Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2024
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
154 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:04 Okay, good evening, everybody. I'll call to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Board Member Brian DeAndrea will attend this meeting remotely from the following address, 1000 Corporate Point, Suite 200, Culver City, California, 90230. Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Here.
2:33 Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Here. Board Member Stapp? Here. Board Member Kreitz? Present. Board Member Perkins? Present. Board Member Steenstra? Here. Board Member DeAndrea? Here. And Board Member Rice? Here. Thank you. Okay, terrific. We'll move on to agenda item two, public comments. This is an established time for any member of the public.
3:00 Wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public desiring to speak on a matter appearing on the agenda should ask the President for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may be submitted to the Executive Director at Patricia at ECHHousing.org or Clerk at Town of MammothLakes.ca.gov before or during the meeting.
3:26 and may be made in person in Suite C or by raising your hand on Zoom. Is there any public comment? I have no public comments at this time, unless... Okay. Okay, no formal public comment. With that, we'll move on to agenda item three, consent agenda. Item 3.1, approval of the minutes of the October 7th, 2024, regular board meeting. I'll entertain a motion to approve or comments or questions. I move that we approve.
4:07 The minutes? I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Any further deliberation? Hearing none, we'll take roll call. Please, Angie. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay.
4:42 Moving on then to agenda item four, policy matters, item 4.1, the board will receive updates on current construction projects, Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments. I think we see Eric's just scrambling in here to give, I think, his presentation. Yeah, can I request that we switch items 4.2 and 4.1? You bet.
5:09 All right, we'll come back to 4.1. Moving on to 4.2, the board will receive updates on other program activities. Patricia? Yes, thank you. This evening, I wanted to introduce our newest staff member, Jarrett Mendez. He's participating via Zoom today. He has accepted the position of Housing Navigator, funded through our contract with Alpine County. And he is from Bridgeport.
5:39 And he has housing experience working on housing programs with the Bridgeport Tribe. And so just with that, I wanted to introduce Jarrett and see if he had anything to say. Hi guys, how's it going? My name is Jarrett Mendez. I am the new housing navigator from Mono and Alpine County. I have two years of experience in housing management and grant management.
6:07 I am currently learning all about your policies and procedures to become a valuable asset to your team. And I look forward to meeting each and every one of you in the future. Thank you. Great. Great, Jared. Pleasure to meet you. And welcome aboard. Welcome. Welcome. And with that, I'll pass it to Isara. Hello.
6:30 So I will be doing the program updates. First thing is the rental program. So over the last two weeks, I did do rental waitlist management in which I removed 60 families off of the rental waitlist. The reason for that are listed below. Some of them did not have active phone numbers, email addresses, or physical addresses. Before we removed them, we did make sure that we did not get an email back, addresses, or get a call back. So we sent letters.
6:57 Early last year, sometime between March, and we have not heard back from a lot of the clients, so the wait list did change, and then a lot of them did ask to be removed since they did do our home ownership program, or because they found housing, or they moved away, or just other reasons as to why they did not want to be a part of it, but we did get their consent before we removed them unless there was no, it was just an understood consent that there's no way to communicate with them. Then, as per last,
7:27 Mammoth's meeting, the units are still being rehabbed in Buckingham Property Management. There was a meeting between Mono County and Buckingham Property Management in which they also stated that they're going to try to do the best they can to get funding to rehab the units and get those up and running as soon as they can. As Patricia did mention, we did get a new housing navigator, Jarrett. Jarrett has...
7:50 been doing a lot of the tasks that we've been doing as housing navigators with the Innsbruck Lodge tenants. So one of our Innsbruck Lodge tenants, they'd move out. So he accompanied me to do the walkthrough of the unit with the tenant as well to make sure everything was kind of in order before she had.
8:08 Officially relinquished your keys to the property manager. He is also going to be helping me with the lease-up process for the new tenant going into Innsbruck Lodge, along with the lease-up process for Birch Creek unit in June Lake. So he just started, but he's already getting the ball rolling for us, which is really, really appreciated. So thank you, Jared. For the HDAP program, there's still only one client that is currently fully enrolled in the Mono County HDAP program, but there are still...
8:43 Clients that we are looking for who would be eligible for the HDF program, the housing disability advocates program just requires the person to be disabled in the process of getting social security disability. So there are our community members do happen to be over the age of 65 and they are in the process of applying for SSI or SSDI where a lot of our community members will also be disabled. So we're just trying to find the individuals who think that they don't qualify for any programs because they fall in that range and then just kind of
9:13 Getting them into our office and making sure that they apply for that program to see if they're eligible or not eligible. As per rental subsidies in Inyo Mono and Alpine County, we did get an email from Marissa Black, who is one of the staff members at Stanislaus Regional Housing Authority, and they did let us know that they will not be distributing any more mainstream vouchers. The mainstream voucher is a rental subsidy for any tenants who are experiencing homelessness.
9:40 are disabled, or just experiencing homelessness in general. But she did not discourage us from turning in applications, but there is just not any to distribute to the Tri-County area at this time. The coordinated entry system, there are 254 clients in all of the CES, and then our office has been working with 47 households, some of which we renew their SPDATs every three months.
10:09 The plan is to hopefully house
10:41 This family for at least six months and put them into the Innsbruck Lodge project in one of the one-bedroom units since they are a family and get them situated into permanent housing. Hopefully, eventually, they can do our home ownership program long-term, but it's just to stabilize your family in their current situation right now. And I think those are the major updates in our programs. Patricia, if you want to add anything. Oh, and, I'm sorry, we are going to be having our
11:13 Credit building course tomorrow at 530 at the Mammoth Lakes Library. This is just for community members who are interested in building credit or rebuilding credit as a lot of the units that will be up and running on behalf of the parcel will be asking for credit checks. And that is the reason why we're doing the credit building course or clients who are interested in home ownership and don't really know how to go about that because they've either tried credit and it just did not work out or they need to start credit in the first place.
