildlife a little bit earlier and the multifaceted approach to that. You know, we made municipal code changes to augment enforcement of trash and support of wildlife. We changed the host program to really work on educating people in the lakes basins, going through the campsites, talking to the campers, engage with them Friday nights and Saturday nights, getting that stuff done.
1:22:43 Really spending time with Fish and Wildlife to review their bear tracking efforts and report that to the town. And then just engaging with the community to address concerns about bear management. We had some really tough meetings in this room. I think they were healing. I think they were appropriate. And I think they were supported by the community if they felt engaged in that space. And then finally, we're working with
1:23:07 Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mono County Department of Fish and Wildlife on the golden mussel threat to our region. So that's an emerging concern and threat. And we are at the forefront of that, as usual. And I expect more to come. I know there's some grants being produced to provide for cleaning facilities all throughout Lakes Basin and even throughout Mono County. So I'll pause there on recreational amenities and ask if there are any questions. Questions? Questions?
1:23:35 Do you have any questions? Well, I just had a question. I guess when I read this, I thought that I read that you had the climbing boulder in there at the CRC, but I, like, don't find it anywhere. Did you put that in there? That's another thing? I don't think I did because I was doing this late at night and I might have missed it, but the climbing boulder is awesome. Well, you should add the climbing boulder because it's super fun. And I do think we need to get some more routes on there, but that was another amenity that we added. Okay, more routes in the climbing boulder. Thank you.
1:24:01 Council Member Wentworth, I know that... Nothing. Is there any... You're sure? Because this would be the time for you to... Again, but I don't want to get into deliberation. Okay. Because I think, Rob, there's a lot of presentation going on here, so I will have comments and ideas, but I don't think it's the time to do it. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Thank you so much. We will look forward to the next two meetings where we... Yeah, I appreciate that. If I would just wrap up a couple of things here. So, yeah, as I stated in the very beginning, the intent of this...
1:24:30 And then we will look to...
1:25:00 Bring that back on the first meeting of January. Minor wordsmithing, if necessary, and an adoption at that point. So I appreciate your guys' engagement with this. And this was a little challenging to get through tonight, but I appreciate the work. Thank you. And I think we accomplished a lot in 2025. There's much to be grateful for. So with that, I think we're on to item nine. I think this is when I get a new seat. Get a new seat. Yeah.
1:25:33 Is that my cue? Item 9.1? Yes. This is recognition of outgoing Mayor Chris Bubser? Yes. I recognize her. Well, I think, I mean, I'd like to really say how much I appreciated the work and effort that you were able to put forth. I think your style, your compassion, and caring for the community has, there's no bounds to it. I mean, it's so deep. It comes out in every meeting.
1:26:02 I would like to say something. So Chris, I feel like
1:26:30 You are such a well-spoken person. It's really been a pleasure having you be the mayor for the year, and we're also incredibly grateful for your time and dedication. You are very welcoming of everyone in our community, and I feel like you're open to hearing everyone's side, and I feel like this year you really made an effort to...
1:26:58 Do community outreach, you know, you had your office hours and it felt like you do a wonderful job of like getting a pulse on the community and getting opinions from like a wide range of people and not just the loudest person in the room. You know, you're very generous with your time and you've put a lot of effort into this position and I really appreciate all the time that you've put in.
1:27:23 And you also, I feel like you really have an open mind and heart going into different discussions and especially tough discussions. I feel like you really want to do right by everyone, which is hard to do. And then I also really appreciate, I feel like you have the attitude of a lifelong learner. You're always willing to ask questions to try to do the best for everyone in our community. So I just want to say thank you so much for being our mayor for the last year. We've really...
1:27:52 Benefited from having you in that position. Thank you, Amanda. And a couple different things. One, I'd use the word care because you come across very much that you not only care for the community but you care in what you do and respect for others and want to get the community well done. And I think the tribute is after Rob just spent the last half hour, 45 minutes talking about what was done in this last year, you should look back and see what was done when your turn as mayor and what this town has accomplished and you should be very proud about that. Thank you.
1:28:21 Your passion for the community shows through in everything you do, which is hard to do when sitting in this chair, that chair, especially after the last chair. So I have to give you great kudos for that. You show great passion with emotion for this community, and that's a big plus, and thank you. Thank you, Bill. I think for all of us as council members and future council members to learn from is that you are
1:28:48 As fully rounded a public servant as I've ever met. The work that you do up here from the dais leading, have you led us for the last year, but the work you've done in Measure L, your ongoing interest and engagement with all things associated with this community and the larger community, it's a really beautiful and profound example to set for all of us, so thank you. Thanks so much. And we have a plaque to present you with.
1:29:13 Shall we all go down there? Sure, let's take a picture. Her husband's going to take a picture. He's going to be like, oh, she's back. Where will I spend all that energy on my family? I don't know. Yeah, why not? Where do I put it? Oh, we'll find it. All right, you ready?
1:29:42 One, two, three. Thank you, guys. Thanks a lot. Thank you, Chris. You know, and I just want to say briefly, you know, when you become the mayor, well, I guess I should. When you take the position of mayor in a town like this where it's a council manager form of government, you don't get any additional really roles and responsibilities except to chair the meeting. But something...
