TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2025

Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board

at 18:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

203 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:46 Okay, good evening, everybody. We'll call to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Board Member Brian DeAndrea will attend this meeting remotely from the following address at 1,000 Corporate Point, Suite 200, Culver City, California, 90230. And with that, Angie will take roll call, please. President Hodges. Present. Vice President Barksdale.

3:20 Treasurer Nuttall, Board Member Stapp? Present. Board Member Kreitz? Here. Board Member Perkins? Present. Board Member Steenstra? Board Member Steenstra, can you hear us? I'm not Steenstra, I'm sorry. Why am I saying Steenstra? Board Member DeAndrea, I apologize. I'm looking ahead of me, can you hear us? Thank you so much, I apologize for that. And it looks like Board Member Rice? Here. And Board Member...

4:01 Here, thank you. Vice President Barksdale, I should say. Thank you. Terrific. So we will have a quorum. We'll move on to item two of the agenda, public comments. This is the established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any manner that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public's desire to speak on a matter appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may be considered.

4:32 May be submitted to the Executive Director at Patricia at ESCHHousing.org or clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov. Before or during the meeting may be made in person in Suite Z today or by raising your hand on Zoom. And it looks like we have someone at the podium. Would you please introduce yourself and we'll take your comments. Good evening. Happy New Year's. It's Billy Stade.

4:59 I wanted to make some public comments about the last meeting, December 2nd. Hopefully you guys have received my email over the holiday. And so I want to commend Eric and Patricia for doing a very professional and thorough job helping me through the process. There were some questions I had regarding the meeting I wasn't really prepared for, like I said in the letter. The Cal Home, the HED,

5:31 office opens tomorrow, and I had reached out to Habitat for Humanity, to the director who has administered these programs before, and she told me to reach out directly to the HCD. I did actually go to their Southern California office, but that was redirected to the main director in Sacramento, and so I...

5:56 I assume starting tomorrow we can start getting some information to better understand the program and see if there's an opportunity to see the project to a fruitful outcome. So I just request the board to reconsider my application and find a way to get some more information on it.

6:26 Okay. Great. Anybody have any questions for Billy? All right. Well, terrific. We'll encourage you to continue to work with our staff, and if there's a need to bring anything back to the board for a decision, we can agendize that for next month's meeting. But, yeah, hopefully maybe there's a way, a path to a solution that'll solve, you know, be a good resolution for all parties involved.

6:53 I appreciate that very much. As you know, we're kind of breaking ground with this thing. It's like the first, I guess, sort of real, you know, working case. Yeah, yeah, of course. And, you know, so, yeah, absolutely. I commend you all and thank you very much. Thank you. I guess I'm a little, no, nothing for you, I'm sorry, but I'm just amongst the board and for staff. That feels a little confusing to me because I thought there was pretty.

7:15 Clear board direction at the last meeting not to pursue the program. And so what I hear you saying, Tom, is a little different from that. So I don't want to confuse staff. So I want to make sure staff understands what they're doing. It sounds like, Bill, you're working directly with HCD and trying to get some answers. But I don't know that that involves our staff at this point, given the staff direction we gave.

7:40 at the last meeting. And I'm not sure if that was a vote, if we took a vote on that or if it was just staff direction. That's my understanding that that hasn't changed up to right now. Okay. Well, you know, again, I guess if there's, you know, incidental time that's helpful at your discretion, you guys can decide whether, you know, there's something there that is workable and leave it up to you guys.

8:09 I guess, you know, it was what we had said, I think, at the last meeting, that we didn't want to spend a considerable amount of time on it, staff time on it. Yeah, I don't want to send mixed messages to Billy or staff or the public about what the direction of the board was. And I suspect there's very limited extra time on your plate. So, I'm just a word of caution and concern.

8:36 And I know this item is an agenda, so we can't get too deep into it, but that was just a confusing rebuttal on my part. Excuse me, can you step up to the podium, please? Thank you. Just to kind of put into perspective that I did start the process, and honestly, it was more difficult than a college course at UCLA to get through that program, and I actually thought it was a foregone conclusion last meeting.

9:10 That said, as I did, I was instructed to spend money, so I did pay for an appraisal, and I did pay for a survey, because I thought this was a foregone deal. And we didn't, if you leave the letter, we did not deliberate if the program, if those, what was deliberated on wasn't actually the program itself. So I just like the opportunity to bring that forward and take a fresh look at it. Thank you.

9:37 And then from the minutes from last time, it says staff was given direction to not move forward with Mr. Stade's loan application at this time and to request additional information from the state regarding this program. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. Any further public comments? I see no comments at this time. Okay. Hearing none, we'll move on then to agenda item three, consent agenda item 3.1, approval of the minutes from the December.

10:14 Second, 2024, regular board meeting. Does anybody care to make a motion to adopt? I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. Second. Any further discussion? Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? I will abstain. Board Member DeAndrea?

10:50 Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Then we'll move on to agenda item four, policy matters. Item 4.1, the board will elect a new president. Great. Yeah, so this item, we went through this process last year around the same time. This is part of our bylaws as an organization that we will elect a president, a vice president, and a treasurer.

11:23 And so these three items in a row will be selecting those individuals to do that. And so the board should receive any nominations or make any nominations and then vote in favor of that board member. I nominate Tom Hodges as president. I'll second the motion. Boom, was that a motion?

11:52 I mean, I'm happy to continue in the role, but if somebody else is so inclined to want to take their turn at it, I'm happy also to, I'm not saying I necessarily have to be the president or anything. I'm happy to have you the president. Okay, well, I'm happy to accept your support. Do we need an official vote? I think that's how we do it, yeah.

12:18 And I'm sorry I was looking down, was that Lizzie who, or Jennifer, okay. And seconded by Board Member Stapp. Okay. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you.

12:49 Okay. So we'll do the same for item 4.2. The board will elect a new vice president. The current vice president is Lindsay Barksdale. Are you looking for someone to nominate you? I don't know. Do I need to speak? Are you happy to continue in your role as vice president? I am happy to. Yours just went so fast, Tom. I don't know what I need to say. I'm definitely happy to stay in, but also happy if somebody else would like to take that role. I would nominate.

13:23 Lindsay Barksdale for Vice President. I'll second. Okay. Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stepp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay, terrific. Congratulations. Moving on to Item 4.3, the Board will elect a new treasurer.

13:57 Our current Treasurer, Sarah Nuttall, who's not here this evening. Perfect. Yeah. I nominate Sarah Nuttall. I'll second. Terrific. Any further discussion on Treasurer? Okay. Hearing that, we'll take a roll call, please, Angie. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea?

14:27 Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. All right. Congratulations, Sarah. All right, moving on to Policy Matter Agenda Item 4.4. The Board will receive updates on current construction projects, including the Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments. And I think Eric is our staff report on this. Oh, and I apologize. It looks like I do have a hand raised. Did you want to take that now, see if it was for one of the last items? Yeah, sure. Okay.

15:12 Angie Tapley, did you wish to speak? Angie Tapley, were you wanting to make a comment? She's unmuted, but I can't hear her. Angie Tapley, were you wishing to make a comment? Can you hear me now? Oh, yes, thank you. Okay, I guess I have to not have my Bluetooth on that. Okay, so I am on the list and qualified for the buyer's program.

