TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Account

Franchise Fee: Cable (100-000-31210)

The Town's budget documents give conflicting figures for the cable franchise fee account (100-000-31210) for FY2025-26 and FY2026-27 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249. A line-item attachment filed June 17, 2026 shows $145,000 and $150,000, while a jumbled table in the agenda packet for the same date appears to show $230,000 and $200,000 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249. Earlier documents list a $230,000 budget for the account in each of FY2022-23 through FY2025-26, while the listed actual revenue ranged from $260,098 in FY2019-20 to $177,941 in FY2024-25 [3] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1[4] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1[6] Agenda (PDF), p. 181. Staff's estimate for total franchise fees (solid waste, electricity, gas and cable) is $1,050,000 for FY26-27 [7] Agenda (PDF), p. 192.

Updated

Findings

8 findings

  1. 1 Two June 17, 2026 budget documents show different cable franchise fee budgets for FY2026-27: $150,000 and $200,000

    Updated

    The Budget line item detail attached to the June 17, 2026 meeting (Fund 100 - General Fund) lists Franchise Fee: Cable (100-000-31210) at $145,000 approved budget 25-26, $145,000 modified budget 25-26 and $150,000 adopted budget 26-27 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1. In that same table, the Gas row (100-000-31208) shows the identical three figures: $145,000, $145,000 and $150,000 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1.

    A table on page 249 of the June 17, 2026 agenda packet has jumbled extracted text [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249. Read by position, it lists $230,000 for the cable account in both the approved and modified 25-26 columns and $200,000 in the 26-27 adopted column [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249. The June 18, 2025 agenda packet listed the cable account's adopted budget for 25-26 as $230,000 [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 181.

    By our calculation, the four franchise fee lines for FY26-27 add to $1,050,000 if cable is $200,000 (350,000 + 350,000 + 150,000 + 200,000), and to $1,000,000 if cable is $150,000 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249. The April 15, 2026 agenda packet gives a total franchise fee revenue estimate of $1,050,000 for FY26-27 [4] Agenda (PDF), p. 192. By our calculation, the FY25-26 lines add to $1,000,000 if cable is $230,000 (325,000 + 300,000 + 145,000 + 230,000), matching the $1,000,000 estimate in the FY25-26 revenue document filed with the April 2, 2025 meeting [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249[5] Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf, p. 5. These sums are consistent with the $200,000 and $230,000 figures [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249[5] Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf, p. 5.

    Why it matters

    The two June 17, 2026 documents differ by $50,000 for FY2026-27 by our calculation [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 249.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 249

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 181

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 192

    5. Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

  2. 2 The cable franchise fee budget was $230,000 in each of FY2022-23 through FY2025-26, up from $225,000 in earlier years

    Updated

    A FY2017-18 proposed budget worksheet filed with the June 21, 2017 meeting lists Franchise Fee: Cable at $223,000 [1] Budget Line Detail - General Fund, p. 1. A FY2017-18 full-Town document lists a 2017-18 budget of $223,000.00 for the account [2] Full Budget - FY2017-18, p. 2. A FY2019-20 Town document lists a council approved budget of $225,000 [3] 2019-20 Budget, p. 64.

    The worksheet filed with the June 15, 2022 meeting lists approved and modified budgets of $225,000 for FY21-22 and a council approved budget of $230,000 for FY22-23 [4] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1. The worksheet filed with the June 21, 2023 meeting lists an adopted budget of $230,000 for FY23-24 [5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1. The worksheet filed with the June 19, 2024 meeting lists an adopted budget of $230,000 for FY24-25, and the FY2024-25 budget book lists $230,000.00 for 2024-25 [6] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1[7] FY24-25 TOML BUDGET BOOK Web.pdf, p. 32. The line-item detail filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting lists approved and modified budgets of $230,000 for FY24-25 and an adopted budget of $230,000 for FY25-26 [8] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 2[9] Agenda (PDF), p. 181.