11:44 And I think that is it for my program updates, Patricia. Thank you. I guess for homeownership, we have been working on to complete the annual monitoring of our existing homeownership units.
12:06 That's currently about 50% complete, and so that's a high priority to get done before the winter comes into full swing. We did close escrow on the Nordica unit. We were unsuccessful in transferring it directly to the 50% AMI household. However, we're still working with them to try to get them into home ownership, into that unit.
12:34 And then there may also be a second household that is eligible for that unit as well. So that's a high priority as well. We have a lot of down payment assistance funds in the town of Mammoth Lakes. There's a lot of money in the CDBG and home pots, which can help households that are 80% AMI and below. And then the town has some funding for
13:03 I think we have a total of four units that we're actively marketing for sale, bridge units. Talking with the town today, it seems like there's a mismatch. We're not getting as many as the higher income clients as
13:32 Previously anticipated. And so the purchase prices with the interest rates seem to be on the higher side. So I'll just continue to work with the town to make sure those numbers are working and meeting the needs of our clients. I know Eric's working on probably at least 10 files. And then I have one that I'm actively working on.
14:01 There's a lot of different files in different stages, and then just trying to match those households with the appropriate unit for homeownership. I think that's all I had for homeownership, but I have a lot of other things. We did have our financial audit in October, so the auditor was in our office. They spent a little bit of extra time with us this year, so it was about a day and a half.
14:34 So that was good. We're getting things really cleaned up. And I'm really starting to spend a lot more of my time on the financial items, making sure that the accountants are, we're coding everything correctly and the accountants have what they need so that we can deliver first quarter financial reports for the board, hopefully at our next meeting. I did have to renew all of our insurance policies.
15:02 That program item is complete. I need to update our retirement plan documents, so I'm working on that. We are onboarding the Alpine Housing Navigator. Isara has been a huge help with that, just getting him right into coordinated entry and showing him all of our processes and procedures and giving him a tour of our properties.
15:30 I did submit the support for Proposition 5 that the board had approved at our last board meeting. I also recertified our deed restricted home ownership program under the Fannie Mae shared equity program. So that certification just gives us credibility when our homeowners are obtaining a mortgage that our program is approved by Fannie Mae and so that makes it easier for them to get a traditional mortgage.
15:59 So that's important. We also certified as a PayPal confirmed charity. So, you know, we've always had PayPal, but then there was also like GoFundMe and to be an approved charity through GoFundMe, you had to do all these things, but now they're one thing. So I had to go through the process to make sure that we were an approved charity so that we can do fundraising through GoFundMe. So that's good. That's done.
16:28 I attended a Community Reinvestment Act luncheon hosted by Eastern Sierra Community Bank which was a great networking opportunity. I'll update you on Valley Apartments. I executed the project report for the HCD staff to take to their loan committee and so I know that they'll be taking that shortly and they have no more questions for me at this time and so we'll wait to hear about the outcome from
17:00 Their loan committee. We also are working on a fee waiver agreement with the Mammoth Unified School District for the Innsbruck Lodge. They agreed to waive our development impact fees for Innsbruck Lodge, and so there's a legal agreement that we need to enter into, so you'll probably see that hopefully at our next meeting. Those are the big ticket items. Jarrett and I will be attending the annual rural housing summit.
17:32 We're leaving tomorrow and plan to attend the Tribal Housing Roundtable as well. I know that there are some other partners from the region that will be attending, including a representative from the Mono Lake Tribe. So I'm excited to attend that conversation and hear what other partners are doing in the state and how we might be able to leverage additional resources for our communities. So that's exciting.
18:01 We'll be closed on Monday for Veterans Day, and I'll be back in the office on Tuesday. Okay. Any comments or questions from the board on the program's update? Patricia, I was just curious, on the bridge program, you were saying you were having trouble matching people up with the units that are currently available, and that was in the, is that in the 120 to 150% AMI level? Yes, yeah. Between
18:38 Yeah, the purchase prices are really closer to the $150 level, so between $120 and $150. You know, I think we've reached out to the hospital in some more, you know, professional positions and haven't really gotten as many applicants in that price range as we anticipated. A lot of our clients and young
19:02 Families are really qualifying just above the 80% limit, which pushes them out of that down payment assistance category and puts them into the 120 category, but they're really only like 90% AMI, for example, where the prices are priced at the higher 120 level. So I'm just talking to the town regularly to make sure that...
19:31 You know, they're happy and we're able to get people into homes. Yeah, I'm just wondering what it says about the demand, I guess, in that income range. If, you know, we always had assumed that there was, you know, kind of a deep demand in that level, but the fact that you have three or four units currently that we're having trouble with, it just...
19:53 I don't know what's that reflective of that just interest rates are a little high right now relatively? I think part of it is interest rates in just the market right now and, you know, the political whatever. But also it could be the type. You know, I think some, well, many of our clients often want a single family home and so maybe they're not willing to compromise at that income level for a condo.
20:23 HOA fees are scaring some clients with the rising insurance costs and the HOA fees going up substantially at some complexes. I think it's just, it's a lot. Yeah. It's a puzzle. Yeah, it's interesting. I think it, not to belabor it, but I just think it's, you know, I think it does speak a little bit to the need to, you know, update the housing needs assessment.
