Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2024
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
240 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:47 Okay. Good evening and welcome to the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and a sustainable community. Board member Brian DeAndrea will attend this meeting remotely from the following address, 1000 Corporate Points, Suite 200, Culver City, California, 90230. And I believe we have another board member who will be...
3:17 Yes, that's correct. I'm on if you can hear me. Yes. Perfect. Just like to request to attend remotely due to child care issues. Okay. Angie, that's permissible, correct? Yep. Okay. Then we will take... Tom? It's Heidi. Heidi? Heidi, excuse me.
3:57 Because you're attending remotely under a little bit different cause, your attendance will require approval from the board. So I'm going to go ahead and take roll first. That way we have a quorum here that can actually make a motion and approve your attendance. So we'll do that first. And then after I take roll, then you can go ahead and state your reason. And then we'll have a motion and a vote on that. OK? Thanks, Angie.
4:27 President Hodges? Present. Treasurer Barksdale is absent. Board Member Nuttall? Present. Board Member Stapp? Present. Board Member Kreitz? Present. Board Member Perkins? Here. Board Member DeAndrea? Present. Board Member Rice? Here. And Board Member Steenstra, I will add you after we have our vote. Thank you.
5:02 So I would like to make a request to the board to allow me to participate remotely due to an emergency circumstance. And that circumstance is a pretty intensive lower abdominal surgery last week that I am still somewhat having complications from. Okay. Yeah. I'll entertain a motion from the board. I make a motion that we allow board member Sheenstra to attend remotely. I'll second the motion.
5:38 Roll call, Angie. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale is absent. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay, thank you.
6:11 With that, we'll move on to item two on the agenda, public comments. This is the established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any manner that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public desiring to speak on a matter or appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard when the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may be submitted to the executive director at patricia at eschhousing.org or clerk at town of Mammoth Lakes.
6:41 .ca.gov before or during the meeting. May be made in person in Suite Z or by raising your hand in Zoom. Angie, do we have any public comment? No comments at this time. We do have one item that we did not agendize, but...
7:01 I wanted an opportunity to introduce our on-site property manager for the Innsbruck Lodge who came on to join our team in July and is currently occupying the manager's unit there and working with the tenants to ensure a safe and healthy community for everybody. And so with that, I just wanted to introduce Jose Diaz. Hello, everyone. My name is Jose Diaz and I'm the new property.
7:32 Manager for Innsbruck Lodge. I'm super happy about this new project. I know it won't be easy, but I'm pretty sure we're going to get there. Actually, I love the place. I love the people who live there. I notice a lot of good things. So I'm pretty excited about this and be part of this team, guys. So thank you for everything. If you guys need anything, I'll be at Innsbruck Lodge.
7:57 Thank you. Terrific. It's a pleasure to meet you, Jose, and welcome aboard, and really appreciate you taking charge there at this, you know, first big project for us here in recent years, so really glad you're on board with us. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Welcome. Thank you. All right. Terrific. Okay, any other public comments? None at this time. All right. Terrific. Then we will move on to agenda item three, consent agenda.
8:28 Item 3.1, approval of the minutes from the August 5, 2024 regular board meeting. Is there any discussion on the minutes or I'll entertain a motion to approve? I move that we approve the board minutes. I second the motion. The motion has been made and seconded. Any further comment? Roll call, please. President Stapp? I'm sorry. President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board member Stapp? Yes. Board member Kreitz? Yes.
9:02 Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Board Member Steenstra, how do you vote? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move on to agenda item four, policy matters. Moving on to 4.1, the board will review and possibly approve the grant agreement for whole person care funds from Mono County for the Innsbruck Lodge.
9:38 Patricia? Thank you. This grant agreement is the result of a long journey in partnership with Mono County Social Services to secure a whole person care grant from the state, which was allocated in the 2019-2020 fiscal year budget for the state's social services programs.
10:07 The intent of these funds is that they were flexible and that they would help provide target populations with comprehensive supportive services to help reduce emergency room visits, improve quality of life and housing security and things along those lines. When Mono County submitted their
10:33 letter of intent to the state, they included a line item for permanent housing. And so these funds are, this grant agreement represents those funds allocated under that line item. They were originally included in the Access Apartments funding stack, but
10:54 Due to the nature of the funds being for high-risk populations, it was agreed upon that they would be moved to the Innsbruck Lodge project, which also had a budget deficit at the time, because that project as permanent housing for folks experiencing or at risk of homelessness would meet the intent of the grant funds.
11:20 The Board of Supervisors will review this grant agreement at their meeting tomorrow morning on the consent agenda. And so these funds will go towards the construction deficit at Innsbruck Lodge. And if you remember, when we went to town council regarding the increased construction costs for this project, there was about a $700,000 deficit. The town allocated an additional $400,000.
11:52 Which left approximately $300,000 deficit. We decided to move forward. And this additional $150,000 reduces the deficit to around $150,000. The grant funds will be expended within the deadline. And I'm happy to answer any questions. Patricia, I had a question. So the
12:24 So the $149,000 proposed, you're saying it was included in our original capital stack analysis for, or you said this is in addition to? It was originally included in the funding stack for access apartments. For access, but for Innsbruck it was not? Correct. Okay, because we did have other separate funds that were approved by the county. Yes, this is in addition to the other allocation by Mono County, which was $500,000.
12:54 $550,000. $550,000 for both projects. $550,000. $600,000 for access. Oh, $600,000. Oh, yeah, yeah. And we won't be using these funds to physically provide care for residents? No, this will go towards the construction, the total development budget. Okay, so it wouldn't expose us to any other risks that we weren't thinking about or liabilities?
13:23 Correct. It will not. I should mention that our attorney has reviewed the agreement, and I spoke with him today. He had a few minor comments, and so mostly around the grant agreement being in the name of our organization instead of the Innsbruck Lodge LLC. So if we do approve the grant agreement, it would be good to include a note that
13:55 Entering this agreement under Eastern Sierra Community Housing or Mammoth Lakes Housing, we intend to use the funds towards the Innsbruck Lodge LLC project, which is outlined in the grant agreement. Okay, are there any further questions from the board? Any comments? No, I'll just make one that it's on the consent agenda for our board agenda tomorrow at the Mono County Board of Supervisors. I anticipate it passing with.
14:33 No issues. And I'm happy to make a motion if you're ready, Chair. Yes, please. Okay. I'll make a motion to approve this grant agreement as amended and mentioned by Executive Director Patricia Robertson. I second the motion. Okay. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Seeing none, we'll take roll call. Please, Angie. President Hodges. Yes. Treasurer Nuttall. Yes.
15:08 Board Member Stapp. Yes. Board Member Kreitz. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Board Member Steenstra. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Motion passes. Moving on to Policy Matter 4.2. The Board will review and possibly approve the revision to Policy 804, Furniture and Equipment Capitalization.
15:43 Patricia? Working with our new accounting firm, they have provided updated guidance from the IRS regarding capitalized expenses and have suggested that we amend the policy to increase the limit from $1,000 to $5,000 per item. Okay. And I was reading there that because we have audited books, it allows us to go up to $5,000.
16:19 Which, at that point, anything below that, you can just expense. Yes, yeah, and this came up when we had some computer, we played a little computer musical chairs, and I ordered one additional computer that was above the $1,000 limit, and so I had asked to capitalize it, and that's when this issue came up. Got it. Okay, any further questions from the board?
16:52 Make a motion to approve the amended policy 804, furniture and equipment capitalization. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Hearing none. Angie, roll call. President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea?
17:25 Yes. And board member Rice. Yes. Thank you. True it. Motion passes. We'll move on to agenda item 4.3. The board will review and possibly approve the revisions to policy 807, employee bonuses. Patricia. This item has come up as the ad hoc evaluation committee has been working through a new process and template for the evaluation of the executive director.
17:56 And also, as part of that, has reviewed the employee bonuses policy and provided suggestions to the board for their discussion. And I know we have at least two members of the committee present if they'd like to make any additional comments. Yeah. Does any member of the ad hoc committee care to make any further comments to the agenda bill?
18:31 Sure, maybe I can speak to the briefly to the suggested changes to the bonus policy. As we previously discussed, the performance evaluation form has been drafted for hopeful adoption by the organization with the expectation that both our Executive Director and all team members of Eastern Sierra Community Housing
19:00 We'll be using that form to establish goals each year and be evaluated by their supervisors on general job performance, including satisfaction of any of those strategic goals and professional development goals that are mapped out in the form. We felt it was important to also tie the organization's bonus policy to job performance. And so the changes, the red line changes that you see before us does just that. It situates the policy.
