TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2025

Town Council

at 16:00 · recording 5 hr 44 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

7 findings

Transcript

697 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:03 Brent, Brent, you were in the tall grass. Look at him. Tall grass. Did you catch a moose? Oh, sorry, I mean an elk? No, I did not. Didn't catch anything. If you catch an elk, I'm going to have some of the elk medallions, my first meet in three years, if you catch one. All right, here we go. I like saying catch. That's what I say to my family. My family are deer hunters, and I'm like, did you catch one?

0:41 I happen to have my driver's license. What fortune? I usually don't have it. What do you need? Oh, you don't have it memorized? Not the expiration date. Oh, it's your birthday five years from when you got the last one. No, I don't remember when I got it. You make it up. Okay, where's my papers? Okay, Jeannie. All right, Bill. Brent's in the tall grass. Let's go. Betsy!

1:22 No, I'm just laughing because look at Brent. He looks like he's in Honey, I Shrunk the Kids. Yeah. Okay, great. Great. Welcome everyone to this regular meeting of Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, November 19th at four something, four o'clock. So, Jamie, can you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Here.

2:14 Councilmember Whiteworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Here. Mayor Bubzer? Here. And I have asked Pat Foster to please lead us in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. We have quite a crowd today.

2:51 We would like to start with public comments for anything not already on the agenda. Good afternoon, Council. I'm Brianna Gueiko, President and CEO of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and the Executive Director of the Mammoth Community Foundation. I just wanted to highlight a couple things going on in the business community. We have a very...

3:13 Active December coming up. As many know, Limelight is opening on Monday, December 1st, and we will be celebrating with them by doing a ribbon cutting three to five. The event will be three to five p.m. with the ribbon cutting at four. So I know I reached out to many of you as well as the Board of Supervisors and some of the leadership in our community today to formally invite you. So hope some of you can make it there.

3:37 We also have a ribbon cutting later that week for Eastern Sierra Mountain Club, which recently, within the last year or so, relocated from the Village to the Main Street Promenade. So that'll be on Thursday, December 4th from 4 to 5. Looking at some of our work with our businesses on customer service, we have our customer service workshops coming up also the first week of December, December 2nd and 3rd. So excited to offer that to the business community.

4:05 And then we are currently recruiting speakers for our Career Expo Day that we do at the high school, which this year will be on Wednesday, January 14th. So we'll be bringing in about 60 speakers from the community to talk to the youth about different career paths and opportunities available for them as they move on from high school. So looking forward to that. Last thing, as many know, we activated our

4:32 Community Foundation, which is the Mammoth Community Foundation, not to be confused with Mammoth Mountains Community Foundation and Mammoth Lakes Foundation, to collect donations for the PAC fire relief efforts. So we started

4:49 Collecting donations Friday morning, the day after the fire. At this point, we have almost 100,000 raised, so huge thank you to anyone in the community who has contributed to that. So we'll be working with our NCF board and a committee to determine how those funds will be dispersed. We are hoping to get those out before Christmas, so second or third week of December.

5:13 So we'll be working on that. In addition, we have used our website kind of as the one-stop shop for anybody that's either that was impacted looking for resources or for those looking to donate goods, gift cards, financial contributions. So we're really happy that we're able to serve in this role for the community just because there were a lot of different organizations doing a lot of great work.

5:38 We will continue operating that site until hopefully it's not needed sometime soon. But yeah, just wanted to update you all on that. Thank you so much. Thank you very much. And Brianna, I just want to thank you and your whole team for really rising to the occasion very quickly. I know the entire community did. Our first responders did an extraordinary job. Our staff just

6:04 Everybody came together in a way that was so beautiful to see and we're incredibly grateful. I see Supervisor Salcido as well. The county did incredible work and we just really want to recognize that how I was amazed at how quickly your emails were going out. So thank you.

6:18 And I should also thank the nonprofit coalition that we run through the chamber. Actually, we all connected very quickly and, you know, really grateful to the MMCF executive director for, you know, just really we wanted to streamline and have all donations going to one place and be coordinated in our efforts. So thank you to all the other nonprofits, too, for their work. Absolutely. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Billy Stade, homeowner, resident, part-time, full-time since 07, former...

6:51 I'm an events coordinator with Mammoth, producing New Year's Eve events, working with Rusty and Mark Lawson back in the day. I've introduced a concept and emailed the tourism board and the council regarding the potential of activating the never before utilized space in the peninsula. So that is a 3,600 square foot spot where we'd like to create a town center, a winter town.

7:21 Square, where the community can participate in a flexible event space. So I brought the landlord with me today. We did address the board earlier, and we'd like to begin requesting a formal request for a conditional use permit and exploring the opportunity how we can activate the entire town to bring renewed energy to the village and bringing everybody back together. Thanks so much.

7:50 Thank you. Next. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Linda Salcido. I'm a member of the Pomona County Board of Supervisors and former also Mammoth Lakes Town Council member. Just wanted to come today and talk a little bit about the PAC fire and express my appreciation for all the actions of the Town of Mammoth Lakes and every associated agency that responded.

8:22 By the time I became aware and was close enough to know what was going on, let's say, the evacuations had already been almost completed with so much help from the fire districts, but also because they were busy fighting fires, from the town of Mammoth Lakes, you know, police department, pounding on doors, going, you know, and getting everybody that could be the notification system was not perfect.

8:51 So not everyone was notified as we had hoped they would be. And it was not only the Mammoth Lakes PD, it was Sheriff's Department, it was the Town of Bishop, it was CHP, it was every, I like to say everybody in a uniform was out there pounding on doors making sure people were out. And it didn't stop there. Every fire district in county, as well as huge response from Mammoth Fire Protection District.

9:19 We're on scene majorly fighting this fire, and as you know how the winds are in our region, Crowley notwithstanding, was unbelievable. I couldn't stand up in the wind. There were people where I was gathered watching the fire come over the ridge, and the speed at which that fire was spreading.

9:42 was, as a firefighter said, really hard to even make any impact. At that point, it was saving lives, making sure people were out, making sure property was protected as best, but always with life as priority. But the larger issue, I think, is the fact that in an emergency, our region, and particularly the town of Mammoth Lakes and the county of Mono, respond really well together. You know, we've lost track of what MOUs are in place and who's supposed to go do what. It's just that response. Those are our people.

10:12 We have people, all of us, that live in Crowley, that come up here and work, that we know, some of us used to live, I mean, it is so entwined. So I would just, you know, with appreciation note that in spite of sometimes our government agencies and in spite of our, you know, attempts to coordinate and make everything, you know, all fancy and sign on the dotted line, people just show up. People show up and do the right thing. No lives were lost.

10:41 Thank you. Thank you.

11:06 Then with that, we will move into Town Council presentations. So Rob, I believe this is you. Yes, there will be a couple of recognition awards tonight, and I believe we've got some folks coming up to present those. First will be Chief Casabian for Crystal Stewart's 10-year service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Good evening, Council Dan Casabian, Chief of Police. But before I get into this, Linda, thank you. I don't know where you're at. Thank you so much for that.

11:41 When incidents like that happen, there are no jurisdictions. So if it happened here, there's no doubt Mono County would be here regardless of what entity. So we are always there for Mono County as I know Mono County is for us. Let me get into this real quick. So we're here to celebrate Crystal's 10-year anniversary.

12:00 Crystal is the hub of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. So she sits right in the front. She takes everything that comes at her. Some of the things that she does, I'm going to read these. She works the front counter, which are people that come in and out quite a bit throughout the day, all day. Live scan, fingerprinting, criminal and civil reporting, case filing with the district attorney.

12:21 Concealed carry weapons for our retirees, animal licensing, federal reporting, state audits, public records requests, lost and found property. But I would say the thing that I appreciate the most out of Crystal is when I get there in the morning on snow days, she is the first person out there shoveling.

12:40 She got her hat on, she's out there shoveling, and she's just making sure we're open to the public and it's safe for the public to come in. So with that, thank you for your service to the town. Thank you for your service to the PD. We love you. Thank you so much. Thanks everybody for being here and the support. What could be said about 10 years with the, as my friends sometimes say, the front seat to the greatest show in Mammoth.

13:17 There's an understanding that if you work in California law enforcement, you can work anywhere. I consider Mammoth to be the equivalent of that to the Eastern Sierra. It's just a gold standard agency. I've become a liaison of sorts. It's an honor to be able to help people with the small stuff and help them with their worst days. I said hello and goodbye to a lot of good people, admin and counsel.

13:43 And I'll be here as this department continues to grow and for the future of Mammoth. Thank you so much. Thank you.

14:42 Thank you. Yes, thank you. Thank you. All right. And next, Rob, who will be doing the next presentation? Hayes. Looks like Hayes. Good evening. We're here to celebrate the 25-year career and retirement.

15:22 of Lon Adams, and bear with me, this is going to be tough, it's hard to say goodbye. Lon asked me to keep it short, and I'm going to do my best, and I'm not going to pontificate, and I'm not going to tell embarrassing stories, but I did ask Lon when we started this to tell me in his words what his career was like at the town of Mammoth Lakes, and he sent me a text message.

15:47 And he said, I started as an intern at Mr. K's in 1985. I became a mechanic at the town in 2000, a supervisor in 2005, and then superintendent in 2007. And I thought to myself, you know, Lon, I appreciate the brevity and your ability to consolidate 9,125 days into four bullet points.

16:15 While that's the kind of efficiency I've come to expect from you, I think we can expand ever so slightly on your career here. And I'm going to consolidate into my bullet points, and I know there's a few others that like to speak. But it's impossible to quantify your impact to this community. And whether or not these people, they're all here for you, by the way. But everybody in this room has relied on you in some way, shape, or form, whether or not they realize it.

16:43 25 seasons, you sat in the plow truck, cindering truck, helping out this community, doing everything it takes to keep our roads clear. I have no idea how many late nights, 12-hour shifts, 7 days a week, months on end, you have spent taking care of our equipment, keeping our loaders going, our blowers going, keeping this community moving, repairing our buses, our trolleys, keeping our transit system afloat.

17:08 I don't actually think there's enough numbers to quantify how many hours you've spent on pop cars fixing them for our police department. You were responsible for all of our parts, our inventorying, ordering, taking care of everybody, everything we need, chains, straps, you name it, you took care of it for all of us. We all relied on you. You secured fuel for not just us, but for the entire community, Mono County, Transit, you know, all of our partners rely on you.

17:39 Even in those tough winters, I know what you were doing to make sure our deliveries got here so our community could be safe and we could do the hard work we needed to do. You did not-so-fun administrative tasks like CARB and licensing and DMV, all these really difficult things that are absolutely critical to our organization. And ultimately and most importantly, 25 years of leadership, mentorship.

18:07 And providing direction to the department and helping all of us out. And I know we all have a job to do in public works, but everyone relies on you to do their job. And it's absolutely critical to us. And I can't put into words how much I appreciate your contributions to the community and how much work you've put into it. And needless to say, your skills and your institutional knowledge is going to be

18:35 Greatly missed. And I'm going to miss you. And I hope you stop in and say hi and come and visit us and rub it in our faces that you're not working. But I'm going to miss you. Thank you. Guys, if you want to come up. I'm Jesse Dimas, fleet manager. I'm taking over Lon's position, but took over already. I didn't know it was so intense if I knew that list.

19:07 I wouldn't have signed up for the job. Right? But yeah, I know Lon for seven years. He mentored me. He still continues to mentoring me. I could call him. He helps me out. He helped me. We both did the fleet management program, which we did from scratch. And we also did all the inventory. And I know you guys are aware.

19:37 Everything we did with the inventory, and you guys are more than welcome to stop by the, and everybody, anybody's welcome to stop by and see the, it's all organized, and there was a lot of late nights, you know, sometimes 13, 14 hour days that we were there, and it was just me, him, and actually Sean, right? So, but he, I don't know how to even say it, but you know, all the help that he's brought to the town, and

20:07 I'm just, it's going to be hard to fill in those shoes. And once again, just thank you for allowing me to take over his position. And, you know, I still continue to learn, but it is a lot of things to do. So, once again, thank you and congratulations. How's it going, everyone? I'm Victor Garnica. I'm a mechanic down at the town yard. Seven years ago, I...

20:42 Walked in into the town yard and I'd known Lonnie prior to that briefly because a friend of mine used to work there. And I heard that you guys had like a training program so I went in there and started getting in his ear. I was like, hey, you guys need some help around here? Kind of annoying, kind of a pain, but walked in and he was like, yeah, let me see what I could do. And then he got the ball rolling on that training program for me and I was able to apply.

21:12 Yeah, so he was a big part in me starting my career as a mechanic. And it's crazy to see him now and be here at this point, giving him a farewell at the end of his career, you know? So, but I just want to thank Lonnie a lot for being so patient with me. I really appreciate that. Like, that was huge. I really do respect that and thank you.

21:38 It's not easy hiring a 21-year-old kid who just... It wasn't. I'm sure it wasn't. I'm sure sometimes I made it difficult. But all jokes decided everything. He was super patient, taught me a lot. He treated me really well there. And I hate to see you go, but...

22:01 I'm really excited for you on your next chapter in life, and it's going to be huge. I'm jealous. I got maybe like another 32 years before I could do the same, but I'm really happy for you, Lon. Thank you. You've been a hell of a boss, so thank you. Appreciate it. I'm going to keep it short. Dan Casabian, Chief of Police, again. I'll keep it short.

22:26 Lon, I met Lon back in, what, 2002, and then ended up taking over for Bob Cashbaugh. Lon actually built my first canine car when we got our first, when we got our first dog for the PD. Out of an old admin explorer. Out of an old admin explorer. Him and I, him and I sat there and talked about it quite a bit, but.

22:41 Jesse, you got some big shoes to fill. You really do. Lawn is always available. It didn't matter if he was home, if he was at work, or where he was. If we needed something at the police department, he made it happen. If we got a flat tire on the road at 1030, 11 o'clock at night, he made it happen. For that, man, thank you for the support for the police department. Thank you for the support from me. And I wish you the best in your time, my brother. Thank you.

23:10 Hi, Francisco Maldonado, Polly Works. I just want to say thank you to Lonnie. It's really easy to say 25 years, but when you work a snow shift, and it's a 12-hour snow shift, and you add up that every six months when it gets snow, it's a long time. It's a lot of times. And when I came in and started working with the town, I didn't have an idea what it was to start.

23:37 Doing snow removal and taking care of the town and so many streets, you know. And it takes a lot. And I just want to say thank you. I mean, it's just, he was out there with us every snowy day, every holiday, every Christmas. I don't know how many Christmas we spend together on the streets. New Year's. Yeah. So, you sacrifice a lot for the town. I mean, when you're working here, you committed to take care of the community. And my kids were born working here. So, you know, we missed so many.

24:08 So many Christmases and New Year's, you know, and I just listen, 25 years, and it's like, it's so simple to say, but when you out there working every day, like the last big year we had, we were two months without having a day off, and we just walk in, and we see each other, and sometimes probably bump heads a couple times, because we were stressed out, but I mean, I'm really glad for you that you made it to retirement, and thank you for everything. I mean, you kept us going every time, you know, and we got fuel, like you said, so thank you.

24:38 Thank you very much. You know, and I'm very glad for you that you made it to retirement. You deserve it. Thank you very much. Thank you. So I've got something real quick before you get up there and say something. You haven't been fretting this for about a month. I know. I wanted to give you a little bit more time to think about it. I hope you see how much love and outpouring is for you tonight. That's really a testament to...

25:12 How much you've done for not only the organization but for all the people in the room, right? You've been a mentor to all these people in bringing them up and I appreciate that, right? You're setting us up for success for the next 20 years. You've got people that have been built to take your role and to go from there. So you've done so much for us and I think that will pay dividends even on into the future. So I'm so grateful for the time that you spent with the town and the dedication that you provided. So I'm grateful for that. Thank you.

25:42 Well, I just want to say thank you to the management, past and present, councils, past and present, for letting me spend my career in such a big place.

26:51 This way? Like this? Just like that. Super nice. You know, a year in Mammoth Public Works is like a dog year, so it's 25 times 7. So thank you from the bottom of our hearts. It was a beautiful place for a career. And you enjoy every minute. Thank you. I hope you have good fun this evening. It's kind of a grandpa. Yeah.

27:28 All right. And thank you everyone who showed up for Crystal and for Lon because this is really what our community is about. It was just nice to see them being honored in a way that they truly deserve. So thank you. With that, we are going to a workshop with the Board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

28:01 To review the fiscal year 24-25 accomplishments and maybe hear a big announcement? I don't know. Take your chairs. Take our chairs. B-Y-L-C on board. Take care.

29:06 Shall we begin? All right, everyone, welcome. And I would like to turn the floor over to Mr. Urdie, who would like to kick us off. Well, I appreciate this. I appreciate the time getting the workshops together here. Obviously, my board, my staff, and the town council know, but I will be leaving Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

29:41 After 15 and a half years, it's been a wonderful run. I have an opportunity to be the new president and CEO of Visit Huntington Beach. So after 55 years of living in snow, I will be moving to the beach. So it's a great opportunity, but this town has afforded a great opportunity here to grow our visitation, our stewardship.

30:02 And to help raise the funds that make things like the parcel possible. So I appreciate everyone's support. I appreciate obviously my board, the town council, town staff, and my staff. Really thank you for that. So right now our board and our staff are probably the best we've ever had. And so I really feel good about leaving the team to do great things moving forward. So thank you for that. I will be on staff until the 19th of December. And then I'll start down there January 5th.

30:32 Exciting times. Thank you. Thanks for all of your service. I think we'll have plenty of time in the future to toast and roast you for all of your contributions, but, you know, I do think that the staff and the Board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism is really firing on all cylinders, and so that is a credit to you. Thank you. And I will turn it over to Rob Patterson for the item.

30:58 Thank you, Mayor Bubser. So as you know, we get together on occasion. This particular one is to talk a little bit about the accomplishments of 24-25. And so we have a report I think you'd like to run through, John. Yeah. Let you take the lead on that. And then we'll have opportunity for just general dialogue afterwards and talking about stuff. So you did mention the possibility of recognition for John. We're going to do something probably on.

31:27 Second meeting of December. I think that would be December 17th. Is that right after he's gone? No, that would be right before he leaves. We would have done it on the 3rd of December, but he's not in town at that time. But it's going to be a little bit different in addition to recognizing John's accomplishments, just all the things that were accomplished in that space during his 15 years here. So it'll be another good, well-deserved recognition event.

31:55 John, go ahead. Thank you, Rob. So what we're going to do here is our annual report. This is basically covering fiscal year 2024-25 that ended in June. And so we'll walk through this. Each member of the team will discuss their portions that they are responsible for. And then we'll do a TBIG report at the end of it as well. Please feel free to ask questions as we go through. And our board is here to help answer questions as well. I guess we're dancing.

32:26 Councilmember, your bag is about to explode. The only other thing I'll mention, too, is that in your packet, there are the recap of our deliverables. So you'll remember when we do our budget and planning, we put together specific deliverables for the town, and at the end of the year, we recap hit, missed, reasons why, etc. So we aren't going to go...

32:48 Thank you, John. Good evening, Council, everyone.

33:20 Boy, some tough acts to follow. I mean, Crystal or Lon alone would have been hard enough and now John. So great to see you all. Community engagement. So this is very exciting for me as fiscal year 24-25 was also my first year in my role at MLT. I started on July 1st, 2024. So it's a little bit of flying the plane as I was building it.

33:45 To recap on community engagement this afternoon, I presented to our board my community engagement plan. It's complete, although it's a living document, so subject to plenty of change. Already implemented many aspects of that, but please check that out. It is in today's MLT board packet, and happy to answer any questions or receive feedback on that.

34:09 Big focus, obviously, in my position is just an increased focus on community outreach and particularly resident quality of life. So a couple of the things that we executed, we have the destination stewardship plan is underway. Hunden Partners is our consultant on that. Really appreciate the partnership with the town and the community. And Hunden Partners has made two of their three visits to the community. They did some great outreach when they were here last. They'll make one more visit and then...

34:38 Their plan will be complete and we'll start hopefully adopting that and implementing at the end of the current fiscal year. And then another responsibility of mine is really just trying to connect those dots between visitation dollars and community benefit. As John mentioned, things like our Housing Now program. So many of the things that our community really critical needs, things we really value. It's just a pleasure to see those funds taken by the town and all that implementation.

35:07 Love that partnership. We have an annual report in addition to this one. It's a printed piece. It's actually going to print right now. So I'm very excited to get that out to the community. I'm also working on a community engagement marketing. We have an agency for that. We'll be super excited to share the tagline and creative with you all very soon.

35:29 And the objective behind that is if you've been in other communities like Tahoe and seen things like Powered by TOT and TBID out and about in those communities, this will be very similar to that, but we think even better. We do an annual resident sentiment survey. We conducted our second one last year.

35:48 And our third one will actually be coming out very shortly. We've just finalized that with that agency. And then finally, I've been pleased to consider or pleased to continue events like our monthly community coffee. Reminder, tomorrow morning, 830, we'll actually have National Weather Service on with a winter outlook. So excited for that. Love our partnership with the town to offer community skate nights to our community and, of course, some other outreach events as well. In terms of local partnerships, this is...

36:18 Pretty self-explanatory, but one of the things that we're really doing, I love being able to work with Hayes and other department heads at the town on, it's kind of, we work to help identify those infrastructure and quality of life needs, and then the town can take what we learn and start implementing those. So projects for those.

36:41 We'll identify in a partner survey as well as the destination stewardship plan, the initial outreach, and that will be a continuing effort. Again, just really appreciate that partnership with the town. A couple of things that we have in progress for this winter based on that are some real-time transit information scheduled for deployment. I understand the testing is going pretty well. Also looking at some kiosks as well as we actually have bike racks.

37:09 On order too. So we'll be excited to roll that program out next summer. Then also really just some great stewardship initiatives. One of our charges in our contract with the town is that both visitor and education awareness, education, the work around stewardship, which we're really excited and proud of. So this is just a quick recap. Some of these kind of cross fiscal years, but I wanted to share them anyway. Trashy Thursday, we had over 14 events.

37:41 This spring and summer with over 1,200 pounds of trash collected. Love being able to sponsor that, working with the town and other partners like MLR. Clean Up the Lake is a major initiative for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We're really proud to partner with that nonprofit organization that comes and has volunteer divers cleaning up our lakes. MLT matches up to $100,000 of funding for that organization, and I think that we'll probably continue that after 2026.

38:10 They cleaned up Lake George in 23, Lake Mary in 24, and then McLeod Lake this fall they did in September. We weren't sure how much they would find in McLeod Lake, given that it's not quite as accessible as our other front country lakes, but over 230 pounds of trash they actually pulled out of McLeod. In addition to that work, they also

38:32 Did some HAB and invasive species studies in Twin Lakes, which led to them confirming an aquatic invasive species, Eurasian milfoil, in Twin Lakes in the Lakes Basin. So clean, drain, and dry. We'll continue to push out that stewardship messaging. Then just a couple other things, Adopt-a-Trail and Tangle-Free Water sponsorships that we do with MLR, which are great programs.

38:54 And then finally, our team has created some great webpages on the visitmammoth.com website, like pre-arrival guides to educate visitors before they arrive in town. Those are webpages that can be shared out by lodging properties and others. And then also we have some great resources about wildfire prevention and education, which are also beneficial to residents as well as visitors.

39:17 Okay, shifting gears just a little bit. Part of my role, I also administer MLT's special events funding program. Really appreciate our committee that works with us on that of Stu Brown, Mary Beth Erickson, John Morris and Deb Radcliffe. They make the hard decisions with the help of the framework that we implemented for this year's events. So for our 2025 funding,

39:45 All of that happens in the fiscal year ahead, so 24-25. For 2025, we funded 26 events. We had three new events and also three first-time funding recipients, so existing events that received funding from us for the first time. We distributed $350,000, which was a 17% increase over 2024's events.

40:09 We implemented the new guiding document and a scorecard, which was very helpful to the committee. That included a green events checklist, some incentives like driving increased visitation to need periods, and also a bonus for events that marketed more than 100 miles out of town.

40:25 Also, the single-use plastic water bottle ban that will go into effect for everyone on January 1st actually went into effect for special events this year, this summer, so that worked out quite well. They were able to figure that out. We'll work with them moving forward, too, in conjunction with the town.

40:42 And then finally, we also had a new event ambassador program. We actually reached out and solicited applications from folks to come and take photos and do social posts to partner with us. We ended up with four different people who provided coverage on those key events where we needed content, and it was a very successful program. So happy to answer any questions before I turn it over to Allie. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Public relations.

41:15 Hello, everyone. I'm going to be giving a recap from the fiscal year public relations efforts. So just to get started, you can see this chart, the darker toned blue is our last fiscal year, 24-25, in comparison with 23-24. You'll see some seasonal spikes there that we can all relate to weather or different seasonal visitation needs. But 24-25 was a milestone year for public relations efforts. We achieved...

41:43 1,511 total earned media placements. And our earned media placements are those that are third party unpaid media. So what you'll see in broadcast clips, publications, digital sites. And we work with a lot of really high value journalists to get those placed and share our messaging. So the growth was driven by proactive pitching with our

42:10 Domestic Public Relations Agency. And also strategic journalist hosting. So we'll bring our journalists here and make sure that they have everything they need to tell their story. And investment in high quality owned assets. So that goes out to our content team who produce incredible photo and video. And a lot of times that's what captures the audience to pick up the story and place it.