20:53 Really kind of try to understand what the demands are out there in the marketplace locally. But I know there's, you know, work going forward with that with council and supervisor and everybody else, you know, county and city of Bishop and so forth to do a collaborative effort. But it certainly, at least in my mind, kind of points to that that would be useful information to have pretty soon. I know it's a ways out probably. You know, there's a lot of excitement around the new
21:21 Joaquin units, you know, they're brand new, they're more townhome style. I think there'll be a lot of interest, you know, depending on the price range around the home ownership phase at the parcel because it's going to be new and more, I think, townhome style, right, with outdoor access and maybe it's, you know, I think the type, the housing type does have an impact on, you know.
21:50 the interested clients. Yeah, yeah, great. Well, thank you. Any other questions or comments? Okay, we'll jump back then to... Sorry, can I ask a quick question? You bet. This is maybe not a question for you, I'm not sure, but the units that are sitting there, at what point do they decide to take those off the market and turn them into something else?
22:14 You know, we haven't had that, we haven't gotten to that part of the conversation, but I'm sure at some point we may have to, and then, you know, perhaps we'll rent them, or, you know, the town will rent them, or sell them. But we haven't had that conversation. Or you have to increase the level of subsidy would be another option, right? To a lower AMI level. Yeah, we did talk about that today. You know, there's a,
22:43 There's a threshold that they're comfortable with the subsidy today that may need to increase, but they're not comfortable doing that at this time. How long have they been sitting on the market? Oh, I don't know. Maybe six months. Thanks. Okay. Thank you very much. We'll jump back then to Policy Matter 4.1. The board will receive updates on the current construction projects Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments.
23:15 I think Eric's going to give us a report. Awesome. Yep. So let's start with our older project. So this is Inspirk Lodge and this for today. So you can see here, these are updated photos from the 29th when we did our walkthrough with Christian and his, which is our GC, our general contractor, and his project supervisor, Luis.
23:50 So as you can see here, we have some pictures. They are, some of them are from the upper units and some of them are from the basement units. So the upper two corner ones are from the upper units and then the rest of them are from the basement units. So they're close to completion but not yet. They still have some stuff to do so they still have to bring some subs in but that can be discussed later. So here's some project updates.
24:19 As Sarah mentioned, we are working, so we have one unit available right now. We're hoping to lease it up by November, and then we're working to process the other 10 units. So that means, you know, updating client's assessments and contacting them to see if they're still interested in the units. And then with that as well, we're working on operating subsidies in order to get them rental subsidies or anything else that they need.
24:48 Like I mentioned, so we did the punch walk, the upper units on the 29th of October, and then I'm hoping in talks with our general contractor that they'll be finished, the upper units, by the 4th, so this week. So I'll be coordinating with him to see what's missing. And then the electrical equipment, as you guys know, the express arrival is not until January.
25:16 of 2025, and that has been communicated with the state, so that has not changed, they're still pending management review, so we haven't, there hasn't been any updates on that side. Our property management, which is Jose, he's been working a lot with the tenants to move around to trade them, and then he's also going to be working with us to do any units, any unit rehab that we need, so for example, that unit that
25:42 The Parcel has become vacant. He's going to do any rehab that we need on it if there is a need. And then he's been extremely helpful coordinating with, you know, outside removal and keeping the property clean and organized to the best of its ability. So it hasn't changed. We've connected the gas. I've been working with Daniel, which is our architect, to come up with the plan for the bike racks.
26:11 for our place, and then I'm still working with the internet to have the program have internet, and I'm working with the optimum for that. So on our construction side, this is some items that you can see that are completed, and then what is left. So our lobby windows have been completed, so the front entrance, all the windows have been replaced, and then we've done a preliminary unit walkthrough.
26:39 of the upper units, and that was done on October 29th. So what is left is receiving the switchgear and connecting that. And again, like I said, we are hoping that we will receive it by January 25th. And then the additional work would be the exterior roof remodel or doing some sort of rehab on the roof, but that's not scheduled till spring or summer of next year, so 2025.
27:07 Like I mentioned, we're doing the upper unit walkthrough, re-walkthrough this week. So I'll be coordinating that with the GC. And then we'll be getting doors for the basement units on the 8th. So this Friday, we'll be getting those doors. And then I've been talking with our general contractor, and he says that
27:27 We'll have the lower units, which is basement units, completed by the end of November. So that means all appliances, countertops, plumbing, and then our punch walk should be completed by the end of November. So everything should be punched out. This is a development budget. So as of November, we spent 92% of our budget. And here you can see a breakdown.
27:51 of our original budget that we submitted to state in 2023, what our actual budget is, the difference in the percent change. So there's a 16.9, 16% change from what we submitted to state and what the actual budget is now. Yes, so that's the slide that last month I said we were going to look at some numbers to get it, to give you guys an updated budget.
28:21 So you can see what the original budget was and then what it is now, what we're currently basing it off of. Okay, so it's just the difference from the one in the packet, the rehab cost, the original budget is 1.5 and here it says 2.4. Yeah, that is the difference. Okay, thank you. The original budget is from the grant application. Right.
28:44 Obviously, there were changes in the bid amount, and then we went back to the town and requested an additional $400,000, and so the actual budget is where we're at today. The actual budget is where we're at, and okay. Thank you. Yep. But what's our funding total of all our funding sources? 6.8. It's not on this slide, I think. Do you have a funding sources slide? Yes.
29:18 Oh, wait, no. I don't have the funding source to slide. Okay. Well, I guess what I'm just trying to understand is, you know, how far over our actual funding are we? It's about $60,000. And that doesn't include carrying costs or the project management. Okay. The project management being the Zen Developments cost? Correct. Okay, so, but that's a cost to us, or? Yes, and that's around $100,000.