19:29 in relation to the individual goals that are established by each team member each year. It also makes clear that any bonus is at the sole discretion of the Board of Directors and that we retain the right to determine, modify, and or eliminate bonuses under this policy. And lastly, we established a bonus cap of no more than 10%, which we felt was in line with
19:58 So I will pause at that and happy to answer any questions or if my fellow committee member, Sarah, has anything else to add that I've left out, please feel free. So if Patricia wanted to award a bonus to one of the staff members, she would make that suggestion and propose it to the board and the board would approve it.
20:31 Or deny it for that matter? Could you hear me, Brian? Yeah, I can hear you. I think the process for awarding any staff bonuses, I might want to defer to Patricia to inquire about what the normal procedure is for those approvals to take place. This wasn't intended to get to that level of detail, but maybe, Patricia, could you answer that question, please? Yes. Typically, after
21:03 The Executive Director's evaluation and any potential bonus that is awarded, the Executive Director evaluates the employees and has the discretion to award bonuses up to that same amount. But that doesn't have to be brought back as an item to the board? Correct. Okay. Thank you.
21:38 Any further questions from the board or comments? Go ahead, please. Can I ask what you think about the revisions, Patricia? Am I allowed to ask that? Yeah, I think that the committee put a lot of work into it and I don't see any issues with it. I just wanted to thank the committee for the work that they've been putting into this process, cleaning it up and clarifying it.
22:20 Just this seems a lot more clear and hopefully we'll put it into action soon and we'll see how it works and nothing's, you know, carved into granite with these policies. So I just appreciate the time that you all put into this. Thank you. Okay. Any further discussion? Entertain a motion?
22:54 Make a motion to approve policy 807 employee bonuses. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Hearing none, we'll take a vote. Angie? President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea?
23:30 Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Motion passes. Moving on to agenda item 4.4. Consider adoption of Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. Resolution 24-06, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc., approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee. Imagine that should say Eastern Sierra Community Housing, but in any event, one and the same.
23:58 Annual performance evaluation of the executive director to also serve as the board's designated representative or representatives for negotiations regarding employee matters pursuant to government code section 54957.6. I believe in our agenda packet is the resolution to create the ad hoc committee. Any questions or comments? I have a question, but it's kind of generally about the whole packet.
24:31 When will we only be Eastern Sierra Community Housing? Because I feel like it flip-flops back. It's confusing reading through it because I feel like sometimes it's MLH and sometimes it's not. Yeah. So that's in my program's update. But we need to send out all the notification letters to all of our contractors, utilities, the state, everybody that we've ever done business with or have an agreement with.
24:57 And so that's on the list of things that we need to be working on in the next month or so. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any further comments or discussions about the proposed resolution? Hearing none, I'll entertain a motion to adopt. So, sorry, are we, like, volunteering to who's going to be on this? That's the next agenda. Okay. This is just a form of committee. Okay. Thank you. I'll make a motion.
25:31 to adopt the resolution 24-06. I'll second. Any further comments? Hearing none, we'll take a roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea?
26:03 Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes. We'll move on then to agenda item 4.5. The board will appoint board members to the ad hoc committee annual performance evaluation and designated representative for negotiations regarding employee matters pursuant to government code section 54957.6. So here's where we'll appoint members to that ad hoc committee. We had, what, three previously, I think? People on the?
26:36 Ad hoc committee. I'll volunteer to be on that if I can do some of those meetings separately. Don't have to do them all in person here in Mammoth. Mm-hmm. Okay. Should be doable. Just a reflection on this. I think this is probably the last year we'll be on the old system, and then going forward for next year, hopefully we're on the new performance evaluation form and we'll be evaluating Patricia based on those goals that are set on that form.
27:14 I think I've done it the last two years. I'd be happy to volunteer an additional year until we get to that new place, but if there are others that wish to step in, I'm more than happy to yield. Everybody's quiet. Essentially echo what Brian just said. I've been on the Ant-Hop Committee now in the last two years as well and have been involved quite heavily with the new proposed structure, so I would be happy to
27:53 And you guys are both talking about the negotiations with the Town of Mammoth Lakes contract, correct? No, no, no, this is the executive director of evaluation. I'm sorry. Yep. Which you said you would.
28:24 Be willing to join. I'll do both. Well, we're not there yet. That's on the agenda too. Okay, well, I was, I thought we were talking about the. Yeah, that's next. Contract. We're on 4.5. Yeah. I'm also happy to stay on the evaluation committee if needed, if nobody else would like to get on. I was on it just this most recent year. Okay. Well, it sounds like we have four volunteers, which is.
28:54 I can withdraw my volunteering. We have Tony, do you want to continue to volunteer? We got yourself, Brian, Sarah. No, I was trying to volunteer to do the other one, so I'll just withdraw my... Okay, fair enough. Sorry. Okay, so I think it's not necessarily an official vote here, but it sounds like we got Sarah, Brian, and Lindsay willing to...
29:24 Take on the ad hoc committee for the executive director evaluation. You could go back in now. Because we can have four. We can have four. And Tony withdrew. Okay. And Kirk as well. So is everybody comfortable with that? With the ad hoc committee? I'm sorry. Heidi, did you have a question? I was going to offer to be on the committee if needed. But I don't know. It feels like it's getting busy.
29:54 Yeah, I think we have four at this point is the most we can have, so to stay within the Brown Act. So I think we'll lock you guys in. Thank you very much for volunteering and continuing your service on that. And with that, if there's no further comments, I'll move on to agenda item 4.6, consider adoption of resolution 2024-07. I feel like we normally do emotions. Oh, do we? Yeah. I'm sorry.
30:24 Okay, my apologies. Okay, I apologize. I'll entertain a motion to appoint those members to the ad hoc committee for the Executive Director of Aviation. I'll make the motion to appoint board member, let's see, Nuttall, DeAndrea, Stapp, and Barksdale to the committee.
30:53 Titled Annual Performance Evaluation and Designated Representative. I'll second. Okay, thank you. Any further discussion? Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stepp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes.
31:29 And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Moving on then to agenda item 4.6. Consider adoption of Resolution 2024-07, approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee, Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Negotiations Committee. And this is, I believe, our contract with the town renews every two years, I think, of this last round.
31:58 Yes, it used to be every three years. And with the last renewal, it was for one year with two six-month extensions, I believe. And so there will be no more extensions as of this June coming up. So the goal would be to have a contract in place for the town by July 1st? Yes. Thank you. Tony would like to serve on this one.
32:28 I know. Well, let's go ahead and approve the resolution 2407. I have a motion. There is no resolution included in our packet. I'll just make a note of that. Oh, there's not? Oh, I've got it in mine. Not on the one that was emailed to me didn't have it in there. Oh, really? It's on the one from Patricia. Okay. I'll quickly read the resolution, just for the record. Oh, it's prior to the staff report. Yeah, so it's just misordered.
32:56 Okay. From what I'm used to. I'll read it really quick. So, resolution number 24-07, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc., approving the creation of an ad hoc Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Negotiations Committee, whereas Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. is a non-profit public benefit corporation formed to provide affordable housing in the Eastern Sierra Region of California, and whereas Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc., MLH seeks negotiated contract with the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
33:25 T-O-M-L, T-O-M-L, for services that are related to the organization's mission to support workforce housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. And whereas Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. will disband the ad hoc Town of Mammoth Lakes contract negotiations committee once the full board of directors in the Town of Mammoth Lakes have approved the contract. Now therefore, be it resolved that the board of directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. hereby creates an ad hoc.
33:50 Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Negotiations Committee for the purpose of negotiating a contract between Mammoth Lakes Housing and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll make a motion to approve. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? I have a question. Yes. Patricia, do you know approximately how many times the committee will be meeting and meeting with the town or how you plan to structure the committee work?
34:26 I don't. I know that the town council will be identifying some priorities and that we'll be having a joint meeting as a board before the contract is approved. But I don't know how the town plans to structure their committee members and how we'll collaborate on that.
34:58 But you anticipated the work beginning shortly before the new year, or is this something you're getting in place, kind of, you know, kind of just getting it set up, or just trying to think about time commitment, should I or anyone want to volunteer? I'm trying to see when the, when...
35:21 Because it's a ways out. Yeah, it looks like the town council priority setting won't be happening until January. Okay. And then our joint meeting would be in February. So in the new year, maybe three times with the council representatives separately. Okay. Thank you. Great. Any further questions or comments from the board? I'd like to volunteer. We're going to take the vote to form a committee. Oh, we haven't done that?