42:33 We hosted 12 media visits last year representing top tier national outlets including US News and World Report, CNN, Travel and Leisure, Parents Magazine, Afar, Westways, Eater, Boston Globe, Thrillist, SFGate. We also updated some travel guides in Fodor's and Lonely Planet so those were really helpful for our restaurant community and they also resulted in a broad range of coverage that

43:01 Continues to elevate Mammoth Lakes as a four-season destination and also a leader in sustainable tourism. So you can see in the graph here in the blue that shows a big spike in our fall colors program which we're really proud of and last year that made up 30% of our coverage in those key fall months so all the work that our team has done to promote that need period visitation in the fall.

43:26 has really done well. Between September and October 2024, we secured 102 placements with 90% increase from the previous year, and that reached 395 million readers and viewers. So that'll be a lot through website syndication and digital sharing.

43:46 This year, continuing on that success, we saw 186 placements, which was another 82% increase. So we're building on that momentum and keeping that fall colors program going. And also we've partnered with Mono County Tourism, California fall colors and created that unified story and we saw a lot of broadcast pick up. So in this chart here, the first one, you'll see those fall colors peak months rising and then

44:16 This fiscal year that I'm not reporting on, we saw even more growth there. And then overall our impact, we have worked with a lot of journalists. We also keep in touch with them.

44:28 Head to visit California, sanctioned events, to meet with journalists one-on-one, maintain those relationships and share those stories, and that's where our agency comes into play by helping us keep momentum there. We also worked with creators on in-person hosting and storytelling, so we hosted five influencer visits last year that helped diversify our reach as well as our voice and storytelling.

44:55 And we also continued the Crib Program hosting athletes to really develop our altitude training destination story and our sponsorship with the Mammoth Track Club, which has been really successful hosting runners that train there with Coach Andrew Castor. And that's all alongside our special event funding promoting endurance season as well.

45:17 Looking ahead, we are continuing to maintain these relationships and extend our reach and aligning our stories with stewardship and community impact, which Betsy went over. Now we'll pass it on to our own marketing. Quick question? Yeah. I was just curious. So is this all media placements that mention Town of Mammoth Lakes or are you counting only specifically tourism-related stories? These all are Mammoth-specific.

45:45 So we keep it within the town and our Mammoth Lakes tourism kind of jurisdiction. A lot of things come from sort of third-party knowledge, you know, especially if there's a big storm, it's going to get picked up a lot. So it's not necessarily entirely from our direct communication, but a lot of it is syndicated through our storytelling and building on the reputation that we have. Thanks.

46:16 Thank you. And now we're going to take over OWN Media with Laura Waddles joining virtually to give this presentation. Hi, all. Thanks, Sam. Take it away, Laura. Local marketing recap. So local marketing projects, we had local advertising in the sheet. We had radio advertising. As usual, we had the Fishmas.

46:57 Banners, window claims, postcards, special event posters, and July 4th stickers, town pad maps, camp like a pro collateral. Next slide. Jumping into content programs. It's a Mammoth Thing. This past fiscal year, we produced nine stewardship-focused videos for the It's a Mammoth Thing campaign that rolled out through our social media platforms and paired with a visit mammoth.com landing page.

47:26 Where the collection of videos live and showcase additional related blog content. This was a very locally collaborative campaign that brought together many community partners and local talent both on and off screen. So thanks to everyone who participated in this and contributed. The project resulted in over 240,000 views and 650 hours of watch time. Sam, next slide, please.

47:58 Seasonal Ready Guides. We created three new resource pages that live on visitmammoth.com this year. These new content pieces serve as a toolkit for visitors and easy shareable landing pages that local community can use to inform travelers quickly, pointing to collections of the right resources and information for things like safe winter travel, wildfire prevention, stewardship tips, and more.

48:26 In-house design. We grew our in-house design this year to lower costs, increased responsiveness and capability. This covered a portion of work that we had previously used outside contractors for, in addition to new internal projects and some collaborative projects with the community, like supportive graphics for the LA community after the Palisades Fire, a logo for host towns, and graphics for the LA Kings Road Trip.

48:57 Awesome. Thank you, Laura. At this point, I'm going to take it away with our Fall Colors Program. So as you've heard throughout the night, this is a program that just continues to grow. We basically start sharing content as soon as we start to see the first leaves change to the very last one. And this is a partnership that we work very closely with Mona County with to make sure that we're covering the whole entire region.

49:22 This past fiscal year, our social media rates jumped 122%, hitting up 1.2 million users, and our Where to Find Fall Colors blog was up 10%, which it already sees a lot of traffic. So to see that jump is really impressive.

49:38 And through our Fall Colors messaging, we continue to push strong stewardship messaging throughout the season, reminding visitors the importance of enjoying Fall Colors responsibly. And this is shared all across our social channels, website, and newsletters. On the note of newsletters, our newsletters also help promote sustainability, our local businesses, our local events, and provide local insights.

50:06 Our database grew almost 5% year-over-year this past fiscal year, and our open rates remained really high. For our visitor-facing newsletters, we've had a 45% open rate, and for our local-facing, 66%, which is really impressive. We also provided info to local businesses more than 50 times information about our business acronym.

50:31 ExtraNet Portal on visitmamoth.com, which is where businesses can go ahead and update their hours, their listing information, add their own photos, submit events, etc. Going into our website, so for our website, we had 1.5 million sessions this last fiscal year with an average engagement time of time of 41 seconds. With AI increasing over the years,

51:00 With AI specifically increasing within like the past few months and within the past year, we've seen some hits to our website. However, we're taking this as a learning experience to essentially modify our strategy as we go into next fiscal year to adapt and better serve AI tools. And then on the local impact side, our referrals to local businesses increased 42% year over year.

51:31 And our event referrals totaled 14,000, which is showing a really strong growth in connecting our visitors with our local business community. And then on the side of social media, last year we had 223,000 engagements with the reach of over 10 million people. And mentioned earlier within this report were some other initiatives that we also support through social media. But separate and aside from those, we also worked with

52:02 Whitebark Institute, Camp Like a Pro in Mono County to produce a campfire safety video, which shared information on key campfire tips during fire season. We also had a total of 12 posts for Clean Up the Lake, totaling over 60,000 views with 1,600 interactions, and we also continue to support

52:24 Trashy Thursdays on our social media with a total of nine posts during the season that that program runs with the total views of 58,000 and our interactions at 1,200. At this point, I'm going to hand it over to Sarah Winters for a paid marketing recap. Hi, everyone. Apologies for how I sound. I'm more excited than how I sound, so. First of all, I hope you see the thread throughout the entire presentation of how much each.

52:56 Member of the team is working together through the paid earned and owned. So I'm going to take us through the paid and hopefully you can hear and understand what I'm saying. So in the fiscal year 24-25 our paid program delivered over 171 million impressions. We had 1.81 million in media spend so a little bit down but still very high and we saw over 26 million.

53:21 Video views of our Real and Real campaign, landing with over 500, 1,000 sessions to our website. It take us through the seasons, starting with fall. So this is one of our smaller spends with the most bang for our buck. We spend about $250,000, and you can see that we achieve most of our goals, if not went over our goals. So running mid-August through October, limited partners. We used YouTube, Ad Theory, Facebook, and the trade desk. So mostly...

53:51 In the intent layer versus the brand awareness layer. This is just our California and Nevada markets or near markets. And so you can see that the campaign, we adjusted slightly earlier, thanks to our board kind of analyzing some of the things that we bring to them. We all agreed that it was important to bump that up a little and start in August. And you can see that some of the implementation for the traffic driving improved by over 21%.

54:19 Looking at that meta goal, reaching over 21% to our on-site engagement. In winter is where we spend a higher dollar amount, $1.1 million in spend last year, and you can see the different partners at the bottom of the page. That's increased. One thing I want to note is this is really where we do some custom content buys, so whether that is with...

54:43 All gear on the snow, Travel Zoo, Expedia, that expands not only the marketing but the direct sales funnel so when we're seeing some dips in sales or lack of snow or whatever we can kind of mobilize those dollars to make immediate changes for that direct booking. We go out to...

55:01 California, Nevada, and our farm markets of Denver in the Northeast. So we are continuing to build on that snow-specific content. That did really well for us in previous years, specifically with on the snow. So we're enhancing that moving forward with an actual snow tracker. So our media will actually be updating as snow falls here. People are going to get served updated feed that are hitting the area. So I think that's going to be very beneficial. And you're also going to see that there are some different intent layers here.

55:30 We'll be launching our new Paddle Without a Trace for the winter for the first time, and so we use kind of rich media units, interactive units, to increase that engagement. Spring and summer, we spent about $420,000. We saw over 36, we saw over almost 36 million impressions, and we saw a really large increase in our video views. This is where we go back to our immediate.

55:56 Drive Markets, our California and Nevada base. We run this mid-April to August, dependent on the type of season that we're having from a weather perspective. But you can see that the challenges and the opportunities here are to really maximize video reach.

56:11 We have a larger budget this year to replace our Real and Real videos, which are some of the content is expiring, and we launched that in the fall of 2022, so it's time to kind of refresh some of the video. But we're still receiving quite a large percentage of completion rates on video, the highest being our 30-second spot, which is kind of rare because usually video consumption does better in the smaller 15-second spots.

56:38 I wanted to provide some creative examples across the seasons, mostly digital, but you'll see Take a Hike there. That was in the Business Traveler of United. We have a really strong partnership with Inc. and United, and that's going to expand into this year as well. And then we have different, we tailor our ads for air service, winter, Northeast Market specifically for winter, and the other seasons. We do have research partners. So for 24, 25, Samari Insights, we actually gave that presentation today that shows how our ads are creative.

57:09 How people are responding to that, what they're looking for, what they're targeting. One of the key findings from last winter was actually that people really want to come here to reduce stress that hadn't showed up in a few years. It was always nature skiing, snowboarding, but I think it's really interesting that that popped up and we can see what we can do from a creative perspective there. Future partners, we did our resident sentiment study, our visitor profile economic impact study.

57:33 Shipyard, our agency manages our seasonal air service studies, so we will be presenting our summer air service analysis soon, and we are all set and ready to go for winter air service. And then we have tourism economics, which provides us our monthly symphony dashboards, which basically pulls in our...

57:52 Occupancy, our TOT, our TBID, primary markets, average nights, and we're launching with a new data partner in 25-26, so I'll make sure to share some of that moving forward. I'm going to toss it to John, but before I do, I do want to thank John for 15 years. He's been an incredible boss. I feel super grateful, but more than that, I feel like he's really been an incredible person to lead this organization and an incredible person for our community, so I'm going to let him.

58:20 Bore you with the next slides, but before I do, I don't want to take it at all. Thank you. Didn't know we were roasting me tonight, but okay. Michael Vanderhurst is on a sales mission with Visit California right now, so I'm going to run through his slide here. And basically, we've gone back and renewed all of our relationships with our seven international agencies that represent us in a total of 18 countries and markets worldwide.

58:48 We really want to make sure that just like with COVID that once we get past some of the challenges with inbound travel that we are still top of mind. And so we will be looking at projects in China, Mexico and Canada as things start to rebound here. But right now our main agencies are in those seven countries or seven agencies. Michael does quite a bit on the road with B2B meetings. So basically speed dating. So he'll go to events where he will have

59:18 He wrote here, he's had 515 meetings in the last year. And so basically like places like IPW, which is one of the largest trade shows in the world, he will sit down with likely 60 people a day and talk about why they should come to Mammoth Lakes, why they should send all of their, these are tour operators, traffic agents, why they should send their people here and why they should spend more than one night.

59:40 I think when we started the organization in 2010, we saw people coming from Yosemite that stay a night here because they saw a bed, but they didn't see the value as to why they should stay. And so with these agencies, we really push the fact that we want to get people to stay here more than one night because there is activity here they need to take advantage of versus coming from Yosemite, staying here and going off to Los Angeles or Las Vegas or wherever. So that's been very successful.

1:00:04 And then on the media side, Ali had mentioned the domestic side. Michael and through these agencies were able to secure 381 international media placements. And the marketing equivalent value of that is about $2.2 million. So telling our story worldwide is a huge piece of that. We also partner with not only

1:00:26 Local with Mono County and with the ski area and Visit California and High Sierra, but we also work on a national level with Brand USA. Brand USA is our organization promoting the United States to the world. So it's the DMO for the country. So their job is being worldwide. So basically you've got Brand USA out there with the full USA message, you've got Visit California out there with the California message, and then you've got Michael coming in with that Eastern Sierra and Mammoth Lakes message.

1:00:57 I'm going to jump into air service here. Last year was a game changer. We were able to finally get to the point where we brought in the Embraer 175. We have a lot of locals that are flying, so hopefully you've had a chance to experience this plane. It made a huge difference for us last year. We've talked about it for years. The old plane that we were flying, the CRJ-700, United, had 19 of those.

1:01:18 Last check, they had 196 of these new planes. This is really kind of the plane right now. And by getting the airport sanctioned to land that plane, it opens us up for American Airlines, Delta Airlines, you know, Alaska. So it really is a great opportunity for us moving forward. And with the efficiencies of the plane and with the technology that they were able to put in, we had zero cancellations last winter in Bishop. And we had one cancellation this summer.

1:01:45 At the end of the summer, we had a windy day in Bishop that caused a cancellation, which was really great to see one cancellation out of two full seasons. Just a brief update. So this is from last winter, and you can see that Denver was very, very strong. It was up 23% year over year, and that's a massive number to bring in. San Francisco being up 31%. We were up in Carlsbad as well with Advanced Airlines into MMH, and Hawthorne was...

1:02:14 Really flat to where we were the prior year. So Hawthorne continues to be something that we try and figure out how that can improve over the year-over-year traffic. Summer, you can see on here the light blue bar is 2024. The dark blue bar is 2025. We saw massive opportunities increases in San Francisco with a 51% growth in that market. And then we did see both Carlsbad and Hawthorne slightly lower than we were last year.

1:02:43 We did do an extension for the fall, so our normal service ended on September 2nd, I think, and then on September 4th, we started a four-day-a-week service through the end of October, or the beginning of October, October 6th. That was really towards the endurance month that we had with the Trail Fest and all the different events that we had going on. That was a partnership between the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and Inyo County to take that risk on adding those seats, and we ended up with the best load factor of the year in that month.

1:03:13 So at 57% of the planes were full. Going quickly into financial overviews, this is just a quick map of where we were prior to when the TBID went in place at $10.7 million average. And through the fiscal year 24-25, that average jumped to $22.3 million. Last year we did $28.3, which is great. Our high was the big snow year when we were at $29.5, but we were second best TOT year last year.

1:03:43 Just a quick budget breakdown here. So you can see the orange bar is Measure A, and really Measure A is dedicated to marketing and special events. And then the blue bar is what we spend on the TBID. And then if you look at the combined, you can see that the majority of the funds, almost $8 million, are really dedicated towards that marketing effort. So that's been a huge piece for us. Obviously, the first year of community engagement last year, we really put together a...

1:04:10 A very small budget just to figure out where we needed to be. It was $67,000 last year. That has greatly increased now that we have Betsy on board to figure out exactly what we were doing. And so you'll see next year that that number is substantially more. Last year's total budget was $11.4 million. Yeah. Light blue is combined. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yep. Oh, sorry. Yep. These are just the reserves that we have in the bank right now. The TBD reserves sit in the money market. That number is actually...

1:04:50 And so we had a $625,000 settlement on that. We used

1:05:15 The reserves last year for event funding, but this year we're still holding onto those with the idea that they're good for an event venue or potentially down the road for more event grant funding.

1:05:27 The infrastructure reserves, you'll remember when we renewed the TBID two years ago that we had dedicated the additional half a percent from the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and the golf course proceeds. And so those have been, that's two years worth of the dollars there at $734,000. Anticipate anywhere from $375,000 to $400,000 plus annually that we're putting into this fund with the idea that we will be doing projects. Hayes and I had a conversation this morning about a new opportunity for us.

1:05:54 We continue to look at things like the bus notifications and kiosks and other things that we can do in the community that benefit both residents and visitors. So that's what that fund is. It'll jump again at the end of the fiscal year. We'll put money back into that account to keep growing that as well. Annually, we need to come out with a TBID report, just basically talk about where that's been and where it's going. And so jumping right into it and actually...

1:06:22 Councilmember Wentworth, you asked in our meeting how we correlate things with snowfall. We don't necessarily have it on the add effectiveness, but what I do, every year when I do this, I put the snowfall amount just to show that it's almost arbitrary. You know, whether we have 715 inches or 286 inches on the hill, the numbers are still strong. So we're very fortunate in that sense. Last winter, we couldn't have asked for a better timing on storms.

1:06:48 You know, right before Thanksgiving, right before Christmas, right before presents, right before spring break. I mean, it was, we could not have ordered it any easier. So this is really just, these are the total revenues in each segment. So you look at the lodging line, the orange bar, that's about $220 million in direct spending at our lodging properties that turn into the TOT and TVIT. And then you can see the blue bar being retail, the light blue bar being restaurant, and then the green bar being the ski area.

1:07:16 These are just the TBID funds that are raised, so we're right around $7 million a year on the TBID funds. These are the historicals by segment, so this is how each one contributes towards the TBID. Again, that orange bar being lodging, that's the biggest participant. The ski area has really been contributing quite a bit in the last few years with that added half a percent as well. Our budget breakdown on the TBID specifically, about $6 million of that goes right directly to marketing.

1:07:48 100% of our staffing costs are in the TBID. They used to be split between, they used to be Measure A, then they were split 50-50, then they were split 75-25, and we moved them into Measure A. It's just easier from an accounting standpoint. Sorry, TBID. So we moved the funds all 100% into TBID.

1:08:10 Basically, there are a couple of things that we definitely need to report on each year. The current term of the TBID runs through August of 28. As we talked about in our Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board meeting, we will be starting the effort to renew that late in 2027, giving us really kind of a nine-month window. The TBID will renew again in September of 2028. There are no changes to the district boundary. It's still the town and the airport that are considered part of the district.

1:08:36 The efforts that we are doing on the marketing and sales side are consistent with where we've been in the past few years. The lodging assessment, retail assessment, and the restaurant assessment are all still unchanged from when we put them in place in 2013. And the ski area and golf courses increased to 2.5% as of the renewal back in 2023.

1:08:58 Lodging last fiscal year missed by about $50,000. Retail missed by quite a bit. I think we had a lot of challenges in retail last year. If you remember, Vons was a disaster with their remodel, and I still can't find things in there. And then also losing Rite Aid was a big piece of the retail drop. Restaurants were pretty close to flat with last year. The ski area exceeded the budget.

1:09:23 And if you have any math skills whatsoever, you can see that my overall TBID missing number is wrong. I don't know how I missed that, but it says minus 68,000. It's actually about minus 237. So it was 3.3% behind budget. I have a feeling I just didn't update that from the previous year. And as we talked about, the TBID has reserves that are held in an interest-bearing money market account to protect those funds, and that's about 1.02 million.

1:09:51 And that's really the whole presentation for today. So if you have questions for me or the team, happy to answer them. If you have ideas or thoughts or questions, we're here. Yeah. Thank you. Questions? Council Member Wentworth? Well, I don't have a question. It's been a real pleasure to serve as the council representative on the MLT board. I think there are a couple of things that are very impressive about the organization. One is obviously the staff.

1:10:26 I mean, this is as good a team as I think we could hope to have. The skill set in the environment that we're working in is really excellent. Also, the board is really impressive. It's an engaged board. They show up. They pay attention. They have a lot of, they ask questions, right? Inquiring questions. They push on things.

1:10:51 But they look out for the interests of their mission and what it is they're trying to accomplish. I think there are a couple of things that stand out as highlights. One is the air service, which has been a partnership effort between the town and a lot of regional partners. We'll talk more about that this evening. But I think it has been a regional game changer. It's now created a region where there perhaps wasn't one before. But a lot of folks are working together on that.

1:11:19 I think there's some challenges coming, just personally from my perspective, I think artificial intelligence is going to be a real, it's going to be a real thing. This is a very digitally oriented crew and they work, they got a lot of expertise in that arena, but that's got a lot of challenges for everybody. And I think the other challenges, you notice the infrastructure fund, which was in the T-bid, it's $700,000 now, it's going to be a million next year.

1:11:45 Still not sure we're there with, I'll ask some questions later about the three projects were identified in Betsy's presentation. These are the three things we're working on. If I ask the town staff, are those the three things we've identified, the things we're working on, I think we've still got some work to do. And I think as we go into the TBID renewal discussion, as John mentioned, in the coming years, I think we want to make sure that that is tight. And I think there was also some interesting polling on the business owners, the folks who are paying the assessment.

1:12:13 You know, the buy-in is really solid with there. So there's some work to do. But I think the work that we do as a council as a town with housing, we couldn't even come close to touching the kinds of things we're doing with that without having these types of resources that come from the basic business model of the town and the community. So I hope that that's a fair representation. But it's been a pleasure being on the board so far. You know, I'm just going to make a quick comment on this because of the fact that I can't resist.

1:12:45 The importance of tourism in this town. I hear people complain all the time, we need to cut our marketing budget, people are going to come anyway. That just doesn't happen. These guys have done a great job in name recognition. And when they've needed to change for the stewardship and not just peer getting numbers here, they were able to do that. So I want to give John and his crew huge kudos for that and us as a town. And I wish there was a way and Betsy's working on it.

1:13:14 To get more of the local people to understand that virtually everything we have here, I was here when it wasn't here, virtually everything we have here is paid for by the tourism that these people help us keep. And there have been places who have cut their tourism budgets and it has taken them decades to get back to where they were before. So I just want for my community to help understand if anyone has questions, give me a call.

1:13:44 But to give them the kudos for what we do and how we've managed to keep the name of a little 7,000 person mammoth in the international headlines to keep them coming. So that's my bet. Councilmember Truax, is there anything you wanted to ask or add? No, I am good. All right. Then I just. Oh, I'll just say thank you so much for. Oh, sorry.

1:14:12 I just want to say thank you so much for your service and we're all sad to be losing you. Thank you for the presentation and we really appreciate you guys doing all that you do for the town. Thank you. So a couple of things. The first thing is I'd be so curious to see the dashboard that or I think it's the dashboard that pulls in all the different data because I look every week at the occupancy rates.

1:14:42 And I personally used the leaf peeping, you know, thing to know where to go every week during the fall. And it was amazing, but it was too good because one time at Crowley on a Friday, I've never seen that many people, no, convict, convict. I've never seen that many people there in my life. So I do want to say that, you know, obviously it's clear based on our

1:15:10 TOT and all of our revenues that all of the programs are working, but I am curious because it felt this fall, it felt more palpable like the leaf peeping was really having a bigger impact and when you look at the occupancy rates, it only sort of started to go down in the beginning of November and now it's back because it snowed for Thanksgiving. So just, you know, something that I think

1:15:34 As Councilmember Sauser said so eloquently, like, our community needs to understand that this is the lifeblood of our community, and here I am looking at the president of our hospital and the reason, part of the reason, it's your wonderful management, but it's also because people come here and use our services that we are building a new wing, which is going to take us into the future in a really positive way. So I think I'm just reiterating what the rest of the council said, that

1:16:01 When I heard the news that you would be leaving, I thought 15 years, that means you started in 2010. I think it's going to be a very interesting conversation we have in the second meeting in December when we talk about what was it like here in 2010 and what was it like here in 2012? And, you know, then things start to get better and then we had COVID. So your tenure was at a time of multiple black swan events and yet.

1:16:27 Here we are talking about how successful we've been. So I think I will leave it at that. Thank you. Is that the end of our workshop or is there more to? I think if there's anything that you would like to discuss about some of the things you saw tonight or any way forward aside from just accolades to John, well-deserved, that would be appropriate. But if there's nothing else to be said, then I think we could be done with that. Okay. Do we need to take public comment? Board members.

1:16:55 Yes. Oh, absolutely. I just, yeah. But should I take public comment first and then? Or should we let you guys? Whatever you prefer. Why don't we let the board speak and then we'll take any public comment to make sure that we fulfill that obligation. I just wanted to thank you for your time tonight and I'm really looking forward to the time on December 17th. I really appreciate the opportunity to go through, thank John for all of his accomplishments and the things that he and the team

1:17:25 Have done for this community. It's significant and it will be a lot of fun. Obviously, big moves today, right? This is a lot of big news. There's never a good time for this type of thing. But the council and the board know this, but for the community,

1:17:45 I strongly feel that this is the best time that this could have happened for us. I think we've got the best team that we've ever had. I think we've got the best relationship with the town council that we've ever had. We've got a clear direction on where we want to go. We've already put together a CEO search ad hoc committee. So we've got a plan and a strategy. And we know what we want to do in the interim to bridge the gap. Like I said, we've got an amazing staff.

1:18:13 But the board will be spending plenty of time with them, making sure they have everything they need. John's going to be available. So anything, he's not going to disappear. So that's good. And then if we don't get the results that we want right away, it took about 15 minutes from the press release hitting before I started getting emails from recruiting companies wanting to help us. So I feel really good about where we're at.

1:18:39 And thankful for your support. And I'm looking forward to December 17th. Anyone else from the board want to add anything? And then is there any public comment that anyone would like to say anything? Either in the room, and I don't see anyone running, but Jamie, anyone online? All right. Then with that, thank you. If I could, I'd really like to ask the board of MOT to...

1:19:05 We're just small-town politicians. We don't know how to roast people. Perhaps if you guys could start working on some jokes. Could you work on something? I have an idea to Rob. Okay, good. Yeah, because you set some expectations for the 17th, so I just want to make sure. We will take a three-minute break while we take away the tables and then restart promptly.

1:19:47 It's my birthday, by the way. It's your birthday? It's my birthday today. When is it your birthday? Today. Councilmember Truax, we need you to sing to Councilmember Wright, Mayor Pro Tem Rice. Brent would sing. Do you want us to sing? No, you don't. You don't want me to sing. It's not pretty. All right. Let's come back to our agenda. So next, making sure.