29:52 With that included, we'd be over about $160,000. Okay. And so where are we making up that difference at this point? In the developer fee. In the developer fee. Okay. Which was how much? $488. Okay. And then does that reflect the anticipated credit from the school district or the dip fee? Yes. It does. Okay. It's included. Okay.
30:20 So how much remaining developer fee would we have then, do you guys presume at the end? Is it $4.48 or $4.88? $4.48. $4.48. So we've taken $117.2 from $4.48 and received that already in previous fiscal years. And then we'd take out $160 for the overage. And then that would be the remaining eligible for us to collect. How much was it? I'm sorry.
30:54 I didn't. Remaining? Okay. 171 is when I come off of it. Yeah, something like that. All right. And maybe on next month's update we can kind of try to reflect that on the, I think it would be helpful just to have a better capture of where we stood on the overall, you know, cash in, cash out. Yeah. So over the last two weeks, Eric and I have spent a lot of time on these budgets.
31:24 And we have a lot more information. It didn't make it into the slide, but we can certainly provide that at any time. Was the money from the COC that we discussed today, is that for Innsbruck or Access, and is that reflected in this? Yes, it's about $343,000. It's for Innsbruck Lodge, and it's included in the sources. That you mentioned? Yes. Okay, thank you. Okay. Awesome. We'll keep going forward.
31:56 So this background, you guys have seen this a couple times already. Nothing has changed. So we're still expecting COO, which is serving occupancy in winter or spring of 2025 for the rest of the 16 units. And that is what I have for that one. In case you guys have any questions, additional questions? Nope, I think we're good. Let me move on to the next one. So this one is for our apartments update.
32:46 And these are current pictures for it. So these are progress photos from the 28th. As you can see, there's been a lot of progress on building A and they're starting to work on building B. This is a more updated picture of it. So that is from the 1st of November. I think those are only pictures of building A. So this is our construction budget. It's been updated.
33:19 And then we had some change orders, so we had seven approved change orders, and there's still one pending, so that brings up the new total of 7.1, and that increased the bid by less than 1%, so we're still looking good on that one. We're currently on pay up, well, we were on pay up three when I made the slides, but I think we're on pay up four now, but currently we paid out one million of it.
33:50 So that is what we have left, is six point something, six point million left. And our new bid amount spent to date is around 15%. Again, this is our spent to date. So we have, our spent to date in November is 48%. And then here is a chart, I guess a graph where you guys can see it. There's just different ways that you guys can look at data.
34:25 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
34:56 You know, still more than 50% of the contingency left on budget, right? Yep. And I think the other thing for my fellow board members is just, you know, from a construction perspective, now the, you know, a lot of the potential, at least from my perspective, you know, a lot of the potential risks that we were facing in the structure, I think are largely behind us because they've done all the demolition.
35:24 And all the remedial foundation work and they're framing everything back up. So the fact that we've only had, you know, it was a 40,000 change order so far, you know, I don't see a lot of risk in construction moving forward, particularly, you know, with that being behind us. So, you know, it seems like we can still manage within our contingencies, at least from my perspective at this point, because we're...
35:51 You know, the rest of the stuff's on the plans, right, as far as putting the building back together and so forth. So, not that there's going to be things going to pop up here and there, but I would think that we're, you know, some of the bigger part of the risk of the project is behind us, just as my personal observation. Yeah. I totally agree. So, there's, next one's project updates. So, again, we're still keeping our OAC meetings, which is our own architect, contractor meetings.
36:22 with Menemsha, and that's on a weekly basis. An update for that was our project manager, Kevin, actually came into town on the 30th and he walked the properties and he spoke to Tim about some stuff. So they're in close communication with them, miscellaneous. So we did talk to Tim and he's having his subs work on extended hours in order to get the property dried in. As you saw in the pictures, we're still missing.
36:51 So we're going to be talking about windows and doors, but those should be, you'll see on the next slide, but we have an update for those. Again, are, we're still on track to have occupancy by the fall of 2025. And this is a three-week look ahead provided by DIM, which is our project supervisor from an MSHA. So just some overview, big stuff, big ticket items. So for building A, roof insulation is going to be started by
37:22 the 18th of this month. Interior framing on the first and second floor will be completed by the 12th of November. Rough plumbing on the first and second floor will be completed around the same time, the 20 and 22nd. And then the window installs and the exterior doors are set to be completed by the 13th. On building B, that is the one that's taking a little while, but the roof framing will be completed by the 12th.
37:53 The exterior door is completed by the 15th of this month, and then the window installs by the 20th. So it's all tracking to be dried in by the end of this month. May I ask you what the X and the Cs mean? C is completed, X are just days that they're working on it. Okay, thank you. This is our funding sources. The other one, so nothing has changed on this one. Again, background on it.
38:27 We've been working on it since 2017, so we've made a lot of progress from then to what we are now with our project. And that is the end. And I guess if you guys have any questions. No questions for me, just, you know, overall, I want to compliment Menemcha for doing a great job on the schedule. Like, you know, they started really in August, right? It was mid-August, I think, when we actually started construction.
38:57 The fact that they're going to get the building effectively dried in here in the next two, three weeks, looks like the weather, good or bad, depending on your perspective, was going to hold out. At least, you know, they'll be able to get the roof on and continue to work through the winter. So that's a huge win. You know, there was a lot of question whether they could accomplish that. And I think they've done a pretty amazing job from what I've seen as far as knocking it out and recognizing the risk and getting it to a point where they can continue to work through the winter.
