Trails Committee
at 17:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
199 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:34 No roll call. Committee Member Souser? Committee Member Patterson? Who'd you call? Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Vice Chair Draper? Yes. And Chair Connolly? Here. Thank you. Okay, item two, public comments. Anyone here from the public with a comment? No comments online, and I see no one in person.
1:17 Okay. I saw there was an email comment. There was an email comment, and that was specific to item 4.1, so we'll do that when we get to that item. Sounds good. Okay, item 3, we have the consent agenda. Move to approve is presented. Just to clarify, the consent agenda does have two items on it this month, and if you would like to read those items off for your committee members, that would be great.
1:55 All right. We have 3.1, which is approve the minutes of the regular meeting from April. And we have 3.2, we have the Mammoth Lakes Trail System budget update fiscal year 25-26 year to date. And we already had one motion. I'll second that. Please. Okay. Yes. Yes. And I'm going to reread that. I'm sorry I didn't push my button.
2:35 Hard enough. Committee Member Sauser? Yes. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes. Vice Chair Draper? Yes. And Chair Connolly? Yes. Thank you. All right. Made it to four. Policy matters. We have 4.1 reviewing the letter of interest. Did everyone get to see the letter? Yep.
3:06 Any comments, questions? My only question would be, is there any other applicants that we're looking at? Yeah, your friend Eric and I have been talking and I'm actually going to talk with him about being on the MLR board. There's a vacancy as well. Cool. Sounds good. Okay. And, you know, along with the letter, there was also emailed in comment. You know, I took a look at it and I tried to understand what it said.
3:40 It sounded like bikes aren't allowed on trails. So I wasn't sure if that was, if anyone else took a look at that email. I read that as well. I assume she meant e-bikes are not allowed on forest trips trails, but okay. No, I think she said bikes. She did say bikes. Yeah, because bikes are not allowed on the hiking, walking trails on the forest. And then there's the whole e-bike thing. So I'm assuming she meant that bikes aren't allowed on.
4:10 Trails in the forest unless it's specifically called out. Right. Well, I'd like to disagree because I think, you know, bikes are allowed on certain dirt trails. Well, I think overall the intent was just a letter of recommendation for the potential candidates. Okay. I was fine kind of glossing over that section and looking at the meat of it. Same with me. I just didn't understand. All right. So,
4:46 Do we have a new member? We, you can make a motion to appoint. Yeah, I'll make a motion to appoint Matthew Hall to the vacant seat currently in the committee. Seconded. All right. Committee Member Souser? Yes. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes. Vice Chair Draper? Yes.
5:19 And Chair Connolly. Yes. And we did not ask for any other public comment, did we? Did I miss it? There is none, but I just wanted to make sure if anybody's watching that that was out there.
6:00 See, I'm new to all this. Sitting at the desk. I've done a lot of presentations at the podium. Never really sat at many desks. Lived in Mammoth about seven or eight years. I'm a landscape architect, a long career in Southern California. So been around the block for park master plans, any kind of projects, open space master plans, park master plans.
6:27 I feel like this is a little bit in my wheelhouse and you probably recognize me and everybody always says, I recognize your name on Strava. Big mountain bike, gravel rider, cyclist, so I've been supporting the cycling community. I'm a board member with Simba along with Caroline. I kind of revitalized Eastside Velo for a few years, tried to get that group back up on its feet. If you're familiar with the Sierra Eastside app, if anybody's scheduling.
6:57 Rides and Events. That's something that I started a few years ago. So big advocate for the cycling community. So hopefully my experience in landscape architecture and cycling kind of go inside and help this group. Big advocate of collaboration. The firm that I ran, we really worked hard to be creative, do a lot of collaboration as a large firm. So hopefully that I can.
7:28 Bring those ideas and that sort of excitement to this group. That's it. Welcome. Yeah, thank you. Thanks for volunteering. Okay, well, let's keep going. Let's see. Item 4.2. We have new chair appointments and vice chair for remainder of the year. I'll just clarify that it's,
8:06 Written that way until the end of the year because the appointments are supposed to be made at the first meeting of the calendar year, but the way the committee was scheduled and we had some workshop items to kind of figure out and finalize that we held off on changing anything until today. So your commitment is minimal to start. That's the selling point here. So we should start pointing some fingers. Well.
8:40 I would say as a starter, Michael's been really good at vice chair, so he could use a promotion. Subtle. I'll second that. Subtle. Okay. Anyone else have any table favorites? Just to keep my mouth shut. Otherwise Connelly will assign you to something. Yeah. Well, we could recommend Bill, but...
9:17 Wasn't there a rule saying you couldn't be the chair? There isn't. It was my preference. This committee's a little different. Most of the committees I sit on, I sit on as a council member. Here, I sit on this committee as a member of the public representing certain groups. But as a council member, I would prefer not to be. There are other organizations where I'm required to sit as chair or vice chair at some point.
9:45 It just seems to me like almost the appearance of a conflict of interest to the public. So I'm, you know, I will do whatever the crew wants, but that's just my own personal take on this particular board. Is there any volunteers? Well, we've got a motion and a second. Yeah, I'll accept the nomination. Sounds good.
10:18 If you want to add to that, I would recommend Caroline, of course, as our advisory chair. John, you could step down to Vice from President. Oh, I forgot about that part. Flip-flop. Oh, yeah. It sounds good to me if everyone's comfortable. I can always fill in and chair a meeting. I'll second John then. Okay. Okay, so make an official motion. Thank you. Okay, the official...
10:51 Motion is I'm out, Michael's in, and I'm chair. Vice chair, I mean. Seconded. You got that. I'm out, he's in. And was the second from Ostergaard? Okay. So we have a motion to appoint Michael Draper as the chair, John Connolly as the vice chair. Motion by Connolly, second by Ostergaard.
11:23 Any further discussion? Okay. Committee Member Souser? Yes. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes. Vice Chair Draper? Yes. Chair Connolly? Yes. Thank you. You good, Michael, if we pass the torch? Of this moment, sure. Yeah. All right. Here we go. All right. We'll move on then to Agenda Item 4.3.
11:57 Review and provide direction for updates to standing rules. Oh, and I apologize. On the last vote, our new committee member was not in my computer yet, so I should ask. Committee member Hall, how do you vote? Yes. Thank you. It's just about texting. He's new. We should have just appointed him for crime. Yeah. I was waiting. That's jumping ahead first. So for this item, I made one.
12:39 Slide, I'll introduce it a little bit. At our last meeting, the primary function of this committee was asked to be reviewed. And so I included the standing rules in your packet. And then on this slide above you is the primary function written out, sort of broken up. And so this item not only can address changes to the primary function, but then any other changes.
13:08 to the standing rules, aka bylaws. One other suggestion I had of a change is eliminating the specific day and time for our board meetings and just leaving it as regular meetings. So I think I'll turn it over to you as a committee on a discussion for any recommendations you would like us to take into account and then we'll come back to you.
13:39 to you at the next meeting with an updated sort of primary function along with any other edits that you'd like to see. I can dive in real quick. You know, this is something we did talk about at the last meeting and how, as we've added the Office of Outer Recreation to the town of Mammoth Lakes, that we sort of changed a little bit of how the trail system is managed. And I think some of the language specific to this was
14:12 In an era perhaps when some of the work was being done by outside contractors and there was a desire to have a tighter oversight on that, in my opinion, I think the primary function has probably shifted in this committee, and that's what we spent quite a bit of time talking about last meeting. So reviewing that, I think some modification needs to happen, but again, I'm sort of presenting the issue more than driving the discussion on it.
