Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2024
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
386 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:09 Okay, good evening, everybody. We're going to call to order the monthly meeting of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board on Monday, December 2nd at 6 p.m. and take a roll call, please. Angie. President Hodges? Present. Vice President Barksdale? Here. Treasurer Nuttall? Here. Board Member Stapp? Here. Board Member Kreitz? Present. Board Member Perkins is absent. Board Member Steenstra is absent.
4:43 Board Member DeAndrea. Resident. And Board Member Rice. Here. Thank you. Okay. We will move on to agenda item number two, public comments. Is it established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda?
5:07 Members of the public desiring to speak on a major, on a matter, excuse me, appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may be submitted to the Executive Director at Patricia at ESCH or ESCHousing.org or clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov before or during the meeting. And I'm also may be made in person here in Sweet C or by raising your hand online.
5:37 On Zoom. Angie, are there any public comments? No comments at this time. Okay. Seeing no comments, we'll move on to agenda item three, the consent agenda. This is agenda item 3.1, approval of the minutes from the November 4, 2024, regular board meeting. I move that we approve the minutes. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Seeing none, we'll take a roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes.
6:10 Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Steph? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Terrific. With that, we will move on to agenda item four, policy matters. Agenda item 4.1, the board will receive a presentation of the audited financial statements for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2024, and consider approval.
6:45 Thank you. Thank you. I'm just looking for our auditor who's supposed to be on the line, but I don't see him. If you'd like, we could move on to the next agenda item and come back when the auditor joins us online. Yeah, that'd be great. Oh, he was? Says Patricia, though. One's Eric and one's Jarrett. Nope, Angie, is somebody else online? Might be logged into the wrong. Oh, that's probably why. You have to use the panel.
8:09 Sounds like we're waiting for the auditor to join online here momentarily. I would like to request that we move on to the next item so the auditor can get on the phone. Okay. Fair enough. We'll move on then to agenda item 4.2.
13:30 Board will receive an update on the current expansion of services into property management. Patricia? Yep. Okay, thank you. This item I wanted to discuss with the board as we move forward with leasing up 10 more units at the Innsbruck Lodge and then eventually 13 more.
14:16 Hopefully next summer at Access Apartments. And so this is a bit, you know, it does take a lot of capacity and so I wanted to make sure the board was aware of where we were going and what it was taking to own and operate these projects. We currently self-manage five units, four at Star Apartments and one in June Lake at the Birch Creek Transitional Housing Unit.
14:50 And we were recently approached by Mono County to offer a proposal for services for property management of their multi-unit project in Bridgeport, which is an acquisition of four or five apartments that are moving from transient rental to full-time
15:14 Workforce rental, and so they asked us to create a proposal for what the property management services might look like if we were to provide them for the county. I think that, I mean, you know, I know that providing premier property management services for our projects is a goal in our strategic plan, and we know that there is a lack of that.
15:40 And so with this item, I did show the project pipeline so that the board and the public could be aware of
16:14 The properties that we currently manage and what number of units will be coming online and what that takes for our organization. Also, we will generate some revenue from these projects by providing these services and so I think in the next item we can talk a little bit more about what I project that revenue to look like in the next fiscal year.
16:43 And how that gets allocated to staff and what those services look like. On page 34 of the packet, you'll see that we have current staffing levels at Eastern Sierra Community Housing, which includes the Executive Director, a Program and Project Associate, two housing navigators, the Innsbruck property manager who's on site there and is part-time.
17:15 And we've historically had an intern in some years and not in some years, but that's also an option that we have used in the past. And then I wanted to show the board where I think the organization is going in terms of growing, you know, adding, we've added
17:43 Our construction projects to the scope of work in the past five years. We've also added housing navigation and homelessness prevention services, which is a really big expansion for our team. And so I sort of outlined where I thought these roles might fit as we grow. And so we still have an executive director. The orange...
18:13 The orange ones in the staff report are newer type positions. So we have the Valley, you know, once Valley Apartments comes online, if that project works out, we'll need to have a property manager on site there. We have our Innsbruck Lodge property manager who may also need to expand hours for that position to include Star Apartments, currently self-managed four units.
18:43 And access apartments, the additional 13 units. And also he's actually also working with us on asset management of the Birch Creek condo right now. So that role has a potential to expand into maybe more than part-time or at least more than what it is now. And then I had some newer ideas of where we could add support.
19:13 Link into the next item around accounting services. So we have an executive director and there is a need for support staff for that role specifically, I believe. And it's more administrative. It's a lot of the accounting side of things. I think currently we have four QuickBooks files that we're managing.
19:44 And so there's a lot. And then there's our annual filings, our secretary of state filings, insurance renewals, all these things that come with managing the organization itself that I think we could parse out to make it easier for the executive director to oversee all of the programs and all of the construction projects and everything else that's going on. So that's that orange.
20:15 It's called Deputy Executive Director, but it could obviously take many different forms. I just, that's what I labeled it. And then we really need a really solid, possibly, ideally, this isn't an ideal world, program manager who can possibly pursue their real estate license, take the lead on our home ownership programs.
20:46 And so I think that having
21:15 Some position that's really focused on managing that program, which is a really big part of the work that we do, would be extremely supportive of the organization. And then possibly maybe that person also manages the housing navigator staff, or maybe that's a shared role with the executive director. Since there's two, maybe we split it 50-50. But someone who's...
21:43 Responsible and, you know, in charge of those programs and can mentor and foster the homelessness prevention program as well. And then you'll see the housing navigators are on there, the intern is on there as an option, and then possibly a Bridgeport property manager, coordinator, or maybe that falls within someone else's. There's plenty of other options, right? That could fall somewhere else, but this is an example of what it could look like. And some of the reasoning,
22:16 Around this also has to do with our movement into our construction pipeline and our project pipeline. We do want to keep doing projects, right? We have a goal to have projects in various stages every year, a new project coming in and all those projects moving forward at various paces. However, historically, and I don't think maybe at the moment,
22:46 That's really the income that our organization survives on. We haven't been operating our organization as a 100% development organization where we do a development and it pays for all the staff. And every time we do a development, that money comes in and it pays for all the staff. And every time we do a development. Historically, it hasn't been that way. I think we're trying to move in that direction, but I think there's a little bit of a
23:17 A hang-up between where we're trying to go and where we're at right now. So that's what I was thinking about in terms of how we're trying to grow and what fits with the strategic plan and the goals of the board. And so I'm really excited to hear feedback from the board around this. And then also, I think I was going to turn it over to Jarrett.
23:44 momentarily to talk a little bit about the work he did on the proposal for services for the Bridgeport property. So, as Patricia was saying, for the proposal for services, pretty much we just created a proposal that kind of had an overview of what Eastern Sierra Community Housing is, what it can do and what it has done in the past 20 years. And then we kind of wrote down the opportunities.
24:25 You know, with a partnership, you know, we can offer many opportunities for Mono County to, you know, kind of get a better grasp on the housing situation within our area. In our proposal, you know, we detailed how we have managed units previously, and we also have, we have over 10 years of property management. And, you know, according to Mono County, they would like to keep houses at under 120% AMI.
24:54 Mainly for a lot of the workforce in Mono County. So we kind of geared a lot of the writing towards that, you know, and primarily we'll be doing a lot of the property management side of like the paperwork. They will have public works doing a lot of the fixing around the area. And as well as our scope of work, you know, we have client eligibility. We'd be offering services in a package deal, basic or premium.
25:23 Client eligibility per application, lease signing, rent collection, unit inspections, unit turnovers, request for repairs. And then if we do a premium service, we'd be venturing into something like a 24-7 emergency call lines, tenant relations and communication, contract management and budgeting management. And that was primarily the scope of our proposal is just kind of
25:52 Letting Mono County know that we can do certain things, that we have a lot that we can bring to the table, and then kind of seeing what they would like and what they wouldn't like. Yes, thank you. And then lastly, before I turn it over to the board, I did want to expand a little bit on the infrastructure needs as we move forward. I touched on the staffing component, but there could be other technology needs that we may have, including
26:23 A property management software to help manage tenant relations, tracking when leases end and noticing tenants and maybe that includes something where they're able to pay their rent online. And we may want to add a 24-hour emergency line, which we don't currently have.
26:44 And then also in speaking with our legal counsel, they have recommended potentially setting up a separate LLC that is the business entity that provides the property management services to protect the other entities as we grow. And so that's just another aspect of how this could impact our business. And I am excited to hear what the board thinks. Okay.
27:16 Thank you, Patricia. So we'll bring it back to the board for initial comments or questions for staff. Did Mono County approach Eastern Sierra about this project or was this opportunistic on your part? We were approached by Mono County staff to submit a proposal. Okay. I know to some degree we're already in the property management business with
27:53 The existing units and there are some additional units coming online between Innsbruck and obviously access and we have limited third party options. I will say that self-managing is fundamentally different than managing for a third party. I think there's a different set of expectations that come with that, even licensing to some degree. So I would want to be very
28:23 Cautious about stepping into a third-party property management relationship. Also, the cost of all this, again, I know we're already in the business, but property management generally is not a money-making business. This is a tough business, especially on the affordable side. And so I know you've got a little bit of the economics spelled out here, but I'm not...
28:49 Feeling like we see the full picture of what you're projecting all this to cost and what the incremental staffing that you think is necessary, the incremental technology, the third parties that we would probably have to hire in terms of compliance. So I think I would want to hear a little more and see a little more granularity here.
29:16 So if I could, just coming from the county side of things, I have been speaking with our CAO and I've spoken with Patricia on this today, but also with the CAO prior to today. And, you know, I think that when the county bought the units and we adopted a management plan,
29:46 That plan was very vague and kind of broad and said, oh, we may manage it ourselves or we may not. It was, you know, we asked specifically of staff what was the plan and they weren't sure. And so I think that staff put this together, requested this, county staff requested this of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing because they wanted to see what it would look like.
30:15 But since then, you know, I've really, from the two different seats, right, from the county side and then from this side, I don't think it's the right route for either. I don't think it's the right route for the county, and I don't think it's the right route for our organization at this time. I agree with your concerns, Brian, but I also see the county as having capacity to...
30:42 Do these five units in-house. Two are going to be county staff members, so they're closely aligned with the county. And the other three are going to be community members. It's not a complex property because it was bought with no grant funds. There's no strings. It's just what we put in the management plan as the board of supervisors on how it will be rented and what AMIs, et cetera.
31:06 One of the things I talk to the CAO about, and I'd like to suggest that our staff think about reaching back out, and I think maybe we'll hear from the CAO or the housing program manager at the county, is
31:21 A training opportunity to train their housing person on how to do leases, how to income qualify in accordance with what the management plan that the county has on that property. Just kind of help him.
31:37 or whoever is doing that for the county in-house, get off the ground. You know, I liken it to when Mono County started, or I'm sorry, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, back then Mammoth Lakes Housing, started doing home buyer assistance in 2006 when I started with the organization.
31:56 They hired an outside expert to come from, I think, the Central Valley and teach us exactly how to do homebuyer's assistance, how to put together the files, how to, you know, what form letters on requesting.
32:14 Just everything that you would need to put together those monstrous files of homebuyer assistance applications all the way through to the end. And it led to, as Patricia just said, a really lucrative
32:28 For not just the organization, but for our region in home ownership, which is such a key pillar of what MLH and now Eastern Sierra Community Housing provides, and it's essential to the continuum of housing that we need in our community. So I think that this could be a model that we offer up. We don't have the capacity, and I don't think we...
32:50 Personally, I don't think we have the capacity, and I think the county does, to manage these five units. They may just need some hand-holding to kind of get their program up and running. Maybe they don't, but maybe this is where we can help them be successful, and we can still be a community member. That would be my suggestion, specifically to the Bridgeport component. Now, I think you've brought up a lot of other things that I...
33:15 I think we need to talk about with regards to the flow chart and the expansion, and I think that needs to be addressed as well. But I kind of, for me, I'm bifurcating them. Yeah, thanks, Jennifer. I would agree in both respects as far as this immediate opportunity that maybe it's not a good fit at the moment. And then as far as the larger discussion with respect to
33:45 You know, expansion of staff. I certainly think it's a warranted discussion, although I'm kind of feeling like maybe that should be brought back at a future meeting as a separate agenda item where we really do start to talk about the staff organization. And, you know, I do feel that we need somebody to kind of fill the shoes that Diane left, you know, when she retired so that, you know, somebody can really help on sort of the accounting side in particular.
34:15 All the things that you mentioned, right? All the sort of higher level administrative duties that keep the organization flowing. And then maybe, you know, also have some abilities in project management as well would be helpful, certainly. You know, we're at this sort of crossroads to a degree of, you know, we're a small but mighty group, but small staff. And, you know, it's tough to bring on another full-time employee.
34:43 To ensure we have adequate funding for that, just in our regular sources of funding versus our, you know, our project sources and so forth. And just, you know, probably need to take a little bit deeper dive into that part of, I think, of our annual cash flows and, you know, re-looking at our budget and so forth to see if there's some bandwidth there that we can, you know, take on another position. And or, you know, we've got to grow additional revenue sources through other, you know, some of the other governmental entities that we're serving.
35:12 That we've talked about in the past as well. So those are kind of my initial thoughts on this item. Anybody else have anything to add to the discussion? Well, if we're going to go into the expansion side, so I just spoke about the one aspect because I was bifurcating. So I spoke about the property management side, but to come back to this.