39:25 Will allow us to deliver the project much quicker, you know, save several months at least, if not more, for them to be able to continue to work through the winter. So that's a fantastic job. Yeah, I'm just really happy to see the buildings changing so much and excited for this project to be occupied. It's been a long road. Yeah, we're making great progress. Congratulations so far. Thank you.
39:57 Okay. No other comments or questions from the board. We'll move on to agenda item 4.3. The board will consider approval of the standard agreement with the State Department of Housing and Community Development for Grant Award 23-ESG-18024. Patricia. Yes, thank you. This item is before you this evening.
40:21 Thanks to our previous Alpine County Housing Navigator, Olya Igorov, who submitted this grant application, I never would have had time to do this. So thanks to her, we were awarded $66,000 in temporary rental assistance for, it's project specific, so it's for the Innsbruck Lodge. And, you know, I think
40:51 As Isara mentioned, it's hard to find rental subsidy, and this is sort of new territory in a lot of ways for us, but this shows that there are resources for this that we can access, and I think it's really exciting. So we can use up to 10% for administration, and it is dispersed on a reimbursement basis, so the board should know that.
41:24 That's the overview, but I'm happy to answer any questions. If we would like to receive these funds for the Innsbruck Lodge, the board needs to authorize the Executive Director to execute any documents, including the standard agreement with the state. Okay. Yeah, you know, I was reading through the pretty lengthy agreements.
41:55 And getting all the way down to the very end there of Exhibit E, which is the last two pages in our agenda packet, which was just the project-specific award amount and then the term of the contract. And I was just curious, because it was approved back in December of 23, so, you know, 10 months ago, and then now we're executing it. It says the
42:22 Contract expiration is October 15, 2025, which is less than a year from now, and that all program funds shall be expended by August 18, 2025. And then there's also intermediate expenditure requirements that you have to expend funds 20% by 120 days after execution of the contract.
42:50 50% after 180 days, 80% after, 80% 60 days prior to expenditure deadline. In any event, you know, I'm just, I guess my question is, if this is all kind of geared towards rental assistance, and we have to expend all of it by August 18th of this coming year, I don't know if you can't spend it all, I guess is my question, or not, or does it matter?
43:21 Well, I don't think it will hurt us if we don't spend it, but I don't think we'll have a problem spending it, considering that we'll be leasing up 10 additional units at Innsbruck Lodge, hopefully in February. Right. And they will all come from the coordinated entry system, and so they'll all be experiencing homelessness for various reasons. It's likely a handful of those would need rental subsidy, and this...
43:51 This rental subsidy can be for, I believe, up to six months. And so I think we could spend it pretty quickly. Okay. And is there any, do you think just because of the delay from the actual approval to now doing the contract, is there any ability to extend the deadline or the term? I think that's a great point, and I will bring that up with our representative. This seems sort of silly. It's like less than a year. It's HCD.
44:21 Yeah, they're like, jump. It takes them 12 months to do anything. They burn up half the time that you could have to use the funds. Yeah. I mean, it seems like maybe we should at least ask them, say, hey, can we get another year? I don't know. It's possible. I will do that. I'd just like to add, I mean, the tenants that are at Innsbruck Lodge currently, there's only one tenant out of the five that is not using rental subsidy. So, yeah, of some kind. So, the tenant that was...
44:49 Just, and there was receiving, is going to be receiving the mainstream voucher, which is a rental subsidy. We have an HDAP client, which is a housing disability advocates program on behalf of Mono County. Then we have a client who's receiving funds from Alpine County, and then we also have an individual who is receiving funds from Inyo County. So, you know, that was 80% of our tenants are using some sort of rental subsidy, and I think, um...
45:14 We see that potentially it will continue being 80% of the tenants that are living at Innsbruck Lodge, even the 30% units that we will have. So I think, yeah, $66,000 really does go by fast when there's a good portion of the tenants that are using a rental subsidy. Brian, you had a comment? Well, I was wondering about the contract rent for the units. Is the rental subsidy...
45:45 Supplementing what the tenant pays up to the affordable rent or up to the fair market rent for the unit? Right now, the rents are set at 80% and 30% AMI affordable rents. And the tenants that are currently receiving subsidy are paying whatever the difference is between the rent and what the subsidy will cover. So, for example, I believe our Inyo County client
46:25 50% of the rent is paid for by Inyo County and the other half is coming from his own funds. And so, you know, I believe we have policies and procedures for this funding source that were required with the application. I could take a look at those and see if it outlines how the subsidy should be calculated.
46:57 Okay. Yeah, I'd be curious to understand. I mean, I think if a housing authority were to provide a tenant with a voucher that we would negotiate the fair market rent for the particular unit and we would collect more than the affordable rent. That's what we would call overhang. So there's a little bit of benefit there. I'm wondering in this case, is HPD willing to pay overhang or are they essentially capping the unit rent, the total unit rent at the affordable rent? And their subsidy would
47:27 Paid the difference between the tenant portion and that affordable unit rent or something higher than that. I'll confirm that and let the board know. How do the tenants qualify? Are we offering it to them or do they let us know that they need the subsidy and we offer them? We have a screening process at the point of
48:03 So we'll go through the coordinated entry system based on highest need first. And then there's some questions about income sources, other services they may need, and whether or not they need rental assistance. So we have a process for that which would help determine who is eligible for rental assistance. Okay.
48:42 You good, Tony? I don't really understand. It seems like everybody's in need, so I would feel like almost we would be offering it to everybody since they're all on a subsidy in getting the affordable housing, but I haven't had the opportunity to read through the stack of paper. Well, and I think that's highly likely, as Isara said,
49:16 Those homeless households that have the highest need have the highest need for reasons including extremely low income or fixed income. And so when we lease up the next 10 units, it's highly likely that the majority of them will need some sort of short-term rental assistance or long-term. But while we have this, we can try to find more permanent sources of subsidy. Wow.