14:41 And hopefully others have thoughts. I have no real issue with how it's written here, maybe how we each understand it. We provide governance, fiscal work program, funding allocation oversight, which I believe is appropriate. The question is, how do we work that in and make it work within the structure of the Office of Outdoor Recreation? Because that's really what we're talking about here more than anything else, right?
15:17 How do we interact with MLR and what our function is on the trail system specific and how do we interface with the Office of Outdoor Recreation? I would love to see this committee be a little more involved than it has been in prioritizing the projects and the fiscal and the budget oversight. I think at this point we are often presented things at a time
15:48 When it appears to most on the committee that the decisions have already been made internally and we're here just nodding our heads, and in that case I don't need to be here nodding my head, but if we're going to actually look at these things up front before those decisions are made and have our input in what those decisions are, then the primary function is vague enough to allow us to do that, if that makes sense.
16:22 Maybe we should all go downstairs for a cocktail and come back for the meeting. So I guess the question to me is whether the terminology needs to change around funding because the rest of it encompasses a lot of what we talked about last meeting is the function of this group, but whether fiscal and specific funding allocations needs to be altered or removed.
16:51 It's kind of the big change from my understanding. Then how that, because most of the funding we're looking at is coming from Measure R, yet MLR is the arbiter of Measure R. They're the ones who approve or disapprove. We approve and disapprove the third of Measure R that's allocated, well, started out as a third, it's not anymore, that is allocated for trails. So how that interplay is, but we're still,
17:23 Fiscally responsible for that $300,000 that's allocated to trails every year, unless that changes from MLR making those recommendations going forward. I think what I see more the role of this group is really prioritizing what projects get worked on and maybe a review of funding for those projects. And the interesting thing about the Office of Outdoor Recreation, right, that the folks over there have the responsibility of managing trail system.
17:55 And so when you think of the terms of managing the trail system, that involves with work plans, forecasting, planning, bringing forth those types of things. I always looked at this group as evolution possibly as a representation of interest groups that we can get a better connection to user groups and make sure that that is the point in which it informs the work plans but doesn't necessarily have as direct of oversight.
18:24 So I have essentially three managers sitting there in the Office of Outdoor Recreation managing the trail system. So I think in that regard, it's looking for true sort of community input from this committee that guides that direction. But I think where we've sort of lost, and I'll say outwardly lost interest of some of the group and some of the MTC is in the fact that
18:50 The work that we're asking the MTC to perform has changed without the assignments essentially modifying. So that's what my desire is to try to bring it into a little bit more of what would be useful from a committee like this to guide the direction of where we go with the trail system and give these managers over here sort of input on what is important directionally.
19:18 So if we can put that into words, I think that would maybe be some modifications that would be valuable. It's putting a lot more emphasis on that second part, the providing recommendations for continuation, prioritization, implementation, design programs and services to support that with more of an emphasis on community input.
19:49 Is that what you're saying basically? Yeah, I think if I was sitting in the seats of town staff, what I want to achieve is I want to achieve success from a community standpoint. And all I have is my own point of view about the way the trail system should be managed to run and even what the next phase of implementation may be. And having that feedback of what is important to the user groups,
20:19 And it seems to me to be probably the best at delivering a product that people can use, right? Because it's just, it's very specialized interest, it's very specialized utilization. And so rather than relying on the folks that I know that can manage work plans and manage staff and manage entire development teams, I...
20:43 I know they can do that, right? I just had an MLR meeting where I presented the budget, and we talked about how it's evolved across time. Right now, we hire a seasonal staff to do the maintenance and development of the trail system work for the summer. So I'm very confident that that's achieved. But what does a community need is, I think, what folks need to hear. I think I said the same thing about five different times.
21:14 And I'm kind of new to the board. But I used to work for the town of Mammoth and, you know, rec department. We would have a recreation commission. And it kind of, it was easy to understand. Like the staff, you know, was in the meeting with the commission. And I saw there was a planning commission and the same thing. It was all under the town umbrella.
21:44 And so now we have kind of like a trail commission or a committee and we have town staff, but are we like freelance committee members or do we fall under the town? We fall under MLR right now, right? And is that structure part of what we're talking about? Yeah, I mean, currently, yes, this is a subcommittee.
22:15 of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And I think, are you asking, does the MLR part need to be involved? No, I'm just asking, like, it's the majority, this is town staff. And so, you know, if this is the, you know, group that we're trying to, you know, inform and direct, I'm just wondering, you know, I remember it all came together because
22:47 You know, there's oversight and contractors and stuff like that. But right now it's, you know, it's a lot of us with staff and MLR. So I was just thinking about it. That's all. I view this a lot like your representation of the Park and Rec Commission. What we are is the public face of the trail system.
23:12 Who should be here giving our knowledge and information of that to staff to help them develop a plan. The plan is there, but to help implement and oversee changes that we as a community, we're not here as individuals. We're all here representing the greater whole like a public official would be. So I think that is our role moving forward.
23:39 What I suppose I'm saying is that some of the projects and how they've been brought forward aren't brought forward far enough in advance for us to come up with a well-educated position from the public side. I know how I feel. I know what my knee-jerk reaction is to a lot of things. But I like to go out and speak with other people and look at what's actually happening on the ground to achieve that. So I think that that's important in us moving forward.
24:09 I think the other thing in moving forward for this group, because I see this as the group that truly represents the greater trail system that the town of Mammoth is relying on. And one of the things that I didn't foresee until the last couple of years is that if you read through this whole thing, there are references over and over again to nodes and staging areas. I wrote down what the heck is a node. Within the town, so our job originally,
24:41 was to connect to the Forest Service system. Well, from my standpoint, the Forest Service doesn't have a system anymore. So then what does our job become? We have to be more, and the town stepped up and took over the grooming program. But I see us having to do more and more of that down the road, and we still become the voice of the populace. You can't go out to public meetings and do...
25:10 Interviews and everything else in a way that is accurate or affordable. So this group needs to be the representative of the general population. Now I'm starting to ramble, I'll shut up. But only for a minute. We're good today. So I'll go back. I think that one of the jobs of this group and one of the places we can be effective for the town is looking at the trail system as whole.
25:47 And redefining what the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is. At this point, it doesn't go out of the boundary of incorporation, but it needs to go out into the sphere of influence. So how do we do that? How do we bring that in? And that's not what we're discussing today, but I see all of that in that primary function. We can change the verbiage maybe to better represent that, but I'm not someone who's good at wordsmithing.
26:16 As I said, I think this is done vague enough, except maybe an explanation of what Mammoth Lakes Trail System means. Yeah, and I'll just offer up, to Bill's point, we've discussed this a bit internally, and you sort of mentioned it, what is the Mammoth Lakes Trail System now? What is that exactly? How far does it stretch? Does it go outside the town boundaries? Inside is how we've operated in the past. But I think defining that and kind of what falls within that.
27:01 So would that be adding, like, I see a lot of these kind of, just kind of fine as they are. I mean, the primary function is kind of what we're getting at, and so I feel like we're maybe discussing, does that need to be added to, or at least the name, does that need further definition and clarification? That's kind of what I'm hearing. I think for, if it's a longstanding document, I mean, what constitutes the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is going to always evolve.
27:31 That's just kind of implied that, you know, I don't think we need to spell it out because that could change in five years. But I guess there should be an understanding of what, there's a sub-understanding of the people that operate within the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. But I like, to Rob's point too, I think something where, you know, we're the bridge between the community and the, you know, we're the middle guy providing hopefully the right voice and we're hearing things that people want to, passing on feedback to staff.
