TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Capital project

Wildlife Security Fence (CIP AP3)

The September 2026 CIP Budget Outlook for 26/27 lists the Wildlife Security Fence (CIP AP3) at Mammoth Yosemite Airport at $4,892,075 in the CON phase, with the amount shown under the FAA heading, not TBID [1] Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf, p. 1. A 2021-22 CIP sheet says the project is required to prevent animal and human incursions, and an October 2022 agenda packet describes 23,000 linear feet of 8-foot-tall chain link fence [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 17. At a September 8, 2021 commission meeting a speaker said the FAA directed the Town to erect the fence and that much of the land is Forest Service property, and a January 19, 2022 staff report says the project had been on hold over USFS environmental clearance questions [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 17[4] Planning and Economic Development Commission — 2021-09-08 14:00:00, 2:13:53[5] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1.

Updated

Findings

7 findings

  1. 1 The 2026/27 CIP Budget Outlook lists the Wildlife Security Fence at $4,892,075 in the FAA column, not TBID

    Updated

    Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26/27, filed with the September 2, 2026 meeting, lists the Wildlife Security Fence (AP3) with a total of $4,892,075 and phase code CON [1] Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf, p. 1. The TBID column shows only $80,000, for a different project (TT5) [1] Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf, p. 1.

    Why it matters

    This is a budget outlook figure for 26/27, not a record of money spent, and the table shows it as an FAA-column amount [1] Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  2. 2 CIP tables from 2022 through 2026 list amounts for the Wildlife Security Fence, from $1,945,000 to $4,892,075

    Updated

    In the extracted table the amount falls under the 'Previous & carryover' heading, though the table text is garbled [1] Attachment 1 - Table 1 – 5-year CIP General Plan Consistency.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Attachment 1 - Table 1 – 5-year CIP General Plan Consistency.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  3. 3 The project calls for 23,000 linear feet of 8-foot-tall chain link fence to prevent wildlife and human incursions

    Updated

    An October 19, 2022 agenda packet says the project scope includes removal of the existing fence and installation of 23,000 linear feet of 8-foot-tall chain link fence to mitigate wildlife incursions at the airport, especially on the runway [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 17. The Final CIP 2021_22, filed with the September 8, 2021 meeting, describes removal of the existing barbed wire fence along the east, west, south and portions of the north side of the airport, and new 8-foot-tall chain link fence [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39. It adds that the project includes some 12-foot-wide swinging gates for airport personnel operations and maintenance access, and says the project is required to prevent animal and human incursions [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39.

    A January 19, 2022 Town Council staff report calls the project a safety project that will prevent wildlife from entering airport movement areas by constructing an 8-foot-tall chain link fence around the Airport [3] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1. The Final CIP 2021_22 says the Town will work with the FAA to use Airport Improvement Program funds and request discretionary funds if necessary [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39.

    Why it matters

    Town documents describe the fence as a safety project with a stated purpose of keeping animals and people out of airport operating areas [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39[3] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 17

    2. Final CIP 2021_22.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 39

    3. Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  4. 4 A north-side portion of the fence was completed in FY 2021; remaining sections are on other land

    Updated

    The October 19, 2022 agenda packet says the remaining sections are on land adjacent to Inyo National Forest and LADWP land, and that the project is listed on the ACIP for FY 2024 [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 17. The Final CIP 2021_22 had said the project was scheduled for 2023/24, consistent with the then-current ACIP approved by the FAA [2] Final CIP 2021_22.pdf, p. 39.

    The September 2026 CIP Budget Outlook lists the project in the CON phase [3] Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 17

    2. Final CIP 2021_22.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 39

    3. Table 2 - CIP Budget Outlook for 26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  5. 5 The FAA directed the Town to erect the fence, and the project had been on hold over USFS environmental clearance questions

    Updated

    The January 19, 2022 Town Council staff report also says the FAA has previously done a NEPA clearance document and the Town intends to continue working with the USFS to resolve any issues [1] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 94.

    Sources

    1. Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 94

  6. 6 A January 2020 agenda item sought approval of a supplemental engineering agreement with Reinard W. Brandley, not to exceed $143,000

    Updated

    The Town Council agenda action sheet for the January 15, 2020 meeting (Agenda Item 8) is titled "Approve the supplemental agreement for the engineering, design, and construction management of the Wildlife Security Fence Project at Mammoth Yosemite Airport" [1] Cover Page, p. 1.

    The staff report says the Town asked Brandley to update the plans, specifications and engineer's estimate to current FAA standards and to provide administrative and construction management services [2] Staff Report, p. 1. It also says the project was being revised to remove portions of the fence on the north side of the Airport near existing buildings, to be pursued under a separate agreement and subsequent project [2] Staff Report, p. 1.

    The General Services Agreement's covered work includes updating the engineering design, plans and specifications, design engineering through bidding and award, engineering design during construction, and resident engineering, testing and inspection during construction of the Wildlife Security Fence [3] Supplemental Agreement 20 - Security Fence, p. 1[4] Agenda Packet, p. 48.

    Why it matters

    The documents show the Town's consulting airport engineer was proposed to handle design and construction management for the fence under a not-to-exceed amount of $143,000 [2] Staff Report, p. 1[3] Supplemental Agreement 20 - Security Fence, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Cover Page

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Staff Report

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    3. Supplemental Agreement 20 - Security Fence

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (date stated in document) p. 1

    4. Agenda Packet

      packetmeeting/filed date Document date (date stated in document) p. 48

  7. 7 Runway safety area grading is planned to follow the fence project

    Updated

    A January 19, 2022 staff report says Runway Safety Area (RSA) and Runway Object Free Area (OFA) grading is needed to bring runway soil shoulder grades into conformance with current standards and FAA compliance [1] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1. It says the grading "needs to happen after the Wildlife Security Fence project happens and the fence is relocated farther south" [1] Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf, p. 1. At the September 8, 2021 Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting a speaker said the RSA/OFA project was programmed out to 25-26 and "also needs the fence project to move forward so we have the right clearances" (at 2:17:46 in the recording) [2] Planning and Economic Development Commission — 2021-09-08 14:00:00, 2:13:53.

    Sources

    1. Receive Update on Draft ACIP for Years 2022-31 and Adopt Resolution.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Planning and Economic Development Commission — 2021-09-08 14:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date