Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
8 findings- Flock deletes at 30 days; the Town's own rules let MLPD keep copies "when no longer required" Flock investigation
-
In June 2024 the Council was told every search would carry a case number
Flock investigation
Also in: License Plate Readers (Flock) - The Flock agreement lets the Town end it on 30 days' notice by not funding it License Plate Readers (Flock)
- Smaller details: the camera rate, Raven coverage, and Raven performance claims License Plate Readers (Flock)
- Council authorized a one-year, not-to-exceed $25,000 Flock lease for eight ALPR cameras on July 17, 2024 License Plate Readers (Flock)
- The MLPD Flock contract slide lists $24,000 for eight cameras and a $25,000 annual recurring subtotal License Plate Readers (Flock)
- Town documents say Flock data is deleted after 30 days, with exceptions for criminal prosecution and evidence License Plate Readers (Flock)
- The Council considered a one-year Flock Safety lease for eight license plate cameras, with a staff-recommended limit of $25,000 Public Safety and Police
Transcript
550 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:00 Jamie, are we ready? You got it. I will then call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council June 5. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. Thank you. Pledge of Allegiance, Betsy Truax is going to lead us in the pledge tonight. Betsy, please.
3:32 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you all. Public comments, now is the time any member of the public wishes to speak on anything that is not otherwise on tonight's agenda. Good evening, my name is Kathy Cage.
3:56 I wanted to address the council to make a request for a possible future agenda item to talk about where
4:05 The appropriate future location for a community center would be. My husband and I happened to catch the planning commission review of the town civic center plans and, you know, clear it's not the community center's not going there, it's not in the CRC, and I'm concerned that as we develop things and every possible spot is taken up and it still doesn't have a community center, my worry is that
4:29 You know, we may get a little development spurt here maybe after limelight goes in and some of the other development there if it actually happens and then we'll get pressure again for redevelopment of the town's property up near the village where the current community center is. As I recall, our public works director has said that he doesn't believe that current structure is of enough value to continue to put money into it. As I recall, who knows?
4:56 But my guess is even in this current state, it's probably not the kind of thing we want to have for our future. I'm just concerned that unless the town council said it's important to have a community center in the future, it's got to go somewhere. At least it doesn't have to be a spending priority now, but identifying and reserving the space kind of does, I think.
5:17 You know, maybe you could ask the rec commission staff or something to give maybe a one and two location. And then at least if another proposal comes to use the space otherwise, you know, we just won't lose it. You know, I've been to many different events at the community centers out in the county in Crowley, Levining. Some of them are quite lovely. You know, you can do a nice little reception with some nice indoor-outdoor space. On the review of the Civic Center, I heard Hayes talk about, you know, a future phase.
5:46 Sounded a little more utilitarian than what a nice community center might be where you could have a little wedding reception or quinceañera or something like that. Anyway, that's my request is just if one of the council members might ask to have something on a future agenda so we can talk about it, I'd love an opportunity to advocate for what features should be in it so that would help you. Any architect will tell you, give me the scope of what you want it to do and then we'll design it.
6:13 So that's my request. If we could potentially put something like that in the future agenda, I'd be happy to come back and advocate for some views about where it should go or what it should include. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comments? Seeing none, we will move on to additions or changes of the agenda. Rob, do we have any additions or changes? No, Mr. Mayor, there are no changes to the agenda. Thank you. We will now open a workshop with the
6:47 Board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We have a budget presentation. Yeah, so, John, we're going to go to you on this. You have the presentation. What size nap is this going to be for me? Okay, give me one second. My computer battery is not great, so I'm going to plug it in here. All right, here we are.
7:47 What we're going to do today, thank you, Mr. Mayor, John Urdi, Maniflake Storzen. We're going to walk you through our strategic plan for this year as well as the high side of the budget. In your packets, you do have the Excel sheets, which is very, very detailed line items of the budget. The plan is that each of our department heads will come up and do presentations of their specific department.
8:07 Please feel free to ask questions as we go. Don't want you to forget them. Don't want them to have to keep going up and down. So when you do have questions, please just raise your hand and let them know that you have something that you want to get a little more detail on. Right now we've got Sarah Winters will be remoting in on Zoom, and so she will be here available for you through the ether. And I will start us off here, but we are happy to be here.
8:39 So first off, we want to just talk about kind of the state of where we've been in the last fiscal year. So you're aware we came out with the Real Unreal campaign back in October of 2022, really all focused on stewardship, the idea of keeping Mammoth Lakes unreal, not focusing on necessarily visitation. We know this is a beautiful place, but we want to keep people coming up here thinking that they're in an unreal place, but we want to make sure that they preserve it for future generations.
9:08 One thing that we found from some local focus groups and some other pieces that we did was that we maybe weren't as straightforward about the stewardship message as possible. I think it resonated in the marketplace, but I think locally it didn't really resonate as much that it was a stewardship and a please take care of this place message. So we're looking at how we can tweak that for this year. If we rewind back to a year ago.
9:32 Spring 2023 was a challenge for us. Summer did not start until July 21st when we got the Lakes Basin open, Tioga Pass, and Devils Postpile. That was really a very late start to the summer. Fortunately, this summer is starting off much better. I think it's going to let us finish fiscal year 2023-24 strong. Last summer, despite those massive snow challenges that we had in the spring, we still ended up having a fantastic year.
10:00 August through October set new records for TOT, and so that was helpful, and obviously last year's fiscal year ended at a record all-time. We were able to renew the TBID, thank you, Town Council, last year for a five-year renewal, and we also had our contract renewed for the three-year period. We focused on getting a need time event. We brought in OCR last October. It was really not as successful as we had hoped or that we were.
10:29 I think there were a lot of challenges with it between the event being purchased late, some of the Forest Service challenges, and I think that we were a little bit behind the eight ball, but we are working for this year to take that event to a whole nother level. The goal for the event promoters is to get 5,000 people here, and then I think we're going to revisit what event we're hosting here.
10:52 With all that said, last year was our first year that we had achieved a million dollars in T.O.T. for the month of October, so even though it may not have been as productive as we had hoped, I think it did get us over that million dollar mark, which is something that we've never been able to achieve. This year we are just, we're well ahead on T.O.T. budget. We are literally 0.97% behind on the T.O.T. budget, and that has a lot to do with the late start to the snow.
11:18 I think that when we lose the month of December, or not lose, but where it's challenged to bring in as many people as normal, it really sets us up for a challenge for the year, but we have been able to pick up those losses over the course of the fiscal, and my guess is we're probably looking at a $27.5 to $28 million TOE2 year at the end of it, so that's good. So to go through the goals of our organization, we did this presentation for our board back in March.
11:46 Number one goal is to foster a symbiotic partnership with the community. Community engagement is critical, and we'll go over some of that. And then educating visitors about the impacts that they make on our community. You know, I think that's critical. And then supporting our residents, the businesses, and the town of Mammoth Lakes during the slow periods. You know, we talked about it in our board meeting today. Occupancy right now today is 22%. Last week was in the low teens.
12:11 So we do have opportunities in the spring and fall. As much as I think we have a lot of folks that want to have a little bit of a break after the winter, we also have a lot of businesses that still need to pay their bills and their employees. So to dig a little deeper into the community engagement, our goal again is to foster that symbiotic relationship and really gathering the resident input.
12:40 We went out last fall. We did a resident sentiment survey. I'll talk a little bit about that throughout the course of this conversation. We also did focus groups with a number of different folks to really understand kind of what the pressure points are, what the challenges are. We are working with...
12:57 Councilmember Wentworth has been part of this process with JLL, which is a company that's working with Visit California on statewide strategic plans. We've got 13 specific regions in the state that are being discussed, and we are obviously one of those combined with Yosemite and Tahoe, so it's not necessarily going to be a one-size-fits-all. Yosemite has a gate. We do not have a gate.
13:17 Tahoe has a day visitor problem. We really don't have a day visitor problem. So we are discussing the opportunity for us to potentially bring them in to do a Mammoth Lake-specific sustainable destination management plan because while we'll glean a lot of good information from the regional plan, it won't be specific to us. Really getting our staff members and our board members out to discuss the challenges that are out in the community.
13:44 Making sure that it's not just myself, it's not just our staff, but getting the board members talking to constituents, finding out what those infrastructure needs are, what those pressure points are, what the focuses are. Listening to the ideas that come from those community partners and really integrate them into our projects and initiatives. I think the infrastructure that we've started to set money aside for in this current fiscal year, we've set aside money.
14:11 Budget that we're talking about today, we've continued to set aside money towards joint opportunities with the town. And so we still have skin in that game and we want to be part of that process. On the community engagement side for sharing, we want to make sure that we have clearly articulated mission, vision, and values. One of the things that we'll be doing, and it is part of the, it's actually part of the measure A budget that I've put in, it's the only thing in the overhead line, it's $10,000 to do a strategic planning session in February.
14:43 For the process of really determining where we're headed for 2024 and 2025 and beyond, looking at building a three-year plan. It's in February because we've got a couple of key staff members that are going out on maternity leave that I want to make sure that are involved, and we should have them back by February at that point. Using our collective voice for tourism as a driver for change, I think that's critical. We know that we live and die on tourism here, and we need to make sure that we are directing that the way that we as residents and as the community want that business to come in.
15:13 Recognizing our locals as brand ambassadors, this is a critical one. I think everybody in this room knows you're here for a reason, you live here for a reason, you have a business here for a reason, and you are our best ambassadors, and we want to make sure that we capitalize on that. Last thing here is to develop a Powered by Tourism message. In a resident sentiment survey that we did was interesting, 93% of the respondents said that tourism was critically important to our community.
15:40 Only 35% of them felt that they actually had a better life because of tourism. And so I think when you look at things like the completion of the CRC, you know, we did over 29,000 paid visits to the CRC this year. The biggest that we ever did in the outdoor rink was just over 10,000. You know, people are utilizing these things. And a lot of that money came because of Measure R, which comes from visitors. We came from the general fund, which comes from visitors. So I think there's a lot of things that we need people to understand that the visitor economy is driving these.
16:08 Even the money that's been to the parcel bill, I think it was $30 million at the last count, had been put towards housing from the TOT, and I think that's critical. Even things down to the free transit and bus shelters. We don't have those things without those visitor callers. So that's a critical thing that we want to work towards moving forward as well. On the deliver side, it's really developing solid numbers in our visitor profiles to share with the business community. You know, we do a lot of research, and we do a lot of things that can help people.
16:40 Understand who's coming here, what they're doing, what they're spending, and what they are for value to our community. I think that's critical. I think that people need to understand the full scope of what people bring to us.
16:52 You know, I'd like to create a stewardship committee and a plan for that. Betsy Truax is in the audience here. Betsy is joining us as of July 1. Betsy will be our community engagement director. We are working towards how do we build that symbiotic relationship, and that's really Betsy's world, to build a community engagement plan and then really start to work on some of these other pieces to say how do we all work together towards that common goal because, again, 93% of the community recognizes that we...
17:17 Live and die on tourism. We just need to make sure that everybody understands what the value of it is on the flip side. The three-year strategic plan will be a big piece for us, and I think that's also going to come out of that session that we do with the board in February. Education. You know, this is something that we have, we switched gears to education prior to COVID. It went on to high gear after COVID, and it's not looking back.
17:49 This is all about the stewardship message. This is where the real and real comes in, you know, making sure that we educate people with all the tools that we possibly have out there. You know, heavily promoting the stewardship message. The real and real, the whole campaign is designed for stewardship. It's not, it has nothing to do really with visitation. It's more about when you come here. This is what we expect of you. This is how we expect you to respect the community and the environment. Again, continuing to participate in discussions, efforts, partnerships that help mitigate those visitation impacts. That's critical.
18:18 You know, I think we've got a lot of great things on. Hayes and his team have a lot of great programs that are coming up here. Those are the sort of things that we're setting aside these funds so we can sit down with Hayes and say, how can we help? What can we bring to the table? Really communicating our efforts and asking for feedback. So making sure people understand what we're putting out there and why, and then if it really resonates with them. And then working together as a team. So our individual departments.
18:47 I think we need to get people out to more events to understand exactly when Michael talks about us going back into China this coming fiscal year because they have 300 million skiers and they're all traveling independently versus as bus groups now. That's an opportunity for us. And I think if we can get out of the community and talk to other NGOs and talk to other groups and make sure that everybody understands why we're doing certain things, I think that's going to be very helpful for us in the future.
19:13 The last thing continues to be critical for us. As I mentioned right now, we're at 22% occupancy tonight, 24% occupancy tomorrow. Not great numbers. Better than last week. Really utilizing the data that we have to look at are we really maximizing our key international markets, looking at our off-season events. Anything outside of anything before 4th of July and after Labor Day is a huge thing for us. Anything we can do to drive those business times is huge.
19:43 Again, quality versus quantity. When I was hired back in 2010, we were facing municipal bankruptcy. The effort was bring as many people here as you can. We need the money. Now it's not so much. Now it's let's bring the folks that are going to be respectful and appreciate our community and the environment. Pivoting messaging. We talked about this in our board meeting as well. Having the flexibility. You know, this winter is a perfect example. We went into it with our normal messaging.
20:12 Didn't snow, we pulled back, we waited until it snowed, and then we really tried to hammer it, and we've recovered quite a bit since then because of that. Midweek visitation, longer stays, less impact, you know, higher spend. That's where air service comes in, that's where destination comes in. When we look at the folks that are flying in here, I was looking at the research this morning, the number one out of California market, first time visitor was New York. New York is the top spending market in the country.
20:38 And so the opportunity to continue to bring them here on a Tuesday when we don't have business, it's a great experience for them and it helps our shops and restaurants stay in business. Shoulder Seasons, we talked about that enough today. The collaborative opportunities with our local business community, again, and all of these pieces fall into what Betsy is going to be focusing on in the community engagement side. So just to give a little bit of highlights on some of the changes in the budget, as I mentioned,
21:07 You have all the detail in the Excel sheets, line item by line item, very, very detailed. Happy to sit down with anyone one-on-one with those. The increases to our wage line, mainly we've got two new key employees. We have two brand new positions. We've hired a content marketing manager, Laura Waddles. She'll be joining us June 17th. Sarah Walsh, who joined us back earlier in the month of May.
21:32 And then Betsy will be joining us, but her position is really replacing Laura Kaler's Director of Community Engagement position that she left. Again, Michael will talk about adding in representation in China. The Community Engagement Plan. We have budgeted to create a Community Engagement Plan. How do we need to get out there and talk to people? A lot of it is research. A lot of it is really doing that effort to listen and understand what people are struggling with. Sarah will talk a little bit in her marketing piece about a Community Engagement Marketing.
22:02 You know, I think one of the things that I've heard since I got here is, you know, well, we don't see your marketing. That's by design. We're not marketing to locals to get molecules here. We're out in the world marketing to get people here. We realize that we need to educate people as to what our messaging is out there and why it's out there. And so that's a big piece of that community engagement. That strategic planning session that I had mentioned, increased funding for air subsidy and service.
22:28 We've supported air subsidy out of the TBID budget at $1.5 million in the winter since we put the TBID in place in 2013. So I've taken that up to $1.75 million for the winter. And what that does is it reduces the impacts or the potential risk to the other partners, the municipalities, Inyo County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Mountain, so that we can take on more of that burden. And then again, continuing to compile those infrastructure dollars.
22:56 Rob and I have had a lot of really good conversations about, well, do we spend the $185,000 that we put aside this year, or do we compound that so that we can put a bigger piece into something that's going to make more of an impact? And again, that's where Rob and I have conversations, and that's where we'll get together with Hayes and talk about what the opportunities are there. So those are just some of the high-level call-outs on the budget. And now I'm going to turn it over to Sarah, and because she's remote, I'm going to let her share her screen.
23:27 Are there any questions on my portion first? Okay. Take it away, Sarah. Sorry, I'm just getting to the correct page. And then I will share the presentation. Hopefully this is coming up okay. Hi, everybody. Lovely to see you virtually. Sarah Winters, Director of Marketing. I'm going to take us through our strategic plan and then some of our paid channels. So kind of a refresher here on our framework.
24:09 And you can see our different impact timing here. So, you know, we categorize fall, winter, spring, and summer with the additional market of being air service, always wanting to push that winter and summer air service that we have. Hey, Sarah, can you make your screen full screen? Oh, sorry. Yes, I can't. Start the presentation. There we go. Thank you. Better? Sorry about that.
24:42 And then looking at kind of some of these additional marketing goals that John mentioned for this year, marketing objectives being that local community outreach, the evolution of the real and real and educating visitors on responsible and sustainable travel, and then looking how we can continue to increase that length of stay and visitor spend. As a reminder, these are our brand attributes, so from functional to emotional.
25:08 You know, talking about really that emphasis on natural beauty and then tugging on the hard strings of how do we leave that lasting impression? How do we keep this, how do we keep this place unreal for generations to come? Brand positioning, you don't know until you go. So really kind of talking to consumers needs on the mother nature's adventure land and really that.
25:35 You haven't really experienced Mother Nature until you come to Mammoth Lake. So down to earth, rugged, confident, genuine and relatable. The creative messaging for the strategy of the real and real has two pillars. You have the brand. It's so incredible. You have to see it to believe it. And then we have our stewardship.
25:57 It's so incredible. You have to protect it no matter what. And as John mentioned earlier, these two are one in the same. When we're talking about our brand, even from a high level of brand awareness down the funnel, we are looking at how we are communicating that stewardship message, how to keep Mammoth Lakes Unreal. So the evolution of the Real Unreal campaign. So we're really focusing on how can we directly communicate, keeping the focus on stewardship.
26:27 So making sure that as we're taking people from awareness into booking down the funnel, being very much more direct to really hit on that stewardship message, as well as to drive that midweek air service and visitation and that longer length of stay. Target markets. So nothing here should be all that surprising. Our near markets are California and Nevada with, you know, an emphasis on Southern California as well as San Francisco.
26:57 Our farm markets being Denver and the Northeast, as John mentioned, New York being one of the most lucrative markets for us, and international, which Michael will touch upon later. Here are our target audiences, so depending on the seasons, this is what we really focus on. So nature enthusiasts without kids, those fall colors, so people being able to drop whatever they're doing and come up to really react to kind of how the fall colors are evolving.
27:29 Are interested in snow activities as well as just general outdoor activities. And the key impacts, so kind of I mentioned this, but we have fall season, winter season, spring and summer, depending on the year. Last year we didn't have a summer, so I think that all depends on the winter. And then always having an air service message to support both summer and winter air service.
27:56 So we have an integrated approach and you're going to hear from everybody on the team. So from paid, owned, earned to events, international and local marketing. So how do we measure how we're doing? We look at this in different ways. So designated KPIs. So we have different benchmarks from just a day-to-day guidance and how we're going to pivot our marketing and our local efforts, depending on how we're doing and how we're going to improve informant.
28:24 Performance. We have a reporting, so really optimizing KPIs. So how are we looking at different KPIs? And we'll go into that a little bit. It's different per department. It's different per media buy. And so kind of looking at everything from video views down to impressions to engagement rate. And then research. So depending on the year, we have different types of research. So we always have an ad effect in this study, which really shows how our brand resonates with consumers.
28:52 We have a visitor volume and slash economic impact study depending on the year. We are always looking at our seasonal air service studies. So we actually give surveys at both of the airports to really capture that real-time data.
29:08 And then we have a data partner called Tourism Economics or Symphony as they've been renamed where we get access to lots of different data points including Visa View data to get a snapshot of international geolocation data and so on.
29:27 So what do our program plans and budgets look like as we move forward? I'm going to dive into the domestic consumer programs, specifically our paid channels. So kind of as a refresher, these are our business objectives. Like, I don't want to keep saying it, but midweek, increasing flight service, or increasing flight.
29:48 Occupancy and really trying to drive general brand awareness and consideration with an intent to travel to Mammoth Lakes. And then you can see some of those strategies really include that full funnel approach that I'm going to dive into. So the full funnel media approach awareness. So we always have a brand awareness component to our paid advertising. As we go down the funnel, we have consideration. So really driving qualified leads.
30:17 All the way down to intent. So getting those conversions to book, to get those people to book those trips to Mammoth Lakes. Just a sample snapshot at some of our media partners. Every year we develop a new paid media channel. That doesn't mean these all change, but often there are new partners and players and we try to capitalize on those different opportunities. A great example of video and audio are Hulu and Pandora.
30:44 Social, which isn't always on platform for us from a paid and organic standpoint is, you know, Facebook and Instagram. So the meta channels. Programmatic. So Google's always on for us. And then Adtherent was a new partner for us this year. And then Search. So continuing to stay on top of what's happening within the search realm and how AI is going to affect that moving forward.
31:08 So our fall campaign framework, typically this starts mid-August and runs through October, and we spend about $250,000 here. We're looking at how we can increase this because our KPIs are performing really well, there's an interest, and there's a lot of conversion that's happening. I know John just touched upon the fact that we made $1 million in TBID that month, so I think kind of looking at how can we continue to grow that, we notice that there's a lot of...
31:36 Midweek visitation during this season and we want to continue to support the fall efforts. Our winter campaign framework, so this is where we spend the bulk of our dollars supporting farm markets, so not only our near markets of California and Nevada, but our farm markets of Denver and the Northeast.