16:11 After lots of years on the list and going through the process, Eastern Sierra Housing has offered me a place at Sierra Manor number 53. Supposedly in May 2024, I believe it was available and apparently the people that are in it are getting evicted.

16:34 Okay. Well, I think that we would need to direct you to staff and if they

17:07 Can hopefully handle your situation, or if necessary, something can be brought back to the board at the next board meeting on the agenda, if necessary, Angie. So that would be a normal sort of process. I mean, the last I heard was from Patricia a couple weeks ago that she had no idea when they would be, they were served eviction papers and she doesn't know when they're going to be out, which means we don't know how long it's going to be until I can even look.

17:34 And meanwhile, I'm pretty desperate for me and my son. So I get no answers. Can I make a comment, Tom? I just want to say, like, if it is an eviction process, like, rules have to be followed. And Patricia may not know because, you know, that it's a process that has to be followed. So it's not, like, it doesn't, to me, it sounds like it's not a vacant unit. It sounds like there's someone in the unit that's being evicted. And so...

18:02 My guess is that, you know, the person- What I was told is that they were one of the families, this could be wrong, but this is what I was told, they're one of the families that were displaced.

18:12 And that they needed housing, and I guess the town offered them this housing through FEMA, and supposedly they're on the housing list also, so they have nowhere to go. That's what I was told. I don't know if that's correct. Well, I know we're not allowed to have a discussion because it's not on the agenda, but what my comment was is just that if someone's being evicted, then there's no, like, you know, exact date when they will be out. It's probably a process that has to be followed. So I'm confident that Patricia would get

18:40 Any one of our clients into housing as soon as possible. And so I'm sorry to hear that you've, you know, have been waiting and hopefully you are able to get into a unit quickly. Yeah, it's been six years, but it's just what it is. I've done all the paperwork and I'm also on the rental list also. So maybe we can, I'll continue until now, until the next meeting and be in contact with Eastern Sierra Housing and also the town because

19:10 Apparently, I don't know if Eastern Sierra Housing is evicting them or the town, but I'll find out and you don't have to take up your time now about it, but thank you for your time. Yeah, I'd continue to work with staff. This is really their expertise. Okay, Angie, thank you for your comments. Wish you the best of luck. Okay, any other comments online? No comments, thank you. All right, so we will go back to the agenda, item 4.4 then.

19:40 Board will receive updates on current construction projects on the Innsbruck Lodge and the Access Apartments. And we'll turn that over to Eric for a report. Yeah. So we'll start with Access. It's exciting. So this is for these are kind of the most current pictures that we have. So these were shot before we went on holiday. So on the 20th, I believe. Here. You see different pictures or different.

20:11 Thank you so much.

20:46 From the new bid amount that we have, we spent approximately 38% of it. And then you can also see how much of the contingency is left, which is around 60,000, and then how much of that has been spent, which is 13%. Does this include payout 5? This includes payout 5. This was brought to my attention that you guys wanted to see sources broken down, how much we use by each source.

21:18 So as you can see, there's some sources that we've used completely, but we're still pretty well off on it. We're still in the six million mark that we're left to draw, and we used four million of that, of the 11 million that we have. This is a development budget. You can't see it, but as of January of 2025, we spent 64% of our development budget.

21:52 And that includes everything below, or before this. And project updates, again, we've been meeting weekly with the development, the team, the OAC team, and we're still working with the town and CBG to get those payments out. Currently, we, like I mentioned before, we process payout five, and we're working on payout six. And then in terms of construction, our

22:25 We're going to be doing a punch walk scheduled for both the buildings on the 8th, which would be Wednesday, I believe. And we're still tracking for occupancy for the fall of 125. So that has not changed. We've stayed on track with that. Can I ask you a quick question? What does pay app 5 mean? Pay app 5, that's currently what we're the payment that we're on. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. This three-week look ahead for the construction project.

22:56 This is kind of what's broken down. For building A, the roof installation will be completed by Thursday. Rough plumbing on the first floor by the 15th. And then on the second floor will be by the 23rd. Mechanical room on the first floor will be completed by the 17th. And that's all on building A. And then building B would have rough plumbing done by the 24th.

23:22 And then the school rough-end will be done on the first and second floor will be completed by the 17th. Can I ask you one other question? On the previous slide, it said the contract expires June of 25. If work is not done, does the contract expire? Or, like, I'm just, I don't know. The contract is through June.

23:47 We have to negotiate terms. Okay. Thank you. Well, I'll just say that we are having a site walk on Wednesday at 2 p.m. if any of the board members would like to join us. These are funding sources. Different breakdown than the other one. This just shows you where all our runs come from. And you guys have seen this already. The background.

24:29 And if you guys have questions on access, I can take them now. You mentioned on your slide that you're working with the town for reimbursement from the pre-development costs. Is that still, is that to them or still working on getting the backup to them or how, where are you in that process, I guess? We're still collecting the data.

25:03 We have a really good understanding of the sources and uses at this point, which is helpful as we sort of work through that process and pull that information. And then just in recapping then on the contingencies in the current budget versus the original budget, we're $230,000 or $40,000 over the original budget, but we still have about $600,000 remaining or something on the contingency level.

25:38 Roughly? Okay. And is there, are there any new sort of concerning issues at all in construction that, for terms of any kind of budget concerns or that'll, you know, hit the contingency at this point that we're seeing or no? No, from what we've talked about during our meetings, our weekly meetings, most of our change orders have been completed already, so we don't foresee any big changes coming on the way. Right, right.

26:06 Yeah, I mean, now that you guys are, you know, demolition's done, the structural work's complete, you're closing the buildings in, it should be pretty much per plan, I would think, so I wouldn't anticipate there would be any surprises, hopefully move forward, so that's great, and they got the buildings dried in, and we're finishing the roofs, it sounds like, quickly, so, and Mother Nature cooperated a bit, good and bad, but, so, it's great, they're continuing to work through the winter, and sounds like they're making good progress.

26:41 All right. Any other questions for Eric on the access part? We can do INSPIRT now. So these are what currently the bottom units are. This is kind of what they look like right now. I've completed the punch walk list for the bottom units. You'll see on the next slides. But this is roughly what they're going to be looking like.

27:19 This is as close to completion as they can. There's still some stuff that needs to be done, small stuff, but this is the overall look to them. And these were taken today. So project updates. So we're currently leasing or preparing for the lease of process for the next 10 units. We did have two vacant units that have already been leased up. And then, like I mentioned, the punch walk was completed on

27:51 The third, which I believe was a Friday. And then that was sent to the team today. I'm hoping that they'll finish that and then I'll be able to punch block it again in two weeks from now. So you'll have an update on that portion of it. And then for the electrical equipment, for the switchgear, we expect arrival on the 14th of this year. So that being said, the GC is working on trenching the area so that we can get

28:21 That switch gear in there and have everything in place so that when it does arrive, we can start connecting it and have power to those 10 additional units. And then bike racks have been ordered, internet's completed, and the gas connections have been completed. So that is all going to work. So how much time does the contractor anticipate to kind of wrap it up once the switch gear shows up? Did he give you any indication of? The last estimate he gave me was about roughly two weeks.