49:45 Like I said, I didn't get to read all of the language behind this agreement. Are there any key points you want to summarize for us? No, just I think it was it's great that Tom pointed out the expenditure deadlines. It's a pretty standard contract from the State Department of Housing and Community Development. We don't have any we don't have too many very specific requirements.
50:17 For our organization, which is a good sign, special terms and conditions. I've met with our representative. He's very hands-on. He's very communicative. So I'm excited to work with him. And this is just the first part of getting these funds into our community. I did, so just a couple other things that I know sort of those, you're allowed to bill up to 10% of the grant amount for administrative reimbursement, I think.
50:47 But then it's also a one-to-one match, right, of, if I read it correctly, but we can match that with staff time or something like that? Is that how it works out? Yeah, I believe that was in the application as well, that our staff time can be included as match as long as we're not allocating that time to another funding source.
51:22 So I just need to outline that, make sure we're not paying for the same time with two different sources of funding. Otherwise, would we have to actually come up with cash to match the 50-50 for what they're providing in subsidy? No, and I think, you know, there's other sources of subsidy that our clients are receiving, including HDAP funding. So that would match against that? That would be matched. Okay.
51:50 All right. I guess my point being is I don't think we want to have to come up with any money out of pocket, so to speak, out of our for rent subsidies. So there's no risk of that? No. Okay. And it's also for security deposits, which a lot of our tenants coming into the project experiencing homelessness for a long time on a fixed income don't usually have a savings account.
52:13 Or have a bank account in general, actually. Some of them just manage everything through a caretaker, which our tenant at Innsbruck Lodge does not, so he gets his funds through somebody else. And that's usually common in the homeless population, so, I mean, that's the great thing about the grant, is that they could use it for security deposits as well, which would be first month's rent. Thank you. Well, let's see, I guess, if there's no other questions or comments.
52:47 From the board, we're going to entertain a motion. I make a motion to approve the standard agreement presented to us as stated in our agenda. I'll second it. It's been moved and seconded twice. Any further deliberations? Okay, hearing none, Angie will take roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Berksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes.
53:19 Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Motion passes. We'll move on to Policy Matter 4.4. The Board will consider approval of a contract for services with the City of Bishop. Patricia? Thank you. I apologize that this item came late from our attorneys. I was actually on a call with them today.
53:51 regarding this item, but I wanted to get it on the agenda, so I understand if the board would like to continue this item, but this is the draft contract with the City of Bishop. Historically, we've had a handful of separate contracts with them for specific services. This contract would encompass all of the services that we provide to them under one form.
54:20 One contract to manage. And I've been working with Anna from their planning department on this agreement. And there was one thing our attorneys have a question on that I wanted to point out. You highlighted the duty to defend? Was that it? Yes, that might be it. It's all highlighted.
54:57 It's on page 4 of 19. Our attorney just thought that that was a pretty strict requirement for such a small contract, and so I can have that conversation with the City of Bishop and see what they're amenable to, and if the board would like me to bring back the contract, I can do that as well. Is there any urgency if it waits a month for us to make a final approval?
55:29 The city is aware that it was coming this evening, and it has been with legal for quite some time between the county and our organization, but I don't think it's going to compromise our relationship with the city.
55:58 Requests, since we just got a copy of it this evening, that we wait until next month to review or to approve it. If there's anything you want us to review or you want to give us a workshop on it tonight, that would be fine. Just information and then action. I would prefer an opportunity to read it a little bit more closely. I appreciate that Raphael's looked at it and the city's legal counsel has looked at it as well.
56:27 But I'm just now getting through the scope of work, and so I feel like I'm just not well equipped to take action on it tonight. If my colleagues would like to, I'm happy to abstain. I tend to concur with you, Jennifer. It's kind of hard to digest all this on the fly. Yeah, so, but if there are any particular terms you want to point out, I'm just looking at the payment schedule here. It looks like it's a five-year
57:01 Term and fairly nominal dollars per year, $4,200 a year is not a lot. Yeah, which is all of our contracts that we currently have with them combined into a total amount. We don't provide them a lot of services. It's mostly grant reporting, home ownership monitoring for two units currently.
57:28 The home annual monitoring of the existing Willow Plaza apartments that we perform annually to ensure that the rents are correct, that the management company is using the correct utility allowances, that the property is in good condition. And so we perform that monitoring annually, which is the largest component of the contract.
58:01 And so in this scope of work before you today, I did include a small escalation after the third year in the fee amount, but it's still very nominal. I think it's a $100 increase. That may be something that the board has feedback on. You know, a lot of our contracts that are a three-year contract don't have any
58:31 Inflationary clauses. This is a five-year contract, so if the board has feedback on what they would like to see, I can certainly have that conversation. We've performed those services the last couple years since we acquired that property, right? We don't own the Willow Plaza Apartments. That's a 12-unit home and tax credit project in the city of Bishop.
59:01 And so we are the monitoring agency on behalf of the city. Oh, okay. I was thinking of the Valley Apartments. Yeah. And so this is a report that we generate every year. That's the one on Willow just east of Third Street? Yes. Making sure that they're doing everything that they said they would do under the regulatory agreement. Do you have an idea of how much time we would be investing to perform those services?
59:32 Historically, I think the amount was $2,500. It recently went up to $2,700. I think that that covers the amount of time. $2,700? Per year. So that's how much we're spending on the employees here to do that? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Because, Tony, you brought up the Valley Apartments. That, because we own...