28:01 I mean, it really doesn't matter to me, honestly, like, who, you know, MLR, you've got the outdoor box, hopefully you guys are all working together, you know, I think as a committee you kind of presume that, and you're all here listening to us, so I think that's the most important thing. But, yeah, I think it is important that we define internally what the Mammoth Lakes, and we should probably revisit that often, but I think for the purpose of that we don't need to get too nitty-gritty. So we're,
28:34 We're talking about adding to the primary function some sort of language of representative to the public, bridge to the public, something along those lines. Is there anything that needs to be taken out of the primary function as it stands, or do we like how vague it is and how kind of overarching it is? For me, it's fine, yeah, in general, with the addition of that.
29:06 Community piece. Yeah, I think it's okay. I think, you know, within that first sentence, convened on a regular basis, the committee representing community recreation interest groups provides governance, financial, blah, blah, blah. So maybe a carrot in there to add something. Just that kind of further defines the committee, perhaps.
29:38 I don't know that I would make any change in that first one. If you go and look at 6.1, we represent nonprofits, clubs, recreation, retailers. We could add in there represent general public nonprofits, clubs, recreation, retailers to specify that out. It doesn't necessarily need to be in that first piece. That 6.1 part is the qualifications of a committee member versus the function of the committee itself. I think that we should draw that public.
30:09 into our function rather than just something that each committee member should be doing to spell it out a little more clearly. Yeah, I agree with that. The fact that the qualifications to be a member, the first thing says that you are representative of these interest groups is probably the same intent was originally here, but it just wasn't quite articulated in the primary function.
30:47 I think it was maybe assumed in that, and I think adding that language helps clarify. I think that addresses my comment. Any other questions or comments or considerations? Is there more direction needed to add that, or is that sufficient? Yeah, I think the four of us can take this conversation and sort of do some wordsmithing and bring you back some options. Rob, for what you said earlier.
31:26 Would you feel better if we just said committee provides governance fiscal work program oversight and that's it, take out any specific funding allocations? Because I can see where specific funding allocation gets in the weeds, but I do want to continue to have some oversight of the overall budget and how that goes, if that makes sense. Does that get to where you want it to go? When I thought about that, I was considering
31:57 Really what role this group has played since Office of Outlaw and Recreation has been created. And other than receiving updates on that, which I think is good for accountability, that the decision points have not been present, right? So I think it feels a little bit like while it says that the allocations are going to be sort of dictated by the efforts of this committee, that hasn't really occurred in the last little bit of time. I think
32:27 You know, we're struggling a little bit tonight with wordsmithing, but perhaps if we did some budgetary review and oversight for fiscal responsibility or something along those terms, you know, we could probably capture the intent of that and get it away from the allocation side and more of the review and accountability side. I think that would be wise. I like that change of verbiage a lot. It makes it what we're actually doing. So, staff, you kind of have?
33:05 Yeah, that sounds good to me. Great. Thank you. We can move then on to agenda item 4.4, review and approve or modify the draft FY2627 fund 215 budget allocation request. And I'll send it over to Lawson. Hello, everyone. Lawson Reef, outdoor recreation manager. This kind of falls in line a little bit of what we just discussed.
33:37 What we proposed is effectively the same as we have proposed since the creation of the Office of Outdoor Recreation in 2022. This allocation has remained constant. We have made a concerted effort over the years to not just spend, because we have those dollars, but to
34:03 Spend on things that are priorities, spend on things that we have discussed in this committee, and as such, we have never gone over this allocation. I can get the exact numbers and where we sit, but obviously you saw the budget on consent agenda right now with, I believe, roughly $40,000 of this allocation remaining with probably $18,000 to $20,000.
34:32 of that allocation for the remainder of this year, most likely going to Mr. Mulford's trail crew staff. So I think we will end the season roughly $20,000 under that allocation. And as I mentioned, we have done so all of the previous years. But we are requesting again that same $300,000 allocation that we've received in previous years, obviously.
34:57 If we start running into challenges with timeframes related to sharp construction, want to do things quicker, things of that nature, we do have some measure reserve allocated for that, but right now I think Mr. Mulford and his team have been extremely efficient putting the trails on the ground that we currently have. Any remaining planning for sharp, you can see under the sharp environmental category there, goes under our S&C grant.
35:26 So as we continue to potentially do some shovel testing, things of that nature related to Sharp 4, that will come out of that allocation. So I say all this to say that I feel pretty confident that this will meet our need. Again, we always strive to not just spend because we have an allocated budget, but to spend on things that are timely, important, and obviously things that we discuss in this committee as well. Any questions regarding
35:56 The proposed allocation for 26-27. Can you remind me of the months when fiscal year starts and ends? July 1. July. Yep. So we're finishing up as we speak right now, the remainder of the fiscal year. And I'll just clarify sort of the budget process for this. We just had the MLR meeting prior to this where town, so MLR makes the recommendations to council.
36:23 For all of Measure R and U budgets, and one of the line items is the $300,000 for the trail system. So MLR has voted to allocate $300,000 again, and then what you have before you is how the Office of Outdoor Recreation will be splitting that $300,000 up. Interesting thing there. So the original $300,000 was set at that level. Sorry, Rob. Was set at that level.
36:54 Because at the time it represented a third of the income of Measure R, Trails, Recreation. So it just seemed appropriate when that number was set. And you've heard me say in the past that maybe we should be looking at changing that. However, in my mind as I sit here today, I think what is important isn't necessarily increasing that number allocated annually for trails, but remembering that if we can find a project that makes sense.
37:23 And would have an impact. We can apply for separate Measure R funding for the trails. I think that we and the populace get stuck in the idea that this is what we have for trails and trails construction, where when actually we can apply for other Measure R funds. So I just, we have a new member here today, so I'm spewing again. But I think it's important for all of us to remember that. We don't, there will come a time when staff will out.
37:52 Run our $300,000, and then we have to ask for more. But at this point, important that we remember if we come up with building a trail or signage that we don't have funding in this for that we can simply apply for more, measure our funding, and that would be appropriate looking at the history of how it was all set up in the first place. Yeah, I'd like to add on to that, Bill, because I was going to ask some questions around that, and I appreciate you bringing up the fact that there's additional requests that can be done midterm.
38:21 for special projects from MLR board to allocate those funds to get that achieved. For the 10 years I've been here with the town, that number has been the same, right? It's been the 300,000. As I talked about in the MLR presentation earlier today, that the approach to those funds and the utilization of those funds has changed across time, and it's evolved with the Office of Outdoor Recreation, and I think they've done a great job of sort of...
38:49 Being efficient in the delivery of the services. I'll ask the question, though, of the team. If there were more funding available or allocated in that space, would more get done? Or is there, what is the constraining element? Is it funding? Is it staffing, which would be provided by funding? Or is it management capability and just the ability to manage the workflow? Because
39:18 I think we should be asking ourselves, how do we increase the opportunities on the trail system? And if we've proven to be efficient and we are seeing potentially more funding, would that produce more? Really putting me on the spot here. No, I've got... Go ahead. Well, before Andrew goes, I just want to say real quickly that much of what we try to put on the ground from a trails perspective is...
39:47 Dependent on our federal land management partners, right? And just saying that we have, oh, this money and we want to build trails with this money, that's, as we all know, often not the reality of moving those projects forward. That doesn't mean we don't try. Obviously, in one of our previous meetings, we discussed a reboot of SHRIC, but I think that is one of our, at least from my perspective, one of the things that I think prevents me from coming to you asking for more.
40:18 From just a trail creation standpoint, right? But I don't want to ramble. I'll hand it over to Andrew. That was what I was going to say, more or less. But, you know, if you look at kind of the way other folks in the area are staffed recreation-wise, you know, our team is very robust compared to what the forest has to bring to the table to take care of their...