1:25:41 We are on to public presentations, and we have a presentation from Pam Bold from High Sierra Energy Foundation, and she is the Executive Director. We just had some community members that lost a lot, and so I wanted to acknowledge that, and with celebration, there can often be...

1:26:22 The reverse of that. So, anyways, so, yeah, I wanted to just give an overview of our organization. We, many of you know us, and I know many of you, but we are a non-profit that's here in, based in Mammoth, and we serve in Yonemono counties. We were founded in 2005 by the founding executive director, Rick Phelps, and he was back in town last week.

1:26:51 To celebrate our 20th anniversary. And he moved on in 2015 to, he's living in Oregon and teaching at OSU and still in the energy world. So I have appreciation that he provided a foundation for us to continue to build upon.

1:27:13 And we, yeah, so the, just a little background about what the foundation was started on. If you don't know, many of you do, were around for a while that do know that it was to explore geothermal heat districts for our community and they secured a

1:27:32 A grant from the California Energy Commission to do some research on that. It did appear that there was potentially some viability. There was some test drilling from Iceland coming to do that. All of that happened around the time when the economic downturn came and adding additional funds to further explore and to have the geothermal heat districts just...

1:27:59 And so that's when the organization refocused its focus to energy efficiency. And so since then we have worked on other energy and sustainability programs and our team is bringing, sorry it's really hard for me to read this, I thought I would have my screen here. So anyways,

1:28:29 Yeah, many of you know that I have worked as a lone wolf for many years, and I'm super pleased to announce that we now have Jess Blackwell who's worked with us for about three years. We have a new employee, Jenna Hirochi, that lives in Independence, and we have an AmeriCorps Civic Spark. If they are working in energy or climate, they're called Civic Sparks. So Ella Francis has joined us for a year stint, so we're excited to have some additional resources. So many people wonder, like, how

1:28:58 How our funding comes, we do have funding from lots of different sources, but the main one is through public goods charge, and public goods charge is a ratepayer fund that on all of our investor-owned utility bills, electric investor-owned utility bills, there's a small line item that turns out to be a large amount in the state of California, and that's what funds many energy efficiency programs throughout the state, and so that's really where

1:29:27 The majority of our funding for statewide and regional energy network programs come from. So understanding what regional energy networks are, they're called RENs often, and we are part of two different ones. There's the Southern California Regional Energy Network, or called SoCal REN.

1:29:47 And we do public agency work and multifamily work with them. And so we currently are doing some work with the town of Mammoth Lakes. And we've done some projects for Mono County on multifamily and others. And that is administered by Los Angeles County. Then we are also part of a new REN, which is called the Central California Rural Regional Energy Network. And for about the last 10 years, that is what...

1:30:14 It has been a big passion of my work is to ensure that rural and hard-to-reach rate payers and communities are getting the access to programs as our urban counterparts are. So a lot of work went into this, and in September of 2024,

1:30:35 The CPUC, the California Public Utility Commission approved the Central California Rural REN or what's called the CCR REN because everything in our industry has acronyms. So we've worked really hard. It's a group that the REN is administered by the County of San Luis Obispo. It includes agencies that have worked in organizations that have worked together for a lot of years, including local governments.

1:31:03 Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments, AMBAG is a partner, San Joaquin Valley Clean Energy Organization, the County of Ventura in an advisory role because they are part of another REN called the 3C REN.

1:31:18 And the ICR Energy Foundation. And when many people have asked, like, are you Central California? I tell them, I don't care what they call us as long as they give us the money. So for now, we're part of Central California. I don't know if everyone views us that way, but we'll view ourselves that way if it includes the funding. And so the CCRN serves 5.4 million customers across 14 counties in almost 50,000 square miles.

1:31:46 Which is 76% geographically hard to reach, 40% disadvantaged, and 50% underserved. So the programs that we have launched through the CCR REN, there's five programs. There's residential, workforce education and training. There's a public agency, but that's just for Monterey Bay since we are partners with SoCal REN for our public agencies, tribes, and schools.

1:32:12 There is a commercial program and we have trained a person locally, has gone through extensive curriculum to be an energy advisor. She will be going around to community businesses to see if there are some no-cost opportunities for electrification. And then our finance program will be launched in January, sorry, in 2026.

1:32:37 So a lot of hard work went into that, and we're already now working on our business plan for 2028 through 2035, crazily enough, since we just started implementing programs, but we're back at the table to write a large business plan to be evaluated by the CPUC. So looking forward to adding additional programs and resources and funding to our community.

1:33:02 Last round was just $36 million. We anticipate asking for significantly more and hoping to have the track record to prove it. Southern California, the Southern California Regional Energy Network, or SoCal REN, what we've been doing with the town is some facility equipment inventories. It's been great to work with some of the public works and facility asset managers.

1:33:26 We've evaluated and done inventories on all of the entire portfolio and are now in the process of looking at what initial measures we can address and offer financing or incentives for. So that will be coming. We're also working on an energy resilience action plan so that when funding comes up for resilient centers or

1:33:54 That we, that the town will have a report and have, you know, what kind of additional resources may be needed to be able to apply for funding for those resilient centers. And so just...

1:34:08 A little information about what we've done. Youth has been something that we've focused on for many years. We have partnered with the Mammoth Community Water District for the last 18 years with Gil Campos and Clay Murray, who now is going to be the district manager. It was great to see that because he's been an integral part of this community. We have done scholarships in the last five years. We've granted over...

1:34:35 Thank you so much.

1:35:02 Thank you so much. Thank you.

1:35:24 Yeah, and some of you, I know Bill, you were on the council at the time, we did the McConkie Foundation, and I think what, maybe even how long that was ago, eight years ago or so, the environmental, or the eco challenge, and we did the whole twist the cap before you, or before you, but try the tap before you twist the cap and the water, and so.

1:35:49 I think it ultimately ended up in the single-use water ban. So we were happy to be a part of that. Yeah, and then we also are doing this Kits for Kids through SoCal RAN for third grade classes at Mammoth High School, and the teachers receive $1,000 for their classroom resources. Can I ask you a question about that? Is that annually third grade teachers? Yeah, for the third grade teachers. It's just focused on that one class.

1:36:19 It's just one classroom? Well, that grade. So any students in that grade. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. We would love to reach it more, but that's the parameters of the program. Then the other initiatives, some of you may have participated in our California Sustainable Library Series on our Earth Month, and that was funded through, unfortunately, received federal funding, and that funding is going away, but we did some wonderful

1:36:47 Workshops and tours at the wastewater treatment plant and hydro facilities. We hope to be able to continue to do that in some fashion as we go forward. And then you see us around town, Kittapalooza, Tri-County Fair, you see us a lot. We're just trying to engage and have people just think about where their energy comes from and how they can reduce it and reduce their environmental impacts. So here's to 20 years and we hope to 20 years more, at least.

1:37:16 Happy to have any questions. Thank you so much. Questions? I have an observation, but I'm not a question. You can make your observation now. Well, I just, I occasionally, from time to time, you know, I wander around in state, and Pam Bold has waded into the deepest muck that it is. And she's done it with, I think, by herself, with very limited staff. And I think all the,

1:37:47 All the communities that you touch, OU and the work you're doing, just an enormous and profound debt of gratitude. Thank you. Appreciate that. In deep, in the dark, acronym swamp of the CPUC. There's nothing more. Everything's complicated in this world. Everything in that world is especially complicated. And yet, at the end of the day, you provide benefits to the community, you do good things for kids. Thank you. I'm sure on behalf of the council may I speak for myself. Thank you. Appreciate that.

1:38:18 Questions or comments? Bill? And Councilmember Truax, questions or comments? Okay, thank you. Well, I would like to add that I had the privilege of attending a conference with Pam Bold because when I first joined Council, I went to her and told her my ideas for how we could bring Mammoth into the future, have it be an all green, all...

1:38:50 You know, safe energy town. And Pam has done an extraordinary job of explaining to me why we can't do all the things that I dream about. But I will say that, you know, so these Wrens are no joke. They are incredibly well funded and they tend to keep the money in the cities. And it's because of Pam that we are now part of the CCR Wren. Is that the right number of letters?

1:39:19 It is, but also a group of my colleagues. Of course, Pam and her colleagues. She's so humble. But you know what, Pam? You're the only one of those colleagues here, except for Jess, who's doing that work. So I think it's really important for us to understand that in the future, when we start to have the opportunity for people who can install solar to install more solar, or for people who want to put a heat pump in for their heating instead of a gas-powered furnace, that

1:39:46 The access that we will get through the programs you are bringing here are what is going to make that possible. So I hope that everyone will make sure that they learn more about High Sierra Energy Foundation, participate in the programs that Pam and Jess and her team bring here, and really just start to engage because the future is renewable energy and we have

1:40:13 Thank you for being here.

1:40:43 Is there any public comment or anyone online that wants to ask a question or just clarify anything? Okay. Well, again, thank you so much for being here and thanks for all you do. Thanks for your time. Okay. Onward. We have reports from commissions and departments as needed. Hello. Good evening. I know we've got a lot on the agenda, so I'm going to keep this relatively brief, but

1:41:27 Just a couple of things I wanted to give the board a quick update on kind of the events of last week. When you talk about relationships, I don't think there's any more important than a relationship than between Crowley and Mammoth Lakes. You know, they're obviously very near to our hearts. So the fire district basically left a skeleton crew here to support town, and we sent six apparatus, four engines, two water tenders, and two chief officers to do what we could to assist our neighbors.

1:41:56 We were placed on structural protection in the McGee area. Had quite a few experienced individuals, including, you know, working with the Forest Service who had an incident commander who's seen quite a few things. And the wind event made it for, you know, pretty catastrophic wildfires as apparent to everybody. And it just kind of, everything was done to do what we could. There were some structures saved, but ultimately, you know, we had the results that we did.

1:42:23 If there's a couple things that we can take away from it, what we generally try to do is work to protect life, property, and the environment. As things get more significant, we start to take things off the list, and ultimately life comes first. I think we have to recognize the work that law enforcement did in evacuations to make sure that we didn't have loss of life there. The reality is that was a...

1:42:47 Huge win by the teams that were involved in that, both on the MLPD side that went down immediately to assist our sheriff's department and the other units involved in that. But again, while there were losses, you know, the fact that we didn't lose any lives with what we saw there is frankly incredible. The other piece of this is, you know, ultimately, while we were able to make some saves, this really comes down to prevention and mitigation. Immediately after this event occurred,

1:43:15 Town staff and I pulled together and we were working on, okay, while we've been doing some really good things, you know, where are some lessons learned to make sure that we can keep doing what we can to protect our communities. And that work is occurring. You know, I feel really proud to have, you know, be part of this team. And there certainly are lessons even in tragedies that we can walk away with. So that's what we're going to continue to do. So that's all I have. Thank you so much. Any questions or? Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you so much.

1:43:46 Mayor Boebser, I'll just add a little bit to that. What Alice just alluded to is Monday night we got together with all of the, so Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection and our PD and town administration, so people who did respond and work in the operations center down there in Crowley for the first several hours of the event, right, the town being a large organization closest to the fire, I mean, that was why the response occurred the way it did.

1:44:15 And we were happy to provide that. But as Alice stated, we've gone back through all the different aspects of the response that we saw, things that we took away, and used that for sort of work plans and areas of focus. So over the next several months, we have sort of a next within a month, within three months, within the 12 months.

1:44:39 Things that we want to get stood up that may help in those spaces. So we're doing a lot of work in that area. We will certainly partner with Mono County. As you heard earlier from Supervisor Salcido, we're already in communications with them and sort of working through something that we do here will definitely dovetail into the Office of Emergency Services that they have within their organization. And it won't be a one-off, if you will. So very much interested in that. It did highlight

1:45:08 The importance of the work that we've been doing at the parcel level since early or late spring of this year. I know going into we will have a program where we talk about the success of that and sort of a year-end closeout and what it looks like for next year. We are committed to doing that project for another two years beyond the first year at the initial phases anyway. We will reevaluate and look at what that looks like.

1:45:35 I think it illustrates the importance of that type of work. It takes an entire community and I'm sort of proud of the work that's been done thus far but look forward to what we can accomplish in the future. So I wanted to add just a little bit more to those comments. Thank you. And so there'll be a sort of closeout for the year on the town-specific wildfire mitigation program. I think also the council and the community would benefit and appreciate hearing from, you know, once you and your colleagues and

1:46:06 I know you had a couple questions. I had a couple questions on the CIP update.

1:46:38 And I'm wondering if we could just, I appreciate the written response, but just like to share some of the information with the council. Good evening. Good evening. Go ahead and fire away. Okay, so. I have them if you want me to. No, I've got the questions. I just, I robbed center of us. Okay. So, the Civic Center, if you just, quick update on progress. I know you're making great progress with move-in dates and what are we looking for that?

1:47:18 And, John, I'm going to deviate slightly from the written response because this is a public setting. Sure. So the Civic Center, the contractors afforded the entirety of their contract time that is currently set in September. They may use that time however they see fit to complete the project. That being said, they are currently over two months ahead of schedule. Depending on what happens this winter, we're hoping that they maintain that schedule. It is looking likely.

1:47:48 Which means we could be in the building sooner than the September date we had previously set. I don't want to commit them to any timelines. I'm not committing staff to any timelines, but internally we are discussing the opportunities an early opening may afford and how we may transition into the space. And we have a transition team tipped up and we're working through that. And as we get closer, we'll provide more details. And that's, of course, if the contractor is willing to give us the building sooner.

1:48:17 Okay, so the agreement is they've got a mutually agreed upon date. Yeah, I get all that. So congratulations and thanks a lot. And we have a lease in our current facilities that's locked in until September 30 of 2026. Okay, got it. So we have to be out by that period of time, but that's been the number I think we've established for years now. Okay, great. Okay, good. Well, congratulations. Good work.

1:48:40 On the shade restrooms, I don't want to get into the details of all this. I appreciate the work that's going on there. But remember, we had a conversation a while ago. And this is coming a little bit out of the MLT work to do with the board. We're talking about restrooms, bathrooms, capital infrastructure, forest service, all the rest of it. I just wanted to get a quick maybe update. Where is that conversation at this point around these things?

1:49:06 Project for the Shady Restroom is moving forward. That's in design. We're moving forward on that. When I provided the CIP update on September 3rd, we briefly talked about the whole restroom conversation. And I presented some different concepts about our existing infrastructure and what it would take to build out additional infrastructure. And the consensus at that time was not to move any of that forward. So until something has changed or if there's different council direction,

1:49:34 Public Works is not advancing any projects in that space. Okay, good. It's good to know that. I would like to add, because I think, John, you're talking about, you know, the TBID infrastructure dollars, right, that were accumulated, and John had those in his presentation this evening, where that's $730,000 that's been accumulated thus far. The town also had $500,000 that we initially put aside. Those are in our coffers, if you will, designated for that purpose.

1:50:00 We continue to have discussions about what's the best use. I think when you mentioned the restrooms, that was Dan Holler was really focused on restrooms and sort of that's what facilitated Hais's conversation in September is really to kind of flesh out, you know, where we were, what we wanted to do, how we wanted to provide those particular services. But I would say that we do have eyes on that. I think we need to move forward. It's kind of difficult to seek.

1:50:28 What would have a broad benefit for the businesses that pay in a T-bid, right? That's kind of the litmus test for whether you can do it or not. And I am looking for a project that isn't sort of ancillary to what we would have already done, but more impactful for the area. So I think there's maybe we're stuck in the too many different constraints about what we're trying to do in that space. There was some kiosk stuff that's out there as well that we're floating about.

1:50:58 For a long-winded answer is we've got eyes on it and we're interested in making it appropriate for the monies that were set aside. Okay, good. Just seeing where all that's going. That's good to know. The Minaret Meridian Roundabout, in my foggy cranium, there was some discussion about maybe in the fall there would be some kind of a public

1:51:22 Yeah.

1:51:32 You are correct. We've been discussing a kind of public forum to discuss the roundabout, and we've taken in a lot of different comments, positive, negative, a lot of questions, and we're trying to anticipate those questions in advance of a meeting. Tomorrow, we're calling it roundabout day. We're setting up a

1:51:52 The roundabout at the airport with cones and we have a number of vehicles coming down. We're flying a drone over that so people can see how semi trucks and different types of vehicles navigate the roundabout. We've got some photo sims coming. We've got even something you can drive, like a simulation where you can drive through the roundabout being put together. We're just creating a number of different tools so that when we bring this forward.

1:52:19 We can answer those questions and provide good responses to the concerns. That's taking time. A lot more time than I anticipated because I didn't realize there was going to be that many questions about a roundabout. Right now, we're looking at January, maybe December if things come together a little bit quicker with some of the photo sims. But we are planning to bring something forward pretty robust. Good. That's good. It's good to hear. Okay.

1:52:47 Thank you for that. And I'd like to add, I'm not going to add, I promise I'm not going to add to what he says. If you, any council members who would like to go and observe the testing, right, that tomorrow is, you just reach out to me, I'll get you all the details on that.

1:53:03 I would really love for you guys to see the depth at which the consultant is going through and reviewing the constraints and concerns, right? As we've been talking about since we started this, you know, Truckee has a ton of roundabouts in their facility and have given us good input on how snow removal and other facts need to be built. I think there were some lessons learned at Truckee that were even conveyed to us and we had the same consultants and so forth.

1:53:31 The depth in which the analysis is ongoing, right? We want to get away from some of the sort of anecdotal emotional kind of responses, and I think it would be really good for you guys to come out maybe and engage with the consultant, see the background of how those tests are being done, because you'll see the outcome, right? You'll see the drone footage and all that stuff in a public meeting, but to be there and to be able to sideline with the consultant and say, here's some of the concerns that I'm hearing. How would this be addressed?

1:54:00 That might be good tomorrow. If you guys can afford a little bit of time, bless you, that might be a really good opportunity. Okay, but do we get to drive anything? You do. What time is it? You can drive my truck through there and see high speed, whatever you want. Okay. What time are we talking, Rob? 10.30. What time? 10.30. Can I drive the loader with the wings? There will be a loader going through it, so yes. Yeah, and I will add that that consultant is...

1:54:29 Dialed into Mammoth. They were actually here today just to learn about this room and this space to understand the opportunities and constraints of what they can demonstrate to you in this setting. Okay, great. Sounds fun. Do we have an idea of time tomorrow? 10.30. There's a lot of things on my calendar already. The total time is around three hours. 10.30 until when? It'll be 10.30, probably, depending on what the weather's doing, hour, hour and a half to run the vehicles through. Good. Well, thank you. That's a really...

1:55:01 Really good update. Parcel phase three, just checking to see kind of where we're at with this. I know that, Rob, maybe, you know, kind of what direction you got from us, where we're at with putting those pieces together. Yeah, so parcel phase three, you know, we're certainly working through the various...

1:55:22 Opportunities we have to get that built. So we've got money set aside both for construction. We set aside money originally that was intended to be the amount necessary as subsidy for what we envisioned to be built there and what we wanted as a price point for sale. So those monies have all been set aside, you know, a few years ago. Even last year we set aside some infrastructure dollars in order to have that built.

1:55:47 We continue to have the plan that we will either work through another contractor to have that constructed. We're developing partnerships with other agencies in town that have a need to provide workforce housing and would like to possibly have units in that space or build units in that space. But we're just continuing to work on that. We've got a few other in-flight activities going on, if you will. There's an opportunity to acquire some land, which we're working on that.

1:56:15 And so it remains there and ready to be worked on. It's part of actually the DDA discussion we had on the 5th of November with Pacific and our opportunity to fund the final Phase 2 of Phase 2, Kingfisher 2, and exit the DDA as an option for the town that would sort of free up that process a little bit more. Right now, I think that resides in the DDA.

1:56:45 While it's home ownership, it has some specific requirements for Pacific to do that. So we're looking for that sort of mechanism to potentially free that up, but still in process. No, it's good to know. It's good to follow up with the DDA discussions we had to get that clear. So thank you for that. Parks and trail signage. I'm assuming that's, is that the, I was just wondering which design specs we're using for that. You're probably going to be using the town wayfinding standards, right? Yeah, so all the

1:57:14 Adopted standards are within the public works standards in different sections. So those will be the standard plans we use. We don't deviate from them. I mentioned at the CIP update that we had delayed that project given the battery of work we have. We just didn't have time to get to it. But we are working on it now. And we've combined that project with some other wayfinding programs. And we're working on the TBID stuff with Betsy. We've got the kiosks designed. And so we're currently packaging all that up and targeting an April, a March-April bid.

1:57:44 With a mid-summer construction. But again, these will be signs that are consistent with the current town wayfinding program. Yeah, we don't deviate from those standards. Yeah, okay, just wanted to check on that. Okay, and then finally, the Minaret MUF, congratulations if that comes to pass. And just the question, I assume that gets integrated into the Mammoth Lakes Trail System with that signage and that whole program. Is that where that lives?

1:58:09 Yeah, and we've applied. The money has been dedicated. It's appropriated. We're actually filling out the paperwork with Caltrans right now to receive those funds, and then we have to go out to bid with a certain amount of time. So that project is moving forward, and it'll be before you for the final approval when we have the contract and the bids in place. Integration can mean a couple of different things. You can talk about integration, the hard infrastructure on the ground, absolutely integrated. Signage.

1:58:39 We're anticipating future projects. There's a lot in that design that integrates it into the overall system, current, and future. Then there's integration into the MLTS, the virtual space, the mapping, the website, opportunities that we kind of provide through the MLTS website. All that's happening in tandem.

1:59:02 Myself and Lawson communicate on these things on a regular basis. So there's the virtual space and the real space, and I can tell you that both of them are being integrated. You also had naming on here, John? Yeah. And we always name projects in public works because that's just how it works. By virtue of the fact, we have to name them to bid them. And there's a process through the MLTS to rename them. And if that's something they desire to do, then I would ask that they get together, work together as a team, and then...

1:59:30 Give that to us in advance so that we can incorporate those names or changes into the plan set. And there's still plenty of time to do that. Okay, good. So it's a public works project is coming forward. But at the end of the day, for the visitors, for the community, it will be a nice, beautiful new segment of the Mammoth Lake Trail System with signage and all the rest of it. It will be seamless. Yeah. Okay, great. Okay. Madam Mayor, thank you for indulging me with all that.

1:59:56 Great to see all the work you guys are doing. Great to hear about it. Thank you. Any other questions or follow-up from this? Councilmember Truax, you look cold. I hope it's warm there where you are. Okay. It is not. Yeah. I'm worried about you. What should we do for him, Betsy? Okay. It's 28 degrees here. Yeah, you can tell. All right. Hang in there. We'll keep going. Next, we have item...

2:00:21 9.1, which is a presentation on enforcement efforts related to trash and wildlife issues. We tried to bring as many people as we possibly could to this presentation, but I will say, you know, I appreciate the work these folks are doing in this space. As you know, this is an important topic that the town has, you know, taken a multi-pronged approach with over the last couple of years now as we look at how we can

2:00:53 Better protect our wildlife and enforcing these processes. So the reason there are a number of people here is it shows you the different arms of our organization that are involved in that. And I think they're doing really good work. So I'm going to let them stake it away and start talking about those different components. So thank you. All right. Thank you. So I'll provide kind of an overview of what has occurred or really the background of where we've got to where we were with the code changes earlier this year.

2:01:23 A little bit on just the enforcement techniques or the tools that our code compliance officers have. And then a little bit on just the types of trash spills and then kind of a map showing some data points that we've collected over the past year related to both wildlife incidents and then how those relate with trash. So really these changes

2:01:51 As far as kind of the enforcement on trash spills came about in March of this year with the changes to the municipal code. Those changes were in the solid waste chapter, in the public, in the nuisance chapter, and then the construction debris chapter. The biggest change was that it placed the responsibility for securing the trash receptacle on the account holder. So the person who has the account with Mammoth disposal is ultimately responsible for their

2:02:20 They're a trash receptacle, whether that be a dumpster or a bear cart or some other type. And the biggest change is that it doesn't matter if they were the ones who left it unsecured or if it was a member of the public, an employee, anybody else. It's ultimately the account holder's responsibility. The changes also went on to specify what the penalties would be for trash spills. So when we talk about enforcement tactics,

2:02:50 And I think our code compliance officers both within the community development department and in the PDE, it's not a one size fits all for enforcement. You know, there's some who have never had a trash spill and might have a slip up one time. There's others who repeat offenders that they take a different approach to and a different tactic to. I think it's important to just highlight that it

2:03:17 Showing up heavy-handed and just issuing a citation doesn't always achieve the desired goal, which is to obviously improve the security of the dumpsters and reduce wildlife encounters or issues. So some of the tactics, and they kind of go in order as far as severity. Oftentimes it's corrected with just a simple site visit.

2:03:41 Either by the, again, either community, either code compliance officer really just to inform them what the issues are, point out areas where they, you might have deficiencies, offer tips to improve, such as, you know, sometimes it's as simple as putting a new carabiner on the dumpster because the one there is broken or defective, but often just a simple site visit achieves

2:04:08 The goal, which is to not come back for a trash spill. Following that, if they get repeat calls to a site, it's usually followed with a notice. It's a certified mail notice. It's really putting them on notice that, hey, if we come back again, you will be issued a citation. So it's kind of more of a stern official warning. Third visit, or not necessarily third, but stepping up from there, it's the citation.

2:04:35 And the citations are issued for each occurrence, and they do escalate with each repeat occurrence. Let Mike or Ryan touch on what those amounts are, but they do increase each time they come back out and for repeat occurrences. Then beyond that, we can actually declare a public nuisance, which involves the town attorney and the courts and actually issuing a civil or creating a civil judicious.

