TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2026

Trails Committee

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

282 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:54 All right. Let's call this meeting to order. 301. Committee Member Souser? Present. Committee Member, excuse me, Patterson? Here. Committee Member Ostergaard? Committee Member Britton? Here. Vice Chair Draper? And Chair Connolly? Here. Thank you. All right. Item 2, public comments. Anyone here from the public with a comment?

2:40 And I have no comments online at this time. Okay. Then let's close public comment. And item three, we've got the consent agenda. We're looking for a motion to approve. Move to approve as presented. We'll second. Roll call. Committee Member Souser? Yep. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes. And Chair Connolly? Yes. Thank you.

3:18 All right. Item four reports. We've got our contract report up first. I need to do anything with Nicole. She's on, correct? I can kind of hear you. A little bit hard to hear, but Christy, I think you were cueing me up here. Yes. Thanks, Nicole. Okay. Can everybody see the first slide here? No, not yet. Okay. Hold on one second.

4:25 All right. Let's do this again. Share. All right. How about... We got it now. Now. Okay, cool. Let me start the slideshow here. Okay. All right. So, Christy, did you want to start or do you want me to start off? You can start through the first couple slides and then I'll jump in about slide three.

4:56 Okay, so we are sharing the fall-winter analytics for the reporting and seasonal transition. MammothTrails.org has been going since about 2012, and MTC has asked us to present this presentation. We typically do this to our partners two times per year, and we're bringing this forward to the group here. So I'm going to continue on here.

5:25 Our objectives today would be going over the MOU, why we are all here, the MLTS technical applications that are used on our MLTS website, reviewing our management team, also doing a year report, a fall, winter, year-over-year comparison so we can look at this year versus last year, a three-year seasonal traffic

5:54 Analysis on the past three years of the website mammothrails.org, and then going over some historical comparisons, learning how people are finding us on the web, also going over some referral traffic.

6:10 Reviewing the top 20 pages and also the top 20 QR pages. And by QR, that reference is when you're out on a trail and an individual scans on a sign or a wayfinding point and comes to the website from the location out on the field.

6:28 And then going over our seasonal transition, which is basically what we highlight on the website and feature as far as trails or destinations or activities for that particular season. And Christy, I'm going to hand this over to you just to give an overview of why we are all here.

6:52 Perfect. Hello. The voice from above is Nicole Whiten. She is the webmaster for the mammothrails.org website. She is an MLTPA employee. So while we're here, as Nicole mentioned, we have a partnership with the Forest Service Town of Mammoth Lakes, and as part of that, we are required to report in and check in twice a year.

7:19 Kim and Gretchen thought it would be a good idea to come in and give you all the same presentation. You all, those of you who've been on the committee for a while, see emails from me inviting you also to this partner presentation. You will receive emails to the partner presentation, which will happen in March. But this is a sneak preview. And so we'd love to hear your thoughts, your feedback. As the MTC, you are part of the TOML side of the partnership. So this is a sneak peek of the presentation that we will give to the partners.

7:49 Back in the day, this started as an MOU that was between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the Forest Service. Now it has morphed into part of the annual operating plan. So just a quick screenshot there of the annual operating plan and how that talks about the mammothtrails.org website. And I guess today what we want to do is, again, give you the sneak peek, but also so you understand

8:19 And see how mammothtrails.org enhances access and awareness of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, to strengthen the partnership and communications in managing and sharing accurate recreation information, and then also to align on next steps for improving. So we're happy to take any suggestions or comments or thoughts that you have to the broader partner meeting that's going to happen in March.

8:44 Quick note that the partnership itself is crucial because all of the content on the site is vetted and approved by the Forest Service and by the Town of Mammoth Lakes as well. So that means it's accurate, it's reliable, it's fully vetted and supported by the Forest Service. You probably all know this already, but almost all the trails in the trail system are on Forest Service land or under special use permits. So it really is a collaborative effort for the whole Mammoth Trails.

9:12 Okay, you can go to the next slide. I'm sorry this slide is so ugly and busy. But to frame it up, mammothtrails.org was built between 2011 and 2012. It was launched in 2012 and then there was a major update performed shortly after that in 2013. At the time it was funded by Measure R grant funds.

9:37 And it was created through a partnership among MLTPA, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and the Forest Service. The goal was to provide complete vetted information for visitors and for the community. At the time, there wasn't another platform that met the needs, which largely are based on the mapping that's required on the site. So the site was custom built on open source software.

10:05 A little bit of pros and cons, pros that it avoids, that you ever have a monthly fee or an annual fee for your CMS, for your content management system, but it also is a little bit more complex than, say, using WordPress or Wix or something like that, so it requires some expertise in the applications that we use.

10:22 On the left side is just a screenshot of the website handbook and that it's a long document but everything that we do is specified in the website handbook. There's standards in there, there's protocols, there's a lot of coding information and technical information but there's also basic information about like all of these platforms and maintaining the site involves

10:47 All of these platforms, which I think is around 20, maybe a little bit over 20, and applications, and we manage those, the subscriptions, and maintain the technical expertise to be able to manage those on behalf of mammothrails.org. Some of the platforms do have pass-through costs, and Kim and Gretchen asked me to flag those for you. So those are Amazon Web Services, which is our hosting platform, Google Workspace.

11:16 is fee-based. Google Cloud is not every month, but that is fee-based. And then the other one that we pay monthly on is Syncopa, which is the platform that allows us to have the photo galleries. Yeah, and just to speak to that a little bit, our site is built off of Django, so that is our CMS. Python is that programming language behind it.

11:43 Pretty much the world is our oyster. We could do whatever we wanted. We have no restrictions in terms of programming. I know we have restrictions in terms of costs to do that programming, but ultimately, anything can be done upon the platform. And as Christy had mentioned, Syncopa being our media base, that's how all the photos are generated and displayed on the website. We have chosen to do a third-party

12:10 Provider for several aspects of the website and the reason being is we don't have to maintain updates to technology and things like that. It's part of the third party's responsibility to make sure slideshows are running correctly and it's things that we don't have to worry about breaking essentially that wouldn't be part of our responsibility.

12:32 And in lieu to that, Share This is a social platform that we have. I know in the beginning when we were developing the website, we had decided that we wanted people to have the ability to share things on social media. So Share This actually gives the ability to...

12:51 Share any piece of content that's on the website out to pretty much any platform, social platform that is desired. If you were to go on the website and click that, share this platform, you'd see almost everything from Instagram to Facebook to any other tools that are out there. And then in the back end, we have Cloudflare, which is actually a security CDN

13:20 Tool that is used so we can guarantee that, you know, our site is secure and we're not going to see like a million bots affecting and crashing our website and just things like that. So there is a lot of really important technology that is built on top of this website that just assures that things will be secure and operating and up in, I mean, ultimately for

13:45 Since 2013, I can say that there has been a very limited amount of time that this site has gone down, maybe here or there if we've been working on things, but I am very confident that we have definitely a workhorse behind us based off of everything that we've built upon on the website.

14:03 And Christy, I know I kind of cut in. No, that's perfect. You are the expert in that area, so you saved me for sure on what all those do. The other one I'll just point out that does have a fee is Lightroom, but that's one that MLTPA has an account to anyway, and so that is not a cost that we pass on through. But it is helpful in processing photos. If you want to go to the next slide, Nicole, please. Okay. So we also were asked to elaborate a little bit more about the team.

14:33 And MLTPA, I think, as you all know, has a broader contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes, and so this is just one of the elements in the scope of services that we provide. But it, in essence, gives the Office of Outdoor Recreation access to our whole team. That said, these are the primary members of the team.

14:54 Who work on website functions. So I serve as the project management specialist. I've been with MLTPA off and on since 2007. I've managed the Mammoth Lakes Trail System project now for like a year and a half, almost two years. And I do manage other projects for MLTPA. Some of you have been on this committee long enough that you saw me giving updates for sustainable recreation and tourism initiatives and other projects.

15:19 But my primary role with the website is really to be the liaison between the Office of Outdoor Recreation and the web team and just making sure that things keep moving on if there are projects or if we find issues communicating that with this team here. Nicole Wyden is the webmaster from mammothrails.org. She's been with the site since its launch in 2013, I think, Nicole.

15:44 Handles content, updates, technical maintenance, seasonal transitions, analytics, reporting, helping us understand how folks engage with the trail system and the website. I'm going to skip really quick down to Kirsten. Kirsten Pusam is our creative director. She doesn't have a whole lot of website tasks, but certainly her skills are available if needed. She is a talented graphic designer. She supports any graphic production needed. She can help with copywriting as well.

16:13 Fun fact about Kirsten is that she actually did a lot of work with the Measure R campaign back in 2008, which, as we all know, created a consistent funding source for the trail system. Ray Van Winkle has been with MLTPA for almost 10 years, I believe. She's our photo and digital assets manager, and her primary role with the website is she's probably the one maybe between her and Nicole who are in the SMS the most, they're in the back end making updates.

16:43 Posting content, she does photo processing, and then she also, you may or may not know that there are daily updates posted from ISAC, from Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center, that go to the website, and she's the one who does those. Circling back up to Scott, so all the four of us are MLTPA employees, and our work is captured within the base structure of our contract.

17:10 Scott Howes is a subcontractor, and he is with a company called Voxelops, and his fees are passed through to the Office of Outdoor Recreation. So as you're looking at budget, that is not included. The work he does is not included in the MLTPA hours. But his background is with Spark Geo, who is the firm who built the website, who built mammothtrails.org.

17:34 And he brings such insight in his role as technical contractor. He manages the site technical infrastructure, cloud hosting, security, deployment pipelines to keep the platform reliable and up to date. Next slide, please, Nicole. Sorry we didn't put your photos. You too. So the other half of the team is the Office of Outdoor Recreation, right, in town of Mammoth Lakes.

18:00 And we rely on specifically Gretchen and Andrew mostly to be providing direction on strategy, content. If it's anything that has to do with the technical backend and making sure it's safe and secure, we have authority to do that. But if it's any sort of messaging or content updates, typically we are reviewing that or taking direction from Gretchen and Andrew. Gretchen's our main contact for website content and strategy. And she's also soon going to be managing the photo and image library. And then Andrew provides GIS support.

18:30 Usually it means he's like pulling a line out of the GIS, sending it over, we're uploading it into the CMS so that we can add new trails or if there's an issue with the trail cleaning, that kind of thing up. So together they guide the website's vision, ensure accuracy for all the users of the website. And I think that's the background that we probably haven't so much given you all in the past. I hope you find that helpful. And now the more interesting part of the presentation is to come with Nicole. Go ahead, Nicole.