35:55 Nope. Oh. Gosh, I thought we'd done that. Oh, you read the- I read the resolution. Yeah, yeah. I'm mixing everybody up today. I'm sorry. Well, I think we're all mixed up. I don't think it's just you, Tom. Okay, vote. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Treasurer Nuttall, you're muted. Sorry, I couldn't hit the button there. Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes.
36:32 Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Motion passes unanimously. With that, we'll move on to Agenda Item 4.7. Appoint Board Members to serve on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Negotiations Committee, previously formed in Agenda Item 4.6. So I'll open it to the Board for...
37:06 Volunteers interested in participating in that committee? I'll volunteer to be on that committee. Thank you, Tony. Jennifer, you've mentioned you'd like to volunteer? Yeah, if there's a need. Okay. I've been involved in, I think, the previous couple of those, and I'm certainly willing to continue doing that, so I'd be happy to volunteer for this committee. Anybody else? Heidi, did you want to join?
37:43 Sure. I would. Terrific. Yeah. If you need it. Okay. Way to share the load here. Okay. Any further discussions? So we will make, I guess I'll entertain a motion to appoint the people who volunteer. I move that we appoint members Hodges, Perkins, Steenstraat, and Kreitz. Yep.
38:16 I'll second the motion. Any further discussion? Angie, roll call, please. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Christ? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Did we forget somebody? Did you?
38:53 Okay. Motion passes. With that, we are on to Agenda Item 4.8. The Board will review and consider support of Proposition 5, which will be on the November 2024 ballot. Patricia, did you want to provide an introduction on this at all? Yes, yeah, I have just a few comments.
39:19 As an organization, we do not have a legislative platform. And so as the executive director, I'm not authorized to sign on to support any initiatives or legislation related to housing at any level. So the two items we have tonight for the board to consider are items that other organizations have signed on to, but that we need to have a
39:48 This first one is Prop 5, which allows local communities to pass certain bonds for affordable housing and local infrastructure with a 55% vote instead of the currently required two-thirds vote. And so I provided some more in-depth background information, but I'd like the board to discuss
40:17 Whether or not our organization should sign on in support or in not of support. What does sign on to support mean? We could, you know, we would sign on to, you know, you can see on the background information other entities that support this particular item, Habitat for Humanity, firefighters, California Professional Firefighters, League of Women Voters.
40:47 And then you can also see those who do not support it. And so to sign on to support would just publicly acknowledge that we support this initiative. And just to be clear, I brought this forward asking for it to be considered by the board knowing that we didn't have a legislative platform, but I think it would be helpful to have one because here we are, you know, considering this tonight and I don't know about you, but I got my ballot in the mail.
41:15 So people are already starting to vote. So it's very time sensitive, some of these things. This is something that the housing advocates in the state have been working on for years trying to change the...
41:34 I think it was a constitutional amendment. I'm not sure. I can't remember because the legislation approved this and then to put it on the ballot, which is on the ballot, you know, on November 5th for us to vote. But it puts affordable housing and public infrastructure in the same category as schools. So we have some school bonds on our local ballots. I know in Bishop you do. I know we do here in Mammoth.
42:03 And it's a 55% threshold to pass, whereas Patricia said if, you know, if they didn't have that, it would be two-thirds. And that's what housing bonds are right now. And any kind of bridges or public infrastructure would be two-thirds. And if this passes, then it will only take 55% vote, just like schools for local public bonds. And so this is a real opportunity to kind of
42:32 I almost think of it as level the planning field for affordable housing.
42:36 As schools, it's such a key part of our community. And I think everyone in California is struggling with, you know, affordable housing and how to fund it. And this is just another tool that makes it more accessible. Passing this doesn't increase our taxes, our property taxes. It just allows a lower voter threshold should our community want to take a bond measure forward in the future. That's all. It doesn't raise our taxes today. So I...
43:06 I am always skeptical about the brochures that you see, so I try to read the language in the law, and that's always a little above my head, but I'm personally in support of what it's trying to do, but I didn't really see how those funds are implemented locally. I assume they would affect somebody's property tax. It wouldn't be...
43:35 Statewide, but locally, if that were to pass, it would be local residents. It's just like what you're going to vote on for your schools. In Bishop, you have a school bond measure or the hospital.
43:48 If there's a hospital, we do that a lot. In Mammoth, I was just looking at my property tax bill because I actually just happened to get that. And it's got a slew of hospital and school bonds on it. And so those are all voted locally and those funds stay local. And when you vote on them, the people putting them forward tell you, well, we're going to do this with these bond monies. This is what we need to do. This is what we want to do. This is what we plan to spend it on. And at that point,
44:18 Okay.
44:42 Or public infrastructure. I want to just be clear. It's not just housing. It could also be used for bridges or any kind of public infrastructure project that your community would want or need. Thank you. Yeah. And so there is a great website. Maybe you went to it, the Yes on Five. It's got broad support. Sorry. I really wasn't just too clear on how it was.
45:16 Implemented and how it was funded and I get that it's just locally. I still don't really understand the details behind that, but it's not necessarily something that has to be. This doesn't fund anything. This just says that if we want to fund something locally, we have a right to do it without such a heavy burden on passing it. 55% versus two-thirds. And at that point.
45:46 Then you could consider whether or not you'd want to support anything. This just makes it easier to pass because housing is so important in our community. I do just want to point out that I was on a California Coalition for Rural Housing legislative meeting today.
46:01 CCRH, California Coalition for Rural Housing, is a big proponent of this, supporting this. It's polling neck and neck with the yeas and nays, so we really do need to get out the vote to pass it. I also mentioned that California State Association of Counties, their board, supported this as well. So just a little bit more background so you know who's in favor as well. Maybe it's not on that list. Well, I'm in favor of Eastern Sierra Community Housing supporting Prop 5 if we were to take a position on it.
46:35 As am I. So is that a motion to approve? Are we doing, are we looking at both propositions before we? No, they're two separate agenda items. Okay. As I see it on the agenda. I'm trying to pay attention. I just, I want to raise a few points. I mean, I tried to read up on this a bit because I haven't had a chance to really deep dive into all these initiatives. But, you know, I mean, I understand the
47:03 The process or, you know, that's lowering that threshold. You know, it's likely, obviously, that the idea is that it's going to make it easier to pass these initiatives. And there certainly probably will be more that will get passed as a result of it. You know, at the end of the day, bonds still cost money. There's still a big cost to bonds. It's a cost that goes, you know, paid through property taxes that ultimately get passed back to the people who live in those housing, whether it's a renter or an owner.
47:32 You know, for me, in some ways, I don't know, I'm just not a big proponent of raising property taxes, quite frankly. And again, it sort of throws the money, the cost of this back into laps of everybody who's paying, whether you're paying rent or whether you're a homeowner, if you do have a tax initiative or a bond passed. Like, you know, I guess it's all fair as much as people are going to vote on it at the time.
48:03 You know, it's not free money, I guess, is my point. And, you know, there's always priorities and decisions to be made on when you're going to self-impose taxes. You know, we passed a school bond, and schools were in dire need of being updated, and I thought that was certainly a good thing. So I would point out, too, in our community, I mean, I know this is a statewide initiative, but, you know, I feel like our community is actually in a pretty good position for funding housing overall, as much as we have a surplus TOT.
48:32 Funds coming in every year, excessive surplus TOT that we've certainly funneled towards housing. Certainly can continue to do that for many, many years to come and I think could more than meet the needs of this community for what our goals are for workforce affordable housing. But anyway, that's my opinion. And the way I see it coming from the perspective of housing is that although some of the
49:01 Measures that take place might benefit affordable housing, whatever gets voted on because of that and the infrastructure, whatever it may be and specifically out here I'm considering recreation for example, we might invest a lot into recreation and then that's going to be passed on into housing through property taxes so it's going to be a
49:32 Everything's going to affect, it's going to raise the proper taxes, but only some of it's going to come back to housing, if it's something that's specific to housing that they're taking bonds on. That was one of the things I read was that just the definition of infrastructure is extremely broad in the measure and there really is no clarity on that. It could be just about anything the local jurisdiction declares as infrastructure and it could be the water district saying we're going to
50:01 Seek this for replacing water lines or whatever it is, right? There's no limits to that. So it's not just the town. It's not, you know, any, I guess, local entity can request a bond measure, as I understand. But then it still has to get voter approval. So instead of, you know, like, I feel like it still has to be approved by the majority of voters. But I know that super majority votes are very hard to pass. So I think that since school bonds and other...
50:28 And I don't understand your hypothetical, honestly.