31:55 And then this is where we start to look at where can we consider other markets. And a lot of that is dictated by the partnership that we have with United and where new flights going to be coming in from. And I know John actively works on that, but kind of looking at the budget, spreading it further over to the Northeast and pulling back a little bit in Denver this coming year, just based on the performance from the 23-24 fiscal year.
32:21 And then a summer recap. So depending again on the summer, we launched in April of this year. So we'll probably be running through August. And this is really the drive market. So the California, Nevada. And again, the key message is kind of being wellness, nature, midweek offers and responsible and sustainable travel. Air service. So and then winter and spring campaigns. We really look to target specific audiences based on.
32:52 You know, A, what is near us and B, where those heavy icon pass holders are, Northeast being one of them. We also look at that data I mentioned where we can actually see where people are booking flights from. We look at the air service studies and we really try to make sure that we're targeting those relevant markets. And then we really benefit from our partnership with United. There's a matching dollar amount. So we try to maximize every year the program that we do with United.
33:24 This is a snapshot at our budget for brand strategy, creative and media. It's not too far off from this current fiscal year. Just dollars are shifting in certain areas, really supporting the Northeast in a more substantial way, pulling back on Denver, which didn't perform necessarily as well in 23, 24. And then looking at kind of what John had mentioned, where can we evolve the real and real to have more of that direct messaging? So not only people are seeing that before,
33:54 In the brand awareness state and in the intent to travel, but when they're in market, how can we make sure that we're executing that cohesively throughout all of our marketing? So it's broken down a little bit differently this year, but same general budget. So I'm going to actually toss it over to Sam for our own channels, and I will stop sharing my screen. Before we do, are there any questions on the marketing side?
34:26 John, why don't we ask if you in the audience got a question on the marketing side? They're all wearing badges and guns, so I suppose that... Hi, my name is Samantha Lindberg. I'm the digital marketing manager, and I'm going to cover our own channels, so starting with our new website launch. In November of 2023, we relaunched our brand new website to align with our Real and Real brand campaign. In the overall design, it was meant to look and feel like an outdoor lifestyle brand to really highlight it.
35:12 How truly unreal our area is. And some of the main features of this relaunch include promoting sustainable tourism, authorizing personalized trip planning, and improved business listings. Some of our website content programs moving forward include we're going to have a higher level of focus on sustainability. And a large part of this includes meeting our guests at the beginning of their planning stages with our pre-arrival guide.
35:41 We also look forward to integrating an interactive map on our homepage. And then some ongoing programs include continuing to promote summer and winter air service, highlighting midweek visitation during winter and shoulder seasons, and maintaining our monthly growth marketing contract for SEL.
36:06 Some of our own channels, you may be wondering, how are we actually driving people to our local businesses? And we do that through website pass-throughs, whether it's internal or external links. And within this past year, we've had nearly 300,000 pass-throughs year-to-date, which is a 24% increase year-over-year. And our visitor guide also has QR codes that directs to our website where users can get further information.
36:38 All of our newsletters are now integrated into our website through one system, IDSS, our content management system. And on average, our newsletters now have a 56% open rate for the 23-24 fiscal year. And as we approach this next fiscal year, we hope to grow our distribution list by 10% across the board. And as you can see on the screen are our traditional newsletters that we have going out throughout the year.
37:07 Now moving on to social media, starting with Instagram. To us, Instagram serves as a platform to spotlight Mammoth Lakes, showcasing its unreal landscapes, experiences, and sustainability messaging to keep Mammoth Lakes unreal. Our main strategy is to hit our key content pillars, which are also up on the screen here. And in addition to our main content pillars, we also boost targeted posts to support important messaging.
37:32 Looking ahead, we're excited to work with local stakeholders to co-create content and collaborate with influencers and content creators. I'll have more on this later. Jumping into Facebook, so Facebook for us generally serves as a community hub for connecting visitors with local experiences, events, and sustainable initiatives. Through Facebook, we support local marketing efforts and campaign videos, share information on upcoming events, news, and general updates, and provide accurate and timely crisis communications as needed.
38:05 Looking ahead, we are going to lean in and support more community engagement messaging and continue to highlight our sustainability efforts and how others can get involved. Now back to our influencers and local ambassadors. We are building out a program to engage with influencers to create authentic content to highlight our business community activities and events within Mammoth Lakes.
38:30 Our goal is to partner with at least four influencers and or content creators with a primary focus on off-season visitation, air service promotion, and sustainability. We're also creating a local ambassador program for this upcoming event season to have someone on-site for coverage of live events, and we think that this will really provide an authentic promotion of events within our area.
38:57 So we are going to re-engage on TikTok as long as we can. We went dark for a period of time just due not to having access. And TikTok is really growing as a platform, as a search engine, with over 40% of Americans now using it for finding their information. And then, so Visit California, through Visit California, we have a partnership with them for...
39:27 Visit California web-hosted stories. And these are evergreen content that is searchable on Google, and they can be embedded within our website. And these continues, you can, in these stories, you can add geolocations that help people directly access information for whatever we create through that story. And so we're excited to integrate these into our website more, social, wherever we can see it best fit.
39:54 As for technology and what's coming forward for us is we're excited to start integrating chat AI into our website and social channels. This will provide real-time assistance with activities, accommodations, and events, and this will also streamline our response time to people that have questions. Any questions before we jump into local marketing from John? Thank you.
40:23 Sam, I'm actually going to do local marketing. Could you drive the slides for me? Yeah. Awesome. I'm just curious about the chat AI. Let me just read. I'm just curious what the algorithms are and who wins and who loses with that.
40:51 Knock on wood, a big fire season, and there's specific information that we want to feed that. We can actually take over the chat and direct, we can input our own information to provide to visitors. Does that answer your question? You're not directing them to specific properties. So we would be directing them to properties within our website, and then if our website does not have the information, it would go to our local partners next.
41:19 I just have a general question about AI in general, but we can save that for later.
41:26 Okay, great. And I kind of want to add on to that, to answering that question. One of the reasons why we're looking at working with GuideGeek specifically, which is an extension of the Matador Network, is because they actually have humans that are helping front load the information to get it to a place where it's the most accurate before AI takes over. And so it will comb our website first looking for that information, which is good timing since we've done a full content audit, we're continuing to audit.
41:55 Sam mentioned in crisis communication, we actually have the ability to override and make sure that we're directing people to the right place. So I'm just going to tag in on the local marketing. So Emily Bryan, our local marketing manager, is on maternity leave. So I kind of wanted to highlight some of our local marketing programs and goals.
42:20 As John mentioned, it's just really important that we're continuing to support local business community through different marketing efforts, communication efforts, optimizing business listings, which we've been able to do by adding IDSS, a CRM, and an integrated business portal for our local business communities. One of the biggest highlights here is actually being able to manage your own business listing.
42:44 Manage your own events that are coming up and really have some ownership over what information is going on to our new website. We'll work with the new community engagement director, Betsy. Welcome, Betsy. We're excited for you to start. And then we'll be looking at how we can evolve the community messaging there. And that's going to really start with bigger campaigns, like John mentioned, whether that ends up being the Powered by Tourism dollars, but looking at how can we really be educating on
43:13 What positive impacts tourism is making in the community. In terms of stewardship messaging, a great example of this is our pre-arrival guide. So we were able to integrate a much needed code of conduct.
43:27 For short-term vacation rentals and lodging properties, as well as really how to be prepared, both from a stewardship side and a recreation side with local partners and organizations. So continuing to partner with and collaborate with certain entities, whether that's Mammoth Lake Trails or the Town of Mammoth Lakes, to educate on key concerns. One of the biggest projects for stewardship messaging coming up is a six-part town video series. I don't know if anyone saw the...
43:54 The lake space and parking video from this winter, but we're working with Gretchen and Kim to really elaborate on how do we really get this information out in kind of like a fun and witty way, but yet really push this responsible tourism messaging. So through video series, newspaper ads, radio PSAs, continued signage, whether that's clean up the lake signage or supporting other signage in the region, continuing to support that stewardship messaging.
44:23 I do want to touch on Clean Up the Lakes. So we're in year two of our five-year matching grant funding with, or not grant funding, funding with Clean Up the Lakes. So we'll share a little bit more about that, but excited to continue that partnership in Clean Up the Lakes Basin. Air service marketing. So from newspaper ads to radio spots to paid social to organic social, we are constantly pushing.
44:47 The air service marketing. I know I even saw Sam's messaging going out on social media today about summer service. Continuing the outreach and promotion of local discount programs. So utilizing local advertising to get that word about and making sure people get those codes. And then working with local properties to promote air service through their own channel.
45:09 How can we support that? We're giving out different photographs, we're giving toolkits, and just making sure that we are providing a service to the local community and business stakeholders to get the information out about air service marketing.
45:24 Promoting local businesses. We continue to sit on the lodging, restaurant, and retail committees and support efforts there. I know I already touched up on the pre-arrival guide, but that really came out of some of these lodging conversations and actively participating in the lodging community and strengthening that partnership. One of the biggest things that we do that has, you know, over a 47% open rate is our current occupancy reporting. So really getting that word out about...
45:51 How many people are coming to town in advance that are going to impact both lodging restaurants and retail? So continuing that program and getting as many lodging properties across the board involved in that. And I am going to let Sam and myself toss it over to Michael for International. Thank you, Sarah. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International Marketing, Sales and PR. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm going to just briefly touch on what our strategy is for
46:22 What am I doing? I lost the PDF for some reason. Got it. So first slide, international recovery. I would say to continue the international recovery, I should have edited that. The primary goal is to further establish Mammoth Lakes as California's premier alpine year-round destination, whether that's a summer road trip or a week, 10-day long winter destination ski experience.
46:55 I think sometimes we get undersold as a destination ski experience where someone can come here easily for week 10 days, enjoy Mammoth, enjoy June, enjoy the town of Mammoth Lakes and everything we have to offer. As John has alluded to a couple of times here, we will be looking to reopen our China office in 2024-25. We currently have seven offices under contract. We had eight in 2019.
47:24 We deemed with the advice of the MLT board to close the China office when the onset of the pandemic became apparent and the breadth of the pandemic became apparent. We knew China was probably going to be the last market to return, and that has proved to be correct. They are returning. They haven't hit 2019 numbers. There are issues with air.
47:47 The amount of air that's available from China into North America, specifically the amount of air that's available into California. And there are issues with visa, new visas being issued by the United States to Chinese national. The current wait time for a visa in China for someone who does not have one is probably somewhere between eight to 16 months. And that's just a matter of staffing. Frankly, it's also a matter of politics.
48:12 It's a little bit of a game being played between the two governments and the two countries as to who's going to blink first. But we do think the time is now to reopen that office. We'd rather strike early than be the last one to the party. Visit California, who is usually our lead in some of these bigger international markets. Never left China. They always kept the light on. And now they have ramped up their commitment, their budget.
48:39 And their efforts in China back to 2019 numbers. So with a market like China, to be honest, they have no idea where we are. They have no idea who Mammoth Lakes is. You know, if they can pick out, a lot of folks, if they can pick out California on a map, they're doing well. So we need to ride the coattails of the state of California. We need to ride the coattails of Visit California.
49:02 We think now is the time to re-engage that market and get back in there and get Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain in the wintertime back in the game. So the first strategy is international consumer education. Basically, this is us presenting Mammoth Lakes as, like I said, the premier alpine destination on...
49:27 Your California experience, whether that's the summer road trip, you guys have seen this with a lot of Europeans that come through here. We are a stop on their overall itinerary. They're coming from us after Death Valley. They're on their way to Yosemite. We used to be happy to have one night on this overall itinerary. Now we're getting greedy. We want multiple nights. We want them to use Mammoth Lakes as a hub to explore Yosemite as a day trip.
49:52 You explore Yosemite as a multiple-day trip, come back to Mammoth, enjoy our lodging at a discounted rate, enjoy our food and beverage, which is much more diverse than you're going to find in the park, and also experience everything that we love, the reason we live here. See Bodie, see Mono Lake, all the things in our backyard that we love. And again, we want to make Mammoth Lakes viewed as a premier ski destination, viable for easily a five to seven.
50:21 10-day stop. We also partner very strongly with North Lake Tahoe to promote what we call the California Ski Safari, where you come into California and you combine the two epic, I shouldn't say epic.
50:35 Iconic ski destinations of California, us and Palisades Tahoe. We're happy to split that length of stay with Palisades Tahoe. Having half of something is better than having zero of nothing. So happy to work with those guys up there and with the Altera Mountain Company. International B2B trainings. This is where the bulk of our effort goes into. We like to train the trainers. So this is to get our offices, our...
51:03 What will be eight offices when China comes online to get them totally up to speed to our talking points to the point where I don't have to be in market talking to people about what makes Mammoth Lakes and a California holiday so special.
51:17 Our staff and our offices can do it as well as I can, talk the talk, and we want to get those people here to experience Mammoth Lakes so that they have a sense of legitimacy when they're talking about Mammoth Lakes and explaining why any California holiday, whether it's summer, autumn, or winter, would be remiss without including Mammoth Lakes. Half of what I do is international media.
51:44 There is a true authentication of the story of Mammoth Lakes if it's being told by a third party. So people, when I'm talking about Mammoth Lakes, a lot of people are like, yeah, that guy's a homer. He's out here selling it. That's his job. If there's a third party telling the story about Mammoth Lakes and all the things that make us special, it adds that sense of legitimacy.
52:06 In a lot of markets where we don't have the budget to go consumer-wide, if they read an article in the newspaper or a magazine about Mammoth Lakes, that spurs interest to that consumer. They're going to go to their travel agent or they're going to go to their OTA and they're going to look us up and they're going to include us on their holiday. So that's the value of the media placement on the international side.
52:30 And then we continue to work with all of our international and local and domestic partners. We work really closely with Brand USA on a national scale. Obviously, everything we do is in partnership with Visit California. There is no place in the world you can go to when you say California that a negative emotion comes to that person's mind. We may not agree with California's politics. We may not agree with California how they do things.
52:56 But once you get out of the microcosm of California, it's still a place that evokes a very powerful emotional response to people when you say California, whether that's their perception of us from the movies, TV, whatever it may be. California still has that magic on an international scale. Clearly, it's important that we work with Altera Mountain Company, Mammoth Mountain Ski Resort, as well as Mono County Tourism.
53:24 Inyo County, and the City of Bishop. All very key partners with us, and we all like to promote that air service. It's a key part, and then I already talked about the China office reopening that. And then we like to put some programs in place so we can track our efforts. It's never going to be a completely precise snapshot of the spend we put in these markets.
53:49 But we are trying to get that a little bit more precise. As Sarah mentioned earlier, we are working pretty hard to get our Symphony dashboard up, which will track international visitation, length of stay, kind of creepy, Big Brother-ish, but it'll track the movement and the activities of people who are in our zip code, 93546. It does it by, obviously, the GPS component of your mobile phone.
54:14 So if you're using any apps or anything you do with your mobile phone, it'll track your location, and then that'll be relayed to us monthly through our Symphony dashboard. Easy to track all the media placements and the value of those media placements, and then track all the co-ops we do with our international partners, whether that's travel trade or media. And then with Sam's help, we'll track the international traffic that goes to the visitmammoth.com website.
54:44 Here's our proposed budget for 24-25. With the exception of reopening our China office, it's pretty much on par with 23-24. The big jump, which represents about 28 to 30 percent, is reopening that China office. That's to the tune of about $75,000. Otherwise, the big bulk of our international budget is going to be the seven existing international offices that we currently have under contract.
55:17 And that is it for International. I'm happy to take any questions from the MLT board, town council, or suite team. Michael, going back to this tracking and the symphony dashboard, I know that there was a lot of information promised through that agency, but is it really coming through? Do they really actually have the capability of doing that detailed tracking? The tongue-in-cheek answer is TBD. We're hoping.
55:46 I would say now that it's been a little bit of a process, to be honest with you, Eric. As John talked about earlier, there was a previous company that we had a contract with that promised the moon and delivered next to nothing in terms of the contract. So we've moved over to Symphony. They have come through. It's been a process. There's no question about it.
56:14 It's taken them a while to understand our needs and our demands. But we're closer to the end than the beginning. Got it. I hope that answers your question. I wish I had a better answer. Sarah, did you want to add anything on that?
56:27 I just wanted to chime in because, Eric, I think what you're referring to is the Zartico contract, which we actually opted not to move forward with. So that was like a full year process that I kind of came on to the tail end. And we already had Symphony slash Tourism Economics. This is the existing dashboard. So what we've been doing over the last six months is really working with them to refine not only our monthly reporting, but also to kind of fit.
56:51 Fixed some of the hitches that came up with specifically to geolocation tracking around our airport, specifically that Bishop airport. So I do think it's come a long way, but I think what you were referring to is Zartico, and these are technically different programs. Exactly. Thank you. Appreciate it. Yeah, of course. Any other questions? Thank you. Hello, my name is Lauren McLeod, Communications Coordinator. I'm just going to double check here on our...
57:30 Okay, so we do have local community outreach and engagement first, which John will go ahead and address. All right, so we've talked about this a little bit in the goals. You know, community engagement is definitely a new thing for us this year, and it's something we started with last year with the resident sentiment surveys, the focus groups, et cetera. We really need to expand that into the second homeowners, the business owners, make sure that we are providing what we have promised to them.
58:03 As I mentioned, Betsy Truax will be joining us July 1st. You know, developing that comprehensive communications plan with the community is going to be huge. We've talked about it for a few years, but we know that there are different ways that we can communicate with different segments of the community, and we need to get that finalized. We know that there are certain tools out there that we have at our resources that we can utilize.
58:27 That will reach the majority of the folks in town, but then there are also pockets that we need to reach out to in specific ways. We talked about finalizing the regional strategic plan with JLL and then really working with the town and all of our partners, stakeholders to work on a sustainable destination management plan, something that's really a three to five year program that helps us understand a roadmap of what needs to be done in the community to help us move forward.
58:54 Eliminate some of the flow issues, the touch points, the stress points. Again, Betsy's joining the team, help us determine those needs and action items. Resident sentiment survey, I think we'll, for now, we'll probably look at doing those every, maybe every two years to make sure that we get that feedback and then really, again, that methods of communications with the different groups.
59:17 Hopefully people are participating in things like community coffee. I think we need to revamp that a little bit. I think we've got a lot of folks that are taking advantage of the coffee portion and not necessarily the information portion. So I think we need to figure out how we can work on that a little bit more. Hopefully people are getting the tourism insights that Lauren sends out, our weekly five and five, and then we'll continue to do our annual report that will get mailed out each year as well, likely bringing back things like our open house as well. So again, the communications efforts.
59:47 Locally, a lot of those different pieces are local newspapers, the radio station, in-person events, you know, really holding those open houses. And again, as I mentioned, trying to get those one-on-one meetings throughout the community with our staff and our board members. And I guess now it's time for Lauren. Turn it over to Lauren for the earned channels.
1:00:12 All right. Excellent. Thank you so much, John. So yes, again, hello. Lauren McLeod, Communications Coordinator. And I will be managing and implementing the strategic plan specifically for our domestic public relations and communications. So first off, with our earned channels, which earned channels covers content that is published by a third party without payment. So we're looking at our traditional media here.
1:00:37 So over the last two fiscal years, we increased the number of media placements by 200%, and we're going to go ahead and continue to essentially maintain the growth that we have had. About 300 of those were snow-focused, which is not somewhere that we typically focus our efforts, and so that leaves about 300 other.
1:01:02 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:01:24 Impressions, like, exactly what that is. Could you just clarify that for me, please? Absolutely. So impressions is how many times an article is clicked on. So it could be one person clicking on an article many times, any time it is pulled up in a search engine. So it's essentially when an article is clicked on, online in particular. Not a problem. So in terms of our earned channels, the strategy for engaging these earned channels...
1:01:50 Pretty much mirrors our paid media efforts, so I won't go into too much depth here, but essentially for our spring and fall messaging, it's going to be very timely. Our go now messaging for fall colors was extremely successful, especially paired with beautiful imagery, constantly updated by our digital marketing manager, Sam. So we're going to continue with that strategy for spring as well. You know, always trying to support the non-peak travel times.
1:02:20 Same with winter. Not only are we marketing the typical winter sports that everyone comes for, but taking on yes and approach. Yes and you can go ice skating. Yes and you can have an elevated F&B experience. And for summer, especially since we are projected to have the Reds Meadow Road reconstruction project for a little while, we'll be focusing on redistributing visitors to kind of hidden gems.
1:02:47 The, you know, the less popular or less common destinations around us. May I ask you, is F&B food and beverage? Yes. Okay, thanks. Apologies, food and beverage experiences.
1:02:58 And, of course, stewardship will continue to underscore all of our efforts, especially using organic incorporations of our partnerships and the community endeavors, such as Camp Like a Pro, Tangle Free Waters, and Leave No Trace, so that we are not just attracting visitors, we're also educating them.
1:03:21 So for our traditional media, we will continue to prioritize those in-house experiences. The communications coordinator, that would be me, when possible, will be guiding those activities to offer a depth of experience so that anyone who does come to visit can foster a deeper connection with our environment and with the ethos of Mammoth Lakes.