40:49 Thousands of miles of trails, you know? So I would feel uncomfortable fielding a crew of bigger than what we have currently. I think we currently are blessed to have the crew size that we do have. We're able to get a lot done. We're able to take exceptionally good care of the trails that we are responsible for and still have capacity to build new trails. So like Lawson said, you know, when we reach that point where we have projects approved that we need added capacity for, we'll
41:18 Be banging on your door, but until that point, I feel like, you know, we're blessed to be in a really good position to provide a great, you know, service to the public, take good care of the trails, absorb new things as they come up, you know, I was a little worried my first couple years was doing a lot of timber work and been able to kind of absorb that, figure out what to do with it.
41:48 Now it's being taken care of more by Mammoth Lakes Fire Department's wildland crew. So yeah, I think if we were to take on, like a couple years ago the Forest Service came and asked us to take on additional maintenance of 13 and a half miles of trail, Mammoth Pass and Duck Pass, we could certainly spend, and I've been discussing this with...
42:11 Forest Service Staff. We could spend some more time out on those trails doing more than just kind of the bare minimum logout work. There's a, you know, kind of an infinity of work out there on the landscape, but when you start looking at the amount of resources, staff time that is available to take care of the really long stretches of wilderness trails and the kind of neglected trails up in the June Lake area, it starts to feel like
42:43 It would make more sense to kind of lean into a regional stewardship model at that point with those extra dollars than to just take extra good care of what we have right around here. But that being said, you know, I'm really optimistic that we get further approval for projects with the Forest Service and are able to ramp up and do more and build a...
43:06 Amazing bike park and probably take on some added responsibility in that realm. As we go through the Trail System Master Plan as a group, I think we might identify things that we want to focus on and put more energy into, so I'm open to increasing our capacity, but currently, you know, like Lawson said, I think a lot of our areas that we want to expand are just waiting on Forest Service engagement and approval.
43:34 And I think I'll offer up one more thing, and Andrew, I really appreciate that response. Thank you very much. I think as we narrow down kind of the previous conversation that we just had, right, like what is the trail system? It's maybe nebulous, right? It may be changes. There could be additions over the years, subtractions over the years. I think as you know, we've taken on a lot of extra work, and what I've kind of found is a lot of those extra things, we have utilized the general fund.
44:04 to help support those things. And as we have these conversations and move forward and start thinking about the definition of Measure R, town owned or managed, I think that's where some of those opportunities could come to potentially request an additional or more allocation from Measure R if we were all to decide, for instance, that either the OSV system that we took on is now part of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and some of these other things. And I think
44:33 That's something we should be looking into as well as we continue to work through this and define how the Mammoth Lakes Trail System has changed from when this first started and what it is now. Thank you. A couple of points. It's a great point. Our biggest restriction is with what our partners at the Forest Service will allow. However, in the next couple of years, there's a lot of huge things coming down that are just now getting on our radar.
45:01 There is not somebody in any other municipality I talk to whose number one recreation issue right now is how are we going to deal with e-bikes. That's huge. We haven't even addressed that here. We don't fund it here. We don't have e-bike trails here. In our case, how are we going to deal with motorized single track all over the forest, which was a growing thing and then stopped because the Forest Service won't work on it anymore.
45:26 Do we create a trail system, and there are maps out there for it, similar to the OSV program, and apply for green sticker grants to make that happen, and then take over the management of that trail system? The value of this committee moving forward, I see it more important now than ever because of the ever-changing scope of what recreation is.
45:54 We're not going to allow e-bikes on the horseshoe trail around horseshoe. It's not compatible with everything else. It's going to happen more and more until we find a way to create an opportunity that can fill that need. So that is, and you know me, you're not going to see me on an e-bike, but that is something looming in our future that we're going to have to create. Our customers are going to demand it. We're either going to have to create it
46:24 Or live with the environmental damage that's going to be done by people going out and creating new trails on their own. We've seen it happen on the Inyo National Forest in several places. So these things become, and the motorcycle thing is the same, that's growing, side by side. There's a huge growing sport in how it impacts the forest. And because we invite all of those people here, we are going to have the job of managing that and moving it forward unless the Forest Service changes.
46:55 Yeah, I wanted to thank you for the answers. And Bill, you're sort of summarizing what I was thinking myself as the evolution of the usage and how do we keep on top of that. I didn't think about the constraints being, you know, the partnership and the willingness of the partnership to sort of expand in certain areas. My question was also in the space of, you know, could we do more if we had more?
47:19 And I think you've answered that question as well. My focus would be on the development of the trails within our area right around the town. I do see, as Bill was pointing out, the evolution of the need will change over time. And as things get built out or we get to build out on certain elements, the role of the team will be...
47:43 Modified. And I think what I would challenge this group is to start thinking, just like Bill said, is what does the future look like? And what do we need to be thinking about today to position ourselves in the future to be ready for what changes we forecast? And I think that would be a really strong usage of this team, of this committee, because that's coming, right? It's either coming based on our hand or it's coming based upon
48:11 The natural progression of utilization. And so ideas about how that's working, what's not working, pain points, gaps, right, in what we have are all really critical things, I think, for us to be focused on. And this was about budget, right? Yeah. Well, it goes back to the last item as well. What our roles and jobs are. Our roles and jobs are to bring these things forward.
48:45 from the public and for the public, that public doesn't just mean people that live here, it means the people we invite here as well. I'll make a motion to approve the budget for 26-27. Seconded. Well, we have a motion to approve the budget. I did. I did. Committee Member Sousa? Yes. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes.
49:36 Chair Draper. Yes. Vice Chair Connolly. Yes. And Committee Member Hall. Yes. Thank you. Just as a final point, I think it might be interesting to see the total Measure R funds in the future, just to kind of see how that $300K relates to the rest of the total amounts. Yep. That's easy to do.
50:07 All right, thank you. We'll move on to agenda item number 5.1, and this is the trail system master plan review, and I'll turn it over to staff member Andrew Mulford. Thank you, Michael. So based on, you know, what we were hearing at our last meeting was that you'd heard enough of me talking and showing you slides, so here we are with a discussion item.
50:35 And I think an obvious place to start is the Trail System Master Plan. We're going to be undergoing an update of that in the next several couple of years. I think we're next on the docket after Parks is done. So, you know, this plan was adopted in 2011. The original one was from 1991. It's great. There's a lot of good stuff in there. 308 pages.
51:01 Just kind of selected out the executive summary to start our discussion today. That was a bunch of content stuff and then 14 pages of summarization. And that's pretty dense. But I think it's a good kind of overview and introduction to how we want to tackle the rest of the document. And I gave you a bunch of prompts here. Feel free to go off script if you notice something.
51:29 That you'd like to bring up and discuss that isn't outlined here in this list of sort of discussion prompts or review questions. And I think with that I'll turn it over to the team and just open it up for anything that you all want to discuss regarding the trail system master plan executive summary. I'll start with the, I don't know if this is jumping into.
51:59 Nitty-gritty, but one thing that jumped when you say about who kind of is in charge of each area, one thing that jumps out to me a lot is this whole discussion on like bike lanes and bike parking. I feel like that's not really the Trails Committee. I did notice those nice blue.
52:17 They're cool. Bike racks going on, those are really cool. I think also with the evolution of the e-bike, I see the bike racks are also a whole, like the standard bike rack doesn't really get it done, so people with the big wagon type thing. But yeah, I think that doesn't seem to fit in this kind of, I don't know where it fits exactly, but it doesn't seem to fit in the trails.
52:44 Bike lanes on the road and stuff like that. I mean, I'm not sure that's really our area. But as Andrew said, this evolved from two different planning efforts in 1991 was really around urban planning on trail systems and so forth. So that's where, you know, it's sort of connected to that. And it's interesting how it's evolved when we think about trails. We're thinking about everything that's soft surface in this definition and out sort of within the...