1:00:07 Do you foresee in the future, with it being five years, does this have any ability to increase our services and increase the payments in the future to make an addendum or amendment to it? We are currently in escrow for the Valley Apartments. And once we close escrow, we will be the owner.
1:00:36 operator of Valley Apartments. At this time, the city has nominal involvement in that project. But if we wanted to, I mean, I think, you know, I was on a call today with the continuum of care, and I think that there is a need for more housing capacity, right? If the, if the
1:01:06 County or the city wanted to increase their services, there would be a cost associated with that and we'd need to increase capacity. Under the exhibit B, B, CDBG grant, the 2009 grant, what is this? I guess it doesn't, is that a down payment assistance or what is that grant?
1:01:34 That you're doing, that you being, Eastern Sierra Community Housing is doing some services, I guess I'm not as familiar with that. Yes, it is the, it's down payment assistance grant, and we are doing the annual and semi-annual program income reporting for CDBG funds. Got it, okay. So that's what this is outlining? Yes, and
1:02:05 You know, I can talk to the city about that, but program income could come from any CDBG grant. It doesn't necessarily have to have the grant number associated with it. So maybe there's a room for improvement there. Okay. Okay. And that's part of the 4,200 a year? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Well, we can obviously talk about this more, but I do believe it's
1:02:46 Worth contemplating a little bit or some degree larger cost escalation. You could perhaps look at the insurance escalation over the last five years, for example, and contemplate that some proportion amount into the five-year trajectory, just knowing how insurance just keeps going up.
1:03:11 To make sure we're covering our basis, at least on that component of running, because I, you know, that's an addendum to their, their contract here is, is insurance. So that made me think, oh, we should make sure that we're covering our basis there. Yeah, I think. I'm not sure if $100 a year after a few years is sufficient. I don't know. I know it's just a small chunk of our overall, I'm not asking them to pay all of the increase, but. Right of proportion.
1:03:47 And is there anything in here with regards to public appearances before the city council? No, there is not. That's been a concern of mine. I know they've asked you to come and present, which I think is, you know, it's a fine balance between, you know, driving an hour each way to go and present to the city council and not...
1:04:19 You know, we want to keep everybody informed, but we also have, you know, just to be, keep an eye on that, I guess, that this doesn't become a recurring, you know, every three months request that you're spending your time preparing for and then going to and all of that without some kind of an agreement that...
1:04:40 that's part of your work that you know that this organization is providing part of what we do is an update annually or biannually or quarterly and that there's a an awareness that that is it costs resources from the organization to provide those updates if they are indeed updates obviously if we're going because we are working on a project together maybe that's different but
1:05:08 It's just something to contemplate too, perhaps. Yeah, I think that's a great point. I think there is a fine balance between strengthening our partnerships and being compensated for our work. I think, you know, we recognize that participating on the continuum of care as well. A lot of people rely on us and we are always willing to help, but it does impact our work program.
1:05:39 You know, to just help everybody who comes looking for help. Right. And I see with the continuum of care, there is a direct benefit both ways for the organization and the continuum and the communities. It's really, I think, a good relation. You know, I just don't know. The city, you know, just has been a little more, just it's been a different kind of relationship. Yeah, and I think just thinking about
1:06:13 how our partners rely on us and you know how if you don't have boundaries that could you know get out of control and so I think maybe adding something about an annual update would benefit both of us and strengthen our partnership so maybe that's something I'll bring up. Perhaps it's a value to them and it's something they would like to request and see value in and then we could build it in.
1:06:41 Perhaps that could happen between now and then. But I might suggest that you maybe scrub, well, I know these are specific to these grant awards that they have, right? But I'm curious whether any of the tasks that we perform for the town of Mammoth Lakes would, you know, maybe be appropriate for the city of Bishop in as much as, you know, sort of expanding the contract of services, so to speak, and, you know, see what that might be.
1:07:11 In comparison, right, because we're collecting, what, $340,000 a year from the town for services we provide to the town of Mammoth Lakes, notwithstanding the grant, additional grant funding through for projects and so on and so forth, right, for a special program, mortgage assistance and so on. So I'm just curious, you know, as much as, you know, I think Bishops recognize the fact that they're kind of behind on addressing this issue in their community.
1:07:40 Maybe there's a lot more that can be done there, and maybe this is an opportunity to try to bring all that to the table at the same time and say, well, not, you know, of course they would have to fund it, right, through their municipal funding sources, but maybe it would be appropriate. And if, you know, and there's always a challenge for us is because we're such a small staff and, you know, if you can get enough work then to subsidize an additional position, then we could hire another body, right?
1:08:10 And sort of leverage that relationship to provide another body. And particularly, like, if we end up, you know, really getting traction on Valley and moving forward with that and any, you know, other projects we do down there, obviously, it would be nice to have, you know, additional staff help. It might be a way to sort of get to that next level, possibly, is a thought. I don't know, maybe it's something our contract committee could meet on.
1:08:39 As it relates to that. And I guess the other thing, too, is, you know, there's always opportunity to come back and renegotiate an agreement. Just because we agree to something right now doesn't mean we can't come back and say, hey, if you thought about this, if you thought about that, maybe we should amend our agreement and do more. That's what I was thinking. I was going to ask if there was any other services that we might want to be performing for the City of Bishop that we can tie into the same contract.