1:03:42 We'll continue to connect traditional media with local constituents and any subject matter experts so that, again, they have that depth of experience and knowledge for anything that they publish. And we will continue to participate in hosted media events like the one pictured here. I traveled to Dallas with Visit California and other destination marketing organizations, specifically with the goal of
1:04:07 Promoting Mammoth Lakes as an alternative out-of-state outdoor destination and especially an essential stop on a California road trip. Oh, I'm sorry. Oh, that's so weird because it exited out on your computer. Thank you. All right. Excellent. Thanks, John.
1:04:40 So one of our biggest changes to the overall strategy for communications will be increasing and expanding our content creator program. So moving some funds from our earned channels to support the continuing growth of the content creator program. And in this aspect, we will be treating these influencers and creators in a way that is very similar to our traditional media visits, curating itineraries and pretty much...
1:05:08 Having more influence on the type of messaging we will receive so that once again we can continue to incorporate the responsible tourism messaging for anyone who is coming to visit and create content.
1:05:21 We will also, as was mentioned in marketing, be focusing on the promotion of events in real time and leaning on these influencers in order to do so. We will continue to collaborate with Visit California and other destination marketing organizations to not only bring in influencers that are visiting Mammoth Lakes, but who are visiting other areas of California as well so that we can create more extensive itineraries and have a larger reach.
1:05:49 We will also be looking for additional opportunities for more in-person activations and collaborating with local organizations and businesses to really get out in the community and to really, you know, make it available. So we're going to focus on limited, high-quality and strategically vetted partnerships, especially in collaboration with our PR agency for the four planned partnerships per year that Sam mentioned through digital marketing.
1:06:19 And finally, we are revitalizing our strategy for the endurance crib. So not only will we be having the endurance crib promote Mammoth Lakes as a premier high-altitude training destination, but also as a resource for visiting athletes through many different strategies listed here as well. And we will also be inviting those athlete influencers in. These are very high-caliber athletes who also have a strong online presence.
1:06:47 To events such as OCR, Trail Fest, Mammoth Tough to continue to promote those as well through this channel. We will also be expanding the sponsorship of the Mammoth Track Club so that they can continue to support the implementation of this new strategy and as we prepare for the 2028 LA Olympics. And finally, we have the budget for the communications program for the next fiscal year, which
1:07:16 Very closely mirrors last year's budget as well. The main shift would be shifting funds from our traditional media visits into the influencer space. Any additional questions? All right, thank you so much. All right, I'm going to bring us home here pretty quick. Just talk about special events. Sorry, I have my hand up, but I don't know if you guys can see it. It's Chris, sorry. I did have...
1:07:54 Not really a question, but a clarification that I think is important because I think it was Councilmember Bryce who asked about impressions and I think the response was about how many times people click on something and I think it's just really important that we clarify that because when you're talking about billions of impressions, we're not getting billions of clicks. So impression is just that content is served to you and whether you take action or not. So I just want to make sure since this is
1:08:24 You know, a public meeting, and it's on the record that nobody thinks we let that slip by and didn't clarify. Sorry, this is Sarah. I'm chiming in as well. Chris, you're correct. It's actually how many times it is viewed, not even reached, but just served, like Chris was saying. We all good? Moving on to special events. I think one of the biggest things here is that we have put together an ad hoc committee of our board to review the current...
1:09:01 Thank you.
1:09:31 Issue out $350,000. For those who have been involved here about five years ago, we were at about $150,000. And so we were at $150,000 for a number of years. We brought that up to $225,000, brought that up to $300,000 the last couple of years, and we're looking to bring that to $350,000 moving forward. Specifically, I think that we want to look at a lot of the need time events. Again, those events that happened before Fourth of July and after Labor Day that can help us fill rooms when we're otherwise at lower occupancy.
1:10:01 Continued support of the 2024 OCR Championships this year for October. And, you know, one of the things that we're talking with them about is the potential of shifting that event for October of 2025 to a more recognizable event that might be able to get us to the numbers that I think we originally were thinking for last year. But that's in process. 2024 is still the OCR World Championships.
1:10:25 The budget for special events is $50,000. It's really similar to where we were last year. That's mainly our brochures, our posters, our different events, marketing that we do out there. Quick question, John. Yep. The $350,000 grants for special events, does that include grants for the OCR or is that fall under something else? No. That's all right. Okay, thanks. On the general administrative side, we talked about this a little bit, we have actually moved all of the wages and benefits into TBIT.
1:10:57 That was one of the things over the last couple of years, if you remember, some of you might, three years ago, we were asked by the council to move 50-50. Last year we moved to 25-75. This year we actually moved 100% of that and the overhead into the TBID funds. So the measure A funds are all, for all intents and purposes, are active marketing dollars. It also includes that 350 for the event funding.
1:11:23 Staff wages, we've gone through with a compensation study and compared to other destinations in the state and made sure that our positions are properly compensated. We have two brand new positions this year. We brought back a community content marketing manager position that we haven't had for a number of years. We've added Sarah Walsh as our...
1:11:47 Marketing Coordinator, and then bringing in Betsy into the position of Community Engagement Director, she'll be replacing Laura Kaler, so that's not a new position, but those other two positions have been filled. General Administrative, which is all of our wages, our benefits, and our overhead.
1:12:05 Is basically flat to last year. It's actually down a little bit. The one caveat I'll put in there is that we do have two employees in the fiscal year that will be out on maternity. So we have about six months for both of those employees that will be paid through FMLA, et cetera. And with that, I think we can wrap up. And if there are any general questions. I have a question for you. The 100% of wages and benefits being covered by TBID, is that in the town's best interest?
1:12:35 I believe, speaking with Mr. Holler before he left, you know, he talked about how the town should pay for a portion of that because TBID is limited on what it can be spent on. So is that, like, have you gotten legal counsel advice on that or what's changed? I thought it was a port, like, that it would be apportioned.
1:13:01 So I spoke with our legal counsel, our Civitas legal counsel on the TBID, and they felt that we were in the right to be able to do that. Because there are actually DMOs in the state of California that don't have any other funding. And so they are 100% funded through the TBID. So I did run that through them. Thank you. I think one of the areas of concern around that has been
1:13:27 You know, trying to bifurcate a little bit of activity. But when you look at TBID, and I think what you talked about expanding that understanding, as long as it benefits all of the businesses that are paying in, and I think when you talk about marketing and that level of activity benefiting the businesses in town, then that's where that sort of decision was made to come down to it. Chris, your hand is up. Yes, thank you. Thanks, John and team. Very thorough.
1:14:00 John, I'm just a little curious about the compensation study. Can you share a little bit about what the findings and what you learned and how you adjusted as a result? Yeah, so we've participated, this is the second time that we've done it. Back in 2022, we participated in a compensation study with very similar destinations. So Monterey, Huntington Beach, Santa Barbara, San Luis Obispo.
1:14:24 Newport Beach. So it's all comparable destinations. And basically what we do is we provide them with our current positions and the salaries and benefits associated. And this third-party company will compile them all, aggregate them. So obviously we don't see what exactly is being paid at other places. And then they'll give us a breakdown of where we are with our budget and our competitive set. So the total set was 12 destinations.
1:14:52 But obviously, we aren't going to fall in with San Diego, Los Angeles, and San Francisco. So they pulled those out. And so we were in a competitive set, which was roughly $10 million budgets. The staff sizes in those other destinations are quite bigger. I think the average was 17 people. But what it does is it identifies as a local marketing manager. This is how many people have the position. This is the high. This is the low. This is the median.
1:15:22 Again, each column is randomized and aggregated, so we don't know who's out there, but we can at least look at it and say, okay, this is how this group operates. This is what this position is paid for across the board. This is the high end, low end, and the median. And so there were slight adjustments within our budget. There was nothing that was drastic or out of line. It was more a few thousand bucks here and there that really kept us in line.
1:15:49 And I think that what was interesting is from 2022 to 2024, I think it all kind of moved in the same direction at the same time. So there wasn't anything that was completely out of whack. Thanks so much. And I think that's always a best practice to just look around and see what's happening with like organizations. So thanks. Yeah, you're welcome. And I think one of the things that I brought up at our board meeting, and it wasn't something that I was able to contemplate when I was doing this budget.
1:16:18 But we also did a comp study with Destinations International, which is a massive international organization for DMOs like ours. And it was interesting. I just got the results, I think, on Monday. And they were, even though there were 283 people in our category, they were really comparable to what the California study gave us for information. So it was reaffirmed that we were headed in the right direction.
1:16:48 Mr. Mayor, whenever you're ready. John. Yeah. Go ahead. Yeah. Okay. I attended the meeting as our representative of the MLT board this afternoon. Very interesting meeting. Again, really impressed with the caliber of the team that MLT has assembled that works. I think one thing we all have to keep in mind, they are, I think, John, as you said, they're looking at the outside world. They're
1:17:17 Looking out there. So I think when it comes time to start doing this kind of community engagement process, just encourage all of us to take the time, find the right tone. You guys, this group is incredibly technologically literate. I would not assume that the community is technologically literate. I think it's going to be really important to find the right...
1:17:36 I would certainly, the Power by Tourism Dollars campaign, I think certainly housing, I would really recommend that housing be a top tier item in there because that's certainly the council, I think we've all come together around that, that's a really important piece. And just a couple sort of high level sort of maybe observations. I think we all need to be careful in the season that we're in that we don't go maybe rushing into things. The China.
1:18:06 One of the candidates for president is proposing just insane, insane tariff program. If something like that were to go in place, I would just want to make sure that before we start heading into that market, that we're kind of, you know, keeping an eye out of what may be down that road.
1:18:26 These are things to think about. And I think a similar thing goes with technology and AI. I mean, I think every single member of the staff of this team is technologically astute and deep in that universe. AI is a thing. This country was never able to regulate social media at all. There's been no legislation about that entire space. Now we've got this AI thing coming online.
1:18:53 And I think it's going to be important for Mammoth Lake Tourism, you guys are right on the front lines of this, but certainly for the town, the community to be thinking about that. I think these questions about, you know, if we do get into mass catastrophic events and we're relying on federal agencies that are giving us, you know, do we want to be overwhelmed by a bunch of stuff coming out of a bot? I mean...
1:19:14 You all know this, and you're all smart about it, but I think these are the things we've got to be thinking about. Yeah, we're not replacing humans by any means. Well, but there are, I appreciate that, but there are industries across the planet that are actively replacing humans, and certainly in the information space. So I think it's just something that we all need to be...
1:19:31 Yeah, and we're cognizant of the fact that AI is not 100% at this point. And we have different companies out there. There's a company called GuideGeek, which we've talked to about being an itinerary planning piece that scrapes your site, scrapes the web. And, you know, I think we have opportunities to audit those things. And so it is with a lot of caution that we go into it. Yeah, there's a lot of things coming our way. We've got to be just kind of be not find ourselves in the shallow end of a deep pool.
1:20:02 Hey, John. Yeah. If I can just add. Sure. So does anybody here use Apple CarPlay at all? Have you seen it? Yes. Well, so if you're doing directions and your map is up from your car, AI takes on a lot of different forms. So one of the things in CarPlay allows that system to look at your itinerary.
1:20:31 And so if you have a meeting at 3 o'clock at Suite Z and 4 o'clock at High Country Lumber and 5.30 in Bishop, the next thing that will pop up on your screen is 17 minutes to Suite Z, 34 minutes to whatever, and all you get are punched, yes. I think that's the positive side of it. I think often we're presented with AI from the negative stand, the predatory stance or the fact that you can...
1:20:58 Cobble together, you know, a picture of Brad Pitt in the Devil's Creek Distillery Tasting Room. And so I think you're right, but I think edging into that as opposed to being drug into it, the best way to predict the future is to invent it, right? And so I think to the degree that we can, I think that that's what I see the team doing. Yeah, yeah, exactly. You know, stepping into it so that we're not left behind. Yeah, no, no, absolutely. We have to do that. We just got to be cautious, mindful, be smart.
1:21:29 So we're running a little over on time here, but I would take this opportunity to ask any of the tourism board or any of the council members that have specific questions of their counterparts to enter into that discussion. If you want to know, you know, what Pat is doing or why John looks like that, this is a good time to... That's the only easy way I can make that joke. But this would be a good time for that communication.
1:21:59 Off time in these meetings, we spend too much time focusing on the product and not enough time doing the interactions that we should have. And you've heard me say often that the council is always open, especially to its commissions. So I would like to see more of that take place. So if any of you have any questions for any of us or vice versa at this point, Chris's hands up. Go ahead, Chris.
1:22:29 Thank you. So this is a question more for Rob, because Rob, I'm trying to, I sent you an email last night, at least I hope I did. And so it was just a question around how we determine what proportion of measure A funds work, because I, you know, tonight we're doing this and then we do the budget at the end of the meeting. And I'm trying to remember, because when I see the measure A funds in the line item,
1:22:58 For Mammoth Lakes Tourism Budget, it went up more than I believe the proportion that we believe Measure A funds are going up in our general fund predict or, you know, sort of, not predictions, but, you know, assumptions. So did I send that email? And if so, could you just elaborate on that a little bit so that my fellow council colleagues are clear that we're staying aligned with what we planned?
1:23:27 Last year when we decided. Yeah, thank you, Chris. And I believe you might find that in your outbox. Sorry. So there's some contradictory terms sometimes used interchangeably, which is allocations to tourism and payments to our contract for Mammoth Lakes Tourism.
1:23:48 So the allocations to tourism are tied to standard allocations that have been created across time. They were massaged, I believe, in 17-18 timeframe that set a percentage of the TOT that goes to each of those buckets, tourism, transit, and housing. That remains unchanged. So when we increase TOT dollars, the allocation changes based upon the dollar amount. But there's no adjustment to that.
1:24:15 Those monies set aside are not going to Mammoth Lakes Tourism directly as they were in the past. We have a specific contract which calls for $1,725,000. That's a three-year contract that was started last year, and that remains in the budget going forward. So no change in the payments to MLT, but the slight change in allocation to tourism. And I just wanted to make note that
1:24:42 In the budget cycle, in the budget process, based on council direction, we have taken any unallocated, meaning funds that we put into tourism from the budget but didn't spend specifically on tourism activity to go directly to housing, right? So while those numbers seem a little bit out of whack from an original allocation standpoint, what actually goes to housing from the initial budget is on par with what goes into
1:25:10 And then from there we go beyond that with our quarterly presentations providing even more money to likely at most cases housing and some cases capital projects for the community. Thank you so much. Anything else from anyone around the table? We're all here. Yes, thank you. Anything from our audience out there? Bill, I just wanted to take a minute.
1:25:37 One of the things that we've been complimented on as an organization, John did it today in our meeting, was the ability to be nimble and to pivot. And it's been a while since we've been together here. And humbly, we learned a lot as an organization last year going through the TBID process. And you, the council, really highlighted a disconnect that we had had with the community.
1:26:05 And I just want to know, I just want you to know that we heard you. And I hope that you can see through the presentation today how much focus has been put on local outreach, community engagement, much more straightforward stewardship messaging, partnering with the town on infrastructure improvements. So I am glad that we're here today. I think that we need to continue to do this. We should try to continue to do quarterly like we've talked about in the past.
1:26:35 But as an organization, we're really looking forward to partnering with the town and accomplishing our mutual goals. So I think it was a little bit rough last year, but I think it was good. I think it was good for all of us. It was eye-opening. So that's all I had. Thanks, Pat. I give MLT kudos all the time for its ability to segue from an original plan to what is needed in time.
1:27:04 And it has always been very good at that and very supportive of the community, while the community hasn't often understood it, part of what we were talking about all here last year. But go through COVID, even go before COVID, to the smoke, every time there's been a need to pivot. MLT has made that pivot. So I give all the credit in the world to the organization for being able to do that. That being said, I... Yes, Rob?
1:27:31 Yeah, I'd like to just kind of add on some comments with regard to MLT. So, you know, MLT is the town's marketing arm, right? That was established well before I was here at any capacity with the town. But I want to recognize the fact that I really appreciate the ability to pick up the phone and have direct conversations about concerns I have. I can't tell you how many hours a day my life involves discussing
1:28:01 Either how we're going to deliver the core services to the town or capital projects or anything that comes up, that is all driven by our financial strength, which comes from tourism. So when I look at the sort of outside of Mammoth Lakes world, I get quite a bit concerned about what the future may hold. We've been very, very strong for the last few years.
1:28:27 We kind of went through COVID very differently than many other destinations did, partly because of where we are and we're in fresh air in the mountains and such. But I will say that there's more turmoil on the horizon. There's more things out there in front of us. Marketing dollars become more and more important all the time. They fund everything we do. So I appreciate that. I appreciate having the ability to pick up the phone and say,
1:28:56 Hey, I've got concerns. I've got concerns about what's coming up. I've got concerns about rising costs in our air subsidy. What are we going to do about that? We can dialogue all the time. And I think that's very, very critical for our overall success. And so I just want to appreciate that. The board never hears from me, but John hears from me every day. So I appreciate that folks having that here. And I really want the community to understand that, right? We're worrying about these things all the time.
1:29:24 And I think collectively. So it's important to us and appreciate having a great partnership. Chris? Yeah, I just also wanted to celebrate the great hire of Betsy Truax to MLT because I think helping the community understand why we need to market ourselves. And, you know, I mean, look, the proof's in the pudding, right? When we market,
1:29:56 Our TOT goes up and that raises all boats in town. And so I think, you know, just want to just celebrate, stop to take a moment to be thrilled that one of our own who really understands our community, really understands our needs, you know, served honorably on our, I guess it's.
1:30:18 Recreation Commission, I'm saying the wrong name, for 10 years, you know, is going to help people understand. And then the other thing is I love the idea of the Funded by Tourism campaign because everything in Mammoth is funded by tourism, let's be honest. And so I think just helping people see the real world implications will be beneficial. So well done, MLT team.
1:30:46 With that, we will take a break until the room is cleared and we're all in our appropriate seats. Now it's okay. Moving on to reports from commissions and our departments. 6.1, Public Works Engineering CIP update. Amy. Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and Councilmembers. Amy Callanan.
1:40:11 Engineering Manager for the Public Works Department. I just wanted to take about five minutes of your time here to supplement the written update that you have in your pocket that describes
1:40:24 The recent progress on our various construction projects and just give you a few photos and a few tidbits of what we have going on on the ground out there. So there are quite a few projects in your packet, but I'm just going to touch on the four that are really active at this moment, and that is the dog park, the fuel island, the child care center, and the main street landscaping project. So we'll start with the dog park.
1:40:53 The dog park is located at 100 College Parkway, also known as the Mammoth Lakes Foundation site. It is a one-acre fenced dog park that includes 5,000 square feet of artificial dog turf, as well as a public restroom and 40 parking spaces. What you see here is a picture of what the site looked like last year before work started.
1:41:17 And then last fall, the contractor began work clearing and grabbing the site, doing a lot of earthwork, and as you can see, they encountered a lot of rocks. They also did some utility work, including digging the stormwater retention basin that will retain the stormwater runoff from the parking lot. That's what we see here. And then when winter hit, they went on winter suspension, but now they are back, and they're making progress on
1:41:46 Particularly on the parking and the turf area, doing some fine grading, preparing to pave in the next two weeks. So we see the driveway, some larger equipment, flattening out the site, and installing the base prior to paving. And here we go. So we hope that this project will be complete sometime, hopefully before the end of July.
1:42:13 Moving on quickly to the Fuel Island. The Fuel Island is located at our town yard on Commerce Drive.
1:42:20 The fuel at this fuel island services vehicles, not just the town of Mammoth Lakes and the police department, but also the Mammoth School District, all of Mono County, including the sheriff's department and Mono County Search and Rescue, the fire department, and ESTA, and I may have missed something there, but you can see it services a lot of vehicles connected to the town. The scope of this project was
1:42:46 Part one was to clean and line the underground tanks, and that was completed last fall. And the second part of the project was to remove and replace the concrete slab that you see here. You may remember that this work was completed last fall. However, the concrete didn't meet the material specifications that were part of the contract. So the contractor is back and is removing the concrete and replacing it again.
1:43:11 You see pictures. They started work last week, so the fuel island is currently closed. Installing rebar into this lab, and just today, pouring concrete. So by the end of today, this concrete will be complete again. It will continue to be closed into Tuesday, Wednesday, middle of next week, and then should be open at least to light traffic and later on to heavy vehicle traffic.
1:43:45 Our child care center. Another project we have at 108 College Parkway, again, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation site. The scope of this project involves relocating six of Mammoth High School's portable or modular units that are currently part of the spa building. And this is the existing set of buildings that you see.
1:44:10 Those buildings will be relocated on new foundations to create just a core and shell only for a future child care center. It involves reconnecting the modular units, reconnecting utilities, electrical, plumbing, whatnot, that are existing in the units, but does not include new walls, new plumbing fixtures, new finishes at this time. That scope will likely come as a second phase to the project.
1:44:40 So a month or two ago, this is what the site looked like. This is next to the parking lot for the Edison Theater. And here we are just about two, three weeks ago. The contractor mobilized and is clearing brush, doing some earthwork, and once again, removing and breaking rocks. So we expect this project to take perhaps about three months.
1:45:13 And last but not least for today, I wanted to give you an update on the Main Street landscaping project. This one has been on our docket for a couple of years now. We put the project out to bid, I believe, two years ago and didn't receive any bids. And so we've been attempting to negotiate with local contractors to do the work, and it has taken until now to secure a contractor to do the work. We found...