1:30:13 It does happen where you do feel this sort of added responsibility. And there are several folks here who have been the mayor and several who might become the mayor one day. So it's really hard to describe. So I just really want to say thank you to Rob and the entire staff and Andy, because you never know when you're going to need help. And the thing about this town and the staff and also all the departments, the police department are fired.
1:30:41 And I just want to say, Mayor Pro Tem, Rice, it made it a lot easier for me this year because the way that you help
1:31:07 Communication across the dais is really extraordinary and I look forward to seeing how you use that in the future and also just knowing how engaged and responsible you are even if I wasn't able to take care of something I knew it would be handled and Councilmember Truax I really want to thank you for stepping up because you have
1:31:28 So much lived experience in this town, both working in our main area of hospitality, as well as raising a wonderful daughter and being part of our schools and being on the board of many nonprofits. It adds a lot of context to our council. And Councilmember Sauser, I want to say that you taught me how to run a meeting where everyone's voices are lifted up and heard. So thank you for that exemplary.
1:31:57 And finally, Councilmember Wentworth, you know, I often tell people they have no idea how lucky they are to have you have been on our council for so long. You love this community. You work tirelessly, not just here, but at the state and often federal levels to make sure that our voice is being heard. And you taught me so much, and you were super patient in my first couple years when I...
1:32:24 Thank you all. I just really am filled with gratitude. Who takes the middle chair? Yeah, right. I know, but I'm joking. But I still do that agenda item, right? You're still there. You're still there until now. Okay. So thanks, everybody. So for the next agenda item, then, we will do the transition. And so I imagine that I could
1:33:05 Accept a nomination for Mayor of Town of Mammoth Lakes for 2026. I would love to make a motion for Amanda Rice to move into the mayoralship. Fantastic. Do I have a second? I'll second. Great. Jamie, can you please call the, oh, Mayor Pro Tem Rice, do you accept the nomination? I do. Okay, fantastic. All right, so Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes.
1:33:32 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. Congratulations. Thank you. And I really want to say I'm very excited to see where you take us in the next year. You couldn't be out of here sooner, Chris. You should sit in the chair. Vote the flags. Come on. All right. Well, I guess my first job will be to have us appoint a Mayor Pro Tem.
1:34:07 Do I have any? I would make a motion to put Brent Truax in as our Mayor Pro Tem and throw him into the fire. I mean, to see that, yeah. I'll second that if that's what you'd like, Madam Mayor. Wonderful. Okay. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, wonderful. Mayor Rice!
1:34:36 I love that. Okay, it looks like we are on to Agenda Item 9.3, Town Council appointments to commissions, committees, and boards. And so if it's to everyone's pleasing, I think we'll go through one at a time through the, I'm sorry, I'm just trying to pull this up and see how everyone is doing with their appointments. So we have the land use.
1:35:06 We have Lafco. This one says Ray on here. That's me. I found a typo on your page. Yeah, it says, it should say Brent on that. Okay. Or Truax on that. So Lafco, yeah, Brent Truax, Amanda Rice, and alternative Chris Bubser is currently what's on that. I think, Mayor Rice, you've expressed a desire to not be on that one.
1:35:37 Is that correct? That would be my preference. Okay. I could be an alternate if Chris would like to switch. Would that be? Or do you have another idea? And I think we had Mr. Sauser who was chomping at the bit to get on that. Okay. Yay. Chomping. Thank you, Bill. So I have written little notes with each one of these, and on this one I show myself and Brent with Chris as the alternate.
1:36:06 That would be my going in. So if appropriate, I would make that motion. Should we make a motion at the end after all the appointments are done? Okay. Perfect. Okay. So Airport Land Use Commission. Is that Ray also? That's Truax, Rice, and Buxer. Should we just substitute the agenda? Am I on the wrong? Page 17 of the agenda.
1:36:33 Oh, on the page 17. I can go to that one. Does that have everyone's name correct? It seems like it so far. Perfect. Okay. Page 17 is where I made my notes. Okay. Airport Land Use Commission, Rice, Truax, and Bubser as alternate. Are there any changes referred there? No? I'm not hearing anything. Mono County Collaborative Planning Team.
1:37:02 We have Senior Planner Kim Cook and Bubser and Truax as alternates. Any changes? Where are we at? Under land use. Last item under land use. Yeah. Okay. Any changes preferred there? Not seeing any? Okay. We have Intergovernmental Relations, Town and County Liaison Committee, Bubser, Rice, and Town Manager. That would be Truax and Rice for the following year? Is that correct? No.
1:37:34 I don't think we are. I thought it was the Mayor and the Mayor Pro Tem. Is that where we're at? Last time we guys agreed that it was the Mayor and the Mayor Pro Tem, but before that it was whoever would do it. Okay. Yeah, I'm a little confused because I'm working off of page seven. Two different sheets. I think page 80 is a better one to go to. On this one, I sort of wanted to move to that myself, if that was acceptable for my notes. Over the place here now.
1:38:09 I'm currently the alternate. I'm currently the alternate, yeah. I don't mind not being on the Town Council. That's okay with me. Okay. Desert Mountain Division of the League of California Cities. Souser and Town Manager is alternate. I'm sorry, I didn't capture. On the previous one, the Town Council liaison, we were removing Bubster and adding Souser. Was there an alternate identified? I can serve as alternate. Truax is alternate? Okay. Okay. Okay.