1:09:09 Like he said, if we could find a variety of services, a larger spectrum of services that are needed to be done down there, we can make it a selling point. Yeah, we'll do this, but how about we make it a larger contract with a variety of services, not just limited to monitoring this one unit, but that's really
1:09:37 Why I'm eager to stay on this board is to grow participation of Eastern Sierra Community Housing throughout Eastern Sierra and especially in Inyo County where I'm living and we grounded ourselves as a regional organization. I think we need to make an effort to sell them on our services. So instead of just saying, sure, we'll do this for you, we need to
1:10:07 Sell all the other things that we can do for them and try to get them to sign off on a larger contract. I guess one could maybe argue that is this the opening of the door? If we get them to agree to this and it's specifying the services for this one thing, does that then kind of open up the opportunity for further collaboration and additional services versus trying to get them to buy into a larger contract right off the bat?
1:10:38 You could think of it that way, but when these small contracts are isolated, I, as a self-employed consultant, I see clients that want to have those small contracts get tied into, they just want to maintain those small contracts and don't want to grow the services, so I think this would be a good opportunity to let them know that we're
1:11:08 eager to serve Inyo County and they need affordable housing there and I think this is a good segue into it because the total dollar amount, I mean, we would be making some on it but is it really worth the effort unless we're going to be getting more work out of it? I'm not sure.
1:11:36 That single contract is worth what we're putting into it. Okay. So is there consensus of the board then that we want to continue this to the next regular scheduled meeting of the board for final consideration approval? Yes. Yeah, I just would like to make sure Patricia feels like she has a board direction and consensus on items to pursue if you need clarity from us.
1:12:10 No, I think those are great. That's great feedback, and I took notes, so I think I'm prepared to go back to the city and take another look at this. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. And let us know if you need any help. Like, I last month signed up to be on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Committee, and if we can dissect that contract and see what could apply toward the City of Bishop, then...
1:12:36 Maybe we can look at specific services that we're trying to sell to them. Yeah, I think that's a good idea. Thanks. Okay. Great conversation. So, nothing else. We'll move on then to Agenda Item 5, Committee Reports. Any reports from any of the active committees?
1:13:02 Just a quick report from the ED Performance Evaluation Committee. I'd like to request that we remove 7.2 and 7.3 from the closed session agenda. There are no reports for that agenda item or those agenda items. Okay. And more information will be coming soon to fellow board members for that evaluation process and we'll have an update next month. Great.
1:13:36 Any other committee reports? I don't think so. Okay. Moving on then to agenda item six, board member reports. Any board members have anything they'd like to report? Well, I guess sure. The dog park is having a grand opening this Wednesday at 3 p.m. If you'd like to come down, there will be a dog costume contest. So I hope to see you all at the dog park at 3 p.m. this Wednesday. Great.
1:14:12 You know, I have to say, I've walked by the dog park on a pretty regular basis, and I've gone in there. My dog, she's not a big fan of it, but she kind of likes it. But, you know, I've got to say, that project, I was sort of like, ah, you know, I get that at Mammoth. But after being there, I actually think it's a great amenity for our community. And as much as so many members of our community are dog lovers, and, you know, a lot of people live in...
1:14:39 Townhomes and condominiums and you don't have a place for your dog to go. It's a fantastic place to take your dog to exercise and get out. And so I'm actually, I've been pleasantly surprised by that. I think it's actually a wonderful addition to the community. So thanks for bringing that up. Well, I'll report in other news that the ski area is scheduled to open on November 15th, which is a week from this Friday. And we've already been making snow.
1:15:07 Looks like we'll continue to get some good temperatures for making snow. Mother Nature might kick in a little natural. So I think we'll make our opening day. And we'll be adding in our new chair one chair lift. We'll begin operation the week after. It won't be ready for opening day, but the weekend after before the Thanksgiving holiday week. So exciting for us up there. And lots going on in that regard.
1:15:34 Kind of kick off the winter season here and the community will get pretty busy with our guests coming back. So that's all I have on my end. So are they going to open stump or just six? Our planned opening at this point looks like chair three, chair six, and lower gondola. And then we'll add in more terrain as we get the ability to cover it with snow. Thank you. And I just want to report that the Mono County...
1:16:03 Mono County closed on a five-plex in Bridgeport, and we are taking applications. You can find the application on our website for those units. Two of them are reserved for county employees and three or four members of the public. I think the AMIs go up to $120 for the public units and 30% of the income for the county employees.
1:16:31 Again, just a reminder that this property was a nightly rental property, that now it will be a long-term rental property, so we're quite excited about that. We're still looking at bridge units, trying to find one that fits the bill for our pilot program.
1:16:49 Lots going on. Contemplating a CDBG application, which I think the NOFA's out. I don't know. I didn't hear any update. I guess the town's not looking at a CDBG application. There's no other jurisdictions this organization's working with on a subrecipient agreement kind of style for one for CDBG. No, the town is not prepared to do a CDBG application. They currently have homeownership and the Access Apartments Award.
1:17:18 And no other jurisdiction has approached us to pursue CDBG. Yeah, I think the county's trying to weigh their options with the 50% rule, and most of it's over the counter right now, so it's going to be quite competitive. So I'm not sure where we'll end up going, but stay tuned. It should be on our agenda on a meeting soon if we are going to do an application since the resolution needs to be passed for that.
1:17:48 So the housing ad hoc for the county continues to meet every other week and work on housing items. And that's all I have. And I'll be at the CCRH Summit this week as well. Any other reports? Okay. With that, we will move to agenda item 7, closed session. I guess just item 7.1, pursuant to government code section 5495 6.8.
1:18:23 The Board will hold a closed session to discuss property negotiations and possible staff directions and or action relative to Assessor Parcel Number 033165001, property located at 550 Mono Street, Meridian Court, Unit A101 in Mammoth Lakes, under negotiation and our terms of sale. And with that, we will recess to closed session.