1:45:39 Gray's Grasshopper Landscaping, and they started work at, I believe, the beginning of May. And just in general, the scope of this project involves cleaning up existing landscape islands along both sides of Main Street, installing new cobble and boulders, and repairing and replacing existing irrigation and installing new irrigation where necessary, and then, of course, planting shrubs.
1:46:08 So you may be familiar with the lower part of Main Street by Footloose prior to work starting in May. And more recently, you may have seen contractors doing work removing unsuitable material and debris on the road, removing dirt in preparation to
1:46:40 to bring in good topsoil and compost. They're moving some rocks and boulders around, troubleshooting the existing irrigation, replacing parts as necessary, and once again, playing with rocks.
1:47:01 So that's just four of our many, many projects upcoming. As things progress, we'll continue to provide information to you about 60 Joaquin, the Rhodes Slurry Seal Project, the Rhodes and Mupp Rehab Project, and all the other various projects that we have on our current work plan.
1:47:23 I just want to touch really quickly, this was included in your packet as well, the ad that we placed in the sheet to help notify residents of the summer road maintenance that is going to start as early as next week. This also includes a QR code and a website that we will work to keep updated on the progress of both construction projects. In addition, the contractors will be providing individual notice to
1:47:51 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:48:24 We've all had a lot of calls from a lot of people. Obviously, you're aware of that. I don't want to merge you with that. I just want to make sure that the public knows we're aware of it. The fuel island, as we start to bring electric heavy equipment or electric vehicles online, is the yard ready for that in terms of the traffic flow? Obviously, it's going to be a fuel island for a while. Could you talk about that a little bit?
1:48:50 I can talk a little bit about it and maybe Hayes can fill in a little bit if I don't get all the answers for you. I would say no, we're not inherently ready for it, but we had at one point discussed the fuel needs of the department, whether that needed to be increased, decreased with respect to whether that project involved replacing the existing tanks, rehabilitating the existing tanks. Ultimately,
1:49:19 We do know that much of our fleet that consists of large heavy equipment inherently will continue to be diesel. Just it's not possible at this time nor likely in the future that electric can provide the power necessary for that type of equipment. However, we're of course planning, doing some long range planning to accommodate and be ready for
1:49:48 Some sort of transition to electric. Yeah, so it's whatever you can along the way. She nailed it. Yeah, okay, good. Just wanted to check on that. Yeah, I think the issue with electric is going to be more connectivity to the systems and infrastructure to support that kind of charging power. That would be necessary more than movement. Yeah, and that's the kind of question. Where is that power in terms of what you guys are going to need? Where is that power? Not there yet. Is that a whole big question? Down the street at Ormond.
1:50:19 Yeah, there's a number of studies. I think ESTA's got the, is first to put one together to kind of look at what infrastructure will be necessary to support electrification of the fleet. Like Amy said, we made a decision not to go with the full fuel island. We had a large-scale project and we decided that's not the right.
1:50:40 Way to go. That's not the future. I think we'll put some work into what we have right now and work to prepare ourselves for what's coming, like just in line with the conversation about CARB and our transition of our fleet. This is a piece of it, something we're going to be working on. And, you know, like Rob said, where that power comes from, that's probably what's key. It's getting that circuitry into the town yard. And that's something that ESTA was working on for their fleet as well, just across the street.
1:51:09 The final question is, in terms of partial update, Rob, is that getting any, I don't know, put anything on the spot? You know, I didn't want to dwell on it today, as we will have a more formal parcel update for you at the next meeting on the 7th, 19th, I think.
1:51:29 It's still on the radar, very much on the radar. Work is progressing right now on site around the buildings. Work is occurring at the park in anticipation of a combined ribbon cutting and groundbreaking ceremony for phase two. Yeah, that's the only thing I was going to mention is first meeting of August.
1:51:52 Is when we're going to have a pretty nice community event out there, probably at lunchtime and have, you know, provide some food for folks to come by and get some barbecue and talk about, look at the facilities themselves. Hopefully we'll be able to actually tour a fully furnished apartment that's there already.
1:52:09 As well as just looking at the different structures around the outside of the buildings and talking about phase two. So it's a little bit of a different kind of a ribbon cutting, if you will, but it's more of a community event and we're going to welcome everybody there. So keep an eye out for that when it comes up in the future. And so, I mean, I just want to make one point, you know, you were talking about the child care facilities and showing the buildings as they exist today on site at the high school.
1:52:35 We do have plans, I believe, and correct me if I'm wrong, to do updates to the exterior of that, right? Roofing, siding, painting. We are replacing the siding. It will get new paint. We are replacing the roof. It's not going to look like that. If you would like to copy that color, we can do that. No, no. Yeah. We're talking a lot about the interior work, which is absolutely true, right? We're not building them out. We're building the shell and at least...
1:53:01 At the moment, right? There's a lot of things going on in the space of child care, things that the town is sort of, you know, helping with our partners and trying to figure out what a good solution is. So that may be a future request of the town, but for this one, it's not. But I just want to make sure they're going to look different than that picture. Yes. Yes, they will. Chris. Oh, just a point of question. Councilmember Warren, do you have your...
1:53:31 Is that better? Much, thanks. I'm sorry, my fault, my fault. No, no, no, all good. Say that, Chris. Okay. Amanda? I'm good. All right, Amy, thank you. Thank you very much. Moving on to item 6.2, June 24, Office of Outdoor Recreation update. This is a written update unless you have questions on it. We good? Chris, we're all good?
1:54:08 Good for the moment. Moving on then to 6.3. Did you know CRC summer operations? Stu. I believe that one is written unless you have questions as well. I know I had Stu down there, but if there were questions to address, they could be asked of Stu. Okay. He's got a presentation just slightly later for the unscripted portion of department's updates. We'll talk a lot about the CRC operations for the summer.
1:54:39 Do you want to take it now? No, my only question, Stu, is are we hitting what we thought or expected in terms of numbers of people? Dive into it. I can dive into it for you. I'll be very brief. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. Let me put my glasses on so I can see what I'm doing. All right. Thank you for this opportunity. If I can see it there. There we go. So we've been doing this monthly.
1:55:14 with LA Kings Ice, with our commission, and I know we've been in front of you before, so this is kind of our first one for the Mammoth Rec Zone. So again, just be as brief as I can, if I can actually get this thing to work or not. So we opened on May 18, if you're able to swing by over that kind of town cleanup day weekend, it was really fun, great to see a lot of people come out and certainly clean up our town.
1:55:42 Thanks to Office of Outdoor, Amanda Disposal, and all those partners for helping. But we were able to get this facility open in time for that weekend, which is wonderful. The crew was here for about seven days before installing this sport court material. So this was something that we looked at about two or three years ago, and it's part of the Prop 68 per capita funding program that I think council approved probably well over two years ago, so finally good to see it.
1:56:10 And you can see it all striped up. If you've been there, it looks great. You know, really well received. We're really kind of interested to get the community's response on a lot of our programs. Just a quick update on kind of where we're at. We opened on May 18. So these numbers are actually from that period of time. But because people actually bought passes when we opened the pool a little bit earlier, those season play memberships are reflected here as well.
1:56:39 Because that summer play membership is both for the pool and the rec zone. But this is kind of where we're at. So you can see again, you know, that number for our local kids in our community. Thank you again for kind of pushing that program. So for $3, you know, 203 kids are coming in. Every time that kid comes in, they run out, run in the playground and then they run back to the rec zone. So we're really trying to talk to the parents about, you know, it's going to be easier if you just buy that membership pass.
1:57:08 So, you know, that's exactly what we wanted to try and do, right? Just try and make it easy for all these kids, come and going anytime they like, you know, when we're open. So, pretty good numbers there, 18 operating days, it's about 25 people a day. Again, it's pretty quiet in town, so a lot of our locals are coming in and looking forward to seeing how this is received during our normal kind of summer period of time. This is our big push for summer, clearly, right? It's our summer play membership.
1:57:35 We have to call it a membership because in our system a pass is kind of a five-punch pass. This is actually a membership that you buy, that you come in, give us your name, and hopefully in the future we can just come and scan a pass off your phone and so forth, right? So really kind of direct the ice, direct the court, that type of play. Again, you know, anywhere from $45 to our local kids, up to $315 for a family of four. So that's our big push. And that's all pool and all rec zone all the time.
1:58:04 This is kind of our schedule that we're kind of promoting right now. So you can see here we open at noon, close at about 5.30 and then we kind of get into leagues. And then we kind of set up the courts for basketball, volleyball and futsal. We can kind of interchange futsal for pickleball, volleyball for pickleball, but to move around the basketball hoops does take a little bit of work to do. So that's kind of how we're set up. And then as we work through the summer, we'll see how the response is.
1:58:31 It's just new for us, right? We haven't really run something this big before. Leagues, we talked about this a little bit, but we have kind of arena soccer leagues. We have a great town team. We're looking at at least getting kind of four teams going. So we've got kind of a co-ed league, a 40-year-old plus league, which is for us. Co-ed league, volleyball, you know, really good volleyball community. So excited about that. 3v3 basketball and our softball leagues.
1:59:00 Over at Shady Rest Park. We're not going to play softball in the Mammoth Rec Zone. So that's it for the Rec Zone. And I just thought I'd give you a brief update on kind of where we're at with the park. Again, just an immense amount of work that went into the last, you know, essentially three to four months to get the playground open. Just great to see again that many smiling, happy people at the playground, right? So what a beautiful playground we built in 2017 and just wonderful to get it reopened after three years of closure.
1:59:29 That is really the big draw for Mammoth Creek Park, so super excited. This is a site plan that we're working with Hayes and his team on. Right now, Council approved that big boulder area, that prefabricated boulder. I'll kind of show you an image of that later. But this just gives you a general layout of what's going to be in the park hopefully come Labor Day weekend. I can show some stuff. Okay, sorry, that.
1:59:59 There we go. There's basically, you can't really see that either, but that's okay. So the top right-hand corner, that big black blob will be that prefabricated climbing wall boulder area. To the left of that is kind of that natural rock area. In the middle is kind of that engineered wood fiber to make it really safe for our kids in our community. And again, that prefabricated boulder is, I think it's like 10 feet high, so it's not particularly high.
2:00:26 For kids to climb up and around. So again, we're going to put that safety surface in just for precautionary safety measures. Big natural turf area. So this will be kind of our lawn. And you've seen a lot of comments. I think when we posted, if you were following the town's Facebook page, when we reopened the playground, if you're following along on Facebook, tremendous amount of response to that park and reopening. And everyone's asking all these questions. Well, you know, it's such a shame you've destroyed the park. There's no grass.
2:00:55 Well, here we go. So we're really, really excited about kind of bringing the park back to life for our community because a lot of people, you know, really have a lot of connections and affinity to Mammoth Creek Park. So again, we'll have that natural turf area, which is what the team will put together. We have a pavilion that I'll show you a little photo of. Playgrounds rebuilding is open. We have kind of that little cornhole area on the left next to the deck.
2:01:23 And that'll be kind of a nice synthetic turf area. And we have a couple of bike racks. We have a bike rack coming, should be here tomorrow. We'll start with one and see how much demand there is. So. Can I ask you a quick question? Please do. My kids' favorite rocks. Are they going to be moved? Are they going to be just staying there? Are they the big ones on the left? Both of them.
2:01:43 There's the rocks closest to the street. They'll all stay there. The big one. And then the one right on the path. There's the little ones. There's the two that the kids like to jump back and forth from. You can kind of see, you know, that one. That one will stay. And then if you've been up there, you've obviously there. There's a lot of these little ones around here. We're just going to push these back to kind of create this kind of natural bouldering wall that you can sit on. So in the shade. It's a nice shaded area. So if you have...
2:02:10 Your kids in the community playing on this new climbing wall, you'll be able to kind of sit on this natural seating wall with those boulders. So, yeah, absolutely. And then the two boulders that are closest to the walking path, those will stay there as well. Okay, thank you. It's almost like...
2:02:24 Don't touch the boulders. Don't touch the good ones. The kids love it. Step away from the boulders. This is kind of just a photo. It might have been in that last presentation if you had a chance to see it. But this is kind of how it's going to look, right? We've got that concrete curb. We've got the engineered wood fiber. And you can see kind of this is a wombat version. Ours is considerably larger. But this is kind of how it goes. You can put all the little climbing, you know, handholds on this wall as well.
2:02:50 May I ask what's on the top of it? Like, can kids climb up to the top of it? They can. It's like a little kind of recessed kind of area up there, but it's not something that, you know, they can really do up there. Because that's exactly what they'll do. Like, all the kids will climb up and just hang out there and hopefully climb back down. And then there'll be kind of a shallower kind of wall that they can kind of get down from once they're up there. Okay. So they don't have to kind of be an ice climber to kind of get back down again.
2:03:19 Thank you. It's really used, as you know, to kind of go around, yeah, not so much up and over, but the kids, as you know, will go in and out and up and down. Thank you. You're very welcome. And just to kind of show you kind of how we're kind of where I kind of thought process was for this pavilion. This is kind of a nice kind of curved laminated beam kind of pavilion area.
2:03:47 It's got to do double duty, right? So it will kind of serve as kind of a picnic area that we can put picnic tables under there. It's also kind of an amphitheater space. It can be used for those type of things too. And then we're kind of looking, which is like why we like this example. It's got that kind of back wall which sits at the back of Mammoth Creek Park that'll protect it from wind and snow and those type of things. And it's got one pitch that just kind of works on the back of the building. I see you have questions. No?
2:04:18 Good. Okay. That's really all I had. Anything for Stu? Thank you for the opportunity, and I can certainly come back in July with another update on how we're doing. So, yeah, it's really exciting. Thank you. I just like to thank you so much for opening up the park. Yeah, thank you for the team. My family, we went there, and we had a wonderful time, and it was packed, and it was so good to see everybody there again. It certainly is, yeah. Thank you. Moving on then to item 7.1, Civic Center Financing Update, Rob. Bill, I just want to make sure there were no other updates.
2:04:50 Oh, that's right. I do have one myself. I'd like to just talk about the ballot initiative that's going to be coming. Before we go there, I should have asked the audience already any public comments on those updates that have been given. Seeing none. Back to Rob M. R. Hayes. Yeah, so just in my department head update, I wanted to talk a little bit about the ballot initiative. You know, we've contracted with a team
2:05:20 A company called Team Civics, and they are focused on assisting us in writing up narratives with regard to the ballot measure. My plan is to have, they're working on that as we speak right now, and again, that's sort of the informational piece and the official statement that the town will make in introducing that bill.
2:05:43 There's another stream that will be standing up of folks outside of town employees that will be advocating and supporting the initiative. But the work that we'll do on the narrative will be before Council as a draft at our next meeting on the 19th of June. And I'm hoping to have a really good sit-down discussion to fine-tune that with Council in the first meeting of July.
2:06:10 And then we would hope to adopt the final language in the second meeting of July, which is in time for the ballot to be put together. So that's sort of an outline of the official work the town will do on the narratives. And then there'll be other work that's going on outside of town activity with regard to support. So just a quick update on we're still working on that. It's still incredibly important to us. As we talked earlier with Mammoth Lakes Tourism about the success of our
2:06:38 Our marketing and bringing in monies for one-time monies to be allocated to housing. We are just looking to set up a system by which we have more permanence to housing funding, but that's not in lieu of the town actually contributing on a regular basis to housing. So folks, I get questions about that from time to time, and I just want to assure everyone that we will continue to make recommendations for
2:07:05 One-time investment in housing as well as capital projects and others. But that funding source will support us up into the future when one-time monies may not be available, right? We've enjoyed that greatly. We've done a good job of spending that on the appropriate items. But this ballot initiative is incredibly important to ensure we have those monies going into the future. So we're working very hard on making sure that it comes to fruition. Thank you. Thank you, Rob. Questions? Yeah, just to just
2:07:35 To bring to Andy, good to see you. There are council members, myself being one of them, who are out speaking publicly and advocating for this, working on putting together committees. So I know the town's guided stuff has got to do, but the citizens are trying to move this thing forward, so. Yeah, and that's perfectly fine. So the rule is, the law is, that the town can't spend town dollars to do advocacy. Council members can do whatever you like.
2:08:04 Okay. Because you're not being paid by the town to do advocacy. It would not be appropriate for town staff to do advocacy, but you can do that. And certainly grassroots groups in the community can do advocacy. Yeah, just want to make sure you know that, I don't know what, because the Brown Act, I don't know what other folks are doing. Chris and I have been talking about it, but certainly out there trying to get this thing going. But then the council members have to make clear that they're speaking as individuals and not.
2:08:29 As an agent of the town? That's correct. I mean, if the town, well, once the town, if the town puts this on the ballot, individual council members can certainly tell members of the public, hey, the council has put this on the ballot. The town, maybe the council will have adopted a resolution in support, and you could say that. But other than that, you're saying I'm speaking as one individual, not acting on behalf of the town. Thank you. Anything else? Very good. Thanks, Rob.
2:09:00 Hayes, you're on for the next one. So, thank you. So, the next item we're talking about right now is Town of Mammoth Lake Civic Center financing update. We've invited Marty Johnson, our consultant, bond self-consultant, who's been a good partner with us for many years, actually partnered with us on all the debt issuances that I've been a part of with the Town.
2:09:30 So he's on tonight to talk about it. I want to give just a brief little bit of an introduction to where we are. So I can't tell you how much is going on in this arena. It's an incredible amount of work, not only from figuring out exactly what the project looks like, getting it ready for bid. Hayes and team have been doing that. That all occurred with HMC, our architect.
2:09:57 So a lot of work went through that process. I will say it was a successful bidding process. We had tremendous interest in that. We do have, you know, a bid that we have in hand. Hazen team are kind of continuing to work through that and just review of that process. But we do have a good number that we know what we need to now fund. So it's a little bit higher.
2:10:22 We need to be dynamic. We need to be able to pivot.
2:10:49 And I'm kind of making a recommendation, and I think, you know, Marty's going to talk a little bit more about this, but a recommendation that we split the difference, right? We're looking at about three and a half to four million dollars higher than we were anticipating. 26.9 was the construction bid, and that's just the cost to produce the building. We had that number closer to 23 in our estimates, and so we're doing some work in that space.
2:11:18 I think we have a good solution to split the difference between the two and say instead of coming with $4 million cash to get that done, we're going to put in, I'm going to recommend anyway for Council to put in $2 million in cash and then increase the expected funding for the building from $25 million to $27 million. That makes an overall palatable
2:11:45 Debt service payment annually throughout the term of the life of the debt and something we can live within, frankly. So a little bit of a tee up. I'm still very comfortable where we are. I'm still happy with where we are. I'm grateful for the work that's been done. But I'm going to turn it over to Marty now and talk a little bit more about that. And I think at the end, if there are more questions, I can certainly spend more time on what financing stuff I'm talking about and where the cash is coming from. It's coming from existing capital.
2:12:14 Investments in capital and not anywhere else. So Marty, you want to take it away? Sure. Thanks, Rob. For the record, Marty Johnson with J&A Consulting Group. As Rob mentioned, I've been working with the town almost 10 years now, I believe, on financing and bond issues and things like that. As Rob described, we originally, when we came to you in February,
2:12:44 Well, we authorized up to $33 million in bonds, which was based on a number of assumptions, but that was going to net $25 million for the town hall project. And as Rob just described, that number has come up a bit. And so we're looking now at doing a transaction that would generate approximately $27 million in terms of net proceeds.
2:13:11 A couple of the parameters that we've been looking at in structuring this bond issue and setting the payments was to identify those existing resources, the termination of the lease for the current town hall, the expiration of the payment for the police facility because we're going to defeat those bonds this month, those other revenue sources that were available.
2:13:38 And use those to make the payments on these new bonds. And even at that $25 million number, for the first two or three years, we were going to need approximately $400,000 to $500,000 in order to make those payments. At the $27 million level, we can still stick within our annual...
2:14:00 Uh, availability, again, except for the first three years or so, uh, and that number goes up to $700,000, $750,000. Uh, so it still works within our parameters, uh, of what we've been trying to look at for the last six to eight months. Uh, if we went to $29 million and tried to do it all with bonds, we're gonna blow through that annual number, uh, to the tune of $100,000, $150,000 a year.
2:14:28 For as long as those judgment bonds remained outstanding, which is the mid-2030s. So again, that's why that $27 million seems to be kind of the sweet spot in terms of getting additional cash for the project, but not going too far outside what our parameters are. And then a couple of things just that have happened since we were there in February. One of the reasons we had a $33 million
2:14:58 The upper limit on the bond issue was that that provided for what we call a cash-funded reserve fund. As part of this transaction, we need to have a reserve fund equal to essentially one year's debt service. And in lieu of putting aside cash and just leaving it in the bank for the next 24 years,
2:15:21 We are able to go to a bond insurance company and for $150,000 or so, they will put up a surety bond that will fulfill the requirements of that reserve fund. In addition to that, they have agreed to insure the bonds, which will raise the rating on the bonds from the A rating that we received from Standard & Poor's to a double A rating, which will save us considerably on the interest.
2:15:51 And then the last part in terms of interest rates and, you know, if you want, I can throw the graph up on my screen. But if you remember in February when we talked, everybody was expecting the Fed was going to cut rates five, six, seven times during 2024. I expressed skepticism about that. It looks like this time I've proved to be right as the Fed has yet to cut rates.