1:38:42 Thank you. All right. Desert Mountain Division of the League of California Cities, Sauser and Town Manager as alternate. I have no problem with that one. Okay. Eastern ESCOG, Bubzer, Wentworth, and Sauser as alternate. Is that fine with everyone? It's fine with me. It's fine with you. Yeah, it's fine with me. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District, Wentworth and Bubzer as alternate. I'm fine with that.
1:39:10 Okay, League of California Cities voting delegate, Bubser, and the town manager as an alternate. So that's usually the mayor. Okay. Okay, actually in the past it has not been the mayor. Oh. So the way we have worked this in the past is that as the representative to the League of California Cities, which I think I was just reelected to, but we're moving quickly here, I would bring back the slate that the league had put up to vote on that session.
1:39:38 Then if a council member other than myself chose to go to the meeting, we could appoint someone to be the voting delegate at that point and agree or disagree on how we were going to vote with the league issues. In that, there is a policy whereby someone can introduce something at convention, bring it forward through an amendment thing. In that case, you're
1:40:09 Whoever is going to go to the meeting, but your appointed person for the league would then take over that role automatically if something new came up. I don't know if I made that at all clear, like mud and water, yeah. So you recommended that you would be the delegate, the voting delegate, but the voting delegate could be chosen if needed. Right, so because I have been the representative for a long time, it was only the last go-around that John recommended that we change it to the mayor.
1:40:38 But it needs to be somebody who can be at that meeting. So appointing it just before the convention makes sense. And as I said, you can pass out a petition at convention to put something new on the agenda that we wouldn't be able to vote on. You could still get your voting delegate in advance. I have always brought it to the council for whatever is brought forward prior to the convention itself to get councils.
1:41:08 Sway on how we should vote, because that's how it should go. Whoever is down there is only 20% of the council. No, but I think also there's going to be a new administration in California, you know, that may be after your term, but I think having, you know, a presence down there to figure out what's being talked about, what the League of Cities is up to, and what's going to be coming up in next year is going to be really important. So I appreciate your work on that and the opportunity to assign delegates to go to those meetings and just keep it to what's happening.
1:41:37 I mean, we can assign to it whoever we want now. I just always found it appropriate to make sure that whoever we assigned was going to be at the meetings and that we as a council had weighed in on anything that was brought forward prior to the convention itself. Yeah. Well, I'm okay with you being the voting delegate on that one. Is everyone else okay with that? Yeah, sure. Okay. Okay. So, let's see. Just stay away from the scooters.
1:42:06 I'm sorry, I was unfortunate. But they're my favorite. Okay, next. California Joint Powers Insurance Authority Board, Truax, an assistant to the town manager as alternate. I finally stay there. Okay. Transportation, LTC. We have Bubzer, Sauser, and Truax, and town manager as alternate. So we modified that mid-year, and Chris was not able to attend based on the timing of the meeting. It was fairly inflexible on the Mona County side.
1:42:34 For when that meeting could be held. So the town manager, essentially we navigated most of the year as Salzer, Truax, and town manager as the representatives and we did not have an alternate. I think that's probably fine for this process too and if we want to identify an alternate that may be helpful because these meetings are, you know, monthly and there are things that come up so. What time are the meetings? This one I've always had a problem with.
1:43:00 Because it says that we can have three representatives and the county can have three and council has weighed in that that is okay for this, but it's always made me a little nervous to have a quorum of council sitting on any board. So I think making the town manager one member and then the two council members makes really good sense to me. We make sure we stay out of any confusion. But an alternate, I suppose, would be a good idea.
1:43:27 John, are you able to be the alternate? I am not. You're not. And Chris, you're not. No. I mean, I work. I have school from 8 to 3. No, I know. The alternate would almost have to be Chris. Well, she said she couldn't do it this past year. Maybe you can just have good attendance. There is no issue going without an alternate. That's a thing. Because there will always be at least two of us. Right. Yeah. And most meetings are really non-voting meetings. They're more informational anyway.
1:43:52 I think an alternate, it would be nice to have in this space. We don't necessarily need to have it. I think we'll get coverage. Okay. Okay. Yeah, like if, for example, even though I wasn't the formal alternate, if you knew in advance that one of you couldn't go and you asked, I can certainly, you know, fill that gap. It's not like I would, but it was just like monthly on Mondays, it just conflicted with the standing meeting I had.
1:44:17 Yeah, there are some meetings over the course of the year where Hayes has made specific requests for dollars and stuff coming out of the program that it is nice to have all three of us there as a block. Right. Okay. So did you get consensus on that?
1:44:35 Jamie, okay. So, but it was Bubser, excuse me, listen to me. It was Souser, Truax, and Town Manager, not as alternate. Those are the three members. That's correct. That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Eastern Sierra Transit Authority Board, Bubser and Souser. I'm fine with that. And I'm fine with that as well. Okay. Local issues. Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. I'm good. I think it's...
1:44:56 There's some continuity issues I think we need to keep an eye on. Okay. Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board, Truax. Yep. That's fine. And Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board, that's mine. I'll stay on that. Mm-hmm. Treasury Oversight Committee, Finance Director, Town Manager as alternate. Yeah, that's good. That's fine. Okay. Parks and Recreation Master Plan Advisory Committee, Rice, Bubser as alternate. That's fine with me. And that's the last one.