28:50 Okay, so pretty quick. So by early February, good chance we'll be done? Yeah. And then we'll have, I guess, a final inspection with the town probably to basically sign off on the TCO and give us a final certificate of occupancy. Yeah. Yeah, that's the plan. And we'll have the bike racks by then? Yes. Great. This is our funding stack. Different look to it. Basically where all our money's coming from.

29:23 Elevator background. That's the presentation. You guys have questions? Did you have a recap on cost and our funding? Where are we standing on our contingencies there? I have not. I was working on it. I was not even clear in this one, but I can send it out to you guys. Okay. Any other questions from the board? No, just good work and thank you. Thanks for the update.

29:59 Can't believe the 14th is only like a week away. I know. Should we have a party when the parks arrive? I feel like we should have some sort of celebration. I guess that's probably actually the next thing is when are we doing a ribbon cutting? I thought we had talked about doing one before that was fully occupied so we could visit the units. I think we'd want to make sure we're officially

30:24 Got our CFO, our certificate of occupancy. We're getting close to it even. I mean, even if we don't have the CFO, but we've got the bike racks and, you know, I mean, I don't know. If he's saying two weeks, I just feel like we should get it on a calendar for sometime in February. Yeah, early February. So we can let folks know. I don't know if Senator Alvarado Gill would want to come, etc. Maybe there's a way to roll it into the board meeting.

30:50 Prior to? I don't know. I'm going to be in D.C. I won't be here for the February board meeting, so I would love for it to be another day. Okay. We'll start working on that. We should definitely celebrate our victories, so good idea. Absolutely. All right. Well, there's no further questions for staff on the projects. We'll move on to the agenda item 4.5. The board will receive updates on other program activities.

31:24 Patricia? Yeah, I'll take this one. I think the items in yellow, I haven't had a chance to get with Jarrett to update them for this report, but I did go through this and make sure most of it was up to date. We are hiring one full-time housing navigator position, and I have had interest from one person, so I'm working with them to see if they're

31:53 going to submit an application. Case management for the households at Innsbruck Lodge is still kind of intensive, and so Jarrett's sort of taking the lead on that, and also helping to coordinate the point-in-time count, potentially with Alpine County. They've had some staff turnover again, and so it's not looking good, but Jarrett seems optimistic, so we'll keep you posted.

32:25 We are, we had a tenant move out of the transitional housing unit in June Lake and that unit still needs some TLC so we are getting quotes for paint and new flooring and then the railing, the stair railing is not to code and so we'll have that updated so that the ballasts are all spaced correctly.

32:49 for health and safety, and then we have some homeless households in coordinated entry that are eligible to participate in that unit. So we're working on that right now. We are working with the parcel. There's just been a lot going on with the property management company, and there's still vacant units there as far as I know. I had a conversation with Jarrett today about

33:26 Trying to make sure that our coordinated entry homelessness clients are applying for and being supported through the application process. I think there's some barriers there. And so we're going to see if we can touch base with some clients and see if we can get those units filled with folks that qualify that need to be housed. So we're working through that.

33:58 I'm going to jump ahead to homeownership. We have a lot of homeownership clients. We have, you know, every client is exceptionally unique, and so, you know, there's a list, a long list, and they're all...

34:14 different and they all qualify for different combinations of programs and so we're trying to make sure that first come first serve that each client is getting matched with a unit or units that could meet their needs so that they're able to make that decision for themselves right before the holidays.

34:35 I showed the Meridian Court one bedroom to two clients. It wasn't going to work out. We're in escrow to buy back the Meridian Court unit. Hopefully, be able to turn it over shortly. But, you know, you get all the way through processing a client and get to the point when they have to make a decision, and it's a big step. And so, I actually have had three clients decline that unit so far. And so, that's a lot of work up to that point.

35:05 Eric's sort of taking the lead on the preliminary income qualification and then I'm stepping in through the escrow and the real estate side. So we're really busy doing that and Eric's on the phone a lot with home buyers and there's a lot of files and paperwork everywhere. So I just wanted to let you know we're processing people and we're trying to use the resources that we have.

35:37 Units and down payment assistance in below market rate prices to get folks into homes. Are people able to use FHA financing on any of the units that we have in the program? Yes. I believe that the Forest Meadows unit was blanket approved. Okay. And I believe Meridian Court is approved.

36:15 Solely because it doesn't allow for nightly rentals. Okay. Because that's a bit of a help too because you only need 3% down, right? That helps people? Yes, sometimes. It's just a matter of weighing the pros and cons between paying the PMI, financing the PMI into your loan. It depends on if it increases the payment too much out of the affordability range. So we're looking at all those angles. Yeah, I'm sure you are. Yeah. Okay, great. At least a couple of them could utilize it. Yeah.

36:46 Thank you. I guess I wanted to let everyone know that we received almost a $5 million award for the acquisition and rehabilitation of the Valley Apartments in the City of Bishop. I don't know if I told you that, but we have that in writing now. We're waiting for the standard agreement to come from the state, and we'll have the board approve that as needed.

37:17 We're working on the request for proposals for architectural services so that we can get the design work lined up in order to get permits through the City of Bishop and then select GC to work with us on that project. So this is our next big project and, you know,

37:40 As soon as Innsbruck Lodge is off the plate, we're really going to be spending a lot of time on this, and especially since it includes relocation of the current tenants, it's going to be a, I don't want to say a heavy lift, but it's going to be a unique situation, just like all of our projects. Silver Peaks, we had a meeting with the lead developer on Silver Peaks today, talking again with them on Friday.

38:11 They've redesigned the project conceptually into 60 low-income apartments and 14 ownership townhomes. The city seems excited about that, and we're trying to figure out if we have enough time to submit an Affordable Housing Sustainable Communities application, which is due like March 8th. So they'll be reaching out to CCRH and the technical assistance team.

38:39 To see if that's even feasible. But today we did talk about a lot of other funding options and the lead development partner, Visionary, seemed optimistic. So it was a good meeting. They're presenting to the Bishop City Council on January 13th. And I'll be at that meeting. That's it for me. I mean, there's a million other things.

39:14 Well, it's exciting news, obviously, about Valley, you know, securing that funding and a bit of work and, you know, but, hey, like I said, wrapping up Vince Brooke, you need something else to do. Perfect timing. So, good stuff. I was looking at your short tentative schedule, the steps there for Valley, and it seemed like a pretty reasonable schedule in terms of implementation time frames and so forth, so it's going to take a bit of time, you know, get the plans prepared and permitting and...

39:44 Like I say, relocations, finding a general contractor. So, I mean, it seems like your steps make a lot of sense. Okay, great. That's helpful feedback. I'd like to get the architect on board so that while they're sort of running with what they do, that gives us a little bit more time to work with the relocation consultants or, you know, talk to the City of Bishop and our other partners. So, that's the next big step. Great. Do you have any

40:12 ideas where the current tenants might be relocated to? Well, as of right now, we've really left that in the hands of the relocation consultant, and they prepared a plan that had to be state approved on what that process would look like. Part of that is finding out if any of them have family that they can stay with, and talking with the tenants and moving through that process is all the responsibility of the consultant.

40:42 Wow, that's a big job. I was excited to see that the chip-in credit card processing was coming along and just excited to see that new participants were signing up for it, that it's gaining a little bit of traction. Do you know, is that kind of coming from word of mouth or has Greg done any other presentations? I think it's word of mouth and I know Greg's been reaching out personally to some businesses. I did meet with him.