50:55 It's not just housing that the bill is supporting. It's supporting infrastructure as well. Yes. And emergency response. Yeah. And emergency response. So assuming, and this is just theoretical, nine out of ten of these projects is not going to be an affordable housing project. Where are you getting that statistic? That's just assuming. Say it's four out of five or not. I don't like to assume. Well, regardless, I'm not going to bet my money that.
51:24 More than half of these projects are going to be directly related to affordable housing. I'm going to say the majority of these, especially with the broad spectrum of stuff that it covers, is not going to be directly benefiting affordable housing. It's possible it could. We don't know, and I think that we're kind of getting in the weeds and we're looking at specifics when this is really, supporting Prop 5 allows all communities to make a decision.
51:53 On whether or not they want to pass bonds for infrastructure, affordable housing, or first responders, I think is what you said the other item was. Emergency response. Emergency response. Which in California, all of those things are quite critical. And at a lower threshold, at a 55% threshold. And I think...
52:20 It's not about what we will do in the future when we see one of these bonds. It's do we want to allow all communities across California to have an opportunity to vote?
52:32 At a lower threshold for these three specific areas. And I want to keep in mind, Tom, too, that we're not just talking about Mammoth. I know Mammoth is flush with money. I don't disagree with that, that they come in way over budget. But we're Eastern Sierra Community Housing, and some of our other communities might actually benefit from having a bond measure that could pass at 55% for affordable housing. I'm thinking specifically of Bishop, which has no resources right now for affordable housing.
53:01 So I just, I don't want to close the door because Mammoth has a lot of money. And the point I'm just trying to make is regardless of how the details work out, although some might get invested into housing, not all of it will, but all of it is going to end up getting paid out of
53:23 People's property taxes. If they say yes. If they vote yes in the future. If it affects. If we are all in support of it. Just like the schools and the hospital and the fire. Fire. Yes. All of those things. Heidi, did you have a comment? Well, I just wanted to thank you all for your comments and thoughts and discussion. It's funny that you are talking, not funny, but talking about this as in my downtime, I
53:57 Don't have a lot to do except for read right now, so I am reading all of the information on the upcoming elections. And one of my concerns with this is, yes, I do agree, a lower threshold will allow smaller areas, maybe like with Mammoth, because we are a smaller community or bishop to
54:25 I also think along Tony's line that
54:52 It's not always going to be about housing, affordable housing, and the broadness of the language in there. So those were just my thoughts on this item. I do want to also point out that infrastructure is largely often tied to affordable housing. I know here in the town of Mammoth Lakes, we received an IIG grant of $23 million, which was an infrastructure and support of housing grant.
55:24 You know, the state of California just doesn't have funds available like they used to for those programs. And so I could see, you know, infrastructure bonds happening that are in support of housing as well. It's important to see the nexus, I think, between these three and why they came forward the way they have in this proposition. There's no guarantees, obviously, in it, much of anything. Death and taxes, I think.
55:56 Well, I'd like to just make a motion and we'll see where this goes so we can move on for the sake of time that we support Eastern Sierra Community Housing, aka Mammoth Lakes Housing, support Proposition 5 on the November 24 ballot. I'll second the motion. Any further discussion by the board? Roll call, Angie. President Hodges? No. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Treasurer Nuttall?
56:36 Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? No. Board Member Steenstra? No. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Board Member Rice? Yes. Okay. Motion passes 6-3. Moving on to item 4.9, the board will review and consider support of Proposition 33, which will be on the November 2024 ballot.
57:20 Patricia, some background? Yes, thank you, a little bit. This initiative will repeal the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act, which currently limits local jurisdictions' ability to enact rent control measures. Locally, I remember having a conversation at the town council about potentially
57:51 Thinking about how to keep space rents affordable since manufactured housing is often seen as affordable by design. But with increasing space rents into the thousand dollars a month, it continues to become more and more unaffordable.
58:13 And the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act was used as a reason why we can't enact any local rent control measures. And so that's just one example of what this proposition might be able to do. It would empower local jurisdictions to formulate and decide upon different rent control measures that they may or may not want to implement. So when you say
58:47 Local rent control measures, so I'm under the impression the state you can't raise the rent over 5% year after year, but if this was repealed, say locally they wanted to reduce that to 3% or just theoretically they wanted to reduce that or change it, we could do that locally.
59:15 In opposition to what the state standard is? Yes, if it's anything in addition to what the current state regulations are stricter, then the local jurisdiction would be able to do that. I've been seeing the commercials for this, both of them, on the baseball games for the last month, and I was going to call you and ask you what you thought. And I tried reading the legal text, and it just...
59:42 said it repealed all the language that I was trying to read that was crossed out, but I still didn't understand what exactly it was doing, and I personally try to also gauge by the supporters that are looking at it, and I'm not exactly sure what the AIDS Healthcare Foundation, what interest they have in this bill.
1:00:11 And I'm not saying that in a discriminatory manner. I had family who died of AIDS, so I'm not an opponent of that foundation, but I don't see what their interest is in it. And reading through the language, I still didn't really understand the ramifications of it personally. I think it applies, as I understood, I was reading up on it a little bit, that currently any housing product that was built after 95 is
1:00:42 Exempt from being considered for rent control, as are single-family residences, which include townhomes and condos and so forth. This would repeal that and would allow local jurisdictions to consider rent control on any of those housing types. And age. I mean, Costa Hawkins was passed, like, in, what, 95? And I think that's part of the need for updating.
1:01:12 Policy is that we get stuck at the state. We passed these, the Costa-Hawkins Act, and then we're stuck in 95, and now it's 2024, and the homes are 20 years old, and they still can't be included in rent control. I think the thinking when this was passed, and anybody, feel free to correct me if I'm misunderstood, because it's highly possible I am, but that they didn't want to put...
1:01:39 Rent control on newer product. So they were rent controlling an older product, but now so many years have passed and that's why they excluded certain product type. But this really allows, you know, for local jurisdictions, again, to make changes and enact policies outside of the state Costa-Hawkins Act.
1:02:02 So we could be more locally prescriptive and not have to adhere to the state's definition from this old policy, this old housing act. You know, for me personally, all this stuff's political, right? I just fundamentally have a real problem with government price controls, period. And I don't feel that the government should be meddling in market rates.
1:02:36 And that the market takes care of itself. I understand that housing's expensive. But, you know, we're making steps in our community to address it in our particular way. We're figuring out a way to find solutions. You know, I would add that, you know, people who make investments in their single-family home is the single largest asset they own. And that this, again, unintended.
1:03:04 Consequences of this potential measure could drastically affect market values of people's assets and, you know, lower their personal wealth that they've worked years to build. You know, I just, again, fundamentally I have a real problem with, and there's just, there's nothing in there. It's just left to the local jurisdiction to decide whether they're going to impose rent control on people who've made investments on their properties.
1:03:32 And now they're changing the rules after they've already, you know, invested, could be the majority of their personal assets in their home and affecting, seriously affecting their personal equity. I just think there's no business for the government to be doing that. And I think that, you know, we're addressing affordable housing through building subsidized housing that's rent controlled, deed restricted, other methods of creating deed restricted units, and it's no business of the governments to be imposing
1:04:02 Basically, imposing on people's personal property rights and personal assets, you know, through this measure, I just think it's totally misguided and has very, very poor, has a lot of potential poor consequences, quite frankly. Yeah, I still have questions about it, so I don't know any, for those who have read up on it more than I have. So, for example, if this was to pass, then our...
1:04:38 Town Council could vote to say rent in Mammoth cannot be more than $300 per room, so if you have a one-bedroom place, it's going to be $300, and that could pass, and that's what people have to do? I mean, is that as how easily you could impose rent control? It's not something that... I think local jurisdictions can always, under the current law, impose more onerous...
1:05:06 Rent controls than the baseline cost to Hawkins with its age limitations and things of that nature. There are lots of examples here in Southern California of local cities that have protections above and beyond the state. The state law just provides kind of a baseline. And I think part of the concern with repealing that is that what I've heard is that some jurisdictions could use new, very onerous rent control provisions to stymie.
1:05:33 The production of housing, it could be an anti-development measure to avoid new projects being developed in communities. This one's complicated to me. This is not straightforward. My inclination would be to vote no on it, but again, this is very arcane, I think. Yeah, I mean, I think there's some good intentions, but I just feel like the way this all came together, there's just so many
1:06:04 Ways this can go run afoul, honestly, is sort of my quick take on it, but again, I'm voicing my own personal opinion. Yeah, it's interesting. Does anybody know what's the, because one of the opponents of it in that document in our packet is a California Council for Affordable Housing? What is that organization? I did not look it up yet. I was surprised to see them on the list as opposing.