2:16:20 Expectations now are that it might be one or zero. But as a result of that change over the last couple of months, short-term rates have jumped almost a half a percent. The longer-term rates have only gone up about a quarter percent. But the end result is rates have come up since where we were in February. We are still within what are estimated.
2:16:47 The average interest rate was on the bonds, which is in the 4.35 to 4.45% range. And our plan is to sell the bonds at the end of June. So if between now and the end of June when we actually price these bonds, we can work out the cost of the project.
2:17:11 Get that reduced a little bit. That still does provide us the opportunity to reduce that bond amount if those things can happen. So that's where we're at now. If you have any questions, I would be happy to answer them. Questions? So this is an information item. When do we anticipate needing to take action or what action would be proposed?
2:17:37 So the action has already been done as far as allocating or authorizing us to go out to bid, authorizing us for a certain dollar amount of sale of bonds. We have gone through the steps with regard to going through the bond rating presentation. We did that late part of May, got that process. So we're sort of in the row of going about this. We will issue a preliminary official statement.
2:18:04 That talks about the performance of the town financially and goes about that. So, Marty, if you want to answer any of those questions, I think we're past the decision phase unless we- Well, I think what would be helpful, Rob, is that for council, because, you know, Dan, you all give a very sort of detailed presentation.
2:18:30 of the next, you know, of the run of the bond and everything else. It would be helpful when you guys, when this gets a little bit more dialed, if it needs to be, to come back with that same thing so that we can just see it did this, this might change, so we can see things in the context of it. I appreciate that there, we may be beyond the point of making a decision, but I think for us to understand exactly what's changing, what's moving around. So when there is
2:18:58 Assail the bonds, it gets locked. We know what it is, and we know what that is for budgeting purposes and going down the road. That would be my request. Yeah, and I think, and appreciate that, John. I think what Marty was talking about, throwing up a chart, those would show sort of the impact of that $27 million issuance that we'd be seeking. We could do something like that on the 19th, I think, to bring that together. Because that's, I mean, at least I'm speaking only for myself. That was my orientation. It was very
2:19:27 You tracked a number of different things, the judgment payments, the bonds for this, money going for other resources. It was very helpful to see the full context of the whole thing. Yeah, we can absolutely do that. I think that's important. We will be looking to go to sell for the bond sell to occur on the 26th of June. And so that would be the time in which we would know exactly what the details are on that. But the plan itself, again, the plan is going to be 99% accurate.
2:19:57 It's just how the sale goes through. There's minor adjustments to that. And I think what you're asking to see is really good for the community to see because it talks about what Marty alluded to where we have our current debt service payments or financial obligations of the town sort of line up to provide the funding that we will need to make this debt service. So we're not sort of going further into sort of annual
2:20:24 We're just simply reallocating those very precisely. So that's the type of, you know, it's rooted in that explanation and that presentation before. It would be helpful to come back to that so that. Yeah, and I'm happy to do that on the 19th just to make sure everyone is clear on exactly what the expectations are. Okay, thank you. Yep. Further questions? I guess I just want to clarify for myself. So $26 million.
2:20:53 The contractor, that was their bid, and then we have $3 million in soft costs. Is that how we're getting to $29? So, you know, Hayes can speak to the details on that, but there's things like construction management has a little bit of a cost. There's fees associated with that. Those are some of the smaller elements to that, but we also have a $2 million contingency on top of that, and so that isn't necessarily planned to be spent, but it's really just prudent.
2:21:22 To have that available. So the 29 includes $2 million in contingency. Okay. And then we would be putting $2 million in cash into the whole deal and then financing the rest? That's correct. As far as the construction goes, right, there will be, you know, some soft cost impacts to us in the future that are not a part of the construction bid and not being financed. I think we've got...
2:21:52 Some set-asides associated with those costs, but those would be a couple of years down the road, so if we need to add or augment that, we would have the opportunity to fund that. Okay, thank you. Yeah, and just a little bit about the available cash, right, you know, having money set aside for capital projects is a great thing to do, especially with the amount of work that we have in flight. Hayes will tell you that
2:22:20 Things change every day in that arena and having those monies available. But the bulk of it is really two areas and I want to just talk about those for a second. When John was talking about a structure of where our existing revenue sources will be and how they will fund the payment, we had in I think early March the analysis and again before all the things that changed that Marty talked about.
2:22:47 You know, showed that we were going to be upside down about $1,334,000 in payments, right? So we, you and I and Dan, set aside a payment reserve to make sure those were fully funded all the way through 2036. The restructuring stuff that Marty spoke about changed those numbers from, at the time, at $25 million, it was going to be somewhere around $350,000 to $400,000 from $1.34. So we had set aside that much money. That left us about $1 million available.
2:23:16 Now that's climbed up to 700. So we still have 700,000 available from that set aside. In looking at way back in 21-22, we set aside a million six for disaster response and funding, hoping for repayment from FEMA on that. We actually submitted a request to our insurance company and received a payment for 1.7 million. So the set aside for the emergency response.
2:23:44 Plus that other $700 is where the $2 million would come from. So it's just a reshuffling of what's been previously allocated, but it would not have an impact to, say, you know, future investments in housing or other things like that. It's just drawing lennies from those areas. So I wanted people to be kind of aware that, you know, we have flexibility. We are dynamic in our financing, but those are the sources that I would be utilizing for that extra $2 million that we're putting into it. Good. Okay. Any other questions?
2:24:17 Questions from the public. What's the length of term for the 27 million, like 20 years, 15 years? Marty, you want to get on that one? Sure, but I couldn't hear the question. What's the length of the term repayment? We're planning to issue bonds that will have a 25-year term. And again, that's one of those things to be updated when you come back. Yeah, we have a payment schedule that shows all those payments.
2:24:52 You know, when we're looking at how those payments will be outlined, one of the key things in that availability of funds is the payment, repayment of the settlement debt in 2035, 36 timeframe, where we will be freeing up about $1,860,000 in annual payments that would go primarily into this fund. So a lot of our principal repayment happens in the back end.
2:25:22 Unfortunately, but that's where those payments would accelerate. So we could be looking at something around a million three, million two five to million three starting this year on this debt. And then in that time frame, it's somewhere around 2.7, 2.8 million. But again, no real impact to the annual operating expenditures. Other questions? Seeing none. Moving on. Okay. Moving to the consent agenda.
2:25:57 8.1. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 15th. 8.2. Approve the award to the annual contract for publication of legal notices to the sheet. 8.3. Award contract for facilities exterior painting project FAC 24-001 to HB Restoration, Inc. 8.4. Accept the donation of real property located at 156 Lost Lane and authorize the town manager to sign the grant deed.
2:26:24 8.5, accept the Project Closeout Report for Lower Orle Mountain Road Rehabilitation and Sidewalk. 8.6, accept check register 515-24, 522-24, and 530-24. Does anyone want to pull anything from consent? Seeing none, I would accept a motion. Go ahead. I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. I'll second.
2:26:55 Motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none. Jamie? Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Very good. Moving on then to policy matter 9.1. Consider resolution to approve a one-year lease agreement with Flock Safety for eight automatic license plate recognition cameras for the Mammoth Lakes Police Department.
2:27:27 Chief, you're going to start us off here. Yes, Mayor. Thanks for having me. Dan Casabian, Chief of Police. With me is Jason Heilman. While he gets set up, he's going to be doing the majority of the presentation. He's kind of in what you call hot seat tonight. Also with us is in the room, we have Chris McCrassick, Director of Emergency Services, who has a short speaking part this evening, along with Aleish Toemeier, Fire Chief, Mammoth Lakes Fire Department.
2:27:56 We are on Zoom in our virtual world. Ulysses Cabrera, he is our Flock Safety Representative for any questions that we may not be able to answer or that Council may have for Flock. With that, I'll turn it over to Jason and present. You know, one thing, actually, I do want to tell Council, he's going to, you know, explain what this technology is, which is important, but also equally important is what it is not. So with that, go ahead, Jason. Good evening, Council.
2:28:26 Thank you for having us, and I'm going to do my best to go through this information. There's quite a bit of information regarding flock safety, automatic license plate readers, and a lot of technology involved in it. A lot of how they benefit us, what it does, what it doesn't do, how it benefits the town, how it benefits public works and emergency services. So with that, I'm going to try my best not to read.
2:28:54 Off the PowerPoint and as I go through this. What is this technology and how does it work? Automated license plate readers, LPRs, ALPRs, license plate recognition, I'll probably refer to them mostly as LPR. What these are, they're cameras, they're high definition cameras that detect passing vehicles and read their license plates and capture that data and
2:29:31 Run that data against a set of a database for vehicles that we're looking for, that law enforcement's looking for, that can be missing persons, that can be wanted vehicles, stolen vehicles, encounters that information, and as it runs it against that list, if these, if that vehicle hits, it sends a notice to law enforcement that this vehicle just passed a certain camera in this location so officers can head to that area. It is a tool that
2:30:01 We use to track down stolen vehicles, track down vehicles that are involved in felony crimes, but also to track down vehicles that are involved in amber alerts, yellow alerts, missing persons. So it captures that data and provides that to us. Flock safety is unique because these cameras
2:30:26 They're solar powered and they don't require to be hardwired in. So what they are is they're solar powered high definition cameras about the size of your palm. They're mounted on existing infrastructure or standalone poles if you don't have existing infrastructure. The nice thing about being solar powered is we have the ability to put these wherever we need, wherever we want. We don't have to
2:30:55 We don't have to rely on having power because they're already pulling that from the solar. They are self-heated and built to last in cold environments. This is important, obviously, because in Mammoth it gets cold here. And we have a wide range of weather. They have what's called, for wintertime, they have what's called a penguin pack. This is an additional battery that helps these work in the cold weather.
2:31:24 And survive the cold until the solar can kick back in and keep charging. They are activated by motion from a vehicle. This one is, they don't, so they're not recording all the time. So as a vehicle passes, they kick on, they capture that image of the vehicle, and then they run that against the, that plate against the database. They do not capture people or facial recognition. So this is an important one.
2:31:53 As the vehicle passes, it gets you an image, and if you look in the upper right of the screen, it's going to get you an image of the back of the vehicle and to capture that license plate. It doesn't show you who's in the car. It doesn't give us how many occupants. It doesn't give us who's driving. It doesn't give us a picture of the face. It just gives us that license plate and vehicle information. There's no facial recognition. You don't know who's driving the car. It's just the license plate. Along with that, you're going to get the...
2:32:21 Last time it was seen, it's going to give you the make and model and the color. It's going to give you how many times it was seen in the last 30 days. In this case, it was seen three times in the last 30 days. You can see it's going to give you the color. This is all the information we get. We don't get who's driving the car. We don't get speed. We don't get if the registration is expired. We just get the license plate and the vehicle make, model, and color.
2:32:50 And also this technology provides a data analytics platform, which I'll get into a little bit more here as we continue on. Can I ask you a quick question? Yes. Sorry to interrupt. On the last slide, so if I understand you correctly, if my license plate, if my car is involved in some kind of crime, that would get sent to you.
2:33:14 But if my car is not involved in some kind of crime, like do you have access to that information or would that be sent to you or both? Yes, we do. And I'll get into that a little further. But what's going to happen is if your vehicle is involved in a crime, say a hit and run, and a witness says, hey, we saw a white Toyota Camry hit a vehicle and leave and left down Main Street. We can run a white Toyota Camry through that system in that area.
2:33:43 And look for any matches. And that time frame. So then it will give us the license plate and we can go back and look at that. Or if we are looking for, say your vehicle because it was involved in a hit and run, we can, we have your license plate, we can run it through the system to find out how many times it hit or which direction it was going. Or we can put it in there and say, hey, let us know if your vehicle passes by this camera.
2:34:11 And then if it does, we get notified that, hey, that vehicle you're looking for is involved in that hit and run, just pinged the main street camera going westbound. So officers can head that way, find the vehicle, conduct an investigative stop, and work the case from there. Okay. So it has two components, either looking back to find information, or if we are looking for a particular vehicle, we can put that in there and get that information. Thank you.
2:34:39 And so this is just an overview. We're going to go a little bit more into what exactly it can do for us. But just to reiterate, small cameras, you drive around and you won't even notice they're there unless you're particularly looking for them. Mount to existing infrastructure, they run off battery, and they are not constantly recording, but as a vehicle travels by, it snaps a picture of that license plate in that vehicle. One other thing to add before I move on.
2:35:08 If I walk by that camera or if I ride a bike by that camera, it's not going to activate that camera. It's vehicles only. So what is this technology? Well, it's license plate recognition. Like I talked about, these cameras are reading license plates. They're capturing that information and they're storing it or they're notifying us if we are looking for a particular vehicle. They gather objective facts about vehicles, not people. This is an important one. It's reading the vehicle.
2:35:40 That's all. It's not telling us who's driving it. It's not running that license plate for expired registration. It's not running it against any law enforcement database that runs registration and gives us who the registered owner is, who the, what the registration is. So when we, in law enforcement, we run a license plate. That goes through the California law enforcement telecommunications system called CLETS. That is going to give us who the registered owner is.
2:36:10 Fees paid, address, if the registration's current, vehicle, make, type. It's going to give us all that personal information attached to that license plate. This system does not do that. It is not tied in any way to that system. It simply captures the license plate and runs it against a list that it already has vehicles that have been entered into that list as being wanted for some form or fashion, whether it's a missing person or whether it's a criminal investigation.
2:36:40 And with that, it doesn't give us, like I said, again, I'll keep saying this, doesn't give us who's driving the car. Just, this is license plate, here's the make and model, do what you want with it through traditional investigative methods. It alerts police of wanted vehicles, and those wanted vehicles may not be wanted for a crime. We have to remember that. It can be wanted for what we call a silver alert. Your loved one is older with dementia, is not supposed to be driving.
2:37:09 Left in a car, and now they're behind the wheel. We know it's unsafe, they're not supposed to be driving, they don't know where we're going. Traditionally, we would have to start searching the area to try and find that person. With flock cameras, we can immediately input that license plate into the system to alert us if that missing person drives by, so we know where to go. We can also search, where did that vehicle go?
2:37:37 Did that vehicle go outbound Mammoth and is now on 395? And we need to notify CHP, Mono County sheriffs, Inyo County, let them know, hey, this vehicle is heading your way. So it gives us that tool to be alerted and to search for these missing persons, felony crimes. It's used to solve crime. That's kind of the bread and butter of this tool for law enforcement. Traditionally, if a crime is reported and
2:38:07 You get a vehicle description. Officers respond to that area and they start checking the area. You have to find the vehicle to run the license plate to stop it to identify who's in there. This system, if the minute that call goes out of that crime and we have a license plate, we can search in the system, see which direction they went, where they're heading to help better send our resources to the right area to try and locate these people and hold them accountable. It also...
2:38:36 Gives us the ability, and I've mentioned in the past, if there's a crime and we know it's a white Toyota 4Runner, maybe left a certain area, we can search that area at certain times to locate that vehicle and run that license plate and get that license plate and get that information, which we can then use to identify the registered owner, create some follow-up leads. Really cool about this system, too, is for criminal investigations, you can upload a
2:39:06 A photo taken from a surveillance camera, and not just a cam, say the village cameras, they capture a suspect vehicle driving by. You can upload that photo into the system and say find that vehicle in the system. And it will look for things like, you know, maybe it has a roof rack, maybe it has a dent on the back. And where this would have been beneficial, and I'll add these stories in as I'm going along, but when we had that rash of catalytic converter thefts.
2:39:32 A few years ago, the mountain was getting hit, people in town were getting hit, and it was more than just, you know, having to get your catalytic converter repaired, which is two or three thousand dollars. You know, there was one person, one victim, who relied on that vehicle as, I believe, a plumber or an electrician and couldn't run jobs until he got that vehicle fixed. Well, with that case, we had a picture of the suspect vehicle from a security camera.
2:40:00 Passing. That's all we had. But you couldn't see who was driving it. You couldn't see the license plate. But we know that vehicle was in town and we had a picture of it. We knew a make and model. We could have uploaded that into this system, found that where it hit our cameras and had that lead to go on and put that vehicle in now as wanted in connection with these thefts. So the next time it came into town, we're alerted right away and we can start heading to that area.
2:40:25 So those are just some examples and real-life examples of how this technology, had we had it then, could have helped us solve those crimes. Jump in real quick. Just kind of on that topic, I spoke with Sheriff Ingrid Braun yesterday and kind of inquired why they went with their LPR system. They have the LPR license plate readers or recognition also. And one of her primary reasons was the Carly Gousset case.
2:40:51 And she told me if we had those cameras on Highway 6, the probability of solving that case quickly would have existed. They would have had every license plate that went up and down Highway 6. And since then, she went through the process and ended up getting LPRs throughout the county. So that kind of goes to show what Sergeant Heilman is saying as far as investigative work and stuff like that, silver alerts, amber alerts, and even kidnappings. Thank you.
2:41:21 So continuing, what, oh, and one last point here, it adheres to all state laws. This, this company is continually growing. They are always staying up to date on the current laws, what's coming out, as far as policies and what information we can share, how long we need to retain it, and it adheres to all state laws. We have a very robust policy, a draft policy, which I will show you, to make sure that we are
2:41:47 Not doing anything that violates state law. It's going to get us in trouble. That we're respecting people's rights, people's rights to privacy, and that we're being transparent with the technology that we have because we understand that this is powerful technology. It's important, but it's powerful. I just want to ask you the acronym. Not tied to PII. What's that? So that's personal identifiable information. Okay. So moving on to that side of the slide.
2:42:14 What isn't this technology? What doesn't it do? That bold point, that was important. It's not tied to personal identifiable information, PII. So it doesn't give you, when it runs your, it captures that license plate, doesn't tell us who you are, doesn't tell us your driver license status, doesn't tell us your registration status, doesn't tell us where you live, doesn't tell us how fast you're going, doesn't tell us who many people are in that car.
2:42:43 It's not tied to any of that. It simply captures an image of that license plate, runs it against a database, that of wanted or missing vehicles, and if it hits on that, it alerts us to it. If it doesn't hit, it stores it for 30 days and it deletes, and I'll go into that a little bit later on. It's not facial recognition. And I've mentioned before multiple times, it doesn't even tell us who's in the vehicle. It doesn't capture a picture of their face.
2:43:10 It's not used for automated traffic enforcement. This is a big one. People are not going to receive a ticket in the mail because you hit a LPR camera and your registration was expired. You're not going to receive a ticket in the mail because you rolled a stop sign. You're not going to receive a ticket in the mail because you were doing 55 miles an hour up Main Street. This technology does not do that. That type of enforcement still relies on an officer in the field observing a violation and making a traffic stop.
2:43:40 And having that personal conversation, why didn't you stop? Why is your registration expired? We're not taking that out of the field. We're not getting rid of that. And this, because this technology does not do that. Fourth bullet point there, it's not used for immigration enforcement. We're prohibited by law. We've sent a bill, 54, the California Values Act, from providing this information to immigration authorities for the purpose of immigration enforcement.
2:44:07 It is our, this data that it captures is ours. We decide who gets to see it. We decide why we go through it and why we actually, you know, are pulling it up. But it's our data. It does not belong to the federal government. It does not belong to the state government. It's ours. And we decide who it goes to and we're going to comply with all the rules and laws and policies and it will not be used for immigration enforcement. The data is not stored beyond 30 days.
2:44:35 We have 30 days to access that saved license plate read. After that 30 days, it's gone. It's deleted. Most crimes are reported within 30 days. So we get that call for that theft. We then have the ability to research, see if that vehicle hit any of our LPR cameras, get that information. If we determine that there's evidence on there, that we have a plate read, we have our suspect vehicle, we then download that data and that plate read.
2:45:04 And we save it as normal evidence using our evidence.com server, which is what also handles our body cameras. So we upload it there and it stays there and it's then governed by our evidence retention policy. But if we don't get it in 30 days, it's gone. So there's not going to be a fishing expedition a year down the road to go look for stuff. Before I move on, any questions on this slide here? No, my only comment is with all the slides you have here, we need to move this thing along. Will do, Mr. Barrett.
2:45:37 So another thing with this is it gives you traffic analytics. This is kind of a dashboard here. A little hard to see, but it's going to tell you how many vehicles hit your cameras at what times. And it also, in the lower right, it gives you what states their plates were coming from, what types of vehicles were they in, you know, how many Teslas came into town. Do we have enough Tesla chargers? And this is not giving you individual plate reads. It's not giving you that data. It's just...
2:46:05 How many vehicles hit these cameras at what time so you know how busy the roadways are when they're busy to help direct your traffic enforcement or assist with public works when's the best time to do construction projects to avoid high traffic areas. So why do we want this? And I kind of touched on a lot of this, which I think will make it a little quicker with going through some of these slides. The emergency management challenge here, this also has emergency management benefit to it.
2:46:34 And with that, you know, I think we can talk a lot about evacuations. Right now, if we, to figure out how many people are in town, we rely a lot on our occupancy numbers. But those can be hit and miss if they're reported correctly. And some of our people in town may be camping. They may be owners who don't report to the occupancy numbers. This data will give us how many cars came inbound into town.
2:47:00 And if we have it to do an evacuation, we now know that we had, for instance, 10,000 vehicles that came into Mammoth, unique license plate reads, it's not double counting, that we now need to evacuate. And we can get real-time data to see how many vehicles actually came out of town, so we know that if we had 10,000 came in, but we've only evacuated 2,000, we need to change our and speed this up. So with that, I could pass along real quick to Chief Tillmeyer from the...