41:13 Before the holidays and talked about some different strategies, we do still want to do like a one-page marketing flyer, but we did receive our first contribution, which I think was $50 for the month of November, and once we get a few more businesses signed on, that's a regular contribution to our operating account monthly, and I can share those numbers with you.

41:43 We get a monthly report. That's exciting. I'm glad it's coming along. Thanks for bringing that up. All right. Any other questions for staff on the program's update? Okay. We'll move on then to agenda item 4.6. The board will receive a presentation on Sierra Solar's submission for the U.S. Department of Energy's Community Solar Power Accelerator Prize. Thank you.

42:13 This item is a result of Sierra Solar reaching out to our staff to see if we had any projects or need for solar infrastructure that might be funded through a grant source that they are eligible for. And I think it was good timing considering the status of the Valley Apartments Project.

42:43 With no requirements or, you know, liability to support their application, Andrea Stewart from Sierra Solar submitted an application to support solar infrastructure at Valley Apartments with a second phase, a more extensive second phase to generate community solar that can be used to help pay

43:13 And so thank you Andrea came to speak a little bit more in detail about the logistics of the grant application and she knows more about solar than I do.

43:39 Well, thank you. I think you did my job for me. I don't have to give you all an overview. Thank you all for having us today. We're really excited, and I was really excited that Patricia and Eric were able to meet with us on such short notice. Community solar is really a totally unique landscape. It's basically kind of an unprecedented thing that is part of the Biden administration. There was a lot of federal funding that came about for affordable housing and multifamily housing at the beginning of the Biden administration and then prior to that.

44:07 But it's operating on smaller scales, right? And so if you can do larger solar siting in one place, you're more efficient, you're using less resources, and you're replicating faster. But then the question is, how do you actually get all of those energy benefits to people that need it? So there's a cool and interesting utility interconnection model that it follows, where you don't have to necessarily put the solar on someone's house, but they can subscribe to the community solar model.

44:34 Receive all of the cost savings and benefits, and be part of a more just and equitable transition to renewable energy. So we're really excited. Our passion has totally been to create more of a nonprofit chapter of our company. We do a lot of work with the Bishop Paiute Tribe, so we see this as a really exciting opportunity to start.

44:54 Providing more benefits to LMI residents in Inyo and Mono counties both. As Patricia was saying, it's a two-part project. So one is particularly focused on the Valley Apartments project and would all be on site. And then the second one is going to be primarily. So we've got a kind of an interesting setup. We're hoping that this proposal totally goes through with

45:22 Our partners down in Bishop for a dual-use land proposal. It would be implementing a large-scale carport project in a parking lot. And then we've got a second Plan B signing arrangement in place down in Elantra area to develop a lot of solar there. And it's already sited and there's a lot of potential for developing this project. So we're excited. This project is, again, aimed at creating partnerships like this. So we are excited that we are able to make this all happen.

45:52 Do you all have any questions for me? I think one of our big asks is for board support in this project and implementing it. Should we move forward in the prize, we will receive funding that will go towards our contracting fees, our legal fees, our engineering fees. It'll go towards education of tenants and then making this a more possible project to replicate across our region.

46:18 Because land is really, really hard to navigate here. So if we can start to develop a model that's very dual-use oriented, we think this could be something that has a lot more potential. With the community model, so if you have your land use or the carport that goes through, then people in anywhere in Mono and Inyo counties can reap the benefits of that.

46:46 Certainly, and this project was specifically scoped to benefit all of the ESCH existing portfolio. We basically did a giant matrix of what we project the energy uses to be for each of the ESCH portfolio affordable housing units, and then proposed what necessary megawattages needed to provide all of the energy. So that's it.

47:10 Current project that we're hoping to realize. And then if not, I think what we're excited to do is see forward the nonprofit chapter of our company, open that and then start becoming the facilitator of the SOMA program and the SASH program, which is delegated specifically to make sure that benefits of solar go to organizations like ESCH and the tenants, the beneficiaries. Sounds very interesting. How is the physical cost of these grids?

47:44 Where does that capital come from? We would be the developer financer, so ESCH isn't taking on any of the liability or financial risk. We're absorbing all of that. Again, it's kind of a model that's designed to help small companies become small-scale developers and then potentially open up their own nonprofit chapters. So it's an accelerator, a pipeline to make it a more just and equitable transition.

48:14 So the, okay, thank you, that helps. The solar that's being discussed for Valley Apartments that would be installed, I presume would be installed on the roof, that would be owned by a distinct entity from the housing partnership? Yes, so that would be owned and managed by the cooperative, it would be installed by the cooperative, and then essentially you all would, it would be a dual ownership model, I suppose.

48:43 But you would own and operate the solar, and then we would manage all of the aspects surrounding the solar. And then Valley Apartments would be the sole beneficiary, of course. Okay, so is there any other questions from the board? Well, it sounds great. I don't know. Free energy for low-income residents sounds great. What's the catch? Well, hopefully this funding doesn't dry up. It's all earmarked. It's all guaranteed.

49:21 So we'll see what happens, but it's all guaranteed through 2027. So we'll see. That's the only catch I can imagine. So I think in terms of next steps, do you know when you might hear of the award or? February 10th. Okay, so we'll let you know at the March meeting or in an update whether or not the application was accepted, and then we can walk through next steps and

49:50 What an MOU or contract relationship might look like, and then our board would have to approve something like that. Perfect. And as I'm standing in front of all of you here today, if we are not awarded the grant, what we're hoping for is that we can continue the relationship and then passively talk about collaborative grant applications through the SASH and SOMA programs. I think that's what we're most excited and interested in doing. This is a pretty exceptional deal that they're handing out.

50:19 Almost half a million dollars in just funding to realize a project like this that can go specifically towards any of the fees that could come up. It's not restricted in any way, shape, or form. It can even go towards ESCH staff time. So it's a pretty cool deal. And should we not get it, I think there's some other really cool opportunities in the pipeline that we'll circle the wagons on. And would half a million dollars be within the budget to get it completed on the apartment complex?

50:48 Just to help the project go through the planning phase, and then the entire project goes through a developer financing model, and we would be the developers taking on the financing burden. I see, and then you just get reimbursed through the funds generated through the electricity? Correct. So there's a kind of interesting utility symbiotic model. It works out. The utility company, by virtue of...

51:15 obtaining some of the energy, they benefit just a little bit, but not so much. We cover all of the costs associated, and then all of the extra benefits generated just goes towards LMI residents. So it's a pretty cool little deal. Great, and that works with the schedule proposed for, is there even a schedule proposed for Valley Apartments? Patricia? No. Well, there was an outline there in the program update that sort of gave some overall

51:47 You know, milestones that we would, you know, look at actual construction starting in the summer of 26. Okay. So, so we're, you know, year and a half out, which I would think something like. Which matches up with our program as well. Would probably, yeah, marry up pretty well with the timing of what this program would do, I would assume. Absolutely. Graham? What, um. Is this, um, sorry, Jennifer. Go ahead. Well, my, my question was just about Valley. Is, um.

52:19 Is Valley service by SCE or LADWP? You know, I've asked for the recent bill and I haven't received it yet and so I don't have that information because there are also some older solar panels already on the roof that we're not even sure if they're plugged in or something. Would that make a difference to your organization if it was L.A. or SCE?