18:58 All right. Okay. So I'm going to jump right in our year report. So we decided in this meeting we were going to do a seasonal. So for the rest of this, we're going to actually pull a winter season. But I wanted to pull in a slide to say, hey, what kind of traffic did we get from March 20th, 2025 to March 20th of 2026?

19:21 And it looks like we pulled about 138,357 sessions on the website. Fun fact, if I were to do an average over the last 13 years when the site first was launched, we were coming up with a number of 1.5 million sessions. So that's just kind of a fun thing to think about. Unfortunately, I don't have true historic data going back that far, but it is something that we wanted to bring forward to the group today.

19:52 And that being said, here is the fall and winter comparison report. So from last year compared to this year, we are up 2.74%. You can see we have over 45,000 visitors in the winter season. I'd say that traffic did remain stable year over year.

20:13 And you'll see in future slides that a lot of this is based off of organic search, and it is consistent with seasonal patterns. And by saying that, I mean, there is a lot of stuff that happens year to year. Like, for example, last year we had, or the year before.

20:30 The year before that, this past year, we had the Palisades Fire. Did that affect visitation? Did that affect people planning? Did that affect site visits? And it definitely could. And in a future slide, we'll kind of look at some historical data that could prove that statement. So moving forward, here's our three-year seasonal traffic trend. And bringing forward my theory on, you know, we did see some...

20:56 Events last year between Palisades Fire also was an election year. And I think that's where some of that influence comes from. But we did see a downturn from 2023 to 2024 into 25. And then you'll see we're back on the up here at 2.74% in sessions. And just to bring forward, my historical comparisons are a bit limited. And just to sum that up a little bit, basically,

21:30 Google loves to change things on us. Back in 2023 and prior, we used something called Universal Analytics, and they changed everything over to what's called GA4 Analytics, which actually is better reporting. We're getting more accurate data based off of users at this point, but it does really impact any type of historical data. It wasn't carried over, and there is big differences in how things were reporting.

21:59 But that being said, we can still use it as kind of a framework of what we had pulled, but it isn't true to say what's being pulled to this day. So I just want to bring that forward as to why we can't do like a pull from say 2013 to compared to this year.

22:20 I'm going to say the next slide here is going to be an archive traffic trends that I had pulled in the past. So you're going to see some dates that definitely do not align with my poll, but can give an idea of where we were at for our winter seasons based off of the GA4 tracking. So back in 2013, you can kind of see how, you know, we launched and there was huge growth. And then over the years,

22:48 to 2023 when they changed the reporting, you know, we had some fluctuation and we had pulled large snow years, we had the Lions Fire, we had COVID, and you'll just see how I think that kind of affected sessions to the website. And going into how people are finding us, so this is based off of our poll from our September

23:17 to March poll for the winter season. Again, organic search is our highest poll here and you'll see that direct comes next and then referral. I just want to be clear that organic search is basically how people are finding us.

23:35 They're typing in like Mammoth Trails, Duck Pass. It's coming up. They're clicking on the link and finding us through any SEO that's been done on the site. So we've always been highest in organic search. We do no marketing, paid advertising on our end for anything on this website currently. And that has been a very big thing about this website is our organic search has always been at the top. Can I ask a quick question? Yep.

24:10 Why doesn't Visit Mammoth link to you? Visit Mammoth does link to us. So that would be part of our referral traffic. And you will see that down in number eight, we had, this is our referral traffic broken down. But this would be, they had 57 clicks over their referral traffic from the direct from their website. Not like when I go to their hiking website, it's really doesn't like.

24:37 It just seems like the amount that they put in for paid advertising, that that should be a much 53. That's like nothing. That should be a lot higher, I think. So any paid advertising that they're doing is likely going to be direct to their website. So basically, that user would be clicking on their paid ad to their website, and then we'd be relying on a click from their website to our website. Does that make sense? Yeah, it makes sense.

25:06 There just seems like that should be a greater traffic source there. Yeah, if I can weigh in. Yeah, I 100% agree with you. Yeah, I think we all agree. Mammoth Lakes Tourism does sit in on the partner meetings. And I think that that is a great opportunity to try to expand use of the site, for sure. I do agree. Yep. 100%. And we always have.

25:27 We tried, and we do try to collaborate with them in terms of, you know, making sure we have the content accessible, and it's just a matter of them actually utilizing it in their marketing on a day-to-day. Thank you. Yep. I mean, we are still the only... Sorry, go ahead. We are still the only Trails website out there, so it does seem unusual that our tourism would not be a greater click-through, that there wouldn't be a Trails...

25:56 Landing page on their site that would then lead you to this site. I think there's huge opportunity there. I also want to give Nicole a second to talk a little bit about ChatGPT and AI, which was a big topic of conversation when we had our summer partner meeting. Nicole, do you want to weigh in on that part?

26:17 Yeah, I think it's a perfect time. We're on our referral traffic screen. You can see that I have highlighted ChatGPT. As you all know, ChatGPT has been changing the landscape of

26:30 The world, essentially, but especially the internet. Ultimately, when somebody goes and types into Google, they are now getting an instant Gemini response that pretty much summarizes everything they could find, whether it be from Visit Mammoth, whether it be from Mammoth Trails, whether it be from the town of Mammoth Lakes. Now, if a person on that end has typed in and

26:55 Felt that they got their answer from that Gemini response that pops up before any search result. They might not continue on and do a click to that website. So they might be like, oh, I got my information, I'm done, and stop there. And that's what Mammoth, or Visit Mammoth and...

27:15 MLT or us at the Mammoth Trails Org website had talked about in our last meeting is we are seeing a shift in traffic due to these AI bots coming in and kind of taking over. So to circle it back, I think there's two opportunities with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. They have their search bot on their Visit Mammoth website. And so just making sure that their search bot pulls first from this site is probably smart.

27:46 Additional links that they can add and push out, they know it is like verified vetted information. So I think that is a smart place to spend some time. Yeah, and part of me might think that, so if somebody is coming to plan a trip, they might stop at Visit Mammoth and not even click through. They might feel they got enough information on that Visit Mammoth website and they're not clicking beyond at that point. With chat GPT, what does that look like?

28:18 If someone makes a prompt and our website comes up, does that count as a visit? No. Or do they have to click on? They would have to click and actually get to our site for it to become a visit at this point, yes. But the positive is we have our organic...

28:40 SEO is very strong on our website and that is how our information is being pulled into ChatGPT. So the fact that ChatGPT is number three on this list tells me that the website is working as planned. We have a strong SEO and we're coming up third at this point in our referral traffic, which is very positive. Any other questions there? Mono County appears twice, once it's .ca.gov.

29:18 And what's this org? Are those the same things or are those? That is a great question. My assumption is maybe one is a subdomain and one is their actual domain. I am not off the top of my head. I'd have to make a note to answer that question clearly. Thank you. Yeah, we're happy to do. Happy to get back to you on that. And I think they are both Mono County, but why there's a difference in where it comes from, we can look into that.

29:56 Yeah, because I think they actually exist in the same space. Yeah. I just typed it in in monocounty.org. It seems to be their main site. But we can check on the other one. Yeah. Yeah. Let's dig in on that one a little bit. Thanks, Nicole. I think you can go to the next slide. Sure thing. Okay.

30:17 So here's our top 20 pages for our winter season. I just want to clarify that forward slash there is our homepage. Very typical for the homepage to be the number one page listed. Not set is a standard label for visits, as you can see in my bottom note, where page details aren't really passed through. These often come from app links, any sort of redirects from like GoGoDuck, which happens to be a browser which protects your privacy.

30:46 And things like that. So there are things that we're not going to be able to track based on users that have higher privacy settings. And then you can see, as we have here, we have forward slash trails, our trails page, off highway vehicles, which has always been very strong for several years. I think based on our poll from September 22nd to March 20th and our season, having a good

31:12 Bucket of four storms at this point. People probably were looking to maybe do things that weren't snow-related, so I feel that's why that was so high at this point for our winter season. But then trickling down to the other trails that were most our top pages here. I shouldn't say trails because these are destinations and activities as well. And then moving forward.

31:41 We have our top 10 QR code pages. I really like to put this into the presentation because I think it gives a really awesome view of, wow, people are out there and they're engaging with our trail content. And that is the core purpose of our website. Yes, people are at home planning their trips, but really our core purpose of this website, and I think we need to keep pushing on this, is engaging with those people out on the trail, having them scan when they're

32:10 You know, at the Hayden Cabin Trailhead and just really interacting with the site. And I think that says a lot to, you know, people actually being out there and we're bringing an on-site experience to individuals that are in our town. And then the spring-summer transition, these are just the pieces of content that we have built on the site that we will...

32:40 Feature on our homepages, our activity pages, our destination pages, and our trail pages throughout the spring and summer season. Right now, basically how our trail system works is we look at what's actively going out on the ground. We don't want to send people up to

32:59 The vista right now, because obviously that's not going to work out, so we really do look at what's happening and take an active approach to say, hey, okay, you probably want to walk on the town loop right now. There's not a lot of snow. So we do look at what's going out on the ground before we feature any of these destinations or activities or trails, but this is what you'll see us, you know, full-on summer rotating beyond and through. And that is my last slide, so I'm happy to answer any questions.

33:35 It's hard to compare the trends because of the GA4. But am I right that it's a general consistent decline in website sessions? I wouldn't say a decline. You can go back to that side if you'd like. So this would be, if we're looking at November to...

34:05 June here, if you look at 2023, we saw 56,000. And then we did see a decline. And again, I mean, this can go back to our conversation of there is no marketing going on to the website. We don't do any ads, things like that, that go directly to this website.

34:31 We have now AI that's taking over a little bit. I mean, there is a lot of factors that can occur to affect that stuff. Is marketing the best way to increase? Absolutely. Marketing and the other best thing to increase is just staying current. Right now, ultimately, we haven't put a lot of new content on the website.

35:01 And Google looks at that type of stuff. They say, okay, wow, this site hasn't posted anything new in a pretty long time and we don't get ranked as high, essentially. So that is some things to think about as we move forward down the road is developing content and keeping current of what's going on out there. That helps us in the long run. What would marketing look like? What is the cost or do you have any?

35:34 Clue on that? I mean, there's, I don't have a number, but there is a lot that we could do in terms of social marketing, email marketing. There's tons of stuff that, you know, we could put into a marketing strategy. So to answer that off the cuff, I don't think I could give a clear picture.

35:58 But there is definitely a lot that can be done, even in terms of like Facebook marketing, things like that. Just things to bring people to the website. But if that's some good, how would we then look at who is using the website? So for me to market it just to get more page views is almost senseless to market it in such a way. And I don't know what that would be.

36:24 But to mark it in such a way so that we are actually getting out to the trail users who need it to find that information, that might make some sense. Yeah, and I do want to bring up, now to cut you off there, there was a time, and Chrissy, I don't know that you can answer this, but there was a time that we left, and maybe Gretchen might be able to answer this.