35:36 Growth staffing. I have some ideas on this, too, that I think could maybe be something to explore, and I do think it needs to come back, but perhaps there's a HR specialty consultant that we could look to hire to do an analysis of where we're at, where are our gaps, what would it look like for us to grow
36:06 and really fill the needs that aren't that are really I would say either slipping
36:16 Overburdening the ED and not really shouldn't be on the ED plate, you know, and then the loss of Diane and all of, and the growth with the new management, somebody maybe who could help do that analysis. I just, I'm concerned that our Executive Director doesn't have the capacity right now with everything on their plate to do that too. And there could, I think there are firms that could help with that. And so that would be
36:45 One option I think we could consider just to help bring somebody outside to come in and look and say, yeah, I think this is where you could fill and this is what it could look like and help in an HR capacity that I think Patricia has just really tapped out on. Okay. Okay. So I think it would be prudent to agendize this for our next meeting and maybe we can
37:20 Possibly have some, you know, options there that we could look into that and maybe we could solicit a quick proposal or two and see, I know those are my thoughts, sort of see what our options are. I mean, I think you're right, Jennifer, in that there's just, there's already so much on the plate and, you know, I think if it's nominal expense, you know, it would make some sense and might be nice to have a fresh set of eyes on as well and get an outside perspective. It's somebody who's,
37:50 Familiar with, you know, our business model or, you know, non-profit affordable housing in particular, if there's something out there like that, I don't know. But, so, okay, do you have something, Lindsay? Sure, I'll kind of cycle back to the Bridgeport property management topic. Do, have you heard, Patricia, any talk in the community in our three tri-counties of any more?
38:19 Instances like the Bridgeport Project, and I know it's hard to look forward, but I'm, because with this list here of the 46 units that would need things that includes the four to five in Bridgeport, that if we do that in-house, it seems like we will need somebody to take care of those units, no matter what, whether it includes Bridgeport or not.
38:47 But then I was also just thinking as we're looking ahead, are there talks in the other counties, other towns, regions of purchasing other places that would need this outside property manager or need us to be outside our organization? There's a couple of proposals out there. One is an acquisition rehab in Inyo County that's about 20 units.
39:16 That Inyo County would like to partner with us on. And then there is talk about some sort of transitional housing unit or two that's needed in Alpine County and what would our role be in that. It's a very wish list item, I think, for Alpine County. And we obviously haven't made any promises, but I've heard them talk about that.
39:46 Yeah, and it's hard to predict the future for sure. And hearing Brian talking about there's so much that goes into the property management outside, it seems to me that for a small, for only four to five units, it's maybe not worth us going down that road. But if there is a potential for something later on, that makes me pause and think about if we have these 46 or 40,
40:18 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
40:47 If we do have a need for more, then I think we should keep talking about it. Yeah, I think certainly in the, you know, a project of a little bit larger scale, 20 units or something like that, right? And then just to be clear, I think, you know, we would have to analyze it such that if we were providing services, that it would be self-sustaining, right? And maybe even a small profit, so to speak. You know, we certainly don't want to get ourselves in a situation where we're...
41:17 Taking on more work and we're, you know, having to come out of pocket to support it, right? So, you know, it would need to be money that would go towards somebody, you know, we talked about possibly with our existing between Innsbruck and Access once it's online, you know, that, you know, the property manager we currently have at Innsbruck will probably assist with Access and, you know, maybe that could grow into a full-time position under property management, but we would.
41:45 I want to make sure that we structure, you know, our, at least to those individual projects and the incomes that would support that property management position, right, would be how I would view it. And certainly as we move into some of these other projects down in Inyo County with Valley potentially and the larger ones down there, the Elm conversion possibly, again, might, that might be enough where you'd have enough stuff down there where we'd want to.
42:15 You know, bring somebody on that position. But again, that's thinking a little bit further down the road. So yeah, maybe this immediate opportunity might be a little too small, and given Jennifer's input and her feedback from the CAO, sounds like maybe we should pass for the moment. Do we need to take an action on this, or is this what... I think Sarah might have a comment. Your mic's on, I noticed. Yeah. I think that...
42:43 That was a lot to digest, actually. So I will focus on just the proposal. I think that someone put a lot of time and effort into the proposal. And when I read it, which I kind of did in a lot of detail and had a lot of notes, I was going to ask, was there an RFP for this? Because it did seem I was unclear of what services were included. What were they asking us to do? Are they just, you know, is there a potential where
43:13 ESCH is just doing tenant sourcing, verification, tenant selection. Maybe there's a partnership with a limited scope of services. Maybe there's not. Without kind of fully understanding what the county is actually looking for or needs, you know, personally, I can't comment on that. But I do think that, well, A, I think that it is on the strategic plan, as you've outlined, that we are or, you know, should be considering.
43:42 Expanding into the providing excellent property management services, we're already doing it. I kind of, personally, I don't, I mean, again, 100% depending on what the requirements of the county are, I don't think that because it's a small complex that it shouldn't be considered. We already have a part-time property manager managing a complex and a property that we...
44:08 We're already providing the services, so to add another four to five units, property management scale is what you want. If you're going to have any hope of making any money, you need to scale it, or even breaking even. I know it's not about the profit, but so I'm not...
44:24 I think in this one, I agree that the county proposal, it was maybe a little bit the cart before the horse, but I think that we should spend time on putting a proposal together on what does that property management service slash business, what does it look like? What are the insurance and licensing requirements? Are they cost prohibitive? What's the technology and software costs? What are the expansion of staffing needs?
44:52 You know, what does the whole picture of that look like if you're really going to kind of consider going into that direction, which with the pipeline you've outlined in the document and what you've just said, it seems like there is actually an opportunity and it might be an opportunity that kind of ends up on our lap regardless if we're going after projects or not.
45:18 I personally think it's something that we should consider. I just kind of feel like it's maybe a little bit kind of all over the place right now. And per Brian's point, like there's a lot of costs and other aspects in setting this up, kind of, especially if it's going to be a separate LLC that we, that I would want to see and I think as the board would want to see to really drill in. Like, yeah, what's...
45:46 Is it even feasible financially? And I think at that point would be able to, you know, provide comments. So I think then tying back to the kind of the growth chart that you put together, I agree. I think it needs its own workshop to really kind of talk about that. And if we collectively as a board decide the direction is to expand into property management services, then of course we need to add additional resources.
46:14 But I kind of feel like they're two separate things. So, yeah. Yeah. So, I guess I apologize as well. I didn't have a lot of comments on the org chart growth staffing because I was more focused on the specific proposal. But I think you've got some good thoughts there and some good ideas on where we might expand. But, yeah, I would like to spend more time looking at that.
46:40 And then it's funny you bring up whoever it was, sorry, about the HR consultant. This has been in the back of my mind for actually a few months now about do we need this regardless? I will speak to my own personal experience. We just brought on an HR consultant. We have 55 employees and we just brought one on. Otherwise it was me doing everything. And there are so many California requirements. It's almost endless.
47:10 I have often thought, who's doing this at Eastern Sierra Community Housing? And I don't know if it's fully on your shoulders, but I actually think that regardless, that's something that we should look at and make sure that, you know, the organization is fully compliant. And yes, I think that them helping us map out a growth plan for staffing and, you know, infrastructure as far as the growth for staffing, I think that could be super helpful as well.
47:41 Yeah, you know, CCRH has gone through, California Coalition for World Housing, I serve on their board, and they've hired a new Executive Director. She just had her one-year anniversary after being with the same ED since inception for 40 years, so a lot of changes happening and really positive, you know, internal systems coming up to speed, and they hired an HR consultant to help get their
48:11 Their workbook, or their, like, employment handbook, if you will, they've used a different term, but, you know, up to speed, in compliance, I think they could probably be somebody to consider looking at, since they're in the affordable housing realm, you hired somebody, Mono County just hired a third party to help, because we're struggling to find an HR director, but, you know, I think we're going to expand in the,
48:39 The management side by default because we have these units coming on. What I'm real trepidatious about and I've heard like Brian hinted and I've heard it from other people in the non-profit rural housing development world really regret expanding into property management because it is
49:03 It's hard to turn a profit to fulfill your mission. It's hard to make it work. It's laborious. And for me, sitting on this board and thinking about our communities, I would like for us to put more energy into putting people in homes. Those units in Bridgeport are going to happen either way.
49:26 They have already been bought and they are going to be affordable units, right? We're not jeopardizing preservation of anything. So I think I want us to think about it from that perspective somewhat too, personally. I think that's important. And I think if that's the direction, which that's, yeah, I agree and see some benefits of both, then it's...
49:50 gives, I think, clear direction when proposals do come our way, that we know, like, nope, we've already kind of given the pass on that, or we can provide these certain services, but that's where it ends. And maybe we can partner with another, you know, whoever it be, organization, local business, whatever, to, you know, consider some of our own.
50:14 I just think it would, yeah, if we came to that conclusion, it would give more clarity in the future, because yes, we will by default get a lot more opportunities. And I do agree that the proposal, Jarrett, is very professional. I was very impressed with it. Yeah, definitely. Thank you. I think staff direction is to bring back an item at a future meeting regarding possibly
50:51 an HR consultant proposal to maybe look at everything we talked about from compliance to job descriptions to growth staffing or moving into property management and what that would look like and start there and then do the work with the consultant to bring back something larger. Is that right? I believe so. Okay. Yep.
51:26 Thank you so much. Okay. So if that concludes item 4.2 in the agenda, are we ready to go back to the presentation on the audit financial statements? Yes, I believe Tom, our auditor, is on the line. Yeah, I'm on the line. You guys are ready. Hi, Tom. I think we're ready. Tom. Okay. Yes, we're ready. Yes. Okay. All right. Everybody can hear me?
52:03 Yes. Okay, so let's talk about the audit. And the first thing I'd like to just make sure the board all knows is that as the auditor, there's three kind of documents that tell us what this engagement is all about. Of course, the engagement letter, and I'm not sure if the board has read it, but it basically defines role, what it is, and it's a canned report, meaning the AICPA writes it, their attorneys.
52:32 So engagement letters for nonprofits are all pretty much the same. There's nothing special about it. There's a lot special about it, but nothing different about your engagement letter. Then there's another letter that's part of the audit, and it's the management representation letter. And that letter basically says that you give to me. Basically, it's the same thing. It's a canned letter. The lawyers write it. It basically states that
52:59 You've given me all of your information, and you sign that. So these two letters are the documents of what are we doing with the audit. It defines the whole arrangement, like a contract. And then the last letter is called the communications to management letter. I sent that over to
53:22 Patricia today, and I don't know if you had a chance to look at it, and it also is kind of a boilerplate letter, but there's room for any comments or findings in there, and most boards, what they want to know is, tell me what's wrong, what did you find, and there's only one thing that I want to kind of read to the board, and it was, there's a section in there called, Difficulties Encountered in Performing the Audit, and basically I encountered no
53:50 significant difficulties in dealing with management or in performing and completing the audit. However, there were a number of material adjustments that were needed to correct the financial statements as of June 30, 2024. And as a reminder, the board, management, and the staff are responsible for the internal control through their organizational policies and procedures over preventing and detecting any deficiencies in financial reporting.
54:21 It's your job to get that right. That was the only flaw, shall we say, was the financial reporting was kind of far off. Now, the key controls over disbursements, payroll, receipts, bank recs, those were all achieved. So the management company, your accounting company did a good job, but there were certain transactions they were uncomfortable with. And in the world of debits and credit,
54:51 You put, you have a debit, you have a credit, and when we got to the trial balance, there was an account called Ask the Accountant, and it had a lot of, like, six, seven hundred thousand dollars. So they didn't know where to put half of the entry for some of the transactions. So that's, that's my only comment on what we got when we showed up to do the audit. We've got it all in the right place now. You've got a, we call it a clean opinion.
55:19 So that's, if you've looked at the audit, that's in pages one and two, and that's what you want. Your financial statements, you're getting bigger. The only other comment I make is that you're presenting yourself on a combined basis. That means the nonprofit is grouped with your LLC. It's your family portrait. So you have several LLCs that you have that own.
55:48 Various developments. So this audit includes everything on page three. And you're looking right now, you're almost at 11 million in assets. So you're getting pretty big. On page four on your statement of activities, that's your income statement. You had a pretty good year this year. You had a bottom line profit of $753,000. That's really good. The feature...
56:15 Element of that was your developer fee. You picked up $371,000 in developer fee revenue, which is kind of a, you know, one-time or rare event, so that contributed to a big year for you, or the year end of June 30th. And you guys can read the footnotes that basically just describes your debts and other issues and your assets, what they're composed of, and the financing.
56:45 Back in the back of the audit, we split out the general operations and the LLC, so you can see how that all totals up to what's on pages three, four, and five. So your numbers look good. You know, you use QuickBooks, and you had a little hiccup with some of the transactions that you got through the year.
57:13 And now I know they have a new, you're going to be hiring a new accounting company. This one you have has given you notice, but hopefully you'll find somebody good and be able to continue with what you've been doing in the past. I want to do this quickly, so do you have any questions for me? The discrepancies that you noted in that, ask the accountant, account, did that have to do with the
57:47 Development activity that was ongoing throughout the year and also capitalized? Yes, they weren't sure on certain transactions. They're not common, so they didn't know where to put the credit, so to speak. The cash was all correct, but when you sold a condo, they weren't sure how to book that. Developer fee, weren't sure quite how to book that. Not anything big.