1:06:42 I don't know them personally, but I assume it's an organization that believes that this proposal would jeopardize the construction of new affordable housing. And then the supporters that are on this list here are not specifically housing-related. Okay, is there any further discussion from the board? I mean, I guess I would like to see that, you know, like how Patricia was saying,
1:07:33 RV park or mobile home units. There's absolutely no rent control on the space. So those have become less and less affordable as the space rental goes up. But I agree with you, Brian. I don't know that this is the right answer for that. It's not specific to that. Right. It's not specific to that. So I would be inclined to not support this one. Well, and I will say the town of Mammoth Lakes, for example, the county.
1:08:03 Any jurisdiction can today pass a rent control on space rents in their mobile home parks. You have jurisdiction already to do that. This doesn't preclude or change your ability to do that right now. Thank you. Yeah. But the Costa-Hawkins Act has been used as a reason why not to.
1:08:33 That it's brought up and then people would need to research more, get legal advice to double check? Yeah, that the state has rules in place for rent control and that we need to make sure we're following all those before we do anything. It's more of an excuse. There's nothing legal about that statement because plenty of jurisdictions in California have rent control on mobile home parks, for example, and it's legal.
1:09:04 So it's more of a deflection. But the act is to repeal it. So it's not we're just repealing something that might be it's not supporting it. It's repealing that. And then not putting anything else in place. Exactly. Are there any other examples of things if it was repealed that
1:09:56 Benefits us in Mammoth. I mean, because it, yeah, I'm having trouble making a decision. If it's not there, so places built after 95, what do we do differently locally if this is repealed? Well, you know, again, it means there's no exceptions at that point, so it could apply to anything, any property.
1:10:32 Whatever the policy the local jurisdiction adopts, there would be no rent control policy in the Eastern Sierra should this cost of Hawkins go away, but we already don't have a rent control policy in the Eastern Sierra in any community, so it really doesn't change anything specifically for us. It more so allows a locally curated policy to be enacted without
1:11:01 These provisions set by the state that it allows that. It's almost like Prop 5 in a way that it doesn't mandate anything. It just allows changes. But it currently excludes all single-family homes, you know, residences, whether single-family residents.
1:11:19 Or condo or townhome. Should you have a rent control policy? But again, we don't have one locally in the Eastern Sierra. Nobody has a rent. But you can't, you couldn't enact one that would impose anything on those types of residents. True, you cannot today. Correct. I think that's pretty critical distinction. And condos are included in that list. Yeah. Okay. But should this pass?
1:11:43 You could curate locally a rent control policy. That would include single-family homes and townhomes. If they wanted to.
1:11:50 Exactly. If they want to. Again, you could curate any policy that you would want without the state telling you what it should or could and can't have. That's exactly what it does. You can't say it will have something should this pass because we don't know. It's just like saying we're going to have an affordable housing bond measure. There's nothing to say that's going to happen. It just allows for it. Yeah, but it...
1:12:16 It does now allow for that single-family homes to be considered where currently it does not. Well, it says, I just pulled this up. It says, at the moment, state law limits rent increases for tenants in apartments and corporate-owned single-family homes that are older than 15 years. The cap is set at 5% plus inflation with a maximum increase of 10%. Local jurisdiction can impose stricter caps but with limits.
1:12:45 Let's see. This law allows property owners to charge whatever they want when a unit becomes vacant. Once a new tenant moves in, the limitations take effect. If Prop 33 passes, it would repeal the state law known as Costa Hawkins that bans localities from capping rent on vacant units, single-family homes, and apartments built after February 1, 1995 or earlier. Local governments wouldn't be required to regulate rents on such properties, but they could if they wanted to.
1:13:16 Yeah, right now, the only rent control we have in our region that we serve is state mandated, and that would be on apartments. And like you said, any corporate owned properties, which I'm not sure we have many. I guess just the mountains homes fall under that. I don't know. One or two at the hospital. The rules are slightly different on commercial property as well. Right, right.
1:13:49 Non-residential. Well, I don't know, what's the pleasure of the board? Is anybody going to make a motion? Is anybody going to make a motion to? No, sounds like there's some ambiguity out there. I don't know. I mean, I don't want to speak for the board. If anybody's prepared to make a motion, otherwise we can move on to the next agenda item. I don't hear a motion. I think we're ready to move on. Okay. Thank you, everybody, for the lively discussion. And get out there and vote.
1:14:34 More than anything, your vote counts. Okay, we'll move on then to item 4.10. The board will receive updates on current construction projects, Innsbruck Lodge and Access Apartments. I think that Eric's going to take this one. Yep, so I'm going to take this one over. So, American Project Program Associate, and this is an update for Innsbruck Lodge. So, these are construction photos. They were taken on October 10th, or October 1st.
1:15:18 So the upper, the two photos on the upper corners are from the upper floors or the upper units and then the two on the bottom are the lower units or I guess on the basement level and then the one in the middle is the laundry room that we have laundry there. It's connected I believe but we just can't use it because we need to switch gear in order to be fully functional. Project updates.
1:15:50 So lease up, we are projecting it to be for November and December, and this will be for the next 10 units, and currently the Healthy Navigators are working to look at operational subsidy sources, so that would include any rental subsidy that we can get for our clients or 10 additional clients that are going to be there. For our punch block item,
1:16:14 We have the upper units. We walked it with our project manager, which is Kevin, and then architect, which is Daniel. We walked the property on September 11th. And then that, I compiled the list together of all the items that still need to be completed or that were missing on the upper units. And that was sent out to Christian, which is our GC, which is general contractor. And he, I talked to him last week.
1:16:42 And he said that he should be completing the punch walk items by the 14th. So after he lets us know about that, then we'll go over there and do a revised punch list on that and hopefully make sure everything is completed. For the electrical portion of it, we got news that the arrival will actually be on the 13th of January of next year. So that notice came later than what we expected.
1:17:12 Initiating an extension request to the state and we're working with the town to finalize that and send that out to them. And then our property manager which just met was Jose. I've been working with him to clean up some of the stuff that we need in the property. So clean up the basement, the hallway in the back and then remove some furniture on the outside and then he's been working diligently with the tenants to build relationships.
1:17:41 That's been going good on his side. Miscellaneous, we've been in contact with Architect, I guess I've been in contact with Architect about bike racks, so that is something that we are, we need to put into it, so we've been working on that, see where we can do that. Gas Connection, that was connected, I believe it was two weeks ago.
1:18:02 So that is connected. We are just waiting for the gas tanks to be empty, the ones we have in the back, so that they can fill up and connect to the main tanks that we have on the parking lot. And then internet that is pending. We are on their project list. So hopefully we can get that sorted out and have internet for the tenants soon. Construction budget. So we are up to 95% of it used. And then you can see on the left side some of the items that were completed.
1:18:32 That is, so the stripe one was completed, cabinetry is done, as you can see from the photos, it's the upper units, and I guess all the units have cabinetry now. So that's completed, again, mentioned, laundry room machines are installed, except they can't be used, so that's still pending switch gear, which leads us to what's left. It is the switch gear, so that we will have to do some exterior roof remodel on a little side roof, not the main roof.
1:19:01 So that will, we'll need to work on that, that will extend it, and then connecting switch gear, so doing the labor for that, and connecting it back to all the other units to that, to the switch gear. Other stuff that is left is the lobby window. We did replace two of them, and then we have the upper lobby windows that we need still to replace, so that's pending. Again, upper.
1:19:26 First unit inspection, or the punch walk, is to be completed next week, so I will reach back out to Christian, which is our general contractor on that, and then the lower units should be completed within a month, and that includes appliances, the countertops, plumbing, the punch walk, and then doing the revised punch walk on that.
1:19:48 I guess percent spent to date right now is 93% as of October. I am going to work on updating this so you guys can see what the proposed budget, after budget, and then spent to date based on each line item. Funding, same thing. We will be, I guess I will be changing this to reflect the percent spent to date from each funding stack that we have. So that's pending next time. And then this is just a background of what we've been doing.
1:20:19 It's just good to know, just to see the progress that we've been doing since now. And then we did update the COO, which is the certificate of occupancy will be in winter or spring of 2025 for the rest of the units, or I guess for the full billing. And that is... Sorry, can you, you said that the certificate of occupancy for the rest of the units will be in the winter? Winter or spring once we get the switchgear installed. Okay. The remaining 11.
1:20:48 So real quick, Eric, I didn't really, wasn't able to decipher from all the information. Thank you very much for all that. You know, we're spent 93%, but where do we think that we are coming in within budget and that we won't expend all of our contingency, we're not going to go over budget? I mean, that's the bottom line question.