36:48 We left QR code cards at the Welcome Center. We used to leave them at Footloose and leave them pretty much all over the town. That, to me, is something we were doing very early on in the website or when it launched and years passed. I don't know if we're still doing that, but that might be something we want to think back on is

37:09 You know, we have a trail user here. Let's give them information. I don't know, and I can't answer that just being, you know, managing the website. I'm not managing the people that are out on foot. But to me, if I were going to say, hey, I'm in Mammoth, hand me something that makes me aware of your trail system, that's what I would want to see, ultimately. I can. And I think that goes back to like.

37:33 Okay, Mammoth Lakes is very like, okay, we get our news through the sheet, which is very different than Southern California gets their news. So I think we need to take a look at, you know, that sort of aspect of things. I can answer that question about the handouts. My host team carries those in their pockets, and we have distributed them throughout town continually the past.

37:57 Seven years that I've been here. One of my staff members actually told me this winter she uses them as the adult gift and gives the stickers to the kids when she's talking to them and hands the QR code to Mammoth Trails to the adults. It's just a small little token. But yeah, we still are using those. And I do think that is active marketing of the website. So we do market the website.

38:25 I mean, ultimately, I would love to be a little bit more proactive with our relationship with MLT. And reason being is they are the marketing engine. And we need to depend on them as using this website as the authoritative source of the trail system. And if people are out planning, we need to put it in front of them. And I do feel maybe there has been a...

38:53 Decline in that push. And again, I'm just, you know, kind of managing the website from a back-end standpoint, but maybe there's a decline in that push on the marketing team to get this trail system in front of people planning. I can speak a little bit to that too in the recent years. I work closely a lot with MLT just in the stewardship realm and that type of stuff. And like Kim and I brought some.

39:22 Stewardship Videos, that whole It's a Mammoth Thing started from us, and they are actively using our site as a resource and putting it through all their social medias, linking it on the It's a Mammoth Thing campaign page. So they are supporting us. Could it be more? Probably. Yeah. Everything could always be more. It probably is. Yeah. There's so many dynamics. So have we ever reached out to the, while there are fewer of them than ever at this point?

39:50 But have we ever reached out to the user groups? There are cross-country ski groups, there are equestrian groups, there are off-highway groups, Blue Ribbon Coalition, there's all of these groups that may be more than willing to put a QR for us or a landing page for us on their sites at no cost because it enhances their site as much as ours. Mammoth is an incredibly popular destination to some people's dismay.

40:20 Maybe one item ahead on the agenda, Billy. What's that? One item ahead on the agenda. We'll talk about that in a minute. And I think those groups were largely very involved in creating the website back in the day and generating the content and doing the reviews. And you'll see there's experience pages. I don't know how familiar you are all with the site, but those are people who went out and used that asset. You probably wrote some of them yourself. Exactly. I think it's a great idea. I think that right now...

40:48 You know, figuring out like that mix of do you want to be hitting people while they're here? Do you want to be hitting people before they get here? All great ideas. And Gretchen definitely takes the lead on, as you can tell, on the marketing side. She's more familiar with all the marketing partnerships and what's going on. But great idea. So we can go ahead. No, I just said I agree. Great idea. We can certainly reach back through to MLT and see if there's a way in which we can get.

41:19 Things a little bit tighter. One quick question on ADA compliance for websites that's coming about here, sort of emerging. I know from the town, this is Rob Patterson, town manager, town of Memphis. We have Civic Plus as our main website for the town, or manages our website for the town. I know that we have a lot of interesting things coming down for the website.

41:47 Management under ADA, and I was wondering how that's going to affect some of the intricacies of these maps and other systems on this website. Yeah, I actually just brought this up at a higher level. Christine, not with you. I was talking to John Wentworth about accessibility and...

42:04 I've seen it come up a lot in the e-commerce world right now where it's becoming a major issue. So I did bring that up and it is something that I think we are going to start looking at. It is very important.

42:20 I did run Mammoth Trails through a test and we were looking fairly good. I think we were in the green, but what needs to be done from a back end as well was an accessibility statement and some of that. So I know Christy and Gretchen in the room have not heard this yet. This is something I just recently started to kind of dig into in the last couple weeks here.

42:47 From what I saw, we are in okay shape. There are some things that we will want to do and consider. That being said, there needs to be some work done in the back end, and I'd like to bring that up at a different time because I don't have clear answers at this moment. Okay, thank you. Second thing is a little bit about the slide that you had where we had the number of sort of supportive subscriptions to support the website, and I think I counted 15.

43:17 Different agencies associated with that. Is that a typical for any website or is that substantial for the type of website we have here? I don't know enough about it to be dangerous, but...

43:30 Yeah, I mean, I would say for our website, it is typical. We did bring in pretty much every piece of technology here. I mean, things like some of our DevOps and deployment stuff like CircleCI, that's used to do some automated testing and deployment. Stuff you guys would not see on a day-to-day, but technologies we want to say is, hey, we're using this. It's important for us to do testing in the back end.

43:56 Things like that, like we had brought forward. Cydcopa is a third party, which we had built this site based off of third party software, so we didn't have to bring things in-house and spend more development dollars. But ultimately, I would say typical on other sites that I do manage. For example, some e-commerce sites that I manage that we have 50 plus apps running in the background.

44:20 So I would say it is a very typical situation. I mean, things like Google Analytics, like that's just kind of on top of your website, Cloudflare on top of your website. So I wouldn't say it's stuff that's used every day, but it is stuff that definitely builds out the site from a technical perspective. Nicole, so the QR codes, I see that the code that...

44:50 The QR code that Gretchen was talking about is not on the top 10 page. I assume that her QR code would register as a direct... Yeah, it's not a question. Well, I think... Oh, I see what you're saying. The QR code, that would go to the homepage. So basically, that would trigger a homepage count. So... You can track the... You could track the individual QR code, obviously.

45:19 So these Q, so how can I put this? So each QR code that's out on the trails relates to a webpage that it renders to, essentially. So it has a different URL, but the cards that Gretchen is currently handing out goes directly to the homepage. So that's part of our homepage count at this time. Does that make sense? Nicole, correct me if I'm wrong, but what's in your report are actual signs in the field.

45:49 These are signs in the field. Now in the future what we could do, and to answer that question, if we ever wanted to track Gretchen's cards that she's passing out, we could put a special code on it essentially in the back end and kind of track and manage that. So before we did a reprint on the code, if that's something we'd want to track, we could definitely do that and we are not doing that to this point. I think that would be an effective way of seeing how

46:19 Well, that's a good idea. Okay. So, Gretchen, before we do a reprint, maybe we can collaborate on that and get you a trackable code there. And maybe also a code for sports shops or rental. Like, that would be an interesting thing. If those are also at the Footloose counter or whatever, get a count on that to see where, if that traffic is on. Yeah. We could definitely do that. We would have to be...

46:47 Very good about where we're distributing those cards based on the fact of where we're putting them if we're going to be tracking at specific locations. How do you feel like apps have taken away visits? I know when I go somewhere, I look at AllTrails or Mountain Bike Project or whatever it is. Do you feel like that's taken away? Any impressions on that?

47:20 Would say yes. It's another place for people to go. People get comfortable in those apps. So to answer that question, I would say yes. And I guess my follow-up question is, I find that the map on the website is not as good as, it's not as user intuitive. And so is there a plan in the future to potentially move to an app to use something like that that would be more friendly for people on the trails?

47:50 Do you use the web-based version of your phone? I do, yeah. You use your phone? Or do you use your laptop? Like if I'm just here, if I was out on a trail right now, this is like not that great. You know what I mean? Whereas like if I'm on the same map on all trails, it's much easier. Yeah, I think it's a great suggestion. And certainly we defer to what y'all want to do. I don't think we stop supporting this website just because there's so much value in...

48:18 The fact that it is so vetted, it is approved by the Forest Service, AI is going to cull through that. But whether you also want to have an app, maybe, like, do you want to be the only game in town? Or do you feel fine that they use Strava or Alta? Like, do you care? Is that something you want to invest in? Great questions, for sure. Yeah, and I don't know if it maybe that doesn't make sense, but I'm just thinking that, yeah, it's hard to keep up with those platforms. Or is there a way that we can...

48:46 Use those platforms, have, you know, you click on a trail, then it provides a link so that you can jump to all trails or Gaia or whatever to get on that trail and utilize your navigation that those apps provide. Yeah, I agree. There's nothing better than coming somewhere and having to download an app to do something. That's true. That was true. Good point. And I just wanted to jump in, you know,

49:17 It was a long time ago when I was asked to preview the website and, you know, it might even be 20 years ago. And, you know, it's got a lot of old pictures in there. I'm ripping around on a dirt bike with my brother. But this is a very, very old platform. And nowadays, if I was going somewhere like Duck Pass, I would just check with my buddy on chat, say, tell me what I need to know about Duck Pass.

49:46 And I'd get all the info. I wouldn't have to clunk around on a platform that you got to search everything out. And by the way, don't forget your chapstick. You know, it's got just a lot of info that 20 years ago was really cool. And now we're like talking about like, do we need to save our payphones? It's been a long time since there was a content overhaul. And we've been doing...

50:13 Like you guys asked us to do a website audit just for accuracy last year, right? And just make sure the information is still accurate. But yeah, like doing a whole photo refresh would be amazing, for sure. If you use ChatDBT, the making... We could do any, like I said, the site is built with pretty much no limitations. We can make any updates, mapping, visual updates, updating the...

50:39 The whole look and feel of the website. The other thing I do want to say is, I think someone in the room mentioned, you know, going to chat and looking for duck pass. I want you to keep in mind that all of the information and content on the website is still being fed into Google and pulled into, say, chat GPT or whatever you're searching. So that is something very important to consider. Yeah, I'm sure it is, but it's also pulling from other places too. Correct.

51:08 And the thing is, if you can get all the websites and the best info at once, you know, maybe we don't need tourism to, you know, look back on and say, hey, you're not driving enough people to us because everyone's getting their information from somewhere. And, you know, this is, it's just old. And so the idea is like, you know, you're not gonna

51:37 You know, make it fresher and better that it's the number one thing because there's smarter things out there already. So it's just something to keep in mind. So interesting concept there. When you go to chat GPT or any of the new search engines, I've been grouped by them twice already, they pull from our site. So some of the maps that come up will be maps from this site.

52:05 Does that clock in as a visitation? How do they electronically go about doing that? Because I don't know. If this site goes away, then some of those maps that chat produces goes away. So in the end, how do you make a business model where you're not providing another company that's making billions of dollars free information? And the internet is crowdsourced, right? So if you have an authoritative source drop out,

52:34 Then now what is going to fill the void is maybe garbage. Maybe it's your review of something on a different platform, right? And it's your personal opinion and it's not necessarily the vetted information. I will say that some of your trails change, but like a lot of the trails don't actually change. So like written content that describes a trail or a GIS line for a trail.