58:16 The numbers are big, but not, you know, it's fairly easy to straighten it out. Okay, thank you. So, I guess what I'm, my point is when you get, when the board gets a, let's say you look at the financials every month or every quarter, you weren't really getting a good set of figures to make any judgments on. They were not really accurate from the standpoint of, you know, bottom line. They were off, like, so,
58:49 And it was not, you know, like I said, the payment of the bills, the payroll, that's all good. Banks were reconciled, but there's these unusual, somewhat infrequent transactions through them a little bit. So that was my only comment, was internal control over reporting, which could have been a lot better. It's straightened out now, so I think you're good to go. But normally, auditors,
59:21 We're not in the business of fixing books. We're supposed to, you know, when we see something not right, we're supposed to throw the penalty flag and walk out. But that's not how we've traditionally done things. We have the flexibility to assist you, and that's what we did. Okay, and one other question from my perspective.
59:46 You have only been commissioned to do one consolidated audit for MLH. None of the other LLC or housing entities are separately audited. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. There's no separate report is what, you know, and they all have to file their own 568 for tax. I think they're all, you know, full member LLC, which in the past you've had another firm do that for you.
1:00:26 Tom, our next agenda item is also talking about some financial and accounting services. Do you have any experience working with your part-time controller or companies who utilize them? No, I've seen them at CPA continuing ed conferences, and they're fairly well thought of. I believe they're out of Phoenix, their main office, so they're in our time now.
1:00:57 I think they're pretty good, actually. Okay, thank you. Yeah. Is there any other questions from the board? Oh, there was one of what you're going to point out to the board. You have to do an audit under the uniform guidance because you have one loan that has ongoing requirements for eligibility.
1:01:32 In this, if you receive in either loans or federal funds, over $750,000, you're required to do a uniform guidance audit. So that's the type of audit that's done. In addition to a yellow book audit, which you have, there's other reasons for that. So those are the guidance that the auditors use to do your audit and why you have to do it is that under the uniform guidance, you have to do it.
1:02:00 Annually, if you receive over $750,000 in either loans or grants. So that's the bucket that you fall in as far as requirements for audits. They are talking about raising that to $1 million. So then if they did, then you would not have to do the uniform guidance anymore. I think that's going to happen next year, I believe. Is that for every year for so long as you're participating in that particular grant? Yeah.
1:02:32 It's a weird thing, the way they do it, usually it's grants, you know, and those are done in a year, but if you have a loan, they want you to continue to do the audit, it was $750,000, it still is, it's going up to a million, because they didn't want to drop a lot of, and it had to do with a lot of HUD projects with loans, they didn't want them to fall out of the net, so to speak, of federal audits, so they counted the loans, and it was because of the
1:03:02 The eligibility of the tenant, that was what they used as the reason to pick it up and count it. The CDBG loan that we have is for the acquisition rehab of Star Apartments, and it's in the financials. The amount is $853,000, I believe, and it's technically a loan to the town of Mammoth Lakes. And then, I'm not sure exactly,
1:03:31 I mean, we will have a multi-million dollar grant for access apartments under CDBG as well, so we'll work on how that. So that'll put your there, so you probably never get out of the single audit, so that's okay. Yeah. So if you get that money, you're going to have to show that if it's a loan. It'll stay on your, they call it a FIFA, Scheduled Expenditures of Federal Awards, it'll be there forever. I think it might be a grant. That's okay.
1:04:00 So, but we'll still have the Star Apartments loan. Yeah. And because you're a, you're a little complicated because you're, the nonprofit isn't holding the note, but one of your controlled entities is holding the note so that they make you put it on your combined audit and you have to go through the uniform guidance audit. So it's a little bit tricky. Okay. Well, any further questions from the board or comments?
1:04:38 So the item also has that we consider approval the audited financial statements. I motion to accept the financial statements as presented for the year ending June 30, 2024. All second. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Hearing none, we'll take a roll call. Angie, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp?
1:05:11 Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Motion passes. Yeah, thank you, Tom. Okay. Thanks so much. Patricia will be in touch on wrapping it up and any further discussion that we probably will have. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you, Tom. Have a good night. Thank you. Good night. Thank you. Okay. Bye. Bye. Bye-bye. Okay.
1:05:41 With that, we will move on to agenda item 4.3. The board will receive an update on the status of accounting and financial services and provide staff direction. Patricia. Thank you. Yeah, I thought this item was timely for this meeting. As we've mentioned in previous items already tonight, that we lost our bookkeeper, Diane, over a year ago.
1:06:08 At which time we did some extensive research on how to proceed and decided to go with a local accounting firm that I met with and described our unique needs and how the organization was growing and the types of real estate transactions that we do. And they were very comfortable with all that. In fact, they seemed pleased because we have a lot of work to do, so they wanted more work.
1:06:38 Right, which is great. They helped us with the transition to QuickBooks, which has been, you know, great now that we're sort of there. You know, it was a process. And obviously they've kept us, you know, up to date up through the audit and still today as best they can. But they've decided to terminate our relationship.
1:07:05 Because of the complexity of the work that we do. And they, you know, I don't think they expected the amount of journal entries, they're called in QuickBooks, where you have to credit one account and debit the other account. And that happens a lot in real estate transactions when, or if you have a loan, like we have a lot of loans with the town, but we pay them back. And there's a lot of back and forth.
1:07:34 They didn't quite have the capacity or maybe the knowledge on how to do that or didn't want to do it as regularly or felt like they couldn't meet that need anymore and I think there was a bit of a communication breakdown and so I'm glad we got through the audit. Tom is great. He has a lot of institutional knowledge and understands how those transactions work and so he's able to take on our complex
1:08:04 I'm glad that we were able to get through that. You know, I've been hoping that we would have updated quarterly financials for the board at this meeting. However, I don't think we're going to have them until the current firm transitions to somebody new and the new person can help get us something together.
1:08:35 ASAP. And so, as you know, last year we had this conversation. We spent a lot of time, you know, onboarding the new firm, working with them throughout the year. We're 12 months later now. And I feel as though we really need this expert support. Historically,
1:09:01 And so having that support of a firm that's able to book these types of transactions,
1:09:30 I've met with them, and they have assured me that we can have weekly communication, at least at the beginning, so that we can make sure everything's where it's supposed to be, so that we can get you those financial reports, ASAP. And so I'm confident, you know, I'm confident in what they told me that they were able to do that, and I know that they're a national firm, and so they do work with nonprofits specifically all over the country.
1:09:59 They assured me that they do work with affordable housing nonprofits. And one thing I like about this service is that we could start it up and cancel it at any time. And so if we did have an HR discussion about how we want to grow and where these roles would fall in four months from now, we could...
1:10:26 You know, terminate our relationship with this firm and move in that direction that the board's decided. I did provide some financial information, so there are some upfront costs. Our current firm said they would stay on through January 31st, and so I'd really like to get somebody on board ASAP so that there's not any overlap of time period where there's nobody.
1:10:58 I don't think that would be the end of the world, but it would really help all of us out if there was no gap in services. And I guess, you know, I provided the numbers. I don't know if you want me to go through all of them, but, you know, ultimately we will be collecting some property management fees and those fees could, you know, each property will have to pay their portion of what the accounting firm is doing for that LLC. And so anything
1:11:31 Above and beyond their costs, which is allocated in their operating budget, comes to Mammoth X Housing, which we can help to pay for the cost for the MLH organization for the accounting fees, the property management fee. And I guess, I think that the only thing I wanted to say was, or the last thing is that if I could spend all my time doing this, I would.
1:12:04 But we have a lot of other things going on. And so if this is an easy place where we can find somebody with expertise to fill the gap, I think I'd appreciate the support. May I ask how the pricing for YPTC compares to what we've been paying the local bookkeeper? I think that their estimate is higher. And I know it's because they're willing to commit more hours and more time.
1:12:43 And then may I ask like how Diane was a bookkeeper that worked at MLH or like if we've had a bookkeeper on staff how does this cost compare to the cost of having an in-house bookkeeper?
1:13:47 Diane came on and she took that position. So it was a full-time benefit. Since Diane left, we filled that position with our intern, who doesn't have a lot of bookkeeping experience, and we've grown to four active L's. And so we have a full-time benefit, historically had time allocated. Well, and if I could elaborate, just because I was...
1:14:33 There at that time, and I did that before Patricia came in. The part that you're leaving out, which was so helpful and critical, was Allegra. If you want to just talk a little bit about how it wasn't just you or me or Diane, there was Allegra, and that's what the shift was. When she retired, that's where we
1:15:00 We formed ourselves needing to hire the local firm. Yes, that's right. So I was thinking about that today as well, which we may have talked about it last year a little bit, but our accountant, our third-party accountant that we were using previously, Allegra, was really hands-on, and we would meet regularly to co-produce the quarterly financials so that the information she was pulling from the financial database
1:15:29 met our expectations of what actually happened with the transaction so that we could explain it to the board in a way that made sense to everyone. And so she retired, and so we didn't have anybody to do those journal entries or our taxes. And the financials. She did the financials. Right, and the quarterly and annual financial reports. She was a huge asset to the organization. And so part of that was, and what I was thinking about when I said,
1:15:59 Communication Breakdown is that we had really strong communication and regular meetings, and she knew what the transactions looked like, so she knew the questions to ask so that we could just answer them. And then when we moved to, you know, a new firm that wasn't as familiar, that broke down and we weren't able to get clear results quickly. And then I noticed it also said that YPTC, that they don't do tax returns. That's correct. So we would take care of that.
1:16:28 Through another entity? Yeah. And I don't know if this answers your question, Amanda, but in the documents that they provided last year, it's like $35 to $50 an hour. It's like a local bookkeeper fee. It was all the research compared to whatever their fee is. $265. Sorry. I have more comment. But I was going to ask a similar question on that. And I wasn't...
1:17:00 So they talk about that you can have a reoccurring subscription basis, an hourly rate, or another mutually agreed arrangement. What are they actually proposing? I couldn't kind of figure that out on there.
1:17:13 It depends, and I think to start, we would want to start hourly, but they offer a package of services with like data analysis and visuals and the opportunity to come and present to the board if we so wish and that we could, you know, have that on a monthly calendar if we have a monthly board meeting or quarterly calendar where we would like them to come and present that information so that we could say, okay, every month this is what we pay and this is what we get. Whereas I think right now to start,
1:17:43 They said they could start, you know, mid-December. We'd want to just get them up to speed on what the books look like so they could get everything in order. And then if we want more, if we want less, or if we want to do, because I'm not sure if we want to do this forever, you know, I think we just need it in the interim. Do you think that their recurring subscription model offers better pricing? When I met with them, we didn't talk about the subscription.
1:18:14 But what I liked about the hourly model was that we could terminate at any time. But maybe move, if we want to move forward with them, if the services are really valuable, maybe that's something I should ask. Well, it could be a transition point if we find that the service is well, it's working for us. You're not finding this ATC account.
1:18:42 Our ATA, what was it? Ask your accountant. File. You know, things of, you know, kind of some red flags. If you're not finding that and if it's going smoothly, then maybe a subscription model is, but maybe this is a good way to kind of enter it and almost, and see how it goes. It's on the hourly rate. And did you, how did you find these folks? Through Tom or?
1:19:10 No, they advertise on NPR, and also board member D'Andrea had mentioned them to me as well. Okay, great. Well, you know, not to tell you to go ask for another proposal, but I know IMACA, since I serve on their board, they just hired outside accounting because their controller retired in need after many years of service and they needed help.
1:19:36 I think we signed a three-year contract for a little over $100,000 or so for services. And I've been impressed. They do come to the board meetings. That's one of the things I would like to, you know, at least for while we're getting our feet back under us, maybe it would be helpful to have them attend a meeting here and there. And Amaka's books are a royal mess.
1:20:00 So if they can help IMACA, I think they could help us. If you want to ask Kelly for a referral, they do nonprofits and they do schools. Brian, do you have experience working with this firm then or it was just an industry referral? No, I heard them on NPR as well. Okay. I thought it might be worth learning more given our needs.
1:20:29 But it sounds like beyond the controller role, whether it's your part-time controller or someone else, we have a need for kind of some additional just basic bookkeeping, someone that's going to process the AR and the AP, right? Yes, yeah. So we still pay 90% of our bills through checks in the office. And we manage, I think there's seven bank accounts now. And many of them have their own checks.
1:20:57 Our hourly transaction coordinator that we've been utilizing for some of our real estate transactions has offered to put in some extra time to at least do the AP and AR until we find a more permanent solution or until she's no longer available, but for now she said that she's available I think no more than 10 hours a week.
1:21:27 And that's a separate person. And I think that's... And you think that's sufficient to handle our transaction volume? Yes. Okay. I just want to be clear. When I say come to our meetings, I don't mean physically. I mean zoom in.
1:21:48 We don't need to pay travel time. To pay the travel expense. Yeah, no, no, that's not what I meant. Sorry. And so at that lower level in office APAR, I think we're currently paying $45 an hour, which is sort of like a local bookkeeper pricing. But I think what I'm asking for here is a more professional look at our books and being able to book.