2:05:02 Judicial action on them related to trash. I'll look to code clients if we've actually taken that step. That's kind of the enforcement tactics. When we talk about types of trash spills, this is really kind of the lead up to the slide after this, which is a heat map of all the incidents. They kind of fall into five different categories. So you have your commercial trash spills. These are typically going to be dumpsters that are

2:05:30 They're left unsecured by an employee or the public using them at night. Typically it's dumpster. These are also the most visible because they're the ones that we see along Main Street or along Old Mammoth Road. Following that, we have residential. Often these, you know, might be a dumpster if it's, you know, within a multifamily complex that has a dumpster or it's a bear cart. It's kind of a rolling cart that single family homeowners can use that they're supposed to keep.

2:05:58 You know, secured in a garage or within a shed and roll out on trash day to be picked up. They do have issues with these if they get overfilled or otherwise and bears have also figured out if they bat those cans around enough they can actually kind of disable the locking mechanism on those. Construction is a big issue because they're

2:06:20 Often unsecured at night. They're not covered and they're not enclosed. They're intended to be just for construction debris, so those on-job sites, but often they're in some semi-public areas, so the public will just throw their trash in there, which then creates both issues for wildlife, but it also creates the issue for the contractor on that site because now they have mixed waste and it's not just C&D waste when they go to dump it.

2:06:47 Public is another issue. So that's going to be your trash cans in parks and other public areas. Often those, you know, they have the latch, but it's, again, relying on the user to make sure it gets latched correctly. Then the last one's kind of a unique one. It's unconfirmable. So we get code components often gets calls or complaints, but when they respond to those, they either can't find the spill or it's been cleaned up or otherwise. And sometimes this is kind of neighborly disputes.

2:07:16 Where a neighbor might see, you know, a very minor trash spill but still call it in to put their neighbors on notice on that. Just something on the unconfirmable. A lot of times when, excuse me, a lot of times when we go out, we'll get a call that there's a trash spill at a specific location. You know, our officers, our co-compliance officers will go out there and when they get there, the lid is closed and secure and there's no trash.

2:07:46 So for the public, for the council, when you see our blog that comes out for all the calls of service for the month, you'll see bear calls, dumpster calls and stuff like that. So a lot of times we're unable to get a hold of anybody, but when we get there, there's no trash and the dumpster's closed and secured. So somebody had already picked it up.

2:08:07 So at that point, there's really nobody to talk to about a trash bill. We didn't see the trash bill. So that's kind of goes into those unconfirmable like, yeah, something probably did happen, but it wasn't there when we got there. So then I'll let Ryan talk through this slide and what it's illustrating. So our parking and administrative site system works hand in hand. It's under the same company. It's data ticket and citation processing center. For like parking tickets, once we write the parking ticket and upload it, it's saved in two.

2:08:43 The cloud database. Same thing with administrative citations. Once that's written on the device and given to the person, that's uploaded into the database. We can also add, if we talk to someone verbally, give them a verbal warning without actually inputting anything into the system and giving them a ticket, we can manually put that in the system. And so we can track

2:09:11 Who we've talked to and if it was a verbal, a warning or an actual citation, we can pull up that data and see an exact location on what their history was if we've talked to them before. The map and I nerd out on presenting data in a way that people can understand. So if council ever needs a visual or management, I'm happy to provide that like this map. So I've broken down

2:09:38 Our calls for service from the police department side, when people call our dispatch saying there's a cash bill, there's a bear in my house, there's a bear in my vehicle. And from the pie chart, you can see that basically trash incidents, vehicle incidents, and home incidents involving bears are pretty evenly distributed. And this is data from January 1st until I believe I used October 31st, since we're not in a complete month.

2:10:05 I've noted the red dots as trash spills that were addressed by our town code compliance, whether that be warning or fines. And then I've broken down the bear incidents that were reported to us, not including someone calling about just a bear walking in front of their house. These are actual trash vehicle and home incidents. I've laid it out with a green trash can for trash incidents.

2:10:33 The car for vehicle incidents and then the little house symbol for home incidents. And as you can see, they're all pretty spread out. And the areas that we've addressed, trash bills, kind of aren't directly correlated to the incidents that are reported to us. I think that's all I had on my part.

2:11:07 I would just go on as we talked earlier about the kind of the enforcement tactics and how citations are issued. You know, when you look at the dots, majority of the red dots trash spills do align with the trash incidents for bears. I'm not aware that we've actually issued a citation when a bear has gotten into a vehicle or a home. I think just the damage that...

2:11:34 Results from that is enough of a deterrent or a reason for, you know, that homeowner to take actions or that person to take actions to secure their vehicle or the home. I don't know that the issuance of $100 citations is kind of just insult to injury then since often if a bearer does get into your car, it's going to be a quick, you know, learning moment to better secure your car and not leave food. Same with in the home. So really it's...

2:12:02 I think the citations align with those that are trash incidents, and again, it's more those that are repeat offenders, not a first-time offender, since often they can be educated to improve. Mike or Ron, do you want to add anything on that? Just to talk about the typical response when a trash spill is reported or found, at least for the Administrative Code Compliance Office, we'll make a

2:12:31 Try to site visit and try to confirm that the spill occurred and contact the responsible party. Usually there's somebody on site that we can talk to and we'll talk to them about the importance of not attracting and feeding the wildlife and what actions that they can take in the future to avoid spills, including things like having additional pickups of the trash, locking the

2:13:00 The receptacle, the padlock, maybe building an enclosure, moving the container to a different location, or going to a transfer station service, so not having a container on the property at all, just taking all of your trash directly to the transfer station. Then this site is added to the list of areas to watch that have had trash spills in the past.

2:13:31 I'll drive by known trash spill sites most days when I'm at work. And I'll ask neighbors to report if I know some of the neighboring businesses or property if there's a trash spill when I'm at work. If an additional trash spill occurs, I'll try to determine if they took any additional steps or actions that we had talked about to avoid the spill. And if they had...

2:14:00 We'll talk about taking other actions. If no action was taken, that's when I'll write a citation with a notice if they haven't done anything. We haven't quite got to the worst case where we would allow the town manager and town attorney to declare a public nuisance and take civil action yet, but there's some cases that are close.

2:14:29 Mike, what's the highest citation you've issued? $1,000? Does that work? I mean, have the people who have received the higher and higher citations come into compliance, or are they still? Yes, I think that the trash spills are less frequent. It does certainly appause the serial trash spilling for a time.

2:15:03 But no, it doesn't make it so it never happens again. All right. Sorry, continue on. I just was... That was just me describing the typical. Yeah. Okay. Let me ask. So the last slide really is just next steps on, you know, kind of where we're going or how we're continuing to improve on it. So I think the biggest one is just to continue educating the public. So that's including businesses as well as the public on why this is so important.

2:15:42 We're also, you know, with that data ticket software and the ability to input not just actual citations issued but kind of warnings, any observance of a trash spill, kind of any of those incidences. So encouraging those who are out in the field the most and driving around and seeing it to then document it and provide that information to code compliance. So this can include the police officers who are driving around.

2:16:08 Road Department, who's out and about, as well as Mammoth Disposal, since they're obviously going to every site servicing as they're picking up those dumpsters. So they have, we believe that the technology within their trash trucks, it's just a matter of then getting that information back to the town so we can track that based on location, create that geo-reference and the data ticket, because then it helps to create that visual.

2:16:36 And a map of, or heat map of where the incidences are, which can then kind of guide on the enforcement on, you know, where they might focus their efforts. So that's kind of on that third point to input all those incidences into the data ticket. It's really important to capture all that data in a single location, again, so that we can track it and just create that log of incidences. And then, obviously,

2:17:03 We'll continue to issue citations as needed to achieve compliance. Again, as Mike pointed out, it doesn't necessarily permanently prevent it, but it at least helps deter it. I'd also like to add, so when Nolan was talking about bears getting into cars and stuff like that, I think that's where discretion comes into play, right? So you have somebody, a tourist or somebody that comes in, bear gets into the car, they don't know much about leaving food in the car and stuff like that. They haven't done their research.

2:17:32 You get there, the entire car on the inside is destroyed. I think that's less than enough for people who do get their cars broken into. We have initiated, not really a policy, but a new way of tracking all this, and that is through data tickets. So that's what Ryan was explaining and Nolan. But what that does, both co-compliance departments...

2:17:57 Have data ticket machines that have the ability to get in. So when our officers respond in the middle of the night sometime and there's a trash spill, they email, the protocol is to email Ryan. Ryan will manually put that into the system. And when he does that, now all code compliance has that information as well as the police department has that information, right? So you go out there, you can look it up. Have we been to this house before? If we have, does it warrant a citation at this point?

2:18:26 So I think that's important. That was an important step that we implemented to get the two entities, this code compliance and this code compliance who live outside in different buildings to come together to work together. And how long ago was that implemented? What do you think about a couple months ago when we talked in the station? About a couple months ago or so. So the code compliance at town code compliance versus PD code compliance.

2:18:54 Telecom compliance has had the ability with data ticket and stuff like that. This portion of what we're doing and sharing information, I wasn't aware of until Ryan brought it up. He said, hey, this is a great idea. Why don't we do this so both entities will be able to share the same information? So we've started doing that within the last couple months. Okay. Thank you. I just want to let you all finish your presentation, but I do want to see if there are questions from council.

2:19:23 Yes, that's the end of our presentation. Obviously, we can answer any questions from the council or the public. Okay, Mayor Pro Tem, right? I have a question. Do we have plans for more aggressive public education? I guess I've seen in Colorado, different mountain towns have more messaging on dumpsters that bears...

2:19:51 We'll get into this. You know, like with a picture of a bear in a dumpster saying, like, you need to lock this. I think the specific message, it was like, oh, you know, don't put this bear's life in danger because you're in a hurry. Lock the dumpster. Something like that. So just my question is, do we have more plans for, like, more aggressive public education?

2:20:14 I think, you know, we've got, we've always, we're always looking at opportunities, right? It came to me the other day, and I'm not sure who provided it, but there was a program that they had seen elsewhere where it was an educational program with all of the restaurants, and they were, they could actually achieve a certification that they could probably display in their windows to say that they were, you know, trained and could execute.

2:20:35 The bear safe environments, if you will, from their activities. And so I think we're always looking for that, right? I mean, what's not present in this discussion, because it's really around trash, is all the other effort we're doing with our host programs up in the lake space and where visitors get to probably interact more closely with the wildlife. And there's pamphlets, handouts.

2:20:57 All kinds of things that we're talking about in that space. But this one's really focused more on trash in that. But we're open to modifying our systems continuously. You know, we talked about the Third Eye program is what is called from the Mammoth Disposal Vehicles, which can take a picture and report back to us that, hey, this was overflowing or this problem at this particular site. And we've just now, we meet with...

2:21:23 Mammoth Disposal on a monthly basis. We're going to include Mike Marder in that conversation. And so we have that agenda item in there to discuss how we can better integrate those programs. So we're constantly evolving it. And I think if there are good examples of signage and other things like that, we would definitely implement those as well. Okay, thank you. And then I also wanted to say, I think this summer I noticed, like at parking for Main Lodge, you know, there was a sign that said, like, don't leave food in cars. You know, I thought that was...

2:21:53 Good that we did that, you know, because I feel like there's, you know, a lot of education that people that are up here visiting don't really know that you shouldn't leave any scented items in your cars. That's true. I mean, there was a particular issue going on up at Main Lodge and a lot of people who were, I think, out for multiple days on hikes and so forth were perhaps leaving stuff in there. But I do want to make a point about smells in cars. I heard recently of a story in town where someone had gone to Pizza,

2:22:22 And I think some of the incidents can also be attributed to that. It's not necessarily carelessness with food in the car. It's just the fact that something that was quite

2:22:52 Smelly came out of the car, if you will. But do you have anything else to add in there? The pizza was good and it did no damage somehow. I have comments, no questions. Okay, we'll do John and then you and then. Brent, you've got to say something. But we're going to go to Council Member Wentworth and Council Member Souser. Go ahead. Thank you. So this program is to be implemented with the entire municipal boundary of the town, correct? Yes, absolutely. Okay, so the map we looked at, sort of, you know, the...

2:23:23 UGB kind of focused. My question is, what are you going to do with dumpsters that are not, like, owned by a private person? What if it's a Forest Service dumpster? What if it's a permittees dumpster? There's a dumpster right now, the Lake Murray Road closure in the parking lot. I've never seen a dumpster there before, but there's a dumpster there. What's the plan to deal with those types of more challenging? They would all be under the same criteria.

2:23:48 Honestly, we have no problem issuing citations in that space. I think the dumpster you're speaking of, I talked to Lawson a little bit about that. They're trying to get that up there, get that removed. That's not supposed to be there. And I think that the Forest Service kind of closed the basin on us a little quick. They closed it Saturday night at 5 and notified us, I think, Monday sometime that it was closed. But we're working on getting that out of there.

2:24:13 But if there is any particular agency or permittee or anyone who's creating the problem, they will hear from our court enforcement folks in that space. Okay, then to the town attorney, can the town hold the U.S. Forest Service accountable for cleaning up their trash? That might be a struggle, but I think the dialogue would be the best approach. Okay, you can practice your yappity-yap. Let's see if we can do it. I'm good at that, John. Okay, good. Thank you.

2:24:43 A couple of things, and Nolan, you create a great point that I was going to bring up on my own. I've had bears get into my vehicles, my old service vehicle, if any of you ever saw what it looked like, there was no food in it. They found nothing, they left. Bears get habituated to finding things in certain places. The last time they broke in my house, they went through the bedroom window. There's no food left out in my bedroom.

2:25:05 And we seem to have a group in town who criticize as soon as a bear gets in a car, you left food in the car. No, I didn't leave food in the car. Yes, it may have smelled. I do eat in my car on occasion. I also eat in my house. So, you know, bears may find that. I'm not going to change my eating habits for that. So I want to say that, and I wrote this down here, that discretion.

2:25:30 It's probably the most important tool we have in our toolbox for this. I would hate to see every time a dumpster gets opened, because you don't know who left it open or how it left open, somebody immediately gets a citation. If it doesn't get cleaned up, yes. But discretion. What is going on? Why is it going on? I have full faith in our officers and town staff who enforce these things. So if there's a habitual problem, that gets dealt with. But the one-off.

2:25:59 I have a dumpster in front of my house because my wife and sister won't let me get rid of it. But I leave it open and people put their poop bags in it. They put their cans in it when they walk down the street. Without it there, or if I lock it, then I find that stuff on my street. So it's a public service that I don't put a padlock on it. And there are many places on my street that do the same thing. So discretion is where we need to be with this.

2:26:29 Not, you know, cut and dry. As far as our education, the better our education is, and it has been great the last few years, the fewer bears we see in town. If you look at what Department of Fish and Wildlife showed us in their presentation, our bears are now ranging natural bear habitat. They're going into the glass mountains. They're not just staying in town. We appear to have the same number of bears, but as our education goes up, you're going to see them less and less often.

2:26:59 You're going to see them less often in the daytime. So everything we're doing is working. I would hate to see us do a knee-jerk reaction and start immediately giving everybody a ticket because somehow that is seemingly going to help. I think our education is working. Our bears are going back to a little more natural behavior. It will never be completely natural because we are a cornucopia of food for them from our flowers to our grass to our trash.

2:27:28 Bill, if I may address a few things. I know you said you leave your dumpster open. What you meant is it's carabiner closed. It's just not locked. It's carabiner closed, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so sometimes somebody will come along and open it and throw in their poop bag, and I appreciate that. Yeah. And then they won't get it re-locked. I do also want to address, you know, the discretion. I appreciate those comments because, you know, the folks that are dispensing and reviewing the incidents are, I think,

2:27:55 Providing appropriate level of discretion. When we went through the municipal code changes, part of that was driven by the fact that prior to making those modifications, we really weren't able to issue citations because of the fact that it's sort of a communal issue and a communal problem. And we really...

2:28:17 An imperfect solution is to get much more aggressive on the owner or whomever has the contract for that particular trash receptacle because at some point additional level of work, additional level of security on the trash receptacles themselves would be the desire because I think we as a community need to find a way to, you know, get the bears out of the trash even more than we've had.

2:28:44 And so that was, we did get a little heavy-handed in that. I think these guys are appropriately managing the system, but the goal would be to heighten that focus on it and make sure that we do have a meaningful change, I think is the opportunity that we took there. And I will be the first to say it's imperfect because of all the things that you described about how anybody can walk up and do that, but maybe we have to make decisions on.

2:29:07 Whether to have that receptacle there, whether to move it, and maybe lock it into something that is not even a receptacle that's available for someone. So we're not there yet, but I think we're continuing to work in the right space. Councilmember Truax, any questions or comments? No, but my first portion is, Nolan, did you order anchovies on that pizza? Because they're really good to attract.

2:29:34 I just want to say I appreciate everybody's efforts and particularly the town staff efforts to tackle this situation and to make sure that we're cognizant of the challenges that we had and attentive to the items that need to be addressed to make sure we're being a good steward of the town and for Bayer's health and well-being. And I just had, is that, thank you. I just had,

2:30:04 One question. I am curious because I read the weekly calls for service and it did feel like there were a lot of calls for service for bears this summer. It was all different things, but there were enough that were around trash. And I'm just curious, total in 2025, how many citations have been issued? And I think that would be for code compliance, correct? Because it wouldn't come from the PD.

2:30:33 About 50 cases in the last two years that were, in my case, tracking. Ten notices were issued and four fines were issued. Okay. So it is, and has that increased in the, well, because when did we change the code? Like how, what's the period of time that you've been able to even issue? And it was possible to issue citations with the old code just citing any nuisance, not trash spills specifically.

2:31:02 But it's much better now that we can decide to trash specifically. Okay. And I guess you sort of answered my question, but do you feel that the change in the ordinance has taken away some of the barriers that you all felt like you experienced in the past? Yes. Okay. Thank you. All right. Is there any public comment on this item? Anyone online?

2:31:28 All right. Well, thank you very much for all of your efforts. You know, we all want the same thing. We want to protect the wildlife who visits our community to try to get our trash, and it's, you know, incumbent on all of us to do everything we can to make it so that they stay wild bears like Bill referenced. So thank you all. I know everyone in the town cares a lot about this, and your efforts are really appreciated. All right.

2:31:57 We are moving on to item 9.2. I would like to ask a point of privilege of a two-minute break, just so I can take a bio break. All right. We are reconvening with item 9.2. This is to receive a presentation and discuss the draft multi-jurisdictional local hazard mitigation plan. Thank you. Good evening, council members. Mayor Bubzer, I'm Pam Kobylarz, assistant to the town manager. And Nolan Bobroff is going to be assisting with the presentation tonight.

2:36:13 So this is the Mono County and Town of Mammoth Lakes multi-jurisdictional local hazard mitigation plan update. We're going to refer to it as the LHMP for the rest of this presentation because that one is a bit of a tongue twister. So the reason this is here before you tonight is because we are in the public review draft period of this process.

2:36:37 We spent quite a long time, probably over a year with Mono County and the consultant IEM putting this plan together. And now we have a 30-day public review period, and it's an opportunity for the public to review the completed draft plan, provide any comments that they may have. The contact information to submit your comments is up on the screen, as well as any comments provided tonight will be part of the public record and included in that process as well.

2:37:06 We'll provide the contact information again at the end of the presentation. So a quick rundown of what we're going to be covering here in this presentation. We'll talk about hazard mitigation, why do we do hazard mitigation planning, who was involved in the process, the mitigation plan specifically, and then next steps in the process. Hazard mitigation is any sustained action to reduce or eliminate long-term risk to human life.

2:37:34 I think everyone here is pretty familiar with hazard mitigation in the process, so I won't get into too much detail, but I think that graphic does a good job of explaining the importance of hazard mitigation planning and how critical it is to take action on the mitigation side of things as opposed to the response side of things when it comes to emergencies and disasters. A little bit more on that topic, just the benefits of mitigation.

2:38:03 There's kind of four stages to a disaster you can see here in the graphic. Prior to a disaster we work on mitigation and preparedness. Those are really the primary focus of this plan and really the areas where we can make the biggest difference. Once a disaster happens we're really in the response and recovery phase. So, you know, mitigation actions help to break the cycle of...

2:38:28 damage caused by hazards and disasters. It can also, like we mentioned on the previous slide, help to decrease losses.

2:38:38 And, you know, a lot of the mitigation actions have dual or compounding benefits because not only are they helping to make us better prepared for disasters, but they might also help to achieve other community objectives such as completion of certain capital improvements, maybe preserving open space, or even things like increasing economic resiliency. A few examples of hazard mitigation, and I do have another slide where I get into this in more detail as well.

2:39:10 Projects can be all kinds of things. They can be physical development. They can be things like restoring rivers or other types of green spaces or protecting those. Some of the actions we have in the plan include things like bark beetle treatment on trees, anything from small to large scale treatments. Things also could include seismic risk assessments or retrofit projects, defensible space programs.

2:39:38 Developing a community resiliency center which could serve as a hub in an emergency both for an emergency operations center as well as potentially a shelter or a gathering space for people looking for resources or who may be impacted by the disaster.

2:39:58 So hazard mitigation planning, again, that's what we're doing here. This plan describes the participants' vision for the hazard mitigation in their jurisdictions. Specifically, we're talking about the town of Mammoth Lakes, although the plan does also cover Mono County and a number of other special districts, which I'll speak to here shortly. It's also an opportunity to promote partnerships, develop sustainable communities, et cetera.

2:40:24 So why do we need to update the plan? Well, this plan is required by FEMA in order to receive FEMA funding. So it's really critical that we have a current plan. I think it's worthy of mentioning that our actual existing plan is not current. It expired in June of last year. Plans are good for five years. And so when we previously updated this back in 2019, the state guidelines and the FEMA guidelines have changed a little bit in terms of how they

2:40:53 Consider a plan to be current. At that time, if your plan had expired, as long as you were actively in the process of updating the plan for FEMA purposes, it was still considered a valid plan. Unfortunately, they don't evaluate them in that way anymore. And so once the expiration date happens, the plan is expired. It doesn't matter what stage in the update process you might be in. And so we are trying to get this done as soon as we can.

2:41:20 Because we would like to have a current and valid plan again. There are a number of state and federal requirements that have to be included in the plan and the plan also once we're done with this public review period will be sent to Cal OES for review and approval and then it will be sent to FEMA for review and approval and then it will ultimately come back to you for approval as a local plan here. Who's involved?

2:41:49 Mono County and the town are really kind of the lead agencies on this plan. It's a partnership between the two of us. However, one major component of the plan is broad public outreach and participation. So throughout the process, we had a number of public stakeholder meetings, lots of opportunities for the public to get engaged. There was a survey that was out for many months that allowed the public to be able to respond with any types of ideas or concerns, hazards they wanted to make sure were addressed in the plan.

2:42:19 Stakeholders included a very wide variety of groups all throughout Mono County. All the public agencies, as you can imagine, as well as important partners like Whitebark Institute, Mammoth Mountain participated in multiple meetings, ORMAT was there, representatives from the Marine Base up in North County. So it was really a very broad representation with a lot of varying viewpoints and areas of expertise, which was really valuable.

2:42:53 Elaborating on that a little bit, plan participants. So these are people or agencies that are actually going to be adopting this plan. Mono County and Town of Mammoth Lakes, as I mentioned, invitations were sent out to all of the special districts that are located within Mono County. I believe there was maybe about 30 of them altogether who were invited to participate.

2:43:15 The group that you see on the screen are the agencies that did opt in to this process and so they will be adopting this plan as well and they will have their own annex included as part of the plan. I will mention that one kind of pitfall to this process was that a lot of the special districts are small, a lot of them don't have any paid staff and they're really just volunteers helping to keep those.

2:43:42 Districts afloat. And so one of the reasons they chose not to participate was just lack of resources and kind of time to be able to participate and complete the process. So quickly touching on the plan process, we went through the starting a review of the old plan, determining what was still relevant in that plan, what needed to be kept, what is new.

2:44:11 Then moving through to the risk assessment, identifying hazards, identifying kind of what level of risk they have, capability assessment, which includes identifying the capability of the various plan participants in terms of resources, staff, financial, equipment, all those sorts of things go into the capability assessment.

2:44:32 And then what we feel is the most important component of this, the mitigation strategy. So that's the part of the plan that lists all of the various mitigation projects and actions that will help us to be able to be better prepared for hazards and disasters in the future. I have another slide about that where I go into a lot more detail, so I won't touch on that here. And we are here right at the end of mitigation strategy and plan maintenance.

2:45:01 Once the plan is adopted, sorry, one more thing here, Nolan. Once the plan is adopted, each year we will conduct some plan maintenance, which means that we will sit down, review the mitigation actions, just kind of touch base on those things, making sure they're still relevant, updating progress, if progress has been made on any of them, perhaps adding additional mitigation actions or taking mitigation actions out of the plan if they're not relevant anymore.

2:45:29 Not going to go into detail on these, but when we started the process, we did identify a number of goals that we wanted to make sure that the plan achieved. So they're in your packet. I'm not going to read through these. Kind of covered this already as well. A lot of our slides are a little bit redundant, but just...

2:45:49 Talking through the process, we did hold a number of stakeholder meetings. Those were in this room as well as up in Bridgeport, as well as option for virtual attendance. Six planning team meetings, many, many jurisdictions attended, over 70 stakeholders, many of whom I mentioned on the previous slide. The county also engaged their RPACs, which represent various different areas of geography within the county.

2:46:15 And that survey I mentioned was available in both Spanish and English, a total of 154 responses throughout Mono County. We also did a push on social media, a couple of different posts over the last few months about this project there, as well as ads in the paper with links to this survey. So the risk assessment was conducted for the entirety of Mono County. As you're aware, Mammoth Lakes is a very small area of Mono County geographically. We're only about four square miles, whereas the county takes up a

2:46:48 Really large area geographically. So most of the hazards identified in the plan are located in other parts of Mono County. Throughout the assessment, it was identifying the hazards, describing them, making sure they're mapped, making sure that important infrastructure was identified, analyzing impacts, et cetera. In the planning process, we identified 16 different hazard areas.