1:45:25 Mayor, I make a motion to accept the nominations as described in our conversations. Second. Okay, wonderful. Whatever our conversation was, I'm agreeing to it. She takes great notes. Okay. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Councilmember Salzer. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Temp, Truax. Yes. Mayor Rice. Yes. Okay, passes. And we are on to the consent agenda.
1:45:56 Okay, yeah. Anyone like to pull anything? No. No one? Okay, I'll read the consent agenda. Okay, 10.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of November 19, 2025. 10.2, authorize the town manager to finalize and execute a professional services agreement in the amount of $224,992 with DUDEC for development of the town's climate adaption and action plan.
1:46:22 10.3. Update and approval to continue emergency installation of above-ground wastewater tank at 299 Commerce Drive. 10.4. Accept check register 11-14-25 in the amount of $2,175,113.43. Accept check register November 20th, 25 in the amount of $2,553,462.39.
1:46:54 And that's the end of the consent agenda. Move to approve. Second. Second. Can I take public comment on this? Do I need to take public comment on the consent agenda? Well, yes. You do. Okay. Are there any public comments in the room? Hi, my name's Ula. I'm a reporter for The Sheet. Realizing I should have asked you to pull this when you said, does anybody want to pull anything?
1:47:25 But I'm curious about what the town's climate adaption and action plan looks like with DUDEC. And I understand it's like a matching with like a grant that you receive from the state, but I just want to hear some discussion about what that plan looks like. After looking at the staff report, you have questions about it? I do, yeah.
1:47:53 Do you have questions about what the adaptation and action plan is going to look like? Yeah. It hasn't been developed yet. It hasn't been developed. Right. This contract is to award a contract to a consultant that's going to help develop the adaptation and action plan. Gotcha. So it doesn't exist yet. It doesn't exist yet. Right. Okay. Cool. Awesome. Thank you. Okay. So you have a motion. We have a motion and a second? Okay. Roll call, please. Council Member Bubzer? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes.
1:48:21 Mayor Pro Tem, Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. And we are on to 11 policy matters. 11.1, consideration of an ordinance amending Title 15 of the Municipal Code for the purpose of adopting the 2025 California Building Standards Code. Is that you, Rob? Yeah, that's all Rob. Rob is all things building code. All right.
1:48:52 So I'll just give a brief introduction before I hand it over to Tom Perry, the building official. So this is the adoption of the 2025 California Building Code. This adoption process is slightly different from other ordinances in that we were introducing the item today, giving the presentation, having the discussion, and then we'll be having the public hearing to adopt the ordinance at the subsequent meeting, so that'll be on December 17th.
1:49:20 So at that meeting, we'll do the formal process of opening the public hearing, taking any public comments, and then closing it. So it's kind of the opposite of a normal ordinance, if you have any questions as to why that is. And Andy is here to explain that process. But like I said, it's slightly different just because the government code creates a uniqueness around that. And can I just ask for clarity, we basically have to do something or else have our own code, which we'd have to put in our own code if we were going to do something separate.
1:49:49 Well, yes. So the way it's always been in California is the state adopts the building code and then local agencies can do local amendments. And we've always had pretty free reign to do that as long as you could justify them by citing unique local climatological or seismological conditions. There was a piece of legislation from last year that now says we can't make any new changes for a period of some years, but what we can do is continue forward
1:50:17 Our local amendments that we've previously enacted. So in Mammoth, we greatly increase the roof structure requirements because of snow loading, and we can't do anything new, but we can continue on our previous snow load requirements, and Tom will go over this in more detail. That's the general idea. We don't really have the ability to just say no to the state code, and we no longer have the ability to really freelance a lot with local stuff, but we can just keep doing what we have been doing.
1:50:47 Okay. Well, good evening, Town Council. Tom Perry, building official for Town of Mammoth Lakes, here to present the formal adoption of the 2025 California Building Codes into the Town Municipal Code, along with certain minor amendments to our Title 15, which is our local code for buildings and construction. And at any point in time during the presentation, feel free to jump in if you have questions, comments, concerns, any of that. This is an interactive presentation, so please.
1:51:17 Feel free. With that, we'll jump right into it here. Delaying process. Sorry. There we go. Okay. That's more like it. Okay, great. So effective, some of this you may already know, but effective on January 1st of 26, all building permit applications that are received will be subject to the new 2025 California building codes.
1:51:51 Projects that were already permitted or had an application submitted before January 1st will be subject to the current codes that we're in now, which is the 2022 code cycle. Building permit applications that are submitted on or after January 1st, 2026 will be required to comply with the new codes, the 2025 California building codes.
1:52:14 California does have its own state code, so it's worth mentioning that regardless of local adoption, all the state codes become effective statewide on January 1st. We do this every three years as a formality really just to adopt local codes to update our local state codes to update our local code and keep that up to date. So we get to do this every three years. So the town codes or the new state codes that are to be adopted or be proposed to be adopted to the town by ordinance are
1:52:45 All the codes you see there, those are the 2025 California codes. Most of those codes there are the same ones that have been in existence for quite a long time. The residential building, green building, administrative, electrical, mechanical, plumbing, energy, historical building, fire code existing, and reference standards code. But you'll notice at the top of the slide, there's a new one, and that is the 2025 California Wildland Urban Interface Code, or the California WUI Code. That is new for this code cycle.