52:49 No, we have strong relationships with both. We think it's actually LADWP. Okay, thanks. Sorry, Brian, go ahead. Yeah, thank you. I was just going to ask if, I presume this funding is tied to the Inflation Reduction Act? Correct. And I know that that funding source requires a law called BABA, Build America, Buy America, and so it's possible that a component like solar could

53:19 Could trigger BABA requirements to be applied across the whole development. I guess I'd be curious. I'd want to understand whether one of those BABA requirements apply and whether they could be self-contained to just the solar and not affect the larger project because that would be a significant cost burden that we were not anticipating. 100% yes, this would be a totally separate endeavor.

53:45 And not tied to any of the other construction or remodel costs that are happening with Valley. And I think there isn't actually a BOBA requirement that's triggered in this specific prize. Sorry, BABA. But should it be, we actually primarily buy mostly American products anyway, so this wouldn't be burdensome necessarily to the project at its base. Thank you.

54:15 Thank you all. Thank you. Good luck. Have your time and look forward to hearing back and updating you soon. Yeah. Thanks for thinking of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you for thinking of us. Absolutely. To partner. All right. Terrific. Okay. With that, then we'll move on to agenda item 4.7. The board will review and possibly approve the contract for services with auto temp for tenant relocation services at the Valley Apartments Project. Patricia.

54:48 Great. Thank you. So we have been engaged with AutoTemp since the very beginning of the Valley Conversations. They produced very early relocation cost estimates for us for both of our grant applications. And recently were contracted by us to update our relocation plan to comply with the state.

55:19 HCD's requirements for relocation plans. So the relocation plan is currently compliant, and we've paid for that part of it. If we would like to engage Autotemp to perform the other relocation services that I spoke about earlier, including communicating with the tenants, noticing the tenants, finding housing solutions for the tenants,

55:50 That estimate is here in the proposal up to around $75,000. And so in order to get them on board for this project, I need board approval to execute this contract and let them know that we would like to move forward and get them on the team in terms of timing. This cost

56:18 The total relocation cost in the budget in the grant application I think was around $330,000 and so the cost of this consultant would come out of that line item or soft contingency. I guess additionally there is not a way that we could perform these services in-house with the staff capacity that we have.

56:58 Autotemp has worked locally in the past and on our projects on Star Apartments specifically and so I think they're a trusted partner and that's why we chose them to update the relocation plan and submit this proposal. I think they also did access. They did the gins when we acquired it. Oh yes, they did. And they also did

57:35 Help us meet the relocation requirements of the commercial tenants at Access Apartments. Right. I forgot about that. Yeah, I was curious because they have a Mammoth P.O. box, but they're not based here, are they? Or at least at the top of their quote. There is a staff person that lives in Crowley. Okay. So you mentioned that in the budget that we presented ACD for the funding that

58:05 You had how much in there for relocations? $330,000 you said? I think it's around $330,000. And this would be $75,000 of that number. What other costs would be associated with the relocation budget? Housing costs for tenants and moving expenses. So if they're relocated to a hotel, those costs would need to be included, storage costs, moving truck movers. And we're obligated to pay their rent?

58:35 During the time they're relocated? While they're relocated, yes. Do you collect the rent, like the rent that they're paying on the property that you're renovating, and then you are paying the rent where they are living? No, because we are displacing them from their home, we pay to have them be displaced. Is there a way to renovate like a unit at a time as they...

59:08 become available instead of incurring all these costs to do it all at once? Yes. Once we get with the architect and the GC, we're definitely going to look at what that construction schedule can look like in terms of minimizing relocation. But at some point, it's likely that all 19 of them will be displaced at one point or another. Well, I just, you know, doing the math here on the numbers, I was looking at it. If we deduct the $75,000,

59:45 Estimate from the 330, that's 255, 255,000 divided by 19 apartments is $13,421 per household or per apartment. For a year. Which would seem to be a little lean for a year worth of rent and relocation costs. That would average $1,118 a month per tenant, which I don't.

1:00:16 Not quite sure. I just have a little bit of concern on the overall budget. I don't think there's any way we can get around it. We have to do relocation, and staff can't do it. I think some of the cost savings could come from the concept of trying to rehabilitate units and move folks in while the others are being. There's also, just like with access and the Star Apartments, the real likelihood that

1:00:48 There'll be natural attrition once we take over the units that will not lease units once they become vacant because of it's an older population. I'm on the IMACA board. It's not uncommon for units to become vacated due to death given the population. And so it's possible that units won't need to be relocated because they'll be vacant.

1:01:15 I think that's, so there's a lot of unknowns, I think, with that, that could help save money, but I don't see how we get around not executing this. Do we, I mean, I guess, do we decide on this? I mean, I feel like, what are the states of the, like, what are the, what's the state of each unit? Like, do they need to be rehabilitated immediately, or is it, you know, like, we acquire it? Like, that's what I feel like, is, do we need to do this right now, or it sounds like we... Yeah, we do. It's a mandate by the state that we...

1:01:44 Have a relocation plan. We have relocation experts. And the units, we've done the work to get the grant to say, oh, the units need XYZ. The architect will come in and give us a better sense of what needs to be done. The GC, we can work with the dental contractor on a timeline.

1:02:06 I think the units are occupied right now, but the goal is to get the units really rehabilitated into present-day standards with the money that we're receiving as much as possible so that we don't have long-term, you know, deferred maintenance. So really bring it up to speed. You did mention, Patricia, also, sorry, Brian, that you could take this $75,000. And is the $75,000 the total?

1:02:37 That's 7,000, 1100, 6,000, are those in addition to 75? You know, we just paid some invoices for the HCD update to the relocation plan, and I believe it was around 6,000, so I was just rounding to the 75. Okay. You mentioned that it could come out of the, like, contingency money that was also in the proposal? Mm-hmm. Okay. So maybe that kind of changes up. Is there enough in that to cover that and then also have?

1:03:09 I mean, we never know. Contingency's not very healthy, I wouldn't say, in the budget. But I can certainly ask our partners in Inyo County, you know, for contributions to these costs. In relocating people, how far away, do they all need to be relocated in Bishop? Or, like, could they go to Mammoth? That's something the relocation expert would know. Okay.

1:03:39 Thinking about units and the availability of places as well. Okay, thank you. I would just say given the cost of relocation and the city of available housing to relocate individuals into, I think we should discuss with Autocamp the idea of, and this would require coordination with the general contractor, whoever that ends up being, but introduce the notion of creating hoteling units or maybe the

1:04:08 Rehab is done in two or three phases and you finish seven units and you use those, you know, you relocate seven households, maybe it's only five or six if, you know, there's through attrition you have a vacancy, but you finish those units and then you use those completed units to move the remaining households into for a period of time and that can help to minimize the amount of external relocation that might be required. Right.

1:04:38 I've worked with Autotemp on this strategy before, and it was effective. Right. You worked with them before? Mm-hmm. Yeah. They're a well-established, very reputable relocation firm across the state. I think having professionals do it is the best chance of being able to get a plan that's going to get it done within our budget.