53:01 Shouldn't change in 20 years if there hasn't been a change that's happened to it. And, you know, I think that's where some of the value is, right? There's just this body. It's like, do you like to go to the library, right? Like, there's a body of information that's available. But, and I will also want to correct that the platform's not old. Like, the technologies are kept current and up-to-date and modernized. But I do agree that the...

53:30 Content could be refreshed. And if you're putting an experience together that has a lot of editorial and narrative, like maybe we add more experiences, maybe we do another round of photos and put more current photos so that you're not seeing John Connelly on his bike back in 2010 or whatever. Barring enough, I'm still there. I'm just saying that's where it started. Yep.

53:53 I don't think you want to like throw the baby out with the bath water, but I think you want to be very aware of new technologies and what's available. And is it an app or is it leaning into AI? Mammoth Lakes Tourism is getting really very good at the analysis of AI. They're the ones who've been working with us to tell us how it overlays. I mean, Nicole knows some beyond that as well, but I've been talking to them about it. And so I think that there are absolutely things that you...

54:21 Kind of want to pick up the rock and look around and look at it. But the fact that a trail itself doesn't change is okay. And to keep that information out is okay. Yeah. And if the website went away, the trail that never changed would still be out there. It doesn't like all of a sudden disappear just because the website turns off. Yeah. Right. I think that for me, the purpose of the website is to get people the information.

54:50 To either go out on the trails or decide on a trail. And so it doesn't matter if they're going to ChatGPT or if some other company's profiting, as long as the individuals who want the information about our trail system are getting it, the website is serving its purpose. And so I think it's important to keep it up. And just because it's been written, the trail hasn't changed for 20 years.

55:20 Rewriting the description doesn't mean that it's wrong. It just could benefit the website and benefit the information and all these new ways of finding information. And that would certainly benefit SEO for sure is to just even change a few words, right? Yeah. Yeah. And I would say, I mean, we're at the brink of such a change with chat GPT and AI and all of it just to kind of stay in it.

55:47 You know, we are tracking well, and I feel like we are coming up in those chats, and that's very important. If we weren't coming up in chat GPT, I'd say, okay, guys, we have a problem. I don't know what's next in this whole AI world. I don't think anybody truly does, but we all need to stay on top of it and be ready to move and kind of keep the site going with it. I guess the question that I'm left with at the end of this presentation is, are we...

56:17 Should we update the website? Should we do an overhaul now, soon? Or is that just something that we're looking to do on the horizon to keep our traffic up, to keep the information flowing about these trails? Well, and looking at AI and the future technologies that are coming down the road, while today this website is being used in a lot of different ways,

56:45 You also have to do the cost analysis. Is it reaching, is it being cost effective for what we're spending on? That is a huge, you know, I don't know what the answers are. I'm feeling a little guilty today because I haven't gone and looked at the whole trails website in years, even though I, you know, did a lot of the winter, helped with a lot of the winter content. I know that in the original contract, we did actually have someone looking at

57:14 The photos and everything else, and they were being upgraded at some point. Where that stopped, how that got out of the contract, why we aren't doing that anymore, I don't know. I will find out. But today I don't know where we're at, what the cost is to the town. I am a little guilty of not having delved deep enough into this subject. Yeah, and I know, yeah, we used to have a field photographer.

57:41 That was available and able to go out and take photos. We processed them into a photo library and I know that is changing. Part of that though was because like you needed a really nice camera and you needed a professional and now like iPhones can take really nice photos and so like thinking it through and understanding the process of how to generate additional photo content would be fabulous. We'd love to be able to rotate some of those photos out.

58:10 Bill, we've spent $8,500 so far this year on website, operation, and photo library. Yeah, and again, I don't know what that really gets us compared to what is coming down the pike. I mean, we need to keep an open mind on what we're doing and where we're going. And I'm not sure, what are you guys, maybe this is a loss in question, is there a certain thing you're required to keep up with your operating agreement with the Forest Service or no?

58:45 Lawson Rafe, Office of Outdoor Recreation, I mean, technically, by the letter of the law, yeah. We don't get much engagement in that space. Well, going back to the origination of this website, it was a fight with the Forest Service to be allowed to put in what we put in. You'll notice there are no Mammoth Creek Trails because technically, according to the Forest Service, they don't exist, so we're not allowed to put them in, while that would certainly be one of our big draws.

59:15 The contract with the Forest Service was pushed by us in order to create the website and get the permission to put on it the things that we did put on it. Just an interesting, I was just perusing a little bit here, not to be on my all trails horse here, but like, so I was checking out Visit Truckee, right? And so they give a nice description of their, you know, do your Mars Valley loop, and then it links to all trails from there. And not that I'm saying that, I just think.

59:46 If you look at all trails of Mammoth, the users are like, it's insane. People are posting, you can see people posted 10 times last week about how the loop is or whatever. But I think it's just something important to, back to the money thing, is just keep looking at what the value is of the website, how people are interacting with it, and if people are really using apps the most, then...

1:00:10 Work with those apps to make that the place where people are going to go and maybe provide more information on like the actual user experience. Like I think people like when they go to an area to see green, blue, you know, black diamond type things so that they kind of know like, oh, like that's a good one for this. So more of a, if people are doing a deep dive, they want to know more about the actual trail and then going elsewhere for the map. So just a thought. I think paying attention to other.

1:00:38 Mountain Communities is always important, so. Just a quick note on all trails. Gretchen set up a meeting with their kind of GIS back-end map guy, and we got to talk with him a bit, and he set us up with basically land manager access, more or less, right, to be able to kind of vet some of the information that's on their platform. And I dug in a bit, and

1:01:08 You know, I've always kind of been curious about that over the years, like anybody can populate a trail on trail forks, right? So we build a new trail, I'll go put it up on trail forks, but is that part of my job? I don't know. And then with all trails, the way they're, trails are organized is pretty interesting. It's not by trail, it's by experience. So I noticed like, oh, their line for the meadow trail connector is a little bit off.

1:01:37 I want to go fix that. But then when I go into their back end or, you know, I have to submit things to them and have them upload it basically. But it's tricky because I can't just go in and say, oh, I want to grab this trail segment and fix it. It's actually, they don't have a metal trail connector. They have a, somebody created an experience where you start at Panorama Dome and you ride the Mammoth Rock Trail and then you connect over to Sherwin Lake Trailhead and there's no differentiation.

1:02:05 on their map of which trail you're on. It's just an experience line. So that was a kind of a major flaw I saw in their system based on the way my brain works and the way trail segments are organized. But to your point, a lot of people are using it. And so I think we're invested in how can we make this thing as accurate as possible and be supportive of

1:02:30 Good information on that platform and all of them, you know, I mean, personally, he's Gaia with trail forks loaded into it, and that kind of gets me everything I need. But, yeah, so we've been kind of tracking these things. Another one's Outer Spatial, and that's one that's been talking to this guy for years now, but he's really expensive, but he makes a really slick app-based product.

1:02:56 That's popular with like state parks down in SoCal. So I thought it might be a good fit for us. Like, you know, you don't want to go somewhere and have to download a new app necessarily, but maybe a lot of our users are coming up from there and are already exposed to this thing. It's just got a huge annual operating fee, but it allows you to have full kind of customizability of experiences and GIS data on the back end as a land manager, you know, partner.

1:03:26 Recreation Manager. So it's complicated. There's so many different sources, but we're trying to pay attention and keep an eye out for a good solution. But I appreciate everybody's thoughts and digging into it here together. I think it's really helpful. Caroline, I would wonder if they have a resource. I think it's pretty unique what we have here.

1:03:53 I almost compare it more to like Mammoth Mountain. They're going to own their trail map, right? Like they're not going to outsource that and let you go try to get that information somewhere else. They want to control that. If you own a business in town, you don't want to just rely, I mean, there are a few that just rely on a Facebook page or Yelp, right, to provide the information. But I think, I mean, you guys manage this.

1:04:18 Like this amazing asset in town, right? It is one of the premier recreation assets in town. And so part of managing that is also owning, I think, things like the website, the narrative. We've talked a lot about reviews because we do have a review function on the site, but more people are used to reviewing just going into Google or Yelp, right? You might even find a trail in Yelp somewhere. So you don't want to shut people down and not allow them to.

1:04:47 Access information where they want it, but you also want to, like, I think, own your stuff, I think. Not that I have much say, but that's my editorial on there. All right. Well, any more comments for Nicole or Christy? And I'm not saying, you know, we don't want to own our trails, but at some point, you have to look at, you know,

1:05:19 Where the information is coming from. And it's changing a lot. And so this is a, to me, it's a very old platform and technology. I was a young man when it came out. I'm not anymore. So we can say it's new and refreshed, but it's really not. It's quite old. And due to that, you know.

1:05:47 We don't have to look at another organization and say like, hey, they're not boosting our numbers, what's wrong with them? I think the numbers are going to get smaller and smaller over time, and it's okay, but just realize that's going to happen. And, you know, it's not throw more marketing dollars and pump up visitation to a website that, you know, it's not, it's relevant, but it's not super relevant in the way people.

1:06:15 access information. That's all. Just my thoughts. But any other comments before we move on? We've got a healthy agenda. I don't want to get stuck too long. You know, we could test its effectiveness by sending people down to fish the settling ponds and see if anybody goes. Sorry. Last question. Do we have numbers from Nordic Pulse on visits to our...

1:06:45 Is that something that can be? Not offhand, but we can get those. Yeah. Thank you all for listening. Happy to answer any questions. You can route questions to Kim or Gretchen, and we're happy to follow up. I took a couple notes on things to follow up with already. Thank you. Thanks for the report. Thank you, everyone. Okay. We're at item 4.2, Trails Program Manager Report.

1:07:20 All right, Trails Program Manager Andrew Mulford. I'll buzz through this thing so we can get on to our discussion about the committee itself. But just wanted to give you a quick rundown of priorities going into the summer season. As you're all aware, you know, we've got about five miles done of the sharp trails last summer, and that'll be our...

1:07:45 You know, number one priority is continuing construction on those. So we're purchasing a compact mini excavator. That should be in hand mid-May. Thanks, Rob, and leadership from the town to get that thing pushed through. Town council. Yeah. So super excited about that. It's going to have a hydraulic thumb and all the attachments. Yeah. We're going to have a puppet show. We'll bring it in here.

1:08:13 Move some stuff around. So anyways, I'm going to a conference in Boise, leaving tomorrow, but a big part of going to that is a mechanized trail construction workshop that I'm going to be going to. That's four days, and then bringing down a really experienced equipment trail builder from Quincy to do a week of just in-house training with me and the crew so that we're rolling off on the right.