1:21:09 As I mentioned under the whole person care item, I think we're about $150,000 over budget, which we had anticipated at the time of requesting additional funds from the town in February of the previous year, 2023. So that can be deferred developer fee. We can
1:21:41 We can allocate it that way. So it will be $150 in addition to if we're successful in the other $149 funding requests to the county supervisors? Yes. Yeah. And that includes all the contingency? Yes. OK. Can I ask, I thought the switch was coming in the fall, and they pushed it to January? Yes. Is there?
1:22:07 A possibility that they're going to push it out further than that, or do we have any guarantee of when that will actually arrive? No, it seems like it's maybe been, it's been, obviously it's been pushed a couple of different times. We've asked for expedited processing, they just keep saying they can't guarantee anything. Okay, thank you. And the funding stack will be updated to include the whole person care funds, but otherwise it's comprehensive besides that.
1:22:38 Yes, yeah, and as Eric mentioned, he's planning to do some updating on these slides to show which sources have been fully expended and what's left in the development budget and in the funding stack as well. And then are we in good standing with the state with the home key funding and just as far as our delays relative to the equipment delivery sort of kind of beyond our control, right?
1:23:06 So I've initiated an extension request with Nolan at the town of Mammoth Lakes. Since it's a joint contract with the state between us and the town, and I've asked him for direction on whether or not he would like me to send the request or if he would like to send the request or make any changes, I'm just waiting to hear back from him. Yeah, but effectively everything will be 100% complete with the exception of that switchgear being installed and tied together.
1:23:35 Otherwise, the units would be signed off. So hopefully the state would, I would think, would look favorably upon the fact that we're basically there, just notwithstanding a supplier delay that was kind of beyond our control. Yeah, and I think the fact that we have temporary certificate of occupancy for the first five units and the manager's unit shows a really good faith effort to occupy the project. Right. And then you had a note that you're already going to be qualifying new tenants for the remaining units.
1:24:02 Yes, yeah, I think it's in the slides, but I'm sure Isara will touch on it in her report. Our plan is to, in November, December, start pre-qualifying tenants from the coordinated entry system. I have another question. On the internet, is Altice providing that at a discount for tenants, or is there any coordination through their programs for some kind of affordable housing clientele?
1:24:30 Yes, they offered us a bulk rate for the affordable housing project, and so we'll be paying for the internet for the project. The only issue is that we are in their construction pipeline. Okay. Similar to the switchgear. Yes, we're just waiting for them to show up. Perfect. Thank you. And the property manager asks me every week, so, about the internet, because the tenants want to watch their Netflix.
1:24:58 You know, there's no internet. And so he asks every week, and I say, I'll email them, and I email them every week, and they say, we'll look into it. And then, so it just keeps going. So the tenants don't have the opportunity to get their own internet from a different provider independently? They could. I don't think any of our tenants have the financial ability to pay for additional utilities on their own at this point. But they...
1:25:27 Yeah, they have their cell phones. That's what most of them are using. So if you create a bulk of time, Patricia, how does that work? Are they paying any common area assessment fees? No, the property pays for all of the utilities. None of the utilities are sub-metered, and so the property will pay for internet, water, gas.
1:25:59 And electricity for all of the units. And that's just built into their monthly rate or something? Yes, and so when we submitted the application to the state, we submitted a pro forma that demonstrated that the restricted rents at these income levels would be able to afford the operating costs of this project.
1:26:31 Through our asset management and operating budgets that we'll be working on as soon as we get fully occupied, we will be making sure that we can stay in the green. And one last question, Patricia, just at least for me, on the AMI mix on the property is up to 80% AMI.
1:27:06 Or the higher AMI level units are still the ones that we need to rent, is that correct? Because all the ones that we have rent so far have been the... We have all 80. Yeah, we have the first five are 80% AMI units. Oh, the first five that already rent are 80%? Yes, yeah. And then there's only two 30% units at the property, and the rest are all 80. Oh, the rest are all 80, okay. Well, that's interesting. Okay. Up to 80. Yeah, they're all at 80%, but we're working.
1:27:37 Yeah. The rents are at 80%, but we are hoping that the rental subsidy will cover the portion, because right now, I believe there is only one tenant that is paying rent at 80% on his own. Everybody else is on some sort of county rental assistance for now, and we're getting them onto the permanent rental subsidy. Great. Any further questions?
1:28:08 I guess I'll just say this now instead of later, but I am in the process of setting up an additional grant award that we received through the Continuum of Care for Emergency Solutions grant funding, which is project-specific for rapid rehousing programs at Innsbruck Lodge. And so it's, I think it's about $60,000 that we'll be able to access.
1:28:36 In the event that our incoming tenants are unable to pay up to the 80% AMI rents temporarily. It's temporary rent subsidy. Okay. Okay. No further questions. We can move on to Access. I saw that being worked on. That was exciting. There it is. Yeah. So next one is Access. That is our newest one, newest development. Again, this is for October.
1:29:22 So these are some progress photos. These were taken the same October 1st where we did a walkthrough with Kevin and the structure engineers. They are working really closely with Tim, which is our project supervisor there, and they are, yeah, just, I guess, working diligently to get that done. You'll see later on, but I guess the picture in the middle, bottom in the middle.
1:29:50 That is Building B. It will look different at the end of this week. They will be adding a second floor to it. So be tuned to that. And if you guys want to go through, just let me know or drive through and we can set up that meeting with Tim. This is more updated construction photos. So these were from before the previous one. So this is more, you know, bare bones portion of it. So yeah.
1:30:18 All right, project updates. Like I mentioned, we've been meeting weekly with the owner, which is our architect and contractor. That's our OAC meetings. And we've been identifying topics and stuff that we need to go through. So that's been really helpful to be meeting with them weekly. And then we, for our financing, we are currently on our third pay app for them. And we're working with the town and CBG to get them paid for that. And then we're pending the money from Mono County.
1:30:48 Which should be done tomorrow. We should be figuring that out and depositing that. Again, sidewalk, we completed that on October 1st with the structural engineers. They had some comments for Tim, so they'll be figuring that out. And then miscellaneous, we'll be having insurance inspection on the 10th, or on Friday, which is the 11th. I will be meeting the inspector out there, so be tuned for that.
1:31:15 Milestones, we are still set to occupy for fall of 2025. So we're on track to be, you know, be finished with the project by then. This is the three-week look ahead for it. So like I mentioned, building A will be, the second floor will be completed floor framing by, it should have been completed already. Then the roof framing will be completed by the 12th. Then the roof installation became
1:31:47 The Parcel begins on the 14th, which is next week. On building B, the first floor framing is complete, and then the second one will start the day after that, second floor framing, which will be on this week, on Wednesday, I believe. And then the trusses, lumber, and the rest of the materials will be delivered on the 15th. So there's a lot going on on the property. Budget development, again, same thing as Innsbruck. I will be updating this one, but we spent up to date four to five.
1:32:20 And that's just background. I have to see what we've done and where we're headed. And then if you guys have any questions.
1:32:46 I just, I was to say that I drove by on my way here today and the sheeting's already up on the north side of the main building, building, I guess that's B or is that A? A, yeah. And it's just trucking along, it looks great. I try to drive down that street more than ever now, so love it. And walk sometimes too, sometimes I walk by, ride, I could look more.
1:33:13 Yeah, I have to say, I mean, I'm very impressed with the progress, the construction progress. They're doing a great job, and I, you know, knock on wood, they're going to get dried in here before the weather turns south on us, or turns white, looking like that. So, yeah, really impressive and very, very happy with their progress, doing a great job. I was going to add, maybe in the future monthly reports, again, just sort of maybe having a slide where
1:33:42 You know, we have just that recap of our, I mean, have what we spent and so forth, but just again, sort of monitoring that contingency. If we know we were expending money is against the contingency, just sort of where we are on a running balance month to month on the contingency, I think would be helpful for the board to hear if we're, you know, just again, so we can kind of recognize if we're, you know, having some issues that are running down the contingency and just want to be well prepared, you know,
1:34:12 I was at the town council meeting where the town council said, hey, if you've run into trouble or whatever, you can come back and ask for more, but let us know. So I'd like to be ahead of that or at least understand if we think we're ever going to be threatening our contingencies as we go through the project. But I would assume at this point a lot of the heavy lifting with the structural modifications is kind of behind us, right? We're putting the building back together now. Have we encountered anything of any note at this point? No, not at this point.