1:05:09 That's going to be one of the goals of the plan is to get it all in line and on budget and on schedule. So it seems like it's the most logical solution. I'll also say legal. There's a lot of legal. It's kind of like an eviction. I mean, there's federal and state laws. It's very complicated. And that's another reason you really want these professionals handling this.

1:05:38 Because it can be very litigious, and we do not need any additional liability. One question that I did have near the bottom, it says that, well, I believe they state at the beginning that they have employees who speak multiple languages. I think that was in here. Yes, so most of their people are

1:06:05 Bilingual. But then at the bottom, it states that there would be additional cost and billed separately for translating and translation services. I feel like maybe that's just something that we could negotiate a little bit if they already have people who are bilingual. Maybe it's legal documents that take a little bit more translation. But I don't know if we anticipate that being a thing.

1:06:32 As far as I know, the current tenants all speak English, and Autotemp has already been in communication with them in order to develop the relocation plan. And so the tenants have already had interviews with Autotemp just to create the required plan for the grant application. And so there were no issues during that process. I was really impressed, actually.

1:06:59 And so they're familiar with the tenants already and we haven't heard anything about needing additional languages. Okay. Thank you. No, thank you. Any further questions or comments? Okay, so the 10 items says that we will review and possibly approve the contract for services. I don't see that we have a contract here. This is a letter of proposal. But are you looking for board direction for you to proceed with?

1:07:33 Working on a contract with our council and proceeding? Yeah, I can, my impression was that this was their letter contract, but I can confirm if that's the case. They said if you'd like to move forward, execute this. But if we'd like something more formal, I can certainly request that. I do see an approve and accept line with the name and date.

1:08:03 So I think as long as they're willing to work with us on some plans and some alternatives such as what Brian and others have suggested, I'm happy to make a motion to approve this proposal. Is there language in here? Sorry, I didn't get a chance to read it thoroughly about our liability. Is this something that our lawyers should be reviewing before we...

1:08:40 I'll vote to approve it. Yeah, and I could take staff direction to have them review it before I execute it. Yeah, I think it would be a good idea. And we could bring it, I mean, I don't know if we have to approve it tonight. I just brought it because we have it and it's available and we don't need to push it into the future if we don't have to, but if we need more time, that's fine as well.

1:09:05 I'm happy to amend my motion to approve after review of legal counsel with any modifications suggested by legal counsel. I'll second that. Okay. I have one further discussion, sorry, that I just thought of. I'm assuming, but I just would like to make sure that they, when they're doing their work for relocating, they have our best financial interest.

1:09:36 in mind as far as putting people or we have some say in where people go or sort of how we're like this, you know, you do seven units and then they relocate and they put the pieces together to make it as cheap as possible? Yeah, we talked through some of that during the plan preparation and so I believe that they're open to communication and that they understand our constraints.

1:10:03 I'm hoping Eric will take, you know, the project management lead on this, and hopefully, if he doesn't have time, then I will communicate with them and make sure it's going smoothly. Okay, and yeah, the financial decisions are approved or something. Okay, thank you. That's all I had. Okay, we have a motion and a second, or a motion with an amendment and a second. Any further discussion? Okay, Angie will take roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes.

1:10:35 Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Steph? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Motion passes. We'll move on then to Gen Item 4.8. The Board will receive an update regarding the research of accounting and financial services and provide staff direction. Patricia? Thank you.

1:11:06 So I've been working with two additional firms since our last meeting. We saw a proposal from one firm. And with the holidays, we didn't have time to get the full, complete proposals. I had a follow-up call this morning with one of them. And so they're really trying to get an understanding of how

1:11:31 Many QuickBooks files we have and may have in the next 12 to 18 months. How many transactions each of those files is processing monthly. And so I've given them all that data. I'm just waiting for those final proposals to come back so that I can share them with you. I will just say that

1:12:00 I believe all three of the proposals are going to be in the similar price range. And, you know, I'll bring back all this data ASAP, but I think it's going to be in the $40,000 to $50,000 price range. Going back and looking at our expenses historically,

1:12:21 At the last meeting, I had not included the cost of the full-time benefited staff person who was spending a third of their time producing these services. And so I can provide that data at the next meeting where we add in the cost that we were actually spending to have that staff person do those things. I think that made a really big difference, stark contrast in the cost.

1:12:51 I just wanted to make a general statement about how accounting is extremely specialized. There's some things that a local person might be able to do, but I feel like we really have the need as we grow for

1:13:20 Support from a team of experts that have resources that a local person may not have, other experts in non-profit accounting, other experts in affordable housing accounting. The number and complexity and amounts of the transactions that we're seeing now are extremely much

1:13:51 More complicated than we've historically ever seen. And so having that support of an expert who's tracking those numbers and talking to me and making sure everything's being recorded correctly and I have someone to lean on and say, yes, that's exactly where that goes and let's tell the board about it. And right now I don't have that. And so I could spend, you know, I could put my head down and spend

1:14:16 All my time playing with these numbers and making sure everything lines up, and I'd be happy to do that, but I don't think that the board wants me to be doing the bulk of that. I think that if one of our strategic priorities is to have a new development in the pipeline every year, that's going to take a lot of work on my part to build relationships, find...

1:14:41 the land, find the funding, and if I'm knee-deep in the financials, that's going to take away from that other leadership work. Unfortunately, you know, I think there is an accounting shortage, and there's more demand than there is supply of accountants, and so I think that has, you know, something to do with the cost, but I'm

1:15:09 excited that all three firms have said that they'd be willing to take us on despite how complicated our books are. You know, I think the onboarding, you know, is going to be something and they're all going to have a different timeline and I think that's reasonable. But those are my thoughts so far. I don't have the data today.

1:15:38 And our current firm would like to off board January 31st. I don't know if the board would consider holding a special meeting for this specific item. I'm fine with that. I think it's highly important. I mean, I don't think there's, I mean, that's one of our primary roles here as a board is the judiciary health of the organization. So absolutely, I'm open.

1:16:14 The last week in January is good for me, and that might be the perfect time for the transition since they want to jump ship on the 31st. And, you know, I would even be willing to hold the board meeting at the end of January since I'm going to be gone, but that's me being selfish.

1:16:38 And that might put too much pressure on you and staff to put the board agenda together and may not work for the rest of the board. But those are just a few of my thoughts. And I also want to say that I'm grateful that you were able to even get another agency to give a proposal. So now we have three. I mean, you can't really ask for more than that, especially in this rural area, which is such a niche.

1:17:06 Kind of industry of nonprofit affordable housing. So kudos to you for that. And I look forward to seeing the proposals. Thank you. Yeah, I mean, I agree. I mean, I think this is one of my comments that I made at the end of the year was just that, yeah, we definitely need to find the good resources to help relieve that burden on you, particularly for all the reasons you mentioned, in particular, sort of leading our efforts on focusing on

1:17:38 Finding other projects to do and delivering units and so forth. So it makes total sense to me. And as you say, in the context of looking at that cost relative to an employee on staff who won't necessarily have all that expertise, right? So it just seems like a good use of resources for sure. And there's plenty to do. So I'm definitely in full support of that and attending a special board meeting at the end of the month if necessary. So whatever you need to do.

1:18:09 Any other comments from the board? Is there anything else, Patricia, you were going to add? I guess I'll maybe just send out a poll. I wanted to ask if this time of day is perfect and this is what we want to stick to, even for a special meeting, or if I could work with Angie to see if Sweet Z is available during the day.