    Sources

    1. Budget Line Detail - General Fund

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Full Budget - FY2017-18

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 2

    3. 2019-20 Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 64

    4. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    5. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    6. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    7. FY24-25 TOML BUDGET BOOK Web.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 32

    8. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    9. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 181

    10. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  3. 3 Actual cable franchise fee revenue fell from $260,098 in FY2019-20 to $177,941 in FY2024-25, with a recovery in FY2021-22

    Updated

    A FY2017-18 Town document lists actual revenue of $229,296.07 for 2015-16 and $240,528.52 for 2016-17, a rise of $11,232 (4.9%) by our calculation [1] Full Budget - FY2017-18, p. 2.

    The Final Budget Line Item Detail filed with the June 15, 2022 meeting lists actual revenue of $260,098 for FY2019-20 and $185,658 for FY20-21, a drop of $74,440 (28.6%) by our calculation [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1. The worksheet filed with the June 21, 2023 meeting lists actual FY21-22 revenue of $239,177, which is $53,519 (28.8%) above FY20-21 by our calculation [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1.

    The FY2024-25 budget book lists a different 2023-24 actual of $171,409.90, and the worksheet filed June 19, 2024 listed $171,410 as FY23-24 year-to-date [4] FY24-25 TOML BUDGET BOOK Web.pdf, p. 32[5] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 30[6] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 1.

    The extracted text does not make the column labeling certain, and the page does not say whether the figure covers a full year [7] Agenda (PDF), p. 249.

    Why it matters

    In FY2024-25 the listed actual of $177,941 was below the $230,000 approved budget, by $52,059 by our calculation [8] Agenda (PDF), p. 181[9] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 2.

    Sources

    1. Full Budget - FY2017-18

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 2

    2. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    3. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    4. FY24-25 TOML BUDGET BOOK Web.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 32

    5. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 30

    6. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    7. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 249

    8. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 181

    9. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

  4. 4 Staff estimated total franchise fees at $900,000 for FY22-23, rising to $1,050,000 for FY26-27

    Updated

    The preliminary FY22-23 revenue projections filed with the March 16, 2022 meeting give a Franchise Fees revenue estimate of $900,000 for FY22-23 [1] Fiscal Year 22-23 Budget - Preliminary Revenue Projections.pdf, p. 4. The April 15, 2026 agenda packet gives $1,050,000 for FY26-27, and says this is $50,000 or 5% higher than the previous year and represents 2.9% of the General Fund revenue budget [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 192. By our calculation, the FY24-25 to FY25-26 change is +$100,000 (+11.1%) [3] Budget 24-25 Revenue .pdf, p. 4[4] Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf, p. 5.

    The FY26-27 document says the Town receives franchise fees for Solid Waste, Electricity, Gas and Cable, and that the budgeted revenue is very close to the 3-year average for actual revenue collected [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 192. A FY22-23 Fourth Quarter Budget Update in the agenda packet filed with the August 2, 2023 meeting says: "This revenue stream has been difficult to budget in the last few years due to changes in agreements, both rate and allowable items." [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 65

    Why it matters

    These are staff revenue estimates for all four franchise fee categories combined, not the cable account alone [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 192[4] Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf, p. 5.

    Sources

    1. Fiscal Year 22-23 Budget - Preliminary Revenue Projections.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 192

    3. Budget 24-25 Revenue .pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    4. Budget Revenue FY25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 65

  5. 5 Staff forecast a 2.2% rise in cable franchise fees for FY22-23, and later budget amendments adjusted the cable account

    Updated

    The preliminary FY22-23 revenue projections say staff forecast a 25% increase in solid waste franchise fees, a 9.5% increase in electricity, flat gas, and "a 2.2% increase for cable franchise fees" [1] Fiscal Year 22-23 Budget - Preliminary Revenue Projections.pdf, p. 4.