2:47:18 You'll know that we have two on here that are noted as new. So those are hazard areas that were not included in the 2019 plan. The first is epidemic and pandemic. So as everyone here is aware, we had the COVID-19 emergency in 2020. That happened after the previous plan was adopted. And that was just something that wasn't really on our radar as we went through the planning process for the last plan.

2:47:42 Additionally, we've had a large influx of PSPS events and just other awareness in terms of energy resiliency. So that's something that's highlighted a lot more in this plan than it was in the previous one. Capability assessment, I spoke to this already, so we don't need to go into more detail here. I do want to talk about the mitigation strategy for a moment, though. So the plan as a whole, as I mentioned, is for all of Mono County.

2:48:12 However, each of the participating plan partners have their own annex and that's really the thing that is focused on the town of Mammoth Lakes. So if you do choose to review any of these documents, I would encourage you to focus your energies on that particular document as opposed to the base plan. And each of them, each of us all have our own annex with specific mitigation actions to our jurisdictions.

2:48:37 So the mitigation actions are quite detailed. We are required to have at least one action identified per hazard area. We have many in some of the hazard areas, and we have a lot of mitigation actions that overlap over multiple hazards identified as well.

2:48:54 The plan goes into a lot of detail in terms of estimated cost of each action, potential funding sources, partners who may be able to participate in implementation of various actions, as well as a prioritization matrix that we applied to it. There was a question that came up.

2:49:14 Earlier in the week as well about the after-action report from the 22-23 winter snowstorms, and there was a lot of actions identified in that plan. We have asked the consultant to make sure that those are included in our annex, so we will be going through and reviewing that during this public review period to make sure that those are in there. Types of actions, I mentioned this before, it could be physical things, development, it could be protecting natural habitats, etc.

2:49:46 Plan Maintenance, I also did talk about this, just a little bit more on the annual review.

2:49:52 Each of the plan participants will be responsible for their own plan maintenance, so we'll really be focused on the TOML annex and doing our annual review of that part of the plan. I also want to mention timing. So since this plan is only valid for five years and it takes a couple years to update it, we will be starting this process again in a few years once the plan is adopted. So we really don't have a lot of time between plan adoption and...

2:50:21 And then starting the planning process again for the next round. Next steps, the plan can be accessed there. I also previously emailed you the links to both the base plan and the annex as well as them being part of the staff report for this item. Mentioning again Casey Garnett's contact information, she is our primary consultant contact and she's...

2:50:47 Collating and consolidating all of the public comments for us. However, if you wanna email Nolan or me, that is also fine and we can make sure those comments get to the correct place. Deadline for comments is December 7th, at which time we'll be finalizing the plan with the hope of getting it over to Cal OES early in the new year.

2:51:07 That is all I have. Questions? Like I said, Nolan's here. Hayes was heavily engaged in this whole planning process as well. And Alice from the fire department was really engaged in the process. And they're also planned participants. So any questions for any of us, we're happy to answer those. Thank you. Questions? My only question, and I think you answered when we expect this to be back fully accepted. Sure. So this... The fact that it isn't accepted yet, how does that affect...

2:51:37 That's a great question. Potentially we're not eligible to receive FEMA funding or FEMA reimbursement without having this plan in place. So time is of the essence. Like I mentioned, it will get routed to Cal OES first. They have up to 45 days to review it. FEMA also has up to 45 days to review it. So I would anticipate maybe an April time frame to bring it back here for final approval. Other questions?

2:52:11 Rob, how was the feel about this? They feel it was burdensome to put all this together. I think it's been quite a long time to go through and sort of spend hours in meetings thinking about all the calamities that could possibly happen with regard to this process. I think we felt initially that there was, you know, a vulnerability of not having it with real change, as was said earlier. And so there was a high degree of urgency to get this accomplished. And, you know, we did...

2:52:42 I can't stress enough, the meetings that we had in these rooms, the whole room was full of responders and other people, I think maybe even some of you took advantage of those meetings. But I think with what we have here, we think it's comprehensive, right? I mean, you saw the list of disasters that were sort of reviewed, plans to mitigate those impacts, all discussed in detail.

2:53:08 I think there's confidence in the plan itself being thorough, and, you know, it's something that will help us. Thank you. Councilmember Truax, any questions or? No, I participated in some of the meetings, so I put my input during those time frames. Any, I don't, no questions for you. So is there any public comment on this item? Anyone online? No, then.

2:53:43 Thank you so much. I think next steps are that if we want to submit comments, it's to you or Nolan or directly through the process. It would be individual council members inputting comments, right? The council as a body doesn't need to respond. I don't think there's any need for that unless the council feels really strongly that something is not addressed that you want to see addressed in the plan. Thank you. It looked quite comprehensive to me. So thank you for all of your efforts on this. Thank you. All right.

2:54:12 Then moving along, we are up to the consent agenda. So are there any items that anyone wants to pull from consent? Councilmember Truax? No? Councilmember Truax is now in front of a fire. So seeing none, I will now read the consent agenda. So 10.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of November 5, 2025.

2:54:39 10.2, approve the resolution authorizing the removal of real property located at 165 Old Mammoth Road, Unit 53 in the Sierra Manors Condominium Complex from the rental market and authorizing the sale of the unit under the Town's Housing Now Bridge Program. 10.3, continue approval of emergency contract for town yard waste oil tank replacement and 10.4, accept check register from 10.325 in the amount of $439,607.75.

2:55:08 And check register from 11-625 in the amount of $1,542,269.81. Do I have a motion? So moved. Second? So seconded. All right. So, Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Salzer? Burke. Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bobser? Yes. Mayor Bobser? Yes. All right. Moving along.

2:55:37 It is now time for us to hold a public hearing for the consideration of an appeal of the October 8, 2025 Planning and Economic Development Commission decision to approve the 54 Mono Street Apartments entitlement application consisting of use permit 24-003, design review 24-006, and adjustment 25-005. So I will now open the public hearing. Madam Mayor.

2:56:05 Yes? If I may, I have to recuse from this. I have been told my property is in too close proximity to this lot. I had heard that might be possible. All right, we will see you when you return from the penalty box. Thank you. All right, so I have opened the public hearing, and so now there will be a statement and presentation by staff. Actually, as Gina is getting the presentation ready.

2:56:44 Andy, did you want to make a brief statement on just the role with the appeal? Just some housekeeping items for the council and for the benefit of the audience. So the town's development code or zoning code has some rules that government appeals that apply to this appeal. One of the rules is that no new evidence can be presented at this hearing that hasn't already been presented unless the council finds that it was simply not available to the party trying to present the evidence.

2:57:13 If there's a tie vote by the council, and there are only four of you participating in this, the appeal will be deemed denied and the decision of the PEDC will stand. That's in our code as well. The council, unless you have a tie vote, the council is required to take action by resolution. There is a draft resolution to pack it that would deny the appeal and uphold the PEDC's decision. There are findings in that resolution to support that conclusion.

2:57:41 If the Council is of a mind to go the other way and to grant the appeal and overturn the findings of the PEDC, what you would want to do is tie those findings to the inverse of the findings for upholding the PEDC that are set forth in that resolution. So as we go through, you might take a look at that. There are findings for CEQA, there are findings for approving the use permit that's part of the application, findings for the design review, and then findings for something called an adjustment.

2:58:10 And so if you think that any of those findings cannot be made, that could be evidence to not uphold the PDC determination. And as always, it bears reminding for the public and for the council that the council's role is not to decide is this a good project or a bad project, not to decide is this a project that you would like to see next to your house. The council's role is really to decide whether it meets the town standards and above all whether the findings can or cannot be made. Thank you.

2:58:46 Okay. Good evening, Council. Okay, so an application for a use permit major design review and adjustment was submitted for a six-unit multifamily residential apartment project subject to the town's density bonus ordinance. The item was originally scheduled for a public hearing at the August 13, 2025 PADC meeting. However,

2:59:07 Due to concerns regarding the access easement between 54 and 56 Mona Street, the meeting was continued to the October 8, 2025 PDC hearing, in which the project was approved by a 4-0 vote. On October 21, 2025. Huh? New slide? Okay. Sorry.

2:59:35 On October 21st, 2025, the property owners of 56 Motor Street submitted an appeal of the PDC decision. The appeal was timely filed within the 15-day period following the project approval. And for today's meeting, I'll provide a quick overview of the project and a summary of staff's response to the topics raised in the appeal.

2:59:55 The project is located on a 0.25 acre vacant parcel in the residential multifamily one zone. The adjacent parcels on the north, south, east, and west sides are also zoned as RMF1. There are multifamily developments to the north, east, and west of the project and a single family home to the south. The proposed use is a multifamily residential

3:00:19 Development, which is consistent with the general plan because the property is located within the high density residential one land use designation allowing residential multi-unit townhomes, condominiums, and apartments. The base density for an RMF1 site is 12 units per acre or three units in this case. However, the town density bonus increases it to six units. The original subdivision of the former lot

3:00:44 into the two parcels that are now 5456 Motor Street was approved by Town Council in 1990 under entitlement tentative parcel map 36-158 and the conditions of approval included that the two parcels shall be limited to and share a single driveway within the 30-foot easement.

3:01:02 That a one-foot non-access strip along Mono Street extending southward from the proposed shared access easement to the southern property line be dedicated to the town to prevent any other access to the parcels and to further affirm the intended shared access. And that a utility easement for 56 Mono Street be created through 54 Mono Street.

3:01:22 However, the resulting final parcel map recorded in February 1992 inaccurately describes the shared access easement as an exclusive access easement and failed to record a utility easement for 56 Mono. This has led the neighbors to the west to contend that the 54 Mono site cannot use the easement area for access since they contend that the easement is exclusively for their use. Oh, sorry. The town staff

3:01:51 I disagree with this argument because although the recorded parcel map does not accurately reflect the conditions of approval for TPM 36-158, the conditions are still in effect and limit the access for both parcels to the shared access easement. The proposed apartment project consists of six multifamily dwelling units within a single structure at 54 Mona Street. The project features one level of understructured parking for seven vehicles and an exterior parking area for three vehicles.

3:02:24 The application includes a request to permit double density on the site for three additional dwelling units through the town's density bonus ordinance. The density bonus request requires a minimum of three of the six units to be deed restricted for workforce housing. However, the applicant has agreed to deed restrict all six of the units in exchange for four concessions, one automatic concession and three additional. The four concessions include an increase in lot coverage from a maximum of 50% to 60%.

3:02:53 A 20% reduction in the south side yard and front yard setback, a reduction of one guest parking space to allow for a total of two guest parking spaces, and to waive the requirement to provide private 60 square feet of outdoor open space for each unit. To ensure the project will remain as occupancy-restricted units, a workforce housing agreement shall be executed by the property owner and the town prior to CFO.

3:03:19 Of the six units, four are one-bedroom apartments and two or three-bedroom apartments. Additionally, an adjustment is requested to allow for one of the guest parking spaces to be located within the front setback. So here's the site plan of the project, which includes three exterior parking spaces, two of which are covered by an overhang and one which is located in the front setback, a trash enclosure, ADA access to the first floor unit, and the project will be providing 43% on-site snow storage.

3:03:54 Prior to the CFO, the applicant will provide a snow management plan to address the remaining snow storage, which is allowed pursuant to the density bonus program. You can also note the 30-foot wide access easement that is located along the northern border of the property, in which the proposed structure and exterior parking spaces are all located outside of. Excuse me, can I interrupt you for a second? Could you demonstrate using your cursor the relationship of the 30-foot easement to the parking spaces?

3:04:26 Say that again. So can you demonstrate on the exhibit where the 30-foot easement is and the relationship of that 30-foot easement to the parking spaces? Sure, so the 30-foot easement is here on the top portion of the screen here. It's along the northern edge of the site. 56 Mono is here to the west. And then the parking spaces.

3:04:57 The outside parking spaces are between the proposed structure and 30-foot easement, so in the area shown here. Then you have the garage, the access to the understructure of parking and approximately this level. Okay, thank you. Okay. So the appeal that was submitted by the property owners of 56 Mona Street consists of seven topic areas.

3:05:30 Seven topic areas. The following are summaries of each topic and the staff response to the topic raised. Additional details can be found in the staff report. The first issue raised in the appeal is that allowing 54 Mona Street to share the easement conflicts with the recorded easement rights and is in violation.

3:05:50 Staff's response is that the condition of approval which states that the 56 Mono Street and 54 Mono Street shall share a single driveway and that a utility easement is required for 56 Mono Street are still legally in effect. The language used in the recorded easement does not override the conditions of approval set forth in the 1990 tentative parcel map approval. Second topic.

3:06:13 And the appeal argues that errors in municipal record keeping have led to inaccurate legal descriptions of both 56 and 54 Mona Street properties. And staff's response is that the town is not responsible for the record keeping of the legal descriptions or the recorded easements. The conditions of approval set forth in the 1990 tentative parcel map remain legally binding despite errors in legal descriptions of both properties.

3:06:42 The appeal argues that the conditions of approval for TPM 36-158 were never fully satisfied or paid by the original applicant and therefore should be invalidated. And staff's response is that the final parcel map was filed and recorded with the county on February 13, 1992, thereby executing the tentative parcel map in a timely manner. Because the tentative parcel map was executed, the conditions of approval legally bind both current and future property owners.

3:07:13 The appeal argues that the proposed development interferes with 56 Monash Street utilities and the owner of 54 Monash Street is responsible for its relocation. Staff's response is that the appeal topic is a civil matter and is not relevant to any requirement for the development of 54 Monash Street per the municipal code or the TPM 36-158 conditions of approval.

3:07:39 Also, condition of approval number 43 is included in the Town Council resolution and requires the applicant to record a utility easement in favor of 56 Mono Street on the 54 Mono Street property prior to issuance of a building permit. The fifth topic argues that the project plans contradict the parcel map language, which references an exclusive easement. The appeal proposes dividing the existing easement lengthwise, creating two distinct driveways.

3:08:10 And staff's response is that the conditions of approval set forth in the 1990 tentative parcel map remain legally binding despite errors in the legal descriptions of both properties. And while an alternative solution, such as splitting the easement, may be possible, town staff cannot force the 54 Mono Street property owner to consider splitting the driveway, nor can staff confirm that the design would work. Renegotiating the existing easement between 56 and 54 Mono Street is a civil matter.

3:08:39 That is not pertinent to the conditions of approval for the 54 Monash Street development. Number six argues that town council should intervene to ensure permanent correction of the town's easement records. Staff's response is that the easements to the town benefit are accurately recorded. The town is not responsible for correcting or recording easements between two private property owners, and therefore topic six remains a civil matter. And then the final topic,

3:09:10 Argues that all permits should be suspended until the easement, title, and utility conflicts are resolved and that utilities for 56 Mammoth Street must be established before permits are issued. Staff's response is that the entitlement approval and any preceding building permits cannot be suspended in the project if the project meets all municipal code standards and findings.

3:09:35 Conflicts regarding the utilities, the title, and the easements have been determined to be civil matters and are not matters to be resolved within the purview of the town approval bodies. So with that, staff recommends the town council deny the appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Commission decision and affirm the approval of use permit 24-003, design review 24-006, and adjustment 25-005.

3:10:04 With conditions recommended by staff. Thank you. So now we will have this statement and presentation by the property owner or appellant. Good evening, Mayor and Council, staff. My name's Keith. I'm here with my wife, Kimberly. We're the owners of 56 Mono Street, which is also an RMM, whatever, a triplex, which could be turned into a sixplex one day. And is this thing on? Yeah.

3:10:49 So we're not here to stop this project, but we're here to maintain our driveway and our access and not share it with maybe a triplex in 1990, but a sixplex now sharing this driveway, we're not going to have it. I want to thank you for your work and we appreciate what you guys do and tonight I realized how much you do and fantastic job. So we're here tonight because this

3:11:21 Project on 54 directly affects our property rights, specifically our recorded exclusive easement, and the planning department has treated this easement as shared, and this is not correct and can't be allowed to stand. I want to keep this simple. Our property has a recorded exclusive easement across the north 30 feet of 54 Mono.

3:11:49 It's in the parcel map. It's in our grant deed. And it's existed for decades. And nothing gives the town the authority to reinterpret an exclusive easement as shared. A public agency cannot override or redefine a recorded exclusive easement. It is only for our use. Under California law, civil code 801, 803, and 845,

3:12:20 Recorded easements are binding and cannot be changed, limited, reinterpreted without the owner's consent. Kim and I own this easement. Under California law, Civil Code 801, 803, and 804, did I already read this? Recorded easements are binding and cannot be changed. Here's what makes this more troubling.

3:12:50 Our attorney, our title insurance investigation team, and the Mono County Assessor all reached the same conclusion. The two documents that the town's relying on, the 1990 draft memo and the 2023 private letter are not valid and non-enforceable. The 1990 memo was never adopted, never signed and expired.

3:13:19 Because of the sloppy paperwork, but that's not our fault. And the 92 parcel map recorded different language, the language that granted us the exclusive easement. The 2023 letter was never recorded, never agreed to by us, the owners of the easement, and never...

3:13:43 Entered any public record, a private letter cannot erase or rewrite a recorded property right. The assessor's office confirmed that the property rights must match the recorded documents and the recorded easement is exclusive and still in full force. The title insurance investigation reached the same conclusion. An expired draft memo, tentative map,

3:14:15 And an unrecorded private letter cannot override a legally recorded easement. So when these two invalid documents are suddenly used decades later to reinterpret something as serious as an easement, it doesn't just raise legal questions, it raises questions about fairness and proper process. Approving any project that interferes with the recorded easement violates several laws, including government code,

3:14:46 66436, Subdivision Map Act. Private easements must be respected in project approvals. Civil Code 801, 803, and 845, recorded easements are binding. Civil Code 1007, easement rights cannot be terminated without the owner's consent. We want to understand how this application

3:15:17 Got so far while ignoring our recorded rights. Did your title company show you the easing? Did they tell you it was exclusive? Or did someone just say, oh, don't worry about it. The town will take care of it. Because if that promise was made, that's a real problem. We shouldn't be the ones paying the price for this.

3:15:52 Kim and I are long-time residents. We've provided and supported workforce housing for decades. But we cannot and will not sit by while exclusive rights are reinterpreted, ignored, or pushed aside. We're not going away until this is resolved. We're asking for one simple, reasonable thing. The town must acknowledge and honor the recorded exclusive easement.

3:16:18 And remove all invalid staff documents from the record. Thank you. Thank you. All right. So now is time for questions from town council. So who would like to go first? Oh, I see a hand up on the Zoom. Yes, this is attorney Hanif Herji. I represent the owners of

3:16:54 Lot 54, and I'm going to have to leave in about 15 minutes, and I was hoping I could have five minutes of the time of the distinguished council persons before I have to leave, so I can just give you a quick five minute overview of my thoughts on this matter. Yes, please proceed. Thank you so much. So, in here, the appellant asks you to basically stop the project

3:17:24 While the issue of the easement as to who's allowed to use a driveway is determined. But this dispute has been going on for over three to four years. My client is a recent owner of lot 54 and for three to four years, lot 56 has not taken any steps to enforce their position.

3:17:52 So why had they not filed anything in court? It's very simple. Any court of law

3:18:22 will laugh the appellant out of the court for the following reason. The easement was granted on lot 54's property. So, lot 54 is a servient property whose property was basically allocated for the use so that lot 56, which was landlocked, could have ingress and egress.

3:18:51 And the law is 100% clear that a servient property can use the easement because it's their property concurrently with the landlocked property and the landlocked property cannot stop the servient property from also using the property for ingress and egress. Of course, the servient property cannot take actions such as build a wall.

3:19:20 That now doesn't allow for the landlord parcel to use the easement for the purpose of the driveway. So first, the law is completely against lot 56. It's absolutely clear that lot 54 that owns that property, even though there's an easement on it, can have concurrent reasonable use that does not conflict

3:19:48 with the use of Lot 56. And the project that's been approved by the City Planning Department clearly shows that Lot 56 right to use the easement for ingress and egress will not be eliminated, modified, or changed. The law that I'm citing to, and I'll actually give you a cite of a case, is Gray v. McCormick, 163 Cal App.

3:20:18 4th, 772, 2008 case that states the Serviett Estate is not restricted from also using the easement land so long as they don't obstruct the landlock property from using it simultaneously. The law is further enhanced by the fact that the tentative parcel map conditions of approval clearly states shared driveway.

3:20:47 So now there's only the issue of this ambiguous language, what does exclusive use mean as written on the map, which is not on the conditions of the approval and which would be completely contrary to the case law and the state law of California. In my opinion, the person who wrote that on the map meant that the ingress and egress used by lot 56

3:21:16 is exclusively for their use, meaning they cannot now let parcel number 55 or 52 or 53 start using that easement for ingress and egress purposes also just because they're entitled to use it. So I have a feeling was there a problem in whoever drafted it? Did they make it ambiguous? Sure. But if you look at a reasonable interpretation of what exclusive means,

3:21:44 That means 56 is the only parcel allowed to use that ingress and egress right that lot 54 granted. It does not under the law prohibit lot 54 from also using that easement concurrently. The conditions state it's a shared driveway. The law completely favors lot 54. So we cannot take ambiguous language.

3:22:13 That Lot 56 has not for the last four years taken any action to have a judicial adjudication of the issue and now come into the council meeting and ask the council to completely stop development of 54 while they decide if they will or will not file a legal action against Lot 54's owners, maybe in 2026, maybe 2027.

3:22:42 Maybe in 2040. Does that mean that every time Lot 54 tries to develop their property, Lot 56 is going to come and say, yeah, we've been sitting on our rights for many years, but dear council persons, please just deny it until we get some sort of adjudication on the matter. If they want adjudication, the courts are open. It's a civil matter. And this plan that's been approved by the planning department

3:23:10 Does not once again in any shape or form deny store, I'm sorry, lot 56 from the continued use of the easement. And I truly appreciate the council person who asked to be shown where the parking is in relation to that easement for ingress and egress. And the plans clearly show that neither the building nor the parking in any way encroach on that easement.

3:23:37 So these are the only points I wanted to make and I wanted you to keep that in your mind as you reach a decision and we hope that you realize that the planning department was correct in granting approval and that Lot 56, while they may not like it, do not have a legal basis in court to deny Lot 54 from using the easement also. The conditions of approval are also very clear. Numerous documents.

3:24:03 Drafted by the city attorney and the city itself clearly state that the driveway is going to be shared. So just one minor ambiguity on a map should not be the controlling factor, especially when that ambiguity is head-on in conflict with the laws of California when it comes to the use of easement by the Serbian estate, which would be law 54.

3:24:28 I thank you very much. I'm happy to stay on if you have any questions directed to me. If not, then I'm going to go ahead and move on because I have to be at another meeting at 8 o'clock that I need to drive to. Are there any questions for the... Go ahead, Council Member Wentworth. So I have questions for our attorney. In this proceeding...

3:24:50 The only other time, I've been on the council now for about a decade, that the council's been serving in some, any kind of a, sort of a, with a legal authority would have to do with TOT disputes and TOT appeals, in which you've advised us that we're acting in that, in that type of a, that type of a capacity. Are we acting in that type of a capacity here, or is this different?

3:25:12 No, you are. When the council makes law, when you're adopting ordinances and you're establishing policies for the town, you're acting in a legislative capacity. When you're making a decision that is in the nature of almost acting like a judge, you're acting in what's called a quasi-adjudicative capacity, and that's what you're doing here. Okay. The next question is the issue about

3:25:35 In our capacity right now, the relationship between the resolution of a civil dispute, it's pretty obvious there is a civil dispute going on here. It's referenced in the staff support that it's not been resolved. What is the relationship of an unresolved civil dispute to any decision we might make here this evening? I think that a civil dispute is something that's entirely between the parties and it should not affect the town council's analysis. The council's role is to decide whether

3:26:05 A particular project or application meets the town's standards and whether the findings to approve it or deny it can be made. I think that ultimately, unless the parties can work things out, I think that the dispute they have is best resolved by a judge. I'm not sure that the council is really in the best position to make a legal determination about the nature of the rights of the easement. But I will also say that if the town council decides to deny the appeal and uphold the PEDC's decision, that is not...

3:26:34 Itself taking away any easement rights. It would be for the property owners to decide whether there's been a trespass upon the easement rights, and it's not until and unless the 54 Mono owner builds something and attempts to use the easement in a way that the 56 Mono owners think may violate their rights. It's not until then that there's any

3:26:58 Potential calling into question of the easement. But the council's decision, the council's action, the town's action, I don't think trespasses upon easement rights. It's only the action of the parties. Okay, so what if it's clear that there is a conflict, there's a dispute, and if it's clear that the nature of that dispute could have an effect on the findings that are presented here,

3:27:27 That could be the grounds for a vote of an individual council member to say, look, if this dispute continues on into the project, it's going to call into question the findings that have been made by the staff. Could you speak to that? Yes. I mean, I think that if you decide that some of the findings cannot be made and you think that that will influence how you vote, I mean, I think that that's fair.

3:27:57 I do think it's fair to question what's the outcome? How long does this go on? And to that point, a continuation of this item, which is an option, I believe. I understand this evening this could be continued. That's an option. It can be continued, but I would say that it cannot be continued indefinitely. Okay, so then the other question is to what degree can the town compel?

3:28:23 The holders of various rights in this dispute to initiate legal action or to get together and try to figure this thing out so the council's not in a position of memorializing a conflict that could undermine the findings that have been presented. The town cannot compel the parties to engage in litigation. The town cannot compel the parties to talk to each other. You can encourage them to do so, but you cannot compel them. That's good. Thank you.