2:47:28 Fire Department here, just to speak briefly on that. Good evening, Alex Tamire, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. I promise I'll be brief. Yeah, so with evacuations, the catalyst for the last time we looked at this was the Creek Fire, obviously, for everybody, right, and that really made this community think about what would we do if this came over the ridge. We did quite a bit of work there because, frankly, a lot of that didn't exist at the time. Getting, working with Kasabian, with Nate Greenberg, and drew some rudimentary.
2:47:58 Ideas and concepts of how we would zone out the town to start doing evacuations. That's moved forward significantly with the county supporting with Zone Haven and really breaking that down. We're actually a really unique community because we have a very good idea of how an evacuation would look. If you think back, and I'm sure you've all seen it, when we have 395 shut down, we have 40,000 tourists here.
2:48:20 on a Sunday and then all of a sudden they open up 395 you see the gridlock that ensues after that and we have
2:48:28 Pinch points where we're working with very limited staff to try to get those people out onto the 395. So a tool like this could really assist with, and again, it's already occurring to a certain extent, it's just there's limited staffing to where, you know, we're already communicating, trying to support that. Again, it is a law enforcement function, but ultimately, if you start having things back up on Meridian or up at the Village, you need to get officers into those areas and work those pinch points to keep the traffic flowing. So having this tool would assist with
2:48:57 Both the assessment of what you have as far as a need to evacuate, but also in real time taking a look at that and working through that process and getting those people safely out of town. So ultimately support this project. Any questions I can answer? Thanks, Alex. Just to touch on that, the cameras have the ability to...
2:49:17 When Sergeant Heilman goes through and lets you know where they're going to be, there's going to be a few, four of them, on the intersection of Meridian and Old Mammoth. So you're going to be seeing who's going out into Old Mammoth. For example, if we did have something come up over the ridge and we needed to evacuate Old Mammoth, we would be able to tell in real time how many vehicles traveled out in that direction and how many...
2:49:39 In the Old Mammoth, how many have come out of Old Mammoth? To give us some sort of an idea of how many vehicles do we have out there in Old Mammoth and what's the evacuation project going to look like? Thanks, Chris. All right, Chris McCrassick, Monroe County Emergency Management. Yeah, I mean, I echo what the chief said. Another thing that it's very useful for is those analytics. We can use that data for pre-planning.
2:50:06 As well as running tabletop exercises and scenarios. And we can run those scenarios so that we're really planned in the event of an emergency. And also letting our Inyo County know, if we're doing a mass evacuation, we need to let them know how many are coming. Not just a good guess, but this will provide the analytics to let us know and let Inyo County know that, hey, you better prep the fairgrounds because we've got a lot of people coming your way.
2:50:36 So again, I echo what they said and they gave a lot of good information. So it has a lot of value on the emergency management side, but just for analytics. Thank you. Thank you. Continuing, so one more thing from our side is generally in the wintertime before the mountain is completely open, we usually have what I call that red snake of tail lights coming down from main lodge and it can take two hours to get down.
2:51:05 We generally just base that on trying to guess how many people we think are up there. With this system, if our cameras are placed in just the perfect position, we can capture how many vehicles went up 203 to main launch so we have an idea in the beginning of the day, and then we can plan are we going to need to assist with traffic control to get those vehicles down and safely off the mountain so they can enjoy the rest of their evening and we deploy our resources accurately and have enough people to assist.
2:51:34 So that's another thing with the traffic handle, it's how many vehicles are hitting certain places and going to certain areas. Law enforcement. So this is really where, and I've already touched on this, but this is a huge benefit for us investigatively. So we talked about detection of alert vehicles. Generally, that's dependent on an officer looking for a certain vehicle, finding it, running that license plate, and getting that information. This system...
2:52:05 We'll be constantly doing that, reading plates as those vehicles pass by. This is a force multiplier for us. It allows us to, you know, if there's only two officers on and you get a theft from the village, one officer is going to be taking that report. Another officer may be interviewing witnesses, attempting to locate video surveillance. So nobody's out there checking the area to actually try and find the perpetrators and hold them accountable.
2:52:32 With these cameras, these cameras can be checking for that suspect vehicle and alert us if it passes so we can stop there, respond, and go attempt to locate that vehicle. And in law enforcement, sometimes you deal with the issue of the reliability of eyewitnesses. You know, people are in distress when they see a crime occur. They're attempting to call 911. They're attempting to get their camera to get a picture. They're attempting to memorize the license plate. And sometimes they get it wrong. And we only get a partial plate.
2:53:00 These cameras take out that, they give us reliable, accurate information. They're going to capture that whole plate, they're going to capture the vehicle make and model, and it's not going to be so reliant on an eyewitness to see that information. And I've touched before, I'll touch on again, the amber alerts, the silver alerts, the yellow alerts, the yellow alert is if somebody's involved in a hit and run involving death.
2:53:25 You can put that information into the database for that vehicle that you're looking for. If it passes one of the cameras, we get notified, we can respond to that location to try and locate that vehicle and bring that person to justice, hold them accountable. Missing persons, that's another big one. We get that a lot. We get calls from down south.
2:53:48 My son headed up to Mammoth. I don't think he made it. We can check the cameras to see if they actually made it and try and find that person, locate them to put the family at ease, let them know, hey, we found your son or daughter. They're in Mammoth. They're safe. Their phone just died while they were driving and they'll be calling you shortly. And it's just, it's accurate information. And I've touched on that before. It's accurate information that we were getting from these cameras.
2:54:12 So how does it prevent crime? We went through this before about the different alerts, stolen vehicles, felony crime vehicles. But what I wanted to touch on is how it can help us quickly clear cases. So if we open up an investigation and we're looking for a vehicle and a suspect, we have to generally assign that to a detective. The detective has to start interviewing witnesses, trying to pull video to try and find information and leads as to
2:54:42 A suspect vehicle and find that license plate. That's time consuming because they have other cases and sometimes they're juggling multiple cases. With this information, if we can eliminate that need to have to try and find witnesses, try and analyze video to find a license plate, we can get that information quickly. We can close that case, hold that person accountable, and they can move on to the next case. So it's going to help close cases quickly so we can continually investigate new cases as they come in and not be tied up on.
2:55:12 This was a news article from the Union regarding Grass Valley and their success with ALPR cameras in 2022. And just to go over it briefly, they recovered, I think 36 stolen vehicles were recovered, 26 which were stolen from outside their jurisdiction. They used these cameras to solve an ATM skimmer ring that was putting those ATM skimmers around their jurisdiction.
2:55:43 And they also used it in a local shooting, kidnapping. And also in 2022, they used it to solve catalytic converter thefts. So just a quote from the mayor there. Not only does Flock System help solve crimes, but it's a preventative solution. So we're being proactive. In addition to help solving crimes, it's sending a message that...
2:56:05 That we take, you know, we're taking public safety seriously and we're going to hold you accountable and use this technology to do so if you come into our town and commit crimes. I went over the traffic analytics but just some additional information here. You know, the real-time data is huge for us and I've touched on it before but just knowing how many people are coming into town.
2:56:27 When the peak times of travel are so we can properly deploy our resources for traffic enforcement to get that safety message out there. If we need to deploy our speed trailer, where's the highest volume of traffic and at what time so we can deploy that and get that message out there. In addition to getting the information as far as where the vehicles are going, what states they're coming from, what types of vehicles.
2:56:55 And I said it before, but how many EVs do we have in town and do we have enough chargers, especially if it comes time for an evacuation? How many EVs are we going to need to get out? And a lot of those people may not charge right when they get into town or they may need to charge. Just additional information that can be used for an emergency situation. In addition to license plate reader reading, this also does, FLOC does a gunshot detection. It's called their Raven.
2:57:23 This system alerts, you receive an alert in less than 60 seconds. So the way this would look, and I'm going to use the term active shooter. It happens all over. It's something we have as law enforcement, we have to constantly prepare for it. If we have an active shooter, generally, somebody's going to have to call 911 to report that to law enforcement. They're going to be under stress. They're going to be shaking. They may be struggling to get their phone out. They may be running, trying to find cover. There's going to be that delay in response.
2:57:52 Average times can be five to ten minutes before that call is made, gets to dispatch, it may go to CHP and you need to get transferred to a dispatcher in Mono County. Call needs to get entered, it then needs to get broadcasted, and officers need to start responding that way. And in an active shooter or any type of shooting situation, seconds matter. With this system, an officer, when they start their shift, they log on on their phone or on their computer in their car. They'll get that notification in less than 60 seconds.
2:58:21 There's been a gunshot detection. It will give you the location with a 90% accuracy rating within 90 feet, and officers can start rolling that way. And those seconds matter. And with the system, you can get a one square mile radius of coverage. So you could have one near the schools and also get the hospital. And we're currently in talks and sharing this technology with the school and the hospital to see if it's something that they would be interested in getting on board with.
2:58:51 But this is additional, and this is something else they do in addition to the license plate reader. In addition, they also do firework detection with that same accuracy. Privacy focus and user auditing. So privacy protection, like we talked about, this data is owned by the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. It's not owned by Flock, it's ours. It won't be sold like some of the data on your phone. This is our data. We decide who we share it with. We decide what we do with it.
2:59:23 There's a 30-day retention period. I've hit that multiple times and it's deleted. This short retention period just ensures that if we don't need it, after 30 days, it's gone. There's not going to be some fishing expedition a year down the road because we're looking for something. It takes the human bias out of crime solving. This is just reading vehicles and reading plates. It's not looking at who's in the vehicle. There's no...
2:59:51 Bias on what the drivers look like or what the car looks like. It's just giving us that information. All data is stored securely in the AWS government cloud. This is the same cloud that's used by the CIA and the FBI to store their data. And if Ulysses, if you're on, if you could speak to that briefly just regarding the security of the cloud. Yes, I'm here. Good evening. Can you hear me on your side? Yes. Yes.
3:00:24 Good evening, Honorable Mayor, members of the City Council, members of the public and staff, Ulysses Cabrera, Community Engagement Manager with Flock Safety. Chief, to your point there about security, as you mentioned, all of the images and data is stored on the AWS, Amazon Web Services Cloud. It is the same cloud that is used by Department of Defense. It's used for storing classified documents from Congress, NSA.
3:00:53 So this is the highest end, end-to-end encrypted cloud storage that is available. And again, that just speaks to how seriously we take security and making sure that privacy is protected in this situation. And I know that the chief has more points that he's going to go over here as well, but I hope that shared a little bit more context as far as the security measures that we
3:01:22 Put in place to ensure that the data is safe. Thank you, Lisa. So regarding privacy, that anytime you go to the system to do a search, you have to put in a reason why you're doing the search and a case number assigned to it so we can track and audit this down the road. So there needs to be a reason as to why you're going in there. I've talked about it before, it's not facial recognition. And there's no PII contained in flock. It's just the license plate and the vehicle.
3:01:54 Anything that we obtain from that, any PIA that we obtain during our investigation does not go into a FLOC server. That goes into our own records management system, goes into evidence. It's not going into FLOC. If I can hit on that real quick. So Jason brought up CLETS earlier.
3:02:10 Cleland is a device that we use to run license plates, to run driver's licenses, to look up criminal histories. And in order to do that, you have to have a reason for it. You have to put that reason in. And that is monitored and it's evaluated by Cleland.
3:02:28 On a yearly basis, right? They come in and they audit that on a yearly basis. In order to get in and look up criminal histories and stuff, you have to have a reason. You have to put that reason down associated with a case number, which is very similar. That's what we would be doing with Flock as well. You have to have a case number. You have to have a reason to go in and look, and that's documented. One more time, just keep hitting on this. It's not used for traffic or immigration enforcement. It's not connected to any other third parties, Carfax, DMV, anything like that. It's strictly
3:03:01 It's its own standalone. And there's a transparency portal. This is what it can look like. This one right here is through Yakima, Washington. We can take this transparency portal and post this on our website for the public to see. How many hits did you get? How many arrests were made? How many cases did this assist in? What do the numbers look like? How many stolen vehicles were recovered?
3:03:25 Be completely transparent and post this information so we can see, are we getting a good, and the public can see, are we getting a good return investment on our FLOC cameras? But this transparency portal, it can be tailored to whatever we want to do, whatever we want to put up there, and FLOC will work with us in tailoring that. ALPR policy. So I'm going to switch. Okay, I think you have the policy. So I'm going to...
3:03:55 This policy here, this is our policy that governs how we use this system. We took the Vallejo Police Department model. The reason we took that one is because it's been vetted by the ACLU and it's been signed off by them. It is a very robust policy, about eight or nine pages, that governs what we can do with FLOC, how we can use it, who we can share the data with, training requirements, who's in charge of the program.
3:04:23 And this policy is implemented through Lexapol. Lexapol is our policy management system. And I think our policy is 740 pages. So we obviously take policy management and our policy very seriously. Just as a side note, we were just recognized by Lexapol for getting a gold achievement in our policy management, which is the highest level you can get. So we take our policy management seriously.
3:04:50 And this policy here governs exactly what you can do and how it needs to be done step by step. And this helps hold us accountable with this technology to make sure that we're following the law and we're following policy and that we're holding our officers accountable and ourselves. And this is readily available on our website for the public to see exactly what our policy is. Program overview. You want to touch on this, G?
3:05:20 So what we're looking at, we came up with a number of eight cameras. We wanted to kind of start small to see what we get out of it, right? Is it worth having throughout the community? Are we getting what we thought we were going to get out of it? So we're looking at eight cameras. That's relatively small. I know Truckee's got, I believe, 30-something cameras up. 23. They started with 17. They started with 17. So last year they started.
3:05:50 This year they went up to a few more cameras. The positioning on this, we looked at it, and Flux the expert on this, and this is kind of what we came up with, entry and exit points from town. Inbound, outbound 203, east of Meridian. We'll have one inbound, one outbound. All four light poles at the intersection of Meridian and Old Mammoth, which is going to cover your northbound, southbound traffic for Old Mammoth, and your eastbound, westbound traffic for Meridian.
3:06:20 So there's six. And then the other two, one at the village, at the crosswalk at the village, pointing up towards the mountain. So you're getting that traffic coming up, you're getting that traffic coming down. But what it also does is it gets the traffic coming in off of Scenic Loop. So our inbound and outbound 203 and our Scenic Loop, the two main areas that people can come in and go out of town. The last one we placed, we're going to place at Canyon in Lake Mary.
3:06:49 To get the amount of people, kind of get a number for the analytics of how many people do we actually have up in the Lakes Basin at any given time. And that goes back to the evacuations and stuff like that. So after one year, what the plan would be is to have this program for a year, come back to council with our statistics.
3:07:11 Let you know how the program's working. Let the community know how the program's working. And at that point, kind of make a determination if we want to move forward with this program for the following year. So just a couple more slides just to give you an idea of how this system works. This is a few years ago and how quickly it can help in an investigation. If you look here, there's an amber alert. It was a missing child issued at 12.33 p.m. So 12.33 in the afternoon.
3:07:45 A search was conducted with Flock Safety, and by 6 p.m. that evening, the vehicle had been located and the missing child is reunited with their mother. And all that is because you can quickly research this information, put that vehicle in there, when it hits, get notified of where that vehicle's at, respond to the area, and locate the vehicle and bring a resolution to the situation. You don't have to rely on just driving around and being in the right place at the right time and hoping you get lucky and finding that vehicle.
3:08:13 So just an idea of a real world situation where in five hours, less than five hours, there was a closure to this case. This technology is being used all over the state of California. And recently it was deployed in Oakland. Now thankfully we don't have the same issues that Oakland has. However, the governor was in support of these cameras. Governor Newsom was in support of the technology. And I think that's just important because if we know the governor's office is obviously going to look.
3:08:47 Look with a magnifying glass at this technology to make sure it complies with the law and respects people's rights to privacy. And they did that and Governor Newsom touted it as a good investment and a step forward in using technology to help solve crime and create a safer community. And that's really what we're trying to do. We're trying to harness technology. There's a lot more of it coming out. We have it now with body cameras.
3:09:16 We have it with, you know, MDCs and cars and vehicle cameras. And this is just another step in using technology to help us solve crime and create a safer environment for everybody. And so with that, we're open to any questions. Questions from Council. John, do you have questions? Who owns Flock? Actual owner of the business.
3:09:49 Yeah, the corporation. Is it a privately held? Is it a subsidiary of another corporation? Who owns it? Ulysses, if you could step in and answer that one. That's a little outside of my realm. Yes, sir. Absolutely. It is a privately held company. It is not a publicly traded company. And our CEO, Garrett Langley, a company that's based out of Atlanta, Georgia, has been in existence for approximately seven years now. And we are solely...
3:10:17 We are based out of the United States. We are not international whatsoever. And we are currently operating in basically every state in the entire country at this point. I know I shared a little bit more there, but I hope that answered your question. And so when reference is made to the system, do you guys manage your own cloud storage? And is all of the data of all the fly cameras going into one cloud system that you manage?
3:10:47 Yes, sir. The cloud, it's all in AWS. It's all the same cloud. And we do have our own IT folks in-house that, you know, work directly with AWS. So it's all done internally. We have our own employees here within FLOT. Okay, thank you. Yes, sir. Quick question on the gunshot detection. Is that included or is that an add-on?
3:11:17 That's an add-on, Mr. Mayor. That's something that I'm working with the hospital and with the school district to see if that's something they would like and if they would want to split the cost to purchase. But we would need to have the flock in place in order for them to purchase the gunshot detection. And that would be placed most likely at the high school, in the back of the high school area, cover one square mile.
3:11:44 We'll go all the way down to the elementary school, up to the office of the superintendent, and then down to the hospital and courts. So that main area within one square mile, we would get that gunshot detection. But that's going to be, that's not something that we would purchase, that's something that I'm working with the hospital and the school district to split the cost on, but we would need to have that flock technology in place in order for them to purchase that. All right, thank you. Chris. Thank you.
3:12:15 I have a question. It's probably for our town attorney, Morris, but maybe, I don't know. Let's just start. So I understand the potential benefits to the community, but there's also on the opposite risks. And this is the age-old problem, that of security versus privacy.
3:12:45 The question I have is not what, you know, our own Town of Mammoth Lakes would do with this, but, so first of all, what assurances do we really have that when these data are deleted after 30 days, they're gone forever? Because as we all know, nothing's ever really deleted. So, I'm not sure who the best person to answer that question is, but I'd like to start there. That sounds like a question for Mr. Cabrera.
3:13:18 Absolutely. Thank you for the question. And like the chief mentioned in his presentation, I guess a couple parts to this, if I may. It's important again to just point out that the data that's collected, right, it doesn't include names, social security numbers, nothing like that. It's purely what we call a vehicle fingerprint. So it's only make, model, color of a vehicle. Does it have a back rack, a bike rack? And that's as far as it goes.
3:13:48 Additionally, as the chief mentioned, the data is not sold or shared by flock. We do not own the data. It is owned by your city, by your police department solely. And you get to choose if you share it with a neighboring police department, neighboring sheriff's department, for example. And ultimately, as has been mentioned, it is stored in the AWS server and each data point or each image in this case.
3:14:18 Has what's called a time to live step. And so from the moment that that picture is taken, the moment that image is taken and stored, 30 days to the second from that moment, it gets hard deleted. And so I can certainly, you know, more than happy to schedule a time to talk to our folks internally to get more technical on the engineering side.
3:14:45 I'm on the community engagement side. It's definitely beyond my scope. But just I think speaking to the fact that there are all these various levels of separation kind of speaks to hopefully your question about guaranteeing that the data is hard deleted. So I hope that adds a little bit more context. I would appreciate follow up on that because it's a matter that's important to me.
3:15:14 Husband worked in technology and dealt with AWS. And I mean, let's be honest, once data are created, they exist, right? So I really do, I would like to understand that. And then I guess my next question is, right now we own our data, but suppose there's a different, there's a change in government where the federal government decides that they own any data they want to get their hands on. Yes, I...
3:15:44 You know, and Andy, maybe at this point you want to talk about the question I had asked you, but basically, you know, what recourse do we have as a small municipality that doesn't want our data, you know, going to other places? So Andy, do you want to talk about the recourse? Because I would like my colleagues to be able to hear that. Certainly. So California has a number of state laws that govern information that are relevant to this product.
3:16:14 There are, there's a set of state laws that was adopted in 2016 that limits how automated license plate reader data can be shared. So we have to comply with that. It can't be shared with any private entities. It can only be shared with government entities and even then there are restrictions. Beyond that, there are a series of laws that are not directly related to license plate readers but limit how
3:16:38 Local governments and the state government of California can cooperate with federal agencies who are seeking to do certain things like immigration enforcement. So if the federal government asked for the data, first of all, they'd have to have a legal reason for it. They can't subpoena it without suing the town. They can't just get a hold of it without having some mechanism to do that. But my suggestion would be that if we are faced with a demand from the federal government that we disclose the data,
3:17:07 I think the first call that we would make would be to the California Attorney General, which I think institutionally is strongly against the federal government getting certain types of data from California. So I think that we would find a receptive audience at the AG's office and could probably get some help at dealing with requests for data that might violate California law. Okay.