1:53:14 And will be a part of the Title 24 Family of Codes, Part 7. And we'll talk about that new code just a little bit here later in the presentation. So the code adoption process, just a quick overview of that. Like I said, California has its own state codes, like other states, and unlike other states, such as Nevada, that do not have a state code, they kind of get to do whatever they want, in so many words. California, not the case.
1:53:42 So with California, there's a state agency known as the California Building Standards Commission whose charge is to adopt new codes by order of the California legislature to establish minimum standards for buildings and construction in the state of California. It includes, as always, new construction, alterations, additions, repairs, changes of occupancy, demolitions, relocated buildings, and about everything else you could think of related to building.
1:54:10 The format of the state, California state codes is that they're based on model codes that are developed by other organizations that were developed last year and the year before. They're basically developed by the International Code Council, the Uniform Codes and NFPA, and various state agencies will add their local requirements into those codes that are known as amendments. Those appear in the state code from
1:54:37 Department such as HCD, Division of the State Architect, and the Office of the State Farm Marshal. Those amendments usually appear as italicized language in the California codes to distinguish California amendments from model code language, which is usually non-italicized. So as mentioned, we have a new code. This code cycle is the California Wild Urban Land Interface Code or the WUI code. Like the building and residential codes, it's based on
1:55:05 An international code that's used as a model code. In this case, this is the 2024 International Wildland Urban Interface code. Just as a refresher, the standards that are in the WUI code basically pertain to the exterior cladding of a building, such as windows, siding, roofing, deck surfaces, and that kind of thing. And it really is designed in short to
1:55:31 Resist ember intrusion and ignition of structures from airborne embers from adjacent wildfires. So that's always been the crux of the standards in WUI. They've been around for a long time. They've been in both the residential and building codes since 2008. But with the increased and worsening condition of wildfires in the state, it has become its own standalone code, which makes a lot of sense and is not a surprise at all.
1:56:00 It's really intended to address the escalating risk of wildfires throughout the state while increasing the resilience of structures and ensuring more sustainable communities in WUI areas. And most of California are WUI areas. It's basically a tinderbox, as we know. So it's a real-world problem. You'll note the picture in the lower right-hand corner is from the PAC fire, which just happened a couple weeks ago. And so this is something that definitely hits close to home.
1:56:27 This code was developed through a multi-year collaboration between a couple of agencies and organizations, such as the Office of State Fire Marshal, the International Code Council, and the California Building Officials Organization, or CALBO, as it's known. So there are no really big, giant changes in the state code, and certainly none that are proposed in our local code, but there are three.
1:56:52 Code items that I think would be worthy of mention to the council tonight. The first is Assembly Bill 130. There's a lot going on in AB 130, but for purposes of tonight's discussion, there's a component called the building code freeze, and that basically significantly curtails the authority of local governments to amend residential building standards on the basis of physical conditions, and he made mention of that previously.
1:57:18 The second item is an appendix that appears in the California Building Code known as Appendix P, sleeping lofts, which in short provides very relaxed standards than what we're used to in the regular building code for small little areas that can be used in residential buildings for sleeping spaces. And then finally, the last topic I wanted to briefly cover with the council tonight would be snow loads. There is a significant change you should be aware of in the state standard for
1:57:46 Snow Loads, which appears in ASCE 722. We'll get into that here in just a little bit coming up. Do you have a question? Yes. If you go back to the, you're going to expand on each of these? I'm sorry? You're going to expand on each one of these? Yes. I'll wait until you go through that. Yeah, sure. Absolutely, yes, of course. So, AB 130. Basically, the Health and Safety Code for many years, for many years has allowed jurisdictions to
1:58:16 Amend and add to the local code for things that are, quote, reasonably necessary due to local topographic, geologic, and climactic conditions. And the town has such amendments we've had for a long time. The county does. Truckee does. Many jurisdictions have local amendments. It's pretty common. AB 130, with the building code freeze provision, basically places about five restrictions on the ability for a jurisdiction to do that.
1:58:46 It went into effect on October 1st of this year, and it's expected to go through June 1 of 2031. Things that are in the local code now or were codified before October 1st are exempted. And the intent of this whole thing is really to promote residential development by trying to limit or reduce local codes that could be construed as onerous or restrictive in some cases.
1:59:12 And so it's really designed to try to promote residential development given the housing issue and the housing crisis that we have in the state. Like I said, certain exceptions exist for us to still be able to do that, such as anything related to WUI, which is also known as home hardening, emergency standards or standards that are related to emergencies still can be eligible, and then local codes that are quote similar.
1:59:38 To existing local codes can still be, that's another exception that could be used in relation to AB 130. As we went through the code, myself, legal counsel and other staff, we looked at what I have proposed in our local code, which are very, very minor changes, just a little housekeeping, some updating of what we have in our local code relative to state codes. We feel very comfortable that there's, we're not even close to violating anything.
2:00:05 We're crossing that line for AB 130. So I think we're on safe ground with what we have here tonight as it relates to Assembly Bill 130. CBC Appendix P, Sleeping Lofts. So this is an appendix that has never been around before. This is brand new for this code cycle. For the last 50 plus years, we've had code language for lofts, as we know, that are known as mezzanines.