1:22:13 Complicated real estate transactions. And, you know, I really like to grow into tracking our time against our grants and expand in other ways with our financials. And so they've said that they can provide guidance on things like that because they specialize in nonprofits. So I'm interested to learn more about that later, but I'm hopeful that we could get, you know, some reports to you soon. I mean, I think it's
1:22:43 I don't think anyone's doubting that it's needed, or certainly I'm not, that you need that help to do all of those things that you just mentioned. I think it would be, I would have to assume a little bit more efficient to have, and I think just, I don't know, more streamlined and beneficial to have the same company do the tax returns that is doing the, you know, accounting reports and cleaning up the books. I think to have three
1:23:12 So they can do it?
1:23:46 They have the ability. Our auditor said they could do it. Oh, sorry. Tom said he could do it. But this firm does not do it. Oh, got it. Well, that would at least be, like, he's very knowledgeable in the, yeah. In our experience, we have our auditor do all of our non-profit, the 990 tax return for the non-profit and our LLC tax returns as well. So I think it's, I would agree that that would be helpful to have that domiciled in one place and minimize the number of different finance people.
1:24:17 And Tom does IMACA's audit and taxes as well. And so we just approved them at our last board meeting. He also used to do CCRH. I'm not sure if he still does. But yeah, so he knows affordable housing and he's capable of doing both. I mean, maybe, I guess the cost, I think we have to have somebody.
1:24:46 I guess since having gone through what Amaka just signed, I'm pretty sure it's a three-year contract, we did it under a little bit of a duress, I want to say in maybe October, but it was over a $100,000 contract over three years. And our books are much more complicated, much larger assets. I mean, I don't think we're going to get it for cheaper than what we have in front of us, honestly.
1:25:16 But you said $100,000 over three years. Yeah, for IMACA. Which is messier. And smaller. But we have bigger assets. Yes. And more LLCs. I mean, what company is that with? I don't know. I can't remember. I could go back and look while we're sitting here. Yeah. They're not local. No, no. Yeah. And I agree that I think it needs a company that is, you know, in this, an organization that knows this and in this industry. Mm-hmm.
1:25:45 Mm-hmm. I didn't see anywhere there was like a term proposed, so I'm assuming it's just sort of a month-to-month arrangement. Yeah. So there's no long-term obligation to... Correct. It seemed that way, yeah. So there's, you know, that meant to a degree we'll limit our risk, I guess. We can see how it plays out and see whether the services are adequate and where the costs start to come in and we can further refine or make changes if necessary. We don't want to come in to a year minimum or anything like that.
1:26:15 Is there is an $8,000 startup fee initially? Yes. Yeah. Yeah. I would like to learn about the company that Imaka went with if it's different to this one, which it sounds like it is. Not to send you back to the, you know, getting the proposals and more research, but, or I would at least like to see some, you know, is this standard industry pricing? Because.
1:26:49 It seems very high to me. I agree with you. I don't have anything to compare it to. It's not like we're looking at two external large organizations and they're both the same price. So this is what the market pricing is. I don't personally know. I know what local pricing is. So I would just maybe like some confirmation that, yes, this is market pricing. I'd love to find out what company Emaka just signed up with and could we get a proposal from them.
1:27:20 Because if I'm reading this right, you're saying it's a 77% increase on next year's budget. And that's just for one year, right? Charter impact is their name. Yes, under that line item. But that line item wouldn't have taken into account the time that our staff were previously spending on it. So that time for staff is gone, but that had a cost as well.
1:27:51 I mean, it's not gone. We still have the staff, but we don't have that time. You're not spending that time on it. Okay. And then year two, the costs increase by 2.5%? That was just my estimate. Just an estimate. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, I realize it's time sensitive with the other company given their notice, but if we can get a quick proposal from, sorry, what was the name? Charter Impact? My opinion that it would be worth it.
1:28:30 There was also another firm that we looked at last year called Jetasa. I know that Mono County First Five uses them. I think I have a meeting with them this week, so I can see if they'll draw up a quick revision to that proposal. But I do believe they're more expensive, so we can have that to look at as well. If we look at, if we get another proposal or a few more, we're looking then at our January board meeting to approve it.
1:29:00 And we have the deadline with the other company of January 31st. So that just starts to cut down on timing for the transition or time for the transition. Well, could we make a request of Patricia to get, you know, X amount of proposals and then go with the lowest one that provides all the services that we need? Or would we be able to make a motion like that so that that would ultimately be on her to select it but put specific parameters on it so that we wouldn't have to wait until?
1:29:37 January 6th or 7th. We have a special meeting at Christmas. Let's just do it Christmas Day, why not? Everybody's off. Yeah, I mean, I guess the only concern I might have on that is, I mean, I would probably want to see the agreement that we would, you know, just make sure we're comfortable with all the terms and so forth, like if we were going to commit to a longer time period, for example, right?
1:30:24 But I mean, to your point, Lindsay, if Patricia, I mean, it's kind of tough because we do have the holidays and everything, but maybe if the next couple of weeks you were able to have that outreach and get those proposals back and then we could, you know, go through it at the January board meeting and give you a direction, final direction and make a decision and you'd still have several weeks or more for the transition period with it. You think that would... Could we also ask the current company to extend their notice?
1:30:55 Being with two to three weeks of their notice time is like inoperable in the financial world with the holidays and whatnot. True. I think it's worth asking them. I don't know how much of a benefit it would be really. Well, yeah, if it's of no benefit, but if we're up against the clock and we're still reviewing proposals and we're making a decision based on, oh, it's three weeks till the other company terminate or whatever.
1:31:22 Yeah, I can ask the other firms, like, what their proposal start date would be. Maybe you can find another Allegra in the meantime. I forgot about Allegra, she was great. So good. Okay, is there any further discussion? Patricia, do you have any questions? It sounds like staff direction is to pursue another, at least one other proposal, hopefully two, and bring them back to the January meeting.
1:32:09 If for some reason these other companies say, no, we're not taking on new clients, are we comfortable moving forward or do we still need to wait for the next meeting? Well, and I guess I would also say I'm also bringing back a consulting, HR consulting firm proposal at the January meeting as well. Well, you may not have that by January. Early January.
1:32:34 Well, hopefully I would. No, I don't know that you're going to get a response between now and January, whatever, from that, but I love your ambition. Yeah, you've got to get it done. But, you know, I will say that the Impact Charter, they have a section, they have staff dedicated to the nonprofits.
1:32:59 And they just hired someone new. And it seems like they're expanding. I didn't get the impression that they were at capacity. They were, they don't, they seem vibrant is the word that comes to mind. That sounds good. Okay. Okay. All right. If no further discussion, then we'll move on to agenda item 4.4. The board will consider the merits of an application to the California Coalition for Rural Housing.
1:33:30 Rural West Internship Program for Diversity in Nonprofit Housing and Community Development. Patricia. This is the capacity board meeting. We didn't apply for an intern last year. And the year before, we weren't able to recruit one, I believe. And so the application deadline is coming up. It comes around this time of year. And I usually ask the board what
1:34:01 If we would like to apply to receive an intern, I think that there's a lot of work to do and a lot of need for help in the office and that possibly having an alternative job position, you know, alternative to full-time benefited but, you know, part-time intern maybe could attract different talents.
1:34:32 I'm open to pursuing an application for the internship. It's not a difficult application for me to fill out. The California Coalition for Rural Housing is very familiar with our organization and the challenges we face, so they're very supportive and flexible with us when we need it around recruitment and things like that. So I'm open to it, and I wanted to make sure the board had an opportunity to weigh in.
1:35:07 Is there a cost to apply or it's just your time? Just time. Thanks. Could they do bookkeeping services? That's an answer. Yeah, that was my only question was do you have time to put in the application and do the recruiting and everything? Yes, yeah. CCRH does a lot of the recruiting efforts and I usually support. But yes, I think it's worthwhile.
1:35:46 for the amount of time that it takes. I did want to say, you know, they can take other things off other staff members' plates that could make time for more financial attention. I mean, I think since your other presentation was talking about how are we going to expand our staff and where do we need help, I mean, as long as you're comfortable taking on an intern, I feel like we had this discussion last year and you were like, I don't think I can take on that responsibility right now.
1:36:20 I think that it, I think it would be beneficial if you think that it's something that we could do and would be beneficial to your team. Yeah. I think so. If we can find one. And there's that. Okay. Great. So that was just feedback for you, right, Patricia? I think you should provide a motion with direction. Okay. Please. Anybody would like to make a motion on this agenda item?
1:36:56 I'll make a motion to submit an application to the California Coalition for Rural Housing, Rural West Internship Program for Diversity in Nonprofit Housing and Community Development. I'll second. Okay, it's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Seeing none, we'll take a roll call. Angie, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Step? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes.
1:37:28 Board Member DeAndrea. Board Member DeAndrea, how do you vote? Thank you. Sorry, yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. All right, motion passes. Moving on then to agenda item 4.5, the board will receive updates on current construction projects, the Innsbruck Lodge and the Access Apartments. And I believe Eric's going to take this one. Yeah, I got this one. So you updated the picture with snow on the ground.
1:38:23 Yep, I have to get a new picture in there. Keep it exciting, you know. We're all excited about the snow. Yeah. So this is the presentation for Itzbrook Lodge. As you can see, this was last week when we took this picture for December 2nd meeting. This is our some construction photos. So all these are from the bottom units. There is updates for the upper units, but...
1:38:50 As you can see, the bottom units are coming along. Those are the only ones that are left currently. We did do the punch walk for the upper units, you'll see in the next slides, but those are completed, but this is what's next to come, so this is what we'll be focusing on for the next month. So project updates, like I said, the upper units, so that's one through five are completed. We did the punch walk on the upper units were completed on the 25th of last month.
1:39:19 And then the lower units will be, we'll do a punch walk on Thursday, I believe. Our project manager's gonna be up here, Kevin's gonna be up here on Thursday. So we'll be doing a sidewalk either with our GC, which is our general contractor, or his project supervisor. So either one of those two, we'll be out there doing that. Lease up for, I guess, for November, December. So the next 10 units, we're gonna start to be
1:39:47 I'm doing the lease of process with them, which you saw and Jared are going to be working on. So they'll eventually start calling people to update their, what is it, their assessment. So they'll be working on that. We did have one unit that was vacant, which is now, has now been leased to temporarily, correct? The unit's been temporarily leased. Oh, yes.
1:40:15 Okay. Yes. Yep. So we have a unit that's been temporarily released, and then just a frame of reference, our vacancy lasted less, a week or less. So we have pretty good turnover on that side of it. The other good thing on this, I mean, apart from our property manager, he's been doing a lot of work, especially now that it's been snowing. So he's been shoveling the parking lot, and then he's been working on keeping everything safe.
1:40:45 And then the other big thing that we have is that we now have internet on the property. So on last Saturday, the property manager and Spectrum, they worked together on Saturday to get all the units, I believe, except the one, which that one is being coordinated this week to be added internet. So that's a good thing. We got internet now on the property. So there's construction updates.
1:41:14 So stuff that was completed, so the lobby windows, the main windows are done. The punch rock, as I mentioned before, that was completed before on the 25th. And then doors were installed the 8th. So we have that. And then what's left is the switch gear, which that we have scheduled to arrive in January. And then additional work would be the exterior roof remodel and then the lower units, like I mentioned. We still have the appliances, the countertop.
1:41:43 Plumbing and Art Punch Walk and then some other other miscellaneous items and then in conjunction with that we talked to GC today and he will be having the painters and the floors go there this week so he can get that started and hopefully we'll be finished with the lower units by the end of December.
1:42:11 This is our development budget. So as of right now, we have spent 94% of our development budget. Here's a little graph in case you guys are visuals. And that includes our contingency as well. And there's just a little bit of background. You guys have seen this part already. And that's the end of it. Do you guys have questions on it? So just...
1:42:42 I just need to clarify here on the budget, the development budget here. So you're showing an original budget and our actual budget, and we're overrunning by almost a million. But that was the $6.9 million, we've got that adjusted funding for that, right? Yeah, this is a comparison of the original budget before we received additional funding from the town. Okay, so we are at this point, I mean, I guess what I would like to see is just
1:43:13 Maybe add to this for future ports is just our sources of funding so we just know that we're within our funded amounts. Yes, and then you'll notice in the audit there is a liability booked against the Innsbruck Lodge for costs expended by MLH, but that's all accounted for in the numbers that Eric is reporting.
1:43:47 Okay. Oh, and then another question on access then, just in terms of the other 10 units that will be, I guess, in theory available by hopefully the end of January, I'm guessing, something like that maybe? Maybe. If the switchgear shows up mid-January and we anticipate a couple weeks for them to sort of finish up hooking that in and getting those units energized and something like that. So February 1st roughly might be, or
1:44:25 You guys, I know you said there was quick turnover and everything else, but no concerns or issues with just having people, you know, work through your application process and then they're ready to be signed up in at least units? There's no shortage of households in the coordinated entry system, which you can see in the programs update for the region, homeless households. The only issue I foresee
1:44:55 which is imminent, is that Isara's last day is on Friday, and so we do have a staffing capacity issue. She's done a great job getting Jared up to speed, and so I'll be supporting him through that process. Okay. All right. And then I guess my other question in regards then to getting the property fully leased out would be maybe at
1:45:27 at the appropriate point, you know, maybe in February or March, board meeting, sort of get an update on our rent roll, our assumptions in our original budgeting for AMI levels and rent roll and where we are with the actual lease out and if we're, you know, our cash flow is looking to be per our original budgeting or how that's trending. Yes, yeah, absolutely. I just talked to our property manager this morning about
1:45:54 The operating budget and, you know, what, how much can we allocate for, you know, supplies for the, for the site, you know, we have purchased some shovels and, you know, some things to get by, but he thinks we, you know, we might need a snowblower, right, to blow around the propane tanks, and so I told him I would start taking a look at that maybe this week, so yeah, certainly in the next couple months we'll have a working operating budget. Yeah.