3:28:56 Certainly, but I want to just get through the first round of questions for the council because I believe wouldn't this be during the part where there's additional testimony or a rebuttal? And Andy, I'm looking to you for this. Well, we've gone slightly out of order to help the timing of the 54 Mono owner's attorney. Okay. So it might be proper to allow Mr. Rutter to speak on behalf of him.

3:29:25 The other property owners. All right, fair enough. So please approach the podium and state your name. Thank you. My name is Paul Rudder. I'm here to represent the Erickson's. And before I start, I understand how painful this is for the council. The town of Mammoth Lakes has managed to accomplish a great deal of affordable housing, and I think that is incredibly laudable.

3:29:52 Every city and county in California is under an obligation to provide affordable housing. Very, very few cities or counties have met that obligation. Mammoth has probably gone further per capita than any county in the state. And I think the planning department and the town council deserve a great deal of praise for that. I also understand why this project is attractive. It provides a great deal.

3:30:21 of affordable housing, and it does so not at the town's expense. That's a terrific thing nowadays. It's very hard to find that. And so I understand where the planning department was coming from. But we heard from the applicant's attorney how ambiguous this deed is. Let me read you the ambiguous part of the deed. It says it runs through the granting of the parcel.

3:30:50 to the Eriksons. And it says, together with an exclusive access easement over the northerly 30 feet of parcel one of parcel map 36-158. There is no way to construe this as ambiguous. It's absolutely clear that this is an exclusive easement. An exclusive easement in California gives the holder of the easement the benefited parcel.

3:31:18 The exclusive right to use that property. While it is true that the property is owned by the Servian tenement, the Servian tenement has no right to even step on it and can be arrested for trespass. It is the sole use of that easement when an exclusive easement is granted is for the benefit of the tenement. And that has been going on. This deed is dated 2002.

3:31:48 The property owner who granted this easement had a right to come to court to seek a reformation of the deed and the easement to the extent that it conflicted with what perhaps that property owner intended. Mr. Holler, in his role as town attorney, wrote a letter interpreting the easement as a shared easement.

3:32:15 Just real quick to clarify, Mr. Holler was never the town attorney. He was the town attorney. Exactly my point. Thank you. He was never the town attorney. And his letter apparently seeks to represent himself as some sort of legal counsel, but it was simply wrong. Well, the town attorney was cc'd on that letter. No, I can't. Okay. The point being that there's nothing ambiguous about this.

3:32:42 The property owner and the town had a right to intervene for a period of time after the easement was granted. Three years for reformation. That was over in 2025 or 2026. I'm sorry, 2005 or 2006. We're now 20 years later. This easement belongs to the Eriksons. Counsel for the applicant says, why didn't they take some court action?

3:33:12 They're not obliged to take any court action. They have a perfectly good easement. There's no obligation whatsoever, and there's no California law that says that because it would be beneficial to the town or anyone else or the applicant that the easement should be reinterpreted. The legal basis that the applicant's attorney cites just simply doesn't exist. This easement

3:33:42 is not ambiguous. And to the extent that the town approves this project, which contemplates interfering with the appellant's easement, the town risks an action for slander of title. Now, I know council will poo-poo that. That has happened in Mammoth in the past. Mammoth is still paying for those mistakes. I hope we don't make that mistake here today. The applicant

3:34:12 is entitled to go to court and contest the validity of this exclusive easement. To turn counsel's arguments around, they have had years to do that and have not chosen to do so. 23 years have elapsed since this easement was granted. Nothing has been done by a town or by the property owner, by the new property owner, the old property owner, by any property owner.

3:34:41 This easement is good. And to the extent that anyone trespasses on it, they are at risk of being arrested. So I would ask the town to hold off on granting this. Allow the applicant to go to court and see if his counsel is right. If so, fine. If not, if the town grants this and there is a trespass, then

3:35:11 The easement owners will have to go to court and hold up the project. It's not their goal to hold up the project. Their goal is to have the project occur on the land of property 54. And that's how this project should be built. The town has a little access easement running along Mono Street. The town could wipe away enough of that easement to allow access with a stroke of a pen. It would not be difficult.

3:35:41 There are driveways all up and down Mono Street. This one won't make a difference. And that's the way this project should be built. Thank you. I have one quick question. Certainly. I'm not sure who can answer this, but who pays the property taxes for the easement? Who pays the property taxes for the easement? It's a parcel owner for log 54.

3:36:12 Okay. The easement area is probably not separately assessed, and so the property taxes for it are simply part of the 54 Mono property tax bill. Okay. Thank you. And the payment of property taxes does not interfere with the rights of an easement. I just, that was just my question. Are there any questions? Any other questions? No. Councilmember Truax? No other questions? Not at this time. Thank you. All right.

3:36:46 May I address some Mr. Rudder's statements? Is that allowed? That's up to you, but if you allow the appellant or the appellee's attorney to rebut Mr. Rudder, Mr. Rudder will probably want a chance to rebut him. You know what, I would prefer not to do that because this is starting to feel like the council is being asked to take legal matters and that is not our role, so I would...

3:37:16 Prefer that we don't go down that path. Thank you. No problem. Thank you. All right. Any other questions for staff or Mayor Pro Tem? No. And none. Councilmember Truax, I see you've come off mute. Do you have something that you wanted to ask? No, I do not. Okay. All right. So based on the process then,

3:37:52 I still haven't taken public comment, so would now be the appropriate time to take public comment. All right, is there any public comment from anyone in the room? If you have public comment in the room, please approach the podium, state your name for the record so that everyone can hear, and then our clerk will record. Everyone has five minutes to make their points. Thank you. Hi, my name is Pete Minor. My wife and I have owned 28 Monon Street.

3:38:25 Since 1991. It has a four-plex and a five-bedroom single-family house on it, which for the first ten years was used for workforce housing. I am only rising to talk about this project because my property is directly adjacent to the contested easement.

3:38:54 So the traffic on that easement is going to at least double. There are 10 units. How many cars are in those units? I don't know. There are 10 parking spaces. There will be a direct impact on the quality of life, specifically my bedroom and my dining area are going to be within 15 feet of that easement.

3:39:22 So to say there is no noise or pollution or disturbance to my life is not true. It also will make my property less desirable. But be that as it may, I've lived with the easement that Keith and Kim have been using for 20 years or more. And if there is a way...

3:39:52 That the misinterpretation that has caused the Erickson's to buy the property in the first place, they did their due diligence and they were essentially conned into buying that lot or that house. So that's scary. For the town to say, well, that's too bad.

3:40:20 It's a civil matter. I'm not convinced it is a civil matter. That's kind of not very good. So my only purpose here is to encourage that the town rules that, like somebody stated, there could easily be a separate driveway for the six-unit complex. It's just somebody doesn't like on this type of lot having two entrances.

3:40:51 It doesn't necessarily have to be that way just because it's a law. That's about all I have to say. I thank you for your attention. Thank you. Any other public comment from anyone in the room? My name is Bipin Murari. I'm a 54 Mono owner of the property. I want to just request a town council to, I had give the good proposal to them to how to resolve that, but

3:41:27 If they don't want to do that, then I'm happy to go to the court and we're going to resolve that issue because none of the town council can resolve that, what they're understanding and what the law is. So the law is very clear. Our attorney has also said that, town council attorney has already said that also. They don't want to accept that resolution, then let judge to decide it. But for that, town council can't hold this development.

3:41:55 And I don't want to further continuation because they already, Planning Commission has already take the time and the continuation and they check every single detail with the municipal code and everything. We comply with that. So therefore, I just request that. No continuation. We can resolve this matter with the, they just decided that. Thank you very much. I'm sorry, could you just clarify that? I'm not, I'm not entirely sure what you just said. Well, I just said that is,

3:42:24 This should not be continued because I know you had requested about the continuing doing or not this discussion. This appeal, you have to just say that either you accept or you deny. So what I'm saying here is already the town council has already clear also what your jurisdiction is. And whether we build, doesn't build, it's a different story. It is an issue of the easement of exclusivity.

3:42:55 If their understanding and our understanding is different right now, they don't want to accept what that interview map condition is, then only somebody can decide it, which is the judge. Correct. So you would not be interested in the counsel continuing this item until you, what I'm hearing from you is your willingness perhaps to go to court with a judge to resolve the issue of this easement.

3:43:25 And what you're saying is you're not interested in the good council continuing this matter until that question is resolved. Is that right? Yes, because that means the council is trying to stop the project. Well, perhaps. Those are your words. I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Yes, thank you. Jamie, was there any public comment online? Is there anyone else in the room who would like to give public comment? Oh, online, we have a hand up.

3:43:58 Hi. Okay. My name is Brent Cooley. I've worked with, been in town about 20 years or in the Eastern Sierra and have worked with Diffin for quite a long time and am kind of part of this project here. And I'd just like to clarify on this that even my research, I'm no attorney or anything, but my research states the same thing that our attorney said, that essentially

3:44:29 This matter will be resolved in our favor anyway. It would be, I think, from what Bippen is saying is to let the Planning Commission's approval stand and we will resolve this with the other property owners either through mutual consent between each of us or through the legal process in the local courts. I don't necessarily, and this is just my opinion.

3:44:56 That I don't believe it's really the town council's position right now to take any sides on that matter. And as long as we have met the obligations of the town's planning rules, this should move forward. Excuse me, could you just clarify your relationship to the project? I'm just not clear what your relationship is to all this. Yeah, I've been the general manager with the hotel that Bippen owns in town for

3:45:26 18 years, and we work closely together on everything, and obviously when he goes into building this, and it's for workforce housing for the hotel, that obviously I'll be involved with that very closely. Okay, thank you. All right, thank you. So I don't see anyone else approaching the podium. Go ahead. You may give your public comment. Okay. My name's Kim. I'm Keith's wife and one of the owners of 56.

3:45:58 I just want to address a few things that were brought up. We haven't known about this project for two or three or four years, like Bippen's attorney has mentioned. We learned about it on August 1st and came to an August 13th planning department meeting. So that was a really wild accusation. But anyways, I do want to thank you guys. You guys work your butts off. I can't believe we're here this late. This is pretty impressive.

3:46:27 And I really appreciate your time and all that you do for this town and especially affordable and workforce housing. I know Keith and I address it daily as landlords here. We totally get it and really appreciate that and appreciate your hard work. When we purchased our triplex in 2002, the sole condition of our escrow was that our driveway access remain exclusive, exactly as promised by the seller. That protection was recorded in our deed on September 4, 2002.

3:46:58 It's the only reason we purchased the property. Yet 23 years later, the same seller promised Mr. Morari he could use our driveway as shared for his over-ambitious project, relying on a 2023 letter from former town manager Dan Holler and to ignore the exclusive access easement recorded on the county parcel map. Both the 90s condition approval letter or the 90s whatever, the town memo

3:47:28 From 1990, saying it was a shared driveway and then never got followed through with. And Holler's 2023 letter had been reviewed by our attorney, the assessor, and our title insurance team all confirmed that neither document has any legal force and cannot override our easement. This 1990 conditions letter suddenly appeared after 23 years. And where did it come from? Because it showed up immediately after a buyer backed out of 54 Mono.

3:47:58 The purchase of 54 money because of our exclusive easement. The seller's attorney even asked us in February of 2022 to sign our rights away to make 54 more marketable. I have that in writing from him. He sent us a letter saying a deal fell through, signed this new contract. It was crazy. Then in 2023, Holler's non-binding letter was circulated privately to planning, the town's attorney, the seller's attorney,

3:48:29 And the seller, but never to us. The first time we saw it was in here at that meeting on August 13th. The letter was pulled out moments before the commission voted on the project. The last minute disclosure deprived us of any fair opportunity to respond and put our legally recorded rights at a clear disadvantage. Fortunately, the planning commission continued the meeting until a site visit was conducted. And the meeting was continued to October 9th.

3:49:00 Equally serious at that meeting when Keith and I asked planning to honor our property rights and remove the square footage of our driveway from the net buildable area 54 and rerun through the density calculator to see what the project qualifies for, your town's attorney stated on the record that the town has never received, has never removed easements or encumbrances from net buildable acreage and no jurisdiction in California does.

3:49:32 His comments to the commission reminding them to not use their emotions when voting. This sweeping legal claim was made minutes before a non-lawyer commission voted. It's simply not accurate. Both the Mono County General Plan and the town zoning definitions require subtracting easements and rights of way from the net buildable area of a lot. So Keith and I pulled up the meeting the other night after being voted on.

3:50:05 Wanted to hear everything over again. And that portion of the statement had been edited out. A legally incorrect claim influenced a vote and then vanished. At minimum, it undermines transparency. At worst, it materially prejudices our rights. Mammoth is in a housing crisis, and we support all legal solutions. But housing cannot come at the cost of longstanding property rights, fair process, and public trust. If this can happen to us, it can happen to anyone.

3:50:35 Unrecorded documents, last-minute interpretations, and inaccurate legal claims put every property owner at risk. Tonight, we ask the council to take a genuine pause before approving a grossly oversized six-unit development on a .16-acre lot with concessions to reduce parking, remove outdoor personal space, a snow storage removal plan to truck 60% of their snow away. Thanks. Appreciate your time. Or can I keep going? You know what? Finish what you were going to say. All right. Thanks.

3:51:07 Okay. So I know planning has recommended a yes vote for council, but approving this project as is would lock the town into legal conflicts, increase liability, and erode public trust. Until the site plans are corrected, honor our recorded, and our exclusive easement is honored, and the easement is removed from the square footage from the developer's net buildable.

3:51:36 We respectfully request that all permits and approvals be held in place. Anything less advances a project that is on the wrong side of the law and undermines the integrity of Mammoth Lake's planning process. I really appreciate your time, guys. Thank you. All right. So is it reasonable to close the public hearing at this point and then there's still time for

3:52:02 Council to ask questions, or should we finish all the questions first? No, you can close the public hearing if there's no further public comment, and the council can discuss and deliberate. Okay. Is there still time, or is this? I mean, the other lawyer left, so. I think the council's practice is typically not to allow any one person to speak more than once, but it's the council's prerogative. I mean, the other lawyer left. I don't think that it's fair to. You said that he couldn't talk. Yeah.

3:52:33 Well, you know what? I think we should, I think we've heard both sides, and I don't think that there's any opportunity for rebuttal, so I think we need to close the public hearing now. Thank you. I think you're right. Okay. Public hearing is closed. Thank you, everyone. So, deliberations, discussions, questions. So, I'll just start with this. So, looking at the findings, looking at finding four. What page are you on?

3:53:03 And what I'm

3:53:34 You've got two caged animals, and they want to go after each other, and we're sitting in the middle of this. I think that there is certainly value to affordable housing, but there's also certainly value to resolving previous issues, administrative issues, having a recording of documents and things like that. So my proposal would be that I'll work.

3:54:00 In this discussion with my council members here is to continue this item, not indefinitely, but to get this issue resolved in a civil court. I don't know which one of these parties is going to go first and sue the other, but someone's got to go first and someone's got to get this thing resolved by a judge so you know what we're dealing with. That would be my recommendation. Okay. What does our attorney think of that recommendation?

3:54:31 Well, go ahead. That's a question. Go ahead. I think as a corollary to what I said earlier where you can't force the parties to engage in litigation, I don't know that the town can decide not to make any kind of decision until and unless litigation is concluded. I think the council owes the parties a decision. I think if you wanted to do a short continuance, a couple, I mean, a couple weeks maybe just to give everybody a chance to talk, I think you could. But I don't know that you could.

3:55:00 Continue it until and unless litigation has been. Okay, fine. So I'll refine that to say a short continuance. And that's what I recommend. Okay. Councilmember Truax, do you have anything that you want to, you know, discuss at this point? I can also go to Mayor Pro Tem. I just want us to start trying to move forward. Yeah. So from my standpoint, I mean,

3:55:31 I recognize everybody's got a challenging situation, and there's going to be a disagreement that goes on, and my concern is that if we pause, or say a short time frame, the media party has any obligation to go forward. I'm more in mind to this standpoint that we...

3:55:55 Deny the appeal and we move forward from that standpoint. And, you know, it's always tough because everybody's got a challenge. Everybody's got a different portion to get it resolved. There's several things in this case that need to be resolved. But the question before us is, the Planning Commission make a good decision and do we uphold that or not? And it's one time I say we uphold it. Thank you, Brent.

3:56:27 I guess I just had a question like with the titles, like does the planning department like look at the titles of both parties or since there is this, you know, approving this, are we, I don't know how to say this, but I mean, I feel like I like the project. I hear that there's, you know, the difficulties is in the exclusive use of the easement. You know, it sounds like you guys are both.

3:56:57 For housing, you know, to me it seems odd that in your title it would say that you have exclusive use of this and it's essentially your property but you don't have to pay property taxes and it's on the other person's lot. So to me that is confusing. Like if that was the intent I would think that when they divided the properties they would have included that portion of land with your portion of land that you purchased. So, you know, I just, I guess

3:57:27 My questions are, like, how do the property titles compare? You know, is 50, I'm sorry, I'm going to get the numbers mixed up, but 54? Okay, like does 54, it has the whole property and says that you're granting a 30-foot easement to the property behind you because they're landlocked? Or in their title, does it say you have sole usage of this?

3:57:55 Easement. So I've not reviewed the title report for either parcel. I would venture to say that probably the title reports for each contain a copy of the same easement that we've been discussing. And title reports generally don't provide any kind of opinion. They just provide documents without interpretation. So they're working with the same document. Okay. With the document. And then there's the court case that says...

3:58:23 You know, the intention behind is the rule of thumb or what can you talk about that? Okay. Mr. Marari's attorney, he described the law in a way that is different from my understanding of it. I don't think it's quite as black and white as he said. It's not that the property owner...

3:58:49 Whose property is burdened by an easement always, always has the right to use the portion of the property that's burdened by the easement. It's not what the courts have said at all. The courts have said that in some cases they do, and in some cases they don't. And the courts have said that that is an unusual circumstance to have a truly exclusive easement where the owner of the underlying property, the Servian tenement, is not allowed to use that portion of their property. It's unusual, but it's not unheard of. So it's possible, and what the courts have said is,

3:59:18 It's a very fact-specific determination. And it's not one that I think that any of us are in the best position to make. I think ultimately a judge is going to have to decide that. Okay, so what sort of place are we putting ourselves in approving this development while we know that there are ongoing issues with usage? Well, I imagine that if the council were to

3:59:46 Deny the appeal and uphold the PEDC's determination. I imagine that somebody will end up going to court. I don't know who. And I think the town could get named. Mr. Mirari has an obligation to defend and indemnify the town. So we might get involved in litigation, but we would be represented and we would be essentially waiting to see what happens. I mean, I think both parties would be looking for some kind of declaratory judgment.

4:00:15 As to the nature of the easement. And then the town, of course, would comply with whatever that is. And if I could, I think that that course of action, keeping the town out of this, and saying, again, degree that we can to say, look, grant a continuance, not directing anybody to do anything, but with the understanding that if we make a decision one way or the other, we're going to get sucked into this litigation somehow.

4:00:43 And to give the parties a chance to go to court and figure this out. And then we have something to work for. With all due respect, it will take at least a year for that decision to be made. And I don't think the council can continue the item for that long. Okay. Well, again, that defies common sense. With all due respect to the legal system, it's not in the community's interest to be, in my mind, to be memorializing and institutionalizing conflict.

4:01:14 I think it's probably in the community's interest to get things resolved and to find a path to get things resolved. So that's my sense of this. And then just so I'm clear on this, so upholding the appeal would then open us up for litigation for denying a project for no reason or what? Well, I don't want to speculate. I mean, presumably if the council were to grant the appeal, you'd have

4:01:44 Strong findings based on the record. We don't have a resolution upholding the appeal ready for you just yet, so we would have to prepare one. But if that's the direction you chose to go, I would hope and would assume that it would be based on really good findings. And beyond that, I won't speculate. Okay. So to that end, our job then would be to have findings from the appeal that we think would compel us

4:02:12 to change the course of action. But so far, does anybody on the council feel that there's any findings we can make? Because the challenge is that this is a civil matter, and frankly, I'm confused why the person who sold the property to both parties isn't the one who's, you know,

4:02:41 Under duress here. And for me, I'm not a judge. I'm not a lawyer. I am a public servant volunteer who wants to do the right thing by everybody in this town. But frankly, this feels like a legal matter that there's nothing we can point to as a council that would allow us to, you know, to

4:03:12 Grant the appeal. I'm making sure I'm saying the right words. And that's the struggle. I mean, it's not that we don't care. I've spent so much time with these documents, and frankly, I'm just perplexed as to why, I mean, we don't have a finding, so it leaves us in a very difficult position. And it's not... Sorry, I'm sorry. No, go ahead. Well, I'd just say, when I look at the findings, the things that I just read...

4:03:40 If we... Say them again then so I'm clear what you're pointing to. There's four different findings I'm looking at. Page 139. Yeah. Item C. Parking areas are located, etc. Minimize stormwater runoff and the heat island effect. And the final phrase, and achieve a safe, efficient, and harmonious development. Right? And if this thing is not presently a safe...

4:04:07 Efficient, harmonious development with opportunities for a bunch of other things. Then if you go to page 140 and you look at the findings for adjustment and you look, a significant public benefit will result because providing guest parking on-site helps prevent conflicts with neighboring properties due to parking in unauthorized areas. Well, it's clear that that's

4:04:32 There's a conflict there. If we simply just say deny the appeal and say go ahead with the project, wouldn't you uphold the appeal? No, he's saying if we did. Yeah, I mean, if we just say, you know, there's going to be conflict with this parking stuff. We know it. I mean, but the nature of the conflict is someone's going to have to sue somebody to try to get this resolved. So that's, in my mind, is inevitable. Or there's going to be conflict.

4:05:00 There's also issues about the snow storage. That's another thing that's going to probably come into this to be part of the conflict. And again, the final one has to do with snow storage. Maybe it's more tangential. But institutionalizing this, saying project proceed, there's going to be conflict. And just a question of whether we approve it and say, OK, folks, go fight it out somewhere. Or, again, to say, look,

4:05:31 Before we do, we would like to give the parties a chance, an opportunity to try to figure this out. Now, Andy, if we say a short continuance, say for two weeks or something like that, or whatever, a short continuance, and the parties, without any direction from us, someone goes to court and says, okay, I'm going to resolve this, could then we continue our continuance until that is resolved? No.

4:05:56 You owe them a decision at some point. Okay, fine. Well, then, I guess if that's a thing, then someone's got to call the vote. Mr. Hayes, is there something to say? Real quick, we huddled up and were able to answer your question about title. We have a copy of the applicant's title report. The easement that's being discussed is not on their title report. Say that once more. The easement.

4:06:24 That Erickson's are referencing that came 12 years after the conditions of approval is not on the applicant's title report. So his title does not say there's a 30-foot exclusive easement. It only references the easement as described in the original map back in 1990, 1989. And say more about what that description was, just so we're clear. We'd have to pull that description. It's on the map.

4:06:50 But your question was that easement on their title. We had to just go review the documents. So just so I'm clear, 54, which is the applicant to build the project, there's a note that there is an easement, but they, I'm trying to understand. I think what Hayes is saying is that the recorded easement is not in that title report. There's only a reference to.

4:07:23 The existence of an easement as described in the map. And we've seen that there is a disconnect between what the map was supposed to say or the easement that was meant to be recorded and what was recorded. And that's sort of the part of the issue. Again, can I ask the question? That's not, we don't have any jurisdiction over anything, correct? That's not anything that we have any. I understand. That lives in the other proceeding.

4:07:54 No, it's true, because it's private parties recording with the county. And disputes, and someone's got one thing, someone's got something else. That's not in our purview this evening. But it keeps creeping into this. That's this conflict that keeps trying to get into this position. Sure, and the findings that you were referencing were from the PEDC, but I thought our findings had to come from

4:08:20 From the appeal, which was the seven points that the appellant. I think what Councilmember Wentworth is saying is he's following the advice I gave early in the hearing. Right. That if you were going to deny the appeal and uphold the PEDC, you'd be making the findings in this resolution, or different findings if you tell us that you want to make different ones. But as I mentioned earlier, if you want to grant the appeal and overturn the decision of the PEDC,

4:08:47 You would make sort of the inverse of the findings. You could use this resolution, flip it around, and that could be the basis of your determination. I think that's what you're doing. Yeah, and that's what I'm doing. I'm looking at the findings, and I'm saying, you know what? I don't believe that will be true. I don't believe that this, you know, moving forward with the project and denying the appeal is going to be

4:09:13 It's going to mitigate conflict. It's going to make for a harmonious environment, all the rest of it, based, you know, using the citations I've read here. I believe that if we uphold the appeal, that that is a logical way to move. My ultimate decision, you know, thought here is to get this thing into court because, you know, get this, all this mishmash of...

4:09:39 You know, easements and titles and maps and all that kind of stuff. Get somebody else to figure all that stuff out because that's not in our purview. But if, you know, to follow your logic forward, then we'd have to look at the liability to the town based on if we were to deny it or uphold it, what type of liability does that type of a decision? I will say that the potential liability of the town should not form

4:10:08 The basis of your determination. Your determination should be based on the findings. Can you make the findings to deny the appeal, or conversely, can you make the findings to grant the appeal? And the liability will be whatever it is, but your action should be guided by findings. Okay, and then I have one other thing I just want to add. There were a lot of accusations made tonight, and I can't...

4:10:28 We don't have any capacity sitting up here to confirm or deny those. And it really troubles me to think that this is now out there in the public and the public is going to believe certain things that we can't confirm or deny. I would like to hear from the rest of council, you know, how that might impact or influence your thinking because

4:10:51 I think we have to put it out there. I mean... Well, I think to that point, I think we have to go with the advice of our attorney, which is saying, look, you've got a very specific thing upon which to make a decision. Whatever people have said this evening, we don't have any control over that, so we can't... I hear that, but I also... All right. I just... You know, we are...