2:00:32 But these, the standards there in Appendix Pier greatly reduced from what we're, or relaxed from what we're used to in the code of old, basically. So it appears, it appears in the CBC, the California Building Code, and it applies to condos and other multifamily buildings, but not to single-family residences. Single-family residences and duplexes are covered by the residential code.
2:00:58 And the language in Appendix P for these relaxed standards for sleeping lofts appears in the body of that code. So those who want to build a new home or they want to alter an existing one or two family dwelling and have a sleeping loft, a very small area where people can sleep, can do so starting on January 1st without any action required locally to adopt codes or to adopt appendix. However, in the building code,
2:01:25 It is an appendix, which means in order for it to be codified and to be able to be used, it has to be adopted specifically by the governing board. The criteria in sleeping lofts, like I said, is greatly reduced from or relaxed from what we have in the codes up to this point. Some of the criteria includes floor areas less than 70 square feet, ceiling heights that are as low as 3 feet.
2:01:51 The allowance of ladders for egress and stairs that could be as narrow as 20 inches. We've never had standards in building code ever that have allowed for that. But now with Appendix P and the language we have in the California Residential Code, we now have those standards. And again, it's in support of trying to address the housing crisis and find more places for people to sleep and to put more people in existing housing stock and to have that also be used for new construction.
2:02:21 The scope. So just to clarify on that one. Please, yes. So in essence, this would relax our current standards that we have, and if I had a certain type unit, I could remodel and all of a sudden have a usable loft that wasn't usable before. Correct, yes. So that really is the gist. That's why I thought this was potentially applicable for the town of Mammoth Lakes, because
2:02:48 There's a lot, as we know, there's a lot of lofts out there, a lot of condos, right? And we know that there's a lot that never, for various reasons, never met code at the time of original construction. And so I do know that there's not a lot of people out there, but some who would like to get their condo with a loft and make it legal because it never complied with code. And so for those folks who want to do that, want to voluntarily remodel their loft to make it comply with code, this appendix, I think, has the potential of really helping these people
2:03:18 Where before, with what we had in the code before, you wouldn't be able to make that happen because these lofts are very spatially confined, such as low ceiling heights that you can never change or floor areas you can't alter or areas that won't accommodate like a full stair set. This appendix now has provisions that...
2:03:40 We'll make, can possibly make that occur where before that wasn't possible. And these standards would overwrite our existing standards once they're done? They would not, no. So, so that's a great point. So, this, these are standards there in the code that are used basically for people who want to pull a permit and do alterations. In our code now for lofts, we have a section, it's section C in the code that
2:04:04 Basically addresses lofts in the as-built state without any remodeling or repairs or any of that going on. In short, it's basically a compilation of codes going back to 1964 all the way till about the 80s when most of these lofts were built to kind of set as a baseline for existing lofts. And that's the criteria that generally is used for TOT inspections and that kind of thing. This would be another avenue for people through the permit process for the town.
2:04:32 To alter those lofts and to bring them into compliance. So it would not supplant or replace what we have in a local code, but it would be adopted by a reference and be able to be used for those who want to pull permits to voluntarily remodel their loft. Got you. Chris, do you have a question? Would this? Sorry. I saw her hand up. Go ahead. Yeah, so there was a specific complex that during the TOT discussions had a
2:04:58 Challenge with this. So I'm not completely certain from your answer what would happen to those units. How this affects our certified property program and how many people are allowed to stay in each unit. Sure. So a year ago, a year and a half ago, it all blurs together when we were doing the certified properties. We're also working with the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors on
2:05:26 We thought that was a little disingenuous because we know once we left.
2:05:53 Beds probably went back in or however they might use it. So we recently worked with the Board of Realtors in the past year to come up with a new process where you'd still require to get your TOT inspection. It would identify any deficiencies or areas where your loft is non-compliant compared to the code. And then when you apply for your certified property or your TOT certificate, you're required to sign a disclaimer.
2:06:21 Acknowledging that you received that inspection, acknowledging that you understand if there's any areas where your loft has been non-compliant, the town's recommendation is that you don't use it for sleeping purposes. So really it shipped the responsibility onto that owner on how they then use that loft. What this code would do, and Tom and I have talked about some of the details of how we'll inform on that inspection that if a loft has become
2:06:51 Compliant under Appendix P so that it's when they get their inspection, at least it's noted that, hey, this permit, this unit did go through an alteration at some point to become legal under Appendix P. So we still work to go on exactly how that gets included in that certified properties and identified. But it doesn't change how the owner may or may not use their loft.
2:07:20 Because they're still, they're basically being told, hey, here you have areas of deficiency, but how they ultimately choose to use it, that's the responsibility of the owner and at their risk. However, if they decide to do a remodel, and a remodel can be as little as, you know, splashing paint on it, they now are in line with the new existing codes. Wouldn't that then allow them to change the use under our current guidelines? They're not.
2:07:53 Change, I mean, they are basically free to use their loft how they choose now, whether they choose to sleep there or not, under the current code, we're acknowledging areas that they're deficient under current code, they choose to remodel it, then yes, now it's a compliant sleeping area under the building code, and they can still use it to sleep or not to sleep. Goes yes. Yeah, I got it.
