TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Account

ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018)

ICMA VantageCare (account 100-420-41018) is a General Fund line in the Police Services budget, and the adopted FY2026-27 budget for it is $62,000 [1] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 64[2] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8. The approved budget was also $62,000 in each year from FY2021-22 through FY2025-26, after $54,000 was budgeted for FY2017-18 through FY2020-21 [3] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[4] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 7[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[6] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[2] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8[7] Budget Line Detail - General Fund, p. 7[8] General Fund Budget - Line Item Detail, p. 6[9] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 47[10] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6. Labor documents in the record require the Town to contract with ICMA VantageCare as a retiree-medical vehicle and provide for employee and Town deposits into employee accounts [11] Exhibit A - Article 25 of POA MOU.pdf, p. 3[12] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1[13] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 16.

Updated

Findings

7 findings

  1. 1 The adopted FY2026-27 budget for ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018) is $62,000, the same as the approved budget in each year since FY2021-22

    Updated

    The Budget line item detail filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting lists an adopted FY2026-27 budget of $62,000 for ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018) in Dept 420, Police Services [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8. The same row shows an approved budget of $62,000 and a modified budget of $62,000 for FY2025-26 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8.

    The approved budget was also $62,000 in FY2021-22, FY2022-23, FY2023-24 and FY2024-25 [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 7[4] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8. The adopted budget was also $62,000 for FY2023-24, FY2024-25 and FY2025-26 [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 7[4] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8. By our count, the approved budget figure is the same in all five fiscal years from FY2021-22 to FY2025-26, and the adopted FY2026-27 figure matches it [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 7[4] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8.

    Why it matters

    The budget documents carry the same $62,000 for this retiree-medical account across these years, so the adopted FY2026-27 figure does not change the funding level shown in them [5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

    2. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    3. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    4. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

    5. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

  2. 2 The ICMA VantageCare budget was $54,000 from FY2017-18 through FY2020-21, then $62,000 starting in FY2021-22

    Updated

    The proposed budget for ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018) was $54,000 for FY2017-18 and $54,000 for FY2018-19 [1] Budget Line Detail - General Fund, p. 7[2] General Fund Budget - Line Item Detail, p. 6. The approved budget was $54,000 for FY2019-20 and $54,000 for FY2020-21 [3] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 47[4] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6. The Council-adopted FY2020-21 budget also shows $54,000 [5] 2020-2021 Budget Book, p. 62.

    The document filed with the June 16, 2021 meeting shows a Council-approved budget of $62,000 for FY2021-22 [4] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6. A FY2021-22 budget document likewise shows an adopted budget of $62,000 [6] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 64.

    Why it matters

    The records show the line rising from $54,000 to $62,000 between FY2020-21 and FY2021-22, and the $62,000 has been used in every later budget cited here [4] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[7] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 8.

    Sources

    1. Budget Line Detail - General Fund

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    2. General Fund Budget - Line Item Detail

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    3. 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 47

    4. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    5. 2020-2021 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 62

    6. 2021-2022 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 64

    7. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

  3. 3 Recorded actual spending on ICMA VantageCare ranged from $47,550 to $61,875 between FY2017-18 and FY2023-24

    Updated

    Budget documents list actual expenditures for ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018) of $47,550 in FY2017-18 and $53,257 in FY2018-19 [1] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 47. They list $61,813 for FY2019-20 and $59,625 for FY2020-21 [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6. They list $58,175 for FY2021-22 and $54,000 for FY2022-23 [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8. They list $61,875 for FY2023-24 [4] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 64.

    By our calculation, FY2019-20 actual spending of $61,813 was $7,813 above the $54,000 approved budget for that year, and FY2020-21 actual spending of $59,625 was $5,625 above the $54,000 approved budget [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[1] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 47[5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6. In FY2022-23, actual spending of $54,000 was below the $62,000 approved budget, and in FY2023-24 actual spending of $61,875 was below the $62,000 budget [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 8[6] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 7[4] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 64.

    Why it matters

    The actual figures show spending on this account was above the $54,000 budget in FY2019-20 and FY2020-21, which is consistent with the later increase to $62,000 [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6[5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 6.