1:34:42 Point. However, I will just mention that there have been some comments about the snow rail design, and so I think that will be going back to the engineers for redesign. I don't have the change order for that, but I'll just give you a heads up, and we'll include that in the next update. Okay. So nothing serious in the $740,000 line I'm for contingency at this point?
1:35:11 I mean, I understand. No, nothing substantial at this point. Yeah, no big unknowns that showed up while we were tearing the building apart at this point. No, not yet. Which is a relief. That's huge. Great. Any further comments or questions from the board? Okay. We can then move on to agenda item 4.11, MLH programs update. Patricia and staff. I will be doing the staff report or program update.
1:35:51 So for the rental program, I recently had a meeting with the supervisor, Santos, I believe is her name, and they have a couple of units actually that are vacant, but they are going to be rehabbing a good portion of them. Only one of the several that they have is going to be leasing up in the next couple of weeks, which is not the best news, but it's also great because the next tenants will have a better place to live in permanent housing.
1:36:20 There are a couple of applications that are pending just due to staff not being able to get to them in the last couple of weeks, but there hasn't been much movement other than that one unit that has opened up. So that is, so I don't have specific household numbers for you as of right now. Could I just ask a quick question? I'm just trying to, I'm reading the staff report on the bullet items there and 220 households.
1:36:48 Comprised of 545 individuals, I'm assuming. And then it says 89% have an income below 80% of the area median income, which is interesting. That's an interesting statistic because I know like with the parcel development, right, with, you know, those units are a blend up to 80% but averaging of 60% AMI. But it would appear that there is actually a lot of demand in those income ranges for that product because they have
1:37:18 You know, the 80 plus one manager unit, right, 81 units plus the second phase is 144 units. So we'll be at, you know, two, whatever the math works out there, 220 something total units that will all be at a blended rate of 60% AMI, I believe, right? So I just, I was just curious because it seems like, you know, we should be able to, I guess there was some concern that we might not be able to fill all the units because there were, the income rates were, you know, relatively low, you know, relative to demand.
1:37:51 It seems like there might be, you know, a fit there still with what we have on the waiting list. I know that our waiting list isn't their waiting list, but I'm assuming those people are applying to them as well. Yes. Which is something that I mentioned a couple meetings ago. A lot of the tenants that were in the Aspen Village Apartments, Manzanita, Jefferies, Bissacone, the affordable housing that was in now, a lot of those tenants transitioned from those units to the parcel. So that is...
1:38:19 The reason why there's a lot of movement of units right now. The 89% are, that includes the 30, 50, 60, and 80% households. So, and then another thing is a lot of our local people know that we are the go-to people for affordable housing, so they will apply with us first, which is great, and then we give them the resource to apply for the parcel. Thank you, that's great. I also want to say, I, I,
1:38:45 I hear the frustration with the units being offline, but those units are almost 20 years old, and they've been occupied full-time since, and so I think a little rehabilitation is probably long overdue, and so I think it's a good thing. We think so, too. A lot of local people, they're like, well, they're just empty, but they're like, yeah, but they're not in great condition, so there can be a better condition once we put you in there, which is great. For housing navigation,
1:39:17 I currently have one client of mine that is enrolled in the HDAP program. We are looking for more HDAP applicants or participants because Mono County does have an HDAP program that a lot of elderly people who are applying for SSDI do not know about. So we are just making an effort to try to find those individuals and get them on that program. For ones that they do get housing, they have that rental subsidy to find them of permanent housing.
1:39:47 Regarding rental subsidies, like I mentioned, there is four tenants at Innsbruck Lodge that are on rental subsidies on behalf of their individual counties. Two...
1:39:58 I would say now we're transitioning one of them. One of them will be on full Section 8 rental subsidy, hopefully in the next two weeks. We're just waiting on some paperwork, but the other tenants are on Alpine County, Inyo County, and Mono County rental subsidies at this moment. It's just one tenant that is paying the full 80% rent, and we're getting funding from CalAIM, Anthem, Section 8 HCV, which is Housing Choice Voucher, the Mainstream Voucher, which is more of a disability voucher.
1:40:28 And then finding other rental subsidies is always in the works. Through sometimes Medi-Cal can often, I believe Medi-Cal is actually going to start a program soon based off of the COC meeting for six months worth of rental subsidies and possibly a down payment, I'm sorry, a security deposit for the units. And then we have two active participants that we are helping with communication for the parcel project just due to some technology barriers sometimes, communication as well.
1:41:01 So anybody who's having a difficult time getting a hold of Buckingham property management or the property manager at the parcel, we are always there to facilitate that communication, whether they're already clients of ours or just somebody that walked in through the door for the first time. I recently just did a training with Inyo County for
1:41:24 Inputting data into the coordinated entry system, since that system is used for statistics federally to get funding, we have to make sure that all of our paperwork is up to date. So I recently, again, just attended that training at Inyo County to input all of our clients who are in some sort of affordable housing, either through the county or through us, transitional housing, permanent housing, or supportive housing, all of those files need to be inputted into that database manually.
1:41:53 So, I just did that as well. Then we have the, where is it? The Continuum of Care at our last meeting did release the 2024 point in time count. And the numbers, I believe you can share the numbers in front of you. But Inyo County, there are 14 chronically homeless individuals in Inyo County and then two chronically homeless individuals in Mono County.
1:42:22 Total individual experiencing homelessness in the region is 71 in Inyo County and 35 in Mono County. And this is the assessment that we did back in January of this past year. Inyo County and Mono County both participated. Alpine County was not able to participate, but they tried to do, well, they didn't try, they did a pick count in the summer, since that is the time of the year that has most homelessness individuals out and about.
1:42:48 So their numbers were released but at a different date and I'm not sure if I have those with me right now. Or they might actually not been released, I'm sorry. Since it was a trial that they were trying to run for homelessness in the summer rather than in the winter when everyone has found shelter in either a shack or in somebody's room, living room, etc. And like Eric had mentioned, we are going to be starting the lease of process for the other 10 units in the next.
1:43:19 Upcoming months. We discovered that the lease process takes a little bit longer just because getting communication with a lot of the people in the coordinated entry system can sometimes be difficult since they change their numbers, they change locations, they change case workers, social workers, stuff like that. It's difficult to get a hold of them and we don't want for them to miss out on housing when they're up there on our list to provide them for housing.
1:43:49 We are working with the tenants very closely with making sure that their leases are being upheld at all times. Having individuals who have a very close-knit community in the homelessness realm of things can sometimes be difficult for people that are in permanent housing since they like to bring them over, have them stay over, provide them for a house for a night or two, which we completely understand and we'll try to get.
1:44:18 We try to have those people come into our office and fill out the same application that they did to get into permanent housing. But friends, family, they still need all of that, all that social connection with people in their community. So although sometimes it could be lease violations, we try to work with them to find other ways instead of just being, okay, sorry you violated your lease, you're out of the unit. So we made a housing retention action plan which gives a couple of steps as to
1:44:45 steps the case manager, property manager, and the owner need to take before getting to the we're going to have to evict you process. Another very key important thing, we did find an IHSS worker, which is an in-home supportive services caretaker for one of the tenants, the tenant that is in the ADA unit.
1:45:11 I believe, as far as it is my understanding, she is the first person in Mammoth Lakes who is not a family member who is helping someone who is in need of in-home supportive services. So that was a good, a great UP for us. Hopefully, from what she stated, is that she wasn't aware of the IHSS program, so she's making it her purpose to tell other people about it so they could participate in in-home supportive services in Mammoth Lakes specifically.
1:45:40 Because we do have a lot, we have a very big elderly population up here that need in-home supportive services and there just aren't any supportive services that live in the unit or that come every other day for these people. And I think that is it. We do have the tenant that is in the transitional housing. He will be moving into the parcel hopefully in the next two weeks. So the Birch Creek unit will be rehabbing it.
1:46:14 After the tenant moves out of the unit. So hopefully we plan on putting a family into the unit rather than putting multiple single individuals because we have noticed that with the projects that are going on it's very difficult for families to get placed in permanent housing since the units are studios, one bedrooms. So we want to make it our purpose to put a family in the unit who has kids or several kids or married couple with kids. If you can touch the ownership part. Thank you.
1:46:47 I just want to say thank you to Isara. Most of all of that work that she just listed has been all of her, and some of it is work that we've never done before, and that's unprecedented to help a client achieve a Section 8 voucher. And so I just wanted to say thank you. Yay, good job, Isara. Thank you. Which helps us grow our revenue.