2:08:25 My other question was, so can we, this is the building code, this is for if I've got an old condo and I want to put in a loft, I can put it. And legally we can't stop them from that under this. However, under our short-term rental program, can we still, because of the number of people that can sleep in the unit and that kind of stuff, enforce our old, not that I want to, but. So we already treat the, if you have a loft in a unit,
2:08:56 Regardless if it was previously a bad loft or a good loft, you still got the occupancy for that loft. So I believe, and probably correct me if I'm wrong, but it's two people per bedroom, which includes a loft. So if you have a two bedroom unit plus a loft, that would allow for six people plus one additional person. So that's the formula. So in a two bedroom with a loft condo, you could get an occupancy of seven under certified properties for how many you could sleep.
2:09:24 So that does not change with this, whether you have a newly remodeled loft or not, you're still, the occupancy numbers are still the same. Basically, this really doesn't affect what we already have in place. This is for those who want to voluntarily model, which a lot of people don't. A lot of people, you know, they get the T.O.T. inspection, you know, there might be some things wrong with their loft. The inspector tells them there's a few things wrong. They give them a, you know, a form that they sign to acknowledge that, and that's really usually the end of it.
2:09:55 And I think that's how most of these go. But there, like I said, there are a handful of folks. I can think of two that have lofts that just, you know, not related to TOT. Just want to remodel them just to make them compliant for general compliance purposes. So hopefully that answers your questions. So anyway. So that's appendix P. So it tends to help folks who want to do that. That's really why I'm just, you know, proposing that.
2:10:26 Floating that out there for consideration for the Town Council. Next and last of the three items that I wanted to discuss with the Town Council, snow loads, definitely very applicable to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And so there is a significant change in ASCE 722 that stands for American Society of Civil Engineers, which is basically the state code for structural design. And in Chapter 7, they address snow loads.
2:10:55 A change in this new standard that becomes effective on January 1, that's known as the hazard tool. And this is basically a program that determines ground snow loads for the entire U.S. essentially. The bottom line here, among other things, is that it yields snow loads that are much higher than what we have here at the town, also what we have in the county, and also locations in Tahoe and Donner and Truckee and whatnot. Just as a brief example,
2:11:23 When we run the numbers in the hazard tool, elevations that are at or below 8,500 feet, if the hazard tool were used, they'd result in snow loads that are anywhere from 139% to 178% of an increase from what we have now. Elevations over 8,500 feet would be more like a 201% increase on average from what we have now. So the snow loads are much higher with the hazard tool. The hazard tool, as we discovered,
2:11:52 has a lot of flaws with it. It has, it's underdeveloped and has things known as elevation smoothing issues, unrealistic recurrence intervals that don't correlate with historic snowpack data, but the hazard tool also doesn't incorporate local things that are specific to the town, such as condos that were built many years ago with insufficient snow load criteria, construction defects that just went undetected for whatever reason, and an unpermitted construction, which happened as well.
2:12:22 The hazard tool does not account for any of that, and we consider it to be flawed in that regard. Myself, I caught wind of this probably a good two years ago, a year and a half ago, and I knew this was pretty significant, and so I started reaching out to other building officials, engineers, other stakeholders, and I teamed up with some of those people as well as a few lawyers, and we started discussing what we could do about this as an alternative to the hazard tool.
2:12:49 And so long, very long story made short is through our efforts of attending code hearings and that kind of stuff earlier in the year, we were finally able to get the formal written support of the California Building Officials Association or CalBO to formally support the position of allowing building officials to use our existing snow load data based on case studies as an acceptable alternative. And the building code allows for that. They have for a long time.
2:13:17 Given the building officially authority to approve alternate methods of construction, so long as that they're the equivalent of what's codified. And we strongly believe that given the hazard or the problems of the hazard tool and the accuracy of our local case studies that were conducted previously, we believe that this is an acceptable alternative to the hazard tool. And as such, as you'll see in the packet with the proposed modifications in our local code,
2:13:43 We're still sticking with our current snow loads. We're not going to change those. They do not go up. And we're going to use that alternative method to keep our existing snow loads in place. That's what's proposed at this current time. Just to add one little, I'd say kudos to Tom and team on the snow loads. This was a pretty significant threat. And it not only was, you know, worrisome at the building official level, but
2:14:13 From the development side too, you know, I think it's rare when you have developers wanting to work with building officials and other attorneys to then go lobby the state as a unified team to get this change implemented. But, you know, what we're hearing from engineers and others is that it would have essentially with a lot of construction in town eliminated wood frame construction entirely and required then pure steel and concrete.
2:14:42 Which would add significant cost to projects and which when you add significant cost usually the outcome is they just don't build it. So it would have definitely a huge significance here locally if they had not got the kind of ability to keep the case studies in that code. So kudos to Tom and team for sure for working on this and really digging in and lobbying at that Calvo level to get it included.
2:15:12 I'd add to you that I know for a fact that Town of Truckee is taking this exact same approach, and it's likely that other jurisdictions in that area are going to follow suit as well. So this seems to be something that other building officials are going to do as well moving forward to the next code cycle. And we hope that there will be a legislative fix at some point. It would be nice. This is not done. I mean, this is real right now. Not yet. We're hoping there will be. Yep. Yep. So.
2:15:39 So with that, that concludes my presentation for tonight, and I'd like to turn it back over to Town Council for any questions or comments that you may have on this. Thank you for the presentation. Do we have any questions? No? No questions. Thank you. Do we have any public comment? No one online? Okay. Anything else? Well, just, you know, echoing Nolan's thanks to...