    Sources

    1. 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 47

    2. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    3. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

    4. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 64

    5. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    6. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

  4. 4 A May 17, 2017 budget amendment increased the ICMA VantageCare Police Negotiations account by $50,000 for FY2016-17

    Updated

    A budget amendment dated 05-17-17 for fiscal year 2016-17, requested by Rob Patterson of Finance, includes the line "Increase ICMA VantageCare Police Negoations" for $50,000 in fund 100 [1] Budget Amendment Page 3, p. 1. A separate record lists the same FY2016-17 amendment as an increase of $50,000 for ICMA VantageCare (100-420-41018) for Police Negotiations [2] FY2016-17 - Resolutions, p. 5.

    Why it matters

    This amendment shows additional money being added to the ICMA VantageCare account for police negotiations during FY2016-17 [1] Budget Amendment Page 3, p. 1[2] FY2016-17 - Resolutions, p. 5.

    Sources

    1. Budget Amendment Page 3

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. FY2016-17 - Resolutions

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

  5. 5 Labor documents require the Town to contract with ICMA VantageCare for retiree medical, with employee contributions and, from July 1, 2019, a $375 monthly Town contribution

    Updated

    The Exhibit A - Article 25 of POA MOU also says employees shall contribute $25.00 per pay period into their ICMA VantageCare account [1] Exhibit A - Article 25 of POA MOU.pdf, p. 3.

    The Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT adds: "Beginning July 1, 2019, the Town shall contribute three hundred and seventy-five dollars ($375) per month into each employee's ICMA VantageCare account" [2] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 16.

    Why it matters

    These documents describe ICMA VantageCare as the retiree-medical vehicle and set out employee and Town contributions into it [1] Exhibit A - Article 25 of POA MOU.pdf, p. 3[2] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 16.

    Sources

    1. Exhibit A - Article 25 of POA MOU.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    2. Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 16

  6. 6 The 2016 MLPOA tentative agreements list six scheduled deposits into employee ICMA VantageCare accounts, from July 2016 to January 2019

    Updated

    A document titled "MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare," filed with the December 7, 2016 meeting, lists under 8.2 Salary Increases that employees "shall receive a deposit" into their ICMA VantageCare account in July 2016, January 2017, July 2017, January 2018, July 2018 and January 2019 [1] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1. The July 2016 item is headed "5.0% Equity Adjustment" and the July 2017 item is headed "3.0% Cost of Living adjustment" [1] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1.

    The text gives each deposit amount as "two thousand five hundred ($2,250) dollars [1] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1." The written words and the numerals do not match, and the document does not say which controls [1] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1.

    Why it matters

    The tentative agreements schedule recurring deposits into employee retiree-health accounts, but the amount is stated two different ways on the page [1] MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. MLPOA Tentative Agreements with respect to VantageCare.PDF

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  7. 7 Medical opt-out payments of $400 and comprehensive-leave payouts above 400 hours are deposited into employees' ICMA VantageCare accounts

    Updated

    Section 23.5 of the draft 2019 Police Officers' Association MOU says employees who opt out of Town-provided health insurance "shall receive four hundred dollars ($400.00) per month in-lieu which shall be deposited into their ICMA VantageCare account" [1] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 15. Section 22.5 of the same draft says comprehensive leave in excess of 400 hours on July 1 is converted to cash and deposited into the employee's ICMA VantageCare account [2] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 13.

    The 2016 MLPOA MOU, filed with the December 21, 2016 meeting, has the same comprehensive-leave provision at section 23.5 [3] MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf, p. 14. At section 24.5 it says employees who opt out of Town health insurance "shall receive $400 in-lieu which shall be deposited into their ICMA VantageCare account" [4] MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf, p. 16.

    Why it matters

    These provisions route medical opt-out payments and excess comprehensive-leave payouts into the same ICMA VantageCare accounts [1] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 15[2] Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf, p. 13[3] MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf, p. 14[4] MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf, p. 16.

    Sources

    1. Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 15

    2. Police Officers’ Association MOU 2019 - DRAFT.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    3. MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 14

    4. MLPOA MOU 2016.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 16