1:47:14 But also helps our clients who need these sources of subsidy but have such a challenging time accessing them. So it's really impressive. For home ownership, we have a lot going on. ESARA is organizing a credit score educational course that we'll have hopefully at the library on October 29th. We'll send out any additional information as soon as we confirm.
1:47:45 We have homeownership stewardship is getting wrapped up with our annual monitoring and then I wanted to highlight the bridge program. We just sold another another home to a family in the town using the bridge program and so that's seven units completed with that program and we currently have three units for sale. Two of those units
1:48:15 Well, actually, all three of them, we have a lot of clients, so we have a lot of interest. We have clients lined up for those units. It just depends on whether or not it's going to work out financially. But Eric and I are working together to make sure we're income-qualifying folks and figuring out which programs they can use for down payment assistance in addition to the bridge subsidy.
1:48:41 So that's been really successful. It's just really busy, a lot of work. We're also exploring setting up a program with Mono County, a similar bridge program. The Mono County Board of Supervisors did allocate some funds for a pilot program. I've met with their staff on that and will be preparing a proposal for them on some services, some different options on how.
1:49:10 We could collaborate and what that might look like. I'll be working on that tomorrow. Are there any questions on ownership or I'll just move to projects. I had a quick question, Patricia. Do you know roughly how many people are on the waiting list for homeownership program? Eight. Eight active. Eight active. Eight active. Eight active. So it's not that deep. No, but there's all these like people.
1:49:40 Scraggling or like that just haven't submitted everything or are interested but haven't gotten their pre-qual and so there's a lot of hand-holding through that entire process. Right, right. But the university they have, like you say, you have three kind of currently in the works and then the town will be adding the four on Joaquin Street once those become complete, maybe in the spring. So there's real opportunities out there for people if they, you know.
1:50:10 Get in, get the paperwork done, make sure they're in touch with you guys and understand what their options are. Again, different levels, different AMI levels and different programs, it's going to be unique fits for each one. So, you know, I guess the point being is somebody, you know, could find a house quickly if they were really, you know, qualified properly and had all their stuff done.
1:50:31 Yeah, yeah, and yeah, that's exactly right, and that's exactly what we say about our rental wait list as well. I mean, you could be number one on the waiting list, and you're a household of three, and the first unit we have come up is a one-bedroom. Right. That doesn't mean you're the first household to get in the unit. Right. So we have folks interested, but that doesn't mean that you shouldn't still apply. Yeah, I've had people approach me. I just tell them, look, go see Eric, Patricia, get your information in there. Yeah.
1:51:00 The most important thing is get on that list and you'll be surprised if something might come up sooner than you expect. Yes, yeah, and I did meet with the town about the Joaquin Project and so we're in conversations about what our role can be to help them get those units sold. Great. Moving on to projects quickly. Valley Apartments, we've been moving to get some additional information.
1:51:30 Back to the state, including a relocation plan, an updated construction loan letter from a bank, and a few other things. And I had a phone call with the state that was optimistic. They said that the project should be going to their internal loan committee in the next month or so, and so that we would hopefully receive something in writing.
1:51:55 So our next steps will be to work on a request for proposals for architectural services so that we can get some as-built plans so that we know exactly the extent of the rehabilitation that we need to do and the ADA improvements. We can have that lined up so that when we get the award we can
1:52:25 We can execute that contract and be ready to go. So that's exciting. I think that will be our next big project. And that's 19 units in the City of Bishop. And then I had a meeting with Visionary Home Builders, who is our partner on the Silver Peak's tax credit project in Bishop as well, and the city administrator and their planning department.
1:52:56 We talked about some different new concepts for the site, which Visionary will be going back to the table to come up with some financing ideas, and then they will bring some more information to the City Council in December. So I'll keep you posted once that meeting is scheduled.
1:53:27 Intend to apply for the next affordable housing sustainable communities round. So we'll be on the team helping them as they need us. Patricia, remind me the number of units on that property? The rental, the original scope was 72, 70 tax credit units and two managers units. Yep.
1:53:55 There's some discussion about maybe doing a small home ownership component and reducing the number of rentals. So we'll see what they come back with. Yeah. Just for my other board members' benefit, that's a property that's located in Bishop, kind of close to the city park, kind of between the city park and Vons, on the sort of east side of Bishop there. Yeah, and so it's still really deep in the financing phase and really struggling to find what tools are going to work there.
1:54:27 And then we have a number of other conversations going on. There's another potential project in the City of Bishop, which is an acquisition, just talking to the Health and Human Services Department about that. I'm having some conversations with the Mono Lake Tribe about a project that they would like to do in Lee Vining.
1:54:53 There's obviously the Glass Mountain Project, which we've talked about, that's on hold until further notice. And then there's been some conversations about launching a safe parking initiative and understanding what our role might be in that. I think those are all the projects that we have. Yeah, just a couple things. Let's see, we have a lot of other things going on.
1:55:28 We did play musical chairs with the computers, which just does take some time and energy. We renewed our liability insurance for the company, so I had to work through that process. I'm currently working to update our retirement plan documents with some new legislation that's come out, so we may need...
1:55:57 I may need to have a tax attorney prepare that and so once I get an estimate I can let you know the cost of that and we can take a look at the budget. I did do, I partnered with Alpine County to interview a candidate for their housing navigator position. I will potentially be onboarding that person.
1:56:24 Shortly, but Alpine County had some staffing changeover again, and so I'm waiting for direction on that. Those contracts expire this June, and so I'll also be working with the counties to renew those contracts for housing navigation. We're doing some outreach around the chip-in initiative, which is the credit card processing fundraising tool that the board
1:56:56 gave direction to pursue, and I met with the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association this morning to see if anybody might be interested in joining us. I have the name change notifications that need to go out on our to-do list. I'll be attending a Community Reinvestment Act luncheon hosted by Eastern Sierra Community Bank on October 15th, so that should be...
1:57:25 Very interesting, and I'm excited to learn how our community banks are reinvesting in our communities. And then the CCRH conference is the first week of November. So that's on my calendar. That's just some stuff. Just a few things. Yeah. Well, great job. You guys are doing a lot. A lot going on. Okay. Is there any further questions or comments from the board? Program support? Nope.
1:58:06 Okay, with that, then we will move on to agenda item five, committee reports. Any of the committees have any report out since our last meeting? And or I can move to six, which is board member reports, and we can do both. I have a board member report. Okay. The town of Mammoth Lakes has a ballot measure, measure L.
1:58:29 And I would love for everyone here to vote yes and tell all your friends to vote yes. Measure L will increase our, if it passes, it will increase our local TOT by 2%. And if you're not familiar, TOT is added on to hotel rooms and Airbnbs. And those are local dollars that can be spent however we want. So we could...
1:58:54 Increased housing between the 80% and the 150% AMI groups, which is not really addressed through state or federal funding. So if you would love to talk about that with me, I would love to explain it some more, but please vote yes on Measure L. Thank you. I would report, I've been participating in a working group with the town and the county, actually, representing Mammoth Mountain on my end, looking at the
1:59:27 Potential use of the old Sheriff's substation down at the lower end of town by Sherwin Creek there as a future safe parking site slash van life sites, if you will. And in any event, there's some potential that that could be put into use after the first of the year. I'm fairly encouraged. It seems like it could actually be a really good site just in regards to location.
1:59:56 Particularly in the winter months, it's a little bit, you know, just at the bottom of town, they're out of town, but so a little bit less snow and so forth, but, you know, close access to the highway and getting into town and so forth. And, you know, I think it actually could be a really good pilot program that could be implemented there this coming winter and really give us an opportunity to see if something can work in that arena of providing, you know, housing for people with different needs.
2:00:24 Pretty interesting stuff, and looking forward to see how things work out on that end. And that's all I have at the moment. Anybody else have anything to report? I'll add something that, so as you know, I'm part of the fire department, that we are also passing a bond, I think it is. So we will be asking for a bond. This will increase property taxes. I believe it's up to $98 for it. But this will help with equipment and wild land or container of wild land.
2:00:55 Program at the fire department, which right now we've sent out a couple crews out on, I believe there's six or seven fires that they've gone out for, or a couple assignments. So that will help for that, and for the equipment, that will help both fire and EMS response times. Great. Any further reports? Okay. With that, we will move to agenda item seven, closed session.
2:01:27 Item 7.1, pursuant to government code section 54957, the board will hold a closed session to consider the evaluation of performance of an employee, the executive director. And 7.2, pursuant to government code section 54956B and 54957.6, the board shall hold a closed session with the board's designated representatives regarding the discussion of the local agency's budget with regards to salaries, salary schedules.
2:01:55 So with that, I think we will go into closed session.