    The Fourth Quarter FY21-22 Budget Review, filed with the September 7, 2022 meeting, says franchise fee revenue "was expected to recover from the drop experienced in FY20-21" and that "the volatility of other items like Electricity, Gas, and Cable recovered more fully in FY21-22" [2] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 4. The FY 21/22 4th Quarter Budget Amendment in the agenda packet for that meeting requested a $15,000 increase to the Franchise Fee: Cable account [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 147. The FY 22/23 4th Quarter Budget Amendment in the agenda packet filed with the August 2, 2023 meeting requested a $2,500 decrease to the account [4] Agenda (PDF), p. 99[5] Attachment A.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Fiscal Year 22-23 Budget - Preliminary Revenue Projections.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    2. Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 147

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 99

    5. Attachment A.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  6. 6 The Town classifies franchise fees as non-proceeds of taxes in its Article XIIIB appropriations limit calculation

    Updated

    The FY2026-27 Article XIIIB appropriations limit page in the June 17, 2026 agenda packet says: "The Town's other revenue sources are classified as non-proceeds of taxes: franchise fees, assessment districts, fines and penalties..." [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 216 The same sentence appears in the Appropriation Limit Calculation filed with the June 16, 2021 meeting (Fiscal Year 2021-22) [2] Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf, p. 1. It also appears in the Fiscal Year 2023-24 calculation filed with the June 21, 2023 meeting and in the agenda packet page for that meeting [3] Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf, p. 1[4] Agenda (PDF), p. 257. The FY2026-27 page says the intent of Proposition 4 was to restrict only the appropriation of "proceeds of taxes" [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 216.

    Why it matters

    Under the Town's calculation, franchise fee revenue, including cable, is classed as non-proceeds of taxes in all four years cited [2] Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf, p. 1[3] Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf, p. 1[1] Agenda (PDF), p. 216.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 216

    2. Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    3. Appropriation Limit Calculation.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 257

  7. 7 Solid waste amendment: the 9.5% franchise fee is not applied to the fuel surcharge

    Updated

    A footnote to the rate table in a Prop 218 notice filed with the January 17, 2024 meeting says the Fuel Surcharge (FSC) is a separate line item starting February 1, 2024, "and the Franchise Fee of 9.50% is not applied to the FSC" [1] Prop 218 notice - with protests.pdf, p. 2[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 94.

    The Second Amendment to the Solid Waste Services Agreement, in the same agenda packet, says the Contractor's rates increased by $214,487 (2.94%) for brokerage costs, "which includes any franchise fee owed by Contractor" [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 82. It says rates increased by $297,999 (4.48%) for the Fuel Surcharge Component, with the "franchise fee... excluded from this rate" [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 82. It also says the Fuel Surcharge Component is a separate customer billing line item and "no franchise fee will be paid by Contractor on the Fuel Surcharge Component" [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 82.

    The FY26-27 final budget narrative says the Solid Waste Franchise Agreement renewal in FY 19-20 adjusted the franchise fees from 5% to 9.5% [4] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 23.

    Why it matters

    The Agenda (PDF) shows what the 9.5% fee does and does not apply to under the 2024 amendment [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 82[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 94.

    Sources

    1. Prop 218 notice - with protests.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 94

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 82

    4. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 23

  8. 8 A Snowcreek VIII benefits list in 2025 agenda packets estimates $33,000 a year in franchise fee revenue

    Updated

    A list of "G.F. Benefits associated with the development of Snowcreek VIII" appears in the agenda packet for March 18, 2025 (pages 26 and 95) and in the packet for April 2, 2025 (page 178) [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 26[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 95[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 178. Under "Utility User Tax and Franchise Fees," it says: "Estimated added utility tax revenue is $66,000 [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 26[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 178. Estimated annual franchise fee revenue is $33,000." [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 26[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 178

    Why it matters

    The page gives an estimate for franchise fees in general and does not say how much, if any, relates to cable [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 26.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 26

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 95

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 178