1:46:24 Remind me on the rent, the AMI levels anticipated, our ranges were up to 80, right? The rents are set, all of the units except for two, the rents are set at 80% AMI, and there's two units at 30% AMI. Okay, so we're failing at those assumed rates at this point? At this point, yes, but a lot of, you know, hand, you know,
1:46:56 percentage of our tenants are receiving assistance through various means, rental assistance through the county, different departments, and we also have two sources of rental assistance that we've received for Innsbruck Lodge as well. So if they're not able to pay the full rent, we can help cover the difference for a short period of time, at least to get them started. Great. Any other questions from the board?
1:47:26 Okay, well, I guess we can move on to access. Eric, please. So next one is access. That's lovely pictures. Again, updated the beginning picture. So these are progress photos from 1121. I also have new progress photos from today, so I'll be sharing those as well. But this, you can see, the first two pictures are building A, and then the bottom ones are just street views of what's been going on in the property.
1:48:08 Our construction budget, so we have change orders and those have been approved. We're currently on pay at four, which we've submitted to the town and we're working with them to get that paid out. And then so with that, those approved change orders, our bid has increased by approximately 1%. You can see on the right side what the actual percentage is. And then as of now, the new bid spent that we've used is 29%.
1:48:38 There's that one. Okay. Development budget. You can't see that. Okay. Well, as of now, we spent 58% of the budget. Again, you can see the breakdown on the left side from our original budget and then where our actual budget is. We can change that over, Tom, to what you suggested for Innsbruck. No, so the...
1:49:11 The, you're talking about the image? Yeah, the graphic, I changed it. It wasn't updating, it wasn't populating, right? So I changed it to that one. Yeah. Yeah, and I didn't look how it looked, so. We got updates. Okay, project updates. So we are still meeting with our owner, architect, and contractor on a weekly basis. And like I mentioned, for our financing, we're working with the town already. We've submitted pay at four.
1:49:47 So we're working with them on that, and then we're working on getting our pre-development reimbursement stuff to the town. So that is still a work in progress, but we're working on that. Sitewalk is, so we have a scheduled, we got updated schedule as well, but, so it's gonna change a little bit, but we're planning on having a sitewalk with our program, our PM on the 10th.
1:50:16 of this month, so on Thursday, I believe it is, next Tuesday, or next Monday, I guess it didn't change. So next Monday, we'll be having a site walk with Kevin on access as well, and then miscellaneous stuff, so our section four grant closed, which is good, and then milestones were still set to have occupancy by fall of 2025, so that's all good, it's still tracking.
1:50:46 For us to finish, here is where there's a change. So to my understanding, everything is mostly the same. The rough electrical was completed by the 27th. And then we got updates. So the siding will be installed on building A by the 20th of December. And then on building B, we will have
1:51:15 The garage door will be installed again by the 20th. The rough plumbing, that has been pushed a week out, so that will be finished on the 18th. And then the building ramp was pushed out two days, and that will be finished by the 11th. So, we just got a little bit delayed because of the storms, but we're still keeping on track with the expected schedule. These are just funding sources. You guys have seen this.
1:51:43 If you guys have questions, just stop me along the way. Background, so a little bit of background, and then that is the end. Oh, and I can show you guys actually updated pictures. Okay. Let's start sharing. So these are pictures from today. So that is building B. It's been wrapped. That is still building B, or it's building A on the left side. That's the front side.
1:52:19 So they're installing porches already. That's just another image. Oh, that's the end of it. So those are the most current up-to-date pictures that we have. And the second floor on Building B was all new construction, right? Yes. Yes, that was all new. I just wanted to say, I know Eric mentioned a few, you know, couple-day delays, but I drove by during the storms and when it was really cold, and there were...
1:52:56 Guys still working. So I think that's why we're still on schedule. They're working really hard out there. Yeah, there was several. I drive past multiple times a day. My office is right in front of it. And yes, there was guys shoveling a lot every time I drove past. More shoveling. So yeah, they're for sure out there. Yeah, I guess I would just point out that on the development budget recap there, again, I think we need to refine that a little bit just to kind of have that incorporate the
1:53:38 Sources of funding and the totals. So this is a quick look at, okay, where are we on our total funding and our estimated forecast to complete and where we're running over and under. And, you know, I see you're reflecting in the original budget versus the actual budget that, you know, we're over $270,000 with, you know, related to some of the change orders, I presume, and some of their costs. You know, we still are carrying our contingency of $740,000. So overall, the project, we've got bandwidth to.
1:54:07 to absorb those overages. So again, I think it's, I think we could need to be helpful if we could settle into a pretty consistent format in presenting this information. So for the board, it's really quick for us to look and not have to decipher numbers and just go, okay, this was originally the approved budget, this is where we are now, this is our approved funding, we're within our funding, or we're not. Kind of like what, not the original budget, but like.
1:54:34 What's our finance budget? Like, what's our current budget that we're working off of? And are the numbers up from that or down from that? And are we within our current budget? Yeah. Yeah. You just need to be able to know right away with a quick summary if there's clear, like, okay, or, oh, we're going over our funding, we're going to need to go back to town, ask for some help, or what, right? So, I think. I agree with you, yeah. I think it needs to be, we need to.
1:55:01 Needs to be a cleaner, consistent format on that. I think we'll see if we can work with that maybe in the development committee and help you out. But otherwise, I think it's, yeah, Manitia's just really been, you know, real troopers getting through this weather and, you know, and certainly there was some challenging conditions there for a few days for sure. And unfortunately, we're getting a little bit of a break for them to, you know, get it to a point where they can keep working through the winter, it looks like.
1:55:35 That's fantastic news on that front for sure. They've gotten a lot done when you think about when they started what effectively begin in September, end of August, September really. So that's been remarkable. Okay. Any further questions for staff on any of the development projects? Okay. If not, we will move on then to agenda item 4.6. The boarder will receive updates on other program activities.
1:56:12 Yes, I will take over from here. So first things first, we usually start with the rental programs and unfortunately there has not been any units available. Buckingham Property Management is Buckingham.
1:56:26 Did I say that? Yeah. Pluginium is still working on trying to rehab the units that are currently sitting big in Aspen Village. There have been community members who have come to our office asking about those units since they know that people moved out of them. We usually just give them straightforward information. They're being rehabbed, and we don't have a date for when they'll be filled. Our wait list, our rental wait list is actively still growing. All of the applicants are still under 80% AMI.
1:56:55 The applicants that are applying right now, if they are homeless, we also give them an appointment to do coordinated entry system, which is a homelessness database. And then as Patricia mentioned previously, this is my last board meeting, unfortunately. I am very excited to start this new chapter in my career, but leaving Eastern Sierra Community Housing is not easy. It is with a heavy heart.
1:57:19 I'm truly grateful for the opportunities and the growth that I've experienced in this role. Our staff has worked really hard to make differences in the lives of families in Inyo, Mono, and Alpine County. The work that we do is very important, and it's an honor to be part of it, or to have been a part of it when I was. The great thing is that we have Jarrett Mendez.
1:57:38 And Jarrett has been a great trooper, taking in so much information over the past week and a half, more or less. He's really jumped on board with a lot of the projects that we have going on, rental wait list, Star Apartments, the rental capacity, not rental capacity, all of the payments that have to come in through Star Apartments and then through Innsbruck Lodge, the lease of process, the tenant selection plan, data reporting, it really is a lot to digest.
1:58:08 Props to you, Jarrett. So Innsbruck Lodge, currently we do have five of the units, four of the units occupied. Unfortunately, we did have a passing of one of the tenants not in the unit. He was in very bad condition and he passed away in Reno Hospital in Reno. So we are currently...
1:58:31 Our office is grieving that the caseworkers and the team that he worked with is also grieving through that process. We're kind of giving the family time to process what they need to do with the funeral and everything, so we're not having them rush into going to get his stuff out of the unit anytime soon. The other unit was sitting empty, but as Eric mentioned, it really did not sit vacant for more than a week. We really pulled from the coordinate entry system and put a family.
1:59:00 A single mom and her son in that unit temporarily while we get Birch Creek unit fully available so that she can move in with her son. Yes. So that tenant specifically, he had been homeless, chronically homeless for about eight years. Inyo County had been working with him since 2014.
1:59:25 So it really was a blessing in disguise for him to be able to have a house of his own before he passed. I know that he was very grateful to our office, to the Inyo County team, to Mono County APS as well to be working with him for so long and being patient, having to work through not just his medical conditions but family issues that were going on, financial issues that were also presented to us. So we know that even though he did pass.
1:59:53 Our team feels very content with the fact that he felt very grateful. He felt very humble, and you can really see the attitude that he had from the moment that we gave him housing, and our office is very content with that. Moving on to Birch Creek. It is still vacant, but like I mentioned, the family that is in Innsbruck hopefully will be going into Birch Creek. We don't have an estimated specific time of when they'll go in.
2:00:26 It's just a matter of making sure that the unit is habitable since the last tenant did more or less of an okay job keeping it up to date, but there's a lot of cleaning, carpet, walls, kitchen, windows, all of that stuff that needs to be taken care of. Through rental subsidies, as per our last meeting we did, the board did grant our office to use the ESG funding, and currently we are going to be using the funding for two families.
2:00:56 Already that we have proposed the fund that we have proposed to pay their rent and their security deposit. As more tenants come up with the Inspiric Lodge, Jarrett will also be working with the ESG funding grant to make sure that they have the security deposit or any other emergency rental subsidies that they need. Meanwhile, since we do know that Stanislaus County is not taking any more mainstream voucher referrals, it's made things.
2:01:23 A little difficult on our side to make sure that the tenants are not worried about being able to pay for the rent to get housing. And then we are also, Jarrett and I will also be meeting with the parcel property manager, Rodrigo, hopefully this week, to kind of introduce Jarrett, kind of his role as a housing navigator. What I've done previously is just being liaison communication with the property manager and the tenant. Or not, I guess future tenant or applicants.
2:01:55 We have helped two of the participants that were part of our homelessness project did go into the parcel. One of the tenants that were in Innsbruck also moved into the parcel. So communication with the parcel in our office is very crucial because we help that communication between the tenant who is going from homelessness to...
2:02:16 Permanent housing, figuring that out, and then going to Buckingham Property Management to figure it out with credit checks, making sure that their rent is paid on time, no late fees, their bills, because they have to pay their own bills at that point. All of that is really needed for me and Jarrett to be able to do with the participants in our projects, moving them on to a different project. So the quarantine entry system is still growing. Me and Jarrett are doing assessments. He has done two assessments thus far in the last week.
2:02:48 So he's definitely getting the hands-on experience to do the assessments and not just do follow the questions but also be able to talk to the clients through their trauma, through some of them through PTSD, and he's doing case management courses as well to be able to support clients through that assessment since although that is just yes or no questions, some of the questions could be triggering for a lot of the clients and participants that we work with.
2:03:17 Then through the continuum of care, me and Jarrett attended a Inyo County pit count, point in time count, for the point in time count that is going to be happening January 30th on 2025. We are actively looking for volunteers, not just Mono County, but Inyo County as well. Inyo County does have a very bigger, wider range that they have to look for. I think at our meeting, me and Jarrett heard someone that was saying that they went out into like the desert.
2:03:46 And they have to have like a four-wheel drive car and they're just having a hard time seeing transportation and getting them there and making sure that they're getting benefits and making sure that they're on programs. So we are actively looking for volunteers if any of the board members are interested or if any of the board members know of anyone who would be interested in volunteering for the pit count. Not just in Mono County, but Inyo County, they don't have to be Mono or Inyo residents. And I believe that is the end of...
2:04:17 Staff updates. We did, let me scroll down really quickly. I think our office is also looking forward to possibly doing another credit building course that we hosted for the community in November. Unfortunately, it is my fault. I had scheduled it for the 5th of November, which was the day for voting. So we did not have a great turnout since everybody was voting. So our plan is to hopefully do one in January, hosted by Eric and Jarrett, to
2:04:47 Kind of strike the community to do New Year's resolutions, making sure if they want to buy a house, you know, how do they start that since that is a time when a lot of people are like, this is my goal by the end of the year, this is what I want to do. So I think that's the perfect time to reach out to the community about any, not just educational seminars that we can hold, but any classes that we can hold for them as well. And then I think that is the end, unless Patricia, would you like to add something?
2:05:18 Does the board have any questions? How many units are in rehab by Buckingham? I unfortunately don't have a number. Buckingham has not released the number of units that are sitting vacant. I think the last time that we had talked to them, they had said three, but there could be more potentially, but I'm not, I can't give you an exact number for that. Thank you. Yeah. I guess on rental,
2:05:52 I just wanted to mention that, you know, all of the coordination that ISARA has been doing and our housing navigators have been doing with the parcel isn't specifically contracted service through Buckingham or the town. I think... Jennifer, I had a number for you for the parcel. So there...