3:17:32 And I appreciate the presentation from our own police department. I know that you've done a very thorough analysis of this. I absolutely appreciate that. I just am very conscious of the fact that once data are created, that sometimes it gets out of our control. And so I guess my last question, and I just like further reassurance, so it's not that I'm saying you didn't cover this, but what other options?
3:18:02 Thought of every other option that could create the same kind of safety opportunities. And maybe not from a crime fighting standpoint, but from a safety standpoint of evacuations. I do feel like there must be other options that we could explore. So, you know, maybe if you could just add some more color around that, I'd be grateful. Yes, I could speak to, from our level, from the police department.
3:18:31 With this system, you can choose to allow other agencies to search your data. We are not going to do that. It's going to be shut off. Any request for any data, any license plate reads from our system, any search, is going to have to come from that investigating agency, that outside agency, accompanied by a written request. We want to know who you are, what agency you're with, and why you want this data.
3:19:00 Then it will then be reviewed by the chief of police or designee to see if it complies with our policy, doesn't violate any laws. And a report will be generated on our end to document that request and the subsequent release of any ALPR information. And in that case, they're just going to get the actual license plate, the image, and that's it. We're not going to do any investigation on that side. And then we'll also be doing...
3:19:29 Audits every year. We'll be pulling reads to make sure that all reads complied with policy and that any inquiries, that they were backed by a case number and a need to know. And there was actually a need to get this information as part of an investigation. And determine if there is an error, find out if it's a training error or if there is something malicious and we'll have to look into that. With regards to... That's definitely my question though, so my question is about the safety part.
3:19:58 That Chief Temeier also talked about, which is we have so many people in town and it's very useful to be able to know how many there are. And I understand there is a level of knowledge from an individual license plate, but are there other methods that would be, that we have explored? Because I want to make sure that we aren't going to the most, I don't have the word, but.
3:20:29 You know, sort of, we haven't gone to the most stringent method for our need. Like, for purpose. If one of our main needs, and that's what Chief Temeier said, was for us to understand how many people are in town that might have to evacuate, is this, have we tried to look at all other possibilities before we get to this one that does have, you know, pros and cons, significant pros and cons?
3:20:58 Council Member Webster, I'd like to address that. So a couple of years ago, if you know, we engaged Zone Haven. So Zone Haven really took a great snapshot of our community. It gives us the opportunity to, you know, perform pinpoint evacuations by sort of selecting an area. I'll say that one of the shortfalls of that program is it relies on census data.
3:21:26 It relies on algorithms to determine the number of people that may be present in a residence. All those items were configured by our teams, and this would have been now probably three years ago. So they're really approximations of who could be out there. There's nothing that we have seen, you know, when you talk about the data collection concerns, you would have to have that level of, I'll use the term intrusion.
3:21:55 And to really understand what's out there. So we don't have anything currently. We do have what we believe to be a good program for evacuating individuals. We just don't have a good program to know exactly what's out there. So Zone Haven has generally a number of people that could be in town. I think we put some seasonality into that depending upon the winter versus the summer.
3:22:22 But it's really macro data, right? It's nothing to do with specifics. Okay. All right. Thank you. I have some questions. Mr. Cabrera, this one's for you. How do you ensure faces are not captured? Yes. Thank you for the question. So the cameras are only looking for the vehicle, right? So our AI models are trained only to
3:22:56 Collect the information about the vehicle. Again, what we call the vehicle fingerprint is what we call it. So might there be, you know, if somebody is walking at the same time that the vehicle passes by and, you know, the image just happens to by chance take a picture of a person as well, that could theoretically happen.
3:23:24 The cameras are not looking for people, right? And also, it is only looking for the rear of a vehicle. So the cameras are not installed in any place or location where they're taking pictures of the front of a car, the front of a vehicle. They're installed so that they're only taking pictures from the rear of a vehicle. And again, it's only trained to look for vehicle information. It can't see into the vehicle. It doesn't...
3:23:52 It doesn't have any kind of filter whatsoever on people. So all it's looking for is information on the vehicle. Okay, thank you. How do these cameras work in the snow? So the trucking police department's using them, as well as departments in Wisconsin and other cold areas. If the plate's covered with snow, we're not going to be able to see it. We're not going to get it. We'll get an image of the car. We're not going to get the plate read.
3:24:24 They have built-in heaters to keep them clear, and that penguin pack ensures that, because we know that cold can drain batteries, that additional penguin pack designed for the cold weather will ensure they keep operating as the temperatures drop. One question I had was, well, they're solar powered, what if we don't see the sun for two weeks? Is the battery going to last long enough? And I was ensured absolutely that the batteries will last long enough.
3:24:50 Now, they're just as good as, you know, they're only as good as the visibility that they have. It's a blowing blizzard. I assume that can affect the ability to read a license plate, but for the most part with the cold, even if there's snow on the ground, we're still going to get good accurate reads. Okay.
3:25:08 And then let's say I have a lot of parking tickets or my vehicle has a lot of parking tickets. Would that be a reason to get flagged? Or are these looking for felony crimes that vehicles were involved in? Or what's the criteria for being flagged? Absolutely not. We're not going to be going after parking enforcement, parking tickets, registration, anything like that. Only for criminal investigations. And it can be a felony or a misdemeanor. If, for instance, we get a call of a...
3:25:36 A DUI driver just left a certain bar in town in this vehicle with this license plate. We can quickly enter in that license plate to let us know if that vehicle dings any of our cameras, hits any of our cameras, so we can respond to that area to conduct a DUI investigation. But we're not going to be going after parking tickets. We're not going to be going after unpaid registration.
3:25:57 We're not going to be going after vehicles that are subject to being towed because their registration hasn't been paid. It's going to be used for criminal purposes, for legitimate criminal investigations, not infractions. Those are infractions. Those require an officer to make the observation and issue a ticket to the person who actually owns and is operating that vehicle. And to answer your question, no. So it's not going to get flagged.
3:26:22 You have outstanding parking citations. Absolutely not. If you drive by an LPR and you have outstanding parking citations, your vehicle will be captured from the camera and the license plate will be captured, but there's no flagging at all of it. If you were involved in a crime and your vehicle got flagged and then we contacted you and found out that you had passed parking citations, at that point you may have to deal with it.
3:26:48 The ultimate reason for the contact would be the reason you were flagged, which would be a felony or a misdemeanor, some sort of crime or a missing person or something like that. Okay. And then it sounds like we won't be sharing the data that we'd be collecting. Is there anything that would change that, that we would share data with third parties or, I don't know, like the Freedom of Information Act or anything like that, like that this data would be available to?
3:27:18 I'll tackle that last one. We're prohibited by law from sharing it with any private party. So even if we get a Public Records Act request, we are not allowed to release it. Okay. Thank you. And to answer with us, so we will share, but only with a legitimate law enforcement request. We will not have open access to our system through other law enforcement agencies. Okay. But regarding the...
3:27:45 The information, and he touched on it, that basically this information is not subject to a public records request act. Okay. Thank you. So if I could, do you have some questions? No, I'm good. Okay. What if there's a warrant out for an arrest and that vehicle drives through this counter, is that going to trigger something?
3:28:11 If that vehicle, if the warrant's out for an individual, it's only tied to that person. If they have a warrant for arrest for a person and they know they drive that vehicle, whatever agency that's looking for that person can enter the vehicle into the database. Okay, so just give me an example. I got, I got a, I jaywalked in Santa Monica at seven o'clock in the morning and I got a ticket. I didn't pay it. It went to warrant.
3:28:40 I ended up getting arrested out in Palm Springs. You know, hey, you got a warrant out for your arrest. Is that, I mean, it sounds like it doesn't trigger things, but what if there's a warrant out? I mean, is that, is that, is it up to you guys to figure out which ones you're looking for? Is that, is that who's making the call? Yes, it's up to us to figure out and to what we enter in, what vehicles we enter into that, what's called a hot sheet. Okay. That we're looking for. Good. Next question, Forest Service.
3:29:07 We're all surrounded by federal public land. What happens if you flag a vehicle, it ends up on a federal road, then what happens? If there's flock out there, it would get a hit, but if there's no cameras out there, it's not going to get a hit. Well, no, no, but if something, you know, you identify somebody in town, and that person leaves town and ends up on...
3:29:30 On a forest service road, they're out in the forest service. What happens at that point? Like jurisdiction. Jurisdictional stuff, yeah. So here's a good example. With the catalytic converter theft, if that vehicle got hit with catalytic converter theft, what happened? Their pursuit ensued, right? Went out, scenic loop, and ended up going out onto a forest service road. And then they left the car and they fled the sea. There's no difference if I...
3:29:57 I was the one that made the observation of the vehicle driving, recognized it as the vehicle that was suspect to the catalytic converters. I initiated a traffic stop. The pursuit ensued. They went wrong way on the highway. They ended up going out to the Forest Service. We lost them, and they ditched the car on a Forest Service road. So what Flock would do, it's take me out of the picture. It would ping the vehicle. Hey, this is your vehicle that you're looking for.
3:30:26 The same thing would happen. So either we would meet up with the vehicle, we'd find the vehicle, we'd pursue the vehicle. We found the vehicle on Forest Service Road probably, I want to say a few hours later, and we still initiated the investigation as we would have initiated the investigation in town. Okay, so the flock would have to give you somebody to initiate an investigation in town.
3:30:51 Wherever the vehicle ends up, that gets in all the usual jurisdictional stuff you got to deal with because like the Forest Service has no law enforcement stuff. We've been talking about Mono County signing agreements with the Forest Service to be able to do things out there in case of fire. Okay. I'm just looking at the resolution. In my math, I'm pretty good at arithmetic. Eight license plate readers.
3:31:18 Then there's a number in here for a flat annual rate of $2,500. And then there's $500 times two. That adds up to a little bit more than I think what the ask is.
3:31:29 I can explain that. So the $500 times two is the analytics. So the two cameras that we would have analytics on, it's $500 a piece. The two cameras that we would have analytics on are inbound, outbound, 203. Let's see how that works. If we want to pursue additional analytics on other computers, it's going to be an additional $500 per, I'm sorry, not computers, cameras per camera. So for example, so those two $500 a piece. So what had happened when we got the quote from Flock,
3:31:59 And Ulysses, you may be able to correct me, but I believe it's, I can't do that math quick enough in my head, but $5,000 a camera, $5,000 a camera per year, and that includes the maintenance, replacement, and anything that happens to the camera flock would come out and replace it. But am I correct in saying $5,000 a camera? Approximately, yes. So each camera for law enforcement is about $3,500, and then I believe
3:32:28 All but two of the eight cameras will be installed on existing infrastructure. And so there are some costs for cameras that are installed on flock poles. I believe it's about $600, $700 per pole. For the cameras that are installed on existing infrastructure, there's no additional cost for any poles or anything. But there is that initial upfront cost for the first year that if you renew and continue for future years.
3:32:57 Those initial upfront costs, you don't have to pay them in the future. It's just per camera that you have to pay in the future. So the $500 for the two cameras, and I definitely need to pull up the quote. I do not have it in front of me, so I don't want to give you the wrong numbers. But $3,500 per camera for certain, plus the installation costs, plus the 500 times two.
3:33:26 I'm not the best at arithmetic either. Like I said, I would prefer to run it through. Yeah, that's okay. I think we may have to make it because that's not the information that's in the agenda items. We need to do a little bit of work on that. Finally, so if we do a one-year pilot, what is the minimum, okay, we like this thing. We want to do it for another year. Is it a five-year term? Is it a three-year term? Can we do it one year at a time? How does that work?
3:33:54 It's my understanding that after the one-year term, if we wanted to continue, I'm going off of what Truckee did. I know they did a one-year pilot. They brought the statistics back to council, and I believe they went into another two-year term after that. So I don't know. Maybe, Ulysses, you can answer that. Can you go one year by one year, or do you have to go into a two-year term after your one-year pilot? Yeah, so...
3:34:24 And I definitely am trying to get the right information from ourselves, folks. Again, that's outside of my scope. But going back to the actual price of the cameras, it's actually $3,000 per camera. I said $3,500, so the correct number per camera is $3,000 per camera. And then we're waiving the $650 installation fee for the eight cameras if the contract is signed before June 30th.
3:34:53 So that might be where there's some differences in the numbers there. And then as far as the term for the contract, we can agree on any term. It's a year, two years, right? So maybe after a year, if you want to bring this back to the council and evaluate how effective the system has been and see where things stand, then you can renew for another year. You can do two years from the get-go. So there's some flexibility there as well.
3:35:22 Okay. Thank you. Other questions? Questions or comments from the public? Seeing none, I'll bring it back for deliberations or motion or whatever we want to do. There's value to this. But I got some questions. And I think it makes sense if, because I know Chris's husband has been involved in some very high-end tech stuff. I would, if that's appropriate, to have
3:36:01 Arrange a meeting with, just get some feedback from about what all that looks like. I'd also like, again, a lot of numbers are kind of thrown around here. I just want to make sure that whatever we're voting on is what, you know, is what is actually needed. It's per the deal. I'm interested in, I think there's some value to this. I have some, look, there's a creepy factor to it as well. And there's something that, you know, we are making this decision on that line.
3:36:31 Privacy and Public Safety, and it's something that needs to be taken pretty seriously. So I'd love to get some information, a meeting between Flock and Chris's husband, and with you guys as well, and really sort of vet this thing out a little bit, and let's just get the numbers clarified, and let's kind of see where we're at. That's me. Amanda? I guess I echo, like, I feel that we need to balance privacy with public safety, and, you know, I do feel like the cost,
3:37:03 For me, we've just spent
3:37:38 About an hour and 15 on a potential $25,000 contract, which is a bit absurd. Also, in a world where all of us have games on our phones, where we had to give permission for that game to get our photos and our location and our everything else, to worry about privacy on a license plate reader in Mammoth, I don't find that scary.
3:38:05 Big Brother's going to look at us and Big Brother already knows. I drive down the road and it shows up on Google Maps how fast I'm going in somebody else's car. I haven't given permission. That's just the way it is. So I'm not afraid of this. I'm not doing anything so egregious that it's going to affect me. I'm not going to, you know, go down the street and shoot John or something. I might shoot back. Yeah. So I really have at 25.
3:38:33 So the only question would be,
3:39:02 Just to get the numbers right, because again, that should take five minutes. I think this thing with Chris and her husband sitting down and getting, that's not staff time. That's just like, how is this integrated with AWS? How does this work? Where does their cloud structure look like? All the rest of it. A little bit more due diligence. I don't need anything more than that. And Bill, I just have to respectfully disagree. It's your prerogative to do what you want with your personal data on your devices.
3:39:33 But we're doing this on behalf of anyone who drives into our town. And that's a bigger responsibility that we need to take seriously. That's fine. So what I'm hearing here is that council would like a bring back after Chris's husband gets to talk to somebody from Flock. Sure. I'm not going to make a motion. You know what? That sounded a little dismissive. Like, John, I'm not sure that we need to draft somebody else. I am happy to prepare the questions and talk to somebody from Flock.
3:40:03 That's my time, so I don't see why anyone should be offended. I'm not wasting anybody's time then. It's my time and it's Flock's time. But I think these are serious matters and I think we should take them seriously. Well, I'm definitely not seeing a majority to move this forward tonight. So we will table this and staff can talk to each of us as they do independently and figure out if they want to bring this back or move it forward.
3:40:34 Gentlemen, have we given you sufficient? Yes, I appreciate that. Thank you. Yes. And I thank you all very much. Moving on. Want to take a break? What's that? Do you want to take a break or are you good? I'm good. I want to get out of here. We've just been gone for quite a while. Okay. I shouldn't say that. Does anybody at the dais want a break? Because we can certainly take one. I'm good. Thank you. Okay. Chris, you're good? I'm good.
3:41:09 Okay. Moving on then to Mr. Lawson and scoping for Reds Meadow Valley Recreation renovation project. Hello, Town Council. Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Another topic in which I would like to engage you all as it relates to public comment that the Forest Service is seeking related to some Reds Meadow Campground improvements.
3:41:39 Obviously outside of the town boundary directly, but something we are all very, very vested in. I want to be very clear here related to my analysis and some of the things that I recommend on here. Admittedly, some of these items are probably outside of the scope for public scoping for a campground improvement, but I did this intentionally because I would like you all to
3:42:09 As much as possible, think very holistically when the forest comes out with these recommendations for improvement or improvement projects in general. A lot of these recreation items or suggestions do not live in a vacuum. So how can we think about these things, maybe not just as an individual campground improvement, but improvements to
3:42:36 How people move and how people interact within these campgrounds as well. I also know that some of these recommendations, not everyone might feel this way. And I think again that that is a good thing. It produces dialogue on these topics and really gets everybody thinking about what's going to be most effective for our campers, for our locals and for our visitors alike. Now with all of that said,
3:43:06 I provided the documents in terms of what the Inyo National Forest is suggesting for these campground improvements. I think what they are suggesting are great. These campgrounds haven't had a lot of love over the years, and I think they need improvement. But with all of that said, I think we can take it a bit of a step further. Number one, PCT hikers and the fact there used to be a shower down in Reds Meadow. I think that would be very advantageous to either utilize the existing sort of hot spring infrastructure,
3:43:36 And for all of you who don't know what happened with that, it basically went into disrepair because it was not maintained, formed a bunch of black mold in the shower, and it had to be closed. So either utilizing that existing infrastructure or creating a different type of shower infrastructure for those PCT hikers through hikers and folks like that. I think that would be a wonderful amenity. This one may be a bit controversial because not a lot of people like pavement.
3:44:04 But paving roads and campground spurs. I think that has both positives and negatives. The negative being that, like anything, paving requires maintenance. And if you let it go, it will be often worse than dirt.
3:44:20 I view the advantage of pavement being the soil is very pumicey down there, much greater mobility for maybe folks with disabilities, folks towing those very, very large RVs who then have to rip around the dirt along with resource protection. The forest has always had difficulty saying
3:44:39 You can park here, you can't park here, but often paving locations, you can say parking is allowed on pavement only, and then you have some more guns, so to speak, to enforce some of that. Now, my other two suggestions.
3:44:55 That I had on here, I think really tie into what I said earlier. Thinking really holistically about the valley, about these campgrounds and trying to create the best experience humanly possible. I do again readily admit that these two may be outside of the scope of this specific public comment related to the campgrounds. But again,
3:45:19 You all had this in your packet and are able to read it. I'll just go through it very briefly. Creating these connections between the Vista and the Reds Meadow Valley soft surface trails for folks who would be recreating down there in a soft surface capacity and doing the same with hard surface trails. I was speaking to Hayes the other day and
3:45:40 Due to costs, there is not going to be bike lanes in the Reds Meadow Road. Tons of people are going to want to bike down there. You know, that road, while once it does get repaired, will be amazing. It's still very curvy, very steep, and maybe not the best place to have those two things occurring at the same time. But again, you had my recommendations in the packet, and please let me know what you think. Let me know if you would like to comment, and of course, I will draft a letter on your behalf.
3:46:09 Any questions? Questions? I have some suggestions, but, you know. Suggestions works too. Okay. I know you've got thought. Do you want to go first? I certainly can. That would be fun. Do you want to take public comment? We can take public comment. Sorry, I was in my pajamas and I ran out because your Zoom is not working. Just FYI, so there's no way for anyone watching that can raise their hand or talk. Just.
3:46:45 Anyway, so I'm talking for two people. Number one, I'm going to read a statement from Bobby Tanner because I was watching. I started looking at the agenda. I was on town council when we were voting about this. It has gone so sideways. So I let Bobby know it was on the agenda. So his first question is, who is OOR? When the Forest Service lost the camp,
3:47:13 The Red's Campground Shower and Postpile was losing their campground. The Forest Service and the NPS asked me to invest. Red's Meadow. It wasn't even his. It was his dad's at the time. He would be allowed to charge for showers to recoup my investment. Having showers at the resort drives business to the resort. Red's Meadow is suffering extreme.
3:47:39 Severe losses due to the road construction project. Losing the business derived from the shower business will further add to the decline of a long-standing small business. And so that was Bobby. So now I'm going to take, what do I have, three minutes? So what I want to add is I have worked on and off for Red's Meadow for over 30 years. Started out when I was about younger than you.
3:48:09 You're the one person who's been around here. Yes, that road is troublesome. What you guys are turning it into now is a travesty. To take those showers away, I deal every summer with the PCT hikers. That is my job. You guys are working amongst yourselves. You're hearing that. I've been working amongst these people. I've been telling the PCT, the JMT hikers, I've been taking care of them for the last three summers.
3:48:39 Thanks to this year with the closing of the road, which wasn't in there, but I guess it made more financial sense to close it down, which is horrendous in itself. So I think that you guys really, no, Rob, don't be talking to someone when I'm making a comment about this. I want you guys to listen to me. This is important. Reds Meadow Road is so longstanding. It went from dirt, it's paved. Yes, it needs
3:49:07 Work on it, but you guys continually, I am so embarrassed that I voted for this project to move forward because what it has turned into now, you guys want to turn it into something that it is not. Showers, Forest Service, they didn't take care of the showers then. You think the Forest Service is taking care of it now? They're not. And I'm probably burning a lot of bridges, but they are not taking care of our lands.
3:49:34 Thank you for your time. Thank you, Cleland. So a few things.