1:18:41 Just to narrow down some of the time options. If the special meeting were specifically focused on that, would it have to be done in person or could we do it on Zoom? I think the same rules apply to special meeting as a regular meeting. So you could notice your location or if you were sick under the conditions of the regulation, then you could attend remotely or had other just cause.

1:19:16 Right, the Brown Act applies regardless. Evening is fine, but some days I have pretty wide open. The 20th and the 27th are wide open for me right now, so I could meet any time. If it's better for my colleagues to meet during the day, that would be fine. I generally can't meet until after 3 p.m. on school days. Okay, that's helpful.

1:19:52 Tightens it right up. Thank you. I'll send out some options. Okay. All right. Any adequate staff for direction from the board? Okay. All right. Terrific. With that, then, we will move on to agenda item five, committee reports. It's an opportunity for any of our committees to report back any progress since the last meeting. And I will just mention that the

1:20:25 I'll participate in the town contract negotiating committee, ad hoc committee, and we're, I think we've just got to go back and forth one more time on some email availability here and try and get a meeting next week, I believe, to start discussing that on that group. What else do we got here? Governance, diversity, equity, inclusion, executive director evaluation, I know we're at a closed session in that regard tonight, and bless you. Thank you. Anybody else have any else?

1:21:04 Committee reports? No. Okay. All right. So with that, then, we'll move on to agenda item six, board member reports. I'll start out and just say with respect to the visitation at the ski area, it was pretty strong over the holiday period between Christmas and New Year. Probably better than last year, certainly. And we had several days of pretty high numbers over the weekend in particular once the

1:21:36 Blackout dates were lifted and Thursday, Friday, Saturday were all pretty strong, really strong days. So a lot of people coming to town and seemed like things went pretty well smoothly all in all with not having a lot of weather. So having enough snow, but not having a big snowstorm while everybody's in town, which seems to always happen. So in any event, just mention that in passing, just seems like there's still strong interest in

1:22:05 So I wanted to let you guys know that I was considering resignation. It's been a little difficult coming from Big Pine and going back to Big Pine at night, kind of, especially in the wintertime, maybe feeling a little drowsy driving all the way back down there and working my private practice at home after working for Caltrans can be difficult.

1:22:37 I signed up for the town contract committee so I can try to get the requirements of attending in person out of the town contract, but I'm not sure if the Brown Act applies beyond just that town contract or if it's feasible to have the requirement to attend

1:23:08 In person removed at all, but I'm not willing to put my home address on the agenda, invite people in. I get fraudulent emails from somebody posing, several people posing to be Kirk just about every other week, trying to get my Zelle account information and et cetera, and I'm certainly not going to open that up to my home.

1:23:38 And I think as a regional organization, it's important to have regional representation. And as Mammoth Lakes Housing, it might have been important to keep it local, but I would see myself as valuable living in Inyo County. But I don't think I can continue to...

1:24:05 Make the trip up every month after work and without being too much of a burden on myself and my family. So you guys seem a little more familiar with the rules and regulations behind the Brown Act on the requirement to attend. If we were able to remove it out of the town contract, would we be able to change it in

1:24:35 Our bylaws or whatever we have here that we would be able to attend remotely? Does anybody know? I don't believe so. You don't believe that? Because we have two members of two elected officials that are appointed by those elected bodies. If we were just voluntarily on this board without being appointed by our respective bodies.

1:25:07 No, we wouldn't have to have the Brown Act, but because our bodies appoint us, because the bylaws state so, no, because IMACA has elected officials, but we all volunteer to be on the board. My body does not appoint me or my colleagues or the Inyo supervisors or the city council doesn't appoint them. We just volunteer directly to IMACA to be on their board.

1:25:36 Therefore, that doesn't trigger the Brown Act, but because our bodies appoint us, it does trigger it. Is the appointment just the town of Mammoth Lakes, or is there... And the Board of Supervisors. And so, I'm sorry, what is the Board of Supervisors? The Mono County. The Mono County. And...

1:26:04 Is it a requirement that you be appointed rather than- Via the bylaws, the organizational bylaws, Eastern Sierra Community Housing bylaws, those could be changed, I guess, theoretically. That's the suggestion that we've had from other board members and our legal counsel. It's the appointment that triggers the Brown Act.

1:26:31 But if this board approved their nomination, that would not require the Brown Act. Right, but I think the premise, the historical impetus to the appointment has to do with fiduciary accountability. That's where this began. The organization was started in large part by the town of Mammoth Lakes with dedicated funding.

1:27:01 And they really wanted the oversight and to always have a seat on the board with that oversight. And that was really the impetus to including it in the bylaws. And I think that's where the rub might be with removing it.

1:27:22 from the town, perhaps. I don't know. I've never had those conversations, but it could be a challenge. I think what's interesting in our budget is that their financial contribution has diminished substantially, and so maybe they don't have that, the same clout, I guess, than in the beginning, but that's just... Well, and perhaps it's something that comes up under contract, you know, the contract team could

1:27:54 Committee could discuss with the town. I don't know. I'm not sure. I know in past negotiations it was brought as a fairly significant point by the town that it be included, that it be required on their end. So that was with the former town manager. We haven't had a negotiation with the new town manager, so I don't know if his opinion would be any different, but in the past it was expressed that they very much wanted us to comply with the Brown Rule Act.

1:28:24 They probably more than anything want us also to ensure that they have a seat at the table. Well, I mean, they're giving tax dollars to the organization, and so they want some... Well, they have a contract. Right, but it's tax dollars that they've collected that they're giving us. But jurisdictions don't sit on the boards of private companies that they contract with.

1:28:57 Yeah, because I do think you bring up a great point, Tony, that, you know, it would be nice to expand our board to represent Alpine County as well. We have you in Inyo County. Even residents of northern Mono County. Yeah, yeah, just outside of Mammoth. And so how do we, I mean, I suppose the solution is to find a public place, like if the library's open later or things like that, where you could go and have your, you know, post that as your meeting location.

1:29:27 Right. Because I think, you know, we have a kind of example of someone willing and able to make that accommodation. He's obviously, Brian's using his office space, but so it's not insurmountable. It is possible to do. It just seems that, Tony, you have a unique challenge where you live, and you don't have a community center, you don't have a library, you don't have...

1:29:55 Uh, a county office or anything where you could hold your, you couldn't hold your meeting at Caltrans where you work. They wouldn't allow you to do it and participate. I mean, I've, I know the Caltrans, Ryan, have you talked to Ryan McDermody to see if he'd be willing to let you do that? Um, no, but I, I'm sure that they wouldn't let the general public into the Caltrans private property, especially after hours.

1:30:25 In order to do this, they'd have to hire security or something to be there at the same time. But like I said, it is a regional organization now and I'm not against coming up here and I would still prefer to be here in person rather than over Zoom, but I've missed a few meetings over the last six months and I...

1:30:50 I feel like it's irresponsible of me to do so and if I wanted to maintain my status as a board member here I feel like I would have to not miss meetings kind of casually and so especially like we said Alpine County if we were to have somebody

1:31:20 Represented from Alpine County, then you really couldn't expect them to be here for an evening meeting. And if someone were to have the resources to have a special location at a public place in order to attend remotely,

1:31:44 It might not be necessarily just a member of the general public. It would be somebody who has a connection with somebody publicly that can open up the community center or something to do that. Well, I mean, I appreciate your concern and your wanting to be accountable and, you know, attend meetings. That's huge. It's a huge part of our role.