2:06:24 Oh, I'm sorry. Well, I mean, that's interesting. With Buckingham. Oh, I'm sorry. I misheard your question. They have units sitting vacant at like Aspen, Jefferies, and maybe Manzanita. Folks have moved out of those units onto the parcel. And they haven't filled them. They're rehabilitating them because they're about 20 years old. But I was curious, how many units are they rehabilitating? How many units are sitting vacant? Is there a timeline? That's a good question. I'll see if I can get some answers for you. Oh, thank you.
2:06:53 Yeah. I think one of the, I will mention one of the clients or participants that is, that went into the coordinated entry system that we are seeing if we can get her and her daughter housed at Innsbruck Lodge, did, was living with her in-laws at the Aspen Village unit and when they left that unit has been sitting empty since. So I think they are taking and
2:07:16 Not a bad thing, but I think they're taking the opportunity when tenants leave that they're just sitting vacant so they can have time to fix them before filling them up again. Yeah, I think that's great. I was just curious, you know, how many are we talking about? It takes time. Construction's always longer than you think. I just wanted to say that that service that ISAR has been providing isn't specifically contracted or called out for in any of our contracts with any of our partners coordinating occupancy at
2:07:48 The Parcel specifically. And I don't know if any of our clients were recipients of services through Mono County or Alpine County through those contracts specifically. But I did want to let the board know, I don't even think it's in here, that I have been in conversation with Mono County Social Services to renegotiate the final
2:08:14 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:08:44 It appears that, you know, our partner should be paying for the full amount of the services because we're not getting the time that we agreed to. So is that retro then? It's only for the final year of the contract, which is this current year, and it ends in June, June 30th, and so we're working to renegotiate a renewal of that as well. Okay. Well, you know, I think that's
2:09:14 Perfect timing to talk about staffing too because if we had budgeted 20% of two folks and we're not spending that, now we've got that to put into a new position potentially given what you just said. Good timing. Yeah. Homeownership is like happening. I know it doesn't maybe look like it on paper but we showed
2:09:51 We have a bunch of units, I think, right before Thanksgiving. We have a household interested in the Forest Meadows unit that we purchased with a loan from the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We have the one-bedroom at Meridian Court with a couple of clients in queue that we're working through to transfer that directly to an eligible client and save time and money.
2:10:20 I'm constantly in communication with the town about how much subsidy our clients really need between 120 and 150 percent of the area median income. A lot of the pricing was done at the higher level and we're not seeing as many clients at that purchase price point. It's usually just over the 120 percent limit, which requires more subsidy. So we're constantly talking about that.
2:10:47 The volatility of the HOA dues right now and other things around homeownership. So if there's any questions, Eric and I are happy to answer any of those, but there's a lot going on there. We're not in escrow on anything right now, though, so that's good. I guess I wanted to...
2:11:14 Just update you that Eric and I are working on a request for proposals for architectural services at Valley Apartments in preparation of a grant award from HCD through the PRP program, which we applied to twice. So I haven't received anything in writing, but we are moving forward with that when we have time. So we are working on that, RFP specifically. And then
2:11:42 There has been some peripheral conversations about a safe parking program and what, if any, our role could be there. If anything becomes substantial, I'll bring it back to the board. And then on the last page, I think there's a lot of things. I've been doing a couple of mandatory trainings that are required. We are moving our office storage unit.
2:12:11 Which is supposed to happen this week. We'll see how that goes. Other admin things I need to work on. Oh, we got our first participant in the chip-in credit card processing fundraising. I haven't had a lot of time to spend on that, but Greg, our partner, Greg Garfield, has been hitting the ground as much as he can, trying to get people to sign up. We did get, I should have provided that.
2:12:46 Do it next time. We did get a graphic design showing both of our logos combined, and it says we support community housing so that participants, if they want to advertise that, they can. And then we're offering also to put their logos on our website as supporters. And so we'll receive our first donation into our bank account at the end of this month, I believe, and that will be for the month of November. And so it's retro one month, and
2:13:15 Our accountants will have to figure out how to reconcile that once we get them on board. So that's exciting. And then we have a few upcoming items next month. We talked about a few proposals that we need. And I wanted to remind you that we'll be appointing new officers. So if anyone's really vying for president, prepare your speech for the next meeting.
2:13:43 I haven't had a lot of time to coordinate on the town contract, but I know we have a committee established and that we need to start scheduling meetings for that, so that's on my mind. I think that's it for now. Okay. Any questions from the board? Any of those long list of tasks and work items? Okay. No questions, but just a quick comment to say thank you, Asara, for your hard work and all your services, and I'm sure.
2:14:19 The team is sad to lose you. I certainly feel the same way, but wish you all the best in your new endeavors. They'll be lucky to have you. Thank you. I appreciate it. I don't think I would have been able to do any of it without Patricia's leadership and the board's help and support through all of that. So thank you to all of you. Yeah. We'll miss you. When did you start? How long has it been? About close to two years? Two years. I started in October 2022.
2:14:49 Yeah, that's what I thought, yeah. Yeah. Wow. So two years. Well, thank you so much. Yeah. Of course, thank you guys. Yeah. We know we'll see you around town, I assume, so we'll see. Yes, probably, hopefully. Yes. I'll be volunteering for the pit count. We're looking for a lot of volunteers. Okay. But yeah, thank you guys. All right. Well, terrific.
2:15:15 Okay, we will move on to item 4.7. The board will receive a recap of the 2024 Rural Housing Summit. I think Jarrett is our staff member reporting on this. Yeah, well, I have a nice little recap for you guys. Hopefully it ain't too long. On opening day of the Rural Housing Summit, the speakers gave a land acknowledgement for respect to the indigenous communities of California.
2:15:42 Then we had a 2024 policy update in What Comes Next session. This session focused on California housing propositions post-election. After, we took a moment to recognize young professionals and recent interns of housing organizations. On day two, we listened to speakers discuss federal and state policies and their impact on California communities. Speakers spoke about the unique challenges faced by rural and tribal communities, as well as federal initiatives that influence rural housing.
2:16:11 After that, we broke off into a sub-sessions offered. I went to New Faces, New Places, a networking opportunity for first-time attendees and met many people in housing and we shared what we do in our fields and our experience in housing. In the next session, Finding Home, we discussed homelessness in rural communities and the limitations of federal funding. While funds cover construction, they often fail to cover operational costs, leaving shelters unsustainable.
2:16:38 Proposition 1 was also in discussion as this new funding is being worked on now and policies are being drafted. The last session I attended was disaster resilience and recovery. This session reviewed federal and state responses to natural disasters, successful strategies, and delays in recovery funding. This conference was a great opportunity for learning about rural housing and the many successes and barriers to affordable housing. Thank you. Thank you, Jarrett. There's a lot of good topics there.
2:17:10 You know, certainly with, you know, unfortunately, natural disasters have struck Mono County here on a couple occasions, and we know North County are still recovering from that fire from several years ago, so it's always a challenge. Definitely. Hopefully, see many more of those things happening anytime soon. Okay. Thank you, Jarrett. Thank you, Jarrett. Thank you, Jarrett. Thank you. Does anybody have any questions for Jarrett? Okay. Alrighty.
2:17:40 We'll move on then to Item 4.8. The Board will consider approval of a contract for services with the City of Bishop. And I'm assuming Patricia will handle this one? Yes, yeah. After our last meeting, I went back and met with the City of Bishop staff and discussed
2:18:02 Refining some of the comments from our attorneys, which they were okay with, and then also refining some of what we could offer in terms of additional services, such as an annual meeting program update where we present to the Bishop City Council on this work program, but also what else we're doing in the region. After the city
2:18:30 went back and reviewed our comments. They accepted most of what our attorney proposed, so that was great, but they chose to opt out of some of our other services, including grant reporting, which we've historically assisted with for a few different grants, and also the annual meeting. So I think it might say as requested, but so I think
2:19:01 You know, talking about staffing and capacity and knowing when to say no, you know, that might be an area where we might not be able to go to a meeting because we can't just go to all these meetings. And so I did ask to change the term from five years to three years so that we would have, you know, an opportunity, a scheduled opportunity to renegotiate.
2:19:32 So what you have before you is what we have agreed on at a staff level, but I'm happy to take any questions or comments. So the contract price is a total of $16,600. That's for three years combined. So it's a pretty nominal amount of work.
2:20:09 But you said, I see the comment that it doesn't include the cost of working on subordinations. Is that above and beyond? They'll pay an hourly rate on that? Correct. Okay. And is it a fixed hourly rate or is it that current hourly rate? I'm sorry, I don't, I didn't see it. Yeah, it should be the current year hourly rate and then I've escalated them in year one, year two, and year three. Okay, perfect. Thank you. There's just,
2:20:40 I would find it difficult to put a set price on something like that since it depends on every case. Okay. Any other questions from the board for Patricia? So I believe you're looking for an approval so you'd like to have a roll call on this one? Yeah, I'll make a motion to approve the contract as presented with the amendments with the City of Bishop. Second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion?
2:21:20 Okay, Angie will take roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Berkstow? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Staff? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay, motion passes. With that, we'll move on to agenda item 4.9. The board will discuss the current open CalHOME grant, 21-CalHOME 17191.
2:21:52 Program status and provide staff direction. Patricia. Yes, thank you. I'm going to just share some slides from Goldfarb and Lipman, our legal counsel, and Raphael's on the line as well, if he can offer some clarity on any of this. And so in 2021,
2:22:19 There was a NOFA release for the Cal Home Program, which is state funding, and the board decided to apply for mortgage assistance, which, as I mentioned before, is sort of our bread and butter program, but also to add a homeowner rehab program, which included construction of an ADU as an eligible activity. And so, Diane and I, and I think Eric worked on that application.
2:22:48 And we were awarded almost a million dollars for those two programs. The program can assist households earning below 80% of the area median income. And so historically, at least within the town, we haven't had a lot of homeowners below 80% AMI that needed rehabilitation. But we had that grant, I think it was in 2013, so we thought we would try it again.
2:23:19 And this time our service area can include all of Mono County. So we can serve the entire region of Mono County with mortgage assistance and rehab or construction of an ADU. To date we have completed one mortgage assistance loan in Walker for a family working locally. And so
2:23:50 We have a qualified applicant for the ADU program, and we've been doing some analysis on how to move forward with this loan program. And so the loan is up to $250,000 to construct an ADU on your property. The Cal Home program works as a reimbursement to us, and so we would finance out
2:24:25 the $250,000 to the applicant or the contractor and then at the end of certificate of occupancy we would apply for the reimbursement from the state. I wanted the board to discuss this considering there's various the the board would have to approve any loan agreement you know of this amount with any with any entity and also
2:25:06 conceptualizing how to move forward with this program and what funding is available from our resources in order to do this. We do have a CalHome reuse pot, which you've probably seen in the financials. That is funding that is paid back through our mortgage assistance program, so clients that are making payments on their mortgage assistance loans make payments to us and we record them onto the books.
2:25:36 And that money goes into the CalHome Reuse pot for the next person. Currently, there's about $66,000 in that account. And so it doesn't cover the full $250,000 that's available if needed to an applicant that was proposing to do an ADU. I'm going to see if Raphael wants to jump in and say anything before. Good evening.
2:26:11 Thank you for having me. I've been helping Patricia analyze the CalHome program and just wanted to discuss a couple of risks that are associated with specifically the ADU construction program. And Patricia identified the first, which is who pays for the construction? Is it the home?
2:26:41 The second is just
2:27:10 As with any other construction, being involved in Innsbruck and Access, I know how fickle these projections can be and what you think is a starting construction price.
2:27:29 might not be what the ending construction cost is, and so what happens with cost overruns is another risk, and then the last risk is depending on the other two, if and to the extent there is default, let's say that the ADU isn't completed, what are the risks to
2:27:58 The Parcel, Jennifer Halferty, Ph.D.: One is obviously the need to complete the unit. And in theory, you could use some of the additional at home money to finish the project. But there's also risk that you might be required to repay.
2:28:26 funds back to the state. So, in essence, the program is very complicated. It will require us to submit an underwriting review guidelines to HCD for their approval. And in that, we would want to consider
2:28:54 Are there maximum costs that we want to put in, that Eastern Sierra is willing to help cover, whether it be a bridge loan or not, and then the idea of how the program requirements can be satisfied, because part of the issue is that
2:29:23 They require property fire and potentially flood insurance. I don't think flood insurance is going to be a requirement up in Mammoth, but it is a potential requirement. And so it's just a pretty robust requirements that may make it difficult for
2:29:48 I think this is my sense is that this would be kind of a new area for us. I don't know that we've served in this.
2:30:25 You know, type of a role before serving as a construction lender. What type of security would we have? Are we able to secure a trust deed against the property in the event of a default or an inability of the borrower to complete the project? Can you help shed some light on that, Raphael? Absolutely. And that's a great question. And unfortunately, the answer is yes, you have security. Yes, you can.
2:30:53 Recorded deed of trust. The problem is that it's subordinated to the primary loan on the main property. So this is for ADUs, right? It's for accessory dwelling units. So it's not funding the acquisition of the entire property. So in most instances, unless you have a homeowner that
2:31:21 Yeah, that senior lender likely has
2:31:52 Approval rights over the recordation of any kind of a subordinate trustee. So there's no guarantee that even if we wanted to do the deal, the first TD lender would accept that, correct? Exactly, exactly. And that's one of the difficulties is that, you know,
2:32:09 The program is going to be different for every one of the participants in the sense that we're going to have to look at their primary mortgage loan documents, understand what the requirements are, the restrictions, get approvals from the lender. And even if you get approval, the reality is that
2:32:32 It's going to be a subordinated deed of trust. And so to the extent that there is a default, then in theory, the primary lender could, and I'm assuming here, but most lenders would likely
2:32:54 Proved a subordinate loan on the condition that there's a cross-default provision that says that if there's a default under the secondary mortgage that they could claim a default under the primary mortgage so that their security doesn't get entailed. And so, likely, if there were a default, they would call default under the first mortgage.