4:11:16 Thinking about reversing a PEDC decision that the PEDC clearly spent a lot of time and energy on, and that's troubling to me. You know, we don't want to make that a practice because the truth of the matter is, really, I believe, is a civil matter that doesn't merit a council override. That's our attorney. That's the town's attorney. It's not the party's attorney. But this is how we...

4:11:51 Follow the Brown Act and follow the law because this is all we have to go on. If Mr. Rudder has an idea he would like to share, perhaps a short recess and he and I could huddle in the hall. Let's take a short recess, please. That would be great. How long? Ten minutes? Five minutes? Until you return? Okay. Ten minutes. Thank you. No, he's... I assume if you... We are reconvening. Thank you. Is there anything that you are able to share?

4:22:51 Well, the Erickson's attorney, Mr. Rutter, has proposed a two-week continuance in hopes that his clients and Mr. Marari can work things out and that he and Mr. Marari's attorney can facilitate that. It's up to you as to whether you are interested in that. I don't know how Mr. Marari feels about it, but the Erickson's attorney has suggested a two-week continuance. Next week's Thanksgiving, right? Is everyone working next week? Well, it continues to the next council meeting, I think. December 3rd.

4:23:23 But December 3rd? I would support that. Well, you haven't asked the other party if they're interested in that. I'm just saying, based on... Well, I think also, though, we are able to do this without asking both parties. We have a right as a council to do that, to try to see if there's any additional information that comes to light. And also, for us to have a little more time to think about these findings, because I don't think we have consensus.

4:23:53 So the question I want to put

4:24:23 I think the planning people has very well worked. When the meeting is there, John is there also.

4:24:53 He was very well aware what is going on and everything also. And I'm happy to work with him. And I have already talked to him several times with Mr. Erickson. And I said, well, look, this is you and me can resolve that. Either you and me can resolve that or either judge can resolve that. And I'm happy to help him because he doesn't have a utility easement. Okay. So the utility right now running in.

4:25:24 Thank you very much.

4:25:53 What John is just keep telling it is finding on four things about the parking. Parking is, I think, it's a legally municipal court. Okay, but if I could restrain from the question. The question was whether or not two weeks, that was the question. No, I know, but I want to just bring it to the attention also to the people so it's not misleading here. Because the way you're asking the question about the finding about what the planning people has done, that trying to...

4:26:22 Deviate towards the wrong things. But there's nothing. They have taken so much time. This project we are working on from completely last year. Whatever you're hearing from me tonight is the process that I'm going through to try to figure out how I would vote on this matter. So that's all that that is. The mayor's question from the town's attorney was two weeks. Now, we didn't know you're going out of the country, but you have legal representation.

4:26:49 And perhaps if Ms. Rudder and your lawyer can get together to try to see if we can work this out to continue this in the next meeting, from my perspective, I don't know, my fellow council members think, but I think that that's a reasonable, just from my perspective, that's a reasonable thing to try to do. I think a two-week continuance when there's a holiday in the middle,

4:27:13 Seems rushed if we're really trying to give people time to do their due diligence. So would it be reasonable to do it for two meetings from now? Because the next meeting is like tomorrow for all of us. That's within the council's discretion. And Mr. Rutter's idea, just so everyone knows what we're talking about, is that perhaps Mr. Marari and the Erickson's would stipulate to a very expedited judicial determination.

4:27:40 Which I think is in everyone's best interest to try to get an answer as quickly as possible. And so perhaps that's worth discussing. So now I'm just not clear. How expedited could that be? Is a month enough? Or do you... No, no, no, no, no. I think the council still owes everyone a decision. But if the parties were all to stipulate to something, to a postponement of a decision or something or...

4:28:08 Stipulate to trying to go to court very quickly, notwithstanding the council having made a decision. That's perhaps worth discussing. Okay. Would it be reasonable for us to say that we will continue this until we have a better determination of when some date in the future so that we aren't stating a date? Well, I don't think you can continue indefinitely. Okay. So can we continue it for a month? That's the question on the table. I don't think that would prejudice the parties. Can someone make a motion? Can I ask a question?

4:28:38 I just want to make sure I understand everything. So if we deny the appeal tonight and the Ericsons are, of course, displeased with that, like what actions do they have to, I mean, disrupt is not the right word, but to appeal his development? Like, do they have other courses of action? Because when I read through this, I mean, I see his design plans and I feel like they've followed.

4:29:09 Okay, so...

4:29:27 If we were to deny the appeal and he's going to continue with his development, they could still resolve this in court. I mean, if the court finds that they have exclusive rights to the easement and he's built on it, then the court could make him tear it down or what are these? I don't want to give anyone legal advice, but I suspect that if this ends up in court, that both sides would be seeking preliminary injunctions, freezing things in place. Okay.

4:29:56 Okay, nobody do anything until the decision is made. Okay, so I mean, I guess to me, I feel like tonight our job is looking over, is he meeting the town's requirements for what we require of developers and, you know, he's getting a density bonus because he's following our rules and then that is a separate matter. The exclusive easement is a separate matter to be cited, to be decided.

4:30:24 Outside of the Town Council Chambers. However, I think we could save everybody the opportunity to save everybody a lot of time and a lot of money if we continue this for a month, which represents being reasonable, to let these two parties go off into that third dimension and try to come up with some kind of an agreement, some kind of understanding to the two parties. It saves everybody a lot of time, it saves everybody a lot of money, and then we can come back and make an informed decision.

4:30:52 Based on whatever agreement the two parties are. Well, but again, what Mr. Rudder has raised, which Mr. Murari's attorney has not had an opportunity to hear or think about, is only the idea of trying to get a very quick judicial determination. It's not trying to work together to resolve it. It's, well, if we're going to go to court, let's do it quickly. That is what he's talking about. That's the same thing, and it's fine. Because then we would know a judicial determination.

4:31:20 Where this stands between these two parties, then that would inform our decision. Well, unless the parties stipulate to the council not taking action, you're still going to owe them a decision before this goes to court. You're not going to get a judicial determination that quickly. Right, but we will have within a month. You might or might not have some idea where they're standing. I'm perfectly willing to come back in a month. If they haven't figured anything out, then we can vote and we can do what we got to do.

4:31:48 I think Councilmember Truax wants to talk. My question overall is that our job job from the standpoint of we are presented with a question of whether or not to overturn a PDEC decision and whether the findings support overturning that decision. At this point in time, those findings don't support overturning that decision. And us...

4:32:09 I get it. I want to make sure that we're trying to do the right decision for the town. We're trying to do the right decision for everybody. You have two parties who have disagreements on that. But our job here is to determine whether or not you're making a determination of whether or not the PDC has made the decision and whether or not to deny that or overturn that appeal. And that's our job from a standpoint. And I don't think...

4:32:35 Delaying that a month or even two is going to change that determination from us as a council to make a determination for where it goes. And whether or not somebody is litigious down the road or not is not within where I'm worried about. It's about whether or not we make a fair and adequate decision based on the information before us and making a determination of where we should be moving forward. Again, I would thank any opportunity.

4:33:02 Any opportunity that a representative body has to get to resolutions, to get to agreements, to get to a way forward that saves money, that saves time, that gets to community harmony and well-being and understanding, it's an obligation of that body to allow that opportunity to happen. I hear what you're saying, Andy. There's no guarantee about anything. And if nothing happens within a month, then we're where we are.

4:33:32 In a month, fine. We'll take the votes. We'll make the decisions. But we have an opportunity here to invest in community harmony and understanding, and I think that's an opportunity that we should take. Well stated. I mean, are we... I guess what I'll do is... Can I make a motion to that effect? Well... To me, it sounds like Brent's in favor of denying the appeal, and John wants to push the decision for one month. That's what I'm hearing, and I don't know...

4:34:08 What Mayor Pro Tem would do, and you don't know. What would you do, Chris? Well, I would push the decision for a month because I really think that what Council Member Wentworth is saying about Community Harmony is worth airing this out for one more month to try to see if there's some kind of way for a decision that, because again, this

4:34:34 Feels like a legal decision that is being made by a town council, and I would just like to see if there's any way that other information could be brought into this before we take this decision that's, you know. My only question with that, Madam Mayor, is that even if they come to an expedited decision, they're not going to have a decision in a month. We're going to be faced in a month in the same exact situation we are today with no difference because

4:35:04 No one's going to be into court. And I appreciate where John's going. I think we all as a community want to make sure whenever possible, we want everybody to work together to try to find an amicable solution to something that's going on. In our situation here, though, in a month, I don't believe that it's going to change. I believe we're going to be in the same situation in a month having the same conversation. So, Brent, let me ask you this. Will you give me a month? Will you give the community a month?

4:35:32 And bring it back. And if we're where we are in a month, we'll make the vote then. We'll do it then. But can we just give it a month and let's see if we can get something back? So the two parties can get in front of us and say, you know what, guys, we want you to do this. And we can support whatever understanding and decision they come to. If they don't come to one, fine. We'll take the vote. We'll do what we got to do. But can we give them a month? I don't support it. I don't see where it's going to change in as much as I want to.

4:36:02 Think that, yes, something could happen a month. I don't see it changing. Okay, well, we disagree. Yeah, and that's fine. But, I mean, you know, the challenge is that. And it's all on me now. Yeah. Because if I side with Brent, then we deny the appeal. Yeah. And it doesn't go for a month. And that was me during the STR moratorium. It just happens sometimes. Yeah. I mean. Just as a procedural reminder.

4:36:32 Anything the council does requires three votes. That's right. We know. Except that if you cannot reach a decision on the appeal and you deadlock 2-2, that counts as a denial of the appeal and upholding the PEDC decision. I understand that. That's why I was trying to get us to yes before we take a vote. But it seems as if, you know, I need someone at this point to make a motion. Go ahead. Do you want to make a motion?

4:37:03 I'll give you a month, John. Okay. So I would make a motion that the council, based on the recommendation of, well, the request of the town attorney to allow the parties

4:37:23 Well, or not my request. Yes, the appellant. The request of the appellant's attorney. Okay, the request of the appellant's attorney for a period of a month to attempt to get two parties to come up with some representation back to the council within a month, and at which point the item will continue to that point. That would be the motion.

4:37:45 I can restate. So we want to continue to a date certain because of the notice, correct? So can you continue it to December 17th, please? Yes. Is that okay with you, Madam Mayor? Yes. Okay, so the motion will be to continue this item to December 17th. Okay. Do we have a second? I'll second. All right. Jamie, can you please call the roll? Councilmember Truax? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes.

4:38:14 The motion carries. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. See you in a month. See you December 17th. Sorry. December 17th. All right. We will get back. Councilmember Sauser. And where are we? We are on to policy matters. And thank you all for being here. If you could all clear the...

4:38:50 Chambers, or let us get back to work. We would appreciate it. We still have a number of other items. Thank you. Placements. All right. We're on to item 12.1. Item 12.1 is to consider a second amendment to the terms of the contract with placement. Everyone, please let us finish our meeting. We're going to be here for quite some time still. I'll need you to have your meetings outside.

4:39:20 All right. This is to consider a second amendment to the terms of the contract with Placemate to operate the Lease to Locals program. All right. Thank you. And we have Isaac Landman with Placemate. They operate Lease to Locals. Thank you, Isaac, for staying on. And so I'll turn it over to you to share your screen and walk through your presentation and request. Great. Thanks, Nolan. Hi, everyone.

4:39:52 Thank you for having me. So let me just get my screen situated here. My name is Isaac Landman. I'm the Associate Market Director for Placemate. We're the program administrators of the Lease to Locals program. I presented to Town Council in the late spring. I'm back again here to give you an end-of-year update and provide you an update on the results of the program extension passed July 1st.

4:40:20 And then discuss what 2026 could look like should Town Council decide that they would like to extend the program. So just to give you a bit more of a granular look at what I'll be presenting, I'll go over the program details, then I will review what year one of the program looked like, the pilot, give you a recap of the results we've just seen, and then discuss the results to date in total.

4:40:51 So, Lease to Locals is a long-term rental conversion program. It provides property owners with a financial incentive who agree to switch the use of their housing unit to be a new long-term rental. In order to participate, the property must be located in Mammoth Lakes town limits, and it cannot have been a full-time rental in the past 12 months.

4:41:21 To move forward, property owners need to sign either a 12-month lease or a seasonal lease, a 5- to 11-month lease, and need to sign that lease at or under the rent caps for the program, which are based on unit size, and they need to sign that lease with a qualified tenant group. And if they do so, they're eligible for an incentive that's based on the number of qualified tenants that are in that tenant group. It's a $4,500 incentive payment per qualified tenant.

4:41:51 For a 12-month lease and a $2,000 incentive payment for a qualified tenant in a seasonal lease. Additionally, the qualified tenant group must, in order for a group to qualify, at least 50% of the members must be locally employed. And a locally employed qualified tenant is someone who works at least 30 hours per week for an employer based within the town boundary.

4:42:18 The household income can also not exceed 150% of the area median income, and that is just under $125,000 per year. So to recap the program pilot, Lease to Locals first launched in Mammoth in August 1st, 2024.

4:42:41 Town Council allocated $425,000 in total funding. That was $320,000 of incentives and $105,000 for Placemate's administrative fee and the program marketing budget. That pilot program ran for 11 months through July 2, 2025, at which point Town Council decided to extend the contract through the end of 2025.

4:43:06 And in that 11 months, we had 141 total property leads, 141 property owners reach out and express interest in that program, in the program. But we had a slow start to the number of participating properties. 12 owners moved forward and leased up their homes, housing 37 tenants during that 11-month period. $130,375 in incentives were allocated.

4:43:33 And our admin fee compared to the total spend on the program was 41%. We heard from town council at that time that that 41% was really too high. And so when we came back to town council, we temporarily reduced our flat $7,500 per month fee to a $1,667 per property submitted.

4:44:02 A performance-based fee. And we also did at that time when we came back to extend the program was we set a goal of spending the just under $200,000 remaining incentive funds on the properties that whose owners had indicated they'd like to move forward with leasing their property up before the end of the program or excuse me, before the end of the calendar year. And what we've seen since then has been quite a bit of successful progress.

4:44:32 And actually, the numbers that I submitted in this slide deck have actually increased. So I'll read over on my notes here. Our total leads, our total number of property owners that are interested in participating is up to 178. So that's up 37 since program extension, which shows that interest in the program remains robust and momentum is continuing. We're also up to 10 properties that have

4:45:01 That have been submitted since program participation, so 10 properties participating, which is indicative of increasing participation rates as property submittals have nearly doubled in the four and a half months since program extension compared with the 11 properties that entered the program in the first 11 months of program operations, so during the pilot year.

4:45:25 We also expect, with these most recent submittals, an additional two to three properties to move forward before the end of the calendar year. There's currently $67,000 in total funds remaining for the program for both administrative fees and for incentives.

4:45:44 And based on the current entrusted properties in our pipeline, we expect to be at the lower end of the range that you see displayed here by the end of the calendar year. So in that $35,000 expected total funding remaining. Now, there's also some additional, these are the total program results since the program extension. So I'll highlight the

4:46:12 The most important stats that are slightly out of date since those two additional properties have been submitted. We're at 22 total properties in the program now, which accounts for 46 bedrooms, and $236,000 of incentives have been committed. The average incentive per property of $10,500 and average incentive per person housed of $3,700 has remained steady, as has the average rent of just around

4:46:40 $2500 per month. On the tenant side of things, the total results have increased to 64 people housed, 58 adults and six children, and then that average household income and average adult tenant income have remained steady with the recent submittals as well. So looking to 2026, and this is why I'm here today,

4:47:04 Placemate and Town Staff have been discussing what kind of changes could we make to the program to continue the momentum and success that we've been seeing and really continue to increase our results. So what we've been seeing is that despite the high program interest, despite that high number of property owners that would like to participate, that 178 number, the conversion of getting those property owners to lease up and join the program has been low.

4:47:33 And participating property owners are anchoring to the rental caps, which you see displayed here in the right-hand column, rather than dynamically pricing their homes. So we think that the rent caps are inhibiting people from moving forward. You can see that the average rents of the properties that have moved forward and leased up in the program are right at the current caps, rather than property owners.

4:48:01 Pricing closer to what, making adjustments to their rents based on what the market might bear. And what this does is, what this means is that property owners may be treating the incentives as a subsidy rather than as an incentive to start long-term renting. What further shows this is there's 81 not interested owners in our pipeline.

4:48:25 21 of those 81 owners indicate that the rent caps are too low. Further, 54 of those 81 property owners are condo owners, and 33 of which are two-bedroom units or smaller. And we bring up condos because we've heard lots of anecdotal evidence from the many condo owners in Mammoth that their carrying costs are quite high. And even with the incentives, the rent caps,

4:48:56 They can't make enough money to make this program pencil, and so they're not able to start long-term renting even though they would like to. Finally, when rent caps are too low, the probability of long-term rental retention goes down, meaning the probability that a property owner continues to long-term rent after their lease to locals lease term is quite low. And that's evidenced by, of the seven properties that have graduated from

4:49:26 The Mammoth Lakes Lease to Locals Program, only two of them have continued renting long-term. So how do we address this? Town staff and placemate have been discussing this quite a bit, and as a suggested path forward, we think it would make sense to increase rental caps by 20%. You can see those amounts on the right-hand column here. And what this would do is it would increase the financial viability for interested owners.

4:49:53 While maintaining relative affordability for tenants. The average increase here is just over $400 across all unit sizes. And we think that this would particularly help us target those condos who have those particularly high carrying costs. Additionally, this would help improve the likelihood that long-term rentals will be retained.

4:50:17 That they'll keep long-term renting after their lease-to-locals term. And the investment that the town is making to convert those properties to new long-term rentals will go further. The current Mammoth Lakes lease-to-locals retention rate is 29%, so that two out of seven. Whereas Placemate's company-wide retention rate across all of our lease-to-locals markets is 71%. And the reason that Placemate's company-wide retention is 71% is because

4:50:45 In the majority of our other markets, we have the rent caps set at a rate that is more appropriate for those markets. And so property owners decide they start long-term renting and then they keep long-term renting because they aren't treating that incentive like a subsidy rather as an incentive to start to continue long-term renting. So additionally, another change we're asking for in the program

4:51:13 In program operation is our administration fee. As Town Council knows, following the program extension to reduce administrative costs relative to the total program costs, we changed our administration fee to $1,667 per property submitted. Since then, we've invoiced just over $13,000 for the eight properties submitted. We'll also invoice for those two properties we recently submitted.

4:51:41 But this low pay for performance fee structure doesn't accurately reflect all of the work that goes into the properties that we don't submit. We still have to talk to all of the property owners that are coming in. We have relationships with all of those 178 property owners. And to account for this in 2026, we're requesting an increase in our admin fee to $2,200 per property. We're not requesting any additional incentive budget at this time, but we will likely return to request additional budget

4:52:10 Program funds as dictated by demand in early 2026, at which point we'll also request additional marketing budget to promote the program policy changes and hopefully increase participation should Town Council decide to move forward with the changes we're proposing and extend the program. So finally, just to give you a bit of a sense of what leased locals in 2026 could look like with these changes, if 20...

4:52:40 Properties participate next year. The total admin cost would be $44,000, which is 17% of the total program cost, still under that 20% mark that council and staff have indicated that they'd like to stay below, and what we try to strive to stay below as well in all of the programs that we administer. So that's my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions you have. I'll go ahead and stop sharing my screen. The public comment? Yeah, I just have no questions.

4:53:15 Come on up to the mic. Rise and speak. Hi, sorry, this is not actually public comment so much as it is, it's like questions for you guys. What does graduating from the Lease to Locals program actually mean? Wait a second. First of all, should we let council ask questions first and then...

4:53:42 You can do it in any order that you like, but Ula can ask questions. For sure, but Ula, introduce yourself for the record. Hi, I'm Ula Lieber. I'm a reporter for The Sheet, which is the local paper in town. Yeah, so my questions are what does graduating from the Lease to Locals program actually mean? And then do you have a number for how many eligible...

4:54:05 So I can answer the first question. Graduating from Lease to Locals means that a property has gone through its full lease term, so either that 5 to 11 month seasonal lease or its 12 month lease term incentives, at which point they don't receive additional incentives.

4:54:37 And I don't know the total stats of eligible properties, meaning properties that have not currently been rented. But we do have, you know, we've heard from 178 property owners that have expressed interest in the program. So we have a quite robust pipeline of folks that would like to participate at some point. Okay, great. So questions from council.

4:55:11 I don't have any questions. Questions? More comments, no questions. Questions? Councilmember Truax, questions? No, I do not. Okay. Then we should take... Is there anything that staff wants to add? One clarifying question to the questions from the sheet reporter. The total number of eligible properties, really, I mean, is any residential property in the town that it's currently at?

4:55:43 Okay, so I just want to remind everybody.

4:56:14 That Aaron, I don't remember his last name starts at the end. He was here last month talking about the housing study, Newsom. Yeah, so he said that 60% of the housing units in Mammoth are vacant. They're not used for long-term housing. And I believe from our short-term rental program, there's like 3,600 short-term rentals in town. Is that correct, Nolan?

4:56:44 That sounds about right. That sounds right. I just want to remind everybody, in his report last month, he had the average price of a two-bedroom condo as $3,500. So to me, increasing the prices seems reasonable. If he's saying that the market rate is $3,500 and we currently have the cap set at $2,500, to me it seems reasonable.

4:57:13 to increase the caps, you know, for a two-bedroom unit to $3,000. And I also, Isaac, I appreciate you being flexible on your pricing and kind of meeting us, lowering your monthly cost. So I'm in favor of this program. I feel like this is a

4:57:41 You know, there are no other middle income rental projects that we have anywhere in town. We have, you know, the parcels addressing low income rentals. We have our bridge program, which is middle income for purchase units, but we don't have any other.

4:58:02 Programs for our missing middle renters. So I'm in favor of continuing this, especially since we've already dedicated funding for this. So, you know, at least until that funding runs out. And I would really love to see if we could convert more empty units or short-term rentals into long-term housing that will continue to house people after

4:58:31 This subsidy runs out after their lease. Those are my thoughts. I'm with you, sister. You better be. You better give me a month, John. I'm with you, sister. And Councilmember Truax. You missed it, Bill. You were in the penalty box during the give you a month. Bill, do you have anything to add? Yeah, my comments here.

4:59:00 What I just heard was that it's okay if they raise the rent that they collect from the renter to $3,000. We're subsidizing that for $3,000. So that's $6,000 a month that they're getting for that unit. No. No, no, no, no. It was $4,500 per tenant per year. Is that correct, Isaac? So what subsidy do we offer a two-bedroom unit now? Depends on how many renters are in there.

4:59:25 That's correct. So let's say you rented a two-bedroom unit to two qualified tenants. The total incentive would be $9,000. Total. That's over the entire lease term for a 12-month lease. So less than $1,000 per month. And only the first year. Yeah, $750. Was that $750 a month? My problem with this program in its entirety is, and I believe that it's...

4:59:52 Too expensive. And I don't believe in Mammoth that it's going to lead to conversions after the subsidy runs out for rentals. But it already is. Homeowner association, well, 17%. Homeowner association fees. 28%. 29%. 29%. The cost of owning a condo up here, losing the ability to use it yourself, I think, and I have some ideas that we don't need to go into tonight.

5:00:18 That we could spend this much money and perhaps create even more rental units, but I'm not going to go on and on about it. I would say bring us that program, but in the meantime, let's keep going. Because I hear you, but like, and Councilmember Truax, I see you might be wanting to talk, so I'll go last, because I try to always hear from everyone first. Go ahead. So, I'm the same way in terms of, I'm not sure this is the best way we spend money, but my concern is,

5:00:48 I'd like to see some other things come forward and we have nothing else to come forward at this point in time and you know we have a need right now. My concern is it may not be where I want it to go but it may be an interim solution that works for this moment.

5:01:04 Fantastic. And I would just say that I would like to remind you all that I've been a fan of this from day one and said we had to give it time and we had to adjust, but that this is a way of putting roofs overheads. And I don't have the number in front of me, but I am absolutely delighted with the roofs.

5:01:20 That are over people's heads. And so thank you for your analysis, Mayor Pro Tem Rice, because I do think you're reminding us about what rents are really in this community. Makes a really good point. Would you entertain a motion? You took the words out of my mouth, Council Member Wentworth. To make motion? Yes. I move that we...

5:01:42 I move that the council directs the town manager to execute a second amendment to the placemate contract to number one, make the contract term subject to the availability of program funding, number two, adjust the performance-based administrative fee to $2,200 per property, and three, increase the program rent limits by 20%. I'll second. Fantastic. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? No. Councilmember Truax? Yes.

5:02:10 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzik? Yes. Motion carries. Moving along to the 12.2. Thank you all. Thank you very much for your patience. It's quite late, and we're grateful to you, Isaac, for hanging in there. Not a problem. Have a great night. You too. All right. 12.2. Air service. Memorize. Madam Mayor.

5:02:36 Sorry to interrupt, but I do have a conflict on this item and I need to recuse myself from this item. Oh! So I'm going to turn off my video and wait until someone tells me to rejoin the meeting. Okay. Would you rather have us text you or tell you in the chat? Tell me in the chat, please. Okay. We will tell you in the chat when it's time to return. Goodbye and good luck.

5:03:00 Okay, so let's see, 12.2, Air Service MOU between Inyo County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, MLT, Mammoth Monski area to provide funding for air service, minimum revenue guarantee for commercial air service at Bishop Airport BIH. Thank you, Mayor Bobser. The item before you tonight is regarding something that we've been working on with the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance for quite a while, and this is really

5:03:30 I'm trying to figure out how agencies like the town and, in this case, Ennio County, Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area can participate in air service subsidies for commercial air service in Bishop. The town previously has been providing funding for air service at Mammoth Yosemite Airport for our chartered air service.