2:16:06 Tom Perry for doing that work. That's the kind of voice that we need to hear from local communities to make sure the state just doesn't run us over every chance they get. But thank you very much. Yeah, thank you. My pleasure. So do I read this recommendation or do we need a motion? Well, a motion could follow sort of the form of the recommendation. And as Tom said earlier, procedurally this is a little bit weird because what you're doing is having the first reading and then setting a hearing that will happen at the next meeting.
2:16:39 It's not how it usually works, but for this specific thing, that is how it works. Is that because of the January 1st date? It's because you're adopting model codes. So there's just a quirk in the government codes that says if you're adopting model codes, this is how you do it. Okay. Thanks. So we still need to make a motion? Yes. Okay. Yes.
2:16:59 I would make a motion to waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance amending title 15 of the Municipal Code to reflect adoption of the 2025 edition of the California Building Standards Code with certain local amendments, additions, and deletions and set a public hearing for December 17, 2025 to consider the second reading and adoption of the ordinance. I'll second. That's a tie. You can have it. That's a dead tie. Mr. Wentworth can have it. Mayor.
2:17:28 What are you, the former mayor now? I don't know. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. Thank you very much for the presentation. Mayor Rice? Thank you. Mayor Rice, if I may, and I promise I'm not trying to give you a curveball on day one, but I'm going to.
2:17:52 I would like to request that we reopen Item 9.3, which is the Town Council appointments to commissions, committees, and boards to make two suggested edits that Council can consider and vote on. I kind of missed some staff suggestions that I think are very helpful with regard to two of the particular bodies that we want to talk about. Would you...
2:18:21 Allow for that to be? Yeah, absolutely. Okay, thank you. Okay, so we're on 9.3 Town Council appointments to commissions, committees, and boards. Do we need to make a motion as a council to approve that, or is it? Because we've already voted on it, we have to vote to reopen, and I think that needs a majority vote of the council. I'm not sure that it requires a formal majority vote, but you're certainly welcome to take one. I'm good either way, I just want to make sure we're good with the process. Okay.
2:18:47 Under land use, there's the Mono County Collaborative Planning Team. Senior Planner Kim Cook, I think, was appointed to that role when we had our previous Community and Economic Development Director step down and take another job outside of the town. And so I think it was more appropriately assigned to the Community and Economic Development Director, which would be Nolan Bobroff, so I'd make the recommendation that Senior Planner Kim Cook be exchanged.
2:19:16 With Community and Economic Development Director, Nolan Bobroff. Okay, that sounds like a... I would make that a motion. We're going to do two if we could. Well, now you've over-emotioned me. Good. Very emotional. That's my goal. The second one is the LTC. We talked about that, and I think we came to the conclusion. We have no alternate for that board.
2:19:42 As Bill astutely noted, you know, sometimes we do need three votes on that, and sometimes if we do have a gap, that could be challenging. So sort of recommending that the alternate be Nolan Bobroff, again, Community Economic Development Director, so staff alternate to the three that are currently assigned. Is everyone okay with those recommendations? Just a quick question on that one. No, I think it's a great choice.
2:20:11 There's probably conflict to have Hayes as a person, so. Yeah, Hayes is a part of, he's a co-chair of that committee. Then I would entertain a motion. I'll move to approve the two boards and commissions recommendations as suggested. I'll second. Jamie, roll call please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes.
2:20:43 Mayor Rice. Yes. Okay. And now we're on to item 12, council member reports. Who would like to go first? I'd love to go first. Okay. Just a couple different things. I attended this week of the chamber power lunch. If anyone didn't get a chance to be part of the trainings, but the chamber did an excellent job bringing in a facilitator and trainer, talking to managers and staff about particularly customer service and a lot of the aspects of how they handle it.
2:21:15 I went to the Limelight Ribbon Cutting. It's a great facility. See how it goes. It's nice to see it open and function for this Christmas season.
2:21:40 And I attended the community skate night last night and did some laps around the ice rink. And I saw, I had reservations about the curling onto the side. It works very well over there. It's separated. People aren't trying to run over each other. And it's set up all the time. And it's fun to see people that are trying to throw stones that weigh, I don't know, 30 pounds or whatever. It's a lot to move those. That's all I have. Thank you. Who would like to go next? I'll go next. Nothing to report. Thank you.
2:22:10 Looking at my calendar, I have nothing passed, but I will note that tomorrow is bingo and sweet Z. I was able to make it to the end of the limelight ribbon cutting, and I wish them all the luck in the world, and a very impressive facility, and let's see what happens. All right. And I also, is that all for you, Councilmember Warmore? That's all for me. Okay. I also attended the limelight opening on Monday.
2:22:40 And my kids loved the children's area with the video games. So a good time was had by all. Okay, so we are going to move into closed session. So our closed session item is Conference with Legal Counsel, Anticipated Litigation, Significant Exposure to Litigation Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9, One Case. Do I need to read anything else, Andy?
2:23:12 It's actually paragraph two. Sorry, there's a typo there. Oh, paragraph two of subdivision D of section 54956.9. One case. Okay. Do I just thank you all for coming. We'll see you next time. Bang your gavel. Bang your gavel. There we go. Mr. Attorney, if this is what I think it's on, do I have to recuse? Yes, you do. We'll see you next time, Bill.