2:33:26 And be able to foreclose out your interest, in which case you might have to repay the state. That's a little unclear, to be honest with you, in looking at the program guidelines, the NOFA and our standard agreement. If we complete the project and then there's a default,
2:33:55 It's unclear whether repayment would be obligated. So that's one of the things that we would have to figure out with HCD. Okay, thank you. I mean, that's on the security side for this. But, you know, I think what we're really underwriting is the borrower's ability to deliver on this project. And I guess we don't know anything about the proposed borrower, their capacity to take this on, their financial standing. I mean, there's kind of the four C's of...
2:34:28 of lending involved here. And so short of knowing anything about the borrower, coupled with the concerns around the collateral, I guess I would have questions about whether this would be a risk we would want to be exposed to. Yeah, and that's one of the things that we want to clarify with the state is in conversations with them, they said that the money wouldn't be dispersed
2:34:59 until there's actually been expenditures and the program guidelines seem to allow for different type of disbursement so I think the concerns over the borrower defaulting would be significantly reduced if Eastern Sierra could
2:35:28 Draw down an entire 250 and then disperse it to the general contractor instead of directly to the homeowner. That then puts you in this awkward situation of being a construction lender and one of the things that's required in the guidelines that we would have to submit is
2:35:56 Just describing that process and thinking through what safeguards you would have in order to make sure that the work gets done, it gets done in accordance with laws and that at the end of the disbursements you have a habitable ADU. So... Raphael, is it true though that
2:36:25 We can't get the lump sum and disperse it out because if we did that, the project would have to be done within 90 days. Right, and that's the difficulty and that's where... So that's not an option? Yeah, in looking at the guidelines, I think there's room to push back and ask the state to waive that requirement because honestly,
2:36:55 It makes the program unusable unless they are willing to allow for the disbursement to be on the forward-looking reimbursement basis. Okay, that's good to know. I guess I just wanted to clarify that we do have an income-qualified applicant within the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:37:26 And Eric has been working really closely with the homeowner and has done an income analysis. I don't know, you know, we've been trying to keep it as high level as possible because we don't know how this is going to pan out. So I don't know in what detail he's reviewed his credit report.
2:37:47 But I do know that there has been an appraisal and so there's a few steps that the homeowner has taken in order to pursue the creation of this ADU in addition to a grant from Fannie Mae or Federal Home Loan Bank for $40,000 that he's received for this project as well. He has had some communication with his lender that has said that
2:38:21 Preliminarily that this would be acceptable. We obviously haven't reviewed any inter-credit loan agreements or anything at this point. But we wanted to come to the board to get direction because of the risk and the homeowners' desire to move forward with this project. Right. And just to add to that, Patricia, the issue, of course.
2:38:49 In order to move forward, there's a couple of things that you would have to do, the first of which is to create the program guidelines and draft documents for the program and to get the lender's approval, the homeowner's primary lender has asked that we provide draft documents to get the guidelines, obviously.
2:39:16 Can be independent documents and can be drafted up. But the question, the fundamental question is if and to the extent Eastern Sierra is required to be the bridge lender in that even worth pursuing, do you have the $250,000 invest? Yeah.
2:39:48 And it sounds like the guidelines have actually already been approved by HCB, so I apologize for that. Well, thank you for the report, Raphael. It was helpful for sure, and these points on the screen as well. Yeah, I mean, clearly that would be a lot of our working capital to tie up at a pretty risky situation. We can give a moment for public comment, but I think we need to have
2:40:24 Board discussion first? Yeah. Yeah. You know, it's one of these things, too, there's, you know, having experienced contractors that, you know, haven't performed and the fallout from those situations can get very sticky and complicated and difficult as well, you know, despite the best efforts of the homeowner or whoever's contracted for the services, something, sometimes things can go sideways.
2:40:52 And I think, you know, the point, too, of potential for cost overruns and so forth. And I'm just questioning, too, I mean, it sounds like, you know, we would be incurring direct expenses for legal services and so forth to pursue this. You know, I just, again, I don't want to be in a situation where we're going to be, you know, out of, you know, contributing funding outside of the program, right? That's not...
2:41:20 for, you know, provided for within the realm of the program. So, like, and I was just reading, like, there's, like, pre- and post-rehabilitation appraisals required. Is that all responsibility of the homeowner, I'm assuming, or? Yeah, I think some, so there is activity delivery admin that comes with the grant that we can use for things like appraisals, or if we can't, or that money's going to another.
2:41:50 Yeah, we have approved.
2:42:19 Guidelines for this program by the state, and there are template, rough template loan documents included in those guidelines. Already, I think we'd want to review those and make sure they're sufficient and run them by legal, and then I presume that the primary lender would need to approve them as well, but there's a starting place already in place.
2:42:49 Anybody else on the board have any questions for staff or Raphael? I have a question when it says there's the income requirement but no requirements or restrictions on the ADU. Is that as far as what the use of the ADU is for or size or both or something else? Raphael might. The only restriction that the guidelines set out is
2:43:20 The ADU cannot be used for Airbnb or other temporary type of rentals. It has to have a 30-day minimum rental period. But there are no income restrictions on the units that are required by the state.
2:43:45 That is an important caveat. It may not be required by the state, but it's something that MLH could theoretically, or Eastern Sierra, sorry, could impose if it so chose. But that would also get back to the underwriting piece of it, which is trying to figure out whether or not the homeowner can afford the first mortgage.
2:44:16 The loans are structured primarily to be deferred loans that they don't have to make any repayment under for the term of the loan. So unless they sell or trigger some repayment obligation, there won't be an issue. So the amount of rent produced by the ADU.
2:44:43 Would it be income that the homeowner could use? I have a question, Patricia. I know that sometimes the town gives Eastern Sierra Community Housing like a no-interest loan or things like that. I wonder if the town would, you know, be amenable to, if we, I mean, I feel like we're putting our necks out on the line here. If we,
2:45:15 Give the $250,000 and then the town would give us a loan until we get that money reimbursed by the state or something. I just, you know, feel concerned that it is a large chunk of our cash and that, you know, there are a lot of requirements and like everything would have to go perfectly. You know, there's some risk involved. So that would be, I don't know, like, does the town.
2:45:43 I know that they've given us like interest-free loans before on different things. Do you think that they would help us with that, like with our cash flow if we were to do this? Yeah, it has been on my list. Yeah, I think it could. I know that the town has put out, you know, free ADU plans. I know the town is trying to encourage. What? Oh, sorry. Yeah. Yeah, so I know the town has put out free ADU plans and they're trying to encourage homeowners to build ADUs.
2:46:32 So, you know, I feel like there are a lot of requirements on there and I worry about the risk involved for us and also the use of capital with having to be reimbursed. But on the other hand, it would be nice to get more housing in town. And if it has, I know the town ordinances also prohibit STRs in single family homes that are zoned.
2:46:59 And I think the homeowner has a regular planning permission.
2:47:31 Um, uh, uh, uh, an ADU type selected, and I don't believe it's a pre-approved plan to the town. I think it's something more cost effective. Does the state funding have, come with a requirement that it is a rent, that unit is rented? Or no, it doesn't have to be rented at all, so I mean, it can be used as a, as a, whatever, just an extra space in the home? Yes. Yeah. Unless we have a requirement in our guidelines.
2:48:05 Yes. That's what I understood that you said, Raphael. And do we have something? Not that I don't believe so. Well, we could stipulate that in our part of the bridge loan. But it'd have to be on our guidelines, our state-approved guidelines, wouldn't it? That's right, yeah. We could amend those or get additional approval. I guess, you know...
2:48:31 It sounds like, you know, like loan documents, okay, subordination, we do that. You know, the logistics of that all seem, those are more known, right? Those are known things. It's the unknowns that creates the risk. It's the contractor, the delivering on time, delivering on budget, and then the security of the loan.
2:49:01 And then the time between advancing the funds and being reimbursed by the state and that all meeting the state's boxes. Those are things outside our control that create an enormous amount of risk for the organization that I'm not even sure the town would want to, I can't put words in their mouth, but
2:49:31 Just having worked with them over the years. I can remember the help loans. Do you remember those, Tom? And those became due before. And there was a lot of uproar about that. So, you know, I don't know. It seems like a lot of risk. Yeah. Any further? Jennifer, I kind of echo that.
2:49:59 You know, we're also underwriting this particular borrower. I don't know anything about them, but their credit, their capacity to write a check, it's not just the contractor's ability to perform, but we're asking the homeowner here to be developer, right? They're going out and commissioning plans and hiring a contractor, and they've got to have the wherewithal to write a check if there is a cost over them. So there are, you know, multiple players involved here, and, you know, we would be in a position where we're
2:50:27 Playing a role that we have not, I don't know if ever, but I don't, you know, not in at least recent memory played that of a construction lender to a, you know, a single homeowner developer. So it does to me feel like a disproportionate amount of risk for, you know, and, you know, one home is one home. I'm not disputing the value and benefit of that, but it feels like a lot to me.
2:50:57 I wonder how successful any other recipient of this grant has been or this loan program because it seems a bit ill-conceived. It seems quite cumbersome. Raphael, have you worked with other jurisdictions or nonprofits on this? We have worked with a couple in drafting the documents.
2:51:26 I'm not sure that we've actually closed alone yet because of the obvious difficulties with the program. Yeah. Okay. Okay. If there's no other comment from the board at the moment, we'll take public comment on this. You're welcome to step up to the podium. Thank you for waiting. Yeah. Please state your name if you don't mind for the record. My name is Guillermo Stade. I've been a resident with Mammoth about 12 years.
2:52:00 My mom recently passed, it was my mother's home, and so I just, I acquired it, and it's taken me some time to get through probate, through COVID, and through the storms we had two years ago, my house got damaged, and it set me back. I participated in producing events with the mountain for decades, and been part of the community for a long time.
2:52:28 Part of the ski and snowboard community and have contributed in many different ways over the years. I truly love Mammoth and I appreciate you entertaining this opportunity. I want to definitely commend Patricia and Eric for helping me through this process. We started in May. I wasn't able to get to it until then. I've seen them work very hard. The office is always busy and I see them really, really having to put a lot of effort into helping the community. So I appreciate that very much.
2:52:58 I was able to learn a lot about the process and what the requirements are. We've been kind of learning together. I did a little background on myself. Before they entered, I was a big retailer, so I was always in the ski and snow industry, and I was creating stores. So I've built stores. I've been through every planning and building department in Southern California. I've had a store in Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego.
2:53:28 And I've been through the building process, and I've submitted many plans to many different towns. So I was, and we were learning together, and it has been cumbersome, and it did start in May, and it is an opportunity for me to kind of like really pivot, and I really have been putting all of my best effort to see this process through.
2:53:56 And so through that, I was able to surmise like, okay, like what would be the qualifications for a second loan? And in this context, a construction loan. And I'm just, you know, and again, I'm not saying, I'm not criticizing anyone. I'm just saying, we don't know exactly what the program entails. But to have a 90-day period to build a house in the state of California, I don't believe is,
2:54:26 It's not possible, right? So I don't believe that that 90-day period is necessarily set in stone. I believe that there's extensions to it. And I believe that if we look deeper into it, that that's what it would say. I don't think it necessarily needs to have an upfront cost from this organization. I believe that there's more investigation into that process. But I also did get a Cal FHA.
2:54:52 ADU grant that would allow me to do all the preliminary aspects of from planning to degrading and all the preliminary needs for permitting. So I went through that process as well. So through that process I was able to understand what these state programs deliver and the person that was with the Cal FHA $40,000 grant, they were able to actually get to
2:55:21 contribute to my understanding of what this program does, too. So I'm hoping that you can have the confidence in me to do the best for myself. And what I was anticipating doing was actually ordering a prefab metal building from Oregon. And they make them in 90 days, and they go up in a week. And it's so much cheaper and so much
2:55:51 More structurally sound, especially for the snow loads here, and it qualifies, it meets the standards of the snow load in town, so there's nothing that's going to be stronger or more resilient or durable, and there's nothing that goes up quicker, faster, or cheaper. A metal building, and they're very modern, they're very European looking, so
2:56:21 I think aesthetically, too, it's going to be very beautiful, and I think it goes up fast, and it would be more cost effective, especially with construction and contractors within the town. I think, again, it would go up in a week, so that's kind of where we're at, and I'm looking forward to getting through the process and understanding better what, you know, how we can, you know, bring this to a successful
2:56:50 Conclusion. Thank you. Thank you. All right, bringing it back to the board here again. Any further deliberations for everybody here? So, let's see. We are just providing staff direction on this, right, at the end of the day? Yeah, I think that would be helpful. We obviously don't want to use up any more of Mr. State's time if it's not a viable
2:57:25 You said there's three uses for this grant, DPA, rehab, and ADU. It's in two pots.