1:32:16 But I just, your lack of willingness to put your house up as an address, I mean, I don't, I've attended meetings from my brother's house in Denver. I've got colleagues on the board, supervisors that have attended meetings from all over the world in their hotel rooms.

1:32:38 Without issue. You have an issue with that process. And I'm not being disrespectful of it, but I think it's unique to you because I haven't seen that issue with my colleagues. I haven't had it. And I can't say that somebody in Alpine or even in, you know, North County of Mono would be opposed to putting a sign on their door and having it in their address on the agenda. I just don't think we're that.

1:33:08 I just, I don't know, but I suspect that there's others that would be willing to do it, and I'm not trying to spare your concern, I'm just saying I'm not sure everyone shares your concern. Well, I do have two kids at home, and I don't think it's... Do you understand what I'm saying, though? In a way, but I also don't think that it would be widely expected for most people to give out their home address on a public...

1:33:38 basis for this and invite the public into their home. I wouldn't expect anybody to join at my place but like I said I've repeatedly received fraudulent emails trying to get me to give my bank account info and that would make me that much more skeptical to put my home address out there especially with the white children at home.

1:34:07 Does the board want to have the committee address this or agendize it for our next meeting? Or, Tony, are you planning to stay on? Well, she said it's the board of supervisors and the town of Mammoth Lake, so even if we were able to get it removed from the...

1:34:35 Town contract, we'd still have to get it removed from something else and have other bylaws amended? No, just one bylaws. Just one bylaws? Just our own bylaws. Our own bylaws? And would we have to get it removed from more than just the town contract? Is there a contract with Mono County as well? No. We just have to make sure our partners, it was acceptable for our partners to, you know, change the course of business. So...

1:35:05 Well, I think we can certainly take it up as a town contract committee negotiation with town. I mean, make a good point, you know, that it's challenging to have a board that services tri-counties and expect to have representation at the far reaches of the counties and have them up here for a meeting in the evening and with the, you know, travel time and so forth and effort it takes to do that. So I think we definitely...

1:35:33 You know, ripe for discussion. I think we should bring it up and raise that as the point and see if we can get past the hurdles. Yeah, if the town of Mammoth Lakes contract is the primary thing that is the obstacle, then I'm already on that contract negotiation committee and I can do my best to argue for that to be changed and we can change the bylaws if the

1:36:04 Board as a general would be voting against that, then there's not necessarily any point in me trying to fight it with the town contract. Well, I know this topic has been discussed at the board level before, and I know that there's feelings on both sides, generally seeing the pros and cons of both options.

1:36:34 I think if you're staying on the board, then we can talk more in depth at the committee level. And then we have a joint meeting with the town of Mammoth Lakes coming up in February. Perhaps that's a time we could have a conversation with them about this specific topic if there's time. Sounds good. Great. Well, I'll go ahead and maintain my role on the...

1:37:04 Town Contract Committee and see what I can do to get that removed from the contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes and if we can get that removed from there then perhaps we can change our bylaws and I can attend remotely and from home without having to invite the public into my home.

1:37:31 Is the intention of listing an address, like on our, on the agenda, it just says that Brian will attend remotely from the address. It does not state public is welcome to join him at that meeting. Does the page that you need to put on your door or on the public facing, does it say something about you're welcome to come in for this meeting? And not that, you know, listing your home address.

1:38:00 Is one thing, but also then inviting people into your home. I'm wondering if that makes it more palatable that it's not an open invitation to attend or is that the intention of listing the address? I think that's the intent. It is. Okay. Without saying it. I mean, I think. That there's a satellite location for the public to attend. Okay. Yeah. I guess that really it's just brainstorming a location near you that's open until 9 p.m. Like I'm thinking a restaurant or something and you.

1:38:30 Create a relationship with them and say, hey, once a month, can I just post up in a corner, buy a lot of cups of tea and hang out for a while or a hotel lobby, actually, or a hotel conference room. I mean, I think there's some brainstorming that we could do offline because I hadn't thought about that, too. Like, what are public locations available near you? So, yeah, I think let's keep this, keep talking about it. Great, thanks.

1:39:03 Okay, we're on agenda item six, board member reports. Are there any other board members like to report? Yeah, I just want to make note of an agenda item tomorrow. The board of supervisors will be considering renewing the housing ad hoc committee that we have and looking for a new member of the board to join since supervisor Gardner is no longer on the board tomorrow.

1:39:31 Supervisor Paul McFarland will be filling District 3 supervisor role for Supervisor Gardner, that was Supervisor Gardner's, and he served on the ad hoc. So anyway, the housing ad hoc at the county continues to meet every other week. We've received some appraisals back on some properties in the county.

1:39:56 Potential for housing, working on still the bridge program and other, oh, the other item that is, continues to move along is the needs assessment, the regional needs assessment. We've talked about that here. That is, that is about to be executed.

1:40:21 Inyo County is taking up the legal aspect of that contract, but it sounds like they've firmed up a provider consultant to do the work for the entire region. It will take about 12 to 18 months once that's executed, so that's encouraging. Everybody's participating. Yeah, that's great. Yeah, that's all I have. Okay, any other board member reports tonight?

1:40:51 Yeah, just briefly is that I sit on a board for a homeowners association and it's really becoming difficult to, you know, schedule ahead for landscaping, painting, roofing, all the things that takes an association. And the association has talked about building or buying both, buying a unit to put employees in.

1:41:20 One, we have a spa, and we might be able to put a unit above the spa area, the garage area there. So it's just really becoming really critical for large associations of over 100 to find staffing when they're having to drive up from Crowley or most likely Bishop. Thank you.

1:41:52 I just wanted to ask our fellow board member, Amanda, you're here, so I assume you're, did you stay on as the town's? I stayed on. Thank you. You get me for another year. Yay, thank you. Okay. Okay, terrific. With that, then we will move on to Gen Item 7, closed session, pursuant to government code, 7.1, pursuant to government code.

1:42:21 Section 54956B and 54957.6, the board shall hold a closed session with the board's executive representatives regarding the discussion of the local agency's budget with regards to salaries.

1:42:34 Salary schedules or compensation paid in the form of fringe benefits to its unrepresented employees, the Executive Director, and may include discussion of MLH's budget and available funds and funding priorities, but only insofar as these discussions relate to provide instructions to the local agency's designated representatives. The purpose of this is to review MLH's position in instructing MLH's designated representatives. No action will be taken.

1:43:01 In agenda item 7.2, pursuant to government code section 54957, the board will hold a closed session to consider the evaluation of performance of an employee, title of the Executive Director. With that, we will adjourn into closed session. Is there a link for the closed session? No, let me send that to you now. I agendized these items so that the committee could meet with the board first and then meet with me after.

1:43:38 But I didn't know if that was correct. Yes, Patricia, I think that's the intent for us to huddle independent of you for some time, and then we'll, I think, call you into the meeting. Okay, great. I just wanted to confirm. I'll send you a link. All right, thank you. All right, perfect. Okay.