1:08:41 Track with that piece of equipment. But that's going to help us to move a little quicker and also just relieve some physical stress on the crew. Last year we had a lot of overuse injuries and it became apparent that if we want to build sustainable trails, we need to develop a little more sustainable model for actually building those trails and not be kind of burning through humans. Anyways, so...

1:09:07 We've got about eight miles left to build, and along with that, we've got 7.6 miles of trails that we traded in, more or less, right, user-created trails that we need to make go away. So we'll dive into that, too, which is going to be, you know, decompacting the soil, seeding native plants, blocking them off so people don't use them, stuff like that. So that's a ton of work. We're going to, you know, get as much of it as we can done this year.

1:09:36 Concurrently, we just want to make sure that the Sharp 4 project keeps moving forward. So, you know, I'm going to be aware of that and pulling away from the crews as needed to make sure that I'm working with the interdisciplinary team at the forest and forest leadership, rec officer staff, stuff like that to make sure that thing keeps moving. It's been dragging a little bit, but, you know, we keep...

1:10:03 Keep in touch with our forest partners, and we've got a contractor kind of waiting in the wings, ready to go once the scope of work for the archaeological work that needs to be done out there gets drafted by the archaeologists at the forest. More information as it comes along there, but should be moving that thing forward, and we're still optimistic that we get the NEPA done for that this summer season and have it available as a project to work on in 2027.

1:10:33 We ordered a bunch of new signs for the new trails that we built. There's six new trail segments. Unfortunately, they're like 12 weeks out, so it looks like they'll probably show up first week of June, which is, you know, would have been okay in a normal snow year, but it's a little late. I want to go back a little. What's up, Bill? I have a question. So we talk about redoing the what is called user-created trails out there. Yeah. However, there is no rule against...

1:11:03 Hiking cross-country. This was part of the NEPA decision, that this was work that we committed to. No, and I understand that. I just sort of, for those who work on trails, we keep talking about keeping people on specific trails and everything else, but there are no rules mandating that. Sure, but as recreation managers...

1:11:26 In good faith as forest partners, you know, it's something that we agreed on that building a sustainable trail is meant to focus traffic here. If you want to go walk stripes through the sagebrush, by all means, but we're going to make those historic kind of scars on the landscape go away to the best of our abilities. Yeah, and I appreciate that we are doing that, believe me, although a lot of those out there were created by cows, not people. Sure. But I guess a cow is a user, right? So that's the way of it.

1:11:55 I just, we keep talking about doing this, and I want to make sure everybody understands that, yes, if you see something you want to go see, you don't, you can go see it. You don't have to just stand on the trail. For sure. Yeah. Yeah, we're going to try and make it, you know, as natural of a process and try and keep away from creating more eyesores to keep people off of these things, right? And, you know, as limited amount of signage, that type of thing.

1:12:26 And it's a new process for us, so we're going to learn a lot. New signs, so those will go in early June, as soon as they get here. At that same time, we'll be blasting it on our socials. Here are these six new trail segments. We're working on developing a handout map to give to people via the host program. I've been getting a lot of personal requests or folks hitting me up, hey, where's the new trails? So it's obvious that we need to get that information out there.

1:12:54 You know, more permanent collateral will be developed as we finish up the remaining eight miles, but we want to get stuff out there to make sure people know how to find these things. We've got a bridge project up on Coldwater George Trail that has been, you know, on our list and didn't get to last year, but that's going to be a technical project of skidding in some big

1:13:23 Down trees that we're going to be able to mill into a replacement bridge there. So that'll be on our high priority list. And as always, we're going to run our normal volunteer events and keep up with maintenance of the entire network as usual. So that's it in a nutshell. Any questions about our summer program work? I know that Keith has retired and that we helped out the U.S. Forest Service a lot last year.

1:13:53 Has there been conversation with whoever from within their ranks? Yeah, yeah. Taking that over? Keith Dolly, Trails Manager for the Forest, you know, he was around for quite a long time. Definitely going to miss him. But just in the last few weeks, I've been meeting with Tim Tolleson. He's, you know, out there on the trails, really epic volunteer.

1:14:20 Forest, right? He's been kind of collating reports of downed trees and things, and so we decided kind of internally, you know, we'll keep that information rolling forward until May 3rd when Clancy Nelson comes back on. He's a permanent seasonal for the forest who's going to be basically stepping into that role that Keith was, I don't know what his official title is going to be, but

1:14:46 Clancy, between Clancy and then Evan Topol as the Wilderness Trails Manager, I think we will, you know, shoot to get everybody back together after that May 3rd date when some of those forest staff are back on and figure out roles and responsibilities and I would assume that we're going to continue to do some maintenance over Mammoth and Duck Passes, but I haven't heard officially if they're going to be relying on us for that this year. Awesome. All right.

1:15:18 So, real quick, just because we just had the webpage updates and all of that, do you guys ever go onto the Mammoth Trail site and change the information as you alter the trails or as you see something on the trails? Because I know it was built that way. I don't know if it's, as I said, I haven't paid close enough attention.

1:15:38 As we build new trails, we send that information over to MLTPA and they build out new pages, you know, so like Black Bear Run, it's probably the last one we did, Meadow Trail Connector, so we're keeping up with, you know, infrastructure as it's added, but in terms, I wouldn't say that it has, there's a trails update function, right, or alert, so sometimes, you know, like,

1:16:07 2017, we were updating it to say, hey, it was a really big winter, trails below this elevation are melted out, because that was kind of a good way to get that information out to people. But yeah, so there is that function that's like some somewhat nimble, I guess. But otherwise, it's just updating as we build new infrastructure. So how do we disseminate information when something happens?

1:16:35 As an example, this winter, at the end of the winter, but when it was still very rideable, several roads got plowed in the forest. Right. And I know there was a Facebook post, but I don't go on Facebook enough to see it. So I was very surprised when I went out in the forest to see it. Do we put that information on the trails website? And just a quick recommendation, my phone number still gets called quite a bit, people asking me about trail information. If I don't get that information,

1:17:04 And, you know, I'm an old guy. So when something like that happens, when it's going to be done, if you could shoot at least this group of people that information in an email, if you get the information, because I know we don't always, that would be hugely helpful for me at least. So when someone asks me, I'm not standing there with my mouth open going, I don't know what you're talking about. Yeah, I think in the winter we should communicate more frequently.

1:17:34 I posted some updates to Nordic Pulse when I got information about logging operations and roads being plowed out off the scenic loop. There was a lag there because I was waiting for kind of vetted information to come directly out of the forest and they told me it would be coming and then it never did come. So then I just put some stuff up there based on what I was seeing. Did that get translated to Mammoth Trails.org? We push Nordic Pulse on socials.

1:18:05 And that gets on to mammothtrails.org using our new widget to have social media on the homepage. So people can find the information. It's just a matter of, like, it all is interconnected in a way because Instagram goes to mammothtrails.org, which has the Nordic Pulse on it. I don't know how we can, we could probably make it easier for people. I don't know.

1:18:34 So we have notify me is a lot of the things that the town is doing. Do we have a notify me for updates to this type of activity? We currently have a Mammoth Trails email list that is housed through our contractor, MLTPA. So if we wanted to send an email, we can do that at any time to that list.

1:18:57 We also, I internally just started a Civic Send. It's Notify Me, except a little nicer because I can put photos in it. Notify Me is just a text thing to consumers. So our Civic Send list is new and we have not, I haven't begun the process of that being notified to the public yet. I haven't started marketing it or advertising it.

1:19:22 We need to make a full plan because we're shifting away from the contractor overseeing that next fiscal year. And so we will be doing it in-house through the Civic Send Town of Mammoth Lakes platform. So it's coming. But we still could send that update information to our list of emails that we have right now, which I think is about 1,500 emails. I only care one. I'm sure you're on the list.

1:19:54 We should coordinate like a trails opening celebration. The trail's great. Whenever that happens, be it in the fall or something, it'd be fun to get a bunch of the user groups together and do a ride or run or whatever you want to do and have some sort of, I don't know, festivities. Yeah, that'd be awesome. I know I talked to Mike Braun quite a lot and he's planning on using most of the new routes in some of his first rides out there.

1:20:24 There's some of some of his first rides out there, so it's exciting. But yeah, we should definitely get everybody together. Ribbon cutting, anytime we do a trail. Ribbon cutting. Or a town center. That sounds good. All right, well, thanks for the report. I'm really interested to see how, you know, the dozer cut trail will be compared to the hand cut, but I'm sure there's a lot of hand cutting required anyways when you're going around boulders. Yeah, that's kind of the plan.

1:20:58 Have it be blended, not totally machine built, leave a lot of natural obstacles and build around those with hand crews so that we don't get rid of that kind of flavor. Yep. That sounds good. Okay. We're on item 4-3, outdoor recreation program manager report. Thanks, John. That's me. That's me. Gretchen Haswar.

1:21:25 I just have a few highlights to share from the report itself. Number one and most importantly is I'm going to be hosting Trails Trivia at Mammoth Brewing Company on June 5th and I hope you all can attend. We will be celebrating our new beer, the Singletrack Red, so you'll get a free taster of that and you can try and win trivia.

1:21:45 So that kind of kicks off our summer of stewardship, and then following that we'll be doing our weekly offerings of Wednesday work nights, the second Wednesday of every month. We added a new stewardship program, Tangle Free Waters Clear the Line event, which will be once a month as well, the third Tuesday of every month, where we are actually focusing on clearing fishing line and things from our lake.

1:22:10 And then the other thing I wanted to highlight was Trashy Thursdays. That used to be a weekly event this summer. It is going to be a monthly event, and that'll be the last Thursday of every month. So I am hopeful that the setup of once-a-week volunteer opportunities, different nights a week, where we're giving dinner every time. So come get some food after you volunteer at each of our events will work. The other thing I wanted to highlight is our Adopt-a-Trail.

1:22:36 Program is continuing. It's now in its sixth summer, and we have only four locations that did not get adopted this year, so we're pretty happy with that. And then for outdoor recreation host programming, again, we're continuing, hoping to have a bunch of hosts out there this year at the trailheads along the bus stops and in town, and the thing I wanted to highlight with that program this year for you guys is that we are going to focus

1:23:05 On the local wildlife information to the public and the invasive species information of the golden mussel and that threat that is coming, hopefully not coming, but get that information out. So this, my host team is going to really support those two efforts this year strongly. Does anyone have any questions about stewardship programs and or the host program this summer? I hope to see you guys at all of the events. You said free dinners? Free dinners, John. Who's making them?