2:57:57 So about half is in the mortgage assistance pot, and the other half is in rehab slash ADU pot. So either or in that pot. Okay. So if we don't take on this, I mean, I guess the rehab is the same. It's the same scenario. Yeah. I mean, rehab. Right, because we thought, you know.
2:58:29 You know, after the big winter, we were sort of anticipating a lot of applications for rehab. We didn't get any, but, you know, there is a need for rehab, and nobody else is providing rehab loans or grants. And so I think when we applied, and then, you know, recently, we feel like we know there's a need, and we want to help meet that need, but now we're not sure if this is the right way, or if maybe it's
2:59:00 Not something we want to do in the future. Yeah, yeah, I mean, that's kind of where I'm leaning is that maybe eyes are more open and there's no penalty for not using the funds. No, and we could request, the grant expires next November, but we could request a budget amendment to move the funds into mortgage assistance. We haven't had a lot of applicants from unincorporated county.
2:59:32 Interested in using the funds below 80% AMI, but we could do some more advertising. There's no way that the homeowner can pursue like a conventional construction loan through a, to then get reimbursed by the state after that, is that not? That is an option, I believe, Raphael, maybe you want to touch on that, but we haven't pursued that with the client at all.
3:00:07 Right. The difficulty there is that the grant, or I'm sorry, the loan program would not, it's not a permissible cost to pay or repay an existing loan. So if and to the extent a homeowner was able to get a construction loan, all the construction loan costs other than the actual
3:00:38 Hard costs for the construction. So interest, closing costs, fees associated with that construction loan, origination fees and this like, those would not be reimbursable expenses. And you're talking about a market rate interest, right? So that's maybe cost prohibited, right? 7%.
3:01:10 Plus interest rate on $250,000. I'm not sure what the construction lead time would be, but even assuming six months, that's six months of interest that wouldn't be reimbursable. So could it work? Maybe. Just the devil's in the details. Okay. Well, I don't know. We've given you a number of concerns.
3:01:50 I don't know if you need a real definitive yay or nay from us at this point or if anything. Well, is there consensus? I mean, I think I've heard a couple of us have some concerns about the risk that we were not comfortable with it. I know that I feel uncomfortable with it. I think Brian said so, but I don't think that's a majority and I'm not sure where my colleagues are on the board. I think Patricia needs some clear.
3:02:19 Sure. Can I ask just for a clarifying question? So if we were to do this, we would give the applicant a loan for $250,000 and then the state would repay the loan and the homeowner would have to pay nothing? No, it's a loan. So we would ideally make payments to the construction GC, right, as progress progresses.
3:02:48 And then at Certificate of Occupancy, we would request reimbursement from the state for our input. And then loan documents would be recorded against the title of the property for $250,000 due in 15 years. Okay. And then they would make payments on that? Back to Mammoth Lakes Housing.
3:03:21 Which would go into the CalHom reuse pot. Okay. And then the homeowner would make payments on that for $15,000? So it would be a $250,000? There's no payments. So they would owe $250,000 in 15 years? Yeah. With interest? I think we have a range of interest-based. I think it's interest-free if I recall correctly, but I'll double-check. I'm pretty sure it has to be interest-free.
3:03:52 Unless you got them to prove something. Or it's, or if, if, and we could pull it out, it could, like some of our home, I think the home ownership is between zero and three percent based on your income level or something like that. And so if it's, in this NOFA, if it wasn't allowed to have interest, it would be zero. But any, most of our other programs go up to three percent interest, maximum.
3:04:18 And so then if they defaulted on the loan after 15 years, it would be our responsibility to go after them or it would be Calhoun? It would be us. And we're in second position. What does that mean? That we, the primary, the people that you pay your primary mortgage to get paid first. But I think what Raphael said, which is unclear, is if at default,
3:04:44 Cal Home has to be paid back, or if we're just going after our Cal Home reuse money, which we've already been reimbursed by the state. That's unclear. Right. Right. It's unclear if we have to spend our legal time and fees going after it, or if we can, yeah. Oh, no, we definitely have to pay our legal fees to go after it, but we don't know if we also have to go after it and pay back Cal Home.
3:05:19 And that's the risk, right, that if you're unable to get any funds back from the homeowner, that you would still be on the hook to repay the state. And you wouldn't be able to force them into a sale to recoup your funds? So that's the difficulty, right? It's a secondary lien, so if the first mortgage...
3:05:48 So, you know, would you potentially
3:06:18 Some recourse against the homeowner, maybe. Maybe the first mortgage lender doesn't declare default and they're like, look, they're paying our first mortgage, they're not under any obligation to do anything under our documents. So they could just sit tight and allow the homeowner to do whatever it is that they're doing. And so, yeah.
3:06:49 There's a lot of unknowns on what would happen. Could you just briefly mention the part about the option of us, if they don't complete the unit, of us completing the unit and taking, you know, management control of it? Yeah, so one of the things that we were thinking in order to mitigate the risk to Eastern Sierra is essentially to give a right to Eastern Sierra.
3:07:18 to complete the unit and then to rent the unit from the homeowner for the affordable housing cost minus whatever cost it took to get the building completed and then that would be your remedy. It would be to be able to rent the unit to
3:07:49 An eligible household of your children. Sounds hostile. It could be complicated. Yeah. It would be very complicated. But to clarify, if we were to proceed with a loan, we can put parameters on the use of the ADU, that it needs to be rented. So long as, yeah, so long as it's in your guidelines approved by HCD, then yes, we can't include
3:08:25 We've been, you know, mulling over how to make this work for quite some time and trying to think of options that, you know, could mitigate risk and or make this feasible.
3:08:55 But we haven't proposed making any significant changes or offering anything because we needed board input. Right, that doesn't mitigate the risk. That might change the landscape, but the risk doesn't change because it's required to be rented to 80% AMI and below. The risk is the risk regardless.
3:09:18 Right. And so it mitigates the risk in that you would have an option to rent the property instead of just letting it sit there uncompleted. And so the idea is that it allows you to step in, complete the project, and therefore, in theory, not owe the money back to Cal Home. During construction. And then allow you to...
3:09:46 Make the unit available for rent. And you can recoup some cost theoretically through the rent charge. So would we be able to recoup the cost of the mortgage through the rent cost if things were to go sideways and we had to do that? Again, this is something we have to explore with HCD what our potential remedies might be.
3:10:19 Whether they would accept that kind of remedy. Yeah, I think a challenge with that is if we arrive at that scenario, clearly something went awry with the original borrower and we've stepped in and taken possession of a piece of that homeowner's property. I mean, they become theoretically, well, potentially an adverse party and we're renting an ADU on their property. It just feels very messy to me.
3:10:51 I wouldn't want to go into it relying on that as a mitigant. Yeah. I agree, Brian. There's just so many ways that can go sideways. And then all this aside, I mean, do we realistically even have the money to lend? I mean, I'm looking at our balance sheet here and going, we don't even really have that much working cash that we can just tie up. I mean, there's not... I mean, we have...
3:11:23 Yes, I'm open to having that conversation with them.
3:11:56 I'm just not sure. Yeah. Yes. Well, does that really... Right. That just gets the cash. Right. But the grant and loan are still between us and the state of California. Yeah. Yeah. We're still on the hook. We're still on the hook for the ultimate people. It just sort of protects during construction. Yeah. I mean, I'm just... I don't think you're going to find a solution that's going to sway me, but... Yeah, yeah. Well, okay, so, again, so we need to give...
3:12:26 You know, firm direction to Patricia here, so I guess we should take a straw poll of the board here and get the sentiments of everybody who's here tonight. What's your opinion? I'm going to start down at the end. Sarah? I'm a no. I do not wish to proceed. Okay. Thank you. Kirk? Kirk's no. Jennifer's no. I've already shared my opinion. Lindsay? Probably not. Okay. I'm a no.
3:13:00 And Amanda? Peer pressure. I guess I'm a I wish we could find a way kind of a vote. Yeah, I wish we could find a way. Okay. And then Brian, clearly you have concerns. Yeah, I think it's a lot of work, a lot of bandwidth and risk. I don't see it. I would be a no. Is there a way to get an answer from the state on
3:13:31 Whether we have to pay back the money to them? I mean, have we asked and they've said we can't tell you or what's the unknown there? I think we've not asked and we could certainly ask and I think that based on this conversation, two things have become pretty clear. One is the structure of the disbursements. Is there a way that the state can just
3:14:01 Finance the amount that is necessary and without the need for a bridge loan, which just adds cost, whether it's from the town, from Mammoth or Eastern Sierra or any other party, it's additional costs that are potentially prohibitive. So if there's a way to solve around that problem and then the other question is just
3:14:30 On the remedy side, if there's no occupancy restriction and no requirement to rent that the unit is completed, is there a requirement to repay? So we could explore that with the state and see what they say. Because how does it work with this loan, the mortgage assistance, that money goes?
3:15:02 Yeah, it's a secondary mortgage and it's payable after 30 years or at time of sale. The easiest part about that is that it just goes through escrow, so there's no... You're buying real property. It's already there. You're not buying construction. Yeah. Well, you have title insurance after 30 years, though, if that homebuyer doesn't pay up. I mean, is our risk still there?
3:15:32 Well, presumably they pay off their primary mortgage in 30 years and then we come, then our loan becomes due, they can refinance and pay us off. That's how it works. And there's also an option to extend under the guidelines. But how is, so then I guess for me just thinking of the risk and if that risk is there, why is...
3:15:55 Why is this risk so different from what we're already? Because this may not come to fruition. But it still could, well, I guess it's still in the, yeah, the one if six still could be built, but they're not paid, and it exists, but it's the fact of it never happens. Okay. Yeah, I just, gosh, I think it'd be great to give the state feedback on just.
3:16:25 You know, the realities of working with their program and how challenging it is, you know, and untenable, really. Yes, Jarrett and I, Jarrett had his first experience talking with HCD about the Calhoun program at the summit this year, but I tell them about the problems with this program annually, I feel like. Yeah, I mean, it just seems like they really want to do this. Not for this reason, but for a lot of other reasons, and now I have another reason.
3:16:54 Yeah. I mean, I think what we can do is, I mean, I got the sense of the board, but maybe we could just clear up some of these hanging pieces and just figure out, wrap it up and how to proceed. Okay. I mean, I would just ask that you be conservative with your time and Raphael's time and costs and resources because
3:17:25 I don't know that you're going to find an answer that's going to make this less risky. And so you've got limited time. Raphael costs our organization money. He's been here all night. It's nine days. I'm not charging you for the whole night. I just don't know. Well, you should. I mean, it's your time. You're here. So anyway, I mean, yeah, let's, yeah, be thoughtful. Okay. Got it. Thank you, Raphael.
3:17:58 Thank you. Have a good night. Good night. Okay. I guess we'll move on then. You got everything you need, Patricia, then? Yep. Okay. All right. Moving on to agenda item five is committee reports. Any reports from any of our committees at present? Thank you. Okay. Hearing no reports on committees. We'll move on to agenda item number six, board member reports.
3:18:37 Board members have anything to report this month? We're still looking for employee housing in my association and looking at the spa building units above the rental workers. Maybe you can get a loan through the ADU program. I'm kidding. I keep reporting this because I'm saying it's hard to find employees. Yep. Yep. No, it is. It's definitely hard. Go to any restaurant. Yep.
3:19:11 No, for sure. Yeah, I don't have anything really to report on the housing-related side at the moment, but the mountain did get open, and we got a lot of good snow at the right time, so we're off to a good start, and I think that portends well for the coming months here. It should be a fairly good ski season, it looks like. We'll see what Mother Nature has in store, but off to a good start.
3:19:37 Mountain is amazing. I got to go yesterday and it's amazing. The town is having a tree lighting ceremony this Friday at 5.30 at the CRC. That's the ice skating rink. Yeah. Yeah. Great. That's all. Okay. If there's no further board member reports, we are going to go to agenda item 7 closed session.
3:20:04 And do I need to recite the items we're going to discuss? I wanted to request to remove 7.1. It was a mistake on the agenda. Okay. Item 7.1 will be removed. Therefore, we will be reviewing item 7.2. Put my glasses on. Pursuant to government code section 54957, the board will hold a closed session to consider the evaluation of performance of an employee, the executive director.
3:20:33 And agenda item 7.3, pursuant to government code section 54956B and 54957.6, the board shall hold a closed session with the board's designated representatives regarding the discussion of the local agency's budget with regards to salaries, salary schedules, or compensation paid in the form of fringe benefits of its unrepresented employees, Executive Director.
3:21:01 It may include discussion of MLH's budget and available funds and funding priorities, but only insofar as these discussions relate to providing instruction to the local agency's designated representatives. The purpose of this is to review MLH's position and instructing MLH's designated representatives. No action will be taken. If my fellow committee board members concur, I believe that 7.2 and 7.3 can be removed from the agenda.
3:21:32 Because I do not believe that there is business to discuss. We don't have all the results. We're not ready to do the results from the survey. No, because I would also like to use this opportunity to remind everyone to please complete your survey. I'd like to request that we keep agenda item 7.2. Sure. I retract my statement. We shall keep 7.2. I believe so. As long as everyone agrees.
3:22:08 If the committee already has direction from the board for negotiations, then you don't need 7.3. 7.3 is we've ended. Midnight's. Midnight's back. I need some water. Okay. Well, then I guess we will adjourn to the side room. Well, there's no restroom. We have to use some other. We will find something. Go out in the parking lot.