5:03:59 But this particular question is with regard to commercial service. So the Air Alliance has built a program in which those agencies talk about the overall plan for a year. Before we get into a season, we will look at what we can receive from a particular carrier, the types of services, meaning the number of flights per week that come in and out of there.

5:04:27 And the locations where we go, the frequency of those flights. And then we look at the overall cost that's presented to us by the carrier. And that's really the overall minimum revenue guarantee that costs us to have those services. And so we make some decisions on what we can do, what we can afford to do in that type of space. With regard to commercial air service in Bishop, it's really previously been born solely by Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

5:04:57 We're backstopped with the mountain, and what that means is that over a certain dollar amount, then the mountain picks up the cost of the MRG, and before that, Mammoth Lakes Tourism does. In this particular agreement, and we struggle to put this agreement together, I think we're probably about a year behind on it, because we've been focused on how we would develop a contract that would allow for each entity to

5:05:27 Pay their defined share, but then have the flexibility of having other agencies join into the MOU. And what I mean by that is if another agency like Mono County or Bishop, who are both not currently a part of the alliance, were to want to

5:05:48 Be at the table and making decisions around air service. They could contribute funding at a similar level to what the town and in your county are proposing to in this MOU. We struggled with how that contract would look and, you know, I think the flexibility of adding and subtracting participants to that. So what we arrived at was an MOU that sort of outlined those different positions and allowed for

5:06:16 The Mammoth Lakes Tourism to have direct individual contracts between MLT and the entities that desire to provide funding. And so we sort of flipped the script on it a little bit and allowed for an agreement to define how the agencies would manage each other and then individual contracts to ensue after that. So once we came to that conclusion, we kind of had a sense of urgency to get this completed as

5:06:43 It really was supposed to be in place for our air service for last winter and this summer. That's how we kind of roll through that. And I think the desire here tonight is to approve the MOU. I think there's some modifications that we really need to make as we go through this.

5:07:02 We talked a little bit about some of the language around the partnerships and I'm going to say the service level of engagement. Right now to be a participant it's about $200,000 per year and then if you want to be sort of a consulted

5:07:18 You could get in for $50,000 and you would at least be able to share thoughts around changes to air service, but you wouldn't necessarily be at the table making the decisions. That language isn't quite specifically outlined in the MOU. This MOU has been reviewed by Inyale County and approved, and so we are seeking to approve it as written.

5:07:39 And then we would probably make modifications within the next 12 months to firm up some of those gaps in the MOU and then probably reaffirm that with both agencies. But before you tonight, I think it's a good agreement, a good understanding to outline the program and recommending that council provide authorization for the town manager to sign on to the MOU. So I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions?

5:08:08 Just a couple questions, Rob. So, Rob, despite perhaps kind of the dryness of the resolution in front of us, this is modeled on other regions' air service programs, like in Jackson Hole, like the things we've seen in Telluride, of other parties making contributions to air subsidy.

5:08:28 Is that a fair assessment? Yeah, in general concept, yes. I mean, I would say that it's not modeled as far as taking someone else's sort of agreements and put them in place for us. It's just the concept of multiple agencies coming together for a shared desire, which in this case would be commercial air service.

5:08:47 And working out how they would interact with each other in deciding those things. And that's kind of what we've got at the Eastern Sierra Airlines. So, yeah, so that mitigates, we can bring private sector parties, tribes could come into this. So it's what we've been trying to get at for a long time, and it's a very good positive step forward. So thanks for working on this. Yeah, and there's been a lot of conversations with other agencies, and I do think that there's a strong desire for more people to participate in this. And so that will likely be the outcome in the future.

5:09:17 But at this stage of the game, there isn't any other signatories inside the four of us. But it's a start. I mean, and it's scalable. We can expand it. We can bring more people into it. Thank you. Oh, Bill has one. Yeah. My assumption reading this is that the $200,000 it costs us to be in this group is something we have already allocated in our budget. That's correct. The town put that as part of the adopted budget.

5:09:49 This spring. Actually, it's slightly higher. It's $255,000 because this last summer we wanted to extend the season through October. And you heard earlier tonight about the success of that extension. I will also say the success of air service into Bishop, commercial air service into Bishop, is really getting us to our goal of year-round air service, getting close to it.

5:10:18 So, for example, as we look into the future, you know, United is entertaining, broadening both the time in which they finish the winter, so going deeper into April, and then also how quickly we pick up summer and pushing that up even earlier. So, right now, we could get to a gap of only maybe 30 days on the front and back end of an agreement.

5:10:42 In the near future. And that's really where municipalities want to be. We want to have year-round air service in here. It's just, it was unaffordable. And I think the success that you saw tonight and the successes that we've seen this last year with commercial air service is broadening their desire to bring us that service year-round. Okay. Questions? No? Okay.

5:11:13 Oh, and we have someone who is recused. So, any public comment from anyone in the room or online? All right. So, any discussion? Oh, I'm sorry. Well, I'm looking really quickly for discussion. Seeing none. Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. So, Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to sign the Memorandum of Understanding Defining the Agency Relationships in Delivering Funding for Commercial Air Service at Bishop Airport. I'll second.

5:11:43 Fantastic. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. Could someone please recall Councilmember Truax? He's not in the chat. I don't have chat, so I didn't know what you were talking about. Oh, there's no chat in the Zoom? I never look at the Zoom. Thank you. Also, John, no? Hang on. Well, that was dumb on me, Jamie. You're like, what are you doing? I'm like, I don't know.

5:12:13 All right. It's all good. We'll get him back. In the meantime, we will allow Megan to... There he is. There he is. He has returned. Thank you, Councilmember Truax. His wife is in the room, so perhaps... Yeah. Oh, yeah. I have a feeling he has to answer her. Really good. Okay. Welcome, Megan Chapman and Rob Patterson.

5:12:38 Who will talk to us about the pre-audit financial results for fiscal year 24-25, including June 30th, 2025, fund balances and fiscal year 25-26 quarter one budget adjustments. Good evening. I come bearing good news. We're going to go through our prior year expenditures and carry over fund balance and then talk about

5:13:05 Thank you so much.

5:13:53 So in addition to our revenue coming in above budget, we also had expenditures below budget, which allows us to have $4.67 million in carryover fund balance in the general fund, as well as money set aside in reserves. This slide goes through the general fund. Specifically, on June 30, 2024, we had a fund balance of $17.04 million.

5:14:29 The net change to the fund balance for 24-25 was 6.31 million. That came from 45.4 million in revenues and 39.1 million in expenditures, bringing us to the 6.31. Of the 23.35 fund balance, 6.65 is for the economic uncertainty in the REU. The operating reserve has 1.65 million.

5:15:00 Debt service of 1.35 million, and then our housing reserves we consistently put money into based on percentages. So the housing reserve balance of 1.55 million comes from 1.85 million of revenues and 1.62 million in expenditures for last fiscal year, leaving you with a balance of 1.55 at June 30th, 2025. For the transit reserve, the balance is 3.798.

5:15:30 That comes from the $2.13 million of revenues with the $1.16 in expenditures, bringing you to the $3.8 million. For the tourism reserve, the balance is $3.095. That comes from $5.1 million in revenues and $3.9 million in expenditures, again bringing you to that $3.095. Now we're getting into some of the commitments from last year that didn't end up in the budget for $25.26.

5:16:04 For the housing reserve, there was a carryover of expenditures for $260,350. That was composed of deed monitoring and the parcel phase three design. The transit reserve had a carryover of $2.3 million, which is set aside for buses. At this point in time, we are not certain that we will need the $2.3 for buses, so we may bring that back with a different recommendation for allocations in the tourism reserve.

5:16:35 We had a $865,000 carryover for wildfire mitigation and the Bishop Air subsidy. So those amounts are recommended to put into the budget for $25,26 using the reserve balances before you today. As far as the general fund goes, there was a carryover that didn't get put into the budget for the Parks and Recreation Master Plan for $300,000 as well as $200,000 for the wildfire crews.

5:17:04 And if I can clarify, Megan's saying it didn't get put into the budget, and what she means by that is it didn't get put into the budget in the second year. They were budgeted as part of when they were approved for 24-25, but the expenditures did not occur in 24-25, so we need to carry, basically, as she said, take them from the reserve amounts and push them into a budgeted item for the next year.

5:17:29 And so we're reserving the dollars to pay for them. So they weren't a budget miss, essentially, but they are shifting budget from last year to this year. Hope that makes a little more sense. So then moving on to the general fund. Fund balance available is the $4.66 million. And for the recommendations today, what we have in front of you is a recommendation of $2 million. And then we'll go into the specific recommendations.

5:18:06 Okay, so then getting into the one-time funding project recommendations, this comes to a balance of the $7.1 million, and this is with use of... Only in capital projects and housing. We go on for another $600,000 or roughly $500,000 that covers other elements, which we'll also talk about here tonight. So the housing now, land acquisition, so we're in the process of trying to obtain some available vacant land within town. We're still in...

5:18:35 And so what I wanted to do was basically set aside monies that could

5:19:04 Be allocated for that purchase, but not necessarily take away from other Housing Now initiatives that were previously allocated. So the $3.25 million is probably not enough to acquire the land, but it's probably a large portion of that. And again, the way the town does these set-asides is when we have the available dollars, we'll create a fund in which we can use in the future, and I think this is a long way down that road.

5:19:29 The second one, Housing Now Parcel Phase II, Kingfisher II, the $800,000. At the last council meeting, we talked about providing an additional $7.2 million for the Kingfisher II project as funds provided by the town to make the grant application more attractive. We do have some time with which to get that accomplished. The first payment would be, I think, in late spring, early summer of 2027.

5:19:55 So what I'm recommending is of the first payment of around $2.5 million, we want to set aside about $800,000. A lot of times these decisions are coming from available funds and a sort of review of a holistic need across multiple components, and so we piece together what makes the most sense. The third item on there, the Dave and Roman McCoy Arts and Cultural Center, construction contingency. As you know, when we awarded that budget, that project,

5:20:25 The bid for that project. We did not have enough funds set aside that would cover the cost of the bid as well as contingency. And so this is intended to provide us with the proper amount of contingency, roughly 10 percent, for the construction of this facility. And that's been a desire of Public Works from the very beginning to say we cannot go into this project really without these contingencies. So it was a priority and a funding request.

5:20:51 And we have the opportunity to do that tonight, and that would be coming all out of general fund. The second item is on the Arts and Cultural Center is a CMU, which is a concrete masonry unit, probably not right, close, all right, surface treatments, like masonry block walls. And in the particular layout of the facility, it was not specified for either textured or colored

5:21:22 And then finally, in this particular category,

5:21:46 Childcare facility interior. As you know, we stood up the child care six classroom facility over by the Edison Theater across the parking lot there. That did not include tenant improvements for the actual interior design, and we've subsequently decided to have five classrooms, an office, and a kitchen, and that needs to be built.

5:22:09 And so setting aside funding, and at this point it's just an estimate, we do not have any bids for it, but we're setting aside funding to get that accomplished. We believe that facility can open in August of 2027 based upon current strategy of things that we have in the hopper and set aside for money, but also work we're doing on how the program can function with multi-agencies desiring to invest in that. So we'll go on to the next one, please.

5:22:37 So as I said before, there's a multiple group of sort of requests that are our tonight. I don't think I have a slide that shows you everything that's requested. It is within the staff report. These services are another grouping of requests for the evening, and a lot of them have to do with things that council has already reviewed, like for example, the archiving contract. You approve the contract with a not to exceed of $180,000. The town had $100,000 in our archiving.

5:23:05 Deferred revenue that we were going to utilize towards that project. So this $80,000 is backfilling that. The other one is a certified property application development work that we need to do. As you know, we've stood this tax collection software up. It's not really scalable or built correctly. So we've hired a professional firm to develop and build that. And we need funding to provide for that work to be completed. And that's the $80,000.

5:23:33 The childcare program analysis that I just talked about, how we are working with a consultant to figure out a process by which multiple agencies like the town, the county,

5:23:48 And school districts and others can be a part of an overall child care program that will function properly. And there's a company out of Michigan, I can't remember the names, but they have a proposal into us to work on that, and I would like to set aside $40,000 towards that effort. And then finally, the SNAP program, which Council

5:24:07 We approved at our last meeting up to $100,000. I think we ran that program for one week. And so I'm estimating the cost of the town to be around $20,000. And so I'm just backfilling our contingency dollars for what I believe we've spent. We haven't been invoiced by the county, and I don't have anything in that space. Go ahead. I just talked about all those. Pretty cool. And can I ask a question? You can.

5:24:37 Okay, so on the land acquisition, I get all that. What Hayes talked about earlier, the design work that's going on, but on the parcel for the potential, you know, home buyer, you know, property, you know, buying homes piece. Yeah, home ownership phase three. Okay. Do we have any funds set aside anywhere for a match or a subsidy or something to get those things built? Yes. Okay. So as we have,

5:25:06 The entire, I think the entirety of that project, we have about eight and a half million dollars set aside to get that part of it done. Right, for the 40 units, you had the full amount of subsidy you thought we'd need already. He said it earlier in this meeting. It was like 12 hours ago. But moving forward on that, we're waiting for the disposition of the development agreement with Pacific. That's correct. And we need a partner.

5:25:33 Exactly. Yes, but the money's there. It's a good question. In money, though, I was intending, before we had the opportunity to set aside some of this money, to repurpose the set-aside for Parcel Phase 3 to acquire the land, because we need to basically lock up that land. But I don't believe I will have to utilize any of those funds for this purchase, because we do have some unallocated funds in housing now that are undesignated and available. So I think we're in good shape.

5:26:02 More questions? John? No, I'm good. Thank you. Councilmember Truax, any questions so far? A little bit of discussion about questions. Okay. All right. Keep going then? Yep. I will keep going. Facilities. So, you know, the town needs to reinvest in its facilities as things break across time. We've got a new position, as you remember, we stood up about a year and a half ago.

5:26:33 In our facilities management, and they've been doing a really good job, they being Riley, been doing a really good job of going through facility needs and assessing what is important for us. And so this is a list of recommendations for things that need to get accomplished. The pool heater needs to be replaced, so the estimate for that is 48,000. There's a full AC unit for the sprung structure system right now that's leased out to LifeLite, and they occupy that facility almost as a dormitory.

5:27:02 During every day, they're in there. Last year, this summer, we got to a high temp inside of 92 degrees, so we want to kind of keep those people happy. We don't want our Life Flight people passing out from dehydration? It turns out we'd like them to be fully functional. That sounds good to me. So we're going to recommend that. The second one is Whitmore sewer system maintenance and updates, roughly 30,000 on that. Townyard light replacement from fluorescent to LED. This is associated with some of the work that's being

5:27:32 Done with Eastern Sierra or High Sierra Energy Foundation that Riley's been working really closely with. So that's one of those things. We think that has about a four-year ROI for the initial cost based on savings that we would see. Police Department needs some work on the building, including gutter systems for entrance and exit in certain areas. And so we've got that laid out at about $20,000.

5:28:01 If you remember, this summer we've had an emergency repair for the Whitmore Pool. It had a $10,000 deductible, so I'm looking to fund that here. I think the total project was a little bit more than $40,000 or close to $40,000, and most of that was paid by insurance, but that is the deductible. And then the town yard, we had a backup boiler, and we had to put that into production, so we are without a replacement, and that's one of the things it takes.

5:28:27 A long time to get. And so we want to make sure we have one in spares so that we can put it in if necessary because in the dead of winter, I don't think it would function without heat. Just to say that out loud. Go ahead, next. Equipment. Similar scenario here. We've got a few things that we've identified a need for. And again, the volume of these needs is only exacerbated by the fact that

5:28:53 This is really the third, fourth, and first quarter review. It's like three budgetary reviews at once. In this particular case, you know, we added a mechanic and we talked about modifying the bay. This is a lift, which is the lift that goes within the bay, allowing us to pick up the equipment and work underneath it very easily. That's about $62,000. We need to add that to the facility.

5:29:21 We have some shade tables at the dog park. And again, these are tables that have built-in shades. They seem to be pretty expensive at $30,000 for the two of them. The towable air compressor, we had one that reached end of life. This type of a vehicle is not in our vehicle replacement policy because it's really a supply. It's below the threshold.

5:29:45 And so we went ahead and authorized the purchase of this because we needed it for winterization. And so that has been acquired. And the CRC access control is basically a RFID entry system similar to an alarm system. And what we're utilizing in this access control is the same thing that we would likely be using at our town hall facility as well as some security camera systems that we will.

5:30:14 Ring before Council in the future, but that's 18,000. Vehicle diagnostic equipment, we need to upgrade our computer systems and connectivity to different types of vehicles, that's about 16,000. We need to update our flatbed trailer to support some of the product, not product, but equipment that we have that needs to be moved around in close proximity to the yard. Need a new tire balancer, paint striper, and

5:30:44 Extended batting cages. So this is one of the elements that's going to go into the CRC. We have the batting cage already, but this just gives it a little bit of an extension tube, if you will, on functionality. And then finally, trash receptacles. These are the brown sort of trash recycling combinations that you see around town. We used to have a stockpile of them, and we would implement them around. We've been trying to replace the one in front of the bonds for...

5:31:11 Almost a year now, if you've seen it, it looks like it's as roughed up as they come. So this would buy a few of those to be ready to be put into different areas, and I think that's a wrap on that. Anything else next? Just wanted to bring...

5:31:28 We are going through the audit at this time, so everything in front of you today is pre-audit balances. I'm confident with the numbers that I've worked through, so I don't think anything's going to change. I'm also very happy to have the auditors here this week to be able to get that step behind us. And then tonight we're just looking for approval of attachment A, which includes all of the recommendations that Rob went through so we can incorporate all of the recommended appropriations into the 25-26 budget. And then we'll be coming back for mid-year.

5:31:58 March 19th. So we've got the appropriations of part of you today, knowing that we will get back into the cycle of mid-year, third quarter, fourth quarter review moving forward. Thank you. Questions? Just an observation from the MLT board meeting today, their TOT numbers, I think we were a little soft in, was it September or October? October. October was a little soft. It was our consistently weakest month. Yeah, not bad, but we were a little soft.

5:32:28 And I like to keep the $1 million as a benchmark for our low times. So I'm looking forward to seeing the numbers coming in. As of today, we were at $500,000. Budget is $600,000. So we're definitely going to meet budget for October, which is great news. And I'm hoping to eke a little closer to that $1 million mark for October, because that's definitely our lowest month.

5:32:50 Yeah, and it should come close to that. I mean, due date's tomorrow, so we'll get a whole lot more on that. But really what we're talking about right now is, I look back at last year, and T.O.T. came in second highest of all time, just slightly behind the big winner a few years ago, 22-23. Yeah. So 28 point.

5:33:08 28.25. 28.25. And when we throw out those numbers, I want to clarify as well that that does not include any aspect of Measure L. So the other two percentage points, taking it from, and it's not two percent increase, it's two percent, two more points of TOT are not even considered in those numbers. Those are going directly to Housing Now Fund 245. Okay. Questions? Question from you? No, we're good.

5:33:37 Councilmember Truax, questions? Just a slight discussion, but no questions. All right, so any public comment? Anyone online? All right, discussion. Councilmember Truax, why don't you go first since you have been in the penalty box much of the night? No, no problem. Actually, DRMAC, just my concern is just that we're adding treatments and whenever we start...

5:34:06 Modifying the scope of what was agreed upon to increase cost. And I'm not against it, but I'm just concerned that also we start creeping on, oh, we'd like this, we'd like this. This is what the project was designed at. We should maintain the project as we've designed. So that's my only comment. Okay. Anyone? Councilmember Sauser? No, I'm good with it. I'm good. Yeah, I'm good. I guess the only...

5:34:39 Question I have, and we don't have to answer this tonight, but I want to make sure that we have a chance to revisit our strategic priorities and align it with what we're spending money on, just that double check to make sure that we are keeping our word for what we said we would do. But that's my only, you know, wish for the future. And to that end, Mayor Bobser, if I may, at the next council meeting, we are going to review accomplishments this year against our strategic

5:35:09 Okay. So anyone want to make a motion?

5:35:39 I would make a motion to adopt the resolution amending the fiscal year 25-26 budget as recommended in attachment A. Thank you. A second? I'll second. Fantastic. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Whitworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Thank you very much. And so, with that, we are on to councilmember reports.

5:36:10 Would you like to go first, Councilmember Seltzer? Sure. I did not do much since the last meeting. Well, that's not true. I did a whole lot since the last meeting. But in terms of official acts, I did attend the winter weather get-together for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Great event again this year, thanks to the staff for all they do for us all the time. And I was happy to be invited and be there. And I wanted to...

5:36:36 Take the extra time to thank once again the staff of the town of Mammoth Lakes and how well we react when put into rough situations. What you guys all did on the PAC fire is huge for the county and for the town and for everyone in the region. So I just wanted to thank once again, especially our police department and fire department. I got nothing but glowing reports from how the

5:37:05 Evacuations were handled. So kudos to all of you for everything we do and those who rely on us to get them done. Thank you. Councilmember Truax, do you want to do your report? Absolutely. And mine's fairly simple too. I attended an MLR meeting where we update bylaws and also our allocation forms for the different applicants. And for my first ever doing a

5:37:37 Remote Portion. I actually had somebody from the community, Steve Schacken, join me for part of the meeting here in the address that I'm at. So I appreciate that we actually had community involvement from quite a ways away. Thank you. Thank you. Council Member Wentworth? Sure. On November 6th, I attended the meeting, regular meeting of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District.

5:38:04 The change of officers will happen, I think at the February meeting or March, something like that. I'm currently serving as the chair. November 17th, we had a really good meeting. Again, this is Sarah Jobs first off, which maybe not everybody's radar, but the Recreation Tourism Working Group focused on governance, really good participation, and we're going to be producing an action plan out of this.

5:38:30 The next meeting is January 19th, and these will go on into June. An interesting note from the Sierra Business Council is that they will not be updating the regional strategy document. Despite all the work that's going on from all the various sectors and all the recommendations and all the rest of it, they've said due to timing and capacity constraints, we're not going to produce an updated version of the regional strategic plan, which is a little dicey given that the state

5:38:56 Might be looking for an updated, and they've got a nice budget, but that's it. The MLT board meeting today was interesting. Obviously, we got the announcement about Mr. Erty moving on, and congratulations extended. Again, we need to roast him hot, you know, with hot sauce. We've got to figure out how to do that. I requested jokes, but maybe someone's got, Bill, you've got, I know you're probably good at this kind of stuff. Yeah, well, I will have to think on it, John.

5:39:25 Way past my bedtime. Okay, okay, okay, I understand. Big news, everything's going well with MLT. The big news, I think, was Eric Clark just announcing that the mountain's going to open tomorrow. Chair one, two, three, gondola one and two, chair 23. Wow, really, 23? They're going to open the whole thing. So that was pretty great. See you there. That was it. And then the December 1st limelight ribbon cutting. I hope you all can go. I can't. You can't. Somebody.

5:39:55 I'll be there. I've got a conflict. I'm trying to move around now. You'll be there? I'll be there. Okay, great. Someone to represent us. Are you not going? Just me? I can't make it. I'm not back for Thanksgiving yet. I'll be there. Okay, good. Good. So, because I didn't, they didn't schedule the, they just did it. Okay, so great. That's my report. Thank you very much. Shall I go? Please. All right. I went to the Business Excellence Awards. Oh, good. On November 6th.

5:40:24 And I just want to echo Bill's sentiments of just, you know, I'm so thankful for our first responders and I'm so thankful that, you know, we didn't have any loss of life in the fire, in the PAC fire, because that was really, it hit home and it's scary. So, and then I don't think I have anything else to report.

5:40:48 Okay, and then finally, I also attended the Business Excellence Awards. It's really just such a nice feeling to see our community, businesses honor and celebrate each other.

5:41:03 Went to the Town-County Liaison Meeting on November 6th with Mayor Pro Tem Rice, and I don't have a lot to report from that. Do you remember? Oh, yeah. I guess I went to that, too. You did. But I'm trying to remember if there's anything you want to talk about. I think it's just always a good opportunity for us to be sharing ideas with the county supervisors, and, you know, as I think...

5:41:27 Supervisor Salcido said, you know, we do work very well together, even if sometimes the paperwork is a hassle, so I think it's just nice that she was here. And then finally, the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance. We had that meeting today. See, good thing I looked back at my calendar, you two. So today was the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance. It was 36 hours ago this morning. And it's really, really gratifying to see. First of all, people,

5:41:56 Thanked and celebrated each other for the way that the communities came together, but also, you know, every time we go to one of those meetings, and right now we're still in formation, there are more people representing a greater area of the Sierra, there are local, federal, state representatives, nonprofits, you know,

5:42:19 I'm very happy to see more and more tribal members representing all of the tribes, or many of the tribes of the area, not all, joining us to find ways for us to bring the resources we need to take care of our own communities. So I'm grateful to everyone who's been participating in that. I know Lawson and Rob are heavily involved. Chief Tamire goes. So we are getting it done. And so thank you, everybody. And we are going to

5:42:47 Go into closed session now. For item 14.1, which is pursuant to government code section 54957.6A, we will have a conference with labor negotiators, the town council and its representatives, town manager, Rob Patterson, Community Economic Development Director, Nolan Bobroff, and human resources manager, Amanda, maybe by Zoom, with...

5:43:12 Jack Hughes, partner with Liebert Cassidy Whitmore, and this is with respect to the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association. So thank you everyone for this productive meeting and have a good night.