1:23:36 Different people. The Wednesday work nights and Tangle Free Waters are all going to be barbecue dinners, community barbecue, so that'll be our staff manning the grill. Andrew got a sweet new grill for this summer. Trashy Thursdays, we have a little bit more financial support with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the town, and so we're actually going through local businesses. I think we're doing Stellar Brew, Capybara Empanadas,

1:24:05 Oh, we are doing one grill out with MLPD support, and then the final wrap-up will be with Latin Market. So lots of food opportunities. A lot of burgers and hot dogs, too. That sounds good. Anybody else? Thank you. All right. Next item 4.4, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Budget Update. Who's doing that one? Hello. Lawson Rafe, Office of Outdoor Recreation.

1:24:37 You should, in your packet, have the most recent budget update. I know I was out for the last MTC meeting, and I do want to explain kind of where we're at, especially as it relates to staffing maintenance, as it relates to winter grooming as well. You may have seen in my staff report the estimated amount of money we're going to spend on seasonal employees to get us into the new fiscal year.

1:25:07 Thank you so much.

1:25:33 I did not do a formal reallocation request. But what I would do is pull that remainder of $17,000 out of winter grooming and moving it into trail and trailhead maintenance to support Andrew's staff that will be on for roughly one month within this fiscal year. But all in all, we are on target. I think we, per usual, have tried to

1:26:04 Spend our dollars wisely, but I will say this is some of the most we've spent since I've been in my position this year, and I think a lot of that is a byproduct of some expanded staff support for Andrew last year with sharp implementation. Obviously, that was a big project moving forward, so we had more seasonal staff that last summer and extra seasonal lead as well, which costs more.

1:26:32 But I think those are good problems. Actually out there building trail, if any of you have been out there on what Andrew's put out on the ground, it's pretty amazing so far and looking forward to continuing that this year. But as you can imagine, the winter grooming season, not ideal. I want to remind everyone that these are the non-moto groomers that come out of this.

1:26:56 The state-funded OSV system, we fund those staff through general fund and then get reimbursed through the state. So you may be wondering why that's so low. How could that, you know, be some of Andrew's time and our other groomers' time, you know, because they were out a lot during those storms. So just a reminder that that is just the non-moto grooming that would occur between the ranger station and Shady Rest Park and out at the Sherwins.

1:27:24 That just because we have fewer storms doesn't mean we have less grooming. Often it means we have more grooming to keep the trails in reasonable shape. Just to give you an idea, you can see on here staff time, and obviously the number I'm about to give you includes more than staff time. Andrew and his crew have put in a lot of work as it relates to signage, things like that. We requested roughly 33K.

1:27:51 In reimbursement from the state. So to your point, and a good chunk of that is staff, they were out a bunch, even though it was only a few storms. So again, that had a lot more in it than just grooming and just staff, but 33K compared to basically the 5K that we spend in staff time for the non-moto system. Obviously, that takes far less time to do as well. And the motorized system is open to non-motorized and gets a lot of use.

1:28:20 Yes, and I actually received a few emails this year, to your point, from a few folks who were really impressed with the work Andrew and the crew did out there, and they were Nordic skiers. They were like, how do I not see more Nordic skiers? And they loved it so much to the point where they said, hey, you know, you guys should save one trail for a few days after Andrew grooms and make it non-moto only. I was like, that's...

1:28:46 We can't really do that, but I love your psych on it, and then you want to ride Andrew's Freshies out there. So, yeah, I was happy to see that this year. A few emails from Nordic users specifically about how good the trails were out there. But I digress. I'm sorry. Any questions related to budget and what we have going on the remainder of the year? Again, most of Andrew's staff, and correct me if I'm wrong, Andrew, comes on.

1:29:15 Effectively June 1st, May 28th, roughly around in there. So about one month to get us to the new fiscal. I don't see a need to be consulted about moving money within the maintenance. Definitely appreciate the notification. Yeah. Would you do a similar for implementation as data collection and analysis is all spent if additional money is needed?

1:29:44 Or is that all done for the year? We will do a changeover, you know, the counters here eventually. If we run into that scenario, I will certainly consult with you all. I think being that the season is ending early, some of that changeover may start a little bit early here, but I will more than likely need to consult with Andrew and see what we're going to do there.

1:30:13 But I will definitely let you know if that is the case. Thank you, Austin. Appreciate you all. Thank you. Yep. Thank you. All righty. We've got a discussion item. 5.1, history, current needs, and future goals of the MTC. Yes, I can introduce this item. Everybody doing okay? Need a break or anything? Doing great. Okay. Okay.

1:30:49 So I wrote a few things down so I would stay on track as we move into this discussion. But thank you all for being here. And before we go forward, I just want to take a step and look back. This committee was built with a lot of intention. There was a lot of real thought in bringing this group together. And really, if you look at where this started and where we are now, it's significant leaps and bounds.

1:31:18 But things are evolving. We have an Office of Outdoor Recreation that has come into the picture and has a much broader scope of work. And so this feels like a good moment to reset a bit and make sure this group is set up to move forward in the right way. Today is not a formal presentation or a critique of the current structure. It's a working session diving into how we can best engage our community.

1:31:47 In the sense of recreation. And so it should be enjoyable. And if it's not, we're not doing it right. Because we're talking about trails, right? Recreation, community, it should be fun. And honestly, to quote my dear friend Sam Nicolosi, we need to have fun to make fun. And so the more connected we are, the more open conversations that we can have, the better ideas we're going to get, and ultimately, the more impact.

1:32:17 Today I really wanted to have this discussion so we could talk about what this committee should be, what we actually need from it, how we can make it more effective and useful for you, for me, for staff, for the community, and just be real about what's working and what's not, and what feels too rigid or disconnected, and how we want to operate, engage with each other and with the community.

1:32:46 And what some simple, practical changes could look like moving forward. And just making sure this committee is an effective, collaborative, engaged, and a group that people want to be part of. And so if anybody has any questions, or does someone want to just jump right in? Well, I'll start with some thoughts. Let's see, I'll start with my logistics request first.

1:33:15 So we meet six times a year. I would love if we could move our April, June, and August meeting to a different day because Thursdays are always our mountain bike races. And I think a bunch of people in here participate in that. And so that would be a request of mine if we could, I think we should maybe move to Mondays. I don't know how people feel about Mondays, but I feel like it's a good day. Everyone's around on Monday, but I'd love to see us move.

1:33:46 If we could specifically move those three meetings to a different day would be helpful. And then as far as thoughts, I don't know, just my thoughts are I'd like to see more specific topics for the meeting that are more roundtable, that are engaging for both the committee. I mean, I think we had actually, we had a good talk today about just the app. It's a great debate. But to maybe outline for the whole year, you know, okay, we're going to talk about signage at this meeting.

1:34:19 We're going to talk about, you know, whatever it might be so that we, and then maybe that we also try to involve some specific user groups in that, you know, and get more involvement from, nice to see Craig and Matt here, but have a few more people in the room and maybe they can participate as well, you know, however we can best do that. But just to have a more specific topic for each meeting that we maybe as committee members come more prepared for, do some homework, go out in the field, figure out things like that.

1:34:49 You know, I really trust like things like budgetary things. It's not that it's not interesting to me. I just, you know, I wouldn't want you coming in my office and telling me what to do with my budget. And I kind of feel the same way. I don't understand enough about what you're doing. And I kind of trust that the system's in place already to, you know, that you're not going to Hawaii or whatever on the money and that, you know. If we have leftovers. Yeah. So I think I can do a lot better as a committee member offering

1:35:18 You know, actual experience and suggestions versus kind of the status quo. So that's my ask. I really like the idea of topics, not just general reporting. Like this website, it's been a very beneficial discussion. Can I add a few things here? And I apologize, you should have jumped in maybe right out after Kim. I didn't have a page of written notes, by the way, so this is going to sound not quite as eloquent.

1:35:49 This kind of topic came to our attention for two reasons. One, you know, sort of a little bit of an exit interview with a member that we recently lost and sort of looking for more value in the time spent and what we could get accomplished in this space. Also sort of reflecting back a little bit on the history of why this was put together and maybe some of the oversight, and you talked about financial, Caroline, that I think at that time it was more

1:36:18 You know, measurement, measure our sort of financial contributions going to a multitude of directions, right? And a lot of the funding was basically being spent out through contractors and other things like that. So quite a bit of oversight was probably more necessary than it is today. I'll say what the town did in this space is we kind of plopped the Office of Outdoor Recreation right on top of a developed and established system of checks and balances across the trail system.

1:36:46 And the MTC was one of those components. And when that was done, it wasn't done in such a way that said, okay, here's how we're going to integrate this organization to all of these things and sort of reestablish those connective tissue and how they work together. We're just going to put them out there. You guys are going to kill it, do great things, report back to the various things. And it was never really integrated, in my opinion.

1:37:15 And so we've continued to have the meetings. We've brought them in. These guys are doing tremendous work on that, on the trails and in the recreation space. They are managing their budget and sort of reporting it to all of you as things are accomplished. But I think for the most part as town manager and them working for me, I'm establishing expectations on how they're going to manage that and how they do that.

1:37:42 So we've kind of lost a little bit of the purpose, in my opinion. And so the goal in adding this today was to really say, like, is there a shift in focus that would be more beneficial for this organization or this committee to provide a better feedback? And one of the things that I thought about, and Carolyn, this align exactly with what you just said,

1:38:06 Is we need a tighter connection to the user groups that are in the community that are using these trail systems. We need to hear from these guys who have developed, they develop the work plans, they develop their own work plans, they're looking at how they're going to accomplish the goals that are established for developing these trails and managing them. But I would absolutely love for them to have a direct connection to the user groups all across the board.

1:38:36 And I know, Bill, you mentioned earlier tonight that the user groups sometimes have not really established themselves. They've kind of fallen apart a little bit. Maybe they've dissolved entirely. But I think there's a group of them out there. And if we find some really tight connection that maybe each member has that and brings it forward and a part of the meeting is focused on either specific trails, specific needs, specific elements.

1:39:03 A topic, I agree with you on the conversation about the website was a really good, very focused topic that garnered some really good responses, I thought. I thought it was a really great conversation. So I wanted this item to really introduce what I believe is a problem. We need to figure out how we modify the interaction between MTC and Office of Outdoor Recreation.

1:39:31 Solidify that to produce the most for the trail system. So maybe a little bit more of an update on really what I'm hoping to achieve in this space. So to change for me, because I was responsible for starting this group in the first place, to change the focus back to being a recommending body for outdoor recreation. We have two almost competing bodies in us and in MLR.