3:50:09 I could go on for an hour and a half on the history of the Reds Meadows Road and what went on down there. Originally, if we go back to my childhood, the showers were run by the Reds Meadows Resort, not by the Forest Service. The Forest Service took them over and ran them into a great decline, and we lost that asset. Not only is it a good place for people to shower, but it was also sort of a...
3:50:37 A novelty that you were showering with naturally heated water from the earth. I mean, it was a beautiful thing. I would have no problem with Bobby taking it over and charging some for the showers. It would still be a great asset. So the shower thing, that could be worked out. As far as the paving, all the lakes, not all.
3:51:03 Because there's a couple that still remain. All the lakes basin campgrounds used to be great, what were called semi-primitive campgrounds. Somebody came up with the idea that they needed to be paved to protect the environment. They needed to be paved to get rid of the dust hazards. And they are now great urban campgrounds. They are parking lots. If you have an RV, you can't park in your little space and have a private. You are parked in a parking lot.
3:51:30 They are no longer semi-primitive. They no longer fit the character of what I believe Mammoth is. So I would not like to see those campgrounds paved. I think that it's a mistake. If you don't want to get your car dirty, go to one of our Lakes Basin campgrounds and have an urban camping experience. That was my biggest issue, I suppose, was the camping. A couple of other things.
3:52:00 I didn't find, and maybe I'm just not reading it correctly. They talk about reducing the footprint of every campground but keeping the camp spaces. I don't know what that means for the compaction of camping and, again, going from a semi-primitive experience. There is a lot of people, myself included, that can no longer go into the backcountry. But to go to Minaret Falls Campground or Upper Soda Springs Campground where you've got a large camping spot all to yourself is a very similar experience.
3:52:30 So, it's creating...
3:52:57 Problems with people parking where they don't belong and everything else because we don't want them parking on the dirt. So I would love for us to comment on we don't want to see a reduction in campsites. We don't want to see a reduction in the size of the campsites. And we cannot afford as a community to lose parking that is already available to those that want those experiences.
3:53:26 We've lost too much of that already. So that's a real quick take on this. I won't go on any longer. I agree with what you're saying, Bill. And I also, you know, I guess I question paving the camping spots if the Forest Service is known for not doing upkeep on there. Like, is that a good idea? Or, I mean, it seems like dirt would be better than concrete that's not being kept up with.
3:53:59 Okay, thank you both. So, a couple thoughts. Perhaps a little bit of a tactical approach to how the comments go to them. The shower thing, I think, is a great idea, however that would happen. I'm thinking at a high level. If it's, you know, figure that out. That's a great idea. The paving of roads, if the concern is dust,
3:54:25 If the concern is some kind of an impact from the current situation, perhaps frame the comment in those terms, right? To say there is an issue with dust or off-road parking, please, you know, Forest Service, do something to mitigate those types of impacts without making like, you know, a specific infrastructure suggestion because they get crazy when they hear that stuff. On the connections between Minaret Fest and Reds Meadow Valley, I know you're kind of out of time.
3:54:54 The Devil's Postpile Management Plan has language in there that specifically, it's not route or corridor specific, but it's specific about that connectivity. And that's something that we could quote from to say, Devil's Postpile Management Plan, National Park Service Plan, use that as a rationale to Mammoth Lakes Trail System. You guys could go over there and start, you know, doing some alignments or something. On the valley floor,
3:55:22 There are system routes. So I would point to those and say, you may not be aware, District Ranger, you haven't been here that long, but there are a number of soft surface system already in the forest surface system routes that exist there that should be elevated and articulated as part of the NEPA analysis to provide the type of connectivity that you're talking to. And then you could use it as an example, this could be a
3:55:51 Maybe not a paved MUP, but a, you know, a DG, you know, some kind of a wider thing. It's not going to be as expensive to connect, to restore, restore the connectivity that once existed down in the Redsamento Valley. And due to the failure of the Forest Service to maintain all those trails for the last 20 or 30 years, let's bring those things back to life. And perhaps the town would be a willing partner or something like that.
3:56:18 My thoughts. One last thing on this, because a great point has been brought up about non-system trails. There is a myriad of incredibly well-used trails throughout the national forest system here in our area that aren't recognized, therefore not maintained, therefore create a larger environmental issue than if they were simply put in the system and somehow maintained.
3:56:43 Whether that is through a partnership with MLR or Mono County or Madera County or whatever that is. So in our comments, I would love to put that in Reds and even outside of Reds, there are trails that have not been officially recognized that need to be officially recognized to tie this all together. Agree 100%. The nice little thing with this is that there already are existing. There are some. Yeah.
3:57:13 Aren't connected. Well, no, we can talk about this over a couple drinks, but the routes, I've been down there and scoped all this stuff up. I would think, Lawson, and if you need some data, we can help you with that. There are existing system trails that would connect all of this stuff. They're already on the books, they're already in the system. They just need to be, they need a little TLC, a little, you know, a little dusting up and you'd have the things that might work for you.
3:57:44 Just a personal point. I have actually pushed someone in a wheelchair into Devil's Postpile. The only part of the trail I had real issue with was not the pumice part. It was the part where they put down gravel, basically, through what is the meadow there that used to be a parking lot. You cannot push a wheelchair very well through gravel. So their attempt to fix something created a much larger issue than it solved.
3:58:15 Well, thank you, and I really appreciate the passion and engagement on this topic, and I will draft a letter on Council's behalf and work with the Town Manager on that and ensure feelings are reflected. Thank you. If you need any follow-up support, just, yeah, please reach out. Much appreciated. Chris, any comments on this one? No, I think my colleagues have covered it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Moving on then to 9.3, Fiscal Year 24-25 Tentative Budget.
3:58:49 Tentative manager recommended. Thank you, Mayor. I will get through this as quickly as possible. I'm going to share my screen. Hold, please. There we go. Okay. Yeah, so this, as you know, as we go through the budget process, there's a number of different presentations that occur throughout our item. Tentative manager recommended typically has, you know, the bulk of everything that has been done thus far.
3:59:42 I kind of changed it up a little bit. This isn't really a comprehensive review. It will take us through changes that have occurred since the last presentation to Council and then we start to do a little bit of a deeper dive into some of the restricted funds. Our next budget recommendation will include the full budget including four areas by which we have not yet talked that are still under analysis and those would be
4:00:09 Housing Now initiatives, capital project write-ups, vehicle replacement, and the garage building. So we're doing some analysis in all of those areas, and those will be the final budget elements. But this sort of ties up some of the really restricted fund elements to talk about. So very first and foremost, talking about general fund revenue changes that have occurred.
4:00:34 Really very, very minor adjustments have been made. I think we had a good opportunity to get through a lot of the first elements of our presentation in the primary that were really well vetted. We made a small adjustment that identified itself during a review of the restricted funds that since we were not going to be operating the theater this particular fiscal year.
4:00:59 Because it's under construction and we'd be building the MAC that we did not need to transfer from Measure U into general fund as additional revenue. So that's a reduction of just $15,000. So really the same numbers, no other adjustments to revenue expectations. Just to remind folks where we are, our major fund revenue elements, you know, we kept TOT fairly low this year with just a $500,000 increment to $18,000.
4:01:27 0.5 million for the year. And some of the other components just incrementally changing, but again, nothing has changed since the last presentation to you. And I want to call out certified properties fee of 1.35 million is a brand new fee, came from the STR Advisory Committee work and Council's adoption of some of those recommendations, really tying to a fee for the
4:01:55 Each unit that is run as an SDR is $250 a unit. And this particular number is both a $250 a unit that will occur for mid-year next year, January renewals, and then 50% of that, so a prorated amount to start July 1st when that program is fully launched. And so that's why that's a little bit higher. Absent that number or that new revenue stream, our TOT number would have had to go up.
4:02:22 You know, roughly to accommodate that, you know, about $2 million instead of the $500,000. So really, really important to note that as we go through this process. Giving you a graphical representation of the revenue and where that flows through, you can see the large blue item being the TOT. That's the bulk of what we bring in. Property tax is secondary to that. We collect about 4% of property taxes collected.
4:02:51 In our region, so that's part of our incorporation. Looking at the expenditure side of things, some minor adjustments, and a lot of this came through a review of vehicle replacement. There was a lot of things going on in vehicle replacement last year. As you know, we were accelerating repayments for debt that we had on that particular item. We've gone through and done an extensive review of the number of vehicles that are out there.
4:03:19 We had a fairly significant impact on our overall vehicle charges for the year. So that's what you're seeing here is we had
4:03:49 The general fund impact in those various departments, and then we had transfers out that covers gas tax and airport. Those also had a significant reduction in charge for the year. So it's going to cause a little bit of whipsaw within our funds, but I think we're, I bumped up the debt service payment by $100,000. That offsets that impact a little bit, but also puts more money into
4:04:17 That debt service payment for the future bond. So just kind of covers that year one a little bit better. But in total, we have right now a little bit of excess revenue over expenditure. I think it was roughly $70,000 off the top of my head. And that will likely be either flow through to the end. It was reserved potentially for an impact tonight on the flock system, which is not in the budget.
4:04:46 Certainly we'll not put it in the budget as we move forward, but we'll probably end up with a planned, I think $71,000 or something along those lines, increase of fund balance. Giving you a graphical representation of that expenditure, that $32,781,587. Talk a little bit about gas tax. The most significant changes that occurred in gas tax, again, were vehicle replacement charges.
4:05:19 You know, you can see there the impact of, it's $510,000 less than it was in a prior year from a budget standpoint. And, you know, we've had various other changes based upon how much of an impact the snow year is this year in sort of a baseline average that we did for snow, which was about $1.5 million, I think, yeah, $1,550,000.
4:05:45 As opposed to last year's $2,400,000. So that $850,000 reduction in revenue is designed to kind of get rid of that whipsaw effect. Quick question. Yes, sir. The state, you know, the nation is wrestling with gas tax revenue issues. Is that going to creep into this, do we think, or are we going to be sufficiently insulated? Well, it's going to creep into it in the fact that
4:06:15 More and more cars that are going electric, this entire process by which taxes are collected for roads and such are really tied to the fuel usage. And so they're having to reevaluate a system by which utilization is determined for all vehicles. I'm just wondering if that's something we should be advocating for. I mean, if that's one of those things we should, we've got somebody in Sacramento, a very specific thing, look, don't start messing with that. I just...
4:06:42 Yeah, I mean, so I guess to answer your question, what I believe will happen is a way to provide a charge for an individual that has a car that doesn't use gas to pay for those impacts to the roads.
4:06:58 In the same vein, it would pay for our snow removal, those types of things. I think that's happening. I think that's the right thing to do. It's got to generate that revenue. So if they figure that out, then this program won't change. Yeah, it'll change a little bit. The source will be a little bit different. But yeah, those calculations are forthcoming, I'm quite certain. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Yep. But what I was trying to show here is, you know, we've had those adjustments in the revenue expectation. Those are really...
4:07:27 Me trying to get a baseline average, we will have some things go higher or lower depending upon the snow year, like for example this year. Our expenses are still fairly high because apparently all the snow storms happened on the weekends, so we had a lot of overtime associated with that. But quite literally, every weekend. No, no, that is a thing. Why does it rain and snow every weekend? Yeah. But that's really impactful when you have people that work Monday through Friday and then you ask them to stay all weekend.
4:07:55 We did have, even though despite this year being, I'll say, slightly less than average in my seat of the pants analysis, the cost is still quite high. But you're seeing that in both the revenue side, from my budget expectations, that will transfer out to assessment district for snow removal. Those are slightly less in the expenditure columns you see down below.
4:08:18 And so we're balanced on this. I always kind of balance it with transfers from the general fund. So we're balanced at $5,264,000 for our gas tax. And so you can kind of see just how much we spend, you know, between snow removal and street maintenance on a typical year. Getting into Measure R. So we had some significant things we were trying to do with Measure R this year.
4:08:46 I went through, if you look at the sales tax number, we're at $2 million. That's up $500,000 from prior year estimates, and that's really based on where we've been really hitting that mark and plus some in the last couple of years. I think we were at $2.6 in our actuals for the year before last when we had that big winter. But measure our sales tax is really affected by visitation, so I felt $2 million was a good average number, so we increased that.
4:09:15 Fairly significantly this year. The other expenses that are present there, there's only minor adjustments to those transfers out, and again, these were all approved by MLR's board, who's the governing body for recommendations to this. We did make an adjustment to the Office of Outdoor Recreation Coordinator position. That was previously not funded by Measure R.
4:09:40 But based upon the activity of that particular individual and the amount of work in the recreation arena versus the arts and culture and transportation side of U, it makes more sense that the bulk of that be paid out of Measure R. So I moved it over from U to R this year. And frankly, because Measure U has got some significant impacts as well as limited ability to generate additional revenue, which we'll talk about here shortly.
4:10:07 We did have a one-time allocation request that, you know, was approved by the MLR board, which is $100,000 to the Sharps Trailhead construction cost. If you remember a previous presentation that I gave, that is coupled with a $50,000 general fund contribution to that program, and really it was providing for contingency on the project that's primarily funded by SNC grant.
4:10:35 At about $950,000, so we wanted to have revenues just north of $1.1 million. And there's fairly good contingency in there of about $80,000, but that was a good contribution from Measure R. CRC financing, that's an annual debt service payment that's covered by Measure R, $610,000. That fluctuates mildly year over year. But based on that,
4:11:00 That look, our annual operating expense, we should have a positive change in fund balance of about $580,000, $574,000 to be exact. So measure ours healthy in generating additional fund balances. And in the staff report, I provided a kind of a detailed analysis that showed last year's fund balance, changes in that, what we anticipate they are year-to-date.
4:11:29 A lot of that work was done really to look at what available funds are out there. And so staff report will tell you exactly what those balances are. And there's a fair amount in measure R to allocate. To the right of the screen, you see measure R trails. That's a separate fund. That's in fund 215. Its only source of revenue is a transfer in from typically it's fund 216. In the past, we've also done transfers from general fund.
4:11:55 And the purpose of this fund is really to accumulate larger pots of money to do larger program adjustments to trails, primarily in construction. So we've done allocations to that in the past. This year there's no recommendation for that. Simply the general, the normal allocation of $300,000 from Fund 216 and most of that is tied up in labor.
4:12:19 With a little bit of contractual services and expenses, but we kind of budget for the full expenditure of that each year. Measure U, as I talked about that earlier, there was some slight adjustments in the revenue there. I think we went from $880,000 to $923,000. That's really based upon, again, trends have been higher, certainly affected by the number of people in town utilizing those utilities. So that's the primary driver on that. That has a consistent...
4:12:49 A set of annual expenses with the programming provided to different agencies based on arts and culture, transit and those types of things at 225. That application has come into MLR and they are reviewed and provided on an annual basis. I have a detailed list of who receives those annually or at least was for the last allocation for 2425, which is this funding cycle. I do note the
4:13:20 Changes that I talked about earlier, that reduction of $50,000 for the Office of Outdoor Recreation Coordinator went from $75 to $25. We removed Edison Hall Operations, that was $15,000 because it's closed for the year. We removed events contract processing, that's something that the town, you know, we have to provide contracts for each person who receives the programming funding. Those contracts are designed to outline exactly what's expected for the receipt of those funds.
4:13:50 We did that. We're going to absorb that within the general fund. We're just simply not impacting Measure U for that because as you see, Measure U has got a bit of a spend this year planned. Audit services standard. And so we end up with an equipment replacement. We had a couple thousand dollars in there, and we simply took that out as well. Again, based on the impact we have planned for Measure U for 24-25.
4:14:18 Then we had some one-time expenses. In the staff report, you'll see an estimation of fund balance, both as it stood at the close of last fiscal year, but how it has generated across this fiscal year so we can get an impact change in fund balance to know what we had available. That was critical for Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board to really make a decision on whether they had the funding available.
4:14:47 to allocate to these one-time projects. We were asking for a total of a million dollars to be provided for construction of the MAC. We're going to do that in two ways. Typically, we have an operational set aside of $300,000. This would have reflected that in the normal operating expenses for Measure U this year, but since I had redirected that expense at the same amount,
4:15:17 To an actual expense for construction. I put it in the one-time section. But the monies we would typically go to the operating allocation are going to go to construction. And then we had a planned use of fund balance of $700,000 from prior year's fund balances. That makes up the total million dollars allocation to MAC construction.
4:15:40 The debt service for Measure U, as part of the debt structure that we're developing for both the Civic Center and the acquisition of the land that Mammoth Lakes Foundation is proposing to sell to the town, we have about $4.5 million in that debt structure, which would be the purchase price of the land. The $180,000 sort of represents a couple of things. It's a portion of the contribution from
4:16:08 So that's the two elements that came into play with
4:16:36 Where the $180,000 came from, it's something that we felt it could sustain as far as Measure U's revenues that are generated. With the million dollars that we have up there, you take $700,000 of that out, that $596,000 change in fund balance, negative change in fund balance, we would still have some money being generated annually through Measure U with both the $180,000 and that $300,000 allocation for operating.
4:17:05 Continuing to go on. And that would be with no real adjustments to revenue. So I felt that was a good number to use. I think it's an appropriate level of distribution of cost for that debt service. And, you know, it was important to remain in there. Giving you a little bit of a summary, talking about, you know, the requests that we had this year, you know, both from Measure U and Measure R up there, changes that we, if you will. And
4:17:37 I wanted to kind of also add in here since we do a lot of, there's been a lot of discussion within these restricted funds about the MAC funding. So I provided, you know, what are the breakdown sources, the timing in which the Town Council and Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board have allocated funding to the MAC construction project and exactly, you know, where they're located in. So those fund 300 items up there above.
4:18:03 The current balance of allocated fund balance at $1.8 million. The two requests for a total of a million dollars. You end up with Measure U funded contributions to MAC to be just over $4.4 million. So $4.4 million is $70,000. I often get asked about the contributions from Measure R and Measure U to the Office of Outdoor Recreation. As was stated earlier in the public...
4:18:32 Comment about what was OOR, that is the Office of Outdoor Recreation. That contribution, really, that department is funded primarily out of the general fund, but we end up, well, primarily it's about a split, if you can see on this chart. Total cost of the staffing is $415,940. We're receiving about $225,000.
4:18:58 The airport, we've had a couple of adjustments this year primarily around the capital projects.
4:19:27 And then the general fund transfer in, slight increases in that total revenue expected is about $887,000 higher than last year, primarily again in grant funding. This is one of those where we have an operating account and then we have a capital projects account within the same fund, so there's a lot more variability than you see typically in a fund, but what I have down below is the expenditures by category and you'll see
4:19:57 Really labor cost, vehicle maintenance, all that stuff remains pretty flat with slight increases in labor cost and keeping those expenditures about $60,000 higher than they were last year. But the bulk of those changes again are that $746,000 in grant funding which would go to capital improvement projects. Looking at the operational budget, primarily
4:20:20 Based on labor, we don't have a lot of people out there, but we also don't have a lot of expenditures out there, so that's why that percentage looks fairly high. And within the staff report, I had a number of diff account adjustments for the year that talked about balances that are available in those funds, as well as the assessment districts. Those have been coming to you via annual reports from MBS and recommendations from staff.
4:20:50 But they do tie up into our general budget presentation. So they are in the staff report. They are not on my presentation for the evening. So I will pause for any questions. Questions for Rob? Amanda? John? The full Monty shows up when? 619. Okay. Chris?
4:21:26 Is there a chance that we could get the 619 budget a little early? Because it usually comes out like Thursday night, right? For the next Wednesday? That's true, yeah. I mean, that's fine. I just want to make sure I have enough time with it because, you know, we've been through and we've really spent time on the revenue side, but, you know, I just want to make sure I have time to dig in.
4:21:54 Yeah, it's a large presentation. It's, I mean, the staff report itself is probably going to be 60 to 70 pages. So recognize that that's pretty challenging. It's something that takes a bit of time to put together, but I will certainly seek to get that out sooner rather than later for you. You know what? Don't rush it. I'll just, you know, it's just good for us to know that that weekend is when we need to be ready to spend a fair bit of time. So that's good. Yeah, I'd rather have you.
4:22:22 Spend the time and have it the way you want. Okay. Thank you. Nothing from me. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Moving on now to council member reports. Chris, let's start with you. You got anything for us? Nothing that comes to mind. Thank you. Amanda? I'll pass. Thanks. Unfortunately, I missed the Eastern Sierra Community Housing meeting on Monday because the...
4:22:56 Three schools in town had a choir performance. So, unfortunately, I missed. So, I don't have anything to report. You made a good decision. John? I was anesthetized. You were, yeah. Yeah, twice. I visited John in the hospital. That's part of my... Was that you? Yeah. Yeah, well, unfortunately, I was there for other business. Yeah, yeah, we... And you were there at the same time, yes.
4:23:22 Actually, didn't we all attend a joint council supervisors meeting on the 21st? We certainly did. We sure did. And had a good conversation. And for me, that's it. So at this point, I will, it's not adjourned, but we will go into closed session. Read the agenda item. What's that? Oh, yeah, read it. Read it. Got it. Got it. It's getting late.
4:23:53 Conference with legal counsel, existing litigation, name of case, Snow Creek 7 Condominium Owners Association and Mammoth Lake Coalition for Responsible Planning, LLC versus Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, Town of Mammoth Lakes Town Council and Town of Mammoth Lakes Planning and Economic Development Commission, case number 24UCM48. Thank you all.
4:24:29 I just wanted to update you guys on that. What are you guys?