53:12 Out of the growth boundaries, but within the sphere of influence. So I thought that was interesting as well because I'd never really considered trails to be the mups and all the things that have been done in town, but if that's an area of evolution from that point, it's pretty interesting. I do think there's like the mup is great because it definitely serves as a connector to the trails and people use that. It's great to see the new one going up on Minerette there.
53:42 But I feel like, so I still think the mups can fall, but just like the specific on-roadway, you know, there's discussion in here about the, I don't know, down about the actual how the bike lane should look and stuff like that. Yeah. I feel like that's getting into a kind of a non-trails, I mean, I've always, I know that we've talked about this, as a biker, I've always loved the green stripe, I know that seems to be an issue with the, whatever, with the.
54:10 The winter and stuff. Every stripe is an issue with the winter. But, you know, I just did the ride around Tahoe yesterday, and there was quite a bit of green in certain areas, especially coming through Tahoe City and places like that, and it's helpful. I think it's very, so I feel like in town here, especially on Main Street, some green would be really, really helpful. Again, I feel like that's kind of out of our, seems kind of out of our privy a little bit to the trails committee.
54:41 Yeah, I think to back that up, it's, you know, if you guys were to bring recommendations around things that fall more under public works or engineering, at least we should probably figure out a way, a formal structure for how that information gets relayed back to those departments, right? Because otherwise, it's like I'm not representing
55:07 I don't have any decision-making power or real representation on those teams, right? And then if our group is supposed to be looking over those things based on this master plan, then maybe those things are kind of falling through a hole because they're not identified in engineering's master plan, maybe. I don't know. Yeah, I think there definitely are. But I go back to the evolution of this.
55:32 And it seems as though in the initial, certainly the 91 one was about mobility. You know, there's a lot of mention of mobility and feet first and that part of it. I think now when we think about trails, we think about them as amenities for both, you know, locals to use and visitors. So there are ways of spreading people out. They're just a different feel than truly just mobility, which was probably some of the initial sort of desire. But I like that bifurcating that into...
56:00 You know, what could be under the public works realm, which all the street hardscapes and things really are. You know, Hayes and team are managing that as you just see now on Meridian is being developed and run through their programs. So I think there is a bit of a separating of this process as we go through it into soft surface is what I think this committee is focused on.
56:27 Although, if we represent the recreating public, part of what they have to do and why that was included in the first place, remember I said earlier, we were more originally about getting to the nodes to go out into the forest. So the trails that we represented were the on-street bike trails, the muffs, the other things in town that has now changed a certain amount, but certainly not completely. We have to look at those things to get our recreating public around.
56:57 I think there's definitely a recognition that a hiking experience or a biking experience is a, it's a circuit, it's a loop usually, maybe it's out and back, but I'm constantly, and it's interesting that the paper maps that you guys have been handing out, I've been helping some people connect the dots, and that experience of the ride includes the Muppet, includes a road, includes Sherwin Creek Road, includes Creekside and Jackrabbit.
57:26 Cowpoke. I remember cowpoke. That's close to my mouth. But anyway, I think it's important to recognize all the elements. To get to the soft surfaces, you're going to experience pretty much everything, including Main Street. Sure. Interesting. One of the first things the group did was come up with the dollars to get custom bike racks built with Measure R. Initially, there were six of them bought.
57:56 With town funds and installed at different locations in town, evidently they failed because there was never any others done, but they were this M looking, you know, thing like the logo. And so, yeah, things have changed. Yeah, and I'll just throw this out there too, just for everyone. You know, some things do overlap, I think, program areas and just to kind of the multi-use pathway, right, and how we've operated with that in the past. You know, if there is a pothole,
58:27 In the multi-use pathway, Public Works, you know, generally takes care of that asphalt type management, right? Gretchen and I have gone out before and put on our stencils like, slow down, you know, these trails are for everyone. So I think there is just providing you a little bit of background of how we've operated with the multi-use pathway. Andrew's dropped hazard trees, signage.
58:48 You know, things of that nature has kind of fallen under our purview. So I think some of these things kind of cross those boundaries, and I just kind of wanted to relay that if folks weren't aware that that's how we sort of operated specifically with the multi-use pathway. You know, Andrew, like I said, has handled tons of hazard trees over the years, signage, appropriate use, stewardship messaging, things like that. You know, back to the original question, I think, and Andrew, I want to commend you for sort of breaking this down into
59:19 Manageable Bites. You know, the review of this summary is good. I think what stood out to me the most that we've done an excellent job at is the maintenance stuff. Like, literally everything in the tablets or the tables that were associated with maintenance, I could check back to things that we are absolutely doing. What I couldn't and haven't been able to see yet is the detail on what was proposed
59:49 And how we've done on that. Like how have we done on, like for example, when we make decisions on where our work plans are going to be and what the next area of focus is and those types of things, does it review back to the original plan and say this was something of great significance or great importance, we haven't quite yet finished that or done that. And I don't have the answer to this, maybe that has already been completed, but the planning for what's next.
1:00:18 And the work to be done next. I don't know that the document has informed us as much as it should have, and it's more of a question. And going back to the desire to update the trail system master plan, every plan has a life cycle, right? And this one we've considered to have gone most of its life cycle, and I think you guys consider most of it to be accomplished to date, and so we have to kind of look at what the next step of that is, and every plan needs an evolutionary process.
1:00:47 So that's what the town is doing on a broader scale. But I guess that when I read through that, I thought we're maintaining these things excellent. Are we utilizing the document to inform what's next? I don't know the answer to that. Yeah. And I think as we get into it further, you know, we'll get into that whole chapter of camp, the sort of resident survey. And I think there'll be a lot of nuggets in there that we probably certainly haven't acted on.
1:01:21 In terms of MUP development, you know, there's Minaret Path is going in, Old Mammoth Road was a gap that was identified in here that is now getting closed. In terms of trail development, I think we've kind of looked at things in sensible chunks around town, right? Labs was a lakes basin special study followed by a plan and a project. Same with Sherwins.
1:01:49 Hoping to continue that to the north. So I think we have a pretty good system for geographically moving around the town and analyzing opportunities for trail development and doing our best to get those on the program of work with the Forest Service. So I'd say I think we've done a pretty good job there, but I think there's a lot of specific things that were called out, even in the 1991 plan that were pretty
1:02:19 Aspirational that I think for one reason or another we've lost sight of in terms of trail development. And additionally, I think in the trailhead and node space, I think there's a lot of work still to be done, you know. And plenty of things that have been kind of identified but not fully fleshed out in these documents that we haven't addressed in that, yeah, specifically in that node kind of realm.
1:02:49 And in terms of roles and responsibilities of this committee, just looking at one here, multi-use pathways outside the urban growth boundary, right? And is that in the purview of this committee? Is it the Mammoth Lakes Trail System? You know, again, I'm not saying it wouldn't be a bad thing. I'd love that. But just, again, how this all kind of ties together. One of the items in future that stuck out to me was Trail System Management MOU.
1:03:18 What we have in place, whether that could be kind of a direction for this committee as well, and outlining all of that a little better. So what is the current status of an MOU? So we've got a non-funded challenge cost share agreement with the Inyo National Forest, and that kind of informs our
1:03:47 General Annual Operating Area. In it is outlined all the trails that we maintain, all the facilities that we maintain, and sort of our priority projects that we'd like to see on their program of work to help us to get those through environmental review and be able to implement them. So I think that agreement, you know,
1:04:14 I think there was an MOU that was signed at the adoption of this document with a lot of folks involved, like the Mammoth Mountain ski area, the water district. So I think to your point, I'm really glad that that group was convened at the time, but a lot of time has passed. And so, yes, somewhere there's a document that all those people signed, but I think it could be maybe worth bringing that group back together and coming to the table and seeing.