1:40:03 Because MLR was formed to deal with all recreation outside of corporate. Municipal. Municipal. Thank you. My brain only works on occasion. So how do we bring us back so that we are helping staff realize what it is the community at large wants? There is always somewhat of a disconnect between staff and community. We need to be

1:40:33 That connecting arm that connects those groups, and Rob has already said user groups, the problem is all the user groups used to exist because so few people are willing to do what we are doing right now, which is volunteering our time to do something for the community, that almost all of those groups, from the snowmobile group to the original motorcycle group to the cross-country ski group, have gone by the wayside.

1:41:01 So somehow as a board, we need to be able to represent what those users are thinking. So I pride myself in talking to cross-country skiers and snowmobilers, and this year there's been a big growth in the motorcycle-snowmobile things, which is incredible to watch out there. And then instead of coming to these meetings and listening to a report from staff all the time and saying, yep, you're doing great work,

1:41:32 We need to be involved somewhat, somehow in that decision-making process. So they come to us and say, we're going to work on sharps again, but the Forest Service is stopping us. At what point do we stop working on sharps? I'm not saying we're going to. I'm exampling here. And move on to something that we can actually get accomplished. How do we help staff do that? How do we politic for it? But that's, we need to represent users.

1:41:59 Or groups, but not necessarily groups because they don't exist unless somehow we're going to fund that. And I don't see that happening because I know at least one council member is really cheap. So to go back, we review a lot, but we don't discuss what to do. The website discussion was a start. I agree. Put these things on an agenda where we get to actually discuss them and give our input to staff and then staff is better empowered to make decisions.

1:42:34 I'm sure I didn't blow that completely and it made some sense. Rob hasn't hit me yet. I must be okay. I'm nonviolent. Yeah. One thing I've always kind of struggled with this group is how much direction to give and what does that look like? When is it beneficial? When is it just telling the staff what to do when it's not necessarily our place? And I think

1:43:10 So I think in this process, defining that is definitely important and yeah. So I think I took the time and read our standard rules and basically the primary function is budget and recommendation. And as we've talked about, I think redefining, rewriting that primary function should be something we really

1:43:40 Consider, and I like what you said about connection between staff and community and making that definitely a primary function to go alongside whatever else we decide. Yeah, so in my vision, instead of us getting just a budget report, we would have a workshop on the budget, and in the end, someone would make a motion, just like the council, to vote on whether we wanted to go forward that way, and then we give that.

1:44:10 Whatever the result of that vote is goes on to staff. So we feel like we're actually in the game, if you will. I'll chime in here. You know, one of the things I see with this group, we do a lot of work on, you know, public lands. And everything is always, you know, we don't have time for this. We can't do that. Our hands are tied here.

1:44:46 You know, right now with sharps, we're coming on the end of like 16 years. And had I been on this board at the start, you know, for some trails out at the propane tanks, I wouldn't have lasted because it's too long and it's unfair to the people that are trying to make things happen. It's the timeline's just too long. So, you know, we're kind of stuck.

1:45:15 Already. And I want to think bigger, and I want to look at the whole forest, and I want to, you know, connect communities, but, you know, everywhere I go, it's the same thing. It's like, the forest isn't prepared for these ideas, and they can't, you know, support it because of it. So, I'm not sure what we're talking about, because we all have our different strengths and backgrounds, but...

1:45:43 For me, this came up because I was like, hey, Kim, I've been chair for over a year now. I think someone else should, you know, share in the fun. And she's like, well, wait, hold on. We're going to talk about the big picture about this whole group. So I thought, OK, maybe something's going to change. But in the meantime, I still show up and I'm still the chair. So, you know, we'll see what happens.

1:46:12 Whatever happens, it's a super frustrating process. Always has been. For normal folk, it's not something you want to do because, you know, it's too frustrating. So, John, that's a great, I mean, that's kind of the reason that it's on the agenda. So how, you know, set the Forest Service aside a little bit because we go from, I have a one-to-one with, you know, the forest, the ranger, district ranger.

1:46:41 Sometimes a force supervisor. These guys are meeting frequently in those spaces and currently driving for accomplishments, right, and trying to push the envelope in that space. So I think work and effort is being done in that, but I'm taking more what you're saying, the frustration is within this group and feeling like you're getting things accomplished. Is that correct or not? Well, I am because I came on the coattails of everyone else.

1:47:12 And I've been here for, you know, two or three years. And, you know, I remember Elise, when she was here, she's like, how much further are we going to go with this sharps? You know, because it's been way too long. And I told her, give it two more years. And something happened, luckily, like in 23 months, we got the okay. And, but it's, you know, for me, I feel like, great, yeah.

1:47:42 We're accomplishing something, but if you look at the whole span of time, we're not, you know, it's taking too long to accomplish things. What do you think would be more beneficial use of our time in this particular venue that would be more effective in supporting and developing trails? Is there something we're not engaged in that would provide

1:48:14 To move that along a little bit faster or potentially, you know, not move along something as large as trying to shift the Forest Service's thought processes. But, you know, there's a lot of stuff that can be done that will enhance the experience of users of the trail system that don't have to depend upon that. And that can be in the work plans of staff to get accomplished. And I think that's where we were thinking about, you know, the user groups are...

1:48:39 The end users of the trail system, what do you need and how does that interact with other user groups? Because these guys have to thread the needle between delivering on that. But I think, you know, just what would be more beneficial for that success? It's a great question. I don't know, at one point I'm like, all right, I'm going to apply forest as hiring for OHV people, you know, so.

1:49:09 I'm like, just jump in there and go to work for the Forest Service. That's the only thing I could think of. But then they yanked the jobs. You know, it's like... They heard you were coming. Yeah, it's fine. But it's a tough one. I don't know. So how... And you've made some really great points, John. How do we not get stuck in working on a sharps or something similar to that because a process was set up by somebody somewhere...

1:49:39 That came up with a plan that the Forest Service really didn't like and didn't want to move forward with, and it's pushed back on us at every step. So how does this group then become that decision maker to say, you know what, the Forest Service in the travel management program closed a thousand miles of roads that they told us we could use for other purposes.

1:49:59 So how do we then go and create the loops and the single track and the other things that we haven't done? And I don't mean single track just for motorcycles. There's a lot of mountain bikers out there. How do we then become the advocate for that and move us off of this institutionalized, ingrained process? You know, the Mammoth to the craters to June Lake, the next big study and the next big group.

1:50:25 Does it behoove us to do that? And we need to make those decisions, I believe, here at this level. You haven't hit me yet. So how do we go about doing that? One of the things I see this group being hugely important in, because we have been stuck in planning for what was. How do we, e-bikes are a great example. We're being overrun. How do we plan for that?

1:50:54 How do we as a group bring that together with maps on the ground showing the Forest Service and then advocate for that as to what we can and can't do using that 1,000 miles of existing trails that they said we'd be able to use? And there's more than just e-bikes. There's a whole lot of things. The average motorcycle rider doesn't do what he did 20, 30 years ago. The snowmobiler doesn't. The equestrian is looking for different avenues. So how do we bring ourselves to the top?

1:51:24 And become decision makers to move forward what we believe is best interest of the community. Not one particular organization, not one particular user group, but the entire community. And I think it's exactly what we were talking about earlier. Bring forward maps, whatever it is we need, bring forward an item and deal with that item at some of our meetings and come to some conclusions as to what we can and can't do.

1:51:52 Do we want to spend 15 years on one project and spend how much of our resources just on that project? Do we want to go back and pimp the town council because $300,000 for trails was set aside because that was one-third of what Measure R was going to create? Does this group now go to council, those dirty dogs, and say, we want our third of Measure R? I don't know the answers to those, but I think that

1:52:22 We could be a much more effective group moving down that role, and I don't know how to get there. I think it's interesting comments of basically thinking outside the box that we've found ourselves in with this committee. I mean, it's kind of just do a rote thing here instead of, I think you're describing a sort of entrepreneurial about, you know, what's possible, how do we dream about things that we maybe take advantage of, circumstances that have occurred, describing those trail systems and just saying, hey, this is

1:52:53 How we want to kind of start looking at our opportunities differently. You know, and I thought it was user groups, but maybe it's, you know, you guys have been selected to be on the committee for a reason. It's just, you know, you've all visionary about things and maybe that's the source. I think we were selected because we're the only hands going up. I'm pretty sure it was my beard that swayed you. It could be, yeah, it could be, yeah, yeah. I was just going to say, I think this committee is really the eyes and ears on the ground of...

1:53:23 Recreation in our town and area in general. And so bringing that back is super helpful to staff and planning and prioritizing projects and then diving in and how long are we going to spend on them or which are quasi feasible type of thing. I do think, go ahead. I'm sorry, I don't mean, you know me, my mouth is always flapping. How do we change or are we happy with the makeup of the board?

1:53:52 Should there be somebody on this board that is also on the MLR board because we're dealing with the same things? Does there need to be a council member on this group? I'm not here as a council member actually, but yeah. We need to, again, it would be another great workshop, maybe even beyond our six meetings a year, for us to sit down and look at what our makeup is and what it should be or if we're happy with where it is.

1:54:20 Is the current connection to MLR just the staff? No, so this committee, the Mammoth Trails Committee, is a subcommittee of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board. And how does that board find out about us? There used to be a better connection. Trails Committee chair or somebody would come to MLR meetings and give a report out. We have staggered meetings.

1:54:49 In theory, so that can happen. So like you'll meet this month, MLR meets next month, and we can transfer information back and forth. But currently it's just basically through staff. I'll give an update at the MLR board or Office of Outdoor Recreation comes sometimes in reports. But I think it... I will correct her history there a little bit. Actually, this group was created before MLR. And for some very specific reasons that I'm not going to get into here because they're sort of political.

1:55:19 Different name, different name, right? Well, it was Mammoth Trails, yeah. Yeah. One thing that comes to mind for me is as a committee member, if we could each take a meeting, so whatever, I'll go back to signage. I'm in charge of signage in June, and it's my responsibility to create the discussion items and also to potentially, like, I think...

1:55:44 We can bring in people from the community there. So, you know, signage, let's get Silver from Footloose to talk about how he sees tourists. Let's get three or four other people that are community stakeholders. And it's kind of your responsibility as a committee member to make that meeting good. And I think just doing that, having that responsibility once a year is pretty reasonable. But I think...

1:56:09 You know, maybe giving people a little homework in advance so that they come and they know what they're talking about. And I think for the topics, I think kind of deferring to you guys about like, what do you think we could best be helpful on? You know, Forest Service, I don't know, that's not my, that's not really why I joined the committee. I mean, it's kind of a, that's not my passion. I know that it's a huge thing to build trails. It's a career.

1:56:38 I don't think I could be helpful in that realm, but I could maybe be helpful in something that feels a little more tangible. And also I think getting stuff done is progress always. So if it's something small, it makes you feel good about being on this committee. You know, we might not get 40 miles of trails built in the next five years, but at least, you know, making a difference feels good. So that would be my suggestion that we each take a meeting and kind of structure that meeting. I really like that because what you're describing to me in a way is engagement.

1:57:07 And, you know, the opportunity to have a voice on a particular thing of interest to you and then bringing in members of the community that, you know, either are subject matter experts in that space or have those abilities. I do want to kind of address one of the questions you mentioned, you know, what do these guys need? I would say the strength of this organization and the Office of Recreation specifically and each one of the three over there that have been. You good, buddy? Oh, yeah. I'll wait till you're done.

1:57:41 The strength that they have as an organization, I think they autonomously could navigate a really tremendous system. What I think is missing is the engagement with the community and not an oversight, but a conduit of information coming to them about

1:58:04 You know, hey, what are the things, how do we piece this together, the needs of the mountain biking, the trail runners, all those different disparate groups? How do we get that information coming in? And if it's a topic of importance to a member, that's great. That's one way to do it. But just kind of get that stuff in. So I think, you know, relying on them to ask questions back to us isn't going, you know, I don't know there's a lot of questions to be asked, right? There's more work to be done than these guys have time to get accomplished.

1:58:34 Getting that feedback, it needs to be a come from and push to versus a draw in from them is what I see needs to happen. So if there's a way to do that, and I really do like your suggestions about taking a meeting, taking a topic, making it real and seeing if we can get some engagement from the community to come to these meetings and participate in them. Andrew, where do you find the most value from these meetings? I think similar to what you guys have been voicing, it's felt.

1:59:11 A little bit like we're just delivering reports, right? So, you know, I like sharing about what we're doing and I feel like you guys are kind of a conduit maybe of giving that information back out to the community. So it feels good to have some transparency over, you know, what we're up to. And I think if we were getting off track, I would...

1:59:41 I wouldn't expect that you guys would, you know, let us know. But I think to everybody's point, what I get out of these meetings is less than I think, you know, what we could get out of these meetings, which I'd be really interested in all the ideas you guys brought forward, but also like, you know, opening it up to maybe more informal and like one-on-one or just more interaction between

2:00:09 Us as staff and you as committee members in terms of mentorship or bringing you along for a day at work or just getting more close in terms of what it is that we actually do. And maybe you guys would have ideas of how you could make our team more effective or you would just at least be better informed in terms of how we're doing things or why we're doing things a certain way.

2:00:38 Yeah, I think, and I think, like, having a topic for each meeting seems like a really smart way to move us in a measured progression forward, right? Like, we've got the trail system master plan, which has a lot of, you know, different categories of signage or, you know, community engagement, staff, stewardship, or, like, the host programs in there, you know? So, something that I think

2:01:08 About sometimes, like, I come up here and give the Trails Manager report, it's called the Mammoth Trails Committee, you know, Gretchen does a lot of work on stewardship in the host program, which is really integrated into the host, into the trails program, but as the Office of Outdoor Recreation, and as that's been kind of new in the last three, four years, does this committee feel like it's a good forum for, like, does everybody feel like they're being heard here, right? Do we need to rename it, like, the...

2:01:37 The Outdoor Recreation Committee, and sort of have more of an equal voice between the three of us, whereas I feel like it's a lot of me talking sometimes. So that's something that I've thought of. Sorry, rambling. Great, it was fantastic. We don't want to be just a PowerPoint you have to make every other month. Which is absolutely an incredibly good point. I think a lot of the reports can just be written.

2:02:06 And then unless we have questions on them, that serves its purpose. Then we can allocate that time to actually having the roundtable discussions we need to be having on the subjects at hand, whether it's trails, whether it's information, whether it's because we're really active in a lot of different spaces. You know, sometimes this agenda takes up all the time, like 90% of just sitting.

2:02:35 And believe me, I've sat in a lot of meetings over my life, and they're all the same. You know, you show up and you just sit there. So instead of doing these agendas, like maybe we should have our one topic that we need to jump into and everyone needs to be a part of instead of, you know, a long-winded report. And it's like, you know, it's fine, you know.

2:03:05 But if you read the packet, you got it already. Now we need to see it on TV and we need to talk line by line. Let's not waste all that time. This is real talk with John Connolly. I like it. Thank you for having fun. So with that in mind, let's have our summer meetings at some campsite out in the woods. Just thinking logistically,

2:03:33 A couple of different things, right? So great comments, and I do like, again, narrowing it down to actually functional topics to be discussed. But logistically, we need to start going about that, right? I mean, so if that's the desire of kind of bringing forward a topic of discussion, we're going to have to figure out how to get that accomplished. And, you know, I know we're at the end of time now, today.

2:04:02 It would be interesting if we find a way to either poll or somehow get information through the group and get some feedback on what potential topics could be format and what you'd like to do. Someone could sign that for it. We can communicate, I think, a lot of things through email or something to get that next agenda maybe built in a different way and provide still for the written but not have to go through an update.

2:04:29 I particularly like your update, just FYI. It's okay to hear you talk, but even if I have to sit here. Well, maybe start bringing those more into council, right? I mean, that's a great point, too. I mean, other places, council or, yeah, it's good information to get out there. And, yeah, this group is probably more familiar with it than others. But I think logistically we need to think about a way of getting this process modified.

2:04:57 I think, too, I would like

2:05:34 Perhaps to do an update to council. You know, we do a lot of presentations at council level and perhaps maybe after we kind of get some of these things decided and worked through, but just new structure, new format. Presenting that to you, I mean, while we have one council member here, that's, you know, 20% of the board itself and there's a lot of others that are quite interested on the activity that goes on in this space and so I think figuring out how to...

2:06:02 You know, communicate these changes and communicate the benefit of what we're trying to achieve. It would be good. Yeah, and I just want to jump in with one thing real quick. I think those were all really good ideas. I really appreciate the feedback on some of these things. And I think for us, so that we can make everybody's time as valuable as possible and do what's right by this community, because that's what we want to do and what we strive to do.

2:06:36 I think we had some good ideas about how these meetings could be structured. There were some initial comments about the goals, objectives, and mission of this committee. So I think it would be helpful while you're kind of thinking about these things and framing these things, you know, what is the ultimate goal and objective of this committee? What are ancillary goals and objectives to that that we can make sure that we're addressing? And not every single meeting needs to maybe

2:07:05 To your point, like some of them could be more specific to some of these ancillary functions of the committee. Some could be specific to the grander goals, I think, of the committee. So just thinking about that, I think, you know, as it relates to a lot of just these Brown Act committees in general, and whether it's town council or whatnot, I think our ultimate goal is to like represent the community like Rob said, right? So how do we best accomplish that? And I think that would be really helpful for us because

2:07:32 We don't want to waste anybody's time. Maybe we need to do a better job of engaging with the community. That's a possible option as well. So I just think kind of framing what we want to do here and kind of that holistic approach of the goals and objectives of this committee would be very helpful, I think, for us because we just want to do what's right by this community. So we are open to any and all suggestions. Thank you. Okay, it is getting late.

2:08:07 Everyone good to move on? All right. I'm going to get you standing up. What's that? I'm going to get you standing up. I know. Okay. Real quick, number six, committee member reports. We'll go down from this. The pamper pedal is May 30th. The theme is Vegas, so hopefully, I think Gresham signed up. Vegas? Vegas. Okay. Just a quick report from me. Pre-pool tournament last night.

2:08:40 I took a bike ride. I was like, all right, I know these trails are open. I know where they're at. I hit five out of the six segments, the new ones, and just kind of sniffed them out and connected them all. Did you set the record on Strava? Not yet, because this is the first time. So anyhow, when I was out there riding these trails, I was thinking, where am I?

2:09:10 I'm not in Mammoth. I'm in some other vacation destination because I've never moved through the woods, gone around all the lava rocks and over hills on these certain trails before. And I was thinking, like, at that moment, that was the purpose of the MLT. Our sole reason is to get new trails and people out there having experiences.

2:09:38 It was just a, it was a real unique hour and a half for myself. I was like, this is incredible. You know, why did it take, you know, so long? But I didn't, I wasn't being ungrateful. I was more just thinking about things as I pedal. But it was something else. And it was only like five miles worth. But, you know, I could imagine and I could see where the new ones are connecting in and the link ups. I'm like, this is going to be great.

2:10:06 You can come up this ridge and you can see people over there coming up another one. And it's a, the Sherwin Meadows is a really great hub. And also, I've got like a 25, 30 mile loop around town that incorporates the mountain. So now, below town, there's, you know, really good connections too, you know, that I can add to my miles. So, you know, this is awesome. And, I don't know.

2:10:37 I feel great about being part of this group, but it's been a long time in the making, and it needs to really spread out to everywhere else. I mean, we're awesome here, but it needs to go everywhere throughout the county. Spring is here. Yeah, so I've been hanging out in my backyard. Front yard's still full of snow, but we're doing it. I've got another...

2:11:09 Baby coming due April 24th, so any day now. Very good. Congratulations. Thank you. Excellent. Spring appears to be here. Noah's telling me we're going to get 6 to 12 inches Saturday night, which messes with me something terrible. No, I'm not applauding for the snow. Other than that, we've got a lot of things coming up, fishing opener and all kinds of things, so, yeah.

2:11:42 Just for real quick, you know, obviously with the town itself, we have a broad opportunity to engage pretty much everywhere within the community. I'm really grateful for my role I have within the community and leading a great team. We've been doing a phenomenal job this year. I think the wild swings of the weather were pretty difficult to manage, and I think we need to be prepared for...

2:12:07 Maybe more of that as we go forward. So some of the things that we're looking at is just really what modifications do we need to make in how we anticipate and expect winter, summer, spring and all that to occur for us because it is impactful on how successful we are as a community. So we're, you know, looking for those really interesting things but just proud of my organization and they're really killing it. Okay, thanks all. Item number seven, request for future agenda.

2:12:39 Agenda items? I got a couple. I'd like to see a discussion on increasing community involvement in these meetings and what that can look like. There's definitely, from the meetings at the brewery, there's people who want to know what's going on and how do we translate that into trails committee meetings.

2:13:09 I'd also like to get a review of where we're at on terms for all the committee members. I know that we've got a new committee member figuring all that out next meeting, June. And then I think I'd like to see a little further discussion on the future of the website, what we want to invest in that or what.

2:13:43 What we want to move forward with it. And then I guess it's already been discussed, but rewriting the primary function, maybe codifying that and adding that into our standard rules. Alrighty. That's a lot. I don't know if that's going to all go in one meeting, but. Thank you. Don't forget we're trimming these meetings too. All these meetings are the same. And everyone's got to bring a friend.

2:14:18 So that's how we get it. Okay. Let's see. 513. Motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn. Second. Okay. Thanks, everyone. Thank you. Great meeting. Went into overtime.