1:04:43 What our sort of shared objectives might be, especially from a trails lens and kind of reaffirming that will to support one another, you know? And the evolution of, you know, we have a lot more people that are focused on trails and within the town. And so that's going to change all of that as well. Yeah, there were many disparate MOUs kind of at the start of this.
1:05:16 Andrew's point that we're then sort of combined into this non-funded challenge cost share. There were a lot of different aspects and we've tried to consolidate a lot of those because the forest doesn't have a ton of capacity to deal with like seven different agreements. Questions? Do we want to hit here? I always wonder like from the, I'm just looking at this summary of recommendations between the soft service and paved facilities. I always wonder if you're a first-time visitor here like how the, is it super confusing?
1:06:04 The intersection between the ski area and our trails and what do you do with that. We know it, so we don't walk that experience often, but I could imagine if I was from Austria and I showed up here or something like that, I'd be super confused about where I can ride my e-bike and where I can't and stuff like that. So I always think there can be a better, I don't know, I don't have a solution to it, but I just think, and especially this
1:06:31 There's this one, okay, the Canyon Lodge thing, people flying down Canyon Boulevard. What's the solution to that? I don't really know. The mountain running Chair 16 would be great, you know, but like, but then that also, but that's, oh, and as the village continues to grow, I always think about like, there's a lot of, it could become more confusing and more dangerous, I think, you know, people bombing down Canyon Boulevard, if you add.
1:06:58 Three more hotels or whatever, you know, whatever is going to happen. There's just going to be a lot more congestion on Canyon Boulevard, kind of a recipe for disaster at some point. And then also improving the uptown node, if you will. That's kind of a very, it's, there's a sign there, but it's, I don't know, it could be hard to quite figure out where that is. I know there's not a lot of room there, but just. And just crossing there from the.
1:07:24 Community Center can feel those catches. Yeah, so that whole, I think that whole village thing as we grow needs to be, a lot of energy needs to be thought about that, kind of just, you know, but anyways, my other point was just more about, you know, how do we inform our visitors about where they're crossing into different boundaries and what they can do and what they can't do and things like that and making that feel not like a restrictive experience but more of an inviting experience, I guess.
1:07:54 I think that when this plan was developed, it was about access and creating something, right, that didn't exist at the time. And now we've got most of it created. And we're talking about things like carrying capacity and disbursement of folks so that they're out there. I think that's a natural sort of progression in this process is what is next?
1:08:22 Phase look like. And I think it's going to be longevity of the product and, you know, how does it modify to support that. We have the destination stewardship plan that we're working on right now that's going to talk about how we protect the golden goose with regard to visitation and availability. So I think, to me, the next phase of this is going to have to really look at that aspect and have that to be
1:08:52 You know, how do we get longer legs in this whole product? More utilization. I do like pain points. I thought about the same thing when you're uptown, downtown. We don't have that crossing right there. There's just some gaps in things that have been done that are on the baseline. But in general, how does this thing sustain itself for a longer period of time?
1:09:17 And that's probably going to be, and it looks different, right, than development. You're talking about building something that doesn't exist. Now it's, you know, interconnectivity. We've talked a lot about nodes, node planning in the last couple of years because that serves the public. If you have really good planning processes, it makes sense for people to know where to go and they know where it's going to take them and it's interconnected.
1:09:46 But right now, sort of these are existing, and if you're local, you know it. If you don't, you don't. So it's just, to me, an interesting evolution here that will be, that'll be hopefully a major part of what's next. I thought it was interesting in the executive summary, I didn't notice a ton of mention of the U.S. Forest Service. And it seems like such a critical part of our current, what we currently deal with on the trails, and that was not a
1:10:26 At all focus in the executive summary from what I was able to read while feeding bottles. Well, I kind of think there's some purpose in that because I think we don't want to extend ourselves into the federal lands and, you know, start on paper saying we're going to be supporting you guys through and through. Reading through it, it does, you know, it's really town-centric as it should be and what we can do and I think that's why we get to these paved trails and these.
1:10:57 Multi-use paths issues because we're trying to support what we can do within our boundaries. And it's sort of like now over the years, kind of under the breath, we've been supporting, you know, the federal. I think that we definitely have been supporting them and I understand that might not want to go on paper, but we also need to all of our major projects to have been on federal land. And so that needs to be acknowledged.
1:11:25 And all the projects we want to do are, not all of them, but almost all of them are going to be on federal land. Let me ask a question in that space. Do you think that the roles and responsibilities that Lawson mentioned earlier, and it's an item on this, needs to be further developed so that the Forest Service, while they are the landowner, they are the...
1:11:49 Essentially, management aspect of that, and as we described earlier, the limiting factor often in how much we get done. Do you think more needs to be fleshed out in the roles and responsibilities so people are aware of how they contribute to the success of this, whether they want to participate in it or not? And that can help move it along a little bit faster, maybe. We talked about that as a pain point earlier. Can this next phase resolve that?
1:12:17 I don't think it can resolve it, but it can definitely bring it to the forefront because it's, you know, that's the federal government. They're going to do what they're going to do. Yeah, and I think to that point, right, you want to build when you're making a planning document like this, hey, what are our pinch points? You know, what are we missing? Where are we missing them? How can we enhance experience, right? And yeah, I think we all acknowledge that those things are going to occur on federal land.
1:12:47 Our ability to get those things through the, you know, trail bureaucracy or the federal bureaucracy, we can have some success with that. We oftentimes can't have success with that. But I think, you know, for the purposes of this document, you know, building in kind of the holistic, hey, it might be tough, but we need things here, here, and here. This is what we're looking at. And then just, again, for everybody here, I worked for the Forest Service for a long time. You know, you can have
1:13:16 And we've all experienced this. You can have one district ranger who signs on to every single one of these things and is stoked, and the next one will come in and be like, absolutely not. Next one will come in and be like, hey, great, this sounds great. So I think for us, of course, engaging our federal partners, keeping those lines of communication open, all of us dealing with our federal partners with respect is something that we'll continue to do. But I think, you know, from a planning process, document process, sure, we acknowledge that, but we plan around
1:13:46 The needs that we perceive and the community is perceived and that we build into a new iteration of the master plan. That's at least how I perceive it. So maybe this new master plan, you know, the section on existing trail system really nicely breaks up, you know, the focuses of the four square miles, the urban growth boundary to the town boundary, and then the sphere of influence. And so maybe we're on to those next steps, the between the
1:14:16 The town boundary and urban growth boundary focus on that and a sphere of influence, that whole area and kind of a more, I don't know, diving into that next evolution. Yeah. I think the UGB is quite small and we maintain all national forest trails within the municipal boundary, which goes right up to the wilderness boundary in the lakes basin, right? So we've established ourselves as really good.
1:14:44 Stewards of those resources and gained a lot of trust with the Forest Service. So, yeah, I think you're spot on with, you know, to Rob's point, thinking about a different lens to look at how we want to manage what we have and then also thinking about targeted efforts where we might want to go outside of that municipal boundary and create some opportunities for
1:15:15 E-bikes are, you know, developing uses that aren't really maybe appropriate within the municipal boundary. I also think the sphere of influence looks west and not as a sphere. It doesn't look at, you know, Hawk Creek or towards Crowley or north towards June. It says, you know, Red's Minnow, Devil's Post File, John Muir Trail.
1:15:44 Pacific Crest in the town. It doesn't... The map will help illustrate it. It's pretty big. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Great. And just a couple comments. As I've been sitting here thinking, you know, what will the next phase look like? And to me, I've been beating just one drum of connecting communities. And that's kind of... I did it.
1:16:14 I had my golden era 20 years ago of doing that, but I want to, you know, see it official. And so, you know, the next phase will look like staging areas. It will look like e-bikes. I don't really see anything wrong with e-bikes, but I don't use them. But I think it's something we got to, you know, look at. And then I'm thinking,
1:16:44 Everything within like a 45-minute drive of Mammoth, you know, we maintain trails, OHV opportunities, you know, you name it. Like we're doing good work up in the Lakes Basin, but, you know, it should be, you know, all the other trails that are heavily impacted too, you know, it could be something like Convict Lake. You know, there's all these spots that are, you know,
1:17:13 Adjacent to Mammoth. And so it's all of it. And they're all connected. And in the end, you know, I'm watching all these other communities reach out with these giant trail systems, or like the one that popped up like a year ago, they're trying to bring it down from Tahoe to Lone Pine. It was like a cool thing, but it was like a pipe dream.
1:17:43 But we need to take control of everything, you know, in our sphere, which gets bigger than just the town. So that's kind of what I see the next phase looking like. And it's what, you know, residents use. It's what visitors use. It's we're not. All of these people are not held to the town. It is the sphere of influence. And that does what draws people to Mammoth Lakes is all of it.
1:18:14 And I think breaking that down in food for thought, like, where is that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System? Where is it the regional collaborative potentially that Andrew has discussed before? What are those boundaries? What are those lines? If that's something, you know, this group wants to pursue. And I think if we're going to go that route, maybe, you know, the county now has a rec office, right? And so some coordination language in there with reaching out to the county because
1:18:44 You know, if we go to the residents of Mammoth Lakes, how many are they going to stomach doing trail work, you know, at Convict Lake or in June Lake with their tax funds? Completely off task, but that's the way my mind often works. Do we feel like our job within the trail system would include interpretation? We have no one doing that. We have the Mammoth City site, the mill site.
1:19:17 A little site we can't use right now. But there's a lot of, you know, the Glass Creek Meadow, which has some history. The Convict Lake has some history. The settling ponds down there, we can explain to people what they are. But there are opportunities which create, especially for our visitors, a better experience. Should that be part of our purview? We talk about signing a lot, but usually we're talking about directional signing. Should interpretation be part of the trail?
1:19:48 It's just a master plan and the trails plans moving forward. I think that Sherwin Meadows Trailhead is a good example of that because there's a lot of interpretive signs out there. It's really kind of a hit in my opinion. And the growing host program I think potentially has entered that world a little bit, right, Gretchen? Not really. Yeah. Talk to me about history. I think that we just...
1:20:19 That's something I think we should look at, and I think if that is something this committee and people provide direction for our department to do, we can look at for sure, but more support, more funding, that's people on the ground, that's staffing is our number one expense. Yeah, and that's what I wanted to get at, right? Interpretation itself is creating intellectual, emotional, and visceral connections to a resource, right? But there are many ways to accomplish that. And what, again, is in the purview of kind of this trail system,
1:20:49 Which leverages Measure R, you know, heavily to accomplish a lot of what we want to do out there. You know, Gretchen has folks doing primarily more visitor information, although there has been a little bit of a transition into that education with some of the bear work that we have done in campgrounds. So again, what is interpretation? What facets would you want to include within something like this? Again, I just ordered...
1:21:16 Three interp signs for all the timber work done in Mammoth Creek.
1:21:20 To put along the multi-use pathway there along with, in conjunction with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they just need to be installed, all the awesome clean up the lake efforts in the lakes basin, right? And obviously I think that's something that's been under the purview of the trail system. There's lots of interpretive signs out there on the landscape. But again, if we're talking about another form of interpretation, a campfire program in a campground, a guided hike, those are all forms of interpretation. And I think that would be for the committee to decide what types of interpretation.
1:21:50 They would want in this scenario. I also want to bring up the fact that one of the things I struggle with for this committee too is all my host program, all of that stuff is under general fund, Office of Outdoor Recreation, and I think that goes back to we need to define your committee's roles and responsibility with the Office of Outdoor Recreation, with the trail system, and how does it all overlap. So really hoping you guys can help with that.
1:22:19 If that is something that this committee wants to have influence on and oversee and direct us to do or give us as a guiding tool, you know, it is coming from general fund, not from the Measure R budget that you guys are reviewing and overseeing. So it's just another layer that is something to think about with the committee's role going back to the original.
1:22:45 Yeah, it's actually, it is in the general fund. It's funded by Tourism Reserve, though. So that's one of the things that, and that's appropriately so, right? I mean, that's what that committee does is support that. But I think it's interesting to have that conversation around the host program, right? The host program is not anywhere in this document whatsoever, but it's an incredibly...
1:23:05 I think there was a mention of... Establish a trail patrol, E6. But trail patrol is different, right? I mean, that is something that, you know, I heard about a year ago and I go, what the heck are these people doing? But those are augmenting enforcement. This has been more of an amenity augmentation than it is an enforcement aspect of it. And so...
1:23:29 When you mentioned interpretive things, I think you had a specific thing you were trying to get at. It was either understanding historical significance or something along those lines, which is sort of the traditional sense of that word. But do we need to step back and look at it? What's the next host program aspect that we're not even thinking about that will add value to the overall program? And it could touch on that in a different way than simply signs.
1:23:58 But just what does that look like? Because I didn't see the host program in there. I know the enforcement part of it is. But there's more of that to be identified. And that will make the program more rich, stronger, and more effective. Yeah, I mean, I think the host program is a great asset for the trails. And so I would definitely support adding that in in some way, shape, or form.
1:24:37 You know, this table, like education, encouragement, and enforcement programs has a few ideas that are just kind of half-baked, right? And we've run with the host program to fulfill needs as they arose. And I think there's...
1:24:56 Other things in here, like publish a trail guide for Mammoth Lakes. It's not clearly outlined, but is that mammothtrails.org or is that the handouts that we do? So, you know, these were kind of like the seeds and what they've become. There's a few things that they've become, but then there's also sort of seed ideas that haven't really made it into anything yet. So, you know, I think like school programs or, you know, getting kids out there more.
1:25:26 I got the opportunity to go out with an AP environmental science class once, and it was amazing, but it was just like random. I was in a meeting with Wendy Sugimura, and she put it together, but it's like we could be a lot more proactive about, you know, making that a little bit more of our work program. Yeah, or maybe that's revised to say like, you know, partnering with other people.
1:25:52 Maybe that's not exactly what you guys have to do to execute that, but there's a lot of good organizations, you know, where you could be being that partner. I think of, I don't know, there's a lot of, I was just at Kidapalooza, so there's a lot, you know, Sierra Stem and people like that, like there's, they probably would love to do trail stuff, so maybe it's just a retweaking of that.
1:26:11 That's the type of nuance, too, that I think is really important for things like this. To your point, too, across from the community center there, you know, and bikes getting across and the wayfinding, right? Just even the nuance for that. Wayfinding when you're sitting at your home before you come here. Wayfinding when you maybe grab some materials or something like that from a visitor center. And then wayfinding when you just show up somewhere and see a sign, you know, the minutia related to those things. It's not just kind of one or the other, right? How do you create that?
1:26:40 That holistic thing from wherever a human is at to be able to navigate our system. I just picked up this document and my brain is like focused on this education encouragement and enforcement program. It's sort of like where can I go? What are the rules? Am I going to get in trouble? And what am I going to learn out of it? Like that's a, there's a lot happening in that one section. A lot of evolution. I think that's a hard, you know, like.
1:27:09 We publish another, you know, as technology, the way that people are accessing their technology, it just changes, you know. Is a trail guide, would you publish a trail guide? Probably not, you know. I mean, maybe we do, but, yeah. I just want to throw out there, I had some slow times when I was at work, so I read both of these documents, and I'm surprised that we have, you know, accomplished so much from such dry material.
1:27:46 It was all about, you know, how big the sign needs to be and what color it is, you know. I was like, I went through pages of that. So, if it's going to be redone, you know, let's make it a little more relevant. So, it was very technical. Maybe leave those to appendices or... Yeah, I guess just bringing it back.
1:28:24 Do you feel like this is a good format to keep going with reviewing? And are we all up to the task and excited about it? Do you think there's additional assignment discussion about, as we go through this process, how we should start to document changes that we think should occur? I know that's what you're seeking. Yeah, yeah. I think that would be great if you guys wanted to just
1:28:54 Provide notes directly back to his team. I don't know, do you think we need to have a more structured feedback? No, I just, I think it's been good in here in the discussion, you know, someone will say something and others will think of just how that, what that means to them and it's just a little bit of a good back and forth. I am very interested in the future phase and just how things, you know, trying to forecast how the needs, the usage, the technology,
1:29:23 Functionality, all that stuff will modify over time. And so it would be interesting to see, to think in those terms, right? Like, what are we missing or what's on the horizon as we look through it? How could this all evolve? Reviews evolve a ton tonight because I think that's really what the state of this conversation is about. And I mean, you know, a little, this master plan review is,
1:29:55 Without this group, it would be on us, right, to come up with the content and direct the contractor. The contractor fluffs it out, right? They don't come with any, like, real meaningful information, right? It's on us as the community to come up with this document to guide us moving forward. So I would just say, you know, there's a little bit of responsibility on our plate, right, to really take it seriously.
1:30:24 And to move it in a direction that we think makes sense, to your point. So it's not like there's somebody that we're going to hire that's going to come in with the magic wand and tell us, you know, what's going to be right for our community because they really don't have that information. What is the process for the master plan? The last group that did this was Alta, and I've worked with them on several planning projects.
1:30:50 It is what you make of it, you know? I mean, they come in and they can facilitate some public meetings, but... Is that something that we put a survey out on? Like, did we do that in the first master plan? There's a lot of it. So, I can share a document out. This master planning process right now is going on with the Parks and Rec master plan. That's the first step. And both Hayes and Stu did a presentation probably a year ago that...
1:31:18 Outlined exactly how that would look for all of the plans going forward, and so it's really well designed. There's a lot of public input in it, but I think what Andrew's saying is the expertise on what the needs are isn't going to come from any contractor, but the organizational skills and so forth is. But I can go back and share that document with this whole group on this is what we laid out for that. It's about an 18-month process, I think, to go from start to finish before you end up with a produced document.
1:31:46 We're trying to stitch all these together, and these master plans really will culminate into a general plan update, right? So it's kind of a larger process than, and that's a seven-year process probably to get through that. So it's pretty substantial. But we did define updating master plan, what it looks like, and participants and process, and I can share that out. That wasn't supposed to be the...
1:32:15 The bridge of the community, I certainly wouldn't feel comfortable not having further input from other people. Staff, do you feel you've gotten enough from this discussion? I think it's a great kickoff and just know that the next homework is on this staff report and it's a lot longer.
1:32:48 Yeah, I think it'll be great to dive in in more detail on the individual topics moving forward. Great. All right. Thank you, everybody. We'll move on to agenda item number six, committee member reports. Let's start on this side of the table with John. All right. I don't know if everyone's seen it, but there is like a survey online for Chipmunk Canyon that's out there, which is
1:33:17 Super interesting because it's a huge trail system and it looks like, you know, maybe the land managers want to take it under their responsibility. Well, who knows? But just, you know, how one system gets built and how other ones get built, you know, it's interesting to me. So I like to follow along. I would think, you know, with all the new trails out at the Sherwins, I have actually seen less.
1:33:47 People building their own trails, because why do all the back-breaking labor when, you know, it's being provided for you out there. So that's just something I notice. Who knows if it's 100% accurate. But I have people I don't even know, you know, hit me up at the grocery store. It's, you know, he knows. And so I keep a little map of all the new trails so I can just, you know, text it off to people and get a lot of...
1:34:15 You know, very positive feedback, what's happening out there, and I let them know, hey, there's a lot more that's coming, and, you know, even though five or six more miles doesn't sound like a lot, it's something, and it shows people what it's like, you know, when you have amenities close to town that you can use, but a lot of positive feedback from it, so I'm impressed by that. That's my report.
1:34:48 I had another kid, so I've got a six-week-old at home, so that's been a lot of what's going on with me. But we got out hiking a bit, everything's looking good, trails are melting out, like spacing is looking good already. I opened the trails news, the Mammoth Trail System news.
1:35:19 And I noticed that the trails committee meeting wasn't on there. And that might be a good way to get some more public input just when there's an upcoming trails committee meeting to add that to that one and the trailhead news and any of the other email blasts that we can. And then I'd still like to see a term review of the trails committee.
1:35:48 Where we're at on all those. It was in? Oh. Okay. Perfect. Thank you. Go ahead. Pass it over, Carolyn. We had the pamper pedal. Can we get to go? Yeah. And it was a great event. Gretchen, last weekend. We had 110 ladies and the weather was a little scary going into it, but it worked out great. We ended up giving...
1:36:24 $2,000 back, so $1,000 to the Bishop Mountain Bike Team and $1,000 to the Mammoth Mountain Bike Team, so that was cool. Yeah, so that was busy for a week or two. Don't despair, summer is coming. That's it. I had nothing to report. Well, this is like show and tell, jump in and so. Semba stuff, the VC races are...
1:36:54 Starting Thursday, we had to postpone the first one because the weather was crap. But the first one is Thursday. There's going to be five. Pedalpalooza, the mountain bike race, is July 25th. So we're excited about that. So, yeah. So I think the cycling community is abuzz and we're going to be seeing a lot of activity starting on Thursday.
1:37:21 Thanks to the new trails. But we had to skip it, but we'll be back there, I think, in July, I think we'll be back there. Yeah, I've been getting out there a little bit. I got to ride some of the new trails. Definitely a little section I had to walk up. Rocky area, but super fun and flowy. Really enjoyed that. And then I recently took a...
1:37:50 Super multimodal trip to Portland, Oregon on the coast. Took the train up from Sacramento and then bussed over to the coast and then rode my bike up the coast with my girlfriend for a little bit and then bussed back and talk about bike infrastructure in Portland was pretty incredible with the coloring of lanes, protected lanes, just routes through community. So it was kind of cool to see all of that going on.
1:38:19 And be around that. I was asking about, you know, well, first off, I'm just always impressed with how you guys are managing the budget. And it kind of shows during this time of the year when you get out and you think we're in summer, kind of, but then you find all these snow patches. And so I think like, man, we have this weird March, April, May, June of who knows when the snow is going to melt and then summer comes full on and there's that kind of break in the budget. And I think you guys do a great job managing that because you're doing,
1:38:49 Four months now and then let's see what happens in those four early months. So definitely that time of year where you get onto trails and find a surprise snowy patch and tree down and obviously you can't get out there and do all that work now. But now you're starting to be able to. But yeah, so just enjoying the hiking up to Crystal Lake and Cloud Lake and getting out there right now and enjoying the trails. That's all I have to report.
1:39:25 Yeah, yeah, he went real quick. So we'll jump to number seven, request for future agenda items. I think we got a pretty good agenda going so far with the work Anzu's doing. All right, number eight, adjournment. Is there a motion to adjourn? I moved. Got a motion, second it if needed, and we can adjourn at 6.40.
1:40